As the Papers Told It

Black Sox · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

House Cleaning

December 1920 – May 1921

Then the case began to come apart. In December 1920 Chief Justice McDonald impounded the grand jury papers after the outgoing state’s attorney, Hoyne, had obtained copies. In January the club owners signed a new National agreement putting Judge Landis in charge of organized baseball for seven years. In March the new state’s attorney, Crowe, was refused six months to gather new evidence, told the court the grand jury testimony had been stolen, and dropped the cases. All the defendants were indicted again, with five new names added.

The outgoing prosecutor asks for copies

A Chicago dispatch of 7 December 1920: Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald impounded the grand jury evidence after learning that Maclay Hoyne, leaving the state's attorney's office, had demanded copies of the papers. Hoyne said the copies ‘were there now, sealed up.’ By July 1921 the confessions were missing, and a trial report said the evidence had apparently dropped from sight when the office passed from Hoyne to Robert Crowe.

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

Norwich Bulletin · 8 December 1920 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SEIZED BASEBALL SCANDAL GRAND JURY EVIDENCE

Chicago, Dec. 7—Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized grand jury evidence in the baseball scandal today following discovery that copies of papers in the case had been obtained by Maclay Hoyne, states attorney, shortly before his retirement from office Monday.

See moreSee less

All of the original papers were turned over to the judge who ordered them impounded by the clerk until the cases of eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial.

Judge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, ordered an investigation after Hartley Replogle, former assistant state's attorney, who conducted the baseball investigation, notified Judge McDonald that Mr. Hoyne had demanded copies of the papers last Friday.

Mr. Hoyne later said he had asked for the records simply to have copies made to be put in the cases in his office, for which he was responsible and that the copies were there now, sealed up.

"As outgoing state's attorney, I was responsible for all of the papers," said Mr. Hoyne, "and I ordered Mr. Replogle to turn them over to my secretary. Mr. Replogle, as assistant state's attorney of course had to do as I ordered. There is no 'scandal' and nothing wrong."

Federal Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, baseball commissioner, when informed of the affair by President Ban Johnson of the American league, said that if it was found any of the evidence had been tampered with or was missing federal action would be taken against the guilty persons.

"Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers and there is no one who will be allowed to interfere," said Judge Landis.

Mr. Replogle tonight said he had acted under Mr. Hoyne's orders and could not say what use had been made of the papers after they left his hands.

The attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicted on a charge of accepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 world series, said that the original evidence was in court last Friday, as he had seen it at that time.

See the clipping

A California ruling and the Chicago case

W. J. Macbeth of the New-York Tribune weighs a Los Angeles ruling that quashed indictments of three Pacific Coast League players because they alleged no criminal act. He reviews the Chicago case: Cicotte, Jackson and Williams confessed, Jackson has since recanted, and Weaver has gone on the stage to clear himself. Whatever the courts did, Macbeth wrote, Landis had given his word the eight were through.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 25 December 1920 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Los Angeles Judge Quashes Indictments of Ball Players Accused of "Throwing" Games

Court Ruling May Affect Plan For Big League 'Housecleaning'

See moreSee less

Decision Holds Indictments Do Not Allege a Criminal Act; Discredited Members of Chicago White Sox Have Excellent Basis for Civil Suit

By W. J. Macbeth

From Los Angeles, yesterday drifted news that may have a direct bearing on the proposed "housecleaning" of gambling, gamblers and dishonest players in the major leagues. The grand jury indictments of William ("Babe") Borton, Carl Maggert and William Rumler, alleging that they conspired to prearrange decisions in Pacific Coast League baseball games, were quashed by Judge Willis in the Los Angeles Superior Court.

Judge Willis held that the indictments did not allege a criminal act. The District Attorney's representative in court said he could not say whether new indictments would be sought until he conferred with his chief.

The procedure on the coast is particularly interesting here because of the effect it may have in the prosecutions of the eight players of the Chicago White Sox, indicted for dishonesty in connection with the playing of the world's championship series of 1919 between the Chicago Americans and the Cincinnati Nationals.

In Line for Trial

These eight Chicago players are now in line for trial because of the confessions of several of their number. The veteran pitcher, Eddie Cicotte, was the first to break down before the Cook County Grand Jury and he implicated the others. His confession subsequently was substantiated by outfielder Joe Jackson and pitcher Lefty Williams. "Hap" Felsch is also supposed to have confessed.

In direct contrast to these confessions have come the absolute denials of Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and Risberg. The three last mentioned all along have maintained that they were "framed" by the others. Weaver, for exoneration, points to his record in the big series in question. He certainly played the most sensational ball of any party concerned and with apparent will that fooled every spectator if, indeed, he were dishonest. In that series Weaver so wormed himself into the fine opinions of critics that he came out of it heralded as the greatest third basemen in the game.

Joe Jackson, since his confession, has recanted. He says he confessed to what was not so under duress. Those who were supposedly implicated in the plot and did not admit the corn presumably are lined-up to give the civil law and organized baseball law a battle. "Buck" Weaver has gone on the stage in monologue to vindicate himself with the Chicago public.

The discredited White Sox players have an excellent angle on which to hang a civil suit. The moment they were indicted by the Cook County Grand Jury all were suspended without pay by Charles A. Comiskey. Not only were their salaries for the balance of the year withheld but also all the world's series split that accrued for finishing second in the 1920 pennant race.

Sure To Be Barred

The unconfessed and denying White Sox players under indictment are threatening legal action for the recovery of salary and bonus claims, and therein will center that delicate point raised by the Los Angeles court. The burden of proof will be thrown on the confessers and proof in such a situation is bound to be difficult if the majority stick to one story.

There is little doubt that all the White Sox players implicated will be barred from baseball, irrespective of court action. Judge Landis, the Commissioner of Baseball, has passed his word that they are through with the game. Charles A. Comiskey, their employer, is quite as positive they will never again appear in uniform.

Comiskey justly resents plain interference by the American League, which voted a fund for the prosecuting attorney of Cook County to press the indictments. He, the most active influence in ferreting out the big scandal, maintains that as it was his club which was involved chiefly, whatever financial assistance is necessary to run the culprits to earth should come from the party most directly concerned.

Since the indictments were returned by the Cook County Grand Jury political changes have been effected. It has been rumored that efforts were made by retiring officials to cloud the issue for political reasons. Fandom, however, should not worry. Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the new head of baseball government, is in a position to arrive at the truth, if anybody can. That he will do so seems an absolute certainty, the attitude of California justice notwithstanding.

See the clipping

Landis is given full power for seven years

An International News report of 13 January 1921: the club owners signed the new National agreement under which Judge K. M. Landis would run organized baseball for seven years, and promised to accept any decision he made. George Gorman, the assistant state's attorney, expected to try the indicted players by 1 February. The trial did not open until 27 June, after the case had been dropped and brought again.

Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Indiana Daily Times · 13 January 1921 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

OWNERS AGREE TO GIVE JUDGE UTMOST POWER

Landis Now Vested With Authority to Boss Magnates and Players Alike.

See moreSee less

LEAGUES CLOSE SESSION

By LUTHER HUSTON, International News Staff Correspondent.

CHICAGO, Jan. 13.—Interviews with baseball magnates promise to be as scarce in the future as the Kaiser's friends.

Besides signing the new National agreement under which Judge K. M. Landis will administer the affairs of organized baseball for seven years, the individual major league club owners likewise signed, at their meeting here, an agreement not to criticize each other publicly or to talk about one another, and to accept any decision Judge Landis renders regardless of their personal opinion of it. Ban Johnson, president of the American League, and John Heydler, head of the National, signed this agreement.

SOX TRIALS COME NEXT.

With the national agreement drawn up and duly ratified plans for an early trial of the ball players under indictment for conspiracy to "throw" the 1919 world's series to Cincinnati were being formulated today. George Gorman, assistant State's attorney, who will direct the prosecution, said he expected to bring the indicted players to trial by Feb. 1. It is Gorman's desire and the desire of the heads of baseball to have the trials completed before the opening of the baseball season.

Most of the magnates had departed from Chicago today, as the business of the big meetings in session here since Monday has been virtually completed. The single business remaining is the promulgation of a new set of drafting rules and this was to be attended to by a committee of major and minor leaguers, which was to meet today. The new International League and the American Association will not submit to the draft, but under the new agreement they are not compelled to. They are barred, however, from drafting from any league of lower classification. The draft will prevail, it is understood, in all other minor leagues.

Formal signing of the new national agreement by the National Association (the minor league body) is yet to take place, but as the minors have voted concurrence in the agreement the signing is a matter of formality only.

Players Rumler, Borton, Maggert and Dale, involved in alleged baseball crookedness in the Pacific Coast League, Wednesday were expelled from organized baseball by the National Association of Minor Leagues.

The national association also decided to punish the players who have been playing with Fred McMullin, an indicted member of the Chicago White Sox, on a semi-professional team in California. The players, numbering six or seven, are members of teams in organized baseball. The national association adopted resolutions calling upon the players "to show cause why they should not be cited" for their actions.

At the joint meeting of the National and American Leagues the player limit during the off season was raised from thirty-five to forty. This means the ballyards will be full of players next spring and during the fall season when the youngsters are brought on from the minors. No major league player will be allowed to go from one club to another after Aug. 1.

NEW ADVISORY BOARD MEETS.

The first meeting of Judge Landis with the new baseball advisory board was held today. The advisory body consists of M. H. Sexton of Rock Island, Ill., and John H. Farrell of Auburn, N. Y., president and secretary of the National Association of Professional Baseball League, representing the minor leagues.

Important subjects discussed at the meeting included: Rules to promote cooperation and understanding in carrying out the provisions of the new agreements, procedure for settling of differences that may come up between the majors and minors, plans for presentation and hearing of future disputes between leagues of the same classification in the minors or between the teams of one league.

Revision of world's series regulations, with relation to the disposition of receipts, also was taken up at the advisory board's meeting. The assessment for the government of baseball was raised to 15 from 10 per cent and the rule awarding the four world's series umpires a flat $1,000 each was replaced by one which stipulates that the four shall divide a sum equal to one losing and one winning player's shares. The umpires have long contended for such a percentage agreement.

See the clipping

The state's three confessors will not testify

On 14 March 1921 Judge William Dever refused the state's motion to take the case off the court call. Pleading for delay, Judge Barrett, attorney for the American League, said Cicotte, Williams and Jackson, who had confessed to the grand jury, would not be available as witnesses, so the state could not win convictions on its evidence. Three days later the state dropped the case.

Capital Journal · Salem, Or.

Capital Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Court Refuses To Postpone Trial of Baseball Players

Chicago, Mar. 14—Judge William Dever today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of the Chicago White Sox players and other indicted for the alleged throwing of the world series in 1919 be taken off the court call. He ordered another hearing for next Thursday when it is believed a date for trial will be set.

See moreSee less

Attorneys for the defense moved that an immediate trial be held Thursday and Judge Dever said that he would announce his decision on this matter later.

Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Charles Risberg were in court. Eddie Cicotte, Bill Burns, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Chick Gandil and Abe Attell were represented by counsel. Hal Chase was the only defendant not present or represented by counsel.

Judge Barrett, American league attorney, in pleading for a postponement, said the prosecution had learned that Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who confessed to the grand jury, would not be available as witnesses. Consequently, he said, the state could not obtain convictions on the evidence it had and would have to have time to seek additional data.

See the clipping

Comiskey cuts all ties with the eight

A brief Chicago dispatch: Charles Comiskey told the eight indicted players that their contracts were null and void and that he would have no further relations with them. The next day the state dropped its cases against seven of them. The break did not settle the money question: in October 1921 Buck Weaver went to court to collect $20,000 in back salary.

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 March 1921 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

COMISKY SEVERS ALL RELATIONS WITH 8 INDICTED WHITE SOX

CHICAGO, March 17. — Charles Comisky, President of the Chicago American League Baseball Club, yesterday notified the eight White Sox players under indictment on charges of conspiring to throw games of the 1919 world series with Cincinnati, that their contracts were null and void and that he would maintain no further relations with them.

See the clipping

The prosecution drops the case to rebuild it

Refused six months to gather evidence, the new state's attorney, Robert E. Crowe, dropped the cases against seven players on 17 March 1921, telling Judge Dever: ‘Well, the game is called then.’ Crowe blamed his predecessors, said grand jury testimony had been stolen and the three confessors corrupted, and promised to seek new indictments. The cases of Gandil and five alleged fixers were taken off the call.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 15 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

CASES DISMISSED AGAINST WHITE SOX

Seven Indicted Players Are Released as World's Series Prosecution Collapses.

See moreSee less

CROWE BLAMES OTHERS

But Says He Will Demand Reindictments of Alleged Throwers of Games.

CHICAGO, March 17.—Immediate prosecution of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted in connection with the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series collapsed to-day, when the State, charging corruption of its chief witnesses, dropped the cases against seven of the players, and Judge William E. Dever took the others off the court call. To-night, however, the State plunged into the task of preparing a new case, with the announcement that the matter would be placed in the hands of a Grand Jury again to-morrow and reindictment of the players whose cases were dropped sought.

Robert E. Crowe, State's Attorney, took charge of the case to-day and announced that he would handle it from now on. He ordered the cases dismissed after his plea for six months in which to gather new evidence had been denied by Judge Dever and May 2 set as date for trial.

To-night in a formal statement Mr. Crowe placed the blame for the collapse of the case on his predecessors in office, charging they had handled it improperly, and on an alleged conspiracy which, he said, had defeated justice and corrupted Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, the men who confessed to the Grand Jury. He announced plans to go personally before the Grand Jury to-morrow to seek new indictments. He pledged him to "use every means to bring the guilty persons in this case to justice," declaring that many guilty persons had not been indicted by the Grand Jury and that important witnesses were excused from answering questions which would have brought the real conspirators to justice.

Players Who Are Released.

Mr. Crowe's action to-day released Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg and Fred McMullin from custody of the law, their cases being dismissed.

The cases against Chick Gandil, Hal Chase, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Abe Attell and William Burns, the latter five charged with engineering the alleged world's series deal, were taken off the call, but may be brought up again.

The cases dismissed were those of men who had surrendered and given bail. There is little prospect of the men returning to baseball, however, all being both unconditionally released and on the ineligible list.

Mr. Crowe in his argument to-day told Judge Dever that Grand Jury testimony had been stolen and that a conspiracy had hampered the State at every point. He demanded six months to gather new evidence.

When Judge Dever replied that sixty days was the limit, Mr. Crowe shouted, "Well, the game is called then. I'll ask nolle prosequi."

The men indicted were still under a ban of silence to-night, their attorneys forbidding them to talk for publication until the statute of limitations expired.

Mr. Crowe's statement, explaining why he dropped the cases, follows in part:

"The investigations before the Grand Jury which returned these indictments was conducted by my predecessors in office.

New Prosecutor Amazed.

"Shortly after February 1 I directed my second assistant, George E. Gorman, to have the baseball cases set for trial at the earliest possible date, and the trial was set for March 14. Mr. Gorman began to prepare for the trial, and we were amazed to find that the investigation of this crime conducted by my predecessor before the October Grand Jury was not a complete investigation and that the witnesses were permitted to withhold material evidence and were excused by the State's Attorney from answering questions which would uncover the entire conspiracy. We were further amazed to learn that all of the testimony taken before the Grand Jury was being publicly offered for sale by a New York newspaper syndicate.

"We then learned that Cicotte, who had testified before the Grand Jury that he was a party to this conspiracy and had received $10,000 as his share of the spoils, and that Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who testified that they had received $5,000 apiece in payment as their share, had been corruptly or otherwise brought under the domination of other defendants who had not testified and were refusing to testify upon the trial of this case as witnesses for the State.

"We further learned that many other persons who were parties to this criminal conspiracy had not been indicted.

"When this situation was called to my attention I directed Mr. Gorman to ask that the cases be passed from the court call in order to give my office sufficient time to obtain evidence which would prove the existence of this conspiracy and end in conviction of every guilty person.

Will Present Evidence Again.

"To-day I told the court that it was absolutely impossible for me to obtain by May 2 evidence which I am satisfied is in existence and which would lead to the conviction of the defendants and other persons not named, and that if the case was set for trial on May 2 I would be forced to enter a nolle pros qui as to those defendants who appeared and gave bail. I stated to the court that the statute of limitations as to certain of these defendants had still less than two weeks to run, that it was absolutely necessary in the interest of public justice that I be given a free hand to make a thorough investigation of this case to the end that this conspiracy might be exposed.

"I further advised the court that these defendants were not entitled to a trial under the law until July 30, 1921, but the court persisted in setting the case for trial on May 2, and knowing the impossibility of a successful trial at that time, and refusing to waste the money of the people of Cook county in a fruitless effort which would result in nothing but a miscarriage of justice, I was forced to and did enter the nolle pros qui.

"I now publicly state that I propose to appear before the Grand Jury of Cook county to again present the evidence of the commission of this crime and to ask the return of other indictments against the defendants named in the present indictments and against others not named therein. It is my purpose to do everything within my power to reach every person guilty of this crime and send them to the penitentiary if the evidence warrants."

See the clipping

Indicted again, with five new names

Soon after their release the seven players were indicted again, along with Gandil, Chase, Burns, Attell, Brown and Sullivan, and five new men were named: Carl Zork and Ben Franklin of St. Louis, said to have conceived the fix, and the Levi brothers and their brother-in-law David Zesler, said to have financed it. That made 18 defendants. One Levi was alleged to have won $80,000.

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

The Southern Herald · 1 April 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

11 MORE BASEBALL GAMBLERS NAMED ONE IS CHARGED WITH MAKING $80,000 ON ALLEGED CROOKED GAMES. PLAYERS ARE REINDICTED Must Furnish $48,000 Bail—St. Louis Non-Players Accused of Engineering Deal to Throw World Series Games.

Chicago.—Jubilation among the seven White Sox players, whose cases were droppel, was cut short when the Cook County grand jury returned new indicements against them, and named 11 others in true bills charging a conspiracy to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati.

See moreSee less

Thirteen ball players and alleged gamblers were named in the original batch of indictments. The five new names included in the new true bills are Carl Zork, St. Louis shirtwaist manufacturer, Ben Franklin of St. Louis, and Douis Levi and David Zesler, all of Des Moines, Iowa.

Zork and Franklin are said to have conceived the idea of "fixing" the games, while the Levi brothers and their brother-in-law, Zesler, are said to have financed the deal. One of the Levi brothers is alleged to have won $80,000 in the deal.

The new bills contain eight counts. They were based on the information presented to the grand jury after State's Attorney Crowe had failed to obtain six months' postponement of the trial of the 13 men indicted last summer.

Among the new indictments are two charging all 18 of the defendants with conspiracy to obtain $250 by a confidence game from Charles K. Nims and $500 from Samuel Pass. Pass has long been known as an ardent White Sox fan. There is also a new count, according to Assistant State's Attorney George Gorman, which charges those indicted with conspiracy to cheat the cording the honest players of the White Sox out of approximately $2,000 each. These players would have won this much had the Sox captured the series.

The 13 men indicted for the second time are Eddie Cicotte, Lefty Williams, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin, Buck Weaver, Happy Felsch and Swede Risberg, the seven former White Sox players whose cases were dropped by the prosecutor last week, and Chick Gandil, formerly of the White Sox; Hal Chase, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachael Brown, Abe Attel and William Burns, all of whom are still under indictment by the grand jury which made the original inquiry.

See the clipping

The defense will say the Reds were better

The defense would argue that Cincinnati won ‘on the square’ and that no indicted player misplayed on purpose. Williams and Jackson had told the grand jury they played their best, admitting only to receiving money and discussing the throwing of games; Cicotte said he hit Rath, the first batter, on purpose and played his best after that. A game-by-game account shows the Sox won three games largely through indicted men.

Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo, Colo.

Pueblo Chieftain · 7 April 1921 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

INDICTED PLAYERS SAY REDS PLAYED THE BEST BASEBALL

Defense Will Show Where Pat Moran's Crew Were the Better of the Two Teams, It Is Said

See moreSee less

Chicago, April 6. — "Cincinnati won the 1919 World Series on the square by playing better baseball than the Chicago White Sox."

That, will be one of the contentions of the defense when the Chicago White Sox players indicted on charges of throwing the series and accepting bribes are brought to trial.

While the complete plans of the defense will not be known until the trial begins, attorneys already have announced that they will contend that the indicted players never intentionally made misplays and consequently could not have taken part in a conspiracy.

Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, in their confessions to the grand jury which investigated the series, maintained they had played their best, confessing only to receiving money and to discussing the throwing of games. Cicotte confessed to hitting Rath, the first man up in the first game purposely, but said he played his best after that. The other players denied either throwing games, entering into the conspiracy or receiving money.

The defense will be prepared to submit the play by play account of the series, which shows that Chicago won its three games largely thru the feats of some of the indicted players. In reply, the state plans to point out that Cincinnati won its five games thru hard hitting of two indicted pitchers and below par playing of other indicted men.

The story of the series shows that in the first game, Cincinnati scored in the first inning after Cicotte hit Rath—deliberately, he told the grand jury.

Jackson, Felsch and Gandil, indicted players, produced a run which tied the score in the second inning. Jackson was safe on an error, Felsch sacrificed and Gandil's single scored Jackson.

In the fourth Cincinnati drove Cicotte, who confessed to receiving $10,000 to throw games, out of the box and produced five runs. Cincinnati won 9 to 0.

Cincinnati won the second game, 4 to 2. Williams, the other pitcher who confessed to receiving money, walked two men in the second and a single and triple scored three runs for Cincinnati. Another walk, followed by a single and a sacrifice produced a run in the sixth.

Weaver, who was indicted, doubled in the sixth for Chicago. Jackson, the third player who confessed, fanned, but Felsch, another indicted man, hit one far out into the field. A sensational catch by Rousch prevented a Chicago run.

Chicago's two runs came in the seventh when Risberg, charged with taking part of the conspiracy, singled. Schalk singled and both scored on Neale's wild throw. In the ninth Gandil singled but Risberg hit into a double play.

The third game was won for Chicago thru the defensive work of Dick Kerr, who pitched, and the offensive work of the indicted players. In the second inning Jackson singled, Felsch bunted safely and both scored on Gandil's hit. In the fourth Risberg singled and went to third when the ball got away. Schalk's bunt, fielded slowly by Fisher, scored Risberg for the third and final run.

Cicotte pitched the fourth game for Chicago, losing 2 to 0, his own errors being responsible for both the National leaguer's runs. In the fourth inning Cicotte threw wild to first, muffed a throw from Jackson and allowed two hits for two runs.

In the fifth game Eller shut out the White Sox 5 to 0. In the first inning Leibold walked, Collins went out and Weaver singled. With two on, Felsch and Jackson flied out. With two out in the ninth Weaver tripled, but Jackson could not score him. Chicago had no other chances to score. Williams pitched for Chicago.

In the sixth inning Eller hit between Felsch and Jackson and what was described at the time as slow fielding by the pair gave him an extra base. Rath singled scoring Eller. Daubert sacrificed, Groh walked, and Felsch misjudged Rousch's fly, letting it drop for a triple which scored two more runs. The indicted players did not figure in any other scoring.

The accused players won the sixth game by their individual work, bringing a 5 to 4 ten inning victory to the Sox with Kerr pitching. Felsch's extraordinary catch of Rousch's fly in the first, cut off a Cincinnati run and in the fourth Jackson threw out a man at the plate for a double play.

Weaver dropped a pop fly in short center for a single in the sixth, getting second on it. Jackson scored him with a hit and Felsch doubled, scoring Jackson. Gandil flied out.

The game was decided in the tenth when Weaver again hit a short fly for a single getting to second when the ball bounded away from Duncan. Jackson bunted safely and Felsch fanned. Gandil singled thru the pitcher, scoring Weaver. Risberg lined to Kopf for a double play.

The seventh game was another Chicago victory in which the eight men charged with throwing the series figured. Jackson scored J. Collins with singles in the first and third innings. Later with E. Collins on first, Weaver was safe on a fumble. Jackson apparently hit into a double play but the ball bounded up and hit Rath and the bases were full. Felsch singled, scoring two runs, but Gandil was an easy out and Risberg fanned.

Cicotte's comeback was marked by steady although not brilliant pitching. On the other hand, Sallee, one of Pat Morgan's mainstays, had to be taken from the box in the fifth inning. Ray Fisher completed the inning. Luque pitched invincible ball, striking out of five of the White Sox batters in the four innings he pitched.

The eighth and final game, won by Cincinnati 10 to 5, shows Wilkinson as the only White Sox pitcher worthy of note. In the final game he threw only seven times. Williams worked on the mound for the Sox in this game with no success.

See the clipping

A report that some have fled to Mexico

A Chicago dispatch of 26 April 1921 reports, on ‘Private information’, that some of the indicted men had fled to Mexico and that the federal government would be asked to find a way to bring them back. It names no one, and no later report confirms it. When the trial opened in June, Brown, Sullivan and Burns had never been caught; Burns later appeared as the state's star witness.

The Nenana News · Nenana, Alaska

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Nenana News · 26 April 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

INDICTED PLAYERS BEAT IT CHICAGO, April 26—Private information has been received in this city to the effect that some of the men indicted in connection with the White Sox baseball scandal, have fled to Mexico. It is understood that an appeal is to be made to the federal government to find some way to extradite the escapes and bring them back for trial.

See the clipping

Abe Attell arrested in New York

Printed under a heading about Ruth's ninth ‘ROUND-CIRCUIT HIT’, this Associated Press item reports that Abe Attell, the former boxer indicted in the scandal, had been arrested in New York as a fugitive from justice and was held without bail. Attell never reached the Chicago courtroom: by June he had won his fight against extradition, and when the trial ended he was still under indictment.

The Cordova Daily Times · Cordova, Alaska

The Cordova Daily Times · 10 May 1921 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

RUTH MAKES NINTH ROUND-CIRCUIT HIT

NEW YORK, May 10 (by Associated Press).—Abe Attell, former boxer, indicted in connection with the White Sox baseball scandal, has been arrested, charged with being a fugitive from justice, and is being held without bail.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: World Series of 1919 Fixed