Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Defense Will Show Where Pat Moran's Crew Were the Better of the Two Teams, It Is Said
See moreSee less
Chicago, April 6. — "Cincinnati won the 1919 World Series on the square by playing better baseball than the Chicago White Sox."
That, will be one of the contentions of the defense when the Chicago White Sox players indicted on charges of throwing the series and accepting bribes are brought to trial.
While the complete plans of the defense will not be known until the trial begins, attorneys already have announced that they will contend that the indicted players never intentionally made misplays and consequently could not have taken part in a conspiracy.
Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, in their confessions to the grand jury which investigated the series, maintained they had played their best, confessing only to receiving money and to discussing the throwing of games. Cicotte confessed to hitting Rath, the first man up in the first game purposely, but said he played his best after that. The other players denied either throwing games, entering into the conspiracy or receiving money.
The defense will be prepared to submit the play by play account of the series, which shows that Chicago won its three games largely thru the feats of some of the indicted players. In reply, the state plans to point out that Cincinnati won its five games thru hard hitting of two indicted pitchers and below par playing of other indicted men.
The story of the series shows that in the first game, Cincinnati scored in the first inning after Cicotte hit Rath—deliberately, he told the grand jury.
Jackson, Felsch and Gandil, indicted players, produced a run which tied the score in the second inning. Jackson was safe on an error, Felsch sacrificed and Gandil's single scored Jackson.
In the fourth Cincinnati drove Cicotte, who confessed to receiving $10,000 to throw games, out of the box and produced five runs. Cincinnati won 9 to 0.
Cincinnati won the second game, 4 to 2. Williams, the other pitcher who confessed to receiving money, walked two men in the second and a single and triple scored three runs for Cincinnati. Another walk, followed by a single and a sacrifice produced a run in the sixth.
Weaver, who was indicted, doubled in the sixth for Chicago. Jackson, the third player who confessed, fanned, but Felsch, another indicted man, hit one far out into the field. A sensational catch by Rousch prevented a Chicago run.
Chicago's two runs came in the seventh when Risberg, charged with taking part of the conspiracy, singled. Schalk singled and both scored on Neale's wild throw. In the ninth Gandil singled but Risberg hit into a double play.
The third game was won for Chicago thru the defensive work of Dick Kerr, who pitched, and the offensive work of the indicted players. In the second inning Jackson singled, Felsch bunted safely and both scored on Gandil's hit. In the fourth Risberg singled and went to third when the ball got away. Schalk's bunt, fielded slowly by Fisher, scored Risberg for the third and final run.
Cicotte pitched the fourth game for Chicago, losing 2 to 0, his own errors being responsible for both the National leaguer's runs. In the fourth inning Cicotte threw wild to first, muffed a throw from Jackson and allowed two hits for two runs.
In the fifth game Eller shut out the White Sox 5 to 0. In the first inning Leibold walked, Collins went out and Weaver singled. With two on, Felsch and Jackson flied out. With two out in the ninth Weaver tripled, but Jackson could not score him. Chicago had no other chances to score. Williams pitched for Chicago.
In the sixth inning Eller hit between Felsch and Jackson and what was described at the time as slow fielding by the pair gave him an extra base. Rath singled scoring Eller. Daubert sacrificed, Groh walked, and Felsch misjudged Rousch's fly, letting it drop for a triple which scored two more runs. The indicted players did not figure in any other scoring.
The accused players won the sixth game by their individual work, bringing a 5 to 4 ten inning victory to the Sox with Kerr pitching. Felsch's extraordinary catch of Rousch's fly in the first, cut off a Cincinnati run and in the fourth Jackson threw out a man at the plate for a double play.
Weaver dropped a pop fly in short center for a single in the sixth, getting second on it. Jackson scored him with a hit and Felsch doubled, scoring Jackson. Gandil flied out.
The game was decided in the tenth when Weaver again hit a short fly for a single getting to second when the ball bounded away from Duncan. Jackson bunted safely and Felsch fanned. Gandil singled thru the pitcher, scoring Weaver. Risberg lined to Kopf for a double play.
The seventh game was another Chicago victory in which the eight men charged with throwing the series figured. Jackson scored J. Collins with singles in the first and third innings. Later with E. Collins on first, Weaver was safe on a fumble. Jackson apparently hit into a double play but the ball bounded up and hit Rath and the bases were full. Felsch singled, scoring two runs, but Gandil was an easy out and Risberg fanned.
Cicotte's comeback was marked by steady although not brilliant pitching. On the other hand, Sallee, one of Pat Morgan's mainstays, had to be taken from the box in the fifth inning. Ray Fisher completed the inning. Luque pitched invincible ball, striking out of five of the White Sox batters in the four innings he pitched.
The eighth and final game, won by Cincinnati 10 to 5, shows Wilkinson as the only White Sox pitcher worthy of note. In the final game he threw only seven times. Williams worked on the mound for the Sox in this game with no success.