Harry Grabiner of the White Sox front office criticizes American League President Ban Johnson for declaring the indicted players banned, saying Johnson ignored the scandal when it first surfaced. Grabiner states that Judge Landis, not Johnson, will determine the players' fate with the White Sox.
The New York Herald · 1 March 1921 · page 10
BAN JOHNSON EDICT 'MONTHS TOO LATE'
Flays A. L. Head. Chicago, Feb. ?8.?The management Of the Chicago White Sox and President j Ban Johnson of the American league are I at It again. The warlare this time prom ises to be particularly open and li tter. The trouble, which has been brewing for some tune, burst Into full bloom when Ban Johnson gave out an interview re cently in Washington v/hlli cn a visit to the capital city, to the effect that none of tho Indicted White Sox players would ever again bo permitted to wear an
The eight indicted White Sox players will stand trial on charges of conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses, and operating a confidence game. The trial has been announced to begin March 14.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Cordova Daily Times · 2 March 1921 · page 5
BALL PLAYERS' TRIALS OCCUR NEXT WEEK
lar! Exquisite Seena Owen, as the “girl” is quite excuse enough for any man's reformation, so you’ll not be surprised, after the burglar episode, that Tom pulls himself together, takes a tug on his manhood and prove# that you “can’t keep a good man down.” “City of Comrades” is repeated for the last time tonight, and if you miss it, you’ll miss some good enterj tainment. The program is completed by a Pathe Review, a reel of cur rent events, and a short comedy. Coming tomorrow is Mary Pickford ; in the third production from her own j studios, "The Heart O’ the Hills.”; She’s the same loveable Mary whom j you saw in “Daddy Hong Legs” and ' "The Hoodlum.” The story is an interesting one— a tale that will lay close to your' ^heart.
See moreSee less
It deals with the hill-folk of BALL PLAYERS’TRIALS OCCUR NEXT WEEK CHICAGO, 111., March 2 (by Asso ciated Press). — The eight indicted White Sox players are to be tried on charges of conspiracy, obtaining mon ey under false pretenses and operat ing a confidence game. It has been announced that the trial will be set for March 14. # FIVE TIMES WINNER OF RACQUET CHAMPIONSHIP PHIJUADELPHIA, March 1 (by As sociated Press).—Stanley W. Peason of the Philadelphia Racquet Club, won the national squash racquet championship for the fifth time in six years, defeating Hewit Morgan of New York, in three straight sets.
Chicago White Sox players began arriving in Chicago ahead of their Friday departure for spring training camp in Waxahachie, Texas. Manager Gleason was expected the next day and would lead twenty-three players south, with pitcher Dick Kerr still negotiating contract terms from his home in Texas.
Norwich Bulletin · 2 March 1921 · page 3
FOR TRAINING CAMP TRIP Chicago. Mar. 1 Members of the Chicago White Sox team began, to ar rive here today in preparation fOr thu trip Friday to , the spring trr.imng camp at Waxahaciie, Texas. The first of the players to report was George Lees, a catcher from Bethlehem. Pa. Manager Gleason is due tomorrow from his home in Philadelphia and will take twenty-three players south. Several will' go direct .from then homes, and Dick Kerr, one of the leading Sox pitchers, now holding out, is expected to run over; from his home at Paris, Texas, and discuss terms. ' ;
Assistant state's attorney George E. Gorman filed a bill of particulars against the eight indicted White Sox players, charging conspiracy, false pretenses, and running a confidence game. The trial was set to begin March 14, with specific sums allegedly obtained by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson detailed.
Norwich Bulletin · 2 March 1921 · page 3
TO BE TRIIID FOK CONSPIRACY , FOB THROWING WORLD SERIES Chicago, March 1. The eight indicted members of the Chicago White Sox charged with throwing the world's series games of 1919, to Cincinnati, will be tried on charges of conspiracyof ob taining money under false pretenses, and operating a . confidence game. It was revealed today hy George E. Gor man, assistant state's attorney, who fil ed a bill of particulars before Judge William S. Deever. The trial, has been set for March 14. . The bill relates that as a result of a "confidence game and fraudulent pre tenses.
See moreSee less
Pitchers EctViie Cicotte and Olaude Williams obtained $10,000 and $5,000 'respectively and that Outfielder Joe Jackson obtained $5,000 and the other defendants other large sums of money, the exact total of which is un known." - . Charles C. Nims, of Chicago, was spe-ci!l-ally named in this bill as one who was victimized. His loss was placed at $250. :
Chicago prosecutors filed a bill of particulars detailing conspiracy and confidence game charges against the eight indicted White Sox players, with trial set for March 14. The document specifies amounts allegedly obtained by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, and names a victimized bettor.
The New York Herald · 2 March 1921 · page 10
'CONFIDENCE GAME' CHARGE AGAINST SOX
Bill of Particulars Filed in Al leged World Series Conspiracy Chicaoo, March 1.?The eight Indicted members of the Chicago White Sox, charged with throwing the world'a series Karnes of 1919 to Cincinnati, will be tried on charges of conspiracy of ob taining money under false pretenses and operating a confidence game. It was re vealed to-day by George E. Gorman, Assistant State's Attorney, who filed & bill of particulars before Judge William E. Deever. The trial has been set for March 14. The bill relates that as a result of a "confidence game and fraudulent pre tences, Pitchers Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams obtained $10,000 and $5,00i) respectively and that Outfielder Joe Jackson obtained $S,000 and the other defendants other large sums of money, the exact total of which Is un known."
See moreSee less
Charlos C. Nims of Chicago whs spe cifically named in the bill as one who was victimized. His loss was placed at $250.
Chicago assistant state's attorney George Gorman filed a bill of particulars against the eight indicted White Sox players before Judge William E. Dever. The players face charges of conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses, and operating a confidence game, with trial set for March 14.
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 March 1921 · page 8
. Will Try Indicted j White Sox March 14 Chicago, March 1. The eight in , dieted members of the Chicago Yvhite Sox, charged with throwing!
Rep. Benjamin Welty of Ohio charged Judge Landis with high crimes for simultaneously serving as federal judge and baseball's $42,500-a-year arbitrator, arguing this undermined both the Black Sox indictments and a Federal League antitrust judgment. Welty also accused Landis of lobbying state legislatures on baseball gambling laws while neglecting judicial duties.
The Morgan County Press · 4 March 1921 · page 5
FEDERAL JUDGE LANDIS UNDER FIRE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The trial of the eight indicted former White Sox players, charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series, will likely be postponed from its original March 14 date. Prosecutors say they need more time to prepare their case and will request a later trial date.
Indicted Ball Players’ Trial to Be Postponed — CHICAGO. March 5. — Trial of the eight indicted former White Sox baseball players, charged with conspiring to ilfow games in the 1919 world's series between Chicago and Cincinnati, probably will be postponed from the date originally scheduled, March 14. The prosecu tion desires more time to prepare its case and will ask for a later date when the date for trial it: set Monday
The report describes Judge Landis facing criticism from factions wanting his resignation as commissioner or retirement from the bench, while baseball insists on retaining him. It also notes Landis is investigating scandals beyond the indicted White Sox, including game-fixing allegations revealed in the Texas Senate.
The New York Herald · 5 March 1921 · page 12
IN ALL SPHERES OF SPORT
baseball. When Judge Landis was appointed baseball commissioner there was considerable wonderment over what he would do to earn his stipend of $42,500. Since that time opportunities for earning this salary have Increased faster than the Judge could handle them. He la working on a great many more baseball matters than the public knows. The Judge came in to clean things up. And he is not confining his attention to the cases of the indicted White Sox. That there is work for Judge Landis down in Texas wps revealed Wednes day in the Senate at Austin.
See moreSee less
Senator McNealus, who used to be president of j the Texas League, In making a futile appeal for the passage of a bill to pro I tect baseball, declared that games had been thrown In that circuit last season. | "A first baseman of the Wichita Falls team threw a game and was sold out j of the State," he declared. "There were many such occurrences here, and i they were smothered for the good of the game In Texas." Texas is not the only place where baseball scandals were smothered. ! Yet State legislators treat appeal? for protective legislation with levity. MRS. WOOD REACHES ! MANUAL TRAINING IS
The trial of eight former White Sox players charged in the 1919 World Series scandal, originally set for March 14, is being rescheduled after the prosecution requested more preparation time. Defense attorneys opposed the delay, fearing it would prevent the players from returning to baseball this season, but a new date was expected to be set the following Monday.
The New York Herald · 5 March 1921 · page 13
/ \ j New Date for Trial of Indicted White Sox j CHICAGO, March 4.?A new data I for the trial of eight former | members of the Chicago j
Heinie Zimmerman's sworn affidavit implicating Benny Kauff, Fred Toney, and Rube Benton in an alleged thrown game to the Cubs in 1919 stirred comment among Giants veterans. McGraw dismissed Zimmerman's credibility while Benton denied the charge, recounting that Zimmerman had approached him with a bribe offer which he refused by winning the game.
The New York Herald · 5 March 1921 · page 13
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Heinie Zimmerman swore an affidavit claiming he carried a $100 bribe offer from a Chicago gambler to teammates Benny Kauff, Rube Benton, and Fred Toney to throw a 1919 game to the Cubs. The writer notes this was common gossip over a year earlier and criticizes baseball officials for failing to investigate it sooner, now urging club owners to bar the accused players until Landis resolves the matter.
New-York Tribune · 5 March 1921 · page 12
Landis Urged Accused Giants Should Be Made To Clear Names; Up To The Owners To Bar Benton, Toney And Kauff Until Case Is Decided
By W. J. Macbeth Organized baseball has been handed another wnllop. Whether a black eye results remains to be seen. But fol lowing so closely as it does upon the scandal associated with the throwing of the 1919 world's series by the Chi? rac?' White Sox. the blow is certainly n< : going; to improve the countenance
Heinie Zimmerman swears an affidavit claiming he carried a Chicago gambler's $100 bribe offers to teammates Benny Kauff, Rube Benton, and Fred Toney in 1919. The piece notes these charges were known as rumor over a year earlier and criticizes baseball officials for inaction, while detailing Commissioner Landis's new data-gathering campaign into club rosters and player records.
New-York Tribune · 5 March 1921 · page 12
ganized baseball. His name is Judge Kei'.esaw Mountain Landis. He is the commissioner of organized baseball. Judge Landis has promised to go to the bottom of the whole baseball mess. He stems to have been serious in that de?
Giants pitcher Rube Benton responds to Heinie Zimmerman's bribery allegations, admitting he was offered money to throw a 1919 game but claims he refused and pitched to win. The report also discusses Zimmerman's suspension over World Series money disputes and calls for Judge Landis to investigate the implicated players, including Kauff and Benton, whose situations are compared to the indicted White Sox players.
New-York Tribune · 5 March 1921 · page 12
Rube Benton Admits Bribe Offer, but Says He Refused to Accept
charge of alleged automobile thievery. Benton, also accused, has admitted win? ning money on the 1919 world's series, which it is said he knew was "fixed" an oifei.se which drove Joe Gedeon from the St. Loui? Browns. The cases of Kauff and Benton are identical with tu se of the indicted White Sox players." Until they can clear themselves to public satisfaction they should have no part in baseball. Tne country will look to Judge Landis for signal action. It is not likely to be disappointed.
Reports indicate attorneys for the prosecution may request a six-month postponement of the Black Sox trial set to begin Monday, citing unfamiliarity with the case and attorneys called out of town. Defense attorneys and Judge Dever both oppose a lengthy delay, with Dever indicating he would grant no more than a month's postponement.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 10 March 1921 · page 5
Postponement To Be Sought In Baseball Case
aay poetpoaemeat,” _._;_ (AandaM Press) CHICAGO, March 9—An attempt to obtain a postponement Of six months In the trial of the Chicago White Sox baseball players Indicted' for the al
Attorneys indicate a request may be made to delay the trial of the Chicago White Sox players indicted for throwing the 1919 World Series by six months. Judge George Barrett, newly retained by the American League, said he needed more time to familiarize himself with the case, though only a one-month delay was expected to be granted, and defense attorneys said they would oppose further postponement.
New-York Tribune · 10 March 1921 · page 12
League Attorney May Ask 6 Months' Delay In White Sox Trial
In White Sox Trial /CHICAGO, March !>.?An attempt to obtain a postponement of six months In the trial of the Chicago White Sox basehall players, indicted for the aliened throwing of the 1919 world's series, probably will be made next Monday when the case is called, according to attorneys who will prosecute the case. Indications, however, were that not more than one month's delay would be granted. Judge George Barrett, who was retained about a week ago by the American League to represent it at the trial, to-day said that he had come into the case so recently that he was not familiar with its details and wanted additional time to look Into it.
See moreSee less
Six months would be de sirahle, he said. Attorneys who will defend the White Sox baseball players accused of throwing the 1919 world series, to-night said they would oppose a further postponement.
Attorneys for the indicted Chicago White Sox players sought a six-month postponement of their trial, with the request expected to be formally made the following Monday. Prosecutors anticipated that at most a one-month delay would actually be granted by Judge George Barrett.
The Pensacola Journal · 10 March 1921 · page 6
Want Six Months' Time in Case Against White Sox Players. (By The Associated Press). CHICAGO, Mar. 9. An attempt to obtain a postponement of six months
Attorneys for the accused White Sox players say they will oppose any further postponement of the trial set to begin Monday before Judge William E. Dever. Prosecution attorneys reportedly wanted a six-month continuance due to being called out of city, while defense wants to proceed quickly.
The Pensacola Journal · 10 March 1921 · page 6
Defendants Object to Postponement. CHICAGO, March 9. Attorneys who will defend the White Sox baseball play ers accused of throwing the 1919 world's series said that they would oppose a further postponement of the trial which is scheduled to begin on Monday. This was in reply to a report today that attorneys for the prosecution would
This is an installment of a fictional baseball serial, 'The Evergreen Wildcats,' describing a barnstorming team's games in Angel City, including a match against a Black team nicknamed the Black Sox. It has no connection to the 1919 World Series scandal, merely sharing the name.
The Pensacola Journal · 10 March 1921 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Attorneys prosecuting the Chicago White Sox players indicted for the 1919 World Series fix may seek a six-month delay when the case is called the following Monday. Defense attorneys plan to oppose further postponement, and indications suggest any delay granted would be limited to about one month.
Indiana Daily Times · 10 March 1921 · page 6
MAT DELAY TRIAL. CHICAGO, March 10.—An attempt to obtain a postponement of six months in the trial of'the Chicago White Sox base ball players indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series prob ably will be made next Monday when the case Is called, according to attorneys who will prosecute the case. Indications, however, were that not more than one month's delay would be granted. Judge George Barrett, who was re tained about a week ago by the American League to represent it at the trial, yes terday said that he had come into the case so recently that he was not fa miliar with its details and wanted ad ditional time to look Into it.
See moreSee less
Attorneys w'bo will defend the White gox baseball players accused of throw ing the 1919 world series have said they would oppose a further postponement of the trial, which Is scheduled to begin Monday.
Attorneys prosecuting the Black Sox case expect the defense to request a six-month postponement when the trial is called, though only a one-month delay is likely to be granted. Judge George Barrett, newly retained by the American League, said he needed more time to familiarize himself with the case, while Judge William Dever's clerk indicated the judge wanted the trial to proceed quickly.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 10 March 1921 · page 6
SEE ATTEMPT TO DELAY TRIAL OF BALL PLAYERS
Months* I'OMI |>oiirini'n t When Cn.Hc In <'ailed. C'lll(\U;o.. March !*.?An attempt io oi'tain a postponement of six' months on the trial of the Chicago White Sox baseball players, indicted lor the alleged throwing of the 1'H't
Zimmerman accuses Giants players Benton, Toney, and Kauff of accepting bribes to throw a game, and claims manager McGraw knew but covered it up. The report notes the White Sox scandal is settled with players banished, but demands similar resolution for these new charges before the 1921 season.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 10 March 1921 · page 6
CHARGES AGAINST FOUR SHOULD BE INVESTIGATED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Heinie Zimmerman swore in an affidavit that three Giants players took bribes to throw a game and that manager McGraw covered it up to protect his club. The paper says the charges may or may not be true but deserve investigation, with the same treatment as the Black Sox if proven.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 10 March 1921 · page 6
SHOULD BE INVESTIGATED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Defense attorneys for the indicted White Sox players, including Benedict Short, stated they would oppose any further postponement of the trial set to begin Monday. They claim the players themselves are eager to have the case heard.
The Milwaukee Leader · 10 March 1921 · page 8
Seek Speedy Trial CHlCAGO—Attorneys who will defend the White Sox baseball play ers accused of throwing the 1919 world series last night said they would oppose further postponement of the trial, which is scheduled to begin Monday. “The players,” said Atty. Benedict Short, one of their defenders, “are eager to get the case to trial. Their attorneys will oppose any postponement.”
The state attorney plans to seek a continuance of the indicted White Sox players' trial until after the baseball season ends, a move defense attorneys strongly oppose, demanding immediate trial or dismissal. Judge Landis has stated he will place the players on the ineligible list if the state refuses to proceed when the case is called.
The Nenana Daily News · 12 March 1921 · page 1
PROSECUTION WANTS TRIAL OF BALLPLAYERS DELAYED CHICAGO, March 12—According to a statement issued by the state attorney, the state will move, when the trial of the indicted White Sox ' players comes up on Monday, for ! a continuance of the case until 'after the close of the approaching baseball season. The attorneys for the defense are objecting vigorous ly to this plan, and declare that they will insist upon immediate trial or a dismissal of the charges. Judge Landis has announced that he will place the indicted players on the ineligible list if the state re fuses to proceed with the trial when it is called.
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · Annapolis, Md.
The trial of Chicago White Sox players charged with fixing the 1919 World Series is set to begin Monday before Judge William E. Dever. Grand jury testimony suggests gamblers and players double-crossed each other over unpaid bribes and unauthorized game wins.
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · 12 March 1921 · page 4
"Double Cross" Worked Overtime In Baseball; Trial Of Indicted "White Sox" Players Up Monday
C HIC AGO. March 12 The trial ofji Chicago White Sox baseball players ji barged with throwing the lhlb worlu series, which begins Monday before i Judge William E. Devt r of the County i Court, is expected to bring forth evi dence ilat almost everyone connected with tin* allegd conspiracy was dou- < ble crossed in some way. The loss by Charles .V Comiskey owner of the c lub, of his champion* ship team and of players valued col lectively as high as $300,000. Was look ed upon at the time of the jury inves- ( i ligation as a double crossing par alleled in baseball history Testimony given before the iq;and jury and which probably w it be introduced during the trial, indicated that the al leged plans of-the gamblers charged with fixing the series and of players charged with throwing it.
See moreSee less
also went astray in several respects. This testimony, given by witnesses, was to the effect that the gamblers double crossed certain players by not making good on promised bribes, teri tain players in return, double crossed the gamblers by winning a game on ; which the gamblers had pyramided j
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · Annapolis, Md.
The report describes grand jury confessions by Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams admitting to receiving money, while Felsch, Weaver, Risberg, and McMullin denied involvement. It details how gamblers pyramided bets and lost money when Dick Kerr won the third game 3-0.
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · 12 March 1921 · page 4
Tiie gamblers, it was said, pyramided j rhoir bets, betting on the second game against Chicago—all they had won the first. The combined winnings were placed on Cincinnati to win the j third game and when Dick Kerr came through with a 3 to 0 victory, in which he was aided by indicted players, the gamblers lost everything. These Deny Conspiracy Felsch. Weaver, llisbcrg and McMullin, maintain that they never en tered ihe conspiracy and never re ceived money Jackson and Williams deny they threw games, although ad mitting they received money.
See moreSee less
Cieotte confessed to receiving money and to intentional misplav. Gandil has never surrendered, but in press state ments was quoted as denying that he took any part in the deal. He wa named by Williams as the man who gave him SIO,OOO. however. $5,000 for himself and $5,000 for Jackson.
The report announces that the trial of Chicago White Sox players charged with throwing the 1919 World Series begins Monday before Judge William Dever. It previews testimony suggesting that gamblers and players alike may have double-crossed one another, and notes Comiskey's heavy financial and team losses.
East Oregonian : E.O · 12 March 1921 · page 7
'DOUBLE CROSS' IS BASEBALL CONSPIRACY
BASEBALL CONSPIRACY Indicted White Sox Players up Monday; Charles Comiskcy Lose3 Heaviest. CHICAGO, March 12. The trial of Chicago White Hox baseball players, charged with throwing the 11)19 world series, which begins Monday before
The report recounts how Kerr won Game 3 for the White Sox despite the conspiracy, and that the gamblers lost money on that game. It details which players admitted involvement—Cicotte confessing to receiving money and a deliberate misplay, Williams and Jackson admitting payment but denying thrown games, and Weaver, Felsch, Risberg, and McMullin denying any participation—while noting Gandil's quoted denial despite being named as a payoff intermediary.
East Oregonian : E.O · 12 March 1921 · page 7
thine:. I Kelsch, 'Weaver. TMsberg and Mc i Mullin. maintained that they never j entered the ronspliacy and neer r 'celved money. Jackson and Williams 'deny they threw games, although nd ' mitting they received money. Cicotte confessed to receiving money and to 'one intentional mlsplay. Uandil has i never surrendered, but In press state ; men's was quoted as denying that he ! took any part in the deal. He was ; named by Williams ns thb man who igave him $10,000, however, $5000 for j himself and $5000 for Jackson.
Chicago prosecutors proposed a six-month continuance in the trial of the indicted White Sox players, prompting defense attorneys to accuse the state of trying to shelve the case. The trial was still scheduled to begin the following Monday.
Bisbee Daily Review · 13 March 1921 · page 4
WOULD PUT OFF
i mm mC CHICAGO. March 12. iBv sociated Press) Announcement today by the state that a six months' nniiuiit;:ut:ui, wuuiu :jc solium m ( the trial of the indicted Chicago White Sox piayers, brought charge, from defense attorneys that an at-' tempt was being made to shelve the fee
Attorneys for several defendants, including Buck Weaver, Swede Risberg, Oscar Felsch, and others, vowed to fight attempts to procure a long delay in proceedings, though a short postponement might be granted as a courtesy. A female defendant appeared composed and more relaxed in court, smiling for the first time during the session.
Bisbee Daily Review · 13 March 1921 · page 4
dence necessary. Judge Barrett Benedict,' naner. scoffed at rumors that the case wa ?nd Fred Mc.Mullin. and beine niceonholed. To orocesd now Short, attorney for Claude Williams. iEhmeut, he declared. ' ; coUe, said, they would fisht any atcheese press. vrr. Swede Itisberg. Oscar Felsch a.; a mattei of courtesy, they said. I be started soon. I U' . y i i I'iir i ili i n -in i mm niiiiiniiii m n ri SMMttcwiinaMMkMa 'H T y 1 '.-'J. ' j -
The state announced it would seek a six-month postponement of the Chicago White Sox players' trial, prompting defense attorneys to accuse prosecutors of trying to shelve the case. Judge Landis placed all indicted players on baseball's ineligible list pending trial, barring them from organized baseball.
Arizona Republican · 13 March 1921 · page 18
T. D. Nash, attorney for Buck Weaver, Swede Risberg, Oscar Felsch and Fred McMullin, and Benedict Shortt, attorney for Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, and allied with D. P. Cas sidy in the defense of Eddie Cicotte, said they would fight any attempt to procure a long delay. Two weeks or 30 days would be granted as a matter of courtesy, they said. . Jackson and Weaver said they op posed even a short postponement. Judge Landis, baseball commissioner, placed all the indicted players on the ineligible list when he heard of the proposed postponement and said they would remain there pending the trial.
See moreSee less
This bars them from playing organized baseball. Concerning the possibility or tne grand jury evidence not being suffi cient to obtain conviction. Judge C A. McDonald, who started the grand jury quia, said that if witnesses repudiated their statements there might be some difficulty.
The prosecution announced it might seek a six-month delay in the trial of the indicted Chicago White Sox players, prompting defense attorneys to accuse them of trying to shelve the case. Judge Barrett defended the request, saying new evidence was needed for an impregnable case and denied rumors the case was being pigeonholed.
Pueblo Chieftain · 13 March 1921 · page 14
PROSECUTION MAY ASK DELAY TO GATHER FURTHER EVIDENCE
» Chicago, March 12.—(8y The Asso » elated Press)—Announcement today . by tho state that a six months* post . ponement would be sought in the trial r of the indicted Chicago White Sox 5 players brought charges from defense attorneys that an attempt was being made to shelve the case and leave the . indicted players permanently under a j cloud of suspicion. . The trial Is scheduled to start Mon* f day. , The prosecution, however, declared , that the delay would be sought "to . make certain that the men back °f the series scandal were driven out of , baseball and into the penitentiary."
See moreSee less
, Judge R. J. Barrett, American league attorney, said that the prosecution had found its evidence was not ready. New evidence being gathered would give the state an impregnable ease, he said, and might result in u further grand Jury investigation. He said known reluctance of some grand Jury witnesses to stnnd by their , testimony had made new evidence ne cessary Judge Barrett scoffed nt ru mors that the case was being pigeon holed.
Defense attorneys for the indicted Black Sox players said they would resist any lengthy postponement of the trial, though a short delay might be granted. Commissioner Landis placed all indicted players on baseball's ineligible list pending trial, while the judge who began the grand jury inquiry noted witnesses recanting could weaken the case.
Pueblo Chieftain · 13 March 1921 · page 14
To proceed now might make a farce of the case and result In guilty men I escaping, he declared. T. D. Nash, attorney for Buck 1 Weaver. Swede Risberg, Oscar Felsch ■ and Fred McMullin and Benedict i Shortt. attorney for Claude Williams. , Joe Jackson and allied with D. P.
The report previews the upcoming criminal trial of eight Chicago White Sox players charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series and accepting bribes up to $10,000. It names the defendants and the alleged fixers, and notes that Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson had already confessed to the grand jury despite expected not-guilty pleas at trial.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 13 March 1921 · page 2
In testifying before the grand, jury. Tha White Sox p)ayrs indicted in connection withi the alleged eon spiracy were Edward V. Cicotte. pitcher, who' lost two games and won one in the series; Claude Wil liams,, .pitcher, who lort three games; Joe. Jackson, outfielder; Oscar Felsch, outfielder; Charles A., Kisberg, shortMop; Uuck Weav er,' third baseman; Chick Oandll, firstbaseman, and Fred McMullIn, utility inflelder.
The state plans to present evidence of a conspiracy among the Black Sox players, including testimony about a meeting in Cicotte's room and confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson. Legal questions arise over whether confessions can be used against players who did not testify, while the prosecution's request for a six-month postponement sparks defense accusations of stalling tactics.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 13 March 1921 · page 2
plans to present evidence tending to show that there was a conspir acy and will attempt to prove that the. men did not piny their best ball. Cinude Williams' testimony before the grand jury that the players met Rrown and Sullivan previous to the series In Cicotte's room, and thero discussed the throwing of the games, will be pre sented as evidence of a cimspiricy. Cicotte's testimony that he delib erately hit Kilh. the first man up ill the first game, is expected to play a big part in the state's case ttnd the confession of Ctrotte that he received 1 10,000 and of Wil liams and Jackson that they re ceived $.1,000 each also probably will be used. Judge never to Hear Case.
The report discusses legal questions the court must decide: whether throwing a game is a felony under Illinois law, and whether club control extends past the regular season. It outlines defense strategies, with some players expected to admit taking money but claim they still played to win, while others will deny any conspiracy.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 13 March 1921 · page 2
to' the penitentiary." Judge K. J. Barrett, American league attorney, said that the pros ecution had found Its evidence was impregnable case, he said, and might result in a further grand Jury Investigation. He said known reluctance of some grand Jury wit neoces to stand by their testimony had made new evidence necessary. Judge Barrett scoffed at rumors that the caso was being pigeon holed To proceed now might make a farce of the case and result in guilty men escaping punishment, he declared. T. D. Nash, attorney for Buck Weaver, Swede Risberg, Oscar Felsch and Fred McMullIn, and Benedict SHortt, attorney for Claude Williams, .loo Jackson and aUted with D.
See moreSee less
P. Cassldy in the de fense of Eddie Cicotte, said they would fight any attempt to pro cure a long delay. Two weeks or thirty days would be granted as a matterof courtesy, they said. Jackson and Weaver said they opposed even a short postponement. Judge Landis, baseball commis sioner, placed all the indicted players on the Ineligible list when
A Chicago court refused the state's request to postpone the trial of the indicted White Sox players, setting another hearing for Thursday to determine a trial date. Prosecutors said they needed more time because confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson would not be available as witnesses, undermining their case.
The Cordova Daily Times · 14 March 1921 · page 8
BALLPLAYERS PROSECUTION SEEMS TO FAIL
| atetl Press).—The court today re fused to comply with the motion of the State for a postponement of the trial of the indicted White Sox ball players and ordered another hearing for Thursday, when it is believed a trial date will be set. The state attorney, appealing for delay, said it had been learned that Cicotte, Williams and Jackson, w’ho confessed to the grand jury would not be available as witnesses. Con sequently the state is unable to ob tain convictions with the present!
Judge Dever refused a motion and ordered another hearing for the indicted White Sox players for Thursday, when a trial date is expected to be set. The report also recaps the investigation's history, from the 1920 grand jury probe to the indictments and the appointment of Judge Landis as baseball commissioner.
The Siftings Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 2
WHITE SOX TO TRIAL NEXT THURSDAY
Inasmuch Arkadelphia as stands a pretty good chance get ting the main line of the Bank head Highway it is well to be posted on the details involved in the big project. After reading the following facts about the Copyright, 1920, ▲. B. Kirschbaum l’umpany the older man. discerning men know the reason. champion Chicago White Sox of eight members of the world finally resulted in the indictment team. two former major league players, two elleged gamblers and a former world champion pugil ' ist on charges that they had con spired for the White Sox team to deliberately lose in the games 1919 world series with Cincinnati Reds.
See moreSee less
It also WAs charged that certain Sox players had accepted bribes rging as high as $10,000 to throw games. Through the investigation, a I world champion team was wreck ed and conditions were revealed which eventually resulted in a new deal for baseball with Fed eral Judge Kenesaw M. Landis as
The report recounts how a Chicago grand jury investigation, sparked by a copyrighted newspaper story about an attempted 1920 fix, led to Cicotte's confession and the indictment of eight White Sox players for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. It notes Jackson's subsequent confession and the eventual appointment of Judge Landis as baseball's first commissioner.
The Siftings Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 2
| article. exposed an alleged at ! tempt to "fix" a National league 'game in August, 1920. The jury investigation then was I ordered and the investigators and started on the 1919 world series. The days that followed produced 'one sensation after another until finally Edward V. Cicotte, White Sox pitcher, once rated the best in the American league. with tears in his eyes confessed that he had received $10,000 to throw games and names seven of his teammates as associates in the al leged deal. Following Cicotte’s confession,. the voted indictments Jury against. him. ( laude ■ Williams. leading southpaw pitcher of the league. Joe Jackson and Oscar Frisch, two of the game’s best outfielders. Buck Weaver, a bril liant third baseman. Swede Ris berg, shortstop. Fred McMullin.
Judge William E. Deever rejected a state motion to remove the Chicago White Sox players' case from the court docket. He scheduled another hearing for the following Thursday to set an actual trial date.
Douglas Daily International · 14 March 1921 · page 1
Refuses to Pigeonhole White Sox Players’ Trial (By Associated Press) CHICAGO. March 14— Judge Wil liam E. Deever today refused to com ply with a motion by the state that
The Chicago Black Sox case was scheduled to be called before Judge Dever, though a 30-day postponement was considered certain amid disputes over scheduling. Most indicted players were reportedly ready to appear, while Comiskey reaffirmed none would ever play for him again.
Arizona Republican · 14 March 1921 · page 5
LID TO COME OFF SCANDAL TODAY
scheduled to be called by Judge W. B. Dever tomorrow, but a postponement of at least 30 days is considered cer tain. The state tonight reiterated its In tention of moving to have the case taken off of the court call, which would prevent its coming up for at least six months, while the defense was pre pared to fight any attempt to postpone the trial more than thirty days. Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver, Fred McMutlin and Swede Risberg tonight were ready to go into court, while Eddie Cicotte was expected from Detroit tomorrow.
See moreSee less
Chick Gandil, the other indicted player, was not expected. , No word has been received from Hal Chase, Rachel Brown. Bill Burns or Joseph J. Sullivan, charged with being the men who arranged the alleged conspiracy. Charles Comiskey, president of the Chicago American league club, who re turned from California tonight, de clared no member of his team who had been indicted last fall would play for him again. These players, he said, are on my Ineligible listIt was not necessary for Judge Landis to put them on his, but I am glad that he did. There is
The case against Chicago White Sox players indicted for throwing the World Series was scheduled to be called by Judge Dever, but a postponement of at least thirty days was considered certain. Players including Williams, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin and Risberg were ready for court, while Cicotte was expected to arrive the next day.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pueblo Chieftain · 14 March 1921 · page 8
MONTH POSTPONEMENT CERTAIN IN BASEBALL "FIXING" CASE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo, Colo.
Comiskey, back from California, declared that none of the indicted White Sox players would ever play for him again, saying they remain on his ineligible list even without Judge Landis's order. The report notes that Gandil was not expected and no word had come from Chase, Burns, or Sullivan regarding the alleged conspiracy.
The article reviews how the scandal probe began in September 1920 when Judge MacDonald charged a Cook County grand jury to investigate fixed games, leading to indictments of eight White Sox players, two ex-players, two gamblers, and a former boxing champion. It notes the fallout included the hiring of Judge Landis as baseball's first commissioner.
Norwich Bulletin · 14 March 1921 · page 3
league baseball was opened officially in September, 1920, when Judge Charles A. MacPonald, chief justice of the criminal court, charged the Cook county grand jury with investigating reports which had come to his attention concerning "fixed" games. .- . ., The grand jury investigation which fol lowed, brought league presidents, club owners and star athletes to the' witness stand.. It finally resulted In the indict ment of eight members of the world champion Chicago White Sox team, two former major league players, two alleged gamblers and a former world champion pugilist on charges that they had con spired for the White Sox team to delib erately lost games in the 1919 world se
Pitcher Cicotte told the grand jury he deliberately hit Rath in the first game but then played honestly afterward, while Williams and Jackson denied actually throwing games. Comiskey, Gleason, and league presidents Johnson and Heydler testified about their own secret investigations into the players.
Norwich Bulletin · 14 March 1921 · page 3
cal reasons, Brown and Sullivan being Indicted as "Rachel Brown and Joseph J. Sullivan, gamblers of New Tork and Bos ton." The confession of Cicotte, which result ed in the indictments, came only after days of investigation made more tense by unconfirmed reports linking Cicotte and others With the ease. . President Charles A. Comiskey and Manager "Kid" Gleason of the White Sox told the jury they had conducted a secret investigation for sev eral months. Certain players were shad owed and every effort made to obtain con vincing evidence, but without result Pres idents B.
See moreSee less
B. Johnson and John Heydler -, the two major leagues confirmed this testimony and told of private Investiga tions they had made. -. Testimony was given that Hal Chase j had sent telegrams to friends, saying the J tioned as one of the bribed players. The pitcher denied the charges, but gradually the circumstantial evidence became stronger and stronger. Finally Billy Maharg, former prize fighter, in an interview with a Philadel phia paper, named Cicotte, Attell, Jack son, and others as taking part in the al leged deal. This, seemingly, was the fi nal straw, for a few days later Cicotte confessed to Mr. Comiskey. Comiskey immediately . suspended the seven players then, with the club, telling them he "would drive hem out of base ball forever", if thecharges were found true. Cicotte was taken to the grand jury and the indictments followed.' On February 14 last, Williams, Weaver and Jackspn filed demand with Judge William B. Dever for a bill of particulars in the case. In affidavits accompanying the demand the three players swore they never conspired to throw games and never actually attempted to throw games. Williams and Jackson, however, did not deny that they confessed to receiving bribes. Xor did Williams deny meeting Brown and Sullivan in Cicotte's room, but said he did not know whether thev were and ! the same Brown and Sullivan that were indicted. The players also denied knowl edge of Charles K Nims.
The case against the indicted White Sox players and others for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series was scheduled to be called by Judge William E. Dever, though a postponement of at least thirty days was expected. The state planned to seek removal from the court calendar while six players, including Jackson and Weaver, were reportedly ready to proceed to trial.
Norwich Bulletin · 14 March 1921 · page 3
INDICTED PLAYERS' CASE SCHEDULED TO OPEN
SCHEDULED TO OPEX Chicago, March 13. The-case .of Chi cago .White Sox baseball ' playersand . others indksed for he alleged hrowing of he 1919 world series is scheduled o be called by Judge William E. Dever of the County courts tomorrow, but a postpone ment of at least thirty days is considered certain. The state tonight reiterated Its inten tion of moving f have the, ease taken off . of the courtcall,- which : would .pre' vent its coming up for at least six months, while the defense was prepar ed to fight an' attempt to postpone the
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
The case against Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series was scheduled to be called in court today. However, a 30-day postponement was anticipated.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 14 March 1921 · page 8
CHICAGO The case of the Chi cago White Sox baseball players and otihers indicted for the. alleged throw ing of the 1919 world's series, is scheduled to be called today, but a postponement of 30 days i3 anticipated
Judge William E. Dever refused the state's motion to remove the Black Sox trial from the court call, setting another hearing for Thursday to determine a trial date. Several indicted players appeared or were represented by counsel, while defense attorneys pushed for an immediate trial and the state sought a postponement of at least thirty days.
Evening Star · 14 March 1921 · page 22
WHITE SOX CASE IS UP
placed on the ineligible list of both Judge Land is and Owner Charles A. Comiskey of the Sox. ne "There is absolutely no chance for ar.y of them to play on my team again unless they can clear themselves to "al my satisfaction of the charges nia^e ?*- | against them." Comiskey said. Plans to have the case taken off the court call, which would delay its reD appearance at least six months, were announced by counsel for the state, hut defense attorneys said this would be contested. A postponement of thirty days is sought by the defense
The trial of indicted White Sox players and others for allegedly fixing the 1919 World Series, scheduled before Judge William E. Dever, is expected to be postponed at least thirty days. Several indicted players including Williams, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin and Risberg were ready for court, while others like Gandil, Chase, Burns and Sullivan had not been heard from.
The New York Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 11
BASEBALL CASE MAY GO OVER FOR 30 DAYS
Object to Postponement. Chicago, March 13.?The case of the Chicago White Sox baseball players and others Indicted for the alleged throwlns of the 1919 world series Is scheduled to be called by Judge William E. Dcver of the "County Court to-morrow, but a post j ponement "f at least thirty day* is con
The criminal trial of indicted White Sox players for the 1919 World Series fix was scheduled to begin before Judge William E. Dever, but a postponement of at least thirty days was considered certain. Several players including Williams, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, and Risberg were ready for court, while Cicotte, Gandil, and alleged conspirators Chase, Burns, and Sullivan were unaccounted for.
The Washington Times · 14 March 1921 · page 12
TRIAL OF INDICTED SOX OPENS TODAY
Felsh, Buck Weaver. Fred McMillin. and "Swede" Risberg tonight were ready to go into court. while Ed4su Cicotte was -expected to reach here from Detroit today. Chick Gandil.
The article reports that the Chicago County Court case against the Black Sox players, set to be called by Judge Dever, is expected to be postponed by at least thirty days. It lists which indicted players were ready to appear in court and notes several others, including Hal Chase and Joseph Sullivan, had not been heard from.
New-York Tribune · 14 March 1921 · page 10
Baseball Scandal Cases Seem Sure To Be Postponed State Reiterates Intent to Have Trials Taken Off Call in Chicago To-day
Call in Chicago To-day CHICAGO, March 13.?The case of the Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series, i? scheduled to be called by Judge Will? iam E. Dever. of the County Court?, to-morrow, but a postponement of at least thirty days is considered certain. The state to-night reiterated its in? tention of moving to have the case taken off the cour-t call, winch would prevent its coming up for at least six months, while the defense was pre? pared to fight an attempt to postpone the trial for more than thirty day-'.
See moreSee less
That length of time would be granted as a courtesy to Judge Barrett. Amer? ican League attorney, so that he could familiarize himself with the charges, it was said. Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver, Fred McMullin and Swede Risberg to-night were ready to go into court, while Eddie Cicotte was expected to reach here from De? troit to-morrow. Chick (tandil, the other indicted player, was not ex? pected. Xo word has been received from Ha! Chase, Rachel Brown, Bill Burns or Joseph J. Sullivan, charged with being the man who arranged the alleged con? spiracy.
Sportswriter W.J. Macbeth criticizes baseball's slow handling of gambling scandals, noting pressure to postpone the White Sox trial set for Chicago and comparing it to past leniency in the Hal Chase case. He also discusses outfielder Benny Kauff's pending auto-theft trial and Judge Landis's involvement.
New-York Tribune · 14 March 1921 · page 11
By W. J. MACBETH connection with automobile stealing, is to be pushed forward as speedily as possible. There seem? to have been a complet? switch in policy since Kauff was called back from the training camp at San Antonio. Tex., for a star chamber interview with Judge K. M. Landis, Commissioner of Baseball. The guilt or innocence of Kauff before the law will be established in trood time?perhaps long before the opening of the championship season. If innocent he deserves every reparation of character; if guilty lie should have no further part, in the game which already has suffered much at the hands of dishonest players.
See moreSee less
There has been far too much sidestepping in this particular case. It is an issue which organized baseball should have insisted upon being brought, to a showdown when it first cropped out, almost a year ago. I p to the present time organized baseball government has shown cross carelessness in administration and lack of initiative in protecting its trust, instead of the probe, the solons were too ready with the whitewash brush. One cannot easily forget the camouflage that was spilled at the o-called trial of Hal Chase two years ago. An ounce of initiative then might have furnished a striking example that would have removed all temptation for the indicted White Sox players to do .business with gam I lers in the 1919 world's series. Out side Pressure Be futidles White Sox Case rrVREMENDOUS pressure is being brought to bear from outside sources to delay the tria] of the indicted White Sox players and to becloud the legal case against them. The trial is set for Chicago to-day, but it is said the prosecution will ask that the case be postponed until next fall. If - done, counsel for the players declares, advantage will be sought of tllinois lav to have said indictments voided at once. A situation, thon, develops which is none too reassuring to a publie which has waited patiently for a long-promised "housecleaning." Organ? ized baseball for many years has suffered from "backstairs" politics, which .-??em brazenly thrust into the case at this time. Many of sound judgment close to baseball politics have suspected a certain clique of attempting to undermine Judge Landis even before he assumed the office of commissioner. They suspect this clique of having worked through Welty all the agitation for the judge's impeachment in order to embarrass or disgust him.
The report describes efforts by unnamed interests to postpone the White Sox players' trial set for that day in Chicago, suggesting legal maneuvering could void the indictments and hinting at a clique trying to undermine Judge Landis. It also notes Heinie Zimmerman's affidavit accusing Giants players Kauff, Benton, and Toney of dishonesty, tying it to the broader 1919 World Series fix scandal.
New-York Tribune · 14 March 1921 · page 11
By W. J. MACBETH connection with automobile stealing, is to be pushed forward as speedily as possible. There seem? to have been a complet? switch in policy since Kauff was called back from the training camp at San Antonio. Tex., for a star chamber interview with Judge K. M. Landis, Commissioner of Baseball. The guilt or innocence of Kauff before the law will be established in trood time?perhaps long before the opening of the championship season. If innocent he deserves every reparation of character; if guilty lie should have no further part, in the game which already has suffered much at the hands of dishonest players.
See moreSee less
There has been far too much sidestepping in this particular case. It is an issue which organized baseball should have insisted upon being brought, to a showdown when it first cropped out, almost a year ago. I p to the present time organized baseball government has shown cross carelessness in administration and lack of initiative in protecting its trust, instead of the probe, the solons were too ready with the whitewash brush. One cannot easily forget the camouflage that was spilled at the o-called trial of Hal Chase two years ago. An ounce of initiative then might have furnished a striking example that would have removed all temptation for the indicted White Sox players to do .business with gam I lers in the 1919 world's series. Out side Pressure Be futidles White Sox Case rrVREMENDOUS pressure is being brought to bear from outside sources to delay the tria] of the indicted White Sox players and to becloud the legal case against them. The trial is set for Chicago to-day, but it is said the prosecution will ask that the case be postponed until next fall. If - done, counsel for the players declares, advantage will be sought of tllinois lav to have said indictments voided at once. A situation, thon, develops which is none too reassuring to a publie which has waited patiently for a long-promised "housecleaning." Organ? ized baseball for many years has suffered from "backstairs" politics, which .-??em brazenly thrust into the case at this time. Many of sound judgment close to baseball politics have suspected a certain clique of attempting to undermine Judge Landis even before he assumed the office of commissioner. They suspect this clique of having worked through Welty all the agitation for the judge's impeachment in order to embarrass or disgust him. The American League majority, which sought to embarrass Charle? A. Comiskey in every conceivable way, insisted upon appointing its own lawyer to handle th? case against the White Sox players. And it is this
Judge Dever refused the state's motion to remove the Chicago White Sox players' case from the court calendar. He set another hearing for the following Tuesday, when the trial date is expected to be determined.
Paper unidentified · 14 March 1921 · page 1
(By Associated Press.) j Chicago. Marcli 14.—Judge Dever [today refused to comply with the mo [tion by tlie state that tlie trial of the [ Chicago White Sox baseball players j and other indicted for throwing the | world series be taken off the court call. He ordered another hearing for i next Tuesday when it is believed the date for trial will be set.
The trial of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series is scheduled to be called by Judge William E. Dever, though a postponement of at least 30 days is considered certain. Most indicted players are reported ready to appear, while Gandil, Chase, Burns, Sullivan and Brown have not been accounted for.
The Pensacola Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX TRIAL BEGINS TODAY
(By The Assorted Press.) CHICAGO, March 13. The case of the Chicago White Sox baseball play ers and others Indicted Tor the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series is scheduled to be called, by Judge Wil liam E. Dever of the county courts tomorrow, but a postponement of at least 30 days is considered certain. The state tonight reiterated its in tention of moving to have the case taken off of the court call, which would prevent its coming up for at least six months, while the defense was pre pared to fight any attempt to post pone the trial for more than 30 days.
See moreSee less
That length of time would be granted as a courtesy to Judge Barrett, Ameri can league attorney, so that he could familiarize himself with the charges, it was said. Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver, Fred McMullin and "Swede" Risberg tonight were ready to go into court, while Eddie Cicotte was expected to reach here from Detroit tomorrow. "Chick" Gandil. the other indicted player, was not expected. No word had been receivea from Hal Chase,
Judge Dever refused the state's motion to remove the Black Sox case from the court calendar. Another hearing was ordered for the following Tuesday, when a trial date is expected to be set.
The Ocala Evening Star · 14 March 1921 · page 1
DEVER IS AFTER THE PIRATES OF DIAMOND
(Associated Press) tie town of Roeers today is in the ut most excitement following the finding t Associated Press) Chicago,' March 14. Judge Dever, today refused to comply with a mo tion by the state that the trial of the Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted for throwing the World Series be taken off the court calendar. He ordered another hear
The eight indicted Chicago White Sox players are brought to trial on charges of throwing the 1919 World Series and accepting bribes. The report notes that one line of defense will contend with the prosecution's case.
The Ocala Evening Star · 14 March 1921 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Judge Dever refused a state motion to remove the White Sox conspiracy trial from the court calendar, instead scheduling another hearing for the following Thursday to set a trial date. The report recaps the grand jury investigation into the 1919 World Series fix, the resulting indictments, and the appointment of Judge Landis as baseball's first commissioner.
Americus Times-Recorder · 14 March 1921 · page 1
JUDGE REFUSES STATE DELAY IN WHITE SOX CASE
Court Call CHICAGO, March 13.—(8y the Associated Press). —Judge Dever today refused to comply with a mo tion by the state that’the trial of the White Sox players and others under indictment, set for today, be taken off the court call. Ke order ed another hearing for next Thur., day, when it is believed the date for the trial will be set. The men are charged with conspiracy to “throw” the 1919 world’s abseball series, in which the White Sox lost to Cincin nati. The investigation into alleged gambling, bribery and game throw ing in major league baseball was opened officially in September, 19$0, when Judge Charles A.
See moreSee less
Mac Donald, Chief Justice of the Crimi nal court, charged theCook county grand jurywith investigating re ports which had come to his atten tion concerning “fixed” games. SIO,OOO Bribes The grand jury investigation which followed, brought league pres idents, club owners and star athletes to the witness stand. It finally resulted in the indictment of eight members of the world champion Chicago White Sox team, two for mer -world champion pugilis't on charges that they had conspicd for the White Sox team to deliberately lose games in the 1919 world series with the Cincinnati Reds. It also was charged that certain Sox play ers had accepted bribes ranging a.-i high as SIO,OOO to throw games. Through the investigation ,a world champion team was wrecked ami conditions were revealed which eventually resulted in a new deal for baseball with Federal Judge Kensaw M. Landis as civilian base
The report reviews the Black Sox scandal, describing how White Sox players conspired with gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series for bribes up to $10,000. It recounts Cicotte's tearful confession, the subsequent indictments of eight players and several gamblers, and the resulting appointment of Judge Landis as baseball's commissioner.
Americus Times-Recorder · 14 March 1921 · page 1
Cicotte Confes-.es The jury investigation then was ordered and the investigators start ed «n the 1919 world series. The days that' followed produced one .sensation after another until finally Edward V. Cicotte, White Sox pitch er, once rated the best in the AmerLeague, with tears in his eyes con fessed that he had received sfo,ooo to throw games and named seven of his teammates as associates in the alleged deal. Following Cicotte’s confession, the jury voted indictments against him, Claude Vyilliams, leading south paw’ pitcher of the league, Joe Jack son and Oscar Felsch, two of the game’s best outfielders.
See moreSee less
Buck Wen . ver. a brilliant third baseman, Swede Risberg, shortstop. Fred McMullin, utility player, and Chick Grandii, first baseman of the White Sox in 1919 but not with the club in 1920 The indictments were voted the day Cicotte confessed September 28, 1920. As soon as they were an nounced, Joe Jackson went to the jury and confessed to receiving $5,- 000, saying it was given to him bv Claude Williams. The next day Wil liams confessed to receiving $lO,- 000 and to giving $5,000 of it to Jackson. The money was given him by Gandill, Williams said. Williams named Gandill and two gamblers who were introduced to him as '“Brown” and “Sullivan” as the go-betweens who arranged the deal with the White Sox players. Indictments immediate! j? were voted aggainst Brown and Sullivan Later Hal Chase, once known as tne “prince of first basemen,” Bid Burns, former major league pitcher, and Abe Attell. ogee world cham pion featherweight fighter, were in dicted as the men who helned engi neer the alleged deal to throw the
The article reviews the September 1920 confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams, detailing how each implicated others and received payoffs, and recaps the subsequent indictments of gamblers Gandil, Brown, Sullivan, Chase, Burns, and Attell for conspiracy. It also notes a bettor defrauded of $250 and Cicotte's account of hitting batter Rath as his only deliberate misplay.
Americus Times-Recorder · 14 March 1921 · page 1
INDICTED AS GAMBLERS IN WHITE SOX BASEBALL SCANDAL
► series. Bettor Defrauded The' indictments charged conspir acy to do an illegal act and obtain ing money under fal'.e pretenses. .Charles K Nims. a'local sportsman, was 'named in the indictments as having been defrauded of $250 through the series, ho having bet that -amount on the White Sox. Cicotte told the grand jury his S I'o,ooo was given him before th Q series started. It was. placed under his piilow, he said. Concerning the actual throwing of the games, the pitcher confessed to' only one delib erate misplay. He said he purpose ly hit Rath, the fibst man rip in the first game, but then repented and after that nlayed his best through out the series.
See moreSee less
Cicotte talked to several officials before going to the grand jury chambers. These offi cians quoted him as confessing to other misplays, but the hitting of
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Judge Dever refused to remove the case from the court calendar despite the state's request, instead scheduling another hearing for Thursday to set a trial date. Six indicted players appeared in court, while Comiskey and Judge Landis confirmed all indicted players remain banned from play pending clearing their names.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 14 March 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX HEARING SET FOR THURSDAY; PLAYERS INELIGIBLE
Judge Landis and Owner Charles A. Comiskey, of the Sox. "There is absolutely no chance ffor any of them to play on my team again unless they can clear themselves to my satisfaction of the charges made against them," Comiskey said. Plans to have the case taken oft the court call, which would delay its reappear ance at least six months, were an nounced by counsel for the state, but i defense attorneys said this would be contested. A postponement, of thirty days is sought by the defense to allow former Judge Barrett, American lea gue attorney, to study the grand iury evidence and charges.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Judge William E. Dever refused the state's request to remove the White Sox case from the court calendar and instead set another hearing for Thursday to determine a trial date. The prosecution argued for delay, noting that confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson might not be available as witnesses.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 14 March 1921 · page 1
Dever. - Chicago, March 14. Judge Wil liam E. Dever today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of Chicago, White Sox players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the world series in 1919, be taken off the court call. He ordered anoth er hearing for next Thursday when it is believed a date for trial will be set Attorneys for the defense moved that an immediate trial be held Thursday end Judge Dever said that he would announce his deci sion on this matter later.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg were in court. Eddie Cicotte, Bill Burns, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachet Brown, Chick Gandil and Abe Attel were represented by counsel. Hal Chase was the only defend ant not present or represented by counsel. Judge Barrett, American league attorney, in pleading for a post ponement, said the prosecution had learned that "Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who confessed to the grand jury, would not be available as witnesses." Consequently, he said, the state could not obtain convictions on the evidence it now had and would have to have time to seek addi tional data. r. f ' - -
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The report describes the opening of the Black Sox trial before Judge Dever, noting that prosecutors may seek a month's delay to study grand jury evidence while defense attorneys plan to contest any postponement. It also notes the indicted players remain banned from play and that three had reportedly confessed to accepting bribes before the grand jury.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 14 March 1921 · page 11
SCANDAL CASE CALLED TODAY, BUT PROSECUTION MAY ASK A MONTH TO STUDY EVIDENCE
Sets Sew Precedents. Cliesgo White Sox baseball playjilt charged with throwing the 1919 jMrid series to the Cincinnati Heas ill with accepting bribes ranging b Ugh as $10,000 to make misjtap deliberately, will go on trial M today in a case wnicn Beta
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The report describes the opening of the Black Sox trial, noting the defense's plan to request a 30-day postponement so Judge Barrett could study grand jury evidence. It lists the eight indicted White Sox players and the four men accused of arranging the fix, along with expectations that the trial will set legal precedents regarding baseball and bribery law.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 14 March 1921 · page 11
COURT TO STUDY EVIDENCE
The Indicted Players. The White Sox players indicted h connection with the alleged con niricy .were Edward V. Cicotte, fttchex who lost two games and toe one in the series; Claude Wil Htms, pitcher, who lost three limes; Joe Jackson, outfielder; Orar Felsch, outfielder; Charles A.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The report outlines expected legal arguments in the Black Sox case, including whether game-throwing is a crime or merely a civil breach. It details how confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson may be used, and how other players plan to deny involvement in the conspiracy.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 14 March 1921 · page 11
Conspiracy is Denied. The chief contention of the de fense in pleading the innocence of tne players will be that they never actually took part in a consDlrucv. The defense has-announced that it will contend that none of them actually threw a game and that tee Cincinnati Reds won the 1919 series on the square. Cicotte, Williams and Jackson, who confessed to the jury that they accepted bribes) are expected to maintain that although they took the money they played their best. The other men are expected to con tend that they never entered into tne conspiracy, neither accepting money nor deliberately making erors.
See moreSee less
The state, on the other hand, plans to present evidence tending to show that there was a conspir acy and will attempt to prove that the men did not play their best ball. Claude Williams' testimony before the grand Jury, that the players met with Brown and Sul livan previous to the contest in CI cotte's room and there discussed the throwing of the series, will be presented as evidence of a con spiracy. Cicotte's testimony that he deliberately hit Rath, the first man up in the second game, is expected to play a big part in the state's case, and the confession of Cicotte that he received $10,000 and of Williams and Jackson that they re ceived $5,000 each, also probably will be used. Concernftifr "Confessions." It is a question, however, how much weight the confessions may have. Under the law, if the accus ed players do not take the witness stand, the confessions can be nsed only against the men who made them. Thus, if Weaver, Risberg and the others who did not confess, do not testify in their own behalf, the confessions of Cicotte. Williams and Jackson could be used only against
A thirty-day postponement was expected when the Chicago White Sox players' case came before Judge William E. Dever. Six indicted players were present, with Cicotte en route, while Gandil and the four accused of arranging the conspiracy had not been located.
The Topeka State Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 5
TO POSTPONE SOX TRIALS
Another Delay of Thirty Days Ex pected When Case Is Called. Chicago, March 14. A postpone ment of at least thirty days was ex pected in the opening of the trial of the . Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series when the case comes up before Judge Wm. K. .Dever of the county court today. Six of the indicted players were on hand, ancK Eddie Cicotte was reported en route here early today, while Chick Gandil. the other indicted player and the four charged "with arranging the alleged conspiracy have not been heard from ' All the indicted players have been placed on the ineligible list of both Judge Landis and Owner Charles A.
The case against the Chicago White Sox players indicted for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series was scheduled to be called before Judge William E. Dever, with a postponement of at least 30 days considered certain. Several players including Williams, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin and Risberg were reportedly ready to appear in court, while Cicotte was en route and Gandil was not expected.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 1
MONTH'S DELAY TRIAL ACCUSED BALL PLAYERS
Today Chicago, March IS.—The case of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series is scheduled to be called by Judge Wil liam E. Deever of the county courts tomorrow. But a postponement ofat least 30 days is considered certain. The state tonight reiterated its in tention of moving to have the case taken off the couht call, which would prevent its coming up for at least six months, while tfte defense was prepar ed to fight an attempt to postpone the trial for more than 30 days.
See moreSee less
That length of time would be granted as a courtesy to Judge Barrett, American League attorney, so that he could fa miliarize himself with the charges, it was said. Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver, Fred McMullln and Swede Risberg tonight were ready to go into court, while Eddie Cicotte was expected to reach here from De troit tomorrow. Chick Gandil, the other indicted player, was not expect ed. No word had been received from Hal Chase. Rachel Brown, Bill Burns or Joseph J. Sullivan, charged with being the men who arranged the al leged conspiracy.
On the eve of the Black Sox trial, the defense plans to argue that indicted players never intentionally misplayed and thus could not have conspired. The report recaps conflicting grand jury testimony, noting Cicotte admitted hitting a batter on purpose but claimed he played to win afterward, while others denied wrongdoing.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 2
MONTH'S DELAY
: ers. In reply, the state plans to point [out that Cincinnati won its five ! games through hard hitting of two ! ihdicted pitchers and below par play | ing of other indicted men. j, The story of the series shows that jin the first game, Cincinnati scored I in the first inning after Cicotte hit I Rath—deliberately, he told the grand | Jury. j Jackson, Felsch and Gandil, indict ! ed players, produced a run which tied the score in the second inning. Jack son was safe on an error, Felsch , sacrificed and Uandil s single scored Jackson.
See moreSee less
In the fo'ur, Cincinnati drove Ci cotte, who confessed to receiving $10, 000 to throw games, out of the box j and produced five runs. Cincinnati won, 9 to 0. I Cincinnati won the second game, 4 l to 2, Williams, the other pitcher who ! confessed to receiving money, walked two men in the second and a single apd triple scored three runs for Cin cinnati. Aother walk, followed by a single and a sacrifice produced a run in the sixth. j Weaver, who was indicted, doubled in the sixth for Chicago. Jackson, ,the third player who confessed, fanned, but Felsch, another indict ! ed man, hit one far out into the field. ; A sensational catch by Rouscli pre j vented a Chicago run. Chicago's two runs came in the seventh when, Risberg, charged with tuning part of the conspiracy, singled, Schalk singled and both scored on Neale’s wild throw. In the ninth Gandil singled but Risberg hit | into a double play. ^ The third game was won from ‘ Chicago through the defensive work of Dick Kerr, who pitched, and the offensive work of the indicted play ers. In the second inning Jackson singled, Felsch bunted safely and both scored on Gandil's hit. In the fourth Risberg singled and went to third when the ball got awav. Schalk’s butt fielded slowly by Fish er, scored Risberg for the third and final run. Cicotte pitched the fourth game for Chicago, losing 2 to 0, his own errors being responsible for both the National Leaguer’s runs. In the fourth inning Cicbtte threw wild to tirct, muffled a throw from Jackson and allowed two hits for two runs. In the fifth Vamc Filer shut out the White Sox o to 0. In the first inning Leibold walked, Collins went out and Weaver singled. With two on Felsch and Jackson filed out. With two out in the ninth Weaver tripled, but Jackson could not score him. Chicago had no other chances to score. Williams pitched f®r Chi cago. in me sixiu inning Eller hit be tween Felsch and Jackson and whid was described at the time as clow fielding by the pair gave him an ex tra base. Bath singled scoring El ler. Daubert sacrificed, Groh walked, and Felsch misjudged Rpusch’s fly, letting it drop for a triple which scored two more runs. The indicted players did not figure in any other scoring. The accused players won the sixth game by their ln<,Jvjdual work, bringing a 5 to 4 ten-inning victory to the Sox with Kerr pitching. Felsch's extraordinary catch of Rousch’s fly in the first, cut off a Cincinati run and in the fourth Jack son threw out a man at the plate for a double play. • Weaver dropped a pop fly in short center for a single in the sixth, get ting second on it. Jackson scored him with a hit and Felsch doubled, scoring Jackson, Gandil flied out. The game was decided in the tenth when Weaver again hit a Bhort fly for a single getting to second when the ball bounded away from Duncan. Jackson bunted safely and Felsch fanned. Gandil s ingled through the pitcher, scoring Weaver. Risberg lined to ICopf for a double play. The seventh game was another Chicago victory in which the eight men charged with throwing the series figured. Jackson scored J. Collins with singles in the first and third innings. later, with E. Collins on first. Weaver was safe on a fum ble. Jackson apparently hit into a
The report recounts confessions given to the grand jury by Cicotte and other indicted players, noting Cicotte admitted deliberately hitting Rath but claimed he played honestly afterward, while other players denied throwing games or receiving money. It details a play-by-play account of several World Series games, which the defense plans to use to argue Chicago's losses stemmed from legitimate baseball factors rather than a fix.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 2
MONTH’S DELAY (Continued from Page One) by playing better baseball than the Chicago White Sox." That will be one of the contentions of the defense when the eight Chica go White Sox players indicted on charges of throwing the series and accepting bribes are brought to trial here tomorrow. While the complete plans of the defense will not be known until the trial begins, attorneys already have announced that they will contend that the indicted players never in tentionally made misplays and con sequently could not have taken part in a conspiracy. Claude Williams and Joe Jackson
The report reconstructs play-by-play detail from the 1919 World Series, highlighting specific actions by the indicted players (Jackson, Felsch, Risberg, Gandil, Weaver, Cicotte, Williams) in each game. It frames errors, hits, and defensive lapses as evidence relevant to the fix allegations being investigated.
Chicago Judge William E. Dever refused the state's motion to delay the trial of the White Sox players indicted for fixing the 1919 World Series, ordering another hearing for the following Tuesday to set a trial date. The American League's attorney warned that confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson might not be available as witnesses, weakening the prosecution's case.
The Bismarck Tribune · 14 March 1921 · page 1
JUDGE REFUSES CONTINUANCE OF BASEBALL TRIAL
Chicago, Mar. 14.—Judge William E. Dever today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for the alleged throw ing of the world series of 1919 be tak en off the court call. He ordered an other hearing for next Tuesday when it is believed a date for the trial will be set. Attorneys for the defense moved! that an at a he dssy and1 Judge Dever said he would! announce his decision on this matter later. Judge Barrett, American League at torney.
See moreSee less
in pleading for postponement said the prosecution had learned that Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who confessed to the grand jury, "would not be available as witnesses." Consequently, he said, the state could' not obtain conviction on the evi dence it now had and would have to have' time to seek additional data.
Judge William Dever refused the state's motion to remove the Black Sox trial from the court calendar, instead scheduling another hearing for the following Thursday to set a trial date. Several defendants including Williams, Weaver, Felsch, and Risberg appeared in court, while others were represented by counsel and Hal Chase was absent entirely.
Grand Forks Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 11
REFUSES TO TAKE BASEBALL TRIAL OFF COURT CALL
OFF COtjRT CALL Chicago/ March 14.—Judge William E. Deyer today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of Chicago White Sox players and. others indicted for the alleged throwing of tfte 1919 world's aeries be taken off •the court "call..( He ordered that an other hearing for* next Thursday.' When it is believed a date for, the trial -will be set... i-] Attorneys. for the defense moved that an imiAediate trial be held Thurs day and. Judge Dever said that he would announce His'decision on this matter later.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, Buck Weaver,' Osciar Felsch and. .Swede Risber^, were In court. Eddie Cicptte, Bill Burns, John J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown Chick Gandll and Abe Attell were represented by counMl. Hal Chase was the, only defendant !j not present or represented by counsel.'
As the trial of the eight indicted White Sox players began in Chicago, defense attorneys announced they would introduce World Series batting and fielding averages to argue the players did not deliberately throw games. The averages showed mixed results, with Weaver and Jackson outperforming their opponents and their own season norms, while Risberg, Felsch, and Gandil fell below theirs.
Grand Forks Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 14
Jackson equalled Weaver's feat, but Risberg and Felsch were outplayed mathematically by their opponents and fell slightly below their own regu lar season averages. Gandil also was below his opponent and his regular
The defense for the indicted Black Sox players plans to introduce their batting and fielding averages from the World Series as evidence. The report details comparative statistics for players like Groh, Kopf, Duncan, Daubert, McMullin, Cicotte, and Williams.
Grand Forks Herald · 14 March 1921 · page 14
DEFENSE OF INDICTED MEN TO INTRODUCE BATTING AND FIELDING AVERAGES SOON
FIELDING AVERAGES SOON season averages except in world series fielding. He outfielded his opponent. Daubert. McMullin was used only as a pinch hitter in the series, batting: .500 with one hit out of two .attempts. Cicott® and Williams, as pitchers, probably were not expected to do much hitting and neither did any in the series. Williams fielded 1,000, but CiCotte made two errors for an average of .778. The following table gives the bat ting and fielding average of each in dicted player in the series, during the regular season and also his oppon ent's world series figures: 'Indicted Players. World Series Reg. Season Bat. Fldg. Bat. Fldg.
The Associated Press reports that the case against the Chicago White Sox players indicted for the 1919 World Series scandal is set to be called by Judge W. E. Dever, but a thirty-day postponement is expected. Several players, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver, are reportedly ready to appear, while Comiskey declares none of the indicted players will ever play for him again.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 2
PLAYERS CASE SET FOR TODAY
than thirty days. Claude Williams. Joe Jackson. Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver. Fred Me.Mullin and Swede Risberg to night were ready to go into court, while Eddie Cicotle was expected from Detroit tomorrow. Chick Candil, the other indicted player, was not expected. No word bad been received from Hal Chase. Rachel Brown, Bill Rums or Joseph .1. Sullivan, charg ed with being the men who ar ranged the alleged conspiracy. Charles Comiskey, president of tho Chicago American league club, who returned from California to night, declared no member of his team Who had been indicted last full would play for him again.
See moreSee less
"These players," he slid, "are on my ineligible -list. It was not nec essary for Judge lindis to put them on his, but I am glad that he did. There is absolutely no chance for any of them to play on my team again unless they can clear themselves to my satisfaction."
The trial of indicted White Sox players for the 1919 World Series scandal was scheduled to begin but a postponement of at least 30 days was considered certain, to allow American League attorney Judge Scott time to familiarize himself with the case. Most indicted players were reportedly ready to appear in court, though Chick Gandil and several alleged conspirators had not been heard from.
The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 14 March 1921 · page 5
Postponement Likely in Trial of Indicted White Sox Players
White Hose Players) Cllle.UiO, Manli 1.1 TinrnD of CIiIpiikij White Sox baseball players and others indicted for tho IlllcKed Ihl'OWlUK of the 1319 World hoi leu, U scheduled to bu
A report states that the opening of the Black Sox trial before Judge William E. Dyer is expected to be postponed by at least 30 days. Six indicted players were present, with Eddie Cicotte en route, while Gandil and others had not yet appeared; Comiskey reaffirmed that all indicted players remain ineligible to play.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 14 March 1921 · page 5
Baseball Trial Postponement Chicago, March 14. A postpone ment of at least 30 days was expected I in the opening of the trial of the ! Chicago White Sox baseball players, ; and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 3919 worl.1 series wfoen the case comes up beforo Judge Wil liam E. Dyer of the county court to day. Six of the Indicted players were on hand, and Eddie Cleotto was reported route here early today, wnne "Chic" Gandil, tho other indicted play er and the four charged with arranging the alleged conspiracy (have not been heard from.
See moreSee less
All the indicted players have been placed on tho Ineligible list of both Judge Landls and owner cnories a. Comlskey ot the Sox. There Is absolutely no chance tor any of them to play on my team again unless they can clear themselves 10 my eatisfaction of the charges made aga,nst tlhtin," Comiskey said. SiMirt Notes From All Over
Judge William Dever refused the prosecution's motion to postpone the trial of the Chicago White Sox players indicted for throwing the 1919 World Series, instead ordering another hearing for the following Thursday to set a trial date. The prosecution argued for delay because confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson would not be available as witnesses, weakening their case.
Capital Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Court Refuses To Postpone Trial of Baseball Players
Chicago, Mar. 14—Judge William Dever today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of the Chicago White Sox players and other indicted for the alleged throwing of the world series in 1919 be taken off the court call. He ordered another hearing for next Thursday when it is believed a date for trial will be set.
See moreSee less
Attorneys for the defense moved that an immediate trial be held Thursday and Judge Dever said that he would announce his decision on this matter later.
Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Charles Risberg were in court. Eddie Cicotte, Bill Burns, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Chick Gandil and Abe Attell were represented by counsel. Hal Chase was the only defendant not present or represented by counsel.
Judge Barrett, American league attorney, in pleading for a postponement, said the prosecution had learned that Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who confessed to the grand jury, would not be available as witnesses. Consequently, he said, the state could not obtain convictions on the evidence it had and would have to have time to seek additional data.
The state's attorney's office announced plans to move for a continuance of the White Sox players' trial until after baseball season ends, while defense attorneys insisted on an immediate trial or dismissal. Commissioner Landis stated he would keep the indicted players on the ineligible list, barring them from organized baseball until the trial concludes.
Capital Journal · 14 March 1921 · page 1
Fight Looms Over Date of Players' Trial
Players' Trial Chicago, Mar. i 4. The state's at- "rneys office has formally an nounced that when the trial of the kicago White Sox players charged n'h throwing the 1919 world ser " comes up next Monday the state H move that the case be taken "hi call and not hrniifrht hock nn- " lent fall when the baseball 4ea has ended. Attorneys for the Ml said they would insist on P an Immediate trial or disMf K. M. Landis, baseball com "loner, when informed of the ' announcement said he would
Judge Dever refused to remove the Black Sox trial from the court calendar despite the prosecution's request for more time, ordering another hearing for Thursday. The state said key witnesses Cicotte, Williams and Jackson would not be available, while defense attorneys accused authorities of unfairly keeping the players under suspicion.
Evening Public Ledger · 14 March 1921 · page 1
HEARING NEXT THURSDAY Chicago. March 14. Judge William K. Dever todny refused to comply xvith n motion by tho state thnt the trinl ot Chicago White Sox plnyers and others Indicted for the nllescd throwing of tho 1010 xvorld series be taken off the court call. He ordcrvd another hearing for next Thursday, when It is believed a date for trial will bo set. Attorneys for the defenie moved that on immediate trial bo held Thursday, and Judge Dever snid he xvould an nounce his decision later. Claude Wil liams, Huck Weaver, Oscar Felsch and Swede Rlsberg were In court.
See moreSee less
Eddie Cicotte. Hill Hums. Joseph J. Sullivan, R. Brown. Chick Onndil nnd Abo Attcl were represented by counsel. Hnl Chnse xx'os the only defendant not present or represented by counsel. Judge Barrett, American League at torney, in pleading for a postponement. nid the prosecution hud learned that "Eddie Cicotte. Claude Wllllnms and Joe Jackson, who confessed to the arand jury, would not be available ns witnesses." Consequently, he said, the state could not obtain convictions on the cvldcnci It now had nnd xvould huve to hnvo more time to seek additional data. In reply, attorneys for Hie defense said that nn attempt wns being made to keep the Indicted men under n cloud of suspicion nnd to prevent them from earning nn honest living. To this the state replied that Judge Kcnesnw M. Landls, baseball commis sioner, already had placed the players on the Ineligible list and that President Comiskey. of the White Sox, had said they couid never play on his team whether guilt) or innocent. Benedict Short, nttorncy for Wil liams and Jackson, said the men were being glx'cn "drty treatment." "There Is a Caesar-like person who sits nt the head of baseball nnd Issues ukases xvith both hands," he said. "One of his objects seems to be to besmirch these Innocent men." Joe Jackson also xvus In court, but Fred McMullin xvas represented by counsel.
The prosecution requested a postponement after learning that Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, who had confessed to the grand jury, would not be available as witnesses, leaving insufficient evidence for conviction. Defense attorneys argued the players were being unjustly kept under suspicion and barred from earning a living, despite being ruled ineligible by Commissioner Landis and barred by Comiskey regardless of guilt.
Judge Dever postpones the trial of the accused White Sox players after the prosecution reveals that Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson—who had confessed to the grand jury—will not be available as witnesses. A new hearing is set for Thursday to determine a trial date, while defense attorneys push for an immediate trial.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 14 March 1921 · page 1
BALL CASE WITNESSES "WON'T BE AVAILABLE"
('lande Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch and Charles i Elisberg were in court Eddie Cicotte, foil Burns, Joseph J. Sulhvan, Rachel Brown, Chick .ainlil and Abe Attel were repre sented b counsel. Hal Ohase was the only defendant not present or represented by counsel. Jildge Barrett, American league attorney, in pleading for a j postponement, s,ul the prosecution had learned thai "Eddie I i 1 cotte Claude Williams and Joe Jackson who confessed to ihe grand jury, would not be available as witnesses." Consequently he said the state could not obtain convictions on the evidence ii now had and would have to have time to se.-k additional data. POLICE BREAK ILiGiTES UP 108 BENT CALLED B? Hi FOR QUIZZING ON lllll JEWS
Earl Sheely, former Salt Lake first baseman, is traveling to join the Chicago White Sox spring training in Louisiana after signing with owner Charles Comiskey. The article notes Comiskey sought new talent after eight 1920 White Sox players were indicted for allegedly throwing games.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 14 March 1921 · page 10
BEES STAR GOING TO JOIN WHITE SOX
Earl Bheely, first baseinan of the Salt iake club of the Pacific Coast league trurlng the 1J20 season, now j the property of Hie Chicago White Sox will arrive in igden this evening! en route to Louisiana, where the White Sox are training, areordlng to! local railroad officials Bheely has been a holdout for the past three weeks but has finally come to terms With Owner Charles Comlskey.
Judge William E. Dever refused a state motion regarding the court calendar in the trial of the Chicago White Sox players indicted for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series. He scheduled another hearing for the following Thursday to set a trial date, despite defense attorneys requesting an immediate trial.
The Caledonian-Record · 14 March 1921 · page 1
BALL PLAYERS TRIAL TO GO ON AT ONCE CHICAGO, March 14 Judge Wil liam E. J)ever toda refusod to coni j)!y with a motion by the state at the trial of the Chicago White Sox play ers and others, indicted for the alleged throwing of the 11)11) World Seri .; bi; taken of the court cali. He ordo i ed another hearing for next Thursday when it is believed a date for trial : will bc set Attoniey?, foy the defense moved that an immediate trial be hcM Thursday and Judge Jiever said he ! would announce his decision later.
Judge William E. Dever refused the state's motion to remove the White Sox players' indictment from the court call, setting another hearing for the following Thursday to possibly set a trial date. Several defendants, including Weaver, Felsch, Risberg, and Williams, appeared in court, while Hal Chase was absent and unrepresented.
Paper unidentified · 14 March 1921 · page 1
NUMBER 131 DEFENSE WINS FIRST ROUND IN WHITE SOX HEARING, MOTION TO TAKE CASE OFF CALL IS DENIED CHICAGO, March 14.—Judge William E. Dever today I refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial . of Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the world series in 1919 be taken off the court call. He ordered another hearing for next Thurs day, when it is believed a date for trial will be set. Attorney tor tho defense moved thatwilllams and Joo Jackson, who conan immediate trial bo held Thursday, fessed to the grand jury, would not and Judge Dever said he would an be available as witnesses. Conse
Defense attorneys for the indicted White Sox players plan to introduce batting and fielding averages showing the players performed at or above their season norms during the 1919 World Series. They will argue there was no conspiracy and that Cincinnati simply won by playing better baseball.
Paper unidentified · 14 March 1921 · page 5
Season; Bride Payments Admitted CHK't'kP’ Batting and fielding averages of the fkVr Chl , c ?B° White Sox players charged with throwing the 1918 world series and the claim that "Cincinnati won the senes on the square by playing better baseball than the Chi cago White Sox will be introduced by the defense in con tending’ tne innocence of the indicted men whose trials were to begin here today but which may Ing into the conspiracy or receiving be postponed on motion of the state. money. Attorneys tor the defense have The defense will be prepared to sub made no secret of the* fact that they
The defense will argue there was no conspiracy, citing World Series batting and fielding averages compared to regular season performance. Confessions from Williams, Jackson, and Cicotte are noted, with each maintaining they played their best despite admitting to receiving money.
Paper unidentified · 14 March 1921 · page 5
TO BE USED IN TRIAL OF PLAYERS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes evidence both defense and prosecution plan to use, recounting a game-by-game breakdown of the 1919 World Series highlighting plays by indicted players. It covers the first four games, attributing Cincinnati's wins partly to confessed pitchers Cicotte and Williams and Chicago's win to Dickey Kerr's pitching.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Paper unidentified · 14 March 1921 · page 5
TO BE USED IN TRIAL OF PLAYERS
The defense will be prepared to sub mit the play by play account of the series, which shows that Chicago won its three games largely through the feats of some of the indicted play era. In reply the state plans to point out that Cincinnati won its five games j through hard hitting of two Indicted i pitchers and below par playing of oth ' er indicted men. The story of the series shows that in the first game. Cincinnati scored in the first inning after Cicotte hit Rath—-deliberately, he told the grand jury.
See moreSee less
Jackson. Felsch and Gandil, Indict ed players, produced a run which tied I the score In the second inning. Jack son was safe on an error, Felsch sacri ficed and Gandil’s single scored Jack son. In the fourth Cincinnati drove Ci cotti, who confessed to receiving >lO,- 000 to throw games, out of the box and produced five runs. Cincinnati' won 9 to 0. Cincinnati won the second game, 4 to 2, Williams, the other pitcher who confessed to receiving money walk ed two men in the second and a single and triple scored three runs for Cin cinnati. Another walk, followed by a single and a sacrifice produced a run’ in the sixth. Weaver, who was indicted doubled in the sixth for Chicago, Jackson, the third player whs confessed, fanned but Felsch, anotriter indicted man, hit one far out into the field. A sensa- • tional cateb by Housch prevented a Chicago run. Chicago’s two runs came in the seventh when Risberg, charged with taking part in the conspiracy, singled, Schalk singled and both scored on Neal’s wild singled but Risberg hit into a double PlayThe third game was won for Chi cago through the defensive work of Dick Kerr,. who pitched, and the offensive work, of the indicted pT&r ers. In the: second Inning Jackson, singled, Felsch bunted safely and both scored on Gandil’s hit. In. the fourth Risberg singled and went to third when the ball got away. Schalk’s bunt.
Chicago court rejected the state's attorney's motion to delay the trial of the indicted White Sox players, setting another hearing for Thursday to fix a trial date. The state had sought more time because confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson were reportedly unavailable as witnesses.
The Nenana Daily News · 15 March 1921 · page 1
DELAY BASEBALL HEARING CHICAGO, March 15—As predict ed several days ago, the state tried to get a postponement of the trial of indicted White Sox players when the case was called yesterday. But the court promptly denied the mo tion and ordered another hearing for Thursday, at which time, it is believed, the date of the trial will be definitely fixed. In appealing for delay, 'the state’s attorney said that he had learned that Cieotte, Williams and Jackson, who confessed to the grand jury, are not now available as witnesses and consequently the state is unable to obtain convictions at present. An extension of time is needed, it is claimed, to gather additional evi dence.
Defense counsel for six of the eight indicted White Sox players successfully pushed for an early trial before Judge Hugo Friend (printed as Dever), over objections from the state's attorney's office. The judge announced the case would be called Thursday with an early trial date to follow.
Bisbee Daily Review · 15 March 1921 · page 1
Elks. i BASEBALL TRIAL SOON CHICXGO. March '14 Despite pro tests of the state's attorney's off'ce. counsel for six of the eight indicted Chiciro White Sox players were suc cessful today in forcing an early trial before Judge Wy E. Dever. Judge Dever announce! that th case would be called Thursday and that an early date for tho trial would be set.
Judge W.E. Dever refused prosecution requests to postpone the Black Sox trial, setting it for Thursday despite objections from special prosecutor C.F. Barrett. The state noted it had lost Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson as witnesses, whose testimony had formed the basis of the indictments.
Pueblo Chieftain · 15 March 1921 · page 3
JUDGE DEVER IS FIRM IN REFUSAL FOR POSTPONING
|: dletments were said to have been, | based on their testimonyClaude Williams, Buck Weaver. 11 Oscar Felscli, Charles Risberg were I in court, Eddie Cieotte. Bill Burns, JI Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown. IjCricg Gandll and Abe At tell were
The article reviews how a 1920 Cook County grand jury investigation into alleged game-fixing led to Cicotte's confession and indictments of eight White Sox players, two ex-players, two gamblers, and a boxer. It notes the scandal's fallout included the hiring of Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis as baseball's first commissioner to clean up the sport.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Pueblo Chieftain · 15 March 1921 · page 8
SAVED LIFE OF NATIONAL SPORT
Chicago. March 14.—The investiga tion Into alleged gambling, bribery and’ game throwing in major league base ball was opened officially in Septem ber. 1920. when Judge Charles A. McDonald. Chief Justice of the Criminal Court, charged the Cook county grand jury with investigating reports which had come to his attention concerning "fixed" games. The grand jury Investigation which followed, brought league presidents, club owners and star athletes to the witness stand. It finally resulted in the Indictment of eight members of the world champion Chicago White Sox team, two former major league players, two alleged gamblers and a former champion pugilist on charges that they had conspired for the White Sox team to deliberately lose games in the 1910 world series with the Cincin nati lleds.
See moreSee less
It also was charged that Certain Sox players had accepted bribes ranging as high as to throw games. Through the investigation, a world champion team was wrecked and con ditions were revealed which eventual ly resulted in a new deal for baseball with Federal Judge Kenosha wH. Landis as civilian baseball commission er with supreme powers to run the pro fessional game as he saw fit'with the object of keeping crookedness out of it forever. While Judge Mae Donald's eharge to the jury was the official opening of the investigation by the state, there had been many rumors since the close of the 1919 world series that It had not been played on the square and testi mony given the grand Juryrevealed that various baseball officials had con ducted private invest igat ions for months, but without definite results. These rumors came to a head when n Chicago paper, in a copyrighted : article, exposed an alleged attempt to, "fix" a National league game in Aug- ■ tist. 1920. The Jury Investigation then was or- , dered and' the investigators started on | the 1919 world series. Tito days that followed produced on-- sensation after; another until finally Edward V. Cicotte. White Sox pitcher, once rated the best in the American league, with | tears in his eyes confessed that he had ; received JlO.ftoo to throw games and , named seven of his teammates as asso- ! dates in the alleged deal. Following t "icotte's confession, the j Jury \ oted indictments against him.! Claude Williams, leading southpaw pit.her of tin* league. Joe Jackson and ; Oscar Fclscli. two of the game’s best \ outfielders. Buck Weaver, a brilliant third baseman. Swede Rlsherc. shor'-j top. Fred M< Mul I in. utility player, an 1 Chick Grandil. first baseman of the WhitSox in I'BO but not with the club In 19-0. The Indictments were voted th" dav Cicotte confessed September 28. 1920 As soon as thc> were announced. Joe Jackson went to the jury and confess- , od ng JS.OOI • g t waa I gi\en to him by Claude Williams. The I next da.' Williams confessed to receiv ing SW.'<on aml to giving $5.<VW> of it *n \ .Takson. The inonc> was given him by GandH. William said. William named Gandll and two gamblers who worn introduced to him as "Brown" and "Sullivan" as the go who arranged the deal with i the White Sox pla> ers. Indictments immediately were voted n gainst Brown and Sullivan. Liter Hal! Chase, once known as the "prince of I first basemen.” Bill Burn former! major league pitcher, and Abe Attell. | once world champion featherweight | fighter, w ere Indicted us. the men who • helped engineer the alleged deal tot throw the series. The Indictments charged conspiracy to do an illegal net and obtaining money under false pretense*. Charles ] K Sims, a local sportsman, was named ; In the Indictments as having been <|e | fra tided of $250 through the -.cries, he having bet that amount on the White Sox. Cicotte told the grand jury his JbV <v>n v..,. given him before the scries started. It won placed under his pil low. he said. Concerning the actual ti • wring ol 'he sunt thi plt< her confessed to only one deliberate inis pliy He said h»- purposely hit Hath, th. first man up in the first came, but then repented and after that pluyed , his best throughout the scrlo* • ’i.-otte talked to S' v«*ra I offb ials before going to the grand iury chambers. These Officials quoted him as • onfessing «•> other mis pi.i >s. but the hitting of Until the only one officially reported to tin* grand Jury by the pitcher William and Jackson aid thej dlu net actually throw any gam re The other players claim that they did not reeeivf piojp and did not throw oii\ gnrn'-s. .! • kson. Williams ; nrt Ficot'e were tile only lndi< ted players to go be fore the grand Jury. Williams said the rigid White :-ot playors met with Brown and Sullivan First of all. get it firmly fixed In jnur mind That nil Um liniment* In thworld would havno rffci l u h.it ever on Rheumatism. Medical scientists differ as to *hc causes "f every form of rheumatism, but agree that when caused by a tiny disease germ, the only effectivo meth od of treatment in to attack the dls rane at Its sourer, and cleanse the blood of its cause. A very common form of Rheuma tism is caused by millions of liny gcruus which lnfcol tho blood. Tlu
The report recounts how Cicotte confessed to taking $10,000 to fix the 1919 World Series, leading to indictments against seven teammates, two gamblers, and later Chase, Burns, and Attell. Jackson and Williams also confessed to receiving money, though all denied actually throwing games.
Pueblo Chieftain · 15 March 1921 · page 8
the White Sox pla> ers. Indictments immediately were voted n gainst Brown and Sullivan. Liter Hal! Chase, once known as the "prince of I first basemen.” Bill Burn former! major league pitcher, and Abe Attell. | once world champion featherweight | fighter, w ere Indicted us. the men who • helped engineer the alleged deal tot throw the series. The Indictments charged conspiracy to do an illegal net and obtaining money under false pretense*. Charles ] K Sims, a local sportsman, was named ; In the Indictments as having been <|e | fra tided of $250 through the -.cries, he having bet that amount on the White Sox. Cicotte told the grand jury his JbV <v>n v..,. given him before the scries
The report reviews how Cicotte's confession to Comiskey led to grand jury indictments, detailing testimony from Comiskey, Gleason, Johnson, and Heydler about secret investigations into the fixed 1919 World Series. It also notes Williams, Weaver, and Jackson's later affidavits denying they conspired to throw games, and the technical revoting of indictments naming Brown and Sullivan as gamblers.
Pueblo Chieftain · 15 March 1921 · page 8
Baseball in Cicotto's room in a small southside hotel and thoro discussed throwing games. The players made individual deals concerning the amounts they were to receive, ho said, after first be ing offered and refusing $5,000 each. Near the end of the investigation all of the indictments were revoted for technical reasons. Brown and Sullivan being indicted as “ilachel Brown and Joseph J. Sullivan, gamblers of New York and Boston.” The confession of Cicotte. which re sulted in tho indictments, came only after days of investigation made more tense by unconfirmed reports linking Cicotte and others with the case.
See moreSee less
President Charles A Comiskcy and Manager “Kid” Gleason of tho White Sox told tho jury they had conducted a secret investigation for several months. Certain players were shadow oil and every effort made to obtain con victing evidence, but without result. Presidents B. B. Johnson and John lleydler of tintwo major leagues con firmed this testimony and told of pri vate investigations they had made. Testimony was givfn that Hal Chase hud sent telegrams *o friends saying t lie series had been "fixed". Cicotte was mentioned as one of tho bribed players. The pitcher denied the charges, but gradually the circumstan tial evidence became stronger and stronger. Finally Billy Maharg. former prize fighter, in an interview with a Phila delphia paper., named Cicotte, Attell. Jackson ami others as taking part in the alleged deal. This, seemingly, was tho final straw, for a few days later Cicotto confessed to Mr. Comlskoy.
Lawyers for six of the eight indicted former Chicago White Sox players succeeded in forcing Judge William E. Dever to set an early trial date, despite objections from the state's attorney's office. Prosecutors Barrett and Gorman said they had lost key witnesses Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, on whose testimony the indictments were based.
The Washington Times · 15 March 1921 · page 18
BALLPLAYERS CASE CALLED THURSDAY
then be set. Former Judge George F. Barrett. special prosecutor. and Assistant State's Attorney George E. Gorman asserted that the State had lost Cl 0tte. Claude Williams and Joe Jack son as witnesses. The indictments were said to have been based on their testimony. "We need time to build up a new Gase," asserted Judge Barrett. "We don't like the Idea of a Szed date dangling before us." Attorney Willim A. Berger ap peared on behalf of Abe Attell, Ralph A. Brown and Joseph J. Sullivan.
Judge William E. Dever refused the state's motion to expedite the trial of the Chicago White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series, instead ordering another hearing for the following Thursday. The prosecution argued for postponement citing the unavailability of key confessed witnesses, while defense attorneys accused the state of trying to keep the players under suspicion to prevent them from working.
Date for White Sox Trials May Be Announced Thursday
Another Hearing Attorneys for the defense moved th.it ? an immediate trial be held Thursday, an.-! Judge Derer said that hi1 would announce his decision later, Claude Williams, Ruck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risborg and Joe Jackson were in court. Eddie .Ciet-tte, Bill Burns, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rache! Brown, Chick Gandil and Abe Attell were repre? sented by counsel. Hal ' base was the only defendant not pro.?; n! ir repre? sented by counsel. Judge Barrett, American League at? torney, in pleading for a postponement, said !l!o prosecution hail learned that.
See moreSee less
"Ktldie f'icot.te, Claude William:* nnci J??,' Jackson, who confessed lo the grand jury, would not be availabla as wit? nesses." Consequently, he Raid, the state could not obtain convictions on the evidence it nosv hail and would have to have more time to see'..; additional d ata. In reply, attorneys fcr the defense said that an attempt vas being made to keep the indicted men under a cloud of suspicion and to prevent them from earning an 'nonest living To this the state rep?r?! that Judge Konosaw M. Landis, baseball commis? sioner, already* had pl'tccrl ibe players on the ineligible list and that ?'resi? lient Comiskcy, of the White Sox, had said they could never plr.y on his team, whether guilty or innocent. Benedict Short, attorney for Wil? liams and Jackson, said the men were being given "dirty treatment." "There is a Csesar-like person who sits at the heatl of baseball and issues ukases with both hands," he said. "One of his objects seems to be to besmirch these innocent men."
Judge Dever reserved decision on the American League's request to postpone the Black Sox trial after prosecutors said Cicotte, Williams and Jackson, who had confessed to the grand jury, would not testify. Defense attorneys argued the delay was meant to keep the players under suspicion, noting Commissioner Landis had already ruled them ineligible and Comiskey said they'd never play for the White Sox again.
New-York Tribune · 15 March 1921 · page 12
To this the state rep?r?! that Judge Konosaw M. Landis, baseball commis? sioner, already* had pl'tccrl ibe players on the ineligible list and that ?'resi? lient Comiskcy, of the White Sox, had said they could never plr.y on his team, whether guilty or innocent. Benedict Short, attorney for Wil? liams and Jackson, said the men were being given "dirty treatment." "There is a Csesar-like person who sits at the heatl of baseball and issues ukases with both hands," he said. "One of his objects seems to be to besmirch these innocent men."
Judge William E. Dever refused a state motion to remove the White Sox trial from the court calendar, instead ordering another hearing for the following Thursday to set a trial date. Prosecutors argued for delay since confessed players Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson would not be available as witnesses.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 March 1921 · page 3
WHITE SOX TRIAL OFF COURT CALL Chicago, March 14—Judge William E. Dover today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial of Chicago White Sox players i and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series be taken off the court call. He ordered another hearing for next Thursday, when it is believed a date for trial j will be set. Attorneys for the defence yoved \ thatan immediate trial be held on Thursday and Judge Dever said that he woudl announce his decision later.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, Ruck Weaver, Os car Felsch, and Swede Risberg were in court. Eddie Cicotte, Rill Burns, | Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown, | Chick Gandil and Abe Attell, were represented by counsel. Hal Chase | was the only defendant not present 1 or represented by counsel. Judge Barrett. American League at torney, in pleading for a postpone- , ment, said the prosecution had
The trial of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted in the 1919 World Series scandal was scheduled before Judge Dever, but a postponement of at least 30 days was considered certain. Comiskey declared no indicted player would ever play for him again, and defense attorneys previewed their argument that Cincinnati won fairly and the players made no intentional misplays.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 March 1921 · page 8
Trial of Indicted Persons in World Series Scandal Scheduled to Start Today, But Postponement Likely
Chicago. March 14. i-The case of i Chicago White Sox base ball players and others indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series is scheduled to be called by Julgc V. E. Dever today, but a postpone ment of at least 30 days is consid ered certain. The state Sunday reiterated its in tention to move the case be taken off the court call, which would pre vent its coming up at least six months, while the defense was pre pared to fight to postpone the trial more than 30 days. Claude William. Jot Jackson, Os catr Fclsch, Buck Weaver, Fred Mc Muilin and "Swede" Risberg Sunday were ready to go into court, while
Defense attorneys plan to argue indicted players never intentionally made misplays, citing play-by-play evidence that Chicago won games through some of the accused players' efforts. The prosecution counters that Cincinnati won through hard hitting against indicted pitchers and poor play by other indicted men, referencing grand jury confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 March 1921 · page 8
games. Ctcotte confessed to hitting Rath, the first man up in the first game, purposely, but said he played his best after that. The other play ers denied either throwing games, entering into N the conspiracy or re ceiving money, to Submit Play by PJay. The defense will be prepared to submit the play by play account of the series, which snows that Chicago won its three games largely through the feats of some of the indicted play ers. In reply, the state plans to point out that Cincinnati won its five games through hard hitting of two indicted pitchers and below par playing of other indicted men.
See moreSee less
, The story of the series shows that in the first game, Cincinnati scored in the first inning after Cicotte hit Rath deliberately, he tolfl the grand jury. . . Jackson, Felsch and Gandil, in dicted players, produced a run which tied tli. score in the second inning. JacksOn was safe on an error. Felsch sacrificed and. Gandil's single scored Jackson. In the fourth Cincinnati drove Ci cotte. sho confessed to receiving $10,000 to throw , games, out of the box and produced five runs. Cin cinnati won 9 to 0, . Cincinnati won the second game, 4 to 2, Williams.- the other pitcher who confessed to receiving money, walked two men in the second and a single and triple scored three runs for Cincinnati. Another walk, fol wlowed by a (single and a sacrifice, produced a r;in the sixth. i
The report reviews specific innings from the 1919 World Series, detailing plays by players later indicted in the Black Sox scandal, including Weaver, Jackson, Felsch, Risberg, Cicotte, and Williams. It highlights suspicious plays, such as misjudged fly balls and wild throws, that contributed to Chicago's losses in several games.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 March 1921 · page 8
Chicago Wins Third Came. The third game'was wonfur Chi cago through the defensive work of DickKerr, wjio pitched, and the of fensive work of the indicted players. In the second inning Jackson singled, Fclsch bunted safely and 'both scored on Gandil's hit. In the fourth Risberg singled and went to third when the ball got away. Schalk's bunt, gfiiflded slowly by Fisher, scored Risberg for the thirl and final run. Cicotte pitched the fourth, game for Chicago, losing 2 to 0, his own trrors being responsible for both the National ""leaguer's runs.
See moreSee less
In the fourth jjining Cicotte threw wild to first, muffed a throw from Jackson and allowed two hits for two Wins. In the fifth game FJler shut out the White, Sox, 5 to 0." fn the first inning Lribold walked, Collins went out and Weaver singled. With two on. Fclsch and Jackson :"fiied out. With two ut in the ninth Weaver tripled, but Jacksoit could not score him. Chicago had no other chances to score. Williams pitched for Chi cago. , In the sixth inning Eller hit be tween Fclsch and Jackson and what was described at the time as slow fielding Dy the pair gave him an extra base. Rath singled scoring Eller. Daubcrt .sacrificed. Groh walked, and Felsch misjudged Rousch s fly, lettering it drop for a trtole. which scored two more runs. The indicted players did not figure in anv other scoring. The accused players won the sixth game by their individual work,' bringing a S to 4 10-ining victory to the Sox Avith Kerr pitching. Felssh's extraordinary catch of Rousch's fly
Judge William Dever refused the state's motion to keep the Black Sox trial on the court calendar for immediate hearing. He scheduled another hearing for the following Thursday, when a trial date is expected to be set.
The Democratic Banner · 15 March 1921 · page 1
ILL RE ID s ten i.h.h.'V t t pr t By Associated Press to The Banner CHICAGO, March 14 Judge 'WIIHam Dover today refused to comply with a motion by the state that the trial' of Chicago White Sox players a'nd others Indicted for the alleged throwing of tho 1919 world sories bo taken pff the court' call. 'He ordered another hearing for next Thursdaywhen it is bellved a date for trial will be set. Attorneys for tho dofonso proved that an immediate trial be held on Thursday and Judge Dover Bald that he would announce his decision later.
Judge William Dever scheduled a Thursday hearing on the state's attorney's motion to strike the Black Sox cases from the court calendar. Defense attorneys demanded an immediate trial, alleging a 'baseball oligarchy' was working to keep the indicted players out of the game.
The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 15 March 1921 · page 10
Postponing Sox Trial CH1CAOO, March 14. Jililgo William H. Dover, In tho superior court todny set Thursday nt 10 a. m. as tlm hour for hearing ar guments on tho motion of tho atat'a attorney that tho cases against tlm Indicted White Sox ball players nnd others bo atrtcken fiom the rourt calendar. Aaslstunt State's Attorney Oeorge llorman moved that tho cases be token off tho court cnl endar when tho case waa report ed In court today. Attornfcya for the defendants demanded nn Im mediate trial, charging that there. Is n "baseball oligarchy" act on keeping the defendants out of baseball, Jildgo Dever declined to hear arguments today but put the mut ter until Thursday.
Lawyers press for an immediate trial while prosecutors say they need Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams to repeat their grand jury confessions or new evidence must be built up. Defense attorneys claim the state's case is collapsing, alleging a witness tried to sell out to the defense, and Jackson's and Williams' lawyer denies his clients confessed anything.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 15 March 1921 · page 8
at a hearing In Judge Dever's court Monday that the state's witnesses were placing themselves >>n tin mar lie said that Charles K NIms. who is named in th<- indictment as the victim of the alleged 'conspiracy to defraud the public." eame to ills ollice and "offered to sell "lit to the de fense." Niins. next to Cicotte. Williams and
At a pretrial hearing, defense attorney Benedict Short denied that his clients Jackson and Williams had confessed anything and criticized Judge Landis as part of a 'baseball oligarchy.' Weaver's attorney presented a petition from 10,000 fans seeking his reinstatement if acquitted, while both Landis and Comiskey have barred all indicted players from play.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 15 March 1921 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The state dropped its case against all indicted White Sox players except Chick Gandil after the court refused a six-month extension to gather new gambling evidence. Prosecutors said they would seek new evidence and indictments, noting that alleged grand jury confessions by Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams were not available as evidence.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 March 1921 · page 1
State Drops Case Against Indicted White Sox Players
Kme throwing' in major league seball. Prosecuting attorneys announced, however, that new evidence wouldj be sought after which new indict-i ments would be usked. Alleged con fessions of Edward V. Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams before the Grand Jury are not a\ailable as evidence, the prosecution said. The case of Gandil was stricken from call by the court and cannot be caTIed again before six months' have elapsed.
Prosecutors announced that charges against the eight Black Sox players were dropped from the current indictment, with plans to seek new evidence and new indictments. The report details the scope of the scandal, naming all accused players and gamblers, and notes the resulting reforms including the appointment of Judge Landis as baseball commissioner.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 March 1921 · page 1
All Famous Players. Seven players are freed from previous charges by the State’s ac tion. They are: Cicotte, once rated the best pitcher in the American League, Williams, leading southpaw of the league, Joe Jackson, one of i the game's best and hardest hitting: outfielders, Oscar Feish, another top rotch outfielder. Buck Weaver, brii liant third baseman, "Swede” Ris-j berg, ehortstop, and Fred McMullin, utility player. The grand jury’s investigation, started last September, resulted in
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey notified the eight players indicted for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series that their contracts were void. He stated he would maintain no further relations with them.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 March 1921 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
COMISKY SEVERS ALL RELATIONS WITH 8 INDICTED WHITE SOX
CHICAGO, March 17. — Charles Comisky, President of the Chicago American League Baseball Club, yesterday notified the eight White Sox players under indictment on charges of conspiring to throw games of the 1919 world series with Cincinnati, that their contracts were null and void and that he would maintain no further relations with them.
Judge William Dever dismissed indictments against seven of the eight indicted White Sox players at the request of State's Attorney Richard Crowe, who said he could not be ready for the May 2 trial date. Crowe stated he would seek to re-indict the players once he reconstructed the case, and the gamblers' trial was also postponed indefinitely.
Cleveland County Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 1
BALL PLimiSMISSEO Indictments Nolle Prossed On Motion of States Attorney Richard Crowe. Chicago, March 17.—Indictments against seven of the indicted White Sox ball players, charged with throw ing the 1919 world’s series, were dis missed today by Judge William De ver. Judge Dever said he had no author ity to dismiss the case against the eighth player, Shick Gandil, because Gandil never appeared in court. The indictments were nolle prossed on the motion of States Attorney Richard Crowe, who said he would be unable to go to trial on May 2, the date set. Crowe said he would later seek to have the men re-indicted, when he was able to reconstruct the case. The trial of the gamblers involved in this deal was indefinitely post poned.
Wire dispatches report on various baseball teams' spring training camps and exhibition game scores, including the Chicago White Sox training at Waxahachie, Texas, before the New York Giants' arrival. Also includes unrelated local news items like a Kansas boxing bill and an orphanage fundraiser.
Pueblo Chieftain · 17 March 1921 · page 10
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey formally severed all ties with seven players indicted in the gambling scandal, declaring their contracts null and void. The players, already under suspension, were named as Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams and Cicotte.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Pueblo Chieftain · 17 March 1921 · page 10
COMISKEY SEVERS ALL RELATIONS WITH INDICTED WHITE SOX MEN
was directed arc: Charles Risberg, Fred McMullln, Joe! Jackson. Oscar Frisch, George Weaver. O. P. Williams and E. V. Cicotte. "he communication from Mr. Comiskey said: 1 BAIT CASTERS TO
Chicago prosecutors dropped cases against all indicted White Sox players except Chick Gandil after a judge refused a six-month continuance, with State's Attorney Crowe citing corruption of key witnesses like Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams. Crowe vowed to seek new indictments once fresh evidence could be gathered.
New Britain Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 1
INDICTED BASEBALL PLAYERS NOT TRIED
William K. Dever had refused to srant a continuance of more than 60 days in the case. The state demand ed six months on the ground that it would take that length of time to gathor evidence which would give the prosection a chance of convic tion. New Action Inter. Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert E. Crowe, state' attorney announced that an attempt would be made to gather new ;vi denoe and that new indictments would be sought against the men. The players whose cases were dropped were those who had surrendered and given bail, namely Claud Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Swede Rlsberg, Eddie CMcotle, Buck Weaver
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
The state dropped charges against the Chicago White Sox players indicted for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series. The move came after Judge William E. Dever refused to grant the six-month continuance prosecutors said they needed to gather evidence.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 17 March 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX Chicago The state today dropped the cases against all of the Chicago White Sox basebaill players indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 w u 1 ili irAV.C,l. viiiv-tv. vraiiuu. The action was taken after Judgar' "William E. Dever had refused tt& grant a continuance of more than 60 days, in the ease. The state demand ed six months on the ground that it would take that length of time to gather evidence which would give the persecution a chance of conviction.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
Charles Comiskey issued a formal notice severing all ties between the White Sox club and the players indicted in the scandal. Those released include Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Cicotte.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 17 March 1921 · page 10
Indicted White Sox Are Now "Free Agents" All of the indicted White Sox ball players got the gate for good yesterday, so far as Charles Comiskcy Is concerned.
The state dismissed its case against all former Chicago White Sox players indicted for throwing the 1919 World Series except Chick Gandil, after a judge refused to grant a six-month continuance. Prosecutors said they needed more time to gather new evidence and announced they would seek new indictments against the dismissed players.
Imperial Valley Press · 17 March 1921 · page 2
TRY GANDIL ONLY (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, March 17.—The state dropped the case against all former Chicago White Sox baseball players, indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1019 World Series, except Chick Gan dil. This action was taken after the the court refuse dto grant a continu ance of more than 60 days. The state demanded six months on the ground that it would take that time to gather new evidence on which to give the pro secution a chance for conviction. New indictments will be sought in the cases dismissed.
State's Attorney Crowe dropped all charges against indicted White Sox players except Gandil after Judge Dever refused a lengthy continuance needed to gather evidence. Crowe stated that key witnesses Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams had been corrupted, undermining the prosecution's case, though new indictments would be sought.
Evening Star · 17 March 1921 · page 1
STATE DROPS CASE AGAINST WHITE SOX
18K6I> I(OD?ri ?i. yfvwc, blakc d ?kwi?ic/i announced that an attempt would be made to gather new evidence and that new Indictment* would be sought against the men. The players whose case* were dropped were those who had surrendered and given bail, namely Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg, Eddie CIcotte, Buck Weaver and Fred McMullln.
State's Attorney Crowe announced the White Sox conspiracy cases were dropped after confessions from Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams were apparently nullified through a mysterious conspiracy. He vowed to seek new indictments once fresh evidence against the players was secured, while Comiskey formally discharged the seven accused players from the team.
Evening Star · 17 March 1921 · page 1
AGAINST WHITE SOX
the state of its three chief witnesses." Mr. Crowe continued. "I don't know just how this conspiracy came about, but I know it existed and that through it the testimony given by Jackson, Williams and Cicotte was-lost to us.
Charles Comiskey, president of the Chicago White Sox, formally severed all relations with seven players implicated in the 1919 World Series scandal. The players—Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Cicotte—had been under suspension since September 1920 and were now permanently released from the club.
The New York Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 13
with permanently severed. Tboso to whom the notice was directed arc Charles Risberg, Fred McMuIlin, Joe Jackson, Oscar Feisch, George Weaver, C. P. Will iams and IS. V. Clcotte. The communication follows: "On or about September 26, 1920, you and each of you were notified of your indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American J^eaguo baseball club (tho White Sox). As you were then notified, your suspension was brought about by information which came to the undersigned directly Involving you, and each of you, in th baseball scandal concerning the world series of 1919.
See moreSee less
Additional information received since that date has con firmed the belief that your actions hate been detrimental to the reputation of the club and entirely inconsistent with your obligations to it. "Investigation of conditions eurroundir.tr your connection with or
Judge William E. Deever was set to rule on the state's motion for a continuance in the Black Sox trial, with preparation reportedly complicated by disavowed grand jury confessions from Cicotte and Jackson. Comiskey formally discharged all seven indicted players from the White Sox, citing actions detrimental to the club's reputation.
Paper unidentified · 17 March 1921 · page 6
WHITE SOX TRIAL MAY BE SET SOON BY JUDGE DEEVER
Chicago, March 17.—The next move in the efforts to start the trial of the | White Sox baseball players and otb ; ers indicted in the 1919 world's series j scandal today was up to Judge Wil liam E. Deever who was to pass on the motion of the state for a continu ance and perhaps set a date for the trial. Attorneys for the defense an nounced their readiness to proceed with the case, but counsel for the state asked for more time for prepar ation which, it was understood, had been complicated by reported dis avowals of the allege confessions to the grand jury of Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson.
See moreSee less
Regardless of the out come of the trial, the seven former White Sox players have been formal ly and completely discharged from thfi team, President Comiskey declared. Contracts of all but two expired last year, while George (Buick) Weaver’s had one year more to run Joe Jack son’s had two years more. ‘‘Additional information received since your suspension last Septem ber." said Comiskey’s formal notice to Risberg, McMullen, Jackson, Felsch Weaver, Williams and Cicotte, “has i confirmed the belief that your actions have been highly detrimental to the reputation of the club and Inconsis tent with your obligations to it.’> The contract w(th Chick Gandil, the other member of the Sox under in dictment, expired in 1919 and he left organized baseball to play with "out law” teams. Bonnie Woodward, 26, a choru9 girl, jumped to her death from the fifth storey window of a New York hotel.
The state dropped indictments against several White Sox players accused of throwing the 1919 World Series after the court denied a long continuance, leaving only Chick Gandil charged. The state's attorney said he would seek new evidence and new indictments against the others, including Hal Chase.
The Ocala Evening Star · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Chick Gandil Seems to be the Only Baseball Criminal Left at Chicago
(Associated Press) ' Chicago, March 17 The state to day dropped the cases against White Sox players . indicted for alleged throwing of the World Series, except Chick Gandil. After the court refus ed to grant more than sixty days con tinuance, the state demanded six months to gather new evidence. The court then ordered the cases of Gan dil, Hal Chase and others charged with being those who arranged the alleged conspiracy, stricken off the court rolL The state's attorney announced he would seek new evidence andjiew in
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Chicago prosecutors dropped charges against all indicted White Sox players except Chick Gandil after a judge refused a long continuance, citing corruption of the state's key witness. State's Attorney Crowe said new evidence would be gathered and new indictments sought against the men.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 17 March 1921 · page 1
STATE'S WITNESS REPORTED TOO CORRUPT TO PROCEED WITH CASE
The players whose cases were ‘drop ped were those who surrenderéd lp4§ lave given bail, Williams; .Ihckqol;.. Telsch, Rizberg, Cicotte, Weavbr, uti hlullin. "" ',* " The cases of Gandil, Hal Chade, l@i; chel, Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, A!J
A Chicago judge refused to grant the state a six-month continuance to gather new evidence, leading prosecutors to drop charges against seven indicted White Sox players, including Jackson, Weaver, Cicotte, and Williams. Only Chick Gandil's case was not dismissed, and State's Attorney Crowe announced plans to seek new indictments from the grand jury.
The Daily Star-Mirror · 17 March 1921 · page 1
-'UL BUT ONE OF ALLEGED CROOK EI> wr'SPnrarm WERE DISCHARGED 1 - 1 CHICAGO—(By A. P.)—The state dropped the cases against all former the i Chicago White Sox baseball players indicted for alleged "throwing" the the 1919 world series, except Chick Gan the die. 1 This action followed Judge De verse's refusal to grant a continuance more than 60 days. The state de manded six months in order to gather new evidence and insure a chance of conviction. State's Attorney Crowe announced that an attempt will be made to gath er new evidence and that newindict ments will be sought.
See moreSee less
• The cases dropped are those of the men who surrendered and gave bail They are: Claude Williams, Joe Jack son, Oscar Felch, Swede Risberg, Ed die Cicotte, Fred McMullin and Buck ! Weaver. Will Seek New Indictments 1 Slate's Attorney Crowe annoi need j late today that he will go before the
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey announced the outright release of Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Buck Weaver, Eddie Cicotte, Swede Risberg, and Claude Williams, who had been under suspension since their indictment. Comiskey made clear that even if acquitted, these players would not play for the White Sox again.
The Lake County Times · 17 March 1921 · page 13
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A Chicago judge dismissed indictments against seven of the eight accused White Sox players after the state's attorney admitted he could not be ready for the May 2 trial date, citing collapse of the case after three players repudiated their grand jury confessions. Gandil's case could not be dismissed since he had never appeared in court, and prosecutors said they would seek reindictment once the case was rebuilt.
Indiana Daily Times · 17 March 1921 · page 8
8 Charges Against Chicago White Sox Players, Accused of 'Throwing' Series Games, Dismissed
GANDIL NOT CLEARED CHICAGO, March 17.—Indictment against seven of the eight White Box baseball players Charged with “throw ing" the 1919 world’s series to Cincinnati were dismissed today by Judge William Dever. The Judge said he had no author ity to dismiss the case against the eighth Slayer, Chick Gandil, because Gandil nad ever appeared in court. The Indictments were nolied e* motion of State's Attorney Robert Crowe, who said that he would be unable to go to trial by May 2, the date set for opening of the trial by Judge Dever.
See moreSee less
Crowe announced, however, that he would later seek reindictment of the ball players when he Is able to reconstruct the case against them which he said was torn down by repudiation of the al leged confessions given before the grand Jury by three of the indicted men. Collapse of the State's case against the baseball players came as a climax to the most sensational charges of alleged fraud ever brought to light in connection with the game. Immediately after the world's series in 1919 rumors of alleged fraud were heard. Although followers of the
Prosecutor Crowe announced the case against the indicted players fell apart after three of them repudiated their grand jury confessions, though he vowed to seek reindictment later. Comiskey formally released seven players, while New York enacted a new law making bribery of ballplayers a felony.
Indiana Daily Times · 17 March 1921 · page 8
once. J sport generally favored the Chicago White Sox to win, the big gamblers on the ''inside” wagered huge amounts oa Cincinnati. Nothing came of the reports until a county grand jury was called to Inves tigate the charges last September. Ed die Cicotte, ace pitcher for the White Sox, appeared before the jury and after he testified the indictments were voted. Be sides Cicotte the following were accused: Joe Jackson, Claude Williams. Hap Pelsch. Swede Risberg, Buck Weaver, Chick Gandil and Freu McMullen.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The state dismissed indictments against seven White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series after a judge denied a six-month continuance request. Prosecutor Robert Crowe vowed to gather new evidence and seek fresh indictments, while Gandil and others accused of orchestrating the scheme had their cases struck from the docket.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Names Dropped. The players whose cases were drop ped are those that had surrendered and given bail, namely: Claude Wil liams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch. Swede Risberg, Eddie Cicotte, Buck
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The next step in the Black Sox trial rests with Judge William E. Dever, who will rule on the state's request for a continuance and possibly set a trial date. The state's preparation was reportedly complicated by news that Cicotte and Jackson disavowed their grand jury confessions; meanwhile Comiskey formally released all seven indicted players from their contracts.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 March 1921 · page 11
WHITE SOX TRIAL MOVE UP TO JUDGE WHO MAY SET DATE
Attorneys for the defense announc ed their readiness to proceed with the case but counsel for the state asked for more time for preparation which it was understood had been complicat ed by the reported disavowal of the alleged confession to the grand jury of Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson. Regardless of the outcome of the trial, the seven former White Sox players have been formally and com pletely discharged from the team President .Charles A. Comlskey an nounced. The contracts of all but two expired last year, whi George (Buck) Weaver's had one . ea.' more to run and Joe Jackson's had two years more. Additional information received
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The state abandoned prosecution of Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg, Buck Weaver, Eddie Cicotte and Fred McMullin for the alleged 1919 World Series fix, retaining only the case against Chick Gandil. State's Attorney Crowe said the corruption of key witnesses—Jackson, Cicotte and Williams, who had confessed to the grand jury—made conviction unlikely without new evidence.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 17 March 1921 · page 1
DROP WHITE SOX CASES IN COURTS
Chicago White Sox baseball play ers indicted for the alleged throw ing of the 1919 world's series, ex-' cept Chick Gandil. ' . The action was taken after Judge William K. Dever had refused to grant a continuance of more than 60 days in the case. The state de manded six months, on the ground that it would take that length of time to gather evidence which would give the state a chance' of conviction. Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert E. Crowe, state's attorney, announced that an at tempt would be made to gather new evidence and that new indictments would be sought against the men.
See moreSee less
The players whose cases were dropped were those who had sur rendered and given bail, namely, Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Os car Felsch, Swede Rlsberg, Buck Weaver, Eddie Cicotte and Fred McMullin. The cases of Gandil, Hal Chase, Rachel Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, Abe Attel and Bill Burns were stricken off the court call by Judge Dever. They were charged with being the men who arranged the al leged conspiracy. . - - Taking the cases off court call prevents calling them up again for six months. Mr. Crowe, In his announcement that the cases were dropped, said that he "was convinced that a crime had been committed, but that cor ruption of the state's principal wit nesses made it impossible to go on with the case." "Joe Jackson, Edle Cicotte and Claude Williams, the men who con fessed to the grand Jury, have been corrupted," he declared. "With their evidence available, we would have had a dean cut case against these men and be sure of obtaining con victions. Without their evidence our case is hopeless. "This case Is not finished, how ever, and these men have not es caped punishment We are going right after the evidence that will convict, and we know where to get it "When this evidence has bean procured I shall personally go be fore the grand Jury and seek new Indictments. And there will be no mistakes this time,"
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey sent unconditional release notices to seven players indicted in the 1919 World Series scandal, including Jackson, Cicotte, and Weaver. Judge William Dever was expected to set a trial date for the defendants.
The Topeka State Journal · 17 March 1921 · page 3
SOX PLAYERS ARE LET OUT - Formal Notice of Unconditional Release Sent Seven Accused Players
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · Annapolis, Md.
The state dropped charges against seven Chicago White Sox players accused of fixing the World Series, after a judge refused to grant a six-month continuance. Prosecutors say they will seek new evidence and indictments within six months, while cases against alleged conspirators like Hal Chase and others were also struck from the docket for now.
Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · 17 March 1921 · page 1
STATE DROPS ALL BALLPLAYERS' CASES WITH ONE EXCEPTION
ments in about six months. The players whose cases were i dropped were those who were out ( on bond, namely: Claude Wilj liams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch. J Swede Ilisberg. Bddie Cicotte. ; Buck Weaver and Fred Mc.Muilin. ,
Judge William Dever dismissed indictments against seven White Sox players accused of throwing the 1919 World Series after prosecutor Crowe said he couldn't be ready for the April 1 trial date. Crowe vowed to seek reindictment, though the statute of limitations was set to expire soon, and Comiskey formally released the players.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 17 March 1921 · page 1
BALL PLAYERS DECLARED SAFE INDICTMENTS DISMISSED ON EVE OF PROSECUTION
Chicago, March 17.-f-Indictments against seven White Sox baseball players charged with “throwing” the 1919 world series to Cincinnati, were dismissed today by Judge Wil liam Dever. / The Judge said he had no author ity to dismiss the case against the SIghth player, Chick Gandil, because Gandil had never appeared in court. The trial of the gamblers alleged to have “fixed” the players was in definitely postponed. The indict ments were nolled on statements of Robert Crowe, who said he would be unable to go to trial by April 1st, the date set for the trial by
Prosecutor Rowe said he would seek reindictment before the April 1 statute of limitations expired, but officials considered the case against the Black Sox players effectively over. Comiskey formally released seven indicted players, while Judge Dever was expected to set a trial date for the defendants.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 17 March 1921 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Chicago state's attorney Robert Crowe dropped charges against seven White Sox players after Judge Dever refused a long continuance, though Chick Gandil's case continued. Crowe announced new evidence would be gathered and new indictments would follow against all players, including those arranging the conspiracy like Hal Chase and Abe Attell.
Hickory Daily Record · 17 March 1921 · page 1
William E. Dever had refused to grant a continuance of more than 60 days in the case. The case wanted! six months on the ground that it would take that long to work up the evi dence. Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert E. Crowe, state's attorney, announced that an attenrnt would (be made to gather new evi dence and that new indictments would followThe players whose cases were dropped were those who Ihad given bonds namely, Claud Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Swede Ris berg, Eddie Cicotte, Buck Weaver '
The state dropped charges against seven indicted White Sox players, including Weaver, Cicotte, and Jackson, after a judge refused to grant a six-month continuance. Chick Gandil's case and those of alleged gambler conspirators were stricken but not dropped, with prosecutors vowing to seek new indictments.
The Bismarck Tribune · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Chicago, March 17—The state to day dropped the cases against all of the Chicago White Sox baseball play ers indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series except "Chick" Gandil. The action was taken after Judge Wijliam M. Dever had refused to grant a continuation of more than 60 days in the case. The state demanded six months on the ground that it would take that length of time to get the evidence which would give the pro secution a chance of conviction. Immediately after the action had been taken Robert E.
See moreSee less
Crowe, states attorney announced that an attempt would be made to gather new evidence and that new indictments would be sought against the men. The players whose cases were drop I ped were those who had surrendered md given bail, namely "Buck" Wea I ver, Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, "Swede" Risberg Eddie I Cicotte and Fred McMullin. Others Go Over 1
The state dropped charges against seven indicted White Sox players, keeping only the case against Chick Gandil, after a judge refused a lengthy continuation. Prosecutor Crowe vowed to gather new evidence and seek fresh indictments, while Judge Landis reacted with shock at the news.
Grand Forks Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 1
DROP THE CASE AGAINST SEVEN BALLPLAYERS
liams, Joe JacksoO, Oscar fVbch, Swede Risberg, Eddie Clcotte, Fred McMuIlin and Buck Weaver. Other Cases Striken Off. The cases of Gandil, Hal Chase, R. Brown, Jos. J. Sullivan, Abe Attell and Bill Burns were .stricken off the
State's Attorney Crowe announced that cases against eight players who had surrendered and given bail were dropped, citing loss of key testimony from Jackson, Williams, and Cicotte due to a 'conspiracy' and leaked grand jury testimony. Cases against alleged fixers Gandil, Chase, Attell, Burns, and others were stricken from the call, with Crowe vowing to seek new indictments.
Grand Forks Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Other Cases Striken Off. The cases of Gandil, Hal Chase, R. Brown, Jos. J. Sullivan, Abe Attell and Bill Burns were .stricken off the court called by Judge Dever. They were charged with being the men who arranged the alleged conspiracy. Taking the cases off the call prevents calling them, up again for six months. Judge Kenesaw M. Landis, baseball commissioner refused to.comment on the action of Mr. Crowe. "They've what?" he shouted when told that the cases had been dropped. ''I can't say a word," he. continued. 'A peculiar conspiracy has stripped the-state of its three chief witnesses."
See moreSee less
Mr. Crowe said. '.'I don't know Just how this! conspiracy came about but know it existed and that through it the testimony given by Jackson. Wil liams and Cicotte was lost to us. "Also, a news syndicate in some un derhanded way obtained copies of the grand jury testimony and offered it tor sale. Thus it has become plain that the defense was in full possession of all of our evidence and to proceed would be useless."
The State of Illinois dropped charges against all indicted Chicago White Sox players except Chick Gandil, who failed to appear in court. The move came after a judge denied a prosecution request for a continuance longer than sixty days, with the State seeking six months to gather evidence for new indictments.
The Evening World · 17 March 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX CASES FOR FIXING GAMES ARE DISMISSED
New Indictments. niUCAGO. March 17. The State to-day dropped the cases against ah of tho Chicago White Sox basoball playorr) Indicted for tho alleged throw. In? of the, 1919 World Serif except Chick Uandil, who did not appear. Tlx etiur. wa taker, after Judge W..1.. tr K Di ' h ie refused to graft .i k.'ontinunne oi more tl.an sixt.v day :i. t'.it -' The State ut :'.aii.leij o..x months on the grounds that it would take that length of j time to gather evldene which would 1 g.ve the prosecution a chance of con vie.tlon Immediately after tho action had
The state dropped charges against all indicted former White Sox players except Chick Gandil after a judge refused to extend the statute of limitations beyond 60 days. State's Attorney Crowe said he would seek new evidence and new indictments against the dismissed players.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 17 March 1921 · page 1
1921 1920 4 Maximum yesterday .6S 40 Minimum yesterday ...S9 U the former Chicago White Sox base-, ball players Indicted for the alleged i throwing or the 1919 world's series ! except "Chick" Gandil. The action j was taken after Judge Dever refused to grant a continuance of npire titan (ill days j Immediately after this action had been taken. State's Attorney Crowe 1 announced that an attempt would be made to gather new evidence and have new Indictments brought against the men The players whose cases were dropped are Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Folsch. Swede Ris berg, Eddie Cicotte. Fred McMullln
Chicago prosecutors dropped the conspiracy charges against seven White Sox players after a judge denied a six-month continuance, though cases against alleged fixers like Hal Chase and Abe Attell were also struck from the docket. State's Attorney Robert Crowe vowed to gather new evidence and seek fresh indictments.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 17 March 1921 · page 8
STATE OF ILLINOIS DROPS THE BASEBALL CONSPIRACY CASE
Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert Kcrowe, State's attorney announced Uint an attempt would be made to gather new evt dence that new Indictments would be sought against the men. Players whose cases were dropped were those who had surrendered and given bnil, namely, Claude Williams, Joe Jack son, Oscar Felsch, Swede Riseherg, Eddie .Clcotto, Buck Weaver and Fred McMullin, The cases of Candil, Hal Chase, Rachel Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, Abe Attell and Bill Burns, wer stricken off the court call by Judge Devers. They were charged with being the men who arretted the alleged con spiracy.
See moreSee less
Taking the cases off the call prevents railing them up again for six months. Judge Kenesnw M. Land is, baseball commissioner, refused to comment to day on the action of tho state In dropping the barebull gambling char acters. "They've ' what" he shouted when told that the cares had bovn dropped. "I can't say a word," he continued.
Chicago authorities dropped the indictments against all former White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series, except for Chick Gandil, after a judge refused to grant the state a lengthy continuance to gather more evidence. The report frames Gandil as the sole remaining defendant in the case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Evening Herald · 17 March 1921 · page 1
All Save Gondii CHICAGO, Mnrch 17. The btate today dropped tbo cases against all former Chicago White Sox ball flay ers, indicted for tho alleged throw ing of tho 1919 world's series, cccopt
Judge Dever refused a long continuance, so Illinois prosecutors dropped charges against seven indicted White Sox players, while Gandil, Chase, and the gamblers' cases were stricken for six months. State's Attorney Crowe said he'd seek new indictments but blamed corrupted witnesses, including confessed players Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams, for the setback.
Capital Journal · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Buck Weaver. The cases of Gandil. Hal Chase. Rachel Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, Abe Attell and Bill Burns were stricken off the court call by Judge Dever. They were charged with being the men who arrangi ed the alleged conspiracy. Taking the cases off the call prevents calling them upon again for six months. Testimony Oomipled Mr. Crowe in his announcement that the cases were dropped said the he "was convinced that a crime had been committed but that corruption oVthc stgte's prin cipal witnesses made it impossible to go on with the case." Joe Jackson. Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, the men who con
State's Attorney Crowe announced the Black Sox conspiracy cases were dropped from the call, stating that corruption of key witnesses Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams made prosecution impossible, though he vowed to seek new indictments. Defense counsel Michael Ahearn countered that his clients wanted full vindication, not a technical dismissal, and would demand immediate trial if reindicted.
Capital Journal · 17 March 1921 · page 1
Claude Williams, the men who con fessed to the grand Jury, have been corrupted, he declared. "Without their evidence our case is hope less." Says Obmph Not Ilnlslied 'This case is not finished, how ever, and these men have not es . i minish ment." Mr. Crowe continued. "We are going right af ter the evidence that will convict and we know where to get it. When this evidence has been nrnrnml I shall personally go be fore the grand Jury and seek new Indictments. And there will be no mistakes 'ext time.
See moreSee less
. Deculiar conspiracy has stripnert the state of its tliree chief wit nesses I don't know Just how this conspiracy came about but I know It existed and that through it the testimony given by Jackson, Wll liams and Cicotte was lost to us. "Also, a news syndicate In some underhanded way obtained copies of the grand Jury testimony and offered It for sale. Thus it has beesme nlaln that the defend was in full nossession of all of our ev idence and to proceed would be useless. Mr. Crowe also said that "It eemed very peculiar that the de fense should have msde no move for a trial during the months after the Indictments were returned, but now. when the state was In a hole. the defense was very anxious ei proceed. ' In reply to this. Michael Ahearn of counsel for Weaver, Fe!rh, McMuMiii and Risberg. mad. th. fol lowing statement: W always have been ready for trial. Our clients do not want a half way vindication as a result of the nolle Drosses. They want to bt fully cleared. If there are new in dictment, we will demand an im mediate trUI." Rumors that Cicotte. Williams
State's Attorney Robert Crowe dropped charges against most of the indicted White Sox players after a judge denied a six-month continuance, citing the corruption of key witnesses Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams. Crowe vowed to gather new evidence and seek fresh indictments against the players and the alleged gambler conspirators.
Evening Public Ledger · 17 March 1921 · page 1
BLACK SOX ESCAPE TRIAL AS STATE'S ATTORNEY SAYS CORRUPTION OF PRINCIPAL WITNESSES MADE IT IMPOSSIBLE TO PROCEED - CAN GET NEW EVIDENCE THAT WILL CONVICT
THAT WILL CONVICT Chicago, March 17. The state today dropped the cases agnlnst nll of ttie Chicago White Sox players indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1010 world serlea except "Chick" Gandll. The action was taken after .Tudse William E. Dever had refused to grant n continuance of morn than sixty days In the case. The state demanded six months on the grounds' that It would tnke that length of time to gather evi dence which would give the prosecution a chance of conviction. Immediately nfter the nction hnd been tnken Robert K.
See moreSee less
Crowe, state's attor ney, announced that an attempt would be made to gather new evidence nnd that new Indictments would be sougtit against tho men. Tho players whose cases were dropped wero those who had surrendered and given ball, namely, Claude Williams, Joe Jackson. Oscar Felsch. "Swede" Risbcrg, Lddlo Cl cottn. "Ruck" Weaver and Fred Mo Mullln. The cases of Gondii, Hnl Chase, Ra chel Ilrown, Joseph J. Sullivan, Abe Atcll and Rill Rums were stricken off tho court call by Judge Dever. They were rtinrged uith being the men. who arranged the alleged conspiracy. Tak ing the CAM'S off the cull prevents call ing tnem up again for six months. Have Not Escaped Mr. Crowe, lu his announcement that the cases were dropped, said he "was convinced a crime had been committed, but thnt corruption of the state's prin cipal witnesses made 'it Impossible to bo on with t he case. "Joe' Jackson. Eddie Cicotte nnd
State's Attorney Crowe announces the indictments against the players who surrendered are being dropped, blaming corruption of key witnesses Jackson, Cicotte and Williams whose confessions were lost. Comiskey formally and unconditionally releases seven players, ensuring none will play for the White Sox regardless of the case's outcome.
Evening Public Ledger · 17 March 1921 · page 1
THAT WILL CONVICT
Fred McMuIliu Joe Jackson. Oscar Felsch. (JeorgeJ'Weaver, C. P. Wil liams nnd K. V. Cicotte. Chick Gondii wus placed on the in eligible list Inst spring when he refused to report and tnckled "outlaw" base hall Instead. Ily the formal document.
Illinois prosecutors dropped charges against seven of the indicted White Sox players after a judge denied a lengthy continuance, citing corruption of the state's key witnesses. State's Attorney Crowe vowed to seek new indictments after gathering fresh evidence.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 17 March 1921 · page 1
WITNESSES HAVE BEEN CORRUPTED, COURT IS TOLD
AFTER N E1V EVIDENCE Immediately after tho action had J been taken. P.obert F. Crowe. State's attorney, announced that an attempt H would be made to gather new "'! ' donee and that new Indictments would be sought against the men. H Tho player? whoso cases were H dropped wer,' those who had sm rendered and given ball. namely, Claude Williams. Joe Jackson, Oscar ETelschi Bwi li Risberg Eddie Cicotte, j Fred McMullin and Buck Weaver.
A Chicago report states that the state has dropped charges against all indicted White Sox players for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series, except for Chick Gandil. The judge refused the prosecution's request for a six-month delay, granting only sixty days instead.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Bennington Evening Banner · 17 March 1921 · page 1
BASEBALL CASES END All Dropped Except that against Chick Gandill Chicago. March 17. The stite has dropped the cases against all of the (-hicato White Sox players indicted fr alleited throwini; of the 1919 world's series except that against "Chick" Gandill. The judge refuse dto grant a continitance of the cases for more than sixty nays, l ne prosecution ussed for six montlu in which to prepare testi mony. .
The state dropped charges against seven White Sox players after a judge refused to grant a six-month continuance, though cases against Gandil, Hal Chase, and gamblers were merely struck from the docket. Prosecutors vowed to seek new indictments once more evidence was gathered.
The Barre Daily Times · 17 March 1921 · page 1
CHICK GANDIL ONLY ONE HELD - Of Numerous White Sox Ball Players Accused of "Throwing" Games - AFTER COURT HAD REFUSED DELAY
Months' Contin uance Chicago, March 17.- The state to day dropped the ease against all of the Chicago White Sox baseball play ers indicted on the charge of throwing the 1919 world series except Chick Gandil. The action was taken after Judge William K. Dever had refused to grant a continuance of more than'sixty days in the case. The sUte demanded six months on the ground that it would fake that time to gather evidence which would give the prosecution a chance of conviction. Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert E.
See moreSee less
Crowe, state's attorney, announced that an attempt would be made to gather new evidence and that new indictments would be sought against the men. The players whose cases were dropped were those who had surrendered and given bail namelv: Claude. Williams, ,Ioc .lackson. Oscar Felch, Swede Risberg, Eddie Cicotte, Buck eater and Ired McMullin. The cases of Gandil. Hal Chase, Ra dial Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, Abe Attel and Bill Hums were stricken off the court call bv Judge Dever. They are charged with being, the men who arranged the alleged conspiracy, laktng the cases off the call prevents call ing them up again for six months.
At spring training in Waxahachie, Texas, manager Kid Gleason predicts rookie Earl Sheely will bat cleanup for the White Sox, citing his .371 average, 51 doubles and 33 homers last season. The report also notes exhibition game results from other major league training camps.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 March 1921 · page 8
Fixture. WAXAHACHIE, Texas — Earl Sheely looks like a major league first sacker. Kid Gleason says the young Pacific Coast league star will do and that he will hit in the “clean-up” position, which is fourth in the bat ting order, when the White Sox run into Ty Cobb's Tigers at Detroit April 13. Gleason evidently thinks well of the coast league slugger or he would make no such prediction after hav ing watched the young man in only one practice. Yesterday Sheely had on a uniform for the first time since the closing of the coast league last fall.
See moreSee less
Sheely is 26 years old, stands 6 feet 4 inches in his ball shoes, and when in perfect physical condition weighs close to 200 pounds. Gleason watched his every move, and as the big lad slammed liners to all sections of the yard the kid couldn’t restrain a smile of joy. Earl is a right hand sticker. It is almost a cinch he will be assigned to the clean-up berth in the batting order. Last year he hit .371, bag ging 51 doubles and 33 homers.
Judge William E. Dever is expected to rule on a prosecution motion to postpone the trial of White Sox players charged with conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series. Separately, Comiskey has formally released all seven suspended players, citing new information confirming their actions harmed the club.
Paper unidentified · 17 March 1921 · page 4
BE ANNOUNCED TODAY CHICAGO. March 17.—Judge Wil liam E. Dever today was expected to pass upon the motion of counsel for the prosecution for postponement of trial of the White Sox players and I others indicted on charges of conspir acy to “fix" the 1919 world series. , Regardless of tho outcome of the 1 trial, Prueldent Charles Comiskey has formally notified each of the seven suspended Sox players of his uncon- | ditlonal release. “Additional information received since your suspension,” said Comis key’s letter to the seven, “has con firmed the belief that your actions have been highly detrimental to the reputation of the club and entirely in consistent with your obligations to it." ♦
State's attorney Robert Crowe dismissed the original charges against seven Chicago White Sox players after corruption of key witnesses, blaming his predecessors for mishandling the case. He announced plans to seek new indictments from a reconvened grand jury, aiming to prosecute the real conspirators including those who had evaded justice.
State's attorney Robert Crowe took over the Black Sox case, blaming his predecessors for mishandling it and corrupting witnesses, and had the original cases against Jackson, Cicotte, Williams and others dismissed. He announced plans to seek new indictments from the grand jury to pursue the real conspirators.
Chicago prosecutors dropped the existing cases against seven White Sox players after claiming the state's chief witness had been corrupted, with state's attorney Robert Crowe blaming his predecessors for mishandling the case. Crowe announced plans to bring the matter before a new grand jury the next day to seek fresh indictments against the players and other alleged conspirators.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 10
DROP CASES AGAINST SOX PLAYERS
CROWE TAKES CHARGE Robert E. Crowe, states attorney, took charge of the case today and an nounced that he would handle it from now on. He ordered the cases dis missed after his plea for six months in which to gather new evidence had been dismissal by Judge Dever and May 2 is as date for trial. Tonight, in a formal statement, Mr. Crowe placed the blame for the col lapse of the case on his predecessors fn office, charging they had handled it improperly and on an alleged con spiracy which he said had defeated justice and corrupted Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, th j men who confessed to the grand jury.
See moreSee less
He announced plans to go personally before the grand jury tomorrow to seek new indictments. He pledged himself to ‘‘use every means to bring the guilty persons in this case to jus tice,” declaring that many guilty per sons had not been indicted by the grand jury and that important wit nesses were excused from answering questions which would have brought the real conspirators to justice.
State's Attorney Robert Crowe took over the Black Sox case, dismissing the original charges against seven players due to alleged conspiracy and stolen grand jury testimony, with a new trial date set for May 2. He announced plans to seek new indictments and blamed his predecessor's office for mishandling the case.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 10
Mr. Crowe’s action today released Joe Jackson, Edche Cicotte, Claude Williams. Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, "Swede” Risberg and Fred McMullin from custody of the law, their cases being dismissed. The case against Chick Gangill. Hal Chase, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachael Brown and William Burns, the latter live charged with engineering the alleged world series deal, were taken off the call, but may be brought up again. The cases dismissed were thoac of the men who had surrendered and given bail. There *ras little prospect oft*the men returning io baseball, however, all being both un conditionally released and on the inel igible list. Mr. Crowe in his argument today told Judge Dever that grand jury testimony had been stolen and that a conspiracy had hampered the state at every pclnt.
State's Attorney Crowe explains why he moved to drop the original indictments, revealing that the prior grand jury investigation was incomplete and that witnesses including Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson had been influenced by other defendants to withhold testimony. He states he needs more time to build a case that will lead to conviction of all guilty parties before the statute of limitations expires.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 10
newspaper syndicate. WITNESSES HUSHED UP "We then learned that Cicotte, who had testified before the grand jury that he was a party to this'conspiracy and had received $10,000 as his share of the spoils, and that Claude Williams
White Sox manager Kid Gleason says the indicted players will never again wear a major league uniform. He made the comment after learning Illinois had dropped its case against the accused players.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 11
PLAYED LAST GAME ^Axnhatchir, Tex.. March 17.— Kid <«lcn«on, mnnnccr of the Chl rogo White Sox, declared today that the Indicted ballplayer* would never appear In uniform nKaln.* When Informed that the Mate of Illinois liad dropped the cases against the Indicted White Sox members, Gleason at his spring training headquarters here said: *T am positive they will never be allowed back in the ranks of organized baseball. They arc out of baseball.**
State's Attorney Crowe dismissed charges against seven White Sox players due to witness cooperation issues, blaming his predecessors for a conspiracy that corrupted key witnesses Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams. He announced plans to seek new indictments from a grand jury the next day, pledging to bring the guilty to justice.
Arizona Republican · 18 March 1921 · page 15
WILL PROSECUTE
set as date for trial. Tonight, in a statement. Judge Crowe placed the blame for the collapse of the case on his predecessors in office, charging they had handled it improp erly, on an alleged conspiracy, which he said had defeated justice and cor rupted' Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, the men who con fessed to the grand jury, and an nounced that he planned to go person ally before the grand jury tomorrow to seek new indictments. He pledged himself to "use very means to bring the guilty personsto justice," declaring that many guilty persons had not been indicted and that important witnesses were excused from answering questions which would have brought the real conspirators to justice.
See moreSee less
7 White Sox Players Dismissed Mr. Crowe's action released Joe Jackson. Eddie. Cicotte, Claude Wil liams. Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg and Fred McMullin from custody, their cases being dis
State's Attorney Crowe took over the Black Sox case and dismissed charges against seven players after being denied a six-month postponement, blaming his predecessors for mishandling evidence and a conspiracy that corrupted witnesses. He announced plans to seek new indictments from the grand jury while cases against gamblers Gandil, Chase, Sullivan, Brown, Attel and Burns were merely set aside, not dismissed.
State's Attorney Crowe explains why he dropped charges against the bailed Black Sox defendants, citing an incomplete prior grand jury investigation and the sale of grand jury testimony to a newspaper syndicate. He states players like Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson were pressured into silence by other defendants, and vows to continue pursuing evidence for future prosecution.
Arizona Republican · 18 March 1921 · page 15
a New York newspaper syndicate. "We then learned that Cicotte, who had testified before the grand Jury that he was a party to this conspiracy and had received $10,000 as his share, and Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who testified before the grand Jury to their participation in this crime and stated that they had received $5000 apiece, had been corruptly, or other wise, brought under the domination of other defendants who had not testi
The state dismissed its case against the indicted White Sox players and others after state's attorney Crowe charged that key witnesses had been corrupted, with Judge Dever removing remaining defendants from the court call. Crowe announced he would seek new indictments from a reconvened grand jury the next day, blaming his predecessors for mishandling the case and alleging a conspiracy that protected the real conspirators.
State's Attorney Crowe dismissed charges against five of the accused in the alleged World Series fix after Judge Dover refused to grant a six-month delay for gathering new evidence. Crowe claimed grand jury testimony had been stolen and the original investigation was incomplete, while the indicted men remained barred from baseball and under a gag order from their attorneys.
Pueblo Chieftain · 18 March 1921 · page 1
The cases against (’hick Gandll, Hal Chase. Joseph J Sullivan. Rachael Brown. Abe Attell and William Burns, the latter five charged with engineer ing the alleged world scries deal, were taken off the call but may be brought tip again The cases dismissed were those of the mm who had surrendered and given ball. There was little pros pect of the men returning to baseball however, all being unconditionally r* - leased and on the ineligible list. Mr. Crowe told Judge Dover that grand Jury testimony had been stolen and that a conspiracy had hampered the state.
See moreSee less
He demanded six months to gather new evidence. When Judge! Dover replied sixty days was the, limit. Mr Crowe shouted. "Well, the game Is called then. I'll ask nolle prosequi." Attorney George Barrett. American league attorney, persuaded him t" , drop the eases only against the men : who had given hail and this was done. • Judge Dover ruled that Mr. Crowe's:
Kid Gleason, manager of the Chicago White Sox, stated that the indicted players would 'never appear in uniform again,' after learning Illinois had dropped the cases against them. He insisted they would not be allowed back into organized baseball.
Pueblo Chieftain · 18 March 1921 · page 10
appear in uniform again." when in- ; I formed that the state of Illinois had , dropped the cases against the indicted j White Sox members. "1 am positive that they will never ' be allowed bark In tho ranks of ori ganixed baseball. They are out of j baseball.”
Chicago authorities report that immediate prosecution of the White Sox players and others indicted for the 1919 World Series fix collapsed after the state found its chief witnesses had been corrupted. Charges against seven players and a judge were dropped as officials moved to gather new evidence.
Norwich Bulletin · 18 March 1921 · page 3
TO GATHER NEW EVIDENCE AGAINST WHITE SOX PLAYERS Chicago, Mar. 17 Immediate prose cution of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted in connec tion with the alleged throwing of the 1S19 world series collapsed today when the state, charging corruption of its chief witnesses, dropped . the cases against seven of the piayers and Jud
White Sox manager Kid Gleason declares the indicted players will never return to organized baseball after Illinois dropped the charges against them. State's attorney Robert Crowe announces he will go before the Cook County grand jury to seek new indictments of the same players.
Several defendants including Hal Chase, Joseph Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Abe Attell, and William Burns had their cases dismissed from the court call, though they remain on baseball's ineligible list. State's Attorney Crowe argued that grand jury testimony had been stolen and a conspiracy hampered the prosecution, requesting six months to gather new evidence before Judge Dever, who limited him to sixty days.
Norwich Bulletin · 18 March 1921 · page 3
: N I ill Bk ... ... .. 77 -TT - " 0 New Teek Ontral . .. TJ C'.i im T I B t I ... u "X not Deen mulcted Dy tne grand jury I and that imrif.rt.in. witneRfutix wpr. or.. cused from answering questions which ; Mo"tJr would have brought the real conspira tors to Justice. . ital Chase. Joseph J. Sullivan, Ra chel Brown, Abe Attell, and WilUam Burns, the latter live charged with
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
White Sox manager Kid Gleason declared that the indicted players would never wear a Chicago uniform again. He made the remark after learning that Illinois authorities had dropped the criminal cases against the accused players.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 18 March 1921 · page 18
Of The Game Waxahachie, Tex. "Kid" Gleason manager of the Chicago White Sox. declared that the tnrttnto players would "never appear in uni form again." When informed that the State of Illinois had dropped the cases against the Indicted White Sox members, Gleason said: "I am positive they will never be allowed back in the ranks of organiz ed baseball. They are out of baseball."
Charles Comiskey severed all relations with the seven indicted White Sox players, notifying them that their contracts were null and void due to the gambling charges. This item appears within a broader sports gossip column covering various unrelated stories.
Imperial Valley Press · 18 March 1921 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The State's Attorney's office dismissed charges against seven indicted White Sox players after claiming key witnesses had been corrupted, collapsing the original prosecution. New State's Attorney Robert Crowe vowed to seek fresh indictments from a new Grand Jury the next day, blaming his predecessors and an alleged conspiracy for the case's failure.
The New York Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 15
CROWE BLAMES OTHERS
Chicago, March 1".?Immediate prose cution of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted in connec tion with ti?e alleged throowing of the 1019 world's series collapsed to-day,
State's Attorney Crowe had the Black Sox cases dismissed after Judge Dever denied his request for a six-month delay to gather evidence, and players including Jackson, Cicotte and Williams were released from bail. Crowe blamed his predecessors and an alleged conspiracy for corrupting witnesses, and announced plans to seek new indictments from the Grand Jury.
The New York Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 15 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CASES DISMISSED AGAINST WHITE SOX
Seven Indicted Players Are Released as World's Series Prosecution Collapses.
See moreSee less
CROWE BLAMES OTHERS
But Says He Will Demand Reindictments of Alleged Throwers of Games.
CHICAGO, March 17.—Immediate prosecution of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted in connection with the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series collapsed to-day, when the State, charging corruption of its chief witnesses, dropped the cases against seven of the players, and Judge William E. Dever took the others off the court call. To-night, however, the State plunged into the task of preparing a new case, with the announcement that the matter would be placed in the hands of a Grand Jury again to-morrow and reindictment of the players whose cases were dropped sought.
Robert E. Crowe, State's Attorney, took charge of the case to-day and announced that he would handle it from now on. He ordered the cases dismissed after his plea for six months in which to gather new evidence had been denied by Judge Dever and May 2 set as date for trial.
To-night in a formal statement Mr. Crowe placed the blame for the collapse of the case on his predecessors in office, charging they had handled it improperly, and on an alleged conspiracy which, he said, had defeated justice and corrupted Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, the men who confessed to the Grand Jury. He announced plans to go personally before the Grand Jury to-morrow to seek new indictments. He pledged him to "use every means to bring the guilty persons in this case to justice," declaring that many guilty persons had not been indicted by the Grand Jury and that important witnesses were excused from answering questions which would have brought the real conspirators to justice.
Players Who Are Released.
Mr. Crowe's action to-day released Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felsch, Swede Risberg and Fred McMullin from custody of the law, their cases being dismissed.
The cases against Chick Gandil, Hal Chase, Joseph J. Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Abe Attell and William Burns, the latter five charged with engineering the alleged world's series deal, were taken off the call, but may be brought up again.
The cases dismissed were those of men who had surrendered and given bail. There is little prospect of the men returning to baseball, however, all being both unconditionally released and on the ineligible list.
Mr. Crowe in his argument to-day told Judge Dever that Grand Jury testimony had been stolen and that a conspiracy had hampered the State at every point. He demanded six months to gather new evidence.
When Judge Dever replied that sixty days was the limit, Mr. Crowe shouted, "Well, the game is called then. I'll ask nolle prosequi."
The men indicted were still under a ban of silence to-night, their attorneys forbidding them to talk for publication until the statute of limitations expired.
Mr. Crowe's statement, explaining why he dropped the cases, follows in part:
"The investigations before the Grand Jury which returned these indictments was conducted by my predecessors in office.
New Prosecutor Amazed.
"Shortly after February 1 I directed my second assistant, George E. Gorman, to have the baseball cases set for trial at the earliest possible date, and the trial was set for March 14. Mr. Gorman began to prepare for the trial, and we were amazed to find that the investigation of this crime conducted by my predecessor before the October Grand Jury was not a complete investigation and that the witnesses were permitted to withhold material evidence and were excused by the State's Attorney from answering questions which would uncover the entire conspiracy. We were further amazed to learn that all of the testimony taken before the Grand Jury was being publicly offered for sale by a New York newspaper syndicate.
"We then learned that Cicotte, who had testified before the Grand Jury that he was a party to this conspiracy and had received $10,000 as his share of the spoils, and that Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who testified that they had received $5,000 apiece in payment as their share, had been corruptly or otherwise brought under the domination of other defendants who had not testified and were refusing to testify upon the trial of this case as witnesses for the State.
"We further learned that many other persons who were parties to this criminal conspiracy had not been indicted.
"When this situation was called to my attention I directed Mr. Gorman to ask that the cases be passed from the court call in order to give my office sufficient time to obtain evidence which would prove the existence of this conspiracy and end in conviction of every guilty person.
Will Present Evidence Again.
"To-day I told the court that it was absolutely impossible for me to obtain by May 2 evidence which I am satisfied is in existence and which would lead to the conviction of the defendants and other persons not named, and that if the case was set for trial on May 2 I would be forced to enter a nolle pros qui as to those defendants who appeared and gave bail. I stated to the court that the statute of limitations as to certain of these defendants had still less than two weeks to run, that it was absolutely necessary in the interest of public justice that I be given a free hand to make a thorough investigation of this case to the end that this conspiracy might be exposed.
"I further advised the court that these defendants were not entitled to a trial under the law until July 30, 1921, but the court persisted in setting the case for trial on May 2, and knowing the impossibility of a successful trial at that time, and refusing to waste the money of the people of Cook county in a fruitless effort which would result in nothing but a miscarriage of justice, I was forced to and did enter the nolle pros qui.
"I now publicly state that I propose to appear before the Grand Jury of Cook county to again present the evidence of the commission of this crime and to ask the return of other indictments against the defendants named in the present indictments and against others not named therein. It is my purpose to do everything within my power to reach every person guilty of this crime and send them to the penitentiary if the evidence warrants."
A newspaper humor column notes that Cicotte and Jackson, recently released after indictment, are the only Black Sox players history will remember. It suggests their quotes—Cicotte's 'I did it for the wife and the kiddies' and the boy's plea 'Say it ain't true, Joe'—belong in Bartlett's Familiar Quotations.
New-York Tribune · 18 March 1921 · page 12
G. S. B. Among the indicted' White Sox Co miskey formally released were Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson. These are the only players posterity will remem? ber, and the next edition of BartlettJa Familiar Quotations. should contain Cicotte'a "I did it for the wife and the kiddies," and the small boy's prayer to Jackson: "Say it ain't true, Joe."
State's Attorney Crowe told the court the case had collapsed due to corruption of witnesses and tampering with grand jury evidence, leading to dismissal of charges against seven ball players including Jackson, Cicotte, and Weaver. Crowe vowed to seek reindictment through a new grand jury while charges against Gandil and other alleged conspirators were continued until May.
New-York Tribune · 18 March 1921 · page 14
STATE SEEKS REINDICTMENT OF PLAYERS WHO HAD CONFESSED; CORRUPTED, SAYS PROSECUTOR
The cases against "Chick" Gandil and the five other persons indicted taken off the calender, which means that instead of coming up May 2, they kkviil be buried for at least six months. .Judge Landis, chairman of the Na-< ,-,-,
State's Attorney Crowe moved for nolle prosse on the seven indicted White Sox players after Judge Dever refused to indefinitely postpone the cases, aiming to seek reindictment before a new grand jury. Jackson, Cicotte and Williams had reportedly confessed but later repudiated their statements, weakening the state's case; several other alleged conspirators remain under indictment.
New-York Tribune · 18 March 1921 · page 14
*U the indictments be nolle prossed. kkviil be buried for at least six months. .Judge Landis, chairman of the Na-< ilonal Commission, was very busy < when informed of the court move. He i? liad just time for a characteristic com ... went. It was: "Doesn't that beat all?" State's Attorney Crowe said he would place testimony before the pres? ent grand jury which, he hoped, would result in the reindictment of all con? cerned. >??.-, The nolle prosse proceedings fol? lowed a stormy court session, in ? which Mr. Crowe at one time threat?
See moreSee less
ened to ask that the "no prosecution" statute be Invoked for every one in? volved, Th? Dismissed Playera * The ball players against whom pro? ceedings were dismissed are Joe Jack Bon, "Eddie" Cicotte. Oscar ("Happy") Felsch, George ("Buck") Weaver, Claude Williams, Charles Eisberg and Fred McMullen. The alleged members ?of the conspiracy still under indict taent are "Chick" Gandil, Hal Chase, Bill Burns, oil man; Abe AttelL gam 7, t>ler and ex-pugilist; J. J. ("Sport") feullivan, gambler, and Rachel Brown, {rambler. Jackson, Cicotte and Wil iams are said to have confessed to the Grand Jury and later to have ruined
State's Attorney Crowe tells the court the prosecution's case fell apart after confessions were stolen and leaked, and several former prosecutors now represent the defendants. Judge Dever dismisses charges against the players and conspirators who appeared in court, while Heydler says Commissioner Landis will handle discipline instead.
New-York Tribune · 18 March 1921 · page 14
Included all of the seven except Mc? Mullen and Cicotte. Regarding them, Mr. Crowe moved that their bonds be forfeited. "No," said Judge Dever, "there is no reason for that. I'll nolle prosse the cases of all the defendants who have put in an appearance. The rest of the ? eases can be continued until May 2." This exempted all the ball players, ' with the exception of Gandil and Hal Chase, who have never come within the Jurisdiction of the local courts. The eases of the alleged framers of the conspiracy are covered by the same !.",' eircumstances.
See moreSee less
"All right," said Mr. Crowe. "Ill make the best of the situation. 1*11 try to have these men reindicted by the grand jury within the state's time limit (fifteen days) and held for trial i again. If that fails I'll have to work I up an entirely new case against them."
The state's case against White Sox players charged with throwing the 1919 World Series fell apart after corruption of a key witness forced prosecutors to drop charges against seven players, with a judge releasing others from custody. State's Attorney Robert Crowe announced he would seek new indictments from the Cook County Grand Jury.
Paper unidentified · 18 March 1921 · page 6
NEW INDICTMENTS TO BE SOUGHT AGAINST WHITE SOX PLAYERS
PAGE SIX Present His Edivence Chicago, March 17. —Immediateprosecution of Chicago White Sox baseball players and others indicted in connection with the alleged throw-! lug of the 1919 world series collapsed today. today when the state, charging cor ruption of its chief witness, dropped the cases against 9even of the players and Judge William TC. Dever took the others off the court hall. Robert E. Crowe, state’ attorney. announced late today that he would
After the state's case against the Chicago White Sox players was dropped, officials announced the matter would go before the Cook County grand jury again the next day. The state requested reindictment of the players whose cases had been dismissed.
Paper unidentified · 18 March 1921 · page 6
Present His Edivence go before the Cook county grand jury ; toidprrow seek reindictment of the I Chicago White Sox baseball players | whose cases were dropped by the state today. Tonight, however, the state plunged into the task of preparing a* new cass with announcement that the matter would placed in the hands of the grand jury again tomorrow with the request indictment of the players whose <mscs were dropped. would step into the swing of a bird. K was kind of tough for the capltol tribe during the early going, but there was no denying a regular lambasting squad. What the Griffs did to tlie ' Phils is Bow ancient history.
State's Attorney Robert Crowe dismissed the existing cases against seven White Sox players after a judge denied his request for a six-month delay, blaming his predecessors for mishandling the case and alleged conspiracy that corrupted witnesses Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams. Crowe announced plans to seek new indictments from a grand jury the next day, pledging to bring the real conspirators to justice.
The Pensacola Journal · 18 March 1921 · page 1
PROSECUTION OF BALL PLAYERS IS WITHDRAWN - NEW INDICTMENTS BEING PREPARED
..e said had defeated justice and cor cupted Joe Jackson. Eddie Cicotte, and Claude Williams, the men who confessed to the grand jury. He announced plana I to gopersonally before the grand jury tomorrow to seen new indictments. He pledged himself to "use every means to bring the guilty persons in this case to justice," declaring that many guilty persons had not been indicted by the grand jury and that important witfroni answering questions which would have brought the real conspirators to justice. Mr. Crowe' action today released Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, Buck Weaver, Oscar Felch, Swede Jtis berg and Ered McMullin from custody of the law. their cases being dlsmtsseL The cases against Chick Candill, Hal Chase. Joseph J. Sullivan, Itachael Brown. Abe Attell anil William Burns, the latter live charged with engineering the alleged world series deal, were tak en off the calendar, but may be brought up again. The case dismissed were those of the men who had surrendered and given bail. There was little pros pect of the men returning to baseball, howevor, all being both unconditionally released and on tho ineligible list.
New state's attorney Hubert Crowe took charge of the Black Sox case and ordered charges dismissed against Jackson, Cicotte, Williams, Weaver, Felsch, Risberg, and McMullin after his request for a six-month delay was denied. Crowe blamed his predecessors for mishandling the case and announced plans to seek new indictments from the grand jury, while the players remained banned from baseball.
Judge Landis announced that upon hearing of the state's confirmation of the trial against the indicted White Sox players, he would immediately place them all on the ineligible list. This marked the formal start of baseball's own disciplinary response to the scandal.
The Ocala Banner · 18 March 1921 · page 11
Judge Landis as soon as informed of the state’s announcement in regard to the trial of the indicted White Sox players, said that he would immediate
The state dropped charges against all indicted Chicago White Sox players except Chick Gandil after the court denied a six-month continuance. Prosecutors said new evidence would be gathered and fresh indictments sought.
Richmond Daily Register · 18 March 1921 · page 1
Unuri LAULf i LIU (I'.y Associated I'rnss) Chicago, Mrrch 18 The state today dropped the cases against all the Chicago White Sox base ball players indicted for alleged
Chicago state's attorney Robert Crowe dropped the cases against seven White Sox players after key witnesses were allegedly corrupted, following the court's refusal to grant a continuance. Crowe blamed his predecessors for mishandling the case and announced plans to seek new indictments from the grand jury the next day.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 18 March 1921 · page 1
STATE DROPS WORLD SERIES FRAUD CASES
it improperly; on an alleged conspira- . cy which he said had defeated jus- ' tice and corrupted Joe Jackson, Ed- | die Cicotte and Claude Williams, the ! men who confessed to the grand jury. j . He announced plans to go personal ly before the grand jury tomorrow to seek new' indictments. He pledged himself to “use every means to bring [the guilty persons in this case,to jus tice," declaring that many guilty per sons in this case had not been indict ed by the grand jury and that import ant witnesses were excused from an- | swering questions which would have | brought the real conspirators to jus- ! tice. Mr. Crowe's action today released Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte, Claude
State's attorney Robert Crowe took over the Black Sox case and had charges dismissed after Judge Dever denied his request for six months to gather new evidence, blaming his predecessors and an alleged conspiracy for the case's collapse. He pledged to seek new indictments from the grand jury while the accused players, though freed from custody, remained banned from organized baseball.
This editorial criticizes the state's attorney for allowing charges against the former White Sox players to be dropped after the judge refused a continuance, expressing skepticism that fresh indictments will follow. It argues the scandal's lingering, unresolved status will leave the public suspicious of baseball and likely dampen gambling on games.
Omaha Daily Bee · 18 March 1921 · page 6
Xne Base Ball Fiasco. Xo blemish is removed from professional base ball' by the dropping of the cases against the former White Sox players who months ago were indicted for the alleged throwing of the world series of 1919. The state's attorney who allowed, the casts to be stricken off the docket after the judge liad refused to continue them for six : months talks now of obtaining fresh indictments, but the' public may be allowed considerable, skepticism as to this. The confessions of certain of the players were complete and definite, and one whose sense of justice is unclouded by knowledge of the tech nicalities of the law will find difficulty in com prehending why the prosecution could not have been 'prepared against what it now terms the "corruption" of its witnesses, Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams.
See moreSee less
It would have been better for the reputation of the sport to have had this trial long ago, that it might pass from account with the opening cf the season. Now. whether it hangs on or is completely abandoned, the public will remember it with suspicion. At All events, it may naturally be supposed the pastime of gambling on the result of games will have a hard time reviving itself to its former proportions. Can River Boats Come Back? As far back as 1819 the Missouri river was navigated. Remnants of that great commerce which led ships 2,285 miles upstream to Fort Benton still persist in isolated stretches, but the most astonishing thing that could happen would be a resumption oLthrough traffic.
Chicago prosecutor Robert Crowe dropped indictments against seven former White Sox players after a judge refused a 60-day continuance to gather new evidence. Cases against alleged fixers Gandil, Chase, Burns and others were stricken from the docket, with Crowe vowing to seek new indictments.
Omaha Daily Bee · 18 March 1921 · page 8
White Sox Given Freedom as Court Drops Indictment Action Taken by Prosecutor After Judge Refuses to Grant Continuance of 60 Days
Chicago, March 17. The state to day dropped the cases against all of the former Chicago White Sox base hall players indicted for the alleged throwing of the Wi world series eveept Chick Gandil. The action was taken after Judge William K. Dover had refused to crant a continuance of more than 00 i.ivs in the case. The state demand- ,d $i mouths on the grounds that it uould take that length of time to :ather new evidence which would' Cive the prosecution a cjiancc of rcuvic'.ion.
State's Attorney Crowe announces the Black Sox cases have been dropped after the confessions of Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams were lost through a mysterious conspiracy and leaked grand jury testimony. He insists a crime was committed and vows to seek new indictments with stronger evidence, while defense attorney Michael Ahern says his clients want full vindication at trial, not a technical dismissal.
Omaha Daily Bee · 18 March 1921 · page 8
Will Be No Mistakes. "When this evidence' has been pro cured, I shall personally go before the grand jury and seek new indict ments. And there will be no niietakcs next time." ' "A peculiar conspiracy has stripped ihe state of its three chief witnesses." Mr. Crowe continued. "I don't know iust how this conspiracy came about, lint 1 know, it existed and that through it the testimony given by Jackson. Williams and Cicotte was
The criminal cases against the indicted White Sox players for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series were dismissed after the judge refused the state's request for a 60-day continuance. Only the indictment against Chick Gandil remained standing.
Omaha Daily Bee · 18 March 1921 · page 8
Cases Against White Sox
I -----" against "Chick" Gandil. "PVTTIWGTWE NEXT ONE OVER" Gink Fowler may have been the cat's whiskers, but the sandpaper collar goes to Forger Blake,, of this
The state dropped indictments against seven White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series after a judge denied a six-month continuance, leaving only Chick Gandil's case active. Prosecutor Robert Crowe vowed to gather new evidence and seek fresh indictments against the men.
The Democratic Banner · 18 March 1921 · page 1
tBy Associated Ptrss to The BaonarJ CHICAGO, March 17-rTha stato to day dropped tho cases against all of tho Chicago White Sox baseball play era Indicted for tho alloged throwing of the 1910 world series, except Chick Gandlll. ' The action was taken after Judge William Dever ahd refused, to grant a continuance of more than CO days in the case. Tho stato domanded six months on the ground that it would
Illinois prosecutors dropped the indictments against seven White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series, after a judge denied their request for a long continuance to gather evidence. State's Attorney Crowe said he still believed a crime occurred but that witness corruption made prosecution impossible, and vowed to seek new indictments.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 18 March 1921 · page 1
i continuance of more than 60 days' n the case. The state demanded sixj nonths on the ground that it would j ake that length of time to gather evij lence which would give the prosecu ion a chance of conviction. 1- - -Ti. i-1. - _ ~4.! L.J I immediately aiter uuuun imu i >een taken, Robert E. Crowe,' date's attorney, announced an at empt would be made to gather new svidence and that new indictments vould be sought against the men. The players whose cases were drop :ed were those who had surrendered ind given bail, namely Claude Wil iams, Joe Jackson, Oscar Flesh, Swede Risber, Eddie Cicotte, Buck iVeaver and Fred McMullin.
See moreSee less
The cases of Gandil, Hal Chase, Rachel Brown, Joseph J. Sullivan, V.be Attel and Bill Burns were stric ken off the court call by Judge Dee per. They were charged with be ng the men who arranged the alleg :d conspiracy. Taking the cases off ;he call provides calling them up a jain for six months. "Mr. Crowe, in his announcement hat the cases were dropped, said V?o+ Vio "nroe /rinvincoH fVint a ?ad been committed, but that cor ruption of the state's principal wit lesses made it impossible to go on vith the case."
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey formally notified seven indicted players of their unconditional release from the team. State's Attorney Robert Crowe simultaneously moved to dismiss the criminal prosecution against the players.
The Columbia Herald · 18 March 1921 · page 1
BASEBALL CROOKS LIKELY GO FREE / SEVEN GRAFTERS ARE GIVEN UNCONDITIONAL RELEASE TODAY BY COMISKY
DAY BY COMlSKY. (By United Press.) CHICAGO, March 17. President Charles Comlsky formally notined seven of the indicted White Sox play ers of their -unconditional release, to day. They are Risberg, McMuIlin, Jackson, Fclsh, Weaver, Williams and Cicotte. Robert E. Crowe, states attorney, asked dismissal of the prosecution against the ball players under indict ment today. . ' .
The State's case against seven indicted White Sox players collapsed after corruption of key witnesses was alleged, leading Judge Dever to dismiss charges. New State's Attorney Robert Crowe took over and announced plans to seek re-indictment from a new grand jury, blaming his predecessors for mishandling the case.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 18 March 1921 · page 8
STATE TO PREPARE NEW CASE AGAINST PLAYERS
Kvidenee Was Stolen. I I5y Associated Press.1 i.'IIICAliO, .March 17.?Immediate prosecution of Chicago Wliite Sox bnsehnl I players and others indicted in eon met i.hi with tlio alleged throw ing of tin.1 1 I;i world's series col
State's Attorney Crowe dismissed cases against several Black Sox players including Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams after blaming his predecessors for mishandling the investigation, citing a conspiracy that corrupted witnesses and stole grand jury testimony. He announced plans to seek new indictments while cases against Gandil, Chase, Attell, and others were merely taken off the court calendar rather than dismissed.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 18 March 1921 · page 8
CROWE NOW HAS CHARGE
being dismissed. The cases against Chick 'iandil. Hal Chase, Joseph J. Sullivan. Itnchel Brown. Abe Attell and William I turns, the latter live | eharBed with engineering the alleged world's series ileal, were taken off the call, but may he brought up again.
The State's Attorney explains why he could not proceed to trial on March 14, revealing that his predecessor's grand jury investigation was incomplete and witnesses were allowed to withhold evidence. He states Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson had testified to receiving money but other implicated players and conspirators had been improperly protected from full testimony or indictment.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 18 March 1921 · page 8
I'lnyer* t mler lloniliialloo. "We then learned thai Cicotte, who., had testified before the grand jury ? hiil hiwa.i a party to this eotispir ac\ a lid had received $ 10,1100 as his sh.ir.- of the spoils, and that Claude Williams ;t-nd Joe Jackson, who t.sti ti ? *1 that they had received i.",.iiiii| a piece in pnymcnt as llu-ir share, liiid been corruptly or otherwise brought under the domination of other de fendant*; who hail not testified ;tI1 | were refusing to testify noon tin trial of their ease as witnee'ss-.v for the Stat--.
See moreSee less
"We further learned that many other persons who were parties to t'i ^ criminal conspiracy had not been indicted. "When this situation was cured to :ny attention I directed .Mr < lorill.i u ask thai the cases be pa sued from
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey sent formal unconditional release notices to seven indicted players, ending any chance they could continue playing for the team. The eighth indicted player, Chick Gandil, had already been placed on the ineligible list the previous spring for holding out and playing outlaw baseball.
The Laramie Republican · 18 March 1921 · page 5
WHITE SOX PLAYERS ARE SUSPENDED BY COMISKEY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
A fresh investigation into the Chicago 'Black Sox' is underway, with reporters noting that club owners like Comiskey were slow to act until pressed by Judge Landis. The piece also mentions other players under suspicion, including Benny Kauff, Rube Benton, Fred Toney, and Heinie Zimmerman.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 19 March 1921 · page 11
ANOTHER DRIVE AGAINST BLACK SOX IS OPENED
"rumors." Back to Laadls. Charles Comiskey didn't remove the indicted players from the White Sox eligible list until Judge Landia did it for him. The New York Giants didn't do a thing to remove the suspicion sur rounding several of their players i until Judge Landis suggested that
A second investigation into the Chicago Black Sox scandal is underway, with club owners criticized for failing to act quickly against suspected players. Judge Landis had to force Comiskey and the Giants to remove tainted players, while Rube Benton remains with New York despite admitting knowledge of the fixed series.
The Topeka State Journal · 19 March 1921 · page 5
AFTER BLACK SOX
be vitally interested. The major league club owners have not been too quick to rake the initia tive In finding out the truth of "ru mon." Charles Comiskey didn't remove the indicted players from the White Sox eligible list until Judge Landia did it for him. . The New Tork Giants didn't do a thing to remove the suspicion sur rounding several of their players until Judge Landia Viggested that Benny naurr oe taken out ot the game until he is tried for grand larceny. Rube Beaton. Fred Toner and Kauff were , directly charged with questionable actions by Heinie Zim merman in an affidavit.
See moreSee less
Benton was also mentioned in a similar story by Charles Herxog. Benton admits he won money on the "crooked series," with the full knowledge of what was going on. Joe Gedeon, second baseman of the St. Louis Browns, was banished from the game forthe same thing, but Benton is still with the Giants.
Illinois State's Attorney Robert Crowe dropped charges against all indicted former White Sox players except Chick Gandil, after Judge Dever denied a six-month continuance. Crowe announced new indictments would be sought against the men.
Paper unidentified · 19 March 1921 · page 4
CROOKED BALL PLAYERS ESCAPE PROSECUTION
ESCAPE PROSECUTION Chicago, March 17.—The State to day dropped the cases against all of the former Chicago White Sox play ers indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series except Chick Gandll. The action was taken after Judge William E. Dever had refused to grant a continuance of more than sixty days in the case. The State demanded six months on the grounds that It would take that length of time to gather new evidence which would give the prosecution a chance of conviction. Immediately after the action had been taken, Robert E. Crowe. State attorney, announced that new in dictments would be sought against the men.
A renewed inquiry into the Chicago "Black Sox" bribery scandal is underway, but club owners have been slow to act against suspected players. Comiskey only removed indicted White Sox players after Judge Landis intervened, and similar inaction is noted regarding Giants players accused by Heinie Zimmerman and Charles Herzog.
The Milwaukee Leader · 19 March 1921 · page 7
CLUBS SLOW TO ACT IN BRIBE CHARGES
Kauff Taken Out. The New York Giants didn’t do a thing to remove suspicion surround ing several of their players until Judge Landis suggested that Benny Kauff be taken out of the game un til he is tried for alleged grand lar ceny. Rube Benton, Fred Toney and Kauff were directly charged with questionable action by Heinie Zim merman in an affidavit. Benton also was mentioned in a similar story by Charles Herzog.
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey sent unconditional release notices to seven indicted players: Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Cicotte. The report notes Chick Gandil, the eighth indicted player, had already been placed on the ineligible list the previous spring for refusing to report and playing outlaw baseball instead.
The Laramie Republican · 19 March 1921 · page 4
company material. White Sox Players Are Suspended by President Comiskey Chicago. March 18.—Whatever chance any of the indicted Black Sox thought they had to play 'baseball with the White Sox was eliminated by Pres
Chicago prosecutors dropped the indictments against all White Sox players accused of throwing the World Series except Chick Gandil. The move came after a judge denied the state's request for a six-month continuance, granting only 60 days instead.
Laredo Weekly Times · 20 March 1921 · page 3
DROPPED CASES OF ALL PLAYERS; ONLY CHICK GANDIL REMAINS TO BE TRIED FOR ALLEGED THROWING OF WORLD SERIES
, i — | ’M_\' Associated Press. ' Chicago March 17 The state to day dropped the cases against ali the Chicago White Sox players indicted for alleged throwing of games except Chick Gandill. The action was taken after Judge Devers hod refused to Cgrant o continuancee of more than 60 cdays in the case. The state demaudLed six months on the grounds that it would take that time to gather evi Cdence which would give The prosecu tion o chanee of conviction. ———
A sports column praises Charles Comiskey for severing ties with the indicted Black Sox players and crediting him with pressuring Eddie Cicotte into a confession that exposed the conspiracy. It notes the original indictments were voided by a Chicago court, and a new Cook County prosecutor is pursuing fresh indictments, promising more revelations to come.
New-York Tribune · 21 March 1921 · page 13
IN ALL FAIRNESS
By W. J. Macbeth congratulated on the attitudo h.e has taken toward those members of his team who wero indicted for the alleged "framing" of the 1919 world's series with the Cincinnati Reds. There never was any doubt as to how the Old Roman stood on the proposition. He asserted himself in no uncertain terms when the scandal first broke. Indeed, it was due to the initiative and perseverance of Comiskey that a confession was got out of pitcher Eddie Cicotte, and this confession unmasked the whole conspiracy. Yet it was very fortunate that Mr.
See moreSee less
Comiskey severed all relations with the accused members of his club hefore the Chicago court voided the indictments against them. Comiskey wltnout doubt is business man enough to rc.lize that none of the accused can ever again appear in organized baseball. Their appcar ance would ruin the game; the public would never approvc. The faith of the public is the cornerstone of baseball prosperity. And still there are few husines-ses in this commereial age that would gracefully sacrifice a cold half million to pure principle. Charles A. Comiskey has given the proper answer at a time when the general public might be pardoned a certain amount of skepticism. Now, as to the fate of the "Black Sox." Unless new indictments are forthcoming within a fortnight, the accused players will have escaped the grasp of the law. The new prosecutor of Cook County hopes to secure these indictments. He seems very scrious in his mission. He intimatcs, too, that so far only the surface has been scratched. He promises, if his hands are not tied, to unfold some startling exposures even in the high places. Perhaps with such an able ally as Judge Landis behind him, the prosecutor of Cook County may be able to institutc that thorough "houso cleaning" of.which the game stands so sadly in need. Anti-Gambling Laws Should Help Sport fJpHE country at large looks to the Empire State for ideas. New York is a leader, in sport as in fashion. It is to be hoped other states will follow our lead in the matter of legislation to protect baseball lovers from the machinations of professional gamblers. In this state hereafter the offering or acceptance of a bribe or any attempt to influence the result of a ball game other than an issue of true merit will be construed as a criminal act and subject to the penalty cf a fine of $10,000 or five years' imprisonment or both. ? It would have been even better had this commendable bill been broad ened to include all branches of human, sportive competition?amateur as well as professional. For tho sooner every avenue is closed to the "sure thing" gambler the sooner all sports will be raised above the breath of suspicion. The sinister shadow of the f'sure-thing" gambler lies athwart every scandal in sport that has ever happened or is likely to happen. He is the leech that sucks the blood out of public interest. Ile ruined professional foot-racing, ruined wrestling for years, ruined boxing on countless occa sions, blackened the turf and professional baseball and, if the truth must come out, has for several years past been trying to corrupt college sports. The "sure-thing" gambler is no re.specter of person or principle. He fears naught but prison bars. New York State hits him in his only ^ulnerable spot. Chicago Situation Smacks of Corrupiion r|pHERE is a lesson for all of us interested in clean sport in this Chicago situation. The strength of the gambling clique has been shown. And, it would appear, it leads to the exalted places of politics.
The article discusses Comiskey's assumed decision to ban the accused players permanently now that the original indictments were voided, and reports that Cook County's new prosecutor is seeking fresh indictments with promises of more revelations. It also covers New York's new anti-gambling legislation aimed at protecting sports from corrupt gamblers.
New-York Tribune · 21 March 1921 · page 13
1919 world's series with the Cincinnati Reds. There never was any doubt as to how the Old Roman stood on the proposition. He asserted himself in no uncertain terms when the scandal first broke. Indeed, it was due to the initiative and perseverance of Comiskey that a confession was got out of pitcher Eddie Cicotte, and this confession unmasked the whole conspiracy. Yet it was very fortunate that Mr. Comiskey severed all relations with the accused members of his club hefore the Chicago court voided the indictments against them. Comiskey wltnout doubt is business man enough to rc.lize that none of the accused can ever again appear in organized baseball.
See moreSee less
Their appcar ance would ruin the game; the public would never approvc. The faith of the public is the cornerstone of baseball prosperity. And still there are few husines-ses in this commereial age that would gracefully sacrifice a cold half million to pure principle. Charles A. Comiskey has given the proper answer at a time when the general public might be pardoned a certain amount of skepticism. Now, as to the fate of the "Black Sox." Unless new indictments are forthcoming within a fortnight, the accused players will have escaped the grasp of the law. The new prosecutor of Cook County hopes to secure these indictments. He seems very scrious in his mission. He intimatcs, too, that so far only the surface has been scratched. He promises, if his hands are not tied, to unfold some startling exposures even in the high places. Perhaps with such an able ally as Judge Landis behind him, the prosecutor of Cook County may be able to institutc that thorough "houso cleaning" of.which the game stands so sadly in need. Anti-Gambling Laws Should Help Sport fJpHE country at large looks to the Empire State for ideas. New York is a leader, in sport as in fashion. It is to be hoped other states will follow our lead in the matter of legislation to protect baseball lovers from the machinations of professional gamblers. In this state hereafter the offering or acceptance of a bribe or any attempt to influence the result of a ball game other than an issue of true merit will be construed as a criminal act and subject to the penalty cf a fine of $10,000 or five years' imprisonment or both. ? It would have been even better had this commendable bill been broad ened to include all branches of human, sportive competition?amateur as well as professional. For tho sooner every avenue is closed to the "sure thing" gambler the sooner all sports will be raised above the breath of suspicion. The sinister shadow of the f'sure-thing" gambler lies athwart every scandal in sport that has ever happened or is likely to happen. He is the leech that sucks the blood out of public interest. Ile ruined professional foot-racing, ruined wrestling for years, ruined boxing on countless occa sions, blackened the turf and professional baseball and, if the truth must come out, has for several years past been trying to corrupt college sports. The "sure-thing" gambler is no re.specter of person or principle. He fears naught but prison bars. New York State hits him in his only ^ulnerable spot. Chicago Situation Smacks of Corrupiion r|pHERE is a lesson for all of us interested in clean sport in this Chicago situation. The strength of the gambling clique has been shown. And, it would appear, it leads to the exalted places of politics.
The piece argues that 'sure-thing' gamblers have corrupted many sports and that the Chicago case against the indicted White Sox players has collapsed amid apparent corruption. It notes that former prosecutors are now defending the accused players and that missing evidence may make new indictments necessary.
New-York Tribune · 21 March 1921 · page 13
IN ALL FAIRNESS
1919 world's series with the Cincinnati Reds. There never was any doubt as to how the Old Roman stood on the proposition. He asserted himself in no uncertain terms when the scandal first broke. Indeed, it was due to the initiative and perseverance of Comiskey that a confession was got out of pitcher Eddie Cicotte, and this confession unmasked the whole conspiracy. Yet it was very fortunate that Mr. Comiskey severed all relations with the accused members of his club hefore the Chicago court voided the indictments against them. Comiskey wltnout doubt is business man enough to rc.lize that none of the accused can ever again appear in organized baseball.
See moreSee less
Their appcar ance would ruin the game; the public would never approvc. The faith of the public is the cornerstone of baseball prosperity. And still there are few husines-ses in this commereial age that would gracefully sacrifice a cold half million to pure principle. Charles A. Comiskey has given the proper answer at a time when the general public might be pardoned a certain amount of skepticism. Now, as to the fate of the "Black Sox." Unless new indictments are forthcoming within a fortnight, the accused players will have escaped the grasp of the law. The new prosecutor of Cook County hopes to secure these indictments. He seems very scrious in his mission. He intimatcs, too, that so far only the surface has been scratched. He promises, if his hands are not tied, to unfold some startling exposures even in the high places. Perhaps with such an able ally as Judge Landis behind him, the prosecutor of Cook County may be able to institutc that thorough "houso cleaning" of.which the game stands so sadly in need. Anti-Gambling Laws Should Help Sport fJpHE country at large looks to the Empire State for ideas. New York is a leader, in sport as in fashion. It is to be hoped other states will follow our lead in the matter of legislation to protect baseball lovers from the machinations of professional gamblers. In this state hereafter the offering or acceptance of a bribe or any attempt to influence the result of a ball game other than an issue of true merit will be construed as a criminal act and subject to the penalty cf a fine of $10,000 or five years' imprisonment or both. ? It would have been even better had this commendable bill been broad ened to include all branches of human, sportive competition?amateur as well as professional. For tho sooner every avenue is closed to the "sure thing" gambler the sooner all sports will be raised above the breath of suspicion. The sinister shadow of the f'sure-thing" gambler lies athwart every scandal in sport that has ever happened or is likely to happen. He is the leech that sucks the blood out of public interest. Ile ruined professional foot-racing, ruined wrestling for years, ruined boxing on countless occa sions, blackened the turf and professional baseball and, if the truth must come out, has for several years past been trying to corrupt college sports. The "sure-thing" gambler is no re.specter of person or principle. He fears naught but prison bars. New York State hits him in his only ^ulnerable spot. Chicago Situation Smacks of Corrupiion r|pHERE is a lesson for all of us interested in clean sport in this Chicago situation. The strength of the gambling clique has been shown. And, it would appear, it leads to the exalted places of politics. The unexpected collapse of the case against the indicted White Sox
Manager Kid Gleason states he will resign before reinstating any of the indicted White Sox players, even though the legal cases against them were dropped. He expresses confidence in his rebuilt, younger roster for the coming season.
Paper unidentified · 22 March 1921 · page 6
NONE INDICTED GETS BACK INTO WHITE SOX TEAM
White Sox. ’’l cannot ,say that 1 was greatly surprised when the cases against the indicted players was dropped,” con tinued the Kid. "But none of those birds is going to wear a White Sox uniform againat least not while
The column remarks that indicted White Sox players have benefited from a nolle prosequi, meaning charges were dropped. It notes this isn't full exoneration but still a hardship, leaving the players back where they started.
The Topeka State Journal · 23 March 1921 · page 4
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Commissioner Kenesaw Landis has ruled the eight indicted Chicago White Sox players ineligible to play, a decision approved by team owner Charles Comiskey. The report notes that millions of baseball fans are relieved by this ruling.
Paper unidentified · 23 March 1921 · page 4
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 24 March 1921
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
A sports column discusses major league team prospects for the upcoming season, noting that the National League race looks tight among four contenders. It mentions that the fallout from the 1919 World Series scandal still lingers, with the fate of the indicted former White Sox players still uncertain.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 23 March 1921 · page 10
MAJOR LEAGUERS RATINGS
I Crimson authorities but Is undecided ; as to which of the two -rh..,.i. h j will enter. j Earl Sheelev will hut in the cleanup position on the Chicago 'White Sox i team during th" coming season. The farmer Salt Laker has cinched his po ! sltlon bn the Pale Hose. Mulligan will ' swing the sticks In sixth place, while
Prosecution of the indicted White Sox players collapsed when the state's attorney dropped charges against seven players, reportedly due to corruption of a key witness, and Judge Hugo Friend ordered them released. The state announced plans to seek a new indictment before a fresh grand jury.
Paper unidentified · 25 March 1921 · page 6
RELEASED FROM CUSTODY CHICAGO March 10. Immediate pros«» utinii of Chicago White Sox | hasehall players and others indicted in ! «'oiineetl.m with the a lieg«. I throwing ..f games in the P.HO wot r» s.-nes |
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md.
Judge K. M. Landis announced that the eight indicted Chicago White Sox players implicated in the 1919 World Series scandal will be barred from playing until their cases are resolved. This item appeared among a roundup of sporting news items from around the country.
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · 25 March 1921 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
A new investigation into the Black Sox scandal is starting, with the report noting fans will only care if it digs deeper than the first probe. The piece criticizes team owners like Comiskey and the Giants for being slow to act against suspected players without prompting from Judge Landis.
Washington Standard · 25 March 1921 · page 5
CHICAGO STARTS ANOTHER DRIVE ON BLACK SOX
By HENRY FARRELL, United Press Staff Correspondent. NEW YORK, Mar. 19. —Another drive the seven Chicago. Unless the second investigation succeeds in getting deeper under the surface than the first, the fans will not be vitally interested. The major league club ,owners have not been too quick to take the initiative in finding out the truth of "rumors." Charles Comiskey didn't remove the indicted players from the White Sox eligible list until Judge Landis did it for him. The New York Giants did not do a thing to remove the suspicion sur rounding several of their players un til Judge Landis suggested that Benny Kautf be taken from the game until he is tried for grand larceny.
See moreSee less
Rube Benton, Fred Toney and Kauff were directly charged with questionable actions by Heinle Zim merman in an affidavit. Benton also was mentioned In a similar story by Charles Herzog. Benton admits that he won money on the "crooked series" with the full knowledge of what was going on. Joe Gedeon, second baseman of the St. Louis Browns was banished from the game for the same thing, but Benton is still with the Giants.
The Cook County grand jury returned new indictments against 18 defendants, including eight White Sox players, for conspiracy to defraud in the 1919 World Series fixing scandal. These charges follow earlier indictments that had been dismissed for insufficient evidence; immediate trial is not expected.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 26 March 1921 · page 1
EIGHT WHITE SOX AGAIN INDICTED
Scandal Investigation. CHICAGO, March New indictj mens charging conspiracy to defraud in connection with alleged fixing of the 1919 world", series baseball games between the Cincinnati Na tionals and tlie Chicago Americans were returned today by the Cook County grand jury against 18 de fendants. All of the men named, including eight members of the White Sox team were named in in dictments returned last year and dismissed recently when the state declared it lacked sufficient evidence to convict. Immediate trial is not expected.
A Cook County grand jury returned 144 indictments against 18 men following a second investigation into the alleged throwing of the 1919 World Series. Named were the eight White Sox players, along with gamblers Bill Burns, Abe Attell, Rachel Brown, and Joseph Sullivan, with bonds set at $24,000 each and extradition proceedings already underway.
New Britain Herald · 26 March 1921 · page 1
18 MEN INDICTED IN BASEBALL FAKE
- - A - . i A . ' i . 1 A M l. . coumy-araim jury u a remit i oi ww second Investigation into the alleged throwiag of the 191t worW seHes to Cincinnati by Chicago White Sox. Eight separate indictments . against each person were returned. ' Those Indicted . Eddie Cleotte, pitcher, who con f eas ed to receivinc $10,000 to throw game: Claud Williams, pitcher, who confessed tc receiving $5,000; Joe Jackson, outfielder, who confessed to receiving $5. 00; Fred McMullln. util ity lnnelder; Chick Oandil.
See moreSee less
first base man; Swede Risberg, shortstop; Oscar Felsch, outfielder; Buck Weaver, third baseman; Hal Chase, former major league first baseman; Bill Burns, for mer major, league pitcher:. Abe Attell. once champion featherweight fighter; Rachel Brown, , alleged gambler;. Jo seph J. ' Sullivan, alleged gambler. The charges against CVeotte, Mc Mullln, Jackson. Felsch, Weaver, Ris
A second Cook County grand jury investigation resulted in new indictments against the thirteen originally charged men plus five additional alleged conspirators, including Carl Zork, Ben Franklin, the Levi brothers, and David Zelser. Each man faced three counts per indictment, with bail set at $24,000 total, and the state's attorney announced extradition proceedings had begun.
Evening Star · 26 March 1921 · page 8
FIVE NAMES ADDED TO ORIGINAL LIST
pitcher. Abe Attel. once champion featherweight fighter. Rachel Brown, alleged gambler. JSullivan, alleged gambler. The cases against Cicotte. McMullin. Jackson. Kelsch. Weaver, Risberg and Williams recently were dismissed on
A Chicago grand jury voted true bills against eighteen men following a second investigation into the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series by White Sox players. The total number of indictments reached 144, including thirteen men from the first investigation and five new non-player defendants.
The Ocala Evening Star · 26 March 1921 · page 1
FORTY-FOUR INDICTMENTS (Associated Presn) Chicago, March" 26. True bills against eighteen men were voted by the county grand jury as a result of the second investigation of the alleg ed throwing of the world's series to Cincinnati by the White Sox players. In the bills were named thirteen men indicted during the first investiga tion, and five others, none of whom are ball players. The total indict ments number 144. There are eight indictments against each man named.
A Chicago county grand jury voted true bills against eighteen men following a second investigation into the alleged throwing of the 1919 World Series by White Sox players. Thirteen were previously indicted, with five new names added who are not ballplayers, bringing total indictments to 144.
The Daytona Daily News · 26 March 1921 · page 1
. OF BALL PLAYERS (The Associated Press.) CHICAGO. Mar. 26 True bills aga'nst eighteen men were vot ed bv the county grand jury as the result of the second investigation of the alleged throwing of the world ser ies gr.nies to Cincinnati by White Sox players. The bills named thirteen men indicted during the first investi gation and five others, none of whom are bail players. Total indictments number 144. There are eight indict ments against each man named.
The Cook County grand jury returned 140 indictments naming 18 men in the renewed investigation into the 1919 World Series fix, including the original 13 accused plus five newly named individuals. Prosecutors said Carl Zork and Ben Franklin organized the scheme, with Joseph Sullivan handling eastern organization and Abe Attell serving as traveling agent.
The Daily Star-Mirror · 26 March 1921 · page 1
CROOKED BALL MEN AGAIN INDICTED GRAND JURY RE-INDICTS THEM AND ADDS NAMES OF FIVE OTHERS TO LIST
Aim At tell Traveling Agent Chicago^(By A. P.)-Officials of j the state's attorney's office said the evidençe on which the baseball in dictments were voted today showed that Carl Zork and Ben Franklin or- ( ganlzed the game throwing plan and ' that Joseph L. Sullivan handled the j organization work in the east and Abe Attell, the pugilist, was travel-j ing agent, for the organization.
The Cook County grand jury returned new indictments against eighteen White Sox players and gamblers connected to the 1919 World Series fix, following earlier indictments that had been dismissed. A fall trial was indicated.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Indiana Daily Times · 26 March 1921 · page 5
RETURN SECOND TRUE BILLS IN BALL SCANDAL
FALL TRIAL INDICATED CHICAGO, March 26.—Eighteen White Sox players anil gamblers were Indicted by the Cook County grand jury today in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal. Eight indictments were returned against each of the men, charging gen eral conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses and operating a confi dence game. The jury returned indictments against the men who were indicted last fall. They follow: Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, George Weaver, Fred McMullln, Oscar Felsch, Joe Jackson, Charles Kisberg and Chick Gandil, former White Sox players; Hal Chase, former New York Giant player; 'Sport" Sullivan, Rachael Brown and Abe Attel, alleged gamblers, and Wil liam Burns, former pitcher.
See moreSee less
The additional meu named are alleged gamblers. Carl Zork and Benjamin Franklin, both of St. Louis; Ben and Louis Levi and David Zelzer, of Des Moines, were the others Indicted today. The indictments were returned before Chief Justice Charles McDonald.
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eighteen men, including former White Sox players and gamblers, on charges of conspiracy to defraud and operating a rigged game. The report names the accused players and gamblers connected to the 1919 World Series scandal.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 26 March 1921 · page 1
(By ynited Press) Chicago, March 26. Eighteen White Sox players aird^amblers were indicted by the Cook county grand jury in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal. Eighteen indict ments were returned charging each man with the general conspiracy to obtain money under false pretenses and "operating a governed game. Those indicted follow: Clcottet Claud Williams, George Weaver, Fred McMullin, Hap Felsch, Joe Jackson, Charles Risberg and Chick Gandil, former White Sox players, 'L. Chase, former Now York Giant player, Sport Sullivan, Rachael Brown, Abe At tel, alleged gambler, William Burns, former pitcher, Carl Zort and Benja min Fanklin, both of St. Louis, Ben and Louis Levi and David Zelzer of
A Cook County grand jury conducted a second investigation into the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series by the Chicago White Sox and returned 144 indictments covering 18 men. The indictments named the original 13 men from the first investigation plus five additional men accused of helping arrange the conspiracy.
Paper unidentified · 26 March 1921 · page 1
SECOND INVESTIGATION OF BASEBAL.Ii CASE Chicago, March 26. One hundred and forty four indictments including 18 men were returned by the Cook onntv errand -Jury as a result of a second investigation into the alleged throwing or the 1919 World series to Cincmnatti by the Chicago White Sox players. Eight separate indictments were filed. The indictments named the 13 men indicted at the first investigation and also five men charged with taking part in arranging the 'alleged con spiracy.
The state's attorney announced charges were dropped against nearly all indicted former White Sox players in the 1919 World Series fixing scandal, except Chick Gandil, who never appeared in court. New evidence is being sought to bring the case before a grand jury again for conviction.
Walker Lake Bulletin · 26 March 1921 · page 2
White Sox baseball players indicted for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series, except Chick tiandll, who has never appeared in court. The state’s attorney has announced that
A Cook County grand jury indicted eighteen White Sox players and gamblers in connection with the 1919 World Series scandal. Each man faced eight indictments charging conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses, and operating a confidence game.
Paper unidentified · 26 March 1921 · page 1
Repudiation of Confessions Causes New Grand Jury Action
New Grand Jury Action By United Press I . CHICAGO, March 26. Eighteen I White Sox players and gamblers were indicted today by the Cook county grand jury in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal. Eight indictments were returned against each of the men. charging general conspiracy and ob-: taining money under false pretenses and operation a confidence game. The jury returned indictments agtinst the thir will start next fall.
The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.
The Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eighteen White Sox players and gamblers for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series against Cincinnati. Eight players including Cicotte, Jackson, Weaver and Gandil were charged alongside gamblers and Hal Chase, with trial not expected until fall.
The Chickasha Daily Express · 26 March 1921 · page 1
EIGHT COUNTS AGAINST EACH MAN RETURNED
Hal Chaoe, Former Giant AI60 Im plicated; Conspiracy, Obtain ing Money Faltely, Con fidence Game I, j;y United Press. Chicago, Mar. 2tl. Kightren While Sox bi ll players and gamblers, were indicted by the Cook county grand jury today, In connection with the baseball .scandal of 1!U!) when it Is alleged that the Chicago players were "lixed" to "throw" the games to the Cincinnati Reds of the National lea gun in tho world series. Klghl indictments were returned against each man, charging bini with conrpiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses and operating a confideiice game.
See moreSee less
The White Sox players who were Weaver, McMulien, Kelsch, Jackson, Indicted were: Cicotte, Williams, Disberg and Gandit. In addition Hal Chase, former New York Giant star was indicted. Those said to be gamblers and who were indicted along with the vVhilo Sox ball players, were Sport Sullivan, Radical Brown, William Carl Zeork, Benjamin Franklin, Ben 'Burns, former baseball pitcher;
A Chicago county grand jury returned 144 indictments naming 18 men in the second investigation into the alleged fixing of the World Series by the White Sox. Thirteen previously indicted men were reindicted, and five new men—including Carl Zork, Ben Franklin, Ben and Louis Levi, and David Zelser—were accused of conspiracy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
East Oregonian : E.O · 26 March 1921 · page 1
CHICAGO, March 26. (A. P.) One hundred and forty four Indict ments, naming 18 men, were returned today by the county grand jury as the result of the second investigation Into the alleged throwing of the 1918 world series to Cincinnati by the Chi cago White Sox. Eight separate in dictments are against each person. Thirteen men, indicted last fall were reindicted and five others were ac cused of taking part In arranging con spiracy were named. They were Carl Zork and Ben Franklin of St. Louis.
A Cook County grand jury returned 144 indictments against eighteen men in a second investigation into the 1919 World Series fix, including the original thirteen players and gamblers plus five newly named suspects. Each defendant faced eight indictments covering conspiracy to defraud, false pretenses, and conspiracy to commit an illegal act, with bonds set at $24,000 per person.
Evening Public Ledger · 26 March 1921 · page 1
144 INDICTMENTS - Five New Suspects in Alleged 1919 World's Series Throwing Act of Chisox - START NEW INVESTIGATION INTO WHOLE SCANDAL
each person were returned. Tlie indictments named the thirteen men indicted at the first Investigation niul also five men charged with taking part in urtunging the alleged con spiracy. lliese men were Curl Aoik and Hen Franklin, of St. Louis: Hen nnd Louis' Levi, Hit i i to be from Des Moinc, und David Zelser. address unknown. The men leindicted were Eddie Ci cotte. pitcher, who confessed to receiv ing .$10,000 to throw gnnies; Clnude Williams, pitcher, who confessed to re ceiving S.'OOO; doe jneksou, outfielder, who confessed to receiving $.'000 ;.
See moreSee less
Fred McMullin, utility inflelder: Chick (inn (111, first baseman : Swede Kisberg. shortstop: Oscar Fclscli. outfielder; Hnck Weaver, third baseman ; Hni Chase, former major league first base man; Hill Hums, former major league pitcher, Abe Attel. once chuinpion feutherweighl tighter: Hnchel Hrown, alleged gambler: Joseph .1. Sullivan, alleged gambler. The cases ugulnst Cicotte. McMullin.
State's Attorney Crowe dropped the original Black Sox case after key confessions were repudiated, but announced he would seek new indictments within the statute of limitations. The report recounts the investigation's history, including the grand jury probe, confessions by Cicotte, Jackson and Williams, and new evidence implicating Carl Zork via Eugene Paulette's statement to Judge Landis.
Evening Public Ledger · 26 March 1921 · page 1
ORIGINAL CASE WAS DROPPED BY STATE
000 to throw u giiliie. Eddie Cicotte, iiitiher; Joe .lacksou, out fielder, und Claude William", pitcher, admitted to the gianil jury Hint they hud accepted bribes. Later they le liudiUtPtl their confessions mid became unavailable as witnesses when the cusl
Chicago's Cook County grand jury indicted eighteen White Sox players and gamblers in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal. The indictments, matching those returned the previous fall, charged general conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretenses, and operating confidence games.
The Madison Daily Leader · 26 March 1921 · page 1
White Sox Ball Players Indicted Chicago, March 26.—Eighteen White Sox players and gamblers wero indicted today by Cook county's grand jury in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal. Eight in dictments were returned against each one of the men and charge general conspiracy, obtaining money under false prtenses and operating confi dence games. The indictments nam ed the same .players and gamblers who were indicted last fail.
A Cook County grand jury returned new indictments against eight former White Sox players and various gamblers in connection with the 1919 World Series scandal. The new charges followed the players' repudiation of confessions made to an earlier grand jury, and bond was set at $3,000 per indictment with trial expected that fall.
The Milwaukee Leader · 26 March 1921 · page 8
car Felsch, Joe Jackson, Charles I Risberg and Chick Gandil, former j White Sox players, Hal Chase, for-1 mer New York Giant player, Sport Sullivan, Rachet Brown and Abe At tel, alleged gamblers, and William Burns, former pitcher. Carl Zork and Benjamin Franklin, both of St. Louis, Ben and Louis Levi and David Zelzer of Des Moines were the others indicted today. The indictments were returned be fore Chief Justice Charles McDonald.
The Cook County grand jury returned 144 indictments against 18 men in a second investigation into the 1919 World Series fix, with eight separate indictments against each person. The accused include the original 13 players and gamblers plus five newly named men, and State's Attorney Crowe announced extradition proceedings would begin immediately.
Paper unidentified · 26 March 1921 · page 1
Eighteen Included On Eight Counts Each in Returns Of Chicago Jury
Chick Gandll, first baseman.- Charles Rfsberg, shortstop. Oscar Felsch, outfielder. George Weaver, third baseman. Hal Chase, former major league first baseman. Bill' Burns, former major league pitcher. Abe Atte’ once champion feather weight fighter. RAPhet gambler. - Joseph J.Sullivan, alleged gambler. The cases against Cicotte, McMul len. Risberg. Weaver. Jackson rand Williams recently w¥r® distnissqd by the. stqt» oq. IhJ
The Cook County Grand Jury returned new indictments against the seven White Sox players and named eleven others, including St. Louis businessmen Carl Zork and Ben Franklin, in connection with the 1919 World Series fix. The 144 total indictments included charges of conspiracy to cheat honest players and fans via confidence schemes.
New-York Tribune · 27 March 1921 · page 1
St. Louis Men Indicted as Series Fixers
Previously Held; Extra-I dilion Will Be Soughtj - Special Oisvatrli to The Tribune CHICAGO, MaVch 26.?Jubilation among the seven White Sox players | whose cases were dropped iast week j was cut short to-day, when the Cookj County Grand Jury retumed new in dictments against them and named; eleven others -:u true bills charging a conspiracy -o "throw" the 1.919 world's series to Cincinnati, There were 144' indictments in all returned. Thirteen hal! players and aileged ? gamblers were named in the original : batclt of indictments. The five new names includcd in the new true bills i
A new grand jury indictment with eight counts each was handed down against the eighteen defendants in the Black Sox scandal, after State's Attorney Crowe's request for a six-month trial postponement was denied. The charges include conspiracy to fix the World Series, confidence game counts against specific victims, and cheating honest White Sox players out of series winnings; Judge Landis praised the reindictment.
New-York Tribune · 27 March 1921 · page 1
George Gorman, which charges those indicted with conspiracy to cheat the honest players of the White Sox team out of approximately $2,000 each. These players would have won this nuich had the Sox captured the series. The thirteen men indicted for the second time are Eddie Gicotte, Claude ("Lefty") Williams, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin. "Buek" Weaver, Oscar C'Happy") Felsch and "Swede" Ris berg, the seven former White Sox play? ers whose eases were dropped by the prosecutor last week, and "Chic.k"Gan dil, formerly of the White Sox; Hal Chase, Joseph J.
See moreSee less
Sullivan, Rachel Brown, Abe Attetll and William Burns, al! of whom ai;e still under indictment by the. grand jury which made the original inquiry. Bond on each of the counts in the indictment was tixed al $o,000. As there are eight counts this will make a total of $24,000 for each defendant, and as the property schedOled for the bond must be double the amount of the bonds this will mean thal each of the players will have to schedule $43,000 to be released. Action IMeases Landis When Judge Landis. chairman of the National Baseball Commission. svas ap
A second Cook County grand jury investigation returned true bills against eighteen men, including five new names, in the alleged 1919 World Series fix. State's Attorney Crowe announced 144 indictments total and said extradition proceedings had begun, vowing no charges would be dropped this time.
INDICTED MORE BASEBALL MEN. COOK COUNTY GRAND JURY MADE NEW PRESENTMENTS IN THE NOTED WORLD SERIES CASE.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A Cook county grand jury re-indicted eighteen White Sox players and alleged gamblers on conspiracy and confidence game charges related to the 1919 World Series scandal. The new indictments followed the repudiation of confessions allegedly made by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, with trial set for fall and bonds fixed at $3000 each.
last fall. They follow; Eddie Clcotts, Claude William«. George Weaver, Fred McMullin, Oscar Felsch, Joe Jackson. Charles Rlsberg and Chick Gandil, former White Sox players, and Hal Chase, former New Ybrk Giant player: Sport Sullivan, Rachael Brown and Abe Attell, said to be gamblers and Wil liam Burns, former pitcher. Carl Zork and Beniamin Franklin, both of St. Louis; Ben and Louis Levi and David Zelxer. of Des Moines, were the others indicted to day. The Indictments were returned beforo Chief Justice Charles Mc Donald. State's Attorney Robert E.
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey is working to rebuild his team following the devastating loss of players from the Black Sox scandal. The report details new infield and pitching recruits, including three players acquired from Salt Lake City, as the team prepares for the upcoming season.
Grand Forks Herald · 28 March 1921 · page 7
Chicago, March 28.—Charles A. Comiskey, owner of vthej Chicago Americans.^rhoW championship clulr ^Wi) w90 shattered as a result of the base ball scandal, today believes he has succeeded in rebuilding the team tsu Which has been his pride. The "Old Roman's" chief concern is whether Manager.Glealson will be able •tobuild up aj» effective pitching staff from the large number of recruits on hand. In -former years, Comiskey had little difficulty getting first 'class pitchers, but was unable to land the kmen who could connect with base hits. This year the tattles seem to have turned, unless the recruit twirlers' make good.
See moreSee less
He has signed a number of players who had goodVbatting •Jmfcrks last season, and may became sluggers this year. 'The leading witchers with the White Sox, and around whom the staff wul be moulded, are' Faber, Kerr, Hodge and Wilkinson, the latter two having Joined last year. It is likely that Hodge and Wilkinson will be able to take a regular turn on the mound.. Joe Morris, of Tulsa, Okla., Mu/renna, purchased from Columbus—and Mc Weeney bought from Milwaukee, probably will round out the staff, aU though one or two others may be re ifcalned. .The infield, which was wrecked last fall, may furnish a big surprise this season. Comiskey obtained three stars from the Salt Lake club in -Ernie Johnson, shortstop Eddie Mulligan, third baseman, and Sheeley, first base man. If these thijee players can fit in with Captain Eddie Collins, the guar dian of the keystone sack, baseball fails declare the infield should be one of the fastest in the country. The three Salt Lake players have been WjDrking together for several years 'tyid with the veteran Collins, are ex pected to make a creditable showing. 'Ernie Johnson, who will attempt to fill Risberg's shoes at short, had a bat ting average of ..299 in the Pacific Coast league last season. He has a strong arm and gets the ball away with great speed and accuracy. The hole at (turd base, caused by., the loss oft"Buck" Weaver, will not :be difficult'to fill. Tw.o great prospects are in line for the place. Harvey Mc Clellan, who played the role of utility with the White Sox, is a' natural field er and is giving Eddie Mulligan, the Salt Lake third sacker, a hard run for J.)i£he position.' Each has a world of speed and it may not be until the sea son opens that one will be given the regular assignment. The club is well stocked. with out fielders, despite the fact that Joe Jackson and "Happy" P\slsch are numbered among the missing. Hany 'Hooper, obtained in""u trade from Bos ton,, will become,^, fixture in right flelE_ Johnny Mostil, who was with Milwaukee last.^sear, will play* center. Mostil 'is a clever fielder, and a good batter. He had a sensational record with, the Milwaukee club. The left field position probably will fall to Anrioe Strunk, although "Bib"
The article previews the 1921 White Sox season, detailing new players brought in to replace banned stars like Risberg, Weaver, Jackson, and Felsch. It highlights new infielders from Salt Lake City and outfielders like Harry Hooper and Johnny Mostil filling the gaps left by the scandal.
A roundup of sports news items includes a brief note that Ben Franklin, a St. Louis livestock dealer indicted in the White Sox baseball scandal, declined to comment on the case. The rest of the digest covers unrelated spring training, boxing, and horse racing news.
Grand Forks Herald · 28 March 1921 · page 7
NEWS FROM THE WIRE
Ben Franklin, St. Louis livestock dealer, indicted in the White Sox base ball scandal Saturday, refused to comment on the case. Carl Tremaine of Cleveland /uid Ja bez White of Albany, bantamweights, ten round bout at Cleveland meet in a tonight. The world champion, Cleveland Indians, are ^scheduled with the Dal las, Texas league' club today. ''Gfoldle" Rapp, star infielder of the NeW York Nationals, is in a New Or leans hospital suffering from a slight attack of pneumonia. He will not^ be, able to Join the team for several days.
See moreSee less
Davy Bancroft, the Glands' shortstop, is at New Orleans for an operation in whiqji his tonsils will be removed. The team was at Mobile, Alp.., today. It was reported today that Andy Chaney and Johnny" Kilbane, the featherweight champion, have been matched tor a boUt some time during the summer at an open air arena in Cleveland, Ohio.
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against White Sox players accused of gambling on games and throwing the 1919 championship series. The dispatch, datelined Chicago, reports the number indicted as eighteen players.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Daily Alaskan · 29 March 1921 · page 4
Chicago, March 28.—The grand jury of Cook County indicted eigh teen of the White Sox players who gambled on the game and threw the championship series.