As the Papers Told It

Black Sox · The full archive

November 1919

4 articles

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

Sportswriter James P. Sinnott reports that rumors of crookedness in the recent World's Series are circulating again, with gamblers allegedly tampering with Chicago players. The piece notes general skepticism toward such rumors, comparing them to routine complaints of fixed races and fights.

El Paso Herald · 15 November 1919 · page 18

Sold Out for Sox Series. There is not a reserved seat to be had for any of the three games, scheduled for the White Sox to play here the next three days, and it is a cinch the plant, which had ample accommodations for all the baseball enthusiasm of Cleveland a dozen years ago, will be completely swamped all the rest of the week. Only a tithe of the fans who are planning to watch the Spokes cinch the pennant at the expense of the Gleasons ever will get nearer than a block to the ball park, according to advance indications.

See moreSee less

The Sox will have to win two out of the three games to stay within fighting distance of the pennant, and if they lose two of the three only a dispensation of Providence can keep them from finishing sec ond or third. And if they can ac complish the unexpected by win ning three straight here the Glea sons still will have a tough task to keep in front, for they will have to win practically every other game on their list, too. There is little likelihood that any team except the Gleasons will take a game from the Indians unless the latter slip.

Clipping to come

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A sports columnist argues that talk of the 1919 World Series being a 'fake' stems from disgruntled gamblers who can't accept losing, not from any real evidence. He insists the Cincinnati Reds were simply the better team, regardless of rumors that gamblers tried to influence Chicago players.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 132 days later.

Wrong

El Paso Herald · 15 November 1919 · page 18

Sold Out for Sox Series. There is not a reserved seat to be had for any of the three games, scheduled for the White Sox to play here the next three days, and it is a cinch the plant, which had ample accommodations for all the baseball enthusiasm of Cleveland a dozen years ago, will be completely swamped all the rest of the week. Only a tithe of the fans who are planning to watch the Spokes cinch the pennant at the expense of the Gleasons ever will get nearer than a block to the ball park, according to advance indications.

See moreSee less

The Sox will have to win two out of the three games to stay within fighting distance of the pennant, and if they lose two of the three only a dispensation of Providence can keep them from finishing sec ond or third. And if they can ac complish the unexpected by win ning three straight here the Glea sons still will have a tough task to keep in front, for they will have to win practically every other game on their list, too. There is little likelihood that any team except the Gleasons will take a game from the Indians unless the latter slip.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A newspaper column argues there is no evidence the 1919 World Series was fixed for Cincinnati to win, dismissing rumors of a 'sell out' by White Sox players as unsupported gossip. The writer argues baseball is uniquely hard to fix compared to other sports, and insists the Series was decided fairly on its merits.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 130 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 November 1919 · page 8

League champ I. white Sox sis under the attack of the White box losing by 10 to 3 ed the Indians in every department of the game. As a result, Cleveland now leads Chicago by only half a game. Available space in the park was taken, with the exception of right field, where Manager Speaker pro tested against permitting spectators to' were caught by the right fielders, was the presencp of the crowd in left!'garn field that started ihe downfall of the Score Indians, as Jackson received credit for a two-base hit in starting the sixth inning that would have been an easy out for Left Fielder Evans had the public not been allowed to take pos session of that part.

See moreSee less

oC the field. Although he split his finger in the fourth inning, Dick Kerr pitched mas

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The article argues that fixing a baseball game is nearly impossible given the unpredictable distribution of fielding chances during a game. It criticizes unnamed sportswriters for alleging certain White Sox players conspired to throw the Series without providing names or evidence, calling such insinuations cowardly and unfair to the whole team.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 311 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 November 1919 · page 8

League champ I. white Sox sis under the attack of the White box losing by 10 to 3 ed the Indians in every department of the game. As a result, Cleveland now leads Chicago by only half a game. Available space in the park was taken, with the exception of right field, where Manager Speaker pro tested against permitting spectators to' were caught by the right fielders, was the presencp of the crowd in left!'garn field that started ihe downfall of the Score Indians, as Jackson received credit for a two-base hit in starting the sixth inning that would have been an easy out for Left Fielder Evans had the public not been allowed to take pos session of that part.

See moreSee less

oC the field. Although he split his finger in the fourth inning, Dick Kerr pitched mas

Clipping to come