At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, witnesses including Daniel Hutzen and his daughters testified about seeing a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness, heavily veiled, with an unidentified gray-haired man on July 9. Hutzen, who had helped search the fire ruins, insisted he recognized her by build and walk despite not seeing her face.
The Billings Gazette · 24 November 1908 · page 3
NEW TURN IN MURDER TRIAL WITNESSES TESTIFY AS TO STRANGE CIRCUMSTANCES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The murder trial of Ray Lamphere for the deaths of Belle Gunness and her three children is nearing its end, with Dr. Walter S. Haines expected to testify about strychnine and arsenic found in the victims' stomachs. The defense has presented evidence suggesting Mrs. Gunness was alive months after the fire, that the fire started earlier than the state claims, and that she may have been driven to suicide by harassment.
Paper unidentified · 24 November 1908 · page 1
pr— JSJ Were by Poison, tia^orte, Ind. Nov. 23.—The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three ejajail children is drawing to aldose. Another dayJ will see the evidence all in, unless something 'unforeseen happens tomorrow. Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago will-.take.&e stand early tomorrow afternoon, acoprding tb calculations, to ..testify as to the finding of strychnine and arsenic In the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness and two of the children. %.As the case now stands the de fense lias introduced evidence to show that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was alive on July 9, more than two months after the fire in which the state contends sLe perished. The-'defense has also offered eyidence to sjiow that the firewas seen before the hour alleg ed by the :state that Lamphere left the Siplth residence, thereby laying ground for an alibi. Then, too, the defense'has offered evidence to show that Mrs. Gunness was so harassed by Lamphere, Hel geline and others that she committed
The defense presented evidence suggesting the fire was seen earlier than prosecution claimed, supporting an alibi for Lamphere's departure time from the Smith residence. The defense also argued Belle Gunness was so harassed by Lamphere and Helgelien that she set fire to her own house and killed herself.
Paper unidentified · 24 November 1908 · page 1
Then, too, the defense'has offered evidence to show that Mrs. Gunness was so harassed by Lamphere, Hel geline and others that she committed suicide after setting lire to the^oii^e''Xl0tice ™P°ri Speaker Cannon and the herself. Lamphere, according to to-i ^er Reactionaries that unless they day's statements of the defendant's attorneys, "will not go on the stand. Neither will Mrs. Elizabeth Smith, the. colored woman at whose house Lamphere spent the night, be used as a witness, according tb present jdans. )^&.fter finding that no person of the name signed to the letters receivContinued on page 8) courage and leadership of a high or der.
See moreSee less
He has made himself the lead er of the progressive forces within the Republican party, and has served come into line they will have trouble on their bands. This applies to the" tariff and ev erything else. Mr. Taft has made his attitude clear. There is no mlsget it. The reactionaries are in a peck of trouble and do not know what to do. They do not like to surrender, and yet they are afraid to fight. The nourse which they wiH-probably adopt is that of seeming to surrender with a secret hope that they may be able to get their way by Indirection and maneuvers in the end. 5*^^ As had been' foreseen, immedlktely after the election of Mr. Taft the Re publican^ councils were divided into two factions, The attitude of Speaker
This brief item identifies Ray Lamphere and Nettie Smutzer, one of the principal witnesses at his trial, pictured together. Lamphere was charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness.
The News-Democrat · 24 November 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE AND A WITNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
The defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial finished presenting its case, offering evidence that a car was seen on the Gunness road and that the fire was spotted earlier than prosecution claimed, suggesting Lamphere could not have set it. A separate note references efforts to trace a threatening letter purportedly signed by Mrs. Gunness demanding attorney Worden meet her alone in Michigan City.
The Madison Daily Leader · 24 November 1908 · page 1
TRIAL NEARING ITS CLOSE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The murder trial of Ray Lamphere for killing Mrs. Gunness and her three children resumed with testimony from Dr. Haines, with all evidence expected to be submitted by day's end. Defense attorney Worden revealed a telegram claiming Mrs. Gunness had been spotted alive in Kansas City, Kansas, a report that authorities were investigating.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Paper unidentified · 24 November 1908 · page 3
SEEN IN KANSAS CITY?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
At the La Porte trial, a witness for Ray Lamphere admitted under cross-examination that poison was found in the bodies recovered from the Gunness home ruins, though it may have been given after death. Another doctor testified the cause of death was suffocation by fire.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 25 November 1908 · page 1
Opinion in Case Lapoite. lud.. Nov. hi.—Ur. Wal ter Haims, who came from Wash ington to testify for Ray igmipliere, admitted under cross examination to day that poison was found in the bodies of the woman and children taken from the ruins of the Gunness home, it might have been adminis tered after death, he said, Dr. .T. L. Gray said tincause of death was ^suffocation by fire.
At La Porte, Indiana, evidence in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children concluded, with closing arguments set for the next day. Toxicologist Dr. Walter Haines testified finding arsenic and strychnine in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and the Gunness family, though another doctor said death could not have been due to strychnine poisoning.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 25 November 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCE ENDS IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Toxicologist Dr. Haines testified that arsenic and strychnine were found in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and of Mrs. Gunness and two children, enough to have caused multiple deaths. However, Dr. Gray, who performed the autopsy, testified death could not have been due to strychnine poisoning, after which the state rested its case.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 25 November 1908 · page 3
EVIDENCE ALL IN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.
Evidence has concluded in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the alleged murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. Jury instructions are being prepared and closing arguments from attorneys are expected the following day.
Attorneys for and against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children, delivered closing pleas to the jury in Laporte, Indiana. The case was expected to go to the jury that night, with a verdict possibly coming early the next day.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 25 November 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Testimony concluded in Ray Lamphere's murder trial, with Dr. Walter Haines testifying about strychnine and arsenic found in the bodies of Mrs. Gunness and two children; closing arguments were set for the next day. Separately, a telegram claiming Belle Gunness was seen alive in Kansas City was traced to a fortune teller, and police there doubted the story.
Los Angeles Herald · 25 November 1908 · page 2
EVIDENCE ENDED IN TRIAL OF LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, a toxicology expert testified he found arsenic and strychnine in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness, her children, and Andrew Helgelein, but could not confirm strychnine poisoning caused death. An undertaker countered that he had applied fifteen pounds of arsenic powder to the bodies during embalming, complicating the poison evidence.
New-York Tribune · 25 November 1908 · page 14
FOUND POISON IN LAPORTE BODIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children was expected to go to the jury late in the day, following closing arguments from both prosecution and defense. Judge Richter ruled that the jury must convict Lamphere of arson if evidence showed he set the fire, and of murder or manslaughter if any victims died as a result of that fire.
Evening Star · 25 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, Indiana, Judge Richter announced he would instruct the jury that if evidence showed Lamphere set the fire at the Gunness house, they must find him guilty of arson. He added that if anyone died in the fire as a result, the jury must find Lamphere guilty of murder or manslaughter.
Evening Times-Republican · 25 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
At the Lamphere trial in La Porte, Judge Richter ruled that if evidence shows Lamphere set the fire at the Gunness house, he must be found guilty of arson even if no deaths resulted. If the fire caused any of the four deaths, the jury must instead choose between murder and manslaughter verdicts.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 25 November 1908 · page 1
MANSLAUGHTER IF EVIDENCE IS SUFFICIENT. THE JURY WILL BE INSTRUCTED TO BRING IN ONE OF THE THREE VERDICTS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago testified at Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, that he detected poison in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness, her three children, and Andrew Helgelein. This testimony was part of a broader news digest covering unrelated political and business items of the day.
The Lake County Times · 25 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, witnesses testified to seeing an automobile speeding away from the Gunness farm road on the morning of the fire. Other testimony indicated the fire had been spotted as early as 3 o'clock that morning.
The Lake County Times · 25 November 1908 · page 4
AUTO USED AS EVIDENCE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Closing arguments began in the Lamphere trial, with defense arguing for acquittal on reasonable doubt while prosecution countered the poison theory using undertaker testimony about embalming chemicals used on the Gunness bodies. Judge Richter's jury instructions on reasonable doubt were expected to be extensive.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 25 November 1908 · page 7
COMPROMISE IS OPPOSED. INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY EXPECTED TO BE VOLUMINOUS. REASONABLE DOUBT WILL BE EXPLAINED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
In the Lamphere trial at Laporte, Indiana, Judge Ritcher ruled he would instruct the jury that setting fire to the Gunness house constitutes arson regardless of whether deaths resulted. He also ruled that if any of the four persons died as a result of the fire Lamphere set, the jury must find him guilty of murder or manslaughter, dealing a setback to the defense.
The Topeka State Journal · 25 November 1908 · page 6
BAD FOR LAMPHERE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The passage reports that evidence has been completed in the La Porte, Indiana trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson. Closing arguments were expected Wednesday, with the case likely to go to the jury that evening.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 25 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont. · and 1 other paper
At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified about his love affair and quarrels with Belle Gunness. They also described threats Lamphere had made against her.
The Enterprise · 25 November 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn. · 25 November 1908
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.
At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified about his romantic relationship and quarrels with Belle Gunness. They also described threats Lamphere had made against her.
The Columbus Journal · 25 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
At the La Porte trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness, Judge Richter ruled he would instruct the jury that if evidence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, they must find him guilty of arson even if the fire did not cause anyone's death. The defense had fought to exclude this instruction but the court deemed it proper.
Paper unidentified · 25 November 1908 · page 1
COURT'S INSTRUCTION TO JURY IN LA PORTE TRIAL ADVERSE TO DEFENDANT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, three defense witnesses—a neighbor named Daniel Hutson and his two young daughters—testified that they saw Belle Gunness alive on her property days after the fire that destroyed her home. They claimed to have seen her heavily veiled and accompanied by a gray-mustached man, and insisted they knew her too well to be mistaken.
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 25 November 1908 · page 6
SAW MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.
Judge Richter ruled that if evidence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, the jury must find him guilty of arson regardless of whether the fire caused deaths. He also ruled that if any of the four victims died as a result of the fire Lamphere set, the jury must convict him of murder or manslaughter.
The Roswell Daily Record · 25 November 1908 · page 1
STATE GAINS A POINT IN LAMPHERE TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
In the murder trial of Ray Lamphere in Laporte, Indiana, Judge Richter ruled he would instruct the jury that setting fire to the Gunness house constitutes arson regardless of whether deaths resulted. He also ruled that if any of the four people in the house died from the fire and Lamphere set it, jurors must convict him of murder or manslaughter.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 25 November 1908 · page 1
LOOKS BAD FOR RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
The Associated Press reports from LaPorte, Indiana that all evidence has been presented in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the alleged murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children. The judge's instructions to the jury are expected the next morning, followed by closing arguments.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 25 November 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS TRIAL NEARS END
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.
At La Porte, Judge Richter ruled that if evidence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, the jury must find him guilty of arson even if the fire did not cause any deaths. The case was expected to go to the jury that afternoon.
The Guthrie Daily Leader · 25 November 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Vinita Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.
In La Porte, Judge Richter announced he would instruct the jury that if evidence showed Lamphere set the Gunness house fire, he must be found guilty of arson even if no deaths resulted. The case was expected to go to the jury that afternoon.
The Vinita Daily Chieftain · 25 November 1908 · page 1
FATE IN HANDS OF THE JURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
Attorney Worden, defending Ray Lamphere, reports receiving a telegram claiming Mrs. Belle Gunness was in Kansas City, Kansas. The report notes the claim is being investigated.
Bryan Morning Eagle · 25 November 1908 · page 6
Worden, defending Ray Lamphere, bays a. telegram has been received from Kansas City, Kan., stating Mrs. Belle Gunness is there. The matter Is being Investigated.
A newspaper miscellany column includes a brief jab suggesting people who claim to have seen Belle Gunness recently are simply seeing double, implying skepticism toward the wave of reported sightings. The item is one of many short humorous or topical one-liners rather than a dedicated news report.
Deseret Evening News · 25 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
At Laporte, all evidence has been presented in Ray Lamphere's murder trial, with jury instructions being prepared and closing arguments set for the next day. Separately, a reported sighting of Belle Gunness in Kansas City is dismissed by police, who identify the woman as a domestic named Nellie Ledford.
The Salt Lake Herald · 25 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE CASE NEARING CLOSE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Police in Kansas City and Kansas City, Kan., say they have no reason to believe Belle Gunness is in their area. The woman identified as 'Ella Hennig' is clarified to be a fortune-telling domestic named Nellie Ledford, who merely suspected a woman she'd met resembled Gunness.
The Salt Lake Herald · 25 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Judge Richter ruled that if evidence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, the jury must convict him of arson regardless of whether the fire caused deaths. He also instructed that if any of the four persons died as a result of the fire, Lamphere must be found guilty of murder or manslaughter.
The Laramie Republican · 25 November 1908 · page 1
STATE GAINS IN TRIAL OF LAMPHERE FOR BURNING OF GUNNESS HOME AT LA PORTE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · and 1 other paper
After the prosecution rested in Ray Lamphere's trial at Laporte, Indiana, the defense began presenting its case, including witness testimony aimed at disproving that the adult body found in the burned farmhouse ruins was Belle Gunness. Attorney Worden opened with a statement to the jury outlining this defense strategy.
The Greenville Journal · 26 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 25 November 1908
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark.
At the Ray Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses including Daniel Hutson and his daughters testified they saw a woman resembling Belle Gunness driving with a gray-haired man on July 9, days before the fire. Hutson described her clothing and the buggy in detail but admitted under cross-examination he never saw her face.
The Nevada County Picayune · 26 November 1908 · page 2
WITNESSES AT LAMPHERE TRIAL SAY WOMAN IS NOT DEAD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark. · and 1 other paper
Neighbor Hutson and his two young daughters testify at Ray Lamphere's trial that they saw Mrs. Gunness riding in a buggy with a gray-haired man near the farm on July 9, months after she was presumed dead in the fire. A letter is also revealed claiming the writer was the man who accompanied her that day, bolstering the defense's case that she survived.
The Nevada County Picayune · 26 November 1908 · page 2
LITTLE GIRLS RECOGNIZED HER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Bee · Earlington, Ky. · 26 November 1908
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The fifteenth day of Ray Lamphere's murder trial was devoted to closing arguments, with defense attorney Worden insisting Belle Gunness was still alive and the body identification incomplete, while State's Attorney Smith attacked the defense's contradictory theories. The judge finished his instructions and the jury retired at 5:30 to consider six possible verdicts.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 1
SIX FORMS OF VERDICT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Defense attorney Worden argued Gunness was still alive and that identification of the fire victims' bodies was incomplete, while prosecutor Smith countered by highlighting dental evidence and inconsistencies in the defense's theory. The judge then read lengthy instructions to the jury on circumstantial evidence and the legal requirements for conviction on the arson-murder charge.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children concluded its fifteenth day with closing arguments, after which the case went to the jury. Defense attorney Worden argued the evidence was circumstantial and claimed Mrs. Gunness was still alive, while State's Attorney Smith delivered a sharp rebuttal before the jury began deliberations.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 26 November 1908 · page 11
FATE OF LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children concluded after fifteen days, with closing arguments from both prosecution and defense. The jury was given six possible verdict forms ranging from first-degree murder to not guilty, and after four hours of deliberation without a decision, was locked up for the night.
Bisbee Daily Review · 26 November 1908 · page 1
JURY IS CONSIDERING CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
After fifteen days of testimony, closing arguments were made in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. The jury received six possible verdict forms, ranging from first-degree murder to acquittal, and was locked up for the night after four hours of deliberation without reaching a decision.
Arizona Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
After fifteen days of trial at Laporte, closing arguments were made in the case against Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson. The jury was given six possible verdict forms ranging from first-degree murder with death penalty to acquittal, and after four hours of deliberation without agreement was locked up for the night.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 26 November 1908 · page 1
CLOSING ARGUMENTS IN TRIAL OF ALLEGED MURDERER OF MURDERESS ARE LONG. TRIAL AT LAPORTE LASTED FIFTEEN DAYS HARD LEGAL FIGHTING.
Degree Carrying Life Sentence. LAPORTE, November 25. Tho trial of Ray Lamphcrc for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunnels and her three chil dren was finished this afternoon, and at 5:30 o'clock, tho case was given to the jury, which at onco began its de liberations to dotermino whother Lam phcrc started the firo that consumed the homo of Mrs. Gunness and cause'd the death of the woman and her children. This was the fifteenth day of tho trial. Tho cntiro day was consumed in tbj argument, Attorney Sutherland opening for tho state, fo'lowed by Attorney Weir for the defense.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worden, who has been Lam phere's attorney from the day follow ing his arrest, last May, made a strong plea for his client and State's Attorney Smith mado tho closing argument. Tho jury was given six forms of ver dict and instructed to sign tho one on which it agreed. Tho forms were: Guilty of murder in tho first degree; death. Guilty of murder in the first de gree; life sentence. Guilty of murder in tho second degree; lifo scntenc. Guilty of manslaughtr. Guilty of ar son, ot guilty. After deliberating for four hours1 without reaching a verdict, tho jury at 10:15 was locked up for tho night.
The case against Ray Lamphere, on trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, was given to the jury in the evening. After four hours of deliberation, the jury had not reached a verdict and was locked up for the night.
Paper unidentified · 26 November 1908 · page 1
NO GUNNESS VERDICT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children concluded on November 25, with the case handed to the jury at 5:30 p.m. The jury was locked up for deliberation but had reached no agreement by 10:45 that night.
The San Francisco Call · 26 November 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
After fifteen days of trial, closing arguments were made and the judge gave the jury twenty-nine paragraphs of instructions on six possible verdicts, including conviction for arson even without proof the fire caused the deaths. The jury then began deliberating whether Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children.
Los Angeles Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE CASE GIVEN TO JURY SIX VERDICTS POSSIBLE BY INSTRUCTIONS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
After fifteen days of trial, the case of Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, went to the jury. The jury was given six possible verdict forms ranging from first-degree murder with death sentence to not guilty.
New-York Tribune · 26 November 1908 · page 1
JURY HAS LAMPHERE CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
After a day of closing arguments, the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children went to the jury on the fifteenth day of trial. The jury was given six possible verdict forms ranging from first-degree murder with death sentence to not guilty.
New-York Tribune · 26 November 1908 · page 1
JURY HAS LAMPHERE CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
The jury in the Belle Gunness murder case, involving defendant Ray Lamphere, has been deliberating since the previous evening without reaching a verdict. Judge Richter instructed jurors they could return one of six possible verdicts ranging from first-degree murder to acquittal, though even acquittal would not free Lamphere due to a separate pending indictment.
Evening Times-Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 1
No Verdict in Gunness Murder Case Returned Up to 9 Late Hour: Jury Out All Night
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Judge Richter instructed jurors on possible verdicts ranging from first-degree murder to acquittal in the Lamphere trial, noting he must remain jailed regardless due to a separate pending indictment for the Helgelein murder. Defense attorney Worden argued all evidence was circumstantial, claimed Mrs. Gunness was still alive, and disputed the body identification and teeth evidence, while the state's attorney gave a dramatic closing argument against Lamphere.
Evening Times-Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 1
OUT ALL NIGHT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Defense attorney Worden argued the hired man Joseph Maxson knew more than he admitted, disputed the teeth evidence, and cited witnesses claiming to have seen Mrs. Gunness alive on July 9th while discrediting prosecution testimony. State's Attorney Smith countered by defending the teeth and medical evidence, dismantling the defense witnesses, and linking Lamphere to Helgelein's disappearance and murder.
Evening Times-Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 1
OUT ALL NIGHT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa
At the Laporte trial, Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made damaging admissions amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home on the morning of April 28. This testimony was part of the broader criminal proceedings against Lamphere.
Audubon Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · and 1 other paper
At the Ray Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified about his love affair and quarrels with Mrs. Belle Gunness. They also described threats Lamphere had made against her.
Audubon Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich. · 28 November 1908
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa
The attorney defending Ray Lamphere during his murder trial released a letter claiming its anonymous writer had accompanied Belle Gunness away from the farm on July 9, the day witnesses saw her and a man drive off in a buggy. The letter asserts Gunness is still alive, contradicting the assumption that she died in the farmhouse fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Audubon Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 7
MRS. GUNNESS IS ALIVE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Judge Richter instructs that Lamphere can be convicted of arson if he set the fire, and of murder/manslaughter if deaths resulted from that fire. Dr. Haines testified that arsenic and strychnine were found in the stomachs of the victims, closing testimony before closing arguments.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 26 November 1908 · page 1
JUDGE RICHTER ADVISES JURY THAT IT CAN CONVICT HIM OF ARSON IF IT IS FOUND HE FIRED GUNNESS HOME
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25. Testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with the ururder of Mrs. Belle Gun ness and her three children, was closed yesterday afternoon-, following expert testimony which was consider ed damaging to* the defense. Today was taken up with arguments and in structions to the jury. It is expected the case will be in the jury's hands by evening, with tho possibility ot a ver dict before midnight. Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago yes terday testified as a. medical expert. For an hour and ten minutes he occu pied the witness stand, telling what he found by analysis in the stomachs "f the three bodies tajcen from the dull ness house ruins.
See moreSee less
He also described the contents of the stomach of Andre\y Helgelein. In so far as the attorneys for the de. fense expected Dr. Haines to testify tha.l arsenic and strychnine in fatal quantities were found by analysis, their expectations were fulfilled. But the expert stated frankly he did not Know whether the poison was intro duced into the bodies before or after death.
Dr. Walter S. Haines testified at trial that he found arsenic and strychnine in the remains from the Gunness ruins and in Andrew Helgelein's stomach, in amounts sufficient to cause death, but could not determine whether poison was introduced before or after death. The defense's case was undercut when an undertaker testified the bodies had been embalmed with arsenical compound before autopsy, explaining some arsenic presence.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 26 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
COURT DEALS A BLOW TO HOPES OF LAMPHERE
JUDGE RICHTER ADVISES JURY THAT IT CAN CONVICT HIM OF ARSON IF IT IS FOUND HE FIRED GUNNESS HOME.
See moreSee less
CASE GOES TO THE JURY LATE TODAY
LAST WITNESS FOR DEFENSE, DR. HAINES, PROVED UNWILLING TO TESTIFY POISON CAUSED GUNNESS DEATHS.
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25.—The state scored a big victory today in the Lamphere trial when Judge Richter announced that he would instruct the jury that if the evidence showed that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, even if the fire did not cause the death of any persons therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. Also that if the jury finds any person in the house lost his life as the result of the fire and that Lamphere set that fire, then it must find Lamphere guilty of murder or manslaughter.
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25. — Testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, was closed yesterday afternoon, following expert testimony which was considered damaging to the defense. Today was taken up with arguments and instructions to the jury. It is expected the case will be in the jury's hands by evening, with the possibility of a verdict before midnight.
Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago yesterday testified as a medical expert. For an hour and ten minutes he occupied the witness stand, telling what he found by analysis in the stomachs of the three bodies taken from the Gunness house ruins. He also described the contents of the stomach of Andrew Helgelein.
In so far as the attorneys for the defense expected Dr. Haines to testify that arsenic and strychnine in fatal quantities were found by analysis, their expectations were fulfilled. But the expert stated frankly he did not know whether the poison was introduced into the bodies before or after death.
Unable to Tell Cause of Death.
Dr. Haines added he could not determine the cause of death by his analysis, or even tell whether the poison had been inside or outside the stomach, owing to the fact that three stomachs were in one jar, and were in advanced stages of decomposition.
In the case of Helgelein, Dr. Haines said he found both strychnine and arsenic. In his testimony he said:
"On May 27 I received three sealed jars form Laporte. One jar contained three stomachs together. Another jar contained contents of the stomachs. A third jar contained the stomach of a man named Helgelein. I analyzed for poison. Helgelein's stomach contained arsenic in abundance, and a considerable quantity of strychnine. I examined a third of the stomach, finding a little less than one-third of a grain of strychnine. If the stomach was of uniform composition I would conclude the total amount of strychnine to have been about one and a half grains. About one-third of a grain is the smallest amount that records show has caused the death of an adult.
"The stomachs in the other jar were run together to the only possible thing to do was to analyze the whole mass. I found an abundance of arsenic and concluded that the whole mass contained between one and a half and two grains— enough to cause the death of three persons."
Dr. Haines was followed by Alexander Neddo, living two miles from the Gunness place, who testified that he saw the fire at 3 o'clock on the morning of April 28.
Prosecution Uses Its Bomb.
In rebuttal the prosecution exploded its bomb against the prison theory. Austin Cutler, undertaker, testified that before the autopsies were performed on the bodies of the Gunness family he embalmed them with from ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical compound in powdered form and about two gallons of light embalming fluid, composed chiefly of formaldehyde.
As he failed to account for the presence of strychnine, the defense seized upon this point to convince the jury that a reasonable doubt of Lamphere's guilt exists.
The undertaker further testified that about 200 persons had access to the bodies before the autopsies, making it appear that opportunity existed for introducing poison in the bodies while they were lying in the morgue.
A toxicologist testified that the combined stomach contents contained enough arsenic to kill three people, while a neighbor testified to seeing the fire. In a dramatic rebuttal, the undertaker revealed he had used ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical embalming compound on the bodies before autopsies were performed, giving the defense grounds to argue reasonable doubt about Lamphere's guilt.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 26 November 1908 · page 1
CAUSED GUNNESS DEATHS
Prosecution Uses Its Bomb. In rebutfo! the prosecution exploded Its bomb £'.gainst the prison theory. Austin Cutler, undertaker, testified that before the autopsies were par-' formed on die bodies of the Gunness fhmily he embalmed them with from ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical com pound in powdered form and about jfwo gallons of light embalming fluid, Composed chifiy of formaldehyde. as he failed to account for the pres ence of strychnine, the defense seized upon this point to convince the jury that a reasonable doubt of Lamphere's pjllt exists. Tbe undertaker further testified that About 200 persons had access to the lodies before the autopsies, making it Appear that, opportunity existed for in troducing poison in the bodies while J»ey were iying in the morsue. a
The Lamphere trial in Laporte continues, with the defense presenting evidence claiming Mrs. Gunness is still alive and had poisoned her children before the fire. They argue the woman's body found in the ruins was actually a murder victim, not Gunness herself.
Paper unidentified · 26 November 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The jury in Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children deliberated for six hours without reaching a verdict before being allowed to rest for the night. The judge outlined six possible verdicts ranging from first-degree murder with death penalty to acquittal, with reports suggesting jurors were evenly split after four ballots.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 26 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE JURY IS STILL OUT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
After the state's closing denunciation calling him an accomplice to the 'arch fiend,' Lamphere was reassured by counsel and sent to jail, where he ate supper. The jury retired at 6:25 p.m. with six possible verdicts ranging from first-degree murder with death penalty to acquittal, while Judge Richter instructed them on reasonable doubt.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 26 November 1908 · page 1
HELGELEIN MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
After deliberating through the night and into the morning, the jury in the Ray Lamphere murder trial has failed to reach a verdict, with rumors suggesting they are evenly divided. Lamphere stands accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson.
Rock Island Argus · 26 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE JURY UNABLE TO AGREE ON A VERDICT
. Standing. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 2C. Though out all night and having spent several hours this morning in deliberation the jury'in the Gunness murder case is unable to reach an agreement. Con flicting reports are heard outside the jury room but authentic information is uot obtainable. t Laporte, Ind., Nov. 2C. The jury went, to bed at 11 o'clock last night by permission of Judge John C. Hit-liter, without arriving at a verdict re specting the guilt or innocence of Ray Lamphere, accused of the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three chil dren by arson. According to rumors current among the watchers, the jury took four bal lots and were about equally divided;
The jury in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children has deliberated through the night and into the morning without reaching a verdict. No decision has yet been announced.
The Topeka State Journal · 26 November 1908 · page 6
NO VERDICT YET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.
During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney released an anonymous letter claiming Belle Gunness staged her own death by killing a headless female victim and her own children, then fled alive. The writer asserts he helped her escape and that she is still living and recently wrote to him.
Abilene Weekly Reflector · 26 November 1908 · page 6
he had to get out. - "Mrs. Gunness ll alive and well. 1 got letter from her no more then live day age and she hoped Lamphert mrnaiA ha tlMIKfld or Ket life tence, but-1 could not think of him an Innocent man, being co treaiea. "Now 1 tell yon again, Lamphere li Innocent and should be acquitted al once." Hoping that you will see thli! ltte,wll do Jilm some good. I remain Tour tor Justice, LO. M.' Mr. Worden Sunday night said thai he had been trying all day to react th writer by telephone. In order tt have him come to.Laporte Monday tc
At the Ray Lamphere murder trial, witnesses including Daniel Hutson and his daughters testified they saw a veiled woman they believed was Belle Gunness near her farm on July 9, days before the fire, accompanied by a mustached man in a buggy. Hutson, who had helped dig for bodies after the fire, insisted he knew her well enough to recognize her despite not seeing her face.
The Bee · 26 November 1908 · page 7
SAY WOMAN IS NOT DEAD
Laporto, Ind., Nov. 23. Tho sensa tions of Saturday afternoon's session of tho Lamphcre trial were the stories told by Danlol M. Hutson and his daughters, by Fred Ryckm&a and by John Anderson, -who saw a strange woman with Mrs. Qunncss on the Saturday bofore tho fire. Hutson and bis daughters declared on the witness stand that they saw Mrs. Qunness on July 9, but they wero unable to dis tinguish her features through a black velL Hutson, a neighbor of Mrs. Ounness and one of the men engaged by Sheriff Smutzer to dig In the ruins for the bodies at the tlmo of , the fire, de clared he knew Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness so well that bo could not be mistaken. He said; "I saw her on the road near the hogpen July 9. I was returning from town with a hayrack and saw two people at the Gunness place She bad on a light skirt, black waist, wide rimmed hat, a white veil on the hat and a black veil that came to her chin, "There was a man with her. He welched about 145 pounds, and had a gray mustache and gray hair. When I got within two wagon lengths they got into their buggy and drove on and 1 tried, to follow them. They got ahead et me and I did not like to follow then.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The evidence phase of Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by arson has concluded, with attorneys' closing arguments scheduled for today. The case is expected to go to the jury by day's end.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Attorney Worden, defending Ray Lamphere at his La Porte trial, released a letter claiming its anonymous writer accompanied Mrs. Gunness to her farm on July 9, matching a date witnesses reported seeing her leave by buggy. The writer insists Belle Gunness is still alive, contradicting the official belief that she died in the farmhouse fire.
The Alliance Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 2
fewer in number rapidly. Heavier tlve, but Pittsburg reports transac tions smaljqr. Prices are higher, Failures' for the week" number 273. Wheat exports for tho week nggre Rate 5,699,314 bushels. Corn exports for, the week are 239,717 bushols. ' ' Says Mrs. Ounness Is Alive, Attorney Worden, who is defending Hay Lamphure, now on trial at La porte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs, Belle Gunness and her children, made public a letter received' by spe--clal delivery by his law partner, Mayor Darrowv The writer, whoao full name .and address is withheld by Mr.
See moreSee less
Wor den, says he knows that Mrs, Gunness Is alive and declares that he waB the man who accompanied her to the Gun ness farm on July 0, the date on which T. M. Hutson and hla daughters Bay they saw Mrs. Gunness and a man drive away in a buggy.
A woman named Mrs. Minor living in Ogalalla, Nebraska, has been noticed to bear a strong resemblance to the notorious Mrs. Gunness of La Porte, Indiana. The brief item suggests authorities or townspeople are considering whether she could be the fugitive.
Omaha Daily Bee · 26 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A sheriff in Ogallala, Nebraska investigated Mrs. Jennie Minor, who accused a man of murder, and noticed she resembled published photos of Belle Gunness. Further inquiry revealed Minor had a long criminal record and may be the same woman previously detained in Buffalo under suspicion of being the La Porte murderess.
Omaha Daily Bee · 26 November 1908 · page 3
MRS. MINOR LIKE MRS. GUNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wahpeton Times · Wahpeton, N.D.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children is drawing to a close. Another day will see all evidence presented unless something unforeseen occurs.
The Wahpeton Times · 26 November 1908 · page 2
Lamphere Trial Near End
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The jury deliberating the case against Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children has been unable to reach a verdict after deliberating all night and into the morning. Conflicting rumors about the jury's leanings are circulating outside the jury room, but no authentic information is available.
Paper unidentified · 26 November 1908 · page 1
JURY UNABLE TO AGREE CONFLICTING REPORTS ARE HEARD OUTSIDE JURYROOM, NOTHING AUTHENTIC
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
The prosecution presented evidence to establish that Lamphere had been harassing Mrs. Gunness and to pinpoint the timing of the Helgelein murder, which allegedly caused a falling out between the two. Joseph Maxson testified about the fire and his escape, and details emerged about an oil can found displaced in the cellar after the blaze.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 26 November 1908 · page 2
EFFORTS OF PROSECUTION
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
At Ray Lamphere's murder trial in Laporte, Sheriff Smutzer testified about discovering ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness' graveyard and described jewelry and remains sifted from the fire's ashes. Cross-examination by defense attorney Worden failed to shake his testimony, though it revealed Mrs. Gunness had reported Lamphere's harassment to police before her death.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 26 November 1908 · page 5
SHERIFF ON THE STAND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
The jury in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and three children, had not reached a verdict by noon. The case had gone to the jury the previous night.
Albuquerque Citizen · 26 November 1908 · page 1
NO LAMPHERE VERDICT YET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
The jury in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children, has been unable to reach a verdict. Reports indicate the jury stood ten for conviction and two for acquittal after being out since Friday afternoon.
The Evening World · 26 November 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS JURY STILL OUT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children concluded, with the case given to the jury to determine if he started the fire that killed them. After four hours of deliberation without a verdict, the jury was locked up for the night.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 26 November 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS CASE GONE TO JURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio
At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified about his romantic relationship and quarrels with Belle Gunness. They also recounted his threats made against her.
The Greenville Journal · 26 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, witness Louise Gaekle testified she saw an auto pass her window at 3 a.m. on April 28 and saw a red glow from the direction of the Gunness farm. She said she stayed silent until now to avoid being involved, and is the second witness to report seeing the fire at 3 a.m., contradicting the prosecution's claim that Lamphere started the fire at 4 a.m.
The Stark County Democrat · 26 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.
The jury in Ray Lamphere's murder trial for killing Belle Gunness and her three children deliberated through the night without reaching a verdict. They requested additional instructions from Judge Richter, who re-read them in court, with reports indicating a 10-2 split favoring conviction.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 26 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE JURY STILL OUT ASKED FOR ADDITIONAL INSTRUCTIONS AT 11 O'CLOCK WERE BROUGHT INTO COURT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
The 15-day trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children concluded, with the case handed to the jury on November 25. After four hours without a verdict, jurors were locked up for the night.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 26 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
After fifteen days of testimony, closing arguments concluded in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson. The jury began deliberations at 5:30 p.m. but was locked up for the night after four hours without reaching a verdict.
The Salt Lake Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 1
ARGUMENTS CONCLUDED AND CASE OF RAY LAMPHERE GIVEN TO THE JURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
The report describes the judge's twenty-nine paragraph instructions to the jury in the Ray Lamphere trial, emphasizing that he could be convicted of arson even if the victims died differently than alleged, or regardless of whether anyone died from the fire. Six possible verdict forms were given to the jury, ranging from first-degree murder with death penalty to not guilty.
The Salt Lake Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 1
INSTRUCTIONS OF RAY LAMPHERE GIVEN TO THE JURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, witnesses including Daniel Huton and his daughters testified to seeing a veiled Mrs. Gunness on July 9, though they could not identify her features. John Anderson testified he saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness the Saturday before the fire, while Fred Rickman claimed he had been drugged.
Iowa County Democrat · 26 November 1908 · page 3
Strange Woman With Mrs. Gunness
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · and 2 other papers
After the state rested its case against Ray Lamphere in Laporte, Indiana, the defense began presenting witnesses whose testimony challenged the claim that the adult body found in the burned farmhouse ruins was Mrs. Gunness. Attorney Worden made an opening statement to the jury before calling these witnesses.
The Ely Miner · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 26 November 1908
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 27 November 1908
The Daily Alaskan · Skagway, Alaska
A jury in La Porte found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the deaths of Belle Gunness and her three children, sentencing him to twenty years. The report notes Lamphere was believed to have murdered her and burned the house to hide the crime, though the formal conviction was only for arson.
The Daily Alaskan · 27 November 1908 · page 1
HE MURDERED B. GUNNESS
15. 6URHESS (By United Press.) LA PORTE, Nov. 27. ? 1 The Jury In the case of Lamphere, tried on charges of murder and arson result ing in the death of Mrs. Gunnc-ss and tier three children, today' return ed a verdfA of guilty of arson. He was promptly sentenced on two counts to a term of twenty years In the penitentiary. Lamphere was in the employ of the woman Gunness, who Is alleged to have carried on a system of mur der and robbery at her farm near this city causing half a dozen known deaths and suspected of many others. Lamphere is thought to have mur dered her and then fired the house to conceal the crime.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but acquitted of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children; he was sentenced to 2-21 years. The verdict was reportedly a compromise, as some jurors held out for a murder conviction while two blocked it.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 5
RAY LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, rather than murder, and Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in prison, a $5,000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement. The defense called the verdict a compromise and said it would seek a new trial or appeal, while jurors revealed some had pushed for a murder conviction.
Bisbee Daily Review · 27 November 1908 · page 1
ARSON VERDICT IS RETURNED FOR LAMPHERE
Him For Five Years. LAPORTE. Ind., Nov. 26. Ra? Lamphere. charged with the murder of Mrs. Belte Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Qnnness
A La Porte jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson, not murder, for burning the Gunness house, and Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years, a $5000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement. Lamphere maintained his innocence of setting the fire but said he believed the adult body found was Mrs. Gunness.
Arizona Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 1
INDETERMINATE SENTENCE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson and sentenced to two to twenty-one years, fined $5,000, and disfranchised for five years, rather than being convicted of murder. The defense called the verdict ridiculous and announced plans for a new trial motion and possible appeal, while jurors revealed the verdict was a compromise after some held out for a murder conviction.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 27 November 1908 · page 4
RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
After 24 hours of deliberation, the jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson but made no mention of the murder charge regarding Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City, with reports noting two jurors had held out against ten others on alternative findings.
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Ray Lamphere received an indeterminate sentence of two to twenty-two years for arson after being acquitted of murder, with jurors explaining their compromise verdict. The jury issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the body found in the fire was indeed Belle Gunness's.
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 1
2 TO 22 YEARS HIS SENTENCE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in connection with the Gunness farmhouse fire, after jurors deadlocked on murder charges through 19 ballots. He was sentenced to 2-21 years, with two holdout jurors believing Belle Gunness likely poisoned her children and herself before Lamphere set the fire.
The New Haven Union · 27 November 1908 · page 3
Twenty-One Years. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lam phere, the farm hand who has been on trial here for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was found guilty of arson last night and* sentenced by Judge Rltcher to serve from two to 21 years In the penitentiary at Michigan City. The Jury was out 24 hours. Nineteen ballots were taken. • For some time 10 men voted for conviction of murder in the second degree. The arson ver dict was a compromise. It is understood that the two mem bers of the jury who held out against a life sentence, Glasgow and Nelson, entertained what they considered a reasonable doubt as to the manner of the death of the Gunness family.
See moreSee less
Dr. Walter Haines, of Rush Medical col lege, Chicago, had testified that arsenic and strychnine were found in the stom achs. -( The two Jurymen likewise thought it probable that Mrs. Gunness had! murdered her three children and killed herself before Lamphere set the house afire. I
A jury convicted Ray Lamphere of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not of murder, sparing him a harsher sentence; he received 21 years and a $1,000 fine. The verdict also affirmed that the body found in the ruins was that of Belle Gunness, though two jurors held out against any murder or manslaughter conviction.
Ray Lamphere was sentenced to 21 years and fined $1,000 after being found guilty of arson but not murder in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her children. The jury issued a signed statement affirming the body found was Gunness's, while reports revealed two jurors blocked a murder conviction, making the verdict a compromise.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 November 1908 · page 3
SENTENCED TO 21 YEARS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A jury in La Porte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty only of arson for burning the Gunness home, rather than murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years, a $5,000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement, while defense attorney Worden called the verdict ridiculous and vowed to appeal.
The San Francisco Call · 27 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but did not sustain the murder charge against him. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in prison, a $5000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement, while the defense vowed to appeal.
Los Angeles Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON ONLY CHARGE OF MURDER IS NOT SUSTAINED JURY DELIBERATES ON CASE MORE THAN 24 HOURS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Ray Lamphere was sentenced to 2-21 years in Michigan City prison and fined $6000 for arson, with his attorney vowing to appeal. Jurors revealed the verdict was a compromise, as some had pushed for a murder conviction while others held out, and Lamphere maintained his innocence regarding the fire and Helgelein's death.
Los Angeles Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 2
MORE THAN 24 HOURS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by burning the Gunness house, was found guilty of arson after a 24-hour jury deliberation. Judge Richter sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City penitentiary, fined him, and disfranchised him for five years; the verdict was reportedly a compromise after some jurors held out for murder or manslaughter.
New-York Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 2
FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON,
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A brief digest item reports that Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's LaPorte home, but was not held responsible for her death or that of her three children. The item appears among other national and local news briefs of the day.
New-York Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING
Orono. Me.: 2 companion was rescued by other students. — Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the destruction of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness. at LaPorte, Ind. but was not held responsipie for the death of Mrs. Gunness and her th children. ——— The balloon Pittsfield,
A La Porte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's house, but not of murdering her and her three children. Judge Richter sentenced him to 2-21 years in prison, a $500 fine, and five years' disenfranchisement, with jurors revealing the verdict was a compromise after some held out for a murder conviction.
New-York Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 2
FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON,
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A news digest reports that Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's home in LaPorte, Indiana, but was not held responsible for her death or that of her children. The item appears within a broader roundup of domestic and foreign news items for the day.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson but not murder in connection with the Gunness house fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.
Evening Star · 27 November 1908 · page 20
EASY FOR LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson rather than murder, a verdict both the defense attorney and jurors themselves found unsatisfying given the circumstances. Jurors issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the body found in the fire was indeed Belle Gunness, but that the case was decided on a different legal basis entirely.
Evening Star · 27 November 1908 · page 20
JURYMEN EXPLAIN FINDING
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report explains the Lamphere jury's verdict as effectively a reformatory sentence under Indiana law, then recaps the entire Gunness case: the farmhouse fire, discovery of the family's burned bodies, Lamphere's arrest, and the subsequent unearthing of a private graveyard containing ten victims. It also notes public uncertainty over whether Belle Gunness herself died in the fire, citing the gold tooth evidence versus rumors of her being alive.
Evening Star · 27 November 1908 · page 20
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson for burning Belle Gunness's home, was visited by his elderly mother at the Laporte county jail in what was described as likely their final meeting. Mrs. Lamphere, supported by her daughter, embraced her son and tearfully declared she still believes he is innocent.
The Washington Times · 27 November 1908 · page 2
MRS LAMPHERE BIDS HER BOY FAREWELL - Pathetic Meeting Takes Place in Laporte Jail - Still Believes Him Innocent
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Mrs. William Lamphere, mother of convicted arsonist Ray Lamphere, visited her son at the Laporte county jail in an emotional farewell meeting. She declared her belief in his innocence before collapsing and being cared for by Sheriff Smutzer.
The Washington Times · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty only of arson for burning the Gunness home, not of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary, and his attorney vowed to appeal.
The Pensacola Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, though he had been charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2 to 21 years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.
The Daily Gate City · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa
Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children, was found guilty only of arson for burning the Gunness home. He was sentenced to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary, fined $5,000, and disfranchised for five years.
Iowa State Bystander · 27 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE SENT TO THE PEN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson rather than murder after 26 hours of deliberation, with Judge Richter sentencing him to 2-21 years and a $3,000 fine. Despite the lesser charge, all jurors signed a statement affirming their belief that the adult body found in the fire ruins was indeed Mrs. Gunness.
Evening Times-Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 5
GUNNESS JURY IGNORES MURDER CHARGE IN THE LAMPHERE CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
The jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in the Gunness farmhouse fire, not murder, and he was sentenced to Michigan City penitentiary. Afterward Lamphere told reporters he believed the adult female body found in the ruins was indeed Mrs. Gunness, though he maintained his own innocence.
Evening Times-Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 5
SAYS BODY WAS MRS. GUNNESS'
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Judge Richter sentenced Ray Lamphere after the verdict, with little chance of a new trial given his lighter punishment. The jurors signed a statement affirming their belief the adult body found in the fire ruins was Belle Gunness, though they based their decision on a separate charge.
Evening Times-Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 5
SAYS BODY WAS MRS. GUNNESS'
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Dr. Walter S. Haines testified about finding strychnine and arsenic in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness and two children. Meanwhile, a reported sighting of Belle Gunness in Kansas City, based on a fortune teller's claim, was dismissed by police as baseless.
A La Porte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, rather than murder, after deliberating overnight. He was immediately sentenced to 2-21 years, fined $5000, and disfranchised for five years, with the defense vowing to appeal.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 27 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
IS GUILTY OF ARSON
VERDICT OF JURY IN LAMPHERE CASE—GETS FROM 2 TO 21 YEARS IMPRISONMENT, $5000 FINE AND DISFRANCHISED.
See moreSee less
La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house, was found guilty of arson last night by the jury, which had deliberated since 5:30 o'clock the night before. Within five minutes after the verdict the defendant was sentenced to the state prison at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to 21 years, fined $5000 and was disfranchised for five years.
Attorney Worden, for the defense, said that a motion for a new trial would be made, and should it be refused, an appeal to the Indiana supreme court would follow. The Indiana supreme court is two years behind in its work, so this case could not be reached until after he had served the minimum time of his sentence. Mr. Worden declared the verdict to be ridiculous.
"If he was guilty at all," said the attorney, "he was guilty of murder. He should have been acquitted. The motion for a new trial will be based on the judge's instructions that a jury could find Lamphere guilty of arson."
Should the case be carried to the supreme court and sent back for retrial, Lamphere could not be tried on any charge in this particular case except arson, the crime for which he was convicted. However, in an event of that kind the state would elect to try him on one of the indictments, probably the Helgelein case.
Members of the jury are reticent in discussing what occurred in the jury room, but enough has been learned to know that but for two members Lamphere would have been found guilty of murder or manslaughter, the verdict being a compromise. Several members of the jury held out for murder in the first degree, with a life sentence. So far as could be learned none was for hanging.
Ray Lamphere, who had been charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty only of arson by the jury. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.
The Berne Witness · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Ray Lamphere Gets Off with Sentence for Arson. Lapohte, Ind., Nov. 26.—Ray Lam phere, charged with -the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three chil
Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house on April 28, was found guilty of arson by the jury after deliberating since Wednesday evening. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.
The Lake County Times · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson and sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in prison. The same jury ruled that the body recovered from the fire ruins was indeed that of Mrs. Gunness.
The Lake County Times · 27 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's home, and Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to one to twenty-one years in the Michigan City penitentiary. The report also describes an emotional farewell scene between Lamphere and his mother and sister before he was taken to prison.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Judge Richter sentenced Ray Lamphere to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years in state prison for arson, plus a $5,000 fine and five years' disenfranchisement. Defense attorney Worden called the verdict ridiculous and vowed to appeal, while the jurors issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the adult body in the fire ruins was indeed Belle Gunness.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Ray Lamphere, tried for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, was instead found guilty of arson by a compromise jury verdict. He was sentenced to 2-21 years in prison, fined $5,000, and disfranchised for five years, with his attorney planning to appeal.
Rock Island Argus · 27 November 1908 · page 1
IS GUILTY OF ARSON
Talks of Appeal. Attorney' Worden announced this morning he would make a motion Monday before Judge RJchter for a new trial, and upon the same being denied, he expected to perfect an ap peal. The transcript alone in the case will cost over $500, and as Lamphere's family have no means, his friends by subscription have provided for his de fense. The general opinion is the ap peal will never be perfected. Galltr of A moo. LaPorte, Ind.. Nov. 27. "We, the jury, find the defendant guilty of ar son, and that he is 38 years old-!--' This wis" tne Verdict given last night by the jury which tried Ray Lamphere for the murder of the archmurderess, Mrs.
See moreSee less
Belle .Gunness, and her three children at Brookslde farm last spring. Lamphere was sentenced by Judge Richter after tfie verdict had been read to Imprisonment in the peniten tiary at Michigan City for a term of from 2 to 21 years, fined $5,000 and disfranchised for five years, which constitutes the penalty for the crime of arson.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire at Belle Gunness's farm, sentencing him to 2-21 years and a $5,000 fine, but stopped short of a murder conviction. Jurors later revealed the verdict was a compromise, with some believing the body found was indeed Gunness's but still refusing to convict on murder charges.
Rock Island Argus · 27 November 1908 · page 1
IS GUILTY OF ARSON
Verdict Is Compromise. It developed after the conclusion of the' case that the jury, which deliber ated on the case for 24 hours, reached its verdict as a matter of compromise, two members of the jury refusing to convict Lamphere of murder. Thl3 development aroused considerable ex citement and resulted in an unusual proceeding on the part of the members of the jury who signed a statement to the public, which was as follows: "We, the undersigned-jurors, impan eled and . sworn in the case of the state of Indiana vs.
See moreSee less
Ray Lamphere, hereby say that it was our judgment in the consideration of this case that the adult body found in the ruins of the fire was that of Belle Gunness, and that the case was decided by us on an entirely different proposition."
After the verdict, Lamphere maintains that Belle Gunness died in the fire along with the children, and says he has no complaint despite the verdict going against him. His attorneys announce they will seek a new trial, arguing the jury should not have been allowed to convict on arson.
Rock Island Argus · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Will Sek Nfrr Trial. Lamphere's attorneys announced last night that a motion for a nev, 'trial would be made, and that an ap peal to the Indiana supreme court would follow if the new trial were not granted. "The verdict is ridiculous," said At torney Worden, chief of counsel foi the defendant. "If he was guilty a all he was guilty of murder. He should have been acquitted. A motion for n new trial will be made, and it will be based on the ground that the court instructed the jury that it could find Lamphere guilty of arson."
See moreSee less
Should the case go to the supreme court and a retrial be ordered, attor neys declare that Lamphere could not be tried again for murder and that he could be tried for arson only because of the wording of the verdict.
Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children, was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home and causing her death. He was sentenced to an indeterminate prison term, while the defense indicated plans to seek a new trial.
The Cairo Bulletin · 27 November 1908 · page 6
HELD GUILTY OF ARSON RESPONSIBLE FOR BURNING OF GUNNESS HOME, CAUSING WOMAN'S DEATH
La Porte, Intl., Nov. 20. Ray Lam phere, charged with, the murder of Mrs. Belle Ounness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gun ness 'house, April 28, last, was this evening found guilty of arson by the jury which had the case since 5:110 last; evening. Within five minutes at' ter the verdict was reported Judge Richter had sentenced the defendant to the 6tate penitentiary at Michigan City for an iudeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years. He will be taken to Michigan City tomorrow to begin his sentence.
See moreSee less
The court room was packed with people when the jury filed in. Lam phere had. In the meantime, been ' , ... . .. . variablt ': orougni irom tne pan ana was care ,i fully guarded by a detail of bailiffs. The foreman of the jury read the ver dict, but there was no demonstration. Previous to the reading of the verdict Lamphere stated that he wished to make a statement, but the judge re fused to hear it. After the verdict had been read Judge Richter asked Lamphere if he cared to make a statement, but he said that, it would do no good now. He also declined to give any reason why sentence should not be passed. Judge Richter then sentenced him to the state prison in Michigan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years, fined him $3,000 and disfranchised him for five year. Lamphere was then returned to Jail. The attorneys fo rthe defense stat ed tonight that a motion for a new trial would be made and if refused an appeal would be taken to the su-
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, which killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at Michigan City penitentiary, plus a fine and disfranchisement.
The Cairo Bulletin · 27 November 1908 · page 6
Lamphere stated that he wished to make a statement, but the judge re fused to hear it. After the verdict had been read Judge Richter asked Lamphere if he cared to make a statement, but he said that, it would do no good now. He also declined to give any reason why sentence should not be passed. Judge Richter then sentenced him to the state prison in Michigan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years, fined him $3,000 and disfranchised him for five year. Lamphere was then returned to Jail. The attorneys fo rthe defense stat ed tonight that a motion for a new trial would be made and if refused an appeal would be taken to the su-
Following the Lamphere trial, jurors issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the adult body found in the fire ruins was indeed Belle Gunness, though they based their verdict on a different legal point. Lamphere himself maintained his innocence regarding the arson while stating his confidence that the body was hers.
The Cairo Bulletin · 27 November 1908 · page 6
! Urn aritJi fall afirvctiama, 10. mrJ ja hour. preme court. LamplionIn n statement tonight saie) that he waconfident that th-; dead bdy iu the fire was Mrs. Gun ness. regardless of what other people may think. He reiterated his Inno cence of setting ftre to the house. Tonicht all the member ofthe jury issue,! a sienet statement in wbirh they declare It was their 'Judement in consideration of this case that th,' adult body found In the ruins of the fire was that of Itelle Gunness, an I that the case was deride,) by ns on an entirely different proposition."
See moreSee less
It Is stated ttntirht that ten Ju.-- or favored life sentence; also that one tf the Jurors said that thr-v would have found him piilty of manslaugh ter had they rnuembered that the sentence for that was the same as tor at win.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, though not of the murders themselves. Judge Richter promptly sentenced him to 2 to 21 years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.
The Topeka State Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
FROM 2 TO 21 YEARS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Ray Lamphere's defense attorney announced plans for a new trial motion and possible appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court after his conviction. The jury's signed statement confirmed their belief that the body found in the fire was Belle Gunness, while Lamphere himself maintained his innocence regarding arson but claimed confidence in the body's identity.
The Topeka State Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
FROM 2 TO 21 YEARS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
At Laporte, Indiana, Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's house on April 28th, but was acquitted of murdering her and her three children. The report calls this a 'funny verdict.'
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 3
At Laporte, Ind., Ray Lam phere,,charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house April 28th, was found
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, though he had also been charged with killing Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter sentenced him immediately to two to twenty-one years at Michigan City, fined him $5,000, and disfranchised him for five years, while his attorney vowed to appeal.
The Detroit Times · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE BEGINS SENTENCE IN PRISON LAMPHERE IS FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON—WAS CHARGED ALSO WITH KILLING MRS. GUNNESS AND CHILDREN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Judge Richter sentenced Ray Lamphere to prison, fined him $5,000, and disenfranchised him for five years after his arson conviction in the Gunness case. The jury clarified they believed the body in the ruins was Belle Gunness's, and defense attorney Worden vowed to seek a new trial or appeal.
The Detroit Times · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
After 24 hours of deliberation, a La Porte jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, though he had also been charged with murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City, fined him $6,000, and disfranchised him for five years; his lawyer vowed to appeal.
The Detroit Times · 27 November 1908 · page 2
PRISONER IS FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON—WAS CHARGED ALSO WITH KILLING MRS. GUNNESS AND CHILDREN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
St. Paul Tidende · St. Paul, Minn.
The report covers the ongoing trial of Ray Lamphere in La Porte, Indiana, accused of being complicit in Mrs. Gunness's crimes and of killing her and her children by burning down the house. While early testimony seemed to confirm Lamphere's guilt, defense witnesses later suggested Gunness herself set the fire, beheaded a victim to fake her own death, and was seen alive afterward, including returning to dig up buried valuables.
St. Paul Tidende · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Gunness Mordsagen
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
The jury in Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children has deliberated all night without reaching a verdict. Conflicting rumors circulate outside the jury room, but no official information is available.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 27 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Greene County Herald · Leakesville, Miss.
During Roy Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney released a letter purportedly from a man who said he accompanied Belle Gunness to her farm on July 9, claiming she is alive. The defense was trying to locate the writer to testify before the case went to the jury.
Greene County Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not guilty of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years and a $5,000 fine, while the defense called the verdict contradictory and vowed to appeal.
The Billings Gazette · 27 November 1908 · page 1
SENTENCED BY JUDGE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
At the Ray Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, Dr. Walter Haines of Rush Medical College testified that he found arsenic and strychnine in stomach samples sent to him by the coroner, including the stomach of Andrew Helgelein. He stated the amount of poison present was roughly three times a lethal dose, with closing arguments expected the following day.
The Billings Gazette · 27 November 1908 · page 3
ARGUMENTS IN LAMPHERE CASE TO BE MADE TODAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.
Sheriff Beat examined records of Mrs. Jennie Minor, noting her striking resemblance to published pictures of Belle Gunness, the La Porte murderess. Inquiry revealed she had a long criminal record and was believed to be the woman previously arrested in Buffalo on suspicion of being Gunness, though released after investigation.
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Resembles Mrs. Gunness.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson for burning the Gunness house where Belle Gunness and her three children died, was sentenced to 2-21 years and taken to Michigan City prison to begin his term. The jury had deliberated over 24 hours, with some members favoring first-degree murder with a life sentence instead.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE BEGINS SERVING TIME, Given Indeterminate Term of From 2 to 21 Years, JURY IS OUT OVER 24 HOURS, Agreement Is Something of a Compromise
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney Worden released a letter claiming its anonymous writer knew Mrs. Gunness was alive and had accompanied her away from the farm on July 9. The letter's claims matched a sighting reported by D.M. Hutson and his daughters of a woman and man driving away in a buggy.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Says Mrs. Gunness Is Alive.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson began, with a jury secured and Coroner Mack as the first witness. Prosecutor Smith outlined the state's case, citing Indiana law on fire-caused deaths and promising evidence of Lamphere's threats and hatred toward Gunness.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE PLACED ON TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
Prosecutor Smith details the state's theory that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, causing the deaths of its occupants, which under law constitutes first-degree murder. He describes evidence including Lamphere's alleged statements, his movements on the night of the fire, and his reaction upon arrest.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A jury in LaPorte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home, though he had been charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter sentenced him within minutes to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.
Omaha Daily Bee · 27 November 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON Jury Returns Verdict After Deliberation Lasting Over Twenty-Four Hours.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A jury convicted Ray Lamphere of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home, not murder of Belle Gunness and her children. He was immediately sentenced to one to twenty-one years in the Indiana state penitentiary, and his attorney vowed to appeal, arguing the verdict was inconsistent.
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 1
After Being Out 24 Hours Jury Convicts Lamphere of Arson He Is Immediately Sentenced to From Two to 20 Years in Pen If He Burned Mrs. Gunness and Children It Was Murder
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.
A La Porte jury acquitted Ray Lamphere of murdering Belle Gunness and her children but convicted him of arson for burning the Gunness house. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.
The Evening Times · 27 November 1908 · page 1
La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle .Gunness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gun ness house, April 28, was yesterday
Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her home, was found guilty only of arson and sentenced to two to twenty-one years in state prison. His attorney called the verdict ridiculous, arguing Lamphere should have been acquitted or convicted of murder, and vowed to appeal.
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE BIDS MEETING OF MOTHER AND SON, CONVICTED YESTERDAY OF ARSON, WAS PATHETIC
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty only of arson for setting fire to Belle Gunness's house, not murder, and was sentenced to 21 years plus a $5,000 fine. His attorney called the verdict absurd, while Lamphere stated he believed the body in the fire was Mrs. Gunness's and denied setting the fire, though he admitted seeing it that night.
LAMPHERE'S LIFE IS SAVED Convicted Only of Arson in the Gunness Murder Trial - Gets 21 Years.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
After Ray Lamphere's conviction, his attorney calls the verdict illogical and vows to appeal, while Lamphere himself affirms he believes the body found in the fire was Belle Gunness's. The jury issues a signed statement confirming they accepted the body was Gunness's but decided the case on another basis, revealing the verdict was a compromise after some jurors pushed for a murder conviction.
A La Porte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in a compromise verdict, and he was sentenced to 21 years in the penitentiary. Lamphere had been charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house.
The Roswell Daily Record · 27 November 1908 · page 1
TWENTY-ONE YEARS IN PRISON FOR LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
A Laporte jury reached a compromise verdict, finding Ray Lamphere guilty of arson rather than murder in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her three children, sentencing him to two to twenty-one years. Lamphere was taken to Michigan City prison, and his attorney announced plans to seek a new trial or appeal.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
The report states that authorities have declared the adult body recovered from the farmhouse ruins to be that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, addressing ongoing doubts about her death. Garbled fragments also reference a conviction on an arson charge, suggesting parallel legal proceedings against a suspect.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson rather than murder in the Belle Gunness case, after a jury deadlocked for 24 hours and took 19 ballots before reaching a compromise verdict. He was sentenced to 2-21 years in prison, with some jurors reportedly doubting the manner of the Gunness family's deaths, believing she may have poisoned her children and herself before Lamphere set the fire.
The Sun · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY Of Arson, Not Murder, Compromise Verdict by Disagreeing Jurymen
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
A jury in Laporte found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home, where Belle Gunness and her three children died. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in prison, fined him $5000, and disfranchised him for five years, though an appeal was planned.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 27 November 1908 · page 1
OP ; (Associated Press.) LAPORTE (Ind.), Nov. 26. Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness home, was this evening found guilty of arson by the Jury which had the case since 5:30 last night. Within five minutes after the verdict was reported, Judge Rlchter had sentenced the defendant to the state prison at Michigan City, to . . . serve an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years, fined htm for $5000, and disfranchised him for five years. An appeal , will be taken. v . A FAST RELAY ' Associated Press.) V SAN JOSE (Cal.). Nov. 26. Sixty-one SECRET OFPABTY mm NEW YORK. Nov. 26. Governor
The state rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere at Laporte, Indiana, and the defense began with a statement by Attorney Worden. Several witnesses testified suggesting the adult body found in the burned farmhouse ruins was not that of Mrs. Gunness.
The Mahoning Dispatch · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio
At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified about his love affair and quarrels with Belle Gunness. They also described threats Lamphere had made against her.
Perrysburg Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but acquitted him of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children; he was immediately sentenced to two to twenty-one years in state prison. Jurors revealed the verdict was a compromise, as some had favored a murder or manslaughter conviction, while defense attorney Worden announced plans to appeal.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 27 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
Jurors reveal that several members initially favored a first-degree murder conviction with life sentence, but Lamphere was ultimately not found guilty of murder or manslaughter. The jury issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the body found in the fire ruins was Belle Gunness, though the case was decided on a different legal basis. Lamphere himself stated he was confident the body was Mrs. Gunness and maintained his innocence regarding the fire and Helgelein's murder.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 27 November 1908 · page 4
In the nilns of tno fire wns that of lielle Gunness and tlint tho case was decided by us on an entirely 'Hfferent proposition." MILL OWWEKS MAY
The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.
Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house in April, was found guilty of arson by a jury in La Porte. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at Michigan City prison.
The Chickasha Daily Express · 27 November 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE IS FOUND GUILTY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Weekly Chieftain · Vinita, Okla.
A letter signed "Mrs. Belle Gunness" was sent to Attorney Worden claiming she could be found at Michigan City, warning him not to attempt her arrest or she would kill him. Meanwhile, the defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial began presenting its final evidence, expecting to rest its case that evening.
The Weekly Chieftain · 27 November 1908 · page 1
i.; . ... .. i.. ... i . i . ... , I, " in in. inin n.ini uie riemuv oi in person, who sent to Attorney Worden. today, from Michigan City, a letter Signed "Mrs. Hctle Gunness" declaring that Mrs. Gunness would be found at Michigan City, at the address given in the letter." The communication concludes as follows; "If you attempt to have me arrested I will kill you. Come nt 10:30 o'clock and come alone. Call for Mrs. McConnell," The defense in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the nlleged murder, of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, began today the intro duction of final bits of evidence in behalf of the prisoner, the expectation being that the defense would rest its case tonight
Judge Richter ruled that if evidence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, the jury must convict him of arson even if the fire did not cause anyone's death. The case was expected to go to the jury that afternoon.
The Weekly Chieftain · 27 November 1908 · page 1
HANDS OF THE JURY By Associated Press La Porte. Ind.. Nov. 25 The state scored a big victory today in the Lamphere trial, when Judge Richter afte. exhaustive argument by both sides announced that he would instruct the jury that if the evi dence showed Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house even if the fire did not cause the death of any people therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. It is expected that the case will go to the jury this afternoon-
The state rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children. Defense attorney Worden opened by claiming the evidence will show Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
The Weekly Chieftain · 27 November 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not guilty of murdering Belle Gunness and her children, accepting a theory that poison was used instead. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at Michigan City prison.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 27 November 1908 · page 1
RAY LAMPHERE GETS INDETERMINATE SENTENCE TWO TO TWENTY-ONE YEARS The Poison Theory In the Gunness Home Is Upheld by Jury and the Poisoner Escapes the Murder Charge
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson but acquitted of murder in the Belle Gunness case, was taken to Michigan City to begin an indeterminate sentence of two to twenty-one years plus a $5000 fine. The defense has apparently decided not to seek a new trial, and it is believed Lamphere may seek parole after serving the minimum term.
Daily Capital Journal · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE BEGINS HIS SENTENCE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
Ray Lamphere, the hired man convicted of burning the Gunness farmhouse, was taken to Michigan City to begin an indeterminate prison sentence. The report notes his prior employment by Belle Gunness and the deaths of her three children.
East Oregonian : E.O · 27 November 1908 · page 1
La Porte, Ind Nov. 27. Hay Lamphere. the hired man, who wuh employed by Mm. Belle Gunness and who was convicted of firing the Gunness homestead waH employed by Mrs. Hello ness nnd her three children, was taken to Michigan City today to nerve an indeterminate sentence.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in connection with the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children, receiving an indeterminate 2-to-21-year sentence. The defense called the verdict ridiculous, arguing he should have been acquitted if not guilty of murder, and announced plans to seek a new trial or appeal.
The Morning Astorian · 27 November 1908 · page 1
THE VERDICT A COMPROMISE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Le Progrès · Woonsocket, R.I.
A jury in Laporte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness farm, but did not convict him of murdering Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.
Le Progrès · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LE DRAME DE LAPORTE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Ray Lamphere, sentenced to two to twenty-one years, was taken to the Michigan City state prison after being found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home. He had been tried for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children but was convicted only of arson.
The News-Democrat · 27 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Aberdeen Democrat · Aberdeen, South Dakota
Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty only of arson and immediately sentenced to two to twenty-one years in state prison. His attorney called the verdict contradictory and announced plans to seek a new trial or appeal.
The Aberdeen Democrat · 27 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE GIVEN TERM IN PRISON
Trial. Is .Not, Granted. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 26. Ray Lamph-ere, charged with the mur derof Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gunness house on April 28, was this evening found guilty of arson by the jury, which has had the case since 5:30 o'clock last evening. Within five minutes after the verdict was re ported, Judge Richter had sentenced the defendant to the state peniten tiary at Michigan City for an inde trminate term of from two to twen ty-one years, Lamphere will be taken to Michigan City to-uiorrow to begin his sentencel The Verdict was reached within half an hour after the jurors had returned from supper.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worden of the defense said to-night that a motion for a new trial would be made, and should it be refused an appeal to the In diana supreme court will follow. Mr. Worden declared the verdict to be ridiculous. If he was guilty at all," said the attorney, "he would have been guilty of murder. He should have mm
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.
The evidence phase of Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children has concluded, with jury instructions being prepared. Closing arguments from attorneys are expected to begin the following morning.
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 27 November 1908 · page 1
READY FOR ARGUMENTS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.
At trial, the sheriff testified that Ray Lamphere told him he had intended to plead guilty to arson but changed his mind because of his mother. The sheriff also recounted catching Lamphere in lies about his whereabouts on the night of the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children.
The Columbia Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 11
HAD INTENDED TO ADMIT ARSON LAMPHERE ON CHARGE FOR MURDER OF MRS. GUNNESS, SO STATED - TESTIMONY OF THE SHERIFF
TESTIMONY Of THE SHERIFF Story of Alleged Murderer's ConfesRl nad come to LaPorte early that sion is Told on Witness even ng on the street car with George Stand. LAPORTE, Ind.. Nov. 19. "I Intend ed to plead guilty to arson, but on account of my mother, decided not to do it." These words were spoken by Ray Is the feature of the testimony of the end of the afternoon session, uary H in Michigan City, had slept there all night. This, I later found ut to be an untruth, as I learned that Vright.
See moreSee less
Ray got off at the power lioiipe. I then went to Lamphere at the suggestion that he would have saved himself a lot of trouble. This is mpposed to have been the night of Oct. 14, I asked Ray if he denied he had caught Mrs. Gunness trying to kill Helgelein. He did not deny, but said It would not be fair to his lawyers to talk about it." Sheriff Amistiss will be recalled to the stand tomorrow. It is believed the confession which Lamphere is said to have made .will be Introduced.
At Lamphere's trial, a witness recounts remarks made weeks earlier in which Lamphere reportedly said he was certain Belle Gunness had killed Helgelien but was unsure about the house fire. The witness also describes seeing Belle Gunness and her three children arriving in LaPorte.
The Columbia Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 11
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Sheriff Amistiss testifies that Lamphere told him details about visiting Belle Gunness before the fire and admitted knowledge of her attempt to kill Helgelein, though he denied certainty about arson. Amistiss says he will be recalled to the stand and Lamphere's confession may be introduced as evidence.
The Columbia Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 11
tion as between state-wide prohibition j death. and local option, he having been an Amistiss related an interview which ardent advocate of Carmack's candi-lhe had with Lamphere in the jail cell dacy on the state-wide prohibition j the night of the arrest. Lamphere platform. He says: "In answer to The Tennessean edi-j torial of the IStn I call our aUeiitioU to the appended ajticle, published in; the Sullivan County Developer of Sept. said: "I went to Nigger Lize's house about 10 o'clock on the night before the fire. I carried a few bottles of beer and a couple of pounds of meat to the wo
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children, though not of murder, and was sentenced to an indeterminate term at Michigan City prison. Lamphere stated he believed the body found in the burned house was indeed Mrs. Gunness, while his attorneys argued the verdict was inadequate given what they saw as clear murder.
Palestine Daily Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE IS SATISFIED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Waxahachie Daily Light · Waxahachie, Tex.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term at the state penitentiary in Michigan City.
The Waxahachie Daily Light · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray ! Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gun- ■' ness house April 28, was yesterday ! evening found guilty of arson by the , jury, which had the ^ase since 5:30 " o'clock Wednesday evening. Within <ive minu*<"« 'TLer the verI diet was reaches '#udge Hichter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an Indeterminate terni. Lamphere will' be taken there at once to begin his sentence. — " Thé verdict was returned within half an hour after the jurors had returned from supper.
See moreSee less
The lights in the big court room were turned on and within fifteen minutes the room was packed. Lamphere was brought over from the jail and at 7:20 o'clock the jury Uled Into the court room and took its place in the jury box. Deputy Sheriff Antiss sat directly back of Lamphere and three bailiffs watched — ' him closely. There was no demonstration from the crowd when the verdict was read —the people having been warned to keep quiet.
Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty only of arson and sentenced to 2-21 years at Michigan City prison. His attorney announced plans to seek a new trial, and jurors revealed two members had blocked a murder or manslaughter conviction.
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1908 · page 1
WILL ASK FOR NEW TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah
Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning their home, was instead found guilty of arson by the jury after deliberating since 9:30pm. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in Michigan City prison, a $5,000 fine, and disfranchisement, while his attorney vowed to appeal, calling the verdict illogical since Lamphere should have been acquitted if not guilty of murder.
Deseret Evening News · 27 November 1908 · page 11
RAY LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON
EOLFIVCVCftVS 1 J t Laporle Intl Nov 26 Hay mm phere cluirged with the minder of Mr 1Bcllo Gunness and hoi tin op chllldrei by setting1 the to the Gunness horn
After Ray Lamphere's conviction for arson (not murder), his attorney calls the verdict illogical, and jurors reveal they compromised after a split between those favoring murder and arson charges. A signed juror statement affirms their belief that the adult body found in the fire ruins was indeed Belle Gunness's.
Deseret Evening News · 27 November 1908 · page 11
adult body In the fire was that of Mrs Gunness He roltoiatoa hUt Innocence In the niattoroV bQttlng Die to the house though admitting that ho was on the road and viw the lire that night tle nlho declared that he did not see Mrs Gunnossj kill Hclegein I have no complaint to make abput tho ver dict Things looked pretty blue but thoverdlct might have been woiso Tpnlghf airaiie rriembeiror the jury made thefolllowlng signed stajement We the undersigned juiprs im paneled and sworn In thsscase of the stxte of Indiana veisusJlayLamphere hereby ay that ltwnsour judgment In fhei consideration of this eibo that tho adult body found in tho ruins of thoillro was that of Belle Gunner and that the COBG Was decided by us on an enliioly different proposition P
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, rather than murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter sentenced him to an indeterminate two-to-twenty-one year term and a $5000 fine, while the defense vowed to appeal.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 1
GUILTY FOUND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Attorney Worden calls the arson verdict for Ray Lamphere ridiculous, arguing he should have been acquitted or convicted of murder. The jury reveals their verdict was a compromise and issues a signed statement affirming their belief that the adult body in the fire ruins was Belle Gunness, though decided on different grounds.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, though he had been tried for the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in state prison, a $3,000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement, while the defense announced plans to appeal.
The Salt Lake Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 3
RAY LAMPHERE PLAYS IN LUCK
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Jurors reveal that the verdict against Ray Lamphere was a compromise, with some holding out for first-degree murder while others favored a lesser charge; all agreed the adult body in the fire was Belle Gunness. Lamphere himself stated he was confident the body was Mrs. Gunness but denied witnessing her kill Helgelein or setting the fire himself.
The Salt Lake Herald · 27 November 1908 · page 3
SENTENCE WAS TWO TO TWENTY-ONE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not guilty of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at Michigan City, while his attorney vowed to appeal, calling the compromise verdict illogical.
The Times Dispatch · 27 November 1908 · page 1
GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire at Belle Gunness's farm, but did not reach a verdict on the murder charges regarding Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.
The Barre Daily Times · 27 November 1908 · page 1
JURY DECIDES HE IS GUILTY
Laporte, Ind., Nor. 87. -While tha church bells were rbglng for Thanks giving services last evening the jury in the case of Bay Lamphere, charged with arson and the murder of Mrs. Bella Gunness and her children, an- - nounccd its agreement that the prison er was guilty of arson. Tho murder charge was not mentioned in the ver- , diet. " The jury .has lad the ease under con sideration for twenty-four Jioirrs. With-' in ftje minutes afVer the verdict was reported Judga Richer sentenced tha defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twenty one years.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, rather than murder, and sentenced to one to 21 years in state prison plus a $5,000 fine. His attorney called the verdict ridiculous and vowed to appeal, though the backlogged supreme court docket would likely outlast Lamphere's minimum sentence.
The Spokane Press · 27 November 1908 · page 2
WHERE SENT TO PRISON
TO PRISON LA PORTE, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the mur der of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, was last night found guilty of arson and sentenced to state's prison for from one to 21 years. He was also fined $5,000 and disfranchised for five years. The case had been with the jury since 5:30 o'clock Wednesday evening. Lamphere's attorney made a statement in which he declared he would immediately prepare a nio-
Ray Lamphere, the hired man who worked for Belle Gunness, was taken to Michigan City to begin an indeterminate sentence. The report states he was convicted of setting fire to the Gunness homestead and of burning to death Mrs. Gunness and her three children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Evening Statesman · 27 November 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Goes to Jail.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A sheriff in Ogallala, Nebraska investigated Mrs. Jennie Minor after noting her striking resemblance to published pictures of Belle Gunness. Inquiry revealed Minor had a criminal record with police in several western and eastern cities, leading to speculation she might be the woman arrested in New York on suspicion of being Gunness.
The Laramie Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 1
WOMEN RESEMBLE.
Like Belle Gun nets. Dgallala, Neb., Nov. 27. —Sheriff fc°al of this city has been examining the record of Mrs. Jennie Minor, who charge that John Dale Smith, who is believed to be her husband, killed Vol ley Mann near Ogallala, A striking ’’eseniblance between the woman and the published pictures of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the La Porte murderess, was Boted. Careful inquiry that followed releaved that Mrs. Minor has a long with the police of numerous
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, which killed Belle Gunness and her three children. He was immediately sentenced to 2-21 years in prison, fined $5,000, and sent to Michigan City penitentiary the same day.
The Laramie Republican · 27 November 1908 · page 1
IS GUILTY OF ARSON
Taken to Penitentiary. Lamphere was taken to prison in Michigan City this afternoon. Before his departure he was visited by his mother, who wept in his arms. A mo tion for new trial will be made, and If it is denied, Attorney Worden has announced that he would appeal the case.
A newspaper opinion column notes that because Mrs. Gunness's body was never found and her death was proven only by circumstantial evidence, this likely saved Ray Lamphere from a murder conviction. The jury instead found him guilty of burning the house and the bodies of the children.
The Daily Alaskan · 28 November 1908 · page 2
The faot that the body o f Mrs. Gunness was not found, that the fact that she was really dearf was estab lished only by circumstantial evi dence, probably saved the neck of the man Lamphere whom the Jury was convinc?d burned the house and her body and those of her children. Twenty years of quiet he will have to think It over. If there are gold nuggets lying round on the beach for geese to eat Is it not pretty good demonstration of the truth that lies under the faith of those mining optimists that have always declared we would yet have a mine in Skagway?
See moreSee less
When Uncle Joe says he believes the tariff will be revised this next session it sounds like a confession that he has grown Impotent. Emperor William needs an editor.
Ray Lamphere, accused of burning Mrs. Gunness's home, was found guilty of arson and sentenced to two to twenty-one years in prison plus a fine. He still faces separate murder charges in the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and three children, and his attorneys have demanded a new trial.
The Ketchikan Miner · 28 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska
A jury in Laporte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home after a trial in which he was also accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children. He was sentenced to not less than two nor more than twenty years in prison.
Seward Daily Gateway · 28 November 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Guilty of Arson
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Guard · Batesville, Ark.
Ray Lamphere was found guilty of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and sentenced to an indeterminate term at Michigan City penitentiary. The defense argued the remains found were not Mrs. Gunness's but planted by her to fake her death, and announced plans to appeal.
The Daily Guard · 28 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Ray Lamphere, sentenced for arson at Belle Gunness's home, was delivered to Michigan City state prison and processed into custody. He expressed relief at avoiding a life sentence, and it emerged he felt his spiritual adviser Dr. Schell had betrayed confidence by revealing he'd made a confession.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 28 November 1908 · page 1
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in burning Belle Gunness's home, was transported to prison in an automobile. Upon arrival he was processed, photographed, measured, and issued a prison uniform.
Arizona Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
RAY LAMPHERE GOES TO THE PEN IN STYLE He Is in a Position to Choose the Kind of Clothes HeWants. La Porte, Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, convicted of having set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, went to prison in style today. He rode from the interurban station to the prison gate in an automobile. Stepping up to the window of Chief Clerk Lorimer, the sheriff handed that official the commitment papers and the prisoner's name was entered upon the register. He was assigned number 4140 and then passed along to the receiving clerk, who escorted him to the Bertillion room.
See moreSee less
There he was given a bath, photographed, measured and garbed in a prison suit of grey, the middle grade. Upon his future conduct depends whether he will be given stripes or a better grade of blue suit.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home, was transported to the Indiana state prison in an automobile. He was processed, photographed, measured, and given a gray prison uniform, with future conduct determining whether he'd receive stripes or a better grade of clothing.
Los Angeles Herald · 28 November 1908 · page 3
LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON SEATED IN AN AUTOMOBILE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Gazette · Cleveland, Ohio
At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, after the state rested its case, the defense began with a statement by Attorney Worden and witness testimony. The witnesses' evidence aimed to disprove that the adult body found in the farmhouse ruins was that of Mrs. Gunness.
The Gazette · 28 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Ocala Evening Star · Ocala, Fla.
A jury in Laporte, Indiana convicted Ray Lamphere of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home, but did not convict him of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the state penitentiary, while defense attorney Worden called the verdict ridiculous, arguing Lamphere should have been fully acquitted if not guilty of murder.
The Ocala Evening Star · 28 November 1908 · page 8
G A Nadi Mayor RAY LA WHERE CONVICTED Escaped Charge of Killing Mrs Gun ness But Found Guilty of Arson Laporte Ind Nov SRay Lam phere charged with arson and the murder of Mrs Belle Gunnes and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness home on April 28 wan found which had the case under considera tion for twentyfour hours Within five minutes after the verdict was reported Judge Richter sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twentyone years Attorney Worden for the defense declared the verdict to be ridiculous If he was guilty at all said he he was guilty of murder He should have been acquitted If you suffer from constipation and liver trouble Foleys Orino Laxative will cure you permanently by stimu lating the digestive organs so they will act naturally Foleys Orino Lax ative does not gripe is pleasant to take and you do not have to take lax atives continually after taking Orino Why continue to be the slave of pills and tablets Solrf by all druggists
Rev. Edward Schell, new president of Wesleyan University, discussed a confession reportedly made to him by Lamphere, who is charged with killing Mrs. Gunness at Laporte, Ind. Schell claims Lamphere admitted to murdering the woman and her children, though he declines to elaborate further.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Evening Times-Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE GUILTY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson after 26 hours of deliberation, a compromise verdict after most jurors initially favored second-degree murder; Judge Richter sentenced him to 2-21 years and a $5,000 fine. Jurors signed a statement affirming their belief that the adult body found with three children's remains was Mrs. Gunness, a belief Lamphere himself now shared despite maintaining his own innocence.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 28 November 1908 · page 1
CONVICTED OF MAIN CHARGE GUNNESS JURY FINDS PRISONER GUILTY OF ARSON AND JUDGES GIVE HIM TWO TO TWENTY-ONE YEAR SENTENCE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A filler item expresses hope that Indiana and Laporte have heard the last of the Gunness case, unless Sheriff Smutzer decides to dig up the cement floor again. It reflects public weariness with the ongoing investigation into the farm.
The Lake County Times · 28 November 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of burning the Gunness farmhouse, made statements while being transported to prison that seemed close to a confession. He expressed bitterness toward a minister he trusted, claiming the man betrayed his confidence.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 28 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE CLOSE TO A CONFESSION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Sheriff Smutzer suggests Lamphere withheld a full confession because his light sentence gave him hope of early release. Lamphere complains about a preacher betraying his trust and refuses to explain a mysterious incident involving a hole bored in a partition at the Gunness house, blaming whisky for his involvement with Mrs. Gunness.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 28 November 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
After entering prison on Nov. 27, Ray Lamphere made statements to reporters, denying he'd said he burned the house and would confess, insisting he goes to prison with a clear conscience. The article also recaps how Tuesdays marked key Gunness case discoveries (fire, bodies, rings, dental work) while Fridays marked milestones in Lamphere's trial.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 28 November 1908 · page 2
A HOODOO DAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home, though not of murdering Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in prison, a $5,000 fine, and disfranchisement for five years.
The Winchester News · 28 November 1908 · page 7
been acquitted The motion for a 1 new trial will be baaed on the courts Instructions that they could find Lamphere guilty of arson Should the case be carried to the supreme court and sent back for re trial Lamphere could not be tried on any charge in this particular case ex cepting arson the crime of which he was convicted However in an event of that kind the state would elect to try him on one of the other indict ments probably the Helgelein case
The jury in the Roy Lamphere trial at Laporte, Ind., found him guilty of arson but did not address the murder charge regarding Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 28 November 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the Gunness house fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children, was transported from Laporte to the state prison in Michigan City under a 2-to-21-year sentence. Before leaving, he received a visit from his aged mother.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 28 November 1908 · page 12
CONDENSED DISPATCHES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.
Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified at the Laporte trial that Ray Lamphere made damaging admissions amounting to a partial confession. He reportedly admitted to setting fire to Mrs. Belle Gunness's home on the morning of April 28.
The L'anse Sentinel · 28 November 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Semi-Weekly Leader · Brookhaven, Miss.
A jury convicted Ray Lamphere of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term at the Michigan City penitentiary.
The Semi-Weekly Leader · 28 November 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Convicted of Arson.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A local news column from Mayville, N.D. mentions that a traveling troupe presented moving pictures depicting the murders at the Gunness farm. The report is a brief aside within a broader roundup of local town news and events.
Paper unidentified · 28 November 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in connection with the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children, was taken to Michigan City state prison after a tearful farewell visit from his mother. He received an indeterminate two-to-twenty-one-year sentence and his attorney planned to seek a new trial or appeal.
The Madison Daily Leader · 28 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON Given indeterminate Term on Convifr tion for Arson. L&porte, Ind., 'Nov. 28.—Before Say Lamphere, under sentence from two to twenty-one years, was taken to the state prison in Mictigan City to be gin his term he received a visit from his aged mother. Though not with him during the trial she came here fiom South Bend in order to say good bye to bim and cheer him up. The meeting of mother and son was a pathetic one, the mother breaking down and crying as she clasped her son in her arms.
See moreSee less
The prisoner bore up well, though there was a mistiness about his eyes. Later in the day Lamphere was taken to prison. In a statement be said that he intended to become an exemplary prisoner so as to get the benefit of all good time and would be paroled after his first two years. Lamphere, who was charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson by the Jury after it had been out about twenty four hours. Attorney Worden of the defense said that a motion for a new trial would be made and, should it be re fused, an appeal to the Indiana su preme court would follow. The In diana supreme court is two years be hind in its work and so this ise could not be reached until after he had served the minimum time of his sentence.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson, not murder, for setting fire to the Gunness home where Belle Gunness and her three children died. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term in state prison and a $5,000 fine, with jurors reporting the verdict was a compromise after some held out for a murder conviction.
The Utah County Democrat · 28 November 1908 · page 4
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home, was transported to Indiana State Prison in Michigan City and processed as inmate No. 4140. His mother visited him briefly before he was taken inside, and he maintained composure despite her tears.
The Salt Lake Herald · 28 November 1908 · page 6
DOORS CLOSE ON LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Free Lance · Fredericksburg, Va.
Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children and with setting fire to her house on April 28, was found guilty only of arson after lengthy jury deliberation. Judge Richter sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the Michigan City penitentiary, with a fine and disfranchisement.
The Free Lance · 28 November 1908 · page 3
LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Sheriff Beal in Ogallala, Nebraska examined the record of Mrs. Jennie Minor, whose husband is accused of murder, after noting her resemblance to published photos of Belle Gunness. Investigation revealed Minor had a long criminal record and may be the same woman previously held in Buffalo on suspicion of being the LaPorte murderess.
The Laramie Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 1
WOMEN RESEMBLE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
In the Ray Lamphere trial at LaPorte, Indiana, Judge Richter announced he would instruct the jury that setting fire to the Gunness house constitutes arson regardless of whether the fire caused deaths. The judge also added instructions that if any of the four persons in the house died as a result of the fire Lamphere set, the jury must find him guilty of murder or manslaughter.
The Laramie Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 8
State Makes Another Hit. LaPorte, Ind Nov. 25.—The state scored a victory today in the Lamphere trial, when Judge Richter, after ex haustive arguments by both sides, an nounced that he would instruct the jury that if the evidence showed that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, even if the fire did not cause the death of the persons therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. The state scored another victory when it secured the Incorporation in the instructions of a paragraph by which, if the jury finds that any one of the four persons in the house lost his life as the result, of the fire, and that Lamphere set the fire, then it must find Lamphere guilty of murder or manslaughter.
A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, though not of the murders themselves, and he was sentenced within minutes to 2-21 years in prison. He was immediately transported to the Michigan City penitentiary while his attorney announced plans to appeal.
The Laramie Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 8
IS GUILTY OF ARSON JURY RETURNS VERDICT AGAINST RAY LAMPHERE FOR BURNING GUNNESS HOME AT LA PORTE
Taken to Penitentiary. Lamphere was taken to prison in, Michigan City this afternoon. Before his departure he was visited by his mother, who wept in his arms. A mo tion for new trial will be made, and if it is denied. Attorney Worden has announced that he would appeal the case.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to Mrs. Belle Gunness's home, was taken to prison by automobile and formally processed. He was photographed, measured, bathed, and issued a grey prison uniform, with better treatment contingent on his future conduct.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 29 November 1908 · page 3
RAY LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON IN GREAT STYLE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.
Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning their house on April 28, was found guilty of arson after jury deliberation. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 21 years at Michigan City state prison.
TELEGRAPHIC NEWS CHICAGO, Nov..37.—Thirty familfes were driven panic stricken into the streets early this morning by fire which threatened a part of the busi ness section of South Chicago. Wom ep“l,_!.l.d‘ ‘cl;‘!l_ldren were carried by the firemen and policemen to the streets, The blaze started In the basement of > a three story brick double building oc cupled by the Commerdial National bank and Ingraham, Benko and Com pany. The interior of the buliding was destroyed. NEW YORK, Nov. 27.-—~Wreckers are at work today in the submerged hull' of the Panam raflroad steamer Finance, which sunk off Sandy Hook yesterday In collision with the Geor gle.
See moreSee less
This afternoon, if the sea quiets, divers will go down and examine the rent in the steamer's side caused by the Georgla's prow, ascertain the hest method of patching it as to float the sunken vessel. After the cabin of | the Finance had been loosened by the sea and It was washing about today. The hull of the steamer is completely submerged. LIMA, Peru, Nov. 27—Work In Cal lao bay is paralyzed as the result of a heavy storm which broke over that port yesterday. Enormous waves, higher than any that had been seen for thirty years swept over wharves and created a panic among the inhabi tants of the town. NEW YORK, Nov. 27--Daniel Quigley, truckman, 49 years old, lit erally died of fright yesterday in the Fordham hospital. Taken to the in stitution after he had slightly injured his foot, he grew pale when ushered into the operating room and asked if his case was serious. He was assured his Injurles slight, but at the sight of the surgical instruments and operat ing table he became panic stricken and expired, a victim of his own fear CHICAGO, Nov. 27.—A desperate battle between burglars and detectives on a fire escape 100 feet from the ground yesterday thrilled hundreds of spectators, who surrounded the plant of the Western Meal Manufacturing company. The detectives were held at bay by the thieves they had trap ped. Stanley Closlinsky, aged 19 years, and Stanley Glerch, aged 20 years both of whom have been in the hands of the police before, were the men ar rested. Closlinsky was released from the Bridewell only Tuesday after serv ing a time for burglary. The burglars fled across the roof, down a fire escape and into a second story window, where they agaln held the pursuing officers at bay un til a company of firamen arrived, when they were cantured. i A ST. PETERSBURG, Nov. 27—Three men, armed with revolvers, made a desperate attempt to kill the dowager empress of Russia during her recent journey from Copenhagen to this city by firing at the imperial carriage. She owes her life to the fact that the walls of the coach were of steel and are bomb proof, and to the vigllance of the secret police acting as her escort CHICAGO, Nov. 27.—Rdmund MecCabe, an engineer, went home while intoxicated last night, ordered his wife, who had prepared Thanksgiving din ner, to go out and “bring some beer and be quick about it” She was lying in bed, and, being frightened, pulled the bedclothes tighter about herself. The husband then fired two shot from a revolver, one bullet en tering the woman’s body below the heart, the other penetrating her side. He then shot himself through the heart and fell dead. The woman is unconscious at the hospital today bu* way recover. LA PORTE, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Bell Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gun ness house April 28 last, was found gullty of arson by the jury which had been deliberating since Wedneaday evening. Within filve minutes afier verdict reported, Judge Richter gen tenced defendant to state prison at Michigan City for a term of twency one years. He was taken to Michigen City this morning to begin senfence. WASHINGTON, Nov. 27.—That di vorce I 8 two and one-half times as common in the United States as it was forty years ago and that one marriage In twelve nowadays ends in divorce, are conclusions reached by officlals of the census bureau in the new com pilation of statistics of marriage and divorce, covering twenty years, from 1887 to 19806, inclusive. DENVER, Nov. 27.—Thanksgiving sports yesterday were atiended by a million people. In the state Colorado State univer sity defeated the School of Mines 15 to 0, Denver University defeated Coio rado college 6 to 4. Bastern scores: Pennsylvania 17, Cornell 4. Carlisle 17, Bt. Louis 0.
A Greek man in Boston advertised for a butler position and received suspicious letters signed 'W.A. Robinson' from Bath, Maine, which he forwarded to authorities after consulting the Greek consul. Postal inspectors investigated the letters and tracked the sender across Maine and New Hampshire, leading to the man's capture.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 November 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Dr. Edward Schell, a college president who refused to testify at Lamphere's trial, now says Lamphere confessed to him in prison that he killed Mrs. Gunness, her children, and was implicated in all her murder-farm victims. Schell says he is bound by a pledge of secrecy but admits knowing Gunness is dead and that Lamphere could be re-indicted for the Sverud murder.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 November 1908 · page 1
A CONEESSION Said to Have Been Made By Lamptiere. Or. Schell Says Man Was Im plicated In All the Murders Committed by Mrs. Gunness, to Number of Twenty or More. Des Moines, la.. Nov. 20.—Ur. Ed ward Schell, president of Iowa Wesley an University, who steadfastly refused to testify against Ray Damphere dur ing the sensational Gunness murder trial, admitted in Des Moines Saturday that Damphere confessed to him that he had murdered Mrs. Gunness. Dr. Schell declares he is bound by an oath given him by Damphere not to divulge the story told him in prison at Daporte when Damphere sent for him last summer.
See moreSee less
“I cannot give to the world the story of a man who sent for me as a Catho lic would send for a priest,” said Dr. Schell, who is in Des Moines attending an Epworth Deague convention. “Beads of sweat stood out on his fore head that night in his awful agony and he pledged my confidence berore he would tell me a word. But Dr. Schell, closely questioned, ad mitted that he knew Damphere had murdered Mrs. Gunness and her chil dren. He admitted that he knew that Mr« Gunness was dead beyond 3 ques tion’ He admitted that he knew that Damphere had been implicated in every one of the murders which Mrs. Gun ness committed on her Indiana farm. ' He said that if Damphere could now be induced to make the confession to officers that he made to the minister that the man who has been sent to prison for arson could be tried again on an indictment charging him with complicity in the killing by Mrs. Gun ness of Ole Stverud on her murder farm. If Dr. Scholl chose to tell all that her knows, it is a weird story of blood shed and decapitation and wholesale slaughter that he could relate of all the doings of the mysterious murder farm near Daporte. There is not a killing of all the 2 > of which Mrs. Gunness is believed to be guilty of, which Damphere did not know and tell his confessor in the Da perte cell on that night a year ago. But the minister s lips are sealed by a promise, and all he can say is that I^amphere’s sentence for arson was far less than he deserved to get.
Dr. Schell, a minister, discloses that Ray Lamphere confessed to him in a jail cell a year earlier that he knew Belle Gunness was dead and had been complicit in all her murders on the farm. Schell says his lips are otherwise sealed by the confidentiality of the confession, but suggests Lamphere could be retried for murder based on this knowledge.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 November 1908 · page 1
A CONFESSION
Number of Twenty or More. Des Moines, la.. Nov. 20.—Ur. Ed ward Schell, president of Iowa Wesley an University, who steadfastly refused to testify against Ray Damphere dur ing the sensational Gunness murder trial, admitted in Des Moines Saturday that Damphere confessed to him that he had murdered Mrs. Gunness. Dr. Schell declares he is bound by an oath given him by Damphere not to divulge the story told him in prison at Daporte when Damphere sent for him last summer. “I cannot give to the world the story of a man who sent for me as a Catho lic would send for a priest,” said Dr.
See moreSee less
Schell, who is in Des Moines attending an Epworth Deague convention. “Beads of sweat stood out on his fore head that night in his awful agony and he pledged my confidence berore he would tell me a word. But Dr. Schell, closely questioned, ad mitted that he knew Damphere had murdered Mrs. Gunness and her chil dren. He admitted that he knew that Mr« Gunness was dead beyond 3 ques tion’ He admitted that he knew that Damphere had been implicated in every one of the murders which Mrs. Gun ness committed on her Indiana farm. ' He said that if Damphere could now be induced to make the confession to officers that he made to the minister that the man who has been sent to prison for arson could be tried again on an indictment charging him with complicity in the killing by Mrs. Gun ness of Ole Stverud on her murder farm. If Dr. Scholl chose to tell all that her knows, it is a weird story of blood shed and decapitation and wholesale slaughter that he could relate of all the doings of the mysterious murder farm near Daporte. There is not a killing of all the 2 > of which Mrs. Gunness is believed to be guilty of, which Damphere did not know and tell his confessor in the Da perte cell on that night a year ago. But the minister s lips are sealed by a promise, and all he can say is that I^amphere’s sentence for arson was far less than he deserved to get.
Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson for burning the Gunness house, was taken to Michigan City state prison after a tearful farewell from his mother. He stated he intended to be a model prisoner and hoped for early parole, while his lawyer planned to appeal the verdict.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 30 November 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
Judge Richter in La Porte, Indiana overruled the motion for a new trial in the case of Ray Lamphere. Lamphere had been convicted on a charge of setting fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness.
The Hattiesburg News · 30 November 1908 · page 1
NEW TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
A court in La Porte, Indiana denied Ray Lamphere's motion for a new trial after his conviction for burning Mrs. Gunness's home, where several bodies were found. The defense plans to appeal to a higher court, arguing the jury instructions were erroneous and the verdict didn't conform to Indiana law.
East Oregonian : E.O · 30 November 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE DOES NOT GET NEW TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.
A La Porte, Indiana judge denied Ray Lamphere's motion for a new trial after his conviction for burning Belle Gunness's home, in whose ruins several bodies were found. The defense announced it would appeal to a higher court, arguing the jury instructions were erroneous and the verdict did not conform to Indiana law.