As the Papers Told It

Belle Gunness · The full archive

December 1908

122 articles

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson for burning the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and her three children, filed an appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court. This came after Judge Richter had overruled a motion related to completing the appeal process.

Bisbee Daily Review · 1 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the burning of the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and three children, filed an appeal to the Indiana supreme court. This came after Judge Richter overruled a motion for a new trial, with thirty days given to complete the appeal.

Arizona Republican · 1 December 1908 · page 1

APPEAL FOR LAMPHERE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

After Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the burning of the Gunness house, his attorneys filed an appeal to the Indiana supreme court, arguing the judge erred in his jury instructions. They were granted thirty days to complete the appeal, which also challenges the jury's arson verdict despite an indictment for murder by arson.

Evening Times-Republican · 1 December 1908 · page 1

RAY LAMPHERE APPEALS CASE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house on April 28, was found guilty only of arson by a jury in Laporte, Indiana. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Paper unidentified · 1 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Judge Richter sentenced Ray Lamphere to 2-21 years in Michigan City prison, a $5,000 fine, and five years disfranchisement for arson in the Gunness farmhouse fire. Defense attorney Worden called the verdict ridiculous and said he would appeal, while Lamphere maintained he believed the body found was Mrs. Gunness's but denied setting the fire.

Paper unidentified · 1 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa

Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children by burning them, was found guilty only of arson after jury deliberation lasting over a day. He was sentenced to an indeterminate prison term of 2 to 20 years, and despite his lawyer's talk of appeal, Lamphere himself seemed satisfied with the outcome, maintaining he believed Mrs. Gunness died in the fire though he denied setting it.

Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 1 December 1908 · page 1

Lampheres Dom

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

Judge Richter in Laporte circuit court denied a motion for a new trial in the case of Ray Lamphere, convicted of burning Belle Gunness's house on 'Death Farm.' The defense's appeal, based on claims of erroneous instructions and a verdict contrary to law, will now go to the state supreme court.

The Lake County Times · 1 December 1908 · page 3

NEW GUNNESS TRIAL IS DENIED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Bourbon News · Paris, Ky.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the Gunness murder trial, began serving his two-to-twenty-one-year sentence at Michigan City State prison on Friday. He expressed relief at not receiving a life sentence, and had a pathetic farewell meeting with his mother before departing for the penitentiary.

The Bourbon News · 1 December 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

A brief notice states that Ray Lamphere, charged with burning Mrs. Belle Gunness's home in Laporte, Indiana, was sentenced to 12 years in the penitentiary. The item appears amid a mix of unrelated local news and advertisements.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Interior Journal · 1 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, acquitting him of the murder charge; ten jurors had wanted first-degree murder. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate term of 2 to 21 years at the Indiana State Penitentiary in Michigan City.

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 1 December 1908 · page 8

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in connection with the burning of the Gunness house that killed Mrs. Gunness and three children, filed an appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court after a judge denied a motion for a new trial. The appeal argued the court erred in jury instructions, particularly regarding how the jury could return an arson verdict despite the indictment being for murder by arson.

Omaha Daily Bee · 1 December 1908 · page 2

APPEAL IN LAMPHERE CASE

LA PORTK. Ind., Nov. 3n.-Attorneys f"r Ray Iamphere, who has begun his term of Imprisonment for conviction of arson In connection with the burning of the Ujn ness house, In which Mrs. Gunness and three children lost their lives, today took an appeal to the Indiana supreme court, after Judge Rlchter had overruled a mo tion for a new trial. The motion rr a new trial tes based on the allegation that the court erred In refusing to give nine instructions submitted by the de fense by giving nine other alleged objec tionable Instructions. One of these was the one under which the jury brought In a verdict of arson, though the indictment waa for murder by arson.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A sarcastic newspaper aside mocks the jury's decision to convict Ray Lamphere of arson but not murder, joking that the panel must have reasoned Belle Gunness's killing wasn't really a crime. It reflects contemporary commentary on the surprising verdict in the Gunness case.

Omaha Daily Bee · 1 December 1908 · page 4

Jury Reasoning

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Ray Lamphere's attorneys filed an appeal to the Indiana supreme court after Judge Richter denied a motion for a new trial in the Gunness house burning case. The appeal cites errors in jury instructions, including the jury's arson verdict despite the original murder indictment.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 2 December 1908 · page 6

LAMPHERE CASE WILL BE APPEALED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty of arson by a jury after about twenty-four hours of deliberation. Judge Richter sentenced him within minutes to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at Michigan City penitentiary.

New Ulm Review · 2 December 1908 · page 2

FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn.

At the Ray Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, the prosecution rested its case and the defense began, with attorney Worden's opening statement followed by witnesses who testified against the assumption that the adult body found in the farmhouse ruins was Mrs. Gunness. This is reported as one item among many unrelated news briefs in a roundup column.

Willmar Tribune · 2 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, and within minutes Judge Richter sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City prison. Lamphere maintained he believed the body found was Mrs. Gunness's and denied setting the fire or witnessing her kill Helgelein.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Willmar Tribune · 2 December 1908 · page 2

AGREEMENT REACHED IN LANPHERE CASE AFTER SHORT DELIBERATION.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont.

A jury in Laporte, Ind. found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness farmhouse, though not of murdering Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2 to 21 years at hard labor in Michigan City.

The Enterprise · 2 December 1908 · page 2

JURY RETURNS ARSON VERDICT AGREEMENT REACHED IN LANPHERE CASE AFTER SHORT DELIBERATION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont.

The jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire at Belle Gunness's farmhouse, and Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at Michigan City penitentiary. Lamphere stated he believed the body found was Mrs. Gunness's but denied setting the fire or witnessing Helgelein's murder.

The Enterprise · 2 December 1908 · page 2

DELIBERATION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house in La Porte, Indiana, on April 28, though he had also been charged with the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. The jury deliberated for about 24 hours before reaching its verdict.

The Forest Republican · 2 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

Ray Lamphere's attorneys have filed an appeal to the Indiana state supreme court after Judge Richter denied a motion for a new trial. Lamphere was previously found guilty by a Laporte jury of arson for burning the Gunness house, which killed Belle Gunness and three children.

The Madison Daily Leader · 2 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Yakima Herald · North Yakima, Wash.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to Mrs. Belle Gunness's home, was sent to the Indiana state prison. He was subjected to the usual intake procedures upon arrival.

The Yakima Herald · 2 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Dr. Walter Haines, a toxicology professor, testified that he found strychnine and arsenic in the stomach contents attributed to Mrs. Gunness and two children, and strychnine in that of Andrew Helgelein. He stopped short of attributing the deaths to poisoning or confirming it entered through the mouth, and testimony concluded with the case set to go to the jury.

Vernon County Censor · 2 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis.

During the trial of Ray Lamphere in Laporte, Indiana, three witnesses testified that they saw Mrs. Gunness alive after the fire in which she was supposedly killed. This testimony fueled ongoing doubts about whether Gunness actually died in the farmhouse blaze.

Vilas County News · 2 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children concluded, with the case given to the jury at 5:30 pm. After four hours without a verdict, the jury retired for the night without reaching a decision.

Vilas County News · 2 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · and 2 other papers

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house in April, was found guilty of arson at Laporte, Indiana. Judge Richter sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in prison, fined him $5,000, and disfranchised him for five years.

Audubon Republican · 3 December 1908 · page 2

Mrs. Eleanor Merron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, fatally shot herself in her room al the St. Regis hotel. New York. John Gardner Coolidge, the Amori can minister to Nicaragua, resigued from the diplomatic service. Ray Lamphere, charged With the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunn'ess and her three children, by setting fire to th 6 Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Laporte, Ind. Judge Richter sentenced him to the state prison for an indeterminate term oi from two to 21 years, lined him $5,000 and disfranchised him for five years.

See moreSee less

At Vermillion, S. D. Mrs. Christina Clark, accused of the murder of her divorced husband, was found guilty of manslaughter in the second degree. Public Printer John S. Leech re signed and Samuel B. Donnelly of Brooklyn was appointed to the place. Wilbur Carr, who murdered Marshal Thomas Nicholson of Gowrie, la., last summer, was sentenced to life impris onment in the Fort Madison peni tentiary. George R. Sheldon, treasurer of the Republican national committee, filed the list of contributions for the recent national campaign. It shows 12,330 contributors. The total amount con tributed was $1,579,578.27.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 2 December 1908
  • The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · 3 December 1908

The Monticellonian · Monticello, Ark.

Ray Lamphere, tried at Michigan City, Indiana for the murder of Belle Gunness and her two children and for burning their house, was found guilty of arson by the jury. He received an indefinite sentence to the penitentiary.

The Monticellonian · 3 December 1908 · page 2

MONTICELLO, The Ne ws-Seinii tar. of Mem-* phis, has been thrown into the hands of a Receiver. The paper failed to meet its current expen ses. Rnv Lamphere, who was re centlv tried at Michigan City. Indiana, on a charge of murder ing Mrs. Bella Gunness, the

See the clipping

The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.

Ray Lamphere, charged in connection with the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, was found guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness home. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2 to 21 years at Michigan City prison.

The Mena Weekly Star · 3 December 1908 · page 4

LAMPHERE IS GUILTY CONVICTED BY JURY OF SETTING FIRE TO GUNNESS HOME AT LAPORTE, IND.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in the burning of Belle Gunness's house, with Judge Richter sentencing him to Michigan City state prison for 2 to 21 years. Lamphere denied setting the fire or witnessing Helgelein's murder, while the jury separately affirmed its belief that the adult body in the ruins was Belle Gunness.

The Mena Weekly Star · 3 December 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

An editorial complains about police corruption and Black Hand extortion letters sent to a Hammond businessman, warning LaPorte could be next. It references the earlier Gunness affair as an example of local lawlessness.

The Lake County Times · 3 December 1908 · page 8

CLEAN UP. CLEAN OUT.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not guilty of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the Michigan City state penitentiary.

Paper unidentified · 3 December 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE GETS ARSON SENTENCE WAS NOT FOUND GUILTY OF MURDERING MRS. BELLE GUNNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified · and 2 other papers

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the La Porte case after a 26-hour jury deliberation, receiving an indeterminate 2–21 year sentence and a $3,000 fine. Jurors later stated they believed the adult body found with the three children's remains was indeed Mrs. Gunness.

Paper unidentified · 3 December 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 4 December 1908
  • Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 8 December 1908

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Ira Marsh of Oglesby, Illinois wrote to Sheriff Smutzer claiming he had located Belle Gunness and her foster daughter Jennie Olson, one of her alleged victims, and would produce them for a reward. He linked the pair to a man who testified at the Lamphere trial about visiting the Gunness farm on July 9.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 3 December 1908 · page 4

ILLINOIS MAN WANTS REWARD FOR ACT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of setting fire to the Gunness home in La Porte, Indiana. He was given an indeterminate sentence of two to twenty-one years at Michigan City prison.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 3 December 1908 · page 6

LAMPHERE GUILTY CONVICTED BY JURY OF SETTING FIRE TO GUNNESS HOME AT LAPORTE, IND.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning the Gunness house, was found guilty only of arson by the jury. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City state prison, while Lamphere maintained his innocence of setting the fire but admitted being near the scene.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 3 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

The jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in the Gunness farmhouse fire, with the judge confirming each juror's agreement individually. Jurors later issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the adult female body found in the ruins was indeed Belle Gunness, though they based their verdict solely on the arson charge.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 3 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Owingsville Outlook · Owingsville, Ky.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, rather than murder, and Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City prison. Jurors had been divided, with several holding out for a first-degree murder conviction with life imprisonment, but the arson verdict was a compromise.

Owingsville Outlook · 3 December 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON IS SENTENCED TO PRISON FOR TWO TO 21 YEARS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Owingsville Outlook · Owingsville, Ky.

A jury in Laporte, Indiana found Roy Lamphere guilty on a charge of causing the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her children, sentencing him to twenty-one years in prison. The paper notes that despite the verdict, Mrs. Gunness was considered an undesirable citizen whose death benefited the world.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Owingsville Outlook · 3 December 1908 · page 4

= t NOTWITHSTANDING that Mrs Gunness was an undesirable citi zen whose removal was a boon to v the world the jury at Laporte I Ind trying Roy Lamphere on charge of causing the death of O Mrs Gunness and herthildren found him guilty and gave him twentyone years in prison 1 r x THERE is said to be a movement on foot among the county boards of control of the Burley Tobacco Society to make President Clar ence LeBus a Republican an in dependent candidate for Govern sor of Kentucky next term Three years is a long way off and things are liable to happen meanwhile + IF the next Congress under takes genuine tariff reform of the RooseveltTaft kind there r will be something Joing on the It r part of the sndpattcrs If the I Republican leaders were not so J rf smart there would be grave dan r ger of a split of the Republican r party but the Democrats ar e 1 J > f respect for d long time yet t likely to Bold the record in that

See the clipping

The Citizen · Berea, Ky.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in connection with the burning of the Gunness house, though acquitted of murdering Belle Gunness and her children. The jury deliberated over a day, with some members pushing for a first-degree murder conviction and life sentence, before reaching this compromise verdict.

The Citizen · 3 December 1908 · page 7

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON IS SENTENCED TO PRISON FOR TWO TO 21 YEARS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Hickman Courier · Hickman, Ky.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the burning of Belle Gunness's house, which killed her and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2 to 31 years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.

The Hickman Courier · 3 December 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was instead found guilty only of arson. He received an indeterminate sentence of two to twenty years.

The Princeton Union · 3 December 1908 · page 4

An editorial writer in World's Work for September asserts that the Belgians are the thriftiest and most contented of any people in Europe and few of them emigrate, and at the same time they are the greatest beer drink ers in the world. Ray Lamphere, who was charged at La Porte, Indiana, with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch fiend, and her three children by setting fire to the house, has been found guilty of arson and sentenced to serve an inde terminate period of from two to twenty years.

See moreSee less

Frank H. Hitchcock has been offered and has accepted the portfolio of postmaster general. This is a fitting reward for Mr. Hitchcock's excellent work in conducting the republican presidential campaign. It is the first and only cabinet position so far filled

See the clipping

The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D. · and 1 other paper

A jury in Laporte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the state penitentiary in Michigan City.

The Oakes Times · 3 December 1908 · page 2

FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Little Falls Herald · Little Falls, Minn. · 4 December 1908

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

Defense attorney Worden began his opening statement in the Ray Lamphere murder trial, arguing that the body found in the fire ruins was not Belle Gunness and that she was still alive. He claimed witnesses had seen her in July, that her dental work could not have survived the fire, and that the four bodies found had died of poisoning rather than burning.

Warren Sheaf · 3 December 1908 · page 5

VICTORY DEPENDS ON MRS. GUNNESS' FATE

Gunness could not have gone through the Are and that the four persons whose bodies were found in the rains of the lire died of poisoning.

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

At the Lamphere murder trial, defense attorney Worden argued the body found was not Mrs. Gunness's and that she was still alive, having set the fire to escape after poisoning the victims. The state rested its case after cross-examination of Deputy Sheriff Anstiss, whose testimony about Lamphere's alleged admissions may force the defendant to testify.

Warren Sheaf · 3 December 1908 · page 5

Must. Disprove Gunnees Death. Attorney Worden contended that the question to determine was wheth er Ray Lamphere Is guilty of having burned Mrs. Gunness and the children -to death. Continuing, he said: "First, It will be necessary to prove the identification of the bodies. We be lieve that we will be able to show that It was not her body. Even that will not settle the question of Ray Lanv phere's guilt or innocence. Our evi dence will show that Mrs. Ounness is still alive. She had a motive In set ting fire to the house and escaping."

See moreSee less

The state rested Friday noon in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of the murder of Mrs. Belle Ounness and her three children by setting Art to her ^vv-^K bouse, when the defense finished the cross-examination of Deputy Sheriff Anstfss.

See the clipping

The Loup City Northwestern · Loup City, Neb.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson, was found guilty only of arson after a compromise verdict, with several jurors having held out for a first-degree murder conviction and life sentence. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to 21 years at Michigan City, and Lamphere maintained he believed the body found was Mrs. Gunness' but denied setting the fire or witnessing her kill Helgelein.

The Loup City Northwestern · 3 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

Ray Lamphere, hired man of Belle Gunness, was found guilty of arson (not murder) for setting fire to the Gunness house that killed Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter sentenced him to an indeterminate term of 2 to 21 years in Michigan City prison, plus a $5,000 fine and five years' disfranchisement.

The Frontier · 3 December 1908 · page 7

LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 2 other papers

Ray Lamphere was sentenced by Judge Richter to two to 21 years in Michigan City prison for arson, fined $5,000, and disfranchised for five years. The jury issued a signed statement affirming their belief that the adult body found in the fire ruins was indeed Mrs. Belle Gunness, though they based their verdict on separate grounds.

The Frontier · 3 December 1908 · page 7

GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D. · 3 December 1908
  • The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · 4 December 1908

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, but not of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children, after 24 hours of deliberation. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years at Michigan City penitentiary, while the defense called the verdict ridiculous and planned an appeal.

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 3 December 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A miner named Ira Marsh writes to Sheriff Smutzer claiming he has located Jennie Olson living in Illinois, married to a man who once appeared at the Gunness farm. Authorities are skeptical and unlikely to pursue the claim seriously, though the sheriff may send a detective to interview Marsh.

Paper unidentified · 3 December 1908 · page 1

S( aure and bring four or five hundred dollars. This! man, whose name he does not give, came back to Oglesby in January. 1907, shortly after Jen­ nie Olson dlsapeared from the Gun ness place bringing with him a young wife, and Marsh declares this woman is the image of Jennie Olson's jpicreMarsh says he is in danger of be­ ing kill'ed, but he wants Sheriff Smut zer to come to Oglesby at once and to bring with him eJnnie Olson's sis­ ters, who live in Chicago, so that they may identify the woman.

See moreSee less

Marsh also thinks that the man is the fellow who wrote Mayor Darrow from Chicago. on November 23, say­ ing he was the man who accompan­ ied the suppose*! Mrg. Gunness to Laporte July 9./ arsh says he is a miner, employed by the Illinois Zinc company. It is not likely that any investigation of the story will be made by Prosecutor Smith or Sheriff Smutzer, but the lat­ ter stated tonight that he would prob ably send a detective to, Oglesby to interview Marsh. vv :.

See the clipping

Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning the Gunness house, was found guilty of arson after a 24-hour jury deliberation. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

Courier Democrat · 3 December 1908 · page 2

FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson for burning the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and her three children, was taken to state prison after an emotional farewell with his mother. He vowed to be a model prisoner to earn parole after two years, while his attorney planned to appeal the arson conviction.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 3 December 1908 · page 5

LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

Ray Lamphere, accused in the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, was found guilty of arson in Laporte, Indiana. He was sentenced to twenty-one years in Michigan City penitentiary and fined $3,000.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 3 December 1908 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house but not of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the state penitentiary, a $5000 fine, and five years disfranchisement, with jurors revealing the verdict was a compromise after some held out for a murder conviction.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 3 December 1908 · page 3

LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Democrat-Sentinel · Logan, Ohio

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house on April 28, was found guilty of arson by the jury. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

The Democrat-Sentinel · 3 December 1908 · page 6

Ilurnetl tlio Gunness Home (jBp-irte, Intl., Nov, 20 Buy Liunpliere, clmrged with tlio murder of Mru. Belle Gunness and her tlireo children by eettlng fire to tlio Gunnete lioufo April 28, was thin evening found Ruilty of ariort by the Jury, which had the cine since 0:80 last evening. Withiu live mluuten after the

See the clipping

Cameron County Press · Emporium, Pa.

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty of arson after a 24-hour jury deliberation. He was immediately sentenced to 2–21 years in prison, while his defense vowed to appeal, calling the verdict inconsistent with the murder charge.

Cameron County Press · 3 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.

After his trial, Ray Lamphere gave his first extended statement, expressing relief at his comparatively light sentence while maintaining his innocence. He admitted that the circumstantial evidence looked suspicious and that he now believed the body found in the fire was indeed Belle Gunness's.

Turner County Herald · 3 December 1908 · page 7

Lamphere expressed a similar belief in the first extended statement lie has made to other than his attorneys since the trial began. ITe said he consid ered himself lucky, in view of the evi dence produced, in getting off as easily as he has. lie maintained his inno cence, however. Contrary to expectations, Lamphere's attorneys made no motion for a new trial. Unofficially, however, they ex pressed such intention, but in view of Lamphere's light sentence in compari son with the heavy punishment which another jury might bring in were the new trial secured there is little likeli hood of his being tried again.

See moreSee less

In his cell Lamphere professed that he expected acquittal, but his unwont ed buopancy belied his words. Ho re sponded to congratulations on the light ness of the vordice with whole heart edness.

See the clipping

The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house that killed Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and was sentenced to two to twenty-one years in prison along with a fine and disfranchisement. The jury also issued a statement affirming their belief that the adult body found in the ruins was that of Mrs. Gunness.

The Citizen-Republican · 3 December 1908 · page 3

GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Spanish Fork Press · Spanish Fork, Utah

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, in a compromise verdict after jurors split over a murder charge. He was sentenced to two to twenty-one years in state prison, fined $5000, and disfranchised for five years.

The Spanish Fork Press · 3 December 1908 · page 1

Laporlo IndRay Lampherc charged with the murder of Mrs Hello Gunnoss and her three children ly Bolting tiro to tho Gunness home April 28 was on Thursday evening found guilty of arson by the jury which had the case since 530 oclock Wednesday evening Within five min utes after the verdict was reported Judge Richter had sentenced the do Pendant to time state prison nt Michi gan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twentyone years lined him 5000 and disfranchised him for jflvo years Attorney Vorden for tho defense cald Thursday night that a motion for n new trial would be made and phould It he refused an appeal to the Indiana supreme court would follow Should the case be carried to tho supreme court and sent back for re trial Lamphere could not be tried on nny chargo In this particular case ex cepting arson the crime of which ho was convicted However In an event of that kindtho state would elect to try him on one of the Indictments probably tire Helgelcln case Members of the Jury are reticent in discussing what occurred In tho jury room but enough has been learn ed to know that but for two mem bers Lamphere would have been found guilty of murder or manslaughter the verdict being a compromise Sev eral members of tho jury It Is un derstood held out long for murder In the first degree with a life sentence So far as could be learned nono was ilqr hanging o

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

A jury in La Porte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson and he was sentenced to two to twenty-one years in the penitentiary. The jury also ruled that the body recovered from the fire ruins was that of Mrs. Gunness.

Wood County Reporter · 3 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson but not murder, and he was sentenced to 2-21 years in prison plus a fine. Jurors stated they believed the adult body found in the fire ruins was Belle Gunness, a belief Lamphere himself now shared despite maintaining his innocence.

Wood County Reporter · 3 December 1908 · page 7

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson and sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in prison. The same jury also ruled that the body recovered from the farmhouse ruins was indeed that of Belle Gunness.

Iowa County Democrat · 3 December 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Springfield Herald · Springfield, Colo. · and 3 other papers

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of setting fire to the La Porte building where Belle Gunness and her three children died. The judge sentenced him to twenty-one years in the Michigan City penitentiary within minutes of the verdict.

The Springfield Herald · 4 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · 3 December 1908
  • · · 4 December 1908
  • The Julesburg Grit-Advocate · Julesburg, Colo. · 4 December 1908

The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · and 2 other papers

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire at the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter swiftly sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in state prison, fined him $5000, and disfranchised him for five years.

The Kendrick Gazette · 4 December 1908 · page 3

Lamphere Gets 21 Years.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Harlem News · Harlem, Mont. · 3 December 1908
  • Bonners Ferry Herald · Bonners Ferry, Idaho · 5 December 1908

The Mahoning Dispatch · Canfield, Ohio · and 5 other papers

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson, was found guilty only of arson at Laporte, Indiana. Judge Richter sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in state prison, fined him $5000, and disfranchised him for five years.

The Mahoning Dispatch · 4 December 1908 · page 2

PERSONAL

Ray Lamphere charged with tho murder of Mrs Belle Gunncss and her thrco children by setting flro to tho Gunness house April 28 wns found guilty of arson at Laporte Ind Judge RIchter sentenced him to tho stato prison for an Indetermlnato term of from two to 21 years fined him 5000 and disfranchised him for five years At Vermillion S D Mrs Christina Clark accused of the murder of her divorced husband was found guilty of manslaughter in the Bccond degree I rubllc rrinter John S Leech re

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 3 December 1908
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 4 December 1908
  • The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · 4 December 1908
  • The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 4 December 1908
  • Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · 4 December 1908

The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · and 1 other paper

The jury deliberated 24 hours and found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning Belle Gunness's home, but not guilty of murdering her and her three children. He was sentenced to two to twenty-one years in prison, fined $5000, and disenfranchised for five years, with an appeal planned.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Yale Expositor · 4 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Belding Banner · Belding, Mich. · 3 December 1908

Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D. · and 1 other paper

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson after 26 hours of deliberation, and Judge Richter sentenced him to 2-21 years plus a $5,000 fine. Jurors signed a statement affirming their belief that the adult body found in the fire ruins was Mrs. Gunness, a view Lamphere himself echoed.

Hot Springs Weekly Star · 4 December 1908 · page 4

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 3 December 1908

Troy Weekly News · Troy, Idaho

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, resulting in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in state prison, fined him $5000, and disfranchised him for five years.

Troy Weekly News · 4 December 1908 · page 3

Lamphere Gets 21 Years.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho

A La Porte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson in connection with the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in state prison, fined him $5000, and disfranchised him for five years.

Camas Prairie Chronicle · 4 December 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Idaho Republican · Blackfoot, Idaho

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the Belle Gunness case, was sentenced to two to twenty years and taken to Michigan City prison. His attorney announced plans to seek a new trial, arguing the judge erred in jury instructions.

The Idaho Republican · 4 December 1908 · page 8

LAMPHERE IN THE PEN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

Attorney H.W. Worden released a letter Ray Lamphere wrote to his mother after being sentenced to prison for burning the Gunness house. In it, Lamphere protests his innocence of the murders he was tried for and expresses relief that he was not one of Belle Gunness's victims.

The Winchester News · 4 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

St. Paul Tidende · St. Paul, Minn.

A jury in La Porte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere, Belle Gunness's hired hand and suspected accomplice, guilty of arson for setting fire to her house where she and her children burned to death. He was sentenced to an indeterminate term of 2 to 20 years, though the jury stated it had no doubt the body found in the ruins was Mrs. Gunness's, the judge had instructed they could only rule on the arson charge.

St. Paul Tidende · 4 December 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house in LaPorte, Indiana, where Belle Gunness and her three children died. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

Dakota Farmers' Leader · 4 December 1908 · page 10

LAMPHERE IS GUILTY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson rather than murder, expresses relief at his comparatively light sentence and says he now believes the body found in the fire was indeed Belle Gunness's. His attorneys unofficially consider a new trial but decide against it given the lighter sentence already secured.

Dakota Farmers' Leader · 4 December 1908 · page 11

LAMPHERL GUILTY OF ARSON. Jury Ignores Murder Charge—Sen tence from 2 to 21 Years. Hay Larnphere was found guilty of arson after the jury had been out twen ty-six hours in Laporte, Ind. Judge John C. Richter immediately sentenced him to the penitentiary for an indeter minate term of from two to twenty one years and assessed a fine of $5,000. The verdict was in the nature of a compromise, ten of the jurors having held out from the first for a verdict of murder in the second degree, with a penalty of life imprisonment.

See moreSee less

Two stubborn members all day contended for a verdict of arson and not guilty, respectively. Following the sentencing of Larn phere all the jurors signed a statement thnt they were convinced by the evi dence at the trial that the adult body found in the ruins with the bodies of the three children was that of Mrs. Gunness. Larnphere expressed a similar belief in the first extended statement he has made to other than his attorneys since the trial began. He said he consid ered himself lucky, in view of the evi dence produced, in getting off as easily as he has. lie maintained his inno cence, however. Contrary to expectations, Lamphere's attorneys made no motion for a new trial. Unofficially, however, they ex pressed such Intention, but in view of Lamphere's light sentence in compari son with the heavy punishment which another jury might bring in were the new trial secured there is llttle'likeli hood of his being tried again. In his cell Larnphere professed that he expected acquittal, but his unwont ed buopancy belied his words. lie re sponded to congratulations on the light ness of the verdice with whole heart edness. "I'm ready to start and take my med icine like a man," he said. "Consider ing the circumstantial evidence that was produed against me I suppose I am lucky. I haven't got a word to say against It. "I'm just as innocent as you are of what I was charged with, but it ain't any wonder the jury thought what it did. The way I acted that morning of the fire certainly looked suspicious when it was presented in court. "I thought Belle Gunness was not in the fire, because all the money she must have had wasn't shown up. But after hearing the evidence it looks to me as if that must have been her body in the •ire."

See the clipping

The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson rather than murder in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her children, prepares to begin his prison term. His lawyer calls the conviction absurd, while Lamphere maintains he did not set the fire though he believes Mrs. Gunness died in it.

The Montgomery Tribune · 4 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo.

Following his conviction for arson in the Gunness farm case, Ray Lamphere's defense attorney calls the verdict ridiculous, arguing he should have been acquitted if guilty only of murder. The defense claims double jeopardy may prevent a future murder trial, while prosecutors hint they may still pursue murder charges in Andrew Helgelein's death.

The Montgomery Tribune · 4 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Tupelo Journal · Tupelo, Miss.

Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, was found guilty only of arson by the jury. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

The Tupelo Journal · 4 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Greene County Herald · Leakesville, Miss.

A Laporte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, which killed Belle Gunness and her three children, though he was acquitted of the murder charge itself. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City state penitentiary.

Greene County Herald · 4 December 1908 · page 1

Ray Lamphere Found Guilty of Arson. Laporte, Ind., Nov . 27.—Ray Lamp here, charged with arson and the mur der of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house on April 28, was last night found guilty of arson by the jury, which had had the case under con sideration for twenty-four hours Within five minutes after the verdict was reported, Judge Richter sentenced tne defendant to the state penitentia ry at Michigan City for an indetermi nate term of from two to twenty-one years. He will be taken to Michigan City tomorrow to begin his sentence

See the clipping

The Commoner · Lincoln, Neb.

Ray Lamphere, tried at La Porte, Indiana for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was instead convicted of arson and given an indeterminate sentence of two to twenty-one years. The verdict was described as a compromise.

The Commoner · 4 December 1908 · page 13

Ray Lamphere, on trial at La Porte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was convicted of arson and given an indeterminate sentence of from two to twenty-one years. The verdict was a compromise.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the Gunness case, wrote a letter to his mother shortly after his sentencing, insisting he was not guilty and was no criminal before God. He also remarked it was a wonder he had not ended up buried in Mrs. Gunness's private burying ground.

Paper unidentified · 4 December 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE SENDS LETTER TO MOM - MAN CONVICTED OF ARSON IN THE GUNNESS CASE STILL MAINTAINS HIS INNOCENCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A rural North Dakota correspondent's community news column mentions that a traveling troupe presented moving pictures depicting the murders at the Gunness farm. The rest of the passage covers unrelated local events like Thanksgiving celebrations, weather, and social gatherings.

Paper unidentified · 4 December 1908 · page 8

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Ray Lamphere, convicted of arson in the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children, was sentenced to 2-21 years and visited by his mother before being taken to Michigan City prison. The defense called the verdict illogical and announced plans to appeal.

Paper unidentified · 4 December 1908 · page 10

MOTHER GOOD-BYE UPottc, Ind., Nov. IT.—Before Raj Lamphere, under sentence for from two to twenty-one years, was taken to the state prison in Michigan city to begin his term, he received a visit today from his aged mother. Though not with him during the trial, she came here from South Bend in order to say good-5y* to him and cheer him up. The meeting of the mother and ?on was pathetic. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lam* phere, charged with the murder of Mrp. Bella Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness home, April 28, was last night found guilty of arson by the Jury which had the case since 5 o'clock Wednesday even ing.

See moreSee less

Within Ave minutes after the ver -diet was reported uJdge Ricbter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years. He wil be taken to Michigan City today to begin his sen tience. The verdict was reached within half

See the clipping

The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.

A miner named Ira Marsh writes to the La Porte sheriff claiming he has located Belle Gunness and also Jennie Olson living in Oglesby, Illinois. He says he will produce the woman once assured the reward money will be paid, and connects her to a mysterious man who allegedly wrote the mayor in 1907.

The Daily Ardmoreite · 4 December 1908 · page 2

GUNNESS WOMAN ALIVE LETTER TO SHERIFF OF LA PORTE INSISTS WOMAN IS NOT DEAD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D.

Ray Lamphere was convicted but given a light sentence of 2 to 21 years rather than a murder charge, and his attorneys decided not to pursue a new trial given the favorable outcome. In his cell, Lamphere expressed relief at the lenient verdict and admitted that courtroom evidence convinced him the body found in the fire was indeed Belle Gunness's.

Hot Springs Weekly Star · 4 December 1908 · page 4

JURY IGNORES MURDER CHARGE—SENTENCE FROM 2 TO 21 YEARS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty only of arson for burning the Gunness house, not of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. Judge Richter sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to 21 years at Michigan City, and the jury signed a statement expressing their view on the identity of the adult body found in the ruins.

The Mitchell Capital · 4 December 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Philip Weekly Review · Philip, S.D.

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, though not of the murders of Mrs. Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

Philip Weekly Review · 4 December 1908 · page 6

LAMPHERE IS GUILTY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her children concluded in La Porte, Indiana. The case was handed to the jury late in the afternoon for deliberation.

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 4 December 1908 · page 3

NEBRASKA BANK ROBBED. Yeggmen Got Away With Four Thou sand Dollars at Page. Norfolk, Neb., Nov. 25.—Six rob bers dynamited the State Bank of Page, near here today, securing all the cash in the bank, said to ave been about four thousand dollars and made good their escape. While two men did the work, the others stood guard. Gunness Case to the .Jury. Laporte, lnd., Nov. 25.—The trial of Ray Lamphere, for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her children, was finished late this afternoon and given to the jury.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to Mrs. Belle Gunness's home and sentenced to two to twenty-one years, was transported to the Indiana penitentiary in style, arriving by auto. He was processed and assigned prisoner number 4140 upon entering custody.

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 4 December 1908 · page 3

LAMPHERE IN PRISON. Bwgn His Sentence in Indiana Peni tentiary Yesterday. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 2 7.—Ray Lam phere, convicted of setting fire to the Mrs. Belle Gunness home, and sen tenced to serve a term of two to twenty-one years, went to prison to day in style. He rode from the in teruban station to the prison gate in an auto. Stepping to the window of Chief Clerk Lormor, the sheriff handed the official commitment pa pers and the prisoner's name was entered upon the register at r0 p. m. Lamphere was assigned No. 4140 and then passed along to the re ceiving clerk.

See the clipping

The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.

Ray Lamphere, convicted of burning Belle Gunness's home, was taken to Michigan City penitentiary to begin his sentence of two to twenty-one years. He was assigned to the construction department and appeared content, while a crowd at the station shouted support for his release.

The Columbia Herald · 4 December 1908 · page 5

HIS LONG SENTENCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.

Ray Lamphere, the farmhand tried for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was found guilty instead of arson. Judge Richter sentenced him to serve two to twenty-one years in the Michigan City penitentiary.

The Columbia Herald · 4 December 1908 · page 12

LAMPHERE GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Farmville Herald · Farmville, Va.

A jury in La Porte, Indiana found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for setting fire to the Gunness house, though he had also been charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the state penitentiary, a $5000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement.

The Farmville Herald · 4 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Colorado Statesman · Denver, Colo. · and 1 other paper

Ray Lamphere, already serving his sentence for arson in the burning of the Gunness house that killed Belle Gunness and three children, has appealed to the Indiana Supreme Court after his motion for a new trial was denied. The brief item notes his attorneys are pursuing the appeal despite the conviction standing.

The Colorado Statesman · 5 December 1908 · page 2

Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, who has begun his term of imprisonment on conviction of arson in connection with the burning of the Gunness house, in which Mrs. Belle Gunness and three children lost their lives at La Porte, have taken an appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court, motion for a new trial having been denied. Englewood High school, Chicago, is making arrangements to take the long est trip on record for a high school football eleven. Terms have been made with the Butte, Mont., high school for a contest on Dec. 19th, and provisional date filled with the Seattle eleven for a match on Christmas day and for a New Year's struggle at Angeles.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Elk Mountain Pilot (Irwin, Colo.) · Ruby Camp · 10 December 1908

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The Connecticut Fire Insurance Company states that the Lamphere trial verdict does not prove Belle Gunness is dead, and that it believes she is still alive. The company will resist efforts by estate administrator Wesley Fogle to collect $2,300 in fire insurance on the burned dwelling.

The Lake County Times · 5 December 1908 · page 5

REFUSES GUNNESS INSURANCE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La.

Ray Lamphere, tried at Laporte, Indiana for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, was convicted instead of arson. He received an indeterminate sentence to the penitentiary.

The Donaldsonville Chief · 5 December 1908 · page 4

Ray Lamphere, on trial at Laporte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, was convicted of arson and sentenced to an indeterminate term in the peniten tiary. William Montgomery, convicted of embezzling $500,000 from the Alle gheny National Bank while cashier of that institution, was sentenced to serve fifteen years in the Western Pennsylvania penitentiary. Andrew Casrneie, the pbilanthropic steel magnate, has given something like $10,000 towards the rebuilding of

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Ray Lamphere, accused in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house in April, was found guilty of arson by a La Porte jury. Judge Richter sentenced him to an indeterminate term of two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

Paper unidentified · 5 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Garland Globe · Garland, Utah

A jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson for burning the Gunness home, rather than murder of Belle Gunness and her children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to an indeterminate prison term and a fine, with the defense planning to appeal.

The Garland Globe · 5 December 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE FOUND GUILTY OF ARSON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

A news digest reports that Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the Gunness case at Laporte, Indiana, and sentenced to state prison. The item appears among other brief national news summaries for the week of November 27, 1908.

Spirit of the Age · 5 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A detective hired by Ray Lamphere's attorney leaves for Chicago to check a report that Belle Gunness is working as a cook in a Northwest hotel. Meanwhile, the sheriff receives word she may be living with her sister in Tracy, California.

The Sun · 6 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa

A man named Ira Marsh writes to Sheriff Smutzer claiming Mrs. Gunness and missing girl Jennie Olsen are alive and that he knows their whereabouts, but wants payment first. The sheriff is skeptical, having chased similar false leads before.

Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 8 December 1908 · page 1

Et nyt Gunnessrygte

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

A brief news item reports that a man from Ogiesby, Illinois claims Mrs. Belle Gunness, proprietor of the notorious LaPorte 'death farm,' is still alive. He states he will produce her in exchange for a reward.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Yorkville Enquirer · 8 December 1908 · page 2

MERE MENTION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis.

A La Porte, Indiana jury found Ray Lamphere guilty of arson and sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in prison. The jury also ruled that the body recovered from the fire ruins was that of Mrs. Gunness.

Wausau Pilot · 8 December 1908 · page 2

At La Porte, Ind., the jury decided Ray Lamphere is guilty of arson and lie was sentenced from two to twenty-one years in the penitentiary, the jury also ruling that tin* body taken from the ruins was that of Mrs. Gunness. Friday. The Hughes County liana at Blunt, ft. D„ was robbed of about $151) the oth er day. Suit has been filed in Findlay, Ohio, to test the constitutionality of the Rose local option law. Mrs. Christina Clark, accused of the murder of her divorced husband, was found guilty in Vermilion, S. D. Frank 11. Hitchcock has been offered and has accepted the position of I’ost innster General in Mr. Taft's Cabinet.

See the clipping

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

A newspaper humor column references a rumor that Mrs. Gunness went to Texas, joking that if the allegations against her are true she deserves her fate. The item is a brief aside among unrelated jokes, not a factual report.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 9 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Attorney H. W. Worden, representing the Connecticut Fire Insurance Company, filed a plea in abatement in Laporte circuit court arguing that Wesley Fogle cannot serve as executor of Belle Gunness's estate because she is not actually dead. The insurance company is contesting a $2,300 claim on a policy covering the Gunness house and its contents.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 December 1908 · page 3

CLAIMS GUNNESS WOMAN NOT DEAD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

The Connecticut Fire Assurance Company is fighting a $2,500 insurance claim filed by executor Wesley Fogle on behalf of Belle Gunness's estate. The company argues that Fogle cannot be executor since there is no proof Gunness is actually dead.

The Winchester News · 10 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

Judge Richter in Laporte, Indiana overruled a motion for a new trial in the case of Ray Lamphere, who was convicted of burning the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness. An appeal was made to the Indiana Supreme Court.

Wood County Reporter · 10 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Philip Weekly Review · Philip, S.D.

Judge Richter in LaPorte, Indiana overruled a motion for a new trial for Ray Lamphere, who was convicted of burning the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness. An appeal has been filed with the Supreme Court.

Philip Weekly Review · 11 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Elk City Mining News · Elk City, Idaho

Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson, was found guilty only of arson by the jury. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to 2-21 years in state prison, a $5000 fine, and five years' disfranchisement.

Elk City Mining News · 12 December 1908 · page 3

Lamphere Gets 21 Years

I-a Porte ting fire to the Gunness years. should have attention. Pi I I rÆSï \ f 3 1 y l , r 1 / ■

See the clipping

The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va.

Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by burning the Gunness farmhouse, was found guilty only of arson. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years at the Michigan City penitentiary.

The West Virginia News · 12 December 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Fort Worth police report that messages have passed between their city and La Porte, Indiana regarding Belle Gunness, suggesting she may be arrested there. Authorities are investigating the lead carefully.

Paper unidentified · 13 December 1908 · page 10

MAY FIND MRS. GUNNESS IN FORT WORTH

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A bill of exceptions preparatory to an appeal was filed in Laporte circuit court for Ray Lamphere, who was convicted of arson in connection with the burning of Belle Gunness's home. The report notes that her body and those of her children were said to have been found in the ruins following the fire.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 15 December 1908 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The New Era · Walden, Colo. · and 3 other papers

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for setting the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children in La Porte, Indiana, and was immediately sentenced to twenty-one years in the state penitentiary. His attorneys have since appealed the conviction to the Indiana Supreme Court after a motion for a new trial was denied.

The New Era · 17 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Glenwood Post · Glenwood Springs, Colo. · 5 December 1908
  • The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · Idaho Springs, Colo. · 5 December 1908
  • The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo. · 5 December 1908

Paper unidentified · and 3 other papers

Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson for burning the Gunness house, though charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter immediately sentenced him to two to twenty-one years in the state penitentiary.

Paper unidentified · 18 December 1908 · page 7

LAMPHERE IS GUILTY.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb. · 27 November 1908
  • Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · 3 December 1908
  • The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D. · 3 December 1908

In the story →

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

Attorney Worden, who defended Ray Lamphere, said he had evidence Mrs. Gunness is alive, citing a LaPorte woman's affidavit that she rode a train with Gunness in Iowa. The woman claimed she recognized and spoke with her before Gunness left abruptly with a man.

The Daily Gate City · 19 December 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

IS MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE OR DEAD?

Attorney Worden Says He Has Evidence that Murder Farm Owner is Alive.

See moreSee less

LAPORTE, Dec. 19.—Attorney Worden, who defended Ray Lamphere, declared today that he had evidence that Mrs. Gunness is alive. He said that a LaPorte woman who knew Mrs. Gunness well, made an affidavit tnat she rode with her twenty miles on a train in Iowa. She said that she was sleeping in a seat across the isle and recognized her when she woke, and talked with her. She left the train abruptly with a man.

See the clipping

The Parma Herald · Parma, Idaho

A newspaper editor, Mrs. Parkman, publishes an editorial explaining why she blacklists her Republican husband's name from her paper due to political disagreements. She notes that she and her husband agree on many topics, including 'the facts in the Gunness case,' though the case itself is not discussed further.

The Parma Herald · 19 December 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

This is a year-in-review digest of major 1908 events, including the discovery of bodies at the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, and the later conviction of Ray Lamphere for arson (not murder) with a sentence of 2 to 21 years. It also lists numerous unrelated national and international news items from throughout the year.

Paper unidentified · 25 December 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Relatives of Jacob Butts, a restaurant clerk missing since spring, have given up searching for him, with some believing he died at Mrs. Gunness's death farm. Close friends dispute this theory, noting he withdrew only part of his savings before vanishing, suggesting a woman was involved in his disappearance rather than murder.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 27 December 1908 · page 1

BUTTS' RELATIVES BELIEVE WAITER IS NUMBERED AMONG THOSE DEPARTED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A Rushville newspaper account explores rumors that a missing former waiter, Butts, may have been a victim of Belle Gunness, noting he withdrew money before vanishing but left some behind. Relatives, including a cousin who searched extensively, speculate he may have traveled toward LaPorte and fallen victim to the 'arch-murderess,' though his close friends dismiss the theory.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 27 December 1908 · page 1

MURDERESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A railway conductor in Pittsburg, Kansas reportedly sighted Mrs. Gunness, marking the first such sighting claim in that state. The item speculates mockingly about where she might be spotted next.

The Topeka State Journal · 28 December 1908 · page 4

"The white man's burden." or that portion of it. at least which is devoted to the maintenance of supremacy in the pugilistic arena, has taken on added terror because of the ease with which Jack Johnson, the negro, wrested the heavyweight fighting championship from Tommy Burns. That she has not been seen in Kan sas before has probably been disturb ing to the few in this state who think that Kansas should be first or well to the front In all things of this sort. But the fact that Mrs. Gunness has been

See the clipping

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

A humor column of New Year's quips jokes that 1909 readers won't have to endlessly read about Mrs. Gunness being 'located' in various parts of the earth. The remark pokes fun at the flood of contradictory and unreliable sighting reports that dominated coverage of the case.

The Lake County Times · 30 December 1908 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · and 9 other papers

This entry is part of a year-in-review almanac listing major events of 1908, including a brief notice that nine corpses were unearthed on the farm of the late Mrs. Belle Gunness north of La Porte, Indiana. It appears alongside unrelated world news items from throughout the year in a condensed chronological digest.

Valentine Democrat · 31 December 1908 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Also printed in 9 papers
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 31 December 1908
  • The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D. · 31 December 1908
  • · · 1 January 1909
  • Philip Weekly Review · Philip, S.D. · 5 January 1909
  • The Harlem News · Harlem, Mont. · 14 January 1909
  • Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho · 15 January 1909
  • The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · 15 January 1909
  • The San Juan Islander · Friday Harbor, Wash. · 16 January 1909
  • The Athena Press · Athena, Or. · 12 February 1909

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

This New Year's Eve retrospective recaps the major events and deaths of 1908, mentioning the discovery of murders on Belle Gunness's farm near La Porte, Indiana as one of the year's 'dark spots.' It appears alongside other notable 1908 news like the Boyertown theater fire and the assassination of Portugal's king.

Valentine Democrat · 31 December 1908 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D.

This end-of-year summary recounts notable deaths in arts and politics, disasters like fires and floods, and dark events including the Belle Gunness murder farm discoveries, night rider violence, and the Springfield race riots. It then begins a chronological epitome of 1908's major events starting in January.

The Dakota Chief · 31 December 1908 · page 7

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

This year-end summary of major 1908 news events briefly notes that nine corpses were unearthed on the farm of the late Mrs. Belle Gunness, north of La Porte, Indiana. The item appears as a single-line entry amid dozens of other unrelated news events from throughout the year.

Wood County Reporter · 31 December 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

A chief deputy sheriff speculates on what would have happened if swindler-murderer Johann Hoch and Belle Gunness had met and tried to con each other. Both were known for marrying victims for money and then killing them, making the hypothetical meeting a subject of criminological fascination.

The Laramie Republican · 31 December 1908 · page 5

A DRAMA OF VILLAINY.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come