As the Papers Told It

Belle Gunness · The full archive

November 1908, part 3

250 articles

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

At the trial of Ray Lamphere in La Porte, Indiana, Prosecutor Smith presented witness testimony about the fire that destroyed Mrs. Gunness' home and killed her and her three children. Joseph Maxson, Gunness' hired man who escaped the blaze, testified and denied defense suggestions that he had been drugged that night.

Bisbee Daily Review · 19 November 1908 · page 1

WEAVING A WEB

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Prosecutor Smith presented testimony from witnesses who were first at the scene of the fire at Mrs. Gunness's home, aiming to show Ray Lamphere set it and caused the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. The hired man Joseph Maxson denied defense claims that he had been drugged with oranges on the night of the fire.

Arizona Republican · 19 November 1908 · page 3

THE HIRED MAN WAS NOT DOPED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The Connecticut Fire Insurance Company declined to pay the $2,300 policy on Belle Gunness's house to her estate's executor. The company stated it would need proof that Gunness did not set the fire herself, and noted the property was allegedly used for wholesale murder.

Paper unidentified · 19 November 1908 · page 4

GUNNESS' INSURANCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

At Ray Lamphere's trial for the Gunness farmhouse fire, Prosecutor Smith presented testimony from early witnesses at the scene, including hired man Joseph Maxson. Sheriff Smutzer testified that Lamphere had told him Mrs. Gunness was hiding a wanted murderer named Helgelein, a claim that proved false when authorities in South Dakota said Helgelein had no criminal record.

The San Francisco Call · 19 November 1908 · page 6

SHERIFF TESTIFIES AGAINST LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Sheriff Smutzer testified that Lamphere told him Mrs. Gunness was searching for Andrew Helgelein, claiming he was wanted for murder in South Dakota, but authorities there confirmed no such crime occurred. The sheriff also described discovering bodies in the fire debris and the dismembered remains of Helgelein.

The San Francisco Call · 19 November 1908 · page 6

AGAINST LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, Indiana, Prosecutor Smith presented evidence meant to show Lamphere set the fire that killed Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Hired man Joseph Maxson testified and denied defense suggestions that Mrs. Gunness had drugged him with oranges before the blaze.

Los Angeles Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 2

MRS. GUNNESS' HIRED MAN DENIES SHE DRUGGED HIM

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Hired man Joseph Maxson denied defense suggestions that Mrs. Gunness drugged him with oranges on the night of the fire. Prosecutor Sutherland stated the body found was confirmed as Gunness's, along with threats made by Lamphere, while the defense maintains Gunness killed the children and herself before the fire.

Los Angeles Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 2

DENIES SHE DRUGGED HIM

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

Witnesses at Lamphere's trial testified he made repeated threats against Belle Gunness, stemming from a romantic falling-out, and that this culminated in him setting fire to her house on April 28. Testimony from a saloon-keeper, bank cashier, and others also connected Lamphere to items belonging to Gunness's alleged victims.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 1

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 18. —That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Qunness was con clusively shown by a number of the state's witnesses Tuesday, and through them also Prosecutor Smith was able to bring out quite clearly the fact that a strong motive existed for the defend ant to annoy Mrs. Gunness, and that this annoyance terminated on the morning of April 28 In Lamphere's set ting fire to the house. The love affairs of Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere were also told in an in teresting manner by William Slater, and in his testimony the 'state found much of value to strengthen its posi tion that It waa beeause of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

Witnesses at Lamphere's trial testified about his relationship with Mrs. Gunness, including threats he made and his jealous behavior around the property. Bank officials also detailed the large sum of money Andrew Helgelein withdrew before his disappearance, which Mrs. Gunness controlled.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 1

Peter Colson Testifies. Peter Colson testified that Mrs. Gun ness was at times unkind to Jennie Olson. The way in which he related his conversations with Lamphere, his own experiences with Mrs. Gunness, his love for the woman and his suspi cions was straightforward, his broken English adding to the effectiveness of the story. Louis Ruehl, a saloon-keeper, testi fied that Lamphere while in his place of business one night made the re mark that if “the old woman did not leave him alone he would send her over the road.” Lamphere also bor rowed two dollars on a watch which, It is claimed by the state, belonged once to one of Mrsk Gunness' victims.

See moreSee less

Leo Wade, a hack-driver, testified to seeing Lamphere wearing a big gray fur-lined overcoat. He also testified to seeing Mrs. Gunness wearing a man’s fur coat.

See the clipping

Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · and 1 other paper

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, prosecutors presented evidence that the bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse were those of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Ray Lamphere stands accused of their murder.

Audubon Republican · 19 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · 19 November 1908

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, the state presented testimony claiming that Belle Gunness and Lamphere were lovers and that she had promised to marry him. This evidence was offered in the presence of witnesses as part of the prosecution's case.

The Lake County Times · 19 November 1908 · page 4

NEW EVIDENCE OFFERED.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The sheriff recounted the story of the fire that destroyed Belle Gunness' home near Laporte, Indiana, during testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, who is accused of murdering her. The brief item is part of a larger digest of national news items from the day.

The Lake County Times · 19 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Sheriff Smutzer testified under fierce cross-examination that Lamphere had told him Mrs. Gunness was searching for Andrew Helgelein, falsely described as a wanted criminal. The testimony also detailed the $10,000 story and Lamphere's surveillance of the Gunness household, evidence tying Lamphere to Helgelein's murder.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 19 November 1908 · page 7

VISITED GUNNESS HOME. OFFICIAL TELLS OF STATEMENTS MADE TO HIM BY LAMPHERE PREVIOUS TO THE WOMAN'S DEATH.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Sheriff Smutzer testified at the Lamphere murder trial, describing Lamphere's shifting stories about Helgelein's whereabouts and his false claim of a robbery-murder in Aberdeen, S.D. He also detailed finding the bodies in the fire ruins, including the positions of the children and the adult body, and noted an insurance company's refusal to pay the Gunness estate's claim.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 19 November 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Investigators describe the condition of bodies found in the burned Gunness farmhouse, including children found clasped together and a woman with a boy in her arms. The Connecticut Fire Insurance Company refuses to pay Belle Gunness's estate, suspecting she set the fire herself and used the property for murder.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 19 November 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her children continues, with Sheriff Smutzer testifying and cross-examination yielding little new information. Prosecutor Smith presented testimony about the fire from early witnesses, including hired man Joseph Maxson, who denied claims that he had been drugged via oranges or that he told his sister such a story.

Rock Island Argus · 19 November 1908 · page 1

LITTLE PROGRESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

At the Lamphere murder trial, Prosecutor Smith presented witnesses including Joseph Maxson, who denied being drugged by oranges on the night of the fire. Sheriff Smutzer testified that Lamphere had claimed Mrs. Gunness was hunting a fugitive named Helgelien, a story that investigation proved false.

Rock Island Argus · 19 November 1908 · page 1

SHERIFF SMUTZER A WITNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Sheriff Smutzer continues testimony about the positions of Mrs. Gunness and her three children's bodies found in the fire ruins, and describes Lamphere's suspicious behavior including a fabricated robbery-murder story about Helgelein. The state's case is expected to close the following day, with a pastor possibly testifying about an alleged Lamphere confession.

The Topeka State Journal · 19 November 1908 · page 7

STATE'S CASE NEAR END

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, the state presented evidence Friday to prove that the four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness house on April 28 were Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter allowed the coroner's verdict to go before the jury but instructed them to disregard it as proof of Mrs. Gunness's death.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 19 November 1908 · page 10

The Gunness Trial

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, state witnesses testified that Ray Lamphere made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Gunness, suggesting a motive tied to a romantic falling-out. Witnesses including William Slater, Peter Colson, Joseph Maxson, and Louis Ruehl gave testimony about the couple's relationship, Lamphere's suspicious behavior, and the events surrounding the fire that killed Mrs. Gunness.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 19 November 1908 · page 11

' Laporte, Ind, Nov. 18. That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats agalnet Mrs, Belle Gunness was testi fied to by a number of the state's witnesses Tuesday, and through them also Prosecutor Smith made an effort to bring out that a strong motive ex lsted for the defendant to annoy Mrs. Ounness and that this annoyance ter minated on the night of April 18 in Lamphere setting fire to the house. The love affairs of Mrs. Ounness and Lamphere were also related by William Slater, and in his testimony the state claims it has found much of value to ' strengthen its position that it was because of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness. With Joseph MaxBon. the man who escaped alive from the burning house, on the stand the first part of his story of the fire, was told Tuesday. It differs but little from the story which he told following the fire. Until Tuesday there had been nc demonstrations by the spectators and the outbreak when Witness Slater told of the relations between Lam. phere and Mrs. Gunness will probably not be repeated, for Judge Relchtet will order the court room cleared, it It happens again. Peter Colson testified that Mrs. Gun ness was at times unkind to .ennle Olson. The way In which he related his conversations with Lamphere, his own experiences with Mrs. Gunness, his love for the woman and bis sus picions, were unique and straightfor ward, his broken Engusn adding to the effectiveness of the story. Louis Ruebl, a saloonkeeper, testi fied that Lamphere while In his place of business one night made the romnrk that If "the old woman did not leave him alone he1 would send her over the road.", ' 1 Austin Cutler, a local undertaker, testified to the length of time the bodies of Mrs. Gunness and the chil dren were at his morgue before being shipped to Chicago. He said about 200 persons viewed them. The suppo sition Is that from this testimony Prosecutor Smith will lead up to doubt as to how the poison got into tne tnmaphl 1 .. . Leo Wade, a hack driver, testified to seeing Lamphere wearing a big gray fur-lined overcoat. He also tes tified to seeing Mrs. Gunness wearing a man's fur coat. The troubles of Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness, as shown by the records ot Justice Graver's court, were then of fered In evidence. The court records show that one trespass case, one surety of the peace action and proceedings to have Lamphere adjudged Insane, all

See the clipping

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

Witnesses testified at the Lamphere trial, including Joseph Maxson describing the fire and Lamphere's skulking around the property, a saloonkeeper recounting Lamphere's threat to Mrs. Gunness, and court records showing prior legal disputes between them. Other testimony covered the handling of the victims' bodies at the morgue, raising questions about how poison entered the remains.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 19 November 1908 · page 11

DEFENDANT MADE THREATS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, witnesses testified he made threats against Mrs. Gunness after their romantic falling out, with the prosecution arguing this led him to set fire to her house. The defense countered that Mrs. Gunness faked her death by poisoning her children and herself before setting the fire, to escape exposure of her crimes.

The Winchester News · 19 November 1908 · page 3

SAYS MOTIVE EXISTED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

At the Laporte, Indiana trial, Prosecutor Smith presented testimony about the fire at Belle Gunness's home that killed her and three children, focusing on hired man Joseph Maxson's account. Defense attorney Weir attempted to suggest Gunness had drugged Maxson with doped oranges, but Maxson denied this on cross-examination.

The Winchester News · 19 November 1908 · page 4

POISON STORY Is Denied by Witness at Lamphere's Murder Trial

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Vanceburg Sun · Vanceburg, Ky. · and 2 other papers

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, prosecutors introduced evidence aiming to prove that bodies found in the burned Gunness farmhouse were those of Belle Gunness and her three children. Ray Lamphere stands accused of their murder.

The Vanceburg Sun · 19 November 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 19 November 1908
  • The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · 20 November 1908

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, hired man Joseph Maxson testified about the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children, with his account unchanged under cross-examination. The Connecticut Fire Insurance Co. refused to pay the estate, suspecting Gunness set the fire herself, and testimony revealed she had bought an unusual amount of kerosene the day before the blaze.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 November 1908 · page 12

WHO SET FIRE?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

An insurance company refuses to pay Belle Gunness's estate, alleging she set the fire herself and used the house for murder. Trial testimony from witnesses Maxson, Wrase, and Humphrey details the kerosene purchase, Lamphere's suspicious behavior, and the discovery of bodies in the basement.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 November 1908 · page 12

WHO SET FIRE?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial will not dispute that Mrs. Gunness is dead, but will argue she and her children died before the house fire began. This strategy relies on Dr. Walter S. Haines's finding of poison in some of the bodies, meaning Lamphere could not be guilty of murder even if he set the fire.

The Detroit Times · 19 November 1908 · page 7

WILL NOT DENY THAT MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · and 1 other paper

At the Laporte trial, prosecutors sought to prove Lamphere harassed Mrs. Gunness and to pin down the date of the Helgelein murder, suggesting a falling-out over shared profits. Witness Joseph Maxson testified about the fire and his escape, withstanding defense attempts to shake his account.

The Madison Daily Leader · 19 November 1908 · page 1

EFFORTS OF PROSECUTION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · 21 November 1908

The Port Gibson Reveille · Port Gibson, Miss.

Mrs. Dora B. Heeren filed a $30,000 lawsuit against the New York Central Railroad, claiming she was mistakenly identified as Belle Gunness. The brief notes the incident amid other unrelated news items of the day.

The Port Gibson Reveille · 19 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · and 3 other papers

Prosecutor Smith introduced letters Belle Gunness wrote to A. K. Helgelein in which she disparaged 'that crazy Lamphere' to ease suspicions about missing relatives. Helgelein, brother of a missing man, testified after being summoned to Laporte to investigate and bring money.

Ladysmith News-Budget · 19 November 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 20 November 1908
  • The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · 20 November 1908
  • The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont. · 26 November 1908

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children began at Laporte, Indiana, drawing large crowds of farmers and locals. Many residents still believed Belle Gunness had escaped after setting the fire, despite the discovery of fifteen bodies on her farm and suspicions that as many as twenty-five people had been murdered there.

Valentine Democrat · 19 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MTJKDEB CASE , Trial of Alleged Slayer of the Paiaily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte. Ind. , of tht trial of R.'iy Laniphere for tlie murder of 'Mrs. ' Bt'lle Gunncss ami Iicr ithree children by burLiug them to death in the Ounncss "house of a hundred crimes" last April brougUi crowds of farmers and their families to attend the sessions of the famous case. While interest in the country at largo is centered in such further develop ments as the trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings , inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors , "the Brookside Farm , * ' are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Kay Lamphere , the ob-

See the clipping

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

As Ray Lamphere's trial begins in La Porte County, crowds gather and reports note that most locals still believe Belle Gunness faked her death and escaped after burning her home and killing her children. The prosecutor must seat jurors who believe she is dead in order to pursue a murder conviction.

Valentine Democrat · 19 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MURDER CASE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

The report describes the opening of the prosecution's case against Ray Lamphere, which will argue that a gold dental plate and body length prove the corpse found in the fire was Belle Gunness. It also notes the defense will counter with a coroner's physician's statement that the body was not hers, since the head and deformed right arm—key identifying features—were missing.

Valentine Democrat · 19 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MURDER CASE

Mrs. Gunness is dead. The body found in the ruins of the farmhouse apparently was the same length as that of Mrs. Gunness , and later a gold plate , made for Mrs. Gunness by a Laporte dentist , and found in the debris , was positively identified. Contrary to these facts , which will form the basis of the prosecution's contention that Mrs. Guuness is dead,1 the defense will introduce the stakmeiit of one of the coroner's 'board ' of physi cians , which stated positively that the boily found was not that of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness and the remarkable coincidences that the main identfying feahires of the woman's body were missing when the corpse was taken from the ruins. The hotly supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness was without head or right arm when found. The woman's right arm alone would have formed a posi tive identification mark , as it was de formed. The State opened the case with ap parent confidence that the network of evidence would prove so strong as to leave no doubt in the minds of the twelve men as to the complicity of Laraphere in the "mysteries of the house of horror , " and to show that it was the woman's former hired man who. the morning of April 28. set fire to the house in which Mrs. Gunness and her children met death.

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

At the Lamphere murder trial in LaPorte, prosecutors state they have proven Mrs. Gunness is dead and that her body was among those found in the fire ruins. They also claim sufficient evidence of Lamphere's threats against Gunness and his suspicious actions on the morning of the fire, and plan to shorten proceedings by skipping redundant witnesses.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 19 November 1908 · page 1

NET IS TIGHTENING AROUND LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At the La Porte trial, prosecutors announced they had sufficiently proven Belle Gunness was dead and that Ray Lamphere set the fire, so some witnesses would not be called. The defense countered that Gunness killed her children and herself before the fire was set.

Omaha Daily Bee · 19 November 1908 · page 1

PROOF LAMPHERE SET FIRE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At the Lamphere murder trial, prosecutor Sutherland says enough evidence has been shown of threats and arson and the state will shorten its case. The defense counters that Mrs. Gunness killed the children and herself before the fire, while an insurance company refuses to pay out on the burned house.

Omaha Daily Bee · 19 November 1908 · page 1

SOME WITNESSES NOT NEEDED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A newspaper's satirical commentary column briefly mentions that the 'revival of the Gunness murder mystery in Indiana' has one consoling feature: it distracts public attention from local political figures Kern and Taggart. The remark is a passing joke within a broader list of witty observations on unrelated topics.

Omaha Daily Bee · 19 November 1908 · page 6

. ( Tho only' consoling feature of the .revival of the Gunness murder roys tery In Indtana'is that it diverts atten tlon from JCern and Taggart. It would be interesting to know how many bablea born on November have been named Wllhelmina, Instead of William, as originally Intended. "Wa do not elect a senator this year,' he (Mr. Bryan) said with a amlla. Why the smile? . The smile be longs to tho republican occupants of Nebraska's (wo seat in tho senate. One T. Jenkins Halna insists his family la Just a bit proud of hlru.Thl la a little remarkable, in view of tho fact that Halns is In court charged with tho deliberate murder of an un armed man.

See moreSee less

'- The official returns from Douglas county are all in and otlU tho official flgureo on tho recent election n Ne

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Prosecutor Smith presents testimony from witnesses including hired man Joe Maxson about the night of the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children. The report also clarifies the $10,000 story regarding Andrew Helgelien, revealing Sheriff Smutzer's telegram confirmed no murder or robbery occurred and Helgelien was known in Aberdeen.

Paper unidentified · 19 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE CORNERED: Evidence Strong That He Caused Death of Female Bluebeard, He Is Closely Connected With Mrs. Gunness' Helgelien Death

HelgeBne Deai Laporte, Ind., 'Nov. lS^^-Carefully working up to' the denouement?' tlie Vevidence by whidh lt is sought to show that Ray LMppbere s6t fire to the home of Mrs Belle Gunness and thereby caused the death of her and her three children, Prosecutor Smith today unravelled beforp the jurjr jtjie storiea Ot.*h^ flre ttjld bF the" j|^n who were 'earliest on the scene. The greatest Intereet naturally cen? tered sbout the testimony of Jos. Max -i son, the hired msaiv ^ut it varied in no great particular from the story he told to the court, and whieij he relate^ •before the coroner's jurjfc' ^'Indirectly wSlr, for the defense, on cfoes examination, tried to Imply^titsat Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness, on tite night of the fins had "doped", Maxson ia-.t^i^ oranges whid^ he ate, but 'M denied this, 1» lAooording to t®wr defense, Maxaoa Ifw^^-sister such a Story, buthe denied positively ntW stand that he had made such a declaration or-that lie ever believed that there was any1 "dope" In, the oranges, The explanation of the $10,000 story referred to in the letter .from Mrs. Gunness to A. K. Helgeline regarding the disappearance of his btotht'r, was made today. Lamphere. is under in­ dictment for the murder of Aridrew Helgeline and for alleged complicity with Mrs. Gunness in murder. vthat Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of the circumstances whksh could have prevented Helgeline's presence in Laporte. He said that early in January Lamphere came to "him and said: "If I want to tell something, I can make it interesting for her." Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the siheriff that Mrs. Gunness was looking for a man named Helgeline, who waa wanted In South. Dakota for murder, having held up a man in'a gambling house and had seized $10,* 000, but ha4-~been fprced to kill the fellow before.he could get away, Sheriff Smutzer Immediately ^rl'f^d the authorities in Aberdeen, the town named by Lamphere, and received in reply, a telegram that said that there had been no murder nor $10,000 rob­ bery and that Andrew Helgfellne was a well known former in that vicinity and that be was not wanted there for any crime. Sheriff Smutzer, with this disclos­ ure, paid nd attention 'to Lamphere. A month .later Lamphere, when ques­ tioned by the sheriff regarding Helge­ line, told the officer that Hielegeline had left Laporte for Chicago that •morning on the 5:10 train. Sheriff Smutzer also testifiedto See­ ing Lamphere watching Mrs. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to. his office. She complained about Lamphere annoying" her and ^wjten the -'sheriff went to Lamphere and aslfed him why he did not leave the wjoma^ aloi^^e, did not ahswer.

See the clipping

In the story →

Paper unidentified

At Lamphere's trial, witness Maxson denied being drugged with 'doped' oranges the night of the fire, contradicting a defense claim. Sheriff Smutzer testified that Lamphere had given conflicting accounts about Andrew Helgelien's whereabouts and once hinted he could make trouble for Mrs. Gunness.

Paper unidentified · 19 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LAMPHERE CORNERED

Evidence Strong That He Caused Death of Fecale Bluebeard

See moreSee less

He Is Closely Connected With Mrs. Gunness' Helgeline Deal

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 18.—Carefully working up to the denouement, the evidence by which it is sought to show that Ray Lamphere set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness and thereby caused the death of her and her three children, Prosecutor Smith today unravelled before the jury the stories of the fire, told by the men who were earliest on the scene.

The greatest interest naturally centered about the testimony of Jos. Maxson, the hired man, but it varied in no great particular from the story he told to the court and which he related before the coroner's jury.

Indirectly Wair, for the defense, on cross examination, tried to imply that Mrs. Gunness, on the night of the fire had "doped" Maxson in the oranges which he ate, but he denied this.

According to the defense, Maxson was alleged to have told his sister such a story, but he denied positively on the stand that he had made such a declaration or that he ever believed that there was any "dope" in the oranges.

The explanation of the $10,000 story referred to in the letter from Mrs. Gunness to A. K. Helgeline regarding the disappearance of his brothtr, was made today. Lamphere is under indictment for the murder of Andrew Helgeline and for alleged complicity with Mrs. Gunness in that murder.

Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of the circumstances which could have prevented Helgeline's presence in Laporte. He said that early in January Lamphere came to him and said: "If I want to tell something, I can make it interesting for her." Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the sheriff that Mrs. Gunness was looking for a man named Helgeline, who was wanted in South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and had seized $10,000, but had been forced to kill the fellow before he could get away.

Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired the authorities in Aberdeen, the town named by Lamphere, and received in reply, a telegram that said that there had been no murder nor $10,000 robbery and that Andrew Helgeline was a well known farmer in that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime.

Sheriff Smutzer, with this disclosure, paid no attention to Lamphere. A month later Lamphere, when questioned by the sheriff regarding Helgeline, told the officer that Helegeline had left Laporte for Chicago that morning on the 5:10 train.

Sheriff Smutzer also testified to seeing Lamphere watching Mrs. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to his office. She complained about Lamphere annoying her and when the sheriff went to Lamphere and asked him why he did not leave the woman alone, he did not answer.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

At the La Porte trial, prosecutors presented witness testimony, including from hired man Joseph Maxson, tightening the case that Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children. The defense tried to suggest Maxson had been drugged, which he denied under oath.

The Evening Times · 19 November 1908 · page 1

THE GRUESOME TALE TOLD

?ji JLapoite, lnd., Nov. 19.—The chain of evidence which la gradually being drwan around Ray L&mphere for the murder of Mrs. Bell Gunness and her three children was somewhat tighten ed today by strengthening several of the points already Introduced, No tiew evidence except matters tending to ellnch points already made was In troduced. Other Evidence Carefully working up to the de nouement, the evidence by which It Is sought to show that Ray Lamphere Met flie to the home of Mra. Belle Gun ness and thereby caused the death of her and her three ohlldren, Prose cutor Smith today unraveled before the Jury the stories of the fire, told by the men who were earliest on the scene, The-greatest interest natural ly centered abdut the testimony, of Joseph Maxson, the hired man, but it varied In no great partloular from the story he told the coroner and which he related before the grand Jury, Indirectly, Attorney-.

See moreSee less

Weir for the defense, on cross examination, tried to Imply that Mra, Gunness on the night of the flre, had "doped" Maxson in the orange* which ha ate, but he denied this, According to the defense Maxson was alleged to have told his sister such a Ptory, but he denied poaltiveiT on the stand that he had ever made such a declaration or that heaver believed that there was any "dope" in the oranges, •Explanation of the $10,660 story re ferred to la the letter from Mrs, Qun to A, K, Helgetein, regarding the of hia br«thev, waa

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

Courtroom testimony recounts hired man Maxson denying claims he was drugged with doped oranges on the night of the fire, and Sheriff Smutzer describing Ray Lamphere's suspicious stories about Andrew Helgelein being a wanted murderer with $10,000 - a story disproved by South Dakota authorities. The sheriff also detailed the search for bodies after the fire, finding them in the northeast corner under debris.

The Evening Times · 19 November 1908 · page 1

made today. Lamphere Is under In dictment for the murder of Andrew Helgeleln and for alleged complicity with Mrs. GunnesB In that murder. Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of circumstances connected wlth'Helge leln'B presence In La Porte. He said that early In January, Ray Lamphere came to him and said "If I want to tell something, I can make It interest ing for her." Sheriff Smutzer under stood him to mean Mrs. Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the sheriff #hat Mrs. Gunness was then looking for a man named 'Helgeleln, who was wanted In South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and had secured $10,000, but -.V^d been forced to kill the fellow, be ®tti 4,6 00,113 get away.

See moreSee less

SheriffA* immediately wired to the auu^&'•*- Aberdeen,. S. D., the town iu. Lamphere^ and recelv ed in Tep^a, which said that there had been no murder, no $10,000 robbery and that Andrew Hel geleln was a well known farmer In that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime. .Sheriff Smutzer, following this disclosure, paid no further attention to Lam phere. A month later Lamphere,' when questioned, by Sheriff Smutzer regard ing Helgeleln, told the officer that He'N geleln had left La Porte for Chicago that morning on the 6:10 train. Sher iff Smutser also testified to seeing Lamphere watching Mra. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to his office. She qomplalned about Lamphere annoying ner and when the

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

Witnesses at the Lamphere trial testified about Lamphere watching and being confronted about annoying Mrs. Gunness. Sheriff Smutzer and others described the search of the fire ruins, discovery of the bodies, identifying rings, and finding Helgelein's dismembered remains.

The Evening Times · 19 November 1908 · page 1

Gunness. He told of finding the jaw bone and other bones in the same spot where the bodies had been dta covered. The finding of Helgelein's lsmembered body was also told by JB witness. Daniel M. Hutson and Wm. Hum phrey, who helped Sheriff Smutzer to searoh for the dead bodies, and who were early at the fire, related their ex periences, which varied in no way from their former stories. Hutson tftet}fied that he thought Mrs. Gunned weighed in the neighborhood of 245'corfldl pound*. tie Bald that the burned body found in the ruins weighed about 165 pounds in that condition.

See moreSee less

Hutson is the man who recently told a storv of seeing a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness at the farm on July 9. Nothin goh this point was reached In today's evidence.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

At the Lamphere murder trial, prosecutor Smith presented letters written by Mrs. Gunness to A.K. Helgelein about his missing brother, aiming to establish a motive for the house fire. A witness also testified that rings found on the dead woman's fingers were too tight to have been removed without filing, supporting identification of the body as Mrs. Gunness.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 19 November 1908 · page 7

LETTERS OFFERED IN CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, Judge Richter ruled that the coroner's verdict on the Gunness murders was admissible as primary evidence, a defeat for the defense. Coroner Mack testified about finding the bodies in the ruins, identifying one adult female and three children.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 19 November 1908 · page 8

FIRST DEFEAT FOR DEFENSE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.

Prosecutor Smith presents witnesses, including hired man Joseph Maxson, to show Ray Lamphere set fire to the Gunness home. Sheriff Smutzer testifies Lamphere hinted he could tell something 'interesting' about Mrs. Gunness and her search for a wanted man named Helgelien.

Albuquerque Morning Journal · 19 November 1908 · page 1

PROSECUTION DRAWS NEAR ITS CLOSE IN LAMPHERE TRIAL. APPROACHING CLIMAX

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.

Sheriff Smutzer testified at length in the Ray Lamphere murder trial, describing the discovery of ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness's graveyard and the sifting of fire ashes that yielded watches, jewelry, and a bracelet. Cross-examination revealed Mrs. Gunness had visited his office three times to report that Lamphere was harassing her.

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · 19 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHEBE MURDER CASE By Associated Press La Porte, Ind., Nov. 19 Sheriff Smittzer was on the witness stand nearly all morn ing in the trial of Ray Lamphere and told of finding ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness grave yard and of sifting the ashes from the ruins, resulting in the finding of watches, jewelry, bracelet, etc. On cross examination it was brought out that Mrs. Gunness had visited the sheriff's office three times with reference to the fact that Lamphere was annoying her.

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by burning them to death opens at Laporte, Indiana, drawing crowds of 500 before the courthouse doors opened. The report notes widespread public belief that Gunness faked her death and escaped, complicating jury selection since the prosecutor needed jurors who believe she is dead.

Turner County Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MURDER CASE, Trial of Alleged Slayer of the ily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte. Ind., of th* trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belie Guuuoss and her three children by Laming thorn to death in the Gtmness "house of a hundred trimes" brouSM A,)ril mnvds of farmers and their families to attend the sessions of the famous ease. While interest in the country at largo is centered in such further develop ments as tlie trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings, inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors, "the Brookside rami."

See moreSee less

are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Kay Lamphere, the ob scure farm hand around whose person ality lias been built an extraordinary structure of bitterness that involves the whole of Laporte County. As a result of the local feeling and of the wide spread publicity given the case. 500 people had gathered near the court house 'before the doors were open for the first session. After the lirst week of excitement attending the discoveries of the tifteen 'bodies on Mrs. Gunness" farm, where it is believed twenty-live were murdered, attention turned to the mistress of the place and the various theories concern ing her death or escape became, the sole topic of discussion. Nine persons out of ten decided that she is alive, and to this day the major ity of residents think she escaped after setting lire (o her home and killing her children. So if remained fur the State's Attorney to pick only jurors who be lieve her dead, or ir would be impos sible to convict anyone for her murder. The most natural conclusion is that Mrs. Gunness is dead. The body found in the ruins of-the farmhouse apparent-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 20 November 1908

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The Lamphere murder trial begins in Laporte with 500 spectators gathered; prosecutors argue a gold dental plate proves the burned body was Belle Gunness, while the defense cites a coroner's physician who said the body was not hers and that key identifying features (head and deformed right arm) were missing. Public opinion remains split, with many locals still believing Gunness faked her death and escaped.

Turner County Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MURDER CASE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 20 November 1908

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, witness William Slater testified that Ray Lamphere had confessed to an affair with Belle Gunness, to threatening Andrew Helgelien with a gun, and that Gunness had promised to marry him if he joined a secret society and took out insurance. The defense also signaled it would argue Gunness died by suicide.

The Madison Daily Leader · 19 November 1908 · page 4

STATE'S ATTORNEY BRINGS OUT DAMAGING TESTIMONY

RAY LAMPHCR4 nrance were the sensational facts testified to in the Lamphere trial by William Slater, a friend and neighbor of the defendant. Slater was a little unwilling to "tell on Lamphere," but Prosecutor Smith, by frequent refer ence to 81ater'» testimony before the grand Jury, refreshed his memory when ho "couldn't remember," with the result that much damaging evi dence against Laxupbore was brought before the Jury. The first statement of the defense Itt court to show its line of defense was made by Attorney Worden when cross-examining a witness, at which time he remarked that an effort would be made to show that Mrs. Gunness was a suicide.

See the clipping

Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.

State prosecutors announce they will skip several previously subpoenaed witnesses in Ray Lamphere's murder trial, considering key points already proven. The defense counters that even if Lamphere set the fire, Mrs. Gunness had already killed her children and herself, meaning the jury must acquit him of murder.

Bryan Morning Eagle · 19 November 1908 · page 6

Several Not to Testify. -Laporte. Ind.. Nov. 18. Associate Counsel Sutherland at the state attor ney's office announced the state would not use a number of witnesses origin ally subpoenaed In the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Gunness because he felt certain the propositions had already been fully es tablished and further evidence along these lines would be superfluous. From a statement, made by counsel for the defense it became known at torneys for Lamphere will not be wor ried If the titate does prove l.smphere set fire to the house, for the conten tion of the defense now Is Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gun ess disposed of her children and then committed suicide and all were dead before the house was burned. Con sequently, they say. even if Lamp here fired it, the Jury will have to ac quit him, under these circumstances of murder. The jury cannot find hint guilty of arson, It is said. Two In Session,

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, Prosecutor Smith built his case that Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed Mrs. Gunness and her three children, with hired man Joseph Maxson testifying about the blaze despite defense suggestions he had been drugged. Sheriff Smutzer also testified about Lamphere's earlier threat to 'make it interesting for her' and explained how a false story about Andrew Helgelein robbing $10,000 was traced and disproved by telegram from South Dakota authorities.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 19 November 1908 · page 1

DAMAGING TESTIMONY IS GIVEN BY SHERIFF

. Heiv' Statement Made hy the Defendant. LAPOIiTE. Tnd., Xov. IS. Carefully working up to, the evidence with which ho will try to show that Ray Lamphere set fire to the homo of Mrs. Gun ness, and thereby supposedly caused the death of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Prosecutor Smith, in the trial of Lamphere today, uuravelod be fore the jury stories of tho liro, told by men who were earliest on the scene. The greatest interest naturally centered about tho testimony of Joseph Maxson, Mrs. Gunness 's hired man, who escaped from tho burning Gunness home.

See moreSee less

Indirectly Attorney Weir, for the de fense, on cross-examination, tried to imply that Mrs. Gunness, on thc night of the fire, had "doped" Maxson in the oranges which he ate. but ho denied this absolutely. Explanation of tho $10,000 story re ferred to in the 'letter from Mrs. Gunnessto A. K. Ilelgclcin regarding tho disappearance of his brother was made today. Sheriff Smutzer told on tho stand of tho circumstances connectecd with An drew ITelgelcin s presence in Laporte. lie said that earlv in January Bay Lamphere came to him and said': "If I want to toll somothing T can make it interesting for ho'r."

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

Sheriff Smutzer testified at trial about Ray Lamphere's warnings regarding Andrew Helgelein and a false $10,000 robbery-murder story, which Smutzer disproved via telegram to South Dakota authorities. He also described responding to the April 28 fire, organizing the search, and finding Helgelein's dismembered body in the debris.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 19 November 1908 · page 1

IS GIVEN BY SHERIFF

Circulated Falso Report. Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Mrs. Gunness. Lamphere went on to .toll thc sheriff that Mrs. Guuucss was then looking for a man named Hoi geleiu. who was wanted in South Da kota for murder, having hold up a man in a gambling houso and secured $10, 000, but had been forced to kill tho fellow before ho could get away'. .Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired to tho au thorities in' Aberdeen and received in reply a telegram which said that thoro had been no murder, no $10,000 rob berv; that Andrew Ilclgelein -was a ,wel)-kuown-farmcf in that, vicinity and that h'e 'was not wanted there' for any crime.

See moreSee less

A mouth later Lamphere, when ques tioned by Sheriff Smutzer regarding Jlelgoloin. told thc offirer that Ilclge lein had left Laporte for Chicago 'that moraine on thc 5:10 train. Sheriff Smutzer said ho was notified of tho fire about 5 o'clock on thc morn ing of April 28. and told of going there immediately. Ho told of taking charge of thc search for the bodies and of keeping a gang of men at work all day, and of finding tho bodies in tho north east corner, where tho firo had boon tho hottest all day, and where tho great out amount of debris was found. The find ing of Ilclgelein 's dismembered body was also described by the witness.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Prosecutor Smith presents evidence at Ray Lamphere's murder trial, focusing on testimony about the fire that killed Mrs. Gunness and her children. Hired man Joseph Maxson testifies about escaping the blaze, while the defense implies Mrs. Gunness drugged him with oranges, a claim he denies.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 1

TRIAL OF RAY LAMPHERE FOR MURDER OF MRS GUNNESS AND HER CHILDREN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

At Lamphere's trial, witness Joseph Maxson described escaping the burning Gunness home, and the defense suggested Gunness had drugged him with oranges, which he denied. Sheriff Smutzer testified about Lamphere's tip that Gunness was searching for Andrew Helgelein, a man wanted in South Dakota for murder and robbery.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

At the Lamphere trial, Sheriff Smutzer recounted how he had wired Aberdeen authorities to check Belle Gunness's story that a man named Helgelein was wanted for murder and robbery, only to learn Helgelein was a respectable farmer not wanted for any crime. He also described leading the search that found Helgelein's dismembered body amid the fire debris, and recounted Lamphere's claim that Helgelein had left for Chicago by train.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

At the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her children, Prosecutor Smith presented witness testimony about the fire that destroyed the Gunness home. Testimony came from Joseph Maxson, a hired hand who escaped the blaze, and Sheriff Smutzer, who described rumored conflicts between Gunness and Lamphere and the discovery of bodies in the debris.

The Times Dispatch · 19 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

Police in McHenry County, Illinois, began excavating a farm near Marengo believing it may hold multiple murder victims, similar to the Gunness case. A body of a missing neighbor was already found buried in a poultry yard, and the farm's owner, John Betford, was arrested in Nebraska.

Wood County Reporter · 19 November 1908 · page 2

NEW MURDER FARM FOUND.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

Ray Lamphere was brought from the Laporte county jail to circuit court to face a first-degree murder charge in the deaths of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children. The brief item marks the formal start of his trial proceedings.

Wood County Reporter · 19 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis.

At the Laporte, Indiana trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, state's witnesses testified that Lamphere had made numerous threats against Gunness. The testimony was given the previous day in the ongoing proceedings.

Ladysmith News-Budget · 19 November 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, witnesses testified he had made threats against Mrs. Gunness, and the prosecutor argued a falling out between the two gave him motive to set fire to her house. Witness William Slater also testified about the romantic relationship between Lamphere and Gunness.

Iowa County Democrat · 19 November 1908 · page 3

LOVE AFFAIRS IN LAMPHERE CASE FALLING OUT WITH MRS. GUNNESS POSSIBLE CAUSE OF THE CRIME.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, witnesses testified about rings found on the corpse matching those Belle Gunness wore, and her dentist identified dental work and false teeth recovered from the ruins as hers. A defense witness suggested strychnine poisoning may have caused death, which could complicate the arson-murder charge.

Iowa County Democrat · 19 November 1908 · page 4

IS IT BODY OF BELLE GUNNESS QUESTION BECOMES INTERESTING IN LIGHT OF LAMPHERE TRIAL EVIDENCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

At the La Porte trial, the state offered considerable testimony attempting to establish that Ray Lamphere had been hounding Mrs. Gunness and making her life miserable. This was part of the prosecution's case against Lamphere.

The Clarksburg Telegram · 19 November 1908 · page 1

HOUNDED THE WOMAN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

Prosecutor Smith introduced letters Belle Gunness wrote to A. K. Helgelein, urging him to come to Laporte with money even as his brother Andrew lay dead on her property. Bank records confirmed Andrew Helgelein withdrew $2,900 accompanied by Gunness shortly before his presumed murder on January 14.

The Forrest City Times · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LURED BY LETTERS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

At the La Porte Circuit Court trial, deputy sheriffs testified that Ray Lamphere made damaging admissions amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home. Sheriff Smutzer also described his investigation into the Gunness mystery, including debunking a false confession from a Texas inmate claiming to be an accomplice.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 20 November 1908 · page 5

CLOSE TO LAMPHERE

La Porte, Ind., Nov. It.—That Ray Iamphera made damaging admlaeione amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to the home of Mr#. Belle Ounneea on the morning of April S8, was testified to thta afternoon In the La Porte Circuit Court by Deputy Sheriff Anstles and DeputySheriff Marr. Deputy Sheriff Anatlss had not not concluded his testimony when court adjourned. Sheriff Smutzer. who was on the etsnd part of the day, told of his ef forts to unravel the Gunness mystery and the clews which he followed. The Truelson chase to Texas was brought In and exposed as a clever schema, worked up by a man in jail In Texae, whe thought he would be able to escape Ills troubles there by confeselng that he was an accomplice of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Witnesses testify at Ray Lamphere's trial, including Sheriff Smutzer facing defense suspicion, and deputies recounting Lamphere's statements about the fire and his knowledge of Helgelein's death. Deputy Anstiss claims Lamphere did not deny witnessing Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein, though cross-examination reveals Anstiss later changed his belief in Lamphere's guilt.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 20 November 1908 · page 5

EVIDENCE

schema, worked up by a man in jail In Texae, whe thought he would be able to escape Ills troubles there by confeselng that he was an accomplice of Mrs. Gunness. During the cross-examination of Sheriff Smutzer Attorney Wordetf for the defense, by the question!, seem ingly tried to throw sueplcion upon the officer by Intimating that Sheriff Smutzer had been at the Gunnels place In his automobile before the fire. This Smutzer denied. i On redirect examination Prosecutor Smith asked Smutzer If there was In town any other automobile like hie.

See moreSee less

To this the sheriff replied: "Yes; Attorney Worden has one.” Deputy Sheriff Leroy Marr testified that on the evening of April I*. he went to the home of John Wheatbrook to arrest Ray Lamphere. As Marr en tered tbs gate, Lamphere came out of 'he door. Marr testified that he said: "Ray, get on your cost and go to town with roc." Laraphere’s reply was. "Did those three children and the woman get out of the building?” Marr asked. "What building?” Lamphere answered, "That building near town.” Marr asked him where he was when he saw ths fire, and Lamptfero replied “When I got along by the house the smoke was coming out of the windows and around the roof.’ Marr said that he asked Lamphere If he saw anybody around the place, and he said ‘no.,a* , Deputy Sheriff Anstiss testified to having had several conversations with Lamphere after his arrest. Anstles said, "I asked him about the Helgeleln matter, and ha told me first that he was In Michigan City all night. When I told Kim John Rye had told me that he came back with him on the car, he did -not deny It. Then I said to him, When you saw Mrs. Gunness killing Helgeleln, why didn’t you tell Smutzer?’ He said: ’I don’t want to talk about tt.’-‘But you won’t deny It?" I said, ahd ho replied, ‘No, olr.”’ On cross-examination. Attorney Wor den brought out that Anstiss had told friends of Lamphere that although, he believed Lamphere gu^ty at first, he

See the clipping

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

Deputy Sheriffs Antis and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made statements suggesting he knew about and may have set the fire that destroyed Belle Gunness's home, including asking if the children and woman escaped. Under cross-examination, Antis admitted he had changed his mind about Lamphere's guilt after poison was found in the victims' stomachs.

Bisbee Daily Review · 20 November 1908 · page 1

5 Officers Say That He Made Some Damaging Admissions to Them.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in La Porte, deputy sheriffs testified he made statements amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home on April 28. Testimony described his reaction upon arrest, asking whether the woman and three children escaped the burning building, and a remark that he would plead guilty to arson if not for his mother.

Arizona Republican · 20 November 1908 · page 1

PARTIAL CONFESSION OF RAY LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in La Porte, Indiana, Prosecutor Smith presented testimony from early witnesses to the fire, including hired man Joseph Maxson who denied being drugged. Deputy sheriffs testified that Lamphere made incriminating statements suggesting he knew about the fire before being told of it.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 20 November 1908 · page 1

TRIAL OF ALLEGED MURDERER AND FIRE BUG PROCEEDS BUT SLOWLY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

During cross-examination in the Lamphere trial, deputies Antiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made admissions amounting to a partial confession of setting the fire at the Gunness home. The defense tried to suggest Mrs. Gunness had drugged witness Maxson with oranges, which he denied.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE ALMOST CONFESSED, SAYS OFFICER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

In the Laporte circuit court trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her children, deputy sheriffs testified that Lamphere made damaging admissions amounting to a partial confession. He reportedly admitted to setting fire to Gunness's home on the morning of April 28.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 4

LAMPHERE'S CONFESSION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

At the LaPorte trial, Deputy Sheriffs Antiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made statements amounting to a partial confession that he set fire to Belle Gunness's home on April 28. Marr recounted Lamphere's first words upon arrest asking if the children and woman escaped the burning building, while Antiss noted a story about a wanted man named Helgelein at the house was investigated and found false.

Los Angeles Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 3

SAYS ADMISSIONS ARE CONFESSION

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Witnesses Marr and Deputy Sheriff Antiss testify about Lamphere's arrest, recounting his odd question about children escaping a burning building and his claim about a wanted man named Helgelein at the Gunness house, which investigation proved false. Cross-examination reveals Antiss had changed his view of Lamphere's guilt after poison was found in the victims' stomachs.

Los Angeles Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made partial admissions about setting the fire at Belle Gunness's home. Marr recounted Lamphere asking whether the woman and three children escaped the building, while Anstiss said Lamphere indicated he would plead guilty to arson but for concern over his mother.

New-York Tribune · 20 November 1908 · page 12

SAY LAMPHERE MADE ADMISSIONS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified that Lamphere made partial admissions tying him to the fire at Belle Gunness's home. Marr recounted Lamphere asking if the children and woman escaped the building, while Anstiss said Lamphere would plead guilty to arson but for his mother's sake.

New-York Tribune · 20 November 1908 · page 12

SAY LAMPHERE MADE ADMISSIONS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson. Key testimony from Deputy Sheriff Anstiss alleged Lamphere admitted seeing Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein and said he would plead guilty to arson but for his mother.

Evening Star · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS IN GUNNESS CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report covers a Washington hearing on bleached flour before Secretary Wilson, where chemists disputed whether bleaching made flour harmful. It notes that one witness, Prof. Walter S. Haines, had previously served as a toxicology expert in the Gunness trial.

Evening Star · 20 November 1908 · page 23

DISCUSS BLEACHED FLOUR EXPERTS GIVE VIEWS AT SECRETARY WILSON'S HEARING.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

At a pure food board hearing on bleached flour, Professor Haines of Rush Medical College, described as having figured in the Gunness case, testified that bread from bleached flour contained no harmful ingredients. A dispute ensued with Dr. Wiley and another expert over nitrite poisoning claims.

The Washington Times · 20 November 1908 · page 6

ENLIVENS HEARING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

Attorney Worden, representing the defense, plans to argue that Belle Gunness did not die in the fire that destroyed her house. He intends to show that the teeth found in the ruins could not have withstood the fire's intense heat and must have been planted afterward.

The Daily Gate City · 20 November 1908 · page 1

GUNNESS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

At the Lamphere trial in La Porte, the defense attorney claims he can prove the Gunness house fire began before Lamphere left a neighbor's home, suggesting his innocence. He also asserts evidence will show Belle poisoned her first husband, killed her second with a sausage cutter, and is still alive, having been seen recently by witnesses.

The Daily Gate City · 20 November 1908 · page 1

HAS A FEW WITNESSES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

The state rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by burning her house. Defense attorney Worden outlined his strategy, claiming the body found was not Mrs. Gunness, that she had been seen alive in July, and that the victims died of poisoning before the fire.

Evening Times-Republican · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS ITS CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A front-page news index notes that testimony in the Gunness case has concluded, among other listed stories of the day. No further details are given in this index entry.

Evening Times-Republican · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Gunness Testimony Concluded.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

At Ray Lamphere's trial in La Porte, Dr. Gray described medical signs distinguishing strychnine poisoning from suffocation. Coroner Mack testified about removing stomachs from Mrs. Gunness and two children for analysis, and stated that ten bodies plus one extra skull had been exhumed from the Gunness farm.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 3

TELL OF MURDER FARM FINDS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A fragment describes forensic examination of documents in which officials matched handwriting to the name 'Belle Gunness,' using genuine instruments to trace initials and signatures. The testimony appears aimed at proving a document was fraudulently altered or signed.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, the prosecutor introduced letters from Belle Gunness to A.K. Helgelein and documents to establish her signature, building toward the motive for the house fire. A witness testified the rings found on the burned body were too tight to have been removed from Mrs. Gunness's fingers without filing, strengthening the state's identification claim.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 4

EVIDENCE PILED UP IN COURT PROSECUTOR LEADS UP TO MOTIVE OF BURNING HOME OF ARCH FIEND

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Witnesses testified at the Gunness-Lamphere trial, including Mrs. Flynn who noted the dead woman's rings were too tight to remove without filing, and attorney Leliter who described Belle Gunness changing her signature before the fire. Asle Helgelein also testified about his brother Andrew's departure for Laporte and subsequent disappearance.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 4

ACT IS TO BE CLIMAX

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children began in Laporte, with defense attorneys claiming they will prove Mrs. Gunness is still alive. Prosecutors say new evidence will link Lamphere to the Gunness farm murders.

The Jasper Weekly Courier · 20 November 1908 · page 2

Gunness Trial Is On

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

During the Ray Lamphere trial in Laporte, hired man Joe Maxon testified that Belle Gunness handed him a doped orange the night before the fatal fire. The testimony suggested she was plotting to kill him along with others.

The Lake County Times · 20 November 1908 · page 4

PLOTTED TO KILL OTHERS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

The prosecution closed its case against Ray Lamphere with testimony about his confession to deputy sheriff William Anstiss, despite heavy defense objections during cross-examination. The jury has now retired to weigh the evidence, with uncertainty over whether the trial will resume Monday pending a defense witness's availability.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 20 November 1908 · page 1

JURY DEBATES ON LAMPHERE'S GUILT

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Witness Marr recounts arresting Ray Lamphere, who asked whether the children and Mrs. Gunness escaped the burning building, then fled when he saw smoke. Sheriff Smutzer testifies about finding ten bodies and sluicing ashes for jewelry, teeth, and other relics used to identify victims.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 20 November 1908 · page 2

JURY DEBATES ON LAMPHERE'S GUILT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Sheriff Smutzer testified about finding ten bodies on the Gunness farm and the sluicing of ashes that yielded jewelry, watches, and gold dental work. He argued the medical evidence showed Mrs. Gunness's head had burned off rather than being severed, and described exhausting the search for bodies on the property.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 20 November 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE'S GUILT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

In the Belle Gunness murder trial, the state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, who is accused of killing Mrs. Gunness and her three children by arson. Defense attorney Worden outlined his theory that the body found was not Mrs. Gunness's and that the victims died of poisoning before the fire, not burning.

Rock Island Argus · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS; DEFENDANT IN CASE MAY TALK

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

The prosecution concluded its testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house. Deputy Sheriff Anstiss testified about alleged admissions by Lamphere, including that he would not deny seeing Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein, creating a strategic dilemma for the defense.

The Topeka State Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Chanute Times · Chanute, Kan.

In the Lamphere murder trial, the prosecution presented evidence on November 14 asserting that four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness house on April 28 were Belle Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter allowed the coroner's verdict to be shown to the jury but instructed them not to treat it as proof of Mrs. Gunness's death.

The Chanute Times · 20 November 1908 · page 2

The Gunness Trial.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Mount Vernon Signal · Mt. Vernon, Ky. · and 2 other papers

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, letters written by Belle Gunness to Asle K. Helgelein during March and April were introduced as evidence. The letters reportedly referred to 'that crazy Lamphere.'

Mount Vernon Signal · 20 November 1908 · page 4

In the Lamphere trial at Laporte ten by Mrs Belle Gunness to A K Helgelein during March and April this i sear in which references to that l crazy Lamphere are made Two arrests were made in the 18 j 000 South Bend post office robbery

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 20 November 1908
  • The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 20 November 1908

Mount Vernon Signal · Mt. Vernon, Ky. · and 2 other papers

Prosecutors presented evidence in Ray Lamphere's trial at Laporte, Indiana, attempting to prove that the burned remains found at the Gunness farmhouse belonged to Belle Gunness and her three children. Lamphere stood accused of murdering them.

Mount Vernon Signal · 20 November 1908 · page 4

Evidence was introduced by the prosecution in the Lamphere trial at Laporte Ind tending to prove that bodies found in the ruins of the Gun ness farmhouse were those of Mrs Gunness and her three children of whose murder Ray Lamphere is ac cused In a boiler explosion at the Miller Lumber Companys plant at Pound near Pound Gap Ky four men were tilled and four more severely injured Three men were killed outright two were fatally injured and two others were seriously hurt in an explosion at 1 sawmill plant in Wise county Virgi nia The new divorce law increasing the period of residence from six months to one year was carried on November 3 in South Dakota by a vote of two to one

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 20 November 1908
  • The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 20 November 1908

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This is the newspaper's index of today's stories, including a Page Three item describing damaging admissions made by Ray Lamphere, accused in the Belle Gunness murder case, amounting to a partial confession. The same index also lists a separate story claiming other accused men's innocence has been shown.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 1

TODAY'S JOURNAL CONTENTS.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D.

As the Lamphere murder trial begins in Laporte, the report reviews conflicting public opinion over whether Belle Gunness died in the farmhouse fire or escaped after killing her children. It outlines the prosecution's reliance on a dental plate identification versus the defense's argument that the body lacked key identifying features like the deformed right arm.

Dakota Farmers' Leader · 20 November 1908 · page 3

GUNNESS MTTBDER CASE. Trial of Alleged Slayer of the Fam ily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte, Ind., of the trial of Itay Lainphere for the murder of 'Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by burning them to death in the Gunness "house of a hundred crimes" last April brought crowds of farmers and their fumilies to attend the sessions of the famous case. While interest in the country at large Is centered in such further develop ments as the trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings, inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors, "the Brookside Farm," are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Itiiy Liiniphere, the ob scure farm hand arouiul whose ppi*son ality has IXHM built an extraordinary structure of bitterness that involves the whole of Laporte County.

See moreSee less

As a result of the local feeling and of the wide spread publicity given the case, 600 people had gathered near the court house before the doors were open for the lirst session. After the first week of excitement attending the discoveries of the fifteen bodies on Mrs. Gunness' farm, where it is believed twenty-five were murdered, attention turned to the mistress of the place and the various theories concern ing her death or escape became the sol* topic of discussion. Nine persons out of ten decided that she is alive, and to this day the major ity of residents think she escaped after setting fire to her home and killing her children. So it remained for the State's Attorney to pick only jurors who be lieve her dead, or it would be Iinpoe slhle to convict anyone for her murder. The most natural conclusion is that Mrs. GunnesB is dead. The body found in the ruins of the farmhouse apparent-

See the clipping

The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo.

Authorities excavate the farm of John Bedford near Marengo, Illinois, fearing additional bodies after the murder of neighbor Oscar Hoganson, in a case likened to the Gunness and Bender killings. Bedford, arrested in the West, confesses to shooting Hoganson during a dispute over a buggy sale, claiming self-defense, and describes burying the body and stealing the victim's horses.

The Montgomery Tribune · 20 November 1908 · page 6

DIG FOR DEAD ON 'MURDER FARM' WORKMEN RANSACK ILLINOIS ESTATE WHERE RICH NEIGHBOR IS FOUND SLAIN. OWNER ARRESTED IN WEST

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Greene County Herald · Leakesville, Miss.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson has begun in Laporte, Indiana. A jury was secured late in the afternoon as evidence presentation started.

Greene County Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 13.—The intro duction of evidence in the trial of Ray Lamphere, for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the house, has begun a jury having been secured late this afternoon.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

At Lamphere's trial in LaPorte, Indiana, deputy sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made admissions and a partial confession about setting fire to Belle Gunness's home. Marr recounted Lamphere's arrest and his statements about seeing smoke from the burning building, while Sheriff Smutzer described his investigation into the Gunness case, including a false lead from a jailed man in Texas.

The Billings Gazette · 20 November 1908 · page 1

DID LAMPHERE SEE MAN KILLED?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

Deputy Sheriffs Marr and Anstiss testify at the Lamphere trial about his contradictory statements following his arrest, including claims about seeing smoke from the burning house and conflicting accounts of Helgelein's whereabouts. Anstiss recounts Lamphere nearly admitting to witnessing Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein, and offering to plead guilty to arson but for his mother's sake.

The Billings Gazette · 20 November 1908 · page 1

CONTRADICTORY STORY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, Prosecutor Smith presented testimony from witnesses who first arrived at the burning Gunness home, including hired man Joseph Maxson. Sheriff Smutzer also testified about Lamphere's early tip regarding Mrs. Gunness's search for Andrew Helgelein, tied to a fabricated story of $10,000 and murder in South Dakota.

The Billings Gazette · 20 November 1908 · page 6

SHERIFF SPEAKS

Iamphere set fire to the home of iMrs. Belle Gunness and thereby sup posedly caused the death of .Mrs. Gun *pess and her three children, Prosecu or Smith in the trial of Lamphere 'today unraveled before the jury stories '.f the fire, told by men who were first .on the scene. The greatest inter est naturally centered about the testi mony of Joseph Maxson, Mrs. Gun ness' hired man, who escaped from the burning Gunness home, Indirectly Attorney Weir, for the de tense on cross examination, tried to imrply that Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness on the night of the fire had "doped" Maison' in the oranges which he ate, but he denied this. Explanation of the $10,000 story referred, to in the letter from Mrs. "Gunness to A. K. Helgelein, regarding the disappearance of his brother, was mAde today. Sheriff Smutzer told of the circum stances connected with the Andrew Helgelein's presence in Laporte. He Said that early in January, Lamphere came to him and said: "If I want to tell something I cah Silake it interesting for her.' Sheriff Smutzer understood him' to mean Mrs. Gunness. Lamphere went to tell the sheriff that Mrs. Gunness was then looking for a man named Helgelein, who was wanted. in South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and secdred $10,000, but had been forced to kill the fellow before he could get away. Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired to the authorities in Aberdeen and re ceived ih reply a telegram which said that there had been no murder, no $10;000 robbery, that Andrew Helgel ein was a well known farmer in that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime. A month later Lamphere, when questioned by Sheriff Smutzer regarding Helgelein, told the officer that Helgelein,had left Laporte for' Chicago that morning on the 6:10 train. Sheriff 'Smutzer said he was notified of the fire about 5 o'clock on the morn ing of April' 28, and told of going there immediately. He told of taking charge of the bodies and of keeping a gang of men at work all day and of finding the bodies in the northeast corner, where the fire had been the hottest all day and where the greatest amount of debris w"s found. The finding of Hel gelein's dismembered body was also described' by the witness.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

Sheriff Smutzer testified at trial about Ray Lamphere's early tip that Mrs. Gunness was hiding a wanted murderer named Helgelein, which investigation proved false. He also described the fire scene, recovery of bodies, and the discovery of Andrew Helgelein's dismembered remains.

The Billings Gazette · 20 November 1908 · page 6

SHERIFF SPEAKS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.

In the Lamphere murder trial, the prosecution rested and defense attorney Worden outlined his case, claiming Lamphere was a mile away when the Gunness house burned. He also said he would show Belle Gunness killed her first husband for insurance money and remains alive.

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children by arson began with jury selection and Prosecutor Smith's hour-long opening statement. Smith outlined that Indiana law made the fatal fire murder regardless of intent, and previewed evidence of Lamphere's threats against Gunness and his own admissions about the night of the fire.

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 5

RAY LAMPHERE PLACED ON TRIAL / Introduction of Evidence Begins In Gunness Murder Case / CORONER IS FIRST WITNESS / Jury Is Secured and Prosecutor Smith Outlines Case Against Accused Man / Tells In Detail What the State Expects to Prove

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.

Prosecutor Smith's opening statement argues that setting a fire causing deaths constitutes first-degree murder even without intent to kill. He details evidence including Lamphere's alleged threats against Mrs. Gunness, his movements on the night of the fire, and his reported first words upon arrest asking if the occupants escaped.

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 5

RAY LAMPHERE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.

At the Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, witness John Nye testified about a trip with Lamphere to Michigan City, during which Lamphere spent money given to him by Belle Gunness. Another witness recounted a conversation in which Lamphere said that if he quarreled with Gunness he could force her to pay him.

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 20 November 1908 · page 8

LAMPHERE TRIAL.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

The state concluded its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house. The defense finished cross-examining Deputy Sheriff Anstiss about alleged admissions made by Lamphere after his arrest, and is now considering whether to put Lamphere on the stand.

The Evening Times · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The prosecution concluded its case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house, after cross-examining a deputy sheriff about alleged admissions by Lamphere. The defense opened its case and is weighing whether to put Lamphere on the stand.

Paper unidentified · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, witness William Slater testified that Lamphere confessed to an affair with Mrs. Gunness, had chased Andrew Helgelein with a gun, and that she promised to marry him once he joined a secret society and took out insurance. The prosecutor pressed Slater with his grand jury testimony to overcome reluctance, while the defense signaled it would argue Mrs. Gunness committed suicide.

The Washburn Leader · 20 November 1908 · page 6

EVIDENCE IN THE LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Golden Valley Chronicle · Beach, N.D.

A brief notice states that Hans Christianson of Bottineau, North Dakota, is wanted as a witness in the Gunness murder trial taking place at La Porte, Indiana. The item is one of many short local news items in a roundup column.

Golden Valley Chronicle · 20 November 1908 · page 5

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.

The State rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house. The report notes the court proceedings continued with testimony being taken.

The Roswell Daily Record · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS ITS CASE IN THE LAMPHERE TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

In Laporte, Indiana, the state rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere, who is accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house. The brief report notes the conclusion of the prosecution's presentation of evidence.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS ITS CASE IN LAMPHERE TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

At his murder trial, Ray Lamphere's attorney opened the defense by arguing the prosecution treated him unfairly and that he could prove an alibi placing him elsewhere the morning of the fire. The lawyer also claimed witnesses would testify that the deaths resulted from poisoning rather than violence, and that Belle Gunness had been seen alive after the fire.

The Evening World · 20 November 1908 · page 3

LAMPHERE OPENS HIS DEFENSE WITH CLAIM OF ALIBI

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Mahoning Dispatch · Canfield, Ohio

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, state witnesses testified that he had made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Gunness. William Slater's testimony supported the prosecution's theory that a romantic falling-out motivated Lamphere to harm his former sweetheart.

The Mahoning Dispatch · 20 November 1908 · page 12

The Lamphere Trial Laporte Ind Nov 18 That Hay Lamphero made numerous threats against Mrs Dello Gunness was tho testimony of a number of the states witnesses Tuesday In tho trial of Lamphere for the murder of Mrs Gunness Tho love affairs of Mrs Gunness and Lamphere were told by

See the clipping

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

The state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her children, after deputies testified he made damaging admissions about setting the fire. The defense countered that Mrs. Gunness was alive and seen after the fire, claiming the body found was another woman's.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 20 November 1908 · page 1

,t ' ness Killing Helgelein. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 20 Tho State today rested Its enso against Itay Lamrheiu, accused of tho murder f Mis. Belle Chimin's ami nor child ren. 'Attorney Wonlon outlined the dcfer.so nnd said ho expected to provo Mrs. launness was nllvo mil had been scon near hor old home months nftor tho flro. i Wonlon Intimated thnt tho body pr tho woman found In tho mint UUIU10S6. was that of n woman iwho visited Mrs. (iunneps a week beforo tho lire tihd that tho dofimBO would show that 'Mrs;-dimness had a motlvo tor killing her children ami disappear' ' ing.

See moreSee less

"' 'lMie -defenso clnlnu that tho fire 1 broke' out 1G minntoa (hoton; 'Lamp here left' lht' Houso of Kllzabst1) HirtlUii 'a negros, ilivl thoroforo ho could" -not -linYo Uml Ww bltlldln; which fbt a inllo from the negress' hft nonle,

See the clipping

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

A gossipy opinion column touches briefly on the Belle Gunness case, noting that even if Ray Lamphere is proven to have killed her and burned her home, the public might still debate whether he deserves conviction and execution or a different kind of recognition. The rest of the piece covers unrelated political and international topics.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 20 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.

After the state rested its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children, defense attorney Worden made his opening statement. He declared that the defense's evidence would show Mrs. Gunness is still alive.

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · 20 November 1908 · page 1

WORDEN OPENS DEFENSE IN LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Weekly Chieftain · Vinita, Okla.

Sheriff Smutzer spent most of the morning on the witness stand describing how he found ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness's graveyard and sifted ashes from the ruins, recovering watches, jewelry, and a bracelet. Cross-examination revealed that Mrs. Gunness had visited the sheriff's office three times to complain that Ray Lamphere was annoying her.

The Weekly Chieftain · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE MURDER CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.

The state rested its case in the murder trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of killing Mrs. Gunness and her children. Defense attorney Worden opened by asserting evidence would show Mrs. Gunness is still alive.

The Daily Ardmoreite · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE DEFENSE BEGINS STATE RESTS ITS CASE IN TRIAL OF LAMPHERE FOR MURDER OF MRS. GUNNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.

Sheriff Smutzer testified at trial about discovering ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness's graveyard and sifting ashes from the ruins, finding watches and jewelry. Cross-examination revealed Mrs. Gunness had visited his office three times claiming Lamphere was annoying her.

The Daily Ardmoreite · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE ANNOYED HER LAPORTE SHERIFF SAYS MRS. GUNNESS ADVISED HIM LAMPHERE WAS ANNOYER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa.

At the Lamphere murder trial in LaPorte, witnesses testified about his love affair with Belle Gunness and his threats against her, suggesting a motive for the fire that killed her and her children. The courtroom reacted angrily to the revelations, causing Lamphere to weep.

The Citizen · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Woman Who Lured Him to Her Home. Laporte, Iud., Nov. 18. Kay Lainphere, the farmhand accused of mur dering Mrs. Belle Guliness and her three children by setting lire to their home, wept In court when the spec tators, Indignant ut the revelntlons made by witnesses for the prosecu tion, shouted out angry threats against him. Several witnesses testified that Laraphere made numerous threats ngalnst Mrs. Belle Gunuess. Through these witnesses Trosecutor Smith tried to prove that a strong motive existed for Liunphere to nunoy Mrs. Gunness and that this alleged annoyance terminat ed on the morning of April 28 In Lain phere setting tire to the Gunuess house and burning the murderess and her children.

See moreSee less

The love affairs of Mrs. Gunuess and Lampherc were told by William Sla ter, and his testimony tended to veri fy the state's contention thnt it wns because of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress. The relations between Lamphere and Mrs. Gunuess as described by Slater caused a demonstration in the crowd ed courtroom, which was packed to suffocation, while hundreds hung around the outside unable to gain ad' mittance. Peter Colson said he left the em ployment of Mrs. Gunness because he had been infatuated with her, but later he became suspicious, and, fear ing her, he concluded to get away. He said he had been suspicious of the woman since the death of her hus band, retei Gi.7ir.es3. He said Lain phere had threatened to get even with Mrs. Gunness, who had turned Lam phere down for Helgelein. The troubles of Lamphere and Mrs, Gunness, as shown by the records of Justice Grover's court, were offered In evidence. The court records show ed one trespass case, one surety of the peace action and proceedings to have Lamphere adjudged Insane, all insti gated by Mrs. Gunness. Joseph Mnxson, a hired man, who escaped alive from the burning Gun ness home, described the premises and the Gunness family circle fully. He told of seeing Lamphere skulking around the premises at night and said that Lamphere ran when discovered.

See the clipping

The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa.

Prosecutor Smith presented evidence that Ray Lamphere had motive to harm Belle Gunness after being spurned for Helgelein, including testimony from Slater, Colson, and Maxson about threats, stalking, and court records of disputes. The hired man Maxson, who survived the fire, described seeing Lamphere skulking around the property at night.

The Citizen · 20 November 1908 · page 1

THREATS TO MRS. GUNNESS.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The News-Democrat · Providence, R.I.

The state rested its case today in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house. The announcement came after the defense finished cross-examining Deputy Sheriff Anstiss about alleged admissions made by Lamphere following his arrest.

The News-Democrat · 20 November 1908 · page 2

STATE RESTS IN LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The News-Democrat · Providence, R.I.

A brief miscellaneous commentary item notes that Mrs. Gunness, the Laporte, Indiana murderess, fed her victims oranges she had secretly doped, calling it an ingenious method of killing. The remark appears amid unrelated political and labor news items in a general news roundup.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The News-Democrat · 20 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Aberdeen Democrat · Aberdeen, South Dakota

In La Porte circuit court, Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified about confessions that amounted to a partial admission of setting fire to Mrs. Gunness's house on the morning of April 28. Anstiss's testimony was not yet finished when court adjourned for the day.

The Aberdeen Democrat · 20 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.

Testimony began in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with murdering Belle Gunness and three children. Coroner Mack testified first, describing finding the bodies in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse.

The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 20 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Palestine Daily Herald · Palestine, Tex.

The prosecution rested in the Ray Lamphere murder trial, and defense attorney Worden announced plans to prove that Belle Gunness is still alive. He argued Lamphere was miles away when the house burned and that Gunness set the fire herself, substituting another woman's corpse to fake her own death.

Palestine Daily Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 1

It Will Yet Prove That Mrs Gunness Is Alive

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.

Prosecutor Smith presented testimony from Joseph Maxson, the hired hand who was among the first to discover the fire at Mrs. Gunness's home, building the case that Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed her and her three children. The defense tried to suggest Mrs. Gunness had drugged Maxson with oranges, which he denied, while testimony also linked the case to the disappearance of Andrew Helgelein.

Bryan Morning Eagle · 20 November 1908 · page 1

MAXSON TESTIFIES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.

Testimony at Lamphere's trial covered Maxson's denial of being drugged, and Sheriff Smutzer's account of Lamphere's suspicious behavior and false statements regarding Andrew Helgelein's whereabouts. The testimony aimed to establish Lamphere's complicity with Belle Gunness in Helgelein's murder.

Bryan Morning Eagle · 20 November 1908 · page 1

MAXSON TESTIFIES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

At Lamphere's trial in LaPorte, Indiana, deputy sheriffs testified that Ray Lamphere made statements amounting to a partial confession about setting fire to Belle Gunness's home on April 28. Sheriff Smutzer also testified about his investigation, including the Truelson Texas lead which was exposed as a fraudulent scheme by a jailed man seeking to escape his own legal troubles.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 20 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE MADE A FEW ADMISSIONS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

Deputy sheriffs testify at Lamphere's trial that he made incriminating statements, including asking if the children and woman got out of the burning building before officially being told of a fire, and admitting he did not deny witnessing Gunness kill Helgelein. Witnesses also describe conflicting accounts Lamphere gave about his whereabouts and a false story about a wanted man named Helgelein being at the Gunness house.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 20 November 1908 · page 1

DAMAGING TESTIMONY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

At Lamphere's trial, Deputy Sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified he made admissions amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to Belle Gunness's home. Sheriff Smutzer also testified about investigative leads, including a Texas jail inmate's false claim of being an accomplice, which was exposed as a hoax.

The Salt Lake Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 3

WOULDN'T PLEAD GUILTY ON ACCOUNT OF HIS MOTHER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Deputy Sheriff Marr testified about arresting Ray Lamphere, describing how Lamphere asked whether 'those three children and that woman' had gotten out of the building before the fire. Other deputies corroborated testimony about Lamphere's statements regarding Mrs. Gunness and a man named Helgelein wanted for murder in South Dakota.

The Salt Lake Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Deputy Sheriffs Smutzer and Anstiss testify at Lamphere's trial about his statements regarding Helgelein's disappearance and his reluctance to deny witnessing Gunness commit murder. Lamphere reportedly said he would plead guilty to arson but for concern over his mother.

The Salt Lake Herald · 20 November 1908 · page 3

WOULDN'T PLEAD GUILTY ON ACCOUNT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

The state completed its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere at LaPorte, Indiana, who is accused of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house. The report simply notes the prosecution's case has concluded.

The Laramie Republican · 20 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · Idaho Springs, Colo. · and 3 other papers

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial in La Porte, Indiana, witnesses testified that the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house was positively that of Mrs. Belle Gunness. Two rings found on the corpse's fingers were identified as having belonged to her.

The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · 21 November 1908 · page 7

In the trial at La Porte, Ind., of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, wit nesses positively identified the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house as that of Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the fingers of the deal body were declared to have belonged to Mrs. Gunness.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Julesburg Grit-Advocate · Julesburg, Colo. · 20 November 1908
  • The Glenwood Post · Glenwood Springs, Colo. · 21 November 1908
  • The New Era · Walden, Colo. · 3 December 1908

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · and 1 other paper

Sheriff Smutzer testified at length in the trial of Ray Lamphere, describing the discovery of ten bodies in Gunness's graveyard and the sluicing of ashes that yielded jewelry, watches, and Mrs. Gunness's gold teeth. Cross-examination by defense attorney Worden failed to shake his testimony, which also revealed Gunness had reported Lamphere's harassment to the sheriff's office three times.

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 21 November 1908 · page 2

SHERIFF ON THE STAND

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 20 November 1908

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

At the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, defense witness Dr. Wasser cast doubt on whether a gold crown exhibit matched the teeth stubs identified as Mrs. Gunness's. The defense suggested she may have removed her own bridgework and placed it in the fire to fake her death, while awaiting testimony from a Chicago doctor on poison found in the victims' bodies.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Gunness Murder Trial Makes Good Progress

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A defense witness, Dr. Wasser, testified doubting that the gold crown exhibit ever fit the teeth stubs claimed by the state, suggesting Mrs. Gunness could have removed her bridgework before the fire to fake her death. The state rested its case after testimony from Deputy Sheriff Anstiss regarding Lamphere's alleged admissions about witnessing the killing and his willingness to plead guilty to arson.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

At the La Porte trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, the defense presented testimony including witnesses on the timing of the house fire. Dr. Walter Haines was expected to testify that poison was found in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and three of the bodies recovered from the Gunness ruins, while another expert cast doubt on dental evidence used to identify Mrs. Gunness.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 21 November 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE DEFENSE PUTS TESTIMONY BEFORE THE JURY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

This report covers the Lamphere trial, describing defense attempts to suggest Mrs. Gunness removed her dental bridgework before the fire, with Dr. Wasser testifying crowns could be removed without burning the roots. It also details testimony about an empty trunk retrieved from the Warwick place and Deputy Sheriff Anstiss's statements implicating Lamphere as having witnessed Gunness kill Helgelein.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 21 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

A newspaper's miscellany column lists brief offhand remarks on various current affairs, including one line noting that 'the Mrs. Gunness story is under full steam ahead again.' It offers no specific details, only wry commentary that the saga seems endless.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 21 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Colorado Statesman · Denver, Colo. · and 1 other paper

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial in La Porte, Indiana, witnesses testified that the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house was positively that of Mrs. Belle Gunness. Two rings found on the corpse's fingers were also identified as having belonged to her.

The Colorado Statesman · 21 November 1908 · page 2

In the trial at La Porte, Ind., of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Guimess and her three children, wit nesses positively identified the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness, house as that of Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the fingers of the dead body were declared to have belonged to Mrs. Gunness.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Elk Mountain Pilot (Irwin, Colo.) · Ruby Camp · 26 November 1908

The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in La Porte, Indiana, for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, witnesses testified that the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house was positively identified as Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the corpse's fingers were said to have belonged to her.

The Monte Vista Journal · 21 November 1908 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The prosecution concluded its case in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness, described as Laporte's arch-murderess. The item appears as a brief news digest entry among other Eastern news items.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The state rested its case in the Lamphere trial after a deputy sheriff testified to incriminating admissions by the defendant, including that Lamphere allegedly saw Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein. The defense opened by arguing Mrs. Gunness is still alive, was seen after the fire, and that the body and dental evidence found in the ruins were not hers.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 2

STATE CONCLUDES IN TRIAL OF LAMPHERE TWO IMPORTANT POINTS ARE EMPHASIZED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

At the Lamphere murder trial, defense attorney Worden argued that Mrs. Gunness was not killed in the fire but is still alive, claiming the dental evidence and witness sightings prove this, and asserted she poisoned the victims and set the fire herself. Prosecution evidence regarding poison found in the bodies was also mentioned, along with a separate report on a shooting in San Jose.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Gazette · Cleveland, Ohio

Witnesses at Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, Indiana, testified about his romantic relationship and quarrels with Mrs. Belle Gunness. They also described threats Lamphere had made against her.

The Gazette · 21 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

After the state rested its case, defense attorney Worden opened by arguing that the body found in the fire was not Mrs. Gunness's, citing witnesses who claimed to have seen her alive in July and disputing the dental identification. He contended Gunness, fearing exposure over her brother-in-law's death and Lamphere's knowledge of it, set the fire herself and escaped, with another adult and three children poisoned and left in her place.

New-York Tribune · 21 November 1908 · page 5

DEFENCE OF LAMPHERE OPENS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, the defense opened its case arguing that the body found in the Gunness house fire was not Mrs. Gunness herself, and that she had been seen alive afterward by witnesses. The defense contended she set the fire and fled fearing exposure upon the arrival of Asle Helgelien, who came to investigate his brother's death.

New-York Tribune · 21 November 1908 · page 5

DEFENCE OF LAMPHERE OPENS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

At the Ray Lamphere murder trial in La Porte, Indiana, the defense unsuccessfully sought a continuance to Monday because key witness Dr. W.F. Haines, who would testify about arsenic and strychnine found in the victims' stomachs, was unavailable. The defense was forced to proceed with other testimony instead.

Evening Star · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

The state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by arson. In his opening statement, defense attorney Warden argued the body found was not Mrs. Gunness, that she had been seen alive in July, and that the victims died of poisoning rather than fire.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 21 November 1908 · page 1

ATTORNEY WARDEN IN OPENING STATEMENT OUTLINES THE DEFENSE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Elk City Mining News · Elk City, Idaho

At the Ray Lamphere trial in Laporte, Indiana, his attorneys decided not to call any defense witnesses until the state had conclusively linked him to the murders at the Gunness farm. They believe the prosecution will struggle to make that connection and may rest without calling a single witness.

Elk City Mining News · 21 November 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte for the murder of Belle Gunness, testimony was introduced describing remarks he allegedly made to sheriff-elect William Anstiss shortly after his arrest. The report frames these words as evidence presented during the ongoing proceedings.

The Lake County Times · 21 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The prosecution concluded its case against Ray Lamphere at the trial in Laporte, Indiana. Defense attorney Worden stated he would present three witnesses who claimed to have seen Belle Gunness alive after the farmhouse fire.

The Lake County Times · 21 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La.

Mrs. Dora B. Heeren filed a $30,000 lawsuit against the New York Central Railroad after being mistaken for Mrs. Belle Gunness. This item appeared among many unrelated news briefs in a daily roundup column.

The Donaldsonville Chief · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The St. Mary Banner · Franklin, La.

A traveling carnival advertisement lists numerous attractions appearing in town, including "The Gunness Tragedy" alongside acts like The Merry Widows, Wild West Show, and Big Snakes. This shows the murders had already been commercialized into popular entertainment and spectacle.

The St. Mary Banner · 21 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

At the Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, the defense introduced testimony questioning whether the bridgework found in the fire ruins truly belonged to Belle Gunness, suggesting she may have planted it to fake her death. The defense also anticipated testimony from Dr. Walter Haines regarding poison found in the victims' bodies.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 November 1908 · page 2

MAKES GOOD PROGRESS.

Ind., Gats In Considerable Evidence. Laporte. Ind.. Nov. 20.—Excellent progress was mudii by the defence in the amount of testimony placed before the Jury today in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Rclle Gunness and her three children; but aside from two witnesses to show that the Are at the Gunness house occurred at 3 o'clock in the morning of April 28 no statement advanced by Attorney Worden in his opening statement was followed up. Court will be held to morrow, the expectation being that Dr. Walter Haines of Chicago, the de fence's main witness, will he here to testify that he found poison in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and three of the four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness home.

See moreSee less

Dr. George Wasser, who was called as an expert, was shown the teeth and bridge work introduced by the state and identified by state witnesses as having come from the mouth of Mrs. Belle Gunness. He doubted whether a gold crown in the exhibit ever was made to fit the teeth stubs to which It was said by the state to have been attached. The defence tried to show that Mrs. Gunness might have removed the bridge work from her mouth and plac ed It In the fire to lend the impression ! that she was burned to death. Dr. Wasser said the crowns could have I been removed intact without burning UBS. MART MEYER. 8. MARY MEYER, Thomson Avenue, near Shell Road, Win field, L. 1., N. Y., writes: “I have been annoyed with a cough for years. Often it was so bad that I could not sleep half the night. Many people thought I had consumption. Consumption “A woman recom Was Feared.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At the Ray Lamphere murder trial, the defense presented its case, arguing that Mrs. Gunness did not die in the farmhouse fire but is still alive. They claimed she had been sighted on several occasions since the fire.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial in La Porte, after the state rested its case, defense attorney Worden opened by asserting the body found in the ruins was not Belle Gunness's, and that she had been seen alive afterward by a neighbor and two girls. The report covers only the defense's opening statement, not yet any evidence presented.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 November 1908 · page 1

THINKS MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At the trial, deputy sheriffs Anstiss and Marr testified that Ray Lamphere made admissions amounting to a partial confession of setting fire to Belle Gunness's house on April 28. Sheriff Smutzer also testified about his investigation efforts, including debunking the Texas chase and a rumor about a wanted man named Helgelien being at the Gunness house.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 November 1908 · page 18

ADMISSIONS OF LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The defense in Ray Lamphere's trial made progress with testimony suggesting the Gunness house fire occurred at 3 a.m. A key witness, Dr. Walter Hines, is expected to testify that poison was found in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and three of the four bodies found in the fire's ruins.

Paper unidentified · 21 November 1908 · page 4

LAMPHERE DEFENSE'S INNING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

A satirical column aside notes that Ray Lamphere is accused of killing Belle Gunness and cremating her body to hide the crime. It jokes that Lamphere is 'between two fires,' with his victim presumably in one.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 21 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The defense in Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children made good progress presenting testimony after the state rested its case. A forthcoming witness is expected to testify about poison found in the victims' remains, and the defense is expected to argue that Mrs. Gunness may still be alive.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, having presented testimony about poison found in the victims' stomachs and alleged admissions by Lamphere to Deputy Sheriff Anstiss. The defense then opened by claiming the body found in the ruins was not Belle Gunness's, suggesting she was seen alive after the fire and that dental evidence did not match.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 2

MAY BE ALIVE

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Attorney Worden's opening statement for the defense argued that the body found in the ruins was not Mrs. Gunness, citing witnesses who saw her in July and disputing the dental evidence. He claimed Gunness had motive to fake her death and flee, and that the four bodies found died of poisoning rather than fire.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 November 1908 · page 2

WILL SHE BE ALIVE

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Daily Press · Newport News, Va.

At the La Porte trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, the defense presented testimony including an expert dentist who cast doubt on the state's identification of teeth and bridgework as belonging to Mrs. Gunness. The defense suggested she may have removed the dental work herself before the fire to fake her death, while awaiting a Chicago doctor expected to testify about poison found in several bodies.

Daily Press · 21 November 1908 · page 6

(By Asre. iatci Press ) LA PORTE, IND. No* 2?.?Excel-J lent progress was made by t de? fense In the amount <>f testimony] placed before ilnJury today in the trial of Buy Lamphere for the murder1 tf Mrs. Helle Qunness and her three children; but aside from t*o wl -] nesses to show that the fire, ai tin Gunness house, accurred al o'clock! In the morning o April 28. no pro position advanced by Attorney Wooden in his opening statement was followed up. Court will he held tomorrow, the expectation being I hitt Dr.

See moreSee less

Waltr Hayes, of Chicago, the defense's main] witness, will be here to testify that he found poison in the stomachs > f Andrew Helgeleiu and three of the. four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness house.

See the clipping

Daily Press · Newport News, Va.

A defense witness questioned whether a gold crown exhibit actually fit the teeth stubs attributed to Mrs. Gunness, suggesting she may have removed dental work before setting the fire to fake her death. The State rested its case after cross-examination of Deputy Sheriff Anstiss, emphasizing testimony that Lamphere admitted witnessing Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein and would plead guilty to arson but for his mother.

Daily Press · 21 November 1908 · page 6

Thla announcement was made when tbe defense finished the cross exami? nation cf Deputy Sheriff Anstlss. Tae State lsys great stress on two points In the testimony of Anstlss. Srst. the statement of Anstlss that Lamphere hnd admitted he won!.! not deny having seen Mrs. G?nnes, kill Helgelein, tbe second, Anstlss' state ment that f<an:,>here had ssid he would plead ratify to arson were it not for bis motVr.

See the clipping

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

In the Lamphere murder trial, the defense questioned the dental bridgework evidence used to identify Belle Gunness's remains, with an expert doubting a gold crown matched the teeth. The State formally rested its case after cross-examination concluded, with the defense expected to call a Chicago doctor to testify about poison found in victims' stomachs.

The Times Dispatch · 21 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

At the Lamphere trial, the defense challenged whether the dental bridgework exhibit matched teeth stubs, suggesting Mrs. Gunness could have removed it herself before the fire to fake her death. The State rested its case after cross-examination of Deputy Sheriff Anstiss, emphasizing his testimony that Lamphere had implied he saw Gunness kill Belegelin and had offered to plead guilty to arson but for his mother.

The Times Dispatch · 21 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

A jury was impaneled at Laporte, Indiana for the trial of Ray Lamphere, and the state prosecutor outlined his case. Prosecutors described identifying the bodies found in the farmhouse ruins, in a roundabout way, as those of Belle Gunness and her three children.

Spirit of the Age · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

During Ray Lamphere's trial, letters were read in court showing how Belle Gunness responded to inquiries made on behalf of Andrew Helgelien, one of her suspected victims. This detail appeared within a condensed weekly news roundup covering many unrelated stories.

Spirit of the Age · 21 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

At LaPorte, Indiana, the state concluded its presentation of evidence against Ray Lamphere, who is accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by burning her house. The brief dispatch notes only that the prosecution's case is now complete.

The Laramie Republican · 21 November 1908 · page 1

STATE RESTS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

At the Lamphere murder trial in LaPorte, Indiana, the state's associate counsel announced that further witnesses were unnecessary because it had already proven Mrs. Gunness was dead and that her body, along with her three children's, was found in the fire's ruins. He added that evidence of Lamphere's threats against her had been introduced and that proof of his setting the fire would follow.

The Laramie Republican · 21 November 1908 · page 3

TELEGRAPHIC BRIEFS. Proved Woman's Death. LaPorte, Ind., Nov. 18.—Associate Counsel Sutherland of the state's at torney’s office announced today that the state would not use a number of the witnesses subpoenaed, in the Lam phere murder trial because it was felt certain that the propositions had al ready been fully established, and that further evidence along these lines woul4. be superfluous. “We have proved beyond a doubt that Mrs. Gunness is dead and it was her body found in the ruins of the fire, with the bodies of her throe children," said Mr. Sutherland. “We also introduced a lot of evi dence to prove threats made against Mrs. Gunness by Lamphere. Lam phere’s setting the fire will next be shown. We expect to finish our evi dence by Saturday.”

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial in LaPorte, Indiana, farmer D.H. Hutson testified he saw Belle Gunness with a strange man at the orchard two months after her house burned down. His two daughters corroborated his account.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 22 November 1908 · page 1

Mrs. Gunness Lives Says Witness

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, farmer D. N. Hutson testified he and his daughters saw Mrs. Gunness alive with a strange man on the farm months after the fire. Other witnesses described finding a hole in the basement suggesting a hidden skull, and a farmhand testified about a hidden door key, as the defense sought to cast doubt on whether the headless body found was truly Mrs. Gunness.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 1

ODD BITS OF EVIDENCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Witnesses testify at the Gunness murder trial, including a man who found a stone covering a hole shaped like a skull in the basement, and a farmhand who described being instructed by Mrs. Gunness to hide a key for mysterious visitors and later dig a deep hole. The defense suggests more bodies may be buried under a shed based on this testimony.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 1

ODD BITS OF EVIDENCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

This is a newspaper's front-page index listing stories inside, including a one-line tease: 'New sensation in Gunness trial.' No actual details of the sensation are given in this passage.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 1

INDEX OF TODAY'S NEWS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The court pushed to finish the Lamphere murder trial quickly despite the defense's request for delay due to a witness's absence. Witnesses testified about arsenic and strychnine found in victims' stomachs and described sightings of Mrs. Gunness and a mysterious woman before the fire.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 22 November 1908 · page 24

RUSHING THE TRIAL COURT WANTS TO COMPLETE LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Witnesses testified at the Lamphere trial about seeing Mrs. Gunness and an unidentified man on July 9, with a neighbor identifying her by build and walk despite a veil obscuring her face. The defense suggested the headless adult body found in the fire ruins may have been a strange woman murdered by Gunness rather than Gunness herself, with poison findings in victims' stomachs also mentioned.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 22 November 1908 · page 24

LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

A neighbor recalls seeing a strange woman wearing a black veil over a white one walking with Mrs. Gunness the Saturday before the fire. The defense argues this woman was murdered by Gunness and her body was the adult corpse found in the ruins.

Bisbee Daily Review · 22 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

Witnesses Daniel Hulzen, his daughters, Fred Rickman, and John Anderson testified about seeing Mrs. Gunness and a strange woman shortly before the fire. Hulzen, who helped dig for bodies after the fire, insisted he could not be mistaken about recognizing her despite a veil obscuring her features.

Bisbee Daily Review · 22 November 1908 · page 1

SAW MRS. GUNNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

At the Lamphere trial in La Porte, several neighbors testified to seeing a veiled, unidentified woman with Mrs. Gunness in the weeks before the fire, including one encounter the Saturday before the blaze. The defense argues this mystery woman may have been the adult female victim found in the ruins, not Belle Gunness herself.

Arizona Republican · 22 November 1908 · page 1

A MYSTERIOUS WOMAN SEEN WITH MRS. GUNNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

At the Lamphere trial in LaPorte, witnesses including Daniel Hulzen, his daughters, Fred Rickman, and John Anderson testified about seeing a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness the Saturday before the fatal fire. Hulzen, who had helped dig for bodies after the fire, said he saw Mrs. Gunness on July 9 but could not distinguish her features due to a black veil.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 22 November 1908 · page 1

NEW SENSATIONS IN THE LAMPHERE TRIAL WITNESSES TESTIFY TO SEEING MRS. GUNNESS BEFORE FATAL FIRE. ALWAYS ACCOMPANIED BY MEN AND HAD FONDNESS FOR WEARING VEILS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.

Witnesses testified at the Lamphere trial, including Hulzen's daughter Evelyn who saw Mrs. Gunness riding in a buggy with a man, and neighbor John Anderson who saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness before the fire. The defense argues this unidentified woman may be the adult body found in the fire ruins, suggesting she was murdered by Mrs. Gunness.

Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 22 November 1908 · page 4

NEW SENSATIONS IN THE LAMPHERE TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

At the Lamphere trial, witnesses including Daniel Hutzen and his young daughters testified about seeing a veiled woman resembling Mrs. Gunness accompanied by a gray-haired man near the farm on July 9, shortly before the fatal fire. The defense sought to use these sightings to establish the identity of the second adult body found in the ruins.

The San Francisco Call · 22 November 1908 · page 20

STRANGE WOMAN IN GUNNESS CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Neighbors including Hutzen and his two young daughters testified at trial to seeing Mrs. Gunness in a buggy with an unknown gray-haired man shortly before the fire, with her face partly hidden by a veil. Another witness, Ryckman, testified he dug a hole on her property and later became unconscious after drinking with two men who visited the house.

The San Francisco Call · 22 November 1908 · page 20

GIRLS SAW MRS. GUNNESS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

At Ray Lamphere's trial in Laporte, witnesses including Daniel Hulzen and his daughters testified to seeing Belle Gunness with a strange veiled woman days before the fire, fueling the defense theory she killed a substitute victim. Hulzen insisted he recognized Gunness despite her veil, describing her companion as an older gray-haired man.

Los Angeles Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 1

STRANGE WOMAN MAY HAVE BEEN SUBSTITUTE DEFENSE THINKS SHE KILLED GUEST RESEMBLING HER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Trial testimony includes neighbors and children describing seeing Belle Gunness alive after the fire, traveling by buggy with an unidentified man wearing a double veil. Other testimony describes a hired hand digging a hole at her direction and being drugged by visiting men, with a doctor set to testify about poison found in victims' stomachs.

Los Angeles Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BELLE GUNNESS SEEN AFTER FIRE STRANGE WOMAN MAY HAVE BEEN SUBSTITUTE DEFENSE THINKS SHE KILLED GUEST RESEMBLING HER Sensations Sprung in Trial of Ray Lamphere at Laporte—Witnesses Positive in Identification of Slayer

[By Associated Press.]

See moreSee less

LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 21.—The sensations in the Lamphere trial today were the stories told by Daniel M. Hulzen and his daughters, by Fred R. Rickman and by John Anderson, who saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness on the Saturday before the fire.

Hulzen and his daughters declared they saw Mrs. Gunness July 9, but they were unable to distinguish her features through a black veil. Hulzen, a neighbor of Mrs. Gunness and one of the men hired by the sheriff to dig in the ruins of the house for the bodies after the fire, declared he knew Mrs. Gunness so well he could not be mistaken. He said:

"I saw her on the road near the hog pen on July 9. I was returning from town with a rayrack and saw two persons at the Gunness place.

"She had on a light skirt, black waist, wide brimmed hat, a white veil on the hat and a black veil that came down to her chin.

"There was a man with her. He weighed about 150 pounds and had a gray mustache and gray hair.

Afraid to Follow Them

"When I got to within two wagon lengths they got into their buggy and drove on, and I tried to follow them.

"They got ahead of me, and I did not like to follow them. There was too good a chance of getting a chunk of lead. The buggy had a low running gear and black top. The horse was gray with dapples on his hips as large as a half dollar."

Evelyn, the 11-years-old daughter of Hulzen, who followed her father on (Continued on Page Two)

BELLE GUNNESS SEEN AFTER FIRE (Continued from Page One)

the stand, testified she saw Mrs. Gunness in "hay time" near the woods. She was in a buggy with a man. They passed her in the road.

The girl said Mrs. Gunness had on two veils, a black one and a white one, the black one being over her face. The girl said:

"When I saw her she turned her face away from me."

Still Another Witness

Eldora Hulzen, 9 years old, said: "I was playing by the big gate by the road. I saw Mrs. Gunness go by with a man. She had on a double veil and a wide brimmed hat. I did not know the man."

John Anderson, another neighbor of Mrs. Gunness, saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness the Saturday before the fire. This is the woman who, the defense contends, was murdered by Mrs. Gunness and whose body was tht adult body found in the fire ruins.

Fred R. Rickman testified he had worked for Mrs. Gunness three different times. One afternoon under her directions he dug a hole five feet deep and five feet long. Later an automobile with two men arrived.

Drank Wine Together

Mrs. Gunness was in town, but upon her instructions the witness told the men the key was under the mat. They went into the house, he said, and there was some drinking.

Before he went home one of the men gave him a glass of wine and on the way home he became unconscious and did not know anything until the next afternoon.

One of the men gave Mrs. Gunness money to pay him.

Dr. Walter F. Haines will go on the stand Monday to tell of the finding of poison in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and the supposed Mrs. Gunness and two of her children.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the Lamphere trial, neighbors including Daniel Hutson, his two young daughters, and John Anderson testified for the defence that they saw a heavily veiled Mrs. Gunness on her property days after the fire, accompanied by a mustached man and later by another woman. All witnesses insisted they could not have mistaken her identity despite the veil.

New-York Tribune · 22 November 1908 · page 3

SAW MRS. GUNNESS AFTER THE FIRE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the Lamphere trial, neighbors Daniel Hutson, his two young daughters, and John Anderson testified for the defense that they saw Belle Gunness alive after the fire that supposedly killed her, describing her as heavily veiled and accompanied by others. All witnesses insisted they knew her well enough not to be mistaken despite the veil.

New-York Tribune · 22 November 1908 · page 3

SAW MRS. GUNNESS AFTER THE FIRE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

At the murder trial of Ray Lamphere, witness D.H. Hutson testified he saw Mrs. Belle Gunness alive with a strange man at the farm on July 9, months after the fire in which she was believed to have died. The report notes his testimony had already been largely discounted by other accounts, and his daughters corroborated his story on the stand.

The Washington Times · 22 November 1908 · page 8

MRS GUNNESS ALIVE WITNESS TESTIFIES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, defense witnesses Hutson and his daughters testified they saw Belle Gunness with a strange man near her farm two and a half months after the fire that supposedly killed her. Another witness, Fred Rithman, testified Gunness had confided in him about a hidden door key, and Lamphere's trunk was opened revealing only old letters, neckties, an album and books.

The Washington Times · 22 November 1908 · page 8

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, farmer D.H. Hutson and his daughters testified they saw Belle Gunness alive with a strange man on her farm in July, months after she supposedly died in the fire. The defense countered with a farmhand witness and produced Lamphere's trunk, which contained only old letters, neckties, an album, and books.

The Washington Times · 22 November 1908 · page 8

MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE, WITNESS TESTIFIES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

At the Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, the defense opened by presenting evidence intended to show Belle Gunness is still alive and had accomplices who helped her escape after killing her children and burning her house. Witnesses including Joseph Maxson and Daniel Hutson were questioned, with Hutson claiming to have seen Gunness alive in July, while twenty-five defense witnesses including a Chicago doctor were slated to testify.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 22 November 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE'S LIFE NOW IN BALANCE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

At the Lamphere murder trial, the defense unexpectedly called state witness Joseph Maxson for direct examination about the night of the fire, and announced plans to call Dr. Walter S. Haines to testify about strychnine found in the victims' stomachs. A planned exposure involving Prosecutor Smith's visit to the Gunness farm fizzled, while a local pastor publicly criticized women flocking to attend the sensational trial.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 22 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

At the Ray Lamphere murder trial in Laporte, Indiana, defense witnesses testified they saw Belle Gunness alive after her house burned down. Daniel Hutson claimed to have seen her on July 9 with an unidentified gray-haired man, though he admitted on cross-examination he could not see her face.

Paper unidentified · 22 November 1908 · page 1

Defense in Lamphere Trial Tries to Show Mrs. Gunness Is Not Dead / Witnesses Claim to Have Seen Her Day After Her House Burned

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

At the Lamphere trial in La Porte, witnesses including a father and his two young daughters testified to seeing Mrs. Gunness with a mysterious veiled companion before the fire, while another witness described digging a hole and strange men visiting the house. The defense suggests the unidentified woman seen with Gunness may have been the adult body found in the ruins.

The Morning Astorian · 22 November 1908 · page 1

SENSATIONAL EVIDENCE IN LA PORTE CASE THREE WITNESSES ARE ON THE STAND AND ARE INTERESTING.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Prosecution rests its case in the Lamphere trial, and defense attorney Worden announces he will prove Belle Gunness is still alive and that Lamphere was a mile away when the house burned. He claims Gunness set the fire herself and substituted another woman's body after realizing her crimes were discovered.

Laredo Weekly Times · 22 November 1908 · page 11

THE LAMPHERE TRIAL Prosecution Rests Defense Dr dares It Will Be Able Io Prove Mrs Gunness Is Still Alive By OsilHi lr • Laport \ j'* i lion retted in the Lamph» t ww

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, farmer D. N. Hutson testified he saw Belle Gunness alive with a strange man on her farm two and a half months after the fire in which she was presumed to have died. His two daughters corroborated the sighting, insisting the woman they saw was Gunness.

Paper unidentified · 22 November 1908 · page 1

SAW GUNNESS AFTER FIRE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

The defense in the Lamphere murder trial sought an adjournment until Monday because Dr. Walter S. Haines, a Chicago expert, was unavailable due to testifying in Washington. The request was denied, forcing attorneys to proceed with other evidence ahead of Haines's planned testimony about strychnine found in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness, two children, and Helgelein.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 22 November 1908 · page 4

MOVE FOR DELAY IN LAMPHERE CASE BLOCKED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Testimony at Ray Lamphere's trial claimed several witnesses saw a woman resembling Belle Gunness near her farm on the Saturday before the fire, days after she was presumed dead. The defense advanced the theory that the headless body found in the ruins was not actually Gunness, suggesting she faked her death.

The Salt Lake Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 6

GUNNESS WOMAN SEEN AFTER FIRE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

At the inquest, neighbor Hutzen and others testified they saw a veiled woman resembling Mrs. Gunness near her farm on July 9, accompanied by an unidentified man in a buggy. Hutzen claimed certainty based on her build and walk despite not seeing her face, while his young daughter Evelyn corroborated seeing the pair.

The Salt Lake Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 6

BODY IN RUINS NOT THAT OF THE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Witnesses testify at Ray Lamphere's trial to seeing a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness in a buggy with a man near the woods and road after the fire, including two young girls who described her clothing and veiled face. The defense argues this proves Mrs. Gunness is alive and that the adult body found in the ruins belonged to a different woman she had murdered.

The Salt Lake Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 6

BODY IN RUINS NOT THAT OF THE GUNNESS WOMAN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, defense witnesses Daniel Hutson and his two young daughters testified they saw Belle Gunness alive days after the fire that destroyed her home, describing her as heavily veiled and accompanied by a mustached man. The witnesses insisted they knew her well enough not to be mistaken.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Times Dispatch · 22 November 1908 · page 13

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · and 1 other paper

The state rested its case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children by arson, after testimony from Deputy Sheriff Anstiss about alleged admissions by Lamphere. The defense opened by arguing the body found was not Mrs. Gunness, that she had been seen alive in July, and that the victims had actually died of poisoning before the fire.

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 23 November 1908 · page 2

STATE RESTS IN LAMPHERE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 21 November 1908

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney released a letter claiming Belle Gunness was alive and that the writer had accompanied her away from the farm. The attorney said he was trying to locate the writer to testify before the case went to the jury.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 23 November 1908 · page 1

MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A letter received by the defense attorney in the Lamphere trial claims Mrs. Gunness is still alive, with the anonymous writer stating he accompanied her away from the farm on July 9 after she poisoned her children and set the house ablaze using coal oil and a slow match. Meanwhile, Dr. Walter Haines is expected to testify about finding strychnine and arsenic in the victims' remains.

Paper unidentified · 23 November 1908 · page 4

SAY MRS. GUNNESS IS STILL ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' was sent to attorney Worden from Michigan City, giving an address and threatening to kill him if he attempted an arrest. Authorities were trying to determine who actually sent it, while the Lamphere defense neared the end of its case.

Evening Times-Republican · 23 November 1908 · page 1

MRS. GUNNESS WRITES?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney received letters claiming Belle Gunness survived and set the fire herself before fleeing. A doctor also testified that the stomach contents of Gunness and her children were examined together in one jar, making poison detection inconclusive.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 23 November 1908 · page 1

DID MURDERESS WRITE LETTER?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A letter sent to Laporte's mayor claims Belle Gunness is alive and orchestrated the fire herself, killing her children and substituting a headless victim's body for her own. The writer says he helped her retrieve hidden valuables and that she still communicates with him, hoping Lamphere will be convicted.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 23 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' was sent to attorney Worden from Michigan City, claiming she could be found there and threatening to kill him if arrested. Police are working to identify the actual sender as the defense in the Ray Lamphere trial prepares to rest its case.

Rock Island Argus · 23 November 1908 · page 1

TRYING TO LOCATE SENDER OF LETTER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cairo Bulletin · Cairo, Ill.

An anonymous letter to La Porte's mayor claims Belle Gunness is alive and that the writer accompanied her away from the farm on the day she allegedly vanished. The letter states Gunness hopes Ray Lamphere will hang or receive a life sentence, prompting defense attorneys to search for the letter's author.

The Cairo Bulletin · 23 November 1908 · page 1

IN LETTER TO LA PORTE MAYOR WRITER DECLARES THAT SHE CERTAINLY IS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' was sent to attorney Worden, threatening him and giving a Michigan City address, though its authenticity is under investigation. Meanwhile, the defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial presented final evidence suggesting the fire started before Lamphere could have set it.

The Topeka State Journal · 23 November 1908 · page 6

LETTER FROM MRS. GUNNESS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

The state finished presenting direct testimony in the murder trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of killing Belle Gunness and her three children, and the defense began calling witnesses. Testimony included expert analysis of dental evidence identified as Belle Gunness's, and questioning about Lamphere's trunk retrieved after his arrest.

The Winchester News · 23 November 1908 · page 3

STATE COMPLETES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial in Laporte, defense attorney Worden released a letter claiming Mrs. Gunness is alive and that the writer accompanied her away from the farm on July 9. Worden was trying to locate the anonymous letter-writer to testify before the case went to the jury.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 23 November 1908 · page 1

MRS GUNNESS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney released a letter from an unnamed Chicago man claiming Belle Gunness is alive and that he had helped her flee the farm on July 9. The letter alleges she poisoned her children and set the house ablaze herself, but the author could not be located to testify.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 November 1908 · page 12

MRS. GUNNESS IS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, defense witnesses testified seeing a car leave the Gunness farm the night of the fire, suggesting Belle Gunness may still be alive. A farmer also testified that a stranger produced teeth from his pocket during the ash-screening process, casting doubt on how this key identification evidence was actually found.

The Detroit Times · 23 November 1908 · page 1

DEFENSE SCORES A STRONG POINT FARMER TESTIFIES FAVORABLY TO RAY LAMPHERE—TEETH WERE IN MAN'S POCKET

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.

A photograph caption identifies Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness, alongside Nettie Smutzer, described as one of the principal witnesses at his trial. The image appears amid unrelated local news items in the newspaper page.

The Hattiesburg News · 23 November 1908 · page 8

Ray Lamphere and Nettie 8mutzer, one of the principal witnesses at the trial of Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness. EXTERNAL REMEDY FOR ECZEMA ■ Why Salves Fail While a 8imple ' Liquid Has Accompanied Thou ■ liquid. ' Such a liquid can be obtained by

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb. · and 1 other paper

Several neighbors testified at the Lamphere trial about seeing Mrs. Gunness with an unknown man and woman near her farm before the fire, which the defense argues supports their theory that another woman's body was found in the ruins. A hired hand also described digging a mysterious hole and being drugged by visitors, while a toxicologist was set to testify about poison found in the victims' remains.

Omaha Daily Bee · 23 November 1908 · page 7

DEFENSE OF RAY LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont. · 24 November 1908

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

At the Lamphere trial in La Porte, defense witnesses including Daniel Hutson and his daughters, Fred Ryckman, and John Anderson testified they saw Mrs. Gunness near her farm on July 9, accompanied by a strange man. Hutson claimed he recognized her despite a veil obscuring her face, describing the buggy, horse, and her companion in detail, though he admitted under cross-examination he could not see her actual features.

Omaha Daily Bee · 23 November 1908 · page 7

DEFENSE OF RAY LAMPHERE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

During Roy Lamphere's murder trial, defense attorney Worden revealed a letter from an anonymous Chicago writer claiming Mrs. Gunness is alive and that he personally drove her away from the farm in July. The letter alleges she poisoned her children and set the house ablaze herself using a slow match after dousing it with coal oil.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 23 November 1908 · page 2

Claims Mrs. Gunness Is Alive

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.

A letter signed with Belle Gunness's name was sent to Attorney Worden claiming she would be found at an address in Michigan City, threatening violence if an arrest was attempted. Efforts are underway to identify the letter's true author amid the ongoing Ray Lamphere murder trial.

The Guthrie Daily Leader · 23 November 1908 · page 1

SAYS MRS. GUNNESS IS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness,' sent to Attorney Worden, claimed she could be found at an address in Michigan City and threatened violence if he tried to have her arrested. Authorities sought to identify the sender while the Lamphere murder trial continued, with the defense presenting its final evidence.

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · 23 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The News-Democrat · Providence, R.I.

Lamphere's attorney Worden released a letter claiming the writer had been in contact with Belle Gunness five days earlier and had accompanied her away from the farm on July 9. The letter alleges she poisoned her children and burned the house using a slow match after soaking it in coal oil.

The News-Democrat · 23 November 1908 · page 3

ATTORNEY SAYS MRS. GUNNESS IS ALIVE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah

A letter signed Mrs. Belle Gunness was sent to Attorney Worden, giving a Michigan City address where she claimed she could be found and threatening to kill him if he had her arrested. Meanwhile, the defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial began presenting its final evidence, with closing arguments expected that night.

Deseret Evening News · 23 November 1908 · page 6

BELLE GUNNESS LETTER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

During Ray Lamphere's murder trial, three defense witnesses testified they saw Belle Gunness alive days after the fire that destroyed her home. A neighbor and his two young daughters claimed to have seen her heavily veiled with a mustached man, insisting they could not be mistaken.

The Barre Daily Times · 23 November 1908 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children is nearing its end, with Dr. Walter Haines expected to testify about strychnine and arsenic found in the victims' stomachs. The defense has countered with evidence suggesting Gunness was alive in July, months after the fire, and has offered an alibi timeline for Lamphere.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 24 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' was sent to Attorney Worden, claiming she could be found at a Michigan City address and threatening to kill him if he attempted her arrest. Meanwhile, the defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial has begun presenting its final evidence.

The Daily Sentinel · 24 November 1908 · page 1

A MYSTERIOUS LETTER.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The report notes that Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Gunness, is attempting to establish an alibi in court. It also mentions testimony suggesting the alleged murderess may still be alive.

Los Angeles Herald · 24 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The defense in Ray Lamphere's trial introduced testimony suggesting the Gunness farmhouse fire began before 3 a.m., which would make it impossible for Lamphere to have set it given his claimed departure time. Witnesses also described a mysterious letter signed by Belle Gunness and an automobile seen fleeing the scene, supporting theories she was still alive.

Los Angeles Herald · 24 November 1908 · page 2

LAMPHERE TRIES TO PROVE ALIBI WITNESS SAYS MINER PUT TEETH INTO ASHES EVIDENCE OFFERED TO SHOW WOMAN IS STILL ALIVE

[By Associated Frees.] LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 23.-Efforts are being made to learn the Identity of the person who sent to Attorney Worden today from Michigan ( ity a letter signed "Mrs. Belle Gunness, and according to it Mrs. Gunness would be found at a Michigan City address given in the letter. The communication concludes: it you attempt to have me arrested 1 will kill you. Come at 10:30 o clock. Come at once. Call for Mrs. McCon nßThe defense In the trial of Ray Lamphere, for the alleged murder or Mrs Gunness and h*«r three children, began today the introduction of the final bits of evidence in behalf of the prisoner.

See moreSee less

Evidence intended to prove that an automobile -wjas seen to go down the Gunness road the morning of the burnInjr of the home of Mrs. Gunness, and also to show that the fire had been seen as early as 3 o'clock, was offered The' defense contends that the fire •was started before 3 o'clock and that, admitting that Lamphere left the Smith house at 3:30 as claimed by the state, he could not possibly have fired the house. Saw an Automobile Louise Gackle testified she saw an automobile on Park street, coming from the Gunness road at 3:30 on tho morning of the fire. The defense inti mates that this machine might have contained Mrs. Gunness fleeing from the fire after killing the children and firing the house. John Ball testified to seeing a skull removed from a vault on the Cunness place. The lower jaw was missing. The skull was introduced in evidence by the defense, the purpose being to tend to show it to be the missing head of Mrs. Gunness.

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The defense in the Lamphere murder trial introduced testimony suggesting the Gunness fire began before 3 a.m., making it impossible for Lamphere to have set it, and presented witnesses who saw an automobile leaving the scene. A skull found in a vault was introduced to cast doubt on the state's identification of the body as Mrs. Gunness.

Los Angeles Herald · 24 November 1908 · page 2

WOMAN IS STILL ALIVE

The' defense contends that the fire •was started before 3 o'clock and that, admitting that Lamphere left the Smith house at 3:30 as claimed by the state, he could not possibly have fired the house. Saw an Automobile Louise Gackle testified she saw an automobile on Park street, coming from the Gunness road at 3:30 on tho morning of the fire. The defense inti mates that this machine might have contained Mrs. Gunness fleeing from the fire after killing the children and firing the house. John Ball testified to seeing a skull removed from a vault on the Cunness place.

See moreSee less

The lower jaw was missing. The skull was introduced in evidence by the defense, the purpose being to tend to show it to be the missing head of Mrs. Gunness. In order to cast doubt upon the

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, witness testimony described an automobile seen leaving the Gunness farm around 3:30 a.m. on the morning of the fire, which the defense suggests may have carried Mrs. Gunness fleeing after killing her children and setting the blaze. A letter purportedly signed by Belle Gunness was also received by defense counsel, threatening him and inviting a meeting in Michigan City.

New-York Tribune · 24 November 1908 · page 12

MRS. GUNNESS ESCAPED IN AUTO?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At Ray Lamphere's trial, witnesses testified an automobile was seen near the Gunness farm around the time of the fire, suggesting Belle Gunness may have escaped after setting the blaze. The defense also revealed a threatening letter purportedly signed by Mrs. Gunness, claiming she could be found in Michigan City.

New-York Tribune · 24 November 1908 · page 12

GIVING MRS. GUNNESS ESCAPED IN AUTO?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The La Porte circuit court trial of Ray Lamphere was adjourned until the afternoon to await the arrival of Dr. W. S. Haines of Chicago, a key defense witness. Haines was expected to testify about arsenic and strychnine found in the stomach of the adult female body identified as Mrs. Gunness and in two of the three children's bodies recovered from the fire ruins.

Evening Star · 24 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

Dr. Walter Haines of the University of Chicago testified as an expert witness in the Lamphere trial, describing his analysis of the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and an adult body found in the Gunness house ruins. He concluded that death was caused by strychnine poisoning, with the defense's case expected to close soon.

The Daily Gate City · 24 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Sheriff Smutzer testified at length during the Ray Lamphere trial, describing the discovery of ten bodies in Belle Gunness's graveyard and the sifting of fire ashes that yielded jewelry, watches, and her gold teeth. Deputy Sheriff Anstiss also testified to incriminating admissions made by Lamphere, while the state argued Mrs. Gunness's head had burned off rather than been cut off.

Paper unidentified · 24 November 1908 · page 3

SHERIFF SMUTZER ON STAND IN GUNNESS CASE AT LA PORTE, IND.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Sheriff Smutzer described finding ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness' graveyard and recounted gold-miner Schultz's sluicing of ruin ashes, which yielded watches, jewelry, gold teeth, and other identifiable items. He testified the head had burned off rather than been severed, countering defense claims, and withstood cross-examination about rings tied to Lamphere's harassment of Gunness.

Paper unidentified · 24 November 1908 · page 3

DAMAGES DEFENSE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' was sent to Attorney Worden from Michigan City, claiming she would be found there and threatening to kill anyone who tried to arrest her. Authorities are trying to identify the actual sender as the defense in Ray Lamphere's trial prepares to rest its case.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 24 November 1908 · page 1

NEW GUNNESS MYSTERY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

A letter signed "Mrs. Belle Gunness" was sent to prosecuting attorney Worden, giving a Michigan City address and warning that she would kill him or herself if an arrest was attempted. Authorities were working to determine who actually sent the note.

Lewiston Evening Teller · 24 November 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The report notes that the third week of Ray Lamphere's murder trial began, with indications it would conclude before the week's end. He was charged with murdering Belle Gunness and her three children at La Porte.

The Lake County Times · 24 November 1908 · page 4

TRIAL MAY END SOON.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

A news digest notes that evidence in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children, was expected to close that day in Laporte, Indiana. The item appears as a brief entry among many unrelated national and international news items.

The Lake County Times · 24 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

At Ray Lamphere's murder trial, a doctor confirmed finding strychnine and arsenic in the victims' stomachs, and a witness named Louise Gackle testified she saw a red automobile pass by and a fire glow near the Gunness farm around 3 a.m. on the night of the blaze. She explained she kept precise time due to taking medicine hourly, and admitted she had not come forward earlier for fear of being drawn into the scandal.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 24 November 1908 · page 7

WOMAN TELLS OF ESCAPE. SAYS SHE SAW RED AUTOMOBILE IN EARLY MORNING AND WITNESSED THE GUNNESS HOME BURNING.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Miss Gackle testifies she saw the Gunness farm fire and a passing automobile at 3 a.m., supporting the defense's alibi for Lamphere. The defense uses her testimony, along with other evidence, to argue the fire predated the time the state claims Lamphere left Mrs. Smith's residence.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 24 November 1908 · page 7

BURNING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A report claims Belle Gunness has been located in Kansas City, Kansas, based on a telegram from a woman named Ella Henning. Police in both Kansas Cities find no evidence she is there, and the tipster is revealed to be a self-described fortune teller who merely guessed.

The Topeka State Journal · 24 November 1908 · page 1

FLITS TO KANSAS CITY.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Winchester News · Winchester, Ky.

The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children is nearing its end, with the defense presenting evidence suggesting Gunness survived past the fire date and challenging the timing of the blaze. Letters claiming to have seen Gunness alive were investigated but discredited as likely attempts at notoriety.

The Winchester News · 24 November 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A letter signed 'Mrs. Belle Gunness' threatened violence if its sender was arrested, prompting efforts to trace its origin to an address in Michigan City. Meanwhile, the defense in Ray Lamphere's murder trial began presenting its final evidence on Monday.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 24 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.

The defense in Ray Lamphere's trial for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children is close to resting, with only one witness, Dr. Haines of Chicago, remaining. Testimony focused on a mysterious letter signed by Mrs. Gunness threatening violence, and on evidence about when the fire and a car on the Gunness road were seen, to argue Lamphere could not have set the fire.

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 24 November 1908 · page 2

TRIAL NEARING ITS CLOSE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

At the opening of Ray Lamphere's murder trial, his attorney argued that Belle Gunness did not die in the April farmhouse fire but was seen alive weeks later. Defense counsel Worden brought in noted Indiana trial lawyer Ellsworth Weir to help save Lamphere from execution.

The Billings Gazette · 24 November 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come