As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1896, part 2

231 articles

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Martin Julian, manager for Fitzsimmons, announced he had complete evidence proving a conspiracy against his fighter in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout. He named referee Wyatt Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club as conspirators.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Julian Says Earp, Needham and Lynch Defrauded Fitz.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated today that he had the evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsommons-Sharkey fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National Club.

See moreSee less

Julian says it is idle to talk of a contest before the Olympic Club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons, because

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Wyatt Earp pleaded not guilty to carrying a concealed weapon and testified as a witness in Fitzsimmons' suit to recover a check held by Sharkey. Earp denied any conspiracy to defraud Fitzsimmons, saying he had turned the check over to Sharkey; the weapon case was set for Thursday and the civil case continued to Friday.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the clubs in New York will offer larger purses for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If a finish fight cannot be arranged Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in a limited bout.

Earp spent considerable time in court today. He first pleaded not guilty to a charge of carrying concealed weapons and then appeared as a witness in Fitzsimmons' suit to recover the $10,000 check held by Sharkey. Earp said he had turned the check over to Sharkey and denied that there had been a conspiracy to defraud Fitzsimmons. The case then went over until Friday, while the concealed weapon case will be heard Thursday.

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Martin Julian claims to have evidence of a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, naming referee Wyatt Earp among the conspirators. Earp pleaded not guilty to carrying concealed weapons and testified in a separate case concerning a $10,000 check held by Sharkey, denying any conspiracy.

The Laramie Republican · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

JULIAN HAS EVIDENCE. San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated today, he has evidences complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Julian says parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club. Julian says it is idle talk of a contest before the Olympic club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons because the clubs in New York will offer larger purses for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If an unlimited

See the clipping

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

A collection of brief Arizona territorial news items including irrigation congress preparations, cattle quarantine lifting, and agricultural reports. One item notes that Wyatt Earp served as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, suggesting Arizona deserves statehood recognition.

Arizona Silver Belt · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Arizona has been placed on a pedestal in the temple of fame. Her distinguished son Wyatt Earp officiated as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey

See the clipping

Tombstone Prospector · Tombstone, Ariz.

At the San Francisco supreme court trial over the disputed $10,000 purse from the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, Sharkey's trainer Billy Smith testified that referee Wyatt Earp had been 'fixed' beforehand. Lynch, Sharkey's backer, denied the claim indignantly and threatened to prosecute Smith for perjury, suggesting Smith's accusation stemmed from a pay dispute.

Tombstone Prospector · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SAN FRANCISCO—In the trial here before the supreme court for the possession of the $10,000 in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, the testomony of Australian Billy Smith trainer of Sharkey, developed the fact that Earp had been "fixed" as referee. Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and Smith had talked of a referee but could not agree on any referee who would not "talk

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

In the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons purse dispute trial, trainer Billy Smith testified that Sharkey said referee Wyatt Earp had been bribed and was 'all right' for him, and described Earp intervening about hand wrappings. Sharkey's manager Lynch countered that Smith was lying out of a grudge over unpaid wages and would be prosecuted for perjury.

Arizona Republican · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BILLY SMITH'S STORY.

Says the Fight Was Fixed—Denounced as a Perjurer.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9.—The legal contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons for the possession of the $10,000 purse has commenced before the superior court.

"Australian Billy Smith," one of Sharkey's trainers, was the first witness. He said he was asked by Lynch, Sharkey's backer, to suggest a referee. He suggested Hyram Cook and Lynch asked him if he knew Cook well enough to "talk business with him."

Afterwards, witness said, Lynch characterized Cook as "no good" because he would not favor his own brother in the fight. On the evening of the fight Sharkey told witness that Earp had been fixed as the referee and that "Earp was all right."

Witness described the uproar over the preliminaries to the fight and said that when Fitzsimmons objected to the bands on Sharkey's wrists, Earp went over to Sharkey's corner and said: "Take off those cloths. It will be all right, anyway."

Witness said that when Sharkey received the knockout blow on the jaw in the eighth round, Lynch said to Sharkey: "Lie low. Hold your hands on your groin and pretend to faint with pain."

Sharkey was then carried to his room. Witness also said that Allen, another trainer, "removed Sharkey's bandages and did the work which caused the swelling."

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A man named Smith testifies that Sharkey's camp secretly engaged Wyatt Earp as referee, paying him $2,500 to award the fight to Sharkey on any foul claim. Lynch and others deny the testimony, calling it perjury and alleging an extortion attempt by Smith and Allen.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY WAS TO WIN ANYHOW

fore he left New York. According to Smith's testimony, J. J. Grom, J. H. Gibbs, Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, and Sharkey himself were the men who composed the National Athietic club, before which organization the contest was fought. These four men, Smith swears, engaged Wyatt Earp as referee, with the understanding that he was to award Sharkey the fight if Fitzsimmons landed a body blow or stomach punch, which might be stretched into a foul. Earp was to receive $2,500 for his services.

Smith said that three weeks prior to the fight Sharkey requested him to suggest a good referee. Smith named Hiram Cook. A few days later Lynch informed Smith that Cook was not a suitable referee. Smith was then advised that Sharkey and Lynch had an interest in the National club. Sharkey stated that Lynch, Grom and Gibbs were all broke and that he himself was obliged to put up $2,500 to guarantee his appearance in the ring, leaving him almost broke.

See moreSee less

Ten days before the fight Sharkey told Smith that Lynch had engaged Wyatt Earp as referee. Earp had agreed to give the fight to Sharkey on a foul the first time Fitzsimmons hit him a body blow at close quarters and for this decision Earp was to be paid $2,500.

On the morning before the fight Sharkey again assured Smith that everything was "fixed" satisfactory for Sharkey to win.

Lynch, Grom and Gibbs denounce Smith's testimony as rank perjury. Lynch asserts that Allen and Smith, finding that their attempt at extortion would be futile, went to Fitzsimmons' attorneys and offered to make certain disclosures concerning alleged jobbery, which can be easily disproved. Smith's testimony has created a tremendous sensation among the sporting fraternity.

Bayard to be Banquetted.

London, Dec. 9.--The lord mayor of

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Billy Smith testified in Judge Sanderson's court that a conspiracy existed to rob Fitzsimmons of victory by bribing referee Wyatt Earp to call a foul in Sharkey's favor. The report claims this testimony vindicates The Call's earlier reporting on the fight's fraudulent outcome.

The San Francisco Call · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE SWINDLE IS REVEALED

Judge Sanderson's Court Yesterday by Sharkey's Trainer.

The sensation of the hour is the testimony of Billy Smith in Judge Sanderson's court yesterday wherein he laid bare the conspiracy to rob Fitzsimmons and the public by an agreement with Long Green Lawrence's bodyguard, who was to receive $2500 for deciding the fight in favor of Sharkey on a foul.

See moreSee less

George Allen, who assisted Smith in training Sharkey, will testify to the same effect this morning.

William Abbott will also appear and corroborate Smith's testimony.

The stand that THE CALL took on the fiasco of a week ago is being borne out in every detail, and each day the corroboration grew stronger until yesterday, when the whole disgraceful business was exposed to the people who had been so shamefully duped. It needs but the repro[duction]...

and Lynch there were heard mu[r]murs from the indignant spec[tators] they found that their suspicio[ns] too true.

Smith said that he was 28 y[ears old,] a blacksmith by occupation, a[nd] had resided in this City for [more] than seven years. During t[he time he] had worked at his trade in se[veral foun]dries and iron works in this C[ity.]

Smith went on to tell how [he acted] as Sharkey's trainer at the [Seal Rock] House on the ocean beach, [with] Allen as his assistant, and du[ring the] days before the fight Dann[y] came in and helped.

On one of his walks with Sh[arkey] three weeks before the fight, [he re]quested him to look up some[one] among whom a suitable refe[ree]...

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The Call reports that testimony over the past week has corroborated its original story about a disgraceful fixed fight, vindicating its earlier reporting. The courtroom, packed with spectators eager to see Bob Fitzsimmons, awaited Wyatt Earp and attorneys before proceedings began late.

The San Francisco Call · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

mass of spectators. When the court opened at 10 o'clock neither the principals nor their attorneys were present. The tawny mustache and light-blue eyes of Wyatt Earp were conspicuously not to the fore, and there was

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

At the hearing into the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, trainer Billy Smith testified that Sharkey expected referee Wyatt Earp to award him the fight on a foul in exchange for $2500. Sharkey's manager Dan Lynch publicly denounced the testimony as perjury, claiming Smith was bribed by the Fitzsimmons camp and disputing details of events after Sharkey was struck.

The Herald · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

DANNY'S DENIAL

Dan J. Lynch, Sharkey's manager and backer, made the following statement tonight to the Associated Press:

See moreSee less

"Mr. Sharkey desires all his friends, and especially those in the east, to suspend judgment on the story told today in court by Australian Billy Smith until Sharkey can be heard on the stand. The fact of the matter is that Smith perjured himself, and we will prosecute him for perjury when the present trial is over. His statement is a tissue of falsehoods from beginning to end and it is very clear to me that he has been bought by the Fitzsimmons crowd to give testimony damaging to Sharkey's case. Smith demanded $1000 after the fight for four weeks' assistance as trainer. Sharkey refused to give more than $400. This is the animus of his testimony in court.

"Smith stated on the stand today that I had said to Sharkey when he fell in the eighth round to 'place his hand on his groin and pretend to faint.' As a matter of fact I was in the timers' stand, fifty feet from the ring, at the time that Sharkey was struck and did ont get any nearer to the ring than that distance before Sharkey was carried to his dressing room, where I awaited him. He was carried into the room, accompanied by his three trainers, the doctor, myself and several newspaper men. In all there were at least a score of personal friends in the room and there was no opportunity of tampering with Sharkey should any one have so desired. Smith did not remove Sharkey's bandages, but this was done by the doctor. Sharkey never saw Earp until he entered the ring. I did not know Earp was selected to act as referee until I saw the announcement in the afternoon papers. I ask that Sharkey's friends suspend judgment until our witnesses can be heard. We will prove that Smith perjured himself and we will take action against him on this ground."

"Australian" Billy Smith, one of Sharkey's thrainers, said today: "I talked to Sharkey at 10 oclock on the morning of the fight. He told me that Earp would be chosen referee and that the game was for him to be given the decision on a foul in the first round or as soon after that as Fitzsimmons hit him a body blow of any kind. Then Needham was to jump into the ring and claim a foul. He told me not to say I knew anything and that Lynch and Needham would be crazy if they found out he had told me. When the men got into the ring and Fitzsimmons objected to Sharkey's hand bandages, Earp came over to our corner and whispered to Sharkey: 'Take off the bandages, Tom, it will be all right, anyhow.' Well, things went on until the eighth round and I saw Sharkey fall. I did not see the blow that sent him down. I climbed up into the ring, picked him up and hauled him to his corner. In a minute or two Lynch came up into the ring and, rushing over to Sharkey, said to him: "Now keep your hands down and pretend to be in great pain' but Sharkey was so badly dazed by the blow on the head that he forgot to do what Lynch ordered, except once in a while. Lynch

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Referee Wyatt Earp defends his decision to stop the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight on a foul, insisting he clearly saw an illegal low blow. Fitzsimmons denies fouling and claims he could have won outright, while Sharkey accuses Fitzsimmons of fouling deliberately to avoid being knocked out.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

as my eyesight, I saw the foul blow." "FITZ" SAYS HE DID NOT FOUL SHARKEY. "Fitz" said after the fight "Earp knows and so does Sharkey that I did not hit the sailor where they say I did. My left landed straight in his

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

A witness named William Smith testifies in a San Francisco court that a conspiracy existed to pay referee Wyatt Earp $2,500 to rule in Sharkey's favor. The hearing stems from Fitzsimmons's legal effort to overturn the fight's outcome, with testimony detailing an earlier failed attempt to recruit another man, Hiram Cook, into the scheme.

New York Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY'S TRAINER SAYS FITZSIMMONS WAS ROBBED

San Francisco, Dec. 9.--The proceedings in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons injunction case to-day furnished a bonafide sensation. It was rumored yesterday that Australian Billy Smith and George Allen, who helped to train Sharkey, had made confessions to Fitzsimmons's attorney implicating Sharkey and several others in a plot to win the recent fight by fraud. The story was not generally believed, however.

This morning Colonel Kowalsky, attorney for Fitzsimmons, entered Judge Sander-

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

In Judge Sanderson's court, attorney Kowalsky took sworn testimony from William Smith, Sharkey's trainer, detailing conversations about rigging the referee selection for the recent fight. Smith testified that Lynch rejected a fair-minded referee candidate and that Wyatt Earp was discussed as a referee who would be 'all right' for their purposes.

New York Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

that the reason he wanted to have the depositions of his witnesses taken was that they were liable to leave the city and to remain away a long while. Smith's evidence was as follows: "My name is William G. Smith; I am a blacksmith by trade. I sometimes box and train other boxers for a living. I have only known Wyatt Earp since last Wednesday. I trained Sharkey for his recent fight. I have had several conversations with him. Our first conversation was about three weeks before the fight. We were walking through Golden Gate Park.

See moreSee less

He asked me to name some men able to fill the position of referee. I mentioned Hiram Cook. Sharkey spoke to Lynch about Hiram Cook, and Lynch referred to me again. He asked me if I knew Cook well enough to talk business with him. I said no.

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

A witness named Smith testifies that boxer Sharkey and manager Lynch conspired to rig the referee selection, choosing Wyatt Earp to ensure a win by foul. Smith describes Earp telling Sharkey to remove his bandages and Lynch coaching Sharkey to fake pain after being knocked out.

New York Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

fore the fight, Smith testified as follows:

Sharkey Couldn't Lose.

See moreSee less

"When Fitzsimmons insisted upon Sharkey taking the bandages off his hands Sharkey did not want to do it. I was bending down untying one of his gloves. I had just tied it on, and he was in doubt as to whether to take it off again or not. Earp came over and bent down and spoke to Sharkey. He said, 'Take the bandages off. It will be all right, anyhow.'"

Smith further said that Sharkey was so dazed at the end of the second round that he did not know what round it was. He asked the second for information. Continuing. he said:

When the end of the eighth round came, I did not see the blow, but I thought Sharkey

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 11 other papers

In a San Francisco courtroom, Sharkey's trainer Billy Smith testified that Sharkey's camp bribed referee Wyatt Earp with $2,500 to award the fight to Sharkey on a foul. Smith claimed the fix was arranged before Fitzsimmons even left New York.

The Morning News · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY PARTY TO THE STEAL - THE FIGHT FIXED BEFORE FITZ LEFT NEW YORK

The National Athletic Club Composed of Sharkey's Backers—Referee Earp to Receive $2,500 For the Decision Giving the Fight to Sharkey—Australian Billy Smith Gives the Whole Snap Away.

San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 9.—A large assemblage of ring followers and men about town, crowded Judge Sanderson's court room this morning in expectation of hearing sensational developments regarding the manner in which the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight was "fixed" and they were not disappointed.

See moreSee less

If credence is to be placed in the story told on the witness stand by "Australian" Billy Smith, Sharkey's trainer, Fitzsimmons was a defeated man before he left New York. According to Smith's testimony, J. J. Groom, J. H. Gibb's, Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, and Sharkey himself were the men, who composed the National Athletic Club, before which organization the now notorious contest was fought.

These four men, Smith swears, engaged Wyatt Earp as referee, with the understanding that he was to award Sharkey the fight directly Fitzsimmons landed a body blow or stomach punch, which might be stretched into a foul. Earp was to receive $2,500 for his services.

Smith's story is in substance as follows:

Five weeks ago he was employed to train Sharkey at the Ocean Beach hotel, George Allen and Danny Needham assisting. He had frequent conversations with Sharkey about his prospective contest with Fitzsimmons. Three weeks prior to the fight, Sharkey requested Smith to suggest a good referee. Smith named Hiram Cook, and Lynch promised to call on that gentleman. A few days later Lynch informed Smith that Cook was not a suitable referee. Smith was then advised by Sharkey of the fact that he (Sharkey) and Lynch had an interest in the National Club. Sharkey stated that Lynch, Groom and Gibbs were all broke and that he, himself, was obliged to put up $2,500 to guarantee his appearance in the ring, leaving him almost broke. Lynch and he were each to receive 20 per cent. of the gate receipts after the expenses and purse money had been deducted. Ten days before the fight Sharkey mentioned to Smith that Lynch had succeeded in engaging one Wyatt Earp, a horse owner, to act as referee. Earp had agreed to give the fight to Sharkey on a foul the first time Fitzsimmons hit him a body blow at close quarters, and in consideration of his decision, the referee was to be paid $2,500. On the morning before the fight Sharkey again assured Smith that everything was "fixed" satisfactorily for Sharkey to win.

After describing his movements in the ring before the call of time, Smith continued: "Sharkey was dazed at the end of the second round, and was practically defeated then. I did not see the knock-out blow. After Sharkey fell, Lynch whispered to him 'pretend to be in great pain, and it will be all right.' We carried Sharkey to his dressing room and put him on a cot. Lynch refused to allow anybody in the room. Sharkey kept holding his hands to his head and complaining of his sore ear and jaw, but said nothing about his groin. I started to remove his trunks, but Lynch stopped me. We then carried Sharkey to a hack and removed him to his hotel. Allen, Lynch, Needham and myself laid him out on a bed. I took off his shoes and trousers and Allen removed his trunks. He made no complaint except regarding his head and ear, and I saw no evidence of discoloration about the groin. A few moments later we heard Sharkey screaming, and Allen remarked: 'I don't like the looks of this. I am going away.' After waiting fifteen minutes, Lynch let me into Sharkey's room again and I found Tom all bandaged up. A bottle of iodine of potassium stood on the washstand. I do not know what it was used for, but it could hardly have been applied to his sore ear. Lynch then told me I could go for the night, as he had engaged a man to sit up with Sharkey. The following evening I called on Sharkey and found the swelling on his groin very apparent, but he did not complain of suffering any pain in that region. His ear troubled him, however. He asked me what kind of a fight he put up and I told him pretty good. He said that Fitzsimmons could whip Corbett in two rounds. 'He hits like a mule,' continued Sharkey, 'and Corbett would not last any time with him.' Sharkey told me I could stop with him that night. I offered to put hot bandages on him, but he told me they were not necessary. Before going to sleep he jumped out of bed, lit a cigar and walked around the room. He assured me that he was all right excepting his sore ear."

On cross-examination, Smith stuck to his story and could not be shaken. He also disclosed the fact that Dr. Lee was not summoned to Sharkey's bedside until two hours and a half after the fight was over.

Lynch, Groom and Gibbs denounce Smith's testimony as rank perjury. They claim that Smith demanded $1,000 for his services as trainer, and declined to accept the $400 tendered him.

Allen, who promises to corroborate Smith's testimony to-morrow, was offered $200, but attempted to blackmail Sharkey and Lynch into paying him double that amount.

Lynch asserts that Allen and Smith, finding that their attempt at extortion would be futile, went to Fitzsimmons' attorneys and offered to make certain disclosures concerning alleged jobbery which can easily be disproved. Col. Kowalski, Fitzsimmons' counsel, avers that he has enough testimony to convict the entire Sharkey following for gross conspiracy and fraud.

Smith's testimony has created a tremendous sensation among the sporting fraternity.

See the clipping

Also printed in 11 papers
  • Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 10 December 1896
  • The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · 10 December 1896
  • The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn. · 10 December 1896 · an extract
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 10 December 1896
  • The Morning Times · Washington, D.C. · 10 December 1896 · an extract
  • New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · 10 December 1896
  • The Sun · New York, N.Y. · 10 December 1896
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 10 December 1896
  • Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 10 December 1896
  • The Norfolk Virginian · Norfolk, Va. · 10 December 1896 · an extract
  • The Times · Richmond, Va. · 10 December 1896

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper

In court testimony regarding Fitzsimmons's suit to recover a $10,000 check, witness Smith claimed Sharkey suggested paying Wyatt Earp $2,500 to be a favorable referee. Sharkey's manager denounced the testimony as perjury motivated by a wage dispute, while Earp denied any conspiracy to defraud Fitzsimmons.

The Indianapolis Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

inary expenses, which had left the sailor pugilist stranded financially. Witness said a few days before the fight Sharkey told him to thought Earp would be the right kind of a referee for him and added it would be worth $2,500 to Earp if he were the right kind of a referee.

Smith was cross-examined by Sharkey's counsel, but nothing of importance was elicited. The case then went over until to-morrow. Trainer Allen, who has not yet appeared, as a witness, will then go on the stand and corroborate Smith's testimony.

See moreSee less

Wyatt Earp pleaded not guilty to a charge of carrying concealed weapons and then appeared as a witness in Fitzsimmons's suit to recover the $10,000 check held by Sharkey. Earp said he had turned the check over to Sharkey and denied that there had been a conspiracy to defraud Fitzsimmons. The case then went over until Friday, while the concealed weapon case will be heard Thursday.

Dan J. Lynch, Sharkey's manager and backer, made the following statement to-night: "Mr. Sharkey desires all his friends, and especially those in the East, to suspend judgment on the story told to-day in court by 'Australian Billy Smith,' until Sharkey can be heard on the stand. The fact of the matter is that Smith perjured himself and we will prosecute him for perjury when the present trial is over. His statement is a tissue of falsehood from beginning to end, and it is very clear to me that he has been bought by the Fitzsimmons crowd to give testimony damaging to Sharkey's case. Smith demanded $1,000 after the fight for four weeks' assistance as trainer. Sharkey refused to give more than $400. This is the animus of his testimony in court to-day.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 10 December 1896

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

Rumors circulated that referee Wyatt Earp's decisions in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight were dishonest, with Fitzsimmons accused of betting on Sharkey lasting six rounds. Earp reportedly sought out Major Frank McLaughlin to confront him over insinuations that Earp had been bribed, but friends intervened to prevent a physical altercation at a hotel bar.

Canton Weekly Register · 10 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

BAD MAN EARP FEELS INSULTED. Looking for Frank McLaughlin—Story Current Impuging Fitzsimmons' Honesty. San Francisco, Dec. 7.—The story is now current in sporting circles that Fitzsimmons has done pretty well with

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 1 other paper

In the San Francisco court battle over the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons purse, Sharkey's trainers testified that referee Wyatt Earp was told he was 'fixed' and that Sharkey's foul claim was staged after a legitimate knockout blow. Sharkey's manager urged supporters to withhold judgment pending further testimony.

Rock Island Argus · 10 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

EVIDENCE OF A CONSPIRACY

Given in Court in the Fitzsimmons Fight Case - Sharkey's Backer Denies.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec. 10. - The legal contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons for the possession of the $10,000 purse has commenced before the superior court. "Australian Billy" Smith, one of Sharkey's trainers, was the witness. He said that when the question of selecting a referee was mooted in Sharkey's quarters he was asked to suggest a referee. Witness suggested Hiram Cook, and Lynch then asked him if he knew Cook well enough "to talk business with him." Afterwards witness said Lynch characterized Cook as "no good," because he "would not favor his own brother in a fight." On the evening of the fight Sharkey told witness that Earp had been fixed as referee and that "Earp was all right."

Witness said that when Fitzsimmons objected to the bandages on Sharkey's hand Earp went over to Sharkey's corner and said: "Take off those cloths, it will be all right anyway;" when Sharkey received the knock out blow on the jaw in the eighth round Lynch said to Sharkey "Lie low, hold your hands on your groin and pretend to faint with pain." Allen, another trainer, "removed Sharkey's bandages and did the work which caused the swelling."

George Allen, another of Sharkey's trainers, corroborated the story of the previous witness, adding that several physicians were refused admittance when Sharkey was undergoing the operation with which Allen produced the evidence of a foul.

Dan J. Lynch, Sharkey's manager and backer, made the following statement last night to the Associated Press: "Mr. Sharkey desires all his friends, and especially those in the east, to suspend judgment on the story told today in court by Australian Billy Smith until Sharkey can be heard on the stand. The fact of the matter is that Smith perjured himself, and we will prosecute him for perjury when the present trial is over."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · 16 December 1896

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

A brief editorial note states that Wyatt Earp, now referee, is enjoying national notoriety after a controversial prize fighting contest. It notes that western newspapers generally speak well of him, saying he did what he believed was right.

The Globe-Republican · 10 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Referree Wyatt Earp is enjoying a sort of national notoriety. The western newspapers generally speak well of Earp, and say he did in the prize fighting contest what he believed to be right.

See the clipping

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

In a roundup of local citizens' opinions on current events, M. W. Sutton comments that he reads the glowing newspaper notices about Wyatt Earp skeptically. He suggests that those who know Earp personally find these flattering press accounts exaggerated.

The Globe-Republican · 10 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Sutton reads the glittering and flattering newspaper notices of Wyatt Earp with many degrees of allowance. To those who know Earp intimately, these

See the clipping

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

Dr. Cubbison writes that Wyatt Earp made an untruthful and uncalled-for statement about him in a San Francisco paper. He defends his own role, claiming he was always Earp's friend and once saved him from being murdered in Dodge City, while criticizing Earp's exaggerated reputation.

The Globe-Republican · 10 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

R. M. Wright. Some weeks ago Wyatt Earp made an untruthful, uncalled for and undeserved statement concerning myself in a San Francisco paper. These "killers" like a newspaper notoriety, and they are not choice about the means in which they obtain it. Just now, Earp is the "hero" of the hour; but his history is a wonderful perversion of the facts, and I am astonished that the American people can gloat over the alleged escapades of men like Earp. It is true Earp was a brave man, and exhibited skill and nerve in the uses of the "gun" in many instances, but he ought to build up his reputation without traducing other people and misrepresenting facts.

See moreSee less

I was always his friend, and saved him from being murdered in Dodge City. Dr. Crumbine. We are going to ballot on the selection of a preacher next week. These "trials" we have had are not the severest in the line of the preach[er's duty or of the]

See the clipping

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

A wire report on the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match in San Francisco identifies Wyatt Earp, a former Dodge City marshal, as the referee who declared the fight a foul. The local paper adds commentary recalling Earp's reputation as fearless and well-liked during his time as marshal.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Globe-Republican · 10 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

The famous "battle" between the pugilists, Sharkey and Fitzsimmons at San Francisco, on the 2d inst., resulted in a "foul," and Sharkey was declared winner. The fight attracted some interest in Dodge City, because a former citizen was the referee in the "gladiatorial contest." The report speaks of the referee as follows: "Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured in many a gun fights on the border, was chosen referee," Earp was city marshal of this city in

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A report on the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in San Francisco states that Referee Earp awarded Sharkey the win on a disputed foul claim after Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out in the eighth round. The decision was met with hisses and groans from the crowd, with the report asserting the fight was Fitzsimmons' from start to finish.

Barton County Democrat · 10 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

GENERAL NEWS. The little town of Flippen, Ky., has been almost wiped out by fire. A DISPATCH from San Francisco on the 5th said that Sharkey is still confined to his bed. Dan Lynch, the

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A witness testified that Sharkey considered paying Wyatt Earp $2,500 to referee favorably, and that Sharkey was financially desperate before the fight. Sharkey's manager Dan Lynch denounced the testimony as perjury motivated by a wage dispute, while a separate report described trainer George Allen's confession of a conspiracy, allegedly extracted by detectives hired by Fitzsimmons' attorney.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

TWO SIDES TO EVERY STORY

There is Trouble Over the Swag and One of the Gang Peaches.

San Francisco, Dec. 9.--A morning paper publishes the following:

See moreSee less

George Allen, one of the men who trained Tom Sharkey for his fight with Fitzsimmons, has made a confession to the effect that Fitzsimmons was deprived of his victory through a conspiracy. The trainer and the Sharkey management have quarrelled over money matters, it is said, and in the heat of the moment Allen made threats of what he would do if he was not paid for his services. Attorney Kowalsky, representing Fitzsimmons, heard of the circumstances and he employed private detectives to gather in the irate trainer. He was run to ground yesterday and induced to tell the whole story.

See the clipping

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

A Wichita report notes that Wyatt Earp, accused by Bob Fitzsimmons of refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, was well known locally as a former officer under Marshal Mike Meagher in the early 1870s. He is described as a tall, cool-headed man with a deadly aim and a reputation as a 'killer.'

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 10 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

EARP IS FROM KANSAS

TO LICENSE MURDER.

A Bill Introduced in Alabama Permitting a Man to Kill the Despoiler of a Female Relative.

See moreSee less

MONTGOMERY, Ala., Dec. 5.—Representative Pitts, one of the foremost lawyers in the assembly, has introduced a bill which in effect will license a man to kill the despoiler of his female relative. It is urged that the law making such homicide murder is a dead letter on the statute books and that the proposed law would enable the juries of Alabama to cease ignoring the written law in order to meet the ends of justice.

Earp is from Kansas.

WICHITA, Kan., Dec. 5.—Wyatt Earp, who is accused by Bob Fitzsimmons and his friends with having refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, is well known to the oldtimers in Wichita, having served as an officer under Marshal Mike Maegher, in the early '70's. He was a tall, ministerial looking fellow, with a cool head and a deadly aim, and he had the reputation of being a "killer."

See the clipping

The Copper Country Evening News · Calumet, Mich.

Martin Julian claims to have proof that referee Wyatt Earp, Danny Needham, Dan Lynch, and the National Club conspired against Fitzsimmons in his recent bout with Sharkey. He alleges the fix was deliberately planned to favor Sharkey.

The Copper Country Evening News · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Yard at Foot of Portland Street.

1419 F street, as permanent headquarters for the national Republican committee. The inaugural committee, of which Charles J. Bell is chairman, also

See moreSee less

tersford, Va., from apoplexy. When he was found his body was burned to a crisp. He was a Republican leader of this section.

crushed, but later it was found that only two had been seriously injured.

Julian Charges Conspiracy.

San Francisco, Dec. 10.—Martin Julian stated Tuesday night that he had evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Dannie Needham, Sharkey's trainer, and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club.

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

In a San Francisco superior court case over the $10,000 purse from the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, Sharkey's trainer testified about an alleged conspiracy to rig the outcome. The witness described how Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee and intervened during the fight regarding bandages, and recounted instructions given to Sharkey to fake injury after being knocked down.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5

THE SHARKEY-FITZ STEAL

, Tni in Billy" Smith, one of Shark r r iii nwax th" first witness, Jlede t I tin work In connection with prepar i : Shark, y for the ring, and said, when i-. r, lovilon of a referee was mooted In -t.,.rl" training quarters, he was asked to s c--t .1 referee. "Witness suggested H 'nn f'ik. and raid Lynrh then atked i m if )i knew Cook well enough ' to talk i sinewith lilm." Afterward, witness uiil I.vneh characterized Cook as 'no good Ix-i-ause he "would not favor his. nun brother In a tight " On the eenlng 01 the light. Sharkey told wltnej-, that Jvirp had been fixed upon as referee, and

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

Trainers testify that Sharkey, his manager Lynch, and others plotted to fake a foul when Sharkey was losing to Fitzsimmons, with Wyatt Earp allegedly bribed to serve as a favorable referee. An affidavit names Earp, Lynch, Sharkey, and Needham as the plot's prime movers.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5

THE SHARKEY-FITZ STEAL.

h nd I'irp went out to Sharkej & corner ..nd shuI "Take off thove loths It will he nl right anywaj ' Witness ha Id when hh.irke reef lied the knockout hlow on the 1 .w in the eighth round. Lynch said to Sharkev "Lie low, hold jour hands on ur groin and pretend to faint with pain ' Sharkey was then carried to a room lie dirt not appear to he hurt. Wit ness said Ailen. another trainer, "removed Kharkej s bandages and did the work which caused the swilling. Sharkey was then driven to his hotel in a hack. Allen was with him Sharkey was all right "

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A witness named Allen gave an affidavit naming Wyatt Earp, Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham as plotters in a scheme to fake a foul so Sharkey would win his fight against Fitzsimmons. Sharkey's manager Dan Lynch publicly denied the allegations, claiming the accuser Australian Billy Smith perjured himself out of spite over a pay dispute and was bribed by the Fitzsimmons camp.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 10 December 1896 · page 5

THE SHARKEY-FITZ STEAL

made jesterday, named "Wyatt Earp Dan J Ljneh. Tom Sharkey and Dan Need ham as the prime movers In the plot. The whole siheme is said lo hae been hatched at Sharkej's training quarters at Ocean lieaeh It was arranged that Sharkey was to make It appear that he had been fouled a some poln' in the contest when he was in danger of losing from Tits' blows; further that the signal was to be given bv Sharkej who was to bend over and place his hand on his groin, and at that moment Needbam was to jump into the ring and claim a foul Then the referee was to give ii 4ecvon Infavor of Sharkey. I i.tn J I.snih. Sharkers manager and

See the clipping

The Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · and 2 other papers

Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sailor Sharkey on a foul after Sharkey was knocked unconscious in the eighth round, ruling that Fitzsimmons had struck him in the groin with his knee. The crowd of 15,000-20,000 hissed and groaned at the decision, as hardly anyone had seen the alleged foul.

The Valentine Democrat · 10 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LOSES IT ON A FOUL.

Fitzsimmons Fails to Get the Decision Over Sharkey.

See moreSee less

The fight between Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey in San Francisco proved one of the most sensational in the history of the ring. Sharkey was knocked down with a left crook on the jaw in the eighth round and was carried unconscious from the ring amid great excitement. Some confusion followed which the crowd did not understand. Fitzsimmons was trying to speak, but could not be heard. Then it was learned that Referee Wiley Earp had awarded the fight to Sharkey on a claim of foul. It was claimed that Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey in the groin with his knee as the latter was falling.

Fitzsimmons protested and the crowd hissed and groaned. In the eigth round Fitzsimmons soon had his man going and went at him ferociously. A right-hand swing staggered the sailor and then came a left-hand swing, and a left-arm punch under the chin that sent Sharkey over with a thud. While the marine was falling the referee claims that Fitzsimmons struck him in the groin with his knee, thus committing a foul. Sharkey was undoubtedly badly hurt. His seconds rushed into the ring and raised him up, but he fainted away and was borne from the ring unconscious. Hardly any one among the spectators saw the foul, and the decision was received with hisses and groans.

No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted so much public attention. Between 15,000 and 20,00 people ocupied all the available space in the big Mechanics' pavilion and watched the contest, which every one regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world. The long, lean

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D. · 10 December 1896
  • Converse County Herald · Lusk, Wyo. · 10 December 1896

The Pioche Weekly Record · Pioche, Nev.

The report describes the December 2 boxing match in San Francisco between Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey, which was awarded to Sharkey on a foul when the referee ruled Fitzsimmons struck him with his knee. Wyatt Earp, former Tombstone marshal, served as referee, and his decision sparked outrage, with Fitzsimmons moving to block payout of the $10,000 purse.

The Pioche Weekly Record · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The fight at San Francisco between Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey on the 2d inst., was decided in favor of Sharkey in the eighth round, on a foul. Sharkey was knocked out by a blow on the chin, but the referee decided that in going down Fitzsimmons struck him with his knee. Wyatt Earp, formerly Marshall of Tombstone, was the referee, his decision causing intense indignation. The $10,000 purse fought for is in the bank, and Fitzsimmons has enjoined the bank from paying it out until the question is settled.

The Gazette says: Judge Bigelow has formed a co-partnership with Barclay Henley of San Francisco and will move to that city and enter upon the practice of law as soon as his term of office expires the coming January. Judge Bigelow has been a resident of this State for twenty-eight years, and all that time he has occupied a prominent position in politics and at the bar.

See moreSee less

All who are, or expect to be interested in mines will be glad to know that Henry N. Copp, the Washington (D.C.) land lawyer, has revised Copp's Prospector's Manual

See the clipping

Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio

Col. Kowalski, representing Bob Fitzsimmons, has filed suit against Tom Sharkey to recover $10,000 allegedly withheld, naming Sharkey, Wyatt Earp, and Lynch as part of an alleged conspiracy to fix the fight's outcome. The suit claims evidence will show Sharkey faked a foul to win the match through fraudulent means.

Marietta Daily Leader · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BOB FITZSIMMONS

from the rightful owner.

"This action," explained Col. Kowalski, "can settle the whole controversy in short order. If Sharky, Earp, Lynch and that clique are in the right they can get in and prove it. If they are in the wrong they will bring up some technicality and cause delay.

See moreSee less

"We will appear before Judge San-

See the clipping

The Dalles Daily Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

The piece notes Fitzsimmons is protesting that Earp's refereeing was crooked in favor of Sharkey, but points out Fitzsimmons himself had friends betting his money that Sharkey would last six rounds. The writer sarcastically suggests Fitzsimmons' morals only kicked in once he lost.

The Dalles Daily Chronicle · 10 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Scott would prepare. We do not, by any means, agree with many of his ideas, but cheerfully bear witness to the fact that his editorials are almost always models. He leaves nothing to be said on his side of any proposition. While Fitzsimmons is lifting his voice in pious protest against the alleged jobbing done by Earp in giving the victory to Sharkey, it transpires that the honest and gentlemanly Fitz had a few of his friends betting his money for him that Sharkey would stay six rounds. Of course Fitz's keenest admirers were betting Sharkey would not stay six rounds, and Fitz took advantage of the dead thing he had on the play to scoop his friends.

See moreSee less

There was nothing foul about that from Fitz's point of view. It was only when he got robbed that his morals showed them

See the clipping

The Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A San Francisco court began hearing the legal dispute between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons over the $10,000 purse. Sharkey's trainers testified that referee Wyatt Earp intended to award the fight to Sharkey regardless of the actual outcome.

The Evening Tribune · 10 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

San Francisco's Horse Show. San Francisco, Dec. 10.—The third annual horse show opened in the Mechanics' pavilion yesterday. Although no program had been arranged for the earlier hour, a large number of ladies occupied the boxes and inspected the occupants of the stalls in the morning. At noon the management of the house show entertained 300 gentlemen at luncheon. Governor Budd was among the guests. In the evening came the real opening, and the wealth and fashion of the city and state was crowded into the boxes which overlook the ring. The show is considered an improvement on that of last year. The entries of coach horses, saddle horses and Califorina bred hackneys are particularlv good this.vear. Referee Earp Was Not Honest.

See the clipping

The Comet · Johnson City, Tenn.

A satirical newspaper column jokes that Wyatt Earp won't find work in the US, suggesting Gen. Weyler should hire him to referee the Cuban war. The quip references Earp's recent notoriety as referee in the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match.

The Comet · 10 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp will hardly get another job in this country, but he is the man Gen. Weyler is looking for to referee the Cuban war for him.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

Martin Julian claims to have evidence of a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons in a recent boxing match, naming Referee Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, and backer Dan Lynch as conspirators along with the National Club. He also discusses difficulties arranging a future contest between Corbett and Fitzsimmons due to purse negotiations.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 10 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Martin Julian Says He Can Prove That Such a Thing Existed. San Francisco, Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated tonight that he had evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club. Julian says it is idle to talk of a contest at the Olympic club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons, because New York clubs will offer a larger purse for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If an unlimited contest can not be arranged, Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in a limited contest.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex. · and 11 other papers

This report details the controversy surrounding referee Wyatt Earp's ruling of a foul against Fitzsimmons in his fight with Sharkey, including claims that Earp was biased and that the knockout blow was legitimate. It also covers the legal fallout, with Fitzsimmons' camp seeking an injunction to block payment of the $10,000 purse while a conspiracy charge is investigated.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 10 December 1896 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

VIEWS DIFFER ABOUT THE FOUL

Scratch About Him.

San Francisco, Dec. 3.—The city is divided as to the result of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, which continues to be the topic of the hour. No one questions that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly deprived of the decision. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow and was consequently, under the rules, entitled to the honors of victory, including the purse of $10,000.

See moreSee less

A third class base their opinion solely upon the reports of the physicians in attendance upon Sharkey. The doctors point to the swollen and colored condition of the sailor's body in the region of the groin as evidence of a foul blow and some ardent Fitzsimmons advocates reply that this condition was purposely caused by an injection of a drug immediately after the fight. A number of physicians and newspaper men were present in Sharkey's room this afternoon when an examination of his injuries were made. All said they were convinced that Sharkey's condition was the result of a foul blow. Many prominent men, however, condemn the decision and refuse to believe that there was any fouling. Such men as Police Commissioner Gunst, Riley Grannan, Maj. Frank McLaughlin, who was chairman of the republican state committee, believed that Fitzsimmons deserved the decision. It was pointed out that the whole affair has a disagreeable look. The fact is cited that Lynch, Sharkey's backer, refused to consider the name of any one as referee suggested by Julian and refused to suggest any man himself, leaving the selection with a few individuals comprising the National club. As soon as the club announced its choice of Wyatt Earp, well known as a horseman from Arizona, the odds, which had been 10 to 4 against Sharkey, rose to 10 to 6, with more Sharkey money offering than could be well handled. It is recounted that there were whispers yesterday afternoon that Sharkey would be favored in the decision, and these rumors reached Fitzsimmons' ears and he requested the club to substitute any one else as referee. Even at the ringside, when Julian and Fitzsimmons stated in Earp's presence that he had told that he intended to referee unfairly, Earp stood quietly by and insisted on acting as referee despite the protests. It is pointed out that Fitzsimmons fought a clean, skillful, scientific and winning battle, while Sharkey's system was rough and unscientific. It was charged that Sharkey was not equal to Fitzsimmons. It is claimed that the blow on the chin in the eighth was really a knockout blow and that no foul blow was delivered by Fitzsimmons, but that Sharkey, when knocked out, alleged the foul blow as an excuse. All this constitutes the case of Fitzsimmons by which his attorneys expect to prove the existence of a conspiracy to deprive Fitzsimmons of the purse of $10,000. An injunction has been applied for to restrain the Anglo-California bank from cashing the National club's check until Fitzsimmons has an opportunity to prove the conspiracy.

When Lynch and Referee Earp went to the bank this morning with the check, payment was refused by the teller, who referred Lynch to Manager Lilienthal.

See the clipping

Also printed in 11 papers
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 4 December 1896
  • Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · 4 December 1896
  • The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 4 December 1896
  • The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · 4 December 1896
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 4 December 1896
  • Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · 4 December 1896
  • The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 4 December 1896
  • Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb. · 4 December 1896
  • The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va. · 4 December 1896
  • Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va. · 4 December 1896
  • Emmons County Record · Williamsport, N.D. · 11 December 1896

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

A San Francisco trainer, George Allen, reportedly confessed that Wyatt Earp, Tom Sharkey, Dan Lynch, and Dan Needham conspired to fake a foul so Sharkey would win his fight against Fitzsimmons. The report also notes the legal contest over the $10,000 purse has begun before the state supreme court.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 10 December 1896 · page 1

CONSPIRACY SURE ENOUGH.

Confession. San Francisco, Dec. 0.?A morning pa? per publishes the following: George Allen, one ot the men wbo trained Tom Sbarkey for ins fight with Hob Fitzsimmons, bus made a confession to the effect that Fitzsiiiimons was de? prived of his victory tlirotitr.li a conspir? acy. Tbe trainer and the Sbarkey man? agement have quarreled over money mat? ters, it is s'iid, and in the beat of the moment Allen made threats of what be would do if be was not paid for bis ser? vices. Attorney Kowalsky, representing Ifita simmms.

See moreSee less

heard of the circumstances,mid he employed n private detective to gather in the irate trainer. He was run to the ground yesterday nnd induced to tell the whole story. It is claimed that Allen.iu an affidavit, named Wyatt Enrp, Dan .). Lynch. Tom Sbarkey and Dan Nccdham as the prime movers in tho plot. The whole scheme Is said tC have been hatched at Sharkey's traiuin?' quarters al Ocean Beach.

See the clipping

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

In San Francisco's supreme court, trainers Billy Smith and George Allen testify that referee Wyatt Earp, along with Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham, conspired to fake a foul so Sharkey would win the purse after being knocked out. Witnesses described Sharkey feigning injury and being secretly treated to simulate a foul while Earp allegedly knew of the fix.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 10 December 1896 · page 1

CONSPIRACY SURE ENOUGH.

"Australian Hilly" Smith, one of Sharkey's trainers, was the first witness. Ho detailed bis work in connection with prepnrins Sbarkoy for the ring, and said when the question of selecting a referee was mentioned in Sharkey's training quarters he was asked to suggest a referee. Witness suggested Hiram Cook, and said Lynch,then asked him if he knew Cook well ounugh "to talk bus? iness with him." Afterwards the witness said Cook was "no good," because he would not favor bis own brother iua light. On the evert? ing of the light.

See moreSee less

Sbarkey told witness that Earp hud been fixed as referee and that "Earp was all right." Witness de? scribed the uproar over the prelimina? ries to the light lind said when Fity.sim mons objected to the bandages on Sharkey's band Karp went over to Sharkey's corner and said: '"Take oil' those "clothes; It'will be all right any way." Witness said when Sbarkey received tbe knockout blow on tbe jaw iu the eighth round Lynch said to Sbarkey: "Lie low, hold your hands on your groin and pretend to faint with pain." Shurkcy was then carried from the room. He did not appear to be hurt. Witness said Allen, another trainer, "removed Sharkey's bandages and did the work which caused the swelling. Shut-key was then driven to his hotel in a hack. Allen was with him. Sbarkey was nil right." George Allen, another of Sharkey's trainers, corroborated the story of the previous witness, adding that several physicians were refused admittance while Shark *y was undergoing the opera tion with which Allen produced the evi? dence of a foul. Lynch said nc doctor should come into the room and interfere with his pinns. Witn-ss said Sbarkey told him the National Athletic Club wa - 1 composed of Groom, Gibbs, Lynch and Sbarkey, anil t hat Sbarkey was to receive twenty per cent, of the proceeds of the light after the purse was deducted. Sbarkey -aid his three partners in the National Club were broke and Sharkej bad bad to advance ?2,500for preliminary expenses, which had left the sailor pugilist stranded financially. Witness said ti few days before the light Sharkey told him he thought Earp would be the right kind of a referee for him and added that, it would he worth $2,500 to Karp i! he proved to be the proper kind of a referee.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

At a San Francisco court hearing, Sharkey's trainer 'Australian' Billy Smith testified that Wyatt Earp was hired as referee for $2,500 with an agreement to award Sharkey the fight on a foul. Sharkey's own backers denounced Smith as a perjurer for making the claim.

The Times · 10 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE FIGHT WAS "FIXED." IF CREDENCE CAN BE GIVEN TO THE TESTIMONY OF SMITH, His Statement as to How Sharkey Appeared After the Contest - The Sailor's Backers Call Him a Perjurer

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9.—A large assemblage of ring followers and men about town crowded Judge Sanderson's court-room this morning in expectation of hearing sensational developments regarding the manner in which the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight was "fixed," and they were not disappointed. If credence is to be placed in the story told on the witness stand by "Australian" Billy Smith, Sharkey's trainer, Fitzsimmons was a deteated man before he left New York. According to Smith's testimony J. J. Groom, J. H. Gibbs, Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, and Sharkey himself were the men who composed the National Athletic Club, before whom the notorious contest was fought.

See moreSee less

These men, he swears, engaged Wyatt Earp as referee, with the understanding that he was to award Sharkey the fight, directly Fitzsimmons landed a body blow or stomach punch, might be stretched into a foul. Earp was to receive $2,500 for his services. SMITH'S STORY.

See the clipping

The Yakima Herald · North Yakima, Wash.

Fitzsimmons obtained an injunction to stop the Anglo-California bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse awarded by Referee Earp's decision, alleging a conspiracy to fix the outcome for Sharkey. The report notes the claim will be hard to prove, and that bookmakers have already paid out on Sharkey tickets.

The Yakima Herald · 10 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Fitzsimmons has sued out an injunction to prevent the Anglo-California bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse awarded him by the decision of Referee Earp. The complaint alleges a conspiracy to award the fight to Sharkey in any event. The claim will be a difficult one to prove. Pool box men have already cashed the Sharkey tickets.

Steps have been taken in Chicago toward the establishment of the first municipal pawn shop in America. At a meeting of a committee from the civic federation the organization of a corporation with a capitalization of $200,000 was decided upon, the plans and purposes of which will be modeled after the public loan banks of Belgium, England and Germany.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

In a San Francisco court case over the disputed $10,000 purse from the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, witness Billy Smith testified that Sharkey said referee Wyatt Earp had been 'fixed' before the bout. The testimony also described suspicious behavior by Earp and Sharkey's camp during the fight, including advice to fake a foul after being knocked out.

Wheeling Register · 10 December 1896 · page 1

tional Athletic Club was composed of Groom. Gibbs, Lynch and Sharkey and ! that Sharkey was to receive twenty i>er : cent, of tho proceeds of tho light after j the purse was deducted. Sharkey had had

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

In court proceedings over the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight purse, Sharkey's trainers testified that promoter Lynch had arranged for Wyatt Earp to referee and that Sharkey believed it would be worth $2,500 to have a favorable referee. Trainers also described faking an injury after Sharkey was knocked out, including barring doctors from the room while producing evidence of a foul.

Wheeling Register · 10 December 1896 · page 1

SAX FRANCISCO. December 9—The legal contest between Sharkey and Fitz simmons for tlie possession of the $10,000 purse hits commenced before the Superior Court. Excitement was Intense when the proceedings began in the crowded court room to-day and Manager Julian brought out his witnesses to prove the conspiracy which he stated had deprived Fitzsimmons of the purse. "Australian Hilly'’ Smith, one of Sharkey's trainers. w;ts the first witness. He detailed his work In connection with preparing Shar key for the ring and said when the ques tion of selecting a referee was mooted in Sharkey's training quarters lie was asked to suggest a referee.

See moreSee less

Witness suggeled Hiram Cook and aid Lynch then asked him if he knew Cook well enough "to tulk business with hint.” Afterwards, witness said. Lynch char acterized Cook as "no good,” because he would not favor his brother in a fight. On the evening of the fight Sharkey told witness that Earp had been fixed as ref eree and that "Earp was all right." Witness described the uproar over the preliminaries to tin* fight and said when Fitzsimmons objeted to the bandages on Sharkey’s hand, Earp went over to Shar key's corner and said: “Take off those clothes, it will be all right anyway.” Wit ness said when Sharkey received the knockout blow on the jaw in the eighth round Lynch said to Sharkey: "Lie low, hold your hands on your groin and pre tend to faint with PaiC.” Sharkey was then carried to a room. He did not appear to be hurt. Witness said Allen, another trainer, “removed Sharkey’s bandages and did the work which caused the swelling. Sharkey was then driven to his hotel in a. hack. Allen was with him. Sharkey was all right.” Goorgo Allen, another of Sharkey’s trainers, corroborau-d the story of the 1 previous witness, adding that several phy sicians were refused admittance when Sharkey was undergoing the operation with which Allen produced the evidence of a foul. Lynch said no doctor should come into the room and interfere with Ills plans. Witness said Sharkey told him the Na tional Athletic Club was composed of

See the clipping

The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb. · and 1 other paper

Before the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, Sharkey's manager Martin Julian objected to Wyatt Earp serving as referee, claiming rumors that Earp intended to rule against his fighter. Earp denied the charge and defended his reputation as a square sportsman, while Sharkey's backer Dan Lynch insisted his man was ready to fight under the National Club's chosen referee.

The McCook Tribune · 11 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Wrangle Over Referee.

There was a little delay before Referee Earp appeared. Announcer Jordan announced that owing to rumors of crookedness Martin Julian refused to accept Earp as referee. Julian says he suggested several men to Sharkey's backers, but all were rejected. He says San Francisco sporting men had come to him and said the referee had intended to give a decision against his man. This statement was received with hisses.

See moreSee less

Earp made a speech denying Julian's statement, saying he was square. Then Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, said Sharkey had lived up to every article in the agreement, and was here ready to fight with the referee selected by the National club, as per agreement, the men's backer's having failed to agree on a referee prior.

Announcer Jordan announced that Julian was ready to take any referee in the house except Earp. Then there was some more consultation, while the crowd howled "Earp."

Julian's charge against Earp was a surprise, as the Arizona man has always enjoyed a splendid reputation as a square sport.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · 10 December 1896

Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · and 2 other papers

Witnesses Allen and Abbott testify about Sharkey's condition after the fight and events in his dressing room, with Allen denying he saw any foul. Separately, referee Wyatt Earp pleaded guilty to carrying concealed weapons and paid a $50 fine.

Birmingham State Herald · 11 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Game."--Earp Fined.

San Francisco, Dec. 10.--George Allen, Tom Sharkey's assistant trainer, occupied the witness stand most of today in behalf of Bob Fitzsimmons. His testimony was strongly corroborative of that given by Billy Smith yesterday, and tended to show the alleged conspiracy by which the Cornishman was robbed of the decision of the recent fight. Allen said that Sharkey never talked to him about the fight, and he knew nothing before the contest of any deal by which Sharkey was to be given the decision, and he knew of no plan to have a friendly referee named. The night of the fight witness was in Sharkey's corner in the capacity of bottle holder. He could see the men clearly and closely followed their movements. In the eighth round Fitzsimmons landed his left on Sharkey's stomach and followed it up immediately with an upper cut on the chin. It was a second or two before Sharkey fell after receiving the last blow. Allen was positive he did not see any foul. He was holding a towel and started to toss it in the air in token of defeat, but was prevented from doing so. He assisted in carrying Sharkey from the ring to his dressing room and while doing so first heard the sailor had been given the decision on a foul.

See moreSee less

Asked as to Sharkey's condition at the time Allen said: "He was groaning and limp, but was not insensible. He was not knocked out, but he was limp." Allen said that Lynch, William Abbott, Danny Needham, Billy Smith and a reporter went to the dressing room. Smith and the witness began to undress Sharkey, but Lynch objected. Sharkey asked Allen to get some water and motioned for him to bathe his groin, which he did. He saw no swelling or discoloration. Lynch refused to permit a doctor to examine Sharkey until after he was removed to his hotel. When the latter reached his room Allen helped to undress him and again bathed his groin. Even then he saw no swelling or discoloration. Soon after Needham came in with a doctor and the room was cleared, only Lynch and Needham remaining while the physician examined Sharkey. Allen left the hotel and did not return until the next afternoon, when he demanded some money. Lynch gave him $100. Witness thought his services were worth $500, and later Lynch gave him $10 more and followed it Monday with $50.

Allen was cross-examined by Gen. Barnes, but did not add anything to his testimony.

William Abbott, a tenderloin saloon-keeper, testified that he assisted in carrying Sharkey to his dressing room and described the incidents while in there substantially as Allen did.

Permission was given Gen. Barnes to take the depositions of Lynch, Sharkey, Needham, Earp and others and the case was continued till Monday.

Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, plead guilty to carrying concealed weapons today and was fined $50, which he paid.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · 11 December 1896
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 11 December 1896

Mesa Free Press · Mesa, Ariz.

Amid controversy over Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, this piece recounts his earlier career as a deputy under Marshal Mike Meagher in Wichita and later as a lawman in Ellsworth and Deadwood. It describes him as fearless and honorable, with old-timers vouching for his integrity.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Mesa Free Press · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP IN KANSAS.

Wyatt Earp, who is accused by Bob Fitzsimmons and his friends with having refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, is well known to the old timers in Wichita, says The Times of that place, having served as an officer under Marshal Mike Maegher, in the early '70's. Wichita at that time was the great cattle market for the southwest, and it required the utmost vigilance and bravery on the part of the officers to hold the lawless element in check. Earp was absolutely devoid of fear, and

See the clipping

Mesa Free Press · Mesa, Ariz.

This article recalls Wyatt Earp's time as a lawman in Dodge City, Deadwood, and Ellsworth, quoting associates who vouch for his honesty. It appears amid discussion of his controversial role refereeing a prize fight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Mesa Free Press · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP IN KANSAS.

The case of the United States versus the Southern Pacific Company and others will probably soon come up in the Supreme Court of the United States. It involves the title to and possession of 700,000 acres opposite to and coterminous with a portion of the S. P. R. from Tehachapi Pass by way of Los Angeles to Yuma on the Colorado river. The railroad company claims the land by virtue of its succession to the rights of the Texas Pacific Railroad Company, to which the grant was originally made, and under that claim has sold parcels of it to about 20,000 purchasers, who are conceded to be bona fide settlers.

The Government contends that suppressing lawlessness in that town, and was elected marshal. Not much is known of him after he went out to Arizona. Dick Cogdell, ex-city marshal, says of him "I never heard of him doing anything crooked in a business way. He was a fair, honest man and his record is good here."

See moreSee less

Police Clerk John Martin, who was intimately acquainted with him, says: "Earp was just the kind of a man to referee a prize-fight, because all the bullies who ever gathered around a prize ring could not scare or bulldoze him; he was thoroughly honest."

Detective Bedford Wood, who knew Earp, said he never knew him to be charged with dishonesty before this prize fight.—Ex.

See the clipping

Tombstone Prospector · Tombstone, Ariz.

The report states that Wyatt Earp was fined for carrying a concealed weapon in San Francisco, amid ongoing sensational testimony in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight conspiracy case. The fine is linked to Earp's controversial role as referee in the earlier bout.

Tombstone Prospector · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Prize Fight Squabble Getting Rich.

TESTIMONY IS STARTLING.

See moreSee less

Earp is Fined $50 for Carrying Concealed Weapons

NO CLEW TO THE ROBBRS

San Francisco,—The evidence in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey case yesterday was along the lines as the testimony previously given, and Fitzsimmons and Julian have certainly fulfilled their promise to produce a story of conspiracy that would startle the sporting world. George Allen, Sharkey's second and assistant trainer, was the principal witness yesterday. His evidence corroborated in the main the testimony given by Australian Billy Smith.

San Francisco—Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying a concealed weapon yesterday.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Wyatt Earp was fined $50 in San Francisco for carrying a concealed weapon. He had been armed when he entered the ring to referee the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match.

Arizona Republican · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE USUAL DOSE. Wyatt Earp Fined $50 for Carrying a Concealed Weapon. SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying concealed weapons today.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A San Francisco court heard testimony from Sharkey's second, George Allen, regarding the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight that Wyatt Earp had refereed. Allen testified that Sharkey was fairly knocked out and that no foul blow was struck, contradicting claims of a conspiracy.

Arizona Republican · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

STARTLING TO THE SPORTS.

Blow—Says That Sharkey Was Fairly Knocked Out.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—The evidence in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey case today was along the lines of the testimony previously given, and Fitzsimmons and Julian have certainly fulfilled their promise to produce a story of conspiracy that would startle the sporting world.

See moreSee less

George Allen, Sharkey's second and assistant trainer, was the principal witness today, his evidence corroborating in the main the testimony given by "Australian Billy" Smith. On cross-examination Allen admitted that while Sharkey after the fight gave no external evidence of injury in the groin he asked for water when taken to his dressing room, and when the water was brought, directed Allen to bathe his groin.

Allen considered that Sharkey had been fairly knocked out by Fitzsimmons and declares that no foul blow was struck by the latter. He was so impressed by the fact that Sharkey was knocked out that after the sailor had been down six seconds, he started to throw up his towel to indicate Sharkey's surrender.

Allen said he helped to carry Sharkey into the dressing room, from which all but Sharkey, Lynch and the trainers were excluded. In the dressing room Sharkey was carefully examined and the witness was positive he was at that time uninjured in the groin. After Sharkey was taken to his hotel and the trainers were excluded from Sharkey's room, Lynch, Danny Needham and Dr. Lee were alone with him. Shortly afterwards from his position outside the room, the witness said he heard Sharkey cry out as if in pain. No doctor was permitted to examine Sharkey in the dressing room immediately after the fight, although several, including a physician of the National Athletic club, applied for admittance and tendered their services. According to the witness, Lynch said: "We want no doctor here."

William Abbott, who sat close to the ring, corroborated Allen's testimony.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report accuses Examiner editor 'Long Green' Lawrence of rigging the referee selection for the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, claiming he pushed for Wyatt Earp while falsely implying other papers' editors also recommended him. It also addresses testimony from trainers Allen and Abbott regarding the location of the disputed foul blow on Sharkey's body.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CROOKED WORK WAS DONE BY LONG GREEN'S PROTECTOR

Not Recommend Him.

Long Green Lawrence, the Examiner's managing editor, did not recommend Hiram Cook as referee, because Mr. Cook had quietly given Dan Lynch to understand that he would decide in favor of the winner, no matter who he might be.

See moreSee less

According to the testimony of Trainer Allen, Lynch and Sharkey did not want a fair referee. "That —— won't do for us," said Sharkey. Sharkey had Wyatt Earp of the Examiner in his eye.

The fact that Long Green induced Gibbs and Groom to write a letter to The Call with the object of showing that Mr. Bunker of the Report and Mr. Simpson of the Chronicle had also recommended Earp for the position of referee is regarded as a confession of guilt on Long Green's part, for both these gentlemen have branded the statement as a lie and placed the burden where it belongs, upon the shoulders of Lawrence and the Examiner.

As an illustration of the low trickery resorted to by Long Green in order to make it appear that other newspapers besides the Examiner had given Wyatt Earp the glad hand, the reader is reminded of the visit to the Chronicle office of Earp and Police Lieutenant Esola, the latter a relative of Long Green Lawrence, and whose position in the Police Department was obtained through Long Green's influence as one of the powers that be on the Examiner. It will be remembered that Esola asked City Editor Simpson for a

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Witnesses testified in court that Sharkey's claimed low blow was actually a legitimate knockout punch to the stomach, suggesting the foul was faked. The report also accuses Examiner editor Lawrence of conspiring to install his friend Wyatt Earp as referee through deceptive maneuvering with rival papers.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

that the Chronicle had approved of the selection of Earp.

Every day's developments clinch the fact that the whole affair was a fake and a conspiracy on the part of the Sharkey crowd and that Managing Editor Lawrence of the Examiner assisted in the plot by recommending and procuring the selection of Wyatt Earp, his bosom friend, as referee.

See moreSee less

Wyatt Earp has resumed his position as bodyguard and special writer for the Examiner, for that paper contained yesterday a signed article by Earp.

George Allen and William Abbott went on the stand in Judge Sanderson's court yesterday morning and corroborated the statement made the day before by Billy Smith to the effect that Sharkey's injury on which the foul was declared was a fake. Both the witnesses saw the knockout blows delivered and both were positive that the alleged foul blow was landed on the pit of Sharkey's stomach and not below the belt, as claimed.

They told of the visit of Dr. B. B. Lee to Sharkey's room and of Lynch ordering them out while the doctor was there—a proceeding which Allen regarded as uncalled for and unusual in his case, seeing that he was one of Sharkey's trainers and that there was no occasion for secrecy if everything was fair and above board.

Sharkey returned to this City from Vallejo yesterday afternoon, and was followed up Market street from the Baldwin Hotel

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Attorneys continue taking depositions from witnesses in the legal dispute over whether the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, refereed by Wyatt Earp, was fixed. The court declines to compel certain long-time San Francisco residents to testify, and the hearing is adjourned until Monday with more witnesses, including Earp himself, still to be examined.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

CROOKED WORK WAS DONE

Mexico's permission, and on an old claim that the island was ceded to the British, a forgotten treaty. The Mexican Government has ordered the transport Oaxaca to

TO CURE A COLD IN ONE DAY.

See moreSee less

Take laxative Bromo Quinine Tablets. All druggists refund the money if it fails to cure. 25c.

he had with George Allen, but he did not get caught in any of the trap holes that Kowalsky and Freidenrich kindly left open for him.

The examination of Abbott lasted till after noon, and it was agreed to proceed with the taking of further depositions, beginning next Monday morning at 10 o'clock. The counsel for Fitzsimmons said that they had several other witnesses to examine, and the attorneys for Sharkey announced that they desired to put Earp, Sharkey, Gibbs, Groom and others on the stand.

Judge Sanderson remarked that as the matter was simply the taking of the depositions of witnesses who were non-resident and about to leave this City he would not allow Messrs. Gibbs and Groom to be placed on the stand. They were old residents of San Francisco, had no intention of going away, and could not be driven out of the City, he said.

"I am not trying this case now," added the court, "and I don't know whether it ever can be tried."

"Are your witnesses residents here or fugitives from somewhere else?" asked Karnes of Kowalsky.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report recounts a horse race between an American-owned bay and roan horse near Tia Juana, with heavy betting from both Americans and Mexicans. Wyatt Earp allegedly tried to fix the race by convincing Americans to bet on the roan while secretly attempting to bribe the bay's owner to throw the race.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

EARP'S STRAIGHT TIP.

the gold of the Americans. Wyatt Earp was in the neighborhood at the time and took a great interest in the coming race. He went among his American friends and told them to bet all their money on the roan horse, saying he had arranged with the owner of the bay to pull his animal, and that they would all win big money by taking his advice.

The Americans almost to a man followed Earp's advice and took up every bet they could obtain, in many instances giving big odds.

See moreSee less

On the day of the race just before it was called Earp went to McCarthy, the owner of the bay horse, asked him to have it pulled and offered him half the stakes if he would throw the race in favor of the Americans.

This McCarthy refused to do point blank, and then, fearing that his jockey had been tampered with, went out to where the horses were on the track and discharged him. He put another man in the saddle, and remained with the horse until the race was called.

At the start the roan had a slight advantage, but the bay crept slowly up, and at the quarter both horses were neck and neck. Then the bay began to draw ahead

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Wyatt Earp was fined $50 by Judge Low for carrying a concealed weapon, after Captain Wittman testified to confiscating his revolver at the Pavilion prize ring. The report also recounts an earlier incident of Earp allegedly throwing a race for money, angering American bettors.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

EARP AND HIS HOWITZER. Judge Low Sentences Him to Pay a Fine of Fifty Dollars.

Mexico's permission, and on an old claim that the island was ceded to the British, a forgotten treaty. The Mexican Government has ordered the transport Oaxaca to

TO CURE A COLD IN ONE DAY. Take laxative Bromo Quinine Tablets. All druggists refund the money if it fails to cure. 25c.

See moreSee less

and flashed under the wire a winner by a good length. Immense excitement followed, and the Americans, who quickly discovered that Earp had never had any tip on the result and had deliberately thrown his friends, became crazy with rage. Knives and pistols quickly made their appearance, and but for the fact that McCarthy, who was a deputy sheriff, stepped in and protected Earp, he would have lost his li[f]e then and there. The matter was eventually arranged, and the Americans settled their bets like men, but they still remained very sore at Earp, who, finding things decidedly too warm for him, disappeared that night, and has never been seen in that part of the country since. This is a slight and fully authentic sample of Wyatt Earp's squareness from a sporting point of view.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A sarcastic newspaper column lumps together various public controversies, noting that when people talk about the 'great foul' many mean Fitzsimmons' blow, many mean Earp's decision, but most mean the Examiner itself. It references the ongoing public outrage over Wyatt Earp's controversial referee ruling in the Fitzsimmons fight.

The San Francisco Call · 11 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

In the prevalent talk about the "great foul" a few people mean Fitzsimmons' blow, many people mean Earp's decision, but the vast majority mean the Examiner.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A Tucson report notes that Wyatt Earp and others remain under indictment for the 1882 murder of Frank Stilwell. It states the men were outlawed, could not be captured, left the Territory, and the indictment has never been resolved.

The Record-Union · 11 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Indictment of Murder Against Earp.

Two Men Who Have Been Operating at Los Angeles.

LOS ANGELES, Dec. 10.—Two counterfeiters named John Clark and Frank Heniman were lodged in the city jail to-night by Detectives Hawley and Auble after a long chase.

See moreSee less

About six weeks ago several complaints were lodged at police headquarters to the effect that counterfeit half-dollars were being passed upon small shopkeepers whose places of business are outside of the central portion of the city. The matter was turned over to the two detectives, and by hard work night and day they not only succeeded in capturing the criminals, but secured their plant, consisting of metals, dies, tools and quite a large sum of counterfeit coin.

Indictment of Murder Against Earp.

TUCSON (Ariz.), Dec. 10.—Wyatt Earp, with others, stands indicted for the murder of Frank Stillwell in Tucson March 20, 1882. They were out-

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · and 1 other paper

A witness named Allen, who was in Sharkey's corner, testified he saw no foul blow and described the chaotic scene after Sharkey was declared winner on a foul. The report also notes Wyatt Earp, the fight's referee, pleaded guilty to carrying a concealed weapon and was fined $50.

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

and followed it up immediately with an uppercut on the chin. It was a second or two before Sharkey fell after receiving the last blow. Allen was positive he did not see any foul. He was holding a towel and started to toss it in the air in token of defeat, but was prevented from doing so. He assited in carrying Sharkey from the ring to his dressing room, and while doing so first heard the sailor had been given the decision on a foul. Asked as to Sharkey's condition at that time, Allen said: "He was groaning and limp, but he was sensible. He was not knocked out, but he was limp." Allen said that Lynch, William Ab

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · 11 December 1896

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

A bottle-holder named Allen testified in the legal hearing over the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, describing Sharkey's limp but seemingly uninjured condition after Fitzsimmons was given the foul decision. The same report notes that referee Wyatt Earp separately pleaded guilty to carrying a concealed weapon and paid a $50 fine.

The Morning Times · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

REFEREE EARP FINED

SHARKEY'S CONDITION. Asked as to Sharkey's condition at that time Allen said: "He was groaning and limp. He was not knocked out, but he was limp." Allen said that Lynch, William Abbott, Danny Needham, Billy Smith, and a re-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Wyatt Earp, who had served as referee in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, pleaded guilty in San Francisco to carrying concealed weapons. He was fined $50, which he paid.

New-York Tribune · 11 December 1896 · page 3

WYATT EARP FINED

Besides this sum, $1,750 was also shown to be due from delingaent members, he following members were unanimously chosen corve as members of the Executive Commitiee | to for 1867: James Butler, Warren G. Leland. Fred. erick I. Steinway, Captain C,H. McDonald, A. B Gwiathmey, W. kK. Parsons, jr. Andrew Garside, Pdward Martens, J. H. Rogan, I Hedges, Alexander Newburger, and Luke rhe. From this the president, vice-president, secretary | committee will be chosen next Tuesday. It Is anl treasurer Butler will again be elected presi. certain that Mr. dent, re e— *- — WYATT EARP FINED, arp, the referee Kan Francisco, Dee, 10.--Wyatt fight, pleaded gullty of the Sharkey Mitzsimmons to-day and was to carrying c meealed weapons fined $0, which he pald, |

See the clipping

Cottonwood Report · Cottonwood, Idaho

The National Athletic Club issued a statement defending its handling of accusations that referee Wyatt Earp had cheated Fitzsimmons out of a win over Sharkey. The club noted it had doctors examine Sharkey, stopped payment on a $10,000 check pending investigation, and said the matter was now before the courts.

Cottonwood Report · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

OLYMPIC CLUB BIDS FOR IT. Wants to See Corbett and Fitzsimmons Fight.

San Francisco, Dec. 6.—There is a prospect that Corbett and Fitzsimmons may be brought together in this city in a 10-round contest. The Olympic Athletic Club, one of the oldest and most influential institutions in the city, has offered the men $15,000 to fight 10 rounds under its management. Corbett has accepted the proposition, which will now be laid before Fitzsimmons.

See moreSee less

National Club Statement.

See the clipping

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

A small-town newspaper recounts local gossip and business news, including a brief mention that Wyatt Earp, who had recently refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prizefight, was a former Kansas lawman. It notes he had served as city marshal of Ellsworth and Dodge City and as a policeman in Wichita.

The Goodland Republic · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Of course it turns out that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was a formerly of Kansas man. He was city marshal of Ells

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A satirical newspaper column making various political jibes includes a quip that Spanish general Weyler should hire Wyatt Earp to write 'official' battle accounts, implying Earp's reports were seen as embellished or unreliable. This is a passing cultural reference rather than a news report about Earp himself.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 11 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

If Sharkey pretended to be knocked out and so won, there is more drama in pugilism than Corbett's acting indicates.

Allen and Bryan of Nebraska cause more trouble than any other two Pops in the country. Nebraska is worse than Kansas.

See moreSee less

-Kansas Chief. However, another Kansas celebrity, Dr. J. N. O. P. Wood, still survives. He makes his home in Wichita.

As soon as Weyler hears of Wyatt Earp he will probably employ him to go to Cuba and write the "official" ac-

See the clipping

The Citizen · Frederick City, Md. · and 1 other paper

In a San Francisco courtroom, Wyatt Earp, who had refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, testified he had no money or property despite being thought wealthy. The hearing over the disputed purse continued, with Julian claiming evidence of jobbery and Sharkey moving lodgings amid jurisdiction disputes.

The Citizen · 11 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

FITZ-SHARKEY TROUBLE.

Purse---Earp a Poor Man. San Francisco, Dec. 9.—Bob Fitzsimmons, his manager, Martin Julian; Dan Lynch, representing Ton Sharkey; Wyatt Earp, who acted as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, and a number of others interested in the legal squabble for the possession of the $10,000 purse money, appeared in Justice Groezinger's court room yesterday afternoon. Referee Earp was the only witness examined, and he was not asked to explain how or when he consented to act as referee. He testified, however, that he did not possess a dollar in the world and that he owned no property save the clothing he wore.

See moreSee less

This admission created surprise, as the witness was popularly supposed to be a man of means. Cross-examination was reserved until to-morrow. Julian insists that he has abundant testimony to prove the existence of a huge piece of jobbery. Although Sharkey was supposed to have suffered a relapse yesterday, he was nevertheless well enough to change his quarters to the Vallejo last evening. The Fitzsimmons faction positively claim that he moved for the purpose of remaining beyond the jurisdiction of Justice Groezinger's court, but his friends deny this.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 9 December 1896

The Copper Country Evening News · Calumet, Mich.

At a San Francisco court hearing, Australian Billy Smith testified that Referee Earp had been bribed to award the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight to Sharkey. Smith claimed Sharkey was not actually injured during the bout but was later marked up by trainers to support a foul claim against Fitzsimmons; Sharkey called the testimony perjury.

The Copper Country Evening News · 11 December 1896 · page 1

Billy" Smith testified In court Wednes day that Referee Earp hai been bribed to award the fight! between Fttzslm mons and, Sharkey to the sailor. ,That Sharkey was not Injured in the fight, but was "fixed" afterward by his train ers to show that Fltzslmmons had fouled him by having a bruise and swelling on the groin. Sharkey says the testimony is porfurv.'.. . Italian Steamship Lost. '

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The report notes Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying a gun into the ring while refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. It then details ongoing testimony in the fraud inquiry, including trainer George Allen corroborating claims that Sharkey's groin injury was faked and that he was legitimately knocked out rather than fouled.

The Saint Paul Globe · 11 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

EARP FINED $50 FOR WEARING A GUN INTO THE RING FOR THE SHARKEY FIGHT.

"Australian Billy" Smith. On cross-examination Allen admitted that while Sharkey after the fight gave no external evidence of injuries in the groin, he asked for water when taken to his dressing room, and when the water was brought, directed Allen to bathe his groin. Allen declared that Sharkey had been fairly knocked out, and he declares that no foul blow was struck by Fitzsimmons. He was so impressed by the fact that Sharkey was knocked out that after the sailor had been down six seconds, he started to throw up his towel to indicate Sharkey's surrender.

See moreSee less

Allen says he helped carry Sharkey into the dressing room, from which all but Sharkey, Lynch and the trainers were excluded. In the dressing room Sharkey was carefully examined, and witness was positive he was at that time uninjured in the groin. After Sharkey was taken to his hotel and the trainers were excluded from Sharkey's room, Lynch, Danny Needham and Dr. Lee were alone with Sharkey. Shortly afterwards, from his position outside the room, witness said he heard Sharkey cry out as if in pain. When he saw Sharkey the next time, on the following day, his groin was bandaged and there were stains of blood on the groin. He applied fomentations to the groin which was then swollen and discolored. No doctor was permitted to examine Sharkey in the dressing room immediately after the fight, although several, including the physician of the National Athletic club, applied for admittance and tendered their services. According to the witness Lynch said:

See the clipping

Great Falls Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

A trainer's affidavit alleges that Wyatt Earp, Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham conspired to rig the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match by having Sharkey fake a foul when he was losing. The story reports that Fitzsimmons' attorney is using this affidavit in an injunction case being heard in court that day.

Great Falls Weekly Tribune · 11 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9.—A morning paper publishes the following: George Allen, one of the men who trained Tom Sharkey for his fight with Fitzsimmons, has made a confession to the effect that Fitzsimmons was deprived of his victory through a conspiracy. The trainer and the Sharkey management quarreled over money matters, it is said, and in the heat of the moment Allen made threats of what he would do if he were not paid for his services. Attorney Kowalsky, representing Fitzsimmons, heard of the circumstances and employed private detectives to gather in the irate trainer.

See moreSee less

He was run to ground yesterday and induced to tell the whole story. The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey injunction case will be called in Judge Sanderson's court today. It was down on the calendar for hearing a day later, but plaintiff's attorneys besought the court to take up the matter today, as they were afraid that valuable testimony in their possession might not keep. They have no particular faith in their men and propose to take no chances. It is claimed that Allen, in an affidavit, named Wyatt Earp, Dan J. Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and

See the clipping

Emmons County Record · Williamsport, N.D.

San Francisco is divided over referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with many believing Sharkey faked a foul to win after being knocked out. Prominent citizens and physicians offer conflicting opinions, while suspicions mount that Sharkey's backer manipulated the referee selection process.

Emmons County Record · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

IT HAS A BAD LOOK CONSPIRACY ALLEGED IN THE SAN FRANCISCO PRIZE FIGHT

divided as to the result of the Fitzsimmons Sharkey fight, which continues to be the topic of the hour. No one questions that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly deprived of the decision. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow and was, consequently, under the rules, entitled to the honors of victory, including the purse of $10,000. A third class bases its opinions solely upon the reports of the physicians in attendance upon Sharkey.

See moreSee less

The doctors point to the swollen and discolored condition of the sailor's skin in the region of the groin as evidence of a foul blow, and some ardent Fitzsimmons advocates reply that this condition was purposely caused by an injection of a drug immediately after the fight. A number of physicians and newspaper men were present in Sharkey's room to-day when an examination of his injuries were made. All were convinced that Sharkey's condition was the result of a foul blow. Many prominent men, however, condemn the decision and refuse to believe there was any fouling. Such men as Police Commissioner Gunst, Riley Grannan, Maj. Frank McLaughlin, who was chairman of the Republican state central committee, and others, believe that Fitzsimmons should have received the decision. It is pointed out that the whole affair has A Disagreeable Look

See the clipping

Emmons County Record · Williamsport, N.D.

After the disputed fight refereed by Wyatt Earp, Sharkey sought an injunction alleging conspiracy to deny Fitzsimmons the $10,000 purse, and a bank refused to cash the certified check at the National club's request. Meanwhile Sharkey remains bedridden under doctors' care while Fitzsimmons walks freely, celebrated by crowds as the true winner.

Emmons County Record · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

has been applied for to restrain the Anglo-California bank from cashing the National club's check until Fitzsimmons has an opportunity to prove the conspiracy. When Lynch and Referee Earp went to the bank to-day with the check payment was refused by the teller, who referred Lynch to Manager Lilienthal. The latter stated that he had been advised by his attorney that the bank was in the position of an innocent custodian of the money which would be involved in the promised legal controversy, and that for the protection of the bank he would refuse to pay it.

See moreSee less

Lynch supposed that the bank had been formally enjoined from cashing the check, but it afterward developed that the bank was acting on an order from the officials of the National club, who requested that payment of the check should be temporarily deferred. As the check had been certified the right of the bank to refuse payment is questioned and will form the basis of an attack by Sharkey should he be worsted in the injunction suit. Meantime Sharkey is in bed with three doctors in constant attendance and he is likely to remain there for several days; the $10,000 is in the bank and is also likely to remain where it is for some time, and Bob Fitzsimmons, without mark or bruise, and followed by an admiring and cheering crowd, is walking the streets, receiving continued ovations as the real winner of the encounter.

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

Witnesses testified in the Fitzsimmons trial that Sharkey showed no signs of a foul immediately after being knocked out, with bloody marks appearing only after a doctor examined him privately. The same report notes that referee Wyatt Earp was fined $50 in police court for carrying a pistol.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 11 December 1896 · page 6

T THERE WAS NO FOUL. S 0 fays Trainer Allen Regarding the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey Contest. San Francigco, Dec. 11.—In the Fitz slmmons trlal yesterday George Allen, \ assistant trginer for Sharkey, testified

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

Witnesses testified that Sharkey showed no signs of a foul until after a doctor examined him privately, corroborating earlier testimony that no foul occurred. Separately, referee Wyatt Earp was fined $50 in police court for carrying a pistol into the ring on the night of the fight.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 11 December 1896 · page 6

San Francigco, Dec. 11.—In the Fitz slmmons trlal yesterday George Allen, \ assistant trginer for Sharkey, testified that in the eighth round Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out completely. Fitz simmons made no foul, and as one of Bharkey’s seconds, he claimed none, but after Sharkey was knocked out witness jumped into the ring and waved a towel as a tßken of surrender. Witness said@ he and Billy Smith car ried Sharkey into the dressing room. Sharkey was limp and groaning, but the only marks of the fight were on his face. e said nothing about a foul blow, and when witness examined him there was n 5 mark on his groin, which looked just the same as usual.

See moreSee less

Sharkey was then dressed by witness and Billy Smith and taken to his hotel. Witness said that no marks on his groin were visible until after the doctor was ciogeted with Sharkey. After the doctor left witness again saw Sharkey, whose groin was then covered with blood stained clots. William Abbott, a saloon keeper, testi fied that during the fight he/ had sat close to the ring, and that when Sharkey was knocked out he " ad assisted Smith and Allen to carry Sharkey to the dress ing room. e corrokorated the state ments of Smith and Allen that Sharkey had not been fouled, and said that Sharkey gasve no evidence of having been fouled. His testimony regarding the absence of foul, or of any marks on Sharkey’s groin when carried from the ring, was corroborative with that of previous witnesses. A recess was then taken until Monday. In the police court Referee Wyatt Earp was fined SSO for having carried a pistel to the ring on the night of the fight. Harry Corbett is in receipt of a long telegram from Jim Corbett, authorizing him to make every effor:t to get on a match with Fitzsimmons, and as a resuit is out with the following: “Corbett will meet Fitzsimmons be fore the Olympic club for from five to 20 rounds and for a side bet of from SIOOO to §IO,OOO, and for any purse offered. The size of the purse can be SIO,OOO or $15,000. In order to show his readiness to fight, Corbett will not insist on a side bet. In regard to the selection of a referee, Cor bett is willing to leave the appointment to W. Greer Harrison and Major McLaughlin.”

See the clipping

Sierra County Advocate · Kingston, N.M.

Referee Wyatt Earp defends his decision to award the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight to Sharkey on a foul, describing the blow he saw. Fitzsimmons and Sharkey give contradictory accounts of the incident, and Corbett telegraphs Sharkey offering a future match.

Sierra County Advocate · 11 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

GABBLE OF THE PUGILISTS.

Referee Earp, whose decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight at San Francisco, Cal., caused an indignant demonstration from the crowd at the ring side that night, stated next morning that he decided the contest in favor of Sharkey because he believed that Fitz deliberately fouled him.

See moreSee less

He said: "I should have given Sharkey the fight earlier in the contest. In the fourth round, I think, Fitz landed a left-handed blow and returned with his elbow, cutting Sharkey's eyebrow open. The foul blow of the eighth round was seen plainly by me. Fitz smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder; then, with an upper cut with his left, struck the sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul."

Fitzsimmons said: "Earp knows

See the clipping

Sierra County Advocate · Kingston, N.M.

After refereeing the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, newspapers add a biographical aside noting Wyatt Earp was a Dodge City lawman alongside his brothers, who later moved to Arizona and became known as the feuding 'Earp gang' before relocating to California. The item frames his frontier reputation as background to explain the unpopular ruling.

Sierra County Advocate · 11 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

REFEREE WYATT EARP. Wyatt Earp who has made the unpopular decision in the Fitzsimmons Sharkey prize fight, is an old Dodge City, Colo., man, of the days when Bat Masterson ran the town. There were then three brothers of them, all gun fighters, and all men peaceably inclined would walk over into another county to avoid them. After the decadence of Dodge City the brothers went down into Arizona, where they became known as the "Earp gang," and speedily worked up a feud with a neighboring outfit. In the resulting fight one

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

Sharkey's trainers testified in court that the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight was fixed, claiming Earp was selected and paid $2,500 to referee in Sharkey's favor. They also alleged that Sharkey's groin injuries were faked afterward with hypodermic injections.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Morning Appeal · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Prize Ring Jobbery.

The inside of the big fight is now laid bear to the public in the Courts. Billy Smith and George Allen, Sharkey's trainers, have been on the stand and testified that the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight was a fake; that Earp was selected as referee and "fixed" for $2,500, and that the discolorations on Sharkey's groin were made after the fight by hypodermic injections. Billy Smith did the work and he and the other trainers went on the stand and told the truth because Sharkey owed them money he would not pay. This testimony if unrefuted, should give Fitzfimmons the $10,000 and land the rest of the gang in jail.

See moreSee less

Air-ships in Empire.

During several days past there has been rumors of an air-ship in Empire which was seen floating above Wiggin's Hall, and moving along like a large turkey buzzard hunting grub. Yesterday the Appeal received the following:

See the clipping

The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla. · and 19 other papers

A trainer's testimony corroborates claims that Sharkey, Lynch, Needham, and referee Wyatt Earp conspired to rig the outcome by having Sharkey fake a foul. The witness detailed the scheme: Sharkey would signal by grabbing his groin, Needham would jump into the ring to claim a foul, and Earp would rule in Sharkey's favor for a bribe of $3,500.

The Guthrie Daily Leader · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SHARKEY-FITZ IN COURT.

Sharkey's Trainers Testify to an Alleged Plot to Rob Fitz of the Purse.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—The legal contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons for the possession of the $10,000 purse has commenced before the superior court. Excitement was intense when the proceedings began in the crowded court room, and Manager Julian brought out his witnesses to prove the conspiracy which he stated had deprived Fitzsimmons of the purse.

"Australian Billy" Smith, one of Sharkey's trainers, was the first witness. He detailed his work in connection with preparing Sharkey for the ring, and said, when the question of a referee was mooted in Sharkey's training quarters, he was asked to suggest a referee. Witness suggested Hiram Cook, and said Lynch then asked him if he knew Cook well enough "to talk business with him." Afterward, witness said, Lynch characterized Cook as "no good," because he "would not favor his own brother in a fight." On the evening of the fight, Sharkey told witness that Earp had been fixed upon as referee, and that "Earp was all right." Witness described the uproar over the preliminaries to the fight, and said when Fitzsimmons objected to the bandages on Sharkey's hand, Earp went over to the Sharkey corner and said: "Take off those cloths; it will be all right anyway." Witness said when Sharkey received the knockout blow on the jaw in the eighth round, Lynch said to Sharkey: "Lie low; hold your hands on your groin and pretend to faint with pain." Sharkey was then carried to a room. He did not appear to be hurt. Witness said Allen, another trainer, "removed Sharkey's bandages and did the work which caused the swelling. Sharkey was then driven to his hotel in a hack. Allen was with him. Sharkey was all right.

George Allen, another of Sharkey's trainers, corroborated the story of the previous witness, adding that several physicians were refused admittance when Sharkey was undergoing the operation with which Allen produced the evidence of foul. Lynch said no doctor should come into the room and interfere with his plans. Witness said Sharkey told him the National Athletic Club was composed of Groom, Gibbs, Lynch and Sharkey, and that Sharkey was to receive 20 per cent of the proceeds of the fight after the purse was deducted. Sharkey said his three partners in the National Club were "broke," and Sharkey had to advance $2,500 for preliminary expenses, which had left the sailor pugilist stranded financially. Witness said a few days before the fight Sharkey told him he thought Earp would be the right kind of a referee for him, and added it would be worth $2,500 to Earp if he were the right kind of a referee.

It is claimed that Allen, in an affidavit, named Wyatt Earp, Dan J. Lynch, Tom Sharkey and Dan Needham as the prime movers in the plot. The whole scheme is said to have been hatched at Sharkey's training quarters at Ocean Beach. It was arranged that Sharkey was to make it appear that he had been fouled at some point in the contest when he was in danger of losing from Fitz's blows; further that the signal was to be given by Sharkey, who was to bend over and place his hand on his groin, and at that moment Needham was to jump into the ring and claim a foul. Then the referee was to give a decision in favor of Sharkey.

Premature baldness may be prevented and the hair made to grow on heads already bald, by the use of Hall's Vegetable Hair Renewer.

See the clipping

Also printed 20 more times, in 19 papers
  • Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · 9 December 1896
  • · · 10 December 1896
  • Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · 10 December 1896
  • Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · 10 December 1896
  • Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · 10 December 1896
  • The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del. · 10 December 1896
  • The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 10 December 1896
  • The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · 10 December 1896
  • The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · 10 December 1896
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 10 December 1896
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 10 December 1896
  • The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C. · 10 December 1896
  • Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · 10 December 1896
  • Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio · 10 December 1896
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 10 December 1896
  • The Providence News · Providence, R.I. · 10 December 1896
  • El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex. · 10 December 1896
  • The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash. · 10 December 1896
  • Great Falls Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont. · 11 December 1896
  • The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 12 December 1896

The Providence News · Providence, R.I. · and 1 other paper

Witnesses testify in the Fitzsimmons trial that Sharkey was knocked out cleanly in the eighth round, with no foul committed and no groin injury visible until after a doctor examined him privately. The piece closes by noting referee Wyatt Earp was separately fined $5 for carrying a pistol.

The Providence News · 11 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THERE WAS NO FOUL.

So Says Trainer Allen Regarding th Fitzsimmons-Sharkey Contest.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec. 11.—In the Fitzsimmons trial yesterday George Allen, assistant trainer for Sharkey, testified that in the eighth round Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out completely. Fitzsimmons made no foul, and as one of Sharkey's seconds, he claimed none, but after Sharkey was knocked out witness jumped into the ring and waved a towel as a token of surrender.

Witness said he and Billy Smith carried Sharkey into the dressing room. Sharkey was limp and groaning, but the only marks of the fight were on his face. He said nothing about a foul blow, and when witness examined him there was no mark on his groin, which looked just the same as usual.

Sharkey was then dressed by witness and Billy Smith and taken to his hotel. Witness said that no marks on his groin were visible until after the doctor was closeted with Sharkey. After the doctor left witness again saw Sharkey, whose groin was then covered with blood-stained clots.

William Abbott, a saloon keeper, testified that during the fight he had sat close to the ring, and that when Sharkey was knocked out he had assisted Smith and Allen to carry Sharkey to the dressing room. He corroborated the statements of Smith and Allen that Sharkey had not been fouled, and said that Sharkey gave no evidence of having been fouled. His testimony regarding the absence of foul, or of any marks on Sharkey's groin when carried from the ring, was corroborative with that of previous witnesses. A recess was then taken until Monday.

In the police court Referee Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for having carried a pistol to the ring on the night of the fight.

Harry Corbett is in receipt of a long telegram from Jim Corbett, authorizing him to make every effort to get on a match with Fitzsimmons, and as a result is out with the following:

"Corbett will meet Fitzsimmons before the Olympic club for from five to 20 rounds and for a side bet of from $1000 to $10,000, and for any purse offered. The size of the purse can be $10,000 or $15,000. In order to show his readiness to fight, Corbett will not insist on a side bet. In regard to the selection of a referee, Corbett is willing to leave the appointment to W. Greer Harrison and Major McLaughlin."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 11 December 1896

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

In a San Francisco court case examining the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight refereed by Wyatt Earp, witness George Allen testified about Sharkey's condition after being declared the winner on a foul. Allen described Sharkey's groin being uninjured immediately after the fight but later swollen and bloodied after being alone with his manager and doctor.

El Paso Daily Herald · 11 December 1896 · page 4

More and Very Damaging Evidence Against Referee Earp of Arizona.

groin. Alien considered Sharkey had been fataly knocked out by Fit, and declares no foul blow was struck by Tie ivn so i m riressed lir th fact that Sharkey was knocked out that selected by me personally, which will far after the sailor had been down six )- js market seconds ne s;arteo to turuw uj inc towel to indicate Sharkey's surrender. Allen said he helped carry Sharkey into the dressing room from which i'l but Sharkey. Lynch and trainers were excluded. In the dressing room Sharkey was carefully examined and witness was pos'tive he was at that time uninjured in the groin.

See moreSee less

After Sharkey was taken to the hotel and the trainers were excluded from Sharkey's Dining Chairs. i j i., rt.. '"Speci il Attention to out of town trade.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Wyatt Earp, referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, pleaded guilty today to carrying concealed weapons and was fined $50, which he paid. The report also notes depositions being taken from Lynch, Sharkey, Needham, Earp and others in a related case, continued until Monday.

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

San Francisco, Dec. 10.--Harry Corbett yesterday received a long telegram from Jim Corbett, authorizing him to make every effort to get on a match with Fitzsimmons, and as a result Harry Corbett makes the following statement:

"Corbett will meet Fitzsimmons before the Olympic club for from five to 20 rounds, and for a side bet of from $1,000 to $10,000, and for any purse of

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

During the hearing into the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight controversy, witnesses testified supporting claims that Fitzsimmons was robbed of the decision. Separately, Wyatt Earp, the fight's referee, pleaded guilty to carrying concealed weapons and paid a $50 fine.

The Times · 11 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LOOKS LIKE FITZ WAS ROBBED.

Sharkey's Assistant Trainer a Good Witness for the Cornishman,

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—George Allen, Tom Sharkey's assistant trainer, occupied the witness-box most of to-day in behalf of Bob Fitzsimmons. His testimony was strongly corroborative of that given by Billy Smith yesterday, and tended to show the alleged conspiracy by which the Cornishman was robbed of the decision of the recent fight.

Allen was cross-examined by General Barnes, but did not add anything to his testimony.

William A. Abbot, a tenderloin saloon-keeper, testified he assisted in carrying Sharkey to his dressing-room, and described the incidents while in there substantially as Allen did.

Permission was given General Barnes to take the depositions of Lynch, Sharkey, Needham, Earp, and others, and the case was continued until Monday.

Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, pleaded guilty to carrying concealed weapons to-day and was fined $50, which he paid.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

A news digest item reports that sporting men were claiming boxer Tom Sharkey had 'fixed' referee Wyatt Earp in his recent bout. The claim relates to controversy over Earp's handling of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight decision.

The United Opinion · 11 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Turkey——New York sound money Democrats hold an enthusiastic meeting in the Hoffman House——Hon. Garret A. Hobart banquets the New Jersey Republican committee——Ex-Secretary of the Navy Whitney gives a dinner in honor of Captain Alfred T. Mahan——Sporting men say that Sharkey had Referee Earp "fixed."——William C. Danyu of Middlebury, Vt., kidnaps his child at Fitchburg, Mass——Murderer Willis attempts to break out of Taunton (Mass.) jail——Great damage by a cyclone in West India islands——Two Fall River (Mass.) lawyers have a warm wrangle——Marriage of Edward H.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va. · and 3 other papers

Witnesses testified in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight inquiry, with several swearing Sharkey showed no groin injury or foul blow immediately after being knocked out, though injuries appeared later at his hotel. In a separate police court matter, referee Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying a pistol into the ring on the night of the fight.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 11 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

OH, WHAT A STEAL!

towel as a token of surrender. Witness said he and Billy Smith carried Sharkey into the dressing room. Sharkey was limp and groaning, but the only marks of the fight were on his face. He said nothing about a foul blow, and when witness examined him, there was no mark on his groin, which looked just the same as usual. Sharkey was then dressed by witness and Billy Smith and taken to his hotel. Witness said that no marks on his groin were visible until after the doctor was closeted with Sharkey. After the doctor left witness again saw Sharkey, whose groin was then covered with bloodstained cloth.

Allen's evidence corroborated in the main the testimony given by "Australian Billy" Smith. On cross-examination Allen admitted that Sharkey after the fight gave no external evidences of injuries in the groin and he asked for water when taken to his dressing room, and when the water was brought directed Allen to bathe his groin. Allen considered that Sharkey had been fairly knocked out by Fitzsimmons and he declares that no foul blow was struck by Fitzsimmons.

See moreSee less

Allen says he helped Sharkey into the dressing room, from which all but Sharkey, Lynch and the trainers were excluded. In the dressing room Sharkey was carefully examined and witness was positive he was at that time uninjured in the groin. After Sharkey was taken to his hotel and the trainers were excluded from Sharkey's room, Lynch, Danny Needham and Dr. Lee were alone with Sharkey. Shortly afterwards from his position outside the room witness said he heard Sharkey cry out as if in pain. When he next saw Sharkey on the following day his groin was bandaged and there were stains of blood on the groin. He applied fomentations to the groin which was then swollen and discolored. No doctor was permitted to examine Sharkey in the dressing room immediately after the fight, although several, including the physician of the National Athletic Club, applied for admittance and tendered their services. According to the witness, Lynch said: "We want no doctor here."

Witness, on cross-examination, reiterated his positive statement that no foul blow was struck and that the only injuries Sharkey received during the fight were on his head and face.

William Abbott, a saloon-keeper, testified that during the fight he had sat close to the ring and that when Sharkey was knocked out, he had assisted Smith and Allen to carry Sharkey to the dressing room. He corroborated the statements of Smith and Allen that Sharkey had not been fouled and said that Sharkey gave no evidence of having been fouled. His testimony regarding the absence of foul, or of any marks on Sharkey's groin when carried from the ring was corroborative with that of the previous witness.

A recess was then taken until Monday.

In the police court to-day Referee Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for having carried a pistol to the ring on the night of the fight.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 11 December 1896
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 11 December 1896
  • The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va. · 11 December 1896

Tombstone Prospector · Tombstone, Ariz.

The report states that a Pima County grand jury indictment for the murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson, dated March 25, 1882, remains on file against Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp, Warren Earp, Sherman McMaster, and John Johnson. It notes the men fled the area after the indictment was issued.

Tombstone Prospector · 12 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP.

An Indictment in Arizona Still Hangs Over Him.

See moreSee less

There is on file in the district court of this Frst Judicial District in and for Pima county an indictment for murder against Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp, Warren Earp, Sherman McMasters and John Johnson, charging them with the murder of Frank Stillwell in Tucson, March 20, 1882. The Star says this indictment was found and presented to the court March 25, 1882. After the finding of the indictment the parties were outlawed for several months and were never taken. Most of the parties are now dead, but the fact of Wyatt Earp's appearance in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight makes the fact one of interest as the indictments stand against him untried or otherwise disposed of.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The article reports that a Pima County, Arizona indictment for the 1882 murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson still stands on file against Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp, Warren Earp, and others, who were never tried. It notes that Earp's recent appearance refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight has renewed interest in this old, unresolved legal matter.

Arizona Republican · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ANCIENT HISTORY.

wreck. Superintendent Elliott of the Gunsight mines left here last week with a party of capitalists to expert the mines in the vicinity of the Gunsight for the purpose of purchasing them. A basket social was given at the school house by the Good Templars for the benefit of the Christmas tree,

well in Tucson, March 20, 1882. This indictment was found and presented to the court March 25, 1882. After the finding of the indictment the parties were outlawed for several months and were never taken. Most of the parties are now dead, but the fact of Wyatt Earp's appearance in the recent Fitzsimmons-[Sharkey] fight makes the

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

Wyatt Earp was arrested in San Francisco after a policeman found a large pistol in his pocket as he entered the ring to referee the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. The brief item reports his arrest for carrying a concealed weapon.

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 12 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp is under arrest in San Francisco for carrying concealed weapons. When he entered the ring to act as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, a policeman found a big pistol in his pocket.

Dr. and Mrs. Fenner have gone to Los Angeles for the purpose of consulting an architect with reference to the new house which they will build on the corner of Pennington street and Stone Avenue, which the doctor recently purchased.

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

A newspaper brief reprints the Gazette's opinion that Wyatt Earp's refereeing decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match, which declared the loser the winner, was disgraceful and should be reversed. The piece reflects ongoing public controversy over the fairness of the fight's outcome.

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 12 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The decision of Wyatt Earp in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons case wherein the vanquished was declared the victor is one of the most disgraceful decisions in sporting history and ought, in common decercy, be reversed. The Gazete don't take stock in prize fighting, but if such things must take place, for conscience sake let them be fair.—Gazette.

Governor Franklin this morning received from Washington a copy of General Orders from the War department showing that Second Lieutenant Cornelius O. Smith has been ordered to report to the governor for duty with the National Guard of Arizona and will soon reach Phoenix for that purpose. Lieutenant Smith is an Arizonan being the son of Capt. Smith, for many years stationed in this territory, and a grand son of Gen. Oury. He will inspect and drill the various militia companies in this territory.—Herald.

See moreSee less

Messrs. Joe McPherson and E. R. King of Tombstone, arrived this morning and will leave this evening for the Congress

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A report claims Long Green Lawrence conspired with Gibbs to get Wyatt Earp appointed as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, rejecting a list of reputable alternative referees. The piece also includes commentary from journalist Hugh Keough condemning the corrupt practices that doomed boxing's reputation on the coast.

The San Francisco Call · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

immigration and capital away from it.

It has been ascertained that between 6 and 8 o'clock of the evening of the fight a tip was given out to a few favored individuals to the effect that Sharkey would be awarded the victory, right or wrong, and that Fitzsimmons would be done up, not by Sharkey, but by the decision. Those who were so fortunate as to receive the tip hurried to Harry Corbett's poolrooms and placed their money on Sharkey so that they might hedge out of the bet.

See moreSee less

The tip proved to be correct.

People are now asking why was Sharkey kept an hour in the dressing-room, and why the press reporters and many physicians among the spectators were not allowed to examine him?

It is argued that if Sharkey were fouled the sooner the physicians and others were allowed to inspect the injury the better it would be for Sharkey, as there would then be no doubt whatever as to the foul. If this course had been pursued no one would have enjoined the stake money, and there would have been no dispute in the courts.

Attorney Kowalsky said to-day that he had ten or eleven witnesses to prove the existence of the conspiracy and the fact that Earp had been chosen as a suitable tool to do their bidding. He added that the evidence would be stronger and more direct than any that had yet been offered in court.

Julian said to a Call reporter that the witnesses would show the connection of Long Green Lawrence with conspiracy, and the fact that it was he who had induced Gibbs to secure the appointment of Bodyguard Earp as referee.

It will be shown also by the best of evidence that Dan Lynch told the sporting editor of one of the newspapers before the fight that the Sharkey crowd would object to every referee that might be named by the Fitzsimmons people, and that they would have a referee of their own choosing appointed by the club.

The following named gentlemen were proposed to Lynch as suitable material out of which a referee might be chosen: Hiram Cook, Lem Fulda, Eddie Graney, Robert McArthur, W. W. Naughton, Al Herford and Billy Jordan. Each of these gentlemen is well known and has a good reputation for honesty and integrity.

But that was not the kind of a referee that Lynch and Long Green wanted. They had Earp up their sleeve and were determined to play him for all he was worth.

Concerning the fight and the moral to be deduced from it, Hugh Keough has the following to say in the New Orleans Item:

Boxing has been killed on the coast at the outset of its second boom. It was hoped that when the promoters of the game were granted a measure of license after a long period of enforced idleness they would avoid the mistakes that closed San Francisco to the glove men four years ago. But they haven't. The same grasping greed, the same old meretricious spirit and the same old subversion of honesty to serve selfish ends; the same unscrupulous grafters who ran a sick man to his death against Dal Hawkins merely because there

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A newspaper commentary accuses fight organizers of rigging the Corbett-Sharkey bout for financial gain and mocks Wyatt Earp's qualifications to referee it. It characterizes Earp as a gunfighter with a violent reputation from Arizona and Indian Territory, questioning his claims to honorable conduct.

The San Francisco Call · 12 December 1896 · page 2

2 was a little dirty money in it, have had the management of affairs. They have had two chances to foul their own nests, and they have accepted them. The legitimate profits of the Corbett-Sharkey tness were enormous, but they were not sufficient. The temptation to cheat a party of strangers was too great. They loathed the idea of letting that $10,000 purse get out of the State, and, worse than that, the thought of giving Grannan and other big bet tors from the Ea.it an honest ruu for their money could not be entertained for a moment.

See moreSee less

With them a crooked dollar iv hand is worth five straight dollars in prospect. Well, they now have the crooked dollar, and much good may it do them. "I have a passing acquaintance with Wyatt Earp, the man who refereed the fight, and sDeaks so toplofticatly about his honor in the dispatch which follows this. I never dreemt | of him in connection with refereeing a fist fight upon which a championship possibly depended, altnough he might be qualified to adjudicate upon the fine points arising in a bowie-knife duel. He comes of a family who kill and was until he got civilization, so to speak, by the San Francisco route, a more or less picturesque border character, with a reputation of a killer. He gunned his way into notoriety in Indian Territory and Arizona bjfore he went to San Francisco with a halo ol blue smoke about his head. With all its boasted progress San Francisco worships a gun tighter as devotedly now as it did in '49. If Earp has the reputation for squareness that he boasts about I presume he acquired it in the same way Alkali Ikes and Rattlesnake Jims acquired theirs — by boring holes in persons who had made assertions to the contrary. If one man accuses another of being h horse thief the accuser may fully vindicate htmsell and Etand before the world as an honest man by simply blowing the brains out of his accuser according to the ethics of the society in which Wyatt Earp has mingled. We look at thiugrs differently on this side of the divide. Here we do not necessarily hold a man guilt less of horse-stealing because he has killed his man. Earp is regarded as a 'square man' in San Francisco because he has several notches on his stick and is still quick on the draw. "His knowledge of boxing must be limited. In his heart he must despise a man who de per.ds upon nature's weapons to "defend him self. He has the reputation of being game, but the chances are that if you unstrapped the stock of blue hardware from his hips 'One eyed' Connolly could make him jump out of a window."

See the clipping

The Leavenworth Herald · Leavenworth, Kansas

Martin Julian claims to have complete evidence that a conspiracy was arranged against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. He names Referee Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club as conspirators.

The Leavenworth Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Julian Says He Has Proof. San Francisco, Dec. 9.—Martin Julian stated yesterday that he has evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer; Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report states that Wyatt Earp and others remain under indictment for the 1882 murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson, Arizona. It notes the men were outlawed, fled the territory, and the indictment was never resolved.

New-York Tribune · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

it in the transmission of telegrams. The Supreme Court declares the printed contract at the head of every telegraphic message blank, providing that the company is not liable for unrepeated messages, is invalid.

EARP WANTED FOR MURDER IN ARIZONA.

See moreSee less

Tucson, Ariz., Dec. 11.—Wyatt Earp and others stand indicted for the murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson, on March 20, 1882. They were outlawed several months and could not be taken, and left the Territory. The indictment has never been disposed of.

See the clipping

The Independent · Honolulu, H.I.

A Hawaiian newspaper opinion column mixes local annexation politics with commentary on the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, noting that referee Wyatt Earp's decision favoring Sharkey is binding and dangerous to dispute. It states that bettors in California have settled up, with Sharkey declared the winner and Fitzsimmons the loser.

The Independent · 12 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TOPICS OF THE DAY

The people who backed Fitzsimmons in his fight with Sharkey, for coin, will have to "dig," and the stakeholders must turn over the wealth to the Sharkey men. The decision of the referee is binding. When the referee is a man like W. Earp, it is dangerous to dispute his decision—to his face at least. When a decision, however, is given by a referee or judge, approved by contesting parties, it should be accredited by all interested, and the losers drop their money gracefully. All bets were squared in California in regard to the great fight. The bookmakers and other professionals paid up. The dispute in regard to the purse has nothing to do with the betting. Sharkey won, Fitzsim-

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

A ten-round bout between Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons drew a $40,000 house in San Francisco on December 2. Despite Fitzsimmons having the upper hand, Sharkey won by foul in the eighth round, with Wyatt Earp serving as referee.

The Hawaiian Star · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The great ten-round contest between Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons took place before a $40,000 house in San Francisco on the night of December 2. Though Fitzsimmons had the best of it, Sharkey won the fight on a foul committed in the eighth round, when he was knocked out. Wyatt Earp, the well-known sporting man and gun fighter officiated as ref[eree.]

See the clipping

Evening Bulletin · Honolulu Oahu, Hawaii

In the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout in San Francisco, referee Wyatt Earp ruled that Fitzsimmons' knockout blow was an illegal low blow and awarded the $10,000 purse to Sharkey. Fitzsimmons' backers have since blocked payment of the certified check by court order, with Dr. Lee's testimony on the foul likely to be decisive if the matter goes to court.

Evening Bulletin · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY WAS KNOCKED OUT BUT WON THE FIGHT

tie the case, should the Superior Court decide to hear the matter, a point which was yet to be determined. If otherwise, the referee's decision must stand. Throughout the first seven rounds Sharkey fought with wonderful pluck and endurance. He was plainly handicapped by the greater height and longer reach of his more scientific opponent but had stood the punishment man...

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A humor column of topical one-liners on Cuba, politics, and current events includes a joking aside suggesting Wyatt Earp train to fight boxer Fitzsimmons with Sharkey as referee. The item is a miscellany of satirical quips, not a factual news report about Earp.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 12 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Perhaps the easiest way out of the difficulty is for Wyatt Earp himself to go into training, challenge Fitzsimmons and have Sharkey referee the fight.

See the clipping

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan. · and 1 other paper

The report notes that Wyatt Earp, accused by Bob Fitzsimmons and his supporters of refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, was well known to old-timers in Wichita, Kansas. It recalls his service as an officer under Marshal Mike Meagher in the early 1870s, describing him as a tall, cool-headed man with a reputation as a 'killer.'

Western Kansas World · 12 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

MEMPHIS, Tenn., Dec. 5.—A number of outrages were perpetrated by white-caps on negroes near Reel Foot lake last night. A great deal of stealing has recently been going on in that section and the negroes have been warned to leave the county or suffer the consequences. A number of them were given severe whippings, warned to leave or be lynched. A negro named Beasley was so brutally beaten that it is quite likely he will die. Those of the negroes who could leave did so and others have promised to do so immediately.

No Pooling Bill Favored. CHICAGO, Dec. 5.—The railroads have about given up all idea that the coming session of congress will see a bill passed that will legalize pooling. There was a time when all the roads were hopeful and some of them were sure such a bill would be passed. They have been sounding a number of the senators and they find that a great many of them are not favorably disposed toward the measure, at the present time at least.

See moreSee less

Earp is from Kansas. WICHITA, Kan., Dec. 5.—Wyatt Earp, who is accused by Bob Fitzsimmons and his friends with having refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, is well known to the old timers in Wichita, having served as an officer under Marshal Mike Maegher, in the early '70's. He was a tall, ministerial looking fellow, with a cool head and a deadly aim, and he had the reputation of being a "killer."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Nebraska Advertiser · Nemaha City, Neb. · 11 December 1896

St. Landry Clarion · Opelousas, La.

A short item remarks that Fitzsimmons has met his match, with Earp overseeing his defeat with hands down. This refers to the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prizefight where Wyatt Earp served as referee.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Landry Clarion · 12 December 1896 · page 2

Fitzsimmons has met his match. Earp whipped him with hands down. SUCCESSION SALE. ESTATE OF ARSENE VIDRINE. No. 8418, 11th Judicial District Court, Parish of St. Landry, Louisiana.

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A promotional notice previews the next day's Sunday edition of The Globe, listing feature articles including a sketch of Wyatt Earp's life on the border. It notes that Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, 'seems to have a record of which no man could be proud.'

The Saint Paul Globe · 12 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP'S LIFE ON THE BORDER. The referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight seems to have a record of which no man could

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

This is a promotional ad for the next day's Sunday edition of the Globe, listing upcoming feature articles. One teaser references a forthcoming piece on Wyatt Earp's life on the border, noting his controversial record as referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight.

The Saint Paul Globe · 12 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP'S LIFE ON THE BORDER. The referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight seems to have a record of which no man could be proud.

See the clipping

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

A newspaper editorial defends Wyatt Earp's refereeing decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, arguing that his reputation for fairness means the controversial call must have been correct. It recounts his background as a gunfighter and saloon keeper known for honesty in sporting matters.

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 12 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight. We know nothing about the fight, but we know Wyatt Earp, and therefore believe implicitly that his decision in that contest was correct. Earp has been known as a bad man, handy with his gun, and as a participant in several bloody encounters. The two latter statements are true, and yet those who know his career would hesitate long before admitting he was wrong. He fought to the death, but we have always believed he fought in a just cause. At Coeur d'Alene, Earp ran a saloon, and was one of the most quiet and peaceably-disposed men in the camp.

See moreSee less

He is a thorough sport, and thinks as much of his word and his reputation as any business man. He would no more give an unfair decision in a sporting matter than our supreme court would in a matter before it.

See the clipping

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

The item notes that Wyatt Earp has suddenly come into public prominence again, but the passage is truncated before explaining the specific reason or decision referenced. No further details are given in the surviving text.

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 12 December 1896 · page 2

E A RFS DECISION. "Wyatt Earp has come suddenly ino prominence on account of his THE DALLES WEEKLY CHRONICLE SATURDAY,' DECEMBER 12, 1896. rounds, and Fitz took advantage of the opposite side of the skull. The brain make an excellent secretary of state, substance was found very much torn the dead thing he had on the play to and we feel certain that no abler and a hollow with a blood e'ot existed in scoop his friends. There was noth documents, stated in more clear or the left side, this being probably due to ing foul about that from Fitz's point forceful English, ever emanated the passage of the pick when Mr.

See moreSee less

Jonea from that department than those Mr, of new. It was only when he got drew it forth. During the time that robbed that his morals showed them Mrs. Jones lay unconscious at the hos Scott would prepare. We do not, pital, Dr. Barber expressed the opinion selves. by any means, agree with many of that she might have recovered, had the his ideas, but cheerfully bear witness Some good legal member .'of the instrument been clean and free from to the fact that his editorials are al rust, but, after he saw the way in which legislature can find congenial work most alwavs models. He .leaves the brain had been torn, be admitted and do a good thing for the frater that she never had a chance of recover nothing to be said on his side of any nity, as well as everybody else, by ing. The case in its many aspects is proposition. compiling an entirely new probate considered as a very remarkable one, system. The miocene formation of and will be fully discussed in reports by THE FOREST RESERVE. physicians. Oregonian. - the present probate aggregation needs The opening of the Cascade forest to be set aside and something modern ; Plan of Kansas Populists.

See the clipping

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

Amid Fitzsimmons' protests that referee Earp fixed the fight for Sharkey, reports emerge that Fitzsimmons' own associates were betting against him lasting six rounds. This undercuts Fitzsimmons' claims of victimization in the controversial decision.

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 12 December 1896 · page 2

While Fitzsimraons is lifting his voice in pious protest against the alleged jobbing done, by Earp in giving the victory to Sharkey, it transpires that the honest and gen tlemanly Fitz had a few of his friends betting his money for him that Sharkey would stay six rounds. Of course Fitz's keenest admirers were betting Sharkey would not stay six THE DALLES WEEKLY CHRONICLE SATURDAY,' DECEMBER 12, 1896. rounds, and Fitz took advantage of the opposite side of the skull. The brain make an excellent secretary of state, substance was found very much torn the dead thing he had on the play to and we feel certain that no abler and a hollow with a blood e'ot existed in scoop his friends.

See moreSee less

There was noth documents, stated in more clear or the left side, this being probably due to ing foul about that from Fitz's point forceful English, ever emanated the passage of the pick when Mr. Jonea from that department than those Mr, of new. It was only when he got drew it forth. During the time that robbed that his morals showed them Mrs. Jones lay unconscious at the hos Scott would prepare. We do not, pital, Dr. Barber expressed the opinion selves. by any means, agree with many of that she might have recovered, had the his ideas, but cheerfully bear witness Some good legal member .'of the instrument been clean and free from to the fact that his editorials are al rust, but, after he saw the way in which legislature can find congenial work most alwavs models. He .leaves the brain had been torn, be admitted and do a good thing for the frater that she never had a chance of recover nothing to be said on his side of any nity, as well as everybody else, by ing. The case in its many aspects is proposition. compiling an entirely new probate considered as a very remarkable one, system. The miocene formation of and will be fully discussed in reports by THE FOREST RESERVE. physicians. Oregonian. - the present probate aggregation needs The opening of the Cascade forest to be set aside and something modern ; Plan of Kansas Populists.

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

A trainer named George Allen reportedly confessed that Sharkey's win over Fitzsimmons was secured through a staged foul conspiracy involving Wyatt Earp, Dan Lynch, Sharkey, and Dan Needham. Separately, Earp pleaded not guilty to carrying concealed weapons and testified in Fitzsimmons' suit over a $10,000 check.

The Madison Daily Leader · 12 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey's Trainer Says There Was Fraud in the San Francisco Fight.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—A morning paper publishes the following: George Allen, one of the men who trained Tom Sharkey for his fight with Fitzsimmons, has made a confession to the effect that Fitzsimmons was deprived of his victory through a conspiracy. The trainer and the Sharkey management have quarreled over money matters, it is said, and in the heat of the moment, Allen made threats of what he would do if he were not paid for his services. Attorney Kowalsky, representing Fitzsimmons, heard of the circumstances, and he employed private detectives to gather in the irate trainer. He was run to ground and induced to tell the whole story.

See moreSee less

It is claimed that Allen, in an affidavit, named Wyatt Earp, Dan J. Lynch, Tom Sharkey and Dan Needham as the prime movers in the plot. The whole scheme is said to have been hatched at Sharkey's training quarters at Ocean Beach. It was arranged that Sharkey was to make it appear that he had been fouled at some point in the contest when he was in danger of losing from Fitzsimmons' blows; further, that the signal was to be given by Sharkey, who was to bend over and place his hand on his groin, and that at that moment, Needham was to jump into the ring and claim a foul. Then the referee was to give a decision in favor of Sharkey.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The piece reports accusations that Sharkey's camp and trainers made sworn statements implicating referee Wyatt Earp in dishonest conduct during a prize fight. The writer suggests either Sharkey's side is lying or Earp failed his sworn duty as referee to ensure fair play, calling the whole affair disgraceful.

San Antonio Daily Light · 12 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey's gang is either the greatest combination of liars on the modern stage or Sharkey has taken a hand in one of the meanest tricks ever entered into by anyone. Earp is no better nor half so honorable, if reports and sworn statements of Sharkey's trainers are true, for he as referee, was sworn by every principle of honor to see perfectly fair play and prevent fraud. In any case the revelations are disgraceful and will only serve to discredit all prize ring performances so that in time there will be a perpetual end to them all. Decent men will not regret the finis.

The gabfest between Corbett and Fitzsimmons opens indefinitely.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A brief notice recounts that Wyatt Earp and others remain under indictment for the 1882 murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson. It notes they were outlawed for months, could not be captured, left the territory, and the indictment was never resolved.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Earp Under Indictment. Tucson, Ariz., Dec. 11.--Wyatt Earp with others stands indicted for the murder of Frank Stilwell in Tucson March 20, 1882. They were outlawed

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A Salt Lake Herald piece uses Wyatt Earp's recent role as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight as a hook to revisit his storied past. It quotes Judge Osborn, a former Dodge City prosecutor who knew Earp, reminiscing about the lawless cattle-town days and critiquing a New York Journal article by Alfred Henry Lewis as inaccurate.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

OSBORN'S REMINISCENCES

would stir the blood of any man.

It is not generally known that when Dodge City wore the belt for wickedness, our own Judge Colborn was the public prosecutor, and it was while serving in that capacity that he became acquainted with Wyatt Earp. The judge knows the famous gun fighter as well perhaps, as any man living, although he is loath to talk about that chapter of his career except to his cronies, because the judge is essentially a modest man, and every act of his in those terrible days redounded to his credit. But the judge was in a reminiscent mood yesterday because he had just read in the New York Journal an article on Earp from the pen of Alfred Henry Lewis, in which the writer showed marked ability as an economizer of the truth.

See moreSee less

✦ ✦ ✦

"In 1876," said the judge, "when I was prosecuting attorney at Dodge City, the history of the place was being written in blood. In those days, there was a constant procession of cattle over the Chisholm trail, and the cowboys, who were, in fact, only Texas desperadoes, were running the town. They were 'bad men' of the worst class this country has ever produced. The main object of the Texans

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A judge reminiscing after reading Alfred Henry Lewis's New York Journal article disputes its accuracy, recounting his own memories of Wyatt Earp as a lawman in Dodge City and later guarding Wells Fargo stages in Tombstone with his brothers. He describes the buildup to the gunfight with the Clantons and McLaurys as a confrontation the Earp brothers bravely faced.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

as Bat Mastersen and Wyatt Earp. An order was made that citizens, including the 'cowboys,' as the desperadoes were then called, should not carry arms in the town, and it devolved upon these officers to carry out that order. Of course they were paid immense salaries, but they earned more than they ever received and succeeded in their herculean task of establishing respect for the law. While there, I saw Wyatt Earp do things that you wouldn't undertake for a million dollars, and yet he did it every day just

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A newspaper interview-style retrospective recounts the Earp brothers' guarding of stagecoaches, the gunfight with the Clantons and McLaurys, and the subsequent vendetta ride after an ambush killed one of the brothers. It also describes Wyatt's killing of Stilwell at Tucson and the pursuit of Curly Bill.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

came crazy for revenge, and Virgil Earp was their victim. One night not long afterwards, he was playing billiards, when someone shot through the door, killing him instantly. Wyatt was present. He didn't say much, but everyone knew that the climax had been reached. The Santa Fe gave orders to its conductors to take the Earps on board whenever they desired, and the boys started for their home in California with Virgil's body. On the train, Wyatt was told that Frank Stillwell was waiting at Tucson to kill him. When the train reached that place, Wyatt got off and there was Stillwell, waiting, rifle in hand. When the train pulled out, Wyatt was on board, and

See the clipping

Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash.

The National Athletic Club issued a public statement defending its conduct after Fitzsimmons claimed referee Wyatt Earp had unfairly robbed him of victory over Sharkey. The club says it ordered medical examinations of Sharkey, stopped payment on the $10,000 purse check pending investigation, and is awaiting the outcome of a judicial inquiry.

Pullman Herald · 12 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

National Club Statement. The directors of the National Athletic Club sent the following statement today to the Associated Press today, explaining the club's position relative to the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest: "To protect the good name of the club and as a matter of justice to the public, we left nothing undone to determine the correctness of the claim made by Fitzsimmons that Referee Earp had robbed him of the decision over Sharkey. A committee of six physicians, two of whom were designated by the morning papers, examined Sharkey and concurred in saying that he had been injured.

See moreSee less

Apart from the medical examination ordered by the club, the precaution was taken to stop payment of the check for $10,000, so that if fraud had been perpetrated by anybody upon the club and the public an investigation would reveal the same and the guilty party brought to justice. The matter is now in the hands of the courts and the club is awaiting anxiously the result of the judicial inquiry. "L. L. GROOM

See the clipping

Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A newspaper snippet derides Wyatt Earp as the 'bunco-referee' of the recent 'great fight,' sarcastically calling him a famous Arizona stage-driver who may have colluded with road agents in his past gunfights. The item is part of a roundup of satirical press clippings from various papers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Birmingham State Herald · 13 December 1896 · page 15 · transcribed from the page image

CURRENT COMMENT.

The bunco-referee of the "great fight" was Wyatt Earp, "the famous Arizona stage-driver, who has figured in many a gun-fight on the border"—probably in humorous and profitable collusion with the road agents. "Quite a character" is Mr. Earp.—Buffalo Commercial.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A court case is underway to determine whether the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight violated California's Penal Code against brutal prize-fighting, with Judge Sanderson questioning jurisdiction. Manager Julian suggests a conspiracy in selecting Wyatt Earp, a known gunfighter, as referee instead of a neutral party, and more evidence is expected to reveal why Sharkey was kept isolated after the fight.

The San Francisco Call · 13 December 1896 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

BE UNRAVELED.

anyhow. Manager Julian and Bob Fitzsimmons were in good spirits yesterday. They are confident that they can show up all the ramifications of the conspiracy. Julian is asking every one he meets why did not Lynch and Sharkey accept Hiram Cook when they found that he was a square man, and why did they select Long Green Lawrence's bosom companion, a man known to be a gun fighter and believed to be able to take care of himself in case of a row over an unpopular or rank decision, as Earp's decision was? But up to the present time he has not received a satis

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The article reports that court proceedings will reveal why Sharkey was kept isolated after the fight and why doctors were barred from examining him. It alleges that conspirators who arranged for Wyatt Earp to referee tipped off associates that Sharkey would win, prompting bets to be hedged before the fight.

The San Francisco Call · 13 December 1896 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

pugilist. It is natural to suppose that if Sharkey had received a foul blow both he and Lynch would have been only too willing to have let the whole world examine the injured fighter in order that there might not be the slightest doubt or suspicion in the matter. Explanation will be offered on behalf of Fitzsimmons as to the motives which prompted Lynch to order Trainers Smith and Allen out of Sharkey's room when Dr. Lee was about to attend the pugilist and also as to the reason why Sharkey yelled with pain a few moments later. It will be shown also on the testimony

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The Globe reprints Alfred H. Lewis's New York Journal piece on Wyatt Earp, prompted by controversy over Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons fight, describing him and his brothers as gun-toting troublemakers who terrorized Tombstone before fleeing to Gunnison. Lewis claims two of the Earp brothers, Julian and Warren, are already dead.</br>

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Saint Paul Globe · 13 December 1896 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Years—Helped to Make the Wild and Woolly West.

Wyatt Earp is attracting widespread attention at present as the man that had the nerve to deprive Fitzsimmons of a well-earned victory. Alfred H. Lewis, writing in the New York Journal, has this to say of him: "In the early eighties I was a neighbor of the Earp family. They abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence.

See moreSee less

"Wyatt Earp is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented a front to that household made up in the main of Winchesters and Colt six shooters. The Earps construed this into a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented it by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever. They migrated to the Gunnison country. They

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

This piece recounts the Earps' departure from Tombstone and Gunnison, claiming four Earp brothers (Virgil, Wyatt, Warren, and a fictitious 'Julian') plus a sister Jessie who married Ike Clanton. It asserts Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian killed in Gunnison by Clanton, whom Wyatt and Virgil then killed in Socorro.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Saint Paul Globe · 13 December 1896 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

bicycle for seventeen years, and during that time has taken part in hundreds of races at all distances. He has won all the long distance events in England and has, it is said, won as many as any other bicycle rider living. Hale has ridden in many of the big races in France and has often been a winner. He won a road race from Paris to Bayon. Before the present race, the longest distance Hale had ridden was 875 miles, in a road race in England.

Hale rode an English wheel, geared to 98, higher than that of any of the other riders. Representatives of the Irish National Alliance and other Irish societies have extended an invitation to Hale for a banquet, and presentation early next week.

See moreSee less

The prizes to the winners will be: First man, $1,300; second, $800; third, $500; fourth, $450; fifth, $300; sixth, $200; seventh, $150; eighth, $125; ninth, $100; tenth, $100; eleventh, $75. Manager Pat Powers, however, said that every man who remained in the race to the finish, would get $100 extra.

In the twenty-five-mile race which began at 10:30, there were 9 starters—

16,000 points in a game of 24,000.

Base Ball Magnate Dead.

CLEVELAND, O., Dec. 12.—J. Howard Rob[ison], secretary and treasurer of the C[leve]land Base Ball Club company, and a bro[ther] of President F. De Haas Robison, [died] at 1:30 this morning at his home, 436 S[upe]rior street, aged forty-four years. The in[ime]diate cause of his death was inflammatio[n of] the brain. He had been sick about t[wo] weeks. The deceased had been secretar[y of] the club since 1882, and also had taken [care] of the finances of the organization since [that] time. He leaves a wife, but no children.

Becker Wins Prizes.

W. E. Becker, the Minneapolis cyclis[t, is] making a great name for himself ou[t in] California. He has taken three second p[rizes] and two first prizes at San Francisco du[ring] the past week. He is also the champio[n of] California, and receives $10 per week as [long] as he holds that record. Becker says tha[t he] is going to hold it; that there is nothin[g to] interfere except crooked pacemaking, an[d he] says he has a way to provide against th[at].

Loftus Gets Tebeau.

COLUMBUS, O., Dec. 12.—Manager Lo[ftus] of the Columbus team, has signed George [Te]beau, brother of Patsy Tebeau, of the C[leve]land club, to play first base.

SIDLE BLOCK FIRE SALE.

has taken a record of 100 yards in eleven seconds.

were subsequently run out of Gunnison, and Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to California, where Wyatt the other night refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.

The four Earps were named respectively Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as the novelists say, more anon. Virgil was the oldest Earp, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the most foolhardy, Julian the bravest and Jessie the most loving. As a result Wyatt and Virgil lived to get out of Tombstone and the Gunnison in advance of public opinion and the bullets that expressed it; while Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison by Ike Clauton, who had married his sister Jessie, and whom Wyatt and Virgil subsequently killed at Socorro—and Jessie, the loving one, wedded Ike Clauton, with whom her four brothers had a blood feud at the time.

Wyatt Earp, and, for that matter, all the Earps, were gun fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited with ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in '81 and '82, and, eschewing the intervention of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as "fanning" their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.

In the early '80s there were two factions in Tombstone. Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one—the Stage Robbers, Johnny Behan, Ike Clauton and Jack Ringo led the other—the Rustlers. The Stage Robbers were in politics, Republican, and stood up stages and plundered express companies for a livelihood. The Rustlers were Democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle-stealing, murder whisky and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was sheriff of Cochise county and Virgil Earp was the marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the Cow-thief Democracy party, while Earp

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

This sensationalized 1896 account claims the Earp brothers secretly orchestrated stagecoach robberies with Wells-Fargo agent complicity, then profited again by forming posses to "hunt" the robbers they themselves staged. It frames Tombstone's conflict as a rivalry between the Earp-led "Stage Robbers" faction and Behan's "Rustlers" faction.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Saint Paul Globe · 13 December 1896 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

NOT AN HONEST HAIR IN HIS HEAD

Wyatt Earp, and, for that matter, all the Earps, were gun fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited w[i]th ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qual[if]ied to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. Th[e]y had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in '81 and '82, and, eschewing the interv[e]ntion of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as "fanning" their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.

See moreSee less

In the early '80s there were two factions in Tombstone. Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one—the Stage Robbers, Johnny Behan, Ike Clauton and Jack Ringo led the other—the Rustlers. The Stage Robbers were in politics, Republican, and stood up stages and plu[n]dered express companies for a livelihood. [The] Rustlers were Democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle-stealing, murder whisky and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was sheriff of Cochise county and Virgil Earp was the marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the Cowthief Democracy party, while Earp

See the clipping

Weekly Independent · Elko, Nev.

The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight purse dispute came before Superior Court, with a continuance granted due to a service of papers defect. Fitzsimmons' side alleged a conspiracy in which Sharkey would fake a foul blow and referee Wyatt Earp would award him the match on a foul that was never actually delivered.

Weekly Independent · 13 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

A new and complete Fall and Winter line of gents' and children's clothing, furnishing goods, hats and caps, boots and shoes at marvelously low prices. Have also added dry goods to the above stock. The latest style of ladies' Winter goods at C. Alexander's.

One of Elko's young ladies when skating last night, fell and bumped the back of her head against the ice very hard. She now declares that she saw about fifty "airships" when she fell.

See moreSee less

The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest, for the purse of $10,000, was brought up in the Superior Court yesterday morning. A continuance was granted until the afternoon as Sharkey's people claimed a defect in their service of papers. Fitzsimmons' people claim that they will prove a conspiracy was formed against Fitz, and show the details of a plan by which Sharkey was to pretend to receive a foul blow and referee Earp was to give Sharkey a decision on a foul, which was not delivered.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report alleges that Wyatt Earp was appointed referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight at the direct instigation of Examiner managing editor Andy 'Long Green' Lawrence, implying a fix. It claims a witness who first admitted this was later pressured by the newspaper to recant.

The San Francisco Call · 14 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The career of Long Green Lawrence of the Examiner is now freely discussed, apropos of the disreputable part he played in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight. Facts are coming to light day by day that show beyond all question that Fitzsimmons was jobbed in the fight and that the managing editor of the Examiner was deeply implicated in the plot.

Wyatt Earp was appointed referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight at the direct instance of Andy M. Lawrence, bet

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The Call alleges that Examiner editor Gibbs was pressured by the paper to support Wyatt Earp as referee for the fight, reversing his earlier admission. It also accuses the Examiner of hypocrisy, noting its past condemnation of hired gunman Dave Neagle contrasts with its backing of Earp's selection.

The San Francisco Call · 14 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

noon. He went away convinced that Wyatt Earp ought to be the referee of the fight; that he must be the referee. He was the referee. To the better understanding of the peculiar selection of Mr. Earp, The Call is able to give a little inside history, antedating the fight, but

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report alleges Wyatt Earp was secretly employed by publisher 'Long Green' Lawrence as a bodyguard, disguised on payroll as a library attaché credited with authoring serial stories. It claims evidence is emerging that Lawrence profited from rigging the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight by having his own employee Earp named referee, with further evidence to be presented before Judge Sanderson.

The San Francisco Call · 14 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

cate compartments, convenient and deceptive screens, unexpected traps and hidden photographic cameras. Guards are stationed at the inner and outer doors of the main office, reached only by three tiresome flights of stairs—a climb likely to cool and discourage the most enraged man. Just off the room of the outer guard, where Charlie Rochette, the prize fighter, did service for many years, is a waiting-room, comfortably furnished, with entrances and exits directly into the lobby and the editorial rooms.

It was into this side room, commanding both the inner sanctum and the outer entrance, that Wyatt Earp, the greatest living representative of border ruffianism, was installed as bodyguard-in-chief at this time. He was hired by Long Green Lawrence as his special guard. He was placed on the payroll of the Examiner at that time, and it is believed that he remained on Mr. Hearst's payroll up to the time of the now famous fight.

See moreSee less

So while the Examiner was denouncing the hiring of Neagle it was all the while employing Earp in the same capacity. It was certainly a case of unparalleled hypocrisy. Earp was employed in this way: The races were off; characters of his kind were either "broke" or out of town and "grass was uncommonly short." While lounging in front of the Peerless saloon he was approached by one of Lawrence's henchmen and asked if he would not like to earn a little money easily.

Earp intimated that he would be glad of a chance to make money by almost any means short of holding up a train or a stage. The reporter told him that Mr. Lawrence desired to see him, and the two proceeded together to the Mission-street structure. A deal was made at $50 a week, it is hinted, and Earp was installed in the sanctum as chief swashbuckler, with headquarters in the ante-room, though he was also permitted to enjoy the privileges of the inner temple upon occasions. Meantime Earp also shadowed Lawrence about town and from and to his home.

It will be noted that a confidential relation existed between Lawrence and Earp long previous to the fight, and that when he suggested Earp's name as referee of the fight he was giving a place to his own employe and a man whom he well knew and largely owned.

It might be stated, too, that Earp did not appear on the payroll of the Examiner as a bodyguard, but as a library attache. He was paraded and widely advertised as the author of a serial Sunday story, descriptive of his valorous deeds and general outlawry. These stories were written by young Chambers, a special writer, whom Mr. Hearst imported from New York. It was under the guise of pay for these stories that Earp figured on the payroll. Whether this was done to hoodwink bluff Tom Williams, the Examiner's business manager, or to deceive young Hearst has not been explained. It is a mystery that Mr. Hearst will probably solve for himself.

A singular feature of the case is that evidence is daily accumulating that Long Green Lawrence was concerned in and directly benefited by the steal that robbed Bob Fitzsimmons of a well-earned victory and $10,000.

Those who have watched the gradual expose of the crookedness of Long Green and his henchman and bodyguard, Wyatt Earp, have wondered how long it would be before something direct and substantial would show the unmistakable smudge of Long Green's eager fingers.

The evidence is at hand and, moreover, will be made public in the hearing of the case as it progresses before Judge Sanderson.

Of course, no one doubted that little Willie's pet editor was a pot of money in pocket over the steal perpetrated by the border ruffian whom he caused to have appointed referee of the fight.

It is now known positively that a member of the Examiner reportorial staff—a man whom Long Green has kept on the paper when other powers of the Examiner wanted him discharged—bet a large sum of money on Sharkey in the poolrooms during the three hours preceding the fight.

This man has for years been to Long Green what Friday was to Robinson Crusoe—always at his side ready to do his bidding in anything. It was he who acted as the go-between when Lawrence engaged bad man Earp as his bodyguard and brought him to the Examiner sanctum for the first interview. This man is known to be in a continual state of financial collapse. He has nothing outside of the salary he earns running errands for Long Green, and yet he bet hundreds on Sharkey at a time when the poolrooms were crowded and he would be least likely to be noticed, and about the time that a tip that the fight was fixed saved a number of sporting men from serious loss.

The money was certainly not his own, and if this was the case who else would give him a big commission to execute but Long Green?

The poolrooms were jammed with an eager crowd of spectators when Long Green's factotum appeared. He edged up to the box where Fitzsimmons money was plentiful and out of a pocket that jingled musically produced a shining $20 and placed it on Sharkey to win.

Those who knew him wondered where he got so much money and their surprise was increased when $10 more went into the box on the sailor man. Then he edged away for a moment, but was soon back and bet $40 on the sailor.

The crowd was continually shifting as its bets were made, but Lawrence's agent kept close to the box and inside of an hour bet several hundred dollars on Sharkey. There were other men known to be in the confidence of Long Green close to the box and likewise betting amounts ranging from $10 to $50.

Now that the connection of Earp and Long Green has been conclusively shown those who saw the bets made will never be convinced that the Examiner's ex-peanut butcher was not the one who furnished the coin that the reporter bet on Sharkey. It is also known that he made a number of wagers about town, in saloons and elsewhere on the fight during the half day that preceded it.

The Long Green crowd knew that to send in a big commission as honest sports did would be to invite suspicion in case the steal was raw, and they chose this method of "chipping" their money in and cashing a big bunch of tickets when the box was opened for those who profited by the robbery.

By the way, it was not the lamented Eddie Farrell who gave Lawrence his cognomen, but Frank P. Bull, who declared that Andy tried to "pull his leg" for $10,000 in the legislative session. That is an interesting affidavit, even if Bull didn't yield the "long green."

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The article contrasts two conflicting accounts of Wyatt Earp published in Hearst's papers: one glorifying him as a heroic defender against stage robbers, the other, by Alfred Lewis, casting him and his brothers as leaders of a stage-robbing faction in Tombstone. It highlights the contradictory legends already forming around Earp's reputation.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The San Francisco Call · 14 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Two Accounts of His Career in the Examiner and Journal.

Wyatt Earp, the gun-fighting bodyguard of Long Green Lawrence, managing editor of the Examiner, has as many colors as Jacob's coat, if the accounts of him that have been published in Mr. Hearst's two papers are to be believed.

See moreSee less

About the time that he was engaged as gun-fighter-in-chief of the San Francisco Monarch of the Fakers a series of articles appeared in that sheet exploiting his career.

He was held up as the hero of many stage robberies who had defended passengers and mails at the risk of his life. No praise was too great for his courage and honesty.

Here is what Alfred H. Lewis, who knew the "bad man" in Arizona, has to say in the New York Journal, Mr. Hearst's other paper, which is not dominated by Long Green, of Earp, in connection with stage robberies:

In the early eighties there were two factions in Tombstone. Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one—the Stage Robbers. Johnny Behan, Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo led the other—the Rustlers. The Stage Robbers were in politics Republican, and stood up stages and plundered express companies for a livelihood. The Rustlers were Democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle-stealing, murder, whisky and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was Sheriff of Cochise County and Virgil Earp was the Marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the Cow-thief Democracy party, while Earp robbed stages and voted with the Republicans.

The Earps, Wyatt, Virgil, Warren and Julian, had treated themselves to many a killing. But there was no money in murder; nothing but relaxation. So they devoted themselves to holding up the stage. Virgil Earp had a combination with Barshel Williams, then the Wells-Fargo agent at Tombstone. When big money went out on the stage Williams tipped it off to Virgil Earp. The hold-ups were then planted in a convenient canyon. When the stage came along, at the words "Hands up!" Warren Earp, who was a stage-company guard, meekly put his hands over his head. Then the hold-ups went through the express pouches and boxes like the grace of heaven through a camp-meeting.

There was never any shooting; it was from all standpoints a family affair on the part of the Earps. Often they got as high as $25,000. After a robbery the Earps made further money, enlisting themselves with a posse comitatus and chasing themselves. Virgil, as marshal, would enlist Wyatt, Warren and Julian, together with Curly Bill, their cousin, and hunt the hold-ups. It was a great industry, and by thus playing both ends against the middle, first robbing the stage and then proceeding to chase the robbers, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian Earp waxed opulent.

An auditor in a Japanese theater is allowed, for a small fee, to stand up, and the unfortunate individual behind him has no right to remonstrate or to rise and get a peep at the stage. He may hear, but he cannot see.

The Cough which seems to come from the very depths of your system, can be at once relieved and eventually cured with Dr. D. Jayne's Expectorant For the Liver use Jayne's Painless Sanative Pills.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A miscellaneous editorial column mocks William Randolph Hearst's journalism, sarcastically noting he sent to Arizona for Wyatt Earp's record when he could have gotten it free from a local figure called Long Green Lawrence. The item is one aside among many unrelated political and news commentary snippets of the day.

The San Francisco Call · 14 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

There is one thing in Willie Heart's journalism that requires explanation. Why should he have sent to Arizona to get Wyatt Earp's record when he could have got it from Long Green Lawrence for nothing.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A Spokane Review story, based on an interview with one Bussard, claims Wyatt Earp led a gang of toughs who swindled land buyers in early Dodge City, naming local Montana resident Jack Enright as a member. The Anaconda Standard casts doubt on the tale, noting Enright is a respected, law-abiding citizen and the story stems from Earp's recent fame after the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight.

The Anaconda Standard · 14 December 1896 · page 11

HIS DEALINGS IN LAND

TheWhole Story Finds Its Origin^In the Bulk of Notoriety That^Hoferee fcarp Has Re^^cently Acquired. IiffatFulls, Per. 13.^Thf notoriety^recently alialii.-.l by Wyait Karp. r^f-^MM in thf Sharkey-Fitissimnioiis mill,^lias resulted IS llial gentleman'! pa M

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A roundup of editorial quips from various papers includes the Chicago Dispatch musing that a boxing match between Bat Masterson and Wyatt Earp would draw a large, if not entirely fair, crowd. The item is one of several unrelated editorial snippets reprinted together.

The Salt Lake Herald · 14 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SOME EDITORIAL COMMENTS.

Chicago Dispatch: A mill between Colonel "Bat" Masterson and Colonel Wyatt Earp would attract a big and perhaps a fair-minded crowd.

See moreSee less

Denver Times: The anti-department store war that has been progressing for some time in the east promises to nave

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 5 other papers

Testimony continues in the dispute over the $10,000 purse from the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, with Julian alleging a conspiracy involving referee Wyatt Earp. Witnesses including Fitzsimmons and Dr. Lustig testified about foul blows and being denied access to Sharkey after the fight.

Waterbury Democrat · 15 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY-FITZSIMMONS.

Other Witnesses Confirm the Story of a Conspiracy.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 15.—Tom Sharkey, looking little the worse for his drubbing, was in court when the controversy for the possession of the $10,000 purse was renewed.

Fitzsimmons and Julian attempted to expose the alleged conspiracy against Fitzsimmons, but when Julian was asked for positive proof he produced nothing but hearsay testimony. Julian related his efforts to have Lynch join him in selecting a referee, stating that Lynch purposely placed the choice of a referee in the hands of the National club, which named Earp. Julian said Commissioner Gunst and Riley Grannan had come to him before the fight to tell him Earp had been "fixed."

He quoted Riley Grannan as having overheard a conversation between Earp and Joe Harvey, a bookkeeper, in the course of which Harvey said, "Then it's all right, is it?" to which Earp had replied, "You can depend on me."

Julian's testimony sought to involve the National club, Sharkey, Lynch and Earp in the alleged conspiracy. Fitzsimmons denied he had struck any foul blow and repeated Julian's story about the warning not to accept Earp as referee.

Dr. D. D. Lustig's testimony was not so much relished by Sharkey. He said he was the medical examiner for the National club and had examined Sharkey before the fight. After Sharkey had been taken to his room Lustig, with four other doctors, hearing Sharkey had been hurt, offered their services, but they were refused admittance to Sharkey's dressing room. On the following afternoon Dr. Lustig and five other physicians examined Sharkey's injuries in the groin, and witness pronounced the injury superficial. He said it was insignificant, not disabling or productive of much pain. The injuries to the groin might have been caused by artificial means, such as the injection of acidulated water.

Dan Hickey, one of Fitzsimmons' seconds; W. W. Naughton, a sporting reporter, and others present at the fight all testified that they had seen no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · 15 December 1896
  • The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 15 December 1896
  • The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · 15 December 1896
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 15 December 1896
  • Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · 18 December 1896

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Testimony before Judge Sanderson addressed whether Sharkey was genuinely injured by a low blow from Fitzsimmons, with a doctor suggesting the swelling could have been caused by a hypodermic needle rather than a punch. Witnesses, including Sharkey's manager Lynch, gave conflicting and evasive testimony about their connections to referee Wyatt Earp and the circumstances of the fight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Long Green Lawrence Has Been Intimidating Witnesses Who Know of His Crookedness.

The evidence produced before Judge Sanderson yesterday in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey matter proved conclusively to all who heard it that Fitzsimmons was the victim of a conspiracy headed by Long Green Lawrence's man Wyatt Earp, special writer for the Examiner.

See moreSee less

The testimony of Dr. Lustig created a sensation in court. He said that after a careful examination he found that Sharkey had not been injured in the manner alleged, and that the swelling was not where Sharkey was alleged to have been injured, and that it could have been caused by the use of a hypodermic syringe. He was not allowed to tell why he and other reputable physicians had declined to enter into consultation with Dr. Lee, Mr. Barnes having vigorously objected to any evidence on that point.

Manager Lynch, Sharkey's trainer, was badly rattled on the stand, and told a cock and bull story of his connection with the affair to the effect that he was not very well acquainted with Wyatt Earp; that why he did not select Hiram Cook as ref[erence]

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Witnesses testify in the lawsuit over the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, including referee Earp's associate Lynch giving an unconvincing account of events, and sportswriter Naughton describing the location of the alleged foul blow. Julian testified about difficulty getting bets placed until Earp had been 'fixed,' while attorney W.H.L. Barnes is noted as conducting the defense with apparent integrity.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

JULIAN'S TALE OF THE FRAUD.

O'Riley experienced in getting a bet from the Sharkey men until Earp had been "fixed."

The most remarkable thing in connection with this whole matter is that such people as Earp, his protege "Long Green" Lawrence, Sharkey, Lynch, Gibbs and Needham have succeeded in getting such a man as W. H. L. Barnes to represent them.

See moreSee less

The General, as a matter of fact, is the only respectable element on that side of the case, and he has shown up to the present time that he desires all the truth to come out in the testimony.

It is evident that the veteran attorney does not intend interposing technicalities which in themselves would go to show the weakness of his clients' case. He believes in the truth of the statements made to him, and he shows a disposition to fight his way in this affair on its merits. Whether he wins or loses, he will make a creditable showing by not placing barriers in the way of a complete showing up of the way the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey mill disgraced sport in this city.

On the opening of court Dr. D. D. Lustig, one of the Examining Board of the Insanity Commissioners and medical examiner for the National Athletic Club, swore that as an attache of the club he had examined Fitzsimmons and Sharkey before the contest with reference to the condition of their hearts and lungs, in order that there might not be an fatal accident, such as sometimes occurs when one of the contestants is affected with heart disease.

The doctor was asked particularly with reference to being barred out of the dressing-room to which Sharkey had been taken immediately after the fight. He knocked repeatedly at the door, and had others knock for him, and announced that he desired admission as physician for the club, but admittance was denied him. Drs. Rottanzi, O'Brien and Ragan were present and also demanded admission, but they were not allowed to enter. On the next afternoon at 5 o'clock he went to

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Medical testimony disputed Sharkey's claim of a low blow, suggesting his injuries were too mild to match his account. Fitzsimmons testified he struck no foul blow and described the legitimate combination that knocked Sharkey out, also recounting objections to Wyatt Earp's selection as referee.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey's room with Mr. Groom to examine the fighter and to consult with other physicians. There were present Drs. Anderson, Rottanzi, Ragan, Barrett and Pescia. They examined Sharkey and went into consultation. Dr. Lee was also present, but they did not take him into consultation.

"Why did you not take him into consultation with you?" asked Mr. Kowalsky.

See moreSee less

General Barnes strenuously objected.

Mr. Kowalsky said: "We offer to prove that this man Lee was a party to the fraud and participated in a portion of this fraud; that he is not a reputable physician, that he is the character of a man who would be guilty of this sort of thing and that no reputable physician would have anything to do with him. We will prove that he is just exactly what I state him to be and notoriously so."

The question and offer were ruled out.

The witness went on to tell what the doctors found. On examining Sharkey they found two punctures and some discoloration and evidences that leeches had been applied. The injury was but very slight and could have been produced by an injection of water or acidulated fluid under the skin. If Sharkey had been injured in the manner claimed by him there would have been an instantaneous swelling, causing the most agonizing pain. In his opinion the injury was not severe enough to incapacitate Sharkey or to compel him to take to his bed. If the fighter had been injured in the way he claimed his condition would have been much worse the day after the fight than immediately after it. Further testimony was to the effect that Sharkey's account of his injuries and the result of the physicians' examination do not harmonize. The doctor did not think Sharkey was badly hurt. The immediate effect of such a blow would be to produce instant collapse, attended with violent pain, vomiting and other grave constitutional disturbances. There were no such indications in Sharkey's case.

Robert Fitzsimmons, whose square shoulders and lanky form were emphasized by the long black overcoat he wore, was the next witness.

"Do you know Thomas Sharkey?" asked Mr. Kowalsky.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Fitzsimmons describes in testimony how he delivered the knockout blows to Sharkey, then recounts the pre-fight dispute over Wyatt Earp's selection as referee. He claims Julian publicly objected to Earp as a 'crooked' referee before the fight proceeded.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

what he said. Julian suggested Young Mitchell, Colonel Andrews, Lem Fulda and Hiram Cook. Fitzsimmons refused to put on the gloves and made a speech to the spectators, in which he said he had given in to everything in the contest with reference to the gloves, etc., and that as they had called upon him to fight he would waive his objections and go on with the referee, but he insisted that Sharkey should take the bandages off his hands.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A satirical newspaper column mocks rival papers and politics, including a jab suggesting Collis Huntington secretly arranged for Wyatt Earp to referee a prize fight. It's a sarcastic aside referencing the earlier controversy over Earp's disputed refereeing decision.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE CALL SPEAKS FOR ALL.

If some of our contemporaries had not advertised so many lottery swindles to defraud the people during the year they would not have so much need to be calling for charity now.

It would not surprise anybody if "Long Green" Lawrence should make the Examiner declare it was Collis Huntington who put up Wyatt Earp as referee and fixed the whole job.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This editorial excoriates the San Francisco Examiner for hypocritical and unethical journalism practices, citing multiple examples of contradictory coverage. Among these, it notes that the Examiner's local manager praised Wyatt Earp as honorable while the paper's New York counterpart (the Journal) denounced him as thoroughly disreputable and capable of dishonest dealing.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE "EXAMINER'S" OFFENDING

count to watch a contest in the prize-ring. We have seen the managers of the Examiner denounce all persons who claimed to have seen the strange lights in the sky during the past month as drunkards, imbeciles or liars and at the same time send to their companions of the New York Journal a story declaring that an airship was seen by witnesses who are reputable, creditable, reliable and thoroughly honest. We have seen the Examiner manager in this City recommend Wyatt Earp as an honorable man, while the Examiner's proprietor in New York, through the Journal of that city, denounced him as being utterly disreputable and capable of any kind of dishonest dealing, from the running of a bunko game to the robbing of a stage-coach.

See moreSee less

All this and more we have seen. It is not strange, therefore, that at last the public revolts. The strong, straight Saxon speech in which the decent newspapers of California are now denouncing this foul and unclean journalism is none too forceful for the occasion. We have compromised with the evil too long. It is not a pleasant duty to expose all this vileness to the public, but in the interests of the public it must be done. So long as the Hearst estate holds out and Willie Hearst has not fulfilled the New York prediction of changing his residence to Sing Sing and his name to No. 743 we may have the Examiner still circulating in the community. It should not, however, be permitted to circulate in the homes of the people or in places of decent business. Let it go to the slums, to which it panders, and from which all its ideas emanate.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

George A. Morrison, a former prize-fighter from San Francisco, claims he was drugged during a 1891 fight in Ogden that was refereed by Wyatt Earp, allegedly chosen by bunko men and gold bar swindlers. The accusation appears as a brief item amid unrelated city news.

The San Francisco Call · 15 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

warrantable.

George A. Morrison of 200 Eighth street was formerly a prize-fighter. He says he was doped in a fight in Ogden in 1891, Wyatt Earp being the referee chosen by bunko men and gold-bar swindlers.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Witnesses testify at a hearing into allegations of fraud surrounding Wyatt Earp's controversial refereeing of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight. Sharkey's manager Lynch denies claims of a fix or improper treatment, while sportswriter Naughton says he saw no foul.

The Record-Union · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

INVESTIGATION OF CHARGES OF

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 14.—Robert Fitzsimmons and Sharkey met this morning for the first time since their encounter at the Mechanics' Pavilion on the 2d inst., when they came face to face in Judge Sanderson's courtroom, the occasion being the continuance of the legal fight for the $10,000 purse hung up by the National Athletic Club, Fitzsimmons still hoping to gain possession of the golden dollars which Referee Earp awarded to his adversary. The meeting was devoid of excitement, as each gladiator dropped into a seat near his attorney without a glance at his late opponent.

Dr. E. D. Lustig was the first witness. He testified that he was the medical examiner of the National Athletic Club, and examined both men a few days before the fight. He found them in prime physical condition. After Sharkey had been carried out of the ring on the night of the contest witness went to his dressing-room with four others, but all were denied admission. The following afternoon, in company with Drs. Anderson, Rottanz, Ragan and Lee, he examined Sharkey at his room, and found, beside the cuts and bruises on his head, a slight swelling and discoloration in the groin, the latter being due to leeching. The injury was superficial, and could have been produced from any of a number of causes, including the injection of any irritating fluid. Had it been caused by a blow by such a man as Fitzsimmons it would have been most serious.

See moreSee less

Fitzsimmons then took the witness stand. He described his previous meeting with the sailor, and said that before the contest they had agreed not to clinch and break away "fair," but Sharkey had violated the agreement. In the eighth round he landed his left in Sharkey's face, and the latter raised his hands to guard against a repetition of the blow, when Fitzsimmons sent in a left shift on the stomach. This caused Sharkey to drop his hands, and witness gave him an uppercut which sent him to the floor. Fitzsimmons was positive he never struck a foul blow.

Martin Julian then told how he had tried to agree on a referee, how the club had selected Earp, and how Police Commissioner Gunst and Riley Grannan had told him that Earp had been "fixed," and how when he called Earp's attention to Sharkey's unfair tactics and fouls, Earp said Fitz was doing as much wrestling as Sharkey.

Julian was asked for positive proof of fraud, but could produce nothing more than hearsay testimony.

W. W. Naughton, the well-known sporting editor, described the fight, and said he saw no foul blow struck.

D. J. Lynch, Sharkey's manager, then testified that the first he knew of Earp's appointment as referee was about 4 o'clock in the afternoon of the fight. He had never heard Earp's name mentioned in connection with the mill before then. Ne[i]ther he nor Sharkey had any interest whatever in the National Club. Lynch denied the statement of B[i]lly Smith regarding the treatment Sharkey received. He did not know how Dr. Lee came to be called in. Lynch said he had sent for a good physician to report at the Windsor. "That night Dr. Ragan called and attended Sharkey," continued Lynch. Witness denied that he ever asked Smith if he could do business with Hiram Cook as referee. He did not have an understanding or agreement with the referee to award the $10,000 to Sharkey, whether he won or not.

Sharkey will be examined to-morrow morning.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Witnesses including Martin Julian, Dr. Lustig, and Bob Fitzsimmons testified about alleged fouls and a conspiracy to rig the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Julian claimed Wyatt Earp, the referee, was overheard assuring a bookmaker the fix was in, though only hearsay evidence was presented.

The Herald · 15 December 1896 · page 2

and occupied all the window sills. Once In their anxiety to hear what Fitzsim- ] mons had to say they broke down a por tion of the railing that is supposed to separate the common citizens from the attorneys and reporters. The judge j sternly rebuked their action and told ; them that If they smashed anything | more he would order the room cleared. I Sharkey was there all day. He sat in I the jury box and took in every detail of I the evidence, wearing an extremely ju ! dicial air that seemed to sit well on his i thoughtful ami disfigured features. TO BE COLLECTED.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Court testimony examines claims that referee Wyatt Earp was complicit in fixing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, including hearsay about Earp assuring a bookmaker 'you can depend on me.' Crowds packed the courtroom to hear the proceedings, with other witnesses like Danny Lynch also giving testimony.

The Herald · 15 December 1896 · page 2

Sharkey a foul blow. He illustrated the 1 blows he had given Sharkey. He said | I he knew an hour or two before the fight J * there was a conspiracy to decide the fight against him, and told how he had I < protested to Groom and Gibbs of the i National club and how they refused to ; < select another referee. He said that ' during the fight he was extra careful to avoid an appearance of a foul blow, > knowing he had a crooked referee to ' deal with.

See moreSee less

He said he fought at long ' range and took no chances of commitI ting a foul. Martin Julian then told how he had tried to agree on a referee; how the club 1 had selected Earp; how Police Commts sloner Gunst and Riley Grannon had told | him Earp had been fixed, ar.d how when ] ' he called Earp's attention to Sharkey's 1 unfair tactics and fouls, Earp said Fitz simmons was doing as much wrestling as Sharkey. Julian was asked for pos itive proof of fraud, but could produce nothing more than hearsay testimony. He quoted Riley Grannon as saying he had overheard Earp and Joe Harvey, a bookmaker, discussing the fight. Harvey said: "Is it all right?" Earp had re- .

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

Witnesses testify in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight trial about how Wyatt Earp was selected as referee, with Fitzsimmons' manager Julian claiming Earp was 'fixed' and that he protested the appointment. Sharkey's manager Lynch denies betting heavily on Sharkey or having improper involvement, while disputing claims about Sharkey's treatment after the fight.

The Morning Times · 15 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

positive he never struck a foul blow. NAMING THE REFEREE. Gen. Barnes tried to shake his testimony in cross-examination, but failed, and Martin Julian, Fitz's manager, was called. He told of his attempts to have Lynch agree upon a referee, but the latter said he did not propose to have his man get the worst of the deal. Witness offered the names of several well-known men for referee, but Lynch rejected them all, and declined to submit any names to Sharkey. At 3 o'clock on the afternoon of the fight witness first heard that Earp had been appointed referee by the club. After-

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 2 other papers

Doctors and witnesses testify in court about the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, with medical examiners describing Sharkey's injuries as possibly not caused by a blow. Fitzsimmons and his manager Julian testify that Sharkey broke their no-clinch agreement and that Earp was allegedly 'fixed' as referee.

The Morning News · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FITZ AND SHARKEY FACE TO FACE IN THE COURT ROOM.

The Australian Describes the Blows Delivered in Knocking Out the Sailor—The Medical Examiner of the National Athletic Club Gives a Description of the Injury to Sharkey's Groin Which Is in Favor of Fitzsimmons—Sharkey's Clique Claim They Will Prove Perjury and Conspiracy.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 14.—Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey met this morning for the first time since their encounter at the Mechanics' pavilion, on the 2d inst., when they came face to face in Judge Sanderson's court room, the occasion being the continuance of the legal fight for the $10,000 purse hung up by the National Athletic Club, Fitzsimmons still hoping to get possession of the golden dollars which Referee Earp awarded to his adversary.

The meeting was devoid of excitement as each gladiator dropped into a seat near his attorney without a glance at his opponent.

Before proceedings were begun Lynch, Sharkey's manager, stated that after Sharkey's side of the case had been put in, Fitzsimmons would not have a prop under him.

"We will prove," he remarked, "that Smith, Allen and Abbott committed perjury, and we will also show their testimony was manufactured for the occasion. If there is a conspiracy in this affair, it originated with the other side for the purpose of stealing the coin from us after we won it."

Dr. E. D. Lustig was the first witness. He testified that he was the medical examiner of the National Athletic Club and examined both men a few days before the fight. He found them in prime physical condition. After Sharkey had been carried out of the ring the night of the contest, witness went to his dressing room with four other doctors, but all were denied admission. The following afternoon, in company with Drs. Anderson, Rottanz, Ragan and Lee, he examined Sharkey at his room, and found, beside the cuts and bruises on his head, a slight swelling and discoloration in the groin, the latter being due to leeching. The injury was superficial and could have been produced from any of a number of causes, including the injection of any irritating fluid. Had it been caused by a blow by such a man as Fitzsimmons it would have been most serious. Witness described the effects of a hard blow such as Sharkey claimed to have received, and said it would probably have caused collapse and vomiting.

Fitzsimmons then took the witness stand and caused a laugh when he stated, in response to a question, that he had seen Sharkey before. He described his previous meeting with the sailor and said that before the contest they agreed not to clinch and to break away fair, but Sharkey had violated the agreement. In the eighth round he landed his left in Sharkey's face and the latter raised his hands to guard against a repetition of the blow, when Fitz sent in a left shift on the stomach. This caused Sharkey to drop his hands and witness gave him an upper cut which sent him to the floor. Fitz was positive he never struck a foul blow.

Gen. Barnes tried to shake his testimony in cross-examination, but failed, and Martin Julian, Fitz's manager, was called.

He told of his attempts to have Lynch agree upon a referee, but the latter said he did not propose to have his man get the worst of the deal. Witness offered the names of several well-known men for referee, but Lynch rejected them all and declined to submit any names to Julian. At 3 o'clock on the afternoon of the fight he heard that Earp had been appointed referee by the club. Afterward he met Riley Granman, Mose Gunst and others, and all wanted to know what he meant by permitting such a man to be named. He was told that Earp had been "fixed," and went to Groom and said Fitz would not fight with Earp as referee. After the men went in the ring Julian made another protest. He told Earp he would disgrace him if he persisted in entering the ring, but the latter said he knew what he was going to do. Finally, seeing they could not have the referee changed, he agreed to go on and cautioned Fitzsimmons to be extremely careful.

W. W. Naughton, the well known sporting editor, described the fight and said he saw no foul blow struck.

D. J. Lynch, Sharkey's manager, then testified that the first he knew of Earp's appointment as referee was about 4 o'clock the afternoon of the fight. He had never heard Earp's name mentioned in connection with the mill before then. Five days before the fight he made a small bet on Sharkey, the smallest he had made on any of the sailor's contests. Neither he nor Sharkey had any interest whatever in the National Club. He was on the timer's stand during the fight and did not go near the ring after the battle, but when Sharkey went out he went to the dressing room and waited for the sailor to be brought in. He did not whisper to him to simulate pain. Lynch denied the statement of Billy Smith, regarding the treatment Sharkey received. He did not know how Dr. Lee came to be called. Lynch said he had sent for a good physician to report at the Windsor.

"That night Dr. Ragan called and attended Sharkey," continued Lynch.

"Did you ever ask Smith if you could not do business with Hiram Cook, as referee?"

"I did not."

"Did you have an understanding or agreement with the referee to award the $10,000 to Sharkey, whether he won or not?"

"I did not."

Lynch explained that he did not accept the men suggested by Julian for referee as they were Julian's personal friends or sympathizers, or had made bets on Fitzsimmons.

Sharkey will be examined to-morrow morning.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Sun · New York, N.Y. · 15 December 1896
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 15 December 1896

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

In a San Francisco court, Julian attempted to prove a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons but could only offer hearsay testimony. He described how Lynch left the referee selection to the National Club, which named Earp.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 15 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

JULIAN DOESN'T KNOW MUCH Placed on the Stand he has Only Hearsay Stories. San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 14.—Tom Sharkey, looking little the worst for his drubbing, was in court today when the controversy for the possession of the $10,000 purse was renewed. Fitzsimmons and Julian attempted to expose the alleged conspiracy against Fitzsimmons, but when Julian was asked for positive proof, he produced nothing but hearsay testimony. Julian related his efforts to have Lynch join him in selecting a referee, stating that Lynch purposely placed the choice of a referee in the hands of the National club, which named Earp. Julian said Police Commis-

See the clipping

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.

The item reports that it has been well established that referee Wyatt Earp was involved in a scheme to rob Fitzsimmons of $10,000 in his fight with Sharkey. It notes that Fitzsimmons has gone to court to prove Earp's involvement in the scheme.

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 15 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Press Association.

It has been pretty well established that Referee Wyatt Earp was in a scheme to rob Fitzsimmons of the $10,000 in his fight with Sharkey. Fitz has gone into the courts to prove that devilment was Earp.

See moreSee less

"Gypsy," the most dangerous elephant in captivity, that has killed four keepers, is to be electrocuted in Chicago, as the owners have come to the conclusion that they have an elephant on their hands.

All four of the Republican papers of Louisville are roasting Gov. Bradley on account of his refusal to call a special session of the Legislature to elect Hunter to the Senate and to increase the taxes of the people in the midst of hard times.

Gen. Maceo's second in command is Gen. Rios Reivera, who will succeed the brave leader if the report of his death is confirmed. Gen. Reivera proved himself a successful soldier and brave fighter in the last war against Spain.

Gus. W. Richardson, of Meade; Robt. Green, of Franklin; W. B. Gibson,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

In San Francisco court, Julian and Fitzsimmons testified that Wyatt Earp had been bribed as referee, citing an overheard conversation. A doctor also testified that Sharkey's groin injury was superficial and possibly caused artificially.

The Providence News · 15 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY APPEARS IN COURT.

Tom Sharkey, looking little the worst for his drubbing, was in court ar San Francisco yesterday, when the controversy for the possession of the $10,000 purse was renewed.

See moreSee less

Fitzsimmons and Julian attempted to expose the alleged conspiracy against Fitzsimmons. Julian related his efforts to have Lynch join him in selecting a referee, stating that Lynch purposely placed the choice of a referee in the hands of the National Club, which named Earp.

Julian said Commissioner Gunst and Riley Grunnan had told him before the fight that "Earp had been fixed."

He quoted Grunnon as having overheard a conversation between Earp and Joe Harvey, a bookkeeper, in the course of which Harvey said: "Then its' all right, is it?" to which Earp had replied: "You can depend on me." Julian's testimony tended to involve the National Club, Sharkey, Lynch and Earp in the alleged conspiracy. Fitzsimmons denied that he had struck a foul blow, and repeated Julian's story about the warning not to accept Earp as referee.

Dr. D. D. Lustig said he was the medical examiner for the National Club and had examined Sharkey before the fight. After Sharkey had been taken to his room, Lustig, with four other doctors, hearing Sharkey had been hurt, offered their services, but they were refused admittance to Sharkey's dressing room.

On the following afternoon Lustig and five other physicians examined Sharkey's injuries in the groin, and witness pronounced the injury superficial. He said it was insignificant, not disabling or productive of much pain. The injuries to the groin might have been caused by artificial means, such as the injection of acidulated water.

Dan Hickey, one of Fitzsimmons' seconds, W. W. Naughton, a sporting reporter, and others who saw the fight, testified that they had not seen a foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in court as Fitzsimmons contests the $10,000 purse awarded to Sharkey by referee Wyatt Earp after their controversial bout. Sharkey's manager Lynch claims Fitzsimmons' witnesses committed perjury and that evidence was fabricated to steal the win.

The Salt Lake Herald · 15 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THOUGH LYNCH SAYS HE WILL KNOCK OUT FITZSIMMONS' PROPS

San Francisco, Dec. 14.—Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey met this morning for the first time since their encounter at the Mechanics' pavilion, on the 2nd inst., when they came face to face in Judge Sanderson's courtroom, the occasion being the continuance of the legal fight for the $10,000 purse hung up by the National Athletic club, Fitzsimmons still hoping to gain possession of the golden dollars which Referee Earp awarded to his adversary. The meeting was devoid of excitement, as each gladiator dropped into a seat near his attorney without a glance at his late opponent.

Before proceedings were begun, Lynch, Sharkey's manager, stated after Sharkey's side of the case had been put in, Fitzsimmons would not have a prop under him.

See moreSee less

"We will prove," he remarked, "that Smith, Allen and Abbott committed

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Witnesses testify in court about the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, including medical evidence on Sharkey's injuries and Fitzsimmons' own account of the bout. Manager Martin Julian also testifies about disputes over selecting a referee, revealing that Wyatt Earp was appointed under suspicious circumstances.

The Times · 15 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WOULD HAVE BEEN SERIOUS

General Barnes tried to shake his testimony in cross-examination, but failed, and Martin Julian, Fitzsimmons' manager, was called. He told of his attempts to have Lynch agree upon a referee, but the latter said he did not propose to have his man get the worst of the deal. Wit-

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

In San Francisco court proceedings over the disputed $10,000 purse from the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, Julian presented hearsay testimony alleging a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons. He claimed Riley Grannan overheard referee Wyatt Earp assure bookmaker Joe Harvey that the fight's outcome could be depended upon.

The Laramie Republican · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY IN COURT San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 14.—Tom Sharkey, looking a little worse for his drubbing, was in court today. The controversy for the possession of the $10,000 purse was renewed. Fitzsimmons

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Court testimony describes claims that referee Wyatt Earp had been 'fixed' before the fight, with witnesses recounting conversations and warnings about his impartiality. Medical testimony also addressed Sharkey's groin injury, suggesting it may have been minor or artificially induced.

The Laramie Republican · 15 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY IN COURT

Fitzsimmons denied he had struck any foul blow and repeated Julian's story about warnings not to accept Earp as a referee. Dr. D. D. Lustig's testimony was not relished by Sharkey. He said he was a medical examiner for the National club and had examined Sharkey before the fight. After Sharkey had been taken to his room, Lustig, with four other doctors, hearing Sharkey had been hurt, offered their services, but were refused admittance to Sharkey's dressing-room. On the following afternoon, Dr. Lustig and five other physicians examined Sharkey's injuries in the groin and witness pronounced the injury superficial. He said it was insignificant, not disabling or productive of much pain. The injuries to the groin might have been caused by artificial means, such as the injection of acidulated water.

Dan Hickey, one of Fitzsimmons' seconds, W. W. Naughton, a sporting reporter, and others were present at the fight, and all testified they had seen no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

See moreSee less

"I Love You!"

"I love you!"

Oh, what music there was in those words as they flowed mellifluously—which means something about honey—from her parted lips. Her lips were parted in the middle.

"I love you!"

The songs of the birds in the trees overhead seemed jangling and out of tune in comparison with these words of her.

"I love you!"

Aye, for such a one as she kings, and even actors, would have given up their all and fallen captive at her feet.

"I love you!"

And he? Did his heart leap within him? Did his panting breath denote the ardor of his longing to clasp her in his

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

A San Francisco dispatch reports that Allen, one of Sharkey's trainers, confessed that Lynch, Earp, Sharkey and Needham conspired to claim a foul in order to win the purse. The allegation suggests the controversial foul decision in the recent prizefight, where Wyatt Earp served as referee, was part of a prearranged scheme.

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9.—Allen, one of Sharkey's trainers, has made an alleged confession, in which he states Lynch, Earp, Sharkey and Needham put up a job to claim a foul and get the purse.

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

A brief dispatch from San Francisco reports that Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying a concealed weapon. No further details are given about the circumstances of the arrest.

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

known positively that Senator Al[l]ison will be secretary of state in McKinley's caninet.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 10.—Wyatt Earp was fined $50 for carrying concealed weapons today.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Wyatt Earp testified under oath that he never gave any interview or statement to the Examiner about the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, despite the paper publishing a column under his name. The court proceedings also involved General Barnes announcing he would move to dismiss the injunction on the fight purse, arguing it was an unlawful prize fight.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Refers to Earp's Howitzer.

Wyatt Earp yesterday exposed some of the fake methods employed by that sensational and utterly unreliable journal, the "Long Green" Examiner, when he went on the witness-stand and declared under oath that he had never written anything about the fight for that or any other newspaper, and that he had never given a reporter an interview.

See moreSee less

It will be remembered that the Examiner published what purported to be a half-column statement from Earp about the fight over Earp's signature.

William Greer Harrison and others were called to prove that the prize-fight between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons was not a prize-fight but a gentlemanly glove contest "for points," some of the "points" involving broken ribs, smashed noses, blackened eyes and the knocking of one of the gentlemanly contestants into a state of coma guaranteed to last at least ten seconds.

General Barnes announced that on Thursday morning he would move for a dismissal of the complaint and the injunction on the ground that the contest was a fight for a prize and not a kindergarten game.

One of the main bluffs made by Mr. Bad Man Earp during his examination was that Chief Clerk Clough of the Baldwin Hotel would not testify that he, Earp, had called at the hotel the day after the battle and had asked to see Fitzsimmons. Earp was particularly strong in his denial of this point, just as he was in other points where he stands alone as against the sworn testimony of many witnesses.

But, in this Clough matter, the chief clerk of the Baldwin gives Earp the lie in a way most unequivocal.

"Earp has been coming here almost daily for his mail." Mr. Clough stated last night to an assemblage of attorneys and newspaper men.

"The morning after the fight he came in, got some letters and telegrams and asked me if Fitzsimmons was around. The latter was in the cafe, and I suggested that he send him his card. Earp did not wish to do this, but came around a second time asking if Mr. Fitzsimmons had yet come out. It was evident Earp wanted to see Fitzsimmons, but did not care to meet him in the cafe. Finally he walked away."

This statement made by Mr. Clough, a man of unquestioned integrity, and a hotel man of most favorable renown for the past twenty years, stands now against the denial of Wyatt Earp, the gun-fighter and border ruffian, the bodyguard of "Long Green" Andy Lawrence.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A hotel clerk named Clough directly contradicts Wyatt Earp's sworn denial that he sought to meet Fitzsimmons the day after the fight, exposing Earp to a possible perjury indictment. Attorneys also pursue evidence against a disputed Sharkey camp physician, Dr. Lee, coordinating with police detectives.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

and border ruffian, the bodyguard of "Long Green" Andy Lawrence.

Mr. Clough is to make his sworn statement to the Commissioner in regard to this matter, and, at the outcome of the whole matter, Wyatt Earp will be brought up with a round turn by the Grand Jury on an indictment for perjury.

See moreSee less

The prosecution is particularly anxious to see the Sharkey faction place "Dr." B. B. Lee on the stand. This alleged physician is credited with having been either paid or promised $1000 for his services to Sharkey.

Yesterday afternoon Attorney Kowal-

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

During courtroom examination, fight manager Danny Lynch testified about betting on Sharkey and a certificate of deposit handed to Wyatt Earp in the ring by police. Lynch stated Earp did not endorse the certificate at ringside but took it home, later producing it when Lynch visited his residence the next day.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

letic club and acted as doorkeeper until Sharkey arrived. This line of examination was as to Lynch's supposed connection with the National Athletic Club.

On the preceding day Lynch swore that the bet he had made on Sharkey was the smallest he had ever made on a prizefight. Yesterday, in response to a similar question, he said that it was a smaller bet than any he had made before on Sharkey. He admitted in answer to a direct question that he had a pool ticket for $1400 at odds of $1000 to $400, his wager being $400 on Sharkey, but that was nearly a week before the fight. His money was placed with Henry Harris.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A deposition is being taken regarding the Sharkey fight where Sharkey claimed he was fouled while sinking to his knees against Earp as referee. Witnesses, including Lynch and William Greer Harrison, testify about boxing arrangements, training, and the definition of a knockout, while Judge Sanderson questions whether the bout was a prize-fight or friendly match.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

he had heard the evidence. Sharkey explained that a knockout was when a man, after receiving a blow, was unable to proceed for five or ten minutes, and his definition produced a gasp of astonishment from all who heard him.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

In a San Francisco courtroom, witnesses debate the dangers of prize-fighting, and referee Wyatt Earp testifies about his handling of Sharkey's bandages and his decision to award the fight to Sharkey on a foul after Fitzsimmons struck him in the groin. Earp describes his selection as referee and his blunt manner of dealing with objections during the bout.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

finishing blows given and swore that Mr. Fitzsimmons did not strike Sharkey a foul blow.

Wyatt Earp was called and walked up to the stand out of the jury-box with a tent-pole protruding just below the back buttons of his coat. He said that he was chosen as referee by Messrs. Gibbs and Groom at 1 o'clock on the afternoon of the fight. No one had spoken to him about the matter previous to that hour. He was but very slightly acquainted with Lynch, and had not spoken to Lynch more than five words at any one time.

See moreSee less

"That man over there," continued Earp, "Julian, I believe they call him, protested against the bandages on Sharkey's hands. I knew my business, and I knew that I had a right to allow Sharkey to wear the bandages. Then, when Julian protested again, I went over to Sharkey and told him to take off them bandages."

"Did you tell Sharkey to take off the bandages—that it was all right, anyhow?" was asked.

"No, sir," replied Earp, "I don't deal with them kind of people in that way; I deal with them in a different kind of way. I said, 'You take them bandages off.' I done it in a way that Sharkey understood what I said. I don't plead with them kind of people."

The witness then described the finishing blows. He saw Fitzsimmons strike Sharkey in the groin and Sharkey double up and groan with pain. Then he decided that Sharkey had won on a foul.

He met Fitzsimmons four or five years ago on Geary street in this City, in a sa-

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A satirical roundup column mocks a public dispute between William Randolph Hearst and gambler 'Lone Green' Lawrence over Wyatt Earp's tarnished reputation, calling it a 'dirty crow' they'll enjoy picking at. It also jokes that Lawrence should send Earp after a fugitive named Dunham to keep him occupied.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE CALL SPEAKS FOR ALL

Willie Hearst and Long Green Lawrence have a crow to pick with one another over Wyatt Earp's reputation, but as it is a very dirty crow they will find the job congenial.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A roundup of minor San Francisco news items includes a note that British ship captains plan a regatta with a referee whose decision will be final, humorously noting their referee will not be Wyatt Earp. This passing joke shows Earp's name already functioning as popular shorthand for a biased or controversial arbiter.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

CITY NEWS IN BRIEF.

The British ship captains are to hold a regatta next Saturday at Sausalito. They assert that they will have a disinterested referee (not Wyatt Earp) whose decision shall be final.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

British ship captains organizing a Sausalito regatta specify their referee will be a 'disinterested adjudicator (not Wyatt Earp)', a joking jab at his reputation. The item also covers unrelated shipping news about a schooner's cedar log cargo shortfall.

The San Francisco Call · 16 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

The British ship captains whose vessels are now lying at Sausalito have got up a regatta for next Saturday. Nearly every vessel in the bay flying the British flag has entered a boat and some good contests are expected.

One paragraph in the notice issued by the captains reads as follows: "A disinterested adjudicator (not Wyatt Earp), whose decision shall be final, will be on

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · and 4 other papers

In the Fitzsimmons lawsuit over the disputed $10,000 check, boxer Tom Sharkey testified denying he had any financial stake in the National Athletic Club or had arranged for Wyatt Earp to referee the fight. He also denied telling trainer Smith that having Earp as referee would ensure things went well for him.

The Record-Union · 16 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Loaned It Any Money.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 15.—Thomas Sharkey testified in his own behalf to day in Fitzsimmons' suit for possession of that $10,000 check, and his denial of the charges of crookedness were prompt and vigorous. The proceedings opened with Manager Lynch on the stand for further cross-examination, but Attorney Kowalsky was unable to bring out any damaging admissions, and Lynch soon gave way to the sailor, who formally identified the articles of agreement signed by himself and Fitzsimmons, and then General Barnes questioned him along the lines of Trainer Smith's testimony.

See moreSee less

Sharkey denied having any interest whatever in the National Athletic Club, or that he had advanced that organization $2,500, or any other sum. The first he heard of Earp was when he saw his name in the papers before he went to Sausalito to see Fitzsimmons. He did not tell Smith that if he (Sharkey) could get Earp for referee he would be all right, or that there would be good money in it for the right referee. Nor did he ever state that he would refuse to agree to any referee in advance, and the club would then name any man he would suggest. The sailor was positive he had never talked to Lynch or any body else about Earp. He went into the ring with no thought but to win in a fair fight.

Sharkey being asked how the last blows were struck, replied:

"Fitzsimmons struck me a jab in the mouth with his left hand. Then he feinted with his left and swung his right across my head. I jumped back and then forward again, and he gave me the poke in the groin." Sharkey denied that he had entered into an agreement with Lynch to do anything to get the fight, or had he anything to do with the selection of a referee.

Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, was called to the witness stand. His story in general was a denial of what Smith and Allen had said about a referee and about the suspicious circumstance in the dressing-room and in Sharkey's room in the hotel.

William Greer Harrison explained the difference between a prize fight and a glove contest. The former he said was a brutal contest, while the latter was altogether a matter of skill. Harrison saw the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons contest and saw no foul.

L. R. Fulda, formerly President of the California Athletic Club, agreed with Harrison as to the distinction between a glove contest and a prize fight. He was not at the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons contest. He said the referee's decision was final.

Referee Wyatt Earp was then called. He testified that he was in the Baldwin Hotel about 1 o'clock the afternoon of the fight when he was first asked to referee the fight by Groom, Gibbs and some one else. He did not know Lynch except to speak to him, and had not spoken to him half a dozen times in his life. Earp's description of the eighth round was, in his own language, as follows: "Fitzsimmons drove Sharkey to his corner and struck him a blow on the breast. Sharkey came, and Fitzsimmons tried to uppercut him, and struck him on the groin. As he went back he uppercut him on the chin. He did not fall backwards, but went down onto his knees, and placed his hands on the

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 16 December 1896
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 16 December 1896
  • Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 16 December 1896
  • The Times · Richmond, Va. · 16 December 1896

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Wyatt Earp testified in the court case over the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight purse, saying he had refereed fairly, though newspapers were skeptical of his account. Sharkey also testified, denying conspiracy allegations and insisting Fitzsimmons had struck him with a foul blow.

The Herald · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

EARP GIVES TESTIMONY

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 15.—The Evening Post this afternoon will say: The decision in the fight was beyond the slightest doubt the result of a disgraceful criminal conspiracy. Besides the principals in the original plot, the Post says, another figure is now involved in the aftermath of the scandal. This man is "Dr." B. B. Lee, who "happened to be at the Windsor hotel" when Sharkey was carried thither after the fight. The Post says further: "It is announced that Lee was paid $1000 for his services, which, rumor says, consisted in the artificial production of evidence of foul by operating on Sharkey."

The Post also prints a statement that Lee approached a reputable physician with the offer of $500 if he would join Lee in stating that Sharkey's injuries were the result of a foul blow.

See moreSee less

Thomas Sharkey followed Lynch on the stand today. He denied the stories told by Billy Smith and George Allen.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

During court proceedings investigating the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, Sharkey denied claims of fixing and insisted Fitzsimmons fouled him, while referee Wyatt Earp testified he had no betting interest, no prior arrangement to referee, and that Fitzsimmons had fouled Sharkey repeatedly. Allegations also surfaced that Dr. Lee was paid to fabricate evidence of a foul blow.

The Herald · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

EARP GIVES TESTIMONY

were the result of a foul blow.

Thomas Sharkey followed Lynch on the stand today. He denied the stories told by Billy Smith and George Allen. He said he was not a partner in the National club and had no intercourse with Earp before the fight, and declared that Fitzsimmons had struck him a foul blow on the groin. He said he still suffered pain from injuries to his groin. He said he had no bets on the fight, but advised all his friends to back him, feeling confident of winning. He said he was so injured by the blow that he had but an indistinct recollection of subsequent occurrences. He said the reason he holloaed with pain in the dressing room after the fight was because Dr. Lee felt his groin and pressed it hard where he had been struck.

See moreSee less

Wyatt Earp, the referee, was called as a witness by Gen. Barnes. He swore that Fitzsimmons had never said a word of any kind in the ring about the bandages on Sharkey's hands. He had not spoken more than five words to Lynch in his life. Did not bet five cents on the result of the fight. Had entered into no combination with anybody to give the decision to Sharkey, and never heard it hinted that he was to be referee till the afternoon of the fight.

On cross examination he said: "I have refereed one fight in California. It was at San Diego between 'Rocky' O'Neill and another man whose name I disremember. I have also refereed about twenty fights in Mexico. I want to say that Julian's statements are a pack of falsehoods. He never said in the ring or anywhere else that he did not want me for referee. I never put my fingers in Fitzsimmons' eyes during the fight. Sharkey never caught Fitzsimmons around the legs at all, neither did he foul Fitzsimmons in any way during the contest. Fitzsimmons was fouling Sharkey all the time."

The rest of the testimony in the case will be taken by a referee appointed by the court.

IN THE RING.

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

Sailor Tom Sharkey testified in Fitzsimmons' lawsuit over a disputed $10,000 check, denying any crooked dealings or financial interest in his bout with Fitzsimmons. He denied suggesting Wyatt Earp as referee or discussing bribery, stating he first learned of Earp's involvement from the newspapers.

The Morning Times · 16 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Enters a General Denial of Crooked Work

San Francisco, Dec. 15. Thomas Sharkey testified in his own behalf today in Fitzsimmons' suit for possession of that $10,000 check, and his denial of the charge of crookedness were prompt and vigorous. The proceedings opened with Mr. Lynch on the stand for further cross-examination, but Attorney Kowalsky was unable to bring in any damaging admissions and Lynch soon gave way to the sailor, who formally identified the articles of agreement signed by himself and Fitzsimmons, and then Gen. Barnes questioned him along the lines of Trainer Smith's testimony. Sharkey denied having any interest whatever in the National Athletic Club; also that he had advanced that organization $2,500, or any other sum.

See moreSee less

The first he heard of Earp was when he saw his name in the papers before he went to Sausalito to see Fitz. He did not tell Smith that he (Sharkey) could get Earp for referee he would be all right, or that there would be good money in it for

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

Sharkey testifies under cross-examination about the knockout blow, denying any fix with Lynch or Earp, and describing his injury and pain after being struck in the groin. Referee Wyatt Earp also testifies, describing how he came to referee the match and detailing the controversial eighth round where Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey.

The Morning Times · 16 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE KNOCKOUT BLOW.

"When did he?"

"Friday night. Leeches were put on Thursday."

See moreSee less

Did he use a hypodermic syringe or use a knife to make a puncture?"

"He did not."

Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, was the next witness. His story in general was a denial of what Smith and Allen had said about the referee and about the suspicious circumstances in the dressing-room and in Sharkey's room at the hotel.

Referee Wyatt Earp testified that he was in the Baldwin Hotel about 1 o'clock the afternoon of the fight, when he was first asked to referee the fight by Groom, Gibbs, and someone else. He did not know Lynch, except to speak to him, and had not spoken to him half a dozen times in his life.

As to the bandages on Sharkey's hands, Earp said he told Sharkey to take them off on a second protest from Julian. Earp's description of the eighth round was as follows:

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

Referee Wyatt Earp testifies about events before the fight and gives his account of the eighth round, describing how Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey a low blow leading to Earp's foul decision. Earp became visibly agitated when confronted with Julian's conflicting testimony, which he denounced as false.

The Morning Times · 16 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

EARP BECAME EXCITED.

Mr. Sharkey has won on a foul." There was an exciting scene when Earp was asked if he had said what Julian had testified to. Earp denounced Julian's statements as a tissue of falsehoods. At the conclusion of Earp's examination the court adjourned.

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

Wyatt Earp appeared before Judge Sanderson defending his refereeing of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, denying any collusion or bribery in his decision to award the bout to Sharkey on a foul. Testimony from Sharkey, Fitzsimmons' manager, and other witnesses conflicted throughout the day's proceedings.

New York Journal · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ceedings before Judge Sanderson, of the Superior Court.

The entire day was devoted to one set of fighters, seconds, managers and bottle holders, contradicting the others, so the testimony of Mr. Earp was not out of line with that given by other witnesses.

See moreSee less

Tom Sharkey, able seaman, prize fighter and aspiring champion, was on the stand most of the forenoon. He denied flatly the story told by his trainer, Smith, that Earp had been paid or promised $2,500 to give him the fight on a foul.

Several well-known sporting men, including William Greer Harrison, called for Fitzsimmons, made good witnesses for Sharkey's side. They all testified that the decision of the referee, whether it were right or wrong, was final, and that in a sporting sense there was no appeal from it.

Wyatt Earp was on the stand most of the afternoon. He swore that there had been no collusion between himself, Lynch, Sharkey, the National Club nor any other person as to the decision. Earp then described the eighth round. He told of the foul as he saw it, and then said:

"I announced that Sharkey had won on a foul." Earp said he did not have a nickel bet on the fight, that the decision he gave was as he saw it and that he would make the same ruling to-morrow and the next day and so on until the end if he were placed in the same position.

The rest of the testimony will be taken before a commissioner designated by Judge Sanderson. General Barnes, Sharkey's attorney, will move on Thursday to dissolve the injunction on the ground that the glove contest or prize fight was a violation of the laws of California, and that, therefore, Fitzsimmons has no standing in court.

Will Not Be Hanged To-day.

Elmer Clawson was to have been hanged at Somerville, N. J., to-day for the murder of Harry Hegetts. Sheriff Wyckoff yesterday received an order from Chancellor McGill to stay the execution for an indefinite period. The case is now pending before the Court of Errors and Appeals.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The sailor Sharkey testified he never conspired with Lynch and described being fouled by Fitzsimmons before Referee Wyatt Earp gave his own account of the deciding blow. Earp denied all charges of misconduct, insisted he would repeat the same decision, and was questioned about carrying a revolver.

The Morning News · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY PUT ON THE STAND

"Did you have any agreement with Earp or any one else to get an unfair decision?"

"No, sir."

See moreSee less

Referee Earp also testified, denying all the charges brought against him by the Fitzsimmons party.

Earp's description of the eighth round was in his own language as follows: "Fitz drove Sharkey to his corner and struck him a blow on the breast. Sharkey came again and Fitz tried to upper cut him, and struck him on the groin. As he went back he upper cut him on the chin. He did not fall backwards, but went down on his knees and placed his hands on the place he was hit. Needam came up and asked if I saw the foul, and I said: 'That's all right; I see it.' I walked over and gave my decision. I decided that Mr. Sharkey had won on a foul."

Earp said he would give the same decision again every night and knew the foul had been struck.

There was an exciting scene when Earp was asked if he had said what Julian had testified to.

Earp excitedly denounced Julian's statements as a tissue of falsehoods, and repeated this.

Judge Sanderson cautioned him to answer the questions.

Earp was asked if he had a revolver on him, and in reply offered to be searched by a deputy sheriff.

At the conclusion of Earp's examination the court adjourned.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 3 other papers

Witnesses testified in San Francisco regarding allegations of a conspiracy in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, including claims a doctor was paid to fake foul evidence. Sharkey denied conspiracy knowledge, denied talking to referee Wyatt Earp, and insisted Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin.

The Indianapolis Journal · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Says He Never Heard of a Conspiracy to Rob Fitzsimmons.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 15.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses to-day gave no sensational testimony, but "Fitz's" friends say they are now able to prove a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of an apparent foul, and that he was paid $1,000 for the service. Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denied all knowledge of a conspiracy, said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National Club, and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000. On cross-examination by Fitzsimmon's counsel Lynch was asked if he had ever been prohibited from racing at the local tracks, and why. An objection from Sharkey's attorney saved the witness the possible embarrassment of replying. A sporting reporter said he witnessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Fitz.

See moreSee less

Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the fight, had no talk with Earp and bet no money on the fight. He declared "Fitz" struck him a foul blow in the groin. When asked why he screamed as if in pain when he was with Dr. Lee in the dressing room after the fight, Sharkey said that Lee had pressed his groin hard during the examination after Fitzsimmons's blow and that the pressure caused him great agony. He stated that he still suffered pain from his injuries in the groin. Several amateur sportsmen testified that the recent meeting was not a prize fight, but a glove contest, so that the court could take cognizance of the present action.

Awarded to Burns.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · 16 December 1896
  • The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 16 December 1896
  • Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del. · 17 December 1896

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · and 1 other paper

Testimony in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey court case covers claims that a doctor was paid to fake evidence of a foul on Sharkey. Referee Wyatt Earp is mentioned as having no financial interest in a disputed $10,000 check, and witnesses dispute whether a foul blow actually occurred.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY CASE IN COURT

Sailor Lad Testifies as to the Nature of His Injuries.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 15.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses today gave no sensational testimony but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove that a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of an apparent foul, and that he was paid $1,00 for doctor's services. Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denied all knowledge of a conspiracy, said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National club and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000. On cross examination by Fitzsimmons' counsel, Lynch was asked if he had ever been prohibited from racing at the local tracks, and why. An objection from Sharkey's attorney saved the witness the possible embarrassment of replying.

Benjamin, a sporting reporter, witnessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Great Falls Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont. · 18 December 1896

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

During the Fitzsimmons suit trial, Sharkey denied being crooked and claimed Fitzsimmons struck him in the groin in the eighth round. Referee Wyatt Earp testified he witnessed Fitzsimmons strike the foul blow.

The Portland Daily Press · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey testified in his own behalf Tuesday in the Fitzsimmons suit. He denied the charge of crookedness. He also asserted that Fitz struck him in the groin in the eighth round. Referee Earp testified that he saw Fitz strike Sharkey in the groin.

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Witnesses testified in San Francisco regarding claims that Sharkey faked foul-blow injuries via a paid medical operation, with Fitzsimmons' camp alleging a conspiracy. Sharkey denied the conspiracy, denied talking to referee Earp or betting on the fight, and insisted Fitzsimmons struck him a genuine foul blow.

The Saint Paul Globe · 16 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

HIS INJURIES ARE ARTIFICIAL

SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., Dec. 15.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses today gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove that a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of an apparent foul, and that he was paid one thousand dollars for his services. Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denies all knowledge of a conspiracy, and said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National club and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000. Benjamin, a sporting reporter, witnessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

See moreSee less

Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the fight, had no talk with Earp and bet no money on the fight. He declared Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin. When asked why he screamed as if in pain when he was with Dr. Lee in the dressing room after the fight, Sharkey said that Lee had pressed his groin hard during the examination after Fitzsimmons' blow, and that pressure caused him great agony. He stated that he still suffered pain from his injuries in the groin.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · and 2 other papers

A weekly news summary reports that two of boxer Tom Sharkey's trainers testified in court that referee Wyatt Earp had been "fixed" in connection with a controversial prizefight. This stems from the December 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout where Earp's refereeing decision was disputed.

Mower County Transcript · 16 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

It is again said that England, Russia and France will settle the Eastern question.

Two of Sharkey's trainers testified in court that Referee Earp had been "fixed."

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · 18 December 1896
  • The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · 19 December 1896

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

Testimony in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight dispute included denials of a conspiracy to fake a foul injury, with Sharkey's manager confirming referee Wyatt Earp had no financial stake in the prize money. Sharkey testified he was fouled by Fitzsimmons, while witnesses and a sporting reporter disputed this account.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 16 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

PUGILIST SHARKEY

Denies All Stories of His Trainers as to the Injury Received In His Groin.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec. 16.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses yesterday gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove that a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of apparent foul, and that he was paid $1000 for the service.

Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denied all knowledge of a conspiracy; said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National club and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000. On cross-examination by Fitzsimmons' counsel, Lynch was asked, if he had ever been prohibited from racing at the local track, and why. An objection from Sharkey's attorney saved the witness the possible embarrassment of a reply.

A sporting reporter said he witnessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Tom Sharkey testified under oath denying any financial dealings with the National A.C. or advance arrangements regarding referee Wyatt Earp, and gave his account of how Fitzsimmons' low blow ended the fight. His trainer Danny Needham followed with a general denial of earlier testimony alleging suspicious circumstances.

The Sun · 16 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY AS A WITNESS.

Sharkey denied having any interest whatever in the National A. C., or that he had advanced that organization $2,500 or any other sum. The first he heard of Earp was when he saw his name in the papers before he went to Sausalito to see Fitzsimmons. He did not tell Smith that if he (Sharkey) could get Earp for referee he would be all right, or that there would be good money in it for the right referee. Nor did he ever state that he would refuse to agree to any referee in advance, and the club would then name any man he would suggest.

See moreSee less

The sailor was positive that he had never talked to Lynch or anybody else about Earp. He went into the ring with no thought but to win a fair fight. Earp asked him to remove the bandages from his hands, but he did not say it would be all

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report covers testimony from multiple witnesses at a hearing into the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, including Sharkey's trainer and boxing officials disputing claims of a foul. Referee Wyatt Earp testifies about his role and describes the eighth round in which he ruled Fitzsimmons had fouled Sharkey.

The Sun · 16 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY AS A WITNESS.

"No, sir, I put my hands on my groin from the pain."

"Are you still suffering from your injury?"

See moreSee less

"I am."

"Did you ever enter into any agreement with Lynch to do anything to get the fight, or had you anything to do with the selection of a referee?"

"I never did. Lynch had the referee in his hands."

Sharkey was then subjected to a cross-examination by Kowalsky.

"Did you ever send Billy Madden to Fitzsimmons's headquarters to offer Fitzsimmons $500 to let Madden referee the fight?"

"I did not."

"How long did Dr. Lee work on you?"

"He stayed until morning."

"Tell what Lee did."

"After he had examined me he got hot cloths and put them on me. Then he bandaged me."

"Did he use a hypodermic syringe or use a knife to make a puncture?"

"He did not."

Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, was the next witness. His story was a general denial of what Smith and Allen had said about the referee and about the suspicious circumstances in the dressing room and in Sharkey's room in the hotel.

William Greer Harrison explained the difference between a prize fight and a glove contest. He saw the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons contest and saw no foul.

L. R. Fulda, formerly President of the California A. C., agreed with Harrison as to the distinction between a glove contest and a prize fight. He was not at the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons contest. He said the referee's decision was final.

Walter Watson, boxing instructor of the Olympic Club, said he was looking at the eighth round and did not see a foul blow.

Referee Wyatt Earp was then called. He testified that he was in the Baldwin Hotel about 1 o'clock on the afternoon of the fight, when he was first asked to referee the contest by Groom, Gibbs, and some one else. He did not know Lynch except to speak to him, and had not spoken to him half a dozen times in his life.

As to the bandages on Sharkey's hands, Earp said he told Sharkey to take them off on a second protest from Julian. Earp's description of the eighth round was in his own language as follows:

"Fitzsimmons drove Sharkey to his corner and struck him a blow on the breast. Sharkey came again and Fitzsimmons tried to uppercut him, and struck him in the groin. As he went back he uppercut him on the chin. He did not fall backwards, but went down on his knees and placed his hands on the place he was hit. Needham came up and asked if I saw the foul, and I said: 'That's all right; I see it.' I walked over and gave my decision. I decided that Mr. Sharkey had won on a foul."

There was an exciting scene when Earp was asked if he had said what Julian had testified to. Earp excitedly denounced Julian's statements as a tissue of falsehoods and repeated this.

Judge Sanderson cautioned him to answer the questions.

Earp was asked if he had a revolver on him, and in reply offered to be searched by a deputy Sheriff. The court then adjourned.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

In San Francisco court, Thomas Sharkey testified he had no financial interest in the National Athletic Club and denied any agreement to fix the referee selection or secure an unfair decision in his fight with Fitzsimmons. Referee Wyatt Earp was then called to testify about his whereabouts before the fight.

The Scranton Tribune · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FIGHTING IN COURT.

Before Judge Sanderson—Testimony of Participants.

San Francisco, Dec. 15.—Thomas Sharkey testified in his own behalf today in Fitzsimmons suit for possession of the $10,000 check.

See moreSee less

Sharkey denied having any interest whatever in the National Athletic club or that he had advanced that organization $2,500 or any other sum. The sailor was positive he had never talked to Lynch or anybody else about Earp. He went into the ring with no thought but to win a fair fight.

"Did you ever enter into any agree-

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

Referee Wyatt Earp testified in court about his decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, describing the eighth round and defending his ruling that Sharkey won on a foul. Earp angrily denied allegations from Julian and even offered to be searched for a weapon after being asked if he was armed.

The Scranton Tribune · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Spain Tries to Explain. Day with National Lawmakers. Fitzsimmons-Sharkey Fight in Court.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Witnesses testified in the inquiry into the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with claims that a doctor was paid to fake evidence of a foul on Sharkey. Sharkey denied conspiracy knowledge and insisted he was fouled, while questions arose about referee Wyatt Earp's financial interest in the fight's proceeds.

The Providence News · 16 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

MORE TESTIMONY TAKEN.

The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses at San Francisco yesterday gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmon's friends say they now are able to prove that a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of apparent foul, and that he was paid $1,000 for the service

See moreSee less

Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denied all knowledge of a conspiracy, and said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National Club, and denied that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000.

On cross-examination by Fitzsimmons's counsel Lynch was asked if he had ever been prohibited from racing at the local track, and why. An objection by Sharkey's attorney saved the witness the possible embarrassment of reply.

A sporting reporter said he witnessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons. Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith, and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the fight.

He declared Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin. When asked why he screamed as if in pain, when he was with Dr. Lee, in the dressing room, after the fight, Sharkey said that Lee had pressed his groin hard during the examination after Fitzsimmons's blow, and that the pressure caused great pain. He stated he still suffered pain from injuries in his groin..

Several amateur sporting men testified that the recent meeting was not a prize fight, but a glove contest, so that the court could take cognizance of the present action.

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The article describes Wyatt Earp as an old Dodge City gunfighter, one of three fighting brothers who later formed the 'Earp gang' in Arizona and feuded with a rival outfit, resulting in one brother's death and another's maiming. It credits him with killing thirteen men and recounts his later career as a boxing referee in California, prompted by his unpopular decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

El Paso Daily Herald · 16 December 1896 · page 2

AYER'S FILLS Promote Good Digestion. Referee AVyatt Eaip. Wyatt Karp who has miido the unpo pular decision in the Fit.simmons Sharkey prize fight, is an old Dodge Uity, Colo., man, of the days when Hat Masterson ran the town. There were then three brothers of them, all gun fiarhters, and all men peaceably inclin ed would walk over into another county to avoid them. After the decadence of Dodge City the brothers -.vent down into Arizona, where they became known as the "Earp gang, " and speed ily worked up a feud with a neighbor ing outfit.

See moreSee less

In the resulting fijjhi one Earp was killed, and Virgil had one hand shot off. The remaining brothers then went to California. Virgil is citv marshal of Colton, Cal. . a position that only a man of nerve can hold, and Wyatt has been known all over the state. While residing in southern California he frequently refereed fights along the Mexican line, on suppo-ed neutral territory. The favorite place was IiaJuana, just over the line. Lirp always made the men fight, too. There was no sprinting wh3n he was referee: the men must get out in the center and give and take. Wvatt is a man with a cool, clear head, which he never losses, ana his decisions heretofore have been considered as just and euuit able. Earp is well known all over Colorado, and is said to have lived at balida. A few vears ago he was mixed up in a murder eaee. for which he stood trial. He is given credit with having killed thirteen men. Ex.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

At the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight controversy trial, referee Wyatt Earp testified about being asked to referee the bout and his limited acquaintance with promoter Lynch. Other witnesses, including boxing officials and a newspaper reporter, also testified about the circumstances of the fight and allegations of an unfair decision.

The Salt Lake Herald · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

room in the hotel. William Greer Harrison explained the difference between a prize fight and a glove contest. The former, he said, was a brutal contest, while the latter was altogether a matter of skill, uplifting in its nature, while prize fights were debasing. Usually the glove contect was for a limited number of rounds, while the prize fight was to a finish. He said a knock-out did not hurt a man, as he knew that from having been knocked out three times in half an hour by Jim Corbett. Harrison saw the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons contest and saw no foul. L. S. Fulda, formerly president of

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

In court testimony, Sharkey described being struck in the groin by Fitzsimmons and denied any prearranged agreement with Earp to fix the fight's outcome. Earp testified about his version of the foul and his decision, and angrily denied Julian's accusations against him, prompting a judicial caution.

The Times · 16 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY AND EARP TESTIFY

this. Judge Sanderson cautioned him to answer him the questions. Earp was asked if he had a revolver on him, and in reply offered to be seached by a deputy sheriff. At the conclusion of Earp's examination the court adjourned.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Earp testified in court denying any agreement to fix the fight's outcome, describing in detail how Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey with a low blow in the eighth round. He defended his referee decision awarding the fight to Sharkey on a foul, stating he would make the same call again.

Richmond Dispatch · 16 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"When he struck you in the groin, he injured you in the way claimed?"

"Yes, sir."

See moreSee less

"Then what happened?"

"As I was falling he hit me on the jaw."

"Were you insensible?"

"No, sir. I put my hands to my groin from the pain."

"Was your pain little or great?"

"It was great."

"Are you still suffering from your injury?"

"I am."

"Did you ever enter into any agreement with Lynch to do anything to get the fight, or had you anything to do with the selection of a referee?"

"I never did. Lynch had the referee in his hands."

"Did you have any agreement with Earp or any one else to get an unfair decision?"

"No, sir."

Earp also testified, denying all of the charges brought against him by the Fitzsimmons party. Earp's description of the eighth round of the fight was, in his own language, as follows:

"Fitzsimmons drove Sharkey to his corner, and struck him a blow on the breast. Sharkey came again, and Fitzsimmons tried to uppercut him, and struck him in the groin. As he went back he uppercut him on the chin. He did not fall backwards, but went down on to his knees, and placed his hands on the place he was hit. Needham came up, and asked if I saw the foul, and I said: 'That's all right. I see it.' I walked over and gave my decision. I decided that Mr. Sharkey had won on a foul."

Earp said he would give the same decision again, and every night, and knew the foul had been struck. There was an exciting scene when Earp was asked if he had said what Julian had testified to. Earp excitedly denounced Julian's testimony as a tissue of falsehoods, and repeated this. Judge Sanderson cautioned him to answer the questions.

Earp was asked if he had a revolver on him, and in reply offered to be searched by a deputy sheriff.

At the conclusion of Earp's examination, the court adjourned.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

In San Francisco court, Fitzsimmons and Sharkey gave conflicting testimony about the foul that ended their fight, with Sharkey denying any conspiracy against Fitzsimmons. Referee Wyatt Earp testified he had no connection to any alleged crookedness and had awarded the fight to Sharkey because he was deliberately fouled, denying all allegations from the Fitzsimmons camp.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 16 December 1896 · page 2

FIGHTING IT OI T IJS COURT. Wymtt Earp. the Referee, and Fit* and Sksrker TestifySAN" FRANCISCO, Dec. 1-".—Sharkey and Fltieimmons had another round today in court. During the Jay the two princi pals gave their testimony as to their ver sion of the affair. The Cornishman stated that he had a premonition as to the Ulti mate result of the fight and was, in conse quence, careful as to how he fought. not wishing to give the referee any chance to claim a foul against him. Sharkey testified that everything aworp to by his former trainers was false and that he was m no way connected with any such scheme to rob Fltzsimmons.

See moreSee less

He said that he was deliberately fouled during the fight and that he sustained severe Injuries. Wy*tt Earp, the referee, took the stand and testified that he had noi'hi* to do with any alluded crookedness, ana that he ha i awarded the fight to Sharkey because the sailor had been deliberately fouled by *hla opponent. He said that he had not spoken five words to Sharkey's manager, and absolutely den-led all the allegation® •rhat have emanated from the Fi;s.-il;n mons camp. He referred to Marin Juimn'a statement as a tis.-rue of false hoods. The Evening Post today hauled Earp over the in an unmerciful manner, and referred to the decision as a disgrace ful criminal "Dr." T/ee to have artenvpted to bribe a reputable physleian.

See the clipping

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

The item reports that Pima County court records still show an 1882 grand jury indictment for murder against Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp, Warren Earp, Sherman McMaster, and John Johnson in the killing of Frank Stilwell in Tucson. It notes the charge was never tried because the men were outlawed and never caught, and calls this newly interesting given Wyatt Earp's recent appearance at the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.

Arizona Silver Belt · 17 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ters and John Johnson, charging them with the murder of Frank Stillwell in Tucson, March 20, 1882. This indictment was found and presented to the court March 25, 1882. After the finding of the indictment the parties were outlawed for several months and were never taken. Most of the parties are now dead, but the fact of Wyatt Earp's appearance in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight makes the fact one of interest

An English Opinion

See moreSee less

Speaking of Arizona's bilities the Mining Jour[nal] in London says:

"Owing principally t[o] remoteness, the great mi[nes] of the territory have [re]ceived that attention fro[m] ital which they fully just[ify].

"The one great need [of]

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A brief item notes that Wyatt Earp swears he did not write a piece attributed to him in the Examiner, calling it another fake. The item appears as a short aside among other miscellaneous news notes in the Call's opinion column.

The San Francisco Call · 17 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

The Examiner may now have a decent spell for a little while, but don't count on it.

Wyatt Earp swears he did not write that thing for the Examiner, so there you have another fake.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This is a miscellaneous editorial roundup mocking various public figures and political matters of the day, with a brief sarcastic remark suggesting Wyatt Earp should write a gossip column called 'Prattle'. The reference is incidental and not a substantive news report about Earp himself.

The San Francisco Call · 17 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Long Green Lawrence should set Wyatt Earp to write "Prattle" and Ambrose Bierce to refereeing prize-fights. The public demands a change.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A San Francisco judge is reportedly gathering evidence to present to a grand jury seeking indictments against Sharkey, Fitzsimmons, Lynch, Groom, Earp, and the seconds for violating a state law against prize fighting. The principals claim no fear of prosecution, noting the Board of Supervisors who granted the fight license would be equally liable.

The Record-Union · 17 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

FITZSIMMONS-SHARKEY FIGHT.

The Principals and Their Backers Likely to be Arrested.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 16.—The referee to whom Judge Sanderson has relinquished the task of taking further depositions in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey case decided this morning not to begin his labors until to-morrow morning, when it is expected this part of the case will be completed.

There is a possibility that further arrests will soon be made as one of the results of the recent battle. There is a State law prohibiting any prize fight or encounter with or without gloves where the participants are liable to injury. Yesterday afternoon Judge Sanderson asked many questions as to the nature of the contest, and several experts testified on the subject. The questions appeared harmless enough, but it is asserted to-day that his honor was gathering evidence to place before the Grand Jury, in order to secure the indictment of Sharkey, Fitzsimmons, Lynch, Groom, Earp and the seconds. The principals, however, claim to have no fears, and say the Board of Supervisors who granted the license are as liable to prosecution as they are.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A practical joke unfolds at a hotel where baseball player Dowd is convinced to pose as prizefighter Sharkey, drawing a crowd of curious onlookers including reporters. During the prank, one bystander jokingly compares Billy Joyce's appearance to Wyatt Earp without his mustache, accusing him of being a gambler type, referencing Earp's reputation from the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight controversy.

Evening Star · 17 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Dowd what he had done.

The ball player laughed and determined to carry it through. He was quickly surrounded by a score of men who eyed him in wonder. Charley Field, the night clerk at the hotel, finally bolstered up enough courage to ask "Sharkey" how Fitzsimmons fouled him.

See moreSee less

"Foul me? Why, man, alive, he fouled me worse than all the chickens in the country." Then he gave them a detailed account of how the battle was fought and a realistic exposition of the foul, using Mr. Field as a lay figure to illustrate the matter. For all of which Mr. Field felt highly honored.

The crowd was reinforced by all the night hawks around the hotel. Every sleeper in the baths was awakened to get a look at Sharkey. They pressed around him, felt of his muscle and criticised him in audible voices. The questions were innumerable. They wanted to know this and that, to all of which Sharkey made answer in gruff tones.

One gentleman insisted that Billy Joyce was Referee Earp without his mustache, and openly charged him with collusion with Sharkey and robbing Fitzsimmons, who, he declared, was the better man

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A satirical anecdote describes reporters and fans in St. Louis so eager to see boxer Sharkey that they mistake baseball manager Tommy Dowd for him. A passing remark accuses referee Wyatt Earp of colluding with Sharkey against Fitzsimmons in their recent fight.

Evening Star · 17 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

tones.

One gentlemen insisted that Billy Joyce was Referee Earp without his mustache; and openly charged him with collusion with Sharkey and robbing Fitzsimmons, who, he declared, was the better man. "Look at him," he appealed, referring to Joyce, "and if he does not look like a border ruffian and a gambler I will treat the crowd."

See moreSee less

By this time the news had percolated to the newspaper offices. Two reporters rushed into the hotel and asked for the fighter. They were referred to the baths.

When they drifted in they saw the crowd of which Dowd was the center and cynosure. Rightly concluding that Sharkey was the topic of discussion, they walked up.

"Say, Tommy," said the leader, "I hear that Sharkey is here. Do you know anything of him?"

The crowd smiled. "You're a nice sporting man," said one of them. "Don't you know that you are talking to Mr. Sharkey now? Why, I thought you were so wise that you would know a fighter when you saw his shirt." Then, getting sorry for the green reporter, he said to Dowd: "Shake hands with him, Mr. Sharkey."

The reporter was in a hurry. "Oh, I'm not kidding," he said impatiently. "I want to see Sharkey if he is here. I can see Tommy Dowd every day in the week. The manager of a bum base ball team is no great curiosity in St. Louis."

Dowd and Joyce winked furiously, but the game was spoiled.

"Do you mean to say that this is not Sharkey," asked one of the hero worshipers.

"Sharkey, nothing," said the irritated scribe; "that is Tommy Dowd, the manager of the bummest base ball team on earth. Now, show me Sharkey."

The ball players dropped their bluff and the laugh was theirs. The waiter was kept busy for two hours and at the end of that time one of the suckers had wind and sense enough left to say:

"Sharkey! Well, I'm blowed. I wouldn't care to be fooled by a good man, but to be taken in by the manager of the worst base ball team on earth is too much for me to stand."

The recent invention, Vimoid, a kit for repairing a puncture of a pneumatic tire instantly and permanently, has made the Vim tire virtually puncture-proof, in that it has enabled the rider to make his own repair on the road. You can use it on ordinary punctures; if you get a bad puncture or a cut, take it to 511 9th street.—Advt.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 2 other papers

A referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing case is gathering testimony that may lead to grand jury indictments under a state law banning prize fights. Wyatt Earp, who served as referee for the bout, is named among those facing possible prosecution along with the fighters and seconds.

The Morning News · 17 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

NEW PERIL FOR PUGILISTS.

Arrest For Violating a State Law Hanging Over Them.

San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 16.—The referee to whom Judge Sanderson has relinquished the task of taking further depositions in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey case, decided this morning not to begin his labors till to-morrow, when it is expected this part of the case will be completed.

See moreSee less

There is a possibility that wholesale arrests will soon be made as one of the results of the recent battle. There is a state law prohibiting any prize fight or encounter with or without gloves, where the participants are liable to injury. Yesterday afternoon Judge Sanderson asked many questions as to the nature of the contest and several experts testified on the subject. The questions appeared harmless enough, but it is asserted to-day that his honor was gathering evidence to place before the grand jury in order to secure the indictment of Sharkey, Fitzsimmons, Lynch, Julian, Groom, Gibbs, Earp and the seconds. Those in peril of prosecution, however, profess to have no fear, and say the members of the board of supervisors, who granted a license for the contest, are as liable to prosecution as they.

Billy Smith has sued Thomas Sharkey for $900, which he claims is due him for services rendered in assisting to train the sailor for his recent battle with Fitzsimmons. Smith asserts that his services were worth $1,000, but that Sharkey had only paid him $100.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 17 December 1896
  • Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 17 December 1896

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

A witness named Australian Billy Smith testified in San Francisco courts that the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight was rigged, with Sharkey to win by a first-round foul. He claimed referee Earp was paid $2,500 by Lynch for his role in the arrangement.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 17 December 1896 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

"Australian Billy Smith" testified in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey case in the San Francisco courts that it was arranged that Sharkey should be declared winner on a foul in the first round in the recent fight, and that

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill. · and 2 other papers

In San Francisco court proceedings over the disputed $10,000 purse, Julian testified that Wyatt Earp had been "fixed" before refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, citing overheard conversations implicating Earp. Dr. Lustig also testified that Sharkey's groin injury was superficial and possibly self-inflicted.

Canton Weekly Register · 17 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

JULIAN GOES ON THE STAND.

Testifies to the Alleged Plot to Rob Fitzsimmons—Dr. Lustig's Statement.

San Francisco, Dec. 15.—Tom Sharkey, looking little the worse for his drubbing, was in court yesterday when the controversy for the possession of the $10,000 purse was renewed. Fitzsimmons and Julian attempted to expose the alleged conspiracy against Fitzsimmons, but when Julian was asked for positive personal knowledge he could not give it. He was not a party to the alleged plot. Julian related his efforts to have Lynch join him in selecting a referee, stating that Lynch purposly placed the choice of a referee in the hands of the National club, which named Earp. Julian said Police Commissioner Gunst and Riley Grannan had come to him before the fight to tell him "Earp had been fixed." He quoted Riley Grannan as having overheard a conversation between Earp and Joe Harvey, a bookmaker, in the course of which Harvey said: "Then its all right, is it?" to which Earp had replied: "You can depend on me."

See moreSee less

Fitzsimmons denied that he had struck any foul blow, and corroborated Julian.

Dr. D. D. Lustig's testimony was not much relished by Sharkey. He said he was the medical examiner of the National club, and had examined Sharkey before the fight. After Sharkey had been taken to his room Lustig, with four other doctors, hearing Sharkey had been hurt, offered their services, but they were refused admittance to Sharkey's dressing room. On the following afternoon Dr. Lustig and five other physicians examined Sharkey's injuries in the groin, and witness pronounced the injury superficial. He said it was insignificant, not disabling or producing much pain. The injuries to the groin might have been caused by artificial means, such as the injection of acidulated water.

Dan Hickey, one of Fitzsimmons' seconds; W. W. Naughton, a sporting reporter, and others present at the fight all testified that they had seen no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

Sequel to the Wisconsin Floods.

Marshfield, Dec. 15.—Several farmers

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · 15 December 1896
  • The Citizen · Chicago, Ill. · 19 December 1896

The Sauk Centre Herald · Sauk Centre, Minn. · and 1 other paper

Testimony in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight inquiry included denials of a conspiracy by Sharkey's manager Danny Lynch, who said referee Wyatt Earp had no financial stake in a $10,000 check. Sharkey himself denied knowing of any conspiracy, denied betting on the fight, and claimed Fitzsimmons had fouled him.

The Sauk Centre Herald · 17 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY ON THE STAND. Denies the Story of an Alleged Conspiracy.

San Francisco. Dec. 16.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses gave no sensational testimony at the day's session. Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, denied all knowledge of a conspiracy; said that neither he nor Sharkey was a member of the National club and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for $10,000.

See moreSee less

Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the fight, had no talk with Earp and had no money on the fight. He declared Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin and that he still suffered pain from his injuries.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · 18 December 1896

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

In a San Francisco courtroom, Sharkey's trainer Billy Smith testified that fight organizers bribed referee Wyatt Earp to award Sharkey the win on a foul claim. Smith claimed Earp was to receive $2,500 for fixing the outcome against Fitzsimmons.

The Worthington Advance · 17 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

IT WAS "FIXED."

Sharkey's Trainer Confesses Conspiracy Against Fitzsimmons.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec. 10.—A large assemblage of ring followers and men about town crowded Judge Sanderson's courtroom Wednesday morning in ex-

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

At a San Francisco court hearing, Sharkey's trainer Billy Smith testified that promoters had arranged beforehand for referee Wyatt Earp to award the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim. Smith named Sharkey, his manager, and club officials as conspirators who allegedly paid Earp $2,500 to fix the outcome.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Warren Sheaf · 17 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Sharkey's Trainer Confesses Conspiracy Against Fitzsimmons. San Francisco, Dec. 10.—A large assemblage of ring followers and men about town crowded Judge Sanderson's courtroom Wednesday morning in expectation of hearing sensational developments regarding the manner in which the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight was "fixed" and they were not disappointed. If credence is to be placed in the story told on the witness stand by "Australian" Billy Smith, Sharkey's trainer, Fitzsimmons was a defeated man before he left New York. According to Smith's testimony, J. J. Groom, J. H. Gibbs, Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, and Sharkey himself, were the men who composed the National Athletic club, before which organization the now notorious contest was fought.

See moreSee less

These four men, Smith swears, engaged Wyatt Earp as referee, with the understanding that he was to award Sharkey the fight directly Fitzsimmons landed a body blow or stomach punch which might be stretched into a foul. Earp was to receive $2,500 for his services.

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

At a San Francisco hearing before Judge Sanderson, a witness named Smith testified that fight promoters engaged Wyatt Earp as referee with a prior understanding he would award the fight to Sharkey via a foul call. Earp was allegedly promised $2,500 for his role in fixing the contest.

The Sioux County Journal · 17 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

excitement. Mr. Albertini held the opinion that as the Spanish could no longer conceal the fact that Maceo had defeated the Spanish commander, Corujeda, with great loss of life, and had successfully crossed the trocha, they had put out the rumors of Maceo's and young Gomez's death to offset the effect of Corujeda's official report of his defeat, and also to head off, is possible, any action by congress in the way o' Cuban recognition.

Expose a Prize Fight Plot.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec, 10.—A large crowd of ring followers crowded Judge Sanderson's court room yesterday morning in expectation of hearing sensational developments regarding the manner in which the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight was "fixed." If credence is to be placed in the story told on the witness stand Fitzsimmons was a defeated man before he left New York. According to Smith's testimony, J. J. Groom, J. H.

See the clipping

The Pioche Weekly Record · Pioche, Nev.

A court investigation into the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match reveals it was prearranged for Sharkey to win, with Earp chosen as referee because he could be "fixed." When Sharkey was knocked out in the eighth round, Earp declared Fitzsimmons guilty of a foul, and Sharkey's alleged injuries were reportedly staged afterward.

The Pioche Weekly Record · 17 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The court investigation of the Fitzimmons Sharkey fight discloses a dirty effort at outright robbery. The proposition of having Sharkey win out was arranged beforehand, and the Sharkey side would not have for referee, any man who could not be "fixed" Earp was so fixed that when Sharkey was knocked out in the eighth, and was told by one of his seconds to lie still and groan, that he declared Fitzimmon guilty of a foul. Sharkey appears to have been taken to his room practically unhurt, all physicians for a time excluded, and there by injections, swelling in the groin and the alleged injury were created. Sharkey and his backers were strap

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

Testimony continues in the San Francisco trial over the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with Sharkey's manager denying any conspiracy and denying that referee Wyatt Earp had financial interest in a $10,000 check. Sharkey testified he was fouled and denied talking to Earp or betting on the fight.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 17 December 1896 · page 1

FITZSIMMONS-SHARKEY SUIT TO TRIAL

FITZ-SIIARKRY TTTT?ST0 TRIAT Snn Francisco. Dec. 15. The Kitzxiitimons-hharkey witnesses gave no sensa tional testimony today, but 1 ilzs nininns' friends say thev are now nble in nrnvn that a doctor performed nu operation on onarKey 10 produce evidence ot foul. JJan Liynch. hliarkev s mannirer. de nied all knowicdee of a consniraev: snid that neither he nor Sharkey was a niemner or tne national club and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary in terest in tho check for $10,000. On cross examination by Fitzsiminons coun sel Lynch was asked if he had ever been prohibited from racing at local tracks, and why.

See moreSee less

An objection from Sharkey's attorney saved the witness the possible emnnrrassment ot replying. i nomas wnarKey s testimony was simply a denial of the stories by his train ers, Billy Smith and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the tight; had no taiK with isarp and bet no money on tho fight. He declared Fitzsunmons struck him a foul blow in the groin. hen nsked why he screamed as ir in pain while in the dressing room after the hght, Sharkey said that Lee had nressed his groin hard durinir the ex amination after Fitzslmmons' blow and that the pressure caused him great ag ony. He stated that he still suffered Dam from his injuries in tne groin. Several sportsmen tcstined tnnr tne re cent meeting was not a prize bght but a glove contest, so that the court could take cognizance ot the present action.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

An ex-police chief in Hot Springs, Arkansas claims that in the winter of 1884-85 Wyatt Earp and a companion were caught trying to 'cold deck' a faro bank using cards bribed from a porter. He says Earp was arrested and ordered out of town, never to return.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 17 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

STRANGE STATUTE. Little Rock, Ark., Dec. 15.—A special to the Gazette from Hot Springs says: Ex-Chief of Police T. C. Toler says that during the winter of 1884-85 Wyatt Earp, who was referee in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fiasco, and a companion were caught in the act of attempting to "cold deck" a faro bank in this city for the purpose of defrauding the game. He had secured the cards from the gambling house by bribing a porter. He was arrested by Toler and ordered out of town next day, since which time he has never had been seen in Hot Springs.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A San Francisco report describes efforts to summon a jury regarding the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons prize fight, naming Sharkey, Fitzsimmons, Lynch, Julian, Gibbs, and Earp as involved parties. The piece also notes a separate lawsuit by Smith against Fitzsimmons over an unpaid sum.

Richmond Dispatch · 17 December 1896 · page 1

— ——— FITZSIMMONS-SHARKEY CASE, Possible Arrests ns nn Result of the Prize-Fieuht. SAN FRANCISCO, December 16.—~The referee to whom Judge Sanderson has re linquished the task of taking further depositions in the Fiwzsimmons-Sharkey case decided this morning not to begin his labors until to-morrow, when it is ex pected this part of the case will be com pleted, There is a possibility that whole sale arrests will soon be made as one of the results of the recent battle. There 18 a State law prohibiting any prize-ight, or encounter with or without gloves, where the participants are liable to Injury, Yes terday afternoon Judge Sanderson asked many questions as to the nature of the contest, and several experts testified on the subject.

See moreSee less

The questions appeared harmless enough, but it is asserted to day that his Honor was gathering evi dence to place before the grand jury in order to secure the indictment of Sharkey, Fitzsimmons, Lynch, Julian, Groom, Gibbs, Earp, and the seconds, Those 1n peril of prosecution, however, profess 10 have no fear, and say the members of the Board of Supervisors who granted a license for the contest are as liable to prosecution as they. Billy Smith has sued Thomas Sharkey for $600, which he claims is due him for services rendered in assisting to train the sailor for his recent battle with Fitz simmons. Smith asserts that his ser vices were worth $1,000, but that Sharkey has only paid him $100, stati ——

See the clipping

The Citizen · Frederick City, Md. · and 1 other paper

Sailor Tom Sharkey testified in San Francisco in Fitzsimmons' suit over a disputed $10,000 check, denying any financial ties to the National Athletic Club or prior contact with Wyatt Earp. He maintained the blow that knocked him out was a foul.

The Citizen · 18 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey's Denial. San Francisco, Dec. 16.—Thomas Sharkey testified in his own behalf in Fitzsimmons' suit for possession of that $10,00 check, and his denials of the charges of crookedness were prompt and vigorous. Sharkey denied having any interest whatever in the National Athletic club, or that he had advanced that organization $2,500 or any other sum. The first he saw of Earp was when he saw his name in the papers before he went to Sausalito to see Fitzsimmons. The sailor was positive he had never talked to Lynch or anybody else about Earp. He went into the ring with no thought but to win a fair fight. He still insists that the knock-out blow he received was a foul.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 16 December 1896

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Judge Sanderson ruled that Fitzsimmons, Sharkey, Wyatt Earp, and others connected with the glove contest violated the law against prize-fighting and could face indictment. He dissolved the injunction and dismissed Fitzsimmons' complaint against Sharkey, refusing to adjudicate the purse dispute.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Officers May Be Taken Before the Grand Jury.

Judge Sanderson yesterday morning decided that Fitzsimmons, Sharkey, Wyatt Earp (who is the bodyguard of "Long Green" Lawrence), the directors of the National Athletic Club, H. I. Kowalsky, General Barnes and all others connected with or present at the $10,000 "glove contest" had violated the statute prohibiting prize-fighting and were amenable to indictment.

See moreSee less

The court, therefore, could not interfere in the squabble over the purse. So the injunction was dissolved, and the complaint of Fitzsimmons against Sharkey was dismissed.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A judge rules that boxing contests are illegal and dissolves an injunction related to the disputed Sharkey-Fitzsimmons purse, striking the complaint from the files. Fitzsimmons publishes a statement claiming referee Wyatt Earp's decision robbed him of $10,000 through fraud, while noting Corbett has signed to fight him instead.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

DAN MILLER IN THE JOB.

Wyatt Earp's Bosom Friend Falls in With "Long Green" Lawrence.

Robert Fitzsimmons is not crestfallen. The news that J. J. Corbett has signed with Dan A. Stuart to fight him to a finish on March 17 next has reached him, and he declares that it fully compensates for the wrongful decision "Long Green" Lawrence's man Earp gave, and which robbed him of $10,000. Fitzsimmons will leave here in a few days, but he requests

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Attorneys Kowalsky and Julian announce they will pursue criminal charges over an alleged conspiracy to fix the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, claiming Wyatt Earp was deliberately maneuvered into the referee position. They allege Earp's friend Danny Miller and gambler 'Long Green' Lawrence orchestrated his selection to ensure a favorable outcome for Sharkey.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

DAN MILLER IN THE JOB

that I have made during my stay in San Francisco. Yours sincerely.

BOB FITZSIMMONS.

See moreSee less

Colonel Kowalsky and Martin Julian stated last night that the decision of Judge Sanderson ended the matter with them so far as the civil proceedings went, but that they would prosecute criminally some of the people who engaged in the Sharkey-"Long Green" conspiracy to steal $10,000.

"We have evidence to prove that Wyatt Earp was first selected by Danny Miller, his bosom friend, as the proper man to referee the fight," they said. "Miller is also Lynch's friend, and therefore Earp was acceptable to Lynch. All that was needed then was to get Gibbs of the National Athletic Club to propose Earp to have him accepted. Lynch refusing all other referees and the selection being in the hands of the club, all Gibbs required to put Earp in the position of referee was his indorsement by a newspaper.

"Long Green" Lawrence, whose bodyguard Wyatt Earp has been for some months, was anxious to see his gun-fighter in another position where he could do him the most good, and he readily notified Gibbs that Wyatt Earp and only Wyatt Earp must be selected.

The job was then all but consummated. The "foul" decision did the rest.

The numerous garnishments against the money which Judge Sanderson has allowed to Sharkey, keeps about $3000 of it in escrow. The remainder belongs to Sharkey, his trainer and General Barnes. Danny Lynch, who has manipulated the deal by which Sharkey got the money, testified in court that there was no portion of the coin coming to him.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A newspaper advice/trivia column responds to a reader's question about Wyatt Earp, stating that his father was never west of the Rocky Mountains. The item appears among many unrelated reader questions on topics like boxing reach measurements, coin values, and biblical ages.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS.

EARP'S FATHER—A Reader, City. It is stated that Wyatt Earp's father was never west of the Rocky Mountains.

See moreSee less

THE LONGEST REACH—Subscriber, City. The reach of Bob Fitzsimmons is 29 inches, that of

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The item reports that Danny Miller, a horseman and close friend of Wyatt Earp, allegedly worked with 'Long Green' Lawrence to secure Earp's appointment as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. This appears amid other brief city news items, including mention that the Civic Federation wants the fighters indicted by a Grand Jury.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

evening voted unanimously in favor of the proposed boulevard from Nineteenth avenue to Ocean View.

Mounted Policeman W. H. Hanley stopped a runaway team yesterday at Baker and Fulton streets, and turned away danger from many school children.

See moreSee less

The Civic Federation is likely to take vigorous action to have the prize-fighters, Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, and their seconds indicted by the Grand Jury.

The Supreme Court found the burial ordinance of the City and County of San Francisco invalid. The decision is of great importance to property-owners.

The Christian church will soon establish in

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A judge determined that the glove contest between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, refereed by Wyatt Earp, was legally a prize-fight, making participants indictable and spectators lawbreakers. The court dismissed the injunction and complaint over the purse dispute, citing lack of jurisdiction.

The San Francisco Call · 18 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Judge Sanderson yesterday decided that the glove contest in which Fitzsimmons and Sharkey took part was a prize-fight, and that the participants are indictable and the spectators lawbreakers. The court had no jurisdiction over the squabble for the purse, and dismissed the injunction and complaint.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Judge Sanderson ruled that glove contests and prize fights are legally the same, dissolving the injunction that blocked payment of the $10,000 purse to Sharkey. The decision stemmed from referee Wyatt Earp's disputed ruling against Fitzsimmons, who claimed a conspiracy had cost him the fight.

The Record-Union · 18 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

AS MIGHT HAVE BEEN EXPECTED

Had It Been Asked For.

SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 17.—Glove contests and prize fights are synonymous is the legal opinion of Judge Sanderson, and in consequence Thomas Sharkey will get the $10,000 that Fitzsimmons still believes rightfully belongs to him.

See moreSee less

When the matter came up this morning both sides announced that they had no more depositions to take, and General Barnes, Sharkey's attorney, moved to dissolve the injunction restraining the Anglo-Californian Bank from cashing the check given to Sharkey in accordance with the decision of Referee Earp. Barnes said the complaint was defective, as it did not state sufficient facts, and was on information and belief, stating rumors. It had been stated in court that there was a great difference between a prize fight and a glove contest. He read several decisions bearing on the point in support of his contention.

He argued that the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons affair was a pugilistic encounter for a purse of $10,000, to go to the winner. The magnitude of the reward seemed prodigious. Fitzsimmons claimed he had been "jobbed"; that there had been a conspiracy to defraud him out of the prize money, and to do so the conspirators arranged for a referee who should give the decision against him. Fitzsimmons claimed that in the eighth round he had so discom

See the clipping

The Mankato Free Press · Mankato, Minn.

At a San Francisco hearing, Sharkey's manager Danny Lynch denied any conspiracy and said referee Wyatt Earp had no financial interest in a disputed $10,000 check. Sharkey himself denied his trainers' conspiracy claims and insisted Fitzsimmons had fouled him.

The Mankato Free Press · 18 December 1896 · page 7

1.-. U.S slu, st«rv .11 Allege.l < •>»- -P r •< v. ISaN i’iUiCiSCv, 16. — Ihe El '- simmons-Sharkey -witnesses gave uu sensational testimony at the day’s ses sion. Danny Lynch, Sharkey’s man ager, denied all knowledge of a con spiracy ; said that neither he nor Shar key was a member of the National club amf declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary interest in the check for SIO,OOO. Thomas Sharkey’s testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George ALen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the tight, had no talk with Earp and had no money on the fight.

See moreSee less

He declared Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin and that he still suffered pain from his injuries.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report speculates on how the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight purse is being divided, suggesting referee Wyatt Earp received $2500 and implying he should kick back money to the man who arranged his appointment. It also notes the fighters and their entourages remain in town amid talk of a benefit for Fitzsimmons.

The San Francisco Call · 19 December 1896 · page 14 · transcribed from the page image

ECHOES OF THE LONG GREEN FIGHT

end may not be yet.

The garnishments which kept the purse in chancery amount to not more than $3000. This will leave $7000. According to the testimony of Trainer Billy Smith Earp is to receive $2500. Then it is to be presumed that General Barnes' fee will not be less than $1000 for his eloquent defense of public morals and his scathing denunciation of that brutal exhibition known as a prize-fight. He succeeded in convincing the court that his client, Sharkey, had committed a felony, and that he himself by attending the fight as a spectator, was a law-breaker. But he appeared at the fight as a private individual, whereas, in court he was in the role of a lawyer, supporting and urging the enforcement of the law. That was easily worth $1000. It was reported that Manager Lynch was to get $3000. That would leave $500 to compensate Sharkey for receiving the cauliflower ear and the poke in the stomach, and to pay Drs. Lee and Ragan for their services.

See moreSee less

If Earp gets $2500 he should give Long Green Lawrence at least $1000 for inducing Gibbs and Groom to appoint him referee.

Civic Federation talk has evidently had

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This satirical article discusses the financial aftermath of the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, speculating on payouts to various parties including Earp, who refereed the match. It mocks the participants with a mock 'benefit' program featuring jabs at Earp's role in controversially stopping the fight.

The San Francisco Call · 19 December 1896 · page 14 · transcribed from the page image

soothing lotion to his indignation. Several gentlemen interested in the manly art have approached Julian with a proposition to give Fitzsimmons a complimentary benefit before he leaves for the East. The pugilist and his manager say that they are not in need and do not care to accept a complimentary benefit, but when it was represented that the affair was intended as a testimonial of admiration for the prowess of Mr. Fitzsimmons Julian consented to take the matter under advisement until this afternoon. If the benefit takes place at all it will be held in Woodward's Pavilion. Fitzsimmons will give an exhibition of boxing and there will be many other interesting features. It has been suggested that the following

See the clipping

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho

Witnesses testified in the inquiry into the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with claims that a doctor was paid to fake evidence of a foul blow. Sharkey denied any conspiracy or betting, insisting Fitzsimmons struck him foul and that referee Wyatt Earp had no financial stake in the purse.

The Kootenai Herald · 19 December 1896 · page 7

Declare» 'Flint Fl t •/.» I m mon » Struck Foul Blow. Him San Francisco, Dec. 15. — The Fltzslm mons-Sharkey witnesses today gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove that a doctor psrformed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of an apparent foul and that he was paid $1000 for the service. Dan Lynch, Sharkey s manager, denied all knowledge of a con spiracy, and said that neither he nor Cihar key was a member of the National club, and declared that Referee Earp had no pecuniary Interest in the check for $10,uo0.

See moreSee less

On cross-examination by Fitzsimmons' counsel. Lynch was asked It he had i ver been prohibited from racing at the local tracks, and why. Opposition from Shar key's attorney saved the witness from the embarrassment of replying. B. Benjamin, a sporting reporter, wit nessed the fight, but saw no foul blow struck by Pltzslmmon*. Tom Sharkey'» Attraction.

See the clipping

The Coeur D'alene Press · Coeur D'alene, Idaho

At a San Francisco hearing into the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, witnesses gave conflicting testimony about an alleged conspiracy and faked foul, with referee Wyatt Earp's role in dispute. Sharkey denied any conspiracy or payment, insisting Fitzsimmons struck him a genuine foul blow.

The Coeur D'alene Press · 19 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

TOM SHARKEY WAS ON THE STAND.

Declares That Fitzsimmons Struck Him a Foul Blow.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, Dec. 15. — The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses today gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove that a doctor performed an operation on

See the clipping

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · the Dalles, Or.

A San Francisco court dissolved an injunction that had tied up a $10,000 purse from the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match. The ruling effectively ended Fitzsimmons' legal efforts to overturn referee Wyatt Earp's decision awarding the fight to Sharkey.

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 19 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Will Get the Money. SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 17.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest in court for a $10,000 purse came to an abrupt conclusion in Judge Sanderson's court to day. The motion of Sharkey's counsel to dissolve the injunction tying up the check was granted and with the court's decision vanished forever all efforts on the part of Fitzsimmons to overrule the decision of Referee Earp.

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

Sailor Sharkey presented the $10,000 certified check given him by referee Wyatt Earp after his fight with Fitzsimmons to the bank, where he learned $4,000 in attachments had been filed against it. He accepted the remaining balance and left satisfied.

El Paso Daily Herald · 19 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Gits Thar. Sharkey presented the certified check of $10,000 handed him by Referee Wyatt Earp on the day of his fight with Fitzsimmons to the Anglo-Californian bank yesterday, when the cashier notified the sailor that attachments aggregating $1,500 had been filed against the certificate. "All right then give me the balance," remarked Sharkey in a way which indicated that he was anxious to get $8,500 out of reach of the collectors. The money was turned over to him, and he went off smiling.

The New York seventy-first regiment will take part in the inaugural parade at Washington.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Fitzsimmons publicly thanks supporters after winning his court fight to secure the $10,000 purse from the disputed Sharkey bout, while Corbett eagerly agrees to fight for any stake Fitzsimmons names. Meanwhile Sharkey finally cashes the certified check given to him by referee Wyatt Earp, though $1,500 in attachments reduce his payout.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 December 1896 · page 2

San Francisco Dec ISIn a state ment to the public printed here Robe t Fitzsimmons thanks his friends for the aid they have extended him in his I fight in court to secure the 10000 purse which he says he honestly won in his fight with Sharkey He declares that his opponents finding that the justice of the case was with him had it dismissed on the ground that the plsmlssed contest was a prizefight and had no

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · and 9 other papers

Tom Sharkey collected the balance of his $10,000 certified check from referee Wyatt Earp's fight, despite attachments filed against it. Separately, San Francisco grand jurors indicated they would not indict the boxers, believing convictions unlikely.

Richmond Dispatch · 19 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY GETS THAT CHECK.

Ready to Fight Anybody—No Indictment of Boxers.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, CAL., December 18.—As soon as the Anglo-Californian Bank opened this morning Tom Sharkey presented the certified check for $10,000 handed him by Referee Wyatt Earp on the day of the fight with Fitzsimmons. The cashier notified the "Sailor" that attachments aggregating $1,500 had been filed against the certificate. "All right, then, give me the balance," remarked Sharkey, in a way which indicated that he was anxious to get the $8,500 out of the reach of the collectors. The money was turned over to him and he proceeded on his way jubilantly. Sharkey has not definitely determined as to his future movements.

"I'm ready to fight anybody," said Sharkey to-day, "but as nobody seems desirous of meeting me, it doesn't look as if I would get a match for some time. Peter Maher, the man I would like to go against, is matched to meet Steve O'Donnell; so I will be unable to get a fight out of the Irishman until after his present engagement is over."

Inquiry among members of the grand jury leads to the conclusion that that body will not proceed against the boxers by finding indictments for felony. In the jury are a number of prominent citizens who do not disapprove of ring contests. They hold that it would be unwise to proceed against the boxers, as it is certain convictions could not be obtained.

See the clipping

Also printed in 9 papers
  • · · 19 December 1896
  • Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 19 December 1896
  • The Morning Times · Washington, D.C. · 19 December 1896
  • The Norfolk Virginian · Norfolk, Va. · 19 December 1896
  • Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio · 21 December 1896
  • The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 24 December 1896
  • The Charlotte Democrat · Charlotte, N.C. · 24 December 1896
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 24 December 1896
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 25 December 1896

Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash.

Testimony in a San Francisco court examined allegations that Wyatt Earp, as referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, was part of a conspiracy favoring Sharkey. Witnesses including Julian and Dr. Lustig gave conflicting accounts of Earp's conduct and Sharkey's injuries.

Pullman Herald · 19 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TOM SHARKEY WAS IN COURT.

Police Commissioner Gunst and Riley Grannan had come to him to tell him that Earp was "fixed."

He quoted Grannan as having overheard a conversation between Earp and Joe Harvey, a bookmaker, in the course of which Harvey said:

See moreSee less

"Then it is all right?" To which Earp replied: "You can depend on me."

Julian's testimony sought to involve the National Club, Sharkey, Lynch and Earp in the alleged conspiracy.

Fitzsimmons denied he struck any foul blow and repeated Julian's story about the warnings not to accept Earp as referee.

Dr. D. D. Lustig's testimony was not much relished by Sharkey. He said he was the medical examiner for the National Club and had examined Sharkey before the fight. After Sharkey had been taken to his room, Lustig with four other doctors, hearing Sharkey had been hurt, offered their services, but they were refused admittance to Sharkey's dressing room.

On the following afternoon, Dr. Lustig and five other physicians examined Sharkey's injuries in the groin and the witness pronounced the injury superficial. He said it was insignificant, not disabling nor productive of much pain. The injuries to the groin might have been caused by artificial means, such as the injection of any acidulated water.

Dan Hickey, one of Fitzsimmons' seconds, W. W. Naughton, a sporting reporter, and others present at the fight testified that they had seen no foul blow struck by Fitzsimmons.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This item is a satirical media-criticism piece mocking a rival newspaper (the 'New York Charnal'/Examiner) for plagiarizing a poem idea from the New York Press, with a mocking parody poem included. It mentions in passing that staff members had been compelled to write 'bogus statements' by Wyatt Earp, implying fabricated content attributed to him.

The San Francisco Call · 20 December 1896 · page 27 · transcribed from the page image

with a copy of the New York Press of Sunday morning, October 18, 1896, as a mentor and adopting a gas-meter for his versification. As he toiled he gleefully thought of the "soft snap" he had struck as a poet for a "day detail." Infinitely easier than writing up bogus "statements" by Wyatt Earp, as some of the members of the staff had been compelled to do, the

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

Tom Sharkey received his $10,000 certified check from referee Wyatt Earp but had to forfeit $1,500 to creditors' attachments before pocketing $8,500. The report also notes the Grand Jury is unlikely to indict the boxers for felony over the contest.

New York Journal · 20 December 1896 · page 26 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY GETS HIS MONEY Bank Pays Him the $10,000 Purse, Minus $1,500 of It, Which Had Been Attached by Creditors. San Francisco, Dec. 19.—As soon as the Anglo-Californian Bank opened, Tom

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Bob Fitzsimmons is seen around town saying farewells, publicly described as having been "jobbed" by referee Wyatt Earp and Sharkey. His wife Rose Julian packs for their departure East, voicing contempt for the outcome while Fitzsimmons looks ahead to a fight with Corbett instead.

The San Francisco Call · 21 December 1896 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

Robert Fitzsimmons. the tall, blonde boxer from Australia—Bob Fitzsimmons, as he is best known—the fighter who fought Sharkey in the ring and also in the court for a purse of $10,000, winning in the first contest and losing in the second, was around town all day yesterday bidding his friends good-by. As the big, broad-shouldered man passed quietly along the sidewalk clad in a ministerial garb he was pointed out by everybody on the street as "Fitzsimmons, who was jobbed by Earp and Sharkey," so well known is the man who made the sailor turn turtle.

See moreSee less

While the public is yet talking about the "famous victoree" the man who failed to get the coin part of it is taking the matter quietly. He will leave his late opponent to the purse and unenviable glory of that concerted fluke and look forward to interviewing Mr. Corbett in a fairer manner.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

At a Paso Robles boxing match, referee Herman Eppinger Jr. was searched for concealed weapons before entering the ring, revealing a pistol and bowie-knife in his pockets. He explained he was following a precedent set by Wyatt Earp in San Francisco, which satisfied onlookers.

The San Francisco Call · 22 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

left hook on the jaw. The fight was refereed by Herman Eppinger Jr. of Paso Robles. When he entered the ring he was searched for concealed weapons and an officer succeeded in locating a sixshooter and a bowie-knife in his pockets. Eppinger explained that he was following the precedent established by Wyatt Earp in San Francisco, and this was considered satisfactory. The effort is being made to match Lewis and "Spider" Kelly of San Francisco. It is believed the mill will be arranged.

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

A satirical political column references boxer Tom Sharkey collecting winnings from a disputed fight, sarcastically crediting 'Wyatt Earp's probity' as referee. The item mocks Earp's integrity in connection with the controversial decision that favored Sharkey.

New York Journal · 22 December 1896 · page 6

Mr. Mark Hanna is said to think well of the suggestion that he supply himself with a coat of arms. Mr. Hanna has not decided on a design, butjhere will be sure to be something pertaining to friendship to labor in It. Mr. Sharkey has drawn from that California bank the proceeds of his licking and Wyatt Earp's probity, and Is now looking about for some other pugilist who has the nerve to tackle his game. With liquor banished from the Capitol building, the bung starters in the adjacent barrooms will call more Congressmen to order than can be reached by Tom Reed's gavel.

See moreSee less

There is this much to be said for the Texas. The unfortunate battle ship was able to keep afloat .while Secretary Herbert was engaged in the delivery of his eulogy The notion that Spain intends -? a stubborn fight In Cuba is corroborated by +v"s> "ving her mules in Kansas.

See the clipping

Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · Cresco, Iowa

Tom Sharkey presented the certified check given to him by referee Wyatt Earp after the fight with Fitzsimmons, but found that $1,500 in attachments had been filed against it. He accepted the remaining $8,500 and left quickly before more collectors could intervene.

Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · 22 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Gets His Money. San Francisco, Dec. 19.—As soon as the Anglo-Californian bank opened Friday morning Tom Sharkey presented the certified check for $10,000 handed him by Referee Wyatt Earp on the

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A brief item among Arizona news notes mentions that Wyatt Earp served as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, with the Bisbee Orb joking this reflects well on Arizona's bid for statehood. The item is part of a roundup of small regional news items from across Arizona.

Arizona Republican · 23 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Arizona has been placed on a pedestal in the temple of fame. Her distinguished son, Wyatt Earp, officiated as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight. Can they now deny us statehood? says the Bisbee Orb.

Governor Franklin has expressed a box of Arizona oranges to President Cleveland. He should also send one to Major McKinley if he wants to hold onto his job. We charge nothing for the advice.—Bisbee Orb.

See the clipping

The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · and 1 other paper

Tom Sharkey cashed the $10,000 certified check given to him by referee Wyatt Earp after his fight with Fitzsimmons, despite $1,500 in attachments filed against it. The bank paid him the remaining $8,500, which he took eagerly to avoid creditors.

The Ely Miner · 23 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Gets His Money. San Francisco, Dec. 19.—As soon as the Anglo-Californian bank opened Friday morning Tom Sharkey presented the certified check for $10,000 hand[ed him by Referee Wyatt Earp on the]

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn. · 24 December 1896

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A brief notice reports that Wyatt Earp has been sued for $209 for board furnished at the restaurant located at the Ingleside racetrack. No further details of the suit are given.

The San Francisco Call · 24 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Slack's court to-day. Christmas will be appropriately celebrated at the City churches. Wyatt Earp has been sued for $209 for board furnished at the restaurant at the Ingleside track.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A San Francisco caterer named William Schubner filed suit against Wyatt Earp for $209 owed for meals provided over nearly two years. The same complaint also names several other men owing smaller amounts, ranging from $15 to $125.

The San Francisco Call · 24 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Boden, secretary, and Misses Ana Smithers, Carlota Ordenana and Jesusita Parra.

WYATT EARP SUED.

See moreSee less

A Restaurant-Keeper Wants $209 for Board Furnished the Arizona Gun-Fighter.

Unless he speedily settles a bill of $209

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 1 other paper

In testimony during the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight inquiry, Sharkey denied any conspiracy, said he never spoke with Wyatt Earp, and claimed he placed no bets on the bout. He testified that Fitzsimmons had struck him with a foul blow to the groin, contradicting claims from his own trainers.

The Frontier · 24 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey Testifies. San Francisco, Dec. 17.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey witnesses yesterday gave no sensational testimony, but Fitzsimmons' friends say they are now able to prove a doctor performed an operation on Sharkey to produce external evidence of an apparent foul, and that he was paid $1,000 for doctor's service. Thomas Sharkey's testimony was simply a denial of the stories told by his trainers, Billy Smith and George Allen. He never heard of a conspiracy before the fight, had no talk with Earp and bet no money on the fight. He declared Fitzsimmons struck him a foul blow in the groin.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb. · 25 December 1896

Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · Napoleon, Ohio

Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, pleaded not guilty to a charge of carrying concealed weapons during the match. The brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news items.

Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · 24 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

was shot and killed by his tenant, W. W. Tucker, for intimacy with Mrs. Tucker.

The portrait of President Cleveland in the rooms of the Cook County (Ills.) Democratic club has been cut to pieces by silver members.

See moreSee less

Wednesday.

The postal deficit for the last fiscal year was $8,127,088.

Miss Aline Wilcox and Mr. Albert Halstead were married in Washington.

It is officially denied that the American flag was torn down in Armenian villages.

"Crazy Jim," a negro murderer, was captured near Pine Bluff, Ark., and lynched.

Williston J. Brookins, indicted for forgery ten years ago at Buffalo, has surrendered himself.

Referee Earp pleaded not guilty to carrying concealed weapons at the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey mill.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This 1896 article profiles Wyatt Earp ahead of his role as boxing referee, recounting his background as a lawman in Dodge City and later Tombstone, Arizona. It describes a violent feud with cattlemen involving Doc Holliday that left several dead and forced Earp into fugitive status.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 24 December 1896 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

a part of a Dodge City jag as selecting a referee is now part of the arrangements for a ten-round go. As a corollary it was part of the municipal arrangements of Dodge City to select a marshal. The selection at one time fell on Mr. Earp and he showed a zeal in having things

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This feature traces Wyatt Earp's career from Dodge City marshal to Tombstone police officer, describing a gunfight in which he and his brothers killed three cattlemen. It notes the Earps were never tried for the killings and later follows Earp to California, where he became a respected boxing referee in Tia Juana.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 24 December 1896 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

of Dodge City to select a marshal. The selection at one time fell on Mr. Earp and he showed a zeal in having things conducted according to Dodge City rules that increased the size of the cemetery and made him known as a firm, impartial referee in such cases as might come under his jurisdiction. Earp afterward went to Tombstone, Ariz., where he was appointed on the police force. In a vendetta with cattle men he and his three brothers, with a Western killer named Doc Holliday, killed three of the cattle men, and two of the Earps were assassinated.

See moreSee less

As a result Wyatt Earp and his other brother were nominally fugitives from justice, as they evaded arrest. Wyatt Earp came thence to California and has since lived in different parts of the state. While there are two sides to the story of the Tombstone vendetta, no attempt has ever been made to bring the Earps to trial, though the affair happened fifteen years ago and they

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

Two of boxer Sharkey's trainers testified in court that referee Wyatt Earp had been 'fixed' regarding the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight decision. The brief item appears amid a digest of unrelated national news.

Iowa County Democrat · 24 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

New York—The Woman's Indian Association elected Mrs. H. L. M. Rambau president.

Two of Sharkey's trainers testify in court that Referee Earp had been "fixed."

See moreSee less

Orville Rice, traveling for a New York commission house, was held up and robbed of $60 on a prominent street of Norwalk, O.

Edward Hale of Ireland won the six-day a bicycle race in New York, he and eleven other riders breaking the world's record.

Miss Vivian Sartoris, Gen Grant's grand-daughter, was presented to Washington society.

Chicago is to have a 6-day bicycle race in February. The prize money amounts to $4,700.

Mrs. H. W. Jenkins, an old-time actress, who was known professionally as

See the clipping

The Delamar Nugget · Delamar, Idaho

The report states Wyatt Earp awarded the fight purse to Sharkey on a disputed foul, which is now widely considered a dishonest call by a corrupt referee. Courts have since ruled Sharkey may keep the money because the match itself violated anti-prizefighting laws.

The Delamar Nugget · 25 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Earp gave Sharkey the stake money on a foul and it is now admitted by everybody that the swipe on the money by a dishonest referee, was the meanest foul perpetrated. Now the courts have decided that Sharkey may keep the money because it was staked upon a contest carried out in violation of law. It is all a matter of profound indifference to decent people who got the money. An honest prize fight is as much of an impossibility as an honest train robber.

See the clipping

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

A brief news item reports that boxer Tom Sharkey wants another fight with Bob Fitzsimmons, and that Wyatt Earp is wanted as referee for the bout. This references Earp's earlier controversial refereeing of their December 1896 fight.

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 25 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Laxol is the best medicine for children. Doctors recommend it in place of Castor Oil.

Northern Pacific Extensions.

See moreSee less

Fargo. N. D., Dec. 21.—It is authoritively stated that the Northern Pacific will make two extensions as soon as the snow is off in the spring. One will be from Leeds to Dunseith, an extension of the Jamestown Northern, which will open the Turtle mountain country. A longer extension will be on the Fargo Southwestern branch from Edgerly to the Missouri river via Kulm, Ashby and Eureka. The line will open a splendid section of tne country throughout McIntosh county, where formers now have to haul wheat forty miles.

—Sharkey wants another fight with Fitzsimmons. Earp is wanted for referee.

Joseph Kraker, the only "gold Democrat" elected to the legislature, has decided to turn Republican. He is from Melrose, and will be the only Republican in either branch of the legislature from the Stearns-Benton district, unless the Rosebud from Sauk Centre decides to quit Democracy.

The failure of the Bank of Minnesota makes clear just why Banker R. A. Smith was appointed postmaster of St. Paul. Smith was one of the oldest bankers in the state, and it seemed strange that he sought a federal appointment, but it is now known that he needed it.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This passage is a year-end review of 1896 sporting highlights, including the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight where referee Wyatt Earp awarded victory to Sharkey on a foul in the eighth round, even though Fitzsimmons appeared close to a knockout. It also surveys other boxing, football, and baseball events of the year.

The Sun · 27 December 1896 · page 17 · transcribed from the page image

FIGHTING

Peter Maher received the heavy-weight championship from Corbett when he knocked out O'Donnell at Maspeth in a punch, and later lost it to Fitzsimmons. The battle between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey at San Francisco proved to be the most notable event of the year. In the eighth round the referee, Wyatt Earp, awarded the fight to Sharkey on the ground that a foul had been committed, although, according to report, the Australian was on the point of scoring a knock-out. Erne's defeat of George Dixon in a twenty-round bout and the downfall of Plimmer before Pedlar Palmer were also features.

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A stranger calling himself Dr. Middleton of Tombstone impressed a Kansas City hotel with tales of riding with Wyatt Earp and Bat Masterson, even claiming he organized the posse that drove Earp out of Tombstone after the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight controversy. He is now facing forgery charges after trying to pass a bad check to cover his hotel bill.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 28 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

DR. MIDDLETON IN TROUBLE

cation around the hotel.

For the next week everything went well, as the hero of the border paid all of his bills and made himself agreeable around the lobby of the hotel, telling numerous experiences which he and Bat Masterson and several other men of Western note had, while ridding the country of horse thieves, cattle rustlers and other desperadoes around Dodge City and Tombstone.

See moreSee less

About the time of the trouble over the decision of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight in San Francisco, "Dr. Middleton" said he was the one who organized the posse at Tombstone which drove Wyatt Earp, the referee, and his brother from that town. He said that the men rode twenty-six miles on horseback to the railroad, and escaped on the train. He even showed a letter from the San Francisco Examiner, addressed to Dr. Middleton, and asking him what kind of a reputation Earp bore in early days on the border.

About a week after his arrival in Kansas City there was a bill of $4 against this

member of the Tombstone vigilance com-

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The passage is a miscellany of political commentary, mocking Venezuela's claims of diplomatic success by comparing it to Sharkey's disputed win over Fitzsimmons, which was aided by referee Wyatt Earp. This is a brief sarcastic reference rather than a direct report on Earp himself.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 29 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Venezuela says she gained concessions from England through her friend, the United States. In the same way Sharkey won a fight off Fitzsimmons, through his friend, Wyatt Earp.

Clara Barton and the Red Cross Society can do nothing in the aid of the Cubans. The Cubans do not live like lords on money bilked out of poor congregations and do not deserve aid.

See moreSee less

For the first time in years the business interests and the newspapers are getting on opposing sides. The business interests are aginst war with Spain over Cuba. The newspapers are for it.

The Populists of Kansas believe that Republican failure nationally is inevitable. Then they believe Populism will win. But they do not believe in their hearts that Populism can give a remedy.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A snippet notes that a biography of Wyatt Earp is being written, branding him as a crooked gambler and dead shot who referereed the controversial Sharkey fight decision. It sarcastically suggests more such referees would spell the end of prize fighting.

San Antonio Daily Light · 29 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The biography of Earp, who umpired the money in the Sharkey steal into the pockets of that worthy is being written. It comes out in box car letters branding him as a black leg gambler, crooked sport, dead shot, but one who has faced powder so often that he has grown cautious. A few more such referees and results and there would be a finis to prize fighting. It would not come too soon.

Scribner for January comes in like the "New Woman" in a decidedly new dress. The number is also like the new woman in that it is in no sense stereotyped, but is all fresh, decsweet, chic, up to date, is clearly in evidence as to prettiness and thoroughly illustrated in the highest style of art.

See the clipping