A short local news item reports that Virgil Earp, once well known in Tombstone, was seriously injured by a cave-in at a mine near Prescott. The item appears amid a roundup of regional local news briefs.
Sulphur Valley News · 1 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
LOCAL AND PERSONAL
Virgil Earp, once well known in Tombstone, was seriously injured at Prescott recently by a cave in a mine.
A referee identified as Wyatt Earp of Tombstone fame awarded a boxing match to Sharkey over Fitzsimmons on a foul in the eighth round, provoking widespread indignation among fight followers. Reports note Earp is being harshly criticized for the decision, with uncertain consequences and no indication he will reverse his ruling.
Tombstone Prospector · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LATEST NEWS
DR JAMISON RELEASED
SAN FRANCISCO—The referee gave the fight to Sharkey in the eighth round on a foul. The decision aroused much indignation among the knowing sports.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO—Wyatt Earp of Tombstone fame was the referee in the Fitzsimmons and Sharkey fight, and today is being much criticised for his decision in awarding the fight to Sharkey on technical grounds. It is not known what the result may bring
Bob Fitzsimmons fought Tom Sharkey before a huge crowd at San Francisco's Mechanics' Pavilion, with Wyatt Earp serving as referee despite objections from Fitzsimmons' camp. Sharkey was knocked unconscious in the eighth round, but Earp ruled Fitzsimmons had struck him with his knee, awarding the fight to Sharkey on a foul.
Arizona Republican · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY'S FIGHT ON A FOUL
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 2.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted so much public attention here as did the battle between the heavyweights, Bob Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey, tonight.
Between 15,000 and 20,000 people took up all the available space in the big Mechanics' pavilion and watched the contest, which every one regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world.
See moreSee less
It was 10:06 when Fitzsimmons entered the ring, Sharkey following two minutes later. Fitzsimmons showed up fresh and received an ovation, and Sharkey's welcome was equally as warm.
Fitzsimmons chatted with friends at the ringside. When Sharkey entered the ring Bob walked across and shook hands cordially with the sailor and his seconds. Both men were enveloped in long bathrobes, which they threw off before putting on the gloves. It was then the disparity in the build of the men was plainly seen.
Fitz, lean, long and sinewy, looked like a panther, while Sharkey, stocky and sturdy, with his immense muscular development, resembled a grizzly bear.
Martin Julian, Fitzsimmons' second, expressed dissatisfaction at the selection of Wyatt Earp as referee, claiming he heard the referee intended to give his decision against his man. After several minutes' consultation Julian withdrew his objection and at 10:37 the pugilists shook hands.
First round—The men advanced quickly to the center of the ring, and sparred a moment. Fitz leads his left. Fitz feints several times with his left, but Sharkey gets away. Fitz landed light right on head. Sharkey clinches. Sharkey swings left at Fitz's body and a moment later lands a hard left swing on Fitz's neck. Sharkey landed right and left on Fitz's head and ducked a vicious left swing. Sharkey tried with right for the head, but Fitz got away. Sharkey ducked a hard right swing. Sharkey tried for the body and rushed Fitz, landing left on body. Fitz landed left on face and Sharkey got back at Fitz with the same blow. Sharkey landed left and got same in return. Fitz knocked Sharkey down with right on the jaw. The round ended with Sharkey in his corner and Fitz trying for his jaw.
Second round—Fitz standing up before time called. The men sparred and Fitz landed left on face. Sharkey rushed, but Fitz clinched. Fitz swung right, but missed. Sharkey landed a hard left on the chest. Fitz tried for the face, but got a leg right left on the head. Fitzsimmons ducked a hard left. Sharkey ducked a left and clinched. Fitzsimmons swung right, but missed and landed left on head. Fitz landed right on head. Fitz landed left on body. Sharkey missed right and left for the head. Sharkey landed right and left on the head and neck and got two in return. Fitz ducked a right swing. Fitz tried left for the head and missed. The round ended with Fitz the aggressor.
Third round—Fitz rushed, but Sharkey ducked and clinched low. Sharkey tried left for body and then clinched. Fitz swung right and left on the head. Sharkey swung right and left, but with little damage. Fitz staggered Sharkey with right. Sharkey swung left on the head. Fitzsimmons swung left and Sharkey ducked. Sharkey landed left on face. Sharkey landed hard left on wind and got away. Sharkey ducked hard left swing. Sharkey doing the most of the leading for the wind and again landed left on wind. Fitzsimmons evidently laying to get in right on jaw.
Fourth round—Sharkey landed left. Sharkey knocked Fitz down with left in wind. He then ducked left and swung and landed left on wind three times without a return. Fitzsimmons fighting carefully. Sharkey ducked right swing. Fitzsimmons landed a left jab. Sharkey landed left on the face and wind. This rushed Fitzsimmons to the ropes. Sharkey tried for the wind and missed. Sharkey landed left on wind and got left on the head. Sharkey landed left swing on head, staggering Fitzsimmons. Fitz
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
The report describes the arrangements for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, including Wyatt Earp being named referee amid controversy over alleged police betting and interference. It details the crowd, the preliminary bout, and the tense delay as Earp fails to appear before the main fight begins.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
night in the contest at Mechanics' pavilion between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey.
The pool rooms were crowded all day. Fitzsimmons closed a 3 to 1 favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small dribbles, no large wagers being reported.
See moreSee less
All day long Martin Julian and Danny Lynch, representing Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, respectively, argued and squabbled over the selection of a referee. When the eleventh hour was reached the rival managers notified President Groom of the National club that he would have to name a referee. Mr. Groom submitted the name of Wyatt Earp, who in the early days was a terror to the fierce element in Kansas and Arizona.
A sensational story was printed in an evening paper to the effect that Police Commissioner Gunst had bet heavily on Fitz, and would have Chief Crowley stop the contest should it become apparent that Sharkey would win.
Mr. Gunst, however, declared that he did not have a dollar up, and that the pugilisits should not be molested unless the fight became brutal. In that event the police would see that the law was not violated.
Fitzsimmons came over from his training grounds early this afternoon and rested at the Baldwin hotel. Just before entering the ring he said to a reporter:
"I am suffering from a severe cold and it has settled in my bones, but this will not interfere with my putting the sailor to sleep in short order. I weigh just 174½ pounds, which is much less than I have carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull-like rushes. I hope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will just be to my liking."
The pavilion contained no less than 15,000 people when the first event was called, and a more orderly crowd never assembled. A cordon of twenty-five policemen fringed the ringside, while seventy-five officers were distributed about the hall preserving order and preventing confusion.
A ten round go between Lon Agnew of Chicago and Fred Muller of San Francisco, lightweights, was provided as a preliminary attraction. Agnew wore his man down and put him out in the sixth round.
Fitz entered the ring at 10:03, followed by his seconds. Bob's many San Francisco friends shrieked themselves hoarse when their favorite appeared, but their efforts were as the bark of a dog compared with the fierce yelp of sea lion to the greeting which Sharkey received five minutes later, as he vaulted into the ring, scorning to use the ladder.
Fitz sat quietly in his corner and eyed the sailor, while Sharkey surveyed his opponent critically for the first
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
This report describes the chaotic start of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in San Francisco, including a dispute over the referee when Wyatt Earp was initially rejected by Fitzsimmons's camp. After negotiations, Earp was allowed to referee and the fight began, with round-by-round action described.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY WAS KNOCKED OUT
did that of the principals. As Earp stepped through the ropes Julian eyed him suspiciously, evidently having in mind fouls and hugging bouts. The master of ceremonies soon announced that Mr. Julian refused to accept Mr. Earp. Julian stated that he had accepted every reputable man's name which had been suggested, but he did not propose to take any chances with a man who was professedly ignorant of the rules. The crowd's sympathizers were evidently with the Australian. Earp endeavored to make himself heard, but failed. After more talk and a conference between those chiefly interested, Julian shouted that he was willing to have a referee selected from the audience, and the crowd yelled for Earp. After a great deal of wrangling Fitz arose and shouted: "Gentlemen, I have given in to everybody in all my fights and I'll give in to this. Let Sharkey take the bandages off his hands. I have none on mine." The crowd cheered for the Cornishman. Sharkey's bandages were removed, and the men shook hands at 10:35. Mr. Earp removed his coat and the fight was on. Round 1—They were both cautious. Fitz followed his man, led and closed with Sharkey. Tom led and missed. Another lead from Tom caught Fitz on the shoulder. Sharkey was very active, while Fitz seemed cool and settled down to his dangerous crouch. After clinching Tom hit him on the neck. Fitz's lead on the sailor were unproductive. Fitz put his right on the neck lightly and in the clinch Tom lifted Fitz like a baby. The sailor was now doing all the leading, but a sharp hook from Fitz sent him down. A second later Bob had his left on Tom's jaw, and down went the sailor, just as the gong sounded. It was evident that Fitz had lost none of his cunning, and already had the sailor in "Queer" street.
VOL. XLIV. NO. 287. PRICE THREE CENTS.
See moreSee less
SHARKEY WAS KNOCKED OUT
BUT FITZSIMMONS WAS ROBBED OF THE DECISION.
The Sailor's Pretensions as a Fighter Exposed by the Lanky Australian—The Referee Knew Nothing of the Rules—Sharkey Fouled Repeatedly—He Could Do Nothing With Fitzsimmons.
Round 2—Fitz landed a stiff left on the jaw and a clinch followed. Fitz shuffled after his man, while Sharkey seemed rattled. A hard right sent Tom reeling, but he rallied and landed a hot one on the wind. This was repeated a second later, after each had landed a stiff right. Sharkey got another hard right a moment later and clinched to save himself. Fitz was puffing, but confident, and followed his man care-
This report describes the scene at the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, including the large crowd, presence of women, and the selection of Wyatt Earp as referee. It then begins a round-by-round account of the fight itself.
Waterbury Democrat · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Fight by Rounds.
As each man appeared he received hearty applause. Sharkey wore a green sash with red, white and blue trimmings. His right hand was bandaged. Fitzsimmons was introduced as champion of the world, which received a howl of approval. Fitz chatted with friends at the ringside as if a hard fight were not on his hands. When Sharkey entered the ring, Bob walked across the ring and shook hands cordially with the sailor and his seconds. Both men were enveloped in long black robes, which they threw off before putting on the gloves. It was then the disparity in the build of the two men was plainly seen. Fitz, lean and long and sinewy, looked like a panther, while Sharkey, stocky and sturdy, with his immense muscular development, resembled a grizzly bear.
See moreSee less
Round 1.—Both men started to spar. Fitz feinted several times with left, but Sharkey got away. Fitz landed lightly, right on head. Sharkey clinched. Sharkey swung left at Fitz's body, and a moment later landed left hard on Fitz's neck. Sharkey landed right and left on Fitz's head and ducked vicious left swing. Sharkey tried with right for head, but Fitz got away. Sharkey ducked hard right swing. Sharkey tried for body and rushed Fitz, landing left on body. Sharkey landed left and got same in return. Fitz knocked Sharkey down with right twice in jaw. Round ended with Sharkey in corner and Fitz trying for neck.
Round 2.—Fitz standing up before time is called. Men sparred, and Fitz landed light left on face. Sharkey rushed, but Fitz clinched. Fitz swung right and left, but misses. Sharkey landed hard left on chest. Fitz tried left for face, but got light
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded Tom Sharkey a win on a foul claim after Bob Fitzsimmons appeared to knock him out, sparking cries of "fake" and "steal" from the crowd. The report accuses Earp of a barefaced robbery and says he fled the ring before the crowd's anger built.
The San Francisco Call · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Pavilion--Crowd Yelled Fake.
The alleged gun-fighter, Wyatt Earp, who is best known as the bodyguard of Long Green Lawrence, of the Examiner, robbed Bob Fitzsimmons of a well-earned victory over Tom Sharkey in the most barefaced manner last night.
See moreSee less
The sailor, who fought foul all through the eight rounds of the battle, went down from a hook on the chin and a terrific left drive in the pit of the stomach, and the crowd got up to go with the impression that Bob had won.
But then the slouchy would-be referee gave the decision to the sailor on a foul, and the house howled in derision and would not believe it until Fitzsimmons himself confirmed the story by protesting against the outrage.
It was the most bald-faced steal that has ever been seen in the San Francisco prize ring and will do much to hurt boxing on this coast if, indeed, it does not kill it entirely.
Earp did not wait to see what effect the decision would have on the crowd, but sneaked from the ring while Fitz' friends were crowding about the big Cornishman to congratulate him and was far away when the crowd understood and began to yell "Fake," "Steal" and other expressions of that character.
It is safe to say that his fake reputation as a bad man from Arizona would not have saved his hide had the crowd been able to get hands on him.
He showed the "yellow dog" in him by going into the ring with a Colt's navy revolver in his pocket, indicating that he feared trouble over the decision that he knew he would give if opportunity offered.
When Captain Wittman saw it pushing out his coattails he demanded the gun, and it was only after repeated orders from the big police officer that Earp gave up the weapon on which he depends for a living.
The Fitzsimmons people knew when they entered the ring something was wrong, and when the club management announced that Fakir Earp was its choice--the managers of the men having failed to agree on a man--they protested against him.
Julian, who talked for Fitz, said to the throng that they had originally been satisfied with the alleged gun-fighter, but that just before the fight they had heard that Earp was fixed for Sharkey.
"We are satisfied with any other man in the house," he said, "but we don't want this man," pointing to Earp. "We don't want to be kickers, but we want at least a fair show. Let them choose any other man and we will be ready."
Earp hung his head during the speech. The wrangle grew too long for Fitz and he finally sprang from his chair and said:
"I have given in to everything in this matter and I will give in to this. Let's get at it."
That slip of judgment cost Fitz $10,000, but not a whit of his reputation, for not a fair-minded man in the audience saw more than one man in the fight, and that man was Bob Fitzsimmons.
He simply smothered the sailor and won the good will of the crowd, which was at first with Sharkey, by the great fairness with which he fought. When he helped Sharkey through knocking him in that pos[ition the] crowd [was with Bob] to a man.
Sharkey's persistent at[tempts to foul] Bob by catching him by [the leg and] striking in a cinch after [he was warned by the] ring not to do so, showe[d un]ably against the Cornish[man's fair] aways.
The rawness of Fakir [Earp] was emphasized by th[e] sailor's friends after he h[ad gone] to his dressing-room.
When they were asked [the cause of the decep]tion they said he was bad[ly hurt and] a physician was with him.
Multiple boxing insiders and spectators give their opinions on referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision awarding the fight to Sharkey on a foul. Most harshly criticize Earp, insisting Fitzsimmons delivered a clean knockout and that the decision was a disgraceful 'steal' that could damage boxing's reputation in San Francisco.
The San Francisco Call · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
in my life. Sharkey did all the fouling that was done. The Cornishman is the one who deserved the decision. It was a clean, fair knockout and shows that Bob can hit harder than any man that has ever faced Sharkey.
Coroner Hawkins—Fitzsimmons certainly deserved the decision. He knocked Sharkey out as fairly as any man was ever yet knocked out. Earp is deserving not only of severe censure, but of the detestation of every man believing in honest sport.
See moreSee less
Jimmy Carroll—Don't ask me about the decision. I don't care to speak of it. I will say, however, that the referee should not have made his decision till he had called for a surgical examination of Sharkey. Though I believe Fitz the greatest fighter in the ring, I won a barrel of money on the fight.
Young Mitchell—It was the rankest decision I ever heard of in my life. It was the biggest steal on earth. I cannot find words strong enough to express my indignation. Fitz simply gave Sharkey a left hook in the pit of the stomach that doubled him up, and then followed it with a left hook in the jaw that finished him. Bob is the greatest fighter in the world.
Sharkey is nowhere alongside him. This decision will kill legitimate boxing in this City. The referee should be driven off the face of the earth. He ought to hide his face from all decent men.
Billy Daly—Sharkey's position was such that to foul him by hitting him where it was claimed he was cannot be considered at all. This decision, following in the wake of Maher's coming here and failing to get a contest, will kill boxing in San Francisco. It was the clearest case of robbery on earth.
Tom James—I am glad I am leaving San Francisco shortly. This is the best I can say for a city that would permit a man to be robbed of his money as Bob Fitzsimmons was.
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · and 1 other paper
Referee Wyatt Earp stopped the heavyweight contest in San Francisco, ruling that Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey with his knee after knocking him down, awarding the fight and purse to Sharkey despite Fitzsimmons dominating. The crowd jeered the decision and Earp had to flee to avoid being roughed up.
The Record-Union · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey Knocked Down and Out, But Yet Gets the Purse.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 2.—The San Francisco policeman has for once had reason to be pleased with his vocation. A detail of 100 blue coats were assigned to take care of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest to-night, when standing-room at the Mechanics' Pavilion, where the battle took place, was at a premium. Thousands surged about the doors and viewed the "cops" with envy.
See moreSee less
Not since Peter Jackson and Jim Corbett danced about each other for five hours before the members of the California Athletic Club has such enormous interest been aroused in a fight between heavy-weights. Sharkey's personal popularity is in a measure responsible for this, although Fitzsimmons' reputation among the knowing ones had not a little to do with it.
The long Australian came over from his training quarters early this afternoon and rested at the Baldwin Hotel. To a representative of the United-Associated Presses he remarked, just before entering the ring: "I am suffering from a severe cold, as you can see, and it has settled in my bones, but this will not interfere with my putting the sailor to sleep in short order. I weigh just 174½ pounds, which is more flesh than I have ever carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull-like rushes. I hope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will just be to my liking."
Martin Julian was equally confident. He viewed Fitz's red nose with some concern, but when his eyes dropped and took in the Cornishman's massive chest and shapely arms his confidence returned, and 'Bob will win in four rounds" was his verdict.
Jack Stenzler and Dan Hickey, who assisted Fitzsimmons in training, were beside Martin Julian in Bob's corner to-night, both wearing black eyes and sundry scars as eveidence that the Kangaroo had lost none of his hitting power. Each of the trainers were confident that Fitzsimmons would make a short fight of it, despite his cold.
No man ever entered a ring with more confidence in his ability to win than did Tom Sharkey. "I've always been a short-ender," he rembarked to a reporter of the United-Associated Presses, and I've always saved the money of my friends. When I met Choynski the odds were 3 to 1 that I would go down, but I fooled them, didn't I? Yes, I was beaten out of the decision, too, but that will not happen to-night. I am strong, heavy enough and clever enough to whip Fitzsimmons, and I intend doing so inside of seven rounds, if possible. If I fail it will be because he is the best man."
"Australian" Billy Smith, Bob Allen and Danny Needham, who were behind the sailor, and who also trained him, had their last dollar up on their charge, so confident were they of his winning.
"Tom has a short neck ribbed with muscles," said Needham, "and Fitzsimmons can no more reach his jaw than fly. Why did not Corbett or Choynski do the trick? Because they could not, and neither can Fitzsimmons. Sharkey is young and possesses remarkable vitality. He will outlast the Cornishman, and win in seven rounds."
Sharkey was trained to the minute. He weighed 175 pounds, three pounds lighter than when he met Corbett, and many believed that he was a trifle drawn.
All day long Martin Julian and Danny Lynch, representing Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, respectively, argued and squabbled over the selection of a referee. Hiram Cook, who refereed the Corbett-Jackson fight, was suggested by Julian, but Lynch would not hear of him, although Cook was the man put up by Lynch for the Corbett-Sharkey contest and turned down by Corbett. Al. Herford of Baltimore was up, only to be thrown out, as was also Billy Naughton, a local sporting editor. When the eleventh hour was reached the rival managers notified President Groom of the National Club that he would have to name a referee. Mr. Groom was prepared for the emergency, and without hesitation he submitted the name of Wyatt Earp, the man of the keen eye and the delicate nerve who in the early days was a terror to the fierce element in Kansas and Arizona, and who has sent more than a dozen desperadoes to their long rest with cold lead. Earp is no stranger to the ring, having served as referee in a number of battles. He was a featherweight compared to Sharkey and Fitzsimmons, but his nerve never failed him, and both fighters had a wholesome respect for his cautions.
The great pavilion began to fill before 6 o'clock. Sharkey's friends monopolized the upper gallery, and all the shouting for the sailor came from the cheaper seats.
"Why, when Tom fetches the lubber a stiff 'un in the hencoop his ballast 'll shift and it'll be all over, eh, mates?" grunted an aged barnacle in the front row. A chorus of "ayes" greeted the remark, followed by a shower of tobacco juice from the patient sailors.
Fitzsimmons' backers were found among the soft-palmed fraternity in the $10 seats. The sunny face of Captain Rees peeped out from between those of Riley Grannan and Eddy Gaines. The pockets of the three bulged with Fitzsimmons cash. Behind the coterie of horsemen were a score of prominent attorneys, a round dozen of Judges and any quantity of millionaires and other celebrities.
All day long the pool rooms were crowded. Fitzsimmons closed a three to one favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small dribbles, no large wagers being placed.
The pavilion contained not less than 15,000 people when the first event was called, and a more orderly crowd never assembled. A cordon of twenty-five policemen fringed the ringside, while seventy-five officers were distributed about the hall preserving order and preventing confusion.
A sensational story was printed by an evening paper to the effect that Police Commissioner Gunst had bet heavily on Fitzsimmons, and would have Chief Crowley stop the contest should it become apparent that Sharkey would win. Mr. Gunst declared that he did not have a dollar up, and that the pugilists should not be molested unless the fighting became brutal. In that event Captain Wittman, in charge of the officers, would see that the law was not violated.
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 3 December 1896
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the early rounds of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match in vivid detail, noting Fitzsimmons' cool, calculated style against Sharkey's aggressive but erratic attacks. The accompanying headline states that Tom Sharkey was awarded the decision, a fight controversially refereed by Wyatt Earp.
The Record-Union · 3 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
GIVEN THE DECISION.
(Continued from First Page.)
See moreSee less
a jumping-jack, while Fitzsimmons gave an imitation of a man pushing a lawn mower on a warm day, occasionally brushing off an attack from a vicious hornet. They were both cautious. Fitzsimmons followed his man, led and closed with Sharkey. Tom led and missed. Another lead caught Fitz on the shoulder. Sharkey was very active, while Fitzsimmons seemed cool and settled down to his dangerous crouch. Fitz got in a light right on the jaw, and in the clinch Tom hit him on the neck. Two more leads from the sailor were unproductive. Fitz put his right on the neck lightly, and in the clinch he lifted Fitz like a baby. The sailor was now doing all the leading, but a sharp hook from Fitzsimmons sent him down. A second later and Bob put his left on Tom's jaw, and down went the sailor just as the gong sounded. It was evident that Fitz had lost none of his cunning, and already had the sailor on "queer street."
Round 2—Fitz landed a stiff left on the jaw, and a clinch followed. Fitz shuffled after his man calmly, while Sharkey seemed rattled. A hard right sent Tom reeling, but he recovered and landed a hot one on the wind. Tom attempted to land a left, but faile[d], and the men clinched. This was repeated a second later after Bob had landed a stiff right. Sharkey got another hard right a moment later and clinched to save himself. Fitz was puffing but confident, and followed his man carefully. Tom got in one on the shoulder which left a red splotch, and received a hot one on the jaw which staggered him as the gong tapped. The sailor was clearly playing in great luck, as Fitz seemed to have him just where he wanted at the call of time. Fitz scorned to sit down, and came up strong for round three.
Round 3—Sharkey clinched Bob, and got a light left on the neck. Another lead by Fitz was met with another clinch. Fitz got in a hot left on the face, but it was not in the spot and Sharkey clinched. A little infighting followed, in which Sharkey held his own. Bob landed a hard right, which was followed by the usual clinch. Sharkey was putting up his usual rough and tumble fight, and had not so far landed a blow fair. He led time and again, but Fitz was not there. Clinches followed in rapid succession. Just before the bell sounded Tom made and ugly swing, which had it landed would have been a palpable foul. The sailor was puffing, but not distressed. There were shouts of "Foul!" and Sharkey was cautioned.
Round 4—Fitz led and a clinch followed. In the breakaway Fitz slipped and fell, and as he arose Sharkey went at him like a bull, landing two hard blows on the wind. Bob sent a swift right on the neck as he recovered, and followed it a minute later with another on the breast, taking a hot one in the neck in return. A hard rally followed, and the men clinched, Sharkey hitting Fitz twice in the clinch. Bob got the left in on Tom's jaw and upper cut him on the heart. Tom tried a counter, but failed, and got another left in the jaw. Bob warmed up and sent in two terrific rights, closing Tom's left eye. Sharkey clawed his man on the arm and seemed to be decidedly weary as the round closed. But Father Time was kind to the mariner and saved him again.
Round 5—Bob led and landed a right, Sharkey clinching and throwing Fitzsimmons heavily. Another left started a stream of gore down from Sharkey's damaged eye and angered Sharkey, who rushed wildly and tried for the wind. A hard left sent Tom to the ropes and he clinched again. In the breakaway Sharkey again hit foul. After the men separated Sharkey started his rushes, but Bob stopped him with stiff lefts. Sharkey was fighting rotten, but Earp was blind. Fitz landed two hard lefts, the last of which sent Tom on his back through the ropes. Tom was very groggy, and Fitz put it on him hard twice in succession, and for the fourth time Sharkey was all but out when the gong tapped. Fitz was little distressed, the only signs of trouble he showed being an abrasion on the left arm.
Round 6—Sharkey did not rush as stiff as before, and after finding his man Fitz landed a left punch, following it a moment later with a hard left hook. Sharkey was leading for the stomach and clinching continually, lifting Fitz from the floor every time. Fitz let a hard left go, and it landed on the chin, but did not phase his man. An upper cut a moment later sent Tom back a few feet, as did two stiff lefts a moment later. A heart blow from Bob forced Tom to clinch again, and he hit Bob a foul in the break. This angered Fitz, and he went at his man, staggering him with left, right and left on the jaw in rapid succession. Sharkey clasped the Australian around the knees and was hanging on hard when the gong sounded. Sharkey had taken fearful punishment, but still had a fighting punch left.
Round 7—Sharkey rushed and caught a left on the face. He wrestled Fitz and struck him in the clinch, but still Earp could not see. Sharkey was slow and made futile swings for the stomach. Bob was crouching low. He sent a stiff left into Sharkey's face, and the latter clinched and upper-cut Fitz before breaking. He repeated this a moment later, and wrestled Fitz all over the ring. The crowd hollered "Foul, foul," but still Mr. Earp was blind. Fitz landed two hard rights and a left, Sharkey clinching each time and holding Fitz by the knees. The sailor seemed to be strong and fresh at the close of the round, but should have lost the fight on fouls at least a dozen times. The crowd were hooting and jeering at Earp in the interval.
Round 8—Sharkey led and missed. Again he led and clinched. Bob put a light right on the chin, and duplicated it a moment later. In the break Sharkey hugged his man. Fitz led again and landed, only to be smothered once more. This was repeated three times, and the crowd hissed and hissed. Sharkey was doing nothing but wrestling. Bob got in two hard rights, but could not reach the spot. A hot exchange followed, in which Fitz landed right and left, upper-cutting his man and breaking away easy. As Sharkey rushed again Fitz got in his celebrated left hook twice, and the sailor's career was checked. Sharkey rolled over on his back and threw up his left leg. Fitz smiled and turned to his corner. The seconds were counted off and Sharkey was carried to his corner limp as a
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 3 December 1896
The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The report describes the large crowd and preliminary bouts before the main Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, noting Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee. It details the atmosphere, attendance estimates, and the fighters' entrance into the ring.
The Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
when a succession of smashes on the jaw put Muller out. It was 10 oclock when the event of the evening was announced. The crowd cheered, and the cheers became a roar when the gladiators appeared. Fitzsimmons showed up first and received an ovation. Sharkey appeared two minutes after Fitzsimmons and his welcome was equally as warm. Fitzsimmons chatted with friends at the ringside as if a hard
The report describes the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey championship bout, noting the crowd's enthusiastic reception of both fighters before the match. A dispute erupted over Wyatt Earp serving as referee, with Sharkey's backer Martin Julian alleging bias and rumors of crookedness, which Earp denied while asserting his fairness.
The Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The report covers pre-fight disputes over the referee, with Julian accusing Earp of bias before Earp denied it and the fight proceeded. It then gives a blow-by-blow account of the opening rounds between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey.
The Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.
On the eve of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, trainers and fighters traded confident predictions while managers wrangled over selecting a referee, rejecting several candidates. At the last hour, National Club president Groom appointed Wyatt Earp, described as once a terror to lawless elements in Kansas and Arizona, to referee the fight.
The Morning Times · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
SAILOR WELL TRAINED. Sharkey was trained to the minute. He weighed 176 pounds, three pounds lighter than when he met Corbett, and many thought he was a trifle drawn. All day long Martin Julian and Danny Lynch, representing Fitz and Sharkey respectively, argued and squabbled over the selection of a referee. Hiram Cook, who refereed the Corbett-Jackson fight, was suggested by Julian, but Lynch would not hear of him, although Cook was the man put up by Lynch for the Corbett-Sharkey contest and turned down by Corbett. Al Hereford, of Baltimore, was brought up only to be thrown out, as was also Will-
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Referee Wyatt Earp certified payment of the purse to Sharkey after the controversial Fitzsimmons bout, though some backers discussed trying to block payment. Witnesses said a foul blow was likely struck, though opinions differed on whether it was intentional.
Evening Star · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY GIVEN THE PURSE.
Fitzsimmons Men Talk of Enjoining Payment.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, December 3.--A certified check for the amount of the purse was given to Sharkey by Referee Wyatt E. Earp for the fight last night. Some of Fitzsimmons' backers talk of enjoining the bank from paying the check, but it is not believed such action, if taken, would cause the bank to withhold payment to Sharkey.
It is claimed as the check was certified the bank has no option but to pay its holder. It is also declared that the decision of the referee is final, and no appeal to the courts is probable.
Physicians and newspaper men who participated in or witnessed the examination of Sharkey, after he was carried from the ring, say he was visibly wounded below the belt. Doctors say his condition is serious, but not dangerous, and have ordered him to remain in bed at least two or three days, stating that exercise, or any movement might aggravate his injuries.
Sharkey was seen in bed at this hotel this morning. He was resting easily, though suffering some pain and inconvenience.
Witnesses of the fight declared this morning that a foul blow was undoubtedly delivered, but many believe it was accidental.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va. · 4 December 1896
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 9 other papers
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim after Fitzsimmons had knocked him senseless, a decision the crowd booed as an outrage. Witnesses reported no one saw the alleged foul, and Earp fled the ring to avoid being attacked by the angry audience.
The Morning News · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ ROBBED OF THE FIGHT.
Blind to the Fact.
San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 2—Bob Fitzsimmons was to-night robbed of a victory which he had clearly earned by punching Tom Sharkey into insensibility.
See moreSee less
No one in the audience saw the foul complained of, but all saw Sharkey strike the Australian in clinches and wrestle him all over the ring a score of times. The call of time saved the sailor at the end of four rounds, and the referee finally saved him in the eighth, after Fitzsimmons had laid him low, with a couple of left hooks both of which struck the jaw.
Fitzsimmons finished without a mark on his body, and did not receive a single fair punch from the sailor in the entire contest.
As Sharkey rolled over on his back, Wyatt Earp, the referee, announced that Fitz had struck him foul with his knee, and that the decision should go to Sharkey. The decision was received with hoots and jeers and Earp disappeared just in time to avoid rough handling.
Fitz put up a clean hard fight, and though he was fouled repeatedly and wrestled all over the ring he never murmured.
San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 2.—Not since Peter Jackson and Jim Corbett danced about each other for nearly five hours before the members of the California Athletic Club, has such enormous interest been aroused in a fight between heavy-weights as that exhibited to-night at Mechanics' pavilion between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey.
Sharkey's personal popularity is in a measure responsible for this, although Fitzsimmons' reputation among the knowing ones had not a little to do with it.
A detail of 100 bluecoats was assigned to take care of the contest. Standing room was at a premium.
The long Australian came over from his training grounds early this afternoon, and rested all the afternoon on the balcony of the hotel. To a reporter for the Southern Associated Press, he announced before entering the ring: "I am suffering from a severe cold, as you can see, and it has settled in my bones, but this will not interfere with my putting the sailor to sleep in short order. I weigh just 174½ pounds, which is more flesh than I have ever carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull-like rushes. I hope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will just be to my liking."
Jack Stenzeler and Dan Hickey, who assisted Fitz in training, were beside Martin Julian in Bob's corner. Each of the trainers was confident that Fitz would make a short fight of it, despite the cold
No man ever entered a ring with more confidence in his ability to win than did Sharkey. "Australian" Billy Smith, Bob Allen and Danny Needham, who were behind the sailor, and who also trained him, had their last dollar up on their charge, so confident were they of his winning.
Sharkey was trained to the minute. He weighed 176 pounds, three pounds lighter than when he met Corbett, and many thought he was a trifle drawn.
All day long Martin Julian and Danny Lynch, representing Fitz and Sharkey, respectively, argued and squabbled over the selection of a referee. When the eleventh hour was reached the rival managers notified President Groom of the National Club that he would have to name a referee. Mr. Groom was prepared for the emergency and without hesitation he submitted the name of Wyatt Earp, who, in the early days, was a terror to the fierce element in Kansas and Arizona.
The great pavilion began to fill before 6 o'clock. Fitzsimmons' backers were found among the soft-palmed fraternity in the $10 seats. All day long the pool rooms were crowded, Fitz closing a 3 to 1 favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small dribbles, no large wagers being reported.
The pavilion contained not less than 15,000 people when the first event was called, and a more orderly crowd never assembled. A sensational story was printed in an evening paper to the effect that Police Commissioner Cunst had bet heavily on Fitzsimmons and would have Chief Crowley stop the contest should it become apparent that Sharkey would win. Mr. Cunst declared that he did not have a dollar up and that the pugilists should not be molested unless the fight became brutal. In that event Capt. Whitman, in charge of the officers, would see that the law was not violated.
Fitzsimmons entered the ring at 10:03, followed by his seconds. Bob's many San Francisco friends shrieked themselves hoarse when their favorite appeared, but their efforts were as the bark of a dog compared with the fierce yelp of a sea lion to the greeting which Sharkey received five minutes later as he vaulted into the ring, scorning to use the ladder.
Fitz sat quietly in his corner and eyed the sailor, while Sharkey surveyed his opponent critically for the first time.
The gloves were inspected and laid in the center of the ring, but where was the referee? All sorts of rumors were afloat and there was a hurried consultation between President Groom and the seconds and managers of the pugilists. Nothing but the clicking of the telegraph instruments could be heard when the men were introduced.
Still the celebrated Arizona gun fighter failed to show up.
The appearance, finally, of the noted frontiersman created more excitement than did that of the principals. The cause of the delay was explained a second later when the master of ceremonies announced that Mr. Julian refused to accept Mr. Earp.
Mr. Julian secured an audience and explained that he had accepted every reputable man's name which has been suggested, but did not propose to take any chances with a man who was professedly ignorant of the rules.
The crowd heard Mr. Julian patiently, and their sympathies were evidently with the Australian. Mr. Earp endeavored to make himself heard, but failed.
Mr. Lynch, Sharkey's manager, announced that the Fitzsimmons crowd and he could not agree on a man, consequently the selection devolved on the club. Mr. Julian remained obdurate, and there was another conference.
After a great deal of wrangling Fitzsimmons arose and shouted: "Gentlemen, I have given in to everybody in all my fights and I'll give in to this. Let Sharkey take the bandages off his hands. I have none on mine," and immediately the crowd stood up and cheered for the Cornishman.
Sharkey's bandages were removed and the men shook hands at 10:35.
Mr. Earp removed his coat and the fight apparently was on.
Round 1—They were both cautious. Fitz followed his man, led and closed with Sharkey. Tom led and missed. Another lead from Tom caught Fitz on the shoulder. Sharkey was very active, while Fitz seemed cool and settled down to his dangerous crouch. After clinching Tom hit him on the neck. Fitz's lead on the sailor was unproductive. Fitz put his right on the neck lightly, and in the clinch Sharkey lifted Fitz like a baby. The sailor was doing all the leading, but a sharp hook from Fitz sent him down. A second later Bob had his left in Tom's jaw and down went the sailor just as the gong sounded. It was evident that Fitz had lost none of his cuning and already had the sailor in "Queer" street.
Round 2—Fitz landed a stiff left on the jaw and a clinch followed. Fitz shuffled after his man while Sharkey semed rattled. A hard right sent Tom reeling, but he rallied, and landed a hot one on the neck. Tom attempted to land on the neck but failed and the men clinched. This was repeated a second later after Bob had landed a stiff right. Sharkey got another hard right a moment later and clinched to save himself. Fitz was puffing but confident, and followed his man carefully. Tom got in one on the shoulder with the left, and a red splotch resulted, and received a hot one on the jaw, which staggered him as the gong sounded. The sailor was clearly playing in great luck, as Fitz seemed to have him just where he wanted him at the call of time. Fitz scorned to sit down, and came up strong for the third round.
Round 3.—Sharkey clinched Bob and got a left on the neck. Another lead by Fitz was met with another clinch. Fitz got in a hot left on the face, but it was not in the right spot and Sharkey clinched. A little in-fighting followed, in which Sharkey held his own. Bob landed a hard right which was followed by the usual clinch. Sharkey was putting up his usual rough and tumble fight, but had not so far landed a blow fair. He led time and again, but Fitz was not there. Clinches followed in rapid succession.
Round 4—Fitz led and a clinch followed. In the breakaway Fitzsimmons slipped and fell, and as he rose Sharkey went at him like a bull, landing two hard blows on the wind. Bob sent a swift right on the neck as he recovered, and Bob followed it a minute later with another on the breast, taking a hot one in the neck in return. A rally followed, and the men clinched, Sharkey hitting Fitz twice in the clinch. Bob got the left in on Tom's jaw, and upper cut him on the heart. Tom tried an uppercut and got another blow on the head. Bob warmed up and sent in two terrific rights, closing Tom's left eye. Sharkey clawed his man on the arm and seemed to be decidedly weary as the round ended.
Round 5—Bob led and landed a right, Sharkey clinching and throwing Fitz heavily. Another left started a stream of gore from Sharkey's damaged eye and angered Sharkey, who rushed wildly and tried for the wind. A hard left sent Tom to the ropes, and he clinched again. In the breakaway Sharkey again hit foul. After the men separated Sharkey started his rushes, but Fitz stopped him with stiff lefts, and Sharkey was fighting rotten, but Earp was blind. Fitz landed two hard lefts, the last of which sent Tom on his back through the ropes. Tom was very groggy, and Fitz hit him hard twice in succession, and for the fourth time Sharkey was all but out when the gong tapped. Fitz was little distressed.
Round 6—Sharkey did not rush as stiff as before and after feeling his man Fitz landed a left punch and followed it a moment later with a hard left hook. Sharkey was leading for the stomach and clinching continually, lifting Fitz from the floor every time. Fitz let go a hard left and it landed on the chin, but did not faze his man. An upper cut a moment later sent Tom back a few feet. A heart blow from Bob forced Tom to clinch and he hit Bob foul in the break. This angered Fitz and he went at his man, staggering him with a left, also landing right and left on the chin in rapid succession. Sharkey grabbed the Australian around the knees and was hanging hard when the gong sounded. Sharkey was taking fearful punishment, but still had a fighting punch left.
Round 7.—Sharkey rushed and caught a left on the face. He wrestled Fitz and struck him in the clinch, but still Earp could not see. Sharkey was slow, and made a futile lead for the stomach. Bob was crouching low. He sent a stiff left into Sharkey's face, and the sailor clinched, and upper cut Fitz before breaking. He repeated this a moment later, and wrestled Fitz all over the ring. The crowd yelled foul and still Earp was blind. Fitz landed two hard rights and a left. Sharkey clinched each time, holding Fitz by the knees. The sailor seemed to be strong and fresh at the close of the round, but should have lost the fight on fouls at least a dozen times.
Round 8—Sharkey led and missed. Again he led and clinched. Bob put his right on the face and duplicated it a minute later. In the break away Sharkey hugged his man. Fitz led again and landed, only to be smothered once more. This was repeated three times, and the crowd hissed. Sharkey was doing nothing but wrestling. A hot exchange followed in which Fitzsimmons landed right and left, upper cutting his man and breaking away easy. As Sharkey rushed again Fitz got in his celebrated left hook twice and the sailor's career was checked. Sharkey rolled over on his back and threw up his left leg. Fitz smiled and returned to his corner. The seconds were counted off and Sharkey was carried to his corner limp as a dish-rag. He had to be carried from the ring and appeared to be greatly distressed, while Fitzsimmons was spry as a lark and did not bear a scratch.
The crowd yelled its approval and shouted for the Australian. When order was restored the referee announced Sharkey had been given the decision, he having been hit foul by Fitzsimmons. It was clearly an unfair decision, as the knockout blow was a fair punch on the jaw. The crowd became boisterous and cursed Earp loud and long.
The unanimous sentiment was that Fitzsimmons had been robbed in the most cold blooded manner.
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · 3 December 1896 · an extract
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C. · 3 December 1896 · an extract
The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J. · 3 December 1896
Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 4 December 1896
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn. · 4 December 1896
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · 4 December 1896
Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio · 4 December 1896
The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo. · 4 December 1896
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
This report describes the pre-fight buildup to the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, including betting activity, crowd size, and the surprise naming of Wyatt Earp as referee by Club President Groom. The fighters have entered the ring and are being inspected, but a delay occurs as officials realize gloves are present but something is still missing before the fight can begin.
The Morning News · 3 December 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Before the fight began, Sharkey's manager Martin Julian objected to Wyatt Earp serving as referee, citing rumors of crookedness and a tip that a decision against Sharkey was planned. Earp denied the accusation and Sharkey's backer Dan Lynch said Sharkey was ready to fight under the referee chosen per prior agreement.
The Indianapolis Journal · 3 December 1896 · page 2
Atslnnt the? Ilefercc. It was 10 o'clock when tho event of trie ev ninr was announced. The crowd cheered anl the cheers lxcame a roar when the lt)-d!ators a reared. Fitz showed up fresh and received an ovation. Sharkey appeared two minutes after Fltzslmmons, and hla welcome was equally as warm. Fitz chatted with friends at the ring siu aa If a liaxd tight were not on his hand. When Snarkey entered the rinj; Hob walked across the rlnjr ami shook hands cordially with the fahor and his seconds. Roth mm ere en veloped In lon?
See moreSee less
black robo. which they threw off befor, putting on the Kloves. It was then the disparity in the iAiiul of the two men was plainly Men. Fitz. lean, long and Mnewy. looked like a panther, while Sharkey, ntocky and sturdy, with his Im mense1 muscular development, resembled a gTizzly hear. Sharkey wore a green sash with red. white and blue trimmings. Hia rteht hand was bandaged. Fitz was Intro duced as champion of the world, which evoked a howl of approval. 'there was littie delay before Referee Karp appeared. Announcer Jordan said that owintf to rumors of crookednc-ss Mar tin Julian refused to accept Earp . as referee. Julian raid ho Bugptcd several men to Sharkey" backers this morning:, but all were re.cted. He said a San Fran cisco porllusr rran had come to him to-day and said a referee had intended to i?lve a decision against his man. This statement was received vlth hisses and Jeers. Earp made a speech, uenytng Julian's statement. paying ho was square Then. Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, said Sharkey had lived was ready to light with the referee selected by the National Club as per agreement, tho men's backers having failed to agree on a referee prior to 12 o'clock to-day. During the arguments Sharkey and Fitz sat uncon cernedly In their corners, apparently ob livious. Announcer Jordan said that Julian was ready to tako any referee In tho house ex cept Earp. Then there was some more consultation, while the crowd howled Earp." Julian's charge against Earp was a surprise, as the Arizona man has always enjoyed a reputation as a "square sport." Fitz said he had given up his referee in all his fights and would give in to this. Then he stripped off his black role and addet that he would insist that Sh.nvey take th bandacea off hia hand, as he had none o. hi. Sharkey . continued to tie his gloves a rwl n-1 t t o ttont Inn tn t'if j'lmTnnim' f1 rnar.d. Hut 'the referee walked over and examined the bandages complained of and Sharkey then removed the objectionable articlesThe men shook handa at lu:) o'clock.
A massive crowd, including women for the first time, packed the arena to watch Fitzsimmons fight Sharkey, with Wyatt Earp serving as referee amid disputes over hand bandages and allegations of bias. The report describes the pre-fight atmosphere and the start of the bout.
Rock Island Argus · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
GREAT CROWD TO SEE THE MILL
was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring.
It was 10 o'clock when the event of the evening was announced. The crowd cheered and the cheers became a roar when the gladiators appeared. Fitzsimmons showed up first and received an ovation. Sharkey appeared in the ring shortly after. Both men were enveloped in long black robes which they threw off before putting on the gloves. It was then the disparity in the build of the two men was plainly seen. Fitzsimmons, lean and long, and sinewy, looked like a panther, while Sharkey, stocky and sturdy, with his immense muscular development, resembled a grizzly bear.
See moreSee less
Announcer Jordan announced that Julian was ready to take any referee in the house except Earp. Then there was some more consultation, while the crowd howled "Earp." Julian said that a San Francisco sporting man had come to him yesterday and said the referee intended to give a decision against his man. Earp denied the charge, and Fitzsimmons said he had given up his referee in all his fights and would give in to this. Then he stripped off his black robe and added that he would insist that Sharkey take the bandages off his hands, as he had none on his. Sharkey had on his gloves, and paid no attention to Fitzsimmons' demand, but the referee walked over and examined the bandages complained of and Sharkey then removed the objectionable articles.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · and 1 other paper
A massive crowd, including women admitted for the first time, packed the pavilion to see the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, with Wyatt Earp chosen late in the afternoon as referee. The report also covers preliminary matches and details on the fighters' measurements before the main event.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
escorted the spectators to their seats.
Long before the fighters appeared in the ring a solid mass of humanity was banked from one end of the pavilion to the other. There was no lack of enthusiasm at any stage of the fight and notwithstanding the long delay before the actual "event of the evening" occurred, there was nothing but he greatest good nature prevailing everywhere and there was not the slightest sign of a disturbance.
See moreSee less
Several preliminary events preceded the chief event, and it was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring.
One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander being five feet, eleven and three-quarters inches, and Sharkey five feet, eight and one-quarter inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds.
The seconds of Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner; for Sharkey, George Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham.
WYATT ERP, REFEREE.
Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee late this afternoon.
It was fully 9 o'clock before the great crowd began to make an impression on the vast amount of vacant seats. Outside of the pavilion stood a crowd estimated at 10,000, which commenced to assemble as early as 6 o'clock. It is estimated that the National club took in at least $40,000 at the box office.
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 3 December 1896
The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.
A detailed first-person account of the Fitzsimmons versus Sharkey boxing match describes the crowd, betting odds, and physical stats of the fighters before giving a round-by-round description of the bout. Wyatt Earp, described as a famous Arizona stage driver with gunfight experience, is noted as the referee of the contest.
The Evening Bulletin · 3 December 1896 · page 1
THE DECISION GIVEN TO SHARKEY
Vhlch Took Place In tho Mechanic's Pa vlllon In San Francisco. San Francisco, Dec. 3. No event In the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast every attracted public attention here as did the battle botween tho heavy weights, Robert Fitzsimmoii3 and Thomas Sharkey, last night. Between 15,000 and 20,000 people occupied all the available space in tho big Mechanics Pavilion and watched the contest, which every one regarded as practically decid ing tho championship of tho world. Every seat in tho building was occu pied and thousands of men stood up back of tho rows of chairs.
See moreSee less
One uuiquo featuro of tho night was tho fact that for the first time in the history of pugi lism tho management of the club threw open tho doors to women, and several hundred women wero in attendanco, 6ome of them gray-haired matrons, whoso enthusiasm on tho subject has led them to venture beyond tho bounds of conventionality. The betting public naturally leaned toward tho man of experience, and the odds in Fitzsimmons' favor averaged about 2 1-2 to 1, in somofow cases going as high as 4 to 1, and just before tho fight started tho prevailing odds wero about 20 to 9. There was no lack of Sharkey money at theso figures and many bets wero offered at even monoy and accepted that Fitzsimmons would put his man out within six rounds. Long before tho fighters appeared in tho ring a solid mass of humanity was banked in the front end of tho pavilion. There was no lack of enthusiasm at any stage of the fight and notwithstanding tho long delay before tho "event of tho evening" occurred there was nothing but tho greatest good naturo prevailing everywhere and there was not tho slightest sign of a disturbance. Several preliminary events preceded tho phief event, and it was very lato when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey ap peared in tho ring. One of the most noticeable differences in tho men was in regard to height, tho New Zealnnder being 5 feet, 11 8-4 inches and Sharkey 5 feet, 8 1-4 inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds. Tho seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner. For Sharkey, George Allen, Austra
The San Francisco fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey drew massive betting interest, with Fitzsimmons the heavy favorite. The report describes Fitzsimmons knocking out Sharkey in the eighth round with what it calls a clean blow, but referee Wyatt Earp ruled it a foul, awarding the fight to Sharkey.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY WINS Fitz Robbed of the Fight by Referee Earp. Had Sharkey at Mercy and Knocked Him Out In Eighth By a Clean, Fair Blow. But Referee Called it a Foul.
San Francisco, Dec. 2.—Not since Peter Jackson and Jim Corbett danced about each other for nearly five hours before the members of the California Athletic Club, has such enormous interest been aroused here in the fight between heavyweights as that exhibitted, tonight, in the contest at Mechanics' Pavilion between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey. The pool rooms were crowded all day, Fitzsimmons closing a 3 to 1 favorite. Sharkey's money was plentiful but came in small driboles, and no large wagers were reported.
Fitzsimons came from the training grounds early this afternoon. Just before entering the ring he said to a reporter:
See moreSee less
"I am suffering from a severe cold and it has settled in my bones, but this will not interfere with my putting the sailor to sleep in short order. I weigh just 174½ pounds, which is more flesh than I ever carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull like rushes. I hope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will just be to my liking."
No man ever entered a ring with more confidence in his ability to win than did Tom Sharkey. He weighed 176 pounds, three pounds lighter than when
In a heavily anticipated heavyweight bout in San Francisco, Bob Fitzsimmons knocked out Tom Sharkey, but referee Wyatt Earp ruled the knockout blow a foul, awarding the fight to Sharkey. The crowd did not approve of the decision.
The Portland Daily Press · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
WAS A FOUL ONE.
TO CURE A COLD IN ONE DAY Take laxative Bromo Quinine Tablets All druggists refund the money if it fails to cure
before the members of the California athletic club, has such enormous interest been aroused here in a fight between heavy weights as that exhibited tonight in the contest at the Mechanics' pavilion, between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey. The pool rooms were crowded all day, Fitzsimmons closing 3 to 1 a favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small driblets. No large wagers were reported.
The report describes the contentious selection of Wyatt Earp as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout after managers argued, and gives a blow-by-blow account of the fight's opening rounds. It notes Julian's initial objection to Earp, the crowd's approval, and the action through round three.
The Portland Daily Press · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
All day long Martin Julian and Danny Lynch, representing Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, argued and squabbled over the selection of a referee. When the eleventh hour was reached the rival managers notified President Groom of the National club that he would have to name a referee. Mr. Groom submitted the name of Wyatt Earp, who, in the early days was a terror to the fierce element in Kansas.
Fitzsimmons came over from the training grounds early this afternoon. Just before entering the ring he said: "I am suffering from a severe cold and it has settled in my bones. This will not interfere with the contest, however. I weigh 174 1-2 pounds, which is more flesh than I ever carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull like rushes. I hope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will be to my liking."
See moreSee less
Jack Stenseler and Dan Hicks were beside Martin Julian in Bob's corner. No man ever entered a ring with more confidence in his ability to win than did Tom Sharkey. Billy Smith and Danny Needham were behind the sailor.
Sharkey was trained to the last minute, weighing 176 pounds. The great pavilion began to fill before six. Sharkey's friends monopolized the upper gallery and all the shouting for him was from the cheaper seats. The pavilion contained no less than 15,000 people when the first event was called. The police fringed the ring side and seventy-five officers were about the hall, preserving order and preventing confusion.
Fitzsimmons entered the ring at 10.30. Five minutes later Sharkey vaulted into the ring. The referee failed for some time to appear. Soon after he appeared, the master of ceremonies announced that Mr. Julian refused to accept Mr. Earp. Julian stated that he did not propose to take any chances with a man who was professedly ignorant of the rules. After some more talk, Julian shouted that he was willing to have a referee selected from the audience and the crowd yelled for Earp. The men shook hands at 10.35. Mr. Earp removed his coat and the fight was on.
Round 1—They were both cautious. Fitz followed his man, led and closed with Sharkey. A lead from Tom caught Fitz on the shoulder. Sharkey was very active, while Fitz was cool and settled down to his dangerous crouch. After clinching, Tom hit him on the neck. Fitz's leads at the sailor were unproductive.
Fitz put his right on the neck lightly, and in the clinch Tom lifted Fitz like a baby. The sailor was now doing all the leading, but a sharp hook from Fitz sent him down. A second later Bob had his left on Tom's jaw and down went the sailor just as the gong sounded.
Round 2.—Fitz landed a stiff left on the jaw and a clinch followed. Fitz shuffled after his man. Sharkey seemed rattled. A hard right sent Tom reeling. He rallied and landed a hot one on the wind. Tom attempted to land a left, but failed and the men clinched. This was repeated a second later after each landed a stiff right. Sharkey got another hard right a moment later and clinched to save himself. Fitz was puffing, but confident, and followed his man carefully. Tom got in one on the shoulder with his left and a red splotch resulted and received a hot one which staggered him. The sailor was clearly playing in great luck for the gong sounded as Fitz seemed to have him where he wanted him at the call of time.
Round 3.—Sharkey clinched Bob and got a left on the neck. Another lead by Fitz met with a clinch. Fitz got in a hot left on the face. A little in fighting followed, in which Sharkey held his own and landed a hard right, followed by the usual clinch. Sharkey was putting up his usual rough and tumble fight and had not so far landed a blow fairly. Just before the bell sounded, Tom made an ugly swing which had it landed would have been a palpable foul. There were shouts of foul and Sharkey was cautious.
Round 4.—Fitz led and a clinch followed. In the breakaway, Fitz slipped and fell. As he arose Sharkey went at him like a bull, landing two hard blows on the wind. Bob sent a swift right on the neck and followed it a minute later with another on the breast taking a hot one in the neck in return. A rally followed and the men clinched, Sharkey hitting Fitz twice in the clinch. Bob got a left on Tom's jaw and an upper cut on the heart. Tom tried to upper cut and got another blow on the head. Bob warmed up and sent in two terrific rights, closing Tom's right eye.
Sharkey seemed to be decidedly weary as the round closed. Time saved the sailor.
Round 5—A left started the blood from Sharkey's damaged eye and angered Sharkey who rushed wildly and tried for wind. A hard left sent Tom to the ropes and he clinched again. After the men separated Sharkey started his rushes. Fitz stopped him with a stiff right. Fitz landed two hard lefts which sent Tom on his knees to the ropes. For the fourth time the gong saved him. Fitz was distressed. The only sign of trouble he showed was a lame left arm.
Round 6.—Sharkey did not rush as stiff as before and after feeling his man Fitz landed a left punch followed with a hard left. Sharkey was leading for the stomach and clinching continually, lifting Fitz from the floor every time.
Toward the close of the eighth round, as Sharkey rushed, Fitz got in his celebrated left hook twice and the sailor's career was checked. Sharkey rolled over
A massive crowd including women attended the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, with Wyatt Earp chosen as referee late in the day. The report describes the opening rounds blow-by-blow as the fight gets underway.
The Saint Paul Globe · 3 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
NEARLY 20,000 PEOPLE
banked in front of the pavilion. There was no lack of enthusiasm at any stage of the fight and notwithstanding the long delay before the "event of the evening" occurred, there was nothing but the greatest good nature prevailing everywhere and there was not the slightest disturbance. Several preliminary events preceded the chief event and it was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring.
One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander 5 feet 11¾ inches, and Sharkey 5 feet 8¼ inches. Each of the
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the win over Fitzsimmons on a claimed foul, despite Fitzsimmons dominating the fight and Sharkey appearing knocked out. Witnesses reported Sharkey repeatedly fought unfairly while Fitzsimmons fought cleanly, and the foul could not even be verified from the press stand.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
It was Fitzsimmons' fight from start to finish. He fought fairly, while the sailor continually used foul tactics. He would clinch and lift Fitzsimmons from his feet, strike in a clinch, though the men had previously agreed not to do so, and he was generally unfair. Several times during the fight Fitzsimmons had the sailor going but could not land a knockout blow. In the eighth Sharkey started in to do the leading, but seldom landed. Bob
At a packed San Francisco pavilion, referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul after Fitzsimmons' punch dropped him, though the alleged foul was not visible from the press stand and the crowd jeered the decision. The report notes Fitzsimmons dominated the bout and that Sharkey had used repeated illegal tactics throughout.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
2.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted public attention here as did the battle between the heavyweights, Robert Fitzsimmons and
A packed crowd including women attended the heavily anticipated Fitzsimmons vs. Sharkey boxing match, with Wyatt Earp chosen late in the day as referee. The report describes the arena, preliminary bout, and the fighters' entrance before the main event begins.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
chief event and it was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring. One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander being 5 feet, 11¾ inches and Sharkey 5 feet 8¼ inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds. The seconds for Fitz were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Selzner. For Sharkey, George Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham. Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee late in the afternoon.
The report describes the massive crowd and preliminary bouts before the main event between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, noting Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee that afternoon. It details fighter statistics, seconds, and the atmosphere just before the main event was announced at 10 o'clock.
Omaha Daily Bee · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
gard to teight, Fitzsimmons being 5 feet, 11¾ inches, and Sharkey, 5 feet, 8¼ inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds. The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Selzner. For Sharkey, George Allen, "Australian Billy" Smith and Danny Needham. Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee late this afternoon.
The report describes the final preparations for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, including weigh-ins, training camps, and a day-long dispute over selecting a referee. When managers could not agree, club president Groom appointed Wyatt Earp, former Western lawman, to referee the bout before 15,000 spectators.
The Charlotte Democrat · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
HARD TO GET A REFEREE.
was a terror to the fierce element in Kansas and Arizona. The great pavilion began to fill before 6 o'clock. Sharkey's friends monopolized the upper gallery, and all the shouting for the sailor came from the cheaper seats. Fitzsimmons' backers were to be found among the soft-palmed fraternity in the $10 seats. The sunny face of Captain Rees peeped out from between those of Riley Grannan and Eddy Gaines. The pockets of the three bulged with Fitzsimmons cash. Behind the chorus of horsemen was a coterie of prominent attorneys, a round dozen of judges and any quantity of millionaires and other celebrities.
See moreSee less
All day long the pool rooms were crowded, Fizsimmons closing at 3 to 1, favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small dribs, no large wagers being reported.
At a massive San Francisco bout watched by up to 20,000, Fitzsimmons appeared to be winning against Sharkey with a strong right-left combination to the chin. However, referee Wyatt Earp halted the fight and declared it a foul, a controversial decision given Fitzsimmons' apparent dominance.
The News & Observer · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
BUT GOES FIGHT ON "FOUL"
IT WAS FITZ'S FROM THE START
A Swinging Right With a Crook of the Left on the Chin Did the Work-- Why Earp Claimed "Foul"-- 20.000 People Present
See moreSee less
Mechanics Pavilion, San Francisco, Dec. 2.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted public attention here as did the battle between the heavy weights, Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey to-night.
Between 15,000 and 20,000 people occupied all the available space in the big Mechanic's pavilion and watched the contest which every one regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world. The long, lean New Zealander man who has had a succession of victories in the United States for the last five or six years entered the ring to-night with almost every apparent advantage in his favor. He could count upon his experience and science; his height and reach, and every other quality which enters into the making of a successful prize fighter. Against him was the sailor lad who was unknown six months ago, but who rose to fame recently when he came perilously near trailing in the dust the colors of Califronia's idol, James J. Corbett. Against the science and experience and the superior height and reach of Fitzsimmons was Sharkey, with his youth and strength, probably one of the greatest examples of muscular development that the prize ring has produced.
Both men had trained hard before the contest and particularly during the last few days and each had expressed the utmost confidence in his ability to gain a victory and the ten thousand purse which the National Athletic club offered the victor. Although the contest was limited to ten rounds there was hardly a spectator in the pavilion to-night who did not expect to see one or the other of the fighters go down to defeat before the full limit of the fight had been reached.
The betting public naturally leaned toward the man of experience and the odds in Fitzsimmons's favor averaged about 2½ to 1. Many bets were offered
The report sets the scene for the heavily anticipated Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, detailing the fighters' builds, training, and the betting odds favoring Fitzsimmons. It notes the unprecedented attendance of women at the event and identifies Wyatt Earp as the chosen referee just before the bout begins.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The News & Observer · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
IT WAS FITZ'S FROM THE START
the bounds of conventionality. One hundred police and many more special officers were in attendance and a hundred ushers in evening dress escorted the parties to their seats. Several preliminary events preceded the chief event and it was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring. One of the noticeable differences of the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander being 5 feet 11¾ inches and Sharkey 5 feet 8¼ inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 poinds. The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner; for Sharkey, Geo. Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham.
The report describes the scene before the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, including the fighters' measurements, seconds, and crowd reaction. It also recounts a dispute when Julian objected to Wyatt Earp as referee over rumors of bias, which Earp denied before the fight proceeded.
The News & Observer · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
IT WAS FITZ'S FROM THE START
ner; for Sharkey, Geo. Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham.
Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver who has figured in many a gun fight on the border was chosen referee.
See moreSee less
It was 10 o'clock when the event of the evening was announced, the crowd cheered and the cheers became a roar when the gladiators appeared. Fitzsimmons showed up fresh and received an ovation.
Sharkey appeared two minutes after Fitzsimmons and his welcome was equally as warm. Fitzsimmons chatted with friends at the ring side as if a hard fight were not on his hands. When Sharkey entered the ring Bob walked across the ring and shook hands cordially with the sailor with his seconds. Both men were enveloped in long black robes which they threw off before putting on the gloves. It was then the disparity in the build of the two men was plainly seen. Fitzsimmons, lean and long and sinewy, looked like a panther, while Sharkey, stocky and sturdy with his immense muscular developments resembled a grizzly bear.
Sharkey wore a green sash, with red, white and blue trimmings. His right hand was bandaged. Fitzsimmons was introduced as champion of the world, which was received by a howl of approval. There was a little delay before referee Earp appeared.
The announcer said that owing to rumors of crookedness, Martin Julian refused to accept Earp as referee. Julian says he suggested several men to Sharkey's backers this morning, but all were rejected.
He says a San Franisco sporting man had come to him to-day and said the referee had intended to give a decision against his man. This statement was received with hisses and jeers. Earp made a speech denying Julian's statment saying he was square. After more talk Fitzsimmons said he had given up his referee in all his fights and would give in to this. Then he stripped off his black robe and added that he would insist that Sharkey take the bandages off his hand as he had none on his.
Sharkey continued to tie his gloves and paid no attention to Fitzsimmons's demand.
But the referee walked over and examined the bandages complained off and Sharkey then removed the objectionable articles.
10:39. The men shake hands.
Round 1—The men advanced to the centre of the ring and sparred for a moment. Fitzsimmons feinted several times with left, but Sharkey gets away. Fitzsimmons landed lightly right on head, Sharkey clinches. Sharkey swings left at Fitzsimmons body and a moment landed hard left swing on Fitz's neck.
Sharkey landed right and left on Fitz's head and ducked vicious left swing. Sharkey tried with right for head, but Fitzsimmons gets away. Sharkey ducked hard right swing. Sharkey tried for body and rushes Fitz, landing left on body. Sharkey landed left and got same in return. Fitzsimmons knocks Sharkey down with right twice in jaw.
Round ended with Sharkey in corner and Fitz trying for neck.
Round 2.—Fitz standing up before time is called. Men sparred and Fitz landed light left on face. Sharkey rushed, but Fitz clinched. Fitz swings right and left, but misses. Sharkey landed hard left on chest. Fitz tried left for face, but got light left on head. Fitzsimmons ducked hard left. Sharkey ducked left and clinched. Fitz swung right, but missed and then landed left on head. Fitzsimmons landed right on head. Fitzsimmons landed left on body. Sharkey missed right and left for the head. Sharkey landed right and left on head and neck and got two in return. Fitz ducks right swing. Fitz tried left for the head and missed.
Round ended with Fitz aggressor.
Round 3.—Fitz rushed, but Sharkey ducks and clinches low. Sharkey tried for body and then clinched. Fitz swings right and left on the head. Sharkey swings right and left, but with little damage.
Fitz staggered Sharkey with right. Sharkey swung left on head. Fitz swings left and Sharkey ducks.
Sharkey landed left on face. Sharkey landed hard left in the wind and got away. Sharkey ducks hard left swing. Sharkey doing most of the leading for the wind and again landing left on wind. Fitz evidently laying to get in right on jaw.
Round 4.—Sharkey landed left. Sharkey kicks Fitz down with a left in the wind. He then ducks left swing and landed left in wind three times without a return. Fitz fighting carefully. Sharkey ducks right swing. Fitz landed left. Sharkey landed left on face and wind and rushed Fitz to the ropes. Fitzsimmons clinched. Fitzsimmons tried left for head twice and missed. Sharkey tried for wind and missed. Sharkey landed left on the wind and left on head. Sharkey landed left swing on head staggering Fitzsimmons. Fitz swung right and left, staggering Sharkey. Honors even.
A dispatch reports bookmakers refusing to pay bets on the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight after a disputed decision, with Spreckles calling it a 'steal' and claims that referee Wyatt Earp was 'fixed.' Promoter Julian says he was told before the fight that Earp would rule against Fitzsimmons regardless of outcome, while the referee insists he ruled Sharkey the winner due to a deliberate foul.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Bookmakers Refuse to Pay Bets and it May Kill Sparring in Frisco.
NEW YORK, Dec. 3.—A special to the World on the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight says few bets will be paid on the fight today, bookmakers having decided not to pay unless compelled to by a legal process. Adolph Spreckles, son of the sugar king, declares if decision stands he will do all in his power to have boxing stopped in San Francisco. He calls the decision a big steal. President Green denies being implicated in any steal and voiced Spreckles' sentiment as to the outrageous decision. James O'Neil, one of the biggest bookmakers of the country, says Fitzsimmons earned the contest and he will not give up to Sharkey's backers. After the fight the referee could not be found even by his most intimate friends. This morning, however, he was seen and declared that in giving his decision he was only doing what he considered his duty as he thought Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled Sharkey and under the rules the sailor was entitled to the decision.
See moreSee less
After the fight was over Julian at the suggestion of Fitzsimmons, gave out the statement that about 6.30 last evening Mose Guntz, Riley Grannon and Tom Jones came to them and said Earp was "fixed" and that they would not get decision even though Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out. But rather than
In a San Francisco boxing match before 15,000-20,000 spectators, Fitzsimmons dominated Sharkey throughout the fight. Referee Wyatt Earp nonetheless awarded the victory to Sharkey in the eighth round, ruling that Fitzsimmons had delivered a foul blow.
Gloucester County Democrat · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Fitz Won, Sharkey Got the Decision. SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3.—The fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey in this city last evening was witnessed by 15,000 to 20,000 people, including several hundred woman. Sharkey was no match for Fitz, and the fight was the Australian's throughout. Notwithstanding this, Referee Earp awarded the contest to Sharkey in the eighth round, declaring that he had been knocked out by a foul. Sharkey was was carried from the ring unconscious.
Following the disputed Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, referee Wyatt Earp telegraphs newspapers defending his foul decision, describing Fitzsimmons' blow as striking Sharkey below the belt. The report also covers Sharkey's claims of being cheated of victory, Corbett's telegram sympathizing with Sharkey, and threats of legal action over the prize money.
Las Vegas Daily Optic · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CHIPPEWA FALLS FLOOD
SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., December 3 —"I was simply robbed of $10,000 by that decision" said Fitzsimmons after last night's battle. "I felt sure I was going against the worst of it, when Earp was named, but my reputation was at stake, and I took the chances. I never struck a foul blow in my life and no one knows better than Sharkey that I won last night's fight, fair and square. Look at me. Do you see a single mark or scratch? Did I get a good solid punch? Why, that dub is simply a strong, young wrestler, and one of the foulest boxers I ever saw. Nobody can get a square deal from thieves, who handle the fight in this town. I now believe that Corbett was robbed of the decision here in the Jackson fight."
See moreSee less
Sharkey asserts that he had the best of every round and would certainly have won had he not been fouled.
Sporting writers are unanimous in saying that the "sailor" is the luckiest man that ever stepped into a ring. Sharkey announces his willingness to meet all comers for the world's championship.
Julian will ask for an injunction restraining the bank from paying Sharkey the check, for the purse, and the matter may be taken to the courts.
SAN FRANCISCO, California, December 3.—Tom Sharkey, who was knocked insensible by Fitzsimmons, in last night's fight, appears to be resting easily to-day. At 10 o'clock this morning he was reported asleep. A police officer is on watch at Sharkey's quarters, and if the condition of the pugilist becomes serious, Fitzsimmons will be arrested.
Referee Wyatt Earp explains he awarded the fight to Sharkey after judging that Fitzsimmons fouled him with a low blow in the eighth round. Fitzsimmons denies fouling Sharkey, claims he landed a legal body blow, and accuses San Francisco fight promoters of corruption.
Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 3 December 1896 · page 1
GABBLE OF THE PUGILISTS
Francisco Sports in Bitter Lan guage Oorbett Chips In. San Franoisoo, Deo. 8, Rsferee Earp, whose deoision in the Sharkey-Fitzsim-mons fight oansed an indignant demon stration from the crowd at the ring side last night, stated this morning that he decided the oontest in favor of Sharkey because he believed that Fitz deliberately fonled him. He said: "I should have given Sharkey the fight earlier in the oontest. In the fonrth round, I think, Fitz landed a left handed blow and returned with his elbow, cutting Sharkey's eyebrow open. The foul blow of the eighth ronnu was seen plainly by me.
See moreSee less
Fitz smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder; then, with an upper cut with his left, struck the Bailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over and the blow knooked him down. It was olearly a foul." Fitzsimmons said: "Earp knows, and so does Sharkey, that I didn't hit the sailor where they Bay I did. My left landed straight in his stomach, where I had the tight to hit him, and no other place. His lying down and groaning was all b part of the game. There was no need for me to fonl him, because I had him whipped anyway and could have fin ished him before the end of the round. As I telegraphed Dan Stuart last night, I am willing to meet both Sharkey and Corbett in the same ring any night Stnart wants to pull a fight off. I don't blame Corbett for saying that he was robbed in the Jackson fight in this town. No pugi list can get a square deal from the thieves who handle the fighting in this oity aud it is a safe bet that the last big fight San Franoisoo will ever see was pulled off last night." Sharkey Baid: "I am oertain that Fitz fouled me deliberately to save himself from defeat. Had he uot delivered that nasty blow, whioh crippled me, I wouid certainly have finished him in that round. I intend to win the world's ohampionship, if the deoision of this oontest has not already given me the right to that title." COBBITT TO BHABKXY.
Referee Wyatt Earp was initially rejected by Sharkey's camp over bias rumors, but Fitzsimmons agreed to accept him anyway. After Fitzsimmons appeared to knock Sharkey out in the eighth round, Earp controversially ruled it a foul blow and awarded the fight to Sharkey.
The Sun · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY GETS THE FIGHT. FITZ BEATS HIS MAN BUT LOSES BY THE REFEREE'S DECISION. Sharkey Was Knocked Out In the Eighth Round. But Earp Called the Blow a Foul and Gave Him the Fight, Although the Sailor Had Fought Foul All Through.
ago has such great interest been aroused in a fistic contest as that exhibited to-night in the ten-round bout, for a purse of $10,000, between Champion Bob Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey, the sailor-pugilist, in the old Mechanics' Pavilion on Larkin street.
At seven minutes after 10 Fitz appeared in the ring, being warmly received. Three minutes later Sharkey entered the ring. Both men appeared in great form.
See moreSee less
Ten minutes of tedious waiting followed before the appearance of Wyatt Earp, the referee, Jordan, manager of ceremonies, then announced, after introducing Earp, that, owing to rumors which had reached Julian about Earp's prejudice, he refused to accept Earp.
After a long wrangle Fitzsimmons suddenly rose and said:
"I am so anxious to fight that I will give into this and accept Earp as referee."
A moment after he said: "I want Sharkey to take off those bandages on his hands, I have none on mine."
This report describes the early rounds of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in which Wyatt Earp was controversially accepted as referee after Fitzsimmons agreed to the choice. It details Fitzsimmons dominating the early rounds with powerful punches while Sharkey resorted to foul tactics.
The Sun · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ BEATS HIS MAN BUT LOSES
groggy, but the call of time saved him. Second Round—Sharkey tried to force the fight, but got a right-hander clean in the mouth, and rushed like a bull, but Fitz kept him off with his left in a masterly manner. Sharkey landed right and left on Fitz's breast, but the blows did no damage. Fitz again reached the sailor's jaw with his right, a full clean blow which dazed the sailor. Sharkey tried foul work at close range, but the referee stopped him. In this round Sharkey's tactics were evidently to get in left swings at short range, but he failed. Third Round.—Sharkey showed signs of
The report narrates rounds three through eight of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, describing Sharkey's repeated foul tactics and low blows against Fitzsimmons' clean punching. It concludes with Fitzsimmons battering Sharkey until he falls and is counted out.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sun · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ BEATS HIS MAN BUT LOSES
seemed to have little effect on Sharkey.
FIFTH ROUND.—Sharkey again fouled by grabbing Fitz below the belt and trying to throw him. Earp did good work in separating them. Sharkey then tried a left hook, but failed, and he followed this with a right hander on the chin. Fitz landed two straight rights on Sharkey's face knock
A special dispatch describes the heavily bet-on Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout in San Francisco, noting controversy over Wyatt Earp's appointment as referee amid cries of 'Fake.' It recounts the early rounds of the fight, ending mid-description as Sharkey was knocked down.
Morning Appeal · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE CHAMPION. And Is Knocked Cold By a Foul Blow In the Eighth Round.
(Special to the Appeal) San Francisco Dec. 2—The town is all excitement and the pavilion promises to be packed. Outside the whole city is waiting to hear the result. The talent is dumping its money on Fitzsimmons and the race track people are on deck with large wads.
See moreSee less
Every time two dollars strikes the box there is a ready dollar of marine money to meet it. Every sailor in San Francisco who has a dollar, has it up on Sharkey and at 8:30 it was even money that Sharkey would be in the ring fighting when the gong taps for the 7th, round. Wires run from the ring side to all the pool rooms and leading saloons of the city.
At 10:30 Fitzsimmons was in the ring and shortly after Sharkey showed up. He was better trained than when he fought Corbett. Fitzsimmons greeted Sharkey warmly as they shook hands. He then went over and was in whispered conversation with some race track men when Wyatt Earp was announced as referee. Julien, on behalf of Fitzsimmons, objected to Earp on the ground that there were rumors of crooked work. There was a great uproar and cries of "Fake," "Fake" and calls for Hiram Cook.
This report gives a live, round-by-round description of the Fitzsimmons versus Sharkey boxing match, noting the uproar when Wyatt Earp was announced as referee amid rumors of a fix. It covers the action through round seven, with Fitzsimmons appearing to dominate late rounds.
Morning Appeal · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Hiram Cook.
After considerable squabbling Earp was allowed to referee the fight.
See moreSee less
At 10:42 the first round opened. Fitzsimmons made two leads, but failed to land; Sharkey rushed his man, Fitxsimmons holding back for an opening; Sharkey landed heavily on Fitz's stomach; Fitz shot in aa uppercut and landed heavily and then mixed. Fitz met Sharkey's rush and knocked him off his feet and followed his advantage; he wound up the round with a hookback and Sharkey went to his corner somewhat distressed:
Round 2—Long range sparring. Sharkey very active on his feet. Fitz swings, falls short and Sharkey reaches his chest with heavy right. Fitz rushes and the sailor stops him with left jolt on the body. Sailor mills on the retreat and shows good generalship. In the infighting Sharkey has the best of it. Fitz leads twice on the sailors head, but with little effect.
Round 3—Fitz rushes and swings right and left. Sharkey ducks; Fitz lands with left. They mix again and the exchanges are very heavy; Sharkey gets in a stiff jolt in the jaw and is pressing his man hard; Sharkey has his man nearly stopped and has the best of the round at the end.
Round 4—Sharkey rushes and knocks Bob full length; Bob on the retreat and the Navy Yard crowd howling like wild men. Sharkey lands left on wind and gets a right cross; Bob is worried and Sharkey rushes him to his corner and lands three times on Fitz's wind. Fitz tries to land a knockout, but can't get the sailor off his guard. Sailor like a tiger on his feet.
Round 5—Bob forces the fighting and has the best of the round and lands several rights on the sailor's jaw. Sharkey hitting low and crowd hisses. Lands a stiff on Fitz's jaw. Fitz knocks sailor down. Sharkey groggy and clinching to save himself. Foul play by Sharkey.
Round 6—Fitz forces the fight and his blows rattle Sharkey. Sailor's eyes black, Fitz shows more steam and jabs with telling effect; Sharkey goes to his corner with face covered with blood.
Round 7—Fitz after the sailor like a tiger, lands with both hands. Sharkey gets better of mix up and sends Fitz back with stiff right, evening matters up but fighting foul. Fitz not so fast and sailor lands frequently: Sailor has best of it
Round 8—Fitz lands frequently Sharkey walks up and lands sqaure on Fitz's face. Fitz returns and knocks him square on his back and his seconds take him to his corner limp as a dishrag. Great uproar, Police clear the ring. Referee gives the fight to Sharkey on the ground that Fitz fouled him in the last round. The crowd are greatly dissatisfied with the decision: The referee and those nearest the ring insist that the last blow that Fitzsimmons delivered which knocked Sharkey out was below the belt given simultainously with the one on the face.
"All the Comforts of a Home" at the Opeoa House to-morrow night. The seats are going at a speed only attained ty an air ship.
A report from San Francisco describes the heavily attended Fitzsimmons-Sharkey heavyweight boxing match, noting betting odds and crowd details. Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee, but Martin Julian, Sharkey's backer, refused to accept him amid rumors of crookedness.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Capital Journal · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
One hnudred police and as many more special officers were in attendance and a hundred ushers, escorted the spectators to their seats.
Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds.
See moreSee less
The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin and Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelznsr; for Sharkey—Geo. Allen
The report describes the December 1896 San Francisco fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, won by Sharkey on a foul in the eighth round despite Fitzsimmons dominating. It states referee Wyatt Earp was suspected beforehand of favoring Sharkey, and Fitzsimmons claims he was robbed by the decision.
The Dalles Daily Chronicle · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Dalles.
ing out out the hole made by the ice-pick, which was followed with a probe for five inches. Her recovery is not anticipated, and death from septic meningitis is considered only a question of time.
See moreSee less
The marvel is, where the woman obtained the strength to drive the pick to such a depth into her head, as her skull was of unusual thickness, and the operator who handled the keen-cutting trephine saw, experienced more than usual difficulty in cutting through the bone. The surgeons at the hospital are unable to understand this part of the case, as it is something new in their experience.
Sharkey Won on a Foul.
The much talked of fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey came off according to contract in San Francisco last night, and was won by Sharkey in the eighth round on a foul. Fitzsimmons had his opponent whipped from the first
Tom Sharkey was nearly knocked out by Bob Fitzsimmons in the eighth round, but referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the win on a foul. The report gives a round-by-round account of the bout at San Francisco's Mechanics' Pavilion.
The Daily Morning Astorian · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY A WINNER.
Awarded the Big Fight in the Eighth Round on a Foul.
See moreSee less
Special to the Astorian.
San Francisco, December 2.—Tom Sharkey was practically knocked out in the 8th round by Bob Fitzsimmons tonight, at Mechanics' Pavilion, but Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul.
Round 1—The men advance quickly to the center of the ring and spar for a moment. Fitzsimmons feints several times with the left but Sharkey gets away. Fitzsimmons landed a light right on the head, Sharkey clinching. Sharkey swings a left on Fitzsimmons' neck; Sharkey landed a right and left on Fitzsimmons' head, and ducked a vicious left swing; Sharkey tried with the right for the head, but Fitzsimmons got away. Sharkey ducked a hard right swing; Sharkey tries for the body and rushes Fitzsimmons landing a left on the body; Fitzsimmons landed a left on the face and gets back at Sharkey with the same blow; Sharkey landed a left and got the same on the return. Fitz-
Before a crowd of 15,000-20,000 in San Francisco, Bob Fitzsimmons appeared to knock out Tom Sharkey, but referee Wyatt Earp ruled a foul and declared Sharkey the winner. The report details the buildup, contrasting Fitzsimmons' experience and reach with Sharkey's youth and strength.
The Evening Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY FAIRLY KNOCKED OUT! But Referee Earp, on a Claim of Foul, Decided Against the Victor
Decided Against the Victor Fifteen to Twenty Thousand Spectators. Including Several Hundred Women.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted public attention here as did the battle between the heavyweights, Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey, last night.
The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · and 5 other papers
The report describes the heavily anticipated Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, noting Wyatt Earp as referee and early objections to him. It details the fight's progress, culminating in Fitzsimmons appearing to knock Sharkey out, but Earp awarded the decision to Sharkey on a disputed foul claim.
The Evening Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY FAIRLY KNOCKED OUT!
ner. For Sharkey were George Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham.
Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver who has figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee late yesterday afternoon.
See moreSee less
It was after 10 o'clock when Fitzsimmons made his appearance, and was greeted with thunderous applause. Sharkey appeared two minutes after Fitzsimmons, and his welcome was equally as warm. When Sharkey entered the ring Bob walked across the ring and shook hands cordially with the sailor and his seconds.
There was a brief delay at the outset, Martin Julian objecting to Referee Earp. Finally Fitzsimmons said he has given up his referee in all his fights, and would give in to this. He objected, however, to a bandage which Sharkey wore on his right hand, and it was removed.
Both men advanced to the middle of the ring promptly on the call of time. Fitz scored a knockdown in the first round, and in the fourth Sharkey knocked his opponent down. A moment later Sharkey was again knocked down, and the fighting became more vicious. Fitz made some terrific plunges, and had Sharkey practically knocked out in the eighth round, but the referee gave the decision to Sharkey on a claim of foul, claiming that while Sharkey was falling from Fitz's left hook on the chin Fitz struck Sharkey in the groin with his knee.
In the final round, after two minutes and a half had expired, Fitzsimmons landed his right for Sharkey's jaw, and then put his left on the chin, which put Sharkey on the floor with a smash. As he fell he put his hand to his groin. He made no attempt to rise, and was carried unconscious from the ring. The foul, if foul it was, could not be seen from the press stand, but Referee Earp gave his decision in spite of Fitzsimmons' protests.
It was Fitz's fight from start to finish. He fought fairly, while the sailor continually used foul tactics. He would clinch and lift Fitz from his feet, strike in a clinch, though the men had previously agreed not to do so, and he was generally unfair. Several times during the fight Fitz had the sailor going, but could not land a knockout blow. In the eighth Sharkey started in to do the leading, but seldom landed. Bob continually sent in left hand jabs on Sharkey's face, sending his head back every time.
Hardly any one among the spectators saw the alleged foul, and the decision was received with hisses and groans. As far as the art of fighting goes Sharkey is not in the same class with Fitz. He is a willing, strong man, but has little science. A clever man like Fitz had no trouble in avoiding his rushes, and he continually left himself open to damaging blows.
Bottled Sunshine for the sufferer from throat or lung troubles is found in the pleasant tasted and quick curing remedy known as Wenck's Glycerole of Tar and Wild Cherry. It has been tried in this town and has given entire satisfaction. Sold by Chas. Povinsky, Shenandoah, Pa. 12-3-2w
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del. · 3 December 1896
The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla. · 4 December 1896
Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis. · 7 December 1896
The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · 10 December 1896
The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb. · 11 December 1896
The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.
In San Francisco, Tom Sharkey was awarded a win over Fitzsimmons after being knocked out in the eighth round, with the fight ruled a foul. Wyatt Earp served as referee, a choice initially objected to by Fitzsimmons' camp before they allowed him to officiate.
The Scranton Tribune · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FIGHT IS AWARDED TO TOM SHARKEY
San Francisco, Dec. 2.--Not since Peter Jackson and Jim Corbett danced about each other for nearly five hours before the members of the California Athletic club has such enormous interest been aroused in a fight between heavyweights as that exhibited tonight at Mechanics' Pavilion between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey. Sharkey's personal popularity was in a measure responsible for this, although Fitzsimmons' reputation among the knowing ones had not a little to do with it.
The long Australian came over from his training ground early this afternoon and rested at [the] Baldwin hotel. To a representative of the United Associated Presses he remarked just before entering the ring: "I am suffering from a severe cold, as you can see, and it has settled in my bones, but this will not interfere with my putting the sailor to sleep in short order. I weigh just 174½ pounds, which is more flesh than I have ever carried into the ring, but I expect I shall need it all to stand off Sharkey's bull-like rushes. I nope he will make a hurricane fight of it. That will just be to my liking."
See moreSee less
Martin Julian was equally confident. He viewed Fitz's red nose with some concern, but when his eyes dropped and took in the Cornish man's massive chest and shapely arms his confidence returned and "Bob will win in four rounds" was his verdict.
Jack Stenzeler and Hickey, who assisted Fitz in training were beside Julian in Bob's corner both wearing black eyes and sundry scars as evidence that the Kangaroo had not lost any of his hitting powers. Each of the trainers was confident that Fitz would make a short fight of it, despite the cold.
No man ever entered a ring with more confidence in his ability to win than did Tom Sharkey.
"I have always been a short ender," he said, "and I have always saved money of my friends. I am strong enough, and heavy enough and clever enough to whip Fitzsimmons and I intend doing so inside of seven rounds if possible. If I fail it will be because he is the best man."
Sharkey was trained to the minute. He weighed 176 pounds, three pounds lighter than when he met Corbett, and many thought he was a trifler drawn.
The report describes the tense moments before the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout as Julian initially refuses to accept Wyatt Earp as referee, calling him ignorant of the rules, before Fitzsimmons concedes to end the standoff. It then gives a round-by-round account of the early fighting, with Fitzsimmons dominating the first two rounds.
The Scranton Tribune · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE SLUGGERS APPEAR.
Fitzsimmons entered the ring at 10.03 followed by his seconds. Bob's many San Francisco friends shrieked themselves hoarse when their favorite appeared, but their efforts were nothing compared to the greeting which Sharkey received five minutes later as he vaulted into the ring.
See moreSee less
Fitzsimmons sat quietly in his corner and eyed the sailor, while Sharkey surveyed his opponent critically for the first time.
The gloves were inspected and laid in the centre of the ring, but where was the referee.
As Earp stepped through the rope Julian eyed him suspiciously, evidently having in mind fouls and hugging bouts.
The cause of the delay was explained a second later when the master of ceremonies announced that Mr. Julian refused to accept Mr. Earp.
Julian secured an audience and explained that he had accepted every reputable man's name which had been suggested, but did not propose to take any chances with a man who was professedly ignorant of the rules.
Lynch, Sharkey's manager, announced that he had signed the articles in behalf of Sharkey and that his man had lived up to them. The Fitzsimmons crowd and he could not agree on a man, consequently the selection devolved on the club. Earp had been named by President Groom, he was here ready to officiate and Sharkey was ready to fight.
After a great deal of wrangling Fitzsimmons arose and shouted: "Gentlemen: I have given in to everybody in all my fights and I will give in to this. Let Sharkey take the bandages off his hands. I have none on mine" and immediately the crowd stood up and cheered for the Cornish man.
Sharkey's bandages were removed and the men shook hands at 10.35.
At the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, referee Wyatt Earp ruled that Sharkey won by foul after a left hook from Fitzsimmons left Sharkey unable to continue. The crowd erupted in outrage, believing the punch was a clean knockout and that Fitzsimmons had been unfairly robbed of victory.
The Evening Tribune · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
to See the Foul.
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Tom Sharkey was given the decision over Fitzsimmons last night in the eighth round on a foul, the Cornishman hitting the sailor with his knee in the groin, according to the decision of the referee.
See moreSee less
The declared winner was clearly outclassed by his more scientific opponent, and was practically out when the foul occurred.
At first the crowd did not seem to grasp the situation, but when it dawned upon them that the decision had gone against Fitzsimmons such a howl of indignation as went up has seldom been heard in this section. Hisses, curses, groans and hoots split the air.
On the platform and in the ring Bob Fitzsimmons and Martin Julian were jumping about trying to make themselves heard. Although their words were indistinguishable their actions were expressive enough. Dismay and disgust were vividly portrayed. Fitz indignantly denied that he had fouled Sharkey.
Sharkey was undoubtedly badly hurt. He was unable to move his legs, though he clutched spasmodically a[t hi]'s groin with his gloved hand. Hi[s] seconds rushed into the ring and raised him up, but he fainted away, and was borne from the ring unconscious. Hardly anyone among the spectators saw the foul, and the decision was received with hisses and groans. As far as the art of fighting goes, Sharkey is not in the same class with Fitzsimmons. He is a willing, strong man, but has little science. A clever man like Fitzsimmons had no trouble in avoiding his rushes, and he continually left himself open to damaging blows.
In the eight and last round, Sharkey led and missed. Again he led and clinched. Bob put his right on the face and duplicated it again later. In the break-away Sharkey hugged his man.
Fitz led again and landed, only to be smothered once more. This was repeated three times, and the crowd hissed and hissed. Sharkey was doing nothing but wrestling.
Bob got in two hard rights, but could not reach the spot. A hard exchange followed, in which Fitz landed right and left, upper-cutting his man and breaking away easily.
As Sharkey rushed again, Fitz got in his celebrated left hook twice, and the sailor's career was checked. Sharkey rolled over on his back and threw up his left leg. Fitz smiled and returned to his corner.
After referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the decision over Fitzsimmons on a foul claim, Fitzsimmons' manager Julian alleged they had been warned beforehand that Earp was "fixed" and that they would be robbed regardless of the outcome. Club president Groom denounced the decision as an outrage and said he would seek to stop payment of the prize money check.
The Providence News · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
ROBBED.
Payment of the Prize Money.
NEW YORK, Dec. 3.—A special from San Francisco says: After the fight was over and Fitzsimmons returned to his dressing room, Martin Julian, on the suggestion of Fitzsimmons, gave out the following statement: "About 6:30 this evening, Mose Guntz, Elley Grannan and Tom Jones came to us and said that Earp was "fixed," and that we would not get the decision even though we knocked Sharkey out. But rather than have the fight fall through, we consented to Earp. And what has been the result? We have been robbed. Fitzsimmons never struck a foul blow during the fight, but Sharky struck at least fifty. I intend to stop the payment of the check if possible, and will make a protest to the club against its payment."
See moreSee less
At this point J. J. Groom, president of the club, came in and Julian took him to task for the decision and called upon him to stop payment of the check.
Mr. Groom said that the club was taking legal advice as to whether a certified check could be stopped. If it could be, he said, it would be, as he denounced the decision as an outrage. Mr. Groom also declared that during the fight he had repeatedly called to Earp about Sharkey's repeated foul blows. Fitzsimmons broke in here and said: I never struck Sharkey a foul blow during the contest, but he struck me several. One time it was a severe blow and I complained to Earp, but all the satisfaction I got was "Go on and fight."
"The blow that knocked Sharkey out I gave in this fashion. I feinted with my right, and then ducking slightly, planted my left with full force in the pit o the stomach. Sharkey, in his few seconds of consciousness, made out to catch at his groins in order to deceive as to where he was hit. I doubled him up. That is all there was to it. I was robbed of the fight and every fair-minded person will say the same thing. I'm ready to fight him at any time. In fact, I'll fight him now, inside of 10 minutes. He is the foulest fighter and a trickster. I can lick him in short order."
After referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match, millionaire Spreckles publicly accused club officials of fixing the fight in Sharkey's favor, and angry bookmakers refused to pay out on bets they believed were fairly won by Fitzsimmons. Earp was jeered by the crowd and even his friends after the fight, and the report notes that Fitzsimmons' camp had objected to Earp as referee beforehand, citing foreknowledge that the fix favored Sharkey.
The Providence News · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
A later special to the World says: Few bets will be paid, for bookmakers decided early this morning not to pay off unless they were compelled to by legal process. Adolph Spreckles, son of the sugar refiner, met President Groom after the decision was given out, and declared himself in strong terms. Shaking his fist in Groom's face he shouted: "You and all the members of the club are in with this steal. If this decision stands I'll do all in my power to have boxing stopped in San Francisco. The decision was an outrage. It was fixed and you know it."
Groom denied being implicated in any deal to award the fight to Sharkey and voiced Spreckle's sentiment as to the outrageous decision. As Spreckles is strong in politics and his brother John is one of the bosses, his threat to stop prize fighting if the decision was not changed, is no idle one and carries great weight.
See moreSee less
Major McLaughlin, chairman of the Republican committee, was with Spreckles at the time he made his charge of fraud to President Groom and upheld the millionaire in the stand he took. Both men were greatly worked up and were very angry.
James O'Neil, one of the biggest bookmakers in the country, said he held $3,000 on the contest and he would not pay it under the circumstances. He said that Fitzimmons had earned the decision fairly and that he would not give up to Sharkey's backers. This was the decision of all men who booked on the fight. To a man they had laid heavy odds against Sharkey. One thing in favor of the backers of Fitzsimmons is the fact that Julian objected to Wyatt Earp for referee, and stated from the ring that he had learned from good authority that Sharkey was to be given a decision, whether deservedly or not. After the fight Earp forced his way through the crowd and was frowned on by even his most intimate friends.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 23.—Referee Earp, whose decision of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight caused an indignant demonstration from the crowd at the ring last night, stated this morning that
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight to Sharkey on a foul, a decision that sparked outrage since no one else saw the foul and many believed Fitzsimmons had dominated. Corbett telegraphed Sharkey expressing sympathy over the controversial outcome and challenged him to a rematch.
San Antonio Daily Light · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CORBETT CHALLENGES. TELEGRAPHS HIS WILLINGNESS TO MEET SHARKEI.
three calves at a birth, all doing well.
Sharkey is awarded the fight with Fitzsimmons on a foul, so said the referee, but no one else saw it.
See moreSee less
Fitzsimons outfought Sharkey, at all points, and the decision of the referee was received with howls of rage and disappointment. Sharkey was unconscious for half an hour.
Dan Stuart is sick and the doctors forbid his going out for a week.
All of the Pittsburg plate glass factories resume work on full time.
American workmen and foreign laborers fight for work on the Trenton, N. J. reservoir.
A day after Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight to Sharkey on a foul, Earp defended his decision, insisting he clearly saw Fitzsimmons strike low in the eighth round. Fitzsimmons denied the claim, calling it part of a setup, while Corbett telegraphed sympathy to Sharkey and challenged him to a future bout.
San Antonio Daily Light · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Referee Earp, whose decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight caused an indignant demonstration from the crowd at the ring-side last night, stated this morning that when he decided the contest in favor of Sharkey he did so because he believed Fitzsimmons deliberaetly fouled him, and under the rules the sailor was entitled to the decision. He would have been willing to allow half the fouls, that is, fouls that might be considered partly accidental, to pass by with only a reprimand but in such case as this he could only do his duty. He said:
"There is one thing I regret. I should have given Sharkey the fight earlier in the contest. In the fourth round I think it was, Fitzsimmons landed a left handed blow and returned with his elbow, cutting Sharkey's eye brow open. The sailor should have had the fight then. The foul blow in the eighth was seen openly by me. Fitzsimmons smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder and then with an upper cut with his left he struck the sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul and before the sailor moved I mentioned that the fight was over. The first blow was on the neck and I believe the second was intended for an upper cut but it struck foul. No man until now has ever questioned my honor. I have been in many places and in peculiar situations, but no one ever said until last night that I was guilty of a dishonorable act and I will repeat that I decided in all fairness and with all judgment that was as true as my eye-sight. I saw a foul blow."
See moreSee less
Fitzsimmons said after the fight:
"Earp knows and so does Sharkey that I did not hit the sailor where
After Earp's foul call ending the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, Fitzsimmons insists he hit Sharkey fairly in the stomach and denies any foul, while Sharkey claims Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled him to avoid being knocked out. Both fighters express willingness to meet again, with Fitzsimmons also complaining about being cheated in his earlier Jackson fight.
San Antonio Daily Light · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey had this to say: "I am certain that Fitzsimmons fouled me deliberately to save himself from defeat. It was getting too plain to him that I was gaining in strength while he was going down hill, so to
Referee Wyatt Earp stopped the fight in the eighth round, ruling that Fitzsimmons had fouled Sharkey with his knee, awarding Sharkey the victory despite Fitzsimmons dominating the bout. The crowd jeered the decision and Earp fled the ring to avoid being manhandled by angry spectators.
The Salt Lake Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
finally saved him in the eighth after Fitz had laid him low with a couple of left hooks, both of which struck the jaw. Fitzsimmons finished without a mark on his body, and did not receive a single fair punch from the sailor in the entire contest.
As Sharkey rolled over on his back, Wyatt Earp, the referee, announced
On the day of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons heavyweight fight, rival camps traded confident predictions, with Sharkey boasting of his chances and his trainers praising his toughness. After managers squabbled for hours over a referee, club president Groom named Wyatt Earp, the former Western lawman, to officiate the bout.
The Salt Lake Herald · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY'S ORATORY
winning. "Tom has a short neck, ribbed with muscles," said Needham, "and Fitz can no more reach the jaw than fly. Why [d]idn't Corbett or Choynski do the trick? Because they could not and neither can Fitzsimmons. Sharkey is young and possesses remarkable vitality. He will outlast the Cornishman and win in seven rounds." Sharkey was trained to the minute. He weighed 176 pounds, three pounds lighter than when he met Corbett and many believed that he was a trifle drawn.
Referee Wyatt Earp ruled that Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey with a foul blow below the belt, awarding the fight to Sharkey amid crowd protests and jeers. Fitzsimmons denied fouling, claiming he fought fairly and was robbed of a win, while Sharkey said he was unaware of a foul until the eighth round.
Deseret Evening News · 3 December 1896 · page 3
Dmy and disquittAl vividly 1 for Iad Fizommove 10d1RO01Y Or tiled filet lie limit Stifled Sharkey Ho a4ld bo bd fought fairly slid theta w 40 Ito temptation for him 10 cdmmlt a To b 1 oe bo know lie had his Loan 2010a rJbarliey was carried Into his room by hlecooo land was followed by a doctor who examined the Injured tailor Bbarkey recovered consciousness about half an hour later He was al I ly badly Injured his grain being ewollen He says he bad iilztlramont KOlog until the eighth roundwbtu the foul cccurruj Wyatt Earp Ibo referee Says the foul was deliberate Fllxilmmoul Just
At a packed Mechanics' Pavilion bout in San Francisco, Fitzsimmons knocked out Sharkey in the eighth round, but referee Wyatt Earp declared the blow a foul and awarded the fight to Sharkey. The report notes the enormous public interest in the match and describes pre-fight remarks from Fitzsimmons.
The Times · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY GOT DECISION / THE REFEREE CHARGED WITH ROBBING FITZSIMMONS / He Knocked Out the Sailor in the Eighth Round, but Referee Earp Decides That the Blow Was a Foul
SAN FRANCISCO, CAL., Dec. 2.—Not since Peter Jackson and Jim Corbett danced about each other for nearly five hours before the members of the California Athletic Club has such enormous interest been aroused in a fight between heavy-weights as that exhibited to-night at Mechanics' Pavilion between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey. Sharkey's personal popularity is in a measure responsible for this, although Fitzsimmons' reputation among the knowing ones had not a little to do with it.
A detail of one hundred blue coats was assigned to take care of the contest; standing-room was at a premium. Thousands surged about the doors and viewed the "cops" with envy.
Referee Wyatt Earp stopped the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in the eighth round, awarding victory to Sharkey on a claimed foul after Fitzsimmons landed a knockdown blow to the chin. Fitzsimmons protested, and witnesses at ringside were divided on whether a foul (a knee to the groin) actually occurred, with some calling it accidental and others intentional.
Alexandria Gazette · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY WON ON A FOUL.—The fight at San Francisco between Robert Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey came to an unexpected end in the eighth round last night, when Referee Earp gave Sharkey the decision on a claim of foul. It was Fitzsimmons' fight from start to finish. He fought fairly, while the sailor continually used foul tactics. He would clinch and lift Fitzsimmons from his feet, strike in a clinch, though the men had previously agreed not to do so, and he was generally unfair. In the eighth round Fitzsimmons landed on the chin which put Sharkey on the floor with a smash. As he fell he put his hand to his groin. He made no attempt to rise and was carried from the ring. The foul, if foul it was, could not be seen from the press stand, but Referee Earp gave his decision in spite of Fitzsimmons' protests. The referee claimed that while Sharkey was falling from Fitzsimmons' blow on the chin Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey in the groin with his knee.
VIRGINIA NEWS.
See moreSee less
It is understood that General Lee will shortly commence the work of writing a biography of General Stonewall Jackson.
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
After managers for Fitzsimmons and Sharkey failed to agree on a referee despite hours of argument, club president Groom named Wyatt Earp, once a feared lawman in Kansas and Arizona, to referee the bout. The report also describes the crowd of 15,000, heavy betting favoring Fitzsimmons, and a rumor that a police commissioner might stop the fight if Sharkey appeared to be winning.
Richmond Dispatch · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Arizona.
THE "AUDIENCE."
See moreSee less
The great pavilion began to fill before 6 o'clock. Sharkey's friends monopolized the upper gallery, and all the shouting for the sailor came from the cheaper seats. Fitzsimmons's backers were found among the soft-palmed fraternity in the $10 seats. The sunny face of Captain Rees peeped out from between those of Riley Grannan and Eddy Gaines. The pockets of the three bulged with Fitzsimmons cash. Behind the chorus of horsemen were a coterie of prominent attorneys, a round dozen of judges, and any quantity of millionaires, and other celebrities. All day long, the pool-rooms were crowded, Fitzsimmons closing a 3-to-1 favorite. Sharkey money was plentiful, but came in small dribbles, no large wagers being reported.
The pavilion contained not less than 15,000 people when the first event was called, and a more orderly crowd never assembled. A cordon of twenty-five policemen fringed the ring-side, while seventy-five officers were distributed about the hall, preserving order and preventing confusion.
A sensational story was printed in an evening paper, to the effect that Police Commissioner Gunst had bet heavily on Fitzsimmons, and would have Chief Crowley stop the contest should it become apparent that Sharkey would win. Mr. Gunst declared that he did not have a dollar up, and that the pugilists should not be molested unless the fight became brutal. In that event, Captain Whitman, in charge of the officers, would see that the law was not violated.
Fitzsimmons entered the ring at 10:03 and was followed by his seconds. Bob's many San Francisco friends shouted themselves hoarse when their favorite appeared, but their efforts were as the bark of a dog against the fierce yelp of a sea lion as compared with the greeting which Sharkey received five minutes later as he vaulted into the ring, scorning to use the ladder.
Fitzsimmons sat quietly in his corner and eyed the sailor, while Sharkey survey-
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
At a San Francisco bout watched by 15,000 spectators, Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey unconscious in the eighth round, but referee Wyatt Earp declared Fitzsimmons had fouled Sharkey, awarding the decision to Sharkey. The crowd reacted with groans, viewing Fitzsimmons as clearly superior and the ruling as unsatisfactory.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LANKY BOB WINS. But Sharkey Gets Decision on a Foul
Sharkey Was Falling Fitzsimmons Struck Him in the Groin With His Knee--Decision Causes Great Excitement, and Is Received With Groans--Earp Not Satisfactory to Fitzsimmons, Who Enters the Contest Protesting--Sharkey, Although Willing and Strong, Is Without Science, and Was Clearly Outclassed, Yet He Knocked the Invincible Fitz to the Floor--Thousands of Spectators View the Fight, Women Being Admitted for the First Time in the History of the Prize Ring.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report describes the massive crowd and preliminary bouts before the main event at the National Club, noting the unprecedented admission of women and heavy police presence. It identifies Wyatt Earp, the noted Arizona gunfighter, as the chosen referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
the men weighed about 175 pounds. The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Jullan, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner. For Sharkey, George Allen, Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham. Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee late this afternoon. [illegible]
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Fitzsimmons was dominating Sharkey in the eighth round with a barrage of punches before referee Wyatt Earp called a foul and awarded the fight to Sharkey. Both fighters gave conflicting accounts afterward, with Fitzsimmons claiming he was robbed and had struck Sharkey fairly on the jaw.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
FITZ IN THE RING
Visible Marks of the Foul.
Sharkey recovered consciousness about half an hour later. He was not very badly injured, although his groin was somewhat swollen. Sharkey said that he was confident of his ability to whip Fitzsimmons up to the moment he was fouled, for he had played continuously upon his wind and had him distressed.
See moreSee less
Earp, the referee, says the foul was deliberate. Fitzsimmons just before striking his left hook that apparently knocked Sharkey out, hit the sailor below the belt with his fist. Earlier in the fight in a breakaway, Earp says Fitzsimmons deliberately struck Sharkey over the eye with his elbow, making a bad cut. Earp was tempted to give Sharkey the fight then and there, but the sailor made no
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A packed San Francisco pavilion with thousands of spectators, including women for the first time in boxing history, awaited the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout. The report notes Wyatt Earp, described as a famous Arizona stage driver and gunfighter, served as referee, and details preliminary bouts before the main event.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 3 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
event and it was very late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring.
One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander being five feet eleven and three-fourth inches and Sharkey five feet eight and three-fourth inches. Each of the men weighed about one hundred and seventy-five pounds. The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner. For Sharkey, George Allen Australian Billy Smith and Danny Needham. Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured
The report describes the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prizefight round by round, culminating in Fitzsimmons apparently knocking out Sharkey in the eighth round with a flurry of blows. However, referee Wyatt Earp called a foul on Fitzsimmons, a decision the crowd largely disputed, while Sharkey claimed he was winning before the contested foul occurred.
The Laramie Republican · 3 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
San Francisco, Dec. 2.—After Tom Sharkey had been practically knocked out by Bob Fitzsimmons tonight in the eighth round, Sharkey was given the fight on a foul. The referee claimed that Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey in the groin as he was going down. Sharkey was carried from the ring in an unconscious condition.
At first the crowd did not seem to grasp the situation, but when it dawned upon them that the decision had gone against Fitzsimmons, such a howl of indignation as went up has seldom been heard in this section. Hisses, curses, groans and hoots split the air.
See moreSee less
On the platform, in the ring, Bob Fitzsimmons and Martin Julian were jumping about trying to make themselves heard. Although their words were indistinguishable, their actions were expressive enough. Dismay and disgust were vividly portrayed. Fitzsimmons indignantly denied that he had fouled Sharkey. He said he had fought fair and there was no temptation for him to commit a foul, as he knew he had his man going. Sharkey could not be seen. He was carried into his room by his seconds and followed by a doctor, who examined the injured sailor. The physician has not yet made his report.
Fitzsimmons fighting all through was in marked contrast to that of Sharkey. Bob broke away promptly from clinches and made no attempt to strike. The New Zealander showed himself a master of his craft. He cunningly kept away from the sailor's mad rushes, poking his long left into Sharky's face whenever he got too near. Sharkey could not get inside of that long, thin arm, which, when it straightened out, was like a bar of steel.
It was a lively fight from the start. Bob was even more on the aggressive than Sharkey, and kept his man on the move all the time.
In the very first round Fitzsimmons saw an opening and a right swing on the jaw sent Sharkey to the floor. That made the sailor a bit cautious, and during the next few rounds he tried to keep out of reach. In the fourth Sharkey pushed Fitzsimmons over on the floor and before Bob could get up made a couple of vicious swipes at him. Fitzsimmons cleverly clinched and avoided damage, but it was a clear case of foul on Sharkey's part. No claim was made, however, and the fight went on.
In the fifth Sharkey did more mean work, grabbing Fitzsimmons around the legs and trying to throw him. Fitzsimmons began to warm up and went after the sturdy sailor like a cyclone. A poke on the nose and a left swing on the jaw sent Sharkey down. He rolled under the ropes and would have gone off the platform had not Bob courteously hauled him back. It looked as if Tom was done for but the gong sounded and he was given a minute in which to recuperate.
In the sixth Sharkey made a pretense of fighting, leading for Bob's wind. He missed connections every time, however, while Fitzsimmons would land his left on the jaw. When the round closed Sharkey was decidedly groggy, but on his feet. A joyous shout went up from the many sports who had bet even money that he would last but six. When the seventh round opened Fitzsimmons tried to end matters. He swung his right repeatedly for the jaw, but in some manner Sharkey escaped. The left jabs always connected though, and Tom was decidedly on the wane. Bob himself was none too strong and seemed to be a bit tired when the round closed.
Then came the disastrous eighth. Fitzsimmons went at his man with a will and fairly smothered his man with lefts and rights. First it would be the mouth that suffered, then the nose and later the eye. Fitzsimmons was working like a demon. His long arms shot out with amazing rapidity and Tom's head bobbed back and forth in response.
Then Fitzsimmons got up close to finish the job in a workmanlike manner. A right half arm jolt under the chin sent the sailor's head to one side. A left hook similarly applied sent him over backwards. Then came the much disputed foul. Very few of the immense crowd could be convinced that Fitzsimmons had been unfair and it is almost certain that if a foul were committed it was unintentional.
Sharkey recovered consciousness about half an hour later. He was apparently badly injured, his groin being swollen. He says he had Fitzsimmons going until the eighth round, when the foul occurred. Wyatt Earp, the referee, says the foul was deliberate. Fitzsimmons, just before striking his left hook that apparently knocked Sharkey out, hit the sailor below the belt with his fist. Earlier in the fight, in a break
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · and 6 other papers
Referee Wyatt Earp defends his decision to award the fight to Sharkey on a foul, insisting he clearly saw an illegal low blow from Fitzsimmons. Fitzsimmons denies fouling Sharkey and claims he was already winning, while Sharkey insists the foul was deliberate to avoid being knocked out.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
ECHOES OF THE MILL
Make Their Palaver.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dc. 3.—Referee Earp, whose decision of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight caused an indignant demonstration from the crowd at the ringside last night, stated this morning that when he decided the contest in favor of Sharkey he did so because he thought that Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled him, and under the rules the sailor was entitled to the decision. He would have been willing to allow half fouls—that is, fouls that might be considered partly accidental—to pass by with only a reprimand, but in such a case as this he could only do his duty. He said:
See moreSee less
"There is one thing I regret. I should have given Sharkey the fight earlier in the contest. In the fourth round, I think it was, Fitzsimmons landed a left-handed blow and returned with his elbow, cutting Sharkey's eyebrow open. The sailor should have had the fight then. The foul blow of the eighth round was seen plainly by me. Fitzsimmons smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder and then with an uppercut with the left he struck the sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul, and before the sailor moved I mentioned that the fight was over. The first blow had been weak, and I believe that the second was intended for an upper-cut, but it struck foul. No man until now has ever questioned my honor.
"I have been in many places and in peculiar situations, but no one ever said until last night that I was guilty of a dishonerable act. And I still repeat that I decided in all fairness and with a judgment that was as true as my eyesight. I saw the foul blow."
Fitzsimmons said after the fight:
"Earp knows, and so does Sharkey, that I did not hit the sailor where they say I did. My left landed straight in his stomach, where I had a right to hit him, and no other place. His lying down and groaning was all a pat of the game. There was no need for me to foul him, because I had him whipped anyway, and could have finished him before the end of the round. It doesn't make any difference, though. As I telegraphed Dan Stuart last night, I am willing to meet both Sharkey and Corbett in the same ring any night Stuart wants to pull the fight off. I will say one thing for Corbett, and that is I don't blame him for saying that he was robbed of the Jackson fight in this town. No pugilist can get a square deal from the thieves who handle fighting in this city, and it is a safe bet that the last big fight San Francisco will ever see was pulled off last night."
"Sailor" Sharkey had this to say of the affair:
"I am certain that Fitzsimmons fouled me deliberately, to save himself from defeat. It was getting too plain to him that I was gaining in strength, while he was going down hill, so to speak, and rather than be knocked out he thought he would lose on a foul. Had he not delivered that nasty blow which crippled me, I would certainly have finished him in that round—the eighth, I believe it was.
"I am sorry that the question of supremacy was not settled on its merits, rather than in this way. I can beat Fitzsimmons and I would far rather have knocked him out than win the purse on a foul. I don't think he will be anxious to meet me again, however, but if he does—well, I am open to all engagements. I am in the boxing business as a profession."
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 4 December 1896
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · 4 December 1896
Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · 4 December 1896
Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · 4 December 1896
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 4 December 1896
The Times · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
After referee Wyatt Earp disqualified Fitzsimmons for a foul blow against Sharkey, witnesses and boxing experts sharply disputed whether any foul occurred, with most declaring it a robbery. Fitzsimmons himself claimed he was cheated out of $10,000 and vowed to fight the decision in court.
The Times · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ DIDN'T FOUL
of robbery. Major Frank McLaughlin, chairman of the Republican State Central Committee, who was probably in a better position to see the alleged foul than anybody, says that the knock-out was as clean an upper-cut as he ever saw.
Earp's selection as referee came about in a peculiar way. For many days, Martin Julian has urged Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, to name a satisfactory man, but Lynch has invariably refused to do so, claiming there was plenty of time. Yesterday morning, the managers wrangled over the question for hours. Julian named man after man, but Lynch was obdurate, and when the noon hour arrived President Groom, of the National Club, was called on to make a selection. He fixed on Wyatt Earp, and Julian agreed to accept him, rather than leave Fitzsimmons open to the charge of cowardice. Julian took the short end of the stick.
See moreSee less
That Sharkey has improved as a boxer, no one who saw him perform last night will deny. That he is greatly over-rated, and entirely out-classed in a contest with Fitzsimmons, is also not disputed. The men were about evenly matched in weight, there being less than two pounds difference between them.
Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 4 December 1896
Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The day after Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim, Fitzsimmons denounced Sharkey's tactics, Earp, and the fight's management, insisting his punch landed fairly on the stomach, not below the belt. Doctors who examined Sharkey found facial injuries consistent with punches but noted the eye was not swollen shut, raising doubts about the severity of any low blow.
Birmingham State Herald · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY'S CONDITION.
Has An Ugly Swelling Near the Groin—Suspicious Cut Over the Eye
See moreSee less
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Fitzsimmons was around the Baldwin hotel at an early hour this morning, showing not the faintest trace of his encounter with Sharkey last night. He is most bitter in his denunciation of the sailor's foul tactics, Referee Earp and the management of the fight. He says he was robbed of the decision and that it was preconcerted to give the battle to his opponent. The blow which laid Sharkey low, Fitzsimmons declares, was a right hand hook on the stomach. This landed fairly and not below the belt as maintained by the referee. Fitzsimmons is anxious to meet Sharkey again, and will fight him at any time and place the latter may name.
Those in attendance upon Sharkey say that he suffered terribly all night, requiring the constant services of two physicians up to 4 a. m., when he fell asleep. One of his aids said his groins were severely swollen and highly inflamed. He is resting easily today. Police are watching Sharkey's quarters, and if his condition becomes serious Fitzsimmons will be arrested. Prominent doctors examined Sharkey at 10 o'clock this morning, the Southern Associated Press reporter being present. The result was this statement from the doctor:
"Sharkey has a gash over the left eye, which could not have been caused by a blow from a glove, as the eye is not closed; also a swelling on the left cheek, to which we applied a leech this morning. The left ear is swollen from extravasation, or blood settling under the surface. There is not a bruise or a mark on the upper part of the body, save a slight abrasion of the skin, caused by contact with the ropes in the fifth round and which is of no consequence whatever.
"This is what caused the damage," and here Sharkey was stripped and the doctor pointed to a huge swelling on the lower part of the body near the groin. There was discoloration in one spot,
Wyatt Earp is reported as indignant over public criticism of his decision as referee in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, insisting the foul was intentional and his ruling fair. Meanwhile, Corbett telegraphs Sharkey offering a future match.
Tombstone Prospector · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Earp Ruffled Over Comments on His Decision / HE MAINTAINS HIS STAND
He says the foul was plainly intentional.
NEW YORK—James J. Corbett telegraphed Sharkey as follows: "Tom Sharkey, San Francisco, Cal.—I am very sorry at Mr. Fitzsimmon's foul tactics in his contest with you;
Fitzsimmons' camp alleges a conspiracy to rig the fight after referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the purse on a foul claim; Fitzsimmons won a court injunction blocking payment of the $10,000 check. Earp was also arrested for carrying a concealed pistol after the fight, while doctors disputed the cause of Sharkey's groin injury.
Arizona Republican · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
of Trouble Over His Decision in Favor of Sharkey.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3.—The city is divided as to the result of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. No one questions that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly deprived of the decision.
See moreSee less
Sharkey's friends assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow and was consequently entitled to the honors of victory and the purse of $10,000. A number of physicians and newspaper men examined Sharkey's injuries today and were convinced that his condition was the result of a foul blow, the sailor's skin being swollen and discolored in the region of the groin.
Fitzsimmons' attorneys expect to prove the existence of a conspiracy to deprive him of the purse. When Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and Referee Earp presented the $10,000 check for payment this morning the bank refused to cash it, acting upon instructions from the officials of the National club, who requested that the payment of the check be temporarily deferred.
Fitzsimmons said today that the referee selected was chosen to give a decision against him and that he carried out his part of the programme.
He said he never fought fairer in his life, while Sharkey fouled him at least twenty times, but the referee took no notice of his protests.
Late this afternoon Bob Fitzsimmons through his attorney, commenced suit in the superior court to restrain the Anglo-California bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse awarded the sailor by Referee Earp. Fitzsimmons charges conspiracy between Sharkey, the National club and others to award Sharkey the purse under any circumstances.
He therefore prays that the bank be enjoined from paying the money. Judge Sanderson granted the injunction and the case will soon be tried in court.
When Wyatt Earp appeared in the ring last night to act as referee, Police Captain Wittman took from him a large-sized pistol. Tonight Earp was arrested on the charge of carrying concealed weapons, but was released on $40 bail. Earp is very indignant over the comments on his decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight and loudly maintains that his decision was fair and honest. He says the foul was plainly intentional.
Dr. Lee, the man called in to attend Sharkey last night, in spite of the fact that other physicians offered their services, is not recognized by the regular medical fraternity of this city. It is stated by a prominent physician that the injuries exhibited by Sharkey could have been caused by a blow on the navel.
Wyatt Earp was arrested and disarmed by police after appearing as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, charged with carrying a concealed weapon and released on bail. The report also covers ongoing public dispute over whether Sharkey's win was due to a foul blow by Fitzsimmons.
Waterbury Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Men—Law Battle to Follow Fistic One.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 4.—When Wyatt Earp appeared in the ring Wednesday night to act as referee, he was disarmed by Police Captain Wittman, who took from the Arizona man a large sized pistol. Earp has been arrested on a charge of carrying concealed weapons. He was released on bail.
See moreSee less
The city is divided as to the result of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, which is still the topic of the hour. No one questions that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly deprived of the decision. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow and was consequently, under the rules, entitled to the honors of victory, including the purse of $10,000. A third class base their opinion solely upon the reports of the physicians in attendance upon Sharkey. The doctors point to the swollen and discolored condition of the sailor's skin in the region of the groin as evidence of a foul blow, and some ardent Fitzsimmons advocates reply that this condition was purposely caused by an injection of a drug immediately after the fight.
Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 5 other papers
Fitzsimmons' attorneys file suit alleging a conspiracy between Sharkey, promoters, and referee Wyatt Earp to award Sharkey the $10,000 purse regardless of the fight's outcome, securing a court injunction to block payment. Physicians' reports on Sharkey's alleged foul injury and an outside expert's opinion are also cited as the case heads to trial.
Waterbury Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
SAN FRANCISCO MILL'S OUTCOME.
was delivered by Fitzsimmons, but that Sharkey, when knocked out, alleged the foul blow as an excuse. All these constitute the case of Fitzsimmons by which his attorneys expect to prove the existence of a conspiracy to deprive Fitzsimmons of the purse of $10,000.
Bob Fitzsimmons, through his attorney, has commenced suit in the superior court to restrain the Anglo-California bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse awarded the sailor by Referee Earp. Fitzsimmons charges conspiracy between Sharkey, the National Athletic club and others, whose names are not given, to award Sharkey the purse under any circumstances. Fitzsimmons alleges that before Earp was selected as referee this agreement was made and that had he known of it he would have refused to enter the ring. Judge Sanderson granted the injunction prayed for, and the case will be soon tried in court. The National club is composed of J. G. Groom and John Gibbs, local men.
See moreSee less
A delegation of six reputable physicians have examined Sharkey and made the following report:
"We find an oedema, or swelling, on the left side of the groin, extending partially to the left, also two small ecchymotic spots, or discolorations, about half way down on the right side."
Dr. Lee, the man called in to attend Sharkey Wednesday night, in spite of the fact that other physicians offered their services, is not recognized by the regular medical fraternity of this city. It is stated by a prominent physician that the injuries exhibited by Sharkey could have been caused by a blow on the navel.
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 4 December 1896
Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Or. · 4 December 1896
The Copper Country Evening News · Calumet, Mich. · 5 December 1896
The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · 10 December 1896
The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb. · 11 December 1896
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
San Francisco sports fans remain convinced that referee Wyatt Earp wrongly awarded the fight to Fitzsimmons on a foul, citing Earp's odd behavior and the hidden gun incident. Sharkey's camp also drew suspicion by blocking doctors from examining him after the bout.
The San Francisco Call · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Statement.
The lovers of fistic sport who sat about the ring at Mechanics' Pavilion Wednesday night and saw Bob Fitzsimmons put Tom Sharkey to sleep do not and will never believe that the Cornishman fouled the sailor, and moreover, the majority of them are outspoken in their belief that Bob was robbed.
See moreSee less
The fight and its sudden and unsatisfactory termination were the talk of the town yesterday and the peculiar train of events that led up to the fight and what followed it were gone over on every street corner and in every cafe.
The sports recalled the declaration of Martin Julian that the referee was fixed
Reputable physicians say Sharkey's injuries were not severe enough to have stopped the fight, contradicting the serious diagnosis given by an irregular practitioner allowed exclusive access. Manager Gibbs also explains why he chose Wyatt Earp as referee, citing his reputation and experience despite Julian's objections.
The San Francisco Call · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
NOT TO BE SEVERE
No Foul.
for Sharkey, Earp's peculiar action in not defending himself before the assembled throng and the fact that he was relieved of a gun in the arena.
See moreSee less
Then they told each other how foul Sharkey had fought and of Earp's apparent indifference to the sailor's tactics. Then Earp's sudden and precipitate disappearance from the ring were commented on and inferences drawn from that.
An incident that caused a great deal of talk was the refusal of the trainers and backers of Sharkey to allow the doctors to see the sailor. When Sharkey was carried out of the ring he seemed in a complete state of collapse and totally unable to walk. This, ring-goers think, was the time for a physician to be called. Yet, when Dr. Lustig, Dr. O'Brien, Dr. Rottanzi and others offered to attend him they were shut out of his dressing-room and no physician saw him until a man named Lee, an irregular practitioner, with whom the police are well acquainted, was called and with no one but Sharkey's people present at the examination pronounced him seriously injured.
His statement is heavily discounted in view of the subsequent reports of reputable physicians, made yesterday, that Sharkey's injuries are far from being severe enough to incapacitate him from having gone on with the mill. So long a time had expired that it was hard to tell when or how the hurts were received.
Messrs. Gibb and Groom, managers of the National Club, are coming in for no small amount of unfavorable comment for not withdrawing Earp as referee when Julian objected to him. Julian was willing to accept any one in the house outside of the bad man from Arizona.
An easy and honorable solution of the matter would have been to withdraw Earp, have a particle of preference for one over the other. I did not wager a cent and had no other interest in the matter than to have a square and fair contest, the better man to win the $10,000 and the public to get an entertainment for their price of admission."
National Club manager Gibbs explains how Wyatt Earp came to be selected as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight after the fighters failed to agree on one themselves. He describes Earp's reputation and experience, and recounts last-minute objections from Fitzsimmons's camp before the bout began.
The San Francisco Call · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
The Manager Tells Why Wyatt Earp Was Selected as Referee.
Manager Gibbs of the National Club stated to a representative of The Call how he happened to select Earp to decide a question involving the payment of $10,000.
See moreSee less
"You understand," said he, "that the agreement was that in case Sharkey and Fitzsimmons could not select a referee, then the club should do so, and as time passed and they were far away from the decision we began to cast about for a man. Stepping into the Baldwin one day I saw Mr. Earp, and I told Mr. Groom, who was with me, that if we had to find a man, there was good material.
"I knew that Wyatt Earp was a cool, clear-headed person of an unimpeachable reputation, and one who would be perfectly fair to both fighters. Moreover, he had refereed about thirty fights and had the experience necessary for the position. The only desire of the National Club was to give Fitzsimmons and Sharkey an equal chance in the ring and for that purpose we wanted a just and able referee for the contest. Neither Mr. Groom nor myself spoke to Earp regarding the matter until noon on the day of the fight.
"Sharkey and Fitzsimmons had failed to agree upon a referee and the club must act. Groom and I hunted up Mr. Earp and informed him that we had selected him. We three sat in a small curtained apartment in the Baldwin Hotel. Earp thought over the matter for a few minutes and said that if it were agreeable to all parties concerned he would do his best to render a fair decision.
"Then we notified Julian and Needham and both gentlemen expressed themselves as perfectly satisfied. We congratulated ourselves that all these preliminaries had been settled, but when we got to the ring last night Julian informed us that he objected to the referee. He said he had been told that Earp was going to decide in favor of Sharkey.
"I then brought Needham and Julian together and said: 'Gentlemen, I haven't a word more to say in this matter; settle
Boxing official Billy Jordan and Police Commissioner Moses Gunst both denounce Referee Wyatt Earp's decision favoring Sharkey over Fitzsimmons as a robbery. Gunst recounts being tipped off before the fight to bet on Sharkey, suggesting foreknowledge of a fix.
The San Francisco Call · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
BILLY JORDAN'S FORCIBLE OPINION.
and I know the blow that is claimed to have been foul landed above Sharkey's belt.
If he had been struck where they say he was he would have doubled up and fallen forward instead of on his back. Fitz fought a square, manly fight, and should have had the decision. Sharkey is as foul a fighter as lives, and I have seen them all.
See moreSee less
This thing should be denounced in the public press until all such fakers as these are driven out of the business. Boxing, when carried on properly, is the greatest of sports, but such robbery will kill any pastime. I hope the purse will be withheld until this matter is thoroughly sifted.
Police Commissioner Gunst recounts how suspicious betting shifts toward Sharkey tipped him off that the fight was rigged. He cites horseman Riley Grannan's claim that referee Wyatt Earp had a suspicious exchange with gambler Joe Harvey just before odds shifted dramatically.
The San Francisco Call · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WHAT POLICE COMMISSIONER GUNST SAYS OF THE AFFAIR.
[illegible] CALL.
"It was an outrageous steal," the Commissioner said. "Fitzsimmons was clearly the victor, and he fought as fair a fight as any man ever witnessed. These two gentlemen (indicating a couple of Eastern visitors who were in the office) were with me at dinner yesterday. They were prepared to wager $2000 or $3000 each on Fitzsimmons, and I'm happy to say I prevented them from doing so. While we were dining, a man whose name I do not care to bring into this affair came to me and asked if I was betting any money on the fight. I answered truthfully that I was not. In return I inquired the reason for such a question at that time. He answered, 'Nothing, only if you're betting you had better shift over to the Sharkey end.' I paid little heed to this until another man came to me and the same story was told. Then again, another man, just as trustworthy as the first two, repeated the warning, and gave the same advice. My eyes began to open then.
See moreSee less
"My friends, who had been offering to bet $2000 to $800 on Fitzsimmons and who could find no takers, stepped down the street with me, and all around us we found plenty of Sharkey money at odds of $100 to $65. That was too great a
Sharkey's doctor describes injury from the fight as genuine, and Sharkey recounts being fouled by Fitzsimmons mid-bout. Fitzsimmons publicly denounces the decision as robbery, alleges referee Earp was fixed through racing ties with Sharkey's manager Lynch.
The Record-Union · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
was all right up to the time I was fouled," said he. "Fitzsimmons opened the round rather lively and landed three lefts, but I was growing stronger all the time, and I knew I had him going. Then he led a straight left, and I tried to close in for a short-arm blow. As I did so he uppercut with his right and landed foul. After that I had no remembrance of anything until I found myself in bed here."
Sharkey's confident assertion that he had Fitz "going" just at that time was received with smiles, for it was the general opinion that the Cornishman had the sailor going at that particular moment.
See moreSee less
During the afternoon Sharkey was made glad by the following dispatch from Corbett, dated New York:
San Francisco is split over the outcome of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with some believing Sharkey was fouled and others suspecting the injury was faked with a drug injection. Prominent men including police commissioner Gunst doubt any foul occurred and believe Fitzsimmons should have won, while the selection of referee Wyatt Earp is noted as part of a suspicious process.
The Herald · 4 December 1896 · page 1
ROBERT SAYS HE IS ROBBED
Ulnw—Riley Gtannan Sus- . peoted Crookedness. #- - i Associated Press Special Wire SAN FRANCISCO, nee. 3.—The city I* divided aa to the '-esult of the Fitaslnt mons-fiharkty e,c;ht. which continues tot be the topic of tlie hour. No one ques tion* that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly de pth ed of the decision. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert thai ho was knocked out by a foul blow, and he was conse quently under the rules entitled to the honors of victory, Including the purse of $10,000.
See moreSee less
A th-ird class base their opinions solely upon the report of the physicians in attendance upon Sharkey. The doctors point to the swollen and dis colored conditions of the sailor's skin in tlie region of the groin as evidence of a foul blow, and some ardent Fiizsimmc.-us advocates reply that this condition was purposely caused by an injection of a drug Immediately after the fight. A number of physicians and newspaper men were present in Sharkey's room this afternoon when an examination o| h.s Injuries was made. AH were convinced that Sharkey's condition was the resuit eif a fdtl] blow. Many prominent men. however, con demn the decision, and refuse to tielieva tiiat there was any fouling. Such men as Police CbmmisMiuiter Gunst. "Riley Grannan, Major Frank McLaughlin, whei was chairman of the Republican state central committee, and others helie\e that Fitzsimmons should have received tin' decision. It is pointed out that the « hoi" affair has a disgraceful look. The facts are cited that Lynch. Sharkey's backer, refused to consider ihe name of any one as referee, di clihed every name sugge-ted hy Julian and refused to sug gest any man himself, leaving the se lection with the few individuals com prising the National club. As scion as the club announced its choice of Wyatt Earp. famous as a horseman and a bad man from Arizona, but not as a ring expert, the odds, which had been 10 to 4 against Sharkey, unaccountably rose to 10 to 6. with moreSharkey money of fered than could be well handled. It is recounted that there w ere whispers yes tenlay afternoon that Sharkey WJwj'rl be favored in the decision, an 1 these ru mors reaching Fitzsimmons' ears, lie requested the club to substitute any one
Physicians and witnesses debate whether Sharkey's injury proves a foul or whether referee Wyatt Earp wrongly favored Sharkey. Fitzsimmons' camp alleges a conspiracy and seeks an injunction to block payment of the purse pending investigation.
The Herald · 4 December 1896 · page 1
FITZSIMMONS SAYS HE IS ROBBED
the club announced its choice of Wyatt Earp. famous as a horseman and a bad man from Arizona, but not as a ring expert, the odds, which had been 10 to 4 against Sharkey, unaccountably rose to 10 to 6. with moreSharkey money of fered than could be well handled. It is recounted that there w ere whispers yes tenlay afternoon that Sharkey WJwj'rl be favored in the decision, an 1 these ru mors reaching Fitzsimmons' ears, lie requested the club to substitute any one else as referee. Even at the rlngsidiia, when both Julian and Fitr.slmmooa stated in Harp's presence thai th y had been told that he Intended tn referee un fairly, Karp stood quietly by and insist* ed on acting as referee despite the pre tests.
See moreSee less
It is pointed out that Fitzsimmons fought a clean. skillful, scientific and winning battle, white Sharkey's light was rough and unfair, with ninny fouling tacttcSf such as clasping Fitzsimmons around the legs below the knees and at tempting to throw him. For these of fenses it is charged thai Sharkey was not even reproved by the referee, it is claimed that the upper cut en Sharkey's chin in the eighth round was really a knockout blow, and that no foul blow was delivered by FltSslmmons, but that Sharkey, when knocked out, alleged the foul blow as an excuse, although if the tatter allegation be true, then Sharkey Is a eleven.r actor tlinn many hn\ c sup posed. All this constitutes the case of F;t:' K immons, by which his attorney €K „ pects to prove the existence of a con* Bpiracy to deprive Fitzsimmons of the purse of t'o.ooo. An injunction has been applied for to restrain the AngloCallfornla bank from cashing the Na tional club's check until Fitzsimmons* has an opportunity te> prove the con* Bpiracy. Wheh Lynch, Sharkey's back er, and Referee Earp went to the bank this morning with the check payment was refused by the teller, who referred
Prominent sporting men in New York were asked about the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight decision, with most agreeing Fitzsimmons was unfairly robbed of victory. Several accused the club and referee of a fixed outcome, predicting the scandal would damage boxing's reputation.
New York Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CALL IT ROBBERY.
Many well-known sporting men now in New York and its vicinity were asked yesterday for their opinions as to the decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, and they were almost unanimous in the belief that Fitzsimmons had been robbed.
What they had to say follows:
See moreSee less
Al Smith—There is not the slightest doubt that Fitzsimmons was deliberately robbed. Fitzsimmons, in my judgment, based on all the reports I have read, was a better man in every way than Sharkey, and won fairly and squarely. He was "jobbed" by a few men, who have thus given pugilism the hard-
Tom Sharkey insists Fitzsimmons intentionally struck him with a low blow in the eighth round, describing the moment in detail. Fitzsimmons counters that he never fouled, claims he was robbed by referee Wyatt Earp's decision, and calls Sharkey a dirty wrestler rather than a boxer.
New York Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
cut me with his left. The blow caught me in the groin and doubled me up. I fell to the floor in great pain.
"No other blow that I received in that round hurt me in the slightest. I believe the blow was intentionally struck
See moreSee less
TOM SHARKEY."
FITZSIMMONS SAYS HE WAS ROBBED.
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Bob Fitzsimmons has made the following statement about the fight:
"I was simply robbed of $10,000 by that decision. I felt sure I was going against the worst of it when Earp was named, but my reputation was at stake and I took chances.
"I never struck a foul blow in my life, and no one knows better than Sharkey that I won last night's fight fair and square. Look at me. Do you see a single mark or scratch? Did I get a good, solid punch during the fight? Why, that dub is simply a strong young wrestler, and one of the foulest boxers I ever saw.
"Nobody can get a square deal from the thieves who handle fights in this town. I now believe Corbett was robbed of the decision here in his Jackson fight."
Doctors detail Sharkey's injuries following his disputed loss to Fitzsimmons, while police monitor his condition for a possible arrest of Fitzsimmons. The Anglo-Californian Bank refuses to release the $10,000 purse amid disputes over referee Wyatt Earp's decision, with both sides' agents demanding the bank withhold payment.
New York Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
"LANKY BOB" MAY BE ARRESTED.
this they would not have taken the money. Now they will not pay until they are assured that no loss will come to them. Sharkey's representatives made demand for the money at the bank this morning and were refused. Agents of Fitzsimmons were also at the bank and ordered the officials not to pay. The affair will probably go into the courts for settlement. There is much di-
Following referee Wyatt Earp's decision awarding the fight to Sharkey, bettors and fight camps dispute whether winnings should be paid out, with Fitzsimmons's backers blocking payment at the bank. Sporting editor William Naughton gives his eyewitness account of the match's final moments, supporting the view that Fitzsimmons was dominating before Sharkey went down.
New York Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
It is understood that Corbett will take no notice of these warnings, but that as soon as Wyatt Earp hands him a written decision to the effect that Sharkey was awarded the fight he will pay out all the money that is called for by the holders of Sharkey tickets.
Many who made private wagers paid the amounts won, and are now regretting that they did so. Others resolutely refused to make good, on the grounds that the decision was a fraud and that the final issue in regard to the purse is still in doubt. Only one of the big pool rooms here has paid off on Sharkey.
Sharkey's manager plans to sue the bank for withholding the $10,000 purse after it refused payment amid fraud allegations against referee Wyatt Earp and the National Athletic Club. The report notes public disagreement over whether Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey, and mentions Earp was arrested for carrying concealed weapons but released on $50 bail.
The Evening Times · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
NOW COMES A LEGAL FIGHT
sided with the Cornishman, and proclaimed their belief that he was the victim of a deliberate plot on the part of the National Club managers and Referee Earp, to rob him of the decision. But there were others among whom were men of unim-
Tom Sharkey is recovering from the brutal fight and recounts being fouled by Fitzsimmons before losing consciousness, while Fitzsimmons rages that referee Wyatt Earp's foul decision was 'robbery.' Fitzsimmons has filed suit to claim the $10,000 purse after the bank refused to honor the certified check awarded to Sharkey.
The Morning Times · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
SUING FOR THE MONEY.
Robert Fitzsimmons formally began suit in the superior court today to obtain possession of the $10,000 purse offered by the National Athletic Club, and which was awarded by Referee Wyatt Earp to Thomas Sharkey, Wednesday night. The action is directed against the Anglo-California Bank, which issued the certified check, and against Thomas Sharkey, John Doe and Richard Doe.
See moreSee less
This morning the Anglo-California Bank declined to cash the check of the National Club for $10,000 when it was presented
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Wyatt Earp, referee of the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, defends his foul decision and says he regrets not leaving the ring when challenged. Fitzsimmons adds that he now believes the National Club conspired with Lynch and Sharkey.
Evening Star · 4 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
CURRENT SPORTING NOTES
SAN FRANCISCO, December 4.--Wyatt Earp, the referee in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, the most talked-of man of the hour, takes a philosophical view of the criticisms that are being heaped upon him for his decision Wednesday night, and says he will wait for time to set him right with the public.
See moreSee less
"If I had any fears that I erred in my decision, they would have disappeared when I saw Sharkey today," said he last night. "Sharkey did not strike a foul blow, to my mind. At the break he struck Fitzsimmons as soon as his arm was free, but that is following Queensbury rules. It is true that it was agreed that there was to be no fighting at the break, but my instructions from the club were not to be technical, but to give the audience a good fight for their money.
"I have one regret about the whole matter, and that is that I did not leave the ring when Julian objected to me. I thought of doing it, but it occurred to me that it would be showing the yellow to do that; I would be quitting under fire, and I made up my mind to stay until ordered off by the club. I am sorry that I acted as referee at all."
The only inconvenience Fitzsimmons is suffering as a result of his meeting with the sailor is a painful swelling of the joints of the hands.
"I have nothing more to say in explanation," he said, "except we know for a certainty what we only surmised yesterday, and that is the members of the National Club were in this deal with Lynch and Sharkey to rob us, and what is more, we are going to prove it in court.
"Had it not been that I was saving my hands as much as possible I would have put Sharkey out in the second round. His head is as hard as a bullet, and I must
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va. · 5 December 1896
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Wyatt Earp, acting as referee, awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim after Fitzsimmons appeared to knock him out in the eighth round, sparking widespread public and press controversy. Fitzsimmons claimed he had been warned beforehand that the fight was fixed, and bookmakers were ordered not to pay out bets while his manager sought an injunction to block the $10,000 purse.
New-York Tribune · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
manager went in search of an injunction to prevent the payment of the $10,000 purse, and the tongues of the so-called sporting men all over the country were set to wagging at a lively rate. Fitzsimmons
cision on the reports received,, but all say that the bets should follow the decision of the referee.
See moreSee less
All boxing contests should be held in this city, where it is fostered and cared for by leading men in exalted places, who are the exponents of a
Referee Wyatt Earp disqualified Tom Sharkey for a low blow after Fitzsimmons landed a knockout upper cut in the eighth round, sparking accusations of robbery from boxing experts at ringside. Fitzsimmons' manager Martin Julian vowed to seek fights with both Corbett and Sharkey, while witnesses disputed whether the blow was actually a foul.
The Morning News · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Purse.
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Following is a copy of a telegram sent last night by Fitzsimmons' manager: "To Dan A. Stuart, Dallas, Tex.: We were robbed to-night, but this outrageous decision will not make any difference in our plans. Fitzsimmons will meet both Sharkey and Corbett in the same ring any time you are ready to arrange a match. Martin Julian."
See moreSee less
Whether or not Bob Fitzsimmons did or did not foul Tom Sharkey in last night's fight will furnish more talk in this city than is necessary to elect a president.
Sharkey has the money but Fitzsimmons certainly has all the honor. From the time the two shook hands at 10:35 o'clock last night until Sharkey dropped like a tenpin before a terrific upper cut in the eighth round, Fitz out-generaled, out-punched and out-winded his antagonist. Experts in pugilism swarmed around the ring side, but the boxer who saw Fitz strike a foul blow is not to be found.
Jack McAuliffe, Jimmy Carroll, Johnny Herget (Young Mitchell), Long Agnew, Eddie Graney and scores of others declare that the decision of Referee Wyatt Earp was a plain case of robbery.
Maj. Frank McLaughlin, chairman of the republican state central committee, who, was probably in a better position to see the alleged foul than anybody, says that the knockout was as clean an upper cut
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 3 other papers
After referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim, Fitzsimmons bitterly denounced the decision as fixed, insisting his punch landed fairly above the belt. Physicians examined the injured Sharkey through the night while a legal challenge to block payment of the purse was being prepared.
The Morning News · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
as he ever saw.
Earp's selection as referee came about in a peculiar way. For many days Martin Julian has urged Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, to name a satisfactory man, but Lynch invariably refused to do so, claiming that there was plenty of time. Yesterday morning the managers wrangled over the question for hours. Julian named man after man, but Lynch was obdurate, and when the noon hour arrived, President Groom of the National club was called upon to make a selection. He fixed upon Wyatt Earp, and Mr. Julian agreed to accept him. Rather than leave Fitzsimmons open to the charge of cowardice, Julian took the short end of the stick.
See moreSee less
That Sharkey has improved as a boxer, no one who saw him perform last night will deny. That he is greatly overrated and entirely outclassed in a contest with Fitzsimmons is also not disputed. The men were about evenly matched in weight, there being less than two pounds difference between them.
"I was simply robbed of $10,000 by that decision," said Fitzsimmons, after last night's battle. "I felt sure I was going against the worst of it when Earp was named, but my reputation was at stake, and I took chances. I never struck a foul blow in my life, and no one knows better than Sharkey that I won last night's fight fair and square. Look at me. Do you see a single mark or scratch? Did I get a good, solid punch during the fight? Why, that dub is simply a strong young wrestler and one of the foulest boxers I ever saw. Nobody can get a square deal from the thieves who handle fights in this town.
"I now believe Corbett was robbed of the decision here in his Jackson fight."
Sharkey asserts that he had the best of every round, and would certainly have won had he not been fouled. Sporting writers are unanimous in saying that the sailor is the luckiest man that ever stepped into a ring. Sharkey announces his willingness to meet all comers for the world's championship.
Mr. Julian will ask for an injunction restraining the bank from paying Sharkey the check for the purse of $10,000, and the matter will be taken into the courts.
Fitzsimmons was around the Baldwin hotel at an early hour this morning, showing not the faintest trace of his encounter with Sharkey last night. He is most bitter in his denunciation of the "sailor's foul tactics," Referee Earp and the management of the fight. He says he was robbed of the decision, and that it was preconcerted to give the battle to his opponent. The blow which laid Sharkey low, the Australian declares, was a right hand hook on the stomach. This landed fairly and not below the belt as maintained by the referee. Fitzsimmons is anxious to meet Sharkey again, and will fight him any time and place the latter may name.
Those in attendance upon Sharkey, say that he suffered terribly all night, requiring the constant service of two physicians up to 4 o'clock, when he fell asleep. One of his attendants said Sharkey's groin was severely swollen and highly inflamed. He appears to be resting easier to-day. A police officer is on watch at Sharkey's quarters, and if the condition of the pugilist becomes serious. Fitzsimmons will be arrested.
Three of the most reputable physicians in this city, Drs. B. B. Lee, D. F. Ragan, and T. A. Rottanzi, examined Sharkey at 10:15 o'clock this morning, the Southern Associated Press reporter being present. The result was this statement from Dr. Ragan, the other two doctors acquiescing: "Sharkey has a gash over the left eye, which could not have been caused by a blow from a glove, as the eye is not closed, also a swelling on the left cheek, to which we applied a leech this morning. The left ear is swollen from extravasation or blood settling under the surface. There is not a bruise or a mark on the upper part of the body save a slight abrasion of the skin, caused by contact with the ropes in the fifth round, and which is of no consequence whatever."
"This is what caused the damage," and here Sharkey was stripped and the physician pointed to a huge swelling on the lower part of the body near the groin. There was discoloration in one spot, showing where the blow had landed. This, Sharkey said, was caused by Fitz hooking him with his elbow. Dr. Ragan explained that the swelling was the same as in the ear, caused by extravasation, and would require leeches to subdue. There is no hernia and no permanent injury, but the doctors were unanimous that Sharkey could never have entered the ring or stood on his feet had he been in his present condition. It will be several days before Sharkey can leave his bed.
During the afternoon Sharkey rallied somewhat and talked of the battle. "I was all right up to the time I was fouled," said Sharkey. "Fitzsimmons opened the round rather lively and landed three lefts, but I was growing stronger all the time and I knew I had him going. Then he led a straight left and I tried to close in for a short arm blow. As I did so he
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C. · 4 December 1896
The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa. · 4 December 1896
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 4 December 1896
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
San Francisco remains split over referee Wyatt Earp's ruling that Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey, costing him the $10,000 purse. Physicians and witnesses disagree on whether Sharkey's groin injury proves a foul or was staged, while Fitzsimmons pursues legal action to block payment to Sharkey.
Rock Island Argus · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
RUBY BOB APPEALS TO THE LAW.
Earp's Dictum—Foul Blow Was Struck, However—The Marine Severely Hurt. San Francisco, Dec. 4.—The city is divided to the result of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, which continues to be the topic of the hour. No one questions that Fitzsimmons had the fight practically won in the eighth round, and many assert that he was unjustly deprived of the decision. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow, and was consequently, under the rules, entitled to the honors of victory, including the purse of $10,000. Other persons, again, base their opinions solely upon the reports of the physicians in attendance upon Sharkey.
See moreSee less
The doctors point to the swollen and discolored condition of the sailor's skin in the region of the groin as evidence of a foul blow, and some ardent Fitzsimmons advocates reply that this condition was purposely caused by an injection of a drug immediately after the fight.
Following the disputed foul decision by referee Wyatt Earp, Fitzsimmons' camp argues he fought cleanly while Sharkey fouled repeatedly, and that medical evidence shows no bruising to support Sharkey's claim of a low blow. A judge has granted an injunction preventing the bank from releasing the $10,000 purse pending investigation of an alleged conspiracy.
Rock Island Argus · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ FOUGHT A CLEAN FIGHT.
While Sharkey Was Unfair All Through—Case Will Go Into Court.
See moreSee less
It is pointed out that Fitzsimmons fought a clean, skillful, scientific and winning battle, while Sharkey's fight was rough and unfair. For his unfairness it is charged that Sharkey was not even reproved by the referee. It is claimed that the uppercut on Sharkey's chin in the eighth round was really a knock-out blow and that no foul blow was delivered by Fitzsimons, but that Sharkey, when knocked out, alleged the foul as an excuse. All this constitutes the case of Fitzsimmons by which his attorneys expect to prove the existence of a conspiracy to deprive Fitzsimmons of the purse of $10,000. An injunction has been applied for to restrain the Anglo-California bank from cashing the National club check until Fitzsimmons has had an oportunity to prove the conspiracy.
Meantime Sharkey is in bed with three doctors in constant attendance, and he is likely to remain where he is for several days; the $10,000 is in the bank and is also likely to remain where it is for some time; and Bob Fitzsimmons, without mark or bruise, and followed by an admiring and cheering crowd, is walking the streets, receiving continued ovations as the real winner of the encounter.
Sharkey's only visible bruises are two on the left side of the face, one a cut which had rather neatly divided the left eyebrow lengthwise.
"He gave me that cut with his elbow when he fouled me early in the fight," said Sharkey.
The doctors called attention to the fact that there was nothing to indicate that Sharkey had received any particular punishment previous to the striking of the blow which ended the fight. This seemed to be the fact, for there were no discolorations or bruises at all upon Sharkey's body except at the point below the belt where the al-
A Wichita dispatch recounts that Wyatt Earp, referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, once served as a policeman in Wichita under Chief Mike Meagher in 1875. Former colleagues, including ex-chief Dick Cogdell, vouch for Earp's fearlessness and honesty, also claiming he had been marshal at Ellsworth, Kansas.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Topeka State Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
EARP LIVED IN WICHITA. Referee of Fitzsimmons-SharkeyFight Once a Policeman in Kansas. Wichita, Dec. 4.—In 1875 Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was a policeman in Wichita under the notorious Chief of Police Mike
Referee Wyatt Earp explains his decision to award the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight to Sharkey on a foul, insisting Fitzsimmons struck an illegal low blow in the eighth round. Earp also says he regrets not stopping the fight earlier over an alleged elbow foul in the fourth round.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FISTS ARE USELESS ONLY VOCAL ORGANS COUNT IN THE CONTEST NOW ON
EARP STICKS TO IT. He said: "There is one thing I regret. I should have given Sharkey the fight earlier in the contest. In the fourth
A satirical newspaper column of miscellaneous quips includes a brief remark expressing mock surprise that charges have been brought against Wyatt Earp, described as Wichita's resident, regarding his reputation as a 'square sport.' The item is a fragment within a larger collection of unrelated witty observations on politics, sports, and current events.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 4 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Daily Eagle M. M. MURDOCK, Editor.
The question now is whether the Texas is hoodooed or hoodone.
See moreSee less
The only way Spain could whip us, apparently, would be by our fouling her in the last round.
Young politicians should not at this season confound the itch for office with the buckwheat kind.
Up to date the Chippewa is the only river which got jealous over the recent prominence of the Platte.
Kansas has a short grass country, but Topeka, which seems to be long on grass widows, is not in it.
There was a man named Riordan who never recovered sufficiently to claim a foul on Fitzsimmons. Sharkey is in luck
Grover Cleveland could leave the people with a pleasant taste in their mouths by simply doing his duty by Cuba. But he will not.
To think that at this late day charges against Wichita's Wyatt Earp as a
The report covers the disputed outcome of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, including a disputed check payment and an injunction suit over alleged conspiracy. It also notes that referee Wyatt Earp was disarmed by police before the fight and later arrested for carrying a concealed weapon.
The Evening Bulletin · 4 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Not Serious. San Francisco, Dec. 4.—The city is divided as to the result of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight which continues to be the topic of the hour. Sharkey's friends vehemently assert that he was knocked out by a foul blow and was consequently, under the rules, entitled to the honors of victory including the purse of $10,000. Doctors say that Sharkey's condition is serious, but not dangerous, and have ordered him to remain in bed at least two or three days, stating that exercise, or any movement might aggravate his injuries. When Lynch and Referee Earp went to the bank yesterday with the check
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · and 1 other paper
Referee Wyatt Earp declared Fitzsimmons' blow a foul, awarding the fight to Sharkey, while witnesses and Fitzsimmons himself disputed this account, claiming the punch legally landed on the stomach. Sharkey was reportedly in genuine pain afterward, requiring medical attention, though Fitzsimmons accused the whole decision of being a prearranged scheme.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
his bed.
The sporting editor of the San Francisco Examiner, Wm. Naughton, today, said: "If Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey a foul blow, last night, I did not see it. I would scarcely like to go on record as saying that the punch on which the fight was given to the Sailor was no foul. I was in the press stand, on the south side of the hall, and when the critical moment arrived, Fitzsimmons was forcing Sharkey along the ropes toward the north. The Cornishman, whose back was to me, and whose frame shielded Sharkey, was fast bearing the Sailor down.
See moreSee less
"I was calling off the blows to a stenographer, and I saw a whizzing left hook go up from Fitzsimmon's hip. It caught Sharkey on the chin or mouth and the Sailor began to sink. Then I saw Fitzsimmons' right elbow come back, and he delivered a body punch. I should imagine it took effect somewhere about Sharkey's stomach or short ribs on the left side. Any how, in a moment, Sharkey was on the floor on his back. He was not knocked out. He was making grimaces and placing his hands on the groin, and if he was not in agony all I can say is he is a consummate actor.
"Afterward I heard a dozen citizens of excellent reputation say they plainly saw the foul. They were in a better position to see than I, as they were at the ringside, close to where Sharkey fell, and there was nohting to intercept their view. Some of them said the blow was accidental and others thought it was intentional."
Wyatt Earp, referee, made the following statement: "The foul blow of the night was seen plainly by me. Fitzsimmons smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder and then with an upper cut with his left he struck the Sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over, and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul and before the Sailor moved I mentioned that the fight was over. The first blow was weak and I believe the second blow was intended for an upper cut, but it struck foul.
"No man on earth ever questioned my honor. I have been in many places in peculiar situations but none ever said till tonight, I was guilty of a dishonest act. I will repeat that I decided in all fairness and with judgment that was as true as my eye sight. I saw the foul blow."
Fitzsimmons was around the Baldwin Hotel, early, this morning, showing not the faintest trace of his encounter with Sharkey, last night. He is most bitter in his denunciation of the Sailor's foul tactics, Referee Earp and the management of the fight. He says he was robbed of the decision and it was a preconcerted scheme to give the battle to his opponent.
The blow which laid Sharkey low, the Australian declares, was a right hand hook on the stomach. This landed fairly and not below the belt as maintained by the referee. Fitzsimmons is anxious to meet Sharkey again and will fight him at any time and place the latter may name. Those in attendance upon Sharkey say he suffered terribly, all night, requiring the constant service of two physicians up to 4 o'clock, when he fell asleep. One of his attendants said Sharkey's groin was severely swollen and highly inflamed.
During the afternoon, Sharkey rallied somewhat and talked of the battle. At. 9 tonight, the Sailor was comfortably resting.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn. · 4 December 1896
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
Referee Wyatt Earp states he clearly saw Fitzsimmons strike Sharkey with an illegal low blow and insists his decision was honest. Fitzsimmons angrily denounces the ruling as a fix, while doctors confirm Sharkey has no lasting injury despite his inability to have continued fighting.
The Portland Daily Press · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Talks Much—Sharkey's Condition.
San Francisco, December 8.—Wyatt Earp, referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight has made the following statement: "The foul blow of the night was seen plainly by me. Fitz smashed with his right on Sharkey's shoulder, and then with an upper cut with the left, he struck the sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over, and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul and before the sailor moved I motioned that the fight was over. The first blow was weak I believe the second blow was intended for an upper cut, but it struck foul. No man on earth ever questioned my honor. I have been in many places and in peculiar situations, but none ever said till tonight that I was guilty of a dishonest act. I will repeat that I decided in all fairness and with judgement that was as true as my eyesight, I saw a foul blow."
See moreSee less
Fitzsimmons is most bitter in his denunciations of the sailor's foul tactics, Referee Earp and the management of the fight. He says it was a preconcerted scheme to give the battle to his opponent. Fitzsimmons is anxious to meet Sharkey again. Three of the most reputable citizens in this city examined Sharkey at 10.15 this morning. There is no hernia and no permanent injury. The doctors were unanimous in the belief that Sharkey could never have entered the ring or stood on his feet had he been in his present condition. It will be several days before Sharkey can leave his bed.
During the afternoon Sharkey rallied somewhat, and talked of the battle. At nine tonight the sailor was resting comfortably.
Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the bout to Sharkey on a disputed foul call, despite Fitzsimmons dominating and seemingly knocking him out in the eighth round. The 20,000-strong crowd booed the decision, as no one in the press area had witnessed any foul by Fitzsimmons.
Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 4 December 1896 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image
Fight Ended.
Decision Roundly Hissed by the Twenty Thousand People Present.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3.—The 10-round contest between Bob Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey, the sailor, ended in the eighth round by the knockout of Sharkey, although the latter was given the decision on an alleged foul. The decision of the referee was loudly hissed, as few if any of the audience of 20,000 people had noticed any unfair work on the part of Fitzsimmons. The foul, if foul it was, could not be seen from the press stand, but Referee Earp gave his decision in spite of Fitzsimmons' protest.
It was Fitsimmons' fight from start to finish. He fought fairly while the sailor continually used foul tactics. He
Physicians and witnesses disagree over whether Sharkey's groin injury proves a foul blow by Fitzsimmons, while prominent men suspect a conspiracy involving betting odds and referee Wyatt Earp's conduct. Fitzsimmons' camp seeks an injunction to block payment of the purse while they attempt to prove a conspiracy to rig the decision against him.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
HIT SHARKEY BELOW THE BELT
Police Commissioner Gunst, Riley Grannan, Major Frank McLaughlin and others, believe that Fitzsimmons should have received the decision. It is pointed out that the whole affair has a disagreeable look. The facts are cited that Lynch, Sharkey's backer, refused to consider the name of anyone as referee, declined every name suggested by Julian and refused to sug-
Fitzsimmons appeared to knock out Sharkey in the eighth round with a left to the chin, but referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a claim of foul. Conflicting wire reports differ on whether a foul actually occurred, with one account claiming Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey's groin with his knee while another says no foul was visible from the press stand.
Great Falls Weekly Tribune · 4 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
ABSOLUTELY PURE
NNER LOST
See moreSee less
Practically Knocked Sharkey in the th Round.
OF HIS VICTORY
Awarded Sharkey by p on an Alleged l Blow.
Dec. 2.--No event in ugilism on the Pacific ted public attention battle between the ert Fitzsimmons and tonight. and 20,000 people occupied able space in the big on and watched the veryone regarded as the championship of
key then removed the objectionable articles.
At 10:30 the men shook hand and time was called. The seven first rounds were characterized by rather good sparring on the part of both of the contestants though clinching played quite an important part. At the end of the seventh Fitsimmons appeared tired and did not force the fighting, and Sharkey appeared fresh.
Round 8--Fitzsimmons led left for face and missed, but a moment later landed a right swing on head twice. Sharkey clinched and rushed Fitzsimmons to the ropes. Fitzsimmons tried left on head and countered with right on head. Fitzsimmons swung right and left on head and Sharkey landed left on head. Fitzsimmons swung right on head and Sharkey came back with left on wind. Fitzsimmons jabbed Sharkey in face with left and swung right on jaw twice. He then landed his right-arm blow on face. Sharkey down and out. After two minutes and a half of the eighth had expired Fitzsimmons landed a right for jaw and then put his left crook on chin, which put Sharkey on the floor with a smash.
The report details conflicting opinions over whether Sharkey won by a foul blow from Fitzsimmons or faked the foul to avoid a legitimate knockout. It highlights suspicions about referee Wyatt Earp's impartiality, noting betting odds shifted suspiciously once he was chosen, and describes Fitzsimmons' legal action to recover the disputed purse.
The Anaconda Standard · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
decision.
It is pointed out that the whole affair has a disagreeable look. The facts are cited that Lynch, Sharkey's backer, refused to consider the name of any one as referee: declined every name suggested by Julian, and refused to suggest any man himself, leaving the selection with the few individuals comprising the National club. As soon as the club announced its choice of Wyatt Earp, famous as a horseman and bad man from Arizona, but not as a ring expert, the odds which had been 10 to 4 against Sharkey, unaccountably rose to 10 to 6, with more Sharkey money offered than could be well handled.
Bookmaker Grannan describes warning Fitzsimmons about suspicious betting swings favoring Sharkey just before the fight, which made him suspect foul play. The report also notes Wyatt Earp was disarmed before refereeing and later arrested for carrying a concealed weapon, while physicians examined Sharkey's groin injury from the disputed low blow.
The Anaconda Standard · 4 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
ing the fight."
Riley Grannan, when interviewed said: "Yes, I did advise Fitzsimmons to be on his guard. The betting operations assumed such proportions yesterday afternoon that I felt convinced something was wrong. Up to noon the odds had been in favor of Fitzsimmons at about the right price, 4 and 5 to 1, but when, after that time, nothing was seen but Sharkey money, which was offered at any price and when I could find absolutely no one who would take a bet on Fitzsimmons at even money, I felt sure something must be wrong. Ordinarily I would have bet $5,000 or $6,000, but I felt so convinced that things were crooked that I immediately tried to hedge the $1,300 on Fitzsimmons, which was all I had bet, which I was not successful in doing. I immediately hunted up Fitzsimmons and communicated to him my suspicions. I told him I knew nothing definite, but I thought it a remarkable thing that when on Tuesday it was impossible to bet money on Sharkey at 4 to 1 it looked queer to see at least $20,000 go begging yesterday at odds of even money on the sailor.
See moreSee less
"I watched the fight from beginning to end. I cannot say too much in praise of Fitzsimmons' work and I confidently assert that the blow which Sharkey claims foul was above the belt and fair in every respect."
When Wyatt Earp appeared in the ring last night to act as referee he was disarmed by Police Captain Wiltman ,who took from the Arizona man a large-sized pistol. To-night Earp was arrested on a charge of carrying concealed weapons. He was released on $40 bail. A delegation of six reputable physicians examined Sharkey to-night and made the following report: "We find an oedema or swelling on the left side of the groin. Also two small ecchymotic spots or discolorations about half way down on the right side."
Dr. Lee, the man called in to attend Sharkey last night, in spite of the fact that other doctors offered their services, is not recognized by the regular medical fraternity of this city. It is stated by a prominent physician that the injuries exhibited by Sharkey could have been caused by a blow on the naval.
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.
This report describes the heavyweight boxing match between Robert Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey in San Francisco, where referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the win and $10,000 purse despite Sharkey being knocked out, ruling that Fitzsimmons had fouled him with his knee. The fight was called the likely decider of the world heavyweight championship, with a crowd of 15,000-20,000 in attendance.
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY KNOCKED OUT, BUT STILL WINNER OF $10,000
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted public attention here as did the battle between the heavy weights, Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey last night. Between 15,000 and 20,000 people occupied all the available space in the big Mechanics pavillion and watched the contest, which everyone regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world. The long, lean New Zealander, who had a succession of victories in the United States for the last five or six years, entered the ring with almost every apparent advantage in his favor.
See moreSee less
He could count upon his experience and science; his height and reach and every other quality which enters into the making of the successful prize fighter. Against him was the sailor lad who was unknown six months ago, but who rose to fame recently when he came perilously near trailing in the dust the colors of
After Sharkey's win on a foul, Fitzsimmons' manager Martin Julian publicly charged that referee Wyatt Earp had been bribed to rule against Fitzsimmons, alleging the fight's outcome was prearranged. Club president Groom denied complicity while Adolph Spreckels publicly accused Groom and club members of being part of the fix.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TALK OF BRIBERY.
Julian Openly Charges That the Matter Was All Prearranged.
See moreSee less
New York, Dec. 3.—A special to The World from San Francisco says: After the fight was over, and Fitzsimmons returned to his dressing room, Martin Julian, on the sugestion of Fitzsimmons, gave out the following statement:
"About 6:30 this evening, Mose Guntz, Riley Grannan and Tom Jones came to us and said that Earp was 'fixed,' and that we would not get the decision, even though we knocked Sharkey out. But rather than have the fight fall through, we consented to Earp. And what has been the result? We have been robbed. Fitzsimmons never struck a foul blow during the fight, but Sharkey struck at least 50. I intend to stop the payment of the check, if possible, and will make a protest to the club against its payment."
At this point, J. J. Groom, president of the club, came in, and Julian took him to task for the decision, and called upon him to stop the payment of the check.
Mr. Groom said that the club was taking legal advice as to whether a certified check could be stopped. If it could be, he said, it would be, as he denounced the decision as an outrage. Mr. Groom also declared that during the fight he had repeatedly called to Earp about Sharkey's repeated foul blows.
Adolph Spreckels, son of the sugar refiner, met President Groom after the decision was given out, and declared himself in strong terms. Shaking his
Physicians examining Sharkey point to bruising near the groin as proof of a foul blow, while skeptics suggest the injury was staged with an injection; prominent men including police commissioners say Fitzsimmons should have won. Meanwhile a bank refuses to release the $10,000 purse to Sharkey pending Fitzsimmons' legal challenge alleging conspiracy.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
BANK WILL NOT HONOR CHECK.
ever, condemn the decision and refuse to believe that there was any fouling. Such men as Police Commissioners Gunst, Riley Grannan, Major Frank McLaughlin, who was chairman of the Republican state central committee, and others believe that Fitzsimmons should have received the decision.
Experts disagree on whether Fitzsimmons' final blow against Sharkey was a foul below the belt or a legal hit to the stomach. A bank has refused to honor a $10,000 certificate pending court resolution while Sharkey is treated for groin injuries.
The Sun · 4 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
WAS SHARKEY FOULED?
Speaks Out—The Views of Eastern Men. SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3.—The developments of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight have produced a tangle unparalleled in sporting annals. The case may be summed up in this way: The
After Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul blow, Fitzsimmons filed suit alleging Earp and Sharkey's backer Dan Lynch conspired to fix the outcome, securing a court injunction blocking payment of the $10,000 purse. Witnesses were divided on whether the blow was actually foul, with suspicions fueled by betting odds shifts and Earp's friendship with Lynch.
The Sun · 4 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
irrespective of the merits of the contest, and that Earp was chosen as referee to carry out this fraudulent agreement. Fitz charges that he fought a square fight and should have got the decision, but that Referee Earp made use of the alleged foul blow to carry out his corrupt bargain, and that after awarding the fight to
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the $10,000 purse after ruling Fitzsimmons struck a foul blow in their bout. Fitzsimmons is contesting the decision legally, prompting the bank to withhold payment on the certified check pending court review.
The Silver State · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
AFTER THE FIGHT.
Fitzsimmons Contests Sharkey's Right to the Purse.
See moreSee less
A San Francisco dispatch says: Although Sharkey was awarded the decision after the eighth round in Wednesday night's battle with Fitzsimmons, the referee declaring that Fitz had struck a foul blow, the sailor may not get the $10,000 purse after all. At any rate, he will have to make a legal fight for it, which may prove a much harder struggle than he had Wednesday night. When the referee, Wyatt Earp, declared that Fitz had struck Sharkey below the belt and that Sharkey was the victor on a foul, he handed Lynch, who is Sharkey's backer and manager, a certified check on the Anglo-California bank for $10,000. Fitzsimmons promptly protested and consulted an attorney, who decided to enjoin the bank from paying the money until the courts could pass on Sharkey's rights to the purse. Yesterday morning, soon after the bank opened, Lynch presented the certified check and demanded payment. To his surprise, the bank officials refused to honor the check.
In the meantime the bank had been warned by Fitzsimmons' attorney that it would be held responsible for the money if the courts decided against Sharkey. Bank Manager Phillip N. Lilienthal consulted his attorney, and was advised to refuse payment temporarily. Lynch was told that the bank was in the position of an innocent stakeholder, and that for its own protection it would defer the payment of the certified check.
Opinions vary at the outcome of this difficulty about the purse, Lynch and his friends declaring that the decision of the referee is final and that there can be no appeal from his ruling. They maintain also that the courts cannot recognize the validity of the contest or the prize money. Fitzsimmons' advisers assert, however, that a limited contest such as that of Wednesday night is within the law and was not interfered with by the police, and that the purse is a legitimate subject of legal controversy.
Fitz denies that he struck a foul blow, and declares that he knocked out Sharkey by an uppercut on the chin. He accuses the referee of unfair ruling throughout the fight, and says Sharkey fouled him many times, but the referee allowed such fouls to pass unreproved. Fitz declares that Earp had previously arranged to give Sharkey the decision and says that Earp made a crooked bargain to that effect with the bookmakers.
On the other hand the doctors and newspapermen who saw Sharkey stripped after the fight say that there were unmistakable marks of a blow in the region of tne groin.
Many believe that the foul blow was delivered accidentally. Others openly say that Fitzsimmons intentionally delivered the foul blow just after the uppercut on the chin, and that he intended that the uppercut should appear to be a knockout blow, hoping that the foul would pass unnoticed as Sharkey fell.
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the fight on a foul after the 8th round, handing Lynch a $10,000 certified check, but the bank refused to honor it amid legal challenges from Fitzsimmons' camp. Fitzsimmons denies fouling Sharkey and accuses Earp of bias toward bookmakers, while doctors confirm signs of a groin injury on Sharkey.
Morning Appeal · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Opinions vary as to the outcome of this difficulty about the purse. Lynch and his friends declare that the decision is final and that there is no appeal from it Fitzsimmons advisers assert that the contest was not stopped by the police and therefore is subject to legal controversy.
Fitzsimmons' camp argues the fight was not properly stopped and accuses referee Wyatt Earp of making a crooked bargain favoring bookmakers, while denying any foul blow was struck intentionally. Doctors confirm Sharkey has clear signs of a groin injury, but opinions are divided on whether the foul was accidental or a deliberate cover for the uppercut.
Morning Appeal · 4 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Fitz denies that he struck a foul blow. He accuses the referee of unfair ruling throughout the fight and that Sharkey fouled him many times. Fitz declares that Earp made a crooked bargain to that effect in the interest of the bookmakers.
The doctors and newspapermen who saw Sharkey stripped after the fight say that there were unmistakable signs of a blow in the groin. Today Sharkey is in bed and he is badly
Referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey after ruling Fitzsimmons fouled him with a low blow, sparking disputes from Fitzsimmons' backers who claim he was robbed. Corbett telegraphs sympathy to Sharkey and challenges him to a future match, while physicians confirm Sharkey was genuinely injured below the belt.
The Ohio Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY IS A GAME PUG
Sharkey has received the following telegram from James J. Corbett, who had announced his intention of challenging the winner: "I am very sorry at Mr. Fitzsimmons' foul tactics in his contest with you which prevented your getting a decision over him in a full 10-round contest without a foul. I am ready to meet you on or before Jan. 1, 1897." A certified check for the amount of the purse was given to Sharkey by Referee Wyatt Earp after the fight. Some of Fitzsimmons' backers talk of enjoining the bank from paying the
After Wyatt Earp, acting as referee, awarded the fight to Sharkey, a certified check for the $10,000 purse was given to him, but Fitzsimmons' backers sought to block payment and the bank refused to honor it pending court action. Witnesses and doctors confirmed Sharkey was injured below the belt, with opinions divided on whether the foul blow was intentional.
The Ohio Democrat · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY IS A GAME PUG
in bed at least two or three days, stating that exercise or any movement might aggravate his injuries. Witnesses of the fight declare that a foul blow was undoubtedly delivered, but many believe it was accidental. The Anglo-California bank, on which the check for $10,000 was drawn by the National club, has refused payment. The check was presented by Lynch, Sharkey's backer. The bank officials told Lynch they must decline to pay the check until the courts decided that Sharkey was entitled to the money. The bank officials say they are acting on legal advice.
The report describes the massive crowd and arrangements for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, noting Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee. It details a pre-fight dispute when Fitzsimmons' camp objected to Earp over rumors of bias, which Earp publicly denied.
The Guthrie Daily Leader · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
WINS ON AN ALLEGED FOUL
chairs.
One unique feature was the fact that for the first time in the history of pugilism, the management of the club threw open the doors to women and several hundred women were it attendance.
See moreSee less
One hundred police and as many more special officers were in attendance and a hundred ushers, all in evening dress, escorted the spectators to their seats.
One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to height, the New Zealander being five feet eleven and three-quarters inches and Sharkey five feet eight and one-quarter inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds.
The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Stelzner.
For Sharkey, George Allen, Austra[lian Billy Smith and Danny Needham]
In San Francisco, Wyatt Earp was disarmed by Police Officer Wittman of a large pistol when he appeared as referee in a boxing match. He was later arrested on a charge of carrying concealed weapons and released on $40 bail.
Daily Capital Journal · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
is composed of J. J. Groom and John Gibbs, two local men
Arrested
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 4.—When Wyatt Earp appeared in the ring last night to act as referee, he was disarmed by Police Wittman, who took from the Arizona man a large sized pistol. Tonight Earp was arrested on a charge of carrying concealed weapons, He was released on $40 bail.
A delegation of six reputable physicians examined Sharkey tonight and made the following report: "We find an oedema or swelling on the left side of the groin extending partially to the left. Also two small ecchymotic spots or discolorations about one-half way down the right side."
Dr. Lee, the man called in to attend Sharkey last night, in spite of the fact that other physicians offered their services, is not recognized by the regular medical fraternity of this city. It is stated by prominent physicians that the injuries exhibited by Sharkey could have been caused by a blow on the naval.
Bob Fitzsimmons angrily denounces referee Wyatt Earp's decision awarding the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim, insisting his knockout punch was a legal body blow. Doctors who examined Sharkey the next morning found facial injuries but no damage below the belt consistent with Earp's foul ruling.
The Scranton Tribune · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ECHOES OF THAT BIG PRIZE FIGHT
No Ill Effects From the Fight.
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Fitzsimmons was around the Baldwin hotel at an early hour this morning, showing not the faintest trace of his encounter with Sharkey last night. He is most bitter in his denunciation of the "sailors" foul tactics, Referee Earp and the management of the fight. He says he was robbed of the decision and that it was a preconcerted scheme to give the battle to his opponent. The blow which laid Sharkey low, the Australian declared, was a right hand hook on the stomach. This landed fairly and not below the belt as maintained by the referee. Fitzsimmons is anxious to meet Sharkey again and will fight him any time and place the latter may name. Those in attendance upon Sharkey say that he suffered terribly all night, requiring the constant services of two physicians up to four o'clock, when he fell asleep.
See moreSee less
Three of the most reputable citizens in this city, Doctors B. B. Lee, D. F.
Referee Wyatt Earp telegraphs a defense of his controversial decision, insisting he clearly saw Fitzsimmons land a foul low blow on Sharkey and that his judgment was honest. A rival sporting editor's conflicting account is also included, describing confusion among witnesses over whether the blow was foul or intentional.
The Scranton Tribune · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EARP'S DEFENSE
graphed the Journal as follows: "If Fitzsimmons struck Sharkey a foul blow last night I did not see it. But even at that I would scarcely like to go on record as saying that the punch on which the fight was given to the sailor was no foul, as Fitz had his back to me." "I saw a whizzing left hook go up from Fitzsimmons' hip. It caught Sharkey on the chin or mouth and the sailor began to sink. Then I saw Fitzsimmons' right elbow come back and he delivered a body punch.
See moreSee less
I should imagine it took effect somewhere about Sharkey's stomach or short ribs, on the left side. Anyhow, in a moment Sharkey was on the floor on his back. He was not knocked out. He was making grimaces and placing his hand on his groin, and if he were not in agony all I can say is that he must be a consummate actor and must have acted that particular scene many a time. Afterward I heard a dozen citizens of excellent reputation say they saw the foul plainly. Some of them said the blow was accidental and others thought from the manner of its delivery that it was intentional. This is something I cannot understand. In the fifth round, when Fitz sent Sharkey down under the ropes, the Cornishman put out his hand and helped the sailor to his feet. He complained to the referee and chided Sharkey every time the sailor struck foul in his clinches. Why on earth should he alter his tactics and fight foul, the more especially as he was over the worst part of the journey and had his opportunity?"
Wyatt Earp, acting as referee, defends his controversial decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, denying any foul play and expressing only regret at not stepping down when challenged. Fitzsimmons counters that he can prove the National Club conspired with Sharkey and Lynch to rig the outcome.
The Providence News · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
IT WAS A DEAL.
SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., Dec. 4.—Wyatt Earp, the most talked of man of the hour, takes a philosophical view of the criticisms that are being heaped upon him for his decision Wednesday and says he will wait with the public.
"If I had any fears that I erred in my decision they would have disappeared when I saw Sharkey today," said he last
Physicians and witnesses examined Sharkey's injuries, with doctors concluding a foul blow occurred while some prominent men believed Fitzsimmons should have won. An injunction blocked payment of the purse while Earp, who had officiated the fight, accompanied the fight promoter to the bank where the check was refused pending investigation of a possible conspiracy.
The Providence News · 4 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
A number of physicians and newspaper men were present in Sharkey's room yesterday afternoon when an examination of his injuries were made. All said they were convinced that Sharkey's condition was the result of a foul blow. Many prominent men, however, condemn the decision and refuse to believe that there was any fouling. Such men as Police Commissioners Gunst, Riley Grannan, Major Frank McLaughlin, who was chairman of the Re
After Wyatt Earp refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and awarded victory to Sharkey via certified check, witnesses confirmed a foul blow was struck but debated whether it was accidental. Doctors examined Sharkey and found him seriously but not dangerously injured, ordering him to bed rest.
San Antonio Daily Light · 4 December 1896 · page 3
FITZ'S FOUL
Believe it Was Accidental. San Francisco, Dee. 3.—A certified check for the amount of the purs was given Sharkey by Referee Earp after the tight last night. Some of Fitzsimmons’ backers talk of enjoin ing the bank from paying the check but it is not lielieved such action, if taken would cause the bank to with hold the payment to Sharkey. It is claimed that as the check was certi fied, the bank hns no option but to pay its holder. It is also claimed that the decision of the referee is final and not susceptible to an apiaml to the courts.
See moreSee less
Physicians and newspaper men. who participated in or witness ed tiie examination of Sharkey after he was carried from the riug. say he was visibly wounded below the belt. Doctors say his condition is serious but not dangerous and have ordered him to remain in bed at least two or three days, stating that exercise or any movement might aggravate his injuries. Sharkey, when seen in bed at his hotel this morning, was resting easily, though suffering some pain and inconvenience. Witnesses to the tight declare this morning that the foul blow was undoubtedly delivered, but many believe it accidental.
A doctor examines Sharkey and finds a serious groin injury consistent with a foul blow, while Sharkey gives his own account of being hit illegally during the fight. Fitzsimmons furiously denies fouling Sharkey, denounces referee Wyatt Earp's decision as robbery, and stages a theater appearance to proclaim his innocence.
The Salt Lake Herald · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
THE DECISIVE BLOW
New York, Dec. 3. Tom Sharkey, San Francisco: I am sorry for Mr. Fitzsimmons' foul tactics, which prevented you from beating him in ten rounds without a foul. I am ready to meet you on or before Janu
Fitzsimmons claims referee Wyatt Earp rigged the fight and Sharkey fouled him repeatedly; a bank refuses to pay Sharkey's $10,000 prize pending legal review. Earp is arrested for carrying a concealed weapon in the ring, and Fitzsimmons sues to block payment, alleging conspiracy, with a judge granting an injunction.
The Roanoke Daily Times · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
The Bank Officials Decline to Pay Sharkey the Prize Money.
San Francisco, Dec. 3.--The Anglo-Californian Bank, on which the prize fight check for $10,000 was drawn by the National Club, has refused payment. The check was presented by Lynch, Sharkey's backer.
See moreSee less
The bank officials told Lynch that they must decline to pay the check until the courts decided that Sharkey was entitled to the money. The bank officials say they are acting on legal advice.
Doctors dispute whether Sharkey's injuries could have been caused by a low blow, with one attending physician unrecognized by local medical professionals. Fitzsimmons has filed suit to block payment of the $10,000 purse awarded to Sharkey by referee Wyatt Earp, alleging conspiracy between Sharkey, the Athletic Club, and others.
The Roanoke Daily Times · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ BRINGS SUIT. Fitzsimmons, through his attorney, has commenced suit in the superior court to restrain the Anglo-Californian Bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse, awarded the sailor by Referee Earp. Fitzsimmons charges conspiracy between Sharkey, the National Athletic Club and others. Judge Sanderson granted the injunc-
After referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim, numerous boxing experts and witnesses at ringside say they saw no foul and that Fitzsimmons clearly dominated the bout. Fitzsimmons' manager plans to seek a court injunction to stop the bank from paying Sharkey the stakes, with most sports figures agreeing Fitz was cheated.
The Times · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TO FIGHT IN THE COURTS
to be found. Jack McAuliffe, Jimmy Carroll, Johnny Herget (Young Mitchell), Lon Agnew, Eddie Greaney, and scores of others, declare that the decision of Referee Wyatt Earp was a plain case of robbery. Major Frank McLaughlin,
Fitzsimmons dominated the fight against Sharkey but was disqualified by referee Wyatt Earp on a foul claim, sparking heated debate among ringside experts. Witnesses like Major McLaughlin insisted the knockout punch was clean, while Earp's selection as referee came after a day of wrangling between the fighters' camps.
Richmond Dispatch · 4 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SAILOR OUT-GENERALED
railed, outpunched, and outwinded his antagonist. Experts in pugilism swarmed around the ringside, but the boxer who saw Fitzsimmons strike a foul blow is not to be found. Jack McAuliffe, Jimmy Carroll, Johnny Herget (Young Mitchell), Len Agnew, Eddie Greaney, and scores of others declare that the decision of Referee Wyatt Earp was a plain case of robbery. Major Frank McLaughlin, chairman of the Republican State Central Committee, who was probably in a better position to see the alleged foul than anybody else, says that the knockout was as clean an upper-cut as he ever saw.
Earp's selection as referee came about in a peculiar way. For many days Martin Julian had urged Danny Lynch, Sharkey's manager, to name a satisfactory man, but Lynch invariably refused to do so, claiming that there was plenty of time. Yesterday morning the managers wrangled over the question for hours. Julian named man after man, but Lynch was obdurate, and when the noon hour arrived, President Groom, of the National Club, was called on to make a selection. He fixed on Wyatt Earp, and Julian agreed to accept him, rather than leave Fitzsimmons open to the charge of cowardice. Julian took the short end of the stick.
The report describes the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons prize fight in San Francisco, where Sharkey was declared winner after Fitzsimmons was ruled to have fouled him. Wyatt Earp served as referee, and Fitzsimmons' supporters disputed the decision despite his authority in sporting circles.
Washington Standard · 4 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
A PRIZE-FIGHT THAT DECIDED NOTHING.—The daily papers are filled with the details of the prize-fight between Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons, which took place in the Mechanics' Pavilion, San Francisco, Wednesday night. The fight lasted eight rounds in which Tom Sharkey was terribly punished, but declared the victor on account of a foul by his opponent, who it seems struck him in the groin with his knee while falling. It is said that 20,000 people were excited spectators of the mill, and among them, for the first time in the history of pugilism, several hundred women, some of them grey-haired matrons, witnessed the brutal proceeding.
See moreSee less
Nothing has been settled by the fight, as Fitz's friends claim that he was the victor, notwithstanding the decision of the referee, Wyatt Earp, who is considered an authority in sporting circles.
Days after Wyatt Earp controversially stopped the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight on a foul claim, San Francisco physicians disagree on whether Sharkey actually suffered a low blow, with some suggesting he was secretly 'doped' with iodine to fake injury. The purse remains unpaid amid threats of legal action.
Birmingham State Herald · 5 December 1896 · page 2
WAS A CASE OF DOPE
Coveted Check by the Cashier. San Francisco, Cal., Dec. i.—The Fitz simmr ns-Sharkey fight is being fought over and over again on every street cor ner of this city today. Professional men, merchants, horsemen, millionaires and men in every vocation of life, save churchmen, may be seen illustrating just how the Australian put the sailor to sleep. Sharkey is resting easily today, and will be on the streets within a week. Dr. Tausig, physician of the National club, does not hesitate to asert that, in his opinion. Sharkey did not receive any such blow as his backers claim Fitzsim mons administered.
See moreSee less
Another leading physician, who inspected the sailor, is of tile opinion that Sharkey was “doped" with iodine to bear out Earp’s claim of foul. Of all the physicians who examined Sharkey hut two are Inclined to believe that lie was struck foul. One of the two is the mysterious “Doctor" Lee, whom nobody seems to know, and the other is a friend of Danny Lynch. A half dozen reputable physicians were at the door of Sharkey's dressing room when the sailor was brought in at the conclusion of the fight, yet none were permitted to inspect him until "Dr." Lee had concluded his examination an hour later. The purse money has not yet been paid, and from present indications there will be a legal battle which will eclipse the ring encounter. Such men ns Adolph Spreck les. Maj. McLaughlin, Mose Gunst, Wil liam Greer, Harrison and Hiram Cook are behind Fitzslmomns and Julian, while Sharkey's supoprters are few. To add to Fitzsimmons’ troubles suit was instituted against him today by J. J. Raur, on a claim for $905 held in judgment by Jimmy Carroll, tile light weight. Carroll was one of Fitzsim mons' trainers for his fight with Maher near El Paso. His bill for services was not paid and though he put his claim In judgment ho never succeeded in col lecting the money. This will be heard tomorrow.
Following the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, referee Wyatt Earp was arrested for carrying a concealed weapon and sought a court continuance, while Fitzsimmons alleged a conspiracy to defraud him. Former police colleagues from Wichita vouched for Earp's honesty, saying he would have ruled fairly even facing an armed crowd.
Arizona Republican · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP IS GAME.
Would Have Decided Honestly "in the Face of an Arsenal."
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 4.—Tom Sharkey is still confined to his bed, but his physicians say he is doing nicely and that he will be up in a few days no worse for the blow which secured him $10,000 Wednesday night. Fitzsimmons is cheerful and says he will get the purse yet, but Lynch, Sharkey's backer, ridicules Fitzsimmons' expectations. Nearly all bets have been paid. Referee Wyatt Earp, who was disarmed of a big Colt's revolver at the ringside and was arrested last night, charged with carrying concealed weapons, was in the police court today. Earp asked and obtained a continuance till Tuesday.
Fitzsimmons says he has evidence to prove a conspiracy between Earp, Sharkey and the club managers to defraud him, but Earp still stands pat on the foul proposition.
A citizen inquires whether Wyatt Earp had been attacked over his refereeing decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight in San Francisco. Local sporting opinion held that the decision unfairly favored Sharkey.
Arizona Republican · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
in the department of the Colorado: Acting Hospital Steward William C. Livingston, from Whipple Barracks, Arizona, to Fort Logan, Colo.; Acting Hospital Steward Ludwig Shoenfeldt, from Fort Logan, Colo., to Fort Douglas, Utah.
Miss Lena Clanton, the 14-year-old daughter of T. M. Clanton of Buckeye, died Thursday night of heart trouble.
Wyatt Earp expressed strong indignation over public criticism of his referee decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match. He insisted his ruling was fair and honest, maintaining that Fitzsimmons' foul was clearly intentional.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP Is Very Indignant Over the Comments on His Decision.
NEW YORK, Dec. 3.—James J. Corbett telegraphed Sharkey the following: "Tom Sharkey, San Francisco, Calif. Am very sorry at Mr. Fitzsimmons foul tactics in his contest with you, which prevented your getting a decision over
The San Francisco dispatch reports Wyatt Earp selected as referee for the heavily-bet Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, with odds favoring Fitzsimmons. The report then gives live round-by-round action as the fight gets underway at the National Club.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
NEW YORK, Dec. 3.—Eliza C. Cummins about 35 years old, said to be a wealthy widow of Hillsboro, Ohio, committed suicide here today by jumping from a fifth story window of the Empire Hotel.
PAVILION, SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 2—The town is fighting mad tonight. The local pool rooms are crowded and money is pouring in on both fighters. The talent generally seems to be backing Fitzsimmons but there is a lot of Sharkey money going in the box. The betting at this hour (8 o'clock) is two to one on the result with Sharkey on the short end. On the number of rounds Sharkey men are laying 5 to 4 that the sailor will be on his feet at the end of the sixth round. A referee was selected by the National Club at noon today. He will be Wyatt Earp the well-known sporting man. The men are expected to be in the ring about 10 o'clock.
See moreSee less
Jed Gibbs is conferring with the principals and seconds, presumably on the confirmation or rejection of the referee. At 10:14 Sharkey shook his covering and is introduced by the master of ceremonies Jordan as "the Pride of the Navy and Champion of the Pacific Coast." Then Fitzsimmons is taken by the arm and announced as "the Champion of the World." Fitz did not strip. Sharkey looks rosy and somewhat finer drawn than when he fought Corbett. Another resting spell with the attaches resting on the ropes.
Time is called at 10:40 p. m.—Fitz lays both hands on Sharkey's shoulder and does a little talking. The clock now refuses to make a noise and the men sit down again while Jordan asks for the electrician.
Time called 10:42—Round 1—Fitz feints the left and the sailor dances back, neither makes a lead for a moment; then Fitz swings his right but the sailor is inside of it. Sharkey feints and rushes in with a good straight left. Sharkey spars at a long range; then lands right on Fitz's shoulder. Fitz is laying back for a favorable opening. He tries again a right cross but misses as he did at first. Sharkey punches him stiff in the belly. Fitz swings the right cross again; misses. Fitz short uppercuts the Sailor pretty heavily with a left. They mix and Sharkey rushes in. Fitz knocks Sharkey down with a back-handed left and is after him like the wind. He half-hooked him again with a left and Sharkey goes to his corner somewhat the worse for wear.
Round 2.—More long range sparring; then Fitz lands a half round left on the sailor's head. Sharkey is very active on his feet. Fitz swings very hard right and left but falls short and Sharkey lands a sounding blow on his chest. Fitz forcing it. Tom stopped him with a left on the body. Fitz drives vicious rights and lefts at Sharkey's head but the sailor is going back and they do no effective work. It is hard for the sailor to reach the lanky one's head and he retreats most of the time. When he gets close he has decidedly the better of the mix. At the ring of the gong Fitz lands his left and right swings in good shape on Sharkey's head.
Round 3.—Fitz come over three quarters of the way and after feinting tries the left at the head. Sharkey ducked and caught him around the legs again the same tactics; then Fitz waits a minute and hooks Sharkey again with a left. Sharkey is forcing it now. They come together and hard rights are exchanged. Fitz does some ducking and the sailor stops him with a stiff jolt on the jaw and is fighting the long boy hard. He almost has him stopped apparently. Sharkey lands hard on the mark and then Bob sends in a vicious left on the sailor's body. Sharkey is fighting Bob's wind and has much the better of this round.
Round 4.—Sharkey is after Bob and knocks him full length with a left half round punch. Bob is doing considerable clearing now and then. The navy yard contingent are howling themselves hoarse. Sharkey lands his left on the wind and is countered with a right cross. Bob is getting worried and Sharkey rushes him to his corner. Bob's counters are showing a lack of steam. Sharkey lands three times on Fitz wind. Fitz is trying to get in a right swing but can't find the sailor off his guard. The sailor is like a tiger on his feet and Bob shows signs of the fast battle.
Round 5.—Bob is forcing the fight and lands a stiff left upper-cut on the sailor's jaw. Sharkey tries to throw Fitz and Bob lifts his knee in return. Bob is trying for his right. Bob lands hard on the sailor's jaw. Sharkey is hitting low and the crowd hisses. He lands his left straight and hard on Fitz's jaw. Bob returns with another hard
After referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the fight on a foul in the eighth round against Fitzsimmons, he handed Sharkey's backer a certified check for $10,000. Fitzsimmons' lawyers moved to block payment, and when the backer presented the check the next morning, the bank refused to honor it pending a legal ruling.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Will not get the $10,000 Purse, Except Through The Courts. SAN FRANCISCO, Cal. Dec. 3—Although Sharkey was awarded the decision after the eigthth round in last night's battle with Fitzsimmons, the referee declaring that Fitzsimmons had struck a foul blow, the sailor may not get the $10,000 purse after all. At any rate he will have to make a legal fight for it which may prove a harder struggle than he had last night. When Referee Wyatt Earp last night decided that Fitzsimmons had struck Sharkey a blow below the belt and that Sharkey was the victor on a foul he handed Lynch who is Sharkey's backer and manager a certified check on the Anglo-California Bank for $10,000.
See moreSee less
Fitzsimmons promptly protested and consulted an attorney who decided to enjoin the bank from paying the money until the courts could pass on Sharkey's right to the purse. This morning soon after the bank opened Lynch presented the certified check and demanded payment. To his surprise the bank official refused to honor the check.
After Bob Fitzsimmons knocked out Sailor Sharkey in the 8th round, referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul call. The decision stunned onlookers since no one present had witnessed any foul committed.
Mohave County Miner · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Tom Platt must be getting savage. He says that the appointment of Whitelaw Reid to a cabinet position would mean "taking the lid off of hell." Now, it wouldn't be so bad a thing as Boss Platt might think. The vent thus opened up might thaw out the country around New York City.
After lanky Bob Fitzsimmons had knocked Sailor Sharkey cold in the 8th round last Wednesday night the referee, Wyatt Earp, gave the fight to Sharkey on a foul. The decision was a surprise to everybody, as no one had seen the foul.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, had his concealed weapon charge case called in San Francisco police court. At his attorney's request, the proceeding was postponed until the following Tuesday.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey Can't Get the $10,000 Just Yet— Referee Earp's Case.
San Francisco, Dec. 4.—Danny Lynch, manager of Sailor Sharkey, walked into the Anglo-Californian bank this forenoon and demanded payment on the $10,000 check. He was referred to Manager Lilienthal, who said the check would not be paid owing to an injunction. Lynch met this with angry words and said that if the bank refused to hand over the money he would bring suit and ask for heavy damages. Lilienthal told him to go ahead with his suit. Lynch thereupon left.
See moreSee less
The case of Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and who was arrested last night on a charge of carrying a concealed weapon, was called up in the police court this morning, but at the request of Earp's attorney the case was continued until Tuesday next.
Weeks after the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, lawsuits and accusations of a fix are multiplying, with Martin Julian alleging a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons. The report reveals how Wyatt Earp, bodyguard to an Examiner editor, came to be named referee, fueling suspicion of club management complicity.
The San Francisco Call · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
the machinery of the law.
Meanwhile the talk on the referee's decision is still going on, with Wyatt Earp, the Examiner's special writer, as the target of any amount of forcible criticism. Statements that the fight was fixed and that Sharkey could not lose under any circumstances are freely made.
See moreSee less
Those who got even money on Fitzsimmons just before the fight are wondering why on earth they did not scent a rodent and are recalling the many other suspicious incidents that should have placed them on their guard. As the non-committal report of the doctors who examined Sharkey is talked over the thinking sports are more and more convinced that the injuries to Sharkey were made in his room after being taken away from the pavilion.
Martin Julian's statement that one of those connected with the club management was concerned in a conspiracy to rob Fitzsimmons of his well-earned victory is also receiving much comment, and the hope is freely expressed that the matter will be thoroughly sifted in court, and that if a wholesale job was perpetrated the guilty ones to a man will be exposed and driven from the ranks of square sports.
The lovers of boxing cannot get over the fact that when Julian publicly charged that Earp was fixed in Sharkey's interest Messrs. Gibbs and Groom, who appointed Earp and had a perfect right to withdraw him, said not a word, and allowed a man on whom suspicion rested to referee the match.
While not taken as direct evidence that the management was concerned in any job, the matter has created no end of talk, and it will take much to clear these men from the suspicion that has been cast on them.
Danny Needham's telegrams to Seattle friends telling them to bet their last dollar on Sharkey are taken as evidence that the astute lightweight knew that something was sure about the fight—and that was Sharkey's winning.
The National Athletic Club's J.J. Groom recounts how Andy Lawrence recommended Wyatt Earp as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, assuring Gibbs that Earp would be fair and uncontroversial. The passage also describes a later meeting where Fitzsimmons challenged Earp's account of the foul blow using a bellboy demonstration, leaving Earp confused and backing down.
The San Francisco Call · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
NAMED BY LAWRENCE.
Case Was Continued. called for Gibbs to come and see him. Gibbs went to his office as we had some tickets to deliver there, and he and Lawrence entered into quite a conversation. "Lawrence told Gibbs that he understood the fighters were disagreeing as to the selection of a referee. Gibbs stated he believed that to be about right, and added that it made no difference if the principals did not agree, that it was understood that in the case of a disagreement the club would select the referee. "Lawrence said that was right, but the club must select a man who would be perfectly fair and fearless.
See moreSee less
He then said: "'I've got your man. Select Wyatt Earp. I know he's as good a man as you can get, and there will be no kicking against him.' "Gibbs at the time only had a general knowledge of who Earp was, having met him casually on one occasion, but when Lawrence named him as referee he agreed that he would select him for the club if the fighters did not settle upon another choice. "That is a true statement of how we decided upon Wyatt Earp as referee." The close connection between Earp, Lawrence and the referee matter is shown by an incident that occurred the day after the fight. Lawrence, accompanied, as usual, by Earp, called on Fitzsimmons at the Baldwin. Fitz was courteous to his visitors, and, in the course of a conversation, asked Earp to describe the blow which the latter claimed was foul. The referee did so, and Bob, after thinking a moment, said: "Let us illustrate t[h]is matter." He rang up a bellboy, who happened to be about Sharkey's height, and said: "Now, Mr. Earp, just place this boy in the position Sharkey was in when he got the punch." Earp did so and Bob then said, "Place me as I was at that time." When this had been accomplished to Earp's satisfaction Bob remarked: "Now, Mr. Earp, don't you see that as we are now placed I could not have struck Sharkey as you describe?" Earp studied the situation a moment, looked confused, and finally said: "Well, I guess the positions must have been different." Bob looked at the referee, whose eyes were averted, for a moment and then said, "Yes, I think so." The visitors took their departure very soon afterward.
Wyatt Earp, referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, appeared in Police Court on a charge of carrying a concealed weapon. His examination was continued until Tuesday.
The San Francisco Call · 5 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Arthur Jackson acted in self-defense when he killed August Florentine.
The steamer Progressist, that sails for Calcutta to-day, has on board 5200 tons of cargo. The captain wanted to carry 1500 tons more but the surveyors objected.
See moreSee less
Alex Pentages and Sam Brown, charged with having unstamped opium in their possession, will be tried before United States Commissioner Heacock next Friday.
Captain J. Wilson of the fast launch Amy is a very sick man. He caught a severe cold at the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and is now threatened with pneumonia.
A. R. Dundar, who swindled several wealthy men in the name of the Press Club, was locked up in the City Prison yesterday on the charge of obtaining money by false pretenses.
The proceedings against the Bellingham Bay and British Columbia Railroad Company were dismissed yesterday, that corporation having filed its annual report as ordered.
Joseph Dornato, a teamster, was arrested at Taylor and Turk streets yesterday for cruelly beating his horse. Every blow raised a welt on the animal and Dornato came near being mobbed.
Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, was in the Police Court yesterday charged with carrying a concealed weapon. His examination was continued until Tuesday.
R. C. Goodspeed will not be allowed to draw $250 a month from the estate of his wife for the support of their minor children. Judge Coffey will allow only $50, the father to contribute an equal amount.
British ships are playing in hard luck. Since July fifty-six of them have come here "on speculation," and there are still twenty-one disengaged, while many of the others went away at exceedingly low rates.
The Watsonville Water and Light Company has been incorporated with capital stock fixed at $500,000. The incorporators are: Francis Smith, W. W. Montague, F. W. G. Moebus, F. W. Lougee and Daniel Wilson.
A $10,000 certificate of deposit tied to the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight is frozen by a court injunction, leaving the Anglo-Californian Bank liable to suits from both sides. Meanwhile, referee Wyatt Earp appears in court on a concealed weapons charge from the night of the fight and defends his controversial decision awarding the bout to Fitzsimmons.
New York Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
WILL BE SUED BY BOTH SIDES.
Why Earp Has a Gun. Referee Wyatt Earp is as unconcerned as ever. The first thing he did to-day was to go to the City Hall to answer to a charge of carrying concealed weapons. He asked for a continuance of the case. "I do not pretend that I did not have a gun," he said, "but I suppose it was fool-
Attorney Kowalski announces plans to bring the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight decision before a grand jury, alleging that referee Wyatt Earp's appointment guaranteed a predetermined outcome. He accuses Sharkey, his manager Lynch, and others of conspiring to defraud both Fitzsimmons and the betting public.
The Evening Times · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
CRIMINAL CHARGES MADE. Fitzsimmons to Take the Earp Decision Before a Grand Jury. San Francisco, Dec. 5.-There is still a good deal of excitement here over the big fight, and the cries of fraud in connection
Robert Fitzsimmons filed suit in San Francisco superior court to obtain the $10,000 purse awarded to Tom Sharkey by Referee Wyatt Earp. The bank had refused to cash the certified check when presented by Earp and Sharkey's manager.
The Gazette · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
product of reprehensible machinations. Cardinal Rampolla. A Catholic churchman, well versed with all the steps leading up to Bishop Keane's removal, said last night that the action of the pope in sending the above cablegram should put a stop to all further gossip on the subject. Sharkey Must Wait for the Coin.
San Francisco bookmakers have begun paying out bets on the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, treating referee Wyatt Earp's decision as final despite ongoing claims of fraud. A court injunction still blocks Sharkey's manager from collecting a disputed certificate of deposit, while rumors of a Sharkey-Fitzsimmons compromise are denied.
Evening Star · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FIGHT TALK SUBSIDING.
Wednesday.
Dan Lynch, the manager of the sailor, has made another attempt to obtain the money from the Anglo-California Bank on the certificate of deposit, but the officials declined to pay the money. They explained that the superior court had issued an injunction against payment, and that no money will be paid until the restraining order is dissolved.
See moreSee less
A story that Sharkey is willing to compromise with Fitzsimmons has gained currency, although it has no foundation in fact.
Local bookmakers are now paying bets on the fight. They have accepted the decision of Earp as final, and are giving the winners what is due them. This has had a marked effect in silencing the storm of
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · and 1 other paper
After the National Athletic Club stopped payment on the $10,000 purse check, physicians were consulted and most concluded Sharkey's injury came from a blow in the fight, prompting club managers to authorize payment—only for a judge's restraining order and Fitzsimmons's fraud lawsuit against Sharkey, Earp, and the club to block the bank from releasing funds. Separately, referee Wyatt Earp was arrested for carrying a concealed weapon, the pistol he had surrendered to police captain Wittman during the fight, with his case continued in court.
New-York Tribune · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
were not for a restraining order issued by Superior Judge Sanderson upon the bank. Fitzsimmons asked the Superior Court to take the check for $10,000 into its possession until a decision can be reached on the merits of the case. In his complaint Fitzsimmons alleges on information and belief that Sharkey, Earp and the National Athletic Club conspired to defraud him out of a rightful decision.
Meantime the Anglo-California Bank is placed in an extremely awkward position. It has issued a certificate of deposit for $10,000, payable to bearer. The bank is in the peculiar position of having refused to pay and of being enjoined from paying a certificate that it pledged its commercial standing would be honored on sight.
See moreSee less
Wyatt Earp, the referee, will have to defend himself in the police courts against the charge of carrying a concealed weapon. The weapon was delivered by Earp to Captain Wittman at the latter's request just after the beginning of the fight, and it has since been in Wittman's keeping. Last evening Earp was arrested and released on furnishing $50 bail. To-day, in court, his case was continued until Tuesday next.
The Evening Times · Washington, D.C. · 4 December 1896
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
Physicians dispute whether Sharkey was truly struck foul, with suspicions he was 'doped' to support the claim, while the $10,000 purse remains frozen amid legal threats. Referee Wyatt Earp was arrested for carrying a concealed weapon at ringside, with his court case postponed until the following Tuesday.
The Morning News · 5 December 1896 · page 1
UNDER SUSPICION
Over to Sharkey While the In junction Is Pending?. San Francisco. Cal., Dec. 4.—The FltzSharkey fight is being fought over and over again on every street corner o£ San Francisco to-day. Professional men, merchants, horsemen, millionaires and men in every vocation of life, save# churchmen, may be seen Ulus tr;l tlng Just how the Australian put the railor to sleep. Sharkey is resting easily to-day, and tvi.l he on the street within a week. Dr. Tausig, physician of the National Ath letic Club and a doctor of unquestionable reputation, does not hesitate to assert that in his opinion Sharkgy did not receive any such blow as his backers claim Fits administered.
See moreSee less
Another leading physi cian who inspected the sailor, is of the opinion that Sharkey was "doped” with iodine to bear Earp's claim of foul. Of all the physicians who examined Sharkey, but two are inclined to believe that he was struck foul. One of the two is the mysterious Dr.Lee.whom nobody seems to know, and the other is a friend of Dan ny Lynch. A half dozen reputable physi cians were at tne door of Sharkey’s dress ing room when the sailor was brought in at the conclusion of the fight, yet none were permitted to inspect him until "Dr.” Lee had concluded his examination an hour later. The purse money has not yet been paid and from present indications there will be a legal battle which will eclipse the ring encounter. 'Such men as Adolph Spreck els. M'aJ. McLaughlin. Mose Gunst, Will iam Greer Harrison and Hiram Cook are behind Fitzsimmons and Julian, while Sharkey's supporters are few and incon sequential. To add to Fitzsimmons’ troubles suit was instituted against him to-day by J. J. Raur. on a claim for $906 held in judgment by Jimmy Carroll, the light-weight. Carroll was one of Fitz’s trainers for his fight with Maher near El Paso. His bill for ser vices was not paid, and though he put his claim in judgment, he never succeeded in collecting the money. This will be heard to-morrow. Danny Lynch, manager of Sailor Sharkey. walked Into the Anglo raiifornia Bank shortly after It ofr ned this morning and demanded pay ment on the SIO,OOO check. He was re ferred to Manager Lilieotlial, who said that the check could not be paid owing to an injunction. Lynch met this with angry words, and said that If the bank refused to hand over the money he would immediately bring suit and ask for heavy damages. Lllienthal told him that he could do nothing in the matter, and to go ahead with his suit. Lynch thereupon turned on his hrel and left the place. Wyatt Karp, who refereed the Fitzsim mons-Sharkey fight, was compelled to hand over to Police Captain Wittman, at the ring side, a weapon which he carried concealed. For this a charge was made against him, and he was arrested last night, ilis case was called in the police court this morning, but at the request of Karp's attorney, was continued until Tues day next.
A San Francisco dispatch describes the heavyweight bout between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, which drew a huge crowd to the Mechanics' Pavilion. Referee Wyatt Earp declared Fitzsimmons had fouled Sharkey after eight rounds and awarded the fight to the young sailor.
The Coeur D'alene Press · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
WON BY SHARKEY ON A FOUL. REFEREE WYATT EARP GAVE THE FIGHT TO THIS SAILOR.
Mechanics Pavillion, San Francisco, Dec. 2.—No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted public attention here as did the battle between the heavyweights, Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey tonight. Between 15,000 and 20,000 people occupied all the available space in the big Mechanics pavillion and watched the contest, which every one regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world. The long, lean New Zealander who has had a succession of victories in the United States in the last five years entered the ring tonight with almost every apparent advantage in his favor.
See moreSee less
He could count upon his experience and science; his height and reach, and every other quality which enters into the making of the successful prize fighter. Against him was the sailor lad who was unknown 6 months ago, but who rose to fame recently when he came perilously near trailing in the dust the colors of California's idol—James J. Corbett. Against the science and experience and the superior height
The report describes the crowd, preliminary bouts, and the start of the main event between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, noting Wyatt Earp as referee. It details the fighters' measurements, seconds, and the enthusiastic reception as both men entered the ring.
The Coeur D'alene Press · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Several preliminary events preceded the chief contest, and it was late when Fitzsimmons and Sharkey appeared in the ring. One of the most noticeable differences in the men was in regard to the height, the New Zealander being 5 feet 11¾ inches and Sharkey 5 feet 8½ inches. Each of the men weighed about 175 pounds. The seconds for Fitzsimmons were Martin Julian, Dan Hickey and Jack Steizner. For Sharkey, George Allen, "Australian" Billy Smith and Danny Needham.
Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona stage driver, who has figured in many a gun fight on the border, was chosen referee.
See moreSee less
It was 9 o'clock before the great crowd began to make an impression on the vast amount of vacant seats. Outside of the pavilion stood a crowd estimated at 10,000 which commenced to assemble as early as 6 o'clock. It is estimated that the National club took in at least $48,000 at the box office.
Before three-quarters of the seats were filled the preliminaries were called, and a number of local celebrities exhibited their prowess.
Harry Stafford of New Orleans and Jack Howard of San Francisco came up for a three round go.
Lon Agnew of Chicago and Fred Miller of San Francisco, light-weights, in a 10-round contest, were the next attraction.
It was a rattling good fight from the call of time. Miller made a good showing until the fifth round, when Agnew knocked him down several times. The call of time saved him, but he lasted only about a half minute in the sixth, when a succession of smashes on the jaw put Miller out.
The report describes the main event of the evening, a boxing match between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey with Wyatt Earp serving as referee. It gives a chaotic round-by-round account of punches landed, including a disputed moment regarding the referee's conduct.
The Coeur D'alene Press · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
A Mix-Up From the Time the Gong Sounded.
It was 10 o'clock when the event of the evening was announced. The crowd cheered, and the cheer became a roar when the gladiators appeared. Fitzsimmons showed up fresh, and received an ovation.
See moreSee less
Sharkey wore a green sash, with red, white and blue trimmings. His right hand was bandaged. Fitzsimmons was introduced as the champion of the world, which received a howl of approval.
Sharkey appeared two minutes after Fitzsimmons, and his welcome was equally as warm. Fitzsimmons chatted with friends at the ring side as if a hard fight were not on his hands. When Sharkey entered the ring Bob walked across the ring and shook hands cordially with the sailor and his seconds.
Both men were enveloped in long bath robes, which they threw off before putting on the gloves. It was then the disparity in the build of the two men was plainly seen. Fitzsimmons, lean and long and sinewy, looked like a panther, while Sharkey, stocky and sturdy, with his immense muscular development, resembled a grizzly bear.
There was a little delay before referee Wyatt Earp appeared. The announcer, Mr. Jordan, announced that owing to ru-
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper
Reports detail suspicions that Sharkey's injury was staged by his doctor to support a foul claim, while a legal and financial dispute unfolds over the $10,000 certificate of deposit. Referee Wyatt Earp defends his controversial decision, stating he believes Sharkey's blow was not foul and expressing regret only over not leaving the ring when challenged.
The Indianapolis Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
CAUSED BY A FOUL BLOW.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 4.—Thomas Sharkey, who was knocked out by Fitzsimmons Wednesday night, is still in bed, watched over by three physicians. They say he is improving, but that it will be at least a week before he recovers from the effects of the injury he says he received from Fitzsimmons in the eighth round. At least two of the physicians who have examined Sharkey since the fight do not believe his injury was received from Fitzsimmons or that it was caused by a blow at all, but the generally accepted belief now is that he was accidentally fouled by Fitzsimmons.
Friends of Fitzsimmons say that Sharkey submitted to an operation for the purpose of manufacturing the evidence necessary to back up the claim of foul. Certain it is that when Sharkey was taken to his room at the Windsor Hotel no one was allowed to even speak to [hi]m until "Dr." Lee had worked on him. When "Dr." Lee commenced his examination of Sharkey the portieres were closely drawn across the bedroom door and pinned so that no one could see in. A few minutes later, after some low talk was heard, Sharkey began to groan as if in pain. Many believe that the "injury" Sharkey received was given him at this time.
See moreSee less
D. J. Lynch, Sharkey's backer, made another attempt to have his certificate of deposit for $10,000 cashed by the Anglo-Californian Bank to-day. The bank manager told Lynch of the Superior Court injunction restraining the bank from cashing the certificate pending the effort of Fitzsimmons to "prove fraud and conspiracy," and declined to pay the money. Lynch threatened to bring suit against the bank and the manager for the amount of the certificate, and also for damages for refusal to cash it. Sharkey has ten days in which to answer the complaint filed by Fitzsimmons, and it is not expected that the legal fight will be hurried.
Fitzsimmons is taking matters quietly and is making engagements for his appearance at various places of entertainment in this city and vicinity, when he will give boxing exhibitions. The poolrooms and bookmakers decided to cash the bets to-day, and holders of wagers on Sharkey were made happy. A sensational story is being told in sporting circles concerning an alleged telegram sent East, it is said, by Danny Needham, advising the placing of large amounts on Sharkey, with an intimation that the tip was valuable.
Wyatt Earp, the referee, takes a philosophical view of the criticisms that are being heaped on him for his decision Wednesday night, and says he will wait for time to set him right with the public. "If I had any fears that I erred in my decision they would have disappeared when I saw Sharkey to-day," said he last night. "Sharkey did not strike a foul blow, to my mind. At the break he struck Fitzsimmons
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va. · 5 December 1896
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Amid controversy over Wyatt Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, this dispatch from Wichita recalls his earlier police career there in 1875 under chief Mike Meagher. Former colleague Dick Cogdell praises Earp as fearless and honest, also claiming he served successfully as marshal of Ellsworth, Kansas.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indianapolis Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
of the National club were in this deal with Lynch and Sharkey to rob us, and, what is more, we are going to prove it in court. Had it not been that I was saving my hands as much as possible, I would have put Sharkey out in the second round. His head is as hard as a bullet, and I must have landed on him there fully forty times. With my fight with Corbett in view, I did not think it worth while to punch my hands out of shape.
See moreSee less
In a rough-and-tumble scrap Sharkey might do a man some damage, as he is stocky and strong, but in a boxing contest or a ring battle no sane man would ever bet a dollar on him if there was a referee present who knew his business." Police Commissioner Gunst is satisfied that the fight was "jobbed." So disgusted is he with the general result that he has announced there will be no more prize fighting in San Francisco if his influence can prevent it.
Wyatt Earp, under heavy criticism for his referee decision favoring Sharkey over Fitzsimmons, defends himself saying Sharkey's blow was not a foul under Queensbury rules. Meanwhile legal disputes continue over Sharkey's backer's attempt to cash a disputed bet certificate, blocked by a court injunction as Fitzsimmons pursues fraud charges.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Fight—Other News of Sport.
San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 4.—Thomas Sharkey, who was knocked out by Fitzsimmons on Wednesday night, is still in bed, watched over by three physicians. They say he is improving but that it will be at least a week before he recovers from the effects of the injury he says he received from Fitzsimmons in the eighth round.
See moreSee less
At least two of the physicians who have examined Sharkey since the fight do not believe his injury was received from Fitzsimmons or that it was caused by a blow at all, but the generally accepted belief now is that he was accidentally fouled by Fitzsimmons.
D. J. Lynch, Sharkey's backer, made another attempt to have his certified check of deposit for $10,000 cashed by the Anglo-California bank today. The bank manager told Lynch of the superior court injunction restraining the bank from cashing the certificate, pending the efforts of Fitzsimmons to "prove fraud and conspiracy," and declined to pay the money. Lynch threatened to bring suit against the bank and the manager for the amount of the certificate and also for damages for refusal to cash it.
Sharkey has ten days in which to answer the complaint filed by Fitzsimmons and it is not expected that the legal contest will be hurried. Fitzsimmons is taking matters quietly and is making engagements for his appearance at various places of entertainment in this city and vicinity, where he will give boxing exhibitions. The pool rooms and bookmakers decided to cash the bets today and holders of wagers on Sharkey were made happy.
A sensational story is told in sporting circles concerning an alleged telegram sent east, it is said, by Danny Needham, advising the placing of large amouns on Sharkey, with an intimation that the tip was valuable.
A short satirical item notes that former Wichita resident Wyatt Earp is charged with carrying concealed weapons, joking that he also carries concealed friendship for boxer Tom Sharkey. The item is part of a column of political and sporting one-liners referencing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight controversy.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
That former Wichita man Wyatt Earp is charged with carrying concealed weapons in addition to having concealed friendship for Tom Sharkey on his person.
When Jerry Simpson walks up to his old seat in congress he will probably be pained at the absence of applause. Simpson served before in Democratic congresses.
See moreSee less
It might be barely possible that the Hon. Fitzsimmons did give Tom Sharkey a jolt below the belt just as a slight memento of the occasion. Fitzsimmons
Fitzsimmons knocked out Sharkey in their San Francisco bout, but referee Wyatt Earp awarded the decision to Sharkey on a foul claim. The report calls it a 'clean steal' and notes the decision has been protested.
Baxter Springs News · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZSIMMONS WINS. But Sharkley is Given the Decision. The mill between Fitzsimmons and Sharkley at San Francisco on Wednesday night was won by Fitz, who knocked Sharkley out, but Referee Earp gave the decision to Sharkley, declaring that the latter was fouled. It was a clean steal and the decision has been protested. Spring river was on quite a high
The report describes the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey heavyweight fight, in which Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out in the eighth round with blows widely seen as fair. Referee Wyatt Earp nonetheless awarded the decision and championship to Sharkey on a claimed foul, a ruling met with hisses from the crowd.
Baxter Springs News · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
REOEIVED WITH HISSES
sailor continually used foul tactics. He would clinch and lift Fitzsimmons from his feet, strike in a clinch, though the men had previously agreed not to do so, and he was generally unfair. Several times during the fight Fitzsimmons had the sailor going, but could not land a knockout blow. In the eighth round Sharkey started in to do the leading, but seldom landed. Bob continually sent in left-hand jabs on Sharkey's face, sending his head back every time.
In the very first round Fitzsimmons saw an opening and a right swing on the jaw sent Sharkey to the floor. That made the sailor a bit cautious, and during the next four rounds he tried to keep out of reach. In the fourth Sharkey pushed Fitzsimmons over onto the floor, and before Bob could get up, made a couple of vicious swipes at him. Fitzsimmons cleverly clinched and avoided damage, but it was a clear case of foul on Sharkey's part. No claim was made, however, and the fight went on. When the seventh round opened Fitzsimmons tried to end matters. He swung his right repeatedly for the jaw, but in some manner Sharkey escaped. The left jabs always connected, though, and Tom was decidedly on the wane. Bob himself was none too strong and seemed to be a bit tired when the round closed.
See moreSee less
Then came the disastrous eighth. Fitzsimmons went at his man with a will and fairly smothered him with lefts and rights. First it would be the mouth that suffered, then the nose and later the eye. Fitzsimmons was working like a demon. His long arms shot out with amazing rapidity and Tom's head bobbed back and forth in response. Then Fitzsimmons got up close to finish the work in a workmanlike manner. A right half-arm jolt under the chin sent the sailor's head to one side. A left hook similarly applied sent him over backward. Then came the much-disputed foul. Very few of the immense crowd could be convinced that Fitzsimmons had been unfair, and it is almost certain that if a foul were committed it was unintentional.
Although knocked out by Fitzsimmons, Sharkey was given the decision by Referee Earp for the heavyweight championship of the world, in spite of Fitzsimmons' protests.
The decision was received with hisses and groans. As far as the art of fighting goes, Sharkey is not in the same class with Fitzsimmons. He is a willing, strong man, but has but little science. A clever man like Fitz had no trouble in avoiding his rushes, and he continually left himself open to damaging blows.
Daily Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky. · and 1 other paper
Following the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight where referee Wyatt Earp ruled Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey, legal proceedings began over the $10,000 purse, with a restraining order issued and Fitzsimmons asking the court to hold the disputed check. The item also notes Earp was arrested for carrying a gun.
Daily Public Ledger · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
IN THE COURTS.
of the National club managers and Referee Wyatt Earp to rob him of the decision. But there were many others—among them were men of unimpeachable reputation—who declared they saw the foul and that Earp's decision was strictly just.
Having ordered the Anglo-California bank to refuse payment on the check, a consultation of physicians was or-
Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio · 5 December 1896
Daily Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky.
Following Referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, Fitzsimmons files suit alleging conspiracy to defraud him, while a court injunction blocks payment of the $10,000 purse check despite the fight managers' attempt to authorize payment. Separately, Earp's arrest for carrying a concealed weapon at the ringside is continued in police court until the following Tuesday.
Daily Public Ledger · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
A Gale in the British Channel. LONDON, Dec. 4.—A southeast gale is prevailing in the English channel and the North sea, and a tremendous sea is running. Many casualties have been reported. The historic chain pier at Brighton, which was erected in [1823], has been demolished.
reached on the merits of the case. In his complaint Fitzsimmons alleges on information and belief that Sharkey, Earp and the National Athletic club conspired to defraud him out of a rightful decision; that he showed greater skill in the contest.
See moreSee less
The case of Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharky fight Wednes
The report states that San Francisco's National Club ruled Fitzsimmons violated the rules in his bout refereed by Wyatt Earp, ordering the bank to pay the stakes to Sharkey. However, the opposing party obtained an injunction, leading to an expected prolonged legal fight over the money.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey erhält das Geld nicht. San Francisco, 4. Dezbr. — Die Entscheidung des Referee Earp in dem Preisboxen zwischen Bob Fitzsimmons und Tom Sharkey ist hier immer noch das Tagesgespräch. Die Manager des „National-Clubs" haben entschieden, daß Fitzsimmons die Wettkampfregeln verletzt hat, und die „Anglo-California-Bank" ist von ihnen angewiesen worden, die hinterlegten $10,000 an Sharkey auszuzahlen. Dagegen hat die Gegenpartei einen Einhaltsbefehl erwirkt, und es wird zu einem langwierigen Kampf über die Geldangelegenheit kommen.
Wyatt Earp, who had refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and was arrested the previous night for carrying a concealed weapon, had his case called in San Francisco police court. At his attorney's request, the hearing was continued until Tuesday.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Earp's Case for Carrying Concealed Weapon Continued Till Tuesday.
Continued Till Tuesday.
San Francisco, Dec. 4.—Danny Lynch, manager of Sailor Sharkey, walked into the Anglo-Californian Bank, this afternoon, and demanded payment on the $10,000 check. Manager Lilienthal said the check could not be paid owing to an injunction. Lynch met this with angry words, and said if the bank refused to hand over the money he would bring suit and ask for heavy damages. Lilienthal told him to go ahead with the suit. Lynch thereupon left.
See moreSee less
The case of Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and who was arrested, last night, on the charge of carrying a concealed weapon, was called upon in the police court, this morning. At the request of Earp's attorney the case was continued until Tuesday.
A newspaper joke item notes that Referee Wyatt Earp admitted his work in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight was poor, saying he should have given Sharkey the decision in the fourth round. The item sarcastically dismisses him with 'Pass on, Mr. Earp.'
The Saint Paul Globe · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
I am not going to pose as a talking fighter.—Thomas Sharkey. Please do not forget that remark, Mr. Sharkey.
Probably Capt. Gen. Weyler has plenty of courage, but he can't keep his legs from running away with him.
See moreSee less
If the Fifty-fifth congress holds an extra session in March, 1897, the people will hold an extra session with the Fifty-fifth congress in November, 1898.
Following the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, referee Wyatt Earp publicly defends his decision, expressing regret only for not leaving the ring amid criticism. Meanwhile, legal battles continue over Sharkey's prize money, with Fitzsimmons alleging conspiracy and Lynch unsuccessfully trying to cash a disputed certificate.
The Saint Paul Globe · 5 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
LYNCH ONCE MORE TURNED DOWN
to cash it.
Sharkey has ten days in which to answer the complaint filed by Fitzsimmons, and it is expected that the legal fight will be hurried. Fitzsimmons is taking matters quietly and is making engagements for his appearance at various places of entertainment in this city and vicinity, when he will give boxing exhibitions. The pool rooms and bookmakers decided to cash the bets today, and holders of wagers on Sharkey were made happy.
See moreSee less
A senational story is being told in sporting circles concerning an alleged telegram sent East, it is said, by Danny Needham, advising the placing of large amounts on Sharkey, with an intimation that the tip was valuable.
Wyatt Earp, the most talked of man of the hour, takes a philosophical view of the criticisms that are being heaped upon him for his decision Wednesday night, and says he will wait for time to set him right with the public.
"If I had any fears that I erred in my decision, they would have disappeared when I saw Sharkey today," said he, "Sharkey did not strike a foul blow, to my mind. It is true he struck Fitzsimmons as soon as his arm was free. It is true there was an agreement that there should be no fighting at a break, but my instruction from the club was not to be tech-
Amid the controversy over Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, this piece recalls his earlier career as a deputy under Marshal Mike Meagher in 1870s Wichita, describing him as fearless and honorable though known as a killer. It also recounts his later moves to Deadwood and Ellsworth, including claims of bloody gunfights with desperadoes.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP AS A KANSAN. He Was Regarded as a Killer, but Never Accused of Dishonesty.
served as an officer under Marshal Mike Maegher, in the early '70's. Wichita at that time was the great cattle market for the Southwest, and it required the utmost vigilance and bravery on the part of the officers to hold the lawless element in check. Earp was absolutely devoid of fear, and was one of the most active of Maegher's deputies. He was a tall, min-
This report recounts Wyatt Earp's lawman career in Deadwood, Ellsworth, and elsewhere, citing former colleagues who vouch for his honesty. It appears amid controversy over his controversial decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, offering testimonials to his integrity.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 5 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP AS A KANSAN.
and his record is good here." Police Clerk John Martin, who was intimately acquainted with him, says: "Earp was just the kind of a man to referee a prize fight, because all the bullies who ever gathered around a prize ring could not scare or bulldoze him; he was thoroughly honest." Detective Bedford Wood, who knew Earp, said he never knew him to be charged with dishonesty before this prize fight.
After referee Wyatt Earp disqualified him for a foul, Bob Fitzsimmons angrily claimed he was cheated out of $10,000 and had won the fight fairly against Tom Sharkey. Sharkey countered that he had the best of every round and would have won regardless, while sportswriters called him lucky and his manager threatened legal action over the purse.
The Greenville Times · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey—The Decision the Talk of the Town.
Fitzsimmons Declares He was Robbed.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 3—"I was simply robbed of $10,000 by that decision," said Fitzsimmons after Wednesday night's battle. "I felt sure I was going against the worst of it when Earp was named, but my reputation was at stake, and I took chances. I never struck a foul blow in my life, and no one knows better than Sharkey that I won the fight fair and square. Look at me. Do you see a single mark or scratch? Did I get a good, solid punch during the fight? Why that dub is simply a strong, young wrestler, and one of the foulest boxers I ever saw. Nobody can get a square deal from thieves who handle fights in this town. I now believe that Corbett was robbed of the decision here in the Jackson fight."
Sharkey asserts that he had the best of every round, and would certainly have won had he not been fouled.
Sporting writers are unanimous in saying that the "sailor" is the luckiest man that ever stepped into the ring. Sharkey announces his willingness to meet all comers for the world's championship. Julian will ask for an injunction restraining the bank from paying Sharkey the check for the purse of $10,000, and the matter will be taken into the courts.
The article explains how Wyatt Earp came to be selected as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout after managers Julian and Lynch failed to agree on one. It quotes Maj. Frank McLaughlin asserting the fight ended with a clean knockout blow, defending Earp's ruling against accusations of foul play.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Greenville Times · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
was called upon to make a selection. He fixed upon Wyatt Earp, and Julian agreed to accept him. Rather than leave Fitzsimmons open to a charge of cowardice, Julian took the short end of the stick.
That Sharkey has improved as a boxer, no one who saw him perform will deny. That he is greatly overrated and entirely outclassed in a contest with Fitzsimmons is also not disputed. The men are about evenly matched in weight, there being less than two pounds difference between them.
A satirical newspaper column lumps Wyatt Earp in with other local jabs, saying the next man beaten by Bob Fitzsimmons should be Earp, 'the bad man from Arizona' who cheated him of a fair decision. It credits Earp with discrediting prize fighting more than anyone of his era.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TOO LATE TO CLASSIFY
The next man whipped by Bob Fitzsimmons should be Wyatt Earp, the bad man from Arizona, who beat him out of the decision he earned, and consequently the purse. Mr. Earp, however, is a public benefactor, in that he
Following his controversial role as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, a Wichita item recalls Wyatt Earp's earlier career as a policeman there in 1875 under chief Mike Meagher. Former chief Dick Cogdell praises Earp as fearless and honest, also claiming he served as marshal at Ellsworth, Kansas.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Earp a Former Kansan. WICHITA, Kan., Dec. 5. — In 1875 Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was a policeman in Wichita under the notorious chief of police, Mike Meagher. Dick Cogdell, who succeeded Mike Meagher as chief, says: "Earp was a man who never smiled or laughed. He was the most fearless man I ever saw. He was marshal at Ellsworth, Kan., when that was a cattle shipping point and he was a success. He is an honest man."
Wyatt Earp, facing public criticism for his decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, defends his ruling and claims the match was fixed by club officials. He says he will let time vindicate him, while a police commissioner vows to ban future prize fighting in San Francisco.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 5 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EARP IS CONFIDENT That Time Will Prove the Wisdom of His Now Famous Decision
but that is following Queensbery rules. It is true that it was agreed that there was to be no fighting at the break, but my instructions from the club were not to be technical, but to give the audience a good fight for their money."
Fitzsimmons alleges fraud and collusion among Sharkey, the National Athletic Club, and referee Wyatt Earp, claiming the match outcome was rigged regardless of winner. Meanwhile Earp's own court case for carrying a concealed weapon at the fight is continued, and a bank dispute over the $10,000 prize money check continues amid competing legal claims.
The Sun · 5 December 1896 · page 9
FITZ GOES TO COURT.
m Superior J ltd go Sanderson upon tho bank. iH I'lUslmrrons asked the Superior Court to tnko jE the check for 510,000 Intu Its possession until a B decision could bo reached on tLu merits of the H case. m After alleging that boxing matches are alHH lowed In San Francisco byvlrtuouf nn ordlH Ilance. and that the National Athletic Club had mmWl aecurrd a penult to hold the exhibition. K117jK almmona alleges that there, vvuru corruption, H collusion, and fraud on the part of Sharkey, the H National Athletic Club, and Hufcreo Karo.
See moreSee less
their H purpose being toswltidlo tho plnlntlir. no matH ter which was the. victor. Tocoiillriu this polH tlon KlUsImtiions alleges that the persons so H conspiring refused to ngroo upon a choice of JM referee, so thnt by the terms of the match the H club had thu privilege of choosing n referee al iB the ringside, and tho choice of Knro was InfillVK fllnient n tth the conspiracy. Touching the outmmm come cf the til.-hi Fltislmmnns avers that tie MU "discomfited the said defenilaut Sharkey, so jH that ald ilefendant was unable to proceed with (r Bald boxing exhibition." jV The announcement was made at Harry CorH belt's pool room that all bets on the MiarkeyIH KltzsimmnnsOghl would lie paid to day at 1 JM o'clock, on tho basis of lteferee Wyatt Karp'a decision hwanllni: the victory to Sharkey in the B eighth round because of a foul. HH The case of Heferoe I?arj, who was arrested IV lastnlgblon n chance of carrying a concealed gmM weapon, and which he was couapillid to hand Jhiu over to Polico Captain Wltman at the ringside, 1 was called up In Police Court this morning. At Wfl the request of Earp's nttornej, however, the ECU case waa continued until next Tuesday. LdH D. J. Lynch, manager nf Sharkey, walked Into the Anglo-Callfornlan Hank shortly after It
This report covers the aftermath of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons prize fight, noting Sharkey's recovery and the ongoing legal battle over the disputed $10,000 purse. It also notes that referee Wyatt Earp, who was disarmed of a revolver and arrested for carrying a concealed weapon at the ring, appeared in police court and was granted a continuance.
The Silver State · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Prize Fight Muddle.
A San Francisco dispatch says that Tom Sharkey is still confined to his bed, but his physicians say he is doing nicely and that he will be up in a few days, none the worse for the blow which secured him $10,000 Wednesday night.
See moreSee less
Fitzsimmons is cheerful and says he will get the purse yet, but Lynch, Sharkey's backer, ridicules Fitzsimmon's expectations. Lynch has ten days in which to file an answer to the papers filed by Fitzsimmons in the court, and the legal battle may be long drawn out.
Bets on the fight are being paid off. Some pool sellers settled Thursday and the remainder paid Sharkey's backer's yesterday. One bookmaker paid out $27,000 yesterday to holders of Sharkey tickets.
Referee Wyatt Earp, who was disarmed of a big Colt's revolver at the ring, and who was arrested on the charge of carrying a concealed weapon, was in the police court yesterday. He asked and was granted a continuation until Tuesday.
Lynch made another effort to induce the bank to cash the $10,000 check yesterday. He was accompanied by J. Groom, one of the officers of the National club. The bank refused again to cash the check on account of the injunction granted by Judge Sanderson. Lynch was very indignant and told Manager Phil Lilienthal of the bank that he would sue him for damages for witholding the money.
The day after the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, referee Wyatt Earp and Sharkey's manager Dan Lynch presented a check at the bank, but cashier Stimson refused payment on instructions. Bank manager Lilienthal later explained the funds had been formally enjoined pending a court decision on entitlement.
Morning Appeal · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
The Check Stopped. The Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight is liable to lead to considerable length. The morning after the battle Earp the referee and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's manager, presented the check just three minutes after the bank opened. Paying Teller Stinson said he had been instructed not to pay it, and referred the two men to Manager Lilien
A classified-ad style column includes a brief joke referencing a photo of Wyatt Earp in the Examiner, suggesting his appearance explains why Fitzsimmons balked before the fight. It reflects lingering public mockery of Earp following the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout.
Morning Appeal · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Salvation Army gave a special street parade and preaching last evening, with music, red lights and spectacular effects.
If the picture of Wyatt Earp in the Examiner looks anything like him we don't wonder Fitzsimmons kicked before he put up his hands. He certainly has a bad eye.
An editorial argues the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match was a scripted swindle to fleece the betting public, with pools fixed on Sharkey lasting six rounds. It suggests newspaper talk involving Julian, Fitzsimmons, and Earp was a grandstand publicity stunt rather than a genuine dispute.
Morning Appeal · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
AS BAD AS RACING.
Pugilism is Merely a Slick Dodge to Rob the Public.
See moreSee less
The big pugilistic contest in San Francisco on Wednesday night was from start to finish a scheme to rob the public. The way these matters are arranged now, makes prize fighting fully on a par with horse racing as a means by which the public can be fleeced on a sure thing basis. The nigger in the fence was the pool selling on the proposition that Sharkey would not last six rounds. The backers of the men had it all fixed between them that Sharkey was to last six rounds, and the Fitzsimmons and Julian money went like water into the pool box on that lay along with Sharkey's. This was the sure thing
Following the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, referee Wyatt Earp was disarmed of a large Colt's revolver at ringside and arrested the previous night on a charge of carrying a concealed weapon. In police court, Earp requested and received a continuance of his case.
Morning Appeal · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
New York, December 2.
Cashing Pools.
See moreSee less
San Francisco, Dec. 5.—Bets on the fight are being paid off today. Some pool-sellers settled yesterday, and the remaining pool-rooms are paying Sharkey's backers today. One bookmaker paid $28,000 this afternoon to holders of Sharkey tickets. Referee Wyatt Earp, who was disarmed of a big Colt's revolver at the ringside and who was arrested last night and charged with carrying a concealed weapon, was in the police court today. Earp asked and obtained a continuance till today.
The item notes Wyatt Earp, now known as the referee of a recent San Francisco prize fight, was once a famed Arizona gunfighter. It recounts that Earp once ran Dave Nagle out of Tucson and declared neither Tucson nor San Francisco big enough for both of them.
Lyon County Times · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
They Never Speak as They Pass By. Wyatt Earp, who refereed the recent prize fight in San Francisco, is the noted gun fighter, of Arizona. Some years ago Earp and Dave Nagle had some trouble in Tucson, and Earp told Nagle to get out of the camp. He got. Earp also
The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco was awarded to Sharkey on a foul in the ninth round, with Wyatt Earp serving as the controversial referee amid accusations of crooked work. Fitzsimmons had knocked Sharkey unconscious, but Earp ruled a foul had occurred, sparking outrage and a decision not to pay betting winnings, with the matter headed to court.
Lyon County Times · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Fitzsimmons—Sharkey Fight.
The fight between Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas J. Sharkey took place at the Mechanics' pavilion, San Francisco, last Wednesday night and was awarded to Sharkey in the ninth round on a foul.
See moreSee less
There was much difficulty in the selection of a referee. Fitzsimmons and Sharkey not being able to agree on a man for referee, the National club, which had charge of the affair, selected Wyatt Earp, famous as the marshal of Tombstone, Arizona, in the days when murders were of daily occurrence and desperadoes were plentiful. At the ringside Fitzsimmons' backer objected to Earp on account of rumors of crooked work, but was compelled to either abandon the fight or abide by the club's selection.
The fight commenced a few minutes after 10 o'clock. In the first two rounds honors were even. In the third round Sharkey knocked Fitzsimmons down, but after that Fitzsimmons had the best of the battle. In the seventh round he knocked Sharkey under the ropes and then picked him up and set him on his feet. In the ninth Fitzsimmons knocked Sharkey out and the sailor was carried from the ring unconscious, but a foul was claimed and allowed by the referee, who awarded the fight to Sharkey. The greatest confusion prevailed and for awhile a riot seemed imminent.
During the fight Sharkey continually fouled Fitzsimmons, but these violations of the rules were overlooked by the referee.
Fitzsimmons was the favorite at 10 to 4 at the ringside and his backers put up lots of money. It has been decided, however, not to pay the money bet on the fight, and the matter is to be taken into the Courts.
Fitzsimmons undoubtedly whipped the sailor boy, but was jobbed for the decision.
Martin Julian, manager for Bob Fitzsimmons, telegraphed that Fitzsimmons won his fight fairly but was "robbed" of victory and its financial rewards. Promoter Dan Stuart declined to discuss the controversial decision by Referee Wyatt Earp, though he said public interest in a future Fitzsimmons-Corbett match remained strong.
Marietta Daily Leader · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
finish fight with Jim Corbett for the $15,000 purse offered by Stuart and that if Sharkey will get into the ring with him, he will whip him the same day or night he fights Corbett. Stuart declined to discuss Wednesday night's fight or Referee Earp's decision. He is free to say, however, that the outcome has not lessened pub-
Following the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, a legal battle erupts over a $10,000 check with a restraining order blocking payment amid fraud allegations against Sharkey, Earp, and the National Athletic Club. Separately, referee Wyatt Earp's concealed weapons case from his arrest the night after the fight is continued in police court until the following Tuesday.
Marietta Daily Leader · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FOR A LARGE
was strictly just.
Having ordered the Anglo-California bank to refuse payment on the check, a consultation of physicians was ordered to decide the single critical issue in the case. When the decision and the individual opinions of the physicians were made known, J. J. Groom and J. D. Gibbs, managers of the National Athletic club, addressed a letter authorizing the bank to pay Sharkey the disputed money.
See moreSee less
This would settle the matter if it were not for a restraining order issued by Superior Judge Sanderson upon the bank. Fitzsimmons asked the superior court to take the check for $10,000 into its possession until a decison could be reached on the merits of the case. In his complaint Fitzsimmons alleges on information and belief that Sharkey, Earp and the National Athletic club conspired to defraud him out of a rightful decision, that he showed greater skill in the contest.
Wyatt Earp will have to defend himself in the police courts against the charge of carrying concealed weapons.
The case of Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharky fight Wednesday night, and who was arrested Thursday night on a charge of carry-
The report describes the December 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in San Francisco, which Sharkey won in the eighth round on a foul. It notes suspicions that referee Wyatt Earp intended to favor Sharkey, and that Fitzsimmons was dominating before the controversial foul decision.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 5 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Sharkey Won on a Foul. The much talked of fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey came off according to contract in San Francisco last night, and was won by Sharkey in the eighth round on a foul. Fitzsimmons had his opponent whipped from the first round, Sharkey being unable to do anything with him. It was claimed before the fight that the referee, Wyatt Earp, intended to give the fight to Sharkey on some pretext or other, and the sports all claim this was done. Sharkey had made a foul before that, but Fitzsimmons made no claim on that account.
See moreSee less
The fight all the way through was fair on Fitzsimmons side and if any foul blow was struck it was by accident. Fitzsimmons says he made no foul and that the referee has simply robbed him. The fight by rounds showed that Fitz had no reason to resort to a foul, as he had his man well whipped at the time, and it is doubtful if he could have stayed the round out. Legal steps will be taken to prevent Sharkey drawing the stakes.
A newspaper editorial column briefly mentions that lawyers are preparing to argue over the $10,000 purse that Referee Wyatt Earp awarded to Sailor Sharkey. The item is a passing jab embedded among various satirical political and international comments.
The Evening Tribune · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
It seems that the lawyers are to spar for the $10,000 purse which Referee Earp awarded to Sailor Sharkey.
According to late Spanish dispatches Maceo is in "full retreat." From this
Semi-Weekly Register · Brookings, S.D. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the later rounds of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match, where Fitzsimmons battered Sharkey before a controversial low blow ended the fight in the eighth round. Referee Wyatt Earp declared the foul deliberate, while Fitzsimmons insisted he fought fairly and any injury was accidental.
Semi-Weekly Register · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Apparently Badly Injured.
Sharkey recovered consciousness about half an hour later. He was apparently badly injured, his groin being swollen. He says he had Fitzsimmons going until the eighth round when the foul occurred.
See moreSee less
Wyatt Earp, the referee, says the foul was deliberate. Fitzsimmons, just before striking his left hook that apparently knocked Sharkey out, hit the sailor below the belt with his fist.
Fitzsimmons was seen at the Baldwin hotel after the fight. He said:
"I have been robbed. I have always fought fairly and I did not foul Sharkey. If he was hurt, it was done without my knowledge and was an unavoidable accident."
Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · 4 December 1896
San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.
Former colleagues from Wichita, where Earp served as a policeman in 1875, defend his character following his controversial refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. They describe him as fearless and honest, citing his later success as marshal of Ellsworth, Kansas.
San Antonio Daily Light · 5 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
GOOD WORDS FOR THE REFEREE. Wichita, Kas., Dec. 4.—In 1875 Wyatt Earp, referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was a policeman in Wichita, under the notorious chief of police, Mike Meagher. Dick Cogdell, who succeeded Meagher as chief, says, "Earp was the most fearless man I ever saw. He was marshal at Ellsworth, Kas., when that was a cattle shipping point, and he was a success. He is an honest man." All the officers here who associated with him, declare Earp is honest and would have decided according to his belief in the face of an arsenal.
Wyatt Earp, who had refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was forced to surrender a concealed weapon to Police Captain Whittman at ringside and was arrested that night on a charge stemming from the incident. His case was called in San Francisco Police Court the next morning but was continued until Tuesday at his attorney's request.
The Times · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
hand over to Police Captain Whittman, at the ring side, a weapon which he carried concealed. For this a charge was made against him, and he was arrested last night. His case was called in the Police Court this morning, but, at the request of Earp's attorney, was continued until Tuesday.
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
Competing physicians offer contradictory opinions on whether Fitzsimmons delivered a foul blow to Sharkey, with some suggesting Sharkey was doped with iodine to support Earp's foul claim. A legal battle over the unpaid purse money is brewing, backed by wealthy supporters of Fitzsimmons like Spreckels and Gunst.
Richmond Dispatch · 5 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE "SAILOR" DOING VERY WELL.
SAN FRANCISCO, December 4.--The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight is being fought over and over again on every street-corner of San Francisco to-day. Professional men, merchants, horsemen, millionaires, and men in every vocation of life, save churchmen, may be seen illustrating just how the Australian put the "sailor" to sleep.
Sharkey is resting easily to-day, and will be on the street within a week. Dr. Tausig, physician of the National Athletic Club, and a doctor of unquestionable reputation, does not hesitate to assert that in his opinion Sharkey did not receive any such blow as his backers claim Fitzsimmons administered. Another leading physician, who inspected the "sailor," is of the opinion that Sharkey was "doped" with iodine to bear out Earp's claim of foul.
See moreSee less
Of all the physicians who examined Sharkey, but two are inclined to believe that he was struck "foul." One of two is the mysterious "Dr." Lee, whom nobody seems to know, and the other is a friend of Danny Lynch's. A half-dozen reputable physicians were at the door of Sharkey's dressing-room when the "sailor" was brought in at the conclusion of the fight, yet none were permitted to inspect him until "Dr." Lee had concluded his examination, an hour later.
The purse-money has not yet been paid, and from present indications there will be a legal battle which will eclipse the ring encounter. Such men as Adolph Spreckels, Major McLaughlin, Mose Gunst, William Greer Harrison, and Hiram Cook are behind Fitzsimmons and Julian, while Sharkey's supporters are few and inconsequential.
To add to Fitz's trouble, suit was instituted against him to-day by J. J. Raus, on a claim for $905, held in judgment by Jimmy Carrol, the lightweight. Carroll was one of Fitzsimmons's trainers for his fight with Maher, near El Paso. His bill for services was not paid, and though he put his claim in judgment, he never succeeded in collecting the money. This will be heard to-morrow.
Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was forced to surrender a concealed weapon to Police Captain Whitman at ringside and was arrested on a charge stemming from it. His case was called in Police Court but continued until Tuesday at his attorney's request.
Richmond Dispatch · 5 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
EARP'S CONCEALED WEAPON
"SAILOR" SHARKEY'S PURSE. Payment of Check Demanded Angrily—Threat of Suit. SAN FRANCISCO, December 4.—Danny Lynch, manager of "Sailor" Sharkey, walked into the Anglo-Californian Bank shortly after it opened this
At a San Francisco fight watched by up to 20,000 spectators, Fitzsimmons dominated Sharkey throughout the bout. Despite this, Referee Wyatt Earp declared Sharkey the winner in the eighth round, ruling that Fitzsimmons had committed a foul, and Sharkey was carried from the ring unconscious.
Martinsburg Independent · 5 December 1896 · page 2
Fits Won, Sharkey Got the Decision. Sax Francisco, Deo. 8.—The fight be tween Fitzsimmons and Sharkey in this city last evening was witnessed by 16,00C to 80,000 people, including several hun dred woman. Sharkey was no match foi Fitz, and the fight was the Australian’s throughout. Notwithstanding this, Ref eree Earp awarded the contest to Shariej in the eighth round, declaring that he had been knocked out by a foul. Sharkey was was carried from the ring unconscious.
Tombstone Epitaph · Tombstone, Ariz. · and 1 other paper
After referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the win over Fitzsimmons on a foul, Earp gave Sharkey's manager Lynch a certified $10,000 check. Fitzsimmons' lawyers moved to block payment, and when Lynch tried to cash the check the next day, the bank refused to honor it.
Tombstone Epitaph · 6 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Caving contemporaries are drawing editorial morals from the fact that a Chicago woman asked a court to grant her a divorce inside of twenty minutes the other day and was refused that accomodation. But if the court was rushed at the time it was no more than fair to ask her to stand in line and take her turn.
serious.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO.—Although Sharkey was awarded the decision after the eighth round in the battle with Fitzsimmons, the referee declaring that Fitzsimmons had struck a foul blow. the sailor may not get the purse after all. At any rate he will have to make a legal fight for it which may prove a harder struggle than the fight. When Referee Wyatt Earp decided that Fitzsimmons had struck Sharkey a blow below the belt and that Sharky was the victor on a foul he handed Lynch who is Sharkey's backer and manager a certified check on the Anglo-California Bank for $10,000. Fitzsimmons promptly protested and consulted an attorney who decided to
Tombstone Prospector · Tombstone, Ariz. · 4 December 1896
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
The report claims Wyatt Earp, acting as referee for a boxing match sponsored by 'Long Green' Lawrence, was part of a pre-arranged conspiracy to rob Fitzsimmons of victory. It cites suspicious circumstances, medical evidence, and Earp's carrying of a revolver into the ring as proof of wrongdoing.
The San Francisco Call · 6 December 1896 · page 1
LONG GREEN ANDY LAWRENCE AND HIS ARMED BODY GUARD
Thousand Dollars. Excitement about the raw decision of Wyatt Earp. the bodyguard of "Long ■ Green" Lawrence of the Examiner, is in creasinir rather than diminishing among lovers of honest Bport as the facts of the transparent conspiracy are being dragged ' .to the surface. ■■-'•• It is now said that Earn had been se ••; • lected as "the dark horse" for referee long before the tight, and long before the peo ple had any idea that there was the re '•;. . jnotest chance that San Franciscans of un 'blemislted reputations, who had been con ;..
See moreSee less
' neaped with boxing and other athletics for • years and years, would be turned down, /": and a faro-dealer and gunfighter from .•■..Arizona or anywhere else would be se '...' Jected in their stead. •:;./. B, nee the developments which have '. been made during tbe past twenty-four hours additional significance attacties to . the fact that Referee Earp went into the i ' ■ ■ ring with a navy revolver a foot long j ' sticking out of his hip pocket. ... Mr. Earp is no fool. He knew that he i
The article questions why referee Wyatt Earp carried a hidden revolver during the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight despite assurances of his safety, suggesting foul play and collusion with figures like Andy Lawrence. It also recounts how Sharkey's manager insisted the club choose the referee rather than accept Julian's nominees, fueling suspicion of a fixed outcome.
The San Francisco Call · 6 December 1896 · page 1
■ the persons whom that decision would rob. . " The whole affair reeks with suspicion against Earp and his friends. . One of his most intimate friends, the ' man who recommended Earp for the po ■ sition and who did as much as, if not more, ' than any other person to secure his being selected as referee, is Andy M. Lawrence, ■ familiarly known as "Lonsr Green Law1 . rence," managing editor of the Examiner. Why was Long Green so anxious to have Earp referee the fight? Manager Julian says that from the very •t.• t . start the Sharkey people, and particularly . Mr. Lynch, objected to any person named "... as referee by the Fitzsimmons people or •'• by disinterested individuals, and insisted
Wyatt Earp, referee of the disputed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, failed to appear as a witness in Jimmy Carroll's lawsuit against Fitzsimmons, resulting in a bench warrant for his arrest. The report also details conflicting testimony over the $10,000 purse check and Earp's near-confrontation with a Republican official who questioned his fight decision.
The Herald · 6 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
REFEREE EARP'S CONTEMPT
Selling Liquor Without a License. Sharkey Is Still in Bed.
Associated Press Special Wire
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 5.—The excittement caused by the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight has abated and even popular interest in the final disposition of the ten thousand dollar purse is waning. Sharkey is still in bed and receives visitors in a room filled with flowers, the gifts of admiring female friends. He confidently expects to receive the purse soon, although neither side made any move today. Fitzsimmons says he will remain here only until the suit for the purse is determined, and that he will thereafter be at Dan Stuart's disposal. Fitzsimmons was occupied today in defending the suit brought against him by Jimmy Carroll, his former trainer, for $900, alleged to be due for training services.
The story is now current in sporting circles that Fitzsimmons has done pretty well with his fight venture, even if he receives no part of the purse. Most of the money wagered on the fight was placed on the question of Sharkey's ability to stay six rounds. It is now said that Fitzsimmons placed several thousand dollars on Sharkey's ability to hold out six rounds and then took care that he did not knock out his opponent too soon.
Referee Wyatt Earp had been quoted as saying that when he met Major Frank McLaughlin, chairman of the Republican state committee, he would call McLaughlin to account for having said that Earp's decision was unsavory and for insinuating that the referee had been "fixed." The two met in a hotel bar today and an encounter was expected, but Earps' friends managed to get him out before there was any chance for an altercation.
It looks as if Jimmy Carroll's suit $900 is to be used to secure a judicial against Bob Fitzsimmons to recover decision on the late prize fight between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons. Today Carroll's suit was heard before Justice of the Peace Groezinger and Dan Lynch, Wyatt Earp and others, summoned as witnesses. Lynch appeared and got himself into trouble. He swore that the much coveted $10,000 check was not in his possession. He said Sharkey had given him the check with instructions to hand it to a man named Dowdell, which he had done. This statement of Lynch's was doubted and Justice Groezinger went to Sharkey's bedside and took the sailor's deposition. Sharkey testified that he knew n[o] one named Dowdell, and that he had given the check to Lynch, and it was still in his possession. Justice Groezinger intimated that he would have Lynch arrested on a charge of perjury, and the case went over until Tuesday. Referee Earp did not appear in court and a bench warrant was issued for his arrest.
Groom and Gibbs of the National club are also in trouble. They received a permit for the fight on the condition that no intoxicating liquors be sold. Internal revenue officers allege that liquors were sold in the pavilion without a license and they threaten to hold Groom and Gibbs responsible.
Robert Fitzsimmons writes to the New York Journal claiming he fairly beat Sharkey and that referee Wyatt Earp's decision against him was a fixed, fraudulent job. He gives his own blow-by-blow account of knocking Sharkey down twice before being denied the win.
New York Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
FITZSIMMONS AND SHARKEY TELL STORY OF THE DISPUTED FIGHT
San Francisco, Dec. 5. Editor New York Journal:
The decision of Referee Earp was one of the greatest jobs ever perpetrated in the American prize ring. I won the fight fairly and without a foul. There can be no question about that.
See moreSee less
But I blame myself a good deal for the result. I was warned in time that Earp had been fixed, but thought I could knock Sharkey out so cleanly that all jobs would be upset.
Now as regards the actual fight itself, I will describe it as accurately as I can remember. As soon as we squared off, I said to myself, "This is one of the easiest games I ever struck." I could see my advantage in reach, and he seemed wide open for most any kind of a lead.
I feinted around for a while, and then opened with a high right swing, intending to jar him on the left ear. I got there, and shook him up. He came back with left and right swings, but missed by a foot or more on each. I fooled along with him for two minutes, I guess, before trying again. Then I hooked him on the chin and dropped him.
The fight was mine right through. He got up and came back gamely. I had not hit him hard enough. He was wide open for me, but I was
Fitzsimmons recounts the fight in detail, describing how he landed a legal body blow and uppercut that knocked out Sharkey in the eighth round. He insists there was no foul and claims he was robbed of victory by referee Wyatt Earp's decision.
New York Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE BIG BATTLE.
He is a wonderfully strong fellow, and was in superb condition, and recuperated astonishingly. After th[at] until the eighth round I laid back and waited for a chance to put him [illegible] clean, so that there could be no dispute about the result.
I had lots of openings, but he was so awkward that I found it difficult to put a blow where it would have the desired effect. All this time he did me no damage whatever. Once he landed in my wind, but did not hurt. I encouraged him, however, by saying, "That was a good one."
See moreSee less
But I will tell you about the eighth. He opened with several rushes, but his blows were weak, and I saw I had him. I waited for the right moment and stole in on his feint with my left. In this way I landed my left pretty stiff and dazed him. He wabbled and left his guard open.
I saw my chance, and sent my left in again for his body and caught him squarely in the wind. The blow was not below the belt; in fact, it was fully six inches above. This really finished him.
Sharkey dropped his hands and began to sink. To make the job perfect I sent in an uppercut with my left and jolted him under the chin before he fell, knocking him out completely.
I could have finished him earlier, but wanted to make sure of my friends' money. I was the most surprised and disgusted man in the world when told that Earp had decided for Sharkey on a foul. There was no foul about it, and nobody knows this better than Earp himself.
I believe I have been deliberately robbed, and that the tips I got before I went into the ring were right.
Wyatt Earp, who refereed the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, has been arrested in San Francisco for carrying a concealed Colt .44 revolver, a weapon he reportedly has carried for fifteen years. He is out on bail and plans to argue that carrying the gun was simply force of habit from his years as a Wells-Fargo messenger.
New York Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
trousers as without my gun.
Wyatt Earp has carried that same gun for fifteen years, at least. It is a six-chambered Colt's revolver, 44-calibre, a very handy weapon, light on the trigger. Five of its barrels are always loaded. The hammer rests on the empty chamber when the gun is not in action—when Wyatt Earp is quiescent.
See moreSee less
"I keep one chamber empty," said the man who gave the decision to Sharkey to the writer of this. "I keep one chamber empty in case of accident."
That is, of course, in case of accident to himself. The five loaded chambers have been the frequent cause of accidents—of sudden death—to others.
If Wyatt Earp wishes to support his ingenuous plea of "force of habit," let him tell the police judge before whom he
Fitzsimmons' attorney Kowalski alleges a conspiracy involving Sharkey, his manager, and referee Earp to fix the fight's outcome, citing telegrams from trainer Danny Needham urging bets on Sharkey before the match. A separate letter writer speculates Sharkey used a mustard plaster trick to fake a foul.
New York Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
SAID SHARKEY MUST WIN
Trainer Danny Needham Said to Have "Tipped" His Friends.
San Francisco, Dec. 5.—There is still a good deal of excitement here over the big fight, and the cries of fraud in connection with the referee's decision are as numerous as ever. Colonel H. I. Kowalski, the attorney for Fitzsimmons, declares that the result of the battle was a foregone conclusion the moment Earp was appointed referee, and he charges Sharkey and his manager, Lynch, and some others as co-conspirators in a big plot not only to defraud Fitzsimmons of the prize money, but the betting public as well.
See moreSee less
"We will carry the whole matter to the Grand Jury," said Kowalski last evening, "and I am confident we have enough evidence to sustain several criminal indictments."
A morning paper publishes the following dispatch from Seattle:
"Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, has many friends in this city. To them he sent urgent telegrams just before the fight, saying: 'Bet all you have got on Sharkey to win,' and 'bet Sharkey to win,' and 'Sharkey will win; bet on him; never quit,' and like expressions. Even before the fight began there was talk of 'fake' in this city."
A reader writing to the New York Journal claims Sharkey used an old trick of applying a mustard plaster below the belt to simulate a foul blow, allowing him to win on Referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision. The letter also notes Sharkey's trainer sent telegrams urging people to bet on Sharkey before the fight, suggesting foreknowledge of a fix.
New York Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
DID SHARKEY USE A PLASTER?
a Purse.
Dallas, Tex., Dec. 5.—Dan A. Stuart departed for New York to-day to endeavor to close negotiations with James J. Corbett for a finish fight with Robert Fitzsimmons. Papers were sent several days ago to W. K. Wheelock, Stuart's New York representative. If they reach Stuart to-morrow at St. Louis signed by Corbett, Stuart will go direct to San Francisco to meet Fitzsimmons; if not, he will proceed to New York.
See moreSee less
Stuart said as he was departing:
"I feel sure of bringing Corbett and Fitzsimmons together for a finish fight. If I had any doubt of success, I would not waste my time, but, if I shall fail, the sporting public will know which of the pugilists has shown the white feather, for I mean business to the extent of a $15,000 purse, which I am ready to put up the moment the two men sign articles of agreement.
"If they will sign and I fail to furnish a battle ground, then they can divide the $15,000 between them.
"By the way, if things go smoothly for me with Fitzsimmons and Corbett, I may offer a big purse for a big finish fight between Peter Maher and Tom Sharkey, same time and place."
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 5 other papers
This long retrospective article recounts a highly embellished, largely fictionalized history of the Earp family in Tombstone, inventing a sister named Jessie who married Ike Clanton and claiming two Earp brothers were killed by him. It also describes the Earps and Clantons as leaders of rival 'Stage Robber' and 'Rustler' factions tied to political parties.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 6 December 1896 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
One of Four Brothers, All Men With Records as Gun Fighters—Ten Men to His Credit—Shot With the Stage Robbers and Voted With the Republicans.
Alfred Henry Lewis in New York Journal.
See moreSee less
Washington, Dec. 3.—In the early eighties I was a neighbor of the Earp family. They abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence.
Wyatt Earp is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented a front to that household made up in the main of Winchesters and Colt six shooters. The Earps construed this into a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented it by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever. They migrated to the Gunnison country. They were subsequently run out of the Gunnison and Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to California, where Wyatt the other night refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
The four Earps were named respectively Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as novelists say, more anon. Virgil was the oldest Earp, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the most foolhardy, Julian the bravest and Jessie the most loving. As a result Wyatt and Virgil lived to get out of Tombstone, and the Gunnison in advance of public opinion and the bullets that expressed it; while Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison by Ike Clauton, who had married his sister Jessie, and whom Wyatt and Virgil subsequently killed at Socorro—and Jessie, the loving one, wedded Ike Clauton, with whom her four brothers had a blood feud at the time!
Wyatt Earp, and, for that matter, all the Earps, were gun-fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited with ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in '81 and '82 and, eschewing the intervention of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as "fanning" their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.
In the early 80s there were two factions in Tombstone. Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one—the Stage Robbers. Johnny Behan, Ike Clauton and Jack Ringo led the other—the Rustlers. The Stage Robbers were in politics Republican, and stood up stages and plundered express companies for a livelihood. The Rustlers were democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle stealing, murder, whisky, and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was sheriff of Cochise county and Virgil Earp was the marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the Cow-thief Democracy party, while Earp robbed stages and voted with the Republicans.
The Earps, Wyatt, Virgil, Warren and Julian had treated themselves to many a killing. But there was no money in murder; nothing but relaxation. So they devoted themselves to holding up the stage. Virgil Earp had a combination with Barshel Williams, then the Wells-Fargo agent at Tombstone. When big money went out on the stage, Williams tipped it off to Virgil Earp. The hold-ups were then planted in a convenient canyon. When the stage came along, at the word "hands up!" Warren Earp, who was a stage company guard, meekly put his hands over his head. Then the hold-ups went through the express pouches and boxes like the grace of heaven through a camp meeting.
There was never any shooting; it was from all standpoints a family affair, on the part of the Earps. Often they got as high as $25,000. After a robbery the Earps made further money, enlisting themselves with a posse comitatus and chasing themselves. Virgil, as marshal, would enlist Wyatt, Warren and Julian, together with Curly Bill, their cousin, and hunt the hold-ups. It was a great industry, and by thus playing both ends against the middle, first robbing the stage and then pretending to chase the robbers, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian Earp waxed opulent.
But it all came out on them. Williams, the Wells-Fargo agent, confessed. It happened thus. It was a gala occasion in the Bird Cage Opera House, in Tombstone. Sheriff Jimmy Behan, Ike Clauton, Ringo, and others of the cow thieves, had boxes on one side. The Earps, Curly Bill, Doc Holliday, Nixon and others of the stage robbers, had boxes opposite. When one side cheered a performer the others hissed, and as whisky flowed the spirits of both gangs mounted.
At last Ike Clauton took umbrage because Nixon opposite reposed his boot on the rail of his box. Clauton was too far away for conversation, so in testimnoy of his condemnation of Nixon's action he pulled his gun and put a bullet through Nixon's offensive foot. It came off the box rail.
Much good and enthusiastic shooting ensued. Twelve men were killed and wounded; none of the Earps, however. Williams, the confederate of Virgil and Wyatt Earp in the stage robbing, was badly shot up. He expected to die and confessed. At this Wyatt Earp and his three brothers, with others of their gang, fortified themselves in an old 'doby house on the edge of Tombstone. Behan and the cow thieves put in what time they could spare from faro bank and theft in beseiging them. The siege was a stand-off. At last Warren Earp—the foolhardy one—heeled himself and came down from the 'doby fortress to play faro bank. He has just set a stack of blues on the king open when a cow thief listlessly put a bullet through his head.
Thus died the first of the Earps. There was more fighting then, and at last the Earpes were driven out of Tombstone and into the Gunnison. Their sister Jessie went with them. Ike Clauton, one of the Democrats and cow thieves, followed them to Colorado, and eloped with Jessie. This was too much for the Republican stage-robbing blood of Wyatt Earp and his brothers. They pursued. They ran Clauton and his bride into a mine tunnel. The miners interfered. There must be fair play. Ike Clauton offered to fight Virgil, Wyatt or Julian Earp for their sister. Julian took it up. The two shot it out with pistols, and Julian was killed.
Thus died the second Earp. Ike Clauton and Jessie, nee Earp, lived in peace two years. Then Wyatt Earp, Virgil Earp and Curley Bill crossed up with Clauton, and there was another feast of the guns. Clauton was killed and took with him Curley Bill to the happy hunting grounds. Wyatt Earp, when the smoke blew away, was also full of well-made bullet holes, but he got well.
It was then that Wyatt and Virgil Earp lined out for the slope. Just before they left Tombstone the Earps killed the two McLowries, Billy Clauton and Frank Stillwell. It was these killings rather than the Wells-Fargo hold-ups that caused the public to lay for them. Wyatt Earp was
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 7 December 1896
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · 14 December 1896
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif. · 14 December 1896
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif. · 19 December 1896
The Lamar Register · Lamar, Colo. · 16 January 1897
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 27 January 1897
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
This highly embellished account claims Wyatt, Virgil, Warren and a fictional brother Julian Earp secretly ran a stage-robbing gang while posing as lawmen, in opposition to Sheriff Behan's 'Rustler' faction. It culminates in a lurid, invented shootout at the Bird Cage Opera House sparked by a dispute over a boot on a box rail.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 6 December 1896 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
One of Four Brothers, All Men With Records as Gun Fighters—Ten Men to His Credit—Shot With the Stage Robbers and Voted With the Republicans.
Alfred Henry Lewis in New York Journal.
See moreSee less
Washington, Dec. 3.—In the early eighties I was a neighbor of the Earp family. They abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence.
Wyatt Earp is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented a front to that household made up in the main of Winchesters and Colt six shooters. The Earps construed this into a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented it by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever. They migrated to the Gunnison country. They were subsequently run out of the Gunnison and Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to California, where Wyatt the other night refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
The four Earps were named respectively Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as novelists say, more anon. Virgil was the oldest Earp, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the most foolhardy, Julian the bravest and Jessie the most loving. As a result Wyatt and Virgil lived to get out of Tombstone, and the Gunnison in advance of public opinion and the bullets that expressed it; while Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison by Ike Clauton, who had married his sister Jessie, and whom Wyatt and Virgil subsequently killed at Socorro—and Jessie, the loving one, wedded Ike Clauton, with whom her four brothers had a blood feud at the time!
Wyatt Earp, and, for that matter, all the Earps, were gun-fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited with ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in '81 and '82 and, eschewing the intervention of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as "fanning" their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.
In the early 80s there were two factions in Tombstone. Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one—the Stage Robbers. Johnny Behan, Ike Clauton and Jack Ringo led the other—the Rustlers. The Stage Robbers were in politics Republican, and stood up stages and plundered express companies for a livelihood. The Rustlers were democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle stealing, murder, whisky, and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was sheriff of Cochise county and Virgil Earp was the marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the Cow-thief Democracy party, while Earp robbed stages and voted with the Republicans.
The Earps, Wyatt, Virgil, Warren and Julian had treated themselves to many a killing. But there was no money in murder; nothing but relaxation. So they devoted themselves to holding up the stage. Virgil Earp had a combination with Barshel Williams, then the Wells-Fargo agent at Tombstone. When big money went out on the stage, Williams tipped it off to Virgil Earp. The hold-ups were then planted in a convenient canyon. When the stage came along, at the word "hands up!" Warren Earp, who was a stage company guard, meekly put his hands over his head. Then the hold-ups went through the express pouches and boxes like the grace of heaven through a camp meeting.
There was never any shooting; it was from all standpoints a family affair, on the part of the Earps. Often they got as high as $25,000. After a robbery the Earps made further money, enlisting themselves with a posse comitatus and chasing themselves. Virgil, as marshal, would enlist Wyatt, Warren and Julian, together with Curly Bill, their cousin, and hunt the hold-ups. It was a great industry, and by thus playing both ends against the middle, first robbing the stage and then pretending to chase the robbers, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian Earp waxed opulent.
But it all came out on them. Williams, the Wells-Fargo agent, confessed. It happened thus. It was a gala occasion in the Bird Cage Opera House, in Tombstone. Sheriff Jimmy Behan, Ike Clauton, Ringo, and others of the cow thieves, had boxes on one side. The Earps, Curly Bill, Doc Holliday, Nixon and others of the stage robbers, had boxes opposite. When one side cheered a performer the others hissed, and as whisky flowed the spirits of both gangs mounted.
At last Ike Clauton took umbrage because Nixon opposite reposed his boot on the rail of his box. Clauton was too far away for conversation, so in testimnoy of his condemnation of Nixon's action he pulled his gun and put a bullet through Nixon's offensive foot. It came off the box rail.
Much good and enthusiastic shooting ensued. Twelve men were killed and wounded; none of the Earps, however. Williams, the confederate of Virgil and Wyatt Earp in the stage robbing, was badly shot up. He expected to die and confessed. At this Wyatt Earp and his three brothers, with others of their gang, fortified themselves in an old 'doby house on the edge of Tombstone. Behan and the cow thieves put in what time they could spare from faro bank and theft in beseiging them. The siege was a stand-off. At last Warren Earp—the foolhardy one—heeled himself and came down from the 'doby fortress to play faro bank. He has just set a stack of blues on the king open when a cow thief listlessly put a bullet through his head.
Thus died the first of the Earps. There was more fighting then, and at last the Earpes were driven out of Tombstone and into the Gunnison. Their sister Jessie went with them. Ike Clauton, one of the Democrats and cow thieves, followed them to Colorado, and eloped with Jessie. This was too much for the Republican stage-robbing blood of Wyatt Earp and his brothers. They pursued. They ran Clauton and his bride into a mine tunnel. The miners interfered. There must be fair play. Ike Clauton offered to fight Virgil, Wyatt or Julian Earp for their sister. Julian took it up. The two shot it out with pistols, and Julian was killed.
Thus died the second Earp. Ike Clauton and Jessie, nee Earp, lived in peace two years. Then Wyatt Earp, Virgil Earp and Curley Bill crossed up with Clauton, and there was another feast of the guns. Clauton was killed and took with him Curley Bill to the happy hunting grounds. Wyatt Earp, when the smoke blew away, was also full of well-made bullet holes, but he got well.
It was then that Wyatt and Virgil Earp lined out for the slope. Just before they left Tombstone the Earps killed the two McLowries, Billy Clauton and Frank Stillwell. It was these killings rather than the Wells-Fargo hold-ups that caused the public to lay for them. Wyatt Earp was
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper
The controversy over referee Wyatt Earp's decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight persists, with critics still alleging fraud while supporters cite medical and bookmaker opinions backing the foul claim. A rumor that Sharkey's camp offered Fitzsimmons $4,000 to settle the stake dispute is reported as false and denied.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Denial of a Story that He Is Willing to Give Fitzsimmons $4,000.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 5.--The storm that the contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons raised is rapidly subsiding. Those who insist that Earp rendered an unjust decision are no less emphatic in their assertions than they were on the day after the fight, but they have nothing new to add to their story of fraud. Those who claim that the sailor was fouled stand by their first position, which has been strengthened by the opinion of the consulting physicians and the decision of the bookmakers.
See moreSee less
Sharkey is still confined to his bed and will not be allowed to leave his room until Wednesday, at the earliest. He is not a particularly presentable object, but he rests easily and tells the story of how it all happened before he lay prostrate in the ring at the feet of Fitzsimmons.
Fitzsimmons's hands are considerably better and have almost reached normal size. His future plans will depend in a great measure on the outcome of the present legal controversy over the stake, though he will not stay in California longer than a few weeks before going to New York. Stuart has wired him again, asking him to name the exact date when he would leave for the East. The Australian wired back that he would be unable to give a reply for another week, at least.
A story that Sharkey is willing to compromise with Fitzsimmons has gained currency, although it has no foundation in fact. It was represented that agents of the sailor were willing to give Fitzsimmons $4,000 out of the purse. This is vigorously denied by Sharkey and Lynch, who insist that they will claim every cent of the money that represents their victory. They made no overtures to Fitzsimmons since the fight and they will make none. Local bookmakers are now paying bets on the fight. They have accepted the decision of Earp as final and are giving the winners what is due them. This has had a marked effect in silencing the storm of angry protests and arguments.
The story is now current in sporting circles that Fitzsimmons has done pretty well with his fight venture even if he receives no part of the purse. Most of the money wagered on the fight was placed on the question of Sharkey's ability to stay six rounds. It is now said Fitzsimmons placed several thousand dollars on Sharkey to hold out six rounds and then took care that he did not knock out his opponent too soon.
San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex. · 5 December 1896
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.
Following the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, referee Wyatt Earp reportedly sought out Republican official Frank McLaughlin to confront him over claims that Earp's decision was 'unsavory' and that he had been bribed. The two met in a hotel bar and a confrontation seemed likely, but Earp's friend pulled him away before any altercation occurred.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 6 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
by Jimmy Carroll, his former trainer, for $900, alleged to be due for training services.
The story is now current in sporting circles that Fitzsimmons has done pretty well with his fight venture, even if he receives no part of the purse. Most of the money wagered on the fight was on the question of Sharkey's ability to stay six rounds. It is now claimed that Fitzsimmons placed several thousand dollars on Sharkey to hold out six rounds and then took care that he did not knock his opponent out too soon.
See moreSee less
Referee Wyatt Earp had been quoted as saying that when he met Major Frank McLaughlin chairman of the Republican state central committee, he would call McLaughlin to acount for having said that Earp's decision was unsavory and for insinuating that the referee had been "fixed." The two met in a hotel bar today and an encounter was expected but Earp's friends managed to get him out before there was any chance for an altercation.
San Francisco, Dec. 5.—The storm that the contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons raised is rapidly subsiding. Those who insist that Earp rendered an unjust decision are no less emphatic in their assertions than they were the day after the fight, but they have nothing new to add to their story of fraud. Those who claim that the sailor was fouled stand by their by their first position, which has been strengthened by the opinion of the consulting physicians and the
A short filler item notes that boxer Tom Sharkey staying in bed serves as an endorsement of Wyatt Earp's controversial refereeing decision. This references the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight controversy where Earp, acting as referee, was accused of favoring Sharkey.
The Saint Paul Globe · 6 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SOUTHAMPTON—Sailed: St. Louis, for New York.
Sharkey remains in bed as an indorsement of Wyatt Earp's decision.
See moreSee less
The Fifty-fourth congress is "irrelevant, incompetent" and inconsequen
San Francisco's excitement over the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and Wyatt Earp's disputed refereeing decision is subsiding, with no new developments in the fight purse dispute. Both sides maintain their original positions—those alleging an unjust decision versus those claiming a foul—while Sharkey remains bedridden and Fitzsimmons awaits the purse ruling.
The Saint Paul Globe · 6 December 1896 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
EXCITEMENT IS COOLING RAPIDLY
[illegible] its Interest for San Francisco.
SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., Dec. 5.-The excitement caused by the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight has abated, and even popular interest in the final disposition of the $10,000 purse is waning. Sharkey is still in bed, and receives visitors in a room filled with flowers, the gifts of admiring female friends. He confidently expects to receive the purse soon, although neither side made any move today. Fitzsimmons says he will remain here only until the suit for the purse is determined and that he will hereafter be at Dan Stuart's disposal.
See moreSee less
The story is now current in sporting circles that Fitzsimmons has done pretty well with his fight venture, even if he receives no part of the purse. Most of the money wagered on the fight was placed on the question of Sharkey's ability to stay six rounds. It is now said that Fitzsimmons placed several thousand dollars on Sharkey to hold out six rounds, and then took care that he did not knock his opponent out too soon.
Days after Wyatt Earp's controversial referee decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, critics still allege fraud or a foul, while bookmakers have begun honoring the decision and paying out bets. Legal disputes continue over the purse money held at the bank under court injunction.
The Saint Paul Globe · 6 December 1896 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
Getting Back to Normal.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 5.—The storm that the contest between Sharkey and Fitzsimmons raised is rapidly subsiding. Those who insist that Earp rendered an unjust decision are no less emphatic in their assertion than they were on the day after the fight, but they have nothing new to add to their story of fraud. Those who claimed that the sailor was fouled stand by their first position, which has been strengthened by the opinion of the consulting physicians and the decision of the bookmakers. Sharkey is still confined to his bed, and will not be allowed to leave his room until Wednesday at the earliest. He is not a particularly presentable object, but he rests easily and tells the story of how it all happened before he lay prostrate in the ring at the feet of Fitzsimmons.
See moreSee less
Dan Lynch, manager of the sailor, has made another attempt to obtain the money from the bank on the certificate of deposit, but the officers declined to pay the money. They explained that the superior court had issued an injunction against payment, and that no money would be paid until the restraining order is dissolved.
Fitzsimmons' hands are considerably better, and have almost reached normal size. His future plans will depend in a great measure on the outcome of the present legal controversy, though he will not stay in California longer than a few weeks before going to New York. Stuart wired him again yesterday, and asked him to name the exact date when he would leave for the East. The Australian wired back that he would be unable to give a reply for another week at least.
A story that Sharkey is willing to compromise with Fitzsimmons gained currency, although it had no foundation in fact. It was represented that he was willing to give Fitz $3,000 out of the purse. This was denied by Sharkey and Lynch, who insist that they will claim every cent of the money. Local bookmakers are now paying bets on the fight. They have accepted the decision of Earp as final, and are giving the winners what is due them. This has had a marked effect in silencing the storm of angry protest and arguments.
The report describes continuing controversy over Wyatt Earp's officiating of a boxing match, noting conflicting testimony about whether a foul blow was struck. Earp defends himself in print, claiming critics are motivated by bias, while a Major McLaughlin is reported making threats against him.
Morning Appeal · 6 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Walsh & Wylie, The N vada Boys.
Major McLaughlin of San Francisco, known as the "man with the telephonic hat," is talking about making Wyatt Earp eat six inches of the barrel of his own six shooter, In, case when the Major meets Earp and makes the request, the latter should beg to be excused on the plea of poor teeth, it would place the Major is a peculiar position.
See moreSee less
To Cure a Cold in One Day Take Laxative Brome Quinine Tablets. All druggists refund the money it fails to cure. 25c. o 25.
San Francisco physicians are divided over whether Sharkey was genuinely struck foul by Fitzsimmons or whether his injury was faked with iodine to support Earp's foul claim. Only two of many examining doctors believe a foul blow occurred, and the purse remains unpaid amid threats of legal action.
San Antonio Daily Light · 6 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
WANT FAIR PLAY. Special Wire To Sunday Light.
San Francisco, Cal., Dec. 5.—The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight is being fought over and over again on every street corner of San Francisco. Professional men, merchants, horsemen, millionaires and men of every vocation in life save churchmen may be seen illustrating just how the Australian put Sharkey to sleep.
See moreSee less
Sharkey is resting easy ahd will be on the street within a week. Dr. Taussig, doctor for the National Physical club, does not hesitate in the opinion that Sharkey did not receive any such blow as his backers claim Fitzsimomns administered.
Another leading physician who inspected the sailor, is of the opinion that Sharkey was "doped" with iodine to bear out Earp's claim of foul.
Of all the physicians who examined Sharkey, but two are of the opinion that he was truck foul. One of the two is the mysterious "Dr." Lee whom nobody seems to know, and the other is a friend of Danny Lynch. Half a dozen reputable physicians were at the door of Sharkey's dressing room when the sailor was brought to the room at the conclusion of the fight, yet none were permitted to inspect him, until "Dr." Lee had concluded his examination an hour later. The purse has not been paid and the indications are there will be a legal battle which will eclipse the ring encounter.
Such men as Adolph Spreckles, Major McLaughlin, Mose Gunst, Wm
Fitzsimmons' attorney Kowalski claims the fight outcome was predetermined once Earp was named referee, accusing Sharkey and manager Lynch of conspiracy to defraud both Fitzsimmons and bettors. A Seattle newspaper also reports suspicious pre-fight telegrams from Sharkey's trainer urging bets on Sharkey, fueling further fraud allegations.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
STILL LOUD CRIES OF FRAUD
jury," said Kowalski, last evening, "and I am confident we have enough evidence to sustain criminal indictments." A morning paper published the following: "Seattle, Dec. 4.—Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, has many friends in this city. To these he sent urgent telegrams just before the fight, saying: 'Bet all you have got on Sharkey to win,' and 'bet Sharkey to win' and 'Sharkey will win, bet on him, never quit,' and like expressions. Even before the fight began there was talk of 'fake' in this city."
A spectator describes attending the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout at Mechanics' Pavilion, recounting how Fitzsimmons dominated Sharkey through several rounds despite Sharkey repeatedly fouling him. The writer insists that on the final knockout blow, no foul by Fitzsimmons was visible, casting doubt on referee Wyatt Earp's decision to award the fight to Sharkey on a foul.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Finally the minor bouts were over and the prinicpals of the evening appeared in the ring. The tumult that greeted them was something deafening, and one seemed to have about as many friends as the other. When they shook hands there was a profound silence, and order from that time was the very best.
It was plain from the outset that Sharkey was much out-classed, although nothing startling occurred in the first round. In the second Fitz. went at his man, and from that time it was clearly only a matter of how long Sharkey could stand the punishment. He dodged or ducked it as best he could, and took it when he couldn't. He must have been made of iron to stand it as long as he did, for Fitz. landed about when and where he pleased and his blows fairly echoed in the rafters. The crowd cheered him heartily and several times gave vent to groans of disapproval when it was quite obvious Sharkey fouled him.
See moreSee less
✦ ✦ ✦
"Fitz. made no claims, though, and Referee Earp paid no attention, but allowed the fouls to go by. It, to say the least, semed as though he was determined to give Sharkey the best of it, and probably wouldn't have allowed a foul had Fitz. claimed it. However that may have been, Fitz clearly didn't want to win on a foul, preferring to knock his man out.
✦ ✦ ✦
"With each round, Sharkey's punishment became more severe, and all of our party expected to see him go out at any time. I can assure you I'm not surprised he is not in bed and won't be out if he stays there a month.
Finally the end came. Fitz. swung his terrific right and followed it with a left jab on the chin; that put an end to Sharkey's punishment and the power to think for the time being. When Fitz. struck his final blow he stepped back as though he knew it was all over, and there was no appearance of his raising his knee or in any way touching Sharkey after that blow on the chin. Of course one gets excited at such times, but still we all observed plainly enough the last blow and Fitzsimmons' step back, and I can see no reason why we should not have seen it if he had shoved his knee into Sharkey's groin, as the referee claimed he did. The men were sidewise to us, and we were so close that there was no reason why we should not be able to see as well as the referee.
An eyewitness account describes the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, stating that Fitzsimmons's final blow was a clean knockout punch with no foul. The witness, positioned close to the action, insists no one in the crowd besides Earp saw any foul, suggesting Earp's decision favored Sharkey unfairly.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
able to see as well as the referee.
"There was a great demonstration when Sharkey went out and a greater one a moment later when the referee announced his decision. No one in the great crowd of spectators had seen anything like a foul on Fitzsimmons' part, and you may imagine how they hissed and howled. It actually looked for a moment as though they would do violence to Earp. It was a terrific mill and ought to have been given to Fitz. in my judgment. If there was such a foul as Earp claims, it seems singular to me that no one besides himself out of that great crowd of people, saw it. I have neither seen or heard mention of anyone who was present who saw it besides him."
See moreSee less
The Della Fox Opera company arrived yesterday from San Francisco and put up at the various hotels. The Knutsford and Templeton got the principals and the White house the chorus.
This report covers the aftermath of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight scandal, focusing on the disputed $10,000 check that passed from Wyatt Earp to Danny Lynch. Creditors are trying to seize the check, but both Earp and Lynch claim ignorance of its whereabouts, with conflicting stories about who ordered it handed off for safekeeping.
The San Francisco Call · 7 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
"LONG GREEN" IS SQUIRMING
May Take It Up.
The evidence inculpating a select circle in the fraud perpetrated recently when Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey fought in the Pavilion is narrowing down to the half dozen mainstays who are responsible for the scandal that has been bruited throughout the world, aud that must necessarily be a serious setback to square pugilistic sport on this coast.
See moreSee less
The civil courts are first to take up the matter in connection with the rightful ownership of the $10,000 check. This bit of paper was handed over to Wyatt Earp by James G. Chesley, on the evening of the contest, and from that repository it passed into the hands of Sharkey's alter ego, Danny Lynch.
A dispute has erupted over a missing $10,000 check from the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, with Earp, Lynch, and Sharkey giving contradictory accounts of who held the money. Fitzsimmons' camp, led by attorney Kowalsky, vows to pursue both a civil suit for the money and criminal conspiracy charges, while the piece also recounts public suspicion over why gunslinger Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee.
The San Francisco Call · 7 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
jury is concerned. But it is not so with Sharkey and Lynch, who have each sworn to contradictory statements, which will be brought up later in the criminal proceedings that are to be instituted.
The criminal prosecution is to follow the civil suit. Robert Fitzsimmons, Martin Julian and their attorney, H. I. Kowalsky, declare positively that there is nothing that will stop them from prosecuting every individual implicated in the conspiracy to not only rob Fitzsimmons but the public.
See moreSee less
Colonel Kowalsky declared positively last night that he had enough evidence on hand at that time to send a half-dozen men to jail.
"We will take this affair in natural sequence," he said; "first we will get the $10,000 belonging to us. The other side has ten days in which to answer. That will give them enough rope with which to hang themselves, and then we will take up the conspiracy matter."
One of the points that will be shown as indicative of fraud is the terrific jump in the betting from $100 to $30 on Fitzsimmons to $100 to $65 within a few hours after it was known that Wyatt Earp was selected as referee.
The selection of Earp as a referee has already caused great comment, and not until recently has it come to light why he was chosen.
His past mode of making a livelihood by the use of his "gun" has been told. He has been a man who has shot down people innumerable, wiped the smoke from off the barrel of his shotgun and cut another notch in the butt, and said "What a great man am I."
The public would have preferred to have Hiram Cook or Lem Fulda as referee, as honesty and fairness was all that was needed to properly fulfill the duties of the office. But it was not so with those who were interested in the outcome of a fight in which the public must get the "worst of it."
"Long Green" Lawrence wanted Earp as a referee and he put him there. Every
This report presents the National Athletic Club's statement denying The Call's earlier article that claimed Wyatt Earp was appointed referee at the instance of Examiner editor Andy Lawrence. The piece reproduces both The Call's original accusatory language about 'Long Green' Lawrence and the Club's formal denial, setting up competing versions of how Earp came to referee the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
The San Francisco Call · 7 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
THE CLUB'S STATEMENT
Lee had been permitted to do his bidding, will testify that Sharkey's injuries might have been caused by many different methods any schemer might adopt to earn $10,000.
Anyhow, "Long Green" Lawrence, managing editor of the Examiner, his body guard, Wyatt Earp, Danny Lynch, Sharkey, Groom and Gibbs will have a happy time explaining themselves out of the mess into which they have got themselves.
The National Athletic Club issued a statement defending its conduct after Fitzsimmons claimed referee Wyatt Earp robbed him of victory over Sharkey. The club says it had doctors examine Sharkey, stopped payment on the prize check, and is awaiting the outcome of a judicial inquiry.
The Herald · 7 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THE OLYMPIC ATHLETICS
the News from Aspen, Col., says: D. W. Brunton, a well-known mining engineer, who has just returned from
has accepted the proposition, which will now be laid before Fitzsimmons.
See moreSee less
The directors of the National Athletic club sent the following statemtn today to the Associated Press, explaining the club's position relative to the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest:
To protect the good name of the club and as a matter of justice to the public, we have left nothing undone to determine the correctness of the claim made by Fitzsimmons that Referee Earp had robbed him of the decision over Sharkey. A committee of six physicians, two of
After Earp's controversial refereeing decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight sparked outrage, the press revisited his reputation as an alleged outlaw from Tombstone, Arizona. The article reprints Alfred Henry Lewis's account describing the Earp brothers as gunmen who terrorized the Tombstone community in the early 1880s.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indianapolis Journal · 7 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP'S RECORD, BOLD STAGE ROBBER AND BAD MAN GENERALLY FROM ARIZONA
Whom Were Notorious for Having Killed Their Men.
NEW YORK, Dec. 6.—The decision which gave Tom Sharkey a victory over Bob Fitzsimmons in California, on Wednesday night, has made Wyatt Earp, who acted as referee, the most talked-of man in the country. That the decision was wrong the majority of the spectators agree, and on the face of it there must have been a motive to induce Earp to see a foul committed by Fitzsimmons, which others could not see, and at the same time overlook many fouls by Sharkey, which all agree did occur. There was much money bet on the result of the fight, and the odds on Sharkey strengthened when it was known that Earp would act as referee. Earp's past record is not one for an honest man to be proud of, if the following from Washington, D. C., written by Alfred Henry Lewis for the New York Journal, is correct:
See moreSee less
"In the early eighties," says Mr. Lewis, "I was a neighbor of the Earp family. They abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence. Wyatt Earp is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented a front to that household made up in the main of Winchesters and Colt six-shooters. The Earps construed this into a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented it by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever. They migrated from the Gunnison country, They were subsequently run out of the Gunnison and Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to California, where Wyatt the other night refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
"The four Earps were named, respectively, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as novelists say, more anon. Virgil was the oldest Earp, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the most foolhardy, Julian the bravest and Jessie the most loving. As a result, Wyatt and Virgil lived to get out of Tombstone and the Gunnison in advance of public opinion and the bullets that expressed it, while Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison by Ike Clauton, who had married his sister Jessie, and whom Wyatt and Virgil subsequently killed at Corocco—and Jessie, the loving one, wedded Ike Clauton, with whom her four brothers had a blood feud at the time.
"Wyatt Earp—and, for that matter, all the Earps—were gun fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited with ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in 1881 and 1882; and, eschewing the intervention of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as 'fanning' their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.
Writing in the New York Journal, Alfred Henry Lewis offers a lurid, largely fabricated history of the Earp brothers in Tombstone and the Gunnison country, claiming Wyatt had killed ten men and that a fictional brother-in-law feud led to multiple deaths. The piece appears amid coverage of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, used to cast doubt on Earp's fitness as referee.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indianapolis Journal · 7 December 1896 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
GENERALLY FROM ARIZONA.
Whom Were Notorious for Having Killed Their Men.
NEW YORK, Dec. 6.—The decision which gave Tom Sharkey a victory over Bob Fitzsimmons in California, on Wednesday night, has made Wyatt Earp, who acted as referee, the most talked-of man in the country. That the decision was wrong the majority of the spectators agree, and on the face of it there must have been a motive to induce Earp to see a foul committed by Fitzsimmons, which others could not see, and at the same time overlook many fouls by Sharkey, which all agree did occur. There was much money bet on the result of the fight, and the odds on Sharkey strengthened when it was known that Earp would act as referee. Earp's past record is not one for an honest man to be proud of, if the following from Washington, D. C., written by Alfred Henry Lewis for the New York Journal, is correct:
See moreSee less
"In the early eighties," says Mr. Lewis, "I was a neighbor of the Earp family. They abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence. Wyatt Earp is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented a front to that household made up in the main of Winchesters and Colt six-shooters. The Earps construed this into a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented it by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever. They migrated from the Gunnison country, They were subsequently run out of the Gunnison and Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to California, where Wyatt the other night refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.
"The four Earps were named, respectively, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as novelists say, more anon. Virgil was the oldest Earp, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the most foolhardy, Julian the bravest and Jessie the most loving. As a result, Wyatt and Virgil lived to get out of Tombstone and the Gunnison in advance of public opinion and the bullets that expressed it, while Warren was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison by Ike Clauton, who had married his sister Jessie, and whom Wyatt and Virgil subsequently killed at Corocco—and Jessie, the loving one, wedded Ike Clauton, with whom her four brothers had a blood feud at the time.
"Wyatt Earp—and, for that matter, all the Earps—were gun fighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp himself is credited with ten men; one his own brother-in-law, Clauton. Every one of the Earps had killed his men—not man—and were famed in Tombstone and in the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They had all filed the sights from their six-shooters when I knew them in 1881 and 1882; and, eschewing the intervention of a trigger, were prone to that prowess known as 'fanning' their pistols in a fight, whereby a Colt's six-shooter becomes for the nonce a miniature Gatling.
The report says excitement over Wyatt Earp's disputed decision in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight is subsiding, though critics maintain he was unjust while supporters cite medical opinion backing a foul claim. It also notes Sharkey remains bedridden, Fitzsimmons' hands are healing, and rumors of a monetary compromise between the camps are denied.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 7 December 1896 · page 2
CALMINC DOWN. | Excitement @ver Fitz-Sharkey Fight Rap idly Subsiding. San Francisce, Dec. 6.—The storm that the contest between Sharkey and Fitz simmons raised is rapidly subsiding. ! Those who insist that Earp rendered an unjust decision are no less emphatie in their assertions than they were on the day after the fight, but have nothing new to add te the stery of fraud. Those whe claim that the sailor was fouled, stand by their first position, which has been strengthened by"the opinion of the con sulting physicians and the decision of the bookmakers.
See moreSee less
Sharkey is still con fined to his bed, and will not be allowed to leave his room until Wedaesday, at the earliest. 5 Fitzsimmons’ hands are considerably better, and have almost reached their normal size. His future plans will de pend, in & great measure, on the out come of the present legal controversy, though he will net stey in California lenger than a few weeks before going to New Yerk. Stuart has wired him again, asking him to name the exact date when he would leave for the east. The Australism wired back that'he would be | unable to give & reply for another week at least. A story that Sharkey is willing to compromise with Fitzsimmons has gained eurrency, although it has no
Fitzsimmons recovers from the fight while rumors swirl about a possible compromise with Sharkey over the disputed purse. Bookmakers have now begun paying out bets, accepting referee Earp's decision as final.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 7 December 1896 · page 2
CALMING DOWN
Madison, Wis., Dec. 6.—lt iz said that gt the meeting of the Association of ColJege Presidents of the middle western states, to be held in this city Dec. 14, a _proposition will be made to entirely abol %b.n from the list of college sports, foundation in tao‘:. It was repmonhdi that agents of saflor were willing to give Fitzsimmons "SOOO out of the purse. ‘ This is vigorously dé¢nied by Sharkey and Lynch, who insist that they will
The Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I. · and 2 other papers
A club-appointed committee of six physicians examined Sharkey and confirmed he had been injured, supporting Fitzsimmons' claim about the groin blow. The $10,000 check payment was stopped pending judicial inquiry into whether fraud was committed in the controversial decision.
The Evening Tribune · 7 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CORBETT AND FITZ.
They May Soon Meet Before the Olympic Club at 'Frisco.
See moreSee less
San Francisco, Dec. 7.—There is a prospect that Corbett and Fitzsimmons may be brought together in this city in a 10-round contest. The Olympic Athletic club, one of the oldest and most influential institutions of the city, has offered the men $15,000 to fight 10 rounds under its management. Corbett has accepted the proposition, which will now be laid before Fitzsimmons.
The directors of the National Athletic club sent the following statement yesterday to the press, explaining the club's position relative to the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest:
"To protect the good name of the club, and as a matter of justice to the public, we left nothing undone to determine the correctness of the claim made by Fitzsimmons that Referee Earp had robbed him of the decision over Sharkey. A committee of six physicians, two of whom were designated by the morning papers, examined Sharkey, and concurred in saying that he had been injured.
Apart from the medical examination ordered by the club, the precaution was taken to stop payment of the check for $10,000, so that if fraud had been perpetrated by anybody upon the club and the public an investigation should reveal the same and the guilty party be brought to justice. The matter is now in the hands of the court, and the club is awaiting anxiously the result of the judicial inquiry."
The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 7 December 1896
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va. · 7 December 1896
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · and 1 other paper
Former Wichita police colleagues, including Dick Cogdell, defend Wyatt Earp's character following scrutiny over his role as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. They recall his fearless and humorless demeanor as a lawman in Wichita and Ellsworth, Kansas, affirming he is honest and would rule according to his convictions.
The Madison Daily Leader · 7 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Testimony of Old Associates of the Much Discussed Referee.
WICHITA, Kan., Dec. 5.—In 1875, Wyatt Earp, the referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight was a policeman in Wichita under the notorious chief of police, Mike Meagher. Dick Cogdell, who succeeded Mike Meagher as chief, says:
See moreSee less
"Earp is a man who never smiled or laughed. He was the most fearless man I ever saw. He was marshal at Ellsworth, Kan., when that was a cattle shipping point, and he was a success. He is an honest man."
All officers here who were associated with him declare that he is an honest man and would have decided according to his belief in the face of an arsenal.
Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill. · 10 December 1896
The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
Referee Wyatt Earp defends his decision that Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey, insisting he clearly saw an illegal low blow. Fitzsimmons denies fouling Sharkey and claims he could have won outright, while Sharkey insists Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled him to avoid being knocked out.
The Daily Herald · 7 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
mons fight caused an indignant demonstration from the crowd at the ring side last night, stated this morning that when he decided the contest in favor of Sharkey he did so because he believed Fitzsimmons de-
Had he not delivered that nasty blow which crippled me I would certainly have finished him in that round, the eighth, I believe it was. I am sorry the question of supremacy has not been settled on its merits rather than in this way. I can beat Fitzsimmons, and I would rather have knocked him out
Referee Wyatt Earp explains his controversial decision awarding the fight to Sharkey after Fitzsimmons allegedly fouled him with a low blow in the eighth round. Earp describes the blow sequence and defends his honor against the crowd's indignant reaction.
The Daily Herald · 7 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
EARP, FITZ AND SHARKEY
house which Miss Gleason and Mrs. Zeelie occupy was looted and the servant in charge doubtless lost her life. Men wearing uniforms headed the mob which attacked the house and pulled
reveal only very narrow vests consisting of yellow guipure with a pattern in gold on it hanging loose over cream satin. The cuff is sit up to reveal soft frillings of cream
See moreSee less
fact that there are nine hatches, twelve steam winches and four steam cranes to be used for loading and unloading cargo. The machinery is said to
stated this morning that when he decided the contest in favor of Sharkey he did so because he believed Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled him and under
Referee Wyatt Earp insists he clearly saw Fitzsimmons deliver a foul blow to Sharkey's groin, defending his integrity against accusations of dishonesty. Fitzsimmons claims he hit Sharkey fairly in the stomach and that Sharkey faked the foul to avoid a loss, while Sharkey insists Fitzsimmons deliberately fouled him to escape defeat.
The Daily Herald · 7 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
FITZSIMMONS AND SHARKEY
house which Miss Gleason and Mrs. Zeelie occupy was looted and the servant in charge doubtless lost her life. Men wearing uniforms headed the mob which attacked the house and pulled
reveal only very narrow vests consisting of yellow guipure with a pattern in gold on it hanging loose over cream satin. The cuff is slit up to reveal soft frillings of cream [illegible]
See moreSee less
fact that there are nine hatches, twelve steam winches and four steam cranes to be used for loading and unloading cargo. The [illegible] machinery is said to [illegible]
contest. In the fourth round, I think it was, Fitzsimmons landed a left handed blow and returned with his elbow, cutting Sharkey's eyebrow open. The sailor should have had the fight then. The foul blow in the eighth was seen plainly by me. Fitzsimmons smashed with his right on Sharkey's should, and then with an uppercut with left he struck the sailor below the belt. Sharkey was leaning over, and the blow knocked him down. It was clearly a foul, and before the sailor moved I mentioned that the fight was over. The first blow was on the neck, and I believe the second was intended for an uppercut but it struck foul. No man until now has ever questioned my honor. I have been in many places and in peculiar situations, but no one ever said until last night that I was guilty of a dishonorable act, and I will repeat that I decided in all fairness and with a judgement that was as true as my eyesight. I saw the foul blow."
Fitzsimmous said after the fight: "Earp knows, and so does Sharkey, that I did not hit the sailor where they say I did. My left hand landed straight in his stomach where I had a right to hit him and no other place. His lying down and groaning was all part of the game. There was no need for me to foul him, because I had him whipped anyway and could have finished him before the end of the round. As I telegraphed Dan Stuart last night, I am willing to meet both Sharkey and Corbett in the same ring any night. Stuart wants to pull the fight off. I will say one thing for Corbett, and that is that I don't blame him for saying that he was robbed out of the Jackson fight in this town. No pugilist can get a square deal from the thieves who handle fighting in this city, and it is safe to bet that the last fight San Francisco will ever see was pulled off last night."
Sharkey had this to say of the affair: "I am certain Fitzsimmons fouled me deliberately to save himself from defeat. It was getting too plain to him that I was gaining in strength while he was going down hil', so to speak, and, rather than be knocked out, he thought best to lose the fight on a foul. Had he not delivered that nasty blow which crippled me I would certainly have finished him in that round, the eighth, I believe it was. I am sorry the question of supremacy has not been settled on its merits rather than in this way. I can beat Fitzsimmons, and I would rather have knocked him out than win the purse on a foul. I dont think he will be anxious to meet me again, however. But if he does, well, I am open to all engagements. I am in the boxing business as a profession. I intend to win the world's championship if the decision in this contest has not already given me the right to that title. I am not going to
The passage is a scathing editorial attacking the San Francisco Examiner under Hearst, accusing it of shamelessness and noting it employs Wyatt Earp for 'pistol protection.' It compares the paper's self-published denunciations to a degraded woman boasting of her vices.
The San Francisco Call · 8 December 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
THE LOWEST DEEP OF SHAME.
Dean Swift once declared that he heard a woman of the London slums assert in a quarrel with another: "I admit that I am a bawd, a liar, a blackmailer, a thief, a drunkard and a dirty wench; but otherwise I am as good a lady as anybody." This story sounds incredible, but it has just received in this City a striking example of its probability. The San Francisco Examiner, under the ownership of "Willie" Hearst, the editorial management of "Long Green" Lawrence, and the pistol protection of Wyatt Earp, has made a declara
The report claims Wyatt Earp's selection as referee for the prize-fight was secretly arranged days in advance by a group of conspirators, contradicting public statements by Gibbs and Groom. It accuses an Examiner editor, 'Long Green' Lawrence, of being behind the scheme, likening it to an earlier blackmail attempt in Sacramento.
The San Francisco Call · 8 December 1896 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image
16 MORE FACTS OF THE FAKE
Man Who Procured the Selection of Wyatt Earp.
ts Made by Gibbs and Groom Flatly Contradicted by Simpson and Bunker—Earp's Appointment Was Privately
Newspaper editors trade accusations over who was responsible for selecting Wyatt Earp as referee for the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, with Chronicle editor Simpson denying claims he endorsed Earp. Blame shifts to Mr. Bunker of the Report, who is in seclusion after an accident and unavailable for comment.
The San Francisco Call · 8 December 1896 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
in some baseball deal, but they got on to his curves. Danny Needham figured in a fight here two years ago and was' knocked out by Boston Smith. When Danny went the next day to the bank to collect a $3000 check payment was withheld. He had got the double cross. Long Green Lawrence, Gunfighter Earp, Arizona Staple Lynch and Danny Needham are birds of a similar feather. It is expected that they will fly together in the spring to more congenial climes. In their statement, by typewriter in the Examiner editorial-rooms, and presented for publication to The Call, according to orders received from Lawrence, J.
See moreSee less
J. Groom and J. D. Gibbs, mentioned that City Editor Simpson of the Chronicle had recommended the selection of Wyatt Earp as referee for the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight. Last evening Mr. Simpson, who had returned from the country, reiterated the statement made by his representative, Fred Stowell, the night before, to the effect that both Gibbs and Groom were consummate liars. "I never interceded in behalf of Wyatt Earp as a referee or took part in any other way. The fellow is almost an unknown to me, excepting that I have read of him in the papers. I once met him, when we were introduced by Lieutenant Esola. That was simply a passing affair, which never would have lasted in my mind but for this false statement made by Gibbs and Groom. "Whether Mr. Bunker of the Report had anything to do with selecting Wyatt Earp as referee I do not know, nor do I know whether Mr. Lawrence of the Examiner had anything to do with it. But what I do know is that the use of my name or that of the Chronicle by Gibbs and Groom in this affair was unwarranted, misleading and positively false." This prop falling from under the pretty story concocted by "Long Green" Lawrence, J. D. Gibbs and J. J. Groom left Mr. Bunker of the Report to bear the brunt of public indignation against the people who had anything to do with the naming of Wyatt Earp as referee of the fight. Mr. Bunker met with a slight accident a few days ago and has been in seclusion at his home in the Bella Vista Hotel. He could not be seen yesterday, but his sentiments were voiced at his newspaper office by his city editor, Sutherland. They were not ready to speak for Mr. Bunker, but they told their impression of what had occurred. Some time before the fight Gibbs informed Mr. Bunker that Wyatt Earp would be selected referee. This information was given prior to the time that the two principals had endeavored to come to an understanding. Mr. Bunker, with a journalistic idea of being first in publishing the news and all that goes with it, immediately sent out to ON THE ROAD TO ARIZONA! FAKE JOURNALISM CRIME FILTH SCANDAL SENSATION OR ANY OLD THING TO INCREASE THE CIRCULATION "FOUL" EARP "LONG GREEN" LAWRENCE P. CO $P 30000 30000 30000 30000 $P OF THE FAKE t in the Breach as the ed the Selection Earp. m Flatly Contradicted by Editors ppointment Was Privately Before the Fight. acancy caused by the emigration of Mr. Hawley, that of "publisher." It would be as forcible a way of telling the public that Lawrence was authorized to collect cash in advance for the indorsement or the silence of the Monarch of the Fakers was his promotion from the ranks of in some baseball deal, but they got on to his curves. Danny Needham figured in a fight here two years ago and was knocked out by Boston Smith. When Danny went the next day to the bank to collect a $3000 check payment was withheld. He had got the double cross. Long Green Lawrence, Gunfighter Earp, Arizona Staple Lynch and Danny Need ham are birds of a similar feather. It is expected that they will fly together in the spring to more congenial climes. In their statement, by typewriter in the Examiner editorial-rooms, and presented for publication to THE CALL, according to orders received from Lawrence, J. J. Groom and J. D. Gibbs, mentioned that City Editor Simpson of the Chronicle had recommended the selection of Wyatt Earp as referee for the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight. Last evening Mr. Simpson, who had re turned from the country, reiterated the statement made by his representative, Fred Stowell, the night before, to the effect that both Gibbs and Groom were consum mate liars. "I never interceded in behalf of Wyatt Earp as a referee or took part in any other way. The fellow is almost an unknown to me, excepting that I have read of him in the papers. I once met him, when we were secure a photograph of Earp for reproduc tion in his paper. Further than this Mr. Bunker had noth ing to do with the selecting or imposing of Wyatt Earp on the fighters, the club or the public as a referee. But, this very point, coming out of the Report's end of this business, is probably one of the strongest that can be brought to prove collusion, fraud and the etceteras that go to make up the unhappy mixture. Gibbs was supposed to not decide upon any referee until Julian and Lynch re tired from the field at noon on Wednes day. Still, Gibbs was sure enough of his ground to name the man to the Report a day or more in advance. As neither City Editor Simpson of the Chronicle nor Editor Bunker of the Re port have had anything to do with the naming of the referee, then but Long Green Lawrence remains. Strengthening his position in this matter, the manager of the Examiner has held Gibbs and Groom up and forced them into formulating a statement for publica tion in THE CALL, exculpating him from blame. That statement has been shown as a lie from start to finish. The two gentlemen, Mr. Simpson and Mr. Bunker, who are mentioned in the document, have had no need to send emissaries around to show their position and honesty. It has been reported that Hearst has heard a good deal about the connection o[f] me, excepting that I have read of him in the papers. I once met him, when we were introduced by Lieutenant Esola. That was simply a passing affair, which never would have lasted in my mind but for this false statement made by Gibbs and Groom. "Whether Mr. Bunker of the Report had anything to do with selecting Wyatt Earp as referee I do not know, nor do I know whether Mr. Lawrence of the Examiner had anything to do with it. But what I do know is that the use of my name or that of the Chronicle by Gibbs and Groom in this affair was unwarranted, misleading and positively false." This prop falling from under the pretty story concocted by "Long Green" Lawrence, J. D. Gibbs and J. J. Groom left Mr. Bunker of the Report to bear the brunt of public indignation against the people who had anything to do with the naming of Wyatt Earp as referee of the fight. Mr. Bunker met with a slight accident a few days ago and has been in seclusion at his home in the Bella Vista Hotel. He could not be seen yesterday, but his sentiments were voiced at his newspaper office by his city editor, Sutherland. They were not ready to speak for Mr. Bunker, but they told their impression of what had occurred. Some time before the fight Gibbs informed Mr. Bunker that Wyatt Earp would be selected referee. This information was given prior to the time that the two principals had endeavored to come to an understanding. Mr. Bunker, with a journalistic idea of being first in publishing the news and all that goes with it, immediately sent out to It has been reported that Hearst has heard a good deal about the connection of his hirelings with the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fiasco, and that he has sent word to have the whole disgraceful affair thoroughly investigated. EARP ATTACHED. He Guaranteed the Attorney's Fees of Bunko-Steerers. Wyatt Earp, who gave the decision that robbed Bob Fitzsimmons of $10,000, was attached yesterday, a Sheriff's deputy taking possession of a couple of race horses that Earp claims are his. The claim is for $170 45 and is that of J. G. Swinnerton of Stockton, one of the best-known attorneys in the State. About a year ago three notorious confidence men—"Crooked Mouth" Green, Smith and Brown—swindled Farmer Brack of Lodi out of $2000 on the gold-brick scheme. While they were in jail at Stockton, after being held in $30,000 bonds, Wyatt Earp, the Examiner's special writer, appeared on the scene and showed his friendship for the men by making efforts to get them released. He engaged Judge Swinnerton to defend the bunko-steerers, guaranteeing the attorney's fee. When the men had been let off with exceedingly light sentences, considering the gravity of their crime, Earp disappeared and Judge Swinnerton never saw his money. He has long waited for a chance to tie Earp up, and the opportunity is now
Lawyers for Fitzsimmons and Sharkey sparred lightly ahead of a court battle before Judge Lorezinger, part of the fallout from their recent prizefight. Referee Wyatt Earp has been drawn into the legal dispute via a garnishment for $175 in attorney's fees owed by friends of Earp's.
The Evening Times · 8 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
the judicial maelstrom by a garnishment issued at the instance of Judge Swinnerton of Stockton, who claims $175 attorney's fees for services rendered certain of Earp's friends, and for which the noted duellist agreed to pay.
Sharkey received a cablegram yesterday from his father, stating that a report was current in the sailor's home that he was dead. This seemed to annoy Tom consid-
The Evening Times · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
A gambler named Al Smith refuses to collect bets won on Sharkey, saying Wyatt Earp's refereeing decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight appeared to be a prearranged affair. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated boxing match news and challenges.
The Evening Times · 8 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
either Benny Leon, Sammy Meyers or Otto Zimpfer, of Buffalo.
Al Smith has refused to accept wagers due to him on Wyatt Earp's decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest. Smith bet heavily on Sharkey, but he says he cannot take his friends' money on what appears to have been a prearranged affair.
See moreSee less
Kid McPartland and Owen Ziegler have been matched to box twenty rounds in New York on December 16. They are to weigh 135 pounds and the one who receives the decision will be matched to meet the winner of the Lavigne-McKeever bout.
Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · 14 December 1896
New York Journal · New York, N.Y.
The National Athletic Club reported that a committee of six physicians examined Tom Sharkey to verify Fitzsimmons' claim that referee Wyatt Earp had wrongly awarded Sharkey the decision. The club also halted payment of the $10,000 purse check pending the outcome, noting the matter was now before the courts.
New York Journal · 8 December 1896 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
DOCTORS EXAMINED SHARKEY. And They Say He Was Injured—The Case Now Goes Into Court. San Francisco, Dec. 7.—The directors of the National Athletic Club sent out the following statement yesterday, explaining
A brief editorial aside mocks Wyatt Earp, calling him 'the old Wichita policeman,' and sarcastically wishes he would be 'chained at once' for the peace of California, noting many have recently called him a liar. The remark is embedded in a column of miscellaneous political and social commentary.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 8 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
who have visited this country and fallen in love with it are now planning to give China a revolution and a constitution.
We hope for the peace and quiet of California that Wyatt Earp. the old Wichita policeman, will be chained at once. Too many men have called him a liar recently for the preservation of law and order.
See moreSee less
Revenue must be supplied, and the Dingley bill, which can supply it, appears to be doomed. It would be very unfortunate for the Republican party if it started out its four years with a bond issue.
The Oklahoma friend of Bryan who has gone crazy over his defeat should have calmed himself with the idea that two or three thousand fellows would have been after his job if Bryan had been elected.
Miss Fleck of Chicago has just been fined $10 on complaint of her neighbors that she keeps a rooster that crows every midnight. "The cock's shrill clarion no more" shall pull those people out of bed if they know it.
A satirical editorial squib mocks Wyatt Earp, referencing his reputation for violence in Arizona and Dodge City, in the context of his controversial refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match. It jokes that Earp mistakenly treated the fight like a gunfight, expecting no warning before a 'shot.'
El Paso Daily Herald · 8 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP has umpired plenty of killings in Arizona and Dodge City, but guns and not gloves were used in the fights. When the sailor went down Earp evidently imagined Fitz had
Referee Wyatt Earp, acting in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight dispute, was served with a garnishment in San Francisco for $175 in attorney's fees owed to Judge Swinnerton of Stockton. The fees were for legal services rendered to friends of Earp's, which he had reportedly agreed to pay.
The Salt Lake Herald · 8 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
REFEREE EARP SERVED WITH A GARNISHMENT
attorney's fees for services rendered certain of Earp's friends, and for which the noted duelist agred to pay.
Fitzsimmons spent the day quietly at Sausalito with his family.
See moreSee less
Sharkey received a cablegram from his father, stating that a report was
Martin Julian claims he has evidence that Referee Wyatt Earp, Sharkey's trainer Dannie Needham, backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club conspired against Fitzsimmons in their recent fight. He also dismisses talk of a rematch in San Francisco, saying New York clubs will offer bigger purses.
Arizona Republican · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
the powerful United States which will pacify Cuba.
JULIAN HAS EVIDENCE.
See moreSee less
Says that Earp and the Sharkey Crowd Were "in on the Play."
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated tonight that he had evi
Prompted by controversy over Wyatt Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, a Wichita newspaper recalls his earlier service as a fearless deputy under Marshal Mike Meagher in the 1870s. It describes him as a tall, cool-headed officer with a deadly aim and a reputation as a 'killer' during Wichita's rough cattle-town era.
Arizona Republican · 9 December 1896 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
He Was a "Killer" as an Officer, but Scrupulously Honest.
Wyatt Earp, who is accused by Bob Fitzsimmons and his friends with having refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight unfairly, is well known to the old timers in Wichita, says The Times of that place, having served as an officer under Marshal Mike Maegher, in the early '70's. Wichita at that time was the great cattle market for the southwest, and it required the utmost vigilance and bravery on the part of the officers to hold the lawless element in check. Earp was absolutely devoid of fear, and was one of the most active of Maegher's deputies. He was a tall, ministerial looking fellow, with a cool head and a deadly aim, and he had the reputation of being a "killer."
See moreSee less
Maegher afterwards became marshal of Dodge City and was killed in a fight with desperadoes.
When Dick Cogdell succeeded Maegher as marshal here in the spring of '76, Earp with his two brothers, went to Deadwood, Dak., and went on the marshal's force. They had numerous bloody encounters with the desperadoes who had, up to that time, terrorized the law-abiding citizens, and succeeded in killing off several of the most troublesome of them. Fifteen or twenty men were killed in one of these fights. Earp was strictly honorable in all his dealings with men here, and none knew him has a word to say against him. He went to Ellsworth subsequently to co-operate with the authorities in suppressing lawlessness in that town, and was elected marshal. Not much is known of him after he went out to Arizona. Dick Cogdell, ex-city marshal, says of him: "I never heard of him doing anything crooked in a business way. He was a fair, honest man and his record is good here."
Police Clerk John Martin, who was intimately acquainted with him, says: "Earp was just the kind of a man to referee a prize-fight, because all the bullies who ever gathered around a prize ring could not scare or bulldoze him; he was thoroughly honest."
Detective Bedford Wood, who knew Earp, said he never knew him to be charged with dishonesty before this prize-fight.
A brief notice reports that Wyatt Earp has been sued for $1,157.79 to collect on old notes he signed as a prize-fight referee in Tombstone, Arizona, dated October 29, 1881. The item appears amid a roundup of minor San Francisco legal and civic news.
The San Francisco Call · 9 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CITY NEWS IN BRIEF.
James M. Sharkey died on the 2d inst. and Mary S. Barry has applied to be appointed administratrix of the estate, which is valued at $1500.
Frank R. Laumeister, who escaped from the Napa Insane Asylum in May, 1894, was rearrested yesterday and is now in the Receiving Hospital.
See moreSee less
Miss Lillie Lindo, widow of Jacob Lindo, who died in this City August 30, 1895, has applied for letters of administration on her late husband's estate.
Wyatt Earp has been sued to collect $1157 79 on old notes signed by the Examiner's prize-fight referee in Tombstone, Ariz., October 29, 1881.
Wyatt Earp, acting as referee's associate in the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight controversy, testified in Justice Groezinger's court that he was poor and owned only the clothes on his back, claiming not to know where Sansome Street was despite living in San Francisco for years. Meanwhile boxer Sharkey fled to Vallejo with his manager amid ongoing litigation over the fight purse.
The San Francisco Call · 9 December 1896 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
SWEARS HE IS A POOR MAN
sporting circles. At present the skirmish line is in the
All Classes of Craft Are Repres[ented]
See moreSee less
courts, the stake-money is locked up by an injunction, and it looks now as though there will be but very little left of the $10,000 for Sharkey after Danny Needham, D J. Lynch, the lawyers, court judgments and training expenses are paid.
Sharkey was taken from his bed yesterday afternoon and went to Vallejo with his manager, Lynch. Just what this new movement indicates has not yet come to light, but it is suspected that they have received legal advice to the effect that it will be better for them to get out of the jurisdiction of the courts, in view of the present very active litigation on the subject of debts.
Earp appeared in Justice Groezinger's court yesterday afternoon and testified that he was poor and owned only the clothes on his back. Although having resided here for several years he swore that he did not know where Sansome street was. It was the opinion of many of the spectators that Long Green should take a day off and make Mr. Earp acquainted with the business part of the City.
The investigation into the alleged conspiracy to rob the betting public is being proceeded with very quietly. Detectivess have been working on the case, and it is reported that the evidence they have secured is overwhelming.
When Justice of the Peace Groezinger called the case of J. F. Carroll vs. Robert Fitzsimmons the courtroom was crowded with spectators. Wyatt Earp, who failed to appear at the former session of the court, was present and was the center of observation by the curious crowd.
Attorney Arthur E. Mack was in attendance to look after Sharkey's interests, while George Perry and Jacob Rauer represented the plaintiff. Mr. Rauer sat by Mr. Perry's side and suggested questions to him from time to time. Mr. Perry announced at the outset t[h]at he did not wish to push the contempt matter against "Long Green's" friend.
Earp was called to the stand, and in answer to a question by Justice Groezinger explained why he had failed to obey the subpena. He said the paper was handed to him by a deputy sheriff with whom he was not acquainted, and that having a nandful of correspondence at the time, he placed the subpena in his coat-pocket and forgot all about it. The witness was deferential to the court.
"There is no reason why I should disobey your orders in any way. I have been an officer for thirty years of my life, and for that reason I know what it means to disobey the court."
The court purged Earp of contempt and Mr. Perry proceeded to inquire ab[o]ut the
Martin Julian claims he has evidence of a conspiracy against Fitzsimmons in the recent fight, naming Referee Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club as conspirators. He also discusses prospects for a future Corbett-Fitzsimmons bout and purse negotiations.
The Herald · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ'S FIGHTS.
Julian Thinks He Can Show Conspiracy. The Corbett Mill.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated tonight that he had evidence which will prove a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Dannie Needham, Sharkey's trainer; Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club.
See moreSee less
Julian says it is idle to talk of a contest before the Olympic club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons, because New York clubs will offer larger purses for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If an unlimited contest cannot be arranged Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in a limited bout.
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C. · and 2 other papers
Referee Wyatt Earp testified in a San Francisco court hearing over the disputed $10,000 purse from the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, claiming he owned no money or property besides his clothes. He also pleaded not guilty to a concealed weapons charge after being disarmed of a large revolver before the fight.
The Morning Times · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
PRIZE FIGHTERS IN COURT
Referee Earp Testifies in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey Muddle.
See moreSee less
Stated That He Did Not Possess a Dollar in the World—Julian Still Claims Fraud.
San Francisco, Dec 8.—Bob Fitzsimmons, his manager, Martin Julian, Dan Lynch, representing Tom Sharkey, Wyatt Earp, who acted as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, and a number of others interested in the legal squabble for possession of the $10,000 purse-money, appeared in Justice Groezinger's court room this afternoon. Referee Earp was the only witness examined and he was not asked to explain how or when he consented to act as referee. He testified, however, that he did not possess a dollar in the world and that he owned no property save the clothing he wore. This admission created surprise, as the witness was popularly supposed to be a man of means. Cross-examination was reserved until Thursday.
Julian insists that he has abundant testimony to prove the existence of a huge piece of jobbery.
Although Sharkey was supposed to have suffered a relapse today, he was nevertheless well enough to change his quarters to Vallejo this evening, where he went in company with Lynch and Needham. The Fitzsimmons faction claims that the trio moved for the purpose of remaining beyond the jurisdiction of Justice Groezinger's court, but Lynch denies this.
Mr. Earp, who was relieved of a gigantic revolver by Capt. Whitman just prior to the call of "time" on the evening of the prize fight, pleaded not guilty today to the charge of carrying concealed weapons, and his case was continued.
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 9 December 1896
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 9 December 1896
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Martin Julian, manager for boxer Fitzsimmons, claims to have evidence of a conspiracy against his fighter in the recent bout, naming Referee Earp, Sharkey's trainer Dannie Needham, and backer Dan Lynch as conspirators. He also discusses the difficulty of arranging a future Corbett-Fitzsimmons contest due to purse negotiations between clubs.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
PLOT AGAINST "FITZ."
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 8.—Martin Julian stated to-night that he had evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Dannie Needham, Sharkey's trainer, and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National Club. Julian says it is idle to talk of a contest before the Olympic Club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons because the clubs in New York will offer larger purses for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If a limited contest cannot be arranged Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in a limited bout.
The article recounts Wyatt Earp's background as a police officer in Wichita and later as marshal in Ellsworth, Kansas, before his days in Arizona fighting outlaws with his brother. It frames him as an honorable man with a reputation for fearlessness, offered as context after he refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Barbour County Index · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
life lived at Newton, Kan.
Cravens, the wounded outlaw, has been for years the leader of a notorious gang of horse thieves and is charged with postoffice robbery and two murders.
See moreSee less
WYATT EARP AS A KANSAN
The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey Referee a Man "With a Record."
WICHITA, Kan., Dec. 5.—Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco, lived in this city when it was only a frontier cattle town and served with Mike Meagher on the police force. He was fearless and was a terror to evil doers. Afterwards he went out to Arizona and he and his brother ran a town there for a while and killed a lot of desperadoes which infested the place. Then he was sent for to come to Ellsworth, Kan., at a time when nerve was required in the police government and he was marshal there for some time. Every one here who knew him believes he is thoroughly honorable, and declares that if he thought Fitzsimmons fouled Sharkey he would so decide, regardless of public opinion.
A San Francisco paper reports that George Allen, one of Tom Sharkey's trainers, has confessed to a conspiracy that cheated Bob Fitzsimmons of victory in their fight. Allen's affidavit names Wyatt Earp, Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham as the plot's organizers, with an injunction hearing on the matter set for that day in court.
The Topeka State Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 3
trained Tom Sharkey for his fight with Dob Fitzsimmous, has made a confes sion to the effect that Fitzsininions weg deprived of his victory through a con spiracy. The trainer and the Sharkey manage ment have quarreled over money mat ters, it is said, and in the heat of the moment Allen made threats of what he would do if he was not paid for his services. A.ttorney Kowalsky, repre senting Fitzstmmons, heard of the cir cumstances and he employed private detectives to gather in the irate trainer. -He was run to ground yesterday and induced to tell the whole story.
See moreSee less
The Fitzsimmons-Sharkey injunction case will be called in Judge Sangerson's court this morning. It was down on the calendar for a hearing a day later, but the plaintiff's attorneys besought the court to take up the matter today, as they were afraid that the valuable testi mony in their possession might not keep. They have tio particular faith in their men and propose to take no chances. It is claimed that Allen in an affidavit named Wyatt Earp, Dan J. Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Xeedham as the prime movers in the plot. The whole scheme is said to have been hatched at Sharkey's training, quarters at Ocean Beach. It was arranged that Sharkey was to make it appear that he had been fouled at some point in the contest, when he was in danger of losing from Fitzsinimons' blows; further that the signal was to be given by Sharkey who was to bend over and place his hand on his groin, and at that moment Xeedhatn was to jump into the ring and claim a foul. Then the referee was to give a de cision in favor of Sharkey.
Martin Julian claims he has proof of a conspiracy involving Referee Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. He suggests the scheme favored Sharkey and discusses future bout plans for Fitzsimmons.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 December 1896 · page 2
called to meet In Pitssburg tomorrow. The object evidently is to patch up the differences which promise to disrupt the association. It was learned today that the company which broke away from the pool was the Bellaire, Ohio, Steel com pany. ACCUSES THE SHARKEY CROWD Slartln Jalian Claims to be Able to ProTe a Conspiracy. San Francisco, Cal., Dec. S. Martin paaoons oj 4uoSuiu,sba. uj XjisjaAjun complete which will prove that a con spiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitz-simmons-Sharkey fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Shar key's trainer; Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club.
See moreSee less
Julian, sjojsq S3juoo b jo jhc oi ajpp sp j s.ttrs the Olympic club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons because clubs in New York will offer larger purses for a limit ed contest than any club In a smaller city. If an unlimited contest cannot be arranged Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in an unlim ited bout Paris, Dec. S. Frederic Mistral has com pleted his translation of the Bible to the Provencal dialect.
Doctors examined Sharkey after his fight loss to Fitzsimmons and found a groin injury but no hernia, concluding he could not have continued fighting. Fitzsimmons filed suit alleging a conspiracy between Sharkey and the Athletic Club, and a judge granted an injunction blocking payment of the $10,000 purse pending trial.
The Ely Miner · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Tottanzi, examined Sharkey at 10:15 Thursday morning, the press representatives being present.
Sharkey was stripped and the doctor pointed to a huge swelling on the lower part of the body near the groin. There was discoloration in one spot, showing where the blow had landed. This, Sharkey said, was caused by Fitzsimmons hooking him with his elbow. Dr. Ragan explained the swelling was the same as in the ear, caused by extravasation, and would require leeches to subdue.
See moreSee less
There was no hernia and no other permanent injury, but the doctors were unanimous that Sharkey could never have entered the ring or stood on his feet had he been in his present condition. It will be several days before Sharkey can leave his bed.
Late Thursday afternoon Fitzsimmons, through his attorney, commenced suit in the superior court to restrain the Anglo-California bank from paying Sharkey the $10,000 purse. Fitzsimmons charges conspiracy between Sharkey, the National Athletic club and others. Fitzsimmons alleges that before Earp was selected as referee this agreement was made, and that had he known of it he would have refused to enter the ring. He therefore prays that as he "discomfited" Sharkey so that the latter was unable to proceed, and on account of the alleged conspiracy, the Anglo-California bank, Thomas Shark[ey].
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 10 December 1896
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · and 1 other paper
Wyatt Earp served as referee for the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in San Francisco, and after Fitzsimmons knocked out Sharkey in the eighth round, Earp ruled it a foul and awarded the fight to Sharkey. The crowd of 15,000-20,000 reacted with outrage, believing Fitzsimmons had been robbed, as no one witnessed the alleged foul.
The Ely Miner · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FITZSIMMONS LOSES.
Sharkey Knocked Out, But Gets Decision on a Claim of Foul.
See moreSee less
San Francisco, Dec. 3.—Fitzsimmons and Sharkey fought before the National Athletic club Wednesday night. There was much wrangling over the choice of a referee, but Fitzsimmons finally announced that he would accept Earp, the man chosen by the club. Fitzsimmons had the best of the fighting all the way through and on the eighth round knocked Sharkey out.
As Sharkey rolled over on his back, Earp, the referee, announced that Fitzsimmons had struck him foul with his knee, and that the decision should go to Sharkey. The decision was received with hoots and jeers, and Earp disappeared just in time to avoid rough handling. Fitzsimmons put up a clean, hard fight, and though he was fouled repeatedly and wrestled all over the ring he never murmured. The unanimous sentiment was that Fitzsimmons had been robbed in the most cold-blooded manner. No one in the audience saw the foul complained of, but all saw Sharkey strike the Australian in clinches and wrestle him all over the ring a score of times. The call of time saved the sailor at the end of four rounds, and the referee finally saved him in the ninth, after Fitzsimmons had laid him low with a couple of left hooks, both of which struck the jaw.
No event in the history of pugilism on the Pacific coast ever attracted so much public attention. Between 15,000 and 20,000 people occupied all the available space in the big Mechanics' pavilion and watched the contest, which everyone regarded as practically deciding the championship of the world. Both men had trained hard and well for the contest, and particularly during the last few days, and each had expressed the utmost confidence in his ability to gain a victory and the $10,000 purse which the National Athletic club offered the victor.
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 10 December 1896
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn.
After losing the fight on a foul decision by referee Wyatt Earp, Fitzsimmons' attorney filed suit alleging a conspiracy among Sharkey, the National Athletic Club, and others involving Earp's selection as referee, seeking to block payment of the $10,000 purse. A judge granted the injunction, while Corbett publicly sided with Sharkey and offered to fight him.
The Ely Miner · 9 December 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
account of the alleged conspiracy, the Anglo-California bank, Thomas Sharkey, Daniel Lynch, John Doe and Richard Roe be enjoined from collecting the money on the certificate of deposit, and that the court award said certificate to Fitzsimmons. Judge Sanderson granted the injunction prayed for and the case will soon be tried.
New York, Dec. 4.—Champion James J. Corbett, when he heard the result of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, sent the following telegram to the winner:
See moreSee less
"Tom Sharkey, San Francisco, Cal.: Am very sorry at Mr. Fitzsimmons' foul tactics in his contest with you, which prevented your getting a decision over him in a full ten-round contest without a foul. I am ready to meet you on or before January 1, 1897. JAMES J. CORBETT."
A humor column jab notes that Wyatt Earp once lived in Wellington, Wichita, and Dodge City, implying that explains local troublemaking or wildness. It's presented as a tongue-in-cheek aside amid other satirical local items.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
KANSAS TOPICS.
"There was a man named Riordan," says the Wichita Eagle, "who never recovered sufficiently to claim a foul on Fitzsimmons. Mr. Sharkey is in luck."
George Parker, of Gaylord, who appears to know more about secret societies than politics, has filed his application with Gov-
A San Francisco report says George Allen, who trained Sharkey, swore an affidavit claiming Wyatt Earp conspired with Sharkey, Dan Lynch, and Dan Needham to fake a foul so Sharkey would win over Fitzsimmons. The scheme allegedly involved Sharkey pretending to be fouled and Needham signaling the referee to award him the fight.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., Dec. 9.—A morning paper publishes the statement that George Allen, one of the men who trained Tom Sharkey for the Fitzsimmons fight, has made a confession to the effect that Fitzsimmons was deprived of victory by a conspiracy in which Wyatt Earp, Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey and Dan Needham were the prime movers. The whole scheme was hatched at Sharkey's training quarters. It was arranged that Sharkey was to appear as though he had been fouled at some time when in danger of losing, and at a signal Needham was to jump into the ring and claim the foul. The referee was then to give the decision to Sharkey.
Fitzsimmons' legal representative filed suit against Tom Sharkey to recover $10,000 allegedly withheld through a conspiracy involving Sharkey, Earp, and Lynch. The suit aims to force testimony from witnesses before they become unavailable, settling the controversy over the fight's outcome.
The Jersey City News · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FITZ SUES SHARKEY. The Pugilist Wants the $10,000, Out of Which He Says He Was Swindled SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9, 1896.—Col. H. I. Kowliski, the legal representative of Bob Fitzsimmons, brought suit yes-
The piece defends Wyatt Earp's refereeing decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight, asserting his reputation for fairness despite his history as a 'bad man' with a gun. It cites his quiet, respectable conduct running a saloon in Coeur d'Alene as evidence he would not give an unfair ruling.
The Dalles Daily Chronicle · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EARP'S DECISION.
Wyatt Earp has come suddenly into prominence on account of his decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight. We know nothing about the fight, but we know Wyatt Earp, and therefore believe implicitly that his decision in that contest was cor-
The Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I. · and 3 other papers
Martin Julian claims he has evidence that Referee Wyatt Earp, Sharkey's trainer Danny Needham, Sharkey's backer Dan Lynch, and the National Club conspired against Fitzsimmons in their recent fight. Julian also discusses prospects for a future Corbett-Fitzsimmons bout.
The Evening Tribune · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
There Was a Conspiracy.
San Francisco, Dec. 9.—Martin Julian stated last night that he had evidence complete which will prove that a conspiracy was planned and operated against Fitzsimmons in the recent Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Julian says that the parties to the conspiracy were Referee Earp, Danny Needham, Sharkey's trainer, and Dan Lynch, Sharkey's backer, and the National club. Julian says it is idle to talk of a contest before the Olympic club here between Corbett and Fitzsimmons, because clubs in New York will offer larger purses for a limited contest than any club in a smaller city. If an unlimited contest cannot be arranged, Fitzsimmons wants to fight for the largest available purse in a limited bout.
See moreSee less
Caged From the Spot.
Hackett, the Pawtucket boy, is making a fine showing with Augusta.
A year ago New Bedford led, followed closely by Pawtucket and Providence.
The Tigers meet the Whalers at the Auditorium this evening. Nuf ced.
The Witches will cross shinnies with the Fall Rivers tonight at the latter rink.
New Bedford is the only club that has not lost a game in its own rink, and the task is anything but an easy one.
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 9 December 1896
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb. · 11 December 1896
The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa. · 11 December 1896
The Providence News · Providence, R.I.
Wyatt Earp pleaded not guilty to carrying a concealed weapon and testified in Fitzsimmons' lawsuit to recover a $10,000 check held by Sharkey, denying any conspiracy to defraud Fitzsimmons. The report also describes an affidavit naming Earp, Dan Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham as plotters in an alleged scheme to fix the fight via a fake foul.
The Providence News · 9 December 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Referee Earp in Court
[Lynch and Needham Also Named as] Among Conspirators--The Signal.
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 9.--A morning paper publishes the following: George Allen, one of the men who trained Tom Sharkey for his fight with Bob Fitzsimmons has made a confession to the effect that Fitz was cheated out of his victory through conspiracy. The trainer and the Sharkey management have quarrelled over money matters, it is said and in the heat of the moment Allen made threats of what he would do if he was not paid for his services. Attorney Kowalsky, representing Fitzsimmons heard of the circumstances and he employed a private detective to gather in the irate trainer. He was run to ground and induced to tell the story. It is claimed that Allen in an affidavit named Wyatt Earp, Dan J. Lynch, Tom Sharkey, and Dan Needham as the prime movers in the plot.
See moreSee less
The whole scheme is said to have been hatched at Sharkey's training quarters at Ocean Beach. It was arranged that Sharkey was to make it appear that he had been fouled at some time in the contest when he was in danger of losing from Fitzsimmons' blows, further that the signal was to be given by Sh[arkey]
The piece quotes and mildly mocks a New York Journal editorial that praised Wyatt Earp's gravity and solemnity as referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, comparing him to a judge pronouncing sentence. It is framed as a satirical aside within a broader local political column about police commission reforms.
The Salt Lake Herald · 9 December 1896 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Of the merits or demerits of Referee Earp's decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight we know nothing, and care less, but it seems to us that this from the New York Journal is piling the praise on him a little thick: "Major McKinley, in lifting his hand to take the inaugural oath, will not be more impressed with the awful solemnity of the occasion than was Wyatt Earp when he stood in the ring on Wednesday night and saw 15,000 faces turned upon him. The chances are that he never read of the Circus Maximums, and thought he looked upon the biggest crowd that had ever assembled on earth.
See moreSee less
That he was inspired by a resolve as lofty as it was grave and stern, to do his whole duty as a judge—that he felt the imposing distinction which had been conferred upon him, and that he pronounced his sentence as honestly as any judge who ever sat upon the bench and spoke the word that meant death or life to a fellow creature, there is no room for reasonable doubt."
This item references the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in San Francisco, where referee Wyatt Earp awarded victory to Sharkey after disqualifying Fitzsimmons. The writer calls it 'the baldest robbery practiced lately' and implies Earp's past as a Wichita policeman explains the fix.
Staunton Spectator and Vindicator · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The baldest robbery practiced lately was when Bob Fitzsimmons knocked Joe Sharkey out in San Francisco the other day, and the fight was given to Sharkey. A refferee by the name of Earp was chosen against Fitzsimmons' protest, and he did the work in fine style. As soon as we head that Earp was once on the police force of Wichita, Kansas, that settled it.
The English are going to buy a little Christmas gift for Ambassador Bayard. The London Telegraph has started a popular subscription for this purpose, and the gift will be a handsomely bound volume of Shakespeare's works. Mr. Bayard can substitute this one for
In San Francisco court, Wyatt Earp, who refereed the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, testified he owns no property beyond his clothing, surprising observers who believed him wealthy. Earp also pleaded not guilty to carrying a concealed weapon after being disarmed just before the fight began.
The Times · 9 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
PRIZE FIGHTERS IN COURT,
huge piece of robbery. Although Sharkey was supposed to have suffered a relapse to-day, he was, nevertheless, well enough to change his quarters to Vallejo this evening, where he went in company with Lynch and Needham. The Fitzsimmons faction claim that the three moved in the hope of getting beyond the jurisdiction of Justice Groezinger's court, but Lynch denies this. Mr. Earp, who was relieved of a big revolver by Captain Whitmann just prior to the call of "Time" on the evening of the prize-fight, pleaded not guilty to-day to the charge of carrying concealed weapons, and his case was continued.
In San Francisco, Bob Fitzsimmons, Martin Julian, Daniel Lynch, and referee Wyatt Earp appeared before Justice Groezinger in a legal dispute over the $10,000 purse from the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. Earp testified he owned no property besides his clothes, and separately pleaded not guilty to carrying a concealed weapon, a revolver confiscated by Captain Whitman before the fight.
Richmond Dispatch · 9 December 1896 · page 1
FITZSIMMONS, SHARKEY & (00. { Court Proceedings for Possession of Thut Purse<Money., SAN FRANCISCO, December 8.—Bob Fitzsimmons; his manager, Martin Julian; Daniel Lynch, representing Tom Sharkey; | Wyatt Earp, who acted as referee in the tropical regions, Fitzsimmens-Sharkey fight, and a number of others interested in the legal squabble for possession of the $10,000 purse-money, appeared in Justice Groezinger's court room this afternoon. Keteree Earp was the only witness examined, and he was | not asked to explain how or when he ate than another, consented to act as referee, He testified, however, that he ‘did not possess a dollar in the world, and that he owned no pro perty save the clothing he wore.
See moreSee less
This admission ereated surprise, as the witness was popularly supposed to be a man of means. Cross-examination was reserved until Thursday. Julian insists that he has abundant tes timony to prove the existence of a huge piece of robbery. Although Sharkey was suposed to have suffered a relapse to-day, he was never theless well enough to change his quar ters to Vallejo this evening,’ where he went, in company with Lynch and Need ham. The Fitzsimmons faction claims that the three moved in the hope of get ting beyond the jurisdiction of Justice Groezinger's court, but Lynch denles this. Mr. Barp, who was relieved of a big revolver by Captain Whitman just prior to the call of time on the evening or the prize-fight, pleaded not guilty to-day to genuine bottle. the charge of carrying concealed weapons, and his case was continued.