As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

January 1897

11 articles

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

A sports column reports that boxing manager Martin Julian was in Broadway resorts complaining that Fitzsimmons was treated unfairly in San Francisco. The piece notes public opinion holds that Fitzsimmons was robbed of the decision in the Sharkey fight, and wonders what he will do next regarding a bout with Corbett.

New York Journal · 2 January 1897 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

Martin Julian was swelling himself in the Broadway resorts yesterday and telling knots of the sporting fraternity how outrageously Fitzsimmons was treated in San Francisco. That Sharkey-Earp story has been overworked, and while nine out of every ten fair-minded men agree that the tall antipodean was robbed of the decision in the Sharkey contest, they are anxious to know just what Fitz intends doing about fighting Corbett. Bob says he will fight, but he also stated the same thing on two former occasions. What the public would like to see him do is to sign the articles without any wrangle, prepare himself for the contest, get into the ring on March 17, and let us know whether he is a champion fighter or a champion orator.

See moreSee less

Dan Stuart, the pugilistic impresario, is at Nantasket. Mass., but will return on Monday, when he hopes to settle all the preliminary de[tails]

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The article profiles Wyatt Earp, calling him a noted dead-shot and former lawman famous for refereeing the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, describing his reputation for deadly quickness and his violent past on the frontier. It recounts his family's gunfights, his fearsome appearance, and claims he was born in Missouri.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Portland Daily Press · 2 January 1897 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

How Many Lives He Has Taken.

Wyatt Earp, whose refereeing of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight has made him prominent in the sporting world, is a man with a record.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report recalls earlier Earp adventures, including a shootout at a Tombstone theater between the Earps and the Clantons that allegedly left four men dead, two of them Earps. It also includes an election commissioner's recollection of meeting a heavily armed Earp in Albuquerque in 1883.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Portland Daily Press · 2 January 1897 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

EARP'S LIES

Charley Bassett, Jim Masterson and Wyatt Earp were deputies. It was a tough town then and full of tough people. The officers had shot some cattle man full of holes and his brother and his crowd resolved to be revenged. One day word came up the trail that these men were coming to wipe out the officers or die in the attempt. They came, four of them. Eddie Masterson was on the street near the dance hall, talking to a woman. The gang from the trail opened fire as soon as they saw him.

See moreSee less

He was shot in the stomach and killed. Masterson, Earp and the rest were in the dance hall at the time, and came out as soon as they heard the shots. It did not take them long to join in. When the fight was over three of the four who had come up the trail were dead and the fourth shot full of holes. He was nursed by his father in a little room over the newspaper office. The Mastersons said they would never let him leave the town alive, but he sneaked out one night on a midnight train. At that time Earp wore two big guns, with white handles and long, shining barrels. He dressed usually in blue flannel, without a coat, and no collar to his white shirt. He is now a very well dressed man, but not conspicuous. He wears dark clothes, patent leather shoes and a silk hat. He is as quiet as ever and probably as dangerous. Another adventure he had in the shooting line was at Tombstone, Ariz. His brothers, Jim, Virgil and Morgan, were with him then, and there was a deadly feud between the Earps and the Clatin party. They all attended the theater one night, and one of the Clatins put his foot upon the edge of the box. One of the Earp party took offense at this and put a bullet through his foot. Then everybody went for their guns and started to shoot. There were four men killed in that encounter, two of them being Earp boys. Wyatt, as usual, came off unhurt. He has been through dozens of similar scrapes and always escaped unhurt, not that he avoided danger, because he does not seem to know what it is, but his luck was always with him in all his encounters. William Llewellyn Saunders, the election commissioner, tells an interesting story of his meeting with Wyatt Earp in 1883. It was in Albuquerque, N. M., in 1883," said Mr. Saunders, "when I first saw Wyatt Earp. That section of the country that time was very wild and lawless. People were shot and killed on the streets almost every day. It was a hang-out for cowboys and gamblers, so that there was always some trouble afoot. "I was running a paper called the Review, and Tom Hughes was running the Journal. Wiley Bunnell, now running a paper in Duluth, was down there at the time. My foreman was R. L. Hutchinson, who is now a successful physician at Pana, Ill. "One day, just as I was going to press, I met Earp. The foreman was correcting proof on the Washington press, and I was at my desk. "The foreman stepped to the door for a minute and came back to tell me that there were some people outside who wanted to talk to me. I stepped to the door with my hat and coat off, and a proof sheet still in my hand. There I saw four men on horseback, all heavily armed. "Two of them had sawed-off shotguns, and two had the big revolvers usually carried around there. There was one peculiar thing I noticed then that I never saw except on that occasion. Besides having cartridge belts strapped around EARP'S GUN. The Dead Shot Who Refereed a Prize Fight. Known as a Desperado in the Wild and Woolly West—One of a Family Who Shot to Kill—Earp Does Not Know their waists ea[ch] shells around his When I came out are the Earp boy[s] "I said I was. "Then Doc. H[e] party, told me th[e] trouble, which th[ey] had no righ[t] had come into t[he]

See the clipping

Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A year-in-review boxing roundup recounts Fitzsimmons's fights in 1896, including his bout with Tom Sharkey in San Francisco where referee Wyatt Earp awarded the contest to Sharkey on a foul claim. The report states Fitzsimmons was likely robbed of victory, and notes his lawsuit for the purse was dismissed as the fight was an illegal transaction.

Birmingham State Herald · 3 January 1897 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

IN THE BOXERS' CORNER

Bob Fitzsimmons, after his fiasco with Corbett, took on Peter Maher and they met in a ring on the Mexican side of the Rio Grande on Feb. 21. Maher was almost blind with an ophthalmis affliction; nevertheless, he had the best of the first half minute of the bout.

As they were separating from a clinch Fitz brought his right over against Peter's jaw, knocking him out instantly. Though Fitz was the victor, he gained very little credit through this encounter. Bob's only other encounter was with Tom Sharkey in San Francisco a few weeks ago. It was to have been the best of ten rounds. Fitzsimmons had all the best of the fighting and put Sharkey hors du combat in the eighth round. The referee, Wyatt Earp, decided that Fitz had struck Sharkey a foul blow in the groin and gave the fight to Sharkey. The fact seems to be that Fitz was robbed of his victory. He sued for the $10,000 purse, but the suit was thrown out of court on the ground that the affair was an illegal transaction, and Sharkey get the purse minus $1,500, which he owed to California parties.

See moreSee less

Jim Corbett says that he will begin training for his fight with Fitzsimmons about Feb. 1. "Billy Delaney, my old trainer, will not handle me," said Corbett, "for he has gone into business in California. My work will be done under the supervision of Jim McVey and Charley White. The latter used to train Fitzsimmons. As the fight is scheduled for March 17 I will have plenty of time to get right, if I begin work on the 1st of February. I could get into splendid trim in five weeks."

Peter Maher last season, after his easy victory over Steve O'Donnell, whom he put out with three punches, at Maspeth, was presented with the championship by Jim Corbett. Then he met Fitzsimmons as above stated. After he had had an easy victory over Paddy Slavin in Madison Square Garden he defeated Joe Choynski after a terrific fight of six rounds before the Broadway Athletic club on Nov. 18. Friday he met Steve O'Donnell at Coney Island for the second time, defeating him in 27 seconds.

Joe Choynski's first fight of the year was with Jim Hall at Maspeth early in January. Hall had him all but out in the ninth round, the gong saving him. Then Joe rallied and he put in the thirteenth round. He next boxed with Kid McCoy in New York, but the affair could hardly be denominated a fight, though it was called a draw. In May he undertook to stop Tom Sharkey in eight rounds in San Francisco, but he failed to accomplish his task.

Tom Sharkey's bouts have been few in number. He met Alex Greggains, Joe Choynski, Jim Corbett and Fitz, and only the latter incapacitated him. These bouts, however, prove that he is a "hard man to lick." He is a rough, unruly fighter. What his future in the ring will be is a question hard to answer.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A report previews a physical-culture boxing match between Charley Turner and William Lewis in Sacramento. In an aside, it references Wyatt Earp's controversial refereeing decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, which cost Fitzsimmons the match and purse.

The Record-Union · 12 January 1897 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

TURNER AND LEWIS.

north of the waistband. Robert Fitzsimmons recently sought to introduce an innovation in this respect, when he and Thomas Sharkey gave an exhibition recently, but Professor Wyatt Earp was so shocked thereby that he made it cost Mr. Fitzsimmons the neat little sum of $10,000 for his display of bad form in this respect. Beginning at 8 o'clock, several lesser exponents of physical culture will display their art, and an evening of much enjoyment is anticipated—or words to that effect. Quite a number of visitors will be here from other places to witness the chief event.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This report describes a planned exhibition boxing tour by Tom Sharkey and Joe McAuliffe through California towns, with comedic details about their training and sparring exhibitions. It notes in passing that Sharkey has memorized a speech written by "Sharpshooter Earp" explaining the controversial foul claim that won him $10,000 against Fitzsimmons.

The San Francisco Call · 14 January 1897 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

the immediate vicinity of Breweryville, San Mateo County.

The articles read that Tom and Jerry, or rather Joe, will visit the principal cities of the State and afford the natives an opportunity of seeing how two noted gladiators can tap each other with five-ounce gloves without the painful necessity of having to score a knockout.

See moreSee less

After engaging in a four-round bout, the fistic celebrities will further astonish the natives in exhibitions of bag-punching, at which game they are said to be very experienced, especially big Joe, who is as flash as a cat on his pins and fearfully aggressive as a bag puncher.

Sharkey has thoroughly mastered a cute little speech which was written by Sharpshooter Earp. His explanation of that foul blow which won the champion sailor pugilist $10,000 recently, much to the chagrin of a man named Fitzsimmons, who figured on the capture of the big purse long before he had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Sharkey in battle array.

These beautiful siver cups, with Champion Sharkey's name engraved thereon, were "built" for a purpose which has been kept a secret until now. Mr. Sharkey wisely concluded to part with some of his hard-earned money in the purchase of silverware, because he had an object in view. The cups will be offered as prizes for the young men of the country who will engage in our round-boxing bouts at each performance which will be given by Champions Tom and Joe.

See the clipping

The Lamar Register · Lamar, Colo.

Published around the Fitzsimmons fight controversy, this piece recaps Wyatt Earp's background with a sensational, error-filled account of his brothers and the Clanton feud. It invents a brother named Julian, misstates which Earps died and where, and conflates Tombstone and Gunnison killings.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Lamar Register · 16 January 1897 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

LOOK AT HIS PHIZ. WYATT EARP A BAD MAN AND HE LOOKS IT.

WYATT EARP, whose purchased decision recently robbed Robert Fitzsimmons, the prizefighter, of the purse, is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented to that household made up mainly of Winchesters and Colt sixers. The Earps construed this a lack of confidence on the part of Tombstone public. They resented by shaking the dust of Tombstone from their feet forever.

See moreSee less

They migrated to the Gunnison country. They were presently run out of the Gunnison. Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to [illegible]orula. The four Earps were named, respectively, Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian. They had a sister, Jessie, who was with them in Tombstone. Of her, as novelists say, we are anon. Virgil was the oldest, Wyatt the wisest, Warren the foolhardy, Julian the bravest,

See the clipping

The Lamar Register · Lamar, Colo.

This sensationalized 1897 account claims the Earp brothers were themselves stage robbers and gunfighters who feuded violently with the Clanton-led Rustlers faction in Tombstone. It portrays Virgil as Tombstone marshal secretly orchestrating stagecoach holdups with Wells Fargo agent collusion, while describing family deaths and a blood feud with Ike Clanton.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Lamar Register · 16 January 1897 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WYATT EARP, whose purchased decision recently robbed Robert Fitzsimmons, the prizefighter, of the purse, is one of four brothers; two of whom, Julian and Warren Earp, are happily dead and out. The four Earp brothers were abundant about Tombstone in 1881, 1882 and 1883. The community in 1883 assumed a positive attitude toward the Earps and presented to that household made up in main of Winchesters and Colt sixshooters. The Earps construed this as a lack of confidence on the part of the Tombstone public. They resented by shaking the dust of Tombstone Tombstone public.

See moreSee less

They resented shaking the dust of Tombstone at their feet forever. They migrated to the Gunnison country. They were subsequently run out of the Gunnison. Wyatt and Virgil Earp went to [Calif]ornia. The four Earps were named, respectively, Virgil, Wyatt, [War]ren and Julian. They had a sister, Jessie, who was with them in [Tom]bstone. Of her, as novelists say, [an]on. Virgil was the oldest; Wyatt the wisest, Warren the foolhardy, Julian the bravest,

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

An article about upcoming prizefights references Wyatt Earp's prior controversial refereeing decision, noting that Fitzsimmons won their bout but Earp awarded the decision to Sharkey. The piece otherwise focuses on new matchups being arranged for a boxing 'carnival,' including Lavigne vs. McKeever and Maher vs. Sharkey.

El Paso Daily Herald · 20 January 1897 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE COMING "FISTIC CARNIVAL."

A Few Details About the Fitz-Corbett Prize Ring Racket.

See moreSee less

The sporting editor of the St. Louis Globe-Democrat has arranged for three fights at the coming "carnival." He says:

"Dan Stuart seems determined to achieve fame as the head and front of a fistic carnival. Now that he has secured the signature of Fitz and Corbett to the heavy-weight championship he designs to have Lavigne and Charlie McKeever battle for the lightweight championship, and Maher and Sharkey for what might be called the lieutenant heavyweight championship. Lavigne has come to terms and McKeever 'is willing,' and as for the other two Maher will certainly consider Sharkey an easy mark. Whether Dan Lynch will let Sharkey do battle or not is open to question, for Stuart wants Siler to act as referee. There is no chance to 'fix' Siler. Where he officiates the fight has got to be on the level, and there will be no chance to have a decision arranged in advance to suit a few gamblers. But aside from Sharkey and Maher, there will be a world of interest in the settlement of the other two affairs. Both the heavyweight and lightweight championship titles have flaws. Corbett resigned the heavyweight and then took it up again, while Sharkey and Fitz fought for it in Frisco. Fitz won and Mr. Earp gave the decision to Sharkey. The title of lightweight champion is bestowed upon Lavigne by general consent, and surely no one has a better right to defend it. Neither has any one more license to aspire to it than Charlie McKeever. Stuart has excellent material for his carnival, which, if his plans are carried out, will prove the greatest since Sullivan, Myer and Shelly were laid low by Corbett, McAuliffe and Dixon in the arena of the Olympic Athletic club in New Orleans. Stuart, of course, keeps the details of his plans to himself, but there seems little doubt that he will follow the same method he used in getting Maher and Fitzsimmons together in the little Mexican valley opposite Langtry, Tex. Those desiring to witness the fistic duels will meet in El Paso along about March 17, where they will be given tickets at so much each (a good chunk, presumably), and then they will board a train and be carried to a point where the battles can be fought without interference. Stuart's persistence and his success in bringing Maher and Fitz together in the face of apparently insurmountable obstacles, have given him a high stand in the confidence and admiration of the sporting element, and where he had one man to witness his last fight, he will have a hundred this time."

James J. Corbett turned up in St.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex. · and 1 other paper

A sportswriter's retrospective of 1896's major boxing matches summarizes Fitzsimmons' bout with Sharkey, noting referee Wyatt Earp disqualified Fitzsimmons for a foul blow. The piece also notes Fitzsimmons' lawsuit over the purse was dismissed as the match was deemed an illegal transaction.

San Antonio Daily Light · 24 January 1897 · page 11

PAST YEAR

Fitzsimmons, Corbett went to Cali fornia, and while In San Francisco, be undertook to best Tom Sharkey, the sailor boy, In four rounds. He had all the best of the first two rounds, but Sharkey almost made a "rough and tumble” go of the remaining ones, and Corbett came out of the contest with no fresh laurels on his brow. Bob Fitzsimmons, after his fiasco with Corbett, took on Peter Maher and they met in a ring on the Mexican side of the Rio Grande on the 21st of Feb ruary.

See moreSee less

Maher was almost blind with an ophthalmic affliction; nevertheless, he had the best of the first half minute of the bout. As they were separating from a clinch Fitz brought his right over against Peter's jaw, knocking him out instantly. Though Fitz was the victor, he gained very little credit through this encounter. Bob’s only other encounter was with Tom Shar key in San Francisco a few weeks ago. It was to have been the best of ten rounds. Fitzsimmons had all the best of the fighting, and put Sharkey hors de combat in the eight round. The referee. Wyatt Earp, decided that Fitz had struck Sharkey a foul blow in the groin and gave the fight to Sharkey. The fact seems to be that Fitz was robbed of his victory. He sued for the $lO,OOO purse, but the suit was thrown out of court on the ground that the affair was an illegal transaction, and Sharkey got the purse minus $l,- 500 which he owed to California par ties. Peter Maher last season, after his easy victory over Steve O'Donnell, whom he put out with three runches, at Maspeth, was presented with the

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 3 January 1897

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A newspaper's humor column makes a passing joke comparing a stalled legislature to Wyatt Earp, suggesting he would have rendered a decision quickly. The item is part of a miscellany of short political quips and is not a news report about Earp himself.

The Salt Lake Herald · 30 January 1897 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Those who cannot get into the cabinet might be content to be first consuls.

Had Wyatt Earp been the legislature he would have rendered a decision long ago.

See the clipping