The German-American newspaper reports that Monday's morning session in Dayton focused on arguments over a defense motion to dismiss charges against John T. Scopes for violating the state law against teaching evolution. The expected clash between Bryan and Darrow did not occur, as that would come later when scientific experts are addressed; a juror was questioned and satisfied the attorneys after denying he had formed an opinion.
Der Nordstern · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Sitzung in Dayton ereignislos
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report wryly notes that Webster's Unabridged Dictionary itself defines evolution in terms matching Darwinian theory, suggesting that if Scopes is guilty, Tennessee authorities must also prosecute the dictionary. It frames the absurdity of the anti-evolution law by pointing out evolution's acceptance in standard reference works.
Der Nordstern · 16 July 1925 · page 10
The Dictionary in Tennessee
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.
This editorial discusses the Dayton, Tennessee trial over teaching evolution, predicting a guilty verdict that will proceed to appellate courts and ultimately the Supreme Court. It explores the philosophical divide between fundamentalists, those who reconcile evolution with belief in God, and non-believers.
The editorial discusses the philosophical and religious divisions over evolution, distinguishing fundamentalists, theistic evolutionists, and atheists. It argues the Dayton trial reflects a broader attempt to legislate religious belief, contrary to the Founders' intent of religious freedom.
Der Nordstern · 16 July 1925 · page 12
THE DAYTON TRIAL. The shirt-sleeve trial now occupying the court at Dayton, Tennessee, is watched not only by an interested nation, but by the civilized world. The verdict in the case is only one of the incidents in the controversy. It will probably result in a ver dict of guilty, and will then take its tedious way through the appellate courts. The final word rests with the Supreme Court of the United States. It will have to pass on the constitutionality of the law of Tennessee prohibiting the teaching of evolution in the public schools of that state.
See moreSee less
It can have no effect as a finality in determining whether or not the theory of evolu tion is true. That is a question that cannot be settled in a court. It can at most determine whether or not it can be ban ished from the schools. In doing that it may decide whether or not it is so inconsistent with the Christian conception of crea tion as to be a menace to public morality. On that point many serious thinking persons differ. Those who would accept the words of Genesis literally, and believe that the translations and the traditional teaching are absolutely correct, and are the in spired word of God, are called fundamentalists. There are others that refuse to take Genesis literally, to the effect that the world, and all that is or was in it, was made in six days, but nevertheless believe in God, and that he is the creator and the ruler of the universe. They see in evolution nothing but the working out of God’s laws. Then there are others that do not believe in a supreme being, and that attribute all the wonders of the universe, and its laws to nothing but an accident. These latter are the presumptuous fools that would believe their poor finite minds of sufficient power to grasp the stupendous mar vels of existence, and reduce the mall to the simple factor “hap penstance.” The Dayton case may not be without benefit. It may be more than an opportunity for the jokesmith to cut “monkey shines.” It will cause a lot of discussion, and a lot^of thinking. It already shows us that there is a studied attempt in this coun try to control the religious trend of our people by legislation. This is in direct contrast to the plans and purposes of our fore fathers when they organized this government. They had set tled here in most cases because they had personal experience with religious persecution and intolerance in the old country. They had such a horror of it, that they were resolved that this country would never be that way. And so they expressly pro vided that congress could pass no law respecting any religion, or the free exercise thereof. And the fame of this country as the land of freedom in religious matters went abroad, and to its shores came people of many different forms of belief and un belief. For many years there was a spirit of real tolerance among the people, and the feuds of creed or sect were for gotten. But as the founders of the constitution died, the mem ories of the evils of intolerance faded, and those who had never experienced them were easily persuaded to the support of laws that were favored by certain denominations and were regula tory or prohibitory. In late years the attempted control of the machinery of government has not only become noticeable, but is an admitted fact. It has created a growing spirit of intoler ance, and influences our social and political life to such an ex tent that it cannot be denied or disguised. This is not as our founders wanted it; it is not according to their conception of a republic, where the people were expected to rule themselves, and to have all the rights and liberties, except such as they voluntarily conferred on the government. The constitution tried jealously to guard certain rights, that are termed “inalienable,” so that the government, or the majority of the people them selves, could not take away those rights. We are now facing the plain proposition, whether we want to continue to live un der the government as founded by our fathers, in which the powers of government were limited, so that every person could enjoy life, liberty and happiness in his own way as long as he did not encroach on the rights of his fellow man, or whether we shall have a pure democracy, in which the majority can im pose its will on the others in all things. Shall there be any “in alienable” rights left, or shall the majority, or whatever passes as the majority, have absolute power to regulate the individual in all matters, whether he likes it or not? We can have such a government; we can have so-called majority rule in all things—but it will no longer be the government that our fa thers founded. Do we want a change or not? That question is before us and it must be answered pretty soon. The Dayton case will start us thinking. Have we been drifting toward the rocks, or are we still on the placid sea of security, and safety? Is individualism to remain or shall it be merged in a mass, absolutely the creature of the changing will of a so-called majority? William Jennings Bryan, who is taking a prominent part in the trial at Dayton, used these words in a speech the other day: “The only source of power in this country is the people. If the courts go contrary to the people, if the Constitution balks them, the people can and will change them both.” This is a plain and unvarnished declaration that the majority is supreme, and must not be hindered by any constitutional limitations. It does not breathe that high regard for the sacredness of the constitution that he would have us all feel for its Eighteenth Amendment. It tells us in so many words that it is only a tem porary makeshift, and that it shall not stand in the way of any tyranny that the majority desire to impose on those that do not agree with them. It treats with contempt the propositions that all men are created free and equal, it glorifies the mass and reduces the individual to a state of serfdom. If that is the kind of government that he wants, we do not need any constitu tion, for its purpose is only to limit the powers of government. All we need is to put his bloviating majesty on the throne to rule the poor “sons of apes.”
An editorial criticizes William Jennings Bryan's statements at the Dayton trial, arguing his view that majority rule should trump constitutional limits threatens individual liberty. The piece contrasts the founders' vision of limited government protecting inalienable rights against Bryan's apparent endorsement of unchecked majority power.
Der Nordstern · 16 July 1925 · page 12
in the trial at Dayton, used these words in a speech the other
The piece discusses William Jennings Bryan's distinction between lecturing on evolution versus teaching it to children, agreeing with that point. It then criticizes Bryan's claim that the Scopes trial is 'a duel to the death between evolution and Christianity,' quoting the Duluth Herald's rebuttal that the trial will not destroy or settle either side of the debate.
Askov American · 16 July 1925 · page 4
THE EVOLITIOX TRIAL The famous ‘ Monkey” trial at Dayton, Tennessee, appears to In* the principal topic to fill up front page space of the daily news papers these days. Mr. Bryan who is the principal spokesman against the evolution theory, gave out a statement some time ago to the effect that there is a wide difference between lectur ing on evolution and then teach ing it in the public schools to children and in this it seems that he is perfectly right. A lecture l»efore grown-ups where people are permitted to attend or stay away of their own free will and then teaching it to children in an institution that they are practi cally compelled to attend are two different things and especially in view of the fact that the teach ings in the school is the opposite of that taught in the home.
See moreSee less
But Mr. Bryan gave out an other statement more recently which is too far fetched when he said regarding the Scopes trial * ' V it is "a duel to the death between evolution and Christianity.” The Duluth Herald comments in part on that as follows: “Probably Mr. Bryan, in his zeal, says more than he means. Anyway, he says more than is true. “Whatever the outcome of the Scopes trial may be, it will not destroy either evolution or Chris tianity. Nor will it change either of them very much. "Neither will it settle for all time the issue that has been raised in Tennessee. No matter what happens to Scopes or to the law under which he is to lx* tried, Christianity will go on, and those who lielieve in evolution will con tinue to believe in it. Moreover, those who doubt evolution will continue to doubt it, and those who hold that it is entirely pos sible to believe in some form of evolution and in Christianity too will remain about where they were before the trial.” zMI the time and money spent at the Tennessee trial will prob ably do as much good as the polar explorations and perhaps less, anyway it seems like a case of much excitement wrought up about a small matter. Why so much speculation as to the origin of man? If it was possible to discover that the teachings of the bible in that respect are wrong would evolution give us a sub stitute for the moral teachings of the bible, the church and the Sun day school? If that were pos sible then it would be easy to un derstand why the subject would command the attention, study and interest of everylsxly.
The passage quotes Bryan calling the Scopes trial a duel to the death between evolution and Christianity, then presents the Duluth Herald's rebuttal arguing the trial will not destroy or settle either side of the debate. It frames the trial as overblown excitement over a matter unlikely to be resolved by a courtroom.
Askov American · 16 July 1925 · page 4
* ' V it is "a duel to the death between evolution and Christianity.” The Duluth Herald comments in part on that as follows: “Probably Mr. Bryan, in his zeal, says more than he means. Anyway, he says more than is true. “Whatever the outcome of the Scopes trial may be, it will not destroy either evolution or Chris tianity. Nor will it change either of them very much. "Neither will it settle for all time the issue that has been raised in Tennessee. No matter what happens to Scopes or to the law under which he is to lx* tried, Christianity will go on, and those who lielieve in evolution will con tinue to believe in it.
See moreSee less
Moreover, those who doubt evolution will continue to doubt it, and those who hold that it is entirely pos sible to believe in some form of evolution and in Christianity too will remain about where they were before the trial.” zMI the time and money spent at the Tennessee trial will prob ably do as much good as the polar explorations and perhaps less, anyway it seems like a case of much excitement wrought up about a small matter. Why so much speculation as to the origin of man? If it was possible to discover that the teachings of the bible in that respect are wrong would evolution give us a sub stitute for the moral teachings of the bible, the church and the Sun day school? If that were pos sible then it would be easy to un derstand why the subject would command the attention, study and interest of everylsxly.
A columnist previews the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as a fight over whether the state has a right to protect children from evolutionary teaching that contradicts biblical creation. The piece notes Bryan will argue for the state and Darrow for the defense, and mentions Scopes himself believes he will lose both the case and his job.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1
SOME MONKEY BUSINESS
HAVE we a right to protect our chil dren? That sounds like foolish question No. 9,999 doesn’t it? And yet, before many more days have passed some of the most brilliant minds in all the world will be engaged in a fierce and mighty battle of intellects and oratory trying to thresh out its answer down in old Tennessee. May God determine the outcome! for it is one of the most vital issues before the world today and one of the most pregnant with serious consequences of any problem which our liberty-loving people will ever be called upon to solve.
See moreSee less
Not long ago Tennessee passed a law forbidding the teaching of evolution in the public schools. In open defiance of this law a young professor at Dayton, Tenne ssee, by the name of John T. Scopes pro ceeded to teach that all living things in the world today, including human beings, have, according to the evolutionary hypo thesis, descended and evolved from an cestors which were tiny, simple, one-cell creatures. This teaching, of course, is absolutely contrary to the Bible’s state ment that the first man and woman were made by God during the first week of this world’s biological history, that they were each made full-sized, fully developed man or woman, and that the man was actually made in the image or likeness of God Himself. According to the press Professor Scopes now says that he did this as the result of a dare, that it w’as done to provide a test case as to the constitu tionality of the Tennessee law, and fur thermore that he is now convinced that he will lose both the case and his job. Among the many noted men who are expected to appear at the trial of Prof. Scopes will be William J. Bryan for the state, and the famous Clarence Darrow
An opinion piece argues that Tennessee has the right to protect children morally and spiritually, just as child-labor and education laws protect them physically. It claims evolution is merely an unproven hypothesis that destroys faith in the Bible, citing Jewish history as a warning about abandoning scripture.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Stillwater, Minnesota, Thursday, July 16, 1925 sort of logic which would arrive at such a conclusion! Let us then take a closer look at this evolution law proposition and see what
William Jennings Bryan made his first argument in the Scopes trial, speaking in support of the state's effort to have scientific testimony excluded from the case. The question of admitting scientific testimony occupied the court's morning session during the trial of teacher John T. Scopes.
The Bismarck Tribune · 16 July 1925 · page 1
BRYAN MAKES ARGUMENT IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
William Jennings Bryan made his first argument in the Scopes trial, supporting the state's effort to exclude scientific testimony. Debate over admitting expert testimony consumed the court session, with sharp exchanges between attorneys McKenzie, Hays, Darrow, and Malone.
The Bismarck Tribune · 16 July 1925 · page 1
BRYAN MAKES ARGUMENT IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
The article claims a town near Dayton was settled by relatives of Charles Darwin, some of whom have read his works but keep quiet about it due to local sentiment. It notes a family split, with some Darwins embracing evolution and others declaring themselves fundamentalists who denounce it.
The Bismarck Tribune · 16 July 1925 · page 8
KIN OF DARWIN LIVES IN DAYTON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.
A wire-service digest reports that William Jennings Bryan plans to launch a national campaign to outlaw the teaching of evolution following the Scopes trial. It also notes that Bainbridge Colby withdrew from the Scopes defense team due to his New York law duties.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 16 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Morgan County Democrat · McConnelsville, Ohio
A small-town newspaper column of local personal items notes that some local people expect to attend the 'monkey trial' of Scopes at Dayton, Tennessee. The rest of the passage consists of unrelated community news about illnesses, visits, church services, and social events.
Morgan County Democrat · 16 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
The article recalls the 1884 heresy trial of Rev. James Woodrow, uncle of Woodrow Wilson, who taught evolution at a South Carolina Presbyterian seminary and was convicted but later reinstated. It draws a parallel to the ongoing Scopes trial in Tennessee as a similar clash between science and religious orthodoxy.
The Laurens Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 4
EVOLUTION TRIAL IN 1884
Scopes in Tennessee. Dr. Woodrow was at the time a pro fessor in the South Carolina College and Theological seminary at Colum bia. S. C., a Presbyterian school, where he gave courses in natural science as related to divine revelation. In the course of his lecturers it de veloped that Dr. Woodrow presented the Darwinian doctrine of evolution in such a manner as to conflict with orthodox teachings supported by the Kook of Genesis, so the fundamen talists of that day had him tried and convicted of heresy. His nephew, Woodrow Wilson, who was later to become president of Princeton University and twice presi dent of the United States, was indig nant over the result of the trial, as were the other leading scientific men of the country.
See moreSee less
The conviction was reversed later by the higher Presbyterian author ities, so Dr. Woodrow was reinstated and afterward served as president of the state college until his retirement in 1S97. He died in 11*07.
William Jennings Bryan argued that Christian doctrine has provided a complete moral code for 1900 years that no scholar has improved upon. He contended religion predates education and that passionate service matters more than mere intellect.
The Laurens Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 4
STATE SCORES IN SCOPES TRIAL (Continued from Page One) tonight, took exception to but one re mark. “The doctrines of Christ have stood for 1900 years/’ Mr. Bryan said, and they have furnished so complete a moral code that no scholar has dared add a word to it. Religion was here \ before education, he declared.
Judge Raulston rejected the defense's motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. The report also notes a dispute over daily courtroom prayers after a Unitarian minister opened proceedings.
The Laurens Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1
STATE SCORES IN SCOPES TRIAL
The Judge’s decission upheld the con stitution of the Tennessee anti-evoluj tion law. The motion to quash was made Monday and the day was spent in argument. Judge Raulston occupied all of yesterday in writing his opin ion which was voluminous. The'decision took up each conten tion of the defense and ruled that the defendant would be required to plead further. Unitarian Pastor Prays The Rev. Charles Francis Potter, pastor of the West Side Unitarian church, New York, opened the Scopes evolution trial with prayer. Dr. Potter was called to the plat form by the court after President Stribling of the Dayton Pastors as sociation had announced as the choice of the association.
See moreSee less
Judge Raulston yesterday announj ced that he would ask the Dayton Pastors’ association to nominate a minister to make the opening prayer each day. The following protest from the defense at the custom of having a daily prayer. Just after the brief prayer, John R. Neal of defense counsel, gained the . floor to make his attitude clear on the question of prayer in court.
Defense counsel John Neal objected to daily opening prayers in court, prompting a dispute with prosecution's S. K. Hicks over religious atmosphere, while Judge Raulston defended the practice. Separately, William Jennings Bryan preached an old-fashioned sermon to a large outdoor crowd in Dayton, followed later by a modernist sermon from Rev. Charles Francis Potter.
The Laurens Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Dayton, Tenn., July 12—(AP)— William Jennings iJrj^n preached an oldfashioned se*nonf,to a swelt ering crowd of btivers in an old fashioned God on fie court lawn here this afternoorf and tonight at the same place tft Rev. Charles Francis Potter, pafcor of West Side Unitarian church, ' New York, told a more comfortab audience of the creed of the mode list. “He Calleth The ” was the topic of Mr. Bryan’s ermon and through it he dep ted a Christ who alone can save the vorld from future wars. The crowd, mass of human ity, which began assembling more than two hours bore thime for the sermon, applaudecftiow and then, while numerous s|fts drew fervent “Amens” from th4 midst.
See moreSee less
Overhead an air|lane droned. In the distance a tr& whistled, drew into the city limil and whistled again, so loudly thathe man who was introduced to the alienee as the rep
Dr. Weston Bruner preached a sermon criticizing the Scopes trial defense, calling Darrow an agnostic and claiming the defense team was aided by Civil Liberties League and radical groups to attack the Bible. He argued evolution was disproved and praised Bryan's stance, asserting Tennessee taxpayers had the right to determine school curriculum.
The Laurens Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1
FLAYS TRIAL Declares Defenders of Scopes Worse Than Darwin. Evolution Thor oughly Disproved Preaching from the text as record ed in Ezekial 21:31 and using the theme, “Skillful to Destroy,” Dr. Wes ton Bruner, pastor of the First Bap tist church, in his morning sermon re ferred to the unusual scene in Tenn essee, with an array of skilled law ers, headed by “Harrow, agnos tic, who wouldn’t know the truth if he were to meet it on the street," ail lined up and aided by Civil Liber ties League, Russian Reds, I.
See moreSee less
\V. W.’s and what not, ostensibly to defend a teacher of evolution but in reality to make an onslaught against the divine ly given word of God, the Holy Bible. “Skillful to Destroy,” not to con struct or build up, as the meaning and intent, the speaker said, and gave it as his opinion that the taxpayers of Tennessee had the right to say who should teach and what should be taught in their schools and he prais ed Bryan and his unimpeachable at
The Fort Mill Times reports that Judge Raulston overruled defense objections to opening court with prayer and refused to quash the indictment against Scopes, who is charged with teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law. The editorial supports the judge's rulings and dismisses the defense's arguments, framing the trial as simply a matter of whether Scopes broke the law.
Fort Mill Times · 16 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Fort Mill Times · Fort Mill, S.C.
The New York World argues that Bryan's speeches at Dayton reveal a larger goal beyond the Scopes trial: to spark a nationwide religious movement in politics, possibly even seeking a constitutional amendment establishing the Bible. The piece warns that religious agitation could sway millions of otherwise disengaged voters.
Fort Mill Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The County Record · Kingstree, S.C.
The writer responds to statements by Edward Percy Howard and Judge Neal, arguing that Tennessee had the legal right to pass its anti-evolution statute and that Scopes had options besides violating it. The piece frames the upcoming trial as a legal question about states' rights versus claims of academic freedom.
The County Record · 16 July 1925 · page 8
Mr. Scopes, the teacher, is to be tried for an alleged charge violation of the law—an indictment, it is alleged was secured by his friends who are seek
The County Record reports that John Scopes' trial began July 10 in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as a contest between traditional religion and modern science. The article explains the Darwinian theory of common ancestry, clarifying it does not claim man descended from monkeys but that all life shares a distant single-celled ancestor.
The County Record · 16 July 1925 · page 4
THURSDAY, JULY 16, 1925 THE SCOPES CASE. On July 10th, last Friday, the trial of John M. Scopes of Kentucky, a young man teaching biology in the public schools of Dayton-, Ten nessee, was begun in that town with perhaps the greatest array of legal lights and prominent professional men that has ever gathered in a small Southern State’s town to prosecute or to defend a theory. It is not merely Scopes that is on trial, but a big and vital question—one that the civilized nations of the world*have been more or less interested in for the past six ty odd years, when Charles Darwin promulgated to the world the theory of evolution—a theory which would
The article explains the scientific and religious dispute over evolution, clarifying misconceptions about Darwinism, and recounts how Scopes's indictment arose from a drugstore conversation in Dayton, Tennessee. It notes the involvement of Bryan and Darrow as the case grew into a national symbolic battle over evolution versus Genesis.
The County Record · 16 July 1925 · page 4
In Tennessee a state law was pass ed, prohibiting the teaching of the theory of evolution in the public Schools. But regardless of the law, text bcoks, upholding the theory, were in use in many high schools and colleges. John T. Scopes, a Kentuckey uni versity graduate, teaching in the Day ton (Term.) schools, was using one of these books. Meeting' in the town’s drug store With George W. Rappelyea, chemical engineer of the Cumberland * Coal Company, and two young lawyers, just out of college, Sue M. Hicks and , Wallace Haggard, the men started an argument among themselves over evo lution.
See moreSee less
Scopes mentioned the book he was using in school. They found a copy of the book in the drug store, and read the chapters on evolution. Then Rappelyea, a firm believer in the evolution theory, induced Scopes to permit himself to be indicted to t< st out the Tennessee law, and clear up the argument. The indictment was returned, and at once the entire nation became in terested. William Jennings Bryan, one of the nation’s hardest fighters of evolution, wired his assstance as prosecutor of young Scopes. Clarence Darrow, noted Chcago Criminal lawyer, entered the fight as ccunsel for Scopes. Scopes, seeing that he was being made the spotlight of the world, tried to withdraw, but the case had gone too far. It was not a question of whether Scopes should be fined a few hundred dollars for violating the state law, but whether the Bible version of the creation of life, or the scientific Version, should stand. Other prominent attorneys, includ , ing Dudley Field Malone, New York, offered their services for the defense of Scopes. And equally as many theologians, and firm believers in the Bible ver sion, came to the aid of the state’s attorney general and the county prosecutor for the prosecution of the case. Wililam Jennings Bryan, who vol unteered his services as an attorney, is the leading legal light in the prose cution of Mr. Scopes, but in face of the fact that Mr. Bryan has had n any theories, politically, which car ried no weight other than to disor ganize and defeat his party, we can-’t help thinking that he is as far off the track in his views in this matter as he was way back in .1896 when his “free silver” theory failed of ac ceptance as beneficial to the nation. Mr. Bryan recently said} “The hand which writes the pay checks should rule the schools. A majority of the people cf the nation believe in the Bible. The disgrace is not the law of Tennessee, signed by the governor and passed by the legislature—the disgrace is that any one would make such a law neces sary. “The teachers are employes of the taxpayers, and should no more be al lowed to teach what they personally believe than a clerk should be allow ed to dictate the policy of a bank. The disgrace is that teachers should betray the trust that is imposed in them by the taxpayers. “I believe that the greatest menace we have today is the substitution of education for religion.” Judge Neil says: “The question is rot whether evolution is true or un true, but involves the freedom of teaching. Or, what is more impor tant, freedom of learning. “As we see it, the great question is whether the Tennessee legislature has the power to prevent the young minds of Tennessee from knowing what has been thought and said by the world’s greatest scientists, and thus to prevent them from forming their own judgment in regard to questions of life and science.” At the time this is written no one knows just what the outcome of the case will be in Dayton, Tenn. It is ccncealed however, that it will hard ly end there; it will very probably go on to the supreme court of the Unit ed States. In any event it will have a beneficial bearing upon the subject of “Fundamentalism” and “Modern ism” in this country.
The report recounts how Rappelyea persuaded Scopes to be indicted to test Tennessee's anti-evolution law, drawing in Bryan for the prosecution and Darrow and Malone for the defense. It includes Bryan's remarks on education and religion, and a judge's framing of the case as being about freedom of teaching and learning.
On the opening day of John T. Scopes's trial in Dayton, Tennessee for teaching evolution, defense attorney Clarence Darrow objected to starting court with a prayer, arguing fundamentalist prayers would prejudice the jury against his client. Judge Raulston overruled the objection. The item also notes Rev. Howard Byrd, said to be a prime mover behind the prosecution, resigned his pastorate after congregational objections to a modernist guest preacher.
The Dillon Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
The report quotes Mr. Edgerton, president of the National Association of Manufacturers, denouncing the Scopes trial at Dayton as 'a travesty on law, a mockery of religion and a burlesque of science,' criticizing it as a publicity spectacle for 'freaks, fanatics and fools.' The passage also contains unrelated society gossip about a judge's daughter and prohibition-era drinking habits.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, defense attorney Arthur Hays argued that expert testimony on evolution should be admissible, while Bryan and other state attorneys opposed it. The argument consumed the morning session and was set to continue into the afternoon, with Dudley Field Malone expected to speak further for the defense.
Brownsville Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Arguments Heard In State Move to Bar Evolution 'Experts'
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
At the Scopes trial, debate continued over whether expert scientific testimony should be admitted, with Bryan's son and Arthur Hays arguing opposing sides. Earlier in the day, an exchange between attorneys over belief in creation led to tense words before apologies were made to the court.
Brownsville Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
A photo caption describes William Jennings Bryan as the center of attention during daily sessions of the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee. It notes Bryan leaning across the table to whisper to defense attorney Clarence Darrow, both having removed their coats in the heat.
Brownsville Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 2
BRYAN CENTER OF INTEREST AT SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
William Jennings Bryan is set to make his first courtroom appearance in the Scopes trial, addressing Judge Raulston on the prosecution's motion to exclude scientific testimony on evolution. The prosecution argues the Tennessee anti-evolution law is clear enough that expert testimony is unnecessary, while the defense insists such testimony is essential for judge and jury to decide the case.
The Seattle Star · 16 July 1925 · page 1
EVIDENCE QUESTION UP
Question Is Clear Clll RT ROOM, Dayton, Tenn, Foduly 16~=William Jennings Bryan will make his first form al appearance in the Scopes | evolution trial this afternoon, He will address Judge Raul ston on the motion of the prose. cution to exclude scientific testl mony concerning evolution and the Bible which the defense seelis to offer, The morning session wis devoled to o xeries of arguments by coun #g¢l for both sides on the motion The defense held that nelther the judge nor the jury could decide the ismues involved In the case without expert testimony. The prosecution maintained that the Teonnessse antl evolution law is sufficlently clear as to what evolution is and what the Biblical theory of creation is as to not warrant such evidence
Judge Raulston, angered that a reporter leaked word of his impending ruling on the motion to quash the indictment before it was announced in court, appointed a committee of journalists to investigate the leak. He warned reporters against further breaches after learning newspapers elsewhere were already reporting his expected decision.
FIND CULPRIT DAYTON, Tenn.—-The most un usual procedure thus far in an alto gether unusual trial in a court of law came at the close of Tuesday’s session of the Scopes case.' President Judge John T. Raulston summoned the 150 or more news paper representatives here to “cov er” the trial before him, and ap pointed a committee of five of them to ascertain and report to him which one of their number had sent out, before it was announced in court, a report of the court’s de cision *on the motion to quash the Scopes indictment and in what man ner the alleged information was ob tained.
See moreSee less
The action followed an announce ment by Judge Raulston that he had information that newspapers were being sold in eastern and western cities undertaking to state what his action was to be on the motion pending before the court. The committee held a brief ses sion with a correspondent of a news agency appearing before it. It was announced that report would be made to the court Wednesday. Judge Raulston bad spent the greater part of the day in the prep aration of his opinion on the de fense motion to quash the indict ment. After a short session in the morning adjournment was taken to 1 o’clock, and at 1 o’clock another recess was announced until 2:30 o'clock.
A photo caption identifies the twelve jurors chosen by defense and prosecution to hear evidence in the trial of Prof. John T. Scopes, who was indicted for teaching evolution. The passage is interrupted before further details on the jurors are given.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 4
arid prosecution to hear the evidence in the trial of Prof. John T. Scopes, indicted for CAR SHORTAGE UNLIKELY, SAY RAIL LEADERS Reports read at Wednesday’s ses .Tenn., high school pupils. Main Speaker At Rate Session
Judge Raulston denied the defense motion to quash the case against John Scopes, ruling that Tennessee's anti-evolution law did not violate the 14th Amendment or constitute improper class legislation. He cited precedents including Oregon and Nebraska school law cases to support his decision.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 2
COURT DENIES SCOPES MOTION TO QUASH CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
The report notes that the much-discussed trial of Prof. John T. Scopes, indicted for teaching evolution to Dayton, Tenn. high school students, is beginning. It describes the proceedings starting under the presiding judge, with brief mention of the trial's daily format.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
A newspaper photo caption describes Judge Raulston presiding over the Scopes trial, pounding his gavel. It identifies Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone as defense counsel, standing with defendant Scopes to the judge's right.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
Judge John T. Raulston overruled the defense's motion to quash Scopes' indictment, upholding the Tennessee anti-evolution law as constitutional under both state and federal law. He addressed each defense argument in turn, including claims about free worship, free speech, and due process, before recessing court until 1 p.m.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
A brief item notes that poet and novelist Harry Kemp returned from France to New York, saying he was glad to be back despite the ongoing Scopes trial and prohibition. The mention of the trial is incidental within a roundup of miscellaneous local news items.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1925 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
The report describes the jury selected to try John T. Scopes, composed mostly of Baptist and Methodist farmers with little knowledge of evolution but strong religious convictions. It notes one juror is illiterate, and quotes both Darrow and Bryan expressing satisfaction with the jury selection.
Eagle River Review · 16 July 1925 · page 10
FARMER JURY TO FIX SCOPES' FATE
J. S. Wright, farmer, Baptist. W. D. Smith, farmer, Baptist. All of the twelve said they could give a man a fair trial, but the gen eral sentiment among them was that the Bible was good enough for them, and their ideas of evolution were vague. “It is as we expected,” said Clarence Darrow, after the jury had been chos en In a three-hour court session be
A twelve-man jury was selected for the Scopes evolution trial after a three-hour session before Judge Raulston, with most jurors admitting vague knowledge of evolution but confidence they could give a fair trial. The state also re-indicted Scopes via a reconvened grand jury, and attorneys signaled they would block scientific or theological testimony on evolution's compatibility with the Bible.
Eagle River Review · 16 July 1925 · page 10
FIX SCOPES' FATE
Darrow, after the jury had been chos en In a three-hour court session be fore Judge John T. Raulston. “We are satisfied,’’ said William Jennings Bryan, who sat In court all day without uttering a word for the public. There is one man on the jury who cannot read or write. The state ac cepted him without a quiver. The de fense exercised its three peremptory challenges. It took a reconvened grand jury only one hour to make a new investigation of the Scopes case and indict him again for having taught that theory of evolution to his high-school pupils which Is said to be in conflict with the biblical story of creation, which is against the peace and dignity of the state of Tennessee and a criminal mat ter termed by the court a "high misde meanor.” The efforts of a minister who does not believe in evolution to get on the jury to try Scopes furnished one of the most amusing incidents of the day.
See moreSee less
The crowa broke out in applause. Everybody seemed to want to get on the jury. There was only one man of those summoned who said that he had a fixed opinion. All the rest said in effect that they did not understand evolution, had only heard of it by rumor and believed strongly in the Bible as an Inspired, scientific, and all other kinds of a document, but still they were willing to give Scopes a fair trial. Mr. Darrow, w’ho was given the title of “colonel” by his honor, the judge, was given a new lesson in jury selec tion. Instead of twelve men being called to sit in a row, one man was called at a time from a list kept in the sheriff's old black bat on the judge’s desk. The prospective juror had to stand before the great crowd and the eyes of 150 reporters and the cameras of the world and tell what he thought of God and evolution and the Bible, shift ing uneasily from one foot to the oth er, hat in hand. The courtroom was a study in sus penders ai.J hickory shirts. One man only of the jurors wore a costume that w’ould excite no comment in the North. He is a white-coated southerner of the old type, a former United States mar shal, a plantation owner. The scope; of the trial came in ques tion somewhat when the state attor neys made it clear that they would not permit any evidence from scientists and theologians along tiie lines out lined by the defense, that the theory of evolution does not conflict with xhe Bible. Two Men Held in Plot
The report notes that John Scopes pleaded not guilty to violating the law against teaching evolution. The rest of the article shifts to unrelated Wisconsin political news about Governor Blaine and a possible Senate run by Mrs. LaFollette.
Baraboo Weekly News · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Scopes Pleads Not Guilty To Law Violation
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.
A photo caption identifies William Jennings Bryan and his son, William Jennings Bryan Jr., a Los Angeles lawyer, as both supporting the prosecution in the Scopes trial. The son hurried to Dayton to assist his father in upholding Tennessee's anti-evolution law.
Baraboo Weekly News · 16 July 1925 · page 1
LIKE FATHER, LIKE SON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.
John T. Scopes pleaded not guilty to violating Tennessee's anti-evolution law in Rhea county court. Judge Raulston overruled the defense's motion to dismiss the indictment, ruling the law constitutional in a 5,000-word opinion.
Baraboo Weekly News · 16 July 1925 · page 1
DISMISSAL IS OVERRULED IN MONKEY TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
The judge dismissed all defense objections in a prepared opinion, allowing the Scopes trial to proceed. The opening session included an invocation by a Unitarian minister after a compromise over religious references, amid a news leak about the judge's decision.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 1
CHARGE SUSTAINED IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
A newspaper committee cleared a reporter of wrongdoing over an earlier leaked story, revealing the information had actually come from Judge Raulston himself through his answers to questions. The judge then read his lengthy decision overruling the defense's motion to dismiss the indictment, after which Darrow objected to religious references and the defense filed a demurrer.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
Judge Raulston denies the defense's motion to dismiss the indictment and later overrules their demurrer, after ordering no mention of religious affiliations during proceedings. The report also describes Scopes as uninvolved and media-shy, declining publicity offers during the trial.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
A newspaper miscellany column mentions that the Evening News published pictures of the Scopes trial's opening, which had occurred in the Tennessee mountains. The writer jokes about the trial's themes with a quip about the sun and Earth moving.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
The passage describes a recess at the Scopes trial where Judge Raulston declared court 'at ease,' with colorful details about attorneys smoking and waiting. The trial resumes with Scopes pleading not guilty after being arraigned.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 5
CHARGE SUSTAINED IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
After hours of waiting, smoking, and false starts, Judge Raulston finally resumes proceedings at 2 p.m., leading to Scopes's arraignment and not-guilty plea. Dudley Field Malone then delivers the defense's opening statement, arguing there is no real conflict between evolution and the Bible.
The Telegraph-Courier · 16 July 1925 · page 5
IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Randolph Enterprise · Beverly, W. Va.
A local news column from West Virginia touches briefly on the Scopes trial, comparing the Dayton spectacle to a Barnum circus and predicting a guilty verdict is inevitable since Scopes admits teaching evolution. The writer argues the case's outcome won't settle the broader Evolution versus Christianity debate, as it will be appealed regardless.
Randolph Enterprise · 16 July 1925 · page 4
Poor old P. T. Barnuin will turn over in his grave at the big circus and menagerie on exhibition down at Dayton. Tennessee which has Barnum beaten in his palmiest days. No difference what the decision is in the Scope case, it will not ef fect the matter of Evolution and Christianity one iota. Un der the Tennessee law against Evolution in the schools there can be no verdict except guilty, since Scopes admits it and then it will be appealed to the high er courts and still the matter will not be settled by any man ner or means.
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, the morning session was devoted to arguments over a state motion to exclude scientific testimony from the proceedings. William Jennings Bryan Jr. opened for the state, Arthur Hayes argued for the defense, and Attorney General Stewart closed, with Dudley Field Malone and William Jennings Bryan expected to continue the debate in the afternoon.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 July 1925 · page 1
And Stewart. cnT'KT ROOM, Dayton. Term., July 10.—(/P).—Argument on tin* question of whether scientific* testimony shall he admitted in the trial of John T. Scopes occupied all of the morning ses sion if tin* ease of the young school teacher, charged with teaching evolu tion theories, and was to continue in to the afternoon when court adjourn ed at 11:45 o'clock, until 1:30. Dudley Field Malone was expected to speak for the contention of the de fense in the afternoon with William Jennings Bryan and Attorney General Stewart in opposition. The morning session was enlivened by an exchange between lien.
See moreSee less
T. Mc Kenzie and Arthur <1. Hayes, caused by a question from Mr. McKenzie as to Mr. Hayes belief in the story of creation. The accident closed with apologies to the court after "none of your business" and “impertinent qttes uons" were expressions used. Formal Motion rOf'KT IKt.MM DAYTON'. Tent!., July Hi. -(/!') The state of. Tennessee made a formal motion at the trial of John '1'. Scopes litre this morning to ■xclodc test im ny of scientists from the trial of the ease. The defense was prepared to put up a determined tight to get testimony into the record from qualified experts on the subject of evolution and its relation to tin* llihle. William Jennings Bryan. Jr., opened the argument f* r tin* state. He was followed by Arthur G. Hayes for the defense with Attorney General Slew art closing the statement. Professor Oil St a ml
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, the state formally moved to exclude testimony from scientists regarding evolution, with arguments presented by both prosecution and defense counsel. The court heard Dr. Maynard Metcalf's testimony outside the jury's presence, while attorneys debated whether expert testimony on evolution should be admitted, with the judge suggesting it would substitute trial by experts for trial by jury.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 July 1925 · page 1
TESTIMONY ARGUED AT DAYTON
Professor Oil St a ml rillin' BOOM. DAYTnX. Tcnn.. July 1(1. - (TP) -Hr. .Maynard M. Mcf (•iiIf. professor of /.nullify mill long en gaged in research in l hat held, re sumedthe stand at the opening ef to day's cnurt trial uf John T. Scopes. The zoologist started liistestimony yesterday with (lie jury excluded. Ar gument was to follow on the ci nipcl cncy of the testimony, the state resist in}; the effort of the defense to act this testimony in. Before Dr. Metcalf could answer Clarence Harrow's first question on evolution.
See moreSee less
Attorney (icneral Stewart objected to coiitiiiiialion of this testi mony, the state claiming the witness had testified at sulllcient length to show the nature of the testimi ny. It was said however that the court and attorneys were not in full accord ns to the procedure in the case of the "test witness." the defense proposing to put him on the stand again if the evidence sin nld he admitted. The court requested l)r. Metcalf to stand aside. Clarence Harrow stilted then that the defense expected to show that the Bihle was not in conflict with the theory of evolution. "We expect to show what evolution is,” said the Chi cago lawyer. "We submit.” he su'd. ‘That (In jury can not decide the case intelli gently without knowing what evolu tion is.” It was announced that Arthur <!. Hayes, of defense counsel, would mnke| I lie argument for the defense and this led to a discnssii n uf t!ie order in which the arguments would he deliv ered. During the discussion hid ween the attorney general and Mr. Hayes, ihe court admonished the attorneys to address the court instead of each oth er. “The only issue this jury must de cide is whether or not John T. Scopes violated the law." lie said. "To permit testimony hv experts would he to sub stitute trial by experts fir trial by ju ry.” Among the authorities cited by Mr. Bryan during the course of his speech were many decisions by the Supreme court of Tennessee. Mr. Bryan spoke in so low a tone that In' was requested at intervals by counsel and the Judge to raise Ids voicq. Ilis tones gradually became more audible as he "warmed up.” I he entrance had been closed and no more spectators were being admit ted. The roi in was thus less crowded limn 11poii former days, alihough ev ery seat was occupied. "Speak up. Mr. TSryau.” Mr. Harrow suggested to the young attorney. The spectators rose up and took a seventh inning stretch as Mr. Bryan finished his argument and the court declared a brief recess. The las Angeles law yer was congratulated by his associ ates. Ikefcnsc Responds Arthur fiarlicld Hayes responded for the defense: "Hist, he said. "The prosecution insisted upon the jury not hearing the ,law. .Now they insist upon its not hearing the facts. "We admit that Mr. Scopes taught what the state said he taught. not that he violatci| the law by doing so. i. for one, must lie shown that there is variance between wliat he taught and tlie ltihle. “Hnr scientists are not here to give opinions. They are here to state the tacts of science. None of them are
Attorneys debated whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with Darrow and Hayes arguing it was necessary for the jury to understand evolution, while the prosecution insisted the only issue was whether Scopes violated the law. Bryan cited Tennessee Supreme Court decisions in a quietly delivered speech, after which Hayes responded for the defense.
Professor Metcalf, an evolutionist from Oberlin, was set to resume testimony before a jury-less court as both sides argued over admitting expert testimony on evolution. The defense, through Mr. Malone, argued evolution doesn't conflict with Christianity and that banning its teaching would harm scientific progress, while the state called witnesses including former students of Scopes.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
The report covers the opening of the Scopes trial, including defense attorney Malone's statement that evolution theory doesn't conflict with Christianity, and prosecution witnesses testifying that Scopes taught evolution from the state-approved textbook. School officials and former students described Scopes's admissions and classroom instruction on human descent from lower life forms.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
The state completed its case against Scopes using testimony that he taught evolution, while defense scientists described evolution for the judge to decide if such testimony should be heard by the jury. Bryan interrupted Malone's argument to say he would defend himself.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 July 1925 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The article reports that defense counsel may seek to postpone the Dayton trial and instead pursue a federal injunction in Knoxville against the Tennessee anti-evolution law. It suggests the famous Scopes trial might not take place in Dayton after all.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pinedale Roundup · 16 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
William Jennings Bryan made his first courtroom argument in the Scopes trial, supporting the state's effort to exclude scientific testimony on evolution. He argued the Tennessee statute was clearly written and needed no interpretation, framing the case as a conflict between religious and irreligious forces.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1
ADMISSION OF THEORY WOULD DEFEAT TRIAL BY JURY-BRYAN
The Associated Press.) William Jennings Bryan made his first court argu ment in the John T. Scopes case this afternoon. He addressed the court In support of an effort by the atate to have scientific testimony excluded. His was the first argument of the afternoon. Ilia son, William Jen nings. Jr., Herbert E. Ili'ka and Ben T. McKenzie had spoken for tho state In the forenoon session with Arthur G. Hays, presenting the contention of the defense, that the testimony of scientists should not be admitted. Mr. Bryan opened by toying that he hnd not thought It proper before in the trlnl to take part in the dis cuFskr.
See moreSee less
11,- felt, lie tuild, that in dealing with questions of law proper he thought the state's authorized representative should speak. "But today." said Mr. Bryan. ’ we came to a decision on which the
A prosecution speaker argues that the Tennessee anti-evolution statute is unambiguous and that Scopes knowingly violated it, citing testimony from Walter White and F.E. Robinson. He criticizes outside experts for not lobbying the legislature instead of testifying in court.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1
COURT ROOM. DAY
violating the law.” The speaker recalled the testi mony of Walter White and F*. E. Robinson. Intended to show that Scopes did know what the law meant and realized that he was violating
Tennessee prosecutors formally moved to exclude testimony from evolution scientists, while the defense, led by Darrow and Malone, argued the jury needed such testimony to understand evolution. Dr. Maynard Metcalf's testimony continued with the jury excluded as attorneys disputed procedure.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 5
COURT ROOM, DAYTON. Tenn.. July I®. (Associated Press.)—The state of Tennessee made a formal motion at the trial of John T. Scopes today to exclude testimony of scien tst* from the trial of the case. The defense was prepared to put up u determined fight to get testimony Into the record from qualified ex jierts on the subject cf evolution and its relation to the Bible. William Jennings Bryan. Jr., opened the argument for the state. He was followed by Arthur G. Haves for the defense with Attorney Gen eral Stewart closing the statement.
See moreSee less
Ur. Maynard M. Metcalf, professor of zoology and long engaged in re search tn the field, resumed the stand as court opened. He started bls testimony with the jury ex cluded. Before he ibould answer Clarence Darrow’s first question on evolution. Attorney General Stewart objected to a continuation of this testimony, the state maintaining the witness had testified at sufficient length to the nature of the testimony. It was said, however, that the court and attorneys were not in full accord as to the proedeure in the case of the "test witness." th® defense proposing to put hhn on again if the evidence should be ad mitted. The court requested Dr. Metcalf to stand aside. Clarence Darrow stated then that the defense expected to show that the Bible was not in conflict with the theory of evolution. "We expect to show what evolution is,’’ he said. “We submit that the Jury cannot decide the case intelligently without knowledge of what evolution is." Dudley Field Malone also attempt ed to address the court and Judge Raulston again said: "I can hear only one at a time." Judg® Raulston said he did not think "there is much at issue" and said it made little difference who opened and closed as he would “listen patiently in the middle or the end." He ruled, however, that since the motion was made by the state, the state, would open and close. The argument by William Jen nings Bryan. Jr., marked his first appearance before the court. He characterized the expert testimony suggested by the defense as the “weakest, the most capable of abuse and the fnost dangerous." He said that Mr. Darrow in the Loeb-Leopold trial characterized experts as "pur veyors of perjury." During his son’s speech, William Jennings Bryan, sat Just behind his son and listened Intently to every word, leaning forward at intervals to hear. Finally the Florida man moved his chair and took n scat several feet nearer his son. The defendant. John Thomas Scopes, seated with his counsel, listened with his elbows on a table and apparently followed the argu ment closely. "The only issue this jury must de. clde is whether or not John Thomas Scopes violated the law," Mr. Bryan continued. "To permit testimony by experts would be to substitute trial by experts for trial by jury." Arthur Garfield IJay* responded for the defense. "First." he said, "the prosecution Insisted upon the Jury’s not hearing the law. Now they insist upon its not hearing the facts. "We admit that Mr. Scopes taught whut the state said he taught. Not that he violated the law by doing so. (. for one. must be shown that there is variance between what he taught and the Bible. "Our scientists are not here to give opinions. They are here to state the facts of science. None of them are paid experts. They come here in tho Interests of science. "Does your honor or any one else know* what evolution is. without i hearing the evidence. If your honor 1 says that Opinion evidence may not be produced may not evidence of facts be Introduced?’* he continued. Ilv contended that Mr. Scopes had taught that man wut descended from
Court debates whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with Darrow and Malone for the defense and the Bryans for the prosecution arguing opposing views. Judge Raulston rules the state will open and close arguments on the matter, while Bryan's son calls expert testimony dangerous and Hays counters that scientists are present to state facts, not opinions.
During the Scopes trial, Bryan argued that only the jury should decide whether Scopes violated the law and that expert testimony would substitute trial by experts for trial by jury. Defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays countered that scientific testimony on evolution was factual, not opinion, and necessary to show what evolution and the Bible actually say.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 5
leaving the books In full force W. J. Bryan spoke In the case for the sec ond time, rising to suggest a pqs -age of the statute prohibttng the teaching of evolution theories sus pended all textbook* In conflict with the lew. Another bit of tide p'sy came up when Mr. Iluya spoke of 'Mr. Bryan" suggesting that per hapa he should say * the distinguish *d leader of the prosecution.” Tne court said that William Jennings. Hr., had not yet made an argument In the case and anything he might have said outside the court room would not t>e competent discussion 'n argument.
See moreSee less
Mr. Bryan called at tention to the fact that he was not the leader of the prosecution, but merely ass< elate counsel and that '.ttorney General Stewart was in charge of the stale’s ca»« Mr. Stewart announced that he "bowe<|’’ tu Mi. Bryan Mr. Hajs resumed and the argument went on Herbert E Hicks followed with •• •petch stress.ng tht states pv<iuu
The article describes Judge John Raulston, presiding over the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, as a family man who studied extensively to prepare for the case. It includes a photo caption noting his wife and daughters, Marintha and Rose Comfort.
Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 12
Central rreaa Judge John linulston, before whom the case of John T Scopes, charged with teaching evolution in the Dayton. Tenn., schools is being heard, studied many hours before the trial to prepare himself For it. lie is a family man nnd is shown with Mrs. Raulston and their daughters Marintha. left, nnd Rose Comfort. 4uto “Tramping” New Mode; Charity Appeals Made Here Are Sifted been somewhere else. Needless to Automobile and foot transients tn pay they failed to get the gas and Increasing numbers have Joined those
The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · and 2 other papers
The defense made a brief attempt to get a federal injunction from Judge Gore in Cookeville to halt the Scopes trial, citing the 14th Amendment, but the judge denied it citing lack of jurisdiction. The report also notes a newly published Johns Hopkins study by Dr. H.S. Jennings claiming to have observed evolution occurring under a microscope, potentially useful as evidence for the defense.
The Midland Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Also printed in 2 papers
Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · 16 July 1925
The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo. · 16 July 1925
The Mahnomen Pioneer · Mahnomen, Minn. · and 1 other paper
The twelve jurors to try John Thomas Scopes for teaching evolution in Tennessee schools have been selected, with the first day moving quickly toward a legal battle over admitting scientific testimony. Crowds of mountaineers and townspeople packed the auditorium to watch, with press representatives forming a buffer between spectators and the court.
The Mahnomen Pioneer · 17 July 1925 · page 7
EVOLUTION CASE GETS START
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Askov American · Askov, Minn. · 16 July 1925
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
Judge Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony at the Scopes evolution trial, adjourning court until Monday while the defense prepares a statement of what witnesses would have said. Defense counsel Hays and Malone objected, while Attorney General Stewart accused the defense of using the trial for educational advocacy of evolution.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 July 1925 · page 1
DEFENSE IS HIT HARD IN RULING EVOLUTION TRIAL
J. T. Scopes. Following the derision the court adjourn d until next Monday Mean while the defense counsel will pro pa re a statement, for the records of what their witnesses would have said had they been permitted to testify. Arthur Hayes, defense counsel, tated "it Is a denial of justice to permit the State to permit obstruc tion of every principle of the Anglo Saxon judicial procedure." Attorney General Stewart de clared the defense was trying to use this trial as a means of conduct ing a campaign of education sup porting the theory of evolution.
See moreSee less
Dudley Filed Malone, for the de ft use, heatedly denied tin's. Judge Raulston hurried scientific testimony on the ground it was not competent in tliis cn1 as tile only issue involved was whether the law was constitutional and whether Scopes violated the law The Judge said he held tin* law constitutional when he denied the motion to quash the indictment. Judge Kaulgtnn said: "it is not within tiie providence of tills court to determine which is n trim lory if the Divine Creation as talked in the Bible or tiie story of creation if man as talked by evolution."
Judge Raulston denied a motion to quash the indictment, stating it was not the court's role to decide between Biblical creation and evolution. He then retired to consider whether expert scientific testimony would be admitted, after Clarence Darrow outlined the defense's view that Genesis should be read figuratively rather than literally.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 July 1925 · page 1
RETIRES TO CONSIDER
Views on Creation. Late yesterday afternoon Clarence Harrow, for the defense, outlined His views of tiie Creation through Informal questionings by Judge Raulston. The Judge was answered that the contention of the deft nse lie that the statement in Genesis that God created man out of the dust of the earth, should not be taken and construed literally but as a figure of speech. "The Del 1 cf is that man was not created by God, us a carpenter builds a house, hut gradually through the process called cvolu • on,” said Harrow. Durrow stated he did not pretend to know whether the evolution theory was right hut wished to show through expert witnesses that they held ■> belief to that theory.
The passage reports that a sister of Professor Scopes, on trial in Tennessee for teaching evolution, was denied re-employment as a math teacher in Paducah, Kentucky, because she would not declare disbelief in evolution. The piece criticizes this as unwarranted religious intolerance since her subject had nothing to do with evolution.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska
Judge Raulston ruled that all scientific testimony would be excluded from the Scopes trial, saying the only issue was whether the anti-evolution law was constitutional and whether Scopes violated it. Defense attorneys Hays and Malone protested the ruling as unjust, while the prosecution accused the defense of using the trial to campaign for evolution education.
Seward Daily Gateway · 17 July 1925 · page 1
JUDGE RAULSTON RULES SCIENCE HAS NO BEARING
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska
Judge Raulston retired to deliberate whether expert testimony would be allowed in the Scopes trial, after hearing testimony from Metcalf and arguments for and against its admission. The ruling on this procedural question was pending as the trial continued in Dayton, Tennessee.
Seward Daily Gateway · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Judge Retires to Consider
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Calico Rock Progress · Calico Rock, Ark.
Federal Judge John Gore refused to issue a restraining order in Cookeville, Tennessee, ensuring John T. Scopes would face trial in Dayton's Rhea County Circuit Court for teaching evolution. Scopes' attorney John R. Neal vowed to pursue federal intervention and predicted the case would eventually reach the U.S. Supreme Court.
SCOPES TO GO TO TRIAL AT DAYTON JUDGE GORE REFUSES TO GRANT RESTRAINING ORDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Union Labor Bulletin · Little Rock, Ark.
An editorial discusses the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, arguing that the case is not about whether the Bible or evolution is true, but simply whether Scopes violated Tennessee's law against teaching evolution. It notes that even an appeal overturning the law would not resolve the broader evolution controversy, and cites a local minister's sermon defending the Bible's durability.
Union Labor Bulletin · 17 July 1925 · page 2
DAYTON EVOLUTION TRIAL.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Union Labor Bulletin · Little Rock, Ark.
A sermon by Dr. Philip Cone Fletcher argues that the Bible has withstood historical challenges like persecutions, the Spanish Inquisition, and philosophical critiques, and will not be upset by the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton. He uses rhetorical analogies to assert the impossibility of science undermining the Bible's spiritual truth.
Union Labor Bulletin · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
A syndicated commentary column discusses the controversy over opening the Dayton courtroom with prayer, noting Clarence Darrow's objections. It also mentions Billy Sunday's absence from the trial and includes his quip about evolution.
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
Attorneys argued over whether expert scientific testimony should be admitted in the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, with large enthusiastic crowds cheering both sides. Figures including William Jennings Bryan, Dudley Field Malone, and Arthur Garfield Hays spoke while seven scientific scholars waited to learn if they would be allowed to testify.
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
AT THE TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
The report describes crowded courtroom conditions, alternating fundamentalist and modernist opening prayers, and heated exchanges between attorneys over whether scientific experts would be allowed to testify about evolution. It includes a humorous exchange between prosecutor Herbert Hicks and defense counsel about turning the trial into a 'teachers' institute.'
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
AT THE TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
At the Scopes trial, Judge Raulston took under advisement the question of whether expert scientific testimony on evolution would be admitted, with a decision expected the next day. Bryan argued against admitting such experts while Malone argued for allowing them, marking Bryan's first active courtroom argument in the case.
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
MALONE AND BRYAN CLASH
Admission of the ex soon close. perts on evolution and its relation to the teachings of the Rible would doubtless result in a much more exi tendril session. I
At the afternoon session, Bryan argued against admitting scientific experts, saying the law was clear and needed no interpretation, while Malone countered that the defense sought to let science and the Bible coexist in their proper spheres. The dispute arose after the defense recalled zoologist Dr. Maynard Metcalf as a test witness on evolution, with Darrow stating the defense would show no real conflict between evolution and intelligent interpretations of the Bible.
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Bryan Vs. Malone. Seven of the dozen tawyers in the case spoke today, but the clear-cut division of the issue between re* lizion and arience was placed before the court at the afternoon session when William Jennings Bryan ar gued against the admission of ex ports and Dudley Field Malone plead* ed that the door of Cho witness box be unlocked for them. Jits address this afternoon mark ed the first time Mr. Bryan has raised his voire in active discos-1 sion of the conflict at issue on the floor of the court.
See moreSee less
He contended that the . law as pasned by the legislature was defi nite. riear and understandable, per mittted of no Interpretation from experts and the offorttoinisctex-. exprrtean dthe erretermgert ex of thethildren handed down to them by thir fathers. Each lu own Sphere. Mr. Malone, following Mr. Bryan declared that the efforts of the defense to place experts in the cum as witnesses was not an attack on the Bible. The defense would have the Bible remain. but in the con aclence. he said, while science taker its rightful place in the schools. The whole matter was brought te the floor of the court when tlx defense recalled Dr. Maynard M. Metcalf. zoologist, who answered a series of questions on evolution yes terday afternoon with the jury ab sent from the court room. Dr. Met calf was presented as a “test wit ness" to show the line of testimony the defense sought to introduce. The permitted to scientist answer the one question asked by (larence Darrow, defense counsel if the witness could give any other evidences of evolution of man.
In open court at Dayton, Clarence Darrow outlined for Judge Raulston the defense's view that Genesis's account of God creating man should be read as a figure of speech, not literal fact. Darrow said he personally was agnostic but wished to present expert witnesses holding the evolutionary view that life began as a single cell and developed into various forms including man.
El Dorado Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Darrow Can't Conceive Of God As Being A Carpenter
I 16.—(AP) (lar- ] DAYTON, July ence Darrow outlined the vjews of creation the defense desires to pre sent by expert testimony through an informal question by udg Kaul ston in open i ourt today. This contention would be that the statement in Genesis that tind crea ted man out of the duel of the earth not be construed literally but as a future of speech. “The belief to that Iran was net erented by God as a carpenter build a hotee," lie told the judge, “but gradually through a process called evolution.” "Is this your belief. Colonel Dar asked the court, TOw? "As for myself I dent protend to
Judge Raulston heard arguments on whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with Bryan opposing and Malone favoring it. He took the matter under advisement, with a ruling expected the next day that would determine how long the trial would continue.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
During the Scopes trial, lawyers debated whether scientific experts on evolution should be allowed to testify, with William Jennings Bryan arguing against admission and Dudley Field Malone arguing for it. The dispute arose after defense witness Dr. Maynard Metcalf testified outside the jury's presence, and the judge's ruling on the motion would determine how long the trial would continue.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Attorneys for both sides argue whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with defense counsel Hays and Darrow arguing science and religion are not in conflict, while prosecution's Bryan Jr. and Attorney General Stewart argue to exclude such testimony. Stewart delivers an impassioned speech declaring himself on the side of religion against what he calls dangerous science.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A colorful, editorializing dispatch describes Bryan's impassioned but ultimately failed appeal against the teaching of evolution, framing it as a symbolic victory for science over fundamentalism. The reporter notes the case isn't fully over, as Judge Raulston must still rule on expert testimony before a jury verdict.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 2
BRYAN FLAYS COURT ROOM WITH WHIP OF SCORN AND LOSES BATTLE OF LIFETIME LIGHT OF MENTAL FREEDOM STRIKES TENNESSEE AND DAYTON FOLK WRESTLE WITH THONGS OF FUNDAMENTALISM
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The report describes the dramatic courtroom battle in the Scopes trial, with Dudley Field Malone's electrifying appeal challenging Bryan's fundamentalist stance against admitting scientific testimony. The judge has not yet ruled on whether expert biological testimony will be allowed, leaving the trial's outcome and broader cultural issues unresolved.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The report describes a dramatic courtroom exchange at the Scopes trial, with Dudley Field Malone challenging Bryan's fundamentalist arguments and defending the admission of scientific evidence. Bryan is quoted invoking the Leopold-Loeb case and tracing evolution's family tree to warn of moral corruption, while Malone counters by asking what fundamentalism fears.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Attorneys including Bryan, Malone, and Hays argued before a packed Dayton courtroom over whether expert testimony should be admitted in the Scopes evolution trial. The crowd, though better controlled than previous days, still responded with cheers and laughter to the oratory from both sides.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 3
Commoner Dodges Back As Sons Arms Wave Wildly During Speech Thursday
of the Dayton school teacher for vio- | I lating the evolution law of Tennessee, j j Supporters of the state, including! William Jennings Bryan and Scopes j defenders, received alike the plaudits j of a throng which couM not be held in ! check by the warnings of the court nor'j discouraged by acute discomforts. They cheered the pleas of Dudley , Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Hays*,
The report describes courtroom proceedings at the Scopes trial, including the presence of Mrs. Bryan, crowd control measures, and heated exchanges between attorneys like Ben McKenzie and Arthur Hays. It also notes Clarence Darrow's demeanor and interactions with Bryan during recesses, while scientific experts waited to learn if they would testify.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 3
such a school in Dayton instead. A hum of earnest comment broke ; over court as Ben T. McKenzie, elderly 1 counsel for the state and a favorite in eastern Tennessee, exchanged sharp words with Arthur C5. Hays, defense attorney from New V rk. Mr. Hays had objected to the tenor of the Ten-' nessee lawyer’s argument. Mr. Mc Kenzie asked the objector a question not audible to the spectators wIid were able however to hear tile defense law yer’s loud retort. "it is none of your business.” Mr. Havs a moment later apologized and the tension in the room was relieved.
See moreSee less
* ‘ Hundreds Turned 'Clarence Darrow declined to take an active part in the arguments for the admision of expert testimony, but he rose to protest or to make suggestions at intervals. His tones •ere always even and deliberate. He cihtMeod pleasante rs with tne elder Mr. Bryan during the occasional recesses. When his son addressed the cou-t today, the former secretary of state the young man’s low-pitched voice. As moved wit.nin three feet of him to hear the speaker “warmer* to his argument he began to gesture with bis arms and his father moved out of range. Hundreds were turned away from the door during the sessions. Before each convening scores standing in the aisles were marshalled from the room. A warning by the court that the floor j of the courtroom was heavily burdened ; did not relieve the crush at the door, j Judge Raulston admonished the crowd \ that buildings sometimes “gave way” ,
The report describes tense exchanges between attorneys, including Darrow's measured demeanor and interactions with the elder Bryan, during arguments over admitting expert testimony. It also notes overflow crowds turned away from the courtroom, with Judge Raulston warning about the building's capacity and requesting no applause.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 3
DARROW DEFINES DEFENSE THEORY OF MAN'S CREATION IN OPEN COURT
A satirical newspaper column reports that Lela V. Scopes was dismissed from Paducah, Kentucky schools for refusing to renounce her belief in evolution. The piece sarcastically frames this as religious persecution akin to an inquisition, amid broader mockery of anti-evolution sentiment during the period of the Scopes trial.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
An item notes a theory that crime drops during the baseball World Series, then cites a New York Herald Tribune sports editorial by McGeehan claiming the Dayton trial could not have happened in a baseball-playing community. It adds that Dayton and its surrounding hilly country lack ball diamonds.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 4
BASEBALL AND CRIME
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
This column mixes local Alabama news with wry commentary on the Scopes trial, including a note on a boycott against a Dayton merchant related to Darwin and a congressman's plan to outlaw evolution. It also recounts how an old poem, 'When I Was a Tadpole and You Were a Fish,' has been revived as a satirical anthem tied to the trial.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A reader's letter to the editor complains about poor traffic enforcement and disorganized policing in Birmingham. In passing, he contrasts the importance of local traffic problems with the North Pole discovery, peace in China, and the ongoing Scopes trial.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 4
SAYS TRAFFIC POORLY HANDLED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
At the Dayton courtroom, attorneys for both sides debated whether expert scientific testimony should be admitted in the Scopes evolution trial. Crowds cheered speeches from Bryan, Malone, Hays, and local attorneys, while Mrs. Bryan watched the proceedings from within the courtroom.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Describes courtroom atmosphere in Dayton as attorneys argue over admission of expert scientific testimony, with exchanges between Hays, McKenzie, and others. Notes crowd control, Bryan family presence, and Darrow's restrained participation while his son spoke.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The passage describes courtroom dynamics during arguments over admission of expert testimony, including interactions between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan, and Bryan's son addressing the court. It also notes overcrowding concerns and Judge Raulston's warnings about the courtroom floor being overburdened.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Winslow Mail · Winslow, Ariz.
Local church announcements list Sunday services, including a Methodist Episcopal sermon that will reference the Scopes evolution trial being held in Dayton, Tennessee. The listings also include other Protestant denominations' service times and topics.
The Winslow Mail · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Coconino Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz.
A brief commentary notes the Scopes case has drawn great notoriety as if to settle evolution theory once for all, and reports that jury selection has been completed. It suggests the real question is only whether the law was legally made and whether Scopes violated it, with the suggestion that Bryan seeks mere publicity.
The Coconino Sun · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Putnam Patriot · Putnam, Conn.
An editorial comments on the Scopes trial, noting that despite being bitter courtroom opponents on fundamentalism versus evolution, Bryan and Darrow are seen in photographs conversing amiably outside the courtroom. It uses this as a lesson against small-town feuds and personal animosity over public disagreements.
Putnam Patriot · 17 July 1925 · page 4
PUBLISHED BY THE PATRIOT PRESS, INC. 0 LAWRENCE PERKINS President JOHN J. WHITEHEAD. JR. .. - Editor ARTHUR S MACDONALD Assistant Editor PRAISE FOR MR. BRYAN It is very difficult for anyone decidedly of the opposition to pay anything very kind about Mr. Bryan at thi,s particular mo ment. However, the frequent pictures of Mr. Bryan and Mr. JDarrow talking amiably together in unofficial momenta at the, Scopes trial, shows that The Commoner is not one of those small minded persons who carry controversy outside of the field of battle. Mr.
See moreSee less
Bryan and Mr. Harrow are bitter enemies on the| question of fundamentalism vs. modernism. In open court Mr Bryan is fervid in his ridicule of Mr. Harrow’s agnosticism. Mr.i Harrow is even more grillingjn his ridicule of Mr. Bryan's pre posterous fight aganBt evolution. Yet when court is adjourned these two gentlemen find it possible to converse in friendly terms and without rancor. It is a national spectacle which bears a lesson for many particular cases. Especially in small towns and localities does one find the small mind where opposition on a public subject all too frequently becomes a matter of personal unfriendliness and animosity. Such an attitude is ridiculous, absurd and small minded. It frequently leads to a long-lived and unnecessary hostility. It is sometimes the birthplace of that silly condition, the small town feud. I he out-of-court friend liness of Mr. Bryan and Mr. Harrow is about the only commend able sight in all the absurdities at Dayton.
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude expert scientific testimony from the Scopes trial, a decision that sparked sharp clashes between defense attorneys Arthur Hays and Clarence Darrow and the judge. The defense took exception to the ruling, arguing it unfairly let the state build its case on its own evidence, and court was adjourned until Monday so the defense could prepare a written record of what their expert witnesses would have said.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Defense attorney Hays sought to enter expert scientific testimony into the record for appeal purposes, even if the jury could not hear it, while the prosecution accused the defense of using the trial as an educational campaign. A tense exchange followed between Darrow and Judge Raulston over the court's repeated rulings against the defense.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
An opinion piece argues that the Scopes trial reveals a lack of understanding between religion and science, criticizing Bryan for fostering conflict between the two. It suggests that genuine study of both subjects produces more credible opinions than blind prejudice on either side.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
William Jennings Bryan Jr. is reported assisting his father in prosecuting John T. Scopes at Dayton, Tennessee. He is described as a strong opponent of evolution, warning that the country would be ruined if evolution were taught in schools.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
The Rotary Club of the Oranges, New Jersey, staged a burlesque version of the Scopes evolution trial during their weekly luncheon, with local businessmen playing the roles of Scopes, Bryan, Malone, and Darrow. The event dissolved into chaos when a man dressed as an ape leaped across the tables.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 17
"APE" AT MOCK TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Dayton school officials announced a plan to establish a fundamentalist college, inspired by the Scopes trial, after receiving a $10,000 pledge from a Massachusetts donor. A nationwide campaign for $1,000,000 was planned, with local citizens already pledging money and land for the project.
New Britain Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 23
Immediately Mr. Robinson and H. H. Frasa, a wholesale grocer, sub scribed SI .100 ,,.1 anrl B F Ken son, principal of the Grayiille inj;, school, near here, offered :i acres of land. In his letter to Mr. White, Mr Washburn said in part: "T asree with ymi that this fight at Dayton is 'the beginning of a bat tle that 11 ill encircle the world.' just as the revolution shot at Concord was heard around th world. The keen interest shown in the Scopes trial by the people of Europe shows that, th's nations as well as Amer ica are aroused by the conflict of fundamentalist principles.
See moreSee less
"Therefore, et us prepare for this battle that confronts us and occupy every strategic position. This is the psychological moment to establish a fundamentalist unbersity, . , . "As Columbia university proposes to boycott Tennessee and all other state adopting stmi'ar laws to that of your state, the resentment of fundamenalists will be so great, everywhere that men throughout the. T'nited Ptates ought to respond to this appeal to build a fundamental ist, university in every state that comes under the ban of the modern ist unhersitles.''
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific evidence on evolution was inadmissible before the jury, prompting a tense exchange with Darrow who nearly faced contempt charges. The defense proposed submitting scientist testimony via affidavits for the record, and the trial adjourned until Monday while Raulston considers them.
Imperial Valley Press · 17 July 1925 · page 1
JUDGE'S RULING BRINGS "MONKEY TRIAL" END NEAR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
During the Scopes trial, Bryan demanded the right to cross-examine scientists, leading to a dispute resolved by having testimony submitted as affidavits for Judge Raulston to review before deciding if it goes to the jury. Darrow accused Raulston of favoring the prosecution, sparking a tense exchange, and afterward Raulston's request for a group photo was rebuffed by both Darrow and Malone.
Imperial Valley Press · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
Citizens in El Centro, California staged their own satirical 'monkey trial' in a courthouse, putting local creamery manager B. D. Bibbins on mock trial for allegedly descending from an ape. The jury found him guilty despite a defense arguing he showed no monkey-like behavior, in a parody of the ongoing Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee.
Imperial Valley Press · 17 July 1925 · page 5
El Centro Stages "Monkey Trial" All Her Own
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Washington Journal · Washington, D.C.
William Jennings Bryan, arriving in Dayton for the Scopes trial, declared evolution theory a 'bundle of guesses' at a banquet in his honor, with Scopes seated across from him. Bryan called the conflict between evolution and Christianity a 'duel to the death' and praised the people of Tennessee against accusations of ignorance.
Washington Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Der Prozeß über die Evolutionstheorie
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Washington Journal · Washington, D.C.
The German-language report describes Bryan's speech framing the Scopes case as a battle for public understanding rather than a jury decision, with praise for Tennessee's people. It also notes defense witnesses, including scientists, expected to testify about evolution's compatibility with Genesis, in response to Bryan's challenge.
Washington Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Judge Raulston ruled that expert scientific witnesses could not testify before the jury, prompting a tense exchange between Clarence Darrow and the judge over the court's fairness. The defense was instead permitted to enter written statements of what the experts would have said into the record, with trial proceedings adjourned until Monday.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 1
®y the Associated Press. COURTROOM, DAYTON, Tenn., July 17.—After Judge John T. Raul eton had excluded scientific testimony In the Scopes case court was adjourned until Monday morning at 9 o’clock. The intervening time will be spent by counsel for the defense in preparing statements for the record of what their witnesses would have testified had they been permitted to take the witness stand. Judge Raulston’s decision to exclude the experts from the witness stand developed sharp clashes between Arthur G. Hays and Judge Raulston find Clarence Darrow in the court.
See moreSee less
Mr. Darrow had asked for the rest v of the day to draw up proof which the defense wished to present. The Judge asked if it would take the rest of the day. Mr. Darrow said he did not under stand why every request of the de fense was overruled.
Judge Raulston ruled to exclude expert scientific testimony from jury consideration, sparking heated argument between Darrow and the prosecution over how the defense could enter its evidence into the record. The court also granted a weekend recess after debate, with the judge indicating the trial would move faster upon resuming Monday.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Stewart Hits Defense. Attorney General Stewart said that the defense wished to conduct a cam • paign of education for their theories of education and evolution through the medium of this trial. The State offered no objection, he said, to permitting the defense to j offer the substance of the testimony i in affidavit form. Dudley Field Malone denied that a ] campaign of education was being con-! ducted although he said he thought I the way in which the defense had j conducted the case was educational, i He said that the defense was meeting j propaganda started by ‘‘a distinguishj
The report details Judge Raulston's ruling to exclude expert scientific testimony on evolution from the jury's consideration, with the text of his opinion quoted extensively. It outlines the State's argument that Scopes' guilt was already established by his admission of teaching evolution, making expert testimony unnecessary.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 1
mitted.” He read the first section of the j statute involved in this case and ' added: “The State says that it is both I proven and admitted that this de- ; fendant did teach in Rhea County, J within the limits of the statute, that j man descended from a lower order •
Gov. Peay of Tennessee explained that Hunter's Biology, the textbook Scopes used to teach evolution, remained in use because of a five-year contract with the publisher that had not yet expired when the anti-evolution law passed. He noted a new textbook, Peabody and Hunt Biology, had already been approved to replace it starting that fall.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 3
BANNED TEXT BOOKS' USE DUE TO CONTRACT TERMS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Clarence Darrow outlined to Judge Raulston in open court the defense's approach, arguing the Genesis creation account should be read figuratively rather than literally. He described evolutionary theory and argued it was not inconsistent with the Bible's creation story.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Quiz by Raulston Reveals Darrow's Plans for Defense
Figurative. By the Associated Press. DAYTON. Tenn.. July 17. —Clarence Darrow outlined the views of creation the defense desires to {present in the Scopes trial by testimnjny through an informal questioning bpJudge Raul ston in open court yesterday. This contention would he that the statement in Genesis “that God cre ated man out of the dtla of the earth can not be construed laterally. but as a figure of speech. "The belief is that .man was not created by God as a eafrpenter builds a house," he told the judge, “but gradually through a process called evolution.” "Is this your belief.
See moreSee less
Col. Darrow?” asked the court. "As for myself. I don t pretend to know." Darrow responded. "I am an agnostic to that as well as other things about which there is mystery. I don't profeils to have any opinion on it. hut we -wish to show through our witnesses tjhat they hold that belief. "The theory of evolution which I believe teaches that life, originated in a single cell and progressed through various stages to' man, branching off in different directions to form the other animals. "We think the Bible .story of crea tion not Inconsistent with the evolu tionary theory that all life comes from the single protoplasmic cell and progresses through variations of ani mal structure to man. Many evolu tionists believe in immortality. Some do not.”
A correspondent observes that the Scopes trial has become a proxy battle over Darrow, Malone, and Hays rather than the defendant himself, with Bryan attacking Darrow's beliefs and past cases. Scopes, the piece notes, has been largely forgotten amid the courtroom clash over the lawyers' character and religious views.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 5
SCOPES' LAWYERS REAL DEFENDANTS Teacher Lost to Sight While State Assails Rival Counsel.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report describes how the trial has become less about Scopes himself and more about attacking the character and beliefs of his defense lawyers Darrow, Malone, and Hays. It notes Bryan's rhetorical attacks linking Darrow to the Leopold-Loeb case and atheism, and suggests the public now views the verdict as judging the lawyers rather than Scopes.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 5
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This report describes the shifting public sentiment during the Scopes trial, noting that defense attorneys Darrow, Malone, and Hays won unexpected applause for championing religious tolerance toward evolution. It portrays William Jennings Bryan as ill-suited to courtroom combat after decades away from legal practice, appearing defenseless against the defense's sharp rhetoric.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 5
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This is a general editorial column discussing various topics including a Summer Capitol proposal, Henry Ford's dance preferences, and smoking bans on Detroit trailers. It briefly mentions the Dayton, Tennessee discussion of science and religion as potentially yielding useful by-products of thought, while worrying that European news may be overshadowed by Tennessee dispatches.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This miscellaneous commentary column touches briefly on the Scopes trial, noting scientists' view that the jury's prejudices have settled the case in advance. It also covers unrelated topics like the Gerald Chapman/Knapp manhunt, Henry Ford's shipping bids, and satirical verse.
Evening Star · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Judge Raulston ruled that expert testimony on evolution would be excluded, signaling the trial was nearing its end with only closing arguments remaining. Heated exchanges occurred between prosecution and defense attorneys, including a tense confrontation between Darrow and Raulston over the judge's rulings.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
JUDGE RULES OUT TESTIMONY ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Defense attorney Darrow sparred with Judge Raulston over cross-examination rulings, with tense exchanges bordering on contempt. The second week of the Scopes trial featured dramatic oratory from Bryan and Dudley Field Malone, described as a high point of courtroom rhetoric.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
JUDGE RULES OUT TESTIMONY ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
As the Scopes trial entered its second week, William Jennings Bryan delivered a fiery speech condemning evolution as destructive to religion and morality. Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone responded with a passionate plea for truth that won a surprising ovation even from the fundamentalist audience.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
A $10,000 pledge for a proposed $250,000 fundamentalist university fund in Dayton, Tennessee was followed by additional pledges from local residents and defense-linked figures. The report also notes G.W. Rappleyea, who initiated the Scopes test case to challenge the anti-evolution law, contributing to the fund.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Books of Darwin Offered Dayton "College" $10,000 Pledge for Fundamentalist School Followed by Offers by Defense Counsel
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific testimony on evolution and the Bible would be excluded from the Scopes trial, siding with the prosecution's motion. Darrow clashed with the judge and defied him to hold him in contempt, but Raulston let the remarks pass; court was adjourned until Monday with only closing arguments remaining.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Judge Raulston rejected defense arguments for expert witnesses, saying the anti-evolution law's wording was not complex and needed no clarification. The defense objected, and side anecdotes include book pledges for a library and Darrow and Malone refusing to be photographed with Bryan and Raulston.
The Washington Daily News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
NEW RULING MEANS TRIAL IS NEAR ITS END
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A news service photo caption shows Attorney General Tom Stewart, William Jennings Bryan Jr., and William Jennings Bryan Sr. conferring over papers at Dayton, Tennessee during the trial of John T. Scopes. Scopes had been indicted for teaching evolution in violation of state law.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
INTERNATIONAL NEWS REEL PHOTO
Bt B ■ I I i Bl I ill ft Wl ■bHk 1-. Bbjl p r K • ; ' I • ■tH .' *, I ■ Left to right are shown Attorney General Tom Stewart, young William J. Bryan, jr., and William MrftNMtIONAL NCWX REEL SHOTO
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude all defense scientific testimony on evolution, granting the State's motion that such testimony was irrelevant and incompetent. Defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays objected sharply, accusing the judge of assuming superhuman knowledge, prompting a rebuke from the prosecution.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
DEFENSE READY TO APPEAL CASE
Defense Hit Hard. It was a death-blow to the de» j tense’s hopes for an acquittal of • Scopes. i An immediate objection was made ;by Arthur Garfield Hays, of de i sense counsel, who said the court's i ruling was without a precedent in I American jurisprudence. He charged >the judge was assuming **super . human knowledge” In refusing to ■hear scientists on either evolution |or the creation of man. • This provoked Attorney General A. Thomas Stewart to object to the {manner Hays used toward the court. “It reflects on the court,” said Stewart.
See moreSee less
The decision was rendered imme diately after court was opened with prayer by Doctor C. G. East wood. fundamentalist pastor of tUe Dayton Methodist Church. There was on objection from the defense las an exception was noted auto ! matlcally on the record. In his decision. Judge Ra ilston ruled that the only time expert testimony was needed in a trial was when the “ordinary man could not form an opinion.” He held, though, in the Scopes case, no such situation existed, as the only question was whether Scopes had violated the law by teaching a “theory which denied the Divine creation of man.” “If this is the only question,” the court asked, “then why call ex perts?” Decision No Surprise
Judge John T. Raulston ruled that expert scientific testimony on evolution was irrelevant and inadmissible, siding with the prosecution's motion. This dealt a severe blow to the defense's case, which had hoped to use scientists to argue for Scopes' acquittal, and the trial was adjourned until Monday so the defense could prepare a brief of the excluded testimony for appeal.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
His decision did not surprise the courtroom, although a rumor had spread just before court convened that he would admit the scientific testimony. Prior to yesterday's ses sion, it was forecast everywhere that the scientists would be barred, but when Dudley Field Malone made his impassioned appeal for truth, there was a change in pub lic sentiment. With scientific knowledge barred, the trial of Scopes was adjourned until Monday to permit defense counsel to prepare a brief of the excluded testimony for inclusion in the record so the case can be ap pealed to the higher courts This sensational development, marked the last move of the mod ernist forces before submitting to the inevitable conviction of Scones before a jury of his fundamentalist peers.
See moreSee less
This brief, unique in American jurisprudence, will include testimony from *JI maetere of science,
Judge Raulston ruled that expert testimony from scientists, though barred from influencing the jury's decision, could be entered into the trial record for appeal purposes. The defense won two minor procedural victories, including blocking the state's request to cross-examine the witnesses, before court adjourned until Monday.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 2
NOTES OF SCIENTISTS TO GO INTO RECORD
Desperate Motions Due. When court convenes, the brief will be filed, desperate defense mo tions entered to swell the grounds for an appeal and the case ended by Scopes conviction. With defeat in this mountain court room staring them In the face, the defense won its first vic tory of the case. Over the harsh objections of State’s attorney and after exchanges of personalities the defense was given permission to enter on the record the testimony of the experts whose opinions were not needed by the court of jury of farmers in deciding whether evolution conflicts with Divine crea tion.
See moreSee less
"The court has the right to do something else,’’ the judge said ominously, “but he didn’t.’ He looked away and the storm passed without further damage. The session opened this morning with prayer as usual and then came the court’s ruling. Later, when de fense attorneys were objecting to the decision, the court announced that if he found he had made a mistake, after reading the testi mony of the stfentlsts, he would reverse himself. After another clash between coun sel the defense won a second minor victory when the court refused the State’s appeal for the right to cross-examine the witnesses An agreement then was entered for a<L journment of court until Monday* while the scientists hurried away to "The Mansion,” on a knoll over looking Dayton, to prepare their ex cluded testimony.
Judge Raulston ruled that expert scientific testimony would be excluded from the jury but allowed into the record for appeal purposes, prompting fierce objections from defense attorneys. Darrow accused the court of bias, creating a tense courtroom confrontation, after which scientists went to prepare written statements and court adjourned until Monday.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 2
TO GO INTO RECORD
victory when the court refused the State’s appeal for the right to cross-examine the witnesses An agreement then was entered for a<L journment of court until Monday* while the scientists hurried away to "The Mansion,” on a knoll over looking Dayton, to prepare their ex cluded testimony. Darrow Very Belligerent. This strange procedure was taken first to preserve the record of science onthe appeal to higher jurisdiction, and second, that the scientific theories on the origin of man might not “leak” into the jury’s ears. It was done with fre quent clashes and after Clarence Darrow, ranking defense counsel, had openly charged the court with favoring the prosecution.
See moreSee less
When that occurred, an ominous silence spread through the court room. The spectators leaned for ward in their seats, but the “bull dog” criminal lawyer from Chicago never flinched. The judge’s ruling had outraged defense attorneys. First. Arthur Garfield Hays, then Dudley Field Malone and lastly Darrow himself had attacked the decision. Darrow was mad. Snapping his suspenders the Chicagoan growled: “It is strange that th£ court has sus tained every motion made by the State and overruled every motion made by the defense.” The court room was shocked The State’s attorneys were amazed. The judge stood facing Darrow, uncer tain what to do. "Does the attorney intend to re flect on the court?” Raulston asked in a low tone. "He has the right to decide that.” snapped Darrow, looking the judge In the eye.
A roundup of human-interest details from the Scopes trial in Dayton, including Doris Stevens' complaint about the lack of women in the proceedings, defense attorney John Neal's eye injury, and Judge Raulston's heat-related recesses and applause ban due to fears about the courthouse's structural capacity. The piece captures the carnival-like atmosphere surrounding the trial as it was then underway.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Shines By International News Service. DAYTON, Tenn., July 17.—Miss Doris Stevens, wife of Dudley Field Malone and vice president of the National Woman’s Party, found one fault today with the Scopes anti-evolution trial. • "It is a womanless trial.” said the first “Lucy Stoner” ever to visit Dayton. "It is indicative of the way in which men still ignore women in such affairs. And yet, women are as vitally interested as men in the teaching of evolution. Women must be taught; they are teachers, and they want to know the truth.
See moreSee less
Yet, there isn’t a woman connected with the trial. It is a disappointment. Miss Stevensdeclared women all over the country were inter ested in the Scopes case. From the tea rooms of New’ York to the backfence chats of San Fran cisco, she said, women are talking about the trial. And most of them, she added, are evolutionists. Doctor John R. Neal, chief of defense counsel, has suffered a bursted blood vessel in his right eye, causing him much distress. The attorney attended today’s sessions, after receiving treatment from a local physician. Judge John T. Raulston has inaugurated a system of recesses in court because of the intense heat and high humidity. Each time, the judge orders a rest, one of the uniformed police attendants shouts: “At ease.” It is the signal for a dash by newspaper men to the nearest soft-drink stand. The tremendous crowds seriously testing the courthouse’s capacity have alarmed Rhea county authori ties, who asked Judge Raulston to place a ban on applause. At the start of each session, the judge solemnly warns the audience not to applaud, for fear vibration will cause the building to col lapse. And each time the crowd finds something to its taste, it forgets r ' about the danger and applau<’ Its hearts content. The ,»es trial has done one thing at iesat for Rhea county. It made county authorities install electric fans in the court room. Two of the air producers are trained on Judge Raulston, while most of the correspondents are out of range. Dudley Field Malone, whom Dayton has credited with an oratorical victory over William Jennings Bryan, went around to day wondering anew at the ex poits of science. Just after mak ing his speech yesterday, Malone started for Robinson’s drug store. At its door, he Was met by a messenger boy with a tele gram from a friend in Chicago congratulating him on the speech. “It was a mystery to me,” said Malone, “until I realized my friend had heard the speech over the radio. But it proved that science Is a wonderful thing.’” “We’ve got a mania for govern ment in this country,” said Clar ence Darrow today, "and we won’t let men be free.” The Chicagoan declared the Scopes trial was but one phase of the present “era of intolerance.” “This era will go on for a little while,” he added, "and then blow up” The army of pit men, barkers and concessionaries, who invaded Dayton with the opening of the trial, are beginning to take the long journey home. The crowds of visitors from the surrounding mountain lands did not prove witling patrons. Saves Two From Wreck
A gossip/entertainment column notes the small actual crowd at the Scopes trial site despite media hype, contrasting it with a story about a performer named Patricia Salmon. It mentions in passing that Scopes has received show business offers but likely lacks talent for it.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 9
THE GATE-POST
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
This is a humor column poking fun at the Scopes 'Monkeyville' trial, including jokes about evolution and a cartoon depicting fundamentalist beliefs like Jonah and the whale. It blends satire with a sentimental aside about the importance of motherhood and childbirth.
The Washington Times · 17 July 1925 · page 18
« <■ . • rwe • i The milk in the cocoanut at this Scopes trial is what brand of tadpole we come from. I have a friend who looks like a
Judge Raulston ruled scientific/expert testimony inadmissible in the Scopes trial, leading to a heated exchange between Arthur Hays, Darrow, and the judge. Court adjourned until Monday so the defense could prepare written statements of what their excluded expert witnesses would have said.
Americus Times-Recorder · 17 July 1925 · page 1
INDICATION TRIAL WILL END ON MONDAY
DAYTON, July 17. —After Judge John T. Raulston had excluded scientific testimony in the Scopes case, court was adjourned until Monday morning at 8 o'clock. The intervening it was an nounced, was to be spent by counsel for the defense in preparing their statements for record, of what their witnesse« would have testified, had they been permitted to take the witness stand. The judge’s decision to exclude experts from the witness stand de veloped a sharp clash between Ar thur Hays, Judge Ralston and Clar ence Darrow in the court room.
See moreSee less
Although the court was in ses sion for only 30 minutes this morn ing, these 30 minutes were the stormiest of the evolution trial, and the spectators were afforded a great deal of amusement when Hays, Raulston and Darrow engaged in
A photograph caption describes Clarence Darrow's impassioned assault on "bigotry" during the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. The image was taken during this dramatic courtroom moment.
Americus Times-Recorder · 17 July 1925 · page 1
—Hayden Smith, 17, of Schenectady £as confessed to the murder of Ziba C. Nickerson, 29, of Chatham, Massachusetts and Chicago, authori ties announced Thursday. Nicker son’s body walKfound Sunday con cealed in bushes along a highway near this city. i \ ? J f i This was snapped during Clar ence Darrow’s impassioned assault on “bigotry” during the Scopes trial at Dayton, Tenn. At the right
In New York, Peter Mangin got into an argument with his wife about evolution and the Scopes case, then leaped onto a chandelier and swung from it like a monkey until it tore from the ceiling. His wife called police, and he was taken to the hospital.
Americus Times-Recorder · 17 July 1925 · page 2
MONKEY ACT FOLLOWS ARGUMENT WITH WIFE
APE TAKES MATTERS INTO HIS OWN HANDS NEW ORLEANS, July 17.—Ap parently angered at the panning his rare is receiving at the hands of lawyers in Dayton, Tenn., a large black" monkey Thursday mounted a tall free in the exclusive residence section here and gazed toward the seen#'of the “monkey trial.” Fail ing to see Dayton, his anguish was mad#* known by a loud chattering. Mang; residents and passersby were attrrftted. Someone poked the an cestry of man and down he came to uo battle. Three men bitten and the Monkey counted out after sev eral blows with a club was the out com#: The monkey has not been identified.
This item presents photographs of Sue K. Hicks and J. J. McKenzie, two attorneys assisting in the prosecution of John T. Scopes in the Dayton, Tennessee evolution trial. The captions identify their roles without providing detailed narrative about trial proceedings.
Americus Times-Recorder · 17 July 1925 · page 5
. A-.jiSk Above is J. J. M -Kenzie, assistingj th<- prosecution in the eyoluiion trial of John T. Scope: at Dayton. Examine flies before taking an afternoon nap. Soria them in. y wearing hobnailed shoes,
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Judge Raulston refused to admit scientific and religious testimony into evidence in the Scopes trial, prompting defense attorneys to declare their hopes for the trial effectively over. The excluded evidence will instead be entered into the record as affidavits for use in appeals to higher courts.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 17 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SCOPES SCIENTIFIC TESTIMONY EXCLUDED IN STORMY SESSION
SCOPES LAWYERS LOSE ALL HOPE WHEN COURT REJECTS WITNESSES
See moreSee less
NEAL ADMITS HE HAS REACHED END DEFENSE FIGHT
EVIDENCE WILL GO INTO RECORD IN FORM OF AFFIDAVITS.
By The Associated Press,
DAYTON, Tenn., July 17.—Refusal of Judge Raulton to admit scientific and religious testimony into the evidence of the Scopes case marked the end of the defense hopes for the trial, attorneys for the defense said today, after adjournment of court until Monday, when affidavits containing this evidence will be admitted to record for transmission to the higher courts. "This is the end of our hopes for the trial of this case,'' was the comment of John R. Neal, chief defense counsel.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Judge Raulston excluded scientific testimony in the Scopes trial, leading to a sharp clash between Arthur Hays, Darrow, and the judge. The court recessed until Monday, with the defense seeking to place proposed testimony on record for appeal purposes.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 17 July 1925 · page 1
SHARP CLASHES FOLLOW REPORT - COURT IN RECESS UNTIL MONDAY WITH CHANCE TO CONCLUDE TRIAL ON THAT DAY
o'clock. The interveniiig time was 1o 'be spent by counsel for the defensel” in preparing statements for record of - what their witnesses would bhave tesfif" tilied hiad they been permitted to take!: the witness stand. * ° s ad The judge's decision to_ exclude. ey | perts from the witness stand devel'olp-’:‘, ed a sharp clash between ‘Arthyy’ Hays, ‘Judge 'Raulston”and Clarence: Darrow ‘in -the cofirt. * Althoigh ‘tue tcourt was in session only thirty mig utes it was stormy. 'Raulston ‘indj: cated that on his return, to the bén¢h 'Monday he would insist on the case ‘moving more rapidly. This was tak ‘en to mean that the ease might e'n'd: i Monday. ¢ el
The article summarizes the Tennessee law banning the teaching of evolution and explains how John T. Scopes discussed it in a Dayton store, noting that the state-adopted textbook taught evolution in violation of the statute. It describes how a test case was arranged, leading to the nationally watched trial.
Adams County Witness · 17 July 1925 · page 2
WHAT IT IS ABOUT
teacher in any of the universities, normals,and all other public schools of the state which are supported in whole or in part by the public school funds to teach any theory that denies the story of the divine creation of man as taught in the Bible and to teach instead that man has de scended from a lower order of ani mals.” The law fixes penalties from £100 to $500 for those who violate it. Governor Peay, who signed the act last March, said at the time that it was a distinct protest against an irreligious tendency to exalt so-called science and deny the Bible.
See moreSee less
In a discussion of this law in a Dayton store, John T. Scopes, a teacher pointed out that one of the public school textbooks, adopted for use in Tennessee by the Governor’s com mission. taught evolution as a part of the subject of biology. This book, he said, could not be used without violating the law. A test case was arranged and this is what has attract ed nation-wide attention.
A photograph shows Clarence Darrow in shirt sleeves during his heated assault on 'bigotry' at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, while arguing against the validity of the indictment. The prosecution team, including William Jennings Bryan and his son, is shown seated to the left.
The Indianapolis Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
When Darrow Opened Fire
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific testimony on evolution was inadmissible before the jury, effectively leaving only closing arguments before a guilty verdict. A heated clash between Darrow and Bryan over cross-examining scientists led to a compromise allowing affidavits, with the trial adjourned until Monday.
The Indianapolis Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific expert witnesses could not testify before the jury, though their statements could be submitted as affidavits. The court adjourned amid tension, and afterward Raulston sought a photo with Bryan and Darrow, but Darrow and Malone declined to pose.
The Indianapolis Times · 17 July 1925 · page 17
SCOPES EXPERTS ARE RULED OUT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
The passage describes courtroom speeches by William Jennings Bryan and Dudley Malone during the Scopes trial, debating whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted. Bryan argued against allowing such testimony, while Malone passionately demanded the defense be permitted to call scientists and scholars to testify that evolution did not conflict with Genesis.
The Indianapolis Times · 17 July 1925 · page 17
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
William Jennings Bryan argued that jurors who were church members understood the Bible better than scientists, opposing expert testimony, and received enthusiastic applause despite court rules against it. Dudley Field Malone then delivered a passionate rebuttal demanding the defense be allowed to present scientific and biblical scholars, also receiving strong audience applause.
The Indianapolis Times · 17 July 1925 · page 17
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
At the Scopes trial, William Jennings Bryan argued against admitting expert scientific testimony, while Dudley Field Malone delivered a passionate rebuttal defending the right to present such evidence. Judge Raulston postponed his ruling until Friday, leaving the trial's length and direction uncertain.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION CASE AWAITS DECISION OF JUDGE TODAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone delivered a dramatic speech demanding that scientific witnesses be allowed to testify, framing the case as a 'duel to the death' for truth. William Jennings Bryan countered forcefully that expert testimony on evolution was irrelevant since the law had already been passed by the legislature, with Judge Raulston reserving his ruling until Friday.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
This is a collection of photo captions covering the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, including Judge John T. Raulston, prosecutor B. G. McKenzie, and defense attorney Clarence Darrow. It also includes unrelated news items about Mme. Caillaux's car accident, a Chicago poisoning suspect, Prince Aage of Denmark's military honors, and an air search for a murder suspect.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 17
Tries Scopes 'ouo^^irZ£iL Although engrossed tn the trial b£ Prof. John T. Scopes, charged with having violated the anti-evo lution law. Judge John T. Raulston (aoove), before whom the case ii ielng tried, finds time to smile foe photographer*. Injured L xauXai • While her husband, Finance Min ister Joseph Caillaux, was cele brating two political victories, Mme. Caillaux was seriously injured In an automobile accident while racing to Mainers from the Brit anny coast to learn the election results. In “Ape” Trial p a ?. j. c. ' jav-gir
The Mishawaka public library reports a sharp increase in demand for its twenty-three books on evolution since the Scopes trial began in Dayton, Tennessee, with often fewer than five available at any time. The librarians note most titles are pro-evolution, listing works by Darwin, Osborn, and others.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 15
ON EVOLUTION BOOKS No matter what the outcome of the trial of a Tennessee school teacher for teaching evolution theo ries, residents of Mishawaka will be well informed regarding the subject around which the trial centers if public library records here are any sort of barometer. There are twenty-three books dealing with evolutiorr on local lib rary lists, but since the Scopes trial opened in Dayton, Tenn., there have seldom been more than five of these books in the library at any one time, librarians stated Thursday that a greater demand for the evolution books exists than for any other sub ject.
See moreSee less
* A majority of the books in lib rary stacks here are entirely “pro evolutionary.” Only three or four of them attack the theory, first ad vanced by Charles Darwin, that man was evolved from lower forms of life. The following list of titles and authors, dealing with evolution were prepared by Mishawaka librarians Thursday: “Man's Life on Earth,” Schumak er: "Meaning of Evolution,” Schu maker; “Evolution and the Chris tian,” Lane; “Man, the Animal,” Smallwood; “The Earth Speaks to Bryan,” Osborn; “Concerning Evo lution,” Thomson; “Origin and Evo lution of Life,” Osborn; “New Stone Age,” Tyler; “Origin and Nature of Life,” Moore; “System of Animate Nature,” Thomson;" Primer of Evo lution,” Clodd; “Origin of the Spe cies," Darwin; “Descent of Man,” Darwin; “Evolution or Christianity,” Goldsmith; “History of Creation,”
William Jennings Bryan argues against the teaching of evolution, criticizing Hunter's Civic Biology textbook used by Scopes. He mocks the book's species counts and contrasts Christian belief with evolutionary theory, while the court awaits a judge's decision.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 4
EVOLUTION CASE AWAITS DECISION OF JUDGE TODAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
William Jennings Bryan delivers an impassioned courtroom speech denouncing evolutionary theory, citing Hunter's Civic Biology textbook used by Scopes and mocking its claims about species counts. He argues evolution is merely a hypothesis, not proven science, and warns it will turn children into skeptics and agnostics by excluding God from scientific explanation.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Bryan testifies about evolution's conflict with Biblical teachings, arguing it undermines Christian doctrines like the virgin birth and resurrection. He links evolutionary philosophy to the Leopold-Loeb murder case, provoking an angry rebuttal from Darrow who denies the connection and defends science.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
An opinion piece reflects on a religious revival's power to heal communal hatred, then pivots to mock a different controversy: an Illinois police chief banning women from smoking in public. The writer sarcastically suggests Scopes trial lawyers take up this new 'modernist vs fundamentalist' fight after Scopes is jailed.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 6
ONE MORE JOB
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
A miscellaneous humor column from a South Bend newspaper makes a joking reference to the Scopes trial, suggesting a local teacher should get attention by disagreeing with Einstein. The item is mostly unrelated filler content including musings on marriage, divorce, and prohibition.
South Bend News-Times · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
John Thomas Scopes entered a plea of not guilty to violating Tennessee's anti-evolution law after Judge Raulston ruled the law constitutional. The trial then proceeded, with the jury sworn in and seated in the jury box.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
Judge Raulston ruled the Tennessee anti-evolution law constitutional and denied the defense motion to quash the indictment, ordering the Scopes trial to proceed on its merits. Southern politicians announced plans to push for a similar federal anti-evolution law in Congress.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 2
SOUTHERN POLITICIANS TO SEEK NATIONAL ANTI-EVOLUTION BILL IN CONGRESS; LAW RULED VALID
ment be quashed. the second indictment against Scopes. Judge Uaulston’s decision held that the state of Tennessee was “within its constitutional police powers in prohibiting the teaching of any theory of evolution that denied the biblical story of the creation of man.”
Judge Raulston overruled the defense's constitutional objections to the Tennessee anti-evolution law in an 8,000-word decision, prompting an exception from Clarence Darrow. Attorney General Stewart apologized to defense attorney Hayes for a discourteous remark, drawing applause from the courtroom crowd, while the judge continued investigating a news leak to the International News Service.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 2
DAYTON CROWD APPLAUDS SCOPES' DEFENSE; STATE APOLOGIZES FOR HARSH WORDS; JUDGE PROBES LEAK
case. Crowd Applauds Hayes. Clarence Darrow, ranking defense attorney, made the formal exception to Raulston’s ruling. It was entered on the record. Some of the bad feeling between lawyers was removed when Attorney General A. Thomas Stewart arose to apologize to Arthur Garfield Hayes for his “shut your mouth” statement made during yesterday’s session. Stewart said he was “very much ashamed” for his discourteous remark. A burst of applause greeted Stewart’s state ment. “I accept the apology.” said Hayes, "if the state’s attorney will refrain from further reference to the states from which defense counsel came.” The crowd applauded Hayes, investigate Leak. The court then renewed his investi gation lot the “scoop” carried yester day by the International News Service
Judge Raulston ruled the Tennessee legislature had authority under its police powers to prescribe school curricula and textbooks, rejecting the defense's Fourteenth Amendment challenge. The report also covers a committee's investigation into a leaked news bulletin that correctly predicted the judge's ruling before it was announced.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 2
HARSH WORDS; JUDGE PROBES LEAK
Report on News Leak. Beamish submitted the following re port: “The committee appointed by your honorable court to investigate a re ported news leak of the substance of your honor’s opinion upon the motion to quash the indictment of John T. Scopes respectfully reports: That it
This opinion piece argues that anti-evolution and compulsory Bible-reading laws serve capitalist interests by keeping workers religiously docile and distracted from fighting for better wages and conditions. It claims ruling classes favor such laws to prevent the working class from becoming militant, and separately criticizes French socialists for hypocrisy regarding imperialism in Morocco.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
An op-ed in the Daily Worker argues that American public schools indoctrinate students with nationalist propaganda and that teachers are cowed by orthodox views, citing the Scopes trial as proof. It calls on teachers to organize into unions to defend their independence and improve pay.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
The Daily Worker reports from Dayton, Tennessee, describing the town as dominated by evangelists and bible-driven fear ahead of the Scopes trial, linking this religious fervor to racial oppression of Black residents. The piece claims the all-church-going jury reflects the area's ignorance and argues fundamentalists fear the defense's scientists will undermine their worldview.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 5
SUPPRESSION OF SCIENCE GOES HAND IN HAND WITH OPPRESSION OF WORKERS IN BACKWARD SOUTH
Nejjro Is Oppressed. The 100 per centers of Genesis are filed with fear that perchance this Scopes evolution trial will produce a little intelligence and civilisation that
The report describes the Scopes trial jury as uneducated, superstitious churchgoers fearful of science, aligned with Bryan against Darrow's scientific witnesses. It frames the conflict as part of a broader capitalist suppression of scientific knowledge that could incite workers' revolt, quoting Huxley on economic oppression.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 5
OF WORKERS IN BACKWARD SOUTH
Afraid of Scientists. Yes, Bill Bryan and his gang of morons are over filled with fear and anxiety over the fact that the defense attorneys led by Darrow and Malone will bring in a host of scientists to prove that evolution is a proven sci ence, not a dream. Not only is it feared that the scientists will destroy some of the myth laden minds Os this town, but the elders of the church who are consciously or unconsciously, directly or indirectly aligned with the rulers of our imperialistic government and capiatlist owned industries wll find that with a knowledge of modern science goes a revolt at modern eco nomic society.
See moreSee less
Thomas H. Huxley, the acute, yet cautious scientist and follower and expounder of the Darwinian theory of evolution showed in his day that sci ence is In harmony and leans lire people towards industrial freedom I 'and against industrial slavery and ’Capi talist dominance. He showed an example of this when he, himself, turned his energy sot the ending of the present economic sys tem of society. Thus did he make, his views clear: "Under capitalism there is a a condition in which food, warmth, and clothing which are necessary for the mere maintenance of the functions of the body in their normal state, can not be obtained; in which men, wom en, and children are forced to crowd into dens where decency is abolished, and the most ordinary conditions of healthful existence are impossible of attainment; in which the pains ac-
This passage is an opinion piece criticizing Judge Raulston as biased and fundamentalist, while linking Darwin's co-discoverer Wallace and Huxley to anti-capitalist views. The writer argues capitalism causes poverty and that the trial's jury and judge are inherently prejudiced against scientific truth.
The Daily Worker · 17 July 1925 · page 5
Thus spoke the Scientist Huxley and thus spoke Alfred R. Wallace co worker with Darwin in the discovery of the evolutionary theory. Here we learn that Huxley, the exponent of evolution, looks upon capitalism as a cause of poverty and degredation, and hence calls upon the workers and thinking people to put an end to this disgrace and hell that capitalism and its relgious-crazed henchmen have brot upon the producers of wealth and their wives and children. The cold and bitter experiences of the thinking wage-slaves of the United States has proven to them that cap italism is a crime and a destroyer of all that is good and noble in man, and that it is high time to abolish this crime and instead bring forward a system of society that will make for the economic and social betterment of the working and producing class, and destroy the capitalist parasites, and the religious parasites.
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific evidence on evolution offered by the defense was inadmissible, effectively leaving only closing arguments before a likely guilty verdict. Darrow clashed sharply with the court over the ruling, while Raulston allowed evidence to be entered for the record to support an appeal.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
EVIDENCE IS RULED OUT
teacher guilty. In holding , Judge Raulston said his duty to be to take the intent of the legislature's opinion in ; passing the anti-evolution law into consideration and not quibble over te defense. against the ived he eon general
Judge Raulston upheld the prosecution's interpretation of the Tennessee anti-evolution law, rejecting defense arguments that it was unconstitutional or unreasonable, while allowing expert testimony to be entered for the appellate record. Tensions flared between Darrow, Hays, Malone, Stewart, and Bryan over cross-examination of witnesses and courtroom conduct, with Darrow defiantly resisting the judge's rulings.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
and Arthur Garfield Hays. ; In the course of the wrangle, ! Stewart said the defense "is trying to make a farce out of the case.” Malone asked Stewart to with- । draw his remark. I’ll withdraw it," Stewart said. "but will substitute it with another. I he defense looks upon the trial as a chance to educate the world on • their theoiies of evolution.” .Malone denied that the defense i wa< here to “educate the word.” i “I f the defense is representing. he said, i anything outside the case,” he said,, "it is merely interested in neeting !
During the Scopes trial, Darrow objects to expert scientific witnesses being cross-examined, leading to a tense exchange with Judge Raulston over contempt. The judge adjourns until Monday to allow the defense to prepare affidavits of the excluded scientific testimony instead.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
don’t understand why every moti and every suggestion promptly overruled." _ , "I hope you don't intend this to, tie a reflection on this court," said Raulston. "Yon can hope.’ squaring himself. "I can do somethin? Raulston threateningly. "All right. all right." grimly standing determinedly his arms folded like Ajax defying the i - lightning. But Judge Kauiston refused to hold the distinguished Chicago lawyer in contempt and turned to Bryan, who asked something about cross exam- ' ination. "You would not have the right to cross examine." said Darrow emphat ically to Bryan.
See moreSee less
be testifying for the information of 6the court and not subject to cross examination." After a wrangle over how the ex cluded testimony was to be present ed to the court for its information. Judge Raulston ordered adornment until 9 a. m. Monday. This was to permit the defense to get up the banned testimony in the I form of affidavits which will be sub mitted Monday. i* t 9 make we replied Darrow, said else said Darrow. with I “The witness would (
William Jennings Bryan made his first speech of the Scopes trial, arguing against the admission of scientific expert testimony on evolution. He addressed accusations that he was the chief instigator of the case and defended his role, speaking before a packed, sympathetic courtroom.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 2
"the introduction of scientific testi tmony on evolution and the Bible in . the Scopes evolution trial his first made The commoner \ speech of the trial and he unleashed i‘ ' his most vibrant oratory to a crowd
William Jennings Bryan addresses the court, arguing that the Tennessee anti-evolution law needs no interpretation and that expert scientific testimony should not be admitted to question its validity. He contends the legislature clearly understood what it was prohibiting and that Scopes knowingly violated the statute.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 2
vor. E ink when we come to consider i mportance of this case that the yers on both sides should be l iven a hearing. “Our position is that the statute I (the anti-evolution law) is sufficient. It for :t needs no interpretation. ‘bids teaching of any theory that de ales the account of divine creation found in the Bible." Bryan then launched into a legal i analysis of the law and concluded that the Tennessee Legislature re
The report describes the ongoing Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, where teacher John Thomas Scopes is being tried for teaching evolution against state law, with Clarence Darrow and Malone defending him for free and William Jennings Bryan assisting the prosecution. It notes Darrow's powerful Monday speech, Bryan's silence under attack, the influx of journalists sending both true and fabricated stories, and includes commentary skeptical of Darwinism while praising Mendel's genetics work.
Telegraf · 17 July 1925 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This Czech-American newspaper commentary reflects on the Scopes trial in Dayton, arguing that Darwinism remains unproven theory and citing Mendel's genetics work as a challenge to evolution. It laments that the trial occurred, not because it could prove or disprove evolution, but because it causes scandal and mockery that weakens faith, citing scientists like Virchow and Osborn as believers in God despite their scientific work.
Telegraf · 17 July 1925 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Scopes trial continues in Dayton, Tennessee, with defense motions to skip the opening prayer and appoint a non-fundamentalist minister both rejected. Judge Raulston denied rumors that the case would be dismissed and threatened to hold reporters in contempt for publishing erroneous reports.
Le Messager · 17 July 1925 · page 1
LE PROCÈS SCOPES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Le Messager · Lewiston, Me.
Monsignor Hickey, dedicating a church in Providence, R.I., referenced the Scopes trial in Dayton during his sermon. He criticized those who sought to determine through legal proceedings whether man descended from apes or was created by God, urging them to humble themselves before Christ instead.
Le Messager · 17 July 1925 · page 1
SEVERES PAROLES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Le Messager · Lewiston, Me.
A satirical column reports a New York man went mad imitating a monkey after arguing about evolution and the Scopes trial. It also derides the Dayton proceedings as resembling a circus rather than a real trial.
Le Messager · 17 July 1925 · page 4
QUELQUES POTINS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A brief headline indicates a courtroom dispute in the Scopes trial, with William Jennings Bryan protesting the use of the word 'evolutionists.' The judge is reported to again be uncertain on a related point, though no further article text follows.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Judge Again In Doubt as Bryan Protests Word Of Evolutionists
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Judge Raulston adjourned court after a full day of arguments over whether to admit scientific expert testimony in the Scopes evolution trial. Bryan led the prosecution's push to exclude such testimony while defense attorneys Hays and Malone argued for its admission.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
During the Scopes trial, Bryan argued against admitting scientific experts as it would attack children's religious beliefs, while Malone argued the defense sought to keep the Bible in conscience while science took its place in schools. The debate arose after the defense recalled zoologist Dr. Maynard Metcalf as a test witness, though the judge had not yet ruled on whether such testimony would be allowed.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 3
SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
At the Scopes trial, the defense sought to introduce expert scientific testimony on evolution, which the prosecution moved to exclude as incompetent under the law. Darrow explained to Judge Raulston that the defense viewed the Genesis creation account as figurative rather than literal, compatible with evolutionary theory.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 3
Counsel Darrow Gives His Views on Creation and Evolution
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The editorial discusses testimony from an expert witness at the Dayton trial who stated science supports evolution's occurrence, though more certainly in lower animals than man. It argues Tennessee's law improperly lets religious majority opinion define scientific fact for public schools, blurring church-state separation.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 6
FACTS AND THEORIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The piece speculates on what would happen if Scopes had taught evolution using biblical verses from Psalm 139 instead of textbooks, mocking the law's inconsistency. It criticizes the blending of church and state affairs that the law creates.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 6
SUPPOSE HE HAD TAUGHT THIS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Two brief editorial comments reference the Scopes 'ape trial,' with the Boston Transcript comparing it to a Democratic convention for amusement value, and the Biddeford Journal noting naive hopes it will settle Fundamentalist-Modernist disputes. These appear amid unrelated local news items about road hazards and small-town happenings.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Mahnomen Pioneer · Mahnomen, Minn.
A Minnesota weekly's miscellaneous commentary column briefly mentions that a radio has been installed at Dayton, Tennessee to broadcast the Scopes evolution trial, framing it as ironic proof that 'science is all to the bunk.' The rest of the passage covers unrelated local topics like gasoline prices, weather, and county statistics.
The Mahnomen Pioneer · 17 July 1925 · page 2
In order to prove that science is all to the bunk, a radio has been in stalled at Dayton, Tenn., to broad cast the Scopes evolution trial.
The Scopes 'monkey trial' is underway in Dayton, Tennessee, with Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan as opposing counsel before Judge Raulston. After jury selection, Darrow argued that the Tennessee law restricting teaching of evolution violated religious freedom guaranteed by the state constitution.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Clarence Darrow argues before the court that the Tennessee legislature overstepped its authority by trying to define divine truth and restrict teaching. He contends the law is unconstitutional, violates freedom of religious worship, and represents religious bigotry akin to the Spanish Inquisition.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 4
LEGISLATURE ASSUMED TOO MUCH
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Gwiazda Zachodu = Western Star · Omaha, Neb.
The report describes the Dayton, Tennessee trial of teacher John Scopes for teaching evolution, noting the involvement of famous lawyers Darrow, Malone, and Dudley Field for the defense and Bryan and Stewart for the prosecution. It frames the case as part of a broader push by religious reformers to impose restrictions on American society, contrasting Protestant intolerance with Catholic openness to science, and notes Bryan's goal to enshrine the Bible in the Constitution, which President Coolidge fears could spark dangerous religious conflict.
Gwiazda Zachodu = Western Star · 17 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the notable roster of attorneys on both defense and prosecution sides, noting how Scopes gains publicity from the case. It also discusses William Jennings Bryan's push to enshrine the Bible in the Constitution, President Coolidge's fear this could incite religious strife, and press mockery of Bryan's stance given his support for prohibition.
Gwiazda Zachodu = Western Star · 17 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A journalist describes the carnival-like atmosphere in Dayton, Tennessee during the Scopes trial, including local characters, signs, and a drugstore scene after hearing Clarence Darrow argue for quashing the indictment. The piece captures the town's mix of commercialism and spectacle surrounding the trial.
The Chapel Hill Weekly · 17 July 1925 · page 1
PROFESSOR AND EDITOR SHOOED FROM TABLE TO MAKE ROOM FOR WELL-DRESSED CHIMPANZEE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Chapel Hill Weekly · Chapel Hill, N.C.
A reporter describes the carnival atmosphere in Dayton during the Scopes trial, including a hospitable hotel host and a drugstore known as a loafing spot. The centerpiece is an anecdote of a dressed-up chimpanzee being seated at the 'evolution table' to drink a Coca-Cola, displacing the writer and a colleague.
The Chapel Hill Weekly · 17 July 1925 · page 1
PROFESSOR AND EDITOR SHOOED FROM TABLE TO MAKE ROOM FOR WELL-DRESSED CHIMPANZEE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Chapel Hill Weekly · Chapel Hill, N.C.
A reporter describes the lighthearted mood in Dayton, Tennessee during the Scopes trial, noting Scopes's modest reaction to fame and the town's enjoyment of its sudden notoriety. The piece also includes unrelated local color items about children camping out and a runaway goat.
The Chapel Hill Weekly · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Chapel Hill Weekly · Chapel Hill, N.C.
This editorial from the Chapel Hill Weekly criticizes William Jennings Bryan's character and intellectual substance, timed to his arrival at the Scopes trial in Dayton. It reviews his political history—free silver, Philippine withdrawal, and other causes—arguing he has never said anything sensible despite his oratorical skill.
The Chapel Hill Weekly · 17 July 1925 · page 2
The Quality of Mr. Bryan
Twenty-nine years of con stant talking, and on no imporj tant issue, in all that period, has he said anything sensible. j A story has come down in history that Charles the Second remarked of his nephew-in-law. Prince George of Denmark: “I have tried him sober and I have tried him drunk—and. drunk or sober, there is nothing to him." One might paraphrase this and say with truth: we have heard Mr. Bryan on politics, economics,
A photo caption describes Clarence Darrow's passionate courtroom argument against the validity of the indictment during the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. It depicts Darrow in shirt sleeves at right, with defense counsel including William Jennings Bryan and his son shown at left.
The Bismarck Tribune · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific expert testimony in the Scopes trial, leading to heated exchanges between Raulston, Hays, and Darrow. The defense requested a weekend recess to prepare statements for the record, and court adjourned until Monday with the judge indicating he wanted the case to move faster.
The Bismarck Tribune · 17 July 1925 · page 1
DEFENSE HIT HARD BLOW IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
William Jennings Bryan argues evolution is merely a hypothesis that undermines children's faith in the Bible and God, criticizing outside attorneys for interfering in Tennessee's education. Dudley Malone and Clarence Darrow respond, defending scientific teaching and explaining the defense's view that Genesis should be read figuratively rather than literally.
The Bismarck Tribune · 17 July 1925 · page 1
EXPERTS ARE EXCLUDED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
The report quotes a defense witness explaining the theory of evolution, describing life as originating from a single cell and progressing through stages to man. The witness argues this theory is not inconsistent with the biblical creation story, noting that views on immortality vary among evolutionists.
The Bismarck Tribune · 17 July 1925 · page 3
DEFENSE HIT HARD BLOW IN SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Palisadian · Cliffside Park, N.J.
An editorial discusses the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, noting the teacher was charged for possessing a textbook on evolution, which the state constitution banned from being taught. It praises Judge Raulston's conduct and remarks that William Jennings Bryan has been less combative than expected.
Palisadian · 17 July 1925 · page 4
THE TENNESSEE TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Palisadian · Cliffside Park, N.J.
This editorial opinion piece discusses the ongoing Scopes trial, praising Judge Raulston's handling of the case while noting that William Jennings Bryan has disappointed observers by not being as combative as expected. It also muses on evolution as theory versus fact before shifting to an unrelated item about pipe smoking etiquette.
Palisadian · 17 July 1925 · page 4
THE TENNESSEE TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Butler County Press · Hamilton, Ohio
A satirical column by I. C. McCumber derides the Scopes trial as a sideshow of charlatans and lawyers attacking the Bible, while describing Dayton, Tennessee as a quiet Southern village unsettled by the spectacle. The writer also digresses into criticism of prohibition hypocrisy and liquor prices.
The Butler County Press · 17 July 1925 · page 5
THE KALEIDOSCOPE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
A bank advertisement mentions that the Scopes evolution trial is currently in progress at Dayton, Tennessee, but says the bank doesn't much care about the outcome. It uses the trial as a segue to promote savings and banking habits.
Yorkville Enquirer · 17 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
Judge John T. Raulston rejected the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He spent a day writing a detailed opinion addressing each defense contention, including the claim of discrepancy between the act's title and body.
Yorkville Enquirer · 17 July 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
A local newspaper account describes a sermon by Dr. John K. White in Anderson comparing the current Scopes evolution controversy to an earlier dispute involving Dr. Woodrow, predicting it too would soon be forgotten. The sermon emphasized faith over complete knowledge and framed the trial as a passing controversy rather than reporting on the trial proceedings themselves.
Yorkville Enquirer · 17 July 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
A newspaper opinion column notes that Judge Raulston at Dayton has upheld the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law, calling it unsurprising. The writer sarcastically suggests the judge is determined to make the most of the trial's spectacle.
Yorkville Enquirer · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
A brief news roundup item notes that the anticipated huge crowds for the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee have not materialized. While many people including 'cranks and fanatics' are present, the expected volume of business has not developed.
Yorkville Enquirer · 17 July 1925 · page 4
MERE-MENTION.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone argued for the court to allow expert testimony so the jury could be informed on evolution science, speaking on behalf of schoolchildren and teachers. The prosecution, led by William Jennings Bryan Jr. and later Bryan himself, opposed admitting such testimony, and the judge ultimately excluded it.
The Union Daily Times · 17 July 1925 · page 2
JUDGE EXCLUDES TESTIMONY OF EXPERTS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
A reader's letter argues the Scopes trial is really a contest between evolution and Christianity, embodied by Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan. The writer praises the judge's decision to open court with prayer over the defense's objection and argues Christianity's long endurance proves its truth.
The Union Daily Times · 17 July 1925 · page 2
SOME MORE THOUGHTS ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
Judge Raulston ruled to exclude scientific expert testimony from the Scopes evolution trial, sparking heated exchanges between the defense attorneys and the court. Court adjourned until Monday, with the judge indicating he would push for a faster resolution of the case upon return.
The Union Daily Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
JUDGE EXCLUDES TESTIMONY OF EXPERT SCIENTISTS IN DAYTON MONKEY TRIAL
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
At the Scopes trial, defense attorneys argued for the right to present scientific witnesses and argue the anti-evolution law's unreasonableness, while Judge Raulston resisted hearing testimony meant to challenge his prior ruling. Heated exchanges occurred between Darrow and the judge, with Bryan insisting the prosecution retain cross-examination rights if defense witnesses took the stand.
The Union Daily Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
DAYTON MONKEY TRIAL
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
The court debates whether the defense can present expert scientific testimony to the jury or must instead enter it into the record as affidavits, with Bryan demanding cross-examination rights. A heated exchange occurs between Darrow and Judge Raulston over the court's repeated denial of defense requests, before Darrow is granted the day to prepare his statements.
The Union Daily Times · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Herald and News · Newberry, S.C.
Senator Cole L. Blease said teachers in South Carolina should be required to profess belief in the deity of Jesus Christ, arguing evolution and that belief cannot be reconciled. He said he would push for a stricter anti-evolution law than one already proposed in the state legislature, amid the controversy sparked by the Scopes trial.
The Herald and News · 17 July 1925 · page 1
BLEASE PROPOSES ANTI-DARWIN LAW
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
After Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony from expert witnesses in the Scopes evolution trial, court was adjourned until Monday morning. The defense team plans to use the intervening time to prepare written statements for the record detailing what their witnesses would have testified, amid sharp clashes between attorneys Arthur Hays, Clarence Darrow, and the judge.
Brownsville Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
The court recessed amid defense insistence, with Judge Raulston signaling he would push for a faster pace upon return. A tense exchange occurred between Darrow and the judge over perceived bias, while Bryan argued for cross-examination rights on defense witnesses.
Brownsville Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
The report describes the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, noting the judge ruled the anti-evolution law constitutional and the state presented witnesses showing Scopes taught biology against the statute. It also describes the intense media circus surrounding the trial, including radio broadcasts and newsreel cameras, with no verdict expected that week.
Shenandoah Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 1
BABOON BRAWL HAS LIMELIGHT
Dayton, Tenn.. is crowded this week to such an extent that another visitor could not be squeezed between the surrounding hills with a shoe horn. It is the week of the trial of the celebrated “monkey case" or chimpanzee cause and the Judicial effort to trace the genealogy of the gorilla. Thus far the outstanding features of the trial of young Scopes for teach ing evolution in a state school, in vi olation of a statute prohibiting stch teaching has been the argument of counsel as to the constitutionality of the law.
See moreSee less
The fundamentalists heard a court house sermon through tie attorney general and the agnostrs were agitated by Darrow. The judte held the act constitutional and tn Monday the trial began. A few wi-j nesses were introduced to show that Scopes taught bioogy contrary to law. That was the state’s case. The de fense is now attempting to get evi dence before the jury showing whai evolution is. The jury hearing the case, when the judge lets them in court, is o( mediocre intelligence and probaly is as ignorant of the issues involved as almost all juries are of a court’s in structions and the technical pointf raised by attorneys. The case is being heard in a crowd ed court room before folks from ai over the United States. It is beia broadcast by radio and telegrapl Moving pictures are being made o the legal fiasco and the whole worl is looking towards Dayton. No decision on the matters involve is expected during the week.
This local social and gossip column from Woodstock, Virginia notes that townspeople are endlessly debating the Scopes evolution trial despite knowing little about Darwinian theory. It wryly comments on the amount of idle talk the case has generated among local 'philosophers' while other town news (visits, building projects) is also reported.
Shenandoah Herald · 17 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vashon Island News-Record · Vashon, Wash.
A local editorial comments on the ongoing Scopes trial coverage flooding the big dailies, praising both Bryan and Darrow as good men despite their opposing views. It reflects on how both ultimately seek to bring brotherhood and love into the world, citing Henry Drummond's philosophy.
Vashon Island News-Record · 17 July 1925 · page 2
EERDEVES The big dailies are flooded with news and semi-news from the Scopes trial. Bryan is there sur rounded by Tennessee Baptists! and Democrats, and is the lion of! the town. Bryan is a good man and we are pleased to see him on the popular side of a question for once in his busy lifetime. Darrow maintains his usual mighty poise, and refuses to get exeited. He is also a good man bat in a different way. MHe believes liftle in human responsibility. He would allow everyone to think according to their own conscience, ‘would ex cuse the man who breaks some law based upon arbitrary legislation, has no patience with traditional New England Puritanism, but be licves in the Golden Rule with all his heart.
See moreSee less
These two opposing men—Dßßryan and Darrow—take different roads in their politieal and religious belief, but the hap |y part is they arrive at the same
This opinion piece contrasts Bryan and Darrow's differing political and religious views, suggesting both ultimately believe in universal brotherhood as the key to saving the world. It references Henry Drummond's writings on love and quotes Solomon to dismiss the Scopes trial's importance compared to the fundamental duty of fearing God and keeping his commandments.
Vashon Island News-Record · 17 July 1925 · page 2
man who loves his neighborl wouldn’t covet his neighbor’s wife. He wouldn’t steal his neigh.l bor’s horse. He wouldn’t cheat his neighbor in a business trans action. He wouldn’t be cruel to his own or his neighbor’s children. He wouldn’t shoulder a gun and go forth to shoot and kill! The News-Record dismisses the Scopes trial at this time by summing up all that seems important—taken from Solomon—'‘Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter, fear God and keep his command ments, for this is the whole duty of man.”’
Judge Raulston ruled that defense expert testimony on evolution science was inadmissible before the jury, leaving little left but closing arguments. After sharp exchanges between Darrow and Bryan, it was agreed scientists' testimony would be submitted as affidavits for the judge's consideration, with the trial adjourned until Monday.
The Seattle Star · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
During the Scopes trial, Darrow accused Judge Raulston of consistently favoring the prosecution, leading to a tense exchange where the judge demanded he not reflect on the court. Later, Raulston sought a group photo with Bryan and Darrow, but Darrow was busy and Malone declined to pose, leaving only Bryan and the judge photographed together.
The Seattle Star · 17 July 1925 · page 1
YOU CAN HOPE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
The London Chronicle, owned by Lloyd George, ran mocking headlines about the Scopes evolution trial calling it the 'Most Amazing Trial in World's History' with Americans tuning in to the 'Man or Ape Prosecution.' The editorial suggests that while the verdict on the 'monkey' may be undetermined, broader implications are already clear.
The Seattle Star · 17 July 1925 · page 8
: mind : . Lloyd George and Bryan ; it comments: - Q. Where did the phrass “The * United States of America,” as 19-1 ~ plied to this country, first make
Dudley Field Malone delivered the defense's opening address in the Scopes trial, outlining their strategy of requiring the prosecution to prove what evolution actually is. He acknowledged a direct conflict between evolution and biblical creation accounts, while noting that biblical creation stories themselves are internally inconsistent.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 4
"We Appeal to Bryan of Yesterday," Scopes Champion Cries - DEFENSE CASE IS OUTLINED BY D.F. MALONE
BY D.F. MALONE DAYTON, Tenn. — Dudley Field Malone, New York, made the opening address for the defense in the Scopes trial Wednesday. “The defense,” he began, “believes that God is a Spirit and they must wor ship Him in spirit and in truth.” Malone then read the first section of the act making it unlawful to teach in state schools “any theory that denies the story of the divine creation of man as taught in the Bible and to teach instead that man descended from a lower order of animals.” “We will prove that whether this statute be constitutional or uncon stitutional, the defendant Scopes did not and could not violate it,” he said.
See moreSee less
“We maintain that since the defendant Scopes has been indicted under a statute which prohibits the teaching of the evolutionary theory, the prosecution j mst prove as part of its case what evolution is.
Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone argues the prosecution must prove what evolution is, asserting there is a direct conflict between evolutionary theory and biblical creation accounts. He contends Genesis contains multiple conflicting creation stories, that science and Christianity occupy separate fields, and that Scopes's innocence requires recognizing no science can be taught without evolution.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 4
BY D.F. MALONE
“We shall prove by experts and scientists in every field of scientific knowledge that there is no branch of science which can be taught with out teaching the theory of evolution. “Bryan of Yesterday.” “The defense maintains that the book of Genesis is in part a hymn, in part an allegory and a work of religious interpretation, written by men who believed that the earth was flat and whose authority can not be accepted to control the teach ing of our schools. “The narrow purpose of the de fense is to establish the innocence of the defendant, Scopes.
See moreSee less
The broad purpose of the defense will be to prove that the Bible is a work of religious aspiration and rules of conduct which must be kept in the field of theology.” Malone then quoted from what purported to be a declaration of Mr. Bryan’s, delivered 20 years ago, on Thomas Jefferson’s Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom^ saying, “The defense appeals from the fundamentalist Bryan of today to the modernist Bryan of yester day.”
Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone argues science and theology occupy separate fields, calling on evolution theory as essential to all science, while contrasting Bryan's past support for religious freedom with his current fundamentalism. The report also covers a heated exchange where Attorney General Stewart calls Darrow an agnostic, which Darrow embraces as a compliment.
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, zoologist Maynard Metcalf testified after the jury was excused, telling defense attorney Clarence Darrow that evolution is an absolute fact though specific theories about it vary. The defense hoped his testimony would help educate Judge Raulston on modern science.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Says Evolution Is Now Proved Fact
Fact Is Absolute. “The fact of evolution is abso lute,” Metcalf replied. “There are, however, dozens of theories of evo lution, some absurd. “Evolution means the change of an organism from one character to a different character. The term in general means the whole series of changes which have taken place during hundreds of millions of years.” Metcalf went on to point out that
A scientific witness testifies that man belongs among the primates, grouped with lemurs and monkeys, though not as specialized physically as some other animals. He argues that while direct proof of human evolution is scarce, overwhelming evidence from other animals makes human evolution highly probable.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Proofs of Evolution. “Man is not as highly evolved in his' body, not as highly specialized as some other animals,” he con tinued. “The hand, for instance, is not as finely specialized as the claw of a bird, but man belongs well up in the group of primates, nevertheless. “Fundamental proofs of evolution are found not in man, but in lower animals. These proofs, found throughout the universe, make a tremendous probability in favor of the evolution of man. “The series of proofs are so con vincing that any informed man can not doubt the probability of man’s evolution.”
Attorneys argued over whether expert scientific testimony on evolution would be admissible before the Scopes jury, with the defense seeking to show evolution does not conflict with the Bible. Judge Raulston had to intervene as prosecution and defense counsel clashed over procedure for the arguments.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 1
IF RULED OUT DAYTON TRIAL WILL BE ENDED
Much Hangs on Ruling. Upon Judge Raulston’s ruling de pends whether the testimony of noted scientists and educators will be presented to the Scopes jury. Clarence Darrow made a state ment to the judge outlining what the defense hoped to prove by such testimony. “We expect to show,” said Dar row, “by scientists and real schol ars of the Bible, first, what evolu tion is and, second, that by any in terpretation educated men can show that evolution is not in conflict with the Bible.” A squabble promptly broke out among counsel as to the procedure in the argument, the prosecution seeking to maneuver it so that they would have an opening and closing argument on the question and the defense seeking the same advantage for themselves.
See moreSee less
Judge Raulston had to caution the attorneys not to fight among themselves, but to address all re marks to him. Atty. Gen. Stewart presented to the court a motion to exclude the scientific testimony on the ground that under the interpretation of the wording of the act it would be en tirely incompetent. Malone followed Stewart, to in sist that the agreement entered into by the two staffs Friday to take up the question of scientific testimony out of order be adhered to.
An opinion piece argues that juries cannot settle scientific questions like evolution, which are determined by scientists studying evidence. It quotes Darrow calling the anti-evolution law foolish and wicked, and criticizes Bryan and the law for stirring religious hatred.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 16
ECHOES OF THE BATTLE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
The passage reproduces House Bill No. 185, the Tennessee law prohibiting the teaching of evolution in public schools, signed by Governor Austin Peay on March 21, 1925. It outlines penalties for teachers found guilty of violating the act, including fines between $100 and $500.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 16
New Tennessee Law That Brought About Famous Scopes Trial
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
The editorial compares Mussolini and William Jennings Bryan as power-hungry figures who impose their will on others. It criticizes Bryan for wanting to dictate what children are taught and for opposing evolution while offering no logical reason to prefer belief over theory.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 16
DICTATOR AND REALTOR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
At the Scopes trial, Bryan Jr. argues expert scientific testimony on evolution is incompetent and irrelevant, citing legal precedent that jurors might substitute experts' opinions for their own. The courtroom is also described as a broadcasting hub sending the evolution-versus-religion debate to the American public.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 15
EXPERTS RAISE WAR IN DAYTON
RAGESJNDAYTON Continued From Page One. termine whether this case will be an orderly case, or whether it will de generate into a debate or whether •volution conflicts with the Bible,” said young Bryan. “This exi>ert evidence being of fered on evolution is challenged by the state as incompetent, irrelevant and immaterial. “1 have heard many harsh things said about expert witnesses. Even my friend Mr. Darrow, in the Loeb trial, referred to an expert witness as a ‘purveyor of perjury.’ I don't think I have heard anything strong er than that.
See moreSee less
“This kind of testimony has al ways been regarded by conservative jurors with great disfavor.” While young Bryan made his argument Darrow began reading a stack of letters before him. “ ‘The danger of such testimony is that jurors may substitute such opinions for their own.’ ” young Bryan read from one of the pre cedents. W. J. Bryan, senior, moved out from behind the prosecution table and leaned forward in his chair, listening intently to his son and fanning himself with rapid strokes. Mrs. Bryan, Jr., prettily dressed in white, sat nearby, while from a corner of the platform his mother watched him and the judge.
The trial proceeds with arguments over admitting scientific testimony on evolution, as Darrow calls Professor Metcalf to testify while prosecution objects. The defense also challenges the prosecution to define 'the Bible' itself, noting multiple versions exist, while the courtroom is broadcast nationally.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 July 1925 · page 15
RAGES IN DAYTON
Judge Wants Light. The crucial state of the trial was reached late Wednesday after all legal preliminaries had been raced through and the presentation of testimony reached. Clarence Darrow called Prof. Met calf to the stand to explain evolu tion to the jury. Immediate objec tion was made by the prosecution to the introduction of Metcalfe’s or my other scientist’s evidence. Darrow asked that the matter be argued and the judge consented. “I want all the light I can get on the subject, gentlemen,” said Judge Raulston, “because the matter is ex tremely important and the most dif ficult upon which I will have to rule.” The defense sprang a surprise on the prosecution hy demanding that proof be given by the latter regard ing “what is the Bible?” Stewart introduced in evidence a copy of the King James version saying there were literally scores thought theories contrary to the Bible’s account of the creation of man.
See moreSee less
The defense strongly objected, saying theer wer eliterally scores of different versions and the state would have to establish what is the Bible. More will be heard on this question later if the scientific testimony is admitted.
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude expert scientific testimony from the Scopes evolution trial, a decision that produced heated clashes among Hayes, Darrow, and the judge. The defense will instead submit written statements of what their witnesses would have said, and court adjourned until Monday with the judge signaling he wants the case to move faster.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 17 July 1925 · page 1
RAULSTON EXCLUDES ALL SCIENTIFIC TESTIMONY FROM EVOLUTION TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
The defense sought to place its scientific testimony into the trial record for appeal purposes, arguing the law was unreasonable even without the jury present. A tense exchange occurred between Clarence Darrow and Judge Raulston over the court's repeated denials of defense requests.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 17 July 1925 · page 1
TESTIMONY FROM EVOLUTION TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
This report describes the scene inside the Rhea County courtroom during the Scopes evolution trial, noting Clarence Darrow's arrival with mail, crowded seating, and Mrs. Bryan's early presence. It also notes Judge Raulston's remark that only he and the stenographer knew his pending ruling on expert witness testimony, with the opinion still being prepared.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
The report notes a spirited debate over science and religion in the Scopes trial, with the judge considering whether the jury should hear scientific testimony. Bryan opposed allowing scientists to testify, arguing law is clear and experts should address the legislature instead, while Malone argued for intellectual liberty.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 17 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A news review discusses the Scopes evolution trial that opened in Dayton, Tennessee, noting it has drawn attention worldwide despite mockery. It covers William Jennings Bryan's statement that Christianity is on trial and the defense's countering argument that the trial should focus on the constitutionality of the anti-evolution law and the truth of evolutionary theory itself.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 5
NEWS REVIEW OF CURRENT EVENTS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Rev. W. G. Byrd resigned as pastor of a Dayton, Tenn. church after his congregation refused to hear a modernist preacher he invited, and plans to leave the ministry for electrician work. He is pictured with Dr. George Rappleyea, who planned the Scopes trial, amid criticism for allowing Rappleyea to attend his church.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Dayton Pastor, Bested in Evolution Controversy, Will Quit Ministry?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific expert testimony from the Scopes evolution trial, a decision expected to shorten the proceedings. The court recessed until Monday so the defense could prepare formal statements of what their excluded witnesses would have said, amid sharp exchanges between Raulston, Arthur Hays, and Clarence Darrow.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report quotes the judge's reasoning for barring expert scientific testimony in the Scopes trial, explaining that the court must interpret the statute rather than decide which theory—evolution or divine creation—is true. He states that determining the law's policy is a legislative, not judicial, matter, and that the court's role is limited to interpreting and enforcing the statute as written.
Paper unidentified · 17 July 1925 · page 5
SCIENTIFIC TESTIMONY BARRED IN SCOPES TRIAL AT DAYTON
| offered by the defendant. It is not within the province of the court under these issues to de i clde and determine which is true, the story of divine creation as taught in i the bible or the story of tho creation of man as taught by evolution. "If the state is correct in its Insist
The prosecution rested its case after four witnesses testified that Scopes taught evolution from a state-approved textbook and admitted he couldn't avoid violating the law. Judge Ralston denied the defense motion to quash the indictment, upholding the anti-evolution statute's constitutionality, while evangelist Billy Sunday and others weighed in publicly against Darwinism.
The Kusko Times · 18 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
'IF FROM MONKEYS 'Why Are There Any Monkeys Left?' Asks Billy Sunday. Dayton, July 15.—The state rested its case against John T. Scopes this afternoon, after the testimony of four witnesses had been heard. Former pupils of Scopes in the Rhea county high school presented testimony to the effect that Scopes had taught them a theory of evolution as expounded in an official text book of the state and that he had admitted he could not teach this book without violating the anti-evolution teaching statute of the state. Judge Ralston today denied the motion of the defense to quash the indictment against Scopes.
See moreSee less
The decision upheld the constitutionality of the Tennessee anti-evolution law. Counsel for the state made a formal motion to exclude testimony of scientists from trial of formal motion to exclude testi mony the case. Billy Sunday Wires Bryan. Billy Sunday, noted evangel ist, wired W. J. Bryan, of coun sel for prosecution, as follows: "If we descend from monkeys, why are there any monkeys left? Put me down on the side of God, Christ and the Bible?"
Evangelist Billy Sunday telegraphed Bryan opposing evolution teaching, while Tennessee's governor praised the prosecutor's handling of the Scopes case. The report also details how the state-adopted 1919 textbook 'Civic Biology,' which taught human evolution, formed the basis of the criminal case against Scopes.
The Kusko Times · 18 July 1925 · page 1
Basis of Criminal Prosecution of Scopes Dayton, Tenn.—A text book adopted by the Stale in 1919 is furnishing the basis ot tite criminal prosecution against John T: Scopes, science teacher and athletic director in the Dayton high school, charged with violating Tennessee s anti-evolution law. “Civic Biology ’ is the name of the book, and the author is George W. Hunter. The eutire bookdeals with evolution, and toward the end its teach ings are summed up as follows: “We have now learned that animal forms may be arranged so as to begin with lite very simple one-celled forms and culminate with a group which con tains man himself.” It was thin book which Scopes, as well as most of tlie science teachers in high schools of the state, continued to use iu his classroom after passage of the anti-evolution law, and it was on this that the state based its case and succeeded in having Scopes bound over to the grand jury.
See moreSee less
Carl Westberg, from Little creek, «*• a Tuesday town visitor
The Liberal Church of Denver elected Clarence Darrow to honorary membership because of his courtroom defense work in the Scopes evolution trial. Bishop Frank Rice announced the action and the church sent Darrow a letter expressing hope the trial would awaken progressive thought in America.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 18 July 1925 · page 1
ELECT DARROW CHURCH MEMBER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
During a recess in the Scopes trial, defense attorney Clarence Darrow criticized William Jennings Bryan for hiding behind legal technicalities rather than testifying under oath about his views on evolution and religion. Darrow also stated that Scopes was condemned from the start given the trial's setting, while affirming the broader fight for freedom to think and learn continues regardless of the verdict.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 18 July 1925 · page 1
DARROW SWATS BRYAN BECAUSE OF HIS VIEWS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Nome Nugget · Nome, Alaska
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Darrow argued the jury needed expert testimony to understand evolution, while Bryan contended the only issue was whether Scopes violated the law. Judge Raulston deferred ruling on admissibility of expert witnesses after hearing from Dr. Maynard Metcalf.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 1
Member of Associated Press DAYTON, July IT. (/p Dr. Maynard M. Metcalf unced ti»« 1 professor of zoology resumed the stand yesterady w;th the pening of the court for the Scopes evo lution trial. Th State made a strenuous effort to exclude scientific testimony, on the grounds that it had hearing on the case. Clarence Darrow st; t. ] that the defense expected to show what evolution i-u It was the attorney’s opinion that the jury could not make a decision in the case without knowing, ir having some idea about what evolution actually Metcalf was withdrawn temporarily as th* wit nesses and jury were excluded pending arguments of proceedure.
See moreSee less
William Jennings Bryan, arguing for the pros ecution said “The only issue in this case is this— the jury must decide whether Professor Scopes . elated the law. To permit testimony of -xper would 'ie to substitute a trial by experts for --1Ty denied this.
The judge ruled that scientific testimony on evolution was not competent in the case, deciding that the only issues were whether the law was constitutional and whether Scopes violated it. He had already upheld the law's constitutionality by denying the defense's motion to quash.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 1
ad de. (led :>* • unced ti»« 1 Scopes trial. :ng th*- judc. s justice to perm: n the length of '•ision tief'ourt tinsel will pro 'O attornys
The Scopes trial jury was completed, composed mostly of evangelical church members, with proceedings adjourned until Monday. Attorney General Stewart argued that Scopes's guilt hinges only on whether he taught evolution, not on evolution's scientific validity, making expert testimony irrelevant.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 3
SCIENCE WILL CI T NO ICE IX THE SCOPES CASE Dayton. July 11. (/PiThe court adjourned until Monday after com pleting the jury Friday afternoon. All hut one juryman belongs to evangelistic denominations. and this one. Harrow said, is a fun damentalist. One man who be longed to no church was rejected. Attorney General A. T. Stewart said for the Associated Press- — "it is my understanding tlvht Prof. Scopes will not deny that he taught the students of the high schools in Rhea County that man descended from a lower order of animals.
See moreSee less
If this is true, he is guilty, and all the evidence of scientists within reach cannot help him. Scientists might claim that man descended from lower animals by God’s cre ation but this cannot make a diff erence. The law says that such i a subject cannot be taught. If I such evidence is used, both sides
The jury of twelve was selected including nine farmers, a teacher, a fruit grower, and a shipping clerk. The defense, led by Clarence Darrow, moved to quash the indictment on constitutional grounds, arguing the anti-evolution law violated religious freedom protections.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 3
st OP KS DEFENSE ASKS INDICTMENT Qt'ASIIED Dayton. July 13. (&)— The evo lution trial resumed. The c urt opened following a motion of the j defense to quash the indictments. Harrow, defense counsul cited 14 j
At the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, defense attorney Clarence Darrow filed a formal objection to the court opening with prayer, a practice used in earlier sessions. Judge Raulston overruled the objection, stating he was responsible for the conduct of the court.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 3
DARROW OBJECTS TO OPENING THE COURT WITH PRAYERS
Scopes evolution trial. f'iarenee Harrow, defense attorney, tiled a formal objection to the opening of the court with a pray, r n the The attorney said in reference to this practice which had been in augurated in the former sessions of the case "I do not object to
The report previews the Scopes trial in Tennessee, noting that Bryan will represent the prosecution's anti-evolution stance while Darrow leads the defense. It notes the court ruled the sole issue is whether Scopes taught evolution, and speculates the trial's outcome will boost interest in evolutionary theory regardless of the verdict.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 4
RRY.W AM' RAP.P.Ott as the defendant, charged with vi.Uuin law which prohibits the teaching of theory in the school? of Tennessee. The Ketchikan Chronicle of a lai ments on the prospects of the case as f from the intense interest eneendered in this case by the novelty of the issue involved, added importance attaches to the trial because William Jennings Bry an. who is recognized as the foremost anti-evolu tionist in the country, and Clarence Darrow. criminal lawyer, evolutionist, will be arrayed against each other as assocate counsel." The court has ruled that the only issue in the case is ‘‘whether or not Scopes taught the theory of evolution to his classes or not."
See moreSee less
The world is waiting with interest to see what action will be taken by the defense to show their side of the question, of which so little is known, and the re sult of the trial, whether Scopes is convicted or not is bound to be that a greater demand for the theory of evolution will be noticed throughout the country. V:* •l|
A brief item notes that a prayer leader was selected for the Scopes trial proceedings, identified as being from a Unitarian Church in New York. The selection relates to the courtroom opening prayers during the ongoing Scopes trial in Dayton.
The Nome Nugget · 18 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A University of Pennsylvania Assyriology professor completed translation of Sumerian clay tablets from 2000 B.C. showing the ancient Euphrates Valley inhabitants grappled with a similar religious-scientific conflict over human origins. The ancients reportedly resolved it by compromising: man first existed as an animal, then gods created patrons who helped him develop further.
Seward Daily Gateway · 18 July 1925 · page 7
Evolution-Controversy Was Discussed 4,000 Years Ago
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
Judge Raulston rules to exclude testimony from scientists in the Scopes trial, narrowing the case to the simple fact of whether Scopes taught evolution, which he has already admitted. The columnist predicts the defense has little left to argue and expects the case to proceed to the U.S. Supreme Court on the broader constitutional question.
El Dorado Daily News · 18 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
In the Scopes trial courtroom, lawyers argued over whether defense experts could testify and be cross-examined, with Darrow sparring sharply with Judge Raulston. The court ultimately ruled testimony could be submitted as affidavits, and the session adjourned until Monday.
El Dorado Daily News · 18 July 1925 · page 4
JUDGE IS HAMMERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
Judge Raulston ruled to exclude scientific expert testimony from the Scopes trial, prompting sharp objections from defense attorney Arthur Hays and signaling the trial's imminent end. The defense planned to submit written affidavits from scientists instead, with closing arguments expected to send the case to the jury by Tuesday.