The Montgomery Advertiser · 10 May 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Test Case Being Conducted in Tennessee; Defense Claims Recent Law Enacted is Unconstitutional
See moreSee less
CONSTITUTIONALITY NOT PASSED ON BY JUSTICES
Text Book Introduced Shows Man Was of Low Form of Animal
DAYTON, TENN., May 9.—By The Associated Press.—J. T. Scopes, charged with violating the newly enacted Tennessee law against teaching evolution in schools of the state, late today was held for action by the Rhea county grand jury by three justices of the peace who conducted a preliminary hearing of the charges.
Bond was fixed at $1,000 but the state expressed a willingness to accept the recognizance of the defendant and the court acquiesed.
The defense was built upon a theory that the law enacted by the recent legislature was unconstitutional. To this however, Justice Benson, speaking for his two colleagues, Justices Green and Wilbur, said: "We feel that it is not within our rights to pass on the constitutionality or the wisdom of the law. The defendant is at least technically if not intentionally guilty, hence our decision to hold him for action by the grand jury."
After a defense plea of not guilty the state introduced one witness, Walter White, superintendent of public instruction of Rhea county. Mr. White identified the text book as one approved by the state board of education and as a result required as a part of the course of instruction in high schools, Mr. White said.
Mr. Scopes as the teacher of science in the Rhea county school taught the book and the defense made no denial of this charge. Mr. White said Mr. Scopes was "a good teacher."
Wallace C. Haggard, making the first argument for the state, claimed that the text book and the act of the general assembly showed a clear violation of the law. John Randolph Neal for the defense, declared the act incapable of enforcement and called attention to the fact that the word "evolution" appeared in the preamble but not in the body of the act.
"A civic biology" by George W. Hunter, a text book taught in the Rhea county high school was one of the exhibits on which emphasis was laid. A paargraph under the head of "the doctrine of evolution" was quoted as follows:
"We have now learned that animal forms may be arranged so as to begin with very simple one celled forms and culminate with a group which contains man himself. This arrangement is called the evolutionary series. Evolution means change and these groups are believed by scientists to represent stages in complexity of development of life on the earth. Geology teaches that millions of years ago life upon the earth was very simple and that gradually more and more complex forms of life appeared as the rock formed latest in time to show the most highly developed forms of animal life. The great English scientist, Charles Darwin, from this and other evidence, explained the theory of evolution. This is the belief that simple forms of life on the earth slowly and gradually gave rise to those more complex and that thus ultimately the most complex forms came into existence."
Another paragraph stressed was headed "evolution of man." It says:
"Undoubtedly there once lived upon the earth races of men who were much lower in their mental organization than the present inhabitants. If we follow the early history of man upon the earth we find that at first he must have been little better than one of the lower animals. He was a nomad wandering from place to place feeding upon whatever living things he could kill with his hands. Gradually he must have learned the use of weapons and thus kill his prey. First using rought stone implements for this purpose. As man became more civilized implements of bronze and of iron were used. About this time the subjugation and domestication of animals began to take place. Men then began to cultivate the fields and to (Continued on Page Two)
TEACHER HELD TO GRAND JURY EVOLUTION CASE (Continued from Page One.)
have a fixed place of abode other than a cave. The beginnings of civilization were long ago but even today the earth is not entirely civilized."
In connection with today's hearing Walter White, superintendent of schools, pointed out that Rhea county is developing into the testing ground of the state of Tennessee for its school laws. A case from this county state of Tennessee vs. Covell, was decided by the supreme court of the state in 1920 clarifying the compulsory school attendance law. The law provided Mr. White said, for compulsory school attendance from seven to sixteen years of age inclusive. He held that this should be construed to mean compulsory school attendance until the age of 17 while it was held in some counties that 16 was the maximum. A test case was made and decision handed down that children under the law should attend school until they reached 17.
The case will go before the grand jury convening the first Monday in August.
The act Scopes was charged with violating passed at the last session of the Tennessee legislature and became effective March 21.
The preamble to the act designates it as an act "prohibiting the teaching of the evolution theory in all universities, normal and all other public schools supported in whole or in part by public school funds of the state"
The act continues that it shall be a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of from $100 to $500 "to teach any theory that denies the story of the divine creation of man as taught in the Bible and to teach instead that man is descended from the lower order of animals."
The defense offered no testimony and admitted that the book was taught by the defendant in the science department as a part of the course. The defense, however, in argument centered a sweeping attack against the constitutionality of the law, claiming that the legislation violates both the constitution of the United States and that of the state of Tennessee.
John Randolph Neal, counsel for the defense with John L. Godsey, declared also that the act was improperly drawn in that evolution was mentioned in the preamble but not in the body of the act.
"We deny," Neal said, "that the theory of evolution is contrary to the story of divine creation taught in the Bible. Legislative enactment cannot make it so. Many clergymen believe every word of the Bible and accept the theory of evolution."