The Montgomery Advertiser · 9 July 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
See moreSee less
Commoner is Attempting "Ambitious Program," Prof. Neal, Defense Leader, Declares in Address
BY PHILIP KINSLEY (Staff Correspondent of The Chicago Tribune and The Montgomery Advertiser.)
DAYTON, TENN., July 8.—By The Chicago Tribune Press Service.—Preliminary verbal rumblings of William Jennings Bryan and his opponents in the Scopes evolution trial today may warn the religious liberals of the United States of the urgent need of action to save them from the river of oblivion in this struggle. Where is the grant of the modern church to heed these far of guns in the night?
Today's maneuvers, two days ahead of the opening of the trial, present a situation somewhat as follows:
Mr. Bryan who first said that the constitutional issue was the main one, has confounded the opposition by his sudden switch to the science and religion conflict. He makes science black and religion white.
"You have no idea what a black and brutal thing this evolution is," he is reported to have said as he leaned across the table at the blushing and embarrassed young defendant, John Scopes.
"This anti-evolution law," Mr. Bryan said tonight, "simply prohibits the evolutionists from using the public schools for the purpose of substituting their kind of religion for the religion of the masses."
While Mr. Bryan is thus bringing religion into the foreground, the defense, through Prof. John R. Neal, senior counsel, sought today to swing the constitutional issue, making religion secondary. It was only a short time ago that the defense attorneys were worrying about bringing the religious evolution controversy into the case.
Bryan Termed Ambitious
Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Hayes, defense lawyers, are supposed to be on their way here, but Mr. Bryan has the fort at present. Mr. Darrow is not of the Christian faith, which militates against his effect upon this situation.
Mr. Bryan's challenge was met by Prof. Neal as follows:
"We regard Mr. Bryan's speech last night the most remarkable utterance ever made by a lawyer just before his entrance into a trial of a criminal case. His speech comes as a challenge to the defense not to confine the test of the anti-evolution.. law to the existing limitation of the constitution of Tennessee or even the United States, but instead to put on trial the truth or lack of truth the theory of evolution; the conflict or lack of conflict between science and religion, having demonstrated as he apparently expects to do, at least to his own satisfaction, that evolution is untrue and that it is destructive to Christianity. He forecasts that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the supreme court of Tennessee, then to the supreme court of the United States and having lost his fight on account of the exitsing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational liberties he intends immediately to wipe these constitutional immunities by a new constitutional amendment—a very ambitious program, I should say—even for Mr. Bryan. We have no objections to his undertaking it, but we shall insist as we did at the very inception of this case, that the great issue in this case is not whether evolution is true or untrue, or even whether it conflicts with religion, but whether the Tennessee legisalture has not transcended the limit set upon its powers by the constitution of Tennessee and the constitution of the United States in passing the anti-evolution law and thus attempting to control the mind in its struggle after truth."
Colby Unable to Attend
In an address at a public dinner given by the prosecuting attorneys at Morgan Springs hotel tonight, Mr. Bryan baited the evolutionists as a minority group seeking to foist their kind of religion upon the public schools.
"With some," he said, "evolution is not only a religion but the only religion they have and they are guilty not only of trying to establish their religion by law but they are guilty of trying to establish it in spite of the objections of a majority.
"This trial will be better understood by the people of the nation when they understand that the real purpose is not to protect freedom of knowledge or freedom of investigation. But this law does not attempt to restrain either knowledge or investigation. The students under Mr. Scopes were not investigating, they were simply asked to accept evolutionary views as set forth in the text book and as interpreted by Mr. Scopes."
Mr. Bryan referred to evolution as "guesses strung together and substituted for God."
It seems to be definitely settled that Bainbridge Colby will not appear in this trial, although his services may be used in arguments on constitutional questions later. He wired Professor Neal today that he would be detained in a case in New York but that he stood ready to offer his services at any time to the defense.
Witnesses for the defense have been asked to start for Dayton. Their names will not be revealed until later, as the defense is afraid that some of them will be frightened away. Mr. Bryan with his coat off, spent most of the day working in the offices of Sue and Herbert Hicks, two of his assistants. He found a stack of mail two feet high awaiting him. He is planning when this trial is over to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land then write his memories. He is through with the lecture platform, and his real estate investments in Florida are said to have netted him a fortune. He is still interested in politics, however, and told men in his group at dinner last night that the next democratic nominee must come from the South or the West and frowned, it is said upon the suggestion of Al Smith.