As the Papers Told It

The Scopes Trial · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Biggest Show on Earth

June – July 1925

In June Scopes went to New York to confer with the Civil Liberties Union, and the defense lawyers were named. He had no teaching contract for the next term. Dayton made ready: guards on the water supply, health checks for the concessionaires, a telegraph office for the trial alone, monkey souvenirs in the shop windows. A federal judge refused to halt the trial, Bryan arrived on 7 July, and the two sides argued over whether the case was about religion or the constitution.

Page 194 of Hunter’s Civic Biology

The El Dorado paper reprints the page of George W. Hunter’s textbook that Scopes taught from: the doctrine of evolution, a table of over 500,000 animal species, and an evolutionary tree with the instruction ‘Copy this diagram in your note book.’ The same paragraph was stressed at the May hearing, and in July Scopes’s pupils told the grand jury that Hunter’s book was the one he used.

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

El Dorado Daily News · 2 June 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

The Paragraph That Began The War

194

See moreSee less

EVOLUTION

The Doctrine of Evolution. — We have now learned that animal forms may be arranged so as to begin with very simple one-celled forms and culminate with a group which contains man himself. This arrangement is called the evolutionary series. Evolution means change, and these groups are believed by scientists to represent stages in complexity of development of life on the earth. Geology teaches that millions of years ago, life upon the earth was very simple, and that gradually more and more complex forms of life appeared, as the rocks formed latest in time show the most highly developed forms of animal life. The great English scientist, Charles Darwin, from this and other evidence, explained the theory of evolution. This is the belief that simple forms of life on the earth, slowly and gradually gave rise to those more complex and that thus ultimately the most complex forms came into existence.

The Number of Animal Species. — Over 500,000 species of animals are known to exist to-day, as the following table shows.

Mammals 9500 Birds 13000 Reptiles 3500 Amphibians 1400 Fishes 13000 Insects 360,000 Arachnida 16000 Crustacea 16000 Myriapods 4000 2000 Mollusca 61000 Annelids [illegible] Echinoderms 4000 Round Worms 1500 Flat Worms 500 Sponges 2500 Coelenterata 4500 Protozoa 6000

The evolutionary tree. Modified from Galloway. Copy this diagram in your note book. Explain it as well as you can.

This is what started all the trouble. It is a page from George W. Hunter's "Civic Biology" text book, which John T. Scopes used in his classes at Dayton, Tenn., and for which he was indicted as a violator of the anti-evolution law. Accompanying is a picture of Charles Darwin.

See the clipping

Scopes and Neal confer in New York

A photograph shows Scopes with his Knoxville lawyer, John R. Neal, in New York to confer with leaders of the American Civil Liberties Union, which had said in May it would carry the case to the United States Supreme Court if necessary. Neal is to act as defense counsel. A December report says the Union organized and directed the defense.

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The Washington Times · 9 June 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

CONFER ON EVOLUTION DEFENSE

INTERNATIONAL NEWS REEI

See moreSee less

Doctor John R. Neal (left), of Knoxville, Tenn., and John T. Scopes, the young high school teacher, who are in New York in conference with leaders of the American Civil Liberties Union. Doctor Neal wjll act as counsel in defending Scopes, who is soon to go on trial at Dayton, Tenn., for teaching the theories of evolution in violation of the Tennessee statutes.

See the clipping

A New York dinner for Scopes

At a civic club dinner, Scopes told New York sympathizers of his pleasure in ‘being the goat’ in a fight for freedom of thought: ‘This trial is not to judge whether I am a criminal.’ Dudley Field Malone, offered only research work, threatened to quit and was made active counsel. Of the associate counsel named, Bainbridge Colby would not appear at the trial.

The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.

The Union Daily Times · 11 June 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SCOPES SAYS PLEASURE TO BE THE GOAT

New York June 11—(A P)—Figurative goats, instead of monkeys, have figured largely in the closing hours of the New York visit of John T. Scopes, high school teacher, who goes on trial next month at Dayton, Tenn., for violating the state law against the teaching of evolution.

See moreSee less

In an address last night to New York sympathizers Scopes told of his pleasure of "being the goat" in a fight for freedom of thought.

Dudly Field Malone, New York lawyer, who had been relegated to assist with research work, announced he would not be a "goat" that he would assist actively in the case or not at all. So he was accepted as one of the active counsel.

Scopes, who leaves for home today, was a guest at a dinner of the civic club last night. He said he was embarrassed in addressing the distinguished group of liberals and radicals first because he was young and inexperienced and secondly because while an automobile had been sent to get Clarence Darrow, one of his counsel, he had to walk to the club and got lost.

"Being a goat is not so unpleasant,, he said, "If you are going to be a goat you want to take thought as to whether you are to be a big goat or a little one. I really and truly think this is a fight for freedom of thought. This trial is not to judge whether I am a criminal."

As to sidelights of his New York visit Scopes said: "I found New Yorkers the most lovable people in this country with the most greedy hotels and restaurants and the most selfish people those reporters who wanted to monopplize all my time and not even let me see the follies."

If scopes did get the follies he did find amustment at another theatre in a skirt forecasting the coming evolution trial. There were three characters, William Jennings Bryan, as prosecutor, Scopes and a monkey as a witness.

John Randolph Neal, chief counsel for Scopes, who visited New York wit hhim, has announced a revision in associate counsel. As now planned, they will be Clarence Darrow, Bainbridge Colby, Dudley Field Malone, Arthur Garfield Hayes, eastern manager of the La Follette campaign last fall and Charles W. Thomas, former senator from Colorado.

Malone was reinstated as an active trial associate after he gave notice that he would do mere research work.

"I either stay on an equal basis with other associate counsel or I quit," he said. "If the fact that certain people think I am a Roman Catholic and others know one of my marriages ended in divorce and the fact that my name is Irish is to prove a greater hindrance than help, I must withdraw."

When invited to speak at the dinner to Scopes last night Darrow replied, "I wont come unless you let me make a speech." And speech he did make, bristling with references to "Bryans and bromides" and concluding with this plea for tolerance: "The best way is to try to infere as little as possible with other people, to cultivate a broad spirit of tolerance and charity and let people live their own lives."

Mr. Neal invited everybody down to Tennessee for the trial saying the summer climate was fine and that there are no mosquitoes.

See the clipping

Bryan saves his words for Dayton

A United Press roundup: Scopes leaves New York for Dayton after six days in the spotlight, while in Miami Bryan refuses to answer critics, George Bernard Shaw among them, until the trial, when he promises to ‘make monkeys’ of Darwin’s supporters. His statement: ‘The case will be tried in the Tennessee court and not in the newspapers.’ From Paris, the French lawyer Vincent de Moro-Giafferi offers his help.

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

The Milwaukee Leader · 12 June 1925 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

WE WILL MAKE MONKEYS OF 'EM, BRYAN ASSERTS

BULLETIN. By The United Press.

See moreSee less

NEW YORK—Weary after six days of the center of attraction here, John Thomas Scopes, the country school master who soon must stand trial in Tennessee for teaching evolution, left Thursday for Dayton, Tenn.

Dr. John R. Neal, who, with Bainbridge Colby, Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone and other prominent attorneys will defend him at the approaching trial, accompanied Scopes.

A banquet in Scopes' honor was held Wednesday night at the Civic club.

Referring to evolution case, Scopes said:

"If you are going to be a goat, you want to take thought as to whether you are going to be a big goat or a little one. I really an[d] truly think this is a fight for freedom of thought."

In his speech Clarence Darrow deplored the fact that so many people had tried to improve the world and only succeeded in making it worse.

MIAMI, Fla.—Determined to save his strength for the crucial test at Dayton, Tenn., July 10, William J. Bryan for the first time will not talk in answer to his critics in the prevailing evolution controversy. That is, until the trial. Then he promises to "make monkeys" of Darwin's supporters.

When shown George Bernard Shaw's interview calling him a "blockhead," Bryan "issued a statement," as is his custom. It read:

"Mr. Bryan declines to discuss anybody's criticism of him or anybody's opinion of evolution.

"The case will be tried in the Tennessee court and not in the newspapers."

Mr. Bryan said, however, he was glad to notice that the Tennessee case is "no longer treated as a joke by editors."

"Big Issues at Stake."

"The number and prominence of attorneys engaged by the defense," he said, "would indicate that important issues are at stake."

Prior to the opening of the trial, Mr. Bryan said, he will spend most of his time at his estate near here preparing the case upon which he expects to convict the Tennessee high school teacher, Scopes.

The announcement that Bainbridge Colby, who like Bryan served as secretary of state under Woodrow Wilson, would oppose him in the evolution trial brought no comment from the commoner.

French Lawyer Would Aid.

PARIS—Another great international lawyer Wednesday leaped into the controversy over the Scopes trial when Vincent de Moro-Giafferi declared the Tennessee evolution trial was "the greatest event in law since the trial of Jesus Christ." M. de Moro-Giafferi, whose defense of Henri Landru, the "French Bluebeard," brought him world-wide prominence, asserted he was communicating with Scopes' attorneys, offering his assistance.

See the clipping

No teaching contract yet for Scopes

An AP report from Dayton: Scopes has no teaching contract for the next term, and the trial has spoiled his summer job selling cars. Neal promises witnesses from every branch of scientific thought; on 17 July the judge would exclude their testimony. In Washington, the Bureau of Education stays ‘hands off.’

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 16 June 1925 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

SCOPES JOBLESS FOR NEXT TERM

Indicted Evolution Teacher Has Received No Contract for Coming Year.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn.. June 16.—John T. Scopes, indicted for violation of the State anti-evolution laws, still is without a teaching contract for the next term of school. Also, his plans to sell automobiles for a Dayton concern during the Summer months have gone awry because of the opening of his trial July 10. Since his return to Dayton Scopes has made no comment on New York reports that he had received offers totalling $150,000, including a $50,000 contract for a motion picture in which he would appear.

The limelight in which the case has placed the young science teacher continues to be focused upon him. He was complimented yesterday by a large delegation from the town of Coal Creek, headed by the mayor and other city officials.

It was announced today that Gov. Austin Peay had been informed that his presence as a witness for the prosecution at the trial would be welcome. The invitation, extended by Walter White, superintendent of schools and prosecutor: the formal serving of the indictment on Scopes and the announcement of conferences by both defense and prosecution counsel marked the latest developments in the case.

Counsel to Meet Bryan.

Counsel for the prosecution will meet William J. Bryan in Atlanta on Thursday, while the defense announced that Clarence Darrow would visit Dayton next Monday to familiarize himself with the local setting before the trial opens.

John R. Neal, senior counsel for Scopes, said that witnesses representing every branch of scientific thought would be placed on the stand and that it was the plan to have them cross-examined by Mr. Darrow.

Formal service of the indictment on Scopes was a necessary legal formality, although the action of the local justice of the peace giving him his liberty on his own recognizance until court meets still holds. The service was obtained by the sheriff in the same drug store where the test case was proposed.

DR. TIGERT SILENT.

Even though the Government is keenly interested in the outcome of the evolution law trial to be held next month in Tennessee, when the constitutionality of the State law prohibiting teaching of evolution in the schools will be challenged, the Federal agency most concerned is maintaining an attitude of watchful waiting. The policy of the Bureau of Education, the direct link between the Government and the educational system of the Nation, was defined today by Commissioner Tigert as one of "hands off." Dr. Tigert declined absolutely to commit himself or the bureau on a matter which he holds to be one of State sovereignty and one in which the Government can take no part.

Meanwhile, it developed today that a hitherto obscure and little noticed section of the District of Columbia appropriation act for 1925 makes reference to a prohibition against the principles involved in the Tennessee law. In appropriating for salaries for school teachers here, Congress passed a paragraph which providse that no part of the sum appropriated for salaries shall be available for the payment of any superintendent or instructor who permits the teaching of disrespect of the Holy Bible or partisan politics.

The trial of John Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee law, will bring in the teachings of the Bible during the testimony next month.

The book, "Civic Biology," which Scopes used in Tennessee, is not used in the public schools here, the only book listed in the high schools on the subject being "Inductive Biology," by Lewanna Wilkins, although other books are said to be used.

Prof. Alfred A. Doolittle, professor of biology at Central High School, said today there is no direct reference to the evolution of man in the books on biology used in the high schools here, although all the references made to the progressive civilization of the human race . support the evolution theory.

See the clipping

The author of the law stays home

John W. Butler of LaFayette, the legislator who introduced the statute against teaching evolution, will not attend the trial: Dayton is 100 miles away and he cannot afford the trip. ‘I'll just stay home and pray that the law is upheld,’ he says. On 15 July Judge Raulston upheld it, ruling the law constitutional and refusing to quash the indictment.

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

New Britain Herald · 19 June 1925 · page 25 · transcribed from the page image

It's His Law

It's his law that is causing all the fuss.

See moreSee less

This is John W. Butler of LaFayette, Tenn., who introduced in the state legislature the statute barring the teaching of evolution in the public schools.

He will not attend the trial of John T. Scopes at Dayton. Dayton is 100 miles away, and he cannot afford the trip.

"I'll just stay home and pray that the law is upheld," he says.

See the clipping

Einstein speaks from Berlin

In a United Press interview from Berlin, Albert Einstein, careful not to meddle in an American ‘family squabble’, says any restriction of academic liberty ‘heaps coal of shame upon the community which tolerates such suppression.’ A Berlin theologian, Prof. Seeburg, adds that theories cannot be disproved by removing their exponents from office, and a former German ambassador says ignoring evolution would show the intelligence of the ostrich.

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

The Washington Daily News · 23 June 1925 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

PROF. EINSTEIN ATTACKS 'MUZZLING' OF SCOPES

Finds 'Coals of Shame' on State

See moreSee less

Discoverer of Relativity Theory Claims Science Is 'Common to World'; Hits Tennessee

GERMAN LEADERS AIR VIEWS

Comment on Anti-Evolution Arraignment of Teacher, Finding Free Speech Imperiled

EDITOR'S NOTE: German leaders of thought are taking an interest in the Tennessee evolution trial. Prof. Albert Einstein, discoverer of the 'relativity theory,' finds 'coals of shame' in hampering academic freedom. Prof. Seeburg, of the University of Berlin, noted theologian, and Count Bernstoff, former German envoy to America, have also expressed their views. The first important utterances on the Scopes case to come out of Germany are given here by the United Press.

* * *

By FREDERICK KUH

(Copyright, 1925, by United Press)

BERLIN — Prof. Albert Einstein, world known for his theory of relativity, today broke his customary silence in an interview on the Scopes case in Tennessee.

He condemned muzzling of academic freedom.

Making it clear he did not desire his remarks to be interpreted as interference in an American "family squabble" Einstein said:

"Any restriction of academic liberty heaps coal of shame upon the community which tolerates such suppression."

Common to World

He said science is common to the whole world.

"The exact sciences," he said "may call the whole world their fatherland."

Other German scientists and theologians are following communiques from the American "education battle front."

Prof. Seeburg, University of Berlin, one of Europe's leading theologians, said:

"Darwinism in its original form is a thoroly stimulating scientific theory.

"Subsequent attempts to apply it to every field of thought and 'kultur' are, in my opinion, mistaken and old fashoned. Scientific theories can be controverted only thru hard facts and cold reason."

Then he concluded with the observation manifestly aimed directly at the case of Prof. Scopes in Tennessee:

"They can not be disproved by removing their exponents from office."

Suppression Condemned

Count Johann Von Bernstorff, once German Ambassador to Washington, heatedly condemned all suppression of free speech and thought.

"I am absolutely opposed to any restriction to academic freedom," he said, "and to all persecution for the teaching of established facts.

"The evolution theory is well supported by all our knowledge and to ignore it would be to show the intelligence of the ostrich. Yet it is only a theory, a rational theory which has not connection with religion.

"In this connection I want to repudiate the impression created in America by my friend, Frank Harris, that I am a confirmed atheist. I am no such thing. I believe in religion and its inspiration."

See the clipping

Dayton guards its water supply

Expecting ‘many fanatics’, state health officials have Dayton post guards at the spring that supplies its water, and concessionaires must pass a physical examination before opening booths. In Memphis the state bar is debating a resolution against making the trial an advertising medium, while Dudley Field Malone tells an audience in Chattanooga: ‘I am an American, and have come to meet American citizens on an American issue.’

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 27 June 1925 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

FANATICS FEARED AT SCOPES' TRIAL

Water Supply at Dayton to Be Guarded—State Bar Hits Case.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn., June 27.—Guards will be posted at the source of Dayton's water supply during the trial of John T. Scopes for alleged violation of a statute prohibiting the teaching of evolution in public schools of Tennessee, it became known here today.

After examination of the huge spring, source of the town's water, State health authorities recommended to city officials that such action be taken, and provision has already been made to safeguard the supply.

The spring, more than 20 feet square, gushes forth at the rate of approximately 75,000 gallons daily, and from it the water is distributed to Dayton homes.

State health authorities declared that Dayton has an exceptionally good water supply. They expressed the opinion, that while under ordinary circumstances there was no reason for establishing a special guard over the well, the coming trial probably would bring to the community many fanatics against whom it would be prudent to be prepared. The spring is surrounded by a cement wall several feet high, and flanked by a wire fence, which under ordinary conditions is deemed to be sufficient protection.

Will Examine Concessionnaires.

James S. Frazier, commissioner of public works, said today that in addition to safeguarding the health of the public by protecting the water supply, all concessionaires will be compelled to pass a rigid physical examination before being allowed to open booths here.

Dayton citizens today were discussing with interest the report from Memphis that a resolution had been introduced before the convention of the Tennessee Bar Association there referring directly to the Scopes case. The resolution, which was to be debated today, said, in part: "We deplore and protest against the making and using of a criminal or other trial before any court of our State as an advertising medium, as is now being done in regard to the Scopes trial at Dayton, Tenn., and most especially do we deplore and protest against the action of any court in encouraging or fostering or participating in any such advertisement or publicity scheme."

Malone Explains Stand.

Interest also was displayed in the address of Dudley Field Malone at Chattanooga yesterday, in which the New York lawyer defined the attitude of persons who are to come from other parts of the country to attend the evolution trial. They come to the South, he said, in no spirit of superiority or arrogance, and he declared of himself: "I am an American, and have come to meet American citizens on an American issue."

Mr. Malone, who is associated with counsel for the defense, said he did not fear that the theory of evolution would corrupt the students and "prepare their souls for hell." He insisted there should be no conflict between science and religion.

See the clipping

Scopes’s sister is refused a post

Relatives say Lela V. Scopes, who had taught two satisfactory terms in Paducah, was denied a mathematics post there after she declined to repudiate evolution; she could not see what her views on evolution had to do with teaching mathematics. She was preparing to teach at Bowling Green, but on 1 October a New York dispatch reported her arrival to teach at Highland Manor School, Tarrytown.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 2 July 1925 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

SCOPES' SISTER

FACULTY REFUSES GIRL POSITION BECAUSE OF STAND ON EVOLUTION QUESTION; TAUGHT MATHEMATICS.

See moreSee less

By The Associated Press.

PADUCAH, July 2.—Miss Lela V. Scopes, sister of John T. Scopes, who will be tried this month at Dayton, Tennessee, for violating the Tennessee evolution law, was denied a position on the faculty of the Paducah schools, relatives said today, because she declined to repudiate the theory of evolution as espoused by her brother.

Miss Scopes, who is studying in the University of Kentucky at Lexington, filed application for a position as instructor of mathematics.

Later Professor L. J. Hanifan, superintendent of schools, is said to have told her the plans had been filed.

The superintendent is said to have asked Miss Scopes her views on evolution and to have urged her to say "no" to a suggestion that she concurred in her brother's attitude. This Miss Scopes refused to do, a relative said today, because she said she could not understand just what her views on evolution had to do with teaching mathematics.

The young woman taught two terms in the Paducah schools, 1922-23 and 1923-24. Her record shows that her services were satisfactory. She is at summer school preparing to teach in the Bowling Green schools this winter.

See the clipping

Monkey goods fill Dayton’s shop windows

A United Press writer finds Dayton transformed: banners across the main street proclaim ‘Robinson's drugstore, where it all started,’ a Western Union office has opened just for the trial, and shops sell monkey watch fobs, umbrella handles and neckties. Scopes himself had said the trial grew out of a ‘drugstore argument that got out of control’. After the verdict the druggist was said to have made enough to retire.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 6 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BIGGEST SHOW ON EARTH AT DAYTON, TENN. TODAY

By WILLIAM J. LOSH. (United Press)

See moreSee less

Dayton, Tenn., July 6.—Dayton, Tenn., has experienced one of those metamorphoses known to Shelby, Mont., and other little out of the way places to which fate brings the sudglare of the spotlight of human interest.

This little hillside town which never knew a uniformed policeman or a more ambitious motor vehicle that a rattly four-seater of ancient vintage, where people thought they had reached the quintessence of metropolitanism when two of the fast trains each day stopped at the station, now is all dressed up and in holiday mood.

Fashionably dressed visitors in smart motor cars drive through the narrow streets, tourists who want to send home a postcard from the scene of the Scopes trial.

Traffic is directed by uniformed officers from Chattanooga, sent to help out the lone town marshal whose other duties as superintendent of the street department and water works and public building keep him pretty busy.

Overhead, across the main street, hang banners—"Robinson's drugstore, where it all started," (an allusion to Scopes' remark that the trial was the result of a "drugstore argument that got out of control,") "The Best Place to Eat," "Tourist Lunch," "Park Your Car at the Ball Park," and "Western Union."

Dayton never had a telegraph office of its own and this one is here only for duration of the trial.

While attorneys for both sides and those most vitally interested in the outcome of the trial deplore the expression, "Monkey Business," there is plenty of it in evidence. Shop windows are filled with monkey this and monkey that, monkey watch fobs, with "Dayton, 1925," marked on them, monkey umbrella handles, neckties with monkey designs and so on.

See the clipping

A federal judge will not stop the trial

Federal Judge John C. Gore at Cookeville refused Scopes a restraining order, holding it was not within his jurisdiction to interfere with a case pending in a state court; he did not touch the law’s constitutionality, and Neal will not appeal for now. With the trial set for Friday, Bryan is due in Dayton about noon to join the prosecution.

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Brownsville Herald · 7 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FEDERAL JUDGE REFUSES TO ACT IN SCOPES CASE

Trial Is Scheduled to Begin Friday in Dayton; Bryan Arrives to Help With Prosecution

See moreSee less

(By The Associated Press.)

DAYTON, Tenn., July 7.—Uncertainty as to whether Dayton would be the scene of the trial Friday of John T. Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee evolution teaching law, has been removed as a result of the ruling last evening of Federal Judge John C. Gore at Cookeville refusing to grant Scopes a restraining order to stop the criminal case at Dayton.

It was announced by John R. Neal, leading counsel for Scopes, that no appeal would be taken at present from the ruling of Judge Gore, who held that it was not within his jurisdiction to interfere with a case pending in a state court and expressed doubt that it it were in his power he would grant the petition on the strength of the allegations set forth. The constitutionality of the Tennessee statue which Scopes is alleged to have violated, was not touched upon by the judge.

With the uncertainty dissipated Dayton looks forward today to the arrival of William Jennings Bryan, who will aid in the prosecution of the case. Mr. Bryan, who will aid in the prosecution of the case. Mr. Bryan is due about noon. He will be met by other members of the prosecution. At Stewart, solicitor general for the eighteenth Tennessee judicial district also is expected in Dayton today to confer with Mr. Bryan and others of the prosecution.

See the clipping

Bryan makes it science against religion

Philip Kinsley of the Chicago Tribune finds Bryan, who first called the constitutional question the main one, now casting the case as religion against evolution, ‘guesses strung together and substituted for God.’ Neal replies that the great issue is whether the legislature overstepped its constitutional powers, and in October the state Supreme Court confined the appeal to that question. Bainbridge Colby, Kinsley adds, will not appear.

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 9 July 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Bryan Sits on Throne in Dayton and Confounds Defense With Sudden Switch

RELIGIOUS QUESTION IS SUPREME, SAYS PROSECUTION CHIEF

See moreSee less

Commoner is Attempting "Ambitious Program," Prof. Neal, Defense Leader, Declares in Address

BY PHILIP KINSLEY (Staff Correspondent of The Chicago Tribune and The Montgomery Advertiser.)

DAYTON, TENN., July 8.—By The Chicago Tribune Press Service.—Preliminary verbal rumblings of William Jennings Bryan and his opponents in the Scopes evolution trial today may warn the religious liberals of the United States of the urgent need of action to save them from the river of oblivion in this struggle. Where is the grant of the modern church to heed these far of guns in the night?

Today's maneuvers, two days ahead of the opening of the trial, present a situation somewhat as follows:

Mr. Bryan who first said that the constitutional issue was the main one, has confounded the opposition by his sudden switch to the science and religion conflict. He makes science black and religion white.

"You have no idea what a black and brutal thing this evolution is," he is reported to have said as he leaned across the table at the blushing and embarrassed young defendant, John Scopes.

"This anti-evolution law," Mr. Bryan said tonight, "simply prohibits the evolutionists from using the public schools for the purpose of substituting their kind of religion for the religion of the masses."

While Mr. Bryan is thus bringing religion into the foreground, the defense, through Prof. John R. Neal, senior counsel, sought today to swing the constitutional issue, making religion secondary. It was only a short time ago that the defense attorneys were worrying about bringing the religious evolution controversy into the case.

Bryan Termed Ambitious

Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Hayes, defense lawyers, are supposed to be on their way here, but Mr. Bryan has the fort at present. Mr. Darrow is not of the Christian faith, which militates against his effect upon this situation.

Mr. Bryan's challenge was met by Prof. Neal as follows:

"We regard Mr. Bryan's speech last night the most remarkable utterance ever made by a lawyer just before his entrance into a trial of a criminal case. His speech comes as a challenge to the defense not to confine the test of the anti-evolution.. law to the existing limitation of the constitution of Tennessee or even the United States, but instead to put on trial the truth or lack of truth the theory of evolution; the conflict or lack of conflict between science and religion, having demonstrated as he apparently expects to do, at least to his own satisfaction, that evolution is untrue and that it is destructive to Christianity. He forecasts that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the supreme court of Tennessee, then to the supreme court of the United States and having lost his fight on account of the exitsing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational liberties he intends immediately to wipe these constitutional immunities by a new constitutional amendment—a very ambitious program, I should say—even for Mr. Bryan. We have no objections to his undertaking it, but we shall insist as we did at the very inception of this case, that the great issue in this case is not whether evolution is true or untrue, or even whether it conflicts with religion, but whether the Tennessee legisalture has not transcended the limit set upon its powers by the constitution of Tennessee and the constitution of the United States in passing the anti-evolution law and thus attempting to control the mind in its struggle after truth."

Colby Unable to Attend

In an address at a public dinner given by the prosecuting attorneys at Morgan Springs hotel tonight, Mr. Bryan baited the evolutionists as a minority group seeking to foist their kind of religion upon the public schools.

"With some," he said, "evolution is not only a religion but the only religion they have and they are guilty not only of trying to establish their religion by law but they are guilty of trying to establish it in spite of the objections of a majority.

"This trial will be better understood by the people of the nation when they understand that the real purpose is not to protect freedom of knowledge or freedom of investigation. But this law does not attempt to restrain either knowledge or investigation. The students under Mr. Scopes were not investigating, they were simply asked to accept evolutionary views as set forth in the text book and as interpreted by Mr. Scopes."

Mr. Bryan referred to evolution as "guesses strung together and substituted for God."

It seems to be definitely settled that Bainbridge Colby will not appear in this trial, although his services may be used in arguments on constitutional questions later. He wired Professor Neal today that he would be detained in a case in New York but that he stood ready to offer his services at any time to the defense.

Witnesses for the defense have been asked to start for Dayton. Their names will not be revealed until later, as the defense is afraid that some of them will be frightened away. Mr. Bryan with his coat off, spent most of the day working in the offices of Sue and Herbert Hicks, two of his assistants. He found a stack of mail two feet high awaiting him. He is planning when this trial is over to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land then write his memories. He is through with the lecture platform, and his real estate investments in Florida are said to have netted him a fortune. He is still interested in politics, however, and told men in his group at dinner last night that the next democratic nominee must come from the South or the West and frowned, it is said upon the suggestion of Al Smith.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Tennessee Scraps Feuds for Monkey War