As the Papers Told It

The Scopes Trial · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

Bryan Dies Suddenly

July – August 1925

On 21 July, at the defense’s own request so that it could appeal, the jury found Scopes guilty in nine minutes, and he was fined $100. Five days later Bryan died in his sleep in Dayton, aged 65, and his closing speech, never given at the trial, was printed after his death. Dayton men announced a Bryan Memorial University. At a memorial for Bryan in Chicago Judge Raulston attacked Darrow, who answered that the judge had used the case for political ambition.

After the verdict, Dayton empties out

With the trial over, a Dayton report finds hot dog stands coming down and Scopes back in the deserted courtroom to arrange his $500 bail. The jurors are the most disappointed: ‘We wanted to hear the scientific testimony, most of all,’ one tells Darrow. Townsfolk who expected a devil-like figure have come to respect the agnostic lawyer for his honesty and courage.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

DAYTON BACK TO QUIET AFTER WEEK EXCITEMENT

JURYMEN DISAPPOINTED BECAUSE THEY COULD NOT HEAR SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE THAT WAS EXCLUDED.

See moreSee less

DAYTON, Tenn., July 22.—A young negro sat on the steps of the Rhea county courthouse Tuesday afternoon poring over a cheap magazine. Dayton is back to its quiet ways after a climax that jerked it out of its mountain obscurity for a few fleeting days and put it on the lips of the whole civilized world. Most of the notables and visitors will be gone by Wednesday morning. Darrow is going to Knoxville and Bryan to Winchester Tennessee.

Scopes came back to the deserted courtroom after lunch to arrange his $500 bail. There was no one in the county clerk's office except Scopes, his attorney and th bonding agnt..

The famous court room looked as if it had been swept by a storm. Paper was scattered all over the floor. A microphone stand had been knocked down in front of the judge's bench and a heavy chair lay across it. Empty bottles stood around on the deserted counsel tables among the scattered newspapers.

Village Loafers Hang Around

Out on the lawn, until a drizzle began, a few village loafers hung around. Colonel J. R. Thompson, foreman of the jury, and two other jurors sat on a board talking about the trial they had hardly seen. Hot dog stands were being dismantled. Mercants were looking dolefully over the unsold stocks that had been bought in anticipation of a long trial Neither the length of the trial nor the crowds approached even the most conservative expectations.

But the proprietor of the Aqua hotel, who had bunked guests even on the hallway couches and in the bath rooms, has prospered, and E. F. Robinson, the hustling druggist, has made enough out of his soda fountain to retire for life. From 7 a. m. till nearly midnight, his place has been crowded. Tuesday afternoon, visitors were dropping in for a final drink at the table "where it started."

The jurymen were the most disappointed of all. They fought for a place on the jury and then never got to hear the exciting episodes of the trial.

Wanted to Hear Testimony

"We wanted to hear the scientific testimony, most of all," said W. F. Roberson, the one non-church member on the jury, to Darrow after the trial.

R. L. Gentry, the only juror who has read about evolution, went up to meet Clarence Darrow after the trial.

"You've read a bit about evolution, haven't you?" Darrow asked him.

"Quite a bit."

"If you ever come to Chicago, come in and see me. We'll have a long talk," Darrow said. From the day the jury was picked, Darrow has been much interested in this backwoods philosopher-school teacher.

Felt Juror's Sympathy

"I felt you were with us." Darrow continued. "but we didn't want a hang jury and that was why I urged all of you to return a verdict."

"I know what you are driving at," Gentry replied.

After the trial closed, dozens of spectators crowded around Darrow and Bryan. Interest in Darrow seemed to mount perceptibly after his questioning of Bryan. Many here had regarded Bryan as the greatest man of the age and they wondered what kind of a person it was who dared enter the arena to debate religion with their Hercules. Darrow is the first professed agnotistic many in this region ever saw and many have been curious to know what sort of human he is.

Reaction Favorable to Darrow

The reaction has been favorable, for instead of the mean, devil-like peroson they expected, they have found a comfortable old man much like themselves wearing galluses, full of jokes, affable with everyone, and above all, courageous. Shocked as they were when he stood up in the courtroom and protested against the morning prayer, they have come to respect his honesty and courage and they like him for this much as they dispute his agnostic views.

Old Man Abel, who has a real es-

Contrary to the impression that might be given by the Tennessee antate office over Robinson's drug store, expressed the sentiment of the community.

Cross-Section of Views

"If a man is honest and tries to lead a good life as he sees it, that's all anybody can ask," he said. "Every man is entitled to his views. I believe in the Bible, but that is something every man has to decide for himself."

ti-evolution law, that is the way these folks feel about it. They want to be tolerant and they have made a heroic effort to be so in face of the stern religious code pounded into them from infancy.

See the clipping

Bryan calls Darrow his Exhibit A

In a statement issued after the verdict, Bryan names Darrow ‘our Exhibit A’ of what is cruel in evolution: an avowed agnostic who has slurred the Bible and insulted the court. He says he took the stand only so Darrow could not call him afraid, and promises an answer to the charge that he is an ignorant bigot. He would be dead within the week.

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Bryan's Suppressed Fury Breaks Anew Over Darrow's Head

SAYS COUNSEL IS EXHIBIT A IN BIBLE CASE

See moreSee less

DAYTON, Tenn. — William Jennings Bryan, bubbling over with fury—fury which was suppressed by the sudden jury verdict—burst forth into fresh flame.

Bryan, eager to scorch Clarence Darrow, Scopes attorney, with his burning questions, raised his voice —spoke; and the religious tempest broke over the head of the aged counsel.

Directed At Darrow.

Bryan, whose fiery oratory was quenched by the conviction and closing of the Scopes case here Tuesday, administered his examination of Darrow through the medium of a statement. It was a broadside directed personally at Scopes' counsel. Darrow retaliated in a blistering rejoinder. Bryan's statement follows:

The issue is so large that individuals and localities are relatively unimportant. It dwarfs all other issues now under consideration by the people of the United States and of the world. Is the Bible true, is the question raised by the Tennessee law, and that question is answered in the affirmative as far as this trial can answer it.

Raps Attack On Bible.

Believing as I do in the revealed religion—that is to say, in Christianity built upon the Word of God —I rejoice that the followers of our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ, are at last awakened to the insidious attacks which have been made, under cover of a scientific hypothesis, upon the authority of the Bible by unbelieving of every grade and class.

The attack upon the authority of the Bible is organized, deliberate and malignant, and had only to be uncovered to be understood.

Mr. Darrows entrance into the case has been most fortunate for the Christian church. He is the most conspicuous of the outspoken opponents of religion in the nation. He is the finished product of evolution—the most perfect that has yet developed in the United States. He embodies all that is cruel, heartless and destructive in evolution. He is our Exhibit A, and proves the criminal folly of intrusting to the tempestuous sea of life an intellectual ship without a moral rudder and without a compass.

Is Called Agnostic.

He does not believe that there is a God—he is an avowed agnostic, and therefore has no sense of responsibility to God. As love of fellow man has no other foundation than love of God, as set forth in the two commandments, "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart and thy neighbor as thyself," he has no basis on which to build an unselfish interest in anybody or in anything.

In this trial he has been true to his unbelief from beginning to end. He objected to the customary opening of the court with prayer and insisted on the removal of a sign, "Read Your Bible." He has slurred the Bible, insulted the court, has shown his contempt for everything Christian and everybody identified with Christianity as it is taught in orthodox churches, and "the ruling passion strong in death" closed the after-trial meeting in the courtroom with a sneer when all the other participants had spoken in a spirit appropriate to the occasion.

I shall prepare an answer to Mr. Darrow's charge that I am an ignorant bigot. I am not vain enough to think that this compliment—for, coming from him, it was a compliment—was intended for me alone. While it was addressed to me, it was intended for all who dare differ from him to the exent of believing in the Bible, the God whom it reveals and the supernatural Christ of whom it tells.

Answer Is Planned.

I shall answer for all Christians as well as for myself, but I feel that the answer will receive more consideration if it is separated from the proceedings of today.

When Mr. Darrow summoned me as a witness yesterday I might have refused to testify, but knowing that his purpose was to impose upon the people outside the courtroom rather than to try the case, I consented to testify in order that he might not be able to charge me with unwillingness to face his questions. He did not ask a single question that was proper or that would have been permitted had I objected to it. The judge permitted them to be asked only because I was willing to answer, and later, upon reflection, expunged both questions and answers from the record.

See the clipping

Guilty in nine minutes, fined $100

At the defense’s own request, so that it could appeal, the jury returns a guilty verdict in nine minutes and Scopes is fined $100, the minimum. ‘Your Honor, I have been convicted of violating an unjust statute,’ he tells the court. The 30 days allowed to perfect the appeal would matter: in October the state Supreme Court ruled the judge had no legal right to extend them to 60.

The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.

The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

FILE NOTICE OF APPEAL AT ONCE

Dramatic Scenes Accompany Jury's Verdict Finding Scopes Guilty.

See moreSee less

GETS FINE OF $100

Bryan's Testimony On Monday Is Ordered Expunged From Record by Judge.

Dayton, Tenn. — [illegible] — John Thomas Scopes was convicted in Rhea county circuit court at 11:29 o'clock this morning for violating the state statute prohibiting the teaching of theories of evolution in the public schools.

He was fined $100, the minimum fine under the statute. Notice of intention to appeal to the Tennessee supreme court was filed and 30 days given in which to perfect the appeal with an assurance from the court that if additional time should be found necessary an extension would be granted.

The case was given to the jury at 11:20, a verdict being returned in nine minutes, after counsel had agreed to waive arguments. A short statement was made to the jury by Clarence Darrow of defense counsel in which he said, "I don't see how you can find our client not guilty." He had explained that the evidence upon which the defense had hoped to bring about the acquittal of Scopes had been excluded by the court and it was the wish of the defense that a verdict of guilty be returned to permit an appeal to the supreme court.

Scopes was summoned before the bar.

Judge Raulston told him of his conviction by the jury and read a copy of the statement to him.

The judge then fixed the fine at $100.

Bond was fixed at $500 pending an appeal.

"Have you anything to say, Mr. Scopes," asked the judge.

Scopes Determined to Fight On.

"Your Honor, I have been convicted of violating an unjust statute," replied Scopes, "any action other than I have pursued would be in violation of my idea of academic freedom."

The judge repeated the fine of $100.

Scopes added to the court in his statement that he would continue to oppose the law in every way in his power as he considered it an unjust law and in violation of the constitution.

Dudley Field Malone announced that bond would be arranged at once. Mr. Malone also thanked "the pepole of this community for their hospitality and for the opportunity to try the issues in this case."

Scopes was to appear in court during the afternoon to file a bond of $500, pending disposition of the appeal.

The appeal from the circuit court finding will be made to the Tennessee supreme court meeting in Knoxville in September. A formal motion for arrest of judgment was made on application for a new trial but was overruled. The assembly of the transcript for use in the appeal will be the next task for the defense, attorneys said.

Dramatic Closing Moments.

The scenes attending the close of the eight-day trial were without parallel in the experiences of veteran court observers.

Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone, Arthur Garfield Hays and Dr. John R. Neal, of the array of Scopes counsel, delivered farewell messages to the court and to the crowd. The attorneys from northern cities thanked the court and local organizations for hospitable treatment and courtesies.

William Jennings Bryan, of prosecution counsel, and his colleagues, Ben T. McKenzie, and Gordon McKenzie, proclaimed their confidence in the ultimate triumph of right, regardless of human error. The court in a final plea commended the lawyers in the case and declared that true courage was found in the breast of a man who could fight for what he thought to be right, in the face of adverse popular sentiment.

The jury stood and posed for photographers as defense lawyers made final arrangements for their appeal.

Later the meeting was thrown open for general discussion and a half dozen informal speeches were made, thanking the people of Dayton for their hospitality during the period of the trial.

Bryan Loses a Point.

Testimony of William Jennings Bryan, given in the Scopes case yesterday was expunged from the record of the case by Judge Raulston this morning.

The Scopes trial was opened here this morning by a statement from Judge Raulston that the court had had some important matters to pass on.

"I fear I may have committed error yesterday," he said, "In my overzeal to ascertain if there was anything in the proof that was offered to enable the higher courts to ascertain if there was error."

"I feel that the testimony of Mr. Bryan can shed no light on any issue that will be pending before the higher courts," he said.

"The issue is whether Mr. Scopes taught that man descended from a lower order of animals.

"I feel that Mr. Bryan's testimony cannot aid the higher courts," he repeated. "Therefore I am pleased to expunge this testimony from the records of this court."

In discussing the court's ruling, Clarence Darrow said: "We have no proof to offer."

What Might Have Been.

Arthur G. Hayes, for the purposes of perfecting the record in the event of an appeal, read a list of the witnesses the defense would have offered had they been permitted to do so and took a formal exception.

He also asked that the record show that Scopes had a contract to teach in the Rhea county school from September 1 to May 1.

William Jennings Bryan in discussing the expunging of his testimony, suggested that the views of the defense counsel had not been brought out as clearly as might have been. Dudley Field Malone, for the defense, related that members of his side of the cas ewere ready at any time to make their views public when such an issue was germane.

It was explained that the defense's testimony on which it relied to acquit Scopes having been excluded, the defense would state to the jury that it could not ask a verdict of "not guilty" and was satisfied to have a conviction in this court than an appeal might be made to the supreme court of Tennessee and possibly eventually to the United States supreme court.

Clarence Darrow, of defense counsel said that he would make such a statement to the jury.

Heard Only Little Evidence.

The jury had not heard any of the testimony of the defense "test witness" Dr. Maynard M. Metcalf, nor the statements read into the records from scientists and biblical scholars. The only information officially reaching the jury's ears was four state witnesses, two school boys, the superintendent of schools and the chairman of the board of education, and openments from state and defense.

The judge began reading his charge to the jury at 11:04. He opened his charge by reviewing the act under which Scopes was indicted.

"The state must make out its case beyond a reasonable doubt," the court old the jury.

The judge called attention to the wording of the indictment in which it was charged that the defendant taught a theory of evolution, teaching that man descended from a lower order of animals or denied the story of divine creation as taught in the bible.

The judge charged that if the defendant should have violated the law against teaching that man descended from a lower order of animals he should be convicted. The question of denial of the divine story of creation as taught in the bible was not before the jury, the court ruled.

After the judge finished reading his charge, Clarence Darrow said the defense had no requests to make.

See the clipping

Five days after the verdict, Bryan dies

Bryan died in his sleep on the afternoon of 26 July 1925 at the Dayton house where he had lived during the trial, after church and a big meal. Doctors found a hemorrhage of the brain; he was 65, and his last words to his wife were ‘I am so sleepy.’ He had just arranged to print the speech he never got to give at the trial.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 27 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WILLIAM J. BRYAN DIES SUDDENLY ON EVE OF GREAT BIBLE CRUSADE; BODY WILL BE LAID IN ARLINGTON

Apoplexy Fatal to Commoner in Sleep.

See moreSee less

INVALID WIDOW BRAVING SHOCK

Friends and Foes Pay Tribute to Memory.

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn., July 27.—The body of William Jennings Bryan, who died suddenly in sleep here late yesterday, will move on a special railroad car from Dayton to Washington at 8:40 o'clock Wednesday morning, Mrs. Bryan announced through her friends today.

Burial of the political and religious leader will be in Arlington Cemetery, Virginia, at a time to be determined later, Mrs. Bryan said.

The funeral party, which will include the widow and an escort of Dayton friends, is expected to reach the National Capital early Thursday.

Road Offers Special Car.

Mrs. Bryan has accepted the offer of a special car from the Southern Railway Company, along whose lines the funeral train will pass from Dayton to Washington. The car, a combination observation and Pullman, will be taken on the local train to Chattanooga, whence, at 11:30 o'clock Wednesday morning, it will be connected to the regular fast train from Chattanooga to Washington.

Among Tennessee friends expected to accompany the body are Sue K. Hicks, Herbert Hicks, Ben G. McKenzie, Gordon McKenzie and Wallace Haggard, all of local prosecution counsel in the Scopes trial, and Attorney General A. T. Stewart. No ceremonial guard of honor will be in attendance on the body, in accordance with the expressed wish of Mrs. Bryan, who told her friends:

"We are simple people, and we want all arrangements simply made."

Mrs. Bryan, though an invalid, confined to a chair, continued to display remarkable resolution in the unexpected death of her husband. She gave directions for all arrangements which have been determined upon.

Floods of telegrams poured in upon Mrs. Bryan today. They brought messages of tender sympathy from the humble and great in every part of the continent and many verbal tokens of grief which those in high places shared with the widow. Their messages were read to her at intervals by her friends and attendants. They seemed to soften her sorrow, to which she has resolutely refused to yield.

From 2 until 5 this afternoon the body of Mr. Bryan was to lie in state upon the lawn of the Richard Rogers home, where he lived during the Scopes proceedings, and where he died unobserved by man.

As a guard of honor on this occasion, while the mountain folk of eastern Tennessee pass before the casket, a squad from the Fred W. Brady Post, No. 100, the American Legion, composed of Dayton former service men, will be on duty. The guard will be in uniform and without arms.

Apoplexy Causes Death.

The end came yesterday afternoon while the Commoner was sleeping in the house of Richard Rogers, which had bee assigned him during his stay here, when he came for the Scopes trial. Dr. W. F. Thomason and Dr. A. C. Broyles, who examined the body, stated death was caused by a hemorrhage of the brain, resulting in apoplexy. He was 65 years old.

James McCartney, family chauffeur, was sent by Mrs. Bryan at 4:30 p.m. to wake her husband. McCartney shook Mr. Bryan twice in an attempt to arouse him and then noticed he was not breathing. Rushing to the home of A. B. Andrews, a neighbor, the chauffeur called for physicians, who reached the home within a few minutes.

The doctors said Mr. Bryan probably had been dead 30 or 40 minutes.

The Commoner had been living under a strenuous program since he came here three weeks ago to assist in the prosecution of John T. Scopes, found guilty of violating Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He appeared in excellent health, however, and was planning to launch a great campaign this week in behalf of fundamentalism.

Widow Stands Shock Bravely.

Mrs. Bryan, who has been an invalid a number of years, immediately took charge of the funeral arrangements and received a few of the hundreds of persons who called at the residence to express sympathy.

"I am happy that my husband died without suffering and in peace," she said.

His last words to her, as he entered the room for his nap, were:

"I am so sleepy."

Before he went to sleep, Mr. Bryan autographed two books for Judge John T. Raulston, who presided at the Scopes trial. The books were "The Seven Questions in Dispute," and "In His Image."

He wrote: "To Judge and Mrs. John T. Raulston, Winchester, Tenn., with good wishes of Mr. and Mrs. W. J. Bryan, July 26, 1925."

After traveling over 200 miles Saturday and delivering speeches at Winchester and Jasper, Tenn., Mr. Bryan returned to Dayton early yesterday from Chattanooga, where he had spent the night.

Before he left Chattanooga Mr. Bryan joined A. W. Lessly, owner of the hotel at which he stopped, and several others, for breakfast. Mr. Lessly accompanied him to Dayton, and during the trip the Commoner expressed determination to "see the case through." Mr. Bryan showed no evidence of bad health, Mr. Lessly said, but remarked that he was suffering with diabetes.

While in Chattanooga Mr. Bryan

(Continued on Page 3, Column 3.)

WILLIAM J. BRYAN DIES SUDDENLY; BODY TO BE LAID IN ARLINGTON

(Continued from First Page.)

completed arrangements for publication of the speech he was to have delivered during the closing hours of the Scopes case. He was having it printed for distribution throughout the country, and its delivery was to mark the opening of the nation-wide battle against modernism planned by him.

Although Mr. Bryan appeared to be in good health, he realized it was necessary for him to conserve his strength. During last week he visited Dr. Raymond Wallace in Chattanooga, who informed him that he had a slight dilation of the heart with arrythmia (missed beats).

Previously, July 17, Mr. Bryan was advised by physicians to refrain from further strenuous activities. Dr. Wallace particularly advised against an address Mr. Bryan had planned for Pikeville on the following Sunday. Mr. Bryan delivered the speech, but limited it to 10 minutes, telling his friends that he had to conserve his strength, as he feared he might not live through the Scopes trial.

Dr. Wallace said Mr. Bryan appeared surprised to learn he had heart trouble, but was not worried. Yesterday he declined an automobile from the Chattanooga Hotel to the railroad station, saying he preferred to walk.

Led Prayer in Church.

When he arrived here he went immediately to his home and from there to the Southern Methodist Episcopal Church. He sat on the front seat and before the sermon by the Rev. E. A. Peterson of Buna, Tex., he was called upon for prayer.

Citizens of Dayton still were discussing the prayer today, describing it as one of the most beautiful they had ever heard and as revealing the earnestness and sincerity of Mr. Bryan. Opening with the words "Dear Father," the prayer was the plea of a servant that God should direct all his ways and protect his home and country from sin. The prayer also sought aid in the campaign Mr. Bryan was making for "old-time religion."

After church services Mr. Bryan returned to his home, where, with Mrs. Bryan and Mr. and Mrs. Rogers, he had dinner. He ate a big meal and was in one of his most jovial moods. Before taking a nap he called Chattanooga over long-distance telephone to ask about his speech, which was being published.

Mr. Bryan told his wife that he had never felt better in his life and was ready to take his fight for fundamentalism to the country. He told of his trip to the Holy Land within the next several months and the writing he had planned. He then remarked that "I am so sleepy," and entered his room shortly after 3 o'clock.

Mrs. Bryan was on the porch of the home and could see her husband on the bed. About 4:30 p.m. Mrs. Bryan felt her husband had been asleep long enough and sent McCartney, who also was Mr. Bryan's personal attendant, to wake him.

"He always was a heavy sleeper and was hard to wake" Mr. McCartney said, adding that after he had shaken Mr. Bryan twice he noticed he was not breathing.

While Mr. Bryan had prepared his address in the Scopes trial he was pleased that he would have an opportunity to present it to the public without interruption.

During the closing hours of the trial he was called to the witness stand by the defense and the result was a bitter clash between him and Clarence Darrow, the noted Chicago attorney and one of Scopes' counsel.

The Commoner said the "Christian religion has satisfied me and I have never felt it necessary to look up some competing religion."

At another point he asserted:

"The Bible is good enough to live by and die by."

Mr. Bryan accused Mr. Darrow of attacking "revealed religion." When objections to the defense's questions were made by prosecution attorneys, Mr. Bryan expressed a desire to answer.

Explained Position.

"The reason I am answering is not for the benefit of the court," he stated. "It is to keep these gentlemen from saying I was afraid to meet them and let them question me. I want the Christian world to know that any atheist, agnostic, unbeliever can question me at any time as to my belief in God and I will answer him."

Despite the fact Mr. Darrow and Mr. Bryan figured in numerous bitter verbal exchanges during the trial, they also engaged in a like number of friendly conversations. Mr. Darrow was one of the first to come forward with a tribute to Mr. Bryan, when the news of the latter's death was received.

George W. Rappelyea, who brought charges against Scopes in order that the anti-evolution law might be brought to a test, was one of the first of Dayton's citizens to call at the Bryan home after the Commoner's death.

He revealed that he had been invited to call at the Commoner's home last night for a talk. During the day, Mr. Bryan told Mr. Rogers that he appreciated the tribute Mr. Rappelyea had paid him during the closing moments of the trial.

The children of the dead leader have been summoned to join the party in Washington. The son, William Jennings Bryan, jr., left Los Angeles today. Mrs. Ruth Owen left Mount Vernon, Ohio, for Dayton today, but will divert her course to reach Washington before the body of her father. Mrs. Richard Hargreaves, the other daughter, is with her brother, traveling East.

"Bring your white clothes; don't bring any black ones," Mrs. Bryan advised her children, with whom she talked over long-distance telephone before they left their homes for the East.

The decision to bury the former Democratic chieftain among the country's military great in Arlington was the result of the expressed wish of Mr. Bryan, his widow told friends. Mr. Bryan was a colonel of volunteers in the Spanish-American War.

A huge spreading maple tree shades the spot where the files of friends will look for the last time upon the face of their beloved champion. In this grassy eminence, raised 4 feet above the level of the street, Mr. Bryan was wont to sit and rest during the intervals of the fight over the Tennessee anti-evolution law.

Met Crowds During Trial.

Here he chatted with his friends and grasped the hands of hundreds who came from the Cumberland slopes or from distant cities to witness the noted legal controversy in the Rhea County Court.

Like the still face on the pillow, the home where the statesman had taken a wordless leave of his friends presented an aspect of peaceful rest. There was no throng at the door; no crowds at the curb. One or two late associates of Mr. Bryan sat on the porch, conversing of the eloquence of the tongue that death had silenced and the courage of the man who never feared to fight for his convictions.

"There lies the grandest hero of the times," softly exclaimed Ben McKenzie, the elderly lawyer who is the favorite of the mountain folk. His companions nodded in full agreement.

One or two women of the neighborhood came in at intervals to offer ministrations to Mrs. Bryan.

WILLIAM JENNINGS BRYAN. (Copyright by Underwood & Underwood.)

See the clipping

A reporter says Bryan sensed his end

William K. Hutchinson, a news-service correspondent, recalls his last talk with Bryan on the porch at Dayton after the trial closed. Tired, Bryan twice said ‘My days are numbered,’ while Mrs. Bryan urged him not to promise two speeches in Knoxville. He spoke of giving up the lecture platform to write in Florida, and died, the reporter notes, less than a hundred hours later.

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

South Bend News-Times · 28 July 1925 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

PREMONITION OF DEATH WAS FELT AT TRIAL CLOSE

Bryan in Last Interview Stated, "My Days Are Numbered!"

See moreSee less

BY WILLIAM K. HUTCHINSON I. N. S. Staff Correspondent Copyrighted 1925, By I. N. S.

WASHINGTON, July 27.—William Jennings Bryan had a premonition of death in the closing hours of his vivid career. He voiced this belief in the final interview given this correspondent at Dayton, Tenn., following the close of the Scopes trial. He spoke while resting on the porch of the little white bungalow where he was to meet his fate less than a hundred hours later. He was tired, dead tired, from the strain of the trial. He said so, with a sigh of relief that the "work was done in Dayton."

"Will you go to Washington to help with the new evolution case there?" he was asked.

"Don't ask me that question," Bryan replied wearily. "My days are numbered and I can't spare the time."

Promises Speeches

Then, with a smile, he added, "I can't keep going forever and I must return to Florida to catch up with my literary work."

A telephone call interrupted the interview and Bryan went to the phone. Some one was asking him to make two speeches in Knoxville this week. The commoner was willing.

"Now don't promise two speeches," Mrs. Bryan interposed. "You haven't the strength. One address is enough. You don't need to wear yourself out, they'll be satisfied with just one."

But Bryan said he would make two speeches, one on "The Tennessee case," and another on "What Will You Do With Jesus?"

When the commoner returned to the porch, he said: "My, I'm tired." And then with a faraway look in his eyes, as he gazed out over the green Cumberland hills, he touched that note of destiny again in the same words:

"My days are numbered," he said slowly. "But when I am gone, Christianity will not want for leaders. This fight here has awakened churchmen everywhere to the insidious attacks of irreligion. In the Scopes trial, we unmasked the infidels and the church is now on guard."

Future Plans

Asked as to his plans for the future, Bryan said he had about made up his mind to abandon the lecture platform which he graced for three decades. There were a few more addresses, he said, long promised, which he must fulfill in the vicinity of Dayton and then he would go to Florida.

"I owe myself a long rest," he explained. "And I want to resume my literary work."

Then, with a smile of understanding for the reporter, he added: "You know, I can reach a larger audience by writing, then by lecturing, and it isn't near so wearisome."

A few more words about the speech, denied him at the Scopes trial, which the commoner planned to give to the public as a statement on the issues of the evolution case, and the interview was ended. Over it all, there lingered that twice-voiced reference to the approaching end: "My days are numbered."

See the clipping

Dayton mourns Bryan on the Rogers lawn

The Associated Press describes Dayton’s own service for Bryan, held at the Rogers home while his body lay in state there. Mourners sang hymns, the Rev. Charles R. Jones spoke beside the casket, and former service men stood guard. The headline says thousands, but the report counts hundreds, fully half of them women, many bringing babies to see his face.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 29 July 1925 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THOUSANDS ATTEND FUNERAL IN DAYTON

Tenets of Revealed Religion Are Stressed in Services Over Bryan.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn., July 29.—The revealed religion which William Jennings Bryan himself believed in permeated the first memorial services held to the dead chieftain while his body lay in state yesterday at the residence of Richard Rogers.

From the time the services were opened, when the sweet strains of "Nearer, My God, to Thee," were caught into the air and blended with the refreshing breath of eventide of a sultry Summer day until the last echo of "Shall We Gather at the River?" had died away down Market street there was a feeling that Bryanism had touched Dayton.

It was as though the departed Commoner himself, whose lifeless form was reposing peacefully in its elaborately metallic encasement within five feet of the speaker of the afternoon, Rev. Charles R. Jones, were speaking his gospel of fundamental belief in the Scriptures.

Mourners Throng Lawn.

One other hymn the sympathetic audience, mostly standing about the Rogers high-terraced lawn, sang with acclaim, "Jesus, Lover of My Soul, Let Me to Thy Bosom Fly."

This was preceded by the reading of the Scriptures by Rev. W. A. Moffett, from First Corinthians, fifteenth chapter, twentieth through the fifty-eighth verses, in which the rise of Christ from the dead is related, and the conquering of the "last enemy that shall be destroyed," death is foretold; then followed immediately a prayer by Rev. Mr. Jones, "beseeching Thee for such strength as we stand in need of at this present time."

"We come to shed the sympathizing tear," he said. "We come to mourn with those who mourn and weep bitter tears of sorrow."

"We bless God for the Christian religion," he said. "We thank God for men who have gone up and down the earth proclaiming the gospel of Jesus Christ, which is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth."

Rev. Mr. Moffett then read from the first epistle of the Apostle Paul to the Corinthians.

Veterans Guard Body.

Former service men in Army, Navy and Marine Corps uniform formed a guard of honor at the residence this afternoon while the public viewed the face of the departed advocate of universal peace. The line of sorrowing friends passed in and out quietly under the supervision of the members of the American Legion and two uniformed policemen.

In the hundreds who assembled from many counties and a few distant States to pay tribute to Mr. Bryan yesterday fully half were women. Many of these brought their babies to gaze down upon the powerful features of the champion of Christianity. Fathers led in their little sons, who strove to look into the bronze casket which lay at a level with their faces. All expressed in their countenances a general sorrow over the death of their leader and friend.

See the clipping

A Bryan university for Dayton

Five Dayton men in Washington for the funeral announce plans for a Bryan Memorial University, with $100,000 in property and pledges in hand and hopes of $1,000,000. The site, on a hill just outside town, is one Bryan chose himself from the Rogers porch. The five include Richard Rogers, in whose home he died, and Wallace Haggard, the original prosecutor in the case.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 2 August 1925 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BRYAN UNIVERSITY

FUND NOW $100,000

See moreSee less

Plans for Memorial Forge Ahead and Dayton Men Obtain Support.

Plans for the Bryan Memorial University at Dayton, Tenn., are forging ahead, with prospects that $1,000,000 may be raised, according to a group of those interested, who were here for the funeral of the Commoner.

Five men who participated in the recent events of Dayton's historic flash into fame joined today in the announcement that already $100,000 in property and pledges have been procured for the institution to be erected on a site selected by Bryan himself before he died.

Wallace Haggard, lawyer, of Dayton, original prosecutor in the Scopes case, and later associated with Bryan in the legal battle in which they won a verdict, predicted success for the venture.

With him were Richard Rogers, in whose home Bryan died, and who is associated with F. E. Robinson, in the drug store where the evolution argument started; Kelso Rice, Chattanooga policeman, who opened court, and to whom Mrs. Bryan has given the Commoner's silver fountain pen; R. J. Coulter, Chattanooga and Dayton undertaker, who cared for Bryan's body, and William H. McCartney, personal attendant on Mr. Bryan, who found him cold in death.

These men joined in stating that the original suggestion for the university came from A. B. Fairburn of Washington, while in Dayton for the Scopes' trial. Mr. Fairburn said today it had been his idea that the university should be dedicated to "religion pure and undefiled," and to "deepest respect and reverence for the flag."

University Site Provided.

The site for the university has already been donated, it was stated. Mr. Rogers revealed that William Jennings Bryan, while seated on the Rogers' front porch, had looked out upon the site which he himself had selected, and remarked that it was such a location as could be seen from the entire surrounding country. Bryan, himself, had promised to donate to the university, and the cause to which it was to be devoted, they said.

The site is on the southeast of Dayton, just outside the city, on what is known as Broyle's hill, overlooking the Tennessee Valley and River.

No formal or legal organization has as yet been perfected, Mr. Haggard said, but contributions have already been received; and word has come from Massachusetts from a person who wishes to give $10,000.

Informal Trustees.

The informal trustees of the fund, so far, have been F. E. Robinson of the famous Dayton drug store, and the Progressive Dayton Club, of which the president is B. L. Morgan, cashier of the Dayton Bank and Trust Co.

The group from Dayton called today on Representative Cordell Hull of Tennessee, former chairman of the Democratic national committee, in whose district Dayton is located. Mr. Hull, it was said by Mr. Haggard, is interested in the Bryan memorial, and had promised to contribute.

TENNESSEANS WHO CAME TO BRYAN FUNERAL

Above, left to right: R. J. Coulter, Kelso Rice, William McCartney, Richard Rogers and Wallace Haggard, all of Dayton. Mr. Bryan died at the home of Mr. Rogers. They are participating in plans for a memorial to Mr. Bryan at Dayton, Tenn.

Below: Kelso Rice, who received from Mrs. Bryan a silver fountain pen which belonged to the Commoner, and which was presented to him by employes of the State Department when he resigned.

See the clipping

A Johns Hopkins scholarship for Scopes?

Dr. Joseph S. Ames, acting president of Johns Hopkins, says newspapermen and scientists began seeking a scholarship for Scopes right after the trial. When a place fell vacant, a catalogue was sent to him, but no reply had come. By late September Scopes had enrolled instead at the University of Chicago, to study geology.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 10 August 1925 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SCOPES MAY GET SCHOLARSHIP TO JOHN HOPKINS MOVED STARTED TO GIVE YOUNG EVOLUTION TEACHER UNIVERSITY COURSE. BALTIMORE, Md., August 10.—Information as t᠎o requirements necessary for a scholarship at Johns Hopkins University here has been sent to John T. Scopes, recently found guilty of teaching evolution in violation of the state laws of Tennessee it was learned yesterday from Dr. lation Joseph S. Ames, acting president of the university. Immediately after the trial in Dayton, Tennessee, Dr. Ames said, a movement was started by a group of newspapermen and scientists to obtain a scholarship at Hopkins for Mr.

See moreSee less

Scopes. Application was made but at the time all available scholarships had been awarded. About three weeks ago a vacancy occurred through a resignation and a catalogue explaining courses, regulations and fees was sent Mr. Scopes. Dr. Ames said that the university had received no word in reply at all.

See the clipping

The trial judge preaches against evolution in Chicago

At a Bryan memorial service in Chicago, before Darrow’s own town folk, Judge Raulston weeps as he reviews the trial he presided over. ‘Mr. Bryan didn't believe in evolution and I don't believe in it either’, he declares, and charges that Darrow tried to destroy Bryan. The crowd cheers, and he spends almost an hour shaking hands.

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Indianapolis Times · 10 August 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

SCOPES TRIAL JUDGE WEEPS AT MEMORIAL

Raulston Flays Darrow Bitterly and Praises Bryan in Chicago.

See moreSee less

By United Press CHICAGO, Aug. 10.—Attacking Clarence Darrow as the "agnostic defense counsel," Judge John T. Raulston, who presided at the recent Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tenn., aroused an audience of Darrow's town folk to wild cheering during the course of a sermon at the William Jennings Bryan memorial services here Sunday.

Raulston reviewed the Scopes trial from beginning to end. He had only praise for the "great Bryan" and only criticism for "the agnostic counsel."

Judge Weeps

Weeping throughout the address as he touched on such themes as the possibility of his own parents having sprung from lower forms of animal life, Judge Raulston declared:

"Mr. Bryan didn't believe in evolution and I don't believe in it either. I don't believe God made a miserable monkey and then let nature do the rest.

"I believe in a God than can answer prayers. I believe in a real God, not in a wooden God."

Crowd in Tears

The lanky Tennessee judge charged that "Clarence Darrow tried to destroy Mr. Bryan politically or any way he could."

A large portion of the crowd was in tears when Raulston finished and crowded around him in such numbers that he was required to spend almost an hour shaking hands before he could leave the hall.

See the clipping

Darrow says the judge had political ambitions

Telegraphing from Greeley, Colorado, to the Chicago Daily News, Darrow answers the judge’s memorial speech: Raulston, he charges, used the case to further his own political ambitions. The judge had spoken of citing Darrow for contempt, a citation Darrow answered at Dayton with an apology the court accepted, and said Bryan asked that leniency be shown his adversary.

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

El Dorado Daily News · 12 August 1925 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

DARROW SLAMS TRIAL JUDGE

Criticism of Lawyer by Raulston Brings Retort that the Judge "Was Ambitions"

See moreSee less

CHICAGO, Aug. 11.—(AP)—Clarence Darrow, defense counsel in the John T. Scopes evolution trial, today charged that Judge John T. Raulston, who presided at the trial used the case to further his own political ambitions.

Mr. Darrow, who is in Greeley, Col., made his charges in a telegram to the Chicago Daily News in answer to criticisms of Darrow's conduct at the trial voiced by Judge Raulston, in an address here last Sunday at a memorial meeting for William Jennings Bryan. Judge Raulston in his address referred particularly to citing Mr. Darrow for contempt and said that Mr. Bryan asked that leniency be shown his adversary.

See the clipping

What the world wrote to Governor Peay

Governor Austin Peay, who approved the Butler bill, opens his evolution mail to the Associated Press: praise and ridicule from across the country and abroad, most of it approving. Bryan’s own letter predicted that ‘Other States, North and South, will follow the example of Tennessee.’ The Episcopal Bishop of Tennessee called such legislation ‘not only unfortunate but calamitous.’

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 16 August 1925 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

GOVERNOR OPENS EVOLUTION MAIL

Bryan Letter Praised Law of Tennessee—Bishop Called It "Calamitous."

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

NASHVILLE, August 15.—Praise in the highest to ridicule unprintable is found in letters received by Gov. Austin Peay on evolution from the United States and foreign countries. They were received during the trial of John Thomas Scopes.

The governor tonight opened to the Associated Press a mass of communications, little of which he had read, dealing with the action of the State Legislature in passing the Butler bill barring teaching of the theory of evolution from the public schools and with his approving it.

Peay's only comment was, "I want the country to know what kind of people is in it."

Though a majority of the letters are commendatory to the governor's action, caustic criticisms are contained, directed toward Tennessee and the South, written by individuals.

Bryan Letter Commendatory.

Excerpts made public include:

William Jennings Bryan: "Please accept my cordial congratulations on the great service you have rendered in signing the anti-evolution bill. The Christian parents of the State owe you a debt of gratitude for saving their children from the poisonous influence of an unproven hypothesis that gives man a jungle ancestry and chills his spiritual nature. The South now is leading the Nation in the defense of Bible Christianity. Other States, North and South, will follow the example of Tennessee."

Rt. Rev. James Maxon, Bishop of Tennessee, Protestant Episcopal Church: "* * * I consider such restrictive legislation not only unfortunate but calamitous."

R. W. Deuthat, Huntington, W. Va.: "I have the honor of offering you my congratulations for your approval of the act of a brave Legislautre to cut off the dragon head of evolution 'devil-ution'."

Writes From Germany.

C. H. Mohr, Wohnsaft, Stuttgart, Germany: "I read here in Europe of your efforts to perserve the version of the Bible on the creation. The Ku Klux Klan seems to be of the same opinion."

Leonard Joy, Detroit: "The universe is too immense to be easily conceived and explained by any half-learned mortal man, be he even a Darwin or a Darrow."

Rev. J. C. Coggins, South Norfolk, Va.: ". . . there is absolutely nothing that so paralyzes the moral sensibilities as this devilish doctrine fathered by European infidelity."

R. T. Perry, Washington, D. C.: "To be consistent, I think your schools ought to teach Jehovah's justice—'eye for an eye,' etc."

Henry Clay Babel, Buffalo, N. Y.: "I devoutly covet your progressive State the most auspicious success in the approaching trial."

John Cranston, Wyandotte, Mich.: "No doubt you have received congratulations from Wilbur Glen Voliva of flat world fame."

George F. Crawford, Newark, N. J.: "I hate and despise ignorant, lying, bigoted, fanatical religion that has caused more trouble than anything else."

See the clipping

The speech Bryan never gave

A South Carolina paper prints passages from the closing speech Bryan prepared for the trial, lost when both sides waived argument and published after his death. The law, he argued, binds the teacher only as a paid servant of the state, not as an individual. Christians, he wrote, do not want their children to ‘lose sight of the Rock of Ages while they study the age of the rocks’.

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

Edgefield Advertiser · 19 August 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Mr. Bryan's Parting Message. The speech which William Jennings Bryan had prepared for delivery at the Scopes trial was published after his death, and will rank as one of the greatest of the Commoner's addresses. With every word marked by the utmost sincerity, it had a profound effect on all who read it, and has materially altered the views of many who had judged Mr. Bryan's efforts solely from the distorted view presented in the newspaper accounts. We quote a few of his eloquent paragraphs regarding the proper relationship between the schools and religion:

"Let us separate the issues from the misrepresentations, intentional or unintentional, that have obscured both the letter and the purpose of the law. This is not an interference with freedom of conscience. A teacher can think as he pleases and worship God as he likes, or refuse to worship God at all. He can believe in the Bible or discard it; he can accept Christ or reject Him. This law places no obligations or restrictions upon him. And so with freedom of speech, he can, so long as he acts as an individual, say anything he likes on any subject. This law does not violate any rights guaranteed by any Constitution to any individual. It deals with the defendant, not as an individual, but as an employee, an official or public servant paid by the state, and therefore under instructions from the state.

See moreSee less

"The right of the state to control the public schools is affirmed in the recent decision in the Oregon case, which declares that the state can direct what shall be taught and also forbid the teaching of anything 'manifestly inimical to the public welfare.' The above decision goes even further and declares that the parent not only has the right to guard the religious welfare of the child, but is in duty bound to guard it. That decision fits this case exactly. The state had a right to pass this law and the law represents the determination of the parents to guard the religious welfare of their children." "It need hardly be added that this law did not have its origin in bigotry. It is not trying to force any form of religion on anybody. The majority is not trying to establish a religion or to teach it—it is trying to protect itself from the effort of an insolent minority to force irreligion upon the children under the guise of teaching science. What right has a little irresponsible oligarchy of self-styled intellectuals to demand control of the schools of the United States, in which twenty-five millions of children are being educated at an annual expense of nearly two billions of dollars?

"Christians must, in every state of the Union, build their own colleges in which to teach Christianity; it is only simple justice that atheists, agnostics and unbelievers should build their own colleges if they want to teach their own religious views or attack the religious views of others.

"Religion is not hostile to learning; Christianity has been the greatest patron learning has ever had. But Christians know that 'the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom' now just as it has been in the past, and they therefore oppose the teaching of guesses that encourage godlessness among the students. . . .

"The science of how to live is the most important of all the sciences, but it is necessary to know how to live. Christians desire that their children shall be taught all the sciences, but they do not want them to lose sight of the Rock of Ages while they study the age of the rocks, neither do they desire them to become so absorbed in measuring the distance between the stars that they will forget Him who holds the stars in His hand."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: Climax in Dayton