As the Papers Told It

The Scopes Trial · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

Climax in Dayton

10–21 July 1925

The trial opened on 10 July 1925 before Judge Raulston, who read the law and the first chapter of Genesis. The jury was farmers and others, all but one belonging to an evangelical church. On 15 July the judge held the law constitutional, and the state rested after four witnesses. Two days later he excluded the scientific testimony. On 20 July Darrow was cited for contempt and apologized, and that afternoon, on the lawn, he questioned Bryan. The next day the judge struck Bryan’s testimony out.

The trial opens with a fresh indictment

The AP's account of 10 July 1925, the opening day: Judge Raulston read the law and the first chapter of Genesis, and a special grand jury indicted Scopes again, a formality. Attorney General Stewart warned that the state would resist scientific testimony, a fight it won a week later. Picking the jury, Darrow struck a Baptist minister who declared ‘I am strictly with the Bible.’

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

Seward Daily Gateway · 10 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF SCOPES STARTS DAYTON;

TEST OF TENNESSEE LAW ON TEACHING EVOLUTION BE MADE BY COURTS

See moreSee less

DAYTON, Tenn., July 10 (AP)—The trial of John Thomas Scopes, charged with violating the new Tennessee law by teaching the theories of evolution in a public school, began here this morning with his reindictment by a special grand jury, after Judge Raulston had read the law and the first chapter of Genesis before the court sat.

William Jennings Bryan, anti-evolutionist, who volunteered his services to prosecute the aged professor, received an ovation when he entered the court room. Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone, heading the counsel for the defense, greeted the chief prosecutor cordially. Darrow was in his shirt sleeves, and apparently suffered from the intense heat. The attorneys conferred together while the grand jury was out.

Attorney General A. T. Stewart informed the defense that the State would object to the introduction of scientific testimony regarding evolution. That the case was not to determine the truth of evolution nor of the bible, but rather to try Scopes for violating a state law.

Several boys, pupils of Scopes, testified before the grand after they retired that Hunter's Biology was the text book Scopes used in his teachings. It was placed in evidence.

Walter White, superintendent of the Rhea County schools and prosecuting witness was also called before the grand jury. The indictment was a mere formality to meet with the requirements of thirty days between summoning a grand jury and the indictment. The previous indictment was quashed when the second was returned. Rev. William Cartwight opened the court with prayer and a squad of blue uniformed policemen from Chattanooga filed in and took the best positions to maintain order.

Many Scientists Will Testify.

Darrow told the court the defense expected to call many scientists, who were busy men, and that he would like some indication when he would be ready to hear them. Stewart remarked that it would take but a short time to select the jury. The court postponed its answer until the jury is sworn. Stewart told the court that the prosecution would vigorously resist any evidence tending to reconcile evolution with the Bible.

Stewart proposed to take the rest of the day off to give visiting lawyers a chance to get acclimated, but Judge Raulston ordered an afternoon session for the selection of a jury.

Sheriff Draws Names from Hat

Jury selection begun by the Sheriff drawing the names from a hat. Both sides accepted W. F. Robinson, a farmer-teacher, who said he had formed an opinion as to the guilt or innocence of Scopes, but could disregard it in his deliberations. J. W. Bagley told Clarence Darrow he knew nothing about evolution and declared his ability to be perfectly fair. He accepted Jim Riley, a farmer Baptist, who admitted he could not read.

Darrow rejected J. T. Massengale, a Baptist minister, who declared, "I am strictly with the Bible." The Judge suppressed the tumult of applause at these words. W. G. Taylor, a farmer Methodist, said he had some opinions about the case but would decide fairly. He was accepted.

See the clipping

A jury of farmers, nearly all churchgoers

The jury is complete: nine farmers, a fruit grower, a clerk and a farmer-teacher, all but one in an evangelical church; Darrow called it a fundamentalist jury. Attorney General Stewart says the only issue is whether Scopes taught that man descended from a lower order of animals, and that scientific evidence would end ‘in a babel of tongues’. The judge's charge put that same question.

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

Seward Daily Gateway · 11 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

JURY CHOSEN TO TRY SCOPES FOR FALSE TEACHING

JURY CONSISTS OF NINE FARMERS, FRUIT GROWER, CLERK AND FARMER-TEACHER

See moreSee less

"DID SCOPES TEACH EVOLUTION"

All But One Juror belong to Some Evangelical Denomination—

"Fundamentalist Jury."

DAYTON, Tenn., July 11 (AP)—The jury to try Professor John A. Scopes, the Tennessee professor, for violation of the State law against the teaching of evolution, was secured yesterday afternoon. It consists of nine farmers, one teach, one fruit grower, one farmer teacher and one clerk. The question of the admission of scientific testimony in regard to evolution will be fought in court Monday when it reconvenes. There will be no session today to enable the defense to confer.

The only issue in the case will be "Did Scopes teach that man descended from a lower order of animals," Attorney General Stewart said today. He said that the theory of evolution was not involved in the State's position.

Jury All Church Members

DAYTON, Tenn., July 11 (AP)—Court adjourned until Monday after completing the jury panel yesterday. All but one of the jurors belong to some evangelical denomination. Clarence Darrow said the jury was a fundamentalist one. One talesman who did not belong to the church was rejected.

Attorney General Stewart said to a representative of the Associated Press: "My understanding is that Scopes will not deny that he taught students of the high schools of Rhea county that man descended from the lower order of animals. If this be true he is guilty, and all the evidence of scientists within reach cannot save him. He might claim that man is descended from lower animals by God's creation, but this cannot make a difference. The law says that this cannot be taugh in our schools. If such evidence is used, both sides will end in a babel of tongues. Such evidence is incompetent and our stand is definite and determined."

See the clipping

Darrow argues to throw out the indictment

The Chicago Tribune's correspondent hears Darrow argue the defense motion to quash the indictment on 13 July. Before a crowd thought to be 95 per cent for conviction, Darrow calls Bryan the man responsible for a ‘foolish, mischievious and wicked act’ and says Scopes is on trial ‘because the fundamentalists are after everybody who thinks.’ Two days later Judge Raulston denied the motion and upheld the law.

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 July 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Darrow Makes Great Plea For Liberty of Church, Press and School

ATTORNEY WARNS AGAINST METHODS OF 16TH CENTURY

See moreSee less

Noted Lawyer Details His Views on Religion Before Tennessee Jury; Says Freedom Must Reign

By PHILLIP KINSLEY. (Staff Correspondent Chicago Tribune and Montgomery Advertiser.)

DAYTON, TENN., July 13.—Today it was the Chicago prophet Clarence Darrow, who took Dayton by storm. His religion was that of tolerance. His attack was upon William Jennings Bryan and the fundamentalists, who are leading America, he warned, back to the sixteenth century, of ignorance and bigotry.

In one of the greatest speeches of his career, the liberal leader told Judge John T. Raulston and a packed court room in the John T. Scopes trial that unless constitutional guarantees are upheld in this case, unless the anti-evolution law is killed that step by step liberty of press and church and school will be taken away.

"No subject possesses minds of men like religious bigotry and hate," he cried and these fires are being lighted today in America." Turning to Mr Bryan, who sat at the head of the prosecution table, his mouth set in stern lines, he said: "This is the prosecutor, the man responsible for this foolish, mischievious and wicked act."

He referred to the act "as brave and bold. An attempt to destroy learning, as was ever made in the middle ages." A snare and a trap to get those who don't agree with you in religion." "Scopes is here," he said, "because the fundamentalists are after everybody who thinks." The spirit of freedom and independence has caused death blood in the past, it looks like it will cost more."

He spoke of "bootlegging" evolution into Tennessee and said the law was foisted on the people in the night by "religious bigotry," a phrase that rang again and again through the courtroom where learned lawyers, teachers, students and yeomen of the hill country thought to be 95 per cent in favor of convicting Scopes.

A shiver of apprehension, some merriment even, went over the room as the voice of Darrow, now cold and hard, now soft and now stinging, sent words into their minds, new thoughts, new possibilities.

They had expected God to speak to him and they are still expecting it. But they had looked for the voice of doom and prophecy to come from Bryan, not from this stooping, kindly, farmer-like lawyer, from the great city of the north. Well, Bryan is to come. That was their consolation tonight.

Declares Case Weighty.

"A very weighty question," said Judge Raulston, after court, as he retired to his court room to read briefs.

Weighty indeed, it is the whole case of evolution. It is the echo of a war that has been waged for a century. Libraries have been written about it. A Tennessee jury that never peeped into these libraries is expected to settle it. The specific question which was taken today as the basis for all the argument, which began in the morning, was the motion by the defense to quash the Scopes indictment. It seems impossible that Judge Raulston should fly in the face of Bryan, by whose side he sat yesterday in two religious meetings, to grant this, but the judge has a high conception of his office and considers that the judicial mind should be above all personal and mundane considerations, "superlative and absolute."

He might stop it all tomorrow. The jury has not even been sworn.

Driven out today through fear that they might get a few ideas about the basis of the case, they wandered about the courthouse lawn. They could hear the voices of the lawyers coming through the loudspeakers.

Never had anything like this been thought of in Dayton. The Dayton conception of evolution received a severe jolt. They learned that it had little to do with the claim that man came from monkeys, but was a word of the conception of the processes of life and that God might be found there, a God who did not stop when He made the first man out of dust, but works on forever and forever, speaking today through men as He spoke through Elijah and Moses.

The court room was a rare study. On the bench beside the judge sat several of his friends, but the ones who really took possession standing ready for action, ranged in a row of fifteen by the side of the judge, were the cameramen. They were there even during the sessions.

As the argument of Darrow, showing the fantastic effect of such legislation, its possibilities and decision after decision given and homely illustrations told, the lawyers at the prosecution table were not only amazed but deeply interested.

Faces "Atheists."

The young attorney general, Tom Stewart, sat in deep interest. He made a profound presentation of his case earlier, sticking close to the law. He had faced the table where the "atheists" and heretics sat, and had fought the fight for Bryan and Tennessee. He had admitted frankly that the only basis of such legislation was the police power of the state. He insisted that the legislature had the power to protect the children of the schools, no matter whether their method was wise or not.

The people had spoken; the majority ruled. The police power was at work. Here the impact was shown.

The fundamentalists were using power, force, through the law agency which they controlled. The resentment was apparent at the defense table. The lines were drawn, the issues set. Mr. Bryan and Walter White, the prosecutor, who considers the commoner the greatest man in the world had a frosty gleam of triumph in their eyes.

Their mouths were hard set.

"What they are trying to do is to make us go to heaven whether we like it or not," Mr. Darrow interpolated one. Not a glimmer of a smile from Mr. Bryan. He is biding his time. He will back up the side of the Bible, that they are by the side of God, that this is a Christian nation, that they are going to keep their children under that shelter, close to the rock. The Koran? Confucius? Buddha? What have they to do with American Christian civilization? So they are preparing their thunder.

"This is not a heathen country," Mr. Stewart declared, as Dudley Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Hays baited him on whether the Koran could be written into legislation. He maintained that the Bible was part of the common laws.

The scope of the argument today carried them well into the question of the competency of expert evidence, and the defense is so sure that these will be admitted, that the case will go on, that they have sent for twelve noted scientists, to come here and eight are here or on their way.

The court may adopt their suggestion and withhold action on the motion to quash until after the experts have testified. But this will not come until there has been a hard fight for Mr. Bryan, and he may find his opportunity to speak on this issue. He was urged once today by Judge Ben McKenzie, to get into the fray, but he shook his head. Judge McKenzie had been in and had found it hot water. The old fashioned orator and story teller undertook to cross swords with Mr. Malone, and precipitated a scene for which apologies were afterwards offered. The judge was beaten also by Mr. Darrow. Not only did the Chicago lawyer wear suspenders and go coatless, but he had a hole in his shirt, and his left elbow was bare to the world.

"Hays' argument is not half so much kin to this act as he says we are to the monkey," said Judge McKenzie. The court room tittered. This was what they had expected from this champion. Later he averred that the simplest boy in Rhea county, 16 years old, knew as much about this act as these Chicago and New York lawyers.

Mr. Malone objected to geographical distinctions, and said they were here as American citizens.

"No argument," said McKenzie. "He is not acquainted with me. I love him."

Judge Raulston took a hand and said that he wanted it understood that the lawyers were guests and would be treated so. Mr. Malone said they did not want to be guests, but lawyers. But everybody was smiling.

This part of the program pleased Mr. Bryan, for his side seemed to have plenty of constitutional law, and the Darrow argument appeared to them far wide of the mark, with no more to do with the issues than the testimony of the experts.

Prof. Beall made an argument on the constitutional part of the case. Here Mr. Bryan came in for an attack.

"The Tennessee legislature spoke for the majority. We are the minority. The framers of the constitution intended that no earthly power should attempt to lay down a binding rule on the conscience of the people. We are met by the assertion that if we do not like the law, we may repeal it. The bitter tragedy, the humor of it!

"The man who hurls that at us is either ignorant or has contempt for these great provisions of the constitution which were made to protect one soul or a thousand."

Mr. Darrow did not begin to speak until 3 o'clock in the afternoon. The court room was filled, even to aisles and window seats and a muggy air barely stirred the atmosphere. Messenger boys were kept busy bringing in pop bottles to the notables. Many lawyers from other towns were there, many students, and it is safe to say that more was learned about evolution today than ever Scopes taught to his pupils.

See the clipping

The judge upholds the law

On 15 July Judge Raulston rules that Scopes must stand trial: the law is constitutional and clear, the public schools are not places of worship, and no law compels anyone to seek work in them. Constitutionality would be the only issue left on appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court. The Ministerial Alliance, the AP adds, chose a New York Unitarian pastor, Charles Francis Potter, to open the day with prayer.

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

Seward Daily Gateway · 15 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

JUDGE RULES SCOPES MUST STAND TRIAL

HOLDS LAW CONSTITUTIONAL AND SUFFICIENTLY CLEAR IN INTERPRETATION

See moreSee less

RIGHTS NOT VIOLATED

No Law in State Compels Anyone to Seek Employment in Public Schools, He Avers

DAYTON, Tenn., July 15 (AP)—John T. Scopes must stand trial for the alleged violation of the Tennessee evolution law, Judge John T. Raulston ruled today on a decision on motion by the defense, asking that the indictment be quashed. The judge held the law was constitutional and the caption and body of the act sufficiently clear. He said his ruling violated no constitutional rights respecting religious freedom, as the public schools were not maintained as a place of worship but for the purpose of mental and moral development and discipline.

The judge also said he failed to see how a teacher's rights had been violated as there was no law in the state compelling anyone to seek employment in the public schools.

Court Opened with Prayer

DAYTON, Tenn., July 15 (AP)—The Ministerial Alliance selected Charles Francis Potter, pastor of the west side Unitarian church in New York, to make the opening prayer in the Scopes trial today. The minister prayed fervently that the jury would see the error of rejecting the teachings of the Holy Word and turn from false ideas and beliefs.

See the clipping

Darrow objects to the morning prayer

The Chicago Tribune's correspondent reports the morning after the quash argument, when the judge called for the opening prayer and Darrow rose: ‘I object to prayer.’ Judge Raulston overruled him, citing his custom. The writer judged the defense had lost its last chance; in the end it asked for a guilty verdict to reach an appeal, and Dayton, a later report says, came to respect Darrow's honesty.

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 July 1925 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

'I Object to Prayer,' Says Darrow, and Defense Loses Last Chance of Victory

DAYTONIANS RECOIL, BRYAN WRITHES AS 'BOMB' HITS COURT

See moreSee less

Attorneys Argue With Judge Over Daily Invocation; Stewart and Malone Clash; Custom To Be Continued

By PHILIP MINSLEY (Staff Correspondent of The Chicago Tribune and The Montgomery Advertiser.)

DAYTON, TENN., July 11.—By The Chicago Tribune Press Service.—Four little words were graven into the strange history of the Scopes trial today.

"I object to prayer."

They came from Clarence Darrow, making the most courageous move he has yet made to present the picture of this court and jury to the world.

To Dayton it was a bombshell. If lightning had come straight from Heaven and had struck down the man who uttered these words it would not have surprised many in the courtroom.

If Mr. Darrow ever had a chance to save his client, he lost it that moment. He burned all his ships and started into an unknown wilderness for the shining city of his dreams.

The court was ready for another day. The photographers were posted by the judicial bench and Judge John T. Raulston looked smilingly around, gavel poised. Distinguished visitors, lawyers, judges and ministers were around him. The eyes of the world were upon him. The reporters were poised with pencil and typewriter to start the record a new day. The microphones were listening. His words would soon be winging over the air to all parts of the country.

William Jennings Bryan had risen at the tap of the gavel, his bald old eagle of a head bowed reverently, with a reverence that was even marked above that of other reverence there.

Eyes Closed, Heads Sink.

"Reverend Stribling, will you open with prayer?" said the judge.

All eyes were closing and heads sinking; the defense lawyers were edging closer to the bench. Then Mr. Darrow spoke:

"Your honor, I want to make an objection before the jury comes in."

The judge summoned back his courteous and worldly look and asked:

"What is it, Mr. Darrow?"

Then came the astounding words:

"I object to prayer: I object to the jury being present when the court rules on the question (that of the quashing of the Scopes indictment, argued the day before).

Now all heads were up, and amazement and incredulity battled as every neck craned forward to get every precious word.

Attorney General Tom Stewart could not believe his ears. "What is it," he asked.

The court was nearly startled out of judicial composure, but he managed to answer:

"He objects to the court being opened with prayer, especially in the presence of the jury."

"Meat" For Bryan.

You could have heard a pin drop. Mr. Bryan had raised his head. He had heard four little words before and he had battled mightily against them. The words were "The Ku Klux Klan," at the last democratic convention. He knew the power of little words. He had the power to answer them so that his answer might ring around the world. But he only looked, his eyes growing darker, his mouth snapping.

Here was meat for Bryan. He knew now that the enemy had been delivered into his hands. And he withheld his wrath.

"The jury is not here," said the lawyer-like Stewart. "Are any of the jurors in the courtroom?"

There was no response (they were probably listening outside).

Then the judge buckled up his armor and proceeded to stand by his Lord and his Bible. He did not need to consult any lawbooks here.

Overrules Objection.

"Now, I do not want to be unreasonable," he said, "but I believe I have a right. I am responsible for the conduct of the court and it has been my custom since I have been judge to have prayers in the courtroom when it was convenient. I know of no reason why I should not follow up this custom, so I will overrule the objection."

His voice rose firmly as he said: "Everyone stand up."

But the slouching, homely philosopher and prophet of a new religious war was not through.

"Just a minute," he said, undismayed, as heads started to bow again to the invisible.

The court stopped. Mr. Darrow said: "I understand from the court himself that he had sometimes opened the court with prayer and sometimes not, and we took no exception the first day. But seeing this is persisted in every session, and the nature of the case being one where it is claimed by the state that there is a conflict between science and religion, above all other cases there should be no part taken outside of the evidence in this case and no attempt by means of prayer or in any other way to influence the deliberation and consideration of the jury of the facts in this case.

"For that reason we object to the opening of the services with prayer and I am going to ask the reporters to take down the prayer and make specific objections again to any such parts as we think are especially obnoxious to our case."

McKenzie Champions Religion.

The prosecution lawyers were getting ready to talk. Ben McKenzie, the county wit, the story-teller, became the champion for religion.

"That matter has been passed upon by our supreme court," he said. "Judge Shepherd took a case from the court when the jury after retiring to consider their verdict, at the suggestion of one of them to bow in prayer, asked Divine guidance, afterwards delivering a verdict not excepted to, and afterwards taken to the supreme court. It was commendable to the jury to ask Divine guidance."

Mr. Darrow: "I do not object to the jury or any one praying in secret or in private, but I do object to the turning of this court room into a meeting house on the trial of this case. You had no right to do it."

The court: "You have a right to put your exceptions in the record."

General Stewart: "In order that the record may show the state's position the state makes no contention. As stated by counsel for the defense, that this is a conflict between science and religion insofar as the merits are concerned, it is a case involving the fact as to whether a school teacher has taught a doctrine prohibited by statute, and we for the state think it is quite proper to open this court with prayer if the court sees fit to do it, and such an idea extended by the agnostic counsel for the defense is foreign to the thoughts and ideas of the people, who do not know anything about infidelity and care less."

Malone Also Objects.

Now Arthur Garfield Hays and Dudley Field Malone were pressing to the space in front of the bench.

See the clipping

Malone reads Bryan his own old words

Opening for the defense, Dudley Field Malone quoted a tribute to Jefferson, written by Bryan 20 years before, against compelling belief by law. Bryan rose for the first time in the trial: ‘I ask no protection from the court’, and promised to show at the proper time that his views were unchanged. He never gave his closing speech: the case went to the jury without argument, and he died on 26 July.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

BRYAN'S REMARK CREATES TUMULT

Malone Brings Commoner to Feet for First Time During Trial.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn., July 16.—Silence, which has set at the State counsel table of the Scopes trial with William Jennings Bryan, departed yesterday.

It was absent only a moment, but even its temporary departure and the succeeding brief remarks shattered the intense expectancy that charged the atmosphere, as Mr. Bryan arose and awaited recognition from the court.

During the course of Dudley Field Malone's statement to the jury of the course to be followed by the defense in presenting its case the attorney for the defense referred to Mr. Bryan, calling him by name, and characterizing him as the country's chief exponent of fundamentalism.

The first, comparatively mild, reference brought an objection from Attorney General A. T. Stewart. This produced remonstrance from Judge Raulston, who instructed Mr. Malone not to refer to Mr. Bryan by name in connection with the statement.

Quotes Tribute of Bryan.

Then the defense attorney quoted from a tribute paid Thomas Jefferson by Mr. Bryan a number of years ago.

"'Jefferson said in the first place that to attempt to compel people to accept a religious doctrine by act of law was to make not Christians but hypocrites. * * * He said, too, that there was no earthly judge who was competent to sit in a case and try a man for his religious opinions, for the judgment of the court, he said, would not be a judgment of law, but would be the personal opinion of the judge. What could be more true. No man who has religious convictions himself bears them so lightly that he can lay them aside and act as a judge when another man's religious convictions are involved. * * *

"'Jefferson put first that which I want to speak of last. It was that the regulation of the opinions of men on religious question by law is contrary to the laws of God and to the plans of God. He pointed out that God had it in His power to control man's mind and body, but that He did not see fit to coerce the mind or body in obedience to the divine will. * * * Jefferson realized that our religion was a religion of love and not a religion of force.'"

"These words, your honor, were written 20 years ago by a member of the prosecution in this case, whom I have described as the evangelical spokesman of the prosecution, and we of the defense, appeal from his fundamental views of today to his philosophical views of yesterday when he was a modernist to our point of view."

Judge Orders Halt.

The words brought the attorney general to his feet with an appeal. The judge again instructed that no further reference be made to Mr. Bryan.

"Yes, your honor," Mr. Malone responded, "but I do not think Mr. Bryan is in the least sensitive about it."

Mr. Bryan shook his palmetto leaf fan slightly. Although his lips tightened, he shook his head and responded, "Not a bit."

An exception was taken by Mr. Malone to the ruling of the court.

Then Mr. Bryan arose slowly. Reporters leaned forward expectantly.

"The court can do as it pleases in carrying out its rules," the firm voice of the Floridian began as he eyed Mr. Malone reflectively, "but I ask no protection from the court."

"When the proper time comes I shall be able to show the gentleman that I stand today just where I did then, but that has nothing to do with the case at bar."

A burst of applause such as seldom is heard in any courtroom swept the crowd, echoing down the corridors. The policeman pounded for order. Other courtroom attaches sounded admonitions.

The judge's voice became audible above the disorder:

"I will have to exclude you gentlemen if you persist in this. The jury is present now and I cannot tolerate any expressions of feeling on the issues in this case at all in the presence of the jury."

See the clipping

The scientists will not be heard

An AP bulletin of 17 July: Judge Raulston has refused to admit the scientific and religious testimony, and John R. Neal of the defense calls it ‘the end of our hopes for the trial of this case’. The experts' evidence went into the record for the higher courts, but in October the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled out the bill of exceptions, and that evidence with it.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 17 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SCOPES SCIENTIFIC TESTIMONY EXCLUDED IN STORMY SESSION

SCOPES LAWYERS LOSE ALL HOPE WHEN COURT REJECTS WITNESSES

See moreSee less

NEAL ADMITS HE HAS REACHED END DEFENSE FIGHT

EVIDENCE WILL GO INTO RECORD IN FORM OF AFFIDAVITS.

By The Associated Press,

DAYTON, Tenn., July 17.—Refusal of Judge Raulton to admit scientific and religious testimony into the evidence of the Scopes case marked the end of the defense hopes for the trial, attorneys for the defense said today, after adjournment of court until Monday, when affidavits containing this evidence will be admitted to record for transmission to the higher courts. "This is the end of our hopes for the trial of this case,'' was the comment of John R. Neal, chief defense counsel.

See the clipping

The state rests; Billy Sunday wires Bryan

An Alaska paper's brief, datelined Dayton, 15 July: the motion to quash is denied and the state has rested. Former pupils testified that Scopes taught them evolution from an official state textbook and had admitted he could not teach it without breaking the law; the state's four witnesses were the only ones the jury would hear. The evangelist Billy Sunday wired Bryan to ask ‘why are there any monkeys left?’

The Kusko Times · McGrath, Alaska

The Kusko Times · 18 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

'IF FROM MONKEYS 'Why Are There Any Monkeys Left?' Asks Billy Sunday. Dayton, July 15.—The state rested its case against John T. Scopes this afternoon, after the testimony of four witnesses had been heard. Former pupils of Scopes in the Rhea county high school presented testimony to the effect that Scopes had taught them a theory of evolution as expounded in an official text book of the state and that he had admitted he could not teach this book without violating the anti-evolution teaching statute of the state. Judge Ralston today denied the motion of the defense to quash the indictment against Scopes.

See moreSee less

The decision upheld the constitutionality of the Tennessee anti-evolution law. Counsel for the state made a formal motion to exclude testimony of scientists from trial of formal motion to exclude testi mony the case. Billy Sunday Wires Bryan. Billy Sunday, noted evangel ist, wired W. J. Bryan, of coun sel for prosecution, as follows: "If we descend from monkeys, why are there any monkeys left? Put me down on the side of God, Christ and the Bible?"

See the clipping

Darrow's retort brings a contempt citation

On 20 July Judge Raulston cites Darrow for contempt over Friday's exchange, when the judge said he hoped Darrow meant no reflection on the court and Darrow replied ‘your honor has the right to hope.’ Bond is $5,000. The day then turns to the record for appeal, with extracts from eight scientists' statements read aloud. That afternoon, a later AP report says, Darrow apologized in full and the judge accepted.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 20 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

DARROW IS CITED FOR CONTEMPT BY

SCOPES CASE JUDGE

See moreSee less

Defense Counsel Leader

Smiles as Raulston Reads

Citation in Court.

LAWYER'S BARB CALLED

'OUTRAGE' TO TENNESSEE Court Session Today Taken Up by

Wrangle Over Experts'

Affidavits.

By the Associated Press.

COURTROOM, Dayton, Tenn., July

20.—Clarence Darrow of counsel for the defense in the Scopes evolution trial was cited for contempt of court today by Judge John T. Raulston.

The attorney was ordered to appear tomorrow and show why contempt proceedings should not be instituted.

The judge named as grounds for the citation remarks of Mr. Darrow to the court Friday when the court excluded the testimony of scientific experts from the jury. The Chicago lawyer was directed to make $5,000 bond for his appearance to answer the citation tomorrow.

On last Friday, the judges said, "contempt was committed in this court." He quoted from the record Mr. Darrow's exchange with the court on the discussion after Judge Raulston excluded expert testimony.

Judge Explains Delay.

"Until passion has had time to subdue the court has withheld any action," the judge read. "I feel it is now time to speak. * * *

"Men may become prominent, but they should never hold themselves superior to the law.

"He who would hurl contempt at my court insults and outrages one of the greatest commonwealths in the country.

"I feel that further forbearance would cease to be a virtue."

The court received a guarantee of Mr. Darrow's surety and the trial proceeded by efforts of the defense to introduce documentary evidence in the absence of the jury.

In announcing the contempt citation, Judge Raulston read from the record of Friday's proceedings. Mr. Darrow frequently smiled and chuckled as the court read.

Part of the colloquy read by the judge in citing Mr. Darrow follows:

The Court—Colonel, what is the purpose of cross-examination?

Mr. Darrow—The purpose of cross-examination is to be used on the trial.

The Court—Well, isn't it an effort to ascertain the truth?

Retort Is Quoted.

Mr. Darrow—No, it is an effort to show prejudice. Nothing else. (Laughter.) Has there been any effort to ascertain the truth in this case? Why not bring in the jury and let us prove it?

The Court—Courts are a mockery——

Mr. Darrow—They are often that, your honor. The Court—When they permit cross-examination for the purpose of creating prejudice.

Mr. Darrow—I submit, your honor, there is no sort of question that they are not entitled to cross-examine, that all this evidence is to show what we expect to prove and nothing else, and can be nothing else.

The Court—I will say this: If the defense wants to put their proof in the record, in the form of affidavits, of course they can do that. If they put the witness on the stand the State desires to cross-examine them. I shall expect them to do so.

Mr. Darrow—We expected it and take an exception.

The Court—Yes, sir; always expect this court to rule correctly.

Mr. Darrow—No sir, we do not. (Laughter.)

The Court—I suppose you anticipated it.

Mr. Darrow—Otherwise we would not be taking our exceptions here, your honor. We expect to protect our rights in some other court. Now, that is plain enough, isn't it? Then, we will make statements of what we expect to prove. Can we have the rest of the day to draft them?

The Court—I would not say——

Cites Opinion Ruling Delay.

Mr. Darrow—If your honor takes a half day to write an opinion——

The Court—I have not taken——

Mr. Darrow—We want to make statements here of what we expected to prove. I do not understand why every request of the State and suggestion of prosecution should meet with an endless grant of time, and a bare suggestion of anything that is perfectly competent on our part should be immediately overruled.

The Court—I hope you do not mean to reflect upon the integrity of the court.

Mr. Darrow—Well, your honor has the right to hope.

The Court—I have a right to do something else, perhaps.

Mr. Darrow—All right; all right.

Crowd Arrives Early.

The usual large crowds flocked to the courtroom today long before the hour of convening. The auditorium was comfortably filled half an hour before Judge Raulston was to open the court.

On each counsel table lay a large cardboard sheet, whose top bore the title in black type, "Canons of Professional Ethics." The canons were listed in 32 divisions, beginning with one which read:

"The duty of the lawyer to the courts: It is the duty of the lawyer to maintain toward the courts a respectful attitude, not for the sake of the temporary incumbent of the judicial office, but for the maintenance of its supreme importance."

The declaration was without announced authorization, save this explanation at the bottom:

"These are rules for the conduct of lawyers generally agreed upon and posted by members of this bar that you may know what to expect of the lawyer."

Attorney General Stewart was early on the scene, the first of either counsel.

Godsey on State Side.

Judge John L. Godsey, first attorney for Scopes, and who withdrew from defense counsel as the trial began, conversed with the prosecution lawyers.

Deputies barred the main entrance, but the eagar crowd slipped through (Continued on Page 5, Column 7.)

DARROW IS CITED

FOR CONTEMPT BY

SCOPES CASE JUDGE

(Continued from First Page.) an anteroom and entered by a side door. Scores of these moved unchecked into the inner railed area of the court and sat on the floor around the judge's seat or stood in masses.

Crowd Is Reduced.

As Judge Raulston struggled through the crowd, the bailiff announced:

"Now, all you people who are standing will have to get out of the room. This is an old building and the floor is likely to give way any minute."

The crowd laughed and those without seats began moving toward the door.

"If you don't get out, we'll have to put you out," the bailiff added.

The crowd was thinned out until a few were standing. At 9:40 o'clock the spectators were orderly.

Rev. R. M. Standerfer, pastor of the Clinton, Tenn., Methodist Episcopal Church South, offered the opening prayer. The preacher has been in the Methodist ministry 49 years. He asked for the "guiding, directing presence" of God.

After the judge had read his statement, the case proceeded, the defense offering a certified copy of the governor's message to the Legislature approving the bill. The State objected to the introduction of the document.

Judge Raulston excluded the message. The defense also offered in evidence the text book of biology adopted by the State Book Commission. Arthur G. Hays read what this text book says of Charles Darwin. Mr. Hays said the purpose of the defense was to show the public policy of the State. The State again objected. Judge Raulston ruled that the book might be filed "for the present."

Mild Controversy Develops.

A mild controversy developed between defense and State counsel as to the presentation of statements of scientific witnesses. The question was as to whether the statements should be submitted without reading, or have portions read to the court.

The defense contended that it should be permitted to read these statements to the court in the hope that the court might be convinced of error in having held the law constitutional.

The debate went back and forth for an hour, Attorneys Hayes, Stewart, Bryan, Malone and Darrow taking part.

Statements from eight scientists were offered to be placed in the record for submission to a higher court in the event Scopes is convicted of teaching evolution theories in the public schools in violation of the State law.

Statements were submitted from the following: Winterton C. Curtis, zoologist, University of Missouri; Horatio Hackett Newman, zoologist, University of Chicago; Wilbur A. Nelson, Tennessee State geologist; Jacob G. Lipman, dean, College of Agriculture, Rutgers; Fay Cooper Cole, anthropologist, Universtiy of Chicago; Maynard M. Metcalf, zoologist, formerly of Oberlin College; Charles Hubbard Judd, director school of education, University of Chicago; Kirtley F. Mather, geologist, Harvard.

Give Defense an Hour.

Judge Raulston finally ruled that one hour would be given the defense to read portions of the statements. In the midst of the reading the attorney general asked Mr. Hays if he might interrupt him.

"Certainly," said Mr. Hayes, "but take time out."

The first statement taken up in this reading was one from the Rev. Walter Whitaker, Knoxville minister, followed by a statement from Dr. Shailer Mathews, University of Chicago. He then proceeded to read extracts from extended statements from the eight scientists.

Mr. Hays was still reading at the luncheon recess, ordered at 11:45 until 1:30 p.m. He was near the end, however, of his time limit.

See the clipping

Court moves outdoors, and Bryan takes the stand

Fearing the old upstairs floor would give way, Judge Raulston moved the trial to the courthouse lawn on 20 July, just after accepting Darrow's apology. There Darrow questioned Bryan on science and the Scriptures, and Bryan denounced him as the foe of God and Christianity. Forecasters, the AP says, saw no end in sight; in fact the case went to the jury the next morning.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 21 July 1925 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

EVOLUTION TRIAL SHIFTED TO OPEN AS CROWD GROWS Floor Of The Court Room Threatens To Collapse Before Transfer

(By Associated Press.)

See moreSee less

DAYTON, Tenn., July 20.—The secene of the Scopes evolution trial was transferred late today from the Rhea county courtroom to the shady lawn outside the red brick building where the thronging crowds might see and hear without restraint of walls.

In ordering the change Judge Raulston explained that the floor of the court which is upstairs, because of age and the burden of humanity was in danger of collapsing.

For nearly three hours this afternoon the maples and alms and overhanging caks resounded to the contending voices of counsel whose tones at intervals were raised in heated altercation. Under the trees, on the grass and rough board seats sat or stood a patient throng, too numerous by hundreds to gain admission to the judicial auditorium.

Here in the open aid they strained and pressed against their fellows eager to catch the words and gestures of opposing champions. Each speaker had his following and all received in varying volume the cheers and handclapping of some approving faction.

Clash Of Belief

Two figures acknowledged representatives of two opposing forces had the gaze of the hundreds who had gathered from the hills of east Tennessee and in lesser numbers from adjoining and distant states. And upon the words of these two men millions waited throughout the nation.

The questioning of William Jennings Bryan, champion of fundamentalism, by Clarence Darrow, legal guide of the group now arrayed in opposition, throughout its duration was a clash of conflicting beliefs. The former secretary of state was subjected to a grilling fire of examination upon his beliefs regarding science and the nature and the sources of the Scriptures. With vehemence, which often brought him to his feet, he repeatedly asserted his conviction of the Bible's truth and denounced his questioner as the foe of God and Christianity.

Calm for the most part, Mr. Darrow at intervals grew impatient and raised his own voice in accents of anger. The two men, facing each other on the high rude platform, glared at each other in undisguised displeasure and assumed belligerent expressions which they emphasized with gestures of arm and finger.

Contrast Furnished

These stirring scenes of conflict followed hard upon another of contrasting tone. Just before the removal from the upper hall, Judge Raulston had received the apology of Mr. Darrow in such indulgent language that the entire feeling of resentment which has been apparent between defense and state attorneys appeared to have been dissipated. In a smiling group, the presiding judge, the attorney general, Mr. Bryan and the visiting counsel for young Scopes posed for photographers. They left the hall in friendly mood and with expressions of mutual regard. The breach recurred within a few minutes after the outdoor proceedings were begun.

Today had been looked upon in prospect as the first step in the descending action of the Scopes drama—so, at least, had court attaches and newspapermen described it. But no such opinion was held by the inflowing throngs who flocked to Dayton and the courthouse square in greater numbers than heretofore. They had heard that a sensation would be provided by Judge Raulston and Mr. Darrow as a sequel to the Chicago lawyer's words to the court on Friday. When the sun had set today they had witnessed this expected secene—though milder than rumor had promised—in the contempt citation and Mr. Darrow's full apology, which the court received.

And when the went down, forecasters had revised their estimates as to the early conclusion of the trial and tonight they declared that no end was in sight.

See the clipping

Bryan defends the Bible under Darrow's questions

Robert T. Small calls the outdoor clash the trial's climax. Darrow called Bryan as an expert on the Bible, and before a roaring crowd Bryan answered ‘If it is in the Bible, I believe it’, though he allowed that the days of creation might have been ages. The judge at last adjourned court amid the uproar. The next morning he struck Bryan's testimony from the record.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 21 July 1925 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

CLIMAX IN DAYTON AMAZING BEDLAM

Crowd Roars in Wild Disorder as Bryan and Darrow Clash.

See moreSee less

BY ROBERT T. SMALL.

DAYTON, Tenn., July 21.—This amazing trial!

There was reason from the first to believe it would be one of the most remarkable cases in American jurisprudence, but it has so turned out that there never was and never can again be anything like it in the air, the earth or the waters under the earth. It has broken out in so many different and startling directions that one is left bewildered at each day's end.

But of all the scenes and all the circumstances it remained for the cat-and-dog fight between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan to furnish the climatic spectacle of Dayton's distasteful delirium. All semblance of legal procedure was swept aside and pandemonium broke loose. Both Bryan and Darrow appeared to have the gift of tongues. They flew at each other verbally like a couple of fishwives.

Rebel Yells Fill Air.

And all the while rebel yells filled the air. Men and women shouted at the tops of their lungs. Children wept. Dogs barked. Automobile horns honked. Railroad trains went screeching by. Hot-dog venders called their wares. Newsboys came hurrying through the crowd with the latest extras.

Every now and then the voice of the circuit attorney general, young Tom Stewart, who is so suggestive of Senator Borah in his younger days, could be heard appealing to the judge, in the name of the law and Tennessee, to stop the uproar. But the judge let it go until at last the epithets were being hurled at such a rate and the attitude of the two vocal combatants was such that the court, in something of a panic, banged his gavel and shouted:

"Court's adjourned!"

The setting for the scene was as amazing as the encounter itself. And the whole affair left most of the innocent bystanders gasping and gazing at each other as persons do who awake from some dread nightmare. Court had been adjourned to the great out of doors. There had been the threat all along that this might happen. A platform or stage had been erected against one of the courthouse walls and in front of it were arranged rough board benches to accommodate several hundreds of persons. The courthouse yard is a beautiful grove, affording plenty of shade and sylvan coloring. The whole county has not been able to get into the courtroom despite the generous hospitality of the court officials, who permitted the occupation of aisles, windows and nearly every inch of breathing space

Raulston Hospitable.

Judge Raulston is an extremely kind-hearted man and it has distressed him beyond measure to see any of his friends and voters shut out from the show of the century. And so at last, in the belief that the upstairs courtroom might no longer be safe under its groaning weight of sweltering humanity, the judge unceremoniously moved the proceedings down on the lawn. A rough table was provided as the "bench." Most of the lawyers "toted" their own chairs downstairs and the spectators scrambled for all points of vantage, including the limbs of the trees.

Arms and legs dangled down the courthouse windows overlooking the east lawn. Autos parked all around the outer railing of the yard. Refreshment stands and public comfort stations loomed in the immediate foreground. Children and babies were everywhere. The atmosphere of the old-time camp meeting or the rural Summer chautauqua which has crept into the proceedings from the beginning took complete possession.

Crowd Roars Approval.

It was in this setting, of all places, that Clarence Darrow, always dealing the unexpected, called William Jennings Bryan to the witness chair as an "expert" for the defense on the subject of the Bible and its interpretation. The battle of bedlam was on. The crowd, unrestrained by courtroom surroundings, cut loose and roared its head off. A bailiff, trying in vain to get order, vociferated:

"This ain't no circus."

But it was, and a merry one. The crowd was almost unanimously for Bryan and each time he could be heard shouting louder than Darrow the applause was uproarious. Darrow was cheered by a minority, more or less respectable, and at times there was whooping and howling for both the gladiators engaged in their duel of pitiless publicity.

Mr. Bryan couldn't sit still in the outdoor witness chair for long. Half of the time he was on his feet, haranguing the crowd. There never was such a "witness." In almost agonized tones he would cry aloud: "I am protecting the word of God against the greatest atheist, or agnostic, in the world."

Darrow Calmer of Two.

To which Darrow, far the less excited of the two, would reply in snarling tones that he was trying to protect the world against Mr. Bryan's "fool ideas" of religion.

The upshot of the grilling of Mr. Bryan was a paraphrase of Decatur's classic:

"My country, right or wrong."

With Mr. Bryan it was the Bible. He cared not for seeming contradictions pointed out by Darrow within the book itself; he cared not for dates which appeared to upset some religious theories of world history; he cared nothing for science; in his seeking for worldly knowledge, he had gone beyond "the printed word." His answer invariably was: "If it is in the Bible, I believe it."

Mr. Bryan consented to take the witness chair, he explained, so he "could shut Darrow's mouth, and not have him going about the country boasting to his atheist friends that Bryan had been afraid to meet and answer his questions."

Takes Bible Literally.

Mr. Bryan is as fundamental as the Rock of Ages. He takes literally everything in the Bible. To him there is no allegory. God actually made the snake in the Garden of Eden to crawl upon his belly because he had induced Eve to tempt Adam. Mr. Bryan did not know how the snake traveled before God cursed him. Mr. Bryan believed there was no sun until the fourth day of creation, but he insisted that even without a sun there were "mornings" and "evenings" of the first, second and third days, "because the book says so."

In only one respect has Mr. Bryan admitted a doubt. He says the "days" mentioned in the Bible may not have been 24-hour cycles. They may have been "ages" or "periods." But the Commoner was quick to add that the God in whom he believed "was perfectly capable of making the world in six 24-hour days if he so chose."

Mr. Bryan seemed fascinated by the Darrow questions, but after answering them he would swing his arms aloft and protest against "this slurring of the Bible by an atheist."

The colloquies of the two men in these closing days of the trial have been amazing. There is no other word for it. But the climax has been natural. They have been working up to it. Bryan has attacked Darrow by speech and published statement; almost daily Darrow has replied in kind. Of course, all this "expert" testimony has been barred, but Judge Raulston has permitted the unusual procedure, with the jury absent, to perfect the record of appeal. The "appeal" has been discussed all through the "law suit," just as if the verdict of guilty was a foregone conclusion.

See the clipping

The defense settles for a conviction to appeal

On the last morning, 21 July, Judge Raulston struck Bryan's testimony from the record, and the lawyers agreed to let the jury return a guilty verdict without argument. A directed verdict was dropped, the AP explains, because a formal admission of guilt would cost the defense its appeal. The jury took nine minutes to convict Scopes, and he was fined $100, the minimum under the law.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 21 July 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

LAWYERS AGREE VERDICT GUILTY IN SCOPES TRIAL BRYAN TESTIMONY IS EX- PUNGED FROM RECORDS OF CASE BY JUDGE RAULSTON.

By The Associated Press.

See moreSee less

DAYTON, Tenn., July 21.—Judge John T. Raulston, retired fi m the courtroom at nine forty-five this morning to dictate his charge to the jury in the Scopes case.

The end of the evolution test was brought in sight by an agreement of attorneys to give the case to the jury to permit the record to show a verdict of guilty without argument.

After Judge Raulston had expunged the testimony of William J. Bryan from the record of yesterday's session, an agreement was quickly reached to bring the case to a close. Bryan, however, made a statement that he would make public later a series of questions he would have asked Darrow, Dudley Field Malone and Arthur G. Hayes if he had had opportunity to examine them as witnesses. It explained that the defense testimony on which it was hoped to accquit Scopes, having been excluded the defense would state to the jury that it could not ask a verdict of not guilty, and was satisfied to have conviction in this court that an appeal might be made to the supreme court of Tennessee and possibly eventually to the United States Supreme Court.

Darrow, defense counsel, said he would make such statement to the jury. The suggestion that the judge direct a verdict of guilty was discarded when it was pointed out that for the defense to officially admit guilt would deprive it of the right to appeal.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: Biggest Show on Earth