Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
See moreSee less
Defense Counsel Leader
Smiles as Raulston Reads
Citation in Court.
LAWYER'S BARB CALLED
'OUTRAGE' TO TENNESSEE Court Session Today Taken Up by
Wrangle Over Experts'
Affidavits.
By the Associated Press.
COURTROOM, Dayton, Tenn., July
20.—Clarence Darrow of counsel for the defense in the Scopes evolution trial was cited for contempt of court today by Judge John T. Raulston.
The attorney was ordered to appear tomorrow and show why contempt proceedings should not be instituted.
The judge named as grounds for the citation remarks of Mr. Darrow to the court Friday when the court excluded the testimony of scientific experts from the jury. The Chicago lawyer was directed to make $5,000 bond for his appearance to answer the citation tomorrow.
On last Friday, the judges said, "contempt was committed in this court." He quoted from the record Mr. Darrow's exchange with the court on the discussion after Judge Raulston excluded expert testimony.
Judge Explains Delay.
"Until passion has had time to subdue the court has withheld any action," the judge read. "I feel it is now time to speak. * * *
"Men may become prominent, but they should never hold themselves superior to the law.
"He who would hurl contempt at my court insults and outrages one of the greatest commonwealths in the country.
"I feel that further forbearance would cease to be a virtue."
The court received a guarantee of Mr. Darrow's surety and the trial proceeded by efforts of the defense to introduce documentary evidence in the absence of the jury.
In announcing the contempt citation, Judge Raulston read from the record of Friday's proceedings. Mr. Darrow frequently smiled and chuckled as the court read.
Part of the colloquy read by the judge in citing Mr. Darrow follows:
The Court—Colonel, what is the purpose of cross-examination?
Mr. Darrow—The purpose of cross-examination is to be used on the trial.
The Court—Well, isn't it an effort to ascertain the truth?
Retort Is Quoted.
Mr. Darrow—No, it is an effort to show prejudice. Nothing else. (Laughter.) Has there been any effort to ascertain the truth in this case? Why not bring in the jury and let us prove it?
The Court—Courts are a mockery——
Mr. Darrow—They are often that, your honor. The Court—When they permit cross-examination for the purpose of creating prejudice.
Mr. Darrow—I submit, your honor, there is no sort of question that they are not entitled to cross-examine, that all this evidence is to show what we expect to prove and nothing else, and can be nothing else.
The Court—I will say this: If the defense wants to put their proof in the record, in the form of affidavits, of course they can do that. If they put the witness on the stand the State desires to cross-examine them. I shall expect them to do so.
Mr. Darrow—We expected it and take an exception.
The Court—Yes, sir; always expect this court to rule correctly.
Mr. Darrow—No sir, we do not. (Laughter.)
The Court—I suppose you anticipated it.
Mr. Darrow—Otherwise we would not be taking our exceptions here, your honor. We expect to protect our rights in some other court. Now, that is plain enough, isn't it? Then, we will make statements of what we expect to prove. Can we have the rest of the day to draft them?
The Court—I would not say——
Cites Opinion Ruling Delay.
Mr. Darrow—If your honor takes a half day to write an opinion——
The Court—I have not taken——
Mr. Darrow—We want to make statements here of what we expected to prove. I do not understand why every request of the State and suggestion of prosecution should meet with an endless grant of time, and a bare suggestion of anything that is perfectly competent on our part should be immediately overruled.
The Court—I hope you do not mean to reflect upon the integrity of the court.
Mr. Darrow—Well, your honor has the right to hope.
The Court—I have a right to do something else, perhaps.
Mr. Darrow—All right; all right.
Crowd Arrives Early.
The usual large crowds flocked to the courtroom today long before the hour of convening. The auditorium was comfortably filled half an hour before Judge Raulston was to open the court.
On each counsel table lay a large cardboard sheet, whose top bore the title in black type, "Canons of Professional Ethics." The canons were listed in 32 divisions, beginning with one which read:
"The duty of the lawyer to the courts: It is the duty of the lawyer to maintain toward the courts a respectful attitude, not for the sake of the temporary incumbent of the judicial office, but for the maintenance of its supreme importance."
The declaration was without announced authorization, save this explanation at the bottom:
"These are rules for the conduct of lawyers generally agreed upon and posted by members of this bar that you may know what to expect of the lawyer."
Attorney General Stewart was early on the scene, the first of either counsel.
Godsey on State Side.
Judge John L. Godsey, first attorney for Scopes, and who withdrew from defense counsel as the trial began, conversed with the prosecution lawyers.
Deputies barred the main entrance, but the eagar crowd slipped through (Continued on Page 5, Column 7.)
DARROW IS CITED
FOR CONTEMPT BY
SCOPES CASE JUDGE
(Continued from First Page.) an anteroom and entered by a side door. Scores of these moved unchecked into the inner railed area of the court and sat on the floor around the judge's seat or stood in masses.
Crowd Is Reduced.
As Judge Raulston struggled through the crowd, the bailiff announced:
"Now, all you people who are standing will have to get out of the room. This is an old building and the floor is likely to give way any minute."
The crowd laughed and those without seats began moving toward the door.
"If you don't get out, we'll have to put you out," the bailiff added.
The crowd was thinned out until a few were standing. At 9:40 o'clock the spectators were orderly.
Rev. R. M. Standerfer, pastor of the Clinton, Tenn., Methodist Episcopal Church South, offered the opening prayer. The preacher has been in the Methodist ministry 49 years. He asked for the "guiding, directing presence" of God.
After the judge had read his statement, the case proceeded, the defense offering a certified copy of the governor's message to the Legislature approving the bill. The State objected to the introduction of the document.
Judge Raulston excluded the message. The defense also offered in evidence the text book of biology adopted by the State Book Commission. Arthur G. Hays read what this text book says of Charles Darwin. Mr. Hays said the purpose of the defense was to show the public policy of the State. The State again objected. Judge Raulston ruled that the book might be filed "for the present."
Mild Controversy Develops.
A mild controversy developed between defense and State counsel as to the presentation of statements of scientific witnesses. The question was as to whether the statements should be submitted without reading, or have portions read to the court.
The defense contended that it should be permitted to read these statements to the court in the hope that the court might be convinced of error in having held the law constitutional.
The debate went back and forth for an hour, Attorneys Hayes, Stewart, Bryan, Malone and Darrow taking part.
Statements from eight scientists were offered to be placed in the record for submission to a higher court in the event Scopes is convicted of teaching evolution theories in the public schools in violation of the State law.
Statements were submitted from the following: Winterton C. Curtis, zoologist, University of Missouri; Horatio Hackett Newman, zoologist, University of Chicago; Wilbur A. Nelson, Tennessee State geologist; Jacob G. Lipman, dean, College of Agriculture, Rutgers; Fay Cooper Cole, anthropologist, Universtiy of Chicago; Maynard M. Metcalf, zoologist, formerly of Oberlin College; Charles Hubbard Judd, director school of education, University of Chicago; Kirtley F. Mather, geologist, Harvard.
Give Defense an Hour.
Judge Raulston finally ruled that one hour would be given the defense to read portions of the statements. In the midst of the reading the attorney general asked Mr. Hays if he might interrupt him.
"Certainly," said Mr. Hayes, "but take time out."
The first statement taken up in this reading was one from the Rev. Walter Whitaker, Knoxville minister, followed by a statement from Dr. Shailer Mathews, University of Chicago. He then proceeded to read extracts from extended statements from the eight scientists.
Mr. Hays was still reading at the luncheon recess, ordered at 11:45 until 1:30 p.m. He was near the end, however, of his time limit.