As the Papers Told It

The Scopes Trial · The full archive

July 1925, part 6

250 articles

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Judge Raulston threatened contempt charges against whoever leaked his ruling on the defense's motion to quash the indictment, appointing reporters to investigate the source. Separately, defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays read a petition asking for non-fundamentalist clergy to also offer opening prayers, following Darrow's protest against the practice.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Jail To Author Of Unauthorized Report

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

During the Scopes trial, attorneys Stewart and Hays clash angrily over a defense petition requesting non-fundamentalist ministers lead prayers, which Judge Raulston defers to Dayton's pastors association. Separately, Raulston reprimands the press after a wire service report suggested his still-secret written opinion had leaked, and he announces he will withhold reading it until Wednesday.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A local lawyer from Troy, Alabama, George Grant, has traveled to Dayton, Tennessee, hoping to get within hearing distance of the famous Scopes trial. He stated he only wanted to hear the arguments of noted lawyers and had not been retained by either side.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 3

ATTENDS DAYTON TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A reader's letter to the Age-Herald recounts the 1886 heresy trial of Professor James Woodrow, uncle of Woodrow Wilson, for teaching evolution at a South Carolina seminary, drawing parallels to Scopes. It notes Wilson's own sympathy for evolution, quoting a letter in which he affirms belief in organic evolution.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 4

PROFESSOR WOODROW'S TRIAL AT HUNTSVILLE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A humor column by H.I. Phillips lampoons the Scopes trial with absurd fictional events like a Great Dane causing jury panic, a monkey witness demanding bigger air holes, and bribery claims involving vegetables. The piece is pure comedic satire rather than factual reporting on the trial.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 4

MORE CHATTERINGS FROM THE WILDS OF TENNESSEE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A society/personals column reports that Dr. C. E. Williams and his daughters, visiting relatives in Bessemer, are en route to Dayton, Tennessee to attend the famous Scopes trial. The rest of the item lists various other local visitors and social events unrelated to the trial.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 10

PERSONALS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Col. George L. Carter visited Dayton during the Scopes evolution trial and witnessed jury selection proceedings. He reported that the original indictment was quashed on a technicality and a new indictment was returned by a regular grand jury before the trial continued.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 11

RETURNS FROM DAYTON Col. Carter Witnessed Selection Of Jury In Scopes Trial Col, and Mrs, George I*, Carter are back from a trip through east Tennes see, where they went to visit relatives of the latter for a few days, making the trip through the country by autoj mobile. While In uast Tennessee, Colonel Car ter availed himself of the privilege of going to Dayton to witness the opening of the Scoues evolution trial on was there while the jury to pass on the case Was being selected. One of the first matters disposed of when court convened was that of quashr 1 Ing the original Indictment on the ground that it was illegel, because a Special grand Jury had been called,for the purpose of hearing evidence in the case, After the indictment had been quashed, a regular grand jury took up the investigation and returned an in dictment against Scopes, Colonel Carter states that the case is rather interesting and that many from a distance are attending the daily ses sions of the court.

See moreSee less

Judge Raulston, who Is presiding in the case, is an old friend of Colonel Carter’s. On their return they drove 240 miles tn about 10 hours.

See the clipping

El Fronterizo · Tucson, Arizona

The report outlines the case against John Thomas Scopes, a 24-year-old biology teacher in Dayton, Tennessee, charged with teaching evolution in violation of state law, with a penalty of $100-$500 per offense. It lists the prosecution team led by William Jennings Bryan and the defense team led by Clarence Darrow.

El Fronterizo · 15 July 1925 · page 4

LA GRAN LUCHA

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Fronterizo · Tucson, Arizona

British clergy and scientists, including the Archbishop of Birmingham and George Bernard Shaw, publicly criticized the Dayton, Tennessee trial of teacher John Thomas Scopes. Shaw mocked America for letting the state become a haven for cowardly moralists, while a zoology professor predicted evolution would eventually be as widely accepted as alcohol use after Prohibition.

El Fronterizo · 15 July 1925 · page 4

En Londres Se Critica El Jucio Scopes

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Fronterizo · Tucson, Arizona

Tucson's El Fronterizo reports that the Scopes trial opened last Friday in Dayton with a prayer by Rev. Cartwright, describing a courtroom packed with reporters and scientists in shirtsleeves due to heat. The editorial also offers commentary predicting Scopes will be found guilty and worrying that fundamentalists may next seek a constitutional amendment mandating biblical creation.

El Fronterizo · 15 July 1925 · page 1

¿QUIENES FUERON NUESTROS PRIMEROS PADRES, ADAN Y EVA, O FUERON ANIMALES INFERIORES?

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

El Fronterizo · Tucson, Arizona

The article describes the formal opening of the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, including a prayer by Rev. Courtwright, Darrow's conference with Prosecutor Stewart, and the jury selection. It also reprints the text of the Tennessee anti-evolution law and lists the trial's main figures, including Judge Raulston.

El Fronterizo · 15 July 1925 · page 1

¿ADÁN Y EVA, O FUERON ANIMALES INFERIORES?

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

A newspaper photo caption identifies William Jennings Bryan and his son, Los Angeles lawyer William Jennings Bryan Jr., who joined forces to prosecute John Scopes in Dayton. It notes they are fighting to uphold Tennessee's law banning the teaching of evolution.

New Britain Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

LIKE FATHER, LIKE SON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

Judge John T. Raulston ruled against the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He addressed defense arguments about discrepancies between the act's title and body, ruling the caption sufficiently covered the legislation.

New Britain Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The judge's ruling addresses defense arguments that the Butler Act violated constitutional rights, including religious freedom and teachers' rights, finding these claims without merit. He reasoned the law does not interfere with worship, does not compel anyone to teach, and the indictment was sufficiently clear as it followed the statute's wording.

New Britain Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The report recounts a humorous anecdote about Dudley Field Malone and an ape brought to Dayton by publicity seekers, allegedly placed in his chair by defense scientists. It also notes that Dayton's anticipated flood of visitors and business failed to materialize, with crowds, concessions, and traffic far below expectations.

New Britain Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 3

SIDELIGHTS OF SCOPES TRIAL

Dayton, Tenn, Dyton, Tenn., July 15 P The atory nu toll In Dayton toiay of how Dudly Field Malone was aped by an ap. One of the animals brought to Dayton by publicity seekers w9 car ried to "the mansion" last night for a vlalt with the proposed scientific witnesses for the defense who aro makingthe public house their headquarteri here, the story said. Interested with the animal the scientists wero sold to have placed It In Malone's chair at the table around which they were grouped. While thoy were discussing the ape and subjecting It to various tests.

See moreSee less

Malone entered the room. The conclusion of the story tvas that Malone, disliking the farce, called an automobile, bundled the ape and his master Into It and sent them back to town. Dayton prepared for a flood and

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The report describes the circus-like atmosphere in Dayton during the Scopes trial, noting disappointed vendors, light traffic despite ordinances, and swarms of journalists and publicity seekers. It also mentions songwriters crafting 'monkey trial' ballads and an incongruous scene of a vaudeville tent operating across from a church service.

New Britain Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 3

SCOPES TRIAL

During a preaching service In one of the Dayton churches last night a vaudeville performance was being conducted In a tent directly across the street. As the corgregatlon poured Its feelings Into the song service a tinny piano banged and the piping voice of a soubrette sounded the words to a .lam aong. The conclusion of the hymn across the street wna punc tuated by the applause given the performers In the tent,

See the clipping

Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.

This report describes the informal, carnival-like atmosphere surrounding the Scopes trial in Dayton, including dogs wandering the courtroom, vendors selling cushions, and a chimpanzee paraded down Main Street. It also notes the presence of Mrs. Bryan and Mrs. Darrow in the courtroom.

Imperial Valley Press · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Sidelights On Tennessee's 'Monkey Trial'

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Judge John T. Raulston denied the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He addressed each defense argument, including the claim of discrepancy between the act's title and body, ruling the caption sufficiently broad to cover the law's provisions.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 1

DAYTON. Tenn., July 15.—. Judge! John T. Raulston today denied the dej sense motion to quash the indictment j against John T. Scopes. The judge's j decision upheld the constitutionality of the Tennessee anti-evolution law. | The motion to quash was made \ -Monday and the day was spent in argument. Judge Raulston was occu pied all of yesterday in writing his decision, which was voluminous. It took up each contention of the de- : sense and ruled that the defendant I ■would be required to plead further.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Judge Raulston rules that the Tennessee law banning evolution teaching does not violate constitutional rights to worship, since teachers are not compelled to work in public schools and may seek employment elsewhere if they object. He also dismisses claims of vagueness, discriminatory class legislation, and violation of the Fourteenth Amendment, citing precedent including Meyer vs. Nebraska.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 1

WITHIN STATE'S RIGHTS

These relations, he said, are purely , .contractual, and “if his conscience ; constrains him to teach the evolution ; theory he can find opportunities else-! where in other schools of the State i • * * and give full expression to [ his beliefs and convictions upon this : and other subjects without any inter1 ference from the State of Tennessee ■ or its authorities. “Neither do I see how the act lays ] any restraint on his right to worship j according to the dictates of his conI science.

See moreSee less

Under the provisions of this 1 act this defendant, or any other per-j sons, can entertain any religious be-i lief which most appeals to their con1 science.” The statute, he also held, does not | unlawfully deprive Scopes of any of his liberitcs. privileges or property. ! The alleged vagueness In the indicti 'mcnt. he held, did not exist, since it | "substantially copies the words of the : statute and is, therefore, sufficiently i certain."

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Judge Raulston read from State Supreme Court rulings addressing claims of class legislation and violation of the fourteenth amendment, citing the Meyer vs. Nebraska case regarding language teaching restrictions. He concluded with the Deeper case, a Tennessee authority on the Legislature's control over public school curricula.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Requests of the Army Air Service and the National Museum to the War Department that the museum here be the final resting place of the most fa mous of all airplanes—the Chicago, flagship of the world flight—have met t with no response and the airplane now is wasting away in a hangar at McCook Field, Dayton. Ohio, with the problem of its final disposition no nearer solution than a year ago when it completed the aerial circuit of the globe. Shortly after the official termina tion of the flight at Seattle, Wash., last September, the Air Service recom mended, in the face of a deluge of requests from nearly every city in the country for its acquisition, that the Chicago be brought to Washington and housed here for posterity.

See moreSee less

The City of Chicago made strenuous ef forts to have the plane installed in the Field Museum and there the mat ter died. The craft, along with the New Orleans and the Boston 11. was flown from the coast to Dayton in Novem ber of last year by the original crews and there turned over to the Kngineering Division while Washing ton was to take action. Nothing has been done about it since, as far as could be learned today.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Reporter Robert T. Small describes rising tempers among judge, lawyers, and spectators at the Scopes trial, worsened by stifling heat and sectional friction between Southern and Eastern participants. He notes Judge Raulston's irritability over leaked predictions and speculates the judge may ultimately allow expert scientific testimony, prolonging the case.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 4

NERVES IN DAYTON ALREADY FRAYED Judge, Lawyers and Every one Else About Ready to Snap

May Open Doors to Expert?. Now there is the further hunch go ing the rounds that, after siding with the State on the sufficiency of the in dictment and the constitutionality of the anti-evolution law, Judge Raul ston will hold for the defense that

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A correspondent describes the carnival-like mood in Dayton during the Scopes trial, noting defendant John Scopes's casual demeanor and suggestions he lecture while awaiting sentencing. The piece also covers the courtroom controversy over Darrow's objection to opening prayers and the crowds, mostly women, who flock to watch the proceedings.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Prayer Another Row Maker. And then there is all this quarreling about opening the court with prayer. It was indicated in these dispatches several days ago that The defense was going to object to a daily invocation. Some folks thought Clarence Darrow wouldn't have the nerve to get up in open court and voice such an objec tion. especially after the fundamental ist demonstrations which have swept the courtroom from time to time and have shown which way the sultry re ligious winds are blowing down these Tennessee valleys. They reckoned without their Darrow.

See moreSee less

The Chicago lawyer knew he would he a second Ajax defying the light ning; he knew that hot curses would be heaped upon his aged head and drooping shoulders, but he stood up there and Jiad his sgy, and then no body wondered that Dayton’s lights went out and the water supply sud denly failed. Dayton will never be the same until Darrow leaves. Even then it may be marked for life. That Darrow is an agnostic has been writ ten deep in the court records of the county. State counsel hurled the word at the defense. Malone and some of the others hotly resented the charge. Darrow accepted it with that dry. provoking smile which plays al ways so close to his lips.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evangelist Billy Sunday, vacationing in Oregon instead of joining Bryan at the Scopes trial, mocked evolutionists with a sarcastic parody prayer about a 'cocoanut tree' ancestor. Meanwhile in Dayton, Judge Raulston issued his ruling denying the defense's motion to quash Scopes's indictment, citing the Legislature's broad authority over public school curricula.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Those Who Break Laws of Land. By Consolidated Press PAKKDALE. Oreg.. July 15.—" The only rational prayer an evolutionist can offer Is; 'Our father, who art in a cocoanut tree. hallowed be thy name.’ " Far from the crowded courtroom in Dayton. Tenn., enjoying the cool and quiet of his ranch in the Hood River Upper Valley, Billy Sunday awoke suddenly from a peaceful midday nap and delivered the above declaration. The writer surprised the evangelist stretched out on the floor of his airy bungalow. Billy had dropped off into a snooze while "Ma" Sunday, comfort ably attired in a $1 gingham gown (she said so herself), read aloud to him.

See moreSee less

The Rev. Mr. Sunday had been urged to assist his fellow evangelist Bryan in the Scopes trial, but the lure of snow-capped mountains and his quiet ranch proved too great. He came West instead, hut. like an old cavalry horse responding to gun powder, he leaped from the floor with a typical Sunday spring when he heard the word “evolution.” He turned his back for a moment continued, more mildly; lution. talk about!”

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This is a general editorial column touching on various topics including D.C. public works funding, prehistoric bones found in Mexico, and the death of archeologist Dr. Giacomo Boni. It briefly jokes about the Dayton, Tenn. Scopes trial, noting Bryan's prominence and referring to Scopes becoming 'Exhibit A' in the proceedings.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 6

-- I > ■ —— Prehistoric bones have been dis covered in Mexico. They are of the highest importance, in the opinion of archeologists, who apparently are au daciously determined to go ahead with their own scientific deductions with out waiting for Col. Bryan’s O. K.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An opinion piece argues that Clarence Darrow made a tactical error by protesting the court's opening prayer, claiming it alienated sympathy and obscured the real legal question of state curriculum authority. The writer predicts the Dayton verdict will go against Scopes, with the larger constitutional question to be resolved elsewhere.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 6

Darrow's Blunder. Clarence Darrow, chief counsel for Scopes in the Dayton “evolution'' trial, lias committed a tactical blunder at the beginning of the case, in pro testing the opening of court with prayer. He has by this move alienated sympathy that might otherwise have been felt for his cause, for it lias had the effect of emphasizing the religious issue, whereas the chief question in volved in the case is a strictly legal one. The main question at Dayton is whether the State can rightfully pro-1 scribe a subject of instruction from the curriculum of the public eduea tional system, not whether men de scended from a lower animal order or whether religion should be observed in the conduct of judicial procedure.

See moreSee less

That question will not be finally an swered at Dayton. The verdict of that court is virtually certain to be against the defendant. The Jury i? asked to consider merely the fact of the method of instruction adopted by the teacher who is at the bar. It can reasonably answer only that he has violated the Mate statute. In another court will be argued and decided the question of whether the State had the right to adopt such a statute. To protest the delivery of prayer at the opening of court was to create a prejudice against counsel and de fendant. It is the custom of that court. It is in keeping with the senti ment and belief of the people of that community. To argue that prayer es tablished an “unfavorable atmosphere of religion” was to affront the com munity as well as to becloud the real issue. Prayer has never harmed any one or any cause. Darrow's protest against it exposes him to the charge of narrowness and bigotry that he has brought against his chief oppo nent, Bryan. The monkey might have a little more respect in current popular opin ion if there were the slightest possi bility of any member of his immedi ate family qualifying as a prize winner in a beauty contest. If the present tendencies of political notoriety are permitted to go un checked the two great parties of the future will be the Fundamentalists and the Modernists. No man is content with his lot in life. G. Bernard Shaw insists on talk ing international politics and Mus solini writes a play. China has had many revolutions, and may regard the solicitude of the outside world as interference with a national custom.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This editorial commentary discusses the Scopes trial at Dayton, arguing the jury can only decide whether the teacher violated the state statute, not the broader question of the law's constitutionality. It criticizes Darrow's objection to courtroom prayer as hypocritical given his accusations of bigotry against Bryan, and includes satirical verse mocking the evolution debate.

Evening Star · 15 July 1925 · page 6

To protest the delivery of prayer at the opening of court was to create a prejudice against counsel and de fendant. It is the custom of that court. It is in keeping with the senti ment and belief of the people of that community. To argue that prayer es tablished an “unfavorable atmosphere of religion” was to affront the com munity as well as to becloud the real issue. Prayer has never harmed any one or any cause. Darrow's protest against it exposes him to the charge of narrowness and bigotry that he has brought against his chief oppo nent, Bryan.

See moreSee less

The monkey might have a little more respect in current popular opin ion if there were the slightest possi bility of any member of his immedi ate family qualifying as a prize winner in a beauty contest. If the present tendencies of political notoriety are permitted to go un checked the two great parties of the future will be the Fundamentalists and the Modernists. No man is content with his lot in life. G. Bernard Shaw insists on talk ing international politics and Mus solini writes a play. China has had many revolutions, and may regard the solicitude of the outside world as interference with a national custom.

See the clipping

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

A court ruling confirmed that the indictment against John Scopes for teaching evolution in Tennessee schools is valid. This clears the way for the trial to proceed on the merits of the case.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Scopes Indictment Is Upheld

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

Judge John T. Raulston overruled the defense motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, ruling in a 5000-word opinion that the Tennessee anti-evolution law was constitutional. The decision was a victory for the prosecution, and court recessed until the afternoon for arguments on evidence admissibility.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Judge Rules That Ape Trial Must Be Continued; Says There Is Nothing Loose or Vague in the Charge Against Prof. Scopes; Ruling Covers 5000 Words and Goes Into Extreme Detail

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

The judge delivers his ruling that the Tennessee anti-evolution law does not violate teachers' religious liberty, since public schools exist for moral and mental development, not worship, and teachers may seek employment elsewhere if conscience conflicts with the law. The courtroom reconvenes after a brief recess following the 17-minute ruling.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

A correspondent argues the prosecution is driven by local political ambitions in heavily fundamentalist Rhea County, while the defense aims at a broader constitutional test regardless of Scopes' guilt. The piece suggests a conviction would actually help the defense's goal of reaching the Supreme Court on free speech/academic freedom grounds.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 3

LOCAL POLITICS SPURS SCOPES PROSECUTION

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

This report by N.D. Cochran analyzes how the political realities of fundamentalist Tennessee shape the prosecution and the judge's conduct, noting a Scopes conviction actually helps the defense reach the Supreme Court. A separate item describes Mrs. Clarence Darrow denying she controls her husband.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

A United Press correspondent profiles Mrs. Clarence Darrow, who denies rumors that she controls her husband's legal strategy, laughing off the idea. The piece also notes Darrow's defense team expects no favorable outcome locally and is aiming for a Supreme Court test of the Bill of Rights.

The Washington Daily News · 15 July 1925 · page 3

DARROW'S WIFE DENIES SHE IS BOSS - Lawyer's Stylish and Handsome Wife Has Same Enthusiasm as He

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A satirical cartoon piece by Hal Coffman pokes fun at the residents of Dayton, Tennessee, suggesting they are too closed-minded to accept new scientific ideas. It is dated during the ongoing Scopes evolution trial.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

HAL COFFMAN GETS A BIG LAUGH OUT OF THE DAYTON EVOLUTION TRIAL

(Continued on Page 2, Column 6.) “Hutch” Used His Head and Got Scoop How International News Service “scooped” the other re porters in stating, twenty hours in advance, that the judge of the evolution trial at Dayton would hold the law constitu tional. was the gossip among newspapermen today.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The judge in the Scopes trial read his ruling upholding the constitutionality of the Tennessee law against teaching evolution. A sidebar notes that an INS reporter scooped the ruling twenty hours in advance by reasoning from the judge's comments about further proceedings.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

COURT READS RULING AGAINST EVOLUTION

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A Chicago Evening American correspondent recounts how he obtained advance word that Judge Raulston would rule against the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John Thomas Scopes. The piece describes the chaotic, carnival-like atmosphere in Dayton, Tennessee during the trial.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Writer Gets Clean “Scoop” On Scopes Decision By THOMAS TEMPLE HOYNE, Staff Correspondent the Chicago Evening American. DAYTON, Tenn., July 15—The story of how the world was told

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A newspapermen's committee appointed by Judge Raulston investigated a news leak suggesting the court would uphold Scopes' indictment. The committee found the information did not come improperly from the judge's stenographer, but rather from a casual conversation between a reporter and the judge at a hotel.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Leak Report Made. Beamish submitted the following report: “The committee appointed by your honorable court to investigate a reported news leak of the substance of your honor's opinion upon the motion to quash the Indictment of John T. Scopes respectfully reports: That it has ascertained that the brief bulletin to the effect that the decision would uphold the in dictment was based upon informa tion which the seqder of the bulle tin believed /to be Truthful. “That the sender did not obtain. - this information from your honor’M stenographer, nor in any improper l and unethical matter.

See moreSee less

“We recommend that no good* ground exists for further investlga< tion and that the sender of the bulletin be not disturbed in his re lations with the court.” It was signed by Richard J. Beamish, chairman, Philadelphia Inquirer; Forrest Davis, New York Herald-Tribune; Earl L.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Judge Raulston read an 8,000-word decision overruling the defense's motion to quash and declaring Tennessee's anti-evolution law constitutional, citing precedents including the Oregon school case and Meyer v. Nebraska. The defense objected and entered a demurrer to preserve grounds for appeal, while the courtroom remained hot and crowded.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 2

reporter, an International News Service correspondent, to the stand and asked him whether he intended to “use strategem” upon the judge. When the reporter denied any in tended trickery, the judge dropped the matter. Judge Raulston then began to read his decision, overruling the defense quash motion, and holding the anti-evolution law Constitu tional. The defense immediately entered an objection, and the judge ‘as quickly overruled it. An exception was taken by . Frank McElwee, a new Scopes attorney, who an nounced the defense "intended to keep the record straight for an ap appeal.” At the same time, John R. Neal entered a demurrer for the defenseto the indictment on the same constitutional grounds carried jyy the motion to quash. '’®J»e cOwLjjverruled every ''onsti

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Judge Raulston overruled defense motions to quash the indictment, holding that the anti-evolution law did not violate the Fourteenth Amendment, religious freedom protections, or due process rights. The court also addressed a brief controversy over prayer, noting a Unitarian minister delivered the opening prayer at the judge's request.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 2

lution law did not violate the “constitutional right of due proc ess .of law.” His criminal rights, the judge added, were alee pro tected because he was being given a “speedy public trial by an im partial jury.” The court further held that Scopes was fully informed of his alleged offense and overrule* the motion on that ground. He also denied the defense’s contention that the indictment was irregular. Several minor points were similai ly overruled while the crowd swelt ered in the intense heat. Then there came the flurry of | motions from defense counsel and: the judge ordered a recess.

See moreSee less

A few I minutes later, he reconvened thei session only to adjourn until this | afternoon. A temporary truce was effected today when the opening prayer was delivered by Doctor Charles Francis Potter, a Unitarian minister and noted evolutionist from New York. | Doctor Potter was chosen for the ceremony by the Dayton pastors i' association at the request of JudgeJohn T. Raulston. The prayer, I however, was again objected to by Scopes’ even though the minister came 'here to be a de fense witness.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

During the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, scientists examined a trained chimpanzee named Joe Mendl brought by the defense, pronouncing him humanlike but limited to single-track thinking. The piece also notes the arrival of Doris Stevens (using her maiden name) and a humorous anecdote about Clarence Darrow being deflated by his wife after a courtroom speech.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

This dispatch offers human-interest tidbits from Dayton during the Scopes trial: a woman insisting on using her maiden name, a wife smoking in public, and banter between Darrow, Bryan, and Malone. It also notes visiting school officials attending and Bryan denying he wants to put 'God in the Constitution.'

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The report describes courtroom banter between Bryan and defense attorney Malone, and notes many visiting school officials attending the Scopes trial. Bryan is reported angrily denying published claims that he intends to put 'God in the Constitution,' saying he was misquoted.

The Washington Times · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.

Judge John T. Raulston rejected the defense's motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, ruling that the Tennessee evolution law was constitutional. He addressed each defense argument, including claims about discrepancies between the law's title and body, and rejected the argument that it violated religious freedom.

Americus Times-Recorder · 15 July 1925 · page 1

RAULSTON CITES AUTHORITY FOR HIS DECISION

DAYTON, July IS. Judge Jno. T. Raulston today denied the de fense motion to quash the indict ment against scopes. The Judge’s decision upheld the constitutionality of the Tennessee evolution law.

See the clipping

Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.

The report describes the intense crowds and heat at the Scopes trial courthouse on its fourth day, with spectators in a mix of overalls and fashionable clothing filling every available space. Applause and enthusiasm greeted points scored for fundamentalism despite the oppressive conditions.

Americus Times-Recorder · 15 July 1925 · page 1

CROWDS SWAMP APE COURTROOM ON FOURTH DAY

COURT HOUSE, DAYTON, lenn., July 15.—Every available inch of space was occupied during the spirited arguments that marked the fourth day of the trial of John Thomas Scopes for alleged violation of Tennessee’s antievolution teach ing act here. Although the visiting crowds ebbed and flowed in and out of the Court house and the shady grounds, swirling eddie spassfng the limits of the court housse lawn and col lecting in talkative groups about the streets, the collection as a whole failed to meet the too sanguine an ticipations of Dayton people.

See moreSee less

They come by hundreds, not thousands. Os those who either came early enough or were strong enough to push their way through the group that blocked the door way, there was sufficient to occupy every seat in the room, block the aisles and jam five deep around the walls. Overalls occupied seats beside the latest design in men’s wear, ginghams sank into the auditorium chairs beside the more fashionable silks. During the long hours that drag ged past between sessions of the court, the crowd discussed a wide variet yof subjects, with the trend always leading back to the Scopes case and evolution, or attorneys in the case, visiting newspaper men and evolution.

See the clipping

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

The report notes that William Jennings Bryan and his son William Jennings Bryan Jr. are both joining the prosecution in the Scopes trial, fighting to uphold Tennessee's anti-evolution law. A photo caption identifies the two family members involved in the case.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 15 July 1925 · page 1

LIKE FATHER, LIKE SON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

A photo caption identifies William Jennings Bryan and his son, William Jennings Bryan Jr., a Los Angeles lawyer, who came to Dayton to help prosecute John T. Scopes. The caption notes they are defending Tennessee's law against teaching evolution.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

Rev. Charles Francis Potter, a Unitarian minister from New York, delivered the opening prayer for that day's session of the Scopes trial. He was selected by the Dayton Pastors Association per Judge Raulston's request that a different local minister pray each day.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 15 July 1925 · page 1

VISITING NEW YORK MINISTER PRAYS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

Two Sunday School classes led by Mr. Palmer Greene and Col. Max Land went on a picnic to Blue Springs, where one activity was an entertaining debate about the famous 'Monkey Trial' in Dayton, Tennessee. The item is a brief local social note amid other community items.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 15 July 1925 · page 3

SUNDAY SCHOOL CLASS DEBATES SCOPES TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Judge John Raulston issued a 5,000-word decision overruling the defense motion to quash Scopes' indictment, ruling the Tennessee anti-evolution law constitutional under both state and federal constitutions. The defense's arguments on free worship, free speech, and legislative procedure were all rejected, forcing Scopes to plead further and proceed to trial.

The Indianapolis Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

RULING BIG VICTORY FOR STATE'S FORCES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Judge Raulston ruled against the defense's constitutional challenges to Tennessee's anti-evolution statute, stating the law did not restrict religious worship or violate teachers' rights since employment in public schools was contractual. He also cited precedent from Oregon and Nebraska Supreme Court cases to conclude the act did not violate the Fourteenth Amendment, while expressing anger at a news agency that had prematurely reported his decision.

The Indianapolis Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Judge Raulston dismissed the motion to quash, and defense counsel plans to push for an immediate fight over the admissibility of scientific evidence despite prosecution's wishes to delay it. The jury will finally be sworn in, Scopes will plead not guilty, and both sides anticipate a quick trial, possibly concluding by Saturday with closing arguments from Darrow and Bryan.

The Indianapolis Times · 15 July 1925 · page 9

LAW IS UPHELD

Scopes will plead not guilty. Half Day for Prosecution These formalities completed, the prosecution will put its witnesses on the stand. Attorney-General Stewart told the United Press today that it would take less than half a day to complete the prosecution’s case. The defense will then attempt to put a scientific witness on the stand and the battle over evidence, if not pre viously decided will be fought at this point. A defeat on this point by the de fense means, according to the prosecution, that the trial will be over Saturday. Clarence Darrow will swing into action with his clos ing argument and William J. Bryan whom the natives have waited vainly to hear so far, will sum up for the other side.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes William Jennings Bryan listening stoically at the Scopes trial, expected to speak on the admissibility of evolution evidence. It also analyzes how Scopes's conviction serves the defense's constitutional goals, while noting the political pressures on Judge Raulston and prosecutor Stewart to please their fundamentalist constituents.

The Indianapolis Times · 15 July 1925 · page 9

Dayton Awaits His Voice

Is overwhelmingly fundamentalist to the defense. The conviction of Scopes does not interfere with the purpose of the de fense to test the constitutionality of a law which they believe interferes with religious liberty and is a blow at freedom of thought. In fact the convinction of Scopes makes it easier to carry the constitutional question to the Federal Supreme Court than would his acquittal. What the people of this Tennessee judicial district think about science religion and Scopes makes not the slightest difference to the aims of the attorneys for the defense yet it makes a vital difference to the political fortunes of Judge Raulston and District Attorney General Stewart, for they most get the fun damentalist votes in this section to be elected to office.

See moreSee less

Both Are Human This doesn’t mean that either is a small fry politician. Both are men of ability. Stewart is a clean-cut young lawyer of promise and Raul ston a judge whose mind works quickly. But they can’t escape the human element in the case. The harder Stewart fights Scopes the better he will represent his funda mentalist constituents, and if Judge Raulston can honestly see the law as the opinions and prejudices of his constituents run he will gain in popularity. The strength of fundamentalism in and around Dayton is illustrated by some of the amazing court pro

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report argues that Scopes' conviction actually helps the defense's goal of reaching the Supreme Court more than an acquittal would have. It portrays Judge Raulston and D.A. Stewart as politically motivated by the strong fundamentalist sentiment in Dayton, illustrated by court prayers and procedural quirks.

The Indianapolis Times · 15 July 1925 · page 9

Is overwhelmingly fundamentalist to the defense. The conviction of Scopes does not interfere with the purpose of the de fense to test the constitutionality of a law which they believe interferes with religious liberty and is a blow at freedom of thought. In fact the convinction of Scopes makes it easier to carry the constitutional question to the Federal Supreme Court than would his acquittal. What the people of this Tennessee judicial district think about science religion and Scopes makes not the slightest difference to the aims of the attorneys for the defense yet it makes a vital difference to the political fortunes of Judge Raulston and District Attorney General Stewart, for they most get the fun damentalist votes in this section to be elected to office.

See moreSee less

Both Are Human This doesn’t mean that either is a small fry politician. Both are men of ability. Stewart is a clean-cut young lawyer of promise and Raul ston a judge whose mind works quickly. But they can’t escape the human element in the case. The harder Stewart fights Scopes the better he will represent his funda mentalist constituents, and if Judge Raulston can honestly see the law as the opinions and prejudices of his constituents run he will gain in popularity. The strength of fundamentalism in and around Dayton is illustrated by some of the amazing court pro cedure. Opening court with prayer in this case is not unusual, and as practically all of the preachers are fundamentalists, there was lit tle chance of getting any but a fun damentalist prayer. Lawyers Amazed Although Judge Raulston’s action if referring a motion to Invite other than fundamentalist preachers to pray to the local pastors association amazed lawyers for the defense. It didn’t amaze anybody locally even though all members of that associa tion are fundamentalists But it does throw light on the background of the trial locally and shows a solid fundamentalist background. However, these facts mean little

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

This dispatch describes daily scenes in Dayton, Tennessee during the Scopes trial, including Darrow's mail-reading sessions, political maneuvering against Judge Raulston, Bryan's irritation with reporters, and minor courtroom disruptions like an evangelist's song service. It captures the carnival-like atmosphere surrounding the trial.

South Bend News-Times · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Day by Day in Dayton

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A human-interest dispatch from Dayton describes William Jennings Bryan's irritation after Darrow's questioning, including his sharp retort to a reporter about Joshua. It also covers an evangelist being silenced by court police and describes Clarence Darrow's wife Ruby and her efforts to improve his appearance.

South Bend News-Times · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A prehistoric skull found near Tiberias, close to the Sea of Galilee, is presented by scientists as new evidence in the evolution debate coinciding with the Scopes trial. Researchers say its features resemble both Neanderthal and chimpanzee traits, suggesting an even earlier presence of primitive man in Palestine.

South Bend News-Times · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Prehistoric Skull Provides New Link in Evolution Quiz

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Westbrook Pegler offers a satirical report on Dayton, Tennessee's circus-like commercial activity during the Scopes trial, comparing the town's offerings to theatrical productions. He mentions failed entertainment acts alongside the popular rattlesnake exhibition, highlighting the carnival atmosphere surrounding the trial.

South Bend News-Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Judge Raulston deferred ruling on the defense's motion to quash the indictment, reacting angrily to leaked reports of his decision. Defense attorney Hays also petitioned for non-fundamentalist clergy to offer opening prayers, sparking a heated exchange with prosecutors.

South Bend News-Times · 15 July 1925 · page 1

JUDGE REFUSES TO DECIDE ON QUASH MOTION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

Defense counsel John R. Neal filed a motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, arguing the Tennessee anti-evolution law violates state and federal constitutions. This sparked an immediate clash with Circuit Attorney General A. Thomas Stewart.

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 1

ANTI-EVOLUTION LAW BRANDED UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN FIGHT FOR FREEDOM OF EDUCATION

tutions. The weapon of the defense was a motion to quash the indict ment against Scopes on constitutional grounds. It was made by John R. Neal, chief of defense counsel. A clash between state and defense attorneys immediately followed when Circuit Attorney General A. Thomas Stewart the jury out. moved that the jury be excluded.

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

Defense attorneys Neal and Hayes argued the Tennessee anti-evolution law violated four constitutional guarantees, including religious liberty and freedom of speech. They contended the law improperly mandated teaching a particular religious doctrine, transforming public schools into church establishments.

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Bitterness cropped into the ex change of arguments, but Judge John T. Raulston finally sent The defense based its fight chiefly on four constitutional points. These were that the anti-evolution law violated these state constitutional guarantees:

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

At the resumed Scopes trial, defense attorneys Neal and Arthur Garfield Hays argued the Butler Act was unconstitutional, claiming it established a particular religion's teachings in public schools and violated religious liberty guarantees. Judge Raulston asked both sides to prepare written briefs on the issue amid a tense courtroom atmosphere with armed guards present due to public passion over the case.

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Fight Constitutionality of Law. A wave of public passion, created a tense situation today as the Scopes anti-evolution trial was resumed. Armed sheriff’s guards and import ed uniformed police were scattered thru the courtroom as crowds as sembled for the second session. This element of passion spread to (Continued on page 2)

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

The prosecution broke a gentleman's agreement to focus on scientific testimony, forcing the defense to immediately argue that Tennessee's anti-evolution law was unconstitutional. The report also describes local religious tension, including a minister's resignation after being pressured not to let a Unitarian preach in his church.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Hold Anti-Evolution Law Unconstitutional

(Continue from Page 1) the ranks of prosecuting counsel who repudiated a “gentleman’s agreement" to devote today’s session to arguments over the admissibility of scientific testimony reconciling evolution with the biblical story of the divine crea tion of man. This change caused a postponement of a much advertised debate between Clarence Darrow, de fender of evolution, and William Jen nings Bryan, standard bearer for fun damentalism. The prosecution’s attitude forced de fense counsel to launch at once their fight against the constitutionality of the anti-evolution law. Their chief weapon was a motion to dismiss the indictment against Scopes on the ground that the law violates the con stitutional guarantees of religious liberty, freedom of thought, property rights and for the preservation of science.

See moreSee less

Throw Out Evolutionist. The smouldering fires of religious intolerance swept one modernist min ister from his pulpit here and resulted in another preaching his sabbath sermon in the presence of armed sheriffs’ deputies. The situation was such that Sheriff R. B. Harris announced himself “pre pared for trouble.” As a result of the sabbath out burst, Rev. H. G. Byrd, pastor of the methodist episcopal church north, re signed his post and started out today to hunt a new job. He quit when his congregation threatened to “break up his church” if he permitted Dr. Charles Francis Potter, Unitarian minister, to occupy his pulpit. Byrd, a lean fighting carpenter by profes sion, barred his church door to Potter and then locked it on himself. Byrd has a wife and three children. He said he would try to find work either as a carpenter or electrician. Altho barred from the church, Dr. Potter finally delivered his sermon from a platform on the courthouse grounds, where William Jennings Bryan had spoken earlier.

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

At the Scopes trial, defense attorney Clarence Darrow formally objected to opening court with a prayer, questioning Judge Raulston about the practice. Meanwhile, William Jennings Bryan faced criticism from a Catholic editor over church-state concerns and from a Unitarian minister over his biblical knowledge, while twelve scientists arrived to testify for the defense.

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Bryan Angers Catholic. Bryan faced two new controversies as a result of his sermons to Dayfon audiences. On one side he was attacked by Michael Williams, editor of The Com monwealth, a catholic publication for his alleged purpose to “put god into the constitution.” On the other he was criticised by Dr. Charles France Potter, Unitarian of New York, for his “lack of knowledge” of the school ing of Jesus. Bryan said: “The purpose of this trial is merely to prevent attacks on the Bible and the introduction of ir religion or forms of religion antagon istic to the religion of the taxpayers.” “If this,” said Williams, replying, “is not an open and avowed Intention to bring about a union between state and one particular form of re ligious belief (protestant fundamental ism), then there seems to be no sense in Mr.

See moreSee less

Bryan's words.” Bryan Doesn’t Know Bible, The attack on Bryan’s biblical knowledge on Jesus’ education came when Dr. Potter spoke from a plat from occupied earlier by Bryan for an afternoon sermon. “It is perfectly evident to me that he (Bryan) has been too busy doing other things to read his Bible,” Pot ter said.

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

The report describes the ongoing Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, focusing on William Jennings Bryan's anti-evolution crusade and its potential political repercussions for the Democratic Party. It notes incidents of local intolerance toward dissenters and quotes a columnist comparing the issue's future significance to the Klan and prohibition controversies.

The Daily Worker · 15 July 1925 · page 2

which last year made over soven mil lion dollars in profit. The miners are beginning to realize thru bitter experi ence that the profits of the coal bar ons are made out of the mangled bodies of the miners. A cave-in in an old working forced a pocket of gas into the shaft where the men worked and the explosion fol lowed. As the news of the explosion spread, a large crowd, composed of the wives, children, ahd friends of the miners gathered at the foot of the shaft. It is said at tjie hospital that the men will recover, Another “Incident.” A minor explosion occurred In the mine where I work.

See moreSee less

( The miner was burned about the facp and bands. Al tho the explosion took place Satur day, 1 did not learn about It till Tues day, as the company did Its beat to cover up tha news of the accident. years one of big leaders in the democratic party. The trial is being held in the heart of “the Solid South,” rock-ribbed democratic territory. Bryan has been for years a resident of Florida, with the South adopting him as a “native son,” altho an immigrant from Nebraska. There is no doubt that the South, with Dayton, Tenn., as an example, is adamant for Bryan's reiigioua fundamentalism. One preacher, who showed a little indication of dissent, has al ready been driven from his pulpit, another delivered his mes sage with shotgun protection, while a travelling free-thinker, who sought enjoyment of his constitutional right of free speech, was arrested by Dayton’s “law and order,” and then run out of town. * • • •

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report continues coverage of the Scopes trial, noting the court upheld the indictment against Scopes. It also describes ongoing friction over the practice of opening court with prayer, with defense counsel objecting to fundamentalist clergy being favored over non-fundamentalist ministers.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Indictment of Scopes Is Upheld

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A newspaper photo caption shows William Jennings Bryan receiving good news in the Dayton, Tennessee courtroom during the Scopes trial. Below him, defense attorneys Arthur Garfield Hays and Clarence Darrow are shown puzzling over the development.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Bryan Has ‘Em Puzzled Above: good news in the courtroom in Dayton, Tenn. SALE OF BOOZE RUNNING YACHT IS HELD TODAY Auction of ‘Asp‘ Take#

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Judge John T. Raulston ruled the Tennessee law banning the teaching of evolution to be constitutional, delivering a 5,000-word opinion overruling the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes. With Scopes having admitted to teaching evolution, the ruling effectively left only a formal verdict of guilty to be handed down by the jury, though the defense planned to appeal the constitutional question to a higher court.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

INDICTMENT OF SCOPES IS UPHELD / TRIAL QUICKLY GETS UNDER WAY

State. - i United Press) ; Dayton, Tenn., July 15.—To all in tents and purposes the trial of John T. Scopes for teaching evolution is over as far as the Rhea county court is concerned. Judge John T. Raulston, Who has the final word in the matter, has de c la red the law prohibiting the teach ing of evolution to be constitutions The defense admits that Scopes vis it remains, there ‘ lated this law. fore, for the jury to be instructed ■ to bring in a verdict of guil.

See moreSee less

■ The fight upon the constitsti ality of the law will be mate onf peal to a higher court. , t * It is probable, however, that mal arguments will be made, “roochssi livered, ratory dispensed and Mr sibly expert testimony taken HM: the trial comes to an actual cada ' 4 Dayton, Tenn., July 15.—The ! Scopes evolution trial moved fte i ward today when Presiding Judge i John T. Raulston overruled the de i fense motion to quash the iagte i ment of John Thomas Scopes. a “The court, having passe. : ground chronologically the reasons therefor, is norti ic to overrule the whole monion. require the defendant to plead then,” sail the judge. big victory for The decision was a use in uphold the prosecution because ----- ing the indictment the judge had to and did rule that the Tennesses anti-evolution law was thoroughly violating neither constitutional, 1 ’ Tennessee nor federal constitutions. The judge’s opinion was 5,000 words long and dealt exhaustively ‘-92 *‘e auu ucau E—**2**9*e‘. with every one of the defense’s at tacks on the evolution law’s const tutionality. 7 Before commencing to read the decision he required the courtroom to maintain perfect silence and on der. ’ = I The judge then successively over 1 ruled contentions of the defense that: unconstitutional ; the law was i cause the Legislature was require? i to cherish education, that it violateg ! the right of free worship, freedotsr ‘ speech. constitutional rules ef ! lative procedure, guarantees againe ' seizure of property without due MM ess of law. and all the other chemd ; by which the defense assailed N ' act on the basis of the Tennesnn constitution. • n J

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Judge Raulston ruled against the defense's constitutional challenges to Tennessee's anti-evolution law, rejecting arguments about religious freedom, due process, and legislative procedure. The report also describes rising bitterness between prosecution and defense counsel as the trial proceeds toward a dispute over admissibility of expert testimony.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

...82 11 a. m. 10 p. .. .....M 12 noon 11 p. m. .»( 12 midnight ...71 l p. m Wind velocity at 7 a. in, 2 miles pat hour. Stage of river, 12.5 feet, rise of .2 ft yet staged in the old courthi IOWM s’s when the anticipated dispute admissibility of expert testimony launched. iUUUtUVU. — *** 1 This was expected to follow th announcement by Judge Rauiston of | his decision on a hioticn by the' de i fense to quash the indictment the ! against John T.

See moreSee less

Scopes. No' one Scopes. | has believed from the outset thet the judge would do other than dip j miss the motion and call for the tries to proceed. ' 4 This trial. which started asi” friendly test case in a carnival* Ng mospncre, has reached the staxe, being as scrappy an affair as ay criminal case ever tried with ]|M sides contesting for every point l Tempers are torn an tattered. E ready counsel have indulged in ht ter words to each other, reaching, s peak late yesterday when Attorni General Stewart angrily shouted res Arthur Garfield Hays, one of the o fense counsel, to "keep your mout shut.” H The tactics of the defense ats’t • (Continued on Pace wo19. (Continued on Page Two)

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A color piece describes everyday scenes around the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, including local food complaints, dogs and babies in the courtroom, a chimpanzee paraded through town, and jurors listening to a bootlegged radio broadcast of proceedings. It also notes Mrs. Bryan and Mrs. Darrow seated on opposite sides of the courtroom.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 10

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

On the third day of the Scopes evolution trial, Judge Raulston warned reporters of possible contempt charges after stories leaked his likely ruling on the defense's motion to quash the indictment, before he had announced it. A committee of newspapermen was appointed to investigate the leak, while the jury remained unsworn and the motion undecided.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 1

JUDGE WARNS MAY IMPOSE CONTEMPT ON NEWS SERVICE IN EVOLUTION TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

During the Scopes trial, the defense moved to end courtroom prayers or allow non-fundamentalist clergy to lead them, sparking a heated exchange between defense and prosecution lawyers. Judge Raulston delayed his ruling on the quashing motion after learning reporters had allegedly leaked its contents, threatening contempt charges and appointing a press committee to investigate.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 3

JUDGE WARNS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Judge Raulston postpones reading his decision until the next morning after suspecting improper leaking of information about his opinion, threatening to deal with those responsible. The session also saw Clarence Darrow object to opening court with public prayer, arguing it could prejudice the jury, but Judge Raulston overruled the objection.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Judge Raulston overruled defense objections to opening court sessions with prayer, allowing Mr. Stribling to lead it, while noting Darrow's objection would be recorded as overruled daily. Attorneys expected a ruling on the motion to quash the indictment the next day, followed by jury selection and witness testimony from Scopes' former students.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A compilation of brief news items from July 14, 1925, including one noting that the judge in the Scopes evolution trial denied a defense motion to eliminate prayer from proceedings. Other unrelated items cover boxing succession, dirigible maneuvers, and various national news.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 5

NEWS BRIEFS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A satirical newspaper miscellany column references the Scopes trial with a mocking quip about 'young Mr. Scopes' saying 'Darn' in a YMCA, surrounded by unrelated humorous observations on golf, Prohibition, Coney Island crowds, and other topics. It also jokes that Tennessee-trained teachers won't be in demand elsewhere due to the anti-evolution law.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

An editorial criticizes William Jennings Bryan for insisting only the narrow legal question of whether Scopes violated Tennessee law matters, while refusing to let expert scientific testimony be heard. The writer suggests Bryan should welcome the chance to defend his literal six-day creation belief rather than avoid the issue, and mocks Tennessee's anti-evolution law as possibly a publicity stunt.

Ellsworth American · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Wiiiiam.l. Bryan may be legally right in insisting that the only Ques tion at issue in the Tennessee trial is whether Schtroimaster Scopes vio lated a law of the state in teachittg evolution, attd that expert scientific testimony should not be admitted. But if WilljatiiJ. sincerely believes tha' this old world of ours was made tn six days, and man in a small fraction of one day, he wottld com mand greater respect if lie met and welcomed the opportunity to put his belief to the test, instead of dodging the issue.

See moreSee less

His attitude is in signifi cant contrast to that of ihe eminent scientists wlio have rushed to the de fence. Benighted Tennessee, in its attempt to stifle the theory of evo lution under a silty law. has set the whole world a-howl with it. But perhaps, as has been suggested. Ten nessee and, incidentaliv. i\!r. Bryan, are merely looking for some free publicity. In that case, they have upset their own theory of the origin of man. and at the same time turned tiie cominoiily-uccepted idea of evoiu tion topsy-turvy, by making mon keys of all of us.

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This item describes sidelights from the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, including an anecdote about defense attorney Dudley Field Malone being pranked with a chimpanzee at his lodging. It also notes that despite advance preparations, the town's anticipated flood of visitors, crowds, and traffic congestion failed to materialize.

The Bismarck Tribune · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Judge John T. Raulston denied the defense motion to quash the indictment against John Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. The ruling followed a stormy session in which the judge threatened reporters with contempt for prematurely publishing his decision.

The Bismarck Tribune · 15 July 1925 · page 1

JUDGE DENIES DEFENSE PLEA TO END TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

On the trial's third day, Judge Raulston adjourned without ruling on the defense motion to quash the indictment, amid a dispute over leaked news reports predicting his decision. He appointed a committee of reporters to investigate the premature publications and promised a ruling the next day.

The Bismarck Tribune · 15 July 1925 · page 1

DELAYS HIS DECISION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.

A brief international news item reports that the Scopes evolution trial has resumed in session, opening with a prayer. It appears alongside other short world news items such as a miners' union strike threat and British-Russian tensions.

El Mundo · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.

The Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee resumed with an opening prayer despite the defense's protest. The defense argues this amounts to propaganda against the accused and has announced plans to formally protest.

El Mundo · 15 July 1925 · page 2

EL JUICIO DE SCOPES VUELVE A ABRIRSE CON UNA PLEGARIA

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.

United Press reports that the second day of the Scopes trial in Dayton was marked by heated argument between Bryan and Darrow. The two nearly came to blows disputing whether scientific evidence should be admitted.

El Mundo · 15 July 1925 · page 2

DARROW Y BRYAN DISPUTAN ACALORADAMENTE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

A small-town South Carolina newspaper's editorial column makes brief, opinionated remarks about the ongoing Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, including a jab at Darrow for objecting to opening the trial with prayer. The rest of the column covers unrelated local topics like cotton prices, gasoline spending, and education.

Edgefield Advertiser · 15 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

While relaxing at his Hood River ranch instead of joining Bryan at the Scopes trial, evangelist Billy Sunday denounced evolution as atheism and absurdity. He argued that species don't change, citing Burbank's plant breeding as mere development, not evolution.

Edgefield Advertiser · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Evolution Theory Branded As Bunk By Billy Sunday.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

The Rhea County grand jury returned a new indictment against John T. Scopes after questions arose about the legality of the original indictment, specifically whether 30 days had elapsed between the call for a special grand jury session and its meeting. A last-minute change in defense counsel was also indicated when attorney John L. Godsey failed to appear in court.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Appear Court Room, Dayton, Tenn., July j 10 (By the Associated Press).— The case of John T. Scopes, charg ed with violation o( the Tennessee law against the teaching of evolu tion in the public schools was placed in the hands of the Rhea county grand Jury for' the second time today. A new indictment was returned shortly when court convened for the trial of the twenty-four-year old school teacher. Attorney Gen eral A. T. Stewart asked that the grand jury be, summoned. Judge Raulston informed the grand jury men that some question had aris en as to the legality of the indict ment against Scopes and the case would be given grand jury consid eration again.

See moreSee less

The point at issue was the contention that thirty days had not elapsed after the call for the special session of the grand jury and the meeting of the body. Court recessed one hour while the grand jury reconsidered the case. A last minute change in counsel for the defense was indicated by the failure of John L. Godsey, Dayton attorney, to appear in court with the other lawyers af ter his absence from a conference of defense attorneys last night had been regarded as significant. While Godsey told the Associated Press he had no statement to make at this time, he said he would not ap pear in court wdth other defense counsel. Dayton, Tenn., July 10 (By the Associated PressK—Attorneys for John Thomas Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee law against the teaching of evolution made their position plain, favoring the introduction of scientific testi mony after their client was placed on trial here ■ today. State’s at torneys were prompt to meet the announcement of the defense in tentions with an announcement of a contrary position. , Clarence Darrow of the defense soon after a second indictment had been re turned to place the first technical imperfect document, stated to the court that he and his associates re garded as competent scientific tes timony that the theory of evolution

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

On the opening days of the Scopes trial, defense attorneys led by Clarence Darrow announced they would seek to introduce scientific testimony reconciling evolution with the Bible, which the state immediately opposed as incompetent. A jury of twelve was selected amid a grand jury technicality dispute, and the court adjourned for the weekend with Bryan set to teach Sunday school.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 1

POSITIONS MADE AT START

Dayton, Tenn., July 10 (By the Associated PressK—Attorneys for John Thomas Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee law against the teaching of evolution made their position plain, favoring the introduction of scientific testi mony after their client was placed on trial here ■ today. State’s at torneys were prompt to meet the announcement of the defense in tentions with an announcement of a contrary position. , Clarence Darrow of the defense soon after a second indictment had been re turned to place the first technical imperfect document, stated to the court that he and his associates re garded as competent scientific tes timony that the theory of evolution

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

The twelve-man jury, mostly farmers and church members, was selected after extensive questioning, while defense attorneys planned to introduce scientific and religious expert testimony to show evolution doesn't conflict with the Bible. Prosecutor A.T. Stewart countered that the only relevant issue is whether Scopes taught evolution, making such expert testimony irrelevant.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 1

TESTIMONY OF EXPERTS IS NOT NEEDED - Stewart Issues Statement In Regard to Case - OUTLINES ISSUES - Only Point to Be Settled Is Whether Scopes Taught Evolution

Associated Press tonight. Mr. Stewart Issued the statement as a clarification of his views and supporting his contention that the introduction of expert testimony in an effort to show there is no con flict between evolution and the Bi ble would be irrelevant. The statement follows: ‘•Since the state has made known its position concerning the competency of the proposed evi dence of scientists tending to show that there is no conflict between evolution and the Bible, I think it but right that our position should be definitely stated and that it might be understood that wre in tend to back our position as vigor ously as we know how.

See moreSee less

“The proposed evidence of the scientists would tend to show that there is no conflict between the Bible and science because they claim that the evolutionary process was simply the method by which God created man. It IS my unaersianumg ui<u an. Scopes will not deny that he taught to the students in the high schools of Rhea county that man descend ed from a lower order of animals. “If this be true, he is guilty of the violation of the law and the evidence of scientists within his reach can not save him. The law, itself, says that it shall not be taught to the students in the public schools, that men descended from a lower order of animals. “That is the issue and only issue in this case; whether Scopes taught this or did not teach it. Scientists might claim that man descended from a lower order of animals by the process of God’s creation, but this can make no dif ference. The law says such can not be taught. “If such evidence should be gone Into by both sides, that is if the defense should undertake to show that there is no conflict between the Bible and evolution by expert witnesses, and state likewise show by expert witnesses that there is conflict, it would become a never ending proposition and would in the end be but a babel of tongues "Such evidence is incompetent and our stand in the matter is a definite and determined one.”

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

A South Carolina newspaper editorial argues the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee will settle nothing, since believers in six-day creation and evolution will remain unconvinced regardless of the verdict. It criticizes Bryan, Darrow, and Malone as publicity seekers, and suggests Scopes should simply plead guilty since his technical violation of the law is undisputed.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

Rev. Howard Gale Byrd withdrew from his Dayton Methodist Episcopal church after congregants protested his invitation to modernist minister Charles Francis Potter to preach on evolution. Byrd, who had originally inspired the charges against John Scopes, cancelled Sunday services amid the furor coinciding with the Scopes evolution trial.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 4

CHURCH MEMBERS AGAINST MODERNISM

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

Dr. Charles H. Mayo, returning from a European medical conference, praised European medical research and called for a U.S. Minister of Education. Asked about the upcoming Scopes trial, he called it unfortunate but potentially beneficial in awakening public interest in evolution and the study of life sciences.

The Watchman and Southron · 15 July 1925 · page 3

PRAISES MEDICAL SCIENTISTS ABROAD

St&r liner Olympic with several other American doctors and sur geons from Europe, where they w4ot to attend a conferrence of t|& Interstate Medical Associa tion and visit the principal clinics. "The war has resulted in the Mtablishment of great hospitals abroad.” Dr. Mayo said. The medical men of Europe are ahead o& us in scientific research be cause of their methods, although Jl cannot l>e said that we are at all backward over here, s? “What Is needed in the United States is a Minister of Education, •och as every progressive Euro pean country has, who can super vise and coordinate all branches Of education.

See moreSee less

We also need more abcentratlon of eifort in the study of* medical science.” T Asked for his opinion on the Coming Scopes trial at Dayton, <!*nn., Mayo said: "It is an unfortunate thing and

See the clipping

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Judge John T. Raulston denied the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He addressed each defense contention in a lengthy written ruling, after which Scopes was required to plead further.

Brownsville Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Judge Overrules Move Of Defense to Quash Evolution Indictment

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Judge Raulston rejects defense arguments that the anti-evolution law violates religious liberty, teachers' rights, or the Fourteenth Amendment, ruling the statute is constitutional and the indictment sufficiently clear. He cites precedent including Meyer v. Nebraska to support upholding the law.

Brownsville Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

An opinion piece frames the Scopes trial as a contest between fundamentalists and modernists over whether man descended from lower forms or was literally created from dust. It questions whether a courtroom verdict can truly settle scientific or theological truth, suggesting both sides might be partly right.

Brownsville Herald · 15 July 1925 · page 4

they will finish. It looked at first as though the big question would be, Is the anti-evolution law of Tennessee constitutional or unconstitutional? It now appears that the whole question of whether the scien tists are right in saying that man has evolved'from lower forms, or whether the literal interpretation of Genesis is true, will be decided. In short, it will be solemnly determined whether man sprung from monkeys or mud. There might be some basis for the contention that Tennessee taxpayers have a right to say what the public schools shall teach— a legal if not a moral right, perhaps.

See moreSee less

But can a judge and jury and a fine array of legal talent settle the question of nature’s processes? There will be a decision, of course, and probably an appeal, should Professor Scopes be found guilty, but can anv decision that goes beyond the mere settlement of the constitutionality of the new law settle anything? If evolution is a fact in nature, it will continue to be a fact, even if judge and jury and all the courts go against it. And if God fashioned man out of the dust and breathed the breath of life into him—literally—as Genesis records it, all scientific deduc tion cannot prevail against it. It might develop, as time goes on, that both are partly right and partly wrong. Married Men’s Minds I ■■ " —' ” — — ' 1 ' ' - THE married man has been having so much the best of it in public esteem in these latter years that perhaps the single man deserves an inning. He gets it, in a statement from a Chi cago taxicab owner. “When we first hired men,” he says, “we always insisted on married men, preferably those with children, believing that they would be more careful and conservative. We have found, how ever. that single men are generally more satisfactory, and have concluded that married men, with more on their minds, are less likely to give undivided attention to the work.” Married men, indeed, usually have “more on their minds." But who would have thought that the supposedly erratic and irre sponsible young bachelors would make more trustworthy automo bile drivers than the heads of families? If this is true of driving, it may be true of many less exciting and exacting occupations. Father had better get his mind on the job. s. Henry Ford bids on 200 scrap metal ships. And it won't be long now until lots of us will be riding in Henry’s boats.—Dallas News.

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

Judge John T. Raulston overruled the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, ruling the Tennessee anti-evolution law constitutional. Scopes pleaded not guilty, and the judge's 5,000-word opinion addressed each constitutional objection raised by the defense.

The Seattle Star · 15 July 1925 · page 1

Scopes Loses ~ First Battle Judge Overrulgé Defense Motion to ‘ Quash Evolution Case | BULLETIN | ~ COURTROOM, Dayton, Tenn., | ? July Ib.~John T. Scopes, 24, | ber of the legislature on notice as {o what the nature of the proposed legisiation is and that really the cap

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

Judge Raulston overruled defense arguments that the Butler Act violated the Tennessee and U.S. constitutions on multiple grounds, including free speech, religious freedom, and due process. He cited the Oregon school law case and Nebraska anti-evolution decision to support the act's constitutionality under the 14th Amendment.

The Seattle Star · 15 July 1925 · page 1

OREGON SCHOOL. LAW IS CITED While Raulston read his decision in the steaming court room a police. man stood over him, fanning his head. Raulston himself mopped his face steadily. Of the validity of the act under the federal constitution, Raulston, after citing the Oregon schoolslaw and the Nebraska anti-evolution teaching law decision by the United States supreme court, said: “The rule prevailing in Tennessee by which the courts are governed in passing upon the constitutionality of statutes is that every doubt must be solved s 0 as to sustain it; and where it is subject to two construc tions, that which will sustain its constitutionality must be adopted.

See moreSee less

Under the holdings in the Oregon case and in the Nebraska case and in the Leeper, Tenn., case the court is satisfied that the act involved in the case at bar does not violate the s4th amendment to the constitutibn of the United States, and is therefore pleased to overrule this ground.”

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

A New York man named Peter Mangin got into an argument with his wife about the Scopes evolution case and leaped onto a chandelier, swinging monkey-fashion until he tore it from the ceiling. His wife called police, and he was taken to a hospital.

The Seattle Star · 15 July 1925 · page 5

EVOLUTION DEBATE CAUSES SPOUSE TO PROVE HE'S "MONK"

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

The report notes a coincidence that a direct descendant of Charles Darwin, whose theory is at the center of the controversy, resides in Dayton, Tennessee. This is the town where John Scopes is on trial for violating the state's anti-evolution law.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 1

KIN OF ORIGINAL DARWIN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A reporter describes the carnival-like atmosphere in Dayton during the Scopes trial, including poor local food, dogs and babies in the courtroom, and a chimpanzee paraded through town. It also notes the presence of Mrs. Bryan and Mrs. Darrow in the courtroom and includes a brief Danish press reaction calling the trial disgraceful.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 1

RARE SOUTHERN COOKING NOT SO GOOD IN DAYTON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

On the trial's third day, Clarence Darrow objected to the court opening with prayer, calling it propaganda favoring the prosecution in the science-versus-religion dispute. Judge Raulston overruled the objection, allowing prayer to continue, then recessed to prepare his ruling on the defense's motion to quash the indictment.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 1

'PROPAGANDA' APPEAL FAILS TO WIN COURT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Darrow objected to opening each trial day with prayer, arguing it increased hostility, but Judge Raulston ruled the matter was his discretion and continued the practice. The report also covers arguments on the motion to quash the indictment, with Raulston delaying his ruling due to lack of light to read law books the night before.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 11

DARROW LOSES FIGHT TO STOP COURT PRAYERS

Speech Wins Friends. The purpose for which Darrow came here actually has been ful ^filled. He has sounded what he re gards as a necessary alarm to the American people to rise against “bigotry and intolerance,” and if the Scopes trial ended forthwith he would be content. Judge John Raulston now* will rule on the defense motion to quash the Scopes indictment. Scopes will plead not guilty and the jury will be sworn. There was little doubt that Judge Raulston would overrule the dismissal motion and that the case would immediately proceed to opening statements by both prosecu tion and defense and from that to the fight over admissability of evi dence.

See moreSee less

The defence was enormously heartened by Darrow’s dramatic ex coriation of the fundamentalists. Not once w’as he interrupted by op posing counsel. When Darrow concluded he stepped down from the platform and was met by Mrs. Darrow. “Clarence,” she said, “don’t you think you’d better put on another shirt ” His elbow was out at a tear in a sleeve. “Well, Ruby,” smiled Darrow” “don’t you think its too hot today for two shirts?”

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

After Darrow delivers a powerful speech excoriating fundamentalists, he receives praise from spectators and even opposing counsel General Ben McKenzie, though some onlookers call him an infidel. Bryan, later asked by a reporter if he believes Joshua made the sun stand still, angrily snaps that he's tired of being insulted.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 11

Lauded By Opponents. Along his walk from the court house to the hotel he was stopped by natives who had never met him but who heard him in the court room a few minutes before. They all said the same thing: “A wonderful speech.” Among those W’ho , congratulated Parrow was old general Ben McKenzie, one of the opposing attor neys in the case. He got out of his Ford, came over to the sidewalk, threw his arms around Darrow and iu a voice almost choked with emo tion, said: ^Jt was the greatest speech I ever heard in all my life on any subject.” Darrow patted the general on his back and said: “It’s mighty kind of you to say that.” Another native stopped Darrow, shook his hand, and said: “Mr.

See moreSee less

Darrow, if I could have heard you before I would never have spoken of you as I have in the past.” “That’s all right, that’s all right,” answered Darrow. But two women, leaving the courtroom, looked at each other in horror. “The damned infidel,” exclaimed one. “Insults By Asses.” Just before adjournment the de fense filed a demurrer to the indict ment based on identical grounds with the motion to quash. Another dramatic moment oc curred after the adjournment of the court when Darrow and Bryan shook hanch and sat together at the prosecution table for the photog raphers. As Bryan was leaving the court room a New York newspaper re porter stopped him and asked if he believed Joshua made the sun stand still. Bryan turned red and replied an grily : “I’m getting tired of being in sulted by asses. Don’t do it again I!! I! I”

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Frank J. Weber, a Milwaukee labor official, claims William Jennings Bryan is using his involvement in the Scopes trial as a political platform to seek the 1928 Democratic presidential nomination. Weber characterizes the trial as a politically motivated spectacle designed to keep voters in ignorance and under Democratic influence.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Defense attorney Clarence Darrow complained that opening court sessions with prayer amounted to religious propaganda favoring the prosecution. Judge Raulston agreed to eliminate the prayer practice for future sessions of the Scopes trial.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 7

Prayer Barred At Darrow Hint Of Propaganda

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Clarence Darrow delivered a fiery speech arguing that Tennessee's anti-evolution law represented a return to the Dark Ages and bigotry, as part of the defense's motion to quash the indictment against Scopes. Judge Raulston appeared impressed by the arguments and took the motion under advisement.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 3

Bigotry! Is War Cry of Darrow SEES RETURN OF DARK AGES IN TENNESSEE

Court Is Impressed. Darrow’s speech was the climax of a day of oratory delivered for and against the ostensibly simple motion of the defense to quash the indictment pending against Scopes. And that his arguments impressed the court seemed evident from the

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Clarence Darrow argues before the court that the anti-evolution statute is unconstitutional, comparing it to medieval bigotry against learning. He contends the bill's caption misled the public, as the actual law bans teaching any theory of man's origin except the biblical account, and argues the Bible is a religious text, not a scientific one.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 3

“Here we find today as brazen and bold an attempt to destroy learning as was ever made in the middle ages, and the onlj’ difference is that we have not provided that they shall be burned at the stake; but there is time for that,' your honor; we have to approach these things graduallys. “I am going to begin with some of the simpler reasons why it is ab solutely absurd to think that this statute, indictment or any part of the proceedings in this case are le gal, and I think the sooner we get rid of it in Tennessee, the better for Tennessee and the better for the pursuit of knowledge in the world.” Beginning first with the caption of the bill, Darrow declared that, while the caption described the act as one which would prohibit the teaching of evolution in schools of the state, the bill itself contained nothing relating to the teaching of evolution.

See moreSee less

He continued;

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

Clarence Darrow delivers courtroom argument claiming the Butler Act is void because it violates constitutional protections for science, learning, and freedom of worship. He contends the law is vague since it bans teaching theories conflicting with the Bible without specifying which biblical interpretation applies.

The Milwaukee Leader · 15 July 1925 · page 3

“The bible is a book of religion, however, and not one of science or geology or astronomy. If the law prohibiting the teaching of evolution should be held constitutional it will be necessary to designate some per son who will say just what the Biblical account of the creation of man is. “There are many different inter pretations, and the law simply pro hibits the teaching of any theory of the origin of man that conflicts with the Bible and does not name any theory that may be taught. “Why not say that you must teach that man was made of the dust, and, still stranger, not direct ly from the dust, without taking any chances on it.

See moreSee less

“My client would have to know all about the Bible and the differ ent theories of evolution before he could know just what the law pro hibited.” Darrow pointed to the passage of the statute as the first step toward a series of oppressive laws against freedom which he depicted. He went on: “No law can be passed under the police powers of a state that dis tinguishes between the different citizens, or classes of citizens in

See the clipping

Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis.

Judge John J. Gore of the U.S. District Court refused to grant an injunction sought by Scopes's defense team to stop the Dayton trial, ruling he lacked jurisdiction over state court proceedings. The defense, including Clarence Darrow and Bainbridge Colby, plans to pursue further federal action before Judge Xenophon Hicks in Nashville.

Vilas County News · 15 July 1925 · page 2

SCOPES LOSES IN FEDERAL COURT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis.

A federal judge denied the defense's petition to intervene in the Scopes case, citing lack of jurisdiction over state courts. The defense continues pursuing an injunction through Tennessee courts while also awaiting a ruling on a motion to quash the indictment in Dayton.

Vilas County News · 15 July 1925 · page 2

FEDERAL COURT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

A columnist argues the Scopes trial is less about the defendant than a clash between modernists and fundamentalists, and criticizes the jury as poorly educated and ill-suited to weigh scientific evidence. The writer predicts the trial will yield only 'bigotry' and notes Bryan's hope for a constitutional ban on teaching evolution.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 15 July 1925 · page 1

TETERING ALONG The evolution trial at Dayton, Ten nessee, is attracting more attention than any other trial in recent years. The question involved is a highly con troversial one, und has religion for a basis. Scopes, the school teacher upon whose action the trial centers, is noth ing but a figure-head. The real issue Is lietween the modernists and the fundamentalists—those who lieieve in the advancement of thought in religi ous matters and those who hold to the f teachings of our ancestors. Although we read every word print ed about the Dayton trial and are greatly interetsed in its development, yet just what do wo exj>ect to come from litis tiial.

See moreSee less

What can we expect? The evolution biil was introduced in the Tennessee Legislature by a man who had little or no “sehooing.” The trial is being held in a commu nity in which educational advantages of the higher or cultural type are cou sipcuously absent. One man on the jury selected to try Scopes can neither read nor write, and not one of the remaining eleven lias ever read a scientific hook. Twelve good ni(‘ii and true, no doubt, lmt a line jury to hear evidence uml finally decided ii|mn the great principles in volved in the Dayton trial! AVhat can come from the Dayton trial? Nothing that we can see hut bigotry and a furtherance of an up pcnl to ignorance. William Jennings Bryan believes that the outcome of the Dayton trial will he a constitutional amendment prohibiting the teaching of the theory of evolution in the public schools of the I'nitcd States. Another pucker ing string around the neck of un al ready restless public. In justice to Mr. l’.ryan his sincer ity must he recognized. He believes iie is doing light. Hut so did the monks of the middle ages when they invented the horrible tortures for those who held contrary religious be liefs. And so did those staid old New Englanders, not so many years ago, when they burned witches at the stake. They, too, were sincere; they, too. were imbued with the same idea of intolerant sincerity which sways Mr. Bryan and those otlters who would prohibit the children of this country from free study, free thought and a Chance to form their own opinions from Ihoir own deductions. The people of this country should al ways bo in a position to hold what ever icligious beliefs they please and worship God in their own way. Th.t children of Americans should have the opportunity of the same freedom of thought and religion. And anything vafetch -interfereo’ with Ibis 'ee d::;*' is contrary to the principles which make this country great, and is a step baek wnid In our so far remarkable pro gress in civilization. Jtegardlcss if bow the Dayton trial may end, regardless ams, the fundamentalists, the rnWernists, and so forth, let us, us Ami iriau citiz ens, see to it for our children’s sake, that, our schools are kept tree from bigotry and intolerance.

See the clipping

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

An editorial criticizes the jury selected for the Scopes trial as unqualified, noting the foreman cannot read or write and none have read a scientific book. It also criticizes William Jennings Bryan's anti-evolution stance, comparing his sincerity to historical religious intolerance, and argues schools should remain free from bigotry.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 15 July 1925 · page 1

TETERING ALONG

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

Judge John T. Raulston denied the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. His written ruling addressed each defense contention, finding the law's title sufficiently broad to cover its provisions.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 15 July 1925 · page 1

- I ml KT ROOM. DAYTON, Twin,. .Inly 13— (/Pi— .lulls** .1 <>11n T. ltauls tcin today deneid tin* defense motion lo <|imsli tho indictment against .John IT. Scopes. The Judge's decision tip held I he colistil 111 ioinilily of tile Ten nessee anti-evolution law. , The motion to quash was made on Monday ami the day was spent in nr liniment. .indite Itimlston was occu-1 pied all of yesterday in writing his decision wldeh was voluminous. It took up each contention of the defense and ruled that llit* defendant would lie required to plead furtiier.

See moreSee less

llefore reading iiis decision Judge Itaulsten consented to ihisc for photo- , grnphers with tlie division in his lmnd. | After tlie judge read the grounds on wliielv the defense sought to quash • tin* motion lie discussed the authorities cited. Discussing the alleged discrepancy

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A light anecdote circulates about defense attorney Dudley Field Malone being startled by a publicity ape placed in his chair at his lodgings. The report also notes Dayton's anticipated crowds and business have failed to materialize despite trial-related hype and novelty songs.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

SNAPSHOTS AT SCOPES APE TRIAL

APE TRIAL DAYTON. Tenn., July 15.—(As sociated Preet.)—The story was told in Dayton today of how Dudley Field Malone was gped by an ape. One of the animals brought tp Dayton by publicity seekers was carried to "the mansion” last night for a visit with the proposed scientific witnesses for the defense who are making the public house their headquarters here the story said: Interested with the animal the scientists were said to have placed it in Malone's chair at the table around which they were grouped. While they were discussing the ape and subjecting it to various tests.

See moreSee less

Melons entered the room. The conclusion of the story was that Malone, disliking the farce called an automobile, bundled the ape and his master into it and sent them back to town. Dayton prepared for a flood and received a shower. The anticipated crowds have failed to materialize. Although hundreds nf people have visited the town within the past five days, since the beginning of the trial, the numbers have fallen far beneath the sanguine expecta tions of Daytonlans. Amplifiers arranged at various places about town, have had scarcely more than a handful of listeners since the beginning of the trial. ’ Concession stands, which pre pared for .heavy business during the trial, are finding few cus tomers. Few times have there been more automobiles on the streets than could move freely. Among the host of publicity seekers ore enthusiastic song writers, who have turned their genius to the construction of what they hope will be popular ballads, each with the evolution trlnl ns the predominant therpe, and, the majority' with some breed, of a "monkey” title.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Judge John T. Raulston denied the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. His lengthy written decision addressed each defense contention, including arguments about discrepancies between the act's caption and body.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

QUASH MOTION OF DEFENSE IS DENIED TODAY IN COURT ROOM

The Associated Press.) Judge John T. Raulston to day denied tlie defense’s mo tion to quash the indictment, against John T. Scopes. The Judge's decision upheld the constitutionality of t,h e Tennessee antl-evolutlon law.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The judge addresses arguments that the Butler Act violates constitutional rights to religious freedom and due process, ruling that the law does not interfere with worship or compel employment in public schools. He finds the law's caption properly covers its legislative content and does not restrain religious conscience.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 1

These relations, he said, are pure ly contractural, ''and in his con science tr • i.e hint to '• c-h ■ e evolution theory, he can find oppor tunity elaewliere in other schools of the state • • • and give full ex pression to hia beliefs and convic tions upon this and other subjects without any Interference from the State of Tennesree or Its authorities. ".Neither do I sen licw the act lays any restraint on hJa right to worship according to ths dictates of his conscience. Under tho provis ions of this belief which most opTh* statutes he also held does ((Continued on l‘ig* Eight)

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A reporter describes the twelve jurors in the Scopes trial as honest, God-fearing Nordic types similar to rural New England farmers, including one illiterate but respected juror named Jim Riley. He suggests the jury, while perhaps unlikely to acquit, will render an honest and open-minded verdict on the evolution question.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 5

CONSCIENTIOUS JURY VERDICT IN SCOPES TRIAL ASSURED BY TYPE OF CITIZENSHIP SELECTED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The report describes the jury selected for the Scopes trial as honest but largely ignorant of evolutionary theory, a fact Darrow deliberately secured. It outlines the defense's argument that evolution is compatible with the Bible, contrasting this with Bryan's framing of evolution as an attack on scripture.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 5

By ROBERT T. SMALL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Judge Raulston read his ruling denying the defense's motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, ruling that the Tennessee evolution statute did not unlawfully deprive him of his rights. The report also notes courtroom details including a prayer controversy, with Rev. Charles Francis Potter opening the day's session despite defense objections to religious atmosphere in court.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 8

EVOLUTION STATUTE UPHELD BY COURT IN DECISION READ TODAY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Judge Raulston addressed defense objections to daily opening prayers by agreeing to have the Dayton Pastors' Association nominate ministers without denominational bias. Minor courtroom tensions also arose over a reporter's premature publication of a ruling and an exchange of apologies between attorneys over discourteous remarks.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 8

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Reporter finds evangelist Billy Sunday napping at his Oregon ranch, where he jokingly offers a mock 'evolutionist's prayer' to a cocoanut tree deity. Sunday declines to join Bryan at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, but argues evolution is false and equates teaching it with atheism, a 'public enemy.'

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1925 · page 10

Evolutionist Version Of Lord's Prayer Given By Billy Sunday

Os Lord’s Prayer L m M I McN IM m: \ I (Copyright 1925 The Consolidated Press Association) PARKDALE. Orc.. July 15.—" The only rational prujer an evolutionist can offer is: 'Our Father, who art i up In a cocoanut tree, hallowed La i Thy name!"* Far from tho crowded court rout.l tn Dayton, Tenn., enjoying the ?00l and quiet of his ranch in the lined River upper valley. Billy Sunday awoke suddenly from a peaceful mid day nap and diih e’ed thy above declaration. The writer surprised the evange list atretched out on the floor of his airy bungalow.

See moreSee less

Billy had dropped off into a snooze while "Ma*' Sun day, comfortably attired In u SI.OO gingham gown (she said so herself, read aloud to him. The Rev. Mr Sunday had been urged to assist his fellow evangelist, Bryan. In the Scopes trial, but the lure of snow-capped mountains and h s quiet ranch proved too great. He came vest instead, but like an old cavalry horse responding to gun powder, he leaped from the floor with a typical Sunday spring when he heard the word "evolution." lie turned his back for a moment and • dug his fists into his eyes like a I small boy aroused from slumber. • then shot out: •'lf man Is evolved from a monkey, then why are there any mdnke.'s now? You can t answer that to eave your life.’’ As nobody attempted to answer It, Billy grew less vehement and passed glasses of cold spring water. Then he continued more mildly: "There Is no case on record where the species ever changed. Burbank develops plant life, but he can not change It. That’s not evolution: It’s development. Bo with life. Seed turns to corn, but that is growth, not evolution. "To teach evolution Is atheism because ft denies the existence of God. Atheism Is a public enemy. It destroys society and erects the in dividual. If one man has a right to break some law. then all rpen have a right to break some law. Evolu tion is bent on ejecting God from the universe. If It evoluted. God did not create it. If God created it, It did not evolute. When you say cre ation. you deny evolution. Why, the Mea Is too. silly to talk about. Let’s go out and look at tho swim ming pool.” So we went out among the tower ing firs and pines nnd looked at case, ns It were.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

On July 14-15 in Dayton, Tennessee, the Scopes trial proceeded with oratory over a motion to quash the indictment, as Darrow called the anti-evolution law wicked and objected to opening court with prayer. Judge Raulston overruled the objection, and Governor Peay praised Attorney General Stewart's handling of the prosecution.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Tennessee Evolvtion Trial Now UnderWay DAYTON, Tenn., July 14.—In a day devoted entirely to oratory, the jury having been excused yesterday as soon as arguments on the mo tion to quash the indictment againdt John T. Scopes began. Clarence Darrow, after thanking the court for the title ‘'colonel,” which had been bestowed upon him. declared the anti-evolution law was ‘‘wick ed and mischievous.” Although he took no formal action, Darrow en tered a protest with the judge against the custom of opening the trial with prayer. As court was about to open to day, Darrow filed a formal objection to’ opening court with prayer in the presence of the jury.

See moreSee less

Darrow said: “I do not object to anyone praying in private, but I do object to this court being turn ed into a meeting house.” Judge Raulston responded: "1 don't want to be unreasonable abou' anything, but I am responsible for the conduct of this court. I over rule this objection.” Dudley Field Malone also offered an objection to the prayer saying “I wish to offer an objection as r member of defense council who i' not antagonistic. We have talked this thing over in our chamber and believe the opening of cour' with prayers offered by ministers sc far have been largely arguments tive. We hold that this practict creates a religious atmosphere harm ful to our cause.” Attorney General Stewart said “This is a God-fearing country and we are accustomed to prayer around here. It is the usual thing in this part of the country." DAYTON. July 15.—Commendation from Governor Peay over the man ner in which Attorney Genera’ Stewart is handling the prosecutior of Scope came today in this tele gram. “It is a poor cause that runs from prayer. You are handling this case like a veteran, and I am proud of vou. Regards to Mr. Bryan. "Peay." DAYTON. July 15.—Judge Raul ston this afternoon denied the mo tion of defense counsel to quash the indictment against Scopes, there bv upholding the constitutionality of the Tennessee Anti-Evolution law.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Defense attorney Dudley Field Malone objects to opening court with prayer, arguing it creates a harmful religious atmosphere, while the Attorney General defends the practice. Judge Raulston denies the motion to quash the indictment, the state rests after student testimony on Scopes teaching evolution, and the state moves to exclude scientist testimony.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1

STUDENTS GIVE TESTIMONY DAYTON. Tenn.. July 15.—Th State rested its case against Scope this afternoon after »he testimony of ofur witnesses had been heard. Former pupils of Scopes in the Rher County High School presented testi mony to the effect that Scopes had taught them a theory of evolution as expounded in an official text book They state that he admitted he could not teach this book with out violating the anti-evolution teaching statute. DAYTON. July 16.—The State of Tennessee made a formal motion at the trial of Scopes today to exclude the testimony of scientists from the case at trial. --d*-—

See the clipping

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

At the Dayton trial, prosecution and defense argued over whether scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with Bryan contending only the fact of violation mattered and Darrow insisting evolution must be explained to the jury. Dr. Maynard Metcalf's testimony was taken with the jury excluded pending the ruling.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 16 July 1925 · page 1

TESTIMONY ON SCIENCE BEING

Fight on Testimony. Dr. Metcalf resumed the stand at the opening of court this fore noon, after the State made a strenu ous effort to exclude scientific testi mony as having no bearing on the case. Clarence Darrow stated the de fense expected to show what evolu tion is, as the jury cannot decide the case intelligently unless sonu idea is shown as to what it is. Dr. Metcalf was withdrawn tem porarily as a witness and the jury was excluded pending arguments over procedure. William Jennings Bryan, arguinj for the prosecution, said.

See moreSee less

"Tlie only issue this jury must decide is whether Scopes violated the law. To permit testimony of experts would lie to substitute a trial of experts fora trial by jury." The afternoon session opened with Bryan pleading against admit ting scientific testimony on the grounds that it was irrevalont to the Issue which was whether Scopes did something prohibited by law.

See the clipping

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

Dr. Metcalf testified for the defense, which hoped to show no conflict between evolution and Christianity, while the state tried to exclude scientific testimony as irrelevant. Darrow argued the jury needed to understand evolution, while Bryan argued the only issue was whether Scopes broke the law, not expert testimony on science.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 16 July 1925 · page 1

SCIENCE BEING

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

The Scopes trial defense attorneys oppose starting court sessions with prayer. The report suggests their real concern is that ministers might use the prayers to address the jury rather than genuine opposition to prayer itself.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

A humor column from mid-1925 lists witty one-liners on various topics, including a quip predicting John Scopes will soon be as famous as other public figures. The item is part of a lighthearted roundup of jokes and observations, not a direct news report on the trial itself.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, Dr. Maynard Metcalf resumed testifying before the state moved to exclude scientific testimony. Darrow argued the jury needed to understand evolution to judge the case, while Bryan countered that only Scopes's guilt, not the theory's validity, was at issue.

Seward Daily Gateway · 16 July 1925 · page 1

SCIENTISTS TAKE STAND TESTIFY IN SCOPES TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

During the Dayton trial, Bryan argued that expert scientific testimony on evolution was irrelevant since the case was about whether Scopes broke the law, not about the truth of evolution. Darrow countered by questioning Bryan's own expertise and bias, and the court took the matter under advisement.

Seward Daily Gateway · 16 July 1925 · page 1

BRYAN ARGUING OVER DEMURRER IN SCOPES TRIAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

This is a small-town gossip column mentioning the Scopes trial only in passing, predicting Bryan will claim victory regardless of the verdict. The rest of the item covers unrelated local news and jokes about Stuttgart, Arkansas residents.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Things are going from bad to worse —Judge Wade of Little Rock ruled that home brew making is in viola tion of the 18th. After watching Hoolihan and Rog er Crowe play ball, we came to the conclusion that they are far from be ing old men. If we are decendants of monkeys, there must have been a varied as sortment in the dark ages. Regardless of the outcome of the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tenn., Bryan will come out victorious. If the de cision is against him, he will hold a big revival, spread a lot of hot air, have all join hands and sing, halalu jiah, and if possible declare him a candidate in the next presidential election.

See the clipping

Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · and 2 other papers

A news review discusses the Scopes evolution trial that opened in Dayton, Tennessee, noting international attention despite mockery of the proceedings. It highlights tension between Bryan's claim that Christianity is on trial and the defense's intent to focus on the law's constitutionality rather than religion.

Paris Express · 16 July 1925 · page 2

NEWS REVIEW OF CURRENT EVENTS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo. · 16 July 1925
  • The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · 17 July 1925

Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · and 2 other papers

The report covers William Jennings Bryan's triumphant arrival in Dayton and his controversial remarks framing the anti-evolution law as protecting religious teaching, which angered defense counsel seeking to focus on constitutionality. It also notes a failed defense attempt to get a federal injunction against the trial and a new scientific report on observed evolution that might aid the defense.

Paris Express · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo. · 16 July 1925
  • The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · 17 July 1925

Paris Express · Paris, Ark.

At the Dayton, Tennessee trial of John Thomas Scopes, Judge John T. Raulston retired to consider whether to quash the indictment against the 24-year-old teacher for violating the state's anti-evolution law. Lawyers on both sides, including John R. Neal, Dudley Field Malone, B. G. McKenzie, and Attorney General Stewart, argued the constitutionality of the law while the jury was briefly dismissed during the proceedings.

Paris Express · 16 July 1925 · page 6

EVOLUTION CASE IN FULL SWING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paris Express · Paris, Ark.

The court heard arguments on a motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, with defense attorney John R. Neal opening calmly before tempers flared, including a brief clash between B.G. McKenzie and Dudley Field Malone. The day closed with extended speeches from Attorney General A. T. Stewart and Clarence Darrow debating the law's constitutionality and fairness.

Paris Express · 16 July 1925 · page 6

TWO LAWYERS CLASH

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arkansas Echo · Little Rock, Ark.

A German-language weekly news roundup notes that the Scopes trial is underway in Dayton, Tennessee, receiving extensive newspaper coverage the writer feels is undeserved. It characterizes the defense as trying to confuse the issue to argue for evolution, while praising the prosecutor's opposition.

Arkansas Echo · 16 July 1925 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Arkansas Echo · Little Rock, Ark.

The article discusses competing views on what is at stake in the Scopes trial, quoting Bryan's claim that it is a battle between Christianity and paganism, and Scopes's own fear that religious and political fanatics could impose their views on public school curricula. The editorial dismisses both claims as exaggerated, arguing the trial's outcome won't harm Christianity and criticizing the idea of complete teaching freedom as potentially creating more confusion than political control of curricula.

Arkansas Echo · 16 July 1925 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Courier-Index · Marianna, Ark.

A brief item quotes John T. Scopes claiming the Tennessee evolution controversy originated from a casual discussion at a drugstore. It appears as filler among unrelated local Rondo community notices.

The Courier-Index · 16 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Courier-Index · Marianna, Ark.

Amid a mix of local community news, trivia, and bank financial reports, a short item notes John T. Scopes' comment that the Tennessee evolution controversy is just a drugstore discussion. The passage is largely unrelated filler content surrounding this brief mention.

The Courier-Index · 16 July 1925 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

During the Scopes trial, defense attorney Dudley Field Malone referenced William Jennings Bryan by name and quoted Bryan's own decades-old tribute to Thomas Jefferson to contrast his earlier modernist views with his current fundamentalist stance. The prosecution objected, and Judge Raulston repeatedly instructed Malone not to refer to Bryan by name during his statement to the jury.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 6

BRYAN RISES IN SELF-DEFENSE

With Changing Front DAYTON, Tenn., July 11. Ab) Bilence, whi:h for the ast four ar . of the Scopes triat set at Ur state coursk tab’-' w ith WlUh. Jennings Bryan, departed t ay. It was trunsferred to the crow I which parked the court room and was abeent only a moment, but eve r its ten.perary departure on • udon • I surprise and the succeeding brie remarks shattered the Intens, ex rectancy that charged the att - phere Mr Bryan arose an I awaited recognition from the cou:t They came duringe the course of Dudley Field Malone’s statement t the jury of the course tiy be followed by the defense in presenting ita The attorney for the defer 41 had referret!

See moreSee less

to Mr. Bryan, illing him by name aihI characterizing him ne the’ country’s chief exponent ui fundumentalisin The first. comparatively mild ret ereuce, brought an objection fr rn Attorney General A. T. Stwart.

See the clipping

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

During the Scopes trial, defense attorney Dudley Field Malone quoted Bryan's own earlier writings to challenge his fundamentalist stance, provoking objections from the prosecution and a ruling from Judge Raulston. Bryan rose to respond that he needed no protection from the court, while Darrow interjected that the exchange was irrelevant to the case at hand.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 6

further reference be made to M" Bryan. An exception was taken by Mr. Malone to the ruling of the cou. t. Other members of the prosecutin’ seemed a bout to take part in the impending argument. Then Mr. Bryan arose, slowly. He awaited recognition from the court. Reporters leaned forward antly. Silence descended upon the court room. “The court can do as it pleases in carrying out its rules.” the firm voice of the Floridan hepn. eyed Mr. Malone reflectively. “but i ask no protection from the court. * The defense counsel leaned for ward expectantly.

See moreSee less

Clarence Durrow with a half smile. •‘When the proper time anmes, I shall be able to show the gentleman that I stand today just where I d.l then, but that, has uthingto with the case at bar.”

See the clipping

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

The Scopes trial's daily opening prayer sparked controversy, with a Modernist minister, Rev. Charles Francis Potter, leading prayer after objections from visiting churchmen. Clarence Darrow renewed objections to any opening prayer, arguing it prejudiced his client's case, while the prosecution pushed back.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 1

COURT OPENED WITH A PRAYER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, defense witness Dr. Maynard M. Metcalf, a zoologist, testified about evolution with the jury removed from the courtroom after prosecution objections. Attorneys were expected to argue the next day whether such scientific testimony was legally competent for the jury to hear.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

The jury was finally seated and heard prosecution witnesses including the school superintendent and students before the state rested its case. The defense called Dr. Metcalf to testify about evolution and science, prompting objection from the prosecution and a debate over admissibility that led to the jury's temporary exclusion.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

During the Scopes trial, Dr. Metcalf is questioned by Darrow about the definition of evolution, with the court instructing the witness to whisper certain answers to avoid press exposure. Metcalf distinguishes between the fact of evolution and competing theories, describing organic evolution as a progression from simple to complex forms.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.

The report covers courtroom testimony on the second day of the Scopes trial, with Superintendent Walter White and student witnesses Howard Morgan and Harry Shelton describing how Scopes taught evolutionary theory from Hunter's biology textbook. Darrow cross-examined witnesses, highlighting gaps in their understanding of concepts like mammals, while school board chairman Robinson noted Scopes acknowledged teaching from the state-adopted text.

El Dorado Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

On the trial's first day devoted to oratory, lawyers for both sides argued whether the indictment against teacher John Scopes should be quashed, debating the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. A juror was questioned about possible bias, and defense attorney Dudley Field Malone clashed briefly with former attorney general Ben McKenzie during the proceedings.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 2

EVOLUTION CASE IN FULL SWING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The Scopes trial proceeded with arguments on a motion to quash the indictment, featuring defense attorney John Neal and a tense but good-natured exchange between Malone and McKenzie. Attorney General Stewart and Clarence Darrow delivered extended afternoon arguments on the constitutionality and fairness of Tennessee's anti-evolution law.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 2

TWO LAWYERS CLASH

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A colorful report from Dayton, Tennessee describes courtroom testimony in the Scopes trial, focusing on a young student witness named Howard Morgan who testified about what he had been taught from the evolution textbook. The correspondent mocks the courtroom's scandalized reaction to the 'salacious' details of evolutionary teaching being revealed.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Young student Howard Morgan testifies in whispers about what John Scopes taught him regarding the origins of life and evolution. The courtroom reacts with scandalized fascination as Attorney General Stewart questions him about mammals, leading to dramatic reactions from spectators including ejected youths and a cross-examination by Darrow.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1

BY W. O. McGEHAN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

This report describes student witnesses Howard Morgan and Harry Shelton testifying about Scopes's lessons on evolution and mammals, with Darrow's cross-examination on biological details portrayed as scandalous to the courtroom audience. The tone is heavily satirical, mocking the prosecution's faux outrage and the town's reaction to basic science being treated as indecent.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Zoologist Maynard Metcalf took the stand to explain evolution and its relation to the biblical creation account, prompting the jury to be excluded while Judge Raulston considered whether such testimony was admissible. The state argued the legislature had already settled the question by statute, leaving the case deadlocked pending further arguments.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Three Decades, Argu ment Charges BjPHILII* KINSLEY. (Copyrighted fop The Advertiser.) DAYTON, TENN., July 15.—Science wps offered today as the torch to guide Tennessee out of the darkness and the maze into which the Scopes’ trial has wandered. Into this r-uper-heated religious at mosphere, this pathetic search for the “eternal truth,” this wondering over the greatest problem that the human has ever tried to answer. The mys tery of man’s origin. Nine wise men Horn tne gr’it*! vUuc.uionui institutions '' \he or•’ John T. Raulston to tell the storv of God in the natural world.

See moreSee less

Whether they will be accepted or rejected re mains the great issue on which the case is deadlocked tonight. Oqe of these witnesses, Professor Maynard M. Metcalf, a research schol ar in zoology and evolution, wam placed on |he stand, asked a few mighty questions and the case was halted. Arguments will be heard tomorrow. “What is evolution in general and in fregard to the origin of man? Is theffc anything in evolution in conflict with the account o'f creation as giv en in the Bible?’’ These are the questions of the Scopes’ defense, which science stands ready to give to •Tennessee, together with a religion of love instead of fores.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The trial advanced with Judge Raulston upholding the indictment and the jury sworn in, as Darrow admitted Scopes taught evolution. Defense attorney Malone outlined plans to call Bryan as a witness and quoted Bryan's own past writings on religious freedom against him.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Bryan Article Quoted. It came during the presentation of the defense outline of proof by Dud ley Field Malone * In this case Mr. Malone revealed that the defense planned to prove part | of its case through Mr. Bryan him self. •We will prove our philosophy from | witnesses who are part of the prose i cution." he said. He then quoted from ! an article 'written bv Mr. Bryan. 30 j years ago, on Jefferson’s Ideas of re i ligious freedom. In this qase, Mr.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Dudley Field Malone argues there is no real conflict between evolution and Christianity, quoting Bryan's own earlier writings on religious freedom to challenge his fundamentalism. Bryan reacts angrily, insisting he needs no protection from the court, as the audience applauds Malone's speech.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 2

that. Bryan Beady To Spring. Mr. Malone referred to Mr. Bryan as “the evangelical spokosmanof the ; prosecution. ’ ; He said that while there might be j a conflict between evolution and the | theological views held by Mr. Bryan, | there was no such conflict in realty and that millions of Christians believed in both the Bible and evolution. I “We make & clear distinction,” he said, speaking directly at Mr. Bryan, ! who sat at his table, tense and ready ' to spring. “Between God, the church, i the Bible.

See moreSee less

Christianity and Mr. Bry an’s views.*’ This was somewhat shocking to the court, which ordered Mr. Malone sev eral times to leave Mr. Bryan's name out of the discussions. Also the uudieneo was astonished. “This is not personal. This is a con flict of ideas,” said Mr. Malone. “This is a religious statute. 1 an p#al from Mr. Bryan’s fundamental ism of today to his modernism of yes terday." The court again interposed to pro tect Mr. Bryan.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Judge John T. Raulston issued a forty-five minute ruling declaring Tennessee's anti-evolution law constitutional, denying the defense's motion to quash the indictment against Scopes. The ruling rejected arguments that the law violated free speech, free worship, or the Fourteenth Amendment, citing precedents from Oregon and Nebraska school cases.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 3

By JOHX HERRICK. (Copyrighted for The Advertiser. DAYTON, TENN, July 15.—It may, conceivably, go down in legal history, the decision today, fdrty-five minutes long, in which Judge John T. Rauls ton of Rhea county, declared Tennes see’s anti-evolution law constitution al. Denying the defense’s motion to quash the indictment, he overruled Scopes’ counsel on every point and on the very points by which they hop* to obtain an eventual victory in the higher courts. This anti-evolution law does not violate the right of free worship or }. free speech, ruled Judge Raulston.

See moreSee less

It does not violate that famous section i 1 of the fourteenth amendment to the ' constitution of the United States. \ wherein it is provided that no man \ shall be deprived of his life, liberty or property except by due process of law, and that all men shall enjoy i equal rights under the law. * So deciding and citing the recent

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The court rejects defense arguments that the law's caption was improper, that it violated the legislature's duty to cherish science, and that it infringed religious worship and free speech. The report describes the courtroom scene and the judge's rulings point by point during the Scopes trial proceedings.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 3

Oregon schools case and the Nebraska case concerning the teaching of Ger man. this court of Tennessee asserted firmly the right of the state to e* ercise its police powers In regulating its public schools Assuredly, no matter what the final decision may be, if Scopes is convicted here and his case appealed, the action

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Judge Raulston rejects defense constitutional challenges to the Tennessee law banning evolution teaching, ruling it applies uniformly to all public school teachers and does not violate state or federal constitutional protections. The ruling addresses multiple defense arguments including vagueness, due process, and equal protection claims.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 3

conduct. 67. Sycophant. this defendant or any other citizen of Tennessee to accept employment in the public schools. I “If his conscience constrains him to teach the evolution theory, he can find opportunities elsewhere in other schools to follow the dictates of his I conscience, and give full expression I to his beliefs and convictions upon this and other subjects.” Section of Article one of the Ten nessee constitution covers almost the same ground as is covered by section one of the fourteenth amendment to the federal constitution. That point came next. “The statute Involved applies alike to all persons coming into the like situation and circumstances, so far as public schools are concerned,” de clared Judge Raulston.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

An opinion piece quotes a Chicago Tribune correspondent, 'Scrutator,' who defends Appalachian mountain people against condescension from eastern intellectuals during the Scopes trial coverage. The writer argues American history shows repeated rejection of elite 'intellectual' positions by the broader populace.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 July 1925 · page 4

CHIDING THE INTELLECTUAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Reporter Raymond Clapper describes Dr. Maynard Metcalfe's testimony on evolution and the origin of man at the Scopes trial, delivered calmly in the Rhea County courthouse. The scientific testimony is being transmitted worldwide by wire even as Judge Raulston has yet to decide whether the jury will be permitted to hear it.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 2

World From Dayton Courtroom By RAYMOND CLAPPER (By l.fHsp-l Wire To The Age-Herald.) DAYTON. Tenn.. July 15.—Popular education of the world on the mysteries of evolution and the origin of man be gan in the Rhea county courthouse Wednesday when the Scopes trial swung into the great fundamental human won

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Dr. Maynard Metcalfe testified before Judge Raulston describing the scientific case for evolution, tracing life back some 600 million years to the Cambrian age. The jury was sent out of the room and barred from hearing the testimony until the judge rules on its admissibility.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Jury Is Kxclnded Never has the story of science been broadcast to the world before tonight, but those 12 men who must pass on the fate of young Johnny Scopes were sent out of the room and instructed not even to listen through the loud speaker in the courthouse yard. After Judge Raulston hears the whole story, he will decide whether it is proper material for the jury to hear in deciding the case. Dr. Metcalfe sketched the story of a man as told by science, how life is traced back to the Cambrian age at least 600,000,000 years ago; howman has developed from lower organisms.

See moreSee less

“The series is so convincing,’’ he said, “that it would be entirely impossible for any human being cognizant of them, to have any doubts asK to the facts of evolution, but he may have tremendous doubts as to the method of it." This was the finish of a fast-moving day which began when the judge de livered his opinion over-ruling the de fense motion to quash the indictment. Both sides presented opening statements. Scopes pleaded not guilty. The state put on four witnesses and rested its case and then the defense brought Dr. Met calfe forward as the first scientific witnesses. Whether his testimony will be admitted will be decided later by the

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A scientific witness testifies about the development of plant and animal life from inorganic matter, describing series of species succeeding one another over hundreds of millions of years. The testimony covers the transition from marine to terrestrial life and the development of locomotive organs in animals versus plants.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 2

STATE CLOSES IN SCOPES CASE

IN SCOPES CASE (Continued from Page One) changes. The sun Is comparatively young. The earth has gone through long courses of change. But inorganic evolution we have to conceive of earli est living or inorganic food. Only

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The controversy over opening each day's Scopes trial proceedings with prayer appeared settled after modernist preacher Rev. Charles Francis Potter was chosen to lead the prayer, with fundamentalist ministers to alternate on subsequent days. Clarence Darrow still formally renewed his objection to any prayer, arguing it prejudiced the defendant's case, though the judge considered the matter resolved.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

PRAYER DISPUTE IN SCOPES TRIAL APPEARS ENDED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Modernist and fundamentalist clergy clashed over which prayers should open court sessions, with Darrow objecting to daily prayer as prejudicial to Scopes. Darrow also addressed being called an 'agnostic,' and Attorney General Stewart publicly apologized to Arthur Garfield Hays for a prior courtroom dispute.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

At the Scopes trial, Attorney General Stewart publicly apologized to defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays for a sharp remark made during a dispute over the prayer issue the previous day. Hays accepted the apology and asked that no further references be made to the religious beliefs of Scopes' defense counsel.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz.

Scopes' defense attorneys plan to introduce the first two chapters of Genesis as evidence in the trial. They argue that evolution and religion need not conflict unless Genesis is interpreted strictly literally against modern scientific discoveries.

The St. Johns Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz.

The report notes the paradox that the Scopes trial's success depends on a guilty verdict, since only a conviction allows an appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court and ultimately the U.S. Supreme Court. Without a sentence, the constitutionality of the anti-evolution law cannot be tested.

The St. Johns Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz.

On the eve of the Scopes trial, William Jennings Bryan told a Dayton dinner audience that the case was a 'duel to the death' between evolution and Christianity. He argued that any attack on the Bible threatened revealed religion itself, downplaying the modest $500 fine Scopes faced.

The St. Johns Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 6

BRYAN SAYS FIGHT IS "DUEL TO DEATH" COMMONER SAYS INTEREST IS DUE TO ATTEMPT TO DESTROY RELIGION WIDE INTEREST IN SCOPES TRIAL EVOLUTION FIGHT IS STARTED IN COURTS AT DAYTON, TENNESSEE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz.

William Jennings Bryan, dining with defense counsel Clarence Darrow before the Scopes trial, declined to discuss case details but spoke at length on why the case has captured public interest. He framed the trial as a decisive battle between evolution and Christianity, and defended Tennessee's anti-evolution law and its people's character.

The St. Johns Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, Judge Raulston rebuffed requests from the sweltering crowd for chairs, insisting such matters were the sheriff's responsibility, not his. The report also lists defense expert witnesses already sworn in, including zoologists and anthropologists, and notes a congratulatory telegram sent to the judge by Malcolm McAdoo.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

JUDGE IS JUDGE AND NOT USHER, HE SAYS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, Dr. Maynard Metcalf resumed testimony on evolution while the state objected to its admissibility. Clarence Darrow argued the jury could not decide the case properly without understanding what evolution actually is.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

At the Scopes trial, Clarence Darrow argued the defense should be allowed to present expert testimony to show evolution does not conflict with the Bible, while William Jennings Bryan Jr. made his first courtroom appearance arguing such testimony was dangerous and irrelevant since the jury need only decide if Scopes broke the law. William Jennings Bryan Sr. watched his son's speech intently from nearby, and the exchange grew tense as attorneys were told to address the court rather than each other.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The New York World conducted a symposium of educators on whether American universities should reject educational credentials from Tennessee due to its anti-evolution law. Opinions varied, with some professors condemning the law as intellectual slavery while others cautioned against fighting intolerance with counter-intolerance.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 9

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The item is a brief note stating that attorney S. Gerard Casale plans to travel to Dayton to attend the trial of John Thomas Scopes, the high school teacher charged with violating the Butler law against teaching evolution. It mentions he will be in Dayton for several days during a business trip through the south.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 10

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

Defense attorney Arthur Hays argues scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted as evidence, sparking a heated exchange with prosecution lawyer Ben McKenzie. The prosecution rested its case after brief testimony from four witnesses, framing the issue as simply whether Scopes taught evolution.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 14

MONKEY TRIAL HEARING IS ON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The report describes courtroom arguments over whether expert scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, with defense attorney Hays and prosecution figures clashing, including a heated exchange with McKenzie. It also recounts the prosecution resting its case after brief witness testimony, and the defense calling seven scientific experts, with the jury excluded while Dr. Maynard Metcalf testified for the record.

New Britain Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 14

HEARING IS ON

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.

William Jennings Bryan delivered his first major speech of the Scopes trial, arguing against the admission of expert scientific testimony on evolution. He addressed the courtroom in dramatic fashion, denying claims that he was the chief instigator of the case against Scopes.

Imperial Valley Press · 16 July 1925 · page 1

BRYAN WILDLY FLAYS EVOLUTION IDEA

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The State formally moved to exclude testimony from scientific experts on evolution at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, with William Jennings Bryan Jr. arguing such testimony was dangerous and open to abuse. The defense, through Arthur G. Hays, insisted the testimony was vital for informing the jury, while the judge admitted he needed time to study the legal question.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 1

STATE OPENS FIGHT TO BAN EXPERTS AS SCOPES WITNESSES

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

At the Scopes trial, Bryan's son argued against allowing expert scientific testimony, calling it dangerous and equivalent to substituting trial by experts for trial by jury. Defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays countered that the jury should hear facts of science to understand evolution, arguing man and monkey share the same biological order.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Attorneys Hays and Bryan debate whether scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted as evidence, with Hays arguing man and monkey share classification as primates. The State's attorneys, including Hicks and McKenzie, argue against allowing the courtroom to become a forum for scientific debate.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article describes scientific concepts of evolution presented at the Scopes trial, including explanations of human versus animal traits and the age of the sun. It also recounts an exchange between Darrow and a scientist witness about the age of life on Earth, with Judge Raulston reacting dramatically.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 4

MAN HAS DEFECTS, DAYTON IS TOLD

“hands" of a bird. As a plain matter of fact, it is very difficult for even the most learned scientists to tell the difference be tween some men and some apes. The line of demarcation is so shadowy it almost ceases to exist. That’s the first dirty dig from the Scopes de fense.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report describes expert scientific testimony given in the Dayton courtroom, including an exchange where Darrow questioned a scientist about the age of early life forms, receiving an answer of 600,000,000 years. The piece also humorously recounts testimony about evolutionary biology, including claims about whales once having walked on land.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 4

BY ROBERT T. SMALL

600,000,000 Years Is AH. "Well, let me see.” says the scientist, as he scratches a rather thin thatch of hair on his dome in deep thought. “I should say probably 600,- 000.000 of years.” Judge Raulston gasps and calls for a big drink of water. The Bible w’hich the court swears by says that the world was created a little less than 6,000 years ago. So one may easily see why they contend on the street corners of Dayton that it is difficult to reconcile some of the ways of sci

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A whimsical piece imagines whales as former land-walking creatures who returned to the sea, framed as local color from Dayton during the Scopes trial. The piece notes that Dayton was now absorbed in scientific testimony, though the jury heard little of it directly.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Whales Once Pedestrians. It may not be a matter of common knowledge, but Dayton now knows that whales once walked abroad in the verdant land But one day the whales got tired of the dry land. The whales were naturally “wets." So they suggested to their friends, the seals. “Let’s go back and live in the ocean ” “Whales,” replied the seals, “you said a mouthful.” And away they galloped hack to the sea and have been residing there ever since. One of the whales, it seems.

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

During the Scopes trial, defense attorney Dudley Field Malone's statement to the jury referenced William Jennings Bryan as fundamentalism's chief exponent, provoking objections and prompting Bryan to rise and seek recognition from the court for the first time. Malone quoted Bryan's own past words on Jefferson regarding religious liberty and the incompetence of courts to judge religious opinion.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

BRYAN'S REMARK CREATES TUMULT

Malone Brings Commoner to Feet for First Time During Trial.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

DAYTON, Tenn., July 16.—Silence, which has set at the State counsel table of the Scopes trial with William Jennings Bryan, departed yesterday.

It was absent only a moment, but even its temporary departure and the succeeding brief remarks shattered the intense expectancy that charged the atmosphere, as Mr. Bryan arose and awaited recognition from the court.

During the course of Dudley Field Malone's statement to the jury of the course to be followed by the defense in presenting its case the attorney for the defense referred to Mr. Bryan, calling him by name, and characterizing him as the country's chief exponent of fundamentalism.

The first, comparatively mild, reference brought an objection from Attorney General A. T. Stewart. This produced remonstrance from Judge Raulston, who instructed Mr. Malone not to refer to Mr. Bryan by name in connection with the statement.

Quotes Tribute of Bryan.

Then the defense attorney quoted from a tribute paid Thomas Jefferson by Mr. Bryan a number of years ago.

"'Jefferson said in the first place that to attempt to compel people to accept a religious doctrine by act of law was to make not Christians but hypocrites. * * * He said, too, that there was no earthly judge who was competent to sit in a case and try a man for his religious opinions, for the judgment of the court, he said, would not be a judgment of law, but would be the personal opinion of the judge. What could be more true. No man who has religious convictions himself bears them so lightly that he can lay them aside and act as a judge when another man's religious convictions are involved. * * *

"'Jefferson put first that which I want to speak of last. It was that the regulation of the opinions of men on religious question by law is contrary to the laws of God and to the plans of God. He pointed out that God had it in His power to control man's mind and body, but that He did not see fit to coerce the mind or body in obedience to the divine will. * * * Jefferson realized that our religion was a religion of love and not a religion of force.'"

"These words, your honor, were written 20 years ago by a member of the prosecution in this case, whom I have described as the evangelical spokesman of the prosecution, and we of the defense, appeal from his fundamental views of today to his philosophical views of yesterday when he was a modernist to our point of view."

Judge Orders Halt.

The words brought the attorney general to his feet with an appeal. The judge again instructed that no further reference be made to Mr. Bryan.

"Yes, your honor," Mr. Malone responded, "but I do not think Mr. Bryan is in the least sensitive about it."

Mr. Bryan shook his palmetto leaf fan slightly. Although his lips tightened, he shook his head and responded, "Not a bit."

An exception was taken by Mr. Malone to the ruling of the court.

Then Mr. Bryan arose slowly. Reporters leaned forward expectantly.

"The court can do as it pleases in carrying out its rules," the firm voice of the Floridian began as he eyed Mr. Malone reflectively, "but I ask no protection from the court."

"When the proper time comes I shall be able to show the gentleman that I stand today just where I did then, but that has nothing to do with the case at bar."

A burst of applause such as seldom is heard in any courtroom swept the crowd, echoing down the corridors. The policeman pounded for order. Other courtroom attaches sounded admonitions.

The judge's voice became audible above the disorder:

"I will have to exclude you gentlemen if you persist in this. The jury is present now and I cannot tolerate any expressions of feeling on the issues in this case at all in the presence of the jury."

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

During trial proceedings, defense attorney Dudley Field Malone quotes Bryan's own earlier writings on religious freedom and Jefferson against him, prompting objections from the prosecution. The judge halts further reference to Bryan, and Bryan responds calmly that he needs no protection from the court, setting up tension for a later confrontation.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 5

CREATES TUMULT

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report covers courtroom argument over whether expert scientific testimony should be admitted in the Scopes trial, with Judge Raulston undecided on the question. Attorneys clash, including a heated exchange between Gen. McKenzie and Mr. Hays over religious belief and the Bible's teachings on creation.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 5

State Begins Fight to Ban Experts as Witnesses for Scopes

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This editorial opinion piece discusses the decline of corporal punishment like the whipping post and legal tolerance of wife-beating, noting changing social sentiment. It briefly mentions Clarence Darrow suggesting Scopes trial prosecutors need psychoanalysis, then shifts to an unrelated story about a Japanese scientist allegedly transmuting mercury into gold.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper column reflects wryly on how the Scopes trial has made Dayton, Tennessee famous and sparked public debate about Darwin, religion, and intellectual culture. It includes satirical verses and anecdotes, including a joke about William Jennings Bryan's unflattering photographs from the trial.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A photo caption shows Clarence Darrow delivering a speech in the Dayton, Tennessee courtroom during the Scopes evolution trial, described as pleading against religious bigotry. The caption calls this particular speech one of the finest of his career.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 17

I _. r _. , I ARRIVED HOME YESTERDAY. Speaker Nicholas Longworth and j KING NEPTLNE TAKES IT EAS\ IN HIS NATIVE HABITAT. W. F. Longfellow, assistant national di- ) Myron T. Herrick, United States Ambassador to France, who arrived in ) THE SPELLBINDER IS ON THE JOB AT DAYTON, TENN. Here we have Clarence Darrow, long one of rector of first aid and life-saving of American Red Cross, taking the part of King Neptune for a Red ) New York aboard the steamship Paris yesterday. The Ambassador will f the leading American legal lights, pleading against religious bigotry before the jury in the Scopes evolution

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Judge John T. Raulston announced he would take no further action regarding the alleged invasion of his privacy by International News Service correspondent William K. Hutchinson. The issue arose after Hutchinson sent a dispatch claiming to reveal the court's intentions on a defense motion to quash the Scopes indictment.

Evening Star · 16 July 1925 · page 44

DROPS REPORTER CASE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

The defense called zoologist Prof. Maynard Metcalf to explain evolutionary theory to the jury, with Judge Raulston allowing the testimony over prosecution objections. The report frames the trial as less about Scopes's guilt and more about evolutionists broadcasting their theory nationally ahead of an anticipated larger battle between science and fundamentalism.

The Washington Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

The Scopes evolution trial moved forward as Clarence Darrow called Professor Metcalf as the defense's first witness, which under Tennessee law excluded Scopes himself from testifying since the defendant must go first if he testifies at all. The prosecution objected strongly to Metcalf's testimony on evolution, calling the ruling on its admissibility one of the most difficult and important of the trial.

The Washington Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Scopes Won't Get to Take Stand

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

Zoologist Maynard Metcalf testified for the defense at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, explaining the concept of evolution to Judge Raulston under questioning by Clarence Darrow. A companion dispatch also describes courtroom atmosphere, including an apology from the attorney general to defense counsel and the judge's use of an electric fan amid the heat.

The Washington Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, William Jennings Bryan Jr. argued that expert scientific testimony on evolution should be barred as incompetent and irrelevant, while Clarence Darrow countered that evolution does not conflict with the Bible. Judge Raulston listened intently as the two sides debated whether such testimony would be presented to the jury.

The Washington Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

During the Scopes trial, defense attorney Darrow argued he wanted to show evolution does not conflict with the Bible, while Bryan's son objected that such expert testimony was incompetent and irrelevant. The courtroom scene showed Bryan Sr. listening intently to his son's argument as the debate over admitting evolution evidence continued.

The Washington Daily News · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A brief caption notes Clarence Darrow speaking at the Scopes trial, objecting to something he called 'obnoxious to our case.' The passage shows Darrow addressing the court, accompanying a photo.

The Washington Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

- we think are especially obnoxious to our case,” said Clarence Dar row at the Scopes trial. Darrow is shown addressing the court. LEAVES TO DIE IN ZION; ' WIFE OFF TO STOP HIM NEW ROCHELLE, N. Y.. July 17.—Determined to die in Jerusalem,

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

At the Scopes trial, prosecutors moved to exclude all scientific testimony on evolution and divine origin of man, sparking a heated argument. Judge Raulston excluded the jury and ultimately ordered expert witness Maynard Metcalf off the stand after Attorney General Stewart objected to his testimony.

The Washington Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

BRYAN, JR. REVEALS STATE'S HAND

Maynard Ruled Out. Clarence Darrow projected the issue by calling Metcalf and asking him what was the “evolution theory on the origin of man.” It was the principal “catch” question of the trial and Metcalf was ready to say that science did not deny the divine origin of humansBut At torney General A. Thomas Stewart would not let him reply, interposing strenuous objection. A debate fol lowed and Judge Raulston finally ordered the scientist off the stand, to hear arguments from counsel. The argument brought William Jennings Bryan, jr., son of the commoner, into the trial for the

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Attorneys debate whether scientific experts should be allowed to testify about evolution theory's compatibility with the Bible. Prosecutor Stewart argues the testimony is irrelevant since only the jury must decide if Scopes' teaching conflicted with the Bible, while Bryan warns jurors might defer to scientists' opinions.

The Washington Times · 16 July 1925 · page 2

JUDGE IS EXPECTED TO BAR TESTIMONY OF SCOPES' EXPERTS FINISH OF CASE IN SIGHT

SIGHT (Continued from First Page.) first time. Young Bryan argued for the State’s motion to exclude the scientists. Darrow sought first to have the court hear the «»clentlsts before rendering any decision. His pur pose was to have the scientific testimony broadcast to the world, even though it never reaches the ears of the twelve men who must sit in judgment on Scopes. “We want to put learned scien tists and real students of the Bible on the witness stand,” said Darrow, “to prove the theory of evolution is not in conflict with the Divine origin of man.

See moreSee less

While there Jsn’t a soul on earth, who believes the whole Bible literally, we will not attack it, but merely prove that science and the Bible can be recon ciled.” i Stewart renewed his objection to the testimony and moved that all further scientific evidence be ex eluded from the trial. He charged the scientific witnesses knew noth ing about the question of Scopes’ teaching in the public schools of Dayton and that any other testi mony was “irrelevant and incom petent.”

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Prosecutor Stewart moved to exclude scientific evidence as irrelevant, saying only the jury should decide if Scopes' teaching conflicted with the Bible. William Jennings Bryan then argued against allowing expert scientific testimony, fearing jurors would substitute scientists' opinions for their own judgment.

The Washington Times · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Says Jury Must Decide. "It is up to the jury to determine whether the lessons taught by Mr. Scopes were inconflict with the Bible,” Stewart added. “That is the only issue before the jury.” Young Bryan followed. ' He spoke in a low tone, barely heard atthe press tables. He probably was the best dressed man in the room, wear ing gray-striped flannels with a blue coat. “The, danger of putting on *he scientific witnesses,” said Bryan, nervously, “is that the jury may substitute the opinions of those scientists for their own.” Bryan revealed the State’s hand, for it wants the case decided by a jury, all of whose members have admitted knowing “almost nothing” about evolution.

See moreSee less

“The court should not re ceive opinionated evidence when it touches the issue involved,” Bryan continued. •‘The courts are agreed upon that.” William Jennings Bryan, the father, left his seat behind the State counsel table and moved up beside his son. The commoner sat fanning himself, llstenening intently to his boy. The son, however, showed none of the famous Bryan eloquence. -His arguments were voiced in a conversational tone, without gestures and while stand- ■ ing still. - A few feet away, inside the coun sel rail, sat the speaker’s mother, who had to be carried into the courtroom, and his wife. Across the room, defense counsel opened mail, read newspapers or chatted with friends.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Judge Raulston cautions spectators against applause fearing the courthouse structure, then defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays argues evolution and man's classification in science. A separate item reports John Scopes' father leaving Dayton due to his wife's illness, expressing confidence in his son's acquittal in public opinion despite expecting conviction by the jury.

The Washington Times · 16 July 1925 · page 2

By International News Service. DAYTON, Tenn., July 16. —“My son stands acquitted in the popu j lar mind, but hewill probably be I convicted by the Dayton jurv ” th s parting mesuge, ' Thomas Scopes, a Kentuckian was homeward bound today ufter having left his son, John Thomas Scopes. to face the final music cf ' the anti-evolution trial. The elder Scopes was called home by the illness of him wife, and will not return unless the trial is drawn out over next week. “I believe the world already has acquitted my boy,” said John’s father.

See moreSee less

“It wcgild if it ■ knew him and the theory of evolution.” Scopes, sr., defended the people of Dayton. “They don’t get an opportunity in Dayton,” he said, “to calk and be taught evolution. They lack the atmosphere which would give

See the clipping

Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.

Arguments over whether expert scientific testimony should be admissible occupied the morning session of the Scopes trial, with Arthur Hays for the defense facing opposition from Bryan, Hicks, and McKenzie for the state. A heated exchange between Hays and McKenzie over religious beliefs briefly disrupted proceedings before apologies were made to the court.

Americus Times-Recorder · 16 July 1925 · page 1

SCIENCE POINT ARGUED TODAY IN SCOPES CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia

An opinion piece criticizes those using the Scopes trial to score political and religious points rather than genuine Christian conviction. It specifically references Darrow as an atheist and Malone as a professed Christian, arguing that sincere Christians would not exploit the trial for public showmanship.

The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 16 July 1925 · page 2

:.vcs by a man who would as quickly debase Him and dishonor Him in a community of cut thr.x)ats—ihat is the J vhing that gets on our nerves. This is exactly 'what i§ transpiring in the court daily at the Scopes trial. This is the thing Darrow, the atheiet, and Malone the professed chris

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

A procedural squabble broke out among counsel over how to argue the admissibility of scientific evidence on evolution before Judge Raulston. Darrow explained the defense hoped to show through scientists and Bible scholars that evolution does not conflict with Scripture.

The Indianapolis Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

SCOPES TRIAL IS SPLIT OPEN BY NEW CRISIS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

This editorial argues that if Indiana's legislature passed a law like Tennessee's banning evolution instruction, it would likely be legally valid, citing a 1919 precedent that banned teaching German in schools. The piece notes the Indiana Constitution is silent on legislative power over curriculum, making such a law enforceable despite differing subject matter and motives.

The Indianapolis Times · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Scopes Might Lose in Indiana mF the Indiana General Assembly should enact a law prohibiting the teaching of the theory of evolution in the public schools of

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

During the trial, prosecution and defense attorneys argued before Judge Raulston over whether scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted as evidence. William Jennings Bryan Jr. argued for the prosecution that such expert testimony was incompetent and dangerous, risking turning the trial into a debate on evolution versus the Bible.

The Indianapolis Times · 16 July 1925 · page 11

CRISIS REACHED IN SCOPES CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Scopes trial proceeded with Judge Raulston ruling the anti-evolution law constitutional, after which Scopes pleaded not guilty and the jury was sworn. The prosecution rested after four witnesses, and when the defense called scientist Professor Metcalfe to testify, prosecutors objected, sparking arguments over expert testimony and what constitutes the authoritative Bible text.

The Indianapolis Times · 16 July 1925 · page 11

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

The trial's first day featured the judge overruling a motion to quash the indictment, opening statements, and Scopes pleading not guilty. The state called four witnesses including school superintendent Walter White, then the defense called Dr. Metcalf as its first scientific witness amid disputes over biblical versions and the law's wording.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 4

DEFENSE CALLS DOCTOR TO TELL HISTORY OF MAN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Witnesses including school superintendent White and students testify about Scopes teaching evolution from the state-approved biology textbook. Defense attorneys Hays and Darrow challenge the anti-evolution law's reliance on a specific Bible version and cross-examine witnesses about classroom content.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Witnesses including students Morgan and Shelton testify that Scopes taught evolutionary theory from Hunter's biology textbook, including that man is a mammal and life originated from a single cell. Darrow cross-examines, drawing out that the teaching did not harm the students' faith or standing, while druggist Robinson, who helped instigate the test case, is also questioned about selling the textbooks.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Prof. Edward L. Rice of Ohio Wesleyan University, described as a leading authority on evolution, will testify for the defense in the Scopes trial at Dayton, Tennessee. The report notes the irony that Wesleyan is a Methodist institution.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

At the Dayton courthouse, the defense called Dr. Maynard Metcalfe of Oberlin as its first witness to testify on evolution and the origin of man, though it remained undecided whether the jury would be permitted to hear such scientific testimony. The proceedings drew worldwide attention via wire services and photographs, even as Judge Raulston had yet to rule on the admissibility of expert evolutionary testimony.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

DEFENSE CALLS DOCTOR TO TELL HISTORY OF MAN

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

Defense witness Dr. Maynard Metcalfe, a zoologist, testified before Judge Raulston on the scientific evidence for evolution, tracing life back 600 million years to the Cambrian age. The jury was removed from the courtroom and barred from hearing the testimony until the judge rules on its admissibility.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A commentary piece describes how an International News reporter scooped Judge Raulston by publishing his written opinion on Tennessee's anti-evolution law before he delivered it in court. The writer mocks the judge's indignation as misplaced given the trial's already circus-like, publicity-seeking atmosphere.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

An opinion piece mocks the Scopes trial judge for threatening contempt charges against a reporter who obtained an advance copy of his decision. The writer argues the judge is more concerned with his own dignity and re-election than justice, comparing him unfavorably to Ed Wynn and Will Rogers.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A collection of witty one-liners and jokes referencing the Scopes trial, including jabs at opening prayers, Bryan, and Dayton's local culture. The tone is satirical, poking fun at the town's religious fervor and the absurdity of the proceedings.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A photo caption shows Professor John T. Scopes stepping out of the Dayton, Tennessee courtroom for air between trial sessions. He is described as on trial for violating the state's anti-evolution law, with a verdict still pending.

South Bend News-Times · 16 July 1925 · page 21

Scopes Awaits Verdict

. Latest photo of Professor John T. Scopes, on trial charged with . tiolating the anti-evolution law. taken between sessions as ho came • .ut oLthe small Dayton, Tenn., courtroom for a breath of air. Confesses > I . Wanted jAUfit/RN kaiss, i LIGHT . mustache i i HEIGHT S'Kr| W&0HT IvbOLBS.

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

Judge Raulston ruled the Tennessee anti-evolution law constitutional, rejecting the defense's motion that it violated freedom of expression. The defense's next move will be seeking to admit scientific testimony on evolution over prosecution objections.

The Daily Worker · 16 July 1925 · page 1

DAYTON JUDGE RULES APE LAW CONSTITUTIONAL

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

Judge Raulston is considering the defense's motion to dismiss Scopes' indictment and declare the anti-evolution law unconstitutional, with a decision expected soon. Darrow argued the law fosters bigotry and violates religious liberty, while observers predict the judge will side with the state and allow the trial to proceed.

The Daily Worker · 16 July 1925 · page 2

JUDGE IN SCOPES' TRIAL ASKED TO RULE ON CONSTITUTIONALITY OF TENN. ANTI-EVOLUTION LAW

Question of Liberty of Thought. The defense based their principal | hope for success on a contention that j the law violated the guaranteas of religious freedom in the state and federal constitutions. Their oither points, involving property rights, the protection of scientific education and an alleged technical Irregularity itt the law were issues compared to the great question of religious liberty raised by Clarence Darrow In his ad dress to the court. narrow charged the law fostered bigotry, ignited fires of intolernnce and denied minorities the right to worship .god according to the dictates of their consciences.

See moreSee less

With a decision favorable to the state, both sides were ready to pro ceed with the trial on Its merits. Scopes will be arraigned, plead not guilty and his students will take the stand to accuse him of teaching evolu tion in defiance of the law. Then will f ollow the postponed clash over the admissibility of testi mony by scientists. In this contest, William Jennings Bryan was expected to take his first active part in the. triaL The future of the trial will hinge on this debate and the decision of Judge Raulston on hearing scientists. i Clarence Darrow formally objected - today to opening the trial with prayer. The objection was overruled by Judge John T. Rauston and Darrow immediately entered an exception into the record of the case. The defense forcefully protested against the prayer, leading to sharp argument be tween attorneys for Scopes and the state counsel. After a sharp debate. Rev. A. <L Stribben, pastor of the Cumberland. Presbyterian church, was called to the judge’s rostrum to pray.

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

The court ruled against defense arguments that the Tennessee anti-evolution law violated religious freedom guarantees, clearing the way for trial on the merits with Scopes's arraignment and student testimony to follow. Darrow formally objected to opening the trial with prayer, was overruled by Judge Raulston, and a minister was called to deliver the prayer amid sharp argument.

The Daily Worker · 16 July 1925 · page 2

OF TENN. ANTI-EVOLUTION LAW

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

A left-wing newspaper reports that Tennessee papers are attributing the Scopes evolution trial uproar to Communist agitation, pointing to ACLU's defense of Scopes and its director Roger Baldwin's ties to radical causes. The article mockingly suggests business interests like U.S. Steel and the L&N railroad are behind the religious fervor.

The Daily Worker · 16 July 1925 · page 2

SOUTH BLAMES SCOPES 'HERESY' ON COMMUNISTS

Times or the Chicago Tribune. Is not the American Civil Liberties Union financing the Scopes defense? And has it not defended I. W. W. and Com

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report describes rising anti-evolution sentiment in Dayton, Tennessee, with courtroom crowds openly expressing resentment against defense attorneys. It notes the judge is struggling to maintain order, and includes descriptions of photos showing defense counsel Neal addressing the court and Darrow, Scopes, Malone, and Neal conferring.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1

GROWING ILL-FEELING LENGTHENS ODDS AGAINST SCOPES

a I Growing animosity of Dayton, which is nearly 100 per cent anti evolution in feeling, is increasing the odds against the defense in the Tennessee evolution trial. Resent r ent against defense attorneys is being openly expressed by court room crowds, and the judge is pre serving order with great difficulty. In the upper picture John Randolph Neal, senior defense counsel, is seen making a stirring appeal in behalf of the defendant, John T. Scopes. In the lower photo defense lawyers are seen having a conference. Darrow, Scopes, Malone and Neal have their heads together.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

On July 16, defense and state attorneys argued before Judge Raulston over whether scientific testimony on evolution could be presented to the Scopes jury. Darrow explained the defense hoped to show through scientists that evolution does not conflict with the Bible, while the state objected to this line of evidence.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1

DARROW TELLS EXPECTATIONS

state objection. . .. 3 Upon Judge Raulston’s ruling whether the testimeny pends noted scientists end educators. be presented to the Scopes jury. Clarence Darrow made * M ment to the judge outlining what defense hoped to prove by sMkt| mony. - "We expected to show,” add row, "by scientists and real sche of the Bible, first, what evolutin and second, that by any intorsp tion educated men can show1 evolution is not in conflict will, Bible." i A squabble promptly broke 3 among counsel as to the ,MM| in the argument, the presssd, seeking to maneuver it so that I would have the opening and argument on the question abed defense seeking the same advaid for themselves.

See moreSee less

& Judge Raulston had to cauticn’) attorneys not to fight among th selves, but to address all remart him. Y Attorney General Stewart VMM ed to the court a motion to Ml the scientific testimony ground that under the interpremi of the wording of the act it ti be entirely incompetent. e Malone followed Stewart, tell that the agreement entered ista the two staffs Friday to take wart question of scientific testimony t of order he adhered to.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Arguments were heard before Judge Raulston on whether expert scientific testimony about evolution could be presented to the jury, with the jury excluded from the courtroom during this debate. Darrow argued for admitting scientist testimony to reconcile evolution with the Bible, while the prosecution, including Bryan's son, argued such testimony was incompetent and irrelevant.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Young Bryan Argue*. : William Jennings Bryan. Jr.,1 ed argument for the prosecuting "On your honor’s ruling will termine whether this case wfnj orderly case, or whether it wi generate into a debate on whl evolution conflicts with the ■ said young Bryan. "This expert evidence, as 99 offered on evolution, is chall by the state as incompetent, Ws vant and immaterial. . “I have heard harsh thisgsa about expert witnesses. Evagnt: friend, Mr. Darrow, in the Losetia referred to an expert witness all t 'purveyor of pedjury.’ I don’ttal I I have heard anything stronger dai that.

See moreSee less

"This kind of testimony hasjal ways been regarded by concert jurors with great disfavor." While young Bryan made his ment, Darrow began reading a of letters before him. “ 'The danger of such testime that jurors may substitute opinions for their own’,” I Bryan read from one of preee W. J. Bryan, Sr.. moved ouk$ behind the prosecution taMa.' leaned forward in his chat, WM Ina intently to his son and fanning aim self with rapid strokes.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

During the Scopes trial, defense attorney Arthur Garfield Hays argued that scientific experts should be allowed to testify as fact witnesses, prompting William Jennings Bryan to respond on a legal point about the anti-evolution law superseding textbook requirements. Prosecution attorney Herbert Hicks argued against admitting defense witnesses as biased, and Judge Raulston questioned General Ben McKenzie about biblical creation interpretation.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 10

HEATED TILT OVER 'APE' TESTIMONY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

During the Scopes trial, Judge Raulston sustains an objection to defense expert witnesses as interested parties, then questions prosecutor Ben McKenzie about his literal interpretation of divine creation. Darrow interjects a quip about whether God resembles man, to which McKenzie affirms and Darrow jokes God looks better.

Paper unidentified · 16 July 1925 · page 10

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Reports from Coolidge's summer home say the President believes Bryan's proposal to amend the Constitution to mandate belief in Genesis and ban evolution teaching will fail. Coolidge is said to view it as a threat to religious freedom and is closely following the Dayton trial's constitutional implications.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 5

BRYAN CAN'T GET BIBLE AMENDMENT, COOLIDGE THINKS

j evolution in American schools, and to | compel belief in the first chapter of ! the Bible. President Coolidge is following closely the great legal battle now be ' Ing waged at Dayton, Tenn., between the proponents of Darwinism and the : backers of Genesis. His interest fo j cases on the constitutional aspects of ! the case almost entirely, and he is a reading avidly the daily reports in the press bearing on the evolution trial. | It is the President’s conviction that j Bryan's proposal will die "aborning.”

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report describes President Coolidge's constitutional concerns about the Scopes trial, particularly fears of 'mob psychology' and Bryan's push for a constitutional amendment on religious teaching. It notes Coolidge's personal religious liberalism and his silence on evolution itself, while detailing his worship at a Congregational church whose pastor supports Darwinism.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 5

COOLIDGE THINKS

■ audience they would do far more good (by preaching the gospel of “right liv- , ling” than by seeking to teach in de tail the many tenets of their particu lar branches of the church. He ad , monished these emissaries of the i Christian religion that not all was : perfect in their faith; that, in fact, i they might even learn something from those they sought to convert. Two elements in the trial at Dayton Interests Mr Coolidge especially. The ! first is the possibility of injection of ; "mob psychology” into the evolution i controversy, and the second, follow ing directly in line, is the attempt of | Bryan, as the outstanding member of ,the prosecution in the Scopes trial, to force a constitutional amendment that ' Inevitably would bring about even ' greater differences than the prohibi tion amendment.

See moreSee less

Concerned Over Move to Divide , Oinntry The President is aware of the mag fietic personality of the Commoner displayed so forcefully in three presi ; dential campaigns of the past. He is , watching with interest the attempt 'of Bryan to stir up a national senti ment against the "monkey theory” ..with the ultimate goal of another con stitutional amendment designed to safeguard the literal teaching of the Bible. ; And, constitutionalist that he is, the executive also is concerned with the ! effort to secure an additional article [that would divide the American na i tion Into two distinct camps on the i most dangerous of all questions—re ligion. In so far as his personal opinions on the theory of evolution are con ' cerned, the President is remaining si ; lent. His views, however, are known !to be the most liberal on the general subject of religion. He worships weekly In the Congregational church, >3garded as one of the more modern branches of the church. Rev Dr Jason Noble Pierce, pastor of the President’s church in Wash ington, is looked upon as an advocate I’bf the Darwinian theory, and only last Sunday here in Massachusetts, tMr and Mrs Coolidge listened to a sermon delivered by Rev Dr William . H. Spence, of the Tabernacle church , of Salem, which generally was inter | preted as enunciation of approval of the theory of evolution.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Arriving in Dayton before the trial, William Jennings Bryan declared he would spend the rest of his life campaigning for a constitutional amendment banning the teaching of evolution if the defense won. His remarks, emphasizing religion over constitutional law, reportedly annoyed Scopes' defense team who wanted to focus on freedom of learning.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 5

BRYAN MAY RUN ONE MORE RACE

Federal Amendment (’ Dayton, Tenn., July 9—Promising to devote the rest of his life, if nec essary, to a national campaign for a constitutional amendment to pro hibit the teaching of evolution, in case the Scopes trial results in victory for the defense, William Jennings Bryan today gave his many admirers here - ground for predicting that the Com moner would again bera candidate for the presidency of the United States. Those who heard, and cheered, Bryan’s declaration that he would make the last act of leadership of his .life a nation-wide campaign to put the Bible into the constitution, forecast a day when he would run for President on a fundamentalist platform.

See moreSee less

Showing intense feeling, in his speech delivered following his arrival here, Bryan declared he had no great faith in the infallibility of the courts, * that he believed that power came from the people and morality from the Bible, and that antievolutionists were ’ in the majority in the United States, j,. Defense Annoyed The Commoner’s insistence, on the eve of the trial, upon emphasizing the alleged conflict between evolution and , religion, rather than dealing with the ' question of constitutionality involved, has rather annoyed the defense. The distinguished coup set, who are to de fend Prof John T. Scopes against a charge of teaching evolution contrary s to the laws of Tennessee, had planned to make freedom of learning the burn ing issue. Bryan h.ia set fire to quite a different powder train. •‘The forecast that he will move rapidly from the lower courts, then to the supreme court of Tennessee, then to the supreme court of the United ' States, and then, having lost, will campaign for a constitutional amend ment against existing guarantees of religious and educational liberties is a very ambitious program, even for Mr Bryan,’’ said fudge John R. Neal, senior cobnael for Scopes. Bryan has work'd for two months on the speech which he will deliver in summation at the trial. It probably be the greatest oratorical effort of his career.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This editorial reflects on the trial as an opportunity to study how new ideas spread and why they are often retarded, comparing the rapid spread of Einstein's relativity theory to the slower acceptance of evolution. It argues that scientists bear some responsibility for not popularizing new knowledge, and warns that enlightenment must reach the public or risk reactionary ignorance.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The piece argues scientists must do more to communicate new ideas to the public, lest ignorance and prejudice prevail, citing the Scopes trial as evidence of this need. It also includes miscellaneous notes on topics like Zionist congress plans, a German death penalty appeal, and Tammany boss Charles Murphy's estate value.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A miscellaneous commentary column touches on many world events, including a brief mention that Darrow's scientific witnesses will soon arrive in Dayton and that Bryan has called the Scopes trial 'a duel to the death.' The item treats the trial as one of many ongoing global stories rather than a focal subject.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 6

NOTE AND COMMENT

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The article reports that William North Rice, 80-year-old professor-emeritus at Wesleyan University, will testify for the defense in the Scopes trial. It notes he faced similar heresy accusations years earlier for teaching geology that contradicted a literal Biblical creation account, though those charges were dropped.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 7

Prof Rice to Testify At Evolution Trial

Background T'E TRIAL, which began Frlv ilay at Dayton, Tenn., has reached out its tentacles ~ and grasped Springfield. And Springfield has entered on the side of science, its unofficial and perhaps quite unknowing representative being William North Rice, 80-year-old pro fessor-emeritus of Wesleyan univer sity, the son of William Rice, for many years librarian of the city library. Prof Rice has been called to testify for the defense in the Scopes trial. It is fitting that this eminent scientist should find himself aligned on the side of the defendant; for he himself has played the same role, though the charges of heresy against the geolo gist were dropped and the case never came to trial.

See moreSee less

For years Prof Rice has been an officer of the Council of the Connecticut Federation of Churches. When Middletown learned that its venerable man of science was to take the stand in the Scopes trial, the town recalled the fact that several years

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

At the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, defense attorney Clarence Darrow and Attorney General Stewart made closing arguments over a motion to quash the indictment against teacher John Scopes. Judge Raulston retired to consider whether the indictment should be dismissed, with Darrow likening the anti-evolution law to the Spanish Inquisition.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 7

STARTS IN ATTACK ON BIBLE AS LAW

Teacher Be Quashed (By the Associated Press) Dayton, Tenn., July 13—Judge John T. Raulston, presiding at the trial of John Thomas Scopes, on a charge of violating the law of the state of Tennessee making it a misdemeanor to teach theories of evolution in the public schools, re tired to his chamber tonight to study the question of whether the indictment against the 24-years-old school teacher shall be summarily quashed. The judge carried with him briefs of the half-score points stressed by the contending sides in the case, while ringing in his judi cial ears were words from half a dozen oral arguments presented to the court during the day.

See moreSee less

Day Devoted to Oratory It was the first of perhaps other days to bo devoted entirely to ora tory. Clarence Darrow and Atty-Gen Stewart concluded their arguments over the motion to quash as court was adjourned for the night. They con cluded the arguments for the defense and the prosecution respectively. Darrow termed the law one which would lead to enactments all pointing toward fanaticism and leading to a climax which would recall the days of the Spanish inquisition. The at torney-general contender! that the law was within the police powers of the state and the legislature had the right to control the curricula of the schools it .maintained and created. The custom of opening Rhea coun ty courts with prayer may become an issue in the Scopes case. Mr Darrow, while he has made no formal state ment in court, is known to have pro tested informally to Judge Raulston. Judge Raulston said today that he would not depart from his custom of having prayer daily at the opening of the court and if Darrow persisted in his protest to the extent of enter ing it in the record, the court would rule that the question was one to be determined by the conscience of the judge and the resulting responsibility would be the judge’s alone. State Must Control Schools The attorney-general in his argu ments for the state, combatted the defense motion vigorously. He main tained that the indictment against Scopes was legal; that the act was not unconstitutional and was within

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Darrow and Attorney-General Stewart concluded oral arguments over whether the indictment against teacher John Scopes should be quashed, with Darrow calling the anti-evolution law a step toward fanaticism and Stewart defending the Legislature's right to control school curricula. A dispute also arose over Judge Raulston's custom of opening court with prayer, which Darrow informally protested.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 7

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

William Jennings Bryan faced criticism from two religious figures following his Sunday sermons in Dayton. A Catholic editor accused him of seeking to merge church and state, while a Unitarian minister challenged his claims about Jesus's education.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 12

BRYAN ASSAILED BY CATHOLIC EDITOR

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Miss Lola Scopes, sister of John T. Scopes, lost her teaching position in Paducah, Kentucky schools after refusing to renounce her belief in evolution. She has since been offered a resident teaching post at Highland Manor, a girls' school in Tarrytown, New York, paying about $1000 plus maintenance.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 12

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The passage reports on William Jennings Bryan's speeches in Dayton, Tennessee, where he declared his intent to make Bible teachings the foundation of government, pushing for a constitutional amendment banning evolution teaching if Tennessee's law is overturned. The editorial criticizes this as a threat to free speech and religious liberty, arguing it conflicts with American ideals of truth and scientific inquiry.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This editorial criticizes William Jennings Bryan's position in the Scopes trial, arguing that his attempt to ban evolution teaching threatens free speech and scientific inquiry. It frames the case as fundamentally a constitutional issue, citing the Tennessee state constitution's provisions for promoting science and literature as conflicting with the anti-evolution law.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This editorial discusses the legal ambiguities in the Tennessee statute and the defense's motion to quash the indictment on grounds of vagueness. It also reflects on the broader cultural significance of the trial, comparing it to Galileo's trial and framing it as a battle against intellectual stagnation.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

With the jury removed, defense attorneys questioned Dr. Maynard Metcalf as a test case to argue that scientific testimony on evolution should be admitted, hoping to show no conflict between evolution and Christianity. The court was expected to rule on whether such testimony was legally competent, amid strong prosecution objections.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 4

TRIAL'S BIG FIGHT WILL CENTER ABOUT SCIENTISTS' VIEWS

calf Has to Whisper An swer to Court Stenographer Dayton, Tenn., July 15—CAP) — Argument as to the competency of scientific testimony in the Scopes case will be made in the courtroom her* tomorrow, a development eagerly expected by participants and lookers on in Dayton. The state had rested its case and one scientific witness. Dr Maynard M. Metcalf, former professor of zoology at Ober lin college, Ohio, was on the witness stand for the defense when court ad journed late today. Hia testimony, however, has not yet been made a part of the record of the case, for prosecution attor neys voiced objection when questions concerning evolution were asked him and the jury was retired from the room. With the jury out of the ourferoom, defense attorneys were

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The trial moved into testimony, with the state calling witnesses including the superintendent of schools before resting its case; the defense then called Dr. Metcalf as its first witness to argue evolution does not conflict with Christianity. His testimony was heard outside the jury's presence as a test of admissibility, with the state objecting strongly.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 4

The defense hopes to prove by Dr Metcalf and other scientists that there is no condict between evolution theories and Christianity. One of the questions asked the witness this af ternoon concerned his church affilia tions. He testified that he is now a member of the Congregationalist church and formerly was a member of the Presbyterian church. He has taught two Bible classes, he said. First Witnesses Called The case moved rapidly after reach ing the stage of actual testimony. The first witness took his place on" the stand at the second session of the court today.

See moreSee less

The more or less neglect ed Jury was brought into the court room after an extended period of ex clusion. A plea of “not guilty” was entered for John T. Scopes by one of his attorneys, the jury was sworn and at last was actually a part of the case. The jurymen heard Walter White, superintendent of schools, two school hoy «tudents of Scopes and P. E. Rob insen, chairman of the board of edu cation testify for the state. They saw “a civio biology" by George W. Hun ter, and a Bible introduced in evi dence. The state rested and the de fense called Dr Metcalf as its first witness. No objection came from Atty-Gen A. T. Stewart as the witness ■was led through a detailed account of his scientific activities since he was 10 years of age. Jury Sent Gnt of Hearing At the first mention of ‘'evolution'’ objection came from the state as to

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

During the Scopes trial, the jury was excluded while Clarence Darrow questioned Dr. Metcalf, a zoology expert witness, about evolution and his qualifications. A notable moment involved the witness whispering an answer to the court reporter to keep it from the press, amid procedural wrangling over the admissibility of expert testimony.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 July 1925 · page 4

After this detail Clarence Dnr-ow ;ked: “Are you an evolutionist?” "Surely,” replied the witness, as the torney-general seemed about to in rpose an objection. “Do you know any scientific men to are not evolutionists?” was Mr jrrow’s next question, and Mr Stew ’» objection was in this time before could be made, the court instructed the witness whisper his answer to the. court Biographer and admonished that court attache not to permit the press to get it. The answer was whispered and entered in the record. Defining Evolution Then Dr Metcalf was asked to give his definition of evolution. The wit ness said that he was opposed to def initions but, was willing to give de scriptions. The question was finallv lest in the shuffle, but after the jury

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This is a photo caption noting publicity efforts by anti-evolutionists at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, which was ongoing at the time. No further descriptive text accompanies the image credit.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Publicity Efforts of Anti-Evolutionists at Dayton, Tenn., Trial of Scopes, Now in Progress

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Judge John T. Raulston rejected the defense's motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, upholding the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law. He ruled the law did not violate religious freedom or teachers' rights, since public schools are not places of worship and no one is compelled to teach there.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 1

JUDGE REFUSES DEFENSE PLEA TO QUASH THE CASE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Judge Raulston explained his ruling that the Tennessee anti-evolution law did not violate teachers' constitutional rights, since public school employment is contractual and teachers can seek work elsewhere if they wish to teach evolution. He also stated the law did not restrain anyone's right to worship according to their conscience.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The piece discusses anticipation over Judge Raulston's pending ruling on the defense's motion to dismiss the Scopes case, highlighting Darrow's arguments about the ambiguity of the Tennessee anti-evolution law. It quotes Darrow questioning how a teacher could know what the Bible actually teaches about human origins given conflicting biblical accounts.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 6

DARROW EXCITES CURIOSITY The text of the Judge’s ruling, in response to the plea of the Scopes defense to throw the case out of court has not at this writing appear ed. Some curiosity as to how he may try to get around or avoid the argument of Darrow, for instance, is pardonable. How may there be fair answer to the question, what under the Tennessee act is the school teach er in that State to teach? Regarding the provision forbidding him “to teach the theory that denies the divine creation of man, as taught in the Bible and to teach instead that man has descended from a lower order of animals’’, Darrow asks his honor just what “is given as the origin of man as shown in the Bible”, how reconcile the conflicting ac counts; how may a teacher know that he is not violating the criminal code; who has authority to tell us just what the Bible means"?

See moreSee less

How successfully dispute the statement that “no Legislature is strong enough in any State of the Union to charac terize and pick any book as being divine”, without defying the provi sions of the Constitution? Of course Judge Raulston will not tell us, Mr. Bryan will not tell us, however strenuous or oratorical may be their effort to do so. And when they are through will it remain true, as Darrow says of them in the Bible

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The piece reflects on Darrow's courtroom argument comparing outdated biblical cosmology to modern science, and questions why religious and scientific camps cannot support each other rather than fight. It also references a Dayton pastor driven from his church for allowing a pro-evolution speech, illustrating the 'hatred and venom' Darrow decried.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 6

DARROW EXCITES CURIOSITY

And Darrow says he cannot ac count for “the hatred and the ven om." Within sound of his voice there was a sample of it, the pastor driven from the church and the home he had built because he thought, as Bryan was talking against evolution in another church, H would be proper for a noted divine to speak In his church the same day la favor of evolution. The mother of the hero in “The Tea Commandments,’’ who bemoans , % that ha ia only fit to be a carpenter, | reminds him that there have been In history some mighty good men ■who were carpenters.

See moreSee less

So the unchurched, homeless pas tor ot Dayton, being somewhat of a carpenter and electrician turns to real constructive work, which build ing a church for that people does not appear to have been. And yet that question still looms: why those who really desire the improvement of humanity, who are not seeking to prey upon it, but rather to help it bear a common burden and enjoy a common blessing in living, why they are not supporting each other on what mighjt be a common ground of sweet reasonableness, and wholesome tolerance; at least in a mood to avoid “hatred’' and ‘‘venom’’? for a sensible navy Senator Hale, who has been to a great deal of effort to acquaint him self with the affairs of the navy de clares his unalterable opposition to its further reduction except under "some binding agi*£ment with other nations that will not he to our detri ment,” adding that we should retain a navy sufficiently large to police the seas in any event. His efforts for better understand

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A satirical newspaper column comments on various news items of the day, including radio sets, Chinese communism, Philippine self-governance, and Prohibition enforcement. It mentions Bryan bringing his pastor to the Dayton courtroom and mocks Cole Blease and others opposed to evolution.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 6

Bryan brings along his pastor from Florida to pray for the heathen in the Dayton court. Possibly, too he has brought along a new brand of textbooks for the Tennessee schools. He also takes opportunity to tell the audience what a delightful climate Florida has. "Until the full power of the law has been used, its weak points strengthened, friends of the Eigh teenth Amendment will accept no ultimatum as to the possibility of en forcement”, declares Wayne B. Wheeler. Well, why should they? The seamen’s union of Australia have called a general strike of sail ors.

See moreSee less

It is to be hoped this will not prove to be contagious among the sailors of the visiting American fleet. There are no apprehensions that it will be. * Now Cole Blease of South Carolina rises to expound; another one of those who can’t bear to think they've evoluted and who would devolute the

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This roundup of news briefs mentions that a defense motion to quash the Scopes evolution indictment was denied at the Dayton trial. It also covers unrelated items like a Cardinal's health, a counterfeiting bust, and a yacht race.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 8

NEWS BRIEFS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The trial moved quickly with witnesses testifying for the state including school officials and students, followed by the defense calling Dr. Metcalf as their first witness. When evolution testimony was objected to, the jury was removed so attorneys could argue the admissibility of such scientific evidence.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 10

JURY BANISHED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The state rested its case after testimony from school board officials and introduction of the biology textbook and Bible as evidence. The defense called Dr. Metcalf, whose testimony on evolution prompted the jury's removal while attorneys argued over the admissibility of scientific evidence regarding evolutionary theory.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 10

JURY BANISHED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Dr. Metcalf distinguishes between the fact of evolution and various theories about it, describing a progression of life from inorganic matter through increasingly complex plant and animal forms. He estimates life began roughly 600,000,000 years ago and discusses the transition from marine to terrestrial life.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1925 · page 10

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Auttaja · Ironwood, Mich.

The article describes the massive media and public attention surrounding the Scopes 'monkey trial' in Dayton, Tennessee, noting crowded hotels, journalists, lawyers, and businessmen flocking to the small town. It questions why this case has attracted such outsized interest, suggesting newspapers and speakers like Bryan have exaggerated its stakes by framing it as a battle over Christianity's fate.

Auttaja · 16 July 1925 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Sauk Centre Herald · Sauk Centre, Minn.

A Congregational Church bulletin lists Sunday services and notes the pastor will speak on 'The State of Tennessee vs. Scopes,' addressing the real question involved and how it affects the congregation. The announcement is embedded among unrelated local ads and notices.

The Sauk Centre Herald · 16 July 1925 · page 5

THE CHURCHES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Farmers Independent · Bagley, Minn.

The twelve jurors to try John Scopes for teaching evolution have been chosen, with the first day focused on setting up the legal battle over admitting scientific testimony. Crowds of locals and about 150 journalists packed the courtroom to witness the proceedings.

Farmers Independent · 16 July 1925 · page 1

EVOLUTION CASE GETS START

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come