As the Papers Told It

The Lincoln Assassination · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Mysterious Prisoner

August – December 1865

A prisoner brought to Washington in irons was taken for John H. Surratt; one old friend swore he was, while others who knew Surratt said he was not the man. In November an order called in the claims for the rewards for Booth, Payne, Atzerodt, Herold and Davis, and revoked those offered for Thompson, Tucker, Sanders and Cleary and for Surratt. The Sewards told the story of the night of the attack themselves.

The mysterious prisoner is not Surratt

Three dispatches of 2 August disagree about a prisoner brought to Washington in irons. An old friend at Relay station says positively he is John H. Surratt; the Star reports he gives his name as John H. Ryan, a Confederate captain from Texas, held on a conspiracy charge, and that those who knew Surratt are sure he is not the man. Surratt’s reward was revoked in November.

The Weekly Pioneer and Democrat · Saint Paul, Minn. Territory

The Weekly Pioneer and Democrat · 11 August 1865 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

The Mysterious Prisoner. HE IS JOHN H. SURRATT.

BALTIMORE, August 2.—The person arrested in Texas recently, and supposed to be John H. Surratt, one of the assassins, passed Relay station this morning, en route for Washington heavily ironed and under guard. He was recognized at the station by a family acquaintance, and by an old friend, who was allowed to speak to the prisoner, and who says positively that the man in irons is John H. Surratt. The deposition of this person was at once taken and forwarded to Washington.

See moreSee less

He is not John H. Surratt.

WASHINGTON, August 2——The man brought hither from the west, who was supposed to be John H. Surratt, is said, in quarters where he was known, to be some other individual. His real name is thus far kept a secret.

Not Surratt, but Still One of the Conspirators.

WASHINGTON, August 2.—The Star says: "At twenty minutes past ten o'clock this morning, the train from Baltimore brought in the prisoner reported te be John H. Surratt, in charge of Captain Smith, of the 2d United States artillery, and Provost Marshal of Memphis, Tennessee, and under guard of a sergeant and three men of the 120th Illinois Regiment. He was heavily ironed, and on his arrival was escorted to a carriage and driven to the Provost Marshal's office, when Col. Ingraham ordered him to be committed to the Old Capitol prison. He was arrested in Memphis on the 19th by Capt. Smith, not on suspicion of being John H. Surratt, as has been intimated, but on a charge of having been engaged in the conspiracy, and it is said that the evidence against him is very conclusive. He gives his name as John H. Ryan, and states that he is from Texas, and has been a captain in the Confederate service He bears a singular resemblance to the Surratt family; but those who knew John H. Surratt when here are positive that this man is not him. The prisoner is dressed in gray, with a light colored slouch hat, and is about five feet seven inches in height; of rather slim and slender frame, with light or sandy hair; fair complexion, slightly freckled; light blue eyes; sharp nose, rather long; and has the knuckle of the little finger of the right hand shot off, apparently by a ball."

See the clipping

All the news at once, in Peru

An Indianapolis paper tells of a party landing at Callao, Peru, without a word of news since leaving New York. The first Yankee they met recited it all ‘as monotonous as if reading a washing list’: Richmond taken, Lee’s capitulation, Lincoln assassinated, Davis caught in his wife’s petticoats. General Wilson’s dispatch of May had passed on a report that Davis fled in one of her dresses.

Paper unidentified

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 8 September 1865 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

At Callao, Peru, the party were hungry for home intelligence. They had not heard a word since leaving New York, when Grant was still fighting it out on that line. Mr. Billings asked the first Yankee he met on the plank, "What is the news from the United States?" Slowly removing his cigar, he replied with genuine American nonchalance, reciting the stupendous events in a tone as monotonous as if reading a washing list: "Richmond is taken; Lee has capitulated; Johnson has surrendered; President Lincoln has been assassinated, and Jeff. Davis has been caught in his wife's petticoats!" One can hardly wonder that the listener stood speechless for five minutes at the startling catalogue.

See the clipping

Reward claims called in, five withdrawn

General Orders No. 164, dated 24 November, tells anyone claiming the rewards for Booth, Payne, Atzerodt, Herold or Jefferson Davis to file claims and proofs with the Adjutant General before 1 January, for a special commission to decide. It revokes the rewards for Thompson, Tucker, Sanders and Cleary, offered in the proclamation of 2 May, and for John H. Surratt, whose reported captures in May and August came to nothing.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 25 November 1865 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE REWARDS FOR THE CONSPIRATORS. ORDER OF THE PRESIDENT.

The following order was issued yesterday:

See moreSee less

War Department, Adjutant General's Office, Washington, November 24, 1865.

General Orders No. 164.—Ordered, That—

1. All persons claiming reward for the apprehension of John Wilkes Booth, Lewis Payne, G. A. Atzerodt, and David E. Herold, and Jefferson Davis, or either of them, are notified to file their claims and their proofs with the Adjutant General, for final adjudication by the special commission appointed to award and determine upon the validity of such claims, before the first day of January next, after which time no claims will be received.

2. The rewards offered for the arrest of Jacob Thompson, Beverly Tucker, George N. Saunders, William G. Cleary, and John H. Surratt are revoked.

By order of the President of the United States:

E. D. TOWNSEND, Assistant Adjutant General.

See the clipping

The Sewards recall the night of the attack

The London Spectator’s American correspondent, reprinted in Burlington, Vermont, gives the Sewards’ own memories. Frederick Seward, felled with a pistol butt, lay insensible two days or more; his father, in bed with a broken jaw, saw Payne’s handsome face, felt the knife as if rain were striking him, and later wrote on a tablet ‘Give me some more tea. I shall get well.’

Burlington Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Burlington Free Press · 15 December 1865 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Mr. Seward's Account of the Attack upon Him.

The American correspondent of the London Spectator writes that he recently heard Mr. Seward and Mr. Frederick Seward give the following account of their own sensations at the time of the attempted assassination:

See moreSee less

"Mr Frederick, Seward said that on stepping from his bedroom into the passage and seeing the assassin, he merely wondered what he was doing there, and called him to an account. On his resisting the fellow's endeavor to press him into Mr Seward's room, the assassin drew a revolver, which he presented at Mr. Frederick Seward's head. What followed, it must be remembered, took place in few seconds. Mr Frederick Seward's first thought was, 'That's a navy revolver.' The man pulled the trigger, but it only snapped, and his intended victim thought, 'That cap missed fire.

His next sensation was that of confusion, and being upon the floor, resting upon his right arm which, like his father's jaw, was barely recovered from a bad fracture—the assassin had felled him to the floor with the butt of the pistol—he put his hand to head, and finding a hole there, he thought, 'That cap did not miss fire after all.'

Tnen he became insensible, and remained so for two days or more. His first indication of returning consciousness was the question, 'Have you got the ball out ?' after which he fell off again into a comatose condition, which was of long continuance.

On the very afternoon of the day when Mr, Lincoln was assassinated, Mr Frederick Seward, who was Assistant Secretary of State, had asked his father when preparation should be made for the presentation of Sir Frederick Bruce, which was to take place the next day. Mr Seward gave him the points of a reply to be made to Sir Frederick, and he laid the outline of the speech upon the President's table, and, as I have previously informed my readers, Mr Lincoln that afternoon wrote out the reply, adopting Mr Seward's suggestions, and thus preparing that reception of the British Minister by President Johnson, which was regarded at the time by the people to whose representative it was addressed as so friendly and fair, and dignified.

Mr Frederick Seward's first inquiry after he came fully to his senses, which was a long time after the assassination, was, 'Has Sir Frederick Bruce been pressented ?' He thought that only one night had passed since he knew not what had happened to him, and his mind took up matters just where it had left him.

Mr Seward's mental experience during his supposed assassination was in its nature so like that of his son, that it raises the question whether this absence of consternation and observation of minute particulars is not common in circumstances of unexpected and not fully appreheeded peril. Mr Seward was lying upon his side, close to the edge of his bed, with his head resting in a frame, wdich had been made to give him ease and to protect his broken jaw from pressure.

He was trying to keep awake, having been seized upon by a sick man's fancy—it w s that if he slept he would wake up with lockjaw. He was brought to full consciousness by the scuffle in the passage way, followed by the entrance of the assassin, and the cry of Miss Sewa:d, Oh, he will kill my father.' But he saw nothing of his assailant until a hand appeared above his face, and then his thought was, 'What handsome cloth tha. overcoat is made of.' The assassin's face then appeared, and the helpless statesman only thought, 'What a handsome man !' (Payne was a fine looking fellow.)

Then came a sensation as of rain striking him smartly upon one side of his face and neck. then quickly upon the other side, but he felt no severe pain. This was the assassin's knife. The blood spouted, he thought, 'My time has come,' d falling from the bed to the floor, fai ted.— His first sensation of returning consciousness was that he was drinking tea, and that 'it tasted good.' Mrs. Seward was giving [h]im tea with spoon. He heard low voices around him, asking and replying as to whether it would be possible for him to recover. He could not speak, but his eyes showed his consciousness, and that he desired to speak. They brought him a porcelain tablet, on which he managed to write, 'Give me some more tea. I shall get well.' And from that moment he has slowly but steadily recovered health and strength."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: The Last of the Conspiracy