Reporters let into the conspiracy court
The Herald’s report of 13 May, the first day the military court admitted reporters. A detective describes a room at the Kirkwood House, where Vice President Johnson was staying, signed for as ‘E. A. Atzerott’: a loaded revolver under the pillow, bowie knives under the mattress, a Booth bank book in a coat. Weichman, a lodger at Mrs. Surratt's, says Dr. Mudd introduced him to Booth, which Mudd later admitted was true.
The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.
The New York Herald · 14 May 1865 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE TRIAL. The Court for the Trial of the Assassina'ion Conspirators Holds Open Sessions.
Names of the Members of the Court, the Counsel and the Accused. HE DEPORTMENT OF THE PRISONERS. General Harris Objects to Reverdy Johnson Acting as Counsel. His Regard for the Sanctity of an Oath Questioned.
See moreSee less
IMPORTANT EVIDENCE SUPPRESSED
Testimony of Detective Lee and Lewis A. Weichman. Atzerott's Quarters at the Kirk- wood House Described. Revolvers and Bowie Knives Found in His Chamber Under President Johnson's Room.
History of the Conspirators on Trial,
&c., &c., &c.
Washington, May 13, 1865.
The Court engaged in the trial of the assassination conspirators altered one of its rules to-day, so as to admit the reporters for the press.
THE COURT ROOM.
The court is held at the Old Penitentiary, in an upper room, with two windows at the east and two at the north. These windows are ironed with flat bars.
THE PRISONERS.
Along the wall, on the west side, on raised seats, were the prisoners, Dr. Mudd, David C. Harold, Lewis Payne, Edward Spangler, of Ford's theatre; Michael O'Laughlin, Atzerott and Samuel Arnold. Sitting outside the paling was Mrs. Surratt, leaning on a small green baize table.
THE COUNSEL FOR THE PRISONERS.
Beyond Mrs. Surratt, on the other side of the table, near the northern windows, sit the counsel for the accused, who are as follows:—Mr. Thomas Ewing, son of the Ohio ex-Senator; Attorney Stone, Mr. Walter S. Cox, Hon. Reverdy Johnson, and Messrs. Aiken and Clampett.
THE MEMBERS OF THE COURT.
Running east and west, beside the northern wall, is a long table, also covered with green bai[z]e. At this table sit the court. The following is the detail for the court:—
Major General David Hunter, U. S. V.
Major General Lewis Wallace, U. S. V.
Brevet Major General August V. Kautz, U. S. V.
Brigadier General Albion P. Howe, U. S. V.
Brigadier General Robert S. Foster, U. S. V.
Brevet Brigadier General James A. Ekin, U. S. V.
Brigadier General T. W. Harris, U. S. V.
Brevet Colonel C. H. Tompkins, U. S. A.
Lieut. Col. D. R. Clendinin, Eighth Illinois cavalry.
Brigadier General Joseph Holt, Judge Advocate.
APPEARANCE OF THE PRISONERS.
Dr. Mudd looked calm, collected and attentive, leaning on a table as if to relieve his wrists from the weight of the handcuffs that encumbered them.
Arnold was restless, raising his hands to his hair with a nervous twitching, and constantly varying the direction of his looks, now glancing from face to face, then bowing his head upon his hands, which he supported on his knees. His handcuffs were somewhat peculiar, not being connected, as usual, with a chain, but by a bar about eight inches in length.
Payne, dressed in a gray woollen shirt and dark pants, seemed more intent in trying to obtain a full view of the sunny landscape through the barred windows than of confining his attention to the details of the proceedings. As he looked, a strange, listless dreaminess pervaded his face. His dark hair, irregularly parted, hung over his face, and often clouded his dark blue eyes. His thick and somewhat protruding lips were as if glued together.
His legs were crossed, and his ironed hands rested upon his knees.
O'Laughlin was keenly observant of every move made in the court. He leaned back with his head against the wall, fully exposing his broad but not high forehead, crowned with a full bushy head of black hair. He has dark eyes and a pale, bloodless complexion, and wears a heavy mustache and wide imperial, both very black.
On his knees he rested his manacles, which, like those of
Arnold, were connected with an eight-inch iron bar.
Atzerott is a man of some five feet six inches in heighth, and had it not been for his manacles might have been taken for a mere spectator. He possesses a style of face most common in southern Germany. His hair and beard are of a reddish, sandy color. His eyes are light.
One police officer sat beside each prisoner.
Mrs. Surratt has already been correctly described. She is a stout, buxom widow, fitting Falstaff's ideal, "fair, fat and forty," though it is ascertained she is far beyond that period of life, having nearly reached her grand climacteric. She was dressed in black, and looked a little flushed; but we failed to notice that "cold, cruel gleam in her gray eyes," which some of the gentlemen of the press have attributed to them.
SUPPRESSED TESTIMONY.
The first testimony taken in the case of the several parties arraigned was a portion of that which the government deems it necessary, for the present, to withhold from the public.
OBJECTION TO REVERDY JOHNSON ACTING AS COUNSEL, ON ACCOUNT OF DISREGARD OF THE SANCTITY OF AN OATH.
When that testimony had all been rendered, Brigadier General T. W. HARRIS stated that he rose to object to the admission of Reverdy Johnson as counsel pleading before that court, and that he did this upon the ground that, in an opinion delivered by Mr. Johnson, that gentleman had expressed his disregard of the sanctity of an oath. General Harris then stated that he referred to the opinion expressed in a letter written by Mr. Johnson at the time of the Maryland Convention, held with reference to the adoption of the new constitution of that State.
Mr. JOHNSON replied—It is difficult to speak to that objection—to speak as I feel—without having that opinion before me. That opinion cannot be tortured by any reasonable man to any such conclusion. There is not a member of this court, either the President or the member who objects, that recognizes the obligation of an oath more absolutely than I do; and there is nothing in my life, from the commencement to the present time, which would induce me, for a moment, to avoid a comparison, in all moral respects, between myself and any member of this court. In this rebellion, which has broken down so many moral principles, it has been my pride to stand by the government, from the beginning to the present moment, and to take every obligation which the government thought it necessary to impose, and to do my duty faithfully in every department of public service as well as in my individual capacity. If such an objection was made in the Senate of the United States, where I am known, I forbear to say how it would be treated, because I it would be treated, because I know the terms in which it would be decided. I have lived too long, gone through too many trials, and rendered the country such services as my abilities enabled me and the votes of the people in whose midst I am living, for me particularly to tolerate for a moment, come from whom it may, such an aspersion on my moral character. I am glad it is made now, when I am arrived at that period of life when it would be unfit to notice it in any other way. But I repeat, there is not one word of truth in the construction which has been given to the opinion already referred to. I have it not by me, but I recollect substantially what it is. The convention called to form a new constitution for the State was called under the authority of an act of the Legislature of Maryland, and under that alone, by that Legislature their proceedings were to be submitted to the then legal voters of the State. The convention thought they were authorized themselves to impose, not only as an authority to vote what was not imposed by the existing constitution and laws, but that they had a right to admit to vote those who are prohibited from voting by such constitution and laws; and I said, in company with what the whole bar throughout the Union would have said, to that extent they had usurped the authority under which alone they were authorized to meet, and that so far their proceedings were a nullity. They had prescribed this oath, and all that opinion said, or was intended to say, was that to take that oath voluntarily was not a craven submission to usurped authority, but was necessary in order to enable the citizens to protect their rights under the then constitution, and that there was no moral harm in taking the oath which the convention had no authority to impose. I make it as no reflection upon any member of this court when I say that upon a question of that description I am at least able to form as correct an opinion as any gentleman around this table. I am here at the instance of that lady (pointing to Mrs. Surratt) whom I never saw or heard of till yesterday, she being a Maryland lady, protesting her innocence to me. I am also here because I deem it right, and due to the character of the profession to which I belong, and which is not inferior to that of which you are members—that she should not go undefended. I was to do it voluntarily, without compensation. The law prohibits me from receiving compensation, but if it had not, understanding her condition, I should never have dreamed of refusing upon the ground of her inability to make compensation. I am volunteering to do what evidence will justify me in doing for this lady who is now being tried for her life. My detestation of every one concerned in this nefarious plot, carried out with such fiendish malice, is as great as that of any member of this court. I am not here to protect any one after the evidence is heard and they are proved to be guilty—not even her. Will the honorable member of the court who has thought it proper or believed it his duty to make this objection, or the President, who said, if the honorable member had not made it, he should have done so—will they understand that I am not pleading here for anything personal to myself? I stand too firmly settled in my own convictions of honor and in my sense of duty, public and private, to be alarmed at all at any individual opinion that may be expressed here. I ask the court to decide, and I have no doubt they will decide as seems best to them, and if it shall be such a decision as the President of the court feels inclined to make I can take care of myself in the future.
Brigadier General HARRIS—I trust it is not necessary I should assure you, nor the gentleman to whom I feel it my duty to object as counsel before this court, that I should desire, above all things, not to do injustice to any man. Neither, I hope, need I assure you that in doing what I feel it my duty to do, I have not been influenced by any personal considerations. Though I never had the pleasure of the acquaintance of the gentleman to whom I object, I have known him long as an eminent public man of our country, of whom I must say that my impressions have been of a very favorable character. But in regard to the matter of the objection, if my recollection serves me right, I must contend it is well founded. It is due to the gentleman that I should say that I have made this objection simply from recollection of this letter, which I read perhaps nearly a year ago, and of the effects of that letter upon the vote of that State. Now, if I understand the remarks of that gentleman in explanation of this thing, I cannot say that they remove the difficulty from my mind at least. I understand him to say that the doctrine he had taught the people of his State was, that because the convention had framed and required the taking of an oath as a qualification to the right of suffrage which was unconstitutional and illegal in his opinion, that, therefore, it had no moral binding force, and that the people might take it and then go and vote without any regard to the subject matter of that oath. If that does not justify my conclusion I confess I am unable to understand the English language. Now, I wish the gentleman to understand me, that, in regard to his ability to decide a legal question, I do not intend to enter into any controversy. He remarked to the court, rather boastingly, that he was as well able as any member of this court to judge of any legal point. But this is not a point of law. It is a question of ethics, and of the morality of the thing, of the sanctity of an oath voluntarily taken, which I understand he taught his people might be set aside as having no force because the convention had transcended its authority and done something it had no right to do, and consequently they might voluntarily take this oath to entitle them to go and vote without considering it to have any binding force. And I am much mistaken in the history of those days, and in the effect of that opinion upon the vote of that State, if it was not so considered. A large number cast their suffrages under that ethical doctrine taught to them by the gentleman against whom I have objected. But, as I was about to remark, I would be sorry to do injustice to the gentleman, or any other man, and having made my objection simply from my recollection of this letter, it is perhaps due to the gentleman and the members of this court that the letter itself should be submitted to the scrutiny of the court. I may be wrong; if so, none can be more ready than myself to acknowledge that fact.
Mr. Johnson--I do not intend to make an extended reply to the gentleman's remarks. As to my boasting about my competency to decide any legal question, the gentleman is mistaken. I said, as competent as any of the members of this court, they not being lawyers. Now, the honorable member seems to suppose, because I said there was no harm in taking an oath, that I meant there would be no harm in breaking it if it were taken. If that is the meaning of the terms I am better informed in regard to it than I ever was before. I have already said to the court that I had no idea of using them for any such purpose; that, according to my interpretation of them, they admitted of no such construction. When a gentleman is dealing with gentlemen, even if the words used were liable to misrepresentation, the explanation of the intended meaning of them is held to be sufficient. I submit that among gentlemen—and I hope I am not boasting when I say that in that capacity I consider myself equal to any of the members of this court—I repeat, when, as a gentleman, I say they were not used for any such design as is imputed to them, the gentleman to whom the explanation is given will not be disposed to repeat that they were, in point of fact, with that design. Now, as to the effect upon the people of Maryland, I don't know where the honorable member is from, but he is not a citizen of our State, I suppose.
General Harris—I am a citizen of West Virginia.
Mr. Johnson—I supposed you were not a citizen of Maryland. I was about to say whoever supposes—and I hope the honorable member will send for the letter—that the people of Maryland can be induced by an individual opinion to take an oath in order to violate it is under a very great misapprehension. We have had, what I regret very much, hundreds and hundreds of our citizens leave our borders and participate in this rebellion; but hundreds and hundreds also of those who remained have proved true to their flag, and have evinced their loyalty upon the battle field with their blood and with their lives, and in the relation in which I stand to the people of Maryland I may be permitted to say are the equals, morally and patriotically, of the people of Western Virginia. There were other topics involved in the constitution which influenced the votes of those who voted against it, to which it is unnecessary and useless here to refer. But I deny, and deny implicitly, that there was a single man who voted because of that opinion, and took the oath with a view to vote, intending, therefore, to violate the obligation. But, as a legal question, it is something new to me that the objection made, if well founded in fact, is well founded in law. Are the members of this court to measure the moral character of every counsel who may appear before them? Is that their function? What influence has that upon the court by which their judgment could be led astray? My client may suffer from the possible prejudice it may create in the minds of the court, but how can the court suffer? Who gives to the court the jurisdiction to decide upon the moral character of counsel who may appear before them? Who makes them the arbiters of public morality or of my professional morality? What authority have they under their commission to rule me out, or any other counsel out, upon the ground that he does not recognize the validity of an oath, even if they believed that this was so? But I put myself upon no such grounds. I claim in all moral and honorable respects to be the equal of any member of this tribunal. They may dispose of the question as they please, it will not touch me.
General HARRIS—The Court understands there is no intention to cast any reflection upon the people of Maryland, in regard to their loyalty or morality, or in regard to their patriotism. I am proud to say they have a good record in this great contest through which our country has just passed. While it is true of Maryland, I am sorry to say it is equally true of my State that many joined the rebellion and have made for themselves a terrible record.
But the circumstances of this case were rather peculiar.
The people of Maryland were about to vote upon an alteration in the fundamental law of the State, upon the adoption of a new constitution—a constitution which made some radical changes in regard to the social state of the people of Maryland. Slavery was about to be blotted out. That was the purpose, and it is an unfortunate fact that that portion of the people interested in the proposed change were, as a general thing, the disloyal portion; and it was in reference to the effect which this opinion expressed by the honorable gentleman in the letter referred to, had upon that vote, and upon the action of this portion of the people, that my objection was in part founded; for it did not seem that they understood as I did. In regard to the right of the court to inquire into the moral standing of counsel we have no such right. But the order constituting this court makes provision for the prisoners or the accused having counsel. One of the provisions in reference to that matter, is that the gentlemen shall exhibit a certificate of having taken the oath, or shall take it in the presence of the court, and thus the obligation of the oath is here a special question if it does appear that he ignores the moral obligation, and we admit him, it defeats the very provision of the order. Hence I think it proper in me, as a member of the court, to found an objection of that character upon such grounds. Whether the objection is well founded or not, however, the gentleman disclaims any such intention. But that is a tacit admission that the language of the latter may have been unguarded; that it had the effect supposed, though it was not in accordance with the intention of his mind in writing. It is an unfortunate thing if he wrote a letter so misconstrued. But if it was not the intention of the writer, that, of course, must exonerate. He disavows having any such intention, and claims for himself a moral character which he is not ashamed to put in comparison with that of any member of the Court. Now it is not my purpose to measure characters at all, but simply to bring forward an objection, which I felt it my duty to bring, and nothing else—an objection founded on the understanding I had of the letter referred to. I was sorry to have to do it.
But I did it in no spirit of personal ill will or bad feeling.
I was sorry that it was my duty to do such a thing; but
I could not do anything else with the impression I had on my mind, and he as an honorable gentleman will understand what I mean by this. He understands, too, what the force of convictions must be, and that if a man errs from principle this thing will occasionally impose upon him some unpleasant duties.
His disavowal of any such intention, as I derived from memory of his letter, I am bound to take, but this I must insist upon, that there was some ground for the objection.
Mr. Johnson—Mr. President, one word more. All I
propose to say is the order confers no authority to refuse me admission on the grounds claimed by the honorable member, because you have no authority to administer the oath to me. I have taken it in the Senate of the United
States, in the Circuit Court of my State, in the
Supreme Court of the United States, and I am a practitioner in all the courts in nearly all the States and it would be a little singular if one who has the right to appear before the Supreme Court of the land, and who belongs to the body that creates courts martial—
Major General Hunter—Mr. Johnson has made an intimation as to holding members of this court personally responsible. Mr. Johnson—I made no such intimation, nor did I
intend to. Major General HUNTER--I shall say no more than I was going to say--that I hoped the day had passed when freemen from the North were to be bullied and insulted by the humbug chivalry of the South.
The court here took a recess for half an hour, and when it returned went into secret session, in order to deliberate upon the subject so lengthily discussed.
The court being reopened, General HARRIS stated that he desired to withdraw his objection, as he considered Mr. Johnson's explanation a satisfactory removal of the ground on which the objection was founded.
Mr. JOHNSON expressed his willingness and desire to take the oath, but the court decided it unnecessary, and the oath was not taken.
During the discussion the detonation and screeching of shells fired in practice punctuated the arguments of the learned counsel and his courteous opponent.
TESTIMONY OF DETECTIVE LEE--ATZEROTT'S ROOM IN THE KIRKWOOD HOUSE.
A. W. LEE, being duly sworn, testified as follows:-- Q. Do you belong to the the police force? A. Yes, sir; to the military police.
Q. State whether, at any time, you examined the room of Atzerott at the Kirkwood House. A. Yes, sir. I was ordered by Major O'Beirne to go into the principal part of the building, and see how the house was situated. I made examination, and told him that one could get from the roof to a stairway in the back of the building, which would admit him into any part of the building. I told the Major the circumstances.
Q. When was that? A. (Here the witness looked at a paper.) It was the night of the 15th of April; I then went, and while there a friend came to me and said there was a rather suspicious looking person who had taken a room the day previous, and I had better go and look. I went, and found in the register, badly written, the name of "E. A. Atzerott." I made it out; but in fact nobody could make it out until I asked the proprietor, and he made it out on the register.
Q. Where did you go to after that? A. I went up stairs to a room and saw one of the clerks, and asked him to go up to the room with me; found the door locked, and he said the party had taken the key with him; I went to one of the proprietors and asked if he had any objection to my going into the room if we could find a key to fit it; he said no; but though we tried his keys, we could not get in; I asked him if we might burst in the door; he said he had no objection; and we burst the door open. When I went in I saw a coat hanging on the wall.
Colonel Burnett here ordered a bundle to be passed to the witness. This bundle, on being opened by the colonel, was found to be a coat, enrolled in which were sundry small articles. WITNESS—That coat was hanging upon the wall, just in that way, as you go in on the left hand side. That's the coat, sir.
Q. State what examination you made of the room. A. Well, I saw that coat right opposite; the bed stood in the right; I went towards the bed, and underneath a pillow or bolster found a revolver bound with brass.
Here the pistol was shown to the witness, and it also passed through the hands of Mr. Johnson, who remarked, "It is loaded." WITNESS (continuing)—I then went down stairs to find Major O'Beirne, and we went up stairs to the room again; I took the coat down and found this book, and that also.
Q. In the pockets? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you look inside that book and see what was written? A. Yes, sir; there was an account on the Ontario Bank for $455; I then put my hand in the pocket again and found this handkerchief, with "Mary R. Booth" on it; I then pulled out this other handkerchief, and had some difficulty in making out the mark, but I think it is "F. A. Nelson," or "F. E. Nelson;" I found this handkerchief, with "M. H." on the corner; I got this new pair of gauntlets; I labelled all the things myself, and got these three boxes of Colt's cartridges.
Q. Do they fit the pistol? A. I never loaded the pistol, sir; I don't know. I found this piece of liquorice and this brush.
Q. This writing was in the back of that book, "Mr. J. Wilkes Booth, in account with the Bank of Ontario, $450?" A. Yes, sir. I then got that spur and a pair of socks. That is all I got out of the pockets.
Q. Do you remember the number of the room. A. It was room No. 126, sir.
Q. Was it over where Vice President Johnson was at that time?
The witness here entered into an explanation of the locality, totally unintelligible, but upon being shown the plan or sketch by Mr. Ben Pittman, seemed to recognize the situation of the room. This plan, however, was not admitted in defence.
Witness--I went around the room, took up the carpets, took out the washstand, the stove, and made a thorough search, and then went to the bed again, took off the clothes piece by piece, and after I came down underneath the sheets and mattresses I got those bowie knives.
Here a knife was shown the witness, and handed to the various members of the court. It was a long, stylus-shaped, like that used by Booth, horn handled and sheathed in red leather.
Q. You did not see him in the room yourself? A. No, sir. He had left it the day before; the clerk who was there said he would recognize the man. JUDGE ADVOCATE—Go and get him, after you have been examined, with or without a subpœna. Bring him as soon as you can.
[Here the examination in chief, which had been conducted by Judge Holt, was closed.]
CROSS-EXAMINATION OF DETECTIVE LEE.
Q. What is your business? A. Detective officer of the Board of Enrolment of the District of Columbia, of which Major O'Beirne is Provost Marshal.
Q. How long have you followed the business? A. I have been in the service ever since I left New York, at the commencement of the war; I was in the Ninety-fifth New York Volunteers.
Q. How long have you been a detective in Washington? A. Ever since the burning of Aquia Creek; I had been discharged as a volunteer from the Ninety-fifth New York.
Q. You mentioned a conversation with some one in reference to a suspicious character at the Kirkwood House; where did you first see the man who told you his name? A. I first saw him in the house.
Q. Was he a clerk? A. A night watchman, I think.
Q. What was his precise language to you? A. He said to me there was a suspicious, bad, villanous looking fellow came into the house and took a room. He didn't like the appearance of him.
Q. When was it that the person had come and taken a room? A. I think it was the day before. Q. Can you say for certain? A. No, sir; I would not be positive; I think to the best of my knowledge it was the day before. Q. Did he describe his appearance? A. Yes, sir, he did.
Q. Repeat his description. A. I don't think I could as he described it to me; I don't recollect; I think he said he had a gray coat on.
Q. Have you ever seen to your knowledge Mr. Atzerot? A. I don't know that I ever have seen him; I have seen most everybody knocking around about Washington; I don't know as I ever saw him to know him by name; can't say that I have or have not.
Q. What first brought you to the Kirkwood House? A. I was at home eating my supper. Mr. Cunningham came after me, one of our force; no, I had gone out after supper, and met him a square from the house. Says he, "You are wanted immediately at the Kirkwood House." I went, and there was Major O'Beirne. I found men all about there, detailed for duty to protect the President, or at that time the Vice President.
Q. Describe the appearance of the man who gave you the information. A. The man was about your build; he may be a little heavier, but about your height.
Q. How old does he look to be? A. Somewhere about your age.
Q. What is my age? A. I take you to be about thirty.
Q. Don't you know his name? A. No, sir, I don't.
Q. Now, will you describe the relative position of Johnson's room and the room in which you found this coat?
The witness here entered into a series of gesticulations and explanations, from which neither court, counsel nor reporters could derive any understanding of his meaning or of the locality he sought to describe.
Q. Did you find any signature of Atzerott in any room? A. I did not.
Q. What made you think it was his room? A. Because it said so on the register; it was number 126.
Q. You have no other evidence except the register? A. No, sir; I do not know as I have other evidence.
THE TESTIMONY OF LEWIS A. WEIOHMAN—THE SURRATT FAMILY.
Q. State to the court if you know John H. Surratt. A. I do. I first made his acquaintance in the fall of 1862, at Charles county, Maryland; or in the fall of 1859, I should say.
Q. How long were you together there? A. Until 1862. I renewed my acquaintance with him in January, 1863.
Q. In this city? A. Yes.
Q. When did you begin to board at the house of his mother, the prisoner there? A. On the 18th of November, 1864.
Q. Where is her house? A. On H street, No. 541.
Q. See if that is Mrs. Surratt sitting by you there? A. Yes, sir, that is Mrs. Surratt.
Q. Will you state when you first made your acquaintance with Dr. Mudd? A. It was on or about the 15th of January, 1865.
Q. State under what circumstances. A. I was passing down Seventh street with Surratt, and when nearly opposite Odd Fellows' Hall some one called out "Surratt; Surratt." On looking around Surratt recognized an old acquaintance of his of Charles county, Md. He introduced Dr. Mudd, and Dr. Mudd introduced Mr. Booth, who was in company with him, to both of us. They were coming up Seventh street, and we were going down.
Q. (By the court). Do you mean J. Wilkes Booth? A. Yes, sir; J. Wilkes Booth.
Q. Where did you go to then? A. He invited us to his room at the National Hotel.
Q. Who? A. Booth; he told us to be seated, and ordered cigars and wine to the room for four, and Dr. Mudd then went out to the passage and called Booth in and had a private conversation with him; Booth and the Doctor then came in and called Surratt out, leaving me alone.
Q. How long? A. Fifteen or twenty minutes.
Q. Do you know the nature of their conversation? A. No; I was sitting on a lounge near the window; they came in at last, and Mudd came near me on the settee and apologized for his private conversation, stating that he had private business with Booth, who wished to purchase his farm. Q. Did you see any maps of any sort on the table? A. No; Booth at one time cut the back of an envelope and made marks on it with a pencil.
Q. Was he writing on it? A. I should not consider it writing, but marks alone. They were seated at a table in the centre of the room.
Q.—Did you see the marks? A.—No, sir; just saw the motion of the pencil; Booth also came to me and apologized, and said he wished to purchase Mudd's farm; Mudd had previously stated to me that he did not care to sell his farm to Booth, as he was not willing to give him enough for it.
Q. You did not hear a word spoken between them in regard to the farm? A. No, sir; I did not know the nature of their conversation at all.
Q. Did I understand you to say you did not hear any of their conversation at all, but only saw the motion of the pencil? A. Yes, Sir.
Q. You continued to board at Mr. Surratt's? A. I boarded there up to the time of the assassination.
Q. After this interview at the National Hotel state whether Booth called frequently at Mr. Surratt's? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Whom did he call to see? A. He generally called to see John H. Surratt, and, in his absence, called for Mrs. Surratt. Q. Were those interviews held apart or in the presence of other persons? A. Always apart; I have been in company with Booth in the parlor with Surratt, but Booth has taken Surratt to his room up stairs and engaged in private conversation up there; he would say, "John, can you spare me a word? come up stairs;" they would go and engage in private conversation, which would last two or three hours.
Q. Did the same thing ever occur with Mrs. Surratt? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you ever seen the prisoner Atzerot? A. I have, sir.
Q. Do you recognize him here? A. Yes, sir; that is he.
Q. Have you ever seen him at Mrs. Surratts? A. He came there three weeks after I formed the acquaintance of Booth.
Q. Who did you inquire for? A. For Mr. Surratt--John H.
Q. Did you ever see him with Booth, or only with Surratt? A. I have never seen him in the house with Booth.
Q. How often did he call? A. Some ten or fifteen times.
Q. What was the name by which he was known by the young ladies of the house? A. They understood he came from Port Tobacco, and instead of calling him by his own name, they gave him the nickname of "Port Tobacco." Q. Did you ever see him on the street? A. Yes, sir; I have met him on the corner of Seventh street and Pennsylvania avenue. It was about the time that Booth played Pescara, in the Apostate. Booth had given Surratt two complimentary tickets on that occasion, and they went down and met Atzarott. We told him where we were going, and he said he was going along, too, and at the theatre we met David C. Harold.
Q. Do you know Harold? A. Yes, sir. (Here Harold leaned forward, and, laughing, inclined towards the witness.) We also met another gentleman there, named Hollohan, who stopped in the house; we met him in the theatre, and we remained until the play was over, and the five of us went together as far as the corner of Tenth and E streets; but on turning around Surratt noticed that Atzerot and Harold were not following, and I went and found them in the restaurant adjoining the theatre, talking confidentially with Booth; on my approaching they separated, and then we took a drink; and there was a gentleman there whose face I remember; we left and joined the other two gentlemen, and went to another restaurant to have some oysters.
Q. Do you know where Surratt kept his horses in the city. A. He stated to me that he had two horses, and that he kept them at Howard's stable, on G, Sixth and Seventh streets.
Q. Did you ever see Atzerott there? A. Yes, sir; on the day of the assassination. Q. What time was it? A. About half-past two o'clock.
Q. What was he doing? A. He seemed to be hiring a horse; I had been sent by Mrs. Surratt to hire a buggy; when I got there I saw Atzerott, and asked him what he wanted; he said "to hire a horse;" he asked Booth if he could have a horse, and he told him he could not; then we left, and both went as far as the Post Office; I had a letter to draw, and after that he went off towards Tenth street.
Q. Was this horse that was kept there Surratt's or Booth's? A. I will state that on Tuesday previous to the assassination I was also sent to the National Hotel, and to get his buggy for Mrs. Surratt. She wished me to drive her into the country.
Booth said he had sold his buggy, but he would give me $10, and that I should hire a buggy for Mrs. Surratt, and spoke of horses he kept at Brooks' stable. I then said they were mine.
Q. Did Booth give you ten dollars? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you drive him out? A. Yes, sir
Q. To what point? A. To Surrattsville. We left at ten o'clock and reached there at twelve. That was on Tuesday—on the 11th.
Q. Did you return that day? A. Yes, sir; we only remained half an hour; Mrs. Surratt said she went for the purpose of seeing Mr. Nothwy, who owed her money.
The clerk of the Kirkwood House, and the present proprietor of the house heretofore occupied by the Surratt family and others, were examined with reference to this house, and in relation to arms having been deposited there in order to facilitate the escape of the assassins.
The court was in session until a late hour.
Sketches of the Conspirators on Trial.
[From the Washington Evening Star, May 12.]
The prisoners now on trial on charge of being concerned in the assassination conspiracy are David E. Harold, George E. Atzerott, Lewis Payne, Michael O'Laughlin, Edward Spangler, Samuel Arnold, Mary E. Surratt and Samuel E. Mudd. We have already given the antecedents of some of these parties, and as there is a general interest to know all concerning them we append the following further particulars:—
MRS. SURRATT.
Mrs. Mary E. Surratt was raised near Waterloo, on Calvert's manor, in Prince George's county, Maryland. Her father died when she was quite young. As she grew up she displayed considerable force of character, and expressed a desire to have a better education than was obtainable in her neighborhood, and she was sent to a female seminary in Alexandria.
Returning to her mother's home, she became an acknowledged belle in Prince George's county, and quite as noted for her strong will, she seldom failing in anything she undertook. She married Surratt about the year 1835, and the couple first settled at a place known as Condin's Mill, near Camp Stoneman (Giesboro), which property Surratt inherited from an uncle named Neal. After they had lived here a few years the house was set on fire by their slaves, who seemed to have been infuriated by some cruelty to which they were subjected through the imperious will of Mrs. Surratt. The Surratts barely escaped from the fire with their lives.
Surratt afterwards engaged on the Orange and Alexandria Railroad as a contractor, and on finishing his work returned to Prince George's county and bought a farm, on which he established the tavern known as "Surratt's," and afterwards was appointed postmaster at that point, but he being an uneducated man, the duties of the office devolved upon his wife.
They had three children—a daughter and two sons. One of the latter (Isaac) went South at the outbreak of the rebellion, entering the Southern army, it is said. The other son (John) stayed about home, spending his time in idleness or worse. The father was known as a pro-slavery man, and a sympathizer with the South in the rebellion to some extent, but was not looked upon as an open secessionist. He was an inoffensive, good-tempered man, and was generally esteemed in his neighborhood. He died very suddenly about three years since, and soon afterwards his widow leased the property and came to this city, where she opened a boarding house on H street, which house has since become notorious as the scene where was concocted some of the most stupendous deviltry of the world's history. "Surratt's" (house and farm) is situated on the mail route from Washington to Leonardtown, Md., and is twelve miles from Washington Post office, at the junction of the Marlborough and Piscataway roads. The house is a comfortable two story double frame building, containing nine rooms, and on the front and one side are porticoes for the visitors to enjoy the fresh air during the sultry seasons. The farm is well adapted for gardening purposes, and, though not very extensive, is profitable for wheat and tobacco.
Mrs. Surratt has maintained a confident, stoical air until yesterday, when, in an interview with counsel, it is said she seemed very contrite.
LLOYD.
John M. Lloyd, the party to whom Mrs. Surratt leased the premises, came originally from Port Tobacco, Md., we believe. He is well known in this city as one of what was known as the "Berret Police," of which force but seven declared themselves in favor of the Union.
Since the rebellion we had lost sight of Lloyd until his late arrest. Last year he leased the Surratt house at a rent of five hundred dollars per annum, and continued to keep up the old tavern. Lloyd was arrested after the assassination and taken to Bryantown and delivered to Provost Marshal Wells.
When the officers were on the trail of Booth and Harold, one of them who knew Lloyd saw him under arrest, and remarked to him, "You have got yourself into a nice scrape." Lloyd replied, "Yes, I don't know how I did it," and proceeded to tell that some time ago two carbines and some pistols were left at the house. The Friday before the assassination Mrs. Surratt came to the house and told him to have the carbines and pistols ready, as two gentlemen would call for them. The night of the assassination Booth and Harold rode up to the door. Harold dismounted and went in and took a carbine and the pistols. Booth would not take his carbine on account of his lame ankle. They took something to drink and rode off.
A romancing correspondent of a New York paper states that "Surrattsville," as he terms it, contains nine or ten dwellings. The fact is that there are no dwellings there but those belonging to the tavern premises proper--the house, stable, barn, &c.
O'LAUGHLIN.
Michael O'Laughlin is a young man of twenty-five or thereabouts. In size and some other particulars he resembles Booth, with glossy black hair and black mustache, and rather gentlemanly appearance. He hails from Baltimore. O'Lau[g]h[l]in was the first person confined on the monitor. He was brought from Baltimore, where it is said he surrendered himself to the military authorities.
ATZEROTT.
George A. Atzerott is short, thick-set, round-shouldered, of ruddy complexion, with brown hair, light colored mustache and goatee, aged about thirty-three, and is a blacksmith by trade. He was born in Germany, but raised, we learn, in Charles county, Md., where he has spent most of his life. His character has stood none of the best heretofore, and for some years he had been living with a woman not his wife near Port Tobacco, by which woman he has one child. For some months previous to the assassination he had been missing from Port Tobacco, and it is believed he had been engaged in blockade running and other traitorous practices.
SPANGLER.
Edward Spangler is a rough looking, ordinary sized man, of about forty years of age, hails from Baltimore, and has for some two years past been employed as an assistant to Gifford, the stage carpenter at Ford's theatre, he having worked with Gifford at house carpentering for many years in Baltimore. Spangler came originally from some interior town in Pennsylvania, but, we believe, learned his trade in Baltimore, where he was married. His wife died some years ago in Baltimore, since which time he has been of intemperate habits, and it is said that he appeared to be considerably under the influence of liquor on the morning of the day of the assassination.
He was the subject frequently of practical jokes by his companions behind the scenes, and in this connection an incident is mentioned that in the eyes of the superstitious might be deemed to have an ominous meaning. During the winter of 1864-65, when some new scenery was being prepared, the painters were in the habit of displaying the names of different employes of the establishment upon the backs of the various slips. Spangler remarked that his name had been neglected, when one of the painters, as a joke at his expense, hauled out a piece of scenery designed to figure in connection with a prison yard, and which bore a representation of a gallows. Upon this scene he dashed with a few broad strokes of his brush the name of Edward Spangler.
Spangler, it will be remembered, was the man who had charge of Booth's horse in the rear of the theatre, but who turned the animal over to "Peanut John" before Booth made his exit from the theatre. It is supposed that he may know something of the bar of wood fitted to the door in the rear of the stage box; and also that he had something to do with keeping a path clear for Booth behind the scenes, and with affording ready means of exit through the rear door. The bar above mentioned served as a brace to keep the audience from entering the box while Booth was accomplishing his work, and the job of fitting it accurately to the position required was one in which Booth would need the aid almost certainly of some one connected with the establishment, and naturally one in the carpenter's department.
Of some other employes at Ford's, now in durance, the following may be of interest:—
GIFFORD.
James Gifford, stage carpenter, is a large, square built man, approaching fifty years of age, with dark brown hair, smooth face, and is by trade a carpenter. He formerly was a house carpenter and builder in Baltimore and vicinity, and as such built the house of Booth's father, near Baltimore, it is said. Several years since he engaged as stage carpenter at Holliday street theatre in Baltimore, and has followed that business since. He was of an unpleasant temper, and not generally liked by those under him. He has a fine family living in Baltimore. On the establishment of Ford's theatre here he came to this city and superintended the work of altering the old Baptist church into a theatre, and has been employed there ever since, and superintended the rebuilding of the theatre after it was burnt. He is not a very loquacious man, but his sympathies are known to have been with the South throughout the war.
MADDOX.
James Maddox is a young man well known about Washington. He was born at or near Dumfries, Va.; is twenty-six years of age, and has lived many years in the lower portion of the second ward. For a long time he was an active member of the Franklin Fire Company. He is about five feet six inches in height, round and compactly built, light hair and blue eyes, with a ruddy complexion. He went to school at Henshaw's public school, and after leaving it learned the saddle and harness making business; but has been employed about the theatres for about ten years. He was first at the National, then at the Washington, and for a short time was at Holliday street, Baltimore; but since Ford's theatre has been in operation he has been constantly employed as the property man there. He was married about two years ago to one of the actresses of Ford's company, known on the bills as Maggie Burns. He has always been regarded as a worthy young man, his only fault being that he would get drunk occasionally, and he was looked upon as soundly loyal.
ARNOLD.
Sam Arnold was arrested at Fortress Monroe. He was a Baltimorean, and had been for a short time at Fortress Monroe as chief clerk and cashier of the sutlery establishment of J. W. Wharton.
PAYNE.
Of Lewis Payne little is known as yet. He was apparently a hired assassin, despatched from Canada to do a job of bloody work. He is said to be an outlaw from Kentucky originally, and to have been concerned in the St. Albans robbery and other schemes of deviltry concocted in Canada.
THE GARRETTS.
The two Garretts, who are out on parole, prove to have been entirely unaware as to who Booth and Harold really were while at their house
DURATION OF THE TRIAL.
It is estimated that the trial will last nearly two months, as there are two or three hundred witnesses to examine.