As the Papers Told It

The Lincoln Assassination · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

The Last of the Conspiracy

7–31 July 1865

Herold, Atzerodt, Payne and Mrs. Surratt were sentenced to hang on 7 July; Mudd, Arnold and O’Laughlin got life at hard labor and Spangler six years. Judge Wylie’s writ of habeas corpus for Mrs. Surratt was suspended by the President, and the four were hanged that day. Within weeks the papers were arguing over her guilt, and Booth’s neck bones were on show at the Army Medical Museum.

Four to hang, four to prison

The New-York Tribune of 7 July prints the military commission’s findings: Herold, Atzerodt, Payne and Mrs. Surratt to hang that day between 10 and 2 o’clock; Dr. Mudd, Arnold and O’Laughlin to hard labor for life; Spangler to six years. Told the news, Mrs. Surratt begged four days more to prepare. Many in Washington, the Tribune says, wondered that Spangler was not sentenced to death.

New-York Daily Tribune · New-York, N.Y.

New-York Daily Tribune · 7 July 1865 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE ASSASSINATION. risoners Fou Payne, Harrold, Atzerodt and Mrs. Surratt to be Hanged To-Day.

Dr. Mudd, Arnold and O'Laughlin to be Imprisoned for Life.

See moreSee less

Spangler to be Confined Six Years.

How the Assassins Received the News.

Mrs. Surratt Begs for More Time.

PUBLIC OPINION IN WASHINGTON

Special Dispatch to The N. Y. Tribune.

WASHINGTON, Thursday, July 6, 1865.

The published announcements in the evening papers of the hanging of four of the conspirators to-morrow created quite a sensation in town, although every loyal man expressed himself satisfied with the verdict approved by the President.

It was known for several days that the findings were in the hands of the President, but no one anticipated a decision for some time to come, and the promptitude with which he has acted is universally commended.

Many wonder that Spangler was not included among those to suffer the death penalty, and believe him equally culpable with Atzerodt and Harrold.

Preparations for the executions are going forward rapidly, and Gen. Hancock is overwhelmed with applications for admission to the penitentiary grounds. Notwithstanding the request of Mrs. Surratt for additional time, it is not believed that her execution will be postponed.

There is a universal feeling of satisfaction here that these abhorred assassins are to meet with such a swift and terrible retribution.

To the Associated Press.

WASHINGTON, Thursday, July 6, 1865.

Major-General Hancock repaired to the Arsenal at noon to-day and delivered the death warrants of Payne, Harrold, Mrs. Surratt and Atzerodt to Maj.-Gen. Hartranft, who is in charge of the prisoners, when they together visited the condemned to inform them of the sentences pronounced and the time fixed for their execution.

Payne was the first to whom the intelligence was communicated. It did not seem to take him by surprise, as doubtless he anticipated no other sentence and had nerved himself accordingly. The other prisoners were naturally more or less affected. Mrs. Surratt particularly sank under the dread announcement and pleaded for four days additional time to prepare herself for death.

All the prisoners will be attended by clergymen of their own designation. The scaffold has been erected in the south yard of the old Penitentiary building, which is enclosed by a high brick wall. The coffins and burial clothes have already been prepared. Only a limited number of persons will be admitted to the scene. The sentences of the conspirators who are to be imprisoned will be carried into immediate effect.

The Finding of the Court.

WASHINGTON, Thursday, July 6, 1865.

The following important order has just been issued: WAR DEPARTMENT, ADJUTANT GENERAL'S OFFICE, } WASHINGTON, July 5, 1865. } To Major-Gen. W. S. HANCOCK, U. S. Volunteers, commanding Middle Military Division, Washington, D. C.:

Whereas, By the Military Commission appointed in paragraph 4, Special Orders No. 211, dated War Department, Adjutant-General's Office, May 6, 1865, and of which Major-Gen. David Hunter, United States Volunteers, is President, the following persons were tried and sentenced as hereinafter stated as follows: First—David E. Harrold. Finding—Of the specification "Guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler, as to which part thereof "Not Guilty." Of the charge "Guilty," except the words of the charge that "he combined, confederated and conspired with Edward Spangler," as to which part of the charge "Not Guilty."

Sentence.—And the Commission therefore sentence him, the said David E. Harrold, to be hanged by the neck until he be dead, at such time and place as the President of the United States shall direct, two-thirds of the members of the Commission concurring therein.

Second—George A. Atzerodt.

Finding.—Of the specification "Guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this, "Not Guilty."

Sentence—And the Commission does therefore sentence him, the said George A. Atzerodt, to be hanged by the neck until he be dead, at such time and place as the President of the United States shall direct, two-thirds of the members of the Commission concurring therein.

Third—Lewis Payne.

Finding—Of the specification "Guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this not guilty. Of the charge "Not Guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this not guilty.

Sentence—And the Commission does, therefore, sentence him, the said Lewis Payne, to be hanged until he be dead, at such time and place as the President of the United States shall direct; two-thirds of the members of the Commission concurring therein.

Fourth—Mary E. Surratt.

Finding—Of the specification "Guilty," except as to the receiving, entertaining, harboring and concealing Samuel Arnold and Michael O'Laughlin, and, except as to combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this not guilty. Of the charge "Guilty," except as to combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this not guilty.

Sentence—And the Commission does therefore sentence her, the said Mary E. Surratt, to be hanged by the neck until she be dead, at such time and place as the President of the United States shall direct, two-thirds of the members of the Commission concurring therein; and

Whereas, The President of the United States has approved the foregoing sentences in the following order, to wit:

EXECUTIVE MANSION, July 5, 1865.

The foregoing sentences, in the cases of David E. Harold, George A. Atzerodt, Lewis Payne and Mary E. Surratt, are hereby approved; and it is ordered that the sentences in the cases of David E. Harold, G. A. Atzerodt, Lewis Payne and Mary E. Surratt, be carried into execution by the proper military authority, under the direction of the Secretary of War, on the 7th day of July, 1865, between the hours of 10 o'clock a. m. and 2 o'clock p. m. of that day.

ANDREW JOHNSON, President.

Therefore, You are hereby commanded to cause the foregoing sentences in the cases of David E. Harrold, G. A. Atzerodt, Lewis Payne and Mary E. Surratt to be duly executed in accordance with the President's order.

By command of the President of the United States.

E. D. TOWNSEND, Assistant-Adjut.-Gen.

In the remaining cases of O'Laughlin, Spangler, Arnold and Mudd, the findings and sentences are as follows: Fifth—Michael O'Laughlin.

Finding—Of the specification "Guilty," except the words thereof as follows: "And in the further prosecution of the conspiracy aforesaid, and its murderous and treasonable purposes aforesaid, on the nights of the 13th and 14th of April, A. D. 1865, at Washington City, and within the military department and military lines aforesaid, the said Michael O'Laughlin did then and there lie in wait for Ulysses S. Grant, then Lieutenant-General and Commander of the Armies of the United States, with intent then and there to kill and murder the said Ulysses S. Grant." Of said words, "Not Guilty," and except "combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler." Of this, "Not Guilty." Of the charge "guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler. Of this, "Not Guilty."

Sentence—The Commission sentence Michael O'Laughlin to be imprisoned at hard labor for life.

Sixth—Edward Spangler.

Finding—Of the specification, not guilty, except as to the words, "the said Edward Spangler, on said 14th day of April, A. D. 1865, at about the same hour of that day as aforesaid, within said military department and the military lines aforesaid, did aid and abet him," meaning John Wilkes Booth, "in making his escape" after the said Abraham Lincoln had been murdered in the manner aforesaid, and of these words "guilty." Of the charge, not guilty; but guilty of having feloniously and traitorously aided and abetted John Wilkes Booth in making his escape after having killed and murdered Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States—he the said Edward Spangler, at the time of aiding and abetting as aforesaid, well knowing that the said Abraham Lincoln, President as aforesaid, had been murdered by the said John Wilkes Booth as aforesaid.

The Commission sentenced Spangler to be confined at hard labor for six years.

Seventh—Samuel Arnold. Of the specifications—

Guilty—Except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler; of this, not guilty.

Of the charge—

Guilty—Except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler; of this, not guilty.

The Commission sentenced him to imprisonment at hard labor for life.

Eighth—Samuel A. Mudd. Of the specification:

Guilty—Except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler; of this "Not Guilty;" and excepting receiving and entertaining, and harboring and concealing said Lewis Payne, John W. Surratt, Michael O'Laughlin, George A. Atzerodt, Mary E. Surratt, and Samuel Arnold; of this Not Guilty. Of the charge "Guilty," except combining, confederating and conspiring with Edward Spangler; of this "Not Guilty."

Sentence—The Commission sentence Dr. Mudd to be imprisoned at hard labor for life.

The President's order in these cases is as follows:

It is further ordered that the prisoners, Samuel Arnold, Samuel A. Mudd, Edward Spangler and Michael O'Laughlin, be confined at hard labor in the penitentiary at Albany, N. Y., during the period designated in their respective sentences. ANDREW JOHNSON, President.

See the clipping

The writ that did not save Mrs. Surratt

A Chicago Tribune dispatch, reprinted in Kenosha, follows the last morning: Anna Surratt on her knees at the White House, and a writ of habeas corpus for her mother that President Johnson suspended, Judge Wylie saying his court must ‘submit to the supreme physical power’. As the moment came Mrs. Surratt said ‘Please don't let me fall.’ After about 18 minutes all four were pronounced dead.

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

The Kenosha Telegraph · 13 July 1865 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

The Last of the Conspiracy. The Execution of the Assassins.

[Special Dispatch to the Chicago Tribune.]

See moreSee less

WASHINGTON, July 7.

The assassination tragedy has at length come to a close. The curtain has fallen upon the lifeless forms of four of its actors.

At an early hour this morning, symptoms that an annual occurrence was impending were visible, yet the indications were more those of a holiday than such as befitted so solemn an occasion. Sightseers, anxious to indulge a morbid curiosity, began to arrive on the early trains. Passes were issued by Major General Hancock to such persons as were to be admitted to the scene of the execution, the number being confined to members of the press, necessary witnesses, and a few army officers. Great numbers of people last night and this morning surrounded Gen. Hancock's headquarters asking for passes upon every imaginable pretext. The rules for excluding the miscellaneous crowd was rigidly observed, and the two or three hundred persons admitted but scarcely filled the yard when the hour for the execution came. When the sentences were officially promulgated yesterday, the friends and relatives of the conspirators began to flock to the White House to plead for a respite. The counsel for Mrs. Surratt, the spiritual advisers of the condemned and a number of others whose sympathy with treason or its victimized tools was their only reason for interference, were among the pleaders for clemency. The President decided that the only reason for a reprieve which could properly be considered, must rest on purely legal grounds, such as tne production of important and hitherto unknown evidence if that were possible, and therefore referred the whole matter to the judgment of Judge Advocate General Holt. No such reason could be produced.

Miss Anna Surratt, who had visited the executive mansion last evening, endeavoring to obtain an interview with the President, again repaired thither, accompanied by a lady friend, between eight and nine o'clock this morning. The President having given orders that he would receive no one to-day, she was stopped at the foot of the stairs leading to the President's office. Finding she could not get further, she asked to see Gen. Muzzy, the President's Military Secretary. He at once came down, when Miss S., with streaming eyes and agonizing sobs, threw herself upon her knees and seized him by the coat, and begged him to aid her in obtaining an interview with the President. As tenderly as possible she was told that as the orders to admit no one were imperative, it was impossible to grant her request. Gen. Muzzy then left her, when she threw herself upon the staircase steps, where she remained some time, sobbing bitterly, asserting the innocence of her mother, and imploring everyone who passed to intercede for her. She declared that her mother was too good and kind to be guilty of the great crime of which she had been convicted, and said if her mother must die she wished to die also. Many who were present at this affecting scene, including hardy soldiers, were unable to restrain their tears.—Miss S. finally became more composed and was induced to take a seat in the east room, where she stayed several hours weeping silently and springing up each time the front door of the mansion was heard to open, hoping to see some one who could aid her in seeing the President.

Harrold's two sisters, dressed in deep mourning and heavily veiled, also came to the White House soon after the arrival of Miss S., to intercede for their brother. Unable to see the President they addressed a note to Mrs. Johnson, but she being sick it was not thought proper to deliver it. Failing in this they asked permission to forward a note to Mrs. Patterson, the President's daughter, who, being also indisposed, the request was not granted. The Misses Harrold showed much self-control, and restrained most of the outward manifestations of sorrow.

This morning about half past eight o'clock the following writ of habeas corpus was issued by Judge Wylie upon application of Mr. Aiken, counsel for Mrs. Surratt, and was served upon Gen. Hancock at the Metropolitan Hotel:

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, TO WIT.—In the matter of Mary E. Surratt, petition of habeas corpus.

The people of the United States to Maj. Gen. Hancock, commanding the Middle Division, greeting:

You are hereby commanded to have the body of Mary E. Surratt, detained under your custody as aforesaid, together with the day and cause of her being taken and detained, by whatever name she may be called in the same, before the Criminal Court of the District of Columbia, sitting at the City Hall, in the city of Washington, at the hour of 10 o'clock in the morning, this, the 7th day of July, 1865, to do and receive whatever shall then and there be considered of in this behalf; and have there this writ.

Witness, ANDREW WYLIE, one of the Justices of the Supreme Court of said District, July 7th, 1865. (Signed) R. J. Meigs, Clerk.

ENDORSEMENT.—I certify that I have served a copy of within writ of habeas corpus on Gen. W. S. Hancock, this 7th day of July, 1865, at eight and a half o'clock, at the Metropolitan Hotel, Washington City, D. C.

(Signed.) C. Gooding,

U. S. Marshal, D. C.

The Marshal, 30 minutes afterwards, returned the writ, certifying that it had been served, in order to know what further course the Court would pursue. District Attorney Carrington thought the proceeding extraordinary; that the party had been tried by a legitimate court, the sentence approved by the President and it was now too late to proceed in this matter, without entering into an argument upon the question. He thought the case came strictly under the jurisdiction of the commission upon the principal that the defence was committed at a time when military tribunals have proper jurisdiction in such cases.

Mr. Aiken said the return had not been made at the time. She could not be purged of the charges without being duly brought before this court. The grounds of the position were simply that she was a private citizen, never in any military service. If she was guilty of any crime it was cognizable by this court.

Judge Wylie then said the case is not now here on its merits but on the petition of the party. This morning at an early hour I directed this writ of habeas corpus to be issued. The writ was issued and was served upon Gen. Hancock who has the custody of Mrs. Surratt, the party on whose behalf the writ was obtained. The writ required him to have the body of Mrs. Surratt with the cause of her detention before this court this morning at 10 o'clock. He has neglected to obey the order of the Court, and what is the Court to do under the circumstances? That is the only question before the Court at this term. Any discussions on the merits involved, would now be out of place. The Court acknowledges that its powers are inadequate to meet the military power possessed by Gen. Hancock. If the Court were to decide at this moment that Gen. Hancock was in contempt, the only process which he would issue would be an attachment against the whole military power of the United States! This Court acknowledges that the laws are silent, and that it is without power in the premises, and therefore declines to make any order whatever. If there be a disposition on the part of the military power to respect the authority of the civil courts, they will respect the writ which has already been served. If, on the other hand, it is their determination to treat the authority of this Court with contempt in the matter, they have the power, and will treat with equal contempt any other process which the Court might order. The Court therefore must submit to the supreme physical power which now holds the custody of the prisoner, and declines to issue attachments or to make any other order in this case.

At ten minutes to twelve o'clock Major General Hancock entered the court with Attorney-General Speed, who apologized to the court for the apparent delay in making a return by Gen. Hancock, which was unavoidable. General Speed then proceeded to read the return of General Hancock, as follows:

HEADQUARTERS MIDDLE MILITARY DIV'N

WASHINGTON, July 7, 1865.

To Hon. Andrew Wylie, Justice of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia:

I hereby acknowledge the return of the writ hereto attached, and return the same, and respectfully say that Mary E. Surratt is in my possession under and by virtue of an order of Andrew Johnson, President of the United States, and Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy, for the purposes in said order expressed, a copy of which is hereto attached, and made part of the return, and that I do not produce said body, by reason of the order of the President of the United States endorsed upon said writ, to which reference is hereby respectfully made, July 7, 1865. W. S. HANCOCK,

Major General United States Volunteers,

Commanding Division,

The following is the endorsement upon the writ:

EXECUTIVE OFFICE, June 7, 1865.

To W. S. Hancock, Commanding, &c.:

I, Andrew Johnson, President of the United

States, do hereby declare that the writ of habeas corpus has been heretofore suspended in such cases as this, and I do hereby especially suspend this writ and direct that you proceed to execute the order heretofore given upon the judgment of the military commission, and you will give this order in return to this writ.

ANDREW JOHNSON.

The court reiterated the views before expressed, and then remarked that no further steps would be taken in the matter, and was briefly responded to by Attorney General

S[p]eed. The counsel for Payne and Atzerodt also applied for a writ of habeas corpus in their cases, but were refused upon the ground that a similar writ in Mrs. Surratt's case had been disregarded.

Early in the morning guards were stationed along Pennsylvania avenue south, and around the arsenal ground. The Fourth and First regiments of Hancock's corps, and a large detachment of the 60th Ohio were marched to the prison. The 1st

General Hancock stationed in the South yard, the 4th upon the walls and at the doors, and the 60th Ohio around the outside.

The gallows which was erected by workmen from the arsenal, was completed by

11 o'clock this morning. There are nine uprights holding the floor above, which faces on the west side. The uprights supporting the beam, from which hung four ropes, each being of strong hemp, are twenty feet long and ten feet high. The drops, of which there are two, each four feet by six, are directly beneath the beam, and are held in their place by an upright, which is knocked from under by two pieces of scantling being swung against it. The drop is six feet.

A few feet south of the scaffold, near the east wall, the four graves, each seven feet long by three wide and four deep, are dug, it being the intention that they (the condemned) should be buried there in case their friends do not claim them.

During the night Payne slept for several hours, and spent most of the time in quiet conversation with Rev. Dr. Gillett. He paid close attention to what was said, but did not show much emotion. None of his friends had been to see him.

Atzerodt was unable to sleep, although he made several attempts. His brother was with him yesterday and again this morning. His aged mother, who arrived during the night, also came to see him. Her meeting with her doomed child was very touching, and brought tears from the eyes of some of the prison officers, who had become accustomed to such scenes. Rev. Dr. Butler, of the Lutheran church, who had been sent for, was with Atzerodt during the night.

Harrold slept considerable during the night. Rev. Dr. Olds, of Christ's Episcopal Church, and five of his sisters visited him last night. He conversed freely with them, and said he was ready to die. This morning the minister and the whole family of seven sisters were with him.

Mrs. Surratt slept little if any, and suffered much. Her daughter was with her some hours, and also Rev. Fathers Walter and Wigel.

The breakfast which was sent to the prisoners this morning, was eaten of by none except Payne, who ate heartily.

Those who had passes began to gather in the penitentiary yard soon after 10 o'clock. Through the grated window a fair view of the corridor and cells of the condemned opening upon it could be obtained, and Atzerodt could be seen through the open door of his cell, formerly confined in an upper room. The conspirators sentenced to death had been removed to the ground floor. The military formed tow sides of a hollow square, facing the scaffold, and soon after the arrival of Major General Hancock and staff, who took their place in front and rear of the scaffold, they were ordered to a shoulder arms, and remained in that position until the reading of the orders announcing and confirming the sentence of the court, by General Hartraupt, had been completed.

Payne had conversed freely with Drs.—Gillette and Strickey on religious topics during the morning. It appears that he was raised religiously, and at one time belonged to the Baptist Church. He wept freely and seemed sincerely repentent. After giving his spiritual advisers some commissions of a private character, he expressed his willingness to meet his God, hoping for forgiveness. Col. Doster, his counsel, took leave of him in the morning, as with Atzerodt.

The final interview between Mrs. Surratt and her daughter was very affecting, bringing tears to the eyes of hardy soldiers standing by. Arrangements as to private affairs were here made, both with Miss S. and a male friend present with her spiritual counsel. She evinced great freedom and protested her innocence and her willingness to meet her Maker.

An interview between Atzerodt and his sister occurred at a quarter past 12. The sister showed great emotion, while Atzerodt maintained a dogged silence. Agonizing sobs from Mrs. Surratt's cell told of the parting between her and her child, the latter being soon after carried out insensible. Soon after a brief interview between Atzerodt and his counsel, the chains were removed from the cells. Vague rumors of a reprieve for some of the prisoners were afloat, but as the sequel shows, death came instead.

At fifteen minutes past one, Gen. Hartraupt, with his assistants, came out of the prison, followed by the mournful procession. Mrs. Surratt came first, supported by two officers, and attended by her spiritual friends. Fathers Wigel and Walters. Next came Atzerodt with Rev. Butler, of the Lutheran church, and Chaplain Winchester. Harold followed in the attendance of Rev. Dr. Olds, of Christs Church (Episcopal), while Payne, accompanid by Dr. Gillette, of the First Baptist Church here, and Dr Stryker, of Baltimore, came last.

Owing to her physical state, and the weight of her chains, Mrs. Surratt was almost carried to the gallows. She was placed on the north end of the platform, surrounded by her spiritual friends. With downcast looks she sank almost insensible into her seat. She was shaded from the heat of the sun by an umbrella held by a soldier. Her dress was deep black, the same as worn while on trial. Next to her, and on the same drop, was Payne, whose face and eyes presented an unusual color and appearance. His dress resembled that of a sailor. On the other drop was Harrold, with slouchy dress and woe begone looks. Atzerodt was on the same drop with Payne, and like him and Harrold, was in stockings.

Gen. Hartraupt now advanced and read the sentence of death, after which the dying service of the Catholic Church was administered to Mrs. Surratt by Fathers Wigel and Walter, she holding the cross fervently to her lips. Atzerodt was seen to mutter some words as if in prayer. Through Dr. Gillette, Payne expressed his thanks for the kind treatment he had received from all, with whom he had come in contact since his arrest. Dr. Gillette offered a fervent prayer, in which Payne seemed to join. Dr. Olds said, in behalf of Harrold, that he forgave all and hoped for forgiveness from all, after which the doctor followed in prayer. In like manner, Dr. Butler spoke in behalf of Atzerodt and closed with prayer. The prisoners were now placed on the fatal drop. The arms and ancles of Atzerodt, who came first, were tied securely with strips of white cloth. In the same manner the other criminals were bound, and the nooses adjusted. As the fatal moment approached Mrs. Surratt said: 'Please don't let me fall.' After a violent effort with his feverish lips Atzerodt said: "Gentlemen take "ware," meaning "warning" After the white caps were put over the prisoners heads. Atzerodt said in distinct tones: "Good bye gentlemen, who are before me; now may we all meet in the other world. God help me now. Oh. oh! oh!

The uprights were knocked out at the given signal and the bodies were suspended. Atzerodt died without any appearance of pain, while a slight movement in the limbs of Mrs. Surratt was all that was seen of the death struggle. The bodies of Payne and Harrold struggled considerably. After about 18 minutes solemn silence the bodies were examined by Surgeon Otis, U. S. Vol., and Assistant Surgeons Porter and Woodward, who all pronounced life extinct. One of the cords being prematurely severed by a soldier, one of the bodies fell down with a heavy thump. The bodies of Atzerodt, Harrold, Payne and Mrs. Surratt were then placed in strong white pine coffins, in the order named. It was not ascertained positively whether tha necks of Atzerodt and Payne were dislocated or not, but about those of Harrold and Mrs. Surratt there is no doubt. The burials were completed by a detail of the first corps.

See the clipping

A pass for the priest, on one condition

The Tribune stands by its charge that the War Department interfered with Mrs. Surratt’s priest. In its account General Hardie offered Father Walter a pass only if he promised to say nothing of her innocence, and Walter agreed so that he could give her the sacrament. A plea from her friends for her body went back and forth between Stanton and Holt and was put off.

New-York Daily Tribune · New-York, N.Y.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

New-York Daily Tribune · 17 July 1865 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE ASSASSINATION. Secretary Stanton and Mrs. Surratt.

Treatment of Her Confessor.

See moreSee less

THE STATEMENT OF BROPHY

WEICHMAN CONTRADICTS IT.

Special Dispatch to The N. Y. Tribune.

WASHINGTON, July 16, 1865. On the publication of the statement in THE TRIBUNE a few days ago that the Secretary of War had interfered with the attendance of Mrs. Surratt's spiritual adviser, The New York Times and an obscure Philadelphia journal took occasion. without any knowledge of facts, to denounce it as a malicious fabrication. The subjoined statement was obtained from the very best authority, and neither The Times or the Secretary of War dare deny it.

On Thursday morning, the 6th instant, the Rev. Father Walter, pastor of St. Patrick's Church, in this city, went to the War Office to ask for a pass to visit Mrs. Surratt, ignorant of the fact that she had already been condemned to suffer death on the following day. He had never previously visited Mrs. S., nor did he know her except by reputation. On application, he was informed by Gen. Hardie, A. A. G. to Sec. Stanton, that he could not give him a pass without first consulting Mr. Stanton, who was out at the time. Father Walter returned home, and at 1 o'clock p. m. on the same day received a pass to visit the prison, signed, by order of the Secretary of War, Gen. Hardie, A. A. G.

The messenger who brought the pass to Father Walter, being an intelligent Irishman, Father W. entered into conversation with him on the subject of the execution, firmly asserting his belief in Mrs. Surratt's innocence. In half or perhaps an hour afterward, Gen. Hardie himself called at the residence of Father Walter, and after some irrelevant conversation, said: "Father Walter, you made quite an impression on the mind of my messenger in regard to the execution of Mrs. Surratt," to which Father W. remarked that he was firmly impressed with her entire innocence. Gen. Hardie then said: "Father Walter, the pass you have will not admit you to the military prison to-morrow, because it is not signed by the Secretary of War. I want you to make me a promise to say nothing of Mrs. Surratt's innocence, and I will give you the necessary pass."

Father Walter, naturally indignant, immediately refused to accede to Gen. H.'s demand, giving him to understand, in the plainest kind of language, that no official, civil or military, could enforce his silence on this point; and remarking that he knew under whose authority he (Gen. H.) was acting. Gen. Hardie—a converted Catholic, by the way—then said, patronizingly, that as yet there were no charges lodged against him, Father W., at the War Department, to which the latter rejoined that he might tell his master, Stanton, that he conscientiously believed Mrs. Surratt guiltless; that he should proclaim his belief, and that the War Department might hang him if it thought prope[r].

Gen. Hardie was about to go without giving Father W. the pass, when the latter said: "Gen. Hardie, I cannot suffer Mrs. Surratt to die without administering the sacrament; I say yes to your proposition; give me the pass." Gen. Hardie then drew from his pocket a pass duly filled up and signed by Edwin M. Stanton, admitting him, Father W., to to the prison until after the execution.

Previous to the removal of Mrs. Surratt from the Carroll to the Military Prison, Father W. had made application to the War Office for a pass to visit her, she being very ill, but in every instance his applications were denied, and up to the very day before the execution Mrs. S. was deprived by the Secretary of War of spiritual attendants.

BROPHY AND HIS STATEMENTS.

The affidavits of J. P. Brophy in regard to Weichman and the innocency of Mrs. Surratt, are new to the public, but not so new to the Judge-Advocates of the late Military Commission. They are made up from Weichman's own statements to Brophy just before and since the trial. Mr. Brophy is far beyond the reach of assault by the Government. It may be also stated that he was called by the Government for one of their own witnesses, but by Weichman's special interposition he was not placed upon the stand. Mrs. Surratt's counsel could not use him as their witness, because they were not allowed to recall Weinchman to lay the foundation for his impeachment by Brophy.

A Card from Witness Weichman.

PHILADELPHIA, July 16, 1865.

Weichman, the principal witness for the Government in the conspiracy cases, publishes a card in The Sunday Dispatch stating that the statement of Brophy impeaching his character and testimony is a tissue of lies from beginning to end; that the said statement was twice submitted to Judge Holt and once to President Johnson and all the members of the Court, before the execution, without any effect; that it was only at Brophy's own request that he was not even called to the stand to testify to Weichman's good character. The card also details some conversation of Mrs. Surratt which did not appear before the Court, showing her knowledge of the conspiracy. He says Brophy is an alien, unnaturalized, and has never taken the oath of allegiance to the Government he attempts to assail in the person of its chief witness.

Efforts to Secure Mrs. Surratt's Corpse for Christian Burial.

From The Washington Union.

Before the body of Mrs. Surratt was cut down her friends asked Gen. Hancock for permission to remove the corpse, and had in waiting Mr. Harvey, the undertaker.

Gen. Hancock said he had no authority to grant the request, and referred the friends to the Secretary of War. They went immediately to the Secretary's office, and finding him in, and being refused permission to see him, the following note was sent to him:

WASHINGTON, D. C., July 7, 1865.

To the Hon. Secretary of War.

SIR: The friends of Mrs. Surratt, whose sphere in life has not been widely different from that of other competent and respectable people, desire and earnestly ask permission to remove her body from its present grave in the inclosure of the Arsenal Prison, and to be permitted to give it a Christian burial. They desire to do this this afternoon. Yours, very respectfully,

FREDERICK A. AIKEN,

JOHN A. CLAMPITT.

In a few minutes the above was returned, with the following indorsement on the back:

"Referred to the Judge-Advocate-General, Chief of the Bureau of Military Justice, for report, and to give such directions as to the disposal of the body as he deems proper.

"EDWIN M. STANTON, Secretary of War.

"July 7, 1865.

"To the Judge-Advocate-General, Chief of the Bureau of "Military Justice".

Gen. Holt had likewise given orders that no one should be permitted to see him during the day; but the note was sent to him, and by him referred back to the Secretary of War, and by the Secretary back to Gen. Holt, and by Gen. Holt again to the Secretary of War, and by the Secretary of War back again to Gen. Holt, who at last sent the following verbal message to Mr. Aiken, through one of his clerks, a Mr. Wright:

"Request will be considered, and at a proper time may be complied with, but not at present."

This is a simple statement of the facts.

The Scaffold and Graves—Mudd, Arnold, O'Laughlin and Spangler still in Washington—Their Conduct in Prison.

Saturday's Washington Star has the following:

The scaffold used in the execution of Payne, Harrold, Atzerodt and Mrs. Surratt, on Friday last, remains in its place, just as it was left after the bodies were cut down. It has suffered some chipping at the hands of relic-seeking soldiers. Just south of the scaffold, near the east wall, are seen the graves of the executed in the order the criminals stood on the scaffold—that of Mrs. Surratt being the first, Payne next, then Harrold, and last Atzerodt, each with a plain head-board bearing the name of the party. The authorities have not yet consented to give up the bodies.

The other parties convicted of the conspiracy and sentenced to the Penitentiary—Mudd, Arnold and O'Laughlin for life, and Spangler for six years—are still here, no orders having yet been received for their removal to the Albany Penitentiary. Their sentence has not as yet been officially announced to them by the officers, although they no doubt ere this have been informed by their counsel and friends, some of whom have been allowed to visit them. They seem quite cheerful, and O'Laughlin, who during the trial appeared to be failing in health, seems to have picked up considerably. Under a guard, this hot weather, they are allowed the range of the prison yard to exercise in, and the effects of this privilege are observable on their health and spirits.

They speak but little of the conspiracy and trial, and since the execution they have not divulged anything new. Arnold and O'Laughlin only reiterate what they have said before as to the original plot to capture the President. Mudd seems in very good spirits over his escape from the gallows. He says little about the trial. He acknowledges that the testimony of the witness Weichman in reference to himself is correct. Spangler is extremely cheerful, talking and joking, when allowed, with every one passing near him.

It is thought that in a day or two they will be placed on a steamer, under guard, and sent to the Albany Penitentiary.

See the clipping

The chief witness answers his critics

Weichman, the government’s chief witness, answers Brophy in a Philadelphia paper and says why he believes Mrs. Surratt was guilty, though ‘guilty to what extent I do not know.’ He recalls her Good Friday drive and Booth’s three visits that day. Beside it, a Washington correspondent raises the idea that blue pills from the drug store where Herold had worked once poisoned Lincoln.

New-York Daily Tribune · New-York, N.Y.

New-York Daily Tribune · 18 July 1865 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE ASSASSINATION.

Statement of the Witness Weichman.

See moreSee less

More Evidence Regarding Mrs. Surratt.

HER PRETENDED INNOCENCE.

Attempt to Poison the Late President.

The following appears in The Philadelphia Sunday Dispatch:

PHILADELPHIA, July 15, 1865.

To the Editors of The Sunday Dispatch:

Will you favor me by publishing the following statement in your valuable paper?

Mrs. Surratt is dead and what I now have to say can do her no harm. There was a time when none had more respect for her than I.

When living I did everything for her that was in my power. I testified to her character nobly. I plead for her day after day with those in authority that they might spare her life because she was a woman, and because she was kind to me once. It was in vain. The Government knows best, and must make a dread and just example to terrify all enemies to free Government.

Yet, after all this, an attempt has been made by one Brophy, in Washington, to blacken my character. To silence him, and many other sympathizers with guilt, I deem it necessary to present the following to the public. Let them judge and decide fairly.

I am, sirs, very respectfully, your obedient servant, LOUIS J. WEICHMAN.

MR. WEICHMANN'S STATEMENT.

The affidavit of John P. Brophy of Washington to the public, instead of being to me a matter of surprise and anger, has been one almost of daily expectation. To prove its utter worthlessness, it is merely necessary to state that it was twice submitted to Judge Holt, and once to all the members of the Court, and to President Johnson himself, before the execution of Mrs. Surratt, and that it had no effect whatever. Col. Bennett himself handed me the charges almost ten days before the trial was closed. They had been sent to him by some one who was afraid to affix his signature thereto. I laughed at them then, since they were ridiculous; and I now pronounce the statement, so extensively copied in various papers, a tissue of lies from beginning to end. It puzzles me much to know why these monstrous charges were not brought out on the witness stand by the learned counsel, Aiken, and his worthy associate, Clampitt, who are in close communion with Brophy. The case had not been closed when I read them. I was then, and am now, prepared to answer all such charges.

Brophy himself was summoned twice, once for the defense and once for the prosecution; but according to his own wishes he never appeared on the stand. I had him and a dozen trustworthy, gentlemanly witnesses called to prove my character, against which he dares not say one word.

It was only after a very tearful protestation on his part that his "poor old mother would cry herself to death if she saw his name in the papers in connection with this trial," that I sent a note into the Court-room to Col. Burnett to release him, and he at once acceded to his wishes.

Brophy's "poor old mother" had, consequently, no reason to shed tears.

I never visited President Johnson, never wrote a letter to him, and don't believe that Mrs. Surratt was an innocent woman. The expression about Judge Holt is an infamous lie. Brophy accuses me of disloyalty. I would here say that no person throughout the whole trial had his good character so fully vouched for as I have. It is beyond reproach, either as regards loyalty, veracity or morality.

Brophy had better clear his own shoes first. He is an alien, has never been naturalized, and has not taken the oath of allegiance to the Government which he attempts to assail in the person of its chief witness.

A very prevalent rumor, too, has gained ground that I was placed in irons and maltreated and threatened by the Secretary of War. This is another error. The War Department had all the information which I possessed on the morning of the 16th of April. It was given freely and without compulsion. The Government, too, furnished me with money and transportation to go to Canada in pursuit of John H. Surratt.

Throughout the trial, the treatment I experienced at the hands of the Secretary of War, Judges Holt, Burnett and Bingham, and the members of the court, was very marked indeed and courteous.

As regards my testimony, I have nothing to regret. Conscious of my integrity, and of my desire to do right to all, I stand to-day in the pure light of heaven without one sin on my soul to answer for as regards the trial of the conspirators.

Far from considering it a disgrace to have been a Government witness, I can only esteem it an honor that I have been of so much assistance in ferreting out the diabolical schemes of traitors and conspirators. I am pained only because of one thing, viz: that I have been deceived so much in Mrs. Surratt and her son.

Much has been said and much has been written about Mrs. Surratt's innocence. Sensation paragraphs are being scattered throughout the country, ridiculing our own times, accusing us of a want of deference and respect to the female sex, and recalling us to the days of knight errantry, when woman was respected "in court, and camp, and tourney, and banquet hall." The United States Government itself is assailed, and charged with having murdered an innocent woman.

That a woman so kind, so compassionate, so generous and so religious, should have been cognizant of plots to capture or assassinate the President of the United States, is hardly to be believed. Yet it is strangely true. Her own actions and words, for weeks prior to the assassination, and even on the 14th of April itself, leave very little doubt in my mind but that she was guilty. But, guilty to what extent I do not know.

She may possibly have been cognizant only of the capture and of the parties concerned in it. Yet even that deserved death. It was treasonable and criminal to lay hands on the person of the President in aid of the enemy, and as such it ought to be punished.

Mrs. Surratt is to be much blamed. She should have exercised a woman's influence and a mother's love, and then she could have prevented all. But no, she was too infatuated. She loved the South too much. None can regret her untimely end more than I, yet none can detest her crimes more than I do.

Particles of conversation which were once intended to blind me, and which had a certain air of mystery about them, now come back in their dread reality with a peculiar and an awful significance. Before the 4th of March Mrs. Surratt was continually remarking to everybody that something was going to happen to "Old Abe," which would prevent him from taking his seat, because Gen. Lee was going "to make a movement which would startle the whole world." This appeared in the papers, and no notice was taken of it. The 4th of March came and went. President Lincoln was inaugurated, but Gen. Lee did not execute his "movement." What that "movement" was I do not know. A short time after I asked her why John brought such men as Harrold and Atzerodt into the house. "Oh! John wishes to make use of them for his dirty work," was her reply. I then asked her what the "dirty work" was? She said, "John wants them to clean his horses." He had two at that time. When Richmond fell and Lee's army surrendered, when Washington was in a blaze of glory and all hearts beat high with joy, Mrs. Surratt wept and closed her house. When the illumination took place her house remained dark and silent, without one single ray of light at the windows to denote gladness. Gloomy and forlorn it then was. To use her own expression, it was "indicative of her feelings." But, oh! a gloom and a horror now invests it blacker than the Furies themselves.

On Good Friday I drove her into the country, ignorant of her purpose and intentions. Holiday had been granted to all the clerks in the department by the Secretary of War. We started at 2½ o'clock. Before leaving she had an interview with John Wilkes Booth in the parlor, and no doubt she then received from him the field-glass which she gave to Lloyd.

On the way down she was very lively and cheerful, taking the reins into her own hands several times and urging on the steed. We halted once, and that was when about three miles from Washington, when, observing that there were pickets along the road, she called an old farmer and wanted to know if they would remain there all night. On being told that they were withdrawn at about 8 o'clock in the evening, she said she was glad to know it.

On our return I chanced to make some remark about Booth, stating that he appeared to be without employment, and asking her when he was going to act again. "Booth is done acting," she said, "and he is going to New-York very soon, never to return."

Then turning round, she remarked, "Yes, and Booth is crazy on one subject, and I am going to give him a good scolding the next time I see him." What that "one subject" was Mrs. Surratt never said. The people can judge for themselves.

She was very anxious to be at home at nine o'clock, saying she had made an engagement with some gentleman, who was to meet her at that hour. I asked her if it was Booth. She answered neither yes nor no.

When about a mile from the city, on our return, and having from the top of a hill caught a view of Washington swimming in a flood of light and glory, raising her hands she said: "I am afraid all this rejoicing will be turned into mourning—all this glory into sadness." I asked her what she meant. She replied, that after sunshine there was always storm, and that the people were too proud and licentious, and that God would punish them. The gentlemen whom she expected at nine o'clock, on her return, called. It was John Wilkes Booth's last visit to Mrs. Surratt, and the third one on that day. She was alone with him for a few minutes in the parlor; what transpired there God only knows. As soon as I had taken tea I went to the parlor.

Mrs. Surratt's former manner and cheerfulness had left her. She was now nervous, agitated and restless. Pacing up and down the floor, she seemed to be thinking of something, and on my asking her what was the matter, she said she felt very nervous and was unwell. Then looking at me she asked me which way the torchlight procession was going that we had seen on the avenue? I remarked that it was a procession from the arsenal, and that the employés were probably going to serenade the President, it being the 14th day of April, the day appointed for the restoration of the flag over Sumter. She said she would like to know, as she was much interested in it. Her nervousness finally increased so much that she drove myself and the young ladies, who were creating a great deal of noise and laughter, to our respective rooms to bed. She, however, returned to the parlor and continued pacing up and down the room long after I had retired.

When the detectives arrived at 3 o'clock the next morning, I rapped at her door for permission to let them in.

"For God's sake let them come in! I expected the house to be searched," said she.

When the detectives had gone, and when her daughter, almost frantic, cried out, "Oh! ma, just think of that man's having been here an hour before the assassination! I am afraid it will bring suspicion upon us!"

"Anna, come what will," she replied, "I am resigned. I think that J. Wilkes Booth was only an instrument in the hands of the Almighty to punish this proud and licentious people."

Now who is there, after all these facts, that will not say that Mrs. Surratt knew what was in Booth's mind? God grant he may have spoken to her only of capture; but I believe what Judge Bingham said, and what every true Union-loving man will say: "Capture meant murder."

The abduction of President Lincoln from the city of Washington, which is surrounded by nearly 30 strong forts, and which was at that time protected by 20,000 soldiers, would have been simply an impossibility. His carriage could not have proceeded three squares without being recognized. The attempted execution of this silly plot would have been as absurd as its original conception. LOUIS J. WEICHMAN.

More Light Upon the Assassination Plot—Reported Attempt to Poison President Lincoln and Secretary Stanton—Plan for Shooting Andrew Johnson.

The Washington correspondent of The Pittsburgh Chronicle writes as follows in a recent letter:

I have talked with an intelligent colored woman who says "she was in the crowd at Secretary Stanton's door on the evening of the assassination—that she was in charge of several children; and to prevent their being hurt, placed them in the angle formed by the steps and wall of the house, so that she and they were almost behind Mr. Stanton while he stood on the steps speaking to the people; that a man in a heavy, dark coat, with his hat drawn over his face, edged his way in among the children, and kept moving his head from side to side as if trying to get a good look at Mr. Stanton, while he kept his right hand down at his side, and she thought he had a pistol in it. She became alarmed and spoke aloud to a colored man near, asking him to come and stand between her and this man, for he had a pistol. The colored man came and took the position she desired, and the other moved off. The story was hard to believe, but her daughter stated that she came home that evening quite excited, saying there was a 'specious character in the crowd, and she thought he wanted to shoot Mr. Stanton.' I have reason to believe Mr. Stanton knew of this, and expected to the last that she would be examined before the Commission.

On a visit to Mrs. Lincoln, the day she left for Chicago, I said to her that I had always expected Slavery would poison Mr. Lincoln as it did Presidents Harrison and Taylor. The idea appeared new to her, and recalled the fact that her husband had been very ill, for several days, from the effects of a dose of blue pills taken shortly before his second inauguration. She said he was not well, and appearing to require his usual medicine, blue pills, she sent to the drug store in which Harrold was employed last and got a dose and gave them to him at night before going to bed, and that next morning his pallor terrified her.

"His face," said she, pointing to the bed beside which she sat, "was white as that pillow case, as it lay just there," she exclaimed, laying her hand on the pillow—"white, and such a deadly white; as he tried to rise he sank back again, quite overcome!"

She described his anxiety to be up, there was so much to do, and her persistence and his oppressive languor in keeping him in bed for several days; said he and she both thought it so strange that the pills should affect him in that way; they never had done so before, and both concluded they would get no more medicine there, as the attendant evidently did not understand making up prescriptions. Could this have been the time spoken of in that letter produced on the trial, in which it is said the cup had failed once?

I know an officer's widow who spent some time with her husband in Georgia while Gen. Mitchell was in command. She has told me of a pretended Union woman, in a small town where they were stationed, who kept a boarding-house for Union officers; of the large number of invalids among these boarders, and her especially remarking the excessive and peculiar pallor of these invalids; soon the number of deaths attracted attention, and an investigation was ordered of the charge that this female fiend had been poisoning her boarders. While the case was pending some order changed the troops occupying the town, and my informant never learned how the matter ended, but her description of the pallor of the victims so coincides with Mrs. Lincoln's account of our Martyr's appearance after the taking of the blue bills, that it has occurred to me those monsters may have some peculiar method of poisoning. Moreover, it is highly probable that our political assassinations are not yet over.

A conversation was overheard the latter part of last month, on a dark night, between a knot of men who distinctly detailed a plan for shooting President Johnson on the Fourth. The speakers were to station themselves at different points in the crowd, and while he should be speaking at Gettysburg, at a signal, fire simultaneously. This conversation was promptly reported to Col. Baker by Judge Day, who told me of the fact.

The person who heard it was a colored woman, late a slave, who knew of Judge Day as the slaves' lawyer, and unburdened herself to him of her great secret. After he had reduced her statement to writing, he sent her with it to Col. Baker. An intelligent white woman on the evening after the executions overheard one man say to another that "the d—d blue-legged Yankees had not made much of the conspiracy cut, and were not done with it yet."

Such conversations have been by no means uncommon here during the past four years, and that against Mr. Lincoln's life attracted but little attention here once, but such threats seek the cover of darkness now.

See the clipping

Payne walks to the gallows unaided

A Washington report printed in Butler, Pennsylvania, describes the scene from the jail yard: a photographer readying his instruments, Mrs. Surratt almost carried, and Payne alone ‘bold and erect’, said to have refused stimulants so he could die with a clear mind. Atzerodt’s last words were ‘Don't choke me.’ Herold, experts said, was the only one hanged on correct principles.

American Citizen · Butler, Pa.

American Citizen · 19 July 1865 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE ASSASSINATION.

Hanging of Mrs. Surratt, Payne, Harrold and Atzerott.

See moreSee less

They arc Executed Simultaneously.

LAST HOURS OF THE CONDEMNED

SCENES AT THE SCAFFOLD.

WASHINGTON, July 7, 1865.

The curtain has fallen on the last act of the great conspiracy drama, and Mrs. Surratt, Payne, Harrold and Atzerodt, the unfortunate victims of the arch assassin Booth, have gone to their reward. If even the most charitable concede to the authors of such heinous crimes the pardon of a forgiving Heaven.

General Hancock was badly besieged last night and this forenoon for cards of admission, but adhered to his purpose to admit those who desired to be present as a matter of business instead of curiosity. In consequence the assemblage inside the walls of the jail-yard was not large, being composed of a detachment of the 1st regiment of Hancock's Corps, selected to act as guard on the occasion, representatives of the press and a few other citizens to whom the privilege of being present had been specially accorded.

For a long time previous to the execution, sobs, moans and cries were heard issuing from the grated window fronting the jail-yard to the south, which attracted a large group of the reportial corps, who were assiduously engaged in noting down every trifling circumstance coming under their limited observation.

To the north of the corridor in a cell, Atzerodt in conversation with his former mistress, could be distinctly seen. He frequently used his handkerchief to remove the perspiration from his face, and occasionally sobbed quietly, as she addressed him, apparently in a feeling manner. None of the other prisoners were visible.

In the main hall or corridor slowly strode a number of military officers, among whom the fine figure of Gen. Hancock appeared at intervals, going to and from the cells of the condemned, or giving necessary instructions to his officers.

The cries issuing from the cells were those of the sisters of Harrold and the daughter of Mrs. Surratt, whose grief was naturally enough affecting and uncontrollable.

Thus passed the interval from 10 till 2 p. m., the sentries in the meantime slowly pacing their beats in a thoughtful mood, as if they dreaded the awful scene soon to be enacted and would feel relieved as soon as it was over; the blue coats on the walls looking down silently upon the scaffold below and every one exhibiting the greatest decorum and seeming to be duly impressed with the overawing solemnity of the occasion.

From the cupola of a detached building a large crowd looked down into the jail-yard, while Gardiner, the photographist, with his instruments posted in the old shoe-shop building, was industriously engaged in preparations for obtaining numerous views of the group about to appear on the scaffold.

At ten minutes to 1 o'clock, Hancock personally posted the sentries around the scaffold, and the outer guard were ordered to come to "attention," preparatory to the appearance of the prisoners.

At precisely 1 o'clock, Gen. Hartranft and Staff emerged from the Prison, and in a moment after were followed by the condemned.

Mrs. Surrat came first, dressed in black, supported on either side by an officer, and followed by her spiritual advisers, Fathers Walter and Wiget of the Catholic Church. She wore a black bonnet and vail as on the trial, and had to be almost entirely supported by the officers attending her.

Next came Atzerodt, also necessarily supported by a soldier on either side, and dressed about as he was on the trial, and bare-headed. He was attended by his spiritual advisers, the Rev. Dr. Butler, of the Lutheran Church, and the Rev Mr. Winchester, Chaplain of Douglas Hospital.

Then came Harrold, dressed in his ordinary prison clothes, with a slouch cloth hat on, the brim being turned down. He, too, was much prostrated and had to be supported by a soldier on either side. He was followed by the Rev. Dr. Olds of Christ Church, Navy Yard, and the Rev. Mr. Vaux, Chaplain United States Army.

Payne alone came bold and erect, without any support, a guard walking on either side of him. He was dressed in a blue shirt and pants, with a rather jaunty straw hat on, and was followed by his spiritual advisers, the Rev. Dr. Gillette of the Thirteenth-st. Baptist Church, and other attendants.

Payne alone of the prisoners ascended the scaffold without the support of his attendants. Four wooden arm-chairs had been placed there for the reception of the prisoners, and they were seated as follows, facing West: Mrs. Surratt, on the North next to the prison; Payne sat next; Harrold next, and Atzerodt next; Mrs. Surratt and Payne opposite one drop, and Harrold and Atzerodt opposite the other, the five-eighths manilla rope, with its ominous noose, dangling before each respectively, the nooses reaching to within an average of eighteen inches from the floor.

On the prisoners being seated, or rather sinking into their chairs, the finding and sentence of the Military Commission, as approved by the President and already published, was read, in a clear, calm voice by Major General Hartranft, standing in the middle of the platform.

The appearance of the prisoners as they sat there in a row facing the West, and the crowd and Gardner's photographic instruments peering from the upper windows of an opposite building, and the ropes swaying in the breeze immediately before them, was that of agony ineffable.

The thought came rushing upon the mind of the spectator: "Oh! what would they not give if they could undo the fatal acts that have consigned them to this agony and infamy?"

Mrs. Surrat was very much prostrated, and seemed to be kept alive almost entirely alive by the spiritual consolations of her advisers who were unremitting in their attentions until ke and

After the reading of the sentence by Gen. Hartranft, Rev. Dr. Gillette stepped forward in behalf of Payne, and stated that he had been requested by the prisoner, Lewis Thornton Powell, alias Payne, to publicly, on this occasion return his sincere thanks to Gen. Hartranft and the officers and men under his command for their uniform kindness toward him during his confinement. Not one unkind word, look or gesture had been given him by any one of them.

The Reverend Doctor then led in a fervent prayer in behalf of the prisoner, in which the latter followed, closing with a feeling Amen, his eyes at the same time filling with tears. Payne throughout wore an air of contrition as well as courage, and thereby excited the pity of the spectators fully as much as any of the other prisoners who were more unnerved.

The spiritual advisers of Harrold and Atzerodt also returned the thanks of their charges respectively to Gen. Hartranft and his officers and men, for their uniform kindness; and joined in prayer with the prisoners in succession, Dr. Butler preceding his in the case of Atzerodt with an impressive exhortation.

During all this time the advisers of Mrs. Surratt were assiduous in their attentions to her, and by their consolations kept her measurably nerved up for the terrible denoument. She appeared—bating her unavoidable prostration—passive in their hands and resigned to her fate.

On the conclusion of the prayer in the case of Atzerodt, which was the last, the prisoners were led forward, supported by their respective attendants, and the ropes adjusted around the neck by different persons. About the same time Mrs. Surrott seemed, by a desperate mental effort, to nerve herself up specially for this occasion, looking forward and around her, for the only time, with an air of mingled determination and resignation. Her bonnet and veil were removed previous to the putting of the noose upon her neck.

Payne held back his head and was particular about having the noose adjusted and secured by tightening above his "adam's apple," as if it had been the adjustment of a cravat for a festive occasion.

Harrold and Atzerodt, during the process of adjusting the ropes, looked as if experiencing ineffable agony, as well as Mrs. Suratt, who was now bordering on a fainting condition and was kept conscious only by assiduous fanning and other attentions of her attendants. Payne stood erect and unsupported, and he alone it was said by one of the spiritual advisers, had come upon the scaffold without indulgence in stimulants, which he had steadily refused, saying that he wished to die with an unclouded mind.

At the conclusion of the address of Atzerodt's spiritual attendant and his deeply solemn and feeling petition to Heaved for Divine clemency, he was conducted to the drop by his attendants, and while the white cotton band were being tied about his legs and arms, exhibited great weakness and emotion, being scarcely able to remain in an erect position.—The noose was then placed about his neck, and previous to its final adjustment he addressed a few inaudible words to his executioner, and the rope was removed. Gen. Hartranft then approached, when Atzerodt evidently repeated his request, and the noose was then drawn over his head, when he exclaimed in a terrified voice: "Gentlemen, take warn," probably intending to say, what his agonized feelings prevented him from expressing:—"Gentlemen, take warning by my example."

A moment after and he tremblingly ejaculated, "Good bye, gentlemen, who are before me now." And, after a short interval, added, "May we all meet in the other world"

As the rope was being adjusted to his neck, and just before the drop fell, he cried out in rather a loud voice, "Don't choke me." These were the last words he uttered, which were succeeded by several audible groans.

At this juncture the nooses and white caps having all been adjusted, Captain Rath, Assistant Provost Marshal, having immediate charge of the execution, stepped in front of the scaffold, on the ground, and motioned to all attendants an the scaffold to step back off the drops, which they did, the proper ones still reaching forward and supporting their charges respectively on the drops.

Immediately on this movement being accomplished, Captain Rath also gave the signal for the props to be knocked from under, which was done by a swinging scantling for each shoved longitudinally; and the four conspirators, having fallen about five feet each, were left dangling spasmodically in the air. The contortion of Payne were the greatest, attributable to his highest physical condition.—Harrold died next hardest. The death of Mrs. Surratt and Atzerodt were comparatively easy. Mrs. Surratt on falling, made a convulsive effort to bring her hands around her right side in front of her, and they remained in such contorted position until she was cut down.

After the convulsions of all were over, Mrs. Surratt, Payne and Atzerodt hung with their heads bent forward, while that of Harrold inclined back, which latter was said by experts to be the only execution on correct principles.

See the clipping

Payne’s word that Mrs. Surratt was innocent

A Shepherdstown weekly says that on 6 July Payne told Fathers Wiget and Walter that Mrs. Surratt was innocent, and that General Hartranft passed this to the President with ‘I believe that Payne has told the truth in this matter.’ No respite came. On the scaffold, it says, she told Father Walter ‘I wish to say to the people that I am innocent.’

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

Shepherdstown Register · 22 July 1865 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

The Confession of Lewis P. Payne and Exonoration of Mrs. Surratt.

On Thursday afternoon, July 6th, Rev. B. F. Wiget, Rev. J. D. Walter, Mr. John P. Brophy, and Miss Anna E. Surratt, received permission to visit Mrs. Mary E. Surratt, at her cell in the penitentiary. Mr. Brophy, remembering that Payne had declared Mrs. Surratt's innocence all through the trial, urged Father Wiget and Father Walter to visit Payne and ask him whether she were guilty or not. They did visit Payne, by permission, and he told them openly that she was an innocent woman.

See moreSee less

Friday morning, Father Walter sent Mr. Brophy with a letter to the President, containing Payne's statement, and asking that a little time be allowed Mrs. Surratt to prove her innocence.

Father Walter's letter was endorsed by General Hartrauft, who has had the prisoners in charge, and whose orders were to carry out the execution. Gen. Hartrauft wrote in substance as follows to the President a short time before the execution:

"The prisoner Payne has just told me that Mrs. Surratt is entirely innocent of the assassination of President Lincoln, and of any knowledge thereof. He also states that she had no knowledge whatever of the abduction plot, that nothing was ever said to her about it, and that her name was never mentioned by the parties connected therewith."

At the close of the letter, which Gen. Hartranft wrote to the President, he (Gen. Hartranft) said: "I believe that Payne has told the truth in this matter."

He then signed his name, rank, &c., and very kindly and humanely furnished Mr. Brophy with two of his best horses, in order that he might arrive at the President's in time for a reprieve. At the White House Mr. Brophy met Mrs. Douglas, wife of Senator Douglas, who united her exertions with those of many other distinguished persons, who had come to ask even a short respite for a woman whom they believed to be innocent. All efforts proved fruitless, however. The President, Judge Holt and Mr. Seward, were inexorable. The woman must die, and not a minute should she have beyond the time appointed.

MRS. SURRATT'S LAST MOMENTS.

So many contradictory and false accounts have been published concerning Mrs. Surratt's last moments, that we feel compelled to furnish the public with a true version. To all she declared herself innocent. The parting of mother and daughter was agonizing in the extreme. Mr. Holohan next took leave, and after him, Mr. Brophy bade her adieu. On the scaffold she said to her spiritual attendants, "shall I say anything?" Father Walter asked: "What do you wish to say, Mrs. Surratt?" She replied: "I wish to say to the people that I am innocent." Father Walter told her it would be useless to do so now. She said, "I am innocent; but God's holy will be done!"

See the clipping

Booth’s neck bones go on show

A short Wheeling item reports that the neck bones of John Wilkes Booth, shattered by the bullet that killed him, are on exhibition among the surgical curiosities of the war at the Army Medical Museum. Stanton’s bulletin of 27 April had said Booth was shot through the head; the Evening Star’s own account that day put the ball in his neck.

The Wheeling Daily Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Wheeling Daily Register · 24 July 1865 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The vertebral neck bones of the assassin, John Wilkes Booth, which were shattered by the bullet that caused his death, are now on exhibition among the other surgical curiosities of the war of the Army Medical Museum in this city.

See the clipping

The government takes over Ford’s Theatre

A brief item reports that the government has taken possession of Ford’s Theatre, where Lincoln was shot, and is packing its contents for removal. Mr. Ford is to be paid rent until 1 February; if Congress has not voted money to buy the building by then, it goes back to him. In June the Young Men’s Christian Association had planned to buy it as a memorial.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 25 July 1865 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Ford's theatre in Washington has been taken possession of by the government. Everything therein is being packed for removal. The government is to pay a certain rent to Mr. Ford till the 1st of February, and if by that time Congress has not made an appropriation for the purchase it will be returned to him.

See the clipping

Booth’s stage wardrobe sold at Quebec

From the Quebec Mercury: Booth’s theatrical wardrobe, shipped from Montreal the previous fall for Richmond by way of Nassau and saved from the wreck of the schooner Marie Victoria, is sold by court order for the salvors. Speculators paid far more than the sea-damaged goods were worth. Trial testimony had placed Booth in Montreal in October, talking with George N. Sanders.

Daily Davenport Democrat · Davenport, Iowa

Daily Davenport Democrat · 31 July 1865 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sale of Wilkes Booth's Theatrical Wardrobe.

From the Quebec Mercury, July 18.

See moreSee less

The theatrical wardrobe belonging to John Wilkes Booth, the assassin of President Lincoln, was sold here to-day, by order of the Vice Admirality Court. The sale took place for the benefit of the parties who saved the effects from the wreck of the schooner Marie Victoria, whereon they were shipped at Montreal, last fall, for Richmond, vis Nassau. The prices which the articles brought were far beyond their intrinsic value, for they were greatly damaged by sea water, and the principal purchasers were persons buying on speculation. His dressing case, nearly in pieces, was knocked down at $15; many of the spoiled dramatic costumes at $20 and $25 each, and his stage swords at $4 75 each.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: The Great Murder Trial