As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

April 1807

96 articles

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A legislator argues against a proposed measure seen as favorable to Burr's conspirators, insisting that those who carried letters to Gen. Wilkinson to recruit him into the plot committed treason itself, not merely misprision of treason. He rejects a colleague's milder legal characterization, asserting that aiding the conspiracy's aims constitutes being a principal in treason since the crime admits no accessories.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

its contents, from the principal conspirator to Gen. Wilkinson, for the purpose of engaging him to join in this undertaking—they used their influence to corrupt him. These must be considered overt acts, giving aid and comfort

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This piece discusses the two distinct charges against Aaron Burr: treason under the 1790 act, punishable by death, and a separate charge of preparing a military expedition against Spanish colonies, punishable by fine and imprisonment under the 1794 act. The author urges the U.S. attorney to pursue both charges broadly, even if Burr is acquitted of treason, citing Chief Justice Marshall's February 21 opinion that probable grounds existed for the lesser offense.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

prehend this new offence, even if Col. Burr be discharged on the first. His own reputation and the interests of his country impericusly demand, that the judicial investigation should be satisfactory, and therefore it should be complete. Of course it should comprise that "offence," which Chief Justice Marshall on delivering the opinion of the court on the 21st February, confessed, "there is probable ground for supposing they have committed."

* It is presumed from this circumstance, that Col. Burr was not far from the Florida line ; that he was about to take refuge in the dominions of Spain, the only spot of ground in that quarter of the country, where he was exempt from the authority of the U. S. and that he intended to descend the Mobile and repair to Pensacola.

See moreSee less

† His force was collected on this island.

THOMAS JEFFERSON, PRESIDENT of the UNITED STATES of AMERICA.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A Louisiana justice of the peace records the oath of Dr. John F. Carmichael, describing visits from Burr associates Ralston and Floyd who sought intelligence on U.S. forts and troop strength at Baton Rouge and Fort Adams. The deposition outlines Burr's plan to first seize Baton Rouge, raise his standard, and await reinforcements from agents circulating through the country.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

were stated, and the difficulty attending such an enterprize. Mr. Ralston informed me that col. Burr was to be on the 12th day of January instant at Bayou Pier[r]e, where he was to wait for his reinforcement & to receive his information from his agents, who were circulated thro' the country in that time; that the first object of col. Burr was to take Baton Rouge, where he was to raise his standard & to make his communication to the government of the U. S. where he was to be joined by a number of men already engaged to the amount of 10,000 men if necessary; that the number of men at present with col.

See moreSee less

Burr did not exceed 150, but col. Burr's arrangments were so made that the men already engaged in Kentucky and Tennessee should join without shew, so that no possible alarm or suspicion on the part of the general government might take place before he had left the government, & taken possession of Baton Rouge. Mr. Ralston further stated to this deponent that it was not the intention of col. Burr to promote and make a separation of the union, but to act against the Spanish government, and stated the intended expedition against Mexico. When this deponent mentioned the name of captain Shaw, Mr. Ralston observed, that if he was one of the Mediterranean officers, he was friendly to their measures; that it was well understood that a large proportion of the officers of the army and Mediterranean officers were already engaged in their interests. Mr. Ralston expressed great surprize at the conduct of gen. Wilkinson in arresting certain characters, Swartwout, Ogden, Bollman, and Alexander, and repeatedly asked this deponent what he thought of the conduct of gen. Wilkinson, and whether he believed he had deserted the interests of the party, or was it only to cover his greater objects. This deponent further declares that Mr. Ralston and Mr. Floyd visited the fort of Fort Adams on the evening of the 12th of January inst. between sunset and dark, and walked round the said fort. Signed, JOHN F. CARMICHAEL.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A congressional speaker debates penalties for violating habeas corpus, arguing that a commander in chief who defies the Constitution is a traitor, directly implicating General Wilkinson if reports from New Orleans are true. The exchange includes sparring with Massachusetts representatives over the scope and severity of punishment for such violations.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

death? Whoever commands an army and sets at defiance the constitution, is a traitor. If the facts stated to have taken place at New Orleans are true, Wilkinson is the traitor.—Who are traitors? Burr and co. and why? because they attempt to overturn the laws. The commander in chief does the same.

Suppose he puts down Burr to put up some body else; what then? Suppose it is done to gain a momentary eclat.—If the commander in chief, after having gone all lengths in treason, now turns against his confederates and endeavours to make his zeal atone for the want of fidelity, he is guilty of double treason; he has violated not only his duty to his country, but even that fidelity which is known among knaves.

See moreSee less

The gentleman from Massachusetts (Mr. B.) says this resolution will make the people callous to violations of their rights. Does the gentleman from Massachusetts, or do the house imagine that if we step forward in a case where the habeas corpus has been flagrantly violated, the people will con

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A House member rebuts a colleague's claim that treason law recognizes no accessories, citing English legal authorities (Foster, Hale, Hawkins) to argue that derivative/accessorial guilt still applies in practice, especially relevant to those accused on General Wilkinson's testimony. He argues fairness requires treating accused parties as accessories until the principal offender is convicted, directly bearing on the ongoing Burr conspiracy proceedings.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

der. But there is a humane and liberal principle in the English law upon this subject, which those exclusive republicans who are ready to justify general Wilkinson, by considering the persons accused by him guilty of the actual commission of the crime of treason, either do not know, or are not

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This report describes Burr submitting to judicial authority in New Orleans and later being acquitted for lack of prosecutable crime under existing law. It is largely a passionate defense of General Wilkinson against attacks from Burr's associates, arguing Wilkinson saved the Republic by exposing the conspiracy.

Lynchburg Star · 2 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

could reach and punish.

Thus acquitted, the coadjutors of Burr, with rankling vindictiveness, commenced the yell of vengeance—and, like artful necromencers, strove to divert the general attention from themselves, their chief, and his fell purposes, to the man who at the risk of fortune, fame, and life, had boldly traced their iniquitous steps and arrested them on the threshold of treason. They who had daringly looked forward, through robbery and murder, to the destruction of the liberties of the people, appealed, audacious caitiffs! to the constitution of their insulted country. They denounced, boldly, the commander who had prevented the accomplishment of their traitorous project, and complained, unblushingly, of being deprived of the rights of citizens! The press, which should be alone the vehicle of virtuous sentiments,

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A correspondent reports that Aaron Burr was apprehended around February 18th near the Spanish line and escorted under guard to Richmond, arriving at the Eagle Tavern. He awaits examination before General Marshall pending the arrival of Attorney General Rodney, having already been visited by several gentlemen including Wickham and Randolph.

Lynchburg Star · 2 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

expedient to seize on or pass Baton Rouge." All this proves that the enterprize was unlawful. Why place detachments at different points under different pretences? Why want the officers' commissions? Why seize on Baton Rouge, if the undertaking was legal? Honorable enterprize does not need a pretence: he must have wanted the commissions for a sinister purpose; and the question of seizing on Baton Rouge was very unlike a justifiable procedure. In all the letter there is not a word of acting by authority from the U. States—Burr quoted a higher power—"The Gods (says he) invite to glory and fortune."

See moreSee less

By appealing to plural deities, it is likely he meant the Heathen Gods; for surely none else would "invite" him to such a diabolical business. (a) See the conversation held by Gen. Wilkinson with Swartwout, Bollman, & Alexander—the latter (his declaration of innocence to the contrary notwithstanding) averring vehemently that "It (the conspiracy) will succeed—Burr will be here (at New-Orleans) the beginning of [next] month. Vide the President's communication to Congress of the 26th of Janua-

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A correspondent reports that Aaron Burr was captured near the Spanish line in February and escorted under guard to Richmond, where he awaited examination before Chief Justice Marshall. The report notes visits from his counsel and claims the general opinion in Richmond was that Burr would not even be committed for further trial.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Lynchburg Star · 2 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A Duel was fought last month, opposite Natches, between Cowles Meade, Secretary of the Mississippi Territory, and Captain Robert Sample, of Wilkinson county. The first fire was ineffectual; but at the discharge of the second, Mr. Meade received a wound in his right thigh, of which he was fast recovering.

A letter from Commodore Rogers (says the Boston Palladium) states, that after he had conveyed the Tunisian Ambassador home, he heard observations from him, that induced him to apprehend a rupture between Tunis and America

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A note sewn into a coat links a boy riding Burr's horse to a coded message urging followers to arm and reunite; the Governor arrested some 50 of Burr's adherents in Natchez before releasing them for lack of evidence. Another account places Burr crossing the Ohio River near Kentucky, bribing a ferryman for passage toward Vincennes.

The Wheeling Repository · 2 April 1807 · page 6

BURR. From NATO IF.'/., Feb. 17. On Tuesday morning last, a negro hoy, the property ol Doctor Cummins, of Bayau Pierre, came to the house of M r. \\ illiam Fairbanks, near the mouth of Cole s creek, and inquired the road to this city. He was riding the same horse that ( ol. Burr rode from Wash ington, and was also w airing his surtout coat. Mr. F. immediately stopped anti examined the hoy, and nicelv stitched in the cape of the surtout, he found the following note: II you are together, keep together, i and I w ill join you to-morrow night;-— In the mean time put am.

See moreSee less

vour arms in I perfect order. Ask the hearer no qties tions, hut tell him all you may think f 'I' '. ”1. to k nf’w. He does not k now that this is front me, nor where I am. “ c. t. & i). f.” Besides the above note, the Boy had a puss, and an open letter, on private business, directed to Mr. Douglass, of Concordia. Mr. 1* airhanks thought it necessary to s< cure him, and send him to the Governor, who immediately had all Col. Burr’s adherents who were in the city, f>.> in number, arr-sted,and kept under military guard for 2 ' hours when they were s t at liberty. All their boats at the river were also sei/. <1, and a guard placed over them ; they were examined next day by the Governor, and no military stores of any kind being found, they were discharged.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A speaker in the House argues against subjecting Burr to military custody and transport to a distant territory for trial, insisting due civil process and habeas corpus must be respected. He raises hypothetical scenarios questioning the legitimacy of military seizure and warns against using accusations of treason to justify extralegal measures.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

no tales. I will put a case. I will suppose Aaron Burr a conspirator against the U. S.;—a traitor.—Let him die.—If so, I would hear the sentence pronounced with pleasure.

But suppose another thing—suppose a conspiracy has been going on for se-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This piece defends General Wilkinson's harsh, law-bending measures against Burr's co-conspirators in New Orleans, arguing that though technically illegal, his actions were justified by the gravity of the treasonous plot. It also reprints Gov. Claiborne's earlier message recommending suspension of habeas corpus, which the legislature rejected as unconstitutional.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE (BALTIMORE) AMERICAN

what would these gentlemen have? They cry, Wilkinson has violated the laws, and played the tyrant! It is admitted that he has violated the laws—that he has acted with a stern mind and a steady hand against the conspirators. Is his conduct justifiable? To violate the laws is by no means justifiable; but on the other hand to defeat a conspiracy against the unity and freedom of the states is highly praiseworthy. The laws condemn Wilkinson, but the public opinion applauds his motive. Every man says his conduct has been illegal, but every candid man acknowledges that in his situation he would have acted in the same way—In fine, may it not be said, in the language attributed to a Senator of the U.

See moreSee less

S. that—Wilkinson may be fined and imprisoned, but the nation will thank him. The handbill follows:

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A slave boy riding a horse and wearing a coat belonging to Aaron Burr was stopped near Natchez while asking directions, and a hidden coded note was found in the coat's cape instructing recipients to keep together and arm themselves. This discovery led Governor Williams to order the arrest of several men who had traveled down the river with Burr, though they were later released on parole pending legal examination.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Early yesterday morning, a negro boy belonging to Dr. John Cummins, of Claiborne county, appeared at the house of Mr. Fairbank's, near the mouth of Cole's creek, enquiring the road to Natchez.—He rode a horse recollected by Mr. F. as belonging to col. Burr.—The surtout coat which the boy wore was also recognised as one belonging to Mr. Burr; the suspicion of Mr. F. was excited, and he examined the negro

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A letter from Richmond reports that on Attorney Hay's application, Chief Justice Marshall issued a warrant for Aaron Burr on a charge of treason, and Burr appeared before him at chambers. Burr was granted bail pending continuation of the examination the next day, with the hearing expected to resume at the Capitol.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY. FRIDAY, APRIL 3.

Extract of a letter, dated Richmond, March 30th.

"Col. Burr continued in the custody of the party who brought him from the southward until this day, when he was taken by the marshal, and carried before judge Marshall. I understand (for the examination was private) that he was prayed in commitment on two grounds. The first for having been guilty of treason; the other for raising an armed force, with an intention of carrying on hostilities against a power at peace with the U. States. They have gone through the proof relating to the first charge, and will proceed to an investigation of the proof as to the second to-morrow. The general impression here is that Mr. Burr will be discharged. The judge allowed him to enter into a recognizance this day in the sum of 5,000 dollars for his appearance before him to-morrow morning at 10 o'clock, when it is expected the examination will be [c]losed."

See moreSee less

A Chillicothe paper of the 21 ult. contains a letter, received from St. Louis, which states the arrest and holding to recognizance, on a charge of conspiracy, major Robert Wescott, col. John Smith, and Henry Dodge.

See the clipping

In the story →

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report describes the geography between the Mississippi and Tombigbee/Alabama rivers, debating whether Burr intended to flee into Georgia or into Spanish Florida. It also recounts land-office registrar Perkins's midnight encounter with Burr and an associate, and his growing suspicion of their identity.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ARREST OF [illegible]

We have taken particul[illegible] correctness of the accoun[t] which we detailed in [illegible] versed with his esco[illegible] we have discovered [illegible] more accurate than w[illegible] The following stat[illegible] more correct, an[illegible]

See moreSee less

He was arrest[illegible] bruary, instead o[illegible]

We have obtai[illegible] country, from the [illegible] which the eye can [illegible] situation of places, t[illegible]nish line, and to the road lea[illegible]tates. It is certainly impossible by [illegible] [de]scription in words to lay these particulars before the reader ; but a few remarks may at least elucidate the most interesting points ; particularly if they will acompany these remarks by a reference to Bradley's latest edition of his map of the U. States.

The town of Natches, in the Mississippi Territory, where A. Burr's Boats were deposited, is on the river Mississippi.

About 200 miles to the east of this river is the Tombigbee river; which with the Alabama river, conspire to form the Mobile. The Tombigbee is the western; the Alabama, the eastern branch.—Four miles below the point of confluence, is Fort Stoddart situated on the Mobile; and about 12 miles above the Spanish Florida line.—A body of water connects the Tombigbee and Alabama branches at a certain distance above their point of confluence and forms an island; or as it has been called a cross cut.

A ferry leads over the Tombigbee into this island; through this island the road runs to a ferry over the Alabama ; thence the road leads to the east of the Alabama to a certain point; where the road diverges in two directions. The one road leads to the east through the Creek Country, over the limits of Georgia, into the Atlantick states. The other sweeps to the south, crosses the Spanish line, and thence advances to Pensacola.

And here is the principal point in dispute. A. Burr is said to have asserted that his route lay through the Creek country into Georgia ; some people suspect that his route was through the southern road. According to his own reputed representation, he intended to remain within the jurisdiction of the U. S. According to the suspicions of certain people, it was his intention to seek an assylum in the Spanish possessions.

Mr. Perkins is the register of the land-office, in the part of the Mississippi Territory which is to the east of Pearl river.—He keeps his office at the court-house of the county of Washington. His own lodgings are at Fort St. Stephens, [illegible] miles above the court-house. Mr. Perkins was in his office, about 12 or 1 o'clock of the night of the 18th of February, when Aaron Burr and Ashley appeared before him. The scene which ensued between them is not materially dissimilar from the one which was sketched in our last paper.

The reflections which followed it in Mr. Perkins's mind, were in one respect different from what he had stated. It was not alone as midnight robbers, that these mysterious strangers appeared to his imagination ; the idea also occurred to him that one of them might be col. Burr. This idea was the result of a letter, which he had received from a member of the legislative council at Natchez, stating the escape of col. Burr, and the probability that existed of his passing through Mr. P's village.

But whether they were robbers or one of them was col. Burr, it seemed to him too important a matter to be passed into neglect. He determined to repair to major Hinsen's house. He was accompanied by his friend the sheriff of the county. They reached the major's house about 12 o'clock. The mysterious strangers had arrived before them.—Ashley was in [illegible]—col. Burr was in the

[illegible]

[illegible]

[illegible] lieut. Gaines, [illegible] Stoddart, four tell, these unfortun[illegible] hey met colonel fate, were, in the [illegible] It is useless to strength became ex[illegible] which ensued. It [illegible] being conducted offspring, closely [illegible] s's return to the the abys[illegible] of the

As there was no [illegible] follow me to the lief from the boat [illegible] ressed to him by threatened speedil[illegible] he met Ashley; to embark the la[illegible] Hinsen's house early in the small boats of t[illegible] particular commission we shall to hover around [illegible] conjecture. Our business is Swinton accord[illegible] boats to approa[illegible] nce to the facts, and not with comments.— [illegible] attempted to retrace his steps, and return [illegible] barke[illegible] the court-house. It would be di[illegible] comments, to account [illegible] ey; it is still less our [illegible] ns' letter to the colo [illegible] to arrest Mr. Ash [illegible] in company with [illegible] the conversation former's des[illegible]

[illegible] the conversation former's des[illegible] visit to that [illegible] the court [illegible]ch Ashley would hav[illegible] all of them must [illegible]—for the surf, which b[illegible] from the hour we struc[illegible] [illegible]me to such height, tha[illegible] [illegible]me near the ship.

[illegible]t was now about 6 o'c[illegible] [illegible]e who remained with [illegible]ily more desperate [illegible]is companions [illegible]of preser[illegible]

movements of the Spaniards, and it [illegible] determined on, to bear col. Burr as soon as pos[sible] [to th]e Atlantick states. As lieut. Gaines could [not] conveniently spare a sufficient number of his [o]wn men to form an escort, he requested Mr. Perkins to ascend the Alabama river, and collect a company. He promised to meet him with his prisoner. Every part of this arrangement was punctually fulfilled; and col. Burr was regularly delivered into the hands of his escort.—Enquirer.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report continues an account of President Jefferson's communication to Congress regarding the Burr conspiracy, including General Wilkinson's letter revealing Burr's agent made offers to enlist the army. It describes Burr's dual objectives of severing the western states and attacking Mexico, with the Washita land purchase serving as a cover story.

The Enquirer · 3 April 1807 · page 2

THE CONSPIRACY. \_C.oncluded.~\ The Prefident in his communication to Con grefs. fays : “ By ii letter received from that officer (VVil kinfon,) on the 25th Nov. but dated Od. 21 ft, w-e learnt that a confidential agent of Aaron Burr had been deputed to him with communi cations, partly written in cypher, and partly oral, explaining his defigna, exaggerating his rcfourccs, and making fuch offers of emolument and command, to engage him and the armv in his unlawful entcrprir.e, as he had flattered himfelf would be fuccefsful. The general with the honor of a foldicr, and fidelity of a good citizen, immediately difpatched a trufly officer to me with information of what had pnfl'ed, proceeded to eftablifh fuch an underftanding with the Spanirti commandant on the Sabine as permitted him to withdraw his forces acrofa the MiflifTippi, and to enter on meafures for op* poling the projected enterprife.

See moreSee less

" 1 he generals letter winch came to hand on the 25th of Nov. as has hern mentioned, and fome other information, received a few days earlier, when bro’t together, developed Burr’s

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Defense counsel argue that testimony against Burr, including Eaton's deposition, is unreliable and self-contradictory, and that Burr's actions reflected legitimate plans involving the Ouachita Grant and possible war with Spain. Burr himself addresses the judge, citing his two prior acquittals and arguing no probable cause exists given that civil tribunals in Kentucky and Mississippi had found him innocent.

The Enquirer · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

dence in this cafe, was altogether uncertain and illegal, that the deposition of Gen. Eaton contained its own self-condemnation, and that the flight of Colonel Burr, as it was termed, by the counsel for the prosecution, was nothing more than a wish to avoid military persecution. No reason, he contended, exifted why the United States were unprepared with testimony. They had chosen this place as the scene of action, and dragged Col. Burr to it. Sufficient time had elapsed since the first apprehension of Col. Burr to take affidavits, tending to prove the facts charged, if he had really been guilty.

Mr. Randolph on the same side made an eloquent address to the feelings of the audience, and pursued nearly the same train of reasoning adopted by Mr. Wickham.

See moreSee less

(Col. Burr's counsel asserted that his objects were of a nature to be useful to the U. States. As far as they ventured to develope them, it was said to be his intention to assist the U. S. in case of a war with Spain, which seemed at that time a probable event; and to settle the Ouachita Grant, from which point it would be at least in the power of Col. Burr, to be a useful auxiliary to his country against its enemies.)

Col. Burr then arose and addressed the judge. He principally relied on his two former acquittals, and enquired whether there was probable cause to suppose him guilty, when in Kentucky and the Mississippi territory, where the greatest alarms had been excited, the civil tribunals had pronounced him innocent.

(Col. Burr spoke about 10 minutes. He dwelt upon the unfounded alarms (as he called

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The report covers closing arguments by Attorney General Rodney in the Burr case, followed by Chief Justice Marshall's adjournment to prepare a written opinion. The next day, Marshall delivered his opinion on the standard of 'probable cause' required to commit Burr on charges of treason and of organizing a military expedition against a friendly nation.

The Enquirer · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The U. S. vs. A. Burr. }on a motion for a commitment.

I am required on the part of the Attorney for the U. States to commit the accused on two charges.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report describes the public continuation of Aaron Burr's examination before the Chief Justice of the United States at the Capitol, after a private session the day before. It outlines the charges against Burr, including a misdemeanor for setting on foot a military expedition against Spanish territory and treason for assembling forces to seize New Orleans.

Virginia Argus · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

publicly continued at the Capitol. Between 10 and 11 o'clock, a very numerous audience were assembled, and waited some time for the person accused (who had been admitted to bail) to make his appearance in conformity with his recognizance. At length Col. Burr presented himself, and apologized for not attending pre-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This report covers courtroom arguments over whether Aaron Burr should be committed for trial on charges of treason and of launching an expedition against a friendly nation. Chief Justice Marshall's opinion is quoted, explaining the legal standard of 'probable cause' required for commitment, distinct from the higher standard needed for conviction.

Virginia Argus · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

to have sent it on immediately. Mr. Burr himself made a speech, in which he endeavored to give an account of his transactions, so as to make it appear that they had been innocent; relying greatly on his two acquittals (as he called them) in Kentucky and in the Mississippi Territory. On Wednesday morning the Chief Justice delivered the following opinion.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 3 other papers

The court examines testimony from General Eaton and General Wilkinson to determine if there is probable cause that Burr actually levied war, as required for a treason charge. The judge concludes that conspiracy or intent to commit treason is distinct from the actual commission of treason, and that Wilkinson's letter, per Supreme Court ruling, suggests an expedition against Spanish territory rather than the United States.

Virginia Argus · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

revolutionizing the western states.

That this plan, if consummated by overt acts would amount to treason, no man will controvert. But it is equally clear that an intention to commit treason is an offence entirely distinct from the actual commission of that crime. War can only be levied by the employment of actual force. Troops must be embodied, men must be assembled, in order to levy war. If Col. Burr had been apprehended on making these communications to general Eaton, could it have been alledged that he had gone farther than to meditate the crime? Could it have been said that he had actually collected forces, and had actually levied war?—Most certainly it could not. The crime really completed was a conspiracy to commit treason,—not an actual commission of treason.

See moreSee less

If these communications were not treason at the instant they were made, no lapse of time can make them so. They are not in themselves acts. They may serve to explain the intention with which acts were committed; but they cannot supply those acts, if they be not proved.

The next testimony is the deposition of general Wilkinson, which consists of the letter already noticed, and of the communications made by the bearer of that letter.

This letter has already been considered by the supreme court of the United States, and has been declared to import, taken by itself, or in connection with Eaton's deposition, rather an expedition against the territories of Spain than of the United States. By that decision I am bound, whether I concurred in it or not. But I did concur in it. On this point the court was unanimous.

It is, however, urged that the declarations of Swartwout may be connected with the letter, and used against Col. Burr.

Although the confession of one man cannot criminate another, yet I am inclined to think that, on a mere enquiry into probable cause, the declarations of Swartwout, made on this particular occasion, may be used against Col. Burr. My reason for thinking so is that Col. Burr's letter authorises Mr. Swartwout to speak in his name. He empowers Mr. Swartwout to make to general Wilkinson verbal communications explanatory of the plans and designs of Burr, which Burr adopts as his own explanations. However inadmissible, therefore,

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 8 April 1807
  • Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va. · 16 April 1807
  • The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 30 April 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

The report presents a judge's legal reasoning on whether Aaron Burr's alleged recruitment of men constitutes 'levying war' under the law, referencing the prior Bollman and Swartwout Supreme Court ruling. It parses the meaning of testimony about Burr raising an armed force of 7000 men for an expedition against Mexican provinces.

Virginia Argus · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

quiry. The first piece of testimony relied on, to render this fact probable, is the declaration of Mr. Swartwout, that "Col. Burr was "levying an armed body of 7000 men from "the state of New York, and the western "states and territories, with a view to carry "on an expedition against the Mexican "provinces." The term "levying," has been said, according to the explanation of the Lexicons, to mean the embodying of troops, and therefore to prove what is required. Although I do not suppose that Mr. Swartwout had consulted a dictionary, have looked into Johnson for the term, and find its first signification to be "to raise;" its second, "to bring together."

See moreSee less

In common parlance, it may signify the one or the other. But its sense is certainly decided by the fact. If, when Mr. Swartwout left Col. Burr, which must be supposed to have been in July, he was actually embodying me

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 8 April 1807
  • The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 30 April 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

A letter reports that Colonel Aaron Burr passed through the Creek Nation under guard of ten men as a U.S. prisoner. Another report states he is being taken to Richmond, Virginia, to await trial before the Federal Court, based on the claim that his expedition originated from Blennerhassett's Island in Virginia.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY, March 24.

Col. Burr.—The following is an extract of a letter, dated Cohetic, Creek nation, the 4th of March, received by a gentleman in this city, on Saturday evening.

See moreSee less

"Yesterday Colonel Aaron Burr passed here conducted as a prisoner of U. States, by a guard of ten men."

Col. Burr again.—We have just received certain intelligence that the exe-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The Richmond Enquirer revises its earlier account of Aaron Burr's arrest, stating he was actually taken on February 19th rather than March 3rd as first reported. The piece includes a detailed geographic description of the arrest location near Natchez and the Spanish territorial line, based on information from an escort member.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 6 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ARREST OF AARON BURR

ley's latest edition of his map of the U. S.

The town of Natchez, in the Mississippi territory, where A. Burr's boats were deposited, is on the river Mississippi.

See moreSee less

About two hundred miles to the east

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Aaron Burr was examined privately before Chief Justice Marshall, with only counsel and a few witnesses allowed in the room, causing public discontent at the secrecy. He was released on $5,000 bail, with Gamble and Taylor as sureties, to appear again at the Capitol.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 6 April 1807 · page 3

From tut-'. A'ugus. Macamina'ion of Col. Aaron Burr. On this day, between the hours of tw lv< ocl nio'clock, the exiimi'ia tion ofc 1. Burr c I r*t»thi Ivi ! .n, in this city, bl for Chief | lustii ■ M i'r h 11. A I .l-L-e number of C tiaens hud Colltfctei . in order to hear t,..-- inve.'tig-ition. g'-e.tsur prize of many of tin in, ci 1, Bun, .t t'-■'.■ '■■ I v his c itmsel, wat conducted to a private room, iv a r.-tir d p;irt of the hov,se, and the door* imnn finitely !.

See moreSee less

None were admitted into tbe room but'the counsel for the U. States rmd el. Burr, i >.c,-.nt one Witness, and t'.vo*>r three gentlemen, the connexions of aumt of the Counsel. Conside rable disn mint whs expressed by many of the citizens at this uhuiu.il m d of ;>~ .ceedinij; but with that dtv c')' v ii winch characterises the people of Virginia, no violence of any kind was •1 ; n«ir was any thing heard but in irrnurs ef i-approbation. The re sultoi this enquiry was, that col, Burr \vi s recognized in the sum of five thou sand dotlars, to appear io-inorrow at the Capitol, to be further dealt with as »he law directs. He had no difficul ty in procuring bail for the sum de mand d. Messrs John Gamble and Thomas Taylor, merchants of this place, were admitted as his bail. It is expected that an animated dis cussion will trtV.e plac* to-morrow.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

Multiple dispatches report Aaron Burr passing through various Southern towns under armed guard as a state prisoner en route to Washington. The report also notes Jefferson's displeasure with a treaty and other unrelated foreign and domestic news items.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 6 April 1807 · page 2

most flourishing town in the District of Maine, are to be humbled in the dust; or whether, like Sampson, unsuspicious I ot tne dangers which surrounded you, and too confident of your powers, you have been lulled into sleep, while your enemies have been watching to deprive j you ot your strengh. Their arts have been successful. Already has vour bright fame which before 1807 shone with such splendor, been tarnished by the unhallowed touch oi democracy.... Federalists of Portland /—Will you 'not make one efl’ort to restore its for mer glory ?—Are not the best interests your town j the prosperity and dig will rgain “ lift up hi* tune ’ for some bn c.

See moreSee less

kbw-york, march 26, 1207. A letter from Cadiz, da’ed, Jmcan 23, lbdi, savs, “ Art outer h;:s just aniud tr.iru Madrid ■, reduefitg the rpiarauLr.e <>n vessels from the Northern Stales cf Ameri ca to iitteen days, and on those from the southern to twenty.” Mr. Burr is said to have passed through Cowbetee, .he 4th March, under guard, as a State prisoner, tor VVxsuington. Wt*.n tw/i this StateJurcc have an end? The Pennsylvania papers say, that the “ democratic,” alias “ republican,” alius “ mtid,*’ abas any-thing but federal Gov tn - or ?»1 ri.e a v, will he\n,peaclie: by hisbrotht r den o:rats of the LegisLiure. Somuefr for me “ harmony,” exist,i.g*in a State, where all the branches are “ rep lI>i icon." in New-England iwo cats tied by their tails, and swung across a post, are said to make “ harvioay”

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A hidden note signed 'C. T. & D. F.', believed in Burr's handwriting, was discovered sewn into a boy's coat cape, instructing the recipient to keep armed men together and await Burr. The boy was arrested, the letter sent to Governor Williams, and several men who had traveled downriver with Burr were detained and later released on parole pending legal examination.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"C. T. & D. F." The boy was immediately taken into custody, and the papers transmitted to governor Williams, by whose order a number of persons in this city who descended the river with col. Burr, were arrested. A guard was stationed on the bank of the Mississippi to take charge of the boats of his party (lately arrived) and another at Mr. Michies, where the arrested persons were collected—they have since been liberated on their parole, and are to undergo a legal examination, which it is expected will take place this day or to-morrow.

The billet is evidently in the hand writing of Burr—the circumstance, however, of the boy's being in possession of his horse and coat, has given rise to a conjecture by some that he intended the detection of the billet, in order to divert the attention of the officers of government from the route he has taken to escape. We have understood that an order has been given to arrest Dr. Cummins, and therefore suspend any opinion on the motives which induced the writer of the note until possessed of further information on the subject. The circumstances attending its detection, were unquestionably sufficient to warrant the measures pursued by the executive, on the occasion.

See moreSee less

BALTIMORE, April 1. The following is the "Letter from a member of the legislature of the territory of Orleans, to his constituents.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A member of the Orleans territorial legislature writes to constituents describing secret session debates in January 1807 over General Wilkinson's warnings of a Burr-led invasion of New Orleans. The writer expresses skepticism of Wilkinson's evidence and suggests Wilkinson himself may be implicated in the very conspiracy he denounced.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

New-Orleans, February 1807.

"Sir, and Friend,

See moreSee less

"Conformably to a law passed the last session of the legislature of this territory, approved the 7th of June, 1806, the chamber of representatives assembled the 12th of January last, and on the following day the governour of the territory made his communications, which in my opinion are not, on any ground, either important or interesting, though very long, possessing little or nothing of information, and recommending (solely from an economical motive) a short session. On the following day our chamber entered upon business and continued with closed doors until the 24th of the same month, when the members were relieved from the secrecy which had been imposed upon them in so extraordinary a manner. The subject of debate during the secret sittings was the present state of the territory, in consequence of the communications made by gen. Wilkinson in person, and of observations upon some of our members, who from pusillanimity, and want of character, were afraid to express their opinions to the public, lest they should incur, by that, the displeasure of gen. Wilkinson, to whom they are entirely devoted.

The substance of the communications of general Wilkinson went to shew the imminent danger which threatened the city of New-Orleans and its environs, by the invasion which had been projected by col. Burr, whose object was to make an attack on New-Orleans and to pillage the banks: afterward

See the clipping

In the story →

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The paper reports that the evidence before the Chief Justice would not support a charge of treason, so Burr is to be tried only for a misdemeanor, setting on foot a military expedition against the dominions of the king of Spain, and is again admitted to bail; the charge, it says, is serious but falls very short of treason.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR.—The mail in course, north of Petersburgh did not reach this place on Saturday, which prevented us from receiving and laying before our readers so copious a detail of the circumstances attending the result of the publick examination of Mr. Burr, as we had expected. The only article of information on this subject which we believe reached this place by the last mail is the following, which is extracted from the Petersburgh Intelligencer of Friday.

MORE OF BURR.

See moreSee less

"We learn from Richmond, that a publick discussion and examination of Burr's case was held at the capitol on Tuesday; when it was determined that his trial should commence at the Federal Circuit Court, to be holden in Richmond next month—he was again admitted to bail, himself in 5000 dollars and five securities in 2000 dollars each—his securities are Harry Heth, John Hopkins, John Gamble, Thomas Taylor, and a col. Swainburne.

Colonel Burr will be tried on an indictment for a misdemeanor in setting on foot within the territory of the United States a military expedition, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of the king of Spain, with whom the United States were then and are now at peace."

From this it appears that the evidence produced before the Chief Justice, on behalf of the U. States, was not sufficient to support the charge of treason, it is for misdemeanor only that Mr. Burr is held to answer.

The crime wherewith Mr. Burr is charged, and held to answer at the next court, is certainly a very serious one, and if substantiated by evidence will merit punishment, but it falls very short of treason.

As we expect by mail a particular account of their examination, we shall postpone any further observations on the subject at present.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This editorial discusses the newspaper's approach to covering Aaron Burr's ongoing treason proceedings, pledging to avoid inflammatory rhetoric while correcting false statements from another paper. It specifically denies claims that the administration had hired counsel at Richmond or made offers to Wickham and Wirt.

The Enquirer · 7 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

LUCIUS.

While Aaron Burr continues before the tribunal of crimes, fome difficulties will occur in the manner of difcharging our Editorial duties. It is difficult for us

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This item refutes rumors that Aaron Burr was treated with indignity while being escorted through Virginia counties, stating his guard showed proper civility and only restricted communication for security reasons. It also corrects claims about how attorneys Wickham and Randolph came to represent Burr, clarifying they were retained the day after his arrival rather than through some improper solicitation.

The Enquirer · 7 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tionable authority, that Col. Burr was treated with every civility which was consistent with his situation. There was no indignity in the conduct of his guard; no insult; no unnecessary harshness calculated to wound the feelings of their prisoner. Major Perkins did not permit him to hold any conversation with his guard or himself on the subject of his arrest; nor did Col. Burr make such an effort, more than once. But this expedient was dictated by the duty of keeping his prisoner safe. Major Perkins was charged to deliver him into the possession of the officers of the general government; and it was therefore his

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Representative John Randolph argues in Congress that any military commander who defies the Constitution to suppress Burr's conspiracy is as much a traitor as Burr himself. The debate centers on definitions of treason and the propriety of punishing habeas corpus violations with death.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

death? I say he is a traitor. A commander in chief of an army, who, on his own responsibility, puts the constitution and laws of his country at defiance, is a traitor, and supposing the case stated at New-Orleans to be correctly stated, the commander in chief is as much a traitor as any other man concerned in the conspiracy. Who are these traitors? Burr and Co. What are they about to do? To put down the civil authority by military force; and is there any substantial difference whether the civil authority is trampled under foot, by Burr and his banditti, or by a commander in chief and his regular army. I will go further. Suppose these measures for putting down Burr shall eventually prove to have been measures

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report describes Aaron Burr's examination continuing from the Eagle-Tavern to the Capitol before Chief Justice Marshall, with a large crowd of citizens present. It also clarifies the circumstances behind the initial private examination, defending it against charges of being a secretive, inquisition-like proceeding.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COMMUNICATION.

The examination of col. Aaron Burr, which commenced in private at the Eagle-Tavern, in this city, on Monday last, was continued on Tuesday at the Capitol, before the Chief Justice of the United States, and in presence of an immense assemblage of the citizens. Col. Burr had been recognized to ap-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The U.S. attorney Hay argued before Chief Justice Marshall for Burr's commitment on charges of organizing a military expedition against Spanish territories and treason against the United States. He cited testimony from Eaton, Wilkinson's deposition, disclosures from Bollman and Swartwout, Burr's flight, and his failure to appeal to a magistrate as evidence of guilt.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

treason gainst the U. S.

He cited Blackstone's Commentaries to shew that on a mere question to commit a person accused of a crime, nothing more was necessary than to shew a probability that he had been guilty of it. To require more in this incipient stage of the proceedings, particularly in a country of such thin population and extensive territories as the U. S. would be to hold out an invitation to perpetrate crimes with a certainty of avoiding punishment. In support of these charges, the testimony of Gen. Eaton; the deposition of general Wilkinson, and the disclosures made to him by Bollman and Swartwout were relied on. The treasonable intentions of colonel Burr being clearly established, enough appeared to render it highly probable that he had committed the overt act required by the constitution to consummate the offence. In addition to this testimony, his flight from the Mississippi territory, and the evidence of major Perkins, by whom he was conducted from the Tombigbee, where he was apprehended, to this place, stating his attempt to appeal to a magistrate in the state of South Carolina, were adduced as strong circumstances to prove his guilt.

See moreSee less

[Mr. Hay adduced other reasons for a commitment; among others that the executives and legislatures of Ohio and Kentucky had sanctioned by their own acts the probability of some treasonable conspiracy.]

Mr. Burr's attempt to escape from the hands of his escort is thus represented; in passing though the town of Chester, in S. C. the first town of any size that they visited, Mr. B. suddenly alighted from his horse, and threw himself among the small crowd, which had collected to see the cavalcade. He told them that he was A. Burr; dragged by a military escort, without any warrant, and contrary to the laws of his country. Major Perkins however immediately followed, seized, and replaced him upon his horse. The crowd manifested no disposition to interfere in the business.]

Mr. Wickham, in behalf of col. Burr, combatted with great ingenuity the arguments of Mr. Hay. He contended that facts establishing the guilt of the accused ought to be proved before any inference of a treasonable design could be drawn, so as even to warrant a judge in committing for trial; that the evidence in this case, was altogether un-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A judicial opinion examines a letter allegedly written by Burr describing a military enterprise, concluding there is probable cause to proceed on charges related to an expedition against the United States or a foreign power. The report then turns to the second charge of high treason, noting it as the most serious accusation possible against the state.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

that the key was previously in possession of Wilkinson. If this was the fact, the letter being written in a cypher previously settled between himself and col. Burr, is in this stage of enquiry at least, a circumstance which sufficiently supports that the letter was written by col. Burr.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Chief Justice Marshall ruled there was insufficient evidence to commit Aaron Burr on the charge of treason, but found probable cause for a misdemeanor charge of preparing an expedition against Spanish territory. Burr was committed on that lesser charge, with local gentlemen volunteering to post his $10,000 bail until the May court session.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR'S COMMITMENT.

charge:—But that, on the probable ground of a misdemeanor, in setting on foot or preparing an expedition against the Spanish settlements; the deposition of general Wilkinson, when coupled with the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report praises the defense arguments of Mr. Wickham, Edmund Randolph, and Burr himself during the proceedings, noting a forthcoming fuller publication by Henning and Munford. It also comments favorably on Chief Justice Marshall's handling of the case, including his decision to commit Burr for further trial on a higher charge.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR'S COMMITMENT

Randolph, in a lofty, and at one time, pathetic strain of sublime oratory, strowed over the trodden path of debate anew, with delightful and enchanting observations. Mr. Burr himself closed the defence, with a most concise and pithy narration of his transactions, and the extraordinary proceedings against him. But in all this, it is hoped the publick will be more fully gratified by a publication now preparing by Messrs. Henning and Munford, in whose faithfulness and skill it is believed we may place much reliance.

It would be improper, at this time, to enter fully into the merits of col. Burr's case; both as it

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The piece argues the government should face equal scrutiny for its treatment of Burr, criticizing selective prosecution while sparing General Wilkinson despite similar implicated guilt. It then transitions into printing Chief Justice Marshall's opinion on the motion to commit Burr on charges of organizing a hostile expedition and high treason.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

By their own rules of testimony, is meant one of the principles contended for by the prosecutors for the United States, in the case of col. Burr.—Those gentlemen both contended, that the opinion of the chief justice himself, in the case of Bollman and others, were sufficiently to decide the propriety in his own mind as to the commitment of col. Burr. Let those gentlemen now look at the same judges opinion in col. Burr's case, as it relates to general Wilkinson—and say, whether an application to commit him also, will not be more proper, than a subpoena, to summon a partner in guilt, or strongly implicated, as a witness?

See moreSee less

Hence it is highly fortunate indeed, that this case should have come before this highest of all judicial authorities in the United States. If the persons accused are guilty, it will be the means, it is hoped, of producing a general, and not a partial execution of justice upon all concerned. But, should only a few remain singled out for prosecution, and those prove innocent after-all the extravagant persecutions we have seen; we can only then applaud the course taken by the judge, as perfectly upright and correct in the parts

See the clipping

In the story →

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A court hearing discusses the amount of bail for Colonel Burr, with Judge Marshall setting it at $10,000 for the misdemeanor charge. Burr's securities appear later that day at the Capitol to post bail, while a commodore's affidavit arrived too late to be used in the examination.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Judge Marshal then observed, that he should not commit col. Burr on the charge of treason; but that he should hold him to bail, on the charge of setting on foot a military expedition against the dominions of Spain: That with respect to the amount of bail, he had made up no definitive opinion. He wished it to be neither too large, to amount to oppression, nor too small to defeat the objects of justice. It had occurred to him, that the sum of 10,000 dolls. would perhaps avoid both these extremes.

Mr. Hay was in favour of a larger sum. He had no doubt, from the spirit which had been manifested, that col. Burr could obtain bail to almost any amount he pleased. The day before, col. Burr had obtained bail for 5000 dolls. and he believed without any solicitation on his part

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham had supposed that 5 or 6,000 dollars would have been sufficient. It was only on the misdemeanor that it was to be given. With respect to the possibility of obtaining bail to any amount, he was unable to express any opinion; it was a subject with which he was personally unacquainted. But as to the spirit which it was said had been manifested, he could say, that he had heard several gentlemen declare themselves unwilling to appear as bail for col. Burr, lest it should be ascribed to a spirit of opposition to the administration.

Col. Burr rose and observed, that if the government was to pay him for the losses it had made him sustain, 40,000 dollars would not indemnify him. And yet this circumstance might operate against his obtaining bail to a large amount.

Mr. Hay replied.

The judge then observed that he should fix the bail to 10,000 dollars, and that he would meet col. Burr at the Capitol at 3 o'clock to receive it.

At 3 o'clock, the judge met the parties: when Messrs. Thomas Taylor, John G. Gamble, John Hopkins, Henry Heth, and —— Langborn appeared as his securities.

Enquirer.

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This editorial argues that Aaron Burr's ruin was caused not by misfortune but by his own ambition and lack of virtue, citing his conduct during the 1800-1801 presidential contest as evidence. It concludes by noting that this same ambition is now manifesting again, as Burr stands charged with treason.

Lynchburg Star · 9 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ed him with all its interest.

No. it was NOT misfortune, which has involved the ruin of col. Burr. It was not that blind goddess, which sometimes mars and destroys the best and wisest of men. It was his own imprudence; it was his own want of virtue. It is true that he was once near the top, and is now at the bottom of the wheel: but it was not the revolution of Fortune's wheel, which is the cause of this vicissitude. It was the consequence of that vicious indiscretion, which knows not how to regulate its wishes by its means, nor to wait with patience, till time itself shall have prepared the means of gratifying its desires.

See moreSee less

Was col. Burr ill treated, du

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Attorney Harper addresses the court regarding the improper use of the President's message as evidence in Burr's commitment, calling such doctrine dangerous and unconstitutional. He proceeds to review the evidence for commitment, arguing that depositions from several witnesses who only repeat hearsay from General Wilkinson should be disregarded.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The sole purpose for which they had introduced the President's message, was to show that the assemblage of a military force by col. Burr, was a matter of notoriety. They had not attempted or wished to use the message as direct evidence.] Mr. Harper proceeded. I recollect the learned gentleman's explanation, and I take up the matter on that explanation. I say that to use an executive message in a court of justice for any purpose of proof whatsoever, so as to aid in the commitment of a citizen under a criminal accusation; to introduce it as evidence of any fact, of notoriety for instance, which is a fact; is to give it the effect of testimony, and is a direct and palpable breach of the constitution.

See moreSee less

I am warranted in calling such a doctrine dangerous and novel. I should be warranted in bestowing on it a much harsher epithet. I would do so did I not believe, that it was introduced on

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

An attorney argues before the court that depositions from several witnesses should be disregarded since they merely repeat General Wilkinson's statements rather than offering independent knowledge. The speaker further questions the reliability of Wilkinson's own recollection of conversations from months earlier, suggesting memory errors could distort the testimony used to establish treasonable intent.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Those gentlemen know nothing of their own knowledge. They merely repeat what they heard from gen. Wilkinson, or what they saw him do. Were it necessary to support the credibility of his testimony, by showing that he told the same story at other times, and that he was seen conversing with the person whose conversation he relates, these depositions might perhaps be received for that purpose. But it is not the credibility of gen. Wilkinson, but the legal operations of the facts stated by him, that we are now to consider.

See moreSee less

The depositions of these three gentlemen, therefore, have nothing to do with the case, which rests on the facts disclosed by gen. Wilkinson and gen. Eaton, the two remaining witnesses. Gen. Eaton's deposition comes first in order of events, and on it the main reliance is placed for establishing the treasonable intentions imputed to col. Burr—but when we inspect this deposition, we instantly perceive, that it relates, after a very

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This piece argues that General Eaton's recollections of conversations with Burr, written down months later, are likely distorted by common memory errors that blend separate statements into false meanings. It uses the example of an alleged assassination plot against the president to show how such misremembering could unfairly convert Burr's speculative talk into a wicked conspiracy.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

he states, render it extremely probable that he has fallen into some mistakes of this kind. Now by misplacing detached phrases, by applying to one subject observations which were made in reference to another, he has not only misconceived the nature of col. Burr's operations, but has converted mere conjectural speculations about things that might be done, in certain supposed and possible cases into projects that were to be attempted. Col. Burr, for instance, talked at some times of invading Mexico, for which an armed force would be necessary. Soon afterwards, perhaps in the same conversation, he talked about a separation of the western states f[rom t]he union ; a measure which no man in his [senses c]ould suppose it possible to effect in any oth[er mann]er than by the consent and the act of the pe[ople] themselves, and which colonel Burr represented those people as having a natural and inherent right to effect.

See moreSee less

Col. Burr would na turally speak of a military force with

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A defense lawyer argues that the letter attributed to Burr is unreliable testimony due to falsehoods it contains, and questions General Wilkinson's credibility as a witness. He raises suspicions about Wilkinson's use of cipher communications with Burr, suggesting prior indiscreet dealings that undermine his trustworthiness in accusing Burr, Bollman, and Swartwout of treason.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Thus much of the letter imputed to col. Burr, which forms the basis of gen. Wilkinson's testimony. Let us now take some notice of gen. Wilkinson himself. Let us enquire how far the situation in which he stood qualified him for giving him a correct and credible account of the facts concerning which he speaks. He accuses Burr of treasonable projects—he accused Bollman and Swartwout of participation in this treason. How far was his situation favorable to a correct discernment of the truth? What motives had he for heightening to the utmost the colouring of the facts?

We must recollect in the first place, that this letter was written in cyphers which gen. Wilkinson understood. How did he become able to understand it? I answer that he must have had a key. When was this key furnished? Why was this cypher agreed on? I know not; but I know that such circumstances induce strong suspicion that gen. Wilkinson had previously been engaged, in some very indiscreet communications with col. Burr. It was very indiscreet for the commander in chief of the troops, and the governor of a remote province, to be engaged in communications which required the mystery and concealment of a cypher. This first indiscretion places gen. Wilkinson on very suspicious ground.

See moreSee less

It was soon followed by another, still greater. This mysterious letter, so mysteriously understood, was received early in October. The day is not mentioned, but suppose we say the tenth, which is giving the utmost admissible lattitude to the vague term "early." The communications by Swartwout were then made. These communications disclosed, according to Wilkinson's mode of understanding Swartwout, that Burr was levying a military force of seven thousand men with which he was to ascend the Mississippi, revolutionize the territory of Orleans, and seize and plunder the city of New-Orleans as the first step towards the invasion of Mexico. The project being as general Wilkinson says, that he understood the matter in a course of actual execution, it is plain that no time was to be lost. Yet gen. Wilkinson, very imprudently, suffered Swartwout quietly to depart, omitted for sixteen days to send off a dispatch to the government, with this important intelligence; and, what was still more indiscreet and extraordinary, neglected for a much longer time, to adopt any measures for protecting New Orleans, or the ports above it on the river, against the attack which might be expected. Why did he omit all these obvious and necessary precautions? I know not, but I know that it was very imprudent, and that by that imprudence his conduct was rendered still more suspicious, and his situation still more critical.

In fact, by this succesion of imprudent steps, he had advanced to the very brink of a precipice, into which he was ready to plunge and from the jaws of which it was difficult to retreat. Aware at length, of his danger and pressed by the urgent necessity of making some desperate effort to save himself, he resolved to oppose openly and vigorously Burr's project, and to begin by seizing Swartwout and Bollman, by military authority, and in defiance of the principles and the forms of law. Having taken this bold and dangerous step, he found it necessary to provide the means of his own justification. This was best to be done, by loading Burr and all his associates with the odium of rebellion and treason; and by presenting the facts in such a point of view, as to support this charge. After such conduct, and under such impressions, gen. Wilkinson sits down to recollect conversations which had taken place two months before, and draw up an affidavit, which is to furnish the justification of his own proceedings, the vindication of his own character.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A defense attorney argues that even if the Mexico expedition was unlawful, the motives of its organizers deserve sympathy rather than condemnation as treasonous. The speaker challenges the reliability of General Wilkinson's testimony against Swartwout, noting the two-month delay before accusations were made and Wilkinson's potential self-interested motives.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ed by treasonable acts, or accomplished by treasonable means. New Orleans, it is said, was to be seized and plundered; the territory of the United States on the Mississippi was to be revolutionized, as the first step in this expedition. If so, I have nothing further to say; but I ask, where is the proof of the fact? where is the proof that col Burr entertained such a design? where is the proof if he did entertain it, that the persons now before the court were apprised of the design? The letter imputed to col.

See moreSee less

Burr contains no trace of such project. There is no intimation, no allusion which can lead to such an idea; nor does any thing of this sort appear in the deposition of gen. Eaton. But the proof of this design, it may be said, appears in the verbal communications made to gen. Wilkinson, by Bollman and Swartwout.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A defense attorney argues that General Wilkinson's deposition against Swartwout, made two months after the alleged conversations, is unreliable due to Wilkinson's emotional state and self-interest in justifying his own actions. The attorney further contends that Bollman, as Burr's most trusted agent, would have known of any plot to seize New Orleans if one existed, and his silence on the matter during conversations with Wilkinson is strong evidence no such conspiracy existed.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report dissects deposition testimony from General Wilkinson concerning conversations with Bollman about Burr's plans, arguing that no design existed to seize New Orleans or plunder its bank. It contends Wilkinson misused the word 'defence' for 'opposition,' distorting the meaning of Bollman's remarks about traveling routes to Mexico.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

There is, indeed, one expression imputed by gen. Wilkinson to Bollman, from which it might, at first sight, be inferred that he was apprized of an intention to use force against New-Orleans. He tells Wilkinson that Burr must come to New Orleans in order to get shipping and supplies. It is not said or intimated, however, that they were to be obtained by force. Wilkinson replies, "If he comes this way I must oppose him." Bollman, to use general Wilkinson's phrase, "obliqued a sham defence, and waved the conversation." This last expression seemed to imply, that New-Orleans was to be attacked, and that Bollman proposed to Wilkinson to make a mere show of defending it, so as to save appearances and then to give it up.

See moreSee less

But if we attend to the whole conversation, we find that general Wilkinson, in his eagerness to criminate these men, and in the agitation of mind under which his deposition was made, has inadvertently used the word "defence," instead of the word "opposition;" and has thereby varied the whole meaning of the sentence. They were talking of Burr's course to Mexico. Bollman said that he must come by New-Orleans, for supplies and

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A correspondent to the Enquirer notes that Chief Justice Marshall dined with Aaron Burr at Mr. Wickham's house, despite having ruled there was probable cause Burr committed a high misdemeanor. The writer expresses mild surprise at this but insists Burr deserves a fair trial, while also praising Richmond's hospitality toward Burr and his vigorous legal defense.

The Enquirer · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FOR THE ENQUIRER.

In the Argus of the 7th, it is stated, and the fact is now too generally notorious to be doubted, that the chief justice Marshall has dined with Aaron Burr at Mr. Wickham's, since he himself solemnly decided, that there was probable cause to believe Burr guilty of a high misdemeanor against his country. The story has indeed excited some surprise in Richmond, but none of those sentiments of lively indignation, which a stranger from the country would naturally have expected.

See moreSee less

As to Burr himself, I feel towards him the same sentiment I feel towards every man charged with a crime—the wish, that he may have a fair and impartial trial; that if guilty, he may be punished, if innocent, acquitted. His efforts, to whatever end directed, have not as yet been attended with consequences, which can excite in the bosom of a patriot any thing like personal resentment. I heard with pleasure, that Burr on his arrival in Richmond, was readily furnished with the supplies necessary to his comfort: I thought it a signal proof of the generosity of my countrymen. I heard with pleasure, how zealously and ably his counsel had defended him: I thought such exertions honorable to our bar. That his counsel should admit him to the freest communion of a professional nature, and that such intercourse should be conducted on their part with civility and tenderness, even tho' they may think him guilty, I am not disposed to deny; but I insist, that no situation should, (God forbid, that the profession of the law should!) excuse a man, for wanting the ordinary feelings of a citizen towards the violators of the law. And truly, my surprise would have equalled my indignation, had Burr been admitted to the familiarity of private friendship, much more to the house and table, of any man, but Mr. Wickham. This gentleman (if we may listen to the once loud peal of angry fame, which still rumbles, though at a distance) was once himself regarded as a sort of state offender, as an insidious foe to the liberty and independence of the U. States. I shall not vouch for the truth of the shocking charge I allude to, nor discuss its probability. I resign that task to Mr. Wickham, if he think proper, or dare, to encounter it. But if it be true, no wonder Burr's situation should excite his sympathy. I will not press the subject

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

A newspaper writer condemns Chief Justice John Marshall for socializing with Aaron Burr despite Burr being under suspicion of treason and the murder of Hamilton. The piece questions Marshall's judgment and impartiality given that he will preside over Burr's upcoming trial.

The Enquirer · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

enveloped?

What will the people of Virginia, who yet regard the name of John Marshall with a kind of parental fondness, and too faintly condemn the fatal errors, or impious ambition, that led him to desert them—what will the people of the union, who look up to the chief justice, as the head of the third great co-ordinate branch of government, too high to be ambitious, and supported against any fall from dignity by his very elevation, (for such is the impracticable theory of our independent judiciary)—what will they think, how will they feel, when they learn, that the chief justice has feasted at the same convivial board with Aaron Burr?—with whom?--With the very man, of whom that very chief justice has declared, that there is probable cause to believe him guilty of a high misdemeanor against the U. States; at whose trial the chief justice is himself to preside; who is suspected to have plotted schemes hostile to the happiness, the liberty and integrity of the union, schemes which would have rendered the chief justice an alien to his own father; who is charged on the evidence of a gentleman, on whom his country have bestowed many testimonies of esteem, I mean Mr. Eaton--with having entertained the abominable design, or at least imagination, of assassinating the president, dissolving the congress, disrobing the chief justice himself of his ermine, overturning all our sacred institutions, state and federal, and erecting an execrable despotism on the ruins of freedom.

See moreSee less

Whether Burr will be able to repell these charges or not, I shall not pretend to decide; for I do not mean to prejudge him; but I do say, that the evidence they rest on, is sufficient to render him an unfit companion for the chief justice.

I have searched in vain in my own mind, for some apology for conduct so grossly indecent. Perhaps, it may be thought that my understanding is not likely to be very acute on such a subject; but indeed I have heard no excuse offered by any other person.

Surely the chief justice does not pretend to be the private friend of Burr; if so, I beg leave to enquire by what services Burr has obliterated from his memory, that very, very horrid deed, which was called the murder of Hamilton? By what merits has he conciliated the good will of all good federalists? Surely not by the appearance of a rebellion against the government?

Was the chief justice ignorant that Burr was to be of the party, to which Mr. Wickham invited him? If so, what are we to think of Mr. Wickham's delicacy towards his friend? If so, why did not the judge leave the house so soon as he discovered the indignity imposed upon him? If so, let that be assigned as the reason, and I shall more rejoice to hear it, than any of those sycophants, of whom the judge boasts so numerous a retinue; for I re-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va. · 23 April 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

The report narrates how Mr. Perkins enlisted Lieutenant Gaines and soldiers to intercept Aaron Burr near the Spanish line, leading to his arrest. It details the subsequent journey under armed escort through Virginia towns toward Richmond for trial.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

from one corner of the U. States to the other. It was A. Burr.

Mr. P. determined to arrest him. He repaired to Fort Stoddart on the Mobile, and prevailed upon lieutenant Gaines (the commandant at that Fort) to accompany him with a small file of soldiers.—In the mean time, Col. Burr had sent back his companion (by the name of Ashly, whose name was mentioned in our last paper, under the Frankfort head) for some purpose unknown; and requested his new companion the sheriff, to shew him on the way to the Spanish line.

See moreSee less

On the road they met the file of soldiers, accompanied by Mr. Perkins and lieutenant Gaines. "What" says Col. Burr, or in words to that effect; "do soldiers travel here in this style; on horseback?" "No:" answered his companion. Col. Burr is said to have immediately dropt his bridle, and clasping his hands together, to have uttered some ejaculation of vehement emotion; what that was, we cannot trust ourselves to describe.—Lieutenant Gaines advanced up to him, and interrogated him, whether he was not Col. Burr. The scene closed, by Lieutenant Gaine's ominous words:

"You are my prisoner, sir."

An escort of eight men accompanied col. Burr from that quarter of the country, on their way to Washington. They crossed at Cole's ferry; on Monday morning, between the hours of 11 and 12 they passed Prince Edward court house. On Wednesday evening, about 5 o'clock, they arrived in Fredericksburg. Here they met with a gentleman from Washington, who was instructed to order them to Richmond; and on last evening the stage conveyed them to our city; Col. Burr and his escort of seven men—The gentleman who met them at

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 1 April 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The report describes Aaron Burr's arrest in Richmond by the U.S. Marshal and his examination before Chief Justice Marshall on charges of treason and a misdemeanor related to an expedition against Spanish territory. Burr was granted bail with two sureties, and a public investigation was scheduled at the Capitol the following day.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 10 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, April 1, 1807. On Monday last, about 12 o'clock, Col. Burr was taken into custody by the Marshal of the District, Major Scott, on a warrant on the part of the United States: Soon after which, Col. Burr was removed from his lodgings, and conducted by the Marshal to another room in the Eagle Tavern to be privately examined before Chief Justice Marshal. Edmond Randolph and John Wickham, Esqrs. appeared as counsel for Col. Burr; and Cæsar A. Rodney and George Hay, Esqrs. as prosecutors on the part of the United States.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay informed the Court, that it became his duty, as Attorney for the district, to charge Col. Burr, the prisoner then before the court, with the Crime of treason against the United States, and of a misdemeanor of his having been engaged in setting on foot within the United States an expedition against the King of Spain, and its territories, with which the United States were at peace. After going thro' the evidence that was adduced on the part of the United States, it was determined that there should be a public investigation held at the Capitol the next day at 10 o'clock, and that Col. Burr should be admitted to bail, on his giving security in the sum of 5000 dollars. Thomas Taylor and Mr. John Gamble are his bail. The investigation was proceeding yesterday when we were obliged to put our paper to press.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report states that former Vice President Aaron Burr is held as a state prisoner in Richmond, Virginia, soon to face trial before the U.S. Circuit Court on a charge of high treason. It notes the irony that Judge Chase, whom Burr once presided over during his 1804 Senate impeachment trial, will now preside over Burr's case.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 13 April 1807 · page 2

Col, Burr. The Ex*Vice President is now a State f prisoner, in Richmond, (Virginia) and short I ly will have his trial before the Circuit Court of the U. S. on the charge of high treason. Judge Chase will jr mot. In 1804 J tdge Chase was impeached before t * Senate of the United States, and Col. Bum, was then e*-officio President of the Court—A good comment on the instability of this world’s honours.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A communication reports that Aaron Burr dined with Chief Justice Marshall at Wickham's house after Marshall had already ruled there was probable cause to believe Burr guilty of a high misdemeanor. The writer expresses astonishment that Marshall would socialize with Burr given his official role as the judge who will preside over Burr's upcoming trial.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 13 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COMMUNICATION. It is reported, and we are sorry to say that the fact appears indisputable, that col. Aaron Burr and the chief justice of the United States dined together at Wickham's, since his examination, and since his honour had himself solemnly decided that there were probable grounds to believe him guilty of a high misdemeanor against the United States. We acknowledge that the rites of hospitality ought not to be refused to this unfortunate gentleman by those who believe him innocent; but confess our astonishment that men, whose intellects are so penetrating as those of Mr.

See moreSee less

Wickham and Mr. Marshall, did not perceive the extreme indelicacy and impropriety of such respect being paid him by the judge who is to sit hereafter on his trial, and who, by his own opinion officially pronounced, had affixed a stigma on his character, which can only be wiped off by his future acquittal.—(Argus.) From a Jamaica paper of March 16. The following is translated from the Periodical American Redacteur, of January 19, printed at New-Grenada, in South-America.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The Richmond Enquirer relays a secondhand account, obtained from Burr's escort via a fellow stagecoach traveler, describing the circumstances of Aaron Burr's apprehension in early March near the Spanish line. The report explicitly cautions readers that it may be imperfect and promises corrections if errors are detected.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 14 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

From the Richmond Enquirer of March 27. Aaron Burr, ex-vice-president of the U. States, is now in this city; guarded as a state prisoner.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · and 1 other paper

The report describes how Mr. Perkins grew suspicious of two mysterious travelers at a tavern and alerted Lt. Gaines and soldiers to intercept them. One of the strangers was identified as Col. Aaron Burr, who was apparently trying to reach Spanish territory before being stopped by the armed party.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 14 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

...the kitchen, to warm his shivering limbs.

The first glance, which Mr. P. caught of this visitant of the kitchen, convinced him that the mysterious stranger was no other than Col. Burr: whether Mr. P. recognized him from a previous acquaintance with his person, or from the fire of his eye, the shape of his face and person so well corresponding to the description which he had received of him; the gentleman with whom we had conversed, was incompetent to inform us. Certain it is; Mr. P. suspected that the stranger who stood before him with his white hat slouched over his face and with all the habiliments of a man so perfectly different from those in which he commonly appears, was the very man, whose name had rung for several months from one corner of the U. S. to the other. It was A. Burr.

See moreSee less

Mr. P. determined to arrest him.—He repaired to Fort Stoddert on the Mobile, and prevailed upon lieutenant Gaines (the commandant at that fort) to accompany him with a small file of soldiers. In the mean time, Col. Burr had sent back his companion (by the name of Ashley,) for some purpose unknown; and requested his new companion the sheriff, to show him on the way to the Spanish line.

On the road, they met the file of soldiers accompanied by Mr. Perkins and lieutenant Gaines. "What," says Col. Burr; or in words to that effect; "do soldiers travel here in this style; on

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 31 March 1807

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report narrates Aaron Burr's arrest near the Spanish Florida line by Lieutenant Gaines and his subsequent journey under armed escort through Virginia to Richmond. It explains that he will be examined before Chief Justice Marshall, with the overt act of treason believed to have occurred at Blennerhassett's Island within Virginia's federal jurisdiction.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 14 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

some ejaculation of vehement emotion; what that was we cannot trust ourselves to describe. Lieut. Gaines advanced up to him, and interrogated him, whether he was not Col. Burr. The scene closed, by L. Gaine's ominous words: "You are my prisoner, sir."

An escort of eight men accompanied Col. Burr from that quarter of the country, on their way to Washington. They crossed at Coles' ferry; on Monday morning between the hours of 11 and 12, they passed Prince Edward court-house. On Wednesday evening, about 5 o'clock, they arrived in Fredericksburgh. Here they met with a gentleman from Washington, who was instructed to order them to Richmond; and last evening the stage conveyed them to our city; Col. Burr and his escort of 7 men. The

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The writer recounts skepticism expressed by others that Burr actually wrote the cipher letter attributed to him to Wilkinson, noting the style seemed unfamiliar to Burr's known manner. He also clarifies that he first learned of Burr's alleged plan to sever the union from Western newspapers, though Burr had mentioned intentions regarding Spain, Vera Cruz, and Mexico in case of war.

The Enquirer · 14 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

which could not have been the case in the original letter, as every one who knows Mr. Burr, must know that he is ever too concise to give himself the trouble, in the body of a letter, of using the initial of a name and then explaining it by a note.—Hence I considered this attention as another mark of the good disposition manifested to honor me, in the present day, at the seat of government, by some good friend, and laughed, and invited others to laugh at it. "It is said here, and published in letters from Washington, but from whom I know not, that Mr.

See moreSee less

Burr has declared, that he never wrote any letter to Wilkinson in cypher. Nay, it was previously stated to me by some very respectable gentlemen, that they did not believe Mr. Burr could have written the letter in cypher attributed to him, and I must confess, though I did not doubt at the time, from the manner in which that letter came to Washington, and had publicity, that the language and style is not such as I should consider most familiar to Mr. Burr, or likely to be used by him. I have, therefore, determined to say little on the subject until, from some sort of light, a better judgment can be formed. "The intention of Mr. Burr, as has been stated, to sever the union (a most diabolical project) was first suggested to me by Western newspapers; and the attack on New-Orleans was entirely new to me until I saw the acts of the governor and legislature of Ohio. But it is true, that Mr. Burr did tell me that, in case of a war between the United States and Spain, which he considered inevitable, he intended to attack Vera Cruz and Mexico, give liberty to an enslaved world, and establish an independent government in Mexico; and inviting me to take command of the expedition by sea. But altho' this enterprise was expressly mentioned to me as to take place in case of a war between the United States and Spain, I at once declined it, on asking if the Executive of the United States was privy to, or concerned in, the project, and being answered that he was not; though I said then, and I say now, I shall always be ready as I ever have been, when properly invited by my country, to turn out against any nation with whom we may be at war. "Should I have occasion to appear before a court of Justice, in this business of Mr. Burr's at any time, under the solemn obligation of an

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 15 April 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This editorial argues that General Wilkinson should be fully acquitted of involvement in Burr's conspiracy and praises his patriotic service. It challenges Chief Justice Marshall's reasoning, given in his opinion on Burr's examination, that Wilkinson may have possessed the cipher key before receiving Burr's letter.

Virginia Argus · 14 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

circumstances and motives of the parties. With respect to gen. Wilkinson, we are now satisfied that he ought not only to be acquitted of being concerned in Burr's conspiracy, or in any other evil designs, but that he acted from the purest motives, and has rendered essential services to his country. Chief Justice Marshall, in the opinion delivered by him on the examination of col. Burr, has indeed insinuated very strongly that Wilkinson must have been at one period concerned in the conspiracy, or at least have been too intimately connected with Burr in his projects.

See moreSee less

This insinuation is contained in that part of his opinion in which he speaks of the letter in cypher; a key to which he supposes was, most probably, in the possession of Wilkinson before he received it. The reason given by the

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The piece disputes Chief Justice Marshall's reasoning about the cipher key in Wilkinson's letter, arguing the key could have been communicated separately rather than needing to accompany the letter. It then pivots to accuse Federalists of hypocrisy for sympathizing with Burr despite his killing of Hamilton and his alleged designs to subvert the republic.

Virginia Argus · 14 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WE will beg leave to ask the federalists a few questions in these critical times.

1. How comes it to pass that they view the situation of Aaron Burr with so much more fellow-feeling and compassion than are manifested by the republicans?

See moreSee less

2. Is it because he slew their great friend and leader at New-York, (for whose death they made such heavy lamentations,) so long ago that they have now forgotten that event? or have they so much charity for a gentleman in distress, that all his crimes are of course obliterated from their memories?

3. Did they lament the loss of Hamilton, not through any affection for him as a man, but only because his death cut short the great designs he meditated of revolutionizing the United States, and introducing a more energetic government?—and are they now reconciled to Col. Burr, and receive him, as the worthy successor of Hamilton & head of their party, because his designs are the same with those which he prevented Hamilton from executing?

4. If Col. Burr had been accused of any crimes except those of endeavoring to subvert our republican government, and of striving to involve our country in the horrors of war; would any of them have been his friends and associates?

If the federalists would give candid answers to these questions, in words, as they have already in deeds, they would deserve

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · 2 June 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report relays shipping and consular news from St. Jago-de-Cuba, including a rumor of an express from Burr to Alston. It also presents a firsthand account from a man who lodged with Burr before his arrest, disputing claims that Burr was heading toward Spanish territory and asserting he was arrested without warrant or formal charge.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 15 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Since our last publication we have seen a gentleman from the western country, who states that he lodged with col. Burr at major Hinson's, the night previous to his arrest, and that the colonel left major Hinson's in company with Mr. Brightwell, the high sheriff, whom he had requested to ride with him over the Tombigby river, to the Allatama settlement, he being then on his way to South-Carolina—that after travelling about a mile and a half, they were met by major Perkins and lieut. Gaines, who arrested col. Burr, and in two days afterwards made up a guard, and set off to conduct him to Washington City.

See moreSee less

Our informant states, that the colonel was apprehended without any warrant, and underwent no examination before any civil officer after his arrest, nor was he informed of any particular charge against him—His baggage was left on the way to Tombigby, where it was to have overtaken him. Our informant adds, that the statement about col. Burr's enquiring the way into the Spanish dominions, or sending his baggage there, is not true, as he was himself engaged to accompany the colonel to S. Carolina, and had started for that purpose; and that after the colonel was arrested, he came on by himself. He adds also, that he heard col. Burr in conversation say, that he had never written to gen. Wilkinson one sentence of the letters ascribed to him. He also adds that col. Burr remained at Washington two days after his discharge, and after the adjournment of the court, and then set off for Carolina, under an apprehension that he might be delivered to the officers of the gun-boats near Natchez, and conveyed to general Wilkinson, whom he had no wish to visit in that way. This statement we give as we received it. Our informant on Saturday last left this place for Carolina, on his way to Washington City. Augusta Herald.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

In a letter to Joseph Alston, Commodore Truxtun denies rumors linking him to Aaron Burr's western schemes, noting he refuted the claims to congressmen in Washington. He also notes reports that Burr denied ever writing a ciphered letter to General Wilkinson, and questions the authenticity of the published version's marginal notes identifying 'T' as himself.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 15 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

GEORGE-TOWN, (S. C.) March 28.

Extract of a letter from Commodore Truxtun, to the Honourable Joseph Alston, dated Philadelphia, February 24, 1807.

See moreSee less

DEAR SIR,

"It is scarcely necessary for me to say, that since the peace with France, I have not been off the continent of America, except in April, 1802, making a passage from Norfolk to Amboy. A considerable time, however, previous to the President's message to congress, accompanied by a copy of a decyphered letter, stated to be a communication from col. Burr to gen. Wilkinson, I had heard of ungenerous whispers, extremely unpleasant to me, and afterwards received advices from my friends at Washington, that information had been given to the government, from the westward, or New-Orleans, in which I was noticed as concerned in the projects of col. Burr. This calumny I immediately refuted by

prompt letters of denial, directed to several mem-

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

Aaron Burr was admitted to bail by Chief Justice Marshall, required to appear before the Federal Court on May 22 under $10,000 penalty, with several prominent citizens standing as his securities. The report also expresses shock that Marshall dined with Burr after ruling there was probable cause he committed a misdemeanor, noting the irony of Marshall once being tried similarly under Burr's presidency in the Senate.

Lynchburg Star · 16 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

mond, before which it is believed Burr will appear to answer for the offences by him said to be committed. How slippery is fortune! But a little while since and judge Chase was arraigned before the senate of the U. States where Burr sat as Chief Judge, to answer charges of the most serious nature, preferred against him—and now he sits as Chief Justice on the case of Burr, who is arraigned as a traitor!

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

The report states that Commodore Truxton's deposition, recently received by the U.S. attorney, is understood to strongly confirm General Eaton's earlier affidavit. It claims similar treasonable proposals were made by Colonel Burr to Truxton as those alleged to have been made to Eaton.

Lynchburg Star · 16 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

It is understood that the deposition of commodore Truxton, lately received by the attorney for the United States, contains strong confirmation of the truth of Gen. Eaton's affidavit; since it appears that similar treasonable proposals were made to commodore Truxton, by Col. Burr, with those alledged by Gen. Eaton to have been made to him.

Burr killed Hamilton—and the faction denonuced him! he traduces the administration, and forms a plan to discover the union—and now, forsooth, the federalists are offering their lives, their fortunes, to protect the traitor!!!—Inconsistency, thou art the child, the offspring of faction.

See moreSee less

Republican

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va. · and 2 other papers

Chief Justice Marshall examines whether sufficient probable cause exists to commit Aaron Burr, analyzing the testimony of General Eaton and General Wilkinson. He scrutinizes the admissibility of Wilkinson's affidavit, particularly a letter purportedly deciphered from Burr, questioning whether it can legally support the charges.

Lynchburg Star · 16 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MARSHALL

tation of the innocence of the accused.

In enquiring, therefore, into the charges exhibited against Aaron Burr, I hold myself bound to consider how far those charges are supported by probable cause.

See moreSee less

The first charge stands upon the testimony of general Eaton and general Wilkinson.

The witness first named, proves that among other projects, which were more criminal, col. Burr meditated an expedition against the Mexican dominions of Spain. This deposition may be considered as introductory to the affidavit of gen. Wilkinson, and as explanatory of the objects of any military preparations which may have been made.

I proceed then to that affidavit.

To make the testimony of general Wilkinson bear on col. Burr, it is necessary to consider as genuine the letter stated by the former to be, as near as he can make it, an interpretation of one received in cypher from the latter. Exclude this letter, and nothing remains in the testimony which can in the most remote degree affect col. Burr—That there are to the admissibility of this part of the affidavit, great and obvious objections, need not be stated to those who know with how much caution proceedings in criminal cases ought to be instituted, and who know that the highest tribunal of the United States has been divided on them.—When this question came before the supreme court, I felt the full force of these objections, although I did not yield to them. On weighing in my own mind,

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 3 April 1807
  • The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 23 April 1807

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A judicial opinion examines whether General Wilkinson's affidavit, describing a ciphered letter allegedly from Aaron Burr, provides sufficient probable cause to proceed to trial. The judge reasons about the likely prior existence of a shared cipher key between Burr and Wilkinson, finding the evidence suggestive though not conclusive.

Lynchburg Star · 16 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

by which this knowledge is obtained.

Thus gen. Wilkinson states that this letter was received from col. Burr, but does not say that it was in his hand writing, nor does he state the evidence which

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A letter from Lt. Gaines at Fort Stoddert recounts how he and soldiers intercepted and arrested Col. Burr on February 19, 1807, after being tipped off by Major Perkins. Gaines also describes refusing a Spanish officer's request to visit the imprisoned Burr, citing Burr's status as a U.S. citizen under federal charges.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 17 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The following extract of a letter received from lieutenant Gaines, dated Fort Stoddert, February 22, 1807, furnishes some interesting circumstances relative to the arrest of col. Burr.

"Early in the morning of the 19th of the present month, I was advised by major Perkins that a man, whom he supposed to be col. Burr, had passed thro' the upper end of this settlement the preceding evening; whereupon I immediately set out with a sargeant and three privates of my detachment; and after reconnoitering with major Perkins about 14 miles up the country, met with col. Burr, and escorted him to this place. My apprehensions relative to the Spaniards were strengthened by the arrival of a Spanish officer, who commands o[ne of the] armed vessels at Mobile (whose name I [cannot] collect.) He dined with me yesterda[y, and sent a] request through his interpreter, to be [permitted to] see col. Burr, who he said, he unde[rstood was at] the fort. I promised to see the colo[nel, and] give him an answer. I went to the colo[nel] and informed him that the Spanish officer wi[shed to] see him.

See moreSee less

"He immediately shewed me a paper he had just written, in which he requested me to introduce him to the Spanish officer, adding that he was anxious to send to his friend Moralles for a few necessaries. I observed that perhaps it was nothing more than the idle curiosity that prompted the Spanish officer to wish to see him, and I could not, under the present circumstances, admit an interview. I returned and informed the Spanish officer, through his interpreter, that as col. Burr was a citizen of the United States, and in confinement for an offence against the laws thereof, I could not permit an officer of a neighbouring government to see him, especially as I presumed they could have no sort of business with each other. The officer immediately set out in a small boat for Mobile. This circumstance, together with a communication, made by a Mr. Ashley, who accompanied col. Burr to this country, to one of our citizens, has induced me to adopt a

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

The report details the circumstances of Aaron Burr's capture and transport under guard from Fort Stoddert to Richmond, describing Lieutenant Gaines' precautions against a possible rescue attempt and the conduct of the escort led by Major Perkins. It notes Burr was treated with consideration during the journey, supplied with provisions and allowed to keep his weapons until an escape attempt, after which his pistols were confiscated.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 17 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

which I feel bound to take will be of a much more serious nature than his removal to Washington.

"I have committed the prisoner to the charge of maj. R. Perkins, to whose activity and patriotism the public are indebted for the seizure of this extraordinary man. The major has selected a party of active and respectable men, (See note 2.) to assist him on the route, and he will also be accompanied by sergeant Harris and Cyrus Jones, who were with me when I took the prisoner, and who are amongst the most confidential men of my detachment."

See moreSee less

There was another circumstance, which probably operated strongly on the mind of lieut. Gaines, and which is stated on the authority of maj. Perkins. Information was received in conversation with a Spanish officer, that col. Burr was generally expected at the town of Mobile by the officers there, where also it was reported that Moralles then was. This, together with the immediate departure of the officer from Fort Stoddart, on finding an interview with Mr. Burr unattainable, probably led lieut. Gaines to believe that a rescue might be attempted.

To these circumstances it is proper to add, that col. Burr was treated during the journey with the greatest attention and tenderness. From the beginning to the end of it he was supplied with tea, coffee, wine and brandy, of some of which articles he had even a portion left on his arival at Richmond; and altho' the party were for two or three days destitute of a sufficient supply of provisions, Mr. Burr had allotted to him the same usual quantity. Until the attempt made by him to get out of the power of the escort, he was permitted to wear his pistols and a large knife. After this attempt, he was deprived of the former.

Note 1. The communication here referred to, we understand to be this: While Ashley was in the company of the sheriff, he said he was well acquainted with the objects col. Burr had in view, and among other things stated, that it was his intention to go into the Floridas. On subsequent inquiries made of him by others, he professed total ignorance of the views of col. Burr, and said that he had accidentally fallen in with him. This Ashley is a character of some celebrity. He is reputed to be a man of talents, possesses considerable property, and was with Noland in the Spanish country when he fell.

Note 2. The escort was composed of the most respectable men in the country, some of them possessed of very considerable property, and others much distinguished in their districts.

April 10.

APPOINTMENTS

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 17 April 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A military officer reports refusing a Spanish officer access to the imprisoned Aaron Burr and describes learning of an alleged bribery attempt by Burr to suborn sentries guarding him. Citing security concerns and the risk of rescue attempts, he explains his decision to transfer Burr under guard to the seat of government rather than risk keeping him locally or sending him through Natchez.

The Enquirer · 17 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

relative to the Spaniards were strengthened by the arrival of a Spanish officer, who commands one of the armed vessels at Mobille (whose name I cannot recollect.) He dined with me yesterday, and made a request through his interpreter, to be permitted to fee col. Burr, who, he said, he understood was in the Fort. I promised to fee the colonel, and then give him an answer. I went to the colonel's room and informed him that the Spanish officer wished to fee him. He immediately shewed me a paper he had just written, in which he requested me to introduce him to the Spanish officer, adding that he was anxious to send to his friend Moralles for a few necessaries.

See moreSee less

I observed that perhaps it was nothing more than idle curiosity that prompted the Spanish officer to wish to fee him, and I could not, under present circumstances admit an interview. I returned and informed the Spanish officer through his interpreter, that as col. Burr was a citizen of the U. States and in confinement for an offence against the laws thereof, I could not permit an officer of a neighboring government to fee him, especially as I presumed they could have no sort of business with each other. The officer immediately set out in a small boat for Mobille. This circumstance, together with a communication, made by a Mr. Ashley, who accompanied col. Burr to this country, to one of our citizens, has induced me to adopt a measure, which had

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A political commentary piece criticizes Federalists for softening toward Aaron Burr during his bail proceedings, arguing their newfound sympathy stems only from opposition to Jefferson rather than genuine regard. The writer imagines Alexander Hamilton's ghost confronting his former party for befriending the man who was once his deadliest political enemy and who caused his death.

The Enquirer · 17 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COMMUNICATION

No one can doubt Messrs. John G. Gamble and Henry Heth. As little doubt can be entertained of the political opinions of John Hopkins, Esq. the removed Commissioner of Loans. As to Major Langburn, he has generally passed for a republican; and the admirer of Mr. J. But his politics have not altogether assumed a fixed and consistent character; he is a citizen of the world; of a generous and romantic enthusiasm; and from an acquaintance with Mr. Burr in the army, disposed to befriend him. I perfectly agree in the opinion of the U. S. Attorney, delivered before the court, that M[r.] Burr could have obtained bail for at least 10[0...]

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A Baltimore commentator argues that Burr's New Orleans associates (the Livingstons, Workmans, and Beauregards) have skillfully shifted public attention from Burr's own guilt to attacking General Wilkinson. The writer insists the true question remains whether Burr and his associates are guilty of treason, and promises to present information from a more reliable source.

Virginia Argus · 17 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Germantown, &c. INCONTROVERTIBLE FACTS.

BALTIMORE, April 6. Affairs at New-Orleans.—It cannot have escaped the notice of scrutinizing and reflecting men, that the associates of Col. Burr at New-Orleans have used uncommon efforts to vindicate the actions of themselves and their chief; and it must be confessed that they have exhibited a vast deal of ingenuity and specious cunning in turning the attention of the public from Col. Burr to Gen. Wilkinson. The original and true question was, Are Burr and his Associates guilty of high crimes and misdemeanors, or of treasonable practices? But the associates at New-Orleans have so ably exercised the cunning of misrepresentation—the Livingstons—the Workmans, and the Bradfords have been so industrious in circulating their addresses, their statements, &c. throughout the union, and these have been so unceasingly commented upon by the federal party in a favorable point of view for the real culprits, that the question has got quite off its true bottom, and every one eagerly enquires, Can Wilkinson be justified? In all discussions relative to the conspiracy, it is extremely necessary to determine the previous question first; because, on the decision upon that, depends the fate of the latter. It is not, however, our intention to discuss either of these questions here—We merely wish to draw the public attention to the fact, that all the alarming accounts with regard to any arbitrary conduct on the part of Wilkinson have emanated from the adherents of Burr—and all the arguments adduced by the federal writers against Wilkinson, are founded upon the statements of those who have been inculpated of treason. We now beg leave to lay a little information from a purer source before the public: The following is one of many letters, extracts from which are in our possession, and which come from a genuine American quarter—And we assert it without the fear of contradiction, that the annexed contains the sentiments of the great mass of Americans at New-Orleans:—

See moreSee less

Extract of a letter from a gentleman at New-Orleans of the first respectability, dated March 1st, 1807.

"My last letter informed you, that we were in great dread here of Burr and his adherents. I am happy in being able now to inform you, that these conspirators seem to be completely defeated in their diabolical plots; Burr himself has absconded from Natchez, where he was held to bail, and a reward of 2000 dollars is offered by Governor Williams for his apprehension; and it is reported here that he is actually arrested at or near Fort Stoddert, but of this, however, there is no confirmation. Nothing but the strong measures adopted here by Gen. Wilkinson, & by the government of the state of Ohio, together with the timely proclamation of the President of the United States, saved, or could have saved this country. Had it not been for these I am confident Burr would have had possession of it. I hope he will now meet with that punishment that is due to his crimes."

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The Virginia Argus reports that Chief Justice Marshall denies any insinuation against Gen. Wilkinson in his written opinion on Aaron Burr, though he concedes the wording could be misread. The paper insists its original reading was correct and presses Marshall with pointed questions about a possible cipher correspondence between Wilkinson and Burr.

Virginia Argus · 17 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FRIDAY, APRIL 17, 1807.

THE Chief Justice of the United States has desired us to inform the public that the words used by him in the written opinion, which he delivered in the case of Aaron Burr, import, as he conceives no insinuation against gen. Wilkinson; and has, moreover, declared that none was intended.

See moreSee less

We are happy at being informed by himself that the construction naturally put upon his words was that which it was not his intention they should bear; but we must contend that their plain and obvious import was such as we suggested in the last Argus; of which the public will judge.—When it is considered that virtuous and innocent designs do not stand in need of the cloak of mystery; and that, if gen. Wilkinson and Col. Burr had agreed upon a correspondence by letters in cypher, (which the Chief Justice has declared to be the most probable explanation of the circumstance of Wilkinson's being able to decypher the letter received by Swartwout,) the former must of course have been too intimately connected with the latter in his projects; we trust every candid reader of the opinion of the Chief Justice and of the observations which we made upon it, will be satisfied that we understood it correctly as it was written, though not it seems, as his honor intended. We will intreat permission however, as he seems to be willing to give some explanation of matters, which touch his character very nearly, to ask him a few questions, which we hope he will answer plainly and unequivocally.

If he did not intend an insinuation against gen. Wilkinson in the passage alluded to, what was his intention?

If he believes that Wilkinson and Burr had agreed to correspond in cypher, and that the latter had furnished the former with a key to the cypher, can he conscientiously be of opinion that Wilkinson was not concerned in Burr's conspiracy, or at least, that he had not consented to assist him in some illegal project?

If he believed Wilkinson improperly concerned in the unlawful schemes of Burr, why does he say that he intended no insinuation against his character?

Why did he dine with Col. Burr at Mr. Wickham's?

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 22 April 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A legal notice records that Seaton Grantland deposited the title of a book covering Aaron Burr's examination before the Chief Justice on charges of misdemeanor and treason, including arguments of counsel and Marshall's opinion in the Bollman and Swartwout case. The pamphlet was to be available from Richmond booksellers starting April 11th.

Virginia Argus · 17 April 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA, TO WIT:

BE it remembered that on the fourth day of April, in the thirty first year of the independence of the United States of America, Seaton Grantland, of the said district, hath deposited in this office the title of a book, the right whereof he claims as proprietor, in the words following, to wit: "The examination of Col. Aaron "Burr before the Chief Justice of the U"nited States, upon the charges of a high "misdemeanor and of treason against the "United States; together with the argu"ments of counsel and opinion of the judge, "to which is added, an appendix, containi[n]g "the opinion of the supreme court, deli"vered by Chief Justice Marshall, in the "case of Bollman and Swartwout;" in conformity to the act of Congress of the United States, intituled "an act for the encouragement of learning, by securing the copies of maps, charts and books, to the authors and proprietors of such copies during the times therein mentioned.

See moreSee less

WILLIAM MARSHALL, Clerk of the District of Virginia.

The above will appear in a pamphlet, on Saturday the 11th instant, and may be had of the several booksellers, in Richmond. w4t

BUCKINGHAM COUNTY, FEBRUARY COURT 1807.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A traveler who accompanied Burr writes to contradict a newspaper account (by Mr. Perkins) claiming Burr was in disguise and fleeing to Spanish territory. He asserts Burr was dressed normally, riding openly on the public road toward the Federal City when seized without legal process by Perkins and Lieut. Gaines.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 April 1807 · page 3

S. C, Gazette. Sir, Passing through this plf.ee, on mv Way to the* Federal City, I happened to take up one of your newspapers ami was astonished by the sb.-urd, and no torious false-hoods which Mr. Perkihi has introduced into his account of wiiat V. terms the arrest of col. Burr. I travelled with ehe col. from N it< hz, was with him till within halt an hour of his illegal seizure, and had just then separated from him with an intention ot rejoining him in a few hours. I am able therefore to contradict the above filstdioods from my own knowledge, and being ablt, I ft-< lit an act ot }v - tic.c to do so, Col.

See moreSee less

Burr was neither in j •disguise nor was he going to the Spani

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report describes Burr's examination before Chief Justice Marshall on charges of misdemeanor and high treason, with testimony from Generals Eaton and Wilkinson. Burr spoke in his own defense, denying wrongdoing, and Marshall ultimately declined to commit him but set bail at $10,000.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 20 April 1807 · page 2

BIC HMOND, A TH1L 3, ) #07. MU. BURR—.AGAIN. The examination of Mr. Burr, be fore Chief Justice Marshal, which be gan on Monday, was continued on Tuesday at the Capitol. Mr. Hay, District Attorney, opened the examin ation at id charged (to!. Burr, w ith be ing guilty oi a Misdemeanor^ a« already stated, and High Treason. He addu ced the testimony of (hen. Eaton, Gen. Wilkinson, he. Mr. Wickham, in behalf of Coi. Burr combated the charge. Mr. Randolph (formerly Sec retary of State) followed on the same side.

See moreSee less

They asserted that Col. Burr's objects were of a nature to be servica ble to the C lilted States. Col. Burr addressee! the Judge in a speech of a bout 10 minutes, asserted his Inno cence ;—urged his two former acquit tals in Kentucky, and the Missisippi Territory, declared it to be false, utter ly false, that lie P.ad broken his re cognisance and complained of the treatment ne nao experienced i Ids loss of p» operty (40,0t'0 dollars) from seiz ures ; the hardships received from his guard and being debarred the use if pen, ink and paper. See—He said the alarms were not created by him : but by others ; by the President who had alarmed Gen. Wilkinson, and by Gen. W ilkinson, who had alarmed the city. He c alled Eaton's deposition a crudity he did not understand. The Attorney Gen. Rodney closed ; i-jid the Chief Justice said *;e sfiould deliver his opin ion the next clay in Writing. On the next day the Chief slice gave his opinion at much length jut the close of which r.e observed, he should not commit Col. Purr ; but should hold him to bail, in the stlm of j 10,000 dollars ; which was given ; and i Messrs. Thouxu Taylor, John G. Gatu bti'y John Hcfiking, Hrnry Hrth, and It ilUam Longhumr, became his sure ties—He is recognized to appear be fore the Federal Cou»t, ia Richmond, the 2id May.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

Burr was examined before Chief Justice Marshall on charges of misdemeanor and high treason, with testimony from Gen. Eaton and Gen. Wilkinson presented by the prosecution, while Burr's counsel argued his objectives were beneficial to the United States. Marshall declined to commit Burr but set bail at $10,000, with Burr required to appear before the Federal Court in Richmond on May 22nd.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 21 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, APRIL 3. EXAMINATION.

The examination of Mr. Burr, before Chief Justice Marshal, which began on Monday, was continued on Tuesday at the Capitol. Mr. Hay, District Attorney, opened the examination and charged Col. Burr, with being guilty of a Misdemeanor, and High Treason. He adduced the testimony of Gen. Eaton, Gen. Wilkinson, &c. Mr. Wickham in behalf of Col. Burr combatted the charges.—Mr. Randolph (formerly Secretary of State) followed on the same side.—They asserted that Col. Burr's objects were of a nature to be serviceable to the United States. Col. Burr addressed the Judge in a speech of about 10 minutes, and asserted his innocence. The Attorney Gen. Rodney closed; and the Chief Justice said he should deliver his opinion the next day, in writing.

See moreSee less

On the next day the Chief Justice gave his opinion at much length,—at the close of which he observed, he should not commit Col. Burr; but should hold him to bail, in the sum of 10,000 dollars; which was given; and Messrs. Thomas Taylor, John G. Gamble, John Hopkins, Henry Heth, and William Longburne, became his sureties.—He is recognized to appear before the Federal Court, in Richmond, the 22d May.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Richmond report discusses efforts to discredit Commodore Truxton's deposition against Aaron Burr, comparing his account to General Eaton's similar testimony about Burr's schemes. It argues Burr tested potential recruits with a plan to invade Mexico, intending to reveal further treasonous aims if they agreed, but Truxton halted him before full disclosure.

The Enquirer · 21 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

RICHMOND, 21st APRIL.

An attempt is made to weaken Commodore Truxton's deposition, by means of his late letter to Mr. Alston.—What that deposition contains, it is not yet for the public to determine. We may however enquire;

See moreSee less

Did not A. Burr attempt to unwed him from his attachment to the Navy of the U. S. by re-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A traveler who accompanied Burr from Natchez writes to contradict a prior newspaper account claiming Burr was disguised and fleeing to the Spaniards when seized. He insists Burr was properly dressed, traveling the ordinary road to the Federal City, and was illegally detained by Perkins and armed men without civil process.

The Enquirer · 21 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Country ; he was in the high road to Carson's ferry, on the Tombigby river, which is the direct and only road through Georgia, (3) &c. to the Federal City, to which place he was proceeding, and was accompanied by Mr. Brightwell, the sheriff of Washington County, in the Mississippi territory, whom he had engaged to pilot him as far as the ferry, where he intended to wait the arrival of his servants and baggage, who were at some distance behind. It was in this situation he was stopped by Mr.

See moreSee less

Perkins and Lieut. Gains, with eight or ten men, without the colour of any civil process whatever, and forcibly hurried on a journey of more than a thousand miles ; those who had seized him carefully avoided every town and village, least their conduct might be examined into by some judicial power. When Col. Burr voluntarily surrendered himself at the mouth of the Bayou Pierre, he entered into recognizance himself, in the sum of two thousand dollars, and two sureties in the like sum, to appear before the District Court, which was to be held shortly afterwards, to answer to any bills that might be found against him. He did appear, and the grand jury found no bills against him. The Colonel then demanded a release from his recognizance, which the court refused. Knowing the refusal to be illegal, he troubled himself no further about the recognizance, but set out a day or two afterwards, as I observed, for the Federal City. (4).

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This piece challenges Chief Justice Marshall to answer pointed questions about his relationship with Aaron Burr, including why he dined with Burr at Wickham's and set bail at only $10,000. It accuses him of impropriety and demands he clarify earlier ambiguous remarks about General Wilkinson's involvement.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

If he believes that Wilkinson and Burr had agreed to correspond in cypher, and that the latter had furnished the former with a key to the cypher, can he conscientiously be of opinion that Wilkinson was not concerned in Burr's conspiracy, or at least, that he had not consented to assist him in some illegal project?

If he believed Wilkinson improperly concerned in the unlawful schemes of Burr, why does he say that he intended no insinuation against his character?

See moreSee less

Why did he dine with col. Burr at Mr. Wickham's?

Why did he admit him to bail in the sum of ten thousand dollars only, when he must have been satisfied "from the spirit wich had been manifested," as Mr. Hay very justly remarked, that he could have given bail in one hundred thousand dollars as easily as in ten thousand dollars?

Why did he accept of five securities instead of two?

The Chief Justice may suppose that his not answering questions of the kind proposed, would be considered by his partizans as preserving a dignified silence: but he should recollect that the

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This report discusses naval preparations in Britain against France, then shifts to commentary on Richmond reaction to Chief Justice Marshall dining with Aaron Burr's attorney Wickham, despite Marshall having ruled there was probable cause of treason against Burr. The writer reflects on fair trial principles, Burr's treatment in custody, and Wickham's own past reputation as a suspected foe of American independence.

Lynchburg Star · 23 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

As to Burr himself, I feel towards him the same sentiment, I feel towards every man charged with a crime—the wish, that he may have a fair and impartial tri-

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A newspaper writer criticizes Chief Justice Marshall for dining with Aaron Burr during his treason trial, arguing this compromises judicial dignity. The piece also condemns attorney Wickham for hosting Burr, recalling Wickham's own past suspected disloyalty to the Union.

Lynchburg Star · 23 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

it. But if it be true, no wonder Burr's situation should excite his sympathy. I will not press the subject. Yet Mr. Wickham should have remembered, and having forgotten, should be publicly instructed, that as the people of Virginia have generously forgi-

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A judicial opinion examines whether General Wilkinson's affidavit, describing a coded letter he attributed to Burr, is sufficient to establish probable cause for trial despite lacking the original letter or cipher key. The judge reasons that Wilkinson likely already possessed the cipher key, suggesting prior arrangement between the two men.

The Wheeling Repository · 23 April 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

was obtained. Thus, gen. Wilkinson states that this letter was received from col. Burr, but does not say that it was in his hand writing, nor does he state the evidence which supports this affirmation. But, in addition to the circumstance that the positive assertion of the fact ought not, perhaps, in this stage of the inquiry to be disregarded, the nature of the case furnishes that evidence. The letter was in cypher. Gen. Wilkinson, it is true, does not say that a cypher had been previously settled between col. Burr and himself, in which they might correspond on subjects which though innocent, neither of them might wish to subject to the casualties of a transportation from the Atlantick to the Mississippi; but when we perceive, that col.

See moreSee less

Burr has written in cypher, and that gen. Wilkinson is able to decypher the letter, we must either presume that the bearer of the letter was also the bear-

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A judicial officer analyzes whether a cipher letter attributed to Burr, decoded by General Wilkinson, provides probable cause for a treason-related charge. The judge reasons through the likelihood that Wilkinson already possessed the cipher key and concludes sufficient grounds exist to proceed with the inquiry against the prisoner.

The Wheeling Repository · 23 April 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

er of its key, or that the key was previously in possession of the person to whom the letter was addressed. In stating particularly the circumstances attending the delivery of this letter, gen. Wilkinson does not say that it was accompanied by the key, or that he felt any surprise at its being in cypher. For this reason, as well as because there is not much more security in sending a letter in cypher accompanied by its key, than there is in sending a letter not in cypher, I think it more reasonable to suppose that the key was previously in possession of Wilkinson.

See moreSee less

If this was the fact, the letter being written in a cypher previously settled between himself and col. Burr, is, in this stage of the inquiry at least, a circumstance which sufficiently supports the assertion that the letter was written by col. Burr. The enterprise described in this lett[er]

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Marshal Major Scott arrested Aaron Burr at the Eagle tavern and brought him before Judge Marshall for a private examination. Prosecutors presented the Bollman/Swartwout case record and testimony on Burr's arrest, then moved to commit him for trial at the circuit court.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 24 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

testimony was produced, except that of Mr. Perkins, which related to the arrest of Col. Burr, within the Mississippi Territory.

After this evidence was laid before the court, Mr. Hay submitted the following motion in writing:

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The circuit court record details proceedings against Bollman and Swartwout, followed by prosecutor Hay's motion to commit Aaron Burr for treason and for setting on foot a military expedition against Spanish territories. Chief Justice Marshall ruled there was insufficient evidence for treason but enough for a misdemeanor charge, committing Burr with bail set at $10,000 until the May court session.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 24 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Messrs. Thomas Taylor and John Gamble are his securities. As this affair is at present coram judice, we shall limit our attention to facts alone, without wandering into comments. Of these, enough hereafter. April 4. On Wednesday, the 1st day of April, chief Justice Marshall, pronounced a most luminous opinion on the application for the commitment of this very extraordinary gentleman. The substance of which was, that there was no probable ground from the testimony yet adduced, for believing that Col. Burr had been guilty of treason, whatever might have been the intention; at least that there was not sufficient ground for a commitment on that serious charge: But that, on the probable ground of a misdemeanor, in setting on foot or preparing an expedition against the Spanish settlements; the deposition of General Wilkinson, when coupled with the cyphered lett[er]

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

This report describes Burr's preliminary hearing, where the court found insufficient grounds for a treason commitment but probable cause for a misdemeanor charge of preparing an expedition against Spanish territories. Burr was committed on the lesser charge, required to post $10,000 bail until the next May court session, and several Virginia gentlemen stepped forward to spare him from imprisonment in a dismal dungeon.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 24 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

er from the horrors of a dismal dungeon.

In animadverting on that part of the testimony, on which the commitment was founded; particularly on the key or means which led to the decypher of the letter from Col. Burr to General Wilkinson, the chief Justice does in most pointed and strong terms, as the writer of this article conceived, implicate General Wilkinson in the same offence for which he committed Mr. Burr. And in this there did not seem to be a dissenting voice, as the whole opinion given by the judge appeared to be universally approved and most highly applauded.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A dispatch from Georgetown reports a rumor that an express message passed from Colonel Burr to Joseph Alston, Esq., though the paper does not vouch for its authenticity. It speculates Burr sought documents held by his daughter to prove the guilt of General Wilkinson.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 27 April 1807 · page 2

->--A GEORGETOWN, APRIL 1. It is rumoured that an express from col. Burr to Joseph Alston, Esq. parsed through this place on Saturday last ; the authcntici | ty of which we do not vouch for. In all | probability col. Burr has sent on for docu ments said to be in possession of his daugh ter, to prove thfc guilt of the petty tyrant, Wilkinson. , The Richmond Enquirer of April Tth say*, “ It is nbw almost reduced to a cer tainty, that Mi. Jefferson will retire from 1 the Presidential chair, at the expiration of { his present term.” The same pa|>er contains a column of re 1 marks about a suitable person to succeed !

See moreSee less

Mr. Jefferson—and speaks of Madison and ; Munroe as the most proper persons to bring forward—“ He must bo a republican of a sound heart, and of nerves as rigid as Iron. Not such a man, (says the writer) as Gov. M’Kean, of Pennsylvania, or Lewis of New york, who abuse the principles ofFederal : isvs, while they personally truckle |to the pan; ; who accept their aid, while thi \ pretend to abjure their principles.”

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · and 1 other paper

This editorial argues that the real danger lay not in Burr's conspiracy but in the existence of a standing army that could be misused, noting Burr had no army and General Wilkinson did not betray his post. It contends that national security rests better on justice and reason than on military preparedness, and argues war would not benefit the United States, criticizing non-importation debates as a flawed substitute for principled policy.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 28 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

This question is no longer a point of dispute. It is not now a question about safety without energy or force—the question is changed to its relative—Are we safe with energy?

In answering this question, let it be remembered colonel Burr had no army. Gen. Wilkinson was tempted and fell not: but let it be supposed for a moment, Burr had had an army, or Wilkinson had a little less virtue and carried his army to relieve Burr, what might have been expected? A small army

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 17 March 1807

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

A Republican Advocate editorial mocks Federalist newspapers for contradicting themselves over Burr's conspiracy, noting they once called him a murderer for the Hamilton duel but now defend him against treason charges. The piece accuses Federalists of flip-flopping on whether a conspiracy existed and on the administration's competence.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 28 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The very man who was a few years since denounced as a murderer and an outlaw, has been metamorphosed by the blackest treason, into an honest and peaceable citizen.—Burr, whose guilt must be obvious to every man who does not view the case through the goggles of prejudice, has found a supporter in every federal editor throughout the union—those very editors, who so lately persecuted and hunted him from society, for killing their political deity in a duel.

We have been told of Mr. Jefferson's neglect of duty in permitting the conspiracy to progress so long—we are again told that no conspiracy has existed.

See moreSee less

Gen. Eaton was once a brave soldier, and a man of honour—now he is a liar and defamer.

In one breath they tell us of the imbecility and oppression of the government—of the pusillanimity and "energy" of the President.

One printer says Mr. Burr's intentions were highly honorable—another, that all his followers were democrats! This appears to be the most dreadful blunder of all—federalists linking democracy and

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report criticizes Chief Justice John Marshall for dining with Aaron Burr at Mr. Wickham's house after Marshall had already ruled there were probable grounds to believe Burr guilty of a high misdemeanor. The writer argues this was improper given Marshall would later sit as judge in Burr's trial.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 28 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

It is reported, and we are sorry to say, that the fact appears indisputable, that Col. Aaron Burr and the Chief Justice of the United States, dined together at Mr. Wickham's, since his examination, and since his honor had himself solemnly decided that there were probable grounds to believe him guilty of a high misdemeanor against the U. States. We acknowledge that the rights of hospitality ought not to be refused to this unfortunate gentleman, by those who believe him innocent; but confess our astonishment that men, whose intellects are so penetrating as

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A letter from a Richmond Hill resident describes the anxiety and excitement gripping Richmond's populace during Burr's trial, noting that newspapers present such contradictory evidence that truth is hard to discern. The writer refuses to declare Burr guilty or innocent, citing insufficient clarity, while also remarking on political partisanship (Federalist curiosity) surrounding the spectacle.

The Enquirer · 28 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, 28th APRIL.

Extract from a letter written by a resident of Richmond Hill, to his friend in the country.

See moreSee less

As you insist, my dear F. that I should say something upon the subject of Burr's trial, and its impressions upon the mind of Richmond: you must pardon me, if I am in some measure unavoidably forced into the tedium of repetition. This subject has been presented to the public in such a variety of attitudes, and every incident so fully and minutely scanned, that I fear it is almost impossible to give it an air of novelty. The news-papers of the day teem with such a mass of contrariant evidence, that ingenuity is foiled in extracting the truth, and credulity is put to the test in its belief.

To say that Burr is guilty would be to transcend the rules of justice and to supply an Hiatus of evidence by conjecture. To say that he is innocent would require the infatuation of a bigot, and the assurance of inspiration. Hence we must remain in a state of reciprocal scepticism until the obscurity is removed: for as yet we have but a confused view of the outward form, without being acquainted with the native hue and figure of the design. You cannot conceive, dear F. the state of anxiety and agitation which the arrival of Burr excited in our metropolis, together with the many trivial and ludicrous little circumstances. Every subject, both of foreign and domestic concern was discarded, for the sake of hazarding some conjecture about Burr's conspiracy; "all tongues spoke of him, and the bleared lights were spectacled to see him." Amidst this confusion I could but remark the cunning spirit of federalism, which we thought "quietly inurned," peering above its "cearment" to catch at the dim glimpse of this political comet. I could but fancy that some of the party remarkable for their insipience, expected that the orb of republicanism was about to be consumed. I was astonished at the celerity of their assemblage, and the regularity with which they were marshaled and disciplined to the opinion and conviction, that Burr was the guiltless victim of an

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A satirical letter criticizes federalists for praising Burr despite earlier condemning the duel, while also questioning Chief Justice Marshall's judgment in dining with Burr during his trial. The author argues political opportunism, not genuine belief in Burr's innocence, drives both sides' conduct.

The Enquirer · 28 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the's wharf.

But whilst I feel inclined to ascribe the conduct of federalists neither to charity, nor a belief of Burr's innocence, but to a pragmatic temper of opposition, I hope you will not take it

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A legal notice records that Seaton Grantland deposited the copyright title for a book documenting Aaron Burr's examination before the Chief Justice on charges of misdemeanor and treason. The book will include arguments of counsel, the judge's opinion, and an appendix with the Supreme Court's opinion in the Bollman and Swartwout case.

Virginia Argus · 28 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BE it remembered that on the fourth day of April, in the thirty first year of the independence of the United States of America, Seaton Grantland, of the said district, hath deposited in this office the title of a book, the right whereof he claims as proprietor, in the words following, to wit: "The examination of Col. Aaron "Burr before the Chief Justice of the U-"nited States, upon the charges of a high "misdemeanor and of treason against the "United States; together with the arguments of counsel and opinion of the judge, "to which is added, an appendix, containing "the opinion of the supreme court, delivered by Chief Justice Marshall, in the "case of Bollman and Swartwout;" in conformity to the act of Congress of the United States, intituled "an act for the encouragement of learning, by securing the copies of maps, charts and books, to the authors and proprietors of such copies during the times therein mentioned.

WILLIAM MARSHALL, Clerk of the District of Virginia.

See moreSee less

☞ The above will appear in a pamphlet, on Saturday the 11th instant, and may be had of the several booksellers, in Richmond. w4t

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A traveling companion of Aaron Burr writes to contradict earlier newspaper claims that Burr was in disguise or fleeing to Spanish territory when arrested. He insists Burr was dressed normally, riding openly toward the federal city with a sheriff as guide when illegally seized.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

GEORGETOWN, (S. C.) April 4. We are informed that the rumor, stated in our last paper, of an express from col. Burr having passed through this place, for the purpose of taking on certain papers, supposed to be in the possession of his daughter, which would substantiate the charges made by col. Burr against Wilkinson, is incorrect. No express has been sent on, nor are there any papers in the possession of Mrs. Alston. To the Printer of the Georgetown Gazette. SIR, Passing through this place on my way to the Federal City, I happened to take up one of your newspapers, and was astonished by the absurd and notorious falshoods which Mr.

See moreSee less

Perkins has introduced into his account, of what he terms the arrest of col. Burr. I travelled with the col. from Natches, was with him till within half an hour of his illegal seizure, and had just then separated from him with an intention of rejoining him in a few hours. I am therefore, to contradict the above falsehoods from my own knowledge, and as I am able; I feel it an act of justice to do so. Col. Burr was neither in disguise, nor was he going to the Spani

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Robert Ashley writes to correct the record on Aaron Burr's arrest, insisting Burr was not in disguise nor fleeing to Spanish territory but traveling the main road toward Washington City. He also describes Burr's voluntary surrender, his recognizance bond, and an accusation that Judge Rodney committed forgery regarding that bond.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

mined into by some judicial power.

When col. Burr voluntarily surrendered himself at the mouth of Bayou Pierre, he entered into recognizance himself, in the sum of two thousand dollars, and two sureties in the like sum, to appear before the district court, which was to be held shortly afterwards, to answer to any bill that might be brought against him. The col. then demanded a release from his recognizance, which the court refused.—Knowing the refusal to be illegal, he troubled himself no farther about his recognizance, but set out a day or two afterwards, for the Federal City.

See moreSee less

I have been informed by a gentleman who left Natches some time after me, that judge Rodney thinking the bond which had been given by col. Burr and sureties could not be recovered, had undertaken to draw a new bond which he saved those gentlemen the trouble of signing, by signing it for them; and had surrendered this new bond to the governor as forfeited, for which, my informant added the judge had been indicted for forgery.

I am, Sir, your most obedient Humble servant, [illegible]

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The piece criticizes Democratic newspapers like the Aurora for prejudging Aaron Burr as a criminal before his treason trial has even begun. It argues that every man, however reviled, deserves to be presumed innocent until proven guilty in court.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr.—The democratic papers, as usual, are proceeding to pass sentence upon Burr, as a proper measure preparatory to his trial. The Aurora pronounces him to be a "culprit," an "acknowledged criminal," and declares that "whatever may be the

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

This passage reports part of Chief Justice Marshall's legal opinion addressing the treason charge against Aaron Burr for levying war against the United States. It discusses the constitutional definition of treason, the requirement for two witnesses or open court confession, and begins examining General Eaton's testimony regarding Burr's alleged plan to seize New Orleans and revolutionize the western states.

The Wheeling Repository · 30 April 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Opinion of Chief Justice Marshall. The United States, vs Aaron Burr. On a motion for a commitment.

[Concluded.]

See moreSee less

The second charge exhibited against the prisoner, is high treason against the United States, in levying war against them.

As this is the most atrocious offence which can be committed against the political body, so it is the charge which is most capable of being employed as the instrument of those malignant and vindictive passions which may rage in the bosome of contending parties struggling for power.—It is that of which the people of America have been most jealous; and, therefore, while other crimes are unnoticed, they have refused to trust the national legislature with the definition of this; but have themselves declared in their constitution that "it shall consist only in levying war against the United

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

The opinion argues that if Burr assembled armed forces to levy war, such a public act should be easily provable through witness testimony, yet months have passed without evidence being produced. It suggests that without such proof being furnished soon, the suspicion against Burr cannot reasonably be sustained.

The Wheeling Repository · 30 April 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

this fact did occur, if it ever occurred. More than five weeks have elapsed since the opinion of the supreme court declared the necessity of proving the fact, if it exists. Why is it not proved? To the executive government is intrusted the important power of prosecuting those whose crimes may disturb the publick repose or endanger its safety. It would be easy, in much less time than has intervened since Col. Burr has

See the clipping