As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

March 1807

91 articles

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

New Orleans remained in turmoil with arrests of Gen. Adair, Judge Workman, and printer Bradford; Gov. Claiborne restricted river traffic and dispatched forces to intercept Burr, reportedly descending with about 2000 men near Natchez. The Senate debated the legality of Gen. Wilkinson's military seizures of citizens without civil process.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 2 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Claiborne had been dispatched up the river with about 300 men, to intercept col. Burr, assisted by the naval force under Com. Shaw, who had received a letter from Mr. Smith, Secretary of the Navy, ordering him to take, and if necessary, destroy all boats, &c. belonging to Burr, or any one holding an appointment under him.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

Letters from Natchez dated January 20 report that Col. Burr surrendered himself to civil authorities. His trial was expected to begin shortly thereafter.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 2 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR. By letters received in this city last evening from the Natchez, dated 20th January, it appears that Col. Burr had surrendered himself to the civil authority, and that his trial was expected to come on in a few days at that place.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This opinion piece attacks merchants and insurance men who allegedly feed shipping intelligence to British cruisers, accusing them of being tools of Britain, Miranda, and Burr's conspiracy. It warns that Burr's plot will be unraveled like other foreign schemes and claims British agents in New York are openly threatening to raise their standard and incite rebellion.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Yet it is such men chiefly who bawl for fortifications and a navy—and who themselves, the adherents of Miranda, of Britain, of Burr, roar out against those who guard the country against them.

Who sent for the British frigates from Halifax, when the French were there? What was the employ of the British after their arrival? Capturing American vessels!

See moreSee less

Will our farmers, expend their property for such men?

As the last resource of Britain and her emissaries, every attempt will yet be made use of in her expiring struggle, still to lead us on to ruin. When Burr's conspiracy is unravelled, as that of Yrujo and Corondolet's has been, and as Liston's was, what will the emiss[aries]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A letter from Washington, Miss. Territory describes Burr's arrival with a small following, rumors of his purpose being land settlement on the Washita, and notes several associates have been questioned while others await examination. Additional dispatches report a grand jury indictment against judge Wormian and Mr. Kerr in New Orleans, and the transport of suspected Burr associates from Natchez to Washington for trial.

The Enquirer · 3 March 1807 · page 2

Col. Burr has entered into a recognizance of 10,000 dollars, to appear before t lie Supremi Court, which will commence an extra feHi.in on Monday next. Lyman Harding, Elq 6c Col. B. Olrnun, we underftand, were his two IV

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This editorial piece analyzes Aaron Burr's likely psychological state and strategic calculations leading up to his conspiracy's collapse, citing the Muskingum flotilla seizure and General Wilkinson's sudden loyalty to the U.S. government as key turning points. It notes Burr's denunciation of Wilkinson as a traitor and speculates that Burr, finding his chief accomplice turned against him, wisely abandoned his bold enterprise in favor of a lesser objective.

The Enquirer · 3 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Spanish court; the suspicion of his having been employed as a Spanish Pensioner; and the friendly reception which the emissaries of Burr seemed to have met with at his hands. What other encouragements he had given, are yet behind the curtain.--It was not, therefore, surprising that Burr should have counted upon his co-operation as on one of the

* According to the Natchez Herald of the 20th of January, Aaron Burr has denounced James Wilkinson "as a traitor!—a most precious villain!! and a Spanish Pensioner!!!"

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A gentleman publicly denies that he ever gave Colonel Burr reason to think he would join any scheme against the country, calling such a notion monstrous given his standing and character. He speculates on why Burr nonetheless used his name, suggesting either Burr overestimated his influence or sought to create an impression of broad support among prominent men from different states.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

OAKS, February 6, 1807.

DEAR SIR,

See moreSee less

I have received and read the President's Message with deep mortification and concern. But the letter annexed to it, stated to be a communication in cyphers from col. Burr, to gen. Wilkinson, excites my unfeigned astonishment. I solemnly avow that, when that letter was written, I had never heard, directly or indirectly, from col. Burr or any other person, of the meditated attack on New Orleans; nor had I any more reason to suspect an attack on that place, or any other part of the U. States, than I have, at this moment, to suspect that our militia will be forthwith ordered on an expedition against Gibraltar. On the other hand, I had long had strong grounds for believing that col. Burr was engaged by other objects, of a very different nature from those attributed to him, and which I confess the best sentiments of my heart approved. I need not add, that those objects involved not the interest of my country. Without adverting to that integrity of principle, which even my energies, I trust, have allowed me, can it be supposed that a man situated as I am, descended from a family which has never known dishonor, happy in the affection and esteem of a large number of relations and friends, possessed of ample fortune, and standing high in the confidence of his fellow-citizens, could harbor for an instant, a thought injurious to the country which was the scene of those blessings? The supposition would be monstrous. No Sir: It was but a short period before the impression became general, that apprehended the possibility of Mr. Burr's intentions being hostile to the Union; and the moment which gave birth to that apprehension, gave birth to the resolution which became a citizen. I confess, however, there are times even now when, in spite of the strong facts which have been exhibited, I am almost inclined to believe my suspicions injurious. Whatever may be thought of the heart of Mr Burr, his talents are great beyond question; and to reconcile with such talents, the

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer responds to accusations stemming from Burr's letter to General Wilkinson, denying any involvement in a conspiracy against the country. He points out factual inconsistencies in Burr's claims—his daughter did not accompany him, Commodore Truxton remained in Philadelphia rather than going to the West Indies, and the writer himself has been quietly managing his rice plantation since the legislature adjourned.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

DEAR SIR,

of persons from different states, a stronger impression would be made upon his correspondent. Considerable effect, too, was, no doubt, anticipated by Mr. Burr's discernment from the perfect self confidence which would have been manifested by his taking with him his daughter, receiving my co-opperation, and thus embarking in the scheme the fortunes of his infant grandson—the only relative, except his daughter, that he has. But, whatever the motive, which drew from col. Burr, the assertions contained in his letter to gen. Wilkinson; facts incontrovertible facts, prove that he

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This report covers courtroom arguments in the Burr treason trial over the admissibility of depositions from General Eaton and General Wilkinson. It discusses Eaton's account of Burr's conversations about a Mexico expedition, and the legal dispute over whether Wilkinson's extrajudicial affidavit summarizing Burr's letter can be admitted as evidence.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

depend. Maps and other information preparatory to its execution, and which would rather indicate that it was the immediate object, had been procured, and for a considerable time, in repeated conversations the whole efforts of Col. Burr were directed to prove to the witness who was to have held a high command under him, the practicability of the enterprise, and in explaining to him the means by which it was to be effected. This deposition exhibits the various schemes of col. Burr, and its materiality depends on connecting the prisoners at the bar in such of those schemes as were treasonable. For this purpose the affidavit of general Wilkinson comprehending in its body the substance of a letter from Col. Burr has been offered, and was received by the

See the clipping

In the story →

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 3 other papers

The report examines the contents of Burr's letter to General Wilkinson, debating whether it describes a military enterprise against Mexico or Spanish territory rather than against United States territory. The analysis concludes that language referring to 'the people of the country to which we are going' and plans to seize Baton Rouge suggest the expedition targeted foreign Spanish territory, not an act of treason against the U.S.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES, FEB. TERM, 1807. The United States vs. Bollman and Swartwout. Habeas Corpus on a commitment for treason, Chief Justice MARSHALL on the 21st instant, delivered the following opinion of the Court. The prisoners having been brought before this court on a writ of habeas corpus, and the testimony on which they were committed having been fully examined and attentively considered, the court is now to declare the law upon their case. This being a mere enquiry which, without deciding upon guilt, precedes the institution of a prosecution, the question to be determined is whether the accused shall be discharged or held to trial, and if the latter, in what place they are to be tried, and whether they shall be confined, admitted to bail.

See moreSee less

"If," says a very learned and accurate commentator, "upon this enquiry it manifestly appears that no such crime has been committed, or that the suspicion entertained of the prisoner was wholly groundless, in such cases only it is lawful totally to discharge him. Otherwise he must either be committed to prison or give bail." The specific charge brought against the prisoner is treason in levying war against the U. S. As there is no crime which can more excite and agitate the passions of men than treason, no charge demands more from the tribunal before which it is made a deliberate and temporate enquiry. Whether this enquiry be directed to the fact or to the law, none can be more solemn, none more important to the citizen or to the government—none can more affect the safety of both. To prevent the possibility of those calamities which result from the extension of treason to ffences of minor importance that great ties offences of minor importance that great fundamental law which defines & limits the various departments of our government has given a rule on the subject both to the legislature and the courts of America which neither can be permitted to transcend. "Treason against the U. S. shall consist only in levying war against them, or in adhering to their enemies giving them aid and comfort." To constitute that specific crime for which the prisoners now before the court have been committed, war must be actually levied against the United States. However flagitious may be the crime of conspiring to subvert by force the government of our country, such conspiracy is not treason. To conspire to levy war, and actually to levy war, are distinct offences. The first must be brought into operation by the assemblage of men for a purpose treasonable in itself, or the fact of levying war cannot have been committed. So far has this principle been carried that, in a case reported by ventries, and mentioned in some m de[n] tr[eat]ses on criminal law, it has been determined that the actual enlistment of men to serve against the government does not amount to levying war. It is true that in that case the soldiers enlisted were to serve without the realm, but they were enlisted within it, and if the enlistment for a treasonable purpose could amount to levying war, then war had been actually levied. It is not the intention of the court to say that no individual can be guilty of this crime who has not appeared in arms against his country. On the contrary, if war be actually levied, that is, if a body of men be actually assembled for the purpose of effecting by force, a treasonable purpose, all those who perform any part, however minute or however remote from the scene of action, and who are actually leagued in the general conspiracy, are to be considered as traitors. But there must be an actual assembling of men for the treasonable purpose, to constitute a levying of war. Crimes so atrocious as those which have for their object the subversion by violence of those laws and those institutions which have been ordained in order to secure the peace and happiness of society, are not to escape punishment because they have not ripened into treason. The wisdom of the legislature is competent to provide for the case; and the framers of our const[i]tution who not only defined and limited the crime, but with jealous circumspection attempted to protect their limitation by providing that no per[s]on should be convicted of it, unless on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on confession in open court, must have conceived it more safe that punishment in such cases should be ordained by general laws formed upon deliberation, under the influence of no resentments, and without knowing on whom they were to operate, than that it should be inflicted under the influence of those passions which the occasion seldom fails to excite, and which a flexible definition of the crime, or a construction which would render it flexible, might bring into operation. It is therefore more safe as well as more consonant to the principles of our constitution that the crime of treason should not be extended by construction to doubtful cases; and that crimes not clearly within the constitutional definition should receive such punishment as the legislature in its wisdom may provide. To complete the crime of levying war against the U. S. there must be an actual assemblage of men for the purpose of executing a treasonable design. In the case now before the court, a design to overturn the government of the U. S. in New-Orleans by force, would have been unquestionably a design which if carried into execution would have been treason, and the assemblage of a body of men for the purpose of carrying it into execution, would amount to levying of war against the U. S. but no conspiracy for this object, no enlisting of men to effect it, would be an actual levying of war. In conformity with the principles now laid down have been the decision heretofore made by the judges of the U. States. The opinions given by judge Paterson and judge Iredell in cases before them imply an actual assembling of men though they rather designed to remark on the purpose to which the force was to be applied than on the nature of the force itself. Their o- pinions however contemplate the actual employment of force. Judge Chase in the trial of Fries was more explicit. He stated the opinion of the court to be "that if a body of people conspire and me- ditate an insurrection to resist or oppose the execution of any statute of the U. S. by force, they are only guilty of a high misde- meanor; but if they proceed to carry such intention into execution by force, that they are guilty of the treason of levying war; and the quantum of the force employed, neither lessens nor increases the crime: whether by one hundred, or one thousand persons, is wholly immaterial. "The court are of opinion," continued Judge Chase, on that occasion, "that a combination or con- spiracy to levy war agaist the U. S. is not treason, unless combined with an attempt to carry such combination or conspiracy into execution; some actual force or vio- lence must be used in pursuance of such de- sign to levy war; but it is altogether im- material whether the force used is sufficient immaterial whether the force used is sufficient to effectuate the object; any force connected with the intention, will constitute the crime of levying war." The application of these general principles to the particular case before the court will depend on the testimony which has been exhibited against the accused. The first deposition to be considered is that of general Eaton. This gentleman connects in one statement the purport of numerous conversations held with col. Burr throughout the last winter. In the course of these conversations were communicated various criminal projects which seem to have been revolving in the mind of the projector. An expedition against Mexico seems to have been the first and most matured part of his plan, if indeed it did not constitute a distinct and separate plan, upon the success of which other schemes still more culpable, but not yet well digested might depend. Maps and other information preparatory to its execution, and which would rather indicate that it was the immediate paratory object, had been procured, and for a considerable time, in repeated conversations the whole efforts of Col. Burr were directed to prove to the witness who was to have held a high command under him, the practicability of the enterprise, and in explaining to him the means by which it was to be effected. This deposition exhibits the various schemes of col. Burr, and its materiality depends on connecting the prisoners at the bar in such of those schemes as were treasonable. For this purpose the affidavit of general Wilkinson comprehending in its body the substance of a letter from Col. Burr has been offered and was received by the circuit court. To the admission of this testimony great and serious objections have been made. It has been urged that it is a voluntary, or rather an extrajudicial affidavit made before a person not appearing to be a magistrate, and contains the substance only of a letter, of which the original is retained by the person who made the affidavit. The objection that the affidavit is extrajudicial resolves itself into the question whether one magistrate may commit on an affidavit taken before another magistrate. For if he may, an affidavit made as the foundation of a commitment, ceases to be extrajudicial, and the person who makes it would be as liable to a prosecution for perjury as if the warrant of commitment had been issued by the magistrate before whom the affidavit was made. To decide that an affidavit made before one magistrate would not justify a commitment by another might in many cases be productive of great inconvenience, and does not appear susceptible of abuse if the verity of the certificate be established. Such an affidavit seems admissible on the principle that before the accused is put upon his trial, all the proceedings are exparte. The court therefore over-ruled this objection. That which questions the character of the person who has on this occasion administered the oath is next to be considered. The certificate from the office of the department of state has been deemed insufficient by the council for the prisoners, because the law does not require the appointment of magistrates for the territory of N. Orleans to be certified to that office, because the certificate is in itself informal, and because it does not appear that the magistrate had taken the oath required by the act of congress. The first of these objections is not supported by the law of the case, and the second may be so readily corrected that the court has proceeded to consider the subject as if it were corrected, retaining however any final decision, if against the prisoners, until the correction shall be made. With regard to the third, the magistrate must be presumed to have taken the requisite oaths, since he is found acting as a magistrate. On the admissibility of that part of the affidavit which purports to be as near the substance of the letter from Col. Burr to Gen. Wilkinson as the latter could interpret it, a division of opinion has taken place, in the court. Two judges are of opinion that as such testimony delivered in the presence of the prisoner on his trial, would be totally inadmissible, neither can it be considered as a foundation for a commitment. Although in making a commitment the magistrate does not decide on the guilt of the prisoner, yet he does decide on the probable cause, and a long and painful imprisonment may be the consequence of his decision. This probable cause therefore ought to be proved by testimony in itself legal, & which, though from the nature of the case it must be exparte, ought, in most other respects to be such as a court and jury might hear. Two judges are of opinion that in this incipient stage of the prosecution an affidavit stating that the general purport of a letter may be read, particularly where the person in possession of it is at too great a distance to admit of its being obtained, and that a commitment may be founded on it. Under this embarrassment it was deemed necessary to look into the affidavait for the purpose of discovering whether if admitted, it contains matter which would justify the commitment of the prisoners at the bar on the charge of treason. That the letter from Col. Burr to Gen. Wilkinson relates to a military expedi enterprise meditated by the former, has not been questioned. If this enterprise was against Mexico, it would amount to a high misdemeanor, if against any of the territories of the U. States, or if in its progress the subversion of the government of the United States in any of their territories was a mean clearly and necessarily to be employed, if such mean formed a substantive part of the plan, the assemblage of a body of men to effect it would be levying war against the United States. The letter is in language which furnishes no distinct view of the design of the writer. The co-operation, however, which is stated to have been secured, points strongly to some expedition against the territories of Spain. After making these general statements the writer becomes rather more explicit, and says, "Burr's plan of operations is to move down rapidly from the falls on the 15th of November with the first 500 or 1000 men in light boats, now constructing for that purpose, to be at Natchez between the 5th and 15th of December, there to meet Wilkinson; then to determine whether it will be expedient in the first instance to seize on or pass by Baton Rouge. The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us. Their agents now with Burr say that if we will protect their religion and will not subject them to a foreign power, in three weeks all will be settled." There is no expression in these sentences which would justify a suspicion that any territory of the U. S. was the object of the expedition. For what purpose seize on Baton Rogue; why engage Spain against this enterprize, if it was designed against the U States? "The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us." This language is peculiarly appropriate to a foreign country. It will not be contended that the terms would be inapplicable to a territory of the U. States, but other terms would more aptly convey the idea, and Burr seems to consider himself as giving infor- mation of which Wilkinson was not possessed. When it is recollected that he was the governor of a territory adjoining that which must have been threatened, if a territory of the U. States was threatened, and that he commanded the army, a part of which was stationed in that territory, the probability that the information communicated related to a foreign country, it must be admitted, gains strength. "Their agents now with Burr say that if we will protect their religion and will not subject them to a foreign power, in three weeks all will be settled." This is apparently the language of a people who, from the contemplated change of their political situation, feared for their religion, and feared that they would be made the subjects of a foreign power. That the Mexicans should entertain these apprehensions was natural and would readily be believed. They were, if the representation made of the dispositions be correct about to place themselves much in the power of men who professed a faith different from theirs, and who by making them dependent on England, or the U. S. would subject them to a foreign power That the people of New Orleans as a people, if really engaged in the conspiracy, should feel the same apprehensions, & require assurances on the same points, is by no means so obvious. There certainly is not in the letter delivered to general Wilkinson, so far as that letter is laid before the court, one syllable which has a necessary or a natural reference to an enterprize against any territory of the U S. That the bearer of this letter must be considered as acquainted with its contents, is not to be controverted. The letter and his own declaration sev[e]ral the fact. After stating himself to have passed through New York and the western states and territories, without insinuating that he had performed on his rout any act whatever which was connected with the enterprize, he states their object to be ' to carry an expedition to the Mexican provinces." This statement may be considered as explanatory of the letter of col. Burr, if the expressions of that letter could be thought ambiguous. But there are other declarations made by Mr. Swartwout, which constitute the difficulty of this case. On an enquiry from gen. Wilkinson, he said "this territory would be revolutionized, where the people were ready to join them, and that there would be some seizing, he supposed, at N. Orleans." If these words import that the government established by the United States in any of its territories, was to be revolutionized by force, although merely as a step to, or a mean of executing some greater projects, the design was unquestionably treasonable, and any assemblage of men for that purpose would amount to a levying of war. But on the import of the words a difference of opinion exists. Some of the judges suppose they refer to the territory against which the expedition was intended, others to that in which the conversation was held. Some consider the words if even applicable to a territory of the United States, as alluding to a revolution to be effected by the people rather than by the party conducted by col. Burr. But whether this treasonable intention be really imputable to the plan or not, it is admitted that it must have been carried into execution by an open assemblage of men for that purpose, previous to the arrest the prisoner, in order to consummate the crime as to him; and a majority of the court is of opinion that the conversation of Mr. Swartwout affords no sufficient proof of such assembling. The prisoner stated that "col. Burr with the support of a powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was levying an armed body of 7000 men from the state of New York and the western states and territories, with a view to carry an expedition to the Mexican territories." That the association, whatever may be its purpose, is not treason, has been already stated. That levying an army may or may not be treason, and that this depends on the intention with which it is levied, and on the point to which the parties have advanced, has been also stated. The mere enlisting of men without assembling them is not levying war. The question then is whether this evidence proves col. Burr to have advanced so far in levying an army as actually to have assembled them. It is argued that since it cannot be necessary that the whole 7000 men should have assembled, their commencing their march by detachments to the place of rendezvous, must be sufficient to constitute the crime. This position is correct, with some qualification. It cannot be necessary that the whole army should assemble, and that the various parts which are to compose it should have combined. But it is necessary that there should be an actual assemblage, and therefore the evidence should make the fact unequivocal. The travelling of individuals to the place of rendezvous would perhaps not be sufficient. This would be an equivocal act, and has no warlike appearance. The meeting of particular bodies of men and their marching from places of partial to a place of general rendezvous would be such an assemblage. The particular words used by Mr. Swartwout are that col. Burr was levying an armed body of 7000 men. If the term levying in this place imports that they were assembled, then such fact would amount, if the intention be against the United States, to levying war. If it barely imports that he was enlisting or engaging them in his service, the fact would not amount to levying war. It is thought sufficiently apparent that the latter is the sense in which the term was used. The fact alluded to, if taken in the former sense, is of a nature so to force itself upon the public view, that if the army had then actually assembled either together or in detachments, some evidence of such assembling, would have been laid before the court. The words used by the prisoner in reference to seizing at New-Orleans, and borrowing perhaps by force from the bank, though indicating a design to rob, and consequently importing a high offence, do not designate the specific crime of levying war against the U. States. It is therefore the opinion of a majority of the court, that in the case of Samuel Swartwout, there is not sufficient evidence of his levying war against the United States to justify his commitment on the charge of treason. Against Erick Bollman there is still less testimony. Nothing has been said by him to support the charge that the enterprize in which he was engaged had any other object than was stated in the letter of col. Burr. Against him, therefore, there is no evidence to support a charge of treason. That both the prisoners were engaged in a most culpable enterprise against the dominions of a power at peace with the United States, those who admit the affidavit of gen. Wilkinson cannot doubt. But that no part of this crime was committed in the district of Columbia, is apparent. It is therefore the unanimous opinion of the court that they cannot be tried in this district. The law read on the part of the prosecution is understood to apply only to offences committed on the high seas, or in any river, haven, bason or bay, not within the jurisdiction of any particular state. In these cases there is no court which has particular cognizance of the crime, and therefore the place in which the criminal shall be apprehended, or, if he be apprehended where no court has exclusive jurisdiction, that shall to which he shall be first brought, is substituted for the place in which the offence was committed. But in this case, a tribunal for the trial of the offence wherever it may have been committed, had been provided by Congress; and at the place where the prisoners were seized by the authority of the commander in chief, there existed such a tribunal. It would too be extremely dangerous to say, that because the prisoners were apprehended, not by a civil magistrate, but by the military power, there could be given by law a right to try the persons so seized in any place which the general might select, and to which he might direct them to be carried. The act of congress which the prisoners are supposed to have violated, describes as offenders those who begin or set on foot, or provide or prepare the means for any military expedition or enterprise to be carried on from thence against the dominions of a foreign prince or state, with whom the U. States are at peace. There is a want of precision in the description of the offence which might produce some difficulty in deciding what cases would come within it. But several other questions arise which a court consisting of four judges finds itself unable to decide, and therefore as the crime with which the prisoners stand charged has not been committed, the court can only direct them to be discharged. This is done with the less reluctance because the discharge does not acquit them from the offence which there is probable cause for supposing they have committed, and if those whose duty it is to protect the nation by prosecuting offenders against the laws shall suppose those who have been charged with treason to be proper objects for punishment, they will, when possessed of less exceptionable testimony, and when ab[l]e to say at what place the offence has been committed, institute fresh proceedings against them. The order of the court was as follows: The UNITED STATES vs Swartwout. } On a writ of Habeas Corpus, The arguments of the attorney general and of the attorney of the U. S. for the district of Columbia, and the arguments of counsel for the prisoner having been heard; and the record of the circuit court for the county of Washington containing the order by which the said Samuel Swartwout was committed on the charge of treason in levying war against the U. S and the testimony on which the said commitment made having been inspected and attentively considered, the court is of opinion that the testimony does not furnish probable cause for supposing that the said Samuel Swartwout has levied war against the United States and doth therefore direct that he be forthwith discharged from the custody of the marshal. The same order with regard to Bollman.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 25 February 1807 · an extract
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 4 March 1807
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 6 March 1807 · an extract

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A letter from Washington, Mississippi Territory describes Colonel Burr's arrival about two weeks prior, causing alarm though only 10-50 companions were confirmed and no significant arms found. Depositions are being taken from associates like Comfort Tyler, while legal officials debate whether the territorial court has jurisdiction to try Burr.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY, Feb. 25. Extract of a letter from a gentleman of respectability, dated Washington, Miss Ter. 20th Jan. 1807. "As I suppose that you will be solicitous to hear the state of public affairs here, I take up my pen to inform you that col. Burr has been here about a fortnight: His approach gave

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Lieutenant Luckett testifies he had no personal knowledge of any offense by prisoners Adair and Ogden, only newspaper reports linking them to Burr's enterprise. The judge rules no testimony showed any offense against the United States or any state, and orders both men discharged from custody.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

concerned in any enterprize against the U. States or against any nation in amity with the U. States, and generally whether he knew for what offence they had been taken into custody?” To all of which he answered that he knew nothing relative to them, except what he had heard in general conversation, and had seen in newspapers, which was a report of their connexion with col. Burr in the enterprise which it was supposed he was carrying on, but he had no

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A judge ruled no evidence supported holding John Adair and Peter Ogden, who were arrested by military order, and ordered their discharge under habeas corpus. The Virginia Argus then questions why Bollman, Swartwout and others were sent far from New Orleans for trial rather than tried locally, raising suspicions about General Wilkinson's motives and conduct.

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TUESDAY, MARCH 3, 1807.

THE reports which have lately circulated against the character of Gen. Wilkinson, have a very mysterious aspect. The zeal he apparently manifested against Burr and his adherents, seems quite inconsistent

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The writer, apparently a Burr associate, criticizes General Wilkinson's suspension of habeas corpus and arbitrary detention of Dr. Bollman in New Orleans, comparing it unfavorably to even British tyranny. He disputes Wilkinson's published account claiming the writer was to meet Burr at Bayou Pierre, calling it a fabrication created after his arrest.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

was the answer of the officer who had him in custody? Attend to it ye who respect your government. Although (said he) I respect the civil institutions of my country; yet I must obey the orders of my superior officer. The prisoner was not given up. Here then was a denial of this all-important right; no need for the interposition of the Senate. In England, that land of oppression, this officer would have been immediately punished. In our free government, things are ordered otherwise. Under the administration of Mr. Adams, there was much grumbling about a gag law, that shut people's mouths---under the present administration a man may not only be gagged, but his throat cut without any law, and he that does it will find protectors amongst the sages of the nation.

See moreSee less

Wilkinson tells us he has acted with the approbation of the governor and judges. If this be true, it is high time these men were removed from office. Men placed in the most important stations, over a territory respectable for its wealth and population, and over a city that yields in importance to very few on the continent; sworn to administer justice agreeable to the constitution and laws; who would cringe to a military tyrant, and suffer him to trample on all law, should not be trusted. Perhaps the bayonet was at their breast, or the dagger of the assassin at their side; no less dangerous a situation can plead their excuse. Wilkinson, in telling us this unlikely tale; intends not only an excuse for his own illegal acts, but it is saying to those he has injured; sue me if you dare---I am here entrenched in New Orleans in the favor of the executive---the governor and judges are my creatures---you cannot injure me. How long he will remain thus secure, will rest with the President. Wilkinson in his long fulsom panegyric on himself; published in the Aurora of the 23d inst. as a letter from N[e]w Orleans (for his tricks of this kind are too well known to pass) has discovered from his spy, who had it in confidence from the friends of colonel Burr, that I was sent to New Orleans, and was to meet the col. at Bayou Pierre, on the 12th Jan. Unfortunately for this tale which seems to have been fabricated after my arrest---Major Floyd and Mr. Ralston will declare they have never spoken to me on the subject---but I scorn to justify myself, where I cannot be accused. It was necessary to alledge something against me. Wilkinson and his spies, and other confidential men, have made me a general, and given me an army of 2000 men, (1000 more than I could have needed) and this too without consulting me, whilst I was harmlessly diverting myself in the uninhabited can swamps in West Florida, three or four hundred miles out of the road leading from Nashville to Orleans. What can they not do? Bonaparte can conquer armies as fast as his enemies can raise them. But Wilkinson and his friends can both raise and conquer them in the same breath without powder or ball. This charge, however, cannot be the crime for which I have suffered, because the discovery has been made since my arrest. It seems I have committed another. A very great personage in this city, has declared publicly, that Adair was the most impudent of all the conspirators; for he had said to the first man he met in New Orleans, that the commander in chief of the army was a villain, and a Spanish spy, and that he, Adair, expected to find the city in possession of his Catholic majesty. With due submission, I will correct this statement, which I presume came from Wilkinson, as I was told he repeated it on the same evening I was confined. When I was repeatedly told in the public room, amongst gentlemen, acquaintances and strangers; that Wilkinson had denounced me as a traitor, and declared me at the head of an army coming to attack that city; I coolly answered, that reports were different in different countries; that in Kentucky the people were more afraid of Wilkinson than Burr; because many of them believed him to be in Spanish pay. A gentleman (pointing to a small man in the room) observed to me, take care what you say, that man is a spy on you from the general, and I would not be surprised if you are confined for that before night; I answered with perhaps some warmth, let him confine me and be d----d, I despise his power. For this I have suffered, for this I have been imprisoned; I had before been perse-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 10 March 1807 · an extract

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The court finds insufficient evidence that Samuel Swartwout levied war against the United States to justify holding him on treason charges, and even less evidence against Erick Bollman. The justices unanimously conclude that whatever crime was committed did not occur in the District of Columbia, so the men cannot be tried there.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 4 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

dence to support a charge of treason.

That both the prisoners were engaged in a most culpable enterprize against the dominions of a power at peace with the United States, those who admit the affidavit of general Wilkinson cannot doubt. But that no part of this crime was committed

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Messrs. Shields and Poindexter met with Aaron Burr near Bayou Pierre to negotiate terms, resulting in an agreement signed with Cowles Mead. Burr pledged to commit no violence against territorial inhabitants while militia agreed not to approach his quarters without cause.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 4 March 1807 · page 3

SURRENDER OF COL. BURR

^t*aisib6Sii in^rrisw »Jie nuyptaiie^-i thws shall be aO<pestTai«tf itr his' , hence Or molmtahan tohiVhoats of r. , the military of tbs5 district shall not, uWti turn of tbwfidd A. Bdnr, approach nes^er ^ present quarters, thaw the month of Cole's creeki fv. a. Burr on his pirt; ei^ges, that in thethp 6wv, •<* violence w iipuiy elnili be titnll W an ; «rf hie people to thekhebittmtn of tbef5.** ^ ^ territory—npd {hit they «h«H' keehtfuf not mfring^iAy law of the-CaiM^tes <rf its territories. V The parties above Hasted; muttrall»‘ptel^jr<iuit honor ter the pejfehtiaac>of<bw agreiMUBut.'

See moreSee less

' ' . : ' . \ -:' OpAts Htip, trjrj '■ . R.SkmHr/) Pfc'&i'r&fV " : ©A PejNterfmv W0$>i H# ■ -taffi in*#5' v^*' ‘ "3^" “ *jy.. jj ..,v- \_sry ■ • >■ a» • v. agra*npu & proponed; interview .teoA'jifgr, which teirttcti »fr avoteattery anbtnhsiao « *>,#■ civU aiftbHfity ■ ot^WjSgMg^M «W a *a*r«wlw ,,of ,wh#te**» Mi^MwiK muJit *» fctai f tw* *b* Im4» «Kh» Ws —A (ppafii immediately appbintt<i(*Rttlie the ner4i^ry*xan»inatio*< and report forthwith Jo tbe jpv.erqftr«. (be JMHUbir and dsacripttda of aMJh m^nary il«WI te'thry pnjfrl drover on board *aM

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This is an extract of a letter from Cowles Mead, acting governor of Mississippi Territory, to the War Department describing his mobilization of militia upon Aaron Burr's arrival with boats and men at Bayou Pierre. It details the tense negotiations culminating in Burr's agreement to surrender to civil authority and allow his boats to be searched.

Lynchburg Star · 5 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

descend the river. On the 16th I dispatched two of my aids to col. Burr, who had tendered his respects to the civil authority;—these gentlemen engaged on my part to give the colonel an interview in the neighborhood of the

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

Edward Livingston publishes a public address defending himself against accusations of complicity in Aaron Burr's alleged plans, addressing General Wilkinson's affidavit and claims about payments to Bollman. He insists he had no knowledge of Burr's schemes beyond newspaper reports and public rumor, and describes being told Wilkinson's charges might not be presented after all.

Lynchburg Star · 5 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

But that in all events I pledge myself most solemnly to God and my country, that I was utterly ignorant of any of the plans which it was laid col. Burr was executing, either for dismembering the union, or contravening its laws, except

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

President Jefferson's message to Congress forwards letters from U.S. ministers in London and Paris on treaty negotiations and the French blockade decree, alongside a letter from Cowles Mead announcing that Aaron Burr had surrendered to civil authority in the Mississippi Territory. The passage includes the full text of the diplomatic correspondence as well as Jefferson's cover message.

Lynchburg Star · 5 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Also, a letter from Cowles Mead, secretary of the Mississippi territory, acting as governor, informing us that Aaron Burr had surrendered himself to the civil authority of that territory. TH: JEFFERSON.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

Several men suspected of involvement in Burr's plot were arrested by military order in New Orleans and held without charge; legal efforts via habeas corpus led to some releases while Bollman and Swartwout were sent to Washington and committed for treason trial. The Supreme Court intervened with writs of habeas corpus and certiorari to review the case.

The Wheeling Repository · 5 March 1807 · page 4

( ■ ■%' were apprehended, at rCew-Orlc^ns, by, the military, by order of Cen. Wilkin son, in December last, and kept in close custody, on suspicion of being concerned in Burr’s plot. Writs of habeas corpus ■*\'eft* issued to bring them before the ci auth.ority, that cause might be shewn for their con fi: cment. Mr. Ogden was delivered up in obedience to the writ, and the officer who had him in charge producing only the order of Gen. Wil kinson as the cause of his confinement, he w as set at liberty.

See moreSee less

In the other ca ses, no ret irns were made to the writs until the prisoners were dispatched to the seat of government for trial. James Alexander, Esq. who acted as counsel for Messrs. Bollman and Sv. artwout, and had used every effort to procure their release, moved for an attachment against Gen. Wilkinson for disobedience to the habeas corpus, and on the same day he was himself seized by order of the Ge neral, and sent round to the seat of go vernment, as a suspected person. On his arrival, he was carried before judge Ducket, of the district of Columbia, and released. Upon their arrival at the seat of go vernment, Messrs. Bellman and Swart \vou.t were brought before the district rourt of Columbia, and committed to take their trial for Treason. The Su preme Court of the United States have awarded a writ of habeas corpus, to bring Sollinan and Swartwout before them, • end also a writ of certiorari, to remove therecord of the District Court of Co lumbia into the Supreme Court. In the President’s message to Con gress respecting Burr, he states that Messrs. Bollman and Swartwout were principal emissaries of Burr, and “ par ticularly employed in the endeavour to corrupt the General and army of the U nited States.” On the 1 8th February, Gen. John A «lair, late a Senator of the United States from Kentucky, and Mr. Peter V. Og den, (who it seems was seized a second lime) arrived at Fort M‘Henry, in Bal timore, rent irom New-Orleans in cus tody ot Lieutenants Pinckney and Luc kett, under a military order of General W ibdnson. Upon application, fudge .Nicholson issued a writ of habeas cor pu.i, upon which they were brought be fore him. After examining the order for detaining them, signed by Wilkinson, and also examining the officers touching their knowledge of the guilt of the pri POR THE WHEELING REPOSITORY ^ NOW, when it is known that Burr’s plans, whatever they were, have proven abortive, and that he has surrendered himself up to abide the sentence of the law, it cannot be improper to animad vert* on certain measures which have been adopted against him and his sup posed coadjutors. When we reflect on the means he possessed, to effect a sepa ration of the Union, supposing that to have been his object, it seems strange that much danger could have been ap prehended, or that any violent or op pressive measures should have been deemed necessary to defeat him. The strength of our government is in the aff ctions ol the citizens. No sec tion of the Union can be endangered by domestic disturbance, unless a great por tion of the people are disaffected. That kind of Rebellion, which permits all the officers of government to discharge their functions ; that description of Treason, the standard of which is no where erect ed, the partisans of which skulk and hide ( from the observation of all, cannot be dangerous. A tew desperate men,whose adherents dare not avow themselves, can never endanger a government strong in the affection of the people. For four months past, the country has been under continual alarm and appre hension from Burr’s Treason. Yet on the waters of the Ohio, in the very focus of this supposed Treason, no man could point out a person known to be a Trai tor. While almost every individual war alarmed for the safety of the country, the most undisturbed harmony and con fidence existed among us: the Court* sat; the Legislatures convened; the mail* pursued their routes without interrup tion ; no voice was heard, which did not breathe an ardent w ; h tor the weliarc of the govcrnim nt. Yet in the midst of this perfect tranquility, a most extraor dinary and unwarranted alarm pervaded the count; v. The name of Burr seemed to have bad a magical operation. In a. country where no man openly seconded him, except a few despicable adherents, who were chiefly ignorant of his pur poses, he made as much noise, excited as much terror, and gave rise to as ex traordinary a course of conduct, as it* the standard of Revolt had bet n hoisted, and surrounded by half onr citizens. The Legislature of Ohio, as soon a» they were convened, apparently in a pa nic, passed an act, by which the country w as iu effect put under military govern*

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

Dennis Cassat publicly protests his wrongful arrest at Chillicothe as a supposed Burr conspirator, noting the grand jury found no bill and criticizing papers that reported his arrest but not his acquittal. A Wheeling Repository piece reflects on the harsh measures taken against Burr and his alleged associates now that Burr has surrendered and his plans have failed.

The Wheeling Repository · 5 March 1807 · page 4

[From the (Gettijsburgh) Centinel.] Jl V understand that Dennis Cassat, ii.sy. of Wheeling, is determined to bring a suit against the Governor of the state of Ohio, for issuing ci writ and causing him to be arrested, as one of Burr's conspirators, on mere information. Mr. HAP.rr.u, Sir, 1 am sorry to see some misrepre sentations in public prints, relative to my being arrested at Chillicothe, for being what is called one of Burr's conspirators; and / am also sorry to see that some Edi to s who were forward in stating my arrest, and that my trio’ was depend ing, have not done me the justice to pub hs/i my acquittal■—/ then jorc think it a duty I oxvc to my friends and relations, xvho arc considerably scattered over A m erica, as xveU as to do justice to my self, to state, that, I know nothing of Burr or his conspirators, (if there be any J and that the grand jury in my case found no bill; although some of the members of the Ohio l.n*i stature xvere maliciously de sirous of it.

See moreSee less

Printers xubo have only published my arrest, xl>”7 no more than do me justice by inserting the above.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

This editorial argues that General Wilkinson's conduct in New Orleans—arresting individuals without due process and defying the courts—is worse than the hasty measures taken in Ohio against the conspiracy. The writer insists that even if Bollman is guilty and Burr is a traitor, this does not excuse illegal military actions that threaten personal liberty and the rule of law.

The Wheeling Repository · 5 March 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

A transaction of this nature calls for the indignation of every friend to personal liberty. The guilt of Bollman and the treason of Burr have nothing to do with the subject. Where the law is disregarded, the innocent and the guilty must be involved in one common distress. Admit that Bollman is guilty, how can that extenuate the conduct of Wilkinson? He was on the spot: the proper authority could have been applied to; or when arrested, he might have been brought before the proper tribunal. His guilt could there have been enquired into, and regular proceedings had.

See moreSee less

Was there danger that the court would not do justice? It was Bollman who had cause of alarm on that score. The court do not appear to have had any prepossession in his favour. Was Burr at hand with an army ready to rescue him? Was the country swarming with traitors? No. No such excuse can be offered. Wilkinson was lording it over every thing. Neither the laws of the land, nor the laws of humanity, presented any obstacle to his exercise of unlimited and despotic authority. In extenuation of his conduct, Wilkinson and his friends set up the monstrous plea of state necessity. Yet we cannot see that this necessity existed. And if it did, I hope we are not prepared to permit the General of our army to avail himself of it, and under such a pretext set himself above the law. I have said, that where this doctrine prevails, the innocent must suffer with the guilty. I may adduce the case of

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

The report covers European military and diplomatic developments, including Napoleon's actions and Ottoman war declarations, alongside news of General Miranda's ship. It also states that Aaron Burr surrendered to Mississippi Territory authorities on January 16th, declaring his innocence of any plot to divide the Union and accusing General Wilkinson of slandering him.

The Wheeling Repository · 5 March 1807 · page 6

It is saicl that the negocia'ions be* tween the United States and Great Britain, lrive been amicably terminated. On this subject \s e have no positive in formation. A letter from a member of Contrress to a gentleman in Adams county, Penn s' lvania, mentions that a confidential a gent (.! the executive has followed Burr ,ia.ee the beginning of November, olt* serving iiis motions and reporting bis progn. , and succeeded so far in dis guise, as lo have proposals mad** to him sell ior joining iii the enterprise.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage prints John Smith's sworn certification describing a note he received from Aaron Burr requesting lodging, and Burr's subsequent visit to his house. The deposition is part of ongoing testimony being gathered in Ohio regarding Burr's movements and associates, including Blennerhassett.

The Enquirer · 6 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A Jamaica paper of the 24th Jan. states, that the schooner Eliza had arrived there from New-Orleans, with dispatches to the governor and admiral. They were supposed to relate to Burr's conspiracy.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The court considers objections to the magistrate's certification and oath in the case against the prisoners, with judges divided on whether an affidavit summarizing Burr's letter to General Wilkinson can justify a commitment on treason charges. The judges examine whether the described military enterprise, if aimed at Mexico, would constitute a misdemeanor, or if aimed at U.S. territories, could amount to treason.

The Enquirer · 6 March 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

trate.

On the admissibility of that part of the affidavit which purports to be as near the substance of the letter from Colonel Burr to General Wilkinson, as the latter could interpret it, a division of opinion has ta-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Mississippi Territory officials negotiated an agreement with Aaron Burr near Bayou Pierre, guaranteeing his safety during a parley in exchange for peaceful conduct by his followers. The meeting led to Burr voluntarily submitting to civil authority and surrendering military stores found on his boats.

Virginia Argus · 6 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

NEW ORLEANS, Jan. 30.

The Executive of the Mississippi Territory, in order to ascertain the views of Col. Burr, on the 14th instant, deputed Messrs. Shields and Poindexter, to visit the quarters of that gentleman, near the mouth of Bayou Pierre, and to hold a conversation with him on the subject. On the 16th an amicable agreement was entered into between the parties in the following words, to wit:

See moreSee less

"The Hon. Cowles Mead, acting governor of the Mississippi Territory, with a view to restore public tranquility, proposes to Aaron Burr as follows:

"That an interview shall take place between them at the house of Thomas Calvit, on Cole's creek, at two o'clock to-morrow.

"The said Cowles Mead pledges himself to protect the said A. Burr during his stay in the territory, and that he shall be returned to his present position in a suitable manner as soon after the interview as he may please—that in the mean time, there shall

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This report prints the January 1807 agreement in which Aaron Burr pledged to submit to civil authority in the Mississippi Territory and surrender military stores from his boats, followed by a committee's examination. It also includes depositions from John Smith and Ambrose Smith regarding Burr's visits to Cincinnati and his vague references to his western land project and plans.

Virginia Argus · 6 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

W. B. SHIELDS, } Aids de G. POINDEXTER, } Camp. A. BURR.

Signed in presence of } THOS. FITZPATRICK. }

See moreSee less

In conformity with the above agreement the proposed interview took place, which resulted in a voluntary submission on the part of col. Burr to the civil authority of the territory, and also, a surrender of whatever military apparatus might be found on board the boats under his direction; a committee was immediately appointed to make the necessary examination, and report forthwith to the governor, the number and description of such military stores as they might discover on board said boats.

It is surely a source of felicity to every philanthropic mind that the laws and constitution of the United States are maintained inviolate, without the catastrophe of a civil contest.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report describes indictments presented to a grand jury against a newspaper editor, and details John Graham's secret work tracking Burr's conspiracy for the President. It also includes a letter describing the Mississippi territory's militia search of Burr's boats, finding muskets and supplies, after which Burr gave security to stand trial at the next circuit court.

Virginia Argus · 6 March 1807 · page 3

Suites to follow the footsteps of Col Burr and his adherents, to notice their measures, to discover their views, and if possible »o get full possession of their plan of ope rations was Secretary of Legation at Ma

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The acting Governor of Mississippi Territory sent deputies to meet with Aaron Burr near Bayou Pierre to discuss his intentions. An agreement was reached guaranteeing Burr safe conduct for a personal interview, with both sides pledging to avoid violence in the meantime.

Herald of the United States · 7 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

for public tranquility, proposes to Aaron Burr as follows: "That an interview shall take place between them at the house of Thomas Calcit, on Cole's Creek, at 2 o'clock to-morrow.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

This report prints the January 16, 1807 agreement between Aaron Burr and territorial officials guaranteeing his safety during an interview, followed by news that Burr voluntarily submitted to civil authority and surrendered military stores found on his boats. A committee was appointed to inventory the seized military apparatus and report to the Governor.

Herald of the United States · 7 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ORLEANS. NEW-ORLEANS, JAN. 30. THE Executive of the Mississippi Territory, in order to ascertain the views of Col. Burr, on the 15th inst. deputed Messrs. Shields and Poindexter, to visit the quarters of that gentleman, near the mouth of Bayou Pierre, and to hold a conversation with him on the subject. On the 16th an amicable agreement was enterred into between the parties in the following words, to wit:

"The Hon. Cowles Mead, acting Governor of the Mississippi Territory, with a view to restore public tranquillity, proposes to Aaron Burr as follows:

See moreSee less

"That an interview shall take place between them at the house of Thomas Calcit, on Cole's Creek, at 2 o'clock to-morrow.

"The said Cowles Mead pledges himself to protect the said Aaron Burr during his stay in the Territory, and that he shall be returned to his present position in a suitable manner as soon after the interview as he may please—that in the mean time, there shall be no restraint on his person, no violence or molestation to his boats or people, and that the military of the district shall not until the return of the said Aaron Burr, approach nearer to his present quarters than the mouth of Cole's Creek.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report notes that Colonel Burr delivered himself up to civil authority at Natchez, alongside news that Bollman and Swartwout have been discharged by the Supreme Court. It is framed amid other political news including adjusted relations with Britain and France.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The House of Representatives of the United States appropriated on the 21st inst. 150,000 dollars for gunboats, and the same sum for fortifications.

Yesterday was an important one—and fraught with joyful intelligence. In the morning we received the accounts of our differences having been honorably adjusted with Great-Britain, and that the French ships had received orders to respect our neutral trade. In the evening intelligence arrived that Col. Burr had delivered himself up to the civil authority at Natchez. Thus, with the exception of some adjustments yet to be made with Spain, the political horizon of America appears at present without a cloud to interrupt the sunshine of her prosperity. [Phil. Freeman's Journal

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The writer criticizes the Senate's closed-door suspension of habeas corpus following Jefferson's message about Burr, calling it an unconstitutional capitulation to executive tyranny. The piece also condemns General Wilkinson for defying a habeas corpus writ granted by Judge Bee in the case of Dr. Bollman, comparing American practice unfavorably to even England's.

The Enquirer · 10 March 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ment of last winter, and shut their doors to keep out Burr and his army, least they might be tied neck and heels and tumbled into the Potamac—I have said every citizen of the west, (2) because on them was this bill intended to operate—My own case, may be the case

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer, likely associated with Aaron Burr's circle, recounts being arrested, imprisoned, and forcibly transported by sea without formal charges, protesting the lack of due process. He criticizes General Wilkinson's conduct and the Senate's suspension of habeas corpus, framing the executive's actions as tyrannical and unconstitutional.

Virginia Argus · 10 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

of my health, and the danger of my life. Why has all this been done? I have not yet been told. Wilkinson has acted with the honor of a soldier and the fidelity of a good citizen—and can the President really

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer criticizes General Wilkinson's conduct in New Orleans and the Senate's closed-door passage of a bill suspending habeas corpus following Burr's alleged conspiracy. It cites the case of Dr. Bollman, whose habeas corpus writ was ignored by military officers claiming obedience to superior orders, arguing this represents dangerous executive overreach and tyranny.

Virginia Argus · 10 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the displeasure of all who believe in executive infallibility. I have said the Senate could probably tell what was meant by this aid (and that body I highly respect.) Take the following statement—On the 22d January, this all-important message was communicated to the Senate; their doors were closed, and in a few hours they passed a bill suspending the power of granting the writ of Habeas Corpus; thus prostrating at one blow the civil authority, sacrificing the constitution on the altar of oppression and subjecting every citizen in the west to the will of an ambitious unprincipled tyrant.

See moreSee less

Was this done through the aid of executive means; or had they just heard the Arabian Nights entertainment of last winter, and shut their doors to keep out Burr and his army, lest they might be tied neck and heels and tumbled into the Potomac—I have said every citizen of the west, because on them was this bill intended to operate—My own case may be the case of every individual of that country—imprisoned without having committed, or being charged with any offence, denied the use of pen, ink and paper, I might have been sent to the Columbia river, and kept there for seven years unheard of by my friends or family—Tyrants never lack the means of destroying the reputations of those they oppress. Had not the House of Representatives spurned with indignation this unconstitutional attempt to justify the lawless acts of a lawless tyrant, the sufferings of Baron Trenck would not have been strange in America. And what, let me ask, is our present security, unless Wilkinson is punished for his daring outrage on all law? In the case of Doctor Bollman, we are told in a newspaper, the writ of Habeas Corpus, granted by judge Bee of South Carolina, was actually served. What was the answer of the officer who had him in custody? Attend to it ye who respect your government. Altho' (said he) I respect the civil institutions of my country; yet I must obey the orders of my superior officer. The prisoner was not given up. Here then was a denial of this all-important right; no need for the interposition of the Senate. In England, that land of oppression, this officer would have been immediately punished. In our free government, things are ordered otherwise. Under the administration of Mr. Adams, there was much grumbling about a gag law, that shut people's mouths—under the pre-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece condemns General Wilkinson for ignoring a habeas corpus writ and detaining Dr. Bollman despite civil authority, accusing him of military tyranny. It also quotes a letter purportedly showing Wilkinson's spy network against Burr's associates, while the author disclaims any prior involvement with Burr.

Virginia Argus · 10 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

sent administration a man may not only be gagged, but his throat cut without any law, and he that does it will find protectors amongst the sages of the nation.

Wilkinson tells us he has acted with the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report criticizes General Wilkinson's unconstitutional actions during the Burr conspiracy investigation, including the Senate's closed-door suspension of habeas corpus and the detention of citizens without charges. It condemns the administration for allowing military authority to override civil law, citing the case of Dr. Bollman as an example of a citizen denied his legal rights despite a judge's writ.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

...citizen in the west [to] the will of an [e]n[titled] tyrant. W[as t]his done through [illegible] means; or [ha]d they just heard [illegible]ments of last winter, [abou]t Burr and his army, [h]and heels and tumbled [an]d every citizen of the [bi]ll was intended to ope[rate] the case of every indi[vi]d[ual impris]oned without having com[mitted, nor char]ged with any offence, de­nied th[e use of pen] and paper, I might have been sen[t to Columb]ia river, and kept there for seven ye[ars, unknown] by my friends or family.—Tyrants n[ever want the] means of destroying the reputations of [those they] oppress.

Had not the house of representatives spurned with indignation this unconstitutional attempt to justify the lawless acts of a lawless tyrant, the sufferings of Baron Trenck would not have been strange in America.

See moreSee less

And what, let me ask, is our present security, unless Wilkinson is punished for his daring outrage on all law? In the case of Dr. Bollman, we are told

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report details courtroom arguments over testimony in Aaron Burr's treason trial, focusing on General Eaton's deposition about Burr's schemes, including a planned Mexican expedition. It examines objections to General Wilkinson's affidavit, which was extrajudicial and summarized rather than quoted Burr's letter, questioning whether one magistrate's affidavit can justify committal by another.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Burr were directed to prove to the witness who was to have held a high command under him, the practicability of the enterprise, and in explaining to him the means

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A report on courtroom arguments over whether a magistrate's certificate and an affidavit summarizing Burr's letter to General Wilkinson are legally admissible to justify committing the prisoners for treason. The judges are divided on whether such secondhand testimony can establish probable cause for commitment, though some agree it may suffice given the letter's distance and circumstances.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

substance of the letter from col. Burr to general Wilkinson, as the latter could interpret it, a division of opinion has taken place in the court. Two judges are of opi-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report examines a letter describing Burr's alleged plan to move forces down the river to meet General Wilkinson near Natchez, discussing whether this constituted levying war against the U.S. It debates whether the expedition targeted Spanish territory or threatened American interests, scrutinizing Wilkinson's role and the letter's ambiguous language.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the falls on the 15th of November with the first five hundred or one thousand men in light boats now constructing for that purpose to be at Natchez between the 5th and 15th of Dec.—there to meet Wilkinson; then to determine whether it will be expedient in the first instance to seize on or to pass by Baton Rouge. The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us.——Their agents now wi[t]h Burr, say that if we will protect their religion and will not subject them to a foreign power, in three weeks all will be settled."

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A political letter urges Pittsylvania County voters to elect men of proven integrity to the Virginia Legislature, warning that Burr's conspiracy may have friends in high office. It criticizes one unnamed incumbent candidate for delaying payment of a legitimate debt through court maneuvers.

Lynchburg Star · 12 March 1807 · page 3

To " the -Citizens ' dTPiltsylvantc ■ i yi,,„3, Genteemen—The,time is ap . proaching Whtn: ityil! be incum bent on youto chose two persons, by*4>liomyou wilt be represfehted ; iff the‘ri&st Virginia Legislature. | This being kS^ery cr itical and,hh porhini period, it behoves you as U -fechr. enlightened, and. indepen I dent people, to vote, not from tH impulse of the momeiit, but upoi the most, mature deliberation: ^Experience proves there are in f triguing men «h our country, as [well as in every other—view th< • situation of the western [states an.!

See moreSee less

you will see the utmost con fusion. ■ Although Burr be the Ontaline of the' conspiracy^ yet |? there' is tro doubjtbut he hasfriendi ’and'adherents, who fill the first 1 offices of; government,' and^whc 1 ha re it in their, power to afforc him great assistance., ifo%, maj be convinced that dll your candi ) dates Would oppbsc 9 conspiracj ’ of that kind—yet you are hotcer 1 tain they would oppose one bv ; which they would be profitted.i j A little cash speaks all languages t—Its logic, is irreSidtable* It is : essentially ,necessary that you ; e lect irien,of talents, whose integri ; ty as private Citizens, and virtue anc^ discretion as public, charac. ters have never been [questioned, ; If all the counties, will, but elect &ch men’as are here described : We shall live very tranquil. In my opinion, Thomas. H./Wood ing and Richard Jones will

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

The report describes executive measures to suppress an armed expedition led by Col. Burr, including seizure of boats and provisions and arrest of key figures. It notes Burr surrendered to civil authority in the Mississippi territory with only nine boats and about a hundred men, mostly young men and boys.

Lynchburg Star · 12 March 1807 · page 2

Secretary'of the Mississippi ter ritory, dated the ’ l?,th-of Januq*y last, it appears that Col. Burr hr* surrendered himself, to the. civil authority, by which he will bp brought to tfinj., He ..had only nine boats and one hundred, per sons, consisting., principally oif young men, and some lioysi s Tjv# real objectwhichhe hadinview tempted, that I cati’t avoid notic ing, that I have not received more than eight or ten Numbers of the -Star this session* I men* tion this merely to shew-that tee, as well as you^ have suffered this winter* from neglect, either wilful or intentional in the Post-master’s . Une.7-vn,*s^-‘«. '¥*■*& y •?

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A writer rebuts 'Camillus,' who criticized Ohio's legislature for alarmist overreach against Burr's conspiracy, pointing out that only Blennerhassett and a few others were justly suspected and detained while Burr and his chief accomplices escaped. The author mocks Camillus's inconsistency, noting he previously demanded stronger government action against Burr before condemning the state's eventual response.

The Wheeling Repository · 12 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

I should suppose, that as the principal, his wife, and three of his "choice spirits," escaped, and succeeded in carrying with them a large quantity of fetters, it might in some measure assuage his wrath, unless he should suppose that the chains intended for our faithful citizens, became the manacles of those who forged them, by the prompt and efficacious measures of the state of Ohio. The above and a few other instances, all of which were justly suspected of a connection with Burr, are all that the state of Ohio have in any manner meddled with.

See moreSee less

And I challenge Camillus to the proof of a solitary instance, wherein the fair trader has received the least vexation. "For four months past, (says Camillus) the country has been under continual alarm & apprehension, from Burr's treason."

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

Acting governor Cowles Mead describes mobilizing territorial militia to arrest Burr and his boats after reports of conspiracy. Burr landed near Natchez with about 100 men, professed innocence, and ultimately agreed to have his boats searched by Mead's aides.

The Wheeling Repository · 12 March 1807 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

"SIR,

"In obedience to your instructions by express, of the 20th of December last, I immediately, after proroguing the legislature, proceeded to put the territory in a state of preparation for the arrestation of the suspicious persons, and boats, which were contemplated therein. My militia were collecting at particular points, on the river, when I received a letter from col. Burr, who

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage presents a letter and sworn depositions, including testimony from M. Davidson, describing conversations about Aaron Burr's expected expedition and his military ambitions toward Mexico and New Orleans. Witnesses recount statements made by associates expressing confidence in Burr's ability to seize territory with a small force.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 13 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

DEPOSITION OF HOOKE AND DAVIDSON. The undersigned, on their solemn oaths declare that in a conversation with James Alexander, esq. about the beginning of the present month, at the house of A. L. Duncan. esq. on the subject of col. Burr's expected expedition to this territory, he expressed in general terms, a disaffection to the government of the United States—& declared, that although he was a citizen of those states, he was in politics and patriot an Englishman—that as to the expedition of Burr against Louisiana and Mexico, he was confident it would succeed, should the attempt be made, as the contest was to be between Wilkinson and Burr, men between whose military talents there was no comparison, and signifi cantly enquiring at the same time, if the General had confidence in his officers—that at the head of one thousand men, Burr, in his opinion would be able, in defiance of all the opposition that could

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A letter from New Orleans describes General Wilkinson appearing before the Supreme Court of the Orleans Territory on December 18 to answer for his arrest and deportation of Dr. Erick Bollman, allegedly a Burr agent carrying treasonous proposals. Wilkinson appeared without guard or advocate and stated he would submit to the court's authority.

Virginia Argus · 13 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter from New Orleans.

"The 18th of December was a day of solemn interest and strong emotion in this city. General Wilkinson was on that day called upon to answer to the Supreme Court for having arrested and sent off Dr. Bollman, who was not only the bearer of a treasonable letter from Col. Burr to the General, in which he proposed to seduce the General and the corps under his command, from their fidelity, by the proffer of the second place in command, and high honors and rewards; but was actually the prime agent of Col. Burr in this city, to propagate his revolutionary projects, and to keep him ad-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

General Wilkinson addresses the court, expressing shock at the treachery of Burr's associates and naming Edward Livingston and James Alexander for alleged misprision of treason. He reads letters and documents intended to prove the extent of the conspiracy, warning of public complacency about the danger.

Virginia Argus · 13 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

preparing to defend this capital, the grand depository of the west, is idle and unnecessary, and must involve expenses which the occasion will not justify. And yet it has been said to me in the streets of this city, by men of distinction—"Burr will come;

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

General Wilkinson addresses the court, presenting letters and documents to support claims of a conspiracy, and names Edward Livingston and James Alexander as suspected conspirators linked to Aaron Burr. He also submits a deposition from Dr. Rogers recounting rumors of Burr's military preparations tied to an expedition to Mexico.

Virginia Argus · 13 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the nature of my suspicions. With respect to Mr. Livingston, I have been apprised of that gentleman's paying the conspirator Bollman 2,000 dollars, on a bill of exchange; and from an affidavit now in my hands, I have reason to believe that Mr. Livingston is connected with Burr in his present enterprise. (The general here read an affidavit of Dr. Rogers, of the U. States' navy, which is hereunto subjoined.) As respects the criminality of Mr. Alexander, I have been informed by Swartwout at Natchitoches, that Mr. Alexander had accompanied Dr.

See moreSee less

Bollman from Philadelphia to this place, with letters from Col. Burr to myself—these letters I have received from Bollman. In addition to these facts, immediately after my arrival in this city, Mr. Alexander waited on me, and enquired whether I had seen Bollman, and on my replying in the negative, offered to conduct Dr. Bollman to me. A few days after this I received a second visit from Mr. Alexander, at which time he declared that Col. Burr would suc[ceed]

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report summarizes several acts passed by Congress, including funding for seamen, fortifications, and military enforcement on public lands. It also reprints Burr's January letter to the Mississippi Territory's acting governor, in which he denies rumors of treasonous designs and cites a Kentucky grand jury's favorable report.

Virginia Argus · 13 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Copy of Colonel Burr's letter to the Secretary acting as governor of the Mississippi Territory. Bayou Pierre, 12th January, 1807. SIR, Being on my way down the river, with a number of my friends, who are disposed to

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report, reprinted from the Aurora, lists toasts given at a Jeffersonian celebration marking the anniversary of Jefferson's election. One toast condemns Burr and his co-conspirators, wishing them either death with ignominy or a life of infamy.

The Enquirer · 17 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

enemies. 6. Burr and his co-traitors; if they are not to die with ignominy—may they live in infamy. 7. A remedy suitable to the complaint of parson Smith: a roaring fire and a southern

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A newspaper writer defends General Wilkinson's controversial decision to seize and send three men to the seat of government, arguing that an officer who suspects treason deserves censure only if he fails to act. The piece explains the charges against the three detained men—one accused of aiding Burr, one accused of attempting to bribe Wilkinson, and one a foreign lawyer—while conceding Wilkinson erred procedurally by not delivering them to civil authority.

Virginia Argus · 17 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

whom, all these clamors have been raised. What is the naked fact ? Gen. Wilkinson has seized and sent round to the seat of government, three persons, at a time when he believed Orleans in danger of being attacked by a superior force. Of these persons the one is a bankrupt foreigner, charged on oath with being an accomplice of Aaron Burr. The second a young American, charged also on the oath of your commander in

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A private letter dated January 20 from New Orleans, reprinted via Washington City, reports that General Wilkinson's conduct is being criticized locally, though the writer believes him loyal. It warns that Burr still has many partisans and well-wishers in the western territories, suggesting the danger is not yet over.

Virginia Argus · 17 March 1807 · page 3

WASHINGTON (TTY, March 11. Extract nf a lettr, dated Xao Orient*,! Jannctrir 20'hy from a source entitled to the highest credit, to a gentleman in this cifu. “Gen. Wilkinson’s conduct is much cen sured here. I do not approve all his acts_ but my impressions are, that he is faithful to his country, and is actuated bv the best moth’cs. “I do not consider the danger as over. Burr has many partisans on the western waters, and I suspect many well-wishers in this, and perhaps vonr territory'. But T nevertheless hope, that all will yet lie well.”

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A letter from Natchez describes Aaron Burr being brought before a court lacking jurisdiction, where a grand jury acquitted him and rebuked the government for pursuing him. Burr then escaped, prompting the territorial executive to issue a $2,000 reward proclamation for his capture.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 March 1807 · page 3

„ WAffHjiMSrtOX CrrtpMarth ft. Etfract e? M Utter fmm?% ,.gcwfomgk«|f ondadbted veracity, doted Nottm, ?Jl ''nfmini. to hi* friend in this city. “ Col. Burr's arrival here has Caused a great bus tle, and almost stopped «d! business. ^ Ha Kas been brought before a court here, who. had no jurisdie iion in his case; and a grand jury "has been found, who have not only acquitted him, but presented the government for meddling with him. If this is con ceived abroad to be the sentiment of the people of this territory, : it will be very wrong, for it is quite the contrary.

See moreSee less

This was a jury packed by' He has since made bis escape, and the executive have this morning issued a proclamation, offering 2000 dollars to any one who will take him Op again. It being all a botched affair. I hope this present* mentmay not be misconceived by the general go, vernment; for I can confidently say, that there ts no part of the union more averse to a Separation in general, than this territory; although some things in the load law, have given much umbrage.'* . :; i.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A Mississippi Territory grand jury found no indictment against Aaron Burr after a jurisdictional dispute, but he was not released from his recognizance and then disappeared, reportedly going to his boats to tell his followers he must leave them. Governor Williams issued a proclamation offering $2,000 for Burr's capture after he failed to continue appearing in court as required.

The Wheeling Repository · 19 March 1807 · page 5

lation to offences against the U. States, but no indictment was preferred. The attorney general thought that the court had no jurisdiction, because the act of congress giving federal jurisdiction to the territorial courts of this territory, has relation to the courts operating over the whole territory; and we have no such courts, but the supreme court, which is little more than a court of ap peals in civil cases, and even in that capacity extending only to Pearl river. He moved therefore that the grand jury should be dismissed ; Mr.

See moreSee less

Burr oppos ed it, 8c judge Bruin would not consent to it unless the accused were discharg ed. The jury of course had no regular charge to examine witnesses upon, and stated that they had nothing against Mr. Burr. He was not, however, discharg ed from his recognizance, but he disap peared. It seems that he went to his boats on the Mississippi, above Natchez a few miles—harangued his people, told them he was obliged to leave them— that he could not now comply with his promises to them, but assured them that they should have the lands he had promised, on the IFashita—that it would he some months before he should see them again ; but, that they should not be disappointed.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report defends General Wilkinson's reliability as a witness against Aaron Burr, arguing that accusations from the accused cannot invalidate the accuser's testimony. It references President Jefferson's message to Congress describing how a confidential agent of Burr approached Wilkinson with coded communications outlining Burr's conspiratorial designs.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

[CONCLUDED.]

pr[es]sion, in this very case.

Holding these considerations stedfastly in view, let us concisely notice the facts, as stated either by Wilkinson or other persons.

See moreSee less

Whatever suspicions may be afloat as to the integrity or credibility of Wilkinson, for the reasons which have been already assigned, they cannot be received towards the invalidation of his testimony in this instance. There has not been adduced a shadow of proof of his want of fidelity. He has been, it is true, accused of dishonesty by those charged with guilt, with the crime of treason; but, is not this the first time we have ever heard of the veracity of the accuser being invalidated by the testimony of the accused; while the latter remained unacquitted? Is not such a doctrine monstrous? We must then, on the question now under consideration, consider Wilkinson's statements, as well as those of every other credible witness, true, unless they possess in themselves grounds for disbelief.

Let it not be here understood that we mean to decide on any of the vague charges alledged against the commander in chief. They may be true, but whether true, or not, they are inapposite in this view. His guilt, on a former occasion, cannot make his present acts criminal. Whatever degree of turpitude may attach to the former, the latter may be in the highest degree meritorious. Nor do we mean to pronounce conclusively on the motives of general Wilkinson even in this business. Let time develope them. If he has participated with Burr, let the facts be fairly and fully stated. But until they are, we can only judge on the in-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

President Jefferson's communication to Congress describes how General Wilkinson revealed that Burr's agent sought to enlist him in an unlawful enterprise against the Union, offering rewards for command and support. The message outlines Burr's dual aims—splitting the western states or attacking Mexico—using a fraudulent land purchase as cover, and his plan to seize New Orleans and its resources.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

prise. "The general's letter which came to hand on the 25th of Nov, as has been mentioned, and some other information, received a few days earlier, when brought together, developed Burr's general designs, different parts of which

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This piece defends General Wilkinson's controversial arrests of suspected Burr associates, arguing necessity justified bypassing ordinary civil process given fears of treasonous collusion with external force. It also includes a letter from near Natchez describing Burr's movements, his inability to fulfill promises to followers, and unconfirmed reports he crossed the Mississippi with a former associate of Nolan.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

...idence of intrigue, and to fear that the emissaries of Burr would raise a party against him, perhaps in his very army, and neutralise every measure of defence taken by him. Acting, therefore, on the necessity of the case, he arrested...

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This opinion piece argues that Aaron Burr formed a treasonable plan against the nation's welfare, citing his secrecy, recruitment of young men under false pretenses, and deception of militia officers into believing he had government authority. The author accuses Burr of spreading falsehoods and attempting to seduce U.S. officers from their duty, dismissing claims of his patriotism as political posturing by former opponents turned apologists.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

That Aaron Burr has formed a treasonable plan levelled at the destruction of every ingredient of our felicity cannot be disputed.

That his views were neither lawful or honorable

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report quotes and refutes Aaron Burr's letter to Henry Clay in which Burr denied any design against the government or the Union. It cites Wilkinson's affidavits and Eaton's testimony to argue Burr's protestations of innocence were deceptive, noting his acquittal in Kentucky was undeserved.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

to be his capital; organizing a force on the waters of the Mississippi, and extending conquests to Mexico."

"I have neither published a line on this subject, nor has any one through my agency, or with my knowledge."

See moreSee less

Is it to be believed that the long pieces ascribed to Blannerhasset, and published in the Ohio papers, were written without the approbation of Mr. Burr, when the precipitate flight of the former at dead of night is remembered, and his recent junction with Burr at Natchez.

"I have no design to intermeddle with the government or [di]sturb the tranquility of the United States, or of its territories or any part of them."

The affidavits of Wilkinson prove that his object was to revolutionize the territory of Orleans to

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The paper reprints several dispatches disputing whether Aaron Burr has been seized and confined aboard a U.S. armed vessel near Natchez. One account from New Orleans claims he is in custody, but the editors note this directly contradicts an earlier report that he had not been taken as of February 10th, casting doubt on the story.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From the Baltimore American.

Capt. Hart of the Comet, says it was reported at New Orleans at the time he left there, that Burr had been taken under the proclamation of governor Williams, and that it was understood he would be sent round in a vessel that had been purchased by the government. But as captain Hart was on board his vessel and on the point of sailing when the report reached him, he had no means of ascertaining the correctness of it.

See moreSee less

The foregoing is corroborated by the following article—

New Orleans, Feb. 12.

It is this morning reported, and we believe the report to be true, that col. Burr is now confined in one of the U. S. armed vessels before Natchez

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A judge ruled the territorial court lacked jurisdiction over the charges against Aaron Burr and urged his transfer to a competent tribunal, leading to a divided court and the grand jury's discharge. The jury found no evidence of wrongdoing by Burr, but after being denied release from his recognizance, Burr failed to appear and was discovered to have escaped.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

grand jury, that they would be discharged. Col. Burr made several observations against the motion, and remarked that if the attorney general had no business for the grand jury, he had, and that therefore they ought not to be dismissed. On this

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece dismisses defenders who call Burr a patriot, arguing his secretive conduct proves treasonous intent. It cites his recruitment of young men under false pretenses and reliance on bankrupt associates as presumptive proof of guilt.

The Enquirer · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE NATIONAL INTELLIGENCER.

WASHINGTON, March 13.

See moreSee less

The conspiracy of Burr against the peace and integrity of the union, unquestionably presents one of the most interesting topics for reflection, which either have occurred, or which can occur to a free people. Having for its object the immediate, or eventual overthrow of our representative system, to which we are indebted for the rare felicity we enjoy, and the raising on its ruins a system of military despotism, it is by no means surprising that the national feeling has been excited to the highest pitch, and that this subject has commanded an almost exclusive attention. Compared to such effects, how insignicant are the common contests of party, and even the hostile displays of foreign injustice?

But we are met on the threshold by the jaundiced eye of party, which refuses to see any thing treasonable in the schemes or conduct of Aaron Burr. We are told that he is an honorable man, and that fired by that patriotism which could not brook the degradation of his country, he was only preparing to draw his sword against the aggressions and insolence of its enemy. It is not marvellous that men, who, after furiously opposing the rise of this man, suddenly changed their course, and used their boldest efforts to raise him to the highest office in the government; and who, after having failed in this attempt, enlisted under his banners to make him the governor of an important state; it is not marvellous that men, so pliant in exchanging principle for policy, should now become the apologists of him they before so strenuously supported. But the intelligence of the people cannot be imposed upon by so flimsy an artifice.

That Aaron Burr has formed a treasonable plan levelled at the destruction of every ingredient of our felicity cannot be disputed.

That his views were neither lawful or honorable is evident from the uniform tenor of his actions for a considerable time past. If they were, why involve himself in clouds and darkness? Why not avow his purpose? Why set in motion a body of enterprising young men, under the idle pretext of an agricultural settlement? Why embark in his employ men almost entirely of bankrupt fortunes? These, it is true, form only presumptive proofs; but they

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This editorial argues Burr attempted to raise a military force against Spain, sought commissions to subvert U.S. officers, and deceived Henry Clay into defending him with false assurances. It reproduces Burr's letter to Clay denying any intent to dissolve the Union or arm forces, used earlier to secure acquittal by a Kentucky grand jury.

The Enquirer · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

excepting one, is already before the public: We mean the letter of Burr to Mr. Clay, the flagitiousness of which must startle the least conscientious mind. This letter we subjoin. We invite the attention of the nation to it, and we demand what confidence ought afterwards to be placed in the man, who could write such a letter, with the view of engaging in his defence the powerful talents of one whose whole life attested his devotion to liberty, to republican principle, to union, and who had recently been constituted one of its highest constitutional guardians.

See moreSee less

Let it be recollected that it was on the strength of the assurances contained in this letter, that Mr. Clay's services actually were commanded, that without them they would not have been rendered, and that it was probable in a great measure owing to this circumstance, that Burr was acquitted by the Grand Jury of Kentucky.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer argues that Wilkinson acted patriotically in exposing Burr's conspiracy, listing circumstantial evidence such as secret oaths, seduction of officers, and the Fort Adams affair. It rails against those who doubt Wilkinson's testimony and insists the evidence proves treasonous intent.

Virginia Argus · 20 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

nor human nature !

If the stupid and hardy assertion of the arrested be admitted to criminate their accuser, and to countervail impartial and circumstantial proof of the fact, if the criminal intent fully established by the declaration of the adherents of Burr, be now discredited, because they find it convenient at present to deny their guilt, there is an end to every principle of impartial judgment or just reasoning. If the air of mystery with which an alledged lawful enterprize has been conducted; if the numerous emissaries and agents dispersed throughout a place not the present alledged spot of rendezvous; if the oath of secrecy administered to the partizan; if the labored seduction of officers of the army to a base and profligate desertion of their duty, and a villainous robbery and surrender of public property at Fort Adams, be not admitted as proof; will obstinate disbelief deny that Wilkinson received a cyphered letter from Burr disclosing a dangerous project, or that Swartwout betrayed sufficient of the plot to prove that it intended treason?

See moreSee less

Or is it Wilkinson and facts which are to be alone discredited, on the single, bare, and unsupported asseverations of the criminated?

Why apply to Wilkinson to make him and his officers parties, if the plan was agricultural?

Why not apprize the government if the plan was military against the enemies of the United States, and of which it was the intention to co-operate with the regulars in measures of common hostility against a common enemy?

Why an oath of secrecy for adventurers to settle the Washita?

Why a shameful attempt to seduce the officers of the army into a plan incompatible with their duty?

Why emissaries at New-Or[leans]

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece argues that skeptics wrongly excuse Burr while unfairly condemning General Wilkinson on weaker evidence. The author insists that strong circumstantial proof supports the conspiracy charge and criticizes the public's readiness to believe Burr's denials over documented evidence.

Virginia Argus · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

these observations are not addressed.

True it is that the human mind ever prone to extremes, if it can bring itself to doubt the existence of this conspiracy, by a natural transition proceeds to an unqualified condemnation of Wilkinson. But what temper short of infatuation would it be, which discrediting positive proof, and the stronger assurance of concurring circumstances. commits the compendious injustice of not only declaring Wilkinson guilty upon infinitely lighter evidence than that upon which Burr is at once acquitted, but in return for the detection and defeat of treason, received as indisputable the daring and incredible imputation cast by exasperated guilt on the honor of him who provoked its fury, by opposing its designs and spurning at its offers ?

See moreSee less

Burr in the first rage of his disappointment charges Wilkinson with having been, and still being the "Pensioner of a foreign government"—and there is a party infatuated enough to credit the wicked assertion of a baffled traitor !

Bollman and Swartwout, Alexander, Ogden, and Adair, are discharged by judicial authority from confinement, because the law is not sufficiently strong for their punishment, and there are men hardy enough to assert their innocence, and that they have been the objects of the relentless persecution of a military tyrant !

Is there any doubt that Swartwout and Bollman were each of them the bearer of a treasonable proposal from the ringleader to general Wilkinson? And yet upon their escape by the unprecedented interference of a court without cognizance of the offence, there are to be found men ready to receive them with open arms, and to give public congratulatory dinners on the occasion.

Alexander in the most open and unequivocal manner evinced his knowledge and approbation of the enterprize, and proved himself beyond all reasonable doubt a party interested, and yet there are Americans prepared to defend him, because he has abused Wilkinson and reflected on the administration.

Although it is susceptible of proof, that Adair when in the custody of the officer to whose charge he was committed after his arrest, exclaimed in his hearing, in all the rage of disappointment, "d——n seize him, (Wilkinson) if he had delayed his arrest for forty-eight hours, he should have been my prisoner," and although, as appears by the affidavit hereto subjoined, major Floyd, and Mr. Ralston (to whom reference is made in Adair's publication, and who are therein stated never to have spoken to him on the subject of his intended route) did positively assert to a gentleman of respectability, that the operations of Burr were carried on conjointly with Adair, pointed out with correctness the route which Adair was to take to New-Orleans: and without the slightest temptation to falsehood concurred in saying, that Adair after consulting with Wilkinson, was to meet them at a certain day, at a certain spot, yet the cry of military persecution, and of the invasion of the constitution, will continue to be resounded by all who are ready to adopt even the cause of rebellion, if it can furnish a plausibe occasion of abusing the administration.

Let the reader here refer to the affidavit and judge for himself.

County of Orleans. ss.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The article argues that General Adair was knowingly complicit in Burr's enterprise, countering defenders who accuse Wilkinson of persecution. It presents a sworn affidavit from Dr. John Carmichael describing conversations with Ralston and Floyd that detailed Adair's planned route, coordination with Wilkinson, and reconnaissance of forts along the Mississippi.

Virginia Argus · 20 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

vit and judge for himself. County of Orleans, ss. Personally appeared before me, the subscriber, one of the justices of the peace in and for the said county, Dr. John F. Carmichael, who on his solemn oath declares, that on the evening of the 11th January, inst. Mr. Ralston and Mr. Floyd, the son of captain Floyd of Louisville, Kentucky, called at the house of this deponent, spent the evening and breakfasted with him the next day; that the conversation during the evening and morning generally related to the various opinions in circulation respecting Col Burr and the situation of this country; that after breakfast Mr.

See moreSee less

Ralston opened his business with this deponent, stating that he had descended the Mississippi as far as New Madrid in company with Col Burr, where he left him; that General Adair had gone to New Orleans by a circuitous route, and that his intention was to communicate with General Wilkinson, and to return so as to meet them at my house about that time if possible; that it was an object with them to ascertain the exact situation of the fort at Baton Rouge, the state of the works, the number of men, its weak situation; and that the Fort Adams was of some consequence, what United States troops were there, and who commanded them? where the gun-boats were? and who individually commanded them, who was the commanding officer of marines, &c. All these questions were answered by this deponent as far as he had been acquainted with them. The said Ralston and Floyd proposed to this deponent to visit Baton Rouge to ascertain the exact situation of that fort; but declined when the orders of Col Grand Prez were stated, and the difficulty attending such an enterprize. Mr. Ralston informed me that Col. Burr was to be on the 12th day of January, instant, at Bayou Pierre, where he was to wait for his reinforcement and to receive his information from his agents, who were circulated through the country in that time; that the first object of Col. Burr was to take Baton Rouge, where he was to raise his standard and to make his communication to the government of the United States, where he was to be joined by a number of men already engaged, to the amount of 10,000 men if necessary; that the number of men at present with Col. Burr did not exceed 150, but Col. Burr's arrangements were so made that the men already engaged in Kentucky and Tennessee should join without shew, so that no possible alarm or suspicion on the part of the general government might take place before he

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The report describes legal proceedings against Aaron Burr before the Mississippi Territory Supreme Court at Natchez, where jurisdictional disputes arose and the grand jury was eventually discharged after returning no indictment. Burr failed to appear in court as required and was discovered to have escaped, prompting Governor Robert Williams to issue a proclamation offering a $2,000 reward for his capture.

Herald of the United States · 21 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Georgia.

MARCH 16.

See moreSee less

The Aurora, by yesterday's mail, contains the proceedings of the Supreme Court at Natchez, in the case of Col. Burr. The court adjourned on the 2d ult. Col. Burr appeared on the day mentioned in the indictment; but the court could take no cognizance, as all criminal prosecutions must originate in the Circuit Courts, according to the statutes of the territory. Mr. Poindexter, the attorney-general, said the accused ought to be conveyed before the proper tribunal, and that the Grand Jury ought to be discharged.

Colonel Burr made several observations against the motion, and remarked, that the attorney-general had no business for grand jury, he had, and that therefore they ought not be dismissed. On this motion the court was divided. Judge Bruin declared himself opposed to discharging the grand jury, unless Colonel Burr was also instantly discharged from his recognizance.

The attorney-general then withdrew, and the grand jury were directed to retire to their room, who in the course of the day returned with sundry presentments. We deem it unneces-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The Scioto Gazette reprints a letter from President Jefferson to Ohio Governor Tiffin, thanking state officials and citizens for their vigilance and prompt action against Aaron Burr's conspiracy. Jefferson praises their patriotism and service to the country in confronting the plot.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 23 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE SCIOTO GAZETTE.

Chillicothe, February 26. The governor of this state has obligingly favored us with a copy of a letter from the President of the U. States, which gives us much pleasure in publishing, inasmuch as it is a just tribute of praise bestowed upon our constituted authorities, and those of our fellow citizens who distinguishe themselves by their patriotism in the late occurrence, relative to the conspiracy formed by colonel Burr; and must confound with shame, those who were base enough, either to throw obstacles in the way, or to attempt to turn into ridicule their united efforts for the public good.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 27 March 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A dispatch reports that Aaron Burr was conducted as a prisoner by a guard of ten men, with the information corroborated by a letter from a gentleman at Fort Stoddert. The letter noted that Burr had passed through that location about ten days prior to its date.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 23 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

resides at Fort Stoddert, who says that Mr. Burr passed through that place about ten days previous to the date of the above letter.

The ship Packet, arrived at Boston, in 26 days from Liverpool, brings Lon-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Governor Robert Williams of the Mississippi Territory issues a proclamation stating Aaron Burr failed to appear in court as his bond required and has apparently escaped. The proclamation offers a $2,000 reward for anyone who apprehends Burr and delivers him to authorities.

The Enquirer · 24 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ployed to promote this nefarious enterprize. What has become of Burr? This I cannot answer. Some think that he has escaped to the Spaniards.”

BY ROBERT WILLIAMS,

See moreSee less

Governor of the Mississippi Territory,

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Burr appeared before the Supreme Court of Mississippi Territory in Washington as required by his recognizance, with a grand jury empaneled after Judge Rodney's charge. The territorial attorney general then moved to discharge the jury, arguing the court lacked original jurisdiction over the alleged offenses and urging Burr be sent to a competent tribunal instead.

Virginia Argus · 24 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

NATCHEZ, February 10.

COL. BURR.

See moreSee less

On Monday the 2nd inst. an adjourned Session of the Supreme court of the Mississippi Territory was held in the town of Washington, to which Aaron Burr was recognized to appear and answer such Bill of indictment as might then and there be exhibited against him. Col Burr appeared on the day mentioned in his recognizance, attended by his counsel William B. Shields and Lyman Harding, Esqrs. Agreeably to a venire facias, issued by the Hon. Tho's Rodney and Peter B. Bruin, a jury of 72 freeholders appeared in court, and on the day following 23 of their number were selected by the court as a grand inquest. The hon. Thomas Rodney then delivered to them a comprehensive and impressive charge, and the court was adjourned till ten o'clock the succeeding day—at which time Mr. Poindexter, the attorney general, moved the court to discharge the grand jury. He stated that after examining the depositions submitted to him by the court, he did not discover any testimony which brought the offences charged against col Burr within the jurisdiction of the courts of the Mississippi Territory: that the su-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

After the Mississippi grand jury found no indictment and was discharged, Burr failed to appear in court as required and was confirmed to have escaped. Governor Robert Williams issued a proclamation offering a $2,000 reward for Burr's apprehension and delivery to authorities.

Virginia Argus · 24 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TORY.

A PROCLAMATION.

See moreSee less

Whereas AARON BURR, esq. late vice-president of the United States, was bound in recognizance to appear at the supreme court of this territory, himself in the sum of five thousand dollars, and two securities in the sum of two thousand five hundred dollars each, "to answer any bills of indictment that might be found against him, "and to continue to appear from day to day, until dismissed by the said court," which he has failed to comply with, and as it appears has made his escape:

I do, therefore, issue this my proclamation for apprehending the said Aaron Burr, esq. and by the powers and authorities which I possess, will pay or cause to be paid, to any person or persons who will take the person of said Aaron Burr, and cause him to be delivered to me at this place, or to the president of the United States, the sum of two thousand dollars.

Given under my hand, at the town of Washington, this 6th day of February, 1807.

ROBERT WILLIAMS.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The piece discusses Mr. Eppes's speech on Gen. Wilkinson's handling of the Burr conspirators, suggesting Wilkinson may have acted from patriotic motives in sending prisoners away from New Orleans. It criticizes him for failing to send evidence justifying the arrests, noting the prisoners were later discharged for lack of proof.

Virginia Argus · 24 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE very able speech of Mr. EPPES on Broom's resolution has thrown considerable light on the mysterious conduct of Gen. Wilkinson. His observations on the difficulties which might have attended the trials of Bollman, Swartwout and others at New-Orleans, demonstrate that the General may have acted in this bold and energetic manner, under a persuasion that the prisoners could not have been safely tried at that place, in consequence of the expected approach of Burr, or that no provision in the law existed authorising the courts there to try persons accused of treason against the United States.

See moreSee less

Gen. Wilkinson might therefore have been induced by the best of motives (viz. a desire to save his country) to seize those men and send them away from a scene of action, where they may have had many partizans, and where their presence might have been mischievous, in case their coadjutor Burr had advanced with a[ny considerable force. A difficulty have]

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer argues that while Wilkinson may have been justified in acting on suspicion against Burr's associates, he failed to provide evidence or affidavits, leading to their release, and calls for a public explanation. The piece also urges continued vigilance against Burr's alleged plots and a federal-monarchist faction, referencing Wilkinson's and Eaton's earlier warnings.

Virginia Argus · 24 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

out delay. The tales of the arch traitor, Aron Burr, and of his confederates, against the character of the general, ought to have no weight with rational men; but such parts of the transactions of the latter as are known to have actually taken place, should, nevertheless, be fairly investigated; since, in a free country, no man is above responsibility to the laws, and every citizen ought to be compelled to give a faithful account of his conduct, so far as the public interest is concerned.

Mr. Pleasants, I BEG your permission to throw out to our fellow citizens, in your Argus, such hints, occasionally, as may serve to keep them on the watch with all the eyes of Argus. On the present occasion, I call on them for the vigilance of Argus. I mean to watch the state of our affairs, at home and abroad—at home, respecting Burr's plots, and the plots of a federal or anglo-monarchico-aristocractic faction—and abroad, our affairs which have been supposed capable of an adjustment by our ministers, Monroe and Pinckney.

See moreSee less

With respect to Burr's affairs, let them not be lulled into a dangerous state of security; believing (as all those would persuade them to believe, who wished success to any one of the projects attributed to him) that his views were harmless and honorable—Let them rather be on their guard. Let them carefully avoid discouraging such communications as Genls. Wilkinson and Eaton gave. Let them consider what might have been the consequence, had those gentlemen supposed that their information would be derided, merely because the early exertions of the executive blasted all hopes of success, and gave time for the crafty conspirators to countermand the marching orders; the meeting at their intended place of rendezvous, and to disperse and divest themselves of every instrument which could exhibit an hostile appearance. Let our citizens recollect how long it is since certain

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report states no further information has been received about Burr's arrest, though he is believed to be en route to Washington. It recounts his escape, time with his party, crossing the Mississippi into a swamp, and a letter describing a visit from Burr at Fort Stoddert before he was taken across the Alabama River.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 March 1807 · page 2

Attract of a letter, dated Fort Stod* dcrt, Feb. 24, to a gentleman in fo oshi.-igton. '■ A visit from Aaron Burr, esq. on the ll'th of the present month has pre* vented\ny attention, before this even ing, to the content', of yi.uilettt r, but j having to-day taken leave ef this dis* '• tingoi'sbed character, aft r seeing him, across the Alabama, on his way toyouT city, I returned to this place."

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A House member defends General Wilkinson's suspension of habeas corpus and detention of suspected conspirators as necessary to prevent treason, citing the case of Ogden who was released and allegedly continued plotting. He argues the civil authority was inadequate to safely hold the prisoners and compares the situation favorably against past insurrections.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 25 March 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

After making these observations Mr. S. begged leave to consider the merits of the question. I consider it, said he, as higly improper at this time. Whether it would be proper at any future period I don't pretend to say. It is likely that prosecutions will be commenced against general Wilkinson. And will not this house show as much candor as the editors of newspapers who say nothing on criminals left for trial lest there should be a bius made on the publick mind. No person can candidly say that gen. Wilkinson ought not to have deprived these men of liberty to prevent their treason and the destruction they meant against these United States.

Why such sympathy for these persons? In what circumstances were they taken? Were they taken from their homes and their fire-sides and denied the habeas corpus for some months as has been in former cases, which, compared to this, were only as a drop to the bucket. These men were taken in the act of treason or misprison of treason, against these United States. We ought to wait till we know further into the matter before we decide.

See moreSee less

Is any member so lost to humanity in this house as to reprobate the conduct of the executive or of general Wilkinson in this matter? The former insurrections compared to this, was more properly oppositions to government, oppositions to obnoxious and unjust laws, and which have been since repealed, and are now justly consigned to eternal infamy.

The matter rests solely on two plain questions. The first is, was the confinement of these persons necessary? And secondly, was the civil authority adequate to their safe keeping? It is plain their confinement was necessary, and as to the second question, it appears from the affidavit of gen. Wilkinson, that Ogden, one of the conspirators, was released by habeas corpus after being confined.

If a force of 6000 men had come against New-Orleans as the general expected, and he had not arrested and sent these persons away, and they had been released by Burr after capturing the city, these persons whom we see on this floor to have so much sympathy, would be the first to charge gen. Wilkinson with a neglect of duty. I have no doubt but this would be the case.

I consider the conduct of gen. Wilkinson not only justifiable, but highly commendable, and I am astonished that any one should withhold the tribute so justly due. I would say: Well done thou good and faithful servant, thou hast deserved well of thy country.

Mr. S. made sundry obervations, relative to the faculties of man compared with those of the deity in going from parts to the whole from the whole to parts, and quoted some lines from Pope's Essay on Man which he read from a bit of paper in his hand. Mr. Sloan then concluded by politely observing that he hoped the gentleman from Delaware had had a good rest and comfortable sleep the last night after his long speech of yesterday.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report states that no additional intelligence has been received about Mr. Burr, but he has likely reached Richmond by now to appear before the tribunals there. It notes that Blennerhassett's Island, under Virginia's jurisdiction, was the site of some of the alleged outrages.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY.

FRIDAY, MARCH 27.

See moreSee less

We have not received any additional intelligence relative to Mr. Burr. He has probably, ere this, reached Richmond, before the tribunals at which

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report describes Burr's disappearance after addressing his followers near Natchez, promising them lands on the Washita despite his departure, with rumors he crossed the Mississippi accompanied by a former associate of Philip Nolan. Three of his party—Blannerhassett, Davis Floyd, and Rolston—were arrested on suspicion of plotting to seize Baton Rouge and possibly Fort Adams, while the overall conspiracy appeared to be collapsing.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

been arrested, viz. Mr. Blannerhasset, Mr. Davis Floyd, and Mr. Rolston, on the ground it is said of information given by persons formerly in the scheme, stating the intention to seize Baton Rouge, and probably Fort Adams.—They are not yet finally committed for trial. The party seems to have been frittered away to nothing—many people, ignorant probably of the real views of Mr. Burr, will be most materially injured. Never, perhaps, did an enterprize of such vast extent, and aided by such a concentration of intrigue and talents and energies, terminate in effects so truly contemptible.

See moreSee less

"A Spanish officer came to Mr. Burr ten days ago from Pensacola.—His friend governor Folch, after forbidding the passage of the U. States' troops from Fort Stoddert to New Orleans, to arrest the progress of Burr, has come into the settlement of Baton Rouge, to make an idle parade of resistance. Possibly the ex-vice-president may next shew himself there. But let him shew himself where he will—if from the scattered embers of a fallen faction, he ever revives in a shape formidable to the safety and tranquility of the U. States—he will be a Phoenix indeed."

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A Cincinnati newspaper reprints a sworn deposition in which Major Ephraim Kibbey answers questions before a justice of the peace about his alleged involvement in Aaron Burr's conspiracy, as named in General Eaton's affidavit. Kibbey denies any correspondence or recruitment ties to Burr, describing only an indirect approach by an unnamed intermediary regarding a secret expedition against Mexico.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From the Cincinnati Mercury.

State of Ohio, Hamilton county, } ss.

See moreSee less

By the request of general John S. Gano, major Ephraim Kibbey, personally appeared before me, James Ew-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The piece argues that facts about Wilkinson's actions and the Burr conspiracy are still too uncertain for fair judgment, cautioning against premature condemnation. It defends withholding verdict amid partisan attacks while promising fuller examination of whether military authority can justify infringing civil rights.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tations thrown on his fame we pretend not to say. They may be true; but however clearly this may be eventually established, it is not less certain, that there is at present before the public no information on which an honest and unprejudiced mind would feel itself at liberty to decide. If any judgment were given, it would be that of acquittal and not conviction, according to the invariable feeling of every honest mind that an individual ought to be considered innocent until proof is adduced of his guilt. Equally obscure is the information we have heretofore received of the degree of danger existing or apprehended at New Orleans.

See moreSee less

Nor are we better enlightened with regard to the number or power of Burr's confederates at that place. Under these circumstances it is the duty of a man, not rash to madness, or prejudiced beyond conviction, to hesitate before he definitively declares gen. Wilkinson unjustified in the strong measures he has taken.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Benjamin Stoddert publishes a letter denying a circulated story that he was entrusted with subversive schemes by Aaron Burr and then betrayed him to authorities. He states Burr never communicated any plot to him and that he gave no information to the executive, though he was summoned (but not sworn) as a potential witness in the Bollman and Swartwout case.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

For the National Intelligence. Mr. Smith, An unfounded story, dishonourable I think to me, has been copied from another paper, into yours—that colonel Burr had so far mistaken my character, as to communicate to me, schemes tending to subvert the government—and that after allowing myself to be the depositary of his secrets; I had the treachery to betray him. The story is not told exactly in those words, but such is the only impression, so far as it regards myself, it is calculated to make. Col. Burr never communicated any scheme of any kind to me.

See moreSee less

I never made a communication to the executive, in relation to col. Burr. In common with others who sometimes associated with col. Burr, I have heard from him speculative opinions respecting our government: and I have some times

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A speaker in Congress argues that even if Burr and his associates are traitors, they must be tried under proper law rather than subjected to arbitrary military arrest and transport as General Wilkinson has done. The speech warns that allowing such extralegal action sets a dangerous precedent, even hypothesizing a congressman being seized and killed under similar pretenses.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Suppose Aaron Burr is a conspirator, a traitor, let him be hanged, but let it be done by law. Suppose treason has existed for years; suppose a man has participated in the plot, and gone all length with the traitors; suppose at last he has outherded Herod, cut off his co-conspirators and stabs

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report announces that Aaron Burr, former Vice-President, has arrived in Richmond as a state prisoner, and relays a secondhand account of his arrest in the Tombigbee country in early March. The paper explicitly cautions that the account, obtained from Burr's escort via a fellow stagecoach traveler, may be imperfect and promises future corrections.

The Enquirer · 27 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, 27th MARCH.

AARON BURR, Ex-Vice-President of the U. States, is now in this city; guarded as a state-prisoner.

See moreSee less

We have had no opportunity of conversing with his escort; but a gentleman, who travelled with them in the stage, has given us the following account of the manner of his arrest, obtained from their lips.—It is not to be expected that it should be completely correct: But we shall hereafter amend whatever imperfections which we may be fortunate enough to detect.

Col. Burr was apprehended in the Tombigbee country in the first days of March; perhaps

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 31 March 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A traveler reports that Aaron Burr, in custody of Capt. Perkins and a military guard, passed through Charlotte County, Virginia on a Sunday, stopping near Hampden Sidney College before continuing toward Washington City. The report estimates they would have arrived in Washington by Wednesday evening or Thursday morning.

Virginia Argus · 27 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FRIDAY, MARCH 27, 1807. AARON BURR, IN CUSTODY AGAIN. A gentleman from Charlotte county, in this state, who arrived in town on Tuesday evening, informs us, that Col. Burr, in the custody of a capt. Perkins of the Federal

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This item is an ironic, sarcastic piece reprinted from a Federalist paper, mockingly 'defending' General Wilkinson against charges of tyranny and treason by listing absurd justifications for his actions. It extends the satire to accuse President Jefferson of being behind the conspiracy, using exaggerated contradictions to ridicule Federalist criticisms of the administration's handling of the Burr affair.

Virginia Argus · 27 March 1807 · page 3

From the Trenton True American. Federal Facts and Arcumitots : Condensed from F'ed. fiafiers and afire dies. • Wilkinson is a Tyrant, a Traitor,and a i Coward I—To preserve the Constitution I from total destruction, he violated one pf j its provisions—to protect the liberties of ! millions, he abridged the freedom of four i or live individuals for two nr three weeks! i —to prevent a deluge of blood, he denoun ced and delivered up to the civil authority . those whom he was convinced were pre ; pardug to make it flow—to obviate the | trouble and expense of an army to march from Washington to New-Orleans, he sent j some suspected characters from Ncw-Or I leans to Washington, w.ien they seemed i to be busily preparing for a journey to !

See moreSee less

Mexico!-He is a blood) tyrant, nr he i would have tried these men for spies and j conspirators, and shot them immediately! j —He is a notorious Traitor, or he would j have jo.ned Burr in overturning the Con ; stitution, and establishing a Monarchy !_ | He is a consummate Coward, or he would ! have dared to lead his army against his J country, instead of risking life, property ; and reputation in defence of it!—He is a ; pensioner of Spain, for a convention of 1 Kentuckians voted him their th inks for the very act which is now charged upon him as traiterous !—If he would not aid i Burr, he might have winked at his designs,

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The National Intelligencer argues that General Wilkinson was justified in his extraordinary measures against civil authority at New Orleans, citing the exposed frontier and threat of Spanish attack. It contends that Burr's agents attempting to corrupt Wilkinson's army gave him reasonable grounds for alarm and action.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

From the National Intelligencer.

THE CONSPIRACY. (Concluded.)

See moreSee less

To determine whether the measures pursued at New Orleans are justifiable, it is necessary to consider how far gen. Wilkinson had reason to believe that such a necessity existed, as required an invasion of the civil authority.

The most obvious consideration that presents itself on this subject is the scene of action, which differed from the other parts of the United States, in two material respects; from its being the theatre of menaced hostilities on the part of Spain, and from the circumstances that naturally flowed from its recent acquisition.

The whole tenor of gen. Wilkinson's dispatches and measures shew that he considered the frontier exposed to the greatest danger; and that he doubted the competency of his forces to defend it against the superior forces that Spain either had, or contemplated to put in motion against him. He knew that if he should be defeated, New Orleans must fall. While under these apprehensions, the emissaries of Burr appear in the midst of his army, and attempt to corrupt him. Had he not sufficient reason to be alarmed at the audacity and profligacy of such an attempt? Had he not reason to apprehend that the same motives that led to this attempt would extend itself to efforts to seduce his officers and men? He could fully appreciate the effect on gallant or

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report recounts General Wilkinson's sworn account of letters and conversations with Burr, Bollman, and Swartwout, detailing claims of funds, foreign support, and thousands of men mobilizing for an expedition against Mexico and New Orleans. It reflects the evidence being used to build the case of Burr's alleged treasonous conspiracy.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Spain; and others by offers of land in Bastrop's claim on the Washita."

In consequence of this information a large armed force was, either held in readiness or called out in the several states and territories, and vigorous measures pursued for defending New Orleans.

See moreSee less

His other projects having proved abortive, "He determined to seize on New Orleans, plunder the bank there, possess himself of the naval and military stores, and proceed on his expedition to Mexico."

The impressions on the mind of Wilkinson were derived principally, as far as is known to us, from Burr's letters to him, which announces the following facts.

1. that Burr had funds.

2. That he had commenced the enterprize.

3. That the protection of England was secured.

4. That Truxtun had gone to Jamaica, and would bring from thence aids from England.

5. That the navy of the U. S. would join the expedition.

6. That on the 15th of November, 500, or 1000 men, the first detachment, would move down the river.

7. That Swartwout, the bearer of the letter, was thoroughly informed of the plans and intentions, and would disclose as far as Wilkinson should enquire.

8. That Bollman, equally confidential and even better informed and more intelligent, would hand a duplicate of the letter.

In the conversation, which Wilkinson deposes he had with Bollman, he says Bollman, "informed me that he had seen a letter from col. Burr of the 30th of Oct. in which he, (col. Burr) gave assurances that he should be at Natches with 2000 men on the 20th Dec. inst. where he should wait until he heard from this place. That he would be followed by 4000 men more, and that he (col. Burr) if he had chosen, could have raised or got 12,000 as easy as 6,000, but that he did not think that number necessary.

In his conversation with Swartwout, Wilkinson deposes that the latter informed him, "That col. Burr with the support of a powerful association extending from New York to New Orleans, was levy[ing]

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report recounts depositions, including Lieutenant Wilson's testimony, describing the panic in New Orleans over fears that Burr and his confederates were advancing with an armed force to seize the city, plunder the bank, and launch an expedition against Mexico or dismember the union. It details General Wilkinson's defensive military preparations based on this intelligence, presented to justify his actions as necessary given the perceived crisis.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

He says, "I left New Orleans on my way to this city on the 15th of December last; at that time, and for some time preceding, the strongest apprehensions and belief universally prevailed among the inhabitants of that city, that Aaron Burr and his confederates had prepared an armed force, and were advancing to attack and plunder the city; in consequence of which the greatest alarms prevailed, a general stagnation of business ensued, and the danger was credited there as a matter of public notoriety:—that brigadier general Wilkinson with the army of the United States was at New Orleans, occupied in the most active military preparations for the defence of the place; repairing the forts, mounting the cannon, collecting ammunition, &c. all under the firm persuasion and belief that such an attack was meditated, and about very speedily to take place, by the said Burr and his confederates; this deponent knows that the general was decidedly of opinion, from the most satisfactory information, that the said Burr and his confederates were advancing with an armed force against the place."

Such are the leading facts on which general W. took his measures. There are several other affidavits which strongly corroborate them; but as they all go to the same effect, so far as regards the reality or apprehension of danger at New Orleans, and principally differ from these as to the persons implicated, we shall not particularly notice them.

See moreSee less

Let then any man combine all these facts, and from their collective force appreciate the degree of danger in the territory of Orleans, and say whether there was not reason to believe that without a striking display of power, the plan to seize the city, to plunder the bank, and to provide the means either of an expedition against Mexico, or of a dismemberment of the union, or of both, might not have succeeded? The actual result is not here to be considered. That could not be known to Wilkinson.—

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

Governor Robert Williams of the Mississippi Territory issues a proclamation stating that Aaron Burr failed to appear in court as required by his recognizance and has apparently escaped. He offers a $2,000 reward for Burr's capture and delivery to himself or the President.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 31 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

He stoutly denies any concern in Burr's projects—threatens vengeance against Wilkinson, and shews his teeth at the President. All this is perfectly natural. He may be innocent—but if he were guilty, he would doubtless pursue this very same course. A man

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report describes Aaron Burr's flight toward Spanish territory via the Mobile River, his apprehension by Lieutenant Gaines at Fort Stoddart, and his subsequent escort under guard through Virginia to Richmond. It notes he is being taken to undergo examination before Chief Justice Marshall.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 31 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the Spanish line.

On the road, they met the file of soldiers accompanied by Mr. Perkins & lieut. Gaines. "What," says col. Burr; or words to that effect; "do soldiers travel here in this style, on horseback?" "No," answered his companion. Col. Burr is said to have immediately dropt his bridle, and clasping his hands together, to have uttered some ejaculation of vehement emotion; what that was, we cannot trust ourselves to describe. Lieut. Gaines advanced up to him, and interrogated him whether he was not col. Burr. The scene closed by lieut. Gaine's ominous words: "You are my prisoner sir."

See moreSee less

An escort of eight men accompanied col. Burr from that quarter of the country on their way to Washington. They crossed at Cole's ferry—On Monday morning between the hours of eleven and twelve they passed Prince Edward Court House. On Wednesday evening about five o'clock they arrived in Fredericksburg. Here they met with a gentleman from Washington, who was instructed to order them to Richmond, and on last evening the stage conveyed them to our city, col. Burr and his escort of seven men. The gentleman who met them at Fredericksburg has accompanied them to this place, and bears a communication from the executive to the United States attorney for this district.

He is conducted to this city, to undergo an examination before chief justice Marshal.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The paper revises its earlier account of Burr's arrest, stating it occurred on February 19 rather than March 3 as first reported. It also provides a detailed geographic description of the Mississippi Territory and disputed routes Burr may have taken, debating whether he intended to stay within U.S. jurisdiction or flee to Spanish Florida.

The Enquirer · 31 March 1807 · page 3

ARREST OF AARON BURR

The town of Natches, in the Miflifiippi Ter ritory, where A Burr's boats were depof.ted, is on the river Miilillippi. About two hundred miles to the eafl of this

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Virginia Argus reports that Aaron Burr is in custody charged with treason and will be tried in Richmond, promising faithful coverage of the proceedings. It notes that his examination before Chief Justice Marshall began the previous day at the Eagle Tavern, conducted privately with only the prisoner, court officers, counsel, and witnesses admitted, despite great public curiosity.

Virginia Argus · 31 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Yesterday the examination of Col. Burr before Chief Justice Marshall commenced at the Eagle Tavern. It was conducted in private ; no person being admitted but the prisoner, the officers of the Federal court,

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Col. Burr's examination before Chief Justice Marshall was conducted privately at the Eagle Tavern, excluding the public and causing discontent among citizens. He was released on $5,000 bail with further proceedings to continue publicly at the Capitol the next day.

Virginia Argus · 31 March 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

riously represented. Some say that the Chief Justice consulted the counsel both for and against the prisoner, as to their wishes with regard to the place of examination; informing them that it should either be at the Capitol, or the Eagle Tavern, as they might choose; and that they preferred the latter. Others, report that the examination was secret for the purpose of preventing persons, who might be on the venire on his trial, from previously making up their minds on the subject. But we humbly conceive no good reason can be given for introducing in a free country a practice so similar to that of the holy inquisition in Spain.

See moreSee less

On this day we are informed that the investigation is to be publicly continued or renewed at the Capitol, & that the counsel on both sides are to argue the case. Mr. Rodney the Attorney General of the U. S. and Mr. Hay are to conduct the prosecution, and Messrs. Randolph and Wickham are employed for Col. Burr.

See the clipping