As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

The Western Plot

November 1806 – April 1807

Then Burr all but vanished from these papers: in the whole of 1805 they printed just 13 articles about him. When he came back, in the fall of 1806, it was as something worse than a duelist.

Burr resurfaces in the West

Driven from New York by the duel, Burr has spent months crossing and recrossing the western country. Now he is reported at Marietta, Ohio, hiring boats and offering young men commissions. The writer suspects he means to split the West from the Union.

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Enquirer · 7 November 1806 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr, for some cause or other, has, during the last 18 months, been traversing "to and fro" in the western country. The affair of his killing Hamilton has driven him from his former residence at New-York. He has no wife—no rising family to induce him to forget his chagrin of disappointed ambition in the solace of domestic comforts. His situation is such, as leaves him entirely under the control of his restless, aspiring disposition.

Col. Burr is now gone to the westward. It has long ago been intimated, that he is preparing to effect something in that quarter—supposed to be a separation of the western States, &c. from the Union. These things ought certainly to be looked after by the government—we think the administration must be inexcusable, if it sleeps at such a juncture. The shepherd ought to be awake when the wolf is invading the fold.

See moreSee less

Extract of a letter from a gentleman of respectability in Hampshire County, Mass. to his friend in this vicinity, dated in September last.

"General Eaton is now in this town; and he says, that he has seen a letter but a few days from Marietta (Ohio) which informed, that Col. Burr, was there, and was undertaking, or endeavoring to undertake, an expedition—that he had actually engaged some boats, and offered commissions to a number of young gentlemen in those parts, to engage with him in what he (Burr) said "would be a laudable and honorable undertaking." General Eaton has no doubt that Burr's intent is to erect a separate government west of the Alleganies, and probably make himself either a sovereign, or be Viceroy to some foreign Prince. The latter, I am inclined to think, cannot be the motive. Burr had rather be the first in hell, than to serve in heaven. Spain will not be in a condition to support such a colony: perhaps France may.—Should Burr raise an insurrection, many things will be necessary, which we little think of."

Farmers Cabinet.

See the clipping

Hauled into court in Kentucky

At Frankfort, a federal attorney asks the court to bring Burr in to answer charges that he is raising an expedition against Spain’s colonies. A grand jury is summoned.

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

Virginia Argus · 5 December 1806 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

KENTUCKY. Washington, Nov. 15. Extracts from a letter dated Frankfort, Nov. 8th, 1806.

"A letter received by a gentleman here, from general Wilkinson, of recent date, mentions his having captured sixty mules, thirty of which were loaded with silver, together with their escort; and that he was on his march to meet the Spanish army, and was then within a small distance of them, and although his number of men was far inferior to those of the Spaniards, he felt confident, if an action ensued that he should defeat them.

See moreSee less

"On Wednesday last, the attorney for the United States for the district of Kentucky, made a motion to the Federal court, now in session at this place, for a process to bring before the court col. Burr late vi[ce] president of the U. S. (who was then in Lexington,) to answer charges stated in an affidavit, made by the attorney, that he was well informed and verily believed, that Col. Burr was forming an expedition (and purchasing stores, &c for that purpose) against some of his Catholic majesty's colonies now in amity with the United States. The court, however, no doubt from the importance of the subject, ordered a grand jury to be summoned, before whom I suppose the attorney will prefer an indictment. The jury was sworn to day, and ordered by the court to appear on Wednesday next, by which time the attorney is to produce the evidence in support thereof. Should the grand jury find a true bill, it is probable that an immediate trial will be had, as col. Burr has come to town for the purpose of meeting the charge."—The Auxiliary.

See the clipping

Who is paying for it?

A letter from Washington ‘from high authority’ says more than a thousand young men have passed through Pennsylvania and New York to the Ohio to join Burr. Its writer doubts Burr ever meant to break up the Union. His theory: Spanish money, from Spain’s late minister in Washington, to pay for a strike at New Orleans and then Mexico.

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Enquirer · 3 January 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BURR'S EXPEDITION.

The following STATEMENT is from high authority, and is entitled to considerable credit.

See moreSee less

WASHINGTON CITY, Dec. 19, 1806.

The reports concerning Col. Burr, his party and his scheme, have hitherto been so perplexed, that I could not digest them into any thing which I thought worthy of being sent to you. As you no doubt are extremely impatient to learn what is known, and as I am not less desirous to relieve that impatience, as far as I am able, I will delay no longer. The facts are as follows. In the course of the last Autumn, from August to the 1st inst. more than a thousand young men have passed through Pennsylvania and New-York, to the Ohio, with the acknowledged view of forming a body to defend the Mississippi, under the command of Col. Burr, upon an expedition they have said is authorized by government, but the precise nature of which was not to be communicated to them till they had embodied at the falls of Ohio. A number, not inconsiderable, of persons, being on the Ohio and near it, have openly engaged in the expedition. Boats sufficient to convey an army have been built, under contract with Col. Burr. Many of those boats are of a construction quite unusual for the ordinary purposes of transporting merchandize, produce, or settlers; and will answer it is said for a coasting voyage. Provisions have been amassed in quantity. Arms and ammunition have been collected. Col. Burr has in a few instances by letter, in many by discourse, and in a great number by means of his partizans, assured officers of militia in the Western country, that there would soon be a great call for militia, on the Western waters, upon which he was to have a high command under the government. He has exhorted them to hold themselves and their men in readiness for service, and has encouraged them to look up to him as their future commander.

These circumstances taken together evince a design of magnitude. This tampering with militia officers in order to win their minds to his person, his building sea boats and collecting arms and ammunition, would prove that the design could not be to settle Baron Bastrop's grant of land, as every one at first conjectured; but that is besides completely demonstrated by the fact, that his expenditures already have, perhaps, nearly equalled the sum, for which that grant, if confirmed, would at this time fell. The disclosures made by him to different persons, whom he attempted in vain to seduce, contradict that supposition. Several of those have been communicated by men of high respectability, without any concert with each other, or knowledge that others were doing it; and they all concur to fix upon him treasonable designs, of the most daring and dangerous nature. These disclosures of his views, were so much varied from caution, and so artfully interwoven with the different plans assured only to mask the real object, that it is still somewhat in the dark. The greatest sceptic, however, must now admit that it was not less than to raise the standard of revolt, and take possession of New-Orleans. I believe myself, that this was only the first step in the project. That he would immediately have proclaimed from New-Orleans, an expedition for the conquest of Mexico; which would have quickly brought such a number of bold adventurers to his standard, from all parts of the union, and of the islands, that he would perhaps have been enabled to remain there until his preparations for the undertaking were complete, in defiance of the whole power of the U. S. If the first step could have succeeded, his hopes of ascending the throne of Mexico would have been by no means so extravagant. The rout by land is now perfectly well known to be good and to pass through a country capable of maintaining an army. It is admitted by all that an army of 5000 Americans would be sufficient to penetrate to the capital and to hold the Kingdom for some time, unless succours could be sent to it from Europe. The number of adventurers who would flock to Col. Burr's standard, if he could once raise it in the city of Mexico, would perhaps exceed that number tenfold in the first year and might be sufficient to confirm his authority and his possession of the country.

I cannot believe that he ever seriously entertained the hope of effecting a dismemberment of the union. Every unprejudiced American will I think admit, that such an event is for the present impossible; for the future as far as human foresight can reach by no means probable. That scheme, however as paradomical as the assertion may appear, I strongly believe was the main pivot upon which the whole turned, and yet never was for one moment seriously contemplated by col. Burr.

A question forcibly presents itself, whence has he derived his funds? The answer must rest entirely upon conjecture, for there is nothing known upon that point. One thing seems tolerably certain however from the extent of those funds that they have come from royal coffers. From the coffers of England I do not believe they have come, although I have little doubt there has been a secret communication between Burr and Miranda, who I shall ever belive received advances from Mr. Pitt. I cannot believe that Great Britain would support, countenance or conceal designs of a treasonable nature against our government. The policy of the present administration of that country is two noble and elevated for such a measure.

How has Burr been supplied then? I will answer from the Spanish government, by the person who was lately Spanish minister in the United States and who still resides here in a private station. This, I acknowledge, is as yet only conjecture; but then it has every appearance of truth, and this advantage besides, that it is the only conjecture admissible at all. That person has been completely duped by Colonel Burr. He has been made to believe, that the design was simply rebellion and dismemberment, which from his personal resentment, as well as the animosity subsisting at present between the two nations, he was ready to foster and maintain with the treasures of his King. It is said that several millions of Spanish money have been landed in the United States in the last six months: the fact confirms the suspicion. He viewed Burr simply as a traitor and intended to use him to make a diversion in favor of Spain in the west. Without large sums of money Burr could not proceed at all: from him alone they could be obtained: the concealment of his real design and the assumption of a plan suitable to the views of the Spaniards was necessary. He, therefore, contrary to his confirmed habits of caution, spoke of the design of dismemberment just enough to answer the end of deception. Can it be believed, that it would ever have escaped his lips without some view of that kind? His character and the tenor of his whole conduct, forbid the idea, that he could have spoken openly to so many persons of his intention to commit treason. His private intercourse with the Spaniards some months past is well known. No doubt it has ceased, and the eyes of his dupe are at last open, but his money is gone irrecoverably and has been expended in preparation for the very expedition which he was willing to avert the probability of, under the auspices of our government, by preparing for us at home, scenes of confusion and blood. The necessity Colonel Burr was under of communicating his real views in order to procure partizans must long since have undeceived him. The expressions of apprehension he has lately used, and the sudden desire he has displayed an accommodation between the U. S. and Spain, tend strongly to confirm this conjecture. I make no doubt if the administration, would have suffered him to approach it, he would have betrayed Burr, when he was last in this place, when he shewed such anxiety for a reconciliation with it. I cannot help believing, that the prospects he has held out to his court of a powerful diversion in its favor, by intestine commotions here, have retarded the negotiation.

Although the administration was rather slow, in believing that such a design, as I have communicated, could really have been undertaken; the promptitude and judgment, with which it has since acted, give the strongest hope, that it will be compleatly frustrated in its commencement. It must be indeed, unless the Western militia has been corrupted, or the efforts of its officers, to bring it into the field, paralized by the protestations of Col. Burr, & his partizans, that his views are entirely innocent, and that he is under unjust persecution, for the purpose of which it has been found necessary, to excite a false alarm.

The seizure of his stores, has already been made at Pittsburg. There is every reason to believe, all, or nearly all his parties have been arrested or dispersed before this time, before they could embody. If this should have failed, the Mississippi territory militia, sent back by Wilkinson, to be ready for the purpose, is sufficient strong, to intercept him; it is supposed with the aid of our armed vessels in that river. Letters from New-Orleans, as late as the 8th November, from the highest authority say, that Wilkinson is fortifying on the Sabine, and is certainly superior in force to the enemy. There is not room for the smallest suspicion, that that officer has been at all shaken in his duty. His conduct and communications forbid such a supposition.

See the clipping

Rumor becomes ‘fact’

General Wilkinson reports Burr’s agents boasting of a large force, and the paper repeats a story that Burr had agents at the courts of London, Paris and Madrid. Rumor is now being printed as fact.

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · and 1 other paper

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 13 January 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AURORA.

Extract of a Letter, dated, "Washington, December 27, 1806.

See moreSee less

"We have nothing new or interesting here, excepting the common topics of conversation, the designs of Burr—accounts have been received to-day from Capt. Shaw of the navy and Gen. Wilkinson of the army.—Gen. W. had arrived at N. Orleans, and the army was expected to follow him shortly under Col. Cushing. The reason of this was that the Gen. had received undoubted information from one of Burr's agents, who had been sent to tamper with him, that the city of New Orleans was to be attacked by sea and land—by sea, by a squadron under American colours, but commanded by foreign officers (of what nation is not stated) and by land by a party under the command of Burr. Wilkinson detained the emissary of Burr, and obtained all the information he could get from him under the pretext of being in favor of Burr's schemes. He has written an account of all he knows to the President, and the dispatches were sent by way of Charleston, as it is apprehended that all the mails by way of Natchez and Nashville have been intercepted by Burr's agents. Capt. Shaw states that he has employed all the vessels capable of carrying guns to meet any attempt which may be made by sea, and he has four gun boats and two ketches to meet any force which may go down the Mississippi. In addition to this, the militia of the territory have been called out. These measures, together with the stoppage of Burr's boats by the government of Ohio, will probably completely frustrate his treasonable designs. Burr has without doubt been assisted with money by a foreign government; but there are doubts whether there will be sufficient evidence to bring him to condign punishment. One good effect, however, will arise from this troublesome business. It will prove to the world that the people of the U. S. are too much attached to their republican government to be seduced from their duties either by domestic traitors or foreign emissaries. This plot has been going on for two years, and seems to have been deeply laid and artfully planned. It would fill a volume to develope all the ramifications which have been already discovered. In the mean time all here is peace and harmony: the bickerings of the last session are almost forgotten. This is a mortifying thing to some of the federalists, whose calculations of getting again into power, were founded upon republican divisions."

Another letter, same date, says—

"General Wilkinson writes the Secretary of war that Col. Cushing is descending with the troops from Natchitoches, that the Red River was low, and his progress would be slow; that the agents of Col. Burr had declared that he would soon appear with a force of 5000 men, (at least)—that he has proceeded too far to recede; that his adherents had pledged their lives and fortunes in aid of his enterprize—and report says, that Col. Burr had had an agent at each of the courts of London, Paris and Madrid; that prior to the death of Pitt the plan was digested and agreed on: but that the same countenance had not been given to the project by Fox.—Gen. Wilkinson writes that he was placing Orleans in a posture of defence; he expresses no fears for its safety. I understand that 1500 militia had been ordered some time past to assemble at Natchez and to take post there until further orders."

See the clipping

‘We must hang Miranda’

In a deposition sworn in open court, William Eaton says Burr laid open a plan to separate the western country and make himself its sovereign, with New Orleans for his capital; the regular army would join him, and as for Miranda, ‘we must hang Miranda.’ Burr went further: if he could win over the marine corps and the naval commanders, he would ‘turn Congress neck and heels out of doors; assassinate the President.’

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 7 other papers

Virginia Argus · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM EATON, ESQ. Early last winter, col. Aaron Burr, late vice-president of the United States, signified to me, at this place, that, under the authority of the general government, he was organising a secret expedition against the Spanish provinces on our south-western borders; which expedition he was to lead, and in which he was authorised to invite me to take the command of a division. I had never before been made personally acquainted with col. Burr; and, having for many years been employed in foreign service, I knew but little about the estimation this gentleman now held in the opinion of his countrymen and his government: the rank and confidence by which he had so lately been distinguished left me no right to suspect his patriotism.

See moreSee less

I knew him a soldier. In case of a war with the Spanish nation which from the tenor of the President's message to both Houses of Congress seemed probable, I should have thought it my duty to obey so honorable a call of my country; and, under that impression I did engage to embark in the expedition. I had frequent interviews with col. Burr in this city—and, for a considerable time, his object seemed to be to instruct me by maps, and other information, the feasibility of penetrating to Mexico—always carrying forward the idea that the measure was authorised by government. At length, some time in February, he began by degrees to unveil himself—He reproached the government with want of character, want of gratitude, and want of justice. He seemed desirous of irritating resentment in my breast by dilating on certain injuries he felt I had suffered from reflections made on the floor of the House of Representatives concerning my operations in Barbary, and from the delays of government in adjusting my claims for disbursements on that coast during my consular agency at Tunis; and he said he would point me to an honorable mode of indemnity. I now began to entertain a suspicion that Mr. Burr was projecting an unauthorised military expedition; which, to me, was enveloped in mystery; and, desirous to draw an explanation from him, I suffered him to suppose me resign- resigned to his counsel. He now laid open his project of revolutionising the western country, seperating it from the union, establishing a monarchy there, of which he was to be the soveretgn, New-Orleans to be his capital; organising a force on the waters of the Mississippi, and extending conquest to Mexico. I suggested a number of impediments to his scheme—such as the republican habits of the citizens of that country, and their affection towards our present administration of government; the want of funds; the resistance he would meet from the regular army of the U. States on those frontiers; and the opposition of Miranda in case he should succeed to republicanise the Mexicans. Mr. Burr found no difficulty in removing these obstacles—he said he had, the preceding season, made a tour thro' that country, and had secured the attachment of the principal citizens of Kentucky, Tennessee and Louisiana to his person and to his measures —declared he had inexhaustible resources to funds; assured me the regular army would act with him, and would be reinforced by 10 or 12,000 men from the above men- the above mentioned states and territory and from other parts of the union; said he had powerful agents in the Spanish territory—and, as for Miranda, said Mr. Burr, we must hang Miranda. He now proposed to give me the second command in his army. I asked him who should have the chief command? He said, General Wilkinson. I observed it was singular that he should count on Gen. Wilkinson: the elevated rank and high trust he now held as commander in chief of our army and governor of a province, he would hardly put at hazard for any precarious prospects of aggrandizement. Mr. Burr said gen. Wilkinson balanced in the confidence of government, was doubtful of retaining much longer the consideration he now enjoyed, and was consequently prepared to secure to himself a permanency. I asked Mr. Burr, if he knew gen. Wilkinson? He answered yes: and echoed the question. I said I knew him well. "What do you know of him? said Mr. Burr."—I know, I replied, that gen. Wilkinson will act as Lieutenant to no man in existence. "You are in an error," said Mr. Burr— "Wilkinson will act as lieutenant to me." From the tenor of repeated conversations with Mr. Burr, I was induced to believe the plan of separating the union which he had contemplated had been communicated to and approved of by gen. Wilkinson, (though I now suspect it an artful argument of seduction) and he often expressed a full confidence that the general's influence; the offer of double pay and double rations; the prospect of plunder and the ambition of achievement would draw the army into his measures. Mr. Burr talked of the establishment of an independent government west of the Alleghany as a matter of inherent, constitutional right of the people; a change which would eventually take place, and in the operation of which the present crisis was peculiarly favorable. There was, said he, no energy in the government to be dreaded, and the divisions of political opinions throughout the union was a circumstance of which we should profit. There were very many enterprising men among us who aspired to something beyond the dull pursuits of civil life and who would volunteer in this enterprize, and the vast territory belonging to the United States, which teer offered to adventurers, and the mines of Mexico would bring strength to his standard from all quarters. I listened to the exposition of col. Burr's views with seeming acquiescence. Every interview convinced me more and more that he had organised a deep laid plot of treason in the west, in the accomplishment of which he felt fully confident. Till, at length, I discovered that his ambition was not bounded by the waters of the Mississippi and Mexico, but that he meditated overthrowing the present government of our country. He said, if he could gain over the marine corps, and secure the naval commanders, Truxton, Preble, Decatur, and others, he would turn Congress neck and heels out of doors; assassinate the President; seize on the treasury and the navy, and declare himself the protector of an energetic government. The honorable trust of corrupting the marine corps, and of sounding commodore Preble and capt. Decatur col. Burr proposed confiding to me. Shocked at this proposition, I dropped the mask, and exclaimed against his views. He talked of the degraded situ- situation of our country, and the necessity of a blow by which its energy and its dignity should be restored—said, if that blow could be struck here at this time, he was confident of the support of the best blood of America. I told col. Burr he deceived himself in presuming that he, or any other man could excite a party in this country who would countenance him in such a plot of desperation, murder and treason. He replied, that he, perhaps, knew better the dispositions of the influential citizens of this country than I did. I told him, one solitary word would destroy him. He asked, what word? I answered, Usurper! He smiled at my hesitation, and quoted some great examples in his favor. I observed to him that I had lately travelled from one extreme of the union to the other; and, tho' I found a diversity of political opinion among the people, they appeared united at the most distant aspect of national danger. That, for the section of the union to which I belonged, I would vouch, should he succeed in the first instance here, he would within six weeks afterward have his throat cut by Yankee militia. Though wild and extravagant Mr. Burr's last project: and tho' fraught with premeditated slaughter, I felt very easy on the subject, because its defeat he had deposited in my own hands. I did not feel so secure concerning that of disjointing the union. But the very interesting and embarrassing situation in which his communication placed me, left me, I confess, at a stand to know how to conduct myself with propriety. He had committed no overt act of aggression against law. I could draw nothing from him in writing; nor could I learn that he had exposed his plans to any person near me by whom my testimony could be supported. He had mentioned to me no persons who were principally and decidedly engaged with him except Gen. Wilkinson—a Mr. Alston, who I found was his son-in-law—and a Mr. Ephraim Kibby, late a captain of Rangers in Gen. Wayne's army. Satisfied that Mr. Burr was resolute in pushing his project of rebellion in the west of the Alleghany, and apprehensive that it was too well and too extensiv[ely] extensively organized to be easily suppressed ; though I dreaded the weight of his character when laid in the balance against my solitary as- sertion, I brought myself to the resolution to endeavor to defeat it by getting him re- moved from among us, or to expose my- self to all consequences by a disclosure of his intentions. Accordingly, I waited on the President of the United States ; and af- ter some desultory conversation, in which I aimed to draw his view to the westward, I used the freedom to say to the President I thought Mr. Burr should be sent out of this country---and gave for reason, that I believed him dangerous in it. The Presi- dent asked where he should be sent ? I men- tioned London and Cadiz. The President thought the trust too important, and see- med to entertain a doubt of Mr. Burr's in- tegrity. I intimated that no one, perhaps, had stronger grounds to mistrust Mr. Burr's moral integrity than myself ; yet, I believ- ed, ambition so much predominated over him that, when placed on an eminence and put on his honor, respect to himself would ensure his fidelity : His talents were un- fidelity: His talents were unquestionable. I perceived the subject was disagreeable to the President; and to give it the shortest course to the point, declared my concern that if Mr. Burr were not in some way disposed of, we should, within eighteen months, have an insurrection, if not a revolution, on the waters of the Mississippi. The President answered, that he had too much confidence in the information, the integrity, and the attachment to the union of the citizens of that country to admit an apprehension of the kind. I am happy that events prove this confidence well placed. As no interrogatories followed my expression of alarm I thought silence on the subject, at that time and place, became me. But I detailed, about the same time, the whole projects of Mr. Burr to certain members of Congress. They believed Col. Burr capable of any thing—and agreed that the fellow ought to be hanged; but thought his projects too chimerical and his circumstances too desperate to give the subject the merit of serious consideration. The total security of feeling in those to whom I had rung the tocsin, induced me to suspect my own apprehensions unseasonable, or at least too deeply admitted; and, of course, I grew indifferent about the subject. Mr. Burr's visits to me became less frequent, and his conversation less familiar. He appeared to have abandoned the idea of a general revolution; but seemed determined on that of the Mississip[pi]; and, although I could perceive symptoms of distrust in him towards me, he manifested great solicitude to engage me with him in the enterprize. Weary of his importunity, and at once to convince him of my serious attachments, I gave the following toast to the public:—The United States—Palsy to the brain that should plot to dismember, and leprosy to the hand that will not draw to defend our union! I doubt whether the sentiment was better understood by any one of my acquaintance than Col. Burr. Our intercourse ended here—we met but seldom afterwards. I returned to my farm in Massachusetts, and thought no more of Mr. Burr, nor his empire, till sometime late in September or beginning of October, when a letter from Morris Belknap, of Marietta, to Timothy E. Danielson, fell into my hands at Brim- Brimfield, which satisfied me that Mr. Burr had actually commenced his preparatory operations on the Ohio. I now spoke publicly of the fact—transmitted a copy of the letter from Belknap to the department of state, and about the same time forwarded through the hands of the post master general to the President of the United States, a statement in substance, of what is here above detailed concerning the Mississippi conspiracy of the said Col. Aaron Burr—which is said to have been the first formal intelligence received by the executive on the subject of the conspirator being in motion. I know not whether my country will allow me the merit of correctness of conduct in this affair. The novelty of the duty might, perhaps, have embarrassed stronger minds than mine. The uprightness of my intentions I hope will not be questioned. The interviews between Col. Burr and myself, from which the foregoing statement has resulted, were chiefly in this city, in the months of February and March, last year. WILLIAM EATON. Washington city, Jan. 26, 1807. Sworn to in open court this 26th day of January, 1807. Wm. BRENT, Clk.

See the clipping

Treason, or a raid on Spain?

Here is the legal question that would decide everything. Was Burr’s expedition aimed at Spanish Mexico, a misdemeanor, or at the United States, which would be treason? His own letter to Wilkinson can be read both ways, and the judges split even over whether the sworn copy of it could be used.

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 3 other papers

Virginia Argus · 3 March 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES, FEB. TERM, 1807. The United States vs. Bollman and Swartwout. Habeas Corpus on a commitment for treason, Chief Justice MARSHALL on the 21st instant, delivered the following opinion of the Court. The prisoners having been brought before this court on a writ of habeas corpus, and the testimony on which they were committed having been fully examined and attentively considered, the court is now to declare the law upon their case. This being a mere enquiry which, without deciding upon guilt, precedes the institution of a prosecution, the question to be determined is whether the accused shall be discharged or held to trial, and if the latter, in what place they are to be tried, and whether they shall be confined, admitted to bail.

See moreSee less

"If," says a very learned and accurate commentator, "upon this enquiry it manifestly appears that no such crime has been committed, or that the suspicion entertained of the prisoner was wholly groundless, in such cases only it is lawful totally to discharge him. Otherwise he must either be committed to prison or give bail." The specific charge brought against the prisoner is treason in levying war against the U. S. As there is no crime which can more excite and agitate the passions of men than treason, no charge demands more from the tribunal before which it is made a deliberate and temporate enquiry. Whether this enquiry be directed to the fact or to the law, none can be more solemn, none more important to the citizen or to the government—none can more affect the safety of both. To prevent the possibility of those calamities which result from the extension of treason to ffences of minor importance that great ties offences of minor importance that great fundamental law which defines & limits the various departments of our government has given a rule on the subject both to the legislature and the courts of America which neither can be permitted to transcend. "Treason against the U. S. shall consist only in levying war against them, or in adhering to their enemies giving them aid and comfort." To constitute that specific crime for which the prisoners now before the court have been committed, war must be actually levied against the United States. However flagitious may be the crime of conspiring to subvert by force the government of our country, such conspiracy is not treason. To conspire to levy war, and actually to levy war, are distinct offences. The first must be brought into operation by the assemblage of men for a purpose treasonable in itself, or the fact of levying war cannot have been committed. So far has this principle been carried that, in a case reported by ventries, and mentioned in some m de[n] tr[eat]ses on criminal law, it has been determined that the actual enlistment of men to serve against the government does not amount to levying war. It is true that in that case the soldiers enlisted were to serve without the realm, but they were enlisted within it, and if the enlistment for a treasonable purpose could amount to levying war, then war had been actually levied. It is not the intention of the court to say that no individual can be guilty of this crime who has not appeared in arms against his country. On the contrary, if war be actually levied, that is, if a body of men be actually assembled for the purpose of effecting by force, a treasonable purpose, all those who perform any part, however minute or however remote from the scene of action, and who are actually leagued in the general conspiracy, are to be considered as traitors. But there must be an actual assembling of men for the treasonable purpose, to constitute a levying of war. Crimes so atrocious as those which have for their object the subversion by violence of those laws and those institutions which have been ordained in order to secure the peace and happiness of society, are not to escape punishment because they have not ripened into treason. The wisdom of the legislature is competent to provide for the case; and the framers of our const[i]tution who not only defined and limited the crime, but with jealous circumspection attempted to protect their limitation by providing that no per[s]on should be convicted of it, unless on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on confession in open court, must have conceived it more safe that punishment in such cases should be ordained by general laws formed upon deliberation, under the influence of no resentments, and without knowing on whom they were to operate, than that it should be inflicted under the influence of those passions which the occasion seldom fails to excite, and which a flexible definition of the crime, or a construction which would render it flexible, might bring into operation. It is therefore more safe as well as more consonant to the principles of our constitution that the crime of treason should not be extended by construction to doubtful cases; and that crimes not clearly within the constitutional definition should receive such punishment as the legislature in its wisdom may provide. To complete the crime of levying war against the U. S. there must be an actual assemblage of men for the purpose of executing a treasonable design. In the case now before the court, a design to overturn the government of the U. S. in New-Orleans by force, would have been unquestionably a design which if carried into execution would have been treason, and the assemblage of a body of men for the purpose of carrying it into execution, would amount to levying of war against the U. S. but no conspiracy for this object, no enlisting of men to effect it, would be an actual levying of war. In conformity with the principles now laid down have been the decision heretofore made by the judges of the U. States. The opinions given by judge Paterson and judge Iredell in cases before them imply an actual assembling of men though they rather designed to remark on the purpose to which the force was to be applied than on the nature of the force itself. Their o- pinions however contemplate the actual employment of force. Judge Chase in the trial of Fries was more explicit. He stated the opinion of the court to be "that if a body of people conspire and me- ditate an insurrection to resist or oppose the execution of any statute of the U. S. by force, they are only guilty of a high misde- meanor; but if they proceed to carry such intention into execution by force, that they are guilty of the treason of levying war; and the quantum of the force employed, neither lessens nor increases the crime: whether by one hundred, or one thousand persons, is wholly immaterial. "The court are of opinion," continued Judge Chase, on that occasion, "that a combination or con- spiracy to levy war agaist the U. S. is not treason, unless combined with an attempt to carry such combination or conspiracy into execution; some actual force or vio- lence must be used in pursuance of such de- sign to levy war; but it is altogether im- material whether the force used is sufficient immaterial whether the force used is sufficient to effectuate the object; any force connected with the intention, will constitute the crime of levying war." The application of these general principles to the particular case before the court will depend on the testimony which has been exhibited against the accused. The first deposition to be considered is that of general Eaton. This gentleman connects in one statement the purport of numerous conversations held with col. Burr throughout the last winter. In the course of these conversations were communicated various criminal projects which seem to have been revolving in the mind of the projector. An expedition against Mexico seems to have been the first and most matured part of his plan, if indeed it did not constitute a distinct and separate plan, upon the success of which other schemes still more culpable, but not yet well digested might depend. Maps and other information preparatory to its execution, and which would rather indicate that it was the immediate paratory object, had been procured, and for a considerable time, in repeated conversations the whole efforts of Col. Burr were directed to prove to the witness who was to have held a high command under him, the practicability of the enterprise, and in explaining to him the means by which it was to be effected. This deposition exhibits the various schemes of col. Burr, and its materiality depends on connecting the prisoners at the bar in such of those schemes as were treasonable. For this purpose the affidavit of general Wilkinson comprehending in its body the substance of a letter from Col. Burr has been offered and was received by the circuit court. To the admission of this testimony great and serious objections have been made. It has been urged that it is a voluntary, or rather an extrajudicial affidavit made before a person not appearing to be a magistrate, and contains the substance only of a letter, of which the original is retained by the person who made the affidavit. The objection that the affidavit is extrajudicial resolves itself into the question whether one magistrate may commit on an affidavit taken before another magistrate. For if he may, an affidavit made as the foundation of a commitment, ceases to be extrajudicial, and the person who makes it would be as liable to a prosecution for perjury as if the warrant of commitment had been issued by the magistrate before whom the affidavit was made. To decide that an affidavit made before one magistrate would not justify a commitment by another might in many cases be productive of great inconvenience, and does not appear susceptible of abuse if the verity of the certificate be established. Such an affidavit seems admissible on the principle that before the accused is put upon his trial, all the proceedings are exparte. The court therefore over-ruled this objection. That which questions the character of the person who has on this occasion administered the oath is next to be considered. The certificate from the office of the department of state has been deemed insufficient by the council for the prisoners, because the law does not require the appointment of magistrates for the territory of N. Orleans to be certified to that office, because the certificate is in itself informal, and because it does not appear that the magistrate had taken the oath required by the act of congress. The first of these objections is not supported by the law of the case, and the second may be so readily corrected that the court has proceeded to consider the subject as if it were corrected, retaining however any final decision, if against the prisoners, until the correction shall be made. With regard to the third, the magistrate must be presumed to have taken the requisite oaths, since he is found acting as a magistrate. On the admissibility of that part of the affidavit which purports to be as near the substance of the letter from Col. Burr to Gen. Wilkinson as the latter could interpret it, a division of opinion has taken place, in the court. Two judges are of opinion that as such testimony delivered in the presence of the prisoner on his trial, would be totally inadmissible, neither can it be considered as a foundation for a commitment. Although in making a commitment the magistrate does not decide on the guilt of the prisoner, yet he does decide on the probable cause, and a long and painful imprisonment may be the consequence of his decision. This probable cause therefore ought to be proved by testimony in itself legal, & which, though from the nature of the case it must be exparte, ought, in most other respects to be such as a court and jury might hear. Two judges are of opinion that in this incipient stage of the prosecution an affidavit stating that the general purport of a letter may be read, particularly where the person in possession of it is at too great a distance to admit of its being obtained, and that a commitment may be founded on it. Under this embarrassment it was deemed necessary to look into the affidavait for the purpose of discovering whether if admitted, it contains matter which would justify the commitment of the prisoners at the bar on the charge of treason. That the letter from Col. Burr to Gen. Wilkinson relates to a military expedi enterprise meditated by the former, has not been questioned. If this enterprise was against Mexico, it would amount to a high misdemeanor, if against any of the territories of the U. States, or if in its progress the subversion of the government of the United States in any of their territories was a mean clearly and necessarily to be employed, if such mean formed a substantive part of the plan, the assemblage of a body of men to effect it would be levying war against the United States. The letter is in language which furnishes no distinct view of the design of the writer. The co-operation, however, which is stated to have been secured, points strongly to some expedition against the territories of Spain. After making these general statements the writer becomes rather more explicit, and says, "Burr's plan of operations is to move down rapidly from the falls on the 15th of November with the first 500 or 1000 men in light boats, now constructing for that purpose, to be at Natchez between the 5th and 15th of December, there to meet Wilkinson; then to determine whether it will be expedient in the first instance to seize on or pass by Baton Rouge. The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us. Their agents now with Burr say that if we will protect their religion and will not subject them to a foreign power, in three weeks all will be settled." There is no expression in these sentences which would justify a suspicion that any territory of the U. S. was the object of the expedition. For what purpose seize on Baton Rogue; why engage Spain against this enterprize, if it was designed against the U States? "The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us." This language is peculiarly appropriate to a foreign country. It will not be contended that the terms would be inapplicable to a territory of the U. States, but other terms would more aptly convey the idea, and Burr seems to consider himself as giving infor- mation of which Wilkinson was not possessed. When it is recollected that he was the governor of a territory adjoining that which must have been threatened, if a territory of the U. States was threatened, and that he commanded the army, a part of which was stationed in that territory, the probability that the information communicated related to a foreign country, it must be admitted, gains strength. "Their agents now with Burr say that if we will protect their religion and will not subject them to a foreign power, in three weeks all will be settled." This is apparently the language of a people who, from the contemplated change of their political situation, feared for their religion, and feared that they would be made the subjects of a foreign power. That the Mexicans should entertain these apprehensions was natural and would readily be believed. They were, if the representation made of the dispositions be correct about to place themselves much in the power of men who professed a faith different from theirs, and who by making them dependent on England, or the U. S. would subject them to a foreign power That the people of New Orleans as a people, if really engaged in the conspiracy, should feel the same apprehensions, & require assurances on the same points, is by no means so obvious. There certainly is not in the letter delivered to general Wilkinson, so far as that letter is laid before the court, one syllable which has a necessary or a natural reference to an enterprize against any territory of the U S. That the bearer of this letter must be considered as acquainted with its contents, is not to be controverted. The letter and his own declaration sev[e]ral the fact. After stating himself to have passed through New York and the western states and territories, without insinuating that he had performed on his rout any act whatever which was connected with the enterprize, he states their object to be ' to carry an expedition to the Mexican provinces." This statement may be considered as explanatory of the letter of col. Burr, if the expressions of that letter could be thought ambiguous. But there are other declarations made by Mr. Swartwout, which constitute the difficulty of this case. On an enquiry from gen. Wilkinson, he said "this territory would be revolutionized, where the people were ready to join them, and that there would be some seizing, he supposed, at N. Orleans." If these words import that the government established by the United States in any of its territories, was to be revolutionized by force, although merely as a step to, or a mean of executing some greater projects, the design was unquestionably treasonable, and any assemblage of men for that purpose would amount to a levying of war. But on the import of the words a difference of opinion exists. Some of the judges suppose they refer to the territory against which the expedition was intended, others to that in which the conversation was held. Some consider the words if even applicable to a territory of the United States, as alluding to a revolution to be effected by the people rather than by the party conducted by col. Burr. But whether this treasonable intention be really imputable to the plan or not, it is admitted that it must have been carried into execution by an open assemblage of men for that purpose, previous to the arrest the prisoner, in order to consummate the crime as to him; and a majority of the court is of opinion that the conversation of Mr. Swartwout affords no sufficient proof of such assembling. The prisoner stated that "col. Burr with the support of a powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was levying an armed body of 7000 men from the state of New York and the western states and territories, with a view to carry an expedition to the Mexican territories." That the association, whatever may be its purpose, is not treason, has been already stated. That levying an army may or may not be treason, and that this depends on the intention with which it is levied, and on the point to which the parties have advanced, has been also stated. The mere enlisting of men without assembling them is not levying war. The question then is whether this evidence proves col. Burr to have advanced so far in levying an army as actually to have assembled them. It is argued that since it cannot be necessary that the whole 7000 men should have assembled, their commencing their march by detachments to the place of rendezvous, must be sufficient to constitute the crime. This position is correct, with some qualification. It cannot be necessary that the whole army should assemble, and that the various parts which are to compose it should have combined. But it is necessary that there should be an actual assemblage, and therefore the evidence should make the fact unequivocal. The travelling of individuals to the place of rendezvous would perhaps not be sufficient. This would be an equivocal act, and has no warlike appearance. The meeting of particular bodies of men and their marching from places of partial to a place of general rendezvous would be such an assemblage. The particular words used by Mr. Swartwout are that col. Burr was levying an armed body of 7000 men. If the term levying in this place imports that they were assembled, then such fact would amount, if the intention be against the United States, to levying war. If it barely imports that he was enlisting or engaging them in his service, the fact would not amount to levying war. It is thought sufficiently apparent that the latter is the sense in which the term was used. The fact alluded to, if taken in the former sense, is of a nature so to force itself upon the public view, that if the army had then actually assembled either together or in detachments, some evidence of such assembling, would have been laid before the court. The words used by the prisoner in reference to seizing at New-Orleans, and borrowing perhaps by force from the bank, though indicating a design to rob, and consequently importing a high offence, do not designate the specific crime of levying war against the U. States. It is therefore the opinion of a majority of the court, that in the case of Samuel Swartwout, there is not sufficient evidence of his levying war against the United States to justify his commitment on the charge of treason. Against Erick Bollman there is still less testimony. Nothing has been said by him to support the charge that the enterprize in which he was engaged had any other object than was stated in the letter of col. Burr. Against him, therefore, there is no evidence to support a charge of treason. That both the prisoners were engaged in a most culpable enterprise against the dominions of a power at peace with the United States, those who admit the affidavit of gen. Wilkinson cannot doubt. But that no part of this crime was committed in the district of Columbia, is apparent. It is therefore the unanimous opinion of the court that they cannot be tried in this district. The law read on the part of the prosecution is understood to apply only to offences committed on the high seas, or in any river, haven, bason or bay, not within the jurisdiction of any particular state. In these cases there is no court which has particular cognizance of the crime, and therefore the place in which the criminal shall be apprehended, or, if he be apprehended where no court has exclusive jurisdiction, that shall to which he shall be first brought, is substituted for the place in which the offence was committed. But in this case, a tribunal for the trial of the offence wherever it may have been committed, had been provided by Congress; and at the place where the prisoners were seized by the authority of the commander in chief, there existed such a tribunal. It would too be extremely dangerous to say, that because the prisoners were apprehended, not by a civil magistrate, but by the military power, there could be given by law a right to try the persons so seized in any place which the general might select, and to which he might direct them to be carried. The act of congress which the prisoners are supposed to have violated, describes as offenders those who begin or set on foot, or provide or prepare the means for any military expedition or enterprise to be carried on from thence against the dominions of a foreign prince or state, with whom the U. States are at peace. There is a want of precision in the description of the offence which might produce some difficulty in deciding what cases would come within it. But several other questions arise which a court consisting of four judges finds itself unable to decide, and therefore as the crime with which the prisoners stand charged has not been committed, the court can only direct them to be discharged. This is done with the less reluctance because the discharge does not acquit them from the offence which there is probable cause for supposing they have committed, and if those whose duty it is to protect the nation by prosecuting offenders against the laws shall suppose those who have been charged with treason to be proper objects for punishment, they will, when possessed of less exceptionable testimony, and when ab[l]e to say at what place the offence has been committed, institute fresh proceedings against them. The order of the court was as follows: The UNITED STATES vs Swartwout. } On a writ of Habeas Corpus, The arguments of the attorney general and of the attorney of the U. S. for the district of Columbia, and the arguments of counsel for the prisoner having been heard; and the record of the circuit court for the county of Washington containing the order by which the said Samuel Swartwout was committed on the charge of treason in levying war against the U. S and the testimony on which the said commitment made having been inspected and attentively considered, the court is of opinion that the testimony does not furnish probable cause for supposing that the said Samuel Swartwout has levied war against the United States and doth therefore direct that he be forthwith discharged from the custody of the marshal. The same order with regard to Bollman.

See the clipping

Caught at midnight

How Burr was taken: a land-office registrar named Perkins meets two travelers at midnight in the Mississippi Territory and starts to suspect who one of them really is. The question is whether Burr was running for Spanish Florida.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ARREST OF [illegible]

We have taken particul[illegible] correctness of the accoun[t] which we detailed in [illegible] versed with his esco[illegible] we have discovered [illegible] more accurate than w[illegible] The following stat[illegible] more correct, an[illegible]

See moreSee less

He was arrest[illegible] bruary, instead o[illegible]

We have obtai[illegible] country, from the [illegible] which the eye can [illegible] situation of places, t[illegible]nish line, and to the road lea[illegible]tates. It is certainly impossible by [illegible] [de]scription in words to lay these particulars before the reader ; but a few remarks may at least elucidate the most interesting points ; particularly if they will acompany these remarks by a reference to Bradley's latest edition of his map of the U. States.

The town of Natches, in the Mississippi Territory, where A. Burr's Boats were deposited, is on the river Mississippi.

About 200 miles to the east of this river is the Tombigbee river; which with the Alabama river, conspire to form the Mobile. The Tombigbee is the western; the Alabama, the eastern branch.—Four miles below the point of confluence, is Fort Stoddart situated on the Mobile; and about 12 miles above the Spanish Florida line.—A body of water connects the Tombigbee and Alabama branches at a certain distance above their point of confluence and forms an island; or as it has been called a cross cut.

A ferry leads over the Tombigbee into this island; through this island the road runs to a ferry over the Alabama ; thence the road leads to the east of the Alabama to a certain point; where the road diverges in two directions. The one road leads to the east through the Creek Country, over the limits of Georgia, into the Atlantick states. The other sweeps to the south, crosses the Spanish line, and thence advances to Pensacola.

And here is the principal point in dispute. A. Burr is said to have asserted that his route lay through the Creek country into Georgia ; some people suspect that his route was through the southern road. According to his own reputed representation, he intended to remain within the jurisdiction of the U. S. According to the suspicions of certain people, it was his intention to seek an assylum in the Spanish possessions.

Mr. Perkins is the register of the land-office, in the part of the Mississippi Territory which is to the east of Pearl river.—He keeps his office at the court-house of the county of Washington. His own lodgings are at Fort St. Stephens, [illegible] miles above the court-house. Mr. Perkins was in his office, about 12 or 1 o'clock of the night of the 18th of February, when Aaron Burr and Ashley appeared before him. The scene which ensued between them is not materially dissimilar from the one which was sketched in our last paper.

The reflections which followed it in Mr. Perkins's mind, were in one respect different from what he had stated. It was not alone as midnight robbers, that these mysterious strangers appeared to his imagination ; the idea also occurred to him that one of them might be col. Burr. This idea was the result of a letter, which he had received from a member of the legislative council at Natchez, stating the escape of col. Burr, and the probability that existed of his passing through Mr. P's village.

But whether they were robbers or one of them was col. Burr, it seemed to him too important a matter to be passed into neglect. He determined to repair to major Hinsen's house. He was accompanied by his friend the sheriff of the county. They reached the major's house about 12 o'clock. The mysterious strangers had arrived before them.—Ashley was in [illegible]—col. Burr was in the

[illegible]

[illegible]

[illegible] lieut. Gaines, [illegible] Stoddart, four tell, these unfortun[illegible] hey met colonel fate, were, in the [illegible] It is useless to strength became ex[illegible] which ensued. It [illegible] being conducted offspring, closely [illegible] s's return to the the abys[illegible] of the

As there was no [illegible] follow me to the lief from the boat [illegible] ressed to him by threatened speedil[illegible] he met Ashley; to embark the la[illegible] Hinsen's house early in the small boats of t[illegible] particular commission we shall to hover around [illegible] conjecture. Our business is Swinton accord[illegible] boats to approa[illegible] nce to the facts, and not with comments.— [illegible] attempted to retrace his steps, and return [illegible] barke[illegible] the court-house. It would be di[illegible] comments, to account [illegible] ey; it is still less our [illegible] ns' letter to the colo [illegible] to arrest Mr. Ash [illegible] in company with [illegible] the conversation former's des[illegible]

[illegible] the conversation former's des[illegible] visit to that [illegible] the court [illegible]ch Ashley would hav[illegible] all of them must [illegible]—for the surf, which b[illegible] from the hour we struc[illegible] [illegible]me to such height, tha[illegible] [illegible]me near the ship.

[illegible]t was now about 6 o'c[illegible] [illegible]e who remained with [illegible]ily more desperate [illegible]is companions [illegible]of preser[illegible]

movements of the Spaniards, and it [illegible] determined on, to bear col. Burr as soon as pos[sible] [to th]e Atlantick states. As lieut. Gaines could [not] conveniently spare a sufficient number of his [o]wn men to form an escort, he requested Mr. Perkins to ascend the Alabama river, and collect a company. He promised to meet him with his prisoner. Every part of this arrangement was punctually fulfilled; and col. Burr was regularly delivered into the hands of his escort.—Enquirer.

See the clipping

Not treason, says Marshall

In Richmond, Chief Justice Marshall finds the evidence too thin to hold Burr for treason. He is held only on a misdemeanor, for setting a military expedition on foot against Spain, and let out on bail.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR.—The mail in course, north of Petersburgh did not reach this place on Saturday, which prevented us from receiving and laying before our readers so copious a detail of the circumstances attending the result of the publick examination of Mr. Burr, as we had expected. The only article of information on this subject which we believe reached this place by the last mail is the following, which is extracted from the Petersburgh Intelligencer of Friday.

MORE OF BURR.

See moreSee less

"We learn from Richmond, that a publick discussion and examination of Burr's case was held at the capitol on Tuesday; when it was determined that his trial should commence at the Federal Circuit Court, to be holden in Richmond next month—he was again admitted to bail, himself in 5000 dollars and five securities in 2000 dollars each—his securities are Harry Heth, John Hopkins, John Gamble, Thomas Taylor, and a col. Swainburne.

Colonel Burr will be tried on an indictment for a misdemeanor in setting on foot within the territory of the United States a military expedition, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of the king of Spain, with whom the United States were then and are now at peace."

From this it appears that the evidence produced before the Chief Justice, on behalf of the U. States, was not sufficient to support the charge of treason, it is for misdemeanor only that Mr. Burr is held to answer.

The crime wherewith Mr. Burr is charged, and held to answer at the next court, is certainly a very serious one, and if substantiated by evidence will merit punishment, but it falls very short of treason.

As we expect by mail a particular account of their examination, we shall postpone any further observations on the subject at present.

See the clipping

Out on bail

The judge fixes Burr’s bail at $10,000 and meets him at the Capitol at three o’clock to take it. Five men stand as his securities the same afternoon.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 April 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Judge Marshal then observed, that he should not commit col. Burr on the charge of treason; but that he should hold him to bail, on the charge of setting on foot a military expedition against the dominions of Spain: That with respect to the amount of bail, he had made up no definitive opinion. He wished it to be neither too large, to amount to oppression, nor too small to defeat the objects of justice. It had occurred to him, that the sum of 10,000 dolls. would perhaps avoid both these extremes.

Mr. Hay was in favour of a larger sum. He had no doubt, from the spirit which had been manifested, that col. Burr could obtain bail to almost any amount he pleased. The day before, col. Burr had obtained bail for 5000 dolls. and he believed without any solicitation on his part

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham had supposed that 5 or 6,000 dollars would have been sufficient. It was only on the misdemeanor that it was to be given. With respect to the possibility of obtaining bail to any amount, he was unable to express any opinion; it was a subject with which he was personally unacquainted. But as to the spirit which it was said had been manifested, he could say, that he had heard several gentlemen declare themselves unwilling to appear as bail for col. Burr, lest it should be ascribed to a spirit of opposition to the administration.

Col. Burr rose and observed, that if the government was to pay him for the losses it had made him sustain, 40,000 dollars would not indemnify him. And yet this circumstance might operate against his obtaining bail to a large amount.

Mr. Hay replied.

The judge then observed that he should fix the bail to 10,000 dollars, and that he would meet col. Burr at the Capitol at 3 o'clock to receive it.

At 3 o'clock, the judge met the parties: when Messrs. Thomas Taylor, John G. Gamble, John Hopkins, Henry Heth, and —— Langborn appeared as his securities.

Enquirer.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: The Reckoning