As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

The Trial at Richmond

May – December 1807

Burr’s trial for treason opened in Richmond in the spring of 1807, with the Chief Justice of the United States presiding. It ran into the fall, and it filled the Virginia papers like nothing else in this story.

The trial opens in Richmond

The federal circuit court opens its session in Richmond with Chief Justice John Marshall on the bench, and the expected trial of Colonel Burr has drawn ‘an immense concourse of citizens from various parts of the Union.’ Before a grand jury can even be sworn, Burr objects to the way it was summoned and challenges two of its members, William B. Giles and Wilson Cary Nicholas. The Argus calls its four columns ‘but a mere outline of the proceedings.’

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 4 other papers

Virginia Argus · 23 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF Col. Aaron Burr.

YESTERDAY the Circuit Court of the United States for the fifth Circuit and District of Virginia, commenced its session in this city. The expected trial of Col. Burr drew together an immense concourse of citizens from various parts of the Union; indeed far exceeding any that we recollect ever to have seen upon any former occasion.

See moreSee less

At half past twelve o'clock the court was opened, present

John Marshall, Chief Justice of the United States.

Cyrus Griffin, Judge of the District of Virginia.

Before the grand jury was impannelled and sworn, a lengthy and desultory argument took place between Col. Burr with his counsel on the one side and the attorney for the United States in the District of Virginia, on the other, in relation to exceptions taken by the former to the manner in which some of the jurors were summoned, and finally on objections to some individual members of the jury. The late hour at which the court adjourned obliges us to compress into as narrow a compass as possible, the proceedings in this preliminary stage of the business. Indeed, if it were in our power to prepare the arguments at full length, we doubt extremely the propriety of publishing them during the pendency of the trial, before even the petit jury shall be sworn; especially as some of those arguments contained a degree of asperity which might possibly influence the minds of those who may finally pass between the United States and the accused.

After it was ascertained that eighteen of the grand jury had answered to their names, Col. Burr stated an objection to the manner in which part of them had been summoned by the Marshal. He disclaimed every idea of casting any imputation on that officer, unfavorable either to him or his deputies; but considered the irregularity of his proceedings as the mere effect of an error in construing the law, which error it was proper to correct. He adverted to the law of Virginia, by which 24 persons properly qualified are directed to be summoned as a grand jury; and contended that, when the officer had summoned that number, his authority ceased, and he had no power to summon the twenty-fifth. In the present case, he said, he was authorised to state, that after the Marshal had summoned the number required by law, he had accepted of excuses from part of them, and had afterwards completed the pannel by summoning additional members.

He was followed by Mr. Botts, who went more particularly into an examination of the question, and referred to the judicial act of Congress and the laws of Virginia, prescribing the duty of officers in summoning a grand jury. He also cited the case of Marbury v. Madison (1 Cranch) to shew that when a ministerial act was once performed by an officer, it was irrevocable. It was proposed on the part of Col. Burr, that the marshal should be interrogated as to those members of the grand jury, who had been summoned after the original pannel of 24 had been completed.

Mr. Hay, district attorney, observed that he confessed himself not very well prepared to answer the objection, a similar one to which he had never heard before, but that he conceived it to be of no importance, and was willing that Col. Burr should be accommodated with a grand jury, to which no exception could be made. It appeared to him indeed not be proper to examine witnesses as to the conduct of the marshal in this stage of the prosecution; and he knew not why the objection was now made; for it could make no difference to the prisoner or to the United States; since if any of the grand jurors were set aside, there would either be enough remaining of those who had been summoned, or the deficiency would be supplied by the marshal from among the by-standers. He submitted the whole matter to the court to determine whether testimony should be examined concerning the persons summoned or not.

Mr. Wickham said he meant no imputation on the marshal, whose intentions he doubted not were upright; but as this was an extraordinary case, and great attempts had been made to prejudice the public mind against Col. Burr, he was justifiable in taking every advantage that the law gave him. He cited 2 Hawk. Pleas of the Crown, p. 307 16 sect. and 3 Bac. Abr. 725, to shew that a person bound in a recognizance to answer a criminal charge, has a right to appear and make objections to the grand jury before they are sworn. Whether a plea in abatement might afterwards be filed for the error committed, was a question not necessary now to be determined: neither was it the wish of Col. Burr to resort to that alternative; for he anxiously desired that the prosecution should terminate here and with a grand jury free from all exceptions.

Mr. Hay then read the law of Virginia, (Rev. Code, pa 100, sec. 2,) and contended that the construction attempted to be put upon it was more rigid than could be warranted by sound sense and good policy.—The intention of the law was that 24 good men and not liable to any of the exceptions therein stated should be summoned. What reason therefore could be given to prevent the marshal (if he discovered that a man whom he had once summoned could not attend,) from summoning another, and thereby securing the attendance of the full number required? The marshal summons a man without knowing the situation of his private affairs. The man afterwards informs him that he is subject to uncontrolable domestic difficulties; for example, that he is going a journey on indispensable business. Why should he not excuse him, and summon another? Where is the authority to prove that the functions of the officer who collects a grand jury cease before the day on which it is impannelled?

When the return is made, if a sufficient number do not attend, a discretion is vested in the marshal to appoint others in the room of the absentees: and is not the principle the same, when he knows that the 24, whom he has first summoned, cannot attend?

He observed too that the gentlemen were influenced by a mistaken idea; for he had understood that the marshal, in the instances to which they alluded, had only enquired of the persons said to have been summoned, whether they could attend or not; expressing his intention to summon them, if they could attend; and, upon their assuring him of their inability, had applied to others.

Mr. Wickham said that the counsel for the United States had not fairly met the question. As the authorities he had cited before were short, he read them; observing that his only object in doing so was to shew that the objection ought to be made before the grand jury were impannelled, and therefore must now be made.

On the merits of the objection he said that Mr. Hay's argument concerning policy had no weight; that the words of the law of Virginia being plain on the subject in question ought alone to be regarded; that it was sufficient to answer ita lex scripta est; that policy however was on his side of the question; since great danger would result from permitting a marshal who was appointed by the President of the United States, and dependant upon him for his continuance in office, (however respectable the present marshal is acknowledged to be) to change the members of the grand jury at his pleasure.

The law is, that if the 24 grand jurors who have been summoned do not attend, 16 are sufficient to constitute a grand jury. Mr. Hay is therefore mistaken as to the law in supposing that 24 are necessary. Let it be supposed that a day or an hour before the sitting of the court, the marshal is informed that one of the grand jury cannot attend. According to the doctrine contended for by Mr. Hay, he may excuse him and summon another; but, when they attend in court, if 16 are present, he has no such power. If the excuse is made to the court and they deem it insufficient, a fine is to be imposed. Is the marshal to be substituted for the court? and can he release from the fine?

Upon the whole he insisted that the enquiry should be made; but declared that he had no intention to wound the marshal's feelings, whose error was certainly unintentional.

Mr. Hay. I said before, that no good reason existed for not authorising the marshal, where he discovered it to be certain that a grand juror could not attend, to supply the deficiency by summoning another before the commencement of the term. According to that doctrine, if 12 of those who are summoned should fail to attend, there might be no grand jury at all.

The chief justice enquired whether this question had ever come before the state courts?

Mr. Randolph answered that it never had within his knowledge, although he had thirty years ago been attorney for the Commonwealth; but there never had been a case like the present; and therefore no necessity to make a similar objection had ever been felt. This case was indeed a peculiar one, for in no other had such a torrent of prejudice been ever raised and by means too which we shall shortly unfold. In this case therefore it becomes necessary to contend for the rules of which we now avail ourselves; and in consequence of the power vested in the marshal and his liability to be influenced by the government, great danger would arise from relaxing them.

The Chief Justice. If this is a question which has never been decided in the courts of this state, we must have recourse to the words of the act of Assembly only. No doubt an exception to the grand jury may be taken now.

The law of Virginia authorizes the officer to summon 24 men, but says nothing of any more. He therefore cannot summon 25. If he desires the 25th man to attend, it ought not to be considered as a summons; but the act is void. Most certainly the officer is not authorized to discharge any person. Where 16 grand jurors do appear, by-standers may be called and not impannelled; but if 16 of those summoned appear, they are to constitute the Grand Jury. There is no necessity therefore to vest the Marshal with the power of excusing those who say that they are not able to attend. It is indeed the custom of the officers in this State to exercise a discretion in such cases; and no doubt the marshal acted with the best intentions under an idea that his conduct was proper; but after he has summoned any individual he cannot let him off. A plain argument in support of this position is that the person summoned might nevertheless appear though not called by the marshal, and offer his services to be sworn on the Grand Jury; in which case he could not be rejected. The question depends however on the point whether there was an actual summons, for a conversation merely preparatory to a summons is a different thing. It is therefore proper to examine the marshal as to what has been done.

Maj. Joseph Scott, the marshal of the district was thereupon examined. He said that he had shewed the Judges themselves a letter from Mr. John Taylor, of Caroline, who had been summoned and they had said that his excuse expressed in that letter was sufficient. He had therefore summoned Col. James Barbour, of Orange, in his room; but did not say that the Judges had directed him to do so, altho' he conceived it to be his duty in consequence of what had passed between him and them.—He acknowledged also that Mr. John M'Rae, who had been summoned, having since that time left the state, he had under similar impressions summoned Doct. William Foushee.

The Court decided that Mr. Barbour and Dr. Foushee, had not been legally added to the pannel of the grand jury; they were therefore withdrawn.

The pannel having been reduced to sixteen by the removal of those gentlemen improperly summoned, Col. Burr expressed some regret at exercising the privilege of challenging two others for favor. If the right was conceded, it might be necessary to appoint triers and go into an examination of witnesses. He wished it to be distinctly understood that he claimed the same right of challenge in this stage of the business, as if the cause were now before the petit jury.

Mr. Botts presumed that there could be no question as to the right. Even in civil cases this was a cause, though not a principal cause of challenge. The law which had been read was explicit in its application to this case. Our cause of challenge must be made out by testimony.

Mr. Hay believed the law to be as stated on the other side. No objection would be made by him to the course which the gentlemen wished to pursue. Col. Burr then proceeded to name the persons and causes of challenge. He first mentioned William B. Giles. With respect to him there were two causes, the first of which was of public notoriety. Mr. Giles while a member of the Senate had voted for the suspension of the writ of habeas corpus. The constitution had declared that a suspension of this writ could only be warranted in extreme cases; and that by pronouncing on the expediency of that measure, Mr. Giles had inevitably formed an opinion as to the designs imputed to him. Further, he would endeavor to establish by testimony, that since that time Mr. Giles had said that the documents furnished evidence of his (Burr's) guilt, and guilt of the highest grade.

Mr. Botts added a few observations explanatory of the law, and expressed a firm conviction, that from the intelligence, the virtue and patriotism of Mr. Giles, he would not suppose that the objections were made with a view to wound his feelings.

Mr. Hay observed that if the gentlemen objected to were willing to be withdrawn, he had no objection. [Here Mr. Giles made a very handsome and impressive address to the court, which neither our limits nor present plan will permit us, at this time, to insert. We will, however briefly remark, that he said, it had been an uniform rule with him neither to solicit nor refuse an appointment to any office which his country thought him qualified to fill. It was a very unpleasant thing for him to be summoned as a grand juror at the present term, but having been summoned, he had resolved to waive all objections of a personal nature. He regretted that there had not been energy enough in the House of Representatives in Congress to suspend the writ of habeas corpus,—a measure which he then thought and still thinks the state of the country required. Upon this case he was about to pronounce his real impressions. He meant ultimately to withdraw, but wished to remove certain impressions which had been made.

The chief justice observed that two circumstances must concur, in order to disqualify him as a juror, the one was that he must have made up an opinion on the case, the other was, that he had declared that opinion.

Mr. Giles wished to explain the state of his own mind. He had made up no opinion. He wished, indeed, that the public mind should be satisfied, and that the true character of Col. Burr's transactions should be ascertained.

Col. Wilson Cary Nicholas was also objected to by Col. Burr, on the ground of a personal enmity, sufficient he presumed to blind the judgment of the wisest men.

Col. Nicholas observed, that upon being summoned by the marshal, he had pressed him in the most forcible manner to release him. He doubted the propriety of his serving in this particular case, as the various relations in which he had stood as a public character to Col. Burr, might create some bias on his mind. That he was in Congress with Col. Burr when the nomination of President and Vice President was made, which terminated in an election that presented Mr. Jefferson and Col Burr with an equal number of suffrages for the decision of Congress. When Col. Burr went to the western country his suspicions were excited. He gave, perhaps, too ready a credit to the evidence which had transpired; but which was not sufficient to form a conclusive opinion. The marshal refusing to excuse him, he was obliged to attend. He did not choose that wrong impressions should be made, with respect to his motives, had he been absent. Attempts, he said, had been made to intimidate him. He had been told that if he attended as a juror, such representations would be made of his public conduct as would be highly injurious to his feelings.—Under all these circumstances he felt some difficulty. He had consulted lawyers of the first talents, who informed him that the court would not, for such causes, excuse him. He felt embarrassment from two considerations; the one was that his retiring might have sanctioned those objections; the other was that he did not wish to shrink from the performance of a public duty. But he consented to retire.

Col. Burr remarked, that the circumstance mentioned by the gentleman, that attempts had been made to intimidate him, were calculated to throw a suspicion on his cause. Such a course was not sanctioned by him. It must have been the work of some of his enemies. He disclaimed such conduct.

Col. Nicholas being withdrawn, Major Eggleston wished to be excused, because he had felt and expressed a considerable degree of warmth, on reading the deposition of Gen. Eaton; but the court considering that his case did not fall within the rule, and not being objected to by Colonel Burr, he was not permitted to withdraw.

Dr. William Foushee, on being called, expressed a difficulty in serving. On a consideration of his objections, the court suffered him to withdraw. Mr. John Randolph and Col. James Barbour, were then severally called. These gentlemen wished to be excused, on account of the impressions which the subject had made on their minds, but their excuses were not deemed sufficient by the court.

The following gentlemen were then sworn on the grand jury:

John Randolph, foreman, Jos. Eggleston, Littleton Waller Tazewell, Robert Taylor, William Daniel, jr. John Mercer, Edward Pegram, Munford Beverley, John Ambler, Thomas Harrison, Joseph C. Cabell, James Pleasants, jr. John Brockenbrough, Alexander Shepherd, James Barbour, James M. Garnett.

The chief justice delivered a charge to the grand jury, in which he enumerated the several offences cognizable by them under the laws of the United States, and particularly defined the crime of treason.

After the grand jury had retired, a debate of some length ensued on a proposition to instruct the jury specially with respect to the admissibility of certain evidence which it was supposed would be adduced on the part of the United States. A further discussion of this question, it is expected, will take place to-day.

The names of the several witnesses summoned in behalf of the United States were called over, many of whom and among others Gen. Wilkinson were absent. Such as appeared were recognized to appear on this day at 11 o'clock, to which hour the court adjourned.

The editor of the Argus wishes it to be distinctly understood that the foregoing is but a mere outline of the proceedings.—The materials already collected would occupy more than the entire columns of any one newspaper. They will appear more enlarged in some future number, when the stage of the prosecution may render it more proper.

See the clipping

Waiting for Wilkinson

The prosecutor, Mr. Hay, won’t send his indictments to the grand jury for several days unless General Wilkinson appears. Meanwhile he moves to commit Burr for high treason, in case Burr flees on learning Wilkinson is on his way. Burr’s counsel say the court would ‘forestal the sentiments of the grand jury, and the public.’ The court lets Hay open his testimony, but counsel cannot yet agree how to prevent ‘an anticipated impression on the public mind.’

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From the Enquirer.

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

See moreSee less

Saturday, May 23. The court sat at 11. A. Burr was not present. The proceedings of yesterday being read, and the names of the grand jury called over, Mr. Hay moved to recognize the witnesses who were not present yesterday. Those who appeared were, Erick Bollman, Samuel Swartwout, Thomas Morgan, and Robert Spence. Some conversation ensued on the motion to instruct the Grand Jury: and it was understood, that Mr. Burr's counsel was to give timely notice, to the U. S. attornies, of the propositions they intended to submit to the court. The question was suggested, whether the grand jury could be adjourned to some future day, without being adjourned from day to day. The Chief Justice declared, he was not prepared to give an opinion on the subject.

Monday, May 25. The proceedings of this day were extremely interesting, and will be detailed at length hereafter. Mr. Hay declared that he should not for several days send up his indictments to the grand jury, unless general Wilkinson made his appearance; and that in case he did not appear, he should then determine on the course he ought to pursue. The grand jury was adjourned till Tuesday 12 o'clock. Mr. Hay moved the court to commit A. Burr on a charge of high treason against the U. S. He declared that the reason of this motion was founded on a possibility of Mr. B's flying from the law, in case he should be positively informed that general Wilkinson was on his way to Richmond, unless he was committed for treason, and detained by higher bail; and that he believed the evidence he was now to bring forward, in addition to what had been adduced on the examination of A. Burr, was sufficient to induce the Judge to gra[nt] the commitment. He therefore m[oved], that evidence should be heard on behalf of this motion. Mr. Burr's counsel opposed this motion, principally on the ground; that the Grand Jury and the court possessing concurrent powers in this case, it was inexpedient for the court to exercise this power, while the grand jury was in session; that a more particular reason against the court's exercising this power, was, that they would have to deliver opinions on the evidence, and thus commit themselves on the ulterior stages of the prosecution, and forestal the sentiments of the grand jury, and the public; and that as another mode of producing this last effect, depositions or written papers which could not go before the grand jury, would be brought before the court as a foundation for the motion of commitment. These affidavits would be known to th[e] Grand Jury, and might contribute to prejudicate their mind.—The counsel for the prosecution contested all these arguments. The court postponed giving any opinion, till this day. Mr. Hay avowed his expectation that Gen. Wilkinson would appear in a few days. The government had employed every possible exertions to that effect.

Tuesday, May 26. 1 o'clock. The court has just decided, that "if it is the choice of the prosecutor on the part of the U. S. to proceed with his motion, it is the opinion of the court, that he may open his testimony."

Question postponed till to-morrow.—The difficulty is, to make some arrangement*, which may prevent an anticipated impression on the public mind, by the exhibition of evidence. The counsel for the prosecution and the prisoner cannot yet agree upon any arrangement. * Suggested by the attorney of the U. States.

See the clipping

‘It does not appear to be an oath’

The court rejects a paper offered as the affidavit of one Dunbaugh: nothing shows where the oath was taken, or that the man who administered it was a magistrate, so it ‘cannot be read because it does not appear to be an oath.’ Burr tells the court it has no right to hold him on bail without probable cause, but offers bail anyway, as long as no opinion ‘even of probable cause’ is read into it. The Chief Justice agrees.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR'S TRIAL.

On Wednesday the attorney on the part of the prosecution, produced an affidavit by a man of the name of Dunbaugh—Respecting the legality of the affidavit several arguments took place. On Thursday morning the court delivered the following opinion—

See moreSee less

On the part of the United States a paper purporting to be an affidavit has been offered in evidence, to the reading of which two exceptions are taken:

1st. That an affidavit ought not to be admitted, where the personal attendance of the witness could have been obtained;

2dly. That this paper is not so authenticated as to entitle itself to be considered as an affidavit.

That a magistrate may commit upon affidavits has been decided in the supreme court of the United States, though not without hesitation. The presence of the witness to be examined by the committing justice confronted with the accused, is certainly to be desired, and ought to be obtained, unless considerable inconvenience and difficulty exist in procuring his attendance. An ex parte affidavit shaped perhaps by the person pressing the prosecution, will always be viewed with some suspicion and acted upon with some caution, but the court tho't it would be going too far to reject it altogether.—If it was obvious that the attendance of the witness was easily attainable, but that he was intentionally kept out of the way, the question might be otherwise decided.

But the particular case before the court does not appear to be of this description. The witness resides at a great distance, and there is no evidence that the materiality of his testimony was known to the prosecutors, or to the executive, in time to have directed his attendance. It is true, that general instructions, which would apply to any individval, might have been sent, and the attendance of this or any other material witness obtained under those instructions; but it would be requiring too much to say that the omission to do this ought to exclude an affidavit.

This exception, therefore, will not prevail.

The second is, that the paper is not so authenticated, as to be introduced as testimony on a question which concerns the liberty of a citizen.

This objection is founded on two omissions in the certificate—

The first is, that the place at which the affidavit was taken, does not appear.

The second, that the certificate of the governor does not state the person who administered the oath to be a magistrate, but goes no further than to say that a person of that name was a magistrate.

That, for aught appearing to the court, this oath may or may not in point of fact have been legally administered, must be conceded.

The place where the oath was administered not having been stated; it may have been administered where the magistrate had no jurisdiction, and yet the certificate be perfectly true. Of consequence there is no evidence before the court, that the magistrate had power to administer the oath and was acting in his judicial capacity.

The effect of testimony may often be doubtful; and courts must exercise their best judgment in the case, but of the verity of the paper there ought never to be a doubt. No paper writing ought to gain admittance into a court of justice as testimony, unless it possesses those solemnities which the law requires. Its authentication must not rest upon probability, but must be as complete as the nature of the case admits of. This is believed to be a clear legal principle. In conformity with it is as the court conceives, the practice of England and of this country as is attested by the book of forms, and no case is recollected in which a contrary principle has been recognized. This principle is in some degree illustrated by the doctrine with respect to all courts of a limited jurisdiction. Their proceedings are erroneous, if their jurisdiction be not conclusively shewn. They derive no validity from the strongest probability that they had jurisdiction in the case; none certainly from the presumption that being a court, a usurpation of jurisdiction will not be presumed. The reasoning applies in full force to the actings of a magistrate whose jurisdiction is local. Thus in the case of a warrant it is expressly declared, that the place where it was made ought to appear. The attempt to remedy this defect by comparing the dates of the certificates given by the magistrate, with that given by the government cannot succeed. The answer given at bar to this argument is conclusive. The certificate wants those circumstances which would make it testimony, and without them no part of it can be regarded.

The second objection is equally fatal. The governor has certified that a man of the same name with the person who has administered the oath is a magistrate, but not that the person who has administered it is a magistrate.

It is too obvious to be controverted, that there may be two or more persons of the same name, and consequently, to produce that certainty which the case readily admits of, the certificate of the governor ought to have applied to the individual who administered the oath. The propriety of this certainty and precision in a certificate, which is to authenticate, any affidavit to be introduced into a court of justice, is so generally admitted, that I do not recollect a single instance in which the principle has been departed from.

It has been said that it ought to appear, that there are two persons of the same name or the court will not presume such to be the fact. The court presumes nothing. It may or may not be the fact, and the court cannot presume that it is not. The argument grounds upon the idea that an instrument is to be disproved by him who objects to it, not that it is to be proved by him who offers it. Nothing can be more repugnant to the established usage of courts.

How is it to be proved that there are two persons of the name of Cenas in the territory of Orleans? If with a knowledge of several weeks, perhaps months, that this prosecution was to be carried on, the evidence ought not be required to produce this witness, ought the prisoner to be required with the notice of a few hours to prove that two persons of the same name reside in New-Orleans?

It has been repeatedly urged that a difference exists between the strictness of law which would be applicable to a trial in chief and that which is applicable to a motion to commit for trial.

Of the reality of this distinction, the present controversy affords conclusive proof. At a trial in chief, the accused possesses the valuable privilege of being confronted with his accusers. But there must be some limit to this relaxation, and it appears not to have extended so far as (to the admission of a paper, purporting to be an affidavit and not shown) to be one.

When it is asked, whether every man does not believe that this affidavit was really taken before a magistrate, (it is at once answered that this cannot effect the case.) Should a man of probity declare a certain fact within his own knowledge, he would be accredited by all who knew him; but this declaration could not be received as testimony by the judge, who firmly believed him. So a man might be believed to be guilty of a crime, but a jury could not convict him unless the testimony proved him to be guilty of it. The judicial disbelief of a probable circumstance does not establish a wide interval between common law and common sense—It is believed in this respect to show their intimate union.

The argument goes to this—that the paper shall be received and acted upon as an affidavit, not because the oath appears to have been administered according to law, but because it is probable that it was so administered.

This point seems to have been decided by the constitution.

"The right of the people," says that instrument "to be secure in their persons, houses papers and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated; and no warrant shall issue but upon probable cause supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the places to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.

The cause of seizure is not to be supported by a probable oath, or an oath that was probably taken, but by oath absolutely taken.

This oath must be a legal oath; and if it must be a legal oath, it must legally appear to the court to be so. This provision is not made for a final trial; it is made for the very case now under consideration. In the cool and temperate moments of reflection, undisturbed by that whirlwind of passion with which in those party conflicts which most generally produce acts or accusations of treason, the human judgement is sometimes overthrown, the people of America have believed the power even of commitment to be capable of much oppression in its execution to be placed without restriction, even in the hands of the national legislature. Shall a judge disregard those barriers which the nation has deemed it proper to erect?

The interest which the people have in this prosecution, has been stated, but it is firmly believed, that the best and true interest of the people is to be found in a rigid adherence to those rules, which preserve the fairness of criminal prosecutions in every stage.

If this was a case to be decided by principle alone the court would certainly not receive this paper. But if the point is settled by decisions, they must be conformed to.

It has been said to be settled in the Supreme Court of the United States by admitting the affidavit of Wilkinson, to which an exception was taken, because it did not appear that the magistrate had taken the oath prescribed by law. It was said, that as by law he could not act, until he had taken the oaths and he was found acting, it must be presumed that this prerequisite was complied with; that is, that his acting as a magistrate under his commission was evidence that he was authorised so to act.

It will not be denied that there is much strength in the argument; but the cases do not appear to be precisely parallel.

The certificate that he is a magistrate, and that full faith is due to his oath implies, that he has qualified....if his qualification is necessary to his being a complete magistrate, whose acts are entitled to full faith and credit.

It is not usual for a particular certificate that a magistrate has qualified to accompany his official acts.

There is no record of his qualification and no particular testimonial of it could certainly be obtained.

These observations do not apply to the objections which exist.

But it is said that the certificate is the same with that in Wilkinson's affidavit.

If this objection had been taken and overruled, it would have ended the question. But it was not taken so far as is now recollected, and does not appear to have been noticed by the court. It is not recollected by the judge who sat on that occasion to have been noticed. A defect, if it be one, which was not observed, cannot be cured by being passed over in silence.

The case in Washington was a civil case, and turned upon the point, that no form of the commission was prescribed, and consequently that it was not necessary to appear on the face of it, that it was directed to magistrates.

That it was the duty of the clerk to direct it to magistrates, and he should not be presumed to have neglected his duty, in a case in which his performance of it need not appear on the face of the instrument.

That the person intending to take this exception, ought to have taken it sooner, and not surprize the opposite party when it was too late to correct it.

But the great difference is, that the privy examination was a mere ministerial act—the administering an oath is a judicial act.

The court is of opinion that the paper purporting to be an affidavit made by Dunbaugh, cannot be read because it does not appear to be an oath.

Mr. Hay then observed that as the examination of col. Burr for treason had already taken up much time without being able to make any progress in the business, and from the disposition manifested by his counsel it might last not only ten days, but even ten years longer, he considered it his duty from information which he had received that morning, to suggest to the court the propriety of binding col. Burr in a further recognizance from day to day, till the examination could be ended. He stated on the authority of a letter just come to hand from the secretary at war, that general Wilkinson with several other witnesses might be expected here between the 28th and 30th of this month. This circumstance, said he, renders it essential that he should be considered in custody until he gives security that his person shall be forthcoming to answer the charges of treason against the United States.—The gentlemen who appear as counsel for col. Burr may be and no doubt are sincere in the opinion they have expressed, that he will not shrink from the charges exhibited against him and will not in any conjuncture of circumstances which may occur, fly from a trial; but those gentlemen must pardon me for saying that I entertain a very different opinion. I must believe that his regard for the safety of his own life would, if he perceived it in danger, prevail over his regard for the interest of his securities. I give notice, therefore, that I consider him as being already in custody to answer the motion I have made for his commitment, and that he cannot be permitted to go at large without giving security for his appearance from day to day. His situation now is the same as that when he was first apprehended and brought before a single judge for the purpose of examination. Your honour at that time considered him as in custody, and bound him over from day to day; and I only contend that the same course should be pursued at this time.

Mr. Wickham. The gentleman thinks he has obtained the effect of his motion merely by having made it. I cannot perceive the propriety of a motion to compel col. Burr to give bail in any sum before the probable cause to believe him guilty of treason has been shewn. When he was brought before your honour for examination, you conceived the sum of $5000 sufficient security for his daily appearance. But a recognizance has already been given in double that sum, binding him not to depart without the leave of this court. Yet now, although no probable proof of treason has been exhibited, Mr. Hay requires the court to demand of col. Burr additional security! I trust that such a motion will not prevail.

Mr. Martin. It has already been decided by the supreme court of the United States, that not a single expression in Wilkinson's affidavit amounts to any proof of the charge of treason. The motion of the gentleman amounts to this; we have no evidence of treason, and are not ready to go to trial for the purpose of proving it. We therefore move the court to increase the bail.

Mr. Randolph. The first motion of the counsel for the United States, was to commit col. Burr on the ground of probable cause only. This goes a step farther; and wishes the same thing to be done on the ground of a probable cause of probable cause. But we trust that we shall not be deprived of our liberty, or held to bail on a mere uncertain expectation of evidence.

Mr. M'Rae. The gentlemen seem to consider the recognizance already taken as sufficient for all circumstances, and that col. Burr will comply with it at any rate. But we have not the same expectation that he will appear in case he discovers that sufficient evidence for his conviction has been obtained. When they speak of the sum in which he was bound on a former occasion, they do not recollect the circumstance which induced the judge to take bail in so small a sum. It was expressly mentioned by your honour that his having been brought to a place at a distance from the circle of his friends, and the nature of the offence, (a misdemeanor only,) induced you to hold him to bail in that sum; and that the charge of treason was altogether excluded from view in taking the recognizance.

Mr. Wirt. Mr. Wickham, in saying that my friend Mr. Hay thought he had obtained the object of his motion merely by having made it, clearly misconceived the object of the motion now before the court. The motion we made yesterday was to commit col. Burr on a charge of treason; our motion to-day is to hold him in custody to abide the opinion which the court may pronounce upon the commitment. The gentlemen say that we have secured the object we have in view by the recognizance already taken. The court expressly excluded the charge of treason from that recognizance, which applies only to the misdemeanor. Let us suppose that the motion to commit col. Burr was made out of court before a single magistrate. If the examination of witnesses in support of the motion occupied more than one day, would the magistrate let him go at large, while it was depending? Would he not rather either have retained him in custody, or take security for his appearance, and renew it every evening until the motion should be determined? This is all that we now ask of the court to do. The recognizance which has been given applies to the misdemeanor only. If, therefore, it should be forfeited by his going away, we should have no security for his answering a charge of treason: a much more enormous offence, and attended with a very different punishment. We contend, therefore, that additional security ought to be taken.

Mr. Botts. I shall endeavour to place this subject in some measure in a new light. It has been said that the former examination of col. Burr did not preclude this motion. If so, every new edition of the volume of evidence would justify a renewal of the motion to demand additional bail. Thus motions might be heaped upon motions, and bail upon bail, until the perpetual imprisonment of the accused might be the consequence.

It was a practice in former times to drown a person accused of being a witch, in order to try her. I think that practise is renewed on the present occasion in another shape—A motion is made to commit col. Burr for treason. Before the evidence can be gone through by which alone it can be ascertained that he ought to be committed, the court are requested to predetermine the effect of the evidence, and commit, before they have decided whether they ought to commit. Besides no warrant has been issued against col. Burr on the present occasion. He has not been arrested for treason, and therefore cannot be considered as in custody for that offence.

Mr. Hay then made some further observations on the importance of the charge of treason, (which is of the highest nature, involving the reputation and life of the prisoner) and the necessity therefore of the most ample security to compel his appearance to answer it. He stated that this examination might last many days; that after the court had made up an opinion that col. Burr ought to be committed, he might march off, and leave the court to pronounce it; so that an order to commit might be made by the court, and no person found on whom it could be executed. Such an event, he said, would excite the laughter and scorn of all the people of the United States. He mentioned that an immense expense had been incurred by the government in collecting witnesses, and preparing for his trial;—that therefore he did not wish the whole of that expense to be thrown away. Gen. Wilkinson is expected to arrive between the 28th and 30th of this month. If he arrives, both the bills of indictment will be immediately sent to the grand jury. This is the first instance in which the ministers of the law have been requested to say to the accused, "you may do as you please, and go at large until we pronounce sentence." The gentlemen contend for new principles in favour of col. Burr; but, I trust, that greater privileges will not be granted to him than to the humblest deluded victim of his ambition.

The circumstance that he has already entered into a recognizance to answer for a misdemeanor, is no argument to exempt him from entering into another on a charge of treason. Shall the accused clear himself of a responsibility for one crime by his having committed another? This would indeed be to violate that maxim of law, that no man shall be benefitted by his own wrong. Mr. Botts has contended that there is a difference between the case on the examination and that now before the court; that in the first instance a warrant had been issued; but none in the present. But a warrant is certainly unnecessary, now that the prisoner is before the court. The object of a warrant is to bring him before you. When this has been done, it is functus officio. Here is col. Burr before the court. It is therefore immaterial how he came before it; but he ought to be considered in custody, until discharged by the due course of law.

The Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the court, the substance of which was as follows. It is certainly necessary that a person accused should be retained in custody, or required to give security for his appearance, while his examination is depending. The amount of the security to be required, must depend, however, upon the weight of the testimony against him. On a former occasion, col. Burr was held to bail for his daily appearance in the sum of five thousand dollars only, because there was no evidence before the judge to prove the probability of his having been guilty of treason. When the examination was completed, the sum of ten thousand dollars was considered sufficient to bind him to answer the charge of a misdemeanour only, because the constitution requires that excessive bail should not be taken; but that recognizance had no application to the charge of treason. Yet, whether additional security ought to be required in the present stage of this business, before any evidence has appeared to make the charge of treason probable, is a question of some difficulty. It would seem that evidence sufficient to furnish probable cause must first be examined before the accused can be deprived of his liberty, or any security can be required of him.—Yet before this could be done, he might escape and defeat the very end of the examination. In common cases, where a person charged with a crime is arrested and brought before a magistrate, the arrest itself is preceded by an affidavit, which furnishes grounds of probable cause. The prisoner therefore is continued in custody, or bailed until the examination is finished. But here there has been no arrest for treason, and col. Burr is not in custody for that offence. The evidence then must be heard to determine whether he ought to be taken into custody. But as the present publick and solemn examination is very different from that before a single magistrate; as very improper effects on the publick mind may be produced by it, I wish that the court could be relieved from the embarrassing situation in which it is placed, and exempted from the necessity of giving any opinion upon the case, previously to its being acted upon by the grand jury. It is the wish of the court that the personal appearance of col. Burr could be secured, without the necessity of proceeding in this inquiry.

Col. Burr rose, and observed that he denied the right of the court to hold him to bail in this stage of the proceedings; that the constitution of the United States was against it; declaring that no person shall be arrested without probable cause made out by oath or affirmation; but if the court were embarrassed he would relieve them by consenting to give bail; provided it should be understood that no opinion on the question even of probable cause was pronounced by the circumstance of his giving bail.

The Chief Justice said that such was the meaning of the court.

Mr. Martin said, for his part, he should prefer that all the evidence should be fully gone into. Instead of fearing that publick prejudice would thereby be excited against Col. Burr, he believed it would remove all the prejudices of that sort which now prevailed.

The Chief Justice. As a bill will probably be sent up to the Grand Jury, the court wishes to declare no opinion either way.

Some conversation then occurred relative to the quantum of bail; and Col. Burr mentioned that he would propose that the sum should be ten thousand dollars, if he should be able to find security to that amount, of which he expressed himself to be doubtful. Mr. Hay contended that 50,000 dollars would not be too much; but the court finally accepted of the offer made by col. Burr, who after a short interval entered into a recognizance with four securities, to wit, Messrs. Wm. Langburn, Thomas Taylor, John G. Gamble, and Luther Martin;—himself in the sum of ten thousand dollars, and each security in the sum of five thousand dollars, conditioned that he would appear to answer the charge of treason, and not depart without leave of the court.

Mr. Martin, when offered as a security for col. Burr, said he had lands in the district of Virginia, the value of which was more than double the sum; and that he was happy to have this opportunity to give a publick proof of his confidence in the honour of col. Burr, and of his conviction that he was innocent.

All farther proceedings in the case were thereupon postponed until the next day.

Friday, May 29.

The grand jury were called over, and again adjourned until Saturday morning ten o'clock, but gen. Wilkinson having not arrived, nothing else was done.

See the clipping

‘As to my fortune, it is destroyed’

Ordered to post more bail, Burr tells the court his fortune ‘is in the hands of the government’ and he could not borrow ‘a single dollar.’ The court raises his bail anyway. Wilkinson still hasn’t come.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr. One word more: An idea has struck me since I last addressed the court, which I consider as of some importance. It is in all cases difficult to graduate the bail to the extent of an individual's fortune. But as to my fortune, it is destroyed: It is in the hands of the government. I know not whether in this place I could obtain credit for any thing; no, not for a single dollar; if I was trusted for my fortune alone.

Chief Justice after consulting with Mr. Griffin, gave it as the decision of the court, that Col. Burr should be bailed for 20,000 dollars more; himself in the sum of 10,000, and his securities in the same sum. So that the whole amount of bail, inclusive of the first recognizance, should be 40,000 dollars.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. I will then offer three of my former securities and Mr. Martin.

Mr. Martin. I hold landed property in the district of Virginia to twice the amount of the sum, for which I am to be bailed. And I am happy to give this public proof of my confidence in the integrity and innocence of Mr. Burr.

Messrs. Martin, Langhorne, Taylor, and Gamble, were the securities to this new recognizance; and were of course bound respectively in the sum of 2,500 dollars each.

Order of the Court.

This day came the attorney for the U. S. and A. Burr, and by consent of the said Aaron Burr: It is considered, that he enter into a recognizance in the sum of 10,000 dols, and give one or more securities in the like sum, with condition for his personal appearance before this court on to-morrow, then & there to answer such charges as shall be exhibited against him on behalf of the U. S. and not to depart without the leave of the said court. Whereupon the said Aaron Burr entered into recognizance in the penal sum of 10,000 dols. and Luther Martin, Wm. Langhorne, Thomas Taylor, and John Gamble, jun. in the sum of 2,500 dols. each.

The court adjourned till to-morrow, at 10 o'clock.

FRIDAY. The jury met at 10 o'clock—and were immediately adjourned till this day, (Saturday) 9 o'clock.—This early hour was chosen to suit the convenience of such of the jurors, as might wish to visit their families.

It is understood, that the attorney for the U. S. will not lay his indictments before the present grand jury before the arrival of gen. Wilkinson.

SATURDAY, May 30.

General Wilkinson failing still to appear, nothing was done this day relative to the trial of Colonel Aaron Burr.

MONDAY, June 1.

The grand jury having been called over, Mr. Hay observed that he felt great embarrassment and difficulty as to the course which ought to be pursued. He had confidently expected the arrival of General Wilkinson, and was disappointed. He was therefore unwilling to subject the grand jury to the inconvenience of farther attendance:—but he thought it proper to inform the court that he had this morning received a number of affidavits of witnesses residing in the neighborhood of Chilicothe and of Blannerhasset's island, which bore directly upon the charge of treason against Col. Burr. Those affidavits, however, had been taken in such a manner that according to the opinion lately given by the court concerning the affidavit of Jacob Dunbaugh, they were not admissible as evidence, and would not be permitted to be read. He expected to hear from General Wilkinson (if he should not appear in person) by the Lynchburg mail; which he understood would arrive on Wednesday morning. He therefore hoped that the grand jury would not be unwilling to make a farther sacrifice of a portion of their time for the public good, and would consent to wait with patience.

The grand jury were adjourned until Tuesday ten o'clock.

TUESDAY, June 2.

The grand jury were called and attended, but (General Wilkinson not having arrived) were again adjourned until Wednesday morning ten o'clock.

WEDNESDAY, June 3.

On this day it is expected the grand jury will be discharged, and the motion to commit Col. Burr on the charge of treason renewed; in support of which the evidence will be examined; and, very interesting debates on both sides may be expected.

MONDAY, May 25.

Continuation of the Debate, on Mr. Hay's motion to commit Aaron Burr.

At this moment the grand jury returned into court, & their names being called over requested an adjournment. After some desultory conversation between their Foreman and the Chief Justice, respecting certain points of form, they were accordingly adjourned till to morrow 10 o'clock.—They immediately retired from the court, when Mr. Hay arose to proceed with the argument.—He spoke, in substance as follows.

I stand here, sir, engaged in the performance of a most serious duty. I appear here in a cause, which involves the character of our government. I come here to charge Aaron Burr with High Treason against the U. S. with "levying war" upon his country. Sir, it was natural to suppose, that such a serious charge would have made a most serious impression upon A. B's mind; that he would have roused all the energies of his understanding in his service; in vindicating himself against such heinous charges, and not in casting imputations upon the government. Why then, sir, does he turn from himself against the administration. Why these complaints of persecution, which have fatigued our ears! I most solmnly deny the charge. I most confidently avow, that there is not a tittle of evidence to support it. None can be produced, unless it be a persecution, that the government brings him before a legal tribunal, where his guilt and innocence will be impartially established. A. Burr stands accused of the highest crimes and misdemeanors; he stands charged with a deliberate design of involving his country in all the horrors of civil insurrection, or of entangling her in a war with a foreign nation. This is the true question before the court, and instead of meeting this charge with the energy and firmness which became him; instead of confronting it with his evidence; he complains forsooth of persecution. And where, sir, is this tremendous persecution?

"Because he was sent here by a military authority"? But could A. Burr have been tried in the country where he was arrested? Was Blannerhassett's Island in the Mississippi Territory? Or ought he not to have been conveyed to that judicial district, which possessed a competent jurisdiction? But if A. Burr ought to have been sent here, by what number of men should he have been escorted? Was it by one man only; from whom he could have been so easily rescued, and whose vigilance he could most probably have eluded? Or ought he to have been conveyed, as he really was, by the energy of men, like Perkins, whose unshrinking firmness and whose humanity (in the presence of A. Burr himself, I avow it, let him deny it, if he can!) had completely qualified him for the safe transportation of his prisoner?

But, sir, when this cry and spell of persecution are once excited, it is not easy to set bounds to its fury? Not contented with inveighing against the pretended persecution of the government—a government, which never did persecute—a government which cannot persecute, and which will for ever stand firm in the affections of the people, from the integrity and intelligence which mark its measures—not contented with lavishing their complaints against it, the counsel for the prisoner have even turned against the humble instruments, who conduct the prosecution. They seriously complain, that we have given them no previous notice of this motion—and these are the very men, who have so often offered motions to this court, without the slightest intimation to ourselves—Sir, I most positively assert, that no notice in the present case ought to have been given. I shall not pretend to assert, that A. Burr, was disposed under the present state of things, to effect his escape: But I say, that supposing such to have been the fact, and supposing that, availing himself of the information which we had imparted, he should have taken to flight; I appeal to the candor of every impartial man; I appeal to the opposite counsel themselves, whether I should not have been guilty of a most gross violation of my duties.

(To be CONTINUED.)

See the clipping

A letter from the President

A letter from President Jefferson himself is read in court, about General Wilkinson’s correspondence, which Burr’s lawyers have demanded. The President of the United States is now part of the trial.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Washington, June 17, 07.

Sir,

See moreSee less

In answering your letter of the 9th, which desired a communication of one to me from gen. Wilkinson, specified by its date, I informed you in mine of the 12th, that I had delivered it, with all other papers respecting the charges against Aaron Burr, to the attorney general, when he went to Richmond, that I had supposed he had left them in your possession, but would immediately write to him, if he had not, to forward that particular letter without delay. I wrote to him accordingly on the same day, but having no answer, I know not whether he has forwarded the letter. I stated in the same letter that I had desired the secretary at war to examine his office in order to comply with your further request to furnish copies of the orders which had been given respecting Aaron Burr and his property; and in a subsequent letter of the same day, I forwarded to you copies of two letters from the secretary at war which appeared to be within the description expressed in your letter.—The order from the secretary of the navy, you said you were in possession of. The receipt of these papers had I presume, so far anticipated, and others this day forwarded, will have substantially fulfilled, the object of a subpoena from the district court of Richmond, requiring that those officers & myself should attend the court in Richmond, with the letter of gen. Wilkinson, the answer to that letter, and the orders of the department of war and the navy therein generally described. No answer to gen. Wilkinson's letter, other than a mere acknowledgment of its receipt in a letter written for a different purpose, was ever written by myself or any other. To these communications of papers, I will add, that if the defendant supposes there were any facts within the knowledge of the heads of departments, or of myself, which can be useful for his defence, from a desire of doing any thing our situation will permit in furtherance of justice, we shall be ready to give him the benefit of it, by way of deposition through any persons whom the court shall authorise to take our testimony at this place; I know indeed that this cannot be done but by consent of parties, and I therefore authorise you to give consent on the part of the U. S. Mr. Burr's consent will be given of course, if he supposes the testimony useful.

As to our personal attendance at Richmond, I am persuaded the court is sensible that paramount duties to the nation at large controul the obligation of compliance with their summons in this case, as they would, should we receive a similar one to attend the trials of Blannerhasset and others in the Mississippi territory, those instituted at St. Louis, and other places on the western waters, or at any place other than the seat of government. To comply with such calls, would leave the nation without an executive branch, whose agency nevertheless is understood to be so constantly necessary, that it is the sole branch which the constitution requires to be always in function. It could not then be contended that it should be withdrawn from its station by any co-ordinate authority.

With respect to papers, there is certainly a public and private side to our offices. To the former, belong grants of lands, patents for inventions, certain commissions, proclamations, and other papers patent in their nature. To the other belong mere executive proceedings. All nations have found necessary, that for the advantageous conduct of their affairs, some of these proceedings at least, should remain known to their executive functionary only. He of course, from the nature of the case, must be the sole judge of which of them the public interest will permit publication. Hence under our constitution, in requests of papers from the legislative to the executive branch, one exception is carefully expressed "as to those which he may deem the public welfare may require not to be disclosed," as you will see in the inclosed resolution of the House of Representatives, which produced the message of Jan. 22, respecting this case. The respect mutually due between the constituted authorities in their official intercourse, as well as sincere dispositions to do for every one what is just, will always ensure from the executive, in exercising the duty of discrimination confided to him, the same candor and integrity, to which the nation has in like manner trusted in the disposal of its judiciary authorities. Considering you as the organ for communicating these sentiments to the court, I address them to you for that purpose, and salute you with esteem and respect.

TH : JEFFERSON.

See the clipping

Where to hold Burr

The prosecutor, Mr. Hay, moves to take Burr from his present place of confinement, which he calls expensive and not safe, to apartments the Virginia executive has offered. That would save two hundred dollars or more, he says, and many others charged in the same crime may soon need room. Mr. Wickham, for Burr, answers that the United States will spend thousands on this inquiry, so a hundred or two cannot matter. The court puts it off a day.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The court directed that the clerk enter the communication from the executive as accepted—and desired, that if any motion was intended to be made, as it regards col. Burr, that it might be made this day: upon which Mr. Hay had an interview with Messrs. Wirt and M'Rea, after which he appeared again at the bar, and stated, that he deemed it his duty to motion, that Aaron Burr be removed from his present place of confinement, to one of the apartments alluded to in the communication from the executive—he said, that the present establishment for the confinement of col. Burr was expensive and not safe; and that probably two hundred or more dollars would be saved to the United States by removing him under the proposition of the Virginia executive—he also mentioned, that, in a short time, many others associated in the crime, which col. Burr was charged with, might be brought hither, and that it was certainly correct, that provision should be made, for their accommodation.

Mr. Wickham (Mr. Randolph and Mr. Martin being absent) observed, that it was very probable that colonel Burr would prefer risquing his own and the lives of his counsel, in an apartment in Mr. Roses jail—that the United States had, and probably would, expend thousands and tens of thousands upon this important enquiry, and that the sum of one or two hundred dollars, could not be important; that the situation of colonel Burr's council, he thought, ought also to be taken into consideration.

See moreSee less

The court proposed that the subject should be postponed till to morrow, in which Mr. Hay acquiesced.

See the clipping

A pardon for testimony

A Richmond writer defends Jefferson for pardoning Erick Bollman, one of Burr’s men, in exchange for his testimony, and asks why anyone should believe Bollman’s story of his visit to the President.

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Virginia Argus · 1 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FOR THE ARGUS. WHAT credit does Erick Bollman deserve when he declares he had no personal motives for the interview which he requested with the President of the United States? And how much stronger must be his attachment to Aaron Burr, than to the United States, when he endeavored to convince the President "that he would promote the interest of the United States by going to war with Spain, (that is, in fact, with France, Spain, Holland and Italy) and giving countenance to the expedition which Col. Burr had planned?" Is it possible that so silly a proposition as this could have been a serious object in Bollman's view, when he requested to see the President?

See moreSee less

If this, and his attempt to prove that Burr was not guilty of treason, were all that he communicated to the President, he surely would never have been presented with a pardon. But his important disclosures of Burr's plans, projects, and the means of accomplishing them, which he had not only not disclosed, but had aided in carrying into effect till he was arrested on a charge of misprision of treason by Gen. Wilkinson, certainly required a pardon, and the President was in duty bound to procure his testimony as state's evidence (called king's evidence in England) against Burr and his accomplices: and as to the promise "that his communications should never be used against himself," and "that the paper should never go out of the President's hand." The former part has been strictly and faithfully complied with, and the latter as fully observed as the nature of the case could possibly admit of. For when the President granted a pardon to Bollman, it was on condition that he would say before the grand jury and venire, on his oath, all that he had written, and was material to the conviction of Burr and his accomplices: but unfortunately he had made this promise before Burr was taken, and after seeing him, he had not the courage to keep it, and had recourse to various quibbles and subterfuges to avoid giving his testimony. Foolishly believing that if he refused the pardon, he could not be used as a witness. And when this was his idea, it surely was the President's duty to furnish the attorney with Bollman's written testimony, that he might make such use of it as the nature of the case might require. Was the President for the preservation of Bollman's small stock of honor to suffer traitors to escape even an indictment? was he to keep his word with a faithless traitor, & like him be guilty of misprision of treason, by concealing not only Bollman's, but Burr's and his accomplices' treason also? surely not.—His charge then against the President for a breach of honor in betraying his confidential communication, is the most groundless & imprudent charge that ever was brought against any one since the creation of Man!!

See the clipping

The plan, as one witness heard it

A militia colonel swears to what one of Burr’s men told him the day after the arrest: take Baton Rouge first, then Mobile, Pensacola and St. Augustine, and form a republican government, with General Wilkinson second in command, though Wilkinson, the man said, ‘had deceived him.’

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Baltimore, Aug. 3.

COPY.

See moreSee less

The deposition of John Callier, Esq. a justice of the peace, and colonel of the militia in the county of Washington and Mississippi Territory, taken before Harry Toulmin, one of the judges of the said Territory, at Washington, in the said county. The day after col. Burr was arrested, near Fort Stoddert, Mr. Robert Ashley, who had come to the Tombigbee settlement with colonel Burr, came to my house, accompanied by Mr. Thomas Malone:—I had been just before apprized by a note from Mr. Malone, sent to me at my quarter, that Mr. Burr was come to this country, and was arrested; that Ashley was at my house; but that he knew nothing of the arrest of Col. Burr. On my reaching the house I found that Mr. Ashley was gone to bed; and Mr. Malone acquainted me more fully with the circumstances, but informed me that he could get no disclosure from him of their intention. I mentioned to him that I had known Mr. Ashley several years ago, and that as I was satisfied that his object in coming to see me, was to prevail on me to join in their plans, I should have no difficulty in finding out what they were. The next morning I enquired after Mr. Ashley, about the news, and particularly with respect to col. Burr; and was then informed by him that col. Burr was in this country. After breakfast we rode together to Wakefield; he then informed me that he was in the plans of col. Burr; that he had come to see me, to ascertain if I would join him in the plan; I told him that if it was nothing against government, nor touching on the strings of government, I would do every thing that should tend to relieve us from our oppression. He told me that it was not col. Burr's plan to touch on the strings of government; that gen. Wilkinson had deceived him; that they were to have met at such a time at Baton Rouge; that Burr was to be the first in command; general Wilkinson to be second; that he was to have joined him (Burr) with the fe[d]eral army; that the soldiers were to have double pay, and that s[o]me of the officers of the army, but very few of them, were in the plan; that some small censure having taken place with respect to gen. Wilkinson, was the reason that he had shifted his coat, and made all that great bustle; that the object of the plan was to take Baton Rouge in the first place, and from thence to proceed to Mobile, Pensacola and Augustine; reduce the posts there, and form a republican government; that he had already prepared the laws: that they were so simple and excellent that they would suit from a ten year old boy to an old man; and that like the laws of the Medes and Persians, they would be unalterable; that the people of the U. S. from the Alleghany westward, and down to the sea, would be invited to come into the new republic; and that the ports of this republic would be opened free to all the world; that he had got in with England, so that she would furnish a fleet of 12 sail, which would join him as soon as he had got possession of the Floridas, and be commanded by captain Truxton; that as soon as he had got the country out of the power of Spain, a negociation was to be opened with England, and England was to acknowledge their independence; that after he had done this, he was to go to Mexico, where the co-operation of the Spanish officers had been secured, who were tired of their own government, and ripe for a revolution; that the Spanish minister Yrujo; and that the Spanish officers in Florida, were likewise concerned; and that Mr. Burr had frequent long conversations with Yrujo upon the subject; that general Wilkinson had so much disappointed him, that he had turned his attention entirely to this quarter; that we were so much oppressed by the Spaniards, and so utterly neglected by our own government, that he knew we must be disposed to vindicate our own rights by an attack on the Spanish possessions; and tha[t] if I and major Hanson, and major Buford, would join in supporting him, that he, (Ashley) would immediately set off and procure seventeen hundred men, and march them into this country, where they would be met by col. Burr, who was then on his way to the Federal City, but would return without delay; that the 1700 men were actually engaged and ready to start when called upon—but were scattered in diff[e]rent settlements from the Natchez upwards, and that twelve thousand more were ready engaged. On reaching Wakefield, I arrested the said Ashley, believing that I had got every thing out of him that I could. He continued in custody three or four days, and then escaped. JNO. CALLIER. Sworn to and subscribed the 9th of May, 1807. HARRY TOULMIN.

See the clipping

Can anyone judge him fairly?

Choosing the trial jury, the court sets aside man after man who has already said Burr is guilty, and by the end of the day only four are sworn. One, Thomas Creel, says he never positively called Burr guilty, though he had called him ‘a sensible man, and if there was any hole left, he would creep out of it.’ The Chief Justice holds him over.

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The Enquirer · 11 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR,

(continued by adjournment and held at the Capitol in the Hall of the House of Delegates,) for High Treason against the United States.

See moreSee less

FRIDAY, August 7.

The following new witnesses appeared this day: Lieut. Swaringen, William McFarlane and Lewis Kerr.

Mr. Hay observed, that he had nothing more to submit to the court; and that he hoped all the material witnesses would be present on Monday, and enable him to prosecute the Trial.

MONDAY, August 10.

HERMAN BLANNERHASSET was this day brought into Court.

The following gentlemen appeared and were recognized: Return I. Meigs, Maurice P. Belnap, Charles Duvall, James Taylor, Tunis Dits, Bennett Cook, Hezekiah Lewis, and G. B. Vanhorne.

Mr. Wirt moved the Court to discharge Dr. Wardlaw, one of the Venire. His wife was in extreme danger, and required the assistance for a sea-voyage. The vessel would sail to-morrow. C. Justice.—Is the Court to understand that there is no objection to this measure?—Mr. Burr.—If the remark be addressed to me, Sir, I can only say, that I shall remain passive during the transaction.—Dr. Wardlaw was then dismissed.

Mr. McRae also moved the discharge of Mr. Randolph Harrison, whose extreme indisposition was attested by a certificate from Dr. Adams.

Mr. H. was accordingly dismissed in the same manner.

Mr. Hay moved that H. Blannerhasset be arraigned for high treason: which Mr. Botts opposed on the ground that he had not been furnished with a copy of the indictment for three days. After some desultory conversation on this circumstance, Mr. Botts requested that Mr. B. might be re-conducted to the Penitentiary, as he was extremely indisposed, and the heat nearly overpowered him. No opposition was made, and Mr. B was accordingly re-conducted to his prison.

At Mr. Hay's request, the pannel of the Jury was called over by the Deputy-Marshall, and also, at Mr. Burr's request, the list of the Witnesses, whom he had subpoenaed for the purpose of investigating the qualification of some of the Venire.

Mr. Hay read a certificate from Dr. Upshaw, stating that Mr. James Henderson is sick of a bilious fever and incapable of attending.

Mr. McRae then read a certificate from Dr. Greenhow, shewing that David Bullock, Esq. one of the Venira was prevented by indisposition from discharging his duties. Mr. B. was accordingly excused.

The Clerk informed Mr. Burr, that he was at liberty to challenge such of the Venire as he might object to. Mr. Burr begged leave to inform the jurors, who were within hearing, that a great number of them may have formed and expressed opinions about him, which might disqualify them from serving on this occasion: He expected that as they came up, they would discharge the duties of conscientious men, and candidly state all these objections.—The Deputy Marshall then summoned

1. Hezekiah Bucky.—Mr. Botts. We challenge you for cause. Have you ever formed and expressed an opinion about the guilt of Col Burr? Mr. Bucky. I have not, Sir, since I have been subpoenaed.—Q. Had you before? A. I had formed one before in my own mind.

Mr. Hay wished that the question of the opposite counsel could assume a more precise and definite form. If this question were proposed to this pannel and to every other man, he would venture to predict, that there could not be a jury selected in the state of Virginia; because he did not believe that there was a single man in the state, qualified to become a juryman, who had not in some form or other, made up and declared an opinion on the conduct of the prisoner. The transactions in the west had excited universal curiosity; and there was no man who had not seen and decided on the documents relative to them. Do gentlemen contend, that in a case so peculiarly interesting to all, the mere declaration of an opinion is sufficient to disqualify a juryman? A doctrine of this sort would at once acquit the prisoner; for where is the jury that could try him? Such a doctrine amounts to this: that a man need only do enough to draw down the public attention upon him and he would immediately effect his discharge. Mr. H. concluded with a hope, that the question would assume a more definitive form; he should not pretend to decide the form on which it should be proposed; but it was a privilege to which every court is entitled, and one which the court had exercised, that had presided in the case of James F. Callender.

Mr. Botts considered it as a misfortune ever to be deplored, that in this country and in this case, there had been too general an expression of the public sentiment, and that this generality of opinion would disqualify many; but he had never entertained a doubt, until the prosecution had avowed it, that twelve men might be found in Virginia, capable of deciding this question, with the strictest impartiality. He still trusted that the Attorney for the United States was mistaken; that the catastrophe was not completely fixed; and that every man in the state had not pledged himself to convict Col. B. whether right or wrong. He was not present at the trial of J. T. Callender; but all America had heard the question which was then propounded to the jurymen; and that was: whether he had made up and expressed an opinion respecting the guilt of the prisoner.

Mr. Hay would put Mr. Botts right in a matter of fact. The court would recollect that on the trial of Callender, the question was not whether the jurymen had found and expressed an opinion on that case generally; but on the subject matter that was to be tried, and couched in the Indictment. The question then in the present case should be: Have you formed and expressed an opinion on the point at issue, that is, whether A. B. is guilty of treason? On the trial of Calendar, the court would particularly recollect, that Mr. John Bassett having objected to himself, because he had read the libellous publication, was actually overruled, because it was not on the book itself, but on the subject matter of the Indictment, that he was called upon to say, whether he had ever expressed an opinion.

Mr. Burr declared there was a material distinction between that and the present case. Mr. Bassett's acknowledging that he had seen the book did not disqualify him from serving on the jury; in the same manner the person who had seen a murder would not be an incompetent juror in the prosecution for that crime. But if a man's pretended to decide upon the guilt of a prisoner upon mere rumour, he would manifest such a levity and bias of mind, as would effectually disqualify him. Mr. Bucky however has not yet come out completely with his declarations. Let him be further interrogated.

Mr Hay observed, that the question would even be too general and vague, if it were ever to be—"have you expressed any opinion, on the treason of A. B." for the case stated in the indictment was infinitely more specific. It was treason in levying war against the U.S. at Blannerhassett's Island. Unless this particular allegation be proved, it defeats all the other parts of the accusation; & it was probably on this point that the juror had never made up any opinion.

Mr. Martin contended that it was the province of every juryman to come to any case with the most perfect impartiality; and more particularly in one, where life and reputation were at stake: that it was a libel upon Virginia, a blot upon the whole state, to assert that 12 men could not be found to decide such a case, with no other knowledge than what they had picked up from newspapers; that there was a material distinction between this and Callender's case; the libel was a book in every man's hand; but does any juryman in the present case pretend to know the testimony on which this charge depends? The gentleman proposes to ask the juryman, whether he has made up an opinion on Col. B's treason: but it is extremely probable, that most of them know not what treason is; and though they may decide upon the guilt of Col. B. that they may be ignorant, whether it comes under the name and description of treason.

Mr. Botts quoted authorities in support of his opinion: 3 Bacon 358; a case from Hawkin's; the cases of Smith & Ogden; and Judge Iredell's opinion in the case of Fries.

The Chief Justice observed, that it might save some altercation, if the court was to deliver its opinions at the present time; that it was certainly one of the clearest principles of natural justice that a juryman should come to a trial for life with a perfect freedom from previous impressions; that it was clearly the duty of the court to obtain such men, if it were possible to produce them free from such bias; but that if it were not possible from the very circumstances of the case; if rumours had reached and pre-possessed their judgments, still the court was bound to obtain as large a portion of impartiality as possible; that this was not more a principle of natural justice, than a maxim of the common law, which we have inherited from our forefathers; that the same right was secured by the constitution of the United States, which entitles every man under a criminal prosecution to a fair trial by "an impartial jury." Can it be said however, that any man is an impartial juryman, who has declared the prisoner to be guilty and to have deserved punishment? If it be said, that he has made up this opinion, but has not heard the testimony; such an excuse only makes the case worse; for if the man has decided upon insufficient testimony, it manifests a bias that completely disqualifies himself from the functions of a juryman. It is too general a question to ask whether he has any impressions about Col. B. The impressions may be so light, that they do not amount to an opinion of guilt; nor do they go to the extent of believing, that the prisoner deserves capital punishment. With respect to Mr. Bassett's opinion, it was true he had read "the Prospect before us;" and he had declared that it was a libel; but Mr. B. had formed no opinion about J. T. Callender's being the author. It was the same principle in the present case. If a juryman was to declare that the attempt to achieve the dismemberment of the union was treason, it would be no complete disqualification; but it would be the application of that crime to a particular individual—it would be the fixing it on A. B. that would disable him from serving in his case. Let the counsel then proceed with the enquiry.

Mr. Botts. Have you said that Col. B. was guilty of treason? Mr. Bucky. No. I only declared that the man who acted as Col. B. was said to have done, deserved to be hung.—Q. Did you believe, that Col. B. was that man? A. I did, from what I had heard.

Mr. Hay. I understand then, that the question proposed in Callender's case is to be overruled? C. Justice. My brother judge does not recollect whether it particularly went to the indictment. Judge Griffin. I think the question was, "related to the matter in issue." Mr. Hay. The very position that I have laid down. C. Justice. The simple question is whether the having formed an opinion not upon the evidence in Court, but upon common rumour, a man is competent to decide upon the real testimony of the case. But in my opinion this very circumstance only disqualifies him the more. Mr. Wirt (addressing Mr. Buckey.) Did I understand you to say that you concluded upon certain rumors you may have heard, that Col. B. deserved to be hung? A. I did. Q. Did you believe these rumours? A. I did. Q. Would you, if you were a juryman, form your opinion upon such rumors? A. Certainly not.—Mr. McRae. Did you form and express your opinion upon the question, whether an overt act of treason had been committed at Blannerhassett's island? A. It was upon other rumours; and not upon that, that I had formed an opinion.—Mr. Martin submitted it to the court, whether he could be considered as an impartial juryman. The court decided that Mr. Bucky be put aside.

2. James G. Laidley stated, that he had formed and expressed some opinions unfavorable to Col. B. that he could not pretend to decide upon the charges in the indictment, which he had not heard; that he had principally taken his opinions from news paper statements; and that he had not, as far as he recollected, expressed an opinion, that Col. B. deserved hanging.—Mr. Laidley put aside.

3. James Hamilton being challenged for cause and sworn, stated that he had formed and expressed an opinion from hearsay, that Col. B. was guilty of treason, and in that particular line of treason, in which Col. B. stood charged, as far as he understood. Put aside.

Mr. Burr observed, that as gentlemen on the part of the prosecution had expressed a willingness to have an impartial jury, they could not refuse that any juryman should state all his objections to himself; and that he had no doubt, in spite of the contrary assertions which had been made, that they could get a jury from this pannel.

4. Hamilton Morrison upon being called, said, that he had frequently thought and declared, that Col. B. was guilty, if the statements which he had heard were true; that he did not know whether they were so; but only thought from the great clamour which had been made, that it might be possible they were true; that he had not passed any positive opinion; nor was he certain that he had always qualified it by saying "if these things were true; that he does not recollect to have said that Col. B. ought to be punished, without stating at the same time, "if he was guilty."—Mr. Morrison was put aside for further examination.

5. Yates T. Conwell had formed and expressed an opinion, from the reports he had heard that Col. B. must be guilty of High Treason. Set aside.

6. Jacob Beeson declared, that he for some time past had formed an opinion, as well from newspaper publications as from the boats which had been built on the Ohio, that Col. B. was guilty; and that he himself had borne arms to suppress this insurrection. Set aside.

7. William Prince declared he had nearly the same impressions as Mr. Beeson: that he too had borne arms; as well on Blannerhassett's island as on descending the river in search of Blannerhassett. Set aside.

8. Nimrod Saunders declared that he had expressed an opinion, previously to his being summoned on the jury, that the prisoner had been guilty of treason. Set aside.

9. Thomas Creel had no declaration to make, and was challenged for cause. Upon being interrogated, he stated that he had never asserted that the prisoner ought to be punished, that he had said that he was a sensible man, and if there was any hole left, he would creep out of it, that he had conceived that Col. Burr had seduced Blannerhassett into some acts that were not right; that he had never positively said that Col. Burr was guilty; that he had said that Blannerhassett was the most blamable, because he was well in life, whereas Col. Burr was a desperate man, who had little to lose; that he had never said that Col. Burr had directly led Blannerhassett directly into guilt, but only through the medium of Mr. Blannerhasset; and that there was no determinate impression on my mind respecting the guilt of the prisoner.

The Chief Justice did not think that this was sufficient to let him aside, and suspended his case for further examination.

10. Anthony Buckner had frequently said, that the prisoner deserved to be hung. Set aside.

11. David Creel had formed an opinion from the statements in the newspapers, and if these were true, the prisoner was certainly guilty: He had expressed a belief that he was guilty of the charges now brought against him, and that he ought to be hung. Set aside.

Jurors from the body of the district.

1. John Horace Upshaw declared, that he conceived himself to stand there as an unprejudiced juryman; that he had formed opinions hostile to the prisoner; if opinions they can be called, which are formed from mere newspaper testimony. Mr. Burr. We challenge Mr. Upshaw for cause.

Mr. Hay. Then, sir, I most seriously apprehend that we shall have no jury at all. I solemnly believe, that Mr. U. is an impartial juryman; and I will venture to assert (whatever credit my friends on the other side will allow to my assertion) that I myself could do justice to the accused; I believe that any man can, who is blessed with a sound judgment and integrity. We might as well enter at once a Nole Prosequi.

Mr. Wickham. Then according to the gentleman's doctrine, any honest man, no matter what his impressions may be, is a competent juryman. Is this agreeable to the principles of law? Does the gentleman mean to insinuate, that when we object to a juryman, it is from his want of honesty. No, sir. Every man is subject to partialities and aversions; which may unconsciously sway his judgment. Mr. Upshaw does no doubt deem himself an impartial juryman: but Mr. U. may be deceived.

After some desultory argument between Messrs. Hay and Wickham, Mr. Wirt proceeded to ask Mr. Upshaw, whether he had understood him to say that notwithstanding the hostile impressions he had taken up from news-paper reports, these impressions had not received that determinate character which might entitle them to the name of opinions? A. Such is my state of mind. I have received impressions hostile to Col. Burr and have expressed them with some warmth. Mr. Upshaw stated that his impressions had been drawn from the documents furnished by Gens. Eaton and Wilkinson; that he had conceived that the prisoner had been guilty of some criminal act against the public; and that he had gone on further to vindicate the conduct of those gentlemen who would appear as the principal witnesses against him, & also of the government in the measures which it had taken to suppress his plans.—Mr. Upshaw's case was suspended for subsequent examination.

2. William Pope declared, that his impressions were nearly the same with those of the gentleman, who had preceded him; that he had thought at first from newspaper representations that it was Col. B's intention to make his fortune in the west by the settlement of lands; that when he had afterwards understood that he had formed an union with Wilkinson to proceed to Mexico, he had regarded the prisoner's conduct with a venal eye; but when he had afterwards understood that there was treason mixed with his projects, it was impossible for him to view his conduct without the deepest indignation: If these impressions could be called prejudices, he trusted that he should always retain them; because what other sentiments could he feel against such a crime perpetrated against the very best government on the surface of the earth. But from his heart he believed, that he could divest himself of these unfavorable impressions, and give Col. B. a fair and honourable trial. He would add that in pursuance of the spirit manifested by them, the constitution, which required two witnesses to an overt act of treason; he should think it necessary to require that the evidence for the United States, should be so strong as to make the scales preponderate. Mr. Wickham. You will not misunderstand me, Mr. Pope, when I ask you whether you have not been a candidate for your county, and are now a delegate? A. Yes. Q. In canvassing among the people, have you not declared that the government had acted properly in commencing this prosecution? A. Yes. I believe I have said generally, that I thought col. B. guilty of high treason—Set aside.

3. Peyton Randolph declared, that it had never been his wish or intention to shrink from the discharge of a public duty; but that he had peculiar objections to serving on this occasion; one of which only, he should state. He had been enrolled and was qualified as a lawyer in this court: and he would submit it to the court, whether this did not exempt, nay even disqualify him from serving.——C. J. admitted Mr. R's privilege, unless there was an express interposition on the part of the prisoner to retain some of the Venire: for this would call a conflicting privilege into operation.—Mr. Burr said, that he should be passive.—Set aside.

4. John Bowe did not recollect to have said that the prisoner was guilty of treason; but of something hostile to the peace and happiness of the U. S. Upon being interrogated he observed, that he was a Delegate from the county of Hanover; that there had been a competition at the last election; that he had had occasion to speak at that time, of the views of the prisoner, but had always done it cautiously; had never asserted that he ought to be hung, but that he was guilty of something unfriendly to the peace of the U.S.—Mr. Wickham. You have said that the prisoner was guilty? A. Yes. C. Justice. Did you ever make up an opinion about his levying troops and making war against the U. S. A. Yes: but I have never expressed it. Mr. Burr. Take the whole together, and it amounts to an opinion of treason. Mr. Bowe has said that Col. B. was guilty; and of what? of that which in Mr. Bowe's mind amounts to the disposition of treason.—Set aside.

5. John Roberts had thought and declared that the prisoner was guilty of treason; though he had no doubt, that his opinion might be changed by the production of other testimony.—Set aside.

6. Joshua Chaffin excused from indisposition.

7. Gervas Storrs stated that the state of his mind was like that of the gentleman who had gone before him; he was in the habit of reading newspapers, and could not but examine their statements relative to these transactions. If he could believe Gen. Eaton's assertion that the prisoner had threatened to turn Congress out of doors and assassinate the President, he had said and would still say so, that Col. B. was guilty of treason. If Gen. Wilkinson's letter was true, he had surely been guilty of something in the west, that was hostile to the U.S. He did not know whether in the multifarious conversations he had had on this subject, he had always expressed this opinion of his guilt with that reservation. Mr. S. confessed that it might be prejudiced against the prisoner; and that he might be judging too highly of his own mind, to entertain the belief that he could divest himself of all his impressions.—Set aside.

8. Miles Selden declared, that it was impossible not to have entered into the frequent conversations which had occurred on this topic; and to have declared some opinion; that he had always said, that Col. B. was guilty of something, and that if he was guilty of treason against such a government, he would deserve to be hung; that he could not assert that he had always accompanied his opinions with this reservation; but that he was not afraid to trust himself in the rendering of a verdict. Upon being interrogated, he said that he had frequently jested on this subject; and particularly recollected to have said in a sportive conversation with Col. Mayo, that this was a federal plot and that Burr had been set on by the federalists. Suspended.

9. Lewis Trueheart had said, if the reports were correct, that Col. B. had been guilty of something inimical to the country, and that he always qualified his opinions in that manner. Col. Tinsley was then called in, who stated that from a conversation with Mr. Trueheart he thought he had discovered that he had a general prepossession against Col. B.—Suspended.

10. William Yancey had expressed an opinion that Col. B. was guilty on newspaper testimony; but that he had no doubt, he should entertain a different sentiment, if other testimony were produced.—Set aside.

11. Thomas Prosser had made numberless declarations about Col. B; that he had believed him to be guilty of a treasonable intention, but not of the overt act; on this point he had suspended his opinion, but he was rather inclined to believe that he had not committed it. Mr. Martin. Can this gentleman be considered as an impartial juryman, when he thus comes with his mind made up on one half of the guilt? Suspended.

12. John Staples had been under the same impressions, which had been described by others; that he dared to say that he had said Col. B. was guilty of levying troops and making war upon the U. States. Set aside.

13. Edward C. Stannard acknowledged that his prejudices against Col. B. had been deep-rooted;—that he had no doubt of the criminality of his motives, but he had doubts of the commission of an overt act; he regretted that a man of his genius and energetic mind, should be lost to his country; upon being interrogated he observed, that he had doubts as to the overt act, because he believed him to be a man of such insidious intrigue as never to jeopardise his own life.—Set aside.

14. Richard B. Goode stated, that from news paper information and common report, he had formed an opinion unfavorable to Col. B. and that this opinion had been confirmed by what had fallen in this court from his own lips: but that without arrogating to himself more virtue than belongs to the human bosom, he was satisfied that he could render him strict and impartial justice. Some conversation here ensued respecting certain transactions which took place between him and Capt. Heath of the Manchester troop of horse. Mr. G delivered a long narrative of these incidents, which he concluded by asserting that he had addressed a letter to Capt. H. in which he had refused to act under a commander, who had sanctioned a man, that had been a traitor to his country.—Set aside.

15. Nathaniel Selden stated he had formed an opinion particularly from G. Eaton's deposition, that the intentions of the prisoner were hostile to the United States; but that he had also said, that he had seen no evidence to satisfy him, that he had been guilty of any overt act.—Suspended.

16. Esme Smock declared that he had formed and expressed an opinion as to Col. B's treasonable designs; that he had formed that opinion from newspaper publications and common report; and that he had constantly conceived Col. B's intentions to be treasonable. Mr. Wickham. Have you ever formed an opinion, that Col. B. was guilty of treason? I have in my own mind.—Set aside.

17. Richard E. Parker had, like every other person, formed an opinion on this case, on newspaper statements; but he had heard very little of the evidence that may be adduced on this occasion. He had declared, that if these newspaper statements were true, Col. B. had been guilty; as to the doctrine of treason, he had not formed a conclusive opinion. Mr. Burr. I have no objections to Mr. Parker. He is therefore elected.

A desultory argument here ensued about the propriety of swearing one juryman at a time: The counsel for the prosecution opposed; the counsel for the prisoner advocated the doctrine. The court decided that it would adhere to the practice of Virginia; and swear 4 jurymen at a time.

18. John W. Ellis had entertained and did not now entertain any doubts, that the prisoner had been guilty of a treasonable design.—Suspended.

19. Thomas Starke, without any expectations of being summoned as a juryman, had stated his opinion to his neighbors, that Col. B. had been guilty of high treason.—Set aside.

20. William White stated, that he had been in the western country in May last; and from Col. B's character and from the representations he had received of his conduct, he had been induced to say, that he was guilty of treason, and that hanging was too good for him.—Set aside.

21. Wm. B. Chamberlayne stated, that he stood in a very peculiar situation; if as Mr. Wickham declared, any man was unfit to be a juryman who had asserted Col. B. to have been worthy of death; he was ready to confess that he himself came under this restriction: He had so said; but he did not now believe that Col. B. had committed an overt act of treason, though he believed him to be guilty of the intention: He however believed that he could do him justice; and that he could conscientiously pass between him and his country.—Set aside.

22. David Lambert wished to be excused on account of his indisposition: but the court rejected his plea. On being interrogated, he declared that he does not recollect to have formed an opinion for or against Col. B.—Elected.

23. William Hoomes had no hesitation in saying, that he had often declared his opinion that Col. B. was guilty of treasonable intentions, and perhaps he might say, of treason itself. He had imbibed his impressions from every thing he had seen, heard or read. He had understood that Col. B's counsel had made preparations to prove that he had disqualified himself by his own declarations. He should thank them to develope their objections.—Mr. Burr. I assure you, sir, no preparation has been made.—Set aside.

24. Overton Anderson had often expressed an opinion that Col. B's views were inimical to the United States; these opinions he had principally formed upon newspaper statements; he did not recollect that he had ever asserted him to be guilty of treason; but he had sometimes given credit to the representations which he had heard, without particularly defining the degree of guilt in which they might involve the prisoner.—Set aside.

25. Hugh Mercer upon being called, said, it was his duty to state, that an opinion which he had for some time past entertained of the character of Col. Burr, was unfriendly to a strictly impartial enquiry into his case; that he was entirely uninformed as to the testimony which would be introduced, and that he did not recollect to have ever expressed a positive opinion either as to his guilt or innocence.—Elected.

26. Jerman Baker had entertained opinions unfavorable to A. Burr, which he had repeatedly expressed; he had spoken them with warmth, for it was his nature to be warm: He had no doubt that the prisoner had formed very unfavourable designs against the U. States; but from his ignorance of the evidence, he could not venture to say that they had ripened into an overt act.—Mr. Burr. What opinion have you formed of me? A. A very bad one; which I have expressed often when called upon and often when not.—Set aside.

27. Edward Carrington had formed an unfavorable opinion of the views of Col. Burr; but these opinions were not definitive: some had said that Col. Burr's object was to invade the Spanish Territories; others, that it was to dismember the Union: his own opinion had not been definitely fixed. There was another subject connected with this trial, on which he had also expressed his opinions; and that related to the measures taken at New Orleans. His own opinion had been that it was impossible for any one at this remote scene to determine upon the state of affairs in that city; but that if gen. Wilkinson did not seriously believe what he said he had been represented to him as the views of Col. Burr, that he himself considered it as an extreme case, and that it was proper to act in somewhat the like form that Gen. Wilkinson had pursued. This has been the state of my mind for 12 months—Mr. Burr. Have you, Col. any prejudice of a more settled kind and ancient date against me? Col. C. None at all.—Mr. Burr. He is elected.

The four jurymen that had been elected, were then called to the book, and sworn: viz. Messrs. Parker, Lambert, Mercer and Carrington.

28. Robert Haskins had expressed an opinion that Col. B. was guilty; but does not recollect to what extent he went. He might have said that he deserved to be hung.—Set aside.

29. William R. Fleming had formed and frequently expressed an opinion, that Col. B. was guilty of treasonable intentions; and might have made a general declaration, not only as to intentions, but to acts.—Set aside.

30. George W. Smith suggested a right to the same exemption, which had been granted to Mr. P. Randolph. The Court said that this privilege would be incontestible, unless the prisoner should urge his conflicting privilege. Mr. Burr then requested Mr. Smith to attend to-morrow. Mr. Smith wished to be excused, as he had some important business in another court to attend to: He should however attend on the trial to-morrow; but it might now be proper to state the general impressions which he had received from these transactions. He had generally been solicitous to avoid an expression of his opinions: and as in such cases, where the government commences a prosecution against an individual, there is always a preponderance of prejudice against him; he himself had not only been solicitous not to declare, but even to form an opinion. No one can however avoid reading representations of these things in the public papers; and he had formed and declared his impressions, that Col. B. had entertained designs offensive to the peace and laws of the U. States. What was the species of guilt, he had not pretended to define: but he had concluded from the newspaper reports and the testimony which he had heard in the other wing of the Capitol, that his designs was of a military nature; and that they might amount at least to a misdemeanor.—Suspended.

31. Armistead T. Mason had formed no deliberate opinion, in regard to the actual commission of treason. But it was his deliberate opinion, that Col. B. had designed if not to subvert the government, at least to divide the country—Suspended.

32. Dabney Minor had often said that Col. B's intentions were unfriendly to the U. States, but had received no positive testimony.—Some conversation here ensued between Mr. M. and Mr. Botts, when Mr. M. was suspended until to-morrow.

Of the whole Venire, then, that appeared, 4 only were elected and sworn; and 9 were suspended. The case of these last will probably be decided this day.

The Court then decided, that there was no necessity for delivering the jurymen who had been or should be sworn into the custody of the marshal, until the whole number had been impannelled.

Adjourned till Tuesday, 11 o'clock.

See the clipping

How Burr fought back

As the prosecution tries to prove an armed gathering on Blennerhassett’s island, Burr cross-examines a witness himself about the night muskets were leveled at a man trying to arrest Blennerhassett, and presses him on how his story differs from his own earlier sworn statement.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

TRIAL OF AARON BURR. (The examination on Wednesday, Aug. 19, continued.) Examination of Jacob Allbright. Mr. Hay. Our object is to prove by his testimony the actual assemblage of men on Blannerhassett's island. It goes of course to prove directly the overt act. Jacob Allbright. The first I knew of this business was; I was hired on the island to help to build a kiln for drying corn; and after working some time, Mrs. Blannerhasset told me, that Mr. Blannerhassett and col. Burr were going to lay in provisions for an army for a year.

See moreSee less

I went to the mill, where I carried the corn to be ground, after it had been dried. I worked four weeks on that business in the island.—Last fall (or in September) after Blannerhassett had come home—he had been promising me money for some time; but would pay me soon. Says he "Mr. Albright, you are a Dutchman." But he asked me first and foremost, whether I would not join with him and go down the river. I told him, I did not know what they were upon, and he said "Mr. Allbright, we are going to settle a new country." And I gave him an answer, that I would not like to leave my family. He said he did not want any families to go along with him. Then he said to me "you are a Dutchman, and a common man; and as the Dutch are apt to be scared by high men, if you'll go to New-Lancaster, where the Dutch live, and get me 30 or 40 men to go with us, I will give you as many dollars." I went home and gave him no answer upon that. In a few days after the boats came and landed at the island. The snow was about three inches deep, and I went out a hunting. I was on the Ohio side. I met two men; I knew they belonged to the boats, but I wanted to find out; and they asked me whether I had not given my consent to go along with Blannerhassett down the river. As we were talking together, they named themselves Col Burr's men, belonging to the boats, landed at the island. When they asked me, whether I had not consented to go down with Blannerhassett; I put a question to them. I told them I did not know what they were about; and one of the gentlemen told me, they were going to take a silver mine from the Spanish. I asked the gentlemen, whether they would not allow, that this would raise war with America. They replied, no. These were only a few men; and if they went with a good army, they would give it up and nothing more said about it. I had all this conversation with the two men. These men showed we what fine rifles they had; going down the river with them.—Then I went to the Island, and Blannerhassett paid me off in Kentucky notes. People however didn't like these notes, and I went over to the bank of Kenawha to change them. I got two of these notes changed; and one, a ten dollar note, was returned to my hand, for which I wished to get silver from Blannerhassett. I went to the island the day the Proclamation came out. But before I went to Blannerhassett's house I heard he was not at home, but at Marietta. I went on the Virginia side, where I met three other men, belonging to the boats, with three complete rifles. They made a call upon me, to take them to the island in my canoe, and I accepted (excepted) to it; but afterwards I carried the third man, who stood close by my canoe, over to the island. After being some time on the island, I went down to the four boats—Blannerhassett was not at home yet—and I met some of the boat-people shooting at a mark. They had a fire between the bank and boats. I waited at the house till Blannerhassett came home. He seemed very much scared. One of the men came up to ask him for something and he told him "Dont trouble me; I have trouble enough already." He went up to his chamber; and I saw no more of him. I asked an old gentleman to go up to his chamber, and change my note for silver. He did—and brought me silver. By man brought me silver. By and bye I heard that they were going to start that night.—Thinks I "I'll see the end of it." This was the night of the very day that Blannerhassett got back from Marietta. He got back before night. When night came on, I was among the men, and also in the kitchen, and saw the boat-men running bullets. One of them spoke out to the others, "Boys, let's mould as many bullets, as we can fire 12 rounds." After that, I saw no more till after 12 o'clock at night.—Then Blannerhassett came down from the chamber; and called up some of his servants; he had four or five trunks. There were not trusty hands enough to carry them to the boats; and some person called after my name, and asked me to help them: and I carried one of the trunks and moved along with them. When we got down, some person, I don't particularly know, but think it was Blannerhassett himself, asked me to stand by the trunks, till they were put in the boats. When the last of them went off, I saw men standing in a circle on the shore. I went up to them; perhaps they were five or six rods from me. The first thing I heard was, their laying plans how Blannerhassett and Comfort Tyler should get safe by Gallipolis. One Nahum Bent was called forward, and when he came, Blannerhassett asked him, whether he had not two smart horses. N. Bent answered no; he had but one. Then Blannerhassett told him to go to capt. Dennie, and get his sorrel horse; and N. Bent told him that the sorrel horse had no shoes on, and Blannerhassett said, the roads were soft and would not hurt the horse. Blannerhassett told N. Bent to meet him and C. Tyler with the horses some where about Gallipolis: Bent asked how he was to find him out: should he enquire for him? "No."—"Have you no friends there?" "No." Mrs. Blannerhassett then came forward and she told Blannerhassett and C. Tyler, that they must take a canoe and get into it before they got to Gallipolis, and sail down the stream of the Ohio; for no body would mind two people going down the stream. She said, she'd pay for the canoe. N. Bent was told to meet them above Gallipolis about day break, and then they might surround (go around) Gallipolis. Then a man by the name of Tupper, laid his hands upon Blannerhassett; and said: "Your body is in my hand in the name of the Commonwealth;" or such a word as that. As quick as Tupper made that motion, there were 7 or 8 muskets levelled down at him. Tupper looked about him, and said, "Gentlemen, I hope you will not do the like." A man next to me about two yards off, said, "I'd as lieve do it as not." Tupper then changed his speech, and said he wished him luck and safe down the river. Tupper before told Blannerhassett he should stay and stand his trial. But Blannerhassett said, no; the people in the neighbourhood were coming down next day to take him, and he would go. Next day after, I saw the Wood county militia going down—The people went off in boats that night about one. Q. All? A. All but one, who was a doctor. All had some kind of arms. Q. How many were there in all? A. About 20 or 30: I did not however count them. Every man I saw had arms. Q. At what time of the year was this? A. I do not recollect the particular time. I recollect the year; but not the month. Q. Do you recollect whether it snows in September? A. I do not recollect. Examined by the Counsel for the Prosecution. Mr. Wirt. Had you seen col. Burr on the island? A. Yes. Was he there before Blannerhassett went to Kentucky? A. He was. Q. Did you speak of the boats under the command of Tyler? A. I did. Q. Did the boats quit the island, at the time of hearing about the proclamation? A. Yes.—Mr. Burr. Did you see Peter Taylor converse with Blannerhassett that night? I do not recollect. Mr. Wirt. How long did A. Burr remain on the island? A. I do not recollect. Q. How long was he there before the departure of the boats? A. About 9 weeks. Cross Examined. Mr. Burr. Did you know gen. Tupper? A. Yes. Q. Is that the person? A. Yes. Q. When the muskets were levelled at him, did they seem to have a mind to hurt him? A. Yes: a gentleman near me said, "I'd as lieve shoot as not." You said differently on a former occasion. Don't you recollect saying before, it looked like exercising? A. I do not. A desultory conversation here ensued between the opposite counsels. Mr. Burr professed that it was his intention to degrade the witness by invalidating his credibility. The cross examination proceeded. Mr. Burr. Have you not been examined before? A. Yes. Q. By whom? By Mr. Jackson. Q. Had he not printed questions in his hand? A. he had a paper in his hand. Q. Did he set down your answers? A. Yes. Q. How long after the guns were pointed at gen. Tupper, before the men went to their boats? A. I do not recollect. Any thing that I am not certain of, I cannot speak to. Q. Was Mrs. Blannerhassett there, when the guns were pointed? A. Yes. Q. Was Tupper inside of the circle? Yes. Q. Was she too? A. I don't recoll[ect] too? A. I do'nt recollect. Q. Did you see Mr. Woodbridge there? A. I do'nt know him. Q. How long did you work with Blannerhassett? A. Six weeks. Q. At what time was it, that you saw me there? A. I do not recollect. Mr. Burr. The counsel for the U. S. know, I presume, this circumstance and have testimony to ascertain it. Mr. Hay. We have not, as I am informed. Mr. Burr. I will state that it was on the last day of August and the first of September, that I was on the island. Mr. Anthony (one of the jury). Did you see any powder? A. No. Mr. Hay. Were you in the boats? A. I was not. Mr. Burr. Where does gen. Tupper live? A. In Marietta. Q. Does he not belong to the state of Ohio? A. Yes. Q. When did you first know him? A. Last fall. Mr. Burr then asked the clerk for the statement, which he had taken of Allbright's testimony, when it was submitted to the court on a former occasion, on the motion for binding Mr. Burr in higher bail. The clerk handed him the copy, and the prisoner proceeded with the examination:—You said before, that the men who raised their muskets against gen. Tupper, were not in earnest? A. That was a piece of my opinion. I did not know whether they were not in earnest; as there was no quarrel among them, and no firing af- among them, and no firing afterwards. Mr. Burr. I beg the court to call on the prosecution for the deposition of this witness, taken before John G. Jackson. Mr. Hay. Can gentlemen, when they please, thrust their hands into my Port-Folio? Chief Justice was not satisfied, that the court had a right to call for the affidavit. Mr. Wickham said, it was obvious, that there were certain suspicions attached to the credibility of the witness; and that it was their desire to compare his present testimony with his former affidavit. Mr. Hay objected that Mr. Jackson might not have taken down the testimony of the witness in his language, but couched it in his own; hence there might be an apparent variation between the present evidence and the affidavit. Besides the witness might not have recollected a great many circumstances at that moment, which have subsequently occurred to his mind, since he was set to thinking upon them. Mr. Burr. We have a right to coerce this paper. If the gentlemen will not surrender it, I may at all events avail myself of their refusal.—My object is to prove such a diversity between the statements of the witness at different times, as may destroy all faith in his recollections. Mr. Hay. Then, sir, although I might retain this paper, the gentlemen are welcome to make all the use of it that they can. Take it. Mr. Burr then proceeded: Did you say that all in the circle had arms? A. All that I saw. Q. How many were in the circle? A. I did not count. Q. What kinds of guns had they? A. Rifles and shot-guns. Q. Did you see any guns with bayonets? A. I saw none. Q. When did you see most arms; in the day or in the night? A. I saw more of them in the day; but it was in the night that I saw most arms in their hands. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Why did you think, that most of them had arms? A. Because I was with them almost all night. In the day, I saw some of them shooting at marks; and I saw other arms at that time lying upon the beach. Mr. Wickham. Did you see them all with arms at once? A. No. Q. Did you know the gentlemen who had arms? A. No. Q. How then are you certain, that you did not see the same arms at different times in the hands of different persons? No positive answer. Mr. Burr. If gentlemen have now done with the witnesses as to the overt act, or when they have done, I will thank them to inform us; for then we shall have some considerations to offer to the court. Mr. Hay. We have other additional testimony to offer on this very point. Examination of William Love. Mr. Hay. Were you on Blannerhasset's island; A. Yes; but not there at the time when col. Tyler's boats arrived there. I was then at Marietta; and it was on Sunday that I went down in a skiff with two barrels of salt. Q. How many boats were at the island? A. Four. Q. How many men? A. I cannot tell you: but I suppose about, betwixt 20 and 25 belonging to col. Tyler's boats. Q. Did you see any arms? A. I saw the men had rifles.--I know that Mr. Blannerhassett took away with him two Blunderbusses, one pair of Horse Pistols, a pair of Pocket Pistols and a Dirk. Some fusees were put in the boat; but not more than 3 or 4. Q. And what arms had Tyler's men? A. Pistols, Dirks and Rifles they brought there; but not all were armed with Rifles. I know not whether they were armed with different things. Being as how, Mr. Blannerhassett's servant, that is his groom, I went down the river with him. Q. Did you see Taylor and Allbright there? A. I knew Peter Taylor very well and I saw Allbright. I saw Mr. Woodbridge too. Q. What time did you set sail? A. We were the last to embark; and we set off between 12 and 1. We parted with gen. Tupper in the greatest friendship Q. Did you see the prisoner on the island? A. I never saw col. Burr on the island. I first saw him at Natchez about two and an half years ago. Q. What took place after you left the island? A. That night was very cold. The next morning we stopt and made fires. Mr. Blannerhassett and col. Tyler went ashore and called the company together; and the best I could make out, was, that the governour of Ohio had uttered warrants against Mr. Blannerhassett and Tyler; and that they wanted to make their escape as fast as possible. I went down with the party to Bayon Pierre, where— Mr. Burr expressed a wish that the attention of the witness should be at present confined to the transactions on the island. Mr. Martin Gentlemen had better confine themselves to facts within the District of Virginia. When they travel beyond the District, we shall have some important questions to bring forward. We shall object the production of such evidence. Mr. Hay acquiesced for the present in this arrangement. Cross Examination. Mr. Burr. Were not some of Mr. Blannerhassett's clothes put up in the boats? A. Yes. Q. Were not his books put up in boxes and trunks? A. None; that I ever saw. Q. How long had you lived with Mr. Blannerhassett? A. Ten or twelve days. Q. How many guns had the party? A. I do not know. A great many of the men went a hunting. Q. Did you see any thing like military appearance? A. The men were in a state of preparation to defend themselves, because they expected people from the mouth of Kanawha to attack Blannerhassett and the island. And to the best of my opinion, they did not mean to be killed, without some return of the shot. It was said at Marietta, that the people of Kanawha were to attack him; and I suppose they would have done their best to resist. I should be sorry if a man slapped me on the face without returning the blow. Q. Was there no disturbance among the party on the island? A. None: I did not part with my friends in England, more comfortably than in parting with the people on the island. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Did you ever see all the men with arms? A. I cannot say. When I got to the mouth of Cumberland River I saw a chest of arms opened. Mr. Burr. Were any chests of arms put into the boats at the island? A. Not that I saw. They might have been put on board without my seeing them. Many things were put into the boats, before I got in. Mr. McRae. Was the chest which you see opened at the mouth of Cumberland, the same as those that you saw go from the island? A. No. Q. What did you think of this business? A. I understood the object of the expedition was to settle Ouachita lands. Mr. Hay. Were the persons who went from the island, young active men? A. Yes. Mr. Burr. What kind of looking men were they? A. They looked like gentlemen; such as live upon their own property. Q. Did they look like men used to work? A. they did not.--The witness added, that Mrs. Blannerhasset was at the boats when they started; and that the night was rainy and freezing. Examination of Dudley Woodbridge. Mr. Hay. Were you on the island when Blannerhassett's party left it? A. I slept there that night. Mr. Wirt. What party do you mean? A. I allude to the 4 boats, with Mr. Isreal Smith, Comfort Tyler and others. Q. Were you at the boats? A. I passed them about dusk. Q. Did you see any of the men? A. I saw 5 or 6 about the boats, and about 15 or 20 men together in one of the rooms of the house. Q. What do you conceive was the whole number? A. About 30. Q. Was it about dusk when you arrived there? A. It was. Q. Had they any arms in their hands when you saw them? A. No: I recollect no arms, but two pair of pistols on the bureau of the room where I slept; which were the room where I slept: which were gone in the morning. Mr. Hay. Will you inform us of what you know on this subject? Mr. Woodbridge. About the beginning of September or the last of August, Mr. Blannerhassett in company with col. Burr called at our compting-house at Marietta. I had been connected in commerial business with Mr. Blannerhassett for 6 or 8 years past, under the firm of Dudley Woodbridge, & Co. Mr. Blannerhassett observed, that col. Burr wished us to purchase a quantity of provisions.—Col. Burr went into the enquiry about the price of different kinds of provisions, and the expence of boats best calculated to carry those provisions up and down the river. After his making a number of enquiries and my giving him all the information that I could, he left a memorandum of such provisions as he wanted and of the boats that he wished to have built. They were to be on the Shenectady model; 10 feet wide and 50 feet long. This memorandum ordered 15 of them; but 10 only were completed. Q. What provisions were ordered? A. Pork, Flour, Whiskey, Bacon and kiln-dried meal were wanted; but no articles were to be purchased except the Pork, unless they came under certain prices. Next day I made contracts with col. Barker for building the boats, and proceeded to make arrangements for purchasing provisions. The boats were built up the Muskingum about seven miles above Marietta, and were to be brought down by the 9th of December. On the morning of the 9th, I saw 6 or 8 armed men going to take possession of the boats. I went down to Blannerhassett's island; but met Blannerhassett, Comfort Tyler, Smith and a number of men from Bel-Pre going up to take the boats; I informed them of the proceedings that morning at Marietta, and advised Blannerhassett not to go. They held a consultation and returned to the island. I returned to Marietta to get some necessary papers, and in the evening returned to the island. Mr. Hay. On what terms was the contract for the boats made? A. I made the contract for the boats with Mr. Burr. He wished to give me a draft on Ogden in New York, for payment. With this arrangement I had expressed myself dissatisfied, and Blannerhassett asked with some warmth, whether I doubted col. Burr's honour. After some altercation he consented to guarantee the draft; and to have it charged to himself, if Ogden did not pay it. The draft presented by Blannerhassett to me was payable on the 10th December. It was fi- December. It was finally paid by Mr. Ogden. Q. By the tenour of your contract, where were the boats to be delivered? At the island? A. At no particular place. But when col. Barker was bringing them down to Marietta, from about seven miles up the Muskingum; they were taken by gen. Buel as I understood, by the order of the governour of Ohio. Q. What occurrences took place on the island? A. I arrived at the island about dusk. I saw five or six men at the landing; and fifteen or twenty men in the rooms. I enquired for Mr. Blannerhassett and requested him to be told, that I had brought my papers and money to settle our accounts. After our accounts were adjusted, I wished to leave the island on that night; but Mr. Belnap turned me back. About 8 or 9 o'clock I retired to bed, where I remained; and as to what the witness says about seeing me out afterwards, he is mistaken. I was at the shore about 8 o'clock; but at Mr. Belnap's request, returned.— Mr. Wirt. In having these boats built, did you understand that they were built for Burr, or for Burr and Blannerhassett? A. It was not particularly specified. I thought there was very little distinction in the case, as Mr. Blannerhassett had secured the payment of them. As to these boats, Mr. Blannerhassett made some communication to me respecting their use. Shall I state these circumstances now to the court?--Early in September he mentioned to me that he had embarked in an enterprize with col. Burr; that gen. Eaton and some others were engaged in it. He observed, that their prospects were flattering; our first conversation lasted but a few minutes. The next week I was at the island, and he then went into further particulars; and the inference I drew from his remarks was, that his object was Mexico. I inferred it from the map which he shewed me of that part of the country, he spoke highly of that country; of its fertility and its healthiness. He asked me, if I had any disposition to join. I evaded his question; but could not forbear telling him that I thought my situation was better than a precarious one. Afterwards on his way up to Marietta he requested me to say nothing of the conversation which had taken place. Q. What articles did you furnish the prisoner? A. I purchased no other articles than pork, and this was afterwards sold by gen. Buel, as I understood by order of the government. As to the boats they were fitted up by order of the United States to convey certain troops from Marietta to St. Louis. Cross examined. Mr. Burr. Do you not recollect that I told you I had seen such boats used in the Mohawk river? and did I not complain of the clumsiness and inexperience of your ship-builders? A. You did. The boats were calculated for a shallow stream. Q. At what distance could Mr. Blannerhassett distinguish a man from a horse? ten steps? A. He is very near sighted; and when he reads, the book almost touches his nose. Q. Is he a military man? A. Not that I ever understood. Q. What became of his library? A. I understood that a part of it went down with M. Blannerhassett; the rest was left behind and perhaps sold. Q. What became of the draft on Mr. Ogden? A. It was paid; amounting to 2000 dollars. Q. How much pork did you purchase for me? A. About 100 barrels. Q. At what price? A. It was charged to you at 13 dollars. Q. What became of it? A. I had it stored in Mr. Green's cellar, adjoining to our store and it was afterwards sold by gen. Buel. Q. And when seized, whose loss did you consider it; your's or mine? The witness (smiling) I know not; it may hereafter become a dispute between us. Q. What were the boats estimated to be worth? A. The 11 boats amounted to 1200 or 1300 dollars. Mr. Martin. Were you on that evening at the water's side, in company with Mr. or Mrs. Blannerhassett? A. I was not. Mr. Wirt. You were asked, Sir, about Blannerhassett's military talents; permit me to ask you about his pecuniary resources. A. I gave him $6000 for his moiety of the profits of the stock: and there was besides about $3000 in stock. Q. What was his fortune worth? how much cash could he command? A. It was much less I think, than is generally supposed. He had $5 or 6000 in the hands of his agent at Philadelphia. His landed property on the island cost him about $50,000 a price which no man but himself or some one like him would have consented to have given. The improvements cost him about $10,000 more. Q. Had he no foreign funds? A. I think he had none. The funds which he owned abroad had been vested in the American funds. His property by his father amounted to £20,000, which he vested in 3 per cents. Exclusive of his property on the island, he was worth about $17,000 cash and 4 or 5 negroes, over and above what he owed. Mr. Wirt. Is he esteemed as a man of vigorous talents? A. He is.—It was the common opinion through the country, that he had every sort of sense but common sense. Mr. Burr. What are his favourite pursuits? A. chemistry and musick. Mr. Hay. Was not colonel Burr to have returned to the island? A. I believe so. I expected him to return in about two months, when his boats were to have been delivered. Mr. Lee. What was the size of the island? A. Blannerhassett owned 180 acres, which were about the half of it, and cost him $ 5000. Mr. Hay. Was not one of the boats fitted up for Mrs. Blannerhassett and family? A. One of the large boats was. Q. Which of the boats? A. One of the 11. Mr. Blannerhassett had taken a keel boat; belonging to the firm, up to col. Barker's, to be fitted up for the reception of his family. Col. Barker advised him to have one of the large boats fitted up; on account of its superiour accommodation. This was accordingly done. Mr. Hay. Had not the delivery of the boats been interrupted by the armed men, would not they have been delivered to Blannerhassett? A. I suppose they would have been delivered at Marietta. I considered for my own part that it would have made but little difference whether delivered to the one or the other; as Mr. Blannerhassett had guaranteed the payment. Mr. Martin. Was not the contract made by col. Burr with your firm? A. It was. Mr. Burr. Had I authorised you to deliver them to Blannerhassett? A. No. Mr. Hay. If delivered to Blannerhassett, would you not have considered yourself as delivering them to one of Burr's associates? A. I cannot say what I should have thought. Mr. Baker. Did you make any stay upon the beach, on the night of their departure? A. I did not; for I returned immediately to the house with Mr. Bellnap. Mr. Botts. Were the people peaceable on that night? A. Yes. Q. Did you hear any noise like that of war; the roaring of cannon or the rattling of small arms? A. None. Mr. Wirt. Did you hear any alarms about the militia? A. There was some in the evening. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Did you see the President's proclamation on that day? A. Not for three days after. We received it by the mail. Mr. McRae. Did you hear any thing of it before? A. I do not recollect. I believe a printer who had been at Pittsburg had bro't some information about the enterprise being stopped. The proclamation might have been sent on by a dispatch before the mail arrived.—Mr. Hay. Did you hear any thing of a state-warrant? A. No. I did hear that the legislature of Ohio was sitting with closed doors, with Mr. Graham before them; and that it was supposed they would suppress the enterprize. Q. Did you hear of any particular observations from any of the party on the island? A. I think that Comfort Tyler said, he would not resist the constituted authorities, but he had no notion of be- no notion of being stopped by a mob. Mr. Wirt. At the time he said so, was the legislature of Ohio understood to be in session with closed doors? A. It was. THURSDAY, August 20. Examination of Simeon Poole. I never was on the island on that time; but was opposite to it. I saw boats and men there; if I mistake not about the 10th December. I arrived opposite the island about dusk at the distance of about 150 or 200 yards from it. I do not know how many boats were there. I saw people walking about in the evening; and in the course of the night they built a fire, and I saw some persons by the light that appeared to be armed, and as if they were centinels. Mr. Hay. Why did you think they were? A. I don't know they were; but they appeared so to my view. I did not go over that night, nor did I offer to go. Boats were passing and repassing during the night, from the island to the mainland, which I supposed belonged to the island; not large boats but small craft. I did not speak to them.— I stood as much undiscovered as possible, as I was authorised by the governour of Ohio to apprehend Blannerhassett, and I went for that purpose. Q. Were there any indications of arrangements about a watch word? A. Yes. In the evening, I saw some boats crossed, when a particular word was given. When the people on the Ohio side wanted to go across, they would hail for a boat. The people on the island would ask, "what boat?" If the answer was I's boat, the boat immediately put off. Cross Examined. Mr. Burr. How long did you stay out that night? A. Perhaps till 10 o'clock. Q. Was it not cold enough to render a fire pleasant? A. It was. Q. Is it not usual for boats to build fires on the bank, when it is so cold? A. It is.—The witness also stated in the course of his examination, that there seemed to be a good many men on the island; that lanthorns were passing during the night between the house and boats, as if there was business between them; that he could not say, whether the persons, whom he had called centinels were not merely loitering around the fire; that he thought it likely, that if he too had used the watch-word, that the boats would have put off for him; that he he heard several hails from the Ohio side that did not give the word, and no boat came from the island, but a boat always came, when that answer was given.—He himself was on the Ohio side. Examination of Maurice P. Bellnap. Mr. Hay. Will you tell us, sir, what you saw on the island? Mr. Bellnap. On the evening of the 10th of December I was at the island of Mr. Blannerhassett. I arrived there between 8 and 9 o'clock in the evening. I hailed a boat and they asked my name. Having given it, a skiff was immediately sent over with two of Blannerhassett's servants.—Having crossed, I met with Mr. Woodbridge, who returned to the house with me. When I went into the house, I observed a number of men, who from the promiscuous view I had of them, might have been about 20. The 2 or 3 I noticed near the door had rifles, and appeared to be cleaning them. These were all the arms I saw: for I merely passed through the room where they were. Near the place where I landed, I noticed two or three boats and people about them. It was a dark evening and the lights in the boats was the only circumstance which made me notice them. When cross-examined, Mr. B. said, that he had given no watch-word, when he hailed, but only his name. He was not certain whether any person had crossed during the night. He saw Mr. Dana there, but does not know when he crossed. Examination of Edmund P. Dana. On the evening of the 10th December, I understood that the boats were to start, with Comfort Tyler and his men down the river. Two other young stood river. Two other young men and myself were determined to cross over from Bel-Pre, where I live. We went down to the landing opposite the island, about dusk; took a skiff and landed at the upper part of the landing. We then went to the house. Tyler's boats lay below our own about 7 or 8 rods. I heard some persons talking; but it was dark and I could not distinguish any one. We went into the hall, a large room, where there were a number of men; I remained but a short time and did not count them; but I suppose there were about 15 or 16: One of them was running bullets; and there was nothing but hub-bub and confusion about the large fire. I was then introduced into a chamber, where there were Tyler, Blannerhassett, Col. Smith of New-York, and several other gentlemen. I was introduced to Mr. Smith and Dr. McCastle, who had his lady there.—Col. Tyler, I had seen the day before. Mr. Coleman (a juror). Is it proper to ask any questions about the conversations which took place with those gentlemen?—Chief Justice. It is left to the consent of the accused. Mr. Burr. If any of the jury think proper, I can have no objections. The enquiry was not pressed. When cross examined, Mr. Dana said that he was ons. a perfect stranger to the people in the hall, but that on his going in they did not appear to be alarmed. FRIDAY, August 21. Examination of Israel Miller. Mr. Miller stated, that he had arrived on the island between the 7th and 10th Dec. last, in company with col. Tyler and Israel Smith; with 4 boats and 32 men, with 5 rifles and about 3 or 4 pair of pistols in all, that he knew of; that he had joined them at Beaver and gone down with them at Blannerhassett's island; and there I saw one blunderbuss, and two pair of Pistols. He saw but one man running bullets. Examination of Purley Howe. Mr. Howe stated, that he had not been on the island, during their stay; that he had been applied to by Blannerhasset to make 40 boat poles—and that on the evening of the 10th Dec. he went to the landing (Ohio side) to deliver them from his shop; that Blannerhassett had sent his flat to receive them, that the flat was left with a centinel, being two young men armed with rifles; that he flung the poles down the bank and offered to assist them; but they said they had men enough. One of his neighbours Mr. Allenwood wanted to go over in the flat; but they refused to take him, saying that they had orders to take no person from the Ohio side.—Mr. Hay. Did you see any more arms? A. None; but the two rifles in the hands of the two men. One of the centinels laid down his rifle at the bow of the boat, and stowed away the poles as handed in; while the other sat on the bow and laid his rifle on his lap.

See the clipping

Not guilty of treason

After reading the Chief Justice’s opinion, the prosecutor gives up: he has ‘neither argument nor evidence to offer to the jury.’ Twenty-five minutes later the jury returns an unusual verdict: Burr is ‘NOT proved to be GUILTY’ by any evidence, and so not guilty. His lawyers object to the wording, but the court lets it stand and enters a plain not guilty on the record.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR,

On Friday Mr. Martin resumed the discussion on the important motion before the court, and spoke 3 hours.

See moreSee less

On Saturday he continued his argument and spoke till 3; that is, 14 hours in all. He was followed by Mr. Edmund Randolph, who spoke till 5.

We intended to have commenced in this number our sketch of the argument of counsel on this question—but not being furnished in time with the notes of one of the counsel, and this argument assuming additional interest from the circumstance of its being almost certainly the concluding argument on the prosecution for treason, we have determined to reserve it for our next paper, to give it more correctly and in greater detail.

MONDAY, AUGUST 31.

This day the court met a few minutes after 11, and the Chief Justice was occupied until half after two, in delivering the opinion of the court, on the motion before it. The opinion was of course extremely elaborate and voluminous. We shall present a complete copy of it as soon as possible, to the public, and in the mean time they must be satisfied with the following statement of its principal and very interesting conclusions.

The following explanation will make those points more intelligible to our readers.

The counsel for Mr. Burr stopped the interrogation of Maurice P. Bellnap, who was examined on the 20th ult. and moved the court to exclude farther evidence upon this ground, that the accused was proved not to have been present at th[e] time of the overt act laid in the indictment.

In support of this motion they urged the following reasons:

1. That Burr not being present was merely an accessory, and not a principal, and therefore not punishable under the constitution and laws of the U. States.

2. That if he was a principal, he was a principal only in the 2d degree, where guilt is merely derivative, & that therefore no parol evidence could be admitted against him, until a record was produced of the conviction of the offender in the 1st degree.

3. That the fact must be proved as laid in the indictment, and evidence proving the accused to have been absent at the time of the overt acts is inadmissible to support the indictment charging him with the commission of that act.

4. That no parol evidence could be given to connect the prisoner with the men assembled on Blannerhassett's island, until an act of treason in these men was proved; and that the assemblage there was not an act of treason.

We understand that on the 1st point, the opinion of the court was, that a man might commit treason in levying war against the U. S. without being present at the time of the overt act alledged in the indictment. Being leagued in the general conspiracy and performing a part in it was deemed sufficient.

The court admitted the second and third propositions to be correct.

On the fourth point, the court gave a very long and a very elaborate opinion as to an overt act of levying war. The opinion delivered by the supreme court in the case of Bollman an Swartwout was declared not to be correctly understood—and that there must be, before an overt act of treason is completed, either the actual employment of force, or a military assemblage of men, who are in a posture of war.

As soon as the Chief Justice had concluded, Mr. Hay rose to observe, that the opinion just expressed by the court fur-

MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 7, 1807.

nished matter for the very serious consideration of the prosecution. As he had not very distinctly heard every part of the opinion, he hoped the court would allow him an hour or two for its more complete consideration. He requested also the use of the opinion for his more particular inspection. Some desultory conversation ensued on the possibility and propriety of printing it for the use of the court. This arrangement was however waved, when

Mr. Hay requested the Chief Justice to permit him to have the use of the paper itself. The latter expressed some doubts about Mr. Hay's ability to decypher it, but cheerfully conceded to the request.

Mr. Hay moved an adjournment of the court until Wednesday 12 o'clock, which Mr. Lee objected to, on account of the number of witnesses who were detained on the trial—and Mr. Randolph on account of the inconveniences to which it would subject some of the jurymen. The Chief Justice then proposed to adjourn the court till 6 o'clock this evening—by which time perhaps the counsel for the prosecution might determine on the course which they would pursue.

Mr. Wirt observed, that it would take at least till 6 o'clock to decypher the opinion.

C. Jus. We will adjourn the court till 6 o'clock, and if the prosecution are not ready, we may adjourn till a more distant time.

Mr. Burr. I would ask, if necessary, that the jury should in the mean time go more at large. This proposition was finally rejected.

The court adjourned at 6, without doing any thing.

Tuesday, 11 o'clock.

The court met at 10; when Mr. Hay addressed them: "I have looked into the opinion and have neither argument nor evidence to offer to the jury."

Ch. Justice. The jury may then retire—Marshal, conduct them out. The jury accordingly retired.

After an absence of 25 minutes. Col. Carrington their foreman, reported the following verdict indorsed upon the indictment.

"We, of the Jury, find that Aaron Burr is NOT proved to be GUILTY under this indictment by any evidence submitted to us. We therefore find him NOT GUILTY."

Mr. Burr and his counsel objected to entering this form of the verdict on the Record.

The court at length decided, that the verdict should remain on the indictment, and that the general verdict of not guilty, should be entered on the record.

Jonathan Dayton appeared. An affidavit was exhibited to prove that he was not at Blannerhassett's island at the time charged in the indictment; & he was accordingly discharged from it. He was then admitted to bail on the indictment for the misdemeanor in the sum of 10,000 dols. A Mr. Williamson of New Jersey and Luther Martin were his securities.

Mr. Hay informed the court that the counsel for the United States had not determined on the course which they should pursue; whether they should proceed to the trial of Aaron Burr on the indictment for a misdemeanor, or whether they should move the court to commit him for his trial in Kentucky, where an overt act is said to have been committed at the mouth of Cumberland river.

When the court adjourned to 12 o'clock on Wednesday, Mr. Burr observing that he should not move for his discharge till then.

See the clipping

‘Get them to desert’

On the motion to commit Burr, Blennerhassett and Smith, an army sergeant, Jacob Dunbaugh, swears Burr asked him to get ten or twelve of the best men from the garrison at Fort Massac: ‘get them to desert.’ He refused. He says that one night Burr and a man named Willie chopped away in Burr’s cabin, and he saw two bundles of arms, ‘about 40 or 43 stands,’ sunk on cords through holes at the gunwales of Burr’s boat.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 3 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. On the motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.

SATURDAY, SEPT. 19.

See moreSee less

Examination of Jacob Dunbaugh.

Mr. Hay. Will you describe the situation of the party at the mouth of Cumberland river? Witness. Am I to be confined to the Cumberland river?

Mr. Hay. You may go down to the Chickasaw Bluffs.

Mr. Botts. Go down to the Mississippi river; and whether you are to go further, the court will instruct you. Some desultory conversation here ensued on this point, after which the witness proceeded.

On the 26th Dec. 1806, very early in the morning, a small skiff with four men and a Mr. Hopkins, arrived at Fort Massac. Some time after the arrival of this skiff, captain Bissell (commandant at the Fort) detailed me for command to go to the mouth of Cumberland river, to purchase a beef for him. Q. What were you. A. I was and am still sergeant in the army of the U. S. He told me I was to call on colonel Burr with his compliments; and if colonel Burr wanted my assistance, that I was to furnish it. Capt. Bissell told me, this Mr. Hopkins, who came in the skiff with 4 men, was going up with me. When we got half way up to the Cumberland river, we stopt, and I asked Mr. Hopkins his business at Fort Massac, and he said it was to ask captain Bissell whether he would oppose colonel Burr's passing by the fort. I got to the mouth of Cumberland, about half an hour before sun set, on the 26th Dec. and landed: Col. B. was then encamped on Cumberland island. After I had crossed over to the island, I saw col. Burr and delivered capt. Bissell's message. Col. Burr said he was much obliged to him; and that captain Bissell was very good.

Col. B. asked me, "Is not this my old friend?" I had seen him before. He said he believed I drank no brandy; and asked me if I would not have a glass of wine. When I drank, I said "here's success to col. Burr and his undertaking;" and Mr. Blannerhassett (this was the first time I ever saw him) stamped his foot and said "Amen." Col. Burr told me that I must take breakfast with him next morning, I replied that I would. On the 27th I saw colonel Burr and told him, I was going to the garrison. He told me to bear his compliments to Captain Bissell, and asked me if I could take a barrel of apples to him. I told him I would. Whilst they were getting the apples on board, the wind sprung up very fresh, and I was not able to start. In the course of that day, I crossed him several times over to the Kentucky shore, and several of his men. During that day, Col. Burr asked me, how I would like to go down the river with him. I replied very well, if I could obtain the consent of my general. He said that that would make no odds. He would fix it without. This was on the 27th, and on the 28th, I called on Col. B. and told him I was going to Fort Massac. He sent his compliments to captain Bissell, but said he expected he would get there before me. I told him, that he might mann his barge as well as he could, I would arrive there before him. I arrived at the garrison some time in the afternoon.

Mr. Botts. There you may stop. It is impossible to progress without running into some impropriety, unless we ascertain the limits within which the witnesses are to be confined.

Mr. Hay observed that he did not mean to prove any acts at Fort Massac. After some conversation the examination proceeded:

Mr. Hay. Did you see any military parade? A. I saw the men drawn up at the mouth of Cumberland. Q. How many men? A. I did not count them; but I suppose there were about 100. Q. What kind of men? A. Generally young men.

Mr. Wirt. Did they look like hard laborers? A. The principal part did not. Q. How drawn up? Were they drawn up in a line? A. No: they were drawn up in three wings. Q. What do you mean by three wings? divisions? The witness here described their position, by drawing a figure on the floor with his foot. They described three sides of a square. Col. Burr was introduced by col. Tyler, beginning at the left. The party gradually fell in and formed a circle.

Mr. Hay. How introduced? A. He went around and shook hands with every man.

Mr. Hay. Did you see some chests of arms?

Mr. Burr objected to this manner of putting the question.

Mr. Hay admitted that he had put the question inadvertantly; he merely wished Mr. Dunbaugh to state what he knows of the chests of arms.

Mr. Botts. State what you know of any chests of arms within the U. S.

Witness. I did not see more than a few rifles at the mouth of Cumberland.

Mr. Hay. I think the court yesterday decided, that we were at liberty to state any circumstances out of the U. S which were explanatory of the acts done within the U. S.

On this topic a long and desultory discussion ensued. The Chief justice at length decided, that if an overt act be laid at the mouth of Cumberland river; if a military assemblage was said to be there assembled, that evidence beyond the limits of the states might be produced to shew the military attitude of the party; that with respect to this particular question, if the witnesses could show that no other arms were put on board, and if certain arms were on board at a certain place, it was some presumption that these arms had been at the mouth of Cumberland river; and that he understood it was the intention of the prosecution to show that this party were in such a state at such a place, that they might be able to infer that the party were in a similar state at the mouth of Cumberland. In this point of view, he conceived that such evidence was admissible.

Mr. Hay. State then, Mr. Dunbaugh, what you know on the subject. Did you leave Fort Massac with Colonel Burr? A. I overtook him at New-Madrid on the 1st of January. Q. Did you then go down the river with him? A. Yes, in his own boat.

Mr. Wickham repeated his objections to this kind of evidence. How was the witness to know, whether arms might not have been subsequently put on board the boats? He was not always in colonel Burr's boat; nor was col. Burr's boat with the rest. Can this be good testimony?

Chief Justice. The attorney is to shew that hereafter. He is to shew that there was no connection between the boats and the shore.

Mr. Wickham. But suppose that he has no testimony to that effect?

Chief Justice. Whether arms were subsequently introduced, is a more matter of inference, dependent on the whole of the evidence on both sides. It depends on a variety of circumstances, such as the situation of the shore and the country, &c.

Mr. Hay. State then, Mr. Dunbaugh, what you know about the arms on board the boats. Witness. Sometime in January, we left Bayou Pierre, and descended to Petit Gulph 3 miles below on the opposite side. Col. Burr went ashore, and returned to the Petit Gulph. The boats all shoved off at once; Col. B's. was rather behind. The night we left Petit Gulph, Col. B. and Willie came into the cow of the boat with an axe, auger and saw. They went into colonel Burr's private room and began to chop. He ordered no person to go out, but I did go out. I saw a skiff lying aside of colonel B's. boat. After they had done chopping, a Mr. Pryor, and a Mr. Tooley got out of the window. I got on the top of the boat, and saw two bundles of arms tied up with cords, and sunk by cords going through holes at the gunwales of Col. Burr's boat. I observed to Mr. Pryor, that he must be careful to bring up the boat, or else it could not get close to shore.

Mr. Hay. How many arms were there? A. There were about 40 or 43 stands. I saw besides, pistols, swords, blunderbusses, fusees and tomahawks.

Mr. Wirt. Is not the coast opposite to New-Madrid a part of Tennesse? A. No; it is the Indiana territory. Q. Were you on board any of the other boats? A. Several. Q. Did they keep together? A. They did, when they could. Q. Did you see arms in the other boats? A. I saw several stands of arms, that is, muskets with bayonets, in Floyd's boat; and about 12 rifles. Q. Were you near enough to colonel B. at the mouth of Cumberland to hear his observations to his party? A. I was. He said there were then too many bye standers to divulge his plans. Q. Were any men obtained, after you joined them? A. One, who got aboard at New-Madrid. Q. Were you commissioned by colonel B. to obtain men? A. No; not citizens. Q. What do you mean by the word "citizens?"

Here Dunbaugh was stopped by the opposite council, and his examination proceeded no farther on this day.

MONDAY, SEPT. 21st.

Continuation of Jacob Dunbaugh's Evidence.

Mr. Hay. State what passed between Col. Burr and yourself about your getting people to join him.

Witness. I stopt before with saying, that Col. Burr had not spoken to me to engage citizens: But he had spoken to me about soldiers. On the 30th of December, after Col. Burr had obtained captain Bissell's consent for me to go with him, I went to Col. Burr, where he was encamped, about a mile or two below the garrison at Fort Massac, on the Indiana side. Col. B. asked me into his cabin (a private room he had) and asked me if I could not get ten or twelve of the best men in the garrison to go along with him. I asked him how it was to be done. He said, "get them to desert." I told him no. He asked me, if I could not steal out of the garrison, arms, such as muskets, fusees, and rifles. I told him that I would not, if I could, for him or any other man on earth; that I had always been well treated by the officers of the army. I told him I had a rifle of my own; and he told me to bring it with me, and he would pay me for it. I started then to the garrison, and prepared myself to go; that was, after Col. B. I had obtained liberty of my captain. The counsel for the accused contended that this kind of testimony was not at all relevant to the subject. After some discussion, the examination proceeded.

At the mouth of Cumberland, Walter Davidson engaged a man by the name of Casey. Q. On what terms. Witness. I do not particularly recollect. Q. How do you know that Davidson was the agent of Col. Burr? Witness. He belonged to the party and told me he was an agent for Col. Burr. The substance of the engagement was; he was to receive twelve and a half dollars per month for six months, clothes and victuals for six months, and 100 acres of land, to fight against all opponents. This Mr. Davidson, Plumb, and Andrew Wood, were sent to New Madrid to enlist more men.—The witness here returned to that point in his narration at which he had been interrupted on his former examination. When I returned to Fort Massac, on the 28th December, I gave Col. Burr's compliments to capt. Bissell, and told him that Col. B. had sent him a barrel of apples. The next day, 29th, this Mr. Davidson, Plumb, and Andrew Wood, came to the garrison very early in the morning, in a skiff; this was the time when they told me that they were going to enlist more men for Col. Burr. They bought a skiff of me, that was left with me to sell by a Mr. Cutler, a surveyor, their own skiff was afterwards carried off by Col. Burr's party. That evening after sun down, a barge came down to Fort Massac with twelve men in it. Col. Tyler and Major Hill were in it, and I think also Major Smith. They went up to Captain Bissell's quarters, where they staid about 20 minutes; and I then heard col. Tyler tell the boat's crew to return to where col. Burr was encamped; with some other instructions, that I did not hear. Between 12 or 1 o'clock that night, col. Burr's boats passed by the fort, and landed about one or two miles below the garrison. (Mr. Hay. How many men were then in the garrison? A. 44 men. Q. Was that the usual compliment of men? A. No—some of the troops had gone to Newport, and some to other places. Q. Was there any artillery? A. None. Q. How wide is the river at that place? A. About a mile wide.) Next morning capt. Bissell told me to get six men with the clinker boat, to take him down the river a small piece. While the men were getting ready, a Mr. Fort, (perhaps his Christian name was John) who had been lying there several days, asked me how I would like to go along. I told him I should like it very well, if I could get leave to go. He told me he had been speaking to capt. Bissell the evening before, and that capt. B. had consented to let me go. While the boat was getting ready, capt. Bissell, col. Tyler, maj. Hill, and I believe maj. Smith, came down. Capt. B. got into his own boat; the rest pushed off in the boat that had been lying there several days, and fell down in company with him to where col. Burr was encamped. Capt. B. went into col. B's boat, and while there, col. B. asked him to let me go with him. I heard it, because though I was not in the same room, there was a thin partition between us, and I heard him ask capt. Bissell. I did not hear capt. Bissell's answer. Capt. B. came out, got into his own boat, and after going one or two hundred yards we landed and walked up to the garrison. 30th December, while I was in the military store, a man came in, who brought two letters from col. Burr. He gave capt. Bissell one, and the other to me. Capt. Bissell went out, and after I had done in the store, he called me, took me through the Sally Port, to the back of the garrison, and asked me whether col. Burr had been speaking to me about a furlough. I told him no. He asked me whether I wanted a furlough to go. I told him with his approbation and advice I would take one. Capt. Bissell said he would not advise me; but if I wanted one for 20 days, he would give me one. He told me, before the 20 days were out, I should see the general. He asked me if col. B. had told me any secrets, and if he had, that I must keep them to myself. I accepted of capt. B's offer, and he told me to get ready to go with col. Burr. I then went and saw col. Burr, and the conversation passed about the men and arms which I have already related. That evening (on the 30th Dec.) captain Bissell sent for me to his quarters, and told me he was going to advise me what I was to do; he advised me never to forsake col. Burr, that he would do something for me. He told me, that if ever col. B. got on a field of battle never to leave him on the ground. At the same time he made me a present of a silver breast plate. That evening I went to capt. Bissell's for my furlough. He gave me a furlough, with a letter to gen. Wilkinson, to be delivered by col. Burr. Col. B. had then started, and I was to give him the letter as soon as I overtook him. On the 31st Dec. being the day for muster and inspection, I asked capt. B. if I was to shew my clothing; I said they were all packed up and on board. He told me I must borrow some for inspection, which I accordingly did, agreeably to his orders. Whilst the men were on parade, I went to his lady's quarters to take my leave, and on my return capt. Bissell having brought the men to a ground.—He told me, "Dunbaugh, I wish you success, let you go where you will." I wanted to see Dr. Tuttle before I went, and capt. B. told me, if I had no particular business, I had better go on, and if any one asked me where I was going, I was to say, I was only going a few miles down the river, and that I was coming back again. There was one of col. Burr's boats with eight hands to take me to him.

We overtook col. B. on the 1st Jan. at New Madrid. I handed him the letter for gen. Wilkinson, and he broke it open. I told him the letter was for gen. W. He asked pardon, took me into his cabin, and sealed it up. I asked him what boat I was to go in, and he said in his own; as its accommodations were better than in any other. We left New Madrid about 11 or 12 o'clock that day, (1st Jan.) Andrew Wood remained at New Madrid, and Plumb and Walter Davidson, who had been sent on to enlist men, got on board the boats—and Mr. Hopkins was left in their places to enlist. After we got into the stream, a keel boat came alongside, and took col. B. into another boat some hundred yards off. I saw him on the bow of the boat, giving some instructions, but I could not hear him. Major Floyd had charge of this keel boat and crew; and I understood they were instructed to be at Natchez in four days. When we got within 45 miles of the Chickasaw Bluffs, col. Burr asked me if I would go ahead with him to C. Bluffs, in a small boat, as I was acquainted with the river. I told him I would. We got into a small boat with 12 more men, and he gave general orders to the other boats to follow on, so as to reach the Bluffs early next morning. We got there between twelve and one o'clock that night, (3d Jan.) After we landed, col. B. told me, I must go up to the garrison, and ask the commanding officer, if he could not get quarters, that night for himself and men. When I arrived at the garrison, I was conducted to lieut. Jackson's quarters. He returned his compliments, and said he would furnish them with lodgings. Col. Burr went up with some of his men and supped.—The next morning col. B. asked me, if I was acquainted with the men in the garrison. I told him I was. He asked me, if I could not get 10 or 12 of the best men to desert. I told him, I would not. He then said, he would speak to them himself, and get 2 of the best men, and asked me to name them; which I did. (Upon being interrogated, the witness said, there were 19 men in the fort; few pieces of cannon; and the river about as wide as at ft. Massac.) Some time in the afternoon, I asked col. B. if he had got the men to go with him. He said he had. Sometime that evening he told me that lieut. Jackson and the other men would follow in a few days. That day col. B. employed a man, one Skinner, to run him some musquet balls. He run him 600; for which col. B. paid him one dollar. He bought 3 dozen Tomahawks out of the factory, which col. B. distributed among his men; some he had helved. That day all the boats landed at the Bluff, and on the 5th they all started, except a small boat left for col. B. He soon overtook us, and got into his own boat. No one came from the garrison with him. We proceeded to a place called Palmyra, 35 miles above Bayou Pierre, on the 10th January. Col. B. again asked me, if I would go down to Bayou Pierre with him.

Mr. Wickham asked the court, whether the witness should proceed. How was this kind of testimony calculated to prove the overt act? How was it relevant to the charge? Was it not better for gentlemen to extract whatever they deemed material out of the witness by putting interrogations?

Mr. Wirt. The witness was just coming to certain declarations of the accused, which directly related to the objects of this expedition. When he has arrived at Bayou Pierre, and is about to tell something that is important, he is stopt.

Ch. Justice wished the attorney to put interrogatories.

Mr. Hay. Did you ever get out of col. Burr's boat to go into another? A. Never, except at Chickasaw Bluffs and Bayou Pierre, when I went with col. B. at his particular request. Q. Did you go ashore at judge Bruin's? and state what happened there. The counsel for the accused objected to this general interrogatory.

Ch. Justice. Ask him whether any thing happened there respecting this expedition.

Mr. Hay. Perhaps the witness may omit facts, because he deems them unimportant, which I may consider extremely relevant. Did any thing happen at judge Bruin's respecting a publication? and state what it was.

Witness. On Sunday 11th January, while we were 3 or 400 yards from the shore, col. Burr told me to arm myself with a rifle and conceal a bayonet under my clothes. He told me he was going to tell something I must never relate again. He then told me that gen. Wilkinson had betrayed him; that he had played the devil with him, and had proved the greatest traitor on the earth. I told him I could not believe it, and asked him how he knew it. He said he had seen published in a paper a letter, which he had some time before written to gen. Wilkinson in cyphers.—He mentioned that general W. had made oath to this letter before the court or in open court, I do not recollect which—He then told me he was fearful of being injured or taken; that I must keep a good look out about judge Bruin's—Col. Burr went into judge Bruin's to breakfast; and I went into the cotton gin that was near the house. A boat came, & he told me to take a spy glass and see whether it was his boat. I could not determine—He then directed me to go down, and if it was his boat, to fire a musket. Q. Where is judge Bruin's? A. About a mile and a quarter below Bayou Pierre.

Mr. Wirt. Where did he say he had seen the paper? A. The paper had been handed by judge Bruin to col. B. the evening before. Q. What was the conversation at judge Bruin's? A. col. Burr asked him, if he had any papers; he handed him this paper; and after reading 15 or 20 minutes, he rose up and said he must go to the boats.

Mr. Hay. Did the troops from the boats land there? A. Yes. Q. With what view did the men go on shore below the mouth of Bayou Pierre? A. They landed about 2 or 3 miles below in the Louisiana territory. The opposite counsel objected to these questions; but were overruled by the court.

Mr. Hay. State what happened at the landing of the men.

Witness. Some days after the men landed (they all landed) col. B. ordered ground to be cleared for a parade ground, for the purpose of exercising the men—but I never saw the ground myself, nor the men exercising. Some of the men however are here—Dr. Munholland is one of those men who assisted in clearing of the ground. There was a guard of 12 men paraded at this place. Wyllie for one had a rifle and sword.

Mr. Wirt. Were there any Indians at that place? A. None. Q. What produced this guard? A. They understood that the militia were coming to take col. B.—and those 12 men were placed to alarm the boats. Q. Was this before or after sinking the muskets? A. It was before. The witness, upon being further interrogated, deposed that a Mr. Lemaster had taken potatoes out of a hhd. then in Mr. Bl. boat, a barrel of potatoes, with which he said he was going to fill the box of arms, so as to make it appear like a box of potatoes; that he was asked in the presence of col. Burr to go and help to clear the ground; that col. Fitzpatrick came to take an inventory of all the goods and arms that he could see; but that he did not see col. F. search for the arms.

Mr. Burr. Where was I all this time? A. I know not; but I saw you handing 2 or 3 muskets out of the cabin window of your own boat into Mr. Blannerhassett's boat. The witness further stated, that the arms which were sunk were sunk between Petit Gulf & Coles's creek; that Burr was looked upon as the commander in chief of the expedition; that in the night his boat was distinguished by two lanterns, placed one above another, whereas the rest had but one—and that in the day time handkerchiefs were hoisted in some of the boats by way of flag.

Cross examined.

Mr. Burr. You say your furlough was for 20 days? A. It was. Q. After the expiration of this furlough, were you not advertised as a deserter? A. I was. Q. Were you taken up? A. I was not. Q. When you got to Baton Rouge, did you write to general Wilkinson? A. I did. Q. What did you write? A. That my furlough had been taken from me; and that if he would send me a furlough or a pardon, I would come on in three days. Q. Did you promise to give any information against me? A. I did not.

Mr. Wirt observed, that he was authorised by general Wilkinson to say, that he had the original furlough given by capt. Bissel.

Mr. Martin. Did he send you a pardon? A. General Wilkinson wrote to me to come down. Q. Have you that letter? A. No. It was taken from me at Baton Rouge. Governor Folk has it at this moment. Q. Did you write to captain Bissell? A. I did. I mentioned to captain Bissell, that as both of us might be injured by this transaction, if he would say that he had sent me as a spy, it would clear both him and myself. Q. When were you discharged from the army? A. I was not discharged in 1805, when I travelled with you. Q. Why were you discharged? Show your hand to the court. A. There is my hand (one of the fingers appeared to have been injured.) I can shew my discharge. I procured a substitute, and many have liberty to procure them.

Mr. Hay. Hand me the discharge; the witness accordingly presented it.* Q. Did you come round with general Wilkinson? A. I did. Q. Were you subpoenaed? A. I did not know I was. Q. Who requested you to come round from New Orleans? A. I came by request of general Wilkinson. Q. Did he say for what? A. He said as a witness. Q. You gave a deposition in New Orleans? A. Yes. Q. At whose request? A. At general W's. Q. When I came down the Mississippi in 1805, by whose orders did I have the men? A. I thought, by Gen. W's. Q. Had they arms? A. I think not. Q. Had they colours? A. They had, and they were flying every day. Q. Did you not tell me, you expected your discharge? A. Yes. Q. Do you not know that the soldiers at Chickasaw Bluffs wanted to go with me; and I refused them. A. I recollect that you wanted me to get them to go, but I refused. Q. Did you not tell me that some of them wanted to go? A. I mentioned 1 or 2. Q. Did any go? A. No. Q. Why? A. You told me that the lieut. and all would follow in a few days.

Mr. Wirt. This previous voyage you took the year before—were they not troops of the U States? A. They were. Q. These soldiers; were they going where their company was? A. The whole company were going to New Orleans and this barge with ten men, was sent on ahead. Q. And this flag belonged to them? A. It did.

Mr. Wickham. Were they regimental colors? A. They were colors made for the barge.

Chief Justice. Did you tell captain Bissell, that col. Burr had applied to you to get the men to desert? I did not.

Mr. Wirt. Did you not reject the proposition? A. I did. At the request of the Chief Justice the witness here described the particular manner in which the arms were sunk. He said that they were so deep in the water, as to prevent the boat from going within 50 yards of the shore. He also related his visit to Judge Bruin's, where col. Burr got the newspaper. He also stated at the request of the court the contents of his letter to general Wilkinson; that if he would send him the furlough which lieut. Roney had taken from him or a pardon, that he would be there in three days. General Wilkinson informed him, that he had behaved very wrong in leaving the man he was going down with; but if he would come down he should not be molested.

Mr. Wirt. Where did the party break up? A. A few miles below Coles's creek. Q. How far is Coles's creek from Bayou Pierre? A. About 25 miles. Q. When was it that this parting speech was made at Coles's Creek? A. About 6th or 7th of February.

* The discharge states, that "having served three years and 6 months, and being permitted to procure a substitute in his place (J. D.) is hereby discharged."

See the clipping

Blennerhassett confides in the wrong man

John Graham, then secretary of the Orleans Territory, says Blennerhassett at Marietta took him for one of the party and talked of boats and armed young men; Graham told him he was a government agent. In the Mississippi Territory, Burr seemed to ridicule separating the Union by physical force: ‘it was to be produced by moral, not physical causes.’ On invading Mexico, he said ‘perhaps, when they had a separate government, something of that sort might be attempted.’

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 3 other papers

The Enquirer · 3 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

MR. JOHN GRAHAM.

In the latter end of October last, I received a letter from Mr. Madison, requesting that I would pass through the Western country, on my return to New-Orleans.—I know not whether it be proper to assign to the Court the reasons of this wish. It may serve however to explain my conduct in the Western country.—Mr Madison stated to me, as a reason of this request, that government had received information from various quarters that a project was on foot to sever the Union or to invade the territory of Spain.—Mr Wickham objected to this explanation.—Witness. It was to show that I had acted in obedience to my duty as an officer of the government. Mr Wickham. What office did you hold? a. I was secretary of the Orleans Territory.—When I arrived at Marietta, about the middle of November, I made enquiries and heard what it may not perhaps be proper to state—Mr Duval called on me and informed me that Mr Blennerhassett had just arrived with him and would wait upon me. After passing the usual compliments and expressing his pleasure at seeing me, he begged leave to read to me certain letters which he had received by Captain Elliot of the Western country, who had just returned from Pittsburg. Mr Blennerhassett made many enquiries relative to Comfort Tyler, Dean and Butler, and the preparations which they were making for their expedition down the river; what number of men and settlers they had obtained. Mr Elliot gave him to understand that there would be more settlers than there would be boats for them. When Blennerhassett received this information, he observed that they could descend in his boats, as he had more boats than men. Before Captain Elliot quitted the room, Mr Blennerhassett handed me a letter, which he said he had received a few days before from Col Burr in Kentucky. Shall I state my recollection of the contents of that letter? Mr McRae. Do you believe the letter to have been Col Burr's? a. I believed it was Col Burr's writing; for though I had never seen Col Burr write, yet I had seen many letters said to be written by Col Burr. I merely mention this letter to show that it gave rise to a conversation between Mr Blennerhassett & myself, relative to the contents of this letter. The conversation was somewhat desultory; nor do I particularly recollect the order in which the several topics were introduced. In general I recollect, that Mr Blennerhassett animadverted upon the conduct pursued towards Col Burr at Frankfort; stating however his belief that this conduct was not authorised by the government. He mentioned that Col Burr had purchased from Col Lynch, I think, a certain part of the Baron Bastrop's grant in the Territory of Orleans. He stated also that he was to have an interest in this purchase, and seemed desirous of impressing on my mind a belief, that the object of his preparations was the settlement of this land, but I cannot now recollect that in the course of conversation he did positively avow it. His object seemed to be to avoid an explicit avowal; but he said, that they avowed that this was their object; that it was a legal one, and government would have no right to interfere, until it was ascertained, that they (meaning Col Burr and himself, as I understood) had an ulterior object. He contended that they had a right to go towards this object with just such preparations as they thought proper. This was an opinion in which I did not acquiesce. I made few enquiries; but he admitted in the course of conversation, that he was building boats for the expedition in which he was engaged with Col Burr; that he was engaging young men, single and without families to go down armed; he said they would have no cannon, but they would have rifles. He stated in the course of conversation, the use to which these rifles might be applied: to resist the Indians and Spaniards, or to kill game. It is justice to Mr Blennerhassett to add, that he said, he did not solicit men to go; that he took such only as pleased to go; and that he did not expect more than 300 men would go with him. He stated also that he was engaging provisions for this same expedition. From what I had heard after my arrival at Marietta, and from the manner in which Mr Blennerhassett entered my room and made these communications, I was rather induced to believe that he conceived me to be one of the party. q. Why from his manner? a. My acquaintance with him before was slight; and yet he was extremely polite to me; and expressed how happy he would be at seeing me in his own house. For reasons which it is unnecessary to take up the time of the court with, I was anxious to undeceive Mr. Blennerhassett. I asked him, if he had stated that I was one of the party. He said, that he had; and that he had understood so from Colonel Burr.—When I assured him, I was not, he expressed considerable surprize, not by verbal declarations but by the marked air of his countenance. He observed to me that I did not know Col Burr, and passed some eulogiums upon him; and asked me in a very impressive manner, whether I had not heard of an Association in New-Orleans for the invasion of Mexico. I told him, that I had not, and I ventured to assure him, that there was no such Association there. He told me, that there certainly was, and that about 800 men had signed to such an Association, I think that was his expression, for the purpose of invading Mexico. After I had repeated my thorough conviction, that there was none such, and assigned the fact of his being deceived about me as a presumptive reason why he should be deceived about others, he told me that he had obtained this information from Mr Bradford.

See moreSee less

Considering Mr Blennerhassett at that time as a deluded man, I endeavored to draw him off from the undertaking in which he was engaged; and considering that it was more the policy of the government to prevent than to punish such enterprizes on the Ohio, I informed him, that so far from being concerned in the plan, I was an agent of the government, authorised to enquire into the facts relative to this enterprize in the Western country, and to take such steps as might be necessary for repressing it. I then stated to him, from reasons drawn from Col Burr's visit to New-Orleans in the preceding summer, from the information which government had received, and from the nature of the preparations which Mr Bl. himself was then making, why I believed that the object of Col B. was either to attack the territories of the United States, or those of Spain. I assured him at the same time, that any collection or combination of armed men on the Ohio, would under these circumstances be considered as a violation of the laws and repressed accordingly. He again contended that they had a right to go down the river, as they thought proper, inasmuch as they avowed the settlement of the Ouachita which was a legal object. Though we could not agree on this point, he asked me whether there would be any objection or opposition made to those men, if they went down in small parties. I gave him to understand, that this would depend upon circumstances, but that when they were collected, they would be arrested, and the enterprize would end in the ruin & disgrace of all those who were concerned in it.

During this conversation, I stated to Mr Bl. pointedly, that I knew not the opinions of Mr Jefferson or Mr Madison; that these were my own opinions; and that I had power to act, under the government of the United States, as circumstances required; that I was authorised to call on the constituted authorities of the country, if the constitution was about to be violated. I wish the court to understand, that I was to consider the moving down the Ohio, as a violation of the law, and I was then to call on the constituted authority. When I spoke of the reasons which influenced my belief as to Col B's plan, Mr Blennerhassett observed to me, that however acute the opinions of gentlemen might be, he and Col Burr were as well acquainted with the constitution and the laws as the administration itself; and that they knew very well what they were about. q. What produced this remark? a. I do not recollect, but perhaps it may have been the arguments which I had used to show that the expedition was a violation of the laws. Mr Bl. said, that he had joined his friends in this undertaking and could not abandon them, unless they consented to give the thing up; and asked me, if he was at liberty to communicate to Col B. the information I had given him. I told him, he was. I do not recollect, whether I have mentioned the opinion I expressed to Mr Bl. of the validity of Bastrop's Grant. I told him all that I knew of the title and that Col B. would have no title to it; and that if he had, the Orleans land could be no object with Mr Blennerhassett. Mr Wirt. How came you, sir, informed about this title? a. I had been at New-Orleans, where the subject was much talked of. q. Have there been any judicial proceedings about it? a. I told Mr Bl. that Mr Lynch claimed under Mr E. Livingston; that this was a considerable purchase; and that Mr Livingston had invalidated this contract in court. Mr Burr. I deny that this is a fact.

The next day, perhaps that afternoon, I met Mr Bl. at another house, in company with gentlemen most of them strangers to me. Mr Bl. was speaking & avowing, that Mr Burr had a great many friends in Kentucky. I observed, that this would much depend upon his object; if to settle Ouachita lands, that the people would wish him well; but if it was to attack the Territories of Spain or those of the United States, he would have very few friends. In reply, Mr Blennerhassett observed, that whatever was his object, he either had or would have a great number of friends. This was in a public room, in a tavern; several gentlemen were present; I recollect particularly a Major Sproat.—Either on that evening or the evening of the next day, Mr Blennerhassett said, he was writing to Col Burr. He invited me to his room, and wished to know how much of our conversation he might communicate to Col Burr. I told him, the whole if he chose; that the information was intended for him, but that he might communicate it to Col Burr. During this time and for a few days afterwards, the intercourse between us was friendly; but after I had had a conversation with Mr Henderson, I had no farther communications with him, save dining with him one day at the same table, and he rose immediately after dinner; and I did not see him again until we met in the Mississippi Territory.

Mr. Hay. Had you any communications with Mr. Burr? A. I had; and in the Mississippi territory too.—In consequence of the information I had received from Mr. Henderson and others, I lodged information with the Governor of Ohio, and a law was passed, and I was also instrumental at Frankfort in Kentucky, in the passage of a similar law. Their object was to put an end to these expeditions.

When I arrived at the little town of Washington in the Mississippi T. about the latter end of January or beginning of February, I heard that Col Burr was in the house.—Mr. Hay. Where is Washington? on the Mississippi river? A. No; It is 10 miles from it: and 7 miles back of Natchez. It is the seat of government of the Mis. territory. I waited on col. B. principally with a view to ascertain whether the information I had given to Mr. Bl. had been communicated to him. I asked him, whether Mr. Bl. had communicated our conversation to him. He said that he had.—I told him on entering his room, that I had just arrived from the Upper Country, and perhaps he might be anxious to hear the news. He told me that Mr. Blennerhassett had accused me of a breach of hospitality. I replied, that I never was in his house in my life. He spoke of his protested bills drawn in Lexington, and seemed to attribute their protest to the measures adopted by the government. I told him that just before I left Lexington, the merchants there had received information that they would be paid. He said that they ought to be paid, as the man on whom they were drawn, had the funds to pay them with. He then spoke of the measures pursued by government as ruinous and rigorous (I am not certain which was his expression); that they had detained his people. (Q. Was this before or after his trial? A. It was before; he had then entered into recognizance.) He said, that he had invited investigation into his conduct; he spoke of the measures of the military, and his determination to resist them: I understood him to mean the military of the U.S.; he either said he had or that he would order his people to resist them. He said, that he had claimed the protection of the civil authority, & thought that protection would be adequate to his safety. He spoke too of the Ouachita settlement; I believe, he told me that he should send his people there, but did not know whether he should venture into the territory himself; intimating, as I thought, an apprehension of gen. Wilkinson. He asked me, if I knew, what had given rise to the President's Proclamation. I told him, that I did not; unless it was gen. Eaton's communication.—The Court will see from the date of the Proclamation, that any information I could have imparted had not then reached the seat of government. Col. Burr observed, that the machinations of his enemies had led to these proceedings; and that facts did not support and justify them. I assured him that those who were alarmed and agitated were not his enemies; at least this was the idea I intended to convey; and after stating to him the alarm extending through the Western Country, I proposed to him, that he should make some public declaration as to his real object. His reply to this was, that he was a party concerned and that no declaration of his could have any effect. He seemed disposed to ridicule the idea of his bringing about a separation of the Union by physical force; that it was to be produced by moral, not physical causes. I mentioned to Colonel Burr that I had heard in the Western Country of a considerable number of men, perhaps 2000, being collected for the purpose of invading Mexico. His reply was, that he supposed that event was in case of a war with Spain. I told him, no; that I had not understood it as depending on that condition. He then said something about the Ouachita lands; and replied, that perhaps, when they had a separate government, something of that sort might be attempted (meaning, as I understood, the invasion of Mexico.) Soon after this, or at least before I had heard any explanation of what he meant by "a separate government," a gentleman of his family came in, and I took my leave.—I had no farther conversations with Mr. Burr or Mr. Blennerhassett.—I lodged an information against Mr. Blennerhassett, and was with him before a magistrate.

Mr. Hay. Did you make particular observations to Mr. Bl. about the sort of preparations he was making? A. He spoke of the settlement of the Ouachita as their object. He never positively told me it was, but he said they avowed it as their object. I observed to him, as a reason why I should not think it was, that young men without families or without any of the implements of husbandry were engaged to go: He said that their arms were to kill turkies or Indians. He then launched out into an abuse of the administration, their neglect of the army & navy, &c. I forgot to state this circumstance. When Mr. Bl. met me to know how far he was at liberty to communicate my opinions to col. Burr, I urged to him the impropriety of his engaging in these objects; he said it was impossible that col. B. could have so much deceived him and his son-in-law, Mr. Alston. Mr. Wirt. Was this remark after you had announced yourself as the agent of government? A. It was. Mr. Wirt. Did he say any thing to your objection about the want of implements of husbandry? A. He did say something about the opening of roads. But he never did tell me the real object. Q. Do you know any thing of the Ouachita land? A. I never was on it. Q. What is its character? A. Some say it is good and some say it is bad. I believe the greater part of it is covered with water; and there is some very fine land.

Cross Examined.—Mr. Burr. Did you ever see Bastrop's patent? A. Never. Q. Did you read it? A. No; I always understood, that there never was one. Mr. Burr. You have said that the greater part was water; I will assure the court, that it was to be laid out without any water. Were you ever examined before? A. Yes; I made a deposition, when I lodged information before the Legislature of Ohio. Q. Were you examined on any other occasion? A. I was before the Grand Jury. Q. Did you say any thing then of a conversation you had with Gen. Neville? A. Yes. I told Gen. Neville that I had come to make some enquiries into this affair. Gen. N. informed me what had passed in his conversation with the Mr. Morgans. He said the people had apprehended that your object was the separation of the U. S.; but that if it was the invasion of Mexico, you would be better received on your return than you ever had been. Q. Did you not then speak of the boats? A. I did. Q. Did you not say, they were unfit to go up the stream? A. I so understood at that time. Q. Do you not know that they were seized by government to send troops up the stream? A. I did not hear of it before I came here. Q. Did I give you a welcome reception? A. I was not acquainted with your manner. It was cold, but I thought respectful. Q. Have you not heard Gov. Williams, Mead, and Rodney say, that they would not suffer the military to take me? A. I most certainly recollect, that I both thought and said that it was improper to take you by military authority; & I heard Gov. Williams say, if the attempt was made, he was not authorised to sanction it. Q. Had you not heard of the stipulations made to me by Williams and Mead? A. I knew not of Gov. Williams's stipulating with you. I heard of Mr. Mead's doing it. Q. Was there no law to arrest me? A. I mentioned to Gov. W. that if the laws were not sufficiently energetic to meet such occurrences, it was better to provide one. But I never saw the law. Q. Did you not hear of an officer being there to arrest me? A. I had a conversation with a Lieut. Peter, who was lately in this place, relative to this subject. The counsel for the prosecution objected to this course of examination. Ch. Jus. If Mr. Burr means to allege these measures as an excuse for his own military preparations, he may press these enquiries. Mr. Burr. I did suppose from the sort of duties which Mr. Graham discharged in that country, that he must have known of the stipulations of Meade and Williams, and that in direct violation of these, a party of officers in disguise (that is without their uniform) and with concealed weapons, as dirks and pistols, were there to seize me. Mr. Graham certainly knows something on this subject. Mr. Graham. I can speak of my conversation with Gov. Williams and Lieut. Peter, for with no others did I communicate on this subject. Gov. Williams told me, that a Dr. Carmichael had been authorised to come to the Mississippi Ter. and seize you; whether this was before or after your trial, I know not. He said that he was extremely unwilling to have any such thing done. I observed that it was extremely improper to suffer a person to be seized, who was then in the custody of the law. He said that he had remonstrated with Dr. Carmichael; that Dr. C. had given it up and returned. Mr. Burr. Did C. belong to the army? A. No: to the Mis. Territory. I was proceeding to state that the night Col. Burr left Washington, I heard some of the officers in the room, in which I slept conversing about him, and one of them observed that if Col. B. was not arrested on that night, he would make his escape. The gentlemen left the room, and I afterwards understood from Lt. Peter, that an application had been or was about to be, made to Gov. Williams for permission to arrest Col. Burr. Lt. Peter having understood that I had heard part of this conversation, informed me that he had come with other officers to arrest Col. B. and I advised him to do nothing that would violate the laws of his country. He gave me to understand, that at that moment he felt himself bound to obey the orders of his General, like a good soldier. I urged every consideration I could suggest against the exercise of military authority; and I did then understand, that it was not his intention to proceed against Col. Burr. Indeed I understood that Col. B. had made his escape. I advised Gov. Williams to make such arrangements with him as would send him on to Washington for trial, or to detain him in that Territory for trial?

Mr. Blennerhassett. You stated that you had given information against me, and led to a prosecution? A. I did not say that I had led to a prosecution; but only that I had given information against you, that you might be taken to the district where the expedition had been fitted out. Q. Why did you prefer Judge Toulman to Judge Rodney; the last being the senior judge? A. I made no choice.

Q. Did you not understand that Judge Toulman was the judge of the Tombigbee county? A. I understood that he was judge of the Mississippi Territory, and Judge T. still insists upon it that he possesses this authority. Q. Did you not apply to the Attorney General of that Territory? A. Certainly not. Judge T. would have interfered; but Judge Rodney issued a writ of Habeas Corpus. Q. Was it by direction or request of the government, that you informed against me for the misdemeanor? A. By neither. Q. Do you not expect to pay the 1000 dollars? A. I expect not. Q. To whom are you to pay it?—Mr. Graham here addressed the court; he said that Judge Rodney had refused to send Mr. Blennerhassett round for trial; but had held him to bail; that he himself had been recognised; that the court was to set some time in May; the Judge considered the Supreme Court as the proper tribunal; the Attorney General thought otherwise, that before the court met he had besides been indisposed & had obtained the certificate of his physician that he could not attend that court. Mr. Burr. Are you still secretary of the Orleans Territory? A. I am not. Q. Do you now hold any office under the government and what is it? A. I am Chief Clerk in the office of Secretary of State.

Q. Was there any arrangement made to seize Col B. after their judicial proceedings against him? A. Governor Williams and myself both agreed that his trial in the Mississippi Territory was a mere farce and that something ought to be done. He proposed to see Col. Burr and make some arrangements with him to come on to the city of Washington for his trial. Col. B. informed him that he was merely going to ride to col. Osborne's for that night. Gov. Williams informed me that he received a great coat at the suburbs of the town and disappeared.

Mr. Wirt. Was not Col. Burr held in recognizance? A. Yes. Q. Did you see such a recognizance? A. Yes. I saw it myself in the clerk's office. Mr. Burr. If it is there, I pronounce it to be a forgery. Mr. Hay observed that the truth would appear in time. Mr. Hay. Were any legal proceedings pending at the time of his departure? The witness asked the court if this was a proper question. Ch. Jus. It is a mere difference of opinion about a fact. Col. B. contended that his recognizance had been complied with; Gov. Williams says not. Mr. Hay. Was his departure from Washington sudden? A. It was certainly sudden, as Gov. W. told me, he had been promised with a call from Col. Burr.

See the clipping

Wilkinson on the stand

General Wilkinson tells how Mr. Swartwout brought him a letter from Burr in cypher, and how he decoded enough of it to grow suspicious.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 3 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

[The general then produced a paper, said to be the deposition of col. Cushing, which comprehended this letter. Mr. Botts said, when you are about to shew a paper, you will please to submit it to our inspection. Gen. Wilkinson. I shall be governed by the judge in that respect. Mr. Botts. Then we shall request the judge to govern you in that respect. General Wilkinson. I shall endeavor to conduct myself with propriety, and in the most decorous manner to the court. Here gen. Wilkinson recapitulated the contents of the letter ; which may be seen in the annexed deposition of col. Cushing, marked A.]

Mr. Swarwout took a seat, and informed us that, being on his way down the Mississippi for New Orleans, in company with a Mr. Ogden, they had heard at Fort Adams of the impending operation against the Spaniards, which had induced him to ascend the Red River, in order to join me, and volunteer his services in the campaign ; and that Mr. Ogden had proceeded on his journey to New Orleans. Col. Cushing retired for a few minutes ; and pending that interval, Mr. Swartwout slipped from his side pocket a letter and packet or envelope, which he said he was charged by col. Burr to deliver to me. I hold the letter in my hand ; and it is a formal letter of introduction to Mr. Swartwout by Col. Burr. [Mr. Martin observed that, if any letters were produced, they should be lodged with the clerk, where both parties might have an opportunity of inspecting them. Chief Justice. Not unless they are read. The letter was laid upon the clerk's table.] I enquired of Mr. Swartwout where col. Burr was. He answered that he was in Philadelphia, or that he had left him there. Col. Cushing returned, and the conversation took a general course. After some time Mr. Swartwout withdrew ; and I retired to my chamber ; and in the packet or envelope I found a letter addressed to me in cypher from col. Burr. [Chief Justice. I did not understand you. How did you get that letter? A. It was in the packet or envelope.] This letter was principally in cypher ; the closing paragraph, however, was in the ordinary script. I resorted to the key, and attempted an interpretation of the letter. I did not complete it ; but discovered enough in the course of the evening to satisfy me, that there was some illicit project on foot. I arose early in the morning, and called on col. Cushing, my second in command, and adjutant and inspector to the army. I stated to him that Mr. Swartwout had borne me a letter from col. Burr, the nature of which I explained ; and observed to him that Mr. Swartwout's declarations, that he had come with a view to volunteer his services in the campaign against the Spaniards, were merely intended to cover his real design. I then communicated to col. Cushing the measures which I should pursue ; enjoining on him, at the same time, to observe the strictest secrecy. Were it permissible to be read, here is a statement of the facts sworn to by colonel Cushing. [The general held at this time in his hand the paper marked A. Mr. Wirt. This statement is signed by col. Cushing, with a certificate of his qualification, in legal form, annexed. Mr. Wickham. An affidavit forming no part of the case before the court, cannot be introduced. Mr. Hay. Gen. Wilkinson states that, on the morning after the letter was partly decyphered, he stated to col. Cushing its contents, and communicated to him the measures which he should pursue. These are facts detailed in that deposition ; and, if the gentlemen do not wish to see them, there is an end of the controversy. The gen. proceeded.] [One paragraph of the letter, I have observed, was in the ordinary script. [Here the paragraph was read by gen. Wilkinson, in the following words. "He is a man of inviolable honor and perfect discretion,—formed to execute rather than to project,—capable of relating facts with fidelity, and incapable of relating them otherwise. He is thoroughly informed of the plans and intentions of ——, and will disclose to you as far as you enquire, and no farther. He has imbibed a reverence for your character, and may be embarrassed in your presence.—— Put him at ease, and he will satisfy you."]—I determined to avail myself of this reference to obtain from Mr. Swartwout that information which I could not discover from the letter ; that is, the object to which col. Burr explicitly directed his views : and, in the course of several days, I obtained from him, substantially, the following facts ; that he had left col. Burr at Philadelphia, occupied day and night almost, on an enterprize which he had in contemplation ; that he lived in a retired part of the city, in a small house with several rooms, where he received persons with whom he had to transact business ; and that he saw no two persons at the same time. He observed to me that Commodore Truxton was frequently with him, and zealously engaged in his enterprize. He observed, at the same time, that a man who superintended the public buildings at Washington was also zealously engaged. He did not recollect his name : but on my mentioning the name of Latrobe, he said that was the man. He said that he had been dispatched by Col. Burr from Philadelphia, and had traversed the states of Ohio and Kentucky. I so understood the gentleman at that time ; but have since discovered that he descended the river [Mr. Botts. By whom did you understand that he had descended the river? A. By a man who informed me that he had rowed him down from Pittsburg.] Another reason why I may have been mistaken was this. He informed me that he had passed to Frankfort in quest of General Adair, for whom he had dispatches from Col Burr ; and, not hearing of him there, had returned back to Lexington in pursuit of him ; where he was informed by Major Waggoner that Gen. Adair (being in ill health) had gone to some medical spring ; and that, if he would wait a few days he might see him ; that he did so, and thus had an interview with him without incurring any suspicion ; at which time he delivered his dispatches. He said Gen. Adair was zealously engaged in the enterprize ; and observed "tell him that I will not write to him, but that I expect to meet him at the place ; that he may depend I will meet him on the spot ;" or words to that effect.

See moreSee less

Mr. Swartwout proceded to inform me that he came to Lousiville, and felt himself at a loss how he should reach me with the most certainty : that a rumor had prevailed there that I had descended the river. Finally on the advice of Mr. Floyd, he determined to go across the country, under the expectation of finding me at St. Louis. Accompanied by Mr. Ogden, he prosecuted his journey to Kaskaskias. Finding that I had descended the river, he determined to alter his route ; he purchased a Skiff, employed hands, and followed me down to fort Adams. At this point, I asked him whether this sudden change of route might not expose him to suspicions. He said that, to guard against this, he had wounded his horse with his pen-knife, and informed the people that his intentions were to have visited St. Louis ; but, having experienced this accident, he should pursue his original destination, which was to descend the river to New-Orleans. On arriving at fort Adams, and discovering that I had proceeded to Natchitoches, he determined to follow me ; & his friend Mr. Ogden (pursuing his route) went on with dispatches from Col. Burr, to his friends in New-Orleans. Mr. Swartwout informed me that Col. Burr, supported by a numerous and powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was about to levy an armed force of seven thousand men, with a view to carry an expedition against the Mexican provinces ; that five hundred men would descend the Allegany river with Col. Swartwout, and a major or col. Tyler : that the boats were already built. He observed that this territory would be revolutionized, where the people were ready to join ; & that some seizing, he supposed would be necessary at New-Orleans : that they expected to make their embarkation about the 1st of February ; that they proposed landing at La Vera Cruz, and marching from thence to Mexico. I observed to him that there were large sums of money in the bank of New-Orleans. He replied that he knew that full well. I observed, "surely you will not violate private property." He said "we mean only to borrow and will return it ;" that they must equip themselves at New-Orleans ; that naval protection would be had from Great Britain ; that Commodore Truxton and the officers of the navy were so disgusted with the government that they were ready to join ; and that pilot boat-built schooners were contracted for on the southern coast of the United States for the service.

He enquired of me whether I had heard of Dr. Bollman ; and on my replying in the negative, he expressed some surprize ; observed that Dr. Bollman and a Mr. Alexander had been dispatched from Philadelphia, by sea, to New-Orleans, with dispatches from colonel Burr to me, and that they must have arrived. Mr. Swartwout informed me that he was obliged to go to New-Orleans ; and was also under engagements to meet Col. Burr and Gen. Dayton at Nashville, on the 20th of November. I think Mr. Swartwout left Natchitoches, about 18th of October, for New-Orleans, as I understood.

It may be proper, in this stage of my testimony, to say that the envelope, which contained the cyphered letter from colonel Burr, covered also two other letters. To save misapprehension, it may also be proper to say, that when I speak of an envelope, it is in contradistinction to a sealed packet. It occurs to my recollection that a letter addressed to John Peters, Esq. of Nashville was enclosed in the envelope, as well as another letter, from general Dayton, in cypher. (See Dayton's letter. Note C.)

[Mr. Baker. Do you say that the letter from Gen. Dayton was inclosed in another cyphered letter? A. No. I say expressly the reverse. It came with it.

Mr. Wickham objected to reading the letter from Gen. Dayton. He said that, Gen. Dayton being absent, he had no opportunity of consulting him, or of ascertaining his wishes respecting it. If there be no other evidence that the letter was from general Dayton, except that a letter was received by general Wilkinson purporting to be a letter of general Dayton's, it was not evidence.

Mr. Hay. The fact stated by general Wilkinson is that he received this letter. It may have had a considerable influence with him, as to the course which he pursued. He received the letter, together with another cyphered letter from Col. Burr ; and, the fact being that he received this letter purporting to be a letter from Gen. Dayton, it surely may be read.

Mr. Wickham. If the letter by itself would not be evidence, its being connected with others would not make it so.

Mr. Hay. On that distinction, I mean to offer it. If General Dayton were before the court, he might require some other evidence as to the authenticity of the letter. General Wilkinson is telling his whole story ; he is to give his whole narrative ; and all the circumstances will bear upon each other.

The Chief Justice at first said, that, if general Wilkinson could say that the letter influenced his conduct, it might be read ; but, finally, he observed, that, on the motion now before the court, it might be improper to read it. If it be the intention of General Wilkinson to state that certain conduct of his was produced by that letter, he may state that such conduct was produced.

Gen. Wilkinson. I must say this letter materially influenced the measures which I pursued.

Mr. Hay. There is certainly a wide difference between this case, a mere examination before a judge, and a trial before a jury. This letter may identify general Dayton with the meeting at the mouth of Cumberland.]

Gen. Wilkinson. Here is the letter, addressed to J. Peters Esq. signed "A Stephens." It appears to be in a disguised hand ; but I have no doubt of its being the hand writing of Col. Burr. (See note D.)

I returned from the operations against the Spaniards, the 5th November ; and, on the next morning [Chief Justice. To what place did you return? A. To Natchitoches.] On the morning of the 6th November, a small Frenchman (whom I had never seen before, nor have I ever seen him since) presented a packet to me, and took his leave. This I found to be a letter from Dr. Bollman covering a letter from Col. Burr. The letter from Dr. Bollman, in his proper hand writing, bears date September 27th, 1806, from New-Orleans. (See note **) Here is the cyphered letter enclosed by Dr. Bollman ; and I find it is an exact duplicate, as it professes to be, of the one received by Mr. Swartwout ; with this variation.—"Doctor Bollman, equally confidential, better informed on the subject, and more intelligent, will hand this duplicate." [This letter was laid upon the Clerk's table.] That letter also inclosed one from general Dayton.

[Mr. McRae. Of the same tenor of the former? A. No: quite different.] This letter of general Dayton is partly in cypher, and partly in the common script. (See Note E.)

(TO BE CONTINUED.)

See the clipping

Wilkinson’s story continues

Wilkinson tells the court of his talks at New Orleans with Dr. Bollman, who had seen a letter from Burr saying he would be at Natchez on 20 December with two thousand men, ‘to be followed by four thousand more.’ Wilkinson says he told Bollman he would oppose Burr if he came to New Orleans, and refused when asked to make ‘such a defence as would cover my reputation, and still permit him to come.’

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

On the Motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.

See moreSee less

Saturday, Sept. 26. Gen. WILKINSON'S EXAMINATION, (CONTINUED.)

[Mr. Wirt. Are you acquainted with General Dayton's hand writing? A. Perfect. Mr. Hay. How did you become acquainted with it? A. From a long and familiar correspondence. Here is a letter from General Dayton to me, introducing his son, which will shew the similarity of the hand writing. [Here the General produced the letter of introduction.] On the same morning I received the following information from Natches, in a letter from James L. Donaldson, dated the 30th of November, 1806.—Here General Wilkinson offered to read the letter—but it was rejected by the court. See note F.] In consequence of the receipt of this letter from Mr. Donaldson, and my reflections on the letters from Col. Burr, I determined to concentrate my whole force at New Orleans, as soon as possible. [Mr. Hay said that he was willing in order to save time, to wave every thing which related to the operations of the army; and requested that General Wilkinson would proceed to relate what occurred at New Orleans.] I proceeded from Natchitoches to Natches and descending from that place reached fort Adams on the 18th of November—where I found Mr. Swartwout, who had been taken ill on his route from Natchitoches to New Orleans, and, for his accommodation, was invited by some one of the officers to that place. He informed me that Mr. Ogden had reached that place, on his way to Tennessee—but, being alarmed by the rumors which prevailed in that part of the country, he was afraid to proceed, and had halted there. I enquired of Mr. Swartwout whether Mr. Ogden had borne any letters. He said that he had not.—but that Lieut. Spence of the navy had been sent, some time before, from New Orleans, through the country, with letters from Col. Burr. I proceeded on, and reached New Orleans on the 25th of November, in the evening; and, on the 26th, in the morning, I received a letter from Dr. Bollman. [Here General Wilkinson produced the letter. See note G.] This letter reminds me of a circumstance which I had omitted. The morning after I had received the letter of Dr. Bollman at Natchitoches, I acknowledged the receipt of it in a short note, and informed him that I should be in N. Orleans about the 20th. I did not call on Dr. Bollman till the 30th. After the ordinary salutations, I enquired whether he had heard of col. Burr, since his arrival. He informed me that he had not. I asked him whether he had heard of lieut. Spence's arrival in Tennessee. He enquired how I came to know any thing of lieut. Spence. I informed him that it was through Mr. Swartwout. He assured me that he had sent dispatches for col. Burr by lieut. Spence, and that he had heard of his arrival at Nashville. He then enquired what part I meant to take? I observed that I felt myself delicately situated. It was impossible that I could take any part, while I held my commission; and I was so circumstanced that I could not get rid of it. He asked me what I thought of the competency of the force of the undertaking. I observed that it depended upon a variety of circumstances; such as winds, weather, composition and appointment of the troops, skill in conduct, the resistance of their opponents, and other causes on which the success of military operations depend. But I gave it as my opinion, that I thought the force insufficient. He said that col. Burr had gone too far to retract; that he had numerous and powerful friends in the U. States, who stood pledged to support him with

No. 1089.

PAID IN ADVANCE.

their fortunes; and that he must succeed. He then enquired of me my opinion as to the state of the magazines of provisions in New-Orleans. I observed that, if Col. Burr descended with the force proposed, they would starve, unless he brought provisions along with him; for I had before ascertained precisely the quantity then on hand. He said that it was his opinion, also, that there would be a scarcity of provisions; that he had written to Col. Burr on the subject; and that he expected a supply from New-York and Norfolk, where col. Burr had many friends. He said that he had noticed in the public prints the sailing of some vessels with flour; and supposed that they might be destined for that place. I did not see Dr. Bollman, afterwards, till the 5th of December, the day after the arrival of the mail; and I called on him to enquire the news. He said that he had seen a letter from Col. Burr, of the 30th of Oct. in which he stated that he should be at Natchez, on the 20th of December, with two thousand men; to be followed by four thousand more; and that he could have raised or levied twelve thousand men, as easily as six, if he had thought them necessary. I then informed Doctor Bollman, that, if Col. Burr came to New-Orleans, I should oppose him. He replied, they must come there for provisions and equipments. He observed that Col. Burr had great confidence in me; but he did not know what had passed between us; and asked, if I could not make such a defence as would cover my reputation, and still permit him to come. I replied in the negative; and we then parted. Some few mornings afterwards, he called at my quarters; there was a gentleman in the room; and I took him into the Piazza. He said, that he wanted to know my determination. I expressed my surprize; and told him that he knew my determination.

Mr. Hay. While you were thus extracting from Doctor Bollman the secrets of his party, were you taking any measures for the security of N. Orleans? A. Yes. My orders and instructions will shew what measures I deemed it my duty to pursue. For these I am responsible to the executive of the U. S.

Mr. Martin. Are the cyphered letters filed? A. Yes. Q. Are the keys furnished? A. Here it is.

[Mr. Botts mentioned the situation of Mr. Tazewell who was summoned as a witness on the part of Col. Burr. He said that Mr. Tazewell had represented the situation of his family to be such as to require his immediate return home. Mr. Botts observed that, although he had introduced the request of Mr. Tazewell to be discharged, he should be compelled to oppose it.

Mr. Tazewell stated that he had been unexpectedly summoned, he well knew, to answer interrogatories as to certain proceedings before the grand jury? that he had just been informed of an occurrence in his domestic affairs, which made it indispensibly necessary for him to return immediately; that there were many gentlemen, in this place and its vicinity, of the grand jury, who were as competent to give evidence on the points to which he should be called upon to depose, as he possibly could be; and who would be subjected to no kind of inconvenience in attending. If he were to be examined at all, he requested that it might be immediately done; for the situation of his family was such that he should be compelled to return.

The Chief Justice said to Mr. Tazewell, that he knew full well that it was not in the power of the court to discharge him.

Mr. Botts said it was impossible to examine Mr. Tazewell till general Wilkinson had gone through his testimony. It was not possible to know the importance of his evidence till General Wilkinson was cross examined.

Mr. Hay observed that it was an unprecedented measure to introduce any member of the grand jury to prove what had passed in the jury room.

Mr. Botts. We have not said for what purpose we mean to introduce him.

Mr. Hay. I presume that I may be permitted to presume for what purpose.

Mr. Baker said that he meant to speak generally of the propriety and convenience of giving testimony as to what passed in the grand jury room. One good effect, at least, would result from it: that by introducing witnesses to prove what had passed there, it would prevent people from giving information to the grand jury, which they could not support elsewhere.

Mr. Botts called for the key to the cyphered letters of col. Burr.

Gen. Wilkinson handed him a small pocket dictionary, and a paper containing certain hieroglyphics.

Mr. Botts. In the duplicate received by Dr. Bollman, there is an erazure. Will you be so good as to explain the cause of it?

Gen. Wilkinson. That erazure was made by myself, and the words afterwards introduced by me. I have a deposition which will be more satisfactory than my own explanation.

Mr. Botts. Whose deposition? A. Mr. Duncan's.

[Mr. Wirt read the deposition of Mr. Duncan, for which see note H.]

Mr. Botts. When was the erazure made? A. During the sitting of the legislature in New Orleans. Q. When were the words restored? A. I cannot now state with certainty. Q. Was the letter exhibited to the legislature? A. It was introduced; but I confined myself to oral communications. Q. What was the occasion of the erazure? A. To put it out of the power of a certain faction in the legislature, to whom at that time I intended to submit the paper—to conceal it from that faction who were opposed to my measures, and who, I believed, were inimical to the true interest of their country, and were laboring to excite suspicions that I was connected with Col. Burr, in order to destroy the public confidence in me, and thus to defeat my measures. At the head of this faction I considered John Watkins, esq. the Speaker. Having determined not to submit the letter, I restored the words. Q. Did you prepare any translation to submit to the legislature? A. No. I only made notes. Q. Did you make a translation for any other purpose? A. Only a partial and imperfect one. Q. For what purpose? A. To understand it. Q. Was there any other occasion for which a translation was made? A. No. Q. Did you make any translation for the executive? A. No. Q. Were those words, "your's post-marked 13th of May is received," erased? A. Yes. Q. Where is the copy of your letter, covering a copy of that of Col. Burr, and your deposition to the President of the U. States? A. It is among my papers.

Mr. Hay. Do I understand you correctly, when I suppose you say, that the translation intended for the Legislature of New-Orleans, was sent to the President? A. No.

[Mr. Hay immediately observed that, on recollecting dates, he perceived that he had misunderstood gen. Wilkinson; that the letter was sent to the President before the session of the Legislature of New-Orleans.]

Mr. Botts. Do I understand you to say that this was your translation of the letter which was intended for the legislature of New-Orleans? A. No. It was Mr. Duncan's.

Mr. Botts. Have you ever sworn that this was a true translation? A. No. Only substantially so.

[Gen. Wilkinson. May I be permitted to offer a few words of explanation? When Dr. Bollman was arrested, I will confess to you that I was so little acquainted with judicial proceedings, that I did not know it was necessary to do more than accompany him with a letter of advice. I was about to send him off in this way, when Mr. Duncan suggested to me the propriety of sending forward a deposition to justify his commitment. I put the letter into the hands of Mr. Duncan, with the key; and he made out the interpretation. When Mr. Duncan presented the translation to me, I stated my objections to the omissions. He urged me to sign the deposition. The time was urgent; the express waiting; and I confess that I feared a rescous. This did not give me much time to consult my understanding. If I had, it is probable that I should have resisted the signing of the deposition, with those omissions, notwithstanding my confidence in the judgment and integrity of my counsel. I was, also, at the time, oppressed by domestic afflictions; and my mind was hurried and agitated by the painful and interesting scenes which surrounded me.

Mr. Botts. Were there variations between this original letter in cypher, and that sent on to the president? A. Yes.

Mr. Botts. Were they noticed by you, or by Mr. Duncan in your presence? A. I suppose so—because I objected generally to the omissions.

Mr. Botts. How was the cypher formed? A. It consisted of an American edition of Enticks dictionary, and of Hieroglyphics.

Mr. Botts. Which was formed first? A. The dictionary.

Mr. Botts. When was that formed? [Here gen. Wilkinson referred to a letter, without a signature, dated in 1800—and said he presumed it must have been formed about that time.]

Mr. Botts. Do you know the time of the year? A. I presume it was October.

Mr. Baker. To whom was that letter addressed? A. To myself. Q. by the same. By whom was it written? A. By col Burr. [Gen. Wilkinson observed that it was a private letter, to which he had referred merely to refresh his memory, the concluding paragraph of which is, "when I receive your cypher and your address, you shall hear from me." Mr. Wickham insisted upon seeing the letter.—Gen. Wilkinson refused—but said it was at the disposal of col. Burr, and handed it to him.]

Mr. Botts. With whom was the cypher formed? A. Col. Burr and myself.

Mr. Botts. When were the hieroglyphics agreed upon? A. To the best of my recollection, the hieroglyphics which refer to the alphabet were formed about the change of the administration, after the induction of the president. The hieroglyphics are divided into two parts—one part relates to the alphabet and figures, and the other part to arbitrary names or designations.

Mr. Botts. When were the arbitrary names established? A. I think in the year 1795 or 1796, but not delivered to col. Burr at that time.

Mr. Botts. Who originally devised the cypher? A. That you hold in your hand (the hieroglyphics) was devised partly by myself and partly by capt. Campbell Smith.

Mr. Botts. Are you sure it was in 1796, in which that part was devised? A. I think I said in 1795 or 1796, but could not ascertain which. But, adverting to the motives which induced me to form it, I think it was in 1794.

Mr. Botts. Are there no circumstances which can enable you to ascertain the time? A. I could have proved with certainty, the time, if a witness whom I had summoned had attended. Here is another cypher made by capt. Smith in 1794, and the hieroglyphics representing the President and Vice-President are the same with those used in the cypher with colonel Burr.

Col. Burr. What was the mode adopted by you of sending round the prisoners? By public vessels? A. No. My plan was to engage passages on board private vessels, and to lay in a double stock of stores for their accommodation. Col. Burr. When did your dispatches go on board the vessel? Can you ascertain the time? A. Not without recurring to my correspondence. Mr. Wirt. You had been for many years in habits of intimate correspondence with col. Burr? A. Yes.

(TO BE CONTINUED.)

See the clipping

Was Wilkinson in Spain’s pay?

Burr’s lawyers turn the tables, trying to prove that the government’s star witness took money from Spain. The Spanish subject they call to the stand refuses to answer, citing his duty to his king.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · and 4 other papers

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 2 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr's Trial. RICHMOND, OCT. 20. Thursday, Oct. 15, was wholly occupied by Mr. Wickham. Friday was wholly occupied by Mr. McRea. On Saturday, a Mr. Power, from Neworleans, (who turned out to be a subject of the king of Spain) was introduced by col. Burr as a witness: by whom [as he asserted] he intended to authenticate certain papers, and to prove that gen. Wilkinson was in the habit of receiving money from the Spanish government. The avowed object of establishing this charge, against the general, was, to impeach his credibility, by contradicting some parts of his testimony, and to shew that his motive for defeating the project of Burr, was not patriotism, but to prevent an invasion of the territories of the king, in whose pay he was himself.

See moreSee less

The chief justice decided that the evidence was admissible, and that Mr. Power should be examined. He was therefore sworn, and questioned as to what he knew concerning certain correspondence between the Baron de Corondelet and general Wilkinson. Mr. Power addressed the court with respect but firmness, and declared that, being a subject to the king of Spain, he could not, without violating his duty and honor, give an account of any political transactions which the service of the king his master required to be concealed. He stated that he had come hither from Neworleans with great reluctance; an agent of col. Burr who served a subpoena upon him having threatened him with imprisonment in case he refused; but he hoped the court would not compel him to give the evidence which had been demanded. The council for col. Burr insisted that, whether he was a Spanish subject or not, he was now within the power of the court; and ought to be compelled to disclose whatever he knew. The chief justice decided in their favor, and required the witness to proceed with his testimony. Mr. Power, however, resolutely refused.—Time was therefore allowed until three o'clock to consider whether he would obey the judge or not. At that hour he came again into court; but, [Mr. Wirt being then engaged in speaking] no notice was taken of his appearance. Mr. Wirt began his discourse between 12 and 1 o'clock, but had not finished when the hour of adjournment arrived. His speech, so far as he progressed, shone with his usual fire of eloquence, and was peculiarly luminous in argument. The court adjourned 'till Monday ten o'clock. Monday, Oct. 19—12 o'clock. Nearly the whole of this day was occupied by Mr. Wirt, who concluded his able speech about two o'clock—after which Mr. Power and Mr. Swartwout were again called and examined. The evidence and arguments of counsel having been concluded the court adjourned till this day [Tuesday eleven o'clock, when it is understood the final opinion of the Chief Justice will be delivered. Opinion of the Chief Justice. 12 o'clock—The court has just delivered a long and elaborate opinion, in which it determines, that "it would be improper to commit the accused on the charge of treason." The conclusion of the opinion is as follows: "I shall commit Aaron Burr and Herman Blannerhasset for preparing and providing the means for a military expedition against the territories of a foreign Prince with whom the U. S. were at peace. If those whose province and duty it is to prosecute offenders against the laws of the United States shall be of opinion that a crime of a darker dye has been committed, it is not their choice to act in conformity with that opinion.—Israel Smith is not proved to have provided or prepared any means whatever, and therfore I shall not commit him. If he has really offended against the laws he may be prosecuted for the treason in Kentucky, or for the misdemeanor in his own State, where, if any where, his offence has been committed." Mr. Hay moved to have A. B. and H. B. committed for trial in the District of Ohio.

See the clipping

Wilkinson’s ‘grand scheme’

Burr’s counsel call Major James Bruff to prove, they say, that Wilkinson knew Burr’s views before the cyphered letter. Bruff says that at St. Louis in 1805 Wilkinson locked him in his room, told him ‘God forbid that you should ever see an election in Louisiana,’ and spoke of ‘a grand scheme in contemplation’ to make fortunes. In 1807, he says, the Secretary at War told him Wilkinson ‘must and would be supported.’

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The Enquirer · 3 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITMENT. Tuesday, October 6. Evidence of Major James Bruff.

Mr. Martin. Had you any communications with Gen. Wilkinson about the time of his return to St. Louis? [Mr. Hay requested that the object for which the witness was introduced should be stated. Mr. Martin said, it was to prove the same as Timothy Kibby; that gen. Wilkinson held out the same inducements to him to join in an expedition against the Spaniards. Mr. Hay objected to the introduction of the testimony, on principle. He said that no man could be presumed to come prepared to explain every particular act of his life; That the general reputation of a witness could alone be enquired into, in order to assail his character. This he held to be a sacred rule of law and of justice. Mr. Martin contended, that the evidence was pertinent. Gen. Wilkinson had declared that he had no knowledge of col. Burr's views till he received the cyphered letter. We will prove that he had. He did not mean to say that the views of col. Burr were criminal, on the contrary, they were perfectly innocent; nor would gen. Wilkinson have been guilty if he had joined in them. But now gen. Wilkinson, in order to obtain favor with the government, had turned traitor to col. Burr. Mr. Wickham argued that the testimony of Major Bruff was admissible to shew an inconsistency in that of gen. Wilkinson.

See moreSee less

Gen. Wilkinson. May I be permitted to make one observation; I am not in the smallest degree surprized at the language which has upon this and several other occasions been used by the counsel of col. Burr; men who are hired to misrepresent. [Mr. Wickham. I will not submit to such language from any man in court. The Chief Justice declared the style of gen. W. to be improper, and that he had heard too much of such language in court. Gen. Wilkinson apologized.—He said that it was impossible he could offer any intentional disrespect to the court, but he could not remain silent when he heard himself called a traitor.] Gen. W. proceeded.—I am astonished at the explanation of the objects for which this witness is called. Had I known the purpose for which he volunteered his services, (for he was not summoned) I should have been able to produce documents to shew the long, the implacable hatred which he has borne towards me. [Mr. Wickham said that Major Bruff was under the protection of the court.] Gen. Wilkinson—I pray that his testimony may be introduced. Mr. Hay observed, that he had no doubt of the law, as to the right to impeach the credibility of a witness, by shewing an inconsistency in his testimony. He admitted that if Major Bruff's evidence were introduced for that purpose, it was proper; but if for any other purpose, it was improper. They had no right to interrogate him for the purpose avowed by Mr. Martin; to shew that Gen. Wilkinson entertained the same views as col. Burr. However, as gen. Wilkinson was content that Major Bruff should proceed, he would not object.

The Chief Justice declared that he would not hear the witness as to any particular allegations against gen. Wilkinson; but with respect to any inconsistency in his testimony he must hear him.

Major Bruff proceeded.

My testimony will arise from a number of conversations with gen. W.

In four of these conversations gen. W. took me aside; in three of which he locked me up in his room. The first hint I had of a connexion between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr was drawn from two paragraphs in Kentucky newspapers, in the spring 1805, before gen. W. reached St. Louis; the first alluded to the old plan to form a separate government west of the Allegany, and ascribed it to gen. Wilkinson and his associates, and doubting whether that scheme had yet been abandoned. The next was an extract of a letter from Fort Massac, published in the papers, which stated that col. Burr had been several days there with gen. Wilkinson, probably giving the general lessons on government, or digesting a new code or constitution for the government of Louisiana.—These hints, with information received from capt. Stoddard immediately from Fort Massac, and who assured me that col. Burr was, or had been there closely engaged with gen. W. and that he had or was about to furnish him with a barge and crew, to descend the Mississippi into New-Orleans, [Mr. Wirt. You have not said when. A. In June, 1805.] These circumstances put me on my guard, and determined me to watch the motions of gen. Wilkinson and Burr.

As the general approached St. Louis, ascending the Mississippi from Fort Massac, he dispatched a light barge ahead with directions for me to meet him six or eight miles below. I obeyed. We met, landed and ascended the bank. The general took me into the woods. As we walked on, the general observed, that he had been informed the territory was divided by parties, (I mean upper Louisiana) which he attributed to the Americans, and said he would crush party, or perish in the attempt. I observed, that there had been some party business about the time of the convention and these memorials to Congress, but none since; except the aversion the French had to the expense, delay, and uncertainty of our laws, and the introduction of lawyers. He then asked me how I stood with the French inhabitants, for he had heard there was some misunderstanding or coolness between us occasioned by my observations about antedated concessions and fraudulent grants—I observed, that some uneasiness had been excited by a report I had made to the secretary at war, respecting private surveys which took in public property, but I believed they were then satisfied I had merely done my duty. He observed that he had witnessed their many attempts in the lower country to defraud the public; (the Orleans or Mississippi territories that he knew them and mankind generally, and if I would place my dependence upon him he would manage them for me; [Mr. Hay. He would manage them for you? A. Yes. It alluded to the French.] About this time some Frenchmen from St. Louis had found us out and were rushing through the bushes on us. He damned them for their intrusion; [Mr. Hay. To their faces? A. No. To me,] said he had something of importance to communicate, hoped to have had an opportunity there; but that he would take the first opportunity after he had got settled.

A day or two after his arrival at St. Louis, his orderly came to me. I attended. I was taken into his parlour and he locked the door. [Mr. McRae. What time? A. About the last of June, or 1st or 2d day of July. Mr. McRae. Can you name the day? A. I cannot. Gen. Wilkinson. Can you come within five days? A. No, I cannot.] We commenced walking. The General appeared to be ruminating, and after two or three times he asked me what sort of government would suit Louisiana. Without hesitation, I replied, a representative republic would meet both the wishes and expectations of the people. He answered that he was surprized to hear me say so; for the French could not understand its principle or be brought to attend elections; that the American inhabitants were a turbulent set, the mere emptyings of jails or fugitives from justice, and did not deserve a free government; that a military government was best for these people, and no other was contemplated for them; [Here Mr. Hay, observing that Major Bruff retired to a table on which several papers were laid, asked him when he had made the statement of his testimony, which he was then giving. On being answered that it was recently done and since his arrival here; Mr. Hay requested that he would not again look at it. Major Bruff said that his statement was drawn from a number of letters which he had written to his friends about the time of the transactions alluded to; and from an intended publication against the Gen.] that the politics of the United States had undergone a great change; that the honest and wise had united to save the federal constitution, and prevent a division of property which the democrats aimed at; that the democratic party in Congress had split and dwindled; and that John Randolph, Nicholson and Leib, had lost their influence both in Congress and with the executive. I observed that he attributed principles and motives to the republicans which they abhorred. [Mr. Hay. To which party did you belong? A. To the democratic. Mr. Martin. Were you not then a democrat, and did not Gen. Wilkinson know you to belong to that party? A. Yes.] On this subject we had a good deal of conversation. I remarked on the folly to suppose John Randolph would consent to throw his property into the public stock, in order to have a scramble for a part of it. However, the general observed, that the object of the democrats was to produce a state of anarchy and confusion; to seize on the property of the federalists and divide it among themselves; and this too he told me with a very serious face. I will make one observation here: it is that these conversations which I had with the General, were at different times, and it is possible that I may not have classed them precisely in point of time; but I am certain that they did happen and nearly as I have stated; and if the General will be candid, he will acknowledge it. [Gen. Wilkinson. Indeed I will not.] He said that Pennsylvania was convulsed by the democrats; yet they would not succeed in turning out M'Kean or introducing their arbitration system. I think that this ended the conversation. We got warm; and the General threw open the door, and I walked out.

After dinner his orderly came for me again. I attended; was taken into his room and the door fastened. He assumed a milder manner. And assured me that the politics not only of the United States but of the executive had changed; that the difference between the present and former administration was merely in name; that parties were kept alive by the cunning, in order to help them to office or to keep them in; that the people mistook the character of Mr. Jefferson; that a want of energy was no part of it, but rather obstinacy. Here he observed that the French had not been enough attended to in the territorial appointments; that they were the natives, and the Americans were ungrateful intruders and now railed against a King and government which had raised them from ashes.—[Mr. Wirt. To whom did he allude? A. I considered that he pointed his remarks to Mr. Austin particularly. It was the Spanish King and government to which I alluded.] He then observed that Governor Claiborne, a miserable thing or tool, had distributed the appointments in the lower country among his American followers and dependents, and had neglected the French, for which he was execrated, despised and forsaken by every person of talents and honor, except by a Dr. Watkins, who no doubt had some personal views. I observed that in the lower country the great body of the people were French; but that in the upper country there were more than two Americans for one Frenchman, and that the disproportion encreased daily by emigration, and would soon entitle us to elections. He replied, God forbid that you should ever see an election in Louisiana; and then observed that it was the intention of the government to depopulate that country, except the villages of St. Louis, St. Geneva and St. Charles, and a small district of country around each, merely sufficient to support them; that land would be offered to the inhabitants on the East side of the Mississippi, which if they refused to move to, they would be pushed over at the point of the bayonet, and that I should be employed in that business. As I found that my replies only irritated the General, and kept back the important communications I therefore determined when I could not acquiesce in sentiment with the General, I would endeavour to be silent till I got the important secret. But I found, I had already gone too far. The General appeared to be vexed and disappointed; threw open the door and I walked out.

The next morning his orderly came for me again. I attended; and we had another parlour conversation with closed doors. He assumed a friendly manner, and begged me to recollect that it was sometime since I had left the Atlantic States; and assured me that public opinion had undergone a great change in favour of energetic governments and measures; that if I persisted in exploded notions, they would injure me with my government; that democratic notions produced licentiousness; and that the very existence of an army and democracy were incompatible; that republics were ungrateful; jealous of armies and military merit; and made no provision for the superannuated & worn-out officers, but who were left to starve. In these latter opinions I agreed with him. The general seemed pleased that I should assent to any of his opinions. He was now silent.—While we walked the floor one or two turns, with his eyes down on the floor and seemed to be musing, he then observed that he was fertile

[NUMBER 51.

in schemes, had made fortunes for many who did not then thank him for it. I smiled. He said, "perhaps you think I had better have made my own fortune.—True; But I have now a grand scheme in contemplation, that will not only make my fortune, but the fortunes of all concerned"; he paused as if waiting for my answer; I was silent—had nothing to say; but wanted him to explain and go into the detail; after walking the floor several times, during which he appeared much agitated and vexed, he threw open the door and I walked out; with only this glimpse of the secret which he had so long been preparing me for.

As I attended daily for orders until the arrival of col. Cushing; the next morning I found the General rather distant and reserved. He observed that he had yet enemies in the army; and among them some from his own State; that he either hated or loved Marylanders more than others; presuming this intended for me, I replied, I suppose you take me for a Marylander; "why, are you not?" I answered no. I was born in Jersey, but had the good luck to be brought young to Maryland of which State my father, grand father and great grand father, were natives—"born in Jersey! (replied the General,) a second cousin a yankee, a damned cunning fellow I suspect."—This was the first rude thing he had said to me; for before this, I was treated with respect and had received many friendly letters from him; I therefore attributed this to my declining to join him in his scheme to make fortunes; some time after the troops moved to Cold Water, an officer informed me, that they were encamped on a low damp bottom, subject to be overflowed. (Mr. Hay objected to the course of the testimony pursued by the witness. Col. Burr said that he did not know the whole extent of his testimony, but that he had been introduced to shew palpable contradictions in the evidence of General Wilkinson.) The Missouri on the one side and a marsh or bog on the other, and the whole Cantonment commanded by a high second Bank or hill in its rear; I observed the situation was not only unmilitary, but would probably become the grave of the troops if they were not removed. At that time I did not know the General had contracted for the ground as private property "a snug fixture where he might hang up his sword." The morning after this conversation I was sent for by the General and severely and rudely reprimanded before two strangers; forbid to interfere with his plans and measures; I replied it was my duty and inclination to obey his military arrangements, but should I discover any plans or measures which put to hazard the peace and safety of the U. States, I would not keep silence, be the consequences what they might; he understood me. And from that moment I believe my ruin was determined on.

Colonel Burr arrived a little time after this at St. Louis. (Mr. Wirt. At what time? A. I believe in August 1805.) A Judge Easton who appeared to think very highly of col. Burr and boasted of possessing a part of his confidence, informed me that col. Burr had inquired of him, whether there was any officer of experience & enterprize who could be trusted with the command of an expedition to Santa Fee, and gave me a very inquisitive look. I demanded by what authority col. Burr made the inquiry, or in what light I was to view it. He replied that col. Burr at that time held no public office, but that he had powerful friends and would probably be in a very exalted situation before long; that I had been well spoken of to col. Burr, (I suppose by himself) and he advised me to make him my friend. I answered that the inquiry was a suspicious one; for if government chose to employ me in that or any other way; it had a right to command my services—for (I was in service at that time.) We dropt the subject. (Mr. Martin. Was Easton at St. Louis? A. Yes. Mr. Martin. Was he in habits of great intimacy with gen. Wilkinson. A. Yes, there appeared to be a good understanding between the three.) But as general Wilkinson some time before had wrote me that "every information of the route to Santa Fee would be highly acceptable," and recently sounded my inclination towards energetic governments and his grand scheme to make fortunes, I no longer doubted of their connection. (Mr. Martin. How long was col. Burr at St. Louis, how was he treated by general Wilkinson, and how was he sent across the River? A. When he arrived I was not in town, but understood that the General had rode out with him to the Cantonment to view his troops. I saw the Colonel on the evening he returned. The Colonel strictured the situation and laughed at the General's military notions. Mr. Wirt. At Cold Water? A. Yes at Cold Water and christened afterward; Belle Fontaine. Mr. Wirt. How far from St. Louis? A. Twelve or fourteen miles. Mr. Martin. When col. Burr was there how was he treated? A. The General made a dinner, it was understood for col. Burr. I was invited; the colonel did not attend; but was said to be sick. When col. Burr was leaving St. Louis I was about to cross the River to my plantation on the opposite side, his baggage was brought to the ferry boat, when I saw the General's barge getting ready with colours and a complete crew in uniform. I afterwards saw the Colonel pass my farm on his journey, in company with Doctor Brown only; Easton was not with him.)

Some time after col. Burr left St. Louis, General Wilkinson and Mr. Easton fell out. Easton complained the General persecuted him.—And often talked in a dark mysterious manner about a Western empire. Capt. Stoddart also hinted to me after his return from Fort Massac, that some great scheme was in agitation between col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, but did not say what. Easton positively stated that there was a connection between General Wilkinson and Colonel Burr. He complained that the General persecuted him, I observed that it was very strange that he should be the common friend of col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, and yet they should misunderstand one another about him; that I rather suspected the General finding him unpopular with the French, and that he would not answer their purpose, had persuaded col. Burr to shake him off. Easton replied, that col. Burr was in his power and that he dared not treat him in a deceitful manner. I replied I did not know col. Burr, but that his enemies represented him as an artful intriguer. Some time afterwards Mr. Easton came to me and observed that he believed my conjectures about col. Burr were true—and that he was to be made a sacrifice of; that he should go on to the seat of government and try what he could do for himself. Easton was then a Judge appointed by the President, but not confirmed by

the Senate, and he was apprehensive it would not; that gen. Wilkinson was using his influence to prevent the confirmation.—But observed, col. Burr was much in his power, for that he had made him proposals which made the hair rise upon his head, astonished and confounded him so that he was struck dumb. (General Wilkinson. Were these his very words? A. Yes.) That col. Burr observing this would have retracted but it was too late. I urged him to explain the nature of the proposals. He said he was under an obligation of secrecy; but no obligation should hold him if he found col. Burr false to him. I observed that he well knew that any obligation which lead him to conceal or commit a crime could not be binding. He observed he was going on to the seat of government and should see col. Burr, and then he should take his measures. I saw Easton after his return. I urged him to explain the business which he had mentioned before; but he pretended to have forgot that such a conversation had ever passed between us. Mr. Hay. Was his appointment confirmed? A. No. He lost his appointment and had seen col. Burr.) About this time a paper called the Western World made its appearance, one of which was I believe directed to the General weekly.

[Mr. Hay. After the return of Easton? A. Yes.] It roundly accused General Wilkinson of the old plan, of being concerned with Miranda and connected with col. Burr. I observed to Easton that I believed I should get the whole story from the Western World without being under any obligations to him; that if he had done his duty he might have served himself and his country and perhaps prevented the effusion of blood. He observed that he had once attempted to make a disclosure to Government, but instead of being countenanced he got a reprimand. I demanded the instance, he said that he had wrote to a Senator in Congress either from Vermont or New-York, that he could prove General Wilkinson to be the projector of Miranda's expedition. The gentleman acknowledged the receipt of his letter, but informed him he had burnt it, and advised him to mind his own business and take care how he meddled with men high in power and office. Mr. Martin. Had General Wilkinson any conversation with you with respect to the appointment of a certain John Smith of Louisiana? A. I had a conversation with him about John Smith. I remember going into the General's office when he handed me two letters, one from Major Hunt, the civil and military commandant, and the other from Smith, who complained that the commandant had ordered him off the mineral lands. The General censured the order and asked me if I knew who John Smith was. I replied no, but had been informed he was one of Cox's captains—so Major Hunt insidiously observes, replies the General—but that does not lessen him in my esteem. He added that Smith was brother-in-law to Mr. Early a member of Congress, who had brought forward a resolution to reduce the army and dispense with his services as General; that there were many of his stamp in Congress—therefore they must be attended and kept in good humour, or we shall be turned to the right about. Mr. Martin. Did you appear before the Secretary at war in order to make a statement as to the conduct of General Wilkinson which you considered indangered the United States, and what was his reply? Mr. Hay objected to the question as it had no relation to the subject. Mr. Wickham said that General Wilkinson had been interrogated by them and required to say whether his conduct was approved or disapproved by the Government; that the Government had taken the most active part in this prosecution and it was right and proper that the sentiments of the Government should be known. The Chief Justice said the difference is this. The evidence of General Wilkinson arose from communications officially made directly from the government. This is a different case—The evidence here offered consists of conversations with the officers of the Government. Mr. Martin said that the Secretary at War was applied to in his official character; and in his official character he had said that General Wilkinson must and would be supported; that he had stood low in the estimation of Government before his energetic measures at N.w. Orleans, but now he stood very high. Mr. Hay was about to make some observations in opposition to the introduction of such evidence, when General Wilkinson consented that the witness should go on.]

In March 1807, a few days before the rising of Congress, I was in the city of Washington, and waited on the Secretary of war, and the subject which gave rise to this visit and conversation between the Secretary at war, the Attorney General and myself, was an appeal from the sentence of a general Court Martial, whose proceedings I contended had been arbitrary and oppressive, and sentence illegal and unjust. (Mr. Wirt. Against whom? A. Myself, and that I was not arrested until after gen. W. had sounded and found I would not answer his purpose; and I believed for fear I might penetrate his plans and be a spy on his actions he determined to put me aside. The secretary at war replied that there had been a time when gen. W. did not stand well with the executive, but his energetic measures at New Orleans had regained him his confidence and he would support him. Mr. Wirt. Who? A. I mean the President. (I asked if an inquiry into the conduct of gen. Wilkinson, his oppressions and illegal acts and his connection with col. Burr might be expected. He answered there might be an inquiry after the present bustle was over; but at present he must and would be supported. I then observed that if an inquiry might be expected in a reasonable time I would ask a furlough and wait; but if not I should resign immediately.—He observed that I must not calculate on a speedy inquiry, but if I was determined not to serve under gen. W. my only resort was to resign immediately. (Mr. Martin. Who said so, gen. Dearborn? Yes, gen. Dearborn.) He however recommended me to draw up a short statement of facts for the President respecting my trial and sentence. I replied that if I did I should certainly charge gen. W. with having been connected with col. Burr, and with having made attempts to bring me over to his grand scheme of making fortunes. He replied if these are your impressions you will be correct in stating them. This was the first conversation I had with the Secretary at war.

I had a second conversation with the Secretary at war, in which I insisted that gen. W. was acquainted with Burr's plans; that I would produce proof that he had been concerned and did not secede till he found that col. Burr had commenced the enterprize with a handful of men, that the country was alarmed and the project was a desperate one. I then had a conversation with the Attorney General on the legality of restoring my pay and emoluments, which had been suspended by the sentence of the court Martial. I informed him that a connection between gen. W. and col. Burr could certainly be proved. He observed that the general had been low with the President, but at that time stood high and would be supported. He observed however, that there was a great deal of mystery in the allusions of col. Burr's letter to gen. Wilkinson, as well as their making

use of a cypher. He advised me not to resign, but to wait events, for the Secretary at war had informed him that I was the only republican field officer in the service, and that public opinion was very fluctuating and whimsical.

After this I had a conversation with the Secretary at War and the Attorney General together. I think that Capt. Clark, the companion of Lewis was also present. The Secretary at War shut the doors. We had some previous conversation, as after the Attorney General came in, the Secretary at War introduced it again, by observing, that he had been informed col. Burr had accompanied gen. Wilkinson to the Western Country, spent several days with him at Massac, and then furnished the colonel with a barge and men to descend the Mississippi to New-Orleans; I replied that this was one among many reasons to suspect a good understanding, connection and co-operation between the general and colonel—That I imagined both of them were well-informed of the old plan attributed to the general and his associates, to form a separate government West of the Alleghany under the auspices of Spain or England; of his famous memorial, which it is said procured him exclusive privileges from the Spanish government, and the extraordinary visit colonel Connelly from Canada paid him in Kentucky; but that there were recent events which were not without suspicion. Such as his having spent the last winter of col. Burr's vice-presidency at Washington; their great intimacy, the interest made to get gen. Wilkinson appointed and confirmed governor of Upper Louisiana, with Burr's brother-in-law, Secretary to the Territory, and many of his friends, to places of trust and influence. Gen. Wilkinson's drawing several hundred troops into a cantonment near the mouth of the Missouri; his connections with col. Burr, gen. Adair, John Brown of Kentucky, John Smith of Ohio, and several others, since implicated or suspected of being concerned with col. Burr, to procure a charter for cutting a Canal on the Indiana side of Ohio, on which charter a bank was ingrafted, and would have produced those funds, the want of which seems first to have made the general to hesitate—alluding to a paragraph in the cyphered letter. I then stated colonel Burr's visit to New-Orleans in a barge furnished by General Wilkinson; and that after visiting the lower country, he came to St. Louis. I then stated the conversation with judge Easton, as before mentioned, and the intimacy of those three persons, and that when col. Burr was about leaving St. Louis, the general had a barge got ready with much parade to put him over the Mississippi; that some time after col. Burr's return to the Atlantic States, Miranda's expedition got ready and failed, which a gentleman promised, if called on, to come forward and prove general Wilkinson to be the projector of; (that gentleman is Judge Easton.) I then observed that it was not easy to suppose, that Colonel Burr, who knew Wilkinson's character, his former attempts and desperate fortune, should spend so much time with him at Washington, where the scheme seems to have been first projected; pass through the country where col. Burr must commence his enterprize, where Wilkinson was well acquainted, and where Burr wanted agents (alluding to the Ohio), and partizans; yet never found him to make proposals, but wait till all was ready, and then make his first overtures by a letter; and before he knew the success of that letter in converting a patriot general into a traitor, should throw himself & his best friends, his choice spirits, into the power of a general he had so much insulted; that the general's measures in Upper Louisiana certainly had a tendency to disgust the people with the change of government, and to prepare them for a revolt; that I did not know the general's attempts upon other officers, but he certainly had tried me; but if on the contrary col. Burr did communicate his plans to the genl. either at Washington, at Massac, or at St. Louis, and the general did not immediately inform his government, he has not only grossly imposed on them, and the public at large; but has been guilty of misprision of treason and perjury. The Attorney General, after I had gone through my statement and information, in substance and order nearly as related, asked me what would be the result if all this should be proven?—why just what the federalists and the enemies of the present administration wish—it would turn the indignation of the people from Burr on Wilkinson; Burr would escape and Wilkinson take his place. I observed that it possibly might be the event, but justice and honor required that the whole truth should be known, let it operate as it might.

(Major Bruff's Testimony, to be continued.)

See the clipping

A traitor all the same, says the Enquirer

At the close of the trial, the National Intelligencer reprints the Enquirer’s own verdict. Weighing the evidence, from Eaton’s testimony to Blennerhassett’s island, it decides Burr meant first to split the western states from the eastern, then to invade Mexico, with the Ouachita lands as a last asylum. He may not have committed the overt act, but ‘he saves his life at the expence of his reputation.’ ‘Like Cain, he has a mark, that lasts for ever.’

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE ENQUIRER.

CURSORY REFLECTIONS.

See moreSee less

At the close of the important trial which has so long agitated our city, our readers may very naturally call upon us to deliver our own opinions. To discharge this duty we once more take up the pen.

The subject is complicated and extensive. We shall attempt to seize its leading features and present them in the form of cursory reflections:

These reflections will naturally touch on three great portraits: that of Aaron Burr: The Chief Justice of the U. S. And Gen. Wilkinson.

There is nothing which we have to submit to our readers, which may not very properly fall under one of these heads.

No. I. PORTRAIT OF AARON BURR.

"Who noble ends by noble means attains, That man is great indeed ——."

Is such the greatness of the man who stands before us? Is such the character of the transactions, which have been lately unfolded to the world? Let us analyse both his ends and his means to see what pretensions they can give him to the character which the Poet has described.

This trait uniformly marks his conduct and designs; that he never is contented with a lower seat, so long as he can aspire to the highest. The mines and riches of Mexico are tempting objects; but even the wealth and splendor of the Mexican empire, when viewed through the long tract of water and wood which he would have to pass, and the dangers which were to be encountered, are lost and eclipsed in the superior lustre of a throne, erected at New-Orleans, and stretching its sceptre over the western states. From every thing which we can collect, as well from his own declarations where he dared to unbosom himself, as the more unguarded avowals of his less artful accomplices, A. Burr must have had three objects in view:

To separate the Western from the eastern states. To invade Mexico, or To effect a temporary settlement on the Ouachita.

The first was the foremost in his hopes and first in the period of its attempted accomplishment. The second was but to turn into a new course the very same means which he had collected, and the very passions which he should have excited for the attainment of the first. And the last, was to have been at once the asylum of his despairing ambition, and the germ of new schemes, where it "hush'd in grim repose expects its evening's prey."

Take the principal points of the evidence as they have been disclosed during this examination, and see how they bear us out in these conclusions.

The examination of Gen. Eaton before the court, and in the presence of the very man whom he arraigned at the bar, establishes the truth of his deposition beyond the shadow of a doubt. "Let us wait to see Eaton confronted with A. Burr," was the former cry of Burr's friends. "Let us see what Eaton will dare to say before him, or whether Burr will dare to contradict him." Yet this important confrontation is over, and what is the issue of it? We have seen gen. Eaton, standing in the very front of A. Burr, and under the flashes of that terrible eye which like Medusa's head was to have turned him into stone: but we have seen Eaton rising with the spirit of conscious truth and re-echoing the same charges against A. Burr without hesitation, and without the slightest alarm. We have seen A. Burr writhing under the consciousness of his guilt, and his bleached countenance betraying the agitations of his soul. We have seen Eaton persecuted, by the cross questions of legal ingenuity, but we have seen him turning upon his assailants, and bearing them down, with the consistency and truth of his story. After this who can doubt, that Burr was just as discontented with his situation, and as sanguine and aspiring as Eaton had represented him; that so long as he was doubtful of Eaton's dispositions for his purpose he amused him, with the tale of the Mexican project; but after having thus felt the pulse of his virtue, after having thus attempted to ascertain, how far his temper was lawless enough to acquiesce in this lawless scheme of plunder, and believing at last that he was unprincipled enough for his purposes, that he then began to open to him his favorite and grander scheme of aggrandizement. He talked to him of dismembering the union, of the ease with which he could separate the Western from the Eastern states, and the splendors of a throne at Orleans. He did not reveal these ideas as if they had just been hatched, or as if they would be lightly relinquished. Far from it. He dwelt upon his means. He named individuals whom he had selected for his purposes, and he was prepared to answer every objection which could be made to their accomplishment. After this, who is there sceptic enough to doubt, that this man was at heart a traitor?

His interviews with Mr. Stoddert point to the same conclusion, though with this material difference: that while he manifested the same discontented spirit, and the same contempt for the weakness of the administration which he was afterwards forced to respect, and the same idle confidence in his own means and talents, he did not dare to assail Mr. Stoddert's ear with the details of his plans. He did not designate N. Orleans as the point where he should make his attack; he did not name the persons whom he had chosen for his accomplices, and he seemed to disclose his ideas not as if they were such as he meant to execute, but as those that might be successfully attempted by some daring genius. The reason of this distinction is obvious. He knew that Mr. Stoddert was a man of too much virtue, and of too little means to become an accomplice. Gen. Eaton, on the contrary, was young, he was bold, he had shown a military turn, & his virtues had not yet been probed by Burr.

At Pittsburgh, while he was on his route to the Western country, and under the hospitable roof of the venerable George Morgan, he displays the same bent of mind. In truth, wherever he goes, he is destined like the snail to leave his slime behind him.— It would seem impossible for the mind of man, when seriously bent on any favorite idea, to prevent its bursting forth in continued and indirect indications. Burr's mind was full of war, of arms, of military atchievement, and the disunion of the states. And what were his conversations, and conduct? They were precisely such as might have been expected from this disposition. He could not see a strong man without considering him as a soldier, and wishing that he had a thousand such fellows. His conversation with the young Mr. Morgans before he reached their father's house, his conversations at and after dinner, breathe this predominant spirit. The same plans haunt him at midnight, and he descends at 11 at night with the candle in his hand to the chamber of old Mr. Morgan; for what? Mr. Morgan's ardent virtue stopped his communications, and prevents us from having the full benefit of the disclosure, but there is every reason to believe that his intention was to make the father an instrument in the ruin of his son, and exact from him his consent that this noble minded son should go along with him in his "nefarious" projects to the West. But why should we dwell upon such scenes as these? The whole air of his conversations, at Morganza, and next morning at Washington, was such as was calculated to draw down upon him the worst suspicions of all the Morgans, and to induce them to give the first information to government of his suspicious designs. The complaisant Mr. Julian Dupestre, may indeed deny all these things. But what weight should be given to that man's word, or vigilance of observation, who has to oppose the united testimony of the Morgans, or who upon being asked, whether N. York might not be taken with 500 men, could complaisantly bow assent?

Let us proceed another step in the investigation of this evidence. The next point where we are able to fix this wandering spirit is on Blannerhassett's island. Here it plays the same part; at least if I may calculate the cause by its consequences. Three days after Burr leaves the island, Blannerhassett publishes the Querist. Two circumstances are here calculated to blend Mr. Burr with the guilt or folly of these writings. 1st. That Blannerhassett, the author, was the notorious accomplice of Burr—and 2dly, that the sentiments and very chain of arguments were so similar to those which a witness had a short time before heard from the lips of colonel Burr, that upon being asked who he supposed to be the author; he very sagely replied, that Burr had furnished the ideas, and that Blannerhassett had put them into style.

These writings speak for themselves. No man that reads the Querist can mistake the disposition or design with which they were composed. Writings which display to the people beyond the Alleghany, the imaginary disadvantages of a union with the Atlantic states, which attempt to shew them in how much better condition they would be placed under a government of their own, which persuade them that it is not only a natural right, but a right ingrafted upon the constitution to provide for their own distinct welfare, whoever can mistake the temper of such writings as these from such men, and at such a time, might as well pretend to doubt whether the Declaration of Independence or Common Sense were calculated to promote the revolution of America. No man can doubt them, and no one can pretend to doubt but he who is an accomplice of Burr.

And here it is not improper to give all the weight which they deserve to Blannerhassett's sincere and repeated declarations. From the complex and uncertain code of the law, these declarations may not be received in a court of justice to bear against Burr, but common sense is unable to recognise such an absurd distinction. There are sufficient reasons to satisfy any man, that Burr and Blannerhassett were joint accomplices in a joint undertaking, and that however Burr may have imposed upon the credulity of Blannerhassett, in setting before him the extent of his means, that he fairly represented to him the nature of his plans. Let us then gather these plans from Blannerhassett's declarations, and what are they? Wherever he ventured to be the most frank, his schemes were of the grandest character.

It was not to settle the Ouachita land; nor was it to carry conquest to Mexico; but it was to seize the treasures and arms of Orleans, and by locking up that mouth of the Mississippi, to produce a dissolution of the union, and to establish an independent empire, to the west of the Alleghany. And to whom were these declarations made? Not to such men as Elijah Jones, not to men whom he knew not how to trust; but to such as the Hendersons, and to them too, not in the sportive sallies of his mind; but in the solemnity of retirement, and after he had previously exacted from them a pledge of secrecy. With all that childish garrulity which has been ascribed to him, the simple Blannerhassett could sometimes make distinctions. He was not as fortunate as Burr, in always keeping himself concealed behind the curtain; but like him, he sometimes knew where to be silent. Like him, too, he sometimes mistook his man, as he did in the case of the respectable Hendersons.

Combine with these circumstances, Swartwout's declaration to Gen. W. that there must be some seizing at N. Orleans; the discontented temper of many of the inhabitants of that city; their disposition for a change of government; and the number of friends whom he had there enlisted; recollect the aspiring genius of the man, his desperate fortunes and his vain hope, that the commander in chief and the army would join in with him, and it is impossible to resist the conviction that he would have seized New Orleans if he could*. What were his exact plans we know not; but we may at least guess at some chart, by which he might have steered his course. He might have supposed that he had force enough to descend to New Orleans. He might have passed Fort Massac and the fort at Chickasaw Bluffs, without much opposition. When arrived at New Orleans, he might have expected the aid of Wilkinson and army, and of many, and perhaps most of the inhabitants of that city.

His plan at this point, is not to be mistaken. If his force was large, if the army were sincere in his support—if the inhabitants of New Orleans were prompt and explicit in their attachment, Burr would have unfurled the banners of rebellion. He would have invited adherents from all quarters. He would have lavished the confiscated treasures of this city upon them, and perhaps he would have tried whether by locking up the mouth of the Mississippi, or restricting its navigation, he might not have forced the people of the upper country to have acquiesced in his usurpation. Such would probably have been his plan, or if these things had not turned out so favorable to his wishes, he would then have progressed with his other enterprise; collected arms, provisions and adherents, and attacked Mexico through a sea port as Vera Cruz, or up the Red River. For he frequently contended during his trial that his boats were well fitted for going up the stream.

If such were Burr's plans, was not Burr a traitor at heart? "But he did not commit the overt act, he was not guilty of levying war against the U. States." Perhaps it may be so. But even under this view of the subject, he saves his life at the expence of his reputation. He may still continue to breathe upon the earth; but what of that? Like Cain, he has a mark, that lasts for ever.

We shall hereafter inquire in our strictures on the conduct of the Chief Justice, whether the overt act of levying war was committed at the mouth of Cumberland river. We certainly do not approve of the criterion which the Ch. Justice has laid down on that point.

This mass of evidence is sufficient to convince us that the dismemberment of the union was the first and

* Do not Bollman's confessions to the President amply confirm this idea.

never would have looked to the conquest of Mexico, but in consequence of a fear that he should be disappointed. That object was the next nearest his heart. The host of witnesses who were introduced have proved his attachment to this enterprize; but "this was one" say his advocates "which he would never have meditated but from the prospect of an approaching war with Spain; and never would have executed but in consequence of that war's taking place."

In this we agree with his advocates; that if he had been disappointed in seizing New-Orleans and war had been declared by the United States against Spain, that he might then have attempted to turn his preparations into that channel. Perhaps they will agree with us in this; that if he had such an enterprise in view, the tottering state of our affairs with Spain was calculated to advance that object, by enlisting recruits in his service. But in this we join issue with his advocates; that if there had been no war from the United States, he himself would have attempted to have waged it against Spain on his own account. His friends deny this position and point to the settlement of the Ouachita as the ultimate object of his preparations. This last epithet indeed truly expresses our own opinion of his plans. Can any impartial man believe that he would have retired to the Ouachita until he had exhausted all his other plans? Were his means adopted for agriculture or war? Was his party composed of families or young men? Were they possessed of muskets and bayonets, or ploughshares and hoes? Were they provided with seed corn or kiln-dried meal? But why carry our questions further? Was the man who conducted them better calculated for a farmer or commander? Was the ardor of his desperate ambition to be sooner gratified in the bosom of retirement, and amidst the peaceful harvests of the field, or amidst the din of arms & by mowing of the heads of the Mexicans.

But if these presumptive reasons are not sufficient to remove every doubt, there are three direct facts which must be irresistable. Look at the declarations of Blannerhasset to Peter Taylor. Read the conversation of Comfort Tyler in Blannerhassett's Portico. Look at the testimony of Lemuel Henry who proves that Robert A. New, Burr's intimate friend and the only Virginian we are proud to say who was found under Burr's banners did actually ridicule the idea of a Ouachita settlement; said that it was a good idea to hold out to the world & that it seemed to go down very well.

The man who can resist this force of evidence, must have indeed inherited the soul of an ancient Sceptic.

"And is the settlement of the Ouachita completely out of the question? Did Mr. Burr never intend to visit his land? Why then did he pay so much money to col. Lynch for it?" To this we reply that he did not pay much money to col. Lynch as appears from his evidence, even admitting that there was a perfectly fair contract between them; and 2dly, that the veil which he purchased for his other enterprises was well worth the money which he paid for it; and 3dly, that had those enterprises succeeded, he might have easily have repaid himself from the banks of Orleans or the mines of Mexico. We agree with his advocates in this, that Col. Burr would have retired to the Ouachita as an asylum, but not until all his other schemes had been blasted. How long he would have remained there, is beyond our conjecture, but the probability is, that the Ouachita would have been a germ and not the grave of his ambition, and that being thus planted in the wilderness between Mexico and Orleans, he would have called around him the most desperate and enterprising men from all quarters, and then struck such a blow as would have best suited his means and his wishes. Thanks to the vigilance and energy of the government which has so far defeated his machinations!

Here let us pause. We shall hereafter pursue this subject as in relation to this man's means, to the consequences which are likely to arise out of his conduct, and to the lesson which it should teach us.

See the clipping

Strange bedfellows

The last word: an open letter to Chief Justice Marshall, from the Aurora. In 1804, it asks, would his party have defended Aaron Burr? Would Lee or Martin have been his counsel on an indictment for Hamilton’s murder?

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

Virginia Argus · 4 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AURORA.

LETTER THE FIRST.

See moreSee less

TO JOHN MARSHALL, CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE U STATES.

Sir—The appearance of a letter, addressed to you, in a news-paper, is calculated to excite the curiosity of the public, more than to flatter your vanity—and it is less likely to gratify your feelings, than to excite anticipations of pain, too strong to leave the slightest promise of pleasure. You could have dispensed with the honor of this address, without regret or mortification, and consoled yourself for the want of a proper appreciation of your virtues and talents, with the fruits of their exertion. But you have an equal title to both, and the justice of the public will pay that tribute to your worth, which your modesty would willingly decline.

Your country sir, owes you a debt of gratitude for former favors. The addition of a new item to the account, naturally produces a recurrence to them, and a wish to settle the added amount of the whole. This, I fear, is beyond the ability of your debtor, because the whole stock of national indignation and contempt would be exhausted, before the half of your just claim could be discharged.

But in the distribution of that infamy, and detestation, which will certainly be divided among those, who have long labored, with a zealous ardour which nothing could abate, and a patient industry which no difficulties could tire, for the destruction of our republican institutions, the subvertion of our government, and the erection of tyranny, upon the tomb of freedom, you, as a principal creditor, shall not be forgotten.

If, sir, the exertion of your abilities had been confined to the defence of measures incompatible with the spirit of republican government, or to the mysteries of diplomatic agency, one of the virtues, which most strongly marks your political character, would have flourished and died in obscurity; the invincible strength of your attachment to federal principles. Your worst enemies, and best friends must now acknowledge the fidelity of your attachments, and bear testimony to the uniform consistency of your conduct.

The wisdom of age, has confirmed and sanctioned the choice of youth. The examination and trial of Aaron Burr for treason, and misdemeanor, have furnished you with a happy opportunity, not only to display this hidden virtue to the world, but of exercising the endless variety of your talents.

The superiority of your understanding, the force of your penetration, the strength of your judgment, in conducting the manoeuvres of a political party, have already been displayed and admired, while their application was deplored and detested. Your diplomatic skill and crafty cunning cannot be doubted by any, who recollect, that you have passed even the "X. Y. Z." of ministerial exercises. The facility with which you can "answer" the plainest questions with evasive obscurity, to conceal your opinions from the people, whose organ and representative you wished to be, has been recorded in pages consecrated by the "holy enthusiasm" of exalted genius and pure patriotism. You have not lived in vain. By exciting the genius and talents and indignation of John Thompson you have conferred an unintended benefit on your country, and have added, to the literary glory of Virginia, a ray of lustre, which will shine, when even the splendor of your talents and your crimes shall have faded forever. When your volumes* of apology for British insolence and cruelty, shall be buried in oblivion, the "letters of Curtius" will tell posterity that you existed; and "damn you to everlasting fame."

Your ingenuity in the interpretation of the laws, and the discreet and useful management of that sound discretion, confided to those who ought to be the organs of the true intention and meaning of the legislator, and the impartial dispensers of justice, have been reserved for an occasion worthy of their exertion even by a chief justice, the friend and favorite of John Adams.

An opportunity of doing an essential service to the cause of federalism so seldom occurs, that it would be an injustice to your understanding to suppose that you did not instantly perceive, and to your zeal that you did not improve, that which the projects of Burr has presented. But you have even surpassed the expectation of many of your own party. This, I attribute, not only to the motives which have hitherto guided the movements of that party, and yourself, but to the operation of feelings strongly excited. I do not suppose, that you weakly yield to the effusions of tenderness, or the ebullitions of passion, when they are opposed by your sober judgment, but that, like a wise man, you only indulge them, when it can be safely done without counteracting the superior views of interest or ambition.

It is natural that men, who have long labored to effect the same purpose, although by different means, should sympathise in their mutual sufferings, when disappointed and defeated. A similarity of pursuits, constantly causes a concurrence of sentiments and feelings. A speculative difference in opinions is lost and forgotten, in the pursuits of a common object. Even the leaders of opposed factions, can forget their enmity, and unite their forces, to resist the cause of virtue, and to repel its superior power when it threatens their destruction. It is not, therefore, strange, that you should be affected by the sufferings of Aaron Burr, or should feel a disposition to alleviate them.

Nothing can more aptly illustrate the principles of the federal party, or demonstrate their designs, than a fair exposition of their conduct towards Aaron Burr. The naked deformity of that conduct, has disgusted many who were delighted with the shining robe which had once concealed it. The worthy men of that party, who had been deceived by the pretences and ostensible motives of men, whose real designs were not to "give energy to the government," but slavery to the people, have been awakened from the dreams of federal intoxication, by the severe shock of treason—They have fled with the utmost precipitation.—For good men of every party will unite in their detestation of an action, which, without reference to party, or to names, is in itself immoral, criminal, and wicked.

The spirit which fired the breasts of the federal leaders, and the unhallowed flame that burnt the bosom of Burr, were seen to approach the sphere of each other's attraction. The similiarity of their appearance was marked, the same in colours, shades, and shapes, it was obvious that they were only separated particles of the same body, and would immediately unite. Every atom of honesty, attached to federalism, instantly receded from the detestable union. Recollect, sir, the conduct of your party towards Aaron Burr in 1804,—recollect your own

Was he then their friend, would any one of the party have then volunteered in his defence? Would Lee, or Martin, have been heard as his counsel, on an indictment for the murder of Hamilton? Would you have bailed him, during his examination, for that offence?

What has Burr done since the commission of that crime to atone for it? What has been his "peace offering?" I answer—treason against his country.

Ignorant of the satanic services he was meditating, and counting the death of Hamilton a clear loss; they loaded him with curses and execrations, whom they now cherish and defend, and within a few days have pardoned †

You have eaten of the same bread, and drank of the same cup, after solemnly deciding the probability of his guilt, and the remembrance of his former sins is lost in the magnitude of his present crimes against his country ‡ The "small still voice" of murder is not heard amidst the shouts of treason. Your party with the warmth of sincerity, shake his hand, stained, wet, and chilled with the blood of a former friend; all sense of prior attachments, and the blackest criminality, are overwhelmed by the tide of gratitude for bold attempts to divide the U. States, and to subvert the government.

The general character of your party justified a suspicion, that the projects of Burr would receive their aid, because the object of both was the destruction of our present government. That suspicion has been confirmed by their late conduct, which has developed the designs and demonstrated the tendency of their principles, beyond the possibility of rational doubt. The conduct of the party has been the subject of common observation, and trite remark. But no individual has been marked by particular animadversion. The distinguished part you have acted, and the masterly manner in which you have supported it, gave you a title to separate consideration, and particular attention. A separate critique is due to the chief juggler, while a general remark is all that can be claimed, by such pitiful puppets as Blennerhasset and Dayton, Lee and Martin.

* The life of Washington. O "profanitas impia tituli."

† Nolle prosequi has been entered in Bergen county, Jersey, under the plea of defects in the indictment.

‡ At the house of Jno. Wickham in Richmond.

The collected merits, of your conduct during the examination and trial of Burr, have not failed to make a proper impression on the public mind, although many of the separate parts have lost their divided and peculiar flavour, in the combined sweetness of the whole. The distinct tastes of the component parts, shall yet feast the palate of the public.

In another letter, I shall remark upon your conduct on the examination of Aaron Burr for treason and misdemeanor, and I solemnly undertake to shew, that you have rendered the administration of justice suspected—that you have manifested a partiality disgraceful to the character of a judge—and that you have prostrated the dignity of the chief justice of the U. S.

These serious charges will meet the attention of the public, and will command even your consideration. If they are groundless, the voice of the public by honorably acquitting you, will condemn me. The severity of truth will probably wound your feelings and excite the hatred and animosity, of your friends, and party. But, sir, the best interests of the nation must not be sacrificed to the feelings of any man. I shall not regard the threats and menaces of your friends, nor an affected contempt, or an impudent and hardy denial of facts by yourself.

Whether the whole of your conduct has been guided by personal considerations, private friendship, or by party spirit—or a determined hatred and hostility to the government and the laws, is not for me to determine. I do not wish to dive into your breast. Your warmest friends cannot attribute to personal enmity, or private pique, the animadversions of a man, who never exchanged a word with you, and who, so far as he is acquainted with your private character, will bear testimony to its correctness.

Every good man must deplore the blind zeal, the mad infatuation, which have turned your transcendant talents against your country, and rendered you a disgrace to the bench of justice. You might have been loved for your virtues, revered and respected for your wisdom, and admired for your talents; you might have been one of the boasted patriots of Virginia, and the illustrious benefactor of your own species. But you have chosen to be among the leaders of a faction, who would be as faithless to you to morrow, as they are to Hamilton this day, had they no prospect of deriving advantages from the use of you—a faction remarkable for nothing, but rancorous animosity, violent opposition to the government of their country, and to the choice of the people; and for their daring attempts, by intrigue and violence, to destroy the liberty and happiness of America:—You must deplore in secret the choice you have made.

It is not necessary to the establishment of my charges against you, that I should shew a breach of legal forms: It is the spirit of justice, and the meaning of the laws, which you have violated and disregarded. I complain that only the forms remain. Even Brumley, Jeffries, and Mansfield, as well as Marshall, said they respected the forms of law.—Nor will it be expected, that in arraigning you at the bar of the public, I shall preserve the accurate precision of a special pleader.

If my accusation is substantially true, and plainly set forth, I shall be permitted to disregard those technical forms, which serve only to protect some persons who uphold them, from the punishment due to their crimes. However informal the accusation, and dull the arguments may be, I shall be honored with the attention of the public, because the honor and dignity of the highest judicial officer of the U. States, are involved in the issue.

LUCIUS.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: The Western Plot