As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

The Reckoning

August – November 1804

Hamilton was dead and Burr had fled New York. For the rest of the summer the papers argued over who was to blame, and that fall a New Jersey grand jury indicted Burr for murder. He was still the sitting Vice-President: until his term ran out, one writer said, ‘his life was not his own.’ By March 1805 the papers were calling him the ‘late Vice-President.’

Burr’s enemies cry murder

The American Citizen charges that Hamilton fell victim to ‘a wicked system of deadly hostility, planned by Mr. Burr and his friends.’ Citing ‘one of the DAVISES,’ it says twelve to fifteen of Burr’s friends had met at night before the late election and formed a company of duellists, with Hamilton ‘the first victim.’ About six weeks ago, it adds, three of Burr’s friends combed the files of the Morning Chronicle for a pretext for the challenge.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 4 August 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AMERICAN CITIZEN.

GENERAL HAMILTON'S DEATH——We now propose to shew, from the correspondence published, from other testimony as yet concealed from the publick eye, and from various circumstances of known authenticity and moment, that this unfortunate gentleman has fallen a victim to a wicked system of deadly hostility, planned by Mr. Burr and his friends, and rigidly carried into execution. Attention will be requisite to a due comprehension of the necessary chain of argument and of facts, but when this is viewed in its natural and connected order, the conclusion already mentioned, it is conceived, will be the irresistible and inevitable consequence. By this the publick will determine how far a faction, pursuing projects so bloody, for ends so calamitous, merit their countenance and support.

See moreSee less

For some months back I have been alarmed for the safety, and troubled with fearful presentiments of the danger with which a melancholy event has but too conclusively proved GENERAL HAMILTON was environed. During this period menaces have in whispers been denounced, by those who enjoy the confidence and best knew the secret purposes of Mr. Burr, against this child of genius, this pride and boast of the bar, this ornament of the country. Although not apt to be alarmed by threats, yet, calmly reflecting on all its circumstances, I could not, in this case, avert apprehension. A correct perception of right, a faithful performance of his duty, in a case in which allusion is sufficient for all the purposes of knowledge, had more than ever excited the implacable resentment and aroused the slumbering indignation of Mr. Burr. The circumstance to which I allude had involved him in perplexities so fatal to his aspiring hopes, so blasting to his darling pursuits of personal aggrandizement, that nothing short of the DEATH of HAMILTON could glut his vengeance. Alas! he has at length succeeded. Wrapt up in himself——to appease his resentment, to gratify his ambition, he is capable of wading through the blood of his fellow citizens and of laughing at the lamentations of widows and orphans.

It has for some time been intimated by many of Mr. Burr's friends, in language that could not be misunderstood by those who have calmly observed their conduct for two or three years back, that GENERAL HAMILTON must fall by the hand of Mr. Burr. The reasons assigned by this gentleman's friends for the fatal threat, were precisely those urged by Mr. Burr in his correspondence with the deceased. It was stated that GENERAL HAMILTON had either himself propagated, or had some how encouraged the propagation of what these gentlemen were pleased to term slanders, traducing what they denominated his honour and fame. It was impossible, they said, that Mr. Burr, distinguished for his bravery and known from his constant practice to be a good shot, should be so indifferent to reputation as not to call him to an account. Besides, GENERAL HAMILTON, although, perhaps, the most formidable opponent, was not the only one whose death was meditated by Mr. Burr and those with whom he confidentially associated.—They avowed their intention to accomplish if possible, by acts of desperation, by spilling the blood of their fellow citizens, those, on their opinion, desirable objects which by other means they could not attain. For some time previous to the late election, from twelve to fifteen of these bloody villains assembled together in the night, and, under injunctions of secrecy and pledges of mutual support, planned the diabolical work and selected for destruction those who were viewed as the most formidable obstacles in the way of Mr. Burr's designs. In one word, it was their determination to fight their way through an host of opposition which could not, in their opinion, be subdued without blood! The publick will scarcely credit this plain narration of a horrible scene; but I have the authority of one of the DAVISES for it; and this is confirmed by all the circumstances which led to and accompanied the death of GENERAL HAMILTON, as well as by others which are here well known to have existed a little anteriour to and during the election. To a gentleman who mentioned the fact to me, one of the Davises stated, in express terms, and in a tone and temper indicative of seriousness and courage, for which he has no reputation, that a company of Mr. Burr's friends had formed a regular association on principles, and for the express purpose of duelling, and that they were determined to accomplish by this system of terrour and of blood, what they could not without it. It was triumphantly remarked by the friends of Mr. Burr, when gentlemen called for the author of Aristides and the editor of the Corrector, that if personal satisfaction only was wanted, from twelve to fifteen stood ready to give it. This is a fact well known to many. The twelve or fifteen mentioned were the duellists systematically organized into a company with the approbation, if not under the eye of Mr. Burr. GENERAL HAMILTON, however, was to be the first victim. He was, in their opinion, the greatest offender: he was therefore, at all events, to be despatched.

These are some of the exertions of a system of determined hostility more amply unfolded by Mr. Burr in his correspondence with the deceased, and which will become more and more irresistible to the senses as we pass it in review. We must previously, however, advert to a circumstance which, when viewed in connexion with the letters of Mr. Burr, will evince preconcert and design, and a perfect understanding among him and his friends, that a demand on General Hamilton should be made so general and indefinite in nature and terms as that no explanation could be given or apology received.

From what has been said and what we know, it may be fairly inferred, that, by preconcert and arrangement among Mr. Burr and his friends, it was some time ago determined that General Hamilton should at all events be challenged by Mr. Burr. The removal of this great man was, in the opinion of his antagonist, essential to the accomplishment of various selfish purposes. A temporary, a mistaken; may I not say, a fatal support given to him at the late election, had induced the belief (certainly a false one) that nothing was necessary to insure to him the exclusive management of the federal party, but the death of their highly honorable and distinguished leader; for of this fatal end, if an interview (no matter by what means) could be effected, he calculated with confidence and certainty. He no doubt too concluded, together with his friends with whom he advised, that "so unfavourable an event of things," to borrow the affecting language of the DECEASED, would strike terror into our citizens—abash opposition, and rid himself of a witness distinguished for integrity and truth, and commanding implicit belief.

Having determined on the challenge, it became necessary to seek for a cause, specious if not just. The first step taken was to examine the files of the Morning Chronicle, in order to discover something on which a challenge might be colourably predicated. For this purpose, about six weeks ago, three of Mr. Burr's friends, (whose names are mentioned to me) anxiously examined, at the office a file of the Chronicle and marked in its pages various paragraphs. Whether they found Dr. Cooper's letter or not, or how or by whom it was placed in Mr. Burr's hands, is not for me to say.

(TO BE CONTINUED.)

See the clipping

Did Burr ever check the rumor?

The American Citizen’s case continues, and asks the question at the root of it all. Burr risked a man’s life over a letter from a Dr. Cooper of Albany. Did he ever make sure Cooper really wrote it?

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 August 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The paper headed this “Continued from our last”, meaning it continues a piece begun in its previous issue.

FROM THE AMERICAN CITIZEN.

[CONTINUED FROM OUR LAST.]

See moreSee less

GENERAL HAMILTON'S DEATH.—If additional facts were necessary to evince that GENERAL HAMILTON'S fall is the inevitable effect of predetermined hostility; of combinations unprecedented in their form, and for purposes unequalled in the annals of individual calamity, we are abundantly furnished with them in the gross, yet seemingly subtle, letters, of him whose cruel hand has infused sorrow into every heart, and cast an awful gloom over the dawning hopes of a hapless family. An examination of these letters alone, unconnected with correlative circumstances, will satistactorily shew the unjust and undivertible purpose of Mr. Burr.

The extrinsick cause of the challenge is a letter said to have been written by Dr. Cooper of Albany, in April last. The pretended offensive passages in this letter are these; and as they are made the grounds of an event deeply affecting the feelings of the nation, and greatly add irreparably injuring the family of the deceased, they merit and will receive the attention of all good men.

"General Hamilton and Judge Kent," says Dr. Cooper, "have declared, in substance, that they looked upon Mr. Burr "to be a dangerous man, and one who "ought not to be trusted with the reins of "government."

In another part of his letter, addressing himself to Gen. Schuyler, he says,

"Really, Sir, I could detail to you a "still more despicable OPINION which General Hamilton has expressed of Mr. "Burr."

These are the passages, and the only passages, of which Mr. Burr complains, and which he made the foundation of his challenge.

We now offer to establish, by argument, that, if Dr. Cooper's letter be really and solely the cause of the demand which Mr. Burr made for explananation, his subsequent challenge is a direct, powerful, and highly dangerous attack on the dearest privileges of the electors of this state; one that every man is imperiously called upon to resist with alacrity and vigour; and that General Hamilton has gloriously terminated an illustrious life in the defence of freedom of opinion, freedom of speech, and freedom of the press.

The first thing which, in this discussion, naturally offers itself for consideration is were the letters, ascribed to Dr. Cooper and Made by Mr. Burr the basis of a challenge, actually written by him; for although the presumption is in favour of the affirmative, yet, in a case of life and death, and that too of self-willing, the enquiry ought not to be considered, and cannot reasonably be considered, as an unnecessary and punctilious preliminary, but of prerequisite and indispensable ascertainment. If by fair argument it can be satisfactorily establised that there exists even a possibility of Dr. Cooper's not being the writer of that letter, it will unavoidably result, admitting Mr. Burr has reasoned correctly on the subject, that he has been guilty of cruel and deliberate murder: for in this our contemplation he has killed a fellow-creature without justifiable cause, and with malice aforethought.

The news-papers containing the letter ascribed to Dr. Cooper was published in April but a few days preceding the commencement of the election. It is dated April 23d. This circumstance is of some moment.

The news-paper, it appears, as acknowledged by Mr. Van Ness, was put into the hands of Mr. Burr, at least six weeks subsequent to the termination of the election.

Mr. Van Ness also admits that Mr. Burr was "urged by the evident opinion of his friends," to call on General Hamilton for an explanation of what was fondly viewed as offensive passages in Dr. Cooper's letter.

After all the arguments of incitation to an interview, "urged by his friends," had been exhausted, and they had retired, it could not but occur to a mind, so confessedly perspicacious as that of Mr. Burr, that this letter, signed Charles D. Cooper, which my friends have, with so much zeal and affection, put into my hands, may be a forgery.—This is certainly possible, and because it is possible it is all essential, ere I make it the basis of a challenge that may lead me to take away the life of a fellow-creature, to ascertain its genuineness by application to Dr. Cooper himself, for he only can determine this point. In money affairs forgeries ere committed; and in political intrigues, for party or selfish purposes, we are not, at elections, strangers

[NO. 11.]

to these iniquitous frauds. I cannot, as a man of honour, call on General Hamilton for an explanation of the offensive passages until I am explicitly told, by Dr. Cooper himself, that he is the writer of the letter containing them. It is fair to suppose that these, or similar reflections would, on an occasion so solemn, occur to every rational man.

But there were known circumstances accompanying the publication of the letter ascribed to Dr. Cooper; and next before it in the same column, was published one from General Schuyler, materially contradicting the exceptionable assertions of the former. The letter of General Schuyler was obviously published with a view to acquit General Hamilton of expressions unfavourable to Mr. Burr. If then General Schuyler was correct, it is clear that erroneous opinions were ascribed to General Hamilton in the letter signed Charles D. Cooper: and as all admit that the character of this gentleman (well known to Col. Burr) effectually shields him from conduct so improper, there existed, even on this ground, good cause to doubt the genuineness of the letter.

The longer we reflect on this part of Mr. Burr's conduct, the more we shall be convinced of his fatal and unavertable purpose. To me it is self-evident that his motives were malignant and sanguinary; his object death. He had not the least justifiable cause to call on General Hamilton for an explanation. The first step taken was radically wrong. He owed it to himself, he owed it to the deceased, he owed it to the country to ascertain the genuineness of the letter ascribed to Dr. Cooper, before he called on GENERAL HAMILTON to avow or disavow their offensive passages.

We will, however, suppose (what cannot be correct) that Mr. Burr, without this previous and necessary enquiry, was uneringly convinced of the genuineness of the letters; it remains then to examine the manner of the disclosure and the nature of the pretended offence:

The offence is this.

"General Hamilton and Judge Kent have "declared, in substance, that they "looked upon Mr. Burr to be a dangerous man, one who ought not to be trusted "with the reigns of government,"

Again. "I could detail a still more despicable OPINION which General Hamilton "has expressed of Mr. Burr." Such is the offence; the ground of the challenge, and the exteriour cause of the death of one of the greatest geniuses of the age.

The reader will bear in mind that Dr. Cooper wrote two letters. The first contained this passage above quoted—"General Hamilton (for we shall now lay Judge Kent aside) has declared, in substance, that he looked upon Mr. Burr to be a dangerous man" &c. Mr. Burr is a subscriber to the evening Post, and, (especially during the late election) was regularly served with it. The first letter of Dr. Cooper was published in the Evening Post of April 28. It is therefore highly probable that Mr. Burr was on that day apprised of the opinion which it ascribes to GENERAL HAMILTON. The second, in which Dr. Cooper says he could "detail a still more despicable opinion which GENERAL HAMILTON had expressed of Mr. Burr," never appeared in any of our city papers until within a few days.

The first letter contains the foundation of the pretended offence. The second has exclusive reference to the first, and simply states that GENERAL HAMILTON had expressed a still more despicable opinion than that before mentioned. What then is the opinion contained in the first? for if that is not improper, not reprehensible, not dishonourable, not such as to justify the end, it may truly and with confidence be affirmed that the second, which simply imports that he had expressed a more despicable opinion, (but without specifying what) could not; for, as correctly and pertinently remarked by General Hamilton, the words, more despicable, admit of "infinite shades, from very light to very dark."

This opinion is that Mr. Burr is a dangerous man, and ought not to be trusted with the reins of government.

Let it for a moment be admitted (but for argument sake only) that the expression of that opinion is a justifiable Cause of challenge; I may then ask to whom, in strictness of speech, the opinion truly belongs, to Dr. Cooper or General Hamilton? To the former, undoubtedly.

(TO BE CONTINUED)

See the clipping

A friend answers for Hamilton

Burr’s side had charged Hamilton with ‘a settled and implacable malevolence.’ In a letter to the editor dated New-York, 28 July 1804, his friend Samuel Bayard answers with an account of a conversation in 1801, to show that Hamilton bore Burr no personal malice.

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Enquirer · 11 August 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

(From the Evening Post.)

New-York, July 28, 1804.

See moreSee less

To the Editor.

"In one of the papers introduced by Mr. V. N. in the correspondence which terminated in an event, which every real friend to his country must ever deplore, I observe the illustrious deceased, charged with "a settled and implacable malevolence" and with "committing secret depredations on Mr. Burr's fame and character."

"Opposed to this, are the declarations contained in the paper written by Gen. Hamilton immediately prior to the fatal interview with his antagonist—those made in his last moments, to the Rev. Bishop Moore—and the whole tenor of his conduct and conversation for many years past.

"To those who had the happiness of being most intimately acquainted with Gen. Hamilton, it were needless to state, that "distinct from political opposition proceeding from the most pure and upright motives," there is every ground for believing that he never did harbour the least degree of personal ill will towards Col. Burr—they well know that such was the General's native and distinguished magnanimity—such his superiority to selfish competitions and private interests—such his unalterable goodness of heart, and universal philanthrophy, that the charge of "settled and implacable malevolence" is as little attributable to him as it would be to a Howard or a Washington.

"Yet, lest any one from not knowing the elevation of his mind and the purity of his motives, should attach a degree of credit to the charge alluded to, I feel myself called upon in justice to a character which I shall ever venerate and love, to state the substance of a conversation I had with this excellent man a few years ago, but which is still fresh in my recollection.

"Some time early in the year 1801, while the question of, who should be President of the United States, Mr. Jefferson or Col. Burr, was yet undetermined by the House of Representatives, having one day called on Gen. Hamilton and finding him alone and disengaged I had a full and free conversation with him on the pending election, then the topic of the day. The respective qualifications of the two candidates for the Presidency, and the probable consequences likely to result from the election of the one or the other were considered. The Gen. did not for a moment conceal his decided preference for Mr. Jefferson; the reasons however, which led to this preference arose wholly from a regard to the public welfare.

"In the course of the conversation, I could not forbear noticing that his feelings had been wounded by an idea, which he learnt, had gone abroad, that his preference of Mr. Jefferson had arisen from motives of personal antipathy to Col. Burr. He did not merely disclaim the sentiments as unworthy and totally false, but entered fully into considerations to show that if motives of personal feelings could have influenced his judgement, they would have operated rather to the prejudice of the former than the latter of these Gentlemen.

"He observed in substance, that during the eventful administration of our first president, on various questions of the last importance to the country which arose from the critical circumstances in which our government was then placed frequent collision of sentiment had existed between Mr. Jefferson and himself, and that for several years they had been competitors for the respect and confidence, not merely of the first Magistrate of the Union, but of the National Legislature and the country at large.—That between himself and Col. Burr, no personal competition could be supposed to exist, unless at the bar; but here, their respective circle of connections and sources of business were separated by so broad a line of distinction, that any interference, or rivalship on this ground, was incredible to a person of reflection. That if competition existed any where it was more likely to take place between himself and the more eminent counsel in the federal interest, than with Col. Burr. For the talents of this gentleman as an advocate, he professed a high respect; but as a political character, he frankly avowed the opinion, that if elected to the Presidency of the United States, Col. Burr would greatly disappoint the expectations of those gentlemen in Congress, who with the best views, were endeavouring to advance him to the highest office in the United States.

"In the whole of this conversation not a word escaped Gen. Hamilton in any degree indicative of the sentiment of "malevolence" towards Col. Burr; had it existed, it would not probably have been disguised, when, from the period, and confidential nature of the conversation, every ground of objection to the election of Col. Burr would have been stated by Gen. Hamilton, that impressed his own or was likely to influence the mind of another. I remain, Sir, with respect & esteem, your most obedient servant.

SAMUEL BAYARD."

See the clipping

Will it end dueling?

A Maine paper prints a mourning poem addressed to Hamilton’s killer and asks what everyone is asking: will Hamilton’s death make dueling respectable, or finish it? Hamilton himself, the writer says, was against it.

Jenks' Portland Gazette · Portland, Me.

Jenks' Portland Gazette · 13 August 1804 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

From the Newyork Citizen.

OH! if that muse who fir'd Matilda's* line, For once would shed her fervid glow on mine, Swift as the vivid lightning's rapid course, Strong as the cataract's impetuous force, My animated verse should rise to Heaven, Another Alexander to be given. That him we mourn, may view from realms above, How much he shar'd his country's warmest love— How sad we mourn his loss, how deep deplore Our brightest star that's set, to rise no more, Till the last trump shall sound on that great day, When HAMILTON—disrob'd of mortal clay— At God's right hand shall sit, with face benign, And at his murderer cast a look divine. For what wise purpose did the almighty stay His avenging rod on that eventful day? Why struck he not the murderer to the ground, Who could with coolness aim so deep a wound? Who could with sullen disappointment's gloom Plot for his country so reverse a doom, And with malignant envy'd direful hand Deluge in tears Columbia's happy land; Tear from a much lov'd wife her bosom friend, Cause her, alas! with sorrow to descend, Into that grave where all her joys now lie: Ah, little reptile! know'st thou too must die? And when thou'rt writhing on that awful bed, And view the widow by her orphans led, Think'st thou their tears will not some pangs impart. Or has remorse fed thy obdurate heart? Columbia calls aloud, what have you done? Genius demands from you a fav'rite son. Give her her Hamilton, and thou may'st fly To other climes, and there, detested die.

See moreSee less

*The celebrated Mrs Robinson. Anna Matilda.

Moralist.

What will be the consequence of the late event which terminated in the death of general Hamilton in a moral point of view, is a question of serious importance, and one to which we turn our attention with satisfaction. Will that event encourage, or discountenance the unhappy practice of duelling, so alarming to the future welfare of our country? General Hamilton fell! by the hand of a duellist. Then, says a superficial observer, his whole weight of character will go to justify the practice; and to be like Hamilton will be deemed necessary to expose or take life.

But we are happy to find that the impression on the public mind is more correct, and essentially different. General Hamilton has left both his precepts and example against the murderous custom. His precepts are striking, explicit, under the seal of religion and the solemnity of his dying appeal. His example is a partial illustration of his sense of religious and moral duty, for he fell by the hand of a MURDERER, whom he had no intention to harm, and whom he did not meet, as a duellist.

Why then did general Hamilton expose his life to the fury of a disappointed, exasperated, and blood thirsty duellist! If we are to believe a dying man, and one speaking under the full impression of future accountability, his motives were of a public nature—they were such as induced him to expose his life before, on the field of battle—public good. However it might be, it appeared to him that his foes, without that critical experiment, would oppose prejudices which he could not destroy, to his future usefulness. Is not this satisfactory? Who ever will be in the situation, or have the excuse of a Hamilton? If this is not enough there is more to be said. He trembled lest his example might be thought to authorize violations of the law of God—he implored forgiveness—he asked mercy of heaven nor did he die in peace until his scruples were reposed in the merits of the Redeemer.

What inference therefore can we draw, from the character and conduct of the illustrious Hamilton, but such as give confidence to religion, and support to virtue.—Repertory.

See the clipping

Burr on the run

Burr has slipped out of New York. Reported last week to be in South Carolina, he has in fact crossed New Jersey to Philadelphia, where, the paper says, he is ‘parading himself.’ Tributes to Hamilton fill every column.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 17 August 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From Newspaper intelligence, we supposed it in our last to be ascertained that Col. Burr, since his murder of Gen. Hamilton, had escaped to South Carolina—It now appears, that by a clandestine march through New-Jersey, he has only got on to Philadelphia, and has been parading himself in that City.

The papers received this week abound with fresh records of public veneration for the deceased Hamilton—Among these the most eminent are the solemn rites performed by the State Society of Cincinnati in New-York, with the notice of a very distinguished funeral oration, delivered at their request, by the rev. Mr. Mason, last week—In Boston too every honor has been rendered to the memory of one to whom honor was pre-eminently due—It is sufficient to mention these, to shew how the same sentiment is kept up and has been generally extended—But it is absolutely impossible for us to recount all the various forms and places in which the fate of General Hamilton has been bewailed by his country, and the evidences of glowing respect and gratitude towards him, which have been and still are manifested.

See moreSee less

We have already fully expressed the detestation and horror with which we view Mr. Burr in the late deplorable transaction—It is not our design now to renew the subject—The last number of Mr. Coleman's examination before mentioned, recapitulating the essence of the whole, we shall probably at the next convenient moment republish, to shew how we must be further rivetted in those opinions we have already expressed.—But a special reason now here induces us to proclaim again that we are more and more confirmed in our feelings on this subject—We particularly desire it to be distinctly understood as the independent, decided, and we will say unalterable, sentiment of this paper that the crime, the abominable savageness of Col. Burr is without extenuation, and ought to suffer an exemplary, ignominious punishment; and that with respect to the degree in which we shall always esteem and lament the illustrious victim of his malice, we do most conscientiously believe that our lost Hamilton was beyond all comparison of rivalry, the very first of all the worthies of this nation—We do not conceive indeed that there is in any part of the world a public character with a combination of greatness superior to his—In our own country there are indeed undoubtedly many great men, possibly a few, equal to what Gen. Hamilton was in some one of the particular separate branches of his eminence, here one equal to him may be in one respect, and there another: But where shall we find, or rather we shall look in vain, for any man nearly or any thing like his equal, viewed in the whole compound character?—This was his grand excellence—His established fame was of many kinds; and altogether his vast superiority was when alive surely always felt, or confessed and acknowledged—In the Federal party for instance, there are yet many survivors for whom we entertain the highest proper respect—but none—no not one, who can pretend to stand on the towering height, or approach to where Hamilton stood—Among those survivors, respectable as they are, there will now be found perhaps a dozen or twenty: to whom the first rank will be differently assigned; different followers may now have in their regard a different leader; it will puzzle many indeed, and us among the number, to say who is the chief leader—Whereas, when Hamilton was among us, there was never a doubt or dispute, all agreed that he stood foremost among the fore, none presumed to consider himself a competitor, and all bowed down, whether friends or foes, to his ascendant and master genius—This surely may be said and yet repeated, without appearing to deify Gen. Hamilton; tho' as to that we might indeed say too, that, had he lived in Pagan times, Pagan admiration would certainly have deified him far beyond a host of Tutelaries—What we have advanced now and hereafter can, it is to be hoped, will be no disparagement or offence with any liberal or unsophisticated mind; and if even a secret discontent of this nature should any where strangely infuse itself, what we have advanced is yet not at all less the plain voice of truth—of truth, which will be unyielding, and inflexible and loud. [Frederick Town Herald.]

See the clipping

A defense, of sorts

In Richmond a writer condemns Burr for fighting at all: until his term ran out, a sitting Vice-President’s life ‘was not his own—it was the public’s.’ He is no kinder to Hamilton, whose last statement made the case against dueling and still would not ‘decline the call.’

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Virginia Argus · 18 August 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE TRENTON TRUE AMERICAN.

THOUGHTS ON THE LATE DUEL.

See moreSee less

Mr. WILSON,

As there have in my opinion been some pains taken to present the late fatal affair to the public in an unfair light, and to convert it into a mean of effecting improper political purposes, I have thrown together some thoughts on the subject just as they occurred to me ; and hope, should you see fit to publish them, they will have a tendency to place the matter in a proper point of view, and prevent unjust impressions.

Col. Burr cannot be justified for challenging and fighting a duel with Gen. Hamilton, principally,

Because the practice is obnoxious to divine and human laws:

Because Mr. Burr, from his elevated station, and the influence his example might have, was especially bound to obey and respect those laws:

Because until the expiration of the time for which he was elected, his life was not his own—it was the public's—and he had no right to risk it in a private quarrel.

For these and some subordinate reasons, Col. Burr's conduct cannot, in my mind, be justified.

Yet those who consider the practice of avenging one's own injuries by the mode of duelling as proper, and believe that a magistrate owes no deference to the opinion, or regard to the honor of his constituents, cannot consistently condemn the conduct of Col. Burr.

It is a well known fact that Gen. Hamilton has long been in the habit of censuring the conduct and criminating the motives of Col. Burr, with a freedom uncommon, perhaps unjustifiable between gentlemen and competitors. Gen. Hamilton acknowledges in the paper which he left behind him, that "his animadversions on the political principles, character and views of Col. Burr have been extremely severe, and on different occasions he, in common with many others, has made very unfavorable criticisms on particular instances of the private conduct of that gentleman." He cofesses that Col. Burr has "doubtless heard of animadversions of his that bore very hard upon him ; and that it is probable that as usual they were accompanied by some falsehoods." He confesses that "it is possible in some particulars he may have been influenced by misconstruction or misinformation," and that "it is possible he may have injured Col. Burr."—Yet in reply to Col. Burr's first note, which any gentleman might with propriety have written, and which I think Gen. Hamilton might without disgrace have satisfactorily answered, the latter not only refuses any satisfactory explanation, but throws out a kind of defiance, that he will abide the consequences. By this expression he cuts off Col. Burr's retreat, for had he not then challenged Gen. Hamilton, those who now curse him the most bitterly, would then have ridiculed him the most severely, and reproached him the most clamorously.

As to General Hamilton's being, as is frequently asserted by his frends, compelled to take the field, I cannot discern any compulsion. I believe that acknowledgments from Gen. Hamilton, going but little further than those which he made in the paper he left behind him, that "he might have been influenced in what he said of Mr. Burr by misconstruction or misinformation," and that "he might possibly have injured him," I say I believe that acknowledgments something more explicit than these would have satisfied Col. Burr, and I do not think they would have disgraced Gen. Hamilton. Or if the General's feelings would not permit him to make any acknowledgment, could he not have justified his refusal of a challenge by explaining its inconsistency with his "religious and moral principles," the injury his "wife and children" might suffer, the injustice his "creditors" might sustain, and the want of any "ill will" against the challenger ?—Was not his character for courage too firmly established, to be shaken by such a refusal ?—Or need he have sacrificed his fear of God, his love of his country, his affection for his wife and chilcen, his reverence for the laws, and every other important consideration, to the apprehension that without such a sacrifice his courage would be suspected ?

I conceive that Gen. Hamilton was subject to no compulsion—that his conduct was perfectly voluntary—and that his friends disgrace his memory when they attempt to excite popular resentment against his opponent by asserting that he was wholly and solely to blame. Sufficient is the weight of guilt which must rest on his shoulders, without that of others being imputed to him. Heretofore, when two fought, if one fell, the survivor was burthened with no more than his proportion of the folly and crime. In a matter to which both consented, both were considered equally blamable. When the son of Gen. Hamilton fell, even the father shewed no resentment, sought no revenge. And I repeat that the conduct of Gen. Hamilton's friends in this particular is unworthy of him and them, and must be attributed more to unreasonable hatred of the survivor than to genuine uaffection for the deceased. They should regulate their conduct toward Mr. Burr by the rule laid down by Mr. Morris in his funeral oration, and before they commit any outrages on his person, or give public vent to their indignation against him, ask themselves, "Would Hamilton have done this ?

Mr. Burr is amenable to the laws of his country—if justice is exacted of him, let it be according to the measure they mete, and not agreeably to the impulse of revenge felt by his personal and political enemies.

When federal papers represent the whole country as in deep mourning for the "greatest man in America," as they call General Hamilton, and pronounce his loss a "National Calamity," they shew that they are ignorant of facts or destitute of candor. By the death of Gen. Hamilton, his family, his friends, his party, have indeed suffered a great loss—these may well mourn for him, and with these a general sympathy will be felt—but can those who are not bound to him by the ties of relationship, or the endearments of fellowship, or a similarity of sentiments—who have looked upon him as the author of most of the political evils that have befel us, and the chief of a party who are still struggling to enslave us—Can these, I say, be supposed sincerely to lament his death, and bewail it as a "national calamity ?"—They cannot—they do not. They regret that he countenanced by his example so vile a practice, and ended his life in so ignoble a manner; but to say they are sorry that his presence can no more animate the enemies of our rights, or that his talents will no more be employed in devising and supporting systems and measures inimical to the happiness of the country, is what I believe no true republican can say sincerely. They do not rejoice at his death; but they do not so deeply deplore it as they are represented.

It appears clearly to me, that the high eulogiums pronounced on General Hamilton are intended to have the same effect as the harangue of Mark Anthony over the dead body of Julius Caesar—to multiply and magnify his virtues—to throw a thick veil over his faults and frailties—to degrade his political enemies—to fire with a degree of phrenzy his friends, and consign the man by whose hands he fell to the dagger or the bowl: And as the friends of Caesar through a sympathy for his fate, and by leading on his infuriated partizans to avenge his death, succeeded in crushing the spirit of liberty, and establishing a horrid despotism in Rome—so would the friends of Gen. Hamilton in like manner employ his death to effect those political purposes which in his life they could not accomplish.

And here I cannot but express my surprize, that some Republican Editors, who have till now seemed "as with a hurricane of zeal transported, and virtuous even to madness," should not only accompany the federalists in their lamentations, but outgo them in their Eulogiums; that they would deify him when dead, whom they pretended to despise while living! At the head of this class of Editors, I observe Mr. Cheetham, of New-York, publisher of the "American Citizen."——For his very extraordinary conduct I know no reason, though I have heard many assigned, the most charitable of which do him no honor. If the part he acts is taken out of hatred to Mr. Burr, the motive is unworthy of a man. When a person is down, would a generous enemy continue his blows? When he has his antagonist in the dust, must he grind him to powder? Can his behaviour proceed from an apprehension that Mr. Burr will ever attempt to rise ?—Mr. Burr is but the shadow of what he was; and "Can he who fell'd the monster, fear the ghost ?"—The following extract from Mr. Cheetham's eulogium on Mr. Hamilton, will serve as a sample of the whole performance:

"His private virtues, his public services, his great abilities, involuntarily excite in me the warmest esteem for his memory.

"Of his private virtues there is no difference of opinion. All men, of all parties, speak of them with rapture, and acknowledge them with admiration. To these, vice pays involuntary homage. The plotting, mischievous citizen, whose bloody hand, guided by cool malignancy, terminated his existence, will acknowledge them. In all the private relations of life he was honest, faithful, generous and humane. His heart was the seat of every manly virtue. No man ever impeached his integrity with any color of justice. In vain have party collisions and rancour ransacked public records, and exhausted private inquisition, for a blemish."

On this elaborate eulogium I shall only observe that it is not calculated to add to the fame of either the eulogized or the eulogist, but to depreciate both.

And may I be permitted to ask, whether the pomp and parade at his funeral, and the public exhibitions of sorrow, real or affected, are not improper, considering by what means, and in what act, he died ?—Do not those uncommon obsequies, orations and processions—those almost divine honors, which are paid to his memory, carry with them an indirect approbation of the wicked system of which he was a practiser and a victim ?—Will not young men of spirit and pride be encouraged to continue or engage in this practice, when they see it is considered by a large and leading part of the community as no disgrace ?——Let sober and pious men reflect on these things, and not give any countenance to a practice which so flagrantly transgresses the laws of God and man, and jeopardizes the peace of society.

When Dr. Franklin, Samuel Adams, and Dr. Priestly died, did the federalists so deeply deplore and so loudly lament their deaths ?—These men were in my estimation as good, as great, and as useful, as Alexander Hamilton ; and the manner of their deaths did not, like his, cast a blot on their lives. But these illustrious men were not of the federal party! And do federalists mourn for none but their own partizans ? How then can they expect republicans to unite with them in their demonstrations of grief?

With regard to the question whether General Hamilton fired at Colonel Burr or not, it can be by no means interesting. His going on the ground at all gave his example in favor of duelling, and indicated to Col. Burr, an intention to fire at him. Nor have I seen any thing to convince me that he did not fire at his adversary. He went on the ground—took his stand—his pistol was put into his hand, cocked—he presented on the word—and his pistol instantly went off.—Different persons are entitled to hold different opinions; but from these facts, I can draw but one inference, which is, that he fired at his mark.

The paper which Gen. Hamilton left behind him, and which is called a protest against duelling, I cannot view in that light. It is true he offers several powerful reasons why he wishes to avoid a meeting with Col. Burr—his "religious and moral principles"—his "wife and children," his "creditors"—and his deficiency of "ill-will"—but notwithstanding all these reasons against accepting the challenge, (which ought not only to have satisfied his own mind, but have justified him to every good man) yet his reasons in favor of it outweigh all others in his judgment, and "impose on him a peculiar necessity not to decline the call."——And is this a protest against duelling ?—If men of his standing in society have not fortitude to bear up against "public prejudice," and dissent from the barbarous practice of duelling, what can be expected of young men, whose reputation for courage is not established, and whose passions have not yet been subjected to the control of reason ?

There is one thing in the paper which Gen. Hamilton left behind him which seems very mysterious. He says, "the ability to be in future useful, whether in resisting evil or effecting good in those crises of our public affairs which seem likely to happen, would probably be inseparable from a conformity with public prejudice in this particular."—Of what crises does the General here speak ?—He gives us no idea, except by describing them as those which seem likely to occur. As elections positively, and certainly will occur, and do not merely seem likely, he cannot allude to them. To what then is the allusion ?—This expression is worth the serious reflection of the republicans. Danger may still lurk near us: and tho' he who was to have "rode on the whirlwind, and directed the storm," has been taken away, enough yet remain who will be ambitious to fill his place, and able to take an active part in the expected "crises."

The late duel, fatal as it terminated, may have one salutary effect. Heretofore the federalists have been foremost in upholding the practice of duelling, and loudest in their censure of those who had an aversion for it. It cannot be forgotten, that when Mr. Ellery, a senator from Rhode-Island, refused a challenge from Rutledge, representative from South Carolina, he was abused and ridiculed by the federal papers from one end of the United States to the other.——When Mr. Clinton, senator from New-York, refused a challenge from Mr. Dayton, senator from this state, the federalists were very free with their "gibes and jests" at his supposed want of courage.—Even when Mr. Clinton refused to exchange a fourth shot with Mr. Swartout, after having fired three times, and wounded him twice, he could not escape the imputation of cowardice. When Rutledge killed Dr. Senter in a duel, they found no fault.——But now, when they feel the fatal effects of the practice, they (who before deemed it but sport) denounce it as murderous and cruel!—I am much pleased with this change of sentiment—hope their reformation will be permanent—and that ALL MEN of every party will UNITE to discountenance and abolish a system so unworthy of a free, virtuous, and enlightened people.

A REPUBLICAN.

August 3, 1804.

See the clipping

Not everyone mourned

Hamilton’s political enemies push back against the eulogies. This writer goes through the Rev. John M. Mason’s eulogy point by point, disputing its praise of Hamilton’s honor and politics, and objects to setting him up as ‘something supernatural’ above ‘the sages and heroes of our country.’

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Virginia Argus · 25 August 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE BEE.

EULOGY ON HAMILTON. On Tuesday the 31st ult. an Eulogium on the character of the late Gen. Alexander Hamilton was delivered in the new Dutch church in New York, by the Rev. John M. Mason, an eminent preacher of that city, at the request of the society of Cincinnati of this state. The eulogy was pronounced in an able and impressive manner, and is in the press for publication. As one of the auditors, however, who did not altogether coincide with the sentiments of the orator, we shall give some account of the performance. Mr. Mason commenced his discourse with introducing its hero to our notice, after leaving Columbia College, on entering the American army at the age of 17, and becoming one of our patriots, when our patriots were sages and veterans. And the speaker proceeded to give an historical summary of his conduct, from which what follows is extracted, viz. His personal honor (said Mr. M.) was never questioned (1). A knowledge of the resources, the wants and the interests of his country, and a capacity for discerning the best means of promoting them, "the inspiration of God had assembled in the soul of Hamilton" (2). The proposition for a federal convention would have doomed his name to universal execration (3). Yet he made it, and induced Washington to accept a seat in that convention (4). Every thought of Hamilton was directed to our happiness, and the result is in our national existence (5). The constitution, not such as he wished, but such as he could obtain, he supported (6). A long theoretical apology for strong government next occurred. Governments naturally run into aristocracies (7). The aristocracy of money necessary to be guarded against (8). A government equal to every exigency, and possessing the means of self preservation, was Hamilton's wish (9). His letters of Publius are a manual for future statesmen. He induced Washington to accept the presidency (10). Without his aid Washington might have been borne down, and the nation engaged in a war for France (11). In the western insurrection he advised the sage and humane policy of Washington (12). Low salaries is a popular error. "No people is injured by the liberality of its civil list" (13). A new distress of his country called him from professional engagements. Tribute or the sword was demanded by the new philosophy. He could persuade Washington to accept the command of the armies upon no other terms than the express stipulation that he should be his associate and successor (14). He wanted no office in the gift of the nation (15). He was born to be great. "Whoever was second, Hamilton must be first," in whatever he chose to employ his capacious and comprehensive mind upon (16). When Washington was taken Hamilton was left, but Hamilton is taken and has left no equal (17). God in vengeance for national crimes punishes us with the loss of our fathers and leaders, that "imbecile government and ruthless anarchy" may ensue and ruin the nation. Hamilton's grave speaks portentous (18). "The murdered Hamilton" (19). Our "distracted country" (20). On duelling excellent remarks were made, particularly those addressed to the military, and the orator in a pious and pathetic manner concluded.

See moreSee less

REMARKS. 1. His personal honor has been questioned, tested, and found wanting, in the opinion of at least three whom he challenged and did not fight. 2. He was not inspired in all his actions, at least by God, unless God is the immediate instigator of evil. 3. The proposition for a convention did not doom its author to universal execration. It had been made before, and had been acted upon, and was not unpopular in other states if it was in this. It is very probable that the proposition, made by whomsoever it might be, would have failed if it had depended upon New York for motion or adoption. 4. Mr. M in making Hamilton the prime mover of Washington's important actions, goes too far for common belief. Washington sometimes had other advisers, and sometimes acted contrary to Hamilton's opinion, we dare presume to assert. 5. Our national existence we believe is independent of Hamilton's thoughts, some of which were directed to quite different objects. 6. Here the eulogist was candid. It is true our constitution is not such as Hamilton wished it. But it meets the approbation of many as great and good men as him, though it allows no standing armies, large naval establishments, and several "means of self preservation" against the people enjoyed by strong governments so much desired by him. "Such as he wished it" he would doubtless have made it whenever in his power. 7. If "governments naturally run into aristocracies," according to Hamilton's system, is that a reason why we should adopt an aristocracy at first? It would be like killing children the moment of their birth because they are naturally inclined to disease and death. 8. If the aristocracy of money is so dangerous, why join it to the aristocracy of birth and privileged orders? 9. What and who are governments to preserve themselves against? reform and improvement? and the people? Yet it should be for the good of the people that governments exist, and they should not possess the power of preserving themselves independent of their creators, for whose interest they are instituted. 10. It is a libel on Washington to say that it was Alexander Hamilton who induced him to accept the presidency. As if the advice of Hamilton could prevail in the mind of Washington when the call of his country was insufficient. 11. It was Hamilton, then, who saved this country from a war. Alas! were there not enough virtue and independence in the country to keep it out of war without the aid of Hamilton? Was Hamilton the sole stay and support of Washington, and the arbiter of peace and war for our country? 12. The western insurrection, with the 'sage and humane policy' of laying Pittsburgh in ashes, &c. is understood to be the plan of Hamilton, but not of Washington, who we believe prevented its execution, contrary to the wish of the secretary, who was a strong advocate for energetic measures, and abused president Adams for pardoning an insurgent condemned contrary to law. 13. That "no people is injured by the liberality of its civil list" may be Hamiltonian doctrine, but cannot go down with republicans who are convinced of the ruin of so many nations from large salaries, pensions, sinecures, &c to "swarms of officers, eating out the substance of the people," and contributing the "means of self preservation to the government." 14. It was very unambitious and disinterested in this prime mover of Washington's actions to consent to the ex-president's taking the command on the sole condition of his being his associate & successor. But it is well known who was the instigator or fomenter of this "new distress." The army raised on the occasion was emphatically called "Hamilton's army," and was most doubtless raised for domestic and internal uses more than from any external necessity. Had the public sentiment permitted, Hamilton's army would have been continued and augmented, as one of the efficient "means of self-preservation to the government." 15. That "he wanted no office in the gift of the nation" is evident from the stipulation mentioned in the preceding article. Modest man! 16. So this universal genius excelled in whatever he was pleased to undertake. Washington, Franklin, Adams Hancock, Greene, Gates, Henry, Pendleton, Jay, Ellsworth, Marshall, Livingston, &c. Jefferson, Madison, Gallatin, Clinton, &c. Rittenhouse, Rush, Trumbull, Barlow, Humphries, Freneau, West, Ramsay, &c. retire from public esteem, hide all your diminished heads. Philosophers, statesmen, soldiers, poets, painters, physicians, lawyers, orators, &c Hamilton is superior to you all. In whatever department of science he directed his attention to, he excelled all competitors. If he had condescended to have become a preacher, (i. e. previous to his conversion by Burr) he would have shone superior to the right reverend bishop Moore, his father confessor, or even the learned and accomplished orator himself. 17. If Hamilton has not left his equal behind him, men are strangely degenerated within a few weeks. A few months ago Aaron Burr received the suffrages of more than twenty thousand freeholders of this state as the worthiest and fittest man for their chief magistrate. The panegyrists of Hamilton, in April last, preferred Burr to him in their votes for governor. Adams, Pinckney and King, were thought more eligible to fill the first offices in the country than him. Not to mention some fifty or an hundred citizens of the United States, of different politics, who are as capable, as useful, and as dear to their friends and the country as Alexander Hamilton. 18. The rev. orator apologized for speaking of the nation in this manner by declaring that the language (which he quoted) was in the Bible. Still we hope, however, that "children are not our princes," nor weak and simple men our councillors. 19. If Hamilton was "murdered," who would have been murdered if he had fought all the persons he had challenged? and was he not, is not every duellist, accessary to his own death, a murderer or suicide? 20. The orator might have spared his commiseration of our "distracted nation," as it is hoped, under the blessing of Heaven, we may still retain our senses, and enjoy a tolerable degree of prosperity, notwithstanding it has pleased the Almighty to take Hamilton from us, by his own means.

CONCLUDING REMARK. If the reverend eulogist be considered merely as a venal speaker, exerting his great talents for reward, his eulogium entitles him to much credit, for the very able and handsome manner in which it was executed. But if the performance is to be understood as the honest and voluntary effusion of a preacher of the gospel, and holding up its hero (like the federal editors) as something supernatural, for us to gaze at, admire, and imitate if possible, we must give our opinion and our reasons against this injustice to the sages and heroes of our country, who are insulted so grossly by elevating Hamilton so far above their heads.

See the clipping

Still arguing

Seven weeks after the duel, the American Citizen’s serial is still going through the seconds’ statements letter by letter, to argue that Burr meant to fight from the start. It breaks off, again, ‘to be continued.’

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 August 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AMERICAN CITIZEN.

[Continued.]

See moreSee less

DEATH OF GENERAL HAMILTON. The statement of Mr. Van Ness, introductory to No. 5 which appeared in the Morning Chronicle is fully corroborative of the above extract. Alluding to Mr. Burr's second letter, he says :—

'Gen. Hamilton perused it and said it was such a letter as he had hoped not to have received: that it contained several offensive expressions and seemed to close the door to all further reply—that he had hoped the answer he had returned to Col. Burr's first letter would have given a different direction to the controversy—that he thought Mr. Burr would have perceived that there was a difficulty in his making a more specifick reply, and would have desired him to state what had fallen from him that might have given rise to the INFERENCE of Dr. Cooper. HE WOULD HAVE DONE THIS FRANKLY ; AND HE BELIEVED IT WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN FOUND TO EXCEED THE LIMITS JUSTIFIABLE AMONG POLITICAL OPPONENTS."

The ground of Mr. Burr's first message was inexplicably vague and therefore insusceptible of precise and honourable explanation. To put the pacifick disposition of General Hamilton beyond all question, and give to Mr. Burr the most auspicious of opportunities to state the offence of which he complained in definite and explicit terms, the General says that, 'in answer to a letter properly adapted to obtain from him a declaration whether he had charged Col. Burr with any particular instance of dishonourable conduct, or had impeached his private character either in the conversation alluded to by Dr. Cooper, or in any other particular instance specified, he would state that the conversation to which Dr. Cooper alluded turned wholly on political topics, and did not attribute to Col. Burr any instance of dishonourable conduct, nor relate to his private character.'

Mr. Van Ness says that in a conversation with General Hamilton, the General remarked that 'he thought Mr. Burr would have perceived that there was a difficulty in making a more specifick reply and would have desired him to state what had fallen from him that might have given rise to the INFERENCE of Dr. Cooper. He would have done so frankly.'

Here we rest our opinion of predetermined hostility ; of malice aforethought ; of deliberate cruelty, on the part of Mr. Burr ; and, by contrasting these, the admission of both parties, with No. 8 of the correspondence, as published in the Evening Post, which we have yet to notice, offer to make good these high and heinous charges.

In his first letter, Mr. Burr calls upon General Hamilton to acknowledge or deny, what? that which Dr. Cooper had affirmed as his opinion, viz. that General Hamilton had declared, in substance, that he looked upon Mr. Burr to be a dangerous man &c. and that he had even expressed a still more despicable opinion.—General Hamilton insists, in the most soothing and gentlemanly terms, that the opinion is simply an inference of Dr. Cooper's, drawn from language which may not have warranted it, and spoken he knows not when, since the time is not paticularised. Touched, and somewhat diverted from his purpose, by these pertinent remarks, Mr. Burr admits that the offensive "epithet is ADOPTED by Dr. Cooper," and therefore tacitly concedes that it may not not have been authorised by the expression to which it is referred. The accuracy of this conclusion, from the language of both, is submitted to the inquisition of the intelligent reader.—Agreeing then, in the progress of the correspondence, as to the opinion of Dr. Cooper, nothing was requisite to a peaceful and honourable accommodation but a specification of the language of General Hamilton to which it refers. It was for Mr. Burr to specify and General Hamilton to explain. General Hamilton politely demands the specification and promises to give a frank and explicit answer. It was this answer, and this only, that could enable Mr. Burr to judge whether, and to what degree, the language of General Hamilton was offensive?

Every reasoning man would suppose that Mr. Burr would now promptly specify, and, if the alleged exceptionable passages contained in Dr. Cooper's letters, and given as his opinion, were really the foundation of the challenge, he certainly would have specified, the precise language to which it refers. But, driven from his pretence by arguments unanswerable, by the adduction of reasons which nothing but predetermined hostility could surmount, he quits, he renounces utterly and entirely, the ground of his first message and enters into a field of charges too vague for human perspicacity to meet ; too boundless for memory to embrace. In this shifting of ground, this exchange of position, we cannot but see predetermination ; a thirsting for the life of Hamilton which nothing but his death could quench.

In answer to the note of General Hamilton calling upon him to specify, Mr. Burr, speaking through Mr. Van Ness, says,*

'The letter which you yesterday delivered me, and your subsequent communication, in Col. Burr's opinion evince no disposition on the part of Gen. Hamilton to come to a satisfactory accommodation. The injury complained of and the reparation expected, are so definitely expressed in Col. Burr's letter of the 21st instant, that there is not perceived a necessity for further explanation on his part.

The difficulty that would result from confining the enquiry to any particular times and occasions must be manifest. The denial of a specified conversation only, would leave strong implications that on other occasions improper language had been used—When and where injurious opinions have been uttered by Gen. Hamilton must be best known to him, and of him only will Col. Burr enquire. No denial or declaration will be satisfactory, unless it be GENERAL so as wholly to exclude the idea that rumours derogatory to Col. Burr's honour have originated with Gen. Hamilton or have been fairly inferred from any thing he has said.'

I repeat that in this letter, prest to specify by Gen. H. Mr. Burr, completely abandons his first ground, and, no longer able to conceal his views, has recourse to something unstated and explainable, but which, evidently, embraces every political word and act, relating to Mr. Burr in the life of the deceased. He now calls upon Gen. H. to explain and atone for rumours which he does not even condescend to state! Predetermined hostility cannot be more manifest. Well might Gen. Hamilton remark that, whether the rumours unstated by Mr. Burr were in circulation "openly or in whispers, they have a form and shape and might be specified."

The passages from Mr. Burr's letter first quoted are worthy particular attention, for they shew, more clearly and strongly than any thing else, his ultimate object, which, at first was concealed under the pretended offensive contents of Dr. Cooper's letters.

"The difficulty," says this very cunning and ingenious gentleman, "that would result from confining the inquiry to any particular times and occasions, must be manifest.—The denial of a specified conversation only, would leave strong implications that on other occasions improper language had been used."

Here Mr. Burr has a form and shape: he is tangible. He finds Gen. Hamilton extremely ready and willing to explain, frankly and with definiteness, the conversation to which Dr. Cooper refers, provided it be specified by his antagonist. Unable any longer to parry the strokes of the Gen. finding that his propositions are fair, and his arguments irresistably cogent and persuasive, he casts from him the puny shackles of his first complaint, and, occupying a new and very different position, declares, explicitly, that the denial of the specified conversation to which Dr. Cooper refers and which he is fearful Gen. Hamilton can, consistently with truth and honour, deny, would leave strong implications that on other occasions improper language had been used.

Here then he abandons that conversation as not being sufficiently offensive, taking it for granted, that if specified, Gen. Hamilton could, consistently with honour and truth, deny it. But Mr. Burr asserts that the denial of that conversation would leave strong implications that on other occasions, improper language had been used!! This is the most cruel cut of all! It is a self admission clear and strong enough to convict him, in any court of equity, of deliberate murder.

What is now the ground of challenge? "Strong implications that, on other occasions, improper language had been used." Gen. Hamilton then was to fight Mr. Burr because strong implications might remain that improper language had been used, but where and when Mr. Burr knew not! And shall the life of a distinguished citizen be taken away under a pretence so frivolous? Will our citizens sanction, upon such grounds, a deed fraught with so much injustice and horror?

And since strong implications might remain, Mr. Burr, in the same paragraph, says, that "No denial or declaration will

* See letter No. 8. as published in the Evening Post.

be satisfactory, unless it be GENERAL, so as wholly to exclude the idea that RUMOURS, derogatory to his honour, have been fairly inferred from any thing he has said."

These genrl remarks embraced the entire period of Gen. Hamilton's knowledge of Col. Burr and rendered it impossible to give a satisfactory explanation. Mr. Burr had now determined to put it out of the power of Gen. Hamilton to avert the impending blow.

(TO BE CONTINUED.)

See the clipping

Indicted for murder

A grand jury in Bergen County, New Jersey, indicts Burr for murder. Some say the charge can’t stand, since Hamilton died in New York. The paper says a New Jersey law settles it, and expects a trial soon.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 November 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Case of Col. Burr. A grand jury of the state of New-Jersey having presented a bill of indictment for murder, against this gentleman, it has become an interesting question, whether the crime of which he has been guilty is really murder in legal signification. By the common law, if the stroke of which one dies be given in one county and he die in another, it is not murder in either. The case being much stronger between different states, it is supposed that as Gen. Hamilton died in New-York and not in New-Jersey, Col. Burr cannot be guilty of murder. But the fact is otherwise; for by a particular statute of the state of New-Jersey, if the stroke be given in New-Jersey, and the death ensues in another state, it is murder. No doubt therefore remains of the nature of the crime, and that the grand jury have been correct. U. S. Gaz.

The Common Law is as above stated; but by force of the statute of 2 & 3 Edw. VI. c 24, the offender was indictable in the county where the party died—In this state the law is otherwise; the offender shall be tried in the Court of that District where the stroke was given, or the poison administered.

See moreSee less

The Legislative provision of the state of New-Jersey, supercedes the Common Law, and settles the question at once. As it is presumed that Col. Burr, will shortly undergo a Trial, according to the Laws of his Country, we shall abstain from any further remark respecting him or his case, until the result of that trial is known.

The Grand Jury of Bergen county, in the state of New-Jersey, has found a bill of indictment for Murder against Aaron Burr, for killing Gen. Hamilton in July last, in said county.

See the clipping

What kind of man is Burr?

A Richmond writer who has never met Burr weighs his career, including the still-mysterious presidential election, and refuses to join ‘the war-whoop, that Mr. Burr is a murderer.’ His verdict instead: a gifted man who ‘sullied his own honor’ by stooping to political intrigue.

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Enquirer · 14 November 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The author of the following observations is personally unacquainted with the qualities and actions of Mr. Burr. Like most of his countrymen, he has had no other means of contemplating the character of the Vice-President, than through the imperfect medium of the facts and suspicions which have been already unveiled to the public eye. The following view must therefore be inaccurate, and it may be unjust. He should as much as any man lament such an injustice; and he would go as far as any man to repair it. Should the contrary side of the medal ever be displayed; should Mr. Burr or any of his friends ever determine to enter into a satisfactory vindication of his conduct: the author of the succeeding sketch will not be the last man in the United States to delineate a different and more favourable picture.

AARON BURR

See moreSee less

might have been beloved and respected by his countrymen, if he had not been desirous of acquiring a premature renown. He was rapidly rising in the estimation of the people; among the most distinguished politicians of his own state he had long maintained an equal or ascendant influence; and the lustre of his name was rapidly extending over the union. But his rising reputation did not correspond with his progressive ambition. A continued life of services might have perhaps entitled him to the most elevated office, which it was in the power of a grateful people to bestow: yet while there remained any higher honour to acquire, his quickening desires were unable to wait the tardy progress of events. A few years might have encircled his brow with the richest wreath of honour: but it was his deplorable destiny to attempt to snatch his laurels from the hand of time.

The nomination of Mr. Burr to the second office under the constitution, was zealously adopted by the republican party throughout the union. They were anxious to select some citizen from New-York, and Mr. Burr was seen among her most distinguished citizens. This sentiment was general; but it was not universal. Even at that time, there were a few men equally distinguished for their love of virtue and their knowledge of men, who ventured to suspect the qualifications of Mr. Burr. They had traced him in the recesses of his private life; and they thought they had discerned some lines in his character, which had excited their disapprobation and dread. It was not the sober and unassuming simplicity of Aristides, which met their eyes: They contemplated rather the polished accomplishments and the pernicious dissipation of Alcibiades. In one quality indeed this illustrious Athenian was evidently superior to the American. He had many vices to conceal; but he had the virtue to display them. Of Mr. Burr it had been remarked, that he had studied a system of continued concealment. There were few confidential bosoms in whom he would repose his most important designs, or most vivid sensations; and few were the occasions on which he would trust his reflections upon paper.

Such qualities wherever they exist, are well calculated to excite the suspicions and the fears of all: and those who imagined they had found them in Mr. Burr, were startled at the idea of raising him even to the second office in the union.

His aspiring ambition seems however, to have grasped even at the first. The history of the last presidential election, is still enveloped in an impenetrable mystery. There are scenes in that political drama, which have not yet been developed, and which it may be well for the honour of our country should ever remain behind the concealment of the curtain.

But the part which Mr. Burr is said to have acted on that occasion, is fraught with the deepest duplicity and disgrace. If Mr. Burr did really intrigue with the federalists, the distrust of his own party has formed his merited punishment; if Mr. Burr is innocent, there are no terms in our language, which can adequately convey an idea of his wrongs. Is Mr. Burr then really an apostate? My own decided impression has ever been, that he is.

With those men, who will contemplate the character of Mr. Burr in this precise attitude, I am willing to accord in the most profound disapprobation of his character. Let them shower down their most abundant anathemas upon the head of the political intriguer; and I will not murmur at the dispensation. And surely even his most inveterate enemies ought to be contented with this expert instrument of torture. Let the pencil of a Titian delineate, if it can, a more odious character under a virtuous republic, than that of a political apostate.--But I will not consent to offer up Mr. Burr as a victim to the offended manes of Mr. Hamilton. To indulge a party rancour or the federal resentment, I will never consent to violate the most obvious maxims of common sense or common justice. I will not join in the war-whoop, that Mr. Burr is a murderer, and that his hands are stained with the blood of a fellow-citizen. Amidst the variety of these melancholy cases, which are passed over with impunity, only because they are so frequent in their recurrence, why (let me ask) is this particular case to be culled and held up as an odious exception? If Mr. Burr has violated the precepts of political morality, does that furnish any adequate proof that he has also neglected the maxims of a chivalrous honour?

By prosecuting such a system of rancorous persecution, the enemies of the Vice-President have forgotten that they become his most useful friends. When resentment is strained beyond the proper degree, or when a vicious character is censured for vices, which it does not really possess; what other emotions does it excite than the sympathy of every feeling mind? When this sensibility is once indulged, it destroys all nice discrimination of qualities. Like the genius of the Muse, it "extends her mystic mantle to all the evils of his life," and the mind loses too much of its disapprobation for the vices of the victim, in sympathising with his unmerited misfortunes.

This then is the plain catechism of the republican party: pity for the fate of Hamilton; impunity towards his antagonist; the most unrelenting suspicion of the political apostate.

Should ever this imperfect sketch meet the eye of Mr. Burr, he knows little of the emotions of its author, if he should conceive him to indulge the resentments of a virulent and implacable Foe. Penetrated as he is with a detestation of his political conduct, as that conduct appears to him at the present moment to be, he has not yet excluded from his bosom every sentiment of admiration and sympathy. He admires the courageous spirit that he has hitherto displayed: He admires the almost inimitable ease and polish of his manners, softened as they now are by the touches of adversity; and the endowments of his mind have not escaped his attention, nor have they failed to attract his reverence. He can truly say that the strongest sentiment which he is at this moment constrained to indulge, flows from the melancholy reflection that a man so highly gifted as Aaron Burr with such various and admirable accomplishments should have anihilated all his usefulness, and sullied his own honor by descending from such an elevated station, to mix in the pollution and abomination of political intrigue.

The Editor cannot but lament that the preceding portrait has not fallen into the hands of some more competent person to design; & that his own avocations have prevented him from giving it a more finished appearance.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: The Duel