Burr’s enemies cry murder
The American Citizen charges that Hamilton fell victim to ‘a wicked system of deadly hostility, planned by Mr. Burr and his friends.’ Citing ‘one of the DAVISES,’ it says twelve to fifteen of Burr’s friends had met at night before the late election and formed a company of duellists, with Hamilton ‘the first victim.’ About six weeks ago, it adds, three of Burr’s friends combed the files of the Morning Chronicle for a pretext for the challenge.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 4 August 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FROM THE AMERICAN CITIZEN.
GENERAL HAMILTON'S DEATH——We now propose to shew, from the correspondence published, from other testimony as yet concealed from the publick eye, and from various circumstances of known authenticity and moment, that this unfortunate gentleman has fallen a victim to a wicked system of deadly hostility, planned by Mr. Burr and his friends, and rigidly carried into execution. Attention will be requisite to a due comprehension of the necessary chain of argument and of facts, but when this is viewed in its natural and connected order, the conclusion already mentioned, it is conceived, will be the irresistible and inevitable consequence. By this the publick will determine how far a faction, pursuing projects so bloody, for ends so calamitous, merit their countenance and support.
See moreSee less
For some months back I have been alarmed for the safety, and troubled with fearful presentiments of the danger with which a melancholy event has but too conclusively proved GENERAL HAMILTON was environed. During this period menaces have in whispers been denounced, by those who enjoy the confidence and best knew the secret purposes of Mr. Burr, against this child of genius, this pride and boast of the bar, this ornament of the country. Although not apt to be alarmed by threats, yet, calmly reflecting on all its circumstances, I could not, in this case, avert apprehension. A correct perception of right, a faithful performance of his duty, in a case in which allusion is sufficient for all the purposes of knowledge, had more than ever excited the implacable resentment and aroused the slumbering indignation of Mr. Burr. The circumstance to which I allude had involved him in perplexities so fatal to his aspiring hopes, so blasting to his darling pursuits of personal aggrandizement, that nothing short of the DEATH of HAMILTON could glut his vengeance. Alas! he has at length succeeded. Wrapt up in himself——to appease his resentment, to gratify his ambition, he is capable of wading through the blood of his fellow citizens and of laughing at the lamentations of widows and orphans.
It has for some time been intimated by many of Mr. Burr's friends, in language that could not be misunderstood by those who have calmly observed their conduct for two or three years back, that GENERAL HAMILTON must fall by the hand of Mr. Burr. The reasons assigned by this gentleman's friends for the fatal threat, were precisely those urged by Mr. Burr in his correspondence with the deceased. It was stated that GENERAL HAMILTON had either himself propagated, or had some how encouraged the propagation of what these gentlemen were pleased to term slanders, traducing what they denominated his honour and fame. It was impossible, they said, that Mr. Burr, distinguished for his bravery and known from his constant practice to be a good shot, should be so indifferent to reputation as not to call him to an account. Besides, GENERAL HAMILTON, although, perhaps, the most formidable opponent, was not the only one whose death was meditated by Mr. Burr and those with whom he confidentially associated.—They avowed their intention to accomplish if possible, by acts of desperation, by spilling the blood of their fellow citizens, those, on their opinion, desirable objects which by other means they could not attain. For some time previous to the late election, from twelve to fifteen of these bloody villains assembled together in the night, and, under injunctions of secrecy and pledges of mutual support, planned the diabolical work and selected for destruction those who were viewed as the most formidable obstacles in the way of Mr. Burr's designs. In one word, it was their determination to fight their way through an host of opposition which could not, in their opinion, be subdued without blood! The publick will scarcely credit this plain narration of a horrible scene; but I have the authority of one of the DAVISES for it; and this is confirmed by all the circumstances which led to and accompanied the death of GENERAL HAMILTON, as well as by others which are here well known to have existed a little anteriour to and during the election. To a gentleman who mentioned the fact to me, one of the Davises stated, in express terms, and in a tone and temper indicative of seriousness and courage, for which he has no reputation, that a company of Mr. Burr's friends had formed a regular association on principles, and for the express purpose of duelling, and that they were determined to accomplish by this system of terrour and of blood, what they could not without it. It was triumphantly remarked by the friends of Mr. Burr, when gentlemen called for the author of Aristides and the editor of the Corrector, that if personal satisfaction only was wanted, from twelve to fifteen stood ready to give it. This is a fact well known to many. The twelve or fifteen mentioned were the duellists systematically organized into a company with the approbation, if not under the eye of Mr. Burr. GENERAL HAMILTON, however, was to be the first victim. He was, in their opinion, the greatest offender: he was therefore, at all events, to be despatched.
These are some of the exertions of a system of determined hostility more amply unfolded by Mr. Burr in his correspondence with the deceased, and which will become more and more irresistible to the senses as we pass it in review. We must previously, however, advert to a circumstance which, when viewed in connexion with the letters of Mr. Burr, will evince preconcert and design, and a perfect understanding among him and his friends, that a demand on General Hamilton should be made so general and indefinite in nature and terms as that no explanation could be given or apology received.
From what has been said and what we know, it may be fairly inferred, that, by preconcert and arrangement among Mr. Burr and his friends, it was some time ago determined that General Hamilton should at all events be challenged by Mr. Burr. The removal of this great man was, in the opinion of his antagonist, essential to the accomplishment of various selfish purposes. A temporary, a mistaken; may I not say, a fatal support given to him at the late election, had induced the belief (certainly a false one) that nothing was necessary to insure to him the exclusive management of the federal party, but the death of their highly honorable and distinguished leader; for of this fatal end, if an interview (no matter by what means) could be effected, he calculated with confidence and certainty. He no doubt too concluded, together with his friends with whom he advised, that "so unfavourable an event of things," to borrow the affecting language of the DECEASED, would strike terror into our citizens—abash opposition, and rid himself of a witness distinguished for integrity and truth, and commanding implicit belief.
Having determined on the challenge, it became necessary to seek for a cause, specious if not just. The first step taken was to examine the files of the Morning Chronicle, in order to discover something on which a challenge might be colourably predicated. For this purpose, about six weeks ago, three of Mr. Burr's friends, (whose names are mentioned to me) anxiously examined, at the office a file of the Chronicle and marked in its pages various paragraphs. Whether they found Dr. Cooper's letter or not, or how or by whom it was placed in Mr. Burr's hands, is not for me to say.
(TO BE CONTINUED.)