FROM THE TRENTON TRUE AMERICAN.
THOUGHTS ON THE LATE DUEL.
See moreSee less
Mr. WILSON,
As there have in my opinion been some pains taken to present the late fatal affair to the public in an unfair light, and to convert it into a mean of effecting improper political purposes, I have thrown together some thoughts on the subject just as they occurred to me ; and hope, should you see fit to publish them, they will have a tendency to place the matter in a proper point of view, and prevent unjust impressions.
Col. Burr cannot be justified for challenging and fighting a duel with Gen. Hamilton, principally,
Because the practice is obnoxious to divine and human laws:
Because Mr. Burr, from his elevated station, and the influence his example might have, was especially bound to obey and respect those laws:
Because until the expiration of the time for which he was elected, his life was not his own—it was the public's—and he had no right to risk it in a private quarrel.
For these and some subordinate reasons, Col. Burr's conduct cannot, in my mind, be justified.
Yet those who consider the practice of avenging one's own injuries by the mode of duelling as proper, and believe that a magistrate owes no deference to the opinion, or regard to the honor of his constituents, cannot consistently condemn the conduct of Col. Burr.
It is a well known fact that Gen. Hamilton has long been in the habit of censuring the conduct and criminating the motives of Col. Burr, with a freedom uncommon, perhaps unjustifiable between gentlemen and competitors. Gen. Hamilton acknowledges in the paper which he left behind him, that "his animadversions on the political principles, character and views of Col. Burr have been extremely severe, and on different occasions he, in common with many others, has made very unfavorable criticisms on particular instances of the private conduct of that gentleman." He cofesses that Col. Burr has "doubtless heard of animadversions of his that bore very hard upon him ; and that it is probable that as usual they were accompanied by some falsehoods." He confesses that "it is possible in some particulars he may have been influenced by misconstruction or misinformation," and that "it is possible he may have injured Col. Burr."—Yet in reply to Col. Burr's first note, which any gentleman might with propriety have written, and which I think Gen. Hamilton might without disgrace have satisfactorily answered, the latter not only refuses any satisfactory explanation, but throws out a kind of defiance, that he will abide the consequences. By this expression he cuts off Col. Burr's retreat, for had he not then challenged Gen. Hamilton, those who now curse him the most bitterly, would then have ridiculed him the most severely, and reproached him the most clamorously.
As to General Hamilton's being, as is frequently asserted by his frends, compelled to take the field, I cannot discern any compulsion. I believe that acknowledgments from Gen. Hamilton, going but little further than those which he made in the paper he left behind him, that "he might have been influenced in what he said of Mr. Burr by misconstruction or misinformation," and that "he might possibly have injured him," I say I believe that acknowledgments something more explicit than these would have satisfied Col. Burr, and I do not think they would have disgraced Gen. Hamilton. Or if the General's feelings would not permit him to make any acknowledgment, could he not have justified his refusal of a challenge by explaining its inconsistency with his "religious and moral principles," the injury his "wife and children" might suffer, the injustice his "creditors" might sustain, and the want of any "ill will" against the challenger ?—Was not his character for courage too firmly established, to be shaken by such a refusal ?—Or need he have sacrificed his fear of God, his love of his country, his affection for his wife and chilcen, his reverence for the laws, and every other important consideration, to the apprehension that without such a sacrifice his courage would be suspected ?
I conceive that Gen. Hamilton was subject to no compulsion—that his conduct was perfectly voluntary—and that his friends disgrace his memory when they attempt to excite popular resentment against his opponent by asserting that he was wholly and solely to blame. Sufficient is the weight of guilt which must rest on his shoulders, without that of others being imputed to him. Heretofore, when two fought, if one fell, the survivor was burthened with no more than his proportion of the folly and crime. In a matter to which both consented, both were considered equally blamable. When the son of Gen. Hamilton fell, even the father shewed no resentment, sought no revenge. And I repeat that the conduct of Gen. Hamilton's friends in this particular is unworthy of him and them, and must be attributed more to unreasonable hatred of the survivor than to genuine uaffection for the deceased. They should regulate their conduct toward Mr. Burr by the rule laid down by Mr. Morris in his funeral oration, and before they commit any outrages on his person, or give public vent to their indignation against him, ask themselves, "Would Hamilton have done this ?
Mr. Burr is amenable to the laws of his country—if justice is exacted of him, let it be according to the measure they mete, and not agreeably to the impulse of revenge felt by his personal and political enemies.
When federal papers represent the whole country as in deep mourning for the "greatest man in America," as they call General Hamilton, and pronounce his loss a "National Calamity," they shew that they are ignorant of facts or destitute of candor. By the death of Gen. Hamilton, his family, his friends, his party, have indeed suffered a great loss—these may well mourn for him, and with these a general sympathy will be felt—but can those who are not bound to him by the ties of relationship, or the endearments of fellowship, or a similarity of sentiments—who have looked upon him as the author of most of the political evils that have befel us, and the chief of a party who are still struggling to enslave us—Can these, I say, be supposed sincerely to lament his death, and bewail it as a "national calamity ?"—They cannot—they do not. They regret that he countenanced by his example so vile a practice, and ended his life in so ignoble a manner; but to say they are sorry that his presence can no more animate the enemies of our rights, or that his talents will no more be employed in devising and supporting systems and measures inimical to the happiness of the country, is what I believe no true republican can say sincerely. They do not rejoice at his death; but they do not so deeply deplore it as they are represented.
It appears clearly to me, that the high eulogiums pronounced on General Hamilton are intended to have the same effect as the harangue of Mark Anthony over the dead body of Julius Caesar—to multiply and magnify his virtues—to throw a thick veil over his faults and frailties—to degrade his political enemies—to fire with a degree of phrenzy his friends, and consign the man by whose hands he fell to the dagger or the bowl: And as the friends of Caesar through a sympathy for his fate, and by leading on his infuriated partizans to avenge his death, succeeded in crushing the spirit of liberty, and establishing a horrid despotism in Rome—so would the friends of Gen. Hamilton in like manner employ his death to effect those political purposes which in his life they could not accomplish.
And here I cannot but express my surprize, that some Republican Editors, who have till now seemed "as with a hurricane of zeal transported, and virtuous even to madness," should not only accompany the federalists in their lamentations, but outgo them in their Eulogiums; that they would deify him when dead, whom they pretended to despise while living! At the head of this class of Editors, I observe Mr. Cheetham, of New-York, publisher of the "American Citizen."——For his very extraordinary conduct I know no reason, though I have heard many assigned, the most charitable of which do him no honor. If the part he acts is taken out of hatred to Mr. Burr, the motive is unworthy of a man. When a person is down, would a generous enemy continue his blows? When he has his antagonist in the dust, must he grind him to powder? Can his behaviour proceed from an apprehension that Mr. Burr will ever attempt to rise ?—Mr. Burr is but the shadow of what he was; and "Can he who fell'd the monster, fear the ghost ?"—The following extract from Mr. Cheetham's eulogium on Mr. Hamilton, will serve as a sample of the whole performance:
"His private virtues, his public services, his great abilities, involuntarily excite in me the warmest esteem for his memory.
"Of his private virtues there is no difference of opinion. All men, of all parties, speak of them with rapture, and acknowledge them with admiration. To these, vice pays involuntary homage. The plotting, mischievous citizen, whose bloody hand, guided by cool malignancy, terminated his existence, will acknowledge them. In all the private relations of life he was honest, faithful, generous and humane. His heart was the seat of every manly virtue. No man ever impeached his integrity with any color of justice. In vain have party collisions and rancour ransacked public records, and exhausted private inquisition, for a blemish."
On this elaborate eulogium I shall only observe that it is not calculated to add to the fame of either the eulogized or the eulogist, but to depreciate both.
And may I be permitted to ask, whether the pomp and parade at his funeral, and the public exhibitions of sorrow, real or affected, are not improper, considering by what means, and in what act, he died ?—Do not those uncommon obsequies, orations and processions—those almost divine honors, which are paid to his memory, carry with them an indirect approbation of the wicked system of which he was a practiser and a victim ?—Will not young men of spirit and pride be encouraged to continue or engage in this practice, when they see it is considered by a large and leading part of the community as no disgrace ?——Let sober and pious men reflect on these things, and not give any countenance to a practice which so flagrantly transgresses the laws of God and man, and jeopardizes the peace of society.
When Dr. Franklin, Samuel Adams, and Dr. Priestly died, did the federalists so deeply deplore and so loudly lament their deaths ?—These men were in my estimation as good, as great, and as useful, as Alexander Hamilton ; and the manner of their deaths did not, like his, cast a blot on their lives. But these illustrious men were not of the federal party! And do federalists mourn for none but their own partizans ? How then can they expect republicans to unite with them in their demonstrations of grief?
With regard to the question whether General Hamilton fired at Colonel Burr or not, it can be by no means interesting. His going on the ground at all gave his example in favor of duelling, and indicated to Col. Burr, an intention to fire at him. Nor have I seen any thing to convince me that he did not fire at his adversary. He went on the ground—took his stand—his pistol was put into his hand, cocked—he presented on the word—and his pistol instantly went off.—Different persons are entitled to hold different opinions; but from these facts, I can draw but one inference, which is, that he fired at his mark.
The paper which Gen. Hamilton left behind him, and which is called a protest against duelling, I cannot view in that light. It is true he offers several powerful reasons why he wishes to avoid a meeting with Col. Burr—his "religious and moral principles"—his "wife and children," his "creditors"—and his deficiency of "ill-will"—but notwithstanding all these reasons against accepting the challenge, (which ought not only to have satisfied his own mind, but have justified him to every good man) yet his reasons in favor of it outweigh all others in his judgment, and "impose on him a peculiar necessity not to decline the call."——And is this a protest against duelling ?—If men of his standing in society have not fortitude to bear up against "public prejudice," and dissent from the barbarous practice of duelling, what can be expected of young men, whose reputation for courage is not established, and whose passions have not yet been subjected to the control of reason ?
There is one thing in the paper which Gen. Hamilton left behind him which seems very mysterious. He says, "the ability to be in future useful, whether in resisting evil or effecting good in those crises of our public affairs which seem likely to happen, would probably be inseparable from a conformity with public prejudice in this particular."—Of what crises does the General here speak ?—He gives us no idea, except by describing them as those which seem likely to occur. As elections positively, and certainly will occur, and do not merely seem likely, he cannot allude to them. To what then is the allusion ?—This expression is worth the serious reflection of the republicans. Danger may still lurk near us: and tho' he who was to have "rode on the whirlwind, and directed the storm," has been taken away, enough yet remain who will be ambitious to fill his place, and able to take an active part in the expected "crises."
The late duel, fatal as it terminated, may have one salutary effect. Heretofore the federalists have been foremost in upholding the practice of duelling, and loudest in their censure of those who had an aversion for it. It cannot be forgotten, that when Mr. Ellery, a senator from Rhode-Island, refused a challenge from Rutledge, representative from South Carolina, he was abused and ridiculed by the federal papers from one end of the United States to the other.——When Mr. Clinton, senator from New-York, refused a challenge from Mr. Dayton, senator from this state, the federalists were very free with their "gibes and jests" at his supposed want of courage.—Even when Mr. Clinton refused to exchange a fourth shot with Mr. Swartout, after having fired three times, and wounded him twice, he could not escape the imputation of cowardice. When Rutledge killed Dr. Senter in a duel, they found no fault.——But now, when they feel the fatal effects of the practice, they (who before deemed it but sport) denounce it as murderous and cruel!—I am much pleased with this change of sentiment—hope their reformation will be permanent—and that ALL MEN of every party will UNITE to discountenance and abolish a system so unworthy of a free, virtuous, and enlightened people.
A REPUBLICAN.
August 3, 1804.