As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

September 1804

8 articles

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A reader's letter to the Argus laments the duel between Hamilton and Burr, framing it as a sinful violation of God's law despite their high offices and reputations. The writer argues Hamilton's vanity and Burr's lawlessness both led to their ruin, with Hamilton killed and Burr disgraced.

Virginia Argus · 8 September 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FOR THE ARGUS.

Mr. Samuel Pleasants,

See moreSee less

DEAR SIR,

WITH conscious confidence I can assert that I fear GOD and love my COUNTRY. But the continued efforts which are made to support the fallen dignity and justify or cover the inexcusable folly and madness of Burr and Hamilton, do really hurt my feelings. Being a simple and plain man, I suppose it cannot be inexcusable in me to express a few of my simple thoughts on the subject.

Gen. Hamilton has displayed both military and legislative talent, and as some say, all for the good of his country! He has filled important posts! He has been highly esteemed by his friends!——And Col. Burr!—He was the Vice-President of the U. S.!

Very well—Now what have they done in the greatness of their distinction? THEY HAVE FOUGHT A DUEL!—In defiance of the Laws of GOD and Man they entered the list of Fools,* and both have justly fallen victims to their folly. Hamilton tho' great and pious, "loved the praise of men more than the praise of GOD." He had not fortitude to withstand the clamors of the duelling croud. He chose rather to hazard his life. In the mean time however he thought to compound with his Maker, and while by his example he would give sanction to a Hellish and murderous custom, "he determined to reserve his fire." —But the GOD of our fathers, who declared that obedience is better than sacrifice, was not well pleased. He withdrew his protection!—And Hamilton is slain!

Col. Burr, tho' distinguished by his countrymen!—the second in the nation—the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Ledger reflects on its past coverage of Hamilton's death and introduces a character sketch by Fisher Ames of Massachusetts, praising Hamilton's public and private virtues. The piece is framed as a tribute amid ongoing national mourning.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 September 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

to admit of such a supposition.

Perhaps some biographer worthy of the subject may yet arise; and we may find the life and the character of this great man treated with that justice and with that elegance which the one and the other ought to inspire. But, with the author of the following sketch, we may exclaim—"Who alive can exhibit the portrait?—If our age had produced two Hamiltons, one of them might have depicted the other!" Our age we fear has not been so fecund in genius and virtue.

See moreSee less

Quid illo cive tulisset Natura in terris, quid ROMA beatius unquam?

We do justice to ourselves in presenting an elegant, and we hope acceptable, banquet to our readers, in a rapid survey of the publick and private character of General Hamilton, from a well known statesman and scholar. Mr. Ames does pretend

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This is a published tribute by Fisher Ames of Massachusetts reflecting on Hamilton's public and private character following his death. It describes the nation's widespread grief, comparing it to Roman mourning for Germanicus, and argues that Hamilton's lasting impression on the public over 25 years proves his genuine greatness.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 September 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

OF THE PUBLICK AND PRIVATE CHARACTER OF ALEXANDER HAMILTON, ESQ. BY FISHER AMES, ESQ. OF MASSACHUSETTS.

There are so many persons, who, from various causes, possess only a superficial knowledge of the character of eminent men, that, it is to be expected, the extraordinary marks of grief manifested by the publick on the death of General Hamilton, will to some appear strange, and to others excessive.—America, they may say, has produced many great men, some are dead and others remain alive.—Why, then, should we mourn, as if with a sense of desolation and surprise, for a loss, that, by the lot of human nature, has already become familiar, and why mourn so much, as if all was lost, when we have so many great men left.

See moreSee less

But although General Hamilton has, for some years, withdrawn from publick office to the Bar, and has been, in some measure, out of the view and contemplation of his countrymen, there was nevertheless a splendour in his character, that could not be contracted within the ordinary sphere of his employment.

It is with really great men as with great literary works, the excellence of both is best tested by the extent and durableness of their impression. The publick has not suddenly, but after an experience of five and twenty years, taken that impression of the just celebrity of ALEXANDER HAMILTON, that nothing but his extraordinary intrinsick meri[t] could

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece argues that Federalists who condemn Colonel Burr for the duel with Hamilton are being inconsistent, since they lavish respect on others equally guilty of dueling. It calls for impartiality and for using reason, not partisan anger, to end the practice of dueling, which has left widows and orphans in its wake.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE BOSTON DEMOCRAT. In few instances are the inconsistencies of the Federalists more conspicuous than in their observations on Col. Burr, respecting the late duel. Every epithet that could be bestowed on the most hardened murderer, has been lavished on him; he has been accused of leading an innocent victim like a lamb to the slaughter; every effort has been made to excite the execration of the public against him, and in the listening ears of credulity has been poured a mutilated account of this melancholy occurrence. They have not, however confined themselves entirely to a reprobation of Mr. Burr, but have universally pretended to discountenance duelling; from the pulpit

See the clipping

Rhode-Island Republican · Newport, R.I.

The writer parses a published toast execrating 'that vice which tampers with a life so dear,' arguing its true target is the false notion of honor (dueling) that governed Hamilton's conduct. The essay insists the toast condemns dueling as a principle rather than condemning Hamilton's character itself.

Rhode-Island Republican · 27 September 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

justice to attach to his character and memory, but to such of his vices as had produced that infamy and disgrace: or in other words, that it is not the wicked conduct of a man which demands our detestation and abhorrence, but those vicious principles and irregular passions from which his sentiments were derived, and by which his actions were regulated. That this is the true import of this toast, in my opinion there can be no doubt; and yet perhaps the author of it will not acknowledge that that was his real meaning.

See moreSee less

But if that was not in fact his meaning, pray what meaning could he have had? He cannot deny that it was his intention to execrate that false and foolish notion of honor which has lately become so prevalent in our country; neither can he deny that Hamilton in an eminent degree possessed that false and foolish notion of honor; and I am sure he cannot if he would, alledge with any propriety or consistency, that it was his intention to censure and execrate Hamilton, for having suffered his conduct to be influenced and regulated by that unfounded and wicked principle on which he passed so severe a censure: because the epithet which he affixed to the life of Hamilton was "dear;" and certainly that life can never be esteemed very dear which is possessed by a person whose vices entitle him to public execration and hatred. If then it be admitted that the author of this toast did not intend to censure the conduct or condemn the character of Hamilton, and since it cannot be denied but that he designed to vent all the severity of censure of which he was master, upon a certain vice prominent in Hamilton's character; the conclusion is inevitable, that his meaning could have been no other than the one above stated. Indeed the language of this

See the clipping

Rhode-Island Republican · Newport, R.I.

This opinion piece argues against Federalist rhetoric that treats the duel as entirely Burr's fault while exempting Hamilton from responsibility. The writer contends that excusing dueling as 'honor' undermines law and morality, and criticizes attempts to shield Hamilton's reputation from the disgrace of his own choices.

Rhode-Island Republican · 27 September 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

what reason are principles to be established, which tend to the immediate destruction of those main pillars of our safety and happiness? Why to be sure, to prevent that disgrace from attaching to the late conduct of Alexander Hamilton, which could not otherwise be avoided. A very cogent reason indeed! A most desirable object I must confess; and truely worthy of the attention of every good and sincere federalist. To entirely destroy the foundation of every good principle, can never prove half so pernicious to America, as the delivering over to the custody of justice, the character and reputation of Gen.

See moreSee less

Hamilton. This is evidently the sense and meaning of the toast, and of the general language of the federalists upon that subject: For they say impliedly, that the conduct of Gen. Hamilton in fighting a duel with Col. Burr, was in itself abominably wicked, and ought to be execrated by every person possessed of the least spark of religion or honesty; and at the same time speak another

See the clipping

Rhode-Island Republican · Newport, R.I.

A writer signed 'William Tell' criticizes the double standard in public opinion, noting that Burr is universally cursed as a murderer while Hamilton's role in provoking the fatal duel is excused. The piece argues this inconsistency reveals flawed reasoning about personal responsibility for the duel's outcome.

Rhode-Island Republican · 27 September 1804 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

gree, that effect which their authors foolishly expect. For when we are told that Mr. Burr is a villain, an assassin, and a murderer, for having permitted a false notion of honor, to possess his mind, and that this same false notion of honor, ought to be universally execrated for having audaciously dared to enter the pure and undefiled bosom of Hamilton, who is so stupid and un-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A London newspaper reacts with shock to the Hamilton-Burr duel, criticizing Burr for violating the law as the nation's second-highest magistrate. It further condemns the judge who allegedly countenanced and assisted the duel rather than upholding the law.

The Enquirer · 29 September 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A late London paper in speaking of the late unhappy duel between Gen. Hamilton and Col. Burr, observes.——"The mind is shocked at the circumstance of the second Magistrate of a country having been

See the clipping