Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.
A reader's letter to the Argus laments the duel between Hamilton and Burr, framing it as a sinful violation of God's law despite their high offices and reputations. The writer argues Hamilton's vanity and Burr's lawlessness both led to their ruin, with Hamilton killed and Burr disgraced.
Virginia Argus · 8 September 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FOR THE ARGUS.
Mr. Samuel Pleasants,
See moreSee less
DEAR SIR,
WITH conscious confidence I can assert that I fear GOD and love my COUNTRY. But the continued efforts which are made to support the fallen dignity and justify or cover the inexcusable folly and madness of Burr and Hamilton, do really hurt my feelings. Being a simple and plain man, I suppose it cannot be inexcusable in me to express a few of my simple thoughts on the subject.
Gen. Hamilton has displayed both military and legislative talent, and as some say, all for the good of his country! He has filled important posts! He has been highly esteemed by his friends!——And Col. Burr!—He was the Vice-President of the U. S.!
Very well—Now what have they done in the greatness of their distinction? THEY HAVE FOUGHT A DUEL!—In defiance of the Laws of GOD and Man they entered the list of Fools,* and both have justly fallen victims to their folly. Hamilton tho' great and pious, "loved the praise of men more than the praise of GOD." He had not fortitude to withstand the clamors of the duelling croud. He chose rather to hazard his life. In the mean time however he thought to compound with his Maker, and while by his example he would give sanction to a Hellish and murderous custom, "he determined to reserve his fire." —But the GOD of our fathers, who declared that obedience is better than sacrifice, was not well pleased. He withdrew his protection!—And Hamilton is slain!
Col. Burr, tho' distinguished by his countrymen!—the second in the nation—the