As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

November 1804

7 articles

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A New York editor catalogs embarrassing factual errors by European and American papers, including misidentifying judges and officials. It specifically ridicules a London Weekly Journal's claim that the Burr-Hamilton duel arose from opposing views on Bonaparte and diplomatic appointments.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 November 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Copying into the London Sun of the 20th Aug. the funeral oration of General Hamilton, Mr. Morris is called "Governour of the State of New-York" —This mistake arose from his name, Gouverneur Morris. Say's Weekly Journal, mentioning the duel which terminated the life of the unfortunate and illustrious Hamilton, is wonderfully wise in accounting for it—But we need not be surprised at that in a "Weekly Journal."—He solves all doubts by saying that "it arose from a difference of political opinion; General Hamilton professed himself inimical to the ambition of Buonaparte; and Colonel Burr espoused the cause of Mr.

See moreSee less

Livingston with respect to his general conduct towards the Government of France. It appears that the sentiments of the former had more weight with the American Government, as he had himself received the appointment of Minister at Paris, in the room of Mr. Livingston, and was on the point of setting out on his embassy to that capital".

See the clipping

In the story →

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

The article debates whether Burr can be charged with murder given that Hamilton died in New York while the duel occurred in New Jersey, citing common law versus New Jersey statute. It concludes the Bergen County grand jury was correct to indict Burr for murder, and notes a trial is expected soon.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 November 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Case of Col. Burr. A grand jury of the state of New-Jersey having presented a bill of indictment for murder, against this gentleman, it has become an interesting question, whether the crime of which he has been guilty is really murder in legal signification. By the common law, if the stroke of which one dies be given in one county and he die in another, it is not murder in either. The case being much stronger between different states, it is supposed that as Gen. Hamilton died in New-York and not in New-Jersey, Col. Burr cannot be guilty of murder. But the fact is otherwise; for by a particular statute of the state of New-Jersey, if the stroke be given in New-Jersey, and the death ensues in another state, it is murder. No doubt therefore remains of the nature of the crime, and that the grand jury have been correct. U. S. Gaz.

The Common Law is as above stated; but by force of the statute of 2 & 3 Edw. VI. c 24, the offender was indictable in the county where the party died—In this state the law is otherwise; the offender shall be tried in the Court of that District where the stroke was given, or the poison administered.

See moreSee less

The Legislative provision of the state of New-Jersey, supercedes the Common Law, and settles the question at once. As it is presumed that Col. Burr, will shortly undergo a Trial, according to the Laws of his Country, we shall abstain from any further remark respecting him or his case, until the result of that trial is known.

The Grand Jury of Bergen county, in the state of New-Jersey, has found a bill of indictment for Murder against Aaron Burr, for killing Gen. Hamilton in July last, in said county.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 17 November 1804

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report explains that under New Jersey statute, a fatal stroke given in that state constitutes murder even if death occurs elsewhere, confirming the grand jury's indictment of Aaron Burr for killing Hamilton. It also includes a separately sourced biographical letter from Hamilton describing his early life and Revolutionary War service.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 November 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

GENERAL HAMILTON. From the Liverpool Chronicle of August 24. [We have been favoured, through the courtesy of a gentleman in this town, with the following extract of a letter from the late General Hamilton, dated New-York, 1799, to a relation of his here who

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Bergen County, New Jersey grand jury returned a bill of indictment for murder against Aaron Burr for killing General Hamilton in July, in that county. The brief notice reports the legal action without further detail.

The Enquirer · 10 November 1804 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Grand Jury of Bergen county in the state of New-Jersey, have found a bill of indictment for murder against Aaron Burr, for killing General Hamilton, in July, in said county.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Grand Jury of Bergen County, New Jersey, returned an indictment for murder against Aaron Burr for killing General Hamilton in July, in that county. The report is reprinted from the New York Republican Watch Tower.

Virginia Argus · 10 November 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Providence Gaz.

The Grand Jury of Bergen county in the state of New-Jersey, have found a bill of indictment for MURDER against Aaron Burr, for killing General Hamilton, in July, in said county.

See moreSee less

From the (N. Y.) Republican Watch Tower

See the clipping

Oracle Post · Portsmouth, N.H.

A New Jersey Grand Jury in Bergen County has found a bill of indictment against Aaron Burr for killing General Hamilton in July. The report notes this news arrived via New York papers received by mail.

Oracle Post · 13 November 1804 · page 3

■IMPORTANT JUDGMENT. New^Yurkp ? prrs received by the hflmail,, ■ro^inihe fallowing article ; —"The Grand Jury of Bergen county, in the flare of New-Jersey, have found a bill of indictment ao-iuft Aaron Burr, for killing Gen. HAMILTON io July, in said County.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece discusses Aaron Burr's ambition and disputed role in the 1800 presidential election controversy, questioning whether he betrayed his party through intrigue with federalists. The author argues against condemning Burr as a murderer over the duel, despite believing him politically duplicitous.

The Enquirer · 14 November 1804 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The author of the following observations is personally unacquainted with the qualities and actions of Mr. Burr. Like most of his countrymen, he has had no other means of contemplating the character of the Vice-President, than through the imperfect medium of the facts and suspicions which have been already unveiled to the public eye. The following view must therefore be inaccurate, and it may be unjust. He should as much as any man lament such an injustice; and he would go as far as any man to repair it. Should the contrary side of the medal ever be displayed; should Mr. Burr or any of his friends ever determine to enter into a satisfactory vindication of his conduct: the author of the succeeding sketch will not be the last man in the United States to delineate a different and more favourable picture.

AARON BURR

See moreSee less

might have been beloved and respected by his countrymen, if he had not been desirous of acquiring a premature renown. He was rapidly rising in the estimation of the people; among the most distinguished politicians of his own state he had long maintained an equal or ascendant influence; and the lustre of his name was rapidly extending over the union. But his rising reputation did not correspond with his progressive ambition. A continued life of services might have perhaps entitled him to the most elevated office, which it was in the power of a grateful people to bestow: yet while there remained any higher honour to acquire, his quickening desires were unable to wait the tardy progress of events. A few years might have encircled his brow with the richest wreath of honour: but it was his deplorable destiny to attempt to snatch his laurels from the hand of time.

The nomination of Mr. Burr to the second office under the constitution, was zealously adopted by the republican party throughout the union. They were anxious to select some citizen from New-York, and Mr. Burr was seen among her most distinguished citizens. This sentiment was general; but it was not universal. Even at that time, there were a few men equally distinguished for their love of virtue and their knowledge of men, who ventured to suspect the qualifications of Mr. Burr. They had traced him in the recesses of his private life; and they thought they had discerned some lines in his character, which had excited their disapprobation and dread. It was not the sober and unassuming simplicity of Aristides, which met their eyes: They contemplated rather the polished accomplishments and the pernicious dissipation of Alcibiades. In one quality indeed this illustrious Athenian was evidently superior to the American. He had many vices to conceal; but he had the virtue to display them. Of Mr. Burr it had been remarked, that he had studied a system of continued concealment. There were few confidential bosoms in whom he would repose his most important designs, or most vivid sensations; and few were the occasions on which he would trust his reflections upon paper.

Such qualities wherever they exist, are well calculated to excite the suspicions and the fears of all: and those who imagined they had found them in Mr. Burr, were startled at the idea of raising him even to the second office in the union.

His aspiring ambition seems however, to have grasped even at the first. The history of the last presidential election, is still enveloped in an impenetrable mystery. There are scenes in that political drama, which have not yet been developed, and which it may be well for the honour of our country should ever remain behind the concealment of the curtain.

But the part which Mr. Burr is said to have acted on that occasion, is fraught with the deepest duplicity and disgrace. If Mr. Burr did really intrigue with the federalists, the distrust of his own party has formed his merited punishment; if Mr. Burr is innocent, there are no terms in our language, which can adequately convey an idea of his wrongs. Is Mr. Burr then really an apostate? My own decided impression has ever been, that he is.

With those men, who will contemplate the character of Mr. Burr in this precise attitude, I am willing to accord in the most profound disapprobation of his character. Let them shower down their most abundant anathemas upon the head of the political intriguer; and I will not murmur at the dispensation. And surely even his most inveterate enemies ought to be contented with this expert instrument of torture. Let the pencil of a Titian delineate, if it can, a more odious character under a virtuous republic, than that of a political apostate.--But I will not consent to offer up Mr. Burr as a victim to the offended manes of Mr. Hamilton. To indulge a party rancour or the federal resentment, I will never consent to violate the most obvious maxims of common sense or common justice. I will not join in the war-whoop, that Mr. Burr is a murderer, and that his hands are stained with the blood of a fellow-citizen. Amidst the variety of these melancholy cases, which are passed over with impunity, only because they are so frequent in their recurrence, why (let me ask) is this particular case to be culled and held up as an odious exception? If Mr. Burr has violated the precepts of political morality, does that furnish any adequate proof that he has also neglected the maxims of a chivalrous honour?

By prosecuting such a system of rancorous persecution, the enemies of the Vice-President have forgotten that they become his most useful friends. When resentment is strained beyond the proper degree, or when a vicious character is censured for vices, which it does not really possess; what other emotions does it excite than the sympathy of every feeling mind? When this sensibility is once indulged, it destroys all nice discrimination of qualities. Like the genius of the Muse, it "extends her mystic mantle to all the evils of his life," and the mind loses too much of its disapprobation for the vices of the victim, in sympathising with his unmerited misfortunes.

This then is the plain catechism of the republican party: pity for the fate of Hamilton; impunity towards his antagonist; the most unrelenting suspicion of the political apostate.

Should ever this imperfect sketch meet the eye of Mr. Burr, he knows little of the emotions of its author, if he should conceive him to indulge the resentments of a virulent and implacable Foe. Penetrated as he is with a detestation of his political conduct, as that conduct appears to him at the present moment to be, he has not yet excluded from his bosom every sentiment of admiration and sympathy. He admires the courageous spirit that he has hitherto displayed: He admires the almost inimitable ease and polish of his manners, softened as they now are by the touches of adversity; and the endowments of his mind have not escaped his attention, nor have they failed to attract his reverence. He can truly say that the strongest sentiment which he is at this moment constrained to indulge, flows from the melancholy reflection that a man so highly gifted as Aaron Burr with such various and admirable accomplishments should have anihilated all his usefulness, and sullied his own honor by descending from such an elevated station, to mix in the pollution and abomination of political intrigue.

The Editor cannot but lament that the preceding portrait has not fallen into the hands of some more competent person to design; & that his own avocations have prevented him from giving it a more finished appearance.

See the clipping