From the N.Y. EVENING POST of July.16. TO THE AMERICAN PUBLIC. The shocking catastrophe which has recently occurred, terminating the life of ALEXANDER HAMILTON, and which has spread a gloom over our city that will not be speedily dissipated, demands that the circumstances which led to it, or were ultimately connected with it, should not be concealed from the world. When they shall be truly and fairly disclosed, however some may question the soundness of his judgment on this occasion, all must be ready to do justice to the purity of his views, and the nobleness of his nature.
See moreSee less
It will only here be added, that the authenticity of the documents and the accuracy of the information which we have at last obtained, are beyond any question; and must put an end to all mistake or misrepresentation. The following is the correspondence that passed between general Hamilton and col. Burr, together with an explanation of the conduct, motives and views of general Hamilton, written with his own hand, the evening before the meeting took place, and only to have been seen in the deplorable event that followed. No. I. New-York, June 18, 1804. SIR, I send for your perusal a letter, signed Charles D. Cooper,* which, though apparently published some time ago, has but very recently come to my knowledge. Mr. Van Ness who does me the favour to deliver this, will point out to you the clause of the letter to which I particularly request your attention. You must perceive, sir, the necessity of a prompt & unqualified acknowledgement or denial of the use of any expression which would warrant the assertions of Dr. Cooper. I have the honor to be Your obedient servant, A. BURR. General Hamilton. No. 2. New-York, June 20th, 1804. SIR, I have maturely reflected on the subject of your letter of the 18th instant, and the more I reflected the more I have become convinced that I could not, without manifest impropriety, make the avowal or disavowal which you seem to think necessary. The clause pointed out by Mr. Van Ness is in these terms: "I could detail to you a still more despicable opinion which Hamilton has expressed of Mr. Burr." To endeavour to discover the meaning of this declaration, I was obliged to seek in the antecedent part of this letter for the opinion to which it referred, as having been already disclosed: I found it in these words:—General Hamilton and Judge Kent have declared in substance, that they looked upon Mr. Burr to be a dangerous man, and one who ought not to be trusted with the reins of government." The language of Dr. Cooper plainly implies, that he considered this opinion of you, which he attributes to me, as a despicable one; but he affirms that I expressed some other still more despicable—without, however, mentioning to whom, when, or where. 'Tis evident that the phrase "still more despicable" admits of infinite shades, from very light to very dark. How am I to judge of the degree intended? or how shall I annex any precise idea to language so indefinite? Between gentlemen, despicable and more despicable are not worth the pains of distinction; when, therefore, you do not interrogate me, as to the opinion which is specifically ascribed to me, I must conclude, that you view it as within the limits to which the animadversions of political opponents upon each other may justifiably extend, and consequently as not warranting the idea of it which Dr. Cooper appears to entertain. If so, what precise inference could you draw, as a guide for your conduct, were I to acknowledge that I had expressed an opinion of you more despicable than the one which is particularised? How could you be sure that even this opinion had exceeded the bounds which you would yourself deem admissible between political opponents? But I forbear further comment on the embarrassment to which the requisition you have made naturally leads. The occasion forbids a more ample illustration, though nothing could be more easy than to pursue it. Repeating that I cannot reconcile it with propriety to make the acknowledgment or denial you desire, I will add that I deem it inadmissible, on principle, to consent to be interrogated as to the justness of the inferences which may be drawn by others from whatever I may have said of a political opponent in the course of a fifteen years competition. If there were no other objection to it this is sufficient, that it would tend to expose my sincerity and delicacy to injurious imputations from every person who may at any time have conceived the import of my expressions differently from what I may then have intended or may afterwards recollect. I stand ready to avow or disavow promptly and explicitly, any precise or definite opinion which I may be charged with having declared of any gentleman. More than this cannot fitly be expected from me; and especially it cannot be reasonably expected that I shall enter into an explanation upon a basis so vague as that which you have adopted. I trust on more reflection, you will see the matter in the same light with me. If not, I can only regret the circumstances and must abide the consequences. The publication of Doctor Cooper was never seen by me till after the receipt of your letter. I have the honor to be, &c. A. HAMILTON. Colonel Burr. No. 3. New-York, 21st June, 1804. SIR, Your letter of the 20th instant has been this day received. Having considered it attentively, I regret to find in it nothing of that sincerity and delicacy which you profess to value. Political opposition can never absolve gentlemen from the necessity of a rigid adherence to the laws of honor, and the rules of decorum. I neither claim such privilege nor indulge it in others. The common sense of mankind affixes to the epithet adopted by Dr. Cooper, the idea of dishonor. It has been publicly applied to me under the sanction of your name. The question is not, whether he has understood the meaning of the word, or has used it according to syntax, and with grammatical accuracy; but, whether you have authorised this application, either directly or by uttering expressions or opinions derogatory to my honor. The time "when" is in your own knowledge, but no way material to me, as the calumny has now first been disclosed, so as to become the object of my notice, and as the effect is present and palpable. Your letter has furnished me with new reasons for requiring a definite reply. I have the honor to be, Sir, your obedient, A. BURR. General Hamilton. On Saturday the 22d June, General Hamilton for the first time, called on Mr. P. and communicated to him the preceding correspondence. He informed him that in a conversation with Mr. V. N. at the time of receiving the last letter, he told Mr. V. N. that he considered that letter as rude and offensive, and that it was not possible for him to give it any other answer than that Mr. Burr must take such steps as he might think proper. He said farther, that Mr. V. N. requested him to take time to deliberate, and then return an answer, when he might possibly entertain a different opinion, and that he would call on him to receive it. That his reply to Mr. V. N. was, that he did not perceive it possible for him to give any other answer than that he had mentioned, unless Mr. Burr would take back his last letter and write one which would admit of a different reply. He then gave Mr. P. the letter hereafter mentioned, of the 22d of June, to be delivered to Mr. V. N. when he should call on Mr. P. for an answer, and went to his country house. The next day general Hamilton received, while there, the following letter: No. 4. SIR, June 23, 1804. In the afternoon of yesterday, I reported to col. Burr the result of my last interview with you, and appointed the evening to receive his further instructions. Some private engagements, however, prevented me from calling on him till this morning. On my return to the city I found upon enquiry, both at your office & house, that you had returned to your residence in the country. Lest an interview there might be less agreeable to you than elsewhere, I have taken the liberty of addressing you this note to enquire when and where it will be most convenient to you to receive a communication. Your most obt. and very humble servant, W. P. VAN NESS. General Hamilton. Mr. P—— understood from general Hamilton that he immediately answered, that if the communication was pressing, he would receive it at his country house that day, if not, he would be at his house in town the next morning at 9 o'clock. But he did not give Mr P. any copy of this note. No. 5. New-York, June 23, 1804. SIR, Your first letter, in a style too peremptory, made a demand, in my opinion, unprecedented and unwarrantable. My answer, pointing out the embarrassment, gave you an opportunity to take a less exceptionable course. You have not chosen to do it; but by your last letter received this day, containing expressions indecorous and improper, you have increased the difficulties to explanation intrinsically incident to the nature of your application. If by a "definite reply," you mean the direct avowal or disavowal required in your first letter, I have no other answer to give, than that which has already been given. If you mean any thing different, admitting of greater latitude, it is requisite you should explain. I have the honour to be, Sir, your obedient servant, ALEX. HAMILTON. AARON BURR, Esquire. This letter, although dated on the 23d June, remained in Mr. P's possession until the 25th, within which period he had several conversations with Mr. V. N. In these conversations Mr. P. endeavored to illustrate and enforce the propriety of the ground general Hamilton had taken. Mr. P. mentioned to Mr. V. N. as the result, that if colonel Burr would write a letter, requesting to know in substance, whether in the conversation to which doctor Cooper alluded, any particular instance of dishonorable conduct was imputed to colonel Burr, or whether there was any impeachment of his private character, gen. Hamilton would declare, to the best of his recollection, what passed in that conversation: and Mr. P. read to Mr. V. N. a paper containing the substance of what general H. would say on this subject, which is as follows— No. 6. "Gen. Hamilton says he cannot imagine to what doctor Cooper may have alluded, unless it were to a conversation at Mr. Taylor's in Albany, last winter, (at which Mr. Taylor, he, and Gen. H. were present.) Gen. Hamilton cannot recollect, distinctly, the particulars of that conversation, so as to undertake to repeat them, without running the risk of varying, or omitting what might be deemed important circumstances. The expressions are entirely forgotten, & the specific ideas imperfectly remembered; but to the best of his recollection it consisted of comments on the political principles and views of Col. Burr, and the results that might be expected from them, in the event of his election as governor, without reference to any particular instance of past conduct, or to private character." After the delivery of the letter of the 23d, as above mentioned, in another interview with Mr. V. N. he desired Mr. P. to give him, in writing, the substance of what he had proposed on the part of Gen. Hamilton, which Mr. P. did in the words following:— No. 7. "In answer to a letter properly adapted to obtain from Gen. Hamilton a declaration, whether he had charged col. Burr with any particular instance of dishonorable conduct, or had impeached his private character, either in the conversation alluded to by Dr. Cooper, or in any other particular instance to be specified. He would be able to answer, consistently with his honor, and the truth, in substance, that the conversation to which Dr. Cooper alluded, turned wholly on political topics, and did not attribute to Col. Burr any instance of dishonorable conduct, nor relate to his private character; and in relation to any other language or conversation of gen. H. which col. Burr will specify, a prompt and frank avowal and denial will be given. On the 26th June Mr. P. received the following letter: No. 8. SIR, The letter which you yesterday delivered me, and your subsequent communication, in Colonel Burr's opinion, evince no disposition on the part of gen. Hamilton to come to a satisfactory explanation. The injury complained of, and the reparation expected, are so definitely expressed in col. Burr's letter of the 21st inst. that there is not perceived a necessity for further explanation on his part. The difficulty that would result from confining the enquiry to any particular times and occasions must be manifest. The denial of a specified conversation only, would leave strong implications that on other occasions improper language had been used—When and where injurious opinions and expressions have been uttered by gen. Hamilton, must be best known to him, and of him only will col. Burr enquire. No denial or declaration will be satisfactory, unless it be general, so as wholly to exclude the idea that rumors derogatory to col. Burr's honor have originated with gen. Hamilton, or have been fairly inferred from any thing he has said. A definite reply to a requisition of this nature was demanded by col. Burr's letter of the 21st instant. This being refused, invites to the alternative alluded to in gen. Hamilton's letter of the 20th. It was required by the position in which the controversy was placed by gen. Hamilton on Friday last, and I was immediately furnished with a communication demanding a personal interview. The necessity of this measure has not in the opinion of col. Burr, been diminished by the general's last letter, or any communication which has since been received. I am consequently again instructed to deliver you a message, as soon as it may be convenient for you to receive it—I beg therefore, you will be so good as to inform me at what hour I can have the pleasure of seeing you. Your most obedient and Very humble servant, W. P. VAN NESS. N. Pendleton, esq. June 26th. No. 9. 26th June, 1804. SIR, I have communicated the letter which you did me the honor to write to me of this date to general Hamilton. The expectations now disclosed on the part of col. Burr, appear to him to have greatly extended the original ground of enquiry, and, instead of presenting a particular and definite case for explanation, seem to aim at nothing less than an inquisition into his most confidential conversations, as well as others, through the whole period of his acquaintance with Col. Burr. While he was prepared to meet the particular case fairly and fully, he thinks it inadmissible that he should be expected to answer at large as to every thing that he may possibly have said, in relation to the character of Col. Burr, at any time or upon any occasion. Though he is not conscious that any charges which are in circulation to the prejudice of Col. Burr have originated with him, except one which may have been so considered, and which has long since been fully explained between Col. Burr and himself; yet he cannot consent to be questioned generally, as to any rumours which may be afloat derogatory to the character of Col. Burr, without specification of the several rumours, many of them probably unknown to him. He does not, however, mean to authorise any conclusion as to the real nature of his conduct in relation to Col. Burr, by his declining so loose and vague a basis of explanation, and he disavows an unwillingness to come to a satisfactory, provided it be an honorable, accommodation. His objection is, the very indefinite ground, which Col. Burr has assumed, in which he is sorry to be able to discern nothing short of predetermined hostility. Presuming, therefore, that it will be adhered to, he has instructed me to receive the message which you have it in charge to deliver. For this purpose I shall be at home, and at your command, to-morrow morning from eight to ten o'clock. I have the honor to be respectfully, Your obedient servant, NATHANIEL PENDLETON. William P. Van Ness, Esq. No. 10. SIR, The letter which I had the honor to receive from you, under date of yesterday, states among other things, that in General Hamilton's opinion, Col. Burr has taken a very indefinite ground, in which he evinces nothing short of predetermined hostility, and that Gen. Hamilton The following is Dr. Cooper's letter: [CITIZEN.] Albany, 12th April, 1804. DEAR SIR, You will receive some election papers, and some of them in the German language. I presume you will make use of them to the best advantage: have them dispersed and scattered as much as possible. The friends of Col. Burr are extremely active, and will require all our exertion to put them down. It is believed that most of the reflecting federalists will vote for Lewis. General Hamilton, the Patroon's brother-in-law, it is said, has come out decidedly against Burr; indeed, when he was here, he spoke of him as a dangerous man, and ought not to be trusted. Judge Kent also expressed the same sentiment. The Patroon was quite indifferent about it when he went to New-York. It is thought when he sees gen. Hamilton and his brother-in-law, Mr. Church (who Burr some time ago fought a duel with, and who, of course, must bear Burr much hatred)—I say many feel persuaded that Mr. Rensselaer will be decidedly opposed to Mr. Burr. If you think any of us can aid you in the election in your town, let us know, and we will give you what assistance is in our power. Can you send me word what you think will be the result of the election in your town. Perhaps it will be of use to show the part of this letter that relates to the Patroon, Hamilton, and Church, to some of the Patroon tenants. I leave it to your discretion. In haste, Your's sincerely, CHAS. D. COOPER. A. BROWN, Esq. thinks it inadmissible that the enquiry should extend to his confidential as well as other conversations. In this Col. Burr can only reply, that secret whispers traducing his fame, and impeaching his honor, are at least, equally injurious with slanders publicly uttered: that Gen. H. had, at no time, and in no place, a right to use any such injurious expressions; and that the particular negative he is disposed to give, with the reservations he wishes to make, are proofs that he has done the injury specified. Col. Burr's request was, in the first instance, proposed in a form the most simple, in order that Gen. Hamilton might give to the affair that course to which he might be induced by his temper and knowledge of facts. Col. Burr trusted with confidence, that from the frankness of a soldier, and the candor of a gentleman, he might expect an ingenuous declaration. That if, as he had reason to believe, Gen. H. had used expressions derogatory to his honor, he would have had the magnanimity to retract them; and that if, from his language, injurious inferences had been improperly drawn, he would have perceived the propriety of correcting errors, which might thus have been widely diffused. With these impressions, Col. Burr was greatly surprised at receiving a letter which he considered as evasive, and which in a manner he deemed not altogether decorous. In one expectation, however, he was not wholly deceived, for the close of Gen. Hamilton's letter contained an intimation that if Col. Burr should dislike his refusal to acknowledge or deny, he was ready to meet the consequences. This Col. Burr deemed a sort of defiance, and would have felt justified in making it the basis of an immediate message. But as the communication contained something about the indefiniteness of the request; as he believed it rather the offspring of false pride than of reflection, and as he felt the utmost reluctance to proceed to extremities, while any other hope remained, his request was repeated in terms more explicit. The replies and propositions on the part of Gen. Hamilton, have in Col. Burr's opinion, been constantly in substance the same. Colonel Burr disavows all motives of predetermined hostility, a charge by which he thinks insult added to injury. He feels as a gentleman should feel when his honor is impeached or assailed, and without sensations of hostility or wishes of revenge, he is determined to vindicate that honor at such hazard as the nature of the case demands. The length to which this correspondence has extended, only tending to prove that the satisfactory redress, earnestly desired, cannot be obtained, he deems it useless to offer any proposition, except the simple message which I shall now have the honor to deliver. I have the honor to be, With great respect, Your obedient & very humble serv't, W. P. VAN NESS. Wednesday morning, June 27th, 1804. With this letter a message was received, such as was to be expected, containing an invitation, which was accepted, and Mr. P. informed Mr. V. N. he should hear from him the next day as to further particulars. This letter was delivered to Gen. H. on the same evening, and a very short conversation ensued between him and Mr. P. who was to call on him early the next morning for a further conference. When he did so, Gen. Hamilton said he had not understood whether the message and answer were definitely concluded, or whether another meeting was to take place for that purpose between Mr. P. and Mr. V. N. Under the latter impression, and as the last letter contained matter that naturally led to animadversion, he gave Mr. P. a paper of remarks in his own hand writing, to be communicated to Mr. V. N. if the state of the affair rendered it proper. In the farther interview with Mr. V. N. that day, after explaining the causes which had induced gen. Hamilton to suppose that the state of the affair did not render it improper, he offered this paper to Mr. V. N.; but he declined receiving it, alledging, that he considered the correspondence as closed by the acceptance of the message he had delivered. Mr. P. informed Mr. V. N. of the inducements mentioned by general Hamilton in those remarks, for the postponing the meeting until the close of the circuit; and as this was uncertain, Mr. P. was to let him know when it would be convenient. On Friday the 6th of July, the circuit being closed, Mr. P. gave this information, and that general Hamilton would be ready at any time after the Sunday following. On Monday the particulars were arranged, and the public are but too well acquainted with the sad result. The paper above alluded to is as follows: No. 11. Remarks on the letter of June 27, 1804. Whether the observations on this letter are designed merely to justify the result which is indicated in the close of the letter, or may be intended to give an opening for rendering any thing explicit which may have been deemed vague heretofore, can only be judged of by the sequel. At any rate, it appears to me necessary not to be misunderstood. Mr. Pendleton is therefore authorised to say that, in the course of the present discussion, written or verbal, there has been no intention to evade, defy, or insult; but a sincere disposition to avoid extremities, if it could be done with propriety. With this view G. H. has been ready to enter into a frank and free explanation on any and every object of a specific nature; but not to answer a general abstract inquiry, embracing a period too long for any accurate recollection, and exposing him to unpleasant criticisms from, or unpleasant discussions with any and every person, who may have understood him in an unfavorable sense. This (admitting that he could answer in a manner the most satisfactory to col. Burr) he should deem inadmissible in principle and precedent, and humiliating in practice.—To this therefore he can never submit. Frequent allusion has been made to slanders said to be in circulation. Whether they are openly or in whispers, they have a form and shape, and might be specified. If the alternative alluded to in the close of the letter is definitively tendered, it must be accepted; the time, place and manner to be afterwards regulated. I should not think it right in the midst of a circuit court to withdraw my services from those who may have confided important interests to me, and expose them to the embarrassment of seeking other counsel, who may not have time to be instructed in their cause. I shall also want a little time to make some arrangements respecting my own affairs. The following paper, in the hand writing of Gen. Hamilton, was inclosed with his will and some other papers in a packet addressed to one of his executors, which was of course not to have been delivered but in case of the melancholy event that has happened. As it contains his motives and reflections on the causes that have led to this fatal catastrophe, it is deemed proper to communicate it to the public. No. 12. On my expected interview, with Col. Burr, I think it proper to make some remarks explanatory of my conduct, motives and views. I was certainly desirous of avoiding this interview for the most cogent reasons. 1. My religious and moral principles are strongly opposed to the practice of duelling, and it would ever give me pain to be obliged to shed the blood of a fellow creature in a private combat forbidden by the laws. 2. My wife and children are extremely dear to me, and my life is of the utmost importance to them, in various views. 3. I feel a sense of obligation towards my creditors; who in case of accident to me, by the forced sale of my property, may be in some degree sufferers. I did not think myself at liberty as a man of probity, lightly to expose them to this hazard. 4. I am conscious of no ill will to Col. Burr, distinct from political opposition, which as I trust, has proceeded from pure and upright motives. Lastly, I shall hazard much, and can possibly gain nothing by the issue of the interview. But it was, as I conceive, impossible for me to avoid it. There were intrinsic difficulties in the thing, and artificial embarrassments, from the manner of proceeding on the part of Col. Burr. Intrinsick, because it is not to be denied, that my animadversions on the political principles, character and views of Col. Burr, have been extremely severe, and on different occasions, I, in common with many others, have made very unfavourable criticisms on particular instances of the private conduct of this Gentleman. In proportion as these impressions were entertained with sincerity and uttered with motives and for purposes, which might appear to me commendable would be the difficulty (until they could be removed by evidence of their being erroneous) of explanation or apology. The disavowal required of me by Col. Burr, in a general and indefinite form, was out of my power, if it had really been proper for me to submit to be so questioned; but I was sincerely of opinion, that this could not be, and in this opinion, I was confirmed by that of a very moderate and judicious friend whom I consulted. Besides that Col. Burr appeared to me to assume, in the first instance, a tone unnecessarily peremptory and menacing, and in the second, positively offensive. Yet I wished, as far as might be practicable, to leave a door open to accommodation. This, I think, will be inferred from the written communications made by me and by my direction, and would be confirmed by the conversations between Mr. Van Ness and myself, which arose out of the subject. I am not sure, whether, under all the circumstances, I did not go further in the attempt to accommodate, than a punctilious delicacy will justify. If so, I hope the motives I have stated will excuse me. It is not my design, by what I have said to affix any odium on the conduct of Col. Burr, in this case—He doubtless has heard of animadversions of mine which bore very hard upon him; and it is probable that as usual they were accompanied with some falshood. He may have supposed himself under a necessity of acting as he has done. I hope the grounds of his proceeding have been such as ought to satisfy his own conscience. I trust, at the same time, that the world will do me the justice to believe, that I have not censured him on light grounds, nor from unworthy inducements. I certainly have had strong reasons for what I may have said, though it is possible that in some particulars, I may have been influenced by misconstruction or misinformation. It is also my ardent wish that I may have been more mistaken than I think I have been, and that he, by his future conduct, may shew himself worthy of all confidence and esteem, and prove an ornament and blessing to the country. As well because it is possible that I may have injured Col. Burr, however convinced myself that my opinions and declarations have been well founded, as from my general principles and temper in relation to similar affairs—I have resolved, if our interview is conducted in the usual manner, and it pleases God to give me the opportunity, to reserve and throw away my first fire, and I have thoughts even of reserving my second fire—and thus giving a double opportunity to Col. Burr to pause and to reflect. It is not, however, my intention to enter into any explanations on the ground—Apology, from principle I hope, rather than pride, is out of the question. To those, who, with me, abhorring the practice of duelling may think that I ought on no account to have added to the number of bad examples, I answer that my relative situation, as well in public as private, enforcing all the considerations which constitute what men of the world denominate honour, imposed on me (as I thought) a peculiar necessity not to decline the call. The ability to be in future useful, whether in resisting mischief or effecting good, in those crises of our public affairs, which seem likely to happen, would probably be inseparable from a conformity with public prejudice in this particular. A. H. On the foregoing letters and papers, the Editor will make no comment.—He submits them to the heart and understanding of every reader.