As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

February 1807

109 articles

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Attorney Elias Caldwell moves for a writ of habeas corpus to bring detained petitioners before the court, arguing they were illegally confined after being arrested by General Wilkinson in New Orleans and denied access to counsel. He argues that whatever justified the initial military arrest, no circumstances now justify continued confinement, especially since the President's message suggests the western disturbances have subsided.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

issue the writ prayed for. The court is informed, that the petitioners were arrested by general Wilkinson in New Orleans, that they were sent from thence under the care of an officer of

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Defense counsel argued that General Wilkinson's depositions were inadmissible because the magistrates who took them lacked proven authority, and that even if admitted, they failed to establish any overt act of treason by Burr. Prosecution countered that the President's messages to Congress merited credit as evidence of probable cause, citing public agitation, troop movements, and Burr's conversations with General Eaton as proof of criminal intent.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

sion of a single overt act of treason, by Aaron Burr, much less did they establish the implication of the accused in any such act.

The counsel on the part of the prosecution maintained that to a certain ex-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

New Orleans papers report Edward Livingston's sworn affidavit denying any communication with Aaron Burr regarding the alleged conspiracy against the Union. Separately, Kentucky militia under General Winlock arrested two men and detained several boats on suspicion of involvement in Burr's expedition.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON, CITY,

ing duly sworn on the Holy Evangelist of Almighty God, doth depose, that he hath never had any communication, written or verbal, direct or indirect, with Aaron Burr, or any other person whom he knows or has reason to sus

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Frankfort reports describe militia detaining boats and arresting men suspected of aiding Burr's expedition, with one witness claiming to have seen Burr encamped near the mouth of the Cumberland River. Local commanders are mobilizing militia companies in response to reports of Burr gathering troops and supplies.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Frankfort, January 8

General Winlock, who commands the detachment of militia, now on duty at the Falls of Ohio, has arrested Messrs. Thomas M. Winn and Samuel N. Luckett, both of Jefferson county, on suspicion of being concerned in col. Burr's expedition. Four boats which they were preparing to send off, have been detained, and themselves bound in a recognizance by judge Ormsby, to appear at the next circuit court, the former in the sum of 5000 dollars, and the latter in 10,000 dollars. Another boat, found on the Indian side of the Ohio, and supposed to belong to Davis Floyd, has also been detained.

See moreSee less

General Winlock repaired to Louisville on the 26th ultimo, and positively asserts that no boats or other craft have passed the Falls since that time without examination.

Captain Samuel Philips, of Jefferson county, informs the general, that he passed col. Burr on the 31st ult. at an encampment near the mouth of Cumberland river, where it is conjectured he is endeavoring to collect his troops and provisions.

The above information was communicated to the governor by express, the evening before last.

It is reported that col. Burr has three or four hundred men assembled at his encampment. If the latter should be his whole force at that place, col. Ramsey, of Livingston county, who is authorised by the executive to call out eight companies of militia, will give a good account of him. Col. R. it is expected would be ready to act by the 2d inst.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

In the House of Representatives, John Randolph presses for official information on Aaron Burr's activities along the Mississippi, citing Spain's long effort to separate the Western states. He proposes a resolution requiring the President to furnish Congress with relevant documents.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 2 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Friday, Jan. 16, 1807. CALL FOR PAPERS. Mr. J. Randolph, after quoting that part of the President's message relating to Mr. Burr, said he had waited with

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This editorial argues that the Senate's proposed suspension of the writ of habeas corpus was unnecessary and inexpedient, given the President's own communication suggesting Burr's conspiracy was already defeated and posed no serious threat to New Orleans. The piece accuses Republicans of hypocrisy, contrasting their current support for suspending civil liberties with their past outrage over similar measures under Federalist administrations.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

It is to be deeply regretted that in a government like ours, ambitious and wicked men, who unmerited honours (lavished upon them by the people) have elevated into consequence, should be so regardless of the duty they owe to their country, as to hazard its best interests, and the dearest rights of its citizens, by engaging in plans, that in the event of failure or success, are certain to prove injurious to liberty. Among the circumstances to be deplored on the present occasion, are the extraordinary measures which the government, by its agents, have resorted to, from (we hope) a conviction of their necessity, to the safety of our country; and the yet more alarming measure projected by the Senate of the United States, the suspension of the writ of Habeas Corpus!

See moreSee less

Whatever justification General Wilkinson may offer for that which he appears sensible, was in a measure a violation of the laws of the country, we know not, it may be sufficient, and we have no hesitation in saying that it ought to be compleatly so. As we have paid particular attention to the conduct of Gen. Wilkinson, and mean to keep a steady eye on him hereafter, we shall pass over the extraordinary measures of that officer for the present, and such we think candour demands, as he has declared that he is in possession of such facts as will not only justify him to his country, but command its gratitude. For his sake, we hope he may be able to make good his promise, until then we think his country may withold the gratitude which he almost demands in anticipation. We have said that the bill proposed by the senate was unnecessary, we employ that term because our respect for one of the most dignified authorities of our country, forbid a more forcible expression. We are warranted from the communication of the President, upon which we presume the senate acted, to say that the measure was not expedient. The President states that Burr had failed in his attempts to alienate the attachment to the union of the people of the Western Country, (meaning those of Ohio, Kentuckey, &c.) and was directing his course to New-Orleans, but in another part of the communication the President says, "On the whole, the fugitives from the Ohio, with their associates from the Cumberland, or any other place in that quarter, cannot threaten serious danger to the city of New-Orleans." In short, the general impression made by the communication, is, that Burr's plans are defeated. For

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This report recounts how federal officials learned of Aaron Burr's plans through General Wilkinson and other informants, revealing two objectives: severing the western states from the Union and attacking Mexico. It also describes the Washita land claim as a pretext used to recruit followers and provide cover for the scheme.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

when brought together, developed Burr's general designs, different parts of which only had been revealed to different informants. It appeared that he contemplated two distinct objects, which might be carried on either jointly or separately, and either the

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report describes President Jefferson's proclamation and orders dispatched to Ohio and Mississippi territories to seize boats and arrest conspirators in Burr's scheme. It also recounts Ohio's swift action to crush the plot and Kentucky's earlier failed attempt to prosecute Burr, which had created public sympathy for him.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tion of his proceedings about the last of November; at which time therefore it was first possible to take specific measures to meet them. The proclamation of November 27, two days after the receipt of general Wilkinson's information, was

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This passage details the government's military countermeasures against Aaron Burr's expedition, including militia mobilization in Tennessee, Kentucky, and the Orleans/Mississippi territories, and General Wilkinson's defensive preparations at New Orleans. It notes uncertainty over whether these measures arrived in time to intercept Burr's boats, which passed down the Cumberland and Ohio rivers with fewer men and boats than initially feared.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

yesterday, I learn that on the 22d of December Mr. Burr descended the Cumberland with two boats, merely of accommodation, carrying with him from that state no quota towards his unlawful enterprize. Whether after the arrival of

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · and 2 other papers

President Jefferson communicates to Congress General Wilkinson's letters detailing the apprehension of Burr's associates, noting one was freed by habeas corpus while two key emissaries were being transported to the Atlantic states for trial. He explains that New Orleans was not yet a safe or impartial venue, and that the accused would be arrested and tried under proper judicial direction once they arrived.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

is still suspended to give time for a fair trial of the issue. With the other negociation was in like manner preferred, and provisional measures only taken to meet the event of rupture. While therefore we do not deflect in the slightest degree from the course we then assumed, and are still pursuing, with mutual consent, to restore a good understanding, we are not to impute to them practices as irreconcileable to interest as to good faith, and changing necessarily the relations of peace and justice between us to those of war.

See moreSee less

These surmises are therefore to be imputed to the vauntings of the author of this enterprize, to multiply his partizans, by magnifying the belief of his prospects and support. By letters from General Wilkinson of the 14th and 18th of December, which came to hand two days after the date of the Resolution of the House of Representatives, that is to say, on the morning of the 18th inst. I received the important affidavit, a copy of which I now communicate, with extracts of so much of the letters as comes within the scope of the resolution. By these it will be seen that of three of the principal emissaries of Mr. Burr, whom the general had caused to be apprehended, one had been

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 24 January 1807
  • Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · 9 February 1807

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report describes a general in the western division who, upon learning of Burr's conspiracy, mobilized volunteer militia companies to intercept armed boats. A messenger confirms Burr left Fort Massac with ten boats carrying about six men each, but without arms or military stores.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 February 1807 · page 2

DAN. BISSELL

Bisslc's answcric is stated, than co] Burr left Massacabcuc the lsc inst. With 10 beats wi'sih about six men in each, wizhum arms or any military stores. The vdun tears on this occasion did honor to them. selves And to their country. Figure: to yourself gsicn. R _ as capsi of such men as geu O—-—_---—-ct, majos 'l'-- , _A___ &c. &c. all old vctcraus, and over flih', lendcring (heir services'to thcxr g-si-ncrai and the!!" country. The general ordered the milixia to rbturn to their hnmcs and be ready to march at a momcm'a warn ing." msifctfsssisssssssssi -- ._ ..b- ....--—--- __. _ -._-._..__

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

James L. Donaldson deposes that General Wilkinson confided in him details of an alleged treasonous plot by Aaron Burr to separate the western states, including a coded letter from Burr and the activities of agents Bollman and Alexander in New Orleans. The deposition describes Wilkinson's reactions, his secret meetings with Bollman, and his preparations to send dispatches to the federal government.

The Enquirer · 3 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Wm. BRENT, Cl'k.

DEPOSITION OF JAMES L. DONALDSON.

See moreSee less

In open court personally appears James Lowry Donaldson, who being duly sworn, deposeth and saith that he was in the city of New Orleans, in the Orleans territory, and the environs of said city, from the 15th of October to the 10th day of December, 1806—that during the latter part of this time he was frequently in the company of General James Wilkinson, and visited the General the day after his arrival at New-Orleans. On this occasion this deponent received in confidence from General Wilkinson information to the following purport—That the General had undoubted and indisputable evidence of a treasonable design formed by Aaron Burr and others to dismember the union, by a separation of the western states and territories from the Atlantic states—that New Orleans was in immediate danger, and that he had concluded a hasty compromise with the Spaniards, so as to be able to withdraw his troops instantly to this the immediate object of attack and great vulnerable point—That he had received a letter from Burr holding forth great inducements to him to become a party, of which he shewed me the original in cypher, and another written paper purporting to be a decyphered copy of the letter. He expressed great indignation at the plot and surprise that one so well acquainted with him as Burr should dare to make to him so degrading a proposal, and declared his determination of defeating the enterprize, or perishing in the attempt. He observed in addition that there were many agents of Mr. Burr then in the town, who had already been assiduous in their visits, and towards whom he was determined to act with cautious ambiguity, so as at the same time to become possessed of the whole extent of the plan, the persons engaged, and the time of its execution, and also to prevent any attempt on his person, of which he declared he had serious apprehensions.—Of the number of these agents he was not aware, but mentioned the name of two of whom he was certain, Messrs. Bollman and Alexander. From time to time, as this deponent had interviews with General Wilkinson, he informed this deponent that he had received additional information respecting the movements and designs of Burr by means of these agents, of whom he considered

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The report notes that when the schooner Messenger left Vera Cruz, a British frigate was loading three million dollars in silver. This was done under an order from the King of England, countersigned by the King of Spain.

The Enquirer · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CURIOUS FACT.

From the silence of the National Intelligencer on the subject, we are induced to believe that the rumour of Burr's being at the "mouth of Cumberland river with 1700 men," as mentioned in an evening paper, is not correct. If an express had "arrived at Washington on Monday evening," the Intelligencer would certainly have mentioned something of it. American.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A Richmond newspaper communication argues that Aaron Burr, like Benedict Arnold, hails from Connecticut and is now proven a traitor by official authority. The writer speculates on Burr's political motives and compares his fall from ambition to a potential execution.

The Enquirer · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, 3d FEBRUARY.

COMMUNICATION.

See moreSee less

It is remarkable that the only traitors which America has produced, have been furnished by the little federal state of Connecticut—the favorite abode of "steady habits;" Benedict Arnold, and Aaron Burr: and if, as the Aurora says, the only member of the present administration, who comes from that state, is also false to his country, the seat of true religion will have the honor, of a third traitor to boast. The guilt of Burr no longer rests upon rumour; we have the highest official authority, that he is a traitor. "Ill-weav'd ambition, how much art thou shrunk!" He who thought to sit upon the throne of Mexico, it is not impossible may end his career upon a gibbet. But guilty as this man is, justice has not been done him; because he is now vicious, it is concluded that he was always so; and, because he is detected, his scheme is pronounced extravagant and impracticable. That Burr was not always vicious, I think is proven by his long and steady attach-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report celebrates General Eaton's deposition as decisive proof of Aaron Burr's treasonous designs, praising his incorruptible fidelity despite Burr's alleged attempts to corrupt him. It frames the defeat of Burr's conspiracy as evidence of the strength and popular support of Jefferson's government.

Virginia Argus · 3 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

It is with great pleasure we find that the gallant General Eaton has come forward as an indubitable witness, to prove the detestable treason meditated by Aaron Burr, whose artifices and temptations were all unable to corrupt the fidelity of that brave officer. His deposition in our paper of this day will no doubt be uncommonly interesting to our readers. The horrible designs which are there revealed as intended to have been accomplished by Burr, afford a melancholy example of human depravity.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

President Jefferson transmits to Congress letters from military officers describing Aaron Burr's passage down the Ohio River with about ten boats and sixty men, finding no visible arms or ammunition aboard. Accompanying dispatches from Tennessee and Fort Massac detail efforts to track Burr's movements and militia measures to block further support reaching him.

Virginia Argus · 3 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

MESSAGE OF THE PRESIDENT

By the letters of captain Bissel, who commands at fort Massac, and of Mr. Murrell, to general Jackson of Tennessee, copies of which are now communicated to congress, it will be seen that Aaron Burr passed fort Massac on the 31st of December, with about ten boats navigated by about six hands each, without any military appearance: [illegible] boats with ammunition were said to have been arrested by the militia at Louisville.

As the guards of militia posted on various points of the Ohio, will be able to prevent any further aids passing through that channel, should any be attempted, we may now estimate with tolerable certainty the means derived from the Ohio and its waters, towards the accomplishment of the purposes of Mr. Burr.

See moreSee less

TH. JEFFERSON

See the clipping

In the story →

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 7 other papers

A witness testifies about conversations with Aaron Burr, in which Burr described his plans to raise an army, secure allies across Kentucky, Tennessee, and Louisiana, and establish an independent government west of the Alleghany. Burr allegedly claimed General Wilkinson's support and discussed the prospects for seducing the army with pay, rations, and plunder.

Virginia Argus · 3 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM EATON, ESQ. Early last winter, col. Aaron Burr, late vice-president of the United States, signified to me, at this place, that, under the authority of the general government, he was organising a secret expedition against the Spanish provinces on our south-western borders; which expedition he was to lead, and in which he was authorised to invite me to take the command of a division. I had never before been made personally acquainted with col. Burr; and, having for many years been employed in foreign service, I knew but little about the estimation this gentleman now held in the opinion of his countrymen and his government: the rank and confidence by which he had so lately been distinguished left me no right to suspect his patriotism.

See moreSee less

I knew him a soldier. In case of a war with the Spanish nation which from the tenor of the President's message to both Houses of Congress seemed probable, I should have thought it my duty to obey so honorable a call of my country; and, under that impression I did engage to embark in the expedition. I had frequent interviews with col. Burr in this city—and, for a considerable time, his object seemed to be to instruct me by maps, and other information, the feasibility of penetrating to Mexico—always carrying forward the idea that the measure was authorised by government. At length, some time in February, he began by degrees to unveil himself—He reproached the government with want of character, want of gratitude, and want of justice. He seemed desirous of irritating resentment in my breast by dilating on certain injuries he felt I had suffered from reflections made on the floor of the House of Representatives concerning my operations in Barbary, and from the delays of government in adjusting my claims for disbursements on that coast during my consular agency at Tunis; and he said he would point me to an honorable mode of indemnity. I now began to entertain a suspicion that Mr. Burr was projecting an unauthorised military expedition; which, to me, was enveloped in mystery; and, desirous to draw an explanation from him, I suffered him to suppose me resign- resigned to his counsel. He now laid open his project of revolutionising the western country, seperating it from the union, establishing a monarchy there, of which he was to be the soveretgn, New-Orleans to be his capital; organising a force on the waters of the Mississippi, and extending conquest to Mexico. I suggested a number of impediments to his scheme—such as the republican habits of the citizens of that country, and their affection towards our present administration of government; the want of funds; the resistance he would meet from the regular army of the U. States on those frontiers; and the opposition of Miranda in case he should succeed to republicanise the Mexicans. Mr. Burr found no difficulty in removing these obstacles—he said he had, the preceding season, made a tour thro' that country, and had secured the attachment of the principal citizens of Kentucky, Tennessee and Louisiana to his person and to his measures —declared he had inexhaustible resources to funds; assured me the regular army would act with him, and would be reinforced by 10 or 12,000 men from the above men- the above mentioned states and territory and from other parts of the union; said he had powerful agents in the Spanish territory—and, as for Miranda, said Mr. Burr, we must hang Miranda. He now proposed to give me the second command in his army. I asked him who should have the chief command? He said, General Wilkinson. I observed it was singular that he should count on Gen. Wilkinson: the elevated rank and high trust he now held as commander in chief of our army and governor of a province, he would hardly put at hazard for any precarious prospects of aggrandizement. Mr. Burr said gen. Wilkinson balanced in the confidence of government, was doubtful of retaining much longer the consideration he now enjoyed, and was consequently prepared to secure to himself a permanency. I asked Mr. Burr, if he knew gen. Wilkinson? He answered yes: and echoed the question. I said I knew him well. "What do you know of him? said Mr. Burr."—I know, I replied, that gen. Wilkinson will act as Lieutenant to no man in existence. "You are in an error," said Mr. Burr— "Wilkinson will act as lieutenant to me." From the tenor of repeated conversations with Mr. Burr, I was induced to believe the plan of separating the union which he had contemplated had been communicated to and approved of by gen. Wilkinson, (though I now suspect it an artful argument of seduction) and he often expressed a full confidence that the general's influence; the offer of double pay and double rations; the prospect of plunder and the ambition of achievement would draw the army into his measures. Mr. Burr talked of the establishment of an independent government west of the Alleghany as a matter of inherent, constitutional right of the people; a change which would eventually take place, and in the operation of which the present crisis was peculiarly favorable. There was, said he, no energy in the government to be dreaded, and the divisions of political opinions throughout the union was a circumstance of which we should profit. There were very many enterprising men among us who aspired to something beyond the dull pursuits of civil life and who would volunteer in this enterprize, and the vast territory belonging to the United States, which teer offered to adventurers, and the mines of Mexico would bring strength to his standard from all quarters. I listened to the exposition of col. Burr's views with seeming acquiescence. Every interview convinced me more and more that he had organised a deep laid plot of treason in the west, in the accomplishment of which he felt fully confident. Till, at length, I discovered that his ambition was not bounded by the waters of the Mississippi and Mexico, but that he meditated overthrowing the present government of our country. He said, if he could gain over the marine corps, and secure the naval commanders, Truxton, Preble, Decatur, and others, he would turn Congress neck and heels out of doors; assassinate the President; seize on the treasury and the navy, and declare himself the protector of an energetic government. The honorable trust of corrupting the marine corps, and of sounding commodore Preble and capt. Decatur col. Burr proposed confiding to me. Shocked at this proposition, I dropped the mask, and exclaimed against his views. He talked of the degraded situ- situation of our country, and the necessity of a blow by which its energy and its dignity should be restored—said, if that blow could be struck here at this time, he was confident of the support of the best blood of America. I told col. Burr he deceived himself in presuming that he, or any other man could excite a party in this country who would countenance him in such a plot of desperation, murder and treason. He replied, that he, perhaps, knew better the dispositions of the influential citizens of this country than I did. I told him, one solitary word would destroy him. He asked, what word? I answered, Usurper! He smiled at my hesitation, and quoted some great examples in his favor. I observed to him that I had lately travelled from one extreme of the union to the other; and, tho' I found a diversity of political opinion among the people, they appeared united at the most distant aspect of national danger. That, for the section of the union to which I belonged, I would vouch, should he succeed in the first instance here, he would within six weeks afterward have his throat cut by Yankee militia. Though wild and extravagant Mr. Burr's last project: and tho' fraught with premeditated slaughter, I felt very easy on the subject, because its defeat he had deposited in my own hands. I did not feel so secure concerning that of disjointing the union. But the very interesting and embarrassing situation in which his communication placed me, left me, I confess, at a stand to know how to conduct myself with propriety. He had committed no overt act of aggression against law. I could draw nothing from him in writing; nor could I learn that he had exposed his plans to any person near me by whom my testimony could be supported. He had mentioned to me no persons who were principally and decidedly engaged with him except Gen. Wilkinson—a Mr. Alston, who I found was his son-in-law—and a Mr. Ephraim Kibby, late a captain of Rangers in Gen. Wayne's army. Satisfied that Mr. Burr was resolute in pushing his project of rebellion in the west of the Alleghany, and apprehensive that it was too well and too extensiv[ely] extensively organized to be easily suppressed ; though I dreaded the weight of his character when laid in the balance against my solitary as- sertion, I brought myself to the resolution to endeavor to defeat it by getting him re- moved from among us, or to expose my- self to all consequences by a disclosure of his intentions. Accordingly, I waited on the President of the United States ; and af- ter some desultory conversation, in which I aimed to draw his view to the westward, I used the freedom to say to the President I thought Mr. Burr should be sent out of this country---and gave for reason, that I believed him dangerous in it. The Presi- dent asked where he should be sent ? I men- tioned London and Cadiz. The President thought the trust too important, and see- med to entertain a doubt of Mr. Burr's in- tegrity. I intimated that no one, perhaps, had stronger grounds to mistrust Mr. Burr's moral integrity than myself ; yet, I believ- ed, ambition so much predominated over him that, when placed on an eminence and put on his honor, respect to himself would ensure his fidelity : His talents were un- fidelity: His talents were unquestionable. I perceived the subject was disagreeable to the President; and to give it the shortest course to the point, declared my concern that if Mr. Burr were not in some way disposed of, we should, within eighteen months, have an insurrection, if not a revolution, on the waters of the Mississippi. The President answered, that he had too much confidence in the information, the integrity, and the attachment to the union of the citizens of that country to admit an apprehension of the kind. I am happy that events prove this confidence well placed. As no interrogatories followed my expression of alarm I thought silence on the subject, at that time and place, became me. But I detailed, about the same time, the whole projects of Mr. Burr to certain members of Congress. They believed Col. Burr capable of any thing—and agreed that the fellow ought to be hanged; but thought his projects too chimerical and his circumstances too desperate to give the subject the merit of serious consideration. The total security of feeling in those to whom I had rung the tocsin, induced me to suspect my own apprehensions unseasonable, or at least too deeply admitted; and, of course, I grew indifferent about the subject. Mr. Burr's visits to me became less frequent, and his conversation less familiar. He appeared to have abandoned the idea of a general revolution; but seemed determined on that of the Mississip[pi]; and, although I could perceive symptoms of distrust in him towards me, he manifested great solicitude to engage me with him in the enterprize. Weary of his importunity, and at once to convince him of my serious attachments, I gave the following toast to the public:—The United States—Palsy to the brain that should plot to dismember, and leprosy to the hand that will not draw to defend our union! I doubt whether the sentiment was better understood by any one of my acquaintance than Col. Burr. Our intercourse ended here—we met but seldom afterwards. I returned to my farm in Massachusetts, and thought no more of Mr. Burr, nor his empire, till sometime late in September or beginning of October, when a letter from Morris Belknap, of Marietta, to Timothy E. Danielson, fell into my hands at Brim- Brimfield, which satisfied me that Mr. Burr had actually commenced his preparatory operations on the Ohio. I now spoke publicly of the fact—transmitted a copy of the letter from Belknap to the department of state, and about the same time forwarded through the hands of the post master general to the President of the United States, a statement in substance, of what is here above detailed concerning the Mississippi conspiracy of the said Col. Aaron Burr—which is said to have been the first formal intelligence received by the executive on the subject of the conspirator being in motion. I know not whether my country will allow me the merit of correctness of conduct in this affair. The novelty of the duty might, perhaps, have embarrassed stronger minds than mine. The uprightness of my intentions I hope will not be questioned. The interviews between Col. Burr and myself, from which the foregoing statement has resulted, were chiefly in this city, in the months of February and March, last year. WILLIAM EATON. Washington city, Jan. 26, 1807. Sworn to in open court this 26th day of January, 1807. Wm. BRENT, Clk.

See the clipping

Also printed in 7 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 28 January 1807
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 30 January 1807
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 3 February 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 4 February 1807
  • Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 13 February 1807 · an extract
  • The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · 17 February 1807
  • The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 5 March 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A New York correspondent relays reports that General Wilkinson's forces were nearing Natchez while Burr followed with an army of 6,000 men, causing alarm and a new embargo at New Orleans. The account also mentions Burr being escorted by U.S. troops near Massac and other fragmentary war-scare rumors.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 6 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Fed. Gaz. Philadelphia, Feb 2. We stop the press to insert the following abstract of our New York correspondents' letter dated yesterday. Arrived, Susan and Betsey, New Orleans 25 days. "Capt. Bowen, of the brig Sukey and Betsey, from New-Orleans, informs, that for some days previous to his sailing, the alarm had, in a great measure subsided, and that the embargo was raised on the 31st of December; but that, on the morning of the 2d January, an express arrived from Cumberland, and a second express reached New-Orleans in 3 days from Natchez, with information, that general Adair with an advanced guard of 2000 men was within three days march of Natchez, and that Burr was following with 6000 men.

See moreSee less

This occasioned a new alarm at N. Orleans—another embargo was expected—and all the inhabitants were exerting themselves in removing their property. "A boat with 30,000 dollars pursued the Susan and Betsey down the river,

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The U.S. attorney informs the court that Bollman and Swartwout were seized by military order as participants in treasonably levying war, and were brought under guard to be dealt with by civil authority. He moves the court to issue a warrant for their arrest so they may be examined and committed according to law, citing General Wilkinson's sworn testimony about Burr's planned forces.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The remaining objects relates to the degree of credit this court can give to the common report of a rebellion, authenticated by the publick and official communications of the president to congress. Be it remembered that this is not relied on as being evidence upon the definitive trial of the prisoners when their life or death is at issue ; but merely as a matter of publick notoriety, of which all courts and magistrates may take notice and prima facie presume the existence of such a state of things, for the preliminary purpose of issuing warrants or other process initiative to a prosecution by indictment.

See moreSee less

The constitution expressly prescribes it to the President as a duty, that "he shall, from time to time, give to the congress information of the state of the union." To give information of an existing state of rebellion, or of "levying war," is clearly within the terms of that duty. Common report, thus authenticated, must surely satisfy the terms "probable cause" used in the 6th article of the amendment--If the requisite of that "probable cause" being "supported by oath or affirmation," is strictly insisted on ; it should be remembered that all the functions of the President are performed under the sanction of an oath. The "probable cause" is farther supported by the oath of Gen. Wilkinson, who swears of that one of the prisoners, an acknowledged confederate in this conspiracy, informed him on the 30th Nov. that Burr would be at Natches on the 20th Dec. with 2000 men, to be followed by 4000 more, and that he could have raised 12,000 as easily as 6000, but did not think so great a number necessary. It may be very reasonably and naturally inferred from this information, when the dates are compared, that at least the 2000 men must have been already enlisted on the 30th of November. Mr. Jones then offered the following motion :

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The writer argues that even though Bollman and Swartwout's known actions at New Orleans—attempting to corrupt the American commander—do not themselves constitute an overt act of war, their complicity with Burr's armed confederates elsewhere makes them guilty of treason by association. It contends that the constitutional definition of 'levying war' should be read broadly, in line with English legal tradition, to include such conspiratorial roles.

The Enquirer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

tion,—no levying of war against the U. S.— Agreed ;—it is not necessary to contend otherwise in order to shew that the prisoners should be arrested and committed as traitors.—It is clear from the evidence that they are leagued and confederated, in his atrocious projects, with Aaron Burr, the notorious head and leader of the conspirators. They are active and

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This piece analyzes the legal distinction between treason and mere riotous combination, arguing that Burr's alleged conspiracy must be judged as either treason or nothing. It discusses the constitutional and statutory basis for the President calling forth the militia, emphasizing that an overt act of levying war is required before treason charges or military suppression are justified.

The Enquirer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

any purpose of domestic coercion, strongly implies that there is at least a levying of war against the U. S. He is authorised by law to do so in two cases only. The first is that of an actual insurrection against any state. The second of actual opposition to the laws by combinations too powerful to be suppressed by the ordinary course of judicial proceedings. The last case may perhaps extend to instances of opposition to the laws, by combinations not treasonable in their nature, nor proceeding to the length of levying war against the U.

See moreSee less

S. It may comprehend the case of unlawful assemblies of men, who violently resist and overbear the due course of legal justice, but who from the nature of their designs and ultimate object, are no further criminal than as riotors and disturbers of the peace. As to the degree of the crime committed by Burr and his associates, it is either treason or nothing. The treasonable intent is

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 6 February 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The U.S. attorney informs the court that Bollman and Swartwout were seized by military order as persons levying war against the United States and brought under guard into the district. He moves the court to issue a warrant for their arrest on treason charges, supporting the motion with General Wilkinson's deposition about Burr's planned troop movements.

The Enquirer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

war," is clearly within the terms of that duty.

Common report, thus authenticated, must surely satisfy the terms "probable cause" used in the 6th article of the amendments--if the requisite of that "probable cause" being "supported by oath or affirmation," is strictly insisted on; it should be remembered that all the functions of the President are performed under the sanction of a solemn oath. The "probable cause" is further supported by the oath of general Wilkinson, who swears that one of the prisoners, an acknowledged confederate in this conspiracy, informed him on the 30th November that Burr would be at Natchez on the 20th December with 2000 men, to be followed by

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Militia under General Winlock arrested two men in Jefferson County, Kentucky suspected of involvement in Burr's expedition, detaining several boats. Reports placed Burr with 300-400 men near the mouth of the Cumberland River, with local militia preparing to confront him.

The Enquirer · 6 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

KENTUCKY. Frankfort, Jan. 8. General Winlock, who commands the detachment of militia, now on duty at the Falls of Ohio, has arrested Messrs. Thomas M. Winn and Samuel N. Luckett, both of Jefferson county, on suspicion of being concerned in Colonel Burr's expedition. Four boats which they were preparing to send off, have been detained and themselves bound in a recognizance by judge Ormsby, to appear at the next circuit court, the former in the sum of 5000 dollars, and the latter in 10,000 dols. Another boat, found on the Indian side of the Ohio, and supposed to belong to Davis Floyd, has also been detained.

See moreSee less

Gen. Winlock, repaired to Louisville on the 26th ultimo, and positively asserts that no boats or other craft have passed the Falls since that time without examination. Capt. Samuel Philips of Jefferson county, informs the general that he passed Col. Burr on the 31st ult. at an encampment near the mouth of Cumberland river, where it is conjectured he is endeavoring to collect his troops and provisions.

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

This report details President Jefferson's message describing how federal and territorial officials were alerted to Burr's suspicious activities on the Ohio and Mississippi, and how General Wilkinson reported Burr's agent had tried to recruit him with cipher messages. It outlines Burr's apparent twin goals of severing the western states from the Union and/or attacking Mexico, with the Washita land purchase serving as a cover story.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the projected enterprize.

The general's letter which came to hand on the 25th of November, as has been mentioned, and some other information, received a few days earlier, when brought together, developed Burr's general designs, different parts of which

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report details the actions taken by Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee authorities to investigate and suppress Aaron Burr's conspiracy, including seizing boats and provisions. It notes that despite these efforts, Burr managed to descend the Cumberland River with two boats, evading major disruption from Tennessee's response.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

to arrest the persons concerned, and to suppress effectually the further progress of the enterprize. A little before the receipt of these orders in the state of Ohio, our confidential agent, who had been diligently employed in investigating the conspiracy, had acquired sufficient information to open himself to the governor of that state, and to apply for the immediate exertion of the authority and power of the state to crush the combination. Governor Tiffin and the legislature with a promptitude, and energy and patriotic zeal, which entitle them to a distinguished place in the affection of their sister states, effected the seizure of all the boats, provisions and other preparations within their reach, and thus gave a first blow, materially disabling the enterprize in its outset.

See moreSee less

In Kentucky a premature attempt to bring Burr to justice, without sufficient evidence for his conviction, had produced a popular impression in his favor, and a general disbelief of his guilt. This gave an unfortunate opportunity of hastening his equipments. The arrival of the proclamation and orders, and the application and information of our confidential agent, at length awakened the authorities of that state to the truth, and produced the same promptitude & energy of which the neighboring state had set the example. Under an act of their le[gislature]

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I. · 7 February 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

The report describes Burr descending the Cumberland River with boats but no significant troops, and details the defensive measures taken at New Orleans under General Wilkinson, including militia readiness and citizen support. It also addresses rumors of foreign involvement in Burr's scheme, dismissing them as unsupported, while affirming that current diplomatic relations remain stable.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

orders were sent to the governors of Orleans and Mississippi, supplementary to those which had been given on the 25th of November, to hold the militia of their territories in readiness to co-operate for their defence with the regular troops and armed vessels then under command of general Wilkinson. Great alarm indeed was excited at New-Orleans by the exaggerated accounts of Mr. Burr, disseminated thro' his emissaries, of the armies and navies he was to assemble there. General Wilkinson had arrived there himself on the 24th of Novemb[er]

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · 9 February 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

General James Wilkinson reports on habeas corpus proceedings for Bollman, Swartwout, and Ogden, accusing Judge Workman of complicity with Burr's conspiracy. He includes his sworn warrant charging Dr. Erick Bollman with treason, based on a letter Bollman sent him in September 1806.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

I, James Wilkinson, Brigadier General and Commander in Chief of the army of the United States, do warrant the arrest of Dr. Erick Bollman, on a

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

This report reproduces the decoded cipher letter from Aaron Burr to General Wilkinson outlining the conspiracy's military plans, including troop movements down the Mississippi and a rendezvous near Natchez. It also includes a related dispatch from New Orleans referencing correspondence between Wilkinson and local officials.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the falls on the 15th of November, with the first 500, or 1000 men in light boats, now constructing for that purpose—to be at Natches between the 5th and 15th of Dec.—then to meet Wilkinson—then to determine whether it will be expedient in the first instance to seize on or pass by Baton Rouge—on receipt of this send Burr an answer—draw on Burr for all expences, &c. The people of the country to which we are going are prepared to receive us—their agents now with Burr say that if we will protect their religion, and will not subject them to a foreign power, that in three weeks all will be settled.

See moreSee less

The gods invite to glory and fortune—it remains to be seen whether we deserve the boon. The bearer of this goes express to you—he will hand a formal letter of introduction to you from Burr, a copy of which is hereunto subjoined—he is a man of inviolable honour and perfect discretion, formed to execute rather than to project; capable of relating facts with fidelity and incapable of relating them otherwise. He is thoroughly informed of the plans and intentions of , and will disclose to you as far as you require, and no further; he has imbibed a reverence for your character and may be embarrassed in your presence; put him at ease and he will satisfy you. Dr. Bollman, equally confidential, better informed on the subject, and more intelligent, will hand the duplicate——"29th July." The day after my arrival at this city, the 25th of November last, I received another letter from the Doctor, of which the following is a correct copy.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

General Wilkinson swears under oath that Dr. Erick Bollman revealed Burr's plans to raise thousands of men and move toward Natchez, with supplies expected from New York and Norfolk. The document also includes an 1806 Burr letter of introduction for Samuel Swartwout, followed by a note on district court proceedings in the Swartwout and Bollman case.

Herald of the United States · 7 February 1807 · page 2

Th» mail bavfeg «r rived th* day Wort, I aflr «d him whethsr he had received any intelli gence from Col. B‘jm, [J( informed me that be bad fee* a letter from Col. Burnt of the 30th of OXober, in which he (Col. Bute) gave aflorances chat he % ,Id be at Ntrtdiez with zooo men on the zo.a of December ioft. where he Ihoold wait ontil he heard from thia place. That he would be followed by 4000 men more, and that he (Col. Dur a,) if ha had cholan, eon d have railed or got 12,000 as eofy aa 6,000.

See moreSee less

bat that he did not think that number neceflary— confiding fully to thia ir»- forrdatioo 1 bacams indifferent about further difgcife. I <heo told the Doflor that I (hoold moft certainly oppofe Col. Burr if he came thia way. He replied, they mult come here for eqoipmeats and f!>ipptm>, and obferaed that he did not know what had puffed between Col. Burr and myfeli, obliqued at a ftiam de> fence and waved the fubjeX From the documrnti in my poff.-flidn, end the feyeral communications, verbal at well at writtea, from the faid DoOor Er rick 8011-, man oa thia lubjeX. J feel no hafitetion in declaring under the folemn obligation of an oath, that he haa committed tnifprifon of tree. 1 fan agaioft the government of the Caned

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

President Jefferson recounts how reports of Aaron Burr's unlawful designs in the Western country reached him from September through October 1806, mostly via unsworn letters mixing rumor and conjecture. He describes dispatching a trusted agent to the western territories to investigate the plots, confer with officials, and act to suppress any unlawful enterprise.

Herald of the United States · 7 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CONSPIRACY

Some time in the latter part of September, I received intimations that designs were in agitation in the Western country, unlawful and unfriendly to the peace of the union: and that the prime mover in these was AARON BURR, heretofore distinguished by the favor of his

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report recounts legal maneuvering over the arrest of Erick Bollman, including an attorney's application for a writ of habeas corpus that was initially refused then allowed. General Wilkinson personally appears in court to justify the arrest, claiming full responsibility and citing a conspiracy led by Aaron Burr threatening national safety.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 9 February 1807 · page 2

ry, 1 did pot urge the return of the writ*, | and nt General Wilkinson's request, it aas postponed till the day after, when, it having been understood that the re turn was to be made by the geneial in

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Edward Livingston defends himself against General Wilkinson's charges of complicity in Burr's alleged conspiracy, publishing certificates and correspondence showing he openly disclosed his dealings with Bollman and the payment to Rodman. He challenges Wilkinson to formally present evidence before a tribunal, noting the general has failed to substantiate charges made in open court.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 9 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[in]formed me, that Bollman had presented to him an order for about two thousand dollars, drawn in favor of Bollman by col. Burr, and at the same time expressed his surprise that Burr should have been indebted to Bollman. [Signed] "JAMES BROWN.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

A speaker argues against suspending habeas corpus, questioning whether the Burr conspiracy truly threatens public safety given the overwhelming government forces (1,000 regular troops plus militia) compared to the conspirators' estimated 150 men. He emphasizes that habeas corpus has never been suspended in the government's 30-year history.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

[S]uspension of the [h]abeas corpus for its suppression. In the communication now on our table from the executive, we have been informed that the militia of Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, of the Mississippi and Orleans territories, have been ordered out—that general Wilkinson was at Orleans on the 10th of December with his troops from the Sabine, which from other information we know to consist of one thousand effective men. These are the resources of the nation now in active operation. What is the force of the conspirators ? By the same document we are informed that ‘ some boats, accounts vary from five to double or treble that number, and persons differently estimated from one to three hundred, had passed the falls of Ohio to rendezvous at the mouth of Cumberland river, with others expected down that river.’ From the same document it appears that the force which comes down Cumberland river amounts to two boats, in one of which is Aaron Burr.

See moreSee less

From this statement it appears that the largest calculation as to the actual

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 10 February 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers

Burr's counsel argued in court that the President's message carried no legal weight and that General Wilkinson's depositions were inadmissible due to lack of proper certification. They contended no specific facts proved treason, at most an enterprise against a foreign province.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

On Friday Mr. Lee adduced a number of additional authorities and made some further remarks.

Mr. Rodney then closed the argument in a speech of about an hour and an half in length.

See moreSee less

The volume of matter adduced on this occasion was so great that scarcely a brief outline of it can be expected at present. We shall content ourselves with touching on the most prominent points.

The counsel of the accused contended that the message of the President, on this occasion, was not entitled to the least attention, however worthy of regard by the legislature to whom they were addressed or generally by the people, they could not in a case that required legal evidence, be of any avail. That if, however, the court should be of a different opinion, they notwithstanding would be found on examination to be destitute of any specifick facts which justified the opinion that any act of treason had been committed by Aaron Burr, and much less by the accused. That they in fact establised the commission of no crime whatever, and that at any rate the only offence which could be charged with any colour, was the making preparations for an enterprize against the province of a foreign nation in amity with the U. S. The 6th article of the amendments to the constitution says—"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

In this case there was no probable cause supported by oath or affirmation; and therefore the message of the President were entitled to no weight in a court of justice.

With regard to the depositions of gen. Wilkinson it was alledged that they were totally inadmissible in a court of justice. They were taken before individuals who declared themselves to be justices of the peace, of which fact however there was no evidence which could be legally received. Such papers uniformly required a certificate of authentication, proving that the magistrate was duly appointed. This objection was therefore fatal to the reception of these papers as testimony. It was besides established principle of criminal jurisprudence that none other than the magistrate who examined the accused was competent to arrest him.

But even if this insuperable objection was overruled and the depositions received as testimony, it was contended that they did not establish the commission of a single overt act of treason, by A. Burr, much less did they establish the implication of the

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 2 February 1807
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 10 February 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Attorney General Rodney argued against allowing defense counsel to be heard at this early stage of the treason prosecution against Dr. Bollman and Samuel Swartwout, citing humanitarian concerns and legal precedent. Defense counsel Charles Lee responded that the prisoners themselves wanted full investigation and disputed that hearing counsel now was improper.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

facter, as Mr. Swartwout, accused before this court of so heinous an offence as treason, and I lament that the person who was the means of involving both of them, should have been Aaron Burr ; a person once so highly distinguished by the favour of

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report covers courtroom arguments over whether prisoners charged with treason should be committed without first allowing their counsel to argue against it. Attorneys Lee and Key argue for the right to be heard, citing legal precedent and the calm state of public affairs, while the court deliberates on procedure regarding evidence including a communication from the president.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tranquility at this spot, but in every other part of the union. For my own part I feel as perfectly at ease as if the name of Aaron Burr had never been sounded in my ears. I trust sir that no person will contradict me in this observation.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A defense lawyer argues before the court that President Jefferson's communication to Congress should not be treated as legal evidence of treason against Swartwout and Bollman. He contends the evidence falls far short of establishing probable cause for treason, distinguishing between grounds for arrest versus grounds for commitment.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

to serve as evidence in a court of justice. The constitution expressly declares that you are to arrest no man unless there be probable cause on oath or affirmation, and surely nothing can be shewn in this communication which will appear to your honours as probable cause of treason against these two men. It is necessary, sir, that the charges be substantiated by evidence, and that your opinion be given on this evidence alone—The vile declamation, which has been thundered in your ears, is therefore, to have no effect with this court; it is not to be regarded by you, but entirely to be thrown aside.

See moreSee less

But may it please your honours, there is another reason why the message of the president should not be received on the records of the court, there will be found all the evidence of which the president is in possession—You have the affidavit of general Eaton, as also the depositions of lieut. Wilson and ensign Mead, stating the apprehensions of gen. Wilkinson at New Orleans. And does the communication of the president amount to

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Edward Livingston publishes an address denying any knowledge of Burr's conspiracy and condemning General Wilkinson's harsh conduct toward Bollman, Swartwout, and others. A separate letter from New Orleans describes Wilkinson's reign of suspicion and arrests, including an army officer, with more arrests expected.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

kinson, of Mr. L's. having any concern in, or knowledge of, Burr's conspiracy. Mr. Livingston boldly vindicates the authority of the laws, and lashes Wilkinson for his wild and illegal conduct relative to

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This item reproduces General James Wilkinson's dispatch from New Orleans describing the arrest of Erick Bollman, Samuel Swartwout, and Peter V. Ogden as suspected agents of Aaron Burr's conspiracy. It also includes legislative text remitting penalties under a related act and authorizing the President to suspend its operation until December.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

December 19th, 1806. APPROVED, TH: JEFFERSON.

DOCUMENTS.

See moreSee less

The following are the documents which accompanied the President's Message (given in our last Gazette,) respecting Burr's conspiracy.

Extract of a letter from Gen. James Wilkinson, dated New-Orleans, Dec.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

General James Wilkinson describes from New Orleans how he arrested men suspected of conspiring with Burr, including Bollman, Swartwout, and Ogden, despite habeas corpus writs issued by Judge Workman. He includes a sworn affidavit detailing Bollman's letter to him and a coded communication from Aaron Burr as evidence of treasonous conspiracy.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter from General James Wilkinson, dated New Orleans, Dec. 18, 1806.

SIR—Since my last of the 14th inst. writs of habeas corpus have been issued for the bodies of Bollman, Swartwout and Ogden, the two latter by Judge Workman, who is strongly suspected for being connected with Burr in his conspiracy, as I have proof this man declared some time since that "the republican who possessed power and did not employ it to establish a despotism was a fool." His writ for Ogden was served on Capt. Shaw of the navy who had him in charge at my request, on board the Etna bomb ketch, and delivered him up, and Mr. Workman discharged him without giving me a word of information, although he knew he was confined by my order for a treasonable combination with Burr, and Mr. Ogden now struts at large. Swartwout I have sent off and shall so report, holding myself ready for consequences. Bollman was required by the superior court, but I have got rid of that affair also, under the usual liability for damages, in which case I shall look to our country for protection.

See moreSee less

I, James Wilkinson, Brigadier-General and Commander in Chief of the Army of the United States, to warrant the arrest of Dr. Erick Bollman on a charge of treason, misprision of treason, or such other offence against the government and laws of the U. S. as the following facts may legally charge him with—on my honor as a soldier, and on the holy Evangelists of Almighty God, do declare and swear, that on the sixth day of November last, when in command at Natchitoches, I received by the hands of a Frenchman, a stranger to

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The circuit court for the District of Columbia grappled with the legal status of prisoners Bollman and Swartwout, including motions for warrants, writs of habeas corpus, and attachment against officers refusing to deliver the prisoners. The court ultimately ruled 2-1 that sufficient evidence existed to commit the two men on treason-related charges, while separate reports described Dr. Bollman's visit to the President and Eaton's account of Burr's alleged plot to oust Jefferson.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 February 1807 · page 3

FROM WASHINGTON CITY. JAN. 24:

@?uer was yeflerdsv seceived by 2 member of Congref(s, stating that Jimes Alexancer has been arrested at N, Orleans by order of Gen, Wilkinson, and lent rousd to some port on the Atlantic.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A speaker argues against suspending Habeas Corpus, citing executive reports that only a few hundred men under Burr have gathered near the Cumberland River, vastly outnumbered by militia and regular troops. The speaker contends the conspiracy poses no real threat to justify such an extreme measure.

The Enquirer · 10 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

militia of Ohio, Kentucky, Tenneffee, of the Miffiffippi and Orleans territories have been ordered out. That general Wilkinfon was at Orleans on the 10th of December with his troops from the Sabine, which from other information we know to confift of one thoufand effective men. Thefe are the refources of the nation now in active operation. What is the force of the confpirators? By the fame document we are informed that 'fome boats, accounts vary from five to double or treble that number, and perfons differently eftimated from one to three hundred, had paffed the falls of Ohio to rendezvous at the mouth of Cumberland river, with others expected down that river.'

See moreSee less

From the fame document it appears that the force which comes down Cumberland river amounts to two boats, in one of which is Aaron Burr.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Letters from New Orleans report the arrest of Lieutenant Small for alleged involvement in Burr's conspiracy and note six boats passing Natchez after examination. Dispatches from Nashville describe widespread public outrage against Burr and uncertain reports of his force's size, estimated between 600 and 800 men.

The Enquirer · 10 February 1807 · page 3

partment in the ifland of Cuba. letters have been received from New-Orlratis as late as the £nd of January. Thefe flute the arrcll of Lieutenant Small, on a charge of being engaged in Burr’s confpiracy, and that fix Loats had palled Nat chez, after an examination. A’al. Ini.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report details defense arguments that the President's messages and General Wilkinson's depositions should be inadmissible as evidence against Aaron Burr, citing lack of proper oath, affirmation, and magistrate certification. The prosecution counters that the President's communications and Wilkinson's and Eaton's depositions together establish probable cause of treasonable acts.

The Enquirer · 10 February 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

rest him.

But even if this insuperable objection was over-ruled and the depositions received as testimony, it was contended that they did not establish the commission of a single overt act of treason, by Aaron Burr, much less did they establish the implication of the accused

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A letter from Kentucky to a congressman describes how Joseph Hamilton Daviess discovered Burr's flotilla loading boxes resembling munitions near the Falls of the Ohio, prompting official communications to the governor and a closed-door session of Congress. It further reports that militia were called out in several Kentucky counties and that investigation suggested a conspiracy involving agents near Pittsburg, Blannerhassett, and others to raise men for an unknown enterprise down the river.

Virginia Argus · 10 February 1807 · page 2

WASHINGTON CITY, Feb. 2. Extract rf a letter from a grntlrtnan in | Faria, Kentucky, to n member of Conj grraa, dat'd .Itf January, 1807. “As set lu’.s passed to prevent unlawful ; warlike cnterpriy.es, designed to prevent * the expedition of col. Burr. After the ar1 rival ftf the President’s proclamation, J. II. Daviess having gone to the falls, discover ed Burr’s flotilla in motion, and at the Ra pids* a number of boxes were put on board in their site and shape resembling such as usually contain musquetry and cartridges.

See moreSee less

Some things were also put on board resem bling artillery. He wrote an official com munication to the governor containing the intelligence, whirh with a letter from the Secretary of W’ar was inclosed in a con A den'isl message to tlie II u*c of Repress*i* ! tatives, who were immediately rug J j port of thr-'C days with closed dorr^ Dui - ring that time wt passed the iaw last menj t oned. This proceeding < n account of its ; n yc ty n this country, rrrated a great a- ‘ goa i 'nin the public mind. Mr. Graham, the Secretary of Orlcaa*, was tjumined ' m the constitution, to induce n belief tkat thfc prisoners were guilty of the crime for which they had been arrested. This question he said had been deliberately considered by the court bfefore the warrant issued, and he thought every thing in this inceptive state of the business, was regularly an «<r I parte proceeding; he therefore had been I against permitting counsel to argue on any I j question, except, whether the offence was I bailable, and whether under the circutn- | stances, the court in their discretion ought to bail. They had, however, been allowed to argue in effect to the utmost latitude a gainst the propriety of having issued the j warrant. To this argument he had given | the strictest attention, and could observe ! with Mr Fitzhugh, that it would hare been j well addressed to the jury, if the prisoners had been upon their trial! It had however • produced no alteration in his opinion, as he still thought there was probable cci'4e appearing to the court to authorise the commitment of the prisoners for trial. To determine this question said Mr. D. let us take a short view of the evidence. I lie depositions of general Wilk nson prove unquestionably, the connection of tae prisoners with col. Burr in carrying into effect one common intent or plan, and their j knowledge of this view. They indeed shew I from the acts of the prisoners and their j own c mfessions, their immediate agency in i the furtherance of this scheme. If then it can be shewn, that Mr. Burr has probu bly committed treason, their agency and connection with him, vhile possessing this knowledge of his treasonable views, create the same probability against theta, as in the same treason all in this stage of the bu siness must be considered principals What tnen was the intention, the <:uo ammo with which M>\ Burr’s expedition w.,s underta i ken ? This by general K uril’s deposition, s proved to be the separation cf the we tern from the Atlantic states,-and the establish ment of a monarchy there, of which Mr. B. was tobe the sovereign. It is probable he hud another objtct in view, the ini’ctton of lexica ; but this does not appear to be distinct front his treasonable plan of dis membering t’ne unioh. This treasonable intention is also stated in the confessions made to general Wilkinson by one of the prisoners. In the pursuit then of this ob ject we rtnd that Kir. B. had actually com nrncei th ' n.-heditir>n rhnt l,* pected to be r.t Natchez with an armed force at a certain period. It appears mo, from the cofessions of the prisoners them selves, that Air. 1J. was levying a large bo dy cf armed men. and what may go far to prove their knowlegeof and agency in that business is, that the officer who wastocom m.md tae first five hundred men is stated by name. One of the prisoners also savs that he had written to col. Burr for provisi ons. Should these circumstances, of them | selves^ not amount to overt acts of levying ■war* upon which question Air. 1). said 1 e should at that time sav nothing, yet when tak.au in connection with the situation of the country, the state of alarm existing a General. mongthe pc pie, and the active preparati ons of defence against an expected attack, they, furnished strong prinia facia evi dence that they had been followed up hy commission of other acts on the part ot A»r. Ilnrr and the prisoners, that would amount to « levying cf war within the strictest definition of the terms. Nor is there any thing in the testimony said Air. I D. that can positively exclude the infer ence of an active co-jperaiitm on the part of the prisoners in the different measures that arr probably imputable to Mr. B. Mr. 1). then remarked that an observati on made by himself on issuing the warrant, seemed not to have been correctly uader* S'ond by the prisoners’ counsel. He had not said, thn» in the present case it w.Ts necessary lo resort to public docu ments to aid the depositions in furnishing probable cause for the arrest; but lie would not now observe as he had then done,that although the depositions did to his mind establish a probable cause on which he cruihl act, yet first this probability was strongly corroborated bv the message of the Presi dent and other public doruments on the sub ject. That even admitting that the 6th ar ticle of the amendments to the constitution which provides against general warrants, may require an oath or affirmation before mr.i Tarrant can issue, yet he could not subscribe to the doctrine, that the ciicum stances showing the probable cause, must in all conns Hr contained in the oath Or af firmation itself. If this principle he once troops. considered correct, it would indeed when taken in connection wiih the necessity con tended rnr in the present rase, of proving on a gttrntion of cotnnn"hient the positive existence of the offence charged, be the loornt precedent, as it regarded the public I safety that could possibly be established, though at the same time it might he the ' mr st convenient clonk for treason that could 1 lie invented. Under this doctrine, even an authenticated record shewing the Conviction of Mi B of tie 'ion, could it be produced on the present question, would be tleen.ed i inylmissahle in corroboration of thr pro correctness. bable cauoe contained in the affidavits. Mr. I). concluded by observing, that he was opposed tr> bailing the prisoners, for although the evidence might also have charged them with a misdemeanor in ret ting on foot an expedition against a nation at amity w th the United St ates, vet as they had been arrested on a charge ofthe high est offence against their country, nothing but iheir fie r ho tin could be considerded an adequate security to the public.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage reports a sworn affidavit by Edward Livingston denying any communication with Aaron Burr regarding plots against the Union, alongside news of the Supreme Court's session, the arrest of Lieutenant Small, and public sentiment against Burr in Tennessee. It also includes a court opinion on committing Bollman and Swartwout for trial on treason charges, with a dissent from Judge Cranch on the grounds of insufficient evidence for probable cause.

Virginia Argus · 10 February 1807 · page 2

Letters have been received from New Orleans as late as the 2d of January. These slate the arrest of litnt. Small, on a charge of being engaged in Burr’s conspiracy, and that six boats had passed Natchez, after an examination. Letters arc received in this c.it$> from Nashville, as late as January lJtli. They contain nothing material relative to Burr’s coiispiraC) except the universal execration in which the conspiracy and its author are held in the state of Tennessee. The same sentiment exists, and we feel the pride of an American in being aide to s iy so, thro’ out the whole extent of the western coun try.—.Yat.

See moreSee less

Jntrt. There is not, wc believe, the least foun dation for the paragraphs taken from Bri tish prints, intimating a rupture of the ne gtioiations between the United States and Great Britain.—ib.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

President Jefferson forwarded Congress a letter from Mississippi Territory official Cowles Meade reporting that Aaron Burr had reached the area on January 13, denying any treasonous intent and claiming his purpose was agriculture and emigration. The report also notes military efforts to apprehend Burr and mentions a Supreme Court habeas corpus argument on behalf of Burr associate Samuel Swartwout.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 February 1807 · page 2

WASHINGTON CITY. WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 11.

in iii **c* ■ WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 11. The following message from the Pre;, i sident of the United Slates v/as yester day laid before the two Houses of Con- , gress. To the Senate and House of Represen tatives of the United State*. I communicate for the information of Congress a letter from Cowles Meade, Secretary of the Mississippi territory, to the Secretary at War, by which it will be seen that Mr. Burr had reached that neighbourhood on the 13th ot Ja nuary. TH : JEFFERSON.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage includes letters from Nashville and Meadville disputing rumors of western secession and clarifying that certain men did not join Burr's expedition as previously reported. It also contains Judge Fitzhugh's opinion explaining the legal standard for committing Bollman and Swartwout on treason charges, noting the lower evidentiary bar required at this preliminary stage.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 February 1807 · page 2

Extract of a letter dated Meadville, January \7:/i 1806, to a member of Congress. I obferve in the National Intelligen cer an extratt of a letter from Mead vine, which 1 worte you dated Nov. 17th lflOfi. It is there ftated that James Gibfon, Samuel Lord, Ralph Marlin, and Jab: z Colt had departed from Meadville for Beaver, and that Mr. Colt and Mr. Marlin, expected com millions in the expedition under Col. Burr. It is true that thefe gentlemen went to Beaver at that time, but they did not go on that expedition, hav ing finre returned to Meadville.

See moreSee less

I am therefore happy at having it in my power to oppofe this fact to the report that had been circulated here, and to the information given reflecting the intentions of thefe gentlemen by fome of thofe who have actual!) gone on that expedition from this place. It has j been fince ftated by refpcdtable perfons that Mr. Gibfon's bufinefs to Beaver was of a private, perfonal nature, and that Mr. Marlin had rxpreiTed in ftrong terms his difapprobatton of any under taking ngainlt the peace or intereft of United States.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report details testimony and legal arguments presented regarding Aaron Burr's alleged treasonous plans, including witness accounts of armed men being raised and letters in cypher delivered to General Wilkinson. It discusses whether Burr's associates who carried these letters are guilty of treason or merely misprision of treason, debating legal distinctions in their prosecution.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

which amount to levying war on the U.S.

Burr's treason then being established, we are to enquire whether the prisoners were his confederates. They are represented, under oath, to have been the bearers of the duplicates of Burr's letters in cypher to Wilkinson, and to possess Burr's confidence; they use arguments in addition to those in the letter, to invite Wilkinson to accede to their views: admit that they have corresponded with Burr on the subject since the delivery of the letter: That Swartwout informed Wilkinson that Burr, with a powerful association, extending from New York to New Orleans, was levying an armed body of 7000 men from New York and the western states and territories, with a view to carry an expedition against the Mexican provinces, and that 500 men under colonel Swartwout and major Tyler were to descend the Alleghany, for whose accommodation light boats had been built and were ready—said that New Orleans would be revolutionized when the people were ready to join them, and that there would be some seizing.

See moreSee less

Here then is evidence of a connection with colonel Burr of a treasonable nature. What is it? The act of Congress defines misprision of treason to be a neglect to disclose the knowledge of a treason. But the prisoners have not only known of the treason; but carried a treasonable letter, knowing its contents; endeavored to further Burr's views and wishes, and to seduce Wilkinson from his duty. The offence exceeds misprision of treason, and as there is no intermediate class of offences of a treasonable nature between misprision and treason, it must be treason.

It has been observed by the counsel for the prisoners that no judge could commit on an affidavit made before any other judge. This distinction is certainly new, and I believe unprecedented. In all general warrants for arresting a supposed offender, the direction to the officer is to bring the party before the person issuing the warrant, or some other justice of peace, &c. which would be at least nugatory, if no person could inspect or regard the affidavit except the person before whom it was made. Therefore I conclude that Wilkinson's affidavits made before justices of the peace of New Orleans, whose commissions appear to be properly authenticated by the secretary of state, are evidence at this stage of our enquiry.

I am therefore of opinion, that the prisoners should be committed for treason against the United States, in levying war against them.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A judicial opinion discusses whether prisoners connected to Burr's conspiracy should be charged with treason rather than mere misprision of treason, reasoning that carrying treasonable letters and attempting to seduce Wilkinson from duty constitutes treason itself. The judge concludes the prisoners should be committed for levying war against the United States, also addressing a procedural point about affidavits sworn before justices of the peace in New Orleans.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the person before whom it was made. Therefore I conclude that Wilkinson's affidavits made before justices of the peace of New Orleans, whose commissions appear to be properly authenticated by the secretary of state, are evi-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A judge (Mr. D.) explains his reasoning for denying bail to prisoners arrested in connection with Aaron Burr's alleged conspiracy, citing General Wilkinson's depositions and General Eaton's testimony as establishing probable cause of treason. He outlines the alleged plan to separate the Western states, establish a monarchy with Burr as sovereign, and possibly invade Mexico, noting the prisoners' own confessions implicate them in raising armed forces.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 February 1807 · page 3

view of the evidence. The depositions of genera’ Wilkinson prove unquestiona bly, the connection of the prisoners with col. Burr,in carry ing into effect one common intent or plan, and their know ledge of this view. They indeed shew, from the acts of the prisoners and their own confessions, thuir immediate agency ^urt^erance this scheme. If thermit can be shewn, that Mr. Burr has probably committed treason, their' agency and coimwtion with him, while possessing this knowledge of his treasonoble views, create the same probability against / emy as in the same treason all in this stage of the business must be considered principals.

See moreSee less

What then was the inten TL* ^U° anmf3 Mr. Burr’s expedition was undertak en . This by general Faton’s deposition, is proved to be the •epamtion ot the Western from the Atlantick States, and the establishment ofa monarchy there, of which Mr. B. was to be, the sovereign. It is probable that he had another object •Iso in view, the vroa/nn if Mexico ; but this does not appear to me distinct from his treasonable plan of dismembering the union. This treasonable intention is also stated in the con fessions made to general Wilkinson by one of the prisoners, in the pursuit then of this object, we find that Mr. B. had ac tua ly commenced the expedit<on% and that he expected to be at mtchei with an armed force at a certain period. It appears t*K>, from the confessions of the prisoners themselves, that Air. B. was faying a Urge body of armed men% and what may go far to Pr<>ve their knowledge of and agency in that business is, that the officer who was to command the first five hundred yen is stated by name. One of the prisoners also says that lie had written to colonel Burr for provisions. Should these circumstances, of themselves, not amount to wer tacts ©/ Levy **g war, upon which question Mr. D said he should at that tune say nothing, yet when taken in connection with the si tuation of the country, the state of alarm existing among the people, and the active preparations of defence against an ex *ttack, they furnished prtma facie evidence that they «*a been followed up by the commission of other acts on the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report details a judge's (Mr. D.'s) legal reasoning for finding probable cause to arrest Burr's associates on treason charges, citing General Eaton's deposition and confessions implicating Burr in a plan to separate the western states and possibly invade Mexico. The judge also defends his earlier use of depositions and public documents, including the President's message, to justify issuing arrest warrants despite constitutional concerns about general warrants.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 February 1807 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A legal argument is reported opposing bail for Burr's associates, contending that only imprisonment could secure public safety against treason charges. Separately, Edward Livingston, accused by Gen. Wilkinson in open court of conspiring with Burr, published a lengthy appeal denying the charge and demanding a formal trial.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 February 1807 · page 3

New-YoAk, Feb. 4. Livivgstof’s Appeal. Mr. Edward Livingston, late maypr of this city, was denounced in open court at mw Orleans, by gen. Wilkinson, as an associate of Burr, in a con spiracy tor the dismembering the union. Mr. Li vingston rose, solemnly denied the truth of the ac cusation, insisted that the charge should be made on oath, and that the court proceed immediately to liis trial. This privilege having been denied, and he. having subsequently received additional injury ami insult from gen. Wilkinson,'Mr. Ltvingston came torvvard with an Interesting and energetic ap peal to the public.

See moreSee less

The length of this appeal fit being seven columns) prevents us from publishing it at present. It closes with the following remarks and affidavit:—(Com. Ad.) P" .i “ I know not what effect this publication have, it mayjustify me t* vty country, which j first wish of my heart; it may be the me producing a strict scrutiny into my conduct, 1 invite, it may draw down the further venge my accuser, which I will never deprccattS whatever .may be. the event, nothing can the consciousness I enjoy of mitowi this occasion, nor the deteri sphere, to resist oppression the laws.” •

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

General William Eaton recounts his conversations with Aaron Burr, in which Burr revealed plans to detach the western states from the Union and lead a military expedition to seize Mexico. Eaton describes being initially misled into thinking the scheme was government-sanctioned before Burr's true revolutionary aims became clear.

Lynchburg Star · 12 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

tenor of the President's message to both Houses of Congress seemed probable, I should have thought it my duty to obey so honorable a call of my country; and under that impression I did engage to embark in the expedition. I had frequent intervews with col. Burr in this city— a considerable time, his object appeared to be to instruct me by maps, and give information, the feasibility of penetrating to Mexico—always carrying forward the idea that the measure was authorised by government. At length, some time in February, he began by degrees to unveil himself—He reproached the government with want of character, want of gratitude, and want of justice.

See moreSee less

He seemed desirous of irritating resentment in my breast by dilating on certain injuries he felt I had suffered from reflections made on the floor of the House of Representatives concerning my operations in Barbary, and from the delays of government in adjusting my claims for disbursements on that coast during my consular agency at Tunis; and he said he would point me to an honorable mode of indemnity. I now began to entertain a suspicion that Mr.

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This passage presents sworn depositions from Wm. Eaton and James Lowry Donaldson regarding Aaron Burr's alleged conspiracy to separate western states from the union. Donaldson recounts information from Gen. Wilkinson about treasonable designs and a hasty compromise with the Spanish to protect New Orleans.

Lynchburg Star · 12 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Burr and myself, from which the foregoing statement has resulted, were chiefly in this city, in the months of February and March, last year. Wm. EATON.

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This passage records sworn depositions from James L. Donaldson and Lieut. W. Wilson describing General Wilkinson's alarm over Burr's alleged conspiracy, including a claimed letter about thousands of armed men headed to Natchez. Both witnesses testify to the widespread fear in New Orleans, the commercial disruption, and Wilkinson's defensive military preparations against an expected attack.

Lynchburg Star · 12 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ly risen from his seat, and accompanied this person in a number of turns up and down a balcony in the front of the house; apparently engaged in deep conversation.—

Upon the latter of these occasions the general on his return to the chamber said to this deponent, "that is Dr. Bollman; his infatuation is truly extraordinary; he persists in his belief that I am with Burr, and has this moment shewn me a letter from the latter, in which he says that he is to be at Natches on the 20th December with 2000 men, that four thousand will follow in the course of a few days, & that he could, with the same ease have procured double that number." Gen. Wilkinson then observed that he had obtained all the information he wanted, and that the affair would not be kept much longer a secret from the public.

See moreSee less

When this deponent left the city of N. Orleans, the inhabitants of that city were in a state of great alarm, and apprehended a serious attack from Mr. Burr, and his confederates, this deponent understood that mercantile business was much embarrassed, and great fears were entertained of considerable commercial failures in consequence of the embargo which had been imposed—That general Wilkinson was taking strong measures of defence, and that 400 persons were then actually engaged in the fortifications of the city.

And further this deponent saith not.

James L. Donaldson. Sworn to in open court. William Brent, Clk.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report recounts habeas corpus proceedings in which General James Wilkinson personally appeared in court to justify his arrest of Erick Bollman, claiming national security required it due to Aaron Burr's conspiracy. Wilkinson's written return takes full responsibility for the arrest and asserts he will seize others implicated regardless of rank.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 13 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

having been assured that Bollman had already been removed from the territory, I did not urge the return of the writ; and at gen. Wilkinson's request, it was postponed till the day after, when it having been

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

General James Wilkinson justifies his seizure of Bollman and others under martial law, claiming to protect the nation from a treasonous conspiracy led by Aaron Burr. He names additional suspects including Mr. Alexander and Mr. Livingston, reading affidavits purporting to show their complicity, while the report questions the consistency of his accusations.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 13 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

(Signed,) “ JAMES WILKINSON.” This was introduced and followed by a speech of some length, in the course of which he read the copy of the affidavit he had sent on as the accusation against Bollman, and followed it by remarks tending to alarm the minds of his hearers, with apprehensions of serious and immediate danger, from the invasion of the territory by Mr. Burr, and the traiterous designs of his adherents, whom he represented to be numerous in the city, and two of whom were, he said, counsellors of the court.

See moreSee less

After deliberately casting his eyes round the bar, and seeming to enjoy the astonishment, perhaps the fears of a set of men who found themselves opposed to this inquisition, he asked whether Mr. Alexander was in court, and being answered that he was not, he requested he might be sent for, and committed to close confinement, as he intended [illegible] he left court, to prefer against him a charge o[f] treason. Mr. Alexander not being at that moment to be found, gen. Wilkinson proceeded to state the circumstances on which he grounded his

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report recounts sworn testimony from witnesses describing Aaron Burr's alleged military plans, including gathering armed men at the Falls, correspondence in cipher with General Wilkinson, and fears in New Orleans of an attack. It concludes that Burr's treason is established and raises the question of whether his confederates in the west were complicit.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 13 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

appear, there can be little doubt of the existence and the extent of Burr's views, and of his having embodied and inlisted men with views hostile to the government of his country, and that he has done acts which amount to levying war on the U. States. Burr's treason then being established, we are to enquire whether the prisoners were his confederates. They are represented, under oath, to have been the bearers of the duplicates of Burr's letters in cypher to Wilkinson, and to possess Burr's confidence; they use arguments in addition to those in the letter, to invite Wilkinson to accede to their views: admit that they have corresponded with Burr on the subject since the delivery of the letter; that Swartwout informed Wilkinson that Burr, with a powerful association, extending from N.

See moreSee less

York to New Orleans, was levying an armed body of 7000 men from New York and the western states and territories, with a

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece argues that Burr's conspiracy, though dangerous, was swiftly suppressed without bloodshed, proving the strength of American republican government against skeptics like Montesquieu. It claims the affair has united Western Americans more firmly to the Union and will deter future secessionist plots.

The Enquirer · 13 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Burr's conspiracy has produced these two good effects:

1ft. It has called forth the strongest proofs of the attachment of the Western people to the Union of the states;—and

See moreSee less

2nd. The exhibition this very spirit will discourage all future Burr's from attempting a separation of these states. The Western people at large are attached to the Union; and even many of those who are engaged with Burr may be presumed unfriendly to a dissolution. That was not directly presented before them; and it is not unfair to presume, that many would have engaged in an attack upon Mexico, or locating Bastrop's grant, whose hearts would have shuddered at aiming a blow against the union of their Country.—When future conspirators see this almost perfect unanimity, will they dare to act in the very face of it? Will they presume to attempt a separation of the West from the East; when the West itself is almost to a man opposed to it? Thanks to A. Burr whose villainy has provoked the exhibition of so much virtue!!

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

A witness recounts how Aaron Burr allegedly revealed a scheme to separate the western United States from the Union, establish a monarchy with New Orleans as its capital, and extend conquest into Mexico. The witness describes Burr's claims of inexhaustible funds, army support, and recruits from Kentucky, Tennessee, and Louisiana.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 13 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

orable mode of indemnity. I now began to entertain a suspicion that Mr. Burr was projecting an unauthorised military expedition; which, to me, was enveloped in mystery; and, desirous to draw an explanation from him, I suffer-

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The item reports a prosecution instituted against William Duane, editor of the Aurora, by the Marquis de Casa Yrujo for alleged slanderous statements, with the Marquis refusing to let truth be used as evidence before the grand jury. It also summarizes Edward Livingston's published address denying involvement in Burr's conspiracy and criticizing General Wilkinson's conduct toward Bollman, Swartwout, and others.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 13 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From the New-York Gazette. The Louisiana Gazette of the 30th of Dec. contains a very lengthy address to the public, by Edward Livingston, Esq. late mayor of this city.—This address, which is warmly and elegantly expressed does away the suspicions, and denies the charges of Gen. Wilkinson, of Mr. Livingston's having any concern in, or knowledge of, Burr's conspiracy. Mr. Livingston boldly vindicates the authority of the Laws, and lashes Wilkinson for his wild and illegal conduct relative to Bollman, Swartwout and others. Mr. L. concludes his address in these words: "I know not what effect this publication will have—it may justify me to my country, which is the first wish of my heart—it may be the means of producing a strict scrutiny into my conduct, which I invite—it may draw down the further vengeance of my accuser, which I never will deprecate.

See moreSee less

But, whatever may be the event, nothing can destroy the consciousness I enjoy of my own rectitude on this occasion, nor the determination in my humble sphere, to resist oppression, and assert the Empire of the LAWS."

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

William Eaton's deposition before the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia describes how Aaron Burr approached him last winter to join a secret expedition against Spanish territories, claiming government authorization. Eaton recounts Burr's shifting rhetoric, eventually revealing resentment toward the government and hints of a scheme beyond mere war preparation.

Herald of the United States · 14 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM EATON, Esq. Before the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia: EARLY last winter, Col. AARON BURR, late Vice-President of the United States, sig

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

A witness describes private conversations in which Aaron Burr allegedly spoke of General Wilkinson's support, plans to separate the western union, and ambitions extending even to overthrowing the U.S. government. The witness recounts growing conviction that Burr had organized a treasonous plot in the West.

Herald of the United States · 14 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

the vast territory belonging to the United States, which offered to adventurers, and the mines of Mexico would bring strength to his standard from all quarters. I listened to the exposition of Col. Burr's views with seeming acquiescence. Every interview convinced me

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The piece argues that Wilkinson's harsh, unconstitutional measures against accused Burr conspirators may generate public sympathy for them, likening it to the Wilkes affair in England. It also criticizes secrecy around the gunboat program and questions the wisdom of funding more vessels without public scrutiny.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 16 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

New Orleans, we[nt] to every reflecting person not less dangerous than the projects of Colonel Burr, if the latter even went to the extent which rumour declared th[em.] The plans of Col. Burr were too illy digest[ed to pr]oduce any lasting and serious evil, but the wounds which might be inflicted in the constitution of the country, by measures such as those [w]hich General Wilkinson has adopted, might not [be] easily healed. There is a strain of candour in th[e s]tatement of Mr. Livingston, that removes every suspicion that General Wilkinson endeavoured to excite against him, and leaves the general in a situation which no one can envy, and will in all probability produce a very different sentiment towards him, than he has anticipated.

See moreSee less

His countrymen hate traitors and they abhor oppression; they will not countenance the latter, under a pretext of bringing the former to justice. Nothing is more impolitick, as well as unjust in a government, than to resort to illegal and unconstitutional means to punish an offender. In every country t[here is a] natural sympathy for an oppressed man;

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

A witness recounts conversations with Aaron Burr in which Burr described his plans to raise an army from western states and territories, claimed vast resources, and insisted General Wilkinson would serve as his lieutenant. The witness expresses skepticism about Wilkinson's loyalty to Burr, suspecting Burr may have exaggerated or fabricated the general's involvement.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 17 February 1807 · page 1

RELATIVE TO BURR'S CONSPIRACY.

General Wilkinson, 1 oblesved it was {ingular that he should count on General Wilkinson ; the clevaied rank and bigh troft he now beld as commander in chief of our army und governor of a province, he would hardly put at hazard for any precarious prolpefts of aggran. dizement, Mr. Barr said, Genersl Wilkinson balzoced in the con fidence of government, was doabtfal of retaining much longer the consideration he now enjoyed, and was cuniequently prepared to fecare to himiell 2 permanency. I asked Mr, Barr, If he knew General Wilkinson ?

See moreSee less

He answer ed yes: and echoed the qacfiion. I said 1 koew him well. ¢ What do you koow of him 7 {aid Mr. Burr.—l kaow, I replied, that General Wilkinlon will aft as Lieutenant to no man io existence, — “ You are in an error,” said Mr. Burr.—** Wilkinson will cél as Lieutenant to me.”” From th: tenor of repeated converlations with Mr. Burr, I wasindoced to believe the plan of separating the union which he had contemplated hid been communicated to and approv ed of by General Wiikinfon (though I .now. fufpeél it an artful arga meat of {cduflion) and he often exprefled a full confidence that the general’s inflaence ; the offer of double pay and double rations ; the proipe&t of plander and the ambition of achievement wouald draw the army into his measures. Mr. Burr talked of the cßablifhment of an independent government welt of the Aileghany as 2 mateer of in sherent, conflitutional right of the people ; a change which would eventually take place, and for the operation of which the present crisis was peculiarly favorable. There was, said he, no energy in the government to be dreaded, and the divisions of political cpinions throughout the union was a circumstance of which we should profit, There were very many entérprifing’ meo among us who aflpired o something beyond the dull pursuits of civil life ;—snd who won!d volunteer in this enterprize, and the vast territory belonging to the U. States, which offered to adventurers, and the mines of Mexico would bring firength to his fandard from all quarters. I liflened to the expefition of col. Burr’s views with seeming acquielcence. Ev. ery interview convinced me more and mare that he had organized a deep laid plot of treason in the welt, in theaccomplifbment of which he! felv sally confident. Till, at leogth, I discovered that his ambi tion was not bounded by the waters of the Miflifippi and Mexico, . bat that he raeditated overthrowing the present government of our ‘country, He said, if he covld gain.over the marine corps, and secure the naval commanders, Trux:on, Preble, Decatur, and others, A¢ would turn Congress neck and heels put of doors ; assassinate the BreJident ; [erze on the treasury and the mavy, and declare himfelf the protelior of an emergelic government, . _ PO . ‘The honorable trust of corrapting the marine corps, and of founding commodore Preblc abd captain Deeatur, col. Buarr propof. | .cd coofiding to me. Shocked at this proposition, L dropped the mask,

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The Nashville dispatch reports that various rumors are circulating about the size of Colonel Burr's force descending the river, with estimates ranging from 500 to 800 men. It notes that the expedition has caused considerable alarm in the region, prompting militia mobilization under orders from the Secretary of War.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 17 February 1807 · page 2

NASHVILLE, (TEN.) JAN. 10, Varjous reports-are afloat relative to the force descending the river.under the 'com mand of Col, Burr-~fome {2y 600 {ome Suo men. However, it is (officient to fay, that

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The writer describes financial dealings and his relationship with General Wilkinson, then recounts the December arrests of Bollman, Ogden, and Swartwout under military order. He details the subsequent legal effort by James Alexander to obtain a writ of habeas corpus for the prisoners.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

supped with me, and in the course of that evening I informed him that Dr. Bollman had brought me an order for money from col. Burr, and expressed my surprise as to the manner in which he could have become indebted to Mr. Bollman, whom I understood to have been in failing circumstances in Philadelphia; the general both then, and in several visits which I subsequently made gave me no reason to suspect that this circumstance had made any impression, but behaved with his usual cordiality to me, which continued until the very night before his denunciation.

On Sunday afternoon, the 14th December,

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

General James Wilkinson appeared in court and read a formal statement taking responsibility for arresting Erick Bollman on a charge of misprision of treason tied to Aaron Burr's alleged conspiracy. He followed this with a lengthy speech warning of imminent danger from Burr's adherents, naming even court officials as suspected accomplices, and sought to have an absent attorney arrested for high treason.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

lers band of traitors, affociated under AARON BURR, whofe accomplices are extended from New-York to this city. No man holds in higher reverence the civil inftitutions of his country than the underfigned, and it is to maintain and perpetuate the Holy Attributes of the Conftitution, againft the uplifted hand of violence, that he has interpofed the force of arms in a moment of extreme peril, to feize upon Bollman, as he will upon all others, without regard to ftanding or ftation, againft whom fatisfactory proof may arife, of a participation in the lawlefs combination.'

(Signed)

See moreSee less

"JAMES WILKINSON."

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

An unnamed defendant recounts his courtroom defense against charges of being involved in Burr's alleged conspiracy, explaining a financial transaction and denying knowledge of any plans to dismember the union. He describes General Wilkinson's apparent willingness to drop charges if suspicions about payment to Bollman could be cleared up.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

who confirmed them. With respect to Mr. Rodger's affidavit, I observed that it was difficult to reply to a document which had only been partially read, that Mr. Keene, upon whose hearsay I was accused, had been long absent from the country, and that on his return, I was persuaded a satisfactory explanation of the business would be made, but that in [all] events I pledged myself most solemnly to God and my country, that I was utterly ignorant of any of the plans which it was said col. Burr was executing, either for dismembering the union, or con-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Edward Livingston publishes correspondence with Dr. Rodgers to clarify testimony about names mentioned by a Mr. Keene regarding a Mexican expedition, and to explain his handling of a payment from Burr to Bollman. He argues that since named suspects were not arrested, the accusations against him lack consistency and are unfounded.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SIR,

"In our conversation, I mentioned there was a possibility that I might have introduced names in my affidavit which were not mentioned by Mr. Keene to me, because the persons suspected had been frequently spoken of in my hearing, but believed that I was correct—I likewise mentioned that I had not then placed confidence in Mr. Keene's narrative, supposing that "Burr" would not have chosen a wild rattling fellow, such as he is, to further his schemes. The names of all the persons mentioned by Mr. Keene, were set forth in my affidavit, none of whom have I believe been arrested; one of them is in the service of the U. States, but he, with another, were noticed in my certificate, otherwise than the rest.

See moreSee less

(Signed)

"W. RODGERS

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A letter from Meadville clarifies that earlier reports naming Gibson, Marlin, Colt, and Lord as having joined Burr's expedition from Beaver were incorrect, as they had since returned. It states Gibson's trip was personal and Marlin had actually disapproved of any action against U.S. interests.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter dated Meadville, Jan. 17th 1806, to a member of Congress. I observe in the National Intelligencer an extract of a letter from Meadville, which I wrote you dated Nov. 17th, 1806. It is there stated that James Gibson, Samuel Lord, Ralph Marlin and Jabez Colt had departed from Meadville for Beaver, and that Mr. Colt and Mr. Marlin expected commissions in the expedition under Col. Burr. It is true that these gentlemen went to Beaver at that time, but they did not go on that expedition, having since returned to Meadville.

See moreSee less

I am therefore happy at having it in my power to oppose this fact to the report that had been circulated here, and to the information given respecting the intentions of these gentlemen by some of those who have actually gone on that expedition from this place. It has been since stated by respectable persons that Mr. Gibson's business to Beaver was of a private, personal nature, and that Mr. Marlin had expressed in strong terms his disapprobation of any undertaking against the peace or interest of U.S.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Reports describe volunteers in Tennessee organizing to pursue and stop Aaron Burr, and federal orders dispatched to arrest him in the Mississippi Territory. In New Orleans, General Wilkinson administers loyalty oaths to troops, declares martial law over the battalion, and warns merchants to ready their ships for departure as a precaution.

The Enquirer · 17 February 1807 · page 4

KNOXVILLE, Jan. si. ExtraH of a letter from a gentleman in Galla tin, (Ten.) to bis friend in this town, dated January 1C, 1807. ** The people of Sumner and the adjoining counties are volunteering f.aft to purfue Burr, and Hop him in his career if poflihle. Captain Bradley, and captain B. Martin have both en l.fted full companies and are ready to fet out at a moment's warning.’*

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

An attorney describes assisting James Alexander in applying for a writ of habeas corpus for Erick Bollman, which was initially allowed, then delayed at General Wilkinson's request. Wilkinson personally appeared in court and read a return taking full responsibility for Bollman's arrest on charges of misprision of treason connected to Aaron Burr's conspiracy.

Virginia Argus · 17 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

territory, I did not urge the return of the writ, and at General Wilkinson's request, it was postponed till the day after, when it having been understood that the return was to be made by the general in person, the court was unusually crowded. About

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

General Wilkinson defends his arrest of Dr. Bollman and reads an affidavit implicating Edward Livingston in financial dealings with Burr. He also announces plans to charge another attorney, Mr. Alexander, with high treason and orders him confined.

Virginia Argus · 17 February 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ger from the invasion of the territory by Mr. Burr, and the traitorous designs of his adherents whom he represented to be numerous in the city, and two of whom were he said, COUNSELLORS OF THE

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report discusses the legal standards for issuing a warrant versus the stricter requirements for a treason conviction, which requires confession in open court or two witnesses to the same overt act. It examines whether probable cause exists against Burr based on public rumor, presidential communications, and sworn testimony from Eaton, Wilkinson, Donaldson, Meade, and Wilson, while addressing defense arguments about intention being the key factor in determining treason.

Virginia Argus · 17 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

that treason has been committed by colonel Burr, the public rumor and universal alarm which seems to have convulsed our country from the extremity to the centre—the President's communications to Congress and to the court, afford at least ground of suspicion, and this is supported by the positive oaths of gen. Eaton, gen. Wilkinson, Mr. Donaldson, Mr. Meade, and Mr. Wilson, all going to shew the origin, existence and progress of Burr's treasonable projects and acts. But here the counsel for the pri

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 13 February 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report claims Spanish Marquis Yrujo informed U.S. officials that he and Burr planned two years earlier to bring Vera Cruz treasure to the United States, with approval from the Madrid court. It further alleges British minister Mr. Merry knew of the scheme and pledged British naval forces would not interfere, possibly even assist, anticipating a British-Spanish coalition against Napoleon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

COL. BURR.

MR. ALEXANDER's APPEAL.

FROM THE FEDERAL GAZETTE.

See moreSee less

"Cum ferro, cum metu, cum privilegio, et minis, servitute oppressam cevitatem tenerent. Libertatis signum posuerunt magis ad ludibrium impudentiæ, quam ad simulationem religionis."—Cicero, orat. pro demosua ad Pontifices—section 51.

It is with a regret, which I am unable to express, that I find myself constrained to meet the publick eye, in the following narrative, which I submit to the serious attention of the reader; and reluctantly acknowledge the superior advantages which my accuser derives from rank and patronage, whilst I have nothing but truth and honour to support.

Some few days after general Wilkinson had denounced Aaron Burr as a traitor, at the government-house in New-Orleans, and when he himself had become an object of ridicule and distrust, I was informed that Dr. Bollman was then under arrest a[t] the instance of the general, and without a[ny] other than his own arbitrary authority—Not be[ing suffi]ciently intim[a]te with the Doctor to feel any like friendship for him, I yet felt that as a m[an] particularly as a stranger in [th]e country, claims upon my professional exertio[ns] [illegible] I could, the [illegible] arm of military had been [illegible] at the sam[e] with whom [illegible]

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

President Jefferson transmits to Congress a letter from Cowles Mead, acting governor of Mississippi Territory, reporting that Aaron Burr had reached the area by January 13 and denied any treasonous intent, claiming his purpose was agricultural settlement. Mead describes mobilizing militia to pursue and apprehend Burr, including an incident where a boat evaded pursuers under gunfire.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

sissippi territory, Jan. 13, 1806. SIR, I have just time by the mail to inform you that I received this morning a letter from col. Burr, at Bayou Pierre, avowing the innocence of his views, and the fallacy of certain rumours against his pe

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

The Circuit Court of the District of Columbia debated its jurisdiction over the treason charge against Burr and deferred setting a trial date until March. Separately, Chief Judge Cranch announced that a majority of judges ruled Erick Bollman and Samuel Swartwout should be committed for trial, while cautioning against letting public alarm over conspiracy overwhelm legal principle.

Lynchburg Star · 19 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A Frankfort (Ken.) paper of the 8th ult. says that capt. Philips of Jefferson county, informs that he passed col. Burr on the 31st ult. at an encampment near the mouth of Cumberland River

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

A judge (Mr. D.) reviews depositions, including General Eaton's and confessions made to General Wilkinson, as evidence that Burr intended to separate the western states and set up a monarchy, possibly also invading Mexico. He argues this constitutes strong prima facie evidence of treason sufficient to justify the warrants issued against the prisoners.

Lynchburg Star · 19 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

in his opinion, as he still thought there was probable cause appearing to the court to authorise the commitment of the prisoners for trial.

To determine this question said Mr. D. let us take a short view of the evidence.

See moreSee less

The depositions of general Wilkinson prove unquestionably, the connection of the prisoners with col. Burr in carrying into effect one common intent or plan, and their knowledge of this view. They indeed shew from the acts of the prisoners and their own confessions, their immediate agency in the furtherance of this scheme. If then it can be shewn, that Mr. Burr has probably committed treason, their agency and connection with him, while possessing this knowledge of his treasonable views, create the same probability against them, as in the same treason all in this stage of the business must be considered principals. What then was the intention, the quo animo with which Mr. Burr's expedition was undertaken? This by general Eaton's deposition, is proved to be the separation of the western from the Atlantic states, and the establishment of a monarchy there, of which Mr. B. was to be the sovereign. It is probable he had another object in view, the invasion of Mexico; but this does not appear to be distinct from his treasonable plan of dismembering the union. This treasonable intention is also stated in the confessions made to general Wilkinson by one of the prisoners. In the pursuit then of this object we find that Mr. B. had actually commenced the expedition, and that he expected to be at Natchez with an armed force at a certain period. It appears too, from the confessions of the prisoners themselves, that Mr. B. was levying a large body of armed men, and what may go far to prove their knowledge of and agency in that business is, that the officer who was to command the first five hundred men is stated by name. One of the prisoners also says that he had written to col. Burr for provisions. Should these circumstances, of themselves, not amount to overt acts of levying war, upon which question Mr. D. said he should at that time say nothing, yet when taken in connection with the situation of the country, the state of alarm existing among the people, and the active preparations of defence against an expected attack, they furnished strong prima facia evidence that they had been followed up by the commission of other acts on the part of Mr. Burr

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 4 February 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A man named People, from Kentucky, was arrested by the military in New Orleans on suspicion of being part of Aaron Burr's conspiracy. He was reportedly intoxicated, boasted of holding a captain's commission under Burr, and was expected to be shipped off within days.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 February 1807 · page 3

New-Orleans, Jan. 12. Saturday night last, a man by the name oi People, (of Kentucky) was ar retted by the miliiary, on suspicion jof being a Kurrite. It seems that he vv a* a l'tttie intoxicated, and avowed him self to be 1 ue of Burr's party, shewed his epaulet, and said he held acap-'aJu'S commission, lie is new confined, and we suppose will be shipped off in a few day?. A "Funeral'serthoil will be preached on ! Sunday next, by the Rev. Mr. Srtyr, at j j the Epi ,copal church in j j upon the occasion of the lute Mrs. i I.i.J'NS ' ti'

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report recounts testimony and depositions given before a federal court regarding Aaron Burr's plans and conduct. Witnesses describe conversations with Burr, recruitment terms offered to settlers, and an assurance from Attorney General Breckinridge that Burr's proceedings were honorable and known to the executive.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 20 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Jordan, waited upon the late John Breckinridge, attorney general of the United States, for the purpose of enquiring as to the nature of col. Burr's plans: that Mr. Breckenridge "gave his assurance that col. Burr's plans were perfectly honourable, the executive were well acquainted with all his proceedings, and that any bills col. Burr might offer, would certainly be accepted."—2d. Three of the witnesses deposed, that they had severally inlisted men for col. Burr, on the following terms: "That each settler was to have one hundred acre lot in the Wishita territory, 10 dollars per month for the first 12 months; provisions and agricultural tools for the same period, on those conditions" that certain improvements were to be made on the given lot, which was not only to be fenced but a road was to be cut from this lot, to an adjoining five hundred acre lot, which was reserved for sale; the whole territory of the Washita, being divided by Burr's plan, into lots of one hundred acres and five hundred acres, placed alternately.

See moreSee less

Likewise, that in the [e]v[ent] of a war betwe[en]

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report mocks contradictory claims about Aaron Burr's scheme, contrasting his own claim it was 'agricultural' with accusations that he meant to carry off money or even remove $150,000,000 from the Spanish treasury at Vera Cruz for the King of Spain. The piece treats these wildly differing explanations as absurd and worthy of ridicule.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Virginia Argus · 20 February 1807 · page 2

BALTIMORE, Feb. 12. ..t1 lokc—upon my aoul a joke /—Mr Wood, the man of the “ World," at Wash ngfon, proceeds in defending Mr Burr Among other things he has the following— Can .t lie possible that the Marquis and Burr ha ve trumped up a story of the kind to blind folks? How rame John Wood by the infor matton Burr savs his scheme is agricut tvral. Wood declares it is to carry oft’ a sum of money ! 7 “ {fho ahull decide when dortora dia agree ?*• “ Col.

See moreSee less

Burr is said to be employed by the Court of Spain, to remove the wjiolebfthe Spanish treasury at Vera Cruz in Mexico which is estimated at 150,000,000 of dollars! to the United States; there to he kept at the disposal of his Catholic Majesty, until Europe lie restored to its original state of tranquility.”—Atlantic World.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A Charleston paper relays New Orleans news of arrests of Burr associates including Sen. John Adair, Judge Workman, and printer Bradford, amid martial fermentation in the city. It also reports Burr had descended near Natchez with about 2,000 men, prompting Claiborne and naval forces to move to intercept him.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Virginia Argus · 20 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

military or naval stores, without a pass from Gov. Claiborne. The Legislature of Orleans met on the 14 h ult. and had continued their session for several days with closed doors, during which time Gen. Wilkinson had attended for the purpose of communicating some important information—It was reported that Burr had descended to within sixty miles of Natchez, with about

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

Letters from New Orleans describe General Wilkinson's martial preparations, including fortifying defenses and readying troops against a feared approach by Aaron Burr. Wilkinson's public notice downplays panic while revealing Burr's forces may number up to 6000 men.

Herald of the United States · 21 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

GENERAL WILKINSON Regrets that it is not in his power, from a pressure of public interests, which imperiously command his attention, to be at the Coffee-house as he intended this day. He therefore takes this mode of warning the merchants and ship owners, to hold their vessels in readiness to haul off into the stream, should it be found necessary, on the shortest notice—but he begs that this may be considered merely as a salutary precaution, nor that he believes Col. Burr is at Natchez, or that he will ever reach this city, under his own volition—and he warns the citizens not to respect the rumours in circulation, because the general by a letter from Colonel Burr's own hand, written to Dr.

See moreSee less

Bollman, is authorised to say, that the colonel's utmost calculation of force did not exceed 6000, and that he would in person precede the main body with 2000 men to Natchez, where he intended to halt. The faithful citizen may be assured that with moderate exertions only, and the decisive expulsion of traitors, the storm will burst over the heads of its authors, and hurl them headlong to perdition, whilst the inhabitants of this city shall dwell in security.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The item reproduces a letter from Joseph Alston, Burr's son-in-law, expressing astonishment at Wilkinson's cipher letter and denying any prior knowledge of an attack on New Orleans. Alston insists Burr's true objects, though different from what was alleged, were ones he himself approved of, and argues Burr's character and family standing make treasonous intent inconceivable.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 February 1807 · page 2

M<&/ ■•■ < ,lhe president's message With deep mortification and concern. But the let ter annexed to it, stated to be a communication in djtphen'from! col. Barr'to gen. Wilkinson, excites my unfeigned astontsment. I sotemnlj avow that, wh^&at&tter was written, I had never heard, di rectly or. ■ - - . ^ from col. Burr or ally other htated attack upon New-Orleans r to suspect an 'attack pjfi&\^0r-«nyother part of the U. States, AhaVei;moment, to suspect that our will be foi^htvith ordered on an expedition nst Gibraltar., On thpjUtlier hand, I bad long Bad strong grounds for believing that col.

See moreSee less

Burr was engaged byotherobjects, of .a yery different nature alteibuted ; and which 1 confess sentiments of my hear (approved. I heed t those objects involved not the interest .Without adverting to that integri ioo^ which ever my enemies, I trust, can it be supposed that a man si 1181 descended from a family which has ^dishonor, happy in tlie affection and .. iSi^ga Bomber of relations and friends, • po6aessp#a£ ample fortune,, and standing high in the confipence of.bis fellow citizens, could harbor , for an instant,, a thooght injurious to the country tvvhichwas the scene of those blessings? The sup

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A writer insists he never heard of or endorsed any attack on New Orleans or other U.S. territory, and strongly denies any complicity in Aaron Burr's alleged schemes. He speculates on why Burr might have invoked his name, while affirming his loyalty and puzzling over how a man of Burr's talents could conceive of dismembering the union.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 February 1807 · page 2

, for an instant,, a thooght injurious to the country tvvhichwas the scene of those blessings? The sup r^^tion would be monstrous. No sir—it was but ■ Jtshort perrod before the impression became gtnt | f®4 that apprehended the possibility of Mr. Burr’s ; intentions being hostile to the union; and the mo* , which gave birth to .that apprehension, gave birth to the resolution which became a citizen. I confess. hoyever^ there are times even now, when, in spited tbo throng facts which have been exhibi ost .inclined to believe my suspicions injurpus.

See moreSee less

Whate^rmay be thought of the heart of Jtr. Burr, his talents are great beyond question ; reconcile witbsuch talents the chimerical, ! pr«|^t «f diimembeilig the union, or wresting ,ih»s it apy part of its territory, is difficult indeed,. • I.travelledjthrough a part of the western couutryj dunngthc’ lost summe.r, and have no hesitation m saying, that either of those projects would have been as much reprobated there as in the Atlantick States. With respect, however, to the communi cation annexed to the president’s message, which Occasions you the trouble of this letter—after my solemn assurances to yon, that 1 had never given col. Burr or any other person the smallest reason Jo imagine that I could be induced to engage in any project against my country—it would be infinitely satisfactory to me, could (explain to you, with the same certainty, the motive which led him to intro duce my name as he did. But here, unfortunately, all is conjecture. Two motives only suggest them selves. He imagined, perhaps, which by the way, he had no right to do—that his influence would Ire sufficiently great to induce my assent, and thought, therefore, he might as well consider it already ob tained—or, which is more probable, be might have imagined, that by the apparent concert of a num her of persons from different states, a stronger im pression would be made upon hit correspondent.— Considerable effect,' too, was, no doubt, anticipa ted by Mr. Burr’s discernment from the perfect self confidence which would have been manifested by his taking with him his daughter, receiving my co-operation,.and thus embarking in the scheme the fortunes of his infant grandson—the only relative, except his daughter, that he has. But whatever themorire, which drew from col. Buir, theasserti . ons contained in his letter to gen. Wilkinson; facts,

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A correspondent rebuts claims that he conspired with Aaron Burr, arguing facts disprove Burr's assertions in his letter to General Wilkinson. He insists he remained peacefully at home managing his plantation, never intending any disloyal action.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 February 1807 · page 2

, for an instant,, a thooght injurious to the country tvvhichwas the scene of those blessings? The sup r^^tion would be monstrous. No sir—it was but ■ Jtshort perrod before the impression became gtnt | f®4 that apprehended the possibility of Mr. Burr’s ; intentions being hostile to the union; and the mo* , which gave birth to .that apprehension, gave birth to the resolution which became a citizen. I confess. hoyever^ there are times even now, when, in spited tbo throng facts which have been exhibi ost .inclined to believe my suspicions injurpus.

See moreSee less

Whate^rmay be thought of the heart of Jtr. Burr, his talents are great beyond question ; reconcile witbsuch talents the chimerical, ! pr«|^t «f diimembeilig the union, or wresting ,ih»s it apy part of its territory, is difficult indeed,. • I.travelledjthrough a part of the western couutryj dunngthc’ lost summe.r, and have no hesitation m saying, that either of those projects would have been as much reprobated there as in the Atlantick States. With respect, however, to the communi cation annexed to the president’s message, which Occasions you the trouble of this letter—after my solemn assurances to yon, that 1 had never given col. Burr or any other person the smallest reason Jo imagine that I could be induced to engage in any project against my country—it would be infinitely satisfactory to me, could (explain to you, with the same certainty, the motive which led him to intro duce my name as he did. But here, unfortunately, all is conjecture. Two motives only suggest them selves. He imagined, perhaps, which by the way, he had no right to do—that his influence would Ire sufficiently great to induce my assent, and thought, therefore, he might as well consider it already ob tained—or, which is more probable, be might have imagined, that by the apparent concert of a num her of persons from different states, a stronger im pression would be made upon hit correspondent.— Considerable effect,' too, was, no doubt, anticipa ted by Mr. Burr’s discernment from the perfect self confidence which would have been manifested by his taking with him his daughter, receiving my co-operation,.and thus embarking in the scheme the fortunes of his infant grandson—the only relative, except his daughter, that he has. But whatever themorire, which drew from col. Buir, theasserti . ons contained in his letter to gen. Wilkinson; facts,

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

President Jefferson sends Congress a letter from Mississippi Territory secretary Cowles Meade describing the search for Aaron Burr, who had reached Bayou Pierre by January 13. Meade reports Burr claims innocent agricultural intentions, but militia have been ordered to pursue and apprehend him and his boats.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 24 February 1807 · page 2

WASHINGTON, FEB. 10,

Extrall of a letter from CowlesMeade, Jecres tary and alling governor of the M:jJijfeppz territory, to the department of War, dated Washington, (M.T.) fan. 13 1807. Silr—l bave joft time by the mail t 0 in form you, that I received this morning a let. ter from Col. Burr, at Bayou Pierre, avow.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

President Jefferson transmits to Congress a letter from Cowles Mead, acting governor of Mississippi Territory, announcing that Aaron Burr has surrendered himself to civil authority. The message also includes unrelated diplomatic correspondence regarding a treaty with Britain and France's blockade decree.

The Enquirer · 24 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Last Evening's Mail. Message from the President of the U. States, communicating information of a treaty with G. Britain; Also, explanations of the Imperial Arrets, declaring a blockade of the British Islands, so far as respects neutral commerce: and a letter from Cowles Mead, Esq. announcing the surrender of Aaron Burr to civil authority. February 19, 1807.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A territorial governor recounts how Burr, approaching with nine boats and about 100 men, denied the charges against him and warned against civil war, prompting the governor to call out the militia. Burr eventually surrendered to civil authority, his boats were searched, and depositions were taken before judge Rodney from men described as mostly ignorant youths.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Enquirer · 24 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

all boats that might defend the river. On the 16th, I dispatched two of my aids to col. Burr, who had tendered his respect to the civil authority; these gentlemen engaged on my part to give the colonel an interview in the neighborhood of the detachment stationed at the mouth of Cole's creek. Conformably thereto I met the colonel on the 17th, and after a lengthy interview, he offered to surrender himself to the civil authority of the territory, and to suffer his boats to be searched. On the 18th, col Burr, accompanied by my aids, majors Shields and Poindexter, rode down to the place, and was committed to the highest tribunal of the civil authority, where he now remains for trial."

"Four gentlemen of unquestionable respectability, with a detachment of 30 men, are now in the act of making the search of the boats, and to-morrow I expect their report."

See moreSee less

"Thus sir, this mighty alarm, with all its exaggerations, has eventuated in nine boats and one hundred men, and the major part of these are boys, or young men just from school. Many of their depositions have been taken before judge Rodney, but they bespeak ignorance of the views or designs of the colonel. I believe them really ignorant and deluded. I believe that they are the dupes of stratagem, if the asseverations of generals Eaton and Wilkinson, are to be accredited."

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

An attorney named Alexander describes being asked to help Dr. Bollman, who was arrested in New Orleans on General Wilkinson's orders after Wilkinson denounced Aaron Burr as a traitor. He recounts seeking a writ of habeas corpus from local judges, encountering delay and reluctance from Judge Sprigg who wanted to wait for his colleague Judge Mathews.

Virginia Argus · 24 February 1807 · page 2

Mr. ALEXANDER'S APPEAL.

their party for the next three nights, which that there should be on the face of the are employed in initiating others; and,as earth no other industry than her own ; no they always take to enlist a sufficient num other commerce than that carried on hv ber, they arc aide to discharge their limit herself. She has felt that, in order to suc ed Service Men, according to these agree ceed, it will not be sufficient merely to in ments, when their rights of probationary terrupt, but that she must totally destroy the outrage arc fulfilled, without any diminuti communications subsisting between nations.

See moreSee less

of their numbers actually employed, It is in this view, that under the color of “They have invariably avoided every the right of blockade, she has invented and house where resistance was to be expec put into practice the most monstrous the ted. A gentleman who lives near firanard, ory. give them notice that he was prepared for According tojrommon sense, and the u them, but they did not accept the challenge. sagrs of all civilized nations, the right of A neighbor of his received a message, that blockade is only applicable to fortified pla as his wife was pregnant, they would not ces. give him a call until after her accouch England has undertaken to extend it to ment. scats of commerce not fortified, to harbors “The few persons ofa better description, and the mouths of rivcr3. A place is block whom they have compelled to take these aded only when it is so invested that v/c oaths, they have not ordered to join in their cannot attempt t* approach it without ex nocturnal expeditions, perhaps from a dread posing ourselves to imminent danger. En that they might see two much of their ope gland has declared places blockaded before rations, and there are a few houses in the which she has not a single ship of war. country, that they could visit with safety, , She has done more—she has dared to de that have escaped them. Whether it he clare in a state of blockade places which that extreme poverty will not afford them all her united forces were incapable of all shirts, or from the love of a change, they blockading ; immence coasts and the whole now begin to dress themselves out in straw. •f a vast empire. “ Mondaj se.’nnight a Meeting of the. Deducing afterwards fn*m a chimerical Magisiratosofthe county and city of Lims nge, whilst 1 have nothing hut truth and honor to support. Some few days after general Wilkinson had denounced Aaron Burr as a traitor,at the govern ment house in New Orleans, and when he him

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A message to Congress relayed a letter from Cowles Mead, acting governor of Mississippi Territory, stating that Aaron Burr agreed to surrender after an interview with him, with his boats undergoing examination. The expedition was expected to end in the seizure of nine boats and about one hundred men, mostly young.

Virginia Argus · 24 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CONGRESS.

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.

Thursday, Feb. 19. A message was received from the President containing a letter from our ministers at London, dated Dec. 27th, stating that all points of disagreement had been settled, & that a treaty would in a few days be concluded, which would be forwarded by a special messenger. Also a letter from General Armstrong to the Minister of Marine, requiring explanations of the decree blockading England, and its effect on neutrals: and the answer of the Minister of Marine, stating that American vessels bound to or from English ports, would not be seized, &c. &c.

See moreSee less

Also, a letter from Cowles Mead, acting as governor of the Mississippi territory, stating that, after an interview with Col. Burr, he had agreed to surrender himself; that his boats were undergoing an examination, and that this expedition was likely to end in the seizure of nine boats and about one hundred persons, mostly young men

Two thousand copies of the message were ordered to be printed.

The house have postponed indefinitely Mr. Broome's resolution, 60 to 58.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The court considers objections to the magistrate's certification and oath, then debates whether an affidavit summarizing Burr's letter to General Wilkinson can be used to justify commitment on treason charges. Judges are split but agree the affidavit may establish probable cause even though it would be inadmissible at full trial.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

of treason.

That the letter from Col. Burr to general Wilkinson relates to a military enterprise meditated by the former has not been questioned. If this enterprise was against Mexico, it would

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A letter reports Burr was liberated on $10,000 bail and had rejoined his family, while another describes the territory in commotion since his arrival, with militia raised and a committee inspecting his boats. Further reports mention a grand jury indicting judge Workman and Kerr, and note Burr may be sent to face trial, with conflicting accounts of jurisdiction and procedure.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY,

We have perused a letter dated Natchez, January 26, which states that Mr. Burr had been liberated on bail, in the sum of ten thousand dollars, and that he had returned to his boats.

Extract of a letter from a gentleman in Greenville, Miss. Ter. under date of the 26th January last.

See moreSee less

"Our territory has been in commotion for some time past in consequence of A. Burr's arrival. After raising and marching the militia, a committee was appointed to go and examine col. Burr's boats—they found 30 or 40 rifles and muskets, 3 or 4 pounds of powder, 200 barrels of pork, several trunks of books, and some other small matters. Burr has given security to stand his trial at our next circuit court, and peace and tranquility is restored to the territory. I believe the people here are warmly attached to the general government."

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A correspondent publishes a personal defense against accusations made by Aaron Burr in his letter to General Wilkinson, denying any involvement in a conspiracy against the United States. The writer argues Burr had no authority to invoke his name and refutes specific claims, including about his daughter's whereabouts and the loyalty of the U.S. navy.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tive, except his daughter, that he has. But whatever the motive, which drew from col. Burr, the affertions contained in his letter to gen. Wilkinfon; facts, incontrovertable facts, prove that he had no authority for making them

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A gentleman from Norfolk reports that Gen. Adair arrived there as a state prisoner, sent from New Orleans by Gen. Wilkinson on a charge of treason, en route to Washington. The item adds a hope that Burr himself will be next to face such a fate.

Lynchburg Star · 26 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Western counties of this state. The contest will probably be a bitter one—a hard fought battle, during the month of April between common sense and the distillery.

ADMIRABLE INVENTION.

See moreSee less

Portable Distilleries complete, for the accommodation of canvassing candidates, to the next General Assembly of Virginia, made and sold on the very lowest terms in Lynchburg, by the Patentee—Negotiable notes at Burr's limit (120 days) will be taken in payment, or if the purchaser be an acknowledged harty fellow—that is to say a liberal drinker, orders on the Treasury for the stipulated amount to be deducted from the proceeds of compensation (in the next Assembly) will be taken in payment.

The British were the first who devised and enforced in the most wanton and arbitrary manner, the system of Blockade, to the detriment and anoyance of all neutral commercial Nations—The iniquity of this despotic system will now revert with tenfold vengeance on their own heads. Bonaparte has

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This report covers Mississippi Territory's acting governor Cowles Meade stating he expects to capture Burr within days, alongside rumors about Burr's true intentions regarding Spanish treasure in Mexico. It also notes that a man named Alexander, sent to Washington by General Wilkinson on treason charges, was discharged by Judge Duckett for lack of evidence.

Lynchburg Star · 26 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Cowles Meade the acting Governor of the Mississippi Territory in a letter to the Secretary at War, states that, he had issued orders for Burr's arrest, & doubted not but that in a few days he would have "this troublesome man" in custody.

An idle story has got into print—that Burr's plans have been con

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage reports a heated congressional debate concerning privileges, democracy versus monarchy, and allegations tied to the Burr conspiracy, including references to Bollman and Swartwout. Members including Randolph and others argue over constitutional rights, the law's role, and fears of political persecution disguised as treason prosecution.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 26 February 1807 · page 2

" Dssead men tell no tales; ' 'I'i! put: ca se. Suppose Aaron Burr a traxtor,and on: Wssm wished to save: the union ; let himu "e xfsi so, but if a person who has en dcavcyrcd to acvcr Kcn: sicky From the uni on ous conspired with Burr, no doubt _ s'uc'a pe. ctrsoc would wish Burr dead, for

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage prints a sworn deposition by John Smith of Cincinnati describing Aaron Burr's visits in September and November 1806, including a note requesting lodging and Burr's later disclosure of his plans. It also includes a reference to related correspondence with Blannerhassett being examined as part of the ongoing inquiry into Burr's activities.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

(COPY.)

I do certify, that on the 4th day of September, 1806, col. A. Burr, sent to me, at my house in Cincinnati a pencil'd note in the following words, to wit:

See moreSee less

Dear Sir;

Being in a few miles of you, I send forward a young man to know if you have a room and bed for me, if not, tell me what tavern is best.

Your affectionate,

A. BURR.

4th September.

I told the young man in reply, that col. Burr should be welcome to such accommodations as my house afforded, for a few days.—In a short time after col. Burr rode to the door, and I conducted him into my house, where he

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

This is a sworn affidavit by John Smith, taken before a Hamilton County judge in Ohio, detailing conversations with Aaron Burr about his objectives. Smith states Burr claimed his plans were not hostile to the United States government, mentioned a corps of volunteers if war broke out with Spain, and described land settlement plans on the Washita River.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

And when he made his second visit to Cincinnati, in November last, he disclosed his plan fully to my view, as I thought, which added strength to my confidence. He being about to take his leave of me, observed, Mr. Smith my object in a few months will be disclosed; you will not find it dishonorable or inimical to this government; I feel superior to the mean artifices which are ascribed to me--Calumniators I do not notice, for as fast as you put one down another will rise up. This much I will venture to tell you: If there should be war between the United States and Spain, I shall head a corps of volunteers, and be the first to march into the Mexican provinces--If peace should be preferred, which I do not expect, I shall settle my Washita lands and make society as pleasant about me as possible. In this government I have been persecuted, shamefully persecuted, and I am sorry to say, that in it all private confidence between man and man seem to be nearly destroyed. He shewed me a deed for a large tract of land on Red river, and said if I would consent to let my sons go thither, he would provide well for them; to which I gave consent though I never communicated it to my eldest son, till last Saturday, the day on which he returned from Marietta, and not till he expressed disinclination to co-operate with col. Burr's object till he knew whether it was hostile to the government of the United States or not.

Col. Burr told me further, that very many of his friends in different parts of the United States, would remove and settle with him and that he would be the best neighbor this country ever had, and repeated that his object was not hostile to the (here the word government appears to have been originally inserted but dashed out by the pen) people of the United States, or dishonorable to himself and further, that in a few months many of his enemies would be proud to call him their friend.

See moreSee less

I solemnly declare, that I never purchased, directly or indirectly, any provisions for the use of col. Burr and his party, though application was made to me for that purpose which I declined.

(Signed) JOHN SMITH

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 6 March 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

John Smith swears he never purchased provisions for Burr's expedition, and Ambrose Smith testifies under oath about a sealed letter he carried to Blennerhassett, denying knowledge of his father's or Burr's plans. Both depositions were taken before Hamilton County, Ohio associate judge Matthew Nimmo as part of the investigation into Burr's activities.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

following, the queries hereunto, written in his own hand, viz.

1. Are you acquainted with the views of col. Burr from any conversation with your father?

See moreSee less

Ans. I have never been informed of the views of col. Burr, but from report & never had any conversation with my

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report transmits President Jefferson's message to Congress, which includes a letter from Cowles Mead, acting governor of the Mississippi Territory, informing that Aaron Burr had surrendered himself to civil authority. The message also covers unrelated diplomatic correspondence regarding a treaty with Britain and French trade restrictions.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

United States.

I transmit to congress a letter from our ministers plenipotentiary at London, informing us that they have agreed with the British commissioners to conclude a treaty on all the points which had formed the object of their negociation, and on terms which they trusted we would approve.

See moreSee less

Also a letter from our minister plenipotentiary at Paris, covering one to him from the minister of marine of that government, assuring him that the Imperial decree lately passed was not to affect our commerce, which would still be governed by the rules of the treaty established between the two countries.

Also a letter from Cowles Mead, secretary of the Mississippi territory, acting as governor, informing us that Aaron Burr had surrendered himself to the civil authority of that territory.

TH: JEFFERSON.

February 19, 1807.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

A letter describes how reports of Aaron Burr's expedition prompted the governor to mobilize militia, culminating in Burr's surrender to civil authorities after negotiations. The account notes Burr's force was much smaller than feared—only nine boats and about 100 men, mostly young men described as dupes rather than conspirators.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

...all boats that might descend the river. On the 16th I dispatched two of my aids to col. Burr, who had tendered his respect to the civil authority; these gentlemen engaged on my part to give the colonel an interview in the neighbourhood of the detachment stationed at the mouth of Cole's creek. Conformably thereto I met the colonel on the 17th, and after a lengthy interview, he offered to surrender himself to the civil authority of the territory, and to suffer his boats to be searched. On the 18th colonel Burr, accompanied by my aids, majors Shields and Poindexter, rode down to the place, and was committed to the highest tribunal of the civil authority, where he now remains for trial."

"Four gentlemen of unquestionable respectability, with a detachment of 30 men, are now in the act of making the search of the boats, and to-morrow I expect their report."

See moreSee less

"Thus sir, this mighty alarm, with all its exaggerations, has eventuated in nine boats and one hundred men, and the major part of these are boys, or young men just from school. Many of their depositions have been taken before judge Rodney, but they bespeak ignorance of the views or designs of the colonel. I believe them really ignorant or deluded. I believe that they are the dupes of stratagem, if the asseverations of generals Eaton and Wilkinson are to be accredited."

Extatract of a letter forom col. Ferdinand L. Claiborne, to his friend in this city.

Natchez, Jan. 20, 1807.

DEAR SIR,

I returned yesterday from an expedition up the river, with 550 men drawn from this and Jefferson county, and destined to meet col. Burr, who, with a considerable body of men, was encamped at the Bayou Pierre. When informed of my approach and orders, by major Shields, aid-de-camp to the governor, he surrendered himself and party prisoners—they have been turned over by the executive to the civil authority of our country. What the issue will be or when he will be tried, is uncertain. His arms and other military stores, I expect, were taken possession of on yesterday, by a detachment from my command. Our country is full of those adventurers—our commerce destroyed, and the two territories in complete confusion."

Extract of a letter from governor Claiborne to gen. S. Smith, dated...

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 12 March 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A military officer reports that Aaron Burr, encamped with armed men at Bayou Pierre, surrendered upon being informed of approaching militia forces and was turned over to civil authorities. A separate letter from Governor Claiborne describes General Adair's arrest in New Orleans by order of General Wilkinson after Adair announced Burr's impending arrival.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter from governor Claiborne to gen. S. Smith, dated New Orleans, Jan. 15. "General Adair arrived in this city yesterday, and was immediately arrested by orders from gen. Wilkinson, and is now (I learn) on his passage to Washington. "General Adair was from Nashville; he passed through the Choctaw nation, and was the first to announce his arrival here. He reported that col. Burr, attended by a servant only, would be in this city in three days."

On Tuesday, the tenth day of March next, Will be Sold, The MACHINE built for the Richmond James River Company, under the immediate direction of Capt. Stephen Colver, which was intended for deepening and cleansing out the bed of James River from Rocketts to Warwick, and is remarkably strong, and well calculated for purposes of that kind, and for cleaning out Docks. The sale will be made at Rocketts on a credit of 90 days, the purchaser giving a negotiable note with an approved endorser.

See moreSee less

Prosser & Moncure, Richmond, Feb. 3. lawtds Auctioneers

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A letter from General Adair denies involvement in any hostile scheme against the U.S., claiming Wilkinson invited him to New Orleans for an attack on Spanish territory which he declined. A separate dispatch describes Burr's attempted evasion of arrest near Natchez, his capitulation, and his transport to Washington, Mississippi Territory for examination, where he claimed his aim was only to prepare for a Spanish campaign if war were declared.

The Enquirer · 27 February 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter, dated Washington, Mississippi Territory, Jan. 19, to a gentleman in this city.

"Mr. Burr arrived at Judge Bruin's, above Natchez; ten or twelve days ago. He wrote to Mr. Meade the acting governor, stating that his objects were laudable, that they were not unfriendly to the U. S. and cautioning him against arming citizens against citizens, and thus producing a civil war. Mr. Meade called out the militia. A warrant was issued against Mr. Burr and a party of militia were sent to take him. Several persons who had come to Natchez were apprehended by the military and dismissed by the acting governor on their parole till to-day. Judge Rodney to whom they have come has been examining them, but they appear to know but little of the real designs of Mr. Burr. Mr. Burr himself avoided being taken, by crossing the river. The Secretary sent his aids to him, a written capitulation was entered into, and last night Mr. Burr came to this place, the seat of government, and is to be examined in a day or two. He states that his object was to be ready on the call of government to make an attack on the Spanish possessions, had war been declared. He has nothing with him that can be called a force. He appears indignant at the proceedings, which have been instituted against him, and speaks with much bitterness as I am told of Gen. Wilkinson. The general does not seem to be popular here, and I think upon the whole that there appears to be a greater solicitude to criminate him, than any one else.

See moreSee less

"P. S. Mr. B. alledges that the correspondence which it is said that he has carried on with General Wilkinson, containing plans for invading the Spanish provinces, &c. emanated, as he can prove, from the Marquis Yrujo, who fabricated these letters to injure him."

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Joseph Alston, Aaron Burr's son-in-law, publishes a letter vehemently denying any involvement in treasonous conspiracy and defending his loyalty to the country. He acknowledges his marriage connection to Burr may draw suspicion but insists he welcomes investigation and has nothing to hide.

The Enquirer · 27 February 1807 · page 3

change of good offices with a man with whom I have been long nearly connected, may have givenrifetocircumffanr.es which, however in nocent in thcmfelvee, malignity will delight in difforting, and the illiberal among my political adverfaries exult in difleminating. I am aware that there will be men bafe enough— for you and I have, not long finer, feen proofs of it—to whifper even the rircumffance of n»y connec tion by marrige, with col. Burr, as a circum

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Virginia Argus questions acting Governor Charles Mead's report that only 100 men, mostly boys, were captured with Burr, suggesting Burr's real following must have been larger. It argues Burr's wealth, connections, and influence over figures like Gen. Adair suggest a far more extensive conspiracy than reported.

Virginia Argus · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"men, and the major part of them boys or "young men just from school." But, (however consistent it is with the nature of rumor to magnify whatever it represents, especially at a distance) we may be excused for doubting the correctness of Mr. Mead's conclusion that the one hundred men who had surrendered to him were all who were concerned in Burr's expedition. We cannot believe that the mighty preparations which have rung so long in our ears, notwithstanding their size may have been swelled by the breath of fame, were in reality not more extensive than he appears precipitately to have supposed. The great abilities of Aaron Burr must have produced a more powerful effect; and grey beards

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This editorial piece credits the wisdom of the Republican President (Jefferson) with suppressing Burr's conspiracy without bloodshed, minimal expense, or need for a standing army. It contrasts this favorably with how a Federalist administration under John Adams might have overreacted, citing the costly Fries Rebellion response as an example, before moving on to discuss treaty negotiations with Great Britain and France.

Virginia Argus · 27 February 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

least a whole year's revenue of the United States in making war on Burr and his adherents—What a fine pretence too they would have had for raising and keeping on foot a large standing army!—But, heaven be praised! we had a republican President; and behold! the danger is removed, without shedding a drop of blood, with very little expense, and without producing any standing Army.

See the clipping