As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

May 1807

69 articles

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The piece debates whether General Wilkinson was complicit with Aaron Burr, focusing on the mysterious ciphered letter of September 27th and how Wilkinson obtained its key. It also criticizes legal loopholes that let corrupt magistrates like Workman discharge suspected conspirators before trial.

The Enquirer · 1 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

more difficult than this. Has Wilkinson ever been connected with Burr? On this point we are free to confess, that there exist at present certain mysterious circumstances, which the honor of Gen. Wilkinson requires to be elucidated. It is our sincere wish, that he may appear on the trial of Burr, to give this essential information, and indeed we understand that the Attorney General of the U. S. has spared no effort to have him here. The first difficulty which occurs, relates to the letter of the 27th of September in cyphers.

See moreSee less

The question upon this naturally is, how came the key to it in the possession of gen. Wilkinson? was it delivered to him by the messenger who bore the letter, or had it been previously agreed upon between him and Burr? If the object, on which they were to correspond, were purely innocent, why wrap it up in cyphers?—Let us even admit, however, that these questions are satisfactorily answered by saying that it was on some innocent subject; such as settling the Washita grant; then this other difficulty occurs: Did not this correspondence, at length, extend to less inoffensive objects; such as the one mentioned in the cyphered letter?—Was the

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

The Virginia marshal has sent subpoenas to both sides of the Ohio near Blennerhassett's Island to gather testimony about the armed association reportedly formed there. Blank subpoenas have also gone to Washington to summon witnesses like General Eaton and Commodore Truxton, though it remains uncertain whether General Wilkinson and others near New Orleans can be reached in time for trial.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 1 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

AARON BURR. We understand that the marshal of Virginia has sent on subpoenas to both sides of the Ohio, in the neighborhood of Blannerhasset's island, to collect such testimony as relates to the armed association of men, which is said to have taken place on that island. If it be obtained, it will no doubt be exhibited before the next term of the federal court of this district, on the trial of Aaron Burr. It is also understood that blank subpoenas have been sent on to Washington, to summon such other witnesses as may reside beyond the limits of this district.

See moreSee less

That this process will be served on general Eaton, commodore Truxton, and every other witness, who lives within the Atlantic states, and can be here at the time of the trial, there can be little doubt. But it is for the same reason uncertain, whether the summons can embrace general Wilkinson and the other witnesses, who are now at New-Orleans and on the western waters.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 20 April 1807

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report criticizes Democratic newspapers, especially the Aurora, for prejudging Aaron Burr as guilty before his trial has concluded. It argues that every man, even Burr, deserves the presumption of innocence and a fair hearing, while still suggesting Burr may indeed be guilty and deserving of punishment if proven so.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 4 May 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ed. We sincerely believe Burr to be a very bad man : we beleive so of every man who has made as conspicuous a figure as he in the democratic politics of the country. He has done many things that deserve punishment and one, at least, that is worthy of death. He may be guilty of the crimes now alledged against him. If so, we sincerely hope that he will be punished to the full extent of his deserts. But in order that such punishment may have a salutary effect upon society, it is indispensable that his trial and conviction should be the result of fair and impartial investigation, not of factious clamour and vi

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A legal notice records that Seaton Grantland deposited the copyright for a book titled 'The examination of Col. Aaron Burr before the Chief Justice of the United States,' covering charges of misdemeanor and treason, along with counsel arguments and Marshall's opinion. The notice states the pamphlet will be available from Richmond booksellers on Saturday the 11th.

Virginia Argus · 6 May 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BE it remembered that on the fourth day of April, in the thirty first year of the independence of the United States of America, Seaton Grantland, of the said district, hath deposited in this office the title of a book, the right whereof he claims as proprietor, in the words following, to wit: "The examination of Col. Aaron "Burr before the Chief Justice of the U- "nited States, upon the charges of a high "misdemeanor and of treason against the "United States; together with the argu- "ments of counsel and opinion of the judge, "to which is added, an appendix, containing "the opinion of the supreme court, deli- "vered by Chief Justice Marshall, in the "case of Bollman and Swartwout;" in conformity to the act of Congress of the United States, intituled "an act for the encouragement of learning, by securing the copies of maps, charts and books, to the authors and proprietors of such copies during the times therein mentioned.

WILLIAM MARSHALL, Clerk of the District of Virginia.

See moreSee less

[]^ The above will appear in a pamphlet, on Saturday the 11th instant, and may be had of the several booksellers, in Richmond. w4t

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The piece criticizes a defense of Burr published in the Virginia Gazette, which claimed he merely intended to lead volunteers into Mexico in case of war with Spain. The author argues this vindication is riddled with contradictions, since it would still mean Burr violated the law, risked igniting war, and raised an illegal military force.

The Enquirer · 8 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

SOLON.

The last Virginia Gazette contains a vindication of A. Burr, which deserves attention merely from the importance of the subject to which it relates. Without meaning to pass any particular opinion upon the guilt or innocence of Burr, we may be permitted to remark, that either his vindicator is extremely feeble or that

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece rebuts arguments made in Burr's defense, contending that even amid uncertain tensions with Spain, Burr had a duty as a citizen to avoid inflaming the situation and to seek information about his country's interests. It likens Burr's claimed ignorance of consequences to a thief excusing himself for not knowing a purse's owner.

The Enquirer · 8 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

citizen.

But "war appeared to be inevitable;"—"the political atmofphere of the country was, as it were, filled with war." Even admit the fuppofition that we had at that time ferious and threatening caufes of difturbance with Spain; what does this argument prove? that at this crifis peculiarly fraught with delicate embarraffment, and vibrating as it were, between peace and war,—any individual was to be permitted to ftep forward and plunge his country into the gulph of war, on whofe brink fhe was tottering, but from which the good fenfe of his government might have ultimately rifqued her? Certainly not. At fuch a delicate time, it was more peculiarly the bufinefs of individuals to keep aloof, and to leave every thing to the found and unfhackled difcretion of the conftituted authorities. In proportion as the war feemed imminent, it was A. Burr's or any man's duty to obferve a more cautious circumfpection. In proportion to the number of important points which government had to adjuft with Spain, it was the duty of a good citizen to beware how he added to the heap, and how he fomented the jealoufy of Spain.

See moreSee less

It is the duty of a good citizen to confult for the good of his country; and never "to turn his mind to a foreign project," until he had calculated its effect upon the political relations of his country. Surely thefe are "confiderations which belonged" to Col. Burr, as well as to "others, from whofe confidence and con

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The item reprints correspondence between Aaron Burr and Mississippi Governor Williams from February 1807, in which Burr explains why he withdrew from custody and demands clarity on charges, bail terms, and assurances against military arrest before surrendering again. Burr also disputes the governor's proclamation, insisting his earlier recognizance only required him to appear if indicted.

Virginia Argus · 9 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The following letters appear in the late Mississippi papers as having passed between Col. Burr and Governor Williams. (No date.) SIR, The vindictive temper and unprincipled conduct of Judge Rodney, have induced me to

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A gentleman employed by the U.S. government to take depositions regarding the charge against Col. Burr for allegedly embodying troops for an illegal enterprise passed through town. He had been unable to obtain the deposition of a potential witness, 'young Smith,' in Cincinnati because the man had already departed for New Orleans.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Chillicothe, April 30. We learn by a gentleman from Cincinnati, that the trial of Charles Vattier (who was confined in jail a few weeks ago, on a charge of having robbed James Findley, esq. receiver of public monies at that place) came on in the court of common pleas for Hamilton county, on the 20th inst. The indict-

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A newspaper commentary speculates that Burr may escape punishment while General Wilkinson could be punished, sarcastically suggesting laws rewarding treason. It draws a political parallel to the Whiskey Insurrection, noting Jefferson later appointed that uprising's secretary to high office.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 11 May 1807 · page 2

Should Mr. Burr entirely escape, and Wilkinson suffer punishment, it were well to pass a law oflei ii.g premiums for treason* and prescribing penalties for patriotism !

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A rumor claims Burr passed through Staunton, but the paper doubts this since Philadelphia papers report he arrived there on Sunday. The item also questions the fate of Burr's unpaid bills and discusses unrelated New York election results.

The Enquirer · 12 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[illegible] assume a perfectly new appearance. Richmond, May 12, 1807.

A report is now in circulation in this city—bro't by the Western Stage--that last Thursday evening Col. Burr passed through Staunton. We cannot believe it: as all the Philadelphia papers agree that he arrived in that city on Sunday the [7]th inst. Whether he will return to this place by the 23rd, is not equally certain. "Time and the hour" only can decide.

See moreSee less

The Aurora asks, what has become of the "several hundred thousand dollar bills due" issued by col. Burr "how are those that were protested disposed of? Who paid them off? Whence came the Funds." We answer that many of them (40,000 dollars at least,) are not yet paid off? And shrewdly we suspect that the drawer has yet the funds to seek for.

The New-York papers state from official returns the average Republican majority for the Assembly ticket in the city of New-York to be 424: by which majority Rufus King is of course excluded:—Highest vote on the Republican ticket 4464.

Lewis's majority to be 184. His whole vote 1807.

And Jones's for the Senate, in opposition to De Witt Clinton, to be 187. His whole vote 1787.

None but actual freeholders are permitted to vote for Governor and Senator. Hence the difference in the number of votes for the assembly ticket; and for Governor and Senator.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A communication reports that Lieut. Robert J. Spence, noted for bravery off Tripoli, arrived in Washington after being seized by General Wilkinson's order in late February on suspicion of favoring Burr's plans. The writer expresses hope that this honorable young officer left no grounds for treachery.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 13 May 1807 · page 2

> .f ... , . “"4,a: • ■’ : ' ' :’ 'Mr-s " ■■'COXm^XlCATWKf’^'-r^ ..;■> Arrived at the City Of Washington, On Monfey, the 27th of April, Lieut. Robert J. Spence, who -behaved himself in so gallanta manner off Tripoli. : ••: ije was sewed, by gen. Wilkinson’s order, on the »>S5tb of February last, on a supposition of being favourable to Burr’s plans^and delivered to Cupt.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The paper argues that letters from Hatheway and Griswold prove collusion between Aaron Burr and the Federalist party dating to 1805, and suspects some federal judges may be complicit. It also reports rumors that Burr may skip his court appearance due to pending treason charges and $80,000 in civil suits awaiting him.

Virginia Argus · 13 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WE invite the particular attention of our readers to an extract from "The N. York American Citizen," inserted in this day's Argus. The letter of Mr. Hatheway and that of Mr. G. Griswold to him, prove incontestibly the existence of a combination between col Burr and the federalists, and his complete apostacy from the republican party as far back as in February, 1804. Let the friends of their country who peruse this important document deeply reflect on the strange series of events since that time; particularly, on the extraordinary circumstances which lately occurred in the City of Richmond.

See moreSee less

Let them consider the admission of Aaron Burr to bail in the sum of 10,000 dollars only, and with five securities; the extraordinary attention paid him by the federalists here; and their universal endeavors to vindicate and defend his character: and let them doubt, if they can, that many of that party have been & are still concerned in his conspiracy against the best and mildest government under the sun. We fear indeed, (although the allusion in Griswold's letter appears to have been to the judges of the supreme court of the state of New York) that there is too much reason to suspect some of the judges of the supreme court of the United States of being accomplices in the conspiracy. God grant that future incidents may not have a still more injurious effect on their reputations! CONSIDERABLE bets, we understand, have been made in this city, that col. Burr will not appear in compliance with his re[quisition]

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · and 1 other paper

A government agent in Lexington is gathering proof against Colonel Burr and plans to proceed to Richmond by May 22; another in Chillicothe reports difficulty taking depositions in Cincinnati due to witnesses departing for New Orleans. Both men are traveling to various towns, including Marietta and Blannerhassett's Island, to gather sufficient evidence of Burr's guilt.

The Wheeling Repository · 14 May 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

CHILLICOTHE, April 30. A gentleman passed thro' town this morning, who reported that he was employed by the United States to take depositions relative to the charge exhibited against col. Burr, of having embodied troops for an illegal enterprize. He was returning from Cincinnati, where he had been to take the deposition of young Smith, but was unable to accomplish that object, as the later had gone to New-Orleans. The gentleman stated that he was going to Marietta, and expected to procure, at Blannerhasset's island, proof sufficient to establish Burr's guilt.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 11 May 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

General James Wilkinson writes to deny a letter attributed to General John Adair, calling it a vile fabrication. He claims he can prove through witnesses that Adair left Nashville with Burr's knowledge to cooperate with him in New Orleans.

The Enquirer · 15 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FOR THE PUBLIC. MR. SMITH, I pronounce a letter imputed to Gen. John Adair, and said to be addressed to the Kentucky delegation in Congress, to be a vile and infamous fabrication—and I am able to prove by the testimony of Ralston and Floyd, two of Burr's associates, that general Adair left Nashville with Burr's knowledge and direction, and visited this city for the express purpose of cooperating with said Burr. New-Orleans, April 8, 1807.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Virginia Argus responds to objections about its earlier characterization of Griswold's letter regarding judges allegedly supporting Burr, clarifying that it believed the reference was to New York state judges rather than federal Supreme Court judges. The editor defends their interpretation while addressing accusations that they unfairly implicated federal judges in suspicions of conspiracy involvement.

Virginia Argus · 16 May 1807 · page 2

| to lie united in support of col. Burr,) those ,of the Supreme Court of the United States, and not of the state of.Ncw-York, must have been intended. To this, we answer, that the meaning of the extract appeared differently to us; and we endeavored, according to the best of our judgments, not to misrepresent it. The ietier of Griswold evidently re erred to the election in New-York. and to exertions which were then making to secure the sue cess of col. Burr, who was a candidate for

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The piece argues that sufficient probable cause existed to commit Burr for treason, and criticizes the judge who refused to do so, suggesting this raises suspicion of judicial complicity. It also notes Burr's return to the city to answer his recognizance, framing his eventual trial outcome as separate from the propriety of his earlier examination and Wilkinson's conduct.

Virginia Argus · 16 May 1807 · page 2

Col. Burr returned to this city from the northward on Thursday afternoon. THE return of Col. BURR to this Citv would seem u> prognosticate a dctcruiinntU on to appear in pursuance-of his recogni zance. This may be the ease; antlhis'in noceucc may be demonstrated upon u trial, i But u lit'tut r ai.ch should be the event, or ; not, the observations which wc have made on Ins admission to bail, and on the atten j lion paid Inin oy certa n great men, during ! the pendency or the prosecution against him, ought not to lose any part of their force.

See moreSee less

| Hi> iini.1 acquittal, or condemnation, on such evidence as may hereafter appear (cannot change the state of things at Ou tline of h s examination, which was only ] the » * imencement of the prosecution a I gainst iiim. A similar observation applies I to the question whether Gen. Wilkinson in the situation and under the circumstan ces in which he stood, acted properly or not. We conceive that the guilt or the in nocence of Burr may be established with out criminating or exculpating Wilkinson ; and contend therefore that wc have been unjustly accused of interfering imprcpcrlv .n the pending prosecution, and of endea voring to excite prejudices ag. inst the for mer oy \ indicating ihe latter from the at tacks which were made upon him by tiie Federalists. XA7 P ilpm* f o r tirA itiink ...A __.i • . - . - —•* w wit; JMIU lie mind against Aaron Burr, or toprevent his having a fair trial. We cnlv desire that his friends would be content to let him nave one, by not abusing the witnesses a gnins him; that he may appear, and stand that trial; and that it really may be fair and unbiassed. and with a lull examinati on of all the witnesses on both sides. It on such a trial as this, (which we hope he may have, tho’ we think there is some reason to fear (hecontrary) he shall be acquitted, justice will then be satisfied, and not un til then.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report notes Burr returned to Richmond despite predictions he would flee, and discusses uncertainty over whether his trial will proceed on schedule. One account says the trial may be delayed because General Wilkinson cannot attend, while another report claims Wilkinson will certainly appear as a witness.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MONDAY EVENING, MAY 18, 1807.

TO SHEW THE VERY AGE AND BODY OF THE TIMES, HIS FORM AND PRESSURE.

See moreSee less

The Wasp sloop of war, is still here, and Mr. Purviance has not arrived from Washington. Letters by last mail state that the president is less hostile to the treaty than heretofore.

COLONEL BURR returned to Richmond on Thursday evening, notwithstanding the sage and liberal predictions of certain Editors that he intended to abscond.

The period assigned for Burr's trial is fast approaching, but we understand that it is generally believed that the trial will not come on, as general Wilkinson from some cause cannot attend, the importance of his testimony will induce the attorney of the United States to require a delay until the next term.

Another report says that General Wilkinson will certainly attend the trial of Mr. Burr, and of which

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The report describes Aaron Burr's commitment for further trial on a charge of high misdemeanor after the Chief Justice found him probably guilty of preparing an expedition against Spanish territory. It also discusses the propriety of the prosecution adding additional counsel, given that a hostile lawyer, Luther Martin, has volunteered to defend Burr.

The Enquirer · 19 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

It would have been improper for the Administration when A. Burr was brought up for Examination, to have employed any new council in the prosecution. The U. S. Attorney General, and the Attorney for this district were men of distinguished talents, amply sufficient to conduct the course of an Examination.—Had any additional council been employed, it would have indeed worn the air which, some have been so anxious to give to this business, of a persecution of A. Burr; and it was besides unnecessary to incur the additional expence of other council.

The case is now completely changed. A. Burr has been committed for further trial on a high misdemeanor. The Chief Justice has declared him to have been probably guilty of having prepared an expedition against the territories of Spain, with whom the U. S. were at peace.

See moreSee less

It was well understood, that he either had employed or that he intended to employ the ablest council that he could obtain for his defence. It was even well known, that there were certain malcontent lawyers in the U.S. who would volunteer their services in any cause and for any criminal, by which they might hope to gratify their spleen against the Administration. Such is Luther Martin, Esq. of Baltimore, the scurrilous assailant of Mr. Jefferson in Cresap's affair—and the redoubted champion of the virtuous Chase—who has actually offered his services to A. Burr, and will probably appear on his Trial.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report narrates how Burr, hoping for fortune and perhaps a Mexican throne, failed to attract the thousands of followers he expected, gaining only a few hundred. It details how Wilkinson learned of Burr's schemes via the Sabine agreement and spies, initially kept quiet, then moved to defend New Orleans before publicly denouncing Burr as a traitor.

Virginia Argus · 20 May 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

annoyance. It is understood, that he consulted gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr (at that time vice-president) on the most suitable plan of operations, in case we were plunged into a war. It is also understood, that these two gentlemen suggested nearly the same great outlines, and that the President appeared to think well of them.

These circumstances, added to the prospects of war, strengthened the intimacy between Wilkinson and Burr. Their ostensible objects were nearly the same, but they were influenced by different motives. The former was solicitous to discharge his duty, and to share with his country the glory of successful enterprise; the latter was stimulated by ambition, and the hopes of profit. In consequence of his dispute with Hamilton, and the unfortunate termination of it, he was obliged to abandon the Atlantic states and to seek a residence among strangers. Destitute of employment, he turned his whole attention to the means necessary to accomplish whatever views he had formed. For this purpose he visited the Mississippi in 1805; and most probably a mutual intercourse on the subject of a Spanish war, existed at that time between him and Wilkinson. The real fact is, that Burr was determined in his own mind, at the head of a host of choice spirits, to share the glory of whatever enterprise might be undertaken; and no doubt he flattered himself with the acquisition of a splendid fortune, and perhaps with a seat on the throne of Mexico. Naturally sanguine in his temper, rendered still more ardent by his embarrassed situation, he readily conceived, that the golden prospects, which presented themselves, would induce thousands of warriors to flock to his standard. In this, however, he was sadly disappointed; for with all his exertion, only a few hundred were ready to follow his fortune.

See moreSee less

The conciliatory agreement made by Wilkinson on the Sabine, disconcerted the projects of Burr, and disappointed him in his expectations. Had he been honest in his views he ought to have rejoiced at the continuance of peace, and immediately disbanded his followers.—But instead of this he still exerted himself to procure men, and the muniments of war, and gradually unfolded new schemes, subversive of the interests and peace of the United States. These were doubtless formed long before, as will appear from the disclosure of gen. Eaton. Wilkinson first became acquainted with them while on the Sabine, partly from the written declarations of Burr, and partly from the communications of his spies and adherents. Whatever were the private sentiments of Wilkinson, relative to a Spanish war, no sooner had he concluded the Sabine convention, than his duty compelled him to frustrate the hostile movements of unauthorised individuals, and to arrest them for trial. What then was his astonishment when he found that Burr still persisted in his project, and even attempted to allure him by a bribe! Much greater must have been his astonishment when he found that Burr had either deceived him, or had relinquished his original design; and that instead of aiding the U. S. he contemplated a separation of the union, and the seizure of New-Orleans as preparatory to it. He then repaired to the defence of the capital—and at a convenient time denounced Burr as a conspirator and traitor.

Gen. Wilkinson was early apprised of these hostile projects; but he deemed it prudent to keep the knowledge of them to himself. The people were ignorant of the defection of Burr; and hence the anxiety of Wilkinson to put New Orleans in a state of defence, without any apparent danger,

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

The passage recounts legislative proceedings in Orleans where a committee drafted a memorial criticizing General Wilkinson's conduct, which was ultimately rejected after lengthy debate. It introduces a speech by Mr. Hughes arguing that criticizing Wilkinson does not equate to defending Burr.

The Wheeling Repository · 21 May 1807 · page 4

In the Legislature of Orleans. c.arly in the session ol the Oi lc ans Le gislature, a resolution was unanimouslv adopted to address a memorial to C'on o ess, complaining oi the conduct of Oon. Y\ iikinson, and a commute * ap pointed to draught one. It appears that this committee, after considerable delay, >■. as discharged, and a new one appoint -'T Eight or ten w< eks r the r s - lution had been adopted, a memorial was reported, complaining in strong terms of Wilkinson's conduct. On the iGth of March the memorial was taken I?, when a motion was made to reject 'y fins motion appears to hive been vithdrawn.

See moreSee less

The memorial having been tad, a motion was made to recommit it o a select committee. On this motion an animated debate took place, which ;• t d two days, when the memorial was *: ruddy lost. _J he following speech, delivered hv av Ir. Bushes, places the conduct of Wii-' .inson, in many particulars, in n new point o; view. I* or bold and energetic doquence, severe, sarcastic, and bitter np'; 1 a , we think this speech little in •nor to ar.v of j\ir. Randolph’s. 1seems to be a favourite idea with • /- me people, that calling in question the ■. pprk iy cl the ari.itran* proceedings of Wilkinson, is vindicating Burr. We

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A New Orleans writer signing as 'Veritas' publishes documents challenging claims that General Adair had innocently traveled to Nashville for land business. A supporting affidavit details Adair's and Burr's joint lodging and travels from Nashville, undermining Adair's account of his movements before his arrest.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 May 1807 · page 1

Mr. UELEUUGEY: Sir, Be pleased to assure the public, that the substance of the letter iaiputeel to general Adair, and said to be ad dressed to the Kentucky delegation in Congress, presents a vile and an infa mous breach of truth and honor, un worthy even a conspirator ; —unless indeed,the example of Mr. Burr and ins friends may sanction tils.ho d and give a repute to calumny. This patriot general asmrtd an officer the night af ter he was arrested, that he " had come hither to meet a couple of boats loaded with provisions, which he ex pected down the river ;" and now we Had he had repelled the treasonable proffers of gen, Wilkinson, ana turned land-jobber.

See moreSee less

Reader I cast your eyes over the following documents, and you will find an answer to the declarations of the innocent, virtuous and injured general, and the apologies of his friends, bis numerous friends m this city and elsewhere.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The Virginia circuit court has convened, with Aaron Burr's trial expected to be the most significant case since the government's founding. Witnesses including General Wilkinson have not yet arrived, and the grand jury is expected to be empanelled soon, though the trial itself may be delayed pending witness attendance.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 May 1807 · page 3

Gen. Wilkinson has taken a water pas sage to the Atlantic, states. If this i.s v.., it will render the time of his arrival uncertain. From all these circumstan

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A report states that Colonel Burr's secretary, Mr. Willey (or Witreville), was arrested in Washington County, Mississippi Territory while carrying Burr's papers and clothing toward Georgia. The paper expresses hope the papers will reach the federal government rather than fall under General Wilkinson's control.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 22 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BURR'S PAPERS SEIZED.

We stop the press to announce, from unquestionable authority, that on the 20th inst. in Washington county, Mississippi territory, the secretary of col. Burr, Mr. Willey, or Watreville, was arrested on his route to Georgia. On his examination he confessed that he was then in the service of col. Burr, in the capacity of secretary; that he had been dispatched by col. Burr, from Natchez with two pair of saddle bags, and two valices, containing his clothes and papers, to some part of Georgia. We know not how he has been disposed of, but sincerely hope that he may, with the papers in his possession, be sent to the seat of government, and not suffered to come within the controul of gen. Wilkinson. Orl. Gaz.

See moreSee less

(This paper (Bradford's) has been uniformly and virulently opposed to gen. Wilkinson and his late measures.)

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A brief dispatch states that General Wilkinson was reported to have left New Orleans on the 15th to attend the trial of Colonel Burr. The information is attributed to "good authority" via the Herald.

The Enquirer · 22 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

We have it from good authority, that Gen. Wilkinson was to leave N. Orleans on the 15th ult. to attend the trial of Col. Burr. Herald.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

This item reprints correspondence between Aaron Burr and Mississippi Territory Governor Williams from February 1807, published in Washington newspapers. Burr defends his withdrawal from public view, accuses Judge Rodney of misconduct, and disputes the terms of his recognizance bond.

Herald of the United States · 23 May 1807 · page 2

DISTRICT of COLUMBIA. WASHINGTON, MAY 11. The following letters appear in the late Miffifippi papers as having paffed betwixt Colonel Burr, and Gov ernor Williams; fNo date.) Sir, The vindidive temper and On principled condud of Judge Rodney, have induced me to withdraw for the prefent from public view. I neverthelefs continue in thedif* pofition which has been uniformly manifefted, of fubmitting to civil au thority, fo long as 1 can be affured, that it will be exercifed towards me within the limits prefcribcd for other citizens. It is proper, however, before again furrendering, that I be informed of the cartfe of charge, if any, for which it is purpofed to arreft me ; whether bail will be received—-the tenor of recog nizance, and the fum in which fecurity will be required : I afk further, your affurance, that no attempt to fend me out of the territory will be countenanc ed or permitted, and that my perfbn (hall not be fubjeded to any military arreft.

See moreSee less

1 bavt tbt honor It St, &t.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

Aaron Burr passed through Washington on his way to Richmond to face trial. General Eaton, a witness in the case, also passed through Philadelphia en route to Richmond.

Herald of the United States · 23 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr has passed through Washington on his way to Richmond, to stand trial.

Gen. Eaton, who is to appear as a witness on the trial of Burr, passed through Philadelphia on Saturday, on his way to Richmond.

See moreSee less

The hail storm, experienced in the vicinity of this place, a few weeks since, appears to have extended a considerable way to the southward. In New-Jersey, Pennsylvania and Delaware, the hail stones, like grape shot, are said to have fell in such quantities as to cover the ground several feet deep. Some of the stones measured 5 inches in circumference; and by the force with which they descended destroyed the trees and fences, in every direction.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Richmond Argus reports that the city is crowded with strangers and that Burr's trial dominates all conversation, promising faithful coverage of the proceedings. The editor then pivots to announce future coverage of the presidential succession question, noting Jefferson's decision not to seek another term.

Virginia Argus · 23 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SATURDAY, MAY 23, 1807.

OUR City is at present full of strangers from various and very distant parts of the United States. The bustle of business and crouding of curiosity are observable in every street. The trial of Col. Burr appears to occupy all minds, and to be the subject of all conversation. During

See the clipping

In the story →

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 4 other papers

The report describes the commencement of the U.S. Circuit Court session in Richmond for Burr's trial, presided over by Chief Justice John Marshall, with a large crowd in attendance. Before the grand jury was impaneled, Burr and his counsel disputed with the U.S. attorney over the manner in which jurors had been summoned and objected to certain individual jurors.

Virginia Argus · 23 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF Col. Aaron Burr.

YESTERDAY the Circuit Court of the United States for the fifth Circuit and District of Virginia, commenced its session in this city. The expected trial of Col. Burr drew together an immense concourse of citizens from various parts of the Union; indeed far exceeding any that we recollect ever to have seen upon any former occasion.

See moreSee less

At half past twelve o'clock the court was opened, present

John Marshall, Chief Justice of the United States.

Cyrus Griffin, Judge of the District of Virginia.

Before the grand jury was impannelled and sworn, a lengthy and desultory argument took place between Col. Burr with his counsel on the one side and the attorney for the United States in the District of Virginia, on the other, in relation to exceptions taken by the former to the manner in which some of the jurors were summoned, and finally on objections to some individual members of the jury. The late hour at which the court adjourned obliges us to compress into as narrow a compass as possible, the proceedings in this preliminary stage of the business. Indeed, if it were in our power to prepare the arguments at full length, we doubt extremely the propriety of publishing them during the pendency of the trial, before even the petit jury shall be sworn; especially as some of those arguments contained a degree of asperity which might possibly influence the minds of those who may finally pass between the United States and the accused.

After it was ascertained that eighteen of the grand jury had answered to their names, Col. Burr stated an objection to the manner in which part of them had been summoned by the Marshal. He disclaimed every idea of casting any imputation on that officer, unfavorable either to him or his deputies; but considered the irregularity of his proceedings as the mere effect of an error in construing the law, which error it was proper to correct. He adverted to the law of Virginia, by which 24 persons properly qualified are directed to be summoned as a grand jury; and contended that, when the officer had summoned that number, his authority ceased, and he had no power to summon the twenty-fifth. In the present case, he said, he was authorised to state, that after the Marshal had summoned the number required by law, he had accepted of excuses from part of them, and had afterwards completed the pannel by summoning additional members.

He was followed by Mr. Botts, who went more particularly into an examination of the question, and referred to the judicial act of Congress and the laws of Virginia, prescribing the duty of officers in summoning a grand jury. He also cited the case of Marbury v. Madison (1 Cranch) to shew that when a ministerial act was once performed by an officer, it was irrevocable. It was proposed on the part of Col. Burr, that the marshal should be interrogated as to those members of the grand jury, who had been summoned after the original pannel of 24 had been completed.

Mr. Hay, district attorney, observed that he confessed himself not very well prepared to answer the objection, a similar one to which he had never heard before, but that he conceived it to be of no importance, and was willing that Col. Burr should be accommodated with a grand jury, to which no exception could be made. It appeared to him indeed not be proper to examine witnesses as to the conduct of the marshal in this stage of the prosecution; and he knew not why the objection was now made; for it could make no difference to the prisoner or to the United States; since if any of the grand jurors were set aside, there would either be enough remaining of those who had been summoned, or the deficiency would be supplied by the marshal from among the by-standers. He submitted the whole matter to the court to determine whether testimony should be examined concerning the persons summoned or not.

Mr. Wickham said he meant no imputation on the marshal, whose intentions he doubted not were upright; but as this was an extraordinary case, and great attempts had been made to prejudice the public mind against Col. Burr, he was justifiable in taking every advantage that the law gave him. He cited 2 Hawk. Pleas of the Crown, p. 307 16 sect. and 3 Bac. Abr. 725, to shew that a person bound in a recognizance to answer a criminal charge, has a right to appear and make objections to the grand jury before they are sworn. Whether a plea in abatement might afterwards be filed for the error committed, was a question not necessary now to be determined: neither was it the wish of Col. Burr to resort to that alternative; for he anxiously desired that the prosecution should terminate here and with a grand jury free from all exceptions.

Mr. Hay then read the law of Virginia, (Rev. Code, pa 100, sec. 2,) and contended that the construction attempted to be put upon it was more rigid than could be warranted by sound sense and good policy.—The intention of the law was that 24 good men and not liable to any of the exceptions therein stated should be summoned. What reason therefore could be given to prevent the marshal (if he discovered that a man whom he had once summoned could not attend,) from summoning another, and thereby securing the attendance of the full number required? The marshal summons a man without knowing the situation of his private affairs. The man afterwards informs him that he is subject to uncontrolable domestic difficulties; for example, that he is going a journey on indispensable business. Why should he not excuse him, and summon another? Where is the authority to prove that the functions of the officer who collects a grand jury cease before the day on which it is impannelled?

When the return is made, if a sufficient number do not attend, a discretion is vested in the marshal to appoint others in the room of the absentees: and is not the principle the same, when he knows that the 24, whom he has first summoned, cannot attend?

He observed too that the gentlemen were influenced by a mistaken idea; for he had understood that the marshal, in the instances to which they alluded, had only enquired of the persons said to have been summoned, whether they could attend or not; expressing his intention to summon them, if they could attend; and, upon their assuring him of their inability, had applied to others.

Mr. Wickham said that the counsel for the United States had not fairly met the question. As the authorities he had cited before were short, he read them; observing that his only object in doing so was to shew that the objection ought to be made before the grand jury were impannelled, and therefore must now be made.

On the merits of the objection he said that Mr. Hay's argument concerning policy had no weight; that the words of the law of Virginia being plain on the subject in question ought alone to be regarded; that it was sufficient to answer ita lex scripta est; that policy however was on his side of the question; since great danger would result from permitting a marshal who was appointed by the President of the United States, and dependant upon him for his continuance in office, (however respectable the present marshal is acknowledged to be) to change the members of the grand jury at his pleasure.

The law is, that if the 24 grand jurors who have been summoned do not attend, 16 are sufficient to constitute a grand jury. Mr. Hay is therefore mistaken as to the law in supposing that 24 are necessary. Let it be supposed that a day or an hour before the sitting of the court, the marshal is informed that one of the grand jury cannot attend. According to the doctrine contended for by Mr. Hay, he may excuse him and summon another; but, when they attend in court, if 16 are present, he has no such power. If the excuse is made to the court and they deem it insufficient, a fine is to be imposed. Is the marshal to be substituted for the court? and can he release from the fine?

Upon the whole he insisted that the enquiry should be made; but declared that he had no intention to wound the marshal's feelings, whose error was certainly unintentional.

Mr. Hay. I said before, that no good reason existed for not authorising the marshal, where he discovered it to be certain that a grand juror could not attend, to supply the deficiency by summoning another before the commencement of the term. According to that doctrine, if 12 of those who are summoned should fail to attend, there might be no grand jury at all.

The chief justice enquired whether this question had ever come before the state courts?

Mr. Randolph answered that it never had within his knowledge, although he had thirty years ago been attorney for the Commonwealth; but there never had been a case like the present; and therefore no necessity to make a similar objection had ever been felt. This case was indeed a peculiar one, for in no other had such a torrent of prejudice been ever raised and by means too which we shall shortly unfold. In this case therefore it becomes necessary to contend for the rules of which we now avail ourselves; and in consequence of the power vested in the marshal and his liability to be influenced by the government, great danger would arise from relaxing them.

The Chief Justice. If this is a question which has never been decided in the courts of this state, we must have recourse to the words of the act of Assembly only. No doubt an exception to the grand jury may be taken now.

The law of Virginia authorizes the officer to summon 24 men, but says nothing of any more. He therefore cannot summon 25. If he desires the 25th man to attend, it ought not to be considered as a summons; but the act is void. Most certainly the officer is not authorized to discharge any person. Where 16 grand jurors do appear, by-standers may be called and not impannelled; but if 16 of those summoned appear, they are to constitute the Grand Jury. There is no necessity therefore to vest the Marshal with the power of excusing those who say that they are not able to attend. It is indeed the custom of the officers in this State to exercise a discretion in such cases; and no doubt the marshal acted with the best intentions under an idea that his conduct was proper; but after he has summoned any individual he cannot let him off. A plain argument in support of this position is that the person summoned might nevertheless appear though not called by the marshal, and offer his services to be sworn on the Grand Jury; in which case he could not be rejected. The question depends however on the point whether there was an actual summons, for a conversation merely preparatory to a summons is a different thing. It is therefore proper to examine the marshal as to what has been done.

Maj. Joseph Scott, the marshal of the district was thereupon examined. He said that he had shewed the Judges themselves a letter from Mr. John Taylor, of Caroline, who had been summoned and they had said that his excuse expressed in that letter was sufficient. He had therefore summoned Col. James Barbour, of Orange, in his room; but did not say that the Judges had directed him to do so, altho' he conceived it to be his duty in consequence of what had passed between him and them.—He acknowledged also that Mr. John M'Rae, who had been summoned, having since that time left the state, he had under similar impressions summoned Doct. William Foushee.

The Court decided that Mr. Barbour and Dr. Foushee, had not been legally added to the pannel of the grand jury; they were therefore withdrawn.

The pannel having been reduced to sixteen by the removal of those gentlemen improperly summoned, Col. Burr expressed some regret at exercising the privilege of challenging two others for favor. If the right was conceded, it might be necessary to appoint triers and go into an examination of witnesses. He wished it to be distinctly understood that he claimed the same right of challenge in this stage of the business, as if the cause were now before the petit jury.

Mr. Botts presumed that there could be no question as to the right. Even in civil cases this was a cause, though not a principal cause of challenge. The law which had been read was explicit in its application to this case. Our cause of challenge must be made out by testimony.

Mr. Hay believed the law to be as stated on the other side. No objection would be made by him to the course which the gentlemen wished to pursue. Col. Burr then proceeded to name the persons and causes of challenge. He first mentioned William B. Giles. With respect to him there were two causes, the first of which was of public notoriety. Mr. Giles while a member of the Senate had voted for the suspension of the writ of habeas corpus. The constitution had declared that a suspension of this writ could only be warranted in extreme cases; and that by pronouncing on the expediency of that measure, Mr. Giles had inevitably formed an opinion as to the designs imputed to him. Further, he would endeavor to establish by testimony, that since that time Mr. Giles had said that the documents furnished evidence of his (Burr's) guilt, and guilt of the highest grade.

Mr. Botts added a few observations explanatory of the law, and expressed a firm conviction, that from the intelligence, the virtue and patriotism of Mr. Giles, he would not suppose that the objections were made with a view to wound his feelings.

Mr. Hay observed that if the gentlemen objected to were willing to be withdrawn, he had no objection. [Here Mr. Giles made a very handsome and impressive address to the court, which neither our limits nor present plan will permit us, at this time, to insert. We will, however briefly remark, that he said, it had been an uniform rule with him neither to solicit nor refuse an appointment to any office which his country thought him qualified to fill. It was a very unpleasant thing for him to be summoned as a grand juror at the present term, but having been summoned, he had resolved to waive all objections of a personal nature. He regretted that there had not been energy enough in the House of Representatives in Congress to suspend the writ of habeas corpus,—a measure which he then thought and still thinks the state of the country required. Upon this case he was about to pronounce his real impressions. He meant ultimately to withdraw, but wished to remove certain impressions which had been made.

The chief justice observed that two circumstances must concur, in order to disqualify him as a juror, the one was that he must have made up an opinion on the case, the other was, that he had declared that opinion.

Mr. Giles wished to explain the state of his own mind. He had made up no opinion. He wished, indeed, that the public mind should be satisfied, and that the true character of Col. Burr's transactions should be ascertained.

Col. Wilson Cary Nicholas was also objected to by Col. Burr, on the ground of a personal enmity, sufficient he presumed to blind the judgment of the wisest men.

Col. Nicholas observed, that upon being summoned by the marshal, he had pressed him in the most forcible manner to release him. He doubted the propriety of his serving in this particular case, as the various relations in which he had stood as a public character to Col. Burr, might create some bias on his mind. That he was in Congress with Col. Burr when the nomination of President and Vice President was made, which terminated in an election that presented Mr. Jefferson and Col Burr with an equal number of suffrages for the decision of Congress. When Col. Burr went to the western country his suspicions were excited. He gave, perhaps, too ready a credit to the evidence which had transpired; but which was not sufficient to form a conclusive opinion. The marshal refusing to excuse him, he was obliged to attend. He did not choose that wrong impressions should be made, with respect to his motives, had he been absent. Attempts, he said, had been made to intimidate him. He had been told that if he attended as a juror, such representations would be made of his public conduct as would be highly injurious to his feelings.—Under all these circumstances he felt some difficulty. He had consulted lawyers of the first talents, who informed him that the court would not, for such causes, excuse him. He felt embarrassment from two considerations; the one was that his retiring might have sanctioned those objections; the other was that he did not wish to shrink from the performance of a public duty. But he consented to retire.

Col. Burr remarked, that the circumstance mentioned by the gentleman, that attempts had been made to intimidate him, were calculated to throw a suspicion on his cause. Such a course was not sanctioned by him. It must have been the work of some of his enemies. He disclaimed such conduct.

Col. Nicholas being withdrawn, Major Eggleston wished to be excused, because he had felt and expressed a considerable degree of warmth, on reading the deposition of Gen. Eaton; but the court considering that his case did not fall within the rule, and not being objected to by Colonel Burr, he was not permitted to withdraw.

Dr. William Foushee, on being called, expressed a difficulty in serving. On a consideration of his objections, the court suffered him to withdraw. Mr. John Randolph and Col. James Barbour, were then severally called. These gentlemen wished to be excused, on account of the impressions which the subject had made on their minds, but their excuses were not deemed sufficient by the court.

The following gentlemen were then sworn on the grand jury:

John Randolph, foreman, Jos. Eggleston, Littleton Waller Tazewell, Robert Taylor, William Daniel, jr. John Mercer, Edward Pegram, Munford Beverley, John Ambler, Thomas Harrison, Joseph C. Cabell, James Pleasants, jr. John Brockenbrough, Alexander Shepherd, James Barbour, James M. Garnett.

The chief justice delivered a charge to the grand jury, in which he enumerated the several offences cognizable by them under the laws of the United States, and particularly defined the crime of treason.

After the grand jury had retired, a debate of some length ensued on a proposition to instruct the jury specially with respect to the admissibility of certain evidence which it was supposed would be adduced on the part of the United States. A further discussion of this question, it is expected, will take place to-day.

The names of the several witnesses summoned in behalf of the United States were called over, many of whom and among others Gen. Wilkinson were absent. Such as appeared were recognized to appear on this day at 11 o'clock, to which hour the court adjourned.

The editor of the Argus wishes it to be distinctly understood that the foregoing is but a mere outline of the proceedings.—The materials already collected would occupy more than the entire columns of any one newspaper. They will appear more enlarged in some future number, when the stage of the prosecution may render it more proper.

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 25 May 1807 · an extract
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 27 May 1807 · an extract
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 29 May 1807
  • Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 12 June 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Defense attorneys for Burr challenge the marshal's method of summoning additional grand jurors after accepting excuses from some originally selected members. The court debates whether testimony should be taken on how the marshal assembled the grand jury panel, with Burr's side seeking a jury free from any procedural objections.

Virginia Argus · 23 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ginal pannel of 24 had been completed. Mr. Hay, district attorney, observed that he confessed himself not very well prepared to answer the objection, a similar one to which he had never heard before, but that he conceived it to be of no importance, and was willing that Col. Burr should be accommodated with a grand jury, to which

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Argus announces it has engaged reporters to provide full, accurate coverage of Aaron Burr's trial, with other papers free to reprint, and bound copies available for purchase. A Washington paper similarly announces hiring a stenographer to attend the Richmond circuit court session beginning May 22.

Virginia Argus · 23 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

gus.

Trial of Col. Aaron Burr.

See moreSee less

WESTCOTT & Co. ELEVENTH STREET, NEAR PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE WASHINGTON CITY,

INFORM the public that they have engaged Thomas Carpenter, one of the

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report states that Col. Burr's secretary, Mr. Willy of Natchez, was arrested in Washington county, Mississippi Territory while traveling toward Georgia. He confessed to carrying saddle bags and valises containing his clothes and papers for Burr.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BURR'S PAPERS SEIZED.

From the Virginia Argus.

BURR'S TRIAL.

See moreSee less

The Editor of the Argus, with a view to present to the public an early and faithful report of the contemplated trial of Col. Burr, has engaged Wm. W. Hening and Wm. Mumford, esqrs. reporters of the decisions of the Supreme courts of Virginia, to furnish materials for that purpose.—A full account of the proceedings, with the evidence and arguments of counsel will appear in this paper, from which all other editors of news-papers will be at liberty to copy, and publish in their papers respectively. For the use of such gentlemen as wish to preserve in the form of a book, this interesting trial, a limited number of copies will be published. Those who feel disposed to possess the work in this form will please to leave their names as early as possible, at the office of the Argus.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Public Ledger reports that a gentleman arriving from Richmond supplied them with the Argus newspaper containing proceedings from Colonel Burr's trial. The rest of the item covers unrelated news including the President's return to the capital, naval movements, and a dispute over the translation of a Spanish trade decree.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 25 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TO SHEW THE VERY AGE AND BODY OF THE TIMES, HIS FORM AND PRESSURE.

A Gentleman who left Richmond on Saturday afternoon, favoured us with the Argus, from which we copy the proceedings in the Trial of Col. Burr.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The U.S. circuit court under Chief Justice Marshall convened in Richmond for Burr's trial, drawing a massive crowd. Before the grand jury was sworn, Burr and his counsel raised objections to how jurors were summoned and to specific individual jurors.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 25 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.

After it was ascertained that eighteen of the grand jury had answered to their names, col. Burr stated an objection to the manner in which part of them had been summoned by the marshal. He disclaimed

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This opinion piece uses an extended disease metaphor comparing 'warm federalism' to yellow fever, arguing both are dangerous plagues that thrive in certain conditions. It accuses Federalists of harboring traitors and spies, explicitly linking them to Burr's conspiracy and claiming Burr asserted that hundreds of the nation's elite were involved in his scheme.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 26 May 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"Warm federalism," is only the same disease with a different aspect; the disease in its violent character, appears first under the characteristic of "warm federalism"—and though yellow fever comes only from the West Indies when there is a massacre or a war—the warm federal fever prevails most when we are most at peace and most solicitous to be so—but both are plagues—both equally deadly—both equally to be shunned.

However "warm federalism" is placed by Burr's conspiracy, rather in an awkward situation.

See moreSee less

Federalism has been the covert under which every thing venomous and traitorous has sheltered itself—

Under the wings of federalism, the bats, the night-owls, the birds of prey nestled and brooded.

Warm federalism, British agents, British spies, the Cobbetts, and Cullens, quiddism—and last in the full glare of treason—Burr—crept out from beneath the wings of federalism,—and are all vindicated or connived at by warm federalism.

How dreadful is the crisis of this disease when medicine is not timely administered!

The federalists have constantly held themselves up as the "best blood" of the country—

This has been their regular cry.

The vulgar, as Johnson has it, in Britain, are—the swinish multitude.

In Connecticut, the "fainted pilgrims" call the men of industry and innocence, tag-rag.

The warm federalists and British agents every where stile them the vulgar.

Burr—asserts, that hundreds of the best blood of the U. S. were in his conspiracy.

Federalists have always called themselves the best blood—where there is presumed to be best—that there must be

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The piece attacks British-style class snobbery and urges American mechanics and farmers to unite and vote against supporters of aristocracy. It explicitly invokes 'Burr's conspiracy' as a call to action at the next election, framing Burr as aligned with British elitist agents.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 26 May 1807 · page 2

"~ Burr’s conspiracy, calls on évery real: American, at the next ele&ion to exert himfelf—it calls on him to give his sac red vote for none but men who willfup

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The piece argues that scrutiny into alarming reports about Col. Burr has revealed letters suggesting citizens intended to use Burr against the U.S. administration, though it remains uncertain if Burr himself was complicit. It also addresses political rancor against Gen. Wilkinson for having thwarted such designs, and defends the administration against partisan attacks.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 26 May 1807 · page 3

The many efforts to cast blame up. on the adminifiration for its energies upon the alarming reports refpe@ing Col. Burr, have obliged a scrutiny, which might otherwise have never been attempted. Letters are produc ed which imply that citizens of the - United States intended to employ Mr. - Barr as the infirument of their designs - aganft the administration of the U. nited States. Whether Col. Burr was ~engageld in{uch designs is another ~ thing, but the disposition of a writer may be exprelled, whatever may be his success. If fach were the ripened proje@s of some men in the wunion, it can easily be conceived why much rancour thould be employed against Gen.

See moreSee less

Wilkin{on, who fruftrated all such designs, and that they thould con | vert measures of {uppofed neceflity inYo an intended violation of the rights

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Justice of the Peace John T. Carmichael swears that travelers Ralston and Floyd visited his home and described Aaron Burr's military intentions, including plans to seize Baton Rouge and raise his standard there with reinforcements expected to total ten thousand men. The deponents also questioned Carmichael about U.S. troop strength, gunboats, and fort defenses in the region.

The Enquirer · 26 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THOS. A. CLAIBORNE. His Excellency General Wilkinson.

County of Orleans, ss.

See moreSee less

Personally appeared before me, the subscriber, one of the Justices of the Peace in and for the said county, Doctor John T. Carmichael, who on his solemn oath declares, that on the evening of 11th of January inst. a Mr. Ralston and a Mr. Floyd, the son of capt. Floyd of Louisville, Kentucky, called at the house of this deponent, spent the evening, and breakfasted with him the next day; that the conversation during the evening and the morning generally related to the various opinions in circulation respecting col. Burr, and the situation of this country; that after breakfast Mr. Ralston opened his business with this deponent, stating that he had descended the Mississippi as far as New Madrid, in company with col. Burr, where he left him; that gen. Adair had gone to New-Orleans by a circuitous route, and that his intention was to communicate with gen. Wilkinson, and return so as to meet them at my house about that time if possible; that it was an object with them to ascertain the exact situation of the fort at Baton Rouge, the state of the works, the number of men, its weak situation; and that Fort Adams was also a place of some consequence, they enquired what U. S. troops were there, and who commanded them; where the Gun-Boats were, and who individually commanded them; who was the commanding officer of the Marines. All these questions were answered by this deponent as far as

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

During proceedings in the Burr treason case, the court rules the marshal lacked authority to substitute jurors without proper cause, striking two substituted jurors from the grand jury panel. Burr questions the marshal about which original jurors were excused and who replaced them, seeking to challenge the panel's composition.

The Enquirer · 26 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the pannel. Mr. Burr.—The Court having co-incided with the principle laid down, we muft afk their aid to come at the facts. We wifh to know, when certain perfons were fummoned, when difcharged, and whether others were fubftitut-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The report details courtroom proceedings in the Burr treason trial regarding selection of the grand jury pannel, including disputes over striking jurors and substitutes. Burr exercises his right to challenge jurors, naming William B. Giles as one he wishes removed, citing prior conduct in the Senate as cause.

The Enquirer · 26 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. HAY contefted the right; and called for the law.

Mr. Burr, Let it be diftinctly underftood that I claim the fame right with refpect to the Grand Jury, as before a Petit Jury. I will admit, that it is no peremptory challenge, but that I muft fhew caufe. It will be of courfe neceffary to appoint triers; before whom the party himfelf and the witneffes may appear.

See moreSee less

Mr. Botts. There can be no queftion, that a perfon ftanding in the fituation of Col. Burr, may challenge the Jury through favour; and a fortiori in

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

During jury selection in Aaron Burr's treason trial, Burr's counsel challenges juror William Branch Giles, citing his prior Senate statements supporting suspension of habeas corpus based on documents implicating Burr in rebellion. Prosecutor Hay proposes that challenged jurors voluntarily withdraw to avoid contentious testimony, and Burr agrees this would save time.

The Enquirer · 26 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

of the highest grade.

Mr. BOTTS observed, that there was no necessity of adding any thing to the observations of Col. Burr. If the right of challenge exists, There must also exist the right to try the challenge.—While he was up, however, he would declare that no reflection was intended to be made upon the character and conduct of Mr. Giles. That gentleman would be candid enough to admit that there is not the smallest design to wound his feelings: it is with the utmost reluctance that Col. Burr has prevailed upon himself to advance this exception. He had authorities, however, to prove, that these two causes are sufficient to disqualify Mr. G. The 1st. relates to his public. The 2nd. to his individual conduct.

See moreSee less

Mr. HAY. How many of the Pannel does the council mean to object to?

Mr. BURR. Two only.

Mr. GILES. If the court please! with respect to exceptions to me personally, I can have no objection in itself to have them tried. The court will, however, perceive the delicate situation to which I shall be reduced. The Grand Jury will have to interrogate witnesses, and to decide upon what?—I have no objection to state to the court every impression I have ever had on this subject: but as to calling witnesses, who are to detail loose conversations, which are so apt to be misunderstood I am really indisposed—

Mr. HAY. I was about to make a proposition, sir, which might relieve us from all this useless embarrassment; and which might at the same time gratify the views of the accused. If the gentlemen, who are challenged, on the jury will consent to withdraw themselves, I can have no objection. We may then supply their places.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report describes the empaneling of the grand jury for Aaron Burr's trial in Richmond, noting that Burr objected to certain jurors who were then struck. It also reprints depositions from a separate New Orleans trial of a man named Workman, including testimony from Major William Nott about the Mexican Society and fears of Spanish invasion.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

We learn from Richmond, that as late as the 24th inst. no steps had been taken towards the trial of Aaron Burr, other than empannelling the Grand

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report notes that Bollman and Swartwout have been summoned as witnesses for the United States in Burr's case, while private letters indicate the grand jury will not be discharged until General Wilkinson arrives. It notes Burr reportedly expresses strong anxiety for Wilkinson's appearance, though some doubt he will come at all.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR'S TRIAL.—The Richmond papers are no later than the Argus of Saturday, from which we published in our last. The Virginia Gazette details the same circumstances, but so nearly in the same manner, that we shall not copy from it. Bollman and Swartwout have been summoned on behalf of the United States. Private letters state, that the grand jury will not be discharged for some days, waiting the arrival of general Wilkinson, who, other private letters state, will not appear. Col. Burr, it is said, expresses great anxiety for the attendance of gen. Wilkinson.

Capt. Muren, in 30 days from Savanna la Mar, (Jam.) informs that an Embargo was to be laid the day after he sailed, on account of the sailing of the homeward bound fleet.

See moreSee less

We have been favoured with Baltimore papers of Saturday. The only articles of foreign intelligence which they afford will be found under the New York head of the 22d inst.

The brig Washington mentioned as having arrived from Rochelle, sailed after the Missouri, said to have brought the all important intelligence of the defeat of the Russians, and of gen. Benningsen being made prisoner; the accounts by the Washington do not notice this circumstance, hence we conclude that the information is not correct.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report covers examination of a marshal regarding how grand jurors were summoned, with a ruling that two jurors (Mr. Barbour and Mr. Fouaches) were not legally summoned and thus withdrawn. Burr argues for his right to challenge jurors in a criminal case, leading to legal debate between Burr, Mr. Hay, and others over the applicable law.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The pannel having been reduced to 16 by the removal of those gentlemen improperly summoned, col. Burr expressed some regret at exercising the privilege of chal. lenging two others for favor. If the right

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report describes jury selection proceedings for the Aaron Burr treason trial, including various jurors requesting to be excused for bias or prior opinions, with some requests granted and others denied. The grand jury was sworn in, received a charge from the chief justice defining treason, and witnesses for the prosecution were called, with several including General Wilkinson notably absent.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

have been the work of some of his enemies. He disclaimed such conduct.

Col. Nicholas being withdrawn, major Eggleston wished to be excused, because he had felt and expressed a considerable degree of warmth, on reading the deposition of general Eaton; but the court considered that his case did not fall within the rule, and not being objected to by colonel Burr, he was not permitted to withdraw.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Richmond circuit court under Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin opened proceedings on May 22, 1807, calling the roll of summoned grand jurors. Burr appeared with his counsel—Randolph, Wickham, Botts, and Baker—as eighteen of twenty-four jurors answered present.

Virginia Argus · 27 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Shepherd, and James M. Garnett.

The following were absent; to wit, Carter Page, James P. Preston, Carter Beverley, Benjamin Hatcher, Richard Crump, and Thomas Brockenbrough.

See moreSee less

Col. Aaron Burr appeared at the opening of the court, seated in the front bar with his counsel, Edmund Randolph, John Wickham, Benjamin Botts, and John Baker, Esquires.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage reports the opening of Aaron Burr's treason trial, listing grand jurors present and absent, and describes Burr's objection that the marshal improperly summoned more than the legal twenty-four jurors. Burr's counsel Benjamin Botts also argues that widespread public prejudice against Burr threatens his right to a fair trial.

Virginia Argus · 27 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Botts. An overwhelming prejudice, against Col. Burr, has been extended from Boston to Savannah. The state of the public mind being so inauspicious, he cannot give up the benefits of a legal trial. The past measures, as well as those which the progress of the investigation may unfold, will be strictly scrutinized. The facts complained of by Col. Burr I know have happened.

The 29th section of the judicial act refers to the state regulations for the mode of convening grand juries. The 1st section of the state law directs, that the officer shall summon twenty-four freeholders; who, or any sixteen of whom, shall be a grand jury. If a sufficient number of the said freehol-

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, Burr challenges grand jurors John Giles and Wilson Cary Nicholas on grounds of personal animosity and bias against him. Prosecutor Hay proposes the challenged jurors simply withdraw to avoid embarrassment, and Burr agrees to waive formal objection if they do so.

Virginia Argus · 27 May 1807 · page 3

Fairlamb, James Lowry Donaldson, Willi am Wilson and William C. Meade. The counsel for Col. Burr observed, that, if it was the pleasure of the court, the dis

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, Senator William Branch Giles explains his prior Senate vote while insisting his mind remains open to judicial evidence, but Burr objects to him serving. Burr also challenges Wilson Cary Nicholas, citing personal enmity, and Nicholas recounts his past political rivalry with Burr as grounds for excusal.

Virginia Argus · 27 May 1807 · page 3

Habeas Corpus, in certain cases, but had proposed that measure; that he then thought, and still thought, it was called lor, anil justified by the evidence before the Senate ; and that he now regretted that the nation had not energy fenough to sup port the Senate in that measure ; that this opinion was formed upon the state of evi dence before the Senate; which in ail ques tions of a general nature, is of a very dif ferent character from the legal evidence necessary in aju licial investigation. That his mind, he believed, was perfectly free to receive impressions from judicial evi dence.

See moreSee less

That in relation to the accused, he felt very desirous, and had often so ex pressed himself, that the various transac tions imputed to him, should undergo a full and fair judicial investigation ; and that through that medium, they should receive their just and true character, whatever that character in point of fact might be; and he presented in that character to the world. That he had no personal resent ment towards the accused ; and if the ac cused had received any information incon sistent with this statement, it was not true, i tlier he would serve on the Grand Jury or not, he should certainly withdraw. Col. Burr said lie must he pardoned for nupposing that this elTort of the gentleman to divest himscll of all prepossessions Wars above human nature. He believed he had, as much as any torn could have under such circumstances, a pure mind above bias. But this particular fact of having in his i public character formed a decisive opinion upon his conduct, must render him uuqunll

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During jury selection for Aaron Burr's trial, a juror is objected to due to personal enmity. Wilson Cary Nicholas defends himself, explaining his prior political history with Burr and his attempts to be excused from service, while affirming his ability to judge fairly.

Virginia Argus · 27 May 1807 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No page image survives for this article

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A correspondent challenges reports that government 'runners' were collecting interrogatory testimony against Burr, arguing such ex parte depositions violate basic rules of evidence requiring testimony before a grand jury or in open court. The writer predicts the court will reject any such evidence and anticipates attacks on the judges if the prosecution fails.

The Wheeling Repository · 28 May 1807 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

nection with Miranda, an attempt was made to depart from this rule, but it was soon abandoned. In the late prosecutions against Burr and his associates, there appears to have been a partial departure from this rule, in admitting the affidavit of Wilkinson. It seems, however, from the above paragraph, that some farther attempt is to be made to overset the criminal code of the country. The Executive would not have employed Runners to take exparte depositions, unless it was expected to use them, when taken, as evidence against Burr. There is no risk in predicting that these depositions will be rejected by the Court.—To admit them, unless with the consent of Burr, would be not only a most dangerous and pernicious innovation upon the existing law, but a violation of the best principles of justice & sound policy.

The Executive cannot but know that testimony collected in this manner will not be listened to by the Court. For what purpose then can it be taken? The Editor of the Fredonian must be mistaken. These Runners are perhaps employed merely for the purpose of ascertaining who are in possession of facts, which it would be proper to prove against Burr, with a view of procuring the attendance of such persons as witnesses.

See moreSee less

Any attempt to use testimony collected by these Runners, or rather Procurators, against the accused, without his assent, will certainly be unsuccessful. And should this be the case, there is no doubt but a torrent of abuse will be poured upon the Court. The envenomed bitterness which has already been manifested toward Judge Marshall, is a certain prognostic of the treatment which the Judges who sit on the trial of Burr may expect, should the Executive fail to establish his guilt by legal testimony.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A Philadelphia dispatch reports that earlier news of General Wilkinson's arrest was erroneous; instead, he and Governor Claiborne had received a presidential summons to attend Colonel Burr's trial and were preparing to sail for the United States in early May. The item appears amid miscellaneous foreign and domestic news, including reports from Trinidad, the Mediterranean, and tensions with Spanish authorities at Mobile.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 May 1807 · page 2

From the Mediterranean.—Captain Atkins, ar rived at Boston, on Saturday last, from Tarragonia, was boarded on the 2d April, by a British sloop of war, the lieutenant of which informed him that on the 25th March he fell in with a British schoo ner, 7 days from Algiers, and received front the captain the following intelligence “ That the b. S. frigate Constitution arrived at Algiers from runis, two days before he sailed : with information that the English under Sir Sydney Smith, and ad miral Louis, had taken Alexandria, and afterwards proceeded for the Dardanelles.” pHii.ADfii.pniA, Mffy 22.

See moreSee less

We have received accounts from New-Orleans to the end of last month. The report of Gen Wilkiu sons being under urest, is erroneous. The Genera! and Governour Claiborne, had re ceived a summons from the President, to attend the trial of col. Burr, and would sail for the United States, early in May.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The paper reprints proceedings from Virginia papers on the court's consideration of the U.S. attorney's motion to commit Col. Burr for high treason. It lists the opposing counsel and notes that if committed, Burr likely will not be tried this term.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr's Trial. From the Virginia Gazette, and the Enquirer, we copy the further proceedings, with the opinion of the court on the motion of the attorney for the United States, to commit col. Burr for high treason. If, upon the examination of the witnesses, the court should be of opinion that col. Burr ought to be commited for high treason, it is probable he will not be tried this term.

The counsel on this occasion are, for the prosecution, George Hay, district attorney, William Wirt, and Alexander M'Rae; for col. Burr, Edmund Randolph, John Wickham, Benjamin Botts,

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

At Burr's trial on May 25, prosecutor Hay moved that Burr be committed for high treason, prompting defense counsel Botts to object to lack of prior notice. Despite the complaint, Botts refused postponement and began arguing against the motion.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR.

MONDAY, 25th May.

See moreSee less

The names of the witnesses were first called—those of the grand jury next, who were all present except John Ambler, who was absent for half an hour after the list was called.

When the grand jury had retired, Mr. Hay informed the court that he had a motion to make regarding the commitment of col. Burr for high treason. A short conversation having in consequence taken place between Mr. Hay and the counsel of col. Burr, he addressed the court—" I now move that Aaron Burr stand committed for the crime of

high treason against the United States."

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A speaker objects to a motion allowing the court itself to examine evidence for commitment, arguing this role belongs exclusively to the grand jury. He contends that only in the absence of a grand jury should a judge take on this function, and criticizes the prosecution for failing to cite legal precedent for their unusual motion.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR.

I am willing to postpone the motion. Mr. Botts. "Not a moment's postponement—although we sustain considerable inconvenience by the manner in which it has been brought forward, without being any ways prepared, or having the least expectation of such a measure being adopted; yet, we should sustain much more inconvenience from its delay or postponement. I shall, therefore, beg leave to make a few remarks on the extraordinary application, and the pernicious effects such an extraordinary measure, were it generally practised, would inevitably produce. The organ particularly appropriated for the consideration of the evidence which this motion calls for, is the grand jury, and to vest that power in one which from its nature is so very distinct and different, would be productive of the most inconvenient and even dangerous consequences.

See moreSee less

The grand juror's oath, is to inquire into all the crimes and misdemeanors committed within the district of the state, of which they are freeholders.—Their office is to perform that, which the court is now called upon to perform. To them, belongs the exclusive duty of enquiring and examining into all species of evidence which may lead to a conviction for the crime of which col. Burr is now charged. It is most true, that when a grand jury cannot be had, that in order to avoid a f[ail]ure of justice, and to prevent the guilty from escaping, the measure which the gentleman now proposes, would not only be proper but highly necessary.—But then, it is because the proper and appropriate body of inquest is not empannelled to perform the office. Besides, when a judge is called upon to

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The report describes the opening of the Virginia circuit court in Richmond on May 22, where Aaron Burr's treason trial is expected to proceed. It notes that several witnesses have arrived, but General Wilkinson's attendance remains uncertain, likely delaying the trial's start.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 29 May 1807 · page 3

The circuit court for the Virginia district met the 22nd inst. at Richmond. At this term it is expected will come on. the important trial of Aaron Burr, un questionably tho most interesting, which has occdred smee the establishment of the General Government.—-Some days, it is presumed, will elapse before any material step will bo taken in this case, The grand jury will be probably empan* netted the first day of the term, and bills laid before them.—If sufficient evidence is then offered, and they are judged by them to be true bills, still it is most like* lv that rhne will be atloVred for the full attends dee df witnesses before the trial is entered upon.

See moreSee less

Messrs. Eaton, Truz ton, Uollmanand Swartwout, with others have already passed on to Richmond,but we have not heard of the arrival of Ge neral Wilkinson, a witness, we should suppose, whose attendance will be indis pensable. Equally so will probably be that tcstimony which relates to the al ltdged overt acts committed on Blanner basset’s Island. It ii supposed that Gen. Wilkiqton has taken a water pas sage to the Atlantic states. If this is so, it will render the time of his arrival un certain.- From all these .circumstances the public will probably be urfdcr the ne cessity of exercising their patience for some time. , [Nat. Int.]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This Philadelphia dispatch reports that earlier news of General Wilkinson being placed under arrest was erroneous. It notes that Wilkinson and Governor Claiborne received a presidential summons to attend Colonel Burr's trial and would sail for the United States in early May.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

PHILADELPHIA, May 22. We have received accounts from New-Orleans to the end of last month. The report of Gen. Wilkinson being under arrest, is erroneous. The General and Governor Claiborne, had received a Summons from the President, to attend the Trial of Col. Burr, and would sail for the United States, early in May. Philad. Gazette.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The court discusses when to reconvene the Grand Jury, with Chief Justice Marshall and prosecutor Hay debating scheduling. Hay then moves to commit Aaron Burr on a charge of High Treason, citing new witnesses and depositions beyond the earlier misdemeanor evidence.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

Mr. Wickham stated that as several witnesses were attending at a considerable distance on the behalf of Col. Burr, it was proper to fix upon some particular day for calling the Grand Jury.

Mr. Hay replied that a motion might be made which would render their presence necessary even on that day.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham requested, that before the G. Jury was adjourned, the Counsel for the U. S. would state the object of his motion.

Mr. Hay. The object of my motion is, to commit Aaron Burr on a charge of High Treason against the United States.—You will recollect, Sir, to have decided on a former case, that there was not sufficient evidence of an Overt Act to commit Aaron Burr for High Treason; and you recognized him for a misdemeanor only. Our evidence is now however more ample; we have new witnesses to bring before you; we have new depositions to read; & upon the strength of this additional testimony, I now move that Aaron Burr be commited on a charge of High Treason.

Mr. Wickham hoped that the motion may be made, and counsel be heard.

Mr. Hay. They may be assured, that they will be apprised of the application; but do they wish me now to make it in the presence of the Grand Jury?

Mr. Burr. The gentleman mistakes the motion of my counsel. The object was not that the Grand Jury might hear the application, but to make the impropriety more manifest of mentioning such an application in the presence of the Grand Jury. While things are in this crisis, no measures ought to be taken to prejudice their minds: and while a Grand Jury is impannelled, it is improper to introduce the evidence before any other tribunal.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 5 June 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Prosecutor Hay moves that Aaron Burr be committed on a charge of High Treason, citing new depositions and witnesses beyond the earlier examination. Defense counsel Wickham and Botts object to lack of notice, and Hay agrees to delay the motion until the next day while maintaining Burr stands charged with treason.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

lay, that we have taken them off their guard.

It is to be understood however, if this enquiry

See moreSee less

be postponed, that Aaron Burr must be con

sidered to stand before the court on a charge

of High Treason.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

Burr's counsel argues against a motion that would let the court, rather than the Grand Jury, examine and commit Burr, calling it unprecedented and oppressive. He contends the presiding judge should not prejudge the case and cites precedent regarding summons versus arrest in misdemeanor indictments.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

S. the chance of procuring an opinion from the court unfavorable to Col. Burr—failing in that chance he would then betake himself to his only legal one before the Grand Jury.

Why should this court step out of its ordinary course to forestal or influence the deliberations of the Grand Jury.

See moreSee less

The object of the motion is without precedent or reason, against all legal principle, and would be most oppressive in its consequences. The history of our criminal jurisprudence yields no instance of such a motion during the session of a Grand Jury. It is unreasonable and against principle that the functions of the inquest should be suspended, for the court to assume them. It is not only oppressive, but of a piece with the long course of oppression, which has been practised upon the gentleman whom I advocate.

We might with propriety have moved to discharge Col. Burr from the recognizance already given.

The laws of Congress have adopted our rules and practice in the state, in proceedings upon indictments for misdemeanours. You were of opinion, you will remember, sir, that nothing more than probable cause of suspecting a misdemeanor appeared against Col. Burr. Even after an indictment, in Virginia, for a misdemeanor, nothing more than a summons can go against the indictee. No court of the commonwealth ever permitted a capias to go in the first instance, unless the case passed sub silentio now arrest and bail are utterly incompatible with a summons; and surely if an indictee cannot be arrested, one merely suspected cannot be held to bail.

The conduct of judge Chase in awarding a capias was the subject of one of the charges in his impeachment. Mr. Hay vehemently and ably contended that a summons only ought to have gone against callender.

I know that the court may have an impression that I am wandering from the subject. I will soon shew what application the past recognizance has to the motion now to examine the witnesses to commit for treason.

Notwithstanding Col. Burr was committed upon a charge of misdemeanor, when under the state laws he could not have been committed, a public prejudice has been excited against the lenity of the measure, and attempts have been set on foot through newspapers and general clamour, to intimidate every officer who might have any concern in the trial. This public prejudice would be increased by the present motion rather than allayed, if the necessary explanation should not be made. The multitude around us must hear what is passing, and we cannot submit to a course, which would further invest the public mind with the poison already too plentifully infused.

The persecution of Col. Burr has hitherto been without a check. The seizure of his

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 3 June 1807
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 8 June 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A speaker calculates travel time from New Orleans to argue General Wilkinson could not have reached Richmond sooner, defending the prosecution's decision not to proceed without him. The argument emphasizes Wilkinson's importance to the case and to his own reputation, while asserting sufficient evidence of treason exists independent of his testimony.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the administration. The certainty that A. Burr would be put upon his trial, could not have been known at Washington till the 5th or 6th of April. Now, sir, let the gentlemen on the other side make a slight calculation ; Orleans

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Attorneys argue over delaying the treason indictment due to General Wilkinson's absence, with the prosecution insisting his testimony is crucial to the case. The court then rules on whether it has the power to commit Aaron Burr, addressing both its own authority and whether circumstances warrant restraint in exercising it.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

hope, fir, that the motion to commit Aaron Burr will be received, because we think it a legal meafure and a juft and neceffary meafure of precaution.

(Debate to be Continued.)

See moreSee less

TUESDAY, May 26.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The court addresses the legal argument that Burr cannot be charged with treason again since an earlier application was rejected for lack of probable cause. It rules that the earlier rejection does not bar a new motion, since Burr now stands as if treason had never before been alleged against him.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

of those who make the motion, rather than of the court, and others go to the circumspection with which the testimony in support of the motion ought to be weighed, rather than to the duty of hearing it.

It has been said that Col. Burr already stands charged with treason, and that, therefore, a motion to commit him for the same offence is improper. But the fact is not so understood by the court. The application to charge him with treason was rejected by the Judge to whom it was made, because the testimony offered in support of the charge did not furnish probable cause for the opinion, that the crime had been committed. After this rejection, Col. Burr stood so far as respected his legal liability to

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A prosecuting attorney addresses the court, arguing that the treason charge against Aaron Burr is too significant to be resolved hastily and that Burr should remain in custody. He notes that General Wilkinson is expected to arrive by month's end to present evidence to the Grand Jury on charges of misdemeanor and treason.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ceiving the force of that testimony, cooly marches off & leaves the court to pronounce its decision. Would not this be a ridiculous situation? Would it not be a farce, sir? And would it not expose us to the scorn of the U. S? Can our proposition be deemed an unreasonable one? We ask, merely, that Col. Burr should be kept here to answer the decision of the court. This is no common case. It is one of immense importance; it has already imposed a great expence upon the public. I am informed by the Secretary of War, that we may expect Gen.

See moreSee less

Wilkinson between the 28th & 30th of this month. If he comes, the b[il]ls both for a misdemeanor and treason will certainly be laid before the Grand Jury—Will the court then positively decide, that Col. Burr may in [th]e mean time effect his escape?—But if Wilkinson does arrive and if A. Burr does apprehend that we have sufficient evidence of the crime of treason; will he hesitate to fly to save

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Lawyers argue before the court whether Burr should be granted bail, debating distinctions between treason and misdemeanor charges and the adequacy of prior bail amounts. The Chief Justice explains his earlier reasoning for setting $10,000 bail based on the misdemeanor charge, noting that fuller evidence on the treason charge had not yet been presented at that time.

The Enquirer · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

and the former examination; that in the latter case. Col. Burr was brought before you by a warrant; but that he is not really at this time before the court, But why was this warrant issued on a former examination? because Col. Burr was not before the Judge--it was necessary, but when that arrant was discharged it was void; it was functus officio. Col Burr was in custody; until he gave Bail. It was immaterial how the accused man comes before the magistrate; whether by warrant, by voluntary delivery or by the compulsion of others.

See moreSee less

But when he is there, charged with an offence, which involves both liberty and life--he certainly should not be told, that it was optional with him, whether he remained there or went any where else. Chief Justice delivered an opinion at some length, which it was impossible for us to hear distinctly or to take it down as delivered.--He observed that on Col. Burr's former examination he had demanded bail from day to day, because he had already seen the testimony, and supposed it to contain probable proof of guilt, on the charge of a misdemeanor; that this at least was the principal reason for his having demanded bail; that on completing the examination, the sum of 10,000 dollars was considered sufficient to bind him to answer the charge

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The court convened May 27 with Mr. Hay (prosecutor) announcing that since counsel for the US and Burr could not agree on bail terms, he would proceed to examine witnesses to secure Burr's commitment on the charge of high treason. Burr and his counsel Wickham also requested the court clear space near the bar due to crowding from spectators.

Virginia Argus · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

proceed with the evidence.

[ô From the commencement of the term to the present moment, col. Burr with his counsel had occupied the front bar in common with other gentlemen of the profession. Mr. Wickham suggested to the court the inconvenience to which they were subjected from the immense pressure of the spectators, and concluded by requesting that the front bar and the one next to it should be cleared.

See moreSee less

Col. Burr reiterated the observations made by Mr. Wickham, and further re

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report describes a dispute over seating arrangements in the courtroom before testimony began in Aaron Burr's treason trial, resolved by rearranging the bar. It then details the opening evidentiary arguments, including objections to General Wilkinson's affidavit and testimony from witnesses Taylor and Albright regarding an armed assemblage on Blennerhassett's Island, followed by objections to Jacob Dunbaugh's affidavit.

Virginia Argus · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Burr and his counsel; which being done, Mr. Hay observed that the arrangement was so inconvenient to him, that with the permission of the court, he would take the place at the bar lately occupied by colonel Burr and his counsel, as he had no objection to his notes being inspected. Mr. Hay, with the assistant counsel for the United States immediately took their seats in the front bar, and the vacant seats in that as well as the whole of the second bar were immediately filled by others. From that period, col Burr and his counsel have daily been seated within the bar, and the counsel for the U. States have occupied seats in common with the rest of the profession.]

Before any evidence was offered on the part of the U. S. the chief justice as well as the counsel for col. Burr strongly enforced the impropriety of publishing any part of the testimony which should be exhibited in that stage of the business. Even without these remarks we should have deemed it our duty to have been silent as to the facts disclosed by the evidence.

See moreSee less

The first piece of testimony offered was the affidavit of gen. Wilkinson. On its introduction a long and desultory argument

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During Burr's trial proceedings, defense counsel objected to reading an affidavit from Jacob Dunbaugh, citing procedural defects including the witness's absence and questions about the certifying magistrate's jurisdiction. The chief justice ruled that while live testimony is preferable, the affidavit could be admitted since the witness lived far away and there was no evidence he was being deliberately kept from testifying.

Virginia Argus · 30 May 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THURSDAY, May 28.

Luther Martin, esq. appeared as the counsel of col. Burr.

See moreSee less

On the motion made yesterday to exclude the affidavit of Jacob Dunbaugh, the chief justice delivered the opinion of the court as follows:

On the part of the United States, a paper purporting to be an affidavit has been

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Lawyers argue whether Colonel Burr should be committed for treason before all evidence is presented, with Mr. Hay stressing the gravity of the charge and the expense already incurred by the government. The report notes General Wilkinson is expected to arrive by the 28th or 30th, after which indictment bills would be sent to the grand jury.

Virginia Argus · 30 May 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

to be committed, the court are requested to predetermine the effect of the evidence, and commit, before they have decided whether they ought to commit. Besides no warrant has been issued against Col. Burr on the present occasion. He has not been arrested for treason; and therefore cannot be considered as in custody for that offence.

Mr. Hay then made some farther observations on the importance of the charge of treason, (which is of the highest nature, involving the reputation and life of the prisoner,) and the great necessity therefore of the most ample security to compel his appearance to answer it. He stated that this examination might last many days; that after the court had made up an opinion that Colonel Burr ought to be committed, he might march

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A Washington firm, Westcott & Co., announces they have engaged stenographer Thomas Carpenter to attend the circuit court trial of Aaron Burr, set to begin May 22 in Richmond. They plan to publish a complete account of the proceedings along with related documents, securing copyright on the publication.

Virginia Argus · 30 May 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Trial of Col. Aaron Burr.

WESTCOTT & Co. ELEVENTH STREET, NEAR PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE WASHINGTON CITY, INFORM the public that they have engaged Thomas Carpenter, one of the

See the clipping