The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The passage details courtroom proceedings regarding adjournment of the grand jury and Mr. Hay's motion to commit Burr on treason charges, contingent on General Wilkinson's anticipated arrival. Burr's counsel opposed the motion, arguing it would prejudice the grand jury, while the court postponed its decision on how to proceed.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
From the Enquirer.
TRIAL OF AARON BURR.
See moreSee less
Saturday, May 23. The court sat at 11. A. Burr was not present. The proceedings of yesterday being read, and the names of the grand jury called over, Mr. Hay moved to recognize the witnesses who were not present yesterday. Those who appeared were, Erick Bollman, Samuel Swartwout, Thomas Morgan, and Robert Spence. Some conversation ensued on the motion to instruct the Grand Jury: and it was understood, that Mr. Burr's counsel was to give timely notice, to the U. S. attornies, of the propositions they intended to submit to the court. The question was suggested, whether the grand jury could be adjourned to some future day, without being adjourned from day to day. The Chief Justice declared, he was not prepared to give an opinion on the subject.
Monday, May 25. The proceedings of this day were extremely interesting, and will be detailed at length hereafter. Mr. Hay declared that he should not for several days send up his indictments to the grand jury, unless general Wilkinson made his appearance; and that in case he did not appear, he should then determine on the course he ought to pursue. The grand jury was adjourned till Tuesday 12 o'clock. Mr. Hay moved the court to commit A. Burr on a charge of high treason against the U. S. He declared that the reason of this motion was founded on a possibility of Mr. B's flying from the law, in case he should be positively informed that general Wilkinson was on his way to Richmond, unless he was committed for treason, and detained by higher bail; and that he believed the evidence he was now to bring forward, in addition to what had been adduced on the examination of A. Burr, was sufficient to induce the Judge to gra[nt] the commitment. He therefore m[oved], that evidence should be heard on behalf of this motion. Mr. Burr's counsel opposed this motion, principally on the ground; that the Grand Jury and the court possessing concurrent powers in this case, it was inexpedient for the court to exercise this power, while the grand jury was in session; that a more particular reason against the court's exercising this power, was, that they would have to deliver opinions on the evidence, and thus commit themselves on the ulterior stages of the prosecution, and forestal the sentiments of the grand jury, and the public; and that as another mode of producing this last effect, depositions or written papers which could not go before the grand jury, would be brought before the court as a foundation for the motion of commitment. These affidavits would be known to th[e] Grand Jury, and might contribute to prejudicate their mind.—The counsel for the prosecution contested all these arguments. The court postponed giving any opinion, till this day. Mr. Hay avowed his expectation that Gen. Wilkinson would appear in a few days. The government had employed every possible exertions to that effect.
Tuesday, May 26. 1 o'clock. The court has just decided, that "if it is the choice of the prosecutor on the part of the U. S. to proceed with his motion, it is the opinion of the court, that he may open his testimony."
Question postponed till to-morrow.—The difficulty is, to make some arrangement*, which may prevent an anticipated impression on the public mind, by the exhibition of evidence. The counsel for the prosecution and the prisoner cannot yet agree upon any arrangement. * Suggested by the attorney of the U. States.
The report continues coverage of Col. Burr's trial, describing the court's concerns about publicly examining witnesses at this stage. Counsel for both sides conferred on an alternative arrangement but failed to agree, so the court granted further time to consider how to proceed.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
MONDAY EVENING, JUNE 1, 1807.
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
See moreSee less
Our last number upon the subject of this important trial, finished with the opinion of the court upon the motion of the attorney for the United States, to commit col. Burr for high treason. It will be remembered by our readers, that that opinion closed with some remarks upon the bad effects likely to be produced by a publick examination of witnesses, and a discussion at this time. In consequence of which, the following circumstance occurred, as detailed in the Virginia Argus extra. of the 27th ult.
"Mr. Hay then rose and declared that he was fully sensible of the inconveniencies which might result from a publick examination of the witnesses at this stage of the prosecution; that nothing but the necessity of taking this step, to secure the appearance of col. Burr to answer the charge, had induced him to make the motion for commitment.—He was willing therefore, if any arrangement could be made to attain the same end, and to obviate the inconveniencies mentioned by the court, that such arrangement should be made. He observed that he understood from the counsel on the other side that they were disposed to confer with him and the gentlemen who assisted him, on the subject of adopting some such arrangement. He proposed therefore with the permission of the court to retire for a short time for the purpose of holding the conference proposed.
The court having consented, the counsel on both sides retired together; and returning, after an absence of a few minutes, informed the court that they had not been able to come to an agreement, and wished further time to consider the course which it might be most adviseable to pursue; to which the court acceded.
The case of col. Burr was therefore, without any further proceedings at present, adjourned until the next day."
A private letter received by last mail, states, that on Friday the witnesses were examined upon the attorney's motion for the commitment for high treason, which resulted in the decision of the court, that the evidence was not sufficient to commit Aaron Burr for high treason. The court, however, we understand, has increased the sum for which col. Burr was heretofore bailed from ten to twenty thousand dollars, for which sum bail has been given, to the great mortification of the mild and amiable friends of humanity, who condemn before trial, and would anticipate a part of the punishment which the law contemplates in the eevnt of conviction of the crime alledged.
The grand jury still remain impannelled, and no indictment had been filed by the attorney, who stated that he declined doing so until the arrival of general Wilkinson, who is said to have embarked
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
A witness at Burr's trial describes forming a club to gather intelligence on Mexico in anticipation of war with Spain, insisting it was patriotic and sanctioned only by eventual U.S. government authority. He swears neither he nor fellow club members knew of Burr's alleged schemes to sever the Union or invade Mexico until General Wilkinson arrived with warnings in November.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
cial speculations with the different provinces of his Catholick majesty. Neither this association, or any one of its members, as far as I know or believe, ever heard of Aaron Burr's projects for severing the American Union, or invading Mexico, either directly or indirectly, or of his or any other scheme or plan whatever for violating or infringing any one of the laws of the United States, or in the least degree troubling its peace or tranquility, until the arrival of gen. Wilkinson here in the month of November last. On the contrary, this club was established on the most virtuous and patriotic principles —never speaking of, or contemplating any expedition—the raising of one dollar—the levying one soldier—the purchase of one arm, or engaging one single man, unless under the sanction and by the express orders of the government of the United States.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 27 May 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
A witness describes a dissolved society once focused on invading Mexico, which disbanded after the Senate chose negotiation over war with Spain. He also recounts three rumored but unexecuted plans to seize Baton Rouge, including one by Governor Claiborne involving disguised soldiers in carriages.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
A. I have heard of three contemplated expeditions—the first was to have been accomplished by the governor, in a manner that seems too foolish to be mentioned seriously—the second, which was to take the fort by open force, was projected by governor Mead, and the third was to be effected by gen. Wilkinson with the army when returning from Natchitoches.
Q. What was the project of gov. Claiborne?—Please to relate to the court what you know on the subject.
See moreSee less
A. His intention was I understood, under the pretence of a grand entertainment, to collect a number of carriages; after supper to arm the guests, put them in the carriages, and thus to enter Baton Rouge, where the sight of such merry cavalcade could excite no alarm; having thus obtained admission into the place, the soldiers rushing from their cabriolets were to surprise the garrison, and possess themselves of the fort.
This report details grand jury proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, listing witnesses bound by recognizance and others who failed to appear. The chief justice adjourns the grand jury until Monday due to an absent witness deemed important by the prosecution.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
liam Wilson, and William C. Meade. The counsel for col. Burr observed, that, if it was the pleasu[r]e of the court, the dis-
The grand jury reported to court after two days of deliberation but had no indictments ready to present, as prosecutor Hay wanted to wait until General Wilkinson's crucial testimony could be obtained. The chief justice and counsel debated whether the grand jury needed to be called daily or could be adjourned, with Monday set as the likely next date for proceedings.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Wilkinson, who was still absent, and whose testimony was deemed very important.
A further conversation took place as to the propriety of adjourning the grand jury
The court addresses arguments over whether Burr's prior commitment and the earlier rejection of a treason charge bar a new motion to commit him for the same offense. It rules that the prosecutor retains the right to make such a motion despite the previous rejection, even as new testimony and witnesses have since been gathered.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
It has been said that col. Burr already stands charged with treason, and that, therefore, a motion to commit him for the same offence is improper. But the fact is
The circuit court for the Virginia district met at Richmond, with Aaron Burr's trial expected to be the most significant case since the government's founding. Key witnesses including Eaton, Truxton, Bollman, and Swartwout had arrived, but General Wilkinson's whereabouts remained uncertain, delaying proceedings.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 2 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WASHINGTON CITY, MAY 22.
be that testimony which relates to the alledged overt acts committed on Blannerhasset's Island. It is supposed that Gen. Wilkinson has taken a water passage to the Atlantic states. If this is so, it will render the time of his arrival uncertain. From all these circumstances the public will probably be under the necessity of exercising their patience for some time.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report describes the opening of evidence by U.S. counsel Mr. Hay in the motion to commit Aaron Burr on charges of High Treason, including witnesses and affidavits presented and contested. It notes the Chief Justice's rulings on admissibility of evidence and the eventual arrangement setting Burr's bail at $40,000, with the Grand Jury adjourned until Saturday.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
WASHINGTON CITY, WEDNESDAY, JUNE 3
We received last night at a late hour the Richmond Enquirer, containing the proceedings of the Circuit Court in the case of Aaron Burr, which occupy twelve columns of small print. They are extremely interesting, but defy abridgement. We shall therefore in this number take but a very concise notice of what was done, reserving details for our next. On Wednesday last the counsel on the part of the U. States opened the evidence on the motion to commit Aaron Burr on the charge of High Treason, Mr. Hay having previously observed that all hope of arrangement with col.
See moreSee less
Burr's counsel to secure his person was at an end. Mr. Hay first offered Gen. Wilkinson's affidavit. The Chief Justice said the most proper course was first to adduce evidence of the overt act. Mr. Hay then called Peter Taylor & —— Albright, the first Blannerhasset's gardener, and the other a workman on the island. A letter in cypher to a person in New Orleans was then offered. Mr. Hay then offered the affidavit of Dubas, a sergeant in the army, which he represented as being of the greatest importance. Col. Burr's counsel objected to its admissibility, on which a long argument ensued. On Thursday the Court pronounced an elaborate opinion, and decided the affidavit not admissible. Mr. Hay then gave notice that unless the depending examination was finished that day, he should move that col. Burr should be bound to appear in court tomorrow, to answer the charge of treason. On this proposition considerable argument ensued. The Chief Justice gave an opinion, in which he said the court felt much embarrassment in fixing the sum in which Mr. Burr should be recognised, lest it might implicate an opinion on the charge of treason, and intimated a strong wish that arrangements might be made between the counsel on each side. Arrangements were ments accordingly made, in consequence of which col. Burr gave bail, inclusive of the first recognizance, in the sum of
The report describes courtroom arguments over whether an affidavit by a man named Dunbaugh should be admitted as evidence, with objections raised about witness attendance and proper authentication. The court ruled that while personal testimony is preferred, the affidavit should not be rejected outright, though it would be viewed with caution.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
We continue the further proceedings in the trial of Col. Burr, on which we have not room for comment. Luther Martin, has, we observe, arrived as one of Col. Burr's counsel; and William Duane, as a witness on the part of the United States.
A gentleman who left Richmond on Monday afternoon, informs that nothing since Friday had been done in the trial of Col. Burr, and general Wilkinson had not arrived.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
Aaron Burr contests the court's authority to hold him on bail before the inquiry proceeds, citing constitutional protections against arrest without probable cause. He ultimately agrees to post bail of $10,000 with four securities, after Chief Justice clarifies that accepting bail implies no judgment on probable cause.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
COL. BURR'S TRIAL.
On Wednesday the attorney on the part of the prosecution, produced an affidavit by a man of the name of Dunbaugh—Respecting the legality of the affidavit several arguments took place. On Thursday morning the court delivered the following opinion—
See moreSee less
On the part of the United States a paper purporting to be an affidavit has been offered in evidence, to the reading of which two exceptions are taken:
1st. That an affidavit ought not to be admitted, where the personal attendance of the witness could have been obtained;
2dly. That this paper is not so authenticated as to entitle itself to be considered as an affidavit.
That a magistrate may commit upon affidavits has been decided in the supreme court of the United States, though not without hesitation. The presence of the witness to be examined by the committing justice confronted with the accused, is certainly to be desired, and ought to be obtained, unless considerable inconvenience and difficulty exist in procuring his attendance. An ex parte affidavit shaped perhaps by the person pressing the prosecution, will always be viewed with some suspicion and acted upon with some caution, but the court tho't it would be going too far to reject it altogether.—If it was obvious that the attendance of the witness was easily attainable, but that he was intentionally kept out of the way, the question might be otherwise decided.
But the particular case before the court does not appear to be of this description. The witness resides at a great distance, and there is no evidence that the materiality of his testimony was known to the prosecutors, or to the executive, in time to have directed his attendance. It is true, that general instructions, which would apply to any individval, might have been sent, and the attendance of this or any other material witness obtained under those instructions; but it would be requiring too much to say that the omission to do this ought to exclude an affidavit.
This exception, therefore, will not prevail.
The second is, that the paper is not so authenticated, as to be introduced as testimony on a question which concerns the liberty of a citizen.
This objection is founded on two omissions in the certificate—
The first is, that the place at which the affidavit was taken, does not appear.
The second, that the certificate of the governor does not state the person who administered the oath to be a magistrate, but goes no further than to say that a person of that name was a magistrate.
That, for aught appearing to the court, this oath may or may not in point of fact have been legally administered, must be conceded.
The place where the oath was administered not having been stated; it may have been administered where the magistrate had no jurisdiction, and yet the certificate be perfectly true. Of consequence there is no evidence before the court, that the magistrate had power to administer the oath and was acting in his judicial capacity.
The effect of testimony may often be doubtful; and courts must exercise their best judgment in the case, but of the verity of the paper there ought never to be a doubt. No paper writing ought to gain admittance into a court of justice as testimony, unless it possesses those solemnities which the law requires. Its authentication must not rest upon probability, but must be as complete as the nature of the case admits of. This is believed to be a clear legal principle. In conformity with it is as the court conceives, the practice of England and of this country as is attested by the book of forms, and no case is recollected in which a contrary principle has been recognized. This principle is in some degree illustrated by the doctrine with respect to all courts of a limited jurisdiction. Their proceedings are erroneous, if their jurisdiction be not conclusively shewn. They derive no validity from the strongest probability that they had jurisdiction in the case; none certainly from the presumption that being a court, a usurpation of jurisdiction will not be presumed. The reasoning applies in full force to the actings of a magistrate whose jurisdiction is local. Thus in the case of a warrant it is expressly declared, that the place where it was made ought to appear. The attempt to remedy this defect by comparing the dates of the certificates given by the magistrate, with that given by the government cannot succeed. The answer given at bar to this argument is conclusive. The certificate wants those circumstances which would make it testimony, and without them no part of it can be regarded.
The second objection is equally fatal. The governor has certified that a man of the same name with the person who has administered the oath is a magistrate, but not that the person who has administered it is a magistrate.
It is too obvious to be controverted, that there may be two or more persons of the same name, and consequently, to produce that certainty which the case readily admits of, the certificate of the governor ought to have applied to the individual who administered the oath. The propriety of this certainty and precision in a certificate, which is to authenticate, any affidavit to be introduced into a court of justice, is so generally admitted, that I do not recollect a single instance in which the principle has been departed from.
It has been said that it ought to appear, that there are two persons of the same name or the court will not presume such to be the fact. The court presumes nothing. It may or may not be the fact, and the court cannot presume that it is not. The argument grounds upon the idea that an instrument is to be disproved by him who objects to it, not that it is to be proved by him who offers it. Nothing can be more repugnant to the established usage of courts.
How is it to be proved that there are two persons of the name of Cenas in the territory of Orleans? If with a knowledge of several weeks, perhaps months, that this prosecution was to be carried on, the evidence ought not be required to produce this witness, ought the prisoner to be required with the notice of a few hours to prove that two persons of the same name reside in New-Orleans?
It has been repeatedly urged that a difference exists between the strictness of law which would be applicable to a trial in chief and that which is applicable to a motion to commit for trial.
Of the reality of this distinction, the present controversy affords conclusive proof. At a trial in chief, the accused possesses the valuable privilege of being confronted with his accusers. But there must be some limit to this relaxation, and it appears not to have extended so far as (to the admission of a paper, purporting to be an affidavit and not shown) to be one.
When it is asked, whether every man does not believe that this affidavit was really taken before a magistrate, (it is at once answered that this cannot effect the case.) Should a man of probity declare a certain fact within his own knowledge, he would be accredited by all who knew him; but this declaration could not be received as testimony by the judge, who firmly believed him. So a man might be believed to be guilty of a crime, but a jury could not convict him unless the testimony proved him to be guilty of it. The judicial disbelief of a probable circumstance does not establish a wide interval between common law and common sense—It is believed in this respect to show their intimate union.
The argument goes to this—that the paper shall be received and acted upon as an affidavit, not because the oath appears to have been administered according to law, but because it is probable that it was so administered.
This point seems to have been decided by the constitution.
"The right of the people," says that instrument "to be secure in their persons, houses papers and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated; and no warrant shall issue but upon probable cause supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the places to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.
The cause of seizure is not to be supported by a probable oath, or an oath that was probably taken, but by oath absolutely taken.
This oath must be a legal oath; and if it must be a legal oath, it must legally appear to the court to be so. This provision is not made for a final trial; it is made for the very case now under consideration. In the cool and temperate moments of reflection, undisturbed by that whirlwind of passion with which in those party conflicts which most generally produce acts or accusations of treason, the human judgement is sometimes overthrown, the people of America have believed the power even of commitment to be capable of much oppression in its execution to be placed without restriction, even in the hands of the national legislature. Shall a judge disregard those barriers which the nation has deemed it proper to erect?
The interest which the people have in this prosecution, has been stated, but it is firmly believed, that the best and true interest of the people is to be found in a rigid adherence to those rules, which preserve the fairness of criminal prosecutions in every stage.
If this was a case to be decided by principle alone the court would certainly not receive this paper. But if the point is settled by decisions, they must be conformed to.
It has been said to be settled in the Supreme Court of the United States by admitting the affidavit of Wilkinson, to which an exception was taken, because it did not appear that the magistrate had taken the oath prescribed by law. It was said, that as by law he could not act, until he had taken the oaths and he was found acting, it must be presumed that this prerequisite was complied with; that is, that his acting as a magistrate under his commission was evidence that he was authorised so to act.
It will not be denied that there is much strength in the argument; but the cases do not appear to be precisely parallel.
The certificate that he is a magistrate, and that full faith is due to his oath implies, that he has qualified....if his qualification is necessary to his being a complete magistrate, whose acts are entitled to full faith and credit.
It is not usual for a particular certificate that a magistrate has qualified to accompany his official acts.
There is no record of his qualification and no particular testimonial of it could certainly be obtained.
These observations do not apply to the objections which exist.
But it is said that the certificate is the same with that in Wilkinson's affidavit.
If this objection had been taken and overruled, it would have ended the question. But it was not taken so far as is now recollected, and does not appear to have been noticed by the court. It is not recollected by the judge who sat on that occasion to have been noticed. A defect, if it be one, which was not observed, cannot be cured by being passed over in silence.
The case in Washington was a civil case, and turned upon the point, that no form of the commission was prescribed, and consequently that it was not necessary to appear on the face of it, that it was directed to magistrates.
That it was the duty of the clerk to direct it to magistrates, and he should not be presumed to have neglected his duty, in a case in which his performance of it need not appear on the face of the instrument.
That the person intending to take this exception, ought to have taken it sooner, and not surprize the opposite party when it was too late to correct it.
But the great difference is, that the privy examination was a mere ministerial act—the administering an oath is a judicial act.
The court is of opinion that the paper purporting to be an affidavit made by Dunbaugh, cannot be read because it does not appear to be an oath.
Mr. Hay then observed that as the examination of col. Burr for treason had already taken up much time without being able to make any progress in the business, and from the disposition manifested by his counsel it might last not only ten days, but even ten years longer, he considered it his duty from information which he had received that morning, to suggest to the court the propriety of binding col. Burr in a further recognizance from day to day, till the examination could be ended. He stated on the authority of a letter just come to hand from the secretary at war, that general Wilkinson with several other witnesses might be expected here between the 28th and 30th of this month. This circumstance, said he, renders it essential that he should be considered in custody until he gives security that his person shall be forthcoming to answer the charges of treason against the United States.—The gentlemen who appear as counsel for col. Burr may be and no doubt are sincere in the opinion they have expressed, that he will not shrink from the charges exhibited against him and will not in any conjuncture of circumstances which may occur, fly from a trial; but those gentlemen must pardon me for saying that I entertain a very different opinion. I must believe that his regard for the safety of his own life would, if he perceived it in danger, prevail over his regard for the interest of his securities. I give notice, therefore, that I consider him as being already in custody to answer the motion I have made for his commitment, and that he cannot be permitted to go at large without giving security for his appearance from day to day. His situation now is the same as that when he was first apprehended and brought before a single judge for the purpose of examination. Your honour at that time considered him as in custody, and bound him over from day to day; and I only contend that the same course should be pursued at this time.
Mr. Wickham. The gentleman thinks he has obtained the effect of his motion merely by having made it. I cannot perceive the propriety of a motion to compel col. Burr to give bail in any sum before the probable cause to believe him guilty of treason has been shewn. When he was brought before your honour for examination, you conceived the sum of $5000 sufficient security for his daily appearance. But a recognizance has already been given in double that sum, binding him not to depart without the leave of this court. Yet now, although no probable proof of treason has been exhibited, Mr. Hay requires the court to demand of col. Burr additional security! I trust that such a motion will not prevail.
Mr. Martin. It has already been decided by the supreme court of the United States, that not a single expression in Wilkinson's affidavit amounts to any proof of the charge of treason. The motion of the gentleman amounts to this; we have no evidence of treason, and are not ready to go to trial for the purpose of proving it. We therefore move the court to increase the bail.
Mr. Randolph. The first motion of the counsel for the United States, was to commit col. Burr on the ground of probable cause only. This goes a step farther; and wishes the same thing to be done on the ground of a probable cause of probable cause. But we trust that we shall not be deprived of our liberty, or held to bail on a mere uncertain expectation of evidence.
Mr. M'Rae. The gentlemen seem to consider the recognizance already taken as sufficient for all circumstances, and that col. Burr will comply with it at any rate. But we have not the same expectation that he will appear in case he discovers that sufficient evidence for his conviction has been obtained. When they speak of the sum in which he was bound on a former occasion, they do not recollect the circumstance which induced the judge to take bail in so small a sum. It was expressly mentioned by your honour that his having been brought to a place at a distance from the circle of his friends, and the nature of the offence, (a misdemeanor only,) induced you to hold him to bail in that sum; and that the charge of treason was altogether excluded from view in taking the recognizance.
Mr. Wirt. Mr. Wickham, in saying that my friend Mr. Hay thought he had obtained the object of his motion merely by having made it, clearly misconceived the object of the motion now before the court. The motion we made yesterday was to commit col. Burr on a charge of treason; our motion to-day is to hold him in custody to abide the opinion which the court may pronounce upon the commitment. The gentlemen say that we have secured the object we have in view by the recognizance already taken. The court expressly excluded the charge of treason from that recognizance, which applies only to the misdemeanor. Let us suppose that the motion to commit col. Burr was made out of court before a single magistrate. If the examination of witnesses in support of the motion occupied more than one day, would the magistrate let him go at large, while it was depending? Would he not rather either have retained him in custody, or take security for his appearance, and renew it every evening until the motion should be determined? This is all that we now ask of the court to do. The recognizance which has been given applies to the misdemeanor only. If, therefore, it should be forfeited by his going away, we should have no security for his answering a charge of treason: a much more enormous offence, and attended with a very different punishment. We contend, therefore, that additional security ought to be taken.
Mr. Botts. I shall endeavour to place this subject in some measure in a new light. It has been said that the former examination of col. Burr did not preclude this motion. If so, every new edition of the volume of evidence would justify a renewal of the motion to demand additional bail. Thus motions might be heaped upon motions, and bail upon bail, until the perpetual imprisonment of the accused might be the consequence.
It was a practice in former times to drown a person accused of being a witch, in order to try her. I think that practise is renewed on the present occasion in another shape—A motion is made to commit col. Burr for treason. Before the evidence can be gone through by which alone it can be ascertained that he ought to be committed, the court are requested to predetermine the effect of the evidence, and commit, before they have decided whether they ought to commit. Besides no warrant has been issued against col. Burr on the present occasion. He has not been arrested for treason, and therefore cannot be considered as in custody for that offence.
Mr. Hay then made some further observations on the importance of the charge of treason, (which is of the highest nature, involving the reputation and life of the prisoner) and the necessity therefore of the most ample security to compel his appearance to answer it. He stated that this examination might last many days; that after the court had made up an opinion that col. Burr ought to be committed, he might march off, and leave the court to pronounce it; so that an order to commit might be made by the court, and no person found on whom it could be executed. Such an event, he said, would excite the laughter and scorn of all the people of the United States. He mentioned that an immense expense had been incurred by the government in collecting witnesses, and preparing for his trial;—that therefore he did not wish the whole of that expense to be thrown away. Gen. Wilkinson is expected to arrive between the 28th and 30th of this month. If he arrives, both the bills of indictment will be immediately sent to the grand jury. This is the first instance in which the ministers of the law have been requested to say to the accused, "you may do as you please, and go at large until we pronounce sentence." The gentlemen contend for new principles in favour of col. Burr; but, I trust, that greater privileges will not be granted to him than to the humblest deluded victim of his ambition.
The circumstance that he has already entered into a recognizance to answer for a misdemeanor, is no argument to exempt him from entering into another on a charge of treason. Shall the accused clear himself of a responsibility for one crime by his having committed another? This would indeed be to violate that maxim of law, that no man shall be benefitted by his own wrong. Mr. Botts has contended that there is a difference between the case on the examination and that now before the court; that in the first instance a warrant had been issued; but none in the present. But a warrant is certainly unnecessary, now that the prisoner is before the court. The object of a warrant is to bring him before you. When this has been done, it is functus officio. Here is col. Burr before the court. It is therefore immaterial how he came before it; but he ought to be considered in custody, until discharged by the due course of law.
The Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the court, the substance of which was as follows. It is certainly necessary that a person accused should be retained in custody, or required to give security for his appearance, while his examination is depending. The amount of the security to be required, must depend, however, upon the weight of the testimony against him. On a former occasion, col. Burr was held to bail for his daily appearance in the sum of five thousand dollars only, because there was no evidence before the judge to prove the probability of his having been guilty of treason. When the examination was completed, the sum of ten thousand dollars was considered sufficient to bind him to answer the charge of a misdemeanour only, because the constitution requires that excessive bail should not be taken; but that recognizance had no application to the charge of treason. Yet, whether additional security ought to be required in the present stage of this business, before any evidence has appeared to make the charge of treason probable, is a question of some difficulty. It would seem that evidence sufficient to furnish probable cause must first be examined before the accused can be deprived of his liberty, or any security can be required of him.—Yet before this could be done, he might escape and defeat the very end of the examination. In common cases, where a person charged with a crime is arrested and brought before a magistrate, the arrest itself is preceded by an affidavit, which furnishes grounds of probable cause. The prisoner therefore is continued in custody, or bailed until the examination is finished. But here there has been no arrest for treason, and col. Burr is not in custody for that offence. The evidence then must be heard to determine whether he ought to be taken into custody. But as the present publick and solemn examination is very different from that before a single magistrate; as very improper effects on the publick mind may be produced by it, I wish that the court could be relieved from the embarrassing situation in which it is placed, and exempted from the necessity of giving any opinion upon the case, previously to its being acted upon by the grand jury. It is the wish of the court that the personal appearance of col. Burr could be secured, without the necessity of proceeding in this inquiry.
Col. Burr rose, and observed that he denied the right of the court to hold him to bail in this stage of the proceedings; that the constitution of the United States was against it; declaring that no person shall be arrested without probable cause made out by oath or affirmation; but if the court were embarrassed he would relieve them by consenting to give bail; provided it should be understood that no opinion on the question even of probable cause was pronounced by the circumstance of his giving bail.
The Chief Justice said that such was the meaning of the court.
Mr. Martin said, for his part, he should prefer that all the evidence should be fully gone into. Instead of fearing that publick prejudice would thereby be excited against Col. Burr, he believed it would remove all the prejudices of that sort which now prevailed.
The Chief Justice. As a bill will probably be sent up to the Grand Jury, the court wishes to declare no opinion either way.
Some conversation then occurred relative to the quantum of bail; and Col. Burr mentioned that he would propose that the sum should be ten thousand dollars, if he should be able to find security to that amount, of which he expressed himself to be doubtful. Mr. Hay contended that 50,000 dollars would not be too much; but the court finally accepted of the offer made by col. Burr, who after a short interval entered into a recognizance with four securities, to wit, Messrs. Wm. Langburn, Thomas Taylor, John G. Gamble, and Luther Martin;—himself in the sum of ten thousand dollars, and each security in the sum of five thousand dollars, conditioned that he would appear to answer the charge of treason, and not depart without leave of the court.
Mr. Martin, when offered as a security for col. Burr, said he had lands in the district of Virginia, the value of which was more than double the sum; and that he was happy to have this opportunity to give a publick proof of his confidence in the honour of col. Burr, and of his conviction that he was innocent.
All farther proceedings in the case were thereupon postponed until the next day.
Friday, May 29.
The grand jury were called over, and again adjourned until Saturday morning ten o'clock, but gen. Wilkinson having not arrived, nothing else was done.
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 30 May 1807 · an extract
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.
The court debates whether an affidavit by Dunbaugh can be admitted, focusing on whether it was properly sworn as an oath versus a mere ministerial act. Discussion also covers Burr's continued liberty pending the examination and the expected arrival of General Wilkinson to testify.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
That the person intending to take this exception ought to have taken it sooner and not surprise the opposite party when it was too late to correct it.
But the great difference is, that the privy examination was a mere ministerial act--the administering an oath is a judicial act.
See moreSee less
The court is of opinion that the paper purporting to be an affidavit made by Dunbaugh, cannot be read, because it does not appear to be an oath.
Mr. Hay then addressed the court. It is extremely uncertain, how long this examination will continue; whether it may occupy ten hours or ten days: And if gentlemen continue to make the same captious objections which they have already done at every stage of the enquiry, it is impossible to foresee any termination to it. All this time, however, Aaron Burr is at liberty and he may depart
A prosecuting attorney argues that Aaron Burr should not be released on his own recognizance while the court deliberates on whether sufficient evidence of treason exists. He warns that General Wilkinson is expected to arrive soon with testimony, and that releasing Burr beforehand risks allowing him to flee before the grand jury can act.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Burr should be kept here to answer the decision of the court. This is no common case. It is one of immense importance; it has already imposed a great expense upon the public. I am informed by the secretary of war, that we may expect general Wilkinson between the 28th and 30th of this month. If he comes, the bills both for a misdemeanor and treason will certainly be laid before the grand jury. Will the court then positively decide, that col. Burr may in the mean time effect his escape? But if Wilkinson does arrive and if A. Burr does
The passage reports courtroom debate over whether Aaron Burr's prior bail for a lesser charge could protect him from being held on a new, more serious charge involving 'life itself'. Mr. Botts argues that Burr's custody status and the nature of the warrant mean he cannot claim prior recognizance as protection.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
prisonment for 3 months & a fine of 100 $. Shall then a recognizance for such an inferior crime afford him protection against another, where life itself is concerned? Mr. Botts stated that there was a difference between this and the former examination; that in the latter case, col. Burr was brought before you by a warrant; but that he is not really at this time before the court. But why was this warrant issued on a former examination? because col. Burr was not before the judge—it was necessary, but when that warrant was discharged it was void; it was functus officio.
See moreSee less
Col. Burr was in custody until he gave bail. It was immaterial how the accused man come before the magistrate; whether by warrant, by voluntary delivery or by the compulsion of
Prosecutor Hay denies persecuting Burr and insists there is sufficient evidence for the Grand Jury despite withholding indictments while awaiting further proof. Defense counsel Edmund Randolph responds by recounting Burr's treatment—military escort, affidavits, treason charge—arguing the prosecution's case has been weak and inconsistent.
The Enquirer · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
the light of truth and evidence will diffipate it. Why does he shrink? The gentlemen on the other fide, continued Mr. Hay, do not do us justice. They charge us with perfecution and oppreffion. Sir, I never contemplated or wished to hurt A. Burr. I fcorn it. I look not to him. I look only to the duties, which I am folemnly bound to perform.——One remark more, fir, and I have done: gentlemen on the other fide infift upon the infufficiency of our evidence. Becaufe we have withheld our indictments, from the Grand Jury, they have haftily inferred, that we feel our evidence to be too feeble to fatisfy the jury.
See moreSee less
They are miftaken, fir. I affure them, that they are miftaken. I confcienciously believe that we have evidence enough, even throwing out the depofitions themfelves, to fatisfy the Grand Jury of the guilt of A. Burr. But, fir, puerile indeed would it be for us under the prefent
This report records courtroom argument by Burr's defense counsel objecting to a judge demanding additional bail before the Grand Jury's treason indictment proceedings. The lawyer argues this is an unprecedented procedure that usurps the Grand Jury's constitutional function and risks biasing jurors against Burr.
The Enquirer · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
men call upon us for precedents. If we were asked for our reasons, sir; we should have enough to offer. And first, a judge in the Federal Court, sitting in the capacity which your honor now fulfils, would be in the same relation to the accused as an examining Judge is in the state courts. But, sir, whoever invited a single magistrate or a state court to augment the bail of any individual in the situation of Col. Burr? If a man be
A defense speaker (apparently Randolph) argues in court, criticizing Jefferson's prejudicial statements about Burr's guilt and the harsh treatment Burr received during his arrest and transport from the Mississippi Territory. He questions the jurisdiction of the court and describes Burr being guarded by armed soldiers and denied communication with his daughter.
The Enquirer · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
tion. When I look at the fecond, fir, he has my whole heart. But, fir, the enquiry which is now before us relates not fo much to the intention as to the effect. An order has been given to treat Colonel B. as an outlaw; and to burn him and his property. And, fir, again, when the H. of R. demanded certain information, as it was their right and their duty to do; the Prefident granted it; and would to God! Sir, that he had ftopped here, as an executive officer ought to have done.
See moreSee less
He proceeded, however, to fay that Col. Burr was guilty of a crime; and confequently to exprefs an opinion, which was calculated to operate judicially upon the Judges and the Juries. Such, was the fubftratum of all the cenfures, which have been heaped upon Col. Burr. Mr. R. proceeded to touch upon a fubject,
The Virginia Argus publishes a debate from May 25 on prosecutor Hay's motion to commit Aaron Burr for high treason, including objections from defense counsel Wickham and Tazewell about lack of notice and evidence procedure. The paper explains it withheld this material earlier but now includes it since other local papers had already printed it.
Virginia Argus · 3 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
MONDAY, May 25 Debate on the motion to commit Col. Aaron Burr for High Treason. After the grand jury had withdrawn, (see last column, 3d page of the Argus of May 27) Mr. Hay renewed his motion in the following words:--"I now move the court to commit Mr. Burr on a charge of high treason against the United States, on
A passage describing Aaron Burr's appearance in court and complaints about his treatment by the government, followed by legal arguments between counsel over whether proper notice was given for a motion to commit. The exchange involves the Chief Justice, defense counsel Wickham, and prosecutor Hay debating procedural fairness regarding grand jury indictment notice.
Virginia Argus · 3 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
sition must be held. I will not weary out the patience of the court. I sit down in anxious solicitude that the success of the motion may not add to the catalogue of Col. Burr's grievances. The Chief Justice supposed that it was
Lawyers debate whether to send up the treason indictment against Aaron Burr without General Wilkinson present, with one side arguing his absence could prejudice the case. The grand jury reconvenes but is informed Wilkinson has still not arrived, though new affidavits from witnesses near Natchez and Blennerhassett's Island have been received.
Virginia Argus · 3 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
gentleman should be here; it is important to his own reputation; it is important to the people of the U. S. that he should be here; and on the part of the Grand Jury. Sir, there is no calculating what inferences, unfavorable to the prosecution might be drawn from the mere circumstance of his absence. The attorney is therefore in my opinion very right not to hazard the justice and the fair trial of this case, by sending up the indictment in Gen. Wilkinson's absence.
But it seems that Wilkinson's affidavit has been already decided to have no relation to the charge of treason. To what Gen. Wilkinson's affidavit tended while it was inomulated, or connected only with that of Gen. Eaton, is no proof of what its tendency may be now in connexion with the great mass of additional testimony which we have collected. Sir, we say that it is the key stone which binds the great arch of evidence now in our possession.
See moreSee less
As to sending up the indictment, it is out of the question. Truth and justice require that it should not now be sent up. But we hope, sir, that the motion to commit Aaron Burr will be received, because we think it a legal measure and a just and necessary measure of precaution.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
On May 26, the grand jury in Aaron Burr's case asked the court for discharge, having been empaneled several days without producing indictments. The court and counsel agreed to delay dismissal until General Wilkinson, expected within ten days, could provide key evidence, with the jury to reconvene the following week.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR
We shall be glad of a discharge.
Mr. Hay hoped that the court would not discharge them : he should perhaps have two indictments to send up to them in the course of the week. The council for the prosecution and the prisoner have agreed, that it is better not to do so, until all the important evidence which is to be exhibited, has been actually obtained. General Wilkinson has certainly left New Orleans; and may be expected within ten days, and at the largest calculation, before the rising of the court. Should he be how-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A defense attorney argues against a motion that would have the court itself examine and commit Burr, rather than leaving that duty to the grand jury as constitution and law require. He contends only probable cause of suspicion exists against Burr, that arrest and bail are incompatible with mere summons, and criticizes Judge Chase's earlier practice of awarding a capias in a similar case.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
This novel mode of proceeding, if carried into effect, would give the attorney for the U. S. the chance of procuring an opinion from the court unfavorable to Col. Burr—failing in that case he would then betake himself
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This passage records courtroom argument, likely from Burr's treason trial, debating a motion concerning bail and commitment for treason. Counsel dispute the applicability of an Act of Assembly regarding bail timelines, with one side arguing Burr has not yet been committed for treason, making the cited law inapplicable to the motion at hand.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
"When any person committed for treason"—Now, sir, is Aaron Burr committed for treason? If not, it is obvious that the clause has no manner of application to him. Why, sir, the object of this motion is to commit him. Gentlemen must have been in strange confusion when they resorted to this law. Mr. Wickham asks if general Wilkinson be a material witness, why he is not here? "Who is general Wilkinson?" says that gentleman—is he not the instrument of the government bound to a blind obedience?" I am sorry for this and many other declamatory remarks which have been unnecessarily & improperly introduced; but the gentleman assures us that no imputation is meant against the government.
See moreSee less
Oh no, sir, col. Burr, indeed, has been oppressed; has been persecuted; but far be it from the gentleman to charge the government with it. Col. Burr, indeed, has been harrassed by a military tyrant who is "the instrument of the government, bound to a blind obedience:" but the gentleman could not by any means
The grand jury has been sent home temporarily, set to reconvene in Richmond the following Tuesday, with General Wilkinson not yet arrived. The report notes disputes over whether Wilkinson will testify, confirms the loss of the cipher letter from a respected source, and criticizes the prosecution for causing delays while condemning what it calls persecution of Burr.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Col. Burr's Trial
THE PUBLICK LEDGER.
FRIDAY EVENING, JUNE 5, 1807.
See moreSee less
Mr. Purviance, Secretary of Legation at London, has arrived from Washington with dispatches of the government for our Ministers and Commissioners Extraordinary at the Court of St. James's, with which he will proceed immediately on board the Wasp sloop of war, capt. Smith.
The Chesapeake frigate arrived in Hampton Roads last evening.
The Cybelle, French frigate, came up from Hampton Roads, into the bite of Crany Island, on Wednesday evening.
Col. Burr's Trial.—Nothing further has been done since what was detailed in our last, except that the grand jury have been permitted to return to their respective homes, under an engagement to be in Richmond again on Tuesday next. General Wilkinson had not arrived on Wednesday. From every thing which we can learn, col. Burr and his counsel are extremely anxious to come to trial, and that all the delay is from the counsel for the prosecution. Opinions are different respecting the attendance of general Wilkinson, some affirming that
The paper reprints speeches by prosecutor Hay and Colonel Burr from the ongoing trial, while editorializing that attempts to punish Burr threaten the Constitution and laws more than they harm him personally. It also includes unrelated news about the British capture of Monte Video.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
(not only avowing it openly, but lamenting that he had not succeeded in his attempt) enjoying publick confidence, we conclude there is something wrong, which no efforts of ours can remedy. We take no interest in the case of col. Burr; but as the attempts to punish him have affected the laws and liberties of our country. Those, and those only, are the objects of our solicitude, if they are violated, and trampled under foot in order to punish Colonel Burr; the injury to the individual will be soon for-
The report covers courtroom proceedings on May 25, where the grand jury briefly returned before adjourning, followed by prosecutor Hay's address accusing Aaron Burr of high treason and levying war against the United States. Hay denies Burr's claims of persecution and insists the charges will be proven through legal process.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. Monday, May 25. Continuation of the debate on Mr. Hay's motion to commit col. Burr.
At this moment the grand jury returned into court, and their names being called over, requested an adjournment. After some desultory conversation between their foreman and the chief justice, respecting certain points of form, they were accordingly adjourned till to-morrow 10 o'clock.—They immediately retired from the court, when Mr. Hay arose to address the court. He spoke in substance as follows:
See moreSee less
I stand here, sir, engaged in the performance of a serious duty. I appear here in a cause which involves the character of our government. I come here to charge Aaron Burr with High Treason against the United States; with "levying war" upon his country. Sir, it was natural to suppose, that such a serious charge would have made a most serious impression upon the mind of A. Burr; that he would have roused all the energies of his understanding in his service; in vindicating himself against such heinous charges, and not in casting imputations upon the government. Why then, sir, does he turn from himself against the administration? Why these complaints of persecution which have fatigued our ears? I most solemnly deny the charge. I most confidently avow, that there is not a tittle of evidence to support it. None can be pro-
Aaron Burr addresses the court, arguing that vigilance against government overreach is especially needed during prosecutions, citing the disproportion of means between the state and the accused. He details alleged persecutions including military seizure of his friends, compelled testimony, seized papers, an order to kill him on the Mississippi, and broken-open post offices.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
certainly sir, shall not be charged with declamation. But surely it is an established principle, sir, that no government is so high as to be beyond the reach of criticism. And it is more particularly laid down, that this vigilance is more peculiarly necessary, when any government institutes a prosecution, and one reason is, on account of the vast disproportion of means which exists between it and the accused. But if ever there was a case which justified this vigilance, it is certainly, the present one when the government has displayed such uncommon activity.
See moreSee less
If then this government has been so peculiarly active against me, it is not improper to make the assertion here, for the purpose of increasing the circumspection of the court. Mr. Burr observed, that he meant by persecution the harassing of any individual contrary to the forms of law: and
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the ongoing delays in the Burr treason trial proceedings in Richmond, with the Grand Jury repeatedly adjourning and Mr. Hay explaining the lack of new evidence against General Wilkinson. A separate account describes a supposed prosecution witness who was caught trying to incite enslaved people to arm themselves, casting doubt on the credibility of witnesses being gathered against Burr.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Monday, June 1. Present, Chief Justice Marshall. The Grand Jury met at 2 o'clock; and were adjourned till to morrow 10 o'clock. Mr Hay observed, that it was extremely disagreeable for him to detain the Grand Jury; but he knew of no better expedient under existing circumstances; that he had received no new information respecting General Wilkinson; and that the only new communications which he had received by the last western mail, was a mass of affidavits from Chilicothe, drawn up by persons who had descended the river with col. Burr, and that though their affidavits were extremely important, they could not be brought into court as evidence, there being no evidence that the person before whom they were taken was really a magistrate.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 26 June 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
A witness for the prosecution who made exaggerated claims about freeing slaves and commanding wealth fled before he could be apprehended, raising doubts about witness credibility in the Burr case. Editorial exchanges between Virginia and Kentucky papers debate General Wilkinson's conduct and whether evidence against him should be withheld until after Burr's trial.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The following extraordinary, and we think, illiberal observations are from the Western World of Kentucky of the 7th of May. The editor of that paper believes that colonel Burr will be able to prove that general Wilkinson holds a Spanish commission, and still he is willing that col. Burr should be convicted on the oath of a traitor; for he says "we are willing to withold them [meaning the testimony against Wilkinson] until after the trial of Burr." This is carrying the persecution against col. Burr which originated in Kentucky, and has been followed up by the executive of the union, to a degree of which we did not believe the human heart was capable, and which the most inveterate revenge alone could have dictated.
See moreSee less
That the editor of the Western World can have no cause of enmity against col. Burr we are convinced; but it is probable from the strictures that frequently appear in his paper, that he is the humble tool of certain individuals who would sacrifice every species of justice in order to gratify their own spleen. Vir. Gaz. "We had proposed to have given in this and the succeeding numbers, some strictures on the conduct of gen. Wilkinson; but the avidity with which the friends of colonel Burr avail themselves of the unconstitutional acts of a lawless tyrant, to justify him, has determined us to withold them until after the trial of Burr. That the conduct of Wilkinson has been unconstitutional and highly improper cannot be controverted, upon any principles of justice or right: and we confidently trust, that, abjuring the error into which he has been led by the insiduous intrigues of a man, hacknied in every species of deception, the executive will cause an inquiry to be made, not only into the official conduct of general Wilkinson at New-Orleans; but will demand an
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper
This report covers the Circuit Court proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, including a motion by the U.S. attorney to commit Burr on high treason charges and his rejection of a bail compromise. It also notes the start of grand jury selection before Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin, with Burr objecting to how jurors were summoned.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 5 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Trial of Col. Burr
for what are we enduring these hardships, at this distance from our own country? The reflection must damp their ardor. It is not to secure France, but to gratify the ambition of an Alexander. Duroc is said to be sent home in disgrace. If this be true, he is not alone in sentiment. To express disaffection would be the extreme of folly in a solitary individual.
Much is said of the preparations of Austria. We do not believe that Austria will assume an avowedly hostile position, unless Bonaparte should be evidently discouraged. Even in that case, what could they do? If Bonaparte finds the Russians unconquerable, he will be glad of an opology to quit them, and on Austria he would wreak his vengeance. With such an army he would leave the country through which he should pass, with scarcely the means of supporting its own population. This would be a great security against pursuit. The Austrians would be again compelled to meet him unassisted. They must feel adequate to this, before they will avow themselves his enemies.
See moreSee less
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
On Saturday nothing of moment occurred at the trial. The bill had not been sent up to the grand jury, and of course nothing was done. On Monday the 25th, a motion was made in court by the United States attorney, to commit Col. Burr on the charge of high treason, and an offer was made to introduce additional evidence, to shew probable cause for commitment. The motion was opposed by Col. Burr and his counsel, in an able and a masterly manner. They contended that in the present stage of the business it would be improper on many accounts and for obvious reasons, which will more fully appear in the details and the court adjourned at 5 P. M.—On Tuesday the court gave an opinion in favor of the United States attorney's right to make such a motion, and were prepared to hear evidence. None however was offered, and the criminal business was postponed until Wednesday.
In the mean time propositions were made for compromising. The U. S. attorney would withdraw this motion if col. Burr would find bail to a satisfactory amount, and he might go at large tho' committed for High Treason, and to be tried at the next term. This proposition was rejected by col. Burr with contempt.
We received at a late hour last evening the Virginia Argus, containing a long and interesting detail of the proceeding of the Circuit Court in the case of Aaron Burr, which shall be given in our next—contenting ourselves at present with the following outlines.
The proceedings of Friday only are given.
Chief justice Marshall and Judge Griffin presided.
Eighteen of the grand jury having answered to their names, col. Burr stated an objection to the manner in which they had been summoned, in consequence of which, after argument, Mr. Barbour and Dr. Fouchee were withdrawn.
Col. Burr then challenged William B. Giles and Wilson Carey Nicholas, the former on account of his vote in the Senate on suspending the Habeas Corpus, and the subsequent expression of an opinion; and the latter on the ground of personal enmity. Both these gentlemen were likewise withdrawn.
The following gentlemen were then sworn on the grand jury:
John Randolph, Foreman,
Jos. Eggleston, L. W. Tazewell, Robert Taylor, William Daniel, jun. John Mercer, Edward Pegram, Mumford Beverly, John Ambler, Thomas Harrison, Joseph C. Cabell, James Pleasants, Jun. John Brockenbrough, Alexander Shepherd, James Barbour, and James M. Garnett.
The Chief Justice then charged the jury, when a discussion ensued on a proposition, to instruct the jury with respect to the admissibility of certain evidence which it was supposed would be offered on the part of the U. States, which was not finished on Friday.
Gen. Wilkinson had not arrived.
Nat. Int.
A circular letter from Tobias Lear, esq. dated Tunis, 1st March, 1807.
SIR,
I have the honor and satisfaction to inform you, that the differences which existed between the U. S. of America and the regency of Tunis, and which, on the departure of the Tunisian ambassador from the U. S. threatened to terminate in a rupture between the two nations; are now happily and honorably settled. And the commercial intercourse between the ci
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 29 May 1807 · an extract
Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.
The report describes District Court proceedings in Richmond where U.S. Attorney Hay moved to commit Aaron Burr on a charge of high treason, fearing Burr might flee if General Wilkinson's impending arrival became known. Burr's counsel opposed the motion, arguing it was improper for the court to weigh in while the Grand Jury was still deliberating the same evidence.
Herald of the United States · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
STATE OF NEW-YORK.
NEW-YORK, JUNE 1.
See moreSee less
THE papers by the Southern and Eastern mails yesterday, are barren of news. We have anticipated the following of Colonel BURR, from the Richmond ENQUIRER, of Tuesday last:—
"The proceedings of the District Court on Monday were extremely interesting.
Mr. HAY, (attorney of the U. S.) declared that he should not for several days send up his indictments to the Grand Jury, unless Gen. Wilkinson made his appearance; and that in case he did not appear, he should then determine on the course he ought to pursue.—The Grand Jury was adjourned till Tuesday 12 o'clock.
Mr. HAY moved the court, to commit A. BURR on a charge of High Treason against the U. States. He declared that the reason of this motion was founded on a possibility of Mr. B's flying from the law, in case he should be positively informed that Gen. Wilkinson was on his way to Richmond, unless he was committed for treason, and detained by higher bail; and that he believed the evidence he was now to bring forward, in addition to what had been adduced on the examination of A. Burr, was sufficient to induce the Judge to grant the commitment. He therefore removed, that evidence should be heard on behalf of this motion.—
Mr. BURR's counsel opposed this motion, principally on the ground
At the Richmond circuit court, prosecutor Hay sought to present evidence in chronological order regarding Burr's treason and misdemeanor charges. Defense counsel Wickham objected, insisting the prosecution must first strictly prove an overt act of treason before any other evidence could be admitted.
The Enquirer · 6 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR.
WEDNESDAY, May 27.
Mr. Hay stated to the Court, that all hopes of the arrangement which he had mentioned yesterday, were at an end; for he had received a letter from Col. Burr's counsel, positively refusing to give any additional bail:—that he should therefore go on with his motion for commitment.—He observed, that he was ready to proceed with the evidence, in laying which before the Court, he should observe something like a chronological order. He should read first the depositions of such witnesses, as were absent; and afterwards bring up such witnesses as were present, in such an order as to disclose all the events as they successively arose.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham stated that there were two distinct charges against Col. Burr; the first was a charge of misdemeanor, for which Col. B. had already entered into recognizance.—The other was a charge of High Treason against the U. S.; which was once proposed without success and is now again repeated. On this charge the U. States must substantiate two essential points: 1st: that there was an overt act committed; and 2ndly that Col. Burr was concerned in it.—Every thing that does not bear upon
Counsel debate procedural rules about whether the prosecution must first prove an overt act of treason before presenting further evidence. The argument also touches on the connection between the alleged plots to seize New Orleans and invade Mexico.
The Enquirer · 6 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The two charges which are brought against Aaron Burr, are naturally and intimately blended. They form distinct parts of one great design. What that great design was, in all its bearings and ramifications, I am not absolutely certain. But I have always conceived, that before Mexico was invaded, New-Orleans was to be taken. How then is it possible to separate these two great allegations? This monstrous design consists of two great plots; both going on together; and both so strongly connected, that accomplishing the one is preparatory to accomplishing the other.
See moreSee less
If A. Burr's object was to plant his standards in Mexico, he was first to have seized the shipping and Banks of New-Orleans. We ask then, how can we separate line by line, and word by word, the evidence produced to prove these two distinct allegations. The designs are connected: and the evidence is connected. Mr. Burr rose to speak; when Mr Hay proceeded to the following effect: I have a little
A defense attorney argues that General Wilkinson's personal testimony, rather than his affidavit, should be required since circumstances now allow for better evidence than when the case began. The argument focuses on legal principles regarding treason charges, insisting that no evidence should be admitted until an actual levying of war in Virginia is first proven by two witnesses.
The Enquirer · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
ference from gen. Wilkinson's affidavit, that Col. Burr was the writer of the letter in cypher. If the witnefs was here he would impugn that inference by fwearing that it was not in Col. Burr's hand writing. If general
The passage presents legal argument that treason requires an actual levying of war, not merely intentions, and that the overt act must be proven within the specific judicial district. It cites constitutional provisions and legal authorities to argue that General Wilkinson's testimony about intentions is insufficient evidence of treasonous acts.
The Enquirer · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
But of intentions which are not evidence of acts. 2dly: The war must not only have been levied, but Col. Burr must be proved to have committed an overt act of treason in that war. A treasonable intention to co-operate is no evidence of an actual co-operation. The acts of others even if in pursuance of his plan, would be no evidence against him. It might not be necessary that he should be present perhaps; but he must be, at the time of levying the war, co-operating by acts; or in the language of the constitution, be committing overt acts.
See moreSee less
The acts of associates in a treasonable plan, in countries where the doctrine of constructive war prevails, can never be given in evidence against the accused until after the plan has been
This passage presents a legal argument concerning whether treason requires proof of an overt act within the specific district where the trial is held, and whether intention alone can constitute treason without contemporaneous action. The speaker argues against allowing a defendant to be tried repeatedly in different states for what is essentially one crime, invoking constitutional protections against double jeopardy.
The Enquirer · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
one out of 100 parts of a crime would be a crime within the meaning of the constitution. Let us view the consequences of this logic. Upon proof against Col. Burr touching a crime part of which was committed in this district, he may be tried and acquitted. In Ohio
The grand jury informed the court they found no presentment against Burr but would remain available; they were adjourned until Tuesday. Prosecutor Hay then rose to begin his argument, noting the gravity and delicacy of the proceedings concerning the character of the government.
Virginia Argus · 6 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF Col. Aaron Burr.
MONDAY, May 25. Present the Chief Justice of the United States and Cyrus Griffin, District Judge.
See moreSee less
Continuation of the Debate on the motion made by Mr Har, on Monday the 25th
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
A defense speaker argues against granting a continuance of Burr's trial on grounds that the prosecution is waiting for General Wilkinson to arrive from New Orleans. He calculates travel times to argue Wilkinson should already be present, and objects to proceeding without the grand jury's proper role in the investigation.
Virginia Argus · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
elapsed, and no testimony has been collected.---Wilkinson's deposition contains an improbable, mysterious tale, about a Key and Cypher: Mr. W. said that he would not at present expose this transaction; but does this mysterious tale constitute treason? "You, sir, have already decided that there is no treason, in Wilkinson's deposition; but were the man himself in court, what could he establish further than his deposition can do?"
Mr. Hay is satisfied, that he has sufficient evidence to convict Col. Burr. No man doubts his ability, or his inclination to discharge his duty. Why then does he not lay his indictments before the jury? Because there happens to be a man in New-Orleans, and one perhaps in the East-Indies; and therefore "to make assurance doubly sure," he must wait for their appearance. And all this too, whilst the gentleman most seriously protest against oppression and delay. Tho' the gentleman may not be conscious of such a sentiment, as that of wishing to oppress Col. Burr, there must still be something like it in his heart: But whatever may the motive, the result to ourselves is the same. It produces delay and all its consequent oppressions.---No court should sanction this proceeding. This case is like that of a man whose cause stands for trial. When subpoenas after subpoenas have been issued; when sums after sums have been expended; he moves for a continuance of his suit. At the very same time he insists uppon the sufficiency of his evidence. Surely the court would rule him to trial.
See moreSee less
Why is not the attorney for the United States ready for trial? He has indeed made a computation of time to shew that Wilkinson could not have been here before this period; and he has besides introduced an affidavit to show that an express was on his way to Orleans to give him an early summons. There is, however, nothing in proof that the drawer of this affidavit was not imposed on by this express; or that the express himself was not mistaken as to the contents of his dispatches. And how stands the computation as to time? The post goes from Washington to New-Orleans in 17 days. Mr. Rodney left this city in the last of March. The express must therefore have reached New-Orleans about the 20th of April; and yet where is Wilkinson? Though the Missippi runs down to New-Orleans, and opposes a strong current to those who ascend
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 10 June 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.
This report records courtroom argument, likely by Burr's defense counsel, debating whether the grand jury must be present and whether Wilkinson's delayed arrival should affect the proceedings. The speaker contends the prosecution is stalling and defends Burr against claims of persecution, while discussing legal principles about jury investigation and recognizance.
Virginia Argus · 6 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
ponement of this trial and for want of evidence on their part, we might properly contend that Col. Burr, if bound to bail at all, should be held in a smaller recognizance than at present. But we shall wave
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Attorneys Randolph, McRae, and Wirt argue before the court about whether probable evidence of treason exists against Aaron Burr and whether his current recognizance is sufficient to ensure his appearance at trial. The prosecution contends Burr may flee and that his bail was set for a lesser offense, not for the high treason charge now at issue.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF Col. AARON BURR.
cumstances, to detain Aaron Burr here to answer to the charge of treason. I am of a very different opinion. I think with the Attorney for the U.S. that no-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Attorneys Wickham and Wirt debate before the court whether Aaron Burr's current recognizance (bail bond) is sufficient to hold him on a treason charge or only covers a lesser misdemeanor. Wirt argues the current bond's wording addresses only the misdemeanor offense, not treason, and that a separate, more substantial bond would be needed if Burr is to be examined on the treason charge.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
even then it was evidently for a very small sum; and why? Because the Chief Justice himself observed that as Col. Burr was withdrawn from the circle of his friends, it would increase the difficulty of his obtaining even a small bail even for this smaller offence; & because he completely excluded from his view the present charge. As then he decided, that this sum in which col. Burr is now bound is a smaller one than the charge of High Treason would have warranted; it seems to me that too great reliance is placed upon the present recognizance.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wirt begged leave to make a few remarks on this subject, though he had not so fully prepared himself as he would have wished, because he had not expected that it would provoke such discussion: Mr. Wickham appears not to have understood this subject with his usual correctness, when he declares that the granting of this motion would have the very same effect as granting the motion for commitment. What is the object of this last motion? To commit A. Burr for high treason. But the object of this present motion is merely to keep his person here to abide the opinion of the court: The other was to keep him for trial. The effect therefore is widely different; and we should not, as Mr. Wickham contended, thus gain our point. He supposes too that the present recognizance will hold A. Burr to answer the charge of treason. But if he looks at the terms of the bond, it will at once appear that it is a recognizance only for a misdemeanor, and not as the customary form is, to appear to answer for that or any other crime which may be brought against him. This recognizance may therefore be sufficient as to the misdemeanor; but not on the charge of treason. It is perfectly immaterial that the present motion is brought before the court. It is precisely the same thing as if it were brought before the same judge in his own cham-
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 19 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Defense counsel (Potts and Baa) argue in court that Aaron Burr should not be required to post additional bail for the high treason charge, since his existing recognizance from the misdemeanor examination is sufficient. They criticize the prosecution's logic as backwards, comparing it to witch trials where the punishment is inflicted before guilt is proven.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MONDAY, JUNE 8, BURR.
pearance on this distinct original motion?
Mr. Botts observed that the strange principle advocated by the prosecution was, that the former examination did not at all preclude the present motion. But if this be true, what would be the consequence? That every edition of the volume of evidence might justify a new enquiry. No warrant has been issued for the apprehension of col. Burr; and of course he did not stand in the same predicament, as on the former occasion. The counsel for the prosecution seemed to have profited by one of the fashions of old times; when they wanted to try a witch. If she swam, she was of course condemned to death; if she was drowned, she was to be acquitted: And thus in the very experiment of deciding whether she was guilty of a crime, they inflicted upon her the very punishment, which belonged to that crime. In the same manner col. Burr is to sustain the same punishment, while enquiring whether he deserves it, as would only have resulted from the most unfavorable decision. Let us suppose a case; were I to suggest to this court, that some person present has been guilty of a crime, as the attorney for the U. S. has done; would the court think itself justified upon the credit of my bare word to bind over that person for his examination? I presume not. Col. Burr is already bound by his recognizance: This recognizance is sufficient to keep him here, until the court may discharge him. If he departs, the penalty is of course estreated.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay. A few remarks only, sir! This is a discussion which at the time I certainly could not have expected. Mr. Burr stands here charged with high treason. The evidence will take a con-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers
Aaron Burr is placed under a $10,000 recognizance with sureties to appear before the court, while the grand jury repeatedly adjourns because General Wilkinson has not yet arrived to testify. The prosecutor explains delays and asks the jury's patience, with debate also noted on a motion to commit Burr on the charge of treason.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Burr. One word more: An idea has struck me since I last addressed the court, which I consider as of some importance. It is in all cases difficult to graduate the bail to the extent of an individual's fortune. But as to my fortune, it is destroyed: It is in the hands of the government. I know not whether in this place I could obtain credit for any thing; no, not for a single dollar; if I was trusted for my fortune alone.
Chief Justice after consulting with Mr. Griffin, gave it as the decision of the court, that Col. Burr should be bailed for 20,000 dollars more; himself in the sum of 10,000, and his securities in the same sum. So that the whole amount of bail, inclusive of the first recognizance, should be 40,000 dollars.
See moreSee less
Mr. Burr. I will then offer three of my former securities and Mr. Martin.
Mr. Martin. I hold landed property in the district of Virginia to twice the amount of the sum, for which I am to be bailed. And I am happy to give this public proof of my confidence in the integrity and innocence of Mr. Burr.
Messrs. Martin, Langhorne, Taylor, and Gamble, were the securities to this new recognizance; and were of course bound respectively in the sum of 2,500 dollars each.
Order of the Court.
This day came the attorney for the U. S. and A. Burr, and by consent of the said Aaron Burr: It is considered, that he enter into a recognizance in the sum of 10,000 dols, and give one or more securities in the like sum, with condition for his personal appearance before this court on to-morrow, then & there to answer such charges as shall be exhibited against him on behalf of the U. S. and not to depart without the leave of the said court. Whereupon the said Aaron Burr entered into recognizance in the penal sum of 10,000 dols. and Luther Martin, Wm. Langhorne, Thomas Taylor, and John Gamble, jun. in the sum of 2,500 dols. each.
The court adjourned till to-morrow, at 10 o'clock.
FRIDAY. The jury met at 10 o'clock—and were immediately adjourned till this day, (Saturday) 9 o'clock.—This early hour was chosen to suit the convenience of such of the jurors, as might wish to visit their families.
It is understood, that the attorney for the U. S. will not lay his indictments before the present grand jury before the arrival of gen. Wilkinson.
SATURDAY, May 30.
General Wilkinson failing still to appear, nothing was done this day relative to the trial of Colonel Aaron Burr.
MONDAY, June 1.
The grand jury having been called over, Mr. Hay observed that he felt great embarrassment and difficulty as to the course which ought to be pursued. He had confidently expected the arrival of General Wilkinson, and was disappointed. He was therefore unwilling to subject the grand jury to the inconvenience of farther attendance:—but he thought it proper to inform the court that he had this morning received a number of affidavits of witnesses residing in the neighborhood of Chilicothe and of Blannerhasset's island, which bore directly upon the charge of treason against Col. Burr. Those affidavits, however, had been taken in such a manner that according to the opinion lately given by the court concerning the affidavit of Jacob Dunbaugh, they were not admissible as evidence, and would not be permitted to be read. He expected to hear from General Wilkinson (if he should not appear in person) by the Lynchburg mail; which he understood would arrive on Wednesday morning. He therefore hoped that the grand jury would not be unwilling to make a farther sacrifice of a portion of their time for the public good, and would consent to wait with patience.
The grand jury were adjourned until Tuesday ten o'clock.
TUESDAY, June 2.
The grand jury were called and attended, but (General Wilkinson not having arrived) were again adjourned until Wednesday morning ten o'clock.
WEDNESDAY, June 3.
On this day it is expected the grand jury will be discharged, and the motion to commit Col. Burr on the charge of treason renewed; in support of which the evidence will be examined; and, very interesting debates on both sides may be expected.
MONDAY, May 25.
Continuation of the Debate, on Mr. Hay's motion to commit Aaron Burr.
At this moment the grand jury returned into court, & their names being called over requested an adjournment. After some desultory conversation between their Foreman and the Chief Justice, respecting certain points of form, they were accordingly adjourned till to morrow 10 o'clock.—They immediately retired from the court, when Mr. Hay arose to proceed with the argument.—He spoke, in substance as follows.
I stand here, sir, engaged in the performance of a most serious duty. I appear here in a cause, which involves the character of our government. I come here to charge Aaron Burr with High Treason against the U. S. with "levying war" upon his country. Sir, it was natural to suppose, that such a serious charge would have made a most serious impression upon A. B's mind; that he would have roused all the energies of his understanding in his service; in vindicating himself against such heinous charges, and not in casting imputations upon the government. Why then, sir, does he turn from himself against the administration. Why these complaints of persecution, which have fatigued our ears! I most solmnly deny the charge. I most confidently avow, that there is not a tittle of evidence to support it. None can be produced, unless it be a persecution, that the government brings him before a legal tribunal, where his guilt and innocence will be impartially established. A. Burr stands accused of the highest crimes and misdemeanors; he stands charged with a deliberate design of involving his country in all the horrors of civil insurrection, or of entangling her in a war with a foreign nation. This is the true question before the court, and instead of meeting this charge with the energy and firmness which became him; instead of confronting it with his evidence; he complains forsooth of persecution. And where, sir, is this tremendous persecution?
"Because he was sent here by a military authority"? But could A. Burr have been tried in the country where he was arrested? Was Blannerhassett's Island in the Mississippi Territory? Or ought he not to have been conveyed to that judicial district, which possessed a competent jurisdiction? But if A. Burr ought to have been sent here, by what number of men should he have been escorted? Was it by one man only; from whom he could have been so easily rescued, and whose vigilance he could most probably have eluded? Or ought he to have been conveyed, as he really was, by the energy of men, like Perkins, whose unshrinking firmness and whose humanity (in the presence of A. Burr himself, I avow it, let him deny it, if he can!) had completely qualified him for the safe transportation of his prisoner?
But, sir, when this cry and spell of persecution are once excited, it is not easy to set bounds to its fury? Not contented with inveighing against the pretended persecution of the government—a government, which never did persecute—a government which cannot persecute, and which will for ever stand firm in the affections of the people, from the integrity and intelligence which mark its measures—not contented with lavishing their complaints against it, the counsel for the prisoner have even turned against the humble instruments, who conduct the prosecution. They seriously complain, that we have given them no previous notice of this motion—and these are the very men, who have so often offered motions to this court, without the slightest intimation to ourselves—Sir, I most positively assert, that no notice in the present case ought to have been given. I shall not pretend to assert, that A. Burr, was disposed under the present state of things, to effect his escape: But I say, that supposing such to have been the fact, and supposing that, availing himself of the information which we had imparted, he should have taken to flight; I appeal to the candor of every impartial man; I appeal to the opposite counsel themselves, whether I should not have been guilty of a most gross violation of my duties.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The trial of Col. Burr commenced before Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin, with disputes over the Marshal's authority to summon and replace jurors. After challenges and withdrawals, a grand jury was finally empaneled with John Randolph as foreman.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
COL. BURR'S TRIAL
originally been summoned to attend, in consequence of satisfactory excuses; and added two others in their stead—but the court decided that they had been illegally added to the pannel, and were therefore withdrawn.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The passage describes jury selection for Burr's trial, including his challenge of two jurors and the final grand jury list led by foreman John Randolph. District Attorney Hay then moved to commit Burr on a charge of High Treason, citing fear he might flee once informed of Wilkinson's approach, leading to a debate postponed until the next day.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
COL. BURR'S TRIAL
M. Garnett.
Mr. Hay, district Attorney, moved the court, to commit A. Burr on a charge of High Treason against the U. S. He declared that the reason of this motion was founded on a possibility of B's flying from the law, in case he should be positively informed that G Wilkinson was on his way to Richmond; unless he was committed for treason, and detained by higher bail; and he believed the evidence he was now to bring forward, in addition to what had been adduced on the Examination of A. Burr, was sufficient to induce the Judge to grant the commitment. He therefore moved that the evidence should be heard on behalf of the motion. This was opposed by Col. B's counsel, when a debate ensued, and a further consideration of the subject was postponed until the next day.
See moreSee less
The following is extracted from a letter received at Newyork, from Richmond.
"Mr. Burr to day told the Court, that as they appeared to be somewhat under embarrasment respecting the motion of the attorney of the United States, that altho' he did not deem they had a right to demand one cent more bail, still if he could procure it, he had no hesitation to relieve them from the embarrasment. He immediately found bail for 20,000 dollars Nothing will now be done for a day or two until Gen. Wilkinson comes on. The people think better of Burr's
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
This is a roundup of brief news items including Miranda's situation in Trinidad, British parliamentary votes, a New York gubernatorial election, and a Richmond letter noting General Eaton was insulted with expectation of trouble after Burr's trial concludes. It also covers unrelated items like a bachelors' club, presidential speculation, and a reward notice for a murder suspect.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
A letter from Richmond, dated the 27th ult says, "Gen Eaton has been insulted, and the conjecture is, that something of a serious nature will take place, as soon as the storm of Burr's trial is over."—N Y Herald
Court discusses scheduling of the grand jury, with counsel debating when it should be called. Mr. Hay moves to have Aaron Burr committed on a charge of high treason, citing new evidence including testimony from Eaton and additional depositions not previously presented.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Burr for high treason; and you recognized him for a misdemeanor only, Our evidence is now, however, more ample; we have new witnesses to bring before you; we have new depositions to read; and up
During pretrial argument, prosecutor Hay and defense counsel Botts dispute whether witness testimony should be given viva voce or by deposition, and whether the court or grand jury should examine evidence first. Botts objects to delay, warning it would improperly let the presiding judge pre-judge the case before the grand jury acts.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Hay. If there be the least surprise in the case, sir, I am willing to wave my motion till to-morrow, at Mr. Bott's request. The counsel for the prisoner shall never have it to say, that we have taken them off their guard. It is to be understood, however, if this enquiry be postponed, that Aaron Burr must be considered to stand before the court on a charge of
Defense and prosecution counsel debate procedural questions about which side should open argument and present evidence first, with references to suspicions and accusations against Colonel Burr. The report breaks off mid-argument with a note that it will be continued, followed by an unrelated maritime news item from New York about ships sighted near Havana.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 3
{sign-,Wicctiham observed that he knew the. - _ nsitoo well not essqj dpubctt that he Msimisappreheoded him;—But what mld he think of the motion he had made ? 1, ma msswge Episode wh'fd': he we—av'esid ;.gossbie lade. ]! may be good poetry-in. deed. but it waessooc certainly proper mac ssct of argumerctt.-sig-—-Eveey 'si'man ctwho bean'ÞC: every mM-siwhO-das ever "read on shsiqucct, mmsi'bsicsimw siwbm are the she}. in;; which disietfiss'tzsi- "(kneel-zepicions of col. Burr. Somessmonfficnion was {clt' by his' enemies (not that the-altotney "for the U. State: himself even sclsst it.) that he did re.
See moreSee less
me here forest-&. Bsim here eokmel Ban is and will ahvaye be, to meet every-kind ctossscbactegesiss thai may be 'si-brought against him] The gentleman wiil noc'o'pen his case,. end why,! Because when he'has heard our ;rgumcol against his motion, he may come 4 with the adverse 'argumencagaimt ass; .!" they. do not chose to open their case, we hope the coussrt will great as the .righc to make I eonelusive reply. Mr.. Hay. 'shesioveir we will-ssprodacerzhe i evidence. — . Here a desusikory conversation pale-ned up.-si .oosicbe order of'rhesiproceez 5;- si 'si sisisiactss. After some cdovssessrsatiosict jiejss-nsisiictefssigussssi ssfice determinedjh-agss cal. Barr'e cduc'ssel "thould proceed. wish;— the argument. si To be' ;Co-iztz'nued.
Westcott & Co. of Washington announce they have engaged stenographer Thomas Carpenter to attend the circuit court session opening in Richmond on the 23rd. They promise to publish a complete account of Aaron Burr's trial along with all related documents as soon as possible.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 8 June 1807 · page 4
On May 22, Burr's treason trial began in Richmond before Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin, with Burr objecting to irregularities in how grand jurors were summoned. Several jurors, including William B. Giles and Wilson Cary Nicholas, were challenged and withdrew due to bias or prior statements about Burr's guilt.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 9 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Trial of Burr.
On Friday the 22d ultimo came on at Richmond the trial of Col. Burr.
See moreSee less
At half past 12 the court was opened. Chief Justice Marshal and Judge Griffin present.
Eighteen of the grand Jurors had answered to their names, when Col. Burr rose and objected to the manner in which some of them were summoned; the Marshal having, he said, excused some after they had been summoned, and summoned others to make up the deficiency—which proceeding was illegal and improper.
After some debate on this objection between Mr. Botts, Mr. Wickham and Mr. Randolph on the part of Col. Burr, and Mr. Hay on the part of the U. S. the Martial was examined and admitted that he had excused Mr. John Taylor and Mr. John M'Rae, and summoned Col. Barbour and Dr. Foushee.——The Court decided that these two gentlemen had not been legally added to the pannel, and they were withdrawn.
The pannel then being reduced to 16 Col. Burr proceeded to object to William B. Giles, one of the number, on the ground of his having voted for the suspension of the habeas corpus act, and having since that time declared that the documents furnished evidence of Burr's guilt, and guilt of the highest grade. He also objected to Col. Wilson Cary Nicholas, on the ground of personal enmity, sufficient to blind the judgment of the wisest men.
Mr. Giles and Mr. Nicholas both withdrew, after addressing the court
The court swears in a grand jury including John Randolph as foreman after excusing several jurors, and the chief justice charges them on treason law. Witnesses for the United States are called, with General Wilkinson notably absent, and the court adjourns until the next day.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 9 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
ly with respect to the admissibility of certain evidence which it was supposed would be adduced on the part of the United States. The names of the several witnesses summoned in behalf of the United States were called over many of whom and among others Gen. Wilkinson were absent. Such as appeared were recognized to appear next day at 11 o’clock, to which hour the court adjourned. Richmond, is represented as full of strangers from all parts of the Union, drawn thither by the pending trial.
This report records courtroom arguments during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with defense counsel questioning why General Wilkinson has not appeared before the grand jury despite being a key witness. The speaker criticizes reliance on depositions and 'mutilated statements' instead of sworn testimony, and accuses the press of being enlisted to prejudice public opinion against Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
head of the goverment. In the wars of Europe a general has been known to march the same distance at the head of his army in a shorter time than gen. Wilkinson has had to pass from N. Orleans to this place. He is bound to go whenever the government directs him; to march to Mexico; to invade the Floridas; or to come to this city. Perhaps there are other reasons for his not coming. But let us not press this subject. What, Sir, is the tendency of this application? What is the motive?
See moreSee less
I have no doubt that the gentlemen mean to act correctly. I wish to cast no imputations. But the counsel and the court will know that there are a set of busy people (not I hope employed by the government) who thinking to do right, are laboring to ruin the reputation of my client. I do not charge the government with this attempt. But the thing is already done. Attempts have been made. The press from one end of the continent to the other has been enlisted on their side; to enlist prejudices against col. Burr. Prejudices? yes; they have influenced public opinion; by such representations, by persons not passing between the prisoner and his country, but by exparte evidence and mutilated statements. Ought not this court to bar the door as far as possible against such misrepresentations? to shut every effort to excite further prejudices, until the case is decided by a sworn jury, not by the floating rumors of the day, but by the evidence of sworn witnesses? The attorney for the U. S. offers to produce his testimony; no doubt the most violent; no doubt the least impartial which he can select; testimony which is perhaps to be met and overthrown by superior evidence. Do they, besides these things, wish that the multitude around us
The U.S. attorney, claiming sufficient evidence, moves the court to commit Aaron Burr on a charge of high treason, arguing it would be wrong not to pursue the motion. Defense counsel objects to the motion and to how notice of it was given, while the report argues the evidence shown is only partial and meant to prejudice the public against Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ty. Mr. Wirt. May it please your honors.—The attorney for the United States believing himself possessed of sufficient evidence to justify a commitment of A. Burr for high treason, has moved the court to that effect. In making this motion he has merely done his duty; it would have been unpardonable in him to omit it. Yet the counsel in the defence complain of the motion and of the want of notice. As to the latter objection it must be palpable that the nature and object of the motion rendered notice improper. The gentlemen would have had the attorney to an-
A report of legal argument during Aaron Burr's treason proceedings, addressing the attorney's motives for raising alarm about Burr's potential flight and defending the right to treat Burr like any other accused person. The passage also contains dense procedural argument over whether the court's general power to commit is nullified once a grand jury is empaneled.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
an explanation of his motives, has been pleased to speak of the attorney's statement of his apprehensions as "an episode:" which, "although good poetry, he says, had better have been let alone, when such serious matters of fact were in discussion." It may been episode, sir, if the gentleman pleases; he is at liberty to consider the whole as a piece of epic action, and to look forward to the appropriate catastrophe. But it does not appear to me to be very fair, sir, after havig drawn from the attorney an explanation of his motives, to complain of that explanation: if a wound has been inflicted by the explanation, the gentlemen who produced it should blame only themselves.
See moreSee less
But, sir, where is the crime of considering Aaron Burr as subject to the
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A prosecution lawyer argues against sending indictments directly to the grand jury, warning that delay could let Burr flee the country given public curiosity about the case. He cites evidence of General Wilkinson being summoned to testify and urges the court to bind Burr over for trial on high treason.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
to keep their own counsel? but it is absolutely impossible to exclude completely the busy eye of curiosity. Some vague insinuations may probably escape; something which might justify a suspicion of their determination. Suppose then that Aaron Burr was to be actuated by these considerations; suppose that his fears (if fears he can feel!) should prompt him to escape; what, sir, would become of our indictment? Mr. B. may quit the U. S.—he may flee for ever beyond the jurisdiction of this country; and in that case the whole world would ridicule us for the course we had pursued.
See moreSee less
Or let us even suppose that we were to withdraw this motion, where would be our security? Must we trust to the indulgence of Mr. Burr himself for remaining in this city and standing his trial? We expect General Wilkinson here in a few days. We have an affidavit which positively states, that an express to New Orleans to command his presence on this trial, was met on the frontiers of the Mississippi territory. We have also letters from the attorney general of the U. S. explicitly stating, that General Wilkinson has been officially authorised to leave the army of the U. S. and to select whatever mode of transportation he might think proper, (here Mr. H. read the affidavit, shewing that the express to General Wilkinson had been seen in Athens, in the state of Georgia). In the mean time what is Colonel Burr's situation? It is completely optional with him, whether to stay here and face his accusers, or to avail himself of his liberty
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers
This report covers arguments before the court regarding whether Aaron Burr should be held on charges of treason and misdemeanor, with prosecutor Hay defending the delay in General Wilkinson's arrival due to travel time and weather. The debate also touches on press coverage of Burr's case and whether evidence should be presented to the grand jury.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
and leave the U.S. We call upon this court to exercise the authority with which they are invested; and by binding over Col. Burr as well on the charge of High treason as of a misdemeanor, to detain him here for a satisfactory trial.
Mr. Hay said he scarcely expected to have been asked why General Wilkinson was not here? The gentleman himself has said that he is a general. Can he then leave his army at any time, and without the permission of the government? Make, however, a computation of time. The attorney general left this city on the 4th or 5th of April. He reached Washington on the 7th or 8th. Allow then a reasonable time for an express from Washington to New Orleans—and for a man of General Wilkinson's age and bulk to travel to this city, and is it probable that he could have arrived here before this period? If he availed himself of the liberty and means to come by water; the gales have been lately very severe. And even two of the grand jury had assured him that if General Wilkinson was exposed to the late tempestuous weather, he would probably never see the United States.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham has expatiated upon the attempts made to prejudicate the public opinion through the medium of the press. Sir, a great deal has been said, and a great deal will yet be said on this transaction. But are th. presses shut against Col. Burr? When even in this very city certain presses have been found to vindicate his motives and designs? But what of all this? The public mind is hostile to any encroachment upon the liberty of the press; and it ought to be so. Where then a crime of such gigantic evil arises in this country, like the one attributed to Aaron Burr, the printers will speak and they ought to speak; the purest motives will command them to speak. And if there have been publications against Col. Burr, innumerable communications have also appeared in his favor; and if these publications have contained the severest strictures upon him, they have resulted from his own character and conduct; and he has no right to complain.
Mr. Hay demanded why Col. Burr should then wish to close the only door to his vindication by excluding the evidence. His counsel exclaim, "send the evidence to the grand jury." Surely if Col. Burr wishes to have the evidence before the jury, he should be much more anxious to have it before the court. The jury will have one side of the evidence only before them; and that will be completely against himself. Both however will go before the court. Why then does he shrink from the evidence! If an unjust prejudice assails him, the light of truth and evidence will dissipate it. Why does he shrink?
The gentleman on the other side, continued Mr. Hay, do not do us justice. They charge us with persecution and oppression. Sir, I never contemplated or wished to hurt A. Burr. I scorn it. I look not to him. I look
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 10 June 1807
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 19 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report records courtroom argument over the prosecution's requested continuance pending the arrival of Wilkinson and other witnesses from New Orleans, with counsel disputing the timeline and sincerity of the delay. It also addresses whether the grand jury's presence is constitutionally necessary for proceeding with indictments.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
a computation of time to show that Wilkinson could not have been here before this period; and he has besides introduced an affidavit to show that an express was on his way to Orleans to give him an early summons. There is, however, nothing in proof that the drawer of this affidavit was not imposed on by this express; or that the express himself was not mistaken as to the contents of his dispatches. And how stands the computation as to time? The post goes from Washington to N. Orleans in 17 days.
See moreSee less
Mr. Rodney left this city in the last of March. The express must therefore have reached New Orleans about the 20th of April; and yet where is Wilkinson? Though the Mississippi runs down to New Orleans, and opposes a strong current to those who ascend it, yet it is surely a reasonable proposition that on land it requires no longer time to come than to go. And yet General Wilkinson is not here! Mr. Hay says it is of no consequence whether the grand jury is present or not—But is this consonant with the sound principles of law? Is it constitutional, sir, where there is a particular body set apart for the investigation of facts, for the court to step in and rudely take this power from them? He says that perhaps he shall not send up his bills before the present grand jury. But I trust in God, sir, that this determination will be overruled by the court; and that if this prosecution is ever to be closed, we may see the curtain drop upon it now and forever! If, sir, the prosecution obtains a posponement of trial and for want of evidence, on their part, we might properly contend that colonel Burr, if bound to bail at all, should be held in a smaller recognizance than at
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report explains that public impatience over General Wilkinson's delayed arrival at the Burr trial in Richmond is unwarranted, detailing the timeline of judicial decisions and subpoena issuance. It argues the government acted with maximum speed once the trial venue was legally determined on April 5th.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
WASHINGTON CITY, WEDNESDAY, JUNE 10.
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 10. The impatience of the public with regard to the trial of Aaron Burr seems to have produced an erroneous expectation of the time at which gen. Wilkinson was likely to attend at Richmond. The aid, almost of miracles, has been enlisted to gratify this impatience, and the disposition on the part of the accused to criminate the prosecution, on the ground of delay. Now the fact is, that, notwithstanding the greatest exertions on the part of the latter, the attendance of Wilkinson at a period earlier than the present was extremely improbable.
See moreSee less
We say the greatest exertions—for none have been spared to command his presence at the earliest possible day. This will appear from the following facts: On the 5th of April the Chief Justice made his decision at Richmond, which was the first judicial determination of the place where Aaron Burr was to be tried. Before this period, it would have been absurd for the government to have subpoenaed witnesses, whose presence might have been required in Washington or Orleans, in Virginia or the Mississippi Territory.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report calculates travel times from Washington to New Orleans and back to explain why General Wilkinson had not yet arrived in Richmond for the treason trial. It argues the government and Wilkinson acted properly given realistic travel times, countering criticism of delay.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
required in Washington or Orleans, in Virginia or the Mississippi Territory. For let it be recollected, that the designation of the place of trial is entirely the province of the judiciary. It took three days to bring to Washington information of the decision at Richmond—This brought down the time to the 8th of April—On the 9th a subpoena issued for gen. Wilkinson, & on the same day the messenger started, having received special instructions to lose no time, and carrying orders from the Secretary of the Navy, in case the general determined to come by water, to dispatch a public vessel with the least delay.
See moreSee less
The messenger, it is probable, took 28 days in going to New Orleans. We say this is probable, as there has not, we understand, been an instance in which the road has been travelled in a shorter time, and as at this season the unusual falls of rain must by their effects upon the roads, and by the raising of the creeks and rivers, have created uncommon impediments. In this case he would have reached New Orleans on the 7th of May. If general Wilkinson determined to come on by land, it is evident that he could not
A correspondent questions why General Wilkinson has not yet arrived in Richmond for Burr's trial despite ample time since dispatches were sent, speculating government may be stalling. The piece criticizes the prolonged detention of jurors and witnesses pending Wilkinson's appearance.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
by water, be ought, at the moderate computation of 35 miles or a little more per day, to have been here before this time. But let us examine this mysterious business a little further. Gen. Wilkinson must have received the commands of the executive on this subject by the last of May at farthest.—Is it possible that neither Wilkinson, gov. Claiborne, nor capt. Shaw, commanding our naval force at New-Orleans, to all of whom, as well as to others, letters were written by government, by the same express or mail would not have been answered immediately by the return of the mail—Of this, it is impossible to doubt.
See moreSee less
If letters were written, in answer, by these gentlemen, or either of them, about the 1st May, they would have been received by government at the city of Washington, by the 20th of that month in the usual course of the mail—and certainly, government ought to have communicated to the court, or to their attorney here, who prosecutes for them, whether Wilkinson ought to be expected or not.—No information of that kind has been received by the attorney-general; but the grand jury and a great number of witnesses are kept here, in consequence of the performance, as it is believed, of a governmental farce. It begins, I believe, to be a pretty general opinion, that the trial ought to go on, or that col. Burr should be discharged. More of this in my next. A BYE STANDER. June 5, 1807.
A report from the District Court of Virginia describes arguments over whether Aaron Burr might flee before General Wilkinson arrives to testify. The writer urges the court to bind Burr over, warning that letting him go free could allow him to escape U.S. jurisdiction entirely.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
probably catch some distant hint of the probable decision of the jury. They have certainly too much discretion not to keep their own council: but it is absolutely impossible to exclude completely the busy eye of curiosity. Some vague insinuations may probably escape; something which might justify a suspicion of their determination. Suppose then that Aaron Burr
The court discusses scheduling delays in Aaron Burr's treason trial, as prosecutors calculate that General Wilkinson needs about 45 days to travel roughly 1370 miles from New Orleans on horseback. The grand jury is adjourned for about ten days to accommodate his expected arrival around the 15th of the month.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.
United States entered, and observed that he had a proposition to submit to the court which he wished the grand jury to hear. He requested therefore that they might be called in.
A letter from John Watkins describes a coded letter, allegedly from General Dayton, predicting Burr and Wilkinson's control of Louisiana and Mexico. The Aurora's commentary notes this contradicts Dayton's earlier public denial of involvement in Burr's schemes, reviving suspicions about his role.
The Enquirer · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Comments from the Aurora.
The above letter was addressed, by the writer, (a member of the legislature of Orleans and opposed to general Wilkinson) to the editor of the Orleans Gazette.
See moreSee less
What are we to think of it ?
It is in the remembrance of most of our readers, that when the designs of Burr were detected, and measures taken to frustrate them, this Mr. Dayton was suspected by many to be in the confidence of Burr.
When the suspicions had gained currency, particularly in public prints, a positive and explicit denial was published by Mr. Dayton—in which he said he knew nothing, directly or indirectly, of Burr's plans, or object; and that the first intimation he had received of the af
Before Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin, defense counsel Wickham argues against admitting an affidavit as evidence on the motion to commit Burr for treason, insisting on proper legal procedure and the right of confrontation with witnesses like General Wilkinson. The report also includes an unrelated letter from William Eaton disputing debts and claims related to the late Doctor Turner's estate.
The Enquirer · 10 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Wednesday, May 27. Debate on the order and species of evidence to be introduced, on the motion to commit Aaron Burr for High Treason against the U. S. (Concluded.)
Attorneys debate whether the court should issue a subpoena duces tecum for a letter dated October 21st, with Hay questioning its relevance and whether it has been properly identified. Burr and his counsel argue the order in question could be used both for a commitment motion and at trial.
The Enquirer · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
was properly applied to for it.
Mr. Burr observed, that to avoid all possible misconception, he thought it proper to state, that Mr. Van Ness had assured him of Mr. Smith's positive and unqualified promise to furnish the answer, if applied for through coun-
During pretrial proceedings in Burr's treason trial, counsel argue over which papers should be obtained and whether the court has authority to issue a subpoena duces tecum. The Chief Justice urges the opposing counsels to reach an arrangement, but indicates he will hear argument on the court's power to compel document production if they cannot agree.
The Enquirer · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
gazette was in court.
Mr Burr. No, sir; but I have already seen the same order in other papers; and have no doubt that almost every person has. At Natchez it was a subject of surprise that such an
Attorneys and the Chief Justice argue over the proper form for a subpoena duces tecum to obtain documents from President Jefferson and government departments, including Wilkinson's letter, for Burr's defense. Mr. Hay offers to personally request the papers but is rebuffed when defense counsel insists on originals rather than copies, leading to a tense exchange.
The Enquirer · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
may presume that the others will. Mr. Burr. If the gentleman grants our demand, he may propose any alteration in its form that he pleases. Mr. Randolph. If any arrangement can be made to obtain these papers, we would rather
The Richmond paper reports confusing news from Norfolk that General Wilkinson had not yet left New Orleans by May 11, despite expectations he would testify at Burr's trial. The editor speculates on possible causes—lost orders, accidents to dispatches, or even disloyalty—while defending Wilkinson's likely innocence and intent to appear.
Virginia Argus · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE news from Norfolk (which will be found in this day's Argus) is strange indeed!—that Gen. Wilkinson had not left New-Orleans on the 11th of May, and that the bearer of the intelligence had heard nothing of his intending to leave it. Great joy at this report is no doubt felt by the Federalists and Burrites; but we trust they have very little cause for exultation.
If Gen. Wilkinson was in fact at New-Orleans at the time specified and was not preparing for his journey to this place, it must have proceeded from his not having received the orders of the government; and that circumstance must have been occasioned by some accident's happening to the express who was sent to require his attendance, and to the mail which carried dispatches to him.
See moreSee less
We cannot believe the government to have neglected sending those orders, nor that he would have disobeyed, if he had received them. His own character is so deeply implicated in the investigation now going on at Richmond, that he would not willingly be absent, if permitted by his superiors to be present at the trial of Col. Burr; much less would he be disposed to violate their orders, and run the risk of being broke for his disobedience. If, as his enemies have insinuated, he is afraid to meet Col. Burr, and will not dare to ap
The grand jury reconvened in Burr's trial but General Wilkinson had still not arrived to testify; newspaper reports suggested he remained in New Orleans weeks after expected. The editors speculate on possible causes for the delay, including intercepted mail or partisan interference, while noting such reports may be unreliable.
Virginia Argus · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
when we consider the great distance from Washington to New-Orleans; the unaccountable silence of the western mails on this subject; the unsettled state of the western territories at present; and the number of partizans of Col. Burr in those territories, (some of whom may have designedly stopped the express or intercepted the mail,) we think it not improbable they may have occurred. We think it however most probable that the report itself may be one of the numerous fabrications which are daily circulating; and that Gen. Wilkinson may yet be expected here during the present term of the Federal Court.
Prosecutor Hay informs the court that newspaper reports from Norfolk indicate General Wilkinson was still in New Orleans as of mid-May, with no indication of his departure, explaining the delay in his expected arrival for the trial. He requests a postponement of proceedings, and Burr's associate Martin confirms similar information from a later Norfolk paper, while Burr clarifies he does not object to the delay.
Virginia Argus · 10 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
OF Col. Aaron Burr.
TUESDAY, June 9. Present the Chief Justice of the United States, and Cyrus Griffin, District Judge.
See moreSee less
IT will be recollected that on Wednesday last, the 3d inst. the grand jury were adjourned over to this day, at 2 o'clock. At the hour of three, all the members appeared, and their names being called over,
Mr. Hay observed that it was proper for him to inform the court, that he had received no further information respecting gen. Wilkinson except what was contained in a Norfolk paper (the Public Ledger) received by the mail of this morning; a paragraph in which stated that a vessel had arrived there, in 27 days from New Orleans; and that at the departure of the vessel from the latter place, which must have been about the eleventh of last month, gen. Wilkinson was still in New Orleans, and nothing was said as to his intention of leaving it. There were gentlemen on the grand jury just from Norfolk, who would be able to state whether the information might be relied on or not. He said that he had confidently expected gen. Wilkinson here before this time; but that he might have been led into the mistake by the information received from Mr. Millikin, as to the progress which the express had made, when he saw the messenger on his way to New Orleans. It was possible that in the latter part of his journey, he might not have been able to move with as much rapidity as upon his first setting out. But from a knowledge of the fact that Gen. Wilkinson was at New
Edmund Randolph addresses the court, objecting to the manner in which Aaron Burr's case has been handled, citing the military escort, depositions, and sudden change in procedure. He criticizes the court for introducing a 'new fangled doctrine' without precedent, arguing it undermines Burr's legal rights.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
under a military escort. Then that whole folio of depositions and affidavits was laid before your honor: Then the charge of treason: and then that little cock boat which was destined to attend this great ship on a foreign expedition? You heard it all, sir, and what did you say? You bound colonel Burr to bail, simply on the
This report transcribes a heated courtroom argument concerning procedural fairness in Colonel Burr's case, focusing on whether additional bail should be demanded and criticizing this as an unprecedented, prejudicial step before the grand jury. The speaker also notes that it is widely rumored around town that the judge has already declared Burr guilty of treason before any verdict.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
capacity which you now [illegible] be in the same relation to the a[ccu]sed as an examining judge is in the state courts. But, sir, whoever invi[t]ed a single magistrate or a state court to augment the bail of any individual in the situation of colonel Burr? If a man be bound in a distant county to answer to a misdemeanor, and another crime was to be alledged against him, to be predicated on the very same evidence, have you, sir, ever known the trying court to increase his bail? There never was such an example, sir. Mr. Botts' remark, sir, is not to be answered. You are changing the constitu[tion]
A defense lawyer (Mr. R.) argues in court that President Jefferson prejudiced public opinion by declaring Burr guilty before trial, undermining judicial impartiality. He also decries the harsh manner of Burr's arrest in the Mississippi Territory, including denial of judicial appeal and being marched under armed guard.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
heaped upon col. Burr.
Mr. R. proceeded to touch upon a subject, to which Mr. Hay had referred. Colonel Burr was arrested in the Mississippi territory. Was there no court there? Was there no judge of integrity to try him? Arrested too after he had been acquitted by a grand jury!!! Well! He was transported thence (with humanity it has been said) dragged on by eight musqueteers who were ready to shoot him at a moment's warning; refused any appeal to the judicial authority; denied even the melancholy satisfaction of writing to his only child. Was all this humanity? Dragged before this court, which derives its only jurisdiction from a little speck of land on the Ohio. Yes! Sir, but for that little spot of an island, Virginia would never have enjoyed this honor! What is all this, sir, but oppressive and bitter inhumanity? I trust, sir, from what I have said, that no one will think with Mr. Wirt, that I am shifting the question from col. Burr to Mr. Jefferson. I should not have made the observations which have escaped me, but to show that my client is justified by his situation in stating every objection that he can, to the present measure.
See moreSee less
Mr. R. observed that at least one disadvantage would result from this enquiry; that it was not clear, as Mr. Hay had asserted, that the affidavit would be laid before the court only and not before the grand and petit juries, for the grand jury would soon be possessed of the substance of them; and that it was next to impossible for them to separate the impressions thus illegally to be produced upon their minds from the weight of the legal, viva voce testimo.
The U.S. Circuit Court met in Richmond with Judges Marshall and Griffin presiding over Burr's case. A grand jury was sworn in after jury selection disputes, and proceedings were delayed over disagreements on how to investigate the treason charge without prejudicing public opinion.
The Wheeling Repository · 11 June 1807 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
verley, John Ambler, Thomas Harrison, Joseph C. Cabell, James Pleasants, Jr. John Brockenbrough, Alexander Shepherd, James Barbour, James M. Garnett.
Nothing of any consequence was done on Saturday the 23d. Monday the 25th Mr. Hay stated that he would not send up an indictment to the grand jury for some days, unless Gen. Wilkinson attended. He then moved the court to commit Burr for high treason. This
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The grand jury in the Burr treason trial was called before the court, where U.S. Attorney Hay proposed delaying proceedings about ten days to allow General Wilkinson time to travel roughly 1,370 miles from New Orleans. Hay calculated Wilkinson could only travel about 30 miles per day on horseback, estimating his arrival around June 14-15.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Col. AARON BURR.
This calculation would bring him to the 14th or 15th of this month. He was, therefore, willing if it suited the wishes of the opposite counsel to have the grand jury adjourned for about ten days: That General Wilkinson's situation called upon the court to make this
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Aaron Burr's trial, the Chief Justice and attorneys discuss how long to wait for General Wilkinson's arrival, debating reasonable travel time from Fort Stoddert. The grand jury returns to court as Mr. Hay addresses them.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
court for this purpose.
Mr. Wickham had no doubt himself that if General Wilkinson had intended to have come at all, he would have been here before this time; certainly the
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The court discusses adjourning the grand jury for several days until General Wilkinson can arrive to testify, with lawyers debating the exact timing based on travel estimates and Dearborne's letter. Mr. Hay states he merely wants the prosecution to proceed during the current court term, regardless of the exact adjournment length.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
adjournment to a distant day? Mr. Wilkinson may be expected here ever day. The attorney's estimate of the time is not perhaps correct. Perkins came about the same distance as Mr. W. is to come: but he performed his
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Attorneys and the Chief Justice argue whether the prosecution must first prove an overt act of treason before introducing other evidence, or may proceed chronologically through the alleged conspiracy. Wirt and Hay defend presenting evidence in narrative order to show intent and the conspiracy's development, while the defense insists on strict legal procedure requiring proof of the overt act first.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
grand jury, then I hope the whole evidence will be laid before the world; and we shall hear no more of rumors and prejudice.
These gentlemen say "shall you pretend to order us? shall you dictate." No, sir, the law must dictate. The gentlemen, indeed, have produced a series of irrelevant writings and papers; and they must forsooth pursue a chronological order. No, sir. Away with such informalities. Let gentlemen prove an assemblage of men for war. Let them prove the overt act. If they do not, I confidently hope that Colonel Burr will be discharged. Mr. Wickham here read a quotation from "Fos-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, counsel debate how the prosecution should present evidence, with Botts and Randolph pressing for the overt act to be proven first before accessory testimony is admitted. The prosecutor Hay insists on introducing depositions chronologically, starting with General Wilkinson's affidavit, prompting objections from Burr's defense team.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
court.
Mr. Hay. As I said before, I shall take up the depositions first; and then the viva voce testimony, in a chronological order. I shall first introduce gen. Wilkinson's deposition.
See moreSee less
Some desultory conversation, then ensued between Mr. Hay and Mr. Botts, on the latter's demanding the liberty of examining the deposition. At length Mr. Hay handed the paper to him.—Mr. Botts then addressed the court.
(As Mr. Bott's speech contains an explanation of much of the course, which is probably to be pursued by col. Burr's counsel, particularly in regard to instructions from the court to the grand jury on the evidence; we have published it at some length.)
Mr. Botts. In my objections to gen. Wilkinson's affidavit, I may be compelled to question the correctness of
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Burr's defense counsel argues before the court that General Wilkinson's personal testimony, not merely his affidavit, is now required as the best evidence, since circumstances have changed since the Supreme Court's earlier ruling. The attorney contends the government has had ample time to bring Wilkinson to testify in person, and that his live testimony could rebut inferences drawn from his affidavit regarding the ciphered letter.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
thorities not to be resisted.
The opinion of the supreme court overruling the objection, that the oath administered to gen. Wilkinson was extrajudicial, fixes the law for this court.
See moreSee less
The best evidence that the nature of the case will admit of, should be pro
The paper reports General Wilkinson has arrived in Virginia and is heading to Richmond for Burr's trial, defending its earlier reporting against claims it may have caused the Grand Jury to consider disbanding. The editor insists neutrality, expressing hope for a fair and impartial trial from a respected Grand Jury and court.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FRIDAY EVENING, JUNE 12, 1807.
Our last noticed the arrival of General Wilkinson in Hampton Roads, that officer (having first sent on express to notify his arrival) proceeded this morning in the Stage for Richmond, and will arrive to-morrow morning in that city.
See moreSee less
It would have been matter of great regret to us if the article published in our paper of Friday last had been in any way the means of inducing a discharge of the Grand Jury, which appears from the proceeding in the trial of Mr. Burr, had been thought of under an idea that General Wilkinson was not coming on. It must be observed that we published the information as we received it, without comment, and we believe that our informant stated what were his impressions.
Intelligence from Baltimore we are certain reached Richmond by Tuesday night's mail, which stated Gen. Wilkinson's intention of coming on, consequently the Grand Jury would be detained, and the trial will take place, as every one must desire. The publick mind, it is hoped, will now be satisfied by a fair and impartial trial. A more respectable and intelligent Grand Jury we believe has never been impannelled in this country. Fom the Court there is reason to expect every thing that impartiality and talents can administer.
We are not among the friends or foes of col. Burr, if innocent we hope he will be acquitted, if guilty, that he will be punished as the law directs, but never will we be among that number, who will lend our columns to the condemnation of the accused, before trial, because his accusers are those who command all the power and influence of the country. If on any occasion we have used remarks that might be thought favourable to col. Burr, we hope that they
During Burr's trial proceedings, prosecutor Hay informed the grand jury about General Wilkinson's location based on a Norfolk newspaper extract, acknowledging his earlier information was not entirely accurate. He expressed confidence Wilkinson would arrive soon, estimating the 14th or 15th, and urged the trial proceed efficiently given the importance of the case.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COLONEL BURR.
Last proceedings.
TUESDAY, June 9.
See moreSee less
The same judges were present, as yesterday.
The grand jury had been adjourned till 2 o'clock. About 3, they all appeared, and their names being called over,
Mr. Hay observed, that it might be proper to inform the court, that he had received no further intelligence of gen. Wilkinson, except what was contained in the little scrap of paper in his hand. It
The court debates scheduling, awaiting General Wilkinson's arrival and news from Norfolk papers about ships that might carry intelligence concerning him. Burr requests adjournment be kept short and raises the issue of producing the full October 21st letter from Wilkinson referenced in the president's communication to Congress.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COLONEL BURR.
Mr. Hay. If these are different vessels—
Mr. Martin. The same vessel, sir.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay. These vessels may convey some intelligence to Washington respecting general Wilkinson, which may consequently reach ourselves.
Mr. Burr. I hope, sir, it will be understood, from the observations of my friend (Mr. M.) that I mean not to take any part in this business. I shall certainly not interfere with the grand jury in this stage of the affair. The proposition of the gentleman has my cordial concurrence.
The Chief Justice observed, that if the jury were adjourned till Thursday, some passenger might, perhaps, arrive in the next Norfolk mail, with some intelligence about gen. Wilkinson.
Mr. Hay. presumed, that the jury would not probably be wanting before Saturday.
Mr. Burr hoped that the jury would be adjourned for as short a time as possible: at all events not longer than Thursday.
Chief Justice. This is Tuesday. The attorney for the U States cannot probably expect gen. W. before Thursday, if he comes by water.
Mr. Hay knew not how he was to come. If by water he certainly could not be expected before that time: and if by land he would certainly require one day to recover from the fatigue of travelling.
The Chief Justice then observed to the grand jury that they were adjourned till Thursday 10 o'clock.
Mr. Burr then addressed the court. There was a proposition which he wished to submit to them. In the president's communication to congress, he speaks of a letter and other papers which he had received from Mr. Wilkinson, under date of 21st October. Circumstances had now rendered it
A New Orleans letter claims General Wilkinson altered his interpretation of Burr's coded letter in different sworn statements, changing names and omitting details between his affidavit to the superior court and his affidavit to the president. The writer says this reveals Wilkinson's duplicity in the unfolding Burr conspiracy affair.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
NEW-YORK, June 3. Extract of a letter, dated New-Orleans, April 22. "I must confess to you that my eyes are at length opened with regard to Wilkinson. Amongst other proofs of his duplicity, I find, upon reading his despatch to government, that he has altered in some parts, his interpretation of Burr's letter to him in cypher. Upon his disclosure of the plot here, at the meeting of the merchants at government house, he declared "that general Dayton was to bring up the rear of Burr's army." In the affidavit produced before the superior court, the day he denounced Livingston and Alexander, he swore to a similar explanation of the cyphers.
See moreSee less
In his affidavit transmitted to the president, also under oath, he has substituted the name of Alston and omitted a long paragraph relating to former correspondence between him and Burr."
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The circuit court session for Burr's trial began with an immense crowd gathered in Richmond, with Chief Justice Marshall and Judge Griffin presiding. Before the grand jury was sworn, a lengthy argument occurred between Burr's counsel and the U.S. attorney over how jurors were summoned and objections to specific jury members.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 12 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL or COL. AARON BURR.
Yesterday the 22d inst. the circuit court of the U. S. for the fifth circuit and district of Virginia, commenced its session in this city. The expected trial of colonel Burr drew together an immense concourse of citizens from various parts of the union; indeed far exceeding any that we recollect ever to have seen upon any former occasion.
See moreSee less
At half past 12 o'clock the court was opened, present.
John Marshall, chief justice of the U. States.
Cyrus Griffin, judge of the district of Virginia.
Before the grand jury was impannelled and sworn, a lengthy and desultory argument took place between col. Burr with his counsel on the one side and the
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
During pretrial proceedings in the Burr treason case, defense counsel Wickham objects to the marshal's method of summoning grand jurors, citing legal precedent that a defendant may challenge jurors before they are sworn. Prosecutor Hay argues the Virginia law allows the marshal flexibility to substitute jurors who cannot attend, and the matter is submitted to the court for determination.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 12 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
FRIDAY, June 12, 1807.
tation on the marshal, whose intentions, he doubted not, were upright; but as this was an extraordinary case, and great attempts had been made to prejudice the public mind against col. Burr, he was justifiable in taking every advantage that the law gave him. He cited 2 Hawk. Pleas of the crown, p. 307, 16 sect. and 8 Bac. Abr. 725, to shew that a person bound in a recognizance to answer a criminal charge has a right to appear and make objections to the grand jury before they are sworn.—Whether a plea in abatement might afterwards be filed for the error committed, was a question not necessary now to be determined: neither was it the wish of col. Burr to re[
See moreSee less
marshal's feelings, [illegible] certainly unintentio[nal] Mr. Hay. I said [illegible] reason existed for [the] marshal, where he [was] certain that a grand j[ury] to supply the deficie[ncy] another before the c[ourt] term. According [to] 12 of those who are fail to attend their [du]ry at all. The chief justic[e] this question had ev[er] state courts: Mr. Randolph an[swered] had witkin his know[ledge]
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The chief justice charged the grand jury on federal offenses and treason, then debated jury instructions on evidence admissibility. Witnesses including General Wilkinson were called but many failed to appear, leading to adjournment until more testimony could be gathered.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
were called over, many of whom and among others General Wilkinson were absent. Such as appeared were recognized to appear on this day at 11 o'clock, to which hour the court adjourned.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The court discusses adjourning the grand jury while awaiting witnesses, including the still-absent General Wilkinson, whose testimony is deemed important. Prosecutor Hay moves to commit Burr on a charge of high treason, noting that unlike his earlier examination, evidence of an overt act now exists; the Chief Justice then begins delivering the court's opinion on its power to commit.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
considerable distance on the part of col. Burr, it might be important to know when the grand jury would be again called; Mr. Hay observed that a motion might be made which would render their presence necessary even on that day.
Mr. Wickham then requested that before any order should be taken in relation to the adjournment of the grand jury, the counsel for the U. S. might state
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The passage reports Chief Justice Marshall's delivered opinion addressing whether a court, as opposed to an individual judge, has the power to commit a person charged with an offense against the United States, and whether circumstances in Burr's case restrain that power. Marshall reasons that although the judicial act expressly grants this power only to justices and judges individually, it is implicitly understood that courts may exercise it collectively, based on their cognizance of federal crimes and related statutory provisions.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 12 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
sary to decide—
1st. Whether the court sitting as a court possesses the power to commit any person charged with an offence against the United States.
See moreSee less
2d. If this power be possessed, whether circumstances exist in this case which ought to restrain its exercise.
The first point was not made in the argument, and would, if decided against the attorney for the U. S. only change the mode of proceeding. If a doubt can exist respecting it, that doubt arises from the omission in the laws of the U. S. to invest their courts, sitting as courts, with the power in question. It is expressly given to every justice and judge, but not to a court.
This objection was not made on the part of colonel Burr, and is now mentioned, not because it is believed to present
This report covers courtroom proceedings in the Aaron Burr treason trial, focused on Burr's affidavit requesting military and naval orders related to New Orleans as material to his defense. Prosecutor Hay objects to the motion and the right of Burr to make it, while discussing procedural issues around obtaining the papers.
The Enquirer · 13 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
AARON BURR.
Sworn to in open Court the 10th June, 1807. W. MARSHALL, Clk. This affidavit being read, Mr. Hay begged leave to notice to the court and the opposite counsel, that in conformity to the intimation which he had yesterday given, he had addressed a letter to the President; mentioning the motion which was to be made this day, and suggesting the propriety of sending on the papers required, but reserving to himself the right of keeping these papers by him, until the court should see and determine their materiality. He hoped that in 5 days at least the papers would be in his possession: he should however object to the affidavit produced, and even to the right of Col.
See moreSee less
Burr to make any such motions at the present time. That this
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 17 June 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 19 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 19 June 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
During pretrial proceedings in the Burr treason case, defense counsel moves for a subpoena duces tecum compelling President Jefferson to produce a letter from General Wilkinson referenced in his January 27th message to Congress. Prosecutor Hay objects that Burr, merely recognized on a misdemeanor charge with no indictment yet found, lacks standing to demand such compulsory process.
The Enquirer · 13 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The Chief Justice decided that Mr. Hay might state his objections. Mr. H. then proceeded. The motion now made by Mr. Burr, as far as he could understand it, was to obtain a subpœna from the court (or rather from the Judges sitting there) to the President of the U. States, to attend this court with an original letter from General W. to the President of the U. States, and afterwards referred to by him in his communication to Congress of January 27th. He contended that this motion was premature. Col.
See moreSee less
B. was not authorised by any legal precedents or by the statutes of this or any other country, to demand legal process for obtaining witnesses, whilst he remained in his present situation. What was that situation? He had been committed for a misdemeanor, and recognized to appear before this court; And in
Defense counsel argues before the court that Burr has the same right as the prosecution to subpoena witnesses and documents, citing the precedent of Smith and Ogden's trial where subpoenas were issued to cabinet officials. The speaker insists the defense only seeks copies of certain papers and the original of another from the President.
The Enquirer · 13 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
the decision of his own witnesses? But at what time are we to be entitled to these privileges? At the period of Col. B's transportation? That is a most unwarrantable proceeding; there is no such case recognized by the constitution; and therefore there could be nothing in that constitution to give us the right of founding any judicial proceeding on such a step. But, sir, such an illegal transaction entitles us to still more, it entitles to the protection of every citizen in the country; as well as of this court.—Suppose that Col. Burr was now put on his examination; would he
Defense counsel for Aaron Burr argues passionately that the government must produce Wilkinson's letters and papers requested for the defense, accusing President Jefferson of prejudging Burr's guilt publicly. The speaker insists it is the court's role, not the executive's or prosecution's, to decide what evidence is material to the case.
The Enquirer · 13 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
persecution; to hunt down my friend.—And would this President of the U. S. who has raised all this absurd clamour, pretend to keep back the papers which are wanted for this trial; where life itself is at stake? It is a sacred principle, that in all such cases, the accused has a right to all the evidence which is necessary for his defence. And whoever withholds this information, is substantially a murderer, and is so recorded in the registers of Heaven.—Can it then be presumed, that the President would be sorry to have Col. Burr's innocence proved? No. It is impossible. Would the P. U. S.
The court spent three days hearing arguments on a motion for a subpoena duces tecum addressed to the President, with multiple lawyers arguing both sides and no decision yet reached. Burr also renewed his motion for specific instructions to the Grand Jury on evidentiary standards, citing numerous legal authorities.
The Enquirer · 13 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
resumed by Mr. Hay, who was succeeded by Mr. Randolph.
On Friday, the argument was continued by Mr. Martin and closed by Mr. Burr. The court* have not yet given their decision, on this interesting point. Mr. Burr observed that as Gen. Wilkinson might now be expected in a short time, before the court, it was desirable to obtain a prompt decision.
See moreSee less
On the conclusion of this argument, Mr. Burr addressed the court: he observed that this was perhaps the most proper time for renewing the motion, which he had some time ago made to the court, about giving more specific instructions to the Grand Jury, on certain points of evidence. These points he had reduced to writing in the form of abstract propositions, which he would take the liberty of reading to the court :
The following is a list of those propositions with the authorities cited to support them.
1. That the G. Jury cannot consistently with their oath find a Bill except on such testimony as would justify a petit Jury to find the prisoner guilty.
Foster 232 Sec. 8 3d Institute 25—2d Institute 384—Dalton 519—Judge Wilsons Works, Vol. 2d. 364—T. W. Williams Justice 3d. Vol. printed 1794—3d. State T. 419, 420 and Sir John Hawle's observations, 4 S. T. 183—4th Black.
The newspaper explains it will now publish only summaries of trial proceedings rather than full transcripts, promising a complete pamphlet later. It then reports on a heated debate over Col. Burr's motion for a subpoena duces tecum compelling President Jefferson to produce Wilkinson's letter and related military orders as evidence.
Virginia Argus · 13 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Wilkinson (dated the 21st day of October, 1806, and referred to in his message to Congress in January last;) together with copies of the orders which were issued by his directions to the naval and military officers of the United States, commanding them to suppress the conspiracy imputed to Aaron Burr. Mr. Hay contended that a preliminary question ought to be decided; whether in the situation in which Col. Burr now stands, before any bill of indictment has been found against him, he could, as a matter of right, move for any subpoenas for witnesses in his favor. He solemnly declared it was not his wish, nor that of the gentlemen associated with him in the prosecution to withhold from Col. Burr any testimony requisite for his
Attorneys argue before the court whether Aaron Burr is entitled to compulsory process to summon witnesses, including President Jefferson, at this preliminary stage of proceedings. One side contends the constitutional right to witnesses applies only at trial, not during examination or grand jury proceedings, while the other cites precedent from the Smith and Ogden case to support Burr's right to subpoenas.
Virginia Argus · 13 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
He suggested another difficulty, that no day could be appointed on which the process should be returnable. He acknowledged that on a motion to commit, a prisoner is entitled to examine witnesses on his behalf; but there was no such motion now before the court, though it would be made if Gen. Wilkinson did not arrive. On a motion to commit
During Burr's treason trial proceedings, defense counsel Martin argues for compelling President Jefferson to produce documents, including a letter from Wilkinson, while prosecutor Hay contests the scope of subpoena power. The court leans against Hay on a procedural point but reserves the issue as part of the larger argument over the subpoena duces tecum.
Virginia Argus · 13 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The court seemed inclined to decide the point against Mr. Hay; but desired it to be reserved as a part of the argument on the main question, in the opinion of the court on which the previous question would be involved; and directed Col. Burr's counsel to commence their argument in support of their motion for a subpoena duces tecum to the President of the
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report records courtroom legal arguments concerning the overt act requirement for treason, the two-witness rule, and whether confessions outside open court can be admitted as evidence. It also addresses double jeopardy protections and whether Burr can be tried separately in multiple states for the same alleged offense.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 15 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Col. AARON BURR.
the same crime. Can he plead autrofois acquit in bar, by avowing that the crimes charged in the two states was one and the same? His averment would be against the record of the indictment charging a compleat separate crime in each district. Will you, sir, put upon the constitution, such a construction as will subject a citizen to be hunted down, by trial after trial, in state after state, as long as the persecuting spirit of a wicked executive may last? Do not understand me to allude, in this, to the present administration, the characters of which I have been in the habit of admiring; but the construction now to be fixed must go down to posterity and may be made instrumental in effecting the worst of state oppressions.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report presents legal argument opposing the admission of secondhand or confession-based testimony against Aaron Burr, citing risks of misunderstanding, exaggeration, and false witness testimony. It defends Burr's reluctance to allow unfamiliar witnesses to testify about his character or conduct without clear legal standards.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 15 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ous species of evidence, ever liable to misconstruction and abuse. But if the constitution has proscribed it why now question its exclusion. If the confessions of the accused, out of court, could not be evidence against him, could the confessions of real accomplices be evidence against him? Yet the evidence of Wilkinson relates, in part, to the confession of pretended accomplices no way proved to have been authorised by col. Burr to say or do any thing.
But why, it may be asked, is col Burr afraid to hear illegal evidence, if he is consciously innocent.
See moreSee less
We see witnesses from different, and distant parts of the U. S. whose names, faces and characters, are alike unknown to col. Burr. He cannot ascertain upon what part of his life, or conduct
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This passage records courtroom dialogue during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with attorneys and the Chief Justice discussing delays in proceedings pending the arrival of General Wilkinson and related witnesses. Burr himself addresses the court about correspondence that should be produced in evidence, and the grand jury is adjourned until the next day.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 15 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
sir. Mr. Hay. These vessels may convey some intelligence to Washington respecting general Wilkinson which may consequently reach ourselves. Mr. Burr. I hope, sir, it will not be understood, from the observations of
The report relates circumstances behind claims that General Wilkinson received a letter from General Dayton referencing Burr's conspiracy, with cryptic phrases like 'Louisiana—Mexico—Burr & Wilkinson.' It describes how the letter, partly in cipher, was read before the superior court and the House of Representatives, and translated into French.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 15 June 1807 · page 3
"A: lhc time governor Claibnme coral-Lia 'nicated to me all Lhw he had learned immj ger, Wictlkinson, he men*"ioned amongo h-r 1 things that gen. sizW' lkios on had received a letter from gem. Dctw on in whirh waszhcee ctrem'ark ble words "Law'ssiianasi, m Uexfca— Burrssict Wilctz'ns'an." W heo a p lbsic dis closme Of this "plot'wes {afterWzrds "shade, this let: er of ge eneral Dactrron's was every where spoken of, and seemed to" form a "part of n. S-ss-versialof my friends, person: of the highest res'peccab'zmy; informed me: the: thcv had heard of the same lec'ter, and re "pcated to me Such par s of its coutencsasro convince me it Was the same letter he go vernor had mentioned to me.
See moreSee less
I was n'ot present at the assembiy' of the merchants"; burl had understood that this letter was read "there as well a: {) fore the superior court. in short, gen Duyoo'olener had m my mind become so identisir (! wnh Burr' o {ba} they akways presented thewselves to. L gether. _ _ ] In thesil'touse'c'rf repr'ea'entatlves general Wilkinson read this same letter, and it wasl translated intosiFt-enc'h by the clerk. This letter was partly in -Cypher,'and partly in common character. siltss'bc-gan'by prcnieting to the genekal The [one nsthe government'of Louioiana. and hinIEd— insivefyistrong terms her he was s'inktng in the ssconsifidence (if his siountry-si—shat'M r. "] iffers'on might affec: to a'ssrve him,:bux'tcthat he would final-fy yield sin public opinion, and after talking about ct tra-Apeconcluded wissh "Lauisiana' &} Alex si ica—Burr &? {V.-[Limons' lwfll not pre l tend tu say that-general Dctytonsi-nthe author ' ' of this lever,-, but lpo-ss-ttivcly a-fflrm that such a letter ex'is'u-dctand pledge myself to prmesiwh'enevcr 't_._ may be necessary, that 7 s Wilkmatsisin ssct-gave Dsiayton zs the author, } if not pu'blicly, at least ssin-privnte conver sations. 'si 1 ?, -I am, _ - sss Very respemsisully, 'Ztc; , _ _ . ? _ ss-]OHN siWA'sKlNS. si' ! nou 3 The following is a part esthe-presenrmeassts ct ; made by the grandy jury at the opening ; ? of the present term of the aupe'rior 2' cou'rt : - - i ; The grand jumrs, 'in addition to the z' hill: of "indictment which they have scund. si Present to the honorable say:-ries court, as ,
Defense counsel argues before the court that Burr is entitled to subpoena witnesses and documents in his defense, comparing the situation to the Smith and Ogden trial where subpoenas were issued to Madison and Dearborn. The speaker contends there is legal precedent for such subpoenas even against government officials, though an attachment motion in that earlier case had divided the judges.
The Enquirer · 15 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR
But at what time are we to be entitled to these privileges? At the period of Col. B's transportation? That is a most unwarrantable proceeding; there is no such case recognized by the constitution; and therefore there could be nothing in that constitution to give us the right of founding any judicial proceeding on such a step. But, sir, such an illegal transaction entitles us to still more, it entitles to the protection of every citizen in the country; as well as of this court.—Suppose that Col. Burr was now put on his examination; would he
Attorneys debate whether the court has authority to issue a subpoena duces tecum for Burr's defense before the finding of indictments, citing Magna Charta and precedent cases. The exchange includes sharp disagreements between counsel, including Mr. Martin and Mr. Hay, over procedural timing and the legitimacy of such subpoenas.
The Enquirer · 15 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
We have heard some remarks upon Col. Burr's privileges: and among others, upon the four Counsellors who are to defend him. But what kind of an argument is this? If we turn to the Laws of Congress, we shall find there is one attorney for the U. S. appropriated to each district: And yet there are no less than three counsellors employed on the present occasion. No doubt there is a law providing for the payment of the two others out of the treasury; but with what propriety can these gentlemen complain of my client making such arrangements, as may suit his convenience or his interest?--But what are all these remarks
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 18 June 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
The report describes General Adair's arrival in New Orleans amid suspicions of involvement in Burr's conspiracy, followed by his violent arrest by 120 regular troops under Colonel Kingsbury later that day. The city was thrown into alarm as volunteers and troops were mobilized, and several other local officials were also detained.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 15 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
is true, was wandering through that and the neighbouring states in a suspicious manner; some apprehension had been excited in the publick mind, and he had been twice arraigned before the district court of Kentucky, for hostile intention against the peace of the union, but was acquitted on both occasions. Such was the situation of affairs, when in the afternoon of the 14th Jan. gen. Adair arrived among us. This gentleman, it had been reported, was to hold a distinguished command in Burr's army. He made his entry into this city about one o'clock, alone and unarmed.
See moreSee less
He took up his lodging at a publick boarding-house, and being indisposed sent a messenger to the governour to inform him of his arrival, and requesting that information might be sent to Wilkinson to the same effect. He mentioned that
A speaker addresses a legislative chamber, arguing that while Burr clearly conspired, the true origin of the plot lies deeper than Burr's letters or Wilkinson's claims. He recounts an alleged conversation between Burr and Wilkinson hinting at designs on Mexico, questioning the governor's suspension of civil liberties to pursue the suspected conspirator.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 15 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Chairman, you will not be induced to believe that I have any doubt of the existence of a plan perhaps to subvert our government, and certainly to invade the dominions of Spain. On the contrary, sir, I most firmly believe it; I believe that such a plan has long been in agitation, that it has taken deep root and spread thro' the U. States. But, sir, I am persuaded, from the facts I have detailed, that I can convince you, this honourable house, and the whole world, that its origin is not to be found in Burr's cyphered letters, in Dayton's communications, or in Burr's agents to Wilkinson; and that its defeat is not to be ascribed to the affected patriotism of either Wilkinson or Claiborne.
See moreSee less
The officiously lopping off limbs to preserve the body may answer the ambitious, avaricious purposes of an ignorant quack, but will never meet the sanction of a sound intelligent physician, who, upon taking a view of the whole distemper, clearly sees that such mutilations can have no other effect than to weaken the body, and hurry the patient to death. I have no idea that your constitution is to be preserved by trampling it under foot—that your laws are to be maintained by setting them at defiance. No man will doubt that Burr was a conspirator, and, if we believe Wilkinson, that Dayton and many others were concerned with him. Let us look at his conduct. If I am not mistaken, the last time he met the general at the Federal City, he accosted him nearly in the following words:—(my authority is gov. Claiborne). General, what are you about—what has become of your ambition—your love of glory & dangerous enterprize? I possess these qualities (replied the general) in the same degree I ever did. Then what are you doing here? said Burr. Point out to me a field (said the general) and I am your man. Burr pointed to Mexico—and the remainder of the conversation was in secret, and is still unknown to us.
This report details the ongoing treason trial of Aaron Burr in Richmond, describing new bail terms set by the court (40,000 dollars total) and the delay of indictments pending General Wilkinson's arrival as a witness. It also notes the crowded conditions in Richmond due to the trial and lists prominent witnesses present, including Swartwout, Bollman, Ogden, Eaton, and Truxton.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 16 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
and not otherwise !”
Another letter says, that 40 witnesses on behalf of Burr, attend Court from day to day.
See moreSee less
June 6.--The Richmond Enquirer, of May 30 contains 13 columns of the Pro
This report covers courtroom proceedings before Chief Justice John Marshall and Judge Cyrus Griffin in the Circuit Court for Virginia, concerning a motion to commit Aaron Burr for high treason. Defense counsel Wickham argues forcefully against the admission of affidavits in place of live witness testimony, insisting only legal, competent evidence be allowed.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 16 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR. Circuit Court of the United States for the fifth Circuit and District of Virginia. Present JOHN MARSHALL, chief Justice of the United States, And CYRUS GRIFFIN, judge of the district of Virginia.
Wednesday, May 27.
See moreSee less
Debate on the order and species of evidence to be introduced, on the motion to commit Aaron Burr for High Treason against the U. S.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Defense counsel Wickham objects to the prosecution's introduction of General Wilkinson's affidavit, arguing Burr has a right to confront and cross-examine Wilkinson directly rather than rely on written testimony. He notes Wilkinson could have traveled to Richmond in time, questions why no subpoena was issued, and argues the affidavit does not establish any treasonous act committed in Virginia.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 17 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
dence that they pleased? It cannot be supposed, said Mr. W. that we are afraid of this affidavit; what is in it, which has not been already known and scattered in every loose sheet of a newspaper throughout the U. States? It is not that we resist it in point of fact; but on the ground of principle. We wish two points to be settled; are affidavits to be read at all on such a motion? And at such a crisis of the prosecution as this? And if so, ought they to be read if the witnesses themselves were present?
See moreSee less
Would it be right, if they were in the next street or the next county? Would it in fact be right if there was time enough to produce the viva voce testimony itself? Mr. Burr had a right to be confronted with General Wilkinson. He had a
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 16 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Defense attorneys Wickham and Randolph argue that General Wilkinson's affidavit should not be admitted as evidence, citing the constitutional right to confront witnesses and the requirement of best evidence. Prosecutor Hay counters that they will prove more than the affidavit suggests, including Burr's reaction upon learning of the cyphered letter's publication.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 17 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
the denunciations which escaped from Mr. Burr, when he first heard of the publication of his cyphered letter?— Let them first know what we can prove, before they abandon themselves to their triumph. General Wilkinson's affidavit is the first in the series of our proofs, and it is for this reason that we wish to commence with it. Mr. E. Randolph. Sir, we do not know what those gentlemen expect to prove. But we do object to the production of gen. Wilkinson's affidavit from what is already known; we know it to be perfectly inapplicable to the present question. Sir, this species of evidence is directly in the face of our bill of rights and of the constitution of the U. S. "In all criminal prosecutions the
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Defense counsel argues Col. Burr has a constitutional right to be confronted by witnesses against him, challenging the use of General Wilkinson's affidavit instead of live testimony. The Chief Justice notes the Supreme Court had ruled such affidavits insufficient to establish an overt act, leading to further debate among counsel about proper procedure and evidentiary standards.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 17 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
but they had also determined that gen. Wilkinson's affidavit did not contain any proof of an overt act; that he was certainly extremely willing to permit the attorney for the U. S. to pursue his own course in the order of drawing out his evidence, under a full confidence that he would not waste the time of the court by producing any extraneous matter; but where was the necessity of producing gen. W's affidavit first? If there was no other evidence to prove the overt act; Wilkinson's affidavit goes for nothing; for so the supreme court of the U.
See moreSee less
S. have already decided; and by that decision he should have conceived himself bound, even if he had dissented from it. Why then produce this affidavit? Mr. Hay observed, that there was a great difference between the course prescribed by the court and the one which he would have himself pursued; and that he seriously believed, if he had been left to himself, he would at least have satisfied the court itself that his own course was the best; that as to gen. Wilkinson's affidavit, it might even now be confronted with witnesses; as
The court ruled in favor of Burr's counsel for a subpoena to obtain dispatches from General Wilkinson, who arrived just as the grand jury's patience was nearly exhausted. The grand jury heard testimony from several witnesses including Truxtun, Decatur, and Eaton, with forty total witnesses expected to be examined by the following Saturday.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 17 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WEDNESDAY EVENING, JUNE 17, 1807.
BURR'S TRIAL.—The last mail brought no Richmond papers, which puts it out of our power to furnish any details on this subject.
See moreSee less
We learn however that the Court decided in favour of the motion of Col. Burr's counsel for a subpoena duces tecum, directed to the President or Secretary of State, commanding them to produce a certain dispatch from General Wilkinson.
The General arrived on Saturday morning, on which day the District Attorney for the United States presented two Bills to the Grand Jury, against Burr and Blannerhassett, for a misdemeanor and treason. Commodore Truxtun, Mr. Stoddert, Captain Decatur, General Eaton, and Bollman were before the Grand Jury on Saturday and Monday. General Wilkinson had not been called for on Monday afternoon. There are forty witnesses to be examined by the Grand Jury, who it is expected will not have gone through the examination until Saturday next.
It is reported that the arrival of General Wilkinson was very seasonable, as the patience of every one concerned was nearly exhausted, and a discharge of the Grand Jury had nearly been the consequence of his delay. If that had been the case, the publick would have had great cause to regret the General's having stopped at the Havanna, on his way from New Orleans. We have not understood for what cause the Ranger which brought the General stopped at Havanna.
The Federalists are charged with being the advocates of Burr, and that purely from motives of opposition to the present administration; in answer to which we might say that the democrats are his enemies, from their determination to support the administration, (and ruin every man opposed to it) whether Burr be guilty or innocent. This is assertion against assertion, and proves nothing. With respect to the motives which the democrats are actuated by, we have no knowledge of them, and shall not call them in question. But with respect to the Federalists, we think their conduct is such as from their situation they might have been expected to pursue. It is not to save col. Burr, or to serve him that the federal-
This opinion piece argues that federalist support for Burr and his accused accomplices (Bollman, Swartwout, Adair) stemmed from principled defense of constitutional liberties like habeas corpus, not from sympathy for treason. It contrasts federalist caution with democrats' reluctance to post bail for Burr, suggesting political motives influenced who was willing to support his legal rights.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 17 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
are termed federalists, but would have soon extended itself far and wide, nor have ceased until the constitution itself had been subverted. With such sentiments then, the federalists saw with deep concern, the manner in which persons who were denounced as accomplices to Burr were treated. It was impossible to defend the constitution and laws, violated in the persons of Bollman, Swartwout, Adair, &c. without in some degree to appearance, defending the accused. By a connection and sympathy, Burr himself became an object of interest and concern. But never have the federalists advocated him further than that he should have a fair and impartial trial, and stand condemned or acquitted according to the result, nor have they gone thus far for the sake of col.
See moreSee less
Burr, but from respect and attachment to the laws of their country. We are aware
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · and 1 other paper
Defense counsel moves for a subpoena duces tecum compelling President Jefferson to produce General Wilkinson's original letter, referenced in his January message to Congress. Prosecutor Hay objects that the motion is premature, arguing Burr's recognizance for a misdemeanor does not entitle him to such process before any indictment is found.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
to give his consent, that process should issue.
Mr. Hay observed, that he had not distinctly heard the gentleman; he thought, however, that he had heard the word "consent;" but he would assure that gentleman that he had not consented, and never would consent to such a proposition.
See moreSee less
Mr. Martin then rose to open the motion; when some desultory discussion ensued upon the order of proceeding. Mr. Hay contended that this question was premature; that the preliminary question ought first to be settled, whether colonel Burr did stand in such a situation, as to entitle him to make this motion: If the court pleased, he would state the grounds on which he himself denied the existence of such a right.
The Chief Justice decided that Mr. Hay might state his objections. Mr. H. then proceeded.
The motion now made by Mr. Burr, as far as he could understand it, was to obtain a subpoena from the court (or rather from the judges sitting there) to the president of the U. S. to attend this court with an original letter from general Wilkinson to the president of the United States, and af
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 19 June 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
The passage records courtroom argument over whether Dr. Bollman has been pardoned and whether he must testify before the Grand Jury despite refusing to accept that pardon. Counsel dispute legal principles about self-incrimination and whether a witness or the court decides if a question must be answered.
The Enquirer · 17 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
not. If the Executive should refuse to pardon him, he is certainly not pardoned.—Mr. Martin. But there can be no doubt, if he chooses to decline his pardon, that he stands in the same situation with every other witness, who cannot be forced to criminate themselves. Some desultory conversation here ensued; when Mr. Hay observed that he should extremely regret the loss of Dr. B's testimony: he believed it to be material: he trusted that he should obtain it, however reluctantly given: the court would perceive that Dr. Bollman now possessed so much zeal, as even to encounter the risk of an indictment for treason.—Whether he should appear before the Grand Jury under the circumstance of a pardon being annexed to his name, might hereafter become the object of a distinct arrangement.
See moreSee less
In the mean time, he might go up without any such notification.—Counsel for Mr. Burr acquiesced.—Chief Justice. Whether he is really
Lawyers in the Burr treason trial argue over whether written documents, such as letters allegedly from Burr, constitute proper evidence for a grand or petit jury. Hay, Wirt, Martin, and Botts debate precedents including a Senate ruling and a case called Danby's, disputing whether papers are the best evidence or merely supplementary testimony.
The Enquirer · 17 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
that on such a day he received a letter from A. Burr by the hands of Bollman or Swartwout, might he not say to the jury " Here is the letter. I am ready to read it." Would it not be competent for a Grand or even a Petit Jury to hear it ? Such let-
Reporters describe courtroom arguments in Aaron Burr's treason trial over a motion for a subpoena duces tecum to compel President Jefferson to produce documents. Burr's counsel argues that no claim of state secrecy or policy can justify withholding evidence needed for an individual's defense when life is at stake.
Virginia Argus · 17 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 17, 1807.
Gen. Wilkinson and suite, with a number of other witnesses in the case of the United States against A. Burr, arrived in this city on Saturday morning. Among the witnesses are Mr. Graham, Secretary of the Territory of Orleans, Lieuts. Gaines
Lawyers Botts, Wirt, and Wickham debate whether a subpoena duces tecum can compel President Jefferson to produce documents related to General Wilkinson's letter, referencing Judge Chase's earlier ruling in the Cooper case. Wirt argues for the prosecution that summoning a person as a witness differs legally from compelling production of specific papers, which requires court discretion.
Virginia Argus · 17 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
RICHMOND;
As to the argument that a copy of Gen. Wilkinson's letter will be sufficient; suppose, said Mr. Botts, Gen. Wilkinson should swear to one thing and the copy of his letter should say another, would you condemned him upon the President's
During courtroom proceedings, defense counsel McRae objected to a phrase in the Chief Justice's written opinion suggesting the prosecution wished Burr's conviction regardless of guilt. The Chief Justice clarified and struck the phrase, and the report notes Gen. Wilkinson was sworn in before the grand jury examining witnesses against Burr.
Virginia Argus · 17 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
It is observable that, when the opinion was read from the bench, it contained an expression to the following purport—"If this prosecution shall terminate, as it is expected and wished on the part of the U. States, in the conviction of Aaron Burr." After the Chief Justice had pronounced it, Mr. M'Rae said he hoped he had misunderstood a part of the opinion which he had just heard; he hoped the court was incapable of saying that the government of the United States wished the prosecution to terminate in the conviction of Aaron Burr: he denied this to be the wish of himself, and believed that it was not the wish of the gentlemen with whom he had the honor to act. If he had understood the court correctly, he hoped the expression was written inadvertently and accidentally; for nothing would wound his feelings more than that his Honor should believe it was their wish that Aaron Burr should be found guilty, at any rate, whether really guilty or innocent.
The Chief Justice answered that gentlemen had repeatedly declared their conviction that Aaron Burr was guilty. If so, they must wish him to be convicted.
See moreSee less
Mr. M'Rae. Our declarations have been only as to our opinions concerning the evidence.
The Chief Justice afterwards, before the court adjourned, declared that he had struck out of his opinion the expression that the United States wished Mr. Burr to be convicted; that he had done this to prevent its being misunderstood; for his meaning was not that they wished him to be convicted whether guilty or not; but that as the counsel believed him guilty, they must necessarily wish him to be convicted, if guilty.
On Monday last, Gen. Wilkinson was sworn as a witness, and sent to the Grand Jury.
The Federal Grand Jury have been engaged since Saturday last in the examination of the witnesses against Aaron Burr. Gen. Eaton was before the jury nearly the whole of Monday last. It is expected that the examination of the witnesses will occupy the Grand Jury for six or seven days longer.
The report notes that Samuel Fairlamb, a Marietta newspaper editor and witness for the United States in Burr's trial, had been advertised as having incited slaves to revolt, but was passing through Frederick-Town on his way home. The writer expresses skepticism that Fairlamb was capable of such acts, suggesting he may have been duped rather than guilty.
Virginia Argus · 17 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FREDERICK-TOWN, (Mar.) June 11.
Samuel Fairlamb, who has been advertised in the Richmond Impartial Observer, as having been detected in instigating the negroes to revolt and massacre, passed through this place a few days since, on his return to Marietta. From our knowledge of Mr. Fairlamb, we do not believe him capable of the attempts with which he is charged; but think it much more probable that he has been the dupe of machination, and that his elopement has proceeded from such cause. Mr. F. is editor of a newspaper at Marietta, and was one of the witnesses for the United States on the trial of Col. Burr.
The report describes pretrial proceedings in Richmond where attorney Hay argued for Burr's commitment on treason charges while awaiting General Wilkinson's testimony. Burr was released on $10,000 bail with matching security, and a letter printed in the Aurora claimed the cipher used in Burr's correspondence was written by Wilkinson's aide, not part of any conspiracy.
The Wheeling Repository · 18 June 1807 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
THURSDAY, 17th JUNE, 1807.
Trial of Burr.
See moreSee less
On Wednesday the 27th May, Mr. Hay, the attorney for the United States, opened his testimony in support of the motion to commit Burr on a charge of
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Aaron Burr submitted a sworn affidavit requesting a subpoena duces tecum for correspondence between General Wilkinson and President Jefferson, plus military and naval orders concerning Burr, arguing these documents were material to his defense. Mr. Hay noted he had already written to the President about the request, though reserving the right to review the papers' materiality before full disclosure.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF Col. AARON BURR.
Debate on the motion for a Subpoena Duces Tecum.
Wednesday, June 10.
See moreSee less
An affidavit was drawn up by Mr. Burr, stating that certain papers in the possession of the President might be material to his defence; which affidavit is in the following terms:
AARON BURR, vs. UNITED STATES. Court of the U. S. 5th Circuit and District of Va.
Aaron Burr maketh oath, that he hath great reason to believe that a letter from gen. Wilkinson to the President of the U. S. dated 21st October, 1806, as mentioned in the President's message of the 22d January, 1807, to both houses of Congress, together with the documents accompanying the same letter, and a copy of the answer of said Thomas Jefferson, or of any one by his authority to the said letter, may be material in his defence in the prosecution against him—& further, that he hath reason to believe the military & naval orders given by the President of the U. S. through the departments of war and of the navy, to the officers of the army & navy, at or near the New Orleans stations, touching or concerning the said Burr, or his property, will also be material in his defence.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers
The report records arguments before Chief Justice Marshall on whether Aaron Burr, as the accused, has a right to compel production of papers via subpoena duces tecum. Lawyers including Martin and Hay debate legal precedent, while the Chief Justice reserves his opinion on the point for later decision.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
fin[d]ing of the bills.
Mr. Martin replied, that if there were no precedents on this very point, it was because this objection never was made before; and he hoped never would be made again.
See moreSee less
Here a desultory conversation ensued—when Mr. Hay observed, that gentlemen affected to believe that the present course pursued by the prosecution was dictated by a wish to suppress the evidence; that he conjured the gentlemen to remember that he had voluntarily applied for the papers which they wanted; and had no doubt of obtaining them; and that he made these remarks to guard any human being from the suspicion that there was any indisposition to refuse the papers; that he should exert himself with not less zeal to obtain the evidence that was wanted for Col. Burr, than that which might be produced against him.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 18 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Defense counsel (Martin) argues Burr is entitled to a letter from Wilkinson received by the President and copies of military/naval orders, asserting these are necessary for the defense and were wrongly refused. He accuses President Jefferson of prejudging Burr's guilt publicly and unfairly withholding documents needed for a fair trial.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ing effect?—I have asserted that Col. Burr was entitled to a copy of these orders. We intended to shew that these orders were contrary to the constitution and the laws, and that they entitled Col. Burr to the right of resistance. We intended to shew, that by this particular order his property and his person were to be destroyed; yet, by these tyrannical orders the life and property of an innocent man were to be exposed to destruction. We did not expect these originals themselves; because
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A defense attorney for Aaron Burr argues passionately in court that the accused has a right to access certain documents from the Secretaries of State, Navy, and War, including a letter from General Wilkinson to the President. He accuses President Jefferson of prejudging Burr's guilt and attempting to withhold evidence material to the defense, arguing this is a violation of the sacred principle that the accused deserves all evidence necessary for his defense.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
But why do th y attribute motives to Col. Burr's counsel, which they would themselves disdain ? Why not as much honor to ourselves as to the President of the U. S. himself?
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A Richmond letter describes General Wilkinson being feted at a public dinner alongside other military and political figures, predicting he will emerge from the affair with honor. It also reports Burr's plan to subpoena President Jefferson for a Wilkinson letter, amid courtroom friction involving the chief justice.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 3
Extract of a letter from Richmond, dated VZth June, IgOT. •' Gin. YViikiiwm w*..i yestt relay in vited to a puolic dinner by the Barbe cue Club, .t th. H ymarket g.ruens, together with commodore Truxton, Gen. Eaton, Mr. Graham, Secretary of the New-Orleans district, m ijor Murray, aid of Gen. Wilkinson, .nd several other puulic char cter*. Ihe General's at this place has very much altered the aspects of cer tain politicians, and I venture to pre dict with equal confidence as 1 have done on the same subject several months ago, that Gtn.
See moreSee less
Wilkinson will come cue of this business to the public satisfaction, and to his own hwtior—and in such a m.nner as will exhi it fede ralism in alliance with Burr in a most awkward and humiliating attitude, The chief justice has not appeared to very great advantage in the proceed ings on this case—-a very awkward proceeding occurred this day which he was under the necessity of retracing op the close of the court. Col. Burr means to send off this evening a sub poena du-ces tecum to the President of the U.S. requiring him to appear with a certain letter written by Gen. Wil kinson to the President from Natcbito ch s, 1 believe of 21st Nov.l.ist: this htter they say Is important to C»h'Ni-- Burr's defence, when in fact th *ewlo j have seen it, s:y i< coMainsnothing but I matter vof inculpation, and some, -fit*— i < t.iiistaiicc's v.hih require -ml t* be published* fro n souu't policy m iv, Ito foreign nations. therent uhject Is I m endeavor to throw odium iv th, President, under tjli < w.t at' his hold ing hiCkevidence, tthici Hue sw.ats in y be necessary to hi-, if* •; ac •, tut which any on*e might affirui I'ouhl n.vt render him any ma of servJCc wit ,t*. • v t, tb k>gh It might c" mv tt to Uis crituin.-aic/ii, and uvri&inlr »».d to , credit both For candor and msgnunimi- ( ! The work contain about "?v0 ty of gen. Wilkinson. We shall se —will be printed on gocd paper, and bye how they will act upon it—but i I and sold very low—so as merely to pay you may be assured that things wear a ; ' theexpencts of the ;;.;--,'.er and i, very gloomy aspect for the conspiracy. ; ] seller. Subscription* will be received The grand jury this cGy examined ' by most ot the commodore Truxton, general Eaton, ; masters, who are. desired to inf■■: on and Benjamin Stoddert." Messrs. Brisban and lir mnan, ot ': jYork, (postage paid) of tiie number To the Physician* 0/ the United States, , th. y will take, provided it exceed Cope s. The Subscriber, anxious to bo instru
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers
During the treason trial, Burr submitted an affidavit requesting a subpoena duces tecum for a letter from General Wilkinson to President Jefferson dated October 21, 1806, along with accompanying documents and any reply, arguing these could be material to his defense. He also sought military and naval orders concerning himself or his property near New Orleans. Prosecutor Hay noted he had already written to Jefferson about the request, reserving the right to assess the papers' materiality before releasing them.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
vs. UNITED STATES. Court of the U. S. 5th Circuit and District of Virginia.
AARON BURR maketh oath, that he hath great reason to believe that a letter from gen. Wilkinson to the President of the United States, dated 21st Oct. 1806, as mentioned in the President's message of the 22d Jan. 1807, to both houses of congress, together with the documents accompanying the same letter, and a copy of the answer of said Thomas Jefferson, or of any one by his authority to the said letter, may be material in his defence in the prosecution against him—and further, that he hath reason to believe the military and naval orders given by the President of the U. S. through the departments of war and of the navy, to the officers of the army and navy, at or near the New-Orleans stations, touching or concerning the said Burr, or his property, will also be material in his defence.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 3 July 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, attorneys argue over whether Burr has the legal standing to subpoena President Jefferson for a letter from General Wilkinson. U.S. Attorney Hay contends the motion is premature since Burr has not yet been indicted by the grand jury, while Burr's counsel pushes to proceed with the process.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
The Chief Justice decided that Mr. Hay might state his objections. Mr. H. then proceeded.
The motion now made by Mr. Burr, as far as he could understand it, was to obtain a subpoena from the court (or rather from the Judges sitting there) to the President of the U. State, to attend this court with an original letter from gen. Wilkinson to the President of the U. States, and afterwards referred
The report details courtroom debate between prosecutor Hay and the defense over whether the chief justice could give special instructions to the grand jury after already charging them generally. It also includes an editorial correction about misattributed speeches and unrelated foreign news from England.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ture of treason, and given all the information which he thought material: that there was no reason at all, why A. Burr should enjoy greater privileges than any other man; why he should rake up all the old, musty, and absurd doctrines of antiquity, and have them enlisted in his service; and that he stood on the very same ground as any other man.
(We were compelled to conclude here, as we think there was a mistake in making up the Enquirer, from which we copied, and which, the next number of that paper will we presume correct. We also took the liberty of assigning to Mr. Martin a speech which in the Enquirer was assigned to Mr. Wickham.)
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, attorneys debated whether witness Mr. Wyley could be compelled to answer questions about a partly-coded letter allegedly written or transcribed at Burr's direction. Burr's counsel argued such testimony might incriminate Wyley, citing British legal precedents, while prosecutors Hay and MacRae argued Wyley's ignorance of the cipher's meaning meant he couldn't be criminated by it.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Wyley and his counsel Mr. Williams, contended that giving answers to the questions of the attorney might criminate himself.
The questions proposed were briefly of the following nature. The attorney produced in court a letter partly in cypher and partly written in the Dutch language, which letter was alledged either to have been written by Mr. Wyley from col. Burr's direction, or copied by Mr. Wyley from an original in Burr's hand writing, by col. Burr's order.. The attorney therefore
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Prosecutor Hay and defense counsel argue over whether the overt act of treason or Burr's connection to it should be proven first, with the Chief Justice ruling evidence of the overt act must come first. Several affidavits and a coded letter are introduced, including testimony disputed on procedural grounds, and the court adjourns without final rulings on admissibility.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 19 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.
evidence as to the overt act, and that Gen. Wilkinson's affidavit was not at that time to be read.
Mr. Hay then called Peter Taylor and——Allbright, the first was Blannerhassett's gardener, the other had worked on his island. Of their testimo[ny]
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Prosecutor Hay presents an affidavit from Sergeant Dunbaugh, which defense counsel challenges as improperly authenticated, lacking proper caption and location. The court adjourns without ruling, then resumes the next day with the Grand Jury present and further argument over the affidavit's admissibility before the Chief Justice delivers the court's opinion.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 19 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.
The proceedings of yesterday, were end. The Grand Jury appeared in court and their names being called over, they were adjourned till to-morrow 10 o'clock.
William Duane, Esq. appeared as a witness for the U. S.
See moreSee less
Luther Martin, Esq. appeared as Counsel for Mr. Burr. He enquired of the court, whether he should qualify?
Chief Justice. It is the usual form; but, it is not absolutely material. It may be dispensed with.
Mr. Martin. I did suppose so; and as I am unwilling to take up the time of the court.—
The court then proceeded to the consideration of the point made yesterday, relative to Dubas' affidavit. A desultory conversation ensued between the counsel and the Bar, on the proceedings be-
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The court debates whether an unsworn affidavit can be admitted, distinguishing ministerial acts from judicial ones like administering oaths. Prosecutor Hay complains about delaying tactics and threatens to move that Burr be held to answer the treason charge if the examination isn't concluded that day.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 19 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
tion to it. All this time, however, Aaron Burr is at liberty, and he may depart from this city, at any moment that he pleases. On the very first day that I made this motion, he ought to have been held to bail or in custody, and day after day, until the court should have given their decision.—I expect Gen. Wilkinson here this day or tomorrow; as I have received a letter from the Secretary of War stating that he would probably be here on the 28th or 30th. As to Col.
See moreSee less
Burr's counsel, they may have that confidence in his innocence, which dismisses all apprehensions of his intention to escape. For my own part I freely confess that my confidence is much less and my fears infinitely greater.—I rise therefore to give notice, that unless this examination is finally settled this day, unless all the evidence and argument be concluded and the opinion of the court finally delivered, I shall move that he be bound to appear here tomorrow, to answer the charge of Treason. After some desultory conversation between opposite counsels; Mr. Hay proceeded: I know not, Sirs, whether this motion can be considered as regularly before the court. I certainly intended it as a mere notification of a motion, which I intended to make under certain circumstances. Is there any possible impropriety in such a motion? I consider A. Burr as standing here as if he were formally brought by a warrant before your Honour; as standing precisely in the same situation as he did before you on a former examination. At that time, sir, after having the evidence before you, though without hearing the argument of counsel, you bound him to bail from day to day. Mr. Wickham observed, that this was a most extraordinary motion: it was, however, ingenious; as it had the very effect which they had contemplated by the motion for commitment. It was stated, that Col. Burr is placed in the same situation, as he was on a former examination; and that the court ought, therefore, to bind him over from day to day as they did then. But the analogy is false. At that time, Col. Burr was not bound at all, and it might have been necessary to have demanded some pledge for his personal attendance. But
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Defense counsel Edmund Randolph addresses the court, objecting to a new demand for precedents justifying the proceedings against Burr. He recounts the sequence of events—military escort, depositions, misdemeanor charge, and bail—arguing the court's current stance is unprecedented and unjust.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 19 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
sir, and what did you say? You bound Col. Burr to bail, simply on the charge of a misdemeanor, to appear here at the opening of the court; but not contented with this security, you superadded, that he was not to leave the court until it had discharged him. You opened the door too for an ulterior prosecution; you declared, that if the attorney for the U. S. should obtain any additional evidence,
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The grand jury in Richmond adjourned pending the arrival of Gen. Wilkinson, whose testimony was expected soon based on Norfolk newspaper reports. Burr requested a subpoena duces tecum for government papers, and letters from Wilkinson indicated he expected to reach Richmond by June 16th.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 19 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
MARTINSBURG, June 19.
From Richmond we learn, that the grand jury met on Tuesday, the 9th inst. to which day it stood adjourned from the Wednesday preceeding. The district attorney observed that he had received no farther intelligence of gen. Wilkinson, except what a Norfolk paper furnished him. As he was in the daily expectation of his arrival, he hoped the grand jury would be again adjourned for a few days. After a few observations by the court and bar, it was adjourned until Thursday, 10 o'clock.
See moreSee less
After the grand jury were adjourned, col. Burr gave notice that he intended to
During Burr's treason trial, Mr. Hay reported on the president's response to a subpoena for papers, noting most were produced except an order regarding Burr's arrest. The court also addressed procedural matters, including limiting the number of counsel speaking and whether the pardoned Bollman must testify before the grand jury.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.
TUESDAY June 16.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay mentioned to the court the result of his application to the president of the United States, respecting the papers Col. Burr had required, which was the receipt of the several papers demanded; with the exception of the order that had been given for the arrest and destruction of Burr and his followers, because the order in question could not be produced without resorting to a vast and voluminous number of state papers, unless a particular specification was given of the order.
Mr. Martin replied, that it was impossible to give any particular specification of the order.
Mr. Hay said, the order was more comprehensive than the proposition which was made by the counsel of col. Burr had contemplated.
After some desultory remarks on both sides, it was agreed to wait the issue of the subpoena which had been forwarded. The court then signified on account of the waste of time which had taken place on arguments on trivial points, that some arrangement should take place respecting the number of counsel that should speak on either side.
During Burr's treason trial, lawyers Martin and Hay argue over how many counsel may speak and whether Dr. Bollman, as a pardoned man, must answer questions before the grand jury. Burr offers to submit a certificate about his refused presidential pardon, while debate continues over whether witness Wiley's copying of a coded letter could incriminate him.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR
of to day did not meet the pleasure of the gentleman, he had no objection it should be discussed afterwards.
Col. Burr rose and proposed, if the attorney would agree to send up along with Bollman, a certificate, stating a pardon had been voluntarily offered to him by the president, which pardon he refused, he would have no objection to submit the matter to the grand jury themselves.
During Burr's trial, attorneys argue over whether Dr. Bollman should be considered a pardoned man before testifying to the Grand Jury, with Burr insisting on clarifying Bollman's status despite his refusal of the pardon. The exchange includes disputes over cipher letter interpretation and the scope of questions already answered.
The Enquirer · 20 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR
every question which might be proposed.
Mr. Burr stated, that he had understood the question respecting Dr. B. to have been disposed of, the other day, by Mr. Hay's acquiescence. Dr. B. has been sent up before the G. Jury, and according to Mr. H's own confession, he knows not but he has disclosed all his information without reserve: "We will go on with yesterday's motion."
See moreSee less
Here a desultory conversation ensued, when Mr. Burr observed, that perhaps it would satisfy the attorney for the U. States, if he consented (which he would now do) that it be certified to the G. Jury, that Dr. B had received a voluntary and unsolicited pardon from the P. U. S. which he had refused. For these were facts.—Mr. Hay. An immense distance, sir, from the object of my wishes! I insist upon it, that Dr. B. is a pardoned man; and under that character I wish him to appear before the G. Jury.—There is one reason, sir, why I desire an immediate decision on this question
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 24 June 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 29 June 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
During Burr's treason trial, counsel argue over whether Dr. Bollman must decipher a cipher letter, and whether witness Willie can refuse to answer questions that might incriminate him. Defense counsel Bolts warns that cooperating could expose Willie to abuse by authorities in Louisiana, citing a case of a citizen imprisoned without charge merely for potentially testifying against Burr.
The Enquirer · 20 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
I have an interpreter at this moment under my eye. Mr. McRae. I ask Dr. Bollman, to look at the German of this letter, and not at the cypher. Mr. Martin. Let the court say, whether that is a proper question.
The Chief Justice decided, that Col. B's counsel should go on with the other point: How far a witness may refuse to answer a question, which he thinks would criminate himself?
See moreSee less
Mr. Botts. It has been again strongly insinuated, that Willie's claim to the privilege of not answering, pre-supposes his guilt.
Has Willie no reason to seek exemption from the examination, but such as may grow out of a consciousness of guilt?
The attorney for the U. States sees every object connected with Col. Burr, through a jaundiced medium: with him, "trifles as light as
The report details courtroom arguments in Aaron Burr's treason trial regarding a motion to compel production of General Wilkinson's letter as evidence. It discusses Judge Paterson's earlier ruling and the legal principle that a defendant has the right to obtain a witness's prior statements for impeachment purposes.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The first paper required is the letter of Gen. Wilkinson, which was referred to in the message of the president to congress. The application of that letter to the case, is shewn, by the terms in which the communication was made.
Prosecution attorney Hay contests the sufficiency of Burr's affidavit requesting General Wilkinson's letter, arguing its vague and equivocal language fails to establish the document's materiality to the defense. Hay warns that granting such a loosely justified subpoena would open all government archives to inspection on mere speculation.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
be said and no doubt will be said, and may be a very considerable help to Col. Burr.
The affidavit is truly farcical, because from any thing expressed in it the letter of Gen. Wilkinson may, or may not be material. Suppose those words "or may not" had been inserted would it then have been regarded? The absurdity would then have been too evident—And is it not the same thing in substance as it now stands? If such an affidavit as this is sufficient, and mere curiosity is to be indulged, the President might be required to produce all our csrrespondence with the Spaniards about our disputed territories; in short, all the papers of government would be laid open to the inspection of Burr. But the
This passage reports courtroom argument in the Burr treason trial over whether Wilkinson's letter and certain military orders are material enough to compel their production as evidence. The prosecution argues the defense has not properly sworn to the materiality of the documents and dismisses the defense's claim that the orders were unconstitutional as grounds for justifying Burr's actions.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
probably be so decided, if they were here. I have a knowledge of the orders and think so with respect to them. The letter I know nothing about. Mr. Wickham's argument that the court did right in Smith and Ogden's case, because it was prima facie presumable that the evidence would not be admissable, turns against him here; for, certainly, it is prima facie presumable that gen. Wilkinson's letter cannot make in Burr's favor, since the orders to intercept him on his passage to the seat of his empire were founded on the information received from that letter.
See moreSee less
The conduct of the gentlemen proves that they feel us to be right. Their involuntary conviction of this is evinced by their endeavoring to supply the defect in the affidavit, and to specify the purposes for which the papers are wanted. The accused has not ventured to swear that they are material, but they assert it and attempt to shew it by argument. First, as to the letter;—Mr. Wickham says, that Wilkinson has written other letters to other persons differing from this. We deny the fact. If it be true, why is it not sworn to? But suppose Gen. Wilkinson had done so, what is the inference? Is his evidence before the Jury not to be regarded? It is strange indeed that the gentlemen say they have never seen this letter and only guess at its contents, yet say that letters containing different statements have been written! Surely such efforts as these are deplorable; for, whether the assertion be true or not, it is not known to be true. They next contend that the orders are material because they were illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional, oppressive and unjust; that Burr's acts were merely acts of self-defence against tyranny and usurpati[on]
A defense attorney argues before the court regarding the subpoena of papers to compare General James Wilkinson's official military correspondence against his other statements, aiming to show inconsistencies in his account. The speaker contends Wilkinson is central to the prosecution's case and suggests his testimony may be unreliable due to self-interest or desperation.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
be excused by the worthy gentlemen, if I tell them they are a little inconsistent. In throwing obstacles in our way against obtaining the papers for which we have moved the Court to issue a subpoena, they imitate that bad example, which they have imputed to us---What is the nature of the evidence we do ask? We ask for that sort of evidence which may enable us to confront James Wilkinson with himself.--- There is not an idea beyond this---We wish to shew that James Wilkinson in his official capacity as commander of the army of the United States at New-Orleans, is not the same with James Wilkinson the correspondent of the President. We wish to prove that James Wilkinson has varied from himself, and that he has varied in most essential points in the greatest degree. Mr. Hay tells us, that every thing depends upon this same James Wilkinson, that he is in reality the Alpha and Omega of the present prosecution—He is in short to support by his depesition the sing song & the ballards of treason and conspiracy, which he have heard delivered from one extremity of the continent to the other. The funeral pile of the prosecution, is already prepared by the hands of the public Attorney, and nothing is wanting to kindle the fatal blaze, but the torch of James Wilkinson. He is to exhibit himself in a most conspicuous point of view in the Tragedy which is fancied will take place. He James Wilkinson, is to officiate as the High Priest of this human sacrifice.
Of James Wilkinson we are not afraid in whatever shape he may be produced, in whatever form he may appear before this court. We are only afraid of those effects which desperation may produce in his mind. Desperation, please the Court, is a word of great fitness in the present case General Wilkinson we behold first acting as a conspirator to ensnare others, afterwards as a patriot to betray others from motives of patriotism. What must be the embarrassment of this man when the awful catastrophe arrives, that he must either substantiate his own innocence by the conviction of another, or be himself regarded as a traitor and conspirator in the event of the acquittal of the accused.
See moreSee less
(Remainder of Mr. Randolph's speech in our next.)
A sketch of the most important recent proceedings.
SATURDAY, June 13th. 1807
Col. Burr said, he hoped the court had perused the instructions, which he had wished them
The passage reports part of Mr. Randolph's speech attacking General James Wilkinson's dubious role as accuser and potential conspirator in the Burr case. It also details a procedural dispute on June 20, 1807, over whether the court's supplemental charge to the grand jury should be delivered before witness examinations began.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
livered on that day.
Col. Burr and his counsel wished the supplemental charge to be delivered to the grand jury before they proceeded any farther in examining the witnesses; alledging that they could send no evidence to the grand jury; that that body ought
The Chief Justice ruled on a subpoena duces tecum motion and reaffirmed that treason requires proof of an overt act of levying war, not mere suspicion. The prosecution then called a long list of witnesses including Truxton, Eaton, Decatur, and Dr. Bollman, with discussion over whether Bollman's presidential pardon made him a competent witness.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
George Harris, Cyrus Jones, Thomas Peterkin, Simeon Poole, Dudly Woodbridge, Edmund B. Dana, James Read, Charles Willie, (said to be Col. Curr's private secretary), P. H. M. Prevost, John G. Henderson, Hugh Phelps, Alexander Henderson, David C. Wallace, Ambrose Smith, Charles Lindsay, John Marshallen, James Knox, William Love, David Fisk, Thomas Heartly, Stephen S. Welch, James Kinney, Samuel Moxley, A. D. Smith, Elias Glover, Peter Taylor and Jacob Allbright. Gen Wilkinson, having just arrived in town, and being much fatigued, was not called.
Col. Burr's counsel reported that a subpoena duces tecum served on President Jefferson had been returned without a direct answer, with notice given to move enforcement of the process. Burr's counsel also presented affidavits from witnesses intended to support a motion against Gen. Wilkinson, which prosecution counsel argued should be rejected as slanderous and unfounded.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
before any argument should be had: in order that the grounds intended to be taken on behalf of Col. Burr, should be better understood; and that the motion should be made the following day. Mr Hay thought this very proper, but wished the court, (if they should be of opinion, after examining those affidavits, that they contained nothing on which the motion could be founded,) to reject them altogether; but, if they entertained any doubts, to direct an argument on the subject. He observed that, from a single glance at one of them, he had noted an expression so monstrous, it convinced him of the falsehood of the whole; that they were evidently intended only to slander Gen.
See moreSee less
Wilkinson, and thereby to make an improper impression on the public mind with respect to the trial of Aaron Burr; and had been obtained from persons who were willing to say any thing to answer the purposes of the accused, but very reluctant to give any evidence on behalf of the United States. After a series of desultory conversation, in which Col. Burr's counsel endeavored to vindicate the witnesses whose affidavits
The report details courtroom motions in the Burr treason proceedings, including a motion to hold General Wilkinson in contempt for obstructing justice regarding witness affidavits. It also covers a dispute over whether both prosecution and defense could submit interrogatories to the grand jury, with the Chief Justice weighing in on the propriety of such a practice.
Virginia Argus · 20 June 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
RICHMOND:
this mysterious business.
The Chief Justice asked if there was any objection on the other side to this mode of proceeding. Col. Burr's counsel agreed to it, provided interrogatories might also be sent by them. The Chief Justice said
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
This report details courtroom arguments before the grand jury in Aaron Burr's treason trial, including disputes over subpoenaing documents and witnesses refusing to testify on self-incrimination grounds. Key witnesses like General Wilkinson, Erick Bollman, and Mr. Wyllie were called, with legal arguments over pardons and cipher letters delaying proceedings.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
appeared. Before he was sworn Mr. Hay informed the court that he had made a full communication to the government of the plans, the designs, and views of A. Burr. As these communications might criminate Dr. B. before the grand jury, the President had communicated his pardon—which Mr. Hay here offered to Dr. B. and which the latter refused accepting.
The counsel for Burr contended that this did not amount to a pardon, and that consequently Bollman could not be called upon to answer questions which might criminate himself. This point was contested by the opposite counsel. Dr. Bollman was sent to the grand jury without any special intimation; the point under dissussion being referred for future consideration.
See moreSee less
William Duane, Peter Taylor, ---- Albright, and Jacob Dunbar were sworn and sent to the grand jury.
On Monday gen. Wilkinson was sworn and conducted to the grand jury. A long argument was had on a motion made by the counsel of Mr. Burr, to instruct the grand jury not to receive written papers as testimony. The decision of the court is not given. Mr. Hay proposed sending to the grand jury the letter partly in cypher and partly in German, addressed to some person in New Orleans, and said Mr. Wyllie could prove its identity, and Dr. B. interpret it. This was strenuously opposed by Mr. Burr's counsel. Mr. Wyllie was called into court, and interrogated as to his knowledge of this letter. These questions by the advice of his counsel, he declined answering, under the allegation that the answers would criminate himself as much as Mr. Burr. Here a long argument ensued on compelling Mr. Wyllie to answer the proposed questions, which was not finished this day.
On Tuesday Mr. Hay produced a letter to him from the President of the U.S. stating that the letter of general Wilkinson of the 21st Oct. had been placed in the hands of the attorney ge-
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 26 June 1807
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The piece mocks the poor reception given to General Eaton in Richmond and sarcastically compares him to General Wilkinson, who was implicated in testimony against Burr. It plays on rumors of Wilkinson's dubious conduct and questions his honor versus Eaton's fame from Derne.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 22 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
A PAIR OF GENERALS. "The one is already arrived: the other is said still to be traversing and doubling about in a wild stormy ocean, his friends being apprehensive that he may possibly be swallowed up by the gulph stream, tho his enemies insist upon it, that such a bag of froth would float a thousand miles without sinking. The one took the town of New-Orleans from within: The other seized the town of Derne from without. What astonishing gallantry—Bravissimo!—The one is a man of rank and honor—the other is a soldier of fortune, whose goddess has lately smiled upon him and prevented him from being lodged in a prison.—If Gen.
See moreSee less
E. says that Gen. W. has behaved like a d——d r——l in the affair which is hanging over Col. Burr. Quere, what will the redoubtable hero of the south say, of the conduct of the valient knight of the north? The general who is now here may be distinguished by several characteristic and peculiar circumstances, one of which is, that he is generally alone, both in the streets and out of them: From which it is presumed either that he looks with contempt upon common citizens, or that they look with contempt upon him.—Possibly, however, they may only avoid him as a man dangerous in every shape.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The report describes Burr's trial as a prolonged 'comic State farce,' with the jury dismissed and proceedings adjourned day to day due to the non-arrival of General Wilkinson, called the pivotal figure in the case. It notes that the lengthy arguments of Burr and his counsel were reported in southern papers but omitted here for brevity.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 22 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
BURR'S TRIAL.
The great comic State farce of Burr's trial still hangs on. The jury is dismissed, and adjourned from day to day on account of the non-arrival of Gen. Wilkinson ; who appears to be the pivot on which this mighty affair is to turn.
See moreSee less
The southern papers contain the arguments of Col. Burr, and his council to the Court, but they are too lengthy for insertion in a weekly journal.
During the treason trial of Col. Burr, the chief justice issued an opinion on a motion to subpoena President Jefferson and certain papers, including orders for Burr's apprehension and correspondence with General Wilkinson. The ruling addressed the prosecution's objection that a defendant cannot obtain subpoenas before a grand jury indictment, with the court favoring the traditional right of the accused to compel witness testimony for his defense.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 22 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
OPINION. The object of the motion now to be decided, is to obtain copies of certain orders understood to have been issued to the land and naval officers of the U. States for the apprehension of the accused; and an original letter from general Wilkinson to the president, in relation to the accused, with the answer of
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
At the Burr treason trial, prosecutor Hay reads a letter from President Jefferson addressing the subpoena for documents, including General Wilkinson's letter. Jefferson asserts his right to decide what papers may be disclosed in the public interest, while expressing willingness to furnish materials necessary for justice, and notes logistical issues in locating the specific papers requested.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 22 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
read this following letter from the President of the United States.
Washington, June 12, 1807.
See moreSee less
Sir, Your letter of the 9th is this moment received. Reserving the necessary right of the President of the U. S. to decide, independent of all other authority, what papers, coming to him as President, the public's interests permit to be communicated, and to whom, I assure you of my readiness, under that restriction, voluntarily to furnish on all occasions, whatever the purposes of justice may require. But the letter of gen. Wilkinson of Oct. 21, requested for the defence of col. Burr, with every other paper relating to the charges against him, which were in my possession when the attorney general went on to Richmond in March, I then delivered to him; and I have always taken for granted he left the whole with you. If he did, and the bundle retains the order in which I had arranged it, you will readily find the letter desired under the date of its receipt, which was November 25; but lest the attorney general should not have left those papers with you I this day write to him to forward this one by post. An uncertainty whether he is at Philadelphia, Wilmington or Newcastle may produce delay in his receiving my letter, of which it is proper you should be apprized. But as I do not recollect the whole con
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 26 June 1807
The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.
The report clarifies that Burr will not be tried before a petit jury at the current term, correcting a popular misconception. Instead, the grand jury is examining testimony to decide whether to issue a true bill against Burr, with Gen. Wilkinson's absence from Richmond cited as a factor.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 23 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
BY THE MAILS.
PHILADELPHIA, June 5.
See moreSee less
BURR's TRIAL.—Gen. Wilkinson not having arrived at Richmond, previous to the 3d instant, it is presumed, there were no new proceedings in this case, subsequent to the date of our former accounts. A Richmond paper, received on Saturday, is silent on the subject.
It has been supposed by many, that Burr would be tried at the present term:—this is a mistake. We believe we can say with certainty, that the only object contemplated, for the present, was the examination of such testimony by the grand jury as could enable it to decide, whether they would find a true bill against Colonel Burr. The trial, before a petit jury, will take place at the next term. We have heard this as a reason assigned for the non-attendance of the attorney general for the U. S. during the proceedings. The petit jury to try, is to be nominated from Wood county, Virginia, where the crime is said to have been committed.
The report anticipates General Wilkinson's arrival in Richmond to testify in the Burr treason trial, explaining the delay was due to late government orders reaching New Orleans. It also defends the government against accusations from federalist and British papers sympathetic to Burr.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 23 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
REPUBLIC. The Vice Roy is arrested as a Traitor and for desertion, having deserted this place with a number of troops at the commencement of the siege. The English have here ten ships of war and six thousand troops. They have demanded a surrender of Buenos Ayres, but have been answered in the negative."
We shall probably have the satisfaction, to announce to-morrow, the arrival of gen. Wilkinson, at Richmond. He left New Orleans, in company with Mr. Graham, secretary to gov. Claiborn, on the 21st May, on board the U. S. schooner Revenge, bound for Norfolk,
See moreSee less
The delay that has taken place, is now accounted for. We are assured that the order from government for the attendance of this important witness, was not received at New Orleans on the 10th of May—it is evident, therefore, that the utmost dispatch was used to get the U. S. schooner to sea on the 21st. The promptitude of gen. W. exposes the malice and falsity of those, who have been endeavoring to persuade the public, that this officer dare not attend the trial, and encreases the hopes we entertain of an issue honorable to himself, and beneficial to the country. [Aurora of June 15.
Although the matter of charge against Burr, is now before the tribunal of Justice, and although there is much affectation of a desire that the trial should be permitted to proceed free from and unbiassed by extra...
This editorial from the Aurora newspaper accuses federal and British-leaning papers of defending Burr and attacking the government while his treason trial proceeds. It claims General Wilkinson can prove Burr's associates attempted to corrupt U.S. troops and plotted to seize Baton Rouge, predicting Burr's friends will be mortified once Wilkinson testifies.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 23 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
and although there is much affectation of a desire that the trial should be permitted to proceed, free from and unbiassed by extraneous influence, there is scarcely a federal or British print that has not commenced the exculpation and defence of the man accused, or that has not undertaken to impute the most corrupt and infamous motives to the government of our country.
The objects are easily comprehended—federalism will never be induced to forgive the successful arrest of power in its hands; magnanimity lessens not its anger, and the happiness of the people is a reproach upon the former administration. It watches every opportunity to render the government ridiculous and disrespected; and it associates in its ranks the avowed emissaries of an unfriendly power.
See moreSee less
To those who call on government for proofs to sustain the message to congress, we answer—the government has them—it will make good its charge—Wilkinson can prove, in addition to what has before been
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, a certified copy of a Navy Department letter is presented, showing Secretary Robert Smith's December 1806 order to Capt. John Shaw to intercept and if necessary destroy boats under Burr's command descending the Mississippi. John Randolph then proceeds with a motion for a rule against General Wilkinson, arguing it is based on facts meant to correct public misconceptions, not to defame him.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CH. W. GOLDSBOROUGH, Ch. Clk. N. D.
COPY. NAVY DEPARTMENT, 20th Dec. 1806.
See moreSee less
SIR, A military expedition formed on the Western Waters by Col. Burr, will soon proceed down the Mississippi, and by the time you receive this letter, will probably be near N. Orleans. You will by all the means in your power, aid the army and militia in suppressing this enterprize. You will with your Boats take the best position to intercept and to take and if necessary to destroy the Boats descending under the command of Col. Burr, or of any person holding an appointment under him. There is great
This passage records courtroom argument during Burr's trial about whether affidavits or viva voce testimony should be used, with discussion of proper oath administration and magistrate impartiality. Burr himself participates, addressing an incident involving a Mr. Knox and questioning Mr. Hay's impartiality in the matter.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Burr observed, that it would be much more agreeable to him, if every person could be orally examined ; but that he would deserve the rebuke of this court, if he in every cafe
Lawyers in Burr's trial argue procedural points about whether a rule for attachment can be issued against General Wilkinson before he is present to defend himself, drawing analogies to grand jury procedure. The dispute centers on timing and whether postponing the motion prejudices either side's rights.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
which may exist against him.
Mr. Burr said, that he by no means intended eventually to exclude the gentlemen even on this motion ; if the court thought proper to indulge them. He could not, however, but
A prosecuting attorney argues before the court that Aaron Burr should not have unrestricted power to subpoena any government document merely by request. He contends the prisoner must first demonstrate a paper's materiality to his defense before the court compels its production, leaving the President to judge whether disclosure would endanger national safety.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
would, you put the pursuits and the peace of every individual in the United States, at the mercy of the prisoners caprices and resentments. This argument from inconvenience, assumes an attitude of the most awful and alarming importance, when you extend it to a case like this before the court. A prisoner seldom has any cordial amity for the government by which he is prosecuted for a crime. The truth is, that he feels himself in a state of war with that government; and the more desperate his case, the more ardent will be his spirit of revenge.
See moreSee less
Would you expose the offices of state to be ravaged at the mere pleasure of a prisoner? Who, if he feels that he must fall, would pant for nothing more anxiously than "to grace his fall and make his ruin glorious" by dragging down with him, the bright and splendid edifice of the government. Sir, if Aaron Burr has the right, at his mere wish, to call one paper from the
A prosecution attorney argues in court that papers demanded by Burr's defense—including a letter from General Wilkinson and war department orders—are not relevant to proving Burr innocent of treason or misdemeanor charges. He contends that even if the orders to apprehend or destroy Burr were as harsh as described, this would only prove the administration wrong, not Burr innocent.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
to the orders which have been depicted as being so sanguinary and despotic. I affirm, with the power of proof to support me, that such orders never were given: though if it be true, that Aaron Burr had placed himself in a state of war with his country: was aiming a blow at the vitals of our government & liberty, and that blow could be averted in no other way, I hold that his destruction would have been a virtue, a great and glorious virtue. Affairs, however, had not reached that desperate crisis.
See moreSee less
We have seen the orders, sir, and at a proper time will produce them; the very orders to Lieut. Shaw, which the prisoner has so often mentioned, as having been published in the Natches Gazette: those orders are not as he has described them, they are simply orders to apprehend Aaron Burr, and if it shall become necessary for that purpose to destroy his boats. These are the bloody orders which have been so often mentioned with looks of such tragic and mysterious import! Suppose the orders was as barbarous as he has described them, and that the emergency did not justify them: they prove the administration wrong: but do they prove or tend to prove Aaron Burr innocent. If the president were on his trial, for having issued these orders, it would be necessary to hear the orders themselves, in order to ascertain their merits or demerits. But the question is not now as to the guilt or innocence of the President; it is as to the guilt or innocence of Aaron Burr, on the charges of treason and misdemeanor, and whether the President has acted right or wrong does not and cannot affect the question of Burr's guilt or innocence. The charges against him are to be proved by witnesses on behalf of the U. States; if these witnesses do not prove the charges, there is an end of the enquiry: but if they
This report records courtroom argument rebutting defense counsel Martin's claim that Burr had a right to resist government orders for his apprehension. The speaker contends that resisting lawful authority is itself treason, and references Wilkinson's letter to the President as relevant to the case.
The Enquirer · 23 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
a man becomes a God when he becomes a President: I think he does not become a God even by becoming a King or an Emperor: on the contrary, I think that a man, who, in a government like ours, even aspires to become one, approaches in point of character, a class of beings very opposite to Gods.—But ascending again to our President, he is bound by his oath of office to take care that the laws shall be carried into effect. By the particular act of Congress which prescribes the punishment of the misdemeanor charged on the prisoner, the President is authorised and required to call on the naval and military force of the country to defeat the enterprise: in the present instance, he has done so and given orders for the apprehension of the offender: and we are told that Aaron Burr, instead of submitting himself to the laws and justice of his country, had a right to resist these orders.
See moreSee less
That Aaron Burr was to be the judge, whether he should obey, or not, orders proceeding from the lawfully constituted authorities of his country: and that if he thought them unlawful he had a right to resist them by force: if this be so, there is an end of government; every individual in the country, I presume, has, at least, the same rights with Aaron Burr: and if he has this right of submitting to, or resisting the laws and officers of the government as he pleases, every body else has the same right: then where is the use of our constitution, laws or officers, we might as well abolish them all, and return to a state of nature. But, sir, neither Aaron Burr nor any other individual carries about him this dispensing power. It is clear that
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Burr addresses the court regarding a supplemental charge the court had prepared, noting it had not yet been shown to his counsel as expected. He discusses the propositions submitted to the court and expresses willingness to limit argument time if the court has doubts about the law.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF Col. AARON BURR
SATURDAY, June 18th.
Mr. Burr thought it proper to mention, that his counsel had understood, that a supplemental charge had been written by the court: that it had been
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During the Aaron Burr treason trial, the Chief Justice discusses a supplemental charge he drafted but withholds delivering it until Monday, pending review by both counsel. Attorneys debate whether further legal arguments on Burr's propositions should be presented orally or in writing.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
had submitted to the attorney for the U.S. with a request that it should also be put into the hands of Col. Burr's counsel; that Mr. Hay had however informed him in the conversation which he had just had with him, that he had been too much occupied himself to inspect the charge with attention, and deliver it to the opposite counsel; but another reason was that there was one point in the charge which he did not fully approve. He should not therefore deliver his charge at present; and should reserve it until Monday. In the mean time Col. Burr's counsel would have an opportunity of inspecting it; and an argument might be held on the points which had produced an objection
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, arguments arose over the admissibility of evidence allegedly obtained improperly, with accusations against Judge Toulmin, Rep. Jackson, and Gen. Wilkinson for misusing postal and military authority. The Chief Justice also issued a written opinion on whether a witness could be compelled to answer questions that might incriminate himself.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Trial of Aaron Burr.
Mr. E. Randolph said he meant to have moved for an attachment against gen. Wilkinson for compelling persons to give affidavits, who he knew were to be witnesses, and of illegally forcing by military authority persons from New Orleans to Norfolk.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The court rules on whether a witness must answer questions that might incriminate himself, concluding witnesses may refuse if their answer would form a necessary link in proving their own guilt. The grand jury, through foreman John Randolph, requests a ciphered letter connected to Burr to compare with a copy already in the prosecutor's possession, and Burr notes the President's subpoena was served but only answered verbally.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Court then adjourned. On Friday, Col. Burr rose and stated to the court, that the process which was obtained for the President of the U. S. last Saturday, was served upon him on Monday morning; but a verbal answer was only given, signifying that an answer to the notification of the process, would be returned through some other channel. Col. Burr therefore observed, if nothing was heard in the course of the day from the attorney for the prosecution, that to-morrow morning a motion would be made for enforcing the process of the court.* Mr. E. Randolph rose to make the motion, of which he gave notice on Wednesday, and said he held in his hand certain depositions as grounds for
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The grand jury investigating Burr requested the cipher letter to verify its authenticity, and it was delivered after discussion. Col. Burr noted the President's response to a subpoena was delayed, and Randolph moved for an attachment against General Wilkinson based on depositions, while the court continued examining witnesses toward an indictment decision.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
* We understood that on the 18th inst. a regular return was made at the instance of the President, to the subpena duces tecum, enclosing the orders of the War and Navy departments in relation to Mr. Burr, and stating that the letter of general Wilkinson was either in the hands of the Attorney general, or Mr. Hay, the former of whom had been written to on the subject.
On the 19th instant the grand jury had examined thirty-three witnesses; seventeen remained to give their testimony. It was expected the grand jury would determine on the indictments yesterday.
See moreSee less
The foregoing abstract is formed from the Argus and Virginia Gazette of Saturday last. We failed to receive the Enquirer.
We prefer giving the details attending the trial of Aaron Burr at length to filling our columns with European events of but little importance. Various arrivals bring down our London dates to the 9th of May, and Amsterdam dates to May 8th.
The latest accounts from the Grand Armies are to the 24th of April, when the French head quarters were still at Fickenstein, and when a general engagement was daily expected. Immense reinforcements had joined both armies.
Admiral Duckworth had returned into the Archipelago with 69 killed and 219 wounded.
The English Parliament was dissolved on the 28th of April, and the new Parliament is to meet the 22d of June.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers
A defense attorney argues during Burr's trial that a witness was illegally seized in New Orleans, denied bail, and transported to Richmond under harsh conditions merely on suspicion he might testify against Burr. He warns against intimidating witnesses and questions the suspicious appearance of a letter introduced as evidence.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
voice, in a time of profound peace, was seized in New-Orleans, and without being charged with any offence, but merely on suspicion that he could give evidence against col. Burr in this court, to which place he was willing to come, he was committed to prison without bail or main-prize; thrown into a stinking room with the common felons and negroes confined there, and only taken out at last to be transported to Richmond in custody. He was not even permitted to go to his lodgings to get a shirt, but like a malefactor he was forced to yield, in the humbleness of submission, to the will of his masters. Our revolutionary heroes were provoked to independence in part, by the wrongs of transporting Amer[ic]an criminals for trial to England; but at this time, we are content with such a transportation, under circumstances of enormity, of one guilty of nothing but a suspected capacity to be a witness! Shall we not be wary how we furnish a pretext against this stranger now called to implicate himself, in what are called the treasons and misdemeanors of Col. Burr, when without this he has suffered, tho' in a less degree, than the abused individual from Orleans.
But it has been remarked, that my client and his counsel had taken much interest in this privilege.
See moreSee less
We all feel interested in saving this inoffensive foreigner from the vengeance of illegal power. Col. Burr, particularly from the circumstance of having
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 29 June 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
Defense counsel argues that a witness cannot be compelled to testify about deciphering part of a letter allegedly written by Burr, citing the legal principle that a witness may refuse to answer if it might implicate him. The exchange includes sparring over whether the letter contains treasonable matter and whether the question is relevant to the treason charge.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
such an offence should be made the means of assisting to prove another. The principal of this government, if here, would join in the denunciation. If it behoves the government to suppress a paper thus unconstitutionally, clandestinely and illegally obtained—if they cannot use the end without sanctifying the means—If they in the noble, generous spirit of a Chatham ministry, would disclaim every impure expedient, their able representatives here would do well not to disgrace their fingers with its touch.
Now for the abstract question of law. The question put to Willie is "do you understand that the original of this letter was written by col. Burr." (Mr. M'Rae. No; that is not the question last
This report records courtroom exchanges during Burr's trial, including Mr. McRae defending General Wilkinson against charges that witnesses were improperly brought from New Orleans. It also captures a procedural dispute between defense counsel and Mr. Hay over motions and parliamentary tactics, with sharp personal jabs exchanged between the parties.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
what way ? He presumed that the court would not notice the pretended transactions which had been alluded to, in any other way than as amounting to a contempt. As to any offence against the laws of the United States,—the true course would be to proceed in the way of a presentment. Now, what are the principles of the law of contempt in relation to this subject ? General Wilkinson is said to have taken the depositions of certain persons in New-Orleans and then to have brought them here by military force. This is the only ground of the contempt against this court ? But how can a contempt be committed ?
Either by directly insulting this court ; or abusing its process ; or interrupting its justice, will it be said that gen. Wilkinson's conduct comes under either of those descriptions ?
See moreSee less
Gentlemen have very often pleased to put words into our mouths : and on one occasion they have made us to say that gen. Wilkinson is "the pivot of of the prosecution." And is it this very pivot which they are now attempting to break down by this precipitate application ? Are the communications between the court and the grand jury to be thus interrupted ? Is their examination to be suspended, until gen. Wilkinson has been put upon his trial ? If these suspected transactions do amount to a contempt of this court, it was not his business, officially to notice it. He should move to postpone the motions of gentlemen, until the prosecution was over ; for several reasons—because it would necessarily interrupt the business before the court—because it was intended to impeach the credit of a witness—and because this enquiry could be as well conducted after as before the prosecution.
Mr. McRae. I will affirm, sir, in the presence of this court and the surrounding people, that the charge now adduced against gen. Wilkinson is completely unfounded. I affirm, that no witness has been brought from New Orleans with an affidavit along with him, except one individual, who, refusing to obey the summons of the government, was regularly brought before a magistrate for his disobedience, and dealt with according to the due course of law ; and who is now in the custody of a person before this court—All the rest came as good citizens ought to have come ; and the only fault which can possibly be attributed to them, if it be a fault, is, that they came in the U. States vessel in which gen. Wilkinson was authorised to come.
Mr. Wickham. May I request the liberty, sir, of making a few remarks upon Mr. Hay's motion? Col. Burr, sir, brought forward his motion in the plainest possible style. There was no imputation,
A defense lawyer argues against the prosecution's previous motion tactics, insisting Burr deserves the same procedural rights as any citizen and defending the right to seek an attachment against General Wilkinson. He accuses Wilkinson of bringing witnesses from New-Orleans under military force and taking depositions ex parte to control testimony.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ecutive and Judiciary. These must be kept separate and distinct not only in their duties, but in their practice. The Legislature act upon convenience, the Judiciary acts upon right. The gentleman, however, seems to think himself suddenly transported to the Legislative hall ; and no doubt, would soon think it very convenient to hang col. Burr.—He tramples all our judiciary forms under foot ; if we make a motion before court, he soon trips up ours with his previous motion. And where is his doctrine to end? We certainly have the same rights as the gentlemen themselves; and as they have moved the previous question, we will move, sir, that the court shall not hear their motion.
See moreSee less
It is better that we send these parliamentary distinctions to the other side of the house, where they ought forever to remain. Mr. Hay says, that this motion ought not to be made pendente lite.—Sir, col. Burr ought to have the same justice meted out to him, which is meted to every other person. He stands here on the same footing; and with the same privileges as any other citizen in his situation. I assert that any other man would have a right to this attachment; and that the motion may be made pendente lite, though it is sometimes made afterwards—" Why does he make it at this time? Why does he not postpone it till after the prosecution?" Why, sir, when col. Burr is discharged, and I hope he will shortly be so, he may not be disposed to trouble the court any further—How long this prosecution will last, no one knows; perhaps a week—perhaps longer—it is already gone so far beyond our expectations, it is impossible to conjecture. Now, sir, may not similar contempts occur? is it not necessary to restrain certain people, by convincing them that such practices make them liable to punishment? But what has general Wilkinson done? He has
This report covers courtroom proceedings in the Burr treason trial, detailing a dispute over affidavits used against General Wilkinson and whether counsel charged perjury. Burr's counsel moves for a rule to show cause for attachment against Wilkinson, with disagreement over the specific wording and grounds of contempt to be cited in the motion.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 3
.? ,the character of genera! Wilkinson There may perhaps, sir, be a time which will re quire all the force of their rhetoric, and all the luesre of his talent-s, to defend his con
During the treason trial proceedings, Burr's counsel argue that General Wilkinson improperly tampered with prosecution witnesses, seeking a ruling on the principle involved. The court debates procedural questions about whether Wilkinson must be present for the motion and whether affidavits should be read, with counsel on both sides disputing the timing and propriety of the delay.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 24 June 1807 · page 3
__ Mr. Wirt advocated the propriety, and the expediencysi, not the right that general Wilkinson should be present. _ Mr. HIartinct said they had no (nere busi; ness to interfere in the present motion-, than the eounael for coloncl Burr, had to inter-si, sifcr'e wi it the witneaees before the grand. jury. He there-sore hoped the court would net agree to a delatsir. . .
During the Burr treason trial, Randolph continues his speech on the motion for a subpoena duces tecum, arguing that General Wilkinson has strong motives to secure Burr's conviction since his own reputation depends on it. Randolph predicts Wilkinson will soon be removed from his position as Vice Gerent of Upper Louisiana.
Virginia Argus · 24 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
OF Col. Aaron Burr.
Debate on the motion for a writ of subpoena duces tecum continued.
See moreSee less
(Mr. Randolph's Speech Continued.)
Is it not to be supposed that general Wilkinson will do many things rather than disappoint the wonder seizing appetite of America, which for months together he has been gratifying by the most miraculous actions. If I am not mistaken I have seen it in some of the public prints that he is no longer the Vice Gerent of the upper Louisiana, and if I may be indulged with the slightest power of prophecy I may predict that this same General Wilkinson who has been astonishing the citizens of New Orleans with plots and conspiracies will before many weeks only figure in the capacity of a private citizen. I shall not say that General Wilkinson would commit perjury; let me not be understood as making such an assertion; but if I know human nature; if I understand the feeling of the human Breast; if I have the slightest knowledge of those principles which govern the mind of man, I may be allowed to affirm that every feeling would be asleep in his breast if he did not use every exertion in his power for the conviction of Col. Burr—Upon the conviction of Col. Burr upon the guilt I say of Col. Burr, depends the innocence of Gen. Wilkinson.—If Col. Burr is proved guilty, then indeed General Wilkinson may stand acquitted with many of his countrymen; but if Col. Burr be not found guilty, the character, the reputation in short every thing that deserves the name of integrity will be gone for ever from Gen Wilkinson. Sir, in that event, I say in the event of Burr's acquittal as sure as man is man, storms and tempests will cover the western glory of Gen. Wilkinson and gather darkness all around him. We have
A defense attorney in Burr's trial argues for the production of the full correspondence between General Wilkinson and President Jefferson, countering prosecution objections. He attacks Wilkinson's credibility, calling him an 'approver' who implicated himself in crimes to entrap others, and dismisses concerns about exposing state secrets.
Virginia Argus · 24 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ing any questions which might be put to him. It is really most extraordinary that these gentlemen should tell us after arriving in the porch of the temple that we shall not go into the sanctum sanctorum. Tha' we are at liberty to know part of the correspondence which has taken place between Gen Wilkinson and the President of the United States, but not to know the whole. The gentleman for the prosecution has to day, sir, given us an eulogium upon himself and his associate friends—He has pictured to us the zeal and the anxiety he has had for the production of those papers, and has assured us that he has already taken means for having them here.
See moreSee less
I thank the gentleman for his exertions, but at the same time I must beg leave to remark, the equal zeal with which he and his friends combat our application.—If Mr Burr were now asking you for these papers, without shewing any probable cause that they were material this indeed would be a wanton, womanish, feverish curiosity; but it is no such curiosity; we have shewn in the fullest manner, that they are material and of the first importance.—It is said by the production, that Gen. Wilkinson, that huge Atlas, on whose mighty shoulders the American world is sustained, is wished to be represented as a man in whom confidence ought not to be placed. But I say, if the production of these papers were to effect the annihilation of General Wilkinson, that I hope and believe no other visible chasm in the creation would be produced, but in that portion of space at present, occupied by his material body. How can the rank and safety of General Wilkinson be concerned in the production of these papers. Gen. Wilkin-
A writer disputes a deponent's sworn claims that he and Mr. Floyd had surveyed Fort Adams as agents of Burr, insisting they merely viewed a river eddy from a distance. He also attacks the deponent's credibility, suggesting personal grudges against Gen. Wilkinson motivated the testimony.
Virginia Argus · 24 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
particular period : it goes to enforce the then prevailing opinion, which I believe originated with this deponent, his master and party, "That Burr with an army were about to descend the river, to ransack New Orleans, destroy plantations and lay waste the country." Burr is at hand says the doctor, here are two of his officers carefully examining the fort.
For what? That th[ey] may possess themselves of the strong holds of our country, the better to effect and complete their nefarious purposes. This is certainly the natural inference and intentions of this honorable deponent.—Whatever may have been the public impression, I do aver, that no such thought, no such sentiment, no such wish ever possessed my heart.
See moreSee less
This spy (I suppose it is no secret by this time that the doctor held his honorable appointment under his honorable master) assured me that he had not spoke to gen. Wilkinson for three years or more, owing to a misunderstanding which he said took place between him and the general about pecuniary matters. The latter being scant of cash, applied to the former to borrow of him, the doctor preferring his money to the pleasure of relieving his distressed master, refused the request, fearful the master might forget to return the man his money again. This produced a chasm, which I suppose, has only been filled up by the doctor's affidavit and late extraordinary exertions, in the functions of his late honorable appointment.
I will not trouble the public with any further anecdotes of these great personages, but just remind the doctor, that he forgot to swear that he had sworn secrecy, so far as related to Col. Burr's then situation in descending the river, and his being at Bayou Pierre on the 12th of January last.
ALEX. RALSTON.
In justise to gen. Adair, and respect for the truth, I do declare that I never exchanged a sentiment with him on the subject of what is generally termed Burr's expedition.
The court debated whether to proceed with cross-examining witnesses given General Wilkinson's unavailability due to grand jury duties. After discussion, both sides agreed to postpone the motion until Tuesday, with prosecution counsel to consult Wilkinson on interrogatories in the meantime.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
LATEST PROCEEDINGS
Mr. E. Randolph. " Call James Knox and Chandler Lindsay.
" With submission to the court we shall now proceed with our motion."
See moreSee less
Mr. M'Rea said he understood that the motion was only to be proceeded with, in the event of general Wilkinson's being able to attend.
Mr. Botts observed it was the concession which colonel Burr had made on Saturday which now gave rise to the present proposal of postponement. He therefore would be of opinion, that the consent which was given ought to be retracted.
Colonel Burr said it must be manifest that had he not made the concession on Saturday, the present investigation would now have been gone into; but still he had no objections for a present postponement, if the counsel for the prosecution would name a day.
Westcott & Co. announce they have engaged stenographer Thomas Carpenter to attend the Richmond circuit court session beginning June 22 for Aaron Burr's trial. They promise to publish a complete account with all relevant documents as soon as possible after the trial.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 June 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
ARROWSMITH's, MAP OF THE WORLD; The size of which, will be six feet eleven inches, by four feet ten inches, handsomely engraved and printed on fine thick paper.—Price to subscribers, from nine to fourteen dollars, according to the mounting, coloring, varnishing, &c. &c. *.* Subscriptions received by R. Gray, Alexandria. June 1.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report covers courtroom proceedings in the Burr treason case, featuring a debate over whether Dr. Bollman's pardon implies admission of guilt and whether accepting it would be self-incriminating. The Chief Justice and lawyers also dispute the number of witnesses required for an indictment versus conviction of treason, referencing old English statutes and their applicability after the Revolution.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
government; but he will brave it all, The man who did so much to risque the Marquis La Fayette from his imprisonment; and who has been known at so many courts, bears too great a regard for his reputation, to wish to have it sounded throughout Europe, that he was compelled to abandon his honor through a fear of unjust persecution.
After some desultory conversation, Dr. Bollman was sent up to the grand jury, without any particular notification. The question whether he is pardoned, and of course how far he may be called upon to disclose all that he knows—are reserved for future discussion and decision.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay requested leave to inform the grand jury that fatigue alone had prevented general Wilkinson from attending them on that day; but that he
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
The report describes courtroom proceedings including the Chief Justice's explanation of expunged words from a written opinion, and General Wilkinson's dramatic appearance to testify before the grand jury. Four indictments are announced: two against Aaron Burr for treason and misdemeanor, and two against Herman Blannerhassett.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Monday, June 15. Mr. Hay directed the deputy marshal to request General Wilkinson to come into court. In a few minutes, General W. entered with a firm and dignified carriage, and gracefully bowing to the bench, and surrounding spectators, took his stand behind Colonel Burr's counsel. How replete with feeling and interest, was the scene before us! It was the first occasion on which these two distinguished individuals had met, since the explosion of these interesting transactions which have so strongly agitated our country, and with which both of them have been so deeply connected. Col. Burr's countenance was marked by a haughty contempt: The countenance of General Wilkinson, was calm, dignified and commanding.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Defense counsel for Aaron Burr and Blennerhassett raise concerns about witnesses carrying unvetted papers directly to the grand jury, bypassing court inspection. Prosecutor Hay defends the need for witnesses like General Wilkinson to reference personal letters and documents to give connected testimony.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
ed the inspection of the court; but it had since occurred to col. Burr's counsel that the witnesses themselves might carry up such papers. The object of this promise would b[e] entirely defeated, if
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During pretrial proceedings in Richmond, the court debates whether witness Wyllie's testimony about a ciphered letter connected to Aaron Burr is admissible before the Grand Jury. Wyllie confirms the letter's cipher was written at Burr's direction and copied from Burr's original, sparking argument between prosecutor Hay and defense counsel Wickham over whether partial authorship implies full authorship.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
anxious to be particularly understood. He says that this ciphered letter was first written by col. Burr and afterwards copied: But it is the cypher only which has been copied from col. B's original. Mr. Hay. It is quite sufficient, sir. If col. Burr wrote the ciphered part, he will be considered as the author of
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Arguments unfold in court over whether a cyphered letter attributed to Aaron Burr must be shown relevant before being admitted as evidence to the grand jury. The Chief Justice rules that materiality must be established, and the session is interrupted when a grand jury witness raises questions about the cipher.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The Richmond court proceedings report that Mr. Randolph moved for an attachment against Gen. Wilkinson, but the argument was postponed until Wilkinson could attend. When he appeared Tuesday, witness examination began, though no details or verdict are given.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
We have received a concise notice of the proceedings of the court at Richmond on Saturday last.
Mr. Randolph brought forward his motion for an attachment against Gen. Wilkinson, and spoke at considerable length, when at the request of Mr. Hay, Col. Burr acquiescing, the argument was postponed until Monday, in consequence of the absence of Gen. Wilkinson, when the court adjourned.
See moreSee less
By the Virginia Gazette, received last night, we are furnished with the proceedings of the court of Monday & Tuesday last. On Monday the court set but a short time, gen. Wilkinson being engaged before the Grand Jury, and it being agreed that the examination of witnesses on the motion to issue an attachment should be waved until he was present. On Tuesday gen. W. attended, when this examination was entered upon. Neither the result, or any other proceedings are stated.
Reports of a general battle and defeat of the French had reached London by way of Yarmouth, said to have been brought by a public messenger from Copenhagen—these rumors gained some confidence in London on the 15th May, the Morning Chronicle contradicts them ho[w]ever and alleges that no credit ought to be placed in them.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
During the treason trial proceedings, prosecutor Hay and defense counsel Wickham discuss documents received in response to a subpoena duces tecum, including letters from the Secretary of the Navy and Secretary of War regarding orders issued about Burr's expedition. The navy department's order to Capt. John Shaw, dated December 20, 1806, directing him to intercept and if necessary destroy Burr's boats near New Orleans, is read into the record.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TH: JEFFERSON.
Accompanying this letter, said Mr. H. is a copy of the resolution of the house of representatives containing the exception to which the President refers.—I have also received a letter from Mr. Smith, secretary of the navy, containing an authentick copy of the order, which was wanted, precisely corresponding with the unauthenticated copy in my possession.—Mr. Wickham. I presume that these must be noted by the clerk, as the return to the subpœna Duces Tecum.—Mr. Hay. So far as they go. When we receive gen. W's letter, the return will be complete. I have also received a letter from the secretary at war, which contains all the orders of his department, touching A. Burr.—All which papers I shall deposit with the clerk of this court.
See moreSee less
The following is the order of the navy department.
I Certify, that the annexed is a true copy from the records, in the office of the department of the navy of the United States, of the letter from the secretary of the navy to capt. John Shaw, dated 20th December, 1806.
In faith whereof, I Robert Smith, secretary of the navy of the United States of America, have signed these presents, and the seal of (SEAL.) my office to be affixed thereto, at the City of Washington, this 17th day of June, Anno Domini, 1807, and in the 31st year of the independence of the said states.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 1 July 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
Counsel debate whether affidavits submitted as evidence were improperly drafted by opposing lawyers rather than by the witnesses themselves. Mr. Baker explains he corrected grammatical errors in Lindsley's affidavit after Lindsley brought it to him already written, sparking argument over proper courtroom procedure for collateral testimony.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
very same thing in their situation.
Mr. Baker. May it please the court. I shall not undertake to say, what Mr. Hay would have done in our situation, nor am I much interested in knowing. But I solely rise for the purpose of correcting a mistake, into which he has fallen. He says that these affidavits were originally written by col. Burr's counsel.
Counsel debate whether written affidavits accurately capture a witness's own words versus being colored by the attorney's phrasing. Mr. McRae requests a delay in examining witnesses so General Wilkinson can be present, but Mr. Martin objects, clarifying the current procedural stage of the inquiry.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
off every bias from his mind; but it is impossible that he could have perfectly succeeded; or that he could have precisely drawn such an affidavit, as would have flowed of itself from the mind of the witness. They could not have used precisely the same expressions; but this affidavit which should express the colour of the mind of the witness, is necessarily too much tinged with the colour of the mind of the counsel.
Mr. Botts. You misunderstand col. B. Sir; He acquiesces in your reasons: he feels the expediency of your proposition; and cheerfully consents to the exhibition of the viva voce testimony itself; though he regrets the inconvenience and departure from usage, which it will involve.
See moreSee less
Mr. Martin. If the witness himself is examined, the clerk will reduce the questions and answers to writing, to give it all the effect of an affidavit.
Mr. Hay apologised for frequently misunderstanding colonel Burr, notwithstanding his distinct voice and emphatick manner. Their respective situations prevented him from being distinctly heard.
James Knox was then called, when Mr. McRae addressed the court: he said that as this business was of considerable importance to the respectable gentlemen (gen. Wilkinson) who was immediately interested, it was extremely desirable that he might be present during the examination of this and the other witnesses who might be exhibited on this occasion; that these wishes had been communicated to the opposite counsel, but that they had objected to any delay, and hence he had made this application to the court? that gen. Wilkinson was now before the grand jury, and would be in a short time before the court; that he knew general Wilkinson wished to be here. He therefore requested that the court would suspend their examination for a short time, until he himself could be present: that perhaps some very important facts, which were unknown to the counsel for the prosecution, might be within the knowledge of gen. Wilkinson, who might materially direct their enquiries in this examination.
Mr. Martin said, that gentlemen seemed not to know, in what stage of the inquiry they were now engaged. The question merely is, whether a rule should be granted to show cause; in which neither gen. Wilkinson nor his counsel were supposed to be present.
Mr. McRae. The gentleman from Baltimore has said that we were not present; although the court has been polite enough to recognize our presence; and even the gentlemen themselves, by some time ago declaring their consent to any arrangement which would be most convenient for both sides have admitted the same fact.—Mr. McRae hoped, that if the reasons for desiring general Wilkinson's attendance seemed equally strong to the court as they did to the counsel for the prosecution that they would consent to this short delay; "we mean, sir, with the leave of the court to put some questions to the witnesses ourselves: and still more, we mean with the leave of the court, to introduce some of our own witnesses: and we feel confident, in satisfying this court, that no just foundation exists for the present motion."
Mr. Martin. I know that these gentlemen are personally present; and indeed they take care enough to remind us of it, by so often making us hear their voices. But certainly they are not legally present; and they have no right to in the present discussion. The other day they detained the court three hours on the motion for a subpœna duces tecum, after the court had decided that they had no right to interfere. Let the court decide upon the present motion; and when the rule is made, then may gen. Wilkinson
At Burr's treason trial, Burr requested that an attachment motion proceed now that General Wilkinson was present in court, alleging witnesses had been improperly influenced at Wilkinson's instigation. Prosecutor Hay objected to broadening testimony beyond direct evidence against Wilkinson, while Edmund Randolph argued the matter should extend to other individuals implicated in the same misconduct.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 26 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
LATEST PROCEEDINGS
as general Wilkinson was now in court, he hoped the motion for an attachment would be gone into. He said that in the testimony which should be produced, it would be proved that although gen. Wilkinson, might not appear as the direct agent in the illegal means which had been used in bringing witnesses before this court: yet it would be shewn that those means had been used at the instigation of gen. Wilkinson.
Mr. Hay rose and said, he certainly would object to any other testimony being produced, except that which might be immediately against gen. W.
See moreSee less
Mr. E. Randolph said that he was happy that the motion had been postponed, as general Wilkinson had now an opportunity
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
A defense attorney argues that demanding additional bail before the grand jury convenes would improperly signal the court's opinion on Burr's guilt, undermining the grand jury's constitutional role. He criticizes delays in producing witnesses from New Orleans and insists the defense seeks only a fair, constitutional trial.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.
— Are you then, Sir, to be a pioneer of blood for the Grand Jury?—Is not this precedent outrageous, Sir? The boasted principle, that no man is to be condemned but upon the verdict of 24 of his peers, is gone. Throughout this town, it will be universally reported that you have solemnly declared A. Burr to be guilty of High Treason against the U. S. and some of those to whom the rumour may extend may hereafter be impannelled on the Petit Jury. And will they feel themselves altogether unbiassed by your judgment? Why, Sir, let it be declared at once, that the Grand Jury is to be struck out as an intermediate organ of justice.
Do not, I pray you, Sir, let us suffer for the delays and negligence of other people. I cannot blame the U. S. attorney; it is his business to obey the instructions of the government; and if the witnesses are not here, it is certainly no fault of his. But surely there is time enough to travel from New-Orleans to this city in 17 days; even with the gigantic "bulk" of gen. Wilkinson himself.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay says, our tone is changed. And how, Sir? We demand a trial now, We demand a fair trial. But must we not therefore protest against a measure, which is calculated to defeat this object? Certainly, Sir. You are called upon to prejudice the minds of the G. Jury. But
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
A defense attorney argues before the court that President Jefferson improperly declared Burr guilty before trial, prejudicing judges and juries. He also recounts Burr's arrest after a grand jury acquittal and his forced transport under armed guard, calling it inhumane treatment.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
And, sir, again, when the H. of R. demanded certain information, as it was their right and their duty to do; the President granted it; and would to God! Sir, that he had stopped here, as an executive officer ought to have done. He proceeded, however, to say that Col. Burr was guilty of a crime; and consequently to express an opinion, which was calculated to operate judicially upon the Judges and the Juries. Such, was the substratum of all the censures, which have been heaped upon Col. Burr.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Attorneys Randolph and Hay debate a motion concerning additional affidavits in the Burr proceedings, with Randolph arguing against allowing a pattern of successive affidavits that would require repeated costly recognizances. The exchange includes sparring over accusations of government prejudice and spies, and Hay responds to Randolph's rhetorical characterization of him.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
excited so much prejudice against Col. Burr as was sufficient to make every man in the country desirous of contributing his full quota of information against him.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The passage reports courtroom argument during Aaron Burr's treason proceedings, with counsel disputing whether the Grand Jury must be present and debating bail terms. Burr himself rises to address the court, calling the motion novel and lamenting the lack of precedent, while his counsel protests the political persecution of his client.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
This report records Aaron Burr's own courtroom remarks, in which he complains of his friends being seized by military authority, his papers confiscated, and orders allegedly given to kill him. He also argues that despite six months of searching, the government has found no actual war or treason, mocking claims of civil war as existing only in newspapers.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
forgiven by the amiable morality of this government. Mr. Burr said, there seemed to be something mingled in these proceedings, which manifested a more than usual inclination to attain the ends of justice. As far as it related to himself
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Reports describe General Wilkinson's arrival in Richmond for the Burr proceedings, accompanied by officers and witnesses, after sending advance word to prevent a premature discharge of the Grand Jury. They also detail a multi-day court debate over a subpoena duces tecum to compel the President to produce Wilkinson's October 21 letter and related military instructions concerning Burr.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 26 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
WASHINGTON CITY, June 17.
Richmond prints, received last evening, announce the arrival of General Wilkinson at that place on Saturday. They state that on " his arrival at Hampton, Gen. Wilkinson had the precaution to dispatch immediately an express to the attorney for the U. S. in this city. He left Hampton at 4 o'clock on Wednesday, and arrived about the same hour, on Thursday. The object of this dispatch was to communicate the General's arrival to Mr. Hay, and through him to the court ; and thus to prevent a premature discharge of the Grand Jury.
See moreSee less
Gen. Wilkinson arrived this morning in the stage from Hampton. He is accompanied by his son, Lieut. Murry and servant, Lieut. Gains, Lieut. Smith and Mr. Graham and servant. Sergeant Dunbar, whose affidavit was lately put aside in court, and some other witnesses, accompanied the general as far as Hampton, and came up in the Pilot boat to this city."
G. W. left Governor Claiborne at New-Orleans.
The papers detail in part the proceedings of the Court on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday last.
On Thursday the Grand Jury was adjourned over to Saturday.
On Wednesday the motion for a writ of subpoena duces tecum to summon the President to produce the original letter of General Wilkinson of the 21st of October, together with the instructions issued to the naval and military officers relative to A. Burr, was made, and warmly discussed.
This discussion occupied Wednesday, Thursday and Friday, when it was closed by Mr. Burr—on which day no decision was made by the court.
[We understand that subpoenas have been received by the President, the Secretary of War and the Secretary of the Navy.]
After the close of this argument Mr. Burr addressed the court on the propriety of giving more specific instructions to the Grand Jury on certain points of evidence. These points he offered in writing in the form of eight abstract propositions, limiting the Grand Jury to certain species of evidence. This course was opposed by the counsel for the prosecution as useless and mischievous. After some desultory remarks from the counsel Mr. Burr requested the Chief Justice to inspect his list of propositions, to determine which would admit of the delivery of this opinion. Here the business rested on Friday.
June 19.
Information from Richmond as late as Tuesday, states there had been only five witnesses examined on Monday evening—the examination of Gen. Eaton lasted about four hours. Gen. Wilkinson had been sworn but not examined.
This report details court proceedings from the Burr treason trial, including disputes over compelling witnesses like Knox and Fort to testify, and payments advanced to witnesses for travel. It also notes grand jury testimony beginning June 24, with witness Graham describing the agitated public mood in New Orleans following Burr's arrival.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
company were unwilling ; others were willing ; asked whether any legal process could be obtained to compel the unwilling witnesses to come—answered that he did not, but refered him to the federal j[u]dge, and knows the bad terms between [the] general and judge, waited on the judge at t[he] request of general Wilkinson, witness knows nothing, but about that time when at the judge's, he saw Knox in company with a Mr. Keene, a lawyer—he had been with the judge a very few minutes. The judge asked Knox whether he was prepared to give a recognizance with security, or
Courtroom proceedings in Burr's trial record witness testimony about the agitated public mood in New Orleans, intercepted letters, and General Wilkinson's actions. Witnesses including Mr. Graham and Captain Murray are questioned by Burr and the prosecution about surveillance, guards, and seized papers.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
the purpose of arresting suspicious persons—Heard also that some papers had been seized. Gen. W. did not inform the witness how he obtained these letters. John Milligan, called. Captain Murray, called and sworn. Captain Murray questioned by col. Burr
Attorneys debate whether the Circuit Court has discretion to grant bail to Aaron Burr after a grand jury indictment for treason, with Mr. Martin arguing perjured testimony undermined the jury's findings. Mr. Burr and others dispute whether the court has the authority under common law, congressional acts, or Virginia law to bail in capital cases.
The Enquirer · 27 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
mon Law, but out of our statutes: but will it be said that when this court has once been constituted, it does not proceed according to the established jurisprudence; that is, the common Law? There can be no question that a state District Court can bail, even in capital cases.—"Will this court, however place itself in opposition to the Grand Jury?" No, sir, it will not; and Mr. Wirt certainly forgets that this court is to hear both sides of the evidence;—whereas the Grand Jury heard one side only; and indeed a part only of that side; for had the United States attorney sent up all the witnesses, whose names appear at the foot of the indictment, very different would have been the result of their enquiries.
See moreSee less
The ground which we take is this: that the Grand Jury have found their bill upon the testimony of a perjured witness; and if the court were to bail Col. Burr would it not be justly inferred that they had set themselves up in opposition to the G. J. but that
During pretrial proceedings, lawyers for the prosecution and defense argue over whether Aaron Burr's alleged treason at Blennerhassett's Island, where he was reportedly not present, justifies denying bail, drawing an analogy to constructive murder. The Chief Justice ultimately rules that, lacking precedent to the contrary, he must commit Burr to custody, and Burr is taken to the city jail.
The Enquirer · 27 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
look out for authorities.
The Chief Justice observed, that he was then under the necessity of committing Col. Burr.
See moreSee less
Mr. Burr stated, that he was willing to be committed, but hoped that the court had not forestalled its opinion.
Chief Justice. I have only stated my present impressions. This subject is open for argument hereafter.—Mr. Burr stands committed to the custody of the marshal.
He was accordingly conducted to the jail of this city.
James Knox testified at Burr's trial that General Wilkinson questioned him about Sergeant Dunbaugh and other matters, recording his answers despite Knox's objections. Knox also described Wilkinson offering him money reportedly owed by Comfort Tyler, which Knox refused, viewing it as an attempt to influence his testimony.
Virginia Argus · 27 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL
ing that was not the subject about which Gen. Wilkinson had sent for him. Some of his own answers to those questions he acknowledged did not convey the whole truth nor state the circumstances in the manner in which he would swear to them.
A witness describes being brought by sea from Fort Stoddert to Hampton and then Richmond to testify in Aaron Burr's treason trial, including interactions with Gen. Wilkinson and payment for expenses. Lieut. Gaines then testifies about receiving subpoenas from the Attorney General and delivering them to Gen. Wilkinson in New Orleans for distribution to witnesses.
Virginia Argus · 27 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
brought round by Judge Hall's orders. At Hampton Gen. Wilkinson asked him if he would go up to Richmond, and told him if he would give him his word to come up he would be satisfied, and offered him twenty dollars to bear his expenses. He said he had no cloaths, and that sum would not buy them. The General told him, if he would promise to come up, he should have fifty dollars, which sum he accepted. He came from Hampton in a vessel engaged by Gen. W. for him and other witnesses; and about twelve miles from Richmond, went ashore, and walked up to town in company with Sergeant Dunbaugh.
See moreSee less
On his cross examination he appeared to have been one of the men engaged in Col. Burr's expedition, and gave an account of their voyage down the River, from which it plainly appeared that he was acquainted with, and co-operated in their projects; but cautiously refrained from revealing any treasonable circumstances.
This report recounts courtroom testimony by Lieut. Gaines detailing the legal maneuvering used to compel witness Knox to travel to Richmond for the Burr treason trial, including Judge Hall's instructions on recognizance and forcible conveyance. Gaines testified he acted under the Attorney General's direction rather than General Wilkinson's orders in serving the subpoena.
Virginia Argus · 27 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
conduct him on board the vessel—He declared that Gen. Wilkinson, when he first gave him the subpœnas, recommended it to him to summon Knox, but gave him no other directions that he recollected; that he communicated to the General and he
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, attorneys argue over whether witness Wylie can be compelled to decipher a coded German letter, with the defense claiming this would force self-incrimination. Defense counsel Botts also decries the treatment of a citizen jailed in New Orleans merely for being a potential witness against Burr.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
grow out of a consciousness of guilt?
The attorney for the U. S. sees every object connected with col. Burr, through a jaundiced medium; with him, "trifles as light as air are confirmations as strong as holy writ."
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Aaron Burr's trial, Burr moves for a rule or attachment, prompting a dispute with Mr. McRae over whether this improperly removes the prosecution from public prosecutors. Mr. Randolph and others debate whether an affidavit and investigation into General Wilkinson's conduct should proceed immediately or be delayed.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
attachment itself.
Mr. Mc'Rae. At whose motion?
See moreSee less
Mr. Burr. At the public's.
Mr. Mc'Rae. A pretty proceeding indeed! that the public prosecution should thus be taken out of the hands of the public prosecutor!
Mr. Burr. A strange remark indeed! As if it was not the business of the prejudiced person himself to institute
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report records a heated procedural debate during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with a speaker arguing that Burr deserves the same legal rights as any citizen regarding a motion for attachment. The speaker criticizes the prosecution's methods of collecting depositions ex parte from witnesses, particularly those involving Mr. Jackson and witnesses brought by military force from New Orleans, calling such practices contemptuous of the court.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
at this time? Why does he not postpone it till after the prosecution? Why, sir, when col. Burr is discharged, and I hope he will shortly be so, he may not be disposed to trouble the court any
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The court rules that a witness cannot be compelled to answer questions that might furnish evidence to convict himself of a crime. The passage also reports on a motion for attachment against General Wilkinson, with testimony from James Knox regarding the transport of witnesses from New Orleans.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
took his feat amongh the counfel for the U.S.
Mr. Burr said, that as gen. W. was present, he would now proceed with his enquiry. It was, however, to be understood, that if the charge could not be brought home to gen. W. himself, it
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A Richmond report dated June 24 states that the grand jury returned four true bills, two against Aaron Burr and two against Blennerhassett, for treason and misdemeanor. After debate, Burr was ordered committed to the custody of the marshal and jailed for the night, with further argument to resume the next day.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Richmond, June 24. The Grand Jury this day found four true bills; two against Aaron Burr for treason and misdemeanor; and two of the same tenor against Blannerhasset. A long and animated discussion ensued on a motion to commit Mr. Burr to the custody of the marshal, which was decided (for this night) in the affirmative. He was consequently committed to jail for the night. The argument remains open, and, it is expected, will be resumed to morrow.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
General Wilkinson arrived in Richmond, having landed at Hampton from New-Orleans aboard a U.S. schooner, with both the defense and prosecution reportedly pleased by his arrival. The report includes sharp political commentary, including Randolph's description of Wilkinson as central to the prosecution and a Tennessee Gazette piece predicting Wilkinson would be removed from command.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Burr's Trial. RICHMOND, JUNE 13. This morning General Wilkinson arrived in this city—He landed on Wednesday morning at Hampton, passenger in the U. S. schooner Revenge, from New-Orleans. Both parties appeared pleased with this event.—Mr. Burr, because he shall have a speedy trial :—And the Ministerial Prosecutors because they hope his evidence will serve to hang Burr.—Mr. Randolph late Secretary of State, has described this General Wilkinson, in one of his speeches before the Court, as the "Alpha and Omega of the Presidential prosecution :—who to is support, by his evidence, the sing-song and the ballads of treason and conspiracy, which we have head delivered from one extremity of the continent to the other.—The Funeral Pile of the prosecution already prepared by the hands of the public Attorney, only want but the torch of James Wilkinson to kindle it to a fatal blaze.—He is to be the chief Character in the Tragady of Burr ; and to officiate as the High Priest of this human sacrifice."
See moreSee less
The following article is from the Tennessee Gazette, of April 25:— "We have frequently predicted that gen. Wilkinson, from his late (and part of his former) conduct, would be broke. We can now, from unquestionable authority, say, that he will no longer hold the office of Commander in Chief. His late actions have become so symmetrical to those of Robespierre, that if the President of the United States does not take notice of him, he will no longer be viewed as a person worthy the office he now holds."—[Certainly the writer of the above article ought to receive a patent for his discovery.]
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
This sarcastic piece lampoons the attorneys involved in Burr's Richmond treason trial, mocking their rhetorical excess and predicting absurd outcomes. It includes a joke from the Providence Gazette suggesting Burr will be convicted of 'the Horse-Ail' and subjected to a mock nautical punishment.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
COMMUNICATION.
descendant in a strait line from my Lord Coke. Let him once get over his points, and he could convince a Jury that Burr had conspired to commit treason and adultry all the way up and down the Ohio ; and if this were not sufficient, we would have him indicted, convicted and hung for suicide. Such, and so irresistable is eloquence. [Bos. Gaz.] It is highly probable, says a correspondent that the important trial now pending at Richmond, will tirminate in Col. Burr's being convicted of the Horse-Ail—as Mr. Botts, attorney for the defendant, strongly opposes the operations of Mr.
See moreSee less
Hay, and most of the jury are members of the Jocky-Club.—Our correspondent adds, that, in case of conviction, Mr. Duane is of opinion that he ought to ride quarantine astride the bowsprit of gun-boat No. 1, in the vicinity of Blennerhasset's Island, and be restrained from touching cold iron for the term of three
The passage describes courtroom proceedings in the Burr trial, including arguments over General Wilkinson's conduct and testimony, followed by the grand jury's return of indictments against Burr. Burr's counsel contested the indictment, alleging perjury, and debated whether he could still be granted bail despite the treason charge, with the Chief Justice ultimately committing Burr to custody while leaving open future bail motions.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 29 June 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Some additional questions were put to Mr. Graham, relative to the motion against gen. Wilkinson, his answers to which proved nothing against him. Mr. Murray, a military officer under the general, was called as a witness, and deposed that, at the request of gov. Claiborne, he was stationed by gen. Wilkinson with a guard, at a place on the river, about one mile above New-Orleans, at the time when Burr and his forces were expected to come down; that he was commanded to arrest all suspected persons and take their papers, but particularly charged not to break any seals.
The debate then commenced with a speech of Mr. E. Randolph in support of the motion. He was followed by Mr. Martin on the same side: after which Mr. Wirt said the evidence was so clear in favour of gen. Wilkinson, that his counsel were willing to submit the question on the arguments already heard. The counsel for col. Burr insisted on proceeding further.
See moreSee less
Mr. M'Rae then delivered a most eloquent and forcible discourse; which, we believe, convinced every human being who heard it, that the motion was altogether groundless, and gen. Wilkinson was not only innocent but praise-worthy.
Mr. Botts, in reply, was in the midst of a strain of invective against the general—when the grand jury suddenly came in, and made their report on the four indictments!
The consternation visible in the faces of col. Burr and his friends, and the awful impression produced on the surrounding multitude were beyond description.—(We have a very different story as to colonel Burr.)
Mr. Botts added a few remarks: after which col. Burr said it was discretionary with the court to admit him to bail, notwithstanding the finding of the grand jury; and declared he would produce a witness to prove that the indictment against him for treason was obtained by perjury!!
A long and desultory debate ensued, about the power of the court to bail him in this stage of the prosecution.—The Chief Justice at length declared that the court had the power to admit him to bail; but that power ought to be exercised with sound discretion according to the circumstances, and evidence in the case, and the usages of law; that the court could not impeach the verdict of the grand jury without going into all the evidence; and that he knew of no example of a person accused of treason, being admitted to bail after the indictment had been found against him, upon the ground of impeaching or controverting the evidence upon which it was founded. He called on the counsel of col. Burr to produce any such case; observing that the motion to bail him might be renewed; and in the mean time committed him to the custody of the marshal.
General Wilkinson arrived in Hampton Roads and was feted in Richmond amid the ongoing Burr treason proceedings, while Burr sought a subpoena to compel President Jefferson to produce a Wilkinson letter for his defense. The correspondent claims the letter actually incriminates Burr rather than helping him, and reports the grand jury examined Truxton, Eaton, and Stoddart.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 30 June 1807 · page 2
RICHMOND, (VIR.) JUNE 13.
PuiLaperritia, June 19. Extralt of a letter from Richmond, dated 13th Fune, 18c7. ¢ Gen. Wilkinson was yelterday in vited to a public dinner by the Barbe cue Club, at the Haymarket gardens, together with commodore Truxton, Gen. Eaton, Mr. Graham, Secretary of the New-Orleans diftri¢t, major Murray, aid of Gen. Wiikinfon, and several other public charaéters. The General’s appearance at this place has very much altered the afpets of cer tain politicians, and I venture o pre di&t with equal confidence as I have done on the fame fubje&® {feveral months agn, that Gen.
See moreSee less
Wilkinson will come out of this bulinefs to the public fatisfa@ion, - and to his.own honor— and in such a manner as will exhibit federalifm in alliance with Burr in a molt awkward and humiliating atti tude. The chief justice has not ap peared to very great advantage in the proceedings on this cale—a very awk ward proceeding occuired this day which he was under the neceflity of rétracing on the close of the court.— Col.. Burr means to fend off this eve ning a fubpwna duces tecum to the Pre sident of the U. States, requiring him to appear with a certain letter written by Gen, Wilkinfon'to the President from Nachitoches, I believe of 21t O&. last ¢ this letter they fay is im portant to Colonel Burr’s defence, when in fa& those who have seen it, {ay it contains nothing but matter of inculpation, and some circamftances which require not to be publifhad, from found policy in regard to foreign ‘nations. The real object is to endea. vor to throw oditm on the President, under the idea of his holding back evidence, which Burr {fwears may be neceflary to his defence, but which any one might aflirm could not ren der him any fort of service whatever, thouph it might go much to his crim. ination, and certainly add to the cred it both for candor and magnanimity of Gen. Wilkinson. We shall fee by and bye how they will a& upon it— but you may be assured that things wear a very gloomy afpeéi for the con {piracy. The grand jury this day ex amined commodore T'ruxton, general Eaton, and Benjamin Stoddart.”” The opinion of Mr. chief justice Marshall, on the motion of Aaron Burr, to bring the President U. S. be fore the court, concludes as follows 15= ¢ The affidavit on which this mo. tion is grounded, has not been notic ed. Itis believed, chat such a fub peena, as is atked, ought to issue, if there exists any reason for supposing that the testimony may be material, and ought to be admitted. It is only because the fubpeena is addrefled to ‘thofe who adminilter the government of this country, that fuch’an’ aflidavit ‘was required-as would furnifh proba ble cause to believe that the téftimony
This report records a speech, apparently by John Randolph, during the Burr treason trial proceedings, arguing that General Wilkinson had self-interested motives for testifying against Burr and had orchestrated the prosecution's timing. It also describes the harsh treatment of a witness named Hawkins, who was arrested, jailed among felons, and placed under military guard by order of a magistrate.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 June 1807 · page 2
Of flffllWilkinson. The vessel and all on board of her, siwere under the, control of .:Wil l kinson. General Wilkinson's authority, was the only law known" to those on' board of that