As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

July 1807

82 articles

In the story →

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

During the June 20 session of Burr's trial, John Wickham interrupts proceedings to present a letter received from President Jefferson. The letter addresses the handling of General Wilkinson's correspondence and related war and navy department orders requested by the court.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Washington, June 17, 07.

Sir,

See moreSee less

In answering your letter of the 9th, which desired a communication of one to me from gen. Wilkinson, specified by its date, I informed you in mine of the 12th, that I had delivered it, with all other papers respecting the charges against Aaron Burr, to the attorney general, when he went to Richmond, that I had supposed he had left them in your possession, but would immediately write to him, if he had not, to forward that particular letter without delay. I wrote to him accordingly on the same day, but having no answer, I know not whether he has forwarded the letter. I stated in the same letter that I had desired the secretary at war to examine his office in order to comply with your further request to furnish copies of the orders which had been given respecting Aaron Burr and his property; and in a subsequent letter of the same day, I forwarded to you copies of two letters from the secretary at war which appeared to be within the description expressed in your letter.—The order from the secretary of the navy, you said you were in possession of. The receipt of these papers had I presume, so far anticipated, and others this day forwarded, will have substantially fulfilled, the object of a subpoena from the district court of Richmond, requiring that those officers & myself should attend the court in Richmond, with the letter of gen. Wilkinson, the answer to that letter, and the orders of the department of war and the navy therein generally described. No answer to gen. Wilkinson's letter, other than a mere acknowledgment of its receipt in a letter written for a different purpose, was ever written by myself or any other. To these communications of papers, I will add, that if the defendant supposes there were any facts within the knowledge of the heads of departments, or of myself, which can be useful for his defence, from a desire of doing any thing our situation will permit in furtherance of justice, we shall be ready to give him the benefit of it, by way of deposition through any persons whom the court shall authorise to take our testimony at this place; I know indeed that this cannot be done but by consent of parties, and I therefore authorise you to give consent on the part of the U. S. Mr. Burr's consent will be given of course, if he supposes the testimony useful.

As to our personal attendance at Richmond, I am persuaded the court is sensible that paramount duties to the nation at large controul the obligation of compliance with their summons in this case, as they would, should we receive a similar one to attend the trials of Blannerhasset and others in the Mississippi territory, those instituted at St. Louis, and other places on the western waters, or at any place other than the seat of government. To comply with such calls, would leave the nation without an executive branch, whose agency nevertheless is understood to be so constantly necessary, that it is the sole branch which the constitution requires to be always in function. It could not then be contended that it should be withdrawn from its station by any co-ordinate authority.

With respect to papers, there is certainly a public and private side to our offices. To the former, belong grants of lands, patents for inventions, certain commissions, proclamations, and other papers patent in their nature. To the other belong mere executive proceedings. All nations have found necessary, that for the advantageous conduct of their affairs, some of these proceedings at least, should remain known to their executive functionary only. He of course, from the nature of the case, must be the sole judge of which of them the public interest will permit publication. Hence under our constitution, in requests of papers from the legislative to the executive branch, one exception is carefully expressed "as to those which he may deem the public welfare may require not to be disclosed," as you will see in the inclosed resolution of the House of Representatives, which produced the message of Jan. 22, respecting this case. The respect mutually due between the constituted authorities in their official intercourse, as well as sincere dispositions to do for every one what is just, will always ensure from the executive, in exercising the duty of discrimination confided to him, the same candor and integrity, to which the nation has in like manner trusted in the disposal of its judiciary authorities. Considering you as the organ for communicating these sentiments to the court, I address them to you for that purpose, and salute you with esteem and respect.

TH : JEFFERSON.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 23 June 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 26 June 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

Lawyers in the Burr trial debate whether to delay a motion for attachment until General Wilkinson can appear before the court, with counsel on both sides arguing over prior accommodations. Burr's counsel express frustration at the hardship caused by repeated delays while awaiting Wilkinson's testimony before the Grand Jury.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

site counsel of it.

Mr. Botts observed, that it was a spirit of accommodation which had prompted them to a postponement of this motion on Saturday; that it was their anxiety to have Gen. Wilkinson here, which had produced this accommodating disposition, and that if they had not thus waved their usual right of pressing the motion, they might at this time have been in the very body of the investigation. Considering the hardships and inconvenience which this delay imposed upon Col. Burr, it was but fair to retract the consent which they had given on Sa-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 23 June 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Attorneys Hay and Wirt argue before the Chief Justice over when General Wilkinson can appear to testify and cross-examine witnesses, since he is currently occupied before the Grand Jury. The Chief Justice postpones the motion until the next day, ruling that written records of questions and answers will allow Wilkinson to cross-examine once available.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 1 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Jury would find immediately after G. Wilkinson's examination as several witnesses has been sent up after him, and would come before the jury. He conceived that Col. Burr's testimony should be delayed no longer than till to-morrow: and Gen. Wilkinson will cross-examine those witnesses, when he came into court.

Mr. Hay. That is the very circumstance which we wish to avoid. These witnesses are brought here to accuse Gen. Wilkinson, and he ought therefore to be present, to shape our enquiries to the proper point, and to expose their fallacy.—

See moreSee less

[illegible] Justice. Gen. Wilkinson cannot

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

The report details court proceedings including debate over attaching Gen. Wilkinson and the grand jury's return of indictments against Aaron Burr and Herman Blennerhassett for treason and misdemeanor. It also records Burr addressing the court about the possibility of bail following the indictments.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR.

WEDNESDAY, June 24.

About two o'clock the grand jury entered and Mr. Randolph addressed the court: May it please the Court! We have agreed upon several indictments:" which he handed in at the Clerk's table. The Clerk read the endorsements upon them in the following terms.

See moreSee less

An indictment against Aaron Burr for Treason. "A True Bill."

An indictment against Aaron Burr for a Misdemeanor. "A True Bill."

An indictment against Herman Blannerhasset for Treason. "A True Bill."

An indictment against H. Blannerhasset for a Misdemeanor.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 27 June 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The grand jury returns true bills against Aaron Burr and Herman Blennerhassett for treason and for misdemeanor charges. The court then hears arguments from counsel over whether Burr should be granted bail or committed, with lawyers debating the scope of judicial discretion under the Judicial Act.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR

An indictment against H. Blannerhasset for a Misdemeanor.

"A True Bill."

See moreSee less

Mr. Randolph then continued: May it please the Court! Although the grand jury have returned the bills; they have still other subjects for their consideration, and have adjourned themselves to meet to-morrow at 10 o'clock.

A short time elapsed, when Mr. Burr addressed the court: As bills had been found against him, it was probable, the publick prosecutor would move for his commitment: he would however suggest two ideas for the consideration of the court: the one was that it was within their discretion to bail in certain cases even when the punishment was death: and the other was that it was expedient for the court to exercise their discretion in this instance, as he should prove that the indictment against him had been obtained by perjury.

Mr. Hay moved for the commitment of A. Burr: he stated that if the court had the power to bai[l t]

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Lawyers argue whether the circuit court has discretion to grant bail to Burr after the grand jury's indictment, with disputes over perjured testimony and common law precedent. Hay reverses his earlier opinion, now arguing Burr is not entitled to bail.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ought, therefore, to be previously settled.

Mr. Hay, when he first addressed the court, was of opinion, that the circuit court had this power; having been misled by a very transient conversation with the chief justice on the first examination of Mr. Burr: he had however considered this subject more maturely, and the more he thought of it, the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Attorneys debate whether Burr can be bailed, with Wickham arguing the treason charge rests on constructive presence at Blannerhassett's Island, while Wirt and the Chief Justice press for legal precedents. The Chief Justice ultimately commits Burr to the marshal's custody pending further argument, and he is taken to jail.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

constructive murder is of the very same stamp as the constructive treason of col. Burr, who was indicted for an act said to be done in Blannerhasset's island, where he was said to be present, although

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

During Aaron Burr's treason proceedings, Chief Justice Marshall commits Burr to the custody of the marshal after a dispute over producing legal authorities. The grand jury, through foreman John Randolph, asks the court's assistance in obtaining a ciphered letter from General Wilkinson that Burr possesses, while Burr resists revealing confidential correspondence.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 1 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Thursday, June 25.

About 1 o'clock the grand jury entered, and their foreman Mr. Randolph addressed the court to the following effect:

See moreSee less

"May it please the court! The grand jury have been informed, that there is in the possession of A. Burr a certain letter with the post mark of May 13, from James Wilkinson, in cyphers, which they deem to be material to certain enquiries now pending before them. The grand jury are perfectly aware that they have no right to demand any evidence from the prisoner under prosecution, which may go to criminate himself. But the grand jury have thought proper to appear in court, to ask its assistance, if it thinks proper to grant it, in making such a requisition in their behalf.

Mr. Burr rose and asked whether the court was about to give an opinion?

The Chief Justice stated, that the court was about to say that the grand jury were perfectly right in the opinion that no man can be forced to furnish evidence against himself: he presumed that the grand jury wished also to know, whether the person under prosecution, could be examined on other questions, not criminating himself.

Mr. Burr declared, that it would be impossible for him under certain circumstances, to expose any letter which had been communicated to him confidentially; how far the extremity of circumstances would impel him to such a conduct, he was not prepared to decide; but it was impossible for him even to deliberate on the proposition to deliver up any thing which had been confided to his honour; unless it was extorted from him by the law.

Mr Randolph. We will withdraw to our chamber, and when the court have decided upon the question, they will announce it to the grand jury. The Chief Justice, knew not that there was any objection to the grand jury summoning any man as a witness, who lays under an indictment.—Mr. Martin said there could be no objection.—Mr. Randolph said he was afraid that the object of this grand jury had been misunderstood by the court. The grand jury had not appeared before them to apply for the person of A. Burr, but for a certain paper, which may or may not be in his possession; and upon that paper's being or not being in his possession, and upon its being possible or not possible to identify that paper, it might depend, whether A. Burr himself was or was not a material evidence before them

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Virginia Executive Council offered apartments in the Penitentiary house as alternative confinement for federal prisoners, citing overcrowding at the Richmond jail. Prosecutor Hay moved to transfer Burr there to save guard expenses, but defense counsel Wickham objected, arguing it would hinder attorney access and citing minimal security benefit.

Virginia Argus · 1 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Edmund Randolph, as counsel for Col. Burr, objected to this proposal; and Mr Hay observed that he would consult his co-adjutors in the prosecution, before he made any motion on the subject. He retired for that purpose, and, after a short consultation with Messrs M'Rae and Wirt, returned into court; and said he deemed it his duty to move that Aaron Burr should be removed to an apartment provided for him in the Penitentiary house; observing that very considerable expense would be saved by it to the United States, and more security would exist against the prisoner's escape.

See moreSee less

It appeared that the expense of his guard at present, amounted to seven dollars a day, which sum would be saved by confining him in the place proposed. Mr. Wickham warmly opposed the measure; declaring that Col. Burr would have preferred remaining in the county Jail to

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A defense attorney argues before the court regarding the subpoena duces tecum directed at President Jefferson, citing the precedent of Marbury v. Madison and the role of the Secretary of State in such matters. He questions why the subpoena was addressed to the president rather than the secretary of state if the papers are public, and argues the president should not be compelled to produce documents if they are confidential.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 2 July 1807 · page 2

tatp whether these papere contain considen. tial communications to the head of the go— vernment. but, s'n', if the papers which are called for by the :.ffidavit osA. Burr be

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

Report from Richmond describes the grand jury examining witnesses after indictments for treason and misdemeanor were filed against Burr and Blennerhasset. It also covers disputes over subpoenaed documents, a tendered pardon to Dr. Bollman, and correspondence between the President and prosecutor Hay regarding evidence.

The Wheeling Repository · 2 July 1807 · page 6

WHEELING, Thursday, 2d July, 1807. Trial of Burr.

Trial of Burr. Our intelligence from Richmond U as jftte as Tuesday the Kith ult. tieneral Wilkinson arrived on Saturdav the 13th. On the same day Mr. Hay laid four in dictments before the grand jury—two against Burr and two against Blenner hasset,—one lor treason, and one for a misdemeanor, against eat h. On '] tu .v day evening the grand jury were pro gressing in the examination of w itnesscs. 1 hey had not examined more than five or six out of about .50 that were sworn. I lie court were occupied by motions and counter motions respecting evi dence, J he President has tendered a pardon to Dr.

See moreSee less

Bollman. lie at first in clined to accept it, but lias since detcr T’\‘ •" d neither to accept nor reject it.— Mr. Hay has filed it with the clerk. A question has risen, whether he is bound to answer questions which may crimi ■nate himself. The court had not dod ged upon it. The court awarded the subpoenas (tu tu tecum, mentioned in our last, to pro

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A grand jury returned true bills of indictment against Aaron Burr and Herman Blannerhassett for treason and for misdemeanor. Burr's counsel then argued before the court for bail, claiming the indictment was obtained by perjury, while the prosecution argued for his commitment.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 1

WASHINGTON ADVERTISER BURR

r.ii-deineanor. « A true bill." j Mr. h then continued : May ! lurt l Although the giand j tills, they have other subjects for their consldera and have adjourned themselves to morrow at ten o'clock. :o't time elapsed, when Mr. Burr I the court : As bills had b-en

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom arguments over whether the circuit court has discretion to grant bail to Aaron Burr following his treason indictment. Hay, Martin, and Burr himself dispute the legal basis for bail and the reliability of the grand jury's evidence.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 1

doubt, that such existed. j Mr. Burr. TV I questions have been blended in this discussion, which ought to have been kept st pa rtite: Ist, Whether this court had the ritrht to bail according to its discretion ; and 2nd!y. Whether it was expedfi t.t to exercir-e its right in the present in stance. If the court had no discretion, it was unnecessary to produce evidence. That question, ought, therefore, to be previoudy nettled. Mr. Hay, when he first addressed the court, wss of opinion, that the cir cuit court had this power ; having been misled hy a very tr insient conversa tion with the Chief .T'stice on the first examination of Mr.

See moreSee less

Burr: he had however considered this subject mere maturely, and the more he thought of ss_ the more was he convinced 'hat a. Burr was not privileged to demand bail, I his question was to he decided by the

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Lawyers debate whether the court has power to bail Burr and Blannerhassett, comparing it to the King's Bench, and whether a 1807 act of Congress removes that power. The court rules it does have discretionary power to bail, and Burr's counsel argues the indictment rested on perjured testimony from General Tupper, which prosecutors dispute.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 1

'"•Tr. Martin protested foe ingenious fci- -r. Wart.. chi.iienr-' d him to name of ki:ig Ar time who did or could set in the of King's Bench. After a ' ■ 1 -ihorate argrrment on this point, the t that the court hi. i tl-«- power to bail a ■ tier indicted i ling to its 9dbnd discretion; '•'■cretion v r::s to he ■.- and cir aim ce«rof the evidence, and the ■ Jaw. Mr. Burr staler' that the court had

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The court addressed Aaron Burr's secure confinement, ordering a room fitted with a strong bar and guard for his safekeeping during the trial. Burr was then formally arraigned on the treason indictment regarding the overt act at Blannerhassett's Island on December 10, 1806, and pled not guilty, putting himself upon his country for trial.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Proceedings introductory to the Trial.

Mr. Hay. My only wish is, that this prosecution should be regularly conducted. Is it not the usual practice to read the indictment first, and then move for the Venire.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. I will say that I have been furnished with a copy of the indictment; that I have perused it; & that I plead not guilty to it.

M. Wirt. The usual form requires the actual arraignment of the prisoner: however the court may dispense with it, if they think proper.

Mr. Hay was indifferent about the form; if the law could be substantially executed. He supposed that a simple acknowledgement of the prisoner was sufficient without the customary form of holding up his hand, &c.

Chief Justice. It is enough, if he appear to the indictment, and plead not guilty.

The clerk read the indictment against Aaron Burr, for treason against the U. S.—which specifies the place of the Overt Act, to be at Blannerhasset's Island; & the time the 10th day of December, 1806.

When he had concluded, Mr. Burr, addressed the court: "I acknowledge myself to be the person named in the indictment: I plead not guilty; and put myself upon my country for trial."

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Aaron Burr was brought before the court, arraigned on treason charges, and pleaded not guilty. Because trial in Wood County was impractical, the court ordered a new venire of 48 jurors to convene August 3, and the Virginia executive council offered penitentiary apartments due to overcrowded jail conditions.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR.

SATURDAY, June 27.

See moreSee less

The court took the following order on the postponement of the trial.

Aaron Burr, late of the city of New-York, and state of New-York, attorney at law, who stands indicted for treason, was this day brought to the bar in custody of the marshal of this district, and thereof arraigned and pleaded not guilty to the indictment, and for his trial put himself upon God and the country, whereupon he is remanded to jail. And as the trial of the said Aaron Burr cannot be had in the county of Wood, where the offence is alledged to have been committed, without great inconvenience, it is ordered that a venire facias issue, to the marshal of this district to be directed, commanding him to summon forty-eight fit persons qualified as the law directs, twelve of whom from the said county of Wood, to appear here on the third day of August next, as a venire for the trial of the said Burr.

MONDAY, June 29.

Mr. Hay laid the following order of the executive counsel before the court :

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Executive Council offers the federal court use of the penitentiary's third story for prisoners, which the court accepts. Burr's counsel then objects to committing him there, citing restricted access for consultations, though the Chief Justice notes this was less critical after the trial's postponement.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR

TUESDAY, June 30. The motion to commit A. Burr to the Penitentiary was renewed. It was objected to by his counsel on the ground—(and an affidavit was made by them to the same effect) that in so im-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Virginia's governor offers apartments in the state penitentiary for federal prisoners, placing them under the marshal's control. The court orders Aaron Burr moved to these penitentiary apartments once ready, to be returned to his current location by August 2nd.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Sir, your obedient servant, WM. H. CABELL.

GEORGE HAY, Esq.

See moreSee less

The court then came to the following order:

In consequence of the offer made by the executive of apartments in the third story of the penitentiary and state prison, for persons who may be confined therein under the authority of the United States, and of the foregoing letter from the governour of this commonwealth, it is ordered, on the motion of the attorney for the United States, that so soon as the apartments in the second story of the publick jail and penitentiary shall be fit for the reception and safe keeping of Aaron Burr, he be removed thereto and safely kept therein by the marshal, until the second day of August next, when he shall be brought back to the prison where he is now placed, there to be guarded in like manner as at present, until the further order of the court.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The court ruled that General Wilkinson did not act with intentional abuse of process or contempt toward the court regarding his deputy marshal's actions, and declined to issue an attachment against him. The court also set the first Monday in August as the date for Colonel Burr's trial and addressed compensation for defense witnesses.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

was intended to this court by general Wilkinson, that he has not been guilty of any intentional abuse of its process, or of any oppression in the manner of executing it.

It is said that Capt. Gaines the gentleman whom the marshal had appointed as his deputy for this particular purpose, had not taken the oath of office, and was therefore not legally qualified to act in that character. However correct this observation may be in itself it does not appear to the court to justify an attachment against gen. Wilkinson. The per-

See the clipping

In the story →

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The court considers a motion to move Aaron Burr from his current confinement to rooms at the penitentiary, citing cost savings and space for other accused parties. Burr's counsel, including Mr. Wickham, object to the sudden change after arrangements had already been made with a full court's approval.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The court directed that the clerk enter the communication from the executive as accepted—and desired, that if any motion was intended to be made, as it regards col. Burr, that it might be made this day: upon which Mr. Hay had an interview with Messrs. Wirt and M'Rea, after which he appeared again at the bar, and stated, that he deemed it his duty to motion, that Aaron Burr be removed from his present place of confinement, to one of the apartments alluded to in the communication from the executive—he said, that the present establishment for the confinement of col. Burr was expensive and not safe; and that probably two hundred or more dollars would be saved to the United States by removing him under the proposition of the Virginia executive—he also mentioned, that, in a short time, many others associated in the crime, which col. Burr was charged with, might be brought hither, and that it was certainly correct, that provision should be made, for their accommodation.

Mr. Wickham (Mr. Randolph and Mr. Martin being absent) observed, that it was very probable that colonel Burr would prefer risquing his own and the lives of his counsel, in an apartment in Mr. Roses jail—that the United States had, and probably would, expend thousands and tens of thousands upon this important enquiry, and that the sum of one or two hundred dollars, could not be important; that the situation of colonel Burr's council, he thought, ought also to be taken into consideration.

See moreSee less

The court proposed that the subject should be postponed till to morrow, in which Mr. Hay acquiesced.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes joining Burr's expedition down the Ohio and Mississippi, meeting Burr at Cumberland Island, and later being arrested on Wilkinson's affidavit. Under cross-examination, he details the journey, the boats, and his treatment after arrest before arriving in Richmond for the trial.

The Enquirer · 3 July 1807 · page 2

town, went with about double the number to Cumberland ifimd, (laid a day and a half, mtf with col. Burr and a tew others, tlte who e number 50 or f,o, about 7 or s boats, five fin a-mi, went thence to fort Maflac. Serjenn! Dunbangh joined them therewith a rrujket ; after ftneting with col. Burr, ennfidered him

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

During pretrial proceedings, Burr's counsel moves for a subpoena duces tecum compelling President Jefferson to produce a letter from General Wilkinson. Prosecutor Hay objects that Burr, having only been committed for a misdemeanor with no indictment yet found, has no legal right to demand such process.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Chief Justice decided that Mr. Hay might state his objections. Mr. H. then proceeded. The motion now made by Mr. Burr, as far as he could understand it, was to obtain a subpoena from the court (or rather from the judges sitting there) to the president of the U. S. to attend this court with an original letter from general Wilkinson to the president of the U. S. and afterwards referred to by him in his communication to congress of January 27th.—He contended that this motion was premature. Colonel Burr was not authorised by any legal precedents or by the statutes of this or any other country, to demand legal process for obtaining witnesses, whilst he remained in his present situation?

See moreSee less

He had been committed for a misdemeanor, and recognized to appear before this court: And in consequence of this recognizance he is now present. The court would recollect that no bill had been found, that no bill had been sent up to the grand jury. And all that can be said is that colonel Burr is

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

This passage records courtroom argument over whether a subpoena process for evidence and witnesses should be issued before an indictment is found against Aaron Burr. The speaker argues the motion is premature since the prosecution's progress depends on General Wilkinson's arrival, and no formal indictment or trial date yet exists.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

There is another little difficulty in this case. When is this process to be made returnable? Some day must be named. But can the court name any day, when the witnesses or the papers shall be wanted? Do the records of this court indicate any particular day, when the trial is to commence? Sir, such a nomination would be completely arbitrary. Let an indictment be first found; let a day be first set for the trial; and on that day might this process be returnable. But, sir, even if a day could be fixed on, it does not appear, that this testimony will be wanted during this term.

See moreSee less

It depends upon the arrival of general Wilkinson: It literally depends upon the winds and the waves. The very language of the process confirms this argument. How could the evidence be heard, before the accused is put upon his trial? Perhaps it may be said, that this evidence may be wanted, in case we repeat the motion for committing A. Burr for high treason; and which we shall certainly attempt if gen. W. does not make his appearance. On this point two remarks only are necessary to be made. The first is, that no such motion is actually before the court; and further, if any such motion was made, the court would have no right to issue process, before the commencement of the trial. The court has no more right

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Attorneys argue over whether the court has the right to give specific instructions to the grand jury after its initial charge, with one side citing precedent against such interruptions and the other defending the practice given new information since the original charge. The exchange reflects procedural wrangling during the treason proceedings against Aaron Burr.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 2

Jury on the ground of treason: and that under this expectation, the Chief Justice l h»J dilated on the nature of treason, and givtp all the information which he t thought material: that there wae no 1 reason at all, why A. Burr should enjoy greateer privileges than any other tan ; tohy he should rake up all the old, mue ty and absurd doctrines of antiquity, and have them enlistsd in hig service ; and that he stood on sBp very same ground as any other man 11 that perhaps all the propositions on Me. Burr’s list

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The passage records courtroom debate during Aaron Burr's treason trial proceedings, with discussion over whether the judge should commit to opinions on points that might arise before the grand jury. Burr's counsel, Mr. Wickham, argues for the right to obtain a subpoena duces tecum to compel production of papers (rather than personal appearance) from the president, asserting an accused man's right to obtain witnesses in his defense.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 2

Mr. Burr, then requested him to in speet the list of propositions, which he had prepared ; he might then determine which of those points would admitof the

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

A defense attorney argues before the court that Burr has the same right as the prosecution to subpoena witnesses and documents, citing the precedent of Smith and Ogden's trial where subpoenas were issued for Madison and Dearborn. The speaker contends that denying Burr equal access to witnesses would be an unconstitutional and unequal proceeding.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 2

Suppose that colonel Burr was now put on hi* examination ; would he not hate a right to examine any witnesses, who were beyond the bar, and of course to subpoena every man, who would be brought before you during the term of examination? This practice is evert ! day pursued by magistrates. Why not • in the present case ? ' It has been said, that there is nothin* in this country to justify such an apoli! '•'I00. * thcre «• «o precedents. But I will «^uote, sir, another trial, which wa, similar in its proceeding*^ and similar, I trust, in its results.

See moreSee less

Ire fcr to the cases ot Smith and Ogden be f»e the circuit court of New-Tork. Subpoenas were actually taken out, be fore the trial, for Measra. Madison end Dearborn s and even the expense, of their travelling wera tendered to them. Hilt tB» nPAT»a<i;m*. _

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

The court debated bail for Burr before committing him to jail, then proceedings turned to a motion for attachment against General Wilkinson. The grand jury asked whether Burr must produce a coded letter from Wilkinson, but Burr refused to disclose confidential correspondence on grounds of honor.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Latest proceedings in the case of COL. BURR. Richmond, Wednesday, June 24.

The grand jury on presenting their bills against A. Burr and H. Blannerhasset, informed the court that they had not finished the business before them, having enquiries to make against other persons.

See moreSee less

The argument on an attachment against general Wilkinson went on. Messrs. E. Randolph, Martin, M'Rea, and Botts spoke. While the last gentleman was speaking the grand jury entered the court with their bills.

Mr. Hay moved for the commitment of Col. Burr for high treason.

Mr. Burr and his counsel contended that it was in the discretion of the court to allow bail even in a capital case.

After a long discussion the court expressed the opinion that they were vested with the power, but postponed the consideration of the fitness of allowing bail in the present instance to the next day.

Mr. Burr was then committed to the charge of the marshal, who attended him to his lodgings, where having dined, he was conducted to the public jail.

Thursday, June 25.--The argument on a motion for an attachment against Wilkinson, mixed with much extraneous matter, progressed. In the midst of Mr. Hay's speech, Mr. Burr entered, attended by two deputy marshalls.

At 1 o'clock the grand jury entered--Mr. Randolph, the Foreman, addressed the court--"May it please the court, the grand jury have been informed by a witness that there is in possession of A. Burr who is now present in court, a letter from general James Wilkinson, dated the 18th of May, written in cypher, which letter the grand jury think will afford to them information on matters under consideration. The grand jury therefore wish to know whether the court sees any impropriety, or if it be legal, that A. Burr should deliver up this letter, if it contain matter criminating himself.

Chief Justice.--Certainly no man can be called upon to produce evidence which may criminate himself; but if col. Burr thinks proper voluntarily to produce any letter which the grand jury may require, the court sees no impropriety in his doing so.

Col. Burr. With respect to any information, letters or papers which

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 29 June 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

During courtroom proceedings, grand jury deliberates on whether General Wilkinson's testimony can be compelled, with Wilkinson releasing Burr from secrecy regarding their correspondence. The grand jury returns presentments for treason against Jonathan Dayton, John Smith, Comfort Tyler, Israel Smith, and Davis Floyd, with formal indictments against Dayton and Smith following the next day.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 3 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

gen. Wilkinson. Mr. M'Rae rose and stated to the court that after the grand jury went out, he had a conversation with gen. Wilkinson and that he was authorized by general Wilkinson to request that all the correspondence between colonel Burr and himself should be made public, and that col. Burr through him was absolved from every promise of secrecy he might have given to gen. Wilkinson. Colonel Burr—"May it please the court, some reply no doubt is expected from me to the information which the gentleman has given with respect to gen. Wilkinson—The production of that letter is not now in my power. The letter is not in my possession; and gen. Wilkinson knows this to be the case."

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

During Burr's treason trial, Mr. Randolph moved for an attachment against General Wilkinson for allegedly using improper means to bring witnesses Knox and Lindsley from New Orleans, obstructing justice. Wilkinson appeared in court and sat with the prosecution as witness Knox was examined regarding his dealings with the general.

Herald of the United States · 4 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LAST PROCEEDINGS

Mr. Day who opposed their reading. After some disputation at the bar, Col. Burr agreed, on account of the absence of Gen. Wilkinson, who was then with the grand jury, that the further consideration of the motion should be postponed till Monday. Mr. Randolph then gave notice that he would vary his motion, and instead of the rule to shew cause move for the attachment.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

John Randolph opens a motion accusing General Wilkinson of using unlawful means to compel witnesses James Knox and Chandler Lindsley to travel from New Orleans to Richmond, obstructing the court. Knox testifies about his reluctant involvement with Burr's expedition and his forced transport as a witness, followed by testimony from Lieutenant Gaines on the circumstances of securing Knox's appearance.

Herald of the United States · 4 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LAST PROCEEDINGS

of May he had been formally supoenaed by Lieut. Gaines; about 4 days afterwards he was taken up and carried before Judge Hall, who wished to recognize him in a large sum for his appearance on this trial, which he had refused to give; that he was then committed to the jail, from which he was removed by serjeant Dunbaugh on board the U. States vessel Revenge, and conveyed to this city. On his cross examination it appeared that the witness was one of Burr's men, had been engaged by Comfort Tyler at Meadville; had descended the Ohio and the Mississippi as far as Natchez; and that he had conceived himself as moving under Burr's direction.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report decries the treatment of a U.S. citizen from New Orleans, arrested on mere suspicion of being a witness against Burr and transported under harsh conditions to Richmond for trial. It also includes courtroom exchange about a letter's suspicious lack of a postmark, with Mr. Hay denying one existed.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 6 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

could give evidence against col. Burr, in this court, to which place he was willing to come, he was committed to prison without

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The passage records courtroom debate during Aaron Burr's treason trial over whether a witness (Wilkinson) can be compelled to answer questions about a cipher letter. Counsel argue the witness has the right to decline answering if it might implicate him, citing precedent from English state trials.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 6 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Now for the abstract question of law.

The question put to Willie is "do you understand that the original of this letter was written by Col. Burr." (Mr. Mc Rae— No; that is not the question last put.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

This report covers courtroom arguments in the Burr treason trial over whether a witness may decline to answer questions that might incriminate him, citing legal precedent about a Catholic priest's right to silence. It also includes a political commentary defending Federalists against accusations of supporting Burr, while criticizing Jefferson's administration.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 6 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

If the present question is answered others must be put, which the witness cannot answer. His reason, or how he came to understand that part of the letter which is in cypher, ought to be put, if the one announced is. Gilb. L. of Ev. 154. Could he answer the second question and shall he tell half the truth and have his lips closed as to the other half? It were better that he should tell the whole though it were to involve him in the prosecution with col. Burr.

I know nothing of the contents of this letter. It may have been written for aught I know, by some young amorous intriguer to his mistress.

See moreSee less

Before I sit down I will beg leave of the gentlemen, when they offer a paper for any purpose, to lodge it with the clerk. We do not wish again to press upon the court to rule such a measure without necessity, but heretofore we have been prevented from getting a sight of any paper until the moment of discussion, and then not without difficulty.

The democratic prints are still dinning in our ears that the federalists are at the bottom of Burr's treason: that the federalists of every quarter are arrayed in defence of a culprit, &c. &c. This senseless cant will do no injury; for it is not believed either by those who say it, or by those to whom it is said. It is well known that the federalists have no sympathies for Aaron Burr. They have not forgotten that the democrats placed him exactly on a par with Jefferson in an election for president and vice-president. This is enough. It is true that many of the federalists thought that as the democrats had forced upon us the necessity of taking one or the other for president, the election of Burr would be the less of two great evils; and if we may judge from the prostration which has since happened to the constitution, and to the rights and liberties of the citizens under the administration of Jefferson, we have a right to believe that they were not mistaken. We repeat therefore, that the federalists are not arrayed in defence of Aaron Burr. We care not, as it

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Dr. Bollman writes to the grand jury investigating Aaron Burr, protesting that he has been publicly called a 'pardoned man' by the prosecution despite having rejected an offered pardon in open court. He argues the label unfairly implies guilt and taints his testimony against Burr, and asks the court to correct the record.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 6 July 1807 · page 3

UENTLESIEX, I find myself placed in a very unusual and painful •situation. B'fore I was sworn and sent up to you as a witness against col. Burr, a patent of pardon was tendered to me in open court by the attorney for the United States. It had not been solicited by me, and I cou'.u not ibink of receiving it, because the ac ceptance would have implied an acknowledgment of guilt, and would have led to inferences against col. Burr, which I could not have reconciled to my con

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

During courtroom proceedings on June 30, lawyers argued over whether Aaron Burr should be moved to the penitentiary, with concerns raised about his access to counsel. The court ultimately received a letter from the Council Chamber assuring that the marshal would control visitation rights for any prisoner held for the United States.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 6 July 1807 · page 3

LA TES T PROCEEDINGS. Tuesday, jane—30. si_=-,_-ctct [Concluded from Friday's paper.) ' Mr. Hay remarked he would not in mediately oppose the atatemeot ofsi'the gen tlemen, but he thought it his dutysit'o sup 1 port the motion which he had made. All he wished was that Mr. Burr shuuid be put into a place of security. " Mr..I-Vicklzam tozeio reply and stated that the speech ground of application was not that Mr. Hay mentioned, for that col. Burr would ausser material loss from being deprived of the aseistaoce of his coun sel, were be removed to the penitentia.

See moreSee less

ry. Mr. Baker stated to the court at eorne length his own particular reasons why col. Burr should not be removed to the peniten. trary. The Court were of opinion that if the executive afforded colonel Burr the same opportunity of seeing his counsel in the penitentiary as at present, his removal would he proper, but that they could not give theorder until he was assured of . l this. . ! Mr. Hay replied, that in '24 houre the executive would make the proviaton the ' court required. ' About one o'clock Mr. Hay delivered tho' following letter to the court:

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This opinion piece argues that Burr's objections to General Wilkinson's witnesses—brought by compulsion rather than ordinary summons—reveal his guilt rather than innocence. The writer contends that an innocent man would confront evidence directly rather than complain about procedural technicalities and delay tactics.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 7 July 1807 · page 3

;figyg?vgre compéfledfi come here— thse proceeding is.not according to the s;of law ; it was a contempt of eourt not to fumnmon them in the reg ufar way”’—can any th‘in_]g {peak loud er’ffi%@j}fciofifflgfil{}ggnilt, the ina bility to meet the evidence these men could give. Innocence wonld glory in the extent of persecution, because its final triumph would be the greater ~—but at every step, Burr cgiaplains of forms, and circumßances, isles 5 he del. ys and upbraids ; profelies in nocence, yet covers himfelf" under ev cigdleipicable quibble and fubterfuge. ‘SWhy do not the railers against the 2 OVEIn ent,, the friends of Burr, ex

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This opinion piece criticizes Burr's legal maneuvering as evidence of guilt and attacks his defenders as enemies of the country's peace, while also calling for Wilkinson to face investigation if wrongdoing is found. A dispatch from Richmond reports that the grand jury is examining General Wilkinson extensively, with rumors suggesting more conspirators exist and significant evidence has been produced.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 7 July 1807 · page 3

can fay out of ‘their own body ; and: indeed I queltion if there has been any fifting of sentiment among themselves yet,becatfe upon Wilkinson’s evidence will greatly depend the beafring and repulsion of the adverse witnesses.” = Aaq opinion is cirrent out of doors, that the grand jury will have evidence {uperabundant to prove that the real! oy« of the conspirators was Orleans, | and that the Mexican expedition was' no more than a lure to entice those. whose passion was money. There are many pertdns from the westward here, who do not hesitate to assert this, and that the real plan was the seizure of N.

See moreSee less

Orleans andFloridas under the pro tection of G. Britain ; this faé is said to have been eftablithed by the evi dence or acknowledgement of Boll man. The cypher of which the key is Cusa, Bollman fays was one of bis, left with a private friend, but had no concern (he fays) with Burr’s conspi racy ! Its being hisr however removes the doubt which some of our friends appeared to entertain of its authenti city. I fufpe@ that the cypher of which the key is France will have been fully explained to the grand jury., The letter with ‘German and 'a cypher charaéter in the body, is not yet decy phered—it is an arbitrary cypher and would require much pains to unravel —it is proved on the oath of Wylly to have been copied from a writing of Mr. Barr. It was diréfted to Hernry Windbsurne, which was the cypher name of Dr. Bollman ; there were se veral others who were addressed under thele fi&itious names, some of which I have seen in the band awriting of Burr, tho’ the spelling was artificially incorrect, and a feigned name—all a bout land fpeculazions of course 11 The examination of Gen. Wilkin son commenced on Friday, continued all Batutday, and is not expected to close before Tuesday evening. lam happy to find that the venerable Col. Morgan and his sons Johaand Thomas of Washington county, Pennsylvania, who are here as witneffas, have ‘ac quired great credit for ‘their good ev idence before the grand jury, particnAarly the younger Thomas. John was l_formerly adjutant general in Jersey. The bills before the grand jury are one for treason againft*A. Burr,ano ther for misdemeanor—two similar bills are laid againt Blannerhaffet. « If T am not very much deceived there will be similar bills against othersand among them the great thunderer.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report details grand jury proceedings in Richmond, including testimony from General Wilkinson and revelations about Dr. Bollman's cipher and alleged plans to seize New Orleans and Florida. It concludes by noting the grand jury found two bills against Aaron Burr, one for high treason.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 7 July 1807 · page 3

{ Democratic Press. Of all the a&ts of insolence, of un lawtul force, of tendencies fatal to our peace with the other belligerents, of uvomanly aud barbarian violence, and ot opposition to juit feelings and found principles, the attempt of the Britith Admiral’s’ ship * Leopard to force by broad{ides on a disarmed frigate, our commodore Barron to return our im prefled countrymen to the guns of the Britilh navy, there to fight against na tions with which we are at peace, is the most excefiive. N Lbid. If the convition of Gen.

See moreSee less

Wilkin son for improper, or even unconftitu. tional conduét, could absolve Burr from 2all responsibility, we would not wonder at the artempts made at Rich mond, and in all the federal prints, to represent the charaéer of the former in the molk odious light. Bat, the two questions are totally diftin&: Burr is arraigned for tzeafon, and Wilkia fon is called /o prove it—what would be the course of an horelt and inno-’ cent man, in this fmation 5 would he fly from defence of himfeif, to accofa tion of the witness 2 would he avoid, the‘queftion -of treasonable guile, and difcant upon the mwde in which the treason was deteéted 2 he undoubtedly would not ; he wourld meet the evi:! denee itlelf, he would expose its falla cy, and relt his cause upon the nature of the testimony. _ ‘ How different sis the ¢ondu&, of Burr—when heistold, that Wilkinson has brought Tome of Burr’s owwn con fdan:s to prove his treason, he an{wers,,

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A newspaper account of a Wheeling Light Infantry Independence Day celebration lists seventeen patriotic toasts given at a riverside dinner. One toast directly references Aaron Burr's recent expedition, expressing hope that if he is guilty of treason he will be speedily punished.

The Wheeling Repository · 9 July 1807 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

4th. Aaron Burr's late expedition---If he has been guilty of Treason, may he be speedily punished.

5th. The Constitution of the United States---May it never be altered but by the voice of the people.

See moreSee less

6th. The Constitution of Virginia---May its errors be speedily expunged.

7th. The Congress of the United States; May the public good be their only object.

8th. Thomas Jefferson, the Statesman and Philosopher---May he continue to support the principles of Republicanism, in opposition to internal and external enemies.

9th. The Vice-President of the United States.

10th. The Heads of Departments.

11th. The several State Governments.

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper

Defense attorney Martin argues that Burr is entitled to copies and originals of government orders relevant to his defense, accusing Jefferson of prejudging Burr's guilt and trying to withhold evidence. He insists the accused has a sacred right to all evidence necessary for his defense in a capital case.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 10 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

[CONTINUED.]

Mr. Randolph here related the particulars of his own correspondence with Mr. R. Smith, secretary of the navy.

Mr. Martin proceeded to the following effect:—I have asserted, that col. Burr was entitled to a copy of these orders. We intended to show that these orders were contrary to the constitution and the laws, and that they entitled col. Burr to the right of resistance. We intended to show, that by this particular

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 18 June 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The passage describes courtroom arguments over the proper oath for the grand jury and whether General Wilkinson must produce certain papers before them. Four indictments were presented, including two against Burr for treason and misdemeanor, amid disputes between prosecutor Hay and defense counsel over procedure.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 10 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

oath.

Mr. Hay then informed the court that there were four indictments before the grand jury, two against col. Burr, and two against Mr. Blannerhasset; one against each for high treason, and one for a misdemeanor.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham moved the court that no papers which were not authenticated should be sent up to the grand jury.—He wished solely for the opinion of the court on this subject.

Mr. Hay hoped the court would not agree to the motion, on a mere suggestion of the counsel. That it was very

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A prosecutor argues in court that the papers Aaron Burr has subpoenaed—a letter from General Wilkinson and War Department orders—are not relevant or material to the treason and misdemeanor charges against him. He contends the orders merely authorized Burr's apprehension and, if necessary, destruction of his boats, not the extreme measures Burr's defense has implied.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

tion of himself, his people and his property. Now, sir, what possible tendency can either of these papers have to acquit the prisoner of the treason or the misdemeanor. As to the orders which have been depicted as being so sanguinary and despotic, I affirm, with the power of proof to support me, that such orders never were given: though if it be true, that Aaron Burr had placed himself in a state of war with his country; was aiming a blow at the vitals of our government and liberty, and that blow could be averted in no other way, I hold that his destruction would have been a virtue, a great and glorious virtue.

See moreSee less

Affairs, however, had not reached that desperate crisis. We have seen the orders, sir, and at a proper time will produce them; the very orders to lieutenant Shaw, which the prisoner has so often mentioned, as having been published in the Natchez Gazette: those orders are not as he has described them, they are simply orders to apprehend Aaron Burr, and if it shall become necessary for that purpose to destroy his boats. These are the bloody orders which have been so often mentioned with looks of such tragic and mysterious import! Suppose the orders were as barbarous as he has described them, and that the emergency did not justify them; they prove the administration wrong; but do they prove or tend to prove Aaron Burr innocent. If the president were on his

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report covers courtroom argument during Aaron Burr's treason trial concerning whether orders from the President to apprehend Burr, even if harsh, are relevant to proving Burr's guilt or innocence. The writer argues that the charges must be proven by witness testimony regardless of the nature of the government's orders, and challenges defense counsel Martin's doctrine that Burr had a right to resist allegedly unlawful orders.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

how as to the guilt or innocence of the president; it is as to the guilt or innocence of Aaron Burr, on the charge of treason and misdemeanor, and whether the president has acted right or wrong does not and cannot affect the question of Burr's guilt or innocence. The charges against him are to be proved by witnesses on the part of the U. S. if these witnesses do not

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A legal argument is presented regarding whether a subpoena duces tecum should compel production of General Wilkinson's letter as evidence in Aaron Burr's trial. The speaker argues that even if produced, the letter would not be admissible evidence since no contradiction exists between Wilkinson's parol testimony and the letter unless the letter showed Burr's innocence.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Burr. Now in order to produce any collision between this letter and general W's parol evidence; the letter must have been an opposite character; that is, it must go

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This item is a laudatory address defending General Wilkinson against accusations by Burr's associates that he abused his power during the insurrection crisis in Louisiana. It praises his vigilance and moderation, claiming he respected citizens' rights while justly pursuing only genuine conspirators, and dismisses criticism of him as the desperate slander of the accused trying to become accusers.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 13 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

which would have produced an equally great convulsion, Gen. Wilkinson was sufficiently firm and circumspect to avoid the alternative of measures either too feeble or too severe.

In the midst of trouble and tumult, when the public calamities had reduced in some measure, the laws to silence; the persons and the property of the peaceful citizen were constantly respected. His just severity was directed against the partisans of the treason alone, and with pride we say, that he did not find one of them amongst us: not one of those, who were engaged in the alarming conspiracy, was a native of Louisiana.

See moreSee less

The accomplices of Aaron Burr have not failed to asperse the conduct of gen. Wilkinson—his vigilance was represented as a continued system of inquisi[tion]

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The Grand Jury delivered indictments against Aaron Burr and others including John Smith and Comfort Tyler, and was then discharged by the Chief Justice after praising their diligence. The court then debated a motion by Mr. Botts to improve Burr's confinement conditions, described as a small, vermin-infested room guarded by soldiers, with Mr. Wickham testifying to Burr's dignified endurance of his treatment.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 13 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

BURR'S TRIAL

The United States against Jona. Dayton, John Smith, Comfort Tyler, Israel Smith, [Da]vi[d] Floyd, — Misdemeanors. TRUE BILL.

The Chief Justice in the name of the Court, thanked the Grand Jury for their attention, attendance and perseverance, in this long and laborious investigation.

See moreSee less

They were then discharged; and the Court adjourned on the motion of Mr. Hay, until twelve.

The Court met at 12.

Mr. Botts rose to make a motion that some prison or place of confinement of a more suitable nature than the one now in use should be prepared for Col. Burr. That the prison in Richmond was a disgrace to humanity. That the place of confinement at present allotted to Col. Burr, is only a room of about 10 feet square in which a man...

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The court discusses whether it has power to designate a private room for Col. Burr's confinement instead of the jail, with the Marshal reporting the room could be secured with a guard of seven men. Burr is then formally asked to plead and responds 'not guilty,' submitting himself to trial by his country.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 13 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

promise

The Court expressed their reluctance to interfere, but thought the Executive might.

See moreSee less

Mr. Edmund Randolph. The Court are of opinion that they have the power under certain circumstances, of appointing proper places of confinement to accused persons. The Constitution and the amendments to the Constitution, authorize the court to do this. You have heard, sir, from the gentlemen who are associated with me, the situation of the jail in which Col. Burr is confined—I have been there once, and I confess whether from the ingredients that may have excited my feelings, I feel a repugnance to visit that place again.

The Court after consideration, agreed that the marshal, if he pleased, might procure a safe room for the keeping of Col. Burr.

Mr. William Marshall, the Clerk, then put the following question to Colonel Burr:

"Guilty, or not Guilty."

Col. Burr. I acknowledge myself to be the person named in that indictment, to which I [p]lead not guilty, and accordingly throw myself upon my country for trial.

Major Scott, the Marshal, then entered, and informed the Court, that he had examined the room in which Col. Burr lodged, and that in his opinion with a guard of seven men and a Deputy Marshal, he would be perfectly secure.

The Court then requested that the counsel for Col. Burr should make an affidavit as to the circumstances which they had mentioned respecting the jail.

Mr. E. Randolph read a paper, which he said, he and the associate Counsel had agreed to for that purpose.

This paper stated the same facts as those mentioned by Mr. Botts, Mr. Wickham, and Mr. Randolph.

SATURDAY, JUNE 27.

The Court decided that an attachment should not be issued against Wilkinson.

The First Monday in August was assigned for the trial of Burr. The Petit Jury to be summoned from the county where the overt act or acts were said to have been committed.

Mr. Martin moved that Burr's witnesses be bound to attend & should be compensated

MONDAY, JUNE 29.

Mr. Hay informed that the Executive of Virginia, had offered appartments in the state prison for the accommodation of Burr. It was ordered he should be confined there.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The piece lauds Commodore Truxton for his honorable conduct regarding Colonel Burr's affairs, noting his acquittal of all censure by the Grand Jury. It argues his integrity and patriotism, including his refusal to join Burr's schemes without government sanction, make him deserving of public employment.

The Enquirer · 14 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

COMMUNICATION.

COMMODORE TRUXTON.

See moreSee less

The very honorable part which has been acted by this distinguished veteran, in relation to the affairs of Col. Burr; the flattering manner in which he was acquitted of all censure, by the Grand Jury, are sufficient inducements to bring him again into public notice. But when a long life of private honor, as well public service, in all respects unsullied, are considered, Commodore Truxton, may be recommended to his country, as a worthy object for public employment.

It is true, that Commodore Truxton, is denominated a federalist, but he is neither a political sectarian, nor a factious partizan ; he has uniformly been an open, candid and honest patriot, thinking with independency, & speaking with freedom and candor. The British and French, have both felt the force of his superior talents, and in the projects of Col. Burr, when the most flattering offers were made, he answer

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This is a subscription advertisement for a published report of the trial of Col. Aaron Burr for high treason and misdemeanor, held in Richmond, Virginia, beginning May 22. It details terms of subscription, pricing, binding options, and where to subscribe.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 15 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE

TRIAL

See moreSee less

OF

Col. Aaron Burr,

For High Treason and Misdemeanor

against the United States;

Began and held in Richmond (state of

Virginia) on the 22d day of May,

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

The report covers Richmond court proceedings through June 27, including grand jury indictments for treason against Dayton, Smith, Tyler, Floyd, and others, and Burr's formal not-guilty plea. It also notes the court's refusal to hold Wilkinson in contempt, Burr's transfer to better quarters, and adjournment until August 3rd.

The Wheeling Repository · 16 July 1807 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Trial of Burr.

Our information from Richmond is up to the rising of the Court, on the 27th ult. after a session of five weeks. On Friday the 26th, the Grand Jury presented indictments for treason and a misdemeanor against Jonathan Dayton, John Smith, Comfort Tyler, Israel Smith, and Davis Floyd. The Chief Justice, in the name of the Court, then thanked the Grand Jury for their attention and perseverance in this long and laborious investigation, and they were discharged.

See moreSee less

It does not appear that the motion for admitting Burr to bail had been continued. His counsel on Friday prayed the Court to assign him other apartments than that assigned to him in jail, in consequence of its wretched situation. The Court agreed that the marshal, if he pleased, might procure a safe room to keep him in. After inspecting the rooms which Burr had occupied, the marshal informed the Court that with a guard of seven men and a deputy marshal, he would be perfectly secure in them.

Burr had informed the Court that he had been furnished with a copy of the indictment against him, and that he would plead not guilty.

It was ordered that 12 jurymen should

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The court addresses a motion to hold General Wilkinson in contempt for allegedly obstructing justice by intimidating a witness, Mr. Knox, through improper confinement and transport. Chief Justice Marshall reasons that while such conduct could be punishable, it must be clearly and intentionally shown to have affected the course of justice before contempt can be found.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 17 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

On the motion for an attachment against Gen. Wilkinson.

The motion now under consideration was heard at this time, because it was alledged to be founded on a fact which might affect the justice of the case in which the court is about to be engaged, and because while the bills were depending before the Grand Jury, the court might without impeding the progress of the business, examine into the complaint which has been made.

See moreSee less

The motion is to attach gen. Wilkinson for a contempt of this court, by obstructing the fair course of justice with regard to a prosecution depending before it. In support of this charge has been offered the testimony of Mr. Knox, who states a conversation between gen. Wilkinson and himself previous to his being served with a subpena, the object of which was to extract from him whatever information he might possess respecting the expedition which was the subject of enquiry in this court; and who states also, that he was afterwards summoned before Judge Hall, who examined him upon interrogatories, and committed him to jail, whence he was taken by order of the deputy marshal, who was a military as well as civil officer, and put on board the Revenge, in which gen. Wilkinson sailed, for the purpose of being brought from New Orleans to Richmond.

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Lawyers Wirt and Wickham argue before the court about whether General Wilkinson should be allowed to submit his own papers to the grand jury, beyond what the prosecuting attorney presents. The dispute touches on precedent from Judge Chase's trial and accusations of inconsistent or absurd legal positions.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 17 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE VIRGINIA ARGUS. TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR. [CONTINUED.]

Mr. Wirt after commenting on the opinian of Judge Gripp, said that Judge Gripp only alluded to papers not in the possession of the witnesses who might come before the grand jury, but letters or affidavits of deceased persons. He asked the Court if it would not be highly proper that General Wilkinson should have the privilege of submitting to the grand jury whatever papers that might illustrate the statement he would give.—Mr. Wirt said it appeared to him that all the papers in the possession of General Wilkinson which might throw a light upon the present transactions, would be the most proper evidence to be submitted to the grand jury.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham replied, by adverting to the former promise of the public Attorney, who seemed now willing to deviate from his promise, by drawing a distinction between the papers which he the attorney would submit, and the papers which Gen. Wilkinson might think proper to submit. That by this argument any witness might carry up improper papers; which would have the same improper effect upon the minds of the grand jury as if they had been carried up by the attorney himself. Mr. Wickham then mentioned the circumstance of a particular witness (Mr. Hay himself) who was prevented in the case of Judge Chase from refreshing his memory by the reading of particular memorandums.

Mr. Wirt asked the court if he ever stated that a narrative written by a third person would be proper evidence. He denied he ever made such a statemet.—He only alluded to original letters in the possession of General Wilkinson, which he could substantiate. He did not say what Mr. Wickham had made him say—That he did not wish absurd positions should be put into his mouth.

Mr. Wickham denied having ever put absurd positions into his mouth; but that his argument was absurd, which naturally must lead to absurd positions. He did not say what papers were in General Wilkinson's possession proper or improper. He only meant that neither Gen. Wilkinson nor any other witness;

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Court debates whether witnesses, including General Wilkinson, may use letters and notes to refresh testimony before the grand jury, with arguments over precedent from English law and prior Senate rulings. A separate dispute arises over whether Mr. Wyley must answer questions involving a partly ciphered letter that might incriminate him.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 17 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR.

regarded the transactions respecting which the witness was deposing.

Mr. Hay begged to observe to the court that General Wilkinson might not only refer to letters directed to himself from the person accused; but all such letters or papers that related to his deposition.

See moreSee less

The court was of opinion that the witness could only resort to letters or facts

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

During the treason trial, Colonel Burr moved for an attachment against General Wilkinson, John Graham, and Judge Toulmin, alleging they improperly coerced testimony and affidavits from witnesses. Debate followed among Hay, Botts, Randolph, and Martin over whether such a motion was proper at this stage of proceedings.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 17 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

After some argument on this point between Mr. Hay and Mr. Botts,

Col. Burr rose and said he would wave the discussion of the question at present about robbing of the mails, and would call the attention of the court to another point, the improper means by which testimony now in town had been procured while the case was pending, since he was bound over in his recognizance.

See moreSee less

Upon some argument that the question should come before the court in shape of a motion,

Col. Burr said he should state it in this manner: to move the court why an attachment should not issue against certain characters whom he should prove guilty of the crime he alledged.

Mr. Hay said that Colonel Burr should specify names in his motion.

Col. Burr immediately mentioned Gen. Wilkinson, John G. Jackson and Judge Toulman, as guilty of this crime.

Mr. E. Randolph rose and stated he had not been in court when this discussion began. He said he intended to have moved for an attachment against Gen. Wilkinson for compelling persons to give previous affidavits who he knew were to be witnesses, and of illegally forcing by military authority persons from N. Orleans to Norfolk.

Mr. Hay interrupted Edmund Randolph and protested against such a motion as intended solely to have an effect

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The passage records courtroom debate during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with attorneys Hay, Martin, and Randolph arguing over a motion related to allegations that General Wilkinson compelled witnesses to travel from New Orleans to Virginia. A separate item follows about a British naval officer's complaint to the Mayor regarding a local committee resolution.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 17 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

gular and improper — That this motion could only be justified in the supposition that it was a contempt of court. This charge he understood amounted to this that gen. Wilkinson had compelled certain witnesses to come from New-Orleans to Virginia. This he declared was no contempt of court and if there was an error in this conduct it was no such contempt as the court could notice. He requested the court therefore to consider the case and he was certain the motion could not be sustained. Mr. Hay said the counsel had been pleased to put words into his mouth which he never had uttered. That they had the same object in making these mistatements as in the motion they now proposed. As to the

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

Witnesses testified regarding a motion for an attachment against General Wilkinson, accused of obstructing the free course of testimony and interfering with witnesses. Edmund Randolph argued before the court that evidence showed Wilkinson had ordered the interception of letters and used improper means against witnesses, including Jacob Knox.

Herald of the United States · 18 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BURR'S TRIAL—continued.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT.

See moreSee less

RICHMOND, (V.) JUNE 23, 1807.

WITNESSES were this day examined on the motion for an attachment against General WILKINSON for endeavoring to prevent the free course of testimony. JAMES

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The grand jury delivers four indictments: true bills against Aaron Burr and Harman Blennerhassett for both high treason and misdemeanor. Burr is arraigned, argues the indictment was procured by perjury, and a debate follows over whether he should be granted bail given the capital charge.

Herald of the United States · 18 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

already had occasion to notice the rake which Gen. Wilkinson has in the issue of this business. Sir, the truth is, the names of Burr and Wilkinson are now antipodes to each other by the act of Wilkinson himself. Wilkinson is convinced he never will regain his meridian of brightness unless he can throw Mr. Burr into darkness. Like some mock God he must fall from his imaginary glories, tumbling amidst ruins and into a chaos of rubbish which he himself has occasioned. Thus, sir, we have established what General Wilkinson has done, and have established also his motives.

See moreSee less

Give me now leave to shew Sir, that all these amount to a contempt of Court." [Here Mr. R. produced his authorities.] Mr. M'Rea replied to Mr. Randolph— Mr. Batts answered the arguments of M'Rea.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The grand jury returned true bills against Aaron Burr for high treason and misdemeanor, as well as against Blennerhassett on the same charges. The court debated whether Burr could be granted bail given the gravity of a treason charge, ultimately postponing the decision and committing Burr to the custody of the jail.

Herald of the United States · 18 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

dictment against Blennerhasset for High Treason—True Bill.—Indictment against Blennerhasset for a Misdemeanor—True Bill. Mr. John Randolph then stated to the Court that although they had returned true bills on the four indictments which had been laid before them, yet they had other business to deliberate upon which might occupy them for several days.

Mr. Hay moved for the commitment of Col. Burr for high treason.

See moreSee less

Col. Burr rose and observed he should state to the court their privilege of allowing bail, as he could prove by a witness present, that the indictment was obtained by perjury.

A discussion of the power of the court with respect to Bail in cases where the punishment was death, then took place, and continued for several hours.

The court were of opinion that they were vested with the power of giving bail according to circumstances and usages of Law.

Whether the case of Col. Burr could admit of Bail, was a question postponed for consideration until next day.

Col. Burr was then committed into the [charge of the Marshal, who attended him to

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A member of the grand jury that indicted Aaron Burr responds to published attacks on his character, accusing an anonymous writer aligned with General Wilkinson of slander. He describes the grand jury's internal vote on whether to indict Wilkinson for treason or misprision of treason, noting a close division, and affirms his loyalty to the federal government despite admitting admiration for Britain.

Virginia Argus · 18 July 1807 · page 3

FROM THE RMtJLD. IN the Virginia Herald, 30th tilt. I ob serve a wanton aspersion upon my charac ter, written bv one of Gen. Wilkinson's myrmidons, under the signature of 7,Y rrrrninatory which is so mingled with scur rility ami invective, that I feci myself absolved from every motive of delicacy whatever, as respects the character of Gen. Wilkinson. How far I may have been au unworthy member of the Grand Jury, who presided upon the trial of Col. Burr, I leave to an impartial and unprejudiced public to judge ; my conduct upon that occasion gives an unequivocal contradic tion to the motive that has been ascribed I to me, of sympathy for Col. Burr ; and I

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A courtroom argument reports that the prosecution objected to giving Aaron Burr unrestricted power to demand any government papers, warning this could endanger state secrets and national safety. The speaker proposed a rule requiring Burr to show a paper's relevance to his defense before compelling its disclosure.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

edifice of the government. If Aaron Burr has the right, at his mere wish, to call one paper from the government, he has the same right to call any other; and so, one after another, might divulge and proclaim to the world, eve-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A courtroom argument debates whether Burr can subpoena a letter from General Wilkinson to the President and War Department orders, which Burr claims prove his innocence of treason and misdemeanor charges. The speaker argues the papers are irrelevant to Burr's guilt, disputes the characterization of the orders as bloody, and claims they merely authorized his apprehension and destruction of his boats if necessary.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

he says he wants a letter from gen. Wilkinson to the President; which letter contains a declaration of his guilt —and also certain orders from the department of war, which he says directed the burning and destruction of hi[s]

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A prosecutor at Burr's trial argues that orders to General Wilkinson merely authorized apprehending Burr and destroying his boats if necessary, not the "bloody" measures Burr's counsel described. He contends that even if the orders were excessive, this would reflect on the administration, not prove Burr's innocence of treason, and rejects the defense's claim that Burr acted in lawful self-defense against them.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 20 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

having been published in the Natchez Gazette; those orders are not as he has described them, they are simply orders to apprehend Aaron Burr, and if it shall become necessary for that purpose to destroy his boats. These are the bloody orders which have been so often mentioned with looks of such tragic and mysterious import? Suppose the orders was as barbarous as he has described them, and that the emergency did not justify them: they prove the administration wrong: but do they prove or tend to prove Aaron Burr innocent.

See moreSee less

If the President were on his trial, for having issued these orders, it would be necessary to hear the orders themselves, in order to ascertain their merits or demerits. But the question is not now as to the guilt or innocence of the President, it is as to the guilt or innocence of Aaron Burr, on the charges of treason and misdemeanor, and whether the President has acted right or wrong does not and cannot affect the question of Burr's guilt or innocence. The charges against him are to be proven by witnesses on behalf of the U. S. if these witnesses do not prove the charges, there is an end of the enquiry: but if they do, I ask whether it be possible that his production of the President's orders even in his own terms, will remove that evidence of his guilt? Every judgment must answer no: and if so, the orders are clearly immaterial for his defence. But altho' the affidavit does not attempt to shew, wherein these orders are material for the prisoner's defence, Mr. Martin has attempted to supply this omission by his argument. It seems these orders were so lawless that Burr had a right to resist them; and whatever he has done has been in self defence against these orders. It would be easy, sir, to ex-

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

A circulating address, signed by prominent Louisiana proprietors, thanks President Jefferson for his vigilance in exposing Aaron Burr's alleged insurrection plot before it could engulf New Orleans in violence. It is presented as a rebuttal to criticism of the administration and General Wilkinson's handling of the affair.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 21 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE BEST ANSWER

TO THOMAS JEFFERSON, President of the United States. Sir—We had already passed some years of happiness and prosperity, under the tutelary administration of the union; we had begun to fecilitate ourselves on seeing our country enjoying, under the safeguard of laws, those blessings of peace to which the rest of the world are strangers; when a handful of restless and ambitious men, such as in all times have disregarded the misfortunes of society, plotted in silence a vast insurrection, of which our unfortunate city was to be the focus.—With what painful sensations were we overwhelmed, when the dreadful conspiracy, disclosed by the emissaries of Aaron Burr themselves, was about to be executed!

See moreSee less

A little more circumspection on their part, and all was over, perhaps, forever, with Louisiana. This country, escaped, as by a miracle, from a revolutionary convulsion, was about to witness all the scenes

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Dr. Bollman recounts seeking a meeting with President Jefferson to correct false impressions of treason against Burr and to argue for war with Spain. He describes Jefferson's written promise of confidentiality and his subsequent twenty-page written statement, later used during Burr's imprisonment.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

of its fir[st ha]rd treason

These circumstances occasioned in my mind great indignation, with regard to the reports just mentioned, & great solicitude lest gen. Wilkinson's conduct and col. Burr's situation might lead to occurrences which col. Burr would deprecate, and which involuntarily would put him in the wrong.

See moreSee less

I therefore requested an interview with the president of the U. S. for two decided objects. 1. To remove from his mind the false impressions he had received with regard to treason. 2. To endeavor to convince him that the interests of the U. S. would be best consulted by going to war with Spain, and giving countenance to the expedition which col. Burr had planned.

It appeared to me, that this step

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The piece defends the executive's decision to pardon Bollman in exchange for his revelations about Burr's treason plot, arguing the process of offering and recording the pardon in open court was fair. It criticizes Burr for trying to deflect blame onto government officials who exposed and prosecuted his scheme.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

to delude.

Instead of asserting his innocence or attempting to prove it by facts or evidence, Mr. Burr has endeavored to roll back upon the government by which his treason has been frustrated, and on the public officers who have been most

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A Washington publishing firm advertises that it will soon print and sell by subscription a multi-volume report of Aaron Burr's treason trial, which began in Richmond on May 22. The notice details pricing, binding options, page counts, and local agents taking subscriptions.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 22 July 1807 · page 4

TtH TRIAL OF Col. Aaron Burr, For High Tt**ason ami Misdemeanor _j-siu9t tlie Unifi'd States ; i Began and held in Richftiond (state of j Virginia) on the '2 2d day of May, 16X7.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This opinion piece defends General Wilkinson against attacks from Burr and his associates, particularly addressing Bollman's claims in a note about Wilkinson's conduct. The author argues that Burr's expedition was treasonous from the start, citing grand jury testimony, and criticizes Bollman as an unreliable turncoat who betrays everyone.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Dr. Bollman stands precisely then in a situation similar to that of one of a number of highwaymen, seized on the road in the attempt to rob; the robbery to be sure was not perpetrated, but the Dr. turns stag, and backs out with a full (or a half full) disclosure, and for his useful discoveries as state's evidence, the executive deems him entitled to a pardon.

In this situation it is that this state's evidence comes forward as the vindicator of the man he at first betrayed, and the reviler of a magistrate to whom he owes his being at large and exemption from punishment; and thus he insults the very people against whose peace and union he had been a conspirator.

See moreSee less

These we believe to be the real merits and the true character of Bollman's conduct all round—like his principal, he belies and betrays every body—old friends and strangers, benefactors and partizans—all are alike the victims of his duplicity and wily artifices.

Under such circumstances, and against such an antagonist, so fallen in the estimation of every man of worth and real honor, it m[a]y p[er]haps be superfluous to say another word. But public information demands a f[e]w remarks, in relation to gen. Wilkinson and to the President of the U. States.

The whole course of Burr's conduct, has been since his seizure, to heap revilement and distrust on gen. Wilkinson. Bollman, in his curious note upon gen. Wilkinson's returning to New Orleans "to play the devil," (and he appears to have played the devil with Burr, Bollman and Co.) confesses the whole extent of Burr's treason; and he admits it too in a curious way, for says Bollman, Wilkinson made use of the information which Swartwout gave him of Burr's expedition to close the dispute with the Spaniards, and then very ungratefully (he infers), after preventing the Spanish war, he comes back and after having rendered both illegal and illaudible Burr's plan (by frustrating the Spanish war) he then fixes upon Burr's own project its original and true character of treason!

There is one other point in this note that merits notice. Bollman says Burr's expedition "acquired an illegal character through the inimical conduct of a weak and treacherous friend." The reader will do well to consider this sentence.

Was Burr's expedition originally or at any time legal? Did not Burr to more than ten of the witnesses who were examined by the grand jury, declare that it was not only without the knowledge or consent of the government, but that he held the government itself in contempt? But Bollman says that had not Wilkinson by a stratagem brought the Spaniards to a truce on the Sabine, Burr's project would then have succeeded.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This opinion piece scrutinizes Dr. Bollman's characterization of General Wilkinson as having acted treacherously toward Burr, questioning whether Wilkinson's actions constituted weakness or betrayal. The author argues that by frustrating a potential Spanish war, Wilkinson exposed Burr's scheme for what it truly was: treason against the United States.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Spani[a]rds to a tr[u]ce on the S[ab]ine, Burr's project would then have succeeded.

Here then we have the clue to "the inimical conduct of a weak and treacherous friend." That is, Wilkinson w[a]s so weak as to avert a Spanish war by one stratagem and to destroy a treasonable conspiracy by another; had the Spanish war been suffered to go on, Wilkinson would not have acted inimical to Burr, had he suffered Burr to come down to Orleans in force he would not have acted inimical; but says this renowned intriguer from the county of Hoya, Wilkinson by frustrating both was weak and treacherous. We shall leave the weakness to be judged by the events; let us see by whom it is and how consistently gen. Wilkinson is called treacherous. Treacherous to whom! To his country?—No! To the Spaniards?—No! To whom then? Why treacherous, (says Dr. Bollman who exposed Burr's treasons after the fact) to Aaron Burr!

See moreSee less

Was impudence and audacity ever so barefaced as is this conduct of this man Bollman? Let us suppose the very worst; that the fell spirit of deceit and treachery could inspire Burr to insinuate or assert. Let us suppose the very worst, that Wilkinson had a previous knowledge of Burr's imperial designs—of his determination to seize on New Orleans and make it the seat of his quid empire, of which the youthful fancy of Dr. Bollman was so enamored. Let us suppose even more than ever was asserted or surmised, that Wilkinson had entered into written engagements to consummate such a scheme of treason as the severation of the western and southern territory—and having arrived at the point when Swartwout reached him; that at this moment he had determined and continued resolved to conceal this plot from every one but Swartwout and Bollman, and that on arriving at New Orleans he had, like Coriolanus at the gates of Rome, repented, & instead of prosecuting the scheme of treason and severation of the national territory, compunction filled the bosom, and the love of his country triumphed over his premeditated scheme of treason; we suppose all this freely, because we know that the very reverse is the truth; but suppose this true. Why after all, Wilkinson would have had the merit of at least saving his country, and if he

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The piece argues hypothetically that even if Wilkinson had prior knowledge of Burr's treasonous schemes and concealed communications from Swartwout and Bollman, he ultimately acted nobly by thwarting the plot and preventing civil war. It criticizes Bollman's sense of honor and recounts Wilkinson's reaction upon receiving Swartwout's message, including his initial impulse to treat Bollman as a spy before deciding to consult Colonel Cushing.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FRI[D]AY, JULY 24, 180[7].

was guilty of treachery it was treachery to the most treacherous of men, to one with whom no faith ought to be kept. We do not admire Mr. Bollman's idea of honor. It is that vulg[a]r honor called honor among thieves. He cannot see any turpitude in treason, but he can discover treachery in saving a nation from division of territory, and civil war, and its concomitant horrors; Wilkinson at the very worst has acted a nobler part than the admired Coriolanus. He has frustrated not only a foreign, but a civil war.

See moreSee less

In this place, and we thank Bollman for the opportunity, we will inform the public of two important facts—and they will enable the public to determine the chastisement which this hardened conspirator merits, who has dared to speak as he has spoken of Wilkinson.

We above assumed that Wilkinson had concealed the communication made by Burr through Swartwout and Bollman from every one; it has been re[illegible]

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

A correspondent to the Aurora defends himself against character attacks made by Burr's defense counsel during the trial, regarding his earlier disclosures to the executive about the alleged conspiracy. He recounts events from New Orleans in September, including General Wilkinson's warnings of imminent war with Spain and the subsequent mysterious peaceful resolution with Spanish forces.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

To the Editor of the Aurora.

SIR,

See moreSee less

So much has been said of my disclosures to the executive, respecting the pretended conspiracy of colonel Burr, and they have recently been brought into notice by the counsel for the prosecution, against him in so extraordinary and unwarrantable a manner, that I think it incumbent on me, to make a few observations on that subject, with a view of removing erroneous impressions which otherwise might prevail with regard to my character.

A few days after my arrival at New-Orleans, in September last, letters were received in town from general Wilkinson, then on the Sabine river, stating that hostilities with the Spaniards were unavoidable, that his next letter would bring the details of the first engagement, and that he hoped to give a good account of the dons.

In consequence of this information, which occasioned considerable alarm, about 300 men were dispatched from New-Orleans, to proceed by land to the Sabine, to reinforce gen. Wilkinson. Some artillery was sent off by water to ascend the Red river for the same purpose, and two gunboats were ordered up the Mississippi, to be ready for an attack on Baton Rouge.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 25 July 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Dr. Bollman describes seeking an interview with President Jefferson to refute treason reports against Burr and to argue for war with Spain supporting Burr's expedition. He reproduces Jefferson's handwritten note requesting a written account under promise of confidentiality, and states he complied with a nearly twenty-page statement.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 24 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

his pretended treason.

These circumstances occasioned in my mind great indignation, with regard to the reports just mentioned, and great solicitude lest gen. Wilkinson's conduct, and col. Burr's situation might lead to occurrences which col. Burr would deprecate, and which involuntary would put him in the wrong

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This opinion piece condemns Dr. Bollman as a treacherous conspirator-turned-informant who betrayed Burr's secret plans only after they failed and he faced execution. The author compares Bollman to a highwayman who turns state's evidence, questioning his motives for now criticizing General Wilkinson while owing his freedom to presidential pardon.

Virginia Argus · 25 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

with the executive?

It is ridiculous to say that he had no personal motives—he may deceive himself into the supposition that others will be deceived by him, but the biter is the only one bitten! His concern in the plans—his being a principal emissary, his being taken in a situation that subjected him to be hanged as a spy—the very mercy of Wilkinson, which changed his fate from a gibbet to a transportation by sea to Washington—his situation at Washington—the mode in which he made the application to the President—the very disclosure of the secret plans of Burr, and of the foreign resources from which Burr drew his funds, and his hopes, of establishing that empire with

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 27 July 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This is a publisher's advertisement soliciting subscriptions for a printed volume of the Aaron Burr treason trial, held in Richmond starting May 23. It details pricing, binding options, and subscription agents in Washington and Georgetown.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 July 1807 · page 4

THE TRIAL OK Col. Aakon Burr, For Hi£h Trt-.'.un and Mi-idcmemnor J against the United States ; ! io and held in Richmond (state of ; rim;t) on the 23d day of May, \

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Aurora's editor criticizes Dr. Bollman for publishing a statement defending Aaron Burr, arguing Bollman owes his pardon to the government's mercy yet now seeks to discredit the prosecution. The piece frames Bollman as following Burr's pattern of casting blame on officials rather than proving innocence.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AURORA—July 17.

THE EMISSARY BOLLMAN.

See moreSee less

It appears to be one of the necessary consequences of criminality, that it should, for warning of others, and the moral good of the world, take no step but such as is calculated to betray itself.—When Bollman presented the article which we published yesterday, from the manner of his address, coupled with a declaration which he made in the hearing of the editor, in the district court of Richmond, that the communication of the treasonable projects of Burr, which he made to the executive, "should be made publick by him," we expected that such was the paper he proffered for publication.—After a perusal, however, we perceived, that the real purport of the paper offered, was only the offspring of that system which the unfortunate author of treason has pursued towards the country, the publick, the executive, the persons whom he deluded, and those whom he failed to delude.

Instead of asserting his innocence, or attempting to prove it by facts or evidence, Mr. Burr has endeavoured to roll back upon the government, by which the treason has been frustrated, and on the publick officers who have been most active in defeating his treason, and on the publick officers who have conducted the prosecution—odium, and reproach, and contumely.

"Like master, like man!" as Burr has done, so

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers

This report defends the president's pardon of Bollman, detailing how Bollman first accepted, then returned, then refused to accept or reject the pardon until it was tendered in open court. It argues Bollman voluntarily participated in Burr's treason conspiracy and only later voluntarily revealed the plot to save himself, while also referencing Wilkinson's threats against Spanish forces on the Sabine.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 27 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE EMISSARY BOLLMAN.

voluntary acts—he embarked in the treason with Burr, voluntarily—he went to New Orleans voluntarily—he opened his overtures to Wilkinson voluntarily—he was sent thence to Washington, indeed involuntarily, but without any solicitation or expectation on the part of the executive, he voluntarily proposed to reveal the plans, projects and means by which Burr was to accomplish his treason. The executive, however he must detest the traitor, was bound to hear the revelation of the treason—he condescended to let Bollman come into his presence, and to reveal at once the demonstration of his own criminal purposes, and the foreign aid which Burr was to receive, and had already received, and to which Bollman, before his departure to New-Orleans from Philadelphia, was privy and a participator. Here then we see this Bollman, who first embarks in a scheme of perfidy to the United States, of which two foreign powers were the aiders and abettors, if not the original instigators—after, but not till after he is seized and transported from the proposed theatre of his perfidy, come forward with a new act of that very species of perfidy which he in his essay of yesterday affects to reprobate.

Bollman says that a few days after his arrival at New-Orleans, in September last, advices were received from general Wilkinson, stating that he would chastise the Dons.

See moreSee less

Now the first question we would ask is, what has this to do with vindicating Bollman's character, which he professes to be the object of his essay?

What has general Wilkinson's conduct, or his threats on the Sabine, to do with Bollman's pardon, or his disclosures to the executive?

But a more important question precedes these enquiries—how and for what end came Bollman to N. Orleans? How came letters to be addressed to him in cypher, under the name of Henry Windbourne? Why, possessed of all the knowledge concerning the perfidious intentions of foreign powers against the United States, did he go to New-Orleans, endeavour to seduce the commander in chief of the army, and leave his very tender solicitudes for the U. States,

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 22 July 1807
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 25 July 1807

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This editorial piece denounces Bollman as a duplicitous turncoat who betrays all his associates, including Burr, after receiving a pardon. It also examines General Wilkinson's conduct, suggesting he exploited information from the Burr conspiracy for his own purposes while publicly condemning Burr's expedition.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 July 1807 · page 2

{.Jssf 'ilkmson would not have acted ini is is, mical to Borctr. had he fferccl Burr to come down to Orleans insight: he would H" 'r Vnctqtctbavc acted inimicaj busit says this} re— } ;zzctowzzcd inrrigucr fsem the counzv at Hoya ctWsislkinson by frusrmirg both was weak and sit'rcdtherous. We shall leave the f weakneas to be judged by the eve-cture ," lex * us aeisi5y whi-m u' is, and how congistcnc-' ly general Wilkinson 15 called treacherous. Treachcmns to thomct ? so his country? sss—"Nn. ' "so he Spaniasiyds? No ! To whom ss'ss then? Why treachersiossos l'sa ya Dr._ Bull ct fr'sinao' ss'whu e'xposgd Burr' :; treasssun ai'. cttbe

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report criticizes Erick Bollman for securing a pardon from President Jefferson in exchange for disclosures implicating Burr and others in treason, arguing Bollman acted solely from self-interested motives. It asserts the pardon's condition was that his testimony never be used against him, revealing him as having betrayed his associates to save himself.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 July 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

to be committed to writing, and on what condition? Look at the condition, it is not on the condition of saving A. Burr, or Jonathan Dayton, or James Adair, or any other principal or associate in the treason; the conditi

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

This fiery item defends Aaron Burr against newspapers and public opinion that have already condemned him for treason without evidence or trial. It accuses his accusers of moral murder for inflaming public sentiment against a man awaiting judgment, comparing their bloodthirsty toasts to the mob violence against the Princesse de Lamballe.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 31 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The 9th—"Aaron Burr, the man who once received the confidence of a free people—May his treachery to his country exalt him to the scaffold, and hemp be his escort to the republick of dust and ashes."

To any person of common sense, who possesses one sentiment of candour, one humane feeling of the heart, it would be supposed, that none but daemons from Hell could on such an occasion, have deliberately prepared and drank the preceeding toasts, unless they had the most perfect knowledge of col. Burr's guilt. And even in that case he would naturally conclude the persons to be savages or descendants of savages, who when they kill their prisoner, feast their inhuman souls with every cruelty of torture.

See moreSee less

But, gentlemen, have you any knowledge that col. Burr is guilty of treason or of any other offence? Doth either of you know of one single fact to prove upon him guilt of any kind? Why have you not come forward and informed your government? And why had I not the pleasure of seeing you as witnesses at Richmond?

I know your answer. You must confess that you have no personal knowledge of any thing criminal, that has been committed by col. Burr, but that in the Aurora, the Argus, and many other democratick papers, you have seen him charged with not only misdemeanours, but treason—Nay, you will probably say, that the President of the U. S. in his message to congress, declared his guilt to be placed beyond doubt.

And after the length of time you have lived, a length of time which have whitened some of your heads—After the different publick appointments which some of you have executed, am I now to put you in mind, that not one shillings worth of your dirty property can be taken from you, without your having an opportunity of being personally heard, nor without legal evidence delivered on oath in your presence, with liberty on your part to cross examine, and by other evidence to contradict. And yet you have to the utmost of your power, wantonly and wickedly assailed the good name, fame and reputation of col. Burr, upon no evidence! You have done what is still more wicked—you have without any evidence, assailed his life! For, are you now, for the first time, to be instructed, that whenever a person is to be tried for a charge, which is punishable with death, he who endeavours to prejudice and inflame the publick mind against him; he who does any act of a tendency to prevent the accused from having a fair trial, is, in the eye of God, guilty of as murderous an intention, as if he attempted to plunge a dagger to his heart! Equally murderous, but infinitely more cowardly—as the danger of punishment in the first case is meant to be avoided! What think you, gentlemen, of the cowardly wretch, who anxious for the blood of an enemy, but fearful of danger or of punishment, slips a stiletto into the hand of an assassin, and points to the victim! What think you of yourselves and the rest of those

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · 10 August 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A writer denounces a published toast that presumed Aaron Burr and others indicted for treason were guilty, arguing it slandered both the accused and the grand jury that merely found probable cause. The piece insists the law presumes innocence until a petit jury trial, and criticizes the toasters for prejudging the case out of partisan zeal.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 31 July 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

You have toasted the grand jury, when you knew not whether they did right or wrong; when you knew not whether the persons indicted are traitors or innocent citizens; whether the grand jury were actuated by zeal and patriotism in the cause of liberty, or by zeal and sycophancy in the cause of persecution; whether their conduct deserves a crown of immortal glory, or a noose of immortal infamy; for you have no knowledge that can enable you to decide upon the propriety or impropriety of their conduct. The toast, therefore, only stands staring you in the face, to your eternal dishonour, as a proof of your ferocity against col. Burr. Nor, gentlemen, will the grand jury thank you for the toast

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

This piece is an impassioned rebuttal to a published toast that attacked the grand jury which indicted Aaron Burr and his associates, accusing the toast's author of ferocity and dishonor. It defends the grand jurors as honorable men acting from conscience, not malice, and insists the public cannot judge the propriety of the indictment before a fair trial.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 31 July 1807 · page 1

__ J*£aad jury. when you kejMr rot>.hetbe».they did right or wrolfgi when you knew not whether die persbna indicted are traitor* or innocent citizens whether the grand jury Were actuated by zeal, and patriotum in the cause Oflibcrty^or by zeal and sycophao, « in the cause of persecution *,whether their conduct deserve* a crown of hat mortal glory, or a uoom of immortals** f*my : for yo^ have no knowledge that can enable you to decide upon the pro* prtetv or impropriety of their conduct.. The toasts, therefore, only stands ’star-, ing you in the face, to your eternal dis honor, aa a proof of your ferocity against' oblonei Burr.

See moreSee less

Nor, gentlemen, will the grand jury thank you for the toast. They were gentlemen ofhooor, of worth, of humanity ; they were not actuated by the hellish wish, that the ’persona, con* in* nor fed __M . hi an infernal pleasure. No',‘ firs, not n man of that grand jury absented to thu finding of the bills, whose heart did nog feel a pang, nor it, there bne of them whose heart will not. e^joy «qai**te pleasure should their, innoor ope, on a fair, impartial trial .before a petit jury (if, indeed, such n trial can he had, and which you hare murderously endeavored }: to prevent) be dn^.’ inanifest. Not a friend oPtne gentlemen indicted blames thc grand jury. But are you to bn in* x.';

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

An author who served as one of Aaron Burr's counsel defends his conduct against a group who toasted condemnation of him for doing so. He argues the Constitution guarantees the accused the right to counsel and a fair trial, and insists he believes Burr innocent of treason.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 31 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

I had appeared as one of col. Burr's counsel; and pray doth not the constitution most sacredly secure to him the

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

An unnamed writer defends his past friendship with Aaron Burr, accusing critics who once praised Burr themselves of now inciting mob violence against him. He states he expects to die and reflects bitterly on the hypocrisy of former political allies turned persecutors.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 31 July 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

respected friend or an indicted traitor."

Remember, gentlemen, a few years only have passed since you boasted of your friendship for col. Burr. Your tongues, at that time, moved as quickly, and with as much ease, as doth the

See the clipping