As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

August 1807

120 articles

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

An unnamed author rebukes 'gentlemen' readers for whipping up mob sentiment against him over his past friendship with Burr, now called an 'indicted traitor.' He argues that political friendships should not be judged by shifting fortunes, and expresses fear of mob violence against him despite having no personal quarrel with anyone.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 August 1807 · page 3

Mulonstrous images of defermity Which ? meet yoursssivtston. _ si'la yourtoaat yolisihave particularly no ticed me oathe * mutual and highly res i t'tetl friendes an indicted traitor.' t ct-Rcm'rtlber gentlemen a few years 0an have passed since you boasted of your ; friendshipsijfor col. Burr Your tongues-4 T

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

An anonymous writer addresses newspaper editors, denouncing their inflammatory coverage of Colonel Burr's case and accusing the press of denying him a fair, impartial trial guaranteed by the Constitution. The author warns that such persecution by the press endangers everyone and references the Selfridge case as a similar example of press misconduct.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 August 1807 · page 3

and that l feel no resentment against you. le' indig'cation hath been excited and expressed againstyour conduct, on account of colonel Burr—on account of its immedi- .

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This opinion piece condemns newspaper editors for inflaming public opinion against Aaron Burr before his trial, comparing it to the Selfridge case and accusing them of turning the Fourth of July into an "auto da fe" against him. The author warns these same printers that they too could someday face a jury already poisoned against them by public sentiment.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 August 1807 · page 3

i Such has been the conduct ofpriotct's on afar-m" ecca'eion, as to Col. Burr ; such has been the conduct of printer'a in the' case ofSelfridge; such has been the con due: of printers in the present case, as to col. Burr;-but.—you, gentlemen, have the unparalleled siguilt, which ] hope will .never be paralleled, of endeavoring to turn the lourth es ]uly into an 'auto dafe, 'on that day to burn your 'victims. " , 4 And remember, si'chtlcmch, What is col. Burr'e can now, "may be the case of any one of you hereafter, "unless you are pro.

See moreSee less

tected by yodr insignificancy, You may_ become 'obnoxidus [to individualsi'hatred ;. you may become oboo'xioctus to sieome "so? ture admioistration; you may 'be accused , of [some capit'al crime. silnteredtand influ ence, hatred and ma'lstie may inflame the public mind against you; the 'celebrator'e ; of the "fourth of July may devme'you tal the sihalter—z before : ju'ry "whose minde-"3 have been poisoned against you you lmasiv L be brought for tt'ial ; befor-eia juty that had already prejudged oysiour "cause, from the ' public papers, as you-haveprejudged the - cause" of col. Burr. Their 'fiat'is to deter mine whether you die an ignominious deathg whether your wives and" children shall suffer despair and distraction. In encha situation-yoo wzlifeelthe infamy of that conduct of whichssyuu have'boastedsi: and you will then know but? to apprcsinc thesi-t'nerits of any gentleman who shall dare ' to "advocate your cause even-for the cons'iss derat'too "of money, lsieairissug friendship out unshet;-moan, L _' THER siMsiA-Rsi F-lsiN—ssss' M .

See the clipping

In the story →

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The writer attacks Erick Bollman's credibility, suggesting his loyalty to Burr exceeded his loyalty to the United States. The piece defends President Jefferson's decision to pardon Bollman in exchange for his testimony against Burr before the grand jury.

Virginia Argus · 1 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FOR THE ARGUS. WHAT credit does Erick Bollman deserve when he declares he had no personal motives for the interview which he requested with the President of the United States? And how much stronger must be his attachment to Aaron Burr, than to the United States, when he endeavored to convince the President "that he would promote the interest of the United States by going to war with Spain, (that is, in fact, with France, Spain, Holland and Italy) and giving countenance to the expedition which Col. Burr had planned?" Is it possible that so silly a proposition as this could have been a serious object in Bollman's view, when he requested to see the President?

See moreSee less

If this, and his attempt to prove that Burr was not guilty of treason, were all that he communicated to the President, he surely would never have been presented with a pardon. But his important disclosures of Burr's plans, projects, and the means of accomplishing them, which he had not only not disclosed, but had aided in carrying into effect till he was arrested on a charge of misprision of treason by Gen. Wilkinson, certainly required a pardon, and the President was in duty bound to procure his testimony as state's evidence (called king's evidence in England) against Burr and his accomplices: and as to the promise "that his communications should never be used against himself," and "that the paper should never go out of the President's hand." The former part has been strictly and faithfully complied with, and the latter as fully observed as the nature of the case could possibly admit of. For when the President granted a pardon to Bollman, it was on condition that he would say before the grand jury and venire, on his oath, all that he had written, and was material to the conviction of Burr and his accomplices: but unfortunately he had made this promise before Burr was taken, and after seeing him, he had not the courage to keep it, and had recourse to various quibbles and subterfuges to avoid giving his testimony. Foolishly believing that if he refused the pardon, he could not be used as a witness. And when this was his idea, it surely was the President's duty to furnish the attorney with Bollman's written testimony, that he might make such use of it as the nature of the case might require. Was the President for the preservation of Bollman's small stock of honor to suffer traitors to escape even an indictment? was he to keep his word with a faithless traitor, & like him be guilty of misprision of treason, by concealing not only Bollman's, but Burr's and his accomplices' treason also? surely not.—His charge then against the President for a breach of honor in betraying his confidential communication, is the most groundless & imprudent charge that ever was brought against any one since the creation of Man!!

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

On August 3, 1807, the treason trial of Aaron Burr resumed at the Capitol in Richmond before Chief Justice John Marshall, with a large crowd in attendance. The prosecution's extensive witness list was called and recorded, including figures like Truxton, Eaton, and Wilkinson's agents.

The Enquirer · 4 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[to]l in the Hall of the House of Delegates,) for

High Treason against the United States.

See moreSee less

August 3d, 1807.

Present—John Marshall, Chief Justice

of the United States.

The court assembled at 12 o'clock.—An immense concourse of citizens attended to witness the proceedings of this important Trial.

A few minutes after, Aaron Burr entered attended by Messrs. Wickham, Martin, Botts and Baker and Mr. Alston of South Carolina.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The court addresses delays in compiling witness residence lists and discusses adjournment dates, with Burr agreeing not to object provided proceedings resume by Wednesday. The names of jurors summoned from Wood County for Burr's trial are then read into the record.

The Enquirer · 4 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

pointed out to him by the A. G. for the U. S. It was clearly impossible for him to make out those lists, before the day after to-morrow. The Chief Justice enquired then to what day it would be proper to adjourn the Court. Mr. Hay could not positively state, by what day, he should be able to prepare his lists. Mr. Burr observed, that it was not very probable, he should avail himself of any privileges

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A long list of summoned jurors from various Virginia counties is read, with most answering present except two who did not appear. Prosecutor Hay explains the venire list given to Burr was inaccurate, requiring a corrected list per federal law before trial could proceed, so the court agreed to reconvene the following Wednesday.

Virginia Argus · 5 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

answered, except Edward Carrington and Esme Smock.

Mr Hay observed that he had not yet been able to furnish Col Burr with a list of the witnesses and a statement of the places of their residence, as the law requires; & that, as many of those, who had been summoned and recognized, had failed to appear, he was not ready to prodeed with the trial immediately. He also informed the court that a list of the venire had been delivered on Saturday to Col. Burr, but had since been discovered to be inaccurate. It

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This notice advertises the availability of Volume I of the Trial of Col. Aaron Burr, priced at 75 cents, from several named booksellers in Washington. It lists the vendors carrying the publication, including J. March, A. Suter, and D. Rapine among others.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Washington, Aug. 7.

JUST PUBLISHED,

See moreSee less

(PRICE 75 CENTS.)

Vol. I. of the

Trial of Col. Aaron Burr,

To be had of J. March, and A. Suter, George Town—J. V. Thomas, Navy Yard—D. Rapine, Capitol Hill—R. C. Weightman, Pennsylvania Avenue—and Wescott and Co. 11 street, Washington City.

Aug. 7—3t.

New & Valuable BOOKS.

JUST received, and now opening, at D. RAPINE'S Book-store on Capitol Hill, a Choice and Valuable Collection of BOOKS and STATIONERY, which he will be happy to dispose of to his friends and customers on the most reasonable terms—amongst which are:

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The treason trial of Aaron Burr resumed at the Capitol in Richmond before Chief Justice John Marshall, with Burr present alongside his defense counsel and the prosecution team of Hay, Wirt, and MacRae. The proceedings began with a roll call of the numerous witnesses summoned by the United States.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 August 1807 · page 2

Treason against the United States. August 3d, 1807. Present, John Marshal, chief justice of the U. States. ' The court assembled at 12 o’clock.—An immense concourse of citizens attended to witness the pro* ceedings of this important trial. A few minutes after, .Aaron Burr entered attend ed by Messrs. Wickham, Martin, Bolts and Baker and Mr. Alston of South-Carolina, Mr. E. Randolph entered soon afterwards. Messrs. Hay, Wirt and M‘Rae attended as coun sel for the prosecution. Mr. Hay observed that he could take no steps in this business, until he had ascertained whether the witnesses summoned on the pail of the U.

See moreSee less

States were present; he therefore requested, that their names might be called over. Their names were accordingly called in the fol lowing order: "Thomas Truxlun, "Stephen Deca tur, "Benjamin Stoddert, "William Eaton, William Duune, "Erick Bollman, *Peter Taylor, "Jacob Allbright, "Charles Willie, "John Graham, "Samu el Swartwout, "Julieu Dupiestre, *P. 11. M. Pre vost, Israel Miller, "Samuel Skouten, "George Morgan, "John Morgan, *Thomas Morgan, *J\tchu las Perkins, *Robert Spence, * George Harris, "Cy rus Jones, *'l honias Peterkin, Elias Glover, Si meon Poole, "Dudley Wdodbridge, "David C. Wal

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The court addresses procedural matters including the prosecution's difficulty in compiling witness and juror address lists in time. Burr agrees to a short adjournment until Wednesday, and the jurors summoned from Wood County are named.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr observed, that it was not very probable, he should avail himself of any privileges which he might derive from any delay which had occur

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report lists the venire members present for the Burr treason trial, noting that only two of the panel were absent. It then records courtroom exchanges regarding Burr's request for a subpoena duces tecum to obtain papers, including a letter and a communication from General Eaton to the President.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

as soon as possible, a correct copy of this list to oppo[s]ite counsel.

Mr. Peyton Randolph enquired whether this was a proper opportunity for any man on that pannel, to state his objections to the service.

See moreSee less

The Chief Justice replied, that it would be better to wave any objections, until the jury were about to be impannelled.

The deputy marshal was then about to adjourn the court, when Mr. Burr recalled to the recollection of the court the motion which he had made on a former occasion for a subpæna duces tecum, addressed to the president of the United States. That motion had been partly complied with. He wished to know of the court whether it was not a matter of right for him to obtain a subpæna duces tecum—if it was not he should then lay a specifick motion before the court.

The Chief Justice did not believe it to be the prac_

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Lawyers Hay and Wickham discuss with Chief Justice Marshall how to structure the proceedings, debating whether to follow Virginia practice or the English model. Marshall proposes a sequence: prosecution presents its case and evidence, then defense responds, followed by closing arguments from both sides.

The Enquirer · 7 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

when the jury shall have been impannelled. We should have time to deliberate on it, as well as to consult our client, in a case which may so materially concern him. (Mr. Burr was not this day in court.)

Mr. Hay. This is not a case, Sir, in which the consent of council is at all necessary; for to the court belongs the sole privilege of prescribing the order of proceeding. But permit me to observe, that if this arrangement is postponed until Friday, we may not then be prepared immediately to pursue that course, which the court may prescribe. It is therefore, that I wish the court to make an immediate decision.

See moreSee less

C. Justice. The court is unwilling to dictate any particular course; for although I have read some books of practice, my opinion on this point is not finally made up. Perhaps the best system is pursued in G. Britain, unless indeed

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Lawyers and the Chief Justice discuss whether to follow the English or Virginia method of presenting cases and evidence, given the complexity and scale of Burr's trial. The Chief Justice proposes a hybrid approach to streamline proceedings, deferring final decision to allow counsel to consult.

Virginia Argus · 8 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

or for the commonwealth, states the case on the part of the prosecution, and the counsel for the accused also makes a statement on his part : after which the evidence is gone through on both sides, beginning with the witnesses against the prisoner. This being done, the counsel for the prosecution commences the argument, is answered by the counsel for the prisoner ; and then concludes the debate. Mr. Hay observed that this mode was much more tedious than that which prevails in Great Britain ; and therefore ought, particularly, to be avoided in conducting the trial of Aaron Burr, in which the number of attornies employed & of witnesses to be examined, is so great ; especially, as other trials equally tedious are about to take place ; Herman Blannerhassett being now in custody, and Jonathan Dayton known to be in this neighborhood.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham wished time to consider the subject ; not being prepared to determine whether the counsel for Col. Burr

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Chief Justice affirmed that the court's order for guard payments was legal, but noted the Secretary of the Treasury might refuse to honor the Marshal's expense claims, leading Burr to offer indemnification. The report also notes Blennerhassett's arrival at the Richmond Penitentiary after being apprehended in Kentucky, and mentions William Lewis possibly joining Burr's defense team.

Virginia Argus · 8 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

some arrangement could be made by Col. Burr and his counsel for the indemnification of the Marshal.

Col. Burr declared that an offer had already been made on his part to indemnify the Marshal; and that he was still ready and willing to give him satisfactory security, that the money should be paid him, in case the Secretary of the Treasury should refuse to allow the credit.

See moreSee less

After some desultory conversation, nothing positive was agreed upon; but it appeared to be understood that security was to be given to Maj. Scott; and that Col. Burr was to remain in his apartment near the Swan Tavern.

See the clipping

In the story →

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

John Caller, a justice of the peace and militia colonel, gives a sworn deposition before Harry Toulmin describing events the day after Burr's arrest near Fort Stoddert. The deposition recounts conversations revealing Burr's alleged plan to seize Baton Rouge, then Mobile, Pensacola, and Augustine, forming a republic, with General Wilkinson originally complicit before turning on Burr.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Baltimore, Aug. 3.

COPY.

See moreSee less

The deposition of John Callier, Esq. a justice of the peace, and colonel of the militia in the county of Washington and Mississippi Territory, taken before Harry Toulmin, one of the judges of the said Territory, at Washington, in the said county. The day after col. Burr was arrested, near Fort Stoddert, Mr. Robert Ashley, who had come to the Tombigbee settlement with colonel Burr, came to my house, accompanied by Mr. Thomas Malone:—I had been just before apprized by a note from Mr. Malone, sent to me at my quarter, that Mr. Burr was come to this country, and was arrested; that Ashley was at my house; but that he knew nothing of the arrest of Col. Burr. On my reaching the house I found that Mr. Ashley was gone to bed; and Mr. Malone acquainted me more fully with the circumstances, but informed me that he could get no disclosure from him of their intention. I mentioned to him that I had known Mr. Ashley several years ago, and that as I was satisfied that his object in coming to see me, was to prevail on me to join in their plans, I should have no difficulty in finding out what they were. The next morning I enquired after Mr. Ashley, about the news, and particularly with respect to col. Burr; and was then informed by him that col. Burr was in this country. After breakfast we rode together to Wakefield; he then informed me that he was in the plans of col. Burr; that he had come to see me, to ascertain if I would join him in the plan; I told him that if it was nothing against government, nor touching on the strings of government, I would do every thing that should tend to relieve us from our oppression. He told me that it was not col. Burr's plan to touch on the strings of government; that gen. Wilkinson had deceived him; that they were to have met at such a time at Baton Rouge; that Burr was to be the first in command; general Wilkinson to be second; that he was to have joined him (Burr) with the fe[d]eral army; that the soldiers were to have double pay, and that s[o]me of the officers of the army, but very few of them, were in the plan; that some small censure having taken place with respect to gen. Wilkinson, was the reason that he had shifted his coat, and made all that great bustle; that the object of the plan was to take Baton Rouge in the first place, and from thence to proceed to Mobile, Pensacola and Augustine; reduce the posts there, and form a republican government; that he had already prepared the laws: that they were so simple and excellent that they would suit from a ten year old boy to an old man; and that like the laws of the Medes and Persians, they would be unalterable; that the people of the U. S. from the Alleghany westward, and down to the sea, would be invited to come into the new republic; and that the ports of this republic would be opened free to all the world; that he had got in with England, so that she would furnish a fleet of 12 sail, which would join him as soon as he had got possession of the Floridas, and be commanded by captain Truxton; that as soon as he had got the country out of the power of Spain, a negociation was to be opened with England, and England was to acknowledge their independence; that after he had done this, he was to go to Mexico, where the co-operation of the Spanish officers had been secured, who were tired of their own government, and ripe for a revolution; that the Spanish minister Yrujo; and that the Spanish officers in Florida, were likewise concerned; and that Mr. Burr had frequent long conversations with Yrujo upon the subject; that general Wilkinson had so much disappointed him, that he had turned his attention entirely to this quarter; that we were so much oppressed by the Spaniards, and so utterly neglected by our own government, that he knew we must be disposed to vindicate our own rights by an attack on the Spanish possessions; and tha[t] if I and major Hanson, and major Buford, would join in supporting him, that he, (Ashley) would immediately set off and procure seventeen hundred men, and march them into this country, where they would be met by col. Burr, who was then on his way to the Federal City, but would return without delay; that the 1700 men were actually engaged and ready to start when called upon—but were scattered in diff[e]rent settlements from the Natchez upwards, and that twelve thousand more were ready engaged. On reaching Wakefield, I arrested the said Ashley, believing that I had got every thing out of him that I could. He continued in custody three or four days, and then escaped. JNO. CALLIER. Sworn to and subscribed the 9th of May, 1807. HARRY TOULMIN.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report describes the continuation of Aaron Burr's treason trial before Chief Justice Marshall on August 3, 1807, noting the large crowd present and Burr's arrival with his counsel. Prosecutor Hay requests that government witnesses be called, and a long list of summoned individuals is read into the record.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

AUGUST 3d, 1807. Present—JOHN MARSHALL, Chief Justice of the U. S. The court assembled at 12 o'clock.—An immense concourse of citizens attended to witness the proceedings of this important trial. A few minutes after A. Burr entered attended by Messrs. Wickham, Martin, Botts and Baker, and Mr. Alston of South Carolina. Mr. E. Randolph entered soon afterwards.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The report records courtroom proceedings in the U.S. Circuit Court trial of Aaron Burr, including discussion of adjournment and the calling of the list of summoned jurors. It lists the names of jurors from Wood County and the grand jury venire for the District of Virginia, noting which were present or absent.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

District of Virginia. JOSEPH SCOTT, Marshal.

List of Petit Jurors for May Circuit Term, 1807—Continued.

See moreSee less

Names of the jurors summoned from the body of the District of Virginia, for the trial of Col. A. Burr.

John Horace Upshaw, Essex. Wm. Pope, Powhatan. Peyton Randolph, Richmond City. John Bowe, Hanover. John Roberts, Culpepper. Joshua Chaffin, Amelia. Jarvis Storrs, Henrico. Miles Selden, do. Lewis Truehart, Hanover. Wm. Yancey, Pittsylvania. Thomas Prosser, Henrico. John Staples, Albemarle. Edward C. S[illegible]

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 4 August 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 7 August 1807

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The piece angrily condemns a group who toasted the grand jury's indictment of Burr as if it proved guilt, arguing the law presumes innocence until a petit jury trial. It defends the grand jurors' integrity while insisting the public should await a fair trial before judging Burr.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

colonel Burr. Nor, gentlemen, will the grand jury thank you for toast. They were gentlemen of honour of worth, of humanity; they were not actuated by the hellish wish,

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A speaker defends having served as counsel for Aaron Burr, arguing the Constitution guarantees the accused the right to counsel regardless of public clamor for conviction. He insists Burr is innocent and that offering legal defense from friendship is no less honorable than doing so for a fee.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

col. Burr to be as innocent of any thing treasonable, in act or intent, as the infant unborn; and that I believe the executive of the United States is, at this time, of the same opinion—And for the truth of this asseveration, I appeal to my God. And I further, answer, that if col. Burr was as guilty

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The writer rebukes critics who condemn him for being a friend of Aaron Burr, now on trial for treason, accusing them of hypocrisy since many once praised Burr themselves. He argues that true friendship should not depend on a person's power or misfortune, unlike the fickle loyalty of his accusers.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

In your toast you have particularly noticed me as "the mutual and highly-respected friend of an indicted traitor." Remember gentlemen, a few years only have passed since you boasted of your friendship for col. Burr. Your tongues at

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

Luther Martin, Burr's defense counsel, excoriates newspaper editors for inflaming public opinion against Burr and denying him a fair trial, likening their conduct to earlier persecutions. He warns the editors that such mob-driven justice could one day turn against them.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the shield of innocence, and, even, as to guilt, an angel of mercy—to make that press the dæmon of envy, hatred and revenge—the Moloch of persecution, whenever personal or political enemies were to be hunted down: a practice not only the dishonor and disgrace of the country, but under which no man can be safe; such has been the conduct of printers on a former occasion as to Colonel Burr; such has been the conduct of printers in the case of Selfridge; such has been the conduct of printers in the present case as to Colonel Burr; but you, gentlemen, have the unparalleled guilt, which I hope never will be paralleled, of endeavoring to turn the fourth of July into an auto de fe; on that day to burn your victims.

See moreSee less

And, remember, gentlemen, what is col. Burr's case now, may be the case of any one of you hereafter, unless you are protected by your insignificancy. You may become obnoxious to individual hatred; you may become obnoxious to some future administration; you may be accused of some capital crime. Interest and influence, hatred and malice, may inflame the public mind against you; the celebrators of the 4th of July may devote you to the halter, before a jury whose minds have been poisoned against you; you may be brought for trial before a jury that has already prejudged your cause, from the public papers, as you have prejudged the cause of col. Burr. Their fiat is to determine whether you die an ignominious death: whether your wives and children shall suffer despair and distraction. In such a situation you will feel the infamy of that conduct, of which you have boasted: and you will then know how to appreciate the merits of any gentleman who shall dare to advocate your cause even for the consideration of money, leaving friendship out of the question. LUTHER MARTIN.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

This editorial praises a published letter (Mr. Martin's) for arguing that courts and juries must be free from public pressure and mob influence when trying Aaron Burr. It insists that if Burr is guilty of treason he should be convicted through due process, but warns against private citizens trying to dictate verdicts.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 3

MR. MARTIN'S LETTER

well annihilate all forms of law ; proceed 'tear in pieces the man who has the mis fortune to be suspected ; and set afresh in tins country all the enormities of the won.* oeriod of the French revolution.” Our itate Constitutions declare that whenever any o.K-19 called upon to answer to an\ harp affecting1 either his life property or reputation, he shall b* entitled to as fail and irnpai tial a.iml as the lot of humanitt will a..ui;t. It col. Burr has committed treason, it is td Le hoped, for the safety ol the a in try, that lie will be convicted and punished iti such a manner as law and jus lice r« .quire.

See moreSee less

No country in the world c «n boast ! l aving so enlightened and upright juc.ge." as this ; jet there are individuals among us Who aVe wicked enough to seize every opportunity to excite among the peo p«c a spr.it of jealousy and enmity towards tliis brunch ol ti:e govcrmncnt. Let such churar • r: lie marked as the common ene mies Oi coilized societv.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Herman Blennerhassett was apprehended in Lexington, Kentucky after a witness summoned to Burr's trial informed Judge Todd, leading to a warrant for his arrest. He was brought to Richmond and committed to the penitentiary under a capias for treason.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 10 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HERMAN BLANNERHASSETT. This person is in confinement, in the penitentiary in this city—he was apprehended at Lexington in Kentucky: and the following facts are communicated. Mr. D. Meade of that state, was summoned to the trial of col. Burr as a witness. He was in this city, when the Grand Jury found an indictment against Mr. B.—He returned to Kentucky, and there found Mr. Blannerhasset.—Mr. Meade gave information to judge Todd, who issued a warrant upon Mr. Meade's affidavit.—Mr. Meade was then appointed Deputy Marshal of the state, and conducted Mr. Blannerhassett to this place under a guard.—They arrived in this city on Tuesday last, and B. was immediately conveyed to the penitentiary by the Marshal of Virginia, under a capias for Treason. Richmond Enquirer.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A court session addresses a witness's absence due to illness, postpones trial proceedings to the following Monday, and discharges jurors not present. The Chief Justice also rules on a dispute over the marshal's compensation for safekeeping the prisoner (Burr), affirming the legality of payments while noting the Treasury Secretary might refuse to honor them, with Burr offering to indemnify the marshal against that risk.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

In the course of this day, a difficulty was suggested by maj. Scott, the marshal of the Virginia district, as arising out of the order of the court, by virtue of which col. Burr had been removed from the penitentiary

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This report discusses the British impressment controversy involving claims of American citizenship for sailors taken from the Chesapeake, with papers debating whether government justifications will be substantiated. It also briefly notes that Aaron Burr's trial for treason commenced in Richmond on August 3rd, with Blennerhassett arrested and transported there, and Jonathan Dayton present, while other indicted persons had not yet appeared.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 11 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

On Monday the 3d inst. the trial of Aaron Burr commenced at Richmond. Most sincerely do we hope that the day is at length arrived when what was done in secret, shall be proclaimed on the house top.

Blannerhasset was arrested at Lexington, (Ken.) the 14th of July, and delivered into the custody of the Marshal of the district, to be by him safely conveyed to the city of Richmond

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report records courtroom testimony from prospective jurors during Aaron Burr's treason trial, as attorneys question them about prior opinions on Burr's guilt formed from newspapers and rumors. Several jurors are dismissed after admitting they had already concluded Burr was guilty or deserved hanging based on hearsay and press reports.

The Enquirer · 11 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Laidley put aside.

3. James Hamilton being challenged for cause and sworn, stated that he had formed and expressed an opinion from hearsay, that Col. B. was guilty of treason, and in that particular line of treason, in which Col. B. stood charged, as far as he understood. Put aside.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr observed, that as gentlemen on the part of the prosecution had expressed a willingness to have an impartial jury, they could not refuse that any juryman should state all his objections to himself; and that he had no doubt, in spite of the contrary assertions which had been made, that they could get a jury from this pannel.

4. Hamilton Morrison upon being cal'ed, said, that he had fr[e]quently thought and declared,

See the clipping

In the story →

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The passage records the voir dire examination of potential jurors in Aaron Burr's treason trial, detailing their prior statements and opinions about Burr's guilt formed from newspapers and other sources. Several jurors are set aside for cause due to expressed prejudicial opinions, while attorneys Burr and Hay argue over the standard for impartiality.

The Enquirer · 11 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR,

(continued by adjournment and held at the Capitol in the Hall of the House of Delegates,) for High Treason against the United States.

See moreSee less

FRIDAY, August 7.

The following new witnesses appeared this day: Lieut. Swaringen, William McFarlane and Lewis Kerr.

Mr. Hay observed, that he had nothing more to submit to the court; and that he hoped all the material witnesses would be present on Monday, and enable him to prosecute the Trial.

MONDAY, August 10.

HERMAN BLANNERHASSET was this day brought into Court.

The following gentlemen appeared and were recognized: Return I. Meigs, Maurice P. Belnap, Charles Duvall, James Taylor, Tunis Dits, Bennett Cook, Hezekiah Lewis, and G. B. Vanhorne.

Mr. Wirt moved the Court to discharge Dr. Wardlaw, one of the Venire. His wife was in extreme danger, and required the assistance for a sea-voyage. The vessel would sail to-morrow. C. Justice.—Is the Court to understand that there is no objection to this measure?—Mr. Burr.—If the remark be addressed to me, Sir, I can only say, that I shall remain passive during the transaction.—Dr. Wardlaw was then dismissed.

Mr. McRae also moved the discharge of Mr. Randolph Harrison, whose extreme indisposition was attested by a certificate from Dr. Adams.

Mr. H. was accordingly dismissed in the same manner.

Mr. Hay moved that H. Blannerhasset be arraigned for high treason: which Mr. Botts opposed on the ground that he had not been furnished with a copy of the indictment for three days. After some desultory conversation on this circumstance, Mr. Botts requested that Mr. B. might be re-conducted to the Penitentiary, as he was extremely indisposed, and the heat nearly overpowered him. No opposition was made, and Mr. B was accordingly re-conducted to his prison.

At Mr. Hay's request, the pannel of the Jury was called over by the Deputy-Marshall, and also, at Mr. Burr's request, the list of the Witnesses, whom he had subpoenaed for the purpose of investigating the qualification of some of the Venire.

Mr. Hay read a certificate from Dr. Upshaw, stating that Mr. James Henderson is sick of a bilious fever and incapable of attending.

Mr. McRae then read a certificate from Dr. Greenhow, shewing that David Bullock, Esq. one of the Venira was prevented by indisposition from discharging his duties. Mr. B. was accordingly excused.

The Clerk informed Mr. Burr, that he was at liberty to challenge such of the Venire as he might object to. Mr. Burr begged leave to inform the jurors, who were within hearing, that a great number of them may have formed and expressed opinions about him, which might disqualify them from serving on this occasion: He expected that as they came up, they would discharge the duties of conscientious men, and candidly state all these objections.—The Deputy Marshall then summoned

1. Hezekiah Bucky.—Mr. Botts. We challenge you for cause. Have you ever formed and expressed an opinion about the guilt of Col Burr? Mr. Bucky. I have not, Sir, since I have been subpoenaed.—Q. Had you before? A. I had formed one before in my own mind.

Mr. Hay wished that the question of the opposite counsel could assume a more precise and definite form. If this question were proposed to this pannel and to every other man, he would venture to predict, that there could not be a jury selected in the state of Virginia; because he did not believe that there was a single man in the state, qualified to become a juryman, who had not in some form or other, made up and declared an opinion on the conduct of the prisoner. The transactions in the west had excited universal curiosity; and there was no man who had not seen and decided on the documents relative to them. Do gentlemen contend, that in a case so peculiarly interesting to all, the mere declaration of an opinion is sufficient to disqualify a juryman? A doctrine of this sort would at once acquit the prisoner; for where is the jury that could try him? Such a doctrine amounts to this: that a man need only do enough to draw down the public attention upon him and he would immediately effect his discharge. Mr. H. concluded with a hope, that the question would assume a more definitive form; he should not pretend to decide the form on which it should be proposed; but it was a privilege to which every court is entitled, and one which the court had exercised, that had presided in the case of James F. Callender.

Mr. Botts considered it as a misfortune ever to be deplored, that in this country and in this case, there had been too general an expression of the public sentiment, and that this generality of opinion would disqualify many; but he had never entertained a doubt, until the prosecution had avowed it, that twelve men might be found in Virginia, capable of deciding this question, with the strictest impartiality. He still trusted that the Attorney for the United States was mistaken; that the catastrophe was not completely fixed; and that every man in the state had not pledged himself to convict Col. B. whether right or wrong. He was not present at the trial of J. T. Callender; but all America had heard the question which was then propounded to the jurymen; and that was: whether he had made up and expressed an opinion respecting the guilt of the prisoner.

Mr. Hay would put Mr. Botts right in a matter of fact. The court would recollect that on the trial of Callender, the question was not whether the jurymen had found and expressed an opinion on that case generally; but on the subject matter that was to be tried, and couched in the Indictment. The question then in the present case should be: Have you formed and expressed an opinion on the point at issue, that is, whether A. B. is guilty of treason? On the trial of Calendar, the court would particularly recollect, that Mr. John Bassett having objected to himself, because he had read the libellous publication, was actually overruled, because it was not on the book itself, but on the subject matter of the Indictment, that he was called upon to say, whether he had ever expressed an opinion.

Mr. Burr declared there was a material distinction between that and the present case. Mr. Bassett's acknowledging that he had seen the book did not disqualify him from serving on the jury; in the same manner the person who had seen a murder would not be an incompetent juror in the prosecution for that crime. But if a man's pretended to decide upon the guilt of a prisoner upon mere rumour, he would manifest such a levity and bias of mind, as would effectually disqualify him. Mr. Bucky however has not yet come out completely with his declarations. Let him be further interrogated.

Mr Hay observed, that the question would even be too general and vague, if it were ever to be—"have you expressed any opinion, on the treason of A. B." for the case stated in the indictment was infinitely more specific. It was treason in levying war against the U.S. at Blannerhassett's Island. Unless this particular allegation be proved, it defeats all the other parts of the accusation; & it was probably on this point that the juror had never made up any opinion.

Mr. Martin contended that it was the province of every juryman to come to any case with the most perfect impartiality; and more particularly in one, where life and reputation were at stake: that it was a libel upon Virginia, a blot upon the whole state, to assert that 12 men could not be found to decide such a case, with no other knowledge than what they had picked up from newspapers; that there was a material distinction between this and Callender's case; the libel was a book in every man's hand; but does any juryman in the present case pretend to know the testimony on which this charge depends? The gentleman proposes to ask the juryman, whether he has made up an opinion on Col. B's treason: but it is extremely probable, that most of them know not what treason is; and though they may decide upon the guilt of Col. B. that they may be ignorant, whether it comes under the name and description of treason.

Mr. Botts quoted authorities in support of his opinion: 3 Bacon 358; a case from Hawkin's; the cases of Smith & Ogden; and Judge Iredell's opinion in the case of Fries.

The Chief Justice observed, that it might save some altercation, if the court was to deliver its opinions at the present time; that it was certainly one of the clearest principles of natural justice that a juryman should come to a trial for life with a perfect freedom from previous impressions; that it was clearly the duty of the court to obtain such men, if it were possible to produce them free from such bias; but that if it were not possible from the very circumstances of the case; if rumours had reached and pre-possessed their judgments, still the court was bound to obtain as large a portion of impartiality as possible; that this was not more a principle of natural justice, than a maxim of the common law, which we have inherited from our forefathers; that the same right was secured by the constitution of the United States, which entitles every man under a criminal prosecution to a fair trial by "an impartial jury." Can it be said however, that any man is an impartial juryman, who has declared the prisoner to be guilty and to have deserved punishment? If it be said, that he has made up this opinion, but has not heard the testimony; such an excuse only makes the case worse; for if the man has decided upon insufficient testimony, it manifests a bias that completely disqualifies himself from the functions of a juryman. It is too general a question to ask whether he has any impressions about Col. B. The impressions may be so light, that they do not amount to an opinion of guilt; nor do they go to the extent of believing, that the prisoner deserves capital punishment. With respect to Mr. Bassett's opinion, it was true he had read "the Prospect before us;" and he had declared that it was a libel; but Mr. B. had formed no opinion about J. T. Callender's being the author. It was the same principle in the present case. If a juryman was to declare that the attempt to achieve the dismemberment of the union was treason, it would be no complete disqualification; but it would be the application of that crime to a particular individual—it would be the fixing it on A. B. that would disable him from serving in his case. Let the counsel then proceed with the enquiry.

Mr. Botts. Have you said that Col. B. was guilty of treason? Mr. Bucky. No. I only declared that the man who acted as Col. B. was said to have done, deserved to be hung.—Q. Did you believe, that Col. B. was that man? A. I did, from what I had heard.

Mr. Hay. I understand then, that the question proposed in Callender's case is to be overruled? C. Justice. My brother judge does not recollect whether it particularly went to the indictment. Judge Griffin. I think the question was, "related to the matter in issue." Mr. Hay. The very position that I have laid down. C. Justice. The simple question is whether the having formed an opinion not upon the evidence in Court, but upon common rumour, a man is competent to decide upon the real testimony of the case. But in my opinion this very circumstance only disqualifies him the more. Mr. Wirt (addressing Mr. Buckey.) Did I understand you to say that you concluded upon certain rumors you may have heard, that Col. B. deserved to be hung? A. I did. Q. Did you believe these rumours? A. I did. Q. Would you, if you were a juryman, form your opinion upon such rumors? A. Certainly not.—Mr. McRae. Did you form and express your opinion upon the question, whether an overt act of treason had been committed at Blannerhassett's island? A. It was upon other rumours; and not upon that, that I had formed an opinion.—Mr. Martin submitted it to the court, whether he could be considered as an impartial juryman. The court decided that Mr. Bucky be put aside.

2. James G. Laidley stated, that he had formed and expressed some opinions unfavorable to Col. B. that he could not pretend to decide upon the charges in the indictment, which he had not heard; that he had principally taken his opinions from news paper statements; and that he had not, as far as he recollected, expressed an opinion, that Col. B. deserved hanging.—Mr. Laidley put aside.

3. James Hamilton being challenged for cause and sworn, stated that he had formed and expressed an opinion from hearsay, that Col. B. was guilty of treason, and in that particular line of treason, in which Col. B. stood charged, as far as he understood. Put aside.

Mr. Burr observed, that as gentlemen on the part of the prosecution had expressed a willingness to have an impartial jury, they could not refuse that any juryman should state all his objections to himself; and that he had no doubt, in spite of the contrary assertions which had been made, that they could get a jury from this pannel.

4. Hamilton Morrison upon being called, said, that he had frequently thought and declared, that Col. B. was guilty, if the statements which he had heard were true; that he did not know whether they were so; but only thought from the great clamour which had been made, that it might be possible they were true; that he had not passed any positive opinion; nor was he certain that he had always qualified it by saying "if these things were true; that he does not recollect to have said that Col. B. ought to be punished, without stating at the same time, "if he was guilty."—Mr. Morrison was put aside for further examination.

5. Yates T. Conwell had formed and expressed an opinion, from the reports he had heard that Col. B. must be guilty of High Treason. Set aside.

6. Jacob Beeson declared, that he for some time past had formed an opinion, as well from newspaper publications as from the boats which had been built on the Ohio, that Col. B. was guilty; and that he himself had borne arms to suppress this insurrection. Set aside.

7. William Prince declared he had nearly the same impressions as Mr. Beeson: that he too had borne arms; as well on Blannerhassett's island as on descending the river in search of Blannerhassett. Set aside.

8. Nimrod Saunders declared that he had expressed an opinion, previously to his being summoned on the jury, that the prisoner had been guilty of treason. Set aside.

9. Thomas Creel had no declaration to make, and was challenged for cause. Upon being interrogated, he stated that he had never asserted that the prisoner ought to be punished, that he had said that he was a sensible man, and if there was any hole left, he would creep out of it, that he had conceived that Col. Burr had seduced Blannerhassett into some acts that were not right; that he had never positively said that Col. Burr was guilty; that he had said that Blannerhassett was the most blamable, because he was well in life, whereas Col. Burr was a desperate man, who had little to lose; that he had never said that Col. Burr had directly led Blannerhassett directly into guilt, but only through the medium of Mr. Blannerhasset; and that there was no determinate impression on my mind respecting the guilt of the prisoner.

The Chief Justice did not think that this was sufficient to let him aside, and suspended his case for further examination.

10. Anthony Buckner had frequently said, that the prisoner deserved to be hung. Set aside.

11. David Creel had formed an opinion from the statements in the newspapers, and if these were true, the prisoner was certainly guilty: He had expressed a belief that he was guilty of the charges now brought against him, and that he ought to be hung. Set aside.

Jurors from the body of the district.

1. John Horace Upshaw declared, that he conceived himself to stand there as an unprejudiced juryman; that he had formed opinions hostile to the prisoner; if opinions they can be called, which are formed from mere newspaper testimony. Mr. Burr. We challenge Mr. Upshaw for cause.

Mr. Hay. Then, sir, I most seriously apprehend that we shall have no jury at all. I solemnly believe, that Mr. U. is an impartial juryman; and I will venture to assert (whatever credit my friends on the other side will allow to my assertion) that I myself could do justice to the accused; I believe that any man can, who is blessed with a sound judgment and integrity. We might as well enter at once a Nole Prosequi.

Mr. Wickham. Then according to the gentleman's doctrine, any honest man, no matter what his impressions may be, is a competent juryman. Is this agreeable to the principles of law? Does the gentleman mean to insinuate, that when we object to a juryman, it is from his want of honesty. No, sir. Every man is subject to partialities and aversions; which may unconsciously sway his judgment. Mr. Upshaw does no doubt deem himself an impartial juryman: but Mr. U. may be deceived.

After some desultory argument between Messrs. Hay and Wickham, Mr. Wirt proceeded to ask Mr. Upshaw, whether he had understood him to say that notwithstanding the hostile impressions he had taken up from news-paper reports, these impressions had not received that determinate character which might entitle them to the name of opinions? A. Such is my state of mind. I have received impressions hostile to Col. Burr and have expressed them with some warmth. Mr. Upshaw stated that his impressions had been drawn from the documents furnished by Gens. Eaton and Wilkinson; that he had conceived that the prisoner had been guilty of some criminal act against the public; and that he had gone on further to vindicate the conduct of those gentlemen who would appear as the principal witnesses against him, & also of the government in the measures which it had taken to suppress his plans.—Mr. Upshaw's case was suspended for subsequent examination.

2. William Pope declared, that his impressions were nearly the same with those of the gentleman, who had preceded him; that he had thought at first from newspaper representations that it was Col. B's intention to make his fortune in the west by the settlement of lands; that when he had afterwards understood that he had formed an union with Wilkinson to proceed to Mexico, he had regarded the prisoner's conduct with a venal eye; but when he had afterwards understood that there was treason mixed with his projects, it was impossible for him to view his conduct without the deepest indignation: If these impressions could be called prejudices, he trusted that he should always retain them; because what other sentiments could he feel against such a crime perpetrated against the very best government on the surface of the earth. But from his heart he believed, that he could divest himself of these unfavorable impressions, and give Col. B. a fair and honourable trial. He would add that in pursuance of the spirit manifested by them, the constitution, which required two witnesses to an overt act of treason; he should think it necessary to require that the evidence for the United States, should be so strong as to make the scales preponderate. Mr. Wickham. You will not misunderstand me, Mr. Pope, when I ask you whether you have not been a candidate for your county, and are now a delegate? A. Yes. Q. In canvassing among the people, have you not declared that the government had acted properly in commencing this prosecution? A. Yes. I believe I have said generally, that I thought col. B. guilty of high treason—Set aside.

3. Peyton Randolph declared, that it had never been his wish or intention to shrink from the discharge of a public duty; but that he had peculiar objections to serving on this occasion; one of which only, he should state. He had been enrolled and was qualified as a lawyer in this court: and he would submit it to the court, whether this did not exempt, nay even disqualify him from serving.——C. J. admitted Mr. R's privilege, unless there was an express interposition on the part of the prisoner to retain some of the Venire: for this would call a conflicting privilege into operation.—Mr. Burr said, that he should be passive.—Set aside.

4. John Bowe did not recollect to have said that the prisoner was guilty of treason; but of something hostile to the peace and happiness of the U. S. Upon being interrogated he observed, that he was a Delegate from the county of Hanover; that there had been a competition at the last election; that he had had occasion to speak at that time, of the views of the prisoner, but had always done it cautiously; had never asserted that he ought to be hung, but that he was guilty of something unfriendly to the peace of the U.S.—Mr. Wickham. You have said that the prisoner was guilty? A. Yes. C. Justice. Did you ever make up an opinion about his levying troops and making war against the U. S. A. Yes: but I have never expressed it. Mr. Burr. Take the whole together, and it amounts to an opinion of treason. Mr. Bowe has said that Col. B. was guilty; and of what? of that which in Mr. Bowe's mind amounts to the disposition of treason.—Set aside.

5. John Roberts had thought and declared that the prisoner was guilty of treason; though he had no doubt, that his opinion might be changed by the production of other testimony.—Set aside.

6. Joshua Chaffin excused from indisposition.

7. Gervas Storrs stated that the state of his mind was like that of the gentleman who had gone before him; he was in the habit of reading newspapers, and could not but examine their statements relative to these transactions. If he could believe Gen. Eaton's assertion that the prisoner had threatened to turn Congress out of doors and assassinate the President, he had said and would still say so, that Col. B. was guilty of treason. If Gen. Wilkinson's letter was true, he had surely been guilty of something in the west, that was hostile to the U.S. He did not know whether in the multifarious conversations he had had on this subject, he had always expressed this opinion of his guilt with that reservation. Mr. S. confessed that it might be prejudiced against the prisoner; and that he might be judging too highly of his own mind, to entertain the belief that he could divest himself of all his impressions.—Set aside.

8. Miles Selden declared, that it was impossible not to have entered into the frequent conversations which had occurred on this topic; and to have declared some opinion; that he had always said, that Col. B. was guilty of something, and that if he was guilty of treason against such a government, he would deserve to be hung; that he could not assert that he had always accompanied his opinions with this reservation; but that he was not afraid to trust himself in the rendering of a verdict. Upon being interrogated, he said that he had frequently jested on this subject; and particularly recollected to have said in a sportive conversation with Col. Mayo, that this was a federal plot and that Burr had been set on by the federalists. Suspended.

9. Lewis Trueheart had said, if the reports were correct, that Col. B. had been guilty of something inimical to the country, and that he always qualified his opinions in that manner. Col. Tinsley was then called in, who stated that from a conversation with Mr. Trueheart he thought he had discovered that he had a general prepossession against Col. B.—Suspended.

10. William Yancey had expressed an opinion that Col. B. was guilty on newspaper testimony; but that he had no doubt, he should entertain a different sentiment, if other testimony were produced.—Set aside.

11. Thomas Prosser had made numberless declarations about Col. B; that he had believed him to be guilty of a treasonable intention, but not of the overt act; on this point he had suspended his opinion, but he was rather inclined to believe that he had not committed it. Mr. Martin. Can this gentleman be considered as an impartial juryman, when he thus comes with his mind made up on one half of the guilt? Suspended.

12. John Staples had been under the same impressions, which had been described by others; that he dared to say that he had said Col. B. was guilty of levying troops and making war upon the U. States. Set aside.

13. Edward C. Stannard acknowledged that his prejudices against Col. B. had been deep-rooted;—that he had no doubt of the criminality of his motives, but he had doubts of the commission of an overt act; he regretted that a man of his genius and energetic mind, should be lost to his country; upon being interrogated he observed, that he had doubts as to the overt act, because he believed him to be a man of such insidious intrigue as never to jeopardise his own life.—Set aside.

14. Richard B. Goode stated, that from news paper information and common report, he had formed an opinion unfavorable to Col. B. and that this opinion had been confirmed by what had fallen in this court from his own lips: but that without arrogating to himself more virtue than belongs to the human bosom, he was satisfied that he could render him strict and impartial justice. Some conversation here ensued respecting certain transactions which took place between him and Capt. Heath of the Manchester troop of horse. Mr. G delivered a long narrative of these incidents, which he concluded by asserting that he had addressed a letter to Capt. H. in which he had refused to act under a commander, who had sanctioned a man, that had been a traitor to his country.—Set aside.

15. Nathaniel Selden stated he had formed an opinion particularly from G. Eaton's deposition, that the intentions of the prisoner were hostile to the United States; but that he had also said, that he had seen no evidence to satisfy him, that he had been guilty of any overt act.—Suspended.

16. Esme Smock declared that he had formed and expressed an opinion as to Col. B's treasonable designs; that he had formed that opinion from newspaper publications and common report; and that he had constantly conceived Col. B's intentions to be treasonable. Mr. Wickham. Have you ever formed an opinion, that Col. B. was guilty of treason? I have in my own mind.—Set aside.

17. Richard E. Parker had, like every other person, formed an opinion on this case, on newspaper statements; but he had heard very little of the evidence that may be adduced on this occasion. He had declared, that if these newspaper statements were true, Col. B. had been guilty; as to the doctrine of treason, he had not formed a conclusive opinion. Mr. Burr. I have no objections to Mr. Parker. He is therefore elected.

A desultory argument here ensued about the propriety of swearing one juryman at a time: The counsel for the prosecution opposed; the counsel for the prisoner advocated the doctrine. The court decided that it would adhere to the practice of Virginia; and swear 4 jurymen at a time.

18. John W. Ellis had entertained and did not now entertain any doubts, that the prisoner had been guilty of a treasonable design.—Suspended.

19. Thomas Starke, without any expectations of being summoned as a juryman, had stated his opinion to his neighbors, that Col. B. had been guilty of high treason.—Set aside.

20. William White stated, that he had been in the western country in May last; and from Col. B's character and from the representations he had received of his conduct, he had been induced to say, that he was guilty of treason, and that hanging was too good for him.—Set aside.

21. Wm. B. Chamberlayne stated, that he stood in a very peculiar situation; if as Mr. Wickham declared, any man was unfit to be a juryman who had asserted Col. B. to have been worthy of death; he was ready to confess that he himself came under this restriction: He had so said; but he did not now believe that Col. B. had committed an overt act of treason, though he believed him to be guilty of the intention: He however believed that he could do him justice; and that he could conscientiously pass between him and his country.—Set aside.

22. David Lambert wished to be excused on account of his indisposition: but the court rejected his plea. On being interrogated, he declared that he does not recollect to have formed an opinion for or against Col. B.—Elected.

23. William Hoomes had no hesitation in saying, that he had often declared his opinion that Col. B. was guilty of treasonable intentions, and perhaps he might say, of treason itself. He had imbibed his impressions from every thing he had seen, heard or read. He had understood that Col. B's counsel had made preparations to prove that he had disqualified himself by his own declarations. He should thank them to develope their objections.—Mr. Burr. I assure you, sir, no preparation has been made.—Set aside.

24. Overton Anderson had often expressed an opinion that Col. B's views were inimical to the United States; these opinions he had principally formed upon newspaper statements; he did not recollect that he had ever asserted him to be guilty of treason; but he had sometimes given credit to the representations which he had heard, without particularly defining the degree of guilt in which they might involve the prisoner.—Set aside.

25. Hugh Mercer upon being called, said, it was his duty to state, that an opinion which he had for some time past entertained of the character of Col. Burr, was unfriendly to a strictly impartial enquiry into his case; that he was entirely uninformed as to the testimony which would be introduced, and that he did not recollect to have ever expressed a positive opinion either as to his guilt or innocence.—Elected.

26. Jerman Baker had entertained opinions unfavorable to A. Burr, which he had repeatedly expressed; he had spoken them with warmth, for it was his nature to be warm: He had no doubt that the prisoner had formed very unfavourable designs against the U. States; but from his ignorance of the evidence, he could not venture to say that they had ripened into an overt act.—Mr. Burr. What opinion have you formed of me? A. A very bad one; which I have expressed often when called upon and often when not.—Set aside.

27. Edward Carrington had formed an unfavorable opinion of the views of Col. Burr; but these opinions were not definitive: some had said that Col. Burr's object was to invade the Spanish Territories; others, that it was to dismember the Union: his own opinion had not been definitely fixed. There was another subject connected with this trial, on which he had also expressed his opinions; and that related to the measures taken at New Orleans. His own opinion had been that it was impossible for any one at this remote scene to determine upon the state of affairs in that city; but that if gen. Wilkinson did not seriously believe what he said he had been represented to him as the views of Col. Burr, that he himself considered it as an extreme case, and that it was proper to act in somewhat the like form that Gen. Wilkinson had pursued. This has been the state of my mind for 12 months—Mr. Burr. Have you, Col. any prejudice of a more settled kind and ancient date against me? Col. C. None at all.—Mr. Burr. He is elected.

The four jurymen that had been elected, were then called to the book, and sworn: viz. Messrs. Parker, Lambert, Mercer and Carrington.

28. Robert Haskins had expressed an opinion that Col. B. was guilty; but does not recollect to what extent he went. He might have said that he deserved to be hung.—Set aside.

29. William R. Fleming had formed and frequently expressed an opinion, that Col. B. was guilty of treasonable intentions; and might have made a general declaration, not only as to intentions, but to acts.—Set aside.

30. George W. Smith suggested a right to the same exemption, which had been granted to Mr. P. Randolph. The Court said that this privilege would be incontestible, unless the prisoner should urge his conflicting privilege. Mr. Burr then requested Mr. Smith to attend to-morrow. Mr. Smith wished to be excused, as he had some important business in another court to attend to: He should however attend on the trial to-morrow; but it might now be proper to state the general impressions which he had received from these transactions. He had generally been solicitous to avoid an expression of his opinions: and as in such cases, where the government commences a prosecution against an individual, there is always a preponderance of prejudice against him; he himself had not only been solicitous not to declare, but even to form an opinion. No one can however avoid reading representations of these things in the public papers; and he had formed and declared his impressions, that Col. B. had entertained designs offensive to the peace and laws of the U. States. What was the species of guilt, he had not pretended to define: but he had concluded from the newspaper reports and the testimony which he had heard in the other wing of the Capitol, that his designs was of a military nature; and that they might amount at least to a misdemeanor.—Suspended.

31. Armistead T. Mason had formed no deliberate opinion, in regard to the actual commission of treason. But it was his deliberate opinion, that Col. B. had designed if not to subvert the government, at least to divide the country—Suspended.

32. Dabney Minor had often said that Col. B's intentions were unfriendly to the U. States, but had received no positive testimony.—Some conversation here ensued between Mr. M. and Mr. Botts, when Mr. M. was suspended until to-morrow.

Of the whole Venire, then, that appeared, 4 only were elected and sworn; and 9 were suspended. The case of these last will probably be decided this day.

The Court then decided, that there was no necessity for delivering the jurymen who had been or should be sworn into the custody of the marshal, until the whole number had been impannelled.

Adjourned till Tuesday, 11 o'clock.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 19 August 1807 · an extract

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This notice advertises the newly published first volume of the trial proceedings of Colonel Aaron Burr, priced at 75 cents. It lists several Washington-area booksellers and merchants where copies may be obtained.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 August 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

JUST PUBLISHED,

(PRICE 75 CENTS.)

See moreSee less

Vol. I. of the

Trial of Col. Aaron Burr,

To be had of J. March, and A Suter, George Town—J. V. Thomas, Navy Yard—D. Rapine, Capitol Hill—R. C. Weightman, Pennsylvania Avenue—and Wescott and Co. 11 street, Washington City.

Aug. 7—3t.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

On August 7, 1807, the trial was further postponed because prosecution witnesses were still absent, and court adjourned until Monday. The marshal raised concerns about reimbursement for guard expenses, which the Chief Justice addressed, with Burr offering to personally indemnify the marshal if the Treasury refused payment.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, August 8.

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

See moreSee less

FRIDAY, August 7th, 1807.

Present the Chief Justice of the United States, and Cyrus Griffin judge of the district of Virginia.

The witnesses were again called over, and several who had not been present before, appeared, and were recognized to attend until discharged by the court.

The counsel for the United States, however, not being as well prepared to go into the trial as they expected to be on Monday, (many of their witnesses being still absent) the trial was farther postponed, and the court adjourned until Monday next, twelve o'clock.

In the course of this day, a difficuly was suggested by major Scott, the marshal of the Virginia district, as arising out of the order of the court, by virtue of which col. Burr had been removed from the

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

During jury selection, Aaron Burr challenged potential jurors and called witnesses to support his objections, asking venire members to disclose any bias against him. Burr's counsel and the prosecution debated the proper wording of questions to test juror impartiality, referencing the precedent of the Callender case.

Virginia Argus · 12 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Monday, August 10.

THE proceedings of this day were very interesting; but, as an accurate detail of every circumstance would be too lengthy for the limits of this paper, we shall furnish our readers with a sketch of the most important only.

See moreSee less

Maurice P. Belknap, Charles Duval, Return J. Meigs, James Taylor, Tunis Dills, Bennett Cooke, Hezekiah Lewis, and Gabriel G. Vanhorn appeared and were recognized as witnesses for the United States.

A short time was employed by the counsel for the United States in completing the list of their witnesses, which was delivered by them to Col. Burr; the number amounting to no less than one hundred and thirty-one; of which a large proportion are actually attending.

Doct. William Wardlaw of this city, who was one of the venire, was excused from serving on the ground of the bad health of his wife, which rendered it necessary for him to take a voyage with her to the north. Mr. Randolph Harrison of Cumberland, Mr. James Henderson of Wood county, and Mr. David Bullock of the city of Richmond, were severally excused on account of sickness. The rest of the venire were called over; and were all present to the number of forty-three, Mr. William M'Daniel of Stafford, being alone absent. They were then about to be called one by one, for the purpose of being severally challenged or accepted; but, before this was done, Col. Burr desired several witnesses to be called, whom it appeared he intended to make use of for the purpose of supporting his challenges against those to whom he had objections. The names of those witnesses were, David Briggs, Richard Adams, John Heath, Temple Gwathmy, Thomas Tinsley, James Scott jr. Allen M'Rae, Neil M'Coul, James Clark, jr. and Jedediah Leeds. Some of these, who were not in court, were called at the door.

Col. Burr shortly afterwards observed that he was ready to proceed with the business; and addressing himself to the gentlemen composing the venire, said he had understood that a great number of them labored under a bias against him which ought to disqualify them from serving on the jury for his trial; and therefore exhorted them, as honest and conscientious men, to declare it openly, as they were severally called.

Hezekiah Bukey of Wood county, being called, was challenged for cause, and asked by Mr. Botts (as counsel for Col. Burr) whether he had ever formed and expressed an opinion unfavorable to the accused. Mr. Bukey answered that he had expressed an opinion before he was subpoena'd, but not since.

A debate of considerable length ensued on the propriety of the question propounded by Mr. Botts; the counsel for the United States contending that it ought to assume a more precise and definite form; that no jury could be got, if the question was put in such general terms; for scarcely a man in Virginia could be found who had not (from the various newspaper publications and other sources of information) formed and expressed an opinion either favorably or unfavorably to Col. Burr; that it ought not to be said that a citizen's conversing on a subject of universal interest shall disqualify him as a juror; that the court ought to settle the question to be asked to each venire-man, as had been done in the case of James Thompson Callender; and that it should be, whether he had made up and declared his opinion that Aaron Burr had been guilty of treason, at the place and on the day mentioned in the indictment. Col. Burr and his counsel insisted that there was reason to hope that twelve men could be found, who were candid enough not to have formed an opinion against him, before trial; that no precise form for the question to be put to the venire-men ought to be adopted; but all such questions should be propounded as would discover whether any partiality or bias existed on their minds; that Callender's case was different from this; since every person in that case had the evidence in his own hands of the book's being a libel, but not as to the point whether Callender had published it; and the question put by Judge Chase related only to the fact of publication; but, in this case, if a person had formed an opinion against Col. Burr, he must have done so without any evidence, other than mere report and newspaper statements, and therefore ought to be set aside, on the ground of an improper bias and partiality. The court decided that the examination of the venire-men should not be limited to any precise question; that it was a clear principle of justice that persons intended to be sworn on a petit jury should be determined to find their verdict only according to law and justice; and the only point to be ascertained was whether they were impartial or not.

Hezekiah Bukey, James G. Laidley, James Compton, Hamilton Morrison, Yates S. Connell, Jacob Beeson, William Prince, Nimrod Saunders, Thomas Creel, Anthony Buckner, and David Creel, members of the venire from Wood county who were present, were all challenged for cause by Col. Burr; and, upon examination, rejected, except Hamilton Morrison and Thomas Creel; respecting whom no decision took place. Those who were rejected declared that, (from the rumors they had heard) they believed him guilty of treason, and had expressed that belief. Jacob Beeson and William Prince said that they had borne arms for the purpose of suppressing the armed assemblage of men on Blannerhasset's Island.

Of the rest of the Venire men, Mr. Peyton Randolph of this city was exempted (on his motion) as an Attorney practising in the Court, no objection being made to his exemption; and Mr. Joshua Chaflip of Amelia was excused for ill health; Messrs. William Pope of Hanover, John Roberts of Culpeper, Gervas Storrs, Esme Smock, and William B. Chamberlaine of Henrico, John Staples and Edward C. Stannard of Albemarle, Richard B. Goode and Robert

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 14 August 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage records courtroom argument over whether prospective jurors in Aaron Burr's treason trial are impartial, with prosecutor Hay and defense counsel debating the standard for impartiality. The speaker denies harboring any wish for the prisoner's blood and insists Burr deserves a fair jury, while distinguishing between jurors' prior opinions about intentions versus actual knowledge of treasonous acts.

The Enquirer · 14 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

fore that people, and before the God of his being, that he had never felt the inhuman wish of demanding the blood of the prisoner; of any human being. That man was a stranger to him, who should attribute to him such a disposition. He wished the prisoner to have an impartial jury; and if there was a single one among those set over, who was not impartial, who was not capable of passing between the U. States and A. Burr, he requested the court to reject him. As to the principles stated by

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The court debates whether jurors with preconceived opinions about Burr's treasonable intent should be dismissed, with the Chief Justice setting aside several jurymen based on their prior statements. Mr. Hay requests a new venire of around 150 jurors, while Burr and his counsel object to the composition of the jury panel, including accusations about political bias among those selected.

The Enquirer · 14 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ons.

2. Miles Selden; 3. Lewiis Trueheart; 4. William Yancey; 5. Thomas Prosser; 6. Nathaniel Selden; 7. John W. Ellis; and Armistead T. Mason, were successively set aside.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay then moved the court to award a new Venire; and for such a number, as would probably supply the number of deficient jurymen. He conceived that this number ought to exceed even the first pannel. Perhaps 150 would not be too few.--Mr. Burr was sorry that any such inferences should be drawn from that pannel. He conceived that very different ones ought to be made; and that when it was once demonstrated, that the officer of this court was honestly to seek for proper jurymen, the number could easily be completed.--Mr. Wirt hoped, that when insinuations were thus thrown out against the marshal of the court; a man of as respectable a character as any in the state; he might be called in to justify himself.--Mr. Wickham objected to this pannel, that it contained too many members of assembly and candidates for public office. The marshal should have gone among those, who were not so much in the habit of expressing their political opinions.--Mr.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Richmond editor explains why so much of the paper is devoted to reporting the Aaron Burr trial, noting public interest but also discussing foreign affairs. The piece shifts to commentary on Britain's precarious position following Napoleon's victories and urges continued war preparedness despite conciliatory signals from a British ship captain.

Virginia Argus · 15 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE interest which the public takes at present in the trial of Aaron Burr, renders it proper for us to dedicate so large a portion of our paper to a report of the proceed-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This passage reports on voir dire proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, detailing exchanges over jurors claiming exemptions or expressing prejudice. Several potential jurors, including a lawyer claiming professional exemption and others admitting bias regarding Burr's Western schemes, are examined and some dismissed.

Virginia Argus · 15 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

cused.

Mr. Hamilton Morrison of Wood county (who was one of the venire-men suspended on the day before) was again called. Two witnesses were introduced to prove declarations on his part unfavorable to the prisoner; but established nothing of importance.* He declared it was painful for him to serve; but he had no prejudice, either for or against Aron Burr. As some anxiety was manifested to set him aside, he observed with warmth, that "perhaps his name might be a terror, as his first name was Hamilton." Col. Burr thereupon preremptorily challenged him; saying he would do

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This passage reports courtroom arguments over whether venire members who had formed opinions on Burr's guilt could serve as impartial jurors. Counsel for Burr and the prosecution debated the definition of impartiality, with Wickham arguing that jurors' beliefs were based on prejudicial sources like Jefferson's statements and Wilkinson's deposition rather than factual knowledge of events.

Virginia Argus · 15 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

In reply it was urged on the side of Col. Burr, that the state of the public opinion ought not to be inferred from the impressions of the 48 gentlemen who had been summoned on this venire; that the prisoner and his counsel believed it to be practicable to get from among the people of Virginia a totally impartial jury; and that a contrary supposition was a libel on the state. Mr. Wickham said that, in the trials of the rebels in England, the jury knew the fact of the rebellion to have existed.

See moreSee less

If a war had existed here, if Burr had fought battles; the venire would have had a knowledge of facts, and would not have formed their opinions from prejudice. Here the only evidence, said he, which the veniremen have seen is the President's declaration that the guilt of Col. Burr was unquestionable; together with Gen. Wilkinson's deposition, and Gen. Eaton's affidavit; tho

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A dispatch from Albany reports that Major Israel Smith of Cayuga County, indicted for treason by the Richmond grand jury, was arrested and is being taken to Richmond, where Colonel Burr's trial begins that day. Smith is noted for having voluntarily informed the President and the prosecuting attorney of his whereabouts and intent to appear in court.

Virginia Argus · 15 August 1807 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No page image survives for this article

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The court reconvened but the U.S. counsel were not ready, so the trial was postponed until the following Monday. A separate dispute arose over whether the Treasury would reimburse the marshal for guard expenses incurred in holding Burr, which Chief Justice Marshall addressed, and Burr offered to personally indemnify the marshal.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 17 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF A. BURR, FRIDAY, AUGUST 7, 1807

was suggested by major Scott, the marshal of the Virginia district, as arising out of the order of the court, by virtue of which col. Burr had been removed from the penitentiary house to his present lodgings. He stated that he had

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report describes a session of Aaron Burr's treason trial held in the Capitol before Chief Justice John Marshall, with counsel and jury present. It details procedural disputes over witness summons and Burr's request for a subpoena duces tecum for documents from General Eaton.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 17 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Justice of the United States.

The court assembled at 12 o'clock. An immense concourse of citizens attended to witness the proceedings of this important trial.

See moreSee less

A few minutes after, Aaron Burr entered, attended by Messrs. Wickham, Martin, Botts, Barker, and Mr. Alston of South-Carolina. Mr. E. Randolph entered soon afterwards.

Messrs. Hay, Writ and M'Rae attended as counsel for the prosecution.

Mr. Hay observed that he could take no steps in the business until he had ascertained whether the witnesses summoned on the part of the United States were present; he therefore requested that their names might be called over.

The petit Jury was then called over, and the Marshal ordered to prepare a regular list of them; and summon their attendance.

The subject of a subpœna duces tecum, was again brought up; and after some conversation between the Judge, and Attorny General;—

Mr. Burr observed, that his object was to procure a certain communication from Gen. Eaton to the President of the United States, which is mentioned in his deposition.

Mr. Hay was not certain whether he had that communication, but believed that it was among his papers. If it was there he would certainly produce it.

Mr. Burr. But if after a search, the gentleman finds that he has not that paper, will he consent out of court to issue a subpœna to the President of the United States under the qualification I have mentioned? I wish not at the present exigency, to derange the affairs of the government, or to demand the presence of the executive officers at this place. All that I want is, certain papers.

Mr. Hay could not consent to such a measure; he would rather that it should go through the regular progress of the court.

Mr. Burr. Then, sir, I shall move for a subpœna duces tecum to the President of the U. S. directing him to attend with certain papers. This subpœna will issue as in the former instance. I shall furnish the clerk with a necessary specification of the paper which I require.

The court was then adjourned till Wednesday 12 o'clock.

Capt. Stewart, of the schooner Bellona, from Antigua, informs, that, just as he was about departing from that Island, intelligence of the affair of the Leopard and Chesapeake was received. The people of the island appeared much concerned upon the subject. Flour rose immediately one dollar and one half per barrel.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

Major Isaac Smith of Cayuga county, indicted for treason by the Richmond grand jury, was arrested on a warrant and brought to Albany en route to Richmond, where Burr's trial begins that day. The report notes Smith voluntarily informed the President and prosecutor Hay of his residence and intent to appear in court.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 17 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ALBANY, AUG. 3. Major Isaac Smith, of Cayuga county one of the persons indicted for treason by the Richmond grand jury, has been taken on a warrant from Judge Talmadge, and has arrived in this city, in custody of the deputy marshal, on his way to Richmond—at which place the trial of Col Burr commences this day. We are informed, and we mention the circumstance as honorable to Major Smith, that immediately after being informed that a bill had been found against him, he wrote to the President, and Mr. Hay, the attorney, informing them of his place of residence, and that

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The passage records courtroom argument over standards for juror impartiality, referencing the precedent set in the Callender trial regarding whether jurors had formed opinions on the case. Burr and the court debate the distinction between general knowledge of a case and having a fixed opinion on the specific charge of treason.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 August 1807 · page 2

I {"Bu'rrsis treason : but icsi-is extremelyproþc. \ ( si ble than most. ofrhcm know narwhaursieasi sison is,ct and though they may decide upon \ messgniusiefcozif Burr, .sshathey my be jctchkam, whether it cpweo under sithe, name and descxiptioh of treason;, ' MrBottsis qumcd author-idea in ausisip. port-es his opinion,: 3 Bchm ,358; a-si-dascct from Hawkia's ; th'c' cas-es of Smssith - and_ Ozdcoiz and judge si-lredifl's .octpinion in (he me df'Fricp." " _ ' '- si si ThesiChidsiffussipssssi observed thank-hight -ectavc some all-region if the court was to dplivqr its opinions; at<.- the .presssancssximcctz-g "".zhujtct-was - cer-{zinkysiooc of .chesi'jckeiasiceecsi principle: hs'oatmif justice Jhamajur-y'mga * shossifldsi come to siw- {tial-fix ctli-sesi with a' iside:-see; freedom sif-om previous imp'tes sid'nsss'flrzt-itwssaa dear!")!

See moreSee less

sithe-duty 'of the poor; "to obtain} such-men, if it wet; poisi ssbk to produce themctfrcesifrqm "sucsih-ssbctiaa ; But that it were an pdosisctn'olo fromjhssc very circumstancupfsscbc Cane} if gumsidn 'hadct, tssesissicbed And pie'ctþ'osizctsesscssdsi sheissct rct sisijngmm , 'assiifl the court was bodnd hot—"admit: aslet-gaf K-PPHZQÞOf iqasipaj'tiaiicsisi as possible, {hagct _. ctss'sssi ctsssisssissct T,. .ctct-ctsisi hadst-tam-sspssrbppsszessssdzsictfþm.maw,! for-m Was-ty. Mad! sisiz'vcte'siirctsiy?zems,ctzssiihsisisi-Fv-ssifl-c!i-..;*i'zf*si.*s*;si one-uncbcwomhdsi-md WM " TPMFM utmHumshmpwo si sict si This 'Bosissiwinflgidd—rcditsi as, : anftssassitcsi si ever to be dcplo'redsi that in " tbiasi 'cbnntryssssSt . iucttbisffsic'nie," thcrcss had been wnsi gent-ful no,-. ' expression-Makectpnblicsiscsintimgnt, and sitbntsiz chia 'gcncrasslity _si ofnptnion'Twctdnld disqunfifyss ' isssisisictbflgctmct had sin.-;v cr entertained in dnctubt ' nati} the sip'rsiosec-Jsstsstm hassd gkpmsictd it, the}: ttsivehze'm'en'simjghtssssbe lsi'shund to Vitgctinia,ss ctcapiblc'ofct detisiding this qugssgtiop withssithc' : eflrictcst- .imparxialitysi He s'tffl trusted that the 'assssuossmey fact: the Unitcd Scttatcs 'waunssissnsi taken; that the batastrophcct n'as-LUOtTCÞ'niQct :plete'ly stxcdct; and that every mao'sictincttfisie state-hadnssot pledged himself to con-vsiict ,..cul. Burr, whethcrssright or wrong." "He Was ssr net per-sent at the-trial of]. T. Callcndcr ; ——butall 'Amchca had heard the question which was then propnnndcd totheitsitry men ; and that was ; whether he hadmadcss' up and expressed an Opinion rcspcctinsigct th; ; ggisilt of the;.prison'cr. _ si - 'ssZ'Ir. szy would put ler Bone fight} inþn mactcrgofsisact. The court wonlsidssknsssigsi' cosllcct that.-si on the trial of Caiiendcrsi (sit? ucstien was nnt whether the jurymen "had sound and expssrsscssed an opinion on that case generaliy; but on the subject matter that w_aa_ tosibc cried, and couched in the ind'ictmem. The-question then in the press-? sent case should be: : have you formed and expressed an opinion on the point atisSuc, that is,'whcthcr A.. B. is gn'zlty of trea 'aod\.2ss Onctthc trix-fie! Callcnder the court

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report covers voir dire proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial before Chief Justice John Marshall, with potential jurors being questioned about prior opinions on Burr's guilt. Several jurors admit to having formed opinions that Burr was guilty of treason or something detrimental to U.S. peace, leading to debates about their qualification to serve.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. AARON BURR

had never been his wish or intention to shrink from the discharge of a public duty; but that he had peculiar objections to serving on this occasion; one of which only he should state. He had been enrolled and was qualified as a lawyer in this court; and he would submit it to the court whether this did not exempt, nay even disqualify him from serving.

Chief Justice admitted Mr. R's privilege, unless there was an express interposition on the part of the prisoner to retain some of the venire: for this would call a conflicting privilege in operation.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr said that he should be passive. Set aside.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report records testimony of prospective jurors being questioned about prejudicial opinions they had formed on Aaron Burr's guilt before the trial. Several jurors admitted prior statements suggesting Burr's guilt and were set aside as not impartial.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

accompanied his opinions with this reservation; but that he was not afraid to trust himself in the rendering a verdict. Upon being interrogated, he said that he had frequently jested on this subject; and particularly recollected to have said in a sportive conversation with col. Mayo, that this was a federal plot and that Burr had been

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report documents voir dire proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with potential jurors questioned about opinions they had formed based on newspaper accounts. Several jurors admit holding views on Burr's guilt from press reports, leading to debates over jury selection procedures including whether to swear in jurors one at a time per Virginia practice.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr. I have no objection to Mr. Parker. He is therefore elected.

A desultory argument here ensued about the propriety of swearing one juryman at a time.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The passage lists names of potential jurors (the venire) for Aaron Burr's treason trial, noting their counties of origin and that seven were absent, reducing the panel to 40. Burr proposes selecting eight jurors directly to avoid peremptory challenges, and the account includes examination of juror Christopher Anthony, who admitted expressing a desire to see Burr hanged but was still questioned about his impartiality.

The Enquirer · 18 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Edmund Bally, City of Richmond, Holder Hudgins, Matthews, William H. Hudgins, do. John Price, Henrico, Isham Godwin, do. Wm. S. Smith, do. George Blakey, do. Gray Carrol, Isle of Wight, Isaac Medley, Halifax, Richard Curd, Henrico, Edward Mumford, Powhatan, Samuel Allen, Buckingham, John M. Sheppard, Hanover, John Curd, Goochland.

There were 7 absentees.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr then observed, that the pannel was now reduced to 40; and as it would be exceedingly disagreeable for him to exercise the privilege of making peremptory challenges to which he was entitled, he would lay a proposition before the opposite counsel, which would prevent this necessity. He would select eight out of the whole Venire, and they might be immediately sworn and impanneled on the jury.

The C. J. suggested the propriety of placing those eight at the head of the pannel.

Mr. Hay had no objection to this arrangement. It would be easy for him to examine the qualifications of the eight who were selected, when they were once known.

William S. Smith then requested to be excused, on account of his indisposition. Mr. Burr observed that Mr. S. was one of those whom he had selected; but he would be sorry to impose such a burden upon any invalid. Mr. S. was discharged.

When Christopher Anthony was called, he observed to the court, that he had uttered some expressions since he came to town, which he had been told would certainly disqualify him from serving.—Mr. Burr. Perhaps they were used through levity. Do you think they would be sufficient to warp your judgment? A. No. Mr. Burr. Then, Sir, you are not disqualified. Mr. McRae. State the tenor of those expressions. A. When I first arrived here, I met with an intimate friend, to whom I observed that I had come to town with a hope of being placed on this jury; and that I would use my exertions to hang Col. Burr. Mr. McRae. Did you say so, knowing that such expressions would disqualify you? A. I did not; for I never expected to be put on this pannel. Q. Were you serious? A. Far from it. I spoke in the utmost spirit of levity. Q. Have you been in the habit of reading the newspapers? A. I have. Q. Have you read gen. Eaton's deposition? Messrs. Burr, Martin and Wickham arose and objected to the question. Mr. Martin

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 24 August 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage records voir dire exchanges during jury selection at Burr's treason trial, with potential jurors expressing bias and seeking to be excused. Burr himself engages directly with jurors and the court regarding standards of impartiality and the presumption of innocence.

The Enquirer · 18 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

sufficient cause for challenge, he would ask where would this inquisition stop or where could they obtain a jury? "Gentlemen (turning to the jury) if any of you have made up and declared your opinion on the cafe, you will say so, before you come to the book." Mr. Burr. The law presumes every man to be innocent, until he has been proved to be guilty. It is therefore the duty of every citizen who serves in this jury, to hold himself completely unbiassed; it is no disqualifition then for a man to come forward and declare that he believes me to be innocent.

When Christopher Anthony was called to the book, he stated that he was in court the other day when the first Venire was investigated; that it would be extremely unpleasant to serve on the jury, after having formed the very same opinions which he understood had disqualified others. Mr. A's objections were overruled.

See moreSee less

John M. Sheppard. I too feel myself disqualified from passing impartially between the U. States and A. Burr. From the documents that I have seen, I have believed and do still believe, that his intentions were hostile to the U. States. It would be inflicting a wound on my own bosom, to be compelled to serve under my present impressions. Mr. S. observed, that considerations of a private nature had also borne upon his mind: for he had a child at home extremely sick.—Mr. Burr. Notwithstanding Mr. Sheppard's impressions, I could rely up[on]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report details the voir dire process for selecting jurors in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with several prospective jurors expressing pre-formed opinions against Burr based on newspaper accounts and the depositions of Generals Eaton and Wilkinson. Burr navigates the selection, accepting some jurors despite their admitted bias while rejecting others, as the court works to seat a jury.

The Enquirer · 18 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ments.

Miles Botts. From the affidavits of Gens. Wilkinson and Eaton, my opinion has been compleatly made up for several months past.---Mr. Martin. I suppose you have only taken up a prejudice, on the supposition that the facts stated were true.---Mr. Botts. I have gone as far as to declare, that col. B. ought to be hung.---Mr. Burr. Do you think that such declarations would now influence your judgment? A. Human nature is frail. Nor I can positively say. Q. Have you lately declared them? A. Within a few months. I do not feel myself a competent juryman. Mr. Burr. It will be seen, either that I am under the necessity of taking men pre-possessed against me or of having another Venire. I am unwilling to submit to the further delay of other Tales, and I must therefore encounter the consequences. I will take Mr. Botts, under a belief that he will do me justice.

See moreSee less

Four jurymen then having been selected, the three following were sworn: Messrs. James Sheppard, Blakey and Botts. Mr. C. Anthony was affirmed.

When Henry Coleman was called, he stated that he had conceived and expressed an opinion that the designs of Col. B. were always developed in mystery and always inimical to the U. S. and when informed by the public prints, that he was descending the river with an armed force, he had felt as every friend of his country ought to feel. Mr. Burr. If, sir, you have completely prejudged my case.--Mr. C. I have not. I have not seen the evidence. Mr. B. That is enough, sir. You are elected.

Mr. Hay then suggested to the court, the propriety of not swearing all the jury this day; as it would subject them to the inconvenience of an unnecessary confinement in their own room to-morrow (Sunday.) Would it not be better for Mr. Marshal (the clerk) to swear three only out of the remaining four? The court might then impannel the whole on Monday and proceed immediately to business. Mr. Burr had no objections to this measure; but hoped that the court would enjoin them not to hold any conversations on the subject of the trial.

John Curd upon being called, stated that he had no prejudices for or against the prisoner; but that he was bound in candor to inform the court, that he was afflicted by a disorder (a palpitation of the heart which might interrupt and delay the progress of the cause. Excused.

Isham Godwyn had formed and declared an uniform opinion of Col. Burr's guilt. If he was impannelled, he should be so, under a strong impression that Col. B. was guilty of treason. Suspended.

Samuel Allen had for several months made up an opinion unfavorable to the prisoner.--Suspended.

Benjamin Graves gave a long history of his domestic and family engagements to excuse himself from serving. He was asked whether he could not make some arrangements of this business between this time and Monday, calculated to remove all the inconvenience of his serving. Mr. G. could not positively say.

Mr. Burr then observed, that the two jurors who had been selected, might be sworn: the other two might be selected on Monday. And Messrs. Coleman and Bott were accordingly sworn.

Mr. Burr hoped that the Marshal would direct all the necessary preparations to be made

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 22 August 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Lawyers argue in court over whether potential jurors who have already formed and expressed opinions about Aaron Burr's guilt should be disqualified from serving. The dispute references precedent from the Callender case and debates the distinction between opinions on the general subject versus the specific indictment.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

the strictest impartiality. He still trusted that the attorney for the U. S. was mistaken; that the catastrophe was not so completely fixed; and that every man in the state had not pledged himself to convict col. Burr, whether right or wrong. He was not present at the trial of J. T. Callender; but all America

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report documents the examination of potential jurors in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with the court questioning each about prior opinions formed from newspaper reports or rumors regarding Burr's guilt. Several jurors, including Blennerhassett, Morrison, Comarll, Beeson, and Prince, are set aside after admitting they had already formed opinions about Burr's guilt based on public reports.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr observed, that as gentlemen on the part of the prosecution had expressed a willingness to have an impartial jury, they could not refuse that any jurymen should not state all his objections to himself; and that he had no doubt, in spite of the contrary assertions which had been made, that they could get a jury from this pannel.

4. Hamilton Morrison upon being called, said, that he had frequently thought and declared, that col. B. was guilty, if the statements which he had heard were true; that he did not know whether they were so; but only thought from the great clamor which had been made, that it might be possible they were true; that he had not passed any positive opinion; nor was he certain that he had always qualified it by saying "if these things were true;" that he does not recollect to have said that

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The court addressed challenges to jurors suspended the previous day, including Mr. G.W. Smith's claim of exemption as a practicing lawyer and Mr. Henderson's dismissal for not being a freeholder. Juror Hamilton Morrison admitted to Burr that rumors had created prejudice against him in his mind.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 August 1807 · page 1

TRIAL <JF AARON BURRV ‘ Tlie proceedings of this day were principally con fin®^ to the cases of the jurors, Whowere yesterday suspended for a subseqeiH examination. The first case which was mentioned, wasMr, G.W. Smiths.—Mr. Burr observed, that as some

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This passage details the jury selection process for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including challenges for cause and peremptory challenges against potential jurors. Several jurors are questioned about their prior opinions on Burr's guilt, with one juror describing how his views evolved from believing Burr sought to settle Washita lands to suspecting a plan involving conquering Mexico via New Orleans.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 August 1807 · page 1

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

aside. , . ' . ivir. Hamilton Mormon, one of the tuspended ju rymen, being called up, observed to the court, that he should with pain serve on the jury?; for the de fendant had so many imaginary thoughts against him, as to make that service disagreeable. He had not meddled with the prisoner’s transactions ; but, should have done so if it bad been profitable to him. ■ Mr. Buir. Have not these rumours excited a pre- • judice against me in your mind? A. 1 have uo pre judice for or against you.—Mr.

See moreSee less

Bolts. Are you a ireeholder ? A. 1 have two patents for land. Q.are you worth 300 dollarsi A. Yes; I have a horse iiere that is worth the half of it. Q. Have you another at home to make up the other half ? A. Yes ; four of them. I am not astonished at their wishing to set me aside. Perhaps my Christian name is a sufficient terror.—Mr. Burr. 1 think that

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report describes courtroom proceedings regarding jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including discussion of the marshal's role in summoning jurors familiar with the court's legal opinions on treason. Several summoned jurors were excused for various reasons, and disputes arose over witness expenses and the number of witnesses summoned by Burr's defense.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THURSDAY, August 13.

A list of the 48 men summoned on the tales by the marshal was delivered to col. Burr; but, as he declared himself not prepared to judge of them, and wished a little time to be allowed him for that purpose, the tales were not called over, and the trial, of course was postponed.

See moreSee less

Gen. John Pegram of Dinwiddie (one of the persons summoned) was excused on the ground of his being busily engaged in carrying into effect within his brigade the orders of major-general Woodson, in obedience to the requisition made by the president of the United States of 11,503 men from the state of Virginia.

Mr. Thomas Lewis (of Kentucky) was excused, as not having a freehold in this state.

Mr. William Moncure of this city was also exempted from serving in consequence of his bad state of health.

Mr. Hay suggested the propriety of adding three other names to the pannel, in lieu of those who had been excused; to which col. Burr said, he was willing to consent; provided it should be the act of the court. The Chief Justice answered that no order need be made on the subject, but it might be so understood by the marshal.

Col. Burr mentioned that a Mr. Neal who had been summoned as a witness for him, (for the purpose of proving the disqualification of one of the venire,) had been discharged by him; and the marshal had refused to pay him for his attendance.

Mr. Hay objected to the great number of witnesses which he understood had been summoned on behalf of col. Burr, perhaps wantonly, for the purpose of increasing exorbitantly the already enormous expenses of this prosecution.

Col. Burr said he was glad that this circumstance was mentioned; since it afforded him an opportunity of making some explanations which were necessary. He declared the rumours which had gone abroad of the multitude of witnesses summoned for him to be altogether groundless; that he had indeed directed many to be summoned to prove circumstances relative to the venire-men; (concerning whom it had been impossible for him to foresee that that they would voluntarily state their own disqualifications;) but on purpose to save expense to the United States, he had, as soon as possible, discharged them from farther attendance; and that, in the end, he did not expect half as many witnes-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Several prospective jurors are questioned about their prior opinions regarding Colonel Burr's guilt, with some admitting to having formed opinions based on newspaper reports while others claim impartiality. Jurors are examined and some excused based on their stated biases.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

city—but that if general Wilkinson did seriously believe what he said had been represented to him as the views of colonel Burr, that he himself considered it as an extreme case, and that it was proper to act in somewhat the like form that general Wilkinson had pursued.——This has been the state of my mind for twelve months. Mr. Burr. Have you col. any prejudice of a more settled kind and ancient date against me? Col. C. None at all. Mr. Burr. He is elected.

The four jurymen that had been elected were then called to the book and sworn: viz. Messrs. Parker, Lambert, Mercer & Carrington.

See moreSee less

When R. E. Parker was about to be sworn, he observed to the court, that some

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report records courtroom testimony from potential jurors being examined about opinions they had previously formed or expressed regarding Aaron Burr's guilt. Several individuals, including Baker and Carrington, described unfavorable impressions of Burr's intentions toward Spanish territories or the Union, while others noted uncertainty about the extent of his guilt.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

pinions unfavorable to A. Burr, which he had repeatedly expressed; he had spoken them in warmth for it was his nature to be warm: He had no doubt that the prisoner

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

On August 15, the court convened with the Chief Justice presiding to select a jury from forty-eight summoned talesmen for Aaron Burr's treason trial. Burr proposed selecting eight jurors himself from the remaining pool, a proposal the prosecution accepted, and examination of the named candidates began.

Virginia Argus · 19 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

OF Aaron Burr.

SATURDAY, August 15.

See moreSee less

Present the CHIEF JUSTICE of the United States.

Several additional witnesses for the U. States appeared, and were recognized.

The forty eight gentlemen, who had been summoned as Tales de circumstantibus, were then called over; of whom six were absent. Mr. Benjamin Tate (one of those who were present) was excused from serving, on the ground of his bad state of health.

Col. Burr observed, that since the number present was now reduced to forty one, and he had a right to challenge peremptorily thirty five; it was obviously in his power to select any eight whom he should prefer. He therefore proposed (to prevent the unnecessary consumption of time) that he should be permitted to make a list of eight of the persons summoned; in which case he doubted not a jury might be obtained in a few minutes.

The Council for the United States consented to this proposal; whereupon Col. Burr presented a list of the following names; Christopher Anthony, (Goochland) Reuben Blakey, (Henrico) John M. Shephard, (Hanover) John Fitzgerald, (Nottoway) Miles Betts, (Manchester) James Shiphard, (Richmond) Henry E. Coleman (Halifax) and John Curd, (Goochland.)

Those gentleman were severally called over and examined.

Mr. Christopher Anthony, being called, said that he had uttered certain expressions, which might be considered as having disqualified him.

Col. Burr. If those expressions do not weigh upon your mind, I should trust, from the representation I had heard of your character, that you may nevertheless not be disqualified to serve.

Mr. Anthony. The expression used by me were "that I wished to be put on the jury; and, if I was, would hang Col. Burr without ceremony." But I was not serious in those expressions, which were merely spoken in levity.

Mr M'Rae. Have you read Gen Eaton's and General Wilkinson's depositions? and have they had no effect on your mind?

This question was objected to by Col. Burr and his counsel.

Mr. M'Rae contended that the question was proper, and sanctioned by the example of Aaron Burr himself and of his counsel, in the examination of the venire-men objected to by them. He observed that he did not recollect that they in every case had challenged for cause; that their course had been to ask each venire-man whether he had any thing to say to the court, and to put questions nearly similar to the one which he had propounded. He wished, on the part of the United States, only to have the same privilege of examining the persons proposed to be on the jury, which had been enjoyed on the part of the prisoner. Col. Burr himself had suggested, that it would be dishonorable for a person summoned on

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage records courtroom examination of prospective jurors in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with several admitting they had already formed and expressed opinions that Burr's intentions were hostile or treasonous toward the United States. Burr himself engaged in legal argument over what constituted disqualifying bias, and some jurors were set aside while others were accepted despite stated prejudices.

Virginia Argus · 19 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

as jurors then progressed.

Mr. Christopher Anthony declared himself strongly prejudiced against the designs of Aaron Burr, believing them hostile to the United States. He was nevertheless accepted by the prisoner.

See moreSee less

Mr. John M. Sheppard said he had formed impressions which he conceived ought to disqualify him. He had made up his opinion, and expressed it freely: "that he considered col. Burr's intentions hostile to the United States, and that col. Burr would overturn the government if he could." He observed also, that he wished to be excused from serving, on the ground of the sickness of one of his family.

Col. Burr. Notwithstanding the declarations of Mr. Sheppard, I should wish to retain him, because I hope he would be able to divest himself of the impressions he has mentioned; but I should wish not to subject him to inconvenience in consequence of the sickness in his family. Let him sit down for the present; and I will see whether we can get a jury without him.

Mr. John Fitzgerald declared his opinion to be that col. Burr's intentions were hostile and treasonable against the U. States; and that he had also declared that opinion. He was set aside for the present.

Mr. Miles Botts. From gen. Wilkinson's and gen. Eaton's depositions my opinion is completely made up, and has been declared, that col. Burr ought to be hanged.

Col. Burr. Has your opinion been so decisively made up, that you could not hear-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report captures courtroom argument concerning jury selection standards in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with counsel debating what constitutes an impartial juror. The speaker denies harboring personal malice toward Burr while defending the court's approach to jurors who had formed preliminary opinions but not on the specific treason charges.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

He wished the prisoner to have an impartial jury; and if there was a single one among those set over, who was not impartial, who was not capable of passing between the United States and Aaron Burr, he requested the court to reject him. As to the principles stated by Mr. Martin he did not intend to controvert them. He only differed with him in their application to the present case. Which of these jurymen has informed the court, that he has an ill-will against Aaron Burr? a personal prejudice? and that on the question of treason, he has a bias against him?

See moreSee less

It is true they have formed some opinions about his intentions, but they have received no evidence on which they can form any opinions as to the question of actual treason. And as to these intentions they may have related to other acts, than those charged in the indictment; as to acts done without the district, which are not now before the court. The distinction which they have drawn between intentions and acts is perfectly clear and rational. These jurymen prove that they have

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 19 August 1807

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report covers courtroom discussion about jury selection difficulties, with Mr. Wirt defending the panel's qualifications and the Chief Justice addressing the challenge of finding jurors without pre-formed opinions on the case. Further proceedings include Burr's objection to an incomplete jury panel list and discussion of subpoenaed documents including letters from Bacon and General Wilkinson.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr observed, that just before coming into court he had received a copy of the pannel awarded yesterday. It was deficient in not having the places of residence affixed to the name of the jurors. He should perhaps require till the day after to-morrow to examine it. After some conversation, the court determined to adjourn till Saturday, 11 o'clock. Some conversation then ensued respecting the subpoena duces tecum, when Mr. Hay stated that he had found gen. Eaton's letter, among certain papers transmitted by Mr. Rodney, and had filed it with the clerk. As to gen. Wilkinson's letter of the 21st October, he had not found it amongst those papers; but would seek for it again.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report records testimony from potential jurors Baker and Carrington during jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, with each questioned about prior opinions on Burr's guilt. Burr personally cross-examines the jurors, and Carrington is ultimately seated after disclaiming settled prejudice against him.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr. What opinion have you formed of me? A. A very bad one which I have expressed often when called upon and often when not. Set aside. 27. Edward Carrington had formed an unfavorable opinion of the views of the views of col. Burr; but these opinions were not definitive; some had said

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom testimony during jury selection, with prospective jurors questioned about their prior opinions on Burr's guilt formed from newspaper accounts. Several jurors are challenged and dismissed for bias, while others like R.R. Parker and the four sworn jurymen are accepted after explaining their impressions were not fixed conclusions.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Col. C. None at all.

Mr. Burr. He is elected.

See moreSee less

The four jurymen that had been elected, were then called to the book, and sworn; viz. Messrs. Parker, Lambert, Mercer and Carrington.

When R. E. Parker was about to be sworn, he observed to the court, that some gentlemen had just been rejected who appeared to be so similarly circumstanced with himself in regard to their feelings and opinions, that he had feared that the court and Mr. Burr had not clearly understood his late declarations

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom dialogue during jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including challenges to potential jurors based on impartiality and qualifications. Several jurors are questioned and dismissed, including one who admits prejudice related to rumors about Burr.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Hamilton Morrison, one of the suspended jurymen, being called up, observed to the court, that he should with pain serve on the jury; for the defendant had so many imaginary

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom examination of a potential juror about his prior opinions on Aaron Burr's guilt and alleged western conspiracy, followed by legal argument between counsel over the standards for juror impartiality and challenges. Defense attorney Martin objects to establishing broad precedents on jury selection, accusing the prosecution of seeking a jury predisposed against Burr.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

that were taken by the government.

Mr. Burr. Enough, I think, has appeared to prove that Mr. U. has taken up deep-rooted prejudices against me.

See moreSee less

Mr. M'Rae. Have you any personal prejudices against the prisoner?

A. None: I have no prejudices against him, but from his supposed designs against his country.

Mr. Burr. Had you not taken up some prejudices against me anterior to

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Defense counsel Martin argues the constitutional right to an impartial jury, sparking heated exchanges with prosecutor Hay over accusations of delay and insults. Burr intervenes to ask that no further allusions be made to past inflammatory remarks, hoping to keep proceedings civil.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

say it, sir, to his face.

Mr. Burr. We have entered into this argument, because we thought it more precise to fix the principles on this subject at once; and then to apply these to the particular cases.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. It is our wish, sir, to pursue this enquiry as soon as possible, and to save time: but, sir, it is impossible for us to hear such gross insults as have been cast upon us; insults, which are offensive to humanity itself.

The Chief Justice had hoped that no such allusions would have been made: the government ought be treated with respect.

Mr. Burr had hoped, when he was up before, that he had made sufficient

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

Attorneys argue over whether prospective jurors who have formed opinions about Burr's intentions can be considered impartial, with discussion of how public prejudice was created through inflammatory publications. Burr himself speaks to narrow the argument, distinguishing between judging acts versus judging intent in determining guilt.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Botts observed, that every crime consisted of a great many component parts; and the question was, when upon Analysis a jury-man says he has not committed himself upon two or three of these points, he can be regarded as an impartial juryman. The intention is certainly a most important feature in the crime. Fix upon twelve jurymen, whose minds are made up as to his designs and col. Burr is already half condemned. These men would be prepared to find a verdict of guilty if the acts only could be proved, when 12 other impartial jurymen might be willing to acquiesce in the evidence of the acts, when they could not be satisfied from the testimony, that there was the least guilty intention.

See moreSee less

With what face could col. Burr's counsel stand before a jury thus predetermined, urging upon them an innocent intent? Mr. Burr rose to narrow the argument, not to extend it, not to add any

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 14 August 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 19 August 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 3 other papers

This fragment introduces a report headed 'Trial of Aaron Burr,' dated Thursday, August 13, amid a page of unrelated advertisements. The actual trial content is cut off before any substantive detail appears.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

Thursday, August 13.

See moreSee less

Sketch of the Arguments on the qualifications of an impartial jury (Concluded.)

Mr. Wirt, said, it were to be wished that in this case, a jury could be got of such pure materials as Mr. Martin desired, whose minds were as pure as the unsoiled snow on Dian's lap. But does experience justify such a hope? The case does not exist and the law does not require it. Mr. Martin's authorities are elementary; they are abstract; and not precisely applicable to points of practice. They are general phrases: they deal only in generals; but were these books even to be trusted; and did not their generality exclude them from familiar use; you will find that when they specify, they express a particular reference to the person of the accused. To show that these elementary principles are not completely pursued in the English courts, he would refer to Tooke's case, p. 9. Any enmity and familiarity, is in Reeves a sufficient cause for rejection: but in Tooke's trial, Mr. Thompson's intimacy with Mr. T. for 34 years was said by the judge to be no good ground of exception. But let us select another case in our own country. It is important that the rules of law should not be continually shifting on the waves of uncertainty, in order that a man may know how to steer his course. Well, now what says the case of Callender in a particular point? When Mr. John Basset had objected to himself, because he had already made up his mind on the point of libel, he was overruled. But turn to the English laws of libel and what is the principal point there? Is it who is the author? Is it on that point that the brightest beams of eloquence are shed? No. But it is on the question whether it is a libel or not. Then in the language of Mr. Botts, was not Callender cut off from more than half his defence?—Let us draw an analogy between the two cases. These jurymen might have said, that the assemblage of men on Blannerhassett's Island was high treason: but they knew not whether col. B. was there. Here this case and that of Callender would be strikingly parallel. In both cases, the great facts would be fixed in the mind of the juror—and the only thing that would remain, would be to trace them up to the individual accused. But the present case falls far short of that. These jurymen say, that from newspaper publications they have taken up some impressions, as to Burr's treasonable intentions; but not one of them says that the meeting on Blannerhassett's island was an act of treason. In another point Callender's case was a stronger one than this—It was ridiculous for J. T. Callender to have attempted to counteract the conviction, that lay against his crime. Mr. Basset's opinion was formed upon the book itself; and there was no other evidence to produce. But in this case, a juryman have seen nothing but the evidence in the newspapers; and they say there is conflicting evidence as to the fact of treason. If then you would strip col. B. of half of his defence, because a juryman has made up half of his mind; how much more was J. T. Callender stript of his?—The kind of jury that Mr. Martin contends for, is impossible to be obtained from the very nature of things. Necessity has often given the law in other cases; and perhaps it must in this. This is not the only case, where a purely impartial juryman must have dropt from Heaven or from some other planet. Look at the English rebellions of 1715 and '45; when the question of the Pretender and the house of Hanover was so warmly agitated.—The magazines were filled with it: the utmost zeal and enthusiasm animated every man in the nation; men not only wrote but fought for it; and that in so small a kingdom, that the very clang and the din of the battle of Culloden rung to the other confines of the country. Is this a case in which an impartial jury could have been expected? and yet the rebels were tried; tried by British jurors; tried by jurors which had been perhaps arrayed in battle against them. Perhaps those who fought for the monarch in the fields of Culloden, were the very men who decided on the trials for treason. Mr. Martin's rule is a good rule, when it flourishes in the mind of a good man; it is a good rule for Utopia & Arabia happy: and look to the trials of '94 in Ireland; when men who had fought at the battle of Wexford; when men at the very focus of publick illumination were to sit on the trial of Alexander Hamilton Rowan. Could such men have gone into the jury box as if they had never seen the books on which these charges had been predicated; as if they had been men dropt from another planet?—From the plains of Culloden and Wexford, from London and Dublin let us come back to our own thresholds. He who could pursue the publick prints of North America, for the last 12 months with adamantine indifference; he who could read the depositions of Eaton and Wilkinson without some interest, cannot be a man. No man could do it that has a soul, that can grace the bosom of a man. I appeal to the bench, whether there is that base frigidity of character in the inhabitant of North America.—Look at the very pannel; have they taken no impressions?—Mr. Wirt embraced a number of other points, which our limits do not permit us to detail; and in a stile of eloquence, which it is impossible for us to transfuse.

Mr. Wickham observed, that the remarks of the gentleman last up, reminded him of a Roman Epigram on a lady, who was so completely covered by the decorations which enveloped her, that she was the least part of herself. It was precisely so with the gentleman's argument. It was so perfectly enveloped in figures and graces, that the argument constituted the least part of itself; and it was only by lifting a flounce here and a furbelow there, that you could catch a glimse of it. The gentleman has hurried us to England and to the battle of Culloden, with as much ease as if he had waved the wand of a magician. He has compared the judicial decisions in that country at the period of the rebellion with the case now agitated before this court; without having attended to the natural points of distinction between them. Every man in England could reason upon the cause of the Pretender. The basis of this decision was a chain of historical facts, recorded in books, which reason could appreciate and prejudice could not distort. Such a case would have been precisely similar to the one now before the court, had this too been founded on the annals of history or on matters of fact. Had it been established that gun boats had defended the Ohio; that col. B. had had several engagements with gen. Wilkinson; and had then been brought before this court for trial; the jury would have decided upon these facts, and not upon their own prepossession. But where are the established facts in this case? The President has declared that of his guilt there can be no doubt. Yet the president is but a man and liable to deception. Gen. Wilkinson too is a witness; but his credibility may be hereafter impeached; and the supreme court has already decided that his testimony is not relative to the charge of treason. This whole tale then resolves itself into Gen. Eaton's deposition; of which though we may not be disposed to say it is untrue, we may at least assert that it is marvellous. Is this accusation then founded on historical facts? Is there a single document to support it? No; not one. How then can the gentleman pretend to institute a parrallel between this case, and the case of the rebellions of England?

If it be no disqualification for one juryman to have entertained an opinion of col. B's treasonable intentions, it can be no disqualification for 12 of them. What then would be the situation of his counsel? The jury are impannelled: their minds made up as to the treasonable designs of col. B. With what attitude could his counsel stand before such men to vindicate his innocence? Would they pretend to operate upon marble? They might as well at once abandon the cause of their client—These impressions too, respecting col. B's intentions would directly contribute to influence their judgments as to the overt acts said to have been committed. These impressions do directly bear upon the overt acts; because the intentions is the first step towards the act itself, and render it more probable that that act will be committed. What is most probable is soonest believed to be most likely to happen; and the man whose judgment is therefore made up as to the intention of col. B. cannot be said to be impartial on any one point in the cause—Let the case be supposed by 6 jurymen whose minds are decided as to the intentions; and 6 others to the overt act. How could the counsel pretend to address them on either of those points? If they wished to argue on one of them, they must abandon it; because 6 of the jury are adamant: If they turned on the other, they would meet with equal prejudice and equal resistance. It was like the case of the Abbess and the Nun recorded in Tristram Shandy; where it would be a sin for either of them to pronounce a certain word entire; but by splitting it into two pieces, they completely removed all the sin of the transaction. One of them could then articulate the Bou; and the other the ger.

As to Callender's case, had Mr. Basset concluded that Callender was the author of the libel? Had he decided upon his intentions? Or upon the guilt of publishing it? No. Did the counsel who appeared for him pretend to deny that it was a libel; or did they not rather voluntarily step forward for the sake of disputing the constitutionality of the law & the authority of the court, under which he was arraigned? Did Mr. Randolph himself, in the house of representatives deny that it was a libel? And let it be recollected, that this very decision of Judge Chase was overruled in the senate of the U. S. by a majority of 13 to 16; and yet Mr. Hay has now quoted it as law.

Mr. W. then expatiated upon Mr. Hay's definition of an impartial juryman. The sense of the majority of any country was to be considered as the criterion of impartiality and truth. What a vast saving of trouble would result from this new principle. Instead of a student's poring over the black letter in his own closet, in search of principles and tests; he need only go about to this barbacue and that horserace to take the common sense of mankind.—A lawyer would perhaps consult his McNally; or his Reeves; but Mr. Hay would go about collecting the sense of the nation. Is there then to be an appeal nominal, as there has been in France; when the French people were asked, "are you for Napoleon being king of the French?" But this argument proves too much. Were a man to declare col. B. guilty not only of a treasonable intent, but of a treasonable act, could he be considered as an impartial juryman, because he happened to coincide with the publick opinion? It is in fact impossible to know what that opinion is. Opinions are continually fluctuating: what is law under the administration of John Adams, is not so under the administration of Mr. Jefferson.

Mr. Wirt has found fault with elementary writings, and asserts that they are not always the tests of truth. It is true that they are not always so; but they are most generally so considered. Some elementary books such as lord Cocke's are of inestimable value. As to the variation which Mr. Wirt has pointed out between one of the elementary principles of Reeves and the court's decision in the case of Horne Tooke, a reference to the report of that trial would clearly show that this case had not been accurately represented to this court. Thompson, the juryman, was not in court; he had exercised the discretion of absenting himself, and it was said by way of excuse, that he had been long and intimately acquainted with the defendant. It was to this point that the judge spoke, when he said that it was no excuse. No excuse for what? not from serving

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 18 August 1807 · an extract
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 22 August 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 28 August 1807 · an extract

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report lists the venire panel of potential jurors summoned for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including their names and home counties. It details the jury selection process, including Burr's proposal to select eight jurors to avoid peremptory challenges, and an exchange with a potential juror who admitted bias against Burr.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

There were 7 absentees.

Mr. Burr then observed, that the pannel was now reduced to 40; and as it would be exceedingly disagreeable for him to exercise the privilege of making peremptory challenges to which he was en-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

This passage details the voir dire process during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with potential jurors being questioned about their prior opinions on Burr's guilt. Several jurors state they have already formed opinions against Burr based on depositions from Generals Eaton and Wilkinson and newspaper accounts, leading to debate over disqualification standards.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

John M. Sheppard. I too feel myself disqualified from passing impartially between the United States and A. Burr. From the documents that I have seen, I have believed and do still believe, that his intentions were hostile to the United States. It would be inflicting a wound on my own bosom, to be compelled to serve under my present impressions. Mr. S. observed, that considerations of a private nature had also borne upon his mind: for he had a child at home extremely sick.—Mr. Burr. Nothwithstanding Mr. Sheppard's impressions, I could rely upon his integrity and impartiality. As to his private considerations, I do not wish wantonly to wound his feelings. I must request him therefore to set down for a moment, until we shall ascertain whether we can make a jury without him.—Mr. Hay. Has the court understood the extent of Mr. Sheppard's declarations?—Chief Justice. If the prisoner's counsel wave the right of challenge, there is an end of it.

James Sheppard was then called, who made no declarations.

See moreSee less

Rueben Blakey. I have made up no opinions either way, positively on this subject.

John Fitzgerald. It is incumbent on me to state to the court, that I have formed and delivered an opinion unfavourable to col. B. My opinion has been founded upon the depositions of generals Eaton and Wilkinson, and other newspaper publications; and it is, that col. B's intentions are hostile and treasonable against the United States. On which account I am very unwilling to serve, lest I should possess that biass upon my mind which, is unbecoming a juryman. Mr. F. was requested to sit down for a few moments.

Miles Botts. From the affidavits of generals Wilkinson and Eaton, my opinion has been completely made up for several months past.—Mr. Martin. I suppose you have only taken up a prejudice, on the supposition that the facts stated were true.—Mr. Botts. I have gone as far as to declare, that col. Burr ought to be hung. Mr. Burr. Do you think that such declarations would now influence your judgment? A. Human nature is frail. Nor can I positively say. Q. Have you lately declared them? A. Within a few months. I do not feel myself a competent juryman.—Mr. Burr. It will be seen, either that I am under the necessity of taking men pre-possessed against me or of having another venire. I am unwilling to submit to the further delay of other tales, and I must therefore encounter the consequences. I will take Mr. Botts, under a belief that he will do me justice.

Four jurymen then having been selected, the three following were sworn: Messrs. James Shep-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 24 August 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The passage reproduces the formal treason indictment against Aaron Burr, alleging he assembled an armed force at Blennerhassett's Island and intended to seize New Orleans. It then describes District Attorney Hay's lengthy opening speech to the jury on the legal definition of treason and what constitutes 'levying war' against the United States.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Burr, with the multitude last mentioned, at the island aforesaid, in the said county of Wood, within the Virginia district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did array themselves in a war-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The prosecutor Hay outlines the case against Burr, alleging he sought to seize New Orleans, dismember the union, and recruited men and gathered supplies at Blennerhassett's Island. The passage then shifts to the start of witness examination, with General Eaton called and Burr objecting to the order of proceeding regarding proof of an overt act.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Island; that Burr was not there, because he had been warned not to go, although such had been his intention; that he had joined them when they had descended to the mouth of Cumberland river, that this joint force of about 100 men had then descended the river under the command of Burr and Blannerhassett to a point, perhaps Bayou Pierre, where he first understood that all his preparations had miscarried through the means of the commander in chief; his letter put into the hands of the President, and it was then that he had expressed his surprise and indignation to a certain person at having been thus betrayed.

See moreSee less

That chimerical as these projects may appear, there was only one thing wanting to their accomplishment; the co-operation of the commander in chief and of the American army, and that it was to his exertions, that the country is indebted for the dissipation of this impending storm. A short time after Mr. Hay had concluded, he was about to proceed to the examination of the witnesses; gen. Eaton was sworn; when Mr. Burr rose & objected to this order of examining the witnesses. He said, that Mr. Hay had not stated the nature of Mr. Eaton's testimony; but he presumed that it related to certain conversations at Washington.—Mr. Hay. Our object is to prove by him what is contained in his deposition. Mr. Burr.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Defense attorneys Botts, Wickham, Lee, and Martin argue the prosecution must first prove an overt act before presenting evidence of intentions or conversations. Prosecutor Wirt counters that the chronological narrative of the conspiracy should be presented first, citing legal precedent for prosecutorial discretion in evidence order.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

a part of the law of the evidence; that the court was to judge of the competency of evidence, and that it had a right to stop any evidence, which they deemed immaterial; that it was of no avail to prove intentions, before an overt act had been established; that as in a writ of ejectment it would be rediculous to begin with the boundaries before the title was proved, so it was improper to begin with the declarations of Col. Burr or with any conversations, until the overt act was shown; that these declarations could only be admitted as confirmatory evidence; that it would be peculiarly hard on any individual for his whole life to be exposed in a court, every conversation which he had held, or every inno-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

A prosecuting attorney addresses the jury in Aaron Burr's treason trial, outlining the two counts of the indictment: levying war at Blennerhassett's Island and descending the Mississippi with an armed force to seize New Orleans. He urges jurors to set aside rumors and political bias, basing their verdict solely on the evidence presented.

The Enquirer · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TREASON AGAINST THE UNITED STATES

tion to do justice between the U. S. and Aaron Burr. If after that patient investigation of the evidence which the importance of the case requires, you should doubt whether he is guilty, you must decide that he is not. Such is the language of the law and such the dictate of

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 26 August 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 5 other papers

The court establishes rules for jury accommodation, exercise, and correspondence during the Burr treason trial, then calls William Eaton to testify. Eaton states he has no knowledge of overt acts linking Burr to treason or events at Blennerhassett's Island, but claims knowledge of Burr's treasonable expressions of intent, leading to a legal debate over admissibility of evidence regarding intent.

The Enquirer · 21 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Eaton enquired whether he might be permitted to have recurrence to his notes. Ch. Justice. Were they written by yourself? Mr Eaton. They were. Mr. Wickham. At what time? Mr. E. At different times. Mr. Burr. What is the nature of them? A. They are nothing but memoranda taken from notes, which I made of the conversations between you and myself, at the times that they passed.--The court decided that they were not admissible. Mr. E. May I ask one further indulgence from the court? I have been long before the public.--Much stricture and some severity have passed upon me. May I, in stating my evidence, be permitted to make some explanations about the motives of my own conduct? Ch. Jus. Perhaps it would be more correct for the court to decide upon the propriety of the explanation, when the the particular case occurs. Some cases may require it: And if any objection is made to your explanations, then the court will decide upon it.

Mr. Eaton. Concerning any overt act, which goes to prove Aaron Burr guilty of treason, I know nothing Concerning certain transactions which are said to have happened at Blannerhassett's Island, or any agency which Aaron Burr may be supposed to have had in them, I know nothing. But concerning Col. B's expressions of treasonable intentions, I know much and it is to these that my evidence relates.--Mr. Martin. I know not, how far the court's opinion extends.--Ch. Jus. It is this: that any proof of intention formed before the act itself, if relevant to that act, may be admitted. One witness may prove the intention at one time; and another may prove it at another; so as to prove the continuance of the intention throughout the whole transaction; and therefore the proof of very remote intentions may be relevant to this particular act. Mr. Martin. I trust that when he speaks of a treasonable intention not applicable to this act, the court will stop him.

See moreSee less

Mr. Eaton. During the winter of 1805-6, I cannot be positive as to the distinct point of time, yet, during that winter, at the city of Washington, Aaron Burr signified to me that he was organizing an expedition to be moved against the Spanish Provinces on the South Western Frontiers of the U. S. I understood under the authority of the General Government. From our existing controversies with Spain, and from the tenor of the President's Communications to both Houses of Congress, a conclusion was naturally drawn, that war with that power was inevitable. I had just then returned from the coasts of Africa, and having been for many years employed on your frontiers or on a coast more barbarous and ob-

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 26 August 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 26 August 1807
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 27 August 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 28 August 1807
  • Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · 7 September 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes private conversations in which Colonel Burr detailed his western project, naming General Wilkinson, his son-in-law Alston, and a Mr. Kibby as co-conspirators with militia support near Cincinnati. The witness explains his dilemma in lacking written proof against Burr and his decision to quietly arrange Burr's removal rather than directly accuse him.

The Enquirer · 21 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[E]phraim Kibby, who I learnt was late a captain of Rangers in Wayne's army. Of Gen W. Burr said much, as I have stated: of Mr. Alston very little but enough to satisfy me that he was engaged in the project; and of Kibby he said, that he was brigade major in the vicinity of Cincinnatti (whether C. in Ohio or in Kentucky I know not,) who had much influence with the militia and had already engaged the majority of the brigade to which he belonged, who were ready to march at Mr.

See moreSee less

Burr's signal. Mr. B. talked of this revolution as a matter of right, inherent in the people and constitutional; a revolution which would rather be advantageous than detrimental to the Atlantic States: a revolution, which must eventually take place; and for the operation of which the present crisis was peculiarly favorable: that there was no energy to be dreaded in the general government, and his conversations denoted a confidence, that his arrangements were so well made that he should meet with no opposition at N. Orleans; for

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The Federal Circuit Court in Richmond opened Col. Burr's trial with Chief Justice Marshall presiding, but proceedings were repeatedly delayed due to absent witnesses and disputes over trial procedure. The venire of 48 potential jurors was called, and the court adjourned multiple times as both sides struggled to assemble witnesses.

Herald of the United States · 22 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

COL. BURR's TRIAL.

On Monday the Federal Circuit Court opened in this city.—Chief Chief Justice MARSHAL present. Col. BURR, and his counsel, and the counsel for the prosecution were also present. The names of the witnesses (no less than one hundred and four in number) were read over.—Eighteen only answered. Nearly one half the witnesses have been summoned since the last court.

See moreSee less

The names of the Petit-Jury were afterwards called, forty-eight in number, twelve of whom are from Wood County;—the others from different parts of Virginia. Mr. HAY informed the Court, that as Col. BURR had not been served with a list of the witnesses, he would propose adjourning the Court a few days for that purpose.—The Court was then adjourned to Wednesday.

WEDNESDAY, AUG. 5.

Sixteen witnesses who were not present on Monday, answered this day.

A long conversation was entered into, on the manner of proceeding on the trial.—Mr. HAY, the District Attorney, advocated the mode adopted in Great-Britain. Some of the Council for Mr. BURR did not see any necessity for a deviation from the usual manner in Virginia. The Court came to no decision on the subject, and adjourned until Friday; when it is thought the trial will commence.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report covers courtroom proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, including jury selection with jurors being sworn in and excused for cause. It also details a dispute between Burr and prosecutor Hay over a letter from General Wilkinson that Burr sought, with discussion of a potential subpoena duces tecum, plus conversation about arraigning co-defendant Blannerhasset.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 22 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

discharged.

Mr. Burr was sorry to be importunate, but he was under the necessity of mentioning once more the letter of the 21st of October. He wished to know whether the attorney had yet found it among his papers, or whether he could point out any means for obtaining it. Mr. Hay had gone through two bundles of papers transmitted him by Mr. Rodney: But he had not found it. [T]here were other papers which he was yet to examine. He had however a copy of the orginal letter.—

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. Where is this copy from? From Washington or from general Wilkinson?

Mr. Hay. It is from general Wilkinson? He has however written from the original.

Mr. Burr. I shall not accept of his

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage recounts prosecutor Hay's opening argument at Burr's treason trial, describing the recruitment of men, construction of boats, and gathering of arms and provisions at Blennerhassett's Island in 1806. It details Burr's movements down the Mississippi, his confrontation with Wilkinson's betrayal, his capitulation and later arrest, arguing that only Wilkinson's cooperation was needed to ensure the conspiracy's success.

Virginia Argus · 22 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

proved. They moved down the river to the mouth of Cumberland, where they joined Aaron Burr, and amounted to about one hundred men. They proceeded to Bayou Pierre in the vicinity of Natchez There Burr first learnt that all his schemes were frustrated by the Commander in Chief of the American Army; that General Wilkinson had communicated his traiterous letter to the President. In the neighborhood of that place he complained bitterly to a witness (who will be introduced) of the defeat of his plans by Wilkinson. He afterwards entered into a capitulation with

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report covers prosecutor Mr. Hay's closing argument defending General Wilkinson and the government against charges of conspiracy, urging the jury to judge Burr impartially despite his former high office. It also describes the trial's procedural arrangements for the jury and summarizes testimony from witnesses General Eaton, Commodore Truxton, and Peter Taylor regarding Burr's connections to Blennerhasset and activities on Blennerhasset's Island.

Virginia Argus · 22 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

justice, I trust that you will decide against Aaron Burr, if he be guilty, as soon as against the meanest individual in the community.

LATEST PROCEEDINGS IN THE TRIAL.

See moreSee less

TUESDAY, Aug. 18. Col. Edward Carrington foreman of the

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report details courtroom proceedings from the Richmond treason trial of Aaron Burr, describing testimony from witnesses including Morgan family members, Blennerhassett's associates, and Ohio residents regarding the assemblage of men at Blennerhassett's Island. The defense objects to further evidence since it was established Burr was not physically present when the alleged treasonous act occurred there.

Virginia Argus · 22 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WEDNESDAY, August 19.

Gen. John Morgan of the county of Washington, in the state of Pennsylvania,—his venerable father Col. George Morgan, and Mr. Thomas Morgan his brother, were examined, for the purpose of proving circumstances relative to the treasonable intentions of which Aaron Burr is accused. The manner in which the testimony of these three respectable gentlemen was delivered, was highly honorable to themselves, and satisfactory to the court and jury.

See moreSee less

The next witness introduced, was Jacob Allbright, whose place of residence is in the state of Ohio, about one mile from Blannerhasset's. His evidence was long, and detailed a variety of circumstances concerning the assemblage of men on the island and their departure down the river. On the same subject William Love (who had acted as a servant of Blannerhasset) was also examined. He was followed by Mr. Dudley Woodbridge, who had been Blannerhasset's partner in trade, and had kept a store on their joint account at Marietta. His testimony related partly to the same point; and was also intended so shew the connexion between Burr and Blannerhasset, the purchase of boats for the expedition, and some other circumstances. The court adjourned at 4 o'clock, P. M.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report records courtroom proceedings as potential jurors are questioned about their prior opinions on Aaron Burr's guilt, with several admitting they had already formed unfavorable views based on affidavits from Generals Eaton and Wilkinson and newspaper accounts. Burr and prosecutor Hay navigate challenges to jurors, ultimately seating several despite expressed biases as the panel is slowly assembled.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MONDAY, AUGUST 24, 1807.

and reasonable against the U. S. On which account I am very unwilling to serve, lest I should possess that bias upon my mind which is unbecoming a juryman. Mr. F. was requested to sit down for a few moments.

Miles Bott. From the affidavits of Gens. Wilkinson and Eaton, my opinion has been compleatly made up for several months past.

See moreSee less

Mr. Martin. I suppose you have only taken up a prejudice, on the supposition that the facts stated were true.

Mr. Bott. I have gone as far as to declare, that col. B. ought to be hung.

Mr. Burr. Do you think that such declarations would now influence your judgment?

A. Human nature is frail. Nor can I positively say.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A correspondent's letter from Richmond describes the progress of Aaron Burr's treason trial, detailing testimony from General Eaton and Commodore Truxtun establishing Burr's treasonous intentions and plans to invade Mexico. The writer predicts future testimony will prove the overt act of treason committed at Blennerhassett's Island.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

has proved, exclusive of the treasonable intentions of Burr, that Mexico was to be invaded, revolutionized, and converted into an independent empire.

"This is a specimen of the introductory evidence—from which it may be

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report details witness examinations over several days in Burr's treason trial, followed by defense counsel arguing that since Burr was not present on Blennerhassett's Island when the alleged treasonous act occurred, further evidence of his involvement should be inadmissible to prove treason. Lengthy arguments from Wickham and Randolph are described, with the court granting prosecution time until Monday to prepare a reply.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 24 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE TRIAL OF AARON BURR

has proved, exclusive of the treasonable intentions of Burr, that Mexico was to be invaded, revolutionized, and converted into an independent empire.

"This is a specimen of the introductory evidence—from which it may be

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A letter from Richmond dated August 10 describes the opening of Aaron Burr's trial, with Blennerhassett appearing in court under marshal's custody. The report details contentious jury selection, with potential jurors challenged for having already expressed opinions on the case.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 24 August 1807 · page 2

NEW YORK, AUG. 17.

Extract of c letter from Richmond, dat ed Monday, Aug. 10. “ The trial of Col. Burr will proba bly begin to-morrow. Various opin ions are formed. Some persons sup

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The jury had not yet been impaneled as of August 13th, with many summoned jurors set aside for having formed prior opinions. An exchange is recorded in which Burr challenged juror Hamilton Morrison after a remark about his first name being a 'terror,' using one of his 35 peremptory challenges.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 24 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR.

The Jury was not impanneled, Aug. 13th. Many of the Jurors summoned, were set aside on account of having formed an opinion. It is now stated that the trial was to commence the 20th this month.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hamilton Morrison, was asked by Mr. Burr, Have not the rumours circulated against me, excited a prejudice against me in your mind? Ans. I have no prejudices for or against you.—Afterwards he said, I am not astonished at your wishing to have me set aside—Perhaps my Christian name (Hamilton) is a sufficient terror.—Mr. Burr.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The Virginia Argus questions Erick Bollman's sincerity in claiming he had no personal motives when meeting President Jefferson regarding Aaron Burr. The piece argues Bollman's pardon was justified only because he disclosed Burr's treasonous plans and agreed to testify as state's evidence before the grand jury against Burr and his accomplices.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 25 August 1807 · page 1

What eredit does Erick Bollman de- - serve when he declares he had no per /mal motives for the interview which he requested with the President of the Us » nited States? And how mich fronger - must be Kis atrachment to Aaron Burr, thin the Uniite 1 States. when he endea~ vored toconvince the Piefitear ¢ that he would promoé the interelt ‘of the United Statesiby poing to war with ¢ Spain” (that 13, in fa&, with France, Spain, Holland and lealy,) and giving countenance to the expedition which Col.

See moreSee less

Barr had planned ? Is it poilible that so {illy a proposition as this could bave been a feriods obje& in Bollman’s view, whea he requeiled te fee the Prea fideat ? If this, and his attempt to prove that Barr was® not guilty of treason, were all that'he communicated to the President, he surely would never bhave ‘been presented with a pardon. But his important difclolures of Burr’s plans, projalts, and the means of accomplithing them, which he had not only not dif ciofed, but had aide® in carrying into eff-& 4ill he was arrested on a charge of mifprifon of treason by Gen. Wilkinson; certainly required a pardon, and the President was in duty bound to procure his testimony as (tate’s evidence (called - King’s evidence in England) against Burr amd his aeccmplices :- and as to the promise *that his communications should never be used againit himfelf,” and * that the paper should never go ont of the President’s hand.”” The former part has been strictly and faithfuily compli ed with, and the latter as fully obferva ed as the nature of the case could pofii bly admit of. For when the President granted a p:rdon to Bollman, it was ofi condition that he would - fay before the grand jury and venire, on his oath all that he had written, and was material to the convi&ion of Burr and his accom plices : but unfortunately he had made his promise before Burr was taken, and after feeing him, be had not the cour age to keep it, and had recourse to va rious quibbles and fubterfuges to avoid giving his teltimony. TFoolifhly believ ing, that fb2 refu/ed the pardon, he could not be used as a witness. And when this was his idea, i; surely was the President’s duty to furnith the aitorney with Bollman’s written teitimony, that be might make {uch use of it as the na ture of the case might require. Was the President for the preservation of Boilman’s {fmall fkeck of honor to {uffer traitors to elcape even an inditment ?

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This editorial argues that President Jefferson committed no breach of honor by exposing Bollman's and Burr's treason, dismissing Federalist complaints as groundless. It cites a letter from Federalist Congressman Griswold alleging that the whole Federal party, including Supreme Court justices, had secretly combined with Burr to undermine the government.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 25 August 1807 · page 1

Those Federalists, who are not deter mined to follow their leaders all lengths whatever, are requested to confider se riously the letter of Hon. G Grifavld, Esq, written to 7. Hatheway: Esq. and lately publithed by him. - Mr. Griswold was then (Feb 27, 1804) a Represen tative in Congress, and a leading mem ber of the Federal party. The combi nation between Burr and the Federalifls, atd the objed of it, were matters with in his personal knowledge. He declares that the plan was entered into by the whole federal party at the feat of gov ernment, inclading all of the judgefi&f the Supreme Court of the United States, before some of whom the fame Colonel Burr: is to be tried for his conduét in prosecuting his plots to embarrass, and subvert our government.

See moreSee less

This clue leads to a fatisfadtory explanation of the

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report describes the process of jury selection at Burr's treason trial in Richmond, detailing challenges to potential jurors based on expressed opinions or lack of qualifications. It also notes that Dayton, a co-conspirator, had not surrendered as rumored and had been traveling under assumed names.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ing the testimony. THURSDAY, AUG. 13. Mr. Burr having informed the Court, that he had not time to examine the new pannel ; the Court adjourned until Saturday. Mr. Hay mentioned that he had found Gen. Eaton's letter. We understand that the trial was to commence on the 20th August.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report details the ongoing jury selection (panel) process for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including challenges to jurors based on prejudice, profession, and prior opinions. Burr himself questions and challenges jurors, including one named Hamilton Morrison, and many are set aside for having already formed opinions on the case.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

he has passed in this neighborhood under various names, at one place he was called Col. Spottswood.

TUESDAY, AUG. 11.

See moreSee less

The pannel of the Jury continued. Mr. G. W. Smith excused himself as being a practising lawyer. As Mr. Burr made no objection he was excus-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report reproduces the formal grand jury indictment charging Aaron Burr with treason, detailing the alleged armed assembly at Blennerhassett's Island on December 11, 1806, and accusing him of levying war against the United States. The legalistic language describes his supposed traitorous intentions, seduction by the devil, and conspiracy to incite insurrection and rebellion against the government.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

VIRGINIA DISTRICT.

falsely, maliciously and traitorously did compass; imagine and intend to raise and levy war, insurrection and rebellion against the said U. S. and in order to fulfil and bring to effect the said traitorous compassings, imaginations and intentions of him the said A. Burr, he the said A. Burr af-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage reproduces the formal legal indictment charging Aaron Burr with treason, alleging he conspired to levy war against the United States. It describes the gathering of an armed group of over thirty persons at Blennerhassett's Island in Wood County, Virginia on December 11, 1806, as part of the alleged treasonous plot.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

guns, swords and dirks, and other warlike weapons; as well offensive as defensive, being then and there unlawfully, maliciously and traitorously assembled and gathered together, did falsely and traitorously assemble and join themselves together against the said U. S. and then and there with force and arms did falsely and traitorously and in a warlike and hostile manner, array and dispose themselves against the U. S. and then and there, that is to say, on the day and the year aforesaid, at the island aforesaid, commonly called Blannerhassett's island, in the county aforesaid of Wood, within the Virginia district and the jurisdiction of this court, in pursuance of such their traitorous intentions and purposes aforesaid, he the said Aaron Burr, with the said persons so as aforesaid, traitorously assembled and armed and arrayed in manner aforesaid, most wickedly, maliciously and traitorously did ordain, prepare and levy war against the said U.

See moreSee less

S. contrary to the duty of their said allegiance and fidelity, against the constitution, peace and dignity of the said U. S. and against the form of the act of the congress of the said U.S. in such case made and provided. And the grand inquest of the United States of America for the Virginia district, upon their oaths aforesaid, do further present, that the said Aaron Burr late of the city of New York, and state of New York, attorney at law, being an inhabitant of, and residing within the United States and owing allegiance and fidelity to the same U. States, not having the fear of god before

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The passage reproduces the formal treason indictment against Aaron Burr, alleging he traitorously assembled armed men at Blennerhassett's Island to levy war against the United States and seize New Orleans. It then reports that prosecutor George Hay rose to open the government's case to the jury.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Aaron Burr, with the multitude last mentioned at the island aforesaid, in the said county of Wood within the Virginia district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did array themselves in a warklike manner, with guns and other weapons, offensive and defensive, and did proceed from the said island down the river Ohio in the county aforesaid, within the Virginia district and within the jurisdiction of this court, on the said eleventh day of December, in the year one thousand eight hundred and six aforesaid, with the wicked and traitorous intention to descend the said river and the river Mississippi,

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 4 other papers

Commodore Thomas Truxton recounts in court testimony how Aaron Burr approached him in 1805-1806 about leaving the Navy to lead a naval expedition against Spanish territories including Havana, Cartagena, and Vera Cruz. Burr allegedly told him he planned to establish an independent government in Mexico in the event of war with Spain, claiming General Wilkinson and many officers would join the scheme.

The Enquirer · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

it would require the co-operation of a naval force. Mr. Burr observed, that might be obtained. He pursued the enquiry as to Carthagena and La Vera Cruz; what personal knowledge I had of those places, and what would be the best mode of attacking them by sea and land. I gave my opinion very freely. Mr. Burr then asked me, if I would take the command of a naval expedition. I asked him, if the Executive of the U. S. was privy to or concerned in the project. He answered me emphatically, that they were not. I asked him that question, because the executive had been charged with a knowledge of Miranda's expedition. I told Mr. Burr, that I would have nothing to do with it; that Miranda's project had been intimated to me, and that I had declined any agency in those affairs. Mr. Burr observed, that in the event of a war, he intended to establish an independent government in Mexico; that Wilkinson, the army, and many officers of the navy would join. I replied, that I could not see how any of the officers of the U. S. could join. He said that Gen. Wilkinson had projected the expedition, and that he himself had matured it; that many greater men than Wilkinson, were concerned (or would join;) and thousands to the westward.

Mr. Hay. Do you recollect, whether he said that Gen. W. had seriously joined in it? A. Yes, he said so; and many greater men.—Mr. Hay. I will ask you, sir, whether at that time, you were in the service of the U. S.? A. I was declared not to be.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. I wish not to wound your feelings, Commodore, by my question; but it is necessary to account to the jury for the application which was thus made to you by the accused. Did you not feel yourself hurt at this declaration? A. I certainly was.

Mr. Burr asked me if I would not write to Gen. Wilkinson, as he was about to dispatch two couriers to him. I told him that I had no subject to write on; and declined writing. Mr. Burr observed, that several officers would be pleased at being under my command. He spoke highly of a lieutenant Jones, and asked me, whether he had not sailed with me. I answered him that he had not; and that I could give no account of him, as I never had seen him.—Mr. Burr observed that the expedition could not fail; that the Mexicans were ripe for revolt; and that he was incapable of any thing chimerical or that could lead his friends into a dilemma. He showed me the draft of a periogue, such as plies between Powles's Hook and New-York; and asked me, whether they were adapted to the Mississippi River and the waters emptying into it. I gave my opinion that they were. He asked me whether I could get a naval constructor to make several copies of the draft. I spoke to a naval constructor; but he could not make them as soon as they were wanted, and I returned the draft. Mr. Burr told me, he wanted those boats for the conveyance of agricultural products to New-Orleans, and in

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 29 August 1807
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 29 August 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 31 August 1807
  • Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · 14 September 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A trial transcript records testimony and cross-examination of a witness (referred to as a juror/witness, possibly Commodore Truxtun) regarding conversations with Aaron Burr about western lands, a naval expedition, and plans involving Havannah and the Ouachita lands. The questioning by Hay, Burr, Wirt, and others probes the witness's knowledge of Burr's intentions and alleged promises of naval command.

The Enquirer · 25 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

make him an admiral,--Com. Truxton. Mr. Burr told me he wished to make or to see me one. I do not particularly recollect which was his expression. He said there was a formidable navy to be established.

Mr. H. From what quarter of the world was the expedition by sea to go? A. I do not know. I did not ask him, where it was to go from.

See moreSee less

Mr. H. Did you understand that you were to command the expedition by sea? A. Yes; but I declined and asked no questions particularly on the subject.

Mr. Baker. I understand you to say, that the navy was to have been erected, after the government was to be established? A. Yes.

Mr. McRae. Did he not talk of a naval expedition against Havannah? A. I told Mr. Burr that Havannah could not be taken without a naval force. He said that could be obtained

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report recounts the prosecution's opening statement at Burr's treason trial, describing how armed men gathered at Blennerhassett's Island, retreated down the Ohio and Mississippi, and were eventually joined and led by Burr near the Cumberland River. It details Burr's capitulation near Natchez, his flight, and arrest by Perkins, while outlining the legal theory that all participants in the conspiracy are guilty of treason.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

with Blannerhassett, and descended the Ohio to the mouth of Cumberland river, where Burr joined them with a small party and took the command. By this time their numbers increased to more than 100. The men under the command of Burr and Blannerhassett then descended the Mississippi, to a point called Bayou Pierre in the neighborhood of Natchez. It was here that Mr. Burr first understood that his preparations

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report argues that Burr concealed his true design from almost everyone, repeatedly delaying disclosure of his plan's purpose to followers. It praises General Wilkinson for refusing to join Burr's scheme, crediting him with preventing civil war in the West, and anticipates countering Burr's claim that his expedition was merely peaceful and agricultural.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 26 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The consequence was, that when Mr. Burr was apprehended, they were left to find their way back to their own homes in any way that they could.

Chimerical as this project may appear, there was only one single thing

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Courtroom testimony from Aaron Burr's treason trial is recorded, featuring General Eaton describing conversations in which Burr spoke of organizing a secret expedition against Spanish territories, which Eaton initially believed was sanctioned by the government. The Chief Justice also rules on the admissibility of evidence regarding Burr's prior statements of intent.

Virginia Argus · 26 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Eaton. During the winter of 1805-6. I cannot be positive as to the distinct point of time, yet, during that winter, at the city of Washington, Aaron Burr signified to me that he was organizing a secret expedi-

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

At Aaron Burr's treason trial, General Eaton testifies about conversations with Burr during the winter of 1805-1806 in Washington, describing an expedition Burr proposed against Spanish provinces. Eaton recounts his growing suspicion that Burr had ulterior motives beyond a government-sanctioned military campaign.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

yet during that winter at the city of Washington, Aaron Burr signified to me that he was organizing an expedition to be moved against the Spanish provinces on

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This passage records courtroom testimony from William Eaton's cross-examination in the Burr treason trial, covering the timing of conversations, a printed toast, and communications made to the President through the postmaster general. Burr questions Eaton about his financial dealings with the government, including a disputed claim from his Tunis agency and a recent payment of about $10,000, as well as his understanding of Miranda's expedition to Caracas.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Wm. EATON'S EVIDENCE,

by Mr. Eaton, respecting Col. B's plans —that he had seen Mr. Ely at Northampton, at the session of the court of common pleas, at a time when they had first heard of the building of boats on the Ohio. The notes on the last page in Mr. Granger's writing, and subcribed by himself, were from subsequent conversations between him and Mr. G.

Mr. Burr. You spoke of accounts with the government. Did you or the

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom testimony from General Eaton being cross-examined by Aaron Burr during his treason trial, detailing alleged plans for a western revolution and separation of states. Eaton describes Burr's purported military arrangements, references to commanders like Wilkinson, and his own decision to feign cooperation to extract information from Burr.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

to join you, & that the people also in that country were ready to co-operate. You spoke of your riflemen, your infantry, your cavalry. It was with the same view, you mentioned to me that that man (pointing to Gen. Wilkinson just behind him) was to have been the first to aid you; and from the same views you have perhaps mentioned me.

Mr. Martin objected to the witness interposing his own opinions in this manner.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. Some allowance is to be made for the feelings of a man of honor.

Mr. Eaton bowing apologised to the court for the warmth of his manner.

Mr. Burr. You spoke of my revolutionizing the western states.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report records courtroom argument in Aaron Burr's treason trial over the definition of an impartial juror, with Mr. Wirt and Mr. Wickham sparring over legal precedent and public opinion. The exchange references prior rulings, legal authorities like Coke, and a juror's past acquaintance with the defendant.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the common sense of mankind. A lawyer would perhaps consult his M'Nally, or his Reeves: but Mr. Hay would go about collecting the sense of the nation. Is there then to be an appele nominal, as there has been in France, when the French people were asked "are you for Napoleon being king of the French?" But this argument proves too much. Were a man to declare colonel Burr guilty not only of a treasonable intent,

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A witness describes conversations with Col. Burr in which Burr detailed his plans for a Mexican revolution, claiming vast resources, recruits from several states, and the backing of Gen. Wilkinson as his subordinate commander. The witness expresses skepticism about Wilkinson's loyalty to such a scheme given his high government position.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 28 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

asked him, who would command in chief. He said Gen. Wilkinson. I observed that it was singular, he should count upon Gen. Wilkinson. The distinguished command and high trust he held under government, as the commander in chief of our army; and as governour of a province, he would not be apt to put at hazzard for any precarious projects of aggrandizement. Col. Burr stated that Gen. Wilkinson balanced in the confidence of his country; that it was doubtful whether he would much longer retain the distinction and confidence he now enjoyed; and that he was prepared to secure to himself a permanency.

See moreSee less

I asked col. B. if he knew gen. Wilkinson. He said yes; and echoed the question. I told him that 12 years ago, I was at the same a captain in his wing of the legion of the U. S. his acting brigade major and aid-de-camp; and that I thought I knew him well. He asked me what I knew of gen. W. I said, I knew gen. W. would act as Lieut. to no man in existence. "You are in an error," said Mr. B. "Wilkinson will act as Lieutenant to me." From the tenor of much conversation on this subject, I was prevailed on to believe that the plan of revolution meditated by col. Burr, and communicated to me, had been concerted with gen. Wilkinson, and would have his co-operation; for Col. B. repeatedly, and very confidently expressed his belief, that the influence of gen. W. with his army, the promise of double pay and rations, the ambition of his officers, and the prospect of plunder and military atchievments, would bring the army generally into the measure. I pass over here, a conversation which took place between col. Burr and myself, respecting a central revolution, as it is decided to be irrelevant by the opinion of the bench. (Mr. Hay. You allude to a revolution for overthrowing the government at Washington and of revolutionizing the eastern states.) I was passing over that to come down to the period when I supposed he had relinquished that design, and returned to his project in the west. I was thoroughly convinced myself, that such a project was already so far organized, as to be dangerous, and that it would require an effort to suppress it. For in addition to positive assurances that col. Burr had of assistance and co-operation, he said that the vast extent of territory of the United States beyond the mountains which offered to adventurers together with a view on the mines of Mexico, would bring adherents to him from all quarters of the union. The situation in which these communications and the impressions they made upon me, placed me in, was peculiarly delicate. I had no overt act to produce against col. Burr. He had given me nothing upon paper; nor did I know of any person in the vicinity, who had received similar communications and whose testimony might support mine. He had mentioned to me none, as principally and decidedly engaged with him, but gen. Wilkinson; a Mr. Alston, who I afterwards learnt was his son-in-law; and a Mr. Ephraim Kibby, who I learnt was late a captain of Rangers in Wayne's army. Of gen. W. Burr said much, as I have stated: of Mr. Alston very little but enough to satisfy me that he was engaged in the project; & of Kibby he said, that he was brigade major in the vicinity of Cincinnatti (whether Cincinnati in Ohio or in Kentucky I know not,) who had much influence with the militia and had already engaged the majority of the brigade to which he belonged, who were ready to march at Mr. Burr's signal. Mr. Burr talked of this revolution as a matter of right, inherent in the people and constitutional? a revolution which would be rather advantageous than detrimental to the Atlantic States; a revolution, which

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers

A witness recounts advising President Jefferson that Aaron Burr was dangerous and should be removed from the country, suggesting exile to England or Madrid. The witness describes his own hesitation to accuse Burr directly, given Burr's reputation, and recalls the president's noncommittal but doubtful reaction.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 28 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

must eventually take place; and for the operation of which the present crisis was peculiarly favourable: that there was no energy to be dreaded in the general government, and his conversations denoted a confidence, that his arrangements were so well made that he should meet with no opposition at New Orleans; for the army and the ch[ie]f citizens of that place were ready to receive him. On the solitary ground upon which I stood, I was at a loss how to conduct myself, though at no loss as it respected my duty. I durst not place my lonely testimony in the balance against the weight of col. Burr's character, for by turning the tables upon me, which I thought any man capable of such a project might very conscientiously do, I should sink under that weight. I resolved therefore with myself to obtain the removal of Mr. Burr from this country, in a way honourable to him, and on this I did consult him without his knowing my motive. Accordingly I waited on the president of the United States and after a desultory conversation, in which I aimed to draw his attention to the west, I said to him (I took the liberty of suggesting to the president) that I thought col. Burr ought to be removed from the country because I considered him dangerous in it. The president asked where we should send him. I said to England or Madrid, though it has been said in some publications that I added Cadiz. The president without any positive expression (in such a matter of delicacy) seemed to think the trust too important and expressed something like doubt about the integrity of Mr. Burr. I frankly told the president that perhaps no person had stronger grounds to suspect that integrity than I had; but that I believed his pride of ambition had so predominated over his other passions, that when placed on an emine[n]ce and put on his honour, a respect to himself w[oul]d secure his fidelity. I perceived that the subject w[as] disagreeable to the president, and to bring him to my point in the shortest mode and in a manner which would point to the danger; I said to him, if col. Burr was not disposed of, we should in 18 months have an insurrection, if not a revolution on the waters of the Mississippi. The president said he had too much confidence in the information, the integrity, and attachment of the people of that country to the union, to admit any apprehensions of that kind. The circumstance of no interrogatories being made to me, I thought, imposed silence upon me at that time and place.—Here, sir, I beg indulgence to declare my motives for recommending that gentleman to a foreign mission at that time, and in the solemnity with which I stand here, I declare that col. Burr was neutral in my feelings; that it was through no attachment to him that I made that suggestion, but to avert a great national calamity which I saw approaching, to arrest a tempest which seemed lowering in the west, and to divert into a channel of usefulness those consumate talents, which were to mount "the whirlwind and direct the storm." About the time of my having waited on the president or a little before, I determined at all events to have some evidence of the uprightness of my intentions, and to fortify myself by the advice of more experienced men. I waited upon two members of the house of representatives whose friendship I had the honour long to retain, and in whose wisdom and integrity I had full faith—I am at liberty to give their names if required—and I believe a senator, but of that I am not certain. I opened to them the projects of col. Burr. They did not seem much alarmed—(Mr. Martin objected to the witness stating any of the observations of other persons to himself. After some desultory conversation, the bench supported the objection. Mr. Eaton. I did ask indulgence of the court to make such explanations, because perversions of my conduct were before the publick: but I wave this indulgence; contented with meeting these perversions as some other time and place. Chief Justice. You have used that indulgence.)

Little more passed between col. Burr and myself, relevant to this enquiry, whilst I remained at Washington, though he was solicitous to engage me in his western plans. I returned to Massachusetts; and thought no more of col. Burr or his projects, until in October last a letter was put into my hands, from M. Bellnap, to T. E. Danielson, stating that boats were building on the Ohio. Mr. Burr. Have you that letter? Mr. Eaton. No. Mr. Burr. It is improper then to state it. Mr. Hay. It is immaterial. Mr. Bellnap is here. Mr. Eaton. As to letters, I have had no correspondence with col. Burr. I was about to state that I made a communication, to the president of the United States, through the hands of the post-master general, stating the views of col. Burr.

See moreSee less

Questioned by the Prosecution. Mr. Wirt. Was there any conversation between you and the prisoner, in which you spoke of the odium attached to the name of usurper? A. That conversation was excluded by the opinion of the court, as relating to the central project.—Mr. Hay. Did you mean to state that the honourable indemnity proposed to you by the prisoner was to be included in this plan? A. I understood it to be included in the permanent rank and emolument to be assigned me; in his full confidence, that he should erect a government of which he was to be the chief.

Cross-questioned. Mr. Martin. Do you recollect when you arrived in Washington? A. I said, that I did not recollect particularly. But the principal part of these conversations must have been between the middle of February and the latter end of March. Q. Was there any particular conduct calculated to put an end to col. Burr's importunities? A. Yes. At some of our last interviews, I laid on his table, a paper containing this toast which I had given to the publick: The United States—Palsey to the brain that should plot to dismember, and leprosy to the hand that will not draw to defend our union. Q. Where was that toast drunk? A. I cannot say. This question was made to me from authority. It was sent with other toasts I had corrected, to a paper at Springfield. I laid this paper on col. Burr's table, that he might see it; and I have reason to believe that he did. Q. Was it drunk at any distant place? At Philadelphia? A. I do not recollect. I thought at first it was Philadelphia; but I had received many hospitalities throughout the union; many of my toasts were published; and in the hurry of passing and repassing, I have completely forgotten.—Mr. Burr. Do you recollect, when you left Washington? A. About the 5th or 6th April. Q. Can you not be certain where this toast was drunk? At Washington or at Philadelphia? A. I am certain it was not at Washington, because I gave another there when called upon. Q. Did you say, that all those

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 28 August 1807 · an extract
  • Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va. · 10 September 1807 · an extract

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A witness recounts traveling to Cincinnati and Lexington seeking Colonel Burr and Blannerhassett, describing an encounter with John Smith who gave him a letter, and his eventual meeting with Burr at Jourdan's in Lexington. The testimony details his warning to Burr that people would shoot him if he returned to the area, suggesting this is testimony given during legal proceedings related to the conspiracy.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 28 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

derstanding between them about the Mexican project. Mr. Burr. Are there not preparations now making in Philadelphia, in contemplation of a war with England? A. In New York there are. Mr. McRae. Are not the preparations going on openly? Has any commander been appointed independent of the government? A. No. Mr. Botts. Can ships be built secretly in a corner of a room? A. No.

Examination of Peter Taylor.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. This witness will directly prove the connection of Burr with Blannerhassett, and his connection with the crime itself.

Peter Taylor—The first information I had upon this subject was from Mrs. Blannerhassett, when Mr. Blannerhasset and Mr. Alston were gone down the river. The people got much alarmed concerning this business, and Mrs. Blannerhassett sent me to Lexington after Mr. Blannerhassett, with a letter to prevent col. Burr from coming back with him to the island. I went to Chillicothe, but I did not find Mr. Blannerhassett there, and I then went on to Cincinnatti. I was directed to call at Cincinnatti at Mr. John Smith's, where I would find Mr. Blannerhassett. I called at Mr. Smith's store, where I saw his son. I asked if Mr. Smith was at home. He said yes. I said I wanted to see him. His son went and told him, a man wanted to see him. When Mr. Smith came out, I enquired for col. Burr and Blannerhassett, to see whether he could give any account of them. He allowed he knew nothing of either of them. He allowed I was much mistaken in the place. I said, no; this was the right place: "Mr. John Smith, store-keeper, Cincinnatti:" says I, "Dont you recollect a young man who came here, some time ago for col. Burr's top-coat," (great-coat?) I said, "Sir, I have lived with Mr. Blannerhassett for three years." When Mr. Smith heard me talk so, he knew me, and took me up stairs to talk with me. He wanted to know the news our way, I told him the people had got alarmed. I told him every thing that was in agitation; that they talked about the settlement of lands. He seemed surprized. He asked what was said about general Wilkinson. I said I knew nothing about him. He asked me if I would carry a letter from him to Blannerhassett. I told him I would carry any thing so it was not too burthensome. So he sat down and wrote a letter. He asked me whether I wished to drink, for he had chastised (charged) me not to go to any tavern, lest the people should be sifting me with their questions. I drank; and then he shewed me a tavern, and told me to go, to get my horse fed by the hostler, but not to go into the house. I asked him where I should find col. Burr and Blannerhassett. He said, he expected they were at Lexington. I told him, I supposed at Mr. Jourdan's. When I got to Lexington, it was Saturday about 1 o'clock. Mr. Jourdan happened to be in the street and knew me. He said, "Peter, your old master is not in town." But he said, he expected him either that night or to-morrow early. He asked me what news, and I told him. I asked him what I was to do with my horse. He said, that he was to be put at the livery stable. He then went up stairs, and he opened a door, and beckoned his hand, saying nothing. When I went in, there was col. Burr. Col. Burr wanted to know what was the news in our parts. I began to tell him, that my business was to prevent col. Burr going back to the island. (Q. Did you know col. Burr at that time? A. I did not. He had been on the island three times, but I did not see him.) When I told col. Burr that, says he, "I am the very man, involved in this business; and you must tell me all you know." I said, "if you come up our way, the people will shoot you." I told him, it was my sincere opinion, that it was not safe for him to come up our way. I told him that I had heard several declare, that they had rather shoot him than let it alone. He seemed surprised, that they should have such a thing in their head. I told him, I could not tell why; and then I told him about the land settlement, but the people said all that was a fib, and that he had something else in his head. Then col. Burr asked me, what letters I had. I said two, one was from Mrs. Blannerhassett, and the other from John Smith, of Cincinnatti. He asked me if he might open the letter from John Smith, for he expected it was for him. I told him I supposed it made no difference between him and Blannerhassett, and he might. He broke the seal open, and shewed me that there was a letter inclosed for himself. He asked me about my wife, and after some talking, I asked him whether I was at liberty to go down stairs. I went down and left the opened letter with him. I then went to Mr. Jourdan, and asked him whether I was to stay at his house or go to a tavern. He said I was to go to a tavern and he would pay for me. Mr. Jourdan wished me to go next day to Millersburg after the saddle-bags, left there by Mr. Blannerhassett. I went and left Mrs. Blannerhassett's letter with Mr. Jourdan, expecting Blannerhasset to get there before me. I got back on Monday by 1 o'clock; and there Mr. Blannerhassett was come and preparing to go home. We started and got ten miles that night. We stopt at a tavern. I went to see after the horses, and he went into the house. There were people in the house who wanted to know his name. He told them, his name was Tom Jones. He came out and told me, the people in the house had asked and he had told them his name was Tom Jones, and I must mind and make no mistake, but call him Tom Jones too. So he passed by that name until we got to the Mudlick's. He then told me he was known there, and I must call him by his own name. (Q. When did these things happen? A. All this was in October, 1806, I believe.) He then began to enquire for young men, that had rifles; good orderly men, that would be conformable to order and discipline. He allowed that col. Burr and he and a few of his friends had bought 800,000 acres of land, and they wanted young men to settle it.—He said, he would give any young man who would go down the river, 100 acres of land, plenty of grog and victuals while going down the river, and three months provisions after they had got to the end; every young man was to carry his rifle and blanket. I agreed to go myself if I could carry my wife and family, but he said he must have further consultation upon that. When I got home I began to think, and asked him, what kind of seed we should carry with us? He said, we did not want any. (Mr. Wirt: Of what occupation were you on the island. A. A gardener. Mr. Wirt. I put this question that the jury might understand his last observation.)—I urged that subject to him several times; at last he made a sudden pause, and said "Peter, we are going to take Mexico; one of the finest and richest places in the whole world." He said that col. Burr would be the king of Mexico, and Mrs. Alston was

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Thomas Morgan testifies about a dinner conversation in which Aaron Burr allegedly discussed separating the western states from the Atlantic states and boasted that a small force could take New York or drive Congress into the Potomac. The testimony recounts Burr's confident remarks and a tense exchange with Morgan's brother.

The Enquirer · 28 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR, (CONTINUED BY ADJOURNMENT, AND HELD AT THE CAPITOL IN THE HALL OF THE HOUSE OF DELEGATES.) FOR HIGH TREASON AGAINST THE UNITED STATES.

THOMAS MORGAN. On the evening of the 21ft of Auguft, my father received a letter from Pittfburg, by the hands of fome perfon, the fignature of which was Aaron Burr. In that letter the writer communicated his intention of dining with my father on the following day: he alfo mentioned that he fhould take the liberty of introducing a friend. My father requefted my brother and myfelf to meet him, which we accordingly did. Nothing of importance occurred during our ride in my prefence. Col. Burr was generally with my brother.

See moreSee less

Col. Dupiefter was often with myfelf: and fometimes we were promifcuoufly together. Whilft we were at dinner, Col. B. emphatically, as I thought, confidently and earneftly faid, that we (meaning the people of the weft,) would be feparated in five years from the Atlantic ftates; the Alleghany mountain to be the line of divifion. He faid that great numbers were not neceffary to execute great military deeds; all that was wanting, was a leader, in whom they could place confidence, and who they believed could carry them through. This converfation occurred during dinner. He faid that with 500 men, New-York could be taken; and that with 200, Congrefs could be driven into the Potomac. To the laft obfervation, my brother, I think indignantly replied, "By God! Sir, with that number you cannot take our little town of Cannonfburg."—Col. Burr's reply to this obfervation was, "Confine yourfelf to this fide of the mountain, and I'll not con

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage records courtroom testimony from Burr's treason trial, including cross-examination of a witness named Morgan about conversations with Burr regarding military expeditions and talents under the government. It also includes the examination of Jacob Allbright, who describes being hired at Blennerhassett's Island and being asked by Blennerhassett to join an expedition down the river to 'settle a new country.'

The Enquirer · 28 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

that he had much rather be at the head of a military Corps.--Mr. Morgan then proposed to state the steps which his father had taken to defeat A. Burr's projects, when he was stopped by the court.

Cross-Examined.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. Had you ever spoken to me before? A. Never. Q. Did you not mention, with some complaints, the neglect which your education had received? A. No. Q. Did you not complain about wasting your time? A. I recollect nothing on that subject, but your remark, that I could not surely find employment for either body or mind.

Examination of Jacob Allbright.

Mr. Hay. Our object is to prove by his testimony the actual assemblage of men on Blannerhassett's Island. It goes of course to prove directly the overt act.

Jacob Allbright. The first I knew of this business was; I was hired on the Island to help to build a Kiln for drying corn; and after working some time, Mrs. Blannerhassett told me, that Mr. Blannerhassett and Col. Burr were going to lay in provisions for an army for a year. I went to the mill, where I carri

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes being approached by men associated with Blennerhassett and Burr to join an expedition down the river, with promises of payment and talk of settling a new country. He recounts visiting the island, encountering armed men, and dealing with Blennerhassett's banknotes.

The Enquirer · 28 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

I had not given my consent to go along with Blannerhassett down the river. As we were talking together, they named themselves Col. Burr's men, belonging to the boats, landed at the island. When they asked me, whether I had not consented to go

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

The court convened for Burr's treason trial, excusing Dr. Washington and Randolph Harrison due to illness, and dealing with procedural matters regarding Herman Blennerhassett's arraignment. The jury panel was called over and witnesses were examined regarding qualifications of the venire, with several jurors excused for illness.

Herald of the United States · 29 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

HORNE. Mr. Wirt moved the court to discharge Dr. Wardlaw, one of the Venire. His wife was in extreme danger, and required the assistance of a voyage. The vessel would sail to-morrow. Chief Justice.—Is the court to understand that there is no objection to this measure?—Mr. Burr.—If the remark be addressed to me, sir, I can only say, that I shall remain passive during the transaction. Dr. Wardlaw was then dismissed. Mr. M'Rae also moved the discharge of Mr. Randolph Harrison, whose extreme indisposition was attested by a certificate from Dr. Adams.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

This report details the voir dire process for seating an impartial jury in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with several potential jurors challenged and dismissed for having formed opinions on his guilt. The petit jury is finally impaneled on Monday the 17th, and the indictment charging Burr with treason is read in court.

Herald of the United States · 29 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

have heard, that Col. B. deserved to be [h]ung.

—A. I did. Q. Did you believe these rumors? A. I did. Q. Would you, if you were a juryman, form your opinion upon such rumors? A. Certainly not. Mr. M'Ra[e].—Did you form and express your opinion upon the question, whether an overt act of treason had been committed at Blannerhasset's island? A. It was upon other rumors; and not upon that, that I had formed an opinion.—Mr. Martin submitted it to the court, whether he could be considered as an impartial juryman. The court decided that Mr. Bucky be put aside.

See moreSee less

2. James G. Laidley stated, that he had formed and expressed some opinions unfavourable to Col. B. that he could not pretend to decide upon the charges in the indictment, which he had not heard; that he had principally taken his opinions from newspaper statements; and that he had not, as far as he recollected, expressed an opinion, that Col. B. deserved hanging.—Mr. Laidley put aside.

3. James Hamilton being challenged for cause and sworn, stated that he had formed and expressed an opinion from hearing him say, that Col. B. was guilty of treason, and in that particular line of treason, in which Col. B. stood charged, as far as he understood. Put aside.

Mr. Burr observed, that as gentlemen on the part of the prosecution had expressed a willingness to have an impartial jury, they could not refuse that any juryman should state all his objections to himself; and that he had no doubt, in spite of the contrary assertions which had been made, that they could get a jury from this pannel.

On Monday the 17th inst. the petit jury for the trial of Aaron Burr was impannelled. The following are their names.

Edward Carrington, Reuben Blakey, David Lambert, Benjamin Graves, Richard E. Parker, Miles Bott, Hugh Mercer, Henry Coleman, Christopher Anthony, John M. Sheppard, James Sheppard, Richard Curd.

See the clipping

Herald of the United States · Warren, R.I.

This passage reproduces the formal indictment against Aaron Burr, alleging that on December 10, 1806, he assembled over 50 armed men at Blennerhassett's Island in Wood County, Virginia, with traitorous intent to levy war against the United States. The legal document uses standard treason-charge language accusing Burr of being moved by 'the instigation of the Devil' to incite insurrection and rebellion.

Herald of the United States · 29 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

VIRGINIA DISTRICT.

the said AARON BURR, as the said AARON BURR afterwards, to wit; on the said tenth day of December, in the year one thousand eight hundred and six aforesaid, at the said Island, called BLANNERHASSETT's Island as aforesaid, in the county of Wood aforesaid, in

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage records direct testimony and cross-examination during Aaron Burr's treason trial, including witnesses discussing conversations about Burr's western land speculations, the Ouachita lands, and plans for a naval expedition possibly against Havana. Witnesses are questioned by prosecutor Hay and others about specific statements Burr made regarding admiralties, naval commands, and his intentions.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 29 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

publication upon the subject. A. I did— Q. Your first conversation was about building bridges, settling lands &c? A. Yes; when col. Burr first returned from the westward.

Mr. McRae. He did not express to you his designs respecting the Ouachita land, till he had discovered your aversion to the Mexican project? A. He h[a]d not spoken particularly about the Ouachita lands, but previously about speculations in western lands generally.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wirt. Did he say at the latter end of July that he was about concluding a

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage records courtroom testimony from Burr's treason trial, including cross-examination about couriers sent to General Wilkinson and preparations possibly related to a 'Mexican project.' Witness Peter Taylor describes being sent to find Burr after Blennerhassett and Mrs. Alston left the island, and recounts conversations with John Smith in Cincinnati about Burr's whereabouts and letters to Blennerhassett.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 29 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. M'Rae. Are not the preparations going on openly? Has any commander been appointed independent of the government? A. No.

Mr. Botts. Can ships be built secretly in a corner of a room? A. No.

See moreSee less

Examination of Peter Taylor.

Mr. Hay. The witness will directly prove the connection of Burr with Blannerhasset, and his connection with the crime itself.

Peter Taylor. The first information I had upon this subject was from Mrs. Bl. when Mr. Blannerhasset and Mr. Alston were gone down the river. The people got much alarmed about this business, and Mrs. Blannerhassett sent me to Lexington after Mr. Bl. with a letter to prevent col. Burr from coming back with him to the island. I went to Chilicothee but did not find Mr. Bl. there, and I then went on to Cincinnati. I was directed to call at Cincinnati at Mr. John Smith's where I would find Mr. Blannerhasset. I called at Mr. Smith's where I saw his son. I asked if Mr. Smith was at home, he said yes. I said I wanted to see him. His son went and told him a man wanted to see him. When Mr. S. came out I inquired for col. Burr and Blannerhasset, to see whether he could give any account of them. He allowed he knew nothing of either of them. He allowed I was much mistaken in the place. I said no; this was the right place. "Mr. John Smith store-keeper Cincinnati," says I. Dont you recollect a young man, who came here some time ago for col. Burr's top coat (great coat?) I said, sir I have lived with Mr. Blannerhassett

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes conversations with Aaron Burr about plans to establish an independent government in Mexico, General Wilkinson's involvement, and preparations including boat designs for river transport. The testimony, given under examination by Mr. Hay, details Burr's confidence in the scheme and his contingency plans involving the Washita lands if war with Spain did not occur.

Virginia Argus · 29 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

his establishing an independent empire in Mexico? A. I so understood it. Mr. M‘Rae. Did he speak of any commercial speculations in which he was about to engage; of any commercial establishments he was about to form? A. He spoke of the settlement of the Ouachita; and the bringing down of agricultural produce.

Q. Were the remarks which he made on your relation to the navy, calculated to fill your bosom with resentment? A. My bosom was already full enough, but certainly Mr. Burr spoke in concert with my feelings.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. Could an expedition at sea be made as effectually against La Vera Cruz from any other port in the western country, as New Orleans? A. New Orleans would be a proper place for preparing an armament; but no vessel of bur-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage records courtroom argument in Aaron Burr's treason trial, debating whether a man must be personally present to 'levy war' against the United States. Counsel M'Rae reviews testimony from Eaton, Truxton, and others, and outlines evidence suggesting Burr directed armed men to Blennerhassett's Island and later ordered concealment of boats, arguing this proves treason.

Virginia Argus · 29 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

troduce the evidence if permitted; and Col. Burr and his counsel objecting to the evidence being admitted and insisting that nothing should be said concerning it. But the Chief Justice said that Mr. M'Rae had a right to suppose the existence of any evidence which could by possibility be adduced to prove the prisoner guilty, as the motion was to exclude all evidence. Mr. M'Rae proceeded—can any person doubt, after hearing the testimony of Gen. Eaton, Commodore Truxton, and the Morgans, the treasonable intentions of the prisoner. The credibility of all those witnesses is unimpeached; and Eaton's evidence is immediately to the point.

See moreSee less

[Here Mr. M'Rae took a review of the evidence which had been introduced.] Suppose, in addition to all this, we can prove that the men who came to Blannerhasset's island came thither by Aaron Burr's direction; that he was waiting for them at the mouth of Cum-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A prosecutor (MacRae) argues that Burr's actions constitute treason under English legal precedent, countering defense counsel Wickham and Randolph's use of Throckmorton's case. He contrasts the harsh treatment of Throckmorton with the many legal advantages and freedoms afforded to Burr during his trial.

Virginia Argus · 29 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

[n]ear the situation and treatment of Aaron Burr during this trial has been from Throckmorton's before the commissioners who tried him; and to demonstrate that that case has nothing to do with this. Mr. M'Rae then read a large part of Throckmorton's case; from which it appeared that no counsel was allowed him; books were withheld from him; he was not listened to by the court; and confessions of others were read as evidence against him without proof of his connexion with them. He strongly contrasted with those tyrannical proceedings, the advantages which Aaron Burr had enjoyed during this prosecution.

See moreSee less

Whereas Throckmorton had no counsel, Aaron Burr has six, most able and learned in the law; one of whom is attorney general of Maryland, another has been attorney general of the United States; a third for many years filled the same office in Virginia, and the prisoner him-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness testifies about Burr's conversations regarding military affairs, insurrection plans, and Bradford's leadership capabilities. Cross-examination covers letters, timing of visits, and what Burr knew about the insurrection beforehand.

Virginia Argus · 29 August 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

[Continued from 1st page.] Questioned by the prosecution. Mr. Hay. Which way did he go ? A. I saw him leave Washington for Wheeling Mr. Wirt. Were the separation of the union and military affairs subjects frequently introduced in Burr's conversations ? A.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This passage records courtroom testimony during Aaron Burr's treason trial, including cross-examination of a witness about conversations regarding Bradford and the insurrection, followed by the examination of Col. George Morgan. Objections are raised by Burr's counsel about the admissibility of conversational evidence, with the chief justice and prosecutor Hay debating how to proceed.

Virginia Argus · 29 August 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

COL. MORAN, (the father of the last witness)—There has been a long acquaintance between col Burr and myself: He had introduced to my notice two of his nephews by the name of —— and a third by the name of Edwards, Pierrepont Edwards. I had received many civilities from colonel Burr in New York, after these things had passed: from which I had formed such an attachment to him, that I never should have forgotten it, had not this late business taken place. About three years ago, colonel Burr was under considerable, and as I thought unjust persecution.

See moreSee less

I had then a younger son, who is now here, studying law at Pittsburg. I wished to make him known to col Burr, and wrote a letter to invite col Burr to Morgansey; particularly on account of his persecution; but, in all probability, would have done so without.—I inclosed the letter to my son at Pittsburg. Col Burr however had left Pittsburg, before my letter reached it, and it remains now in my son's Scrutoire at Pittsburg.—On the 24th last August, I received a letter from Col Burr dated at Pittsburg, informing me, that he should dine with me next day. (Here Mr Hay handed the letter to Col M. who said that the letter was dated on the 21st, & that he had not for some time seen it, as he had transmitted it to the President of U. S.) This letter was handed to me by a man, who called himself Count Willie. Col Burr mentioned he had sent it by one of his attendants. I believe my son did not call on me that evening; but the next morning I informed him, if I was able, I should certainly go and meet Col B; and I requested him and his brother to do it, with a letter of introduction explanatory of their names and their intention. What conversation took place between him and my son, I shall not state. When Col Burr and

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report covers courtroom testimony from Commodore Thomas Truxtun during Aaron Burr's treason trial. Truxtun describes conversations with Burr about western land speculation and a secret venture Burr wished to disclose, while lawyers dispute how his testimony relates to the treason versus misdemeanor charges.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 31 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

the court delivered their opinion?

A. I was. I know nothing of the overt act.

See moreSee less

Q. Does your testimony relate to the taking of New Orleans?

A. I know nothing about the taking of New Orlean. My conversations altogether related to the Spanish territories; to the settlement of lands; to digging a canal on the Ohio, and building of boats.

Mr. Hay then observed, that he had no questions then at present for Commodore Truxton.

Mr. Wickham. Then, sir, I hope I may be permitted to ask Commodore Truxton, 1st. whether he had not many and minute conversations with Col. Burr, and 2dly, whether these conversations related to treason.

Mr. Wirt. The court knows that there are two indictments against the accused. The witnesses have been summoned promiscuously; and it is not possible for the prosecutor to know the particular point to which every witness is to testify. Commodore Truxton says that his evidence relates to the misdemeanor. But if he be suffered to come in on the present case, ought not his examination to be free and complete?

Mr. Hay. Upon recollecting the

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A naval commodore testifies about conversations with Aaron Burr beginning in 1805-6, in which Burr proposed a naval expedition against Spanish territories and hinted at establishing an independent government in Mexico. The witness recounts Burr's claims that General Wilkinson and many army officers would join the scheme, and describes his own refusal to participate.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 31 August 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

AARON BURR,

get me interested in land speculations. These conversations were frequently repeated; and some time in the month of July, 1806, he stated, that he wished to see me unwedded from the navy of the U. S. and to think no more of those men at Washington; that he wished to see or to make me (I do not recollect which) an admiral, as he contemplated an expedition into Mexico, in the event of a war with Spain, which he thought inevitable. He asked me if the Havanna could not be easily taken in the event of a war.

See moreSee less

I told him that it would require the co-operation of a naval force. Mr Burr observed, that might be obtained. He pursued the enquiry as to Carthagena and La Vera Cruz; what personal knowledge I had of those places, and what would be the best

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A trial witness recounts conversations with Aaron Burr, including Burr's comments about raising troops, seizing the President and Congress, and taking New York City. The witness describes warning his father to alert the President based on these suspicious remarks.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 31 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

turn. He said he should like to see my brother George at the head of a corps of Granadiers; he was a fine, stout looking fellow. These circumstances induced me to speak to my father: I warned him to beware of Col. Burr, told him, that in course of that night col. Burr would attempt to have an interview with him, and would make a requisition of my brother Tom, to go with him; and that I suspected something was going on. The next morning I rode with Col. Burr to the town of Washington, about 9 or 10 miles.

See moreSee less

We had some conversation principally on military affairs; on the state of the militia, the necessity of attending to military discipline. He told me, that in New York the militia were in good order, which was brought about by the influence and exertions of a single individual (Mr. Swartwout) Col. Burr asked me, if I thought I could raise a regiment in Washington county, or whether I could raise one with more ease in New Jersey

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The report describes jury selection at Burr's treason trial, including challenges, dismissals, and examinations of potential jurors for bias based on prior newspaper-influenced opinions. Burr personally questions jurors about prejudice, accepting some despite admitted negative views, while the Chief Justice adjourns proceedings until Monday with instructions against outside communication.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 31 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF MR. BURR.

Three of the Jurymen on the second venire, were discharged; and substitutes ordered. The venire, consisting 48 was called over seven were absent.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr declared it would be exceedingly disagreeable for him to exercise his right of challenge, and said he would select eight out of the whole venire, who might be sworn. Mr. Hay making no objection, the eight were placed at the head of the venire. Mr. W. S. Smith, one of the eight was excused on account of indisposition. The other jurymen were called, and examined, whether they were conscious of any cause which should disqualify them. They had principally made declarations on the subject; but they were not considered as sufficient to suspend them. Mr. Miles Boots, was examined.--He said he had gone so far as to declare, on newspaper publications, that Colonel Burr ought to be hung. Mr. Burr said, "It will be seen either that I am under the necessity of taking men prepossessed against me, or of having another venire. I am unwilling to submit to the former delay of other tales, and must therefore encounter the consequences. I will take Mr. Boots under a belief that he will do me justice." Mr. Henry Coleman said he had considered Col. Burr's conduct as inimical to the

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The passage describes jury selection for Aaron Burr's treason trial, including exchanges over potential jurors' prejudices, followed by the trial's commencement with the indictment read and opening arguments by prosecutor Hay. A procedural dispute arose over whether the prosecution must first prove an overt act before presenting prior conversations as evidence.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 31 August 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MONDAY, AUG. 17.

TUESDAY, AUG. 18. The Court decided, that Mr. Hay might pursue his own judgment; and the court will arrest any irrevelent evidence. The trial proceeded. The principal part of the jurymen set aside, declared, that they had frequently expressed for opinion that Mr. Burr was guilty and ought to be hung.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The passage records courtroom proceedings from Aaron Burr's treason trial, including objections over the admissibility of Col. George Morgan's testimony about conversations and prior declarations. Morgan then testifies about his long acquaintance with Burr and events from three years prior, including introductions to his sons and nephews.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 31 August 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

(The examination on Wednesday, Aug. 19, continued.) Examination of Col. George Morgan. Col. Morgan was proceeding, when Mr. Burr objected to this kind of evidence, consisting of conversations and previous declarations. Some desultory conversation ensued upon this point, when t[he]

See the clipping