As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

September 1807

158 articles

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The petit jury is sworn in for Aaron Burr's treason trial, and the indictment is read aloud. Prosecutor Hay opens with a two-hour speech, but defense counsel objects to calling witnesses before the overt act of treason is proven, leading to a lengthy argument and a court ruling allowing prosecution discretion.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 1 September 1807 · page 2

BURR'S TRIAL, RICHMOND, MONDAY, AUG. 17.

Hugh Mercer, | Henry Goleman, Chriftopber Anthony, l Fobn M. Shepard, Fames Skepbard, Richard Curd, Aaron Burr, was then called, 'who standing up, the trial commenced by teading the indi®uaent, which'is long, and charges him with treason. Mr. Hay then opened the case on the part of the prosecution, in a speech of two: honrs. He then _caligd _his’

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

This report covers proceedings in the Burr treason trial over several days, including arguments about whether the overt act of treason must be proven before other testimony is admitted. The Chief Justice ruled on the scope of admissible evidence, witnesses including Gen. Eaton and Commodore Truxton testified, and Burr himself objected to irrelevant testimony being introduced.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 1 September 1807 · page 2

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST, IQ. Gen. Morgan,Col. Morgan, Thom as Morgan, Jacob Alright, William Love, (hostler to Blannerhaflet) and Dudley Woodbridge. lln the course of the examination Col. Burr remark

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report describes a day of pointed legal argument at Burr's Richmond trial, including Burr's objections to court principles and procedures. It sharply criticizes his counsel Luther Martin for alleged insolence and vulgar accusations against the prosecution.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 1 September 1807 · page 2

- The infclence and vulgaritzfif Lu ther Martin, one of his counsel, mu(t be disgusting in the extreme to every man poflefled of common ideas of de corumHe indulges himfelf in the molt unqualified abuse of govern ment, at every opportunity. His as sertion, in o@ court, that the coun sel for the US. w}&d to deprive Col. Burr of a fair trial, and to bang him up, togratify the wifbes of the gro ‘ernment, Was such as was never ‘toler

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage records cross-examination testimony regarding conversations about Bradford and an insurrection, followed by Col. George Morgan's testimony about his acquaintance with Burr. Attorneys debate the admissibility of evidence concerning prior conversations and declarations, with the court reserving judgment on objections.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 September 1807 · page 2

; Col. Morgao. (.hc sasizher of the last ( witness.) The-Ye has bccpalrct-cg acquaim. faace þctwccn col. er and myself. He had introduced to my nonce two of his ocphewa by the name of -——, and a third by the: name ofEdwards, Pic-rrcpsmc EJ. wards-. ( had receive;-;! mziuy c'visili. tisses from col. Burr in New ank, after

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

After 25 minutes of deliberation, the jury foreman reported that Aaron Burr was not proved guilty under the indictment by the evidence submitted, resulting in a verdict of not guilty. The court also addressed Jonathan Dayton's case, discharging him from one indictment and admitting him to bail on a misdemeanor charge.

The Enquirer · 1 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

dict indorsed upon the indictment.

"We, of the Jury, find that Aaron Burris NOT proved to be GUILTY under this indictment by any evidence submitted to us. We therefore find him NOT GUILTY"

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr and his counsel objected to entering this form of the verdict on the Record.

The court at length decided, that the verdict should remain on the indictment, and that the general verdict of not guilty, should be entered on the record.

Jonathan Dayton appeared. An affidavit was exhibited to prove that he was not at Blannerhassett's island at the time charged in the indictment; and he was accordingly discharged from it. He was then admitted to bail on the indictment for the misdemeanor in the sum of 10,000 dols. A Mr. Williamson of New-Jersey and Luther Martin were his securities.

Mr. Hay informed the court that the counsel for the U. S. had not determined on the course which they should pursue; whether they should proceed to the trial of Aaron Burr on the indictment for a misdemeanor, or whether they should move the court to commit him for his trial in Kentucky, where an overt act is said to have been committed at the mouth of Cumberland River.

From the rapidity of Mr. Woodbridge's utterance, some Errata have necessarily crept into our statement of his testimony. As we wish to catch every beam of light that can be shed on this interesting trial, we think it proper to correct them, in Mr. Woodbridge's own words.

ERRATA:—First column D. Woodbridge's testimony—answer to Mr. Hay, "Col. Burr wished to give me a draft on New-York for payment, &c." Instead of which say, "I agreed to take a draft on New-York; but expressed to Mr. Blannerhassett, who handed me the draft, my dissatisfaction at the long sight on which it was drawn; viz. 90 days;" observing that the draft would not fall due until after the time in which the boats and provisions were to be delivered, and that I wished to run no hazard. Mr. Bl. with some warmth, asked me, if I doubted Col. Burr's honor, and observed, that he would relieve my fears by guaranteeing the draft.

Second column of D. W's testimony—question by Mr. Wirt. "In having these boats built, did you understand they were built for Burr or for Burr and Blannerhassett?"—Note—if this question was asked, I could have made no other answer, than that they were built for Burr.

Mr. Blannerhassett did not, as was stated, tell me the use that was to be made of the boats. In my narrative of Mr. Blannerhassett's communication to me, I am made to say, "I evaded his question, but could not avoid telling him I thought my situation better than a precarious one"—I did not evade his question, but did tell him I thought my situation better than a precarious one.

Answer to Mr. Wirt's question—instead of "his landed property cost 40,000 dollars," &c. Say the Island and improvements cost about 40 or 50,000—it would not however sell for near that sum, except to a person of a similar taste, with Mr. Blannerhassett.

Mr. Hay's question—"If delivered to Blannerhassett, would you not have considered yourself as delivering them (the boats) to one of Burr's associates?" I am made to answer "I do not know what I should have thought."—It is impossible that I should have made that answer, for I just before stated that Mr. Blannerhassett had told me he had embarked with Col. B. and I never had any reason to doubt it.

With respect to the questions generally about Mr. Blannerhassett's property, I did not speak positively. The expression from Tyler, I was positive in.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report covers courtroom proceedings in the trial of Aaron Burr, including an objection by Burr to testimony from General Morgan concerning conversations and prior declarations. Colonel Morgan (the father) then testifies about his long acquaintance with Burr and prior civilities, describing a personal relationship rather than direct evidence of treason.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Morgan (the father of the last witness.) There has been a long acquaintance between Col. Burr and myself. He had introduced to my notice two of his nephews by the name of ——, and a third by the name of Edwards, Pierrepoint Edwards.—I had received many civilities from Col. Burr in New York, after these things had

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A witness describes conversations with Aaron Burr about disunion plans and the Western states, followed by cross-examination questioning his prior statements and residence history. The testimony covers details about a 'nefarious plan,' meetings with local judges, and the witness's past time living near New Madrid in Spanish territory.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Cross Examined.

Mr. Burr. What sort of a book was the one I had in my hand? Was it bound?

See moreSee less

A. It was not so large as this; I do not recollect whether it was bound, as it would not be very polite in me to take particular notice of such things, when gentlemen are at my own house.

Q. When you spoke of a nefarious plan, to what transaction did you allude?

A. To Vigo's plan, which I conceived was intended to dissever the union.

Q. Who were present when judge Thilman saw you?

A. General Neville and judge Roberts.

Q. Was there any other from Pittsburg?

A. None.

See the clipping

In the story →

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

Aaron Burr personally cross-examines prosecution witness Allbright regarding the Blennerhassett Island incident, probing inconsistencies between his current testimony and an earlier deposition. The exchange grows contentious as Burr seeks the witness's prior affidavit to challenge his credibility, prompting objections from prosecutor Hay.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

TRIAL OF AARON BURR. (The examination on Wednesday, Aug. 19, continued.) Examination of Jacob Allbright. Mr. Hay. Our object is to prove by his testimony the actual assemblage of men on Blannerhassett's island. It goes of course to prove directly the overt act. Jacob Allbright. The first I knew of this business was; I was hired on the island to help to build a kiln for drying corn; and after working some time, Mrs. Blannerhasset told me, that Mr. Blannerhassett and col. Burr were going to lay in provisions for an army for a year.

See moreSee less

I went to the mill, where I carried the corn to be ground, after it had been dried. I worked four weeks on that business in the island.—Last fall (or in September) after Blannerhassett had come home—he had been promising me money for some time; but would pay me soon. Says he "Mr. Albright, you are a Dutchman." But he asked me first and foremost, whether I would not join with him and go down the river. I told him, I did not know what they were upon, and he said "Mr. Allbright, we are going to settle a new country." And I gave him an answer, that I would not like to leave my family. He said he did not want any families to go along with him. Then he said to me "you are a Dutchman, and a common man; and as the Dutch are apt to be scared by high men, if you'll go to New-Lancaster, where the Dutch live, and get me 30 or 40 men to go with us, I will give you as many dollars." I went home and gave him no answer upon that. In a few days after the boats came and landed at the island. The snow was about three inches deep, and I went out a hunting. I was on the Ohio side. I met two men; I knew they belonged to the boats, but I wanted to find out; and they asked me whether I had not given my consent to go along with Blannerhassett down the river. As we were talking together, they named themselves Col Burr's men, belonging to the boats, landed at the island. When they asked me, whether I had not consented to go down with Blannerhassett; I put a question to them. I told them I did not know what they were about; and one of the gentlemen told me, they were going to take a silver mine from the Spanish. I asked the gentlemen, whether they would not allow, that this would raise war with America. They replied, no. These were only a few men; and if they went with a good army, they would give it up and nothing more said about it. I had all this conversation with the two men. These men showed we what fine rifles they had; going down the river with them.—Then I went to the Island, and Blannerhassett paid me off in Kentucky notes. People however didn't like these notes, and I went over to the bank of Kenawha to change them. I got two of these notes changed; and one, a ten dollar note, was returned to my hand, for which I wished to get silver from Blannerhassett. I went to the island the day the Proclamation came out. But before I went to Blannerhassett's house I heard he was not at home, but at Marietta. I went on the Virginia side, where I met three other men, belonging to the boats, with three complete rifles. They made a call upon me, to take them to the island in my canoe, and I accepted (excepted) to it; but afterwards I carried the third man, who stood close by my canoe, over to the island. After being some time on the island, I went down to the four boats—Blannerhassett was not at home yet—and I met some of the boat-people shooting at a mark. They had a fire between the bank and boats. I waited at the house till Blannerhassett came home. He seemed very much scared. One of the men came up to ask him for something and he told him "Dont trouble me; I have trouble enough already." He went up to his chamber; and I saw no more of him. I asked an old gentleman to go up to his chamber, and change my note for silver. He did—and brought me silver. By man brought me silver. By and bye I heard that they were going to start that night.—Thinks I "I'll see the end of it." This was the night of the very day that Blannerhassett got back from Marietta. He got back before night. When night came on, I was among the men, and also in the kitchen, and saw the boat-men running bullets. One of them spoke out to the others, "Boys, let's mould as many bullets, as we can fire 12 rounds." After that, I saw no more till after 12 o'clock at night.—Then Blannerhassett came down from the chamber; and called up some of his servants; he had four or five trunks. There were not trusty hands enough to carry them to the boats; and some person called after my name, and asked me to help them: and I carried one of the trunks and moved along with them. When we got down, some person, I don't particularly know, but think it was Blannerhassett himself, asked me to stand by the trunks, till they were put in the boats. When the last of them went off, I saw men standing in a circle on the shore. I went up to them; perhaps they were five or six rods from me. The first thing I heard was, their laying plans how Blannerhassett and Comfort Tyler should get safe by Gallipolis. One Nahum Bent was called forward, and when he came, Blannerhassett asked him, whether he had not two smart horses. N. Bent answered no; he had but one. Then Blannerhassett told him to go to capt. Dennie, and get his sorrel horse; and N. Bent told him that the sorrel horse had no shoes on, and Blannerhassett said, the roads were soft and would not hurt the horse. Blannerhassett told N. Bent to meet him and C. Tyler with the horses some where about Gallipolis: Bent asked how he was to find him out: should he enquire for him? "No."—"Have you no friends there?" "No." Mrs. Blannerhassett then came forward and she told Blannerhassett and C. Tyler, that they must take a canoe and get into it before they got to Gallipolis, and sail down the stream of the Ohio; for no body would mind two people going down the stream. She said, she'd pay for the canoe. N. Bent was told to meet them above Gallipolis about day break, and then they might surround (go around) Gallipolis. Then a man by the name of Tupper, laid his hands upon Blannerhassett; and said: "Your body is in my hand in the name of the Commonwealth;" or such a word as that. As quick as Tupper made that motion, there were 7 or 8 muskets levelled down at him. Tupper looked about him, and said, "Gentlemen, I hope you will not do the like." A man next to me about two yards off, said, "I'd as lieve do it as not." Tupper then changed his speech, and said he wished him luck and safe down the river. Tupper before told Blannerhassett he should stay and stand his trial. But Blannerhassett said, no; the people in the neighbourhood were coming down next day to take him, and he would go. Next day after, I saw the Wood county militia going down—The people went off in boats that night about one. Q. All? A. All but one, who was a doctor. All had some kind of arms. Q. How many were there in all? A. About 20 or 30: I did not however count them. Every man I saw had arms. Q. At what time of the year was this? A. I do not recollect the particular time. I recollect the year; but not the month. Q. Do you recollect whether it snows in September? A. I do not recollect. Examined by the Counsel for the Prosecution. Mr. Wirt. Had you seen col. Burr on the island? A. Yes. Was he there before Blannerhassett went to Kentucky? A. He was. Q. Did you speak of the boats under the command of Tyler? A. I did. Q. Did the boats quit the island, at the time of hearing about the proclamation? A. Yes.—Mr. Burr. Did you see Peter Taylor converse with Blannerhassett that night? I do not recollect. Mr. Wirt. How long did A. Burr remain on the island? A. I do not recollect. Q. How long was he there before the departure of the boats? A. About 9 weeks. Cross Examined. Mr. Burr. Did you know gen. Tupper? A. Yes. Q. Is that the person? A. Yes. Q. When the muskets were levelled at him, did they seem to have a mind to hurt him? A. Yes: a gentleman near me said, "I'd as lieve shoot as not." You said differently on a former occasion. Don't you recollect saying before, it looked like exercising? A. I do not. A desultory conversation here ensued between the opposite counsels. Mr. Burr professed that it was his intention to degrade the witness by invalidating his credibility. The cross examination proceeded. Mr. Burr. Have you not been examined before? A. Yes. Q. By whom? By Mr. Jackson. Q. Had he not printed questions in his hand? A. he had a paper in his hand. Q. Did he set down your answers? A. Yes. Q. How long after the guns were pointed at gen. Tupper, before the men went to their boats? A. I do not recollect. Any thing that I am not certain of, I cannot speak to. Q. Was Mrs. Blannerhassett there, when the guns were pointed? A. Yes. Q. Was Tupper inside of the circle? Yes. Q. Was she too? A. I don't recoll[ect] too? A. I do'nt recollect. Q. Did you see Mr. Woodbridge there? A. I do'nt know him. Q. How long did you work with Blannerhassett? A. Six weeks. Q. At what time was it, that you saw me there? A. I do not recollect. Mr. Burr. The counsel for the U. S. know, I presume, this circumstance and have testimony to ascertain it. Mr. Hay. We have not, as I am informed. Mr. Burr. I will state that it was on the last day of August and the first of September, that I was on the island. Mr. Anthony (one of the jury). Did you see any powder? A. No. Mr. Hay. Were you in the boats? A. I was not. Mr. Burr. Where does gen. Tupper live? A. In Marietta. Q. Does he not belong to the state of Ohio? A. Yes. Q. When did you first know him? A. Last fall. Mr. Burr then asked the clerk for the statement, which he had taken of Allbright's testimony, when it was submitted to the court on a former occasion, on the motion for binding Mr. Burr in higher bail. The clerk handed him the copy, and the prisoner proceeded with the examination:—You said before, that the men who raised their muskets against gen. Tupper, were not in earnest? A. That was a piece of my opinion. I did not know whether they were not in earnest; as there was no quarrel among them, and no firing af- among them, and no firing afterwards. Mr. Burr. I beg the court to call on the prosecution for the deposition of this witness, taken before John G. Jackson. Mr. Hay. Can gentlemen, when they please, thrust their hands into my Port-Folio? Chief Justice was not satisfied, that the court had a right to call for the affidavit. Mr. Wickham said, it was obvious, that there were certain suspicions attached to the credibility of the witness; and that it was their desire to compare his present testimony with his former affidavit. Mr. Hay objected that Mr. Jackson might not have taken down the testimony of the witness in his language, but couched it in his own; hence there might be an apparent variation between the present evidence and the affidavit. Besides the witness might not have recollected a great many circumstances at that moment, which have subsequently occurred to his mind, since he was set to thinking upon them. Mr. Burr. We have a right to coerce this paper. If the gentlemen will not surrender it, I may at all events avail myself of their refusal.—My object is to prove such a diversity between the statements of the witness at different times, as may destroy all faith in his recollections. Mr. Hay. Then, sir, although I might retain this paper, the gentlemen are welcome to make all the use of it that they can. Take it. Mr. Burr then proceeded: Did you say that all in the circle had arms? A. All that I saw. Q. How many were in the circle? A. I did not count. Q. What kinds of guns had they? A. Rifles and shot-guns. Q. Did you see any guns with bayonets? A. I saw none. Q. When did you see most arms; in the day or in the night? A. I saw more of them in the day; but it was in the night that I saw most arms in their hands. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Why did you think, that most of them had arms? A. Because I was with them almost all night. In the day, I saw some of them shooting at marks; and I saw other arms at that time lying upon the beach. Mr. Wickham. Did you see them all with arms at once? A. No. Q. Did you know the gentlemen who had arms? A. No. Q. How then are you certain, that you did not see the same arms at different times in the hands of different persons? No positive answer. Mr. Burr. If gentlemen have now done with the witnesses as to the overt act, or when they have done, I will thank them to inform us; for then we shall have some considerations to offer to the court. Mr. Hay. We have other additional testimony to offer on this very point. Examination of William Love. Mr. Hay. Were you on Blannerhasset's island; A. Yes; but not there at the time when col. Tyler's boats arrived there. I was then at Marietta; and it was on Sunday that I went down in a skiff with two barrels of salt. Q. How many boats were at the island? A. Four. Q. How many men? A. I cannot tell you: but I suppose about, betwixt 20 and 25 belonging to col. Tyler's boats. Q. Did you see any arms? A. I saw the men had rifles.--I know that Mr. Blannerhassett took away with him two Blunderbusses, one pair of Horse Pistols, a pair of Pocket Pistols and a Dirk. Some fusees were put in the boat; but not more than 3 or 4. Q. And what arms had Tyler's men? A. Pistols, Dirks and Rifles they brought there; but not all were armed with Rifles. I know not whether they were armed with different things. Being as how, Mr. Blannerhassett's servant, that is his groom, I went down the river with him. Q. Did you see Taylor and Allbright there? A. I knew Peter Taylor very well and I saw Allbright. I saw Mr. Woodbridge too. Q. What time did you set sail? A. We were the last to embark; and we set off between 12 and 1. We parted with gen. Tupper in the greatest friendship Q. Did you see the prisoner on the island? A. I never saw col. Burr on the island. I first saw him at Natchez about two and an half years ago. Q. What took place after you left the island? A. That night was very cold. The next morning we stopt and made fires. Mr. Blannerhassett and col. Tyler went ashore and called the company together; and the best I could make out, was, that the governour of Ohio had uttered warrants against Mr. Blannerhassett and Tyler; and that they wanted to make their escape as fast as possible. I went down with the party to Bayon Pierre, where— Mr. Burr expressed a wish that the attention of the witness should be at present confined to the transactions on the island. Mr. Martin Gentlemen had better confine themselves to facts within the District of Virginia. When they travel beyond the District, we shall have some important questions to bring forward. We shall object the production of such evidence. Mr. Hay acquiesced for the present in this arrangement. Cross Examination. Mr. Burr. Were not some of Mr. Blannerhassett's clothes put up in the boats? A. Yes. Q. Were not his books put up in boxes and trunks? A. None; that I ever saw. Q. How long had you lived with Mr. Blannerhassett? A. Ten or twelve days. Q. How many guns had the party? A. I do not know. A great many of the men went a hunting. Q. Did you see any thing like military appearance? A. The men were in a state of preparation to defend themselves, because they expected people from the mouth of Kanawha to attack Blannerhassett and the island. And to the best of my opinion, they did not mean to be killed, without some return of the shot. It was said at Marietta, that the people of Kanawha were to attack him; and I suppose they would have done their best to resist. I should be sorry if a man slapped me on the face without returning the blow. Q. Was there no disturbance among the party on the island? A. None: I did not part with my friends in England, more comfortably than in parting with the people on the island. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Did you ever see all the men with arms? A. I cannot say. When I got to the mouth of Cumberland River I saw a chest of arms opened. Mr. Burr. Were any chests of arms put into the boats at the island? A. Not that I saw. They might have been put on board without my seeing them. Many things were put into the boats, before I got in. Mr. McRae. Was the chest which you see opened at the mouth of Cumberland, the same as those that you saw go from the island? A. No. Q. What did you think of this business? A. I understood the object of the expedition was to settle Ouachita lands. Mr. Hay. Were the persons who went from the island, young active men? A. Yes. Mr. Burr. What kind of looking men were they? A. They looked like gentlemen; such as live upon their own property. Q. Did they look like men used to work? A. they did not.--The witness added, that Mrs. Blannerhasset was at the boats when they started; and that the night was rainy and freezing. Examination of Dudley Woodbridge. Mr. Hay. Were you on the island when Blannerhassett's party left it? A. I slept there that night. Mr. Wirt. What party do you mean? A. I allude to the 4 boats, with Mr. Isreal Smith, Comfort Tyler and others. Q. Were you at the boats? A. I passed them about dusk. Q. Did you see any of the men? A. I saw 5 or 6 about the boats, and about 15 or 20 men together in one of the rooms of the house. Q. What do you conceive was the whole number? A. About 30. Q. Was it about dusk when you arrived there? A. It was. Q. Had they any arms in their hands when you saw them? A. No: I recollect no arms, but two pair of pistols on the bureau of the room where I slept; which were the room where I slept: which were gone in the morning. Mr. Hay. Will you inform us of what you know on this subject? Mr. Woodbridge. About the beginning of September or the last of August, Mr. Blannerhassett in company with col. Burr called at our compting-house at Marietta. I had been connected in commerial business with Mr. Blannerhassett for 6 or 8 years past, under the firm of Dudley Woodbridge, & Co. Mr. Blannerhassett observed, that col. Burr wished us to purchase a quantity of provisions.—Col. Burr went into the enquiry about the price of different kinds of provisions, and the expence of boats best calculated to carry those provisions up and down the river. After his making a number of enquiries and my giving him all the information that I could, he left a memorandum of such provisions as he wanted and of the boats that he wished to have built. They were to be on the Shenectady model; 10 feet wide and 50 feet long. This memorandum ordered 15 of them; but 10 only were completed. Q. What provisions were ordered? A. Pork, Flour, Whiskey, Bacon and kiln-dried meal were wanted; but no articles were to be purchased except the Pork, unless they came under certain prices. Next day I made contracts with col. Barker for building the boats, and proceeded to make arrangements for purchasing provisions. The boats were built up the Muskingum about seven miles above Marietta, and were to be brought down by the 9th of December. On the morning of the 9th, I saw 6 or 8 armed men going to take possession of the boats. I went down to Blannerhassett's island; but met Blannerhassett, Comfort Tyler, Smith and a number of men from Bel-Pre going up to take the boats; I informed them of the proceedings that morning at Marietta, and advised Blannerhassett not to go. They held a consultation and returned to the island. I returned to Marietta to get some necessary papers, and in the evening returned to the island. Mr. Hay. On what terms was the contract for the boats made? A. I made the contract for the boats with Mr. Burr. He wished to give me a draft on Ogden in New York, for payment. With this arrangement I had expressed myself dissatisfied, and Blannerhassett asked with some warmth, whether I doubted col. Burr's honour. After some altercation he consented to guarantee the draft; and to have it charged to himself, if Ogden did not pay it. The draft presented by Blannerhassett to me was payable on the 10th December. It was fi- December. It was finally paid by Mr. Ogden. Q. By the tenour of your contract, where were the boats to be delivered? At the island? A. At no particular place. But when col. Barker was bringing them down to Marietta, from about seven miles up the Muskingum; they were taken by gen. Buel as I understood, by the order of the governour of Ohio. Q. What occurrences took place on the island? A. I arrived at the island about dusk. I saw five or six men at the landing; and fifteen or twenty men in the rooms. I enquired for Mr. Blannerhassett and requested him to be told, that I had brought my papers and money to settle our accounts. After our accounts were adjusted, I wished to leave the island on that night; but Mr. Belnap turned me back. About 8 or 9 o'clock I retired to bed, where I remained; and as to what the witness says about seeing me out afterwards, he is mistaken. I was at the shore about 8 o'clock; but at Mr. Belnap's request, returned.— Mr. Wirt. In having these boats built, did you understand that they were built for Burr, or for Burr and Blannerhassett? A. It was not particularly specified. I thought there was very little distinction in the case, as Mr. Blannerhassett had secured the payment of them. As to these boats, Mr. Blannerhassett made some communication to me respecting their use. Shall I state these circumstances now to the court?--Early in September he mentioned to me that he had embarked in an enterprize with col. Burr; that gen. Eaton and some others were engaged in it. He observed, that their prospects were flattering; our first conversation lasted but a few minutes. The next week I was at the island, and he then went into further particulars; and the inference I drew from his remarks was, that his object was Mexico. I inferred it from the map which he shewed me of that part of the country, he spoke highly of that country; of its fertility and its healthiness. He asked me, if I had any disposition to join. I evaded his question; but could not forbear telling him that I thought my situation was better than a precarious one. Afterwards on his way up to Marietta he requested me to say nothing of the conversation which had taken place. Q. What articles did you furnish the prisoner? A. I purchased no other articles than pork, and this was afterwards sold by gen. Buel, as I understood by order of the government. As to the boats they were fitted up by order of the United States to convey certain troops from Marietta to St. Louis. Cross examined. Mr. Burr. Do you not recollect that I told you I had seen such boats used in the Mohawk river? and did I not complain of the clumsiness and inexperience of your ship-builders? A. You did. The boats were calculated for a shallow stream. Q. At what distance could Mr. Blannerhassett distinguish a man from a horse? ten steps? A. He is very near sighted; and when he reads, the book almost touches his nose. Q. Is he a military man? A. Not that I ever understood. Q. What became of his library? A. I understood that a part of it went down with M. Blannerhassett; the rest was left behind and perhaps sold. Q. What became of the draft on Mr. Ogden? A. It was paid; amounting to 2000 dollars. Q. How much pork did you purchase for me? A. About 100 barrels. Q. At what price? A. It was charged to you at 13 dollars. Q. What became of it? A. I had it stored in Mr. Green's cellar, adjoining to our store and it was afterwards sold by gen. Buel. Q. And when seized, whose loss did you consider it; your's or mine? The witness (smiling) I know not; it may hereafter become a dispute between us. Q. What were the boats estimated to be worth? A. The 11 boats amounted to 1200 or 1300 dollars. Mr. Martin. Were you on that evening at the water's side, in company with Mr. or Mrs. Blannerhassett? A. I was not. Mr. Wirt. You were asked, Sir, about Blannerhassett's military talents; permit me to ask you about his pecuniary resources. A. I gave him $6000 for his moiety of the profits of the stock: and there was besides about $3000 in stock. Q. What was his fortune worth? how much cash could he command? A. It was much less I think, than is generally supposed. He had $5 or 6000 in the hands of his agent at Philadelphia. His landed property on the island cost him about $50,000 a price which no man but himself or some one like him would have consented to have given. The improvements cost him about $10,000 more. Q. Had he no foreign funds? A. I think he had none. The funds which he owned abroad had been vested in the American funds. His property by his father amounted to £20,000, which he vested in 3 per cents. Exclusive of his property on the island, he was worth about $17,000 cash and 4 or 5 negroes, over and above what he owed. Mr. Wirt. Is he esteemed as a man of vigorous talents? A. He is.—It was the common opinion through the country, that he had every sort of sense but common sense. Mr. Burr. What are his favourite pursuits? A. chemistry and musick. Mr. Hay. Was not colonel Burr to have returned to the island? A. I believe so. I expected him to return in about two months, when his boats were to have been delivered. Mr. Lee. What was the size of the island? A. Blannerhassett owned 180 acres, which were about the half of it, and cost him $ 5000. Mr. Hay. Was not one of the boats fitted up for Mrs. Blannerhassett and family? A. One of the large boats was. Q. Which of the boats? A. One of the 11. Mr. Blannerhassett had taken a keel boat; belonging to the firm, up to col. Barker's, to be fitted up for the reception of his family. Col. Barker advised him to have one of the large boats fitted up; on account of its superiour accommodation. This was accordingly done. Mr. Hay. Had not the delivery of the boats been interrupted by the armed men, would not they have been delivered to Blannerhassett? A. I suppose they would have been delivered at Marietta. I considered for my own part that it would have made but little difference whether delivered to the one or the other; as Mr. Blannerhassett had guaranteed the payment. Mr. Martin. Was not the contract made by col. Burr with your firm? A. It was. Mr. Burr. Had I authorised you to deliver them to Blannerhassett? A. No. Mr. Hay. If delivered to Blannerhassett, would you not have considered yourself as delivering them to one of Burr's associates? A. I cannot say what I should have thought. Mr. Baker. Did you make any stay upon the beach, on the night of their departure? A. I did not; for I returned immediately to the house with Mr. Bellnap. Mr. Botts. Were the people peaceable on that night? A. Yes. Q. Did you hear any noise like that of war; the roaring of cannon or the rattling of small arms? A. None. Mr. Wirt. Did you hear any alarms about the militia? A. There was some in the evening. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Did you see the President's proclamation on that day? A. Not for three days after. We received it by the mail. Mr. McRae. Did you hear any thing of it before? A. I do not recollect. I believe a printer who had been at Pittsburg had bro't some information about the enterprise being stopped. The proclamation might have been sent on by a dispatch before the mail arrived.—Mr. Hay. Did you hear any thing of a state-warrant? A. No. I did hear that the legislature of Ohio was sitting with closed doors, with Mr. Graham before them; and that it was supposed they would suppress the enterprize. Q. Did you hear of any particular observations from any of the party on the island? A. I think that Comfort Tyler said, he would not resist the constituted authorities, but he had no notion of be- no notion of being stopped by a mob. Mr. Wirt. At the time he said so, was the legislature of Ohio understood to be in session with closed doors? A. It was. THURSDAY, August 20. Examination of Simeon Poole. I never was on the island on that time; but was opposite to it. I saw boats and men there; if I mistake not about the 10th December. I arrived opposite the island about dusk at the distance of about 150 or 200 yards from it. I do not know how many boats were there. I saw people walking about in the evening; and in the course of the night they built a fire, and I saw some persons by the light that appeared to be armed, and as if they were centinels. Mr. Hay. Why did you think they were? A. I don't know they were; but they appeared so to my view. I did not go over that night, nor did I offer to go. Boats were passing and repassing during the night, from the island to the mainland, which I supposed belonged to the island; not large boats but small craft. I did not speak to them.— I stood as much undiscovered as possible, as I was authorised by the governour of Ohio to apprehend Blannerhassett, and I went for that purpose. Q. Were there any indications of arrangements about a watch word? A. Yes. In the evening, I saw some boats crossed, when a particular word was given. When the people on the Ohio side wanted to go across, they would hail for a boat. The people on the island would ask, "what boat?" If the answer was I's boat, the boat immediately put off. Cross Examined. Mr. Burr. How long did you stay out that night? A. Perhaps till 10 o'clock. Q. Was it not cold enough to render a fire pleasant? A. It was. Q. Is it not usual for boats to build fires on the bank, when it is so cold? A. It is.—The witness also stated in the course of his examination, that there seemed to be a good many men on the island; that lanthorns were passing during the night between the house and boats, as if there was business between them; that he could not say, whether the persons, whom he had called centinels were not merely loitering around the fire; that he thought it likely, that if he too had used the watch-word, that the boats would have put off for him; that he he heard several hails from the Ohio side that did not give the word, and no boat came from the island, but a boat always came, when that answer was given.—He himself was on the Ohio side. Examination of Maurice P. Bellnap. Mr. Hay. Will you tell us, sir, what you saw on the island? Mr. Bellnap. On the evening of the 10th of December I was at the island of Mr. Blannerhassett. I arrived there between 8 and 9 o'clock in the evening. I hailed a boat and they asked my name. Having given it, a skiff was immediately sent over with two of Blannerhassett's servants.—Having crossed, I met with Mr. Woodbridge, who returned to the house with me. When I went into the house, I observed a number of men, who from the promiscuous view I had of them, might have been about 20. The 2 or 3 I noticed near the door had rifles, and appeared to be cleaning them. These were all the arms I saw: for I merely passed through the room where they were. Near the place where I landed, I noticed two or three boats and people about them. It was a dark evening and the lights in the boats was the only circumstance which made me notice them. When cross-examined, Mr. B. said, that he had given no watch-word, when he hailed, but only his name. He was not certain whether any person had crossed during the night. He saw Mr. Dana there, but does not know when he crossed. Examination of Edmund P. Dana. On the evening of the 10th December, I understood that the boats were to start, with Comfort Tyler and his men down the river. Two other young stood river. Two other young men and myself were determined to cross over from Bel-Pre, where I live. We went down to the landing opposite the island, about dusk; took a skiff and landed at the upper part of the landing. We then went to the house. Tyler's boats lay below our own about 7 or 8 rods. I heard some persons talking; but it was dark and I could not distinguish any one. We went into the hall, a large room, where there were a number of men; I remained but a short time and did not count them; but I suppose there were about 15 or 16: One of them was running bullets; and there was nothing but hub-bub and confusion about the large fire. I was then introduced into a chamber, where there were Tyler, Blannerhassett, Col. Smith of New-York, and several other gentlemen. I was introduced to Mr. Smith and Dr. McCastle, who had his lady there.—Col. Tyler, I had seen the day before. Mr. Coleman (a juror). Is it proper to ask any questions about the conversations which took place with those gentlemen?—Chief Justice. It is left to the consent of the accused. Mr. Burr. If any of the jury think proper, I can have no objections. The enquiry was not pressed. When cross examined, Mr. Dana said that he was ons. a perfect stranger to the people in the hall, but that on his going in they did not appear to be alarmed. FRIDAY, August 21. Examination of Israel Miller. Mr. Miller stated, that he had arrived on the island between the 7th and 10th Dec. last, in company with col. Tyler and Israel Smith; with 4 boats and 32 men, with 5 rifles and about 3 or 4 pair of pistols in all, that he knew of; that he had joined them at Beaver and gone down with them at Blannerhassett's island; and there I saw one blunderbuss, and two pair of Pistols. He saw but one man running bullets. Examination of Purley Howe. Mr. Howe stated, that he had not been on the island, during their stay; that he had been applied to by Blannerhasset to make 40 boat poles—and that on the evening of the 10th Dec. he went to the landing (Ohio side) to deliver them from his shop; that Blannerhassett had sent his flat to receive them, that the flat was left with a centinel, being two young men armed with rifles; that he flung the poles down the bank and offered to assist them; but they said they had men enough. One of his neighbours Mr. Allenwood wanted to go over in the flat; but they refused to take him, saying that they had orders to take no person from the Ohio side.—Mr. Hay. Did you see any more arms? A. None; but the two rifles in the hands of the two men. One of the centinels laid down his rifle at the bow of the boat, and stowed away the poles as handed in; while the other sat on the bow and laid his rifle on his lap.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 28 August 1807 · an extract

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Witnesses are cross-examined during Burr's treason trial about whether armed men were seen on Blennerhassett's Island and what weapons were present. William Love testifies about rifles, pistols, dirks, and blunderbusses taken by Blennerhassett and Tyler's men, while denying he ever saw Burr himself on the island.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

it was in the night that I saw most arms in their hands. Mr. Parker (a juror.) Why did you think, that most of them had arms? A. Because I was with them almost all night. In the day, I saw some of them shooting at marks; and I saw other arms at that time lying upon the beach. Mr. Wickham. Did you see them all with arms at once? A. No. Q. Did you know the gentlemen who had arms? A. No. Q. How then are you certain, that you did not see the same arms at different times in the hands of different persons?

See moreSee less

No positive answer. Mr. Burr. If gentlemen have now done with the witnesses as to the overt act, or when they have done, I will thank them to inform us; for then we shall have some considerations to offer to the court. Mr. Hay. We have other additional testimony to offer on this very point. Examination of William Love

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

A witness named Thomas Morgan recounts dining with Aaron Burr and Col. Dupiester, describing Burr's statements about separating the western states from the Atlantic states and his boasts about military conquest with few men. The testimony is part of courtroom proceedings during Burr's treason trial.

Virginia Argus · 2 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WEDNESDAY, August 19.

Examination of THOMAS MORGAN.

See moreSee less

ON the evening of the 21st of August, my father received a letter from Pittsburg, by the hands of some person, the signature of which was Aaron Burr. In that letter the writer communicated his intention of dining with my father on the following day: he also mentioned that he should take the liberty of introducing a friend. My father requested my brother and myself to meet him, which we accordingly did. Nothing of importance occurred during our ride in my presence. Col. Burr was generally with my brother. Col. Dupiester was often with myself: and sometimes we were promiscuously together. Whilst we were at dinner, Col. Burr emphatically, as I thought, confidently and earnestly said, that we (meaning the people of the west,) would be separated in five years, from the Atlantic states; the Allegany mountain to be the line of division. He said that great numbers were not necessary to execute great military deeds; all that was wanting, was a leader, in whom they could place confidence, and who they believed could carry them through. He said that with 500 men, New-York could be taken; and that with 200, Congress could be driven into the Potowmac.

To the last observation, my brother, I think indignantly replied, "By God! Sir, with that number you cannot take our little town of Cannonsburg."—Col. Burr's reply to this observation was, "Confine yourself to this side of the mountain, and I'll not contradict you," or words to that effect. Col. Burr withdrew from the room, where we dined; and on reaching the door leading into the entry, he expressed a wish by looking at me, or with a nod, manifested a wish for me to come out. I went out. When we had arrived at the back door of the entry, out of hearing of any other person, Col. Burr enquired what my pursuits were. I informed him I was studying the law. He then said, he was sure I could not find employment for either body or mind: and he said that there were, or asked, if there were not, a number of young men in Pittsburg similarly situated. He said, that under our goverment there was no encouragement for talents; that John Randolph had declared on the floor of Congress, that men of talents were dangerous to the government. He asked me, how, or whether I would like a military Expedition for Life; I cannot recollect which. My answer was, it would intirely depend upon the object or cause, for which I was to fight. I think previously or certainly soon after he said, "I wish you were on your way with me." After asking Col. Burr concerning a young man (Mr Duer) living at New Orleans, with whom I had a slight acquaintance, he said he was doing well; and he then spoke of Duer's brother, who was also doing well, as a lawyer, but that he had much rather be at the head of a military Corps.—Mr Morgan then proposed to state the steps which his father had taken to defeat Aaron Burr's projects, when he was stopped by the court. Question by Mr McRae. What did Col. Burr say after the answer which you gave to his question concerning a military expedition? A. He instantly drop'd the conversation.—I think it proper to mention that I may not have stated every thing in the order in which it occurred.

Cross-Examined.

Mr Burr. Had you ever spoken to me before? A. Never. Q. Did you not mention, with some complaints, the neglect which your education had received? A. No. Q. Did you not complain about waisting your time? A. I recollect nothing on that subject, but your remark, that I could

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 31 August 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 2 September 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Witnesses Dudley Woodbridge and others testify about the night Blennerhassett's party left the island with boats, describing the men present, arms seen, and provisions ordered by Burr. Woodbridge recounts his business dealings with Blennerhassett and Burr regarding boat construction and provisioning, and describes armed men taking possession of the boats on December 9th.

Virginia Argus · 2 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

under the firm of Dudley Woodbridge and Co. Mr Blannerhasset observed, that Col. Burr wished us to purchase a quantity of provisions. Col. Burr went into the enquiry about the price of different kinds of provisions, and the expence of boats best

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes contracting with Burr to build boats near Marietta, provisioning details, and the standoff when armed men attempted to seize the boats before Blennerhasset's men backed down. The witness also recounts being detained overnight on the island by Mr. Belknap and denies leaving his room after retiring to bed.

Virginia Argus · 2 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

in the evening returned to the island. Mr. Hay. On what terms was the contract for the boats made? A. I made the contract for the boats with Col. Burr. He wished to give me a draft on Ogden in New York, for payment. With this arrangement I had expressed myself dissatisfied, & Blannerhasset asked with some warmth, whether I doubted Col. Burr's honor. After some altercation, he consented to guarantee the draft; and to have it charged to himself, if Ogden did not pay it. The draft presented by Blannerhasset to me was payable on the tenth of December.

See moreSee less

It was finally paid by Mr Ogden. Q. By the tenor of your contract, where were the boats to be delivered? At the island? A. At no particular place. But when Col. Barker was bringing them down to Marietta, from about seven miles up the Muskingum; they were taken by Gen. Buel as I understood, by the order of the Governor of Ohio. Q. Was the contract for the boats a separate or a partnership business? A. It was on behalf of the partnership that I made the bargain with Col. Burr. Q. What occurrences took place on the island? A. I arrived at the island about dusk. I saw five or six men at the landing; and fifteen or twenty men in the rooms. I enquired for Mr. Blannerhasset and requested him to be told, that I had come to settle our accounts. After our accounts were adjusted, I wished to leave the island on that night; but Mr Belinap turned me back. About eight or nine o'clock I retired to bed, where I remained; and as to what the witness says about seeing me out afterwards, he is mistaken. I was at the shore about 8 o'clock; but at Mr Belnap's request, returned. Mr Wirt. In having these boats built, did you understand that they were built for Burr, or for Burr and Blannerhasset? A. It was not particularly specified. I thought there was very little distinction in the case, as Mr Blannerhasset had secured the payment of them. As to these boats, Mr Blannerhasset made some communications to me respecting their use. Shall I state these circumstances now to the court?—Early in September he mentioned to me that he had embarked in an enterprize with Col. Burr; that General Eaton and some others were engaged in it. He observed, that their prospects were flattering: our first conversation lasted but a few minutes. The next week I was at the island, and he then went into further particulars; and the inference I drew from his remarks was, that his object was Mexico. I inferred it from the map which he shewed me of that part of the country, he spoke highly of that country; of its fertility and its healthiness. He asked me, if I had any disposition to join. I evaded his question; said I did not understand his object; but could not forbear telling him that I thought my situation was better than a precarious one; and that I

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The jury's handwritten endorsement sparked debate over whether a verdict could be recorded in that form rather than the standard 'guilty' or 'not guilty.' The Chief Justice ruled the indorsement could remain on the indictment while a general verdict of 'not guilty' was entered on the record for Aaron Burr; General Jonathan Dayton then appeared to answer treason charges and was admitted to bail.

Virginia Argus · 2 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

on the record.

Colonel Burr said he should not move for his discharge until to-morrow. If there were any objections to his taking this course, they might be made.

See moreSee less

The counsel for the United States not being prepared to adopt any certain course with respect to the indictment against him for a misdemeanor, nothing farther was done.

General Jonathan Dayton appeared in court, to answer indictments found against him for treason and a misdemeanor.

He was admitted to give bail; and entered into a recognizance for his appearance the day after to-morrow in the sum of ten thousand dollars, with a Mr Williamson of Elizabeth Town (New Jersey) and Mr Luther Martin, his securities.

The court is to sit again on this day (Wednesday) at 12 o'clock.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A witness, William Love, testifies at Burr's treason trial about the boats, arms, and men gathered at Blennerhassett's island before departure, including cross-examination by Burr himself. Testimony covers the number of boats and guns, the warrants issued against Blannerhassett and Tyler, and preparations the men made expecting an attack from Kanawha.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

wanted to make their escape as fast as possible. I went down with the party to Bayou Pierre—where

Mr. Burr expressed a wish that the attention of the witness should be at present confined to the transactions on the island.

See moreSee less

Mr. Martin. Gentlemen had better confine themselves to facts within the district of Virginia. When they travel beyond the district, we shall have some important questions to bring forward. We shall object to the production of such evidence.

Mr. Hay acquiesced for the present in this arrangement.

Cross examined.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Witnesses testify at Burr's treason trial about the night Blennerhassett's party left the island, describing the men as gentlemen-like, armed with little more than pistols, and numbering about 30. Testimony suggests the expedition's stated purpose was to settle Ouachita lands, with preparations seemingly defensive against a feared attack from Kanawha.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A. Yes. Mr. Burr. What kind of looking men were [t]hey? A. They looked like gentlemen; such as live upon their own property.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Courtroom testimony describes the boats built for Blannerhassett's expedition, the provisions ordered, and the departure of armed men from the island in December. Witnesses recount seeing men at the boats, estimate numbers present, and describe warnings given to Blannerhassett before he joined the group.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

nerhassett for 6 or 8 years past, under the firm of Dudley Woodbridge and Co.

Mr. Blannerhassett observed, that col. Burr wished us to purchase a quantity of previsions. Col. Burr went into the enquiry about the price of different

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The jury deliberated 25 minutes and foreman Col. Carrington delivered a verdict stating Burr was not proved guilty by any evidence submitted, finding him not guilty. The court debated the verdict's wording, admitted Jonathan Dayton to bail, and prosecutor Hay indicated uncertainty whether to proceed on a misdemeanor charge or move to commit Burr for trial in Kentucky.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[illegible], and asked in the mean time the use of the written opinion, which was granted, and the court adjourned till six in the evening, at which hour the court met, but adjourned till the next morning without doing any business.

Tuesday, 11 o'clock.

See moreSee less

The court met at 10; when Mr. Hay addressed them: "I have looked into the opinion and have neither argument nor evidence to offer to the jury."

Ch. Justice. The jury may then retire—Marshal, conduct them out. The jury accordingly retired.

After an absence of 25 minutes, Col. Carrington their foreman, reported the following verdict indorsed upon the indictment.

"We, of the Jury, find that Aaron Burr is NOT proved to be GUILTY under this indictment by any evidence submitted to us. We therefore find him NOT GUILTY."

Mr. Burr and his counsel objected to entering this form of the verdict on the Record.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The jury's unusual verdict form sparked debate over whether it could stand as recorded, with Burr objecting that it exceeded the court's charge; the verdict was ultimately entered as 'not guilty' in common form. General Jonathan Dayton then appeared to answer treason charges, with his counsel arguing he was bailable based on affidavits.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 4 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr observed that he should not move for a discharge till to-morrow. If any objection should occur to that course it might now be made.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The jury returns a verdict stating Aaron Burr is 'not proved to be guilty... therefore we find him not guilty,' prompting objections from Burr and his counsel over the unusual wording. Arguments ensue between counsel and the court over whether the verdict should be recorded in this form or as a simple 'not guilty.'

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 4 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr. The charge given to the jury so far from including such matter as they have inserted in their verdict expressly excludes it. If they had delivered it ore tenus it would have been considered as mere conversation addressed to the audience, and nothing more would have been thought of it. But they had no right to deface a record of the court. Mr. Parker, one of the jury, enquired whether the indorsement on the indictment could not stand, as the jury, and the verdict be entered on the record in the common form of not guilty. If he were sent out again he should not agree to return a verdict in any other form, and if he

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Witnesses including Albright, Love, Woodbridge, Poole, Tupper, and Dana testified about the gathering of men at Blannerhassett's Island and Burr's connections to it. After it was acknowledged Burr was not present when the alleged overt act occurred, his counsel objected to further evidence, sparking a major legal debate led by Mr. Wickham over whether such evidence could convict Burr of levying war against the U.S.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 4 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THURSDAY, August 20.

Simeon Poole, Maurice B. Belknop, and Edmund B. Dana, all of whom reside in the state of Ohio, in the neighborhood of Blannerhasset's island, were examined as to the assemblage of men at that place.

See moreSee less

From all the evidence hitherto introduced it having appeared that col. Burr was not in the island at the time when the overt act of treason was charged to have been there committed; and it being acknowledged on the part of the U. S. that he was not present; col. Burr and his

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

Defense counsel argued that accessories to treason cannot be charged unless convicted as principals in the overt act, and reviewed evidence regarding events at Blannerhassett's Island. The court heard additional witnesses and granted the prosecution until Monday to prepare arguments, while scheduling Blannerhassett's arraignment for Saturday.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 4 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

pleting the evidence relative to the assemblage of men on Blannerhasset's island.

Mr. Randolph then continued the debate on the part of Col. Burr, until nearly 3 o'clock.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay then moved the court to a[djourn]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

In court, Mr. Hay moved to have Blannerhassett and Smith examined together with Burr regarding the overt act of treason, but Burr objected, arguing their cases were separate and should be heard individually. The court debated whether joint examination would cause confusion, with discussion of where the alleged treasonous assembly occurred near the mouth of the Cumberland River.

The Enquirer · 5 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

court to commit them together with the person who now stands before them indicted of a misdemeanor, in order that they may be sent to the place where the overt act was committed; if the court should be of opinion, after hearing the evidence that it would be proper to do so. For this purpose he moved that Blannerhassett and Smith be brought into court.--Col. Burr contended, that his case and that of Mr. Blannerhassett and Mr. Smith was quite separate and distinct, and that the motion could not be blended.

See moreSee less

To hear them together would tend to produce confusion. He should insist that the motion against him be taken up separately. He should also insist that there be a specification of the place where the offence is supposed to have been committed.--Mr. Hay said, he did not know that he was bound to specify the place; but he had no objection to doing it as far as was in his power. It is said that Col. Burr was at the mouth of Cumberland; there he was joined by Blannerhaffett and Smith; &

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 11 September 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 11 September 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

During Aaron Burr's treason proceedings, lawyers and the Chief Justice debate whether Burr, currently in custody on a misdemeanor charge, can be transferred to another jurisdiction for trial on a different offense. The discussion centers on procedural order—whether commitment or transmission should occur first—with Hay insisting the court can resolve the issue when it arises, while Wickham warns the maneuver could amount to persecution.

The Enquirer · 5 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Col. Burr said there could be no doubt but that there could not be a joint trial without consent of parties.

The Chief Justice mentioned a difficulty which he did not know how the court could get over. Colonel Burr was now in custody of the marshall, and bound to answer an indictment for a misdemeanor. He did not know how he could be taken out of that custody and sent to a foreign jurisdiction for trial of another offence.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. I shall make the motion to the court, and leave it to the court to decide.

Chief Justice said he did not know how he could do it.

Mr. Hay. I know how to do it. When the court is called upon to decide, and the difficulty presents itself, I will remove it. I do not expect to untie the knot, but I can cut it.

Mr. Wickham contended, that the difficulty should be removed in the first instance. Col. Burr was now in custody.

Mr. Hay observed, that it was obvious the question did not occur till the court was called upon to transmit the accused. Then the difficulty will present itself and not before.

Mr. Botts said, the subject presented two questions, one to commit, and the other to transmit to a foreign court. Which was the most regular in the order of proceedings? Surely the commitment. Suppose Col. Burr had been in custody, and bound to answer in another court—Could this court act upon him till he was discharged from his prosecution there?

Mr. Wickham, after making some observations as to the course of proceedings in this case, said, that this might be sport to the government. He would not say it was death to Col. Burr; but it was death to every individual whom the government might think

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Following the treason verdict, the court discusses whether Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith can be transferred to another court's jurisdiction for the misdemeanor charge, and whether Burr remains legally in custody. Burr himself objects to being arraigned, arguing procedural points about his status before the court.

The Enquirer · 5 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

disturb the opinions of the court; but would go on with the trial for a misdemeanor against Col. Burr.

The clerk was about to read the indictment for a misdemeanor, when he was interrupted by Col. Burr, who said he was not to be arraigned, but might plead by attorney. He said that he was not in court upon that indictment. He was only in court because he had not moved to be discharged from the first indictment. He hoped that nothing which had passed would prevent a full consideration of this subject. In this case he wished to set up certain land marks by which others might be guided, who were to follow; and he feared there would be many.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wirl enquired as to the effect of the proclamation which was made by the marshal after the jury had returned their verdict. The usual course was, (and the one which had been adopted in this case,) for the officer to make proclamation if any person "knew of any treasons, felonies, or other misdemeanors committed or done by the prisoner at the bar, "let them come forth and they shall be heard. The "prisoner at the bar stands upon his deliverance," that is, his discharge.

Mr. Hay. It was at first objected that Col. Burr was in custody, and therefore he could not be transmitted to any other court. We are now told that he is not in custody.

Mr. Botts went into a lengthy argument to prove that although Col. Burr was corporeally present, he was not legally in court. He produced a number of

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Attorneys argue before the court about whether Aaron Burr, already in custody, requires a capias or summons for the misdemeanor charge, with debate over how federal and state criminal procedure laws apply. The Chief Justice reserves judgment on precedent and adjourns the case until the next day.

The Enquirer · 5 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

mind, that if the grand jury had not found a true bill as to the treafon, it was believed that Col. Burr would have been taken with or without procefs, and fent to fome other place. He therefore gave bail as to the mifdemeanor, in order that he might be under

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Chief Justice delivered a written opinion on whether capias was the proper process for misdemeanor cases involving imprisonment, ruling that since Burr was already in custody, issuing it was unnecessary but he could be admitted to bail. After debate over the amount of bail and its potential effect on treason proceedings, the court set bail at $5000 and continued the misdemeanor trial, while Hay entered a nolle prosequi on the treason indictment against Jonathan Dayton.

Virginia Argus · 5 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LATEST PROCEEDINGS IN THE TRIAL.

WEDNESDAY, September 2.

See moreSee less

THE session of the court commenced at twelve o'clock.

Present the Chief Justice of the United States

Mr. Hay wished to know whether he correctly understood the opinion of the court delivered the day before. He had understood it to be that the transaction at Blannerhasset's island did not amount to an overt act of levying war against the United States. If so, he should not be disposed to prosecute Blannerhasset and Smith on the indictments for treason found against them here. After dismissing those indictments, he should move the court to commit, for the purpose of sending them to the state of Kentucky, where overt acts of treason could be proved upon them.

The Chief Justice. The court did not mean to give an opinion upon the act at Blannerhasset's Island, but a statement of the law, to be applied by the jury—Yet, as the jury has now been discharged, I think it proper to give the information requested; and to say it was the opinion of the court that the transaction at Blannerhasset's island was not such as constituted an overt act of levying war.

Mr. Hay. As this is the case, I shall enter a nolle prosequi upon those indictments, and wish Messrs. Blannerhasset & Smith to be brought into court, that a motion may be made against them as well as against Col. Burr.

Col. Burr observed that the motions were distinct, and ought not to be combined. He wished also the place to be specified where the treason was alledged.

Mr Hay sa'd he did not think himself bound to specify the place particularly; but would do it as well as he was able He understood that, at the mouth of Cumberland river, an overt act of treason had been committed; that Burr, Blannerhasset and Smith were all present at that place, where an armed multitude was assembled. They moved on to Bayou Pierre, certainly not decreasing, but rather continually increasing, tho' slowly, in military appearances, until they reached the last mentioned place. The court will decide after hearing the evidence, to which place the persons accused ought to be sent for trial. Mr Hay observed also that the cases of all three being nearly the same, combining the motions into one would save time: since it would prevent the necessity of repeatedly examining the witnesses.

Col. Burr. There will be no necessity of examining the same witnesses more than once, as the same court will hear their testimony; but different evidence may be adduced for one or the other of the persons accused.

Mr Botts observed that the case of Col. Burr stood on different grounds from the rest, as to many points of legal enquiry as well as evidence; that there were also different counsel employed for the other prisoners, which would render a separate argument necessary. The motions ought therefore to be separate; one examination of the witnesses will be sufficient: when that is gone thro', Mr. Hay's overt act will be a subject of ridicule even to himself.

Mr Wickham. There is another ground of objection to a joint motion. Col Burr is acquitted, and entitled to his discharge. Shall he be detained in confinement, while evidence is examined, and arguments of counsel are heard, relating only to the cases of Smith and Blannerhasset?

The Chief Justice said that the plea of acquittal presented a question of law and not of fact, and might be reserved for discussion. As to the joint motion, that is another question. The grand jury often find a joint bill of indictment against several persons charged with the same crime; tho' the trial cannot be joint without consent. But I think the motions ought to be taken up separately; and as a great portion of the testimony must bear upon all the persons accused, they must all be in court when the examination is going on. for the purpose of cross-examining the witnesses

Messrs. Blannerhasset and Smith were accordingly sent for; but before their arrival the Chief Justice suggested a difficulty to Mr Hay, arising from the pendency of the indictment for a misdemeanor It appeared to him that, while a person was in custody charged before a court with an offence, that court could not divest itself of its jurisdiction, and send him to another court to be tried for any other crime.

Mr Hay observed that after the evidence was examined, if the court should be of opinion that the prisoner ought to be committed and sent, but for that difficulty, he could then remove it, by entering a nolle prosequi on the indictment for a misdemeanor.

Messrs. Wickham and Botts contended that that question ought to be settled before the evidence was examined.

Some conversation ensued on this point.

Mr Hay said the application made to the court was to commit; but the district judge was to transmit the prisoner; that, when the motion should be made to the district judge, it would be time enough to remove the difficulty, if it should then occur.

The Chief Justice said the principal difficulty was whether he was not bound, on the motion to commit, to consider the whole question which might come before the district judge. He examined the law of congress, (1 vol. L. U. S. p. 72, § 33) which requires that if the offence is found bailable, the person accused is to be bound in a recognizance to appear before such other court of the U. S. as should have jurisdiction; and asked how this could be done when he was "in custody here," for another offence? He said too, "this court is compelled to specify in its order the court to which he is to be sent, and the district judge is bound to carry the order into effect. How can this be done while the prosecution for a misdemeanor is pending here?"

Herman Blannerhasset and Israel Smith were brought into court.

Mr Hay said he was sorry so much trouble had been occasioned; that, as the court appeared to be of opinion, that the prisoners could not be transmitted, until the indictments for misdemeanors were disposed of, he would acquiesce in that opinion, and proceed to try Aaron Burr for the misdemeanor.

The clerk was about to read the indictment, when Col Burr stopped him, and said he was not to be arraigned, but could plead by attorney; that he was not before the court as to this charge!! but was ready to make his motion for his discharge; having been acquitted of the treason.

Mr Wirt observed that the proclamation made by the officer of the court was that "if any person could inform the court of any treason, felony, or misdemeanor committed by the prisoner, &c.;" that the counsel of the U. S. now shewed cause against his discharge, by charging him upon the indictment for a misdemeanor.

Mr. Botts contended that the court was to judge whether the charge was of such a nature as to detain him in custody. He then proceeded to argue, very much at length, that a person charged with an offence less than capital is not to be retained in custody, but, in the first place, to be summoned to answer the indictment. He said that on indictments for misdemeanors, the regular course in Virginia was to issue a summons or venire facias, commanding the accused to appear; not a capias to take his body; until he should be in contempt; that it was contrary to common sense, in cases where the punishment, or conviction, is only fine and imprisonment, that imprisonment should precede the sentence. In support of this position, he cited Purcell's case in 1779, from the order book of the general court No. 36. p. 73, 79 and the cases of the Hunts for riots, ib. p. 76 and 97.—He said the laws of the several states furnished the rules of proceeding in trials, & with respect to process also in the federal courts. To prove this he cited Call's M. S. reports of cases decided in this court p. 113, 233 and 247, and the 34th sec. of the judicial act. (L. U. S. 1 vol. p. 74); Mundel's case in this court, order book A. 358 and 397—St. Clair's case, ib. 404 and 459.

He observed that Judge Chase, in the case of Callender, had awarded a capias instead of a summons; but this was done without argument, and proceeded from his not being acquainted with the law of Virginia; that his doing so was the foundation of one of the articles of impeachment against him. The Senate had indeed unanimously acquitted the judge on that article; but it did not follow that they approved of his opinion; since they might have thought, that he had acted inadvertently, and with no evil design. To shew that Judge Chase's opinion was erroneous, he quoted the argument of Mr. John Randolph one of the managers of the impeachment (Chase's trial p. 17) and cited Mr. Hay's own declarations, ib. p. 35

Mr. Hay interrupted him, and said that this conduct in Mr. Botts was unfair; that Mr. Martin had delivered on that occasion a long speech maintaining a doctrine opposite to that now contended for by Col. Burr's council, but he would scorn on the present occasion, to make use against him of what he had then said.

Mr. Botts said there was a difference between the situation of Mr. Martin and Mr. Hay. Mr. Martin was defending a person accused, and was therefore justifiable in using the best arguments he could for his client, but Mr. Hay had declared, as to himself, that he defended Callender merely as the Lawyer of the constitution; and on that occasion was giving testimony as a witness.

He proceeded to cite 2 Hawk. 402 c. 27, sec 9, that a venire facias to cause the party to appear is the proper process; the Rev. Code p. 106 sec. 28 to shew "that upon presentment by a grand jury of an offence not capital, a summons or other proper process is to be issued, returnable to the next court;" and 4 Tuck. Bl. as explaining the word "presentments" to comprehend "indictments."

He observed that the oath of the grand jury for that very reason mentioned presentments only. He contended that the words "or other proper process" meant process in the nature of a summons;—such as a venire facias.

Mr. Hay said he felt very little solicitude about the event of this motion; but rested his opposition to it on the circumstance that the court had already held Col. Burr to bail.—He admitted the opinion was not binding; since it was on a point not argued; but it was founded on the 33d. sec. of the act of congress. (L. U. S. 1 v. 1 p. 73) which directs bail to be taken. It would be a manifest incongruity to hold the prisoner to bail for his appearance, before the grand jury had found a bill of indictment against him; and, afterwards to let him go at large.

Mr. Wickham answered Mr. Hay in a witty and ingenious speech, which we are sorry our limits will not permit us to give in detail. He took, however, nearly similar ground with Mr. Botts, and relied on the same authorities; though, with great skill, he varied the points of view in which he placed the subject. He particularly attacked the argument of Mr. Hay, that a man's being held to bail by a magistrate before he was indicted furnished a reason for continuing to hold him to bail after the indictment was found; contending it was not the law or the practice; upon an indictment for a misdemeanor, to hold the person accused to bail, where there had previously been no commitment; and that the circumstance of a prior commitment ought not to vary the case.

The Chief Justice took time to consider the question, and adjourned the court till Thursday 10 o'clock.

THURSDAY, Sept. 3.

The Chief Justice delivered his opinion in writing at considerable length on the question made the day before; the result of which was that a capias was declared to be the proper process, in this and other cases of misdemeanor where imprisonment is part of the punishment upon conviction; but that the accused being already in custody, it was unnecessary to issue it. He might however, be admitted to bail.

Mr. Hay said he would then proceed with the indictment for misdemeanor.

Col. Burr mentioned that the letter from gen. Wilkinson to the president of the U. S. had not yet been produced.

Mr. Hay declared that he had looked over all the papers received from Mr. Rodney, and had not been able to find it. He had written to that gentleman on the subject; and offered to furnish col. Burr with a copy verified by an affidavit.

Col. Burr said he was not prepared to go into trial to-day. He would reflect by to-morrow whether he could accept a copy.

A variety of desultory conversation took place on the subject of the quantum of bail to be required of col. Burr; and on a question, whether his giving bail might not entangle or obstruct the motion to commit him for treason; the chief justice seeming inclined to think that, if he was bound in a recognizance here, he could not be sent to another state for trial; and his counsel contending, that, to get rid of the difficulty, the counsel for the U. S. ought to dismiss the prosecution for the misdemeanor. At length the chief justice declared it was necessary to bring the question to a close: that if the prisoner was ready to proceed to trial for the misdemeanor, on the next day, the trial should take place; that, if a continuance should be obtained, and a motion then be made to commit him for treason, the difficulty suggested should be reserved, for consideration after hearing the motion at large; that in the mean time, col. Burr should be admitted to bail in the sum of 5000 dollars.

Mr. Hay entered a Nolle Prosequi on the indictment for treason against Jonathan Dayton; declaring he had no evidence against him except certain letters which he had written to gen. Wilkinson; and that he understood he had never been present at any of the overt acts of treason.

Mr. Wickham said that gen. Dayton was ready to plead not guilty on the indictment for a misdemeanor, and go to trial immediately.

Mr. Hay said he would take up his case after that of Aaron Burr had been disposed of; that as counsel for the U. S. he had a right to exercise his discretion on that subject; in which the court and Mr. Wickham appeared to acquiesce.

The court adjourned till Friday twelve o'clock.

See the clipping

In the story →

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

After deliberating 25 minutes, the jury found Aaron Burr not proved guilty under the indictment and returned a verdict of Not Guilty, though Burr's counsel objected to the specific wording entered on the record. Jonathan Dayton was discharged from the indictment after proving his alibi, then admitted to bail on a misdemeanor charge, while prosecutors remained undecided on whether to proceed against Burr on the separate misdemeanor indictment.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR,

On Friday Mr. Martin resumed the discussion on the important motion before the court, and spoke 3 hours.

See moreSee less

On Saturday he continued his argument and spoke till 3; that is, 14 hours in all. He was followed by Mr. Edmund Randolph, who spoke till 5.

We intended to have commenced in this number our sketch of the argument of counsel on this question—but not being furnished in time with the notes of one of the counsel, and this argument assuming additional interest from the circumstance of its being almost certainly the concluding argument on the prosecution for treason, we have determined to reserve it for our next paper, to give it more correctly and in greater detail.

MONDAY, AUGUST 31.

This day the court met a few minutes after 11, and the Chief Justice was occupied until half after two, in delivering the opinion of the court, on the motion before it. The opinion was of course extremely elaborate and voluminous. We shall present a complete copy of it as soon as possible, to the public, and in the mean time they must be satisfied with the following statement of its principal and very interesting conclusions.

The following explanation will make those points more intelligible to our readers.

The counsel for Mr. Burr stopped the interrogation of Maurice P. Bellnap, who was examined on the 20th ult. and moved the court to exclude farther evidence upon this ground, that the accused was proved not to have been present at th[e] time of the overt act laid in the indictment.

In support of this motion they urged the following reasons:

1. That Burr not being present was merely an accessory, and not a principal, and therefore not punishable under the constitution and laws of the U. States.

2. That if he was a principal, he was a principal only in the 2d degree, where guilt is merely derivative, & that therefore no parol evidence could be admitted against him, until a record was produced of the conviction of the offender in the 1st degree.

3. That the fact must be proved as laid in the indictment, and evidence proving the accused to have been absent at the time of the overt acts is inadmissible to support the indictment charging him with the commission of that act.

4. That no parol evidence could be given to connect the prisoner with the men assembled on Blannerhassett's island, until an act of treason in these men was proved; and that the assemblage there was not an act of treason.

We understand that on the 1st point, the opinion of the court was, that a man might commit treason in levying war against the U. S. without being present at the time of the overt act alledged in the indictment. Being leagued in the general conspiracy and performing a part in it was deemed sufficient.

The court admitted the second and third propositions to be correct.

On the fourth point, the court gave a very long and a very elaborate opinion as to an overt act of levying war. The opinion delivered by the supreme court in the case of Bollman an Swartwout was declared not to be correctly understood—and that there must be, before an overt act of treason is completed, either the actual employment of force, or a military assemblage of men, who are in a posture of war.

As soon as the Chief Justice had concluded, Mr. Hay rose to observe, that the opinion just expressed by the court fur-

MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 7, 1807.

nished matter for the very serious consideration of the prosecution. As he had not very distinctly heard every part of the opinion, he hoped the court would allow him an hour or two for its more complete consideration. He requested also the use of the opinion for his more particular inspection. Some desultory conversation ensued on the possibility and propriety of printing it for the use of the court. This arrangement was however waved, when

Mr. Hay requested the Chief Justice to permit him to have the use of the paper itself. The latter expressed some doubts about Mr. Hay's ability to decypher it, but cheerfully conceded to the request.

Mr. Hay moved an adjournment of the court until Wednesday 12 o'clock, which Mr. Lee objected to, on account of the number of witnesses who were detained on the trial—and Mr. Randolph on account of the inconveniences to which it would subject some of the jurymen. The Chief Justice then proposed to adjourn the court till 6 o'clock this evening—by which time perhaps the counsel for the prosecution might determine on the course which they would pursue.

Mr. Wirt observed, that it would take at least till 6 o'clock to decypher the opinion.

C. Jus. We will adjourn the court till 6 o'clock, and if the prosecution are not ready, we may adjourn till a more distant time.

Mr. Burr. I would ask, if necessary, that the jury should in the mean time go more at large. This proposition was finally rejected.

The court adjourned at 6, without doing any thing.

Tuesday, 11 o'clock.

The court met at 10; when Mr. Hay addressed them: "I have looked into the opinion and have neither argument nor evidence to offer to the jury."

Ch. Justice. The jury may then retire—Marshal, conduct them out. The jury accordingly retired.

After an absence of 25 minutes. Col. Carrington their foreman, reported the following verdict indorsed upon the indictment.

"We, of the Jury, find that Aaron Burr is NOT proved to be GUILTY under this indictment by any evidence submitted to us. We therefore find him NOT GUILTY."

Mr. Burr and his counsel objected to entering this form of the verdict on the Record.

The court at length decided, that the verdict should remain on the indictment, and that the general verdict of not guilty, should be entered on the record.

Jonathan Dayton appeared. An affidavit was exhibited to prove that he was not at Blannerhassett's island at the time charged in the indictment; & he was accordingly discharged from it. He was then admitted to bail on the indictment for the misdemeanor in the sum of 10,000 dols. A Mr. Williamson of New Jersey and Luther Martin were his securities.

Mr. Hay informed the court that the counsel for the United States had not determined on the course which they should pursue; whether they should proceed to the trial of Aaron Burr on the indictment for a misdemeanor, or whether they should move the court to commit him for his trial in Kentucky, where an overt act is said to have been committed at the mouth of Cumberland river.

When the court adjourned to 12 o'clock on Wednesday, Mr. Burr observing that he should not move for his discharge till then.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 1 September 1807 · an extract
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 4 September 1807

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A witness recounts being recruited by Colonel Burr for an expedition, initially believing it aimed at Mexico, but later suspecting ulterior motives after Burr voiced grievances against the U.S. government. The witness admits personal grounds for disaffection due to mistreatment during the Tripoli conflict, but denies any willingness to turn against fellow countrymen.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 7 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

RICHMOND, AUGUST 18.

by maps and other documents of the feasibility of penetrating to Mexico. At length from certain indistinct expressions and inuendoes I admitted a suspicion, that Col. B. had other projects. He used strong expressions of reproach against the administration of the government: accused them of want of character, want of energy, want of gratitude. He seemed desirous of irritating my resentment by dilating on certain injurious strictures I had received on the floor of Congress on account of certain transactions on the coasts of Tripoli; and also on the delays in adjusting my accounts for advances of money on account of the United States; and talked of pointing out to me modes of honorable indemnity. I will not conceal here, that Col. Burr had good grounds of reason for sup-

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A witness recounts conversations with Aaron Burr in which Burr described his plan to foment revolution in Mexican territories, recruit thousands of men, and secure cooperation from General Wilkinson as commander-in-chief. The witness details Burr's confident dismissal of obstacles including U.S. Army opposition and Miranda's potential resistance, with Burr suggesting Wilkinson's loyalty was wavering and could be secured for the plot.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 7 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr, facetiously, "we must hang Miranda." In the course of repeated conversations on this subject, he proposed to give me a distinguished command in his army; I understood the second command. I asked him, who would command in chief. He said, General Wilkinson I observed that it was singular, that he should count upon Gen. Wilkinson. The distinguished command and high trust he held under government, as the commander in chief of our army; and as the governor of a Province, he would not be apt to put at hazard for any precarious projects of aggrandizement.

See moreSee less

Col. Burr stated that Gen. Wilkinson balanced in the confidence of his country; that it was doubtful whether he would much longer retain the distinction and confidence he now enjoyed; and that he was prepared to secure to himself a permanency. I asked Col. B. if he knew General Wilkinson. He said, yes; and echoed the question. I told him that 12 years ago, I was at the same time a captain in his wing of the legion of the U. S. his acting brigade major and aid de-camp; and that I thought I knew him well. He asked me, what I knew of Gen. W. I said, I knew Gen. W. would act as Lieut. to no man in existence. "You are in an error," said Mr. B. "Wilkinson will act as Lieutenant to me." From the tenor of much conversation on this subject, I was prevailed on to believe that the plan of revolution meditated by Col. Burr, and communicated to me, had been concerted with Gen. W. and would have his co operation; for Col. B. repeatedly, and very confidently expressed his belief, that the influence of Gen. W. with his army the promise of dou-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A published letter addressed to Chief Justice John Marshall criticizes a reported ruling allowing testimony about conversations in Washington before the overt act of treason in Virginia was proven. The writer argues this risks reviving dangerous 'constructive treason' doctrines like those once prevalent in England.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

To the honourable John Marshall, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States.

SIR,

See moreSee less

Although perhaps no one more admires your character, or holds your talents or integrity in higher estimation than I do, I must, in compliance with what I deem an imperious duty, question the propriety of a decision, which is said to have been lately given by you, and the hon. judge Griffin, in the case of the United States, against col. Burr—and the more so, as it really appears to me that it lays

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The editor explains that due to illness he inadvertently approved publication of a piece signed 'Soldier' attacking Major McRae, taken from the Virginia Gazette regarding the Burr case, without reading it first. He clarifies the paper takes no side in the dispute and will allow McRae or his friends to respond.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

We shall never hesitate to confess ourselves in the wrong when we are made sensible of it, even had we committed the act with intention, but when we have fallen into error accidentally, we feel doubly solicitous to explain. The republication in our last of the piece signed Soldier, from the Virginia Gazette, addressed to Major McRae, was accidental and not intentional. We do not mean to make ourselves a party in the affair between the Soldier and the Major; but perhaps we appear as such from the republication of the piece.

See moreSee less

The truth of the case stands thus. The editor was sick and confined to his bed, when the mail papers were brought to him for selection; having occasion to select a part of the proceedings in the case of col. Burr from the

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The court debates postponing Blannerhassett's arraignment until after deciding key legal points raised in Burr's case, since the ruling would affect what evidence is relevant. Prosecutor Mr. M'Rea argues for four hours that the definition of treason from the Bollman and Swartwout case is constitutionally sound and based on English legal precedent.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 8 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BURR'S TRIAL.

forward on the part of the United States; but few of whom could perhaps be examined.

The chief Justice said, that one of the points made in the case of Col. Burr, did not occur in that of Mr. Blannerhaffett. There could be no question but Mr. Blannerhaffett was present when the overt act, whatever it may be, was committed, and that was also present, when Col. Tyler's boats were at the Island.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay declared he had no objection to the postponement if the gentlemen on the other side thought their conduct would be regulated by the decision of the Court on the points now under consideration; and that they might name their own time for the arraignment.

It was finally agreed that the arraignment of Mr. Blannerhaffett should take place after the questions now before the Court should be decided.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report recounts several days of courtroom arguments in late August between prosecution (Wirt, Hay) and defense (Botts, Lee, Martin) counsel in Burr's treason trial, with the court expected to rule soon. An editorial comment criticizes the court's ruling that jurors who had formed any opinion on Burr's guilt were ineligible, arguing this would produce a jury biased in Burr's favor.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 8 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TUESDAY, AUGUST 25TH

Be the fate of Burr what it may, he could not wish a trial under more favorable circumstances. A Court, to say the least, not unfriendly to him—Counsel, learned in the law, eloquent at the bar, and engaged in the cause, viz. Messrs Randolph, Wickham, Martin, Botts, Lee and Baker—a Jury, selected by himself out of 85 men—if he is convicted, he must indeed be guilty. The decision of the court that no man who had expressed or formed an opinion as to the guilt of Burr, was eligible as a juror, was calculated either to get no jury, or just such an one as Burr would wish.

See moreSee less

We cannot believe there is a man in the Union possessing common sense and common means of information, but what has formed an opinion one way or the other. Those who felt unfriendly to Burr would instantly confess this opinion, that they might avoid the

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

A Richmond letter reports that Burr's trial is proceeding slowly, and that a servant tried to poison a key witness named Duncan with laudanum-laced porter. The servant, promised $700 and his freedom, was caught and jailed after Duncan detected the poison before drinking it.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 8 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The following is an extract of a letter from Richmond, dated August 27 :—

"Burr's trial is going on very slowly.— An attempt was made a few nights ago to poison a Mr. Duncan, a material witness in

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The court discusses whether an overt act of treason was committed and debates motions to transfer Blennerhassett and Smith to the location where the alleged offense occurred. Burr objects to being grouped with the other defendants, arguing their cases are separate and distinct.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

act was committed.

The Chief Justice said that it was undoubtedly the opinion of the court that the facts proven to have been committed at Blannerhassett's Island did not amount to an overt act of treason. But the court did not intend their opinion should apply to the facts of any particular case. They only meant to declare the law, leaving it to the jury to determine from the facts submitted to them, whether an overt act of treason had been committed or not.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay said he believed he should enter a nole prosequi as to Blannerhasset and Smith, and move the court to commit them together with the person who now stands before them indicted for a misdemeanor, in order that they may be sent to the place where the overt act was committed: if the court should be of opinion, after hearing the evidence, that it would be proper to do so. For this purpose he moved that Blannerhassett and Smith be brought into court.

Col. Burr contended that his case and that of Mr. Blannerhassett and Mr. Smith, was quite separate and distinct, and that the motion could not be blended. To hear them together would tend to produce confusion. He should insist that the motion be taken up separately. He should also insist that there be a specification of the place where the offence is supposed to have been committed.

Mr. Hay said that he did not know that he was bound to specify the place; but he had no objection to doing so as far as in his power. It was said that col Burr was at

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The court, likely Chief Justice Marshall, analyzes whether Burr must have been actually or legally present at Blannerhassett's Island to be convicted of treason under the indictment. The opinion walks through hypothetical parallels to argue that without proof of such presence by two witnesses, the overt act charged cannot be established.

The Enquirer · 9 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

some other place in the same county, and that Burr had been proved to be with them by four witnesses: That the resolution to march to Blannerhassett's island for a treasonable purpose had been there taken; that he had been seen

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness identifies a letter as being in the handwriting of Capt. Walter Burling, aide to Gen. Wilkinson, prompting a dispute over whether the government must produce the original letter of Nov. 12, 1806. Prosecutor Hay resists disclosing certain passages he deems irrelevant or damaging to third parties, while the defense argues the accused has a right to all evidence relevant to his defense.

The Enquirer · 9 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Hay declared, that he was willing to expose so much of the letter as related to Col. Burr himself. But he enquired whether it would be right to exhibit to public view those parts which would tend to

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Counsel argue over whether portions of a letter (obtained via subpoena duces tecum) should be suppressed or disclosed during Burr's trial. Defense counsel argue full disclosure is necessary for justice and to assess Wilkinson's credibility, while prosecution raises concerns about delicacy and confidentiality.

The Enquirer · 9 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

under any circumstances. He would, indeed, rather go to jail than expose them.

Mr. Wickham observed, that after the sentiments of defiance which had been uttered by the gentlemen on the other side, it only remained to apply to the court for an exertion of its authority. Motives of delicacy, it was well settled, were not sufficient to suppress evidence which was deemed essential for the purposes of justice. He instanced the case of the Dutchess of Kingston, in which certain gentlemen were compelled to give testimony of a most delicate nature, and relative to subjects which they had solemnly promised forever to conceal. But these parts of the letter proposed to be suppressed, may be of the utmost importance to the accused. If Gen. Wilkinson shall have denounced persons deservedly high in the confidence of the government and people, it would materially lessen his credibility in relation to col. Burr.

See moreSee less

C. Justice. The writ of subpoena duces tecum is sometimes awarded upon motion, but it is more frequently a matter of course upon the mere suggestion of the party. An argument as to the propriety of calling for the paper for the production of which it was awarded, is referred for the return.

The writ of Subpoena Duces Tecum was accordingly issued, to which Mr. Hay made the return inserted in our last; and on the next day annexed the supplemental return, which we have given in this day's paper.

On this return an animated debate ensued. Mr. Botts and Mr. Wickham spoke on the side of Col. Burr; Mr. McRae and Mr. Writ on the side of the prosecution. Col. Burr also addressed a few observations to the court.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

Defense and prosecution counsel debate whether a confidential letter, believed to implicate General Wilkinson, must be disclosed as evidence for Burr's defense. The dispute centers on executive privilege, the President's discretion over confidential communications, and the proper scope of Burr's affidavit request.

The Enquirer · 9 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

parts were really unimportant. The counsel for the United States referred to the form of the affidavit filed by col. Burr, in which he states, that the letter may be of importance to him as a matter of evidence; that no particular ground was stated why the letter would be material, and it was impossible in such a case to detect the person making the affidavit, because there was no point to which it was directed; that if a person might capriciously by a vague affidavit of this kind extort evidence, no man's private papers would be sacred; that the most confidential papers in his possession might be extracted from his desk, under a pretext that they might be essential for the purposes of justice; that even admitting the passages proposed to be withheld from public view, were really important as it respected the persons alluded to, yet they were of no importance to col.

See moreSee less

Burr, nor could they form any part of his defence; that the President having confided

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 12 September 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage discusses legal opinions on what constitutes levying war under treason law, citing Judge Iredell's charge in the Fries case. It then reports on September 3rd proceedings in Burr's trial, where a dispute arose over a confidential letter from General Wilkinson to the President that Burr claimed was material to his defense, with the court ultimately proposing that defense counsel examine the letter to select relevant portions.

Virginia Argus · 9 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Latest Proceedings in the Trial. THURSDAY, Sept. 3. In addition to the other occurrences of this day, (which were mentioned in the last Argus) Col. Burr said he had lately discovered that a letter from Gen. Wilkinson to the President, bearing date Nov. 12th, 1806, might be material in his defence. He had made an affidavit to that effect. Mr Hay acknowledged that he had that letter; but observed that some parts of it were of such a nature as ought not to be made public. It had been communicated to the President in the strictest confidence, and contained several strictures upon certain characters in the western country, & free remarks on the state of affairs there, the revealing of which might be productive of mischief, and could be of no service to the accused.

See moreSee less

He observed that a part only of that letter could be evidence. He therefore wished the court to examine it, and select such parts as, in its judgment, might be necessary to the defence of Col. Burr. The counsel for col Burr objected to this, saying it would be transforming the court into a secret tribunal. The Chief Justice proposed that the letter should be submitted to their inspection; and that such parts should be selected by them as they conceived would be useful to their client Mr Hay consented; and said he had no objection that Messrs. Botts, Wickham & Randolph should upon honor, examine the letter; and take only such parts of it as apply to the case.—On this subject some desultory conversation took place; in the course of which Mr. Botts suggested a difficulty; that Mr Hay might think certain parts of the letter not important as evidence in favor of col. Burr, which his counsel might conceive to be very important. Mr Hay said, in case of a difference between Mr Botts and himself, he was willing the Court should decide. Mr. Botts. It is the right of every person accused to decide what evidence is important in his cause. We have heard that Gen. Wilkinson has shewn that letter to several persons; perhaps it was before the grand jury. There can, therefore, be no objection to its being published. Mr Hay. I wish it to be distinctly understood that no parts of the letter are to be used as evidence but such as are agreed upon, and that no part is to be shewn to col. Burr. Gen. Wilkinson would not choose to depend on the honor of Aaron Burr. Mr Botts. We shall certainly do nothing with the letter, if our client is not permitted to see it. Mr. Wickham made a similar declaration; and declined any agency in examining the letter. The subject was waved for the present, on col. Burr's observing that perhaps the counsel on both sides might come to some agreement on the point by the next day.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During courtroom proceedings, defense counsel and prosecutor Hay argue over access to a letter from General Wilkinson, with Burr demanding to see it and Hay refusing to let him view it directly, citing Wilkinson's distrust. The dispute continues into the next day's session, including questions about whether the letter was shown to the grand jury and the authenticity of a copy versus the missing original.

Virginia Argus · 9 September 1807 · page 2

never seen the evidence exh bited t(» the Grand Jury, and had only taken, from some of the witnesses, general notes of th< points to which their testimony related. He had ins Mivwicu^c ai prc sent, bearing on Gen. Dayton, but his let ter to Gen. Wilkinson.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report covers courtroom exchanges regarding a missing letter copy and whether to proceed with the misdemeanor trial against General Dayton. Discussion centers on whether sufficient evidence exists against Dayton since his alleged acts occurred in New Jersey rather than Virginia, with debate over the admissibility of General Wilkinson's letter.

Virginia Argus · 9 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

never seen the evidence exhibited to the Grand Jury, and had only taken, from some of the witnesses, general notes of the points to which their testimony related. He had no evidence, within his knowledge at present, bearing on Gen. Dayton, but his letter to Gen. Wilkinson.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During Burr's treason trial, prosecutor George Hay withheld portions of a letter from President Jefferson, claiming they were confidential and irrelevant to the defense. Burr's counsel argued the court had no right to judge this in secret, leading to a heated debate over whether the trial should be continued until the full letter was produced.

Virginia Argus · 9 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

GEORGE HAY.

He then offered to read such parts of the letter as were proper for public view; in order to shew the total irrelevancy to the defence of Aaron Burr, even of those parts.

See moreSee less

The counsel on the other side would not permit them to be read.

Mr Botts said it would be painful for them to move for an attachment against Mr Hay. Another alternative was to make a motion, that the cause should stand continued until the whole letter should be produced.

On this motion an able and animated discussion ensued; conducted by Messrs. Botts & Wickham on one side, and Messrs. M'Rae and Wirt on the other.

On the part of Col. Burr, it was contended that the Attorney for the U. S. had no discretion to withhold the paper; and that the court had no right to judge in secret upon it.—The Attorney for the U. S ought not to have that discretion; because from the nature of his office, he was inclined against the accused, and wished to have him convicted. The President could not delegate this power to him, even if he possessed it himself. The court ought not to assume the power of examining the paper & judging whether it should be produced; because the counsel for the prisoner would not be possessed of the means of arguing on the opinion to be formed by the court; which they had a right to do.

It was urged that Col. Burr believed that the parts of the letter which were attempted to be withheld were important to his defence; but that the parts which mr. Hay was willing to shew were unimportant; that in a government like ours, of responsibilities, nothing of a domestic nature ought to be concealed; and that justice ought not to yield to delicacy.

The counsel for the U. S. insisted that the affidavit of the accused (that the letter may be material) was too vague and uncertain to furnish a reason for compelling its production; that Mr. Hay's return (which was to be considered as being on oath) shewed that the letter ought not now to be considered as material; since his solemn and positive declarations ought to outweigh the doubtful suppositions or surmises of Col. Burr; that the arguments on the other side only tended to shew what the counsel for the U. S. admitted, that the paper ought not to be withheld, if it was necessary or material to the defence of the prisoner; but, since it related altogether to other persons, and could not be useful for his defence, they contend he had no right to demand it; that the letter having been confidentially written to the President of the U. S. the President had a right to withhold it under the circumstances of this case, and to delegate the power of acting in his stead to Mr. Hay, which he had done; that as the court could not perceive the irrelevancy of the letter to the case of col. Burr, and of

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During pretrial proceedings in the Burr treason case, prosecutor Hay and defense counsel dispute whether President Jefferson's letter must be produced, with Hay sending an express to Monticello to consult Jefferson. The court also sets bail for Burr with Jonathan Dayton and Jonathan Langston as sureties, and debates whether to proceed with the trial on Monday despite the letter's absence.

Virginia Argus · 9 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

letter!

Mr Botts observed, he wished Mr Hay to understand that the counsel for col. Burr did not mean to commit themselves absolutely. They were willing to go to trial under the prospect that the letter might be furnished by the time it would be wanting in the course of proceeding ; but, if it should be ultimately withheld, they meant to reserve the right of insisting hereafter on its production.

See moreSee less

Col. Burr. At present I know of no objection to the trial on Monday.

Mr Martin mentioned the case of Israel Smith.—Mr Hay, under the opinion of the court heretofore pronounced, entered a nolle prosequi on the indictment against mr. Smith, for the treason charged to have been committed in Virginia.

The session of the court was suspended till half after 2 o'clock ; at which time bail was to be offered by Col Burr. Gen. Jonathan Dayton of New-Jersey, and Major Thomas Langsurn of this city, were accepted as his bail.

The court then adjourned until Monday 10 o'clock.

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

A witness describes conversations with Aaron Burr in which Burr detailed his plans to raise forces from Tennessee, Kentucky, and the territories, boasting of inexhaustible resources and expecting cooperation from General Wilkinson and thousands of soldiers. The witness expresses skepticism about Wilkinson's loyalty, while Burr insists Wilkinson will act as a lieutenant in the scheme.

Lynchburg Star · 10 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

[...]ed by 10 or 12,000 men from the [me]ntioned states and territory; and powerful agents in the Spani[tory, and "as for Miranda". M]r. Burr facetiously, "we must [have M]iranda." In the course of repeat[ed conver]sations on this subject, he pro[mise]d to give me a distinguished command [of the] army; I understood the second [in comman]d. I asked him, who would co[mma]nd in chief. He said, General [Wilkins]on. I observed that it was sin[gular] he should count upon General [Wilkins]on. The distinguished command, [thou]gh trust he held under government, [as] commander in chief of our army; as governor of a Province, he would be apt to put at hazard for any precious projects of aggrandizement.— Col.

See moreSee less

Burr stated that Gen. Wilkinson balanced in the confidence of his country; that it was doubtful whether he would much longer retain the distinction and

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This passage records courtroom questioning of General Eaton regarding his conversations with Aaron Burr about an alleged plot and a toast referencing treason. Eaton testifies about the timing and details of these conversations, while defense counsel probes inconsistencies in his recollection of dates and locations.

Lynchburg Star · 10 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

bruary and the middle of March. Q. Was there any particular conduct calculated to put an end to Col. Burr's importunities? A. Yes. At some of our last in- [illegible]

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This report covers the August 22, 1807 session of the Burr treason trial, where Herman Blennerhassett's arraignment was postponed due to a misnomer in the indictment and the absence of defense counsel. It also details legal arguments by Mr. Martin citing precedents on the role of court and jury in determining overt acts of treason.

Lynchburg Star · 10 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LATEST PROCEEDINGS.

cessity of summoning a large proportion of a long list of witnesses with which he had been furnished; since, after the decision of the court upon any of the four questions now under discussion in the case of Aaron Burr, some of the facts intended to be established by those witnesses might be unnesessary for the defence of Mr. Blannerhasset.

The Chief Justice said that only one of these questions could affect Mr. Blannerhasset; viz. whether the assemblage of men at the Island constituted an overt act of treason against the U. States; it having been proved that he was present.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay consented to defer the arraignment until those questions should be decided.

We understand the alledged misnomer in the indictment consists in this; that the name is written Blanaerhasset; whereas it is said the true spelling is Blennerhasset!

The case of Mr. Blannerhasset, or Blennerhasset, having been disposed of, Mr. Martin observed that, since the counsel for the United States were to continue the argument in Burr's case on Monday, he thought they ought to be apprized of all the authorities relied on by the counsel for the prisoner. He therefore cited

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

Defense and prosecution lawyers cite legal authorities over whether the court or jury should determine the overt act of treason, as arguments continue in the Burr case. Randolph raises a constitutional point on indictment clarity, and McRae begins the prosecution's argument, criticizing Burr's conduct and his attacks on Wilkinson and government officials.

Lynchburg Star · 10 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LATEST PROCEEDINGS.

whether it has been proven by two witnesses, or not. He cited also Vaughan's Rep'ts 382, on the subject of extrajudicial opinions, for the purpose of shewing that opinions of courts on points not necessarily involved in cases under their consideration are not authority. The object of this quotation was to invalidate the authority of some parts of the opinion of the supreme court in the case of Bollman and Swartwout.

Mr. McRae proposed as a number of new authorities had been adduced on the part of Col. Burr, and would require additional time to be considered, that the court should adjourn until 12 o'clock on Monday, instead of 9 the usual hour.

See moreSee less

Messrs. Martin and Botts opposed the motion; but after a short discussion, the court approved it, and adjourned 'til Monday, twelve o'clock.

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

The report describes closing arguments in Aaron Burr's treason trial, focusing on prosecutor MacRae's speech condemning Burr's attacks on General Wilkinson and public officials who suppressed the conspiracy. It also notes that attorney Wirt delivered a lengthy argumentative speech for the prosecution, followed by Mr. Botts speaking for the defense.

Lynchburg Star · 10 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

more of the prisoner's conduct. Before Gen. Wilkinson's arrival the most virulent abuse had been uttered against him; it was said he would never appear; that he dared not confront the prisoner. After these expectations were dis[appointed]

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The Chief Justice delivers his opinion on the proper legal process for the misdemeanor indictment against Colonel Burr, determining that a capias was the regular process after reviewing precedents. Burr then requests a reduction of his bail, arguing his situation has changed since the jury's verdict and citing other circumstances, with the Chief Justice proposing $5,000 as sufficient while prosecution wished to proceed with commitment for the overt act location.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

bail.

The chief justice said that he had always considered the bail in which col. B was bound to answer the misdemeanor as very high. To bind a man in six times the sum which he would be bound to pay under a judgment of the court, for the offence with which he was charged, especially in a country where excessive bail cannot be required, always aappeared to him to be unreasonably high. He therefore proposed the sum of five thousand dollars as sufficient, under the present circumstances of col. Burr. He also mentioned the civil process which was known to have been served upon him.

See moreSee less

Much difficulty and desultory argument ensued with respect to the course which should be pursued. The counsel for the prosecution wished to go on with the motion for a commitment with a view to send col. Burr to the place where the overt act was supposed to have been committed.—This was opposed by the counsel for col. Burr, who contended that the court was bound to have a decision on the indictment for misdemeanor before he could be transferred to a foreign tribunal. The court seemed to express strong doubts upon this point. At length the chief justice determined that he would proceed upon the trial of the indictment for misdemeanor, to-morrow if col. Burr should be ready.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

During Burr's trial proceedings, defense counsel sought a subpoena duces tecum for an original letter from General Wilkinson to President Jefferson dated November 12, 1806. Attorney Hay complied but withheld portions he deemed confidential and immaterial, submitting the redacted letter to the court for inspection while the dispute over full disclosure remained unresolved.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

posing those parts which the counsel for the U. S. deemed confidential; but no definitive arrangements were made. The court adjourned till to-morrow 12 o'clock.

FRIDAY, September 4. The proceedings of this day commenced with an application on the part of col. Burr for the production of an original letter from gen. Wilkinson to the president of the United States, dated the 12th of Nov. 1806, and which letter was in the possession of Mr. Hay, the attorney for the U. S. The president having confided to Mr.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers

The jury returned a verdict stating Burr was 'not proved to be guilty under this Indictment' and therefore 'NOT GUILTY,' after only 20 minutes' deliberation. Burr and his counsel objected to this unusual phrasing, arguing it should simply read 'Not Guilty,' sparking a courtroom debate with prosecutor Hay over legal form and precedent.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"TY."

This form of a verdict was objected to by col. Burr and his counsel, who insisted that it should be in the usual form, simply, Not Guilty.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay contended, that the jury had a right to find their verdict in this form if they thought proper; and that it should be recorded in the very words of the verdict. It might be more satisfactory to them, and amounted in effect to the same thing as a general verdict of Not Guilty. He knew of no law, & he was certain there was no principle against it.

Mr. Randolph answered that form was against it; and in criminal cases, form was law. Why else are precedents always consulted to ascertain what the law is.

Col. Burr contended that the jury had no right to bring in a written verdict, or to say more than whether he was guilty or not guilty. The form of the charge given to the jury (which was read, at his request, by the clerk) would point out their duty. This was, that they were to say whether guilty or not guilty, and no more.

Mr. Hay observed, that if the verdict were not in writing the same objections might occur, if the jury should persist in the form adopted by them.—They might direct their foreman to deliver it ore tenus, in the very words which had been indorsed on the indictment.

Col. Burr. The charge given to the

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 4 September 1807
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 5 September 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A transcript of courtroom argument in which prosecutor Wirt and others debate whether Aaron Burr's bail bond would exonerate him if he committed a capital offense like murder or treason. The Chief Justice and counsel spar over motions for commitment and continuance of the case.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Mr. Burr observed, that the gentleman should state an analogous case, such as the present; of levying war, where two indictments grew out of the same act. Let the attorney enter a Nolle Prosequi and he may then proceed to his motion for commitment.

Mr. Hay suggested a method for removing the difficulty. He wished to remove Mr. Burr for his trial to another district. Most of the witnesses have been here for a long time, and he wishes to dismiss them as soon as possible. Let the court then hear this motion; if after the evidence is produced, and not till then, does the diffi[culty occur]

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The passage records courtroom debate between prosecutors Wirt and Hay and defense counsel Botts, Martin, and Wickham over the nature of the charges against Burr and the handling of confidential letters from General Wilkinson. The Chief Justice rules that the trial on the misdemeanor indictment will proceed the next day if Burr is ready.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 11 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

after to demonstrate that we are directed by a regard to the rights and liberties of the people.

Mr. Burr then observed that he had lately discovered that a letter of gen. Wilkinson's of the 12th of Nov. was material to his defence. He had made an affidavit to that effect.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay observed that he had that letter; but he would beg leave to state, that in gen. W's letters there was a great deal of matter which ought not to be made public; among the rest several strictures upon certain characters in the western country, which were freely imparted to the government in the strictest confidence. Would it not be better to trust the court with the selection of such parts as it might deem necessary to the defence of the accused?

Mr. Martin. Are we to have a secret tribunal? Let the argument be in writing

Mr. Hay then proposed to submit those letters to the inspection of either Mr Randolph, or Mr. Botts, or Mr.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

During Burr's trial, defense counsel Hay sought clarification on whether events at Blannerhassett's Island constituted an overt act of treason, and indicated he would enter a nolle prosequi for co-defendants Blannerhassett and Smith if so. The Chief Justice clarified that the court's opinion was general law, leaving it to the jury to determine from the facts whether an overt act had occurred.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

David Robertson, Esq. of Petersburg, the celebrated Stenographer of the "Debates of the Virginia Convention," is preparing to publish his reports of the Proceedings on the Trials of Aaron Burr. Subscriptions received at the office of the Publick Ledger.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers

Following Burr's acquittal on the treason charge, attorneys and the Chief Justice debate whether his co-defendants can be tried jointly or must be tried separately, and whether Burr should now be discharged. The Chief Justice explains the legal distinctions regarding jurisdiction and grand jury findings versus petit jury trials.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 11 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

a joint examination. He did not expect to have heard such observations addressed to the court.—However chaotic, however confused the case may be, the court will have no difficulty in separating the evidence and applying it to each person. But he believed the testimony would bear equally upon all; for they were all present. If however, it should be the pleasure of the court to hear the motions separately he should acquiesce.

Col. Burr remarked, that there would be no necessity to repeat the testimony, because the court could recollect it and apply it to the case of each individual. Besides some evidence might be deemed necessary by some, which would not be by another.

See moreSee less

Mr. Botts said, that col. Burr, having gone thro' one trial for the whole treason, he stood upon different grounds from any one of the others. Different, not only as it related to many legal questions, but to the evidence which might be adduced. When the evidence should be gone through, he expected that Mr. Hay's overt act would be to himself a subject of ridicule. Besides there were separate counsel retained for the several gentlemen; and the examination ought, as nearly as possible to assume the shape of a final and regular trial.

Mr. Wickham observed, that col. Burr had been tried for treason; and the jury had found a verdict

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 9 September 1807
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 11 September 1807

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The report describes Mr. Martin's lengthy thirteen-hour argument for the defense, followed by remarks from Randolph and Hay. Chief Justice Marshall then delivers a lengthy opinion excluding further testimony as irrelevant, prompting discussion about adjournment and the eventual discharge of the jury.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 11 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COLONEL A. BURR.

MONDAY, August 31. The Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the court, on the motion made by the counsel of Col. Burr, to exclude all other evidence from the consideration of

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The jury's verdict of not guilty was recorded in common form after the court accepted the indorsement as given. General Jonathan Dayton then appeared in court to answer treason and misdemeanor indictments, with his counsel arguing for bail using affidavits placing him elsewhere at the time of the alleged overt act; bail was set at $10,000.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 11 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

in which they have returned it, the court cannot reject it; because it is a full answer to what was given them in charge. The indorsement remained as the Jury had inserted it, and the clerk recorded the verdict in the common form not guilty.

Col. Burr observed that he should not

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

During Aaron Burr's treason trial, attorneys debate whether certain passages of a letter dated in 1806 should be read aloud in court, with Burr's side citing concerns about exposing private opinions on individuals and state secrets. Colonel Burr argues some passages reflect changeable personal opinions and requests the court decide which excerpts are truly material to the case.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 12 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

him that he had sent all the letters; the large packet had been received, but he had not been able to find this particular one. Mr. Botts moved for a subpoena duces tecum to be directed to Mr. Hay for the production of the original letter of the 12th November, 1806, which then lay before him. He denied the right of the government to withhold the paper. Colonel Burr said that state secrets were such only as affected the public at large -- But if a man thought proper to make a denunciation of individual characters, he had been guilty of a great offence and deserved no protection.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay declared, that he was willing to expose so much of the letter as related to col. Burr himself. But he enquired whether it would be right to exhibit to public view those parts which would tend to produce controversy between others. Cases may occur in which the disaffection to the government may be such, and so extensive even among the officers of the government, that it may become the duty of private citizens to inform. The accused may have all that belongs to his defence; but he never would put it in his power to make use of the letter for the purposes to which he was satisfied it would be applied. He could not see why col. Burr should step forward as the friend of those who had been denounced, even if there were such. But, in truth, the passages of the letter which he was unwilling to expose, were merely opinions of the writer with respect to certain persons, which opinions may have changed; as it related to some of them he knew they had changed. There were two passages in the letter which he could not consent should be seen unless they were extorted by the court. He did not know that he would yield under any circumstances. He would, indeed, rather go to jail than

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage records the voir dire examination of potential jurors in Aaron Burr's trial, with many candidates dismissed for having already formed opinions about his guilt. A twelve-man jury was ultimately empaneled, including Orris Payne and others, after extensive questioning about their prior exposure to publications and conversations about the case.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the guilt of the accufed. Set aside.

13. Jeffe Bowles had faid, that if common report was to be believed, Col. Burr had been guilty of fomething ; but he had not made up a pofitive opinion on this charge. Accepted.

See moreSee less

14. Daniel Holloway was excufed from indifpofition.

15. John Price was excufed for the fame reafon.

16. Thomas Lewis had in general converfation expreffed an opinion unfavorable to Col. Burr ; being afked by the Ch. Juftice, he faid, that his opinion on this charge was not fixed. Accepted.

17. Richard Young was excufed from indifpofition.

Carter B. Berkeley, one of the felected jurymen, wifhed to be excufed from ferving, on account of his bufinefs. Mr. Hay. Have you, Mr. Berkley, formed and expreffed no opinion on this fubject ? Mr. Be. I have feen, fir, different publications about it ; I have thought that Col. Burr might have been guilty of fomething ; but I have formed no pofitive opinion. Mr. B's excufe was overruled by the court.

M. Hay was folicitous to have Orris Payne excufed, and afked him whether upon his confcience he had formed no opinion on the fubject ? Mr. Payne obferved, that he had formed an opinion. Mr. Baker. Is it a fixed opinion on this particular charge or has it

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report describes the empaneling of the jury in Aaron Burr's trial, listing jurors' names after discussion of potential bias. It also records the clerk reading the indictment charging Burr with setting on foot a military expedition from Blennerhassett's Island against Spanish territory while the U.S. was at peace with Spain.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ON THE INDICTMENT FOR A MISDEMEANOR.

fluctuated according to circumstances? Mr. Payne observed, that he had no fixed opinion as to this particular charge. Mr. Payne was retained.

The Jury were then sworn and consisted of the following individuals:

See moreSee less

Orris Payne, | Carter B. Berkeley, James Bootright, | Robert McKim, Obadiah Garthright, | Robert Gordon, John Murphy, | James Penn, Wm. Bentley, | Jesse Bowies, Yeamans Smith, | Thomas Lewis.

The clerk then rose to read the indictment, to which Mr. Botts objected. He said that it was the province of the attorney himself, to read his own indictment. Mr. Hay replied, that such was not the usual practice; and, after a short conversation it was read by the clerk in the following terms:

CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT AND DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA.

DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA, TO WIT:

The grand inquest of the United States of America, in and for the body of the district of Virginia, upon their oath, do present, that AARON BURR, late of the City of New-York and district of New-York, attorney at law, did, on the tenth day of December, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and six, within the jurisdiction of the United States, to wit: at a certain Island in the river Ohio, called Blannerhassett's Island, in the County of Wood, within the district of Virginia aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, with force and arms, begin a certain military expedition, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of a foreign prince, to wit: the dominions of the King of Spain; the said United States then and there being at peace with the said King of Spain, against the form of the statute, in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States and their dignity; and the jurors aforesaid, upon their said oath, do, farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards, to wit: on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and six, and within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at a certain Island, in the river Ohio, called Blannerhassett's Island, in the County of Wood, in the district of Virginia aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, with force and arms, did set on foot a certain military enterprize, to be carried on from

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This passage presents the formal grand jury indictment against Aaron Burr, detailing charges that he set on foot military enterprises on December 10, 1806 at Blennerhassett's Island in the Ohio River, intended to be carried out against Spanish territory including Mexico. The indictment also charges Burr with providing military materials—boats, men, provisions, gunpowder, and bullets—for these enterprises, all alleged to violate U.S. neutrality statutes.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

certain military enterprize, to be carried on from thence against the territory of a foreign Prince, to wit: the territory of the King of Spain; the said United States then and there being at peace with the said King of Spain, against the form of the statute, in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States, and their dignity;—and the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath, do farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards; to wit: on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and six, within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at a certain Island in the river Ohio, called Blannerhassett's Island, which is in the County of Wood, in the district of Virginia aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did, with force and arms, set on foot a certain other military enterprize, to be carried on from thence, against the territory of a foreign Prince, to wit: against the Province of Mexico, in North America; the said Province of Mexico, then and there being the territory of the King of Spain; and the said King of Spain then and there being at peace with the said United States, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States, and their dignity, and the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath, do farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards, to wit: on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and six, within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at Blannerhassett's Island, in the river Ohio, which Island is in the county of Wood, in the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did, with force and arms, provide the means, to wit: boats, men, provisions, fire, arms, gun-powder, bullets, leaden bars and other military munition, for a certain other military enterprize, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of a foreign Prince, to wit: against the dominions of the King of Spain; the said United States then and there being at peace with the said King of Spain, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States and their dignity; and the jurors aforesaid, upon their said oath, do farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards, to wit: on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and six, within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at an Island in the river Ohio, called Blannerhassett's Island, in the county of Wood and district of Virginia, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did, with force and arms, prepare the means, to wit: boats, men, provisions, fire-arms, gun-powder, bullets, leaden bars, and other military munition, for a certain other military expedition, to be carried on from thence against the Province of Mexico, in North America, the said Province of Mexico, then and there being the territory of a foreign Prince, to wit: the territory of the King of Spain, and the said United States, then and there being at peace with the said king of Spain, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States and their dignity; and the jurors aforesaid upon their said oath, do farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards, to wit: on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our lord one thousand eight hundred and six within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at an Island, in the river Ohio, called Blannerhassetts Island, in the county of Wood and district of Virginia, aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did with force and arms, provide the means, to wit: boats, men, provisions, fire-arms, gun-powder, balls, leaden bars, and other military munition, for a certain other military expedition, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of some foreign state, to the jurors aforesaid yet unknown, with whom the United States were then and there at peace, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States and their dignity; and the jurors aforesaid, upon their said oath, do farther present, that the said Aaron Burr, afterwards, to wit, on the said tenth day of December, in the year of our lord one thousand eight hundred and six, within the jurisdiction of the said United States, to wit: at Blannerhassett's Island, in the river Ohio, in the county of Wood and district of Virginia aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did with force and arms, set on foot a certain other military enterprize, to be carried on from thence against the dominions of some foreign state, to the jurors aforesaid, yet unknown; with whom the United States were then and there at peace, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, to the evil example of all others, in like case offending, and against the peace of the said United States, and their dignity.

GEORGE HAY, Of the City of Richmond, in the state of Virginia, Attorney of the United States for the Virginia District, Prosecutor. A TRUE BILL, JOHN RANDOLPH. A Copy. Teste, WILLIAM MARSHALL, CL'K.

See moreSee less

The clerk was then proceeding to charge the jury. Mr. Botts contended that this was the province of the attorney for the prosecution. The Ch. Justice observed, that there was no charge necessary. Mr. Hay. All that the clerk had to say, was that to this indictment the accused had entered not guilty, and that the jury were to try the validity of that plea. In saying this, however, I have delivered the charge. Mr. Hay then stated to the court, that his express had arrived from Monticello, and had brought back the return of the President of the United States, which he was now prepared to read. The Ch. Just. did not know whether there was any necessity for it, if there

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 18 September 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

At Burr's trial, witness Peter Taylor testified about the party gathered on Blennerhassett's Island, describing Blennerhassett's statements about conquering Mexico and making Burr king. Another witness, Mr. Belknap, was then called to testify about delivering a letter from Burr that prompted the party's hasty departure from the island.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

provisions; he recited his interview with Dr. Bennett (whom Mr. Hay stated had departed from Richmond in spite of all his admonitions;) he repeated in the most consistent manner Blannerhassett's communications to him; how they were going to take Mexico and make Burr its King; and his daughter to be his successor; as also his conversation with Aaron Burr at Lexington. He stated that he saw no appearance of any preparations to settle land; that

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage records courtroom dialogue in Burr's trial, with Burr objecting to testimony about letters and actions occurring outside Virginia's jurisdiction. Witness Mr. Belknap testifies about delivering a letter from Burr to Blennerhassett's associates, discussing rumors of unlawful expedition plans and preparations including boats and provisions.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Hay observes, that he wished to prove by Mr. Belknap that he had conveyed a letter from Aaron Burr to the party on the island, which had produced their precipitate departure. If he was not mistaken, this was at least one great point in Mr. Belknap's testimony, and it would necessarily prove how much the party on the island were under the direction and agency of the accused. Mr. Burr observed, that if they were to shew his acts done without the district of Virginia, he should object to it; that he was willing that the whole of the testimony exhibited on the former case should be gone through; and to save the time of the court, that the whole of it might be read from the judge's notes; but now it seemed, they were proceeding to an enumeration of those acts which were done out of the district.

See moreSee less

He should also protest against the right, which gentlemen were about to assume, of bringing the acts and sayings of other people at any time and place, as evidence against himself. Mr. Hay wished to prove by Mr. Belknap an act that was done, it is true, without the district of Virginia; but which was consummated in that district. He wished to prove that Mr. Burr had apprised the party in the island of his own apprehensions, that he had conveyed his dispatches by Mr. Belknap, and that they had produced the precipitate departure of his men. Mr. Burr. I will permit the gentlemen to go on with Mr. Belknap's testimony, although it is not right to produce it, because I am satisfied that Mr. B. is incapable of proving any such circumstance as they relate.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

A witness recounts carrying letters between Burr and Blannerhassett, describing their contents about boats, provisions, and travel plans down the river. The testimony details Burr's acquittal in Kentucky and discusses whether the expedition's object was against the government.

The Enquirer · 12 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

MORRIS B. BELKNAP.

Mr. Hay. Were you not on the ifland on the night of Blannerhaffett's departure? A. I was; on the night of the 10th of December. Mr. Hay. State the caufe and confequences of your going.

See moreSee less

Mr. Belknap. I had been employed by Mr. Blannerhaffett to carry a letter to John Jourdan at Lexington, Kentucky. (Mr. Hay. Jourdan is here.) In that letter, was one enclofed for Col. Burr. Sometime previous to his afking me to go to Lexington, I had ftated to him in converfation that certain rumors were afloat calculated to fhew the unlawfulnefs of his expedition. He declared to me that his expedition was not unlawful, and he read to me this letter addreffed to Col. Burr. I do not particularly recollect the contents of this letter, but this was the fubftance of it: He congratulates Col. B. on his acquittal in Kentucky, and that the grand jury did not find a bill againft him; he mentioned the ftate of the boats building on the Mufkingum, though I do not particularly recollect what he faid about them. (Q. At what time was this? A. About the middle of November 1806.) He likewife mentioned the quantity of provifions, that he fhould probably have to take down the river with him; I particularly recollect corn meal, as one of the articles. He mentioned that he fhould probably take his family down with him. The letter was long; and occupied about 2 pages of common paper, I delivered to Mr. Jourdan the letter addreffed to him. He broke the feal and requefted me to carry the enclofure to Col. Burr at Frankfort. I did carry it to Frankfort and delivered it to Col. Burr, I returned then to the ifland, and took back with me a letter from Col Burr to Mr. Blannerhaffett. Mr.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 21 September 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The court received a certified copy of parts of General Wilkinson's November 12th letter to President Jefferson, with Jefferson explaining why certain confidential passages were withheld as irrelevant to the treason charges against Burr. Proceedings also covered jury selection, including questioning of potential jurors about their prior impressions of the case.

Virginia Argus · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Latest Proceedings in the Trial.

WEDNESDAY, Sept. 9. Mr. Hay informed the court that the Express he had sent to the President of the United States, had returned, and brought a copy of such parts of the letter of November 12th, from General Wilkinson as the President thought proper to be laid before the public; with a certificate written by the President annexed to the said copy. The certificate was in the following words:— On re-examination of a letter of November 12th, 1806, from General Wilkinson to myself (which having been for a conside-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage records the detailed jury selection process for Aaron Burr's trial, with prospective jurors questioned about prior opinions on his guilt. Many were rejected for having formed decisive opinions against Burr, while twelve were ultimately sworn in, after which prosecutor Hay began outlining the misdemeanor charges under the 1794 act.

Virginia Argus · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Messrs. James Taylor, John Glynn, John New and William Rowlett, severally declared that they had formed and expressed opinions of the guilt of Aaron Burr; and were therefore rejected.

Mr. James Penn declared that he had conversed a great deal on the subject, but had no decisive opinion. He was, of course, accepted.

See moreSee less

Mr. Heath Jones Miller. I have been decidedly of one opinion, ever since the commencement; and that has been of his guilt.

Messrs. Jordan Harris, James Harris, Samuel Woodson and Benjamin Wolfe, declared that their opinions were fully made up. Mr. Wolfe said he had expressed his opinion a thousand times.

Maj. David Holloway and Mr. Richard Young were excused on account of ill health.

Mr. Thomas Lewis said that in conversation he had generally expressed himself unfavorably to Col. Burr, but had made up no decisive opinion. He was accepted.

Mr. Orris Paine (who had been called before on Monday last) was again called; when Mr. Hay asked him if he could say, with a safe conscience, that he had formed no opinion on this subject?—He answered that he had formed no decisive opinion.

The jury was then sworn; consisting of Messrs. Orris Paine, James Bootright, Obadiah Gathright, John Murphy, John M'Kim, William Bentley, Yeamans Smith, Carter Berkley, Jesse Bowles, James Penn, Robert Gordon and Thomas Lewis.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This report details courtroom proceedings in the Burr treason trial, including the prosecution's outline of the alleged conspiracy to divide the union, seize New Orleans, and attack Spanish territories. It includes exchanges between Burr, his counsel, and prosecutor Hay over the order of evidence presentation, particularly regarding witness Mr. Graham's testimony about preparations in Virginia.

Virginia Argus · 12 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

leans Territory) was called as a witness. Col. Burr wished Mr. Hay to state the substance of what he intended to prove by Mr. Graham. Mr. Hay. I expect to prove by Mr. Graham that the accused was the leader and preparer of the exe[cution]

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

A witness (likely a naval commodore) testifies at Burr's treason trial about conversations in 1806 where Burr proposed an expedition against Spanish territories including Havana, Carthagena, and Vera Cruz, aiming to establish an independent government in Mexico. The witness recounts Burr's claims that General Wilkinson and many others supported the plan, and describes his own refusal to participate or correspond with Wilkinson on Burr's behalf.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Circuit Court....Richmond.

Trial of Col. Burr.

See moreSee less

RICHMOND, AUGUST 18.

Commodore Truxton's Testimony.

About the winter of 1805-6, Col. Burr returned from the western country, and

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The Chief Justice ruled that no further testimony was relevant to the treason indictment, after which the prosecution offered nothing more. The jury deliberated briefly and returned an oddly worded verdict stating Burr was not proved guilty by the evidence submitted, which they clarified meant "not guilty," a phrasing Burr's counsel objected to before the Chief Justice accepted it as responsive to the charge.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF MR. BURR. RICHMOND, (VIRG.) AUG. 31, 1807. The Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the Court, on the motion made by the Counsel of Col. Burr, to exclude all other evidence from the consideration of the Jury, as irrelevant upon the present indictments;—the result of which opinion was, that under the particular circumstances of the case, as detailed in the evidence already given, no further testimony could be relevant. At the request of Mr. Hay, (who wished time to consider as to the course which it would be proper for the Counsel on the part of the United States to pursue) the Court adjourned until to-morrow.

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The jury returned after 25 minutes with a verdict stating Burr was not proved guilty under the indictment based on evidence submitted, rather than a simple 'Not Guilty.' Burr's counsel objected to the wording, but the Chief Justice ruled it must stand as a full answer to the charge; the court adjourned until the next day to determine further proceedings regarding Burr, while Gen. Jonathan Dayton separately answered treason charges and posted bail.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF MR. BURR.

if he were sent out again he should not agree to return a verdict in any other form; and if he were to answer cre tenus, he should use the very same words The Chief Justice said, the Court could not reject it; because it was a full answer to what was given them in charge.

Col. Burr observed, that he should not move for a discharge until to-morrow; and that if any objection should occur to that course it might now be made.

See moreSee less

The Court adjourned until to-morrow; when the Counsel for the United States will determine upon the course to be pursued with respect to Col. Burr.—Previous to the adjournment, however.

Gen Jonathan Dayton appeared in Court, to answer the indictments found against him by the Grand Jury, for treason and misdemeanour. He entered into bail, in the sum of 10,000 dollars, and Mr. Williamson and Mr. Martin entered as his sureties in the recognizance.

Mr. Martin was nearly thirteen hours in delivering his argument, on the 28th and 29th Aug.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The passage discusses the treason case against Mitchell, noting that two witnesses proved his active participation despite not being seen at every location. It then analyzes how Judge Patterson's strict constitutional standard requiring two witnesses to the same overt act would apply if similar circumstances were applied to Burr's case.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 14 September 1807 · page 1

But to estimate the dpmioa in, Mitchell's case, - let its circumstances be transferred to Burr's case.-** Suppose the body of men assembled in B la oner has sett's island bad previously met at some other place in the same county, aad that Burr had been proven , to be With them bjr four witnesses t that the pwoljf 26. -evidence that the arcuscd was nf the particular p*f~ ty which assembled on Blanneihaseett's island, bof. the whole evidence shows he was not of that patty^> * In felony then, admitting the drime to have beett'*" completed on the island, and to have been advised, procured, or commanded by the accused, hewould1 have been inrontestubly ad accessary and not'a prin-* cipali » But in-treason it is said, the law is otherwise, be cause the theatre of action is mote extensive.

See moreSee less

The reasoning applies in England as strongly Ra in the United States: While in *15 and '43 the fa mily of Stuart fought to regain the crown they had' torleited, the struggle was for the whole kingdom ;, yet do man' was ever considered'as legally present at one place, when actually at another ; or is aid ing inoc.edransaction, while actually employed in? another. With the perfect knowledge’that the v^ole nation may be the theatre of action, the English book* unite in declaring; that he who counsels,- procures* or aide-treason, is guilty accessonally and solely itt virtue of the common law principle, that what wilB make a man an accessary in felony makes him ar principal in treasom So far from considering a mam as constructively present at every overt art of the general treason in which he may have been con cerned, the whole doctrine of the books limits the* proof against liinr to those particular overt acta oi levying war with whiclrhe is charged. 1 What would be the effect of a different doctrine Clearly that which has been stated. If a person le vying war in Kentucky, may be said to be construc tively present, and assembled with a party carrying on war in Virginia, at a great distance train him g? then hc'is present at every-overt art'performed any where; he may be tried in any state on the conti nent,- where any overtact has been committed ; he* may be proved to-be guilty of an overt act laid in the indictment in which he had no personal partici pation, by proving that he advised it, or that her committed other acts. <■ This is, perhaps, too extravant to lie in-term# maintained: Certainly it cannot be supported by the doctrines of the l-.nglish law. The opinion of Judge Patterson in Mitchell's case,, has been cited on this point. 2 Dal. 348. The indictment is-not specially stated but frooy the case as reported,- it must-have beon-either gene ral for levying war in the county of Alleghany, ahd the overt act laid must have beenthe assemblage of men and levying of war in that county ; or it must have given a particular detail of the treasonable transactions iirtliat county. The first supposition is the most probable-; but let the indictment be in the one form ot the other, and the result is thw same. The facts of the-ease art, that a large body of men, of whom Mitchell was one, assembled afr Braddoek’s field, in the county of Alleghany, for tha purpose of committing acts of violence at Pittsburgh That there was alter art assemblage at a different time at Couches fort, at which the prisoner also at tended. The geueial and avowed’ object of that meeting was to concert measures for resisting tlm execution of a publirk law. At Couches fort, the resolution was taken to attack the house of the in spector, and tiie body there assembled marched to that house and attacked' it.- It was proved by the competent number ot witnesses, that be was at Couches fort armed, that he offered to reconnoitre; the house to be attacked, tliat he-marcHed with the' insurgents towards the house, that he was with them alter tlie action attending the body of one of hie comrades who was killedin it; one witness sworn positively that he was present at the burning of the* house, and a second witness said that “ it ran its his headthat he had seen hinv there.” That a doubt sboaid exist in such a case as this, is strong evi dence of the riecessity that the over* act should bn unequivocally proved by two witnesses. Hut what was the opinion of the judge in tbi* case? Couches fort and Neville’s house being in the same county, the assemblage having, been at Cou ches fort and the resolution to attackthe house having been there taken, the body having been'asseiubled for the avowed purposes moved in execution <>f that rdfco lulion towards the house tobe attacked, he inclined to think that the act of marching wasin itself le vying war. If it was, then the overt act laid inthe indictment was consummated by the assemblage afe Couches and the marching from thence, and Mit chell was proved to be guilty by more than two po sitive witnesses. But without deckling this to L» the law, he proceeded to consider the meeting at Conches, the immediate inarching to Neville's house, and the attack and burning of the house, as one transaction. Mitchell was proved by more iliac* ' two-positive witnesses to have been in-that transac tion, to have taken an active part of it, and the judge declared it to be unnecessary that all should have seen him at the same time and place. But supposed not a single witness had proved Mit chell to have been at Couches, or on the march, or at) Neville’s. Suppose he had at the time notori ously absented in a different state. Can it be be lieved by any person who observes the caution with which judge Pattersonrequired the constitutional proof of two witnesses to the same overt act, he would have said Mitchell was constructively pre sent, and might on that straining of a legal fiction; be found guilty of treason? Had be delivered such an opinion, what would have been the language of tliit country respecting it? Had he given this opinion, it would have required all the correctness of his lift to strike bis name from that bloody list ia whirls > the name of Jeffries is enrolled. Y * ‘ But to estimate the dpmioa in, Mitchell's case, - let its circumstances be transferred to Burr's case.-** Suppose the body of men assembled in B la oner has sett's island bad previously met at some other place in the same county, aad that Burr had been proven , to be With them bjr four witnesses t that the pwoljf

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

In the Burr treason trial proceedings, prosecutor Hay agrees to enter nolle prosequi on treason charges against Blannerhassett and Israel Smith, with bail for misdemeanor set at $5000 like Burr's. The passage also details jury selection, including excusals and challenges of potential jurors.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

23. Yeaman Smith was accepted.

24. Richard Young was excused on account of his indisposition.

See moreSee less

25. Carter Page was extremely indisposed; suspended until to-morrow.

26. Robert Randolph was indisposed & wished to be excused.

Mr. Burr requested him to be suspended until to-morrow. Mr. Randolph argued his extreme anxiety to be excused from serving. Mr. Hay. I do not wish to object to you sir; but there is one ground on which you may get off. Have you not formed and expressed some opinion on this subject? A. I have.

Mr. Wickham. If Mr. Randolph will deliberately declare that he cannot give an impartial verdict on this case, we wish him to be discharged. A. I must repeat that I have formed an opinion on this subject, without intending to say on which side that opinion leans. Mr. Randolph was discharged.

The Chief Justice then instructed the deputy Marshal to summons twelve additional jurymen by to-morrow.

Mr. Burr. The marshal can hand me a list of them this evening.

The court then adjourned until to-morrow 1 o'clock.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The passage details the voir dire examination of potential jurors for Aaron Burr's treason trial, with Burr personally questioning candidates about their prior opinions of him. Several jurors were excused due to expressed prejudice, personal connections to Burr, or family indisposition, while others were accepted or set aside based on their responses.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

10. Francis Walker. Mr. Burr. I challenge Mr. Walker. Mr. W. I intended to have stated my objections to serving. I believe the plans attributed to col. Burr were such as he had really formed; and that he contemplated the separation of the Western from the Atlantic States, & that after seizing on New Orleans, he intended to attack Mexico.

11. Benjamin J. Harris had received and still retained an opinion that A. B. had been guilty of something. Set aside.

See moreSee less

12. Jacob Ege had formed and expressed strong prepossessions against the accused. Set aside.

13. Tarlton Williams was not a freeholder.

14. Robert Adams had made declarations

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The passage details the ongoing voir dire process for Aaron Burr's treason trial, recording numerous potential jurors being examined, set aside due to prior opinions, or excused for health reasons. It also notes an unrelated bail proceeding for Israel Smith on a misdemeanor charge and mentions a ship's arrival with mail.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Chief Justice determined that he should give the same as Aaron Burr: 5000 dollars. The same sum was also fixed for Israel Smith.

Mr. Botts observed, that as Mr. Blannerhassett would find some difficulty in getting two securities, he hoped it was not an inflexible rule with the court to insist upon two; when one alone was deemed sufficient to cover the amount of bail. Mr. D. Woodbridge had offered himself to be Mr. Bl's bail.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. I can have no objection, if the court deems one security sufficient.

Mr. Woodbridge was accepted.

Some conversation then ensued about the jury; when it was determined to examine but not to swear them to-day.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The court discusses the judge's charge regarding what constitutes treason and overt acts, noting the prosecution's evidence may be insufficient. The jury ultimately returns a verdict finding Aaron Burr 'not proved to be guilty' under the indictment.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 15 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

Burr, the jury were informed that the court by no means intended to interfere with their rights, and, if they chose to find him guilty upon the testimony which had been introduced, they had a right to do so!!

The joy and exultation visible in the faces of Burr and his friends, was such as might have been expected.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

After brief deliberation, the jury found Aaron Burr not guilty of treason, with foreman Col. Carrington presenting a written verdict that Burr's counsel initially objected to as improperly formatted. The Chief Justice ruled the verdict could stand and be recorded as 'not guilty,' though a juror noted the written form had been necessary for the panel's agreement.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 15 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The jury then withdrew ; and, after an absence of twenty minutes, returned into court ; and Col. Carrington their foreman offered their verdict, in the following words indorsed on the bill of indictment : "We of "the jury find that Aaron Burr is not prov-"ed to be guilty under this indictment by "any evidence submitted to us. We therefore "find him not guilty."

Col. Burr and his Counsel warmly objected to this verdict, as informal, and not au-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Mr. Wickham argues for the defense that the indictment against Burr is improperly framed, citing legal precedents to claim it should have specified named co-conspirators and the location of treasonous acts. He further contends that before evidence connecting Burr to Blennerhassett can be admitted, the prosecution must first prove an overt act of treason occurred, questioning whether a hostile assemblage actually took place on Blennerhassett's Island.

The Enquirer · 16 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

that the doctrine that in treason all in England are principals, applies only to the punishment and to the denomination of the offence, and not to the manner of profecution; that if a person gives traitors advice in one county, and the treason is committed in another, he must be indicted in the county where he gave the advice, for there his offence was committed; and that therefore Col. Burr ought not to have been tried here—if any where.

FRIDAY, August 21.

See moreSee less

Mr. Wickham contended, that even if all these points were against him, there was one so perfectly clear on reason and authority, that in a cafe of less importance, no other need to have been mentioned; that if aiders, procurers and abettors of treason be liable, their guilt being derivative, can only be established by legal proof that the principals are guilty, and the only proof is a record of their conviction. To this point he spoke at considerable length and quoted 4th St. Tr. 130 for Act of Parliament reversing Lady Lyfle's attainder, Lord Hale 1, 613, Foster, ch 2, sec. 38, p. 100.

Mr. W. observed, that if it were possible that he could be wrong in this point, he would then contend that before the evidence of the connection of the accessary Mr. Burr with the principal Mr. Blannerhaffett was given, it must appear to the Court that the principal was really guilty of an overt act of treason; and that from the circumstances of the cafe there was no hostile assemblage of men on Bl's Island; that if it be objected, that if the court undertook to decide this question, they would invade the province of the jury, it might then be answered, that the jury were to decide on the weight of the evidence only; the court must decide upon its relevancy. Mr. W. then enquired what constituted an overt act of levying war; and inferred from the opinion of the Chief Justice on a former occasion, Mr. Rawle's argument in the trial of Fries; and Fries's trial p. 19, 20; that all these authorities proved that actual or potential force was necessary. Mr. W.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

During Aaron Burr's treason trial, prosecutor Mr. McRae argues that even though Burr was not physically present at Blennerhassett's Island, he directed treasonous activity there. He outlines evidence including testimony from Eaton, Truxtun, and the Morgans, and claims Burr organized enlistment, provisions, and boats for the men gathered on the island.

The Enquirer · 16 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

we must rely, and have attacked them as arbitrary and oppressive; as springing from the cruelty of judges like Lord Coke, whom Mr. Wickham declared to have been without bowels, and Mr. Randolph without a heart. I will read one of those cases (Throckmorton's case 1 St. Tr. 60) to shew how differently constituted the court who tried Throckmorton was from this court; how widely dissimilar the situation and treatment of Aaron Burr during this trial has been from Throckmorton's before the commissioners who tried him; and to demonstrate that that case has nothing to do with this.

See moreSee less

Mr. McRae then read a large part of Throckmorton's case; from which it appeared that no counsel was allowed him; books were withheld from him; he was not listened to by the court; and confessions of others were read as evidence against him without proof of his connexion with them. He strongly contrasted with those tyrannical proceedings, the advantages which Aaron Burr had enjoyed during this prosecution. Whereas Throckmorton had no counsel, Aaron Burr has six, most able and learned in the law; one of whom was attorney general of Mary-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

During Aaron Burr's treason trial, prosecutor Mr. McRae cites the Throckmorton case to argue legal definitions of principal traitors acting in concert. He contrasts the harsh treatment of Throckmorton with the extensive legal resources, counsel, and courtroom freedoms afforded to Burr.

The Enquirer · 16 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the United States without being personally present? Mr. McRae was about to speak of the evidence which might be adduced to prove that Aaron Burr, although not present at Blannerhassett's island, at the time charged in the indictment, did in fact levy war against the United States at that time and place; when Mr. Martin interrupted him and objected to his saying any thing about the evidence which had not been heard. Here a desultory conversation took place for a few minutes; the counsel for the U. States declaring that they were ready to introduce the evidence if permitted; and Col.

See moreSee less

Burr and his counsel objecting to the evidence being admitted and insisting that nothing should be said concerning it. But the Ch. Just. said that Mr. McRae had a right to suppose the existence of any evidence which could by possibility be adduced to prove the prisoner guilty, as the motion was to exclude all evidence. Mr. McRae proceeded—can any person doubt after hearing the testimony of Gen. Eaton, Commodore Truxton, and the Morgans, the treasonable intention of the prisoner? The credibility of all those witnesses is unimpeached; and Eaton's evidence is immediately to the point. [Here Mr. McRae took a review of the evidence which had been introduced.] Suppose, in addition to all this, we can prove that the men who came to Blannerhassett's island came thither by Aaron Burr's

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage reports courtroom arguments between prosecutor Mr. McRae and defense counsel Mr. Wickham regarding legal precedents for treason prosecution. McRae argues Burr was a principal in the treason, not merely an accessory, and disputes defense citations of prior cases including Lord Balmerino's case.

The Enquirer · 16 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

fecution. But we do not rely upon any fuch cafes. No part of the evidence goes to prove Aaron Burr an acceffory after the fact. He was the Alpha and Omega, the body and the foul of this treafon; not an acceffory at all, but a principal; and the chief among

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

This report examines the Chief Justice's legal opinion on what constitutes 'levying war' under the treason charge against Aaron Burr, parsing the meaning of 'assemblage' and whether an actual gathering of armed men was required. It quotes and interprets the court's reasoning about whether marching in detachments toward a rendezvous point would satisfy the legal definition of treason.

Virginia Argus · 16 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

OPINION

of force?

After quoting the words of Mr. Swartwout, from the affidavit in which it was stated that Mr. Burr was levying an army of 7,000 men, and observing that the treason to be inferred from these words would depend on the intention with which it was levyed, and on the progress which had been made in levying it, the court say " the question then is, whether this evidence proves col. Burr to have advanced so far in levying an army as actually to have as-

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 5 September 1807
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 9 September 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes conversations with Blennerhassett about the expedition's purpose, including plans for war with Spain or settlement on the Washita if peace held, and names of supposed participants. The witness also recounts how General Eaton's contradictory deposition caused several men, including himself, to abandon the enterprise upon realizing they had been deceived.

Virginia Argus · 16 September 1807 · page 3

■ ri. nils ; and this occasioned several to » bandon the expedition, finding tiny hud neon deceived. Mr. //hi/. U id yoit anv conversation wiih Col, Burr ? A. No. Me

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report covers courtroom proceedings in Aaron Burr's treason trial, focusing on witness Marris B. Belknap's testimony about events on Blennerhassett Island. Attorneys Hay and Burr dispute the scope of evidence, particularly regarding a letter Burr allegedly sent that prompted the party's hasty departure from the island.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 September 1807 · page 2

Mr. He}; ivished to profit: by Mr. Belle. ———-—————v————ffl_———__—_—__—_— nap an act that was done, it is true, without the districtsi of Virginia; but was consum mated in that districr. He wished to prove that Mr. Burr had appssrised the party in the island of his own apprehensions, that he had conveyed his dispatches by Mr Belk. nsp, and that they had produced the preci pitate departure of his men Mr. Bu; r. I Will permit the gentlemen to go on with Mrss. Belknap' s testimony al though it is not right to prodnssceit, be cause Iam satisfied that Mr B is incapable l of proviog any stfch circumstance as they relate. . . --— ] Marris B. Belhpaþ. ] Mr. Hay K-Vexc you not on the island !

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Witness Morris Belknap testifies about carrying letters between Aaron Burr and Blennerhassett, including details on provisions and expedition plans. He recounts a letter congratulating Burr on his Kentucky acquittal and mentions boat-building on the Muskingum River.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 September 1807 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A letter from Richmond describes court proceedings in the Burr treason trial, including arguments by counsel and rulings on evidence and testimony. The text is heavily corrupted by OCR damage, and portions mix in unrelated commentary on British impressment and neutral rights.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WASHINGTON CITY, FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 18.

A letter is received in this city, dated Richmond, 13th inst. by which it appears that the court had that day given an opinion in the case of colonel Burr, that may be said to have put an end to the proceedings in this case. It goes to the exclusion of testimony, and of course to the acquittal of Burr, on the charge against him for a misdemeanor. The substance only of the opinion which is given above, that no testimony would be permitted to be adduced, is given in the letter.

See moreSee less

After the opinion of the court was delivered several questions were addressed to the Chief Justice by the counsel for the U. States, as to the effect of that opinion, upon particular points. At length it was deemed the most eligible course to adjourn the court till the next day, in order that the counsel on both sides might be furnished with

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

Aaron Burr's defense counsel submitted five legal points to the court regarding the treason/misdemeanor indictment, arguing that no accessorial offense exists under the relevant act of Congress and that acts on Blannerhassett's Island did not constitute setting on foot a military expedition. Counsel contended the statute was too vague and ambiguous to be enforced under rules of construing penal statutes.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FRIDAY EVENING, SEPT. 18, 1807.

TRIAL OF AARON BURR ON THE MISDEMEANOR.

See moreSee less

The counsel of Mr. Burr on the 9th instant submitted the following points for the consideration of the court:

1. That under the act of Congress there can be no accessorial offender, i. e. none are within the pains of the statute but such as are acting at the fact.

2. If the first point be not sustainable, no act of Col. Burr out of the district can be given in evidence against him.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 25 September 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The report covers defense counsel Botts's legal arguments about what legally constitutes a 'military expedition' under the act of Congress, followed by the Chief Justice's opinion favoring the accused. The jury ultimately found Aaron Burr Not Guilty, with the piece also noting a related correspondence concerning an attack on Major M'Rae.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

enquiring into what constitutes the offence under the act of Congress, he contended that the act was so uncertain and ambiguous that it never could be carried into execution. He instanced many cases which went to shew, that according to the rules of construing penal statutes, this act could not be enforced. He argued that providing the means spoken of in the act of Congress, required the entire means; that the means must be, not of an expedition merely, but a military expedition; that to make it a military expedition it must have military character, the most essential means of a military expedition is a military organization; that there must be a military posture; that the means must be adequate to the end; that no assembly of men was engaged in this expedition, nor was Burr ever present at it; that no intention could aid facts in furnishing the means of a military expedition; that war might be without military form, but the means of a military expedition must have a military character; and that hostile means will not do, the means must be military.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The passage reports courtroom proceedings from Burr's treason trial on September 15, detailing arguments between prosecutor Hay and defense counsel over the admissibility of testimony linking Burr to military preparations on Blennerhassett's Island. Witnesses including Woodbridge and Taylor are examined about boat-building, provisions, and corn purchases connected to the alleged expedition.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

Mr. Dudley Woodbridge was then called up, whose testimony we have already retailed in the Enquirer. He now gave a particular history of his contract with Burr, the building of the boats and the preparing of provisions. The prosecution interrogated him particularly about the corn which Mr. Blannerhassett had purchased on his island, and attempted to show that in this transaction he acted under the powers of the firm. The opposite counsel asked him, whether this purchase of corn had ever been carried into the company's books. A. No. Whether were the partnership accounts settled? A. Yes.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report examines the court's legal reasoning regarding whether an actual assemblage of armed men is required to constitute the crime of levying war, referencing the Swartwout case and testimony about Burr's alleged army of 7,000 men. It scrutinizes the court's distinction between a mere agreement to assemble versus an actual gathering with appearance of force.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"the question then is, whether this evidence proves colonel Burr to have advanced so far in levying an army as actually to have assembled them."

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness is cross-examined by prosecution and defense about Blennerhassett's recruitment efforts, the stated purpose of the expedition (war with Spain or settlement on the Ouachita), and Burr's own statements about boats, signals, and men joining the enterprise. The witness describes his own initial involvement, his decision to withdraw after hearing of General Eaton's deposition, and details about Burr's cautionary instructions regarding public sentiment and constituted authorities.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

[CONTINUED]

He mentioned gen. Wilkinson.

Mr. Wirt. Did you go down with him?

See moreSee less

A. I did not. Q what prevented you?—

A. When I had returned to Marietta I received a letter from young Danielson, stating to me the substance of general Eaton's deposition. I repeated this important contradiction of one of Blannerhasset's statements to a number of my friends and they all abandoned the enterprize.

Mr. Hay. Had you any conversation with Mr. Burr? A. We had some about the boats and the party.

Mr. McRae. How many persons desisted from the enterprize? A. Mr. Cushing, Mr. Munn, and two or three from Marietta.

Mr. Hay. Did you not carry some message to Blannerhassett about the necessity of his immediate departure? A. No. Col. Burr stated this; that he believed in con

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The report describes the final days of Aaron Burr's treason trial, including Chief Justice Marshall's lengthy opinion favorable to Burr delivered on September 14. The jury then returned a verdict of NOT GUILTY on the treason charge.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF COL. BURR

10 o'clock.

Tuesday, September 15. Mr. Hay wished to enter a nolle prosequi on the indictment; this was objected to by colonel Burr, and submitted to the court, who decided against it. The case was submitted to the jury, and they returned a verdict of NOT GUILTY.

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The court proceeded with Aaron Burr's misdemeanor trial after discharging him on treason charges. General Dayton's treason indictment was dropped via nolle prosequi, and he pleaded not guilty to a misdemeanor charge, while disputes continued over production of General Wilkinson's letters to the President.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 18 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

strong doubts upon this point. At length the chief justice determined that he would proceed upon the trial of the indictment for misdemeanor to-morrow if Col. Burr should be ready.

Col. Burr was declared by the court

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The chief justice ruled that a capias was the proper process for indicting Burr on the misdemeanor charge, after reviewing precedents. Burr then argued for reduced bail given his changed circumstances, and the judge proposed lowering it to $5,000, leading to further argument among counsel.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 18 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Latest proceedings in the case of Col. Burr.

RICHMOND, September 3.

See moreSee less

The chief justice delivered his opinion as to the proper process of an indictment for a misdemeanor of the kind charged against col. Burr; the result of which was, after examining the laws of congress and reviewing all the precedents, that the regular process was a capias.

Col. Burr proposed a reduction of the sum in which he had before given

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage reports courtroom arguments from Burr's defense team contending he cannot be a principal in treason since he was not present on Blennerhassett's Island during the assemblage. The defense argues the indictment must be proved as laid, and that evidence of other acts cannot establish treason by relation without first proving conviction of principals in the first degree.

The Enquirer · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

of treason.

Let us examine the first ground: — it is because A. Burr, not being present on the island at the time of the assemblage cannot be a principal in the treason within the constitutional de-

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This report discusses the Supreme Court's opinion in the Bollman and Swartwout case, examining the Court's reasoning on treason and the concept of constructive presence in a treasonable assemblage. It analyzes testimony from General Eaton, General Wilkinson, the ciphered letter, and Swartwout's declarations regarding Burr's alleged levying of an armed force, questioning the Court's logic about absence versus guilt by conspiracy.

The Enquirer · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

look to the deposition of gen. Eaton and gen. Wilkinson, to the cyphered letter, to the declaration of Swartwout that Burr was levying an armed body of seven thousand men; and they look to these parts of the evidence expresly for the purpose of discovering whether it was probable that Burr had actually brought those men together; not whether Bollman and Swartwout

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage presents a legal argument that physical presence at the overt act of treason is not required to establish guilt, arguing that Aaron Burr as the principal instigator bears greater moral culpability than the men he deceived into action at Blennerhassett's Island. The writer cites English common law precedent (Lord Coke) to support the Supreme Court's constitutional interpretation of treason, warning that requiring actual presence would create a loophole for ambitious plotters to escape punishment while their dupes suffer death.

The Enquirer · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

require actual presence at the overt act to constitute the guilt of treason : nor can a sound mind or a sound heart doubt one moment, between the comparative guilt of Aaron Burr (the prime mover of the whole mischief) and of the

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Following the court's prior ruling on evidence, prosecution and defense counsel argue over whether testimony about events at Cumberland Island and the mouth of Cumberland River can be admitted against Burr. Witnesses are examined regarding Burr's presence and statements, with lawyers disputing how the Chief Justice's opinion restricts what evidence may be presented to the jury.

Virginia Argus · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ken place.

Mr. Martin proposed that the gentlemen should offer any evidence which they had, and the counsel for Col. Burr would then make their objections.

See moreSee less

Mr. Neal was called a second time. Mr. M'Rae asked him if he was at the island about the time laid in the indictment. He answered that he knew nothing about those transactions, and was therefore examined no farther.

Mr. James M'Dowell was next sworn. Mr. Hay. This witness is introduce to prove what passed, in an interview between the accused and himself at the mouth of Cumberland, where the accused was, at the head of the party assembled, and stated to him the object of the expedition. Mr. M'Dowell, being questioned said he was one of those who went down the river, and that he first saw Col. Burr at the mouth of Cumberland.

Col. Burr objected to this evidence.

Mr. Wirt contended it was admissible

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

Prosecutor Hay moves to commit Burr, Blennerhassett, and Smith for trial on treason charges in another district, alleging the overt act occurred at the mouth of the Cumberland. The Chief Justice and counsel dispute procedural matters, including whether charges should be heard separately and jurisdictional questions about the location.

Virginia Argus · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WEDNESDAY, September 16. Mr. Hay made his motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhasset and Smith. Col. Burr said, that notwithstanding he might claim his discharge on the ground of acquittal, he agreed to permit the evidence

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The passage reports courtroom arguments in Aaron Burr's treason trial, with counsel debating whether the court has jurisdiction over acts committed in the Mississippi Territory and whether Burr's acquittal on the Blennerhassett Island overt act bars further prosecution. The Chief Justice reserves judgment on the constitutional question, and proceedings continue into the next day with debate over whether to hear witness testimony before further argument.

Virginia Argus · 19 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

threshold. He also observed that the acquittal of Col. Burr for the treason prohibited farther enquiry.

The Chief Justice said he wished that question to be reserved, as he did not wish to decide it, unless it should be absolute

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A witness is cross-examined about conversations with Blannerhassett and Burr regarding the expedition, including mentions of a possible war with Spain, settlement on the Ouachita, and names like Wilkinson and Gallatin. The witness describes abandoning the enterprise after learning of General Eaton's contradictory deposition.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Had you any conversation with Mr. Burr? A. We had some about the boats and the party. Mr. M'Rae. How many persons desisted from the enterprize? A. Mr. Cushing, Mr. Mann, and two or three from Marietta. Mr. Hay. Did you not carry some message to Blannerhassett, about the necessity of his immediate departure? A. No. Col. Burr stated this; that he believed in consequence of newspaper reports, the public mind was much incensed; that he apprehended the party would meet with some opposition in going down the river; and that he hoped they would not oppose the constituted authorities.

See moreSee less

Q. Were there any men preparing to depart when you arrived on the island? A. When I returned from Lexington, I was surprised at the number of men whom I saw there; about 20. Mr. Wirt. When Burr spoke of these men and boats, did he speak of them as having any authority over them? A. He spoke of them as one concerned. Mr.

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

A witness is questioned about Blannerhassett's sudden departure, his connection to Burr, and offers of land made to induce participation in the expedition. The testimony touches on rumors of a Spanish war versus invasion of Mexico, and mentions Blannerhassett's statements implicating Gallatin's involvement.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

tin and Burr both objected to this question. Mr. M‘Rae. My object is, next to ask the witness whether Col. Burr did not inquire about this state of the public mind? Did not Mr. Burr say something about it? A. He asked me what was going on abroad, such was his expression. I particularly recollect him to have asked this question; whether I had seen any thing in the papers from the government on this subject. I replied, that I had not. Q. What offers did they make to induce you to join them? A. None particularly, except that if when I descended the river, I did not find gens. Eaton and Wilkinson either there or coming there, and if there was no Spanish war; then Blannerhassett was to bear my expences back. Mr. M‘Rae. Then you considered yourself as engaged for a Spanish war? A. I did. Q. And Mr. Gallatin was to have joined? A. Yes: most particularly; so Mr. Blannerhassett said.

Cross examined by the accused.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. Do you remember a particular portion of land, which I offered

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 18 September 1807

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

Prosecutor George Hay returns a redacted copy of a presidential letter subpoenaed by Burr's defense, withholding parts he deems confidential and irrelevant. Burr's counsel threatens to seek an attachment against Hay or halt proceedings until the full letter is produced, while Hay insists he would rather go to jail than surrender it.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Trial of Col. Burr.

RICHMOND, SEPT. 4. The following is Mr. Hay's return made this day to the writ of subpœna duces tecum :

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The court ruled that General Wilkinson's letter must be produced despite prosecutor Hay's objections, though confidential portions would be protected from public disclosure. Burr was discharged from the treason indictment but faces trial for misdemeanor, while Dayton's treason charge was also dropped via nolle prosequi.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Tray said, he should consult Gen. Wilkinson, and he hoped he would consent to the production of the letter, under the restrictions mentioned by the court. The Marshal was instructed to summon a jury, and Monday was fixed for the trial of Burr, for misdemeanor. Mr. Burr has been discharged from the indictment for Treason. The Attorney of the U. S. has entered a nole prosequi on the indictment found against Gen. Dayton for treason. He has pleaded not guilty to the indictment for misdemeanor

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

This editorial defends Chief Justice Marshall and the Burr acquittal against accusations from Democratic writers that the verdict encourages treason. It explains that the indictment charged treason at Blannerhassett's Island in Virginia, but evidence showed Burr was in Kentucky at the time, making conviction legally impossible.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Burr has violated the laws of society, every friend of the country would rejoice at his conviction ; but would any good citizen wish to see the laws and consti

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The piece argues that Burr's treason charge for Blennerhassett's Island collapsed because evidence showed he was in Kentucky at the time, making continued prosecution there illegal. It defends Chief Justice Marshall against newspaper accusations that he improperly favored Burr, insisting he ruled strictly on legal principle rather than personal favor.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 21 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

and so nefarious an assertion? There cannot be a single instance shown of Mr. Marshall's neglecting the interposition or prerogative of the Court, when proper or necessary. There were sometimes instances where the opposite counsel disagreed, and the Court did not interfere till time was given them to come to a mutual agreement. If such agreement did not take place, the Court never shrunk from its duty in giving a decision; and that in writing, with the reasons for it, on all important questions. How many times, in dispute, some of great, and some of less moment, did Judge Marshall decide against Burr's counsel.

See moreSee less

But it was not a question with him, in whose favor the decision might be; but what was the law, or what were the sound legal principles by which he ought to be governed. This New-York writer knows little indeed of the character of the Chief Justice, to suppose him capable of intentionally perverting the law or established legal modes of proceeding for the purpose of clearing a man charged with so heinous a crime as that of treason, a crime, in the punishment of the author of which, the duty and the interest of every individual in the union is concerned. What possible motive can it be supposed that Judge Marshall could have, in a wish to save Burr? Placed in the exalted situation of the first Judicial officer in the union; under the most solemn obligations of an oath; acting under the highest degree of responsibility; in a cause of greater magnitude, and more interest, than any that has yet come before any Court in the United States; having the eyes of his political enemies, constantly turned with scrutinizing fierceness towards every act of his, and their ears carefully gathering every sound that should escape his lips; and sometimes deciding new principles hereafter to operate as precedents: what inducement, we ask, could he have, wilfully to go wrong, or knowingly to relinquish his authority or prerogative, where it ought to be exercised? None. Judge Marshall is as much interested in the punishment of a traitor, as any man in the union. Every man wishes such punishment, except those concerned in the treason; but, on the supposition of Burr's guilt, if he has so conducted, that neither the constitution, the laws, nor the established legal principles and precedents, can condemn him, would you have the constitution and laws trampled under foot and have him condemned by the law of public opinion; or that of common sense?—Why was the Constitution itself, so particular on this very subject? Because its framers had seen in England, the injustice and the murders committed by the Judges under the Crown, on the vague unfettled notion of constructive treason.—If Burr has been guilty, every good man will regret that he could not be legally convicted; but if it be necessary to burn the statute books to convict him, we say it is better that he escape.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This report records courtroom argument over whether declarations made by alleged co-conspirators, out of court and not under oath, can be used as evidence against Aaron Burr. It distinguishes between conspiracy as the crime itself versus conspiracy as evidence of criminal intent, debating which legal standard applies to Burr's case.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.

3dly, The admission of the declarations of Mr. Blannerhassett may be instituted upon under the idea he was the agent of col. Burr. How far the

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

This report covers courtroom arguments and judicial ruling on whether actions taken in Kentucky, such as providing arms or enlisting men, can be used as evidence to prove the expedition charged in the indictment at Blannerhassett's Island. The judge discusses the legal principle that distinct offenses generally cannot be used to prove a separate charged crime, while acknowledging exceptions for evidence showing the character of the expedition itself.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

vidence upon the same principle that the state of the expedition may be shown, it does not follow that other acts of third persons may be given in evidence.

It has also been contended that no transactions out of the district are testimony.

See moreSee less

This position is correct to a considerable extent, but not to the extent in which it is laid down. A declaration of Mr. Burr for example when in Kentucky or elsewhere, that he did set on foot a

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 30 September 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper

A court argument examines whether Aaron Burr can be held legally liable for the actions of accomplices who provided means for the military expedition, drawing parallels to Colonel Smith's case involving money. The argument distinguishes between directly committing an act versus advising or procuring it, questioning whether the same legal penalty applies to both under strict construction of penal law.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

curately stated, and the question has been argued without them, the court must decline giving any opinion, or consider the orders as offered, and say what orders would be admissible and what inadmissible. The latter course may save the bar the trouble of another argument. To whom are orders supposed to have been given, and who are supposed to have executed them? They must have been given to accomplices or to those who had no share in the expedition. If accomplices, under the direction of col. Burr, have provided the means, can their liability to the penalties of the law be doubted?

See moreSee less

I presume not.—If persons engaged in the expedition have provided the means for carrying it on, it will I presume be admitted that they are within the letter and the spirit of the act. Each man has himself provided and prepared those particular means which he has furnished. If col. Burr, as was the case with col. Smith,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 30 September 1807

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Public Ledger publishes the Chief Justice's opinion in United States vs. Aaron Burr and defends the court against accusations of bias. The editorial argues the judge must impartially apply the law regardless of political pressure or popular opinion about Burr's guilt.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HIS FORM AND PRESSURE.

MONDAY EVENING, SEPT. 21, 1807.

See moreSee less

TRIAL OF AARON BURR.—We have occupied a very considerable portion of our paper this day with the opinion of the Chief Justice in the important case of the United States vs Aaron Burr on a misdemeanor. We have deemed this to be a duty which we were bound to perform, in order that, as far as we have the means, we may counteract the malicious insinuations which have been made against the court. That Aaron Burr may merit punishment,

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report criticizes a court decision that arrested the ordinary course of testimony in Aaron Burr's treason trial, lamenting that only fifteen of 135 witnesses had been examined. It questions whether vital testimony from Wilkinson and others will now be suppressed, implicating unnamed persons.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 22 September 1807 · page 1

BURR'S TRIAL

_thefe fifteen but a few have said any thing of the dire& agency of Burr.— The moment he wa< pursued into the states of Ohio and Kentucky, and the territories, the disclosure is arrested-— by whom ? By Aaron Burr ahd his counsel—and the arreltation, although strenuously opposed by the council for the United States, is fun&ioned by the court. The question forcibly prefeats Jitfelf —are the nation to have the door fhnt againit that. mass of te@imony, which is expe@ed, from Wilkinfon.and the other witnesses. fommoned™? Are they flill to grope in the dark on points of valt importance, which deeply im

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

During the federal circuit court proceedings, Aaron Burr's defense sought production of an original letter from General Wilkinson to President Jefferson dated November 12, 1806. Prosecutor Hay withheld portions he deemed confidential and irrelevant, prompting a subpoena duces tecum and a dispute over what parts of the letter must be disclosed.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 22 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR. FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT. FRIDAY, SEPT. 4,

FRIDAY, SEPT. 4. The proceedings of this day, commenced with an application on the part of Aaron Burr, for the production of an original letter from Gen. Wilkinson, to the president

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

George Hay certifies a copy of a letter dated November 12, 1806, withholding parts deemed confidential and not material to the case, with discretion delegated by the President. Burr's counsel pushes for a court rule compelling production of the full letter, leading to the Chief Justice ruling that it must be produced, with safeguards to keep confidential portions from public disclosure.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 22 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

GEORGE HAY.”

Col. Burr's counsel then observed that they had two resources for compelling the production of the paper; either to move for an attachment against Mr. Hay, which

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The passage records courtroom argument over whether accessorial acts must be detailed in a treason indictment against Burr, concluding the charge of levying war is sufficient. It also presents the court's opinion on two questions: whether a judge of this court can commit a person for trial in Mississippi Territory, and whether a verdict here bars prosecution elsewhere for different overt acts of treason.

The Enquirer · 22 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

came directly in question before the court, it was unanimously and solemnly declared to be sufficient.

Is it not sufficient in reason as well as in law? Is it to be believed that A. Burr is not sufficiently apprized by this indictment of the charge against him to prepare for his defence? Has he not prepared, sir? Look at the fact. He himself states that he has summoned twenty or thirty witnesses.

See moreSee less

Let us not then, Sir, by these captious exceptions unsupported either by law or reason, permit ourselves to be turned aside from the enquiry before us. Reason and law concur in shewing that there is nothing in Mr. Wickham's second point to obstruct the evidence.

OPINION of the Court--Delivered on

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Witness James McDowell testifies about the number of men, arms, powder, and bullets assembled with Burr's party at the mouth of Cumberland river. He describes the party's composition, leadership under Burr with Tyler and Blennerhassett, and notes most men appeared to be gentlemen rather than laborers.

The Enquirer · 22 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE. Friday, Sept. 18. James Mc'Dowel. Mr. Hay. Did you go as low as the Chickasaw Bluffs? A. I did. Q. What number of men were assembled at the mouth of Cumberland river? A. About 100. Q. How many additional men joined them there? A. I do not recollect. Q. Did you see any boxes of Arms? A. No. Q. Did you see any guns with bayonets? A. I saw a few. Q. Any pistols? A. Six or eight Pair; and some rifles. Q. Do you know of any men who joined them at Fort Massac?

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr objected to this question. Fort Massac was in the Indiana Territory.--Mr. Hay. Did you see any powder? Yes. Q. What quantity? A. A couple of small casks. Q. Did you see any bullets; and what quantity? A. I helped to run some myself, & I saw one barrel about two thirds full. I saw those bullets below Bayou Pierre. Q. Did you see Blannerhassett and Smith? A. Yes. Q. Did this party seem to be under Burr's command? A. They said, it was Col. Burr's boats and party. They regarded themselves as under his direction. Q. Were there any other officers apparently under Burr's command? A. Yes, Col. Tyler was an off[ic]er and Mr. Blanner-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The report covers several days of courtroom argument in Richmond over whether Burr, Blennerhassett and Smith could be sent to another district for trial on treason charges tied to acts in Mississippi territory. Chief Justice Marshall ultimately ruled he had no power to commit them for trial in the Mississippi territory court, so that avenue would not be pursued.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 23 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

POSTCRIPT.

BURR'S TRIAL.——Our accounts from Richmond embrace the proceedings of the Court on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday last. On WEDNESDAY Mr. Hay moved to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett and Smith, with a view to sending them to another

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A reader writes to the editor criticizing the newspaper's celebratory tone over Aaron Burr's acquittal on treason charges. The writer argues that while Burr may be legally innocent, his moral culpability—especially given Hamilton's death—should bar him from future honor or elevation.

Virginia Argus · 23 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

From the New-York Evening Post.

COMMUNICATION.

See moreSee less

Mr. Coleman,

I read with considerable pain and mortification, your editorial article in last evening's paper, respecting the acquittal and discharge of Col. Burr. The exulting manner in which you treated the subject was unbecoming the principles you have so long and so ably supported. What is there in the result of this prosecution that can justly be considered as a matter of triumph, among men of understanding and integrity? Such persons will undoubtedly always feel great satisfaction in seeing the law take its course, and justice administered with purity and impartiality, whether Col. Burr be the subject of it, or the humblest creature in existence. To acquiesce therefore in the decision of the court on Burr's case, and to submit to it as the correct judgment of law is the duty of every good citizen; but to rejoice in it belongs only to the partizans of the man himself. I trust that Federalists will not by any public countenance of Mr. Burr, forget what they owe to the memory of Hamilton, and what is due to their own honor. Let me not be misunderstood: I would not hang Burr for treason, if he is not legally guilty of it, because he murdered Hamilton; still, bearing this event in mind, I think he has forfeited all claims to our sympathies. Whilst I would withhold from him therefore, every thing like favor, I would by no means exclude him from justice. The legal proof against Mr. Burr of treason, failed—but will honorable men say that he has established his innocence in a moral point of view; I have no desire if I know my own heart to be vindictive; but I cannot help viewing it as both dangerous and disgraceful to contribute in any degree to the future elevation of a man, who has so deservedly lost the confidence of his country. Let us then stand indifferent with regard to his fate, so long as he in common with every one else enjoys the security and protection which the law guarantees alike to all. But let us beware of representing him as martyr.

C. D.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The report describes testimony taken from witnesses including Jacob Allbright and Peter Taylor during Aaron Burr's treason trial, followed by the Chief Justice's decision to arrest further proceedings before the bulk of testimony could be heard. The editor expresses regret that the broader conspiracy may never be fully disclosed, noting only 15 of 135 witnesses had testified.

Virginia Argus · 23 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

have said any thing of the direct agency of Burr. The moment he was pursued into the states of Ohio and Kentucky, and the territories, the disclosure is arrested—by whom? By Aaron Burr and his counsel—and the arrestation, although strenuously opposed by the counsel for the U. States, is sanctioned by the court. The question forcibly presents itself—are the nation to have the door shut against that mass of testimony, which is expected from Wilkinson and the other witnesses summoned? Are

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

Legal argument continues on whether treason indictments must specify an overt act, with citations to Hale and East on pleading standards. In court, Burr demands specification of the charge against him, and counsel dispute whether the alleged levying of war occurred at the mouth of the Cumberland River, raising jurisdictional questions about Virginia versus Kentucky.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL of AARON BURR. ON THE INDICTMENT &c. WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16.

DEMEANOR.

WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr observed that he should wave the right to which he was entitled of putting an end to this enquiry at the present time; but that as much had been said boldly about his levying war

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The court debates jurisdiction over the island at the mouth of the Cumberland River where the alleged treason occurred, with arguments over whether Blannerhassett and Smith should be tried together with Burr. The prosecution then calls witness James W. Dowell, who describes meeting Burr, Blannerhassett, and others at the Cumberland River and forming a secret council about their river expedition.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The attorney of the U. S. for the Virginia district, charges A. Burr, Herman Blannerhassett and Israel Smith, with treason, in levying war against the U. S. and charges that an overt act of levying war was committed on an is-

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A witness describes meeting Colonel Burr at the mouth of the Cumberland River and the secretive organization of boats and men under Comfort Tyler and Blannerhassett as they traveled downriver. The passage then shifts to courtroom argument among prosecutor Hay, defense counsel Wickham, and co-counsel M'Rae over whether testimony about an alleged overt act should be admitted before the court, with Chief Justice Marshall weighing in on procedure.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 25 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

it. We went on down to Bayou Pierre. Mr. Burr. Gentlemen have set out to prove an act of war at the mouth of Cumberland river. We shall presently object to that kind of testimony, they are now bringing forward.—Mr. Wick-

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The judge discusses his unresolved doubts about whether levying war constitutes a single continuous crime, comparing it to felony jurisdiction rules, and whether a separate indictment could be brought for actions in Kentucky despite Burr's acquittal. He also addresses rumors that the court had reversed rather than construed the Supreme Court's opinion in the Bollman and Swartwout case, which he denies.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 25 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

My doubt consists in this. The overt act now charged could not have been laid in the indictment on which col. Burr has been tried. There is therefore

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

Defense and prosecution argue whether the Blennerhassett Island assemblage constituted an overt act of treason requiring actual force, with Burr claiming new evidence suggests he was betrayed. The Chief Justice allows depositions to be taken while witnesses Dunbaugh, McDowell, and Miller are examined in court.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 25 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

military attitude was sufficient to constitute treason.

On Monday Mr. Burr came prepared to discuss the propositions which he had advanced on Saturday. He added that no man could be more dissatisfied than himself with th[e]

See the clipping

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.

The report describes the Chief Justice's legal opinion on evidence admissibility, followed by the jury's verdict of 'Not Guilty' after brief deliberation on Tuesday. Prosecutor Hay then announced he would seek removal of Burr, Blennerhassett, and Israel Smith to another district, likely Kentucky, where treason charges might still apply.

Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 25 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

day about 3 o'clock the jury retired, and in a few minutes returned with a verdict of "NOT GUILTY." Mr. Hay then gave notice that on the next day he would move the Court for an order of removal, in the cases of Burr, Blannerhassett, and Israel Smith, N. Y. to a district where HE understood, they had committed treason. He did not designate the place—It is probably Kentucky where the mouth of Cumberland is situated.

We have not yet heard the fate of the last motion.

See moreSee less

ibid.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A prosecuting attorney argues that Aaron Burr, despite being physically absent from the island where the alleged treasonous assembly occurred, should be considered a principal rather than an accessory, citing the precedent of Bollman and Swartwout. He contends that Burr was the author and active projector of the conspiracy, and that Blennerhassett's role was secondary to Burr's guiding mind.

The Enquirer · 26 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A plain man who knew nothing of the curious transmutations which the wit of man can work, would be very apt to wonder by what kind of legerdemain Aaron Burr had contrived to shuffle himself down to the bottom of the pack as an accessory, and turned up poor Blannerhaffett as principal in this treason. It is an honor, I dare say, for which Mr. Blannerhaffett is by no means anxious; one which he, has never disputed with Col. Burr, and which I am persuaded, he would be as little inclined to dispute on this occasion as on any other.

See moreSee less

Since, however, the modesty of Colonel Burr declines the first rank and seems disposed to force Mr. Blannerhaffett into it in spite of his blushes, let us compare the cases of the two men and settle this question of precedence between them. It may save a good deal of troublesome ceremony hereafter. In making this comparison, sir, I shall speak of the two men and of the part they bore as I believe it to exist and to be substantially capable of proof: although the court has already told us that as this is a motion to exclude all evidence, generally, we have a right, in resisting it, to suppose the evidence which is behind, strong enough to prove any thing and every thing compatible with the fact of Burr's absence from the island. If it will be more agreeable to the feelings of the prisoner to consider the parallel which I am about to run, or rather the contrast which I am about to exhibit, as a fiction, he is at liberty to do so; I believe it to be a fact. Who then is Aaron Burr and what the part which he has borne in this transaction? He is

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A lawyer argues that Aaron Burr should be tried as a principal rather than an accessory in the treason case, insisting the jury's role must not be usurped by the court. This is followed by continued witness testimony from Jacob Dunbaugh describing Burr's attempts to recruit soldiers and obtain weapons from the garrison.

The Enquirer · 26 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the court shall think otherwise, and shall deem Aaron Burr an accessorial offender in the treason, can you for this, shut out the evidence from the jury? The indictment does not charge Aaron Burr as an accessary; but as a principal. Whether he is a principal or not is the question of fact which the jury is sworn to decide. Will you because of your impressions of this fact, from a partial view of the evidence, compel them to decide also upon that partial view? If you do, do you not thereby divest the jury of their proper and peculiar functions?

See moreSee less

The province of the jury must not be invaded, Sir; the invasion is big with danger and terror. I trust that you will see this subject in the awful light in which it really stands and that you will suffer the trial to take its natural course. Mr. Wirt's Speech to be concluded in our next.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A judge (likely Marshall) discusses whether Burr's acquittal on one overt act bars indictment for a separate act of levying war in Kentucky, weighing arguments comparing treason to murder and distinguishing jurisdictional rules. He also addresses rumors that the court defied rather than followed the Supreme Court's ruling in Bollman and Swartwout, which he denies.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

-My doubt consists in this. The overt act now charged could not have been laid in the indictment on which Col. Burr has been tried. There is therefore considerable

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness, James McDowell (OCR-garbled name), testifies about the number of men, weapons, boats, and families assembled with Burr's party at the mouth of the Cumberland River and Bayou Pierre. Attorneys Hay and Burr dispute the relevance of evidence from outside U.S. territory, with the Chief Justice ruling on admissibility.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE.

A Yes. Q Did this party seem to be under Burr's command? A They said it was Col. Burr's boats and party. They regarded themselves as under his direction. Q Were there any other officers apparently under

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes joining Burr's flotilla below Fort Massac, the number of boats and men, and the terms offered to recruits—twelve and a half dollars a month plus 100 acres of land. He testifies that Burr was regarded as the head of the expedition and that recruits were to be placed under his command.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

was not with them.

Thomas Hartley.

See moreSee less

Mr Hay. Were you at the mouth of Cumberland? A. No, I was at Fort Massac when the boats were there. I had left it two weeks before. Q. You were with Col. Burr at Fort Massac? A. I was. Col. Burr objected to this question. Fort Massac was in the Indiana Territory.—Q. Did you descend the Mississippi; and with whom? A. With Mr. Fort and Mr. Hopkins. Q. Where were you joined by Mr. Burr's party? A. Just below Fort Massac. They passed the Fort in the night; and we

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This passage records cross-examination testimony in the Aaron Burr treason trial regarding the recruitment of men at New Madrid and their intended service under Burr, including terms of pay, land grants, and destinations such as the Ouachita lands and New Orleans. Lawyers for both prosecution and defense dispute the relevance and admissibility of various lines of questioning about the men's contracts and purpose.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

chita country, and also to descend to New Orleans to work on Col. Burr's boats. Mr. Wirt. Was Col. Burr looked on as the head of this party? A. He was. Q. Did you and did these recruits understand that they were to be placed under Col. Burr's command? A. They were to be delivered to him; and to go on board his boats?

Cross Examined by the accused.

See moreSee less

Mr. Burr. Who wrote the articles, under which they were engaged? A. Mr. Hopkins. Q. Repeat them. A. I do not

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A sergeant testifies about delivering a message from Captain Bissell to Colonel Burr at his camp on Cumberland Island in December 1806, describing their friendly exchange over wine. The testimony details Burr's movements, his men, and preparations before continuing downriver.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

of the United States. He told me I was to call on Col. Burr with his compliments; and if Col. Burr wanted my assistance, that I was to furnish it. Capt. Bissell told me, this Mr. Hopkins, who came in the Skiff with four men, was going up with me. When we got half way up to the Cumberland river, we stopt, and I asked Mr. Hopkins his business at Fort Massac, and he said it was to ask Captain Bissell whether he would oppose Col. Burr's passing by the fort.

See moreSee less

I got to the mouth of Cumberland, about half an hour before sun set, on the 26th December, and landed: Col. Burr was then encamped on Cumberland island. After I had crossed over to the island, I saw Col. B. and delivered Captain Bissell's message. Col. Burr said he was much obliged to him; and that Captain Bissell was very good. Col. Burr asked me "Is not this my old friend?" I had seen him before. He said he believed I drank no brandy; and asked me if I would not have a glass of wine. When I drank, I said "here's success to Col. Burr and his undertaking;" and Mr. Blannerhasset (this was the first time I ever saw him) stamped his foot and said "Amen." Col. Burr told me that I must

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During Burr's treason trial proceedings, Burr sought to disqualify witness Jacob Dunbaugh by alleging he was a deserter from the U.S. Army subject to execution, and claimed General Wilkinson's malice made Dunbaugh's testimony coerced. The prosecution countered that Dunbaugh had never been formally prosecuted for any offense and remained a competent witness.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

[...]ved that his life was in the power of Gen. Wilkinson who would take it away, if he did not swear to what he wished. He said the malice of Gen. Wilkinson was so great a-gainst himself, he had said that, rather than

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

During the treason trial, Burr's counsel challenged the credibility of witness Dunbaugh, arguing he was testifying under duress to save his own life. The Chief Justice ruled that evidence of Blennerhassett's conversations was admissible to explain the purpose of the assemblage at the mouth of the Cumberland, and the prosecution proceeded with witness examinations including Alexander Henderson.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Hay was about to proceed with his witnesses, when Col. Burr objected to the admission of testimony to prove for the purpose of criminating him, any conversations with Blannerhasset, when he was not present, and prior to the meeting at the Island. The Chief Justice said he thought that point had already been decided.

Col. Burr and his council, however, insisted on an argument, by which they said they could demonstrate that no such evidence was admissible. The C. Justice permitted the argument to be commenced.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay declared he should proceed with taking the affidavits of the witnesses out of court; that gentlemen might say what they pleased; but he should not be diverted from the course he had taken. He accordingly retired for that purpose.

After speeches of some length from the counsel for Col. Burr, to which no answer was thought necessary on behalf of the U. States, the Chief Justice decided that the evidence of Blennerhasset's conversations was admissible, by way of explanation of the nature and object of the assemblage of men at the mouth of Cumberland.

The counsel for the U. S. therefore proceeded with their evidence. The examination of Alexander Henderson of Wood County consumed the rest of the day.

THURSDAY, September 24.

This day Mr. Alexander Henderson was cross-examined. Among other questions, he was asked by Mr. Hay if he had read any numbers of the "Querist," a publication which appeared in September last (a few days after Col. Burr had paid a visit to Blennerhasset's Island,) in the Ohio

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The court debates admissibility of affidavits in the Burr trial, with the Chief Justice ruling them inadmissible as legal evidence before adjourning until Saturday for General Wilkinson's testimony. A separate item defends Wilkinson's controversial arrests of Bollman, Swartwout, and Adair as necessary measures against Burr's conspiracy.

Virginia Argus · 26 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the 5th of October, captain Alexander Murray President. It is well known that for the means pursued by General Wilkinson to suppress Burr's Conspiracy, and to punish those concerned in it, he has obtained the thanks, the praises of some—the censure and the execrations of others. The seizure of Bollman, Swartwout, Adair and others, and their transportation to the Atlantic States, has been denounced as a measure subversive of the constitutional rights of the citizen, and as a precedent dangerous to the liberties of the people. Others again have justified the conduct of General Wilkinson from the peculiar circumstances under which he acted, and the imminent danger to which his country was exposed.

See moreSee less

New Orleans was to have been the first object of attack—it was there probably the conspirators were to gather their scattered forces, seize on the banks, plunder property, and proceed on their Mexican expedition. The agents of Burr had begun to assemble—The smooth-tongue Bollman, with eagle eye, was watching the course of events, and ingratiating himself into the good opinion of the inhabitants. Adair, Swartwout, and others, were also there, acting as spies on the conduct of the commander in chief, and no doubt ruminating on the means by which they should corrupt the army, and by holding out to them the chance of plunder and of conquest, detach the soldiers from their allegiance. Wilkinson had been apprised of the intentions of Burr and his partisans—Reports too had magnified the ex[tent]

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

Chief Justice Marshall delivers an opinion on whether testimony about Herman Blannerhassett's out-of-court declarations can be admitted against Aaron Burr. He upholds the general rule against hearsay, noting exceptions exist for conspiracy cases but cautioning courts to guard against undermining this fundamental principle of justice.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14.

The chief justice delivered the following opinion on the question concerning the admissibility of evidence on the present indictment, for a Misdemeanor against col. Burr.

See moreSee less

The U. States vs. Aaron Burr, }On a misdemeanor.

The present motion is particularly di[illegible]

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 21 September 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This report records a judge's legal opinion during Burr's treason trial regarding whether declarations by an alleged agent (Mr. Bollman/Blannerhassett) can be used as evidence against the principal, Col. Burr. The judge discusses the legal distinction between felony and treason regarding accessory guilt, and references precedents from the Smith and Ogden trials in New York.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

3dly. The admission of the declarations of Mr. Blannerhassett m[a]y be instituted upon under the idea he was the agent of Col. Burr. How far the acts of one man may affect another criminal

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The passage reports courtroom proceedings from the Burr treason trial, including witness Jacob Dunbaugh's testimony about the assemblage at the mouth of Cumberland and Burr sinking arms before a search. It also details legal arguments over whether the assemblage was an 'equivocal act' and whether testimony about intent could be admitted, with the Chief Justice ruling such evidence admissible.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 28 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SATURDAY, SEPT. 19.

The court was opened at 10 o'clock

See moreSee less

The proceedings of this day commenced with the examination of Jacob Dunbaugh, a witness on the part of the United States. But the interruptions were so incessant, arising from the various objections made to the questions propounded to him, that his examination was not closed when the court adjourned, at 4 clock.

This witness proved the assemblage at the mouth of Cumberland, and that the arms (to the amount of forty or upwards) which were on board the boats, were sunk in the river by the direction of Col. Burr, before his boats were searched by the persons sent for that purpose, by the civil authority.

The great point in controversy at present seems to be this. The court considered the fact of the assemblage at the mouth of Cumberland as an equivocal act, and that testimony might be adduced to shew the character of that act, and the intention with which the assemblage took place. On the other hand, it was contended by Col. Burr and his counsel that there could be no such thing as an equivocal act. That the meeting at the mouth of Cumberland was either innocent in itself or criminal. If innocent, no testimony drawn from any other source could make it criminal. Upon this point it is expected that the counsel of col. Burr will urge to be heard on Monday next.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 23 September 1807

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness at Burr's treason trial describes the men, arms, and boats assembled at the mouth of the Cumberland River, noting about 200-275 men, guns, bayonets, pistols, and barrels of powder and bullets. The witness confirms the party was regarded as under Burr's command, with Blannerhassett and Col. Tyler acting as subordinate officers.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 28 September 1807 · page 2

'Bayou Pierre. QctDid'yonsi see Blannerhas sett and Smith ? .A-si.Yes.; Q. Didsi'sithis par ty seem to be under Burr's command? A. They said, it was Col. Burr's-boats and—party. They regarded themselves as under hisctdi— .rection. Q. \Vctere there any other officers apparently under Burr's command? A".- Yes.

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report covers courtroom proceedings in Burr's misdemeanor trial at Richmond, with prosecutor Hay arguing about proving Burr provided means for a military expedition at Blennerhassett's island. Witnesses including McDowell, Woodbridge, and Taylor testified about boat-building, provisions, and corn purchases connected to the alleged expedition.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 29 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR, FOR A MISDEMEANOR

mind, and he thought they would be equally so to them.

Chief Justice—If you have any testimony about providing the means at the island, let it be produced.

See moreSee less

Maj. Dudley Woodbridge was then called up. He gave a particular history of his contract with Mr. Burr, the building of the boats and the preparing of provisions. The

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

After deliberating about twenty minutes, the jury foreman Mr. Orris Payne returned a verdict of 'Not Guilty' for Aaron Burr. Prosecutor Hay then announced plans to pursue a misdemeanor charge against Burr, Smith, and Blannerhassett related to the military expedition.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 29 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ing to submit it to the court. The Chief Justice decided that the attorney could not enter a Nolle Prosequi.

The jury retired with the indictment, and after an absence of about twenty minutes, Mr. Orris Payne, their foreman, returned a verdict of "NOT GUILTY."

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay then announced the course which he was to pursue; Mr. Burr was not yet discharged from his recognizance for the misdemeanor; that it was his intention to move for his commitment to that place for trial where the military expedition is said to have been completed; that he should combine in the same motion Messrs. Smith and Blannerhassett, and that he should have no difficulty in entering a Nolle Prosequi to their trials for a misdemeanor. Mr. Burr requested the attorney to alledge the place where the act is said to have been committed. Mr. Hay replied, that the evidence he should introduce would cover a vast extent of territory; that he would name if he could the very spot. Mr. Burr. The district then. Mr. Hay. [illegible]

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The report reprints an 1804 letter from Federalist congressman Gaylord Griswold to Matthew Hathaway, claiming Federalist leaders secretly supported Aaron Burr's plans to disrupt the government. The piece argues that Burr's recent acquittal at his Richmond treason trial proves this long-standing Federalist conspiracy and its success in securing impunity for Burr.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 29 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

generally, thro' the United States.— The nature of that letter, and every circumstance attending it, gave it a high claim to the serious attention of every friend to his country. If any thing could add to its importance, it is the result of the late trial of Burr at Richmond, for treason. The letter of itself proves the determination of leading federalists to support Burr in any scheme which could "disturb the quiet" and "shake the very centre" of our government, so long as it should

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness is cross-examined about Blennerhassett's island, boats and arms, and recruitment of men at New Madrid for Burr's expedition. Details include pay terms, purpose of the recruits, and confirmation that Burr was regarded as head of the party.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 29 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Mr. Burr's party? A. Just below fort Massac. They passed the fort in the night, and we joined them next morning. Q. How many boats had they? A. About 8

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Testimony recounts recruitment of men ostensibly to settle Ouachita lands but actually to proceed to New Orleans and serve on Burr's boats, with disputes over contract terms and length of service. Attorneys for both prosecution and defense spar over objections to the evidence and the scope of witness testimony.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 29 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

boats. Mr. Wirt. Was colonel Burr looked on as the head of this party? A. He was. Q. Did you and did these recruits understand that they were to be placed under colonel Burr's command? A. They were to be delivered to him; and to go on board his boats?

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A defense attorney argues that acts committed by Blannerhasset, Tyler, and Smith cannot be attributed to Burr without direct proof he began the expedition or prepared means in Virginia, citing constitutional venue requirements. He contends no such evidence has yet been presented, only a contract made in Ohio.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

How then do gentlemen mean to make this testimony relevant? It is by making the acts of Blannerhasset, Tyler and Smith the acts of Burr, by insisting that their acts show an unlawful expedition

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The piece argues that Jefferson's proclamation never named Aaron Burr or declared his guilt proven, rebutting a Federalist claim to the contrary. It also defends the ongoing circuit court trial as fair, noting both prosecution and defense have presented witnesses and the government has spared no expense.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

prin[t]s into detraction and persecution, ought themselves to be peculiarly careful to avoid being detected in untruths. If so, what are we to think of the following extract from the Gazette of the U. S.?

"Neither Washington nor Adams ever, by proclamation, pronounced the guilt of an offender to be proved beyond a doubt, and afterwards put him upon trial to have it ascertained whether his guilt could be proved or not. Such a flagitious interference of the executive with the judicial authority and with the impartial administration of justice is as unexampled as it is indecent and wicked."

See moreSee less

The plain implication is, that Mr. Jefferson did by proclamation pronounce the guilt of A. Burr to be proved beyond a doubt. And yet not a word to this effect is to be found in any proclamation issued by the executive; indeed, so far as our recollection serves us, the name of Aaron Burr is not even mentioned in the proclamation. This last circumstance may possibly be otherwise; but we think not.

The fact is, that while the western expedition was disclosing itself, the federalists were loud in their calls for information. The President was charged with treachery for his silence. His energy was doubted: an alarm was sounded; vigorous measures were called for. During this time the friends of the administration retained their confidence in them; they inculcated the propriety of temperance in the public mind; they had no doubt but that the government was pursuing the best measures for the public safety, and they realised the great advantages that might flow from the secrecy with which it conducted its operations. But the public solicitude reached the deliberations of Congress; and the House of Representatives called for information. Information, thus called for, was given, and then, and not till then did the President make that disclosure, which is now termed perse[cution].

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper

A witness, Mr. McDowel, is cross-examined about the composition, arms, and numbers of the men assembled under Burr's expedition, including questions about Blennerhasset's recruitment efforts. Lawyers for both prosecution and defense dispute what inferences can be drawn about where arms were loaded and whether acts occurred within U.S. territory.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

Mr. Hay presumed that it would not be departing from the opinion of the court, if he asked a question concerning some transaction out of the U. S. which might serve to elucidate the state of the party at the mouth of Cumberland. Might he not, for instance, enquire whether the witness had seen any boxes of arms at Bayou Pierre; because it was perfectly fair to infer, that if they had not been subsequently received, they must have been with the party at the mouth of Cumberland river. Mr. Burr. No precise inference can be drawn from that circumstance;

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 22 September 1807

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

A witness is cross-examined about the number of men and whether chests of arms were seen at the mouth of the Cumberland River and on Blennerhassett's island, with Burr's counsel objecting to the admissibility of certain conversations as evidence of the overt act. The Chief Justice rules on which testimony concerning activities at the island and nearby can be admitted in relation to the treason charge.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR

mount of the party? A. There were about 130 at Cole's Creek. Q. Was there any application to you to join them? A. Mr. Blannerhasset applied to me. Q. In what manner? A. He asked me to go along with him; but I said I did not wish to go without knowing where they were going. He was at me two or three times. He said that many men were going, without knowing any more than I did. I told him I had very little in the world; but that I did not wish to leave it in that way.

Mr. Burr here interrupted the examination. He observed that the counsel for the prosecution were bound to prove the overt act first; that there was no impropriety in producing circumstances explanatory of the overt act; but how could these conversations between other persons, and held in his absence contribute to establish this act, or how could they affect him?

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay contended that these circumstances might contribute to show

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

This passage contains courtroom testimony from the Burr treason trial, with witnesses being cross-examined about boats, chests of arms, and military supplies seen at the mouth of Cumberland River and the Falls of the Ohio. Questions focus on the number of boats, contents of chests (rifles, bayonets, bullets), and their association with Blennerhassett and Burr's expedition.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

there? A. Mr. Blannerhassett did— Q. How many boats went down the mouth of Cumberland river? A. I do not recollect how many. Q. Were there 10? were there 6? A. There were more than 6 altogether. Q. Did no one join you at the mouth of Cumberland but col. Burr? A. Yes, some more. Q. Who were in the boats? A. M[r.]

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness recounts being granted a furlough by Captain Bissell after discussions involving Colonel Burr, describing conversations about men, arms, and secrecy. The testimony details a sequence of meetings, a letter to General Wilkinson, and a gift of a silver breast-plate from Burr.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

days and tell down, in company with him to where colonel Burr was encamped. Captain Bissell went into colonel Burr's boat, and while there, colonel Burr asked him, to let me go with him. I heard it because though I was not in the same room, there was a thin partition between us, and I heard him ask captain Bissell. I did not hear captain Bissell's answer. Captain Bissell came out got into his own boat, and after going one or two hundred yards we landed and walked up to the garrison. 30th December while I was in the military store, a man came in, who brought two letters from colonel Burr. He gave [illegible]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

Witnesses James Fiske and Israel Miller testify about boats, boxes, and armed men gathered with Aaron Burr near Cole's Creek and the mouth of the Cumberland River. Testimony covers the number of men, weapons, and Burr's statements to his followers about the Ouachita land venture.

The Enquirer · 30 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITTMENT.

Stephen S. Welch. Q. Were you at the mouth of Cumberland? A. I was; I only joined there. I was there with a load, and capt. Berry wished me to join and go down the river, to make a settlement; for that it was advantageous to young men. I said, that I had no incumbrance; and being a single man, I was willing to go. Q. Who is Berry? A. John Berry, a man I met there. Mr. Burr. He was called captain of the boat.--Witness. He was appointed captain of the boat I went in.

See moreSee less

I agreed to go down. The proposition made to me by capt. Berry was to settle the Ouachita country; to have a certain portion of land, besides other compensation. Q. What was it? A. Capt. Berry offered me 10 dolls. a month; but I said, I was not for hire, and as I was a young man, would go as a volunteer. Q. Did you descend the river with them? A. Yes. Q. Do you recollect hearing any conversation from Mr. Burr to Mr. Floyd, on the subject of arms? A. I do not. Did you go to Bayou Pierre?

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 3 October 1807

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes joining Burr's flotilla at the mouth of the Cumberland River, detailing boats, arms, men, and an engagement to descend to Ouachita lands, with contingency to resist Spanish invasion. Burr's counsel objects to questions seeking the witness's personal opinion on the enterprise's true purpose, arguing such opinions could be based on false rumors.

The Enquirer · 30 September 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ment? A With Mr. Berry of Indiana, 12 miles from Jeffersonville. Q What was the nature of that engagement? A To descend the Ohio and Mississippi and to ascend the Red River, to settle the Ouachita lands. I was not certain whether these lands belonged to Col. Burr or Mr Lynch: but I supposed, the latter. It was also stated, that should our frontiers be

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage records courtroom proceedings in Aaron Burr's trial, including a clerk reading the formal misdemeanor charge against Burr, Blennerhassett, and Smith for organizing a military expedition against Spanish Mexico. Witness testimony follows regarding activities at Bayou Pierre and Thompson's Bayou, including questions about ground cleared for military exercises and a guard.

The Enquirer · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

writing, and had notified its existence to one of the opposite counsel, though it had never been publicly read in court. The clerk then read the paper in the following terms:

"The Attorney of the U. S. for the Virginia district, charges Aaron Burr, Harman Blannerhassett and Isrrael Smith, with a misdemeanor against the United States, in beginning, or setting on foot, or preparing or providing the means of a military expedition or enterprize, against Mexico, a province in North America, of the King of Spain, with whom the United States are at peace."

See moreSee less

Mr Hay. It is immaterial besides, whether this charge has been proferred; because though the charge actually alledged is treason, yet if the other crime should occur during the investigation of the evidence, it is the province of the court to enquire into it. Chief Justice. It would certainly be unnecessary to re-examine the same witnesses, a second time

Mr Wirt. Did you then hear nothing of the Mexican invasion? a I did not from any leading characters. Mr Hay. Who did you consider as the leading characters? a Col Burr, Tyler, Smith, Blannerhassett and Floyd. q Had you not been informed of the plan by the President's Proclamation. a That did not reach us before we got to Bayou Pierre. q Were you at Thompson's Bayou? a I was. q Do you know any thing of the ground that was cleared for exercising the men? a I assisted in clearing it. Mr Burr. The witness does not perhaps attend to the question:

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A witness is cross-examined about militia rumors, a guard set up near Bayou Pierre, searches of boats for arms, and conditions on the island including food, powder supplies, and local alarm. The testimony covers details about rifles, pistols, and whether any unlawful design was suspected among the party.

The Enquirer · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ident's Proclamation before you arrived at Bayou Pierre? a I said that you had not reached us before we got to Bayou Pierre; but I am not certain whether it was there that we received it. Ch. Just. Had you received the Proclamation, before the guard was put out? a I do not recollect. Mr Burr. Was it not afterwards? a I do not recollect, I heard that it was contained in some news-paper, perhaps in your boat Mr Wirt. Do you know any thing of the search? a I do; I was in our boat at that time.

See moreSee less

When Col Fitzpatrick came, Col Tyler lifted the curtain and he was introduced. We did not once change our posture. q How many arms did he find there? a There were a couple of rifles, belonging to a Mr Lamb, and some pistols. q Did you hear of the searching of the other boats? a I did not trouble myself about them. q Did you hear of the sinking of arms? a I did not. Cross-Examined:--Mr Burr. How many guns had you at Beaver? a Five rifles. q Did you see any more

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This passage records courtroom testimony from witnesses questioned by Burr, Blannerhassett, and prosecutor Hay about events on the island, including provisions, militia numbers, rumors of arrest warrants, and talk of a Spanish war. Witnesses describe confusion over troop movements, warnings from Major Floyd, and uncertainty about whether unlawful designs were planned.

The Enquirer · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the mouth of Cole's Creek? a Major Fleehearty. The answer from Major Floyd was, that he must get more militia. Mr Burr. This was a piece of impertinence in Fleehearty, for it was after the stipulations entered into between Mr Mead and myself. I was at that time, 50 miles off, at Washington, (M T) where I went to stand a trial. Mr Blannerhassett. Did you hear of any report about arresting me, on the night I left my island? a I did hear something about it; but I believe it was not before the next morning.

See moreSee less

q By whom? the militia? a No. Mr Hay. Did you not hear of an arrest by Gen Tupper? a I did not; but the morning after I left the island, Mr Blannerhassett himself mentioned, that he understood there was a writ or warrant to do it; and asked us if we were willing to take him along after that was out. Mr Wirt. Was Major Fleehearty a militia officer? a He seemed so from his dress. Mr Burr. Was there not a good deal of talk about a Spanish war? a Yes. I saw a good deal about it myself, in the newspapers.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

The passage reports courtroom testimony from witness Dunbaugh at Aaron Burr's treason trial, describing how Burr asked him to recruit soldiers to desert and steal arms. The defense objected that this testimony was not relevant to the case.

Virginia Argus · 30 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MONDAY, Sept. 21st.

CONTINUATION OF JACOB DUNBAUGH'S EVIDENCE.

See moreSee less

Mr. Hay. State what passed between col. Burr and yourself about your getting people to join him.

Witness. I stopt before with saying that col. Burr had not spoken to me to engage citizens: But he had spoken to me about soldiers. On the 30th of December, after col. Burr had obtained capt. Bissell's consent for me to go with him, I went to col. Burr where he was encamped about a mile or two below the garrison at Fort

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 30 September 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness describes the small garrison's troop strength, lack of artillery, and events including Colonel Burr's visit and request for his companionship. The testimony details how Captain Bissell granted the witness a furlough to accompany Burr after being questioned about any secrets Burr may have shared.

Virginia Argus · 30 September 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Bissell got into his own boat; the rest pushed off in the boat that had been lying there several days and fell down in company with him to where colonel Burr was encamped. Captain Bissell went into colonel Burr's boat, and while there, colonel Burr asked him, to let me go with him. I heard

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A witness recounts conversations with Mr. Swartwout describing Colonel Burr's alleged plans for an armed expedition against Mexican provinces, including troop movements, naval support from Great Britain, and coordination with figures like Commodore Truxton. The testimony also describes Burr's efforts to locate the witness by altering his travel route and sending dispatches via Dr. Bollman.

Virginia Argus · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

patches from Col Burr to his friends in New-Orleans. Mr Swartwout informed me that Col Burr, supported by a numerous and powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was about to levy an armed force of seven thousand men, with a view to carry an expe-

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This passage records trial testimony, likely General Wilkinson's, describing Aaron Burr's alleged plans to march on Mexico, raise funds, and secure naval support, along with references to Dr. Bollman and cyphered correspondence. The excerpt also includes courtroom argument between counsel over the admissibility of a letter purportedly from General Dayton.

Virginia Argus · 30 September 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

He enquired of me whether I had heard of Doctor Bollman; and, on my replying in the negative, he expressed some surprize; observed that Doctor Bollman and a Mr. Alexander had been dispatched from Philadelphia, by sea, to New-Orleans, with dispatches from Col Burr to me, and that they must have arrived. Mr. Swartwout informed me that he was obliged to go to New-Orleans; & was also under engagements to meet Col. Burr and Gen. Dayton at Nashville, on the 20th of November.

See the clipping