The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 3 other papers
This report records courtroom testimony from Sergeant Jacob Dunbaugh during the U.S. Circuit Court proceedings on the motion to commit Burr, Blennerhassett, and Smith. Dunbaugh describes being sent by Captain Bissell to meet Burr near the mouth of the Cumberland River in December 1806, delivering a message and encountering Burr's encamped party.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. On the motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.
SATURDAY, SEPT. 19.
See moreSee less
Examination of Jacob Dunbaugh.
Mr. Hay. Will you describe the situation of the party at the mouth of Cumberland river? Witness. Am I to be confined to the Cumberland river?
Mr. Hay. You may go down to the Chickasaw Bluffs.
Mr. Botts. Go down to the Mississippi river; and whether you are to go further, the court will instruct you. Some desultory conversation here ensued on this point, after which the witness proceeded.
On the 26th Dec. 1806, very early in the morning, a small skiff with four men and a Mr. Hopkins, arrived at Fort Massac. Some time after the arrival of this skiff, captain Bissell (commandant at the Fort) detailed me for command to go to the mouth of Cumberland river, to purchase a beef for him. Q. What were you. A. I was and am still sergeant in the army of the U. S. He told me I was to call on colonel Burr with his compliments; and if colonel Burr wanted my assistance, that I was to furnish it. Capt. Bissell told me, this Mr. Hopkins, who came in the skiff with 4 men, was going up with me. When we got half way up to the Cumberland river, we stopt, and I asked Mr. Hopkins his business at Fort Massac, and he said it was to ask captain Bissell whether he would oppose colonel Burr's passing by the fort. I got to the mouth of Cumberland, about half an hour before sun set, on the 26th Dec. and landed: Col. B. was then encamped on Cumberland island. After I had crossed over to the island, I saw col. Burr and delivered capt. Bissell's message. Col. Burr said he was much obliged to him; and that captain Bissell was very good.
Col. B. asked me, "Is not this my old friend?" I had seen him before. He said he believed I drank no brandy; and asked me if I would not have a glass of wine. When I drank, I said "here's success to col. Burr and his undertaking;" and Mr. Blannerhassett (this was the first time I ever saw him) stamped his foot and said "Amen." Col. Burr told me that I must take breakfast with him next morning, I replied that I would. On the 27th I saw colonel Burr and told him, I was going to the garrison. He told me to bear his compliments to Captain Bissell, and asked me if I could take a barrel of apples to him. I told him I would. Whilst they were getting the apples on board, the wind sprung up very fresh, and I was not able to start. In the course of that day, I crossed him several times over to the Kentucky shore, and several of his men. During that day, Col. Burr asked me, how I would like to go down the river with him. I replied very well, if I could obtain the consent of my general. He said that that would make no odds. He would fix it without. This was on the 27th, and on the 28th, I called on Col. B. and told him I was going to Fort Massac. He sent his compliments to captain Bissell, but said he expected he would get there before me. I told him, that he might mann his barge as well as he could, I would arrive there before him. I arrived at the garrison some time in the afternoon.
Mr. Botts. There you may stop. It is impossible to progress without running into some impropriety, unless we ascertain the limits within which the witnesses are to be confined.
Mr. Hay observed that he did not mean to prove any acts at Fort Massac. After some conversation the examination proceeded:
Mr. Hay. Did you see any military parade? A. I saw the men drawn up at the mouth of Cumberland. Q. How many men? A. I did not count them; but I suppose there were about 100. Q. What kind of men? A. Generally young men.
Mr. Wirt. Did they look like hard laborers? A. The principal part did not. Q. How drawn up? Were they drawn up in a line? A. No: they were drawn up in three wings. Q. What do you mean by three wings? divisions? The witness here described their position, by drawing a figure on the floor with his foot. They described three sides of a square. Col. Burr was introduced by col. Tyler, beginning at the left. The party gradually fell in and formed a circle.
Mr. Hay. How introduced? A. He went around and shook hands with every man.
Mr. Hay. Did you see some chests of arms?
Mr. Burr objected to this manner of putting the question.
Mr. Hay admitted that he had put the question inadvertantly; he merely wished Mr. Dunbaugh to state what he knows of the chests of arms.
Mr. Botts. State what you know of any chests of arms within the U. S.
Witness. I did not see more than a few rifles at the mouth of Cumberland.
Mr. Hay. I think the court yesterday decided, that we were at liberty to state any circumstances out of the U. S which were explanatory of the acts done within the U. S.
On this topic a long and desultory discussion ensued. The Chief justice at length decided, that if an overt act be laid at the mouth of Cumberland river; if a military assemblage was said to be there assembled, that evidence beyond the limits of the states might be produced to shew the military attitude of the party; that with respect to this particular question, if the witnesses could show that no other arms were put on board, and if certain arms were on board at a certain place, it was some presumption that these arms had been at the mouth of Cumberland river; and that he understood it was the intention of the prosecution to show that this party were in such a state at such a place, that they might be able to infer that the party were in a similar state at the mouth of Cumberland. In this point of view, he conceived that such evidence was admissible.
Mr. Hay. State then, Mr. Dunbaugh, what you know on the subject. Did you leave Fort Massac with Colonel Burr? A. I overtook him at New-Madrid on the 1st of January. Q. Did you then go down the river with him? A. Yes, in his own boat.
Mr. Wickham repeated his objections to this kind of evidence. How was the witness to know, whether arms might not have been subsequently put on board the boats? He was not always in colonel Burr's boat; nor was col. Burr's boat with the rest. Can this be good testimony?
Chief Justice. The attorney is to shew that hereafter. He is to shew that there was no connection between the boats and the shore.
Mr. Wickham. But suppose that he has no testimony to that effect?
Chief Justice. Whether arms were subsequently introduced, is a more matter of inference, dependent on the whole of the evidence on both sides. It depends on a variety of circumstances, such as the situation of the shore and the country, &c.
Mr. Hay. State then, Mr. Dunbaugh, what you know about the arms on board the boats. Witness. Sometime in January, we left Bayou Pierre, and descended to Petit Gulph 3 miles below on the opposite side. Col. Burr went ashore, and returned to the Petit Gulph. The boats all shoved off at once; Col. B's. was rather behind. The night we left Petit Gulph, Col. B. and Willie came into the cow of the boat with an axe, auger and saw. They went into colonel Burr's private room and began to chop. He ordered no person to go out, but I did go out. I saw a skiff lying aside of colonel B's. boat. After they had done chopping, a Mr. Pryor, and a Mr. Tooley got out of the window. I got on the top of the boat, and saw two bundles of arms tied up with cords, and sunk by cords going through holes at the gunwales of Col. Burr's boat. I observed to Mr. Pryor, that he must be careful to bring up the boat, or else it could not get close to shore.
Mr. Hay. How many arms were there? A. There were about 40 or 43 stands. I saw besides, pistols, swords, blunderbusses, fusees and tomahawks.
Mr. Wirt. Is not the coast opposite to New-Madrid a part of Tennesse? A. No; it is the Indiana territory. Q. Were you on board any of the other boats? A. Several. Q. Did they keep together? A. They did, when they could. Q. Did you see arms in the other boats? A. I saw several stands of arms, that is, muskets with bayonets, in Floyd's boat; and about 12 rifles. Q. Were you near enough to colonel B. at the mouth of Cumberland to hear his observations to his party? A. I was. He said there were then too many bye standers to divulge his plans. Q. Were any men obtained, after you joined them? A. One, who got aboard at New-Madrid. Q. Were you commissioned by colonel B. to obtain men? A. No; not citizens. Q. What do you mean by the word "citizens?"
Here Dunbaugh was stopped by the opposite council, and his examination proceeded no farther on this day.
MONDAY, SEPT. 21st.
Continuation of Jacob Dunbaugh's Evidence.
Mr. Hay. State what passed between Col. Burr and yourself about your getting people to join him.
Witness. I stopt before with saying, that Col. Burr had not spoken to me to engage citizens: But he had spoken to me about soldiers. On the 30th of December, after Col. Burr had obtained captain Bissell's consent for me to go with him, I went to Col. Burr, where he was encamped, about a mile or two below the garrison at Fort Massac, on the Indiana side. Col. B. asked me into his cabin (a private room he had) and asked me if I could not get ten or twelve of the best men in the garrison to go along with him. I asked him how it was to be done. He said, "get them to desert." I told him no. He asked me, if I could not steal out of the garrison, arms, such as muskets, fusees, and rifles. I told him that I would not, if I could, for him or any other man on earth; that I had always been well treated by the officers of the army. I told him I had a rifle of my own; and he told me to bring it with me, and he would pay me for it. I started then to the garrison, and prepared myself to go; that was, after Col. B. I had obtained liberty of my captain. The counsel for the accused contended that this kind of testimony was not at all relevant to the subject. After some discussion, the examination proceeded.
At the mouth of Cumberland, Walter Davidson engaged a man by the name of Casey. Q. On what terms. Witness. I do not particularly recollect. Q. How do you know that Davidson was the agent of Col. Burr? Witness. He belonged to the party and told me he was an agent for Col. Burr. The substance of the engagement was; he was to receive twelve and a half dollars per month for six months, clothes and victuals for six months, and 100 acres of land, to fight against all opponents. This Mr. Davidson, Plumb, and Andrew Wood, were sent to New Madrid to enlist more men.—The witness here returned to that point in his narration at which he had been interrupted on his former examination. When I returned to Fort Massac, on the 28th December, I gave Col. Burr's compliments to capt. Bissell, and told him that Col. B. had sent him a barrel of apples. The next day, 29th, this Mr. Davidson, Plumb, and Andrew Wood, came to the garrison very early in the morning, in a skiff; this was the time when they told me that they were going to enlist more men for Col. Burr. They bought a skiff of me, that was left with me to sell by a Mr. Cutler, a surveyor, their own skiff was afterwards carried off by Col. Burr's party. That evening after sun down, a barge came down to Fort Massac with twelve men in it. Col. Tyler and Major Hill were in it, and I think also Major Smith. They went up to Captain Bissell's quarters, where they staid about 20 minutes; and I then heard col. Tyler tell the boat's crew to return to where col. Burr was encamped; with some other instructions, that I did not hear. Between 12 or 1 o'clock that night, col. Burr's boats passed by the fort, and landed about one or two miles below the garrison. (Mr. Hay. How many men were then in the garrison? A. 44 men. Q. Was that the usual compliment of men? A. No—some of the troops had gone to Newport, and some to other places. Q. Was there any artillery? A. None. Q. How wide is the river at that place? A. About a mile wide.) Next morning capt. Bissell told me to get six men with the clinker boat, to take him down the river a small piece. While the men were getting ready, a Mr. Fort, (perhaps his Christian name was John) who had been lying there several days, asked me how I would like to go along. I told him I should like it very well, if I could get leave to go. He told me he had been speaking to capt. Bissell the evening before, and that capt. B. had consented to let me go. While the boat was getting ready, capt. Bissell, col. Tyler, maj. Hill, and I believe maj. Smith, came down. Capt. B. got into his own boat; the rest pushed off in the boat that had been lying there several days, and fell down in company with him to where col. Burr was encamped. Capt. B. went into col. B's boat, and while there, col. B. asked him to let me go with him. I heard it, because though I was not in the same room, there was a thin partition between us, and I heard him ask capt. Bissell. I did not hear capt. Bissell's answer. Capt. B. came out, got into his own boat, and after going one or two hundred yards we landed and walked up to the garrison. 30th December, while I was in the military store, a man came in, who brought two letters from col. Burr. He gave capt. Bissell one, and the other to me. Capt. Bissell went out, and after I had done in the store, he called me, took me through the Sally Port, to the back of the garrison, and asked me whether col. Burr had been speaking to me about a furlough. I told him no. He asked me whether I wanted a furlough to go. I told him with his approbation and advice I would take one. Capt. Bissell said he would not advise me; but if I wanted one for 20 days, he would give me one. He told me, before the 20 days were out, I should see the general. He asked me if col. B. had told me any secrets, and if he had, that I must keep them to myself. I accepted of capt. B's offer, and he told me to get ready to go with col. Burr. I then went and saw col. Burr, and the conversation passed about the men and arms which I have already related. That evening (on the 30th Dec.) captain Bissell sent for me to his quarters, and told me he was going to advise me what I was to do; he advised me never to forsake col. Burr, that he would do something for me. He told me, that if ever col. B. got on a field of battle never to leave him on the ground. At the same time he made me a present of a silver breast plate. That evening I went to capt. Bissell's for my furlough. He gave me a furlough, with a letter to gen. Wilkinson, to be delivered by col. Burr. Col. B. had then started, and I was to give him the letter as soon as I overtook him. On the 31st Dec. being the day for muster and inspection, I asked capt. B. if I was to shew my clothing; I said they were all packed up and on board. He told me I must borrow some for inspection, which I accordingly did, agreeably to his orders. Whilst the men were on parade, I went to his lady's quarters to take my leave, and on my return capt. Bissell having brought the men to a ground.—He told me, "Dunbaugh, I wish you success, let you go where you will." I wanted to see Dr. Tuttle before I went, and capt. B. told me, if I had no particular business, I had better go on, and if any one asked me where I was going, I was to say, I was only going a few miles down the river, and that I was coming back again. There was one of col. Burr's boats with eight hands to take me to him.
We overtook col. B. on the 1st Jan. at New Madrid. I handed him the letter for gen. Wilkinson, and he broke it open. I told him the letter was for gen. W. He asked pardon, took me into his cabin, and sealed it up. I asked him what boat I was to go in, and he said in his own; as its accommodations were better than in any other. We left New Madrid about 11 or 12 o'clock that day, (1st Jan.) Andrew Wood remained at New Madrid, and Plumb and Walter Davidson, who had been sent on to enlist men, got on board the boats—and Mr. Hopkins was left in their places to enlist. After we got into the stream, a keel boat came alongside, and took col. B. into another boat some hundred yards off. I saw him on the bow of the boat, giving some instructions, but I could not hear him. Major Floyd had charge of this keel boat and crew; and I understood they were instructed to be at Natchez in four days. When we got within 45 miles of the Chickasaw Bluffs, col. Burr asked me if I would go ahead with him to C. Bluffs, in a small boat, as I was acquainted with the river. I told him I would. We got into a small boat with 12 more men, and he gave general orders to the other boats to follow on, so as to reach the Bluffs early next morning. We got there between twelve and one o'clock that night, (3d Jan.) After we landed, col. B. told me, I must go up to the garrison, and ask the commanding officer, if he could not get quarters, that night for himself and men. When I arrived at the garrison, I was conducted to lieut. Jackson's quarters. He returned his compliments, and said he would furnish them with lodgings. Col. Burr went up with some of his men and supped.—The next morning col. B. asked me, if I was acquainted with the men in the garrison. I told him I was. He asked me, if I could not get 10 or 12 of the best men to desert. I told him, I would not. He then said, he would speak to them himself, and get 2 of the best men, and asked me to name them; which I did. (Upon being interrogated, the witness said, there were 19 men in the fort; few pieces of cannon; and the river about as wide as at ft. Massac.) Some time in the afternoon, I asked col. B. if he had got the men to go with him. He said he had. Sometime that evening he told me that lieut. Jackson and the other men would follow in a few days. That day col. B. employed a man, one Skinner, to run him some musquet balls. He run him 600; for which col. B. paid him one dollar. He bought 3 dozen Tomahawks out of the factory, which col. B. distributed among his men; some he had helved. That day all the boats landed at the Bluff, and on the 5th they all started, except a small boat left for col. B. He soon overtook us, and got into his own boat. No one came from the garrison with him. We proceeded to a place called Palmyra, 35 miles above Bayou Pierre, on the 10th January. Col. B. again asked me, if I would go down to Bayou Pierre with him.
Mr. Wickham asked the court, whether the witness should proceed. How was this kind of testimony calculated to prove the overt act? How was it relevant to the charge? Was it not better for gentlemen to extract whatever they deemed material out of the witness by putting interrogations?
Mr. Wirt. The witness was just coming to certain declarations of the accused, which directly related to the objects of this expedition. When he has arrived at Bayou Pierre, and is about to tell something that is important, he is stopt.
Ch. Justice wished the attorney to put interrogatories.
Mr. Hay. Did you ever get out of col. Burr's boat to go into another? A. Never, except at Chickasaw Bluffs and Bayou Pierre, when I went with col. B. at his particular request. Q. Did you go ashore at judge Bruin's? and state what happened there. The counsel for the accused objected to this general interrogatory.
Ch. Justice. Ask him whether any thing happened there respecting this expedition.
Mr. Hay. Perhaps the witness may omit facts, because he deems them unimportant, which I may consider extremely relevant. Did any thing happen at judge Bruin's respecting a publication? and state what it was.
Witness. On Sunday 11th January, while we were 3 or 400 yards from the shore, col. Burr told me to arm myself with a rifle and conceal a bayonet under my clothes. He told me he was going to tell something I must never relate again. He then told me that gen. Wilkinson had betrayed him; that he had played the devil with him, and had proved the greatest traitor on the earth. I told him I could not believe it, and asked him how he knew it. He said he had seen published in a paper a letter, which he had some time before written to gen. Wilkinson in cyphers.—He mentioned that general W. had made oath to this letter before the court or in open court, I do not recollect which—He then told me he was fearful of being injured or taken; that I must keep a good look out about judge Bruin's—Col. Burr went into judge Bruin's to breakfast; and I went into the cotton gin that was near the house. A boat came, & he told me to take a spy glass and see whether it was his boat. I could not determine—He then directed me to go down, and if it was his boat, to fire a musket. Q. Where is judge Bruin's? A. About a mile and a quarter below Bayou Pierre.
Mr. Wirt. Where did he say he had seen the paper? A. The paper had been handed by judge Bruin to col. B. the evening before. Q. What was the conversation at judge Bruin's? A. col. Burr asked him, if he had any papers; he handed him this paper; and after reading 15 or 20 minutes, he rose up and said he must go to the boats.
Mr. Hay. Did the troops from the boats land there? A. Yes. Q. With what view did the men go on shore below the mouth of Bayou Pierre? A. They landed about 2 or 3 miles below in the Louisiana territory. The opposite counsel objected to these questions; but were overruled by the court.
Mr. Hay. State what happened at the landing of the men.
Witness. Some days after the men landed (they all landed) col. B. ordered ground to be cleared for a parade ground, for the purpose of exercising the men—but I never saw the ground myself, nor the men exercising. Some of the men however are here—Dr. Munholland is one of those men who assisted in clearing of the ground. There was a guard of 12 men paraded at this place. Wyllie for one had a rifle and sword.
Mr. Wirt. Were there any Indians at that place? A. None. Q. What produced this guard? A. They understood that the militia were coming to take col. B.—and those 12 men were placed to alarm the boats. Q. Was this before or after sinking the muskets? A. It was before. The witness, upon being further interrogated, deposed that a Mr. Lemaster had taken potatoes out of a hhd. then in Mr. Bl. boat, a barrel of potatoes, with which he said he was going to fill the box of arms, so as to make it appear like a box of potatoes; that he was asked in the presence of col. Burr to go and help to clear the ground; that col. Fitzpatrick came to take an inventory of all the goods and arms that he could see; but that he did not see col. F. search for the arms.
Mr. Burr. Where was I all this time? A. I know not; but I saw you handing 2 or 3 muskets out of the cabin window of your own boat into Mr. Blannerhassett's boat. The witness further stated, that the arms which were sunk were sunk between Petit Gulf & Coles's creek; that Burr was looked upon as the commander in chief of the expedition; that in the night his boat was distinguished by two lanterns, placed one above another, whereas the rest had but one—and that in the day time handkerchiefs were hoisted in some of the boats by way of flag.
Cross examined.
Mr. Burr. You say your furlough was for 20 days? A. It was. Q. After the expiration of this furlough, were you not advertised as a deserter? A. I was. Q. Were you taken up? A. I was not. Q. When you got to Baton Rouge, did you write to general Wilkinson? A. I did. Q. What did you write? A. That my furlough had been taken from me; and that if he would send me a furlough or a pardon, I would come on in three days. Q. Did you promise to give any information against me? A. I did not.
Mr. Wirt observed, that he was authorised by general Wilkinson to say, that he had the original furlough given by capt. Bissel.
Mr. Martin. Did he send you a pardon? A. General Wilkinson wrote to me to come down. Q. Have you that letter? A. No. It was taken from me at Baton Rouge. Governor Folk has it at this moment. Q. Did you write to captain Bissell? A. I did. I mentioned to captain Bissell, that as both of us might be injured by this transaction, if he would say that he had sent me as a spy, it would clear both him and myself. Q. When were you discharged from the army? A. I was not discharged in 1805, when I travelled with you. Q. Why were you discharged? Show your hand to the court. A. There is my hand (one of the fingers appeared to have been injured.) I can shew my discharge. I procured a substitute, and many have liberty to procure them.
Mr. Hay. Hand me the discharge; the witness accordingly presented it.* Q. Did you come round with general Wilkinson? A. I did. Q. Were you subpoenaed? A. I did not know I was. Q. Who requested you to come round from New Orleans? A. I came by request of general Wilkinson. Q. Did he say for what? A. He said as a witness. Q. You gave a deposition in New Orleans? A. Yes. Q. At whose request? A. At general W's. Q. When I came down the Mississippi in 1805, by whose orders did I have the men? A. I thought, by Gen. W's. Q. Had they arms? A. I think not. Q. Had they colours? A. They had, and they were flying every day. Q. Did you not tell me, you expected your discharge? A. Yes. Q. Do you not know that the soldiers at Chickasaw Bluffs wanted to go with me; and I refused them. A. I recollect that you wanted me to get them to go, but I refused. Q. Did you not tell me that some of them wanted to go? A. I mentioned 1 or 2. Q. Did any go? A. No. Q. Why? A. You told me that the lieut. and all would follow in a few days.
Mr. Wirt. This previous voyage you took the year before—were they not troops of the U States? A. They were. Q. These soldiers; were they going where their company was? A. The whole company were going to New Orleans and this barge with ten men, was sent on ahead. Q. And this flag belonged to them? A. It did.
Mr. Wickham. Were they regimental colors? A. They were colors made for the barge.
Chief Justice. Did you tell captain Bissell, that col. Burr had applied to you to get the men to desert? I did not.
Mr. Wirt. Did you not reject the proposition? A. I did. At the request of the Chief Justice the witness here described the particular manner in which the arms were sunk. He said that they were so deep in the water, as to prevent the boat from going within 50 yards of the shore. He also related his visit to Judge Bruin's, where col. Burr got the newspaper. He also stated at the request of the court the contents of his letter to general Wilkinson; that if he would send him the furlough which lieut. Roney had taken from him or a pardon, that he would be there in three days. General Wilkinson informed him, that he had behaved very wrong in leaving the man he was going down with; but if he would come down he should not be molested.
Mr. Wirt. Where did the party break up? A. A few miles below Coles's creek. Q. How far is Coles's creek from Bayou Pierre? A. About 25 miles. Q. When was it that this parting speech was made at Coles's Creek? A. About 6th or 7th of February.
* The discharge states, that "having served three years and 6 months, and being permitted to procure a substitute in his place (J. D.) is hereby discharged."
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 26 September 1807 · an extract
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 29 September 1807 · an extract
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 30 September 1807 · an extract
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The court at Richmond spent several days hearing testimony, including depositions and examinations of witnesses such as Alexander Henderson, John G. Henderson, Richard Neale, John Graham, Charles Davall, and others connected to Blannerhassett. The prosecution debated with the defense over whether evidence of conspiracy could be used against Burr before an overt act was proven, with the Chief Justice allowing testimony to proceed while reserving judgment on its direct application to Burr.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 October 1807 · page 3
Mr. Burr. The Chief Justice seemed disposed to think that it did not affect him. Mr. Hay contended that when a connexion and conspiracy were prov en, the act and declarations of one ac complice are good against the rest— Tne Chief Justice was willing to hear an argument upon the point. Mr. Burr then said that as he understood he
The paper explains it had paused reprinting the Burr trial proceedings but resumes due to public interest in General Wilkinson's testimony. It then presents the trial transcript for September 26, 1807, beginning Wilkinson's account of communications from Burr and Swartwout.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
We have latterly discontinued to republish the proceedings in the case of Col. Burr, but knowing publick anxiety for the testimony of General Wilkinson, we commence it this day, and shall pay particular attention to lay it before our readers.
General Wilkinson describes receiving a letter from Swartwout, allegedly from Colonel Burr, written partly in cipher. He recounts decoding portions of it overnight and concluding it revealed an illicit project, then reporting this to Colonel Cushing the next morning.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR
I enquired of Mr. Swartwout where col. Burr was. He answered that he was at Philadelphia ; and that he had left him there. Col. Cushing returned, and the conversation took a general course. After some time Mr. Swartwout withdrew; and I retired to my chamber, and in the packet or envelope I found a letter addressed to me in cypher from col. Burr.— [Chief Justice.] I did not understand you. How did
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The court heard arguments on whether testimony about events beyond the state's limits could be used to establish the overt act of treason at the mouth of the Cumberland. Chief Justice Marshall ruled such evidence could be admitted if the assemblage's character was equivocal, while Burr argued no act could be legally equivocal and denied that a mere military posture constituted treason.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 2 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
sources, even if they lay beyond the limits of a state. He observed, that standing in the character of a committing magistrate, he was disposed to let in any evidence explanatory of such a doubt, although he might not perceive its bearing or its relevancy.
Mr. Burr denied that there could be any equivocal act in law; that every act must be either innocent or guilty; and that no explanatory or collateral evidence could be introduced to eke out the evidence of an overt act. He denied that there could be an overt act of treason unless there was either actual, or potential force; either actual hostilities or virtual intimidation; and that this was the first and only case in which it had ever been decided, that a mere military attitude was sufficient to constitute treason.
See moreSee less
On Monday Mr. Burr came prepared to discuss the propositions which he had
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper
The report describes courtroom proceedings in the Burr treason trial, detailing arguments over delay, witness depositions, and the examination of multiple witnesses including Jacob Dunbaugh, James M'Dowell, and others. Prosecutor Hay moves to discharge some witnesses while Burr objects, insisting on discrediting certain testimony, and the court adjourns amid ongoing procedural disputes.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 2 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FROM RICHMOND
for that purpose.
After some desultory conversation the counsel for col. Burr waved the argument which they intended to urge, and the court proceeded with the examination of the evidence. Jacob Dunbaugh was again introduced, and examined at considerable length. He was followed by James M'Dowell, for the second time, and by Israel Miller.
See moreSee less
In the course of these proceedings, Mr. Hay suggested the propriety of discharging such witnesses as had already been before the court on the treason case.
Mr. Burr objected to this discharge. He observed, that Mr. Eaton should at all events attend the court; as he intended to disqualify his evidence; and to show that he ought not to be received as a witness in a court of justice.
On Tuesday the examination proceeded. Jacob Dunbaugh was again called in. He was followed by Stephen S. Welch; by Wm. Love, for the second time; by Samuel Moxlew, Chandler Lindley and John Mulholland.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Hay moved to send Burr, Blennerhassett, and Israel Smith west for trial on charges of levying war at the mouth of Cumberland. After lengthy argument, the chief justice ruled the court lacked power to commit for offenses done in the Mississippi Territory, but reserved judgment on whether Burr's Richmond acquittal barred further trial.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 2 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FROM RICHMOND. On Wednesday Mr. Hay made his motion to have Burr, Blannerhassett, and Israel Smith sent to the western country for trial, on a charge of having levied war against the U. S. at the mouth of Cumberland. When Mr. Hay was about to offer his testimony, Mr. Botts commenced an argument on three grounds—First, that court had no power to commit for any crime which might have been committed in the Mississippi territory. 2d, That the acquital of colonel Burr here went to bar any future trial at any place in the United States—and third, that the enquiry in the Mississippi territory was sufficient to exempt him from farther trial within that territory for the same offence.
See moreSee less
This argument continued till Saturday, when the chief justice delivered the opinion of the court, that they had no right to commit for an offence done
This report quotes and analyzes the court's opinion in the Burr treason trial, focusing on whether an actual assemblage of armed men is required to constitute levying war. It examines the legal distinction between merely enlisting men versus actually assembling them for a treasonable purpose.
The Enquirer · 3 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
We have been before told that the assemblage with the treasonable intent would amount to levying war, would compleat the crime of levying war, here in variant language but language equally as strong if not stronger—we are told that if the treasonable intent is carried into execution, how? by deeds of violence and force? No: but by an open assemblage of men for that treasonable purpose; this crime is consummated; not that by such assemblage the crime is in an incipient stage; not that it is advancing to maturity; but that it is consummated. To remove all possibility of doubt, the court then begin to consider the subject analytically. "The prisoner stated that" "Col. Burr with the support of a powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was levying an armed body of 7,000 men from the state of New-York and the western states and territories, with a view to carry an expedition to the Mexican territories."
"That the association, whatever may be its purpose, is not treason, has been already stated. That levying an army may or may not be treason, and that this depends on the intention with which it is levied, and on the point to which the parties have advanced, has been also stated. The mere enlisting of men without assembling them is not levying war. The question then is whether this evidence proves Col. Burr to have advanced so far in levying an army as actually to have assembled them." Here again it is clear that if the case has gone so far as that the men have been assembled, the crime in the opinion of the court is compleat. Proceeding with the analysis the court say: "It cannot be necessary that the whole army should assemble, and that the various parts which are to compose it should have combined. But it is necessary there should be an actual assemblage, and therefore this evidence should make the fact unequivocal.
See moreSee less
"The travelling of individuals to the place of rendezvous would perhaps not be sufficient. This would be an equivocal act, and has no warlike appearance. The meeting of particular bodies of men and their marching from places of partial to a place of general rendezvous would be such an assemblage.
"The particular words used by Mr. Swartwout are that Col. Burr was levying an armed body of 7,000 men. If the term levying in this place imports that they were assembled, then such fact would amount, if the intention be against the United States, to levying war.— If it barely imports that he was enlisting or engaging them in his service, the fact would not amount to levying war.
A prosecution attorney argues to the jury that the assemblage on Blennerhassett's Island alarmed the governments of Ohio and the United States, proving it had the character of levying war. He contends the jury must decide whether the facts constitute an overt act of treason, while acknowledging the court's role is limited to general instruction.
The Enquirer · 3 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
prove upon them, if permitted. And contemptible in point of numbers as the party under Aaron Burr may appear, it will be shewn to you, Sir, that the United States had not a garri
A witness recounts a conversation with Blennerhassett, who showed him letters from Burr and discussed preparations for an expedition down the river, including boats and men gathered by Comfort Tyler and others. The witness also describes Blennerhassett's claims about purchasing land in the Orleans Territory as the stated legal object of their venture, while suggesting an unstated 'ulterior object' existed.
The Enquirer · 3 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
MR. JOHN GRAHAM.
In the latter end of October last, I received a letter from Mr. Madison, requesting that I would pass through the Western country, on my return to New-Orleans.—I know not whether it be proper to assign to the Court the reasons of this wish. It may serve however to explain my conduct in the Western country.—Mr Madison stated to me, as a reason of this request, that government had received information from various quarters that a project was on foot to sever the Union or to invade the territory of Spain.—Mr Wickham objected to this explanation.—Witness. It was to show that I had acted in obedience to my duty as an officer of the government. Mr Wickham. What office did you hold? a. I was secretary of the Orleans Territory.—When I arrived at Marietta, about the middle of November, I made enquiries and heard what it may not perhaps be proper to state—Mr Duval called on me and informed me that Mr Blennerhassett had just arrived with him and would wait upon me. After passing the usual compliments and expressing his pleasure at seeing me, he begged leave to read to me certain letters which he had received by Captain Elliot of the Western country, who had just returned from Pittsburg. Mr Blennerhassett made many enquiries relative to Comfort Tyler, Dean and Butler, and the preparations which they were making for their expedition down the river; what number of men and settlers they had obtained. Mr Elliot gave him to understand that there would be more settlers than there would be boats for them. When Blennerhassett received this information, he observed that they could descend in his boats, as he had more boats than men. Before Captain Elliot quitted the room, Mr Blennerhassett handed me a letter, which he said he had received a few days before from Col Burr in Kentucky. Shall I state my recollection of the contents of that letter? Mr McRae. Do you believe the letter to have been Col Burr's? a. I believed it was Col Burr's writing; for though I had never seen Col Burr write, yet I had seen many letters said to be written by Col Burr. I merely mention this letter to show that it gave rise to a conversation between Mr Blennerhassett & myself, relative to the contents of this letter. The conversation was somewhat desultory; nor do I particularly recollect the order in which the several topics were introduced. In general I recollect, that Mr Blennerhassett animadverted upon the conduct pursued towards Col Burr at Frankfort; stating however his belief that this conduct was not authorised by the government. He mentioned that Col Burr had purchased from Col Lynch, I think, a certain part of the Baron Bastrop's grant in the Territory of Orleans. He stated also that he was to have an interest in this purchase, and seemed desirous of impressing on my mind a belief, that the object of his preparations was the settlement of this land, but I cannot now recollect that in the course of conversation he did positively avow it. His object seemed to be to avoid an explicit avowal; but he said, that they avowed that this was their object; that it was a legal one, and government would have no right to interfere, until it was ascertained, that they (meaning Col Burr and himself, as I understood) had an ulterior object. He contended that they had a right to go towards this object with just such preparations as they thought proper. This was an opinion in which I did not acquiesce. I made few enquiries; but he admitted in the course of conversation, that he was building boats for the expedition in which he was engaged with Col Burr; that he was engaging young men, single and without families to go down armed; he said they would have no cannon, but they would have rifles. He stated in the course of conversation, the use to which these rifles might be applied: to resist the Indians and Spaniards, or to kill game. It is justice to Mr Blennerhassett to add, that he said, he did not solicit men to go; that he took such only as pleased to go; and that he did not expect more than 300 men would go with him. He stated also that he was engaging provisions for this same expedition. From what I had heard after my arrival at Marietta, and from the manner in which Mr Blennerhassett entered my room and made these communications, I was rather induced to believe that he conceived me to be one of the party. q. Why from his manner? a. My acquaintance with him before was slight; and yet he was extremely polite to me; and expressed how happy he would be at seeing me in his own house. For reasons which it is unnecessary to take up the time of the court with, I was anxious to undeceive Mr. Blennerhassett. I asked him, if he had stated that I was one of the party. He said, that he had; and that he had understood so from Colonel Burr.—When I assured him, I was not, he expressed considerable surprize, not by verbal declarations but by the marked air of his countenance. He observed to me that I did not know Col Burr, and passed some eulogiums upon him; and asked me in a very impressive manner, whether I had not heard of an Association in New-Orleans for the invasion of Mexico. I told him, that I had not, and I ventured to assure him, that there was no such Association there. He told me, that there certainly was, and that about 800 men had signed to such an Association, I think that was his expression, for the purpose of invading Mexico. After I had repeated my thorough conviction, that there was none such, and assigned the fact of his being deceived about me as a presumptive reason why he should be deceived about others, he told me that he had obtained this information from Mr Bradford.
See moreSee less
Considering Mr Blennerhassett at that time as a deluded man, I endeavored to draw him off from the undertaking in which he was engaged; and considering that it was more the policy of the government to prevent than to punish such enterprizes on the Ohio, I informed him, that so far from being concerned in the plan, I was an agent of the government, authorised to enquire into the facts relative to this enterprize in the Western country, and to take such steps as might be necessary for repressing it. I then stated to him, from reasons drawn from Col Burr's visit to New-Orleans in the preceding summer, from the information which government had received, and from the nature of the preparations which Mr Bl. himself was then making, why I believed that the object of Col B. was either to attack the territories of the United States, or those of Spain. I assured him at the same time, that any collection or combination of armed men on the Ohio, would under these circumstances be considered as a violation of the laws and repressed accordingly. He again contended that they had a right to go down the river, as they thought proper, inasmuch as they avowed the settlement of the Ouachita which was a legal object. Though we could not agree on this point, he asked me whether there would be any objection or opposition made to those men, if they went down in small parties. I gave him to understand, that this would depend upon circumstances, but that when they were collected, they would be arrested, and the enterprize would end in the ruin & disgrace of all those who were concerned in it.
During this conversation, I stated to Mr Bl. pointedly, that I knew not the opinions of Mr Jefferson or Mr Madison; that these were my own opinions; and that I had power to act, under the government of the United States, as circumstances required; that I was authorised to call on the constituted authorities of the country, if the constitution was about to be violated. I wish the court to understand, that I was to consider the moving down the Ohio, as a violation of the law, and I was then to call on the constituted authority. When I spoke of the reasons which influenced my belief as to Col B's plan, Mr Blennerhassett observed to me, that however acute the opinions of gentlemen might be, he and Col Burr were as well acquainted with the constitution and the laws as the administration itself; and that they knew very well what they were about. q. What produced this remark? a. I do not recollect, but perhaps it may have been the arguments which I had used to show that the expedition was a violation of the laws. Mr Bl. said, that he had joined his friends in this undertaking and could not abandon them, unless they consented to give the thing up; and asked me, if he was at liberty to communicate to Col B. the information I had given him. I told him, he was. I do not recollect, whether I have mentioned the opinion I expressed to Mr Bl. of the validity of Bastrop's Grant. I told him all that I knew of the title and that Col B. would have no title to it; and that if he had, the Orleans land could be no object with Mr Blennerhassett. Mr Wirt. How came you, sir, informed about this title? a. I had been at New-Orleans, where the subject was much talked of. q. Have there been any judicial proceedings about it? a. I told Mr Bl. that Mr Lynch claimed under Mr E. Livingston; that this was a considerable purchase; and that Mr Livingston had invalidated this contract in court. Mr Burr. I deny that this is a fact.
The next day, perhaps that afternoon, I met Mr Bl. at another house, in company with gentlemen most of them strangers to me. Mr Bl. was speaking & avowing, that Mr Burr had a great many friends in Kentucky. I observed, that this would much depend upon his object; if to settle Ouachita lands, that the people would wish him well; but if it was to attack the Territories of Spain or those of the United States, he would have very few friends. In reply, Mr Blennerhassett observed, that whatever was his object, he either had or would have a great number of friends. This was in a public room, in a tavern; several gentlemen were present; I recollect particularly a Major Sproat.—Either on that evening or the evening of the next day, Mr Blennerhassett said, he was writing to Col Burr. He invited me to his room, and wished to know how much of our conversation he might communicate to Col Burr. I told him, the whole if he chose; that the information was intended for him, but that he might communicate it to Col Burr. During this time and for a few days afterwards, the intercourse between us was friendly; but after I had had a conversation with Mr Henderson, I had no farther communications with him, save dining with him one day at the same table, and he rose immediately after dinner; and I did not see him again until we met in the Mississippi Territory.
Mr. Hay. Had you any communications with Mr. Burr? A. I had; and in the Mississippi territory too.—In consequence of the information I had received from Mr. Henderson and others, I lodged information with the Governor of Ohio, and a law was passed, and I was also instrumental at Frankfort in Kentucky, in the passage of a similar law. Their object was to put an end to these expeditions.
When I arrived at the little town of Washington in the Mississippi T. about the latter end of January or beginning of February, I heard that Col Burr was in the house.—Mr. Hay. Where is Washington? on the Mississippi river? A. No; It is 10 miles from it: and 7 miles back of Natchez. It is the seat of government of the Mis. territory. I waited on col. B. principally with a view to ascertain whether the information I had given to Mr. Bl. had been communicated to him. I asked him, whether Mr. Bl. had communicated our conversation to him. He said that he had.—I told him on entering his room, that I had just arrived from the Upper Country, and perhaps he might be anxious to hear the news. He told me that Mr. Blennerhassett had accused me of a breach of hospitality. I replied, that I never was in his house in my life. He spoke of his protested bills drawn in Lexington, and seemed to attribute their protest to the measures adopted by the government. I told him that just before I left Lexington, the merchants there had received information that they would be paid. He said that they ought to be paid, as the man on whom they were drawn, had the funds to pay them with. He then spoke of the measures pursued by government as ruinous and rigorous (I am not certain which was his expression); that they had detained his people. (Q. Was this before or after his trial? A. It was before; he had then entered into recognizance.) He said, that he had invited investigation into his conduct; he spoke of the measures of the military, and his determination to resist them: I understood him to mean the military of the U.S.; he either said he had or that he would order his people to resist them. He said, that he had claimed the protection of the civil authority, & thought that protection would be adequate to his safety. He spoke too of the Ouachita settlement; I believe, he told me that he should send his people there, but did not know whether he should venture into the territory himself; intimating, as I thought, an apprehension of gen. Wilkinson. He asked me, if I knew, what had given rise to the President's Proclamation. I told him, that I did not; unless it was gen. Eaton's communication.—The Court will see from the date of the Proclamation, that any information I could have imparted had not then reached the seat of government. Col. Burr observed, that the machinations of his enemies had led to these proceedings; and that facts did not support and justify them. I assured him that those who were alarmed and agitated were not his enemies; at least this was the idea I intended to convey; and after stating to him the alarm extending through the Western Country, I proposed to him, that he should make some public declaration as to his real object. His reply to this was, that he was a party concerned and that no declaration of his could have any effect. He seemed disposed to ridicule the idea of his bringing about a separation of the Union by physical force; that it was to be produced by moral, not physical causes. I mentioned to Colonel Burr that I had heard in the Western Country of a considerable number of men, perhaps 2000, being collected for the purpose of invading Mexico. His reply was, that he supposed that event was in case of a war with Spain. I told him, no; that I had not understood it as depending on that condition. He then said something about the Ouachita lands; and replied, that perhaps, when they had a separate government, something of that sort might be attempted (meaning, as I understood, the invasion of Mexico.) Soon after this, or at least before I had heard any explanation of what he meant by "a separate government," a gentleman of his family came in, and I took my leave.—I had no farther conversations with Mr. Burr or Mr. Blennerhassett.—I lodged an information against Mr. Blennerhassett, and was with him before a magistrate.
Mr. Hay. Did you make particular observations to Mr. Bl. about the sort of preparations he was making? A. He spoke of the settlement of the Ouachita as their object. He never positively told me it was, but he said they avowed it as their object. I observed to him, as a reason why I should not think it was, that young men without families or without any of the implements of husbandry were engaged to go: He said that their arms were to kill turkies or Indians. He then launched out into an abuse of the administration, their neglect of the army & navy, &c. I forgot to state this circumstance. When Mr. Bl. met me to know how far he was at liberty to communicate my opinions to col. Burr, I urged to him the impropriety of his engaging in these objects; he said it was impossible that col. B. could have so much deceived him and his son-in-law, Mr. Alston. Mr. Wirt. Was this remark after you had announced yourself as the agent of government? A. It was. Mr. Wirt. Did he say any thing to your objection about the want of implements of husbandry? A. He did say something about the opening of roads. But he never did tell me the real object. Q. Do you know any thing of the Ouachita land? A. I never was on it. Q. What is its character? A. Some say it is good and some say it is bad. I believe the greater part of it is covered with water; and there is some very fine land.
Cross Examined.—Mr. Burr. Did you ever see Bastrop's patent? A. Never. Q. Did you read it? A. No; I always understood, that there never was one. Mr. Burr. You have said that the greater part was water; I will assure the court, that it was to be laid out without any water. Were you ever examined before? A. Yes; I made a deposition, when I lodged information before the Legislature of Ohio. Q. Were you examined on any other occasion? A. I was before the Grand Jury. Q. Did you say any thing then of a conversation you had with Gen. Neville? A. Yes. I told Gen. Neville that I had come to make some enquiries into this affair. Gen. N. informed me what had passed in his conversation with the Mr. Morgans. He said the people had apprehended that your object was the separation of the U. S.; but that if it was the invasion of Mexico, you would be better received on your return than you ever had been. Q. Did you not then speak of the boats? A. I did. Q. Did you not say, they were unfit to go up the stream? A. I so understood at that time. Q. Do you not know that they were seized by government to send troops up the stream? A. I did not hear of it before I came here. Q. Did I give you a welcome reception? A. I was not acquainted with your manner. It was cold, but I thought respectful. Q. Have you not heard Gov. Williams, Mead, and Rodney say, that they would not suffer the military to take me? A. I most certainly recollect, that I both thought and said that it was improper to take you by military authority; & I heard Gov. Williams say, if the attempt was made, he was not authorised to sanction it. Q. Had you not heard of the stipulations made to me by Williams and Mead? A. I knew not of Gov. Williams's stipulating with you. I heard of Mr. Mead's doing it. Q. Was there no law to arrest me? A. I mentioned to Gov. W. that if the laws were not sufficiently energetic to meet such occurrences, it was better to provide one. But I never saw the law. Q. Did you not hear of an officer being there to arrest me? A. I had a conversation with a Lieut. Peter, who was lately in this place, relative to this subject. The counsel for the prosecution objected to this course of examination. Ch. Jus. If Mr. Burr means to allege these measures as an excuse for his own military preparations, he may press these enquiries. Mr. Burr. I did suppose from the sort of duties which Mr. Graham discharged in that country, that he must have known of the stipulations of Meade and Williams, and that in direct violation of these, a party of officers in disguise (that is without their uniform) and with concealed weapons, as dirks and pistols, were there to seize me. Mr. Graham certainly knows something on this subject. Mr. Graham. I can speak of my conversation with Gov. Williams and Lieut. Peter, for with no others did I communicate on this subject. Gov. Williams told me, that a Dr. Carmichael had been authorised to come to the Mississippi Ter. and seize you; whether this was before or after your trial, I know not. He said that he was extremely unwilling to have any such thing done. I observed that it was extremely improper to suffer a person to be seized, who was then in the custody of the law. He said that he had remonstrated with Dr. Carmichael; that Dr. C. had given it up and returned. Mr. Burr. Did C. belong to the army? A. No: to the Mis. Territory. I was proceeding to state that the night Col. Burr left Washington, I heard some of the officers in the room, in which I slept conversing about him, and one of them observed that if Col. B. was not arrested on that night, he would make his escape. The gentlemen left the room, and I afterwards understood from Lt. Peter, that an application had been or was about to be, made to Gov. Williams for permission to arrest Col. Burr. Lt. Peter having understood that I had heard part of this conversation, informed me that he had come with other officers to arrest Col. B. and I advised him to do nothing that would violate the laws of his country. He gave me to understand, that at that moment he felt himself bound to obey the orders of his General, like a good soldier. I urged every consideration I could suggest against the exercise of military authority; and I did then understand, that it was not his intention to proceed against Col. Burr. Indeed I understood that Col. B. had made his escape. I advised Gov. Williams to make such arrangements with him as would send him on to Washington for trial, or to detain him in that Territory for trial?
Mr. Blennerhassett. You stated that you had given information against me, and led to a prosecution? A. I did not say that I had led to a prosecution; but only that I had given information against you, that you might be taken to the district where the expedition had been fitted out. Q. Why did you prefer Judge Toulman to Judge Rodney; the last being the senior judge? A. I made no choice.
Q. Did you not understand that Judge Toulman was the judge of the Tombigbee county? A. I understood that he was judge of the Mississippi Territory, and Judge T. still insists upon it that he possesses this authority. Q. Did you not apply to the Attorney General of that Territory? A. Certainly not. Judge T. would have interfered; but Judge Rodney issued a writ of Habeas Corpus. Q. Was it by direction or request of the government, that you informed against me for the misdemeanor? A. By neither. Q. Do you not expect to pay the 1000 dollars? A. I expect not. Q. To whom are you to pay it?—Mr. Graham here addressed the court; he said that Judge Rodney had refused to send Mr. Blennerhassett round for trial; but had held him to bail; that he himself had been recognised; that the court was to set some time in May; the Judge considered the Supreme Court as the proper tribunal; the Attorney General thought otherwise, that before the court met he had besides been indisposed & had obtained the certificate of his physician that he could not attend that court. Mr. Burr. Are you still secretary of the Orleans Territory? A. I am not. Q. Do you now hold any office under the government and what is it? A. I am Chief Clerk in the office of Secretary of State.
Q. Was there any arrangement made to seize Col B. after their judicial proceedings against him? A. Governor Williams and myself both agreed that his trial in the Mississippi Territory was a mere farce and that something ought to be done. He proposed to see Col. Burr and make some arrangements with him to come on to the city of Washington for his trial. Col. B. informed him that he was merely going to ride to col. Osborne's for that night. Gov. Williams informed me that he received a great coat at the suburbs of the town and disappeared.
Mr. Wirt. Was not Col. Burr held in recognizance? A. Yes. Q. Did you see such a recognizance? A. Yes. I saw it myself in the clerk's office. Mr. Burr. If it is there, I pronounce it to be a forgery. Mr. Hay observed that the truth would appear in time. Mr. Hay. Were any legal proceedings pending at the time of his departure? The witness asked the court if this was a proper question. Ch. Jus. It is a mere difference of opinion about a fact. Col. B. contended that his recognizance had been complied with; Gov. Williams says not. Mr. Hay. Was his departure from Washington sudden? A. It was certainly sudden, as Gov. W. told me, he had been promised with a call from Col. Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 9 October 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 14 October 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 14 October 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.
This report records courtroom testimony from witnesses James McDowell and Israel Miller during Burr's treason trial proceedings, detailing observations of armed men, boats, boxes, and Burr's own words to his followers near Bayou Pierre. Cross-examination by Burr and Blennerhassett probes details about the boats, leaks, and numbers of men present.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT
James M'Dowell again called in.
Mr. Hay. How far did your evidence go, on your former examination? Mr. Wirt. The court stopped him within the limits of the United States. Mr. Hay. Do you recollect any thing that passed, after you left the mouth of Cumberland?
See moreSee less
The Witness replied to successive interrogatories, that he saw 8 or 10 arms in the boat, which at sat out in, the boat of Capt. Tyler and Maj. Smith, that he saw guns, but not so many, in the other boats; that Colonel Tyler was the Captain of that boat; that he thought there were about 130 men at Coles's Creek; that at a little Bayou below Bayou Pierre the boats stopt and Col. Burr got out; he knew nothing of clearing ground for exercising the men; he did not see the boxes opened; that some of the boxes were 4 feet long and some six, that they were heavy, and he could not lift them; he saw 6 or 7 boxes; that a few miles below Coles's Creek, they went up on a hill, and formed a circle: Colonel Burr told them, he was a thorn in their side, so long as he remained with them; that he had been taken from them two or three times; he had been carried on his trial to Washington; and that he was now about to leave them; he told them, what was his, was their's, (alluding as the witness supposes to his property,) and that they might go on and settle the Ouachita country, which he had purchased.
Cross-Examined.
Mr. Burr. Did you see General Wilkinson at New-Orleans? A I do not know whether I saw him. Q Who invited you to come here? A I was summoned in Pennsylvania. Mr. Blennerhasset. Do you recollect being in Dean's boat? A I do. Q Do you not recollect, that its roof was leaky? A I do. Q Do you not recollect, that I expressed some fears, lest the leaks might injure my boxes? A I do not recollect.
Multiple witnesses are cross-examined about events at Blennerhassett's Island and the mouth of the Cumberland, including the number of men, boats, weapons, and powder supplies. Testimony also covers Burr's stated intentions regarding Baton Rouge and the Ouachita lands.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
with any thing but bullets.
TUESDAY, Sept. 22.
See moreSee less
Jacob Dunbaugh was re-examined; He stated there were two keels and four batteaux; that Mr Burr had told him between Chickasaw Bluffs and Bayou Pierre, that his first object was to sieze Baton Rouge, and make that his home, until he could collect his forces which he expected would amount to 10 or 12000; he stated that Mr Blennerhasset told him, that governor Foulk of Baton Rouge would order the men to take the flints out of their guns; he said that some of the men went up the Red river.
Upon being cross-examined, he stated that he had made a deposition at New-Orleans at the request, but not compulsion of General Wilkinson; that he was well acquainted with the construction of batteaux, that they could go up stream, and that they were built for that purpose.
Chandler Lindsley testifies about joining Burr's party at the mouth of the Cumberland River, estimating the force at 70-80 men. He describes recruitment terms for settling Ouachita land and the purchase of bar-iron and supplies from Mr. Ellis.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Burr.
No Cross-Examination.
See moreSee less
CHANDLER LINDSLEY.
Q Where did you begin with your voyage? A I descended the river with Mr Ellis from Pittsburg. Q What was the object of the voyage? A Mr Ellis called it a trading voyage. Q Did you join the party at the mouth of Cumberland? A I did. Q What do you suppose was the force at the mouth of Cumberland? A I should suppose that there were about 70 or 80 men. The circle, to which Col. Burr was introduced, consisted of 30 or 40; and I should suppose, they composed about a half of the whole. Q. Did you stop at Cincinnati? A I did. Q Did you receive any information of the party there? A I heard that col. Burr had been there a day or two before; and had excited some consternation among
A witness recounts the terms of Aaron Burr's expedition agreement, describing the purchase of boats, iron tools, and supplies at the mouth of the Cumberland River, and his own recruitment into the venture by Colonel Tyler. Prosecutor Wirt and defense counsel Hay question him closely about the origins of the supplies and whether the plan involved hostile intent.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CHANDLER LINDSLEY
thers in a keel boat purchased by Colonel Burr of Mr Ellis. Q What was in that boat? A Bar-iron, hoes, mattocks and a few barrels of apples. Q Do you know where the bar-iron and other articles were obtained? A Yes; they were purchased by Col. Burr of Mr Ellis at the mouth of Cumberland. Mr Wirt. Was Mr Ellis's being there accidental? A At the time Mr Ellis was at the Falls, Major Floyd talked of making a contract with Mr Ellis, for these articles: he did not however buy them; but told Mr Ellis, that he would see colonel Burr on the river, and he was confident that the colonel would purchase the whole. Q Where were these articles from? A From Pittsburg. Mr Wirt. My
A witness describes the Ouachita land company address signed by Tyler's party, Burr's introduction to the men at Cumberland, and instructions to make cartridges. The witness states he understood the purpose to be settling Ouachita lands but recalls conversations about seizing Baton Rouge after passing Bayou Pierre.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Q How many signers were to it? A About 30 or 32. Q Had you any assurance that the plan would be disclosed to you at the mouth of Cumberland? A None, from those who had a right to be informed. Such however, was the talk among the men, as we went down. Q When you were at the mouth of Cumberland, were you introduced to colonel Burr? A I was, on the 27th December. We arrived there on the 26th. Q What took place on this introduction? A Nothing particular.
See moreSee less
Q At this introduction did the party form any thing like the 3 sides of a square? A They did. Q Was he introduced along the line? A He was; to the men, one by one. Q After this ceremony was there any speech from col Burr? A I was not near enough to hear what he said; but I understood that he said he would impart something at another time. Q Did you receive any instructions to run bullets and make cartridges? A One day, while we were in the Mississippi col Burr came into our boat and asked whether there was any one there that could make cartridges? I told him that I never had made any, but I believed I could make them, and I made 3 or 4 dozen. Q Did col Burr act as the head of the party? A I considered him as such. Q Did you understand that the real object was to settle Ouachita lands? A It was so stated. Q Was there no occurrence or particular conversation which induced to believe there was a different object? Mr Botts. Was there any conversation in the presence of col Burr? It was not a general conversation. Mr Hay. Is it a fact or is it not a fact, that many of the men did suppose there was a different object? A I do not recollect, nor did I attend to them; because I did not suppose they knew more about it than myself. Q Do you know any thing about the seizing of Baton Rouge? I never heard it before we got below Bayou Pierre, and then there were some conversations among the men about it. But I did not hear it suggested by any person, that there was any design of invading any part of the U. States; nor did I ever hear any thing from col Burr or any of the leaders about invading Mexico. The counsel for the accused said that it was unnecessary to make any statement on that subject. Mr Hay. The present enquiry relates as well to the misdemeanor as to the treason. Mr Martin. We have never heard of such a charge before. Mr Hay observed that he had also reduced this charge to writing, and had notified its existence to one of the opposite counsel, though it had never been publicly read in court. The clerk then read the paper in the following terms: "The Attorney of the U. S. for the Virginia district, charges Aaron Burr, Herman Blennerhasset and Israel Smith, with
The report details circuit court proceedings over several days, including cross-examination of General Wilkinson and testimony from George Poindexter about Burr's surrender and flight in Mississippi Territory. A grand juror also testified confirming Wilkinson's consistent statements, while the motion for Burr's commitment continued to be argued.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THURSDAY, October 1.
The greater part of this day was consumed in the farther examination of General James Wilkinson by the Counsel of Col. Burr, who was himself sick, and did not appear in court.
See moreSee less
George Poindexter, Esq. Attorney General of the Mississippi Territory, was next introduced, and stated a variety of circumstances concerning the surrender of Aaron Burr to Cowles Meade, the acting Governor of that Territory; the proceedings there relative to the accusations against him; the strange presentments made by the Grand Jury; and Col. Burr's flight, in violation of his recognizance; whereupon a Scire-facias issued against his securities, which is now depending and undetermined.
Mr Poindexter produced the original Convention in writing entered into by Col. Burr, previous to his surrender; also an authenticated copy of the Recognizance.
This passage presents documentary exhibits from the Burr conspiracy case, including a sworn affidavit from Colonel Cushing about troop movements at New Orleans, a letter of introduction from Burr to General Wilkinson regarding Samuel Swartwout's brother, and a decoded cipher letter from General Dayton to Wilkinson discussing political plans involving 'Wealth and Glory, Louisiana and Mexico.' These documents were being used as evidence to establish the conspiracy's scope and communications network.
Virginia Argus · 3 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
(C) Copy of a letter from General Dayton to General Wilkinson, written in cypher except those parts printed in Italics. This cypher was designed by General Dayton, and founded on the Hieroglyphics known to General Wilkinson and Col. Burr. July 24th, 1806.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report covers courtroom proceedings in the U.S. Circuit Court on the motion to commit Burr, Blennerhassett, and Smith, featuring testimony from General Eaton and General Wilkinson. Wilkinson is questioned about communications with Burr and produces documents, including a deposition from Colonel Cushing, amid procedural disputes over evidence inspection.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
On the motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.
See moreSee less
SATURDAY, SEPT. 26.
Gen. Eaton was introduced as a witness on the part of the United States, to supply those parts of his testimony
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 3 other papers
General Wilkinson recounts courtroom testimony describing how Samuel Swartwout delivered a letter and packet from Aaron Burr, which Wilkinson later found contained a coded message suggesting an illicit scheme. He describes decoding part of the cipher and consulting with Colonel Cushing about Swartwout's suspicious cover story of volunteering for a campaign against the Spanish.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
[The general then produced a paper, said to be the deposition of col. Cushing, which comprehended this letter. Mr. Botts said, when you are about to shew a paper, you will please to submit it to our inspection. Gen. Wilkinson. I shall be governed by the judge in that respect. Mr. Botts. Then we shall request the judge to govern you in that respect. General Wilkinson. I shall endeavor to conduct myself with propriety, and in the most decorous manner to the court. Here gen. Wilkinson recapitulated the contents of the letter ; which may be seen in the annexed deposition of col. Cushing, marked A.]
Mr. Swarwout took a seat, and informed us that, being on his way down the Mississippi for New Orleans, in company with a Mr. Ogden, they had heard at Fort Adams of the impending operation against the Spaniards, which had induced him to ascend the Red River, in order to join me, and volunteer his services in the campaign ; and that Mr. Ogden had proceeded on his journey to New Orleans. Col. Cushing retired for a few minutes ; and pending that interval, Mr. Swartwout slipped from his side pocket a letter and packet or envelope, which he said he was charged by col. Burr to deliver to me. I hold the letter in my hand ; and it is a formal letter of introduction to Mr. Swartwout by Col. Burr. [Mr. Martin observed that, if any letters were produced, they should be lodged with the clerk, where both parties might have an opportunity of inspecting them. Chief Justice. Not unless they are read. The letter was laid upon the clerk's table.] I enquired of Mr. Swartwout where col. Burr was. He answered that he was in Philadelphia, or that he had left him there. Col. Cushing returned, and the conversation took a general course. After some time Mr. Swartwout withdrew ; and I retired to my chamber ; and in the packet or envelope I found a letter addressed to me in cypher from col. Burr. [Chief Justice. I did not understand you. How did you get that letter? A. It was in the packet or envelope.] This letter was principally in cypher ; the closing paragraph, however, was in the ordinary script. I resorted to the key, and attempted an interpretation of the letter. I did not complete it ; but discovered enough in the course of the evening to satisfy me, that there was some illicit project on foot. I arose early in the morning, and called on col. Cushing, my second in command, and adjutant and inspector to the army. I stated to him that Mr. Swartwout had borne me a letter from col. Burr, the nature of which I explained ; and observed to him that Mr. Swartwout's declarations, that he had come with a view to volunteer his services in the campaign against the Spaniards, were merely intended to cover his real design. I then communicated to col. Cushing the measures which I should pursue ; enjoining on him, at the same time, to observe the strictest secrecy. Were it permissible to be read, here is a statement of the facts sworn to by colonel Cushing. [The general held at this time in his hand the paper marked A. Mr. Wirt. This statement is signed by col. Cushing, with a certificate of his qualification, in legal form, annexed. Mr. Wickham. An affidavit forming no part of the case before the court, cannot be introduced. Mr. Hay. Gen. Wilkinson states that, on the morning after the letter was partly decyphered, he stated to col. Cushing its contents, and communicated to him the measures which he should pursue. These are facts detailed in that deposition ; and, if the gentlemen do not wish to see them, there is an end of the controversy. The gen. proceeded.] [One paragraph of the letter, I have observed, was in the ordinary script. [Here the paragraph was read by gen. Wilkinson, in the following words. "He is a man of inviolable honor and perfect discretion,—formed to execute rather than to project,—capable of relating facts with fidelity, and incapable of relating them otherwise. He is thoroughly informed of the plans and intentions of ——, and will disclose to you as far as you enquire, and no farther. He has imbibed a reverence for your character, and may be embarrassed in your presence.—— Put him at ease, and he will satisfy you."]—I determined to avail myself of this reference to obtain from Mr. Swartwout that information which I could not discover from the letter ; that is, the object to which col. Burr explicitly directed his views : and, in the course of several days, I obtained from him, substantially, the following facts ; that he had left col. Burr at Philadelphia, occupied day and night almost, on an enterprize which he had in contemplation ; that he lived in a retired part of the city, in a small house with several rooms, where he received persons with whom he had to transact business ; and that he saw no two persons at the same time. He observed to me that Commodore Truxton was frequently with him, and zealously engaged in his enterprize. He observed, at the same time, that a man who superintended the public buildings at Washington was also zealously engaged. He did not recollect his name : but on my mentioning the name of Latrobe, he said that was the man. He said that he had been dispatched by Col. Burr from Philadelphia, and had traversed the states of Ohio and Kentucky. I so understood the gentleman at that time ; but have since discovered that he descended the river [Mr. Botts. By whom did you understand that he had descended the river? A. By a man who informed me that he had rowed him down from Pittsburg.] Another reason why I may have been mistaken was this. He informed me that he had passed to Frankfort in quest of General Adair, for whom he had dispatches from Col Burr ; and, not hearing of him there, had returned back to Lexington in pursuit of him ; where he was informed by Major Waggoner that Gen. Adair (being in ill health) had gone to some medical spring ; and that, if he would wait a few days he might see him ; that he did so, and thus had an interview with him without incurring any suspicion ; at which time he delivered his dispatches. He said Gen. Adair was zealously engaged in the enterprize ; and observed "tell him that I will not write to him, but that I expect to meet him at the place ; that he may depend I will meet him on the spot ;" or words to that effect.
See moreSee less
Mr. Swartwout proceded to inform me that he came to Lousiville, and felt himself at a loss how he should reach me with the most certainty : that a rumor had prevailed there that I had descended the river. Finally on the advice of Mr. Floyd, he determined to go across the country, under the expectation of finding me at St. Louis. Accompanied by Mr. Ogden, he prosecuted his journey to Kaskaskias. Finding that I had descended the river, he determined to alter his route ; he purchased a Skiff, employed hands, and followed me down to fort Adams. At this point, I asked him whether this sudden change of route might not expose him to suspicions. He said that, to guard against this, he had wounded his horse with his pen-knife, and informed the people that his intentions were to have visited St. Louis ; but, having experienced this accident, he should pursue his original destination, which was to descend the river to New-Orleans. On arriving at fort Adams, and discovering that I had proceeded to Natchitoches, he determined to follow me ; & his friend Mr. Ogden (pursuing his route) went on with dispatches from Col. Burr, to his friends in New-Orleans. Mr. Swartwout informed me that Col. Burr, supported by a numerous and powerful association extending from New-York to New-Orleans, was about to levy an armed force of seven thousand men, with a view to carry an expedition against the Mexican provinces ; that five hundred men would descend the Allegany river with Col. Swartwout, and a major or col. Tyler : that the boats were already built. He observed that this territory would be revolutionized, where the people were ready to join ; & that some seizing, he supposed would be necessary at New-Orleans : that they expected to make their embarkation about the 1st of February ; that they proposed landing at La Vera Cruz, and marching from thence to Mexico. I observed to him that there were large sums of money in the bank of New-Orleans. He replied that he knew that full well. I observed, "surely you will not violate private property." He said "we mean only to borrow and will return it ;" that they must equip themselves at New-Orleans ; that naval protection would be had from Great Britain ; that Commodore Truxton and the officers of the navy were so disgusted with the government that they were ready to join ; and that pilot boat-built schooners were contracted for on the southern coast of the United States for the service.
He enquired of me whether I had heard of Dr. Bollman ; and on my replying in the negative, he expressed some surprize ; observed that Dr. Bollman and a Mr. Alexander had been dispatched from Philadelphia, by sea, to New-Orleans, with dispatches from colonel Burr to me, and that they must have arrived. Mr. Swartwout informed me that he was obliged to go to New-Orleans ; and was also under engagements to meet Col. Burr and Gen. Dayton at Nashville, on the 20th of November. I think Mr. Swartwout left Natchitoches, about 18th of October, for New-Orleans, as I understood.
It may be proper, in this stage of my testimony, to say that the envelope, which contained the cyphered letter from colonel Burr, covered also two other letters. To save misapprehension, it may also be proper to say, that when I speak of an envelope, it is in contradistinction to a sealed packet. It occurs to my recollection that a letter addressed to John Peters, Esq. of Nashville was enclosed in the envelope, as well as another letter, from general Dayton, in cypher. (See Dayton's letter. Note C.)
[Mr. Baker. Do you say that the letter from Gen. Dayton was inclosed in another cyphered letter? A. No. I say expressly the reverse. It came with it.
Mr. Wickham objected to reading the letter from Gen. Dayton. He said that, Gen. Dayton being absent, he had no opportunity of consulting him, or of ascertaining his wishes respecting it. If there be no other evidence that the letter was from general Dayton, except that a letter was received by general Wilkinson purporting to be a letter of general Dayton's, it was not evidence.
Mr. Hay. The fact stated by general Wilkinson is that he received this letter. It may have had a considerable influence with him, as to the course which he pursued. He received the letter, together with another cyphered letter from Col. Burr ; and, the fact being that he received this letter purporting to be a letter from Gen. Dayton, it surely may be read.
Mr. Wickham. If the letter by itself would not be evidence, its being connected with others would not make it so.
Mr. Hay. On that distinction, I mean to offer it. If General Dayton were before the court, he might require some other evidence as to the authenticity of the letter. General Wilkinson is telling his whole story ; he is to give his whole narrative ; and all the circumstances will bear upon each other.
The Chief Justice at first said, that, if general Wilkinson could say that the letter influenced his conduct, it might be read ; but, finally, he observed, that, on the motion now before the court, it might be improper to read it. If it be the intention of General Wilkinson to state that certain conduct of his was produced by that letter, he may state that such conduct was produced.
Gen. Wilkinson. I must say this letter materially influenced the measures which I pursued.
Mr. Hay. There is certainly a wide difference between this case, a mere examination before a judge, and a trial before a jury. This letter may identify general Dayton with the meeting at the mouth of Cumberland.]
Gen. Wilkinson. Here is the letter, addressed to J. Peters Esq. signed "A Stephens." It appears to be in a disguised hand ; but I have no doubt of its being the hand writing of Col. Burr. (See note D.)
I returned from the operations against the Spaniards, the 5th November ; and, on the next morning [Chief Justice. To what place did you return? A. To Natchitoches.] On the morning of the 6th November, a small Frenchman (whom I had never seen before, nor have I ever seen him since) presented a packet to me, and took his leave. This I found to be a letter from Dr. Bollman covering a letter from Col. Burr. The letter from Dr. Bollman, in his proper hand writing, bears date September 27th, 1806, from New-Orleans. (See note **) Here is the cyphered letter enclosed by Dr. Bollman ; and I find it is an exact duplicate, as it professes to be, of the one received by Mr. Swartwout ; with this variation.—"Doctor Bollman, equally confidential, better informed on the subject, and more intelligent, will hand this duplicate." [This letter was laid upon the Clerk's table.] That letter also inclosed one from general Dayton.
[Mr. McRae. Of the same tenor of the former? A. No: quite different.] This letter of general Dayton is partly in cypher, and partly in the common script. (See Note E.)
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 30 September 1807 · an extract
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 2 October 1807 · an extract
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 15 October 1807 · an extract
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
General Wilkinson recounts deciphering a letter from Burr delivered by Swartwout, and his subsequent actions including briefing Col. Cushing. He reads a passage of the letter describing an unnamed trusted agent, then describes extracting further details from Swartwout about Burr's enterprise, including mention of Commodore Truxton's involvement.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
cannot be introduced. Mr. Hay. Gen. Wilkinson states that, on the morning after the letter was partly decyphered, he stated to col. Cushing its contents, and communicated to him the measures which he should pursue. These
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
Burr's counsel objected to testimony about acts in the Mississippi territory, arguing the court lacked jurisdiction and that his prior acquittal barred further prosecution; the Chief Justice ruled he could not commit for trial based on Mississippi conduct but would hear evidence on Burr's actions within the United States. The passage also discusses conflicting accounts of the nationality of sailors taken from the Chesapeake, noting discrepancies between British and American claims.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mississippi territory, they were stopped by Mr. Burr's counsel, who objected to the introduction of any testimony of facts out of the jurisdiction of the State of Kentucky. Mr. Botts contended that no further testimony could be heard on the present motion. He relied on Mr. Burr's former acquittal as a perpetual bar to any future prosecution; and that the act of Congress which authorizes a judge to transmit a person charged with an offence from one district to another for trial, does not extend to the territorial governments. He was followed by Mr.
See moreSee less
M'Rae, on the part of the United States. On the 17th, Messrs. Hay, Martin, Wirt, Wickham and Botts severally delivered their opinion on the motion of yesterday. An unusual share of animation and eloquence marked the speeches of all the gentlemen on this interesting subject. The argument was not closed. On Friday Mr. Randolph closed; the Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the Court, that he had no power by law to commit for trial in the Mississippi territory:—But he would hear testimony on Burr's con
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
Accounts from Richmond report that Burr told the court he had received letters suggesting evidence would show that he and the public had been betrayed. He requested a delay in proceedings based on this expected testimony.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
More Mystery of Iniquity.
Accounts from Richmond state, that Burr had declared to the court, that from two letters he had just received, intimating that evidence was coming on to prove that the public and himself had been sacrificed and sold, he wished for delay.
See moreSee less
A draft has been made of one fifth of the militia of Canada for its defence, to be equipped at the expence of the government. The Canadian papers say the men volunteered their services, and that the French subjects in particular discovered the same loyalty as the English.
Vermont Election.—Israel Smith, the democratic candidate, is elected Governor of that State in the room of Gov. Tichenor. Pamphlets it is said were circulated by the democrats previous to the election stating that Gov. Tichenor was concerned in Burr's conspira
This report presents courtroom documents from Aaron Burr's treason trial, specifically Colonel Cushing's deposition read during the examination of General Wilkinson. The deposition recounts an October 1806 meeting where Samuel Swartwout delivered a letter from Jonathan Dayton introducing him and Ogden to Cushing at a military post near Natchitoches.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR.
(A) Deposition of Col. Cushing. On or about the 8th of October, 1806, I was sitting at the dining table in my quarters at Natchitoches with General Wilkinson, when a gentleman entered the room and enquired for Col. Cushing, I rose to receive him, and he presented to me the letter from Gen. Dayton, of which the following is an exact copy, viz. "Elizabeth Town, (N. J.) July 27th, 1806,
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
This passage recounts General Wilkinson's account of meeting Swartwout, who arrived with a coded letter from Aaron Burr proposing a treasonous enterprise. Wilkinson describes Burr's claims of funds, naval support, and an offer to make Wilkinson second-in-command, read into the record during the treason trial.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 5 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR.
The next morning I was walking on the gallery in front of my quarters, when gen. Wilkinson came up, and taking me aside, informed that he had something of a serious nature to communicate to me. So much so, that although it was necessary to hold it in strict reserve for the present, he begged me to bear it in mind, that I might be able to make fair statement of it at any future period. He then asked me if I knew, or had heard of an enterprize being on foot in the western states.
See moreSee less
I replied that I had heard nothing on the subject, and asked him what the enterprize was to which he alluded. He then said, "yes my friend" a great number of individuals possessing wealth, popularity and talents, are at this moment associated for purposes inimical to the government of the United States, Col. Burr is at their head, and the young gentleman who delivered you the letter last evening, is one of his emmissaries. The story of serving as a volunteer, is only a masque. He has brought me a letter from Col. Burr, which being in cypher, I have not yet been able fully to make out, but I have discovered that his
A witness is cross-examined about Burr's plans to settle the Ouachita country, his recruitment by Captain Berry, and the construction and purpose of the boats used on the expedition. Further testimony describes guard duties over the boats near Natchez and orders given regarding militia and countersigns.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE
-a certain portion of land besides other compensation. Q. What was it? A. Captain Berry offered me ten dollars a month, but I said I was not for hire and would go as a volunteer. Q. Did you descend the river with him? A. Yes. Q. Do you recollect hearing any conversation from Mr. Burr to Mr. Floyd, on the subject of
A witness describes the boats, men, and supplies gathered at the mouth of the Cumberland River, and recounts a search conducted by Captain Fitzpatrick near Bayou Pierre. Under cross-examination by Burr and Wirt, the witness discusses his separation from the group, his later contact with General Wilkinson, and a small payment he received to cover expenses as a witness.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Burr. Did you know Dean's boat? A. It sailed with us in company from the mouth of Cumberland; but I do not certainly know whether it was connected with us. Q. What became of Boyce's boat?—A. It went down to Natchez.
Mr. Wirt. Who dismissed you from the party? A. When the boats were stopped and the eruption took place, I went down to Natchez. Mr. Wirt. When col. B. left the party was there any ceremony at parting? any speech? A. He did speak to them. He said he would have to leave them them until he could see them again. I think he said his property was to be distributed among them. Q. Was any thing said about wages; about the means of paying them? A. I don't recollect.
See moreSee less
Mr. Burr. How did you come round from New Orleans? A. I came with general Wilkinson. Q. Were you subpœnaed? A. I was. Q. Had you any communication with general Wilkinson? A. Not till after I had received the subpœna. Q. Did you receive any money there? any from general Wilkinson? A. Yes, I received ten dollars from general Wilkinson to help bear my expences as a witness. Did you give any deposition there? A. None; but some statement of my evidence, taken down by general Wilkinson; but I did not give my qualification to it.
William Love called in again. Mr. Hay. When did you separate
A witness describes joining Blennerhassett's party at the Falls of Ohio, details on boats carrying arms and provisions, and his eventual discontent leading him to leave for Natchez. Under cross-examination by Burr, he discusses being brought by Gen. Wilkinson from New Orleans, receiving money, and the number of men at the mouth of the Cumberland.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 5 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Burr. Who brought you round here from New Orleans? A. Gen. Wilkinson. I was introduced to him by serjeant Dunbaugh before I was subpœnaed.
The court heard testimony from witness Jacob Dunbaugh about the assemblage at the mouth of the Cumberland River, including that weapons were sunk in the river before Burr's boats could be searched. Chief Justice Marshall ruled such evidence admissible as the gathering appeared 'doubtful and equivocal,' while Burr's counsel argued an act could not be partly innocent and partly criminal, and prosecutor Hay complained of delays and announced he would proceed to depositions.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 6 October 1807 · page 2
FEDERAL COURT.
-sac of tac assemblage at the mouth of Cum ' berland as an equivocal a&, and that tefti ~ mony night be adduced to shew the chaE racter of that adt, and the intention with ~ which the assemblage took place. On the ~ other hand, it was contended by Col. Burr and his counsel that there could be no such thing as an equivocal a@. That the meet ing at the mouth of Cumberland was either innocent in itfelf, or criminal. . If innocent, no testimony drawn from any other {ource could make it criminal., , NS
The piece argues that under Jefferson's judges, criminals go free through technical pretexts about evidence and venue rather than facts, contrasting this with an earlier era when trials reliably convicted the guilty. It specifically attacks the reasoning that Burr could not be convicted of treason at Blennerhassett's Island because he personally joined his forces downriver, calling this a mockery of justice and common sense.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 6 October 1807 · page 2
BURR ACQUITTED, THOUGH GUILTY,
“ wrong,” and a little ingenuity to ; twist out a plaufibie pretext for the | new one. Thisis the eff=& of pro- | feflional nivftery, and will grow worse § and worse, so. long as improvement | in ingenuity attaches to the human ? mind. i The ancient trial, and the true ob. ! je& of all wrial, is simply to search for | and find out the truth : but instead ! of pursuing the simple path which na ture has laid down for arriving at truth, there are a thousand fliles and gates that stop you, this is not relevant, that is not 7 order of time, and to’ther s out of place.—We are not to arrive at knowledge by the common inlets or channels ; but thro’ particular ones, and in a particular position.
A witness describes joining Burr's expedition down the river, including making cartridges, seeing arms and riflemen, and being introduced to Aaron Burr near the mouth of the Cumberland River. The testimony covers the recruitment, an address to a land speculation company, and Burr's request for cartridge-making assistance.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 6 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
formed that company? There were no names mentioned in the address; but I considered col. Burr as one though his name was not mentioned. Q Who drew up the address? Major Tyler and Smith.
A witness is cross-examined about whether he heard any talk of invading Mexico or Spanish territory, naming Burr, Blennerhassett, Tyler, Smith, and Floyd as the figures discussed. Counsel and the chief justice argue over whether a misdemeanor charge regarding a military expedition against Mexico was properly read into the treason proceedings.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 6 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
of invading any part of the U. S. nor did I ever hear any thing from col. Burr or any of the leaders about invading Mexico.
The counsel for the accused said that it was unnecessary to make any statement on the subject.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay. The present enquiry relates as well to the misdemeanor as to the treason.
Mr Martin. We have never heard of such a charge before.
Mr. Hay observed that he had also reduced this charge to writing, and notified its existence to one of the opposite counsel, though it had never been publicly read in court. The clerk then read the paper in the following terms:
"The attorney of the U. S. for the Virginia district, charges Aaron Burr, Harman Blannerhassett and Israel Smith, with a misdemeanor against the United States, in beginning, or setting on foot, or preparing or providing the means of a military expedition or enterprize, against Mexico, a province in North America, of the king of Spain, with whom the U. S. are at peace."
Mr. Hay. It is immaterial, besides, whether his charge has been preferred; because, though the charge actually alledged is treason, yet if the other crime should
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 2 other papers
General Wilkinson testifies at Burr's treason trial about his march to New Orleans and his exchanges with Dr. Bollman regarding letters from Burr and Lieutenant Spence's mission. He recounts being questioned by Bollman about what part he would take, to which he claimed he remained noncommittal while holding his military commission.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
On the Motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.
See moreSee less
Saturday, Sept. 26. Gen. WILKINSON'S EXAMINATION, (CONTINUED.)
[Mr. Wirt. Are you acquainted with General Dayton's hand writing? A. Perfect. Mr. Hay. How did you become acquainted with it? A. From a long and familiar correspondence. Here is a letter from General Dayton to me, introducing his son, which will shew the similarity of the hand writing. [Here the General produced the letter of introduction.] On the same morning I received the following information from Natches, in a letter from James L. Donaldson, dated the 30th of November, 1806.—Here General Wilkinson offered to read the letter—but it was rejected by the court. See note F.] In consequence of the receipt of this letter from Mr. Donaldson, and my reflections on the letters from Col. Burr, I determined to concentrate my whole force at New Orleans, as soon as possible. [Mr. Hay said that he was willing in order to save time, to wave every thing which related to the operations of the army; and requested that General Wilkinson would proceed to relate what occurred at New Orleans.] I proceeded from Natchitoches to Natches and descending from that place reached fort Adams on the 18th of November—where I found Mr. Swartwout, who had been taken ill on his route from Natchitoches to New Orleans, and, for his accommodation, was invited by some one of the officers to that place. He informed me that Mr. Ogden had reached that place, on his way to Tennessee—but, being alarmed by the rumors which prevailed in that part of the country, he was afraid to proceed, and had halted there. I enquired of Mr. Swartwout whether Mr. Ogden had borne any letters. He said that he had not.—but that Lieut. Spence of the navy had been sent, some time before, from New Orleans, through the country, with letters from Col. Burr. I proceeded on, and reached New Orleans on the 25th of November, in the evening; and, on the 26th, in the morning, I received a letter from Dr. Bollman. [Here General Wilkinson produced the letter. See note G.] This letter reminds me of a circumstance which I had omitted. The morning after I had received the letter of Dr. Bollman at Natchitoches, I acknowledged the receipt of it in a short note, and informed him that I should be in N. Orleans about the 20th. I did not call on Dr. Bollman till the 30th. After the ordinary salutations, I enquired whether he had heard of col. Burr, since his arrival. He informed me that he had not. I asked him whether he had heard of lieut. Spence's arrival in Tennessee. He enquired how I came to know any thing of lieut. Spence. I informed him that it was through Mr. Swartwout. He assured me that he had sent dispatches for col. Burr by lieut. Spence, and that he had heard of his arrival at Nashville. He then enquired what part I meant to take? I observed that I felt myself delicately situated. It was impossible that I could take any part, while I held my commission; and I was so circumstanced that I could not get rid of it. He asked me what I thought of the competency of the force of the undertaking. I observed that it depended upon a variety of circumstances; such as winds, weather, composition and appointment of the troops, skill in conduct, the resistance of their opponents, and other causes on which the success of military operations depend. But I gave it as my opinion, that I thought the force insufficient. He said that col. Burr had gone too far to retract; that he had numerous and powerful friends in the U. States, who stood pledged to support him with
No. 1089.
PAID IN ADVANCE.
their fortunes; and that he must succeed. He then enquired of me my opinion as to the state of the magazines of provisions in New-Orleans. I observed that, if Col. Burr descended with the force proposed, they would starve, unless he brought provisions along with him; for I had before ascertained precisely the quantity then on hand. He said that it was his opinion, also, that there would be a scarcity of provisions; that he had written to Col. Burr on the subject; and that he expected a supply from New-York and Norfolk, where col. Burr had many friends. He said that he had noticed in the public prints the sailing of some vessels with flour; and supposed that they might be destined for that place. I did not see Dr. Bollman, afterwards, till the 5th of December, the day after the arrival of the mail; and I called on him to enquire the news. He said that he had seen a letter from Col. Burr, of the 30th of Oct. in which he stated that he should be at Natchez, on the 20th of December, with two thousand men; to be followed by four thousand more; and that he could have raised or levied twelve thousand men, as easily as six, if he had thought them necessary. I then informed Doctor Bollman, that, if Col. Burr came to New-Orleans, I should oppose him. He replied, they must come there for provisions and equipments. He observed that Col. Burr had great confidence in me; but he did not know what had passed between us; and asked, if I could not make such a defence as would cover my reputation, and still permit him to come. I replied in the negative; and we then parted. Some few mornings afterwards, he called at my quarters; there was a gentleman in the room; and I took him into the Piazza. He said, that he wanted to know my determination. I expressed my surprize; and told him that he knew my determination.
Mr. Hay. While you were thus extracting from Doctor Bollman the secrets of his party, were you taking any measures for the security of N. Orleans? A. Yes. My orders and instructions will shew what measures I deemed it my duty to pursue. For these I am responsible to the executive of the U. S.
Mr. Martin. Are the cyphered letters filed? A. Yes. Q. Are the keys furnished? A. Here it is.
[Mr. Botts mentioned the situation of Mr. Tazewell who was summoned as a witness on the part of Col. Burr. He said that Mr. Tazewell had represented the situation of his family to be such as to require his immediate return home. Mr. Botts observed that, although he had introduced the request of Mr. Tazewell to be discharged, he should be compelled to oppose it.
Mr. Tazewell stated that he had been unexpectedly summoned, he well knew, to answer interrogatories as to certain proceedings before the grand jury? that he had just been informed of an occurrence in his domestic affairs, which made it indispensibly necessary for him to return immediately; that there were many gentlemen, in this place and its vicinity, of the grand jury, who were as competent to give evidence on the points to which he should be called upon to depose, as he possibly could be; and who would be subjected to no kind of inconvenience in attending. If he were to be examined at all, he requested that it might be immediately done; for the situation of his family was such that he should be compelled to return.
The Chief Justice said to Mr. Tazewell, that he knew full well that it was not in the power of the court to discharge him.
Mr. Botts said it was impossible to examine Mr. Tazewell till general Wilkinson had gone through his testimony. It was not possible to know the importance of his evidence till General Wilkinson was cross examined.
Mr. Hay observed that it was an unprecedented measure to introduce any member of the grand jury to prove what had passed in the jury room.
Mr. Botts. We have not said for what purpose we mean to introduce him.
Mr. Hay. I presume that I may be permitted to presume for what purpose.
Mr. Baker said that he meant to speak generally of the propriety and convenience of giving testimony as to what passed in the grand jury room. One good effect, at least, would result from it: that by introducing witnesses to prove what had passed there, it would prevent people from giving information to the grand jury, which they could not support elsewhere.
Mr. Botts called for the key to the cyphered letters of col. Burr.
Gen. Wilkinson handed him a small pocket dictionary, and a paper containing certain hieroglyphics.
Mr. Botts. In the duplicate received by Dr. Bollman, there is an erazure. Will you be so good as to explain the cause of it?
Gen. Wilkinson. That erazure was made by myself, and the words afterwards introduced by me. I have a deposition which will be more satisfactory than my own explanation.
Mr. Botts. Whose deposition? A. Mr. Duncan's.
[Mr. Wirt read the deposition of Mr. Duncan, for which see note H.]
Mr. Botts. When was the erazure made? A. During the sitting of the legislature in New Orleans. Q. When were the words restored? A. I cannot now state with certainty. Q. Was the letter exhibited to the legislature? A. It was introduced; but I confined myself to oral communications. Q. What was the occasion of the erazure? A. To put it out of the power of a certain faction in the legislature, to whom at that time I intended to submit the paper—to conceal it from that faction who were opposed to my measures, and who, I believed, were inimical to the true interest of their country, and were laboring to excite suspicions that I was connected with Col. Burr, in order to destroy the public confidence in me, and thus to defeat my measures. At the head of this faction I considered John Watkins, esq. the Speaker. Having determined not to submit the letter, I restored the words. Q. Did you prepare any translation to submit to the legislature? A. No. I only made notes. Q. Did you make a translation for any other purpose? A. Only a partial and imperfect one. Q. For what purpose? A. To understand it. Q. Was there any other occasion for which a translation was made? A. No. Q. Did you make any translation for the executive? A. No. Q. Were those words, "your's post-marked 13th of May is received," erased? A. Yes. Q. Where is the copy of your letter, covering a copy of that of Col. Burr, and your deposition to the President of the U. States? A. It is among my papers.
Mr. Hay. Do I understand you correctly, when I suppose you say, that the translation intended for the Legislature of New-Orleans, was sent to the President? A. No.
[Mr. Hay immediately observed that, on recollecting dates, he perceived that he had misunderstood gen. Wilkinson; that the letter was sent to the President before the session of the Legislature of New-Orleans.]
Mr. Botts. Do I understand you to say that this was your translation of the letter which was intended for the legislature of New-Orleans? A. No. It was Mr. Duncan's.
Mr. Botts. Have you ever sworn that this was a true translation? A. No. Only substantially so.
[Gen. Wilkinson. May I be permitted to offer a few words of explanation? When Dr. Bollman was arrested, I will confess to you that I was so little acquainted with judicial proceedings, that I did not know it was necessary to do more than accompany him with a letter of advice. I was about to send him off in this way, when Mr. Duncan suggested to me the propriety of sending forward a deposition to justify his commitment. I put the letter into the hands of Mr. Duncan, with the key; and he made out the interpretation. When Mr. Duncan presented the translation to me, I stated my objections to the omissions. He urged me to sign the deposition. The time was urgent; the express waiting; and I confess that I feared a rescous. This did not give me much time to consult my understanding. If I had, it is probable that I should have resisted the signing of the deposition, with those omissions, notwithstanding my confidence in the judgment and integrity of my counsel. I was, also, at the time, oppressed by domestic afflictions; and my mind was hurried and agitated by the painful and interesting scenes which surrounded me.
Mr. Botts. Were there variations between this original letter in cypher, and that sent on to the president? A. Yes.
Mr. Botts. Were they noticed by you, or by Mr. Duncan in your presence? A. I suppose so—because I objected generally to the omissions.
Mr. Botts. How was the cypher formed? A. It consisted of an American edition of Enticks dictionary, and of Hieroglyphics.
Mr. Botts. Which was formed first? A. The dictionary.
Mr. Botts. When was that formed? [Here gen. Wilkinson referred to a letter, without a signature, dated in 1800—and said he presumed it must have been formed about that time.]
Mr. Botts. Do you know the time of the year? A. I presume it was October.
Mr. Baker. To whom was that letter addressed? A. To myself. Q. by the same. By whom was it written? A. By col Burr. [Gen. Wilkinson observed that it was a private letter, to which he had referred merely to refresh his memory, the concluding paragraph of which is, "when I receive your cypher and your address, you shall hear from me." Mr. Wickham insisted upon seeing the letter.—Gen. Wilkinson refused—but said it was at the disposal of col. Burr, and handed it to him.]
Mr. Botts. With whom was the cypher formed? A. Col. Burr and myself.
Mr. Botts. When were the hieroglyphics agreed upon? A. To the best of my recollection, the hieroglyphics which refer to the alphabet were formed about the change of the administration, after the induction of the president. The hieroglyphics are divided into two parts—one part relates to the alphabet and figures, and the other part to arbitrary names or designations.
Mr. Botts. When were the arbitrary names established? A. I think in the year 1795 or 1796, but not delivered to col. Burr at that time.
Mr. Botts. Who originally devised the cypher? A. That you hold in your hand (the hieroglyphics) was devised partly by myself and partly by capt. Campbell Smith.
Mr. Botts. Are you sure it was in 1796, in which that part was devised? A. I think I said in 1795 or 1796, but could not ascertain which. But, adverting to the motives which induced me to form it, I think it was in 1794.
Mr. Botts. Are there no circumstances which can enable you to ascertain the time? A. I could have proved with certainty, the time, if a witness whom I had summoned had attended. Here is another cypher made by capt. Smith in 1794, and the hieroglyphics representing the President and Vice-President are the same with those used in the cypher with colonel Burr.
Col. Burr. What was the mode adopted by you of sending round the prisoners? By public vessels? A. No. My plan was to engage passages on board private vessels, and to lay in a double stock of stores for their accommodation. Col. Burr. When did your dispatches go on board the vessel? Can you ascertain the time? A. Not without recurring to my correspondence. Mr. Wirt. You had been for many years in habits of intimate correspondence with col. Burr? A. Yes.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 5 October 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 10 October 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
General James Wilkinson is questioned at length about his erasure of words in his transcription of Burr's coded letter and the purpose of various translations he made. He explains his motives involving political rivals in the Louisiana legislature and admits Mr. Duncan actually prepared the translation used in Bollman's deposition, which he signed hastily under time pressure despite having objections to omissions.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
the letter which was intended for the legislature of New-Orleans? A. No. It was Mr. Duncan's.
Mr. Botts. Have you ever sworn that this was a true translation? A. No. Only substantially so.
See moreSee less
[Gen. Wilkinson. May I be permitted to offer a few words of explana-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report describes several days of court proceedings in Aaron Burr's trial, including testimony from General Wilkinson, attorney George Poindexter, and Commodore Shaw. It also notes Burr's absence due to illness and the beginning of witness examination for the defense.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 7 October 1807 · page 3
LATEST PROCEEDINGS
FROM THE. ENOUIRER. LAT EST PROCEEDING S. The court have been occupied since our last in the examination of evi dence. On Wednesday col. Burr was indis posed, and there was no court. On Thursday the court proceeded with the examination of gen. Wilkin son—col. Burr not, present. Gabriel Vanborne (an immaterial witness) Sc George Poindcxter, Etq. attorney ge neral for the Mississippi Territory, at the time of B's arrest, were intro duced in the course of the day. On Friday the examination of gen. Wilkinson was completed* Mr. Poin j dexter was called in at the request of j Mr.
See moreSee less
Burr. Commodore Shaw was inj troduced to show the state of Orleans, | at the lime they apprehended the ap- ' proacb of Aaron Burr. The exami nation of the witnesses on the part of the accused was commenced, and L. ' W. Tazewell, Esq. one of the Grand , was examined.. . «■■■■!, inn ».!■*■———»
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers
This report presents trial documents from Aaron Burr's treason proceedings, including a letter from Bollman to General Wilkinson and a deposition by witness A. L. Duncan. Duncan's testimony describes advising Wilkinson to seize suspected persons and declare martial law in New Orleans during the Burr conspiracy scare.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR
(II)
The deposition of A. L. Duncan, a witness in behalf of the United States against Aaron Burr, taken at the request of the said witness, but by the consent of George Hay, Esq. Attorney for the U. S. in the district of Virginia and of the said Aaron Burr, to be read in evidence, if required on all trials, motions or other proceedings in course of law in which the said Aaron Burr shall be concerned at the prosecution of the said United States.
See moreSee less
I consent that this affidavit may be read in all cases in which the United States are concerned against Aaron Burr in the same manner as above expressed.
(Signed)
GEO: HAY, Att'y. U. S. for the Virginia District.
During the commotions excited in New-Orleans last winter by what was termed col. Burr's conspiracy and his associates and accomplices in that place, I was called upon in my professional capacity by general Wilkinson for counsel and advice in some measures which he was about to adopt. The temper and disposition which I had discovered in New-Orleans and the reports which daily reached that city from above, induced the belief that half measures were not suited to the times and that the publick safety required the exertion of extraordinary energies. I therefore urged the general repeatedly to the seizure of suspected persons and the declaration of Martial Law. When Bollman was seized, I suggested to the General the expediency of transmitting with him a statement of facts, on oath, to justify the step and to warrant his commitment.—He then put the letters which he said were written to him by col Burr, and which he said were transmitted to him by Swartwout and Bollman, into my hands, on which, together with some further information and knowledge of their views which the General possessed, I framed the deposition which accompanied Bollman, intentionally omitting every thing which was calculated to inculpate the general or which might by exciting suspicions have a tendency to weaken his testimony. Having prepared the deposition I presented it to gen. Wilkinson to be deposed to, who strongly and repeatedly objected to the omissions I had made, and urged warmly that the whole should be introduced. He also desired that a declaration of Bollman with which he frequently interlarded his conversations, should be entered, viz. "That he had come to New-Orleans "with views to the settlement of lands on the Ouachitta and was a mere spectator." And it was only after a full exposition of the sole objects of the document, that I could prevail on him to depose to it. It is idle and absurd to impute any similar intention to the omission, because on my trial which might ensue, it was known the original documents must be introduced as they have been.—I recollect, during the winter, gen. Wilkinson was called before the legislature of the territory to give an account of the state of publick affairs, and he informed me he intended to submit to their inspection col. Burr's duplicate, he having erased such parts as had been intended to implicate him, as he knew several of the members and particularly the Speaker, to be interested in opposition to his measures, and for the promotion of such a state of things as were best calculated to favour col. Burr's enterprize. I understand that the erasure made on this duplicate was but partial, the General having determined to give oral information to the legislature, which employed him two successive days: and that he considered the duplicate unimportant, (whilst the original has been preserved untouched) excepting the short paragraph relative to Bollman, which is preserved in its original state, and the only words erased, "Your letter post marked 13th May is received" have been re-inserted in the general's own hand. On or about the 15th of August, since my arrival in this city, gen. Wilkinson put into my hands and those of J. L. Donaldson, Esq. four or five letters, observing to us "I submit to you those letters which I have not examined since I left St. Louis, they are from col. Burr, I do not recollect their particular contents, but having received them in confidence, and knowing they blend personalities with politicks, I have not permitted myself to re-examine them, because I feel an insuperable repugnance to violate the trust of any man.—I give them to you, here is the cypher, decypher them, consider their contents well, and then inform me whether their promulgation may be necessary to my honour." We did so, and we gave the general our opinion, that the promulgation might be necessary and proper from an examination of those letters and the general's evident surprize, and prompt declaration of his ignorance when we communicated certain passages of those letters, it was my own and Mr. Donaldson's opinion that he had but partially decypher them.
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 7 October 1807 · an extract
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 7 October 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
This passage reproduces a sworn deposition by A. L. Duncan regarding General Wilkinson's authority to arrest Burr, followed by courtroom proceedings from late September 1807 where witness examination continued despite Burr's illness. Mr. Graham adds clarifying testimony about conversations with Blannerhassett and General Nevill concerning Burr's plans and beliefs about western settlers.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
In answer to interrogatories on the part of Col. Burr, I recollect to have solicited the command of a party to Natchez for the purpose of arresting col. Burr, and believed from the instructions which the general possessed, together with the state of things at that period, that the measure was warrantable; and having seen several communications from the government to gen. Wilkinson and particularly that in reply to his letter of the 21st of October, I had no doubt of the sanction of government to any measures which were calculated to defeat the views of col. Burr. I have seen communications of a confidential nature from the President to gen. Wilkinson and I believe in reply to the general's letter of the 21st of October. (Signed)
General Eaton testifies about conversations with Blennerhassett regarding western separation from the union, and clarifies earlier testimony about General Nevill. He also introduces a letter from Stephen Pynchon to clarify facts about a toast previously discussed ambiguously.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
I have some reason to believe that I may have been misunderstood with respect to what I said relative to gen Nevill. Col. Burr had asked before what conversation I had about a gentleman in the neighbourhood of Pittsburg, before the grand jury; without mentioning his name. The allusion was understood to be gen. Nevill; and whenever I mention the name of a gentleman it is my wish, to state every circumstance which occurred as nearly as possible. My recollection of the conversation with gen. Nevill is this. After detailing the conversations which he had had with others he said that there had been a strong prejudice against col.
See moreSee less
Burr about Pittsburg; that the people there were attached to the union, and believed that col. Burr had intended to separate it. Afterwards he said there was an
General Eaton testifies at Burr's treason trial about the origins of a toast condemning disunion, detailing his conversations with Jonathan Dayton and Aaron Burr about a western revolution and Spanish expedition. A supporting letter from Stephen Pynchon corroborates the toast's publication and origin at Eaton's entertainment.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
western country and hinted at a general revolution, and said he should introduce me to col. Burr. I go as fully into the subject as gen. Dayton had done; he talked much of war and enterprize, and of an expedition against the Spaniards; and here the conversation ended at that time. I passed on the northward; and entered the village in which I lived; and having received many civilities from my fellow-citizens and neighbours, I gave an entertainment in return; at which I gave this toast. I was still ignorant of the extent of the project, nor did I positively know that col.
See moreSee less
Burr was the chief mover. On my return to the city of Washington, col. Burr laid open to me his whole views, as I have before stated. Then it was that I wrote on for the paper containing this toast, for the purpose of laying it before col. Burr, and with it my sentiments on his project. Copy of a letter from Stephen Pynchon to General Eaton.
A witness recounts being asked by Blennerhassett to join Burr's expedition, describing promises of land, rifles, and blankets to recruits, with plans to rendezvous at the mouth of the Cumberland. The witness also describes visiting the boatyard where boats were being built, including a special compartment for Burr, and Blennerhassett's statement that they would burn towns if resisted while descending the river.
The Enquirer · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
to be governed on descending the river.— Each boat's crew was to choose the Captain, until they joined col. Burr at the mouth of Cumberland where he was to direct their proceedings. At the boat-yard, he directed the builder to have an apartment fitted up in his boat for Col. Burr, as he expected the Colonel, when he joined him at the mouth of Cumberland, would sometimes wish to stay with him. During the ride, I observed to Mr. Blennerhassett that I did not believe the plan would succeed, as the people generally detested and execrated the plan. To which he replied, "if the people could not see their interest, we will not cram the measure down their throats." Mr. Blennerhassett showed me some letters he had received from Col. Burr about this period—(Mr. Wirt. At which time was it? A. Between September and the time of going down the river.) in one of which he admonished him not to be alarmed by the rumours respecting his arrest in Kentucky; as he apprehended no danger but delay to retard the intended settlement on the Ouachita. A person present (Capt. Elliott) enquired, whether Col. Burr had mentioned any thing about the expedition. To which he replied "No: Nothing comes to us on that subject by the mail." Mr. Blennerhassett spoke to me to furnish them a quantity of medicines and such directions for using them as were calculated for a military expedition.
In a conversation with Col. Burr in 1805, he expatiated upon the situation of the Western country; on its being compelled to pay large sums, for the sale of lands which were spent in the Atlantic States, and on the 2,000,000 dollars, which he said, we paid for tax. These observations made by Col. Burr induced me to believe—Mr. Botts objected to the witness stating any of his own inferences.—Col. Burr observed that this same money would vastly improve the commerce of the Western country.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay. Did you ever read the Querist? A. I read the 1st and 2nd Nos at Cincinnati. Q. Did the observations in these papers recall to your recollection your conversation with Mr. Burr? A. They did. When I saw these papers, I was asked my opinion about the author. I said that in my opinion, Col. Burr had suggested the ideas, and that Mr. Blennerhassett had put
A witness testifies at trial about conversations with Blennerhassett, who recruited men, spoke of Burr as a leader of the expedition, and described plans to use force against Spanish forces and any opposition. The witness recounts Blennerhassett's claims that General Wilkinson and the army would join the enterprise and that success would make their fortunes.
The Enquirer · 7 October 1807 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
This passage records cross-examination testimony, likely from a witness (possibly Eaton or another associate), being questioned about conversations with Aaron Burr regarding his plans. The witness is pressed on specific expressions of disapproval, timing of events, and details about marine corps conversations and a newspaper report, with the witness repeatedly stating uncertainty about exact timing and details.
The Enquirer · 7 October 1807 · page 2
“ prefence—put him at eafe and he will fat’sfy “ you.” ] I determined t<» avail myfrlf of this ; reference to obtain from Mr Swartwout that in i tormation which 1 could not difeover by the let- ; ter ; tliat is, the o'tjrfl to which col Burr ex pli itty diredled his views : and in the courfe of fever d days, I oht,tilled from him fitbflanti.ally I the following l.t‘Is : That he had left co! Burr at Philadelphia occupied day and night a! molt! on an rnterprize which he h nl in contemplali ou ; that he lived in a retired part of the cltv, in a fmall houle with fcveral rooms, where he received perfons with whom he had to tranfadt 1 hufinef" ; and that he fa w no two perfons at the jlante tinie.
See moreSee less
He ohfervrd to me that commodore j 'T'ruvten was frequently with bim, and zealouf lv engaged in hi • enteiprize lie obferved, at the fune time, that a man who fuperintended ■ the public buildings at Wafiiington was af> Ionf]y engaged. lie did not recoiled! ' s i me, but on my mentioning the name of I.a .t’-vc-e, he f.tid, that was the man. lie fa id that he had been difpatclicd bycol Burr from Philadcdphia„znd had travelled the Rates of I Ohio and Kentucky, i lo undciRooil the gen tleman at that tune; hut have fince difeover : ed that be defcendetl the titrtr. [d/r Beits. By | whom did you underR-md, that he had defeend j ed thg river. A By a man who inf irmed me that nc had rowed him down from IMlfburg.’] Anoth'-r re Ton why I may h »ve been miRakcn wastlu ■. IIinformed me that he had paired to hrar'k' r-t in q'-eR of gen Adair, for whom he had difp:itchc> from col Burr; and not hearing or him there, had returned back to Lexington in purfuit i>f him ; where lie was informed bv tnaj W g roner, that general Adair, being in ill health had gone to fume medical fpring, & that i; tie would wait a few days he might fee him ; tiiat he did lo, ami thus had an interview with lism without incurring any fufpicion, at which time he delivered h s riifpatches. He faid that ren Adair was aealoufly engaged in his enter Pr’ze J and obferved, “ ted hint that I will not “ wri‘e to him, but that I expert to meet hint ««*»•*• U.. _ . I * t . .
A witness is questioned about the timing and details of his communications regarding Aaron Burr's plans, including how information reached a Springfield newspaper. He explains he sought advice from Samuel Dana and John Cotton Smith before deciding not to fully disclose his concerns to the government, given Burr's reputation.
The Enquirer · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
this time? A Col Burr, Sir, has a powerful command of his muscles. I did not find at all times that they were unruffled. I could read in his countenance sometimes concern, sometimes solicitude; and sometimes a disposition to make a trifle of my objections. Mr Botts. I think you said that it was generally your purpose not to disclose in your intercourse with col Burr that you were inimical to his views? A You understood me correctly. Q But that nevertheless his muscles were sometimes ruffled? A They were. Q Were your observations then of a nature to ruffle him?
See moreSee less
A I spoke to col Burr, Sir, with much plainness; and even if I had been cordial in my approbation of his plans, I should have founded my objections that I might have tried his force. I have done the best that I could for my country. I have attempted to exert all my wisdom. It was a painful ground on which I was taken. I took the advice of two intelligent gentlemen (whose names I am at liberty to mention), and they did not think it advisable for me to make a full disclosure to the government, for my solitary communication would not avail against the weight of col Burr's character; for with all the evidence, even now before the world, I still feel the weight of that character. Mr Baker. And who were the gentlemen that advised you? A The honorable Samuel Dana and John Cotton Smith. Mr Burr. Had we any conversation before the month of Jan.? A It recurs to me as highly probable, that I first spoke to you in Philadelphia between the 20th and 24th of December. Q On this subject? A I had a communication with another gentleman at that time, of a very indefinite nature. At Philadelphia, you gave me no distinct nor well-digested ideas of the project, but you spoke of a Spanish war. Mr Martin. We must have that gentleman's name. Who was it? A Jonathan Dayton. Mr Burr. Had you any expectations or promises of a military command from government? A It is true that the chief clerk n the department of war, tho' in confidential
This item reproduces a deposition by a witness describing General Wilkinson's actions against suspected Burr conspirators in New Orleans, including the arrest of Bollman and the handling of letters implicating Burr. It also includes a letter from Erick Bollman to Wilkinson and an attorney's note certifying the deposition for use in Burr-related legal proceedings.
The Enquirer · 7 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
in the same manner as above expressed.
(Signed) GEO: HAY, A.U.S. for the Va. District.
See moreSee less
During the commotions excited in New-Orleans last winter what was termed Colonel Burr's conspiracy and his associates and accomplices in that place, I was called upon in my professional capacity by gen.
In courtroom proceedings regarding a motion for commitment, witness Hugh Allen testifies about embarking with Tyler and Smith to settle lands, describing the parties gathered at the mouth of Cumberland under Tyler, Floyd, and Burr. Cross-examination by Burr probes details about boats, weapons, and personnel to challenge claims of a military expedition versus a legitimate land settlement venture.
Virginia Argus · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT
TUESDAY, Sept. 22.
HUGH ALLEN.
See moreSee less
Mr Hay. Where did you embark? A I embarked at Beaver with Maj. Tyler and Smith. Q On what terms? A Mr Tyler and Smith told me, they were going to settle lands; and that whatever profits they shared, I should share; I bearing an equal proportion of the expenses. Q How many men did you see at the mouth of Cumberland? A About seventy. Q Was that the whole party? A Perhaps there might be more. Mr Tyler's party was about forty; and Mr Floyd's about thirty or forty; so there were in all about seventy or eighty. Q How many men came with Mr Burr to the mouth of Cumberland? A I do not know.
Mr Wirt. Did Tyler's and Floyd's parties arrive there together? A We got there first, by a few hours. Q When did you arrive there? A On the evening of the 26th December. Q Had Colonel Burr a party, like Tyler & Floyd? A There were a number of boats there, which I understood were Colonel Burr's. Q Did any thing occur to change your opinion of the object of this enterprize? A The only ground of my ever changing my opinion, was, when I understood that the government designed to arrest Colonel Burr. Mr Hay. And do you think that men would have left the better part of the world, to go and settle a wilderness? Why did you go? A I made my calculations on this subject; Mr Tyler and Mr Smith had said that the object was the settlement of lands, which would be profitable.
Cross-Examined:—Mr Burr. How many guns were in your boats? A five rifles and one fusee gun. Q Did you get any more, except at Blennerhasset's island? A None. Q Did you ever see musquets and bayonets in those boats? A Never. Q What was the construction of the boats? Were they able to go up the stream? A They were. Q Did you ever see any boats that could go up the stream with them? A I never the experiment tried. Q Do you know whether I had a single man at the mouth of Cumberland with me, except Dunnahue the pilot? A I do not know him; nor how many were with you.—Mr Burr here stated, that he had hired hands at Nashville to bring him down to the mouth of Cumberland.—Mr Burr. Were you present when I was introduced to the party? A I was. When you were introduced, you said you had intended saying something to us then; but for certain reasons of your own, you had deferred it. Q Did I say that I had any thing like secrets to disclose? A You did not. Q Had you any reason to suspect that any of the party meditated hostility against the United States. A Never. Q
Courtroom examination continues with questions about powder, bullets, and supplies aboard Burr's boats on the river. A deposition from David Fisk is read describing how Davis Floyd recruited him in 1806 to join the expedition down the Ohio and Mississippi, eventually meeting Burr, Blennerhassett, and others at the mouth of the Cumberland.
Virginia Argus · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
go down.
WEDNESDAY, Sept. 23.
See moreSee less
On account of Mr. Fisk's indisposition, the following deposition was taken and read:
The affidavit of David Fisk, of lawful age, who being first sworn before me, Daniel L. Hylton, a Justice of the Peace for the county of Henrico, saith, that some time in the month of September, 1806, a certain Davis Floyd, of the Indiana Territory, came to this affiant and asked him if he did not wish to take a voyage down the river with him during the course of the fall or winter, that he was going to settle a new country, the Washita on the Red River. This happened either the next day or a few days after Colonel Burr had left Jeffersonville, the residence of the said Floyd. At that time this affiant did not tell him whether he would go or not; but about two or three weeks afterwards he did agree to go, the said Floyd having several times mentioned what a fine chance there would be for him, that they would not agree to give to any one man more than twelve dollars a month and one hundred and fifty acres of land at the end of six months, besides clothes and provisions; but as he and this affiant were well acquainted, if he would have a con[t]
A sworn affidavit describes how Davis Floyd recruited men for the Washita lands venture, which later revealed hidden weapons and plans to seize Baton Rouge and Mexico. The witness recounts joining Aaron Burr's expedition at the mouth of the Cumberland River with over a hundred men and discusses coordination with General Wilkinson's forces.
Virginia Argus · 7 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
said Floyd; but when the boats joined Col. Aaron Burr at the mouth of Cumberland, (which was of a Saturday night, either on Christmas night or the first Saturday after Christmas,) he understood that the whole number of men, including those of the said Aaron Burr, were one hundred and three. After the boats had left the Falls of the O-
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
A witness testifies about conversations with Blennerhassett describing plans for separating the union under Aaron Burr's leadership. The testimony names alleged associates including General Eaton, John Graham, Harper, and Astor, and mentions plans to seize New Orleans and French artillery.
Virginia Argus · 7 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
crecy which we agreed to observe. Mr Blannerhasset observed that it was a subject of great importance. He stated that the object was the separation of the union; he mentioned characters who were concerned in it; observed that col. Burr was at the head of it, or words to that effect.— He spoke very much in praise of Colonel Burr; mentioned an instance of his goodness of heart with respect to the Manhattan Company, and making the fortunes of many without benefitting himself. General Eaton's and Mr Graham's names were again mentioned as concerned, and a number of others, whom I do not recol[lect] that were acquainted with it; a
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 14 October 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
Witnesses testify about General Eaton's court martial over nankeen cloth speculation, which Eaton defends himself against. Silas Dinsmore testifies about conditions in New Orleans and vouches for General Wilkinson's integrity, while clarifying Wilkinson's orders regarding Burr's arrest did not authorize removing him from civil authority.
Virginia Argus · 7 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
nature was scarcely worthy of notice; General Eaton, to remove any prejudice against him which might have been excited by it, entered into a full explanation of all the circumstances; (which shall appear in the Argus hereafter;) and we believe fully convinced every body that heard him of his own innocence, and that he had been unjustly persecuted and oppressed by Col. Gaither.
The next witness introduced was Mr Silas Dinsmore, from New-Orleans, who was called by the counsel for the U. S. to testify as to the state of affairs in that city at the time when col. Burr was expected to be descending the river with an army. It appeared that Mr Dinsmore had himself advised gen. Wilkinson to seize the partizans of Burr, so far as he found opposition from them; that he conceived it to be absolutely necessary altho' an evil which he lamented. He stated, too, that he had been acquainted with gen. Wilkinson a little more than five years; that, as to his integrity, he had never seen any thing but what would induce him to think it purity itself; and that his Patriotism always appeared of the most zealous and ardent kind; such as the witness would wish himself and every American to possess.
See moreSee less
Mr. Dinsmore's testimony was moreover important in proving that neither the spirit or letter of gen. Wilkinson's instructions to the men, whom he sent to Natchz with orders to seize col. Burr by all practicable means, authorised them to take him out of the hands of the civil authority.
On that subject the affidavit of Lieutenant George Peter was read on the side of col. Burr, but did not contradict Mr. Dinsmore's evidence. (To be Continued.)
Documents referred to in Gen. Wilkinson's Evidence—Continued.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 12 October 1807
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A court of inquiry appointed by the government met aboard the Chesapeake to examine Commodore Barron's conduct, with Captains Murray, Chauncey, and Hull presiding. The court adjourned without business, and it is noted that Judge Advocate Tazewell is currently in Richmond serving as a witness in the Burr case.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 9 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
board the Chesapeake, present. Captains Murray, Chauncey, & Hull.
The court adjourned without doing any business until to-morrow. Littleton W. Tazewell, Esq. has been appointed Judge Advocate. Commodore Barron is we understand, very much indisposed, and Mr. Tazewell is at Richmond, a witness in the case of Col. Burr.
During Burr's treason trial, General Wilkinson continues testifying under cross-examination by defense attorneys Martin and Wickham about the ciphered letter sent to the president. He admits he never fully deciphered the letter and cannot specifically identify discrepancies between the original and Duncan's translation, though he claims some omissions were made to avoid implicating himself.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
(Evidence of General Wilkinson, continued.)
See moreSee less
TUESDAY, Sept. 29th, 1807. After general Wilkinson had finished his address to the court, Mr. Martin asked him if he had the original translation of the cyphered letter of
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 1 other paper
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel Wickham questions General Wilkinson about discrepancies between a translated cipher letter and the original, and about when certain ciphers were created. A dispute arises between counsel over whether the letter itself must be produced in court before questions about its contents can be used as testimony, with the Chief Justice ruling that such questioning would not bear on the case unless the letter was produced.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
ted to inculpate me for the reasons already stated.— Mr. Wickham. I observe one of the cyphers is in hieroglyphicks designed in 1799 or 1801. A. That is erroneous. When the hieroglyphicks were formed they were taken from a small slip of paper and annexed to that in your hand to prevent its being lost. Q. Can you tell when they were made. A. I cannot precisely. I have before stated the time as nearly as I can. Q. Can you tell upon what occasion they were made? A. For the purpose of communicating with col.
See moreSee less
Burr. Q. Do you recollect your having sent a letter to col. Burr, from St. Louis, in May or June, 1806? I have such an impression, but have not the most distant recollection of its contents. [Mr. Wirt submitted it to the court whether it could be proper for the opposite counsel to interrogate general Wilkinson as to a letter which was in their own possession. If they meant to rely upon the letter as evidence they ought to produce it. He considered it unfair to select such parts as might tend to inculpate general Wilkinson, and keep back those which would lead to an explanation of his conduct. Mr. Wickham said it was their own paper, and they were not bound to pro-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 16 October 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
During Burr's trial, defense counsel Wickham and Baker cross-examine General Wilkinson about letters he wrote to Burr in 1805-1806, pressing him on recollections of specific expressions regarding war with Spain. Wilkinson claims poor memory of exact contents but offers to produce correspondence and instructions to officers for the court's review.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Chief Justice. General Wilkinson says that he has no recollection of the contents of the letter.—The subject matter of the letter cannot be established by the examination. But the witness may be cross examined for the purposes avowed by the opposite counsel. Mr. Wickham. Do you recollect that you did write to col. Burr in 1806? A. I have before stated that I have such an impression; but I have no recollection of the contents of any communication made to him, although I remember the motive which induced me to write.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. You have no recollection of any particular expression. A. No. Except in a letter of October or November 1805—2. Q. Have you no recollection of any expression or sentiment expressed in your letter of 1806. A. I have no recollection. Q. Was it your expression that we should have a war with Spain? A. It was my opinion; and there was a very general impression that we should have a war with that power. Q. Do you recollect writing any thing respecting the measures of the government, in relation to a war with Spain. Have you no recollection of any opinion expressed in a letter to colonel Burr? A. I do not recollect having expressed any opinion respecting the measures of the government. The only expression of which I have any idea, is the one used in a letter of October or November, 1805, in which I believe I say "I fear Miranda has taken the bread out of your mouth." Mr. Wickham. There were letters published from you while in the neighbourhood of the Spaniards. Have you copies of those letters here? A. I have the whole correspondence. Mr. Wickham. We only want the letters of September and October, which state that war with Spain is inevitable. Gen. Wilkinson. I think I may have said so, and believe that I have papers which throw some light on the subject. Here are my instructions to the officers who commanded the troops when they left St. Louis—[Gen. Wilkinson handed to Mr. Wickham copies of his instructions to col. Cushing.] Mr. McRae. What is the date of those instructions? A. The 6th and 8th of May, 1806. Gen. Wilkinson said that he would, with pleasure, submit the whole correspondence, if he could do it consistently with his own ideas of propriety. But there were contained in it such secret military operations, as it might be improper to expose. Mr. Wickham. I think you state that at that time, the expectation of a war with Spain was very general? A. It was so: and if my instructions to col. Cushing can be read, they will shew my own impressions. [Here Mr. McRae read the instructions of gen. Wilkinson to col. Cushing of the 6th and 8th of May 1806, for which
Defense counsel Wickham questions Wilkinson about letters sent to the president, Spanish troop strength near the Sabine, and military orders received in late 1806. Wilkinson resists disclosing secret orders, and prosecutor Hay objects to producing presidential correspondence, citing executive privilege, which the chief justice upholds.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. W. You note two letters to the president, one of the 21st Oct. and the other of the 12th Nov. 1806. Have you a copy of that of the 12th of Nov. and will you give me leave to ask whether that letter was before the grand jury? A. It was submitted to the grand jury. [Mr. Wickham said that they called for a copy of that letter. If the counsel on the other side thought proper to oppose it, they might do it at once.] Mr. Hay. We shall certainly oppose the production of the letter.
See moreSee less
The president has been consulted on the subject; and he has excepted such parts as he thought it would be improper to produce. The chief justice remarked, that after the president had been consulted, he could not think of requiring from Gen. Wilkinson the exhibition of those parts of the letter which the president
During the treason trial, Mr. Wickham questions General Wilkinson about orders received from the government regarding Colonel Burr, including whether he sent officers in disguise to apprehend him. Wilkinson names the officers sent (Hook, Peter, Mulford, Davidson, Carmichael) while debate ensues over whether he can be compelled to disclose confidential military or executive orders.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
communication from the executive government. We are not at liberty to dive into the secrets of the executive department to know what orders they give to their agents, and to proclaim those orders to the world ;—orders which were given for the publick good. There can be no doubt but the publick good does require that various orders of the government should forever remain a secret. Mr. Wickham. The gentleman did not understand my question. I asked general Wilkinson what orders he had received from the government in relation to col. Burr.] Mr. Wickham. Did you receive any ordes to attack col. Burr and his party ? A. That question may require some qualification. Mr. Wickham. Did you send any officer in disguise to take col. Burr? I sent three. Mr. Wickham. Their names? [Mr. Hay said that he did not think general Wilkinson was bound to answer such questions ; that he was not bound to furnish evidence against himself, or to subject himself to prosecution. Altho' he had believed that the exigencies of the times would justify the measures which gen. Wilkinson whether he would answer the question or not. General Wilkinson. If the question goes to criminate myself, I presume that I am not bound to answer it. Chief Justice. Would general Wilkinson be subjected to an action for sending to apprehend col. Burr unless he had been seized. Mr. Hay. It may go to criminate him as a military man. He may have acted without orders. Mr. Wickham. I do not presume that he acted without orders ; but under the orders of the government. The Chief Justice said, that he could not perceive the application of the evidence ; but as evidence was introduced to shew the flight of col. Burr from Washington, this, he presumed, was intended to account for it.]
Mr. Wickham. Will you state the names of the officers sent to apprehend col. Burr. A. Captain Hook, Lieutenant Peter, Lieutenant Mulford, Doctor Davidson, of the army, and Doctor Carmichel of the Mississippi Territory. Mr. Wickham. Did you direct them to go without uniform ? A. I believe I did. Mr. Wickham. Did you direct them to conceal the object of their mission? A. I feel great delicacy in revealing my orders.
Courtroom testimony covers the officers sent to apprehend Aaron Burr and whether General Wilkinson ordered them to conceal their mission and travel without uniform. A deposition from Captain Walbach follows, attesting to Wilkinson's use of ciphers in correspondence with various figures including Alexander Hamilton, and vouching for Wilkinson's zealous military conduct.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
(I) Deposition of capt. J. B. Walback.
I had the honour to become acquainted with general James Wilkinson some time in August, 1799; became attached to his military family in December, 1800—was appointed an aid-de-camp in the spring following, and continued in that capacity until the last of November, 1804.
See moreSee less
During the above period, I have witnessed that gen. Wilkinson did employ cyphers of different kinds in his correspondence, among them was an English pocket dictionary—Several of these cyphers I have made myself, designed copies of some of them are still in my possession, and others I have recognized since my arrival at the city of Richmond—Particularly one to the late gen. James Jackson, another to the late major general Alexander Hamilton, a third to a Mr. Hulings, then at New Orleans, a fourth to col. Cushing, a fifth to Mr. Silas Dinsmore and one to myself—Several of these were projected in 1802 and 1803, at the time the port of New Orleans was shut, and for the purpose of procuring & conveying intelligence to the government.
Question—Did you ever observe in gen. Wilkinson any act, or disposition, which marked inattention to his duty, as to the zealous and faithful discharge of the trust reposed in him as an officer of the United States.
A witness recounts conversations with Blannerhassett about preparations for an expedition down the river, including inquiries about Comfort Tyler, Dean, and Butler, and a letter believed to be from Colonel Burr. The testimony details Blannerhassett's remarks on recruiting settlers, boats, and land interests tied to Bastrop's grant.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
on of the contents of that letter? Mr. McRae. Do you believe the letter to have been col. Burr's? A. I believed it was col. Burr's writing; for although I had never seen col. Burr write, yet I had seen several letters said to have been written by col. Burr. I merely mention this letter to show that it gave rise to a conversation between Mr. Blannerhassett and myself, relative to the contents of this letter. The conversation was somewhat desultory; nor do I particularly recollect the order in which the several topics were introduced.
See moreSee less
In general I recollect that Mr. Blannerhassett animadverted upon the conduct pursued towards col. Burr at Frankfort; stating his belief however that this conduct was not authorised by the government. He mentioned that col. B. had purchased from col. Lynch, I think a certain part of baron Bastrop's grant in the territory of Orleans. He stated also that
A witness recounts conversations with Blennerhassett about recruiting young, unmarried, armed men for an expedition organized with Col. Burr, with purposes described as possibly resisting Spaniards or hunting game. The witness also describes being mistaken for a party member and Blennerhassett's surprised reaction upon learning otherwise.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
[illegible] Burr; that he was engaging young men, single and without families to go down armed; he said they would have no cannon but rifles.——He stated in the course of conversation the use to which these rifles might be applied; to resist the Indians and Spaniards, or to kill game. It is
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The report details several days of witness examinations in Colonel Burr's treason trial at Richmond, including testimony from Alexander Henderson and others regarding Blannerhasset's conversations and actions. The court debates whether such collateral evidence can be used against Burr, with Chief Justice Marshall allowing the testimony while questioning its direct relevance, and the prosecution indicates only two more witnesses remain, including General Wilkinson.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 9 October 1807 · page 3
Ceionel A. BURR. Richmond, October 4. _ TV court have been principally oecd pied by the examination of cvideacb. Om Wednesday, Mr.. Hey read tk deposition of David Fitk. Mr. Alexander Hendcrsnn was theft called, on the part of the U. S. to cxplaM the views of the party, when the cotio •el far the accused Bade aa elaborate effort to exclude «ach testimony « on the ground that an overt act ought first to be proved, and that such testimony could only be considered as collateral. The Chief Just tee overruled the objection on the ground* represented in onr last paper.
See moreSee less
Some conversation then ensued upon the question, how far the evidence, about to be adduced (principally consitiog of sets and conversations of Blanncrhastet) would affect Mr. Burr. The Chief Jus. ties seemed disposed to think that it did not affect him. Mr. Hay contended that whan a connection and conspiracy were proven, the act and declarations of one accomplice are good against the rest. The Chief justice was willing to hear an argument upon the point. Mr. Burr then said ihet as he understood He
This courtroom testimony covers questions about Aaron Burr's bail recognizance in the Mississippi Territory and whether it had been properly fulfilled before his departure. Witnesses including Governor Williams dispute whether Burr's compliance with his bond was legitimate, with Burr's own counsel calling a related document a forgery, amid questions about the suddenness of his flight from authorities.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
refused to send Mr. Blannerhassett round for trial; but had held him to bail; that he himself had been recognised; that the court was to set some time in May; the judge considered the supreme court as the proper tribunal; the Attorney general thought otherwise, that before the court met he had besides been indisposed and had obtained the certificate of his physician that he could not attend that court.
Mr. Burr. Are you still secretary of the Orleans Territory? A I am not. Q Do you now hold any office under the government and what is it? A I am Chief Clerk in the office of Secretary of State.
See moreSee less
Q Was there any arrangement made to seize col Burr after their judicial proceed
This passage records courtroom testimony from witnesses including Charles Duval describing conversations with Burr about purchasing land, recruiting men, and arming them for an expedition down the river. The testimony details Burr's efforts to enlist young men with arms, promising ammunition, as part of his questioned venture.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
that I had understood from Mrs. Blennerhassett that he was going down the river and a number of my acquaintances were going with him, and that I did not know, but that I too would go, if I knew what he was going for. He told me that col. Burr and himself and others had purchased large tracts of land and wanted settlers to go on it, I told him that I had land enough at home; and that I did not want to go to settle land. He then represented it as
A witness recounts being recruited by an associate of Burr's, describing promises of commissions, land, and riches in Spanish territory, with plans to rendezvous at the mouth of the Cumberland River. The testimony describes organizational details of the expedition and is interrupted as cross-examination is postponed to the next day.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
got to the mouth of Cumberland river, we should be joined by colonel Burr and the whole party, when the whole secret would be divulged, and if I did not like it he would bear my expences back to Marietta. I told him that if I went down and a number of my friends were going also, I would like to have the choice of my boat's crew. He said that if it was so I must still expect to be under the same regulations as regular troops; that was, that we might have the priviledge of chusing our own officers, till we got to the mouth of Cumberland, there we were to meet col.
See moreSee less
Burr and we must submit to such regulations as colonel Burr thought proper. My motive for making this proposition as to my friends was, that a number of strangers were going and I did not wish to be with them. I recollect nothing farther of any great importance. Mr. Duval's further examination was postponed and the court adjourned till to morrow.
General Wilkinson continues testimony in the Burr treason proceedings, explaining why he erased and altered portions of the coded letter before presenting it to the Louisiana legislature. Defense attorneys press him on inconsistencies regarding translations made for the legislature, the executive, and his own understanding.
The Enquirer · 10 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITTMENT.
Saturday, Sept. 26. Gen. Wilkinson's Testimony continued. Q Was the letter exhibited to the Legislature? A It was introduced; but I confined myself to oral communications. Q What was the occasion of the erazure? A To put it out of the power of a certain faction in the Legislature, to whom, at that time, I intended to submit the paper; to conceal it from that faction who were opposed to my measures, and who, I believe, were inimical to the true interests of their country, and were labouring to excite suspicions that I was connected with col.
See moreSee less
Burr, in order to destroy the public confidence in me, and thus to defeat my measures. At the head of this faction I considered John Watkins, esq. the Speaker. Having determined not to submit the letter, I restored the words. Q Did you prepare any translation to submit to the legislature? A No. I only made notes. Q Did you make a translation for any other purpose? A Only a partial and imperfect one. Q For what purpose? A. To understand it. Q Was there any other occasion for which a translation was made? A No. Q Did you make any translation for the executive? A No. Q Were those words, "your's post-marked 13th of May is received," erased? A Yes. Q Where is the copy of your letter, covering a copy of that of col. Burr, and your deposition to the president of the United States? A It is
General Wilkinson addresses the judge, explaining his earlier interrogatory answers regarding his interpretation of Aaron Burr's coded letters. He details the timeline of his translations and testimony before the Orleans territory legislative council and grand jury.
The Enquirer · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TUESDAY, Sept. 29.
Gen Wilkinson addressing the judge.
See moreSee less
From the rapidity with which the interrogatories were put, and the promptitude of my answers when last before you, I fear some misapprehension may have occurred; I therefore beg leave to explain the facts to which the interrogatories appeared to be pointed, which I trust I shall be able to do clearly, concisely and satisfactorily.
The only explanation of the cyphered letters of col Burr, transmitted by Swartwont, & Bollman which I have made, was done hastily and by piece meal at Natchitoches; I think I have called this an imperfect interpretation, and I have done so, because although it gave me their full sense, yet by omissions and abbreviations, it could not be well understood by another.
On reflection, I think it was from this document, and not from notes, that the purport of col Burr's letters, were given to the legislative council and representatives of the territory of Orleans. I find the summons from the house, bears date the 15th of January last, and I believe the examination commenced the 17th. It lasted two days, and therefore I cannot recollect the particular course or circumstances. I find by references to my papers, that certain documents were submitted to the clerk to be read under restrictions, and it is probable I carried with me to the house, all the papers respecting the subject of enquiry.
I have some impression that this same document was proffered to the grand jury, to aid them in their interpretation of the cyphered letters of col Burr, but I cannot speak with certainty. This examination lasted several days.
General Wilkinson testifies about his examination regarding the decoding of Burr's cipher letter, describing the timeline of interpretations given to Isaac Briggs and the President. He also recounts fears of being seen as Burr's accomplice and being warned he might be tarred and feathered.
The Enquirer · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Referring to col Burr's letter of the 10th of October, 1800, I have said, that I believed the cypher depending on the book, was formed in that year, yet it may have been afterwards. I perfectly remember, that about that period, col Burr informed me he had to send 150 miles for the counterpart of the book, and also in answer to a letter, I wrote him from the frontier of Georgia, the Oconee river in the year 1802, he then being in Charlestown, he informed me he could not write as freely as he wished, as he had not the cypher with him.
See moreSee less
In accounting for the erasure of the duplicate of col Burr's letters, I have mentioned the apprehension which had been excited of my being an accomplice of col Burr's, and that I was preparing for his reception.—This device had excited such alarm, and the friends of government were so incensed, that I was cautioned by Silas Dinsmore, Esq. to take care how I moved, as I was in danger of being tar'd and feathered. After Gen. Wilkinson had finished his address to the court, Mr. Martin asked him if he had the original translation of the cyphered letter of Col. Burr. His answer was, I have not. I have looked for it, but cannot find it.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 17 October 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
This passage records courtroom testimony from the Burr treason trial, in which General Wilkinson is cross-examined about his translation of a ciphered letter sent to the President and his correspondence with Burr. Attorneys dispute whether Wilkinson must produce the original letter in his possession to test the consistency of his testimony.
The Enquirer · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
tell upon what occafion they were made? A For the purpofe of communicating with col. Burr. Q Do you recollect your having fent a letter to col Burr, from St. Louis, in May or June 1806? I have fuch an impreffion, but have not the moft diftant recollection of its contents. (Mr. Wirt fubmitted it to the court whether it could be proper for the oppofite counfel to interrogate Gen. Wilkinfon as to a letter which was in their own poffeffion. If they meant to rely upon the letter as evidence, they ought to produce it.
See moreSee less
He confidered it unfair to felect fuch parts as might tend to inculpate gen. Wilkinfon, and keep back thofe which would lead to an explanation of his conduct. Mr. Wickham faid it was their own paper, and they were not bound to produce it 'til they thought proper. Their object was to crofs-examine the witnefs and fee whether he
John G. Henderson testifies about conversations with Blennerhassett concerning a possible new government in the Western country and military plans involving Colonel Burr. The testimony covers Blennerhassett's comments about defending mountain passes, an undetermined government structure, and Burr's alleged threat to deal harshly with impertinent officials.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
heels, and throw them into the Potowmac. Mr Hay. Did I understand you to say, that this was an expression as quoted from col. Burr? A. Yes. We desired Mr Blen-
A witness is cross-examined about conversations with Blennerhassett regarding a supposed secession plan and meetings held in Wood County. Testimony covers the witness's politics, the content of local resolutions, and references to boat-building and meal-kiln-drying as evidence of movements on the Ohio.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
the danger which was to be apprehended. One of the resolutions alluded particularly to col. Burr. Q Was Mr Blennerhasset's name ever mentioned? A A proposition was made to insert Mr Blennerhas-
The report reprints testimony from Burr conspiracy witnesses, including Mr. Wirt noting Burr's presence near the Querist's publication date, and Blennerhassett's associates describing plans to divide the states along the Alleghenies and establish a separate government with a capital at Lexington, Kentucky. Witnesses also mention disaffection among army and navy officers and General Moreau's expected involvement.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Mr Wirt to the court: "[I]t is remarkable that Col. Burr was at the island on the 1st of September and the 1st No. of the Querist is dated on the 4th."
This passage records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson during the Burr treason trial, detailing his communications with Spanish Governor Cordero regarding troop withdrawals from the Sabine River. Defense attorney Wickham questions him about a secret convention with Spanish forces, correspondence with the President, and whether any money changed hands, with Wilkinson denying secret articles or payments while declining to divulge the convention's contents.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ish commandant, on the subject of colonel Burr's expedition against Mexico? A None. The earliest communications which I made on that subject were after my return to Natchez. Mr W. Has the jurisdiction of the United States ever been ex-
This passage records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson being cross-examined by defense attorney Mr. Wickham regarding military orders, troop strength near the Sabine River, and his actions against Col. Burr. Wilkinson resists answering certain questions, citing military confidentiality and executive privilege, while prosecutor Mr. Hay argues he cannot be compelled to incriminate himself.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
but under the sanction of the oath which General Wilkinson has taken he may be compelled to give testimony as to the points on which he has been interrogated. In England, nothing is more common than for the most secret transactions to be disclosed in a court of justice. Considerations of delicacy in the witness have never been permitted to have any weight.—Mr. Hay There is a material difference. Those
* The document marked K* referred to above, containing the instructions of Gen. Wilkinson to colonel Cushing of the 6th of May 1806 has been misplaced, and could not be procured in time for our paper of to-day.
The report covers courtroom testimony from the ongoing Burr trial, including Lemuel Henry's account of a conversation with Burr and a suspicious offer by an associate named New to sell muskets and bayonets at a discount, despite claiming the weapons were for settling Washita lands. It also notes an affidavit by Julien Depestre that contradicted testimony from the Morgan family, and mentions Major James Bruff's examination the following day.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
MONDAY, October 5.
Mr Lemuel Henry (a member of the legislative council of the Mississippi territory) was examined as a witness for the U. States, concerning a conversation between a Mr Caller, Colonel Burr and himself, the evening after the Col. arrived at the town of Washington; and also w th respect to an offer of Mr Robert A. New (one of Burr's
This report covers courtroom proceedings from October 6-8, 1807, including contradictory testimony from witnesses about General Wilkinson, particularly Major James Bruff's lengthy testimony suggesting Wilkinson made statements contradicting his court testimony. The session also notes a court adjournment due to a death in attorney Wirt's family, and concludes with the start of arguments on the motion for Burr's commitment.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
TUESDAY, October 6. The session, of the court on this day was almost entirely consumed in the examination of Maj. James Bruff, a witness introduced by Col. Burr for the purpose of proving that Gen. Wilkinson had made statements to him of a nature contradictory to his evidence in court. The testimony of this witness was very lengthy, and will hereafter be communicated to the public. It is proper, however, now to remark that he declared himself injured by General Wilkinson, and appeared to be his personal enemy. Commodore Shaw was also examined as to this point, and stated that he travelled in the stage from Alexandria with Maj.
See moreSee less
Bruff, and heard him say a great deal in conversation; from which he understood him to declare that he had been injured by General Wilkinson, and was disposed to retaliate to the utmost of his power; that he had come to give evidence without being summoned; having been informed by Mr. Martin that he was to be summoned; that he was to tell a long story, and would do Wilkinson considerable injury.
This editorial argues that the federal government is not persecuting Aaron Burr, noting that Jefferson only disclosed his opinion of Burr's guilt after Congress demanded information. It defends the fairness of the trial process, citing the extensive witnesses brought by both sides and the pending question of full disclosure before the circuit court.
Virginia Argus · 10 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
liberations of congress ; and the House of Representatives called for information. Information thus called for, was given, and then, and not till then did the President make that disclosure, which is now termed persecution, in which disclosure he gave his opinion of the guilt of Aaron Burr.— What since has occurred in relation to this
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A witness testifies about Burr's stated plans to seize Baton Rouge and gather thousands of men, and his acquaintance with Wilkinson. Another account describes Blennerhassett discussing with a witness the benefits of western secession and praising Burr's character.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
we were paying 3 or 4 million of dolls. towards the support of the present government, when with 100,000, we might support a government of our own: he mentioned colonel Burr's
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This passage records courtroom examination of a witness, questioned by Mr. Wirt, about conversations with Blannerhassett regarding his association with Burr's plans and expedition down the river. The witness describes a public meeting held by local citizens to discuss resolutions on how to proceed, and discusses letters received from Blannerhassett.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
man. Mr. Wirt. Did you understand whether he said any thing of Mr. Jefferson? A. Mr. Blannerhasset said, if Mr. J. was any way impertinent, that colonel Burr would tie him neck and heels, and throw him into the Potomac. Q. What did he say of his means of opposition to the government? A. He mentioned that with 3 pieces of artillery and 300 sharp
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The passage records courtroom cross-examination testimony, including Blannerhassett's exchange about his political relationship with Alexander and a witness's admission he viewed Burr as a dangerous man plotting to overturn something. Testimony continues regarding authorship of certain writings and a textual gap that needed to be filled in.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THURSDAY, Sept. 24.
Mr. Alexander Henderson's cross examination.
See moreSee less
(CONTINUED.)
Mr. Blannerhasset. Do you recollect at the time of our conversation, you expressed any personal dislike of col. Burr? Did you not express a sense of hostility towards him? A. I am sorry that the gentleman has put the question. I am sorry to wound any man's feelings wantonly. But I always thought him a dangerous man, and the late occurrences have not at all changed my opinion. Mr. Martin. How long has your opinion of him been formed? A. Ten or fifteen years ago, when he was making the tour of Virginia. Mr. Martin. Not when he was said to be fixing means to overturn the federal administration? A. I do not recollect; but I heard much at that time of col. Burr.
Mr. Hay here wished to identify the two letters, which Mr. Henderson had presented to the court, from Mr Blannerhassett. Mr. Botts, however, admitted them. They were then read by Mr. Hay, but they contain nothing important. The examination proceeded.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · and 1 other paper
During the treason trial, Burr's counsel questioned General Wilkinson in an attempt to discredit him or draw incriminating answers, particularly about a letter allegedly written to Aaron Burr. Wilkinson angrily demanded the letter be produced and asked to give a full account of his dealings with Burr, but the Chief Justice ruled such explanation unnecessary to the court's proceedings.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 12 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
LATEST PROCEEDINGS
An attempt had been made and was now repeated, to turn to the injury of his character, some words alledged to occur in it. He therefore demanded that Col. Burr should produce that letter. This demand becomes necessary, said he, from the strange and unfounded accusations against me which are adduced from it; and, I only say, the humble repute I have had among my countrymen for thirty years, is not to be destroyed by the fraud, artifice and deception of my enemies. With the permission of the court I will for my own vindication, on Monday next, go into a full detail of all the transactions between Col. Burr and myself; which at first I avoided doing in order to save the time of the court.
The Chief Justice. I cannot sit to hear matters foreign to the subject. There is no sort of necessity for the explanation which General Wilkinson wishes to make; so far as repects the questions of a variance between his testimony to the grand jury and that pronounced before the court; for the evidence of Mr. Tazewell has proved that there is no variance. To suffer all the circumstances to be gone into would be converting the trial from that of the persons at the bar to a trial of Gen. Wilkinson's conduct. His vindication if he desires it, had better be given to the public in another form.
See moreSee less
Mr. McRea wished General Wilkinson to be heard more fully on some points, respecting which his reputation had been particularly assailed, if he could not be permitted to state all that he knew.
Col. Burr. Gen. Wilkinson was sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. If his recollection is now animated let him proceed.
General Wilkinson. I mentioned before that I had received certain letters from col. Burr which, from motives of delicacy, I did not think myself authorised to shew. Yet the letter from me bearing the post-mark of the 13th of May has been made use of against me. I demand that letter. When it is produced I shall be liberated from all reserve, and will shew his letters; which I do not wish to do; for I really feel that delicacy which others profess to feel. I here solemnly declare the assertion of Aaron Burr, that he had put that letter out of his power, with my knowledge, to be utterly destitute of truth.
Upon hearing this declaration and demand, Col. Burr hastily put an end to the cross examination, saying "If the General has any more evidence to give, let him give it; if not he is discharged."
(The residue of the proceedings of this day in our next.)
A witness recounts being approached by Blennerhassett to join an expedition, offered land and supplies, and describes plans to descend the river with armed men from Marietta. The testimony details boat-building on the Muskingum and discussions of using force against anyone trying to stop the expedition.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 12 October 1807 · page 2
L ! rode with Mrifllansincr'hasset to me the ss ctsiboats that were buildiogop the Muskin. F'gum', where he showedihe builder of thy ? beats and msiV-els the ar—ticlcs by which the people under his command, as be called if, were :o.-besi'_'_'govcrqch on deacc-nding the ; river. si Passcsih boata'cr &! was zo choosectshc nap'. : ! usimil the;-joined col. Burr at the ment.. :" F
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Court testimony covers the printing of 'Querist' articles in the Marietta Gazette discussing division of the union, and witness accounts of Blannerhassett discussing the conspiracy under Burr's direction. Witnesses named including General Eaton and John Graham are described as being involved, with most witnesses then discharged except Eaton.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 14 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
not " wish to go." JOHN G. HENDERSON. I rode with Mr. Blannerhassett and his wife to my brother's house, on the second Monday in September last.—When we got near to my brother's, Mr. Blannerhassett introduced the subject of the separation of the union. He stated, I think, that it was to be conducted under the auspices of col. Burr. He mentioned that there were
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A witness describes conversations with Blennerhassett regarding plans involving the Ouachita lands, young men being recruited without farming tools, and suspicions about the true purpose of the expedition. Cross-examination by Burr challenges details about the land's quality and prior testimony given before a grand jury and the Ohio legislature.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 14 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
to know how far he was at liberty to communicate my opinions to col. Burr, I urged to him the impropriety of his engaging in these objects ; he said it was impossible that col. B. could have so much deceived him and his son-in-
A deponent describes private conversations with General Wilkinson, who spoke of Col. Burr's enterprising nature and hinted at a coming expedition against Spanish territories in Mexico. The witness was asked about recruiting men from St. Charles and pledged willingness to serve, while Wilkinson suggested he would personally lead the attack.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 14 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
STATEMENT OF FACTS.
Some time in the month of July, 1805, I was introduced to gen. James Wilkinson at St. Charles, and after some conversation in which he observed that I had been recommended to him by my friends at Cincinnati, he asked me to walk with him, as he wanted some private conversation. After enquiring very particularly into my pecuniary circumstances, observed, that he should be happy in a farther acquaintance. That the present was not however a proper time for him to communicate to me what he intended to do hereafter, and wished me to call on him at St. Louis, as soon as I could make it convenient.
See moreSee less
At the time col. Burr was in this country, I think in the month of August in the same year, I called on general Wilkinson at Camp Belle Fontaine.—He remarked that he was extremely glad that I had come, as it saved him the trouble of sending for me; and that he wished to communicate to me a matter of a very secret nature. That col. Burr had gone to St. Charles and expected to return to St. Louis the same evening, and to leave this country the next morning, that he wanted to know my mind before the colonel left St. Louis. The general began by enquiring into the minds and disposition of the people in the disrict of St. Charles, and asked whether they were pleased with the change of government? And whether I did not think the greater part of them would prefer a government different from that of the United States and particularly those who had removed to this country while it was under Spanish government, it convinced him they were not pleased with their own. He observed that in a little time it would be in his power to place me in affluent circumstances, which he was determined to do, and that he should do the same by Mr. Peter Provenchete. He appeared very desirous that I should become acquainted with col. Burr; as he said the col. was one of the most enterprizing men in the United States. The above conversation took place on our way from the Camp to St. Louis.
At the request of the general I remained at St. Louis several days, and he continued apparently very desirous of communicating something to me—however, I returned home without his disclosing the secret to me at that time, and under a promise to call on him again in a short time.
In the month of October, I believe, I accordingly called again on the general, when a similar conversation to the one before related took place, except that col. Burr's name was not mentioned.—
A witness is cross-examined about conversations with Aaron Burr concerning his supposed designs against the U.S. government, including remarks about the nation's unpreparedness for an attack. The testimony recounts dinners and meetings at Burr's boarding house where such views were allegedly expressed.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
where Mr. Burr boarded, I frequently dined at that house with gentlemen in congress, and we some times passed an hour or a half before dinner in conversation. We
This passage records courtroom cross-examination testimony, likely from the Burr treason trial, with a witness being questioned about toasts printed in a Springfield newspaper and about conversations and interactions with Colonel Burr. The witness describes consulting advisors about whether to disclose information to the government and discusses Burr's demeanor and composure during their exchanges.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
toasts were printed in a Springfield paper? A I was about to observe with the permission of the court on that subject. I never meant to be positive on that point.—I am impressed with the opinion that this toast went through the hands of Stephen Pynchon of Brimfield, and through him to said paper. The toasts have been given to the public and it is more than probable. I gave it more than once.
Mr. Botts. Who was the printer of the Springfield paper? A I do not at this time recollect his name, though he is among the number of my friends.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. Or the title of the paper? A. 'The Spy.'
Mr. Botts. You have detailed a number of harsh expressions which you used to col. Burr. Did he keep in perfect good temper all this time? A. Col Burr sir, has a powerful command of his muscles: I did not find at all times that they were unruffled. I could read in his countenance some times concern, sometimes solicitude, and some times a disposition to make a trifle of my objections.
Mr. Botts. I think you said that it was generally your purpose not to disclose in your intercourse with col. Burr that you
General Wilkinson testifies under cross-examination about his correspondence with the government, his orders to seize Aaron Burr, and his refusal to let anyone kill rather than capture him. He also fields questions about communications with various individuals regarding Burr's alleged conspiracy and the purpose of Lieutenant Pike's expedition.
The Enquirer · 14 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Deposition of Commodore Shaw and Wm. Tharp.
Be it remembered, that this day, to wit: the sixteenth day of April, anno Domini 1807, personally appeared before me the subscriber, one of the justices of the peace for the City and Parish of New-Orleans, John Shaw, Esq. Captain in the United States Navy, and William Tharp, Esq. who being first duly sworn on the Holy Evangelist of Almighty God, declare and say, that on or about the fifteenth day of January last, 1807, passing from the Coffee-House, about the hour of 12 o'clock at noon, they were accosted opposite the principal by Judge Prevost of this place, who observed that he was happy to inform these deponents, that General Adair, the second in command to Col. Burr, had arrived in town and was then at Madam Nourage's, that he had just waited on him, or had seen the man who had created so much stir, who said Col. Burr would be in town in three days, after him, that it would soon be discovered if the constitution & justice would prevail, or that of the usurpation of power and tyranny manifested in the measures at present adopted. Other remarks were made by the judge in tone and gesture discovering evident marks of irritation and opposition to the measures of the officers of the government, and impressed one of these deponent's with an idea that the judge's object was to be personal with Capt. John Shaw, and extorted a reply that he (Capt. Shaw) knew no private character he obeyed, and executed his orders without partiality, and should always be alert to meet and apprehend the disturbers of the peace and harmony of his government. These deponents remained but a few minutes with judge Prevost, and went to the lodgings of the Captain, where the deponents considered it correct to inform Gen. Wilkinson, that Gen. Adair was then in town, which Capt. Shaw did by sending his servant with a note to General Wilkinson.
Captain John Shaw and William Shaw/Tharp give sworn testimony describing reports that Colonel Burr had seized gunboats, armed thousands of men, and assembled a flotilla for an expedition. The depositions recount secondhand claims from a printer named Bradford about Burr's forces and plans near New Orleans.
The Enquirer · 14 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
(P) Deposition of Commodore Shaw.
Be it known that on or about the seventh day of January, anno domini 1807, Mr. Bradford, printer of the New-Orleans Gazette, waited on this deponent, Captain Shaw of the United States Navy, and after delivering a letter from a correspondent, he observed, that he had spent some time in the city of Washington and Philadelphia; and from Philadelphia he had travelled to Pittsburg, and from thence proceeded towards New-Orleans; that the country through which he passed was filled with commotion, and that there were a great number of the friends and followers of Col. Burr. Mr. Bradford also mentioned, that he had seen at the mouth of Cumberland river some of the public gun-boats and a number of men employed in fitting them out, and that they were to join Burr; that the men at work on board the gun-boats told him (Bradford), that Col. Lyon had given up the gun-boats to Col. Burr, and that he Col. Lyon was one of Burr's partizans: Bradford further observed that he saw a number of small arms which he supposed were carried on board the gun-boats, and that the men at work on board the gun-boats informed him (Bradford) that Col. Burr had issued arms and ammunition to 12,000 men; that Burr's flotilla consisted of seven gun-boats and a brig of 10 guns, and that Capt. Talbot was commander of the flotilla: Bradford also observed, that he was suspected, and that in order to shew his innocence, he would wait on Gen. Wilkinson and disclose to him all he knew concerning Burr and his plots, and further this deponent faith not.
Captain John Shaw and William Tharp give sworn testimony about January 1807 encounters with Judge Prevost, who spoke favorably of Burr and General Adair's arrival in New Orleans. The affidavits detail suspicions about Prevost's sympathies and Shaw's loyalty to the government in apprehending conspirators.
Burr would be in town in three days, after him, that it would foon be difeuvered if the couftituttbti & judicc would prevail, or that of the ufurpation of power and tyranny manifefted in the meafures at pre ient adopted. Other remarks were made by the judge in tone and jefture difeovering evident marks of irritation and oppofirion to the nuafures of the offi cer* of the government, and impreffed one of thel'e deponent’s with an idea that the judge’s obiedl was to be perforin 1 with Capt. John Shaw,and extorted a re fs.y that he (Capt. Shaw) knew no private charaifter he obeyed, and executed his orders w ithout partiality, and fliould always he alert to meet and apprehend the difturbersof tile peace and harmony of his govern• n\e"t! deponents remained but a few minutes with judge Prevoft, and went to the lodgings of the Captain, where the deponentsconfidcrrd it correift to inform Gen. Wilkinfon, that Oen. Adair was then in town, whicn Capt. Shaw did by fending his fer'vant with a note to General Wilkinfon.
A witness testifies about meeting Blennerhassett in Marietta, describing letters from Colonel Burr and conversations about their expedition plans, including land purchases and settlers. The testimony explores whether their objective was legitimate land settlement or something else, as Blennerhassett avoided explicit admission of ulterior motives.
Virginia Argus · 14 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
letter? Mr M'Rae. Do you believed the letter to have been col. Burr's? A. I believe it was col. Burr's writing; for though I had never seen col. Burr write, yet I had seen many letters said to be written by col. Burr. I merely mention this letter to show that it gave rise to a conversation between Mr Blennerhasset and myself, relative to the contents of this letter. The conversation was somewhat desultory; nor do I particularly recollect the order in which the several topics were introduced. In general I recollect, that Mr Blennerhasset animadverted upon the conduct pursued towards col. Burr at Frankfort; stating however his belief that this conduct was not authorised by the government. He menti...
This passage recounts courtroom testimony describing a conversation in which the witness warned Blennerhassett that he suspected Burr's expedition aimed at either U.S. or Spanish territories, and that armed collections on the Ohio would be treated as unlawful. The witness states he acted on his own authority, not that of Jefferson or Madison, to investigate and potentially suppress the enterprise.
Virginia Argus · 14 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
government had received, and from the nature of the preparations which Mr Blennerhasset himself was then making, why I believed that the object of col. Burr was either to attack the territories of the Uni-
The report covers circuit court proceedings in the Aaron Burr case, detailing speeches by lawyers Mr. Wirt, Mr. Randolph, and Mr. Martin over several days, with delays due to illness. An editorial comment sarcastically labels the trial 'The Real Jugglers, or The Tricks of the Grand Impostor,' suggesting skepticism about the outcome and possible escape of the accused.
Virginia Argus · 14 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT.
FRIDAY, October 9. Mr Hay finished his speech, which opened the argument on the part of the U. States, and was followed by Mr Randolph on the side of Col Burr.
A correspondent casts the ongoing Burr treason trial as a stage drama, listing the judge, lawyers, and witnesses as actors performing in a comedy titled 'The Tricks of the Grand Impostor.' The piece mocks the trial's great expense and length, predicting the defendants may escape punishment entirely.
Virginia Argus · 14 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Gov. Hardy, Squire Dupe, Israel Cypher, Mahomet Volpone, the Grand Impostor, Mr Eaton. Mr Bienerhas't. Mr Smith. Mr Burr.
This celebrated Play, has by some been called a Farce, by others, a Tragi-come.
This passage recounts courtroom testimony, likely from Samuel Swartwout, describing conversations with Burr about enterprises involving Commodore Truxton, Latrobe, and General Adair. It details Swartwout's pursuit of Burr down the river, disguised intentions, and a staged accident to avoid suspicion.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 15 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
of Latrobe, he said, that was the man, he said that he had been dispatched by col. B. from Philadelphia, and had traversed the states of Ohio and Kentucky. I so understood the gentleman at that time, but have since discovered that he descended the river.
Mr. Botts. By whom did you understand that he descended the river? A By a man who informed me he had rowed him down from Pittsburg.
See moreSee less
Another reason why I may have been mistaken was this. He informed me that he had passed to Frankfort in quest of gen. Adair, for whom he had dispatches from col Burr; and not hearing of him there, had returned back to Lexington in pursuit of him; where he was informed by maj. Waggoner, that gen. Adair, being in ill health had gone to some medical spring,
A witness (apparently General Wilkinson) recounts conversations and correspondence implicating Aaron Burr, including cryptic remarks about borrowing money, British protection, naval officers' discontent, and the dispatch of Dr. Bollman to New Orleans with Burr's dispatches. Defense counsel objects to admitting a letter purportedly from General Dayton on grounds of insufficient authentication, prompting legal argument over evidentiary standards.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 15 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
delphia, by sea to New Orleans, with dispatches from colonel Burr to me, and that they must have arrived. Mr. Swartwout informed me that he was obliged to go to New Orleans, and was also under engagements to meet colonel Burr and general Dayton at Nashville on the 20th November. I think Mr. Swartwout left Natchitoches about the 18th of October, for New Orleans, as I understood. It may be proper, in this stage of my testimony, to say that the envelope which contained the cyphered letter from colonel Burr, covered
The jury returned a verdict of not guilty for Burr after the prosecution failed to fit the case within the court's legal principles and attempted unsuccessfully to withdraw the charge. Hay then moved to send Burr, Blennerhassett, and Israel Smith to Kentucky or Mississippi Territory for a treason trial, but the defense objected, arguing double jeopardy and jurisdictional issues; the court ruled Mississippi Territory lacked jurisdiction over treason, leaving the prior acquittal's effect undecided.
The Wheeling Repository · 15 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
any of the acts charged in the indictment, might be received.
When this opinion was delivered, Mr. Hay proceeded in the examination of witnesses; but finding that he could not bring the case within the principles laid down by the court, he proposed to enter a noli prosequi. Burr objected to this, and the court decided that it could not be done, after the jury was impaneled, without consent. The jury then retired, and returned a verdict of not guilty.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay then moved the court to commit Burr, Blennerhasset, and Israel Smith, to Kentucky, or the Mississippi territory, to be there tried for treason. The counsel for Burr objected to this motion, and contended that he could not
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
David C. Wallace testifies about conversations with Burr regarding Western lands, taxation, and commerce, suggesting Burr influenced ideas later published as 'The Querist.' Cross-examination explores the timing of conversations with Blannerhassett and Wallace's medical background.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT of the UNITED STATES.
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 24.
Evidence of David C. Wallace—concluded.
See moreSee less
In a conversation with col. B. in 1805, he expatiated upon the situation of the Western country; on its being compelled to pay large sums, for the sale of lands which were spent in the Atlantic states, and on the 3,000,000 dollars, which he said, we paid for tax. These observations made by col. B. induced me to believe—Mr. Botts objected to the witness stating any of his own inferences.
Col. Burr observed that this same money would vastly improve the commerce of the Western country.
Mr. Hay. Did you ever read the Querist? A. I read the 1st and 2d Nos. at Cincinnati. Q. Did the observations in these papers recall to your recollection your conversation with Mr. Burr? A. They did. When I saw these papers, I was asked my opinion about the author. I said that in my opinion, col. B. had suggested the ideas, and that Mr. Blannerhassett had put them into words. Q. Were the rumors that you spoke of, general? A. They were so. They were in every man's mouth.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A witness testifies about riding with Blannerhassett to recruit young men for the expedition, describing conversations where Blannerhassett named Burr and General Eaton as leaders and discussed plans for western separation and possible conflict with Spain. The witness also describes weapons seen on Blannerhassett's island, including guns, blunderbusses, pistols, and powder.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
father told Mr. Blannerhassett he had better give up the enterprise, and stay at home on his island; that it was impossible he could succeed; that his force was too small and the opposition too great. Mr. Blannerhassett said that gen. Wilkinson and the army would join him. When I was at the island, Mr. Blannerhassett told me, that he expected we should have a little fighting with the Spaniards; but that they were great cowards, and would soon run, and leave every thing in our possession,—In the month of August, Mr.
See moreSee less
Blannerhassett was at my father's house, and used many arguments to prove that it was the interest of the Western states to separate themselves from the union. Mr. Wirt. Did Blannerhassett speak of Burr? A. Yes, I understood that he spoke of him as the leader. I recollect to have asked him whether col. Burr was concerned.—
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel cross-examine General Wilkinson about letters he allegedly wrote to Burr, with the Chief Justice ruling on whether the letter's contents can be discussed without producing the letter itself. Wilkinson claims poor recollection of the letter's contents, admitting only to fearing 'Miranda has taken the bread out of your mouth.'
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
bearing on the cause unless the letter was produced. Any thing drawn out of the letter would not be testimony, unless the opposite party who had it in their possession would exhibit it to the court. But it was obvious that they had another object, which was to ascertain the consistency of the witness. Mr. Wirt. If the object be to shake the credibility of the witness, is it not fair to him and to the conduct of the cause to exhibit the whole letter. Mr. Baker. A very ingenious mode has been adopted by the gentlemen.
See moreSee less
We put the questions, and they undertake to furnish the answers without leaving it to the witness to do it himself. We do intend to shake the credibility of gen. Wilkinson, and to make him produce the shake himself.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This passage recounts testimony by Gen. William Eaton describing conversations with Aaron Burr, in which Burr allegedly proposed recruiting Marine Corps officers and naval commanders like Truxton, Preble, and Decatur to support a scheme to overthrow Congress, possibly assassinate the President, and establish himself as protector of an 'energetic government.' Eaton admits uncertainty about exact wording but insists on the substance of Burr's treasonous intentions.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
from Fort Adams an eight inch howitzer, which you will find there properly equipt and amply ammunitioned.
GENERAL WILLIAM EATON, sworn.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay. We only wish that part of your testimony, sir, which you have not yet delivered. You recollect that there was a part of it which was excluded by the decision of the court.
Gen. Eaton.—I know nothing concerning Blannerhassett and Smith. I have no recollection that their names were mentioned to me, till after the prosecution was commenced. All that I know of Burr's project to dismember the union, is already before the court. After col. Burr had expressed to me the intended projects already related and overcome my objections, he went so far as to assert that he would erect his standard at the seat of government. Mr. Burr enquired of me, with what officers of the marine corps and of the navy, I was acquainted. I told him, with most of them. It is impossible for me at this period to remember distinctly every adverb expressed to me in the course of conversation; but this I perfectly recollect, that if he could gain the Marine Corps, and secure to his interests the naval commanders Truxton, Preble and Decatur, he would turn Congress neck and heels out of doors, assassinate the President, or what amounted to that, and declare himself the protector of an energetic government. If that distinct expression was not used (though the impression is strong on my mind, that it was used in the course of conversation) yet he used such expressions as these "hang him," "throw him into the Potomac," "send him to Carter's mountain."—Mr. Burr proposed to me to endeavor to gain the Marine Corps, and to sound Preble and Decatur, with whom I had been in habits of intimacy, but I had not been so with Truxton.—A circumstance now recurs to my recollection. He also desired me to gain a capt. Davidson, a very brave man and who is as honest as he is brave. Mr. Burr seemed to select a Mr. Reynolds, a lieutenant of marines, a handsome, and excellent officer, whom he wished to engage. He grew importunate on the subject of the Marine Corps; and asked me with some engagedness, how the Marine Corps stood. I answered him, "Make yourself easy, sir; The Marine Corps stand as they should stand." Here I beg leave to observe that I never felt myself prepared to insult the honor of either of those gentlemen, by making such propositions to them; and if I had tho't them corruptible, I was not yet prepared. I remonstrated with colonel Burr on the fallacy of his hopes to engage such men as Truxton, Preble
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A witness describes conversations with Aaron Burr in which Burr spoke of violent threats and attempted to recruit military officers like Truxton, Preble, and Decatur for his schemes. The witness recounts warning Burr that such plans were treasonous and that no group of Americans would support such a revolutionary project.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
collect to have mentioned to colonel Burr, that I had lately travelled from one extreme of the union to the other—and though I found a diversity of political sentiment among the people, they appeared united at the most dis-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
A witness testifies about advice he received from Samuel Dana and John Cotton Smith regarding disclosures to the government, and recounts conversations with Jonathan Dayton and Dr. William Thornton about potential military commands and a Spanish war scheme. The witness defends his character against Burr's attempt to discredit him on the stand.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
must have that gentleman's name. Who was it ? A. Jonathan Dayton. Mr. Burr. Had you any expectations or promises of a military command from government ? A. It is true that the chief clerk in the department of
The report details courtroom proceedings from Richmond, including delays due to Mr. Wirt's illness, arguments by Mr. Martin, and a dispute over evidence involving Mr. Graham's role in the Western country. It also notes the arrival of witnesses including Daniel Clark, Mr. Powers, and Dr. Cummings.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
There was no court on Saturday, on account of Mr. Wirt's indisposition.
On Monday, Mr. Martin resumed the argument at 10, and continued speaking till four.
See moreSee less
On Tuesday, Mr. Hay offered the affidavit of Benjamin Stoddert, Esq. which he has just received from that gentleman.—Mr. Burr objected to its production, on the ground that Mr. S. ought to have been present to be cross-examined.—The affidavit was not received.—Mr. Hay then moved for an attachment against Mr. Stoddert; which was awarded by the court.
Mr. Wirt observed, that he had understood, the gentleman who had opened the cause on the part of the defendants, had asserted that a system of espionage had pervaded the transactions in the western country, of which Mr. Graham was said to have been the first minister.—"I hold in my hand, says Mr. W. the original instructions of the secretary of state to Mr. Graham, which I offer as evidence to the court."
A witness recounts conversations with Dr. Bollman and references to Lieutenant Spence carrying dispatches from Colonel Burr, including discussions about the strength of Burr's force and provisions in New Orleans. The testimony details exchanges about whether Burr could still retreat from his plans given his supporters' commitments.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 2
COLONEL A. BURR
and that he had heard ofhis arriygl at Nct-"sik tiil e. He then ctfflfffl ctffi" ! {meant ss WMT at ( felt myself deli costly sit-noted [! was impossible that ! could take any part while ] held my com mission, and ( was so circumstanced, that ] could not get rid of it. He asked me what] thought of the competency of the lforce foe the unde-making. I observed that itdssependsied on a vaticty of circumstances , -. such as winds. weather. composition and rappointment of the tmch, slt .'ll tn conduct the rezistassne'e of their opponents, and other zcauses on which the success of mihtztry' ctoperationa depend.
See moreSee less
But ,I gave it as my opinion that I thought the force insuffici -cntHe said thzt Lo!. Burr had gone too far to retractsi, * that he had numerous & sipoweriul" friends in the United" States; who stood pledged to. support hi on with their tortuous,-end that-lie must succeed, 'He _ then enqnited at me my opinion, as to the state of the simagezinee of pkovistons
The passage records courtroom dialogue involving witnesses Wilkinson, Bollman, and Tazewell during Aaron Burr's treason trial, including cross-examination about cyphered letters and security measures for New Orleans. There is also procedural dispute over whether Tazewell, summoned as a witness, can be excused early due to family matters, with the Chief Justice ruling the court cannot discharge him.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 16 October 1807 · page 2
!ss 51. Yea, my orders andlnstmcctons will " shew what Smeaeusircsse ] deem9d it msi'y du 15 to pursue. For these ! am i'espanjflble lo the executive of the U. S . My. Martin. Are the cypheredletters .fi!ctcssd.i. Ass. Yea. Q Are the keys furuiabxd ? A Here it is. ss Mr. Boss'tts mentioned the situat'mn of ! Mr. 'lazewcll, who was summoned as a witness on The part of cal. Burr. He said
General Wilkinson is cross-examined by defense counsel Wickham regarding his earlier letters and communications about Burr's alleged conspiracy, including testimony from Swartwout. Wilkinson explains his shifting levels of confidence in various reports about Burr's intentions and funding sources.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
stood that a copy would be received by col. Burr. Now we see the necessity of having the original.] Gen. Wilkinson. I have no sort of hesitation to state what my feelings were. If the Spaniards had been seriously disposed to war, I did believe that by a suitable appeal to the feelings and patriotism of the deluded citizens who might have defended with col. Burr, they would have been induced to join our standard, and oppose a foreign enemy sooner than enter into a conflict with their own countrymen. My idea was this, that the President should have forwarded to me blank commissions to be offered to influential leaders.—Mr.
See moreSee less
Wickham. This postscript says nothing as to leaders but to the body in general. Gen. Wilkinson. I cannot give any definite idea of my sensations at the moment. I think I could not have meant leader, but the leaders. Mr. Wickham. If you were ignorant of the intentions of the leaders, why not as well apply the expression to the leader? A. Because I did not think I could offer any thing to him which he would accept. Mr. Wickham. As to the postscript, you are uncertain whether it was written at the time of the original letter? Gen.
This passage records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson being cross-examined by defense counsel (Randolph, Wickham, Martin) about his military orders regarding Spain, his decoding of Burr's cipher letter, and how he communicated its contents to the government via Mr. Briggs. The exchanges probe inconsistencies in Wilkinson's account of when and how he learned of Burr's alleged designs.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Martin. Did you not drive them beyond the Sabine? Gen Wilkinson (smiling) said it was a sort of driving. Mr Wickham. You say that the first intimation you had of col Burr's designs, was from the cyphered letter?
General Wilkinson is cross-examined by defense counsel Randolph and Wickham about his decipherment of Burr's letter and his instructions to Briggs regarding the grand jury. He also answers questions about military encounters with Spanish forces near the Sabine River.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
foot according with your own ideas; or that you should say, col. Burr's views were not distinctly known till you received the cyphered letter?—
A. I had received a number of ambiguous letters from col. Burr; and in a letter of mine to him, I made use of the expression "I fear Miranda has taken the bread out of your mouth," in order to draw from him his real object.
See moreSee less
Q. In what manner did you consider Miranda as taking the bread out of his mouth?
A. If I can state the grounds of those opinions, I would say that they were derived from letters received from col. Burr; which I am not at liberty to disclose.
The passage records courtroom testimony in which General Wilkinson is questioned by Randolph and Wickham about his communications with Spanish commandants and his correspondence with Aaron Burr. Wilkinson describes destroying a letter he wrote to Burr and explains that information from Donaldson first raised his suspicions of Burr's conspiracy.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
not permit a repetition of the trefpafs. Mr Wickham. I think you faid that you wrote to col Burr from Nachitoches. Gen Wilkinfon. When did I fay fo? Mr Wickham. I thought I heard you fay fo. Gen Wilkinfon. You guefs well; but if I am not miftaken, you got that information from Swartwout. Q Did you write? A I did. Q What did you do with the letter? A Deftroyed it. Q Did it go out of your hands? A It did. It was fent to Natchez; to which place I followed, recovered and deftroyed it.
See moreSee less
I will give you my reafons for doing fo. After writing, I received the letter from Mr Donaldfon, dated the 30th of October, and conveying the information received from Myers Michael, which removed my doubts as to the extent of Mr Burr's defigns and their finifter nature. Mr Wickham. Then I underftand you to fay, that Mr Donaldfon gave you the firft correct information. A It excited very ftrong apprehenfions in my mind, that fome general and deep-rooted confpiracy had taken place above. Mr Wickham. You have no recollection of the letter of the 19th of May. A No. I wifh it could be produced. It would releafe me from
Defense and prosecution counsel argue over whether a private letter, possibly from President Jefferson, must be produced as evidence in Burr's trial. Hay resists producing it as irrelevant, while Burr and Martin claim a right to see it, and Wirt accuses the defense of trying to implicate the President.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 3
I will not fay that the gentlemen know this fait, nor do I fay that they have other objects in view. What effects they may have out of doors ; what materials of declamation they may furnilh to gentlemen of a certain way of think ing ; I know not. But I do alTure gentlemen, that when this letter is produced, it will have a very different elicit, from what they may con template. (Mr Hay then read the laft para graph of the letter.) Mr. Burr. If there be a
An army officer recounts receiving orders in late 1806 about secretive troop movements, the return of General Wilkinson's expedition from the Sabine, and the sudden embarkation of military stores from Fort Adams. He describes Wilkinson revealing to him that Col. Burr's conspiracy targeted New Orleans, based on intercepted letters via Burr's agent Swartwout, and his own subsequent orders to monitor for armed men descending from the Ohio country.
The Enquirer · 16 October 1807 · page 3
quelied roe to walk with him rn the battery, where | he communicated to n.e the dtfigas of Col. Burr, iu ; forming me mat lie had received fevcral letters from | Col. Burr, thro'one of hi* agents (Mr. Swartwout) | and that l.urr's principal attack would be upon Or ! leans; 1 was never ?.iore aftonilbed, not having heard that any lufpicions were entertained againfthim; I informed the General the fituation in which I had found Mr. Swartwout o.i my arrival, and requelled leave to aired him. The General refufed, faying, that he ex.
See moreSee less
edled to get much more out of him, that he had h. id out to S.vsrtwout the idea of his nor opptifing Col. Burr, and that he (hould NTcmble his whole force at Orleans, to enable him to defend that place and defeat the whole plan. I was diredl-.l to continue r.iy c vil.ties as Uetore, for fear that Mr. Swartwout might get alarmed at the movement of the troops and .nlitary llores. On the I9h I received i t« 1 tocCed with niv coumaod to Natchez, with [ iiiHrudliou* to tiue the neteffji-y m-afn es to afeertain i the approac > of :• body of armed iv.cn from the Ohio : country ai u.vetnc General the rarlietl inforr.ia | (ion by nxjMe.«, ol c»try movement from that quar j ter, ti'.her at Natchez or hv lending a confidential I party up tin. river above the Yazoo, iiithe difguife of | I: .' ten, and ! according communicated regularly i -very information 1 could v.ilcrt. About tin-lafi of ; '-'fct-mber, i (aw two letters, one from the Pofl-ntaf ! ter of Nafi.v lie, to blvlirv Burner nf N.iirV..-. A tlvIStli I*e.i:Hib.:r, dating that Col. Burr was then i:i Nufh vil'e, and that he meant ro proceed, <*r> the 20th', to the m.-Hih of Cumberland, where,report foul j h*. wiitilj IjiVeaifiinh!.'J *r »ti live, ft) c’g.ir thnufond | Ii-.en, and ih.it it U!5 generally believed that he iti t ended a v fir in Mexico. Til" other Utter toa Mr. Wood fro >| Nath viile—futfUe of V. *1. Burr's being in Nafbvdle j tii.it t*o ni nit pn*l-iyt*'s had l*Tt town that morning for ft i- .i;.* by food ; from the lied o} niy recollection the above ftiitr.mrnt of the letursto Turner and Wood iacorreCi, and Col. Iit>»rfo anival v.ry daily expected by all perfouj r.t Natchez._ For my o/vn p.,rt I did not d>u’>t i‘, and conftdcring tliia information as all important f*> the Genrr d, I pro ceeded for Orleans, arrived time on the 2d fi .uary, and communicated it to him. SoAii after, this infor mation waa corroborated JiV the arrival of Bradford the printer ol the Gazette (i leans. flfiO: PETER, Court* of lVufbirt^'n, ,7.-7, On thi* • D;h day of S«| . in'irr, I *07, George Pe tar came before me, a |..«k* of the Perce for the county aforefaid, ami nude oath on the Holy Evan-1 gely of A! Iiigpty God that the la‘Is dated in the fore going, is true us dated.
A witness named Graham recounts conversations with Governor Williams and Lieutenant Peter about an authorized attempt to seize Aaron Burr, including a plan by officers in disguise with concealed weapons. He describes advising against extralegal military action and urging that Burr be sent for proper trial instead.
Virginia Argus · 16 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
he had come with other officers to arrest Colonel Burr, and I advised him to do nothing that would violate the laws of the country. He gave me to understand, that at that moment he felt himself bound to obey the orders of his General, like a good soldier. I urged every consideration I could suggest against the exercise of military authority; and I did then understand, that it was not his intention to proceed against Colonel Burr. Indeed I understood that Colonel Burr had made his escape. I advised Governor Williams to make such ar
This passage records courtroom testimony during Aaron Burr's treason trial, including cross-examination about bail, recognizance, and Burr's sudden departure from Washington. Witnesses including a Governor Williams figure discuss Burr's movements, his office status, and arrangements for secrecy to avoid detection by Spanish authorities and spies.
Virginia Argus · 16 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
farce and that something ought to be done. He proposed to see Colonel Burr and make some arrangements with him to come on to the city of Washington for his trial: Col. Burr informed him that he was merely going to ride to Colonel Osborne's for that night. Governor Williams informed me that he received a great coat at the suburbs of the town and disappeared. Mr Wirt. Was not Colonel Burr held in recognizance? A. Yes. Q. Did you see such a recognizance? A. Yes. I saw it myself in the clerk's office.
See moreSee less
Mr Burr. If it is there, I pronounce it to be a forgery. Mr Hay observed that the truth would appear in time. Mr Hay Were any legal proceedings pending at the time of his departure? The witness asked the court if this was a proper question. Ch. Jus. It is a mere difference of opinion about a fact. Colonel Burr contended that this recognizance had been complied with; Governor Williams says not. Mr Hay. Was his departure from Washington sudden? A. It was certainly sudden, as Gov. W. told me he had been promised with a call from Col. Burr.
The court proceedings cover a dispute over an unread affidavit from Benjamin Stoddart, leading to an attachment against him, and debate over admitting Graham's instructions as evidence regarding spy allegations. Mr. Martin then delivers a three-day closing argument for the defense, arguing Burr's innocence and attacking General Wilkinson's credibility.
Virginia Argus · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT.
man, which he offered as evidence. Col. Burr opposed the reading of those instructions on the ground that they referred to previous "verbal explanations." After some debate, the Chief Justice observed there was no necessity for introducing them. He said that according to Mr. Graham's own testimony, he had been commissioned by the government to enquire into the situation of the Western country, in a character very different from that of a spy; and that nothing had appeared to disprove the statement he had made. Mr Wirt then declared that, if no further allusion should be made to Mr Graham as discharging the services of a spy, he should not insist upon reading his instructions.
See moreSee less
Otherwise, he should conceive it his duty to press the question with the court. Mr. Martin resumed his discourse, and continued speaking until the usual hour of adjournment.
The report describes ongoing courtroom debate in the Burr treason trial, including Luther Martin's sarcastic rebuttal of President Jefferson's language about the Allegany Mountains and the union. It also notes that Mr. Wickham continued the defense's argument for hours, while the Essex Register comments that public opinion remains unsettled about the Burr affair.
Virginia Argus · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The Essex (Salem) Register says the public mind is far from being satisfied with the affairs of Burr. But what can we do? It belongs to the representatives of the nation to examine the transactions, and to provide against future calamities.
The piece warns that British agents and Tory sympathizers will push for a maritime code favoring property on land over American sailors at sea. It invokes the recent acquittal of Burr as evidence of how British-style law distinctions harm Americans, urging Congress to reject such double standards.
Virginia Argus · 16 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
BRITISH AGENTS.
There can be no doubt but the British agents and tories, will use every endeavor in their presses, to obtain a confirmation of the old maritime code of law, from the next meeting of congress. That the persons and property of their employers shall be sacred, because on shore, whilst that of the poor unoffending American sailor, because on the ocean, shall be subject to the piracy and imprisonment of the British navy.
See moreSee less
We are certain that the American citizens will not connive at those distinctions—they see enough of British laws in the acquittal of Burr—and they never will submit to further wrongs in the adoption of other laws from the dictates of the cabinet of St. James.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The examination of evidence on the motion to commit Aaron Burr, Herman Blannerhassett, and Israel Smith was declared closed by both sides. Mr. Hay opened arguments for the United States, following testimony from Major James Bruff that implicated General Wilkinson.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 16 October 1807 · page 3
Latest proceedings in the Trial of Colonel A. Burr
Chauncv and Hull. The Court adjourned without doing any basinets nntu to morrow. Ut'Uton IV. Tazewell, E*f. hit been appointed Judge Adyocate. Commodore Barron i». we understand, very much indiapo sed, and Mr. Tazeweli it at Richmond, a w itnets in the case of CoL Burr.
A witness recounts testifying before the Orleans territory's legislative council about interpreting Aaron Burr's ciphered letters, describing the timeline of communications to the President and confidential messengers. The testimony details uncertainty over whether certain documents were shown to the grand jury and references a cipher system tied to a specific book from 1800.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
phered letters of col. Burr, but I cannot speak with certainty. This examination lasted several days and like that before the legislative council and representatives of
A sworn affidavit from a military officer (Capt. Walback) is read as evidence in Burr's treason trial, addressing correspondence between Burr and General Wilkinson and defending Wilkinson's conduct toward the troops. The document is certified by the U.S. Attorney for the Richmond District and notarized in September 1807.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ly.
Question.-- Did you hear a sentiment from General Wilkinson, calculatad to disaffect the troops, or to abate thoir zeal for its promotion ?
See moreSee less
Answer.---No, on the contrary, I have witnessed that General Wilkinson always used his utmost endeavors to promote harmony, comfort and good order among the troops, and and by his precepts as well as his example, to insure subordination and patriotism.
[Signed] J. B. WALBACK,
Capt. Artillery.
I am content that the above shall be read as evidence in all cases, between the United States and Col. Burr---and that any thing which may be added by the affiant, by way of answer to interrogatories may also be read.
The report details courtroom proceedings in Aaron Burr's trial, including arguments over the admissibility of Benjamin Soddard's affidavit and instructions given to Mr. Graham. The Chief Justice ruled on evidentiary matters, including whether Graham had acted as a 'spy' in the western country.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
LATEST PROCEEDINGS
system of espionage had pervaded the transactions in the western country, of which Mr. Graham was said to have been the first minister. "I hold in my hand, says Mr. W. the original instructions of the secretary of state to Mr. Graham, which I offer as evidence to the court."
Mr. Burr objected to their production, on the ground that the paper referred to previous "verbal explanations."
See moreSee less
The Chief Justice observed that there was no necessity for their introduction; that, according to Mr. Graham's own statement, he had been commissioned by the government to enquire into the situation of the western country, in a character very different from that of a Spy; and that no evidence had been produced to disprove these statements.
Mr. Wirt observed, that if no further allusion was made to Mr. Graham as discharging the duties of a spy, he should wave the reading of those instructions; but if the opposite
This report corrects an earlier account in the Enquirer of Mr. Graham's testimony regarding Colonel Burr's claim to the Ouachita land under Bastrop's grant. It clarifies that Graham did not say Burr had no title, and that Lynch's claim derived from sources beyond just Livingston, also correcting a misstatement about how much of the land was covered by water.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
"That you have been for years a pensioner of "Spain, and have held a secret intelligence with "that power: and you were engaged in Burr's "conspiracy and deserted him."
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The report records cross-examination testimony of General Wilkinson during the Burr conspiracy trial, detailing his instructions for capturing Aaron Burr near Natchez and the secrecy maintained around troop movements. Defense counsel Wickham probes Wilkinson on written versus oral orders and whether private soldiers were involved in the operation.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
...ed than those which we threw out on Burr's conspiracy, before the public were awakened to their danger.
CIRCUIT COURT of THE UNITED STATES.
See moreSee less
On the motion to commit Messrs. Burr, Blannerhassett, and Smith.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel argue they aim to show General Wilkinson acted improperly to discredit his testimony against Burr, including allegations he seized letters from the post-office and made erasures before swearing to translations. Prosecutor Hay objects that such claims, even if true, do not bear on the question of Burr's guilt.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
counsel to be to identify gen. Wilkinson with the government. Admitting that gen. Dearborn had made the declarations ascribed to him; admitting that the President had formed that opinion of gen. Wilkinson, how can his answer to the question propounded have any bearing on this case. Suppose gen. Wilkinson should say that in consequence of the expected arrival of B. the agitated state of the country, and a knowledge that he was surrounded by the accomplices and partizans of B. in New Orleans, he had taken letters from the post-office (and he would only say he had done what he ought) how could it affect the present case.
See moreSee less
It is manifest that the answer of gen. Wilkinson must leave the question between the U. States and col. B. exactly where it was before. Mr. Wickham. When these questions were asked Mr. Murray before, they were thought proper, and he was even cross examined by the counsel for the prosecution. The gentlemen have ascribed to col. B. improper acts. Now to impeach gen. Wilkinson's credibility, we show that he has been guilty of violent acts. Is he not interested to show the conduct of col. B. to be improper, in order to justify his own. Mr. Baker. Suppose, says Mr. Hay, this declaration of gen. Dearborn to be true; suppose that gen. Wilkinson did not deserve to stand high in the
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The passage reports courtroom testimony in which General Wilkinson is questioned about his orders and communications regarding the seizure of Swartwout, Bollman, Adair, and Burr himself. Wilkinson hesitates to answer certain questions, citing concerns about self-incrimination and military honor, prompting debate between counsel and the Chief Justice over whether he must respond.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Mere sympathies were no cause of refusal. However unpleasant those questions might be to general Wilkinson, it would be a shameful dereliction of duty in the counsel of Col. Burr not to put them. He said he had not experienced any sympathies toward his client.] Gen. Wilkinson to the judge.
Is a trial before a court martial similar to a criminal prosecution? I might be subjected to military punishment, to as severe punishment as could be inflicted by a civil tribunal, for revealing my orders. The Chief Justice said that he was not sure that General Wilkinson could be required
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
During the treason trial, defense counsel Wickham and Martin press General Wilkinson about orders he received from the Jefferson administration regarding Burr's seizure, while prosecutor Hay defends the government's conduct. Wilkinson refuses to produce a written order, citing honor and confidentiality, and the Chief Justice rules he need not disclose it if mixed with private matters.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
letter, it would not be required of gen. Wilkinson to produce it. Chief Justice. If the order be mingled with other things private and confidential, the court will not require its production.) Mr. Wickham to gen. Wilkinson. Did you by letter or otherwise, request any person not of the army to seize col. Burr and put him on board a vessel A. I gave instructions to a gentleman who is now here, Silas Dinsmore, Esq. and who is not of the army. Q. Did you give such orders to others? A.
See moreSee less
I recollect Dr. Carmichael; but no other person, except the officers of the army. Q. Do you recollect expressing to any person that he would confer the highest obligation on the government by seizing Col. Burr? A. It is probable that I did, for these were my sen[timents]
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 3 other papers
The passage continues newspaper coverage of Aaron Burr's treason trial, reporting the cross-examination of General Wilkinson by defense counsel Mr. Wickham. Wilkinson explains his instructions for apprehending Burr, including the use of plainclothes agents to avoid detection by Burr's spies and to not alarm Spanish authorities.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
[In our paper of the 9th inst. we had brought up the interesting examination of General Wilkinson to Tuesday the 27th ult. and concluded where Mr. Wickham asked the General if the persons sent to apprehend Burr, were in uniform, to which the General replied as follows.]
See moreSee less
TUESDAY, Sept. 29.
I think I did mention to them the propriety of going in the attire of private citizens, to elude the vigilance of Burr's spies, many of whom were in New-Orleans, and would give him notice of their departure from that place. It was also prudent to send them in that manner, that the jealousy of the Spaniards through whose territories they had to pass might not be excited. They were sent privately, for the success of the enterprize depended upon it.—Mr. Wickham. Did you give them written or oral instructions? A. Both. Q. Have you copies of the written instructions? A. Not here. Q. Will you furnish copies? [Mr. Hay objected to the production of those orders. He said that they had a right to impeach the credibility of the witness, but not to compel him to disclose the orders given to those under his command.] Q. Were these orders to seize col. Burr wherever they could find him? A. They were sent on that service expressly. I think the orders were confined to Natchez, information having been received, that col. Burr had taken up his quarters there. Q. Were there any orders to seize him even in court? I cannot say, but presume there were not. Q. Were any private soldiers sent on this service? A. No. Q. Were any soldiers sent to lieut. Jones's gun boats? A. Infantry were furnished to supply the place of marines, in all the gun boats. Q. Were any instructions sent by you that the men in lieutenant Jones's gun boats should act? A. I gave lieut. Jones no orders; he was not under my command. Q. Was commodore Shaw considered under your authority? A. He was rather considered as co-operating with me; but he had a discretion of his own. Q. Was there a recommendation to commodore Shaw, to give directions to lieutenant Jones to take any measure to apprehend Col. Burr? A. I think the orders required him to do so? Q. What orders were given for the disposal of col. Burr? A. The orders were, that he should be put on board a vessel and sent by the way of New-Orleans to the City of Washington. Q. Were these orders written? A. I believe they were. What orders had you from the government, or did you do it on your own authority? [Gen. Wilkinson took time till tomorrow, to consider the subject and examine his papers.] When you were at New Orleans, were not letters addressed to other persons frequently brought to you from the post-office; by whose orders were they delivered to you; were they opened and with what view? [Mr. Hay thought that they had no right to ask such a question. It might be important between gen. W. and the government, or between any other person and gen. Wilkinson. But it does not appear to be proper to interrogate him as to his conduct any where, unless it has some bearing on the cause; nor can a witness be asked any question, the answering of which might subject him to a prosecution. If we introduced evidence on that point, they had a right to cross-examine him. Mr. Wickham. We may suppose, without impeaching the credit of Gen. Wilkinson, that he will give us as favourable an account of his conduct, as any man standing in his situation may be disposed to do. Gen. Wilkinson has detailed a number of facts to account for the conduct of col. Burr. He has taken very strong ground. We wish to show that the general has the strongest possible motive to criminate Col. Burr. We were permitted to ask him, about sending officers in disguise to seize col. Burr. We wish now to prove some other seizures. This evidence has a direct referrence to the case of col. Burr. If gen. Wilkinson took all these measures it will surely have a tendency to weaken his testimony. Mr. Martin. We mean to show that gen. Wilkinson is identified with the government; and that the government had declared they would justify him. We have a witness to prove the express declarations of the secretary at war, that gen. Wilkinson stood low with the government till his energetick measures at New-Orleans had raised him in the estimation of the President. They can only justify his acts by shewing an impropriety in the conduct of col. Burr.
The more we shew that the constitution has been trampled on and the rights of the citizens invaded, the more they will endeavour to shew the impropriety of the conduct of col. Burr, in order to justify it. Mr. Hay. Mr. Martin has avowed the motives of col. Burr's counsel to be to identify Gen. Wilkinson with the government. Admitting that Gen. Dearbourn had made the declarations ascribed to him; admitting that the President had formed that opinion of gen. Wilkinson, how can his answer to the question propounded have any bearing on this case. Suppose gen. Wilkinson should say that in consequence of the expected arrival of Burr, the agitated state of the country, and a knowledge that he was surrounded by the accomplices and partizans of Burr in New-Orleans, he had taken letters from the post-office (and he would only say he had done what he ought,) how could it affect the present case. It is manifest that the answer of gen. Wilkinson must leave the question between the United States and col. Burr, exactly where it was before. Mr. Wickham. When these questions were asked Mr. Murray before, they were thought proper, and he was even cross examined by the counsel for the prosecution. The gentlemen have ascribed to col. Burr improper acts—Now to impeach gen. Wilkinson's credibility, we show that he has been guilty of violent acts. Is he not interested to show the conduct of col. Burr to be improper, in order to justify his own? Mr. Baker. Suppose, says Mr. Hay, this
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 19 October 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
General Wilkinson is questioned about guards near New Orleans and his early warnings of war with Spain, producing letters and a convention with Spanish commandants as evidence. Defense counsel Martin and Wickham argue the government must produce all papers relevant to Burr's defense, while prosecutor Hay objects to reading documents tied to foreign negotiations.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
propriety, the circumstances in which I am placed will excuse me.—Here are all the papers relative to that convention. (Gen. Wilkinson produced a number of letters containing the correspondence between him and the Spanish commandants about the time the troops of that nation re-crossed the Sabine. Mr. Martin said, they wished to have the papers, and hoped the court would have no objection. The Chief Justice observed, that he had no objection, but wished it to be distinctly understood that he would not coerce the production of any paper which related to a negotiation between this country and any foreign government.
See moreSee less
Mr. Martin said, that would depend upon circumstances. He held it a sacred principle that if the government thought proper to prosecute a citizen, they were bound to produce every paper which might be necessary for his defence, or give up the prosecution. Mr. Hay thought it would be improper to read the papers; because they related to a negotiation with a foreign government and because they had no relation to the subject before the court. Gen. Wilkinson had, indeed, from the insinuations which had been made, been induced to produce those
General Wilkinson testifies about translated Spanish correspondence and a disputed convention, insisting on accuracy before publication. He is cross-examined by defense counsel Wickham about his role in seizing Swartwout, Bollman, Ogden, and Adair, and hedges on whether he received government orders regarding Burr's arrest.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
papers; but it was evidently done with a considerable degree of embarrassment; and would not justify the reading of them, if it were otherwise improper. Mr. Wickham. I have asked for the convention with the Spanish commandant, but am told that it is a state secret. I concur with Mr. Martin, that when an individual is prosecuted by the government, no state secrets should prevent the production of every paper necessary for his defence.
—Gen. Wilkinson said he wished it to be understood that these were very imperfect translations of the letters from the original Spanish, and therefore, that he could not deliver them but under the stipulation that they should be accurately translated before publication; as he had discovered gov. Cordero and gov. Herrara to be officers of polished education, from his correspondence with them. He had made this stipulation as a duty which military men owe to one another throughout the world. These letters contain the convention; a convention without an article. [The Chief Justice said that he would not compel the production of the convention unless its bearing on the case be shewn. Mr. Martin. We have a right to it—I hope it will be noted that we have made a solemn demand of these papers.]—Gen. Wilkinson proceeded. The next question which was asked was, whether I had not made private communications to lieut. Jones; but if I had, here are documents to shew if not a justification of my conduct in all the measures I presumed, at least an extenuation. [Here gen. Wilkinson presented several papers shewing the agitated state of New Orleans and the dangers with which it was threatened. They were not read. See notes O, P. Q. R.]
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham to gen. Wilkinson. Do you recollect the last question I put to you? has your conduct in seizing Swartwout, Bollman, Ogden and Adair been approved or disapproved by the government; and have you received any communications from the government on this subject? Gen. Wilkinson said he must refer to his honour to know whether he was bound to answer that question.—[The Chief Justice declared that it might be answered under the restrictions already laid down.] Gen. Wilkinson. I can say that three of these persons, perhaps four, were seized on my own responsibility, without any orders from the government. Mr. Wickham. Which three? A. Bollman, Swartwout, Ogden, and perhaps Adair. Mr. Wickham. Had you any orders then, or afterwards to seize them; had you any orders with respect to the seizure of col. Burr by military force? A. No; not at that time. Q. Had you afterwards? Gen. Wilkinson. That is a question of very great delicacy with me. (Addressing the judge) can a question be fairly put and an answer coerced which may destroy a man's honour? [Mr. Wickham said there was no rule of law which prevented a witness from giving an answer unless it subjected him to a criminal prosecution. Mere sympathies were no cause of refusal. However unpleasant these questions might be to gen. Wilkinson, it would be a shameful dereliction of duty in the counsel of col. Burr not to put them. He said that he had not experienced any sympathies towards his client.] Gen. Wilkinson to the Judge. Is a trial before a court martial similar to a criminal prosecution? I might be subjected to military punishment, to as severe punishment as could be inflicted by a civil tribunal for revealing my orders. The Chief Justice said that he was not sure that gen. Wilkinson could be required to answer that question. [Mr. Wickham conceived that there could be no articles of war which could punish a man for disclosing what he is called upon to declare in a court of justice. The court had a right to require the disclosure, and would enforce its own au-
General Wilkinson testifies under cross-examination by defense counsel Wickham, admitting he was mistaken in claiming he had a presidential order to seize Burr, clarifying the order actually came from the secretary of war. The defense presses for production of a letter from the president that might reveal more about Wilkinson's communications.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FRIDAY, October 2.
Mr. Wickham called on gen. Wilkinson to produce the president's letter approving his measures. Gen. Wilkinson. By referring to my papers, I discover I have made a mistake, I find I have no orders from the president, directing the seizure of col. Burr—the order is from the secretary of war and has been already published, directing me to seize
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel Martin and Burr demand production of a letter from Jefferson referencing communications from General Wilkinson, arguing it may be material to the defense. Prosecutor Hay resists full disclosure, questioning its relevance, while debate continues over whether courts can compel government document production.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 19 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
merely. Mr. Wickham then applied for the production of this letter. It might be important to col. Burr in this point of view. Gen. Wilkinson sends on certain communications by Mr. Briggs, and in this letter, the president acknowledges the receipt of them. So that by referring to that letter, it was easy to know what were the communications made to the president by gen. Wilkinson. Mr. Martin. We have a right to demand this letter. Chief Justice. It is easy to read the passage, which refers to the two letters and Mr.
See moreSee less
Brigs's communications. Mr. Martin proposed to put the letter into the hands of the Chief Justice, who might mark such passages as he might think improper to be read. Gen. Wilkinson. The letter is in the hands of the attorney for the United States. Mr. Hay. If the court will state those subjects, to which the letter should relate to have any bearing on this case, I am ready to produce such passages. Mr. Burr observed, that he knew of but one ground on which a publick document should be withheld from a court of justice, which was, that it might contain something relative to foreign negotiations, actually pending, and the publick good required its concealment. But in the present case, the transactions referred to in the letter might have passed over ; a letter too, which is not a publick document, but a private communication. Mr. Martin. No government ever dared to suppress information, which was necessary to an individual against whom it had commenced a prosecution. There never was such an attempt to establish a new principle, as is done on the present occasion. Mr. Hay. Mr. Martin asserts that there never was such an instance as the present, and that we are attempting to establish principles altogether new. I do not, sir, attempt to establish new principles : I do aver my confident opinion, that this paper does
This passage records courtroom dialogue during Aaron Burr's treason trial, with defense counsel Mr. Wickham cross-examining General Wilkinson about letters he wrote to Burr in 1805-1806. Wilkinson claims poor recollection of specific contents, though he admits to expressing opinions about potential war with Spain and offers to produce his correspondence.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Chief Justice. Would general Wilkinson be subjected to an action for sending to apprehend colonel Burr, unless he had been seized?
Mr. Hay. It may go to criminate him as a military man. He may have acted without orders.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. I do not presume that he acted without orders; but under the orders of government.
The Chief Justice said, that he could not perceive the application of the evidence—but as evidence was introduced to shew the flight of colonel Burr from Washington this, he presumed, was intended to account for it.)
Mr. Wickham. Will you state the names of the officers sent to apprehend col. Burr? A Captain Hook, lieutenant Peter, lieut. Mulford, doctor Davidson, of the army, and doctor Carmichael of the Mississipp, Territory.
Mr. Wickham. Did you direct them to go without uniform? A I believe I did.
Mr. Wickham. Did you direct them to conceal the object of their mission? A I feel great delicacy in revealing my orders.
This passage records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson being cross-examined by defense counsel Wickham regarding his communications with Spanish commander Cordero and troop movements near the Sabine River. The questioning also probes a secret convention with Spain, whether money changed hands, and letters sent to the President that were submitted to the Grand Jury.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ing by their right intersected the highway from Natchitoches to Nacogdoches, about 20 miles in my front, pursued that route, and re-crossed the Sabine about the 29th or 30th.
Mr. Wickham. Was this after you had received the cyphered letter? A No. It was some time before.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. Had you any correspondence with the Spanish commandant, on the subject of col. Burr's expedition against Mexico? None. The earliest communications which I made on that subject were after my return to Natchez.
Mr. Wickham. Had the jurisdiction of the U. S ever been exercised as far as the Sabine? A I cannot tell.
Mr. Wickham. Was it in consequence of instructions from the government that you concluded the convention with the
Defense counsel Wickham cross-examines General Wilkinson at Burr's treason trial about sending disguised officers to apprehend Colonel Burr. Wilkinson reveals he dispatched Captain Hook, Lt. Peter, Lt. Mulford, and two doctors without uniforms, while a related military order document is also reprinted.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
examined for the purposes avowed by the opposite counsel.
Mr. Wickham. Do you recollect that you did write to colonel Burr in 1806? A I have before stated that I have such an impression; but I have no recollection of the contents of any communication made to him, although I remember the motive which induced me to write.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. You have no recollection of any particular expression? A No. Except a letter of October or November 1805—6 Q Have you no recollection of any expression or sentiment expressed in your letter of 1806? A I have no recollection. Q. Was it your expression that we should have a war with Spain? A It was my opinion, and there was a very general impression that we should have a war with that power. Do you recollect writing any thing respecting the measures of the government in relation to a war with Spain? Have you no recollection of any opinion expressed in a letter to col. Burr? A I do not recollect having expressed any opinion respecting the measures of the government. The only expression of which I have any idea is one used in a letter of October or November 1805, in which I believe I say. "I fear Miranda has taken the bread out of our mouths."
Mr. Wickham. There were others published from you while in the neighborhood of the Spaniards. Have you copies of these letters here? I have the whole correspondence.
Mr. Wickham. We only want the letters of September & October, which state that war with Spain was inevitable.
Gen. Wilkinson. I think I may have said so, and I believe I have some papers here
This passage records courtroom testimony, likely from General James Wilkinson, detailing military orders given to apprehend Aaron Burr and transport him to Washington via New Orleans. The questioning covers written instructions, the involvement of various officers like Lieutenant Jones and Commodore Shaw, and the chain of command regarding Burr's seizure near Natchez.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
those orders. He said that they had a right to impeach the credibility of the witness, but not to compel him to disclose the orders given to those under his command.]
Q Where those orders to seize col. Burr wherever they could find him? A They were sent on that service expressly. I think the orders were confined to Natchez; information having been received that col. Burr had taken up his quarters there. Q Were there any orders to seize him even in court? A I cannot say but presume
This passage records courtroom debate during Burr's trial over whether witnesses could be questioned about General Wilkinson's actions, including intercepted mail and seizures of Burr's associates. Lawyers dispute the relevance and propriety of such questions, with discussion of Wilkinson's credibility and his relationship to the government's case against Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 20 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
in disguise to seize col Burr; we wish now to prove some other seizures. This evidence has a direct reference to the case of col. Burr. If gen. Wilkinson took all these measures, it will surely have a tendency to weaken his testimony.
Mr. Martin We mean to shew that general Wilkinson is identified with the government, and the government had declared that they would justify him. We have a witness to prove the express declarations of the secretary at war, that general
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel Martin and Wickham argue that withheld portions of General Wilkinson's letter to President Jefferson should be disclosed, since Wilkinson himself produced it before the grand jury. Chief Justice Marshall declines to compel production without evidence of relevance, while Burr insists on his right to know what was said against him before the grand jury.
The Enquirer · 20 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
man to the Mr. Jefferson, as not to abuse him. Remember that the life and liberty of col. Burr are shown to be no longer dependant on Virginians: and therefore I am freed from any restraint, in declaring what I think. If Mr. Jefferson himself was here, would not this court call him before it, and make him disclose upon oath, the contents of that letter? Suppose, sir, that in this letter gen. Wilkinson has denounced Governor Claiborne and Cowles Meade; suppose that he has represented all the people of New-Orleans as disaffected; suppose that he has attempted to throw every influential man but himself under the suspicions of the government, in order that he may raise himself into favour; is this a satisfactory reason why this letter should be respected or withheld? Mr. Burr repeated that this letter had been laid before the grand jury; that it was therefore no longer a state secret; and that he had a right to ask for any thing which gen. Wilkinson had showed or said to the grand jury. Chief Jus. After such a certificate from the President of the U. S. as has been received, I cannot direct the production of those parts of the letter, without sufficient evidence of their being relevant to the present prosecution. I should suppose, however, that the same source, which informed you of the existence of this paper, might inform you of the particular way in which it was relevant.
Mr. Burr. In such a case I ask no man's opinion, but my own.
See moreSee less
Ch. Justice. I cannot assist you.
Mr. Burr. Have not I a right to ask what any one said before the grand jury?
Mr. Wickham read certain parts of the extracted and furnished copy, to show that from the context of those parts, the omitted passages bore directly on the subject.—The President of the U. States might have had proper reasons on account of gen. Wilkinson, to withhold those parts, but gen. Wilkinson himself has no right to withhold them; and if he produced the whole letter before the grand jury for the sake of criminating col. Burr, he may certainly be called upon to lay it before this court.
Gen. Wilkinson begged leave to correct the expression of the gentleman about his motives. He did not produce this letter before the grand jury to criminate col. Burr, but to vindicate himself. Mr. Wickham. That is the very thing which I say. Why did he wish to vindicate himself, but to give greater effect to his crimination of col. Burr? Gen. Wilkinson begged leave to state another consideration. When he
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, an argument arose over whether testimony before the grand jury had been given in confidence, with Burr protesting that his counsel's concerns about secrecy had been betrayed. The passage also records cross-examination of General Wilkinson by Burr regarding orders to seize Peter Alston and Davis Floyd and to search descending boats on the Mississippi.
The Enquirer · 20 October 1807 · page 2
the grand jury unheard ; and appea'ed to Mr. Tazvvel! for what he knew on this fuhjcCt. Mr. iiurr. They have no right to introduce a wit iiel's now, when w,e hare one under examinati on. Mr. fVirt fuppofed, tllat when the grand jury was thus charged by the accufcd or his counfeljr they had a right to appear in vindi cation of their own conduit. Mr. Burr. That
This passage reports courtroom examination of a witness during Aaron Burr's treason trial, detailing cross-examination by McRae, Wickham, and Burr himself about General Wilkinson's defensive measures and the panic in New Orleans in December and January. The witness describes rumors of an English fleet near the Mississippi mouth and a printer's account of armed men and gunboats on the Cumberland River allegedly meant for Burr's command.
The Enquirer · 20 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
A There were. Mr Wickham. I should suppose then, that gen. Wilkinson might have easily judged from that circumstance, of the correctness of the rumours which were circulated about col. Burr. Mr. McRae. State, sir, what you know of these transactions? A. The alarm at New-Orleans in December and January was very considerable. We did not know when the enemy would advance upon us. There was an apprehension of an attack by sea, and I was then authorised to purchase a large ship, to be stationed at the Balize. The gun-boats which had been ordered to enter Lake Ponchartain, were commanded to take a different position.
See moreSee less
Some time after, there was a report, that a fleet under English colours were actually cruizing off the mouth of the Mississippi, and this encreased the alarm. Mr. Burr. Was it a fact or not, that this fleet was there? A I do not know. Such was the report and it was brought up by a packet which comes up weekly from the Balize. It was not said to be a fleet of merchantmen but of ships of war. The report was, I believe, on the compting-house books. Mr. Bradford, the printer, also made a communication to me on the 6th of January, which produced a considerable effect. He informed me that he had spent some time in the city of Washington and Philadelphia; and from Philadelphia he had travelled to Pittsburg; and from thence proceeded to New-Orleans; that he had seen a number of men under arms at the mouth of Cumberland river; two gun-boats building, which the men at work on board told him would be delivered up by col. Lyon to col. Burr; besides a
General Wilkinson resumes testimony in the Burr treason case, addressing questions about expected hostilities with Spain, troop movements, and a Spanish convention. He references his own letters from September and October 1806 to support his account of the timeline.
Virginia Argus · 20 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
THURSDAY, October 1. Gen. Wilkinson's testimony continued.
See moreSee less
General Wilkinson was about to explain more fully some of the interrogatories put to him at his last examination—when he was interrupted by Mr Wickham, who declared that he felt no disposition to interfere with the explanations of the witness, but was very anxious to go on with the cause. With respect to the motives with which any act was done, he knew nothing and cared nothing. The Chief Justice declared that gen. Wilkinson had a right to explain interrgatories ; and again repeated the substance of the opinion which he had before given. Gen Wilkinson proceeded. I have been asked whether in October 1806, I did not expect immediate hostilities with the Spaniards ? I was required to account for the cause of the sudden change of position of the Spanish army ? I was interrogated as to the convention
General Wilkinson testifies about Spanish correspondence translations, the Neutral Ground convention, and his role in the arrests of Swartwout, Bollman, Ogden, and Adair. He hedges on whether the government approved his conduct and whether he had orders to seize Burr by military force.
Virginia Argus · 20 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
unless its bearing on the case be shewn.— Mr Martin. We have a right to it—I hope it will be noted that we have made a solemn demand of these papers] General Wilkinson proceeded. The next question which was asked was, whether I had not made private communications to lieutenant Jones. I have said that I gave no orders to lieutenant Jones; but if I had, here are documents to shew if not a justification of my conduct in all the measures I pursued, at least an extenuation. [Here general Wilkinson presented several papers shewing the agitated state of New-
Two witnesses, Capt. John Shaw and William Tharp, swear before a judge about an encounter with Judge Prevost in January 1807, who informed them General Adair (Burr's second-in-command) had arrived and that Burr himself would follow within days. The deposition also describes Prevost's hostile remarks toward the government and includes a separate letter warning of military action against New Orleans.
Virginia Argus · 20 October 1807 · page 2
" *>**>* CTJ a \vr JI ux »'•• Kilbsr one ‘lie pistir.f* >'f til'* |KfHCO for the City and ’’nrish of Npw*( Menus, ! J bn C.tpt .in in the U. States N.-.vv, and Wdli.itn Tharp. I'.scj. wuo til - ing first dnlv sw. ir i on the Holy hvmijjeliw of Almighty (i '.|, d«rl »re and say, that on or about the fifteenth daof J i unary last, 18or, p tssing from the Cottee-llouse, about the hour of 1? oM >ck at noon, they were accosted opposite the principal by Judge l’rcv.st of this place, who observed that he was hippy to inform these deponents, that General Adair, the second in command to Col.
See moreSee less
Burr, had arrived in town and was then at Madam Nouruge’s, that he hud just waited on him, or had seen the man who h ‘.d created so much stir, who said Col. Burr would be in town in three days, after
Two sworn affidavits are reprinted describing private conversations in which Luther Martin, Burr's attorney, allegedly predicted the Western states would separate from the Union and that Burr would become Emperor of Louisiana. The introduction mocks Martin as a notorious gossip unfit to be trusted with secrets.
Virginia Argus · 20 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FROM THE BALTIMORE AMERICAN
District of Maryland, viz. Philip Graybell, of lawful age, residing in the city of Baltimore, maketh oath on the Holy Evangelists of Almighty God, that some time during the summer of 1806, he this deponent, was standing at his store door in Market street, in the said city, & Luther Martin came up and addressed himself to this deponent, to the following effect: That Aaron Burr was to divide this country, and that the Allegany Mountain would be the divisional line. (Signed) PHILIP GRAYBELL.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers
During Burr's treason trial, General Wilkinson objects to Major Bruff's testimony, claiming it stems from personal animosity rather than relevant facts. Bruff testifies about early 1805 newspaper hints and information from Captain Stoddard suggesting a connection between Wilkinson and Burr regarding plans involving Louisiana.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
...tency in his testimony he must hear him. Major Bruff proceeded : My testimony will arise from a number of conversations with gen. Wilkinson. In four of these conversations gen. Wilkinson took me aside ; in three of which he locked me up in his room. The first hint I had of a connexion between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr was drawn from two paragraphs in Kentucky newspapers, in the spring 1805, before gen. W. reached St. Louis ; the first alluded to the old plan to form a separate government west of the Allegany, and ascribed it to gen.
See moreSee less
Wilkinson and his associates, and doubting whether that scheme had yet been abandoned. The next was an extract of a letter from Fort Massac, published in the papers, which stated that col. Burr had been several days there with gen. Wilkinson, probably giving the General lessons on government, or digesting a new code or constitution for the government of Louisiana.--These hints, with information received from capt. Stoddard immediately from Fort Massac, and who assured me that col. Burr had been there several days closely engaged with gen. Wilkinson, and that he had or was about to furnish him with a barge and crew, in which he was to descend the Mississippi to New-Orleans, [Mr. Wirt. You have not said when. A. In June, 1805.] These circumstances put me on my guard, and determined me to watch the motions of gen. Wilkinson and Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 21 November 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
A witness testifies at Burr's treason trial about early disputes with General Wilkinson, including a heated exchange over regional loyalties and a reprimand for questioning the army's campsite location. The testimony also touches on Judge Easton's claims that Burr sought an experienced officer for an expedition to Santa Fe.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
luck to be brought young to Maryland, of which state my father, grand father, and great grand father were natives—born in Jersey! (replied the general,) a second cousin to a yankee, a damned cunning fellow I suspect—This was the first rude thing he had said to me; for before this, I was treated with respect, and had received many friendly letters from him; I therefore attributed this to my declining to join him in his scheme to make fortunes: some time after the troops moved to Cold Water, an officer informed me that they were encamped on a low damp bottom, subject to be overflowed.
See moreSee less
[Mr. Hay objected to the course of the testimony pursued by the witness; col. Burr said that he did not know the whole extent of his testimony, but that he had been introduced to shew palpable contradictions in the evidence of general Wilkinson.] The Missouri on the one side and a marsh or bog on the other and
A witness describes Burr's reception by General Wilkinson in St. Louis, including a dinner, an honor guard barge, and later gossip about a 'Western empire' scheme. The testimony also recounts conversations with Eaton suggesting Wilkinson and Burr had a secret connection that later soured.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
tary notions. Mr. Wirt. At Cold Water? A. Yes, at Cold Water and christened after Belle Fontaine. Mr. Wirt. How far from St. Louis? A. Twelve or fourteen miles. Mr. Martin. When col. Burr was there how was he treated? A. The general made a dinner, it was understood for col. Burr—I was invited, the colonel did not attend; but was said to be sick—when col. Burr was leaving St. Louis, I was about to cross the river to my plantation on the opposide side, his baggage was brought to the ferry boat, when I saw the general's barge getting ready with colours and a complete crew in uniform. I afterwards saw the colonel pass my farm on his journey, in company with Dr. Browne only; Easton was not with him.]
Some time after col. Burr left St. Louis, general Wilkinson and Mr. Easton fell out. And often talked in a dark mysterious manner about a Western empire. Captain Stoddard also hinted to me after his return from Fort Massac, that some great scheme was in agitation between col. Burr and general Wilkinson, but did not say what. Eaton positively stated that there was a connection between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr. He complained that the General persecuted him, I observed that it was very strange that he should be the common friend of col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, and yet they should misunderstand one another about him; that I rather suspected the General finding him unpopular with the French, and that he would not answer their purpose, had pursuaded col. Burr to shake him off. Easton replied, that col. Burr was in his power and that he dared not treat him in a deceitful manner. I replied that I did not know col. Burr, but that his enemies represented him as an artful intriguer. Some time afterwards Mr. Easton came to me and observed that he believed my conjectures about col. Burr were true—and that he was to be made a sacrifice of; that he should go on to the seat of government and try what he could do for himself. Easton was then a judge appointed by the president, but not confirmed by the Senate and he was apprehensive it would not, that gen. Wilkinson was using his influence to prevent the confirmation—But observed, col. Burr was much in his power, for that he had made him proposals which made the hair rise upon his head, astonished and confounded him so that he was struck dumb. [Gen. Wilkinson. Were these his very words? A. Yes.] That col. Burr observing this would have retracted but it was too late. I urged him to explain the nature of the proposals. He said he was under an obligation of secrecy; but no obligation should hold him if he found col. Burr false to him. I observed that he well knew that any obligation which lead him to conceal or commit a crime could not be binding. He observed he was going to the seat of government and should see col. Burr, and then he should take his measures. I saw Easton after his return. I urged him to explain the business which he had mentioned before; but he pretended to have forgot that such a conversation had ever passed between us. [Mr. Hay. Was his appointment confirmed? A. No. He had lost his appointment and had seen col. Burr.] About this time a paper called the Western World made its appearance, one of which was I believe directed to the General weekly. [Mr. Hay. After the return of Easton? A. Yes. It roundly accused gen. Wilkinson of the old plan, of being concerned with Miranda and connected with col. Burr. I observed to Easton that I believed I should get the whole story from the Western World without being under any obligations to him; that if he had done his duty he might have saved himself and his country and perhaps prevented the effusion of blood. He observed that he had once attempted to make a disclosure to government, but instead of being countenanced he got a reprimand. I demanded the instance, he said he had wrote to a senator in congress either from Vermont or New York, that he could prove gen. Wilkinson to be the projector of Miranda's expedition. The gentleman acknowledged the receipt of his letter, but informed him he had burnt it, advised him to mind his own business and take care how he meddled with men high in power and office. Mr. Martin. Had gen. Wilkinson any conversation with you with respect to the appointment of a certain John Smith of Louisiana. A. I had a conversation with him about John Smith. I remember going into the General's office when he handed me two letters, one from major Hunt the civil and military commandant, and the other from Smith who complained that the commandant had ordered him off the mineral lands—The General censured the order and asked me if I knew who John Smith was. I replied no, but had been informed he had been one of Cox's captains—so major Hunt insidiously observes, replies the General—but that does not lessen him in my esteem. He added that Smith was brother in-law to Mr. Early a member of congress who had bro't forward a resolution to reduce the army and dispense with his services as General; that there were many of his stamp in congress—therefore they must be attended to and kept in good humour, or we shall be turned to the right about. Mr. Martin. Did you appear before the Secretary at war in order to make a statement as to the conduct of gen. Wilkinson which you considered indangered the United States, and what was his reply? Mr. Hay objected to the question as it had no relation to the subject. Mr. Wickham said that gen. Wilkinson had been interrogated by them and required to say whether his conduct was approved or disapproved by the government; that the government had taken the most active part in this prosecution and it was right and proper that the sentiments of the government should be known. The Chief Justice said the difference is this. The evidence of gen. Wilkinson arose from communications officially made directly from the government. This is a different case—The evidence here offered consists of conversations with the officers of the government. Mr. Martin said that the Secretary at War was applied to in his official character; and in his official character he said that gen. Wilkinson must and would be supported; that he stood low in the estimation of government before his energetick measures at New-Orleans, but now he stood very high. Mr. Hay was about to make some observations in opposition to the introduction of such evidence, when general Wilkinson consented that the witness should go on.]
See moreSee less
In March 1807, a few days before the rising of congress, I was in the city of Washington, and waited on the secretary of war, and the subject which gave rise to this visit and conversation between the secretary at war, the attorney general and myself, was an appeal from the sentence of a general court martial, whose proceedings I contend-
General Wilkinson cross-examines Major Bruff regarding prior statements about Burr's guilt, Wilkinson's dual offices, and land dealings with Judge Easton. Bruff confirms he believed Burr was involved in the expedition with Wilkinson and discusses the circumstances of his subpoena and conversations with Mr. Martin.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 21 October 1807 · page 3
expected that he would1 have made the disclosure without my saying that I wished him to make my fortune. 1 did not intend to come under any obli gation or to commit myself. Q. When was the first time that you made any communications to the go vernment or any of its officers, with respect to those projects ? A. 1 have a letter here dated Janu ary 8, 1806, in which I say: “ I have no confi dence in the patriotism of geuera! Wilkinson, and as a man 1 think of him with hotrur.” Mr.
See moreSee less
Wirt. To whom is that letter addressed ? A. To the se cretary at war. Gen. Wilkinson. Were you unde# arrest at that time ? A. No. I was not—(looking at his papers.) It does not appear from this letter that 1 was under arrest at that time. Mr. Hay. I want to know thej'act, whether you were under arrest or not. A. I was not. Q. What was the interval be tween your arrest and the trial by the court martial ? A. I believe 8 or 10 days, but ] am not certain.— Mr. McRae. Had you not been in expectation of an arrest? A. 1 hud expected it for some time. In a conversation with the general, about my saying that he would not be in service six months, he got very warm, and said “ this is sedition.” I replied then arrest me. Mr. Hay. At what time did this conversation take place about Cold Water, when you stated in your evidence, your ruin was decided on? A. I think in September 1805. Then com menced a system of persecution, which terminated in my arrest. I was dforged among other things with contempt to the’grtieral ; that-1 never denied. 1 was not guilty of all the other charges except that one. Major Brulf then said that the sentence of the court martial had been disannulled by the presi dent of the Uuited States, and his pay and emolu ments, which had been suspended, by the sentence, restored. [Gen. Wilkinson. I understood thatwas by stipulation : what is the date of the president’s reversal ? A. believe it was on the 12th March last, and my pay and emoluments being restored, is equi valent to a reversal,] Maj. Brulf proceeded—the secretary at war observed that the president was disposed to do me justice ; but it was a delicate point, and there was no precedent where a sentence had been confirmed by the commander in chief, and afterwards reversed by the president. I answered that I thought it was not very delicate in General Wilkinson to approve a sentence when it was a mere personal thing between us. I understood that it was about the 1.5th November when the expedition was to have commenced, and the Mexican stand ard, (an emblem of the sun), to have been raised. This delayed my departure from St. Louis. 1 ex pected to have seen knights of the sun, and buds of Mexico, among the chiefs of those chosen spi rits. Mr. Martin. Whose property is the place called told water ? A. I understand the greater part be longs to gen. Wilkinson. About four acres of which is deeded to the United Slates for a factory. He ■wrote on to me to purchase such a place. It was about this place, that geu. Wilkinson made the rude attack upon me which I have before mentioned: but i believe the true source was, that I had said to au officer in the confidence of gen. Wilkinson, that he would not be in office six months. I knew that congress was about to meet, and that it was contrary to the genius of our government that he should hold two offices of General and Govcrnour of Louisiana. General Wilkinson. When did you receive the first intimation of myintention to letire from ser vice ? A. This is intimated in a letter from the Ge neral, dated April 5, ] 805. Did I not reiterate this intention after 1 came to St. Louis. A. 1 believe vou did. Gen. Wilkinson. Do you recollect at what period after I got to St. Louis, whether late or early ? A. I can not recollect. Vou often mentioned the subject. Gen. Wilkinson. Were you subpeened to attend this place ? A. 1 was. I saw a subpoena in the bunds of a gentleman for me ; and Mr. Martin had told me in Baltimore that there was one ordered, and Vtherefore I considered myself as subpoened from Queen Anne's county, in Maryland. Gen. Wilkin son. Then you had a conference with Mr. Martin ? A. I bad. Gen. Wilkinson. Do you recollect to have said that you were reluctant to come, but Mr. Martin had promised to lash me into tortures ? A. I have said that from a conversation with Mr. Mar tin, I had reason to believe that your letter to col. Burr “ post marked 13th of May,” would be pro duced ; but that I should have come in any event. The first intimation I had of this letter was from a letter written by a gentleman of the grand jury to a Iriend of mine, stricturing the testimony of Gen. Wilkinson given before that body. That part of the letter was confidently read to me. [Major Bruff was about to state a conversation with Mr. Martin, when he was interrupted by col. Burr, who said that he could not consent to a nar ration of the conversations which might have been held with his counsel.] Gtn. Wilkinson. Bid you not say that you thought Burr was guilty ; but that I bud done you a serious injury, and you thought this a good time to seek redress? A. I have said that I believed col. Burr concerned in tliat expedition with you. I have said so, and I think so still. Mr. M’Rae. Will you state the character of Judge Easton? A. I have accused him of an endeavour to swindle tne out of half the laud we purchased in common, on which an arbitration is now depending. Gtn. Wilkinson. Had you no land speculations with Easton? A. N'o. 1 I rad no speculations; but we made u purchase of a single tract of land together. Perhaps you call that htnu speculations. Gen. Wil kinson. V ou said that when col. Burr arrived at St. Louis, Easton and myself were intimate ?—Ma jor Bruff. I thought so. Gen. Wilkinson. Did you not know that about that time 1 did not sulier him to come into my house? A. 1 heard him sav af ter col. Burr had left St. Louis some little time, that you were persecuting him.
This report reproduces part of William Wirt's courtroom argument in Burr's treason trial, comparing his eloquence to famous orators like Erskine and Curran. It characterizes Burr as the restless, ambitious author and prime mover of the conspiracy, who recruited followers across the continent by appealing to their various desires for adventure, titles, or wealth.
The Wheeling Repository · 22 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
BURR AND BLENNERHASSET.
[Mr. Wirt, in his argument against the point laid down by Burr's counsel, that Burr not having been present at the assemblage on Blennerhassett's island in December last, could only have been an accessory, draws the following characters of these two FAMOUS persons.—A New-York editor, speaking of this extract from Mr. Wirt's speech, says: "Those familiar with the eloquence of the late Lord Chancellor of England, and of the celebrated Curran, will immediately recognize the resemblance, and may possibly think with us, that the American Barrister does not suffer in the comparison with either."]
See moreSee less
.....WHO then is Aaron Burr, and what the part which he has borne in this
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · and 2 other papers
The report covers a court day in Burr's trial where an adjournment was requested due to Mr. Wirt's child's illness and General Wilkinson's wish to respond to damaging witness testimony. Burr opposed the adjournment, noting his own counsel had received no such accommodation, but the Chief Justice granted it after hearing testimony from grand jury members Brockenbrough and Cabell.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF COL. BURR.
WEDNESDAY, Oct. 7.
See moreSee less
Mr. McRae requested, that on account of the extreme indisposition of one of Mr. Wirt's children, which prevented him from attending, the court might be adjourned till to morrow. Independently of this circumstance, gen. Wilkinson, whose feelings had been severely wounded by the testimony of a witness yesterday, was in the course of preparation to remove those unjust imputations. He hoped that no objection would be made to the adjournment. Mr. Hay said, that by an arrangement of the counsel for the United States, the principal part of the reply would devolve upon Mr. Wirt. It was therefore important that he should be present, to know what ground had been occupied by the counsel who preceded him. He did not expect any inconvenience would result from the proposed adjournment; and hoped it would not be opposed. The adjournment was opposed by col. Burr, who stated that one of his counsel had been placed in the same situation as Mr. Wirt, and no indulgence was asked of the court on that account. He also mentioned that the court had, at his own request, proceeded with the examination when he was too much indisposed to attend—The Chief Justice, after hearing an explanation from major Bruff, about that part of his testimony respecting his daily attendance for orders and going through the examination of John Brockenbrough and Joseph C. Cabell, esquires, two of the members of the grand jury, adjourned till to morrow.
Major Bruff, begged leave to correct an errour in part of his evidence given yesterday, in a point not material. This respected his attendance at the office of gen. Wilkinson every day. After his remark about Cold Water, and his saying that should he discover plans and measures which put to hazard the peace and safety of the United States, he would not keep silence be the consequence what it might. Gen. Wilkinson was not visible to him for several days. Other officers attended, said major Bruff, but I was not permitted to his presence. I wrote to the General; and I received an answer which I have not here. It however stated that I should receive such attention as my conduct and rank entitled me to.
John Brockenbrough and Joseph C. Cabell, members of the grand jury, were called by col. Burr.
Col. Burr. I will ask you both, gentlemen, whether gen. Wilkinson, before the grand jury, acknowledged that in any of his letters he had used the words, "he was ready?" Mr. Brockenbrough. I recollect that gen. Wilkinson acknowledged that, in the winter 1805—6, he had written to you several letters, in one of which he used the expression "what has become of the grand expedition. I fear "Miranda has taken the bread out of your mouth, "I shall be ready before you." He also assigned as a reason for writing such a letter, that he had done it with a view of drawing from you a full diclosure of your project: if it should be correct and patriotick, that he might unite in it; if improper that he might reject it. I asked gen. Wilkinson whether he had written the letter "post-marked 13th of May." He said that he did not recollect. Col. Burr. What period was assigned to that letter containing the expressions just quoted? A. The winter of 1805—6.
Mr. Cabell being requested by col. Burr to state his recollection of the evidence of gen. Wilkinson as to the points above mentioned, proceeded in substance as follows—Gen. Wilkinson had stated, that he had had an interview with you at St. Louis, at which you mentioned a grand project; but that you did not enter into particulars. He remarked that he had made some enquiries as to the nature of the enterprize; but you observed it was unnecessary to enter into particulars, for it was possible it might never be carried into effect. After col. Burr left St. Louis, gen. Wilkinson remarked that he had revolved in his mind the conversation which had passed between him and col. Burr, when he spoke of a western enterprize; and concluded that an attack on Mexico was contemplated, which was to be carried on by the aid of a British fleet through the gulph of Mexico—That he had written several letters or notes to col. Burr, with a view to ascertain his real design, between the time of their interview at St. Louis, and the commencement of the following summer; but did not appear to be positive as to the number or nature of those letters. But he remarked, that his object was to draw from col. Burr a disclosure of the nature of the enterprize; if it were proper that he might participate in it; if not, that he might communicate the information to the government. Gen. Wilkinson on being interrogated as to the contents of his letters, said he could not recollect precisely their terms, and but only two expressions which he had used in one of them; "I fear Miranda has taken the bread out of "your mouth; I shall be ready for the grand enter "prize before you are." I must repeat that gen. Wilkinson did not appear to be positive as to the nature of the number of those letters; but only as to these two expressions.
With respect to the letter "post marked 13th May," gen. Wilkinson on being interrogated, was not positive whether he had written it; but said he believed it had.
Mr. Wickham. Do you recollect whether gen. Wilkinson produced a copy which he said was a true copy of the cyphered letter? A. I do not recollect. I recollect gen. Wilkinson tendered a copy. Mr. Wickham to Mr. Brockenbrough. Do you recollect whether gen. Wilkinson produced any fair copy of the cyphered letter to the grand jury? A. I recollect that we had a newspaper in which it was published; and as we decyphered the original,
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 6 November 1807 · an extract
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 4 December 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
General Wilkinson addresses the court to rebut insinuations made by Major Bruff linking him to Burr's schemes, explaining his procurement of the Louisiana governorship and his prior acquaintance with Burr. He describes a conversation in which Burr stated his intention to visit New Orleans after leaving the vice-presidency.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ly, intentionally and deliberately by Major Bruff; and his explanations could not be so well understood unless he heard, in some instances, resort to argument.] The General resumed.—When I was first brought before the court, it was my intention to have commenced with Mr. Burr at Washington and to have traced him step by step from his passage of the mountains until his return—But I was confined to such facts as were deemed immediately relevant to the question before the court, and therefore I commenced with the reception of his letter at Nachitoches.
See moreSee less
I now, sir, find myself obliged to adopt this course in order to explain certain observations, which have come from the grand jurors, and also inuendoes and insinuations of the witness major Bruff; who having charged me with a sinister connexion with Mr. Burr, has travelled from Washington to St. Louis to find matter for justification of the imputation—He has laid some stress on the interest which he says was made (by Mr. Burr and his friends) to procure me the government of Louisiana. I am under no obligation to explain how I procured that government; if I were, I could say it had been tendered to me by the president, two months before they had any idea of the circumstance. I am charged with having invited col. Burr to the western country—Herein I have been misunderstood, for the thing was not so—A few days after col. Burr descended from the vice-presidential chair, an inquiry was made by me, as to the course he intended to pursue, he told me he intended to visit New-Orleans, and I remember his very words were, "I have a few thousand dollars left and I will not go to work until they are spent." I was solicitous to see him reinstated in the councils of his country, and speaking to the hon. John Fowler then a member of congress on the subject, he informed me that Mr. M. Lyon had suggested the idea of Burr's going to Tennessee, to procure his election to a seat in congress, as residence was not a necessary qualification to election in that state, and requested me to speak to Burr on the subject; I did so, and I think he said it was a luminous idea, appeared to be delighted with the plan, and in concert with Mr. Fowler and Mr. Lyon, I then understood and have since been assured by the former, who is now in town, the plan was digested without my presence or participation at any interview. Mr. Burr soon after proceeded to Philadelphia; he wrote me on the 26th March, requesting a letter of introduction to gen. Adair and informing me he should set out for the western country about the 10th of April. The next letter I received from him was at Pittsburgh, dated the 30th of April, in which he tells me he should sail that day for the lower country and is sorry he could not see me. At Louisville I received a third letter from him dated the 19th May, in which he deeply regrets he could not see me there, and begs me to forward the letters of introduction I had promised him for New Orleans, after him to that city. He proceeded from Louisville to Frankfort, and I am authorised to say did there apply to John Brown, Esq. to aid him in his proposed election in Tennessee and to that end requested letters from Mr. Brown to his friends there. He then proceeded to Nashville, where it appears he remained beyond his calculation. I fell down the river to Massac, where col. Burr arrived on the 8th of June, and instead of spending several days...
This passage records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson being cross-examined by Mr. Wickham about his communications with Burr and Swartwout, including letters discussing plans involving Spain and national concerns. Wilkinson explains his shifting confidence in Burr's intentions and discusses a postscript about engaging associates' patriotism in case of war with Spain.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Swartwout from whence col. Burr derived his funds. He said, from the aid of friends and the sale of property; in which sale he had been employed. I knew that col. B.
The court examines testimony from witnesses including Commodore Decatur, General Eaton, and Commodore Truxton about Burr's stated plans to invade Mexico or separate the Western states, contingent on war with Spain. The opinion also discusses the significance of a cyphered letter sent via couriers Bollman and Swartwout to General Wilkinson, understood to relate to a military expedition against a foreign territory.
The Enquirer · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Spain? The conversation held by col. Burr with Commodore Decatur, stated his object to be an expedition against Mexico, which would be undertaken, as the Commodore understood, with the approbation of government in the event of war. To general Eaton, he unfolded in various conversations, plans for invading Mexico and also for severing the Western from the Atlantic States. To Commodore Truxton he spoke of the invasion and conquest of Mexico in the event of a war, as a plan which he had digested in concert with general Wilkinson, and into which he was extremely desirous to draw the Commodore.
See moreSee less
A circumstance is narrated by this witness which has been noticed by the counsel for the United States, and deserves consideration. It is the declaration of col. Burr that he was about to dispatch two couriers with letters to general Wilkinson relative to the expedition. It was at this time that Messrs. Bollman and Swartwout are said to have left Philadelphia, carrying each a copy of the cyphered letter which has constituted so important a document in the various motions that have been made on this occasion. This letter, though expressed in terms of some ambiguity, has been understood by the supreme court and is understood by me to relate to a military expedition against the territories of a foreign Prince. In this sense, the testimony offered on the part of the United States, shows it to have been also understood by Bollman, by Swartwout, and by general Wilkinson. The inference is very strong, that this letter is the same to which col. Burr allud
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 26 October 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · 30 October 1807
The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va. · 19 November 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
This report records part of Chief Justice Marshall's legal opinion during Burr's trial, analyzing English doctrine on levying war and conspiracy to commit treason. He concludes that witnesses from the Cumberland Island assemblage testified they suspected nothing hostile and would not have acted against the United States, undermining the prosecution's case.
The Enquirer · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
United States to establish a general design to dismember the union, applies only to col. Burr and Mr. Blennerhassett. It is not proved to have been ever communicated even to Tyler or Floyd. There is not only a failure to prove that such a design was communicated to or entertained by the men who were assembled at the mouth of Cumberland, but the contrary is in full evidence. The United States have adduced several witnesses belonging to that assemblage who concur in declaring that they heard nothing, that they suspected nothing, and that they would have executed nothing hostile to the U.
See moreSee less
States. This testimony cannot be disregarded for it is uncontradicted and is offered by the prosecution. How then can this assemblage be said to have levied war against the U. States? Had Burr and Blennerhassett constituted this meeting, no man could have construed it into
This report records courtroom testimony from the Burr treason trial, focusing on questioning of a witness named Mr. Tazewell about inconsistencies in General Wilkinson's testimony. The witness states he observed no contradiction between Wilkinson's testimony before the judge and before the grand jury, though he questions why Wilkinson invited Burr to the Western country.
The Enquirer · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
[i]mpossible for us to take down.
SATURDAY, Oct. 3.
See moreSee less
Mr. Tazewell was again called by col. Burr, and asked whether he had observed any inconsistency in the evidence of Gen. Wilkinson. Mr. Tazewell said
Witnesses are questioned about inconsistencies between General Wilkinson's testimony and that given to the grand jury, particularly regarding how Swartwout delivered a ciphered letter from Burr. Another witness, Matthew Flui, testifies about meeting a man named Dunbaugh at Baton Rouge who claimed to have escaped custody and sought a pardon from Wilkinson.
The Enquirer · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Cushing, which was spoken of by both of them, Mr. Swartwout slipped into his hand the cyphered letter from Col. Burr. Mr. Swartwout who discovered the utmost frankness and candor in his evidence, stated the transaction in a different manner. He declared that the letter was delivered openly, without any effort to conceal it. Mr. Hay. But they both stated the fact to be the same that it was delivered in the absence of Col. Cushing? A. Yes. They both stated that fact in the same way. I would not be willing to be understood that I doubted any thing, Mr.
See moreSee less
Swartwout said. Altho' he appeared before the grand jury under very unfavorable circumstances, and my impressions were very strong against him; yet the very frank and candid manner in which he gave his testimony, I must confess, raised him very high in my estimation, and induced me to form a very different opinion of him, from that which I had before entertained. [illegible]
A witness is cross-examined about letters, boats, and goods sold to Aaron Burr during his journey down the Mississippi. The testimony covers details of cargo, travel companions, and encounters with Burr at various points including New Orleans and Washington in the Mississippi Territory.
The Enquirer · 23 October 1807 · page 3
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.
The report records continued testimony of General Wilkinson in the Burr treason proceedings, as defense counsel Mr. Wickham presses him on the exact dates he met with Swartwout and why he delayed informing the government. Wilkinson explains his caution in gathering information and defends apparent inconsistencies between his letter to the President and his courtroom testimony.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
THURSDAY, October 1. Gen. Wilkinson's testimony continued. Mr Wickham. You mentioned that Swartwout was with you about the first of October? General Wilkinson. I think about the
Defense attorney Wickham questions General Wilkinson about his shifting beliefs regarding Burr's intentions and the authenticity of a postscript in Wilkinson's letter. Wilkinson admits uncertainty about the postscript's origin and explains his suspicions about Burr's foreign backing and lack of personal funds.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
kinson. I wish you to understand me. When I contemplated the audacity, the iniquity and the folly of the enterprize, I did believe that Colonel Burr was stimulated by some foreign power. With respect to revolutionizing the territory, I could not place any solid confidence in it, until I received the communication of James L. Donaldson, esq.; when combining all the circumstances I wrote my letter of the 12th of November. Mr Wickham. Then I understand you to say that this was the true state of your mind at that time?
See moreSee less
Gen. Wilkinson. Yes. Propounding this question brings to my recollection a subject not thought of before. I enquired of Mr Swartwout from whence Colonel Burr derived his funds. He said, from the aid of friends, and the sale of property; in which sale he had been employed. I knew that Colonel
General Wilkinson is questioned by defense counsel Wickham and Randolph about a postscript to Burr's cipher letter, which suggested winning over Spanish-sympathizing citizens to the American cause. Wilkinson admits uncertainty about whether the postscript was part of the original letter but maintains it reflects his feelings at the time.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
at the measure. Mr Wickham. This postscript on the letter: "Should Spain be disposed to war seriously with us, might not some plan be adopted to correct the destination of the associates, and by a suitable appeal to their patriotism, engage them in the service of their country? I merely offer the suggestion as a possible expedient to prevent the horrors of a civil contest. And I do believe that with competent authority I could accomplish the object." Am I to understand that the postscript contains the true state of your mind at that time?
See moreSee less
A. There is some uncertainty whether that postscript is a part of the original letter. It is noted on the corner in my own hand writing, and not in that of Mr Burling, who was then one of my aids-de-camp, and by whom the copy was made. [Mr Baker. It never was understood that a copy would be received by Colonel Burr. Now we see the necessity of having the original.] General Wilkinson I have no sort of hesitation to state what my feelings were. If the Spaniards had been seriously disposed to war, I did believe that by a suitable appeal to the feelings and patriotism of the deluded citizens who might have descended with Colonel Burr, they would have been induced to join our standard, and oppose a foreign enemy sooner than enter into a conflict with their own countrymen. My idea was this, that the President should have forwarded to me blank commissions to be
The piece criticizes Chief Justice Marshall's legal reasoning in blocking certain testimony during Burr's treason trial, accusing him of judicial overreach and favoritism toward the defense. It argues Burr's counsel used procedural delays to suppress evidence rather than prove innocence, and disputes Marshall's view that corroborative testimony cannot establish the overt act.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
sonable cause for removal.
Burr's counsel set out at the commencement of the trial, with strong declarations of innocence, but in no instance, have they attempted to prove that innocence. All their quibbling has been contrived to prevent evidence proving him guilty, that he might escape negatively. They have labored to waste time by continually interrupting the progress of trial, and to weary out the patience of the witnesses on the part of the prosecution that they might go away without giving their evidence; and the court has so far countenanced the views of Burr and his counsel that it was not till after Mr. Hay declared he would adjourn to the Washington Tavern and take the testimony there, that the court permitted the testimony to go on—Marshall then saw it best to pull in his horns as Kenyon had done. But it would perhaps have been better had Mr. Hay done as he proposed and laid the whole matter before congress.
See moreSee less
The opinion of Mr. Marshall, that corroborative or subsequent testimony cannot prove the overt act upon Burr is not well founded. The absence of Burr from Blennerhasset's island while the assemblage of troops were going on, might be, and very probably was, a contrived designed thing to avoid being present lest he should be apprehended in the very act; and if such testimony had come forward, and Mr. Marshall could not know it would not, will Mr. Marshall say it would not connect Burr immediately with the overt act of raising and assembling troops, which no individual
This opinion piece criticizes Chief Justice Marshall's ruling that corroborative testimony cannot prove the overt act against Burr, suggesting Marshall may be biased or even complicit given rumors that judges supported Burr. The writer links this to broader accusations that Federalist judges, appointed by Adams, sought to undermine the republican government.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
has the right of doing without the authority of the government. If he says it would not, then I tell him his law is not common sense and that it is law of his own making.
Why is Mr Marshall so unwilling that testimony should come forward? Is he afraid he may be implicated himself? According to evidence, Burr had given out that government was privy to his proceedings and approved them. He may also have said that the Chief Justice approved them. We know that Gaylord Griswold in his letter to Mr Hathway, in speaking of some former conduct or misconduct of Burr, said, "the judges of the supreme "court are with Burr," and Mr Marshall
A witness named Power describes being subpoenaed to testify at Aaron Burr's trial, objecting on procedural grounds and citing his duty to the Spanish crown as reasons to avoid answering questions about correspondence and his relationship with General Wilkinson. Burr and the prosecution press him on his objections, with Power invoking the honor of his office rather than a formal oath as his binding obligation.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
objected to receiving the subpoena, saying that it was irregular and illegal, first, because no writ could be served on a Sunday, and secondly, because it ought to have come through the hands of the Marshal of the district. I soon found that my objections were nugatory. I had heard that several others had been subpoenaed, and were excused from attending by giving their affidavits. I offered to do the same, and to declare that I was totally ignorant of Burr's plans.
Those objections of mine were not admitted; nor would my affidavit be received. On my expressing a reluctance to attend, I was given to understand, by the agent of Col. Burr, that by the same authority which was exercised on Knox last winter and by which he was put on board a ship and confined with malefactors, I should be treated in the same way. This, I confess, had more weight with me than all his logic. [Col. Burr. Are you about to object to answering the question? A. I am, Sir.] I believe it is a fact too generally known that for several years prior to running the boundary line between the U. States and the Spanish provinces, I was employed as an agent for my government. [Mr. Hay. Are you going to answer the question as to the correspondence? A. I am about to shew my situation to be so delicate, that I cannot consistently with honor answer it, nor can I answer any question which may operate against the King my master.] Col. Burr. Had you any mercantile connexion with Gen. Wilkinson? A. I had not.
See moreSee less
Col. Burr said that he did not think there had been any pretext offered which would justify an evasion of the question.
Mr. Power. What would be the amount of the deposition of a man, who in the very act of deposing, was breaking his most sacred engagements, and pronouncing himself a purged villain.
Col. Burr. Are you under the obligation of an oath, as to the transaction? A. I
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, a witness named Mr. Power refuses to answer questions on grounds of honor and loyalty to the King of Spain, despite pressure from prosecutor Wickham who argues no one is exempt from testifying in court. The Chief Justice rules the question must be answered, but Power insists his honor is more important than even Burr's life, while Burr's defense team also contends with disputed depositions being offered as evidence.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
was not a valid one.
Mr Power. I have already said that when the interest of the king my master is implicated, I will not answer. The court may take what measures it pleases. (Addressing Colonel Burr) Place yourself in my situation, Col. Burr; put your hand upon your own bosom, and say what you would do yourself.
See moreSee less
Mr Martin, (in a plaintive tone of voice,) begged Mr Power to recollect that the life of a man was at stake; a man who was prosecuted with rigor by his own government. He must recollect the importance and necessity of calling in the aid of all the evidence which can be procured to exempt him from unmerited punishment.
Mr Power. I feel full well the situation of Col. Burr. But I have more at stake than Col. Burr. I have my honor, my reputation, which are more dear to me than life or property. What would my family, my children, do with property, if these were violated?
Mr Wickham said he would not press the answer at that time, nor apply to the court to take the necessary measures to enforce it; but would give Mr Power a few hours to reflect. He will be expected to attend here at 3 o'clock, at which time the same question will be repeated.
Mr Power attended a little before 3 o'clock, and remained for several minutes after. But Mr Wirt being then in the midst of his argument, he was not called till after he had left the court room. He was again introduced on Monday.
[Colonel Burr offered to read the depositions of Messrs. Mercier and Derbigny.
This report covers courtroom arguments over admitting depositions from absent witnesses (Mercer, Delaigny, Stoddart) in Burr's trial, with debate over whether excuses for non-attendance were valid. It also details continued examination of witness Power, who refused to disclose details of a correspondence between General Wilkinson and the Baron de Carondelet, with the Chief Justice ruling on the relevance of such testimony to Wilkinson's credibility.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
pressive. The counsel for Colonel Burr contended that there was a wide difference between the case of Mr. Stoddart and that of those witnesses.
A territorial attorney general describes advising that Burr be sent to Washington for trial since the Mississippi court lacked original jurisdiction over treason charges. He also recounts moving to discharge a grand jury of 28 jurors after Judge Rodney convened one anyway, citing insufficient evidence and lack of proper jurisdiction.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
(Continued from first page.)
menced before judge Rodney. A committee of five gentlemen, as well as I recollect, was appointed to examine the boats, who proceeded up the river for that purpose, and I believe made their report to the executive.
See moreSee less
I was then called on in my official capacity, as attorney general, to give a written opinion as to the course which ought to be pursued with col. Burr. I did so, and that opinion, I believe, was filed in the office of the secretary of the Mississippi Territory. My opinion was, that he had no evidence to convict col. Burr of any offence in the Mississippi Territory—that the supreme court
A witness recounts the Mississippi Territory court proceedings where he moved to discharge the grand jury against Burr, which was overruled, and describes the jury's controversial presentments against the governor and Burr's subsequent disappearance. The testimony is given under cross-examination during Burr's treason trial in Richmond, including questions about military men sent to seize Burr.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
day. At a meeting of the court the next morning, I moved to discharge the grand jury; 1. Because the court did not possess original jurisdiction in any case. 2 Because the depositions, submitted to my inspection did not furnish sufficient evidence to convict col. Burr of the offences with which he was charged, so as to bring them within the Mississippi Territory. 3. That a warrant might issue, transmitting the accused to a court, having competent jurisdiction, to try and punish him, if guilty of the crimes alledged against him. The court being divided, on this motion, it was overruled. The grand jury then retired. I determined to prefer no indictment, and left the court. In the evening while I was engaged in the Legislature, a message was sent to me by the court, requesting my attendance. I immediately repaired to the court-room, and was desired to look at the presentments of the grand jury. I perused them, and found that the grand jury, had presented the acting governor for calling out the militia—the manner in which col. Burr, had surrendered to the civil authority--the proceedings at Orleans; and I believe, the general government itself, did not escape. I felt, and declared my astonishment at such unwarrantable proceedings, and informed the court that I should take no further notice of the presentments, and retired. Judge Rodney, I believe likewise, censured the conduct of the grand jury; it may be proper to mention, that a respectable proportion of the jury withheld their signatures from those presentments. Col. Burr, that evening, went to the house of col. Osmun, and disappeared. I afterwards attended the court, and had a judgement nisi entered on the recognizance given by Burr, and his securities, Lyman Huding and Banijah Osmun; a scire facias was issued and served on the securities which is now depending before the supreme court of the Mississippi Territory. What happened after col. Burr withdrew, I know not except from hearsay.
Cross-Examined.
See moreSee less
Question by Mr Martin. Have you a copy of the recognizance said to have been entered into by col Burr? A I have not, but have seen a copy in the hands of Mr Hay.
This passage records courtroom testimony during Burr's treason trial, detailing cross-examination about a recognizance bond, the judges involved, and attempts by military men sent by Gen. Wilkinson to seize Burr. A dispute arises over whether the recognizance document is authentic, with defense counsel Martin alleging forgery.
Virginia Argus · 23 October 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Q Were you present when it was executed? A No.
Mr Martin. You said that the judges ordered 76 jurors to be summoned—Who were the judges? A Bruin and Rodney. Mr Wickham. Do you know any thing of military men sent from New Orleans, to seize col Burr? A I understood that there were, and that Dr Carmichael, who resides in the Miss. Ter. was one. Mr Wickham. Was there an expectation in that part of the country that Gen Wilkinson had sent men for that purpose, and that Col Burr would be seized? A It was talked of and generally disapproved. Q Where was Col Burr at the time of his entering into the convention on the west side of the Mississippi? A He was in the territory of Orleans, and, in pursuance of his agreement came over to the Miss. Ter. Mr Wickham. Did not Col Burr seem to be apprehensive of military force? A He did not, except that he was particularly unwilling to fall into the hands of Gen Wilkinson. He enquired of Col Fitzpatrick, Maj Shields and myself, whether there was any pass or way above Natchez through which he could get to Ouachita, and wished to know whether there was any person who could be employed to pilot him. We gave him no satisfactory answer on that subject. My own impression was that he wanted to establish himself on the Ouachita, as a place of rendezvous to which his men might rally. Mr Wickham. Have you understood that an officer of the army was sent by Gen Wilkinson to take Col Burr? A I heard a lieutenant of the army (but I had rather not mention his name) say that he was one of the persons employed for that purpose.
See moreSee less
Here Mr Hay offered to read the recognizance entered into by Col Burr in the Mississippi territory. Mr Martin objected to its being read and declared it a forgery. He said he was willing to answer the consequences to judge Rodney, and to give it under his hand that it was a forgery. Mr Hay. Judge Rodney is so near Mr Martin that you can answer for it with perfect safety.
Mr Poindexter. Mr Harding, one of the securities in the recognizance, said that the recognizance returned by judge Rodney was not the one entered into by Col Burr, Mr Osmun and himself. But I do not think it was believed by one honest man in the territory.
Mr Hay. Did the paper to which this is an authentic copy, bear any mark of erazure? Not that I recollect. It was in the usual form in which judge Rodney took other recognizances; that the person bound should attend from day to day until discharged by the court. The recognizances of
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
The report covers legal arguments at Burr's trial over whether Blennerhassett must first be convicted as principal before Burr can be tried as accessory. It includes an extract from prosecutor William Wirt's courtroom speech dramatically characterizing Burr as the restless, ambitious mastermind of the conspiracy and Blennerhassett as a quiet literary exile drawn into his scheme.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 23 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
EXTRACT.
"Who then is Aaron Burr and what the part which he has borne in this transaction? He is its author; its projector; its active executor. Bold, ardent, restless and aspiring, his brain conceived it; his hand brought it into action.—Beginning his operations in New-York he associates with him men whose wealth
General Wilkinson testifies under cross-examination by Mr. Wickham about letters exchanged with Aaron Burr, including one he destroyed after it was sent to Natchez. Wilkinson describes receiving information from Donaldson and Michael that raised suspicions of Burr's 'sinister designs' and a conspiracy.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 24 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
[illegible], you got that information from
Swartwout. Q Did you write? A I did.
See moreSee less
Q What did you do with the letter? A
Destroyed it. Q Did it go out of your
hands? A It did. It was sent to Natchez, to which place I followed recovered and destroyed it. I will give you my
reasons for doing so. After writing, I received the letter from Mr. Donaldson, dated the 30th October, and conveying the information received from Myers Michael, which removed my doubts as to the extent
This passage records courtroom examination testimony regarding General Wilkinson's military posts between Pittsburgh and New Orleans, and witness accounts of Aaron Burr's presence at Chickasaw Bluffs during his descent down the river in January 1807. Witnesses describe interactions between Burr, Colonel officers, and local factors including disputes over supplies and lead shot.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 24 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
at the time of col Burr's descent down the river. On the 4th of January 1807, lieut. Jacob Jackson came to the United States' Factory at fort Pickering, accompanied by a gentleman, who he introduced to Thos. Peterkin, United States' factor, Peter Morgan and myself clerks to the said factory, as col. Aaron Burr. After some conversation Col. Burr and Lieut. Jack...
A witness describes Burr's dealings at the island garrison and factory, including purchases of lead, tomahawks, and bear skins, and private conversations with his men. The passage then shifts to cross-examination of General Wilkinson by defense counsel Wickham regarding the origin and timing of the cipher allegedly used in correspondence with Burr.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 24 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
goods and he would pay for them. Col. B. was frequently at the factory in the course of the day, and often had conversations with Mr. Peterkin.
In the evening Mr. Peterkin, Mr. Morgan and myself, went to the garrison where we found col. Burr. I took notice that colonel Burr was frequently called to the door by the men that had arrived in the boats, to have private conversation with him. Lieutenant Jackson asked Col Burr when Mr. Blennerhassett would be there? To which col. Burr replied he was then floating by and could not land his boat. In the morning colonel Burr came to the factory and demanded a bill for the articles which his men had got the day before. This bill was made out amounting to sixty or seventy dollars, which he paid. The only articles which I can remember were the lead, three dozen tomhawks, and three bear skins. After paying the bill col Burr departed and I saw him no more.
See moreSee less
Cross Examined.
Mr. Burr. What kind of tomhawks were these; were they intended for war or more peaceable purposes? A. They were such as were generally used for shingling.
Mr. McRae. Would they do well for fighting? A They would answer very well.
Mr. Wickham to Gen. Wilkinson, after his return to court. Can you ascertain when the hieroglyphic cypher was made? A The arbitrary characters I think were designed in 1794; but I do not say it was given to col. Burr at that time.——Mr.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
At the Richmond circuit court, Mr. Hay finished the opening argument for the United States, followed by Mr. Randolph for Burr's defense. Proceedings were delayed by Mr. Wirt's illness, with Mr. Martin continuing arguments the following Monday.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 26 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CIRCUIT COURT.
RICHMOND, Oct. 9.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay finished his speech, which opened the argument on the part of the United States, and was followed by Mr. Randolph on the side of Col. Burr.
Saturday, Oct. 10,—Mr. Wirt being very much indisposed and unable to attend the court, nothing was done on this day. Mr. Martin was to have continued the argument; but he consented to postpone it until Monday.
Monday, Oct. 12.—Mr. Martin is now engaged in a speech which probably will occupy the whole day. We understand Mr. Wirt is to answer him.
A judge's opinion details testimony about sixty to one hundred men gathering at the mouth of the Cumberland River in December 1806, where Burr addressed them but postponed revealing his full purpose. The account notes the men behaved peaceably, carried ambiguous supplies, and claimed to be settlers bound for the Red River, though circumstances raised suspicion.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ed by some as somewhat circular, to receive col. Burr, who was introduced to them, and who said that he had intended to impart something to them, or that he had intended to communicate to them his views, but that reasons of his own had induced him to postpone this communication; or as others say, that there were then too many byestanders to admit of a communication of his objects.
The men assembled at the mouth of Cumberland appear to have considered col. Burr as their chief. Whatever might be the point, towards which th[e]
The report details courtroom testimony and conversations suggesting Burr's plans to dismember the union and invade Mexico, including communications with Blennerhassett, the Hendersons, and General Wilkinson. It discusses the authenticity of a ciphered letter linking Burr to Wilkinson and assesses its evidentiary weight in the ongoing trial.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
...gainst their Atlantick brethren. That the object of these writings was to prepare the western states for a dismemberment is apparent on the face of them, and was frequently avowed by himself. In a conversation with the Messrs. Hendersons, which derives additional importance from the solemnity with which his communications were made, he laid open a plan for dismembering the union under the auspices of Mr. Burr. To others at subsequent times, he spoke of the invasion of Mexico as the particular object to which the preparations then making were directed. In all those whom he sought to engage in the expedition, the idea was excited that though the Ouchita was its avowed object, it covered something more splendid, and the allusions to Mexico when not directed were scarcely to be misunderstood.
The language of Comfort Tyler also tends to prove that the enterprize was destined against Mexico.
See moreSee less
The communications made to general Wilkinson deserve much consideration in marking the real intention of the parties, because it is obvious that col. Burr, whether with or without reason, calculated on his co-operation with the army which he commanded, and that on his co-operation, the execution of his plan greatly, if not absolutely depended. To general Wilkinson, both the cyphered letter and the explanations made by Bollman and Swartwout, declared the expedition to be military and to be intended against Mexico.
I do not think the authenticity of this letter can now be questioned. When to the circumstances enumerated by the counsel on the part of the United States, are added the testimony of Mr. Swartwout, and its being written in a cypher previously established between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr, I think it sufficiently proved at least for the present, although not in the hand writing of the person to whom it is ascribed.
The conversation stated by gen. Wilkinson as passing between Mr. Swartwout and himself, so far as it is contradicted by that gentleman, cannot affect Mr. Burr for this plain reason; the person alledged to have made those declarations avers not only that he never made them, but that he was never authorised to make them; that he never heard from Mr. Burr any sentiment indicating designs against any part of the United States, and never even suspected him of such designs. If then gen. Wilkinson be correct, I must consider the observations he narrates, as the conjectures of Mr. Swartwout, not authorised by Mr. Burr.
A legal opinion, likely part of the Burr treason trial proceedings, argues that the gathering at Blennerhassett's Island does not meet the legal definition of levying war since no overt hostile act was committed and participants claimed no treasonous intent. The writer distinguishes this case from the historical precedent of the Earl of Essex, reasoning that intent alone, without an overt act, cannot constitute treason under the Constitution.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 26 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
in the nature of conspiracy than of actual war.
Suppose Mr. Burr had at the mouth of Cumberland declared his object to seize upon New-Orleans and dismember the union; and that upon this declaration, his men had universally abandoned him
The writer describes accompanying officials to locate Aaron Burr along the Mississippi River, seeking information and urging his peaceful surrender to civil authorities. Burr reportedly denied any intent to harm U.S. citizens and accused General Wilkinson of betraying him, threatening to expose him via his papers.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 26 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
to whom major Shields handed a letter, of which he was the bearer from Mr. Meade, acquainting col. Burr with the object of our visit. In the letter there was a sentence relating to the restoration of tranquility in the territory, which sentence Burr repeated once or twice with a sneer, adding, that "he had no intention to injure the citizens of the United States." Col. Burr then expressed himself to this effect: "As to any projects or plans which may have been formed between general Wilkinson and myself heretofore, they are now completely frustrated by the perfidious conduct of Wilkinson, and the world must pronounce him a perfidious villain" Burr also, in speaking of Wilkinson, said "if
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
President Jefferson's message to Congress recounts the 1806 Burr conspiracy, crediting the militia, army, and General Wilkinson with defeating it on the Sabine and Mississippi. He promises to submit the evidence from the Virginia treason trial so Congress can judge whether the law, testimony, or its administration failed to secure conviction.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 27 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
exertions.
I informed Congress, at their last session, of the enterprizes against the public peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and his associates, of the measures taken to defeat them, and to bring the of-
Courtroom testimony from Aaron Burr's treason examination includes witness statements about events at Natchez and questioning of General Wilkinson regarding presidential authorization for Burr's seizure. Wilkinson admits he misunderstood a letter and had no specific presidential order directing Burr's arrest.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 27 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Gen. Wilkinson. By referring to my papers, I discover I have made a mistake, I find I have no orders from the president, directing the seizure of col. Burr—The order is from the secretary of war and has been already published, directing me to seize the principals of the enterprize. I did believe I had an order from the president specifically directing the arrest of col. Burr——The mistake arose from my misapprehension of the tenor of a letter from the president of Feb. which blends public communications with private affairs.
Mr. Wickham. Have you no letter from the secretary of war approving your conduct in general terms? A I never had such letter from him. The approval of my conduct is expressed in qualified terms.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. You wrote the president about these transactions, was the letter to which you referred an answer to these communications? A That letter in its public relation merely acknowledges the receipt of two letters from me, and the arrival of a confidential messenger I sent to the president. It gives some directions,
The report records courtroom examination of a witness (Judge Todd) during Aaron Burr's trial, with Burr himself questioning the witness about the Bastrop land grant title papers and General Wilkinson's reputation. The witness describes alarm in Kentucky over reports of boats and provisions being prepared, and discusses unfavorable opinions about Wilkinson's official conduct.
The Enquirer · 27 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR.
Examination of Evidence.
JUDGE TODD.
See moreSee less
Colonel Burr. Did Colonel Lynch submit to you, for your opinion the title papers of Baftrop's grant? A. Col. Lynch shewed me the title papers on which he said the grant was founded. Col. Burr. Did he say any thing about my having acquired an interest in it? A. No. Col. Burr. Did you give any opinion as to the title? A. I was not sufficiently informed of the laws of the territory to give any decided opinion. I discovered the grant was founded on a condition which it was said had not been complied with, and I was rather inclined to doubt its validity. Col Burr. Were you in Kentucky during the summer of the last year? A. I was. Col. Burr. Was there a good deal of alarm among the people? A. There was. Col. Burr. Was that owing to any acts which I had done? A. [illegible]
A witness testifies about letters from General Wilkinson inviting him to join a cavalry expedition against Spanish colonies in Mexico, and about a burned letter from Burr inviting him to meet at Bayou Pierre. The witness explains he destroyed Burr's letter out of fear of arrest for merely carrying it.
The Enquirer · 27 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
to the Choctaw nation. Q. And when did your office cease? A. I was removed by the President in 1802. Q. Did you not recieve a letter from col. Burr through the had of Lieut. Jackson. A. I did. Q. Where is that letter? A.
A witness is cross-examined at Aaron Burr's treason trial about the drafting and recording of a deed for Ouachita land, and payments made to Colonel Lynch for the purchase. The testimony also touches on widespread talk of impending war with Spain and willingness among young men in Kentucky to join such a conflict.
The Enquirer · 27 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
war? A There was a great deal. Q Were not expeditions against the Spanish territories a very common topic? A. The Spanish was frequently mentioned at musters. War was considered as inevitable; and it was said to be so stated in letters from the commander in chief on the Sabine. Mr Burr. Was there not a general ardor on the subject, especially among the
Witnesses testify in Burr's treason trial about the Bastrop land grant, its acreage, and the Spanish/Baton Rouge claims, with cross-examination by Burr and prosecutors Wirt and McRae. Testimony also covers Burr's discussions of a potential Mexican expedition in case of war with Spain and his land purchase arrangements with Col. Charles Lynch.
The Enquirer · 27 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
On whom were the drafts on New-York drawn? A On George M. Ogden.
Mr Burr. Had we any conversations about a Mexican expedition? A Yes; frequently: and frequently he spoke about a Spanish war. He spoke several times on this subject to me and others. He thought, if there was any war with Spain, that it was the interest of the U. S. to carry an expedition into Mexico; He said, that he himself would willingly engage, and asked me, whether men could be got in Kentucky to embark in it. I told him, I thought they could.
See moreSee less
Mr Hay. Did you make any contract with col Burr for flour? A He said, that he expected to settle the Ouachita land, and in the event of a war, he would stipulate with his men to go against the Spaniards; and that then he would take from me any quantity of flour, not exceeding two boat loads.
A witness is cross-examined by Aaron Burr and prosecutor McRae about the sale of land interests in the Bastrop grant, including payments, a compromise with Livingston, and the validity of the land title. The testimony details financial arrangements, drafts drawn on Mr. Ogden, and opinions on the grant's legality from legal counsel.
The Enquirer · 27 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Stephen Wartz. I found that Edvard Livingston had also purchased the same mortgage. I commenced a writ against Morehouse. I was about to commence one against Livingston, but I purchased him out. Under that compromise I was entitled to about seven hundred thousand acres. The survey was made and marked upon the grant. I was entitled to six tenths and he to four tenths of the whole grant of twelve hundred thousand acres. Mr Burr. Was it a separate or joint interest of mine? A A joint interest. Mr Burr. Was I to settle what you owed to Livingston?
See moreSee less
A That was my object in selling. Mr Hay. Had you a suit with Livingston? A No I was about to commence a suit, but we compromised. I agreed to give him thirty thousand dollars for his interest. Then I sued Morehouse. Col Burr was to pay Livingston the amount of my purchase of him; he also paid me four or five thousand dollars in money, and was to take up certain paper which I valued at thirty thousand dollars more. Mr. McRae. Did you receive any drafts from col. Burr? A Yes O On whom were they drawn? A On Mr. Ogden of New-York. Mr McRae. Had you any grant conveying an absolute title? A In 1796, the petition was presented by Bastrop; in 1797, Bastrop was to furnish 500 families, the government to find them in provisions for six months: but it being inconvenient to the government to furnish the provisions, a letter of office was given to Bastrop by the Baron de Carondolet, to dispense with the necessity of introducing the families. Q Will you state the various proceedings which have taken place on this grant? A First, there was the petition, then the survey, upon that the patent, and then the letter of office. Mr. Burr Did
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
At the circuit court hearing on Burr's commitment, General Wilkinson's testimony continues and Burr demands the full November 12 letter be produced in court. Defense counsel Luther Martin clashes with prosecutor Hay over whether President Jefferson can dictate what evidence is relevant, sharply criticizing Jefferson's legal competence and motives.
Virginia Argus · 27 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
FRIDAY, October 2. Gen. Wilkinson's testimony continued.
See moreSee less
Mr Wickham demanded the production of the whole letter of the 12th of November. General Wilkinson, did you lay it before the grand jury? A. I did.
Mr Burr. The entire letter has been used against me before the grand jury. All idea of state secrets is therefore at an end; and there can be no objection to produce the whole of it in court. I shall expect that General Wilkinson will bring the whole of it into court to-morrow. Mr Hay.
During Burr's treason trial, the court debates whether grand jurors can testify after proceedings, with the Chief Justice ruling on the legal effect of changes to the secrecy oath. Mr. Tazewell then testifies about the cyphers used in correspondence, including dates and origins of the alphabetical and hieroglyphic codes discussed before the grand jury.
Virginia Argus · 27 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
tive to reserving their objection to Mr. Tazewell's testimony, Mr Burr said that gentlemen might submit to his testimony with a protestando—the Chief Justice again stated, that the original policy of the institution which presented the oath of secrecy being changed, the testimony he supposed must be heard, and
Mr. Tazewell was then sworn.
See moreSee less
Mr Burr. Can you state the questions you put to gen Wilkinson in the grand-jury, and his answer?
The writer argues that General Wilkinson never agreed to any treasonable proposal from Burr and remained loyal to the United States throughout his military service. It explains Wilkinson's invitation to Burr as innocent, noting that at the time Burr still had many supporters and had not yet become a declared enemy of the Union.
Virginia Argus · 27 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The whole evidence (which might remove every difficulty,) is not before the public, and therefore unknown to the writer of these observations, who is not in the secrets of Wilkinson or Burr, and cares nothing for either; except so far as the good of his country is concerned; but he cannot refrain from declaring that enough has appeared to satisfy his mind that general Wilkinson never did assent to any proposal of colonel Burr to engage in a treasonable or unlawful enterprize; that he never in any respect deviated from his duty, as a patriot, and his honor, as an officer in the service of the U. States.
His having invited Aaron Burr to the Western country, is a ground of suspicion with some, and may require explanation. It is capable, however, of an easy solution, without supposing any impropriety in his conduct. At the time when that invitation took place, colonel Burr had not yet lost the esteem of all his former friends; he had not yet become an avowed enemy of the union of the states, and of the liberty and happiness of his country. He had indeed, been accused of intriguing for the office of President, but this accusation (altho' generally believed to be true by the republicans,) was supposed by a considerable number even of that party, especially by those who had been in habits of intimacy with him, to be slanderous and unfounded. The venerable Col. George Morgan was one of many others, who believed that Aaron Burr was an object of unmerited persecution; and gen. Wilkinson might have concurred with them in opinion, without being justly liable to any imputation on his own character. Col. Burr had, indeed, slain in a duel the celebrated Alexander Hamilton, and on that account was the object of the hatred and execration of the federalists; tho' now, (for what reason is best known to themselves,) they have forgiven him that and all his other offences; for, with them, it is not charity, but hostility to the present administration which covereth a multitude of sins. He was driven by that fatal event from the state of New York, and forced to seek an asylum elsewhere. Is it wonderful that, under these circumstances, general Wilkinson (who had coresponded with him long before, and no doubt had been induced, from the smoothness and plausibility of his manners, to entertain a favorable opinion of him) should have regarded him as a great man in adversity, and invited him to the paradise of the west, where a new and immensely fertile country would afford him a happy settlement?
See moreSee less
The general has declared on oath tha[t] in the subsequent letters which he receved from col. Burr, obscure hints were drop'd of some great design, (of which Mexico appeared to be the object,) but that no explicit communication was ever made to him previous to that by Mr. Swartwout. Until then he had no reason to suspect that col. Burr intended to play the part of a traitor. The probabi[lity]
The paper reports on depositions concerning General Wilkinson that raise serious questions needing explanation. Thomas Power, claiming privilege as a Spanish subject, refused full examination but addressed the court, admitting cipher correspondence existed among Wilkinson, Burr, Dayton, and others, while denying it reflected badly on his government.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 28 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
However I apprehend that, without any violation or breach of my most sacred duties, I can satisfy the gentlemen—I can gratify their curiosity, and give them the information they appear so obstinately bent upon getting: for I confess I do not see any thing criminal or deserving of blame in gentlemen's carrying on a correspondence in cypher with the baron of Carondelet, or any other baron or governor of Louisiana, or any other province, and more particularly in gen. Wilkinson, who I have every reason to believe, has been in the habits of corresponding in cypher with several of his acquaintance: witness, col.
See moreSee less
Burr himself—witness, gen. Dayton—I can even quote myself—also a very excellent and worthy friend of mine, Mr. R. R. Keene, of New-Orleans, who has shewn me a cypher he had from gen. Wilkinson. So that I feel myself perfectly at my ease on this point, as it does not in any shape affect or throw any light on the political concerns of my government. As the col. has also said something about monies, neither shall I feel any reluctance in declaring what I may know concerning any sums of money said to have been received by general Wilkinson. For it is pretty well known that the Spanish government, at a former period, did contract with the general and I believe with some other gentlemen of Kentucky, for considerable supplies of tobacco—if the gentlemen will confine themselves within these limits, in their interrogatories, they shall find me ready to satisfy them. But beyond these I declare I will not step. Col. Burr then asked capt. Power, if he knew that gen. Wilkinson had corresponded in cypher with the baron de Carondelet—to which he replied that he did know that gen. Wilkinson had carried on a correspondence in cypher with the baron, that as far as he recollected the cypher was complicated, and that a small pocket dictionary was also used.—No interrogatory concerning monies received by gen. W. was put to Mr. P. as the court had decided that it was unnecessary and improper." As we expect general Wilkinson will notice the
The Public Ledger criticizes General Wilkinson's defenders, particularly questioning Mr. Power's refusal to swear testimony about Wilkinson's dealings with Spain. The editor insists that Wilkinson's conduct at New Orleans deserves investigation, claiming neutrality regarding both Wilkinson and Burr while criticizing political coverage of a New Jersey election and the Aurora's editorial excuses.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FRIDAY EVENING, OCT. 30, 1807.
We have given insertion this day to sundry publications, if not written by general Wilkinson himself, written on his behalf, we shall make no comment on them. Mr. Power's certificate deserves notice. This gentleman it seems can certify, but he will not swear. Although we can with great readiness admit, that the officer of a foreign government ought not to be compelled to disclose transactions of a secret nature which did occur, we cannot perceive the difficulty which exists in stating that which did not occur. In the present case, general Wilkinson was charged with certain matters deeply affecting his reputation, and it was only for Mr. Power to say that they were not to his knowledge true. Instead of which he hesitates upon disclosing the secrets of his master's government, as if there had been any improper correspondence between general Wilkinson and the government of Spain.
See moreSee less
We are perfectly indifferent as to general Wilkinson and colonel Burr, but we shall always insist
The piece disputes claims that Burr was universally detested in the western country, citing Western World articles suggesting he had many adherents who believed war with Spain justified his actions. It also recounts a Vincennes legislature incident where a Burr supporter was lightly punished yet given a prestigious office.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The Administration papers have unceasingly insisted upon the general detestation of Burr and his adherents in the western country. Upon the veracity of this assertion, the following articles copied from the Western World, will enable us to form some judgment. It is evident, either that Burr's designs are not in that country judged wicked, or that he has more adherents and friends than was supposed. One of his principal adherents was fined Ten Dollars and imprisoned Three Hours, but by way of consolation, was rewarded with one of the best offices in the gift of the representatives of the people.
See moreSee less
It is our opinion that the people of the western country, believed that war on the part of Spain had commenced, that war on the part of the United States ought to, and would have followed, and that Burr and his associates contemplated an attack on Mexico, and nothing more.
A letter writer describes witnessing Davis Floyd's election as clerk of the Indiana Territory House of Representatives, despite Floyd having just been convicted of a misdemeanor and standing indicted for high treason as Burr's agent. The writer expresses outrage, suggests the legislature and governor are sympathetic to Burr's conspiracy, and warns readers that the conspiracy's threat has not truly subsided.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
our government at Jeffersonville a few days since! The very man who now stands indicted for high treason against the United States!!! I never was more astonished in my life, than when I saw the man charged with treason—the man who was Burr's principal agent to overturn our government, elected as clerk to the legislature of the Indiana Territory. Does not this conduct on the part of the house of representatives, prove that they are all Burrites? Does it not go further and prove, that they are parties to the infernal conspiracy, by supporting one of its known members, by giving him an office of profit in this territory.
See moreSee less
But birds of a feather will flock together. And what was very strange to me, the Governor publickly advocated Floyd's innocence. —I am afraid the pillars of our government are rotten.” The preceding extract of a letter from the Indiana Territory demands a serious attention. Those who believe that the scheme which Burr was to
This report records courtroom testimony from General Wilkinson during Aaron Burr's trial, including cross-examination about communications with Timothy Rigby and alleged plans for an invasion of Mexico. Wilkinson addresses the judge about his complicated position as both a witness for the prosecution and a party accused by Burr's defense.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
I can prove.
Col. Burr said that if gen. Wilkinson had any further evidence to give he would go on with it. But these appeared to be mere conversations, and he did not know whether dictated by passion or not.
During Burr's treason trial, counsel and the court debate whether General Wilkinson should be permitted to further explain parts of his testimony outside the court's normal examination process. Wilkinson also mentions possessing letters from a Colonel Swan of a mixed personal and political nature, which he claims contain nothing incriminating.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
hear him. Mr. Wickham. Gen. Wilkinson must necessarily stand in a very delicate situation. Very heavy charges are brought against Col. Burr, which are attempted to
Courtroom testimony examines discrepancies in dates on a cipher document used as evidence, with witnesses debating whether '1793' or '1804' was originally written and whether changes were made after the document was shown to the grand jury. General Wilkinson's clerk's handwriting and memory are questioned regarding the endorsement on the cipher.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Witnesses on behalf of the accused.
(Mr. Tazewell's testimony continued.)
See moreSee less
Mr. Wickham. [Holding in his hand a key of one of the cyphers.] Has there been any addition or alteration in this paper since you saw it before the grand jury?— A. I will state my impressions. I well recollect that this endorsement suggested one doubt to the grand jury; "I solemnly swear that the numbers and hieroglyphics within, excepting those which denote the alphabet and units, 'Burr' and 'Wilkinson' were written by the late captain Campbell Smith, in the year 1804, 5, or 6,
During Burr's treason trial, defense counsel debated whether a Court Martial record (destroyed in a War-Office fire) could be used to prove General Eaton was convicted of crimes disqualifying him as a witness. The Chief Justice overruled objections to pursuing this line of evidence regarding Eaton's competency and credibility.
The Enquirer · 30 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
or a witness, but not as to any particular fact. Under such circumstances it was unnecessary to occupy the time of the court either with this affidavit or with parol evidence.—Mr. Burr. The affidavit proves that such papers were burnt in the War-Office. We shall prove by a
During Burr's treason trial, a deposition states War Office court martial records before 1801 were destroyed by fire. Courtroom exchanges follow between Burr, Wickham, and General Eaton regarding Eaton's prior conviction and the admissibility of testimony about his character.
The Enquirer · 30 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Col. Henry Gaither.
Mr. Burr. Are you acquainted with general Eaton? A. I am. Early in '96;—Gen. Eaton. I presume I have a right to know what is to be proved by this witness. Mr. Wickham. With respect to gen. Eaton's right, that is out of the question. He forgets that this is a case between the United States and Mr. Burr. Mr. Burr. I have stated twice that col. Gaither is
A witness is cross-examined in the Burr treason trial about General Wilkinson's arrival in New Orleans in November, his private disclosures of danger, and the mixed public sentiment both before and after Wilkinson exposed Burr's alleged plans. The testimony details how opinion was divided, with some citizens favoring Burr and others supporting Wilkinson's measures.
The Enquirer · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
public mind at New-Orleans at the time of the arrival of Gen. Wilkinfon ? A. I difcovered nothing unufual about that time. Q What was the ftate of the public mind after the approach of Burr was announced; did there appear to be a confiderable party difpofed to favor the views of Col. Burr ? A. A confiderable party appeared to be in favor of Col. Burr, and were
A witness testifies about General Wilkinson's disclosure of alleged dangers at the government house in New Orleans, describing mixed public reaction among merchants and citizens. Lawyers Hay, Martin, and Wirt argue over the admissibility of hearsay evidence regarding rumors of Burr's approach down the river.
The Enquirer · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
[Mr. B]urr, (in a lower tone of voice) to Mr. Martin. [You know a good deal of those things.] Mr. Hay. Did you see col. Burr at Washington, in the Mississippi Territory? A. Yes. I received a verbal message from him, by an unknown person, and returned an apology for not waiting on him that day, but went to see him the next day. I met him in company, but he solicited no private interview, and I had none with him. Mr. Hay. Was there any circumstance which particularly attracted your notice?
See moreSee less
A. No. I never saw him till he was in the hands of the civil authority. Mr. Hay. Do you recollect whether in New Orleans and while general Wilkinson was there, intelligence frequently came down the river stating the approach of col. Burr and his party? [Mr. Wickham objected to the witness speaking of
President Jefferson's address to Congress recounts the defeat of Burr's conspiracy through militia and army action, and announces he will submit the proceedings and evidence from the Virginia trial of the principal offenders. He invites Congress to judge whether the failure to convict lay in the testimony, the law, or its administration, and to consider remedies.
The Enquirer · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
the public peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and his associates, of the measures taken to defeat them, and to bring the offenders to justice. Their enterprizes were happily defeated, by the patriotic exertions of the militia, whenever called into action, by the fidelity of the army, and energy of the Commander in
This report examines evidence presented at Burr's trial, including General Wilkinson's communications and testimony about a cipher letter suggesting a military expedition against Mexico. It discusses conflicting accounts between Wilkinson and Swartwout regarding alleged conversations about disunion schemes.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
tied against Mexico.
The communications made to general Wilkinson deserve much consideration in marking the real intention of the parties, because it is obvious that colonel Burr, whe-
This report discusses testimony and legal arguments presented during Aaron Burr's treason trial, focusing on General Wilkinson's account of conversations with Burr and the interpretation of evidence regarding Burr's true objectives. The analysis concludes that the enterprise was likely directed against Mexico rather than against the United States, while also discussing legal definitions of treason related to revolutionizing a territory by force.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
ture of Mr Swartwout, not authorised by Mr Burr.
It is also a circumstance of some weight, that Mr Burr's declarations at the mouth of Cumberland, furnish strong reasons for the opinion, that he did not wish those to whom
The passage describes courtroom proceedings where the Chief Justice limits testimony to matters relevant to the cause, and discusses General Wilkinson's opportunity to explain his motives and actions. Lawyers debate whether Wilkinson has been allowed to fully explain his testimony, with Mr. Mack noting that Wilkinson's credibility is naturally subject to cross-examination given the serious charges against Burr.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
regular detail of the proceedings of colonel Burr from his first passage of the mountains, but I have been advised to confine myself to a narration of the occurrences which commenced at Natchitoches. It is now my duty to go back to that period and trace col. Burr step by step.
The Chief Justice said, that the court could not sit to hear any thing except what related to the cause. As to the intention with which general Wilkinson had done any particular act, he had been permitted to explain, in the whole course of his testimony. With respect to what had been drawn from Mr Tazewell, as he understood it, there was no variation between his statement and that of General Wilkinson.
See moreSee less
The papers which gen. Wilkinson wished to refer to had as well appear before the public in any other way as thro' the channel of this court.
Mr McRae said he did not know that general Wilkinson had gone so fully into an explanation of the various parts of his evidence as he intended. He had understood the court to say, that general Wilkinson might be permitted to explain himself as to any particular fact mentioned in the course of his testimony. It is the wish of general Wilkinson, on every occasion, to explain the motives which governed him: and if in some points, he has not been so full as he intended, he hoped that the court would still hear him.
Mr Wickham. General Wilkinson must necessarily stand in a very delicate situation. Very heavy charges are brought against colonel Burr, which are attempted to be established by the testimony of general Wilkinson. It must have been foreseen that the counsel of colonel Burr, if they did their duty, would endeavor to impeach the credibility of general Wilkinson as a witness. But this is a common case. It is a thing which may happen in the case of every witness who is brought before the court. A witness is brought forward on whose testimony much reliance is placed. He is, of course, cross-examined to see whether he be consistent with himself; or whether his credibility can be impeached. In the present case, I am certain that general Wilkinson has been treated with every degree of delicacy which the nature of the case would admit of. With respect to myself, I am conscious of having done nothing but what my duty dictated; and of having used as much delicacy towards general Wilkinson, as his relation would justify. We do not see the necessity or propriety of general Wilkinson's entering into explanations. If these are to be made, they had better be reserved for some other time, and some other place.
Col. Burr. Gen. Wilkinson has been sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth and
General Wilkinson testifies at the Burr treason trial about ambiguous letters from Burr, denying he destroyed the May 13th letter and challenging its production. Testimony continues regarding a cipher document whose date appears altered, with questions raised about whether Wilkinson's memory or the document itself had been improperly refreshed since grand jury proceedings.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
feel. The letter post marked the 13th of May has often been mentioned, and has been used to injure my character, and envelope it in doubts and suspicions. This letter, if written at all, must have been in answer to one received from colonel Burr. Why has it not been produced ? I challenge its production : for if it were brought forward, it would release me from all obligation to silence ; and would enable me to exhibit to public view, the letters of col. Burr. Sir, I am incapable of uttering an intentional falsehood ; and under the solemnity of the oath which I have taken, I have no hesitation in saying, that the declarations of that gentleman (pointing to colonel Burr) that he had put the letter beyond his power and with my knowledge, is totally destitute of truth.
This opinion piece argues that Wilkinson's courage and decisive action in exposing Burr's scheme prove his honesty, dismissing claims that he was bribed by Spain. It contends that Burr's supporters contradict themselves by calling their plan lawful while also accusing Wilkinson of thwarting it treacherously.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FRIDAY, OCTOBER 30, 1807.
THE enemies of General Wilkinson endeavor to account for the apparent inconsistency both of the motives and actions which they attribute to him, by saying that his heart failed him when the great enterprize of Burr and himself was about to be carried into effect. But the General never has been charged with cowardice except by the illustrious Mr. Samuel Swartwout in his late eloquent address, in which the extravagance of the abuse defeats its own object. He has, on a multitude of honorable occasions, displayed firmness and valor fully sufficient to evince, that, if he had been guilty of the daring villainy of projecting such a scheme as that of Burr, he would have boldly persevered, and either succeeded or perished in the attempt. The vigor and energy displayed by him in defeating the conspiracy, his undaunted bravery in defying the machinations of a host of Traitors, and the fortitude with which he took an immense burthen of responsibility on himself to save his country, are proofs of his possessing qualities very different from those of a man whose timidity would induce him to desert his associates, or betray his trust. The Burrites indeed know that his courage is as great as his honesty; and, for that reason, they fear, hate, and traduce him.
See moreSee less
But if, as Col. Burr and his friends pretend, his design was lawful, and he only intended to attack the territories of Spain in the event of a war, how can Wilkinson be said to have defeated that design? War had never been declared between the United States and Spain. The Government of the United States thought proper to consider the two nations in a state of peace; and Col. Burr had surely no right to declare war instead of the government. If his intention was to strike a blow immediately, that intention was plainly unlawful; and unless the blow was to have been struck immediately, Wilkinson did not counteract or repel it. The war, in the event only of which it is ludicrously pretended that Burr's preparations were to be put in action, has never yet occurred. Of course, whenever that war shall actually take place, it will still be in the power of the Colonel and his associates to offer their services as volunteers to the government, and to display their heroism in the brilliant atchievement of the conquest of Mexico; in which case, it is to be hoped that their victories will be for their country, not for themselves,—to gain additional territory for the United States, not a diadem for their leader. In fact, if their design was only to serve their country as good citizens, Gen. Wilkinson never did and never can prevent their
This editorial piece defends General Wilkinson against accusations of treachery, perjury, and forgery, arguing that Burr's supporters contradict themselves by claiming their enterprise was lawful while also accusing Wilkinson of thwarting it. It cites Mr. Power's certificate as proof Wilkinson did not take Spanish gold, and dismisses testimony from Major Bruff and Mr. Dsoartwout as biased.
Virginia Argus · 30 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
[f]irm adherence to his duty to his King deserve applause even from republicans, who love and admire virtue tho' in a monarchist,) has plainly and positively declared the innocence of Gen. Wilkinson of those very charges, to support which against him he was forced to come hither from New-Orleans; and has sufficiently explained and obviated any effect which might otherwise have been produced by the obscure insinuations and hear-say stories contained in the ex parte affidavits of Mercier & Derbigny. It is a little remarkable that Mr. Power was compelled by Col.
See moreSee less
Burr's agent to take so long a journey (when it must have been known that he could prove nothing against Gen. Wilkinson), and that Mercier and Derbigny, whose affidavits were so vastly important, were permitted to stay behind. The object must have been, (since it probably was understood that Mr. Power would refuse to reveal the political transactions in which he had been employed), to injure the reputation of the General by making the public believe, that if Mr Power would tell all that he knew, terrible things would come to light, and thus to attempt to gain a greater advantage by his silence than by any thing he could say.—This crafty stratagem of Col. Burr has, however, been defeated, like all the rest of the same sort, and his friends may condole with him for his very bad luck. They are not content, however, with accusing Gen. Wilkinson of fraud and treachery, but presume to charge him also with perjury and forgery. The first of these heavy accusations is supported only by the long-winded tales of Major James Bruff, who, in open court, acknowledged himself to be the bitter personal enemy of the general; by the opposing oath of Mr Swartwout, the same person who wrote the "extract of a letter from a "gentleman of honor and veracity in the "city of Richmond, to his friend in New "York," which extract contained almost as many falsehoods as words; and by the circumstance that the general, in the course of his cross-examination, in answer to a question artfully expressed, said that he did not recollect that he had corresponded with the Baron de Carondelet, in the same cypher with that which was used between him and Col. Burr. As to the last of these grounds of reproach, (for the two first are not worthy of notice.) it should be observed that the question put to Gen. Wilkinson was not whether he had ever corresponded with the Baron de Carondelet at all, but whether he had carried on the correspondence in a particular cypher. If it had been put in the first shape, no doubt he would have answered, without hesitation, in the affirmative; but, as to any one particular cypher which had been used, it is not sur
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · and 1 other paper
The court delivered its opinion that Aaron Burr and Herman Blennerhassett should be committed for preparing a military expedition against Spanish territories, while Israel Smith was not committed for lack of evidence. The prisoners were ordered transferred to the District of Ohio for trial and were admitted to bail at $3,000 each, with Luther Martin and Dr. Cummings standing as securities.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 30 October 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Hay moved to have A. B. and H. B. committed for trial in the District of Ohio.
After the delivery of the opinion of the Court, on Tuesday, the Chief Justice observed, that he had not specified (in that opinion) the particular district to which the prisoners were to be committed. He thought it best that there should be only one trial for them; but if Burr was sent to Kentucky, Blannerhasset could not, because he had provided no means for the expedition but in the district of Ohio.
See moreSee less
Mr. Hay then moved for their commitment to Ohio, which was ordered.
Mr. Wickham then moved for an attachment against Mr. Benjamin Hawkins, an Indian agent, for detaining Dr. Cummings, a witness in this prosecution, and breaking open certain papers in his care belonging to Mr. Blennerhasseett, one of the accused: a rule ordered.
Messrs. Burr and Blannerhassett were admitted to bail, in the sum of 3,000 dollars each. Luther Martin and Dr.