Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me. · and 4 other papers
During Burr's treason trial, a witness named Power (a Spanish subject) was called by Burr's defense to help prove General Wilkinson received payments from Spain, aiming to discredit Wilkinson's testimony. Power refused to answer questions about correspondence between Wilkinson and the Baron de Carondelet, citing his duty to the Spanish king, while Burr's counsel argued he must testify since he was within the court's jurisdiction.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 2 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Col. Burr's Trial. RICHMOND, OCT. 20. Thursday, Oct. 15, was wholly occupied by Mr. Wickham. Friday was wholly occupied by Mr. McRea. On Saturday, a Mr. Power, from Neworleans, (who turned out to be a subject of the king of Spain) was introduced by col. Burr as a witness: by whom [as he asserted] he intended to authenticate certain papers, and to prove that gen. Wilkinson was in the habit of receiving money from the Spanish government. The avowed object of establishing this charge, against the general, was, to impeach his credibility, by contradicting some parts of his testimony, and to shew that his motive for defeating the project of Burr, was not patriotism, but to prevent an invasion of the territories of the king, in whose pay he was himself.
See moreSee less
The chief justice decided that the evidence was admissible, and that Mr. Power should be examined. He was therefore sworn, and questioned as to what he knew concerning certain correspondence between the Baron de Corondelet and general Wilkinson. Mr. Power addressed the court with respect but firmness, and declared that, being a subject to the king of Spain, he could not, without violating his duty and honor, give an account of any political transactions which the service of the king his master required to be concealed. He stated that he had come hither from Neworleans with great reluctance; an agent of col. Burr who served a subpoena upon him having threatened him with imprisonment in case he refused; but he hoped the court would not compel him to give the evidence which had been demanded. The council for col. Burr insisted that, whether he was a Spanish subject or not, he was now within the power of the court; and ought to be compelled to disclose whatever he knew. The chief justice decided in their favor, and required the witness to proceed with his testimony. Mr. Power, however, resolutely refused.—Time was therefore allowed until three o'clock to consider whether he would obey the judge or not. At that hour he came again into court; but, [Mr. Wirt being then engaged in speaking] no notice was taken of his appearance. Mr. Wirt began his discourse between 12 and 1 o'clock, but had not finished when the hour of adjournment arrived. His speech, so far as he progressed, shone with his usual fire of eloquence, and was peculiarly luminous in argument. The court adjourned 'till Monday ten o'clock. Monday, Oct. 19—12 o'clock. Nearly the whole of this day was occupied by Mr. Wirt, who concluded his able speech about two o'clock—after which Mr. Power and Mr. Swartwout were again called and examined. The evidence and arguments of counsel having been concluded the court adjourned till this day [Tuesday eleven o'clock, when it is understood the final opinion of the Chief Justice will be delivered. Opinion of the Chief Justice. 12 o'clock—The court has just delivered a long and elaborate opinion, in which it determines, that "it would be improper to commit the accused on the charge of treason." The conclusion of the opinion is as follows: "I shall commit Aaron Burr and Herman Blannerhasset for preparing and providing the means for a military expedition against the territories of a foreign Prince with whom the U. S. were at peace. If those whose province and duty it is to prosecute offenders against the laws of the United States shall be of opinion that a crime of a darker dye has been committed, it is not their choice to act in conformity with that opinion.—Israel Smith is not proved to have provided or prepared any means whatever, and therfore I shall not commit him. If he has really offended against the laws he may be prosecuted for the treason in Kentucky, or for the misdemeanor in his own State, where, if any where, his offence has been committed." Mr. Hay moved to have A. B. and H. B. committed for trial in the District of Ohio.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 23 October 1807 · an extract
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 23 October 1807
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va. · 30 October 1807
The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · 3 November 1807
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.
This report critically examines General Wilkinson's conduct, questioning why he took two months to report Burr's alleged conspiracy despite receiving Burr's coded letter in early October. It argues Wilkinson's claims of a large armed force were later proven false and suggests he fabricated or exaggerated the threat despite having ample means to verify it earlier.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Nothing short of information the most particular and unequivocal could authorise any man to spread so serious alarm through the country; and that gen. Wilkinson had no such information is evident, as it has since appeared that the facts related never had even a shadow of existence, except in the fables of the general himself. By subsequent disclosures of his own indeed it has long since been reduced to a moral certainty, that he could not at the time have believed the story himself. He by his own statements on oath since that time acknowledges the receipt of Burr's famous letter in cypher by the hands of Mr.
See moreSee less
Samuel Swartwout, at Nachitoches "early in October." From this letter and his conversations with Swartwout at that time, he pretends to have learned the nature and views of the expedition in its full extent. If on that occasion the General had been faithful as a citizen or vigilant as a soldier, is it not reasonable to believe at least that instructions were given to the military posts under his command on the leading water courses, if the propriety did not suggest itself of using other means of information also to obtain the earliest intelligence of the actual movements of an expedition so important, if not also pregnant with danger to his country? Is it to be believed that he remained two months incurious as to the physical existence of that expedition; that with all the means of positive information in his power, he contented himself with chance news and conversations with persons who knew as little of the actual situation of colonel Burr as he did himself, was really imposed on by rumour, which by the way no body had heard but himself, on the 9th of December, when he addressed the merchants? If he had really received any credible intelligence from the upper country it must have told him that there were no armies there: he therefore either deceived the merchants by telling them that he had certain accounts from that country, when in truth he had none, or having had intelligence from that quarter, misrepresented it most grossly. It remains then to be asked, on what authority did gen. Wilkinson make this communication? On nothing more than this, that col. Burr, in a letter written early in July, and two of his friends who had not seen him since that time, told the General, among other things that col. Burr intended to raise an army, and intended to be with the advance guard at Natchez by a certain time. But that these intentions, if ever they were conceived, had not been carried in effect, must have been as well known to gen. Wilkinson on the 9th Dec. as it is now. How con
President Jefferson's message to Congress recounts the Burr conspiracy, the militia and military response that defeated it, and the arraignment of the principal offenders before the Virginia circuit court. He promises to submit the trial proceedings and evidence so Congress can judge whether failures lay in the testimony, the law, or its administration, and asks for remedies to better secure the government against treason.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 2 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
I informed congress, at their last session, of the enterprizes against the publick peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and his associates, of the measures taken to defeat them
President Jefferson reports to Congress that Burr's conspiracy was defeated by militia and army action, and that he will submit the evidence and proceedings from the Virginia treason trial for legislative review. He notes Congress must judge whether failures lay in testimony, law, or its administration, and consider remedies.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
I informed Congress at their last session, of the enterprizes against the public peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and
This report reproduces portions of prosecutor William Wirt's speech during Aaron Burr's treason trial, responding to Burr's defense that he could not be convicted as an accessory before his alleged principal Blennerhassett was tried. Wirt's dramatic rhetoric portrays Burr as the sole author and mastermind of the conspiracy, recruiting men across the continent with promises tailored to their ambitions.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 November 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. Wirt's Speech.
The following Extracts from the Speech of Mr. WIRT, on the motion to arrest the evidence on the Trial of AARON BURR, for High Treason, deserve to be classed amongst the happiest efforts of descriptive eloquence which the English language affords. To understand its particular force and application, it ought to be remarked, that amongst other stratagems of defence which have been set up by "the great Culprit," against the charge of Treason, he contended, that if any overt act had been committed, it was by Blannerhasset, who ought to be considered the Principal Traitor, and that he (Burr) not being present at that overt act, could be considered only as an accessory to the crime; that an accessory could not be convicted, until after the trial and conviction of his principal. And of course that he (Burr) was not amenable to punishment on that indictment. It is in reply to this ground of defence, that this part of Mr. WIRT's Speech is intended.
The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · and 1 other paper
This passage reports a dramatic courtroom speech arguing that Aaron Burr, not Blennerhassett, was the true mastermind of the treason conspiracy, comparing Burr's influence to the sun controlling planets in their orbits. The orator insists it would be monstrous to treat the manipulated Blennerhassett as the principal offender while excusing Burr as a mere accessory.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 3 November 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
keeped in knery, is comparatively innocent, a mere accessory. Sir, neither the human heart, nor the human understanding, will bear a perversion so monstrous and absurd, so shocking to the soul, so revolting to reason. O no, sir.—There is no man who knows any thing of this affair, who does not know, that to every body concerned in it Aaron Burr was as the sun to the planets which surround him—he bound them in their respective orbits, and gave them their light, their heat and their motion. Let him not then shrink from the high destination which he has courted; and having already ruined Blannerhasset in fortune, character and happiness forever, attempt to finish the tragedy by thrusting that ill fated man between himself and punishment
A witness recounts testimony given at Burr's trial describing conversations about troop movements and an officer's remarks about General Wilkinson, including a reprimand incident. The testimony touches on Burr's inquiries about commanding an expedition to Santa Fe and his reaction to being mistaken for a Marylander.
The Enquirer · 3 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
he came across the River? A. When he arrived I was not in town, but understood that the General had rode out with him to the Cantonment to view his troops. I saw the Colonel on the evening he returned. The Colonel strictured the situation and laughed at the General's military notions. Mr. Wirt. At Cold Water? A. Yes at Cold Water and christened afterward Belle Fontaine. Mr. Wirt. How far from St. Louis? A. Twelve or fourteen miles. Mr. Martin. When col. Burr was there how was he treated? A.
See moreSee less
The General made a dinner, it was understood for col. Burr. I was invited the colonel did not attend; but was said to be sick. When col. Burr was leaving St. Louis I was about to cross the River to my plantation on the opposite side, his baggage was bought to the ferry boat, when I saw the General's barge getting ready with colours and a complete crew in uniform. I afterwards saw the Colonel pass my farm on his journey, in company with Doctor Brown only; Easton was not with him.) Some time after col. Burr left St. Louis, General Wilkinson and Mr. Easton fell out. Easton complained the General persecuted him.— And often talked in a dark mysterious manner about a Western empire. Capt. Stoddart also hinted to me after his return from Fort Massac, that some great scheme was in agitation between col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, but did not say what. Easton positively stated that there was a connection between General Wilkinson and Colonel Burr. He complained that the General persecuted him, I observed that it was very strange that he should be the common friend of col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, and yet they should misunderstand one another about him; that I rather suspected the General finding him unpopular with the French, and that he would not answer their purpose, had persuaded col. Burr to shake him off. Easton replied, that col. Burr was in his power and that he dared not treat him in a deceitful manner. I replied I did not know col. Burr, but that his enemies represented him as an artful intriguer. Some time afterwards Mr. Easton came to me and observed that he believed my conjectures about col. Burr were true—and that he was to be made a sacrifice of; that he should go on to the seat of government and try what he could do for himself. Easton was then a Judge appointed by the President, but not confirmed by
A witness recounts courtroom testimony describing how Burr allegedly made shocking secret propositions to a military officer (likely Eaton), and discusses General Wilkinson's Senate confirmation troubles and the Western World newspaper's accusations linking Wilkinson to Burr and Miranda. The testimony explores whether obligations of secrecy should have been broken given suspicions of treason.
The Enquirer · 3 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITMENT. Tuesday, October 6. Evidence of Major James Bruff.
Mr. Martin. Had you any communications with Gen. Wilkinson about the time of his return to St. Louis? [Mr. Hay requested that the object for which the witness was introduced should be stated. Mr. Martin said, it was to prove the same as Timothy Kibby; that gen. Wilkinson held out the same inducements to him to join in an expedition against the Spaniards. Mr. Hay objected to the introduction of the testimony, on principle. He said that no man could be presumed to come prepared to explain every particular act of his life; That the general reputation of a witness could alone be enquired into, in order to assail his character. This he held to be a sacred rule of law and of justice. Mr. Martin contended, that the evidence was pertinent. Gen. Wilkinson had declared that he had no knowledge of col. Burr's views till he received the cyphered letter. We will prove that he had. He did not mean to say that the views of col. Burr were criminal, on the contrary, they were perfectly innocent; nor would gen. Wilkinson have been guilty if he had joined in them. But now gen. Wilkinson, in order to obtain favor with the government, had turned traitor to col. Burr. Mr. Wickham argued that the testimony of Major Bruff was admissible to shew an inconsistency in that of gen. Wilkinson.
See moreSee less
Gen. Wilkinson. May I be permitted to make one observation; I am not in the smallest degree surprized at the language which has upon this and several other occasions been used by the counsel of col. Burr; men who are hired to misrepresent. [Mr. Wickham. I will not submit to such language from any man in court. The Chief Justice declared the style of gen. W. to be improper, and that he had heard too much of such language in court. Gen. Wilkinson apologized.—He said that it was impossible he could offer any intentional disrespect to the court, but he could not remain silent when he heard himself called a traitor.] Gen. W. proceeded.—I am astonished at the explanation of the objects for which this witness is called. Had I known the purpose for which he volunteered his services, (for he was not summoned) I should have been able to produce documents to shew the long, the implacable hatred which he has borne towards me. [Mr. Wickham said that Major Bruff was under the protection of the court.] Gen. Wilkinson—I pray that his testimony may be introduced. Mr. Hay observed, that he had no doubt of the law, as to the right to impeach the credibility of a witness, by shewing an inconsistency in his testimony. He admitted that if Major Bruff's evidence were introduced for that purpose, it was proper; but if for any other purpose, it was improper. They had no right to interrogate him for the purpose avowed by Mr. Martin; to shew that Gen. Wilkinson entertained the same views as col. Burr. However, as gen. Wilkinson was content that Major Bruff should proceed, he would not object.
The Chief Justice declared that he would not hear the witness as to any particular allegations against gen. Wilkinson; but with respect to any inconsistency in his testimony he must hear him.
Major Bruff proceeded.
My testimony will arise from a number of conversations with gen. W.
In four of these conversations gen. W. took me aside; in three of which he locked me up in his room. The first hint I had of a connexion between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr was drawn from two paragraphs in Kentucky newspapers, in the spring 1805, before gen. W. reached St. Louis; the first alluded to the old plan to form a separate government west of the Allegany, and ascribed it to gen. Wilkinson and his associates, and doubting whether that scheme had yet been abandoned. The next was an extract of a letter from Fort Massac, published in the papers, which stated that col. Burr had been several days there with gen. Wilkinson, probably giving the general lessons on government, or digesting a new code or constitution for the government of Louisiana.—These hints, with information received from capt. Stoddard immediately from Fort Massac, and who assured me that col. Burr was, or had been there closely engaged with gen. W. and that he had or was about to furnish him with a barge and crew, to descend the Mississippi into New-Orleans, [Mr. Wirt. You have not said when. A. In June, 1805.] These circumstances put me on my guard, and determined me to watch the motions of gen. Wilkinson and Burr.
As the general approached St. Louis, ascending the Mississippi from Fort Massac, he dispatched a light barge ahead with directions for me to meet him six or eight miles below. I obeyed. We met, landed and ascended the bank. The general took me into the woods. As we walked on, the general observed, that he had been informed the territory was divided by parties, (I mean upper Louisiana) which he attributed to the Americans, and said he would crush party, or perish in the attempt. I observed, that there had been some party business about the time of the convention and these memorials to Congress, but none since; except the aversion the French had to the expense, delay, and uncertainty of our laws, and the introduction of lawyers. He then asked me how I stood with the French inhabitants, for he had heard there was some misunderstanding or coolness between us occasioned by my observations about antedated concessions and fraudulent grants—I observed, that some uneasiness had been excited by a report I had made to the secretary at war, respecting private surveys which took in public property, but I believed they were then satisfied I had merely done my duty. He observed that he had witnessed their many attempts in the lower country to defraud the public; (the Orleans or Mississippi territories that he knew them and mankind generally, and if I would place my dependence upon him he would manage them for me; [Mr. Hay. He would manage them for you? A. Yes. It alluded to the French.] About this time some Frenchmen from St. Louis had found us out and were rushing through the bushes on us. He damned them for their intrusion; [Mr. Hay. To their faces? A. No. To me,] said he had something of importance to communicate, hoped to have had an opportunity there; but that he would take the first opportunity after he had got settled.
A day or two after his arrival at St. Louis, his orderly came to me. I attended. I was taken into his parlour and he locked the door. [Mr. McRae. What time? A. About the last of June, or 1st or 2d day of July. Mr. McRae. Can you name the day? A. I cannot. Gen. Wilkinson. Can you come within five days? A. No, I cannot.] We commenced walking. The General appeared to be ruminating, and after two or three times he asked me what sort of government would suit Louisiana. Without hesitation, I replied, a representative republic would meet both the wishes and expectations of the people. He answered that he was surprized to hear me say so; for the French could not understand its principle or be brought to attend elections; that the American inhabitants were a turbulent set, the mere emptyings of jails or fugitives from justice, and did not deserve a free government; that a military government was best for these people, and no other was contemplated for them; [Here Mr. Hay, observing that Major Bruff retired to a table on which several papers were laid, asked him when he had made the statement of his testimony, which he was then giving. On being answered that it was recently done and since his arrival here; Mr. Hay requested that he would not again look at it. Major Bruff said that his statement was drawn from a number of letters which he had written to his friends about the time of the transactions alluded to; and from an intended publication against the Gen.] that the politics of the United States had undergone a great change; that the honest and wise had united to save the federal constitution, and prevent a division of property which the democrats aimed at; that the democratic party in Congress had split and dwindled; and that John Randolph, Nicholson and Leib, had lost their influence both in Congress and with the executive. I observed that he attributed principles and motives to the republicans which they abhorred. [Mr. Hay. To which party did you belong? A. To the democratic. Mr. Martin. Were you not then a democrat, and did not Gen. Wilkinson know you to belong to that party? A. Yes.] On this subject we had a good deal of conversation. I remarked on the folly to suppose John Randolph would consent to throw his property into the public stock, in order to have a scramble for a part of it. However, the general observed, that the object of the democrats was to produce a state of anarchy and confusion; to seize on the property of the federalists and divide it among themselves; and this too he told me with a very serious face. I will make one observation here: it is that these conversations which I had with the General, were at different times, and it is possible that I may not have classed them precisely in point of time; but I am certain that they did happen and nearly as I have stated; and if the General will be candid, he will acknowledge it. [Gen. Wilkinson. Indeed I will not.] He said that Pennsylvania was convulsed by the democrats; yet they would not succeed in turning out M'Kean or introducing their arbitration system. I think that this ended the conversation. We got warm; and the General threw open the door, and I walked out.
After dinner his orderly came for me again. I attended; was taken into his room and the door fastened. He assumed a milder manner. And assured me that the politics not only of the United States but of the executive had changed; that the difference between the present and former administration was merely in name; that parties were kept alive by the cunning, in order to help them to office or to keep them in; that the people mistook the character of Mr. Jefferson; that a want of energy was no part of it, but rather obstinacy. Here he observed that the French had not been enough attended to in the territorial appointments; that they were the natives, and the Americans were ungrateful intruders and now railed against a King and government which had raised them from ashes.—[Mr. Wirt. To whom did he allude? A. I considered that he pointed his remarks to Mr. Austin particularly. It was the Spanish King and government to which I alluded.] He then observed that Governor Claiborne, a miserable thing or tool, had distributed the appointments in the lower country among his American followers and dependents, and had neglected the French, for which he was execrated, despised and forsaken by every person of talents and honor, except by a Dr. Watkins, who no doubt had some personal views. I observed that in the lower country the great body of the people were French; but that in the upper country there were more than two Americans for one Frenchman, and that the disproportion encreased daily by emigration, and would soon entitle us to elections. He replied, God forbid that you should ever see an election in Louisiana; and then observed that it was the intention of the government to depopulate that country, except the villages of St. Louis, St. Geneva and St. Charles, and a small district of country around each, merely sufficient to support them; that land would be offered to the inhabitants on the East side of the Mississippi, which if they refused to move to, they would be pushed over at the point of the bayonet, and that I should be employed in that business. As I found that my replies only irritated the General, and kept back the important communications I therefore determined when I could not acquiesce in sentiment with the General, I would endeavour to be silent till I got the important secret. But I found, I had already gone too far. The General appeared to be vexed and disappointed; threw open the door and I walked out.
The next morning his orderly came for me again. I attended; and we had another parlour conversation with closed doors. He assumed a friendly manner, and begged me to recollect that it was sometime since I had left the Atlantic States; and assured me that public opinion had undergone a great change in favour of energetic governments and measures; that if I persisted in exploded notions, they would injure me with my government; that democratic notions produced licentiousness; and that the very existence of an army and democracy were incompatible; that republics were ungrateful; jealous of armies and military merit; and made no provision for the superannuated & worn-out officers, but who were left to starve. In these latter opinions I agreed with him. The general seemed pleased that I should assent to any of his opinions. He was now silent.—While we walked the floor one or two turns, with his eyes down on the floor and seemed to be musing, he then observed that he was fertile
[NUMBER 51.
in schemes, had made fortunes for many who did not then thank him for it. I smiled. He said, "perhaps you think I had better have made my own fortune.—True; But I have now a grand scheme in contemplation, that will not only make my fortune, but the fortunes of all concerned"; he paused as if waiting for my answer; I was silent—had nothing to say; but wanted him to explain and go into the detail; after walking the floor several times, during which he appeared much agitated and vexed, he threw open the door and I walked out; with only this glimpse of the secret which he had so long been preparing me for.
As I attended daily for orders until the arrival of col. Cushing; the next morning I found the General rather distant and reserved. He observed that he had yet enemies in the army; and among them some from his own State; that he either hated or loved Marylanders more than others; presuming this intended for me, I replied, I suppose you take me for a Marylander; "why, are you not?" I answered no. I was born in Jersey, but had the good luck to be brought young to Maryland of which State my father, grand father and great grand father, were natives—"born in Jersey! (replied the General,) a second cousin a yankee, a damned cunning fellow I suspect."—This was the first rude thing he had said to me; for before this, I was treated with respect and had received many friendly letters from him; I therefore attributed this to my declining to join him in his scheme to make fortunes; some time after the troops moved to Cold Water, an officer informed me, that they were encamped on a low damp bottom, subject to be overflowed. (Mr. Hay objected to the course of the testimony pursued by the witness. Col. Burr said that he did not know the whole extent of his testimony, but that he had been introduced to shew palpable contradictions in the evidence of General Wilkinson.) The Missouri on the one side and a marsh or bog on the other, and the whole Cantonment commanded by a high second Bank or hill in its rear; I observed the situation was not only unmilitary, but would probably become the grave of the troops if they were not removed. At that time I did not know the General had contracted for the ground as private property "a snug fixture where he might hang up his sword." The morning after this conversation I was sent for by the General and severely and rudely reprimanded before two strangers; forbid to interfere with his plans and measures; I replied it was my duty and inclination to obey his military arrangements, but should I discover any plans or measures which put to hazard the peace and safety of the U. States, I would not keep silence, be the consequences what they might; he understood me. And from that moment I believe my ruin was determined on.
Colonel Burr arrived a little time after this at St. Louis. (Mr. Wirt. At what time? A. I believe in August 1805.) A Judge Easton who appeared to think very highly of col. Burr and boasted of possessing a part of his confidence, informed me that col. Burr had inquired of him, whether there was any officer of experience & enterprize who could be trusted with the command of an expedition to Santa Fee, and gave me a very inquisitive look. I demanded by what authority col. Burr made the inquiry, or in what light I was to view it. He replied that col. Burr at that time held no public office, but that he had powerful friends and would probably be in a very exalted situation before long; that I had been well spoken of to col. Burr, (I suppose by himself) and he advised me to make him my friend. I answered that the inquiry was a suspicious one; for if government chose to employ me in that or any other way; it had a right to command my services—for (I was in service at that time.) We dropt the subject. (Mr. Martin. Was Easton at St. Louis? A. Yes. Mr. Martin. Was he in habits of great intimacy with gen. Wilkinson. A. Yes, there appeared to be a good understanding between the three.) But as general Wilkinson some time before had wrote me that "every information of the route to Santa Fee would be highly acceptable," and recently sounded my inclination towards energetic governments and his grand scheme to make fortunes, I no longer doubted of their connection. (Mr. Martin. How long was col. Burr at St. Louis, how was he treated by general Wilkinson, and how was he sent across the River? A. When he arrived I was not in town, but understood that the General had rode out with him to the Cantonment to view his troops. I saw the Colonel on the evening he returned. The Colonel strictured the situation and laughed at the General's military notions. Mr. Wirt. At Cold Water? A. Yes at Cold Water and christened afterward; Belle Fontaine. Mr. Wirt. How far from St. Louis? A. Twelve or fourteen miles. Mr. Martin. When col. Burr was there how was he treated? A. The General made a dinner, it was understood for col. Burr. I was invited; the colonel did not attend; but was said to be sick. When col. Burr was leaving St. Louis I was about to cross the River to my plantation on the opposite side, his baggage was brought to the ferry boat, when I saw the General's barge getting ready with colours and a complete crew in uniform. I afterwards saw the Colonel pass my farm on his journey, in company with Doctor Brown only; Easton was not with him.)
Some time after col. Burr left St. Louis, General Wilkinson and Mr. Easton fell out. Easton complained the General persecuted him.—And often talked in a dark mysterious manner about a Western empire. Capt. Stoddart also hinted to me after his return from Fort Massac, that some great scheme was in agitation between col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, but did not say what. Easton positively stated that there was a connection between General Wilkinson and Colonel Burr. He complained that the General persecuted him, I observed that it was very strange that he should be the common friend of col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson, and yet they should misunderstand one another about him; that I rather suspected the General finding him unpopular with the French, and that he would not answer their purpose, had persuaded col. Burr to shake him off. Easton replied, that col. Burr was in his power and that he dared not treat him in a deceitful manner. I replied I did not know col. Burr, but that his enemies represented him as an artful intriguer. Some time afterwards Mr. Easton came to me and observed that he believed my conjectures about col. Burr were true—and that he was to be made a sacrifice of; that he should go on to the seat of government and try what he could do for himself. Easton was then a Judge appointed by the President, but not confirmed by
the Senate, and he was apprehensive it would not; that gen. Wilkinson was using his influence to prevent the confirmation.—But observed, col. Burr was much in his power, for that he had made him proposals which made the hair rise upon his head, astonished and confounded him so that he was struck dumb. (General Wilkinson. Were these his very words? A. Yes.) That col. Burr observing this would have retracted but it was too late. I urged him to explain the nature of the proposals. He said he was under an obligation of secrecy; but no obligation should hold him if he found col. Burr false to him. I observed that he well knew that any obligation which lead him to conceal or commit a crime could not be binding. He observed he was going on to the seat of government and should see col. Burr, and then he should take his measures. I saw Easton after his return. I urged him to explain the business which he had mentioned before; but he pretended to have forgot that such a conversation had ever passed between us. Mr. Hay. Was his appointment confirmed? A. No. He lost his appointment and had seen col. Burr.) About this time a paper called the Western World made its appearance, one of which was I believe directed to the General weekly.
[Mr. Hay. After the return of Easton? A. Yes.] It roundly accused General Wilkinson of the old plan, of being concerned with Miranda and connected with col. Burr. I observed to Easton that I believed I should get the whole story from the Western World without being under any obligations to him; that if he had done his duty he might have served himself and his country and perhaps prevented the effusion of blood. He observed that he had once attempted to make a disclosure to Government, but instead of being countenanced he got a reprimand. I demanded the instance, he said that he had wrote to a Senator in Congress either from Vermont or New-York, that he could prove General Wilkinson to be the projector of Miranda's expedition. The gentleman acknowledged the receipt of his letter, but informed him he had burnt it, and advised him to mind his own business and take care how he meddled with men high in power and office. Mr. Martin. Had General Wilkinson any conversation with you with respect to the appointment of a certain John Smith of Louisiana? A. I had a conversation with him about John Smith. I remember going into the General's office when he handed me two letters, one from Major Hunt, the civil and military commandant, and the other from Smith, who complained that the commandant had ordered him off the mineral lands. The General censured the order and asked me if I knew who John Smith was. I replied no, but had been informed he was one of Cox's captains—so Major Hunt insidiously observes, replies the General—but that does not lessen him in my esteem. He added that Smith was brother-in-law to Mr. Early a member of Congress, who had brought forward a resolution to reduce the army and dispense with his services as General; that there were many of his stamp in Congress—therefore they must be attended and kept in good humour, or we shall be turned to the right about. Mr. Martin. Did you appear before the Secretary at war in order to make a statement as to the conduct of General Wilkinson which you considered indangered the United States, and what was his reply? Mr. Hay objected to the question as it had no relation to the subject. Mr. Wickham said that General Wilkinson had been interrogated by them and required to say whether his conduct was approved or disapproved by the Government; that the Government had taken the most active part in this prosecution and it was right and proper that the sentiments of the Government should be known. The Chief Justice said the difference is this. The evidence of General Wilkinson arose from communications officially made directly from the government. This is a different case—The evidence here offered consists of conversations with the officers of the Government. Mr. Martin said that the Secretary at War was applied to in his official character; and in his official character he had said that General Wilkinson must and would be supported; that he had stood low in the estimation of Government before his energetic measures at N.w. Orleans, but now he stood very high. Mr. Hay was about to make some observations in opposition to the introduction of such evidence, when General Wilkinson consented that the witness should go on.]
In March 1807, a few days before the rising of Congress, I was in the city of Washington, and waited on the Secretary of war, and the subject which gave rise to this visit and conversation between the Secretary at war, the Attorney General and myself, was an appeal from the sentence of a general Court Martial, whose proceedings I contended had been arbitrary and oppressive, and sentence illegal and unjust. (Mr. Wirt. Against whom? A. Myself, and that I was not arrested until after gen. W. had sounded and found I would not answer his purpose; and I believed for fear I might penetrate his plans and be a spy on his actions he determined to put me aside. The secretary at war replied that there had been a time when gen. W. did not stand well with the executive, but his energetic measures at New Orleans had regained him his confidence and he would support him. Mr. Wirt. Who? A. I mean the President. (I asked if an inquiry into the conduct of gen. Wilkinson, his oppressions and illegal acts and his connection with col. Burr might be expected. He answered there might be an inquiry after the present bustle was over; but at present he must and would be supported. I then observed that if an inquiry might be expected in a reasonable time I would ask a furlough and wait; but if not I should resign immediately.—He observed that I must not calculate on a speedy inquiry, but if I was determined not to serve under gen. W. my only resort was to resign immediately. (Mr. Martin. Who said so, gen. Dearborn? Yes, gen. Dearborn.) He however recommended me to draw up a short statement of facts for the President respecting my trial and sentence. I replied that if I did I should certainly charge gen. W. with having been connected with col. Burr, and with having made attempts to bring me over to his grand scheme of making fortunes. He replied if these are your impressions you will be correct in stating them. This was the first conversation I had with the Secretary at war.
I had a second conversation with the Secretary at war, in which I insisted that gen. W. was acquainted with Burr's plans; that I would produce proof that he had been concerned and did not secede till he found that col. Burr had commenced the enterprize with a handful of men, that the country was alarmed and the project was a desperate one. I then had a conversation with the Attorney General on the legality of restoring my pay and emoluments, which had been suspended by the sentence of the court Martial. I informed him that a connection between gen. W. and col. Burr could certainly be proved. He observed that the general had been low with the President, but at that time stood high and would be supported. He observed however, that there was a great deal of mystery in the allusions of col. Burr's letter to gen. Wilkinson, as well as their making
use of a cypher. He advised me not to resign, but to wait events, for the Secretary at war had informed him that I was the only republican field officer in the service, and that public opinion was very fluctuating and whimsical.
After this I had a conversation with the Secretary at War and the Attorney General together. I think that Capt. Clark, the companion of Lewis was also present. The Secretary at War shut the doors. We had some previous conversation, as after the Attorney General came in, the Secretary at War introduced it again, by observing, that he had been informed col. Burr had accompanied gen. Wilkinson to the Western Country, spent several days with him at Massac, and then furnished the colonel with a barge and men to descend the Mississippi to New-Orleans; I replied that this was one among many reasons to suspect a good understanding, connection and co-operation between the general and colonel—That I imagined both of them were well-informed of the old plan attributed to the general and his associates, to form a separate government West of the Alleghany under the auspices of Spain or England; of his famous memorial, which it is said procured him exclusive privileges from the Spanish government, and the extraordinary visit colonel Connelly from Canada paid him in Kentucky; but that there were recent events which were not without suspicion. Such as his having spent the last winter of col. Burr's vice-presidency at Washington; their great intimacy, the interest made to get gen. Wilkinson appointed and confirmed governor of Upper Louisiana, with Burr's brother-in-law, Secretary to the Territory, and many of his friends, to places of trust and influence. Gen. Wilkinson's drawing several hundred troops into a cantonment near the mouth of the Missouri; his connections with col. Burr, gen. Adair, John Brown of Kentucky, John Smith of Ohio, and several others, since implicated or suspected of being concerned with col. Burr, to procure a charter for cutting a Canal on the Indiana side of Ohio, on which charter a bank was ingrafted, and would have produced those funds, the want of which seems first to have made the general to hesitate—alluding to a paragraph in the cyphered letter. I then stated colonel Burr's visit to New-Orleans in a barge furnished by General Wilkinson; and that after visiting the lower country, he came to St. Louis. I then stated the conversation with judge Easton, as before mentioned, and the intimacy of those three persons, and that when col. Burr was about leaving St. Louis, the general had a barge got ready with much parade to put him over the Mississippi; that some time after col. Burr's return to the Atlantic States, Miranda's expedition got ready and failed, which a gentleman promised, if called on, to come forward and prove general Wilkinson to be the projector of; (that gentleman is Judge Easton.) I then observed that it was not easy to suppose, that Colonel Burr, who knew Wilkinson's character, his former attempts and desperate fortune, should spend so much time with him at Washington, where the scheme seems to have been first projected; pass through the country where col. Burr must commence his enterprize, where Wilkinson was well acquainted, and where Burr wanted agents (alluding to the Ohio), and partizans; yet never found him to make proposals, but wait till all was ready, and then make his first overtures by a letter; and before he knew the success of that letter in converting a patriot general into a traitor, should throw himself & his best friends, his choice spirits, into the power of a general he had so much insulted; that the general's measures in Upper Louisiana certainly had a tendency to disgust the people with the change of government, and to prepare them for a revolt; that I did not know the general's attempts upon other officers, but he certainly had tried me; but if on the contrary col. Burr did communicate his plans to the genl. either at Washington, at Massac, or at St. Louis, and the general did not immediately inform his government, he has not only grossly imposed on them, and the public at large; but has been guilty of misprision of treason and perjury. The Attorney General, after I had gone through my statement and information, in substance and order nearly as related, asked me what would be the result if all this should be proven?—why just what the federalists and the enemies of the present administration wish—it would turn the indignation of the people from Burr on Wilkinson; Burr would escape and Wilkinson take his place. I observed that it possibly might be the event, but justice and honor required that the whole truth should be known, let it operate as it might.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 26 November 1807
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va. · 28 November 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.
This opinion piece excoriates Aaron Burr's methods of manipulation, describing how he flattered young men, spread discontent against the Jefferson administration, and deceived even his closest followers like Blennerhassett. It portrays Burr as vain and self-deceived, noting his absurd plan to take New York with only a small force.
The Enquirer · 3 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
tion of the union, and on their right to establish a government of their own. Wherever he goes and wherever he dares to show the secret propensities of his soul, he seems bent, like Satan, on withering every bud of virtue; of depreciating the beauties of the system he opposed; and making every other bosom as morose and turbid as his own. But there is one trait in which Burr has improved upon his model. Burr's system was full of deception. He not only deceived the government and the people, but he lied even to his most sincere adherents.
See moreSee less
He persuaded the simple Blennerhassett, that Mr. John Graham was enlisted in his scheme. We shall not stop here to enquire who Blennerhassett was, and the great claims which he had to honourable treatment and fair dealing from Burr. But this was the man's constant system. He was continually magnifying the extent of his resources and the number of his friends. And indeed throughout the whole of this transaction Burr
This editorial piece condemns Aaron Burr's ambition and alleged conspiracy, describing his grand schemes to seize New York and overthrow the government as having failed. It reflects on how Burr, once a respected public figure with presidential prospects, is now viewed as a disgraced traitor due to his own flawed character rather than misfortune.
The Enquirer · 3 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
at firft in this attempt, but it was to fave his life at the expen[c]e of his reputation. This finesse of itself sufficiently shows how "the galled jade winced" at the production of the evidence.
The fate of this man furnishes a most instructive lesson to the members of a free Republic. Burr had been a great man in this country. He was elected by the suffrages of a free people to the second office of the government, because
A newspaper transcript records continued examination of evidence in Aaron Burr's commitment hearing, with witness Matthew Ellis describing deserter Dunbaugh's claims about pardons, letters, and his movements along the river. Burr and prosecutor Hay cross-examine Ellis about the witness's own travels and dealings with Blennerhassett.
Virginia Argus · 3 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
SATURDAY, October 3. MATTHEW ELLIS. Mr Burr. What do you know of Dunbaugh? Did you see him at Baton Rouge? A I did. He told me that he had just got out of prison for debt; by paying part of the debt and giving bail for the rest Q But what passed between you? A When I met him, I was surprised to see him. He said he had been arrested in Natchez by Lieut. Romney. Q For what cause? A As a deserter. Mr M'Rae. At what time did you see him at Baton Rouge?
See moreSee less
A On Sunday the 25th of March. Mr Burr. What further account did he give of himself? A He said that he had been sent down the river, that he had made his escape and had demanded protection of Governor Grand Pre at Baton Rouge. He said that he intended to stay there, till he had got his pardon from Gen Wilkinson, which he had written for. Mr Burr. His pardon for what? A For desertion. He told me that he had descended the river with you at Capt. Bissell's request; and that he had written to general Wilkinson, that if a pardon was sent to him he would come down and give information of all that he knew against you. He also put a letter into my hands for Capt. Bissel. Mr Burr. What was the purport of that letter? A To inform him that he
A witness describes letters between Burr and Captain Bissell, and details his sale of a boat and merchandise to Burr near Blennerhasset's island. Under cross-examination, he recounts his trading voyage down the Mississippi, his encounters with Blennerhasset's group, and his attendance at parts of Burr's trial in the Mississippi Territory.
Virginia Argus · 3 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
sold your boat to Blennerhasset at the mouth of Cumberland? A I sold it to Mr Burr; but went down in her to Natchez. Q You came with certain articles? A Yes. Q On a general trading voyage? A Yes. Mr Wirt. You went down in your own boat after you sold her to Burr? A Yes, I was not to deliver her till I got to Natchez. Mr M'Rae. What time did you pass Blennerhasset's island? A I do not exactly recollect; but some time in the latter end of November.
See moreSee less
Mr Hay. Where did Blennerhasset and his squadron fall in with you? A Not before I arrived at the mouth of Cumberland. Q Did you sell your merchandize to col Burr? A The greater part Q What induced you go down the river with them to Natchez, after your boat was sold? A Because it was not paid for. Mr M'Rae. What articles did you sell to col. Burr? A parcel of hoes, axes, iron and ploughs, I was not to receive any pay, till I got to Natchez. Q Were there any boats at the mouth of Cumberland? was Blennerhasset there? A I believe he was? Q Was Floyd? A Yes. Q Tyler? A Yes. Q Israel Smith? A I expect he was. Q You went down with Floyd a head? A Not altogether under Floyd. Q Why did you go a head? A I did not know. Q When did you leave Natchez? A About the first of March. Q You were not sent to New Orleans by any body? A No. Q What carried you to New Orleans? A business of my own. Q Did you carry any thing for sale to New Orleans? A May be, I had a few deerskins and some racoon skins left. Mr Wirt. How long did you remain in Orleans? A About 8 or 10 days. Q Did you see col Burr on your return? A I Did. Q Where did you see him last? A At Washington in the Mississippi Territory; where I was at the trial of col. Burr. Q Were you there when the trial closed? A No. I went up several times to hear it, but the croud was so great that I could not get in Q Why did you go to Washington? A I went to see col. Burr for a settlement. Q What claims had you on col. B.? A I do not exactly recollect the amount. Q Any claims for your boat? A Col. Burr consented I might take back my boat. Q What other claims had you? any for iron? A Yes, and for apples and other articles. Col. Burr had told me not to part
This sarcastic opinion piece, written from a mock-federalist perspective, celebrates Aaron Burr's escape from conviction and praises the judge's favorable treatment of him. It criticizes the legal advantages Burr had, including jury challenges, and mocks the 'democrats' who expected his conviction.
Virginia Argus · 3 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
NUMBER I. HUZZA for good old federal principles, and an union of honest men! The democrats are at length disappointed, and the federalists re-animated at the prospect of liberty, and live again opening to the view of their great leader Aaron Burr. I wish, Mr. Pleasants, you could feel that joy which
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
Written at the close of Burr's trial, this editorial offers the author's analysis of three key figures: Aaron Burr, the Chief Justice, and General Wilkinson. It focuses first on a critical character portrait of Burr, arguing his ambitions escalated from lesser schemes toward seizing supreme power, possibly a Mexican throne or western empire.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CURSORY REFLECTIONS
Aaron Burr : The Chief Justice of the U. S. And Gen. Wilkinson. There is nothing which we have to submit to our readers, which may not very properly fall under one of these heads.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This report analyzes General Eaton's courtroom testimony confronting Aaron Burr, arguing that Burr's demeanor and inability to effectively rebut Eaton's accusations prove his treasonous intentions. The writer walks through Burr's alleged schemes—from a Mexican invasion to Western secession—framing his caution and shifting plans as evidence of calculated treachery rather than innocence.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 4 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
FROM THE ENQUIRER.
CURSORY REFLECTIONS.
See moreSee less
At the close of the important trial which has so long agitated our city, our readers may very naturally call upon us to deliver our own opinions. To discharge this duty we once more take up the pen.
The subject is complicated and extensive. We shall attempt to seize its leading features and present them in the form of cursory reflections:
These reflections will naturally touch on three great portraits: that of Aaron Burr: The Chief Justice of the U. S. And Gen. Wilkinson.
There is nothing which we have to submit to our readers, which may not very properly fall under one of these heads.
No. I. PORTRAIT OF AARON BURR.
"Who noble ends by noble means attains, That man is great indeed ——."
Is such the greatness of the man who stands before us? Is such the character of the transactions, which have been lately unfolded to the world? Let us analyse both his ends and his means to see what pretensions they can give him to the character which the Poet has described.
This trait uniformly marks his conduct and designs; that he never is contented with a lower seat, so long as he can aspire to the highest. The mines and riches of Mexico are tempting objects; but even the wealth and splendor of the Mexican empire, when viewed through the long tract of water and wood which he would have to pass, and the dangers which were to be encountered, are lost and eclipsed in the superior lustre of a throne, erected at New-Orleans, and stretching its sceptre over the western states. From every thing which we can collect, as well from his own declarations where he dared to unbosom himself, as the more unguarded avowals of his less artful accomplices, A. Burr must have had three objects in view:
To separate the Western from the eastern states. To invade Mexico, or To effect a temporary settlement on the Ouachita.
The first was the foremost in his hopes and first in the period of its attempted accomplishment. The second was but to turn into a new course the very same means which he had collected, and the very passions which he should have excited for the attainment of the first. And the last, was to have been at once the asylum of his despairing ambition, and the germ of new schemes, where it "hush'd in grim repose expects its evening's prey."
Take the principal points of the evidence as they have been disclosed during this examination, and see how they bear us out in these conclusions.
The examination of Gen. Eaton before the court, and in the presence of the very man whom he arraigned at the bar, establishes the truth of his deposition beyond the shadow of a doubt. "Let us wait to see Eaton confronted with A. Burr," was the former cry of Burr's friends. "Let us see what Eaton will dare to say before him, or whether Burr will dare to contradict him." Yet this important confrontation is over, and what is the issue of it? We have seen gen. Eaton, standing in the very front of A. Burr, and under the flashes of that terrible eye which like Medusa's head was to have turned him into stone: but we have seen Eaton rising with the spirit of conscious truth and re-echoing the same charges against A. Burr without hesitation, and without the slightest alarm. We have seen A. Burr writhing under the consciousness of his guilt, and his bleached countenance betraying the agitations of his soul. We have seen Eaton persecuted, by the cross questions of legal ingenuity, but we have seen him turning upon his assailants, and bearing them down, with the consistency and truth of his story. After this who can doubt, that Burr was just as discontented with his situation, and as sanguine and aspiring as Eaton had represented him; that so long as he was doubtful of Eaton's dispositions for his purpose he amused him, with the tale of the Mexican project; but after having thus felt the pulse of his virtue, after having thus attempted to ascertain, how far his temper was lawless enough to acquiesce in this lawless scheme of plunder, and believing at last that he was unprincipled enough for his purposes, that he then began to open to him his favorite and grander scheme of aggrandizement. He talked to him of dismembering the union, of the ease with which he could separate the Western from the Eastern states, and the splendors of a throne at Orleans. He did not reveal these ideas as if they had just been hatched, or as if they would be lightly relinquished. Far from it. He dwelt upon his means. He named individuals whom he had selected for his purposes, and he was prepared to answer every objection which could be made to their accomplishment. After this, who is there sceptic enough to doubt, that this man was at heart a traitor?
His interviews with Mr. Stoddert point to the same conclusion, though with this material difference: that while he manifested the same discontented spirit, and the same contempt for the weakness of the administration which he was afterwards forced to respect, and the same idle confidence in his own means and talents, he did not dare to assail Mr. Stoddert's ear with the details of his plans. He did not designate N. Orleans as the point where he should make his attack; he did not name the persons whom he had chosen for his accomplices, and he seemed to disclose his ideas not as if they were such as he meant to execute, but as those that might be successfully attempted by some daring genius. The reason of this distinction is obvious. He knew that Mr. Stoddert was a man of too much virtue, and of too little means to become an accomplice. Gen. Eaton, on the contrary, was young, he was bold, he had shown a military turn, & his virtues had not yet been probed by Burr.
At Pittsburgh, while he was on his route to the Western country, and under the hospitable roof of the venerable George Morgan, he displays the same bent of mind. In truth, wherever he goes, he is destined like the snail to leave his slime behind him.— It would seem impossible for the mind of man, when seriously bent on any favorite idea, to prevent its bursting forth in continued and indirect indications. Burr's mind was full of war, of arms, of military atchievement, and the disunion of the states. And what were his conversations, and conduct? They were precisely such as might have been expected from this disposition. He could not see a strong man without considering him as a soldier, and wishing that he had a thousand such fellows. His conversation with the young Mr. Morgans before he reached their father's house, his conversations at and after dinner, breathe this predominant spirit. The same plans haunt him at midnight, and he descends at 11 at night with the candle in his hand to the chamber of old Mr. Morgan; for what? Mr. Morgan's ardent virtue stopped his communications, and prevents us from having the full benefit of the disclosure, but there is every reason to believe that his intention was to make the father an instrument in the ruin of his son, and exact from him his consent that this noble minded son should go along with him in his "nefarious" projects to the West. But why should we dwell upon such scenes as these? The whole air of his conversations, at Morganza, and next morning at Washington, was such as was calculated to draw down upon him the worst suspicions of all the Morgans, and to induce them to give the first information to government of his suspicious designs. The complaisant Mr. Julian Dupestre, may indeed deny all these things. But what weight should be given to that man's word, or vigilance of observation, who has to oppose the united testimony of the Morgans, or who upon being asked, whether N. York might not be taken with 500 men, could complaisantly bow assent?
Let us proceed another step in the investigation of this evidence. The next point where we are able to fix this wandering spirit is on Blannerhassett's island. Here it plays the same part; at least if I may calculate the cause by its consequences. Three days after Burr leaves the island, Blannerhassett publishes the Querist. Two circumstances are here calculated to blend Mr. Burr with the guilt or folly of these writings. 1st. That Blannerhassett, the author, was the notorious accomplice of Burr—and 2dly, that the sentiments and very chain of arguments were so similar to those which a witness had a short time before heard from the lips of colonel Burr, that upon being asked who he supposed to be the author; he very sagely replied, that Burr had furnished the ideas, and that Blannerhassett had put them into style.
These writings speak for themselves. No man that reads the Querist can mistake the disposition or design with which they were composed. Writings which display to the people beyond the Alleghany, the imaginary disadvantages of a union with the Atlantic states, which attempt to shew them in how much better condition they would be placed under a government of their own, which persuade them that it is not only a natural right, but a right ingrafted upon the constitution to provide for their own distinct welfare, whoever can mistake the temper of such writings as these from such men, and at such a time, might as well pretend to doubt whether the Declaration of Independence or Common Sense were calculated to promote the revolution of America. No man can doubt them, and no one can pretend to doubt but he who is an accomplice of Burr.
And here it is not improper to give all the weight which they deserve to Blannerhassett's sincere and repeated declarations. From the complex and uncertain code of the law, these declarations may not be received in a court of justice to bear against Burr, but common sense is unable to recognise such an absurd distinction. There are sufficient reasons to satisfy any man, that Burr and Blannerhassett were joint accomplices in a joint undertaking, and that however Burr may have imposed upon the credulity of Blannerhassett, in setting before him the extent of his means, that he fairly represented to him the nature of his plans. Let us then gather these plans from Blannerhassett's declarations, and what are they? Wherever he ventured to be the most frank, his schemes were of the grandest character.
It was not to settle the Ouachita land; nor was it to carry conquest to Mexico; but it was to seize the treasures and arms of Orleans, and by locking up that mouth of the Mississippi, to produce a dissolution of the union, and to establish an independent empire, to the west of the Alleghany. And to whom were these declarations made? Not to such men as Elijah Jones, not to men whom he knew not how to trust; but to such as the Hendersons, and to them too, not in the sportive sallies of his mind; but in the solemnity of retirement, and after he had previously exacted from them a pledge of secrecy. With all that childish garrulity which has been ascribed to him, the simple Blannerhassett could sometimes make distinctions. He was not as fortunate as Burr, in always keeping himself concealed behind the curtain; but like him, he sometimes knew where to be silent. Like him, too, he sometimes mistook his man, as he did in the case of the respectable Hendersons.
Combine with these circumstances, Swartwout's declaration to Gen. W. that there must be some seizing at N. Orleans; the discontented temper of many of the inhabitants of that city; their disposition for a change of government; and the number of friends whom he had there enlisted; recollect the aspiring genius of the man, his desperate fortunes and his vain hope, that the commander in chief and the army would join in with him, and it is impossible to resist the conviction that he would have seized New Orleans if he could*. What were his exact plans we know not; but we may at least guess at some chart, by which he might have steered his course. He might have supposed that he had force enough to descend to New Orleans. He might have passed Fort Massac and the fort at Chickasaw Bluffs, without much opposition. When arrived at New Orleans, he might have expected the aid of Wilkinson and army, and of many, and perhaps most of the inhabitants of that city.
His plan at this point, is not to be mistaken. If his force was large, if the army were sincere in his support—if the inhabitants of New Orleans were prompt and explicit in their attachment, Burr would have unfurled the banners of rebellion. He would have invited adherents from all quarters. He would have lavished the confiscated treasures of this city upon them, and perhaps he would have tried whether by locking up the mouth of the Mississippi, or restricting its navigation, he might not have forced the people of the upper country to have acquiesced in his usurpation. Such would probably have been his plan, or if these things had not turned out so favorable to his wishes, he would then have progressed with his other enterprise; collected arms, provisions and adherents, and attacked Mexico through a sea port as Vera Cruz, or up the Red River. For he frequently contended during his trial that his boats were well fitted for going up the stream.
If such were Burr's plans, was not Burr a traitor at heart? "But he did not commit the overt act, he was not guilty of levying war against the U. States." Perhaps it may be so. But even under this view of the subject, he saves his life at the expence of his reputation. He may still continue to breathe upon the earth; but what of that? Like Cain, he has a mark, that lasts for ever.
We shall hereafter inquire in our strictures on the conduct of the Chief Justice, whether the overt act of levying war was committed at the mouth of Cumberland river. We certainly do not approve of the criterion which the Ch. Justice has laid down on that point.
This mass of evidence is sufficient to convince us that the dismemberment of the union was the first and
* Do not Bollman's confessions to the President amply confirm this idea.
never would have looked to the conquest of Mexico, but in consequence of a fear that he should be disappointed. That object was the next nearest his heart. The host of witnesses who were introduced have proved his attachment to this enterprize; but "this was one" say his advocates "which he would never have meditated but from the prospect of an approaching war with Spain; and never would have executed but in consequence of that war's taking place."
In this we agree with his advocates; that if he had been disappointed in seizing New-Orleans and war had been declared by the United States against Spain, that he might then have attempted to turn his preparations into that channel. Perhaps they will agree with us in this; that if he had such an enterprise in view, the tottering state of our affairs with Spain was calculated to advance that object, by enlisting recruits in his service. But in this we join issue with his advocates; that if there had been no war from the United States, he himself would have attempted to have waged it against Spain on his own account. His friends deny this position and point to the settlement of the Ouachita as the ultimate object of his preparations. This last epithet indeed truly expresses our own opinion of his plans. Can any impartial man believe that he would have retired to the Ouachita until he had exhausted all his other plans? Were his means adopted for agriculture or war? Was his party composed of families or young men? Were they possessed of muskets and bayonets, or ploughshares and hoes? Were they provided with seed corn or kiln-dried meal? But why carry our questions further? Was the man who conducted them better calculated for a farmer or commander? Was the ardor of his desperate ambition to be sooner gratified in the bosom of retirement, and amidst the peaceful harvests of the field, or amidst the din of arms & by mowing of the heads of the Mexicans.
But if these presumptive reasons are not sufficient to remove every doubt, there are three direct facts which must be irresistable. Look at the declarations of Blannerhasset to Peter Taylor. Read the conversation of Comfort Tyler in Blannerhassett's Portico. Look at the testimony of Lemuel Henry who proves that Robert A. New, Burr's intimate friend and the only Virginian we are proud to say who was found under Burr's banners did actually ridicule the idea of a Ouachita settlement; said that it was a good idea to hold out to the world & that it seemed to go down very well.
The man who can resist this force of evidence, must have indeed inherited the soul of an ancient Sceptic.
"And is the settlement of the Ouachita completely out of the question? Did Mr. Burr never intend to visit his land? Why then did he pay so much money to col. Lynch for it?" To this we reply that he did not pay much money to col. Lynch as appears from his evidence, even admitting that there was a perfectly fair contract between them; and 2dly, that the veil which he purchased for his other enterprises was well worth the money which he paid for it; and 3dly, that had those enterprises succeeded, he might have easily have repaid himself from the banks of Orleans or the mines of Mexico. We agree with his advocates in this, that Col. Burr would have retired to the Ouachita as an asylum, but not until all his other schemes had been blasted. How long he would have remained there, is beyond our conjecture, but the probability is, that the Ouachita would have been a germ and not the grave of his ambition, and that being thus planted in the wilderness between Mexico and Orleans, he would have called around him the most desperate and enterprising men from all quarters, and then struck such a blow as would have best suited his means and his wishes. Thanks to the vigilance and energy of the government which has so far defeated his machinations!
Here let us pause. We shall hereafter pursue this subject as in relation to this man's means, to the consequences which are likely to arise out of his conduct, and to the lesson which it should teach us.
The writer defends himself against a rival editor ('the Farmer') who accused him of downplaying British hostility, arguing instead that claims of English collusion with Burr's treason and Indian incitement lack proof. He cites President Jefferson's own message to Congress stating such surmises are 'without proof or probability.'
The Wheeling Repository · 5 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
prove that the conduct of England was justifiable. I expressly declared my opinion, that the attack upon the Chesapeake could only be wiped away by reparation or war. Yet the Farmer has discovered that it was my "real design," to lull the spirit of the people asleep upon this subject. His vision must be uncommonly penetrating:
"For he has optics sharp, I ween, Who sees what is not to be seen."
See moreSee less
I have deemed it necessary to say this much in defence of my intentions; but I will not dismiss the Farmer without examining some of his positions. He asserts, that the "attack upon the Chesapeake was premeditated: that the Indians were stimulated to renew their savage murders: that the English were in collusion with Burr to destroy our internal peace;" and that these things took place in consequence of a "predetermination to go to war with us." All these assertions of the Farmer may be true; but there is no evidence of their truth before the public. There is no certainty that the Indians have hostile intentions. Indeed we know that some of them have solemnly declared the contrary. But the Farmer found the assertion in the Aurora, and he looked no farther.
It has been repeatedly declared in the Aurora, that the "English were in collusion with Burr." Therefore the Farmer has "no doubt" upon the subject. But the assertion rests without proof; and the President, in his message to Congress, of the 22d Jan. 1807, gives it no credit. He says, "Surmises have been hazarded, that this enterprise is to receive aid from certain foreign powers; but these surmises are without proof or probability." The Farmer, however, hazards the assertion that such was the fact; and perhaps he is better advised on the subject than the President. If he is not, it is rather rash in him, thus to impeach the President's veracity.
If the Farmer is correct; if a plan to "attack us in every vulnerable quarter," was formed at the time of the last
The report states that the inquiry into Aaron Burr and his associates concluded at Richmond on October 20th. A decision was made that day regarding whether to commit Burr, Blennerhassett, and Israel Smith to Kentucky for trial.
The Wheeling Repository · 5 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
NORFOLK, October 14. The Triumph, Captain Sir Thomas Hardy, the Leopard, Capt. Humphreys, and the Hamilton tender, have sailed for Halifax. The ships now on this station are the Bellona and Ville de Milan. Commodore Barron, we understand, has so far recovered from his late severe illness, as to be able to attend the court [of inquiry,] which stands adjourned to Friday next. New and positive orders, we understand, have been sent to the officers in the military service of the United States, not to enlist any British deserters.
Courtroom testimony describes a letter from General Wilkinson chiding Adair for caution and referencing a coming 'Spanish war,' with Adair later being seized by Wilkinson at New Orleans. The witness also lists other individuals who could testify to the connection between Burr and Wilkinson, including details about commissions, proclamations, and plans for a Western Empire.
The Enquirer · 6 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
(CONTINUED.)
give evidence of the connection between col. Burr and gen. Wilkinfon? A. Judge Eafton, to prove that gen. Wilkinfon was the projector of Miranda's expedition, and his connexion with col. Burr; Major Timothy Kibby the perfon whofe depofition has been printed, and Pierre Provenchere who could prove the connexion between gen. Wilkinfon and col. Burr, and who was the common friend of both; col. Samuel Hammond with whom gen. Wilkinfon had a converfation nearly fimilar with the one held with me, and Samuel Hammond, jun. I believe I did not mention col.
See moreSee less
Dupiefter, to prove the defigns of the party, as to the eftablifhment of a Weftern Empire. I think col. Dupiefter was mentioned as the friend of col. Burr, and as I am informed, came to St. Louis, as his agent, and brought with him commiffions and proclamations. Mr. McRae. Did you fee him at St. Louis? A. I did. A colonel's commiffion it is faid was offered to col. Chotau, who attempted to throw it into the fire. Mr. Hay. From whom did the proclamations and commiffions come? A. They were faid to be from col. Burr. Mr. Hay. Who was to have commanded the horfe? A. A Mr. Delony, who had been an officer of the horfe in the French fervice, & it was faid, was offered a diftinguifhed command in col. Burr's army. A col. Dupiefter, it was faid, brought on letters, one
Witnesses before the Burr treason trial are questioned about whether General Wilkinson's testimony before the judge matched what he told the grand jury, revealing minor variances regarding letters exchanged with Burr and details of the Natchitoches interview. Counsel and the court also dispute notes on testimony consistency between Wilkinson and Swartwout.
The Enquirer · 6 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
of Mr. Swartwout and Gen. Wilkinson? A. As to the delivery of the letter from Col. Burr, there is no material variance; but in the details of their conversations there was a very important one.
This piece debates the legal doctrine of constructive treason as applied to Aaron Burr, questioning whether Chief Justice Marshall's ruling was too lenient toward Burr given his earlier involvement in the conspiracy. It cites commentary from a Mr. Thompson, brother of the noted Curtius, arguing that all who were knowingly leagued in a general conspiracy should be considered traitors regardless of physical presence at the scene.
The Enquirer · 6 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
jure up this doctrine of constructive treason and all its terrors. If presence be necessary to prove the guilt of the man who plotted five years ago, and of whose subsequent co-operation no trace of evidence is produced, could it have been necessary in the case of Burr? A man, who formed this plot, who was preparing means for it, up to the time of the assemblage on Blennerhassett's Island, and even then; who afterwards joined them and conducted their movements? A man, who was in fact absent, from design?
The fact of presence is therefore very unessential in many cases. Its necessity will depend upon the circumstances of each particular case; but surely the Chief Justice might have been more explicit on this particular case of Burr's, than he has been.
See moreSee less
Let us pass to the second point and on this subject we shall submit the following reflections from the pen of Mr. Thompson, the brother of the celebrated Curtius, whose ideas we have so repeatedly used in this essay;
"The Attorney for the United States, had adopted the opinion of the Supreme Court of the United States, as the rule by which he was to model the prosecution. That opinion, in the mind of every man, except the Chief Justice of
The report describes the court's ruling that testimony not directly related to the overt act of treason at Blennerhassett's Island was irrelevant unless proven by two witnesses. It also includes commentary defending the public's right to judge the Chief Justice's conduct during the trial, and discusses jurisdictional reasoning for why Burr must be tried in Virginia rather than Kentucky.
The Enquirer · 6 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
rited— They are called to say, whether, after the expenditure of vast sums from their public treasury, the measure of national justice shall be curtailed, by the organ of national law. The issue between the government, and Aaron Burr, never fairly tried, in which the herculean efforts
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers
During the circuit court proceedings on the motion for commitment, defense counsel sought to introduce testimony from Major James Bruff to show inconsistency in General Wilkinson's account of Burr's intentions. Wilkinson angrily objected to the defense's characterization of him, sparking a heated exchange with opposing counsel in court.
Virginia Argus · 6 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
Tuesday, October 5.
See moreSee less
Evidence of Major James Bruff.
Mr Martin. Had you any communications with General Wilkinson about the time of his return to St. Louis? [Mr Hay requested that the object for which the witness was introduced should be stated. Mr Martin said, it was to prove the same as Timothy Kibby; that General Wilkinson held out the same inducements to him to join in an expedition against the Spaniards. Mr Hay objected to the introduction of the testimony, on principle. He said that no man could be presumed to come prepared to explain every particular act of his life; That the general reputation of a witness could alone be enquired into, in order to assail his character. This he held to be a sacred rule of law and of justice. Mr Martin contended, that the evidence was pertinent. General Wilkinson had declared that he had no knowledge of Col Burr's views till he received the cyphered letter. We will prove that he had. He did not mean to say, that the views of Col. Burr were criminal, on the contrary, they were perfectly innocent; nor would Gen. Wilkinson have been guilty if he had joined in them. But now General Wilkinson, in order to obtain favor with the goverment, had turned traitor to Col. Burr. Mr Wickham argued that the testimony of Major Bruff was admissible to shew an inconsistency in that of General Wilkinson.
General Wilkinson. May I be permitted to make one observation; I am not in the smallest degree surprized at the language which has upon this and several other occasions been used by the counsel of Colonel Burr; men who are hired to misrepresent. [Mr Wickham. I will not submit to such language from any man in court. The C. Justice declared the style of Gen. Wilkinson to be improper, and that he had heard too much of such language in court. Gen. Wilkinson apologized.—He said that it was impossible he could offer any intentional disrespect to the court, but he could not remain silent when he heard himself called a traitor.] General Wilkinson proceeded.—I am astonished at the explanation of the objects for which this witness is called. Had I known the purpose for which he volunteered his services, (for he was not summoned) I should have been able to produce documents to show the long, the implacable hatred which he has borne towards me. [Mr Wickham said that Major Bruff was under the protection of the court.] Gen Wilkinson—I pray that his testimony may be introduced. Mr Hay observed, that he had no doubt of the law, as to the right to impeach the credibility of a witness, by
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va. · 21 October 1807
The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 3 November 1807
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.
During Burr's treason trial, Major Bruff gives testimony about multiple private conversations with General Wilkinson in 1805, describing early hints of a Wilkinson-Burr connection from newspaper reports and Captain Stoddart. The defense sought to use this testimony to suggest Wilkinson shared Burr's alleged separatist views, while the prosecution argued it was only admissible to show inconsistency in Wilkinson's own testimony.
Virginia Argus · 6 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Major Bruff proceeded.
My testimony will arise from a number of conversations with General Wilkinson. In four of these conversations general Wilkinson took me aside; in three of which he locked me up in his room. The first hint I had of a connexion between General Wilkinson and Colonel Burr was drawn from two paragraphs in Kentucky newspapers, in the spring 1805, before General Wilkinson reached St. Louis; the first alluded to the old plan to form a separate government west of the Allegany, and ascribed it to General Wilkinson and his associates, and doubting whether that scheme had yet been abandonded. The next was an extract of a letter from Fort Massac, published in the papers, which stated that Col. Burr had been several days there with General Wilkinson, probably giving the general lessons on government, or digesting a new code or constitution for the government of Louisiana.—These hints, with information received from Captain Stoddart immediately from Fort Massac, and who assured me that Col. Burr was, or had been there closely engaged with General Wilkinson, and that he had or was about to furnish him with a barge and crew, to descend the Mississippi into New Orleans, [Mr Wirt. You have not said when. A. In June, 1805.] These circumstances put me on my guard, and determined me to watch the motions of General Wilkinson and Burr.
See moreSee less
As the general approached St. Louis, ascending the Mississippi from Fort Massac, he dispatched a light barge ahead with directions for me to meet him six or eight miles below. I obeyed. We met, landed and ascended the bank. The general took me into the woods. As we walked on, the general observed, that he had been informed the territory was divided by parties, (I mean upper Louisiana) which he attributed to the Americans, and said he would crush party, or perish in the attempt. I observed, that there had been some party business about the time of the convention and these memorials to Congress, but none since; except the aversion the French had to the expense, delay, and uncertainty of our laws, and the introduction of lawyers.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · Martinsburg, Va.
Jefferson's address to Congress reviews the Burr conspiracy, crediting militia and military action for its defeat, and states he will submit evidence from the Virginia Circuit Court arraignment of the principal offenders. He calls for Congress to examine whether failures lay in testimony, law, or administration, and to strengthen safeguards against treason.
Berkeley and Jefferson Intelligencer · 6 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
I informed Congress, at their last session, of the enterprizes against the public peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and his as-
Baltimore newspapers report threats to tar-and-feather or burn in effigy Luther Martin for defending Aaron Burr, with civil authorities issuing warnings to prevent riots. Rival papers trade accusations over the Mayor's sympathies and Martin's public advocacy for Burr.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 November 1807 · page 3
THE EMPIRE OF THE LAWS !
States and others would be burnt in effigy. We are authorised to say (and beg the “ young men” will take warning) that Efficient Measures have been taken to quell riot and preserve the peace of the ci ty. Fed. Guz. November -1. We had thought that Luther Martin intended to confine his vindication of Burr to a court of jus tice. lie has, however, turned Advocate for him in the newspapers ; and evinces that his malignity of heart and dislike of the present ad ninisti'al'oii far exceed his zeal for Burr.
See moreSee less
It Martin bud one grain of discretion, he would see the propriety of be ing silent at this moment on the scoie ol his “ ho nourable friendY’persecution, as he terms it. Hr may sharpen puhtfck indignation by his imprudence till it cuts liiinselt or some of his imperial cronies hi more than one place. American. "If the civil authority has taken precautions to prevent riots, as the Gazette says, we would just hint the good effects that would be produced by pitt ing Luther Martin in a strait waistcoat. The less that man says the better for the pobliek peace. , ibid. Burr’s presence in town and that of biscoadjuj
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, his counsel sought to introduce evidence that General Eaton had been convicted by a court martial, offering an affidavit that the original records were destroyed in a War Office fire. Prosecutor Mr. Hay objected, arguing such records were inadmissible and irrelevant to establishing a witness's general character.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 9 November 1807 · page 2
COLONEL BURR'S MOTION FOR CROSS EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE
MonssnctAY, October 55 ss zctssifz-ctfhractxsi'daysi Mfizsififlrrcterccirededkw in! ifz-ct f ujsse'xssctc edition ' hfsifs sithjrgete_;essgqiuet gensssisieþel fEa-y fObsi-L ,ct 'lss ,ss-Zsszszss'ctssi _. 4 ' ; siss M.i-;cti-Burr adsidreseed=3jrhesi court z—Isihare
This report praises President Jefferson's annual message to Congress, which addresses the Chesapeake affair and promises to submit the Burr trial proceedings for Congress to judge whether failures lay in testimony, law, or administration of justice. The paper commends Jefferson's handling of both foreign negotiations and the domestic fallout from Burr's case.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
We have received the President's Message, and it has afforded us sincere pleasure. It communicates all we wish, and in a manner which increases our confidence in the administration. It satisfies us that the negociations with England are conducted with the same moderation and firmness with which they commenced. It represents the true causes of delay, and the nature of the articles sent to the President from England, which obliged the refusal to ratify them.—The measures of the executive already taken in consequence of the attack on the Chesapeake, are satisfactorily explained, and the most interesting facts which accompany them. The statement relative to Mr. Burr
The report criticizes Judge Marshall's decision not to commit Aaron Burr for treason, noting instead he and Blennerhassett will be tried in Ohio on a lesser misdemeanor charge. The writer sarcastically suggests Burr will likely be cleared of even this charge, accusing Federalists of hypocrisy regarding judicial independence.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
ably to the anticipation of all, that Burr shall not be committed for treason; but by way of softening the matter has consented that Burr and Blennerhassett shall be committed for trial in Ohio, on the charge of misdemeanor! Even on this charge he will probably be cleared in some way or other. All this is very much as we predicted. What think ye, fellow-citizens, of Griswold's letter?
A Richmond death notice reports that Joseph Moxley, formerly a U.S. Navy midshipman, had been summoned to testify in Richmond on behalf of the United States against Aaron Burr. The notice states he killed himself by swallowing a dose of laudanum.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 10 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Mary Paul.
DIED.
See moreSee less
In New-Orleans, of yellow fever, Capt. George Waterhouse, of the Artillery of the United States, in the 35th year of his life; He appeared well on the parade one day, and died the next.
In Richmond, (Vir.) Mr. Joseph Moxley, formerly a midshipman in the U. S. Navy: He had been summoned to Richmond, on the part of the U. S. against A. Burr, and killed himself by swallowing a dose of laudanum.
In Boston, Mr. Samuel Hall, aged 67,—One of the oldest and most correct printers in the State. He edited a truly republican newspaper, from the commencement to the termination of the revolutionary war.
In Collegetown, (Me.) suddenly, Mr. Ezra Baker, aged 24; and Mr. Ebenezer Baker, aged 26.
In New-Chester, (N. H.) Mr. Joseph Favour; killed by the caving in of a clay-pit.
In Hopkinton, (N. H.) Lt. B. Eaton.
In this town, Miss Isabella Elliot, aged 73; Mrs. Smallcorn, consort of Mr. John S.; a child of Mr. Samuel Nelson, aged 6 weeks; Mrs. Candice Spring, (a woman of colour) relict of the late Mr. Spring.
General Wilkinson's testimony continues, describing his impressions of Burr's plans involving a possible expedition against Mexican provinces with British cooperation, contingent on war with Spain. He also notes Burr's continued political influence, including his step-son's judicial appointment and Senate support.
The Enquirer · 10 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT. Thursday, October 8. Gen. Wilkinson's evidence continued. I had formed several opinions of Mr. Burr's views: fometimes I thought them chimerical and the moft definite idea I had ever attached
Courtroom examination of Major Bruff regarding his suspicions about Burr and General Wilkinson, focusing on the dating and content of letters he wrote describing a supposed grand project. Prosecutors press him on whether his January 1806 letter contained the specific facts he now recalls, or only vague hints.
The Enquirer · 10 November 1807 · page 2
1 arc not thofe letters with me. I did thi.ik that Wilkinfon and Burr were counseled and acting hi concert, and under th's inipreniou re
Witnesses are cross-examined about suspicions of General Wilkinson's conduct and letters warning officials about Burr and Wilkinson's alleged treasonable designs. Captain Gaines also recounts overhearing Major Bruff discuss being subpoenaed to testify against Wilkinson.
The Enquirer · 10 November 1807 · page 2
Government ? A. I think in November 1805. Mr. McR,ie. Did you i.<-t give Eaflonfpeci.il letters of introd'Mftion to your friends ? A. I believe I did, or if 1 did not, f ought to have done f>-*, |!r was then denouncing Birr «nd Wi kinfon. Q Was that after you fufpetted him of I reafnnsble dcligrs ? A. It was af-rr be mentioned »he treafnnable di ligns of Burr -V Wukinfon. Q. 1) <1 you i;o? writ** to vonr f> tends, particularly recommending K ill »n ? A. J wrote to Mr.
See moreSee less
R if rrt "Wright and jisii. Samuel .Smith, as to the ft ate of the Tt rr it mv, and that Judge EtAon \v • * perferuted by Wilkinfon, and w united with in to penetrate and dt teat ihtir ihfigr g. O. As tar back an November iso.s, w.ih there a public rii nuneiation ? A. I gave t he conversations with Judge E-ffon the day before yeftcrdiy. When did Judge Barton fwindie you ? A. My irdmrr.ition " as long lince that eonverfition. O Arc you on terms <>l intimacy with him nose ? A. No: at vari ance. We have an arbitration defending. CapUrin Edmund Pendleton Getintj.
This is courtroom testimony from Major James Bruff describing Burr's 1805 meeting with Judge Easton in St. Louis, in which Burr allegedly inquired about an officer to lead an expedition to Santa Fe. Bruff also recounts suspicions of collusion between Burr, Easton, and General Wilkinson based on prior communications about the Santa Fe route.
Virginia Argus · 10 November 1807 · page 1
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
Tuesday, October 5. Evidence of Major James DruJJ'. ( Continued.) Col. Burr arrived u little time after this at St. Louis. (Mr. Wirt. At what time ? A. i believe in August, 1805 ) A Judge iiaston who appeared to think very high ly of col. llurr and boasted of possessing a part of his confidence, informed me that col. Burr had .uqui.-.d of him, whether tnere was any officer of experience and enterprise who could lie trusted with the command of an expedition to Santa Fee, and gave me a very inquisitive look.
See moreSee less
I de mumled hy what authority col. Burr made the enquiry, or in what light I was to view it. 11c replied that col. Burr at that time held no puo.ic o.Tice, but that he had pow erful friends and would probably be in a very exalted situation before long; that 1 had been weil spoken of to col. Burr, (I suppose hy himself) and he advised me to make him my friend. 1 answered that the enquiry was a suspicious one ; for if government chose to employ me in that *r any other way, it had a light to command my services—for (I was in service at that time) We dropt the subject. (Mr. Mar tin. Was Easton at St. Louis? A. Yes.
A witness recounts conversations with Easton about General Wilkinson's suspected dealings with Burr, including hints of a shocking secret proposal Burr made that Easton refused to disclose. The testimony also describes the Western World newspaper's accusations against Wilkinson regarding ties to Miranda and Burr.
Virginia Argus · 10 November 1807 · page 1
(Gen. Wilkinson. Were these bin ver words i A. Yes ) That c«>5. Burr obser ving this would have retracted nut u wa too late. I urged hint to explain the na . lure of the proposals, lie iie whs un ( der an ooligstion of secrecy ; but no nidi gnth’ii should hold him if be i<ui id dl. Bur j L lsc to him. I otncimu that lie well kne, ; tit.it any obligation which Tad him toc.oii t eal or commit a crime cmiid not be Ihml ing.
See moreSee less
He observed he wu* going on to th . suit in government and simu.d se" co ■ horr, amt then he should lake his men *• seres. 1 s »w Fusion al>er his return, s ii;*ed him to explain the buYis. 9s whic he had mentioned hsfws'U ; hul he preten ded to lmvc forgot that sufth a ctmverss turn had ever passed between n». (Mi May. Was his appointment confirmed 1 A No. Me lost his appointment and h.i [ seen col Burr ) AI*out this time a pap* Called the Wvo.ciu World made its
President Jefferson's message to Congress recounts the suppression of Aaron Burr's conspiracy through militia action and military vigilance on the Sabine and Mississippi. He notes he will submit the evidence from the Virginia district court proceedings so Congress can judge whether the law, testimony, or its administration failed to secure conviction.
The Wheeling Repository · 12 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
for present defence ; and have, moreover, encouraged the acceptance of volunteers, and I am happy to inform you that these have offered themselves with great alacrity in every part of the union; they are ordered to be organized, and ready at a moment's warning to proceed on any service to which they may be called, and every preparation within the executive powers has been made to insure us the benefit of early exertions. I informed congress at their last session, of the enterprises against the public peace, which were believed to be in preparation by Aaron Burr and his associates ; of the measures taken to defeat
This report prints Chief Justice John Marshall's opinion, delivered October 20, 1807, on a motion to commit Aaron Burr, Harman Blennerhassett, and Israel Smith to Kentucky for trial on charges of treason and misdemeanor. It begins by noting the unusual circumstances of the case compared to typical commitment motions.
The Wheeling Repository · 12 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
TH: JEFFERSON. Tuesday, Oct. 27th, 1807.
OPINION Of Chief Justice Marshall, Delivered the 20th October, 1807, on a motion to commit Burr, Blennerhasset, and Israel Smith, to Kentucky, to be tried for treason and misdemeanor.
See moreSee less
Much of the difficulty of the present case arises from its being attended by circumstances entirely opposite to those which are usually found in motions of a similar description.
An examining magistrate commits and ought to commit on probable cause. In defining his duty, after stating that he may arrest either upon his own sus-
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
This piece argues the President had a constitutional duty to protect the nation against Burr's treasonous or warlike scheme, and acted properly by disclosing evidence to Congress. It defends Jefferson's suggestion that a defect may exist in the testimony, the law, or its administration, noting even the Chief Justice has acknowledged deficiencies regarding treason law in U.S. territories.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 13 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Under his oath it became his duty to the best of his ability to protect the constitution against Aaron Burr and his associates, whether their ends
An article reprinted from the Citizen criticizes mob action in Baltimore, arguing that even though Burr and his associates are detestable conspirators, mobs cannot be the proper judges of a Chief Justice's rulings and the civil authorities should have suppressed the riot. The piece also contains unrelated foreign news about the surrender of Copenhagen and a Tunisian-Algerine battle.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 13 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
The Riot at Baltimore
He who cannot hate, with a holy hatred, a conspiracy like that of the miscreant Burr, and the persons who were engaged in it, and yet be orderly, and yet be decorous, and yet be respectful to the laws of his country, has no claim to the appellation of a good citizen."
The ship ————, capt Stanwood, arrived at Boston on Thursday in 53 days from Gottenburgh. Our correspondent informs us that she left there on the 13th of September, previous to which time official intelligence had been received of the surrender of Copenhagen to the British on the 7th and that the Danish fleet was to be sent to England in six weeks from the time of signing the convention.
See moreSee less
On this subject a respectable merchant of this city has received a letter from an Ameri-
Thomas Lindsay is recalled to clarify details about a memorandum for a deed between Col. Lewis and Burr, confirming no mention of corn, roads, or similar items. Another witness discusses Ephraim Kibby's military rank, and a prior witness clarifies his earlier testimony about a conditional flour contract with Burr that was never delivered due to the President's proclamation.
The Enquirer · 13 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITMENT. Examination of evidence, continued.
In the course of Wednesday Thomas Bodley was again called into court at the request of the attorney for the prosecution.
See moreSee less
Question by Mr. McRae. You mentioned in your testimony on Saturday last, that a memorandum was given you to write the Deed by, from col. Lynch to Mr. Burr; Was there any thing in that memorandum about corn, cutting roads or making settlements? A. There was not; it was simply a memorandum stating the quantity of land to be conveyed, the description of it, and the consideration; the Deed was wrote agreeable to the memorandum—I never saw the original contract, but was informed by the parties there were other stipulations in their agreement. Q. Was there any thing of corn, cutting roads, &c. mentioned in the deed? A. There was not. Mr. Hay. Do you know Ephraim Kibby? A. I do. Q. In what capacity did he act in gen. Wayne's army? A. In the year 1793 he had command of a small party of spies or Rangers; in 1794, he had command of a larger party—and in both years was called captain Kibby.
Mr. Bodley. As I am again before the court I beg leave to observe on part of my testimony more fully; I stated that "I made a conditional contract with Col. Burr for flour"—I did engage two boat loads of flour with a view of letting him have it; but before the boats were sent off, the President's proclamation came to hand and no part of it was ever delivered to col. Burr or to any person for him.—When col. Burr enquired of me if men could be got to go to Mexico in case of a war, I gave it as my opinion, they could. I gave him the names of a number of young men who I thought would probably engage, and made him acquainted with some of them. Having heard it remarked since I gave my testimony that I must have had some knowledge of col. Burr's plans; I think it my duty to state, that in every conversation I had with col. Burr, his remarks relative to an enterprise against Mexico, were predicated on a war with Spain; and I never did hear him or any other person with whom he had conversed in Kentucky, intimate that he had any thing in view inimical to the U. S. or that his views were in any respect treasonable.
I hope that the court will indulge me with one further observation. I have been charged by the editors of the Western World (which paper I consider one of the most scurrilous, abusive and unprincipled ever published) with being a partizan of col. Burr; I have been represented in that paper in different capacities, from the foot pad to the aid of col. Burr. I avail myself of this opportunity, under the solemnity of an oath in the presence of this court and before the whole world, to declare, that I never have, either directly or indirectly been engag'd in any act of treason against my country, or in any misdemeanor in violation of the laws of the United States. I am firmly attached to the Federal Government, and will do my utmost to support it whenever my services may be required.
A witness defends himself against accusations of being Burr's partisan, denying under oath any treasonous acts and stating Burr's Mexico plans were premised on a war with Spain. Another witness, Lemuel Henry, is recalled to testify about a guard posted near Burr's lodgings in Washington, Mississippi Territory.
The Enquirer · 13 November 1807 · page 1
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION FOR COMMITMENT. Examination of evidence, continued. In the cniine or Wednefday Thomas Untiley wit j gain called into court at the req.ielt of the attorney for the profecution. Oucftion hy Mr. AfcPue. You mentioned in your tcltimony on Saturday lalt, that a memorandum was x given you to write the Deed hy, fr.en col. !.)mS to Air. Burr; Was there any thing in that memoran dum about corn, cutting roedsor making frmem.tiu ? A. There was not; it was tiinply a memorandum Ha ling the quantity of land to he conveyed, the deferip tionofit,and the confideration ; ihe Deed was w rote agreeable to the memorandum—I never law the ori ginal contract, hut was informed hy the parties there ■were other Copulations in their agrtemenf.
See moreSee less
Q. Was there any thing of corn, • toting road*, ike. mention- : ed in the deed? A. There w as not. Mr. IIj y. Do you know Ephraim Kihhy ? A. I do. O. In w hat capacity did l.e ad in gen. Wayne’* army ? A In the year 1793 he had command ol a fniall party <•( , Ipies or P.angers; hi 171)-I, he had command of .. I n - , ger party—and in both years was called captain Kilt, by. Mr. Ite-Hry. As I am again before the court I beg 1 leave to ohierve on part of ivy tefiiniony more fully ; ] fiattil f! at “ I made a ctivtiviotial contrad! with L't.l. Burr for Hour”—I did engage two boat l.v.d* of flour j with a view of letting him have it; 1-tit 1 ltd ore the boats w ere ient off, the Pri (idem procl; mation came fo hand and no part of it t*a* ever t|t l.ver*d to col. 1 Burr f»r to-;iy perfon h>r |iiiit.--When cot. Burr enI qnired ef me il nu n could be got to go t<> Mexico in i cafe of n war, 1 gave it as my opinion, they could. ] I gave him the names of a number of young men 1 who I thought would probably engage, anti m ide him ! acquainted with fume of them. Having heard it re* ' marked fince l gave my teflimony that I mull have ; had lonit knowledge of ml. Burr’s plans ; I think ir , riy duty to Hate, that in every r.uiveriatiou I had with col. Burr, hi* r<-m:,i k* relative to on euterprife againll Mexiio, were predicated cu a war with Spain; and I never did bear him or any other peri.ui with whom be had converted in Kentucky, intimate tliar he had any tiling in view inimical to the U S. or that hi* views were in any r.-tpe£l treafonuble. I hope that the cuurt w .11 indulge me with one •further obferration. 1 havbeen charged l»y the e. 1 riitorol the tt'ijhrn V.’trld (which paper I confider one of the moll fcurri!< : ■>, abufive ami unprincipled ever published) withluiug ap;.rt:z.n ol cch Burr; I have been rtprefe.. in that pa> it ill difT-emt ca pacifier, frotn theyosf /-•/./to the ,i.d «[ col. Burr. 1 avail nay It If of this i ppuTinnity, i ma r il.t foleumitv of an oath sn tin. prelenci < t this court and hrii.re tlie whole work!, to declare, tr.at I never have, e»lier di reiflly or indirectiy hern engag’d in any aiff of treat.,n rs/inil ivy country, *r in ai-v ivHilemtunorin viulati «•' vt ife lows ol uiv Dull..; Slates. I an: firmly at tad.i «.l to the Federal Coverl merit, and will do my utmoft tolupport it whenever niy Icrvices may bere quir«d.
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, attorneys dispute whether General Wilkinson can be impeached as a witness by proving he received Spanish silver payments while denying correspondence with Baron de Carondelet. Defense counsel argue Wilkinson's conduct is explained by his secret Spanish pension even as he publicly opposed Burr's expedition, while prosecution objects to the line of questioning as improper character attack.
The Enquirer · 13 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
of his innocence) refused his request. Gen. Hamilton also declared that he thought the charge a slander, and a trial unnecessary.
Mr. Wickham. Receiving money from the king of Spain is not an indictable offence. Our ground of defence is that Mr. Burr's expedition was in concurrence with Gen. Wilkinson, against the dominions of the king of Spain, in case of a war. If we pr[o]ve that at the time Wilkinson was pretending to fa[vor] Burr's expedition, and secretly determined to defeat [it], he was receiving a Spanish pension, this will explain his conduct. He defeated the enterprize of Burr by making a charge of treason against the United States, on purpose to save the king whole money he was receiving.
See moreSee less
Mr. Martin. I am not surprized that gentlemen should have so much feeling on this subject; especially the gentleman who made this objection. There can be no prosecution against a man for receiving Spanish money. Mr. Benjamin Sebastian, in Kentucky, was indeed accused of this as an offence; and it was proved upon him; but I have not heard, though he re[sign]ed his office of Judge, that any prosecution was instituted against him. For my part I wish there was a little more Spanish money among us. I should like to have some of it myself. We wish to show that Gen. Wilkin-
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
Major James Erwin testifies about letters revealing a connection between General Wilkinson and Colonel Burr's plans, including an expedition toward Santa Fe. He expresses surprise that witnesses who could prove this connection were not summoned before the Grand Jury.
Virginia Argus · 13 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT
TUESDAY, October 5.
Evidence of Major James Bruff. (Continued.)
See moreSee less
I then left the Attorney General and Secretary at War together, and stepping down to the post office, found letters from St. Louis, detailing the operations of col. Burr; and of a party from St. Louis and St. Geneva, the common friends of gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr, who attempted to join him with twelve thousand weight of lead. (Mr Wirt. Who was the letter from? A. Samuel Hammond.) That letter offered proof that the party sent by gen. Wilkinson to Santa Fee, was connected with, and a part of col. Burr's plans.—As that letter related to the subject which we had been talking on, I sent it to the Secretary at War, and the Attorney General; and another letter which came on with it to the same point from judge Easton. They wrote that Major Wasot and Dr. Stell had left St. Louis and were joined by a Mr. Smith, Dodge, &c. from St. Geneva, who attempted to join col. Burr near the mouth of the Ohio. The Secretary at War returned the letters and thanked me; but I have been surprized after offering proof, and naming gentlemen who knew that a connexion existed between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr, that none of them were summoned to the Grand Jury. Maj. Bruff was here asked who those gentlemen were, and he mentioned gen Adair, judge Easton, and Major Kibby, who would prove the object of the expedition to Santa Fee, also Mr. Provinchere. He then stated that he had seen a letter from gen. Wilkinson to gen. Adair, in which gen. Wilkinson urged him to come on, said that he could not go without him, and then asked if he was ashamed to serve under a Spanish conspirator. Gen. Wilkinson. When was that letter dated? A. I do not recollect when. Gen. Adair read it to me, he offered me a copy, which made me the less particular about its date. Q. Where was the letter received? was it at Washington in March last? A. It was the letter which induced gen. Adair to go to Orleans, as he said. Gen. Wilkinson pressed him to come on: said that thirty thousand troops would be sufficient to effect their purpose; as they would have little more to do than to take possession of the country; that they would have to divide them into three columns, and gen. Adair was to have the command of one of them. Mr. McRae. What country were they to take possession of? A. I cannot say; but my impression was the Spanish country. The general then chided him for the caution he used in writing; asked him if he was afraid to trust his friend or ashamed to serve under a Spanish conspirator. At the bottom of the letter were these words: "We shall certainly have a Spanish war." Ch. Justice. Do you know the hand writing of Gen. Wilkinson? A. I do very well. I sat by gen. Adair when he read the letter: and appeared to be the hand writing of gen. Wilkinson; but I did not take it up to compare it. Mr. Martin. Do you remember the date? A. I cannot tell the date or the place from which it was written.
Mr. Hay. Did it appear as if it was of ancient date or modern? A. Recent—Gen. Adair complained bitterly; he said that this letter had induced him to go to New-Orleans, where he was seized by gen. Wilkinson. Mr Wirt will you name all the witnesses, who could give evidence of the connection between col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson? A. Judge Easton to prove that gen Wilkinson was the projector of Miranda's expedition, and his connection with col. Burr; Major Timothy Kibby the person whose deposition has been printed, and Pierre Provinchere who could prove the connexion between gen. Wilkinson and col Burr, and who was the common friend of both: col. Samuel Hammond with whom gen. Wilkinson had a conversation nearly similar with the one held with me, and Samuel Hammond, jun. I believe I did not mention col. Dupiester, to prove the designs of the party, as to the establishment of a Western Empire. I think col. Dupiester was mentioned as the friend of col. Burr, and as I am informed, came to St. Louis, as his agent, and brought with him commissions and proclamations. Mr McRae. Did you see him at St. Louis? A. I did. A colonel's commission it is said was offered to col. Chotan, who attempted to throw it into the fire. Mr. Hay. From whom did the proclamations and commissions come? A. They were said to be from col. Burr. Mr. Hay. Who was to have commanded the horse? A. Mr. Delony, who had been an officer of the horse in the French service, and it was said, was offered a distinguished command in col. Burr's army. A col. Dupiester, it was said, brought on letters, one to Provinchere and another to Timothy Kibby, the common friend of col. Burr and gen. Wilkinson. Chief Justice. Did you see these letters? A. We had a little democratic club intended to counteract these gentlemen. A Mr. Wherry to whom Provinchere shewed the letter, took a copy of it, and brought it down to us. Mr Wirt. What was in the letter? A. Something to this purport: "He was ready; hoped they were ready; and, that the expedition would begin to move about the 15th Nov." Mr. Martin. How long have you been in the American service? A. I bore arms in 1775 against the tories, had a 2d
A witness testifies about a letter from General Wilkinson to General Adair urging him to join an expedition against Spanish territory, describing plans to divide troops into three columns. The witness also names additional people, including Judge Easton and Major Kibby, who could testify to the connection between Burr and Wilkinson.
Virginia Argus · 13 November 1807 · page 1
Tuesday, October 5. Evidence of Major Janies Era f. f Continued.) T then left the Attorney General and Se cretary at War together, and stepping Fnyn t.o the post office, found letters from it. L »uia, detailing the op: rations of col. Burr; and of a party from St. Louis an l St. Genova, the common friends of yen WiWovm and col. Burr, Who attempted to j >ia him with twelve thousand weighted 'end. (Mr Wirt. Who war. the letter from ? A. Samuel Ma-nm >nd ) That letter offered proof that the party sent by gen.
See moreSee less
Wilkinson to S i Fee. was connec ted with, and a part of r. »1. Burr’s plans.— As that letter related t > the subject which we had been talking oa, I sent it to the Secretary at War, and the Altornev Gc acr.il; and another letter which came on witii i: to the same p dor from judge Hus ton. They wrote that Major Was ot and Dr. Stcll hud left St. Louis and were join • 1 by a Mr. Smith, Dodge, 8cc. fr > n St. Geneva, who attempted to join col. Burr near the mouth of the Ohio. The Secre tary at War returned the letters and thank ed me ; but I have been surpriz *d alter nfioriny proof, and naming gentlemen who knew that a comectu-a exis*c 1 between gen. Wilkinson and col. Burr, that n no of them were summoned to th • Gran l Jury. M m. Bi'U.T was h# re asked who tnose geu t!cmrn were, and he rrv rtim • ’ n Adair, judge F.astnn, an 1 Major Ki .oy, who would prove t’ac object of the expedition to Santa F «, nlsn Mr. Provinchege. ide unm o. i* i:uin»: nil hern ir/vcr :rom gen. V\ Ikinson to gen. Adftir, in which gen. Wilkinson urged him to come on. said that he could not go without him, and then *ked if he was nsirtmed to sew" un der a Snsnish conspirator. Gen. SVdfcin sc.n. When was thit letter dated ? A. i do not recollect v hen. Ci n. Adair readit to roe, he oHlw ■* ne a cony, which mad me the lex<5 particular ah <tV. it*, d lie. Q. Where was the letter received? w is i t Washington in March last? A. hum* he letter which indu ed gem. Adair to go to Orleans, Us he said. Gc-rt. Wilkinson pressed him to er-roc on : s -d tie t thirty tlvusand troops would be su-orient to cf !*:c. their purpose ; r.s they would have little more to do than to take possession of the country ; that they would have to di vide them into three columns,- and gen. Adair v..s to have the command of one of then. Mr. McRae. What country were they to take possession of? A. 1 cannot say ; hut my impression was the Spanish country. The general then chided him for the caution be used in writing ; asked him if lie w isafr ii<1 to trust his friend or ashamed to serve under a Spanish conspi rator. At the h ittom of the letter were these words: “We shell certainly have .. -panish war.” C-h. Justice. I)n you know ’he hand writing of G n. Wilkinson ? A. T do very well. I sat by gen. Adair when he read the letter : and appeared tobc the hand writing of gen. Wilkinson; but I did imt take it up to compare if. Mr. Martin. l)n you retn-rnber the .date ? A. I cannot toll the date or the place from which it was written. Mr. I lay. Did if appear ns if it v/r>s of ancient date or mcl #;? A. Recent — G<-n. Adnir complained (utterly; he said that this letter h id induced him to go to N "\v.Orleans, where lie was seized by gen. j Wilkinson. Mr Wirt will you name all the witnesses, who could give evidence of the connection between col, B irr arid gen. W ilkiusnn ? A. Judge Kaston to prove that gen Wilkinson war. the projector of Miranda’s expedition, mid his connection with col. Burr; Major Timothy Kibhy ihc person whoso deposit ion has been printed, and Pierre Provinchrre who could prove tllP roilliPvinn l»f>t rrr»t* V\/lt 1J .. col Burr, and who was the common friend of both : coi. Samuel Hammond with whom gen. Wilkinson li id a conversation ne rlv similar with the one held with me, ano Samuel Hammond, jun. I believe I did not mention cel. Dupicster, to prove the designs of th»* party, as to ihe establish ment of a Western Empire. 1 think col. Dupicster was mentioned as the friend «>t col. Burr, and os I am informed, rstrir tr St. Louis, as his agent, and brought v. i' h him t.emmt'.sioi s and prori'imr.ti'T.s. Mr McRae, Did you see him at St. Louis? A. I did. A colo/iei’s commission it b said was ofT ie.i to n.l. Ctioian, who fit tempted tot now it into the fire. Mr.Hay. I i’in whom did the proclamations ano commissions rome ? A. Thev were said to be from col. Burr. Mr. H y. Who was to have commanded the horse ? A. Mr. Delony, who tmd been an i>Pir#*t* of the horse in the French service, and itwa* so id, was offered a distinguished command in col. Burr’s rirmy. A col. l)nple-ter, it ’•"as said, hr.vsyhton letters, uiy* to I’vo vinchcre and another to Timiwhy Kibbr, the common friend of col Ifftrr and jrt-n. Wilkinson. Chief Justice. Did ymj sec these letter n ? A. Wc had a little rb nun rr".t'>c club intended* to counteract thr«e i-cntlemen. A Mr. Wherry to whom 1’ro vinchcre she wed the >tte*. took a copy of it, and brought it down to iis. Mr Wirt. What was in the let'er ? A. }»',imethirte to this purpor* : “ lie was ready ; ho peti they were ready; end, that the expe dition would begin to move about the ij.»li Nov.” M r. M.rrtiti. II<rv h’ng have yoi been in the American service? A. I !»ort arms in 1775 against the torse. , had + 2.
A fiery political essay criticizes Chief Justice Marshall for acquitting Aaron Burr of treason, invoking the pseudonymous writer 'Curtius' who had questioned Burr's motives and talents. The author speculates about hidden schemes and urges political allies not to lose heart despite the setback.
Virginia Argus · 13 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
to blame the Chief Justice, for the commitment of the illustrious Burr. He has acquitted him of treason, and perhaps more ought not to have been expected.—
The great writer, whose hallowed name I have used, suspected his motives, on account of the greatness of his talents: he stated, "that the gross errors of a mind "like his, excited the mingled emotions of "suspicion and wonder; that it was difficult to believe that genius and knowledge, "could seriously adopt, the monstrous opinions of imbecility and prejudice; that "when we hear a man of uncommon understanding, advocate absurdities, which "are palpable to the plainest capacities, "we cannot help suspecting the sincerity "of his declarations, and the purity of his "motives." In those very talents which
A witness is questioned about General Wilkinson's arrival in New Orleans in November, his disclosures of danger to the colonel, and the public reaction including support for Burr and criticism of Wilkinson in the press. The testimony covers the state of public opinion both before and after Wilkinson revealed Burr's alleged plans.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Burr, and were much opposed to the measures of general Wilkinson. Q What appeared to be the general impression on the minds of the citizens, & what was their conduct before and after gen. W. exposed the plans of col. Burr? A Before the disclosure of those plans it was a general subject of enquiry as to the conduct of general Wilkinson in taking post at New Orleans, and many censured the measure. About that time several numbers of the Westeren World appeared, in which many severe strictures were cast upon general Wilkinson and others, which after the disclosure made by general Wilkinson at the government house, occasioned very considerable commotions among the citizens. It became a general topic of conversation in the coffee house, in the hotels and even in the streets. I will repeat further that there appeared to be a large portion of the mercantile interest in favor of general Wilkinson's conduct, some censured and some doubted. General Wilkinson condescended to ask my opinion, having previously made a full disclosure of the dangers and of the measures which he had adopted. I did give my advice in favor of seizing every man whom he found opposed to his measures. This was after a developement of the state of affairs by gen Wilkinson.
Mr. Martin. And that not to be depended upon.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wirt. That will be a subject of discussion hereafter.
Mr. Martin. I know that.
Mr. Wirt [in a low tone of voice] to Mr Martin. You know a good deal of those things.
This report records courtroom testimony from Burr's treason trial, in which a witness describes General Wilkinson's disclosures at New Orleans and the public reaction to them. Lawyers Wirt, Hay, and Martin dispute whether hearsay rumors about Burr's approach down the river are admissible evidence, with the chief justice ruling on the matter.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 November 1807 · page 2
Burr; and were much opposed to'the mea— sures ctof general lVilksilnf-onct. Q What appeared to be the geoeralimpression on the winds ofthe cizizens, & what was their si conduct before and after gen. W. expOs ed the'plans of col. Burr} A Before the sidiaoloswe 'osthose plans it was a general subjectofenquiry as to the conduct of ge neral Wilkinaoo in taking 'postat New Orleans, and many censured the measure. About that time several numbers of the VVeatersien W'orld appeared, in which many eevere MrlCtut'es were cast upon general KVilkios-on and others, which after the dia cloaure madesssshy general Wilkinson at the sissgover-nctmeot house, occasioned very consi de'_rable corn;-notions among the citizens.
See moreSee less
Itbecame a gmeralss-topic of conversation in the ccssee house, in the hote-le and even i in the streets. _I will rep-catctfunher that there appeared to be a large portion of the mercaotile interest in lavor os general Wilkinson'e conduct, some censured and none doubted. General VVilkioson conde acended to ask my opinion, having previ-l 05le made a full diessclosure ofthe dangcrs and of the measures which he had adopt edss 'I did give my , advice in favor osisseiz inLsiessdy man whom he found opposed to sissl'ssissiufi'eaeures. This was after a develope. bent o! the state of affaira by gcn Wilkin— ! ' "gon;-si ctsi ' ss 'I . . I -!si-si--.ss L- .]- <_ n'". warns. not] mak-not to un uc pendCd upon, ' Mr. Wirt. That will be a subject of dis lcbssifm hereafter. Mr. Marrin. ! know that. Mr. Wirt [in a low tone of voice] to Mr Martinss Tousiknow a good deal of those ! tltz' s. r. Boy. Did you see colonel Burr at
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
This opinion piece from the U.S. Gazette accuses President Jefferson of usurping judicial authority by pronouncing Burr guilty before trial, then questioning the outcome after two juries acquitted him. The author argues Jefferson's suggestion that Congress address a 'defect' in the administration of the law is an improper intrusion on judicial independence.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 16 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FROM THE U. S. GAZETTE.
There is much important and alarming meaning in these few words. "You will be enabled to judge whether THE DEFECT," &c. How does it appear that there was any defect? Why, simply thus. At the last session of congress, Mr. Jefferson usurped the prerogatives of a court and jury, by positively pronouncing upon the guilt of Aaron Burr. Afterwards he was put
This report records courtroom testimony from Silas Dinsmore, continuing his evidence in the treason trial of Aaron Burr. He is questioned about General Wilkinson's offer of a reward for Burr's capture and the instructions given to pursue him through Choctaw and Chickasaw territory.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 16 November 1807 · page 2
RICHMOND ENQUIRER
if LYAMLNA'rmN—or eYiDENCE. i Monnnr,35tohrr _ 53 ' [Silas Dinsmorc's evidence concluded-] ' Col siB'urr. Did gen' Wilkinson'offer you a' reward for apprehending me" ?— (I think four ' or five thousand dollars were offered on behalf of the government. q When was that siosser . made? A Some-time in December last, — Q Did you undertake to effect-it? A Idid, as far as was psirab'ticable .and expedient. q Was ss diet-offer predicated on an order of the govern1 "ment, or was lt the flat of the general ? . A ] do not know.
See moreSee less
q Did he satisfy you that he had authority for making the offer ? A ! think he did. q When did you leave New 'Or leans ZOn the morning of the 9th or llth of December. ' Mr. Baker: When was the offer made ?. A Just about thet time. - ' ' ss ' ' Colonel Burr. Did you send en order to the Choctaws to! take me ? A I carried myself the proclaanation of governor W'illi-ims to the Upper Choctaws, end employed runners to ss carry proclemations, with instrilctions to in tersesict the paths in every direction, and wrote to the agent in the Chickasa'w nation to the j same effects " _ - si ] ll Mr. Wirt. Whatdoctyou mean ny SflYlng that you undertook tsio arrest colonlel B_urr as far as was ex'pedient? A I meant that if I should have. shund him at large, I should have taken him, but not outof sithe hands os'the ci vil authority. q Were there not officers sent up to take'him? A siYes, and l was instructed to co-operate with them ; but he being exact lssy where general 'Wilkinson wished him, in ss the hands of the civil authority, I advised the officers to return, and they separated. < Colonel Burr.- Were you to seize me pri vately ? A Yes; if practicable. Colonel Burr. \Vas I not reputed to be at the head of an ar my by general X-Vilkinson? Yes; and by o ' thers too. Colonel Burr. How then were these men to take me ! Colonel Burr. _si When were those officers sent? A I can insorm you " when ! first saw them, which was on the first of February. Colonel Burr. Of the orders of the officers you know nothing? ,A Only what I_ saw, an order from commodore Shaw to lieutenant Iones to receive you. , Colonel Burr; You said the officers returned on your advice; did you see them retire ; or do you know when they lest that part of the country. Had they separated before I left the town of VVashington ? A I cannot tell when you" lest there, but the last time I saw them was on the
Testimony recounts how officials Dinsmore and Commodore Shaw coordinated with General Wilkinson to intercept and arrest Aaron Burr, including proclamations sent to the Choctaw and Chickasaw nations. Burr directly cross-examines the witnesses about the timing, authority, and nature of these orders during his treason trial.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 16 November 1807 · page 2
Sth of February at Natchez. . Colonel Burr to commodore S/za-w. I un derstood that you received orders from general VVilkinson? Were these orders from the go vernment? A I think they were the result of an arrangement between governor Claiborne and general VVill-ssinson I_ did not know at ' that time, that I was subject to the orders of , general lVilkinson; but always understood] that I was to co-operate with him. I consil dered that as governor Clai'sioorne took the rcsi sponsibility I was to. co-operate, and that the orders were given cenjointly with gem, VVHT i kinson, .
See moreSee less
' l Colonel Burr to Mr. Dinsmore. Did gen. 1 Wilkinson express any doubts of the militia !. 1 A He expressed no doubts of the creeles; but } he doubted the incongruous group which con— ? stituted the citizens of New Orleans; Coloss nel Burr. Did he doubt the eivil authori-ties?
A witness is questioned by Mr. Hay about conversations with Colonel Burr regarding the nature of his 'enterprise,' with testimony suggesting some partisans believed it targeted Spanish colonies rather than the U.S. The witness also testifies about Mr. New's intimacy with Burr and an offer of muskets, amid objections from defense counsel Wickham.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 17 November 1807 · page 2
COLONEL BURR
Do you rssccoilect "Mr; Robert Ncwct? A ! ss ' do. Q Did he descend the river with co " --$ss_];nnci-Butr2 A sil no understood. - QssWzs " side in company with coibnel Bnrr ?. A He lodged in the same-_rnom,nnd theysineemcd {to be in the habixs of the suicua: intimacy. , Mrflzsiy. - Did Mr New make you any '__ss'si'ssj:._'ssjþenposit_ion ? ' sssssisisi-Mr Wickham objecced to this quesmmu * fct-si'Whatia Mr. New's conduct to coL Burr ? Mr "New i: & gentleman of reapectable con. I tree—lions imhiassparcosshe country. if it;?
See moreSee less
be necessary,—why not directly proceed no ; gaiostsihim. inscead of thus employiqgss his i * ct' conduct to crim'mate colousseLBurrsi-Z ! ,Mr Hay. Mr. New, air, was an ageoi'ict of colonel Burr, and concerned.?nthis enfss. ijfgqyjzrize. [wish to shew by thiawimcs si-L ssWt Mr New offered to 80" him & comb" 7. si ctof musquets. As to MrsisiNew'a being" act'z " -_ lnpecublc man, it is : mcldnsscholy sack, ' that there were & number of men who were then respectableemþarked-in this enter pxsse, and who will have to'regret. to she! - lines! dav of rheir flse, (but they have been : "si -' cttbnssi deluded. - Cbief justice tsio the witness. Dbctsiyou si ." know whethersithere w'as any coouectiqn besi "zwfebsi Mr Burr cnd'M'rNews? A I know ss ssictssfdoshingssposuive about it. They'appearcd -ztff..siþe"sery intimate. and die-{New some ctss me! treat.-on coloael-Burr'css business; He {45an deuysschn he came "down the river ss- (Lo!-'- df . thou neoeiaressdctctio an enterprise, ' si-y'irh' she object-at whichctsslsi am not-pareicu-ss . ;hflv assssc named. _ si. Mtsi aye Theressieehe strongest pre; : ;, - on to believe, that these were rbessiz
This report presents the sworn deposition of Lieutenant Jacob Jackson, describing Aaron Burr's arrival at Chickasaw Bluffs in January 1807 and his cryptic remarks about a secret project. Burr reportedly spoke of relieving Spanish subjects from tyranny and asked Jackson's opinion on joining an enterprise against Spain.
The Enquirer · 17 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TRIAL OF AARON BURR. MOTION for commitment. Examination of evidence, [CONCLUDED.]
Examination of evidence,
[CONCLUDED.]
See moreSee less
Evidence of Lieutenant Jacob Jackson, delivered in court, on Monday the 19th of October, 1807, which evidence was revised and again sworn to by him, on Tuesday the 20th of the same month, in the form of a deposition.
I, Jacob Jackson, a second Lieutenant in the regiment of Artillerists, do certify and say, that on the third or fourth day of January, 1807, Aaron Burr arrived at the Chickasaw Bluffs in the night time, with one boat, and sent to the commanding officer of the garrison, wishing to know whether he could have quarters in the garrison during the night. Being the commanding and only officer there, I informed the messenger that the said Burr could be accommodated. Accordingly he came to the garrison in
Lieutenant Jacob Jackson swears testimony describing how Aaron Burr gave him money and a draft to raise a company of men and build a boat, and spoke of plans to settle in Spanish territory. The sworn statement is followed by a cross-examination from Burr himself challenging details of the account.
The Enquirer · 17 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
JACOB JACKSON,
Lieut. Reg't. of Artillerifts.
See moreSee less
Henrico county, sc.
Sworn to before me in due form, agreeable to law, this 20th October, 1807.
DAN'L. L. HYLTON, Justice of the Peace for the said county.
Cross-Questioned by Mr. Burr. Did you ever see me before that night? A. Yes; but I had no ac-
This opinion piece attacks Chief Justice Marshall's ruling that a prior conviction of a principal is needed before Burr can be convicted of treason. The writer argues that English common law, per Blackstone, holds all participants in treason as principals, undermining Marshall's legal distinction.
The Enquirer · 17 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
PORTRAIT OF THE CHIEF JUSTICE. No. V. His 5th position is, that it is "necessary to adduce the record of the previous conviction of some one person" who was present at the island, before A. Burr can be convicted of Treason.—The counsel for the prisoner placed this upon the ground, that A. Burr was merely an accessory, or at most a principal in the 2nd degree;
This passage critiques Chief Justice Marshall's legal definition of 'military posture' required to constitute treason by levying war, arguing it is either too vague or incorrect. The author contends that armed display, banners, or complete military readiness are not necessary preconditions, and that Burr's scheme to gradually seize territory and potentially dismember the union should still qualify as treason even without full military capability at each stage.
The Enquirer · 17 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Even arms themselves are not absolutely necessary. According to Hales, numbers will supply the want of military array or weapons; and even Furor ministrat arma. Let us suppose, what was extremely probable, that it was in proof that A. Burr had intended to equip his army with arms at some arsenal on the Mississip-
The Virginia Argus reports continued testimony from Major James Bruff in a Richmond circuit court proceeding concerning a motion for commitment, likely tied to the Burr affair. Bruff and General Wilkinson spar over details of Wilkinson's land holdings, his stated intent to leave government service, and the circumstances of Bruff's subpoena to testify.
Virginia Argus · 17 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MOTION FOR COMMITMENT.
Evidence of Major James Bruff.
(Continued.)
See moreSee less
Mr Martin. Whose property is the place called Cold Water? A. I understand the greater part belongs to general Wilkinson. About four acres only is deeded to the U. S. for a site of a factory. He wrote on for me to purchase such a place. It was about this place, that gen. Wilkinson made the rude attack upon me which I have before mentioned: but I believe the true source was, that I had said to an officer in the confidence of gen. Wilkinson that he would not be in office six months. I knew that Congress was about to meet and that it was contrary to the genius of our government that he should hold the two offices of General and Governor of Louisiana.
Gen. Wilkinson. When did you receive the first intimation of my intention to retire from service? A. This is intimated in a letter from the general, dated April 5, 1805. [Here Major Bruff read a letter from gen. Wilkinson to him.—See reference A.] Q. Did I not reiterate this intention after I came to St. Louis? A. I believe you did. Gen. Wilkinson. Do you recollect at what period after I got to St. Louis, whether late or early? A. I cannot recollect. You often mentioned the subject.
Gen. Wilkinson. Were you subpoenaed to attend this place? A. I was. I saw a subpoena in the hands of a gentleman for me; and Mr Martin told me in Baltimore that there was one ordered, and therefore I considered myself as subpoenaed from Queen Anne's county, in Maryland. Gen.
Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper
This passage records courtroom testimony from Major Bruff being cross-examined by General Wilkinson and defense counsel regarding Wilkinson's prior statements, subpoenas, and relations with Burr and others. The exchange touches on land disputes, personal grievances, and Wilkinson's credibility as a witness.
Virginia Argus · 17 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
I considered myself as subpoenaed from Queen Anne's county, in Maryland. Gen. Wilkinson. Then you had a conference with Mr Martin? A. I had. Gen. W. Do you recollect to have said that you were reluctant to come, but Mr Martin had promised to lash me into tortures? A. I have said that from a conversation with Mr. Martin, I had reason to believe that your letter to col. Burr "post marked 13th of May," would be produced; but that I should have come in any event.—
[Here a certificate of col. Meig's was read; which see note (B.)] The first intimation I had of this letter was from a letter written by a gentleman of the grand jury to a friend of mine, stricturing the testimony of gen. Wilkinson, given before that body. That part of the letter was confidentially read to me.
See moreSee less
[Major Bruff was about to state a conversation with Mr Martin, when he was interrupted by col. Burr, who said that he could not consent to a narration of the conversations which might have been held with his counsel.] Gen. W. Did you not say that you believed Burr was guilty; but that I had done you a serious injury, and you thought this a good time to seek redress? A I have said that I believed col. Burr concerned in that expedition with you. I have said so, and I think so still. Mr McRae. Will you state the character of judge Easton? A I have accused him of an endeavor to swindle me out of half the land we purchased in common on which an arbitration is now depending. General W. Had you no land speculations with Easton? A No. I had no speculations; but we made a purchase of a single tract of land together. Perhaps you call that speculations. General Wilkinson. You said that when col. Burr arrived at St. Louis, Easton and myself were intimate? Major Bruff. I thought so. General W. Did you not know that about that time I did not suffer him to come into my house? A I heard him say after col Burr had left St. Louis some little time, that you were persecuting him.
Commodore Shaw was called by the Prosecution.
Mr Hay. Did you travel in the stage with Major Bruff as he was coming to this place? A. I did. Mr Hay. Will you state the conversation which passed in the stage? Commodore Shaw. The conversation was lengthy and not particularly addressed to me. I understood, as Major Bruff stated, that a conspiracy had been organized in the Western country, at the head of which was Burr, and that Gen. Wilkinson and several others were implicated; that he had kept a watchful eye on them; had been on the alert; and that he had a just right to know that such a conspiracy existed. He said that gen. Wilkinson had done him a serious injury, and that he had come on from some information that Mr Martin had given him, to tell a long story. Q. What was the drift of the conversation; that he intended to injure gen. Wilkinson? A. The impression on my mind was, that gen. Wilkinson had done him a serious injury, and he was coming to retaliate; but that I cannot recollect the very words. (The Chief justice declared that impressions were not evidence. Witnesses must always depose to facts.)
Major Bruff and Captain Disacl are examined about conversations regarding Burr's conspiracy and General Wilkinson's alleged role in it. Testimony touches on land disputes, subpoenas, and prior court martial proceedings involving Bruff.
Virginia Argus · 17 November 1807 · page 1
Queen Anne's county, in Mary and. Gen. Wilkinson. Then you had a conference wi.h Mr Mftrtin ? A. I had. Gen. W. Do you recollect to have sr.irt that you were rc-luc.tajil to conit, hut Mr M ivtin tiad promised to lftdi me into tortures ? A. I have said that from a conversation with Mr. Martin, I had reason to belicv 4hat vour letter to col. Burr u post marked *33th of May,” wouid be produced ; but Jthat I should have come in any event.— [Here at certificate of cnl.
See moreSee less
Meig’swn* read ; ‘which see note (B.)] The fir^t intimation Thftd of this letter was from a fi tter writ ten bv n. gentleman of the grand jury to a friend ot mine, stricturir.g the testimony of ven. Wilkinson, given lie fore that body. That part of the lctier was confidentially read to me. [Major Bruif was about to state a con •ver&ation with Mr Martin, when he ^as in dei rupted by col. Burr, who said that he could not consent ton narration of the con versations which might have been t'.elcl with his counsel.] Gen.. W. Did you nol any that you believed Burr was ipdlty ; hut that 1 had done you n serious injury, and you thought this a good time to bet!-, re dress ? A 1 have said thatl believed col, Bui r concerned in that expedition with you I have snid to, and I think so still. M i ATrRar. Will you state the character o judge Easton? A I have accused him o an endeavor to swindle me out of had tin Inrrl we purchased in common on which a? arbitration is now depending. General W Had you no land speculations with Easton A No. 1 had no * free ninth titn ; but w< made a purchase of a single tract ot lain together. Perhaps yon tali that specula lions. General Wilkinson. Yon said tha when col. Burr arrived at St. Louis, Eastoi and myself were intimate? Major Bruf I thought so. General W. Did you nc know that about that time 1 did not fcitfie him to come into my house ? A 1 hear him say nfter col Burr had loft St. Loni c ine little time, that you were persecutin him. Comnodirc Shan man called brj the Prt tecution. Mr Huy. Did you travel in the ftfnp with Mnjor liniff ns he was coming to ih jilr.ee? A. 1 did. Mr Hay. Will yc state the conversation which passed in tli ttnge ? Commodore Shaw. The convci tutinn was lengthy and not particular B'ddveusrd to me. I understood, as Maj< JJrnfTstated, thst n conspiracy had bet organized in the Western country, at *1 Ittad of which wits l’urr, and ih f fu Wilkinson and several others were impl rated ; that he had kept n watchful to on them ; had hep»< on the alert j and th Inhad a just right to know that «urh aco splruey existed. He said ‘.hat gen. W kinson had t’.t>ne him a serious injury, til th .t lie bed ro*rr on from semi: inform lion that Mr Martin had given lorn, tell a long story. Q. What was the dr #>f the couvpf*r,ttf«n ; that he intended l tn,iurc ten. Vyi'kitison? A. The imprt Sion on tr.y m ud was, that gen. Wi’.ki son hftd tU>ne him a serious injury, t»nd tvtu coming to retaliate ; 1 ut that I can? trr ilrctthe very wrru». (TheC jnstiect1 (hired that impr« ssiors wert not eviden ♦ \Vitue«ei must always depths tu facts.]
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The passage reports a secret congressional debate over a resolution concerning Britain, followed by rumors of Burr associates gathering in Philadelphia, and a sworn affidavit describing Blannerhassett's admissions about the planned expedition and his view of Burr's betrayal. The deposition recounts Blannerhassett calling Burr a 'damned rascal' while defending the aims of the venture as potentially honorable or profitable.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 18 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Extract of letter dated Philadelphia, November 12th, 1807.
"Col. Burr, Blannerhassett, Bollman, Swartwout, Ogden, and others of the party have been convened in this city for some time. They were in frequent consultation; and occasionally in some bustle.
See moreSee less
"Bollman has applied for a passage in a vessel to New-Orleans. There is a rumor of a renovated enterprize under the auspices of a foreign government."
Mississippi Territory, Washington County.
Before me, one of the United States' Judges, for the said Territory, personally appeared at the town of Wakefield, in the said county, on the 6th day of September, 1807, Arthur Patton, who declared on oath, duly administered by me, that as he was travelling in the state of Tennessee, about the 24th of June last, he fell into com-
A deponent testifies he has no knowledge of Colonel Burr harboring any designs against the United States, New Orleans, or Spanish territories. He describes traveling with Burr from Bedford through Pittsburgh and into Virginia in the summer of 1806, recounting encounters with men who believed a Spanish war was imminent and that Burr would command it, which Burr denied.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 18 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
rose. The Chief Justice conceived that the declarations of all the party who were at the mouth of Cumberland, as to the intention of the expedition, were admissible evidence.
Cross Examined.
See moreSee less
Mr. Burr. Did not you and Mr. Callier express very strong sentiments concerning the right of the people to redress themselves? A We did express ourselves in that manner, and spoke of the difficulty of restraining the people from attacking Mobille. Q Do you recollect the resolution of your legislature on this subject? A I do. Q Did not that contain the same sentiments which you ascribe to me? A Not particularly. Q Did you vote for this resolution? A I believe so.
Here Mr. Wickham read the following affidavit:
The affidavit of Julian Depestre of lawful age, saith—
I have no knowledge of colonel Burr ever entertaining any designs or intentions against the peace of the United States nor against New Orleans, nor against any other part of the United States. Nor have I any knowledge of his having any designs against any part of the dominions of the king of Spain, so long as that power should keep peace with the United States.
In the last days of July 1806, in one of my visits to colonel Burr in Philadelphia, I communicated to him my desire to make a tour in the western country to seek for an advantageous situation for my family. Colonel Burr told me that if I could be ready he would be glad country with me; and that if I could be at Bedford by the tenth of August, we would spend there a few days, and then proceed by Pittsburg, adding obligingly, that he would introduce me to some of his friends, who probably would be the most proper persons to direct me in some requisition; I agreed, and the 11th of August I met colonel Burr at M'Connelsburg, and continued in his company till the 2d or 3d of September, that I left him a few miles the other side of Chilicothe.
We spent about seven or eight days of the time I was with colonel Burr at the Springs of Bedford, then we went to Pittsburg, where I was introduced by him to general O'Hara.—The 22d of August we went to Mr. Morgan, half way we met with his two sons, the eldest and youngest, who came, sent by their father, to welcome colonel Burr and accompany him to his house, there we dined and passed the night; next morning we went to breakfast to Washington. Mr. Morgan's eldest son accompanied us; again after breakfast we parted and continued our journey. When we travelled in the back part of Virginia and in the state of Ohio, I saw several men coming, some in their name, some in the name of several others, to colonel Burr; they generally told him that they had understood that there would be a Spanish war, and that he was to have a command, in which cases they came to offer themselves, manifesting the pleasure they would have to serve under his orders: colonel Burr would always hear what they had
A deponent describes Burr discussing the purchase of Ouachita lands, offering to share them, and questions about Burr's intentions regarding a possible Spanish war. Under cross-examination, the witness denies hearing Burr speak of separating the western from eastern states, saying Burr laughed off such suggestions raised by others.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 19 November 1807 · page 2
The deponent, on creed-examination on the part of colonel— Burr, being asked the following questions, viz. 'siQctDid you, when at Motgan*e,hear col. wmslussfstmyetped'nmz sioros ' '-a'lepa'ration'-fs0m the union? " a No, exceptduring the dinner, when did Mr Mnrgan began once or twice to l lpesiak about the stir-sore of : separatienof the wcazern from the eaotern states; but dolonel Burr seemed not willing to engage --in such conversation, and did all he could to get rid of 'it, e'ecming'mnre pleased with the conversation of the ladies. , ss ssq, Were you generally near colnnelsi Bnrr or separately engaged.
See moreSee less
Did you see him .engege in particular conversation during Aha!; visit"? ! ' . . A ( heard the Norgans' give their testi si away, and-! do nbt know for my partmhen suchsilong conversation could teke place ;ct it me no: before me, and colonel Burr was - but very little time abeeotjfrom—me; after dinner l_ left him with the company. end went with old Mr Man-gan into the garden si where cosslonel Burrenme &sijoined us with. si ;the ladicambont 1_5 minute: after ; we were iognhernll the remainingsiol' the day, in " he ne took. and visits we made, ex, cepjpsijbco l was abcd, colonel Burr took the candle,— end went out the doors for a ' few minutes, and then came back to his ::bed- - * - ss . . Q. Didsiyon hear cnlonel Burr, during the stinte won was" with him, talk of'a separa. tion of sstbe western from the eaatern mates,} ' ' " A "Neverzsilsinnly remember that in al ssncttost all the houses "weletopped to, people -wonld often engage 'a conversation with an upon that eubjctect ; ?bnt colonel But: would, g.]fllYI laugh at theidea. _ , " si - Q, Did it siappearcttoyou that home or-be -" strained; seriously—. interested in "making sie'onte'new eatablishment in lands ? __ -._A ss Hie project of purchasing lands on the "Coachttn was a more general topie of our convereation when we "Were. tratrelliog, and be seetned noxious to prevail upon me to come to it. _ ss . si. . , "A. men:: sute of mind ,was sisstben old
Chief Justice Marshall's opinion addresses whether Burr and associates conspired to separate Western states or invade Mexico, based on testimony from Decatur, Eaton, and Truxton about Burr's stated plans. The opinion examines the cyphered letter sent via couriers Bollman and Swartwout to General Wilkinson as key evidence.
The Wheeling Repository · 19 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
OPINION
Of Chief Justice Marshall,
See moreSee less
Delivered the 20th October, 1807, on a motion to commit Burr, Blennerhasset, and Israel Smith, to Kentucky, to be tried for treason and misdemeanor.
[Concluded.]
The first question which arises on the evidence, is,
With what object did those men convene, who assembled at the mouth of Cumberland?
Was it to separate the Western from the Eastern states, by siezing and holding New-Orleans?
Was it to carry on an expedition against Mexico, making the embarkation at New-Orleans?
Was this expedition to depend on a war with Spain?
The conversation held by col. Burr with commodore Decatur, stated his object to be an expedition against Mexico, which would be undertaken, as the commodore understood, with the approbation of the government in the event of war.
To gen. Eaton, he unfolded in various conversations, plans for invading Mexico, and also for severing the Western from the Atlantic states.
To commodore Truxton he spoke of the invasion and conquest of Mexico in the event of a war, as a plan which he had digested with gen. Wilkinson, and into which he was extremely desirous to draw the commodore. A circumstance is narrated by this witness, which has
This report examines testimony and documents presented regarding Aaron Burr's true intentions, debating whether his plans targeted Mexico rather than U.S. territory. It scrutinizes General Wilkinson's letters and the conflicting accounts of Swartwout's testimony to assess the credibility of treason charges.
The Wheeling Repository · 19 November 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
if not absolutely depended. To gen. Wilkinson both the cyphered letter and the explanations made by Bollman and Swartwout, declared the expedition to be military, and to be intended against Mexico.
The passage presents legal reasoning on what constitutes levying war under treason law, distinguishing between conspiracy and the overt act itself. It argues the prosecution failed to prove the men assembled at the mouth of the Cumberland knew of or intended any treasonous design against the United States.
The Wheeling Repository · 19 November 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
death, the conspiracy without the act will not support the indictment. So in this case, if the object be the embarkation of a body of men against a foreign country, in the execution of which war may or may not be levied, the fact becomes necessary to constitute the treason.
It is also a circumstance of considerable weight with me, that the proof exhibited by the United States to establish a general design to dismember the union, applies only to col. Burr and Mr.
The report presents a judicial opinion analyzing whether Aaron Burr's gathering of men constituted the crime of 'levying war' under treason law, arguing that intent alone without an overt act may not suffice. It compares the case to the historical English precedent of the Earls of Essex and Southampton, distinguishing the legal reasoning in that case from the current Burr proceedings.
The Wheeling Repository · 19 November 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
The case does not appear to me to be essentially varied by the circumstance, that this design was not avowed, and that the men followed col. Burr with other views.
A judicial opinion explains the decision to commit Aaron Burr and Herman Blennerhassett for preparing a military expedition against Spanish territory, while discussing whether war with Spain was imminent as a possible extenuation. Israel Smith is not committed due to lack of evidence that he provided or prepared any means for the expedition.
The Wheeling Repository · 19 November 1807 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
I shall commit Aaron Burr & Herman Blennerhasset, for preparing and providing the means for a military expedition against the territories of a foreign prince with whom the U. States were at
The report describes Commodore Thomas Truxton's testimony before the jury in Burr's trial, which the paper says fully confirmed his honorable reputation despite earlier suspicions of involvement in treason. It praises Truxton's distinguished naval service against France, including the capture of the Insurgent and the defeat of the Vengeance.
The Enquirer · 20 November 1807 · page 3
COMMODORE TRUXTON, AGAIN. The intending trial of col. Burr, and the col ateral circumltances wtiieh have been brought into view, have excited mnch private fueling as
The writer recounts casual, joking conversations with friends Hall and Campbell in which he speculated that Burr might separate the western territories and become 'emperor of Louisiana.' He defends these remarks as idle banter, not evidence of treasonous intent, while noting his friends' political reliability and character.
Virginia Argus · 20 November 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
"What news?" And from the time that Col. Burr was introduced by democratic papers, I have often answered him, "nothing, except that Col. Burr was about to separate the western country from the
The writer denies ever discussing separation of western states with Aaron Burr or an unnamed 'united Irishman,' insisting he never corresponded with Burr and never heard his plans. He closes by accusing President Jefferson of wanting to hang him or at least strip him of his liberty.
Virginia Argus · 20 November 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
I have reserved for the last, my United Irishman, and as to him I must solemnly declare, I have ever detested his principles too much to have had any other communication with him, than the mere common civilities, which every gentleman ought to shew not merely to a stranger, but to a stranger whose acquaintance they ardently wish to shun—I am confident that I never had any political conversation with him upon any subject, much less any in which the name of Col. Burr was mentioned. I will not say he may not have been in the coffee house, or some other public place, where I may have been conversing with others, and may have listened to my conversation—but I solemnly aver that if I ever in any place said that before 12 months the western states would be separated from the Atlantic states.
See moreSee less
I never did add, "that I had it from the best authority," and that whoever has or shall say or swear such a declaration to have been made by me, has or will say or swear to what is absolutely false. I shall here add that from the time Col Burr first went to the westward, until he
During Aaron Burr's treason trial, lawyers dispute whether Major Bruin's testimony about General Wilkinson's prior communications with Burr is admissible. General Wilkinson angrily objects to being called a traitor by Burr's counsel, prompting a rebuke from the Chief Justice.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 21 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The report reprints remarks from the N.Y. American Citizen criticizing a Baltimore mob that hanged and burned effigies of Chief Justice Marshall and others, apparently in anger over Burr's trial outcome. The piece condemns mob violence generally while also denouncing Burr and his co-conspirators as deserving vigilant legal scrutiny.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 23 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The following correct and proper remarks upon a late outrage in Baltimore, in which the effigies of Chief Justice Marshall and several others were hanged and burnt, by a lawleles, disorderly rable, are extracted from the N. York American Citizen. "Mobs, those many headed hydras, which in no one instance can be right, but in all must be wrong, should be discountenanced by every good man; e press should in an especial manner reprehend them. A mob is the same monster whether on this side or on that. Burr & his associate conspirators, are, indeed, detestible, and cannot be too vigilantly watched within the limits of the law.
See moreSee less
But are mobs—are persons tumultuously assembled in our streets the constitutional judges of a Chief Justice? Where is the empire of our laws; Where order, the element of all law and all good? The civil authority of Baltimore is reprehensible. It should have suppressed, I will not ssy by an energy beyond the law, but it should have suppressed this vile rout; it should have prevented this stain on our national character. He who cannot hate, with a holy hatred a conspiracy like that of the miscreant Burr, and the persons who were engaged in it, and yet be orderly, and yet be decorous, and yet
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.
The report describes President Jefferson's displeasure with Burr's acquittal, still calling him an offender despite the verdict, and notes a Vermont legislative push to subordinate the judiciary to legislative control. It also recounts how a Baltimore mob, prevented from tarring and feathering attorney Luther Martin for defending Burr, instead burned him and Chief Justice Marshall in effigy.
Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 23 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Independent Judiciary.—The President, in his message to Congress, sufficiently shews his dissatisfaction at the decision on the trial of Burr (whom he still, notwithstanding his acquittal, calls an offender,) and his desire that the judiciary may be placed more within reach of the arm of power.——In the Vermont legislature a motion has been introduced by a member, who has long been in intimate connection with the President, for placing the judiciary of the United States under the controul of the legislature.——The democrats of Baltimore, practising upon these wise hints, came well nigh deluging their city in blood, by assembling to tar and feather Mr.
See moreSee less
Martin, on account of his pleading the cause of Burr; but they were prevented by a military force; they however succeeded in burning him, together with Chief Justice Marshall, in effigy.——Blessed times we shall have, when the constitutional judiciary shall be overthrown, and we shall receive judgment from a mob, under a lamp post!—Salem Gaz. Reasoning in favour of Mobs.—"You think (says A. to B) that my friend John is a rascal, and so you are determined to tar and feather him—I think your friend Peter is a scoundrel, and therefore I intend to pull his house down."—Palladium.
A Virginia Gazette writer rebuts critics who accused Chief Justice Marshall of improperly blocking evidence from the jury in Burr's treason trial. The writer argues Marshall correctly ended the trial once it became clear the indictment's specific allegations about Blennerhassett's Island could not be proven against Burr.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
From the Virginia Gazette.
So much abuse has been bestowed upon the chief justice, throughout the United States, for his opinion on the trial of Aaron Burr for treason, and the points upon which that decision took place, has been so uniformly mistated, that I am really inclined to think that the most of those who have animadverted upon the subject, have not read the opinion.
See moreSee less
A writer in a New-York paper, who calls himself Common Sense, says the judge prevented the evidence from going to the jury, declaring it insufficient to convict Burr, and triumphantly asks how he knew it? another writer in a Trenton paper says, the judge wrested the evidence from the jury; that he deprived them of their constitutional right to hear all the testimony; that he declared it insufficient to convict Burr before he knew what it was; and concludes with telling the publick, that there never was a case where, after a jury was sworn, the judge could prevent them from hearing all the evidence: for says he, to reject it is to judge of it, which belongs exclusively to the jury. With all due submission to the talents of so great a lawyer as this gentleman appears to be, I will tell him that the people of Virginia, do not extend the rights of jury quite so far.
The great author of Common Sense, will also pardon me for telling him he is not so fortunate in the sentence to which I allude, as he has been in many of his former publications: For the fact was, judge Marshall did know that no evidence whatever could convict Burr under the indictment, and knowing this, he very properly put an end to the trial. The cause had progressed so far, as to demonstrate an impossibility of conviction, and whenever this is the case, in any criminal prosecution; whenever it is manifest that the accused cannot be convicted, all further evidence becomes illegal, and ought to be rejected. A fact was admitted by the prosecutor, which, in the opinion of the court, rendered it impossible to support the indictment, it was this—Aaron Burr was indicted for assembling with others, for a treasonable purpose, at Blannerhassett's Island on the 10th day of December; it was admitted, that he was on that day, and had been for two months before, in the state of Kentucky, three hundred miles
A juror explains that Marshall properly ended the trial because the prosecution admitted Burr was in Kentucky, not at Blennerhassett's Island, on the day charged in the indictment. The writer argues the defect was in the choice of trial venue, not the law or evidence, and states personal belief that Burr likely caused others to commit the crime.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
distant from the place laid in the indictment. The question before the court was, whether, when a man is indicted for doing a criminal act, by himself, it be sufficiet for his conviction, to prove that the act was done by others; the court decided that it would not. But Aaron Burr might have caused others, to commit, at Blannerhassett's Island, the crime with which he was charged. So he might, and so I verily believe he did, but this is a distinct offence, for which he was not indicted.
When the proceedings in this trial are laid before congress, the defect will be found to exist, neither in the law, nor in the administration of the law, nor perhaps in the evidence, but in the place of trial, which should have been in Kentucky or Ohio. I do not mean by this, to cast the smallest reflection on the able and eloquent counsel who conducted the prosecution. He very probably never heard the testimony until he heard it in the court, it was then too late. The evidence was rejected because it was admitted, that the charge, as laid in the indictment, not only could not be proved, but that in fact, Aaron Burr was not guilty of the act of assembling at Blannerhassett's Island on the 10th December.
This editorial defends President Jefferson's constitutional right to submit evidence on the Burr case to Congress, arguing his oath to protect the constitution obligated him to act against Burr's treasonable or warlike designs. It argues any defect in securing conviction may lie in testimony, law, or administration, and that Congress alone can supply a remedy.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 23 November 1807 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
his ability to protect the constitution against Aaron Burr and his associates, whether their ends were treasonable, or whether they aimed at carrying on a war against a nation at peace with the United States. That one or the other was the end of his ope
The piece reports that Davis Floyd, an accomplice of Burr's treason, was tried and found guilty only of a 'high misdemeanor,' receiving a token fine of ten dollars and three hours imprisonment. It bitterly criticizes the government for then rewarding Floyd with a Territorial clerkship, accusing Federalist-aligned officials of coddling traitors.
The New Hampshire Gazette · 24 November 1807 · page 2
~_ [LATE OMISSIONS.] ~ Heres vor Virtue—The following in telligence is-furcly a proof that our judges are men *“ fearing God, and hating covetousness” ~—they are a “ terror to evil doers and a praise to them that do well.” Gracious God ! must we become rotten be forc we are ripe " Shall #aitors be the fa vourites, when our legislative and executive officers looks around to make a fclection for office from amongst their fellow citizens !— Read and reflect. S Accounts have been received from Louif villy, and Jefferfonville, which state that Da vis Floyd, one of the accomplices of Burr, in
This opinion piece harshly criticizes Chief Justice Marshall for his legal rulings during Aaron Burr's treason trial, accusing him of drawing artificial distinctions to favor Burr and disparage the executive branch. The writer argues Marshall improperly excluded evidence linking Burr's conspiracy across different locations and allowed defense counsel excessive latitude against the administration.
The Enquirer · 24 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
he certainly is not judged by common sente.
But we have dwelt long enough upon this subject. The pencil is wearied with the samenefs of the portrait which it has sketched. For wherever we have bent our eye, we have seen the Chief Justice drawing hair-breadth distinctions, or distinctions without a difference; advocating principles which do not reach the most important cases; or leaning with a perceptible propensity on the side of Burr and against the administration.
See moreSee less
Why did he wrest the evidence from the jury? Why insult the rights of that great palladium of our liberties? Why permit the foulest and most irrelevant abuse against the administration to flow in endless streams from the prisoner's counsel? Why forget that respect which is due from one department of the government to the other? Why stain his own opinion with the most pointed accusation against the integrity of the executive, as if they had thirsted for the blood of a victim? Why suffer the executive cabinet to be so rudely and unnecessarily pillaged by the profane hands of A. Burr? Or if on one occasion he affected a respect for the
The report criticizes Judge Marshall's conduct during Burr's treason trial, calling his rulings effectively legislative and arguing the jury's rights were trampled. It urges Virginia's legislature to propose a constitutional amendment in response to what it calls a 'mockery' of justice.
The Enquirer · 24 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
legislate for each. His decisions to day are quoted as precedents to-morrow. No man could behold judge Marshall lately sitting on the bench of justice, and deciding the complicated and important cases of the law of Treason, without regarding him as a real legislator. All his opinions were so many laws, some of them perhaps destined to screen the worst of traitors from punishment, and to shake the safety of this country. One more remark. Let not the distant states of Vermont and Ohio be the most zealous in supporting this amendment. The evil has been produced in our own vitals. Here, have the rights of the jury been trampled down. This has been the scene of the mockery of A. Burr's trial.—Let then the Legislature of Virginia cour
A Richmond publisher (Mr. Robertson) announces he is producing a faithful, complete report of the ongoing Burr treason trial, calling it the most important trial yet held in America. The notice also mentions forthcoming coverage of subsequent proceedings against Burr for misdemeanor and a possible transfer to Kentucky for trial on treason charges tied to the Cumberland River.
Virginia Argus · 24 November 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
and accuracy of his report To the foregoing will be added, the subsequent proceedings against Col. Burr. His trial for a misdemeanor—for preparing an expedition against Mexico—and the motion to commit him, in order to send him to Kentucky to be tried for treason said to be committed at the mouth of Cumberland river.
A witness describes clashes with General Wilkinson over military camp placement near St. Louis and being reprimanded for voicing safety concerns. The testimony also recounts Judge Easton relaying Burr's inquiry about officers for a Santa Fe expedition, raising suspicions about Burr's intentions.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 25 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE
Colonel Burr arrived a little time after this at St. Louis.
[Mr Wirt. At what time? A I believe in August, 1805.]
See moreSee less
A judge Easton who appeared to think very highly of colonel Burr and boasted of possessing a part of his confidence, informed me that colonel Burr had inquired of him, whether there was any officer of experience & enterprize who could be trusted with the command of an expedition to Santa Fe, and gave me a very inquisitive look. I demanded by what authority col. Burr made the inquiry, or in what light I was to view it. He replied that colonel Burr at that time held no public office, but that he had powerful friends and would probably be in a very exalted situation before long; that I had been well spoken of to colonel Burr, (I suppose by himself) & he advised me to make him my friend. I answered that the inquiry was a suspicious one; for if government chose to employ me in that or any other way, it had a right to command my services—(for I was in service at that time). We dropt the subject.
[Mr Martin. Was Easton at St. Louis? A Yes. Mr Martin. Was he in habits of great intimacy with general Wilkinson? A Yes, there appeared to be a good understanding between the three.]
But as general Wilkinson some time before had wrote me that " every information of the route to Santa Fe would be highly acceptable." and recently sounded my inclination towards energetic governments and his grand scheme to make fortunes, I no longer doubted of their connection.
[Mr Martin. How long was colonel Burr at St. Louis, how was he treated by general Wilkinson, and how was he sent across the river? A When he arrived I was not in town, but understood that the general had rode out with him to the cantonment to view his troops. I saw the colonel on the evening he returned. The colonel
A witness recounts conversations with Eaton, who claimed Wilkinson made shocking secret proposals to Burr that left him speechless, and described suspicions about Wilkinson's role in Miranda's expedition. The testimony details Eaton's failed Senate confirmation and his frustrated attempts to alert the government about Wilkinson's conduct.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 26 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
mysterious manner about a western empire. Captain Stoddart also hinted to me after his return from fort Massac, that some great scheme was in agitation between colonel Burr and general Wilkinson, but did not say what. Easton positively stated that there was a connection between gen. Wilkinson and colonel Burr. He complained that the general persecuted him, I observed that it was very strange that he should be the common friend of col. Burr and general Wilkinson, and yet they should misunderstand one another about him; that I rather suspected the general finding him unpopular with the French, and that he would not answer their purpose, had persuaded colonel Burr to shake him off. Easton replied, that colonel Burr was in his power, and that he dared not treat him in a deceitful manner. I replied I did not know colonel Burr, but that his enemies represented him as an artful intriguer.
Some time afterwards Mr Easton came to me and observed that he believed my conjectures about colonel Burr were true—and that he was to be made a sacrifice of; that he should go on to the seat of government and try what he could do for himself. Easton was then a judge appointed by the president, but not confirmed by the senate, and he was apprehensive it would not; that general Wilkinson was using his influence to prevent the confirmation. But observed, colonel Burr was much in his power, for that he had made him proposals which made the hair rise upon his head, astonished and confounded him so that he was struck dumb.
See moreSee less
[General Wilkinson. Were these his very words? A Yes.]
That colonel Burr observing this would have retracted but it was too late. I urged him to explain the nature of the proposals. He said he was under an obligation of secrecy; but no obligation should hold him if he found colonel Burr false to him. I observed that he well knew that any obli-
The piece recaps that Judge Marshall's opinion, concluding the Burr proceedings at Richmond, found no treason had been committed. It then presents Virginia judge St. George Tucker's earlier published arguments on the strict, limited definition of treason for comparison.
The Wheeling Repository · 26 November 1807 · page 2
treason. ^ile would conclude, that in a country where liberty and law was the first boast of its citizens, no judge woidd be thus overwhelmed with a torrent of opprobrium, unless he had departed from, and disregarded all former opi nions ; unless he had given to the con stitutional definition of treason a con struction which had never before been heard or thought of, except by traitors themselves. This is no doubt the opi nion of many ot those who clamour a gainst the judge ; and to produce a more correct impression on this subject, is the object of this essay. 1 he two lust numbers of the Reposi tory contain judge Marshall’s opinion, which concluded the proceedings against Burr anti others at Richmond. From
This editorial debates who should succeed Jefferson as president, warning against ambitious men like Burr manipulating public opinion to stay in power. It notes that the Chesapeake affair and Aaron Burr's trial have diverted public attention from the succession question, with only a few newspaper essays discussing Madison and Monroe as candidates.
The Enquirer · 27 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE NEXT PRESIDENT.
ring the resentment of their country. It is to be hoped too, that we shall never see the time in this country, when any man shall think himself authorised to plead the invitations of a part of the public voice as a reason for his continuing in this high office. Would it be difficult for an intriguing man, like Burr, if such a man should unfortunately be made President, to raise an artificial voice in some section of the U. S., pretend that his services were required by his country and labour to keep himself perpetually in power?
See moreSee less
Every man knows that such is not the case with respect to the addresses presented to Mr. Jefferson: but every man also knows how easy it is for the best of actions to be quoted as precedents for the worst. As to the next question which occurs; who is to be the successor of this illustrious man; it is perhaps fortunate that so little discussion has taken place; for discussion might produce contrariety of opinion, and this again would be productive of schisms and divisions in the republican party. It is perhaps the only advantage which has resulted from the attack on the Chesapeake and Aaron Burr's trial, that these
The writer argues for constitutional amendments limiting presidential terms and invokes Edmund Pendleton's warnings about executive power. It also reports that Senator John Smith of Ohio, described as a noted accomplice of Burr, passed through the city en route to Washington, and urges the Senate to expel him under its constitutional authority to punish or remove disorderly members.
The Enquirer · 27 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
It is said, that John Smith, Senator of the U. States from Ohio and the noted accomplice of Burr, passed through this city a few days past—on his way to Washington. Should it be possible that this man will dare to insult the dignity of Congress by taking his seat among them, it is hoped that the Senate of the U. S. will remember the following clause in the constitution: "Each house may determine the rules of its proceedings, punish its members for disorderly behaviour, and with the concurrence of two-thirds, expel a member."—If he does not attend, ought not the Senate to exercise the same privilege?
See moreSee less
This measure, so far from injuring the representative rights or contradicting the wishes of the Legislature of Ohio, would probably consult both. It would enable that state to be fully represented in the Senate of the U. S. and it would remove that very member, whom they requested (during their last session) to retire from his office; but requested in vain. Q.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.
The Senate takes up the question of whether Senator John Smith of Ohio should be expelled for his alleged part in Aaron Burr's conspiracy, after a nolle prosequi was entered on his treason indictment in Virginia. Multiple resolutions are proposed and debated, including calls for a committee of inquiry and cautions about damaging an innocent man's character without sufficient evidence.
The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 30 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 30.
Resolved, That a committee be appointed to enquire and report to the Senate their opinion whether John Smith, a Senator from the state of Ohio, ought not to be expelled from the Senate in consequence of the part which he took in the conspiracy of Aaron Burr against the peace and prosperity of the U. S. or what other steps
During a House debate over requesting the president's proclamation on British armed vessels, a representative cites the earlier Burr conspiracy proclamation as a precedent for papers never formally laid before the House. The exchange shows Burr's case being invoked months later in an unrelated legislative dispute.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
so, in the case of the famous conspiracy of Mr. Burr, a proclamation was issued at the time, and not laid before the house, nor had the house thought necessary to call for these papers. They were before the publick, and every member of the house
This passage records a House of Representatives debate over whether a presidential proclamation should be formally submitted to Congress or whether its publication in newspapers sufficed as official notice. Members dispute precedent, referencing both the Burr case and prior proclamations under President Washington, debating the proper constitutional procedure.
Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 30 November 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
the Union. It had always been the custom for the President to publish his proclamations, but in no instance had he laid them before the house—The two extraordinary sessions of Congress had been held by proclamation published in the newspapers, and the proclamations for convening them had not been laid before the house. It having been done by another President had no bearing on the present case : no law existed authorising President Washington to issue such a proclamation, as that referred to ; but the proclamation now referred to, as well as that in the case of Mr. Burr were issued under an act of Congress. Mr. C. had
A witness (apparently Major Bruff) testifies about letters he delivered to the Secretary of War and Attorney General linking an expedition to Santa Fe with Colonel Burr's plans, and names several men who could confirm the connection between General Wilkinson and Burr. He also describes a letter from Wilkinson to General Adair urging him to join the expedition.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE
&c. from St. Geneva, who attempted to join col. Burr near the mouth of the Ohio. The Secretary at War returned the letters and thanked me; but I have been surpriz
A witness recounts a letter from General Wilkinson urging General Adair to march on New Orleans with thirty thousand troops to seize Spanish territory, divided into three columns. The testimony also names several figures—including Dupeister, Dayton, and Chotard—connected to Burr and Wilkinson in the alleged conspiracy.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE
[C. Just. Do you know the hand writing of gen Wilkinson? A I do, very well.]
I sat by gen Adair when he read the letter; and it appeared to be the hand writing of gen Wilkinson; but I did not take it up to compare it.
See moreSee less
[Mr. Martin. Do you remember the date? A I cannot tell the date or the place from which it was written. Mr. Hay. Did it appear as if it was of ancient date or modern? A Recent.]
General Adair complained bitterly; he said that this letter had induced him to go to New Orleans, where he was seized by general Wilkinson.
[Mr. Wirt. Will you name all the witnesses, who could give evidence of the connection between colonel Burr and general Wilkinson? A Judge Easton, to prove that general Wilkinson was the projector of Miranda's expedition, and his connection with colonel Burr; major Timothy Kibby
This passage reports courtroom testimony describing General Wilkinson's alleged role in Burr's conspiracy, including connections to Colonel Dupiester, Pierre Provencher, Timothy Kibby, and others who could allegedly prove links between Wilkinson and Burr. Witnesses discuss proclamations, commissions, and letters suggesting an expedition was being organized, with testimony about a planned western empire and military commands.
Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 30 November 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Miranda's expedition, and his connection with colonel Burr; major Timothy Kibby the person whose deposition has been printed, and Pierre Provenchere who could prove the connection between general Wilkinson and colonel Burr, and who was the common friend of both; colonel Samuel Hammond, with whom general Wilkinson had a conversation nearly similar with the one held with me and Samuel Hammond, jun. I believe I did not mention colonel Dupiester, to prove the designs of the party, as to the establishment of a western