FROM THE AURORA.
LETTER THE FIRST.
See moreSee less
TO JOHN MARSHALL, CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE U STATES.
Sir—The appearance of a letter, addressed to you, in a news-paper, is calculated to excite the curiosity of the public, more than to flatter your vanity—and it is less likely to gratify your feelings, than to excite anticipations of pain, too strong to leave the slightest promise of pleasure. You could have dispensed with the honor of this address, without regret or mortification, and consoled yourself for the want of a proper appreciation of your virtues and talents, with the fruits of their exertion. But you have an equal title to both, and the justice of the public will pay that tribute to your worth, which your modesty would willingly decline.
Your country sir, owes you a debt of gratitude for former favors. The addition of a new item to the account, naturally produces a recurrence to them, and a wish to settle the added amount of the whole. This, I fear, is beyond the ability of your debtor, because the whole stock of national indignation and contempt would be exhausted, before the half of your just claim could be discharged.
But in the distribution of that infamy, and detestation, which will certainly be divided among those, who have long labored, with a zealous ardour which nothing could abate, and a patient industry which no difficulties could tire, for the destruction of our republican institutions, the subvertion of our government, and the erection of tyranny, upon the tomb of freedom, you, as a principal creditor, shall not be forgotten.
If, sir, the exertion of your abilities had been confined to the defence of measures incompatible with the spirit of republican government, or to the mysteries of diplomatic agency, one of the virtues, which most strongly marks your political character, would have flourished and died in obscurity; the invincible strength of your attachment to federal principles. Your worst enemies, and best friends must now acknowledge the fidelity of your attachments, and bear testimony to the uniform consistency of your conduct.
The wisdom of age, has confirmed and sanctioned the choice of youth. The examination and trial of Aaron Burr for treason, and misdemeanor, have furnished you with a happy opportunity, not only to display this hidden virtue to the world, but of exercising the endless variety of your talents.
The superiority of your understanding, the force of your penetration, the strength of your judgment, in conducting the manoeuvres of a political party, have already been displayed and admired, while their application was deplored and detested. Your diplomatic skill and crafty cunning cannot be doubted by any, who recollect, that you have passed even the "X. Y. Z." of ministerial exercises. The facility with which you can "answer" the plainest questions with evasive obscurity, to conceal your opinions from the people, whose organ and representative you wished to be, has been recorded in pages consecrated by the "holy enthusiasm" of exalted genius and pure patriotism. You have not lived in vain. By exciting the genius and talents and indignation of John Thompson you have conferred an unintended benefit on your country, and have added, to the literary glory of Virginia, a ray of lustre, which will shine, when even the splendor of your talents and your crimes shall have faded forever. When your volumes* of apology for British insolence and cruelty, shall be buried in oblivion, the "letters of Curtius" will tell posterity that you existed; and "damn you to everlasting fame."
Your ingenuity in the interpretation of the laws, and the discreet and useful management of that sound discretion, confided to those who ought to be the organs of the true intention and meaning of the legislator, and the impartial dispensers of justice, have been reserved for an occasion worthy of their exertion even by a chief justice, the friend and favorite of John Adams.
An opportunity of doing an essential service to the cause of federalism so seldom occurs, that it would be an injustice to your understanding to suppose that you did not instantly perceive, and to your zeal that you did not improve, that which the projects of Burr has presented. But you have even surpassed the expectation of many of your own party. This, I attribute, not only to the motives which have hitherto guided the movements of that party, and yourself, but to the operation of feelings strongly excited. I do not suppose, that you weakly yield to the effusions of tenderness, or the ebullitions of passion, when they are opposed by your sober judgment, but that, like a wise man, you only indulge them, when it can be safely done without counteracting the superior views of interest or ambition.
It is natural that men, who have long labored to effect the same purpose, although by different means, should sympathise in their mutual sufferings, when disappointed and defeated. A similarity of pursuits, constantly causes a concurrence of sentiments and feelings. A speculative difference in opinions is lost and forgotten, in the pursuits of a common object. Even the leaders of opposed factions, can forget their enmity, and unite their forces, to resist the cause of virtue, and to repel its superior power when it threatens their destruction. It is not, therefore, strange, that you should be affected by the sufferings of Aaron Burr, or should feel a disposition to alleviate them.
Nothing can more aptly illustrate the principles of the federal party, or demonstrate their designs, than a fair exposition of their conduct towards Aaron Burr. The naked deformity of that conduct, has disgusted many who were delighted with the shining robe which had once concealed it. The worthy men of that party, who had been deceived by the pretences and ostensible motives of men, whose real designs were not to "give energy to the government," but slavery to the people, have been awakened from the dreams of federal intoxication, by the severe shock of treason—They have fled with the utmost precipitation.—For good men of every party will unite in their detestation of an action, which, without reference to party, or to names, is in itself immoral, criminal, and wicked.
The spirit which fired the breasts of the federal leaders, and the unhallowed flame that burnt the bosom of Burr, were seen to approach the sphere of each other's attraction. The similiarity of their appearance was marked, the same in colours, shades, and shapes, it was obvious that they were only separated particles of the same body, and would immediately unite. Every atom of honesty, attached to federalism, instantly receded from the detestable union. Recollect, sir, the conduct of your party towards Aaron Burr in 1804,—recollect your own
Was he then their friend, would any one of the party have then volunteered in his defence? Would Lee, or Martin, have been heard as his counsel, on an indictment for the murder of Hamilton? Would you have bailed him, during his examination, for that offence?
What has Burr done since the commission of that crime to atone for it? What has been his "peace offering?" I answer—treason against his country.
Ignorant of the satanic services he was meditating, and counting the death of Hamilton a clear loss; they loaded him with curses and execrations, whom they now cherish and defend, and within a few days have pardoned †
You have eaten of the same bread, and drank of the same cup, after solemnly deciding the probability of his guilt, and the remembrance of his former sins is lost in the magnitude of his present crimes against his country ‡ The "small still voice" of murder is not heard amidst the shouts of treason. Your party with the warmth of sincerity, shake his hand, stained, wet, and chilled with the blood of a former friend; all sense of prior attachments, and the blackest criminality, are overwhelmed by the tide of gratitude for bold attempts to divide the U. States, and to subvert the government.
The general character of your party justified a suspicion, that the projects of Burr would receive their aid, because the object of both was the destruction of our present government. That suspicion has been confirmed by their late conduct, which has developed the designs and demonstrated the tendency of their principles, beyond the possibility of rational doubt. The conduct of the party has been the subject of common observation, and trite remark. But no individual has been marked by particular animadversion. The distinguished part you have acted, and the masterly manner in which you have supported it, gave you a title to separate consideration, and particular attention. A separate critique is due to the chief juggler, while a general remark is all that can be claimed, by such pitiful puppets as Blennerhasset and Dayton, Lee and Martin.
* The life of Washington. O "profanitas impia tituli."
† Nolle prosequi has been entered in Bergen county, Jersey, under the plea of defects in the indictment.
‡ At the house of Jno. Wickham in Richmond.
The collected merits, of your conduct during the examination and trial of Burr, have not failed to make a proper impression on the public mind, although many of the separate parts have lost their divided and peculiar flavour, in the combined sweetness of the whole. The distinct tastes of the component parts, shall yet feast the palate of the public.
In another letter, I shall remark upon your conduct on the examination of Aaron Burr for treason and misdemeanor, and I solemnly undertake to shew, that you have rendered the administration of justice suspected—that you have manifested a partiality disgraceful to the character of a judge—and that you have prostrated the dignity of the chief justice of the U. S.
These serious charges will meet the attention of the public, and will command even your consideration. If they are groundless, the voice of the public by honorably acquitting you, will condemn me. The severity of truth will probably wound your feelings and excite the hatred and animosity, of your friends, and party. But, sir, the best interests of the nation must not be sacrificed to the feelings of any man. I shall not regard the threats and menaces of your friends, nor an affected contempt, or an impudent and hardy denial of facts by yourself.
Whether the whole of your conduct has been guided by personal considerations, private friendship, or by party spirit—or a determined hatred and hostility to the government and the laws, is not for me to determine. I do not wish to dive into your breast. Your warmest friends cannot attribute to personal enmity, or private pique, the animadversions of a man, who never exchanged a word with you, and who, so far as he is acquainted with your private character, will bear testimony to its correctness.
Every good man must deplore the blind zeal, the mad infatuation, which have turned your transcendant talents against your country, and rendered you a disgrace to the bench of justice. You might have been loved for your virtues, revered and respected for your wisdom, and admired for your talents; you might have been one of the boasted patriots of Virginia, and the illustrious benefactor of your own species. But you have chosen to be among the leaders of a faction, who would be as faithless to you to morrow, as they are to Hamilton this day, had they no prospect of deriving advantages from the use of you—a faction remarkable for nothing, but rancorous animosity, violent opposition to the government of their country, and to the choice of the people; and for their daring attempts, by intrigue and violence, to destroy the liberty and happiness of America:—You must deplore in secret the choice you have made.
It is not necessary to the establishment of my charges against you, that I should shew a breach of legal forms: It is the spirit of justice, and the meaning of the laws, which you have violated and disregarded. I complain that only the forms remain. Even Brumley, Jeffries, and Mansfield, as well as Marshall, said they respected the forms of law.—Nor will it be expected, that in arraigning you at the bar of the public, I shall preserve the accurate precision of a special pleader.
If my accusation is substantially true, and plainly set forth, I shall be permitted to disregard those technical forms, which serve only to protect some persons who uphold them, from the punishment due to their crimes. However informal the accusation, and dull the arguments may be, I shall be honored with the attention of the public, because the honor and dignity of the highest judicial officer of the U. States, are involved in the issue.
LUCIUS.