As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

December 1807

28 articles

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The Aurora and Baltimore Whig warn of impending war with England, citing troop movements, British deposits, and naval preparations near American shores. The piece bitterly notes that Burr and his associates, thanks to Judge Marshall's acquittal, are now free to potentially join renewed conspiracies amid the war crisis.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 1 December 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

And it is too likely that it will appear, that the secret expedition, said to be fitting out for Madeira, will bring to our coasts the first tidings of a declaration of war. New Orleans is much likelier to be the place of its destination than Madeira; and, thanks to judge Marshall and company, Burr

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

A letter from Philadelphia notes Burr, Blennerhassett, Bollman, Swartwout, and others gathering and conferring, with rumors of a new conspiracy under foreign auspices. Separately, General Wilkinson is praised by Baltimore citizens for his role in exposing the traitors.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 1 December 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Extract of a letter dated Philadelphia, November 12, 1807. "Col. Burr, Blannerhasset, Bollman, Swartwout, Ogden, and others of the party have been convened in this city

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The U.S. Senate considered resolutions to investigate Senator John Smith of Ohio, who had been indicted for treason and misdemeanor in connection with Aaron Burr's conspiracy. Members debated whether a committee should examine his conduct and whether he should be expelled, with Smith himself agreeing to delay taking his seat pending inquiry.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 1 December 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

which he took in the conspiracy of Aaron Burr against the peace and prosperity of the U. S. or what other steps in their opinion it may be necessary and proper under the present circumstances for the senate to adopt.

Mr. Pope moved to amend this resolution; to make way for which amendment Mr. Maclay withdrew his resolution.

See moreSee less

Mr. Thruston moved the following resolution as an amendment, omitting that part in Italics which Dr Jones moved as an amendment to the amendment:

Resolved, That a committee be appointed to enquire whether it be compatible with the honor and privileges of this House, that John Smith a senator from the state of O.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers

President Jefferson sends Congress the official proceedings and evidence from Aaron Burr's arraignment before the U.S. Circuit Court in Virginia, as promised earlier in the session. The House also handles routine business including petitions, committee referrals, and a report on British naval aggressions in American waters.

Virginia Argus · 1 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Monday, Nov. 23.

The following message was received from the President of the U. States.

See moreSee less

To the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States.

Agreeably to the assurance given in my message at the opening of the present session of Congress, I now lay before you a copy of the proceedings and of the evidence exhibited on the arraignment of Aaron Burr and others before the circuit court of the United States held in Virginia in the course of the present year in as authentic form as their several parts have admitted.

TH. JEFFERSON.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C. · 25 November 1807
  • The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H. · 8 December 1807

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The Federal Court allowed District Attorney George Hay $2,000 for extra services during the Burr trial, not $3,000 as erroneously reported in northern papers. This item corrects an earlier inaccurate figure.

Virginia Argus · 1 December 1807 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The sum allowed by the Federal Court to the District Attorney, George Hay, Esq. for his extra services during the trial of Burr and his accomplices, is two thousand dollars; and

See the clipping

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · Washington City, D.C.

The Senate committee investigating Senator John Smith of Ohio, an alleged associate of Aaron Burr, was authorized to expand its inquiry and subpoena persons and papers. The Senate also requested President Jefferson to provide any information in his possession relating to Smith's conduct.

The National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser · 2 December 1807 · page 3

SENATE UNITED STATES, November 30. Mr. Adams from tlie committee ap« i pointed in the case of Mr. Smith, made a report, recommending the a doption ot the following resolutions, j which were agreed to : Rasoived, That the committee pointed on the 27th inst. to enquire >* report t'ne facts, respecting tnc con duct of John Sm>th, a Senator from the state of Gilo, as an alleged asso ciate of Aaron Burr, be authorised to

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This passage records courtroom testimony from Major Bruff during the Burr treason trial, concerning land at Cold Water, General Wilkinson's conduct, and circumstances of Bruff's subpoena to testify. Wilkinson cross-examines Bruff about letters, conversations with Mr. Martin, and the timing of notice regarding testimony before the grand jury.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 2 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE

Queen Anne's county, in Maryland. General Wilkinson. Then you had a conference with Mr. Martin? A I had. General Wilkinson. Do you recollect to have said that you were reluctant to come, but Mr. Martin had promised to lash me into tortures? A I have said that from a conversation with Mr. Martin, I had reason to believe that your letter to colonel Burr, "post marked 13th of May," would be produced; but that I should have come in any event. [Here a certificate of col. Meigs was read; which see note B.] The first intimation I had of this letter was from a letter written by a gentleman of the grand jury to a friend of mine, stricturing the testimony of general Wilkinson given before that body. That part of the letter was confidentially read to me.

[Major Bruff was about to state a conversation with Mr. Martin, when he was interrupted by colonel Burr, who said that he could not consent to a narration of the conversations which might have been held with his counsel.]

See moreSee less

General Wilkinson. Did you not say that you believed Burr was guilty; but that I had done you a serious injury, and you thought this a good time to seek redress? A I have said that I believed colonel Burr concerned in that expedition with you. I have said so, and I think so still.

Mr. McRae. Will you state the character of judge Easton? A I have accused him of an endeavor to swindle me out of half the land we purchased in common on which an arbitration is now depending.

General Wilkinson. Had you no land speculations with Easton? A No. I had no speculations; but we made a purchase of a single tract of land together. Perhaps you call that speculations.

General Wilkinson. You said that when colonel Burr arrived at St. Louis, Easton and myself were intimate? Major Bruff. I tho't so.

General Wilkinson. Did you not know that about that time I did not suffer him to come into my house? A I heard him say after colonel Burr had left St. Louis

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

This report records courtroom testimony in which General Wilkinson questions Major Bruff about statements regarding Burr's guilt and a land dispute with Judge Easton. A letter from Wilkinson to Bruff is also read into the record as part of the examination of evidence.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 2 December 1807 · page 2

EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE

Queen Anoe's coumyssss, in Maryland. Ge. nerai Wilkinson. When you had :: conser. ence wissh Mr. Maninr A 1 had. General 'Wiikineoo. ss-_si Do you reccllcCt to have said .thar you were reluctant to come, but Mr. Manin bade-promised to lash me into tor. wren? A lsi-haire said thatfsirom acon-si'crsa. w-.. ' tion "wirh Mr. Martim *l had reason [) believe that yr—ur letter to coionel ,Burr, "posz marked leh ofsiMa _'." would ..be produced; but that ] should have come in any evcnt. [Here a ecrrisicaze of col. Meigs was read; which see note 13] The firstintimazion l had of this letter was from aienei written by a,gen*.leman of lhe '.

See moreSee less

sigrand jury in a friend of mine, stricturing " rhe-tcarimony of generai *.\Vilkinaon given before that body. That pan of the letter . wu eocfidenrialfy read lo—me. - ( -.[Major Brusswas about to state a coover. ! nation with Mr. Martin, when he was in) terruptcd by cc—lonel Burr, wssho said that he could no: consent to a nal-ration of the - conversaiioos which might have,,becnsibcid ,- wiib his counsel] General WilkinsanctctDid you not say that you believed b'urr was guilty-si;- but that ! had done you :: seriouainjury, and you though: this a good time to seek" redress-3 A .] have said that Ibelieved eolonelct-Buir concerned in that exped'uion with you. ;! have said so. and ! :hiokso sail}. ", si Mr. M'cRae. Will you state the chafe-c. I in of judge Easxon? A I have sea-used him of an endeavor to swiudle me out of half thsiess'isiaud we purchaoed in common on which an ss'bitraziou is now depending. General Wilkinson. Had you no land s '- speculalions wizh Eastoosi? A ss'NO. I had no spcculaticns ; but we made :: purchase of ; single tract o! land together, Per ha'pcts you tail that specuiatioos. Generai -Wilkineon.— You ssctsaid that when colooel But: arrived at St; Louis, Easton and my ;siself wereimimme? Major Brzctff. l—lho'c so. .. General Wilkinsan. Did you notknow that aboutctehzc time [did not suffer him losscomc into my house? A ! heard him say siafler coionel But: had left St. ctLouio

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

The Senate committee investigating Senator John Smith of Ohio, an alleged associate of Aaron Burr, was authorized to broaden its inquiry and summon witnesses and records. The Senate also requested that President Jefferson provide any information he possessed regarding Smith's conduct.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 3 December 1807 · page 3

IN' SENATE. Nav. 30. ss Mr. Aciams'fmm the sinnrnmittee ap. 3 poirred in the case of Mr._8_mith. made a report, recommending "the adnprion of ss the foliotfirtg resolutiobs," which were a. greed" to .-_ " ' - 1 '- ssResaIvectd, That the committee appointed ; on thesiss27th inst. to enquire and report the _ factatrcspecting "theconduct of ]. Smith, ss a senator from the etate of Ohio, as an aiisicdged asieasiociatect of Aaron Burr, be an.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

Witnesses recount General Wilkinson's letters to Burr referencing a 'grand expedition' and his claim he wrote to draw out Burr's true intentions. Testimony covers conflicting recollections about the timing and content of the letters and a prior meeting at St. Louis.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 4 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ed to that letter containing the expressions just quoted? A The winter of 1805—6, or the following spring. Mr. Cabell being requested by colonel Burr to state his recollection of the evidence of general Wilkinson as to the points above mentioned, proceeded in substance as follows: general Wilkinson had stated, that he had had an interview with you at St. Louis, at which you mentioned a grand project; but that you did not enter into particulars. He remarked that he had made some enquiries as to the nature of the enterprise; but you observed it was unnecessary to enter into particulars, for it was possible it might never be carried into effect.

See moreSee less

After colonel Burr left St. Louis, General Wilkinson remarked that he had revolved in his mind the conversation which had passed between him and colonel Burr,

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A polemical letter addressed to Chief Justice John Marshall questions the legality of his conduct in examining and bailing Aaron Burr across two separate sessions. The author argues Marshall's jurisdiction as examining magistrate should have ended once he ruled on probable guilt, making the second day's proceedings legally improper.

The Enquirer · 4 December 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

TO JOHN MARSHALL

were calculated.

The examination of Aaron Burr before you at the Eagle Tavern in Richmond, I presume was not final; the proceedings at the capitol on the succeeding day, were nothing more than a continuation of that examination. I make this conclusion, because the functions of an examining magistrate cease, as such, immediately on his determining the probable guilt or innocence of the accused, and discharging, bailing or committing to the custody of the prisoner.

See moreSee less

If you had decided upon the probable guilt of Aaron Burr at the Eagle Tavern, your functions were ipso facto discharged, and you could not have re-examined him on the same warrant the next day at the capitol; for you would have had no jurisdiction, having previously decided on the same charges.

Do the laws of Congress, or the state of Virginia authorize an examining magistrate to take the body of the accused out of the custody of the officer, having a warrant against him, and to bail, discharge or commit him previous to the decision of his probable guilt or innocence.

Is not the right to bail, &c. consequent of the decision of the case upon the exhibition of the testimony? If it is, from whence derive the legal right to bail A. Burr during the examination and before the delivery of an opinion upon this case?

But suppose this to be one of the powers confided to the sound discretion of an examining magistrate; that he might even make any temporary order pendente examinatione, to suit his own convenience, that of the accused, or to father the cause of justice, or humanity; was this a case where the exercise of that discretionary power was necessary, either for the purpose of humanity, of justice, or such convenience, as was compatible with the safe keeping of the accused until a final decision?

Every man who recollects that Richmond was the scene of the examination, must know that A. Burr might have been accommodated in the custody of the marshal for one day without being put to any inconvenience sufficient to justify you in giving him an opportunity to escape. Do you believe that he had any thing to fear from the cruelty, or even any supposable rudeness of Major Scott? You must know that the politeness of the marshal would have afforded to his charge every accommodation which was consistent with his duty.

For what purpose then, sir, if you had the right, did you bail A. Burr, between the time of the private examination at the Eagle Tavern, and the public one the very next day at the Capitol?

I defy all the Federalists, traitors, casuists, and jesuits of counsel for you, to help you to one good reason.

This extraordinary and illegal act of partiality and tenderness no doubt relieved the groundless fears of Burr. The very act which gave him an opportunity to escape, proved incontestably that flight was not

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

An anonymous writer addresses a chief justice (implicitly John Marshall), accusing him of favoring Aaron Burr's cause out of federalist party loyalty and personal animosity toward Jefferson's administration. The letter frames the judiciary's handling of the Burr case as politically motivated, written in a scathing, sarcastic tone referencing 'Curtius' and federalist conduct toward Burr.

Virginia Argus · 4 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

An oppurtunity of doing an essential service to the cause of federalism so seldom occurs, that it would be an injustice to your understanding to suppose that you did not instantly perceive, and to your zeal that you did not improve, that which the projects of Burr has presented. But you have even surpassed the expectation of many

See the clipping

In the story →

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

This opinion piece accuses Federalist leaders of hypocrisy for now defending Aaron Burr on treason charges after condemning him for killing Hamilton in 1804. The author argues Federalists are motivated by shared political corruption rather than principle, noting lawyers like Lee and Martin now represent the man they once cursed.

Virginia Argus · 4 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FROM THE AURORA.

LETTER THE FIRST.

See moreSee less

TO JOHN MARSHALL, CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE U STATES.

Sir—The appearance of a letter, addressed to you, in a news-paper, is calculated to excite the curiosity of the public, more than to flatter your vanity—and it is less likely to gratify your feelings, than to excite anticipations of pain, too strong to leave the slightest promise of pleasure. You could have dispensed with the honor of this address, without regret or mortification, and consoled yourself for the want of a proper appreciation of your virtues and talents, with the fruits of their exertion. But you have an equal title to both, and the justice of the public will pay that tribute to your worth, which your modesty would willingly decline.

Your country sir, owes you a debt of gratitude for former favors. The addition of a new item to the account, naturally produces a recurrence to them, and a wish to settle the added amount of the whole. This, I fear, is beyond the ability of your debtor, because the whole stock of national indignation and contempt would be exhausted, before the half of your just claim could be discharged.

But in the distribution of that infamy, and detestation, which will certainly be divided among those, who have long labored, with a zealous ardour which nothing could abate, and a patient industry which no difficulties could tire, for the destruction of our republican institutions, the subvertion of our government, and the erection of tyranny, upon the tomb of freedom, you, as a principal creditor, shall not be forgotten.

If, sir, the exertion of your abilities had been confined to the defence of measures incompatible with the spirit of republican government, or to the mysteries of diplomatic agency, one of the virtues, which most strongly marks your political character, would have flourished and died in obscurity; the invincible strength of your attachment to federal principles. Your worst enemies, and best friends must now acknowledge the fidelity of your attachments, and bear testimony to the uniform consistency of your conduct.

The wisdom of age, has confirmed and sanctioned the choice of youth. The examination and trial of Aaron Burr for treason, and misdemeanor, have furnished you with a happy opportunity, not only to display this hidden virtue to the world, but of exercising the endless variety of your talents.

The superiority of your understanding, the force of your penetration, the strength of your judgment, in conducting the manoeuvres of a political party, have already been displayed and admired, while their application was deplored and detested. Your diplomatic skill and crafty cunning cannot be doubted by any, who recollect, that you have passed even the "X. Y. Z." of ministerial exercises. The facility with which you can "answer" the plainest questions with evasive obscurity, to conceal your opinions from the people, whose organ and representative you wished to be, has been recorded in pages consecrated by the "holy enthusiasm" of exalted genius and pure patriotism. You have not lived in vain. By exciting the genius and talents and indignation of John Thompson you have conferred an unintended benefit on your country, and have added, to the literary glory of Virginia, a ray of lustre, which will shine, when even the splendor of your talents and your crimes shall have faded forever. When your volumes* of apology for British insolence and cruelty, shall be buried in oblivion, the "letters of Curtius" will tell posterity that you existed; and "damn you to everlasting fame."

Your ingenuity in the interpretation of the laws, and the discreet and useful management of that sound discretion, confided to those who ought to be the organs of the true intention and meaning of the legislator, and the impartial dispensers of justice, have been reserved for an occasion worthy of their exertion even by a chief justice, the friend and favorite of John Adams.

An opportunity of doing an essential service to the cause of federalism so seldom occurs, that it would be an injustice to your understanding to suppose that you did not instantly perceive, and to your zeal that you did not improve, that which the projects of Burr has presented. But you have even surpassed the expectation of many of your own party. This, I attribute, not only to the motives which have hitherto guided the movements of that party, and yourself, but to the operation of feelings strongly excited. I do not suppose, that you weakly yield to the effusions of tenderness, or the ebullitions of passion, when they are opposed by your sober judgment, but that, like a wise man, you only indulge them, when it can be safely done without counteracting the superior views of interest or ambition.

It is natural that men, who have long labored to effect the same purpose, although by different means, should sympathise in their mutual sufferings, when disappointed and defeated. A similarity of pursuits, constantly causes a concurrence of sentiments and feelings. A speculative difference in opinions is lost and forgotten, in the pursuits of a common object. Even the leaders of opposed factions, can forget their enmity, and unite their forces, to resist the cause of virtue, and to repel its superior power when it threatens their destruction. It is not, therefore, strange, that you should be affected by the sufferings of Aaron Burr, or should feel a disposition to alleviate them.

Nothing can more aptly illustrate the principles of the federal party, or demonstrate their designs, than a fair exposition of their conduct towards Aaron Burr. The naked deformity of that conduct, has disgusted many who were delighted with the shining robe which had once concealed it. The worthy men of that party, who had been deceived by the pretences and ostensible motives of men, whose real designs were not to "give energy to the government," but slavery to the people, have been awakened from the dreams of federal intoxication, by the severe shock of treason—They have fled with the utmost precipitation.—For good men of every party will unite in their detestation of an action, which, without reference to party, or to names, is in itself immoral, criminal, and wicked.

The spirit which fired the breasts of the federal leaders, and the unhallowed flame that burnt the bosom of Burr, were seen to approach the sphere of each other's attraction. The similiarity of their appearance was marked, the same in colours, shades, and shapes, it was obvious that they were only separated particles of the same body, and would immediately unite. Every atom of honesty, attached to federalism, instantly receded from the detestable union. Recollect, sir, the conduct of your party towards Aaron Burr in 1804,—recollect your own

Was he then their friend, would any one of the party have then volunteered in his defence? Would Lee, or Martin, have been heard as his counsel, on an indictment for the murder of Hamilton? Would you have bailed him, during his examination, for that offence?

What has Burr done since the commission of that crime to atone for it? What has been his "peace offering?" I answer—treason against his country.

Ignorant of the satanic services he was meditating, and counting the death of Hamilton a clear loss; they loaded him with curses and execrations, whom they now cherish and defend, and within a few days have pardoned †

You have eaten of the same bread, and drank of the same cup, after solemnly deciding the probability of his guilt, and the remembrance of his former sins is lost in the magnitude of his present crimes against his country ‡ The "small still voice" of murder is not heard amidst the shouts of treason. Your party with the warmth of sincerity, shake his hand, stained, wet, and chilled with the blood of a former friend; all sense of prior attachments, and the blackest criminality, are overwhelmed by the tide of gratitude for bold attempts to divide the U. States, and to subvert the government.

The general character of your party justified a suspicion, that the projects of Burr would receive their aid, because the object of both was the destruction of our present government. That suspicion has been confirmed by their late conduct, which has developed the designs and demonstrated the tendency of their principles, beyond the possibility of rational doubt. The conduct of the party has been the subject of common observation, and trite remark. But no individual has been marked by particular animadversion. The distinguished part you have acted, and the masterly manner in which you have supported it, gave you a title to separate consideration, and particular attention. A separate critique is due to the chief juggler, while a general remark is all that can be claimed, by such pitiful puppets as Blennerhasset and Dayton, Lee and Martin.

* The life of Washington. O "profanitas impia tituli."

† Nolle prosequi has been entered in Bergen county, Jersey, under the plea of defects in the indictment.

‡ At the house of Jno. Wickham in Richmond.

The collected merits, of your conduct during the examination and trial of Burr, have not failed to make a proper impression on the public mind, although many of the separate parts have lost their divided and peculiar flavour, in the combined sweetness of the whole. The distinct tastes of the component parts, shall yet feast the palate of the public.

In another letter, I shall remark upon your conduct on the examination of Aaron Burr for treason and misdemeanor, and I solemnly undertake to shew, that you have rendered the administration of justice suspected—that you have manifested a partiality disgraceful to the character of a judge—and that you have prostrated the dignity of the chief justice of the U. S.

These serious charges will meet the attention of the public, and will command even your consideration. If they are groundless, the voice of the public by honorably acquitting you, will condemn me. The severity of truth will probably wound your feelings and excite the hatred and animosity, of your friends, and party. But, sir, the best interests of the nation must not be sacrificed to the feelings of any man. I shall not regard the threats and menaces of your friends, nor an affected contempt, or an impudent and hardy denial of facts by yourself.

Whether the whole of your conduct has been guided by personal considerations, private friendship, or by party spirit—or a determined hatred and hostility to the government and the laws, is not for me to determine. I do not wish to dive into your breast. Your warmest friends cannot attribute to personal enmity, or private pique, the animadversions of a man, who never exchanged a word with you, and who, so far as he is acquainted with your private character, will bear testimony to its correctness.

Every good man must deplore the blind zeal, the mad infatuation, which have turned your transcendant talents against your country, and rendered you a disgrace to the bench of justice. You might have been loved for your virtues, revered and respected for your wisdom, and admired for your talents; you might have been one of the boasted patriots of Virginia, and the illustrious benefactor of your own species. But you have chosen to be among the leaders of a faction, who would be as faithless to you to morrow, as they are to Hamilton this day, had they no prospect of deriving advantages from the use of you—a faction remarkable for nothing, but rancorous animosity, violent opposition to the government of their country, and to the choice of the people; and for their daring attempts, by intrigue and violence, to destroy the liberty and happiness of America:—You must deplore in secret the choice you have made.

It is not necessary to the establishment of my charges against you, that I should shew a breach of legal forms: It is the spirit of justice, and the meaning of the laws, which you have violated and disregarded. I complain that only the forms remain. Even Brumley, Jeffries, and Mansfield, as well as Marshall, said they respected the forms of law.—Nor will it be expected, that in arraigning you at the bar of the public, I shall preserve the accurate precision of a special pleader.

If my accusation is substantially true, and plainly set forth, I shall be permitted to disregard those technical forms, which serve only to protect some persons who uphold them, from the punishment due to their crimes. However informal the accusation, and dull the arguments may be, I shall be honored with the attention of the public, because the honor and dignity of the highest judicial officer of the U. States, are involved in the issue.

LUCIUS.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Enquirer · Richmond, Va. · 1 December 1807 · an extract

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

This is an opinion piece/open letter condemning a prominent attorney for defending Burr despite earlier believing him guilty of murdering Hamilton, accusing the writer's political party of embracing Burr for his treasonous attempt to divide the Union. The author promises a follow-up letter detailing the lawyer's conduct during Burr's treason examination and trial.

Virginia Argus · 4 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

government. The general character of your party justified a suspicion, that the projects of Burr would receive their aid, because the object of both was the destruction of our present government. That suspicion has been con-

See the clipping

The New Hampshire Gazette · Portsmouth, N.H.

The passage reports that the Aurora newspaper is publishing a series of pointed letters addressed to Chief Justice Marshall, criticizing his conduct during the Burr treason trial. It also notes a monument to naval officers killed at Tripoli has arrived in Washington, and comments on changing public opinion toward Jefferson.

The New Hampshire Gazette · 8 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

pertinent, severe, and well written letters addressed to Chief-Justice Marshal, animadverting upon his extraordinary conduct during the trial of Burr. We are sorry that their length and our narrow limits will not admit of their insertion. [Ægis.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The U.S. Senate considers resolutions on whether Senator John Smith of Ohio should be expelled or investigated for his alleged role as an associate of Aaron Burr's conspiracy, despite a nolle prosequi being entered on his treason and misdemeanor indictments. Members debate the scope of a proposed investigating committee and the standard of evidence needed for Senate action, distinct from a court of law.

The Enquirer · 8 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SENATE UNITED STATES,

Italics, which Dr. Jones moved as an amendment to the amendment:

Resolved, That a committee be appointed to enquire whether it be compatible with the honor and privileges of this House, that John Smith, a Senator from the state of Ohio, against whom bills of indictment were found at the circuit court of Virginia, held at Richmond in August last, for treason and misdemeanor, should be permitted any longer to have a seat therein, and that the committee do enquire into all the facts regarding the conduct of Mr. Smith, as an alledged associate of Aaron Burr, and report the same to the Senate.

See moreSee less

In this stage of the business we entered

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

Senator John Smith requests a public Senate investigation into charges against him from the Richmond grand jury, expressing confidence it will clear his name. Senators Smith, Mitchell, and Thruston debate whether the Senate should pursue the inquiry, citing testimony from Blennerhassett's gardener and Lieut. Jackson.

The Enquirer · 8 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

I am, dear sir, respectfully yours, &c. JOHN SMITH.

Hon. Mr. Tiffin.

See moreSee less

Mr. S. Smith said, that however unpleasant it might be, it was the duty of the Senate to meet the proposed enquiry. It did not follow that such an investigation would go to criminate Mr. Smith. It might, on the contrary, issue in his exculpation. He understood that that gentleman had expressed his conviction that a full investigation would completely exculpate him from the charges which had been profered against him. Be this as it might, Mr. S. thought there were circumstances which had been disclosed at Richmond, which called upon the Senate to go into the enquiry. He alluded to the testimony of Blennerhassett's gardener and Lieut. Jackson. He had, however, heard that Mr. S.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Senate debates and adopts resolutions to form a committee investigating Senator John Smith of Ohio for his alleged association with Aaron Burr's conspiracy, with power to subpoena persons, papers, and records. The President is also requested to provide any information he has regarding Smith's conduct.

The Enquirer · 8 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

therefore, of opinion that in this case the Senate might decide upon what appeared to them credible testimony, although it should not be of such a character as would be admitted in a court of law.

The question was then taken on the resolution, offered by Mr. Thruston, and amended by Mr. Jones, and carried without a division—and Messrs. Adams, Maclay, Franklin, Smith of Maryland, Pope, Thruston and Anderson appointed the committee.

See moreSee less

In the course of the proceedings, Mr. White read the following resolution, as such an one as he thought it most expedient to adopt.

Resolved, That a committee be appointed to enquire whether any, and what proceedings should be had against John Smith, a Senator from the state of Ohio, in relation to any connection he may be supposed to have had with the conspiracy or any illegal enterprize of Aaron Burr, and that the said committee have power to send for persons, papers and records, on the subject committed to them, and to report the facts to the Senate.

Mr. Adams from the committee appointed in the case of Mr. Smith, made a report, recommending the adoption of the following resolutions, which were agreed to:

Resolved, That the committee appointed on the 27th inst. to enquire and report the facts, respecting the conduct of John Smith, a senator from the state of Ohio, as an alledged associate of Aaron Burr, be authorised to extend their enquiries to any other facts, which in their opinion would be incompatible with his duty as a senator of the U. States, and that they be authorised to send for persons, papers and records.

Resolved, That the President of the U. S. be requested to cause to be laid before the Senate such information as may be in his possession, in relation to the conduct of John Smith, a senator from the state of Ohio, as an alledged associate of Aaron Burr.

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A published letter addressed to Chief Justice John Marshall argues he was unjustified in expecting the executive to produce proof of an overt act of treason at Burr's Richmond examination. The writer contends the government could not have known Burr would be tried there until just ten or twelve days before the hearing, making timely evidence production impossible.

The Enquirer · 8 December 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

mission avail?

Will it shew that the production of that evidence could be reasonably expected on the examination in Richmond? Surely not—and for this plain reason, that the executive could not possibly know that A. Burr would be examined at Richmond, or that he ever would be in Virginia, until about ten or twelve days previous to the examination.

See moreSee less

Burr was arrested on the 19th of February on the Tombigbee river, in the Mississippi territory, and arrived in Richmond on the 26th of March.—The President could not have been apprised of his arrest more than ten or twelve days previous to the examination. The necessity of producing the testimony at Richmond, could not exist until it was known that Burr could be examined there. This was ten or twelve days previous to the examination.

Now sir, admitting the evidence of the overt act, which you demanded on the examination, to have been collected, where should we reasonably expect that this evidence was at that time? I am as unwilling to attribute to the executive any "remissness" or neglect of duty as you professed to be on the examination, and therefore suppose that if any evidence of the overt act had reached the executive, it had been transmitted to the court where A. Burr was recognized to appear. Was not this the duty of the executive? The evidence then ought to have been, and you were bound to presume it, ten or twelve days previous to the examination, at a place 6 or 7 hundred miles distant from Richmond. If it was impossible in the time intervening between the examination, and that point of time at which it was known that A. Burr could be examined at Richmond, to produce at that place, testimony of the overt act, what opinion ought we to entertain of a judge who demands the production of that testimony?

When A. Burr was in the western country, the theatre of his treason, recognized to ap[pear]

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A letter signed 'Lucius' accuses a judge of improperly omitting review of key arguments and evidence presented by the U.S. attorney regarding the timing of Burr's arrest and the impossibility of proving an assemblage. The writer argues the judge's refusal to charge treason in the warrant was unjust given what had already been established.

The Enquirer · 8 December 1807 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ticular operation" of this argument of Mr. Rodney on "your judgment." "In the short time which has elapsed since the apprehension of Col. Burr was known; there has been no possibility of getting the proof, which his

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Senate considers resolutions on whether John Smith, a senator from Ohio indicted for treason and misdemeanor in connection with Aaron Burr's conspiracy, should be expelled or investigated. Several amendments are proposed and debated regarding the scope of a committee's inquiry into Smith's conduct and alleged association with Burr.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

quire into all the facts regarding the conduct of Mr. Smith, as an alledged associate of Aaron Burr, and report the same to the senate.

In this stage of the business we entered the senate chamber.

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Senate committee reports on its inquiry into Senator John Smith of Ohio, an alleged associate of Aaron Burr, expanding its investigative authority and requesting information from the President. Separately, the Senate debates and amends a bill concerning foreign armed vessels in U.S. ports, voting down a section restricting British ships.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 9 December 1807 · page 3

SENATE OF TIIE UNITED STATES. November 30. Mr. Adams from the committee appointed in the case of Mr. Smith, made a repott, recommending the adoption of the billowing resolutions, which were agreed to : Rrsolvi rf, that the committee appointed on tbs 27th instant, to enquire and repot t the lads, res pecting the conduct ol John Smith, a senator from the state ol Ohio, as an alledged associate of Aaron Burr, he authorised to extend their enquiries to any other fads, w hich m their opinion would he incom patible with his duly as a senator ol the United States, and that they he authorised to send for per sons, papers and records.

See moreSee less

Hiyihrd, That the president of th? United States be requested to cause to he lain ueiore ino st nau* such information as may he in his possession, in relation to the conduct ol John Smith, a senator from the state of Ohio, as an alledged associate ol Aaron Burr.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness is cross-examined about alleged confidential conversations with Major Bruff and claims of fortune-making schemes, denying key allegations. The defense and prosecution also dispute whether Governor Harrison's full letter to General Wilkinson must be produced after an extract was read in evidence.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 11 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

EXAMINATION OF EVIDENCE

substantiate his tale, has affected an air of mystery, and his imagination has furnished the scenery—for this purpose he takes me into the woods, has us hunted up by Frenchmen, then locks a door where there was no lock, it being fastened by hooks & staples; nor was it necessary to shut it at all, as the ordinary guard at head quarters gave two sentinels for its protection. This locking of the door betrayed some concert; for I well remember that a few days ago, one of the counsel of colonel Burr (Mr. Martin) demanded of me emphatically, whether I did not recollect being locked up in a room with a gentleman and having a long conversation with him. Mr. Hay. Did you ever select major Bruff for the purpose of making confidential communications; or state to him any thing about the prospect of making fortunes? A No, never.

Colonel Burr. Are you acquainted with a Mr. Bon Ami, a magistrate of New Orleans? A I have no recollection of any person of that name.

See moreSee less

[Mr. Wickham called for the production of the original letter of governor Harrison to general Wilkinson, from which an extract had been read. The counsel of col. Burr contended that as an extract had been read from it, they had a right to the whole letter, as the best evidence. They were answered by the counsel for the U. S. that there was not a word in the letter which had any relation to Mr Bruff except the paragraph which had been read; and that the letter was entirely private and confidential.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A fiery opinion piece accuses the presiding judge (evidently John Marshall) of partiality toward Aaron Burr during his treason trial, citing his dining with Burr and failure to rebuke defense counsel Luther Martin's abusive language. The writer doubts impeachment will follow but insists the judge's misconduct should be publicly condemned.

Virginia Argus · 11 December 1807 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

certainty of your sins therefore only serves to strengthen their attachment.

The circumstances of your dining with a man, the probability of whose guilt you had pronounced your patient attention to indecorous slander and scurrilous abuse of the executive branch of the federal government—your soul discovering lapsus linguae, about the wishes of the government to convict Burr—your insulting the counsel of the United States, by including them in a general remark, occasioned not by the "unprincipled and unfounded" assertions of Luther Martin, who was constantly excited by habitual intoxication to the language of Billingsgate, and whom you ought to have sent to the stocks—but by the expression of Mr. M'Rae's honest indignation.

See moreSee less

Your perfect disregard to the dignity of the court, in neglecting to censure Martin individually for his blackguard effusions of spleen and brandy, and yet insulting the gentlemen of counsel on both sides by a general observation—all these things, besides superior services in opinions and explanations of opinions, serve only to endear you to your party, the worst enemies of the United States.

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

A letter describes Aaron Burr passing through Washington and Alexandria without being received by anyone of standing, after being refused lodging by a tavern keeper. It also notes that effigies of Burr, Marshall, and Blennerhassett were burned by crowds in Baltimore.

Virginia Argus · 11 December 1807 · page 3

COMMUNICATION

Extract of a letter from a gentleman, dat ed, Ha-shiv -ion City, Aov. 6, 1807. “Air. Burr uas passed thro* this place. He did not experience either itipathy nr attention litre. He st »pt in Alexandria, sent a servant to Mr. Myers Here, who keeps a Tavern, to send his Hack for him and prepare rooms. Myers refused to rc i ceive linn, and he passed through Wash | ington without stopping. 1 do no: believe, , that any man cf character here, either fa lderal, republican, or tor)', would have condescended either t > speak to, cr visit Aaron Burr. In Baltimore, the Effigies of Burr, Marshall and Blennerhfcssett, Were burnt amidst the acclamations of the peo ple.”

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A polemical letter accuses an unnamed judge of consistent bias and partiality favoring Aaron Burr throughout the legal proceedings, from his examination through his recognizance to appear in Ohio. The writer argues the judge's supporters will excuse this favoritism regardless of evidence, comparing the judge's conduct to a guide leading observers through a biased 'labyrinth' of legal reasoning.

The Enquirer · 12 December 1807 · page 4

# aistance.' To comment upon every evidence of partiality iuid illegal bias which your conduct lias afforded would render necessary the introduction of even opinion, and almost every obiturdictum which \>m have pronounced from the commencement of the examination to the time of Burr’s recognizance to appear in Ohio.

See the clipping

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · Alexandria, Va.

A witness is questioned at length about the nature of a military post, the quality of its land and water, and the relationships between General Wilkinson, Colonel Burr, and Judge Easton. The testimony explores whether Wilkinson and Easton had an unusual intimacy and touches on rumors concerning Lieutenant Pike's party.

Alexandria Daily Advertiser · 14 December 1807 · page 2

A There is a good spring "and a handsome ss marsh next to the second b ck. ] nere is also & enow-ending Situation for a canton ment Within the purchase but not at that 'j spot. Q Are you certaitt that there was a ss good noderstaodiog between general Wil kiuson, colonel Burr and jodgectsi Laston ? A .! believe there was. Easton often visit sit ed him, and eodeavcred to reconcile us as ter We iellout, and the geoetal has some ! times read to me parag aphs from letters he received from colonel Burr, abour the ;

See the clipping

The Wheeling Repository · Wheeling, Va. W. Va.

A self-identified Republican writer recounts his reactions to newspaper essays discussing General Wilkinson's conduct toward Burr and the New Orleans judges. He expresses indignation against Burr and his confederates while rationalizing Wilkinson's legally questionable actions as necessary to suppress treason.

The Wheeling Repository · 17 December 1807 · page 2

\ l t his attack upon Gen. Wilkinson and' the Judges of New-Ot leans vexed me. 1 iutt Cion. Wilkinson had violated the law; that the Judges had shrunk from tlu ir duty, I could not doubt: but as this was done for the purpose of crushing treason, I did not feel tiny indignation a g.iuiu. them. My w hole indignation, was mused against Burr and his confe-V derates, and l could not see how any • man could he dissatisfied with Wilkin son, without being a partisan of Burr.

See the clipping