As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

July 1891

22 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An attorney relays a story told by an old freighter claiming that after a murder was discovered, searchers forced a confession from the Bender family and then hanged them, shooting Kate Bender when she protested. The bodies were allegedly buried near the house, explaining the family's mysterious disappearance that had prompted a long official manhunt.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 16 July 1891 · page 7

FATE OF THE BENDERS.

Were Lynehed by Avengers. K. B. Randolph, an attorney of St. Joseph, Mo., who has just returned from Nickerson. Kan.. aiys that he there made the acquaintance of Ton Deolittle. an old-tinie freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family, which. if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle lays that after the murder of York a bend of senrchers. headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman. They then quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rofters of the house.

See moreSee less

During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the faily had been dispatched York's avengers took the l-odies to the creek bed, some yards distant from the house, and buried them. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

An attorney relays secondhand testimony from an old freighter claiming that after a murder victim's brother led a posse to the Bender house, the family was hanged and Kate Bender shot after confessing, with bodies buried near a creek. The story purports to finally resolve the long-standing mystery of the Benders' disappearance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Indianapolis Journal · 16 July 1891 · page 5

THE MURDEROUS BENDERS.

An Alleged Trne Story of the Awful Fate of the Entire Family. St. Joseph, Mo., July 13. K. B. Kandolph. an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nickerson. Kan., says that he there made the acquaintance of Thomas Doolittle. an old-time freighter, who tolu hi ui a story of the famous Bender family which, if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of mur derers. Doolittle says that after the mur der of York, a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house aud extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, to gether with his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding, Kate Bender offered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched. York's avengers took the bodies to the creeK bed somo yards distance from the house and buried them. The attention of n family living on an adjacent ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and then the ab sence of the family was first made kuown to the public. This gave rise to the report that the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment and caused the pro longed search after them by the officers of the law.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A St. Joe, Mo. report recounts attorney E. B. Randolph's secondhand story from an old frontiersman claiming the Bender family was caught, forced into a confession, and lynched by a vigilante mob avenging victim York, with the bodies buried near the farm. The piece explicitly frames this as an unverified tale ('if true') meant to explain the family's disappearance and the fruitless official manhunt.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 16 July 1891 · page 1

THE BENDER CHESTNUT. St. Joe, Mo., July 15. K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city, who has just re turned from Nickerson, Kan., saya that there he made the acqumtance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time Indian fighter, who told him a fetory of the famous""" Bender family, which, if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of York a band of searchers, head ed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son, to the rafters. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and wa shot to death. After the family was despatched, York's aven?er took the bod ies to a creek bed near tha houss and burled them. The attention of the family living on the adjacent ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and the absence of the fam ily was first made known. This gave rie to the report that the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment, and canned the prolonged search alter them by tae officers of the law.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

An attorney relays a story heard from an old freighter in Kansas claiming vigilantes led by victim York's brother extorted a confession and hanged the Bender family, shooting Kate Bender when she resisted. The account explains the family's disappearance as a cover-up rather than a successful escape from justice.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 July 1891 · page 4

St. Joseph. Mo., July 15. —K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city who has just returned from Nickerson, Kan., says that he there made the acquaint ance of Tom Doolittle, an old time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family which, if true, settles all question as to the where abouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of York, a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a con fession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this pro ceeding Kate Bender uttered some pro test and was shot to death. After the family had been, despatched York's avengers took the bodies to the creek bed some yards distant from the house. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days alter by a starving caif. and then the absence of the family was first made known. This gave rise to the report that the murder ous family had tied to avoid punish- ; ment, and causeil'the prolonged search after them by the officers of the law. *» FAKE FOOT RACE.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

An attorney relates a story from Tom Doolittle claiming that after a murder, vigilantes led by the victim's brother forced a confession from the Bender family, then hanged and shot them, burying the bodies near the house. This account contradicts the long-standing belief that the Benders fled and were never found.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Omaha Daily Bee · 16 July 1891 · page 1

BENDER FAMILY AGAIN.

Undertho Sod. ST. .TOSCPII , Mo. , July 15. 1C. D. Randolph , an attorney of this city , who has just re turned from Nlckorson , Kan. , says that ho made tbo acquaintance of Tom Doollttlo , an old-tlmo fighter , who told him a story of the fatnousJJendcr family , which if true settles all question as to tbo whereabouts of that family .of murderers , Doollttlo says that after > the murder of York n band of searchers , headed by the murdered man's brother , went to the Bender house nnd extorted a confession from tha old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly procccdod to hang Old man Bender , his wife and sou to the ratters of the house. Dur ing this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been despatched York's avengers took the bodies to the crock bed some yards distant from the house and burled thorn. The attention ot a family living on an adjacent ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by u starving calf and then the absence of the family was lirst made known to the public. This guvo rlso to the report trial the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment nnd caused prolonged search after them by the olllcors of tbo law.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

An attorney recounts a story told by an old freighter claiming that a band of avengers led by victim Dr. York's brother tracked down the Benders, forced a confession, and hanged or shot the entire family before burying them near their house. The account also explains the calf-discovery origin of the search that followed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 16 July 1891 · page 5

THE BENDERS WERE LYNCHED.

his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender ut tered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been despatched, York's avengers took the bodies to the creek bed, some yards distant from the house, and buried them. The attention of the family living on an adjoining farm w as attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and then tho absence of tho family was first made known to the public

See the clipping

In the story →

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

A St. Joseph attorney relays a story told by an old freighter, Tom Doolittle, claiming that after the murder of a man named York, vigilantes forced a confession from the Bender family and hanged them, shooting Kate Bender when she resisted. The bodies were supposedly buried near the house, discovered later by neighbors.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Madison Daily Leader · 16 July 1891 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HUNG THE BENDERS

A Queer Story Concerning an Old Sensation Told by a Kansas Man.

See moreSee less

An Old Time Freighter Says the Notorious Family Were Hung to the Rafters of the House,

And That He Helped to Do It—A Bold Robbery Committed on a Chicago Street Car.

ST. JOSEPH, MO., July 16.—K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nickerson, Kan., says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family, which, if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of York a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman. They then quietly proceeded to hang the old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protests and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched York's avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and their absence was first made known to the public.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

An attorney recounts a story told by an old freighter claiming that after York's murder, a band of avengers led by his brother extracted a confession from the Bender family, then hanged the parents and son and shot Kate Bender. The account says the bodies were buried near a creek and that the family's disappearance was later wrongly attributed to flight, sparking the long official search.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Alexandria Gazette · 16 July 1891 · page 2

The Bender Family K. P.aodolpb, an alt >rn&y of St. Joseph, Mo., whn b&ejnst returned home from Nick crson, KansR*, says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old-Mme freighter, who told him a story of tho fa? mous Bender family, which, if true, settler all qaestior. 8=) to the whereabouts of that famtiy o! murd^rcm. Doolittle says that af? ter the murder of York, a band of searchers, headed by tho murdorel mau'd brother, went to tbe Bender hcu9e end extorted a confession frem the old wtman, They then !

See moreSee less

quietly proceeded to bang old man Bender, j his wife arid son to the rafters of the bouse. IDurirg this proceeding Kate Bender utter i od some prottst, end was shot to death. Af ! ter the family bud boon dispatched, York's {avengers tnck the oodles to the creek hed Bome yards distant from the hours and Juried them. The ;i!Leution of a family liv? ing on no adjoinhig ranch was tittmoted to tho Bender place some days af;er by a

See the clipping

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

An attorney relays a secondhand tale from an old freighter claiming vigilantes led by victim York's brother hanged the Bender family and shot Kate Bender, then buried the bodies near the farm. The story suggests this explains the family's disappearance, contradicting the official narrative that they fled and were never found.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 17 July 1891 · page 3

THE MURDEROUS BENDERS.

Thomas Doolittle, aud old-time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Ben der family which, if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of York, a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to tho Bonder house and extorted a confession from the old wo man. They then quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, together with his wife and sou, to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding, Kate Bender offered some protest and was shot to death.

See moreSee less

After tho family had been dis patched, York's avengers took the bodies to the crock bod somo yardo distance from the house and buried them. The attention of tho family living on an ad jacent ranch was attracted to the Ben der place some days after by a starving calf, and then the absence of the family was first made known to the public. This gave rise to the report that the murderous family had fled to avoid pun ishment and caused the prolonged search niter them by the oflicers of the law.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

An attorney relays a secondhand story from an old freighter claiming that after the murder of a man named York, vigilantes hanged and shot the Bender family at their homestead and buried them nearby. The account suggests this explains their mysterious disappearance, contradicting the long-held belief that they fled.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wheeling Register · 17 July 1891 · page 2

END OF THE BENDERS.

That Old Mystery. St. Joseph, July 16.—K. It. Ran dolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nickerson, Kas., says that ho there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Ben ders which, If true, settles all question as to the present whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says af ter the murder of York, a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man’s broLher, went to the Bender house and ©Uorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly pro ceeded to hang old man Bender, tis wife and sou to the rafters of the bouse. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been despatched, York’s avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distant aud buried them. The aUeutlon of a family living on an ad joining ranch was attracted to the Beu der place sujne days after by a starving ■caif, aud then bheir absence was first made known to me public. This gave rise to the report that the murdered family had fled to avoid punishment and caused the prolonged search after them by the officers of the law and detectives. Mr. Raudolph says Doolittle bears a good reputation for truth and \eraclty and named several persons by whom he claimed the truthfulness of his story could be proved.

See the clipping

Fairhaven Herald · Fairhaven, Wash.

An attorney reports hearing from an old freighter in Kansas that after Dr. York's murder, a posse led by York's brother forced a confession from the Benders and hanged the family, shooting Kate Bender when she resisted. The bodies were allegedly buried near the house, and the family's disappearance was later mistaken for a flight from justice.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Fairhaven Herald · 21 July 1891 · page 1

THE BENDERS WERE LYNCHED

Sr. Joseru, Mo., July 20—-K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nicker son, Kan., says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family which, it true, settles all questions as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of York a band of search ers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old wo ‘man. They then quietly proceeded to Thang old man Bender, his wife and son

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.

An attorney relays a story from an old freighter claiming that after one of their victims was discovered, a mob led by the victim's brother hanged the Bender family and shot Kate Bender when she resisted. The account also explains how neighbors first noticed the family's absence via a starving calf, giving rise to the belief they had fled.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Watertown Republican · 22 July 1891 · page 2

How tlio Benders Died. K. B. Randolph, an attorney of St. Joseph, Mo., who has just returned from Kickerson, Kas.,says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle,

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

An old-time freighter named Doolittle recounts a tale that after the York murder, a posse led by the victim's brother tracked the Bender family to their house, extracted a confession, and hanged them from the rafters, shooting Kate Bender when she resisted. The bodies were allegedly dumped in a creek bed, supposedly settling the long-unresolved question of the family's fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 909 days later.

Wrong

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 23 July 1891 · page 8

derer is bordering on deliriu tremens. Tot Doolittle, old-time freighter, , Kansas, tolls a story of of the fumons Bender family, which, if true, settles all question ns to the whereabout» of the family of murderers. Doolittle savs that ufter the murder of York a hand fliers, headed by the munlured of 's brother, went to the Bender house jrted a confession from the old id . They then quietly proceeded to to Bender, his wife and s< the rafters of the house. During this pro ceeding Kate Bender o protest and was shot to death. After the famil had been dispatched, York's ave the bodies to the creek bed yards dis taut from the house «1 buried them. The steamship Pickhuben arrived at at

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

An attorney relays a secondhand account from an old freighter claiming vigilantes hanged three Benders and shot Kate Bender after extracting a confession, then buried the bodies near their house. The story is presented as unverified hearsay, with the attorney vouching only for the storyteller's reputation, not the facts themselves.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 909 days later.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 23 July 1891 · page 7

ANOTHER BENDER STORY. Three of the Monsters Hanged to the Kafters of Their Home aud Kate Bender Shot. St. Joseph, Ma, July 16. K. B. Ran dolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nickerson, Kan., says that he there made the acquaint ance of Torn Doolittle, an old-time freighter, who told hitn a story of the famous Benders which, if true, settles all question as to the present where abouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of York, a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched York's avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and then their absence was first made known to the public This gave rise to the reports that the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment and caused the prolonged search after them by the officers of the law and detectives. Mr. Randolph says Doolittle bears a good reputation for truth and veracity and named several persons by whom he claimed the truthfulness of his story could be proved.

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

An attorney recounts a story told by an old freighter claiming that after the murder of a man named York, a vigilante posse extorted a confession from the Bender family and then hanged them, shooting Kate Bender when she protested. The account claims this explains the family's disappearance, which had previously been attributed to flight from the law.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 909 days later.

Wrong

The Frontier · 23 July 1891 · page 2

The Benders* Fate. St. Joseph, Mo., July 18.—K. B. Ran- ] dolph, an attorney of this city who has just returned from Nickerson, Kan., says that he there made the acquaint ance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time freighter, who told mim a story of tne famous Bender family, which, if true, | settles all question as to the where abouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of York a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man’s brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

Then they quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this pro ceeding Kate Bender uttered some pro test and was shot to dfeath. After the family had been despatched, York’s avengers took the bodies to the creek bed, some yards distant from the house. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and the absence of the family was first made known. This gave rise to the report that the murder ous family had fled to avoid punish ment, and caused the prolonged search after them by the officers of the law. Th« Scheme • Saecew,

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

An attorney relays a story from an old freighter claiming vigilantes, led by a murdered man's brother, hanged and shot the Bender family at their home and buried them nearby. The account explains the family's disappearance as a cover-up rather than escape, contradicting the official search narrative.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 909 days later.

Wrong

Eagle River Review · 23 July 1891 · page 2

How the Benders Died. K. P. Randolph, an attorney of St. Joseph, Mo., who has just returned from Nickerson, Kas., says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle,

See the clipping

The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo.

An attorney recounts a story told by an old frontiersman claiming vigilantes led by York's brother hanged and shot the Bender family after extorting a confession, then buried them near their house. The account claims this explains their disappearance, which was later misreported as a flight from justice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 909 days later.

Wrong

The Rawlins Republican · 23 July 1891 · page 6

Probably the True Story. K. P. Randolph, an attorney of St. Joseph, Missouri, who has Just returned from Nickerson, Kansas says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doo little, an old time fighter, who told him a itory of the famous Bender family, which if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says that after the murder of ' York, a band of searchers, headed by the 1 murdered man’s brother, went to the Ben- ' der house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They then quietly pro ceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. Dur ing this proceeding Kate Bender uttered lome protest and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched, York’s avengers took the bodies to the creek bed tome yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a family living on an adjacent ranch was attracted to the Ben der place some days after by a starving calf, and then the absence of the family was first made public. Thia gave rise to the report that the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment, and caused the ' prolonged search after them by the officers of the law.

See the clipping

Alma Record · Alma, Mich.

A St. Joseph, Mo. dispatch reports that a band of regulators extorted a confession from the Bender family and then hanged the father, mother, and son, while Kate Bender was shot when she cried out. The bodies were allegedly buried near a creek by the Bender farm, with a starving calf found later giving rise to the earlier escape story.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 908 days later.

Wrong

Alma Record · 24 July 1891 · page 2

Fate of the Bender Family. A dispatch from St. Joseph, Mo., says; Tho mystery of the notorious Bender fam ily has again been solved. Thomas I too little, of Nickerson, Kas., savs that after the murder of Senator York's brother which caused the investigation a band of regulators visited the Bender homestead and extorted a complete confession from the old woman. Tho regulators then hanged Bender, his wife aud son to u rafter in tho kitchen. Kate Bender made some little outcry and she was promptly shot to death Later tho bodies were buried near the lit tle creek which runs by tho Bender farm.

See moreSee less

A neighboring family found a starving calf in Bender's shed several days nfter, aud this cave rise to tho story that the family had lied to escape the avengers.

See the clipping

The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb.

An attorney from St. Joseph relates a story told by an old freighter claiming that after the murder of York, a band led by York's brother forced a confession from the Benders and hanged the parents and son, shooting Kate Bender when she resisted. The account claims their bodies were buried near the house, explaining why the family's disappearance was later mistaken for a flight from justice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 908 days later.

Wrong

The McCook Tribune · 24 July 1891 · page 2

The Lost Bender Story

The Lift lleiulor Story. ST. JOSEPH , Mo. , July 17. T. B. Randolph , an attorney of this city , who has just returned from Nicirerson. Kas. . says that he there made the ac quaintance of Tom Doolittie. an old time freighter , who told a story of the famous Benders , which , if true , settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family. I'oolutle ' says after the j murder of York , a band of searchers , headed by the murdered man's brother , went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They hung old man Bender , his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During these proceedings Kate Bender offered some protest and was shot to death. Afterwards York's avengers f.ook their bodies to an old creek some yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a fam ily living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place by a starving calf and then their absence was first made known to the public. This gave rise to the report that the family had fled to avoid punishment and caused the prolonged search for them by the officers. Mr. Randolph cays Dooh'iUe bears

See the clipping

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

An attorney relays a story from an old freighter, Tom Doolittle, claiming that after the murder of a man named York, vigilantes forced a confession from the Bender family and then hanged and shot them, burying the bodies near their house. The account is offered as explaining the family's disappearance, though it rests entirely on one man's secondhand recollection.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 907 days later.

Wrong

The Caldwell Tribune · 25 July 1891 · page 7

END OF THE BENDERS, St. Louis Republic. St. Joseph , July 14.—K. B. Ran dolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nick erson, Kansas, says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, aa old-time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Benders which, if true, settles all question as to the present where abouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of of York, a band of searchers, head ed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Beuder house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

Then they quietly pro ceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and eon to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched, York's avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distant from the house and buried them. Tha attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender some days after by a starving calf, und then their absence was first made known to the public. This gave rise to the report that the murderous family had fled to avoid punishment and caused the prolonged search after them by the officers of the law and detectives. Mr. Randolph says Mr. Doolittle bears a good reputation for truth and veracity and named several persons by whom he claimed the truthfulness of hi« story could be proved.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

An attorney recounts a story told to him by Tom Doolittle claiming that after York's murder, a mob led by York's brother forced a confession from the Bender family, then hanged Pa, Ma, and the son from the rafters of their house while shooting Kate Bender when she protested. The bodies were allegedly buried near a creek, and the family's absence was only later discovered by neighbors, fueling the false belief they had fled.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 905 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Call · 27 July 1891 · page 8

HUNG TO RAFTERS.

Hun tbe Benders Were Swung Up In Their House by the Mob. K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Ni.kerson, Kan., says that he there madu the ac quaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time fighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family, which, if true, settles all question as to liie w hereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle snys that after the murder of York a baud of searchers, headed by tlie murdered man's brother, went to the Ben der house and extorted a confession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

They thpn quietly pro ceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son lo the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some pro test, and was shot to death. After the fam ily had been dispatched. York's avengers took the bodii-s to the creek bed some, yards distance from the house and buried ihem. The attention of a family living on an ad jacent ranch was attracted to the Bender

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

An attorney relays a story from an old freighter claiming vigilantes led by York's brother forced a confession, then hanged the Bender family and shot Kate Bender, later burying them near their home. The account explains their disappearance as explaining away the mystery that spurred years of searching, rather than an actual escape.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 901 days later.

Wrong

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 31 July 1891 · page 4

r.ml of the IteioterH. K. B. Randolph, an attorney of St. Joseph, Missouri, who has just re turned from Nickerson, Kansas, says that he there mude the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old-time freight er, who told him a story of the fa fa mous Bonders which, if true, Betties all question us to the present where abouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of of York, a band of searchers, headed by by the murdered man's brother, went to to the Bender house and extorted a con fession from the old woman.

See moreSee less

Then they quietly proceeded to hang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched, York's avengers took their bodies to to an old oreek bed some yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a family living on an ad joining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a a starving calf, and then their absence

See the clipping