As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

August 1891

1 article

Democratic Northwest · Napoleon, Ohio

An attorney relays a story from an old freighter claiming that after John York's murder, a vigilante band forced a confession from the Bender family and hanged them, shooting Kate Bender when she protested. The account claims this explains their disappearance, which had been mistakenly attributed to a flight from justice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 895 days later.

Wrong

Democratic Northwest · 6 August 1891 · page 3

THE BENDER FAMILY. An Eye Witness Telle of Their Death and Burial. K.B. Randolph an attorney of St. Joseph. Mo., who has returned from Mckerson, Kan., says mat oe were made the acquaiutance of Tom Doolit tle, and old time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender fami ly, which, it true, settles all questions as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of York a band of searchers, headed by the mu rdered man's broth er, went to the Bender house and ex torted a confession from the old wo man.

See moreSee less

They then quietly proceeded to bang old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During these proceedings Kate Bender uttered some protest and was shot to death. Af ter the family bad been dispatched. York's avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distance from the house and buried them. The attention aoffumilyon an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving cat, and then their absence was first made known to the public. This gave rise to tne report tnat the murderous luiuiiy had fled to avoid uunishment and caused the prolonged search after them by the omcers or tne law.

See the clipping