As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

January 1894

3 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

More than twenty years after the Bender family's murders in southern Kansas, officers still receive letters from detectives worldwide claiming to have tracked them down, including a recent false lead in Mexico's Sierra Madre mountains. Ex-Governor Lyman Humphrey, former law partner of Dr. York's brother, recounts the discovery of York's remains and the family's flight, while officials suspect the Benders were secretly killed by York's friends soon after the murders.

CorrectionThis set right 9 earlier articles: Delaware Gazette and State Journal, 23 July 1891, Barton County Democrat, 23 July 1891, The Frontier, 23 July 1891, Eagle River Review, 23 July 1891, Alma Record, 24 July 1891, The McCook Tribune, 24 July 1891, The Caldwell Tribune, 25 July 1891, Idaho Semi-Weekly World, 31 July 1891, Democratic Northwest, 6 August 1891.

Evening Star · 17 January 1894 · page 2

ARE THEY YET ALIVE?

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A Kansas City Star piece recounts renewed but dismissed claims that the Bender family was found in Mexico, and quotes former Governor Humphrey retelling the 1870s discovery of Dr. York's murder at the Benders' homestead. It recaps the family's background and the belief that York's friends killed the Benders after their escape.

Evening Star · 17 January 1894 · page 2

ARE THEY ALIVE?

Speefll CONrspsiaes of The Eremia Star. TOPEKA. Kan., January 13, 1iM. Although over twenty years have elapsed since the Bender family carried on their campaign of murder and slaughter in southern Kansas. from which place they were compelled to flee, officers in Labette and Montgomery counties continue to re ceive letters from detectives from all quar ters of the globe announcing that they are on the trail of this celebrated family of outlaws and will deliver them to the proper officers If the big reward offered for their capture Is forthcoming.

See moreSee less

Recently, detectives in Old Mexico claim ed to have the Benders located in the lierra Madre mountains. This has become a chestnut to the officers and no attention is paid to such reports any more. The reason is no doubt because of the well-grounded belief that the friends of Dr. York. the Benders' last victim, put them out of the way soon after they murdered him. The story of the murders committed by this femily of outlaws would fill a book. For years they murdered Innocent people in cold blood and their victims were num bered by the dosen. Ex-Governor Lyman U. Humphrey. who is in Topeka, is fam War with the record of this family, and to door in the rear room, into an excavation The Star correspondent has related the story of the murder of Dr. York, the dis covery of his remains on their premises, and the subsequent Slight of the family. He said: "I was law partner of A. M. York. Dr. York, a brother of my partner. was the last victim of the Benders. That is the reason why I have been credited with knowing all about the family. I sup great deal of attention, has a theory, and pse I do know all about it that Mr. York ows. The Benders lived on the old Mis sian road, about twelve miles east of Inde pendence, in Labette county. The family ccnsisted of the father and mother, old Germans, who could scarcely speak a word of English, John Bender, their son, and Kate Bender, their daughter, a girl about eighteen years old. Their house was a small box structure about thirty feet long. with the gable end facing the road. It was divided intu two rooms by a curtain. From the time the family located in Labette county It was surrounded by mystery, and the suspicion of neighbors was always di rected toward the house it occupied. At that time, upwards of twenty-one years ago, the country was new and organised bands of horse-thieves and outlaws operat ed extensively in the southern tier of coun

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper looking back from 1894 recaps the 1873 disappearance of Dr. York, the Benders' sudden flight by wagon and train, and the subsequent discovery of multiple bodies buried in their orchard. It also describes the alleged murder method using a curtain, pick, and trap door, and notes that the family's ultimate fate remained unknown.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Rawlins Republican, 23 July 1891, The Morning Call, 27 July 1891.

Evening Star · 17 January 1894 · page 2

ARE THEY ALIVE?

Scott, and as he did not return when ex pected, inquiries were made about him at the latter place. It was learned that he had started for home on time, and a great deal of uneasiness was manifested by his friends. Then a searching party was or ganised to go to Fort Scott, and if possible ascertain his whereabouts. He was traced to the home of the Benders, but beyond that point nothing could be heard of him. The house was entered by the searchers and a hurried examination was made.

See moreSee less

Blood stains were found on the walls, but no other evidence. being seen, the party continued Inquiries. "This visit frightened the Benders, and shortly after the friends of Dr. York left the house they hitched their horses to a wagon and drove away. They went north hurriedly and struck the Missouri. Kansas and Texas railroad at Chanute. They took few of their belonging. with them, the flight being so hurried that a calf which they owned wan found tied near the house two days afterwards nearly famished. At Chanute the team was abandoned in the streets. The family boarded the south bound train and that is the last that was ever heard of thenm positively.

See the clipping