Captain I.C. Reeves claims he witnessed the lynching of the Bender family in early May 1873 after a posse tracked their wagon through Kansas into Indian Territory, where they were shot and buried on a hill by the Grand River. Kansas newspapers are reported to be divided over whether Reeves' account is reliable.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Der Westbote · 2 October 1884 · page 3
Doch nicht todt!
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A man named Reeves had claimed vigilantes tracked the Bender family to the Grand River in Indian Territory and shot them, burying the bodies on a hilltop. Colonel York, supposed leader of the avengers, publicly denounces the story as a lie and offers $2000 to anyone who can prove otherwise, so Kansas's reward for the Benders' capture remains in effect.
The St. Louis Republican interviews Capt. J.G. Reeves, who claims he was part of an avenging posse that tracked down and annihilated the Bender family in Indian Territory. The article recounts how Col. York and Capt. Stone first investigated the Benders after Dr. York's disappearance, setting up the claimed manhunt and killing.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.
Wrong
The Sully County Watchman · 4 October 1884 · page 3
.J. Ileevew, AN Ej eIT IICNN Ol the Tri»t:e«ly. St. Louis Republican. The sudde* disappearance of the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocities and the failure of all etl'orts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole atFair with an air of impenetrable mystery. The veil was not lifted un til some twelve months a^o, when the Republican published the story of o:i« of the a vending party wbieh vertoolc and annihilated the whole family, in Indian Territory, not far from the banks of the Gr'.nd river.
See moreSee less
The author of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. (J. Reeves, of Appletou City, Mo., is at present a guest at the Hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican re porter he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Benders' tragic ending except the name of the man by whose hand thev were slain. When Dr. York was missed," the 41 captain began, as he lit a fresh cigar, "Col. York traced him to the house occupied by the Benders. Being un able to obtain any further informa tion of his lost brother, he returned to Independence, Kan., and communi cated the result of his investigations to Capt. Stone, sberilFof Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Cajt. StO'-'.e visited the Bender resi dence, and were r«.chived by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York
A St. Louis Republic report reprints an 1884 interview with Capt. J. C. Reeves, who claims to have witnessed a posse track down and annihilate the fugitive Bender family in Indian Territory years after their crimes were discovered. The account describes how Col. York and Sheriff Stone first investigated the Benders' home after Dr. York's disappearance, leading eventually to the alleged vigilante killing.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.
Wrong
The Superior Times · 4 October 1884 · page 1
THE BENDER FAMILY. The Killing of the Old IVlitn mihl Wonmu HH(I dohn Jiiui Kiilf KelaU'd hy ('ttpt .1. C, UtevrH, hu l yeWitn*‘rt ot the irugcdy [From the St. Lomu Kepublieat.] The sudden disappearance of the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of theinum erous atrocities and the failure of ail ef forts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impenetrable mystery. The veil was not lifted until some twelve months ago, when the Republic an published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and an nihilated the whole family in Indian Territory not fur from the banks of the Grand River.
See moreSee less
The author of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. C. Reeves, of Apptetou City, Mo., is at present a transient guest at the H del Raruum, and when seen by a Republican reporter he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Benders’tragic ending ex cept the name of the man by whose hand they were slain. “When Dr. York was missed,” tl * captain began, as he lighted a fresh ci gar “Col. York traced his brother I the house occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further in formation of his lost brother, he returned to Independence, Kas,, and communi cated the result of his investigations to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery County. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender resi lience, and they were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bend er. John Bender admitted that Dr York had stayed at their house, and as serted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since. Being unable to ob tain any satisfaction, Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced their steps to In dependence. A posse was formed and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender home stead the birds had tlowu. The house and garden were examined, and in the garden we found nine bodies of mur dered persons, one of which was recog nized as that of Dr. York. Public in dignation at this discovery knew no bounds, and the excitement became in tense. “What was the next step taken for the purpose of avenging this wholesale butchery ?” “A party consisting of S. S. Peterson, deputy United States marshal, Col. York. Bell Wright,George Dawson, and myself was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked the wagon to Thayer. Kas., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railroad cars for Chanute, on the
An unnamed man recounts riding with Col. York's posse that allegedly tracked the Bender family to Indian Territory and executed them on the banks of the Grand River. He describes the shooting, burial, and identification of the four Benders in detail, though no bodies or physical evidence were ever produced.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.
A man identifying himself as Capt. J. C. Reeves, interviewed at a hotel, describes how Colonel York and a sheriff's posse discovered nine bodies in the Bender garden after the family fled, then formed a tracking party that followed the Benders' wagon trail toward the Indian Territory. He claims the pursuit ended in the Benders being killed, though he withholds the name of their killer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Kimball Graphic · 17 October 1884 · page 3
How the Benders Died
Bow the Bendwa Died. ... The sudden disappearance of members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their nu merous atrocities, and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts o! the fugitives, enshrouded the whole af fair with an air of .impenetrable mys tery. The vail was not lifted until some twelve months ago, when the St. Louis Bepublican published the story of one of the avenging party which over took and annihilated the whole family the Indian Territory not far from in tho banks of the Qrand river.
See moreSee less
The an-v thor of that graphio narrative, Capt. J. C. Beeves, of Appletou City, Mo., ia at present a transient guest at the Hotel, Barnum, and when seen by a Bepubli can reporter he cheerfnlly consented to give all the details of the Benders' trag ic ending, except the name of the man by wliow hand thev were slain. "When Dr. York was missed," the Captain began, "Col. York traced his brother to tile house occupied by th« Benders. Being unable to obtain any further informatian of his lost brothel he returned to Independence, Kan., and communicated the result of his in vestigation to Capt. Stone, -Sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence, aud they were re ceived by the mm who married Kate Bender, and who wont by tho name ot John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed at their house, and asserted that he had heard nothing of the Doctor since. Being unable to obtain any satisfaction, Col. York and Capt. Sttne retraced their steps to Independence. A posse was formed, and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead the birds had flown. The house an^ garden were ex amined, and in the garden we found nine bodies of murdered persons, one of which was recognized as that of Dr. York. Publio indignation at thia discovery knew no bounds, and the ex citement liecaine intense. "A party consisting of S. S. Peterson, deputy United States marshal, Col. York, Bell Wright, Qeorge Dawson and myself was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked th« wagon to Thayer, Kas., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railrood cars for Chanute, on the M., K. and T. railroad. At Chanute we procured another wagon and proceeded in the direction of the Grand river, which runs through the Indian territory. It was in Indian ter ritory on the banks of tho Grand river that Col. York, who was in the van of the party, overhauled the Benders. They all died very suddenly and they are buried in the Indian territory near where they fell. 1 have nothing mor« to say. That ends tho story."
An unnamed narrator describes forming a posse with Col. York, a US marshal, and others after discovering nine bodies in the Bender garden, including Dr. York's. The party claims to have tracked the Benders' wagon to Indian Territory on the Grand River, where they "all died very suddenly" and were buried where they fell.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The item recounts that the Bender family vanished after their crimes were discovered, baffling investigators for years. It cites a story from the St. Louis Republican, published about a year earlier, claiming a member of an avenging party described hunting down and annihilating the entire Bender family.
A letter from Texas asked the Kansas Secretary of State's office whether a reward had been offered for the arrest of Kate Bender. The item notes that about eighteen thousand such letters have been received since the massacre.
CAPITOL TOPICS. A letter was received at the office of the Secretary-of State a few days ago, written from Texas, and asking whether a reward had been offered for the ar rest of Kate Bender. There have been