The Warner Weekly Sun · Warner, S.D.
A St. Louis Republican story, republished here, claims one Capt. J. C. Reeves was part of a posse that tracked down and annihilated the entire Bender family in Indian Territory. The account begins with Col. York and Sheriff Stone investigating Dr. York's disappearance at the Bender home before forming a posse.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 27 days later.
The Warner Weekly Sun · 7 November 1884 · page 5
How the Benders Died. The sudden disappearance of tht members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their nu merous atrocities, and the failure of all afforts to discover the whereabouts of ihe fugitives, enshrouded the whole af fair with an air of impenetrable mys tery. The vail was not lifted until 3ome twelve months ago, when the St. Louis Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which over took and annihilated the whole family in the Indian Territory not far from the banks of the Grand river.
See moreSee less
The au thor of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo., is at present a transient guest at the Hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republi can reporter he cheerfnllv consented to give all the details of the Benders’ trag ic ending, except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain. “When Dr. York was missed,” the Captain began, “Col. York traced his brother to the house occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further informatian of his lost brothel he returned to Independence, Kan., and communicated the result of his in vestigation to Capt. Stone, Sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence, and they were re ceived by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed at their house, and asserted that he had heard nothing of the Doctor since. Being unable to obtain any satisfaction, Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced their steps to Independence. A posse was formed, and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead the birds had flown. . The house and garden were ex amined, and in the garden we found nine bodies of murdered persons, one of which was recognized as that of Dr. York. Public indignation at this discovery knew no bounds, and the ex citement became iutense. “A party consisting of 8. 8. Peterson, deputy United States marshal, 001. York, Bell Wright, George Dawson and myself was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked the wagon to Thayer, Kas., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railrood cars for Chanute, on the M., K. and T. railroad. At Chanute we procured another wagon and proceeded in the direction of the Grand nver, which runs through th( Indian territory. It was in Indian ter ritory on the banks of the Grand river that Col. York, who was in the van ol the party, overhauled the Benders. They all died very suddenly and they ire buried in the Indian territory near yhere they fell. I have nothing more so say. That ends the story.’*