As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

September 1884

11 articles

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

After an unrelated item about a bear attack, the report recounts the eleven-year-old Bender murder mystery from Kansas, noting that every reported sighting or capture had proven false. It then relays Capt. J. C. Reeves's detailed claim of leading a posse that tracked the Bender wagon through Indian Territory to the Grand River, where they allegedly caught up with the fugitives.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 4 September 1884 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

A St. Louis Republican reprint quotes Capt. J. C. Reeves, who claims to have witnessed a posse track down and annihilate the Bender family in Indian Territory. He recounts how Col. York and Sheriff Stone first traced Dr. York's disappearance to the Bender homestead before the alleged pursuit and killing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 9 September 1884 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE BENDER FAMILY.

The Killing of the Desperadoes, Related by Capt. J. C. Reeves, An Eye-Witness of the Tragedy.

See moreSee less

The Names of the Party Given, and the Story of the Slaying Told in Its Details.

St. Louis Republican.

The sudden disappearace of the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocties, and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugtives, enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impentrable mystery. The veil was not lifted until some twelve months ago, when the Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family in the Indian territory not far from the banks of the Grand river. The author of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo., is at present a transient guest at the hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican reporter last night he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Bender's tragic ending, except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain.

"When Dr. York was missed," the captain began, as he lighted a fresh cigar, "Col. York traced his brother to the house occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further information of his lost brother he returned to Independence, Kas., and communicated the result of his investigation to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence and they were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed ai their house and asserted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since. Being unable to obtain any satisfaction Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced their steps to Independence. A posse was formed and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead the birds had flown. The house and garden were examined, and in the garden were found nine bodies of which one was recognized as that of Dr. York. Public indignation att his discovery knew no bounds, and the excitement became intense."

"What was the next step taken for the purpose of avenging this wholesale butchery?"

"A party consisting of S. S. Peterson, deputy United States marshal, Col. York, Bill Wright, George Dawson and myself was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked the wagon to Thayer, Kas., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railroad cars for Chanute, on the M. K. & T. railroad. At Chanute we procured another wagon and proceeded in the direction of the Grand river, which runs through the Indian territory. It was in the Indian territory on the banks of the Grand river that Col. York, who was in the van of the party, overhauled the Benders. They all died very suddenly and they are buried in the Indian territory near where they fell. I have nothing more to say. That ends the story.

"Were they shot?"

"Yes; they were shot with a sixteen-shot repeating Henry rifle."

"Who did the shooting?"

"That I am not at liberty to state."

"Did Col. York offer any reward for the discovery of the Benders?"

"No, he did not, although he was worth $100,000 at the time. The government offered $10,000 reward but nobody claimed it."

"Do the Benders lie close to the river?"

"Yes."

"Are you certain that they are all killed?"

"I saw them killed, all four of them—old man Bender and his wife, John Bender and Kate Bender."

"Were they shot by one man?"

"Yes, by one man only. He killed them. Bang, bang, bang, bang. Every shot counted."

"Where were you when the shooting was done?"

"I was sitting on my horse a few yards from the man who did the shooting. I entered into an agreement not to tell anything about it."

"Were there any United States troops present?"

"No."

"Did you see the bodies buried?"

"I did."

"Could you find the place again?"

"I could very easily."

"How were they buried?"

"We just dug a hole tumbled them in and covered them up."

"Did you find anything on the bodies?"

"We did not search them."

"How were they shot, from behind?"

"They were shot from behind and to their faces. We were very much exasperated at finding the nine bodies in the garden, and immediately we overtook them the firing commenced. They were not looking when we overtook them, but as soon as the firing began they turned round. The man was ahead that did the shooting. We had our carbines leveled ready to shoot, but there was no resistance offered."

"What description of vehicle were the Benders in?"

"They were in a two horse wagon. I think the two men were seated in front and the two women behind."

"Are you sure you got the right people?"

"We knew we had the right people. We all recognized them and identified them after they were dead. I knew every one of them. At one time I had seen them every day for six months."

"Where did you live?"

"I lived at Independence where I was running a marble shop."

"What did you do with the team?"

"We turned them loose."

"With their harness on?"

"Yes."

"Did you ever hear of them again?"

"No."

"What became of the wagon?"

"I think we burned it."

"How far were the Benders from their home when they were murdered?"

"About forty-five miles."

"What time were they killed?"

"About 4 o'clock in the afternoon. They were on the prairie on the outskirts of the town."

"How long did the killing last?"

"Only a few moments."

"Who was killed first?"

"It was all done so quickly I do not know who was killed first."

"Did any of them jump out of the wagon?"

"No."

"How far were you from the wagon at the time?"

"Thirty-five or forty steps."

"What did you do after the bodies were buried?"

"I started on to deliver the news, but after I had gone fifteen miles I was overtaken and told not to say a word about the killing. 'All right,' I replied, 'Mum's the word.' We solemnly agreed not to give the thing away, and the first time it was told to the public, except as a suspicion, was about a year ago, when I gave some of the facts to Senator Wear for publication in the Republican, but you have fuller details now than have ever been published.

See the clipping

Weekly Graphic · Kirksville, Mo. · and 7 other papers

A Captain Reeves tells a reporter that after Dr. York's murder was discovered, a posse chased the Bender family into Indian Territory and killed all four of them by rifle fire near Grand River. He refuses to name the shooter but insists he personally witnessed the killings.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Weekly Graphic · 19 September 1884 · page 1

TUEBEHDER PAM1LT How Tney Were Killed The St Louis Republican has the following in relation to the killing of the notorious Bender family The sudden disappearance of the members of trie murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atroci ties and the failure oiall efforts to dis cover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impenetrable mystery The veil was not lifted until some twelve months ago when the Republican published the story ot one of the avenging party who overtook and an nihilated the whole family in the Indi an Territory not far from the banks of Grand river The author ol that gra phic narrative Capt J C Reeves of Appleton Mo is at present a guest at the Hot si Barnum and when seen by a Republican reporter last night he cheefully consented to give all the de tails of the Benders tragic ending ex cepting the name of the man by whose hands they were slain When Dr York was missed the Captain began as he lighted a fresh cigar Col York traced his brother to the house occupied by the Benders Being unable to obtain any informa tion of his lost brother he returned to Independence Kas and communicat ed the result of his investigation to Capt Stone sheriff of Montgomery county The next morning Col York and Capt Stone visited the Bender residence and they were received by man who married Kate Bender by the name of John Bender John Bender admitted that Dr York had stayed at their house and asserted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since Being unable to obtain any satisfaction Col York and Capt Stons retraced their steps to Independence A posse was formed and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom When they arrived at the Bender homestead the

See the clipping

Also printed in 7 papers
  • The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo. · 9 September 1884
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 21 September 1884
  • Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · 25 September 1884
  • Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis. · 25 September 1884
  • Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 25 September 1884
  • The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D. · 4 October 1884
  • The Superior Times · Superior, Wis. · 4 October 1884

Weekly Graphic · Kirksville, Mo. · and 5 other papers

A man claims he witnessed a posse of avengers shoot and kill all four Benders on the prairie forty-five miles from their homestead, then bury the bodies and release the team. He says the group swore secrecy, and this is allegedly the first full account given to the public after a year of hints to a senator.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Weekly Graphic · 19 September 1884 · page 1

What description of vehicle were the Benders in They were in a two hone wagon I think the two men were seated in the front the two women behind Are you sure you got the right peo ple r We know we had the rieht Deoole IWc all recognized them and identified

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo. · 9 September 1884
  • Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · 25 September 1884
  • Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis. · 25 September 1884
  • Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 25 September 1884
  • The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D. · 4 October 1884

Weekly Graphic · Kirksville, Mo.

The St. Louis Republican reprints a story from a guest named Capt. J.C. Reeves, who claims to have witnessed a posse track down and annihilate the Bender family in Indian Territory. The account describes how Col. York and Sheriff Stone first confronted John Bender after Dr. York's disappearance, setting up the pursuit that allegedly ended in the family's destruction.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Weekly Graphic · 19 September 1884 · page 1

THE BENDER FAMILY - How They Were Killed

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A traveler, Capt. J. C. Reeves, tells a reporter the long-unknown fate of the Bender family: that a vigilante posse tracked them to Indian Territory and killed them all. He recounts how Col. York and Sheriff Stone first investigated the Bender homestead after Dr. York's disappearance, setting up the posse's formation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 September 1884 · page 14

THE BENDER FAMILY. The Killing of the Old Man and Woman and John and Kate Related by Capt. J. C. lice vet, anlHue- . . it tics.* of the Tragedy. The sudden disaprearance of the mem bers of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocities and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole affair with an uir of impenetrable mys tery. The veil was not lifted until some twelve months ago, wheu the Republican pub lished the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family in Indian territory not far from the banks of the Grand river.

See moreSee less

The author of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. C. Reeves, of Ap pleton City, Mo,, is at present a transient guest at the Hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican reporter he cheerfully con sented to give all the details of the Bender's tragic ending except tlie name of the man by whose hand they were slain. "When Dr. York was missed," the captain began as he lighted a fresh cigar, "Col. York traced his brother to the house occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further Information of his lost brother, he returned to Independence, Kan., and eomninnieated, the result of,the Investigations to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence, and they were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John I Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed at their house, and asserted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since. Being unable to obtain any satisfaction, Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced thf-irr stt-ps to Indepen dence. A posse mi formed and the compa ny started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead the birds had flown. The house and garden were examined, and in the garden were found nine bodies of mur dered persons, one of which was recognized as that of Dr. York. Public indignation at this discovery knew no bounds, and the i excitement became intense." ''What was the step taken for the purpose • of avenging this wholesale butchery" "A party consisting of S. S. Peterson, dcI puty United States marshal, Col. York, Bell Wright, George Dawson, and myself was formed to follow the trail of the. Benders. We tracked the wagon toThaycr,Kan., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railroad cars for Chaiiute, on the Missouri, Kansas and Texas railroad. At Chanute we procured another wasou and proceeded in the direction of the Grand river, which runs through Indian Territory, on the banks of the Grand river, that Col. York, who was in the van of the party, overhauled the Benders. They all died very suddenly, and they are buried in Indian Territory, near where they fell. I have nothing more to say. That ends the story." "Were they shot?" "Yes; they were shot with a sixtecn-shot repeating Henry rifle." "Who did the shooting?" "That I am not at liberty to state." "Did. Col. York offer any reward for the discovery of the Benders "No, he did not, although he was worth $100,000 at the time. The government of fered $10,000 reward, but nobody claimed it." "Do the Benders lie close to the river?" "Yes." "Are you certain that they were all killed !" "I saw them killed, all four of them — old man Bender and his wife, John Bender, and Kate Bender."

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A man interviewed by the St. Louis Republican describes in detail how a vigilante posse tracked down and shot the four Benders on the prairie forty-five miles from their home, then buried the bodies and swore secrecy. He claims this is the first full public account, beyond mere suspicion, of their fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 September 1884 · page 14

"I think we burned it." "How far were the Benders from their home when they were murdered?" "About forty-five miles." "What time "were they killed?" "About 3 o'clock in the afternoon. They ' were on the prairie on the outskirts of the

See the clipping

East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I.

A St. Louis Republican story, republished here a year after first appearing, quotes Captain J. C. Reeves describing how a posse pursued the Bender family into Indian Territory and killed them all, though he withholds the shooter's name. The account traces the investigation from Dr. York's disappearance through Colonel York and Sheriff Stone's visit to the Bender homestead before the alleged pursuit and killing.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

Wrong

East Providence Eagle · 24 September 1884 · page 3

THE ATROCIOUS BENDERS.

Without Mercy. The sudden disappearance of the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their nu merous atrocities, and th: failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole af {air with an air of impenetrable mys tery. The veil was not lifted wuntil some twelve months ago, when the St. Louis Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family in the Indian Territory vot far from the banks of the Grand River. The author of that graphic narrative, Captain J.

See moreSee less

C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo., was in St. Lonis recently, and when seen by a Republi can reporter last might he cheerfully consented to give all the details ol the Benders’ tragic ending, except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain, “When Dr, York was missed,” the captain began, “Col. York traced his brother to the hous2 occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further information of his lost broth er, he returned to Independence, Kan sas, and communicated the result of his investigation to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence, and they were re ceived by tha man who marriad Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed at their house, and asserted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since. DBeing anable to obtain any satisfaetion, Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced their steps to Independence, A posse was formed, and the company started forth letermined toinvestigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead - the birds had lown. The house an‘ garden were examined, and in the garden we found nine bodies of murdered persons, one of which was recognized as that of Dr. York., Public indignation at this liscovery knew no bounds, and the excitement became intense. A party, ronsisting of 8. 8. Peterson, Deputy United States Marshal, Col. York, Bell Wricht, George Dawson and myself, was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked the wagon to

See the clipping

East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I.

A man recounts how Col. York and a posse discovered nine bodies in the Bender garden, then pursued the fleeing family to the Indian Territory. He claims the posse caught and fatally shot all four Benders near the Grand River, with no survivors.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

East Providence Eagle · 24 September 1884 · page 3

THE ATROCIOUS BENDERS.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper

A man identified as Capt. J. C. Reeves tells the St. Louis Republican that he witnessed an avenging posse track down and kill the entire Bender family in Indian Territory. He recounts how Col. York and Sheriff Stone first investigated the Benders' home after Dr. York's disappearance, setting up the backstory to the alleged killing.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

Wood County Reporter · 25 September 1884 · page 2

St. Louis Republican. The sudden disappearance of-the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocities and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impenetrable mystery. The veil was not lifted un til some twelve months ago, when the Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family, in Indian Territory, not far from the banks of the Grand river. The author of that graphic narrative, Capt.

See moreSee less

J. C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo., is at present a guest at the Hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican re porter he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Benders’ tragic ending except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain. “ When Dr. York was missed,” the captain began, as he lit a fresh cigar, “Col. York traced him to the house occupied by the Benders. Being un-' able to obtain any further informa tion of his lost brother, he returned to Independence, Kan., and communi cated the result of his investigations to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender resi dence, and were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · 25 September 1884

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

Capt. J. C. Reeves recounts to a reporter how Col. York and a posse pursued the Bender family after Dr. York's disappearance was traced to their house. He claims the family was eventually overtaken and annihilated in Indian Territory near the Grand River, though he withholds the name of their killer.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

Mineral Point Tribune · 25 September 1884 · page 2

of the Tragedy. St. Louis Republican. The sudden disappearance of -the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocities and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugitives enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impenetrable mystery. The veil was not lifted ua til some twelve months ago, when the Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family, in Indian Territory, not far from the banks of the Grand river. The author of that graphic narrative, Cant.

See moreSee less

J. C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo,, is at present a guest at the Hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican re porter he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Benders’ tragic ending except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain. “When Dr. York was missed,” the captain began, as he lit a fresh cigar, “Col. York traced him to the house occupied by the Benders. Being un* able to obtain any further informa tion of his lost brother, he returned to Independence, Kan., and communi cated the result of his investigations to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stoae visited the Bender resi dence, and were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York

See the clipping