Paper unidentified
This story presents a secondhand narrative, reportedly from a Western paper, describing how a tramp's late-night sighting of digging led a posse to pursue the fleeing Bender family and catch them after a 45-mile chase. It culminates in violent deaths, including a dramatic self-inflicted gunshot by a disguised woman posing as a man named Joseph, with the vigilantes burying the bodies and expressing guilt.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 651 days later.
Paper unidentified · 2 August 1877 · page 4
The Fate of The Benders. A Narrative by One of the Men who Lynched Them.
I ed for the home of the Benders, but j when they arrived there It was de serted. The party found the wagon tracks of the fleeing inmates, and Im mediately started in pursuit. The track of the Bender wagon could be seen leading to the south west, The horsemen followed at full speed. Just before sunset the pursuers came in sight of the fugi tives. They had evidently urged their teams on with all speed possi ble, ns they were a good forty-five miles from their tavern, and their animals appeared well used up.
See moreSee less
As the pursuers came in sight of their game they gave a yell, and charged down upon them. The moment the Benders caught sight of their pur. suers, the greatest consternation ap peared to seize upon them. John Bender, who was walking by the side of the wagon, run forward to the head team, as though to unhitch tliem, but was evidently recalled by the old man who handed him out an old-fashioned smooth-bore Yaeger rifle. With this weapon he fired a harmless shot at the advancing horse men, and then drew a navy revolver and reached his hand into the wa gon for another. Before he had time to draw it forth, however, a shot from one of the farmers laid hira out lifeless on the prairie, the ball entering his left breast and piercing the heart. Old man Bender stood up in tlie