As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

July 1877

3 articles

Bozeman Avant Courier · Bozeman, Mont.

The report describes how a man named Jones was found murdered near Drum Creek, his skull smashed and throat cut, leading local farmers to suspect the Benders. A tramp who had slept near the Benders' property later recounted overhearing them speaking German while digging in the dark, fueling further suspicion.

Bozeman Avant Courier · 5 July 1877 · page 1

The Fate of the Renders. The Benders might have continued their bloody work in peace and prosperity for au indefinite length or time had they continued p'&nting their victims in the garden. But previous to the killing of Dr. York, they had murdered a man by the name of Jones. In February, a man named Conklin, in company' with another, while riiiing a^ng Drum Creek, saw the dead body of a man caught in some drift wood. It proved to be the body of Jones. He had hud his skull smashed m with a hammer, and his throat cut from ear to| car.

See moreSee less

The body had no clothing upon it, save a shirt. Some ten or a dozen farm ers met quietly on the banks of Drum Creek, and, after viewing ihe body of Jones, held a council. At this meeting the Benders were spoken of suspiciously, «"d it was determined to beep the discov ery of the body quiet Until furtnei uevci opments. The next day a man who was evidently a tramp, and had footed it from Independence on his way to Fort Scott, stopped at Dutroit's house and a-i'-ed for something to eat. In conversation with 'his man, Dutroit learned that late the previous evening the tramp had, while looking around for a place to pass the night, come across a small haystath back of the Benders' house, into which he

See the clipping

Bozeman Avant Courier · Bozeman, Mont.

A tramp who hid in a haystack near the Benders' house reported seeing three figures digging at night and speaking German. His account led a search party to investigate the deserted Bender property, where they dug and uncovered the body of Dr. York.

Bozeman Avant Courier · 5 July 1877 · page 1

Mr. Dutroit said nothing at the time, but when the party of twelve met by ap pointment on Drum Creek, he relat'd the circumstance to them, and it was deter mined to give the Bender mansion a quiet investigation. A wagon track was dis covered leading to the Bender place from where Jones' body had been thrown into the creek. The party struck out on the wagon trail, and at about sunset it brougL them within view of the tavern. It was then determined to forego proceedings un til the morrow, when in the morning tin entire party would meet on Drum Creek.

See moreSee less

well armed, and ride over to the Bender , . , o ...J On the morrow, at about 8 o'c. k, the party assembled on the ertek and itmne diately proceeded over the prairies to the suspected house. But when they arrived they found the Bender ranche deserted. The Benders had noticed the squad of horsemen riding upon the wagon trail tbc previous evening, and during the night had bundle ! up their effects and departed. The Benders at this time had four horses,

See the clipping

Bozeman Avant Courier · Bozeman, Mont.

A search party discovers Dr. York's buried corpse at the abandoned Bender ranch and tracks the fleeing family's wagon. After a prairie chase, pursuers shoot and kill John Bender as he reaches for a weapon, while Kate escapes on foot.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 679 days later.

Wrong

Bozeman Avant Courier · 5 July 1877 · page 1

Mr. Dutroit said nothing at the time, but when the party of twelve met by ap pointment on Drum Creek, he relat'd the circumstance to them, and it was deter mined to give the Bender mansion a quiet investigation. A wagon track was dis covered leading to the Bender place from where Jones' body had been thrown into the creek. The party struck out on the wagon trail, and at about sunset it brougL them within view of the tavern. It was then determined to forego proceedings un til the morrow, when in the morning tin entire party would meet on Drum Creek.

See moreSee less

well armed, and ride over to the Bender , . , o ...J On the morrow, at about 8 o'c. k, the party assembled on the ertek and itmne diately proceeded over the prairies to the suspected house. But when they arrived they found the Bender ranche deserted. The Benders had noticed the squad of horsemen riding upon the wagon trail tbc previous evening, and during the night had bundle ! up their effects and departed. The Benders at this time had four horses, a cow, and a wagon load of household a truck. While the scouting party were canvass ing the new state of affairs, Mr. Dutroit and others went in search of the spot in dicated by the tramp.—They searched around for some time in vain, as the ground had been recently plowed oyer, but at length struck a spot that appeared moister than the rest, as though the earth beneath it bad recently been turned over, No shovel being found, three of the party set to work with shingles torn from the house, and after digging a bole four feet deep, one of them, with a shout, reached down his hand, and pulled np the skirt of a min's under-garuisnt, and beneath it could be seen an exposed portion of a hu man body. This was the corpse of Dr. York, though at the time the explorers did not know it. The track of the Bender wagon could be seen leading ts the southwestThe horsemen followed at full speed. Just at sunset the pursuers came in sight of the fugitives. They had evidently urged their teams on with all speed possible.

See the clipping