The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.
The Chicago Times reports that pursuers caught up with the fleeing Bender family and killed John and the elder Bender in a gunfight, with Kate also apparently captured after a horse fell on her. The account describes a violent confrontation on the prairie immediately following discovery of their murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 712 days later.
The Arizona Sentinel · 2 June 1877 · page 4
Slaughter of the Benders
German and flourished a revolver over his head. As they were go ing down a roll in the prairie one of their lead horses fell, and Kate, springing out of the wagon, went to the fallen animal. as if to get it up. But instead of rising the fallen beast she cut loose its mate, mounting it, was eng deavouring to make her ecape on its back. At this the old man seemed crazed with anger, and fired his revolver at her. He did not hit her, however, but the horse springing forward caught a leg in the breeching of its fallen mate, and went down with Kate under him.
See moreSee less
The old man having emptied his revolver, the pur surers closed in on him and beat him down with their gun barrels, though he and his wife fought like tigers to the last. After they had tied Bender and his wife they got the girl out from under the horse, and found that she had a leg broken in Ihe fall. Dutroit .said Kate acted like a very devil. She cursed them, cursed her fa ther and mother, and seemed a red-hot vial of wrath. Kate Bender seemed to think