As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

September 1877

2 articles

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A Western paper recounts a tramp who saw figures digging at night near the Benders' house, prompting a posse of twelve to pursue the fleeing family some forty-five miles southwest. The account describes the Benders being overtaken, with John Bender firing a rifle before the posse closed in, implying their capture and lynching.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 596 days later.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 26 September 1877 · page 1

hem nor make out what they were bun-- j ng. The next day he told this circumo r><iirrV>V?r?rincr fnrmpr Trim lmI nediately organized a party of twelve J aid started for the home of the Benders, |

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A posse pursues the Bender wagon forty-five miles, and in the clash John Bender is shot dead and old man Bender is beaten down after a gunfight; Kate Bender breaks her leg trying to flee on horseback and reportedly admits to the murders while cursing her captors. The group then makes camp for the night with the family in custody.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 596 days later.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 26 September 1877 · page 1

lrged their teams on with all speed possible, as they were a good forty-five miles rom their tavern, and their animals appeared well used up. As the pursuit same in sight of their game they gave a rell, and charged down upon them. The noment the Benders caught eight of heir pursuers,the greatest consternation j ippeared to 6eize upon them. John j Sender, who was walking by the side of J he wagon, run forward to the haad ; earn, as though to unhitch them, but "j ras evidently recalled by the old man, j rho handed him out nn old-fashioned i imooth-bore Yaeger rifle.

See moreSee less

With this J weapon he fired a harmless shot at the j idvancing horsemen, and then drew n 1? 1 ,\,f? I?VJ rCTUiVCl aiiU. ICUVUCU inr? iiuum xu*.\/ j he wagon for another. Before he had j ime to draw it forth, however, a shot rom one of the farmers laid him out1 ifeless on the prairie, the ball entering ! lis left breast and piercing the heart. ; Old man Bender stood up in the! ragon, and, striking down the cover,

See the clipping