As the Papers Told It

Black Sox · The full archive

August 1921

41 articles

Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.

In Chicago, Attorney Prendiville delivered the first half of the state's closing argument in the Black Sox trial, calling the indicted players 'murderers' of sport who would ruin baseball if acquitted. The defense was set to begin its ten hours of allotted argument the following Monday.

Palatka Daily News · 1 August 1921 · page 1

For Crook 1 Players 1 (By Awiodiite Ptml Chicago, July 30. Branding the indicted White Sox players as "mur derers, 'f sport who, if allowed to go free, would ruin baseball, just as racing and boxing were ruined," Attorney Prendiville today conclud ed the first half of the state's clos ing argument' in the baseball trial. Monday the defense will begin the ten hours of argument allotted it will hold court long enough for the nine attorneys to 'finish - their pleas. The state will make its final rebuttal

See the clipping

Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.

The state's attorney urged the jury to convict Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, Gandil and the gamblers, accusing them of conspiring to murder baseball. He asked for the maximum punishment on each count, with the judge expected to let court run long enough for all nine defense attorneys to finish their pleas.

Palatka Daily News · 1 August 1921 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Attorney Edward Prindiville, in the state's closing argument, called the indicted White Sox players 'murderers of sport' who defrauded the public and children who idolized them. He demanded the maximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and five years in prison for Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, Gandil, and the gamblers involved.

Omaha Daily Bee · 1 August 1921 · page 8

"A murderer deserves the utmost in punishment. Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Happy Felsch, Buck Weaver, Claude Williams, Chick Gandil. and the gamblers conspired to murder base ball and I demand

See the clipping

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

The item notes that a hearing is being held regarding the case against the indicted 'Black Sox' players. It appears as a small headline amid baseball scores and other news, with no further detail provided.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 2 August 1921 · page 5

Hearing Case Against the Indicted "Black Sox."

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

Bill Burns, the self-confessed 'fixer' of the World Series scandal, endured twelve hours of grueling cross-examination on the witness stand, describing his role as go-between for the indicted White Sox players and gamblers. The same day, final arguments in the baseball scandal case concluded before Judge Friend, who recessed to prepare jury instructions.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 2 August 1921 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

A brief filler comment notes that the Chicago court trying the indicted White Sox players is conducting a drawn-out legal process, compared humorously to a ball game with a 'chain to it.' It reflects public cynicism about the ongoing trial's pace and outcome.

The Lake County Times · 2 August 1921 · page 4

THE CHICAGO ccurt trying the indicted White Sox is playing a ball game that has a chain to it. SOMEBODY SUGGESTS that it Is about time for this country to start a movement to get back to "honesty."

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A Chicago jury found the seven former White Sox players and two co-defendants not guilty of conspiracy to defraud the public by fixing the 1919 World Series, reaching the verdict on a single ballot after less than three hours deliberation. The acquittal sparked wild celebration in the courtroom, with jurors lifting defendants onto their shoulders and Judge Friend calling it a just verdict.

Arizona Republican · 3 August 1921 · page 1

SAY RUM RUNS SOLUTION

clean sox." Judge Friend Jury, saying he verdict. Eddie Cicotte was the first of the defendantsto reach the Jurors. He grabbed Wlllia.u Barrett by both A Just Verdict congratulated the thought it a Just game.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The courtroom erupted in cheering and celebration as the jury left to deliberate after closing arguments concluded at 7:52 p.m. The report recaps the full list of indicted players and gamblers, notes only seven players and four gamblers were actually apprehended, and details how charges against some defendants were dismissed during trial.

Arizona Republican · 3 August 1921 · page 1

prove that it was the Intent of the Chicago White Sox players and oth ers charged with conspiracy to de fraud through the throwing of the 1919 world series, to defraud the pub lic and others and not merely to throw baseball games. The case went to the Jury at 7:52 p. m. The Indicted Those Indicted by the grand Jury are: Eddie Cicotte, former star pitch er for the White Sox; Claude Wil liams, former White Sox pitcher: Arnold "Shick" Gandil. former first baseman; Charles ("Swede") Ris berg, former shortstop; George ("Buck") Weaver, former third base man: Joe Jackson, former outfielder; Oscar ("Happy") Felsch, former out fi elder; Abe Attell, former pugilist and alleged gambler; Hal Chase, for mer baseball player; William ("Bill") Burns, former player and alleged go between: Rachael Brown, alleged New York gambler; John J.

See moreSee less

("Sport") Sullivan, alleged Boston gambler; David Zelcer, Des Moines. Iowa, ad vertising man and alleged gambler: Louis Levi and Ben Levi, brothers, of Kokomo, Ind.: Carl Zork, of St. Louis.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The jury's verdict lists counts of conspiracy to defraud the American League and Ray Schalk via a confidence game, while the report recaps trial details including defendants who evaded prosecution, Burns's state's evidence testimony, and defense claims that Ban Johnson instigated the case out of a feud with Comiskey. It also notes Rothstein's alleged financing role and the eventual revelation about the players' original confessions.

Arizona Republican · 3 August 1921 · page 1

A Just Verdict Statutory conspiracy to obtain from the public generally diver sums of money by means of the confidence game. Common law conspiracy to cheat and defraud the American league baseball clttb of large sums of money by causing and inducing the playert improperly and erroneously and not in accordance with their skill and ability to execute plays required of them. ' ' Common law conspiracy to cheat and defraud Ray W. Schalk out of J1784 by causing the ball players not to execnte play required of them with their best jjkill and ability.

See moreSee less

. . Attell Escapes Law Prior to the trial Abe Attell "beat extradition proceedings In New York to bring him to Chicago. Hal Chase was arrested in California but wai never brought here. Ben Franklin, another of Jthe defendants from St, Louis, became 111 and could, not be brought to Chicago for trial, while Fred McMulIen, utility infielder for. the White Sox, was not apprehended on the second Indictment, although he gave bond on the first. Rachel Brown and "Sport" Sullivan were never apprehended. During the trial the name of Ar nold Rothstein. an alleged New York gambler, was frequently brought out. It was charged he financed the con spiracy which was said to have orig inated in New York and was then consummated in Cincinnati and Chi caeo. "Bill" Burns, a defendant, turned state's evidence and took the witnes stand to tell of the plana made to throw the games. He was corrobo rated by William Maharg of Philadel phia, who said he accompanied Burnt on all of his alleged dealings between the ball players and the gamblers. Burns asserted Cicotte and Gandil were originators of the scheme to throw the series for $100,000. Ac cording to Burns. Abe Attell. who was supposed to be the lieutenant ot Rothstein, double crossed the player! and gae them only $10,000 of the promised $100,000. During the trial the defendants attorney contended Ban Johnson, president of the American league, had instigated the prosecution because of a feud between himself and Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White, Sox. During the trial it became known that the original confessions said to have been made by Cicotte, Williams and Jackson, along with the immunity waivers they had signed, had been stolen from the state's at torney's office. It was charged-eastern gamblers had made up a pot Ot $10,000 to obtain these documents. . o

See the clipping

Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo, Colo.

The prosecution gave a brief closing argument, confident its case against the Chicago White Sox players and gamblers was conclusive, and the judge instructed the jury that intent to defraud the public must be proven. The case went to the jury at 7:52 PM, with the report recapping the list of indicted individuals and noting dismissals of charges against the Levi brothers and motions to dismiss others.

Pueblo Chieftain · 3 August 1921 · page 10

BASEBALL CASE GOES TO JURY

(Continued from Page One) this afternoon when George Gorman, assistant state's attorney, informed the jury briefly that, in his opinion, the state had presented such a con clusive case that a lengthy address was unnecessary. Judge Friend in his Instructions told the jury that the state must prove tha’ it was the_ intent of the Chicago. White Sox players and others charged with conspiracy to defraud thru the throwing of the. 1919 world , series to defraud the public and ] others and not merely to throw base- ' ball games.

See moreSee less

The case went to the Jury at 7:52 o'clock this evening. Those indicted by the grand Jury are: Eddie Cicotte. former star pitcher for the White Sox. Claude Williams, former White Sox j pitcher. Arnold «"Chick"") Gandil. former first baseman. Charles (‘Swede”) Risberg. former short stop. George • "Buck”) Weaver, former , third baseman. Joe Jackson, former outfielder. Oscar ("Happy*') Felsch. former; outfielder. Abe Attell. former pugilist and al leged gambler. Hal Chase, former baseball player. William ('"Bill*') Burns, former player and alleged go between, i Rachael Brown, alleged New York gambler. John J. i’ Sport") Sullivan, alleged Boston gambler. David Zelcer, Des Moines. lowaad vertising man and alleged gambler. Louis Levi and Ben Levi, brothers of Des Moines.

See the clipping

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

A Chicago jury found the seven former White Sox players and two others not guilty of conspiracy to defraud the public by throwing the 1919 World Series, reaching the verdict on one ballot after under three hours of deliberation. The courtroom erupted in cheers, with players embracing jurors and being lifted onto their shoulders amid celebration.

Norwich Bulletin · 3 August 1921 · page 1

Found Not Guilty Chicago, Aug. 2 (by the A. P.) The seven former Chicago White Sox baseball players and two others on trial for alleged conspiracy to de fraud the public through throwing of the 1919 world series games tonight were found not guilty by a jury. The jury took only one ballot . The verdict wis reached after two hours and forty-seven minutes of de liberation, but was not returned un til forty minutes later. Judge Hugo M. Friend being out of court, when the decision was reached. The defendants were: Buck Weaver, third baseman ; Os car Felsch, outfielder ; Charles Ris berg, short stop ; Arnold Gandil, first baseman ; Claude Williams, and Ed die Cicotte, pitchers ; Joe Jackson, outfielder all former White Sox players and Carl Zork.

See moreSee less

of St. Louis, and David Zelcer, of Des Moines.

See the clipping

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

The jury delivers nine not-guilty verdicts for the accused White Sox players, prompting celebration as jurors lift Cicotte, Jackson, and others onto their shoulders. Players react with joy and relief, with Gandil mocking Ban Johnson and Weaver thanking the public for standing by him.

Norwich Bulletin · 3 August 1921 · page 1

arms and shouting. Felsch and Williams merely smiled while Joe Jackson took the decision very quietly. Gondii shook hands with a few friends and quietly slip ped from the court room. 'Til give a sailor's farewell to Ban Johnson." said Gandil. "Goodbye, good luck and to .with you." 'I knew I'd be cleared," said Weav er, and I'm glad tne public stood toy me until the trial was over." Williams termed the verdict a "true one," saying he was proud to have "come through clean. Cicotte and Risberg rushed to tel egraph offices to notify their wives.

See moreSee less

Tiovid Zelcer will return to his home in Des Moines immediately and carl 7.nrk nlans to leave for St Louis tomorrow. Henrv Berger. defense counsel. termed the verdict a "complete vlndication of the most mistreated ball players in history.' The state's attorneys were silent

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

A Chicago jury found the players connected to the alleged 1919 World Series fix not guilty, setting them free from the scandal charges. The verdict ends the criminal trial phase of the Black Sox case.

New Britain Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8

ACCUSED PLAYERS inner White Sox Are Freed Froin Scandal Charges Chicago, Aug. 3. The seven former members of the Chicago White Sox were jubilant today over their ac

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

The seven former Chicago White Sox players were acquitted by a Chicago jury of charges related to throwing the 1919 World Series. Players including Jackson, Weaver, Risberg, Williams, Cicotte, and Felsch gave statements reacting to the not-guilty verdict, with mixed feelings about returning to organized baseball.

New Britain Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8

V "I am - entirely innocent and thj jury has proven that" said Charles Risberg, former shortstop: "I leave my future in organized baseball in the hands of the officials. - "How could the verdict have been anything else?" asked Claud Williams, pitcher. "I'm going to stick -to semi professional baseball." '-',-. dcottc to be Quiet "All I want to do is to get to De troit" said Eddie Cicotte once the leading pitcher of the American league, while he sho6k hands with the jurors. "Talk, did you say?" - Never again, I talked in this building; never again."

See moreSee less

"The jury hassaid all that -I can say;' said Oscar "Happy" ; Felsch, former outfielder. "I am not guilty and never had anything to do with any so called conspiracy." ' May Play for fltoldicrs " I never had any doubt about the verdict" said "Chick", Gan,dil, former first baseman who did not Teturn to the White Sox in the 1920 season. If it had not been for two liars. Bill Burns and Billy Maharg, I would not have been here. . We are going to form a semi-profesional teemi in Chicago and play a few games for ,the benefit of the wounded soldiers." David Zelcor of Des Moines alleged first lieutenant of Arnold Rothstein in the conspiracy declared he never knew Rothstein and had nothing to do with any conspiracy. "I don't know why they brought me up here" said Carl Zork of St. Louis another defendant. "I never knew of the other defendants until I met them in court.". - ' . ' ' To '. Drop Further Action " It was stated at the state's attor ney's office today that the cases against the other players and alleged gamblers who are also under indiptment. would be allowed to lapse. Among this group are Chase, McMullin, Attell, Sullivan and several oth ers. On acount of their services to the prosecution the cases against Burns

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

Following their acquittal, Buck Weaver, Risberg, Williams, Cicotte, Felsch, Gandil, Zelcor, and Zork each proclaim innocence and distance themselves from the conspiracy, blaming Bill Burns and Billy Maharg. The state's attorney announces charges against remaining defendants, including Chase, McMullin, and Attell, will be dropped, while Burns and Maharg avoid prosecution for cooperating.

New Britain Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A jury found the former Chicago players not guilty of conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series, but the report asserts this verdict will not restore their standing with fans or organized baseball. It predicts none of the accused will ever again appear in a major league ballpark.

Evening Star · 3 August 1921 · page 20

star, will devolve unon Walter Johnson. The Kansan recently has given indications of a return to the form which made him the most feared of all hurlers. and with a team back of him fighting as are the Nationals, a bitter scrap may be expected. Black Sox Still Black. The whitewashing given by the jury to the former Chicago players accused of betraying their employer and the public. In plotting to sell out in the world series of 1919. will have no effect on their status tn the eyes 01

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

A Chicago jury found seven former White Sox players and two others not guilty of conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. The courtroom erupted in cheers as players were carried on spectators' shoulders and Judge Friend congratulated the jury on its verdict.

The New York Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 1

SOX ARE ACQUITTED OF THROWING GAMES IN '19 WORLD SERIES

Just Decision. Bu the .l&soctatrd PrtM. Chicago, Auk. 2.?The seven former Chicago White Sox baseball players and two others on trial for alleged con spiracy to defraud the public through throwing of the 1919 world series games were fourd not guilty by a Jury. The verdict was reached after two hours and forty-sevMi minutes of de liberation, but was not returned until forty minutes later, Judge Hugo M. Friend being out of court when the de-j cision was reached. The defendants were: Buck Weaver, third baseman; Oscar Felsch. outfielder; Charles Risberg, shortstop; Arnold Gandil, flrst baae man; Claude Williams and Eddie Ci cotte, pitchers; Joe Jackson, outfielder ?all former White Sox players?and Carl Zork of St. Louis nnd David Zelcer

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The jury delivered not-guilty verdicts for all defendants in the Black Sox trial after a single ballot, sparking wild celebration, cheering, and chaos in Judge Friend's courtroom. Players reacted variously—Weaver and Risberg shouted with joy, Jackson stayed quiet, and Gandil gave a defiant farewell to Ban Johnson—while defense counsel called it complete vindication.

The New York Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 1

JUDGE FRIEND SMILES

gladness. Felsch and Williams merely smiled, while Joe Jackcon tocfk the decision very quietly. Gandll shook hands with a few friends and quietly slipped from tho courtroom. "I'll give a sailor's farewell to Ban Johnson," said Gandll. "Good-by, good luck and to hell with you!" "I knew I'd be cleared," said Weaver, "and I'm glad the public stood by me until the trial was over." Williams termed the verdict a "true one." saying he was proud to have "come through clean " Clcotto and RIs berg rushed to telegraph offices to no tify their wives.

See moreSee less

i)nvld Zelcer will return to his home In Pes Moines Immediately and Carl 7.ork plans to leave for St. Louis to morrow. Henry Uerger. defence counsel, termed the verdict a "complete vindication of the most mistreated ball players In his tory." The State's attorneys were silent

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The report covers the acquittal verdict in the Black Sox trial, with defense counsel Henry Berger calling it a complete vindication of the accused players. It lists the fourteen originally indicted men and details how only seven players and four gamblers were actually apprehended and tried, with some charges later dismissed for lack of evidence.

The New York Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 1

Fourteen Indicted. Those indicted were : "Eddie'' Clcotte, former star pitcher of the White Sox Claude Williams, former White Sox pitcher. Arnold Gandll, former first baseman. Charles (Swede) Blsberg. former shortstop. George ("Buck") Weaver, former third haoeman Joe Jackson, former outfielder Oscar < "Happy") Felsch, former out fielder. Abe Attell former pugilist and al leged gambler. Hal Chase, former baseball plftyer. William T"BI1I") Burns. former player and alleged go-between. Bachael Brown, alleged New Vork gambler. John J. ("Sj*>rt") Sullivan, alleged Boston gambler L>avld Zelcer, Des Moines, Towa. ad vertising man and alleged gambler. I?ouls I^evl and Bew I/vl, brothers, ' of Kokomo far) Zork of St. Louis.

See the clipping

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.

The report states a Chicago jury acquitted the seven former White Sox players and the gamblers charged with conspiracy, but argues the verdict does not erase the moral offense. It predicts the players will never return to professional baseball despite their legal acquittal.

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 3 August 1921 · page 6

Acquittal of Ball Players. There will be no surprise occasioned over the acquittal by a Chicago Jury of the seven former members of the White Sox of charges

See the clipping

Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

A Chicago jury found the seven former White Sox players and two co-defendants not guilty of conspiracy to defraud the public through throwing the 1919 World Series. The verdict was reached on the first ballot after nearly three hours of deliberation, and was met with cheers of "Hooray for the Clean Sox" from spectators in the courtroom.

Great Falls Tribune · 3 August 1921 · page 1

"HOORAY FOR CLEAN SOX" WHEN VERDICT IS READ

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

The jury delivered a not-guilty verdict for Cicotte, Jackson, Williams, Weaver, Risberg, Felsch, Gandil and others, sparking wild celebration in the courtroom. Players thanked jurors, were hoisted on shoulders, and spectators cheered amid chaotic scenes as Judge Friend looked on.

Great Falls Tribune · 3 August 1921 · page 1

Judge Friend Late. When the three loud knocks on the jury room door were heard, indicating a verdict, everyone jumped for the courtroom but the excitement was momentary, it being some time be fore Judge Friend could be reached. Buck Wearer and "Swede" Risberg were the most excited over the verdict grabbing each other by the arms and shouting in their gladness. Felsoh and Williams merely smiled while Joe Jackson took the decision quietly. Gandil shook hands with a few friends and quietly slipped from the courtroom. "I'll give a sailor's farewell to Ran Johnson," said Gandil. "Good bye, good luck and to hell with you." "I knew I'd be cleared, and Pm glad the public stood by me until the trial was over."

See the clipping

Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

The jury delivers a not-guilty verdict for all eight White Sox players and other defendants charged with conspiracy to defraud through fixing the 1919 World Series. Players react with relief and joy, with Weaver and Risberg celebrating, while defense counsel calls it a complete vindication and prosecutors remain silent.

Great Falls Tribune · 3 August 1921 · page 1

was over." State's Attorney Silent. Williams termed the verdict a "true one." saying he was proud to have "come through clean." Cicotte and Risberg rushed to tele graph offices to notify their wives. Davis Zelcer will return to his home in Des Moines immediately and Car! Zork plans to leave for St. Louis Wednesday. Henry Berger, defense counsel, term ed the verdict a "complete vindication i of the most mistreated hall »players is j history." j The state's attorneys were silent, j j The case was placed in the hands of !

See moreSee less

the jnry in a special session of the court at 7:02 after Judge Friend had I instructed the jury as to the numerous ! iegal points involved. The closing arguments were rm eluded Tuesday afternoon when Geowa Gorman, assistant state's attorney in charge of the prosecution, in a brief closing address informed the Jury that in his opinion, the state had presented such a conclusive case that lengthy address was unnecessary.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

After closing arguments, Judge Friend instructed the jury that the state must prove intent to defraud the public, not merely to throw games, and the case went to the jury at 7:52 p.m. The report lists all those indicted by the grand jury in the 1919 World Series fix conspiracy.

Omaha Daily Bee · 3 August 1921 · page 10

Fate of Indicted White Sox Players Rests in Hands of Jury

Judge Friend, in his instructions, told the jury that the state must prove that it was the intent of the Chicago White Sox players and oth

See the clipping

In the story →

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

A Cook County jury acquitted the American League players charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series, sparking jubilant courtroom scenes. Baseball commissioner Landis immediately declared that regardless of the verdict, any player involved in discussions to fix games would be banned from organized baseball.

Grand Forks Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

BALL PLAYERS SET FREE BY COOK CO. JURY

Court Room is Wild Scene When Verdict of Not Guilty is Reported.

See moreSee less

Judge Joins in Congratulating Players; Calls it Just Decision.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—None of the American league players who were acquitted last night of an alleged criminal conspiracy to throw the 1919 world's series, has any immediate prospect of being restored to organized baseball, according to a statement issued today by Judge K. M. Landis, national baseball commissioner.

"Regardless of the verdict of the jury," said the statement, "no player that throws a ball game, no player that entertains proposals or promises to throw a game, no player that sits in a conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing games are discussed, and dares not tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball."

"Of course I do not know that any of these men will apply for reinstatement, but if they do, the above are at least few of the rules that will be enforced.

"Just keep it in mind that regardless of the verdict of juries, baseball is entirely competent to protect itself against the crooks both inside and outside the game."

Comiskey Unchanged.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—Charles A. Comisky, owner of the Chicago White Sox, declared today that the verdict freeing his former players of conspiracy charges to throw the 1919 world's series, did not change his stand and that until "they cleared themselves" to his satisfaction, he would have nothing to do with them.

"Cicotte confessed he was guilty and implicated others," Mr. Comisky said today. "We had three confessions and they have not been accounted for. They implicated themselves and until they can offer a good excuse we will have nothing to do with them."

Comisky said that he would have a complete statement on the matter in a day or two and refused to make further comment until that time.

Judge Charles A. MacDonald, to whom several "black sox" confessions were made, refused to talk about the outcome of the trial today. As chief justice of the criminal court, Judge MacDonald was in charge of the grand jury which returned the indictment.

Of the players acquitted last night only "Buck" Weaver, former third baseman of the Chicago White Sox and "Swede" Risberg, former shortstop, indicated an immediate intention to apply for reinstatement.

Weaver's attorney, Thomas Nash, announced he was going to "put Weaver back in organized baseball," and Risberg indicated a desire to return to major league diamonds but said he would "leave his future in organized baseball in the hands of the officials."

Chicago, Aug. 3.—Failure to secure convictions in the trial of the seven White Sox players was disappointing to President Ban Johnson of the American league, but he declared in a statement today that "a very good lesson had been taught."

"The trial of the indicted players and gamblers which closed yesterday uncovered the greatest crime it was possible to commit in baseball," President Johnson said.

"The fact that the outfit was freed by a Cook county jury does not alter the conditions one iota or minimize the magnitude of the offense," he added.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—The seven former Chicago White Sox players and two alleged gamblers brought to trial in the baseball scandal case today, stood legally cleared of any connection with the alleged conspiracy for the White Sox to throw the 1919 world's series to Cincinnati, a jury last night having found them not guilty on the first ballot.

The verdict freeing Buck Weaver, Happy Felsch, Chick Gandil, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams, Charles Risberg and Eddie Cicotte—the former players—and Carl Zork of St. Louis and David Zelcer of Des Moines, was returned shortly before midnight amidst a scene of wild cheering, whistling and yelling from 500 spectators which would have seemed more natural in the bleachers of a baseball park than in the dignified court room of Judge Hugo Friend.

Judge is Happy.

Judge Friend's bailiffs vainly tried to establish order out of the pandemonium which broke loose despite the judge's previous request that no demonstration be given when the verdict was read. With chair overturned and hats thrown in the air as the spectators rushed to shake hands with the ballplayers and as the players rushed to grasp the hands of the jurors, Judge Friend finally motioned to his aides to let the demonstration go on and finally joined in by congratulating the defendants and telling the jury it had returned a just verdict.

Only Nine Held.

While only nine of the eighteen persons indicted in the baseball investigation were defendants when the case ended, it is believed that the baseball scandal has forever been swept from the books so far as the courts of Cook county are concerned. Bill Burns' case was dismissed in return for his evidence for the state and during the trial the cases of Ben and Louis Levi of Kokomo, Ind., were dropped. Abe Attell, Hal Chase, Fred McMullen, Richard Brown of New York, J. J. Sullivan of Boston and Ben Franklin of St. Louis still are under indictment, but it was reported at the state's attorney's office today that their cases would be allowed to lapse through the statute of limitations.

Only One Ballot.

The attorneys for the prosecution had little to say of the case, but the defense pointed to the fact that only one ballot was taken by the jury as an absolute vindication of the defendants. The jury was not ready to return its verdict until two hours and forty-seven minutes after receiving the case, but most of this time was taken in signing the verdicts. Each of the twelve men had to sign each of the nine verdicts, a separate verdict being returned for each defendant.

Today the jurors expressed surprise that the case had been allowed to drag through five weeks. While refusing to permit use of their names in discussing the case with reporters, every juror declared that the defense would have received the same verdict had it sent the case to the jury without presenting any witnesses or making any closing arguments.

"We thought the state had presented a weak case," said one juror. "It depended entirely on Bill Burns and Burns did not make a favorable impression with any of us. We felt from the time the state finished its evidence that we could not return any verdict other than not guilty and we used to privately wish there were some way to let the defense attorneys know that it was unnecessary to go further."

The jurors refused to say whether, in reaching their verdict they were of the opinion that there was no attempt to throw games in the 1919 world's series or whether it was based on the contention that the state had failed to prove its charge that there was intent to defraud the public and various individuals through the throwing of the series.

Big Celebration.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—In a little Italian restaurant on Chicago' west side the former White Sox players, indicted in the baseball scandal, early today accidentally met the twelve jurors who last night found them not guilty of the charges brought by the state and the twelve judges of fact in the case joined with the men whose fate had been in their hands for five weeks in a celebration which did not end until sunrise.

The jurors went to the restaurant for a farewell dinner before returning to their homes. The players and their attorneys went for the same purpose. After several hours the two parties discovered each other in adjoining rooms, the doors were thrown open and the party became one.

If this jury could decide whether the acquitted players will be permitted to return to organized baseball, there would be no doubt of a favorable verdict for each of the twelve went to the players as they separated and expressed a desire to see them on a major league team again.

Laud Cicotte.

Eddie Cicotte drew particular attention from the jurors for it was Cicotte who sought most of the state's fire in the trial.

They talked of games they had seen the pitcher hurl and one of them, grasping him by the hands, said:

"Eddie we were talking the other night about you and I want you to know that every man on this jury hopes that the next time he sees you, you'll be in the center of the diamond putting over strikes."

"And we'll be there in a box cheering for you and the rest of these boys, Eddie," added another juror.

The jurors and the recent defendants left the restaurant together singing, "Hail, Hail, the Gang's All Here."

Hard Luck.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—Fred McMullin, former Whit Sox utility infielder, who was indicted but not on trial, was the victim of ill luck, it became known today.

McMullin after his indictment in the first investigation, came here from California at his own expense to stand trial. After two weeks the case was dropped and McMullin broke, borrowed money to get back to California and take a job as a sign painter.

Indicted in the second investigation, McMullin sent word he could not afford the trip to Chicago, but would come for trial if the state paid his way. He received no answer and finally got together enough money for the trip.

McMullin arrived here the day after the trial began—a fact not known until today. He was too late to go on trial and returned to California. His former team mates believe that this one day's delay prevented McMullin from sharing in the verdict of not guilty, although it is not believed that the state will ever press the indictment against him.

All indictments remaining against the acquitted baseball players will be quashed it was announced by Robert E. Crowe, state's attorney.

"As far as I am concerned, the case is a closed book," said Mr. Crowe.

Investigation of the disappearance of the waivers of immunity signed by Cicotte, Jackson and Williams, and which are said to have been sold to eastern gamblers for $10,000 is still going on, the state's attorney said.

Men Are Happy.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—The seven former members of the Chicago White Sox were jubilant today over their acquittal by a jury last night of charges involving the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series with Cincinnati. Some of them expressed hopes that they soon would be reinstated in major league baseball.

Joe Jackson, former star outfielder, was the only one who declared he was "through with organized baseball." The others said they would leave their baseball future in the hands of officials of organized baseball.

"The jury could not have returned a fairer verdict," said Jackson. "But I don't want to go back to organized baseball. I am through with it."

"Everybody knew I had nothing to do with this so-called conspiracy," said Buck Weaver, once the third baseman of the White Sox. "I believe that I should be given my old position back. I cannot express my contempt for Bill Burns."

"I am entirely innocent and the jury has proven that," said Charles Risberg, former shortstop. "I leave my future in organized baseball in the hands of the officials."

"How could the verdict have been anything else?" asked Claude Williams, pitcher. "I'm going to stick in semi-professional baseball."

"All I want to do is to get to Detroit," said Eddie Cicotte, once the leading pitcher of the American league, while he shook hands with the jurors. "Talk, did you say? Never again. I talked once in this building; never again."

"The jury has said all that I can say," said Oscar "Happy" Felsch. "I am not guilty and never had anything to do with any so-called conspiracy."

"I never had any doubt about the verdict," said "Chick" Gandil, former baseman, who did not return to the White Sox in the 1920 season. "If it had not been for those two liars—Bill Burns and Billy Maharg, I would not have been here. We are going to form a semi-professional team in Chicago and play a few games for the benefit of the wounded soldiers."

David Zelcer of Des Moines, alleged first lieutenant of Arnold Rothstein in the conspiracy, declared he never knew Rothstein and had nothing to do with any conspiracy.

"I don't know why they brought me up here," said Carl Zork of St. Louis, another defendant. "I never knew any of the other defendants until I met them in court."

Boston, Aug. 3.—"Kid" Gleason, manager of the Chicago White Sox, said today that none of the players involved in the world series conspiracy charges would ever play with any club of which he was manager. Gleason, violent in his denunciation of the men who were acquitted of charges of throwing the world's series of 1919, denied that he had fraternized with the defendants in the court room at Chicago where he was a witness.

"Wish them well?" Gleason exclaimed. "Not much," and he broke into a string of epithets. "I don't think they'll ever play in organized baseball again. I know they'll never play with any club that I manage."

Gleason said he stood with Comisky in his attitude expressed in Chicago today and endorsed entirely the statement issued by Commissioner Landis.

The White Sox players withheld comment, turning to Eddie Collins as their spokesman. Collins said there would be nothing for the players to say unless the baseball authorities took unexpected action.

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

Following the players' acquittal, Charles Comiskey says he will bar them from the White Sox until they clear themselves, citing confessions by Cicotte and others. Ban Johnson calls the lack of convictions disappointing but says a lesson was taught, while Weaver and Risberg move to seek reinstatement.

Grand Forks Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8

Of the players acquitted, lalst night only "Buck" Weaver, former third baseman of the Chicago White Sox and "Swede" Risberg, former short stop, indicated an immediate inten tion to apply for reinstatement. Weaver's attorney, Thomas Nash, announced he was gSfig to "put Weaver back in organized baseball," and Risberg indicated a desire to re turn t.o major league diamonds but said he would "leave his future in or ganized baseball in the hands of the officials."

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

A Cook County jury found the seven former White Sox players and two gamblers not guilty on the first ballot, clearing them legally of conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series. Ban Johnson called the verdict disappointing but insisted a lesson had been taught, while Weaver and Risberg sought reinstatement in organized baseball.

Grand Forks Herald · 3 August 1921 · page 8

Chicago, Aug. 3.—Failure to secure convictions in the trial of the seven White Sox players was disappointing to President Ban Johnson of the American league, but he declared in a statement today that' "a very good les son had been taught." "The trial of the ipdicted players and gamblers which closed yesterday uncovered the greatest crime it was possible to commit in baseball," Pres ident Johnson said. "The fact that the outfit was freed by a. Cook county jury does not alter. the conditions one iota or minimize the magnitude of the! offense," he ad ,« «. ... 1 ded

See the clipping

The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.

Hours after a jury acquitted the former White Sox players of conspiracy charges, the players and jurors unexpectedly met at an Italian restaurant on Chicago's West Side and joined in a celebration. Jurors praised Eddie Cicotte and expressed hope for his return to baseball, while the group sang together before Cicotte departed for Oklahoma oil interests.

The Guthrie Daily Leader · 3 August 1921 · page 1

- -r x-w r-'i - a la. A Z " ." t'rbJt fa!.-. cooT to3iVair-a Ok-' tra. Tiiy I a major league team agiin. Eddie Ckotte drew particular attention from the jurors for it was Cicotte who taught most of the state's fire in the trial They talked of games they had seen the pitcher hurl and one cf thern graipirj him by tk hand, said :

See the clipping

In the story →

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

After the not-guilty verdict, the former White Sox players and the jurors who acquitted them accidentally met at a small Italian restaurant in Chicago and ended up celebrating together until sunrise. Jurors expressed hope the players would be allowed to return to major league baseball.

The Barre Daily Times · 3 August 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

JURY AND ACQUITTED SING "HAIL, HAIL, THE GANG'S ALL HERE"

Freed Ball Players and the Men Who Had Exonerated Them Met in a Chicago Restaurant.

See moreSee less

Chicago, Aug. 3.—In a little Italian restaurant on Chicago's west side, early to-day, the former White Sox players, indicted in the baseball scandal, accidentally met the 12 jurors, who last night found them not guilty of the charges brought by the state, and the 12 judges of fact in the case joined with the men whose fate had been in their hands for five weeks in a celebration which did not end until sunrise.

The jurors went to the restaurant for a farewell dinner before returning to their homes. The players and their attorneys went for the same purpose. The two parties soon discovered each other in adjoining rooms, the doors were thrown open and the parties became one.

If this jury could decide whether the acquitted players will be permitted to return to organized baseball there would be no doubt of a favorable verdict for each of the 12 went to the players as they separated and expressed a desire to see them on a major league team again.

Eddie Cicotte drew particular attention from the jurors, for it was Cicotte who got most of the state's fire in the trial. One of them, grasping him by the hand, said:

"Eddie, we were talking the other night about you and I want you to know that every man on this jury hopes that the next time he sees you you'll be in the center of the diamond putting over strikes."

The jurors and the defendants left the restaurant together singing, "Hail, Hail, the Gang's All Here."

See the clipping

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

Judge Landis declares that none of the players acquitted of conspiracy in the 1919 World Series fix will be reinstated to organized baseball. He states that regardless of jury verdicts, any player who throws a game, discusses fixing games, or fails to report such conspiracies will never play professional ball again.

The Barre Daily Times · 3 August 1921 · page 1

NO REINSTATEMENT. If Landis Has Anything to Do About It. Chicago. Aug. 3. None of the Amer--an league players acquitted laat sight of an aliened criminal conspiracy

See the clipping

The Nenana News · Nenana, Alaska

Seven former White Sox players and two others charged with conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series were acquitted by a Chicago jury after less than three hours of deliberation. The verdict sparked celebration in the courtroom with players and jurors dancing together, and Comiskey issued a statement regarding the players' earlier confessions.

The Nenana News · 4 August 1921 · page 1

Must Explain Confeations Charles Comiskey, owner of th< White Sox club, has issued a publi< statement in which he declares tha JAPS OBJECT TO COOLIES

See the clipping

The Nenana News · Nenana, Alaska

Despite their acquittal by the trial jury, Judge Landis announced none of the players has any immediate prospect of returning to organized baseball. Pacific Coast League President McCarthy likewise declared the acquitted men would not be permitted to play in his Western organization.

The Nenana News · 4 August 1921 · page 1

] of not guilty returned by the trial j jurj. Can’t Play In West SAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 4—The ■ acquittal of the White Sox players . will not get them anything on the Pacific Coast, according to Presi i dent McCarthy, of the Pacific Coast j league, who has announced that | none of the acquitted men will be permitted to play in the Western . organization.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Nenana News · Nenana, Alaska

An editorial reacts angrily to the acquittal of the indicted White Sox players, noting that several had confessed to conspiring to throw the World Series. It calls the verdict a disgrace nearly equal to the original conspiracy, but praises Judge Landis for vowing to bar the players from baseball regardless.

The Nenana News · 4 August 1921 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

In view of the fact that several of the. indicted White Sox players confessed that they knew of a conspiracy to throw the World series and were implicated in it, the acquittal of those charged with an attempt to use organized baseball as a medium through which to rob an unsuspecting public, will be regarded by Americans as a farce and a disgrace, almost on a par with the conspiracy. The defense of the accused players was that it is not a crime in Illinois to rob the public in that manner, and the jury appears to have been of that mind also.

See moreSee less

Under the circumstances, it is reassuring to know that Judge Landis takes a different view of the matter and will not give the guilty men another chance to accept bribes. It is good to know that there is at the head of the big leagues an honest man who is bigger than a trial jury and more dependable.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A reporter surveyed passersby in downtown Chicago about whether the acquitted Black Sox should be allowed back in baseball. Most opposed their return, though some expressed sympathy for Buck Weaver and Happy Felsch as victims of circumstance.

The Washington Times · 4 August 1921 · page 14

FANS ARE AGAINST LETTING BLACK SOX RETURN TO GAME

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Former White Sox players indicted in the scandal accidentally met the jurors who had acquitted them at an Italian restaurant, and the two parties merged into one celebration lasting until sunrise. Jurors expressed hope the players would return to organized baseball and play again.

The Washington Times · 4 August 1921 · page 14

BLACK SOX AND THEIR JURY CELEBRATE AT BANQUET BOARD

Side, the former White Sox players, indicted in the baseball scandal, ac cidentally met the twelve Jurors who found them not guilty of th charges brought by the State, and the twelve udges of fact in the can joined witthe men whose fate had been in their hands for dve week ia elobtion which did not end until sunrise. The Jurors went to the restaurant for a farewell dinher before reti ing to their homes. The-flayers and thet' attorneys went for the sam pupose. The two parties soon discovered each other In adjoining room the doors were thrown open and the parties became one. If this jury could decide whether

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

After the Black Sox players were acquitted by a jury, White Sox manager Kid Gleason declared none of them would ever play for a team he managed, endorsing Commissioner Landis's banishment. Philadelphia Athletics manager Connie Mack echoed the sentiment, barring the players from Shibe Park and noting some had confessed to the fix despite the jury's verdict.

The Washington Times · 4 August 1921 · page 14

KID GLEASON NEVER WILL COUNTENANCE ANY OF BLACK SOX

'. SIDE WITH JUDOE LANDIS masager of the Chicago W Ire ao said today that none of the playe invol%red in the world eries cone spiracY charges would ever play with r any club of which he was a man er. Gleason, violent In his denu.t ihof the men who were acI quited. o o throwing the world lsrin of11 denied that he had fraternied with the defendants in the courtro6m at Chicago, where I he was a witness.i "Wish them well?" - Gleaon ext claimsed "Not mucht" and he broke 4Into a string of epitheWs "I don't t think they'll ever play In ornis.

See moreSee less

ed -bassball agaln. I know they'll never play with any club that I manage." Glesson said he stood with Preal-. dent Comiskey in his attitude ex preVe -In Chicago today, and In dorsed entirely the statement Ws sued by Commissioner Landis. The C White Box PlaYers withhold com Iment, turning to Eddie Collins as tMair spokesman. Collins said there would be nothing for the players to say unless the baseball authorities took unexpected aetion. T

See the clipping

Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Following the not-guilty verdict, the indicted White Sox players and their attorneys accidentally encountered the twelve jurors at a Chicago restaurant, and the two farewell parties merged into one celebration lasting until sunrise. Each juror personally told the players he hoped to see them return to major league baseball.

Indiana Daily Times · 4 August 1921 · page 8

Stage Sunrise Party CHICAGO, Aug 4.—ln n little Italian restaurant on Chicago's west side, the former White Sox players, Indicted in the baseball scandal, early Wednesday, accidentally met the twelve Jurors who

See the clipping

Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

Following the acquittal of the Black Sox players, most of the defendants' attorneys say their clients will not pursue damage suits against organized baseball. Only Buck Weaver is reported likely to sue for back pay owed under his contract, while Comiskey says all players have been paid what they were due.

Indiana Daily Times · 4 August 1921 · page 8

Weaver Alone May Sue CHICVGO, Aug, 4. Interest in after math developments of the trial that ro suited in acquittal <>f the "Black Sox centered last night In the announcement that only one of the discredits 1

See the clipping

Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo, Colo.

This editorial reflects on the acquittal of the White Sox players, noting that the trial judge congratulated the jury on reaching a just verdict. It argues that despite the legal acquittal, the public retains lingering doubts about whether the players truly tried to win, partly because defense attorneys argued that throwing games, while dishonest, was not illegal.

Pueblo Chieftain · 9 August 1921 · page 6

Players’ Acquittal The average mind is in a haze over the acquittal of the White Sox Baseball players. If the boys were not guilty of the crimes for which they were indicted,

See the clipping

Audubon County Journal · Exira, Iowa · and 1 other paper

Despite a Chicago jury's acquittal of the indicted former White Sox players on conspiracy charges related to the 1919 World Series, Federal Judge K.M. Landis ruled that none would be allowed to play professional baseball again. The report frames Landis as the 'supreme arbiter' of organized baseball, overriding the jury's verdict.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 48 days later.

Wrong

Audubon County Journal · 11 August 1921 · page 3

Despite the verdict of the Jury at Chicago, none of the seven indicted former White Sox, acquitted of con spiracy to "throw" the 1919 world's series, will be permitted to play pro fessional baseball, according to the verdict announced by Federal Judge K. M. Landis, supreme arbiter of op ganized baseball. Foreign A Prague dispatch says one work man was killed and tqn were wounded, at Aussig'when a crowd of Germans clashed with Czech gendarmes and legionnaires. The American relief officials In London are placing little faith in the reports that the American prisoners in Russia have been released and now are leaving that country.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis. · 10 August 1921

Paper unidentified

Despite the Chicago jury's acquittal of the seven indicted former White Sox players on conspiracy charges related to fixing the 1919 World Series, Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis ruled none of them would be permitted to play professional baseball. Landis is described as the supreme arbiter of organized baseball.

Paper unidentified · 11 August 1921 · page 8

Despite foe 'verdict of the Jury at Chicago none of the seven Indicted former-White Sox! acquitted of con spiracy to “throw” too 1919 world’s series will be permitted to play pro feeriontl baseball according -to - the verdict announced by Federal Judge X M Land! supremo arbiter of or ganised baseball - - - ’ e i ’

See the clipping