Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
BALL PLAYERS SET FREE BY COOK CO. JURY
Court Room is Wild Scene When Verdict of Not Guilty is Reported.
See moreSee less
Judge Joins in Congratulating Players; Calls it Just Decision.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—None of the American league players who were acquitted last night of an alleged criminal conspiracy to throw the 1919 world's series, has any immediate prospect of being restored to organized baseball, according to a statement issued today by Judge K. M. Landis, national baseball commissioner.
"Regardless of the verdict of the jury," said the statement, "no player that throws a ball game, no player that entertains proposals or promises to throw a game, no player that sits in a conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing games are discussed, and dares not tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball."
"Of course I do not know that any of these men will apply for reinstatement, but if they do, the above are at least few of the rules that will be enforced.
"Just keep it in mind that regardless of the verdict of juries, baseball is entirely competent to protect itself against the crooks both inside and outside the game."
Comiskey Unchanged.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—Charles A. Comisky, owner of the Chicago White Sox, declared today that the verdict freeing his former players of conspiracy charges to throw the 1919 world's series, did not change his stand and that until "they cleared themselves" to his satisfaction, he would have nothing to do with them.
"Cicotte confessed he was guilty and implicated others," Mr. Comisky said today. "We had three confessions and they have not been accounted for. They implicated themselves and until they can offer a good excuse we will have nothing to do with them."
Comisky said that he would have a complete statement on the matter in a day or two and refused to make further comment until that time.
Judge Charles A. MacDonald, to whom several "black sox" confessions were made, refused to talk about the outcome of the trial today. As chief justice of the criminal court, Judge MacDonald was in charge of the grand jury which returned the indictment.
Of the players acquitted last night only "Buck" Weaver, former third baseman of the Chicago White Sox and "Swede" Risberg, former shortstop, indicated an immediate intention to apply for reinstatement.
Weaver's attorney, Thomas Nash, announced he was going to "put Weaver back in organized baseball," and Risberg indicated a desire to return to major league diamonds but said he would "leave his future in organized baseball in the hands of the officials."
Chicago, Aug. 3.—Failure to secure convictions in the trial of the seven White Sox players was disappointing to President Ban Johnson of the American league, but he declared in a statement today that "a very good lesson had been taught."
"The trial of the indicted players and gamblers which closed yesterday uncovered the greatest crime it was possible to commit in baseball," President Johnson said.
"The fact that the outfit was freed by a Cook county jury does not alter the conditions one iota or minimize the magnitude of the offense," he added.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—The seven former Chicago White Sox players and two alleged gamblers brought to trial in the baseball scandal case today, stood legally cleared of any connection with the alleged conspiracy for the White Sox to throw the 1919 world's series to Cincinnati, a jury last night having found them not guilty on the first ballot.
The verdict freeing Buck Weaver, Happy Felsch, Chick Gandil, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams, Charles Risberg and Eddie Cicotte—the former players—and Carl Zork of St. Louis and David Zelcer of Des Moines, was returned shortly before midnight amidst a scene of wild cheering, whistling and yelling from 500 spectators which would have seemed more natural in the bleachers of a baseball park than in the dignified court room of Judge Hugo Friend.
Judge is Happy.
Judge Friend's bailiffs vainly tried to establish order out of the pandemonium which broke loose despite the judge's previous request that no demonstration be given when the verdict was read. With chair overturned and hats thrown in the air as the spectators rushed to shake hands with the ballplayers and as the players rushed to grasp the hands of the jurors, Judge Friend finally motioned to his aides to let the demonstration go on and finally joined in by congratulating the defendants and telling the jury it had returned a just verdict.
Only Nine Held.
While only nine of the eighteen persons indicted in the baseball investigation were defendants when the case ended, it is believed that the baseball scandal has forever been swept from the books so far as the courts of Cook county are concerned. Bill Burns' case was dismissed in return for his evidence for the state and during the trial the cases of Ben and Louis Levi of Kokomo, Ind., were dropped. Abe Attell, Hal Chase, Fred McMullen, Richard Brown of New York, J. J. Sullivan of Boston and Ben Franklin of St. Louis still are under indictment, but it was reported at the state's attorney's office today that their cases would be allowed to lapse through the statute of limitations.
Only One Ballot.
The attorneys for the prosecution had little to say of the case, but the defense pointed to the fact that only one ballot was taken by the jury as an absolute vindication of the defendants. The jury was not ready to return its verdict until two hours and forty-seven minutes after receiving the case, but most of this time was taken in signing the verdicts. Each of the twelve men had to sign each of the nine verdicts, a separate verdict being returned for each defendant.
Today the jurors expressed surprise that the case had been allowed to drag through five weeks. While refusing to permit use of their names in discussing the case with reporters, every juror declared that the defense would have received the same verdict had it sent the case to the jury without presenting any witnesses or making any closing arguments.
"We thought the state had presented a weak case," said one juror. "It depended entirely on Bill Burns and Burns did not make a favorable impression with any of us. We felt from the time the state finished its evidence that we could not return any verdict other than not guilty and we used to privately wish there were some way to let the defense attorneys know that it was unnecessary to go further."
The jurors refused to say whether, in reaching their verdict they were of the opinion that there was no attempt to throw games in the 1919 world's series or whether it was based on the contention that the state had failed to prove its charge that there was intent to defraud the public and various individuals through the throwing of the series.
Big Celebration.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—In a little Italian restaurant on Chicago' west side the former White Sox players, indicted in the baseball scandal, early today accidentally met the twelve jurors who last night found them not guilty of the charges brought by the state and the twelve judges of fact in the case joined with the men whose fate had been in their hands for five weeks in a celebration which did not end until sunrise.
The jurors went to the restaurant for a farewell dinner before returning to their homes. The players and their attorneys went for the same purpose. After several hours the two parties discovered each other in adjoining rooms, the doors were thrown open and the party became one.
If this jury could decide whether the acquitted players will be permitted to return to organized baseball, there would be no doubt of a favorable verdict for each of the twelve went to the players as they separated and expressed a desire to see them on a major league team again.
Laud Cicotte.
Eddie Cicotte drew particular attention from the jurors for it was Cicotte who sought most of the state's fire in the trial.
They talked of games they had seen the pitcher hurl and one of them, grasping him by the hands, said:
"Eddie we were talking the other night about you and I want you to know that every man on this jury hopes that the next time he sees you, you'll be in the center of the diamond putting over strikes."
"And we'll be there in a box cheering for you and the rest of these boys, Eddie," added another juror.
The jurors and the recent defendants left the restaurant together singing, "Hail, Hail, the Gang's All Here."
Hard Luck.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—Fred McMullin, former Whit Sox utility infielder, who was indicted but not on trial, was the victim of ill luck, it became known today.
McMullin after his indictment in the first investigation, came here from California at his own expense to stand trial. After two weeks the case was dropped and McMullin broke, borrowed money to get back to California and take a job as a sign painter.
Indicted in the second investigation, McMullin sent word he could not afford the trip to Chicago, but would come for trial if the state paid his way. He received no answer and finally got together enough money for the trip.
McMullin arrived here the day after the trial began—a fact not known until today. He was too late to go on trial and returned to California. His former team mates believe that this one day's delay prevented McMullin from sharing in the verdict of not guilty, although it is not believed that the state will ever press the indictment against him.
All indictments remaining against the acquitted baseball players will be quashed it was announced by Robert E. Crowe, state's attorney.
"As far as I am concerned, the case is a closed book," said Mr. Crowe.
Investigation of the disappearance of the waivers of immunity signed by Cicotte, Jackson and Williams, and which are said to have been sold to eastern gamblers for $10,000 is still going on, the state's attorney said.
Men Are Happy.
Chicago, Aug. 3.—The seven former members of the Chicago White Sox were jubilant today over their acquittal by a jury last night of charges involving the alleged throwing of the 1919 world's series with Cincinnati. Some of them expressed hopes that they soon would be reinstated in major league baseball.
Joe Jackson, former star outfielder, was the only one who declared he was "through with organized baseball." The others said they would leave their baseball future in the hands of officials of organized baseball.
"The jury could not have returned a fairer verdict," said Jackson. "But I don't want to go back to organized baseball. I am through with it."
"Everybody knew I had nothing to do with this so-called conspiracy," said Buck Weaver, once the third baseman of the White Sox. "I believe that I should be given my old position back. I cannot express my contempt for Bill Burns."
"I am entirely innocent and the jury has proven that," said Charles Risberg, former shortstop. "I leave my future in organized baseball in the hands of the officials."
"How could the verdict have been anything else?" asked Claude Williams, pitcher. "I'm going to stick in semi-professional baseball."
"All I want to do is to get to Detroit," said Eddie Cicotte, once the leading pitcher of the American league, while he shook hands with the jurors. "Talk, did you say? Never again. I talked once in this building; never again."
"The jury has said all that I can say," said Oscar "Happy" Felsch. "I am not guilty and never had anything to do with any so-called conspiracy."
"I never had any doubt about the verdict," said "Chick" Gandil, former baseman, who did not return to the White Sox in the 1920 season. "If it had not been for those two liars—Bill Burns and Billy Maharg, I would not have been here. We are going to form a semi-professional team in Chicago and play a few games for the benefit of the wounded soldiers."
David Zelcer of Des Moines, alleged first lieutenant of Arnold Rothstein in the conspiracy, declared he never knew Rothstein and had nothing to do with any conspiracy.
"I don't know why they brought me up here," said Carl Zork of St. Louis, another defendant. "I never knew any of the other defendants until I met them in court."
Boston, Aug. 3.—"Kid" Gleason, manager of the Chicago White Sox, said today that none of the players involved in the world series conspiracy charges would ever play with any club of which he was manager. Gleason, violent in his denunciation of the men who were acquitted of charges of throwing the world's series of 1919, denied that he had fraternized with the defendants in the court room at Chicago where he was a witness.
"Wish them well?" Gleason exclaimed. "Not much," and he broke into a string of epithets. "I don't think they'll ever play in organized baseball again. I know they'll never play with any club that I manage."
Gleason said he stood with Comisky in his attitude expressed in Chicago today and endorsed entirely the statement issued by Commissioner Landis.
The White Sox players withheld comment, turning to Eddie Collins as their spokesman. Collins said there would be nothing for the players to say unless the baseball authorities took unexpected action.