As the Papers Told It

Black Sox · The full archive

September 1921

3 articles

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

The report explains that the Chicago jury acquitted the seven former White Sox players only on a technicality, since no Illinois law in 1919 made it illegal to intentionally play poorly. It questions whether baseball and the public will allow the players back into the game despite their legal acquittal.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 2 September 1921 · page 4

White or Black Sox?

(New York Post.) Those who are astonished by the acquittal of the seven former White Sox players on trial In Chicago (will quickly realise that it was acquittal in a techni cal sense only. Judge Friend instructed the jury thut it was not enough for the State to prove that the players "threw” the World Series in 1919. it must prove that they threw it with intent to defraud the public and others. It appears thattbere was no Illi nois law in 1919 to make it criminal for men to play a second-rate game when they might be playing a [first-rate game.

See moreSee less

The written confessions of Cicotte, 'Williams, and Jackson were admitted only under strict reservations. Thus in reading Cicotte’s thirty page Grand Jury confession the prosecution was compelled to omit all references to any defendants ex cept Cicotte himself.

See the clipping

The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.

This editorial criticizes small towns for allowing the banned Black Sox players to play exhibition games, arguing it undermines law, morality, and the integrity of sport. It argues that fans who support these games are complicit in excusing dishonesty and that the players must face lasting social penalty for their conspiracy with gamblers.

The Chickasha Daily Express · 8 September 1921 · page 4

Furthermore, anybody who goes to see these Black Sox play, by his presence, gives countenance to conduct which is at variance with all the fine principles which make for decency and fairness in baseball and every other sport. The league players who entered into a conspiracy with gamblers to fleece the public were false to themselves, false to their profession, false to the ideals of fair sport, false to patrons of the game, false to all sense of honor; to condone or in the slightest degree, in any manner, extenuate ineir crimes, is 10 tower one s own standard ot morality and ac cept a share of the shame which these perfidious players drew upon themselves.

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A one-year-later sports retrospective briefly lists the eight White Sox players indicted by a Chicago grand jury for conspiracy related to fixing the 1919 World Series against Cincinnati. The item is part of a broader 'this day a year ago' column covering various sports events from September 1920.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 48 days earlier.

The Milwaukee Leader · 28 September 1921 · page 8

THIS DAY A YEAR AGO IN WORLD OF SPORTS

OFSPORTS j Brooklyn won the National league ? pennant while idle. With a home run I off Ryan in the ninth inning. Tony z Boeckel gave the pennant to Brooklyn, j as the Braves beat the Giants, making J it impossible for them do either tie or i win the pennant. Frisch had tied the » score in the eighth with a home run. g Duster Mails won his sixth successive I victory for the Indians against the | Browns. The American league won the toss g for the choice of the first game in the I world's series and elected to begin in | the west on the American league I grounds.

See moreSee less

' 2 Babe Ruth hit his 52nd and 53rd | homers off Rommell, Athletics, in the ? first and sixth innings. Clcotte, Jackson. Felsch, Risberg, ? Weaver. Gandil, Williams and McMulI lin, members of the Chicago White Sox, | were indicted by a grand jury in ChiI cago for an alleged conspiracy to comz mit an illegal act in connection with I the world’s series against the Cinclnz nati Reds in 1919. Slsler, Browns, made his 250th base I hit. beating Cobb’s record of 24 8 made | in 1911. ! Brooklyn gave Cleveland permission i to use Shortstop Sewell in the world’s f series. New York Americans offered Chicago I White Sox use of players to finish the | season, but Chicago declined.

See the clipping