A short item reports that in a recent game against Cleveland, Ray Schalk was the only player remaining from the 1920 regular lineup under manager Kid Gleason. This highlights how drastically the team had been reshaped following the banishment of the indicted players.
Indiana Daily Times · 2 July 1921 · page 5
j view wa* a good one and they were able I to see every move In the big fight. WHITE SOY CHANGED. •Tust showing how the White Sox have j changed In a recent game against Cleveland Ray Schalk was the only 1920 j regular in Kid Gleason's liae-up.
The state's witness list for the prosecution of the ex-White Sox players and gamblers includes Bill Burns and Joe Gedeon, both former players, causing surprise. The report notes the state may try to introduce the players' repudiated confessions, with Judge Hugo Friend to rule on admissibility when the trial begins the following Tuesday.
Indiana Daily Times · 2 July 1921 · page 5
Burns and Gedeon Are Witnesses in Sox Case
have been made, although later repudl .-ed b- .Toe Jackson, I-: i.lleCicotte and Claud* "Williams. Whether It Is permis sible f r sn.-h evidence to be submitted will t.e decided by Judge Hugo Friend, who will begin hearing the case next Tuesday.
Examination of a 100-man jury panel began in Chicago after Judge Hugo Friend denied a defense motion to quash the indictments against the White Sox players. Prospective jurors were questioned about accomplice testimony, as the prosecution's witness list included Billy Maharg and the fugitive William Burns.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 6 July 1921 · page 9
REAL TRIAL OF INDICTED MEN NOW UNDER WAY
far as Is publicly known, and of Billy I Maharg of Philadelphia. Maharg told many details of the alleged con spiracy in an Interview before the indictments were returned, and tsatc j officials have said privately that it v.as through liis story primarily that a grand Jury confession was obtained from Eddie Cicotte, White Sox pitch er. Meharg was not indicted. Of the six men examined, two were excused. One said h£ was acquainted with John Seys, Chicago National League club secretary, called as a state witness. The other, Stanley Siexas.
See moreSee less
a machinist, declared that al though he was a former semi-profes sional ball player in New Jersey, he had nevtfr heard of the baseball scandal. The state will decide tomorrow whether to turn over the other four to the defense for examination. All veniremen examined were questioned as to whether they knew any ball players, whether they ever played ball, attended professional games, saw the 191!) world series, or opposed professional or Sunday baseball;
Judge Hugo Friend denied a defense motion to quash indictments against the Chicago White Sox players and others charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Jury selection began, with prospective jurors questioned about weighing testimony from alleged co-conspirators, including witnesses William Burns and Billy Maharg.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 6 July 1921 · page 1
Motion of Chicago Ball Players To Quash Indictments Is Denied
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.
The report describes jury selection in the Black Sox trial, noting prospective jurors were questioned about their views on accomplice testimony and baseball knowledge. It also lists witnesses including Billy Maharg, whose pre-indictment interview reportedly led to Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession.
Norwich Bulletin · 6 July 1921 · page 7
of Philadelphia. Maharsr told manv deJails of the alleged' consniraev In in interview before anv IndVtmrnts wtre returned and staff officials have said pri vately that It was through his story primarily that a pTand jury confession was obtained from Eddie Cicotte. White Sox pitcher. Maharg was not indicted. ' Of the six men examined, two were excused: One said that he was aenrif-lrrted with John Srys, ("bleaTo Nation al League club secretary called ns a state witness. . The other. Stanley Biexas, p. machinist, declared that although he was a .former semi-nro ball player In New Jersey, he had never heard of the base bail spandal.
See moreSee less
. The state win decide tomorrow wheth er to turn over the other four to the de fense for examination. All yenirerpen examined were ques tioned lis to whether they knew any ball players, whether they ever played ball, attended professional jtam's, saw the liU9 world's series, or opposed pro fessional '.or Sunday baseball. whether they thought baseball an honest name, whether they took part' in baseball pools, bet on games or would he influenced hy the fact that all the defendants were not on trial. -
Jury selection for the trial of eighteen White Sox players and gamblers indicted in the 1919 baseball scandal continued in Chicago, with little prospect of quick completion. The state was questioning prospective jurors extensively about their baseball knowledge and connections.
New Britain Herald · 6 July 1921 · page 11
ARE PICKING JURY
Slow Process Made in Getting Men to Try Indicted Ball Players. Chicago, July. 6. The task of selecting a Jury to try the eighteen White Sox players and alleged gamblers indicted in connection with the 1919 baseball scandal was con tinued today, although there was lit tle prospect of securing a jury im mediately. Three prospective Jurors were ten tatively accepted yesterday by the state which is subjecting all poten tial jurors to a lengthy' questioning regarding their knowledge of and connection with baseball. Jurors are being asked by the state whether they have ever played base ball, amateur, semi-professional or professional and whether they are baseball fans.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
In Chicago, the process of selecting a jury for the trial of 18 White Sox players and gamblers indicted in the 1919 scandal continued, with little prospect of quick completion. Three prospective jurors were tentatively accepted the previous day as the state questioned potential jurors extensively about their knowledge of baseball.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 6 July 1921 · page 1
To Try Players ----- , Chicago, July 6The task of se lecting a jury to try the 18 White Sox 'players and alleged gamblers indicted in connection with the 1919 baseball
In Chicago, the process of selecting a jury to try the eight White Sox players and alleged gamblers indicted in the 1919 World Series scandal continued, with little prospect of quick completion. Jurors are being extensively questioned about their baseball knowledge and connections, including whether they have played the game or are fans.
Evening Star · 6 July 1921 · page 22
Scandal Case. . CHICAGO. III., July 6?The task of ! selecting a jury to try the eighteen J[ White Sox and alleged gamblers indicted tn connection with the 1919 < base ball scandal was continued towi day. although there was little prosfly pert of securing a jury immediately. wi Three prospective jurors were tenwc tatively accepted yesterday by the wl
Efforts to seat a jury for the trial of the eight White Sox players and gamblers indicted in the 1919 World Series scandal continued without quick success. Prospective jurors were being questioned about their baseball experience and fan status, with only three tentatively accepted so far.
Paper unidentified · 6 July 1921 · page 1
JURY FOR WHITESOX CASES IS PROVING HARD TO GET
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Judge Friend denied a defense motion to quash the indictments against the White Sox players charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Jury selection proceeded with prospective jurors questioned about accomplice testimony, and the state's witness list included Billy Maharg and the still-unapprehended William Burns, with Maharg's pre-indictment interview reportedly key to obtaining Cicotte's grand jury confession.
The Pensacola Journal · 6 July 1921 · page 1
Cicotte, White Sox pitcher. Maharg was not Indicted. Of the six men Indicted, two were excused. One said he was acquainted with John Seys,- Chicago National league club secretary, called as a state witness. ' : The state will decide tomorrow whether to turn over the other four to the defense for examination. All the veniremen examined were questioned as to whether they knew any ball players, whether they ever played ball, attended nrofesslonal games, saw the 1919 world series, or opposed profes sional ; or Sunday baseball, whether they thought baseball an honest game, whether they took part In baseball pools, bet on games, or would be in fluenced by the fact that all the de fendants were not on trial.
Judge Hugo Friend rejected a defense motion to dismiss the conspiracy indictment against the Chicago White Sox players. Prospective jurors were questioned about weighing testimony from alleged co-conspirators turned state's witnesses, and the state's witness list included Billy Maharg, whose earlier account reportedly helped secure Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession.
Palatka Daily News · 6 July 1921 · page 6
Maharg, of Philadelphia. Maharg told many details of the alleged con spiracy in an interview before any indictments were returned and state officials have said privately that it was through his story primarily that a grand jury conviction was obtained from Eddie Cicotte, white sox pitch er .Maharg was not indicted. Of the six men examined two were excused.
Judge Hugo Friend denied a motion to quash indictments against the Chicago White Sox players and others charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series, and jury selection began with examination of a 100-man venire panel. Prospective jurors were questioned about accomplice testimony law, knowledge of baseball, betting habits, and attitudes toward the sport; witness lists included William Burns and Billy Maharg, whose earlier account reportedly helped prompt Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession.
South Bend News-Times · 6 July 1921 · page 10
Alleged Crooks. By Associated Tress: CHICAGO. July 5 F.ramination of the federal panel of 100 veniremen called for jury service in the baseball trial, got under way Tuesday after Judge Hugo Friend had denied a motion to quash the Indictments against the Chicago White Sox play ers and others charged with conspir ing to throw the 1910 world series. Questioning of six men examined by the prosecution indicated that the atate -would depend primarily on the testimony of men believed to have been in the alleged conspiracy and reported to have turned state's evi dence.
See moreSee less
Every prospective Juror was qnestioned at length concerning the value he would attach to the testi mony of a co-conpirator and as to whether he found fault with the Illi nois law that a man may be convicted on the unconfirmed testimony of an accomplice. The list of witnesses read into the court record Tuesday by the state contained the name of William Burns, indicted but never apprehend ed .so far as in known, and of Billy Mah arg of Philadelphia.
In Chicago, examination of a 100-man jury panel began after Judge Hugo Friend denied a defense motion to quash the indictments against the White Sox players and gamblers. Prospective jurors were questioned about weighing testimony from alleged co-conspirators expected to serve as the prosecution's main witnesses.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 July 1921 · page 1
TRIAL OF ACCUSED BALL PLAYERS AT CHICAGO
1 offleias said privately that it was through his story primarily, that a errand fury confession was obtained from Eddie Cicotte, White Sox pitch er. Makars' was not indicted. Of the six men examined, two were excused. Ones aid he was acquainted with John Seys, Chicago National league club secretary, called as a state witness. Or.e other, Stanley Siexes, a machinist, declared that al I though he was a former semi-pro fessional ball player in New Jersey he had never heard of the baseball scandal. The state will decide tomorrow whether to turn over the other fo’ r to the dpfrnse for examination.
See moreSee less
All veniremen examined were ques tioned as to whether thv knw am* ball pla'TS whether thev ever played ball, attended professional jr-imos, saw the 1010 world series, or opposed pro fessional or Sundav baseball, wheth er they thought baseball an honest name, whether they took part in baseball pools, bet on games or would be influenced bv the fact that all the defendants were not on trial.
During jury selection, prospective jurors were questioned extensively about how much weight they'd give to testimony from alleged co-conspirators like Bill Burns and Billy Maharg. The state's case was expected to rest heavily on accomplice testimony, including a grand jury confession reportedly obtained from pitcher Eddie Cicotte after Maharg's interview.
The Wheeling Intelligencer · 6 July 1921 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial in Chicago, defense attorneys stated the indicted White Sox players were not highly paid, contrary to assumptions. This prompted the state to compile a salary list ranging from $3,000 to $7,250 among the accused players.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 7 July 1921 · page 8
White Sox Salaries Brought Out in Trial (By Associated press) CHICAGO, July 7. Statements by defense attorneys during examination of prospective jurors in the baseball
Four jurors have been accepted in the Chicago trial of indicted White Sox players, with defense attorney Henry Berger questioning jurors about their knowledge of star witnesses like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins. These players may be called to testify about player character, the possibility of game-fixing, or the White Sox's pennant-winning drive after the 1919 World Series.
Arizona Republican · 8 July 1921 · page 6
Four Jurors Take Seats In Chicago Baseball Hearing
Baseball Hearing Republican A. P. Leased Wire CHICAGO, July 7 Some of the greatest stars in baseball, including Ty Cobb, manager of the Detroit Americans; Eddie Collins, captain of the Chicago White Sox, and half a dozen other Detroit players may be called to testify in defense of the White Sox players and others on trial here. This was made known by the defense today in accepting the first four jurors. AsHenry Berger. de fense attorney, finished examining the fourth Juror, he asked if he knew any of the witnesses1 announced by the state and then said: "Do you know Ty Cobb.
See moreSee less
Harry Hellmann, Veat'h, Young. Bill James, Owen Bush Howard Ehmke, Oscar Stanage, Day er, Dauss or Mitchell of the Detroit club, or Eddi Collins, John Collins, Red Faber, Bird Lynn. Harry Lei bold, Eddie Murphy or G4arence Row land who are now with or formerly were with the White Box?" Later Mr. Berger said these men might testify as to the character of the indicted players, render opinions as to the possibility of a game being thrown, or about the pennant win-
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial, defense attorneys claimed the indicted players were not highly paid, prompting the state to release official salary figures. The list showed salaries ranging from $3000 to $7250 per season for players including Gandil, Weaver, Jackson, Felsch, Cicotte, and Williams.
Arizona Republican · 8 July 1921 · page 6
Washington Street nlng drive of the White Sox at the close ot the 1919 series in which , a number of games were won by De troit. The fourth Juror to be chosen was Stephen Suben, a machinist. He is married and is 42 years old. The other Jurors sworn in with him fol low: Paul Luepcke, 38, "married, tele phone company employe. Herbert Jordan, stationary engineer, 41, married. 1 Joseph Vesley, 41, married, foreman of a motor company. Statements by defense attorneys during examination of prospective jurors In the baseball trial that the indicted White Sox players were not high salaried men, as had been sup posed, resulted in the state making public a list of salaries which in cluded figures as low as $3000 per season for some of the men and as high as S7250 for others.
See moreSee less
- The list, as given out by the state. follows: . Chick Gandil, I6S6.CS per month for the playing seasofi of six months in Charles Risberg. $3250 for the 11 season plus $183.76 for the extra time required for the world series. Buck Weaver, $7250 for 1919, plus $tl9rS6 for world series period. i Fred McMullin. $500 per month for season -of about six months, plus $149.94 for world series period. $S0 per month for 1920. Joe Jackson, $1000 per playing sea son month An 1919, plus $299.97 for world series period. Oscar Felsch. $714.50 per month in 1919, plus $214.38 for world series period. Given a bonus of $3000 after 1919 series and $1M00 per season contract for 1920. Claude Williams. $300 per month in 1919. plus a bonus of $375 In ac cordance with his contract, and an other bonus said to have been given voluntarily by Charles A. ComUkey.
During jury selection in the Chicago Black Sox trial, defense attorneys claimed the indicted players were not highly paid, prompting the state to release a list of actual salaries. Figures ranged from about $1,000 to $7,250 per season, including Gandil's monthly pay and Weaver's and Risberg's season totals plus World Series bonuses.
Pueblo Chieftain · 8 July 1921 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
PLAYERS DIDN'T GET BIG PAY SUPPOSED BALL TRIAL REVEALS
Chicago, Ill., July 7.—Statements by defense attorneys, during examination of prospective jurors in the baseball trial today, that the indicted White Sox players, were not high salaried men, as had been supposed, resulted in the state making public a list of salaries, which included figures as low as $3,000 per season for some of the men and as high as $7,250 for others.
See moreSee less
The list as given out by the state follows:
Chick, Gandil, $666.66 per month for the playing season of six months in 1919.
Charles Risberg, $3,250 for the 1919 season plus $195.76 for the extra time required for the world series.
Buck Weaver, $7,250 for 1919 plus $419.36 for world series period.
Fred McMullin, 500 per month for season of about six months plus $149.94 for world series period. $600 per month for 1920.
Joe Jackson, $1,000 per playing season month in 1919 plus $299.97 for world series period.
Oscar Felsch, $714.50 per month in 1919, plus, $214.38 for world series period. Given a bonus of $3,000 after 1919 series and $10,000 per season contract for 1920.
Claud Williams, $500 per month in 1919 plus a bonus of $375 in accordance with his contract and another bonus of $500 said to have been given voluntarily by Charles A. Comiskey.
Cnotract for 1920 season $6,000.
Edward Cicotte $952 per month in 1919, season plus, $3,000 bonus after 1919 series, plus $285.75 for series period.
The report lists detailed monthly salaries and bonuses paid to accused players Fred McMullin, Joe Jackson, Oscar Felsch, Claude Williams, and Eddie Cicotte for 1919 and 1920, including World Series bonuses. These figures appear to be financial evidence presented during the ongoing legal proceedings against the players.
Pueblo Chieftain · 8 July 1921 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
During the Black Sox trial, attorneys struggled to seat an impartial jury due to the scandal's wide publicity, with prospective jurors questioned about their knowledge of the 1917 World Series teams. In response to defense claims that the indicted players were not highly paid, the state released a detailed list of each player's salary and bonuses for 1919 and 1920.
Evening Star · 8 July 1921 · page 12
List of Their Salaries. "Statements by defense attorneys that the indicted White Sox players w?ra not high-salaried men resulted la the state making public a list of salaries. The list is as follows: Ghlek Gandil?$666 66 a month for ayingr season of six months in j 1&19. Not with club in 1920. Charles Risberj??$3,250 for the
The state released a detailed list of salaries and bonuses paid to the eight accused White Sox players in 1919 and 1920, including figures for Gandil, Risberg, Weaver, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Williams, and Cicotte. The list is followed by unrelated National League baseball game results.
Evening Star · 8 July 1921 · page 12
a month for 1920. Jos Jackson?$1,000 a playing season month In 1919. plus $299.97 for world series period; $S,000 for 1920 season. Oscar Felsch?$714.50 per month In 1$19, plus $214.39 for world series period. Given a bonus of $3,000 after
The report describes jurymen being accepted for the trial connected to the 1919 baseball scandal, noting defense attorney Berger's suggestion that the inquiry might extend further back to 1917 involving Detroit and White Sox players. It hints the trial could widen beyond the 1919 World Series fix to include earlier game-fixing allegations.
Evening Star · 8 July 1921 · page 12
SPEAKING, TRIAL HINTS
Athletics' tallies. The Timers defeated the White So: 13 to 8 and 9 to 6. Both games wei slugfests. The Cobbmen never wei headed after their four-run rally i the third inning of the first engage | ment. In the second contest, th White Sox tied the score in th seventh, but #the Tigers chased ove ir three markers in the ninth.
A fourth juror, Stephen Shuben, was selected for the trial of the indicted White Sox players, joining three others accepted the previous day. The defence revealed that stars like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins might be called to testify on behalf of the accused players.
The New York Herald · 8 July 1921 · page 10
Tlw? fourth tlirnr tn ha phmm* woo Itephen Shuben. a machinist, who testiled that he wan a White Sox fan but iet on Cincinnati in the 181$) aeries boause he thought the Reds were the beter team. He said he still was of that pinion. He is married and ia 4 2 years
This item reports ordinary American and National League game results from July 7, 1921, including a Yankees-Pirates box score and a Tigers-White Sox doubleheader. It contains no reference to the Black Sox scandal or related proceedings.
The New York Herald · 8 July 1921 · page 10
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
During the trial, the State publicized the full 1919 season salaries of the indicted White Sox players to counter defense claims that low pay motivated the fix. The report lists amounts paid to Cicotte, Weaver, Felsch, Jackson, Williams, Gandil, and Risberg, alongside implied gambling syndicate payments.
The New York Herald · 8 July 1921 · page 10
From Club in 191J Special Despatch to Tn CHICAGO. 111., July 7.?In refutatioi torneys for the defence In the bas players, that their salaries were n< the State to-day made public the cntir world's series moneys received by the pi total amount paid the seven players was Iri addition they are alleged to hav< gambling syndicate implicated in the se for the 1919 season : hows the amounts pa club:
As the Black Sox trial opens in Chicago, four jurors are seated and the defense announces it may call baseball stars like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins to testify about the players' character and the pennant drive. The report also notes salary figures and the $10,000 allegedly found under Eddie Cicotte's pillow.
New-York Tribune · 8 July 1921 · page 5
CHICAGO, July 7.? Sme of the great? est stars in baseball, including Ty Cobb, manager of the Detroit Ameri? cans; Eddie Collins, captain of the Chi? cago White Sox, and half a dozen other Detroit players may be called to testify in defense of th? White Sox players and others on trial charged with throw? ing the 1919 world series. This was made known by the defense to-day in accepting the first four jurors to be chosen for the trial. As Henry Berger, defense attorney, finished examining the fourth juror, hf asked if he knew any of the witnesses announced by toe ?t?te and then said: "Do yo-tf know Ty Cobb, Harry Heil mann, Veach, Younj, Bill James, Ower Bush, Howard Ehmke Oscar Stanage Deyer, Dauss or Mitchell, of the De troit club, or Eddie Collins, John Col lins, 'Red' Faber, Bird Lynn, Harr; Leibold, Eddie M-irphy or Clarenc Rowland, who are now with or formerly were with the White Sox?"
See moreSee less
Later Mr. Berger said these mei rjiight testify as to the character o the indicted players, render opinion a^ to the possibility of a game beini thrown or about the pennant winninj drive of the White Sox at the clos?, o the 1919 series in which a number o games were won from Detroit. Fans who believed the Sox players
The report lists potential character witnesses for the indicted White Sox players and details the actual salaries paid to the accused players in 1919 and 1920, noting they were lower than popularly believed. It specifies figures for Cicotte, Gandil, Risberg, Weaver, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, and Williams, including bonuses and alleged graft payments.
New-York Tribune · 8 July 1921 · page 5
they feel about it. were pulling down enormous salaries are discovering that the actual figures are considerably below the popular conception. Another illuminating fact is con? tained in the charge that seven of the fermer Sox players collected nearly $109,000 in graft and salary in 1919. Eddie Ciotte, who is charged with "discovering" $10,000 under his pillow, a little reminder from the gambUrs of what was expected of him, wa? Ccmiskey's highest salaried man. He was paid $952.50 a month for 19(9, with a $300 bonus for the season and his salary for 1920 was made $10,000.
See moreSee less
Others of the indicted plajers received salaries as follows: Chick Gandil, $666.60 a month for the 1919 season; Swede Risberg, $3,250 for the 1919 season; Buck Weaver, $7,250 for the season; McMullen, $50) a month for 1919 and $600 a month for 1920; Joe Jackson, $6,000 for 1919 and $8,000 for 1920; Happy Felsch, $714.50 a month for 1919, plus a bonus
Four jurors have been accepted for the trial of White Sox players charged with throwing the 1919 World Series. Defense attorney Henry Berger indicated stars like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins may testify regarding the players' character and the team's pennant drive.
The Pensacola Journal · 8 July 1921 · page 6
FOUR JURORS FOR WHITE SOX TRIAL
Bush, Howard Ehmke, Oscar Stanage. Deyer, Dauss or Mitchell of the Detroit club or Eddie Collins, John Collins, "Red" Faber, Bird Lynn, Harry Leibold, Eddie Murphy or Clarence Rowland, who are now with or formerly were with the White Sox?" Later .Mr. Berger said these men might testify as to the character of the indicted players, render opinions as to the possi bility of a game being thrown or about the pennant winning drive of the White Sox at the close of the 1919 series in which a number of games were won from Detroit.
See moreSee less
The fourth juror to be chosen was Stephen Shuben a machinist, who testi fied that he was a White Sox fan but bet on Cincinnati in the 1919 series be cause he thought the Reds were the bet ter team. He said he still was of that opinion.
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial, defense attorneys revealed that baseball stars including Ty Cobb, Eddie Collins, and several Detroit and White Sox players may be called to testify on behalf of the indicted players. Potential jurors were questioned about whether they knew these players, as testimony could address the defendants' character or the possibility of a thrown game.
Palatka Daily News · 8 July 1921 · page 1
(By Associated Prenn) Chicago, July 7. Some of the greatest 'stars in baseball including Ty Cobb, manager of the Detroit Americans, Eddie Collins, Captain of the Chicago White Sox and half a dozen other Detroit players may be called to testify in defense of White Sox players and others on trial here charged with throwing the 1919 world's series. This was made known by the defense today in accepting the first four jurors to be chosen for the trial. . PTl.ni.lk. HjiTirn .tjalaneil .Hrnnm hnished examining the' Tburth juror he asked if he knew any of the wit nesses announced by the state and, then said: ..nts- "Do you know Ty Cobb, Harry" Heilmann, Veach, Young, Bill James, Owen Bush, Howard Elomke, Oscar Stannagc, Deyer, Dauss or Mitchell, of the Detroit club, or Eddie Collins, John Collins, Red Faber, Bird Lynn, Harry Leibold, Eddie Murphy, or Clarence Rowland, who are now with or formerly were with the White Sox?"
See moreSee less
Later Mr. Berger said these men might testify as to the character of the indicted players, render opinions as to the possibility of a game being thrown, or about the pennant win ner drive of the White Sox at the close of the 1919 series in which a number of games were won from De troit. - -
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial, defense attorney Henry Berger asked prospective jurors if they knew numerous Detroit and Chicago White Sox players, including Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins. These players might be called to testify about the character of the indicted players and the feasibility of throwing a pennant-deciding game.
Paper unidentified · 8 July 1921 · page 7
White Sox players and others on basis. in accepting the first four jurors to be chosen for the trial. As Henry Berger, defense attor ney, finished examining the fourth
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial, defense attorneys indicated that baseball stars like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins might be called to testify about the character of the indicted players and the possibility of game-fixing. Four jurors were sworn in, and separately the defense revealed salary figures to counter claims that the accused players were underpaid.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 8 July 1921 · page 4
STARS MAY APPEAR IN PALS' DEFENSE
Sox?" Later Mr. Berger said these men might testify as to the character ot the indicted players, render opin ions as to the possibility , of a game being thrown or about the pennant winning drive of the White Sox at the close of the 1919 series in which a number of games were won by Detroit. The fourth juror to be chosen was Stephen Shuben. a machinist. Mb Is married and is 42 years old. The other Jurors sworn in with him follow: Paul Luepeke, 88, married, tele phone company employe. Herbert Jordan, stationary en gineer, 43, married. Joseph Vesely, 31, married, fore man for a motor company.
During jury selection in the Black Sox trial, defense attorneys argued the indicted players were not highly paid, prompting the state to release their actual 1919 salaries. New jurors including a machinist, telephone employee, engineer, and foreman were also sworn in.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 8 July 1921 · page 4
SOX GIVEN OUT (By The Amorlatrd PrM.) ntitnan-n Tnlv TStatements by defense attorneys during examina tion of prospective Jurors in the ho.oHoii trial tnrinv that the in dicted White Sox players were not high salaried m.n as naa Deen bup Dosed. resulted in the state making public a list of salaries which in cluded figures as low as 33,000 per season for some of the men and as high as $7,250 for others. The I st. as given out Dy xne state follows: Chick Gandil $666.66 per month for the playing teason of six months in 1919. Charter THshrrir S3 2R0 for the 1913 stanor plus $185.76 for tho extra time required lor me worm
During jury selection for the Chicago trial, defense attorney Henry Berger indicated stars like Ty Cobb and Eddie Collins might be called to testify about the indicted players' character and the 1919 series. The questioning of jurors revealed the scope of potential witnesses from both the Detroit and White Sox clubs.
Evening Public Ledger · 8 July 1921 · page 13
COBB AND COLLINS MAY BE CALLED
Hurry Lelbold. Eddie Murphy. Clarence Bowlnnd, who nre now with or formerly were with the White Sox?" Lnter Mr. Bcrger said these men might testify as to the character of the indicted playcrB, render opinions ns to the possibility of a gome being thrown or about the pennnnt-winning drive of tlie White Hox nt tlie close of the 1010 scries, in which a number of games wero won from Detroit.
During jury selection in Chicago for the Black Sox trial, defense attorney Henry Berger questioned potential jurors about their familiarity with star witnesses, naming Ty Cobb, Eddie Collins, and several other Detroit and White Sox players who might testify about the defendants' character or the 1919 World Series games. Four jurors were tentatively accepted, including machinist Stephen Shuboli, who said he had bet on Cincinnati in the Series.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 8 July 1921 · page 6
BLACK SOX STARS IN THE WITNESS STAND
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The state announces it will seek the maximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and five years' imprisonment for each convicted player, while jury selection proceeds slowly with only four jurors chosen. The defense plans to subpoena numerous players and officials, including Ray Schalk, Eddie Collins, and Urban Faber, to testify on behalf of the indicted White Sox players.
Evening Star · 9 July 1921 · page 18
SOX SCANDAL CASE
White Sox. CHICAGO. July 9.?The state antounced during: examination of prospective jurors yesterday in the base 8 tall trial that it would demand the naximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and Ive years' imprisonment for each
During jury selection in the Chicago trial, prosecutors announced they would seek the maximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and five years' imprisonment for each convicted player. Defense attorney Henry Berger countered by announcing plans to subpoena numerous ballplayers to testify that the White Sox played their best in the 1919 World Series.
New-York Tribune · 9 July 1921 · page 3
? Prison Terms Demanded For Indicted White Sox Prosecution Announces It Will Ask $2,000 Fine and Five Year Sentences CHICAGO, vJuly 8.?The state an? nounced during examination of pros?
Defense attorneys announced they will ask Judge Landis to compel attendance of World Series players and umpires at the Black Sox trial if subpoenas fail. Meanwhile, jury selection continues slowly, with only four jurors chosen so far.
Grand Forks Herald · 9 July 1921 · page 8
Players and Umpires. Chicago, July 9.—A possibility that the playing schedules of both the Na tional' and American leagues might be interrupted at the height of the sea son by the trial of the Indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers in the 1919 world series scandal' case, was seen today with the -announce ment by attorneys for the defense that Judge K. M. Landis, supreme arbiter of baseb^l, will be asked to
The defense announced it would ask Judge Landis to compel attendance of 1919 World Series players and umpires if subpoenas prove ineffective. Subpoenas were issued to numerous former and current White Sox players, with jury selection ongoing and only four jurors chosen so far.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 July 1921 · page 12
TRIAL OF INDICTED PLAYERS MAY HALT BIG LEAGUE PLAY
Chicago, July 0.—Possibility thu the playing: schedules of both major leagues might be interrupted by the trial of indicted White Sox players; and alleged gamblers, was seen to day with the announcement by the defense that Judge K. M. Landis, baseball arbiter, would be asked t » compel the attendance at the trial of players and umpires df the 191') world's aeries games, in case sub poenas are ineffective Subpoenas have been issued for the following; Ray Schalk, Sox ratchet: Byrd Lynn, and Joe Jenkins, now with Salt Lake City; William Glea son, Sox manager: I'rban Faber.
See moreSee less
Sox pitcher: HaVry Leibold Boston; Eddy Murphy and Erskine Mayer, Coluta bus; John Collins. Boston; Eddie Collins. Sox second-baseman; Harv. y McClellan, Sox infielder; Ted Jour dan. Salt I>ake City; Roy Wilkinson, Sox pitcher, and Dick Kerr, So v pitcher. Work of selecting a jury to tr/ the cases will be continued Monday. Only four jurymen having thus far been selected.
Defense attorneys for the indicted White Sox players say they will ask Judge Landis to compel players and umpires from the 1919 World Series to testify, potentially disrupting league schedules. Jury selection continues, with only four jurors chosen so far.
Pueblo Chieftain · 10 July 1921 · page 4
MAY STOP SCHEDULE FOR SCANDAL TRIAL
FOR SCANDAL TRIAL ‘■’hieigo. July 3.—A possibility that the playing schedules of both the Na : tional and American Leagues might ‘ be interrupted at the hoieht of the reason by the trial of the indicted 1 White Sox players and alleged gamb lers in the 1919 world series scandal case was see n today with the an -1 notincement by attorneys for the de r fense that Judge K. M Landl®, su * preme arbiter of baseball, will be asked to compel the attendance at the trial of the players and um -1 pires of the world’s series games in i which the alleged conspiracy to throw the fames functioned, in case subpoenas cannot force their attend f ance.
See moreSee less
« Such a step would summon prac tically every veteran on hnth the Chicaco and Cincinnati teams aHi several who have been transferred j from the.s-e teams to other clubs. Subpoenas also have been Issued 1 ■ for Byrd Lynn. Joe Jenkins and Ted I * Jourdan. now with Salt Lake City.
Chicago defeated New York 10 to 9 in a marathon 16-inning American League game, with Sheely's timely hitting and Hodge's pitching credited for the win. The report also notes other league results including Athletics over Indians and Browns over Senators.
Great Falls Tribune · 10 July 1921 · page 6
White Sox Victors in 16 Innings Over New Yorkers, 10-9 Sheely's Timely Batting and Hodge's Great Pitching Are Given Credit for Game. Chicago. July 9.—Sheely's timely batting and Hodge's great pitching en
The report describes the July 1921 trial preparations for the indicted White Sox players and gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal, noting that defense attorneys may ask Judge Landis to compel attendance of players and umpires via subpoena. Only four jurymen had been selected so far, with jury selection to continue Monday.
Great Falls Tribune · 10 July 1921 · page 6
World Series Players and Umpires. Chicago, July 9.—A possibility that the playing schedules of the major leagues might be interrupted by the trial of the indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers in the 1919 world series scandal case was seen Saturday with the announcement by attorneys for the defense that Judge K. M. Landis, supreme arbiter of base ball will be asked to compel the attend ance at the trial of the players and umpires of the world's series games in which the alleged conspiracy to throw the games functioned, in case subpoenas cannot force their attend ance.
See moreSee less
Such a step would summon practic ally every veteran on both the Chicago and Cincinnati teams and several who have been transferred from these teams to other clubs. Subpoenas also have been issued for the following: By« Lynn. Joe Jenkins and Ted Jourdan, now with Salt Lake City. Work of selecting a jury to try the cases will be continued Monday, onlv four jurymen having thus far been ae lected.
This editorial argues that baseball was ultimately strengthened, not permanently harmed, by the 1919 World Series scandal exposure. It notes the court's refusal to quash indictments against the implicated players, allowing the trials to proceed, and argues public odium already serves as sufficient deterrent regardless of the trial's outcome.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 11 July 1921 · page 2
- X. X. — — BASEBAND AIDED BY EXPOSURE. Although, as sporting writers ex press It, baseball got a "black eye” as a result pf the exposure of dishon esty in connection with the playine of the world’s series in Cincinnat’ and Chicago in 1919, the favorit* sport of Americans was not perma nently injured. Immediately follow ing the disclosures of crookedness there may have been a temporarj loss of confidence in some circles but the ingrained faith of all of us that the great mass of baseball play ers is composed of men of sterling character who are too upright tc betray the public and their mates anc ' employers was too strong to permii the game to remain long under £ cloud.
See moreSee less
Recently there has beer more concern lest the proceedingi against the players implicated mlgh prove futile as a result of a motior to quash the Indictments on teclini cal grounds. But this feature of thi case has now been obviated by thi
Seven former White Sox players, including Eddie Collins, Dick Kerr, and Ray Schalk, appeared in court in Chicago in connection with the 1919 World Series scandal, responding to subpoenas as witnesses. An attorney for some of the accused players objected to the testifying players leaving the city.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 11 July 1921 · page 2
INDICTED BALL PLAYERS I APPEAR IN OOITRTj i Chicago, July 11.—Seven former White Sox ball players, on trial here In connection with the 1919 world series, faced their former team mates in court today. The ^layers were in court in answer to subpoenas j issued to defense attorneys. Harry Berger, attorney for some of the accused players, told the court he was opposed to having the play ers, who wore here to testify, leave the city. Those in court today were Eddie Collins, Dick Kerr, Erban Faber, Ray Schalk, Roy Wilkinson, Harvey Mc Clellan and "Kid’’ Oleason; White Sox manager. .
Members of the 1921 Chicago White Sox team greeted and encouraged the indicted players from the 1919 World Series scandal before court resumed. Jury selection continued, with four jurors sworn and others being considered before Judge Hugo Friend.
The New York Herald · 12 July 1921 · page 8
0 Chicago. July 11.?The Indicted White ? Sox anrd tire loyal members of the fa:t mous 1919 world's series team fraternized < tor a few moments to-day before the " baseball conspiracy trlRl was resumed ' ? before Judge Hugo M. Friend. Among ' " ths White Sox who crowded the bleachI ers of the court were Eddie Collins. Dick 1
This report details a regular-season American League game between the New York Yankees and Chicago White Sox, highlighting home runs by Meusel and Ruth. It also briefly covers a Dodgers-Pirates game decided by a ninth-inning rally.
The New York Herald · 12 July 1921 · page 8
singled, and it looked like a bis Inning. Ward drove a wicked liner, which Collin* wickedly grabbed. Slchang hit into a double play, the third time in the game the Yank* were snuffed out that way. The White Sox also unearthed eomo hita in the fifth. Shecly opened with one, but on a hit and run play 8chalk missed the ball, and Schang threw Sheely out at Ward's corner. They had been priding out here that Ruth hadn't made a home run off a Chicago pitcher here thie year. The
Indicted Chicago White Sox players charged with throwing the 1919 World Series appeared in court alongside loyal teammates, with both groups mingling casually as jury selection proceeded slowly. Only two jurors had been tentatively accepted, bringing the total to six, though either could still be disqualified.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 12 July 1921 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
LOYAL WHITE SOX MINGLE WITH INDICTED PLAYERS
CHICAGO, July 11.—Members of the Chicago White Sox charged with throwing the 1919 world series to Cincinnati, and players said to have remained loyal to their club through the alleged sell-out fraternized in Judge Hugo Friend's court today, where the indicted men are on trial, and apparently the games of 1919 were forgotten in the realization of those of 1921. The players intermingled, shaking hands and slapping each other on the back. The only mention of the baseball scandal was when some of the men now on the team wished the others good luck in their trial.
See moreSee less
The present team members in court—Manager Kid Gleason, Dick Kerr, Urban Faber, Roy Wilkinson, Eddie Collins and Harvey McClellan—had been called as defense witnesses, but as the jury had not been chosen they were excused for the time.
Little progress was made in the selection of jurors. Two were accepted tentatively, bringing the total to six, but either of the two may be disqualified.
A third panel of one hundred prospective jurors was called in Chicago for the trial of indicted White Sox players and gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge Hugo Friend ordered jurors out of the courtroom during questioning to prevent them from learning excuses used by others to avoid service, and both sides promised surprises once the trial began.
New Britain Herald · 13 July 1921 · page 8
THIRD VENIRE CALLED Difficulty Experienced in Getting: Jury for Baseball fecandai Trial Chicago, July 13. The third venire of one hundred men has been ca.lled for today in an effort to obtain a jury to try the indicted White Sox plyers and alleged gamblers in connection with the 1919 world's series scandal. Prospective jurors were ordered out Tf the courtroom yesterday by Judge Hugo Friend so they could not hear he excuses of predecessors and learn reasons why they would not have to 3erve. This, however,, did not expedite natters and night sessions may be ordered. Each side yesterday promised a surprise when the trial gets under way.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
Chicago courts summoned a third panel of 100 potential jurors in an effort to seat a jury for the trial of indicted White Sox players and gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge Hugo Friend ordered prospective jurors out of the courtroom during questioning to prevent them from learning excuses used by earlier candidates to avoid service.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 13 July 1921 · page 1
Of 1 00 Men Chicago, July 13The third venire of 100 men has been called for to day in an effort to obtain a jury to try ttie indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers in connection with the 1919 world's series scan dais. Prospective jurors were ordered out of the courtroom yeaterday by Judge Hugo !Friend so they could not hear the excuses of predecessors and learn reasons why they would not have to serve. This, however, did not expedite matters and night sessions may be ordered. Each side yester day promised a. surprise when the trial gets under way
The first pool of 100 potential jurors was exhausted with only four jurors selected in the trial of the indicted White Sox players. Judge Hugo Friend warned both sides to speed up the process or face night sessions.
The New York Herald · 13 July 1921 · page 12
First Venire Exhausted. Chicago, July 12.?The first venire f of 100 men was exhausted to-day. with t only four Jurnrtt selected In the trial of the Indicted White Sox players and a
Only four jurors have been seated after the first venire of 100 men was exhausted in the trial of the indicted White Sox players, prompting a new venire to be summoned. Judge Hugo Friend warned both prosecution and defense that night sessions would be ordered if the pace did not improve.
New-York Tribune · 13 July 1921 · page 3
; Only 4 Jurors Obtained in Chicago White Sox Trial CHICAGO, July 12.?The first venire ? of 100 men was exhausted to-day, with ! only four jurors selected in the trial | of the indicted White Sox players, and
The first venire of 100 men was exhausted with only four jurors selected for the trial of the indicted White Sox players, prompting a new venire to be called. Judge Hugo Friend warned both state and defense he would order night sessions if the process did not speed up.
The Pensacola Journal · 13 July 1921 · page 6
PLAYERS INCOMPLETE (By The Associated Press) CHICAGO.,, July 12. The first venire of 100 men was exhausted today, with only four jurors selected In the trial of the indicted White Sox players, and a new venire was ordered into court to morrow when efforts to complete the jury ' will be resumed. The slowness with which the Jurors are being accepted led Judge Hugo Friend to warn both state and defense that unless more speed were shown he would order night session of court. , ,, ' "Greek offensive In Ushak sector" says a headline. Is the second word : an adjective or a noun?
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report tracks Babe Ruth's home run totals for 1921 against his record-setting 1920 season, noting he had hit 34 homers by mid-July including two against the Browns. It also mentions his recent homer off White Sox pitcher Kerr, the first against Chicago in over a year.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 July 1921 · page 11
BABE RUTH'S HOMERS EXCEED 1920 BY 7
White Sox game, on Monday, the first he had made against any White Sox pitcher since June, 1920, a matter of 13 months, seemed to serve as an impetus to the swatter. On his next trip to the plate in' Monday's game he hit a fly that would have been a homer in almost any other major league park. Then he went to St. Louis with the Yankees and yesterday made two circuit smashes off Davis, the Browns hurler. The White Sox pitchers all have ad mitted that they were trying to get through the season without letting the ball out of the lot. but after Monday's game Kerr had no excuse to offer cad did not attribute the homer to the "lively" ball.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A third venire of 100 prospective jurors was called in Chicago as the effort continued to seat a jury for the indicted White Sox players and gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal case. Judge Hugo Friend had jurors removed from the courtroom to prevent them from hearing other candidates' excuses for avoiding service.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 July 1921 · page 11
Call Third Venire in Effort to Get Ball Jury (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, July 13. The third ve nire of one hundred men has been called for today in an effort to obtain a jury to try the indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers in con nection with the 1919 world series scandal. Prospective jurors were ordered out of the courtroom yesterday by Judge Huge Friend, so they could not hear the excuses of predecessors and learn reasons why they would not have to serve. This however, did not expedite matters and night sessions may be ordered. Each side yesterday prom ised a surprise when th twot under"way. Oculists have found that a peculiar form of eye strain is due to persons reading while lying down.
After a full panel of 100 men was exhausted, only four jurors had been chosen for the trial of the indicted White Sox players. Judge Hugo Friend ordered a new venire and warned both sides he would call night sessions if the pace did not improve.
South Bend News-Times · 13 July 1921 · page 9
In Trial of 6 Black Sox By Associated Tresw: CHICAGO. July 12 The lirst verl iere of 100 nu n was exhausted Tues day with only four jurors elected in the trial of the indicted White Sox players and v. new veniere was or dered into court Wednesday when ef forts to complete the Jury will bo resumed. The slowness with which theJurors are being accepted led Judge Hugo Friend to warn both state and defenso that unles-'H mor& speed were thown he would order night sessions of court.
The New York Yankees ended a four-game losing skid against the White Sox, winning 2-0 in Chicago on home runs by Babe Ruth and Bob Meusel off Dickie Kerr. Red Faber's teammate Kerr held the Yankees' bats in check otherwise, but White Sox hitters were shut out by Yankees pitcher Collins for all nine innings.
South Bend News-Times · 13 July 1921 · page 9
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
In Chicago, the first venire of 100 potential jurors was exhausted with only four jurors selected for the trial of the indicted White Sox players. Judge Hugo Friend warned both sides to speed up the process or he would order night court sessions.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 July 1921 · page 1
From First Venire to Try Sox Players Chicago, July 12—The first venire of 100 men was exhausted today with only four jurors selected in the trial of the indicted White Sox players and a n< w venire was ordered into court tomorrow when efforts to complete the jury will be resumed. The slow ness with which the jurors are being accepted led Judge Hugo Friend to warn both state and defense that un less more speed were shown he would order night sessions of court.
A third venire of one hundred men was called to help select a jury for the trial of the indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge Hugo Friend ordered prospective jurors out of the courtroom during questioning to prevent them from hearing excuses given by others, though this slowed proceedings and night sessions may be needed.
Grand Forks Herald · 13 July 1921 · page 2
MORE MEN CALLED TO BE EXAMINED FOR JURY IN BALL CASE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Four more jurors were chosen, bringing the total to eight, in the trial of former White Sox players and gamblers indicted for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series. A defense motion revealed that witnesses William Burns and Joe Gedeon were being held in the custody of state's attorneys.
Evening Star · 14 July 1921 · page 31
FOR WHITE SOX TRIAL CIttC AGCW July 14.?Four more jurors. makiifl? eight in all. to hear the ?ase of former White Sox ball players rain). and gamblers indicted on a charge of conspiracy to fix the 1919 world series, have been chosen. A motion by the defense to compel the state to produce two witnesses. William Burns, former hall player, and Joe Gedeon. former second baseman of the St. Louis Americans, disclosed that they were virtually in custody of the state's attorneys.
A third venire of one hundred men was called in Chicago to find jurors for the trial of the indicted White Sox players and alleged gamblers connected to the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge Hugo Friend ordered prospective jurors out of the courtroom so they could not hear the excuses given by others seeking to avoid service.
The Pensacola Journal · 14 July 1921 · page 2
JURY NOT YET OBTAINED CHICAGO, July 13 The third ventre of one hundred men has been called for today in an effort to obtain a jury to try the indicted White Sox players and al leged gamblers in connection with the 1919 world's series scandal. Prospective jurors were ordered out of the courtroom yesterday .by Judge Hjgo Friend so they could not hear, the ex cuses of predecessors and learn reasons why they would not have to serve. ;
After more than two weeks and roughly 600 veniremen questioned, a twelve-person jury was finally sworn in for the trial of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for conspiracy. The defense plans pretrial motions to exclude the players' grand jury confessions and to dismiss two of the indictment counts.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 July 1921 · page 11
Opr ding Monday G. E, Gorman, assistant state's at torney, in charge of the prosecution, will make the opening statement for the state Monday. Prior to his ad dress to the jurors, however, the de fense plans to move that the baseball | grand jury statements of Eddie Ci cotte, Claud Williams and Joe Jack son, indicted White Sox players, be 1 barred from the trial and that no reference to them be permitted in the state’s opening statement. The defense will contend that the evidence given the grand jury by these men cannot be used even against themselves although they signed immunity waivers before testi fying.
See moreSee less
In these statements the three players confessed to receiving money to throw games. « Another motion planned by the de fense is for dismissal of the last two counts in the indictments. These indictments charge conspiracy to de fraud Ray* Schalk, White Sox catcher, out of about $1,700, the difference be tween the winners and losers share In the series money, and to injure and defraud th® Chicago American league baseball club. The defense will contend that there is no law covering such charges.
The jury to decide the fate of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for conspiracy in the 1919 World Series fix was completed, with the trial set to begin Monday. The defense plans to challenge the use of players' grand jury confessions and to dismiss certain conspiracy counts.
Arizona Republican · 16 July 1921 · page 1
JURY TO TRY SOX COMPLETE
Another motion planned by the deJ fense is for dismissal of the last two counts In the indictments, inese in dictments charga conspiracy to de fraud Ray' Schalk. White Sox catcher, out; of about $1,700, the difference
The twelve-member jury for the Chicago White Sox conspiracy trial was finalized after more than two weeks of selection from nearly 600 candidates, with the actual trial set to begin Monday. Defense attorneys plan to move for exclusion of grand jury confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, and to dismiss two counts of the indictment related to defrauding catcher Ray Schalk and the Chicago American League club.
die Clccot*. Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, indicted Whit? Sox player* he barred from the trial and that no reference to them be permitted in the state's opening statement The de fine* will contend that the evidence given the grand Jury by these iVi-n can not he used ev*n against themselves, altho they signed Immunity waivers be fore testifying In then* statem-nts the threw players confewed to receiving money to throw game# and Cicotte admitted that he deliberately hit Rath, the first man up In the first game* according to state officials. Another motion planned by the de fense Is for dismissal of the last two counts in the Indictment* These in dictments charg conspiracy to defraud Ray Sohalk White Sox catcher o«t of about $1,700 the difference between the
The jury to try seven former White Sox players and four gamblers in the 1919 World Series scandal has been selected after nearly two weeks of examining veniremen. The defense plans to argue that Judge Landis's presence might improperly influence the jury and also seeks to exclude grand jury testimony and dismiss some indictment counts.
New Britain Herald · 16 July 1921 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
WOULD BAR LANDIS FROM SCANDAL TRIAL Defense Claims His Presence Might Influence Jury
Chicago, July 16.—The jury to try seven former White Sox players and four alleged gamblers accused in the 1919 world's series scandal is complete. Nearly two weeks was occupied in examining almost 600 veniremen. Judge Friend adjourned court until Monday.
See moreSee less
It was intimated today that Attorney Henry A. Berger of the defense will attemp to show at the trial next week that the ill feeling existing between Ban Johnson, president of the American league, and Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, was one of the motives behind the prosecution.
A lively tilt is expected between attorneys for the prosecution and the defense when the latter endeavor o have Judge K. M. Landis, baseball arbiter, barred from the courtroom because of the possible influence on the jury.
Prominent Witnesses.
Among the prominent witnesses who, it is said, will bo in court Monday are George M. Cohan, John J. McGraw, Charles A. Comiskey, Ban Johnson, Kid Gleason, the loyal White Sox and the entire Cincinnati Red team. The trial will last three to four weeks, according to Prosecutor George E. Gorman.
The defense plans to move that the grand jury statements of Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, indicted White Sox players, be barred from the trial and that no reference to them be permitted in the state's opening satement. The defense will contend that the evidence given the grand jury by these men cannot be used even against themselves, although they signed immunity waivers before testifying.
Another motion planned by the defense is for dismissal of the last two counts in the indictments. These indictments charge conspiracy to defraud Ray Schalk, White Sox catcher, out of about $1,700, the difference between the winners' and losers' share in the series money and to injure and defraud the Chicago American league baseball club.
No Fans On Jury.
The jury chosen for the world's series trial is made up of two clerks, two machinists, a telephone repair man, a stationary engineer, the foreman of a motor company, a steel worker, a salesman, a florist, a hydraulic press operator and the foreman of a stock yards rendering plant.
All but two are married and their ages range from 30 to 47.
All said they understood baseball and occasionally saw major league games, but none has ever played semi-pro or pro baseball and none is a student of the game or of the "fan" type.
After more than two weeks and roughly 600 potential jurors questioned, the jury to decide the fate of the Chicago White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series has been finalized, with trial set to begin Monday. The defense plans to challenge the admissibility of grand jury confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson despite their signed immunity waivers.
Imperial Valley Press · 16 July 1921 · page 1
World's Series. (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, July 16—The jury which will decide the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges in connection with the alleged throw ing of the 1919 world series, hasdieen completed and the actual trial of the men will begin Monday. The final panel of four jurors was sworn in late today amid cheering from spectators and veniremen of the kind which generally greets a ninth inning rally by the home team. More than two weeks had been tak en up in selecting the 12 jurors.
See moreSee less
Approximately COO persons were questioned by state and defense at torneys. The defense plans to move that the baseball grand jury statements of Edward C. Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, indicted White Sox players, be barred from the trial and that no reference to them be permitted in the state’s opening statement. The defense will contend tha the evidence given the grand jury by these men cannot be used, even against them selves, although they signed immunity waivers before testifying! In these statements the three ball players con fessed to receiving money to “throw” games, and Cicotte admitted that he deliberately hit Rath, the first man up in first game, according t# state officials. The jury is made up of two clerks, two machinists, a telephone repair man, a stationary engineer, a steel worker, a salesman, a florist, a hy draulic press operator and the fore man of a stockyards rendering plant. All but two are married and their ages range from JO to 47. All said they understood baseball and occasionally saw major league games, but none has ever played semi-professional base ball and none is a student of the game or of the “fan” type.
The twelve-member jury that will decide the guilt or innocence of the indicted Chicago White Sox players has been completed after more than two weeks of selection, during which about six hundred people were questioned. Assistant state attorney George E. Gorman will give the prosecution's opening statement on Monday.
Evening Star · 16 July 1921 · page 7
BASE BALL TRIAL JURY HAS BEEN COMPLETED
HAS BEEN COMPLETEI CHICAGO. July IS.?The Jury w?U? ill decide the guilt or innocence < >e Chicago White Sox players an there indicted oh conspiracy charg< l connection with the alleged thro* ig of the 1919 world series has bee jmpleted. More than two weeks had bee iken up in selecting the twelr irors. Approximately six hundrc eraons were questioned. George E. Gorman, assistant state ttorney in charge of the prosecutio ill make the opening statement ft le state Monday.
Dick Kerr pitched Chicago to an 11-inning 3-2 win over Washington, aided by a triple play started by Earl Sheely. The box score and game details are reported in full.
The New York Herald · 16 July 1921 · page 8
Triple Play Feature of Victory by White Sox Kerr Wins Eleven Inning Game From Senators. Chicago, July 15 (American).?Dick Kerr won his first extra inning game
After nearly two weeks examining almost 600 veniremen, the jury to try seven former White Sox players and alleged gamblers was completed. Defence plans to argue Ban Johnson–Comiskey animosity motivated prosecution, and will seek to bar Judge Landis's influence on jurors.
The New York Herald · 16 July 1921 · page 8
four nlloirofi mmhlera accused in the 3 919 world's series scandal wax completed to-day. Nearly two wockx was occupied In examining almost 600 veniremen. Judge Friend adjourned court until Monday. It was Intimated to-day that Attorney Henry A. Berger of the defence will attempt to show at the trial next week that the ill feeling existing between Ban Johnson, president of the American League, and Charles A. Comlskey, ownei of tl)e White Sox, was one of the motives behind the prosecution.
A Chicago report describes the jury chosen for the World Series fraud trial, noting none were serious baseball fans or had played professional ball. It also previews upcoming courtroom motions by the defense to exclude grand jury testimony from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, and lists prominent witnesses expected to testify.
The New York Herald · 16 July 1921 · page 8
| "fan" type. 'v J from the courtroom because of the possible influence on the jury. Among the prominent witnesses who, it is said, will be in court Monday are George M. Cohan, John J. McGraw, Charles A. Comlskey, Han Johnson, Kid Glenson, the loyal White Sox and the entire Cincinnati Red team. 'Idle trial will last three to four weeks, according to Prosecutor George E. Gorman.
After more than two weeks and questioning of about 600 potential jurors, the panel of twelve was completed for the Black Sox conspiracy trial. The defense plans to move to bar the grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams from being used at trial, and to dismiss two of the indictment counts.
New-York Tribune · 16 July 1921 · page 13
SERIES FIXING JURY COMPLETE; 12 MEN CHOSEN FROM 600
Cicotte, Jackson and Wil? liams Before Grand Jury CHICAGO, July J5.-~The jury which will decide the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges in connection with the alleged throw? ing of the 1919 world series was com? pleted to-day. The final panel of four jurors was sworn amid cheering from spectators and veniremen of the kind which gen? erally greets a ninth inning rally by the home team. More than two weeks had been taken up in selecting the twelve jurors. Approximately 600 per?
See moreSee less
sons were questioned. George E. Gorman, Assistant State's Attorney in charge of tho prosecution, will make the opening statement for the state Monday. Prior to his ad? dress to the jurors, however, the de? fense plans to move that the baseball grand jury statements of Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, in? dicted White Sox players, be barred from the trial and that rto reference to them be permitted in the state's opening statement. Tho defense will contend that the evidence given the grand jury by these men cannot be used even against them? selves, although they signed immunity waivers before testifying. In these statements 4fhe three players confessed to receiving money to throw games. Another motion planned by the de? fense is for dismissal of the last two counts in the indictments. These in? dictments charge conspiracy to defraud Ray Schalk, White Sox catcher, out of about $1,700, the difference between the
The jury that will decide the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges related to the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series was completed. More than two weeks and about 600 people questioned were needed to select the twelve jurors.
The Pensacola Journal · 16 July 1921 · page 1
IS NOW SECUREb (By the Associated Press) CHJCAGOi-July 15. The Jury which will decide the guilt or innocense of the Chicago "White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges in connection .with the alleged throw ing of the 1919 world series was com pleted today. The final panel of four jurors was shown .in. late today amid cheering from spectators and veniremen of the kind which generally greets a ninth Inning rally bythe home team. More than two weeks had been taken up in selecting the twelve jurors. Approxi mately 600 persons were questioned.
A twelve-person jury was finally sworn in Chicago on July 15 to hear the conspiracy case against the indicted White Sox players, after more than two weeks and some 600 potential jurors questioned. The defense plans to challenge the admissibility of Grand Jury confession statements from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson before the prosecution's opening statement on Monday.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 July 1921 · page 5
Complete Jury to Hear Case of Accused Ball Players Chicago, Julv 15.—The jury will decide the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy char ges in connection with the alleged throwing of the 1019 world series was completed today. The final panel of four jurors was sworn in late today amid cheering from spectators and veniremen of the kind which generally greets a ninth inning rally by the home team. More than two weeks had been tai kc-o up in selecting the twelve jur i ors.
See moreSee less
Approximately six hundred persons were questioned. George K. Gorman, assistant state's attorney in charge of the prosecu tion, will make the opening state ment for the state Monday. Prior to this, however, the defense plans to move that the baseball Grand Jury statements of Eddie Cicotte, t'laude Williams, and Joe Jackson, indicted White Sox players, be bar red from the trial and that no ref erence to them be permitted in the state’s opening statement. The defense will contend that the evidence given the Grand Jury by these men cannot be used even against themselves, although they signed Immunity waivers before tes tifying. In these statements the three players confessed to receiving money to throw games.
The jury for the Chicago White Sox conspiracy trial was completed Friday after questioning about 600 persons over two weeks, with spectators cheering the selection of the twelfth juror. Prosecutor George Gorman will open Monday, while the defense plans to seek exclusion of grand jury confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson.
Great Falls Tribune · 16 July 1921 · page 8
Final Panel Sworn In Amid Cheers Like Those Attending Ninth Inning Rally
12 jurors. 600 Are Questioned. Approximately 600 persons were questioned by state and defense attor neys, and those in court did not hesi tate to express their satisfaction when the twelfth man was chosen. George E. Gorman, assistant state's attorney in charge of the prosecution, will make the opening statement for the state Monday. Prior to his ad dress to the jurors, however, the de fense plans to move that the grand jury statement of Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams and-Joe Jackson, in dicted erstwhile Sox players, be barred from the trial and that no reference to them be permitted in the state's opening statement.
The jury to decide guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted for conspiracy in the 1919 World Series fix has been completed after more than two weeks of selection. The defense plans to move to bar the Grand Jury confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson from the trial, arguing their immunity waivers should not permit use against them.
The Evening World · 16 July 1921 · page 8
Jury at Last Picked to Umpire Baseball Scandal
Baseball Scandal CHICAGO, July 10. The jury which will decide tho ffullt or Innocence of the Chicago White Sox play ers and others indicted on conspiracy
After two weeks of questioning nearly 600 prospective jurors, a jury was completed to try seven former White Sox players and four alleged gamblers over the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge Hugo Friend had pressured attorneys to finish selection, and the completed panel's seating was greeted with cheers from jurors who had been sequestered for over a week.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 July 1921 · page 9
Chicago Complete CHICAGO—After two weeks of ex amination, during which nearly 600 men were questioned, a jury to try the seven former White Sox players and four alleged gamblers indicted in connection with the 1919 world’s series scandal was completed yester day. Attorneys for the state and the defense will go to bat before Judge
Assistant State's Attorney George Gorman says bettors who lost money on the 1919 Series, including Cohan, will testify when the trial resumes Monday. The state also plans to introduce the repudiated confessions of Williams, Jackson and Cicotte despite defense objections.
Evening Star · 17 July 1921 · page 22
MILLIONS LOST
Besnmed Monday. CHICAGO, July 16.?Fans who lout money betting1 on the White Sox In the 1919 world's series with Cincinnati will be among the first witnesses called when the base ball trial gets
At the Chicago conspiracy trial, Judge Hugo Friend ruled that State's Attorney Gorman could not tell jurors that three of the accused players had made confessions. Friend did allow Gorman to use the contents of the confessions by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, but barred any reference to the fact that confessions existed.
Paper unidentified · 18 July 1921 · page 1
(United Press) Court House, Chicago, Ill., July 18. —Chicago “Black Sox" got to first base today when they made the in itial hit in their trial. Umpire Hugo Friend, criminal court judge, ruled that State's At torney Gorman must not mention that three of -the "Black Sox" made confessions during his opening state ment to the twelve score keepers in the jury bleachers. This followed arguments by At torney James C. "Ropes" O'Brien and other pinch hitters for the seven former White Sox stars charged with conspiracy to throw the 1919 world series with the Cincinnati Reds.
See moreSee less
Umpire Friend gave Gorman per mission to mention everything in the confession of Eddie Cicotte, Wil liams and Jackson, but forbade him to let the score keepers know con-i fessions had been made. |
The White Sox swept a doubleheader from the Red Sox by one-run margins, with Kerr and Hodge pitching, despite the recent loss of several star players. The report briefly notes the team coping without its banned athletes amid other day's baseball results.
Evening Star · 19 July 1921 · page 23
HARRIS' STREAK ENDED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The trial of seven White Sox players and four gamblers charged in the 1919 World Series fix entered its second day in Chicago after a tense first day of altercations. Bill Burns, an indicted White Sox pitcher, was turning state's evidence and expected to give revealing testimony.
Evening Star · 19 July 1921 · page 23
SOME TELLIN EXPECTED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
On the second day of the Black Sox trial, secretary Harry Grabiner testified that the accused players were paid by the White Sox during the 1919 World Series, countering defense claims they weren't under contract. Prosecutor George Gorman outlined the state's case, recounting the alleged bribery scheme involving Cicotte, Jackson, Williams and gamblers, and previewed testimony expected from state witness Joe Gedeon.
Evening Star · 19 July 1921 · page 23
While yesterday's session produced , - plenty of excitement, it brought little i in the way of evidence. George Gor^ man, assistant state's attorney, outlined I ^ the state's case, telling the jury that | ] - Burns met Eddie Cicotte, White Sox ] pitcher, in New York and suggested , e that the series be thrown. , < He then went through with the oft- , j ~ repeated story of how Cicotte and the j seven other indicted players were al" leged to have discussed the matter and t it was finally agreed to throw the series. i ? He repeated the stories told at the . time of the grand jury investigation that ^ Cicotte received $10,000 and Jackson and ~ Williams $5,000 each.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
The conspiracy trial of seven former White Sox players and four gamblers entered its second day, with Bill Burns expected to testify after turning state's evidence. A surprise witness, Phillies manager Wild Bill Donovan, also appeared, while club secretary Harry Grabiner testified about the players' contracts.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 19 July 1921 · page 1
PLAYER WHO TURNED STATE'S EVIDENCE EXPECTED TO TESTIFY TODAY
IFY TODAY. Chicago, July 19.—After the first day filled with legal arguments anq alter cations, the trial of -seven former Whit 2 Sox players and four alleged .Z2amblers charged with conspiracy in connection with the 1919 world series, today enterad the. second. inning with every indication that the excitement of yesterday as the taking of testimo ny got under way would be continued today. Bill Burns, indicted White Sox play er who gained immunity by turning state’s evidence, was expected to take the stand during the day., : That the gtate had a surprise wit ness was learned today when “Wild Bill” Donovan, manager of the Phila delphia Nationals, appeareq in the wit ness room.
See moreSee less
Asisstant State’s Attor ney Turrell said Donovan would testi fy to .information of an alleged con spiracy which he obtainad from Bill Burns, former White Sox pitcher.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Kid Gleason and Harry Grabiner testified for the prosecution, describing the contracts between the indicted players and the club to support the claim they were bound during the 1919 World Series. Cross-examination failed to shake their testimony, though no contract clause specifically mentioned the World Series; Bill Burns was expected to testify next.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 19 July 1921 · page 10
IN BASEBALL TRIAL (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, July 19. William "Kid" Gleason, and Harry Grabiner, manager and secretary, respectively, lot the Chicago White Sox, testified for the state today in the baseball trial, tell ing of the contract between indicted players and the club." Their testimony was designated to prove the prosecution's contention that the men were under contract to the club during the world's series. Both men said the players were under contract in the series and cross examination by the defense failed to shake their testimony, although they ; could not point out any clause in the contracts which were admitted as evi dence specifically mentioning the world's series.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
White Sox manager Kid Gleason and secretary Harry Grabiner testified for the prosecution that the indicted players were under contract during the 1919 World Series, not just the regular season. Cross-examination by the defense failed to shake their testimony, though players joked among themselves using baseball metaphors during the proceedings.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 19 July 1921 · page 1
GLEASON TAKES STAND IN TRIAL OF "BLACK SOX"
Contracts Held for World's Series. Both men said the players were under contract in the series and cross-examination by the defense failed to shake their testimony, al though they could not point out any .clause in the contracts which were admitted as evidence specifically mentioning the world's series. Testimony of the two White Sox officials brought some interesting side play among the players on trial. As Grabiner recited details of the contract which seemed to favor the prosecution, the players remarked in an undertone. "There's a Double." "There's a double," or "He hit that one on the nose."
See moreSee less
But when the secretary told of a bonus Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, one of the defendants remarked: "Oh, Boy! Boy! A triple with two on." "But there aren't any home runs yet," said Cicotte, and as Grabiner became a little confused by the questioning, "Happy" Felsch whis pered, "He lost that one in the sun." Grabiner TJoots One.'' "Lost it, nothing," Joe Jackson said. "He just booted it," Court adjourned for luncheon, with Taylor Spink, official scorer of the J919 world's series, sched uled for the afternoon session. Bill Donovan, manager of the Philadelphia Nationals, who is un derstood to have been told of the alleged conspiracy by Bill Burns, was expected to follow Spink, with Burns then coming on the stand.
Bill Burns, a former pitcher turned state's witness, gave his firsthand account of the alleged conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series. Chicago White Sox manager Kid Gleason and secretary Harry Grabiner also testified about player contracts, supporting the prosecution's claim that players were under contract during the series itself.
The Bismarck Tribune · 19 July 1921 · page 1
BURNS TESTIFIES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Harry M. Grabiner, secretary of the Chicago American League Baseball club, was the first witness called when the trial of the alleged 1919 World Series conspirators began. The report (garbled with unrelated racing and baseball news) notes an indicted conspirator agreed to turn state's evidence.
Grand Forks Herald · 19 July 1921 · page 10
was hardly in condition for great speed. The second event, a five mile class story of the alleged conspiracy to race went .to Haughdahl in his Peer-| throw the '1919 world's series. Burns lew.' The little Norwegian daredevil was indicted as one of the conspira-! covered, the five mile3 in 6 minutes tors but agreed to turn state's eviand 15 seconds. Alien was a close second in his Maxwell, while Cobb, White Sox today to tell hi3 first hand dence.
The conspiracy trial against White Sox players resumed with Harry Grabiner, secretary of the Chicago American League club, called as the first witness. Bill Burns, an indicted player turned state's evidence, was expected to testify against the other defendants, with Ban Johnson also slated to address technical aspects of the alleged fix.
Grand Forks Herald · 19 July 1921 · page 10
Chicago. July 19.—Harry M. Grab iner, secretary of the Chicago Ameristate resumed presentation of evi7, dence in the trial of White Sox play ers and others charged with' conspir acy to throw the 1919 world's series fiUed wi®h lega'l arguments an^alfe^-- cations, the trial of seven former Chicago White Sox players ,and four alleged gamblers charged with con spiring to throw the 1919 world's se ries today entered its second Inning with every indication that the' ex citement which yesterday transformed the court room Into, a veritable bleachers would be continued today.
Former major league pitcher Bill Burns appeared in court to give firsthand testimony in the trial of seven indicted former Chicago White Sox players. High officials and legal arguments were expected as excitement continued in the proceedings.
Grand Forks Herald · 19 July 1921 · page 10
EXCITEMENT CONTINUES IN BASEBALL TRIAL
Sox Win Two. Chicago, July 18.—Chicago took both games of a doubleheader from Boston today, winning the first five to four in ten innings, and the second, 4 to 3. Erratic playing gave the visitors an early Ipad in the initial contest and the locals were compelled to play an uphill game, the winning run coming in the tenth inning when Pitcher Jones walked McCellan, forcing the winning tally. Hodge pitched in great form in the second game. A ninth Inning batting rally by the White Sox gave them the victory. Scores: First gaihe— R. H. E.
At the Black Sox trial in Chicago, White Sox secretary Harry Grabiner testified that the accused players were paid for the 1919 World Series as part of their regular season employment. Prosecutors announced that Bill Burns, an indicted player turned state's evidence, and AL president Ban Johnson were expected to testify next about the alleged conspiracy.
Evening Public Ledger · 19 July 1921 · page 17
BURNS TO RELATE
game. (Jrablner testified tlint the White Sox plajers were pnld for their work In the 1010' world's M'ries by tho Chicago club and were employed for the series period a: well as the regular season. rue plajrrs pay in the series wn. ut Un tie .name rate us In the regnlaspnson snid This testimony wa' introduced by the State to counteract the contention of the defense that the men were not under contract to the club during the serlesJI The Mate s case While Jcstcrday'H Mission produced lots of excitement, it brought little in the way of evidence.
See moreSee less
Ucorge pormnn, As sistant State's Attorney In charge of the prosecution, outlined the State s cope, telling the jury that Hill llurns met Eddie Cicotte. White Sov pitcher, in New York and suggested that the
The Black Sox conspiracy trial resumed with Grabiner testifying that players were paid under contract during the Series, and prosecutor George Gorman outlining the State's case involving Bill Burns, Eddie Cicotte, and Arnold Rothstein. Charles Comiskey clashed angrily with defense counsel during cross-examination, while Judge Friend ruled the State could not mention Cicotte's grand jury confession in its opening statement.
Former major league pitcher Bill Burns took the stand to give a first-hand account of the alleged conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series. He testified after White Sox manager William Gleason and secretary Harry Grabiner.
The Laramie Republican · 19 July 1921 · page 1
Stand in Hearing on World Series Rumpus (By Ataoclated Pre**.) Chicago, July 19. —Bill Burns, a (or mer major league pitcher, took the stand today, at the trial of the indicted White Sox players, to tell first-hand the story of the alleged conspiracy to "throw” the 1919 world series. He Joi lowed William Gleason and Harry G rub In ger. the manager and secretary ‘ of the White Bae.?. - 1 * ‘ ’
Bill Burns, testifying for the prosecution in the Black Sox trial, described how players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but turned on the gamblers when the bribe money wasn't fully paid. He said the players decided before Game 3 to double-cross the gamblers by playing to win, which they did, taking that game 3-0.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Imperial Valley Press · 20 July 1921 · page 1
DOUBLE CROSS WAS USED BY BOTH SIDES
Cicotte who said lie would lose bis game if he had to throw the ball over the fence. Attell and Bennett, identified yester day as David Zelser of Des Moines, one of the defendants, were the lead ers of the alleged gamblers, and Chick Gandil of the players, according to Burns. Burns said Attell refuse! to pay $20,000 promised the players after each game. He persuaded Attell to give him SIO,OOO after the second game, which sum he passed on to Gandil for distribution he said.
The report lists various American League game outcomes, including Boston's 1-0 win over the White Sox and other close contests decided by one run. It also includes player statistics, injury updates, and minor league announcements unrelated to the Black Sox scandal.
Evening Star · 20 July 1921 · page 24
GAMES IN A. L. CLOSE
There was nothing wrong with the hurling of either. Mulligan's work at bat and at third for the White Sox was a feature. Babe Ruth blossomed forth yesterday as a base runner, reports of the victory of his team over Detroit
Bill Burns, testifying as the state's star witness in the Black Sox trial, described meetings in Cincinnati hotels where gamblers including Attell and Rothstein organized bets and payments to players. He named Cicotte and Williams as agreeing to throw games, and detailed conversations about money being distributed among the conspirators.
Evening Star · 20 July 1921 · page 24
STAR WITNESS TESTIFIES OF FRAME-UP
I that Eddie Cicotte said he would , throw the first grame if he had to throw the ball over the fence, as! serted Claude Williams. White Sox I southpaw, agreed to throw the sec1 ond game of the series, and named Arnold Rothstoin of New York, Abe
Gambler Bill Burns testified about hotel meetings with Abe Attell and other gamblers during the 1919 World Series, describing cash handoffs to Gandil and the players' scheme. He recounted how the players, feeling double-crossed by the gamblers, won the third game 3-0 behind Dick Kerr instead of throwing it as planned.
Evening Star · 20 July 1921 · page 24
"When you were in room 708 of the Hotel Sinton the day of the seconu game what happened?" asked Gorman. "Attell and several others were Vifrn " anouorO/1 Rlimo "AftAll Rothstein had $200,000 to bet on the series, but it was hard to get bets down and he did not want to give me any money. I insisted on at least $10,000. Attell showed me piles of money under a mattress. Forty-six thousand dollars was due the players then. Attell, in talking of Rothstein, said Rothstein had a private wire from New York to Cincinnati and
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
At the Chicago trial, gambler accomplice Bill Burns testified that the indicted White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but grew angry when the bribe money wasn't paid, deciding before the third game to play to win. An attempt to get Burns to describe a New York conversation with Eddie Cicotte was blocked by the judge on defense objection.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 20 July 1921 · page 1
BEST. Chicago, July 20.—Thp indicted Chicago White Sox players agreeing with a clique of gamblers to throw the 1919 world sories to Cincinnati for a hundred thousand became sick of the deal when they were not paid th: bribes promised and at a meeting be fore the third game cdacided to play their best® to win the series, Bill Burns, accomplice in tha alleged deal, testified today in the baseball trial. He was the state’s witness, Attempts to have Burns tell of a conversation with Eddie Cicotte in New York, where th'e state claims the alleged conspiracy was formed, failed when Judge Friend sustained the de fens'a objection.
Bill Burns continued his trial testimony describing how gamblers bought the 1919 World Series, with Eddie Cicotte allegedly offering himself for sale and agreeing to lose games. Burns recounted how manager Kid Gleason's decision to start Dickie Kerr instead of Cicotte in Game 3 disrupted the fix, costing gamblers money and sparking accusations of double-crossing.
Indiana Daily Times · 20 July 1921 · page 8
DOUBLE-CROSSING GAME
STAR PITCHER WAS “FOR SALE.” They heard the allegation that Eddie Clcotte ran around New York wiji a “for sale" tag on the world's series and how gamblers made the purchase with a promise of SIOO,OOO. He recounted how ‘‘Kid” Gleason, the venerable White Sox manager, interferred with the “fixed" series when little Hick Kerr was put in the pitcher s box In the third world series game instead of Eddie Clcotte. Cicotte had agreed to lose the game. Burns testified, and the gamblers, led by
Eddie Burns testified at the Black Sox trial about how the 1919 World Series games were fixed, describing payments from gamblers led by Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein to players including Cicotte and Gandil. He detailed a $10,000 payoff hidden under a mattress and player suspicions of being double-crossed by the gamblers.
Indiana Daily Times · 20 July 1921 · page 8
Attornevs for the State were jubilant todav over the testimony given by Burns. They considered his story of the alleged “fixing" of the series as a smashing blow at the defense. It was expected that Burns would con clude his direct testimony during the day and would be turned over to the de fense for cross examination. It was evi dent the former big league twirler would be subject to a savage cross fire of questioning by the lawyers representing the defense. Burns in his testimony thus far has named Arnold Rotbstein. of New York; Abe Attell. former feather weight champion: William Maharg. of Philadelphia; a man named “Bennett," and himself as the principals in the plot. I.ate yesterday he identified “Bennett" as Havis Zel9er of Des Moines, lowa.
Billy Burns recounts testifying at trial about collecting $10,000 from Abe Attell, hidden under a mattress, and delivering it to players including Risberg, McMullin, Cicotte and Gandil. He describes negotiations over throwing specific games and additional payoff proposals from Attell for subsequent games.
Indiana Daily Times · 20 July 1921 · page 8
PLAYERS SUSPECT DOUBLE CROSS
the players' room, I passed Kik Gleason, White Sox manager. ‘•Risberg. McMullin and other rlayers were in the room. Cicotte and Gandll came In later. “The players asked me If I had doubled crossed them. “I told them JIO.OoO was all I had. “I said I hadn't double crossed them at all, but brought all the money 1 could. “I gave them the money and asked about the game next day. “I told them Attell wanted them to win the third game necause the odds were going against Chicago. "He wanted small odds so they could bet on Cincinnati to win the series." “When you first met Cicotte In New Y’ork what conversation did you have?” State's Attorney Gorman asked.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Bill Burns, the state's star witness and a former accomplice in the betting scheme, testified that the White Sox players grew angry after gamblers failed to pay promised bribes and decided to play to win, including a 3-0 victory in game three. The defense successfully blocked testimony about a New York conversation with Eddie Cicotte regarding the conspiracy's formation.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 20 July 1921 · page 8
TO WIN, SAYS BURNS (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, July 20. The indicted Chicago White Sox players, after agreeing with a clique of gamblers to throw the 1919 world series to Cincin nati, for $100,000, became sick of the deal, when they were not paid the bribes promised and at a meeting be fore the third game, decided to play their best and win the series. Bill Burns, accomplice in the alleged deal, and the state's star witness, testified today in the baseball trial. Urged by the alleged fixers to win the third game to improve the betting odds, the players said they had lost for two regular pitchers, Cicotte and Wil liams, and would not win for a busher.
See moreSee less
Dick Kerr, Burns said. Then feeling, they had been crossed by the gamblers they double crossed their bribers, by telling them they would lose the third game, but instead won it 3-0 with Kerr pitching.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Star witness Bill Burns detailed conspiratorial meetings between players and gamblers, saying Cicotte vowed to throw the opener and Williams agreed to throw game two. He named Rothstein, Attell, Zelser, Maharg and himself as organizers, though defense objections blocked some testimony, including about a New York meeting with Cicotte.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 20 July 1921 · page 8
TO WIN, SAYS BURNS
Relied upon by the state as a pinch hitter, Burns yesterday seemed to measure up to the proscution's ex pectations. When court adjourned he had recited a story of numerous meet ings between the players and alleged gamblers involved, testified that Ed die Cicotte said he would throw the first game if he had to throw the ball over the fence; asserted Claude Wil liams, White Sox southpaw, agreed to throw the second game of the se ries, and named Arnold Rothstein of New York, Abe Attell, former pugil ist; David Zelser of Des Moines, a de-j fendant; Billy Maharg of Philadelphia and himself as among the organizers of the alleged conspiracy.
See moreSee less
Testimony Broken Burns testimony, however, was broken repeatedly by arguments and objections of the defense attorneys, who succeeded in having much of his testimony barred. His testimony to day relating to events during the ac tual games of the series was expected to cause many clashes between the opposing array of counsel.
State's witness Bill Burns testified that the indicted White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but grew angry when gamblers failed to pay the promised bribes. He said the players then double-crossed the gamblers by winning the third game 3-0 after being urged to lose it, and named Abe Attell as a go-between who shorted them on payments.
Richmond Daily Register · 20 July 1921 · page 1
BURNS TELLS OF BASEBALL SCANDAL
BASEBALL SCANDAL (By Associated Press) Chicago, July 20 The indicted Chicago White Sox players, after agreeing with a clique of gamb lers to throw the 1919 world ser ies to Cincinnati for $100,000, be came sick of the deal w.ien not paid the promised bribes and at a ! meeting before the third game decided to play their best an i win the series. Bill Burns, accomplice in the alleged deal and the state's ;tar witness, testified today at the baseball trial. Urged bv the alleged fixers to win th tlr'id game to improve the bcrlir.g o lds persuaded Attell to give Clvck the players, according to Burns, said they would not do it and then feeling thev had been crossed bv the gamblers, they double crossed their bribers by telling them they would lose the third game, but instead won it 3 to 0.
See moreSee less
Burns named Abe Attell, as one . of the traders for the "-amblers. 'Jle said Attell refused to pay thei stipulated $20,000 to the players at the end of each game. He said he oersuaded Attell to "ive Chick Gandil $20,000 after the "-aine. ne. Iater Burns said he ask Gandil for his share, but Gan el dil rcfused to share it.
Bill Burns, who turned state's evidence, testified about the conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, naming Arnold Rothstein, Abe Attell, David Zelser, and Billy Maharg as organizers. He described meetings with players in Cincinnati and quoted Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams agreeing to throw specific games.
Great Falls Tribune · 20 July 1921 · page 8
Burns Gives Details of Frame Up to Throw 1919 World's Series
Have Received for Selling Out. Chicago, July 19.—The state Tuesdar turned its full strength into the pros ecution of hte Chicago White Sox baseball players and others charged with the alleged conspiracy which re sulted in the 1919 world's series scan dal, sending Bill Burns, admitted ac complice of the defendants, and who turned state's evidence in return for immunity, to the witness stand to tell the inside story of the reported sell out of some of the game's greatest players, to gamblers who wanted the series thrown to Cincinnati. Burns, who was only about one-third through hiss toyw hrnc ueroatd soqit through his story when court ad journed for the day.
See moreSee less
was on the stand long enough to name Arnold Rothstein of New York; Abe Attell, former featherweight pugilist champion; David Zelser of Des Moines, one of the de fendants; Billy Maharg of Philadelphia and himself, as among the organizers of the alleged conspiracy. He drew a vivid verbal picture of numerous meet ings between the players and the al leged fixers in Cincinnati hotels the day of the first two games of the 1919 series, saying that the athletes agreed to make the series a "made to order" one, throwing games just as desired. Quotes Eddie Cicotte. fense?" "No," he replied. said Judge Friend. went into the oil business. us what you did." business." Mr. Gorman continued: New York ?" "Yes."
Billy Burns, the state's key witness, testified about organizing meetings between players and fixers before the 1919 World Series, quoting Cicotte and Williams agreeing to throw games. He described broken payment promises by Attell and Rothstein's alleged involvement through intermediaries.
Great Falls Tribune · 20 July 1921 · page 8
bets made. $20,000 For Each Game. The players were to get $20.000 af ter each game lost, Burns said. He then explained that when he offered to put up a lease on 12,000 acres of oil land in Texas as security. Maharg re fused to let him do so. saying that Rotlistein might not pay the money. Rothstein testified before the grand jury last fall that he was approached on the deal, but refused to go into it and that his name was used by Attell without his permission. The former major league pitchers' entrance into the court room came in a dramatic manner.
See moreSee less
For fifteen min utes, those in court had fidgeted, with the defense repeatedly asking the cause of the delay. "We are waiting for a witness, your honor." said George Gorman, of the prosecution. "We don't wish to di vulge his name as we don't want him interrupted on the way here." Detectives Escort Him.
Bill Burns, the state's key witness, testifies about meeting Cicotte, Gandil, Risberg, McMullin, Williams, Felsch and Weaver in a Cincinnati hotel before the World Series, claiming he told them he had $100,000 to finance a fix. He describes his baseball background and the defense's failed attempt to interview him before his testimony.
Great Falls Tribune · 20 July 1921 · page 8
Detectives Escort Him. Finally two private detectives en tered, Behind them came Bums, fol lowed by two more plain clothes men. The state's chief witness was dressed plainly. He walked through the sec tion occupied by the defendants with out looking at them. On the stand he spoke in low even tones which scarcely carried past the jury and repeatedly wiped his forehead with his handker ehief. Finally he took off his coat. Bunns fidgeted a bit during the legal arguments over his testimony, but while hesitating at times over ques tions. most of his answers came quietly. Burns testified that before the world's series he went from Xew York to Cincinnati, and in a hotel room there met. Cicotte. Gandil, Risberg, Mc Mullin, Williams. Felsch and Weaver.
At the Black Sox trial, state witness Bill Burns testified that the indicted players grew angry when gambling bribes weren't paid and decided to play to win. He said they refused to throw a game started by substitute pitcher Dick Kerr, instead winning it 3-0 after telling fixers they would lose.
Paper unidentified · 20 July 1921 · page 1
FOR BUSH PITCHER
Chicago, July 20. The indicted White Sox players after agreeing with gamblers to throw the series of 1919 to Cincinnati fbr $100,000 be came sick of the deal when they were not paid the bribes promised and at a meeting decided to play their best and win the series, Bill Burns accomplice in the alleged deal and state's star witness, testified to day in the baseball trial. Uurged by alleged "fixers" to win the third game to Improve the bet ting odds the players said they had lost for two regular pitchers Cicotte and Williams, and would not win for a bush pitcher, Dick Kerr,' then Burns said they double crossed their bribers by telling them they would lose but won 3 to 0 with Kerr pitch ing.
See moreSee less
Efforts of the state t ohave Burns tell of a meeting with Cicotte in New York failed when Judge Friend , - sustained an objection.
Bill Burns, the state's key witness, continued testimony in the Chicago trial of accused White Sox players, describing how they agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but grew angry when not paid. He testified they decided to double-cross the gamblers and win the third game, with Dick Kerr pitching.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 20 July 1921 · page 2
BILL BURNS AGAIN TAKES STAND IN BASEBALL TRIAL
STIND IT BISEBILL TRIAL CHICAGO, July 20—An hour be fore the opening of the third day of the baseball players trial with Bill Burns scheduled to continue his story of the plot the doors of the court room were ordered closed when every seat was taken. Hun dreds of disappointed fans awaited the arrival of star baseball players, accused by Burns of planning to lose the series in return for $100,000 to be paid by a gambling syndicate. George Gorhman, state’s attor ney, resumed his questions when Burns took the stand.
See moreSee less
The indicted Chicago White Sox players after agreeing with a clique of gamblers to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati for $100,000 be came sick of the deal when they were not paid the bribe promised and at a meeting before the third game decided to play their best and win the series. Bill Burns, accomplice in the alleged deal and the state’s star witness, testified today in the baseball trial. They double crossed their bribers by telling them they would lose their third game, but instead won it with Dick Kerr pitching.
Bill Burns testified that he served as stakeholder in the 1919 World Series fix, handing indicted White Sox players money with the understanding the series would be thrown. He described meetings with Cicotte, Gandil, Attell, Chase, and financier Arnold Rothstein that led to a $100,000 deal arranged in Cincinnati.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 20 July 1921 · page 4
BILL BURNS ADMITS HE ACTED AS STAKEHOLDER IN THE 1919 WORLD SERIES BALL SCANDAL
Burns testified. l'lot Hatched in New York. Ilurns said that hjs conversation with Cicotte occurred in New York In September, 1919. on the last day the White Sox played in Gotham, and when they wire sure of the American league finer. Grandil, he said, entered the room and was introduced by Cicotte, and both players Rave Hums their' Chicago addresses when they left. The three net met in Cincinnati, the witness said, but In the meantime, Burns admitted, he met Abe Attell. Hal Chase and a third party named Bennett in the east.
See moreSee less
Ar nold Ilothstein was also visited at a race track in the interim. Burns paid. After further meotinrs in New York, in which Rothslein fig ured, Burns moved to Cincinnati for the opening of the series, ac cording to the testimony, and upon his arrival met several Sox players and Attell in a hotel room. Said He Hail $100,000.
Billy Burns testified at the Black Sox trial about how the fix was arranged, describing a September 1919 conversation with Cicotte in New York and later meetings in Cincinnati with Attell, Bennett and the implicated players. He recounted details of the $100,000 payment plan financed by Rothstein, with Cicotte and Gandil agreeing to throw the first two games.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 20 July 1921 · page 4
Gambler Bill Burns testified that the indicted White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but grew angry when not paid, so they decided to win games instead. He described how they won the third game 3-0 with Dick Kerr pitching after double-crossing the gamblers who wanted them to lose it.
Evening Public Ledger · 20 July 1921 · page 1
SAYS ATTELL HELD OUT
and Williams nnd would not win for a "busher." Dick Kerr, Hums said. Then, feeling they hnd been crossed by the gamblers, thy)' double-crossed their bribers by telling them they would lose the third gnme. but distend won it .'5 to (I. with Kerr pitching. Attempts ot the State to have Hums tell of a conversation with Eddie Cicotte In New York, where the State claims the alleged conspiracy wns formed, failed when JudgeFriend sustained a defense objection. An hour before the opening of the third duy of the trial the doors of the courtroom were ordered closed, when every sent was taken.
See moreSee less
Hundreds 0f disappointed fans crowded the corridors and waited out side the Criminal Court Huilding to watch the arrival of the former star bnll pin) ers. who .vesterclny were ac cused b) Hums of plnnnlng to lose the series in return for S100.000 to be paid by a camblinc sviullcnte. (leorcc (lormnn. Asslslnnl Stulo's Attorney, resumed bis questions con cerning meetings in Cincinnati hotels when Hums took the stntul. "When )ou were In Room 70S of the Hotel Slnton the clav of the second game, what happened V" asked Gorman. Saw Plies of Money "Attell nnd severnl others were Ihere." answered Hums "Attell snld Rothsteln had $200,000 to bet on the scries, but it was hard to get bets down and be did not want to give me any money. I insisted on nt lensl $10,000. Attell showed me piles of money under a mattress. Forty thousand dollnrs was due the play era then Attell in tnlking of Rothstein snld Rothsteln hnd a private wire from New York to Cin cinnati and some one said that Pitts burgh gamblers were in on the deal. I. don't know who snld thnt. Attell. Hcnnctt and Mnhnrg were there. Sonic pno said the Pittsburgh gamb'ers had n hard time gettiir. inouer down. "Attell then took SIO.OllO from under the mattress and gave it to me I offered it to MnhaTg. He wouldn't take it. I put it in my shirt and took il up to the players' room. I passed 'Kiel' (ileason on thn way. "Risberg and McMuilin were In the hotel room I don't recall the others. Later Clcotte nnd finntlil came in ami I gave the $10,000 to Gnndll "Tlii'rj were two othei p'avcrs there. In qiic.-riou nnd nnsrwer form the te tiinony was as followsQ. "What did the plovers snv? ' A "(Inndii nid th-v had bn double crossed. Attell snld they mut win the third game the next dav so ns to imfontlnnrd on rni Four, Column four
Billy Maharg (testifying as Burns) describes meetings with Abe Attell and gamblers in Cincinnati hotel rooms, detailing cash payments and plans to lose games in the fixed 1919 World Series. He recounts seeing piles of money under a mattress, receiving $10,000 to pass to players, and discussions of double-crossing the gamblers.
Evening Public Ledger · 20 July 1921 · page 1
SAYS ATTELL HELD OUT
"Attell nnd severnl others were Ihere." answered Hums "Attell snld Rothsteln had $200,000 to bet on the scries, but it was hard to get bets down and be did not want to give me any money. I insisted on nt lensl $10,000. Attell showed me piles of money under a mattress. Forty thousand dollnrs was due the play era then Attell in tnlking of Rothstein snld Rothsteln hnd a private wire from New York to Cin cinnati and some one said that Pitts burgh gamblers were in on the deal. I.
See moreSee less
don't know who snld thnt. Attell. Hcnnctt and Mnhnrg were there. Sonic pno said the Pittsburgh gamb'ers had n hard time gettiir. inouer down. "Attell then took SIO.OllO from under the mattress and gave it to me I offered it to MnhaTg. He wouldn't take it. I put it in my shirt and took il up to the players' room. I passed 'Kiel' (ileason on thn way. "Risberg and McMuilin were In the hotel room I don't recall the others. Later Clcotte nnd finntlil came in ami I gave the $10,000 to Gnndll "Tlii'rj were two othei p'avcrs there. In qiic.-riou nnd nnsrwer form the te tiinony was as followsQ. "What did the plovers snv? ' A "(Inndii nid th-v had bn double crossed. Attell snld they mut win the third game the next dav so ns to imfontlnnrd on rni Four, Column four
State's star witness Bill Burns testified that the White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000 but grew angry when not paid, deciding to win the third game with pitcher Dick Kerr instead of losing as instructed. Burns described being double-crossed by Chick Gandil over his own share and recounted meetings in Cincinnati hotels where gamblers and players discussed the fix.
The Barre Daily Times · 20 July 1921 · page 1
W imam and would not win for "busher," Dick Kerr, Burns said. Then, feeling they had been crossed by the gamblers, they double-crossed their bribers by telling tbem they would lose the third game hut instead won it three to nothing with Kerr pitching. Attempts nf the state to have Burns tell of a conversation with Eddie Ci eotte in Xew York, where the state claims the alleged conspiracy was formed, failed when Judge Friend sus tained a defense objection. Swede Risberg. thf White Sox short stop, aLTeed to "go through" with the game-throwing.
See moreSee less
Burns testified. Re peated attempts to persuade the play ers to throw the ret of the games failed and Burns then gaxe up his ef forts to brilie the players, again, he said. Burns himself was doiiblerrossed out of his sharp of the spoil bv "Chick" Gandil, who refused to pay him, the witness testified, adding that he told Gandil then that he would "squawk" and expose the whole deal. Burns related urther details of meetings in Cincinnati hotels at which, he said, the gambler and player dis. cussed throwing the games. Attell and Bennett, identified yesterday as David Bennett, identified yesterday as David Zelzer, of Dcs Moinet, la., a defendant, were the leaders of the alleged gam blers and "Chick" Jiandil headed the players, according to Burn. Burns said Attell refused to pay the twenty thousand dollars promised the pluver after each game. He per suaded Attell to give him ten thou sand after the second gsme, which was given to Gandil, he said. A St. IiiiK man volunteered to put un ten thousand didling to have the the plavers fucned him down. Burn faiij. ii awl not know the mans name, but said Joe Gedeon, of the St. Louis Americans, who was released after the grand jury probe, was pres ent at the time tire proposition was made. Burns then told how he conferred with Ban .lnhnon. president of the American league, and John Tyrell, s i.-tant state's attorney, about the cae. He said he -ame here voluntari ly to te,tify and had received no prom ises or compensat ion other than his eipenj,e, which were aid by Johnson. Burns then was turned over to the de fence for cro examination.
Billy Maharg (Burns) testifies about Cicotte and Williams refusing to pitch to lose, the players double-crossing gamblers by winning game three with Dick Kerr pitching, and Gandil double-crossing Burns out of his payoff. Judge Friend sustained a defense objection blocking testimony about a New York conspiracy conversation with Cicotte.
Witness Bill Burns told the grand jury/trial that Abe Attell and Chick Gandil led the gambling and player conspiracy, and that Attell reneged on promised payoffs. Burns also described a St. Louis man's offer to bribe players and his own contacts with Ban Johnson and the state's attorney.
Bill Burns, the state's star witness in the Black Sox trial, testified that the indicted White Sox players grew angry when gamblers failed to pay the promised $100,000 bribe and decided to win the series instead of throwing it. He said the players, feeling cheated by gambler Abe Attell and others, deliberately won the third game behind pitcher Dickie Kerr after being double-crossed on payment.
The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 20 July 1921 · page 1
DOUBLE CROSSED THEIR BRIBERS
" THEIR BRIBERS liill Rums. Star Witness for State, Says lie Was lieaten Out of His Share of Spoils Iiy "Chick" Gandil and Then "Squealed." ( 'I HC AGO, July 20. The indicted Chicago White Sox players after agree ing with a clique of gamblers to throw the 101t world series to Cincinnati for if 100,000 became sick of tlie deal when they were not paid, the bribes promised and at a. meeting before the third game decided to play their best and win the series, Hill Burns, accomplice in the al leged deal and the state star witness testified today in the baseball trial.
See moreSee less
Urged by the alleged "fixers " to win the third game to improve the bitting odds the players said iney had lost for t ieotte and Wil two regular pitchers, nt win for a liams, and would Burns said. Then "busher', Dick Kerr, crossed by the feeling they had been they double crossed their gamblers telling them they would lose bri Iters by game, but instead won it 3 the third
Billy Burns testified about meetings between players and gamblers, naming Arnold Rothstein, Abe Attell, David Zelser, and Billy Maharg as organizers of the fix. He described how Cicotte agreed to throw games and how Gandil double-crossed Burns out of his share of the payoff.
The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 20 July 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CHICAGO WHITE SOX GOT COLD FEET Non-Payment of $10,000 Bribe Spurred Them to Win Third Game DOUBLE CROSSED THEIR BRIBERS Bill Burns, Star Witness for State, Says He Was Beaten Out of His Share of Spoils By "Chick" Gandil and Then "Squealed."
CHICAGO, July 20. — The indicted Chicago White Sox players after agreeing with a clique of gamblers to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati for $100,000 became sick of the deal when they were not paid the bribes promised and at a meeting before the third game decided to play their best and win the series, Bill Burns, accomplice in the alleged deal and the state star witness testified today in the baseball trial.
See moreSee less
Urged by the alleged "fixers" to win the third game to improve the betting odds the players said they had lost for two regular pitchers, Cicotte and Williams, and would not win for a "busher", Dick Kerr, Burns said. Then feeling they had been crossed by the gamblers they double crossed their bribers by telling them they would lose the third game, but instead won it 3 to 0 with Kerr pitching. Swede Risberg, the White Sox shortstop, agreed to "go through" with the game throwing, Burns testified. Repeated attempts to persuade the players to throw the rest of the games failed and Burns then gave up his efforts to bribe the players, again, he said.
Burns himself was double crossed out of his share of the spoils by "Chick" Gandil, who refused to pay him, the witness testified, adding that he told Gandil that he would "squawk" and expose the whole deal.
Yesterday Burns named Arnold Rothstein of New York, Abe Attell, former featherweight pugilistic champion, David Zelser, of Des Moines, one of the defendants, Billy Maharg of Philadelphia, and himself as among the organizers of the alleged conspiracy.
Burns described numerous meetings between the players and the alleged fixers, in Cincinnati hotels on the days of the first games of the 1919 series, saying that the players agreed to make the series a "made-to-order one", throwing games just as desired.
Burns testified that Eddie Cicotte, one of the American league's greatest pitchers, said he would "throw the first game if he had to throw the ball over the fence".
Burns identified David Zelser, defendant, as a man he had known as Bennett during the forming of the alleged conspiracy and declared that Bennett, or Zelser was present at most of the meetings, when the reported sell-out was arranged.
Burns said Abe Attell had termed Rothstein a "walking bank" who would pay all he promised but that after the first game Attell refused to give him any money, saying he couldn't pay the players until he collected the bets made.
Rothstein testified before the grand jury last fall that he was approached on the deal but refused to go into it and that his name was used by Abe Attell without his permission.
Witness Billy Burns testified at the Black Sox trial about secret meetings between players and gamblers in Cincinnati hotels before the 1919 World Series. He described Eddie Cicotte's pledge to throw games and detailed Abe Attell's dealings with Arnold Rothstein over payment to players.
The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 20 July 1921 · page 1
Burns testified that Kddie Cicotte. one of the American league's greatest pitchers, said he would "throw the first fame if he had to throw the ball over tin fence". Burns identified David Zelser, defend ant, as a man he had known as Ben nett during the forming of the alleged conspiracy and declared that Bennett, or Zelser was present at most of the meetings, when the reported sell-out was arranged. Burns said Abe Attell 1 termed Kothstein a "walking bank" who would jav all he promised but that after the first ame Attell refused to give him ;!tiv money, savin?
See moreSee less
he couldn't pay the phi vers until he collected the bets made. l!othtein testified lefore the grand jury last fall that he was approached on the deal but refused to go into it and that his name was used by Abe Attell without his permission.
Confessed go-between Bill Burns testifies at the Chicago trial about delivering gamblers' money to White Sox players during the 1919 World Series. He describes meetings with Abe Attell, Kid Gleason's team, and gambler Arnold Rothstein's role in financing and monitoring the fix.
The Seattle Star · 20 July 1921 · page 9
"BILL" BURNS TELLS HOW SERIES WAS GAMBLED ON
Abe Attel." said Burn*. • When I took the ft 0.00« I told Attel I didn't think the players mould accept It." Hums continued. "I tried to get Bill Maharg to take It to them, but be wouldn't, so I did. "As I went from the gamblers' (room to the players' room, I met Kid Oleason, Whit* fox manager Itlsberg and McMullin and other
Witness Bill Burns testified that Eddie Cicotte had a "for-sale" tag on the World Series and that gamblers led by Abe Attell, acting for Arnold Rothstein, paid $100,000 for the fix. Burns described how manager Kid Gleason started Dickie Kerr instead of Cicotte in Game 3, resulting in a shutout that cost the gamblers money and sparked bitter quarrels over players allegedly double-crossing them.
The Seattle Star · 20 July 1921 · page 9
Fane loaned forward In their seata to catch every word Uiat n*aa being said about tha men they one* wor shipped. They beard tha allegation (hat Rddie Clcotte ran around New Tot* with a "for-aale" tag on tha world aerlea and how gambler* nude the purchase for 1100,000." He recounted how "Kid" Cleaaon. the venerable Whit* Box manager, interfered with the "fixed aeries" when Utile Dickie Kerr was put In the pitcher's box In the third world series game Instead of Clcotte. Cicotte had agreed to lose the game, Burns testified, and the gamblers, led by Attel, who.
See moreSee less
the wit nee* stated, colled himself "Able," the Agent of Rothsteln, the (lamb ler," placed Jarge sums of money on Cincinnati to win. Thla money was lost said Bum*, when Kerr went to the bog and pitched a shutout game. Bl'tcr quarrels between fhe gamhUra and tbe playera ensued. according to Burns, during which the players were accused o( "double crossing" the gamblers.
Bill Burns, testifying as the state's witness, described how gamblers led by Abe Attell shortchanged the players and used Arnold Rothstein's money to bet against Cincinnati's loss. He recounted how manager Kid Gleason's decision to start Dickie Kerr instead of Cicotte foiled a fixed game, costing gamblers their bets.
The Milwaukee Leader · 20 July 1921 · page 4
FOUR GAMBLERS TRIED DOUBLE CROSS, SOX STARS SAY
“Kid” Gleason Interferes. He recounted how “Kid” Gleason, the venerable White Sox manager, interfered with the “fixed series” when Little Dick Kerr was put in the pitcher’s box in the third world series igame instead of Eddie Cicotte. “Cicotte lad agreed to lose the game,” Bur.s testified, “and the gamblers, led by Attel, who the wit ness stated called himself “Abie, the Agent of Rothstein the Gambler,” placed large sums of money on Cin cinnati to win. “This money was lost,” said Burns, “when Kerr went to the box and pitched a shut out game.” The “Black Sox” and their eight lawyers were closeted until early to day mapping out a way to overthrow the evidence presented by Burns, who told the jury he was their confed erate.
Former pitcher Bill Burns took the stand in Chicago to give firsthand testimony about the alleged conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series. He followed testimony from White Sox manager William Gleason and secretary Harry Grabiner.
The Laramie Republican · 20 July 1921 · page 1
Stand in Hearing on World Serie* Rumpus (B.v ARRnrlnted Frew.) 1 Chicago, July 19—Bill Burns, a for nicr major league pitcher, took the [stand today, at the trial of the Indicted White Sox players, to tell first hand the story of the alleged conspiracy to r'throw" the 1919 world scries. He fol
Chicago White Sox manager Kid Gleason and secretary Harry Grabiner testified for the prosecution in the Black Sox trial, describing player contracts. Their testimony aimed to show the players were under contract during the World Series itself, not just the regular season, though cross-examination found no explicit contract clause naming the Series.
Paper unidentified · 20 July 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX ON REGULAR PAY IN WORLD SERIES, IS CLAIM
With Throwing Games CHICAGO, July 19.—William (Kid) Gleason and Harry efabiner, manager and secretary, respectively of the Chi cago White Sox, testified for the state today in the baseball trial, telling of the contracts between the indicted players and the club. Their testimony was designed to prove the prosecution’s contention that to the club during the world’s series and not just in the regular season, as the men were under contract j ecution. the players remarked in an I undertone:- “There's a double.” or
During the Black Sox trial, testimony was given about a bonus paid to Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams, and as team secretary Grabiner described plays, the accused players made sarcastic remarks mocking the proceedings. Joe Jackson, Happy Felsch, and Cicotte joked about hits and errors as the official scorer Taylor Spink looked on before court adjourned for lunch.
White Sox secretary Harry Grabiner testified that the accused players were paid by the club and under contract during the 1919 World Series, countering defense claims otherwise. The prosecution also revealed a surprise witness, Phillies manager Bill Donovan, expected to testify about an alleged conspiracy involving Bill Burns.
Paper unidentified · 20 July 1921 · page 1
1919 world’s series, scheduled to be the first witness at the afternoon session. Bill Donovan, manager of the Phila delphia National* who is understood to have told of an alleged conspiracy by Bill Burns, was expected to follow Spink with Burns then coming on the stand.
A jury has been completed in Chicago to decide the guilt or innocence of the White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges related to the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series. The trial proceedings are now set to begin with the jury in place.
Paper unidentified · 21 July 1921 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The jury that will determine the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspiracy charges related to the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series was completed in Chicago. This marks the start of courtroom proceedings in the case.
Paris Express · 21 July 1921 · page 3
The jury which will decide the guilt or innocence of the Chicago White Sox players and others indicted on conspir acy charges in connection with the al leged throwing of the 1019 world's series wus completed at"" Chicago.
During cross-examination at the Black Sox trial, Charles Comiskey angrily denied jumping his contract when questioned by defense attorney Benedict Short, nearly coming to blows before other lawyers intervened. Separately, prosecutor George Gorman announced that gambler William Burns had been granted immunity in exchange for testimony against the accused players.
The Frontier · 21 July 1921 · page 7
COMISKEY SHAKES FIST AT SHORT
- AT SHORT Chicago, July 19.—Charles A. Com iskey, owner of the White Sox, shook bis fiat In the face of Attorney Ben edict Short, on Monday when the lat ter asked him If he did not Jump tils contract when he left the Cin cinnati team to come to Chicago. The scene occurred while he wae being cross-examined at the trial of the Indicted ball players accused of "throwing the 1919 world eerles for the benefit of a gamblers’ syndicate." The attorney had been questioning Comiskey concerning the details of bis baseball career. "Is It not true, Mr. Comiskey,” he asked, "that when you left the Na tional league you jumped your con tract?"
Charles Comiskey testified as the state's first witness in the Black Sox conspiracy trial, describing how his once-successful club was ruined after the 1919 scandal. Judge Friend ruled that prosecutors could not reveal to the jury that three defendants had signed confessions, though details within those confessions could still be used.
The Frontier · 21 July 1921 · page 7
COMISKEY TELLS OF WRECKED CLUB
BY CARL VICTOR LITTLE, Rules Out Confessions. The Black Sox got to first baa* when they made the initial hit In their trial. Umpire Hugo Friend — criminal court judge—ruled that State’s Attor ney Gorman must not mention that three of the “Black Sox” made con fessions, during his opening state ment to the 12 scorekeepers In the Jury bleachers. This followed arguments by At torney James C. "Ropes” O’Brien and other pinch hitters for the seven for mer White Sox stars charged with conspiracy to throw the 1919 world aeries with the Cincinnati Reds.
See moreSee less
Umpire Friend gave Gorman per mission to mention everything in the confession of Eddie Cicotte, "Lefty" Williams and “Shoeless Joe” Jackson, but forbade him to let the scorekeep ers know confessions had been made. Repdlation «, of the statements Signed by three of the seven stars outlawed from baseball came as soon as Umpire Hugo Friend, criminal court judge—shouted "play ball!” Grounds of Contest.
Attorney James O'Brien argued to exclude the signed confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson from trial, claiming they were made without other accused players present and only after promises of immunity. Judge Friend allowed prosecutor Gorman to reference the confessions' content but barred informing the jury that confessions existed, while Buck Weaver appeared to actively direct the defense's strategy.
The Frontier · 21 July 1921 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
COMISKEY SHAKES FIST AT SHORT
Chicago, July 19.—Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, shook his fist in the face of Attorney Benedict Short on Monday when the latter asked him if he did not jump his contract when he left the Cincinnati team to come to Chicago.
See moreSee less
The scene occurred while he was being cross-examined at the trial of the indicted ball players accused of "throwing the 1919 world series for the benefit of a gamblers' syndicate."
The attorney had been questioning Comiskey concerning the details of his baseball career.
"Is it not true, Mr. Comiskey," he asked, "that when you left the National league you jumped your contract?"
Leaps Toward Attorney.
"That is not true," shouted the witness as he reddened and leaped toward the attorney.
Other lawyers sprang between them to prevent what looked like a possible fist fight. Judge Friend warned the witness that he would have to be calm. Then the judge ordered the question stricken from the records.
"I never jumped a contract and I never broke my word," Comiskey declared after he had resumed his seat.
Complete immunity has been given William Burns as the price of his testimony, Prosecutor George E. Gorman announced in court Monday.
"When Burns takes the witness stand the state will drop the cases against him," Mr. Gorman said.
The defense made an effort to show that Comiskey has made more money each succeeding year out of baseball than he did the year previous.
"This man is getting richer all the time and we are charged with conspiracy to injure his business," said Attorney Short.
COMISKEY TELLS OF WRECKED CLUB
Chicago, July 19.—Charles A. Comiskey, the "grand old Roman" of baseball testified against seven of his former stars late today.
Comiskey, owner of the Chicago White Sox which were wrecked when his stars were outlawed and charged with throwing the 1919 world series, was the state's first witness.
The "Black Sox" shifted uneasily in their seats when their former "old man" passed them on the way to the witness chair.
Since the Black Sox were ruled off the diamond Comiskey, for years a winner, has been a steady loser and crowds have dwindled.
"The White Sox had a first class reputation up to 1919," said Comiskey. "Business of the team I built up had steadily increased since 1900.
"The defendants have harmed the reputation of my club."
BY CARL VICTOR LITTLE. Rules Out Confessions.
The Black Sox got to first base when they made the initial hit in their trial.
Umpire Hugo Friend — criminal court judge—ruled that State's Attorney Gorman must not mention that three of the "Black Sox" made confessions, during his opening statement to the 12 scorekeepers in the jury bleachers.
This followed arguments by Attorney James C. "Ropes" O'Brien and other pinch hitters for the seven former White Sox stars charged with conspiracy to throw the 1919 world series with the Cincinnati Reds.
Umpire Friend gave Gorman permission to mention everything in the confession of Eddie Cicotte, "Lefty" Williams and "Shoeless Joe" Jackson, but forbade him to let the scorekeepers know confessions had been made.
Repdiation of the statements signed by three of the seven stars outlawed from baseball came as soon as Umpire Hugo Friend, criminal court judge—shouted "play ball!"
Grounds of Contest.
O'Brien's plea, stripped of all fancy curves, for throwing out the confessions, follows:
1. The statements were not signed in the presence of other players accused in them.
2. The confessions were made only after immunity baths had been promised.
Following conclusion of arguments of various defense attorneys, George Gorman, assistant state's attorney, fought the motion.
All the players but "Buck" Weaver sat on the sidelines displaying little interest in what was going on.
"Buck" seemed to be the captain of the Black Sox, whispering at times to the pinch hitters and in other ways directing the defense.
State's witness Bill Burns testified in the Chicago trial that the accused White Sox players conceived and planned the conspiracy themselves rather than being approached by gamblers. He said Eddie Cicotte and Chick Gandil made the sell-out proposition to him, offering to throw the series for $100,000.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 July 1921 · page 2
INDICTED WHITE SOX PLANNED 1919 DEAL THEMSELVES
| the best in the American league, | made the sell-out proposition to Burns and (Jandil, and Cicotte then volunteered the information that they i could have the series thrown for ! $100,000, Burns testified. Players Made Plan I Burns’ testimony to this effect was i admitted late today after Judge ! Friend three times had barfed it
Sleuth Bill Burns gave key testimony tracing the fix conspiracy's origins to New York meetings with gamblers and players, surviving a grueling cross-examination with only minor inconsistencies. The state plans to continue building its case in Chicago the next day with witness John Seys.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 July 1921 · page 2
part of the witness' testimony, and ; it was designed to do away v^th the j belief that the players were cor i rupted by millionaire gamblers and j to show that the alleged conspiracy had its inception in New York. The testimony was given in re ; Idling details of conversations be tween Burns, Abe Attell, Hal Chase, 'Cicotte, Gandil and Bennett, iden ! tit ltd by Burns us David Zelter of Des $ Moines, la., defendant. These 'conversations were said by the wit , ness to have taken place at the j Anaonia hotel in September, 1919, ami were contended by the defense to be I inadmissible, on the ground that they I took place prior to the inception ot | the conspiracy.
See moreSee less
Having placed before the jury its i contention that the alleged con i spiracy had its inception In New ' York and its birth in Cincinnati, the state tomorrow plans to bring it to Chicago. John Seys, secretary of the Chicago National League club, is ex pected to be the first witness and it is understood he will testify to ree ling bets paid to Abe Attell. Burns
A sports column analyzes how often American League pitchers falter in the eighth and ninth innings during July 1921, highlighting the White Sox, Braves, and other teams' late-game records. It also notes a Senators player's medical explanation for recent rib pain and a strong pitching performance by Oldham.
Evening Star · 22 July 1921 · page 16
It would not appear that their t tellers have been bumped much toard the close of the game. They 11 ive been well within victory or deB at or the score has been tied by the H na the eighth inning began. ij White Sox Good Finishers, rhe White Sox have been the busy rds around the eighth and ninth and e extra innings. They have won six tn imes from the eighth Inning on and c at three in July, and that is a very _ lart total when it is considered that _ ere have been only twenty-one g aying days. Pittsburgh has won two such games td lost two. That isn't much, and tl an dlcated high-class pitching for the a Pi
At the Black Sox trial, witness John Seys testified about seeing bets placed by Abe Attell and Louis Levi in Cincinnati before the 1919 World Series, with Burns' earlier testimony suggesting players themselves originated the fix rather than a gambling syndicate. The report outlines upcoming witnesses and anticipated legal battles over admitting the players' grand jury confessions.
'6 recalled by the defense. A legal battle is anticipated when he state attempts to introduce the rrand jury confessions of Eddie Ciotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Wiliams, former White Sox players, now n trial. The state is expected to aek for a ourt session Saturday. If its request s granted, the prosecution may finish
This passage covers various sports news including boxing matches, track meets, and baseball results like Red Faber's 20th win for the White Sox, along with a United Press article on baseball attendance trends. It does not pertain to the Black Sox scandal.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1921 · page 6
Red Faber turned in his twentieth i victory for the White Sox this sea son when he won a 2 to 1 hurling , duel from Naylor of the Athletics in : (Additional port on page 7)
A witness named Soys testified about betting arrangements with gambler Abe Attell on the 1919 World Series outcomes, describing specific wagers and stakeholding. Separately, Pitcher Burns testified that the accused White Sox players were not approached by gamblers but instead initiated the conspiracy themselves and sought financial backing from gamblers in New York.
The Evening World · 22 July 1921 · page 1
PLAYERS HATCHED PLOT
Soon after this iu!ing was handed down from he bench. Pitcher Burn-) sprang the sensation of the trial when he testified that the White Sox players aesuted of throwing the 1919 World's Series were not approached by the gamblers on the proposition, but
At the Chicago trial of accused gamblers and Black Sox players, prosecutors revealed the original signed grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams were missing, forcing reliance on carbon copies. The defense signaled it would argue the confessions were involuntary, while testimony also implicated Carl Zork and Ben and Louis Levi as fixers connected to Abe Attell.
Evening Star · 23 July 1921 · page 7
\> - - * "i '. i HICAGO. July 23.?The trial of j I alleged gamblers will be com j that it will be completed earl; I anticipated. It probably will take up Original copies of the grand Jury confessions in which Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams.
At the Black Sox trial, state witness Harry Redmon testified that Carl Zork admitted starting the fix conspiracy, while also naming Ben Levi as a go-between for Abe Attell's money during the 1919 series. Zork's defense attorneys announced they would present an alibi contradicting the timing of Redmon's account, and financier Arnold Rothstein was reported to be preparing a statement on the case.
Evening Star · 23 July 1921 · page 7
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Testimony from Replogle disputes claims that Cicotte was promised immunity for his confession, with cross-examination by Cicotte's attorney challenging this account. Redmon testifies about being approached to help fund the fix and implicates Sport Sullivan and Bill Burns associates in betting on the fixed Series.
New-York Tribune · 23 July 1921 · page 4
you and I talk about immunity for Cicotte?" asked Mr. Cassidy. "Yes," replied Replogle, "but that was several months after the con? fessions." "You remember a newspaper story appeared the next day that Cicotte had agreed to turn state's evidence for immunity?" "I don't remember it." "When you took me to Judge Mac Donald and we discussed immunity for Cicotte didn't you ten me you assured Cicotte that he would be granted im? munity if he came here when wanted and testified?" "I did not." "You mean you don't remember it?"
See moreSee less
"I mean I did not say it any time, anywhere." Mr. Replogle will be on the stand again when court resumes Monday and probably will be followed by Judge MacDonald and grand jurors. Redmon Implicates Attell Redmon when on the stand testified that he and Joe Pesch, who also testi? fied before the grand jury last fall, were in on a conference with Ben Franklin, Zork's partner, when the two men asked them to "chip in $5,000 into the pot to fix the ball players." Red? mon declared that he and Pesch turned down the proposition. During the conversation, the wit? ness asserted, Franklin was talking in a loud tone, and when cautioned that "Ban Johnson might do something to you" Franklin replied, Redmon de? clared: "That's all right. I've got an alibi. I've bet $2,000 to $8,000 with 'Sport' Sullivan on the White Sox." "Sport" Sullivan was among those indicted by the grand jury, but he was not brought1" to trial with the ball players. Redmon also implicated Abe Attell I as one of the figures in the plot. "Did you see Abe Attell ?" asked Attorney Gorman.
Witness Replogle denies telling Cicotte he'd get immunity for testifying, with more testimony expected Monday. Redmon testifies he refused a $5,000 bribe request and that Abe Attell showed him a box of cash after game four, implicating Attell and Sport Sullivan in the fix.
The report states that a man named Redmon allegedly approached Alfred Austrian, attorney for White Sox owner Charles Comiskey, seeking a $10,000 reward for information about the plot to fix the World Series. Redmon denied the accusation.
New-York Tribune · 23 July 1921 · page 4
Redmon had not come to Chicago and approached Alfred Austrian, attorney for Charles Comiskcy, owner of the White Sox, in an effort to obtain a reward of $10,000 for giving informa? tion of the plot to throw the series. Redmon denied the accusation.
The editorial argues that if gambler Bill Burns is telling the truth, the White Sox players themselves orchestrated the fix rather than being lured by gamblers. It calls for the full scandal to come out, however bad, to prompt a stronger reform.
The Evening World · 23 July 1921 · page 10
THE WORST YET. IF Bill Burns told the truth, the indicted White Sox deserve even less sympathy than has been ac corded to them. The tearful confessions of last fall were the rankest sort of cry-babyism. For if Bums is telling the truth, it was not the wicked gaipblers who undermined the virtue of hon orable ball players with the insidious lure of easy money. Unless Burns is lying, the ball players planned the whole filthy betrayal and went seeking aid to put the deal across on a remunerative basis. The revelations at Chicago make every fan sick at heart and despondent.
See moreSee less
But while the story is coming out, let us have the worst and have it over with. The vorse the scandal proves to be, the greater the reac tion likely to result. The most encouraging thing about the whole affair Is that the crooks inside and outside of the game seem to have quarrelled and lost most of their ill-gotten pins.
While the Black Sox trial recessed for a day, several indicted players received offers from small-town teams across multiple states to play exhibition games on Sundays. Meanwhile, attorneys for both sides prepared for the resumption of arguments over admitting the Williams, Jackson, and Cicotte grand jury confessions.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 24 July 1921 · page 14
INDICTED MEN SPEND DAY ANSWERING MESSAGES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A new scandal brews after immunity waivers and grand jury confessions disappear from the state's attorney's office. In court, with the jury absent, attorneys argue over admitting confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson describing their conspiracy to throw the World Series for payment.
The Siftings Herald · 25 July 1921 · page 4
Frey. Orchestra. of Cicotte, Williams and Jackson | conferring on question of throw ing world’s series and receiving their series share of money for aiding in the conspiracy. I ♦ Athens, July 25.—Greeks in Asia Minor, following up victory over the Turk Nationalists when the lat ter attempted to recapture Eski, I
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
As the second week of the Black Sox trial opened, lawyers resumed arguing whether the grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson could be admitted as evidence. Judge Hugo Friend was weighing the issue outside the jury's presence, with testimony from Replogle, Judge MacDonald, Austrian, and grand jury foreman Brigham expected, amid reports the original signed confessions and immunity waivers were missing.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 25 July 1921 · page 1
Confessions Of Cicotte And Jackson As Second Week Of 'Sox' Trial Starts Chicago. July 25--The fight over admission as evidence of the grand jury confessions of Eddie Cicotte, In these confessions, according to - state's attorneys, Cicotte declared that
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
State's attorneys reveal details from the confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson regarding the 1919 World Series fix, including payment amounts and meetings with gamblers. The report notes procedural issues about whether the confessions can be used as evidence against other defendants.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 25 July 1921 · page 1
parties to the alleged conspiracy. Williams told of a meeting in Cicotte's room in a, hotel here, between the players and "Sport" Sullivan of Bos ton and Rachel Brown of New York. when the pla,n to throw games was said to have been discussedHe said he was given $10.000 by Chick Gandill and gave $5,000 to Jackson. Jackson - corroborated Williams' storY. If the confessions are submitted, ' they can be used as evidence only against the men making them, and not against other players unless Wil liams. Jackson or Cicotte testify-,
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
At the Black Sox trial, the state resumed its fight to have Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson's grand jury confessions admitted as evidence, with testimony given outside the jury's presence pending Judge Friend's ruling. Witnesses described Cicotte receiving $10,000 under his pillow to throw games and named the eight indicted players, while the original confession documents and immunity waivers were reported missing or stolen.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 25 July 1921 · page 1
STATE RENEWS FIGHT TO ADMIT CONFESSIONS
Harry Brigham, foreman of the Grand (Jury, were prepared to follow Heploglt I on the stand. The evidence over the confessions is being presented with the jury absent.; (pending a decision by Judge Hugo'» Friend as to its admissibility. The original copies of the confessions and muhe immunity waivers the Players are 5,310 10 have M sned are alleged to hav, been lost or stolen. If Judge Friend rules for the state, the testimony will be repeated before the jury ln these confessions, according to state attorneys. Cicotte declared that he was paid »10,000 to throw games.
See moreSee less
The money was given him in advance —placed under his pillow nc testi fled. Cicotte named the eight White .Sox players who were indicted as parties to the alleged conspiracy Williams told of a meeting in CL cotte's room in a hotel here between the players and J, J. Sullivan of Boston, and Rachel Brown of New York, when the plan to throw games was said to have been discussed. He said he was given »10,000 by Chick Gandil and gave »6,000 to Jackson, Jackson corroborated Williams' story, tf the confessions are admitted, they can be used as evidence only against the men making them, and not against the other players. unless W illiams. Jackson or Cicotte testify, which is highly improbable. They may testify
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
At the Black Sox trial, Judge Hugo Friend considers whether the confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson can be admitted as evidence, with the jury absent during arguments. The confessions detail payments for throwing the 1919 World Series, including Cicotte's $10,000 and Williams' account of a hotel meeting with gamblers Sullivan and Brown.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 25 July 1921 · page 1
Harry Brigham, foreman of the Grand (Jury, were prepared to follow Heploglt I on the stand. The evidence over the confessions is being presented with the jury absent.; (pending a decision by Judge Hugo'» Friend as to its admissibility. The original copies of the confessions and muhe immunity waivers the Players are 5,310 10 have M sned are alleged to hav, been lost or stolen. If Judge Friend rules for the state, the testimony will be repeated before the jury ln these confessions, according to state attorneys. Cicotte declared that he was paid »10,000 to throw games.
See moreSee less
The money was given him in advance —placed under his pillow nc testi fled. Cicotte named the eight White .Sox players who were indicted as parties to the alleged conspiracy Williams told of a meeting in CL cotte's room in a hotel here between the players and J, J. Sullivan of Boston, and Rachel Brown of New York, when the plan to throw games was said to have been discussed. He said he was given »10,000 by Chick Gandil and gave »6,000 to Jackson, Jackson corroborated Williams' story, tf the confessions are admitted, they can be used as evidence only against the men making them, and not against the other players. unless W illiams. Jackson or Cicotte testify, which is highly improbable. They may testify in the fight over admission of the documents, however. After the confession right tiled, Billy Maharg, of Philadelphia, is ex pec ted to corroborate much of Bill Burns' testimony. Joe Gedeon. former St. Louis player, is expected t finish the State's presentation of evidence. Eddie t'icotte, former White Sox pitcher, was called to the stand to tell his "own story of how h» en confessed. after Ueplogle's cross-examination had been finished, with a further denial by the witness that any promises of immunity had been made the men who confessed.
As the second week of the Black Sox trial begins, lawyers continue arguing whether the grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson can be admitted as evidence. Testimony details alleged payments to players, including Cicotte's $10,000 and Williams' account of a hotel meeting with gamblers to fix the World Series.
Paper unidentified · 25 July 1921 · page 4
SECOND WEEK OF BASEBALL TRIAL BEGINS TODAY
peated before the jury. In these confessions, according to state attorneys. Cicotte declared he was paid SIO,OOO to throw games. The money was given him in advance, placed under his pillow, he testified. Cicotte named the eight White Sox players who were indicted, as par ties to the alleged inquiry. Williams told of a meeting in Cicotte's room in a hotel here, between the players and J. J. Sullivan, of Boston, and Rachael Brown, of New York, when the plans to throw the games was said to have been discussed. He said he was giv en SIO,OOO by Chick Gandil and gave $5,000 to Jackson. Jackson corrobor ated Williams’ story. .
Judge Hugo Friend considers whether to admit the players' confessions as evidence after original signed copies went missing, with testimony describing Cicotte's $10,000 payment and Williams' account of meetings with gamblers. The report also previews upcoming witnesses Billy Maharg and Joe Gedeon as the state nears the end of its case.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Eddie Cicotte testified that attorney Alfred Austrian and prosecutor Replogle pressured him to confess with promises of protection before he spoke to the grand jury. Joe Jackson similarly testified that Austrian told him Cicotte had already confessed and urged him to do the same under assurances he would not be prosecuted.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 25 July 1921 · page 1
CONFESSION WAS MADE TO LAWYERS CICOTTE AND JACKSON WERE WITNESSES IN BASEBALL TRIALS
TRIALS. Chicago, July 25,—-Tiddie Cicotte former White Sox pitcher, was called to the stand today when the basehall trial was resumed, to tell his own story of how he confessed. (Mieotte said he was introduced to Replogle by Alfred Austrian, attorney fgr Charles iComiskey, who said ‘‘this is Mr. Replogle of the State’s Attorney of fice.”’ Cicotte said ¢“ Austrian said to we, Replogle has the goods on you, Eddie. now come e¢lean with Replogle anid he'll take care of vou.”’ He said that on his wav to the grand juy room he said to Replogle ‘“don’t this go about what von and Austrian promised me’’ andy Replogle answered “ome it goes”’ Then 1 went before the grand jury.’’ On ecross examination Cicotte said he did not know whether the immuni ty waiver had been read to him in the grand jury room.
See moreSee less
Joe Jackson testified next and told of a visit to Austrians' office before aoing to the grand jury. “CAustrian said I would be indicted in a few min vtes and that Cicotte had bheen down. Austrinn then gave me my notice of suspension anid when I said 1 had no lawyer, he said I needed one damn had. Austiian promised if 1 would tell what T knew I would not be proseeut od. Austrian called up Judge MecDonald and said T had agreed to tell what I knew under the same condi tions as made with Cicotte.”
Judge Hugo Friend (OCR garbled as 'Irmend') ruled that the grand jury confessions of Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, and Joe Jackson admitting they were paid to throw the 1919 World Series could be used as evidence, but only against the player who made each confession. He warned that if defense evidence showed the confessions were not voluntary, he would instruct the jury to disregard them.
The Daily Star-Mirror · 25 July 1921 · page 1
Each confession can be used only against the man who made it. Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams, former White Sox players, confessed to tlle S rand J ur Y last fall that they had received money to throw t e gam , Each declared the confession was made after Judge McDonald, who ordered the baseball scandal investigation, Hartley Replogle, former assistant state's att orney, who directed the inquiry, and Alfred Austrian, Chicago American »■«» •** r' e "r ,rv -r rr. them and wanted only so that baseball gamblers might be trampled under foot". Radical Granger is Suspended
Eddie Cicotte repudiated the confession he had made alongside Joe Jackson and Claude Williams, claiming he was promised immunity and was indicted anyway. He denied weeping when confronted with the indictment, and the report notes the original confession document had allegedly been stolen from the district attorney's office and sold to gamblers for $10,000.
East Oregonian : E.O · 25 July 1921 · page 1
WHITE SOX BALL PLAYER - CHICAGO, July 25. tP. P.I Ed die Cicotte, once a White Sox prize, repudiated hi 'confession made with Joe Jackson anoW Claude .Williams, three of tbe seven former Chiram
A sports column discusses how trades and star player acquisitions like Babe Ruth and Tris Speaker boost team success and revenue, citing the Yankees, Indians, White Sox, and Braves as examples. It argues that winning teams draw fans and money, with a warning against the Phillies disrupting team chemistry through trades.
Evening Public Ledger · 25 July 1921 · page 14
All the World Loves a Winner F BASEBALL, the same as everything else, there's nothing that succeeds like success. If a club is down in the lace the gate receipts fall off, but just ns soon as it steps in front the coin rolls in. For ears the ankees wero stymied by several other teams in the Amen, an League and the owners lost a fortune. Then they purchased Babe Ruth, obtained a strong supporting can and made more money last year than at any other time in history. Cleveland was trailing the league for years, the owner of the club went broke and the franchise was sold to .llm Dunn.
See moreSee less
Dunn, being a clever person. nnt over a deal with Boston, purchased Tris Speaker and now look at the team It has been up in the race, won one World Series and Is on the way to win another pennant. When the White Sox Hopped several years ago Comlskcv bought Jackson. Eddie Collins and a few others and came through In other words. It tones a winner 10 gci mv ujuk". " " " ' n Is got together. The best way to get star players is to buy them, but team islonally a few clever trades will accomplish the same thiug. For example. occasionally l-'or three venr - the club had been losing money. nfr tho Ttncton Braves w iion
Eddie Cicotte testified at trial that he signed a paper but doesn't recall if it was an immunity waiver or confession. He described being pressured by Comiskey's attorney Austrian and Replogle to testify before the grand jury in exchange for protection.
Evening Public Ledger · 25 July 1921 · page 14
CICOTTE ADMITS HE SIGNED PAPER
Grand Jury. The pitcher was taken to the Grand Jury room by Hartley lleplogle, then Assistant Stnte At torney, who was In charge of the In vestigation. Clcotte said he wns Introduced to Heploglc by Alfred Austrian, counsel for Charles Comlskey, owner of the White Sox. "Austrian," said Cicotte. "said to me: 'lleplogle hns tho goods on you, Eddie. You know this will be a long trial. You don't want your wife nnd babies here then. Now come elenn with lleplogle and he'll lake care of you. "Thev took mc to Judgo McDonald.
See moreSee less
He nskVd mo if I couldn't tell more about the gamblers. I said I could, and McDonald then said, 'Go abend nnd in dict him.' Promised Immunity "I said to lleplogle on my way to the Grand Jury room, 'Don t this go about what you and Austrian promised meV He said. 'Sine it does Then 1 went before the Grand Jury.' Cnder cross-examination Clcotte nun he had heard last fall of Hilly Ma Jiarg's statement in Philadelphia, in which the latter told detail of the al leged conspiracy. Harry Grnb ncr. sec retary of the White Sox, took him to Auhtrinn's ofllco, ho said. ,,,,, "And sou sailed naht in and told of getting $10,000, didn't you.' asked Gorman. "Not in Austrian's ofhec, said Cicotte.
State Attorney's agents search frantically for the immunity waivers and confessions signed by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson, which were stolen from the files. A New York gambler reportedly paid $10,000 for the documents, which later surfaced during Abe Attell's extradition hearing, and Crowe plans to present this theft to the Grand Jury.
Evening Public Ledger · 25 July 1921 · page 14
in the alleged plot. An attorney for Attell. waving some pupeis in court, declared: "I have here the full pro ceedings of the Cook County Grand Jury," it was said. Other reports being Investigated in clude one that the New York gambler wlio is mid to have pin chased the btolen evidence later offered to sell it to n New York newspaper when he found there were no dnmaging refer ences to himself. The newspaper de clined to buy, and efforts of the dis appointed gambler to recover his $10,000 have so far been unsiicccesful. Stato Attorney Crowe is preparing to lay evidence in connection with the theft of the records before the Grand Jury.
Eddie Cicotte testified that he repudiated his earlier confession to throwing the 1919 World Series, claiming he only confessed after being promised immunity by the state. The report notes that even if acquitted of conspiracy, the players are unlikely to return to organized baseball due to public opinion and Commissioner Landis's authority.
The Milwaukee Leader · 25 July 1921 · page 3
SALE CONFESSION BY CARL VICTOR LITTLE Staff Correspondent The United Press CHICAGO — Eddie Cicotte, out lawed pitching ace of the Chicago White Sox. repudiaied his confession of selling out to gamblers today. Eddie, once the finest of the White Sox, stated he confessed to his part in "throwing" the 1919 world series after he was promised immunity by the state. The pitcher is one of the seven Sox players charged with con spiracy to throw the championship games. Cicotte, according to testimony al ready given at the trial, said he would lose the first game to Cincin nati if he had to “throw the ball over the fence.” State's Attorney Gorman then cross examined the pitcher.
Prosecutors in the Black Sox trial pushed to have the confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson admitted into evidence, pending Judge Friend's ruling on whether they were made voluntarily. Billy Maharg was expected to arrive from Philadelphia to testify for the state and complete its case against the indicted players.
The Milwaukee Leader · 25 July 1921 · page 3
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Court stenographer Walter J. Smith began reading Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession at the Black Sox trial, prompting numerous defense objections over wording that could implicate other players. Judge Friend ordered attorneys to revise the confession's language before it could be presented, with only two of thirty pages agreed upon after two hours of argument.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 26 July 1921 · page 8
OF CICOTTE IN TRIAL ' (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, July 26 When waiter J. Smith, court stenographer, who took down Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession, began reading the confes sion in the baseball trial today, so 'many objections were raised by the defenca that t was necessary to ad1 . i nrtttla VlO juurn me court leuiyuiamj attorneys went into conference witn Judge Friend. ' Since a confession may be used against the men making it only, Smith was not allowed to mention any names except Cicotte's. The defense maintained that such words as "ball ' players," "outfielders" and "infielders" also were barred.
See moreSee less
Judge Friend ordered the attorneys to reach an agreement on the wording of the confessions, before presenting them in court, but after two hours' argument only two pages of Cicotte's 30-page statement had been revised. Indications were that it would take all day to revise the confessions. Others Follow Smith Smith was on the stand yesterday but court adjourned before he had read Cicotte's confession. The stenog raphers who took down the confes sions of Joe Jackson and Claude Will iams, former White Sox players were expected to follow on the stand. Alfred Austrian, attorney for the Chicago American league club will strengthen the state's case by telling .of the confessions Cicotte. Jackson
Three indicted former White Sox players testified at trial that they confessed to the 1920 grand jury only after being promised the confessions would not be used against them. Judge Friend ruled the confessions admissible as evidence, though he left open the possibility of instructing the jury to disregard them if coercion were proven.
Great Falls Tribune · 26 July 1921 · page 3
FORMER MEMBERS WHITE SOX TELL OWN STORY
Chicago, July 25. —Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams, for mer White Sox players, told their own stories in the baseball trial Monday of how they confessed to a special grand jury last fall that they had re ceived money to throw games in the 1919 world's series. Each of three men declared that his confession had been made only after Judge Charles A. McDonald, who or dered the baseball scandal investiga tion, Harley Replogle, former assistant states attorney, who directed the in quiry and Alfred Austrian, Chicago American league club attorney, had promised them that their confession would never be used against them and were wanted only so that baseball gamblers might be "trampled under foot."
See moreSee less
Cicotte said that he had broken down and cried while telling Judge McDonald his story and that much of what he did on that day was simply a hazy memory. Under cross-examination he replied to many questions: "I don't remember."
Judge Hugo Friend ruled that the grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson are admissible as evidence, provided they were voluntary. Meanwhile, investigators probe reports that the confessions were stolen from the state's attorney's files and sold to a gambler for $10,000.
Great Falls Tribune · 26 July 1921 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
FORMER MEMBERS WHITE SOX TELL OWN STORY
Indicted Play[ers] Confessions to Be Used A[gainst Them]
See moreSee less
Cicotte, Jackson and W[illiams] Told Story in Order T[hat Baseball Gamblers] Might Be "Tramp[led Under Foot."]
Chicago, July 25.—Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams, former White Sox players, told their own stories in the baseball trial Monday of how they confessed to a special grand jury last fall that they had received money to throw games in the 1919 world's series.
Each of three men declared that his confession had been made only after Judge Charles A. McDonald, who ordered the baseball scandal investigation, Harley Replogle, former assistant states attorney, who directed the inquiry and Alfred Austrian, Chicago American league club attorney, had promised them that their confession would never be used against them and were wanted only so that baseball gamblers might be "trampled under foot."
Cicotte said that he had broken down and cried while telling Judge McDonald his story and that much of what he did on that day was simply a hazy memory. Under cross-examination he replied to many questions:
"I don't remember."
Confessions Admissible.
Judge Hugo Friend ruled that the grand jury confessions Cicotte, Williams and Jackson made are admissible as evidence.
The judge, however, informed the state that if the defense presented further evidence which proved that the confessions were not made voluntarily by the players he would instruct the jury to disregard them. Each confession can be used only against the man who made it.
A new baseball scandal was brewing as agents of the state's attorney continued their frantic search for immunity waivers and confessions signed before the grand jury by Cicotte, Williams and Jackson.
Information in the hands of Assistant State's Attorney George Gorman indicates a New York gambler paid $10,000 for the papers soon after they were stolen from the state's attorney's file.
Another development was the discovery that a signed statement made by Williams in the office of Alfred Austrian, attorney for the White Sox, has disappeared from Austrian's files. In this statement which was made public by Austrian when Williams went before the grand jury, the ball player detailed the ramifications of the alleged plot to lose the 1919 world's series.
The grand jury evidence apparently dropped from sight during the confusion incident to the retirement of State's Attorney Hoyne and the taking over of the office by State's Attorney Crowe.
Reports being investigated by the state's attorney include one that a gambler who is said to have purchased the stolen evidence later offered to sell it to a New York newspaper when he found there was no particularly damaging references to himself. The newspaper declined to buy and efforts of the disappointed gambler to recover his $10,000 have so far been unsuccessful.
State's Attorney Crowe is preparing to lay evidence in connection with the theft of the records before the grand jury.
When Harry Redmond, of East St. Louis, Ill., was on the stand last Friday, the defense asked him if Austrian had not called him a blackmailer and kicked him out of his office when Redmond came here to see Austrian about testifying. Mr. Austrian, on the stand Monday, denied the defense charges and said he knew nothing derogatory to Mr. Redmond. He said he understood that Redmond told "Kid" Gleason, manager of the White Sox, that he would furnish proof that the series had been thrown if $5,000 he lost on the series were returned to him.
Eddie Cicotte was called to the stand to tell his own story of how he confessed after Replogle on the stand made a further denial that any promises of immunity had been made the men who confessed.
Cicotte Tells Story.
Cicotte said he was introduced to Replogle by Mr. Austrian, who said: "This is Mr. Replogle, of the state's attorney's office."
"Austrian," said Cictote, said to me: 'Replogle has the goods on you, Eddie. You know this will be a long trial. You don't want your wife and babies here then. Now come clean with Replogle and he'll take care of you.'
"They took me to Judge McDonald. He asked me if I could tell more about the gamblers. I said I could and McDonald then said 'go ahead and indict him.'
"I said to Replogle on my way to the grand jury room, 'don't this go about what you and Austrian promised me?' He said, 'Sure it does.' Then I went before the grand jury."
"And you sailed right in and told of getting $10,000, didn't you?" asked Gorman. "Didn't you tell Austrian the whole story?"
"Yes, I did," replied Cicotte.
"Didn't you sign a statement there?"
"No."
"Didn't you cry bitterly in Judge McDonald's office?"
"There were tears in my eyes. I cried plenty of times, but not bitterly."
"In the grand jury room an immunity waiver was read to you?"
"Yes."
"You signed it?"
"I signed something; I don't know what it was."
"Didn't you tell Judge McDonald that you threw the 1919 series and got $10,000 for it?"
The defense objection to an answer was sustained.
Joe Jackson then testified.
Joe Jackson told of his visit to Mr. Austrian's office before going to the grand jury.
"Austrian said I would be indicted in a few minutes and that Cicotte had been down. Austrian then gave me my notice of suspension and when I said I had no lawyer he said I needed one very bad. Austrian promised if I'd tell what I knew I would not be prosecuted."
"Did Austrian tell you that Cicotte had been taken care of and you would be too?" asked Benedict Short, attorney for the defense.
"Yes He said that after confessing nothing would be done with me. Then they sent two bailiffts with me when I left to protect me, and the bailiffs and I went out and got good and drunk."
Under cross-examination Jackson said he had asked for bailiffs after he had confessed because "someone in the crowd around the court building might get next." Although the ball player declared he was not "scared of any ball players nor anyone else."
Too Drunk to Read.
"What did you read in the papers that night?" asked Gorman.
"I didn't read nothing. I already told you I was too drunk to read. The next day I was supposed to come back and see Judge McDonald, but I could not make it. I got teed up again that night. They had promised me they wouldn't take me into a jail house or fine me or even indict me. If they'd have promised me any more I wouldn't have taken it."
"Were you drunk when you testified before the grand jury?"
"No, but I might have been cooked up a little," Jackson replied.
Claude Williams, former White Sox pitcher, followed Jackson on the stand and said that Judge McDonald had not promised him anything but a just and square deal if he would confess and Replogle agreed "to stand back of anything Austrian said."
Asked by the state if he had not "come running to Judge McDonald for an immunity bath" and if Judge McDonald had not told him "you will get no immunity here," Williams replied:
During the 1921 trial, Eddie Cicotte testified about his confession, describing how Austrian and Replogle urged him to cooperate with promises of being 'taken care of,' though he denied any formal immunity deal was explicit. Joe Jackson also began testifying about his pre-grand jury meeting with Austrian, while other testimony addressed a gambler's attempt to sell stolen confession records to a newspaper.
Great Falls Tribune · 26 July 1921 · page 3
FORMER MEMBERS WHITE SOX TELL OWN STORY
When Harry Redmond, of East St. Louis, HI., was on the stand last Fri day, the defense asked him if Austrian had not called him a blackmailer and kicked him out of his office when Red mond came here to see Austrian about testifying. Mr. Austrian, on the stand Monday, denied the defense charges and said he knew nothing derogatory to Mr. Redmond. He said he understood that Redmond told "Kid" Gleason, manager of the White Sox, that he would furnish proof that the series had been thrown if $5,000 he lost on the series were returned to him.
See moreSee less
Eddie Cicotte was called to the stand to tell his own story of how he confessed after Replogle on the stand made a further denial that any prom ises of immunity had been made the men who confessed. Cicotte Tells Story.
At the Black Sox trial, stenographer Walter Smith began reading Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession, but defense objections over wording like 'ball player' and 'infielders' forced a court adjournment for conference with Judge Friend. The article also notes upcoming testimony on Jackson and Williams' confessions and a planned grand jury probe into an alleged $10,000 bribe related to testimony.
Grand Forks Herald · 26 July 1921 · page 8
14**1 ..» ^Jhicago, July 26.—When Walter J. Pth. coart stenographer, -who took Eddie Cicotte's grand jury con pi jrion,'began reading the' confession iS'T^-the. baseball trial today, so many ^"wections were raised by the defense i~f.. it was necessary to adjourn court S ,%fi mporarily while the attorneys went conference with Judge Hugo .end. iSince a confession can be used 5y against the man making it. Smith not allowed to mention any name Jjsepit Cicotte's. The defense main ..^ft/^ned that such words as "ball play 5d" "outfielders" and "inflelders" i'm1 •to were barred.
See moreSee less
ftdgeFriend ordered the attorneys |Sf "rtijch an agreement on the wording Ij.Jrc ntbe confession before presenting 8-'* i®m -in. court, but after two hours of Bf' "jfument only two pages of Cicotte's irty page statement had been re 'iedv "indications were that it would c»-u»i-v?e all day to'revise the three con jfl wj uaiona. T» Austrian to Take Stand, •v 'Smith was on the stand yesterday, court adjourned before he had J.d Cicotte's confession. The ste- /graphers who took down the eon- ^^sions of Joe Jackson and Claude :'l€ .lliams, former White Sox players, .re expected to follow Smith on the }5RT fbd. and Alfred Austrian, attorney [ifjtf S the Chicago American league, will Hftl engthen the state's case by telling V4 the confessions Cicotte, Jackson ..id Williams made to him before go lf to the grand jury room. irh'e confession testimony is ex ,'Jsted to consume the entire day.
Bill Burns, a former player turned state's witness, gave sensational testimony describing how Chick Gandil, Eddie Cicotte, and six other White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for money from Abe Attell and others. Former teammates Nemo Leibold and John Collins also appeared as witnesses for the state.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 26 July 1921 · page 4
recent pictures with Moore. The couple were secretly married and it was gome days before their honeymoon spot was discovered, , At right. Bill Burns, testifying in baseball trial, and, together. Nemo Lelbold and John Collins, two other state's witnesses. The testimony of Bill Burns, former big league ball player, stands out as the sensation of the trial of the former members of the Chicago White Sox for the alleged throwing of the world's series of 1919. Burns, indicted, turned state's evidence with the promise of immunity and has told the whole story of how Chick Gandil, Kddie Cicotte and six other members of the team agreed to lose when promised money by Abe Attell and others implicated in the deal.
See moreSee less
Nemo Leibold and John Collins, former mem bers of the Chicago club and now with the Red Sox, were snapped while waiting to testify for the state. machine had to be placed twelve a record of about forty feature photoplays for himself.
During the Black Sox trial, the defense raised numerous objections when prosecutors tried to introduce Eddie Cicotte's 30-page grand jury confession, forcing Judge Friend to adjourn court. The judge ordered attorneys to revise the confession's wording to remove all names except Cicotte's own, a process that moved very slowly.
The Barre Daily Times · 26 July 1921 · page 1
CICOTTE'S CONFESSION IN BASEBALL SCANDAL WAS BITTERLY FOUGHT
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Ban Johnson, president of the American League, charged that gambler Arnold Rothstein paid $10,000 for stolen confessions belonging to the indicted White Sox players. Rothstein denied the charges the following day.
The Laramie Republican · 26 July 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
ROTHSTEIN DENIES HE PAID THOUSANDS FOR STOLEN PAPERS (By Associated Press.) New York, July 26.—Charges made by Ban Johnson, president of the American league yesterday, that Arnold Rothstein, of this city, paid $19,000 for the stolen confessions of the indicted White Sox players were denied today by Rothstein.
The report identifies Judge Hugo Friend of Chicago as presiding over the hearing of the indicted White Sox players. They are being tried for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series.
The Laramie Republican · 26 July 1921 · page 1
Hearing Case Against the Indicted Black Sox
Judge Hugo Friend, of Chicago, be fore whom the Indicted White Sox players are being tried for tho alleged' j throwing of the 1 1919world series. j
A witness named Burns, granted immunity for his testimony, stated he was promised $1,100 by the indicted White Sox players to act as a go-between with gamblers, though he says he never received the money. A photo accompanying the report shows Burns on the witness stand during cross-examination.
The Laramie Republican · 26 July 1921 · page 4
' << iff been promised Immunity for his story, said he was .promised >l,lOO by the White Sox players, since indicted, for acting as a go-between for them and the gamblers, but he added, he never got tlie money. The photo shows Burna as ho appeared on the stand during tu« grilling.
At the Black Sox trial in Chicago, stenographer Walter J. Smith began reading Eddie Cicotte's confession from his shorthand notes, prompting numerous defense objections over wording that could implicate other players. Judge Friend recessed court so attorneys could negotiate acceptable phrasing before the confession could be presented to the jury.
Paper unidentified · 26 July 1921 · page 1
PROBE OF NEW BALL SCANDAL TO BEGIN
Court Takes Long Recess into conference with Judge Hugo Friend. Since a confession can be used only against the man making it. Smith was not allowed to mention any name ex cept Cicotte’s. The defense maintained that such words as 'ball players,’’ “outfielders” and '’infielders” also were barred. Judge Friend ordered the attorneys to reach an agreement ou the word ing of the confession before present ing them in court, but after two hours of argument only two pages of Cl cote’s thirty-page statement hod been revised. Indications were that it would take all day to revise the three confessions.
See moreSee less
The confessions finally were read to the jury by Edward Prindlvllle of the prosecution, the revision of them making it almost impossible for Smith to read them from his notes. The defense agreed not to dispute the authenticity of the confessions. game postponed; rain.
Court stenographer Walter L. Smith read Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession to the jury after lengthy disputes over revising the wording for admissibility. Meanwhile, authorities announced plans for a new grand jury probe into an alleged $10,000 bribe related to testimony in the original scandal.
Paper unidentified · 26 July 1921 · page 1
PROBE OF NEW BALL ,SCANDAL TO BEGIN. CHICAGO, July at. Walter L. Smith, court stenogrpaher who took down the alleged confession of Eddy? Cicottc to the grand'jury, this morn ing l»egan reading Cicotte's confession from his shorthand notes when the trial of former White Box players and alleged gamblers charged with con spiring to throw the 1919 world scries was resumed. Smith was on the stand yesterday but court adjourned before he had read Cicotte’s confession. Tho steno graphers who took down the confes sions of Joe Jackson and Claude Wil liams.
See moreSee less
former White Sox players, were expected to follow Smith on tnc stand and Alfred Austrian, attorney for the Chicago American league club, will strengthen the state's case by telling of the confessions Cicotte. Jack son and Williams made to him before going to the grand jury room. Harry Brigham, foreman of the grand jury before whom the confessions made will be called to verify the court reporters' stenographic stories. Meanwhile preparations are going forward for the proposed investigation by a grand jury of the newest tiase ball scandal, the alleged >IO.OOO bribe given for the testimony presented to the first grand jury while state's at torneys have also announced a wider Investigation of the 1919 scandal and other possible indictments in case con victions are secured In the present cases.
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
During the Black Sox trial, defense attorneys objected so strongly to stenographer Walter Smith reading Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession that court was temporarily adjourned. Judge Hugo Friend ruled the confession could only be used against Cicotte himself, barring mention of any other defendants' names.
The Laramie Republican · 27 July 1921 · page 1
HE WILL BE CONFINED TO NAME OF ONE MAN AND CANNOT USE OTHERS
By th* Associated Pi-m*. Chicago, July 26.—When Walter J. Smith, the court stenographer, who took down Eddie Cicotte's grand jury con fession, began reading the confession at the baseball trial to day, so many objections were raised by the defense that it was necessary to adjourn court temporarily while the attorneys went into conference with Judge Hugo Friend. Since the con fession can be used only against the man making it. Smith was not allowed to mention any name except Cicotte’s. The defense maintained that such words INQUEST HELU as "ballplayers,” "outfielders,” etc., were barred.
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 26 July 1921
Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.
As the Black Sox conspiracy trial entered its final stages of state testimony, confessions by Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson were read to the jury. The defense announced that Gandil, Weaver, Risberg, and Felsch would testify in their own behalf, with the state expected to rest its case the next day.
Norwich Bulletin · 27 July 1921 · page 1
Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Claude Williams, the three players who con fessed to the grand jury last fall that they were paid to throw games, also may take the stand in their own defense. The state will hmsn us case tomor row. The defense announcement came after the confession of Cicotte, Williams and Jackson had been read to the jury to
Grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams were read to the jury, detailing payments and the conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series. The defense announced it would rest its case soon, while the state considered calling Bill Maharg to corroborate Bill Burns' testimony.
Norwich Bulletin · 27 July 1921 · page 1
day. Previously, it had been understood that the defense would depend on trying to disprove various details of the testimony of Bill Burns and othei' state witnesses, on statements from Chicago and Cincin nati players that they saw nothing wrong with the 1919 world series, and on the contention that even if ihere was a con spiracy -to throw games, it never was carried out and if it was it was not il legal. Most of the Wnite Sox team have been called as witnesses and today "Dutch" Ruether, now with Brooklyn, but who pitched the first game of the 1919 se ries for Cincinnati, was subpoenaed by the defense.
See moreSee less
Court adjourned this morn ing while the attorneys went over the grand jury confessions, editing them for presentation at the afternoon session. The actual transcripts of the confes sions varied but little from the frequentr ly published reports of them. Cicotte confirmed some of the BUI Burns' testimony, mentioning the meet ings Burns said were held in New York, Cincinnati and Chicago, although men tion of Burns himself o of other play ers said to have been present was stricken out. The former pitcher told of hitting Rath, the first man up in the first game, while trying to walk him. but said he played his best after that. "I pitcher by best afterwards," said Cicotte, "I didn't care what happened. They could have had my heart and soul If I could have gotten out of the deal I guess that was the trouble; I tried too hard and played poorly as a result." Speaking of another game Cicotte said that while playing he "wished some one
During the Black Sox trial, portions of the confessions by Jackson, Cicotte, and Williams were read to the jury with other names deleted by agreement of lawyers. Billy Maharg is set to testify next, and the state expects to rest its case soon, with Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson seen as most likely to be convicted.
New-York Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 5
state official to-night when he named Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson as three of the five most in dangar of conviction thus far in the case. Doubt as to whether the other six of the eleven defendants would be j fcund guilty was freely expressed, j Those who have been hardest hit are "Chick" Gandil, named by Burns as the leader of the eight Sox players who agreed to throw the games; David Zelcer. the Des Moines gambler, point? ed out by the same witness as the lieutenant of Arnold Rothstein, New York gambler, and the three who con? fessed. Jackson, Cicotte and Williams not
The state calls Bill Burns and Billy Maharg to testify, implicating Gandil, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Zelcer in the fix. Confessions from Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson are read into the record with names of other conspirators redacted.
New-York Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Jury Gets Part Of Confession Made by 3 Sox
Names of Others Mentioned by Jackson, Cicotte and Williams Are Deleted by Agreement of Lawyers
See moreSee less
State Will Close To-day
Rothstein Denies He Got Missing Papers; New York Lawyer Admits He Did
Special Dispatch to The Tribune
CHICAGO, July 26.—Billy Maharg, the Philadelphia boxer, Nemesis of the "Black Sox" and their gambler friends, will be called to the stand to-morrow to testify as to his knowledge of the conception and carrying out of the 1919 baseball scandal. Maharg is chiefly responsible for the present plight of the indicted Sox players and the gamblers. He went into the wilds of Texas and brought out Bill Burns, whose testimony was vital to the prosecution. Maharg is expected to verify everything Burns told and may add a few thrillers of his own.
With Maharg's testimony in, the state expects to close its case to-morrow. Judge Friend gave warning to-day that the presentation of the state's case must be finished to-morrow, even if a night session is necessary.
Those Who Confessed in Most Danger
Indications that the players who made confessions would be the hardest hit was seen in the statement of a state official to-night when he named Cicotte, Claude Williams and Joe Jackson as three of the five most in danger of conviction thus far in the case. Doubt as to whether the other six of the eleven defendants would be found guilty was freely expressed. Those who have been hardest hit are "Chick" Gandil, named by Burns as the leader of the eight Sox players who agreed to throw the games; David Zelcer, the Des Moines gambler, pointed out by the same witness as the lieutenant of Arnold Rothstein, New York gambler, and the three who confessed.
Jackson, Cicotte and Williams not only name themselves, but are also named by Burns as players who were willing to sell out their team for their "price" in greenbacks. The other five players have thus far only been mentioned as having been present when the conspiracy was made.
Attorneys Ben Short, Michael Ahern and Tom Nash contend that this evidence is insufficient to warrant a guilty verdict. Every effort will be made when they begin producing witnesses Thursday to discredit Burns's testimony. As to the other three gamblers, Attorneys Harry Berger and Max Lusker deny that the state has a chance to convict. They point out that thus far the only evidence produced against the Levi brothers, of Des Moines, is that David Levi bet right on the series and seemed to know that the series was fixed.
Against Carl Zork the state has the testimony of Harry Redmon, East St. Louis moving picture theater owner. He testified that Zork openly boasted in his presence that the series was fixed and that "a little red-headed fellow from St. Louis had fixed it."
Because of the number of times the confessions have been read and reread during the preliminary hearings, the actual placing of the players' statement in evidence to-day was a rather tame affair.
Confessions Deleted
The confessions read into the record were much deleted, as all matter referring to others aside from the three men making the confessions was cut out under an agreement among the attorneys. Blanks were substituted for the names of the other conspirators. The confessions, as deleted, pictured the Sox as men who had made a bad bargain and then repented. After selling themselves and their teammates and owners out, the playing of the series was not only a competition of playing ability but a battle between themselves and their consciences.
Every one of the three told the grand jury they were sorry. Jackson and Cicitte declared that after taking the money they still played to win.
The mystery of the missing records was further complicated to-day when Richard Fallon, a New York lawyer, said that he had obtained the copies of the confessions through the Chicago State Attorney's office. Denial was made here that this statement was true. Arnold Rothstein, the New York gambler, also denied to-day that he had caused the records to be stolen as charged by Ban Johnson, president of the American League.
Rothstein Orders Suit Filed Against Johnson
Arnold Rothstein, when asked yesterday about the communication which Ban Johnson sent to Robert Crowe, Illinois State Attorney, and in which he charged that Rothstein paid $10,000 for the grand jury confessions of three Chicago players, said that he had directed his attorney to file suit against the president of the American League.
In a signed statement Rothstein said: "Mr. Johnson gives me the opportunity I have long sought to bring this entire matter before a tribunal, when my entire vindication may be had.
"Mr. Johnson has made certain statements about me, which if not true, become libelous and afford me ample opportunity to present this entire situation to a court of law, where my standing in regard to the matter may be known and understood."
Rothstein added that he was ready to go to Chicago on two minutes' notice and appear at the trial at the request of either side. He said that in case of such an appearance he would willingly sign a waiver of immunity.
Deleted confessions of three Black Sox players were entered into evidence at preliminary hearings, portraying them as repentant after taking bribe money. Separately, a dispute arose over missing confession records, with Rothstein denying Ban Johnson's claim that he paid for stolen grand jury statements and announcing a libel suit against Johnson.
New-York Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 5
Filed Against Johnson Arnold Rothstein, when asked yes? terday about the communication which Ban Johnson sent to Robert Crowe, Illinois State Attorney, and in which he charged that Rothstein paid $10,000 for the grand jury confessions of three Chicago players, said that he had di? rected his attorney to file suit against the president of the American League. In a signed statement Rothstein said: "Mr. Johnson gives me the op? portunity I have long sought to bring this entire matter before a tribunal, when my entire vindication may be had. "Mr.
See moreSee less
Johnson has made certain state? ments, about me, which if not true, become libelous and afford me ample opportunity to present this entire sit? uation to a court of law, where my standing in regard to the matter may be known and understood." Rothstein added that he was ready to go to Chicago on two minutes' notice and appear at the trial at the request of either side. He said that in case of such an appearance he would will? ingly sign a waiver of immunity. Body of Missing Auto Dealer Found With Skull Crushed
At the Black Sox trial, the written confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams were read to the jury, largely matching previously published accounts of the fix. The defense announced it would call Weaver, Risberg, and Felsch to testify, with the state set to finish its case the next day.
The Pensacola Journal · 27 July 1921 · page 5
The state will finish Its case to morrow. The defense announcement came aft er the confession of Cicotte, Williams and Jackson had been read to the Jury today. Previously it" had been understood that the defense would depend on try ing to disprove various details of the testimony of Bill Burns and other state witnesses on statements from Chicago and Cincinnati players that they eaw nothing wrong with the 1919 world series and on the contention that even If there was a conspiracy to throw games, it never was carried out and if it was It was not illegal.
See moreSee less
Most of the White Sox team have been called as witnesses and today "Dutch" Ruether now with Brooklyn, but who pitched the first game of the 1919 series for Cincinnati, was sub poenaed by the defense. The actual transcripts of the con fessions varied but little from the fre quently published reports of themCicotte's confirmed some of Bill Burns' testimony, mentioning the meet ings Burns said were held in New York, Cincinnati and Chicago, al though mention of Burns himself or of other players said to have been present was stricken out. The confessions of Jackson and of Williams told how they were given $3,000 dollars each after the fourth game, being promised twenty thou sand dollars each. Both denied mak ing intentional errors but said they "might have tried harder."
During the Black Sox trial, the defense announced it will put at least four former Chicago White Sox players on the stand to testify in their own behalf, including Gandil, named by state witnesses as an organizer of the conspiracy. The report also describes a near fist fight between a judge and defense counsel, and an admission by the special prosecutor about notes given to a local newspaper editor.
The Pensacola Journal · 27 July 1921 · page 5
Messrs. I their aunt, jurs. u. it. jinuara. tonight. Mr. an,d Mrs. L. M. Rhoda, from Chick Gandil, named by state wit Milton, are the guests of Mrs. W. J. nesses as one of the organizers of the Japanese'Influence From Paris!
The defense in the Black Sox conspiracy trial announced that Gandil, Weaver, Risberg, and Felsch will testify, while Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams may also take the stand. The confessions of Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson were read to the jury as the state neared the end of its case.
Great Falls Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 8
4 INDICTED SOX TO STAND FOR DEFENSE IN BASEBALL SCANDAL
Announcement Made. Chicago, July 26.—The defense in the baseball trial will send at least four of the former Chicago White Sox players charged with conspiracy to throw the 1919 world series to the wit ness stand to testify, it was announced Tuesday night as the state entered the last half of the ninth inning of its presentation of evidence. Chick Gan dil, named by state witnesses as an was gone." organizer of the alleged ,$100,000 sell out; Buck Weaver, third baseman; Swede Kisberg, shortstop, and Happy Felsch, ««ntesfielder. are the men it was announced would testify.
See moreSee less
Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson and Burns. Claude Williams, the three players who confessed to the grand jury that they were paid to throw games, also may take the stand. The state will finish testimony. its case Wednesday. The defense announcement came after the confessions of Cicotte. Wil liams and Jackson had been read to the jury Tuesday. "Dutch" Ruether Called.
The grand jury confessions of Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams were read to the jury at the Black Sox trial, with names of other implicated parties largely struck out. Cicotte's testimony described hitting a batter intentionally, his regret over the fix, and willingness to return the $10,000 he was paid.
Great Falls Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 8
lished reports. Cicotte confirmed some of Bill Burns' testimony, mentioning the ^ meetings Burns said were held in New York, Cincinnati, and Chicago, although men tion of Burns or of other players said to have been present was stricken out.
During the Black Sox trial, Cicotte's and Williams' statements and denials were discussed, with Williams claiming he simply walked batters rather than deliberately erring. Arnold Rothstein denied Ban Johnson's charge that he paid $10,000 for stolen grand jury confessions, while court wrangled over how Cicotte's confession could be read to the jury without implicating others.
Great Falls Tribune · 27 July 1921 · page 8
pr esident of the American league, j Monday morning, that Arnold RotJ)- j stein of this city, had paid .$10.-1 000 for the stolen confessions of j the indicted White Sox players were denied Tuesday by Rothstein. He re iterated his denial of any connection with the 1919 world series scandal. Denies Records Stolen.
Billy Maharg testified at the Black Sox trial about Rothstein's $100,000 payment arranged through Attell, including a telegram confirming $20,000 wired. He denied being former catcher 'Peaches' Graham, described his background, and denied seeking a reward from Comiskey despite cross-examination by defense attorney Benedict Short.
The Evening World · 27 July 1921 · page 15
Rothstcln to put up the $100,000 and that $20,000 would 'be given the players after car.h game. "That night Attcll told mo tho same thing, explaining that Itothstein had put tip tho money because Attell saved his lifo once, hater Attcll showed me a telegram which read: " 'Have wired you twenty grand, wntvlng Identification.' "It was signed 'A. It.' " The witness confirmed Hurnn's story -fif a meeting In Chicago of himself. Attell, Hums and a Hi. Louis man who was willing to put up $100.00(1 in have games thrown, Malmrg denied that he was "Peaches" Ciraham, lormer major league catcher, as the defense ha claimed.
See moreSee less
"Hecause my name spells 'Graham' backward, lots of persons think that It Is my real name," he ."uld "My name Is Billy Maharg. I was raNed on a farm and was a prizefighter from 1897 to 1307." Jlnharg related how Man Johnson, President of the American Inigiic.
A Chicago report says no court proceedings authorized access to Grand Jury minutes related to the Black Sox confessions, which reportedly vanished between two state's attorneys' terms. New York lawyer William J. Fallon, representing Abe Attell, explains he got a copy through an associate named Berger who had a contact in the State Attorney's office.
The Evening World · 27 July 1921 · page 15
IN WHITE SOX CASE
World Serlis baseball games, told u reporter for The levelling World to day Just how ho obtained a copy o' the Grand Jury minutes, includlm copies of the ro-called confessions or the Indicted White Sox playois. "I went to Chicago and ofiered t i surrender Abe Attell," said Mr. Fallon. "I stipulated that the State Attor ney's off ico should place Attcll on trial immediately. This they icfused :n di. I then told them 'to get Attell themselvesand left Chicago "While theie I engaged a man named lletgi'i tn repieMiii min the Attell uise In l'lili.i,:u lleigei Intel told me he believed ho i.iiitd obtain a copy ot the Gland lury minuiis l.i'iger torwai'iU'd them to me in New York.
See moreSee less
I iimli-r.'sfiiml that lie had ,i friend In the State Attornej ' atltie from whom ho obtained the iniiiiiii . I cannot understand that there 1-. anything unethical in ibis piocediir."
Arnold Rothstein denied charges made by American League president Ban Johnson that he paid $10,000 for stolen confessions from the indicted White Sox players. The denial was reported by the Associated Press from New York.
The Laramie Republican · 27 July 1921 · page 1
ROTHSTEIN DENIES HE PAID THOUSANDS FOR STOLEN PAPERS
FOR STOLEN PAPERS (By Assectetod Press.) New York, July 26.—Charges made by Ban Johnson, president of the American league yesterday, that Ar nold Rothstein, of thio city, paid $lO,- •000 for the stolen confessions of the indicted White Sox players were de nied today by Rothstein.
A photograph caption identifies Judge Hugo Friend of Chicago as the judge presiding over the trial of the indicted White Sox players accused of fixing the 1919 World Series. It notes the players are being tried for the alleged scheme.
The Laramie Republican · 27 July 1921 · page 1
Hearing Case Against the Indicted "Black Sox"
91 Judge Hugo Friend, of Chicago, be fore whom the indicted White Sox players are being tried for the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series.
The state concluded its case in the Chicago baseball trial after Billy Maharg testified, corroborating Bill Burns' account of the conspiracy by White Sox players to throw the 1919 World Series. The court indicated Weaver, Felsch, and Cicotte could go free based on the evidence presented.
Paper unidentified · 27 July 1921 · page 1
STATE RESTS IN TRIAL OF SOX PLAYERS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Billy Maharg, final witness for the state in the Chicago White Sox trial, described meetings involving gambler Bill Burns, players Eddie Cicotte and Chick Gandil, and financier Arnold Rothstein. He detailed how the players allegedly agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for $100,000, with Abe Attell securing the funds from Rothstein.
Paper unidentified · 27 July 1921 · page 1
Informs the Prosecution ' CHICAGO. July 27 Billy’ Maharg , Philadelphia, pal of Bill Bumsahd Abe Attell during the fi rmaUon-ef'the alleged conspiracy for the throwing, of the 1919 world aerie* today told his story e* the reported 1100 000 sol - out of the indicted Chicago White Sox players. Maharg was the final wit nm Tor the state in the baseball trial. I He was raid by Burna to have been present at several meetings of the gamblers and p’ayers where plana for the alleged game throwing were tmulT. Maharg began his testimony fcy tolling of the meeting he witnessed between Bums and Eddie Cicotte at ( the Ansonia hotel in New York in September, 1919.
See moreSee less
( ' Chick Gandil also was there,” said i Maharg. ‘ "1 heard Cicotte say that if the Sox won the pennant the world series could be thrown for 9100,000 Gandil said the players would throw the games in any order desired. ' After Ciootte and Gandil left Burns re;»eated the conversation to me as I had not hoard all of it. He said Ci cotte and Gandil had agreed to sea that the scries wan thrown for 9100, L 000. I went to New York with Bums , and saw ArnoM Rothstein. "Burna told Rothstein the Sox had agreed to throw the series for 9100.- • OOd and naked Rothstein to put it up. . but Rothstein refused. I ' I went hack to Philadelphia. Then ■ I got a telegram from Burns to meet r him on a trail for Cincinnati. ' I went to Cincinnati, getting there f the morning of the first game. I met • Burns nt the Sinton hotel that even o Ing. He told me Abe Attell got Roth s stein to put un the 9100,000 and that 920.000 would be given the players
Billy Maharg testified in the Black Sox trial, detailing meetings between Burns, Attell, Cicotte and Gandil in New York and Cincinnati, and how Attell sent $10,000 to players through Burns. Judge Friend indicated he would direct not-guilty verdicts for Weaver, Felsch and Zork unless more evidence was presented, though the state resisted dropping the charges.
During the Black Sox trial, Judge Hugo Friend indicates he will not allow guilty verdicts against Buck Weaver and Happy Felsch, prompting the players to publicly celebrate their expected exoneration. However, their return to baseball remains uncertain, pending the decision of Commissioner Landis and Owner Comiskey, who has vowed none of the suspended players will ever play for the White Sox again.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 July 1921 · page 8
Two Indicted Stars See Chance to Get Back in Sox Togas Weaver and Felsch Encouraged Over Action of Judge—Up to Landis, However.
Over Action of Judge—Up to Landis, However. CHICAGO, July 28— Although techni cally listed among the defendants in the famous Black Sox case of the 1919 w orld s series, George (Buck) Weaver and Oscar (Happy) Felsch, virtually are free today of charges that they participated in the plot to "throw'' the series. Judge Hugo M. Friend has made It plain he will not countenance a verdict of "guilty" against these playeru. Weaver and Felsch were openly Jubi lant when court reconvened this morning. The *mi!!ng "Buck” confidently predicted he would be playing again with the White Sox within a few weeks.
See moreSee less
Whether or not Weaver and Felsch will be restored to good standing in organised baseball, however, depends upon the ac tion of Judge K. M. Landis, arbiter of baseball affairs, Judge Landis has given no indication of what his attitude toward the players will be. .William L Veeck, president of the Cub*, was the only basebal official who would comment on tbe case, Y'eeck said : ‘'Whether they play ball again la some thing for Judge Landis to decide. But thsy can't p'ay ball for the We don't want them.'' A petition signed by 10,060 fans ask ing the reinstatement of Weaver is to be filed with Owner Com'skey of the White Sox. as soon as the player Is ex onerated. according to Ms attorney, Thomas D Nash.
The report covers the ongoing Black Sox trial, noting that reinstatement for suspended players depends on Judge Landis, with Cubs' president Veeck commenting that his team doesn't want them. It also mentions a fan petition for Weaver's reinstatement, Comiskey's refusal to ever let the players return, and expectations that Weaver, Felsch, and Risberg would testify in their defense.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 July 1921 · page 8
onerated. according to Ms attorney, Thomas D Nash. Owner Comiskey stated shortly after the seven player* were suspended fol lowing Indictment that none of them would ever play for him again, even If tb**y should he freed. Wearer and Felsch were expected to clinch fh'-lr freedom today when they were scheduled to take the witness stand tnd answer a few perfunctory questions. Swede Rlsberg was also expected to tes tify. denying ha had any part In the conspiracy Besides Weaver and Felsch. Judge Friend also Indicated that ao conclusive evidence Involving Carl Zork of 8t Loui*.
Attorneys for the remaining Black Sox defendants and an alleged gambler consider resting their case, confident the prosecution has failed to prove its charges. Former teammates John Collins and Nemo Leibold testify about whether the accused players performed to their best ability during the 1919 World Series.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 July 1921 · page 8
Get Results. CHICAGO. July 28.—The baseball scan dal case will be In the hands of the Jury within twenty-four hours It was Indi cated today by attorneys for the remain ing “Black Sox” and the one alleged gambler involved in the “throwing’’ of the 1919 world's series. The attorneys declared they would con fer during noon recess upon the advisa bility of resting the case and allow the jury to decide the fa f e of the defendant*, so confident were they that “the State had proved nothing.” The action of Judge Hugo M.
See moreSee less
Friend yesterday in nolle prosaing the case* of Ben and Louis Levi and his statement that he probably would set aside a ver dict of guilty if the jury returned It in the case of ’’Buck” Weaver and “Happy" Felsch and Carl Zork, are understood to have Influenced the defense in consider ing this move. Resting by the defense would mean that the remaining five “Black Sox” would not have to take the stand, and that the members of the White Sox team who were subpoenaed from Washington yesterday with Manager William Gleason and Captain Eddie Collins would not have to testify. The attorneys who were to confer dur ing recess of the court on whether the J case will be rested were James C. O'Brien, Michael Ahern, Thomas D. Nash, Bene dict Short, Max Lester, Harry Berger and j A. M. Frumberg.
Bill Burns, a self-confessed fixer of the World Series, testified for twelve grueling hours under cross-examination that none of the defense attorneys could break. He stated he had been promised immunity and that White Sox players had promised him $1,100 for acting as a go-between with gamblers, but he never received the money.
Capital Journal · 28 July 1921 · page 4
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
In the Chicago trial of the indicted White Sox players, Judge Friend ruled against the prosecution twice, barring the confession of "Happy" Felsch from evidence and tentatively denying the state's request to recall defendant David Zelser to the witness stand. The report frames these as defeats for the prosecution's case.
The Siftings Herald · 29 July 1921 · page 1
Chicago, July 29.—The state met defeat twee today in the trial of the when indicted White Sox players alleged Judge Eriend barred the confession of “Happy” Felsch and tentatively denied prosecutions’ at tempt to recall David Zelser, defend ant, to the witness stand.
Five Chicago White Sox players, including Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, and Manager Gleason, testified that the indicted players were practicing in Cincinnati during hours when Bill Burns claimed the fix deal was completed. The defense rested its case after this testimony, with state rebuttal expected to begin the next day.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 29 July 1921 · page 1
Surprise By Associated Pres* Chicago, July 28.—The defense In the baseball trial rested its case to night. The action was taken after five Chicago While .Sox players, forced by law to abandon their team in the eafct and journey 900 miles to testify, had made statements from the witness stand which tended to disprove some of the most important points in the state's evidence againat their former team mates, charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati. Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, Dick Wilkinson and Manager William Gleason of the White Sox testified at a night session of court that the seven former players on trial were at Redland Field, Cincinnati, practicing from 10 to 12 a. m., the day before the first 1919 world's series games.
Defense witnesses including Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, and manager Kid Gleason testified that the seven defendants were practicing at Redland Field during the hours Bill Burns claimed he finalized the fix deal. The defense abruptly rested its case, surprising the state, which will begin rebuttal testimony the next day.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 29 July 1921 · page 1
TRIAL AT CHICAGO
IMayera at Practice. Gleaion Gleason said he thought Weaver was at practice, ami was sure Felsch Risbery, Gandil, Williams. Jackson, and Clcotte, the other player-defend anis. were there. “They weren't in the Sinton. then, at the hours Burns says he talked
The defense rested its case after five White Sox players testified that the seven indicted players were practicing at Redland Field during the exact hours Bill Burns claimed he was finalizing the fix deal. The state was set to begin rebuttal testimony as the judge considered night sessions to speed the trial.
Great Falls Tribune · 29 July 1921 · page 8
Them in Hotel Room. Chicago. July 28—The defense in the baseball trial rested its case Thurs day night after five Chicago White Sox players had made statements from the witness stand tending to disprove some of the most, important points in the state's evidence against their former team mates, charged with con 8piriug to throw the 1910 world series to Cincinnati. Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, Dick Kerr, Roy Wilkinson and Manager William Gleason, of the AA'hite Sox.
Defense witnesses, including Manager Gleason, Schalk, Collins, and Dick Kerr, testified about the players' whereabouts during practice before the first 1919 World Series game, contradicting Bill Burns' testimony about meetings to arrange the fix. The defense abruptly rested its case amid a dispute over character witnesses, leaving many scheduled witnesses uncalled.
Great Falls Tribune · 29 July 1921 · page 8
week. Asked Some Questions. Testimony of the players said to have been double-crossed by the men for whom they were testifying, was brief, each man being asked the same questions by the defense attorneys, who had subpoenaed them, forcing them to take part in the trial. Manager Gleason said he left Chi cago with his team Monday night, two days before the first game. . "We reached Cincinnati about 8 a, m.,"' said Gleason. "and went to the Hinton hotel. A little before 10 the men went to Redland field for practice. We got back to the hotel a little be fore noon." Gleason said he thought Weaver was at practice, and he was sure Felsch, Rishberg, Gandil. Williams, Jar-kson Cicotte, the other player-defendants, were there. All at Practice.
The defense abruptly rested its case despite waiting witnesses, after a dispute over character testimony for Carl Zork. White Sox secretary Harry Grabiner's financial records showed the club profited over $409,000 in six years, undermining claims the 1919 series fix hurt the team financially.
Great Falls Tribune · 29 July 1921 · page 8
Had Loss in 1918. The figures» showed gross receipts of $2,622,858 for the six years. In only one year was there a loss—1918, when the war cut the season short. The deficit then was $51,673. Grabiner's testimony also showed the tremendous expense of a major league club, ranging from more than $225.000 in 1915 to nearly $700,000 in 1920, when gross receipts were $910, 30(5. Charles A. Comiskey, president of the club, draws an annual salary of $50.000, Grabiner testified. Previous to Grabiner's testimony, the defense called John Collins and Harry Leibold, former White Sox players, now with Boston Red Sox, an ,j Walter Reuther.
See moreSee less
who pitched for Cincinnati in the 1919 world's series. It had been planned to have these men tell whether they thought the 1919 sc ries was on the square, but on numer ous objections by the prosecution, they were withdrawn. Attorneys for Carl Zork of St. Louis presented numerous witnesses whose testimony was intended to offset that given against him. Alibi for Zelcer.
The passage reports that Judge Hugo Friend of Chicago is presiding over the trial of the indicted White Sox players accused of throwing the 1919 World Series. It includes a photo caption identifying the judge hearing the case.
Great Falls Tribune · 29 July 1921 · page 9
Hearing Case Against Indicted White Sox< V ■trvd m mm Judge Hugo Friend, of Chicago, be fore^ whom the indicted White Sox players are being tried for the alleged t rowin g cf tfce 10jL8 world series, '
John J. McGraw, manager of the New York Nationals, denied on July 29 that he had made any proposals to Buck Weaver, one of the indicted White Sox players. The brief item appears amid unrelated advertisements and department store listings.
Grand Forks Herald · 29 July 1921 · page 10
NO DEAL WITH WEAVER
Graw, manager of the New York Na. •tionals denied today that he had made any proposals to Buck Weaver, one of the Indicted White Sox, in the
John McGraw denied making any proposal to Buck Weaver, one of the indicted White Sox players on trial, about playing for the Giants. He said he was at the courtroom to find NL President Heydler, and that Weaver merely shook his hand and wished the Giants well in the pennant race.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 29 July 1921 · page 6
PROPOSAL TO BUCK WEAVER CINCINNATI. July 2D.—John H. McGraw denied ho had made any proposal to Buck Weaver, one of the v Indicted White Sox, on trial to play 1 with the Giants. He also said he *
Giants manager John McGraw denied making any proposal to indicted White Sox player Buck Weaver to play for New York if acquitted. McGraw said he only visited Chicago to see Commissioner Landis about his own suspension and happened to encounter Weaver in the courtroom.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 July 1921 · page 13
NO OFFER TO WEAVER McGraw Denies He Made Proposal to Former Sox Player Cincinnati, July 2!). John J. Mc Giaw, manager of the Now York Na tionals, denied today that he had made nny proposal to Buck We.ner, one of the indicted White Sox on trial In Chicago, to jilnv with the Giants -UMir.iw said that he merely went to i Chicago to see Pieshhnt Ilc.wllor about his suspension nnd went to the court room to find air. Hejdlor. Ho said fuither that Woaier shook haniK with I him and expressed the hope that the I Giants would win the pennant.
See moreSee less
miic tilnnts' manager emnliat ca v j " - -ii-i.i.ii.Hii, nsserted that lie ncier broached t he subject of ienier pin j ing with the Giants in the event of his acquittal. "If ho is acquitted nnd Judge I.nndis glies bin. n dean bill of honesty, why then the Giants mm engageIn the bidding for Wenier," ho said.
During the Black Sox trial in Chicago, Judge Hugo Friend ruled that an alleged confession by Happy Felsch, in which he admitted receiving $5,000 to throw the 1919 World Series, could not be admitted as evidence. The defense also blocked the prosecution's attempt to recall defendant David Zelcer to the witness stand, with the case expected to reach the jury by early next week.
Paper unidentified · 29 July 1921 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CONFESSION OF FELSCH IS BARRED BY CHICAGO COURT
Defense Scores Two Important Points Today; Case to Reach Jury by Monday or Tuesday, Belief
See moreSee less
CHICAGO, July 29.—Fighting desperately in a final attempt to tighten the grip of the law on the defendants in the baseball trial, the state today twice met defeat when Judge Hugo Friend barred an alleged confession from "Happy" Felsch that he received $5,000 to throw the 1919 world's series and tentatively denied the prosecution's attempt to recall David Zelcer of Des Moines, Iowa, another defendant, to the witness stand. Felsch's statement was alleged to have been made to a local newspaper reporter just after the first indictments. The state maintained it had just learned of this statement but
Judge Friend held that it should have learned of it long ago and that "negligence in the state's attorney's office should not jeopardize a defendant's liberty."
The state announced that Joe Gilcon, formerly of St. Louis, would be its last witness, and that arguments then would begin. Each side will be allowed 10 hours of oratory and with only a half day session of court scheduled for tomorrow, the case may not reach the jury until late Monday or Tuesday.
FATHER OF "HAPPY" FELSCH DIES SUDDENLY.
CHICAGO, July 29.—Alfred Austrian, attorney for the Chicago American league baseball club, was the first witness summoned in rebuttal today by the state in the trial of former White Sox players and alleged gamblers indicted in connection with the 1919 world's series scandal.
"Happy" Felsch, former Sox outfielder and one of the defendants was excused from the courtroom today by Judge Friend, to go to Milwaukee when it was learned his father had died there.
The surprise action of the defense which followed testimony of White Sox players that tended to refute the statements of Bill Burns, star state's witness concerning the former Sox players on trial for conspiring to throw the 1919 world series, left future action on both sides a matter of conjecture but seemed to assure speedy ending of the trial with the case probably going to the jury Saturday night or Monday.
During the Black Sox trial, attorney Alfred Austrian was called as the state's first rebuttal witness. Happy Felsch was excused from court by Judge Friend to travel to Milwaukee following the sudden death of his father.
Paper unidentified · 29 July 1921 · page 1
FATHER OF "HAPPY" FELSCH DIES SUDDENLY
trian. attorney for the Chicago Amer | lean league baseball club, was the first I witness summoned in rebuttal today ■by the state in the trial of fobmer i White Sox players and alleged gamb 'lers indicted in connection with the 11913 world's series scandql. "Happy" Felsch, former Rox outI fielder and one -jf tho defendants was ! excused from the courtroom today by I Judge Friend, to ge *.a ABwaukee Caspar Batly
Special State's Attorney Prindeville delivered a closing argument for the prosecution, calling for guilty verdicts to preserve the honesty of baseball and America's honor, and requesting five-year prison terms and $2,000 fines for each defendant. The court adjourned until Monday when the defense would begin its argument, while the indicted players were reportedly planning a barnstorming tour.
The Cordova Daily Times · 30 July 1921 · page 1
PROSECUTION IN SOX TRIAL CLOSES CASE
While the special prosecutor was addressing the jury, demanding con viction, the indicted White Sox play-1 lers were planning a barnstorming tour; [of the country and have arranged an
State prosecutor Prindiville gave a two-hour closing argument calling the indicted White Sox players traitors who sold their souls for $100,000, focusing heavily on Cicotte, Jackson, Williams and Zelcer. The defense won a strategic victory by keeping Happy Felsch's alleged confession statement out of the court record, with the case expected to reach the jury by Tuesday or Wednesday.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 July 1921 · page 1
FINAL ARGUMENTS IN BASEBALL TRIAL
■ early Wednesday. Mr. Prindiville directed his works j mainly against Cicotte. Joe Jackson. ! Claude Williams and David Zclcer. : the latter identified by two state s witnesses as a man who under the
State's attorney Prindiville delivers closing arguments, focusing on Cicotte's confession of taking $10,000 to throw games and comparing it to Bill Burns' testimony. He also attacks Zelcer's alibi, linking him to Abe Attell and the money used to pay players.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 July 1921 · page 1
IN BASEBALL TRIAL
j mainly against Cicotte. Joe Jackson. ! Claude Williams and David Zclcer. : the latter identified by two state s witnesses as a man who under the name of Bennett, held organized the conspiracy. Similarity of Stories After outling details of the alleged conspiracy as related by Bill Burns. ’ who turned state’s evidence. Mr. Prindiville called the jury's attention to the similarity of Burns’ story and the confessions of Eddie Cicotte. tie was particularly bitter in speakinp of Cicotte. “This man. by his own confession, sat in his room at the Warner hotel here and arranged to receive $10,000 for the dirty work he planned," said Mr. Prindiville. “Then. Judas lfke.
Prosecutor Edward Prindiville opened closing arguments, calling the accused players traitors who sold out baseball for $100,000. The defense scored a win by keeping out an alleged admission by Happy Felsch that he was paid to throw games; the case was expected to reach the jury by Wednesday.
New-York Tribune · 30 July 1921 · page 5
State Asserts Cicotte Proved Burns Charges
Mr. Prindivilie directed his words mainly against Eddie Cicotte, "Chick" Gandil, Joe Jacison, Claude W.lliams and David Zelcer, the latter identified ] by two state's; witnesses aa a man who, under the name of Bennett, ' helped organize the alleged conspiracy ' for the throwing of the 1919 world' series. After outlining the details of the ; alleged conspiracy, as related by Bill j Burns, who turned state's evidence, Mr. \ ifindiville called the jury's attention to the similarity of Burns's story and ? the confession of Eddie Cicotte. He ; Tas particularly bitter in speaking of ?
See moreSee less
Cicotte. "This man, by his own confession, | sat in his room at the Warner Hotel | here and arranged to receive $i0,000? for the dirty work he planned," said ! Mr. Prindivilie. "Then, Juda3-!ike, he ' ??rent downstairs to hobnob with his ? innocent team mates and, in his own words, to aliay the suspicions of the: men he had just betrayed. "Be said he'd throw the ball over the fence, if necessary, to lose the first -rams. He confessed to Judge Charles A. McDonald, and then he went to the jury and confessed. And what happened in the first game? Cicotte, t&e American League's greatest pitcher, hurling with a heavy heart?by his own confession ? and a pocket made heavy by?$10,000 in graft, was beaten nice to one." Says Gandil Was One of Leaders Mr. Prindivilie declared the evidence prove,: Gandil one of the conspiracy Ssdera and that Williame and Jackson stood convicted by their own confes? sion.;. '*\\ iair.s and Jackson have admitted their guilt," he said. "What can you gentlemen do but go the limit in pun? ishing them?" "And this man Zelcer," he shouted. "He has tried to prove an alibi, to prove he is not the man Bennett who helped Abe Attell run this deal. "'" ? we proved that Abe Attell had thousands of dollars under the mat? tresses in his room at the Cincinnati Hotel. We proved there were suitcases of money there and that he took $10, 000 of this money against Bennett's wishea and gave it to Burns for the players and Burns gave it to Williams *nd Jackson. "Burns may be a squealer. But is he any worse than these defendants? Three of them squealecr. His story is as good as theirs?better, because he withstood two days of gruelling cross examination without changing a single main fact. "These men did what Abe Attell told them. Abe said. 'Lose the first two.' i They did. Abie said, 'Win the third.' They did."
State's attorney Prindiville delivers closing remarks targeting Cicotte, Gandil, Jackson, Williams, and Zelcer, citing Cicotte's confession about receiving $10,000 and deliberately losing the first game. He also references Bill Burns's testimony and evidence of cash at Attell's hotel room used to pay players.
New-York Tribune · 30 July 1921 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
State Asserts Cicotte Proved Burns's Charges
Prosecution Makes Bitter Attack on Accused Sox; Case Expected to Go to the Jury by Wednesday
See moreSee less
Defense Wins One Point
Felsch's Alleged Admission That He Got $5,000 for Throwing Game Barred
CHICAGO, July 29.—Final arguments in the baseball trial were begun to-day, with the state directing a two-hour attack on the defendants, in which the former White Sox players were pictured as "traitors who for $100,000 of dirty money sold their souls, betrayed their comrades and the public and conspired to make the only truly American pleasure and sport, baseball, a confidence game."
Edward Prindiville directed the prosecution's first fire in the final plea, his talk coming after the defense had won a battle of strategy from the state by keeping out of the record a statement "Happy" Felsch, former Sox centerfielder, is alleged to have made to a newspaper reporter that he was paid $50,000 to throw games.
Mr. Prindiville expects to finish his argument in a special session of court to-morrow. The defense pleas will take up Monday and possibly part of Tuesday, with George Gorman closing for the state late on Tuesday. The case is expected to be in the jury's hands late Tuesday or early Wednesday.
Main Attack on Five Defendants
Mr. Prindiville directed his words mainly against Eddie Cicotte, "Chick" Gandil, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams and David Zelcer, the latter identified by two state's witnesses as a man who, under the name of Bennett, helped organize the alleged conspiracy for the throwing of the 1919 world series.
After outlining the details of the alleged conspiracy, as related by Bill Burns, who turned state's evidence, Mr. Prindiville called the jury's attention to the similarity of Burns's story and the confession of Eddie Cicotte. He was particularly bitter in speaking of Cicotte.
"This man, by his own confession, sat in his room at the Warner Hotel here and arranged to receive $10,000 for the dirty work he planned," said Mr. Prindiville. "Then, Judas-like, he went downstairs to hobnob with his innocent team mates and, in his own words, to allay the suspicions of the men he had just betrayed.
"He said he'd throw the ball over the fence, if necessary, to lose the first game. He confessed to Judge Charles A. McDonald, and then he went to the jury and confessed. And what happened in the first game? Cicotte, the American League's greatest pitcher, hurling with a heavy heart—by his own confession — and a pocket made heavy by $10,000 in graft, was beaten nine to one."
Says Gandil Was One of Leaders
Mr. Prindiville declared the evidence proved Gandil one of the conspiracy leaders and that Williams and Jackson stood convicted by their own confessions.
"Williams and Jackson have admitted their guilt," he said. "What can you gentlemen do but go the limit in punishing them?"
"And this man Zelcer," he shouted. "He has tried to prove an alibi, to prove he is not the man Bennett who helped Abe Attell run this deal.
"Yet we proved that Abe Attell had thousands of dollars under the mattresses in his room at the Cincinnati Hotel. We proved there were suitcases of money there and that he took $10,000 of this money against Bennett's wishes and gave it to Burns for the players and Burns gave it to Williams and Jackson.
"Burns may be a squealer. But is he any worse than these defendants? Three of them squealed. His story is as good as theirs—better, because he withstood two days of gruelling cross-examination without changing a single main fact.
"These men did what Abe Attell told them. Abe said, 'Lose the first two.' They did. Abie said, 'Win the third.' They did."
At the Black Sox trial, prosecutor Prindiville argued that evidence proved Gandil was a ringleader and that Williams and Jackson were convicted by their own confessions. He described Abe Attell's cash stashed at the Cincinnati Hotel and how money flowed through Bennett and Burns to the players, while separately McGraw denied offering Weaver a job with the Giants.
State prosecutor Edward Prindiville began closing arguments calling the indicted White Sox players traitors who sold their souls for $100,000. He focused especially on Eddie Cicotte, drawing parallels between Cicotte's confession and Bill Burns' testimony about the conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series.
Great Falls Tribune · 30 July 1921 · page 2
Betrayed Comrades. Chicago, July 2î>. — Final arguments 9 to 1. in the baseball trial were begun Fri day with the stato directing a two hour attack on the defendants in which the former White Sox players were pictured as '"traitors who for $100, 000 worth of dirty money, sold their souls, betrayed their comrades and the public and conspired to make the only truly American pleasure and sport— baseball—a confidence game." confessions. Edward Prindiville directed the pros ecution's first fire in the final pleas, his talk coming after the defense had won a battle of strategy by keeping punishing them ?" out of the record a statement Happy Felsch, former Sox center fielder, ^ ^ ^ ^ ceni allege(1 ' to have raade tp a newspaper
State's attorney Prindiville delivered a closing argument focused heavily on Eddie Cicotte, describing his confession of accepting $10,000 to throw the 1919 World Series. He contrasted Cicotte's admitted guilt with his outward camaraderie with teammates, calling him 'Judas-like,' and tied his account to testimony from accomplice Bill Burns.
Great Falls Tribune · 30 July 1921 · page 2
Attacks Eddie Clcotta. Mr. Prindiville directed his words mainly against Eddie Cicotte. Chick Gandil, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams and David Zelcer, the latter identified by two state's witnesses as a man who under the name of Bennett, helped organize the alleged conspiracy for the throwing of the 1919 world series. After outlining the details of the al leged conspiracy as related by Bill Burns, admitted accomplice who turned state's evidence, Mr. Prindiville called the jury's attention to the similarity to Burns' story and the confession of Eddie Cicotte. He was particularly bitter in speaking of Cicotte.
See moreSee less
"This man by his own confession, sat in his room at the Warner Hotel here and arranged to receive $10,000 for the dirty work he planned," said Mr. Prindiville. "Then, Judas-like he went down stairs to hobnob with his innocent team mates and, in his own words, to allay the suspicion of the men he had just betrayed.
Prosecutor Prindiville argued that Chick Gandil was a conspiracy leader and that Williams and Jackson were guilty by their own confessions. He attacked defendant Zelcer's alibi, detailed the money trail from Attell to Burns to the players, and defended Burns' credibility as a witness.
Great Falls Tribune · 30 July 1921 · page 2
Jumps On Zelcar. "And this man, Zelcer," he shouted, "he has tried to prove an alibi, to prove that he is not the man Bennett who helped Abe Attell run this deal. "Yet we prove that Abe Attell had thousands of dollars under the mat treses in his room at the Cincinnati hotel. We prove there were suitcases of money there and that he took $10, 000 of this money—against Bennett's wishes—and gave it to Burns for the players and Burns gave it to Williams and Jackson. "And Zelcer. after first saying lie knew Attell slightly, finally admits that Attell roomed with him at Cincinnati during the series and that he regis tered Attell himself.
See moreSee less
He then admits that he has known Attell for years an ^ yet he did not know of this con spiracy or of the $10.000 transaction in his own room. "Burns may be a squealer. But is he any worse than these defendants? Three of them squealed. His story is good as theirs—better because he with stood two days of gruelling cross-ques tioning without changing a single main fact. Uuholds Burns' Story.
As closing arguments began in the Black Sox conspiracy trial, the indicted former White Sox players were reportedly planning a barnstorming tour, electing Eddie Cicotte as captain. Most of the accused players, including Jackson, Williams, Gandil, Risberg, and Felsch, were said to be joining, though Buck Weaver refused to take part.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 31 July 1921 · page 15
INDICTED SOX PLAN BARNSTORMING TOUR
BARNSTORMING TOUR Chicago. July 30.—Plans for a 'barnstorming tour" by former White Sox players charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 world's series were aelng made today as Edward Prin iiville addressed the jury in the prosecution’s final argument in the >aseball trial. The players elected Eddie Cicotte aptain of the team and began wora 5n an itinerary which includes most [>1 the larger cities of the country. Weaver was the only player on trial who refused to consider the tour. Weaver has refused to play jail with anyone since his Indictment, rhe players who expect to make the trip are Cicotte, Jackson, Williams, Jandil. Kisberg and Felsch.
Attorney Edward Prindiville concluded the state's closing argument, calling the indicted players murderers of sport who conspired to defraud the public. He demanded the maximum sentence of a $2,500 fine and five years in prison for each defendant.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 31 July 1921 · page 15
INDICTED WHITE SOX ARE BRANDED KILLERS OF SPORT
“A murderer deserves the utmost In punishment. ICddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Happy P'elsch, Buck Weaver, (Taud Williams, Chick Gandil and these gamblers conspired to murder baseball and 1 demand that you 13 gentlemen inflict the maximum pun ishment of a $2,500 fine and five years in the penitentiary on each of them.”
Attorney Edward Prindiville delivered the state's closing argument in the Black Sox trial, calling the indicted players 'murderers of sport' who conspired to defraud the public and children. He demanded the maximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and five years in prison for each defendant, including Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Gandil.
Arizona Republican · 31 July 1921 · page 1
MURDERERS OF SPORT
be honest: A murderer deserves the utmost in punishment. Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Haony Felsch. Buck Weaver. Claude Williams. Chick Gandil and these gamblers conspired to murder baseball and I demand tnat you in
State's attorney Edward Prindiville concluded the first half of the closing argument, calling the indicted players "murderers of sport" and demanding the maximum fine and prison term for each. The defense was set to begin its own closing arguments Monday, with the case expected to reach the jury by Tuesday; meanwhile players were reportedly planning a barnstorming tour if acquitted, though Weaver refused to join.
New-York Tribune · 31 July 1921 · page 7
Hours' Arjsrument To-mor? row; Players Plan Tour of Country if Acquitted CHICAGO. July 30.? Branding: the i indicted White Sox player? cs "mur? derers of sport who, if allowed to go ? free, would ruin baseball just as rac? ing and boxing v.-ere ruined," Attorney' Edward Prindiville to-day concluded the first, half cf the state's closing argument in the baseball trial. Monday the defense will begin the i ten hours of argument allotted it, with indications that. Judge Friend will hold court long enough for the nine attori neys to finish tneir pleas.
See moreSee less
The state; will make its final rebuttal Tuesday! and the case should be in the hands of the jury the same day. Six weeks then will have been taken up. Mr. Prindiville demanded the maxi mum punishment for the indicted men. "These men are killers," he told the jury. "A murderer deserves the ut? most in punishment. Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Happy Felach, Buck Weaver, Claude Williams, Chick Can? dil and these gamblers conspired to murder baseball and I demand that you twelve gentlemen inflict the maximum punishipent of a ?2,000 fine and five years in the penitentiary on each of them." Plans for a "barnstorming tour*' by the former White Sox players if they are acquitted, are being made. The players elected Eddie Cicotte captain of the team and began work
State prosecutor Prindiville asked the jury to impose maximum penalties of $2,000 fines and five years imprisonment on the indicted players and gamblers, calling them conspirators who tried to murder baseball. Meanwhile, the accused players were reportedly planning a barnstorming tour with Cicotte as captain if acquitted, though Weaver refused to join them.
In the Black Sox trial, state attorney Edward P. Rindoville concluded the first half of the prosecution's closing argument, calling the indicted players murderers of sport who would ruin baseball if acquitted. The defense was set to begin its ten hours of argument the following Monday, with Judge Friend expected to let court run long enough for all nine attorneys to finish.
The Pensacola Journal · 31 July 1921 · page 1
(By The Associated Press.) CHICAGO, July 30. Branding the indicted White Sox players as "mur derers of sport who, if allowed to go free, wotild ruin baseball just a3 rac ing and boxing were ruined," Attorney Edward P. Rindoville today concluded the first half of the state's closing argument in the baseball trial. Mon day the defense will begin the ten hours of argument allotted it' with indications that Judge Friend will hold court long enough for the .nine attor neys to finish their pleas. The state
During closing arguments at the Black Sox trial, prosecutor Rindoville told the jury that Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Gandil conspired with gamblers to "murder baseball." He demanded the jury impose the maximum penalty of a $2,000 fine and five years in prison on each defendant.
The Pensacola Journal · 31 July 1921 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
As prosecutor Edward Prindiville delivered closing arguments in the Black Sox conspiracy trial, the indicted former White Sox players were already planning a barnstorming tour, electing Eddie Cicotte as captain. Weaver was the only defendant who declined to join the planned trip.
Omaha Daily Bee · 31 July 1921 · page 1
Indicted White Sox Lay Plans For Long Barnstorming Trip Chicago, July 30. Plans for a "barnstorming tour" by former White Sox players charged with conspiring to throw the 1919 world
Attorney Edward Prindiville closes the first half of the state's argument in the Black Sox trial, calling the indicted players 'murderers of sport' who conspired to defraud the public. He demands the maximum punishment of a $2,000 fine and five years in prison for each defendant, including Cicotte, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Gandil.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 31 July 1921 · page 4
Baseball Trial. By The Associated IVess.) Chicago, July 30. Branding the indicted White Sox players as "murders of sport who, if allowed to go free, would ruin baseball just as racing and boxing were ruined," Attorney Edward Prindiville today concluded the first half of the state's closing argument In the baseball trial. Monday the defense will begin its ten hours of argument, with indications that Judge Friend will hold court long enough for the nine attorneys to finish their pleas The state will make its final re buttal Tuesday and the case prob ably will go to the Jury the same day. Six weeks will have been taken tip then. Maximum Punishment.