A humorous newspaper account describes gunfighter Bat Masterson being sworn in as a deputy U.S. marshal in New York City, treated as a celebrity spectacle by reporters and photographers. The piece references Billy the Kid as part of the mythic outlaw lore invoked to hype Masterson's reputation.
The Topeka State Journal · 1 April 1905 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
CHAPTER 3. Merely the advance sheets of "Bat Masterson Library No. 1," entitled "Bat Masterson in New York, or on the Trail of the Black Hand." It is expected that this number will be issued right away, since Bat Masterson is here. He has come; he has arrived. He took the oath of office today, and counterfeiting plants all over the city are being beaten into frying pans.
At 3 o'clock yesterday afternoon a corps of war correspondents and special commissioners stood in United States Marshal Henkel's office waiting. As they waited they talked in awesome whispers of Billy the Kid, and Black Bart, and the cousin that went west
This passage is a listing of magazine contents, including a mention of an article titled 'Billy the Kid—A Man All Bad' by Arthur Chapman about wild life in cow towns. The rest of the passage describes other articles in the same magazine issue, including gardening tips, owl photography, fox terriers, and Atlantic Monthly essays.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 2 April 1905 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
unknown to stable hands. Arthur Chapman tells us more of the wild life in the cow towns before they were tamed in Billy the Kid—A Man All Bad. Then in the departments we find our old friend, John Burroughs, attacking a would-be animal writer; Dan Beard telling how to build a Land and Water Aquarium; William C.
A books/magazines roundup notes that the April issue of 'Outing' magazine includes Arthur Chapman's piece titled 'Billy the Kid—A Man All Bad,' part of a feature on wild cow-town life before it was tamed. The item is listed among various other magazine articles and stories.
The Jersey City News · 3 April 1905 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Billy the Kid—A Man All Bad. Then in the departments we find our old friend, John Burrough, attacking a would-be animal writer; Dan Beard telling how to Build a Land and Water Aquarium; William C. Harris advising where to fish and what to wear, and Ralph D. Paine writing about the School
An Outing magazine piece reprinted in the newspaper paints Billy the Kid as a uniquely bloodthirsty, effeminate-looking killer who murdered Mexicans 'just to see them kick.' It credits Pat Garrett as the only man quicker on the draw and frames the Kid as a case study for criminologist Lombroso.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 79 days later.
Wrong
Evening Times-Republican · 10 April 1905 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
"JUST TO SEE THEM KICK."
The Worst Man on Record.
See moreSee less
[Arthur Chapman in April Outing.]
It is one of the anomalies of western life that a pale, slender, high voiced, light haired and altogether effeminate individual named William Antrim, sometimes called Billy Bonny, and generally known as Billy the Kid, should be the worst desperado in the history of the frontier. Yet, in considering the so-called "bad men" of the west, his name must stand forth as the superlative of badness. Some of the gun fighters of frontier days killed in self-defense, and others killed when they were in liquor or inflamed with anger—but Billy the Kid was the only white man who slew out of pure wantonness. Three of his victims—Mexicans they were—he bowled over "just to see them kick," as he laughingly explained afterward. If he had a grudge against a man he never harbored it long, but simply confronted his victim and slew without making explanation. Only sturdy John Chisholm bade defiance to Billy to the end of the desperado's red career, and only one man ever proved himself a quicker shot—Patrick A. Garrett, one of the nerviest sheriffs that ever served in the days when the southwest needed nervy men in that office.
Could a Lombroso have studied this mere boy, who seemed to have been born with a tiger's blood-thirst, no doubt science would have received an interesting contribution. Without a spark of pity for his numerous victims, and with no fear of his enemies in his heart, Billy the Kid presented a peculiar phenomenon. His desire was to kill, and it seemed to make lit-
The article recalls Billy the Kid as a bloodthirsty, pitiless young outlaw who killed without remorse or explanation, noting only John Chisholm defied him and only Pat Garrett outdrew him. It frames the Kid as a unique, inexplicable figure in frontier history, dying violently as he had lived.
Bisbee Daily Review · 18 April 1905 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
BILLY WAS BAD
HAS NO SUBSTITUTE
grudge against a man he never harbored it long, but simply confronted his victim and slew without making explanation. Only sturdy John Chisholm bade defiance to Billy to the end of the desperado's red career, and only one man ever proved himsef a quicker shot—Patrick A. Garrett, one of the nerviest sheriffs that ever served in the days when the southwest needed nervy men in that office.
See moreSee less
"Could a Lombroso have studied this mere boy, who seemed to have been born with a tiger's blood thirst no doubt science would have received an interesting contribution. Without a spark of pity for his numerous victims and with no fear of his enemies in his heart, Billy the Kid presented a peculiar phenomenon. His desire was to kill, and it seemed to make little odds to him whether he killed in the most cowardly manner or whether be boldly faced the weapons of his enemies. Few men have been the Kid's
The Columbian · Bloomsburg, Pa. · and 1 other paper
The report announces the death of outlaw 'Kid' Curry, who shot himself after being wounded and cornered by a posse. It places him alongside legendary western 'bad men' including Billy the Kid, Wild Bill, the Earps, and the James boys.
The Columbian · 20 April 1905 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
Worst "Bad Man" Dead. "Kid" Curry, one of the last of the Western "bad men," is dead. For cool, unflinching outlawry he takes his place with "Billy the Kid," "Wild Bill," "Apache Kid," the Earps, the Youngers and the James boys. True to tradition, he died fighting. Wounded, cornered by a posse, he said calmly to a companion who sought to rescue him, "I'm all in," and, turning his pistol to his head, sent a bullet through his brain. Thus the most desperate of recent bandits met his death.
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 10 November 1904
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A 1905 report describes an upcoming hunting expedition into Mexico's Sierra Madre organized by Colonel W.C. Greene, with many notable guests invited. Among the hunters mentioned is Colonel Patrick Garrett, identified as the former sheriff who killed Billy the Kid.
New-York Tribune · 22 April 1905 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TO HUNT WITH COLONEL GREENE.
Mexico; Governor Ysabel, of Sonora, Mexico; P. Mallen, Mexican Consul, and several others.
Nearly all of the foregoing have accepted the invitation, but there is some doubt about the ability of Mr. Fairbanks and Mr. Shaw to join the party. In addition to those mentioned, Colonel Patrick Garrett, Collector of the Port, of El Paso, who killed "Billy the Kid" while Sheriff in New Mexico, will be in the party.
See moreSee less
The guests of Colonel Greene will arrive here Tuesday evening from the East. They will go from here to Casas Grandes, and from there they will journey by horseback and wagon into the wild hunting grounds of Sonora, where big game is plentiful.